Podcast Search

The Talk Show

18: Instawhatsit, with Marco Arment

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00I'll tell you what. I am convinced that at some point during this show we're gonna be interrupted by

0:00:04some device nearby me making noises

0:00:08Because it's I've got too many too many phones

0:00:11Yeah, I was messing with my website configuration about an hour ago

0:00:16And and I caused some downtime and I had like four devices vibrate with some kind of alert, but we're telling me about this

0:00:22it's it's crazy and I've got wires everywhere all they're all white and

0:00:28with different ends on him, it's a mess.

0:00:32Yeah, it's a weird and unique time of the year,

0:00:36like the new iPhone just got into my hands time.

0:00:41And my personal iPhone just came here yesterday.

0:00:45I just got it yesterday.

0:00:46So now it's like this is the worst,

0:00:49because I had been using on a daily basis the review unit

0:00:54iPhone from Apple.

0:00:56but I still had my personal iPhone 4S.

0:01:05And now I've got my new one, which I've restored, and now I'm just going to use that one.

0:01:09But I find I have so much affection for my old 4S that I – and I've – this is the

0:01:17first year I've really been conscious of it, but I've done it every previous year,

0:01:20too, that for a day or two, I keep it running, and sometimes I put it in my other pants pocket

0:01:25walk around with both phones.

0:01:26[laughter]

0:01:27>> Mine's still on my desk, but I haven't, the only thing I used it for was I had to

0:01:32set up some kind of, some dock accessory yesterday that didn't work with the lightning plug,

0:01:36so I had to use the 4S, but yeah, I mean, I still have almost all my old phones. I keep

0:01:42one of every generation. So whenever Tiff and I have the same one, then I'll end up

0:01:47selling one of those once we move on. But I still have all of mine, because, I don't

0:01:52I don't know. I mean, my excuse so far has been for testing, but I'm a little bit sentimental

0:01:57about some of them. Except for 3G. That was a piece of crap.

0:02:00Yeah, that kind of was.

0:02:01That was fun getting rid of that. But I have to keep my 3GS for testing, but even when

0:02:06that's… I might keep that afterwards. I don't know. But I have my original iPhone

0:02:09sitting in the drawer. I haven't turned it on in probably a year because I can't

0:02:14run anything on it anymore. But in case I need to, it's there.

0:02:17The ones… I could probably get rid of everything except the original. The original I still

0:02:22like to take out and just—I don't turn it, even turn it on. I just put it in my hand

0:02:26and feel it. And now, you know—and there's still something. And I know, like, I know

0:02:32Cable Sasser, I don't know if he still feels this way, but I know that when the four first

0:02:36came out, he was a real—even after he'd used it for a while, was not a fan of the

0:02:42harsh corners. And I know Edward Tufte—Tufte? God, I don't—Tufte, I think.

0:02:49I have no idea.

0:02:50I have no idea.

0:02:51But I know that he does not like the corners.

0:02:55He's complained about it.

0:02:56And not like, hey, he just got his first iPhone 4, 4S, or now 5 with the corners, and like

0:03:01a day or two in he's complaining about it after he's been using it for a while, actually.

0:03:07And he was singing the praises of the retina display and about how much more detail you

0:03:11can put in, that this is fantastic.

0:03:14But he also said, why in the world did they go away from the round edges?

0:03:18I don't mind it. I like the sharp edges. But there is something to be said about the round

0:03:23edges of the original.

0:03:24It never really bothered me. I don't know. Actually, one thing that did bother me about

0:03:28the original was that it got so hot.

0:03:30I never noticed that. I guess sometimes on edge it did.

0:03:33Well, it was only edge.

0:03:35Yeah, but I'm saying when I was using it on edge, not like--

0:03:40Well, rather than Wi-Fi.

0:03:41Exactly. When I was using a lot of data on the cellular network.

0:03:44Yeah, yeah, I did notice that. And I haven't, the new one, the 5, I haven't noticed it

0:03:50really getting hot at all. And I don't even know if it's gotten warm. Like, you know,

0:03:54it's hard to tell when you've been using it for a while whether it's warm because

0:03:56your hand's been on it or whether it's generating heat from inside that you can actually

0:04:00detect. But it seems, like I've used mine out a lot already and it seems pretty solid,

0:04:05pretty, pretty elegant. You know, it's, the A6, man, I, I think Apple really underplayed

0:04:11the A6 in the presentation because it's so far from what we know about it, you know,

0:04:17like an end text running these benchmarks and trying to figure out what it is and it

0:04:21looks like it's really awesome. And it makes the A5X look like a piece of crap.

0:04:25Yeah, it really does. And I know there's a bunch of stuff I'd listen to the latest

0:04:32episode of Build and Analyze. When was that from? Earlier this week or end of last week?

0:04:36Yeah, Monday. Yeah, it was four days ago.

0:04:38You pointed out there that it's significantly and noticeably faster CPU-wise than the current

0:04:44iPad parenthesis 3 and close parenthesis.

0:04:50And the iPad 3 needs more speed because, you know, as I mentioned on the show, I'm not

0:04:54going to go too far into it here, but it got the huge boost of all those extra, all the

0:04:59extra GPU power from the A5X, but it's the same CPU.

0:05:02And a lot of graphical operations still run on the CPU, like things that aren't fully

0:05:06hardware accelerated.

0:05:08And one of the things that hits me with Instapaper was that page turn animation, because I have

0:05:13to capture the image of one page before it turns away so I can scroll the web view underneath

0:05:19it.

0:05:20Oops, I just told all my competitors how I did that.

0:05:22Well, oh well.

0:05:23They don't listen.

0:05:24They don't listen to the show.

0:05:25They listen to your show.

0:05:27If they listened to my show, they would have submitted voiceover updates already, but they

0:05:31haven't.

0:05:32doing like some of those graphical operations that I do with the pagination are done in the CPU and so

0:05:37when the iPad 3 came out it was the first time a new device made something in my app slower and

0:05:43Because it was all these like way more pixels, you know four times as many pixels

0:05:47But roughly the same CPU speed as the iPad 2 and that was that was the skepticism of the whole before they came out with

0:05:54The retina iPad the skepticism was from people who know their shit, you know people like you who are

0:06:01developers who are writing code that does things like the page curl animations or game

0:06:07developers. There's a lot of skepticism about, I just, really? I don't know. That's an awful

0:06:12lot of pixels, right? I mean, just in all sorts of ways. Putting them through the CPU,

0:06:19just everything. In and out of video memory. I think people underestimate just how aggressive

0:06:24it is to have that many pixels on a tablet.

0:06:27Oh yeah, and I mean that many pixels on anything.

0:06:30Like we've seen, we even see now with the retina MacBook Pro that, that you know, one

0:06:34of the biggest bottlenecks of the retina MacBook Pro is the GPU just pushing that many pixels.

0:06:40And so I think the one reason, and that the iPad was always ahead of the iPhone CPU wise,

0:06:46there's a couple reasons.

0:06:47One, it needed it because it's had bigger screen, and two, it physically has more room

0:06:53for it.

0:06:54you know, there's a ginormous battery in there

0:06:56compared to the iPhone.

0:06:58And you know, it's just easier place

0:07:01to put a bigger CPU or system on a chip.

0:07:03- Oh, definitely.

0:07:05And they also, they sell way fewer iPads than iPhones.

0:07:09So if there's any kind of manufacturing yield issues

0:07:12or potential issues, like if it's a new process

0:07:15or a new architecture, it's generally easier for them,

0:07:19I would imagine, to run it first on the iPad

0:07:21and then launch it on the iPhone later

0:07:22because of what they've done until now.

0:07:23- Right.

0:07:24This is the first time that an iPhone is faster than the iPad.

0:07:28Yeah, it's really amazing.

0:07:30And I do think that they underplayed it.

0:07:31And I think one of the reasons maybe is that you can say it on stage, but it's not really

0:07:39demoable.

0:07:40You know, you just say faster, and it just sounds like marketing, pap, you know?

0:07:45Well, and even if they said, "Oh, this is a custom-designed thing," well, technically,

0:07:50the A4 and A5 were custom in the way that they were custom arranged in the package.

0:07:55But the cores weren't really customized.

0:07:58And I think that's a level of detail that the press wouldn't have really appreciated

0:08:02at the time of the event.

0:08:03I think people underestimate, if you really think about it, and we're so used to Apple

0:08:06giving these good introduction events, but I think it's really, really hard to write

0:08:11them, to structure them, and to pick what you're actually going to say.

0:08:14Because I know that if it were me, I would have been lazy.

0:08:17The thing I would have said is, at first, just before it even got into what it does,

0:08:23just in terms of the build, I would have just said, "You have to feel it.

0:08:28You have to feel it.

0:08:29You've just got to put it in your hand and feel how light it is and feel it."

0:08:32And everybody who gets one – this is what everybody says.

0:08:35This is what Amy said when I first showed it to her.

0:08:38Everybody who first picks it up is like, "I can't believe what it feels like."

0:08:41But they don't say that, right?

0:08:42They talk about specific stuff about the microns and the build quality.

0:08:47Because I feel like saying you have to feel it, it doesn't sound, it is true, but it doesn't

0:08:53sound true.

0:08:54It sounds like just this type of marketing stuff anybody would say.

0:08:57Yeah, and I mean, maybe that's why, you know, they probably assume that if they say it,

0:09:02no one's really going to believe them.

0:09:04Right.

0:09:05Whereas if everyone who picks one up says it, that's a different story.

0:09:07That's more powerful.

0:09:08Yeah, I love the thing.

0:09:11I still, it's still almost, like the whole first day or two that I had it, it felt kind

0:09:16of fake and I was a little worried about dropping it just because it was so light I figured

0:09:20like it's you know like I think you said it's like picking up an empty shell like it really

0:09:24is it feels like you're picking up just an iPhone case you know with no iPhone in it

0:09:29I actually but now I'm used to it and man it was getting used to the tall screen was

0:09:35fast like now I so I've so quickly got to the point where when I looked at the iPhone

0:09:404 again it looked ridiculously short to me that took me like three days yeah and I kind

0:09:46of touched on this in my review, and part of it is my personality, is that I'm just

0:09:50an inveterate procrastinator. So I wrote, you know, the embargo was Tuesday evening.

0:09:57I wrote the review all day Tuesday, kind of, you know, cleared the schedule, didn't post

0:10:02much during the day, and I pretty much wrote the whole—I had notes that I had been taking,

0:10:06just scribbles, like my notes looked like crazy person notes. And I just wrote it all

0:10:12on Tuesday. But I almost think that I had to though, because my opinion of it had evolved

0:10:17significantly from the first few days. And honestly, I still look back and sort of wistfully

0:10:28look back at the days before I was getting these things in advance, and I would just

0:10:32write reviews whenever I was ready. And I kind of feel like I wish I had more time,

0:10:38still had more time with the device,

0:10:40'cause it still hasn't really settled in.

0:10:42- Yeah, I think that that's kind of a problem

0:10:45with a lot of the way the tech press operates

0:10:47is that a lot of these products,

0:10:50you really want a little bit longer term review,

0:10:53but everyone's interested in reading the review

0:10:55when the thing comes out.

0:10:56But there's so many, anything,

0:10:58especially a mobile product,

0:11:00you kind of need to have it for a while.

0:11:02You need to go different places with it.

0:11:03You need to maybe go on vacation or something

0:11:06to see how it performs there,

0:11:07and maybe go to a conference or something,

0:11:10to get a good feel for how good this thing is

0:11:13or how it works with your life

0:11:15and how it works in different types of situations

0:11:18rather than you get the review unit

0:11:21and you gotta write your review in two days.

0:11:23And that's, it's definitely hard to,

0:11:28as you said, it's probably hard to really get

0:11:32a good review of it out then.

0:11:34But if you don't do it then,

0:11:37like if you're a big site, like one of the big gadget sites,

0:11:40they have to get it out on day one.

0:11:42Like that's what their audience demands,

0:11:44and they're competing on day one

0:11:45with all the other publications.

0:11:47New York Times, Wall Street Journal,

0:11:48they have to get theirs out on day one

0:11:50because that's what people demand from them.

0:11:52And like you're in this kind of weird halfway spot

0:11:56where you're on Apple's good side with the PR stuff

0:12:01so you get the review units in advance,

0:12:04but your audience is more people like me

0:12:08who would appreciate the longer term review.

0:12:11But how do you balance that?

0:12:13That's gotta be difficult.

0:12:14- Well, six days is not bad.

0:12:16And part of it is you just have to be,

0:12:21and it's the luxury of being,

0:12:22that I do this site full time

0:12:23and I don't have anything else to do,

0:12:24that I knew that I could spend all day Tuesday writing it.

0:12:27And if I have evolving thoughts as I go forward,

0:12:32I can just write something new, I guess.

0:12:34But I found with the things, and I know you were talking about it on your show, you know,

0:12:39stuff like reaching with the thumb, it really changes as you use the device.

0:12:45It, you know, just to – but you need a couple days.

0:12:48And I'll tell you what, my day one response was I – the draft in my head that I was

0:12:53writing two Wednesdays ago, the first day that I had the device, the review unit, was

0:12:59boy, I'm really – I'm going to have to trash the four-inch screen.

0:13:03I really thought it was a disaster the first day, for exactly the reasons that I had worried

0:13:08about all along ever since it was rumored, because I kept missing the buttons in the

0:13:13top corner.

0:13:15And by Tuesday, it was way less of an issue.

0:13:18And even by now, a week later, it's really almost a non-issue.

0:13:23Yeah, I didn't really have any trouble with it after about an hour.

0:13:28I guess my grip adapted well for it, I guess.

0:13:32I think if there's one thing I would change, if I could go back and change my review, I

0:13:35would probably actually lessen that criticism. Even now, in another week later, I find that

0:13:40the thumb coverage is a lot less.

0:13:43Yeah.

0:13:44And I really do think. And in a way, and I've used, like I've used the Galaxy Nexus. I always

0:13:53forget if it's the Nexus Galaxy or whatever the hell it's called.

0:13:55Doesn't matter.

0:13:56But I've used it for two weeks, at least two weeks, where it was my primary phone. And

0:14:00And I never ever got used to the screen size on that device.

0:14:03But I will say, but also to Android's credit, they don't have as much stuff at the top of

0:14:08the screen.

0:14:09Their back button is down low.

0:14:11So it actually is, it's an operating system that is better suited to bigger than four-inch

0:14:18screens than iOS would be.

0:14:20But I never got used to it.

0:14:21But that causes other problems like with the keyboard.

0:14:23I never got used to it.

0:14:24The space bar.

0:14:25to use one-handed or to thumb-type one-handed.

0:14:29And I think that this should and probably will

0:14:33affect people's design decisions with iOS apps. In particular,

0:14:37and we talked on my show, do you hold your phone in your left hand?

0:14:41No, well I use it both ways. Usually right-handed

0:14:45though. I keep it in my right pocket and if I'm using it one-handed

0:14:49generally it is in my right hand. But sometimes I'll use it in my left hand.

0:14:53So I mentioned on my show that even though I'm right-handed, I keep my phone in my left

0:14:57pocket and I use it, and when I'm using it one-handed, it is with my left hand holding

0:15:02the phone and using my left thumb across the screen. Apparently, I've gotten so many

0:15:07crazy Twitter replies from people either saying, "That's really weird. Why do you do that

0:15:11when you're right-handed?" or people saying, "Oh my God, I do the same thing." So it

0:15:15seems like people are very split on this. But if you hold your phone with your left

0:15:18hand, the most difficult spot to reach with your thumb is probably the upper right corner.

0:15:22And I guess, see it's a big problem if you hold it with your right hand because then

0:15:28you're missing all the back buttons in the upper left corner. That would be a bigger

0:15:32problem I think.

0:15:33But that's exactly the problem that I had.

0:15:37Like I wouldn't design an iPhone app anymore that has anything important in the upper corners

0:15:42if I can help it. But unfortunately, as you said, the navigation bars do. I wonder which

0:15:47hand is more common for people to use.

0:15:48Oh, it's got to be the right hand. It has to be.

0:15:50You think so?

0:15:51- Yeah, I think so. - I don't know.

0:15:53- I think so, but I'm weird.

0:15:54My handedness is weird.

0:15:56Like, I'm right-handed and very much right-handed.

0:15:59I play all sports right-handed,

0:16:01but I use the mouse left-handed.

0:16:04- Oh, that's crazy.

0:16:06- Well, long story short, it was an RSI issue way back.

0:16:10I mean, I was in college, and my right wrist was just,

0:16:15both wrists were really killing me,

0:16:16but my right wrist especially, and even my right shoulder.

0:16:21I mean, and I really hate going to doctors and stuff like that, but I really thought

0:16:24I got to go to a doctor and I thought you know

0:16:26I thought I was me with somebody who had to have surgery or something because and I was sort of terrified because I thought I

0:16:31Don't know what I'm gonna do with the rest of my life if I can't use a mouse and keyboard

0:16:34So I switched to the left-handed mouse and spent like two days where my mouse cursor was just

0:16:42ying-yang from one corner of the screen to the other

0:16:45But then you know within three days it got pretty good, and I think I really do think long term

0:16:51It's actually made my left hand significantly more. What's the word dextrous?

0:16:56Than it was it you know before I made that switch

0:16:59But I should try that but when I use a trackpad I'd use it with my right thumb

0:17:04Well I mean hey make both hands great, but anyway, so I

0:17:09Used the mouse I used the iPhone you know whichever hand is

0:17:14convenient. But I do agree though. I also find myself, over two weeks, I grip the iPhone

0:17:21differently. I do less of a rested on the pinky and more of a complete side grip.

0:17:28So I'm always afraid of it falling downwards if I move that pinky out of there and don't

0:17:33support it from the bottom.

0:17:34Yeah, I don't – I feel like the texture of the metal really lessens that.

0:17:37Yeah, maybe.

0:17:38Yeah, maybe.

0:17:39Anyway, my other thing that as I've used this more and more, that the metal, the metallic

0:17:46feel to me, it just grows fonder and fonder as the weeks have gone by.

0:17:51And it really does harken back to the original iPhone in a very, very positive way.

0:17:57See, I wish the back surface was a little bit more textured.

0:18:02Like even if it was just like a little bit less smooth metal, just some kind of slight

0:18:06grit on it I think would be welcome.

0:18:08now it almost feels like glass. Well, I don't know if I would say it feels like glass, but I could see

0:18:14it being ever so slightly even more textured. It's actually more slippery than the glass with

0:18:20your finger. So you got a black one? Yeah, I did. What do you think about this scratch gate?

0:18:25You know, I was disappointed to learn, which this appears to be true, I was disappointed to learn

0:18:33that the black covering is really a very thin layer on top.

0:18:38- Right.

0:18:39- But otherwise, I don't really care

0:18:41because every Apple product from like the last decade

0:18:44has had polished metal surfaces somewhere.

0:18:47And I don't, you know, if people are saying,

0:18:49oh my god, this scratches, well, you know,

0:18:52that's the life of a cellphone.

0:18:53You know, you can put it in a big rubbery case

0:18:56and attempt to prevent scratches

0:18:57and those don't always work.

0:18:59Or you know, you can just enjoy it naked.

0:19:02And I like to enjoy mine naked.

0:19:03I like how small it is, how easily it goes in the pocket.

0:19:07And I just, I chose a couple years ago

0:19:10to just stop worrying about scratches.

0:19:12And it turns out myself doesn't really get

0:19:14that scratch anyway, 'cause I'm still careful with it.

0:19:16I'm just, you know, I'm not gonna be totally crushed.

0:19:19And in fact, I hope this doesn't become

0:19:21some kind of scandal, 'cause you've heard of people

0:19:24like opening up and they say

0:19:25that it's scratched out of the box.

0:19:28I actually had, on my iPhone 5, a very, very small,

0:19:32like a dot, a very small spot of seemingly unpolishable surface on the back. And now

0:19:42I'm looking, I can't even find it now. But I tried like rubbing it and I could not

0:19:46get that out and so I assumed it was some kind of like tiny little nick in the finish

0:19:50and I just decided not to care. I was like, you know what, it's even fresh out of the

0:19:54box if it has this little spec that doesn't look quite right, I don't care. And now

0:19:58I'm looking at it, I can't find it.

0:20:00Mine has my personal one that arrived yesterday is black and

0:20:04the demo from Apple was white and I always prefer black and I

0:20:09I'm so happy now that I have this black one. I like it so much more

0:20:12But I'm glad that the review unit they gave me was white because I got to see it

0:20:16And Amy had pre-ordered a white one. I think we still could have canceled

0:20:22Although I guess if we would have canceled she would have would have put her order in the back of the queue

0:20:26But, at the very least, though, she did get to see it and know that, you know, feel like

0:20:30she made the right decision by pre-ordering a white one.

0:20:35Mine has a weird thing that I haven't seen anybody else talk about.

0:20:38And I don't care because I'm not that obsessive about it.

0:20:40But you know the – I don't even know what material is, but it's like some kind of plastic

0:20:45or rubber between the antennas and the side.

0:20:49The little lines on the side?

0:20:50Yeah, the little lines on the side.

0:20:53And they're black, too.

0:20:55But on the right side, on the left, there's just black, black, black.

0:20:59On the right side, and this is – it's so subtle.

0:21:02There's no way I could photograph it.

0:21:05But on the chamfered part, it's not black.

0:21:10It's like clear.

0:21:11It's like clear plastic on both the top and the bottom.

0:21:16Just on the little –

0:21:17So if you're looking at the phone's front, it's the right edge?

0:21:20Yes.

0:21:21And so it's not –

0:21:22And the front or the rear chamfer?

0:21:24front.

0:21:25Oh, man. All right. I can't see this online, but I'm going to try to photograph it later

0:21:29because that's the kind of challenge that I enjoy spending time on.

0:21:32I don't care. In fact, it's one of those things where I feel like it makes my iPhone

0:21:35a unique snowflake.

0:21:38I don't think mine has that.

0:21:40No. And it's only on the one side. And it's definitely not… And it's not like it's

0:21:47glaring out at me, but it's the sort of thing that obviously though there are some

0:21:51poor people out there. And I sympathize. I do not mock them because I have my own obsessions.

0:21:57I actually sympathize. But the people who are truly obsessive about having a truly perfect

0:22:02iPhone, it's the sort of thing where I feel like they would take it back to the store

0:22:05and see if they could get it swapped out.

0:22:09I did just discover a very small chamfer scratch on one of my corners. But I still can't make

0:22:14myself care that much.

0:22:15It's just – I don't even know what you call that. Just that little plastic buffer

0:22:18between the antenna and the frame.

0:22:20On the front chamfered edge on both the top and bottom one, it's not black.

0:22:26It's like clear.

0:22:27Like you can kind of see that it's made out of plastic.

0:22:30But I don't care.

0:22:31And on the other side, it's totally black.

0:22:34I think if they – now that I'm seeing it in person and now that I've owned the

0:22:38black one for – I don't know, what is it, a week or six days?

0:22:42I think it's a little bit too dark on the anodized aluminum.

0:22:46I would have if they sold one that had black glass

0:22:50You know a black front and black glass panels, but the regular polished aluminum like from the white one. I think I'd get that one

0:22:58And it would actually it would look more like the original iPhone

0:23:00They would well and it would also look a lot more like the iPhone 4 and 4s

0:23:06Well, the back would be all silver though, right? But from the sides would yeah the sides would like

0:23:12Maybe that's why they had to make it more different so that people would say oh now it's a new iPhone 5

0:23:16No, I don't think they really want people to say that I really don't I don't think that's something they're interested in and I you

0:23:21Know I think I said this last week on the show with MG that I

0:23:25Just used it out and about and nobody ever said anything because people it looks so much like it

0:23:31I mean and like mg said that like in San Francisco

0:23:33he got a few looks because it's a little bit more tech savvy of a

0:23:37crowd like so he'd be using it on Bart or something and

0:23:40He'd get like maybe somebody kind of like who is that the new one a week in a week ahead

0:23:45But you know here in Philadelphia nobody noticed

0:23:47So my problem with the dark with the darkness of the of the black metal is

0:23:53That I can't I can't really see many of the details in most indoor lighting

0:23:57Like I can't like it just looks like one big black slab

0:24:00I did like I can't really tell much of a difference between the black glass and the aluminum which is not quite black

0:24:07you know what is charcoal or slate whatever they call it like I wish there

0:24:10was a little bit more of a difference there I think it would look nicer what

0:24:13do you think about my theory that the home button has been improved

0:24:15technically well you're at that you're right I think I fix it probably somebody

0:24:20I when they disassemble it they found it like a big metal bracket now it's really

0:24:23reinforced and it and it does it feels clicky er I think it feels fantastic it's

0:24:28it's a it's a much more satisfying click although you were wrong about one part

0:24:32of that you said that they kept the vibrator motor from the iPhone 4s and

0:24:36that's incorrect. They reverted back.

0:24:38I don't know that I, did I say that or did I just say that it vibrates?

0:24:42Well, I think you speculated.

0:24:43Right.

0:24:44Yeah, but anyway, that's wrong. They actually changed back. And remember, you and I discovered

0:24:47this at Singleton last year, that if you take an iPhone 4S and if you hold it like a seesaw

0:24:53and you tap a certain part on the back, then you can feel the vibrator vibrating loosely

0:24:59in there.

0:25:00Yeah.

0:25:01And it kind of makes it feel cheap or, you know, somehow wrong.

0:25:03Or broken.

0:25:04Right, exactly.

0:25:05Exactly. But the iPhone 5 does not do that anymore. The type of vibrator motor they switched

0:25:10to from the 4S does that. And now they switched back to the old kind, because it's like

0:25:15a counterweighted motor that just spins with this offset weight. So it doesn't have that

0:25:22weird vibrating feel anymore when it's not supposed to be vibrating. So I think it's

0:25:27an improvement.

0:25:28My right thigh has gone totally defective over the last five years. And so when I feel

0:25:32something vibrating and it's generally not. And when my phone does vibrate half the time

0:25:38I do miss it.

0:25:39Let's – the phantom vibrate is actually a thing that's like a real –

0:25:43And I'm severely afflicted.

0:25:45Yeah, me too.

0:25:46I'm totally afflicted. I also have a – well, I don't know how to describe it, but I tend

0:25:54to sleep late. You know, I usually wake up around 10 or 11. I have a thing where at least

0:26:01once a week. And our bedroom is on the third floor. I have a thing where at least once

0:26:08a week, I would say easily four times a month, I will be woken by the doorbell and know that

0:26:13there's, you know, like a delivery, you know, FedEx or UPS or something like that, and quick

0:26:17throw on a pair of pants and run down three flights of stairs and there's nobody there.

0:26:21And sometimes Amy will already be in the kitchen and she'll be like, "Doorbell?" And I'd be

0:26:25be like, "Yeah, did it ring?" And she'd be like, "Nope." And I'd be like, "Well,

0:26:29I'm up." But that's how I get up. And I hear it.

0:26:32Well, how do you know that she's not just ringing it to wake you up? I'm just telling

0:26:35you.

0:26:36Well, because a lot of times I do it and she's at the gym or something and she's not even

0:26:41home. No, I mean, she couldn't be bothered to do that. But I hear it. I hear doorbells

0:26:50in the sleep.

0:26:51Phantom UPS.

0:26:52Well, and then the other thing is, you know, half the time it really is, it is FedEx or

0:26:59UPS.

0:27:00That's like a true nerds problem right there.

0:27:02Because it—

0:27:03You get so many deliveries.

0:27:04It's so easy.

0:27:05I think about it.

0:27:06We get so much stuff mail ordered to us now.

0:27:09It would be so easy to be a hermit.

0:27:12Oh, yeah.

0:27:14No, the UPS guy stops at our house almost every day.

0:27:17Like it's very strange when we see him drive past us.

0:27:21The very rare, 'cause we get everything online

0:27:25for the most part, especially now that we have the baby,

0:27:27like there's even less reason to go out shopping.

0:27:29So Amazon, we have stuff coming,

0:27:32we have stuff from Soap.com, all the baby supplies

0:27:34and toiletries and stuff, and Apple products

0:27:38come every week or something, I don't know,

0:27:39whenever they release new stuff.

0:27:41- I like Merl, - Seriously,

0:27:42he's here every day. - I like Merlin's bit

0:27:43where I know Merlin's got like a thing

0:27:45where he signed up where they get paper towels delivered on a regular… they don't even

0:27:49have to order them. They just show up. They know how many paper towels they go through.

0:27:53And so every two weeks, a new thing of paper towels comes from Amazon. But he thinks that

0:27:58instead of bringing it to their house, they should drop it off X number of blocks away

0:28:01so he still has to walk to get them. Because it's just so decadent having all this stuff.

0:28:09Tim Cynova The big thing about the Amazon subscribe stuff,

0:28:12one of the things I found that was really good to use that for, and I think it's the

0:28:15The only thing I'm using it for is the water filter in my fridge.

0:28:19Because they say, like, "Oh, change it every X months."

0:28:21I think it's six months.

0:28:22And of course, nobody ever remembers to do that.

0:28:24But with mine, if you don't change it for a while, it starts slowing down and clogging

0:28:27up.

0:28:28So I just did the subscribe and save thing with Amazon, where I just have them deliver

0:28:31me a new water filter every six months.

0:28:32I don't even have to think about it.

0:28:33When it arrives, I replace it, and that's it.

0:28:36Dave: I want to look something up.

0:28:38I'm going to look something up here.

0:28:40Hold on a second here.

0:28:41I remember this from last night, and I forgot to look it up before the show.

0:28:44we go. What do you think about the iPhone 5 camera?

0:28:49You know, I haven't had a chance to use it that much. I mean, so far it seems, it

0:28:56seems so far like it's good. I don't, it doesn't seem in my usage so far that it's

0:29:01that different from the 4S. It's a lot faster to take pictures. Mostly, I don't know if

0:29:05that's the A6 or what. But that's like, like when Tiff was deciding whether to upgrade

0:29:10upgrade or not. She wanted me to get mine first so she could see it and then decide.

0:29:15And at first she was thinking she wasn't going to upgrade. But what sold her on it

0:29:19was the weight and, I mean, the lack of weight, and the speed of the camera. That, you know,

0:29:26it's because, you know, with the baby, if you've got to take a good picture of the

0:29:30baby, you've really got to take 20 pictures and pick the one where he's looking at you,

0:29:34know, and not making a sour face. So the speed of the camera really matters to us right now.

0:29:41And even if you don't have a baby, it's just convenient to have fast response time. And

0:29:47it is way faster. But the actual image quality, I can't tell a difference. I saw those comparison

0:29:54pictures you posted, and it seems like the differences might only be in software for

0:30:00the most part.

0:30:01Well, and in low light, although that is partially software, partially hardware, because I've

0:30:09noticed that, and I don't know if it's an API that they can be updated to take advantage

0:30:13of, but the new low light stuff, I only see it when I'm using camera.app.

0:30:19Like if I take a photo in Instagram, I don't get it.

0:30:22Oh, that's interesting.

0:30:25And it's, you know, I forget how they described it, but it's more or less that they're sampling

0:30:284 pixels at once. It's sort of like they're sacrificing resolution and crispness for…to

0:30:38get it. Brightness.

0:30:39Jared Polin To get low noise.

0:30:40Steven

0:30:40Well, and it is kind of noisy, but it's, you know, it's to open it up, effectively open

0:30:45it up more. And they say you get two full stops, and I believe it. I really do. I think

0:30:50you get two stops, and it's a, what is it, like an f/2.2 lens now?

0:30:54I think 2.0, something like that.

0:30:57I think, or two, is it a 2.4 lens? But two stops from 2.4 I think would take you down

0:31:02to like 1.8, which is serious, you know, low-light camera area. And the other thing, and they

0:31:07they didn't even mention this, it goes to much higher ISOs.

0:31:10Right, yeah, that's the thought. That's why the low-light pictures look so much brighter,

0:31:16because they're just cranking it up. But it sounds like if they're actually doing

0:31:19that kind of super-sampling, or whatever the term would be for that, where they combine

0:31:23the light from four different pixel sites, that would be remarkably effective.

0:31:28And it is, it's definitely noisy. I mean, you know, high ISO and the sampling and this

0:31:35really tiny lens. I mean, it's definitely noisy. But you get exposures like, you know,

0:31:41wow, you can see what you're looking at, exposures in the low light that on all previous iPhones

0:31:46would have just been black, or you would have to use the flash, which is horrible. Especially

0:31:50like the darker it is, the worse flash makes things look.

0:31:53Oh, yeah. I think it was one tip we can give photographers using the iPhone 5, never use

0:31:58the flash.

0:31:59Right.

0:32:00Or any, that's true.

0:32:01love to have an option in settings app to just turn off the flash just don't

0:32:06ever turn it on well that is one of the options you have in the camp in camera

0:32:11app you can you can set it you know auto off or on you I just keep mine on yeah

0:32:15but every once in a while that gets reset I don't know if I it's like a

0:32:17phantom touch that you know if I accidentally touch that and do it or and

0:32:21sometimes other apps like if I'm taking a picture with Instagram or something

0:32:24like that somehow the flash gets turned on and I accidentally shoot a flash

0:32:29photo and then I'm all, "Oh, I'm sorry, I'm sorry." To me, that's one of the--

0:32:32I get so embarrassed when that happens.

0:32:34I know. That's what I want. I want a thing in settings that says, "Don't turn the flash

0:32:37on for any photograph in any app, period. Just take the option."

0:32:41Except for the flashlight apps that kind of hack a camera into display.

0:32:44Right. Let apps turn the LED on if they want, but don't let the camera apps do it. I don't

0:32:49know. Something like that. But anyway, I never do it. And you get pictures you never did.

0:32:53Now this drives me nuts. This is crazy. I just saw this last night. Consumer Reports

0:32:58iPhone 5 review. Here's what they say.

0:33:02What did they pick this year to jump on?

0:33:06The claimed improvements of the iPhone 5 in handling low light shots were not apparent

0:33:10in our tests. In overall quality, both still and video images shot in low light on the

0:33:15iPhone 5 were of comparable quality to those shot in the iPhone 4S, though they did appear

0:33:19little cooler with a bluish hue. The shutter delay for both iPhones seemed all but instantaneous.

0:33:26What the hell camera are they using?

0:33:29That's interesting.

0:33:30Now, there's a picture next to it. Here, let me send you the URL.

0:33:37Did they not go into low enough light to trigger this new mode, maybe?

0:33:40I think what they did is they used some sort of third-party app to take the pictures, because

0:33:47a picture of them taking pictures.

0:33:49Oh yeah, the same with like the clock on the left?

0:33:52Yeah, I don't think that's camera.app, is it? It looks like there's like a status bar

0:33:58at the top.

0:33:59No, that's just, that's the…

0:34:01Or is that just…

0:34:02No, that is camera.

0:34:03Oh, it's the picture. I see it. It's actually what's in the picture.

0:34:07Yeah, that is the picture.

0:34:08I don't understand how they could have written this. I don't understand how they could

0:34:11say that the... I think it is true that in regular light, broad daylight, typical lighting

0:34:18situations, the camera is very much equivalent to the 4S. You know, very, very hard to say

0:34:23one is better than the other. In some of my comparison shots, I think the 4S one looked

0:34:27better. And just because I tapped, you know, just the luck of the draw of getting slightly

0:34:32better sunlight or tapping a better target in the building I was shooting.

0:34:36Yeah, it seemed like sometimes the iPhone 5 was overexposing the bright areas and blowing

0:34:39the highlights. You know, and I don't really think that they tried to make it sound at

0:34:44any point that in regular lighting situations that the new camera is all that much better.

0:34:49I mean, the old one was really good. But for Consumer Reports to say that it's not better

0:34:55in low light, I don't understand, I really don't understand how they could say that.

0:34:58I mean, to me that's crazy. Yeah, that's, I mean, I wonder really what

0:35:05what their testing was here.

0:35:07What were they taking pictures of?

0:35:09'Cause it looks like in this picture

0:35:11that they're taking pictures of a computer screen.

0:35:13Is that accurate?

0:35:13- Yeah, it looks like it.

0:35:14It's very hard to tell.

0:35:16- So it looks like a Windows computer.

0:35:18You can see in the,

0:35:20it looks like the clock window that they have there

0:35:22has a Windows title bar on it, maybe.

0:35:25Like that gray style, I don't know.

0:35:27But it looks like they're definitely taking a picture

0:35:30of a screen there.

0:35:32And so I have to wonder,

0:35:33how did they do low light comparison?

0:35:36Did they just turn the screen,

0:35:38like have the screen show dark gray or something?

0:35:40- I don't know.

0:35:42- I'm curious to know, 'cause you're right,

0:35:44there is a noticeable difference in how low light

0:35:48you can shoot in with the iPhone 5.

0:35:50And I think any review would have noticed that

0:35:53if they looked at the camera.

0:35:55- Yeah, I really, I would like to see

0:35:57one of the camera sites, like dpreview.com

0:36:00or somebody like that review.

0:36:02Honestly, I think Apple should seed those sites with review units.

0:36:05I think that the iPhone and Apple, I think Apple is, I think one of the stories of the

0:36:11next five years, honestly, is that Apple, and truth be told, Samsung, really, are going

0:36:18to become the top camera companies in the world.

0:36:21And I don't think that, you know, like Nikon is being completely taken by surprise here,

0:36:27because I know Nikon has like an Android-based phone.

0:36:31I don't think it's out yet, but I know that they were previewing it.

0:36:36So they're aware of that.

0:36:39But I really do think that the cell phones are going to just blow away the standalone

0:36:46camera industry.

0:36:47I mean, I think they already have for a lot of it.

0:36:51But even, like, you know, now they have this whole category of these small, mirrorless

0:36:56prosumer cameras.

0:36:58And so you have the micro four thirds and Canon's making a new one.

0:37:02And I actually preordered the Canon one, the EOS M, because I figured that might be useful.

0:37:07I have these Canon lenses even though you need an adapter and blah blah blah.

0:37:11I ordered a thinking, you know, I would love to carry around a small camera sometimes that's

0:37:18way better in quality than the iPhone.

0:37:21And it turns out, I did that two years ago with an S90 and I just never used the thing

0:37:26so I ended up selling it.

0:37:28And I have my big SLR.

0:37:30And the question is, what do you do to solve times when you don't want to bring the whole

0:37:37SLR with you or you don't have it with you, but you want something higher quality than

0:37:41the iPhone?

0:37:42And the problem is that gap keeps narrowing.

0:37:45And it's narrowing to the point where if you get one of those middle cameras, it's like,

0:37:52how often will you actually use that thing?

0:37:54often will you have that but not the SLR? And for me, this is why I'm thinking I'm

0:38:01probably going to cancel that pre-order, because that solves a problem that I don't have

0:38:08anymore. I know in reality, instead what I did was I got the little 40mm pancake lens

0:38:14that Canon released a couple months ago. And it's not amazing, but it's decent. And

0:38:19so I got that little pancake lens and I just keep that on the 5D. And so whenever we take

0:38:24a trip somewhere where I'm bringing like a backpack with the computer and everything,

0:38:28I toss the whole 5D in there with that lens on it.

0:38:30Yeah, and it makes it—I have the exact same camera too, and it makes a big difference

0:38:33because my other go-to lens is my baby. And you know what I'm talking about. I'm talking

0:38:37about that— The 1.250?

0:38:38Yeah, the 1.250. I mean, I've blacked out. I've already blacked out on my memory. What

0:38:43did I pay for that? What is that? I think it's $1600.

0:38:46Yeah, it's a $1600 camera lens. That's my baby. But it's—

0:38:50It's a great lens, but it's huge. It's huge. It is—

0:38:54how do you get f1.2 with a lot of glass?

0:38:57- Oh yeah.

0:38:58- So it's a lot of glass which means it's really heavy

0:39:01and it's a lot of glass and you know it's made of glass

0:39:03and so you do not want to drop that.

0:39:05(glass breaking)

0:39:06- Oh yeah.

0:39:08Whereas like the little pancake lens,

0:39:10it's 40 millimeter, it's 200 bucks.

0:39:11- Right.

0:39:12- And it's a pancake prime and it fits any Canon EOS mount

0:39:15and it's great.

0:39:16- If you're gonna wear your camera around your neck all day

0:39:18it makes a huge difference.

0:39:20- And also if you're putting it in a bag,

0:39:22The problem with a camera is if you're putting it in any kind of thin or rectangular bag,

0:39:26like a messenger bag, the shape of a camera with a lens mount on it is like this big bulbous

0:39:31shape.

0:39:32It's not just flat.

0:39:33And the 40mm pancake makes it a lot flatter.

0:39:36Like it makes it so that the...

0:39:38Here, let me see.

0:39:39I have one right over here.

0:39:42Yeah, see the 40mm lens extends out from the 5D Mark II just about maybe a half of a second.

0:39:52of an inch beyond the little blob on top that says Canon points outward.

0:39:58But that usually would be a flash if it wasn't a professional camera.

0:40:01Yeah, so I think it's really short.

0:40:03And so it makes it fit into bags a lot better just to have the reduction of lens depth with it.

0:40:09Yeah, throw that thing on your 5D and it kind of is your gap camera.

0:40:12Right, exactly.

0:40:14And it's, you know, that's why I like, I mean sure, like the EOS M and these mirrorless cameras,

0:40:19they are a lot smaller, the 5D body is pretty big and chunky, so these things are a lot smaller,

0:40:24but it's still relatively the same size class. It's like

0:40:28comparing a 13-inch MacBook Air to a big MacBook Pro.

0:40:34Yeah, the Air is a lot smaller, but it's still the same general size class of object,

0:40:40so chances are if you are somewhere or in some situation where it's

0:40:45impractical or impossible to carry

0:40:49a 13 inch MacBook, or to carry a MacBook Pro,

0:40:53you probably also won't be carrying a MacBook Air.

0:40:57Similar kind of thing as this, if you're in a situation where you can't carry

0:41:01an SLR with the 40mm lens on it, you probably also won't have

0:41:05any little mirrorless camera with you. Because they don't fit in pockets. Unless you have

0:41:09really big pockets. But for the most part they don't fit in pockets. So they still have to go

0:41:13in a bag or something. So it's still the same portability class.

0:41:17Absolutely agree. And I used to, as an amateur photo enthusiast, certainly not a serious

0:41:27photographer but I enjoy taking pictures. And Dan and I used to talk about it all the

0:41:33time. My Ricoh, oh geez I forget what the hell it was called.

0:41:37GR something, GR1?

0:41:39GR1, which I paid, I think in 2006 I paid 800 bucks for, which is a lot for a little

0:41:46point-and-shoot camera but I loved that camera. It's one of the greatest $800 I've ever spent

0:41:53in my life. It has sadly given up the ghost. It doesn't really work that well anymore,

0:41:59like power it on and sometimes the lens gets stuck and stuff like that. And like, I don't know,

0:42:05and the software gets stuck sometimes where it's on but it won't take pictures. But I just,

0:42:11even if it worked perfectly, I would never carry it around anymore though because

0:42:14The whole reason I loved it was that it took such great pictures for a point-and-shoot,

0:42:19and it took such great pictures in low light without a flash.

0:42:22And that is the one thing that I'd like for the last year or two I'd been on the fence about

0:42:29replacing that, either with the latest Ricoh GR whatever, or probably with the one that I think

0:42:36has probably taken its place, the Canon S100, and before that the S95, which actually looks a lot

0:42:42like a little black point and shoot from Canon which is a fantastic camera really

0:42:49is really fast lens and it shoots nice video and stuff like that but it's

0:42:54really gotten to the point and the five the iPhone 5 really has gotten to the

0:42:57point now where with the low-light performance so that you know you can

0:43:01take pictures of people at dinner and stuff like that it's not as good it does

0:43:07definitely is not as good it doesn't take pictures as good as the s100 but

0:43:10it's close enough and so much more radically convenient that what's the, you know, it's just,

0:43:20there's no way I'm ever going to buy a point and shoot again, I don't think.

0:43:22Jared: Exactly. And, you know, and it's easy for us, you know, I think a lot of people took a similar

0:43:30path that we did, or at least that I did, where you kind of, you discover photography through

0:43:34these awesome SLRs over the last five, six years that have existed. And I've heard

0:43:40a lot of people in our circle of nerds and nerd friends that are like us who have done

0:43:46this path. And once you get used to the quality from an SLR, even a bad SLR, even the lowest

0:43:52end ones, I guess bad is the wrong word, but even the lowest end SLRs.

0:43:56Right. Bottom of the line, Cannon Rebel.

0:43:59Yeah, basic Cannon Rebel, even the S series I think is the cheapest one now.

0:44:03Even that has way better quality than what you get from the S90 and S100 series.

0:44:09Exactly. Exactly.

0:44:10Because the sensor is so much bigger, the optics are so much bigger, the tolerances are way different.

0:44:15Even that is way better quality.

0:44:17So, like I found with the S90, one of the reasons why I didn't really care for it, besides that I would always forget to bring it with me,

0:44:24was that optically it didn't hold a candle to what I had at the time was the Rebel.

0:44:30Right.

0:44:31and it didn't even compare.

0:44:34- So if you're gonna, basically,

0:44:35if you're gonna compromise on quality,

0:44:36and all point and shoots are severely compromised

0:44:39on quality compared to SLR. - Yes, even your beloved

0:44:41S100, everybody, that's, even those--

0:44:43- Right, I would rather compromise with the iPhone camera

0:44:46and make up for that with software, right?

0:44:50So you can put filters on it,

0:44:52you can diddle with it right there,

0:44:53and you can Instagram it right away, right?

0:44:56It doesn't, it hardly even makes sense anymore

0:44:57to have a camera that you can't upload

0:44:59the picture immediately.

0:45:01Oh yeah, that's why, like you see the new Canon, what is it, the 6D? I think it's,

0:45:07yeah, the 6D. They just announced it like two weeks ago, they're releasing it soon,

0:45:13and it's the first Canon camera that has, as far as I know, at least the first SLR that

0:45:17has Wi-Fi built in and GPS. So they're kind of getting towards a smartphone, like obviously

0:45:25there's still a long way to go there, but I feel like it was kind of a waste to not

0:45:29put that in their high-end 5D Mark III or in their portable EOS M. But anyway, I think

0:45:37going back to your original point that you're right, and it seems obvious, but I think it's

0:45:42really worth pointing this out that the market for non-professional cameras is pretty much

0:45:49gone. It's like the market for PDAs. No one's buying PDAs anymore.

0:45:55And the store shelves like when you walk into Target, they don't reflect that yet

0:45:59There still is a counter where you can go and choose from 30 different point-and-shoot cameras, but I think that's going away

0:46:06I really do and you know and people still are buying them like, you know, my mom has a point-and-shoot camera

0:46:11but how many more years like

0:46:13When the current one dies will she replace it?

0:46:16Maybe by that time she'll be using a smartphone that has a better camera in it, right?

0:46:21You know, I don't know and like I think everybody can point to people in their lives

0:46:25they know who have point-and-shoots now, but if you think about it, all right, well, let's

0:46:28say that last another three or four years, then what phone will they be using in three

0:46:33or four years?

0:46:34And will it become worth it for them to replace that camera or not?

0:46:37Right.

0:46:38It's like non-smartphone phones.

0:46:39Right.

0:46:40Exactly.

0:46:41I mean, they are there.

0:46:42And I guess point-and-shoot cameras will never truly go away, but they're going to become

0:46:44like this little thing that only a very handful of people use.

0:46:49I mentioned this a few weeks ago, where I was actually had to go in.

0:46:52I didn't have to but I wanted to, sounds weird, go into a Verizon retail store here.

0:47:00Long story short, because we were switching from AT&T, we could only buy, we could only

0:47:05pre-order one iPhone from Apple.

0:47:10Which makes sense, I think it has stuff, you know, it might even be related to the unlocked

0:47:15sim thing where they don't want to sell you subsidized iPhones before they know that you're

0:47:23you know not gonna take them all to China.

0:47:26Right I actually I actually don't blame them for this even though it was a bit of an irritation

0:47:30and that's why my iPhone didn't get here till yesterday instead of on day one.

0:47:37But we had to pre-order one and then get it set up before we could add another one to

0:47:42the account. And so I went into a Verizon store just to see if there was any way that

0:47:45I could shortchange that and just say, "Here, can you just charge my credit card now and

0:47:50let me open an account? Or do we have to have the device?" And the bottom line was you

0:47:54have to have the device. And I actually even thought about buying just a burner, just get

0:48:00like a $40 whatever so that I could have a Verizon account and then I could add iPhones.

0:48:05And then I honestly, and it was like a moment of like wisdom.

0:48:10I was like, you know what, don't throw another $40 away.

0:48:15Just wait, just wait.

0:48:16It's not gonna kill you to wait.

0:48:17And so I did it.

0:48:18- I love how the option you never considered

0:48:21was getting an Android phone.

0:48:22- Right, but I did know.

0:48:23Here's the thing that makes me bring it up right now is

0:48:26there's, it was actually hard.

0:48:29When the idea occurred to me in the store

0:48:31of maybe I'll just buy the cheapest phone I can get

0:48:33open a Verizon account, it was actually hard to find them. I mean, there are very few of

0:48:37them left. It's really – Verizon retail store is really a smartphone and even tablet

0:48:44store. The tablets are more prominent. And of course, they want – they're higher

0:48:47priced and it makes sense that the cheap phones aren't – actually, I think they really

0:48:52rip people off on those cheap phones. They're actually expensive. I remember –

0:48:56Oh, yeah. You pay like 100 bucks for one. Yeah. I remember 10 years ago, they were free

0:48:59free or almost free. My phone that I had before the iPhone was just this POS Nokia thing,

0:49:07although it did make good phone calls. I very distinctly remember that I did get it on a

0:49:12contract I guess, but I paid like $19 for it. It was like $19.95 with a two-year contract

0:49:17and a very reasonable all I was paying for it. There's no data. It was just minutes.

0:49:21Yeah, you're paying like 40, 50 bucks a month for it.

0:49:23You couldn't get – if they had a $19 phone, I probably would have done it and just bought

0:49:27the $19 Verizon phone and opened an account. But they didn't. They were all like 50 bucks,

0:49:34like 100 bucks.

0:49:35Jared Ranerelle>> I bet the reason why is because they know, because they don't require

0:49:39you to buy data plans for all the random Android smartphones, do they? I think that's still

0:49:44optional. But they know that if you buy this flip phone for 40 bucks or 50 bucks, you're

0:49:51spending 40 bucks a month for that contract. But they know that if they can upsell you

0:49:56you to a smartphone that there's x percentage chance that you're going to opt for a data

0:50:01plan.

0:50:02And that's going to get them way more money over the course of that contract.

0:50:05So I think it's in their best interest to price those flip phones fairly unappealingly

0:50:09close to a smartphone.

0:50:11So it's like, "Well, you can get this flip phone for $129 or you can get this low-end

0:50:15Android phone for $50."

0:50:16I don't know if they'll sell you one without a data plan.

0:50:19I don't know.

0:50:20It would seem weird to sell you a smartphone without a data plan.

0:50:24But maybe they do.

0:50:25I don't know.

0:50:26- Well, either way, if they don't require it,

0:50:28they know that some percentage of people

0:50:30will be able to be upsold to it.

0:50:32And if they do require it, then that's 100%.

0:50:34So it's either way, they know that if they can get you

0:50:37into an Android phone rather than a flip phone,

0:50:40they have a much better chance of making more money

0:50:42from you in the long run.

0:50:43- Hey, let me take a break, and it's actually a good point

0:50:45'cause we were just talking about cameras

0:50:49and the advantage of having software right on your device.

0:50:52Let me take a break and tell you about our first sponsor.

0:50:53Game Your Video. It's from our friends at Global Delight, the most frequent talk show

0:51:00sponsor, so I thank them.

0:51:01They're great.

0:51:02Game Your Video, they call it the ultimate video creation app. In a lot of ways, it really

0:51:09is, it's almost like the anti-iOS iMovie, like where iMovie has a zillion little controls

0:51:13on screen, very complicated. Game Your Video, super simple. You open it up, you either shoot

0:51:18the video or you grab one from your library and you just have this simple little stuff

0:51:23at the bottom of the screen for doing things like slow motion and Instagram style filters

0:51:31that all get applied live. You don't pick a filter and then sit there and wait while

0:51:35it renders. You can just, you can actually change the filters while you're playing the

0:51:39video or while you're shooting the video in the app. It's kind of amazing considering

0:51:45how putting filters like that on still photos in apps like Hipstamatic takes like 30 seconds

0:51:52to render an image. They're doing it live in video. Really, really cool stuff.

0:51:58**Ezra Klein:** That's impressive.

0:51:59**Ezra Klein** It really is. You play with it and it's like,

0:52:03"I kind of can't believe this is possible." And this works on all the iPhones too. It

0:52:08works on iPhone 4, 4S. It's not like you need the iPhone 5 for it. They call the interaction,

0:52:16what do they call it here? They call it "play and change." So, the whole point is that

0:52:20you can change the stuff while you're playing the video on the fly to see how it looks.

0:52:25Really, really cool stuff. I first saw it. I saw this app this year at Macworld Expo

0:52:32in San Francisco. And it won. The app won a Best of Show award from Macworld magazine.

0:52:39Well deserved. And I just remember thinking on the show floor, I remember thinking that

0:52:44it really seemed fake. I didn't want to accuse them of it, but I really wanted to play with

0:52:49it in my hand to make sure that I wasn't watching a canned demo of these filters being applied

0:52:55to video as it goes without any kind of hiccup or pause or rendering mode or anything like

0:53:01that. Really, really cool app. So here's the URL. Bitly, you know Bitly, bit.ly. Go to

0:53:09bit.ly/gameyourvideo, all one word. Bit.ly/gameyourvideo. Or just go to the App Store and search for

0:53:22game your video. One last thing, through October 7th. Now today as we record it is September

0:53:2927th. So, you got a little bit over a week. 50% off. 50% off. It's only a buck 99 in the

0:53:35App Store.

0:53:36Jared Polin Nice.

0:53:37Tim Weiss Great app. See me on Charlie Rose last week?

0:53:42Jared Polin Yeah, I did. That was pretty cool.

0:53:44Tim Weiss It was pretty cool. I'll tell you what. My

0:53:45one regret, speaking of camera apps, is my one, the one answer I wish I had back was

0:53:50when he asked, "What does this not do that you wish it did?" And I said, first thing,

0:53:57you're under the gun, you're on live TV,

0:53:59I thought, well, I wish it had like double the battery life.

0:54:02Instead of like one day of battery life,

0:54:03I wish it had double.

0:54:05Two days of typical use, and then I could get through

0:54:07one day of like heavy use at a conference.

0:54:11Like in theory, just blue sky,

0:54:13what do I wish the iPhone had that it doesn't?

0:54:16In hindsight, what I wish I'd said was,

0:54:19I wish it shot near SLR caliber photographs.

0:54:24Like that's my dream for like where I hope

0:54:26the iPhone is five years from now. I hope that it can take, I don't know, the laws of

0:54:34physics are actually hurting them with regard to how thin these things are and the way that

0:54:38cameras really need big, big glass and big sensors and distance from the glass to the

0:54:44sensor. But they've got smart people. I don't know. They can figure it out somehow. That's

0:54:48just pie in the sky. I wish that the iPhone could shoot, I won't say SLR quality, but

0:54:54near SLR quality.

0:54:56I wonder if there's some way and please email John, I wonder if there's some way

0:55:01that to combine a bunch of small sensors and small lenses like a mosquito eye, like just

0:55:07like in like a grid, that way, you know, and somehow combine all those into one coherent

0:55:12image. I don't know if that's possible or if the results would be good or not. Isn't

0:55:16that, that's kind of what that little, what was that little box camera that was the novelty

0:55:20with the 3D focusing?

0:55:21Lycra, Lycra, Lytro?

0:55:23Lightro, that's it, yeah. Kind of like what they were going for, but not quite. I'm

0:55:29sure people have tried this. I wonder if that's a direction Apple could go in the future,

0:55:34to basically have like, you know, like it wouldn't, they'd probably make it look

0:55:37like one big camera on the back, but to have like, you know, an array of maybe four sensors

0:55:42with four little micro lenses on them, and then one big lens in front of it kind of masking

0:55:46it all.

0:55:47Well, and I really do think that that sort of pushing the limits thinking is exactly

0:55:51what's going on with the low-light photos here in the iPhone 5, you know,

0:55:55where they're doing this thing where they're sampling four pixels at once to

0:55:58get a pixel of the image and yeah I maybe there is something they could do

0:56:03like that where you know somehow I guess I could just be one big sensor just

0:56:08with just with different lenses on the front like right an array of lens just

0:56:11really doesn't need to be separate sensors yeah just rethink the way that

0:56:13all that's you know all that stuff works and I really do think I do get the

0:56:17impression that I mean they don't pitch it that way they pitch it as hey it's a

0:56:21great, great, great, never better, better than ever before camera in your phone. But

0:56:28I really do think that Apple sees itself now as a camera company. That that's one of the

0:56:33things that's like a top-tier priority for them. I really do. And it's this combination

0:56:39of camera hardware and lens and, you know, the sapphires, you know, coding and stuff

0:56:46like that combined with software.

0:56:48And you know, in the APIs for controlling the camera, they don't give developers access

0:56:56to raw settings like ISO or aperture. As far as I know, I know there's no ISO control.

0:57:01As far as I know there's no aperture control. There might be exposure control.

0:57:05Yeah, there's definitely exposure control. You can at least, like, you can set where

0:57:08it focuses in the photo. But, you know, I wonder if the reason why they haven't exposed

0:57:13this yet, you know, at this point, if there's something missing in iOS or the APIs at this

0:57:18this point, it's probably a conscious decision not to offer that, rather than, "Oh, they

0:57:23just haven't gotten to that yet."

0:57:25You could say they haven't gotten to it yet for iOS 1 through 4 or so, but now it's

0:57:30like if they don't offer something now, they probably have decided not to offer that.

0:57:35I think maybe with the camera manual fine-grained controls, maybe they aren't offering that

0:57:41to be able to then rely more on software optimizations.

0:57:45optimizations. I definitely think so. I think it's, you know, that to them the camera is this black,

0:57:50from a developer standpoint, it's this black box, and inside the black box is hardware and software

0:57:57together. Right, and they don't want developers to be setting the controls themselves. You know,

0:58:02Apple wants to be able to say, for this device and for this hardware and for this lighting situation,

0:58:07we know better, and we're going to do our optimizations, and we're just going to hand

0:58:11you an array of a finished pixel image here. Here's another crazy thing from that, just

0:58:18while we're on the consumer report story. Here's the next paragraph. We also tried out

0:58:22the new panorama feature. And I bring this up because it's related to this software as

0:58:27part of the camera, which is all, you know, the panorama thing is software. We tried out

0:58:32the new panorama feature to the camera, which allows you to take a 240 degree wide angle

0:58:36still image. It worked well and comparably to similar features now

0:58:41found on Android phones. One quibble. The feature only works in portrait model. I

0:58:48guess I guess sick. And there's no alert when you shoot in landscape which can

0:58:57mean trial and error when you shoot your first panoramic shot. So they devoted a

0:59:03whole... is that true? Well, no. It does work in... when you hold the camera in

0:59:09landscape, but then you have to move up and down. So you can... it's so you, you

0:59:13know, you can shoot a panner... they're complaining that you can't go side to

0:59:17side when you hold it sideways. And it does... it is a little counterintuitive at

0:59:22first, because you think, "I'm shooting this crazy wide image. I'll hold the

0:59:25camera wide too." But if you think about it, it actually makes more sense that you

0:59:31hold it in portrait to shoot these things because then you're getting

0:59:36significantly more data vertically. Right. Yeah. Right? Because you don't have to

0:59:43worry about how much data you're getting with each sample of the camera

0:59:47horizontally because you're gonna pan. You're panning your hands. You're gonna

0:59:50get it all anyway. It's up and down where you're getting more. You're actually

0:59:54getting, you know, it makes total sense that they do it this way. Although it is

0:59:57true that the first time you use it, the very first time you shoot, one time with panoramic

1:00:02thing, you're very likely to make a mistake and hold the camera sideways.

1:00:07So what – but if it – everybody, you do it one time, you think, "Oh, okay, I get

1:00:12it." You throw that – you scrap that one and then you'll never do it again. Like,

1:00:16why complain about it? And –

1:00:19Well, if they didn't copy edit this sentence –

1:00:21Yeah. And if it worked –

1:00:23You're like, "How much effort do you think they put into this?"

1:00:24It obviously didn't think about it. And if it worked the way they are saying that they

1:00:29think it should, then you wouldn't be able to take a vertical panorama. And I've seen

1:00:33some pictures people have taken like out of skyscrapers where you're like looking down

1:00:38out of a window or something like that, and a panorama where you move your hand up and

1:00:42down and it looks fantastic. Like a, you know, an up and down panorama.

1:00:47Yeah.

1:00:48Anyway.

1:00:49Anyway, it just it seems like you know Consumer Reports has I

1:00:53lost a lot of respect for them over the last couple years with their various iPhone hijinks and and

1:00:59It just seems like

1:01:02They look for problems first and and I know that's kind of their job in most of their product reviews

1:01:08It's like find what's wrong with this car, you know find out what sucks about this air conditioner

1:01:12but

1:01:14With phones it you know it there. It's such a complex

1:01:17landscape of you can't sum up a phone in three paragraphs and a bulleted list of five criteria.

1:01:24Like you really can't sum up any phone that way. Android, iOS, even Blackberry for God's

1:01:29sake. But it seems like they approach phones the same way they would approach testing a

1:01:35dishwasher and it just doesn't work. They pick three or four criteria ignoring everything

1:01:42else and they make judgments based on those things that they don't really have anything

1:01:47to do with it or might only apply to a very small portion of its users or things like

1:01:53that. It's just kind of weird how they approach these things. It also seems like they judge

1:01:59iPhones with far more scrutiny than the other phones they review. The things they complain

1:02:05about with iPhones, like Android phones they review, have many problems like that and they

1:02:10don't mention them.

1:02:11And people say, you know, the people who hate Apple say, you know, that,

1:02:15you know, like Antennagate is ground zero of this debate, with no doubt, because I don't think

1:02:22Antennagate happens without Consumer Reports. I really don't. Consumer Reports made that happen.

1:02:27And it ends up, they made a mountain out of a molehill. The iPhone 4 on GSM

1:02:36remains a best-selling phone. It's like still the third best-selling phone at AT&T.

1:02:41**Matt Stauffer** Oh yeah, they haven't changed that since then.

1:02:43**Ezra Kleinman** Now there was room for improvement in that antenna design, no doubt. And they

1:02:48improved it six months later in the CDMA version, and they improved it again in the 4S, and

1:02:53they've improved it again now in the 5. But they're still using that antenna, you know.

1:02:57And all the people who said that this was a huge mistake, Apple doesn't, you know, there's

1:03:02There's a reason that none of the people who really know how to make phones like Nokia

1:03:05and Samsung have ever done an external camera antenna.

1:03:11You know, what a disaster, you know, looks over functionality, you know, all those complaints.

1:03:21Here we are three years later and they're still using that antenna design in the iPhone

1:03:265.

1:03:27I mean, of course, you know, it's better than it was.

1:03:29Did you hear that?

1:03:30One of the…

1:03:31No.

1:03:32I told you it was. I found one that didn't have the mute switch on. They blew it. And

1:03:41I do think that they absolutely look for… and they don't do it with other devices.

1:03:45They really don't.

1:03:46Yeah, it seems like the iPhones under way more… and by the way, in retrospect, having

1:03:51an iPhone 4 with both me and my wife, the proximity sensor was way more of an issue.

1:03:57Yeah, totally.

1:03:58And they didn't even really mention that.

1:03:59Right.

1:04:00I think if anybody was going to make a big deal out of something being poorly designed

1:04:04on the iPhone 4, it's the proximity sensor, because a lot of people had issues with that.

1:04:09My wife, it hit her constantly.

1:04:12I hit me sometimes even.

1:04:15And they quietly fixed that, I think with the 4S.

1:04:18I don't think the CDMA version really fixed that, but with the 4S, they definitely had

1:04:21fixed it by then.

1:04:22And that got almost no attention at all.

1:04:28Speaking of antennas, I wanted to ask you about the iPhone 5 LTE and battery life thing.

1:04:34Have you looked at this much?

1:04:35No.

1:04:36Have you seen people talk about this?

1:04:37I haven't heard anything about it.

1:04:38So of course whenever any Apple hardware or software product gets launched, everyone says

1:04:44it makes their battery life worse.

1:04:45And sometimes it actually does, and sometimes it just doesn't and people think it does.

1:04:50And so some background here, as I'm sure you know, but for listeners, when a cell phone

1:04:57cannot get a good signal, what it usually does is start amping up its transmit power

1:05:02so that in poor signal strength, it turns up its power to try to reach more towers and

1:05:08try to get better signals. So it burns through battery life faster in areas of poor or no

1:05:13coverage.

1:05:14And that is probably also why it tends to get hotter when you have poor signal.

1:05:19Yes, exactly, because it's using more power. So I've seen some reports of, I think yesterday

1:05:26and today of people saying the iPhone 5 is having bad battery life because it is trying

1:05:32to reach LTE signals in areas like where I live, I have LTE on some blocks of my neighborhood

1:05:39and not others. My house does not have LTE because my house is not worth covering for

1:05:44any wireless carrier very well, but at least AT&T covers it partially. So I'm in an area

1:05:51with spotty LTE coverage.

1:05:53And by the way, I live like 10 miles from Manhattan,

1:05:56and this has spotty LTE coverage.

1:05:58Thanks, AT&T.

1:06:01It's a long 10 miles, though.

1:06:03Yeah.

1:06:05So I've seen these reports from people speculating.

1:06:10Now, I don't know how they design the LTE radio.

1:06:12I don't know if that's doing the same thing, where

1:06:15if it has a 3G signal, that's perfectly fine,

1:06:19but it can't get an LTE signal.

1:06:20Does it amp up transmit power for a while and look for one and then give up?

1:06:23Like I don't know how they've programmed that

1:06:26um

1:06:26but I think that that could have an effect on battery life and

1:06:29Like if you're somewhere where there's just no LTE coverage at all, or it's very very spotty

1:06:34maybe turning off LTE in the settings might give you better battery life, I don't know but

1:06:38I I assume they would have designed the radio software a little bit better so that it was more tolerant of that

1:06:45I

1:06:48I can't say that I've had better, if anything, the longer I've used the iPhone 5, I've had

1:06:54better battery life than I did on the 4S, which blows me away because it's thinner and lighter.

1:06:59And so I can't help but think that the battery is smaller and it's on LTE, not 4G. But I get through

1:07:07the day easily. And the other day, and I don't even know why I did this because I'm going to send it

1:07:12back. I'm going to pack it up and send it back by the end of the week to Apple, the review unit. But

1:07:17But I did the thing where you're – I don't even know.

1:07:19Apple still does recommend it.

1:07:20Every once in a while, you should use the whole thing.

1:07:22Run the battery down to zero and then recharge it.

1:07:25Like their how to get your best battery life suggestion page for iPhone still says to do

1:07:30that.

1:07:31So I did it.

1:07:32Even though it was the review unit, so who cares if the thing is – I don't know.

1:07:36I just wanted to see what happened because I had never once run it all the way down.

1:07:40And I got the 20 percent warning and I kept using it.

1:07:43And I wasn't doing anything.

1:07:44I wasn't doing something specifically to run the battery life down.

1:07:46I wasn't like playing video or something or streaming stuff.

1:07:49I was just using the phone.

1:07:52And then I got the 10% warning about when I would expect to and I couldn't get the damn

1:07:58thing to run all the way down.

1:08:00After the 10% warning, it just kept going and going and it was getting later at night

1:08:03and I was like getting ready to go to bed and I kind of wanted it to go down before

1:08:07I went.

1:08:08I wanted it to just go all the way down and then go to bed.

1:08:12And it wouldn't – it took forever.

1:08:14It was amazing.

1:08:16I just think that those 10% things, it's like that's all sort of, it's guessing, I think.

1:08:22Oh yeah, because battery chemistry is very complicated, and yeah, those are all just

1:08:27estimates.

1:08:28But I got, I found, usually though, once you get the 10% warning, you really better find

1:08:31a charge, in my experience.

1:08:33Oh yeah.

1:08:34You know, and maybe that speaks to the fact that the brand new phone, it isn't as calibrated

1:08:39as well as you'd think.

1:08:40It isn't as accurate.

1:08:41But anyway, I've had great battery life.

1:08:43I had trouble running the damn thing down to zero.

1:08:46See, I've had a little bit less battery life,

1:08:48or so it seemed, but then I realized,

1:08:51and I think this might apply to a lot of people,

1:08:53the reason why my phone kept getting lower and lower

1:08:55is because I don't really have anything around the house

1:08:57with the lightning port that I rested in to plug it in.

1:09:00So like before, we had these speaker docks

1:09:04in a couple of rooms, and so like every time

1:09:06we did eat a meal, or if I'm like washing the dishes,

1:09:08I got one in the kitchen, so I would put the phone

1:09:11in the speaker dock and play a podcast or something.

1:09:13- And just sip a little bit of charge, right?

1:09:16And it was charging, it's an AC-powered dock, so it would charge.

1:09:20And it would be charging there for like 20 minutes at least, 20-30 minutes.

1:09:24So throughout the day, my phone would keep getting these little sips of power, and that

1:09:28would power it up.

1:09:29And now I don't have lightning ports anywhere really, except I went to the Apple store the

1:09:36other day and finally got some extra cables.

1:09:38But I'm not putting it in docks all day in various different locations.

1:09:43So I think that might be happening to a lot of people who you think this has worse battery

1:09:49life, but in reality this effect is biting you.

1:09:51Yeah, maybe.

1:09:52This effect is saying, "Oh, wait a minute.

1:09:54It's just because I'm not plugging it in as much."

1:09:56Yeah.

1:09:57It was a real pain for the first couple of days when I only had one lightning cable.

1:10:03And it was like, "Where the hell is it?"

1:10:04And it's like, "Oh, it's upstairs.

1:10:05Damn it.

1:10:06I got to go upstairs."

1:10:07Yeah.

1:10:08I kept moving mine around the whole house to my computer and then upstairs for charging

1:10:12overnight.

1:10:13The one day I was actually walking around the house with it around my neck, like just

1:10:17like a scarf. Maybe it was like, "You look like such an asshole." And I was like, "I

1:10:23need this cable."

1:10:24That's great. That's like the calculator watch and the modern day equivalent.

1:10:30I also spent one day over the weekend, the first weekend I had it at a family thing way

1:10:36outside the city where there is no LTE it was on Verizon 3G and I was in fact

1:10:41and there was a Yankees game on so I was streaming it over 3G and I battery life

1:10:48was excellent now maybe it was so far outside LTE range that it wasn't even

1:10:52doing that if this hypothesis is correct that if you're on the cusp of LTE

1:10:57coverage it'll spend too much energy trying to get on LTE rather than just

1:11:02using the 3G or whatever is available. Maybe I was so far outside of LTE range that it

1:11:08wasn't even trying. I don't know. But I had to – I was streaming live video over

1:11:123G and got excellent battery life.

1:11:14Yeah.

1:11:15Do you ever go to the Wirecutter? That's Brian Lamb of formerly –

1:11:19Yeah, sometimes. I like it. It's a good site. I don't always agree with their recommendations,

1:11:24but I like the site.

1:11:25But they do things – they do this the way I think Consumer Reports should be. I think

1:11:29There's room for somebody to come in and be like the new consumer reports.

1:11:35Maybe the wire cutter is that for technology.

1:11:38But I like the way that they do this, where instead of giving you this stupid matrix of

1:11:42seven different criteria rated from zero to five circles and half circles and blue circles

1:11:49and blue half circles and all this shit, they just say, "Here, TV is the best TV.

1:11:54Here it is.

1:11:55It's the Panasonic TCPS T50.

1:11:58TV under $600? Oh, we'll get this one. Best small TV? Get that one. And that's it. That's

1:12:04their TV section. The best one, the best one under a certain price, and the best one that's

1:12:09small.

1:12:10Jared: It's certainly a lot more helpful.

1:12:11John: It really, I think it really is.

1:12:14Jared; Because that's, you know, that's really what you want. Like, you don't, you

1:12:16don't necessarily want to see, you know, and, you know, I should say, before last year

1:12:21when their 4S review annoyed me, I was a Consumer Reports online subscriber for like six years.

1:12:27And I would go there and check whenever I want.

1:12:29And during this time I've gone through many different apartments and we finally bought

1:12:31a house.

1:12:32So I bought a lot of small appliances, dishwashers, air conditioners, even a washer/dryer, usually

1:12:38window air conditioners for the various apartments.

1:12:41And we would always check consumer reports, vacuum cleaner, anything I bought that was

1:12:46an appliance type thing I would always check there.

1:12:48And it was usually not very helpful.

1:12:52And partly because it was the stupid thing where you can't buy the same air conditioner

1:12:57two years in a row because they changed all the models and each store you go to has different

1:13:00models because they have their own exclusives and blah blah blah.

1:13:02But even when I could find the ones they recommended, they would do one report every three years

1:13:12on which humidifier was the best and it wouldn't even give you a conclusion.

1:13:17It would be like, "Well, this is kind of good.

1:13:19This one's kind of good.

1:13:20This is kind of good but loud and this one's too expensive."

1:13:22And that's not really what I want.

1:13:24You know, just tell me which one to buy.

1:13:26And that's what the Wirecutter does.

1:13:27It's like just bite through all the bullshit

1:13:29and just tell me which one to buy.

1:13:30- Yeah, I really wish more people would take that route.

1:13:33Now we're an hour into the show,

1:13:34we're over an hour into the show,

1:13:35and we haven't even talked about maps yet.

1:13:37I feel like we gotta talk about maps.

1:13:39- Do we?

1:13:40- I don't know.

1:13:41Maybe just briefly, I don't know.

1:13:43- All right.

1:13:44- You know, and now I've got Dan Lyons.

1:13:48Dan Lyons is back, he's over at Gizmodo now.

1:13:50he says that MG, Sigler, and I are, what did he call us?

1:13:55- Who knows?

1:13:55- Spoke spots, something like that,

1:13:59that were paid spoke spots for Apple

1:14:01or something like that because we're not--

1:14:03- Is that even a word, spoke spot?

1:14:05- He's, you know, it's a gizmodo.

1:14:07I don't really understand,

1:14:11I feel like there's some people who because,

1:14:12okay, so the maps data is not good

1:14:16in the new maps from Apple, right?

1:14:18I've never said otherwise, right? I've linked to people's criticism of it. I've,

1:14:26you know, I don't know what I'm supposed to write that would make people

1:14:31think that I'm doing this, that somebody like that, that I'm doing this

1:14:36right. I'm not sure there is such a thing that you could write. Right? I mean, what

1:14:40are you supposed to do? You have to say what? That this is doom and gloom and now

1:14:45Apple, you know, don't upgrade your phone and, you know, don't buy a new iPhone. I mean,

1:14:52it doesn't make any sense. I can't say that honestly. Right? They were screwed. I feel

1:14:58like the way, it's one of those things where I kind of figured it out as I wrote it. By

1:15:02writing about it, I really thought about it. That Apple really only had three options.

1:15:07Go another year with the old deal, which would have still meant all of the same missing features.

1:15:12turn by turn, no vector maps. The vector maps thing is a big deal, because they load faster

1:15:18and they zoom faster. It's a huge difference. Like, say what you want about the quality

1:15:24of the data or the searching on the new Apple maps, but I don't see how anybody can deny

1:15:30that it's a hell of a lot faster, and that's because of the vector-based maps. And maps

1:15:36on Android, where they do have the Google maps that get vector-based tiles, are a lot

1:15:41faster than Maps was on iOS. So option one, to go another year with the old deal. No turn

1:15:48by turn at all. None. You don't have any of it. And you couldn't use. If you were by yourself

1:15:55in a car, you could not use your iPhone for directions, or else you'd be risking your

1:16:00life in the texting. No joke. In the way that texting while driving is reckless and kills

1:16:06people every year. Using your iPhone by yourself without a co-pilot to tell you what to do,

1:16:12you're risking your life. I mean that without any exaggeration.

1:16:15So you had no turn-by-turn. No help at all. So every single person who gets successful

1:16:22turn-by-turn directions in iOS 6 is a person who wouldn't have had it in that option.

1:16:29I think they were really hurt by that competitively. It is a useful feature.

1:16:35know, I think it's turning into one of those Antennagate things where with Antennagate

1:16:39it was the iPhone 4 can't make a phone call. Right? And now I think that it's in large,

1:16:48it's like the Dan Lyons angle is that iOS 6 maps doesn't work. That no matter what you

1:16:54do, it's not going to work. Whereas, that's, you know, obviously there's a lot of cases

1:16:59where it doesn't. But in most cases it does work just fine.

1:17:02Yeah, honestly, I mean, one of the reasons I haven't really written about the maps

1:17:05thing myself is that I'm just not seeing these problems, because the data around me

1:17:09is fine.

1:17:10Right.

1:17:11And, by the way, and this is a lot like, like when, when the Verizon iPhone first came out,

1:17:15everybody in our, you know, world who switched to AT&T could not wait to get back to Verizon

1:17:22because it was going to be perfect and solve all their problems.

1:17:24But Verizon is not perfect, and they have problems too.

1:17:28They're just different problems, and we'd forgotten about them for a while.

1:17:30Right.

1:17:31iOS 6 maps, you know, Google Maps data sucks in a lot of ways. And I have been bitten so

1:17:37many times by, usually the way it sucks is not the road data but the business data, where

1:17:42it'll tell me that some store is somewhere and that store will have closed down six years

1:17:46ago and they haven't updated their data and stuff like that. And I had tons of problems

1:17:52with Google Map data, but nobody thought about it because it was Google. Of course, it's

1:17:57the best. That's just the reality of having it. And now with Maps, with Maps and iOS 6,

1:18:04I think people are, again, they're applying a lot of scrutiny to it because it's new,

1:18:07and in some ways it is worse. But I think not all of the scrutiny, or not all of the

1:18:12criticism is justified as something that Google Maps does better, because a lot of them aren't.

1:18:17Right. So what I, and the other thing that helps spread the meme, if you will, is that

1:18:25it does demo well. Like when you search for the Washington Monument and it shows up in

1:18:30the wrong space. You know, you could take…

1:18:32Right.

1:18:33It screenshots well. The mistakes screenshot well. And, you know, the amazing iOS 6 maps

1:18:39Tumblr site is funny. Although it's starting to get old. I feel like…which I think kind

1:18:43of shows that it's not that bad. Right? Like it's, you know, how many melted bridges,

1:18:49you know, can you laugh at?

1:18:51Right.

1:18:52Now, what I call option three is the option Apple went with, which was to kiss Google

1:18:56Goodbye and go out on their own with the trade-off.

1:18:59And it is a trade-off.

1:19:00This is the thing that people can't – I feel like every single one of these incidents,

1:19:04these gates, is always about trade-offs.

1:19:07And the people wanting to blow it up refuse to acknowledge that there's anything – that

1:19:12it's a trade-off, right?

1:19:13It's – iOS 6 maps is a total bag of dog shit.

1:19:16That's it.

1:19:17That's the argument from the other side.

1:19:19It's total shit and anybody saying otherwise is wrong.

1:19:22Whereas it's not.

1:19:23It has vector-based tiles, which look great and are much faster, and it has turn-by-turn

1:19:29directions, which is a great feature that it didn't have before.

1:19:34And this is the route Apple went.

1:19:36Now, I think the problem is that the critics, what I call option two, which was give in

1:19:43to Google and let Google have what it wanted to get turn-by-turn and vector maps from Google

1:19:49that that's what Apple should have done. And the concessions would have been

1:19:53significant. It would have been, you know, Google wanted and a couple people

1:19:57have reported this. It's not just from one site. It's like the Times had it. I

1:20:00think somebody else had it too. But Google wanted more branding, more Google

1:20:05branding in the app, more control over the design of the app. You know, I think

1:20:10that the, I think people listening to our show know this, but I think in the large

1:20:13world when people write about this, they think there's a lot of people who

1:20:17probably think Google wrote the old iOS Maps app, which isn't true. Apple wrote the app

1:20:24and worked with Google on how they were going to do the APIs for the back. It was like an

1:20:28API call to get the map tiles themselves.

1:20:30And if you look at the iOS apps that Google has written, you might not want them to write

1:20:35the maps.

1:20:36Exactly. No, it's very true. And some of them aren't bad. The new YouTube app is like a

1:20:45plus and minus in certain ways, I think.

1:20:47I would say the new YouTube app is just as good and bad as the iOS 6 maps app.

1:20:52Yeah.

1:20:53But, you know, it's less important to people.

1:20:57But the big one is the privacy angle that Google wanted.

1:21:01I don't even know if they still call it Latitude, Google Latitude, or if that's been rolled

1:21:05into Google Plus, the Google Plus umbrella.

1:21:07But in other words, though, you log in with Google credentials and then Google tracks

1:21:12where you go.

1:21:14you do check-ins, it's like foursquare type thing where you check into places and stuff

1:21:18like that. And you know, if you don't mind that, and I'm not saying that Google's collection

1:21:26of user identifiable data, your search queries and your location and all of this stuff and

1:21:31indexing your email to serve you ads based on the content of your email and stuff like

1:21:37that. I'm not saying it's wrong, but I'm saying though it's something to think about and I'm

1:21:42not comfortable with it personally.

1:21:44And there are.

1:21:45Right?

1:21:46Millions of people are, obviously.

1:21:49And I feel like the tech-minded people who don't mind it, who are totally embracing the

1:21:57Google angle on this, you know.

1:22:00And Dan Lyons is a perfect example, a guy who loudly and publicly and happily switched

1:22:06to an Android phone years ago.

1:22:08You know, people who are totally into the whole Google lifestyle, Google Docs for all

1:22:11of your writing and stuff like that. Obviously don't mind it because they're into it, but

1:22:17they don't seem to be willing to concede that there is another angle on this that, you know,

1:22:23other people wouldn't want that stuff to be collected, and that Apple has an interest

1:22:28in not allowing Google to build a location monopoly similar to their web search monopoly.

1:22:36>> Oh, sure. And, you know, it's important also for people to realize, and, you know,

1:22:42you outlined this too, but it's important to realize that, you know, I think Apple would

1:22:47have had to move away from Google eventually. Like, there was no question that this could

1:22:51not last that much longer, especially given the relationship between the two companies

1:22:55breaking down so much over the last five years. And I think, especially, you know, Apple does

1:23:02not like when somebody else has them by the balls over anything. And they always consistently,

1:23:09you know, in the Steve 2 era and beyond, they have always worked to eliminate ways in which

1:23:17other people had them by the balls.

1:23:18Exactly.

1:23:19And like the retail stores were a huge thing in that regard. You know, the iPhone, to launch

1:23:26a cell phone you have to be willing to be controlled by the carriers to some degree,

1:23:30but Apple did a pretty good job of negotiating themselves out of that, and now their demand

1:23:33is propelling that.

1:23:34The switch to Intel?

1:23:35Yeah, the switch to Intel, exactly.

1:23:37Because they were really – IBM had them by the balls on PowerPC.

1:23:41Right.

1:23:42And even you think, well, then Intel has them by the balls, but they don't really because

1:23:45their Intel had – there's AMD.

1:23:47Now Apple's ever –

1:23:48And now there's ARM.

1:23:49Right.

1:23:50Apple's never bought – used AMD chips, but it was always on the table.

1:23:55Right.

1:23:56And so now, you know, I think, hold on, my dog's about to bark.

1:24:00That's alright.

1:24:01The male's here.

1:24:02Well, and the other thing too about Intel is that, you know, because everybody else

1:24:06is using them too, they're never going to be behind.

1:24:09Unless they want to be behind like they are with the Mac Pro.

1:24:12Like that's my choice.

1:24:13And now Apple has arm to hold over Intel, so even that is something that they've kind

1:24:16of insured themselves from.

1:24:18Right.

1:24:19You know, but, you know, the Google Maps thing on the phone, like, web search is honestly,

1:24:25Apple is finding, web search is not as important on smartphones as it is on computers for the

1:24:30most part. And so I think Apple is willing to let Google have that. Plus they could always

1:24:34just make a deal with Bing or they could buy DuckDuckGo and do their own thing on starting

1:24:39out small, just kind of what they're doing with Maps. Stuff like that. They have options

1:24:42in search and it isn't that important to them. And that just goes to the browser anyway.

1:24:48So Google can change their website to do whatever they want. Whereas in Maps, it's this native

1:24:54integrated thing that's, in the context of a smartphone, extremely important. And

1:24:59so if they would have just kept going with Google for more years in the future or indefinitely,

1:25:06Google would have always had them by the balls with this Maps thing.

1:25:09Right. And that would have made Apple very vulnerable

1:25:12in that way, and as their relationship with Google is going sour, that would have been

1:25:17really uncomfortable. Kind of in the same way that Samsung is a little uncomfortable

1:25:22with Apple because of their component relationship.

1:25:25Yeah, very true.

1:25:26Which they're also, as you can see, Apple's also trying to diversify a lot of things there.

1:25:29Right.

1:25:30But, you know, this maps transition, I think, any way you look at it, Apple had to take

1:25:36this on their own at some point.

1:25:38This was inevitable.

1:25:39The only choice was timing.

1:25:41Right.

1:25:42And—

1:25:43And as you wrote, the timing, even that, the timing here is actually kind of the obvious

1:25:47choice.

1:25:48Right.

1:25:49to go another year without, if they would have gone

1:25:52another year with Google, they would have had to renew

1:25:54for another year on top of that.

1:25:56- Right, exactly. - Right, they need,

1:25:59the transition has to take place during the year

1:26:01when the deal expires.

1:26:03It can't take place at the end when the deal does expire.

1:26:06- Right, and Google was under, Google had no incentive

1:26:10to keep the terms Apple-friendly over time.

1:26:14- Right, I don't blame-- - If they were gonna

1:26:15keep reopening with Google, they would just keep

1:26:17making the terms more and more Google friendly because they could. They had all the power.

1:26:21Right. Yeah, I don't even, you know, and like this Dan Lyons piece, it's, you know, that,

1:26:28I don't know, I think he says that we said Google's evil or something like that. I'm

1:26:31not, I don't even say Google is evil. Google was acting in its own interest too. Like,

1:26:36both companies were acting in their own interest. I guess the other thing though that lay people

1:26:41kind of vaguely wish is for something that just, you know, it's sort of like a people

1:26:45and hell-wanting ice water situation is what they wish is for the alternate universe where

1:26:51Google didn't decide to become Apple's arch rival for the future of mobile computing.

1:26:58Right, like iPhone 1.0 and then they were best friends.

1:27:01Right, that the Eric Schmidt on stage at the iPhone introduction, Kumbaya laughing and

1:27:07singing and talking about what a great future Apple and Google were going to have together,

1:27:10that that would have kept going and that, you know, Apple could have just kept going

1:27:17and let Google handle the mapping backend and just do the app and have vector tiles

1:27:23and turn-by-turn directions from Google in the iOS Maps app and have, you know, none

1:27:30of the privacy or any of the other stuff in there. But that option wasn't on the table.

1:27:36Google wasn't offering that.

1:27:37that would never have happened because Google's not stupid.

1:27:41They would have seen that these integrations with the iPhone,

1:27:44you know, on the computer, the computer's kind of a fluke.

1:27:47On the computer, they have the web browser,

1:27:49and, you know, people can choose to go to Google,

1:27:51and then Google made their own web browser for the same reason.

1:27:53Um, on the smartphone, it's this kind of,

1:27:56this more, quote, "curated environment,"

1:27:58this more controlled environment

1:28:00where things are more customized and less, quote, "open."

1:28:03Uh, I use air quotes a lot when talking about Google,

1:28:06Google because you have to.

1:28:07But with the iPhone, Google could see that Apple had a lot

1:28:14of control on this new platform.

1:28:16And at any point--

1:28:18let's say things were still in iPhone 1.0 relationship days.

1:28:21At any point, Apple could have said, you know what, Google?

1:28:24We're going to switch to Bing Maps now, and

1:28:26you're just screwed.

1:28:27So Google had to make their own platform to be able to

1:28:30control their own destiny.

1:28:31They have to.

1:28:33That's the same reason why Amazon has their tablets now.

1:28:36because they have to do the same thing to control their media sales.

1:28:38I disagree with you there. I do. I think that there was a hypothetical path for Google to

1:28:44take based on trust. And think about how much trust there was circa 2006, 2007 between Apple

1:28:53and Google. Eric Schmidt was on Apple's board. In hindsight, that's…

1:28:56He didn't last forever in business.

1:28:58In hindsight, that's…

1:28:59Because people don't last forever in business.

1:29:01Isn't that mind-boggling, though, in hindsight? Thinking about how long five years is, could

1:29:05Did you imagine now if they put Eric Schmidt back on the Apple board?

1:29:10I mean, you would honestly think that Tim Cook had had a stroke or something.

1:29:13That would be amazing.

1:29:14Or imagine if Tim Cook joined Apple's board, or Google's board, I mean.

1:29:18Right, exactly.

1:29:19Right?

1:29:20How nuts would that be?

1:29:21You would not believe it.

1:29:22You would just automatically assume that whatever website you were reading was doing like an

1:29:26April Fool's thing early.

1:29:27You would never believe it.

1:29:28You couldn't believe it.

1:29:30No, but Google, you know, in that 1.0, in those 1.0 days, Google was totally, they were

1:29:37replaceable on iOS. You know, if anybody else had a good enough map service or a good enough

1:29:43video service or all the other things they were integrated with, anybody else could have

1:29:47been swapped in.

1:29:48Now, you know what? All they would have had to do is make sure that their maps were still

1:29:52the best. And if their maps were still the best, they would have been in good shape.

1:29:57So their destiny would have been in their own hands.

1:29:59Like if they had either A, not even done Android, or B, kept Android as a sort of blackberry

1:30:05killer, low-end, you know, third world, open source sort of.

1:30:12Really?

1:30:13Not attacked iOS head on.

1:30:14Right.

1:30:15Everything, you know, just wipe out all the low end of the market platform.

1:30:21I think the only thing they would have had to do is the same thing they've done with

1:30:24web search.

1:30:25has an Apple replaced Google as a default for web search because Google is still the

1:30:30best by far. It really is.

1:30:32Well, and because that doesn't really impact Apple having Google there.

1:30:35No. No.

1:30:36It doesn't really do it. It doesn't really harm them. They might even be getting paid

1:30:38for it still.

1:30:39Oh, I'm sure they are. I don't know, but I would be flabbergasted if they are not getting

1:30:47paid a nice chunk of change for that because it is extremely valuable.

1:30:50Oh, yeah. I mean, in reality, that might not matter too much to Apple's financials.

1:30:54No.

1:30:55It's probably not, but it's one of those things where there's a lot of little things that

1:30:59don't matter a lot to Apple's financials, but there's so many of them that they kind

1:31:03of, you know, they'd be sort of derelict not to cash the checks.

1:31:09**Ezra Klein:** I still think that it was inevitable that Google was going to make their own platform,

1:31:15because they also don't want anyone else to have them by the balls.

1:31:19And in this case, Apple would have had them by the balls.

1:31:22The whole industry is about balls these days.

1:31:23I suppose you're right though.

1:31:26I do, you know, maybe you're right.

1:31:27I don't know.

1:31:28It's hard to say.

1:31:30But, you know, there's the other argument though

1:31:32that they're like $20 billion in the hole on Android.

1:31:36- That's true, yeah.

1:31:37And Amazon I don't think is doing that well

1:31:39in their efforts either, profitable.

1:31:40- I think I linked that up.

1:31:42Well, but they're breaking even though.

1:31:44They're not in the hole.

1:31:44You know, I feel like Bezos really wanted to emphasize that,

1:31:47that they're not losing money on this stuff,

1:31:49but they're not making money on this stuff.

1:31:51Like that's what makes them,

1:31:52That's what makes Amazon the crazy guy at the poker table.

1:31:54That's kind of their whole business.

1:31:55Right.

1:31:56All their businesses are kind of like that.

1:31:58If all you want to do is break even, but do it in great quantity, you are a crazy ass

1:32:04competitor to compete against if you're trying to make money.

1:32:07Right.

1:32:08It's really crazy.

1:32:09Especially against Apple, which is totally the opposite.

1:32:10I think it was Brian S. Hall.

1:32:12I think I linked to it a couple days ago.

1:32:14Maybe I didn't, though.

1:32:15But anyway, he just a back of the envelope argument about how Google is 20 billion in

1:32:20in the hole on Android. Most of it is from the $12 billion acquisition of Motorola, which

1:32:25still hasn't made them a nickel of profit.

1:32:28Right, and probably won't.

1:32:30Once you've spent $12 billion on Motorola, it's not that hard to figure out that maybe

1:32:34they spent $8 billion on other stuff. Even if $20 billion is a little high, it's probably

1:32:39at least $15 billion. They even admit publicly that the lion's share of their mobile advertising

1:32:46still comes from iOS.

1:32:49interesting from web traffic I guess not from local anymore

1:32:54well whenever they said it might have been I don't know if they were ever

1:32:57making much on the map stuff I get sponsored I used to get sponsored

1:33:01results every once in a while but never that much

1:33:03I can't yeah it was only only like in the last six months or so right it was

1:33:06no I got some starting like a year ago

1:33:08okay well still that's five years into the iPhone or four years at the iPhone

1:33:11right

1:33:12hey I would go crazy long but let me do the second sponsor and we have a couple

1:33:16a couple other things I want to ask you about. Our second sponsor is one of my favorite companies,

1:33:21long time sponsor of Daring Fireball, Mac Mini Colo. Mac Mini Colo is exactly what the

1:33:29name says. They host Mac Minis as servers. You think, "Well, that's a crazy little…

1:33:35What do you want a little computer like that as a server?" They're actually deceptively

1:33:40powerful computers and they're really, really small and it actually makes for a great co-hosted

1:33:45server. They've got SSD options. They can have up to 16 gigabytes of RAM nowadays. They

1:33:52really do make for a good server. And Mac Mini Cola has been doing it for a long time.

1:33:59And they're a big part of the Mac community. One of the things they do, they just do this

1:34:03for free. They're the people who host Fireballed.org, the automatic caching site.

1:34:09Oh yeah, I didn't know that.

1:34:11So, any time that I link to somebody, they see it.

1:34:15They immediately cache every single site that I link to from Daring Fireball.

1:34:19And all you have to do is take the URL from Daring Fireball, take off my domain name,

1:34:25replace it with fireballed.org, and you'll get the cached version of whatever it is I

1:34:31just linked to.

1:34:32That's running on a Mac Mini at Mac Mini Cola.

1:34:36So, it's obviously, by definition, fireball proof.

1:34:41They're actually in, this is actually interesting, I didn't know this until they sent me this

1:34:44stuff for the sponsorship, but they're actually hosted in this place, this Switchnap in Las

1:34:53Vegas, and they've got fantastic connections.

1:34:57It's actually an old Enron bandwidth station.

1:35:00You go to switchnap.com and you can find out more.

1:35:05But it's actually like this crazy, crazy high power co-hosting facility, super high bandwidth.

1:35:13Some of the people, they actually have people who, listeners of the show will know who use

1:35:17them and recommend them and have given their permission to say this.

1:35:24Michael Jurowitz from Black Pixel uses Mac Mini Cola.

1:35:27Steven Frank at Panic.

1:35:29Federico Vettucci of Mac Stories, great site too.

1:35:35Will Shipley, never heard of him.

1:35:38He's at a place called Delicious Monster, but I think Delicious Monster site hosted

1:35:43at Mac Mini Cola.

1:35:45You can send them a Mac Mini that you own, just send it to them and they will host it

1:35:50for you.

1:35:51rent one or buy one from them and they'll just set it all up. Great support. You just

1:35:57call them. You have great options. Super, super easy and it's a great service. So if

1:36:03you want to use Mac Mini as a hosted server, Mac Mini Colo, here's the URL to go to. And

1:36:11you go to this URL, it'll help the show because they'll know you're coming from here. So go

1:36:14Go to www.macminicolo.net/the-talk-show.

1:36:23And you know that they love this show.

1:36:24You know they love this show because the URL, it's slash the talk show, not slash talk show.

1:36:30Jared Ranerelle Attention to detail.

1:36:31Marc Thiessen Attention to detail.

1:36:33And they know that I paid good money for that, the macminicolo.net/the-talk-show.

1:36:42So while you're here, Marco, I want to talk about some Marco stuff before I let you go.

1:36:50You've been doing a lot of stuff lately.

1:36:52It seems to me like – well, Instapaper has always got new stuff going on.

1:36:55But it seems like a lot of the stuff you've been doing recently has been accessibility-related.

1:37:01And I won't even go into it because you've covered it so extent.

1:37:03But you're a big proponent of voiceover and developing, and your thing is that you

1:37:10I mean, what's your rule of thumb?

1:37:13You assign triple tap the home button to voiceover on and off.

1:37:17Right, but your rule of thumb is you can tell if somebody's a good iOS developer if you

1:37:20triple tap their iPhone's home button and voiceover doesn't go on.

1:37:24Yeah, somebody else had written that.

1:37:26I quoted it.

1:37:28And I don't know if I'm quite that extreme that I would say they're a bad developer,

1:37:31but I think certainly if that does happen, you can tell they're definitely a good developer.

1:37:34I mean, and we could literally do like a whole two-hour show just on accessibility stuff,

1:37:39really, really important. And I feel like I'm in a weird space, because I do link to

1:37:43our accessibility stuff, and I value it a lot at Daring Fireball. And so I often get

1:37:47good links from people about accessibility-related issues. But I also feel like I do value it,

1:37:53and I think it's so great that iOS has so many great accessibility stuff. I mean, if

1:37:58you don't get choked up when you see those videos of blind people using an iPhone, like,

1:38:04really, I mean, getting tons out of it, using all sorts of different apps.

1:38:08And not just using it, you know, wasting time in their house, but using it to let them do

1:38:13things they couldn't do before. Like Apple's promo video at WWDC had the guy walking through

1:38:17the woods.

1:38:18Exactly.

1:38:19Having the iPhone navigating it.

1:38:20If you don't, if that doesn't choke you up, you're not upright. I mean, I can't even,

1:38:23I don't know what, you know, you don't have a heart.

1:38:25Oh, yeah.

1:38:26And you know, you can, you don't even need help setting these things up. I noticed when

1:38:29I took my new iPhone out of the box yesterday, you triple tap home and it turns voiceover

1:38:33on. So you can just, you can actually, you know, and...

1:38:36And by default it does that?

1:38:37Yeah, in the factory state, in the out of the box factory state, you can just by triple

1:38:47tapping the home button, you get voiceover.

1:38:53So you can configure your brand new right out of the box iPhone without any help from

1:38:57a sighted person.

1:38:58I found that out by – you know how I found that out?

1:39:00I found it out because I wanted to see if the button was good.

1:39:03So I was like doing a button and all of a sudden Siri started talking to me.

1:39:07I was like, "Oh, that's awesome."

1:39:11So just give me the…how does VoiceOver work?

1:39:16I know, but you tell people listening to the show, because I do feel like for a lot of

1:39:20sighted people they kind of, you know, they know iOS is good for this stuff, but they

1:39:24don't really think about it because they don't have to.

1:39:26Sure.

1:39:27I mean, it's a screen reader.

1:39:28And what that means is for somebody who's partially or fully blind, they can use an

1:39:33iPhone or an iPad, and actually OS X has those too, but it works really well on iOS devices.

1:39:39And it just reads to them in the "Siri" voice, which was actually before Siri, but it reads

1:39:45to them in that voice the various interface elements that they're looking at, or that

1:39:51they're not looking at, I guess.

1:39:53And as a developer, iOS does almost all of this automatically.

1:39:57If you use the built-in components, like the labels

1:40:00for text and a button with text on it, or table views

1:40:04that have titles and descriptions on each cell, it

1:40:07will read all these things automatically for you.

1:40:09You don't have to do anything.

1:40:11And so having your app be friendly to voiceover is not

1:40:15that hard.

1:40:15And the reason why I've gotten so loud about it recently--

1:40:20and I've not done this perfectly.

1:40:22In the past, I've shipped lots of voiceover problems.

1:40:24And for the most part, most apps,

1:40:28you know, there aren't a lot of blind people

1:40:29who will download your app

1:40:31and tell you about the voiceover problems

1:40:33because chances are they won't be able

1:40:36to find your support email address in your app for one thing

1:40:39but, you know, there aren't that many of them.

1:40:42There's not like millions and millions

1:40:44of blind people downloading your app.

1:40:46So, you know, the chances that somebody who hits a problem

1:40:49will find it worthy of emailing you

1:40:51and be able to email you

1:40:53and be willing to take all the time and effort to do that is low.

1:40:56So you're probably shipping voiceover problems without knowing it.

1:40:59But the reason why I've gotten so loud about it recently is that it's just so easy to fix.

1:41:04And like,

1:41:05like when I, I'm very fortunate to have a few

1:41:08blind users of Instapaper who will

1:41:10email me every time I screw something up.

1:41:13And then, you know, I can go fix it. And it takes like ten minutes to fix. I mean, that's the thing,

1:41:17like it's so easy.

1:41:18All you have to do is,

1:41:20if you're doing anything custom with the controls,

1:41:22like if you have a button that's just an image

1:41:24and doesn't have any text on it,

1:41:26or if you're like custom rendering a cell or a control,

1:41:29you have to just set a trait on that object in the code

1:41:33to say what should VoiceOver say about this item?

1:41:36And that's it.

1:41:38It's like, it's typing in a string, like refresh button.

1:41:40That's it.

1:41:42It's so easy.

1:41:43And that's so, it's just so embarrassing

1:41:45when I learned that I was doing this badly in some cases

1:41:48that that kind of stuck with me, like,

1:41:50"Oh man, I gotta do better on this,"

1:41:52because it's such a tiny thing for me to do,

1:41:56and it can make such a massive difference

1:41:58to somebody's ability to use this app,

1:42:00that I just feel like it's like a social responsibility

1:42:03for developers, like we should be really making sure

1:42:06we're not screwing this up,

1:42:07because it's so easy to do it right.

1:42:09- The great irony is, and it sort of gets back

1:42:15to the whole how important, you know,

1:42:17It really comes back to the argument Steve Jobs gave on stage about why the iPhone was

1:42:24just a touchscreen, was that it's the flexibility of software, that you don't know what buttons

1:42:30you need, so you don't want to make the buttons hardware because you don't know what buttons,

1:42:34you know, the buttons you want for the phone are different than the ones you want for a

1:42:37web browser.

1:42:38And we don't even know what buttons we're going to want next year for an app, the idea

1:42:41for which we haven't even had yet.

1:42:43But I think, and I do remember, I don't have any URLs, Hanley, but I remember, though,

1:42:49that people were saying that the downside of this design, this is circa 2007, is that

1:42:53this is going to be a disaster usability-wise, or accessibility-wise, because how in the

1:42:57world is a blind person going to use a thing where there's no buttons, right?

1:43:00Like, imagine, like, on a traditional old pre-smartphone cell phone, a blind person,

1:43:05once they knew which buttons were which, could use it by feel, because you just, you know,

1:43:10here's the place a call button and I know that if I go, you know, or if I long press

1:43:15on the one button it's going to call my wife and if I long press on two it's going to call

1:43:19Marco.

1:43:21You could do that without looking at it.

1:43:24But everybody thought with the iPhone because it's just this touch screen that it's not

1:43:28going to be usable by the blind or the low sighted and it maybe even was going to get

1:43:34Apple and legal problems because of certain requirements for accessibility.

1:43:39it ends up, it's actually the most accessible device, I think, ever.

1:43:43Yeah, and they didn't have it on day one, just because I think they didn't have enough

1:43:47RAM to have all the stuff loaded. I believe it came in iOS 3.0 and on the 3GS and above.

1:43:53I think you're right. And it was, and, yeah, because it was before Siri, but it was when

1:44:00you could first start giving voice, I think it coincided with when you could give the

1:44:05voice controls.

1:44:06- Right, yeah, which was the 3GS,

1:44:08because it was the first one that had more RAM,

1:44:10and they needed more RAM to just fit these voices

1:44:13in this code loaded up into RAM all the time.

1:44:15- Right.

1:44:16- But it's just so easy.

1:44:19- Yeah.

1:44:20- And I added these two fonts recently to this paper

1:44:22that one of them is aimed at making it easy

1:44:25for dyslexic people to read,

1:44:26and the other one is aimed at people

1:44:27with learning disabilities, making it easier

1:44:29for them to read.

1:44:30And the dyslexic font was free,

1:44:32and the learning disabilities font was really inexpensive

1:44:34far as font licensing for apps goes. It took almost no effort for me to add those things.

1:44:41Just like VoiceOver. It takes almost no effort to do this, but it makes a huge difference

1:44:45for somebody. It just seems like a no-brainer.

1:44:49It's a great app. I have a good friend here in Philadelphia. He's like my Yankees boyfriend.

1:44:56His name is Matt. He's got some kind of vision thing, but he doesn't see stuff close

1:45:04real well. But he's a voracious reader and he's an enormous Instapaper fan. He's

1:45:11ground zero for the Instapaper target audience because he's a voracious reader. But I almost

1:45:17feel like he's friends with me just to try to get a connection with you because he just

1:45:21loves it because you keep making it better and better. If you didn't, if the fonts

1:45:26were always small and it only had a limited number of fonts, it'd be a lot harder for

1:45:31for him to read. He reads better with Instapaper than he does with anything else on iOS.

1:45:38That's great.

1:45:39I asked him the other day, because he just got the iPhone 5 II, also said that he loves

1:45:45the taller screen because it makes it easier to use bigger fonts to read.

1:45:52Yeah.

1:45:53Do you?

1:45:55And even just like there's more, like you can use voiceover if you turn voiceover on

1:46:00and there's like a whole bunch of things on screen, you can swipe left or right to kind

1:46:04of go next in previous item.

1:46:06Or you can just put your finger on something and move it around the screen.

1:46:10And so a lot of blind people actually use iPads because it's just more area, more surface

1:46:15area.

1:46:17And initially if you don't think about it or if you don't know how this stuff works,

1:46:20you might think that doesn't make any sense.

1:46:21Why would they want a bigger screen?

1:46:23But it's more area, and it makes it easier for a lot of people.

1:46:26It just is interesting to me, and it's one of those things where I do try to be really

1:46:30cognizant of it, but because I don't really have any vision problems to speak of.

1:46:36I would have thought intuitively that something like Instapaper on the iPhone, reading, doing

1:46:42long form reading on a tiny, tiny screen is something that's really sort of by definition

1:46:48only for people with good vision.

1:46:52not true at all. Which I think is so fascinating. To me it's counterintuitive, but it's

1:46:58great.

1:46:59Exactly. And with the iPad, again, I actually back in, I don't know, probably two years

1:47:05ago, I had a guy email me and he said his father had very bad vision, very low vision

1:47:09problems, and he was trying to get people to read on the iPad. And he said Instapaper,

1:47:14he could almost read, but the maximum font size was just a little bit too small. And

1:47:20So I sent him a beta build and I said, "Here, here's a beta build," and it had a little

1:47:24label somewhere telling him the font size in points.

1:47:28And I said, "Increase it," I removed the limit, I said, "Increase it as high as you can.

1:47:33Tell me when he can start reading it."

1:47:35And by working with this guy, I made the font size way bigger, the maximum font size, I

1:47:42made it way bigger.

1:47:44And I made it so big that it can pretty much only fit one or two words per line on an iPad.

1:47:50Hmm possibly even only in landscape depending on how long the words are and

1:47:53But I since not only did I make a huge difference to that guy but

1:47:59I've since heard from so many of the people who said I can finally read because I can finally make the font big enough

1:48:04That's and it's just it's so

1:48:07Amazingly fulfilling to hear those stories that this stupid little change. I made that took me no effort

1:48:13Made a difference in somebody's life. You know there's there's not a it's hard to it's hard to get those those

1:48:19is helping people out in life connections

1:48:23through the internet.

1:48:23You know, you don't really,

1:48:24it's hard to know how you're affecting people.

1:48:26It's hard to know, like even here,

1:48:28we don't know who's listening to this.

1:48:29We don't, you know, we could be helping somebody

1:48:31through a tough time,

1:48:32unknowingly just by talking about iPhones and stuff.

1:48:35You know, and you don't, but you don't hear about that.

1:48:38So the few times that you do hear

1:48:41about something positive happening

1:48:43where you didn't even realize it was having

1:48:44that big of an effect,

1:48:45or where it's really easy for you to do it,

1:48:48It's incredibly fulfilling.

1:48:50- Yeah, you deserve it.

1:48:51It's great.

1:48:52And it's just funny too.

1:48:53It's like you said, it's like by making the font size

1:48:56so crazy big that you would think,

1:48:58well, no one would ever want it this big.

1:49:00- Right, but someone does.

1:49:01- They actually do.

1:49:02That's great.

1:49:03I think I've made it through the whole show.

1:49:06I think, correct me if I'm wrong.

1:49:07Maybe you're too polite.

1:49:09You probably wouldn't have said it.

1:49:10But the over under was on me saying Instagram

1:49:14instead of Instapaper at least three times.

1:49:17- Really?

1:49:18Because every time I talk about either one, I say the other. Like, if I start talking

1:49:22about Instagram, I say Instapaper, and when I start talking about Instapaper, I say Instagram.

1:49:26I didn't hear a single slip of this time.

1:49:29Yeah. As I call it, it's like a hashing collision in my brain. I filed them both under Insta.

1:49:34I know. I'm so mad at them for having that name and being so successful.

1:49:38And now it almost looks like I copied them.

1:49:40I know. Yeah, it does, because they've gotten so big. They, you know, billion dollar.

1:49:44Exactly.

1:49:45They're less than a billion dollar acquisition now because it was all Facebook.

1:49:49Yeah, now it's down to like the 700 million range.

1:49:51Oh no, you know.

1:49:53But I wanted to bring this up to you because Instagram, which is an app I love, well, I

1:49:58don't love maybe getting tough, but I like it a lot and I still use it.

1:50:02But they updated for the iPhone 5 and took away live filters, meaning that you can't

1:50:12the filter live in the camera as you're shooting. And it infuriates me, it really does, because

1:50:23when they shipped version 2.0 like a year ago, they replaced all of their existing filters

1:50:29with a new filters. And a lot of them had the same names, but they did not look the

1:50:33same. They didn't even look close to the same. Some of them looked ridiculously different,

1:50:36even though they had the same name. And the reason why was probably for some kind of technical

1:50:41technical performance reason where like you know if they make the if they make

1:50:44this hardware accelerated they can do it in in real time it was for live filters

1:50:49because in the 1.0 you couldn't filter live you'd shoot first then apply a

1:50:53filter and it took a while it took a bit like you know three seconds of lag right

1:50:58on the iPhone 4 this before the 4s came out right but it would cache it though

1:51:02so if you were like this one or that one this one or that one when you switch

1:51:06between the two if it had already computed at once it you wouldn't have to

1:51:09do it again. But I think the fact that it was a little bit computationally expensive,

1:51:14you know, a second or two then, although it would probably be a lot faster now in the

1:51:18five, they were just so much more aesthetically pleasing. They got rid of them because they

1:51:22said live is better. And now they've gotten rid of live, but they've kept the same crappy

1:51:29filters. So now we have crappy filters and no live. And they said, because it's still

1:51:38If you upgrade to the new version of Instapaper, there I did it.

1:51:42Instagram.

1:51:43One time.

1:51:44Instagram, on an older iPhone, you still have the live filters.

1:51:47They've only taken it off on the 5.

1:51:51But they said going forward, though, for consistency, they're going to do away with live filters.

1:51:56And then I thought about that.

1:51:57And here's what I did.

1:51:58I fired up my Galaxy Nexus and opened Instagram there.

1:52:03And guess what?

1:52:04No live filters.

1:52:06So I think by consistency, they mean consistency with other non-iOS platforms, cough, cough,

1:52:15Android.

1:52:16Because they don't have live filters there, now we can't have nice things.

1:52:19And Android, one of the biggest challenges for Android development for fragmentation

1:52:25is the GPU, and doing any kind of hardware accelerated thing with GPUs, because the GPUs

1:52:29vary so widely on Android.

1:52:31That's why games have a really hard time there, just working everywhere, because there are

1:52:34so many different GPUs.

1:52:36But I don't know.

1:52:37I think--

1:52:38and you're probably not going to agree with me on this--

1:52:41I really think that Instagram would be better

1:52:43without the filters.

1:52:45And I think the reason why-- so a brief story, back when

1:52:48Tumblr first launched, I had this brilliant idea, which is

1:52:53the worst idea I've ever had.

1:52:55Hey, why don't we have a feature that imports RSS feeds

1:52:59onto your blog, so that every time somebody posts a link in

1:53:02in an RSS feed, you automatically blog it on your Tumblr blog.

1:53:07And this was back in 2006 or 2007.

1:53:12So this was during the time when all these cross pushing tools were also coming out.

1:53:15So by having this feature, even though this was this little side feature of Tumblr that

1:53:20was barely even visible in the interface to enable, by having this feature at all, though,

1:53:27everyone started thinking Tumblr was an aggregation service for all your different social networks.

1:53:31And isn't that what FriendFeed was supposed to be?

1:53:34I think it was.

1:53:35Regardless.

1:53:36It never was quite clear.

1:53:37They never really had a clear, "Here's what you're supposed to use FriendFeed for."

1:53:40But I think that's, if they had, that would have been it.

1:53:43There were these aggregation services out there, these other ones.

1:53:45So everyone thought Tumblr was that, that this aggregation service that would just,

1:53:49you'd be able to combine all your other activity from other services onto this one

1:53:53page.

1:53:54And that's really not what we set out to build.

1:53:56And in fact, as an aggregation service, it was a pretty bad one.

1:54:00But just simply by having that feature, everyone classified it as that in their heads.

1:54:04And that's how the press wrote about it, that's how people used it, because that's how they

1:54:07saw other people using it.

1:54:09And it was actually pretty problematic for a while.

1:54:12I think with Instagram, the filters are that problem.

1:54:15Whereas people, especially when Instagram was new and not as many people used it, but

1:54:20a lot of people were hearing about it or seeing people posting these photos on Twitter and

1:54:24stuff, I think everyone thought Instagram was all about the filters.

1:54:28And it's really not.

1:54:29Instagram is about the social network of sharing these photos with people.

1:54:33That's what Instagram is about.

1:54:35And that's why Facebook wanted it so badly.

1:54:38That's why Flickr should be embarrassed that they didn't do it, and possibly to some degree

1:54:42Tumblr also.

1:54:44It really is the social network for sharing photos.

1:54:46It's Twitter for photos, basically.

1:54:49And the filters are really this distraction.

1:54:53And they are useful occasionally, but I think, like, I've tried to not use filters for, like,

1:54:58the last year or so and I really haven't missed them. I think I used one once or twice

1:55:02to just amp up the brightness for a badly exposed photo but that was about it. I think

1:55:10the filters are a fad actually. They really scream 2011 to me. I think that fad is maybe

1:55:20going to end in like a year or two. I think if Instagram downplayed the filters, and maybe

1:55:27Maybe that's what they're doing.

1:55:28I don't know.

1:55:29But if they downplay the filters a little bit, I think maybe then people will start

1:55:33seeing this isn't just about making pictures look old.

1:55:36It's about sharing pictures.

1:55:39I agree to some extent.

1:55:42And I'm a little conscious of the fact that while that's been filtered, filters, and

1:55:52the ones that really make it look old per se are going to date poorly 10, 15 years from

1:55:59now.

1:56:00I think three years from now.

1:56:01Yeah, but really going to stand out.

1:56:04It's like bell-bottom jeans and stuff like that in disco.

1:56:08It's going to stand out.

1:56:09But I think though that the filters I like best and I think the ones that I use going

1:56:14forward the most aren't about making it look like a crumpled up old Polaroid, but just

1:56:20changing the color temperature and you know the way that you modify you know

1:56:27more like what you do when you dig around with the exposure settings in

1:56:31Lightroom or aperture or even iPhoto about making something look warmer or

1:56:35making it look cooler you know or just black and white like black and white to

1:56:40me is not a gimmick get black and white is like a serious way of doing

1:56:46photography to really change a photo in an evocative way. Like I don't think there's

1:56:50anything gimmicky about black and white, like in having good black and white filters. So I would

1:56:55separate it there. I do think it's useful and I think that it makes a lot of their photos look

1:56:59better. But again, though, I think that their new ones, the current batch of Instagram,

1:57:06I swear to God, it's hard. Instagram filters are worse in that way, though, where like,

1:57:14almost half of them are just like preposterously gimmicky,

1:57:18and they're not really about making it look good,

1:57:20but making it look hipstery.

1:57:22I think there's-- - Yeah, I mean, I agree

1:57:24with you that there is definitely,

1:57:26there is value and there is a place

1:57:29and a good reason to use filters

1:57:32that do common post-processing type operations,

1:57:35things like what you said,

1:57:36like adjusting the color temperature

1:57:37or adjusting the exposure curve a little bit.

1:57:40There is certainly a place for that.

1:57:42It just seems like so many of Instagram's filters so far have been not to make a photo

1:57:48look better, but to make it look filtered.

1:57:51Like to make it really obvious that this has had this filter applied.

1:57:54See, I think they should, I think the way they should look at it going forward is less

1:57:58as like a hipstamatic type thing and making it look kitschy and more like a one-touch

1:58:07Lightroom type thing.

1:58:08Yeah.

1:58:09I keep meaning to tell people about this.

1:58:12And I should disclose, of course, Adobe Revell has been a sponsor of my site a lot, and they're

1:58:18sponsoring even more of it soon.

1:58:21What they did, they explained this to me, and I verified that this is actually the case.

1:58:26Adobe Revell is this whole photo sharing app from Adobe.

1:58:32But what they did was they basically took the Lightroom processing engine and rewrote

1:58:38it so it runs well on a phone. And so, it's the engine from Lightroom 4, I think it's

1:58:45based on that, or the code base at least is based on that same code base from Lightroom

1:58:494. And so, I've been using Revell not just to view my photos, which is what it's made

1:58:55for, but I've been using it as an editing program on iOS. And in particular, what it's

1:59:01really, really good at is changing the exposure. Because they, and people who play with Lightroom

1:59:08know about this, or I think Photoshop CS6, I think it's in that camera raw version.

1:59:13Adobe rewrote the exposure adjustments in these versions so that you can adjust the

1:59:18exposure up or down and it doesn't blow out the highlights or blacken the shadows as much

1:59:24as you go up and down.

1:59:26They've always been good at that, and I do think that the one in four is radically better,

1:59:32But even Lightroom 1 had amazing exposure controls.

1:59:35And oh, the Ricoh.

1:59:39This is bringing the show full circle.

1:59:41So my Ricoh didn't shoot raw.

1:59:44Or if it did, it was like a five-second write time.

1:59:47It either didn't shoot it or it took like five to ten seconds to write, so I never ever

1:59:52used it.

1:59:53So I shot everything JPEG.

1:59:56And then I got my 5D a couple years later, and I was already in the Lightroom.

2:00:01I was so excited to start shooting RAW, and because everybody said the exposure, the things

2:00:06you can do exposure-wise with a RAW photo versus JPEG, it's just night and day.

2:00:12It actually didn't even seem that different to me because the Lightroom was so good at

2:00:16adjusting exposure from 1.0, so good at adjusting exposures on JPEGs, not even RAW images, which

2:00:23is what you're getting on the phone.

2:00:25So I believe it.

2:00:26I do believe it.

2:00:27I think that is Adobe at its absolute best.

2:00:31- Oh yeah, I really do think,

2:00:33and I don't think they would do this

2:00:34'cause it's not really what they want out of Revel

2:00:36or out of most of their businesses,

2:00:38but I wish Adobe would just take that editing engine

2:00:41and just make a dedicated editing app just for that

2:00:43because with Revel, there's a few extra steps

2:00:45'cause it's not really made for that.

2:00:46You have to import it and then export it back out.

2:00:48There's a few extra steps to use it just as an editor.

2:00:51But if they just made a dedicated photo editing app,

2:00:54photo processing app for iOS with that engine, it would be killer.

2:00:58They have Lightroom, or not Lightroom, Photoshop, Express or PS or Photoshop something, but

2:01:03I didn't, I did not like that app. There is a Photoshop, something called Photoshop

2:01:08for iOS. Oh yeah, I think I missed that. I think it's called Photoshop, but it's

2:01:12Adobe something, but I think it's called Photoshop, but it's not, it's not good.

2:01:16It's not bad, but it's not good. But this sounds good.

2:01:19I mean, the editing controls in Revel are awesome. They really, and like they kind of

2:01:23You have to like, there's like, it only shows three at first,

2:01:26like exposure, color, and so on,

2:01:27and then like you tap one and it expands it

2:01:30into these three more manual controls.

2:01:31So like you gotta play with it a little bit,

2:01:33but really like if they brought that into its own app

2:01:36and just made it for photo editing, it would be amazing.

2:01:39I would put everything through that

2:01:40before posting it to Instagram.

2:01:41- Hmm, well, there we go.

2:01:43But do you agree with me that they're just,

2:01:45they're pandering now to the Instagram,

2:01:47they're pandering to the lowest common denominator?

2:01:50- It does seem that way, yeah.

2:01:51I don't know why not just let iPhone users have better filters?

2:01:54I mean, they have better phone, why not just let them have better filters?

2:01:58Why make everybody have the same set of filters? Who cares?

2:02:01I mean, like you said, the most important thing is the sharing network,

2:02:04which is why it's useful that Android phones can participate.

2:02:08Like, if your friend has an Android phone, why shouldn't they be allowed to post to Instagram?

2:02:13Or, again, maybe it is Instagram's people recognizing that a lot of these filters are going to be temporary fads,

2:02:20ads, and trying to minimize the appearance of filters being so necessary or such a main

2:02:28focus of the app.

2:02:30I don't know.

2:02:32I just feel like you're always in trouble if you're… you really ought to second-guess

2:02:37yourself if you're holding back in any way.

2:02:40If you're saying, "We're not giving it our best on this."

2:02:46Yeah, I agree with you on that.

2:02:48I just think with Instagram it might not matter soon.

2:02:50you know, if they do indeed start downplaying the filters,

2:02:52which I don't know that they will,

2:02:54but if they do, then all this will be fairly moot.

2:02:57- Yeah, I mean, you're probably a poor example of this

2:03:00with Instapaper, but,

2:03:04'cause you obviously would not hold back

2:03:06on adding cool features to the iOS version of Instapaper

2:03:10if they couldn't be added to the fairly,

2:03:13still fairly new Android version,

2:03:16because your Android version of Instapaper

2:03:18is sort of an experiment, it's not--

2:03:20Oh, yeah.

2:03:20In fact, when we-- so I don't even develop the Android

2:03:23version.

2:03:23MobileLux does.

2:03:24They're a great contractor.

2:03:25And the arrangement I had set up with them was I don't want

2:03:33this to have feature parity.

2:03:34Not because I don't want Android to be as good, but

2:03:37because I don't want to have to be restricted in what I do in

2:03:39the future.

2:03:40I want to be able to just add a feature to the iOS app or

2:03:42change it as I see fit and not have everybody expect that it

2:03:46simultaneously changed and applied to the Android app.

2:03:49And so it still doesn't have some of the features

2:03:53of the iOS app.

2:03:54And part of that was just, let's see what we can get done

2:03:57for 1.0, given limited time and money.

2:03:59But I've always maintained that I

2:04:02want this to be two separate things.

2:04:04Because it is two separate things.

2:04:05These are two very different platforms

2:04:06with very different use types, very different hardware,

2:04:10very different software, and very different users, honestly.

2:04:14And so it's important that you leave yourself the freedom with both your expectations, your

2:04:21customers' expectations, and your development philosophy. You leave yourself the freedom

2:04:25to do things on a platform even if your other platforms can't do it. It's the same thing

2:04:28with web browsers. There's no reason you can't enhance things for modern web kits because

2:04:34you want things to look the same on IE5.

2:04:36Right. Why hold back?

2:04:38Right.

2:04:39I feel you're always doing a disservice if you're holding back. And it's always the

2:04:43with cross-platform software. I think Adobe's made mistakes in this regard over the years,

2:04:49where the Mac software isn't as Mac-like as it should be, or doesn't support features because

2:04:55it can't do it in the Windows version. And if I knew the Windows version, I'll bet diehard

2:05:01Windows users who know everything about the system probably have the same complaints about

2:05:04the Windows versions. Microsoft Office, I think, is probably a good example of a company that's

2:05:11done it right where Office for Mac was never meant to be feature compatible with Office

2:05:18for Windows or, you know, design compatible. It's not supposed to look exactly the same

2:05:23except that the window controls are different, you know.

2:05:26Exactly. And I think, and actually you can point to Apple as an example of doing this

2:05:29badly with iTunes for Windows.

2:05:31Yeah. You know what? That's a great example. Right. Because Windows users hate it.

2:05:35Yeah. I mean, when I was, I was a Windows user until 2004. And one of the apps I hated

2:05:41by far the most was QuickTime for Windows.

2:05:44So I would occasionally download some file

2:05:46that needed to be viewed in QuickTime,

2:05:47and I would hate installing this thing,

2:05:48'cause it would, you know,

2:05:49it would crapple over my system tray

2:05:51and the window was all non-standard,

2:05:53and you know, it just looked like the typical

2:05:55metal Apple Windows at the time,

2:05:57but to a Windows user, this was this weird foreign thing

2:06:00that I really didn't like.

2:06:01And you know, 'cause Apple's position has always been,

2:06:04well, what we do is the best,

2:06:06and we're just gonna copy what we do on OS X

2:06:10for our Windows ports. And to quite a deep level, they've like, with Safari, they've

2:06:16ported the entire font rendering engine over to Windows.

2:06:19So Safari was what I was going to bring up, and that's probably even the best example,

2:06:22because the heart and soul of it is WebKit, and that WebKit is just the best web rendering

2:06:30engine. I just don't see how anybody could deny that. It's best technically, it's

2:06:35the best aesthetically.

2:06:36Now you're going to hear from both the Opera users about that, though.

2:06:39Well, maybe not best for everyone, but it's the best general purpose one.

2:06:45And then they brought it to Windows and it went nowhere, just sunk like a brick.

2:06:50And Google Chrome, I think is now, is Google Chrome now the most popular browser on Windows?

2:06:54I think it is.

2:06:55It certainly is among people who aren't using 1999 compact boxes running XP.

2:07:05people who are using even vaguely modern Windows computers, Chrome is the most popular, which

2:07:10is insane given the situation with IE having 91% market share 10 years ago.

2:07:18And what's Chrome?

2:07:19It's at least Chrome on Windows.

2:07:22I mean, I don't use Windows, so I can't say it, but everybody who seems to like it, it

2:07:27feels like a Windows app with WebKit rather than trying to shoehorn a Mac app on Windows.

2:07:35on Windows users. Just doesn't go over well.

2:07:38- And that's one of the reasons I don't like,

2:07:39I don't really care that much for Chrome on OS 10,

2:07:41because it still feels like a bit of a Windows app.

2:07:44Not as bad as when Apple puts their stuff on Windows,

2:07:46but yeah, still not great.

2:07:49That's a whole other show.

2:07:50- That's a whole other show.

2:07:51So are you a Safari user?

2:07:53- I am. And you know, this is also a whole other show.

2:07:56I really have a love-hate relationship with Safari,

2:07:59because it seems like every major version of Safari is,

2:08:03you know, one step forward, two steps back.

2:08:05And Safari is so buggy in Mountain Lion now.

2:08:09It is so ridiculously buggy.

2:08:11It was buggy in Lion.

2:08:12It was buggy in Snow Leopard.

2:08:13And now it's just different bugs.

2:08:17But I'm very disappointed in general in our industry for

2:08:21how few options we have for email clients and web

2:08:24browsers, the two most important apps for so many

2:08:28people, or at least the most frequently used apps for so

2:08:31many people.

2:08:32And our options for both are okay, but not great.

2:08:37As a long-time Mac user, though, see, this is the difference as, like, someone who's always used a Mac.

2:08:44I still feel like we have so many choices for web browser because, like, in the late '90s, we had zero choices.

2:08:51Right. That's true.

2:08:52I mean, it really was. It was like--I think it was the single--

2:08:55I think it was the single reason--single biggest reason why there had such market share problems at the time

2:09:01browsing was such a problem.

2:09:03Oh sure.

2:09:04But even Windows users didn't have that many options.

2:09:07We had two or three.

2:09:09So it wasn't that different.

2:09:11Still better than zero.

2:09:12That's true.

2:09:13Yeah.

2:09:14But every browser has its own problems and I use Safari because it fits me the best,

2:09:20but it drives me crazy.

2:09:21Almost every day it drives me crazy for some stupid reason.

2:09:24I have to either restart it because it's starting to bug out or it has some kind of

2:09:28of weird bug that, you know, okay, I've got to restart it anyway, or it stops rendering

2:09:34the bottom half of the page and it's all white. That's a new bug with Mountain Lion.

2:09:39It's just so, there's so many weird little problems. And I wish that Safari adopted more

2:09:45of the Chrome process model, where everything's so isolated and everything.

2:09:50I forget who I talked, I think I talked about this on the show a few episodes ago. But yeah,

2:09:54I do kind of feel like they lost they bet wrong on that with them

2:09:58Yeah with the one one separate rendering process versus one for every open tab

2:10:04Right and the reason they use the separate rendering process in lion was for this whole sandboxing XPC thing

2:10:10They were moving towards like the the architecture of separating out the parts of your program so that if there's a security hole

2:10:17That exploits JavaScript then it can't access anything else for example

2:10:20because it's only the web rendering.

2:10:22And moving to that introduced tons of bugs

2:10:24and tons of performance problems.

2:10:26And so they fixed some of those now,

2:10:28but now they have other bugs

2:10:29and other performance problems.

2:10:30It's just like every year when they make Safari,

2:10:34you know, the new major version of Safari for that year,

2:10:37they just shift the bugs around.

2:10:39And so I know that I'll be annoyed in different ways

2:10:41the week later.

2:10:42- But mobile Safari I think is great

2:10:45and has only gotten better.

2:10:46- Yeah, you're right, mobile Safari is awesome.

2:10:47I feel like maybe there's a back to the Mac moment coming from Safari, where maybe,

2:10:53you know, some of the, I don't know, I don't know if it's the people or the code or whatever,

2:10:57but like at least the philosophy of mobile Safari would be great on Mac OS X.

2:11:02See, I don't see it happening because I feel like, I feel like the Mac OS X Safari team

2:11:10seems to have a tolerance for bugs.

2:11:12Yeah.

2:11:13It just seems like they are okay shipping a very buggy version of Safari.

2:11:18And that's scary to me.

2:11:20That does not sit well with me.

2:11:21But they've just shown over the last two or three years or so that they're okay with these

2:11:27imperfections.

2:11:28Well, and the other thing too, and I know I've mentioned this before, but I think it's

2:11:31worth reemphasizing, is in the old days, back when they used to blog a lot more, I don't

2:11:36think they do that anymore.

2:11:37Like the WebKit blog or the Surf and Safari blog, like Dave Hyatt's thing has kind of

2:11:41on quiet. But I know that Hyatt at least had even said that they had a rule that you can't

2:11:48check in anything that causes a regression in the benchmarks.

2:11:53Oh yeah, yeah. It made everything faster for a long time.

2:11:57So if you wanted to check something in that was going to have a regression, you had to

2:12:01find something, you had to fix something elsewhere so that the overall check-in you were about

2:12:05to make came in under, so that Safari only ever got faster. And the idea was that this

2:12:10was in contrast to was the idea that you add features in one mode. You're adding new features,

2:12:16and then we'll fix the performance stuff at the end. Because they said that that doesn't

2:12:21work because at the end you end up just having to ship and you're like, "Oh, crap. Now it's

2:12:25slower." So that every step of the way, every day as you're checking in stuff, you cannot

2:12:29make it slower. Well, at some point they obviously got rid of that rule.

2:12:33I'm pretty sure that point was when they switched over to the separate process model for the

2:12:37I think that's very clear. That's when they gave that up, because they had to.

2:12:41And I really do think that internally, I suspect, that there was

2:12:45like a, they did exactly what they said long ago, you know,

2:12:49the reason they didn't do it. They said, "Well, we'll switch to this renderer, and then we'll make it fast later."

2:12:53Exactly.

2:12:57This show has gone on ridiculously long. Marco Arment, you're very kind with your time,

2:13:01and it was great to have you here. Thanks, my pleasure to be here.

2:13:05So good luck with your app Instagram and shooting your photos with Instapaper without any filter.

2:13:19You should add filters to Instapaper by the way.

2:13:21Make it look like an old crinkled up newspaper.

2:13:24That would be great.

2:13:27Filters.

2:13:28It would be an in-app purchase.

2:13:30Right.

2:13:31like a USA Today filter, put a big blue circle in the corner of everything.

2:13:35But anyway, thank you. This is a good show.

2:13:38See you later.

2:13:39All right.

2:13:40[End of Audio]

2:13:40[BLANK_AUDIO]