Podcast Search

The Talk Show

14: You’re Not Gonna Name Him Fuzzbutt, with Craig Hockenberry

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00I've got two things that I'm obsessed with this week.

0:00:02I'm obsessed with Twitter and what they're doing with their API, and I remain obsessed

0:00:08with the Retina MacBook Pro and what it means for software.

0:00:13Dave Asprey And I've coincidentally been working on both

0:00:15of those things.

0:00:16Dave You're a perfect guest, Craig Hockenberry,

0:00:19for this week's show.

0:00:20You've got Twitterrific, the Twitter client for every single platform that comes from

0:00:26Apple and you're working on an upgrade to Xscope which is how would you

0:00:34how would you pitch Xscope in a nut? It's a tool for developers and designers to

0:00:41make sure everything that they see on screen is what they expect. It lets you

0:00:45test and sample. I use the loop. The loop is what I use all the time and I know

0:00:52there's other tools there's rulers you can snap things to guide you can make

0:00:55things exactly, you know, but the loop is what I, and that's like a magnifying glass.

0:00:59Yeah, the loop is probably one of my most used tools as well because, you know, the

0:01:05designer or something gives you a Photoshop composition or something like that and, you

0:01:09know, you got to make sure that this button is really, you know, five pixels over from

0:01:13this line and that kind of thing.

0:01:16What do you want to talk about first?

0:01:20best to talk about Twitter. That's the thing that most people are concerned about these

0:01:27days.

0:01:28And you've had a lot to say. And I know, like, I thought it was notable because he called

0:01:32it out. Our friend Lex Friedman over at Macworld had an article where he kind of went around

0:01:39and talked to several Twitter client developers. But the thing that he called out, in particular,

0:01:45upfront and I thought was notable was that he said a number of Twitter client developers

0:01:50simply did not want to speak on the record because they feel relations are so frayed

0:01:56between client developers and Twitter itself that they just don't even want to – they

0:02:00just don't even want their name on the thing. Now you did speak though, right? Is that right?

0:02:04Tim: Yeah. I was very carefully chosen words. The problem for me and for the company is

0:02:14that we've had a good relationship with Twitter over the years. It's been a symbiotic relationship.

0:02:21We've helped them in the very early days, things like coming up with the bird logo,

0:02:28coming up with the name tweet. We have substantially contributed to their ecosystem. They've

0:02:36given us a platform to make a product which we make money off of.

0:02:40I would go further than that too though and I mean this sincerely not just because you're

0:02:45here and I'm blowing smoke up your butt but that I really do feel though that with the

0:02:48initial Twitterrific for iPhone you really well actually I think it probably goes back

0:02:56to the one for the Mac actually because that was the first version of Twitterrific was

0:03:00the Mac only client and I think that you really really simplified and focused on what a minimal

0:03:10incoming stream of information from Twitter could be presented as.

0:03:15Right, right.

0:03:16Which I think was very different than what you were getting at the time from twitter.com on the web.

0:03:21And like you said, I definitely think that, certainly for you, but I would say you guys are emblematic of the client developer community as a whole, that it's been a symbiotic relationship.

0:03:34Yeah, yeah. And the API guidelines that they announced, what was it, last week, everybody's

0:03:46going to be fine in the short term. Tweetbot, I've talked to Paul Haddad, and Tweetbot's

0:03:52going to, they're fine, we're fine, in the short term. In fact, this is the thing that

0:03:58I pointed out the last time. Nobody needs to worry about their favorite third-party

0:04:03Twitter client for now. Keyword there is "for now." They've built a fence around us.

0:04:12We can't grow beyond a certain amount. Luckily, that amount is fairly large right now. I think

0:04:21that they thought very long and hard about how that fence should be constructed. But

0:04:29regardless, there is a fence there now.

0:04:31It's a very weird restriction. And the more I think about it, the more weird I find that,

0:04:38because I can't think of any other platform where the platform owner—and again, I don't

0:04:45want to be accused of hypocrisy for saying that Twitter shouldn't wield any control

0:04:49over their thing, yet I accept that Apple wields significant control over the App Store.

0:04:55And I don't think I'm being hypocritical about this, because I at least understand

0:04:59Apple's motivations for the control that they wield. I don't understand what Twitter's

0:05:03trying to do here. And with the limit, I guess on one, I guess the idea with the limit is

0:05:08if they put a limit on it, no single client could ever grow so large that it would rival

0:05:14Twitter itself.

0:05:15Yeah, that, that to me is, it's, it's, the restrictions are based upon fear. They fear

0:05:25something becoming—you know, right now, the third-party clients are a small percentage

0:05:29of Twitter.

0:05:33The average person goes and gets the Twitter-branded client.

0:05:39They're happy with it.

0:05:40Everything's great.

0:05:41Or they use the website.

0:05:43Again, that's fine as far as Twitter's concerned.

0:05:46It's only the power users and the people who have been using Twitter a long time that

0:05:53really even know that the third-party clients exist and why they want them.

0:05:58But it's pretty clear to me that the promoted tweets are going to be a part of this

0:06:081.1 API. They're going to be ads that start showing up in the timelines.

0:06:18I'm pretty sure Twitter's fear is that that small percentage now could turn into a pretty

0:06:25huge percentage if people start getting aggressive with the promoted tweets and people start

0:06:31getting pissed off.

0:06:32They're going to be, "I don't want this crap.

0:06:34I'm going to go get a tweet bot or a Twitterrific."

0:06:40My thought on that is that—and this to me would be a perfectly reasonable restriction.

0:06:44To me, it would be if they said, "Look, we're going to have these promoted tweets," and

0:06:48you have to show them.

0:06:50Even if your Twitter client has a filter feature where you can put keywords in that filter

0:06:54out tweets or you can – I know some clients have a blackout button where you can say,

0:07:01"Oh, God, group is going on about a Yankees game.

0:07:03Black them out for 12 hours," and then it doesn't show tweets from me for 12 hours.

0:07:07Then all of a sudden, you wake up in the morning and my tweets are back.

0:07:10You don't have to remember to turn it off.

0:07:11Cool features like that.

0:07:12Very useful.

0:07:13However, but I would just say that the rule would be if it's a promoted tweet, if the

0:07:18tweet comes in with this promoted tweet metadata, you have to show it regardless of, you know,

0:07:23filters or features or stuff like that.

0:07:25And to me, I know some people would still complain about that because you cannot please

0:07:29– there's some people who really want to block ads, hell or high water.

0:07:33But to me, it would be – but to me, that would be perfectly reasonable.

0:07:36Eric Lander Yeah, well, the problem then is how far do

0:07:39you go with those, you must do this.

0:07:41I mean, what happens if cards come out?

0:07:43Right.

0:07:44Right.

0:07:45And the cards are there.

0:07:46That's a good problem.

0:07:47Are there things with the partners, right?

0:07:48And the partners, you know, some companies, you know, paid to have a card on Twitter, right?

0:07:54They want you to see it.

0:07:56Right.

0:07:57And I read that.

0:07:58And then it's like, then it's like, "Oh, crap.

0:07:59You know, I don't want to add cards.

0:08:00You know, I don't really care about that."

0:08:02Right.

0:08:03Well, and that really gets to the heart of my fear about the future of Twitter because

0:08:07I, one of the things I love about Twitter is because it's succinct and it forces everybody

0:08:12to be succinct. To put it another way, it always feels like at least a bit of a chore

0:08:17to read my email and it never feels like a chore to go through my Twitter.

0:08:21**Matt Stauffer:** Yeah.

0:08:21**Ezra Klein:** And the busier I am or the longer it's been since I've checked, maybe the faster

0:08:25I scroll and the more I'm skimming, but I'm at least looking at everything. And because

0:08:29everything's there, that's what I worry about cards ruining because a card in there, all of

0:08:34a sudden, like one tweet is the height of the screen. Like on the phone, at least.

0:08:39Yeah, I don't know what the user interaction is going to be there.

0:08:47It's weird because it's taking that small, efficient piece of communication and blowing

0:08:58it up, right?

0:09:00And blowing it up has many different connotations, right?

0:09:03Making it bigger, making it…

0:09:05Well, and it's making a very, very, a very decided opinion about what the tweet should

0:09:14look like.

0:09:16Whereas I think that part of the reason Twitter has been such an innovative playground for

0:09:21user interfaces is that there, it's really just been, look, it's 140 characters of text

0:09:28and a name.

0:09:29Yeah.

0:09:30And, and, and if you want, if you want the names avatar, you know, and

0:09:35Do what you want with it.

0:09:37So like for example, I mean all the mobile clients I'm aware of when they are aware

0:09:42of the URL for like a twit pic or any of these picture hosting services, in the mobile, they

0:09:49don't show the whole image by default because it would be too big.

0:09:53I mean the screen is so small.

0:09:54So they show a thumbnail and if you want to see it, you tap it and then it's another

0:09:58view.

0:10:00Like I just think on a mobile, boy, that's how cards should work is it should be something

0:10:04It shouldn't be something that you put in the main timeline, but I think that's what

0:10:08they want.

0:10:09I'm not even sure.

0:10:10Maybe by the letter of the law, that's what they're already demanding.

0:10:12Dave Asprey Well, that's the big question right now,

0:10:15is that they have the guidelines.

0:10:19They've published guidelines, and they say that those are going to be requirements.

0:10:23Well, there's obviously going to be some editing there.

0:10:28They've been pretty open saying, "Well, okay, some of the stuff is we're still trying

0:10:33to figure it out, or yeah, it wasn't worded quite right, or maybe this wording is oriented

0:10:39towards people who are doing tweets in line on a website versus people that are doing

0:10:44tweets in a native app.

0:10:48There's obviously going to be a lot of work there on their end to turn those guidelines

0:10:54into requirements.

0:10:56And I think that a lot of those requirements are going to be about what they feel is important

0:11:02in the timeline, regardless of what third-party clients think is important to be in the timeline.

0:11:09Right. With the user limit, and I think I mentioned this last week with Michael Lobb,

0:11:15but I just keep thinking about it, is that it's such a weird constraint to put on developers.

0:11:21And like I said, I can't think of anybody else who's done it. And even Apple, who I

0:11:25think most people would hold up, is the company that's most willing to stress its relationship

0:11:32with developers in the name of maintaining its own control over its platform doesn't

0:11:37place limits on how successful you can be.

0:11:43And that includes – and you say, well, that's because they're taking 30 percent.

0:11:48But that also includes free apps.

0:11:50And here's to me a perfect example of that is the Amazon Kindle app, which is free download.

0:11:56So Apple doesn't make any money.

0:11:57If anything, Apple loses money because they're paying the bandwidth for the downloads of

0:12:02the Kindle app. And the more people who download that to iPhones and iPads, the stronger the

0:12:09Kindle rival to Apple's own iBooks platform gets, yet there's no limit. It's not like,

0:12:17well, you can have 500,000 downloads and then you've got to come to us and we're going to

0:12:22have to talk. If every single iPhone user downloads the Kindle app, that's okay.

0:12:28That's, I think that's one of the things that makes me saddest about this new fence

0:12:35that we're dealing with is that it, there's never going to be another great third party

0:12:41Twitter app, right?

0:12:44Twitterific, Tweetie, Tweetbot, that's it.

0:12:47You're done, right?

0:12:49There's, you know, some guy can sit down and say, "Okay, I'm going to write this

0:12:53awesome Twitter app."

0:12:55He's never going to sell more than 100,000 copies of it.

0:12:57That's just the bottom line.

0:13:00That's what Twitter wants.

0:13:01And the economics of the app store and the competitive situation in terms of what you

0:13:05can get away with pricing your app at, it's just not that much money.

0:13:09And somebody out there is going to say, "Well, if you charge four bucks, it's $400,000."

0:13:14But the bottom line is that $400,000 is not a lot of money because as you are well aware

0:13:19and are a prime example of, even if you could get it all in a year, if you could write the

0:13:25and get 100,000 users in a year, which probably isn't going to happen. It's an ongoing relationship

0:13:31as you evolve with Twitter and keep the app going. I mean, you've been working on some version

0:13:35of Twitterific since like 2006?

0:13:39**Matt Stauffer** Seven, I think was the first version. But yeah,

0:13:42it's been a while. So it's long enough not to remember when you started.

0:13:45**Ezra Klein** Right. So the cap, the cap multiplied by the

0:13:49pricing of apps is, you know, even if you think that, hey, 400, $500,000 is a lot of money,

0:13:55It's really not, and especially since it's really, really hard for one guy to do it alone.

0:13:59So you're already fighting.

0:14:00Yeah, it's, you know, for a top shelf iOS app, you're spending $100,000 to $200,000

0:14:07to build an app.

0:14:08I mean, don't forget Apple's 30% cut.

0:14:10Right.

0:14:11I mean, it gets sliced up very quickly.

0:14:14Yeah, that's why I say, there's—and you're absolutely right about it being the UI playground,

0:14:20right?

0:14:21it very exciting to build Twitter clients. In fact, the new version that we're working

0:14:26on now has got some really great innovations in it. Things that people are going to see

0:14:32and go, "Oh, we need to put that in our app," just like pull the refresh. Lauren put that

0:14:39in and it's like, "Oh," started showing up everywhere.

0:14:42Now it's in the OS.

0:14:44Yeah. It behaves a little bit differently in the OS, but the concept and everything

0:14:50is still there. And it's a good idea, right? And that would not have existed without Tweedy.

0:14:59I also think, and again, and this one may not be, I pulled a refresh, I really was,

0:15:05like that, Lauren invented that. But like the first app I can remember that had infinite scroll

0:15:12was Buzz's, it's not the bird house, it's bird feet.

0:15:17- The bird feet, yeah.

0:15:21- Where you got to the bottom and the assumption was,

0:15:24hey, you've scrolled to the bottom,

0:15:25why don't I just show you more tweets,

0:15:27older tweets from the timeline you're in right now.

0:15:30And it was, you know, it was like magic.

0:15:33It was like, I don't have to hit a little button.

0:15:35I just scrolled to the bottom, it bounced,

0:15:37and then, hey, they just faded in, 50 more tweets.

0:15:40That was a great client.

0:15:47For every great Twitter third-party app that succeeded, there have been a lot of other

0:15:52great ones that haven't.

0:15:55It's been a really interesting five, six years of Twitter clients, and a lot has happened

0:16:08over that time.

0:16:10And that's, again, that's what makes me sad, right?

0:16:13That's going to stop happening.

0:16:16So here's a quote that Lex had from an unnamed developer, a developer who did not want to

0:16:22be named.

0:16:23And I do not believe to be you.

0:16:24And I hope it's not you because it's not you.

0:16:25No, no, I was, that was one of the points of saying things, you know, as an attributed

0:16:31quote, right?

0:16:32It's like people aren't going to be guessing, "Oh, that guy's an asshole."

0:16:36I'll say that though, but one thing I've learned over the years is that whenever you read an article that quotes some people

0:16:41But has did not want to be mentioned also

0:16:44Double-check in your mind if it makes sense that one of the people quoted might have said okay that said off the record

0:16:51Because they've already spoken to the reporter

0:16:53So I'm not saying it's common

0:16:55But I'm saying it's more common than you might think that somebody who is quoted by name will also then say okay

0:17:01That's it for the record. Do you want me to say something off?

0:17:04the record.

0:17:05You want some juice, yeah.

0:17:07Right.

0:17:08So I just want to double check.

0:17:10I don't want to put you on the spot here.

0:17:11No, no.

0:17:12That was not me.

0:17:13I don't want to go forward on that.

0:17:14But he pointed out that Twitter left the door open for developers by saying that once they

0:17:17hit the user caps, it's not – they don't say – and this is part of what really annoys

0:17:22me about that message is they don't say – I would almost rather them say, "That's

0:17:25it.

0:17:26You're done.

0:17:27Hit the bricks," or something.

0:17:28Like, it was so vague because it could have been anything.

0:17:30But they more or less said, "Once you hit the user limit, then you've got to come

0:17:33Come talk to us.

0:17:34Whenever somebody's being vague like that,

0:17:36it's their way of saying no.

0:17:38They're afraid to say no.

0:17:40Right.

0:17:41Well, my other thought, though, is maybe--

0:17:43That's my take on it, right?

0:17:44It's like, that's not going to happen.

0:17:46My other thought, though, is that all they want to do

0:17:48is evaluate, are you a threat?

0:17:51Is there a revenue share thing?

0:17:55You know, because-- and again, I don't have a Twitter client,

0:17:58so it's a lot easier for me to say this

0:18:00than you, who have a popular Twitter client,

0:18:02might think about it. But to me, it might make some sense that if you hit your user

0:18:07cap and you talk to Twitter, that they might – if you're selling, let's say, a $4

0:18:13Twitter client, that they might say, "Okay, we want 10% of each sale," henceforth. So

0:18:19you would – your next 100,000 users would cost a couple thousand dollars in fees to

0:18:28Twitter.

0:18:29- John, that's not what Twitter wants.

0:18:31- I know.

0:18:32- They don't want money from us.

0:18:33They want money from advertisers, right?

0:18:35And advertisers don't like hearing,

0:18:38well, okay, there's some people out there

0:18:40that don't see your ad because they've paid money.

0:18:42- Right.

0:18:44- Right, they want to reach every eyeball.

0:18:47They want to force their message upon you.

0:18:50- Right.

0:18:51- And that's what's gonna happen.

0:18:52- Right, because that's, and I guess that's what

0:18:55I keep banging my head up against,

0:18:57is that there's all sorts of ways for Twitter

0:19:00to monetize the whole thing and what they already have

0:19:03in a nice way that's profitable,

0:19:05but that there's very, very few ways

0:19:10that they can monetize this whole thing

0:19:11in a way where they become like

0:19:14a hundred billion dollar valuation

0:19:17standalone mega corporation.

0:19:19- Another Google. - Another Google.

0:19:21- Or Facebook or whatever.

0:19:23- Right, right.

0:19:26I would bet, I don't know this to be a fact, but I would bet that there is a huge internal

0:19:33debate at Twitter between the developers and the business people.

0:19:43The developers see the value in that openness, in that letting the information flow.

0:19:50And yeah, you could make some money off of that flow of information.

0:19:55I mean, that's totally monetizable.

0:19:57They see the benefits and the dangers, I think.

0:19:59I think they see both sides,

0:20:01that once you start closing this stuff off and say,

0:20:04we don't need innovation from the outside

0:20:06and stuff like that, that man, you can really get,

0:20:09that's how you get blindsided by somebody else.

0:20:12Yeah, and the suits, the business people,

0:20:17look, that's the whole advertising

0:20:22is a very predictable thing, right?

0:20:24Business people like predictability.

0:20:28It's a proven thing, right?

0:20:30Look at Facebook has done it, Google's done it.

0:20:33You have a popular channel, you can make money

0:20:37off of the people that watch that channel.

0:20:41So it's that simple.

0:20:44Have I ever told you the story about how tweet came about,

0:20:48the word tweet?

0:20:49- I don't think you did.

0:20:50- Yeah, it's...

0:20:53The first version of Twitterific, which we—I basically built the first version of Twitterific

0:21:00in a day, got it to a working state, enough functionality to show to a designer kind of

0:21:08thing.

0:21:10They loved it.

0:21:11We all immediately started using it internally.

0:21:16I then had a problem on the menus.

0:21:19It's like I needed to come up with a noun

0:21:23for what you were doing with these things.

0:21:25- A noun or a verb?

0:21:27- A noun, right?

0:21:28Because you could select something in that timeline

0:21:32and then what do you do with that selection?

0:21:34That selection needed a name.

0:21:36So I started calling them twits.

0:21:38It was just like just top of the head kind of thing.

0:21:41And it kind of stuck but nobody liked it.

0:21:46Nobody at all.

0:21:47It was just like, "Oh, God, that's kind of demeaning."

0:21:50Well, because in US English, it's synonymous with a dimwit.

0:21:56Right, exactly.

0:21:58And we had a very, again, back to the symbiotic relationship with Twitter.

0:22:05No offense to Leo Laporte.

0:22:08Well, yeah, that was another consideration, right?

0:22:12It's like, "Okay, Leo's already using Twit.

0:22:14I don't want to go there.

0:22:16So back to the symbiotic relationship with Twitter,

0:22:22they were using this beta version of Twitter.

0:22:26They loved it as much as we did.

0:22:28It was pretty obvious having this thing on your desktop

0:22:31was a good thing.

0:22:33And they didn't like Twit either.

0:22:34And they realized that there was a problem there.

0:22:38And one of their API engineers, a guy named Blaine Cook,

0:22:44He said, "David Lanham had done the bird icon."

0:22:48We had the bird, everybody loved the bird, that was great.

0:22:53He says, "You got the bird, why don't you call them tweets?"

0:22:56I was like, "Ahh!"

0:22:59Problem solved.

0:23:01And in fact, the first version, I had to go through all the UI and change everything and

0:23:11basically do a search and replace for Twit to Tweet, and we released it and it's like,

0:23:19"Okay, they're going to be called tweets from now on."

0:23:22In fact, the version 101, there were some tool tips that I had missed that, in fact,

0:23:27in the release notes, it says, "Remove the remaining Twits."

0:23:32And again, that was just, it's the perfect example of how a third party and Twitter can

0:23:40work together to make something meaningful.

0:23:44It's funny that the bird came first and yet tweet didn't jump out at you.

0:23:49Yeah.

0:23:50In retrospect, it's like, "What were we thinking?"

0:23:52I think it's because you were too close to it.

0:23:53I think that once your guys get too close to something like that and the bird, you're

0:23:58already comfortable with the bird.

0:23:59You don't even see it.

0:24:01And we'd seen tweet before we had the bird, right?

0:24:05preceded the bird so it was like we're kind of locked in with twit and it was

0:24:09You know again somebody with a little bit of distance from the project can make a better

0:24:14Decision about it a lot of times than the people that are just right in there, and that's all they see

0:24:18so

0:24:22So what do you think you think?

0:24:24You're thinking near term. We don't need to worry that it's not yeah

0:24:28Yeah, the end the end is not not the but the end might be on there. Yeah tap bots

0:24:35blog post title was perfect, right?

0:24:37Don't panic.

0:24:39There's no reason to panic.

0:24:42But yeah, long term, don't expect there

0:24:45to be Twitter clients.

0:24:47And if you've got one, if you've

0:24:50got a user token for Twitterific or for Tweetbot,

0:24:54you're fine.

0:24:56Don't go and delete it.

0:24:59Don't go into your app settings on the Twitter homepage

0:25:03and delete that because you're losing your place in line.

0:25:09But as long as you've got the authentication token,

0:25:12you can use that product as long as it exists.

0:25:16And it is a different story for apps like Twitterific and

0:25:21Tweetbot that are already successful and presumably

0:25:27over the 100,000 limit, where you get double what you've

0:25:31already got ahead of you before you run into the "you gotta come talk to us" you

0:25:37know close yeah close the door come on in and close the door back to back to

0:25:42the fence right the fence is a long ways away which is a big tap odds and whoever

0:25:46else but the echo phone which is a big big difference from the poor guys out

0:25:50there who just have this idea that's like sketched out on paper yeah that

0:25:56they haven't that they know is an awesome idea but they haven't started

0:25:58And now they're looking at that hard-core, hard-coded permanent limit of 100,000.

0:26:03Yeah, hearing that they were shutting, that they were just going to take the, you know, build that fence.

0:26:14Can you hear my dog barking there?

0:26:16Ah, that's, ah, yes.

0:26:17Okay.

0:26:20We love dogs.

0:26:22Sippy's first post kind of put the fear in our hearts that they were going to shut down

0:26:30the API.

0:26:31I think it was on the table.

0:26:34Yeah, I'm pretty sure it was too.

0:26:40We've been working on this new version of Twitterific for the last six months.

0:26:43We were seriously thinking, "Okay, what are we going to do if they totally shut it down?

0:26:48What's our exit plan here?"

0:26:52So hearing that they're letting the established players stay around, that's great news for

0:26:59us.

0:27:00I'm sure the guys at Tapbots are thinking the same thing.

0:27:05I think they're going to have a problem with the Mac client.

0:27:10There aren't a lot of user tokens that they've accumulated from the beta of that.

0:27:16How are they going to get more?

0:27:17Have they said when that applies?

0:27:18It applies when they do the switchover to the version 1.1 of the AP.

0:27:22That's the date when the count starts.

0:27:26I don't – that's one of the vague points.

0:27:29I don't – I presume it's when they –

0:27:31I think it's as of the announcement.

0:27:34Oh.

0:27:35Hmm.

0:27:36Yeah.

0:27:37I thought maybe it was as of the endpoint switchover to the 1.1 APIs.

0:27:42I don't know.

0:27:43It wasn't clear.

0:27:44You had another one that wasn't clear in that message.

0:27:48the tweetbot for the Mac may be the first client to run into this problem. In fact,

0:27:59I suspect it will be. And again, that shows the problem. It's a great piece of software

0:28:08that they're not going to be able to sell.

0:28:10One of the ways I feel like Twitter could tweak this, and in a very Apple-like way,

0:28:15in a way that Apple has not really made any major changes to the App Store.

0:28:20Fundamentally, it is exactly what they announced it as, but that they've made a slew of minor

0:28:25course adjustments here and there, you know, with the – oh, so for example, like one

0:28:30perfect example that was real frustrating early on in the App Store was that whole rule

0:28:34against duplicating built-in behavior.

0:28:36And so they were saying, "What?

0:28:37No calendar apps?"

0:28:39Because the phone has a built-in calendar app?

0:28:42know all of these guys have ideas for calendar UIs that are nothing like the

0:28:46Apple one and the whole reason I do it is they're frustrated and then Apple

0:28:49backed away from there and they were like that's like all right that never

0:28:51happened you can put calendar apps in now they may not let you they still

0:28:55don't let you switch the default calendar system wide you know and they

0:28:59can't do famous like with Sparrow you can't set a default email client you

0:29:03can't set Chrome as your default browser but at least you're allowed to put it in

0:29:06which was a course correction so one way that I feel like Twitter could course

0:29:10correct on this would be to raise that limit a little bit. Like 100,000.

0:29:13**Matt Stauffer:** Yeah, loosen the reins.

0:29:15**

0:29:17**

0:29:17And I know that for some people out there, it's like, "Man, 100,000 users in my app

0:29:22would be fantastic."

0:29:23But in the grand scheme of things, you're selling $2 apps or something like that.

0:29:27It is not that much.

0:29:29And conversely, 100,000 users to Twitter is nothing.

0:29:33John: Exactly.

0:29:34That's like the number of signups in a day.

0:29:37Steven: Right.

0:29:38And so that's what I think is that trying to think this through logically and just in

0:29:42the benefits of everybody, I do understand that Twitter doesn't want to let any individual

0:29:47client grow so large that it could threaten, you know, like there was that

0:29:52that thing last year where that one company bought a bunch of Twitter

0:29:54clients that accounted for like 40% Twitter client usage and then they

0:29:58started talking about, "Hey, we're gonna build our own Twitter-like service and

0:30:02let all the users of our apps sign up for that too." I think I think that had a

0:30:07lot to do with current policies. Yes, I really did. You know, I talked earlier

0:30:12earlier about fear. That's when the fear began. It's like, Oh, crap. Come out, come along and

0:30:19broadside us, you know, that's our exposure,

0:30:22Trenton Larkin set set that number at a number that that was

0:30:27is a feasible competitive threat to Twitter, which is a lot higher than 100,000. And you

0:30:31could even codify it in the guidelines that it that the number is is all user tokens that

0:30:39are owned by the same company. So that if one company went out and bought 10 clients

0:30:45that each had 200,000 users, that the company's count would be a million. And then you got

0:30:52to come talk to Twitter or something like that. But anyway, I feel like that's one thing

0:30:56that they could do that could really keep the innovation flowing without threatening

0:31:02Twitter itself.

0:31:04I think there are a lot of things that they could do, right?

0:31:11But they've chosen this path.

0:31:14And you know, it's their network.

0:31:18They built it.

0:31:19It's their product.

0:31:20It's their company.

0:31:21You know, they can do whatever the hell they want with it.

0:31:24I don't necessarily think what they're doing right now is in my best interest or in your

0:31:36best interest, but it may be in their best interest.

0:31:41And it's their prerogative to do that.

0:31:49We've always played the game by their rules.

0:31:53They specify the API.

0:31:54They specify who gets access.

0:31:58They specify how you're going to display stuff.

0:32:01In that case, that's the same way

0:32:09that it is with Apple and the App Store.

0:32:12And that's where the parallel rings true.

0:32:15Now, yeah, there are a lot of other things

0:32:20where those two aren't the same.

0:32:23But I don't know.

0:32:27Bottom line--

0:32:27It's going to be interesting to watch it play out.

0:32:29Yeah, it's going to be interesting to watch

0:32:31it play out.

0:32:34For me, the known entities right now are that Twitter clients

0:32:37are by third party.

0:32:40The things that show the timeline

0:32:42on your mobile, your laptop, wherever,

0:32:47are eventually going to die out.

0:32:51On that happy note, let's take a break for our first sponsor

0:32:55here.

0:32:56I want to tell you about a great app, app/service, really,

0:33:01called AppsFire.

0:33:03They've sponsored the talk show long before--

0:33:06well, not too long before earlier in the year,

0:33:08but they're back.

0:33:10Here's the bottom line.

0:33:11The problem they're trying to solve

0:33:12is that in Apple's App Store, it's really, really difficult

0:33:15find the best apps. And everybody who does this, if you look at the top list, you know

0:33:22that the top lists do not correspond to the best apps.

0:33:25Right.

0:33:26Right. I mean, everybody knows this, right?

0:33:28Yeah.

0:33:29And so in their notes...

0:33:30Quality does not equal quality.

0:33:34I think in their list, right now, they're saying of apps that don't show up in the top

0:33:38rankings include the Mule Radio app, Instapaper, and Coda. Now, in what world should those

0:33:43those apps not be in the top quality apps.

0:33:46So that's what Appsfire does, is they've

0:33:48built a great user experience to help users find apps.

0:33:51Not just apps in general, but the best apps.

0:33:55And what they've done is they've built a thing.

0:33:57They have a thing that they call the App Score.

0:33:59And they're equivalent in app terminology

0:34:02to what Rotten Tomatoes does for movies.

0:34:06And it's a daily rank of tens of dozens, I guess,

0:34:12of quality parameters on apps all over the App Store

0:34:18and from various review sites outside the App Store that

0:34:22give rankings and they filter the stuffs

0:34:24to get the low quality junk out there.

0:34:26So even if something's popular, but if it's

0:34:28getting poorly reviewed outside the App Store,

0:34:31that's what the App Store can identify.

0:34:33So you're not just-- the way that the App Store works

0:34:35is like if you just pick your movies based on box scores.

0:34:38Well, everybody went to see this movie,

0:34:40so that's what I'll go see. As opposed to Rotten Tomatoes, which says, "Look, Robert

0:34:43J. Ebert said this thing stunk. Peter Travers at Rolling Stone said that he fell asleep

0:34:47during the movie. You don't want to see this movie."

0:34:50Yeah. That's my contention all along, is that we need to know apps. There needs to

0:34:58be something about that where trusted sources say this is a good app, not Johnny 6969 on

0:35:07on the App Store, Sam.

0:35:09How did you know--

0:35:10This sucks.

0:35:11How did you know my Apple ID?

0:35:13I'm sorry, John.

0:35:15It's out there.

0:35:16I didn't mean to--

0:35:17AppSpire, they surface the test apps.

0:35:19Can you edit that out?

0:35:21We'll take that out.

0:35:22OK, go right out of there.

0:35:23And they add in the rich data.

0:35:25They add in the stuff like YouTube videos or Vimeo

0:35:28and videos, screenshots, and stuff like that.

0:35:30So you can check out the app.

0:35:31You can see it for yourself.

0:35:34You can personalize the app to see just the type of apps

0:35:37you prefer. If all you want to see are games, you can just set it up so that it all you want to all

0:35:42it's going to show you are the best games. And it's a free app. And it's universal. You get it

0:35:49for the iPad, you get it for the iPhone. It is retina ready on both. Can't say enough good things

0:35:56about this. So here's what you do. You can go to you got two options here. You can go to apps fire

0:36:02dot com a p p s fire dot com

0:36:06I or just go to the app store and search for apps fire

0:36:09and it'll be the first hit you get right up there I just wrote that down

0:36:13sounds like a good thing

0:36:16really good

0:36:20I here's another situation with the Twitter client the twin now this is a

0:36:23little bit outside your wheelhouse

0:36:24I is the way and it does seem like where the rubber is first hitting the road on

0:36:29these changes

0:36:30is with Twitter's interaction with other networks, right?

0:36:35So first they yanked Instagram out

0:36:38and everybody sort of raised an eyebrow.

0:36:41In other words, what you could do with Instagram

0:36:43is you could say, hey, plug in your Twitter credentials

0:36:46and it will go through and say, look,

0:36:48here's all of your people you know,

0:36:52your friends on Twitter who are also on Instagram.

0:36:54Do you wanna follow them?

0:36:55And I have to say, I used that 'cause I don't use Facebook

0:36:59so I couldn't use Facebook for that.

0:37:01I did that when I, it made Instagram,

0:37:03it maybe made the difference to me from at the beginning

0:37:06of whether Instagram was something that stuck with me or not

0:37:08because I found, you know, I don't know,

0:37:12a dozen, two dozen friends.

0:37:15- It bootstraps you.

0:37:16- Yeah, and all of a sudden I'm seeing pictures

0:37:18from people who I'm personal friends with in Instagram

0:37:21and I didn't have to hunt through and take a guess

0:37:24what their names are and stuff like that.

0:37:26And the truth is, you just don't think,

0:37:29You know, like, if you just start trying to do it from memory, you just forget.

0:37:33I mean, I forgot good, like, with—and we can get to this later in the show and talk

0:37:37about app.net a little bit—but, like, with trying to get started on app.net, it's like—I

0:37:42mean, some of my very best friends, I just forgot to look for them.

0:37:45Right.

0:37:46Like, Paul Kofosits was like, "Hey, dude, why don't you follow me there?"

0:37:49And it's like, he's one of my best friends.

0:37:51And I was like, "Uh, I thought I was."

0:37:53And I looked, and I'm like, "Oh."

0:37:54I mean, because I just didn't know.

0:37:56Whereas if I had like a thing that just said, "Hey, here's all of your friends from Twitter

0:38:00who are on this service.

0:38:01Do you want to follow them here too?"

0:38:02And then follow, follow, follow, follow, follow, follow, and they're all in.

0:38:07So they yanked it from Instagram and everybody thought, "Well, we know that they and Facebook

0:38:12hate each other and they're rivals and there's some bad blood because Facebook kind of crapped

0:38:16all over Twitter a while ago with another similar type feature.

0:38:20So let's just chalk this up.

0:38:22Let's be optimistic and chalk it up to a Facebook/Twitter type thing.

0:38:27But now yesterday when they did it to Tumblr, I mean, that's just like, to me it's like

0:38:33beyond the pale because…

0:38:34I don't understand it at all.

0:38:37Right.

0:38:38It's just, it's like, how is knowing who I follow a competitive advantage?

0:38:48Well and the other thing…

0:38:49I just don't get it.

0:38:50Tumblr's response and I give them credit for it because I think that their public response to this was in very plain language

0:38:57And and you know that I should actually quote it because it was so well said I thought it wasn't mealy-mouthed

0:39:03It wasn't whiny but it was just we don't get it. I mean we're disappointed because

0:39:08We're contributing to Twitter. We've made it easy for people who as they tumble to auto tweet their Tumblr

0:39:16You know that hey, I've got a new thing here. They're adding content to Twitter. They're not just pulling

0:39:22information in one direction from the Twitter

0:39:25Quote-unquote. I hate the term social graph. I

0:39:29Do hate to use it, but I think in this sense

0:39:32It really there's it really is what what people are talking about this connection of who you know

0:39:37but they were contributing like tweets tweet content is

0:39:43Constantly streaming into Twitter from people using tumblr it is absolutely like you used the word before and I don't hesitate to use it

0:39:50At all I thought it was a very healthy symbiotic relationship

0:39:54Right where Twitter our tumblr is not a Twitter competitor at all right. It's to me

0:40:00It's almost a picture a picture a dictionary example of what a symbiotic relationship was where tumblr users are writing content

0:40:09that gets

0:40:11tweeted when it's completed and then people see it on Twitter and click the URL and go to tumblr

0:40:17I can only met I know what my refers look like and I know that I've said this before

0:40:22My referral listings are turning in to more and more they're more and more useless because it's just they're all just they're all

0:40:30Tico leaks it's all

0:40:32Speaking of alternate monetization schemes. Would you pay to know where those TCO links came from? Oh, I would pay I would

0:40:39I would –

0:40:40Here's a check for $1,000.

0:40:41You know?

0:40:42Absolutely.

0:40:43Oh, yeah.

0:40:44It would be better than Google Analytics to me because they could do it in real time.

0:40:48It would absolutely be interesting.

0:40:50And if they could correlate that with – oh, yeah, absolutely.

0:40:57There's a goldmine of information there.

0:40:58It's actually – like I said, because I use Sean Inman's Mint and it's still great

0:41:03for tracking other stuff too as a daily thing. I have Google Analytics hooked up, which is

0:41:12interesting for other stuff. I had a potential sponsor the other day who just wanted to know.

0:41:16He had an app that is just for people who live in Chicago. And he wanted to know, "I don't think

0:41:22it's a great idea, but just wondering how many readers do you have in Chicago?" And I thought,

0:41:26"I have no idea." Ends up 1.8% of Daring Fireball readers live in greater Chicago area. I had no

0:41:32idea. Google Analytics gave me that and that's just really, really useful. I think the information

0:41:37that Twitter could give me from the Tico links would be great. It would probably become my

0:41:43go-to source for checking on how the site's doing on a daily basis.

0:41:47Do you think advertisers are getting that information?

0:41:51I don't know if they are yet.

0:41:52I think that's going to be a part of the deal.

0:41:54I don't know if they are yet, but there has to be. It has to be part of the deal. There's

0:41:59There's no other reason why they even went the TCO route.

0:42:03Right.

0:42:04I mean, there is a safety issue there, right?

0:42:08They can shut down a malicious link.

0:42:10But how many malicious links are there really?

0:42:16I know you're not going to post a malicious link.

0:42:20People know I'm not going to post a malicious link, other than maybe a Rick Roll.

0:42:24But it really is about the analytics angle.

0:42:29Oh, absolutely. And the analytics, it should be if they play their cards right. I mean,

0:42:34they've got the winning hand. If they don't monetize the analytics from Tico right, then

0:42:40it'll be like a case study in the future for how to botch an opportunity. It really will.

0:42:47It's like new coke.

0:42:48Right. You're sitting there with four aces in your hand, and everybody is starting to

0:42:55bet. I mean, you can't lose unless you're an idiot.

0:42:58Yeah.

0:42:59So, yeah, I'd agree with that.

0:43:03Here's the comment from Tumblr.

0:43:07"To our dismay, Twitter has restricted our users' ability to find Twitter friends on Tumblr.

0:43:12Given our history of embracing their platform, this is especially upsetting.

0:43:17Our syndication feature is responsible for hundreds of millions of tweets,

0:43:21and we eagerly enabled Twitter cards across 70 million blogs

0:43:25and 30 billion posts as one of Twitter's first partners.

0:43:30While we're delighted by the response to our integrations with Facebook and Gmail, we are

0:43:34truly disappointed by Twitter's decision."

0:43:36That's a great statement.

0:43:37I have to – hats off to Tumblr for just calling it as they see it.

0:43:40It's not angry?

0:43:41And it's not angry?

0:43:42Right.

0:43:43Yeah, clear and concise.

0:43:44Yeah, clear, concise, and honest.

0:43:45And admitting, "Look, this is their call.

0:43:50We're not going to pretend like this is some kind of mutual agreement."

0:43:53They yanked it out on us.

0:43:54Yeah, well, you know, it's not knowing what Twitter's thinking, right?

0:44:07You mentioned Apple.

0:44:09Apple has restrictions, but you can understand why those restrictions exist.

0:44:13They're protecting Apple's own interests and they're predicting Apple's customers' interests.

0:44:20That's the bottom line for 99 percent of what Apple does.

0:44:24Twitter, I'm not – okay, other than the advertisers are more important to us than

0:44:31the users of our network.

0:44:37Other than that, I just don't get things like this.

0:44:41I really don't.

0:44:43So anyway, we've got app.net.

0:44:49had some smart stuff there. I don't want to spend too long on it. And I don't want to

0:44:54create the impression that by me having linked to it and helped them meet their fundraising

0:45:00goal and talking about it, that I'm banking on app.net or I'm switching to app.net or

0:45:06that I think that even if somebody is going to come up with a rival to platform, that

0:45:10it is app.net. But I do think that they picked the right time to try something like this.

0:45:15And the right approach right in the right approach

0:45:18But you've been talking on on app.net about

0:45:23some of the naming problems they have just obvious things like the fact that they don't have a

0:45:28Word like tweet, which is both a noun and verb. Yeah, right what so there's no personality there

0:45:36There's no personality. It's like it sounds like a Microsoft product right you post

0:45:42Right. Yeah, you submit you you know, it's like it's just it's just there's no it's not a bad word

0:45:47But it's got like you said no personality. It's it's yeah

0:45:51It if you know if they expect to see wide up

0:45:55Adoption for this thing. It's gotta have some personality. It's got to be

0:46:00Non-threatening it's got to be

0:46:03something that the average person can look at and

0:46:10Understand where the value is

0:46:12I think part of the problem right now is is is they're confusing infrastructure, which is app.net with

0:46:20What people are going to be using which is?

0:46:23the alpha the the clients that

0:46:26just and

0:46:29I can't can't get too upset about this. I mean how long is this thing existed?

0:46:39Yeah, right a month and a half. It's early days. It's it's it's like, you know, it's like when Twitter was TW TTR

0:46:45Yeah, all right

0:46:47It's it's that it's it's a baby right? I'm not gonna be you know, dragging too much on a baby, but

0:46:53If you give a baby a name that name sticks with them for the rest of their life

0:46:58Right. It's important to come up with a

0:47:01Good name a name you're happy with, you know, you're not gonna name fuzz bud or something like that

0:47:06that, and then, "Oh, shit, he's 16, and we're still calling him Fuzzbutt."

0:47:10When Jonas was born, Amy's legal name was still her. She had her maiden name as her

0:47:16legal name. And so he was born, and his name on the sign in the booth in the box—they

0:47:25put babies in a box, really. It just said, "Baby Boy McGow." And my dad did it.

0:47:32That's kind of a good name.

0:47:34It kind of had a good ring to it.

0:47:35It almost stuck.

0:47:36That's the thing.

0:47:37That's why I bring this up, is that if we had gone another day or two, it might have

0:47:42stuck.

0:47:43Baby boy McGow.

0:47:44And that's really my point of Dalton Caldwell and the other guys there, that spend a little

0:47:51bit of time thinking about it now, because if you don't, you're going to regret it in

0:47:55the future.

0:47:56I guess another way to look at it in the big picture is you've got to start thinking product.

0:48:02You can't just think infrastructure and technology, right?

0:48:05And it's just getting down into Steve Jobs' territory, where the product has to drive

0:48:11the technology, not the other way around.

0:48:14This is right out of like the 1997 Jobs' interim CEO, what are we going to do?

0:48:23At that point, he hadn't even done the radical, "Look, we're going to get rid of 37 of these

0:48:27products and we're going to have four.

0:48:30laptop, a consumer desktop, a pro laptop, and a pro desktop. And that's it. And that's how we're

0:48:34going to get back into focus. It was before they even picked those things. But he just said,

0:48:38I think it was in response, I forget if it was at WWDC. I think it was at WWDC when he took the

0:48:44questions and answers. And somebody had asked about OpenDoc, which they said they were going

0:48:49to kill. And he said, it does all sorts of clever stuff. And it's great technology. But it doesn't

0:48:56fit. It doesn't matter if it's great technology sometimes. The vision has to drive the technology,

0:49:03not the other way around. You can't say, "Well, we've got this good technology, so we have

0:49:07to figure out a way to use it." That's what App.net has to do, is it's not enough to just

0:49:13have the infrastructure. That alone is hard. I mean, and everybody who watched Twitter

0:49:18grow from small to big and who still remembers the days of the fail well knows that that's

0:49:24And who even knows if app.net's technology backend is actually would survive that time of growth

0:49:29But let's just assume that it is that alone is not enough. That's not enough

0:49:33It's got to be a product that makes sense as a cohesive whole from the outside not the inside

0:49:40Yeah, no, it's it

0:49:42It's interesting. We were one of the first people on

0:49:45Twitter to actually think about product right because we were gonna

0:49:50release this thing, right?

0:49:51It was originally a free app,

0:49:54but we're not gonna release something

0:49:56that's not thought out, right?

0:49:58And we had to go through that thought process, okay,

0:50:02coming up with what this thing is gonna be.

0:50:07And that's hard.

0:50:12I mean, people, I think a lot of people

0:50:15take that for granted.

0:50:17It's like this whole Apple Samsung case, right?

0:50:21The thing that's been most eye-opening for me

0:50:23is how many frickin' prototypes they did of the iPhone,

0:50:26and how varied they were.

0:50:30- Well, and the better the idea,

0:50:31the more obvious it seems afterwards.

0:50:33- Exactly, exactly.

0:50:34And the more you think it through,

0:50:37the more you clarify it,

0:50:38the more it becomes simple,

0:50:43the more obvious it is.

0:50:45It's really a weird thing.

0:50:46It's like coming, you know.

0:50:50And there's that moment when somebody says, "Why don't you name them tweets?"

0:50:54Where it's just like, "Oh."

0:50:56That's like the sky is open and clarity is achieved.

0:51:01And you can't unsee it after that.

0:51:03Yeah.

0:51:04Right?

0:51:05Once you heard that, you couldn't not call them tweets.

0:51:08Right.

0:51:10And once you saw the iPhone…

0:51:14I originally wasn't going to get an iPhone.

0:51:16I watch the announcement and I think it's like, you know, I don't really want I

0:51:18Had to don't want to carry email around in my pocket, you know, I'd get enough

0:51:23I don't know. I'm not electronic interruptions in my day. Anyway, I don't kind of want that with me all the time

0:51:29And then you know five minutes in the Apple Store playing with that first iPhone. It's like oh

0:51:35Jesus this this is the future right? I

0:51:39This is this is another this is the next 30 years of computing. I remember more

0:51:45the glass cylinder that they were behind on the Macworld show floor.

0:51:50Yeah. I love that picture that Duncan took.

0:51:52Oh, that's true. You know, that's one of the—I think it honestly, I think not just for the

0:51:57tech nerd world, I think it's one of the best photos that I've seen in the last decade.

0:52:02Right.

0:52:03I think—and I think that it'll—it should rightfully go down as like the iconic picture

0:52:09of the decade, that decade in technology. Honestly.

0:52:14Yeah, it's that it's that moment of clarity right now. Are you looking at that and just going that this is that they got abs

0:52:21Absolutely everything right here, right? You know after using it for a month, you know, there were little niggles here and there but

0:52:2899.9% of that original iPhone was perfect. Yep

0:52:33Have one right here on my hand at my desk batteries on I've got an original Mac up in the attic

0:52:40I've got my original—

0:52:41I will never sell that.

0:52:42I've got my original iPhone right here.

0:52:45I still turn it over in my hand every once in a while.

0:52:47I still love it.

0:52:48I do too.

0:52:49I love it.

0:52:50The metal back.

0:52:51The metal back, it still hasn't been topped.

0:52:52Yeah.

0:52:53In fact, I'm holding it right now.

0:52:54It's like holy crap.

0:52:57This is—yeah.

0:53:01Like the front face is not as good.

0:53:03The front face is absolutely sort of a hack with the silver, the chrome around the bezel.

0:53:10But from the back, man, that thing is perfect.

0:53:13John: You can see why they did that chrome bezel, right?

0:53:17They didn't have the technology to meet those two different materials, right?

0:53:24They need something to tie them together.

0:53:25Again, in hindsight, it's really easy to look at that and go, "Yeah, of course,

0:53:33it's a and that you know how many iterations that it take them to come to that conclusion can only imagine I

0:53:40Mean I'm gonna start wrapping things up. I want I still I do want to talk about retina stuff

0:53:47but before we do while we're still on Twitter, I would like to talk about our second sponsor and

0:53:53Fits right in it is a brand new app

0:53:55Called tweet keeper

0:54:01I just installed it. It does exactly what it says and I'm gonna tell you now don't interrupt me because I'm gonna tell you again

0:54:06I see if you can predict who I've loaded up in here

0:54:09Craig but what tweet keeper does it's an iPhone app that lets you easily save search and

0:54:16Export tweets and it's not just for yours

0:54:18You could just put in a username any username and it'll slurp down all the available tweets for that user

0:54:24Now, why would you want to do that? It's because the Twitter API only lets you get 3200 tweets

0:54:28So if I said "Chalk & Berry," it'll give me Craig Hockenberry's last 3,200 tweets.

0:54:34Now, here's the thing.

0:54:36A month from now, when Craig has posted a few hundred more, and I'm using TweetKeeper,

0:54:40TweetKeeper, I just launch it every couple days, and it'll keep launching them.

0:54:43And so a year from now, I'll have more than 3,200 of your tweets.

0:54:48So it still can't go back beyond today's 3,200 tweet horizon.

0:54:52But starting now, you can start saving tweets from the users whose tweets you want

0:54:58to archive and it will just get them all starting from now, go back 3200 and then going forward

0:55:05will keep them all. Let's you search them of course and search is real fast. I've already

0:55:09loaded up a couple of accounts with all 3200 tweets searched for peanut found them. There's

0:55:15a hint as to who I'm using it for. And you can export them. You can export them to JSON.

0:55:22The raw JSON format it exports is exactly in the same format that Twitter gives you

0:55:27over the API. You can export them in plain text. You can export them to a spreadsheet.

0:55:35And then you can just email or open the tweets in another app. It works exactly as it says.

0:55:41It is very, very fast. It even works with private accounts, which I haven't tried because

0:55:46I don't have a private account. I presume you'd need a password for that. It's super

0:55:51simple. So you want to save tweets. The sooner you start using it, the quicker you're going

0:55:56to have a more complete archive of a user. Now, who do you think I'm saving in there?

0:56:02Well, I haven't gotten to the peanut portion of Dad Boner yet, but I'm guessing it's Dad

0:56:09Boner. Right. My friend Carl Wellzine out in Detroit,

0:56:14who is the greatest, in my opinion. Grand Blanc.

0:56:17Well, near Detroit. Yeah, okay. Detroit area.

0:56:23A literary character, an anonymously written fictional character on Twitter who I believe

0:56:31to be one of the great literary characters of the last 10 years, hilarious.

0:56:36And you read him, you fall in love with him, but then you want to go back and read his

0:56:40old ones.

0:56:41Or a month from now, when he starts referencing something that happened a couple months ago,

0:56:45you want to go back.

0:56:46Well, guess what?

0:56:47You're stuck in regular Twitter apps because you've only got the most recent ones.

0:56:50If you use something like TweetKeeper, you've got them all.

0:56:53You can go back, you can search, you can see the old stories.

0:56:57And it's a great way to back up your own Twitter account past what Twitter would let you do.

0:57:01So the sooner you put your own username in there, the longer you're going to have an

0:57:06archive of your own tweets.

0:57:08TweetKeeper is available in the App Store for an introductory price of just $1.99.

0:57:13$1.99, get this great app.

0:57:15It works, got a nice interface, super fast.

0:57:18You can find out more at TweetKeeperApp.com or just search for "tweetkeeper" in the

0:57:24App Store.

0:57:25That's what I did, first thing that came up.

0:57:28TweetKeeper, it's a great app.

0:57:31Let's talk about retina stuff.

0:57:32Let's just go through this.

0:57:33Yeah.

0:57:34You and I started talking about it yesterday.

0:57:37And this is really, really fascinating.

0:57:39And developing Xscope puts you right – I mean, like, you could not be more –

0:57:44I've looked at every single freaking pixel on that display.

0:57:47You're neck deep in this stuff, and you're 6 foot 8.

0:57:51Yeah.

0:57:52That's a lot of pixels.

0:57:55Well, and the most interesting thing about it

0:57:57is that prior to the Retina Mac, Xscope's job was showing--

0:58:04helping you show pixels on screen,

0:58:06whether it was aligning them or constraining them

0:58:10or magnifying them.

0:58:11But it's, here's the pixels on the screen.

0:58:13We're going to show you them bigger.

0:58:16the big change with retina is not like iOS where it's just four times more pixels. It

0:58:23is variant, right? That's the thing that blows my mind and really it gives me headaches just

0:58:30thinking about the math that's involved in the X-scope. Like, and so, Syracuse has covered this

0:58:37stuff extensively and it's still mind-blowing is that everybody knows you get the MacBook retina,

0:58:43you have five choices for resolution, and the middle one is the default, which is best

0:58:52for retina, which is the only one where pixels are pixels.

0:58:56Yeah, it's the one where you see two pixels for every one window point.

0:59:03Right.

0:59:04A window point is a…

0:59:07The old pixel.

0:59:08In pre-retina, a window point is a pixel, and in the new world, a window point in Best

0:59:15for Retina is four.

0:59:16But there's two other dimensions in each way.

0:59:22So when it simulates like the 1900 by 1200 something display, it is drawing off screen

0:59:31to a pixel-doubled version of that.

0:59:34and then scaling it down to the actual 28 by whatever.

0:59:42So you're actually losing…

0:59:43>> Twenty-eight eighty by fourteen four…

0:59:44>> Right.

0:59:45It's actually only showing you…

0:59:46>> No, no, no.

0:59:47Eighteen hundred.

0:59:48Excuse me.

0:59:49>> Right.

0:59:50So it's actually only showing you two-thirds of the pixels.

0:59:51But it looks okay because the pixels are so small.

0:59:54It actually looks good.

0:59:55>> You can't tell.

0:59:56Yeah, you can't tell.

0:59:58When you're on that more space setting, the retina image that's being created by Mac OS

1:00:0710 is twice of that size that you selected, and then it gets scaled down 66% to fit on

1:00:18the display.

1:00:22If you see something that's drawing a one-pixel line, it'll get a little bit fuzzy.

1:00:27It gets a tiny little bit fuzzy, but you're far enough back that you can't tell.

1:00:33That's one of the things that's interesting in the new version of XCO for me is that in

1:00:39the loop, it draws a little grid so you can delineate each pixel easily.

1:00:45I'm drawing that grid with one pixel, and it's just so fine.

1:00:50It's like it's there, but it's not.

1:00:54I can't tell that it's a pixel.

1:00:55It's just like this...

1:00:56Because in a hairline, it's like a piece, you know, sometimes you get a piece of hair on your laptop screen, you know

1:01:03It's just that really thin

1:01:05What it is in in regular?

1:01:08UI design like if you and I were just working on a regular Mac app in and we're going retina with it

1:01:14The the most the thinnest you typically would get though would be one point, right?

1:01:19You wouldn't typically draw stuff in the UI at less than one point. Is that correct?

1:01:25Yeah, that's it that so you just want to put a line you want to put a one you want to put a hairline

1:01:30Between the source list and the content that's the app

1:01:33We're making you're gonna draw that at one point and then write pre retina max

1:01:37It'll register it'll draw as one pixel and on retina max. It'll draw as two pixels as two pixels, right?

1:01:42So what you've done the thing that's interesting is that you can draw a half a point now on a retina display

1:01:48You're drawing you're drawing half of one of those and that's that's where the math got complicated, right?

1:01:55Right.

1:01:56Because, for example, the windows can only be positioned on full point boundaries, right?

1:02:04But Xscope has got to measure stuff that's on those half-point boundaries.

1:02:08So I'm positioning windows and then having to shift views around in those windows so

1:02:14that they align on that right half-point position.

1:02:19Now one of the reasons…

1:02:20It was hard.

1:02:21I'm sure it really is.

1:02:23And you're not done yet.

1:02:25do have a beta then I yeah I've got it and it works great and it's just makes

1:02:30me more happy to just stare at the retina mac well have you noticed that

1:02:35the one pixel shadow border on the windows on yours no I haven't no no no

1:02:44I'm talking about just on a standard Mac OS 2 window yeah yeah yeah there's just

1:02:47that one pixel that that kind of makes the window pop out a little bit yep

1:02:51That's not there on the non-retina version.

1:02:55No.

1:02:56Apple, I mean, it's an amazing piece of engineering, right?

1:02:59I've been reverse engineering this thing for the last month or so.

1:03:02But they've taken advantage of it in some very subtle ways, like that.

1:03:05Oh, it's, yeah.

1:03:07Again, it's that one pixel can do some pretty amazing things to your UI.

1:03:14Yeah.

1:03:15It's used judiciously, right?

1:03:16You know, you don't want to get carried away with it because then it's like nobody's

1:03:20can be able to see what you're doing.

1:03:22Well, the weirdest-- well, not weirdest, but the thing that blows me away and that really

1:03:26is noticeable is that-- and you know this.

1:03:28I mean, it's no surprise that you're the one-- the icon factory is the developer, co-developer

1:03:36of-- are you guys Xscope entirely now?

1:03:39I know it's--

1:03:40No, it's a joint project still.

1:03:44We've taken on Wolfgang Ante at Microsoft.

1:03:49I'm doing the primary development on it now.

1:03:52But it's no surprise that you guys are doing this because it's sort of one of those,

1:03:56we're building this for ourselves because of course the name of the company is the Icon

1:03:59Factory.

1:04:00You guys still do tons of icon, you guys do artwork.

1:04:03You do user interface artwork.

1:04:05And so what you're building is a tool for people who sweat the pixels of beautiful,

1:04:10beautiful icons and user interface elements and buttons and anything like that.

1:04:16Or developers even.

1:04:19gets a Photoshop comp and they've got to build a UI and, you know, they've got to measure color,

1:04:24they've got to measure pixel distance, and, you know, there are a lot of uses for the app.

1:04:29Steven: And that's what the app is for, is to… We're going to insanely insist that every single

1:04:35pixel of this icon is perfect, but we need software, you know, we need special software

1:04:40to actually magnify it and see it now. It's no surprise that you made it. With your hairlines,

1:04:46for your guides and the new thing. It reminds me of, going back to my review of the MacBook

1:04:50Retina Pro, whatever the hell it's called, when I got access to a 1200 DPI laser printer.

1:04:56And I remember at Quark, we started making, just as a test, we started making hairlines.

1:05:01We set them to a quarter of a point, a tenth of a point, and it was like a twentieth of a point.

1:05:07And you could see it. You could see like a twentieth of a point hairline. And we're like,

1:05:11like, "Oh my God, that's amazing." But then it was no good for like, you couldn't

1:05:16reproduce it. You couldn't put a 20th of a hairline. You could see it on the output

1:05:21you got out of the printer, but then if you tried to put it in newsprint, it was gone.

1:05:24I mean, it was like, you can't.

1:05:27Yeah, yeah. That's why I think the thing that Apple's done is smart. By default,

1:05:36UIs on the retina display are using two pixels, right, which are easier to see.

1:05:41You know, they took a lot of different approaches, and I think the current one that they that this is a perfect example

1:05:49of where they learned a lot from iOS, right?

1:05:51It's it's you know, they originally had

1:05:54TIFF files which had different scale factors and them, you know, it's like because it they were thinking that okay

1:06:00we can adjust the scaling to any value, right? If somebody wants to see their screen at 1.3

1:06:07times, you know, we can have a slider and they'll do that. But in reality, people just

1:06:13– they want to see the best they can see.

1:06:15Right. The idea of – I think the older idea, the original idea for independence was about

1:06:20switching from bitmaps to vector graphics, of doing like, you know, making it like PDF,

1:06:26everything would be like PDF and where when you open up a PDF file and preview

1:06:31you can get reasonable font rendering at 87 percent 113 percent 114 percent you

1:06:39do it doesn't really matter because the fonts are all outline you know they're

1:06:43all either open type or true type or post script or something like that so

1:06:47they're going to scale and you know especially when you blow stuff up big if

1:06:51you really want to zoom in and just say what I want to really look at this

1:06:55capital R and just blow it up real big.

1:06:58It's going to look great.

1:06:59The problem is that it's not going to look pixel perfect when it's small.

1:07:02>> Yeah.

1:07:03And that is the problem with people saying, "Oh, you know, well, why does the whole UI

1:07:08even, you know, the graphics are in a vector format?"

1:07:11Because they're unpredictable, right?

1:07:14Sometimes you need to have that pixel precision in order to, you know, pull out some element

1:07:19and the icon or to make sure something's aligned correctly.

1:07:23It's sort of, it's like that colored status bar, right?

1:07:29Designers like predictability.

1:07:31Right.

1:07:31And control.

1:07:33Yeah, exactly.

1:07:34And they need it.

1:07:35And they need that.

1:07:36They create great stuff because they have that control.

1:07:40Start taking that control away from them.

1:07:41And for fonts, it's a different thing, right?

1:07:44the font designers have always worked with vectors.

1:07:49They would then take some of that work

1:07:57and make pixel-based versions of it, screen fonts.

1:08:01Which, it's funny, screen fonts have been deprecated.

1:08:04It's pretty clear that that pixel-level control

1:08:10over a font is just something that's going

1:08:13the way of the dodo bird. It doesn't make sense at these resolutions, really. No, no.

1:08:25My only complaint with the Retina display is the form factor that it sits in. I love

1:08:32my MacBook Air. Yeah, we just commiserated. We cried ourselves asleep over this on aim

1:08:37yesterday. But yeah, I desperately want a retina machine, but I don't want it in a

1:08:4315-inch MacBook Pro. But I think that's what I'm going to have to do, because unless

1:08:49Apple surprises us with maybe like a 13-inch MacBook Pro by the end of the year, I think

1:08:54I'm just going to suck it up and buy the 15-inch and use it as my only machine.

1:08:59Yeah, it's interesting to me that their first machine that they put the retina display in

1:09:05was a 15, right? You'd think that as far as production yields and similarities with the

1:09:12iPad's retina display, they would have gone with the smaller screen, right? The 11-inch

1:09:16or the 13-inch.

1:09:17Right. Or, well, not 11 because the only 11 is the Air and that's got these price points

1:09:23that I don't think they can hit yet. And I don't think they want to.

1:09:25Oh, right. Yeah, yeah.

1:09:26I'm not surprised. They're not going to do an 11-inch Pro. I don't think.

1:09:29Right.

1:09:30I think they're going to do 13 and 15.

1:09:31No, no, no.

1:09:32I'm a little disappointed maybe is the more the right word than surprised that they didn't

1:09:38do the 13 and 15 at the same time.

1:09:41And like you said, if they can do the 15 and get yields of these 15 inch screens, then

1:09:46certainly they should be able to get the 13s too.

1:09:49But I also do think though that it speaks to the 15 inch MacBook Pro as the defacto

1:09:56king of the Macs.

1:09:58Like it may not be the fastest, it's never going to be faster.

1:10:01It's still not faster than the Mac Pros, even the jokey joke, you know, Syracuse, I hate

1:10:05Mac Pros that they released at WWDC.

1:10:09But of course not.

1:10:10I mean, a Mac Pro is the size of my dorm room refrigerator.

1:10:15I love my Mac Pro, man.

1:10:16I've got two 30-inch displays hooked up to it.

1:10:18I mean, it's like real estate city.

1:10:21I'm just saying it's the king of the Macs in terms of being like the sweet spot between

1:10:25what normal people buy versus what pros buy.

1:10:30right there and you know that it kind of makes sense that it would be the first

1:10:34one to get this amazing new technology. And I read a post by our friend Gus, Gus

1:10:41Mueller and he was saying you know he's got the MacBook Pro with the retina

1:10:47display and it's obviously doing acorn development on it and you know he's got

1:10:51his MacBook or excuse me his Mac Pro sitting side by side just like me right

1:10:56The Retina MacBook Pro is faster than my old Mac Pro. It's weird. It doesn't have as much screen real estate.

1:11:06My Mac Pro doesn't need to be super fast. I'm not building the OS. I build times for half a minute or something.

1:11:16Yeah, but you guys who use Xcode really still are. And I've mentioned this on a couple shows.

1:11:21that's fewer and fewer for normal people,

1:11:23or people who aren't, there's fewer and fewer tasks

1:11:26that are CPU constrained.

1:11:28I'm almost never CPU constrained,

1:11:30except when Safari really gets bogged down

1:11:34with a ton of tabs.

1:11:35Sometimes Safari will chew up over 100% of my CPU

1:11:38because I've got so much going on.

1:11:40- You know what I wish Safari had?

1:11:42A processor or a tab monitor, right?

1:11:44So you could see which tabs were using the most CPU time.

1:11:48- Or I wish that I could set a thing that says,

1:11:50don't let tabs in the background have more than a 2% CPU.

1:11:54- Yeah, exactly, exactly.

1:11:55- I wish that I could just set a nice setting

1:11:58on anything except the front-most tab,

1:12:00'cause I don't do anything.

1:12:01I don't use web apps that I want doing stuff

1:12:05in the background.

1:12:06I wouldn't care if it was iOS,

1:12:07and it just shut background tabs off.

1:12:10I don't care.

1:12:12- The browser is an OS now, right?

1:12:14We used to reboot our Macs.

1:12:15Now we reboot our Safari.

1:12:17- Safari's the number one reason why I feel like

1:12:20need a new faster computer. But you guys who use Xcode, you realize there are CPU constraints.

1:12:25You guys save time.

1:12:26At times.

1:12:27At times, yeah. There are times when you are significantly more productive with a faster

1:12:32CPU. I mean, that's a fact.

1:12:34Yes, that's correct. That's correct. Especially with the new version of Xcode is it likes

1:12:40to use all those cores.

1:12:41Yeah. Now, I've been thinking about this a lot.

1:12:43And there are times when it does.

1:12:44I've been thinking about it a lot. And I think you said the same thing where it's like we're

1:12:47into this corner number we've seen the 15 inch MacBook Pro with a retina display and because

1:12:52we've seen the retina display we'd never want to buy another Mac without a retina display again

1:12:56but we don't want the 15 inch heavier portable hardware I would rather have like an iMac on my

1:13:04desk or a Mac Pro with a cinema retina display something like that big standalone retina display

1:13:10and I would like a little 11 inch retina air or a 13 inch retina air uh none of that exists and

1:13:16And the way I say, I don't know what's going to come first, and I feel like Apple's pulled

1:13:20in two different directions, where with the iMacs, it's just their screens are too big.

1:13:25I mean, I think it's too expensive.

1:13:26I don't think there's any feasible – I think they're just up against the tech where they

1:13:30can't get 27-inch retina displays.

1:13:32I think that's absolutely true.

1:13:33I mean, look at what happened with the iPhone, right?

1:13:35It's like we got a 320 by 480, the 640 by 960 screen, and that was feasible.

1:13:42Right.

1:13:43Right?

1:13:44"Okay, it's feasible on the iPad, a much larger screen."

1:13:49I think that was, again, back to the,

1:13:55it's like why didn't they start with 13

1:13:56and work their way up?

1:13:57Well, I think you're right in that the 15

1:14:00was the sweet spot, price-wise, machine-wise,

1:14:05a lot of reason that they went there.

1:14:06But I think they'll probably go down a little bit now

1:14:10they do some retina 13, but those 27-inch screens in retina, they're gonna be awesome.

1:14:17Yeah.

1:14:18But that's gonna be two, maybe three years from now.

1:14:22I think so, yeah.

1:14:23Or at least a full year out, at least.

1:14:26And then on the other side with the Air, they obviously could, I mean, if they can do 15

1:14:31inch, then they can do the smaller ones.

1:14:32So they could have an 11-inch Air retina screen now.

1:14:36But I think it's about the Air brand being tied to these very consumer-friendly price

1:14:42points.

1:14:43The 11-inch Air, it starts at $999, which is magic.

1:14:47That's a number that Apple spent like a decade not really being that near with a laptop and

1:14:53being able to say, "We've got a $999 laptop that…"

1:14:57And unlike the white plastic – I think they were still called iBooks always, right?

1:15:05which hit that – the first ones that hit that $999, but they were like decidedly less

1:15:10cool.

1:15:11The materials, right. The materials were –

1:15:12Right. Whereas you look at the 11-inch air and it's in some ways more beautiful than

1:15:18the Pros because it's so much thinner and lighter and has this cool teardrop thing and

1:15:22it's just like you can really just hold it with a finger and a thumb. It actually

1:15:27arguably is a better design than the more expensive Pros and I feel like that they're

1:15:32It's a matter of just not of technology but of cost, that they're not going to retina-ize

1:15:37the heirs until they can still keep it in these $999, $1100 price points.

1:15:46What do you think is going to happen first, a retina iMac or retina air?

1:15:50I think a retina air.

1:15:51I think so too.

1:15:53I think they'll be able to hit those price points first and maybe even do it and eat

1:15:57a little bit of the margin for the first year but just get it out there to do it.

1:16:01Yeah, but how many of them are they going to sell?

1:16:04That thing's going to sell like hotcakes.

1:16:08I skipped the upgrade when they added the Thunderbolt instead of the original DisplayPort

1:16:16stuff.

1:16:17Because the machine's fine for what I use it for.

1:16:20I don't do my primary development on that machine.

1:16:22But man, when that thing's got a retina display, I'm first in line.

1:16:27It's a no-brainer upgrade for me.

1:16:30It's interesting.

1:16:32One of the hard things for Xscope was making sure that the retina display works alongside

1:16:37a normal resolution display.

1:16:42You're magnifying the screen on the retina display.

1:16:44Well, you can drag that magnifier over onto another window, which is not retina.

1:16:50So it's like you got a—there's a little bit of complication there as far as making

1:16:56sure both the retina screen and the non-retina screen work together.

1:17:01And that's the way things are going to be for the next couple of years, right?

1:17:04Because nobody—

1:17:05What happens when you drag a window—because I don't use multiple displays anymore—but

1:17:07what happens when you drag a window half onto one and half on the other?

1:17:11The half that it's most on gets the retina treatment.

1:17:16Huh.

1:17:17Or not, right?

1:17:18If it's more than half onto the retina screen, it renders everything retina.

1:17:23And then on the normal screen, it doesn't look quite right because it's the retina

1:17:29graphics scaled down to the half size, basically.

1:17:35Gotcha.

1:17:3650% reduction.

1:17:37But again, with a tool like the loop, an Xscope, it's got to seamlessly switch between those

1:17:47two environments. Same with the ruler and all the other stuff that Xscope does.

1:17:57Who says you don't grow up and use your math classes?

1:18:00Yeah, that's very true. In fact, it's funny. I've got a stack of paper here that's got

1:18:06nothing but rectangles.

1:18:07Well, you know, Samsung told me that it's all just rectangles. All just simple rectangles.

1:18:16have square corners though. It's all very obvious. Did you guys design, did Icon Factory

1:18:24design the new Microsoft logo? No. No. Square corners. The last thing we did for them were

1:18:33the icons for Vista. Then they... I forgot that you guys did that. That was a big deal.

1:18:40folder standing on their side, that was a long and involved design process.

1:18:47Microsoft has gotten smart, right? They're doing a lot more of their design in-house.

1:18:55They realize that design is a competitive tool.

1:19:02You know what they own?

1:19:03Kind of taken a play from Apple's playbook.

1:19:05You know what? I joke there, but I don't mean this. I don't buy into the argument that round

1:19:13wrecks are inherently better than square corners. I think there's room in design for all sorts

1:19:18of stuff. I think that they're owning. I think Microsoft is owning square corners.

1:19:24Yeah.

1:19:25And I think that's kind of a cool thing to own, that they've eked out a very distinctive

1:19:30aesthetic. And it works.

1:19:33It's consistent.

1:19:34It works both as a screen UI and as a branding UI, this square corner rectangles and squares

1:19:43thing.

1:19:44I think it's a powerful visual brand, honestly.

1:19:47I think that it's by far and away their best user interface branding ever.

1:19:54The only other one that was good was the Windows 95 one, which they just ripped off from Next.

1:19:58Yeah. The Windows 8, I think, looks great. To be honest, I have not used it.

1:20:05Yeah, but it's not -- oh, Windows 8. Windows 8. Yeah, yeah, yeah. I thought you were saying

1:20:10Windows 7.

1:20:11Yeah, the X Metro UI.

1:20:13I'm just going to keep calling it Metro. To hell with them.

1:20:16That's a weird thing.

1:20:18Because you know what? I'm so sick of --

1:20:19Why didn't they think of that earlier?

1:20:21I don't want to sit there and write "formerly known as Metro" or the Windows 8 style UI.

1:20:25I'm just gonna call it Metro and that's their problem. You know what I mean? That's it. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, that's great it

1:20:32Yeah, it's consistent. It's I

1:20:35Think that the biggest problem they're gonna have are the people who have been using Windows since Windows 95

1:20:43Going oh my god. This is different. Yep

1:20:46It's really different

1:20:49It is so much riskier and it's going to make people so much angrier than if it was only

1:20:55on the Windows RT for ARM on these tablet devices as Apple style. The equivalent of

1:21:03the iPad to Apple. A new thing and it's, you know, it'll interrelate, you can sync it,

1:21:09you can dock it, it'll talk to exchange and all this stuff. But if you just buy a Dell

1:21:13shitbox PC and install the Windows on it.

1:21:17It's going to look like your Windows desktop and have a start menu down there.

1:21:25I say we wrap it up.

1:21:26I think we've been on for a long time.

1:21:27Craig Hockenberry, thank you for being here.

1:21:29You're the best.