Podcast Search

The Talk Show

12: Down to the Mac Nerd Guys, with John Siracusa

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00You know what I had to do to get this to happen?

0:00:02What'd you have to do?

0:00:03Reboot into my super duper clone

0:00:05Really?

0:00:06Yeah, because I just upgraded to 10.8

0:00:08I was like i'd upgraded every other computer in the house to 10.8 without a problem

0:00:12I said oh this looks like it's going to be a cakewalk

0:00:14I'll just upgrade my main machine to 10.8 and it was going fine until I tried to use skype and you sounded like

0:00:20Whatever the the voice from uh, the scream movie. Oh, yeah

0:00:26I always do my Skyping from my MacBook Air.

0:00:29But right after I upgraded that machine to 10.8

0:00:32and first tried to record a show,

0:00:33I forget how many problems Skype gave me.

0:00:36So it was pretty bad.

0:00:38Anyway, before we get started, this is De rigor.

0:00:41This is something I do with everybody on the show now

0:00:43is I need a little bit of personal information.

0:00:45I need your mother's maiden name

0:00:47and the name of the street you grew up on

0:00:49and your first elementary school.

0:00:52- What about my pet's name?

0:00:53First pet.

0:00:54- Yeah, exactly.

0:00:54all four of those things.

0:00:56>> BRIAN KARDELL Yeah, that's always just been weird to me that we have all these rules

0:01:00around passwords and the backup, the backup for like, well, in case you forgot your password,

0:01:04the backup is like things people can easily find out about you using the internet. That's

0:01:08like the category of what they are, you know?

0:01:10>> JONATHAN KARDELL Right.

0:01:11>> BRIAN KARDELL Of all the things, like what color is your hair? What is your eye color?

0:01:15You know, like you can Google for all this stuff. Mother's maiden name, do you kill off

0:01:19your entire mother's side of the family? Like they no longer exist. How hard is it to look

0:01:22up what someone's mother's maiden name is?

0:01:24Yeah, and of course the reason we're talking about this is the Matt Honan situation from

0:01:30a week ago.

0:01:31There's a picture of him in case you wanted to know his hair color and eye color.

0:01:34Right.

0:01:35You can go right to the Wired story.

0:01:36See the poor guy right there.

0:01:38You can just – the look on his face is like I just lost all the photos of my daughter.

0:01:43That's what that look says to me.

0:01:46So anyway, long story short, I mean I'm sure everybody who listens is probably at least

0:01:49somewhat familiar with the story, but Matt Honan is a lot of Twitter followers and he

0:01:53for Wired, used to write for Gizmodo. Really had like a war almost like a

0:01:58worst-case scenario where like Saturday afternoon he's playing with his young

0:02:03daughter and all of a sudden like starts noticing some funky things. I forget what

0:02:07what came first but it's like all of a sudden his phone rebooted, his iPhone

0:02:10rebooted, and next thing you know is his iPad reboots, his MacBook Air reboots, they

0:02:17all get locked out, they're all remote wiped, and all of a sudden some hacker

0:02:22hacker group starts posting, takes over his Twitter account and starts posting, I mean,

0:02:27just horrible, racist and homophobic and maybe even most embarrassing of all, ridiculous

0:02:33hacker Leetspeak talk to his Twitter account.

0:02:39And long story short, the whole thing happened because they wanted to mess with his Twitter

0:02:44account.

0:02:45And to get his Twitter account, they wanted his Gmail account.

0:02:52and his Gmail account had as his backup his me.com iCloud email address as like a secondary

0:03:02account.

0:03:04And they knew that they could take that over just by calling Apple and giving them his

0:03:10street address in the last four digits of his credit card.

0:03:14And they could get the last four digits of his credit card just by calling Amazon and

0:03:21Amazon is what was it I forget what you needed to know like an email address and

0:03:26a shipping address and then you could say hey I have a new credit card I just

0:03:29wanted to add it to my account you give them a bogus credit card then you call

0:03:34Amazon right back and say I lost access to my email I think I've got this right

0:03:41so far do I have you got it right I lost access to my email but I do know the

0:03:46last four digits of my credit card which is the bogus one they just gave you you

0:03:49they you just gave Amazon not even a real credit card. You just go online and use like a tool that

0:03:55gives you like a credit card. You know, one that hasn't been verified to make charges, but just

0:04:01the numbers comply with the rules, you know, we're like MasterCard start with a five and visas start

0:04:07with a four and a couple of other rules. At which point Amazon will let you reset your account to

0:04:17I forget what they do.

0:04:18Somehow they reset your-- they let you add a new email address,

0:04:22I think.

0:04:22They let you log in, and you can't see your credit card

0:04:25numbers after logging in.

0:04:26But you can see the abbreviated versions

0:04:27of your existing credit card number.

0:04:29Which is all you need to give Apple.

0:04:31Right, just those last four digits,

0:04:33because they star out everything except for the last four.

0:04:35Right.

0:04:36And so then you can call Apple back with-- say, I'm Matt

0:04:39Honan.

0:04:40Here's my home address.

0:04:42Here's the last four digits of my account.

0:04:46I you know, please reset my iCloud password.

0:04:50And then at that point, all that all those dominoes

0:04:53that I just set up over the last four minutes,

0:04:55they all fall down because now they've got

0:04:57his iCloud account.

0:04:59And they can they've got the password for that.

0:05:02And then they use that to use the find my iPhone

0:05:05to remote wipe his devices to lock them out of his computers.

0:05:09And then they had Gmail send a reset password

0:05:13to the iCloud account they were in control of,

0:05:15which let them take over his Gmail, and then they just, I mean, it seems like the guy,

0:05:19I can't, he does, the thing that most surprised me is that he wasn't, at least publicly and

0:05:24writing about it, didn't seem angry about the guys who did this to him.

0:05:27That's one of those things where like you're in shock, because it's just, it's just such

0:05:31a huge thing that's just so unlikely to happen, you don't even imagine it happening. And also,

0:05:37he says many times that he blames himself, and probably rightly, like you don't blame

0:05:42yourself for getting hacked, but you blame for yourself for having no backups.

0:05:44Right, that's that's the killer

0:05:46All the guys wanted to do is take over his Twitter account and mess around with it which in and of itself

0:05:51They're being assholes about it

0:05:53But at least if that's all that they did all they did was embarrass him by

0:05:57Putting a bunch of gibberish on his Twitter account for 12 hours

0:06:00But the remote wiping of his computers and they they also like remote or not remote wipe

0:06:07But you know did whatever you do in Gmail to say hey just you know

0:06:10Delete everything I have in here which is like for him like seven years of email or something like that

0:06:15Boom just closed out the account. That's just spite

0:06:18Well, it's not it's not so much spite because they don't even know the guy

0:06:22It's just like if you give hackers once hackers get access

0:06:26How are you gonna resist that like now, you know that the whole idea is like control and power

0:06:30It's like you know what I can remotely wipe all these guys machines because of how he set everything up

0:06:34That's just the ultimate in power. You're reaching across the internet and just like massively

0:06:39Smiting this person so it's impossible to resist I guess so because I guess whatever is wrong with your with whatever is wrong with your

0:06:46Mind that would make you want to

0:06:48Take over someone's Twitter account like that

0:06:50It's probably wrong in the same way where you're gonna get a half a giggle out of remote wiping their computer and that's

0:06:56That's all you need

0:06:58Yeah, that's just that's that's just the mindset. But the thing about it is like

0:07:02so we all heard this story and I think

0:07:06First thing everyone's looking for like what can I do to prevent this happening to me?

0:07:10That's why we all read all these details about how this is a kind of ad and you know

0:07:14Like is there something I can do to my setup to make it so this can't happen to me

0:07:19I think the worst part of the story is

0:07:21There's probably nothing you can do to stop something similar happening to you

0:07:26not the exact same thing but something similar because

0:07:29All you can do is have good backups obviously, but ignoring having good backups

0:07:34Everything else is like things that aren't under our control

0:07:37We don't control Amazon's policy for recovering your credit card or Apple's policy for how to reset like we don't control any of that stuff

0:07:44And so there's nothing it doesn't seem we seem powerless because like I have good passwords. They're all different

0:07:50Have like having a backup email account seems like a good thing

0:07:54I have you know if I ever need to recover I've got my backup email account like everything seems to be good and then

0:07:59Where we end up getting screwed is because of things that other people did that we can't control they probably never even thought of right

0:08:05Like Google for example really really encourages you to have a backup email account

0:08:09But in fact if he didn't he would have been better off

0:08:12Right or if it had been something other than you know a different service that didn't have as exploitable

0:08:19Rules for a password recovery, and this kind of gets back to the question of you know the getting your what is your first?

0:08:25pet's name and stuff like that. The idea that there's all this security, but the weak link

0:08:29and the security is the thing that's there because we all forget our passwords, and that's like,

0:08:34"Oh, I forgot my password. How do I recover it?" And the things that you use to recover it are so

0:08:39much less secure than every other part of the system. It's just the most glaring weak link.

0:08:44I mean, then why is it I'll ask you, "What is your first name? What is your last name?"

0:08:47Like, it's so easy to find that information.

0:08:50And just, you know, just tell me the truth. Is it really you? Right, like, you know, if you

0:08:54pinky, if you pinky swear, you can get your account. And I, I recognize why that's the case.

0:08:58But it seems almost perverse. It's like, it's easier. You know, it's easier than remembering

0:09:03your password, remembering simple demographic information about yourself and looking in your

0:09:07wallet for two seconds at your credit card. And that's all you need to get into these accounts

0:09:10if you're willing to sit on that phone for two seconds. So. Right. And I have to admit,

0:09:15at a certain selfish level, one of the things I was looking at over the weekend is this

0:09:19excuse me, as this situation exploded was I remember thinking I kind of hope that Honan

0:09:27did something stupid at some point along the way. Like, you know, figures out that it, you know,

0:09:32like he logged into his Gmail on a, you know, library, public library computer or something

0:09:41like that, like something that I would never do, so that I then I could think,

0:09:49well, that couldn't happen to me. Whereas I kind of think, yeah, it might be.

0:09:59I don't know. I don't know that anybody could take over my Twitter

0:10:02account the way that they did. I don't think I have a chain of email accounts

0:10:07that's connected to Gmail like that. But I'm not 100% sure. But somebody certainly could have

0:10:16or even still could take over my iCloud account the same way.

0:10:22**Matt Stauffer** Yeah. Well, not anymore because of that.

0:10:25**Ezra Kleinman** Right. And Amazon has as well.

0:10:28**Matt Stauffer** Yeah. And the one thing in this story is I think

0:10:30Amazon decision to display the stars and then the last four digits of their credit card,

0:10:36I don't think you should ding them for that because that's been standard practice forever

0:10:39Starting out everything the last four digits

0:10:42the flaw is not that Amazon shows you last word is the flaw is an Amazon's customer service allowing you to reset passwords and

0:10:48Secondarily an Apple saying oh you just need to give me the last four digits because I don't want you to read the all the

0:10:53Digits over the phone because that would be insecure or whatever like that's crazy

0:10:57Where you just need the last four digits as to prove that you're you it's not I don't I don't blame

0:11:02Amazon at all for showing the credit cards the way they did everything else yes, there's plenty of blame to go around for that one part

0:11:08I don't think people should get hung up on right and a prayer yeah, and so am an Amazon

0:11:12I think has an easier fix where I just don't think that they should allow like you said they shouldn't allow

0:11:17That stuff to be changed over the phone like that

0:11:20And particularly not oh you know

0:11:23It's so disconnected where you give them a credit card, and they say okay went to them

0:11:28And you call back and say hey, I just got locked out

0:11:30here's my credit card number that you just gave them and there's no awareness that you just gave

0:11:33them to that it doesn't have to be a credit card that you use like their verifications procedure

0:11:37for proving who you are is similarly bogus that it's gamed so easily by call give a fake number

0:11:43hang up call back right it certainly shouldn't be possible to do it with a credit card that

0:11:48like if you want to say this is my new credit card and that they want to enter it without actually

0:11:52running a charge that's okay but it should still somehow be flagged as okay there's a new credit

0:11:58card here, but this is an unverified card that hasn't even had a charge run against

0:12:01it yet.

0:12:02Or just have an awareness that this guy just called two minutes ago, or yesterday, or whatever,

0:12:06and has called to add this card.

0:12:10Not a lot of thought has gone into those recovery procedures.

0:12:13And I understand the recovery procedures have to be easy, because look, these guys couldn't

0:12:17even remember their password.

0:12:18We got to make it so easy.

0:12:19Can you imagine the turmoil if they had policies that were more like you'd forget your password

0:12:25and you'd call them up and you're like, "I can't prove to these people that I am who

0:12:27I am like they want my passport and I have to show up in person and give a blood sample like I don't know

0:12:33It's ridiculous. I can't get my account unlock. They won't believe that I am. Oh, yeah, my totally am like that is bad PR

0:12:38It's also they go to the other way and they say okay

0:12:41well

0:12:41We'll just ask them some basic stuff and ask them some

0:12:44Security question that anyone could Google the answer to and you know

0:12:47Maybe something about their credit card or just the expiration date or some stuff like that

0:12:51So people come out of that experience like oh, I forgot my password. I call customer service. It was so nice

0:12:55It was so easy. I got right back in

0:12:57That's 99.99% of the time.

0:13:00Those policies put good feelings on customers and how easy it was for them to recover their

0:13:05account.

0:13:06But this 1% is a doozy.

0:13:07Right.

0:13:08And I can sort of see.

0:13:09And so I think bottom line is that Apple really had the procedure in place that deserves the

0:13:14most criticism, where being able to get your iCloud account or Apple ID, I should say,

0:13:19because it's any kind of Apple ID, not just an iCloud account.

0:13:22you can get your Apple ID password reset just with your name, home address, and last four

0:13:30digits of a credit card really seems like glaringly insecure.

0:13:35Like when I wrote about it, you'd never write your password on a piece of paper and put

0:13:40it in your – or at least most people wouldn't do it and keep it in your wallet.

0:13:45But anybody who picks up my wallet has my home address and the last four digits of all

0:13:49my credit cards.

0:13:50I mean, and so, I mean, obviously you're in a lot of trouble if some, you know, no good

0:13:54nick has your wallet, but you shouldn't be thinking, like if I lost my wallet or I suspected

0:14:00somebody stole it, I would never think, well, now they've got my iCloud account.

0:14:04But in fact, according to the, you know, by their previous procedures, they would.

0:14:08Yeah.

0:14:09And it's the worst because that is the power of the Apple ID has just vastly increased

0:14:14over time.

0:14:15Like at first it was like, you can buy stuff from iTunes.

0:14:17That's bad enough.

0:14:18Right.

0:14:19iCloud and you can remote wipe those machines and then extend it to Macs and so like finally

0:14:23iCloud became powerful enough to control any piece of hardware anyway if so configured

0:14:28and this poor guy just after that happened gets hacked and they just they reach out and

0:14:33they just wipe all his hardware which is such a crazy thing you would expect like oh they

0:14:36have to break into each thing or whatever no they just get that one little key to the

0:14:39kingdom and over the network wherever you are wherever these things are they can go

0:14:44I mean you're really once you're in fine once you're in find my iPhone you're

0:14:48you're I don't know six clicks away from wiping out all three of the devices yeah

0:14:54so I I don't know what what they should do I know everybody a lot of people a

0:15:01lot of thing a lot of publicity and in response to this is about Google's

0:15:05optional two-factor authentication you know which I don't use even in and after

0:15:13this because it just seems like a pain in the ass.

0:15:16Yeah, I wonder if that would have helped though because if you had your backup email address

0:15:20as your Mac.com thing, would that be the two-factor?

0:15:23I don't think the two-factor lets you use email.

0:15:25I think it has to be like a phone or something.

0:15:27Well, two-factor is for just getting in, but what if you can't get into the two-factor

0:15:32thing?

0:15:33I thought you could go, "Okay, I've totally forgotten.

0:15:35You send something to my backup email address."

0:15:37Isn't that the point of the backup?

0:15:38It's like the last resort?

0:15:39But I think if you turn if think if you'd sign up for the two-factor authentication at Google then

0:15:44You can't reset your account that way

0:15:47Yeah, I mean the one thing I did in response to the story was changed my backup email address on Google to not be

0:15:55One of my various Apple IDs. Mmm

0:15:58There's only predictions old people have is we have multiple Apple IDs for historical reasons and you know that helps a little bit

0:16:07security through obscurity, but yeah, I changed it to not be my my because so then

0:16:11like because your main email address is really like the keys to the kingdom because that's always like associated with all of your accounts and

0:16:17You can send the password resets there. So that really has to be super protected and I've many times

0:16:21I've considered putting two-factor auth on my gmail account

0:16:23But it just seems too annoying to me

0:16:27Maybe I should just try it for a while to see if it really is annoying

0:16:30But it's especially annoying to me because I don't even have an iPhone. So I got my crap phone and

0:16:34Do I really want to be making sure my crap phone is charged and it has a signal and I can look at the little

0:16:39code and I don't know

0:16:41Maybe I'll try it someday. But but anyway, like, you know, I would have been more motivated motivated to do that. There was some sort of

0:16:46Password hack or something or really it's just it's customer service policies that that bit him, right?

0:16:53And I can also see how I you know, it was a mistake and not clearly somebody with a good

0:16:59suspicious hardened

0:17:02Security mindset didn't really look at these procedures that Apple had in place

0:17:06But from a customer support standpoint you could see I mean who knows who only knows who can only guess how many people call

0:17:13Apple every honest people with the honest problem that they don't remember their iCloud password

0:17:18Who need to just need it reset?

0:17:22I mean who knows I mean I wouldn't be surprised if it's a huge number

0:17:26Yeah

0:17:27When they say social engineering you think it's like someone who's a smooth talker kind of cajoled somebody into doing something

0:17:32they weren't supposed to or whatever, but this was a case of they were just going right down,

0:17:35they were totally within the guidelines. They didn't have to sweet talk anybody. They didn't

0:17:39have to make a sob story. And I bet those sob stories work. Like I bet, you know, if you're

0:17:43really convincing and you're just like, oh, it's an emergency or I need this right now, you know,

0:17:47I don't remember my home address. Can you, you know, or if you can be convincing, not that I

0:17:51remember my home address, but if you can be convincing in that way, that's what you think

0:17:54of when you're social engineering. This wasn't social engineering. This was just a normal

0:17:58Customer services a call that proceeded exactly as expected right? That's that's the really scary part, right?

0:18:04Yeah, it wasn't like this was you know, the world's greatest con man

0:18:07really pulling a clever a

0:18:11Clever scam over the support rep. Yeah, it was just right it also seems to me and this isn't is so clear from

0:18:18Honan's reporting on it, which has been copious, you know, he did a really good thorough write-up of it for wired the

0:18:24day or two later

0:18:27But I got the impression from his back and forth with the one of the hackers who got him

0:18:33That

0:18:37This seems like at least in certain underground circles seemed to be widely known that you can take over at

0:18:44An Apple ID pretty easily if you can get those things yeah

0:18:49This is the type of thing that would be widely known because it just doesn't require any technical skills. It's just simply you know a

0:18:56Not very well kept secret among people who are in these circles that here here are the easy ways to

0:19:00Exploit customer service policies to get access to people's accounts and hacking required and so I you know one of the floods I've had

0:19:08In the week since is that I've seen a lot of reports over the last year or two

0:19:12Not a ton but enough that I've seen it. It's like a

0:19:16Something that's repeated that people getting their iTunes account hacked and they're swear up and down that they used a unique password

0:19:24never put it into with somebody else's computer and it just doesn't make any

0:19:31sense how their account got hacked. And there was the stories like oh this is a

0:19:38well-known hack and Apple's addressing it maybe if it was all customer service

0:19:42stuff. I wonder though because it and my first thought was I bet that maybe

0:19:45that's the source of this is that there's people who you know that who use

0:19:49this this address and four digits of a credit card combined maybe with the

0:19:53Amazon thing to do that but I would think that Apple would be able to and

0:19:59Apple's publicly at least has brushed these off by saying you know with you

0:20:03know that their response when people write in and say look my account was

0:20:06hacked was that you know you should be more careful with your password blah

0:20:09blah blah more or less kind of blaming them assuming that it was somehow the

0:20:14users fault that for leaking their password but I would think if there was

0:20:17a pattern where these people who called and said my account got hacked and their

0:20:22account records show that they had one of these phone calls where they got the

0:20:27account changed presumably recently, right? I mean I don't think any of these

0:20:32hackers if their goal is to do things like buy $100 worth of apps from your

0:20:39iTunes account it's not like they're changing your password and then doing it

0:20:46two months later because you're gonna notice right away because all of a

0:20:49of a sudden you can't get into your iTunes account.

0:20:51Presumably they change the password and immediately use it.

0:20:55You would think that that pattern would be detectable

0:20:57in your records that hey, these people all called up

0:21:00and had their password changed right before

0:21:02they then claimed to be hacked.

0:21:04- It's the same as the Amazon situation though

0:21:06where you call up, add a credit card, hang up,

0:21:07call right back and say I can't get into my account.

0:21:09Like there probably is a lack of global awareness

0:21:13of what has happened in the past to this customer.

0:21:16I mean, you always say, let me pull up your record here

0:21:18before you talk to it and you expect them to see a record of all the times you've called,

0:21:21but maybe that's not happening.

0:21:24Obviously it's not happening in the Amazon case where they're not pulling up your thing

0:21:27and saying, "You just called two minutes ago to add this credit card.

0:21:29Now you're reading the number back to me."

0:21:31Anyone can see that that's weird.

0:21:33So you're just assuming that they would realize that, "Oh, all these people who got hacked,

0:21:39well, I can look from their records and they all did this password."

0:21:41Maybe they don't even see that.

0:21:42Maybe it's not even the same people.

0:21:43Maybe they don't have access to that record.

0:21:45Who knows?

0:21:46You can't tell.

0:21:47The other alternative is that Apple knew and was trying to cover it up, but I don't see

0:21:50why they would do that because it's so easy to change that policy.

0:21:53As we see, they changed the policy.

0:21:55It's not rocket science.

0:21:56It's not like they need to patch some piece of software.

0:21:58They just say, "Okay, new policy, everybody.

0:22:01Don't do that anymore."

0:22:02Right.

0:22:03It's a hard problem to solve, though, because what should they do?

0:22:05What should they do to let you reset your password if you forget it?

0:22:09Yeah.

0:22:10I mean, you could go with the full credit card number if it's a credit card that's actually

0:22:14been used.

0:22:15That's not good though, because I don't think it should be information that you can

0:22:19get by stealing somebody's wallet.

0:22:21Well, I mean, it's got – the thing with the two-factor is like something you have

0:22:24versus something you know and all the different things that you can use to authenticate.

0:22:28But when they've forgotten their password and if you don't have any other shared piece

0:22:33of information with them, all you can do to prove that you're you is give them information

0:22:38they already have about you.

0:22:39There's no new information you can give them to prove that you're you.

0:22:43You can only, I mean, maybe what you could do in the fantasy world type thing is when

0:22:49you create your account, have a photo have to be associated with the account, and when

0:22:55you try to recover your thing, they can do a video chat with you, which we currently

0:22:58don't quite have the technology to fake.

0:23:00They ask you questions and you talk to them and they can see that it's really you.

0:23:03Then your twin brother can break into your account, I guess, but that's kind of more

0:23:06of a family problem.

0:23:09Stuff like that.

0:23:10What else can you really do?

0:23:11They all they know about you is what they have on file and if you can parrot back every piece of that information to them

0:23:16Then what else do they have?

0:23:18So I think photos and video is that the only next place that can go and beyond that it has to be some sort of

0:23:23Two factor thing. I know I've gotten credit cards before

0:23:28Where like when the new credit card comes you have to call to activate it and that only works if you call from the phone

0:23:35Number that they have on a file for you. Yeah, I

0:23:39Don't know how much your phone can be, you know

0:23:42And I know that's how partly least partly how Google's two-factor authentication works is assuming that you have a phone number that can be trusted

0:23:48Yeah, that's that's the something you have. What do you have? I have my cell phone. I have my home phone

0:23:52I have possession of the home from which this number

0:23:55I mean, it's not people don't have landlines as much anymore, but it's it's it's the something you have thing there

0:23:59I had a similar situation

0:24:00I don't know if you saw these tweets from like the other week when I was going in to pick up my monitor at the Apple

0:24:04Store. Yeah, I did and I forgot my wallet

0:24:08and they said oh, sorry, we can't give you your computer without your wallet and and

0:24:12What I thought of was look you've got my information on file

0:24:16Why don't you just call the telephone number?

0:24:19Associated with with you know this repair and my wife will answer the phone and she'll

0:24:24Tell you that I just left to go to the Apple store and she'll talk to me on the phone and confirm that it's to

0:24:28You that it's like right? What's more secure than that?

0:24:30Like anyone can get a wallet and a photo ID and who knows the picture they even look at the picture if it looks

0:24:36Particularly like me or anything like that anyway

0:24:39Yeah, that's much easier to fake then you have this telephone number on file that I gave you when I drop the thing off

0:24:44Why would I you know if someone had my wife a gun pointed home so they can get a new 27 inch monitor?

0:24:49But they wouldn't accept that

0:24:51And nor would they accept the other things that I suggested which was like a

0:24:54Google for my name or other people said how about you just sign in with your Apple ID like there's an Apple ID

0:24:59Associated with this repair if I can sign in with that does that prove it as me nope photo ID only

0:25:05So I have to go back home and get a photo ID and then I know I don't know I know the kicker

0:25:09Yeah, the guy doesn't even ask me for it. I think I said silent the whole time. I'm like

0:25:15Tell him what I hear he goes back

0:25:17It's a thing gives it to me puts it back in the box all packed up

0:25:20He says alright, so you're all set like I just wanted to make sure that he wasn't waiting till the very end to say okay

0:25:24Oh, yeah, let me see that photo. We had nothing I

0:25:26Can't it was like you know

0:25:28I just went home to get my photo ID and then now you didn't even ask for it

0:25:32So I recognize you from when you dropped it off. I

0:25:34Did I didn't recognize him he wasn't the guy who helped me and he wasn't I didn't see him when I first came

0:25:39Where were you killing me? Where was he half an hour ago? Yeah

0:25:42But there's a similar situation where you're gonna hand somebody especially like it was a warranty repair

0:25:49So it's free you're gonna hand somebody a potentially expensive piece of hardware

0:25:52just because they told you like their name and

0:25:55That there's something waiting for them and they want some way to show that you're you and that

0:26:00That's even weirder because when you drop it off,

0:26:03they don't think they take the photo ID.

0:26:04I don't remember.

0:26:05Maybe someone will send you angry emails and say they do,

0:26:07but that's what they go with, photo identification.

0:26:12So it seems like for online,

0:26:14it has to be something similar where either they're relying

0:26:16on your physical appearance and things that are difficult

0:26:19to fake, not so much a photo,

0:26:20but a video of you talking or something you have,

0:26:23which is your cell phone or your home phone

0:26:24or something like that that they can show that,

0:26:27"Yeah, I have this information."

0:26:28And you may know the information that we have on file here,

0:26:31but let's prove it's really you.

0:26:32I'm gonna call the phone number on here

0:26:34and you better answer it to show that it's really you.

0:26:36- Only other thing I can think of that could verify stuff

0:26:42like that would be like your home address.

0:26:46Like that seems pretty secure,

0:26:47but then you don't get fast turnaround.

0:26:49Like maybe they could--

0:26:50- Send you a piece of mail.

0:26:51- Right, they'll send you a piece of mail

0:26:53and the mail would contain like a, you know,

0:26:57some kind of keyword or something like a unique and then you have to call Apple

0:27:00and read the keyword and then you know you could get your account back but you

0:27:04know I customer service wise the three or four day turnaround on that is you

0:27:09know it's intolerant flip out yeah people would flip out it would be like

0:27:12there would be a story in the New York Times and within two days of that policy

0:27:17going to affect it's got to be electronic it's got to be immediate but

0:27:21it also has to be secure right now and I guess I would be negligent if I didn't

0:27:26mentioned that the recent act didn't Apple recently acquire on of the URL handy they just bought like a fingerprint ID company

0:27:33Yeah, and that's that's not good tweet about that

0:27:35I forget who it was saying that if if this this hack had happened two days earlier before the acquisition

0:27:42The acquisition would have been read would have been reported as a desperate move by Apple to shore up its security resources

0:27:47I didn't think of that but that is true. That's totally true

0:27:50Apple that story dodged the bullet just by by mere days

0:27:56Right because everybody wants to see cause and effect. All right. Yeah

0:27:59Yeah, that would have been huge. That would have been absolutely huge and then it would have been that, you know

0:28:04And it got a regular amount of well

0:28:06This means Apple must be adding fingerprint ID to phones and trackpad soon or whatever, but it would have been deafening

0:28:11It would have been like iPhone 5 is gonna have a fingerprint ID scan all because of that Matt Horner

0:28:16They was you know

0:28:17What happened is he got hacked and then 24 hours later they acquired a company for several million dollars because that's how those deals work

0:28:22All right, so he wakes up and said what Matt Horan was hacked by the fingerprint company the next day. It's bought

0:28:28It's done. I will say this though in terms of coincidences and cause and effect and thinking maybe you know

0:28:34This might be related somehow tonight just a few hours ago. I got a direct message from

0:28:39at verified

0:28:42Then it's the Twitter verified accounts

0:28:45Account and the direct message said that Twitter wanted to verify my Twitter account and click this URL

0:28:52Sure, rub it in. Go ahead.

0:28:54And I click it, and you have to answer like three questions, and then all of a sudden

0:28:59now I've got the little blue stamp up there on my Twitter account.

0:29:03And you get recognized at Apple stores, and your Twitter account is verified. It's all

0:29:06right. I'll handle it.

0:29:07You know what? Getting recognized at Apple stores is no good.

0:29:10I don't ask for it, but it's just one time it would have actually helped me.

0:29:13Yeah, that's true.

0:29:14It's the one time that it would have saved me, you know.

0:29:16You should have had him call me. I would have vouched for you.

0:29:18Oh, that would be the worst. That's the worst.

0:29:22Well, Krewberry will tell you that to me.

0:29:25So what did Twitter ask you?

0:29:26Well, you know what?

0:29:27And the funny thing is, it's not really – they're not really assuming that – they say – here's

0:29:32what they say when you – this is how you get verified.

0:29:33They say you're going to answer three questions.

0:29:35And I'm thinking – I'm so suspicious and paranoid.

0:29:38I was already thinking –

0:29:39This is a scam.

0:29:40Number one, I was thinking when the direct message came in that it was a scam.

0:29:42And I was hesitant to click the link and –

0:29:45Because you don't follow at verified.

0:29:46So how did they DM you?

0:29:48That's a very good question.

0:29:51And in fact, I don't know.

0:29:53And –

0:29:54Well, their Twitter, they can do whatever the hell they want.

0:29:55Exactly.

0:29:56But it was the weirdest DM I ever got because it showed up on my Mac in the tweetbot alpha

0:30:02and I went – just I don't even know why because I was so suspicious about this whole

0:30:06thing.

0:30:07I went to my iPhone and opened the official Twitter client and looked for it there and

0:30:11it wasn't there.

0:30:12And I like waited a couple of minutes and reloaded and it didn't come.

0:30:17And I started thinking like, "Whoa, that's weird.

0:30:18What the hell is going on?"

0:30:19That never happens.

0:30:20sometimes there's 30 seconds of latency between one client or another with DMs.

0:30:24They're not real-time, but they're not two, three, four minutes apart just

0:30:30because you're on a different client. Then I logged in to twitter.com, the

0:30:34website, which I think is, I think most people would agree, is probably the

0:30:37canonical interface to Twitter. Yeah, I always go there when I have a doubt. Right, and so I

0:30:41went there and the DM wasn't there either, and now I'm thinking, now this is

0:30:45weird, this is really, now I'm like, this is crazy. But then within like another two,

0:30:50Three four minutes it did show up everywhere. Yeah, I've seen that with DMS like I

0:30:54Frequently very frequently pretty much all the time get the email

0:30:58I still have emails for DMS get the email response that I've got a DM before I see it in most of my clients

0:31:03But yeah bottom line is they they have it's their their verified accounts account has a superpower that it can send DMS to whoever

0:31:12They want

0:31:13The three questions though are not about verifying you it's and it makes sense in hindsight

0:31:18It has nothing to do with that because they're not suspicious

0:31:21That I'm not that at my accounts been hacked, right? They already you know, I mean

0:31:27All they asked me and it's so silly is they ask you a series of three questions of which tweet is better and it's so

0:31:35obviously

0:31:37Geared toward the assumption that you are some sort of pop culture celebrity

0:31:43know that you're like a pop culture celebrity and it's like which tweet is better and

0:31:47One on the one side. There's a fake a fake Twitter account saying

0:31:51watching the Oscars

0:31:53Like with a hashtag like washing the hashtag Oscars on ABC

0:31:58Loving the fashions on the red carpet and then the other one is

0:32:02watched the Oscars last night and

0:32:05And then you vote you pick obviously the right answer is the one where you're doing it live

0:32:11And then you click that and it says correct what you know tweeting things while they're happening is much more engaging with your fans than

0:32:19Tweeting things after the fact well, so the question is if you had gotten these quote-unquote wrong

0:32:25What would have happened? I don't have a verified account

0:32:28I thought about trying that with the third one and you know and the third one's the same

0:32:32It was like is it better you know the difference is is it better to tweet with pictures or not with pictures?

0:32:36It's like you know hanging out with something something

0:32:39And then there's a pic dot twitter dot something URL and the other one is just hanging out with someone someone

0:32:45And I thought of obviously the one of the picture is supposed to be the one I thought about clicking the other one

0:32:49I think that they just tell you the answer. I'm guessing I don't think it's a test and they're not gonna let you in

0:32:54I think you click the wrong one and they say wrong

0:32:57It's actually better to tweet with pictures and now you're allowed to be verified

0:33:00That's weird like well first of all the verification process is weird because you like you would imagine. They're going like

0:33:07Sorted by a number of followers descending and they just got down to like the hundred K's or whatever you're at

0:33:12All right

0:33:13Like they started with like the 20 million people like Ashton Kutcher or whatever and they're working their way down

0:33:17So the poor team or guy or whatever whose job it is to verify accounts like boy now

0:33:21Really scraping the bottom of the barrel because they're done with the actual like real

0:33:25celebrities with millions and millions of followers and they're down to like the Mac nerd guys and

0:33:29Then like so how do they know that this is the John Gruber kind of this?

0:33:32It was just because they're Twitter guys and they were also happen to be computer nerds and they know who you are

0:33:36Yeah, I guess so. I can only guess. There wasn't really any sort of actual, like if

0:33:44@Gruber had been run by someone for years impersonating me, there was no, you know,

0:33:50no, I mean, I don't know. I don't know how they would do it.

0:33:52I mean, well, verified as being who? Like, say it was run by years. Maybe they're not

0:33:56impersonating you. Maybe it's just some other guy named John Gruber. And like, you know,

0:33:59all that, all your vari-, like, what are you even verifying? Because it's weird to me.

0:34:03If there is a famous celebrity, internationally known celebrity like Tom Cruise,

0:34:07you want to verify that the account that says Tom Cruise is really the account of Tom Cruise.

0:34:13But when you get down to people who like everyone in the world doesn't know who they are,

0:34:17what are you even verifying?

0:34:19Yeah, I'm not quite sure.

0:34:21What I think is you're about to be monetized. That's what I think.

0:34:24For the bill, it's going to be like, "Hey, John Gruber, verified celebrity.

0:34:27Would you like to keep your verified account at Twitter? Well, consider sending it."

0:34:30I mean, actually that may be welcome, you know.

0:34:33Finally, you have a business model.

0:34:35I'll pay you.

0:34:36Just stop trying to show ads.

0:34:38I don't know.

0:34:39I don't know.

0:34:41The other thing I don't know and I haven't had a chance because it just happened a few

0:34:43hours ago, but I'm wondering now if it's going to be – if it's harder for me to reset my

0:34:47password.

0:34:50I don't know.

0:34:51Like, all I can think is that this has something to do with the Honan thing and that they like

0:34:55went and found people who are similar to Matt Honan who don't have verified accounts and

0:34:59or verify them.

0:35:00Yeah, but how does that help?

0:35:02Yeah, I guess you have to try that.

0:35:04All that would do is reinforce when the hackers take over your account.

0:35:07Like, no, that's totally John Gruber saying those terrible things.

0:35:09It's use a verified account.

0:35:11Well, presumably being verified is extremely rare.

0:35:14I would guess a sliver, a tiny little sliver of a thousandth of a percent of Twitter accounts.

0:35:21Because you can't choose.

0:35:22There's no way.

0:35:23You can't go in and ask to be verified.

0:35:25There is no way.

0:35:26That's what I'm saying.

0:35:27Starting with the celebrities and they just say they just sort by followers

0:35:30And you're you're still in the very tiny tippy edge of that long tail out there, right?

0:35:35but it's so rare that I'm wondering that if you call up with a

0:35:38account password thing and and you know

0:35:41Whoever you get or whoever helps people with with those type of problems with Twitter that if it's shows up as verified

0:35:47It goes into like a white gloves department

0:35:50Yeah, or they ask you the same questions about which tweet is better and you say shut up and reset my password

0:35:56I don't know

0:35:57Yeah, do you like the dick bar?

0:35:59Yes, or no one of the questions they ask you

0:36:02What's your favorite hashtag?

0:36:04Yeah, I guess

0:36:05Speaking of making money into the app net thing like the same same reason we're all desperate for something to happen

0:36:12There is because we don't see Twitter

0:36:13Being able or willing to make money in the way we think they should and like I made a joke about verified account

0:36:19Costing you money, but like isn't that isn't that how you would prefer to pay for Twitter

0:36:24Yeah, versus having to see ads yeah or something or all third-party clients dying

0:36:29I mean you've got to make that choice you'd say you pay in a second

0:36:32I was on the fence with I did I signed up for apt on that soon after it was announced. I became a backer

0:36:37But I was on the fence about promoting it on daring fireball, but I just did right before we started recording tonight

0:36:44I actually linked it up and encouraged people to sign up because then I saw their spam email got to you

0:36:51And that actually I did that actually had nothing to do with that. I've actually been watching it

0:36:56Through I don't forget how long ago they launched it, but I've been watching it and thinking if it gets close

0:37:02Maybe I'll see if I can help him out a little but I'm a guy and I know I've helped Kickstarter projects out before

0:37:08I don't think that I can even come close to helping raise that they're like $300,000 sure

0:37:13Yeah, this is the email said is that everybody who currently backs a service got three of their friends to sign up

0:37:19They'll make it and that's that's a tall order with a few days to go

0:37:22And I don't know what they're gonna do

0:37:26It's a weird thing and and I know that you've talked about it on

0:37:30Hypercritical you did talk about apt on that. I know you talked about

0:37:33Along with penny arcade and stuff. Yep, and it is weird. It's a weird situation a it's weird because it's not even really

0:37:42Kickstarter they like built their own

0:37:45Kickstarter because they had to they weren't they didn't fit in the Kickstarter rules, right? Is that why they did it?

0:37:50I didn't yeah, that's in the fact

0:37:51I said basically we would have been a Kickstarter but we can't because it says you can't use Kickstarter to start a business and that's what

0:37:55We're doing. So right. That's that

0:37:57hmm

0:38:00And you know, it doesn't necessarily mean that if they fall short that they're just gonna pack it in and throw it out and not

0:38:06Do anything? I don't know what I don't know what their plan B is

0:38:09Well, that was that I convinced a friend of mine to sign up for it today. In fact doing my part to

0:38:14to help them reach their funding goal.

0:38:17And what I thought the deal was,

0:38:19and I didn't bother to check

0:38:20'cause I guess I don't care enough,

0:38:21is that if they don't reach their goal,

0:38:23nobody gets charged.

0:38:24So like I pledged $50 or whatever,

0:38:26but that just means if we get our goal,

0:38:28then we charge everyone's credit cards or whatever.

0:38:30But if we don't get our goal, no one loses any money.

0:38:32That's the secret Kickstarter is that

0:38:34it eliminates the risk

0:38:35that you're dumping your money down a hole.

0:38:37It's like you're excited by the fact

0:38:39that they're gonna reach their goal.

0:38:40But if they don't, yeah, you do not add any money.

0:38:43That was one of the interesting things about the penny arcade thing is that their big goal

0:38:46was so far down, but to be fully funded, it was like 250K and they reached that in the

0:38:51first day or two.

0:38:52But that's not what everybody wanted.

0:38:53So as soon as they reached that first limit, everyone's money is gone.

0:38:57And then people aren't really motivated to...

0:38:59It would rather have, "Wow, this audacious goal.

0:39:02Let's everyone put their money towards it.

0:39:03And if we get it, we'll be so excited that we won't care that we all just got charged."

0:39:06Versus, "Everyone give me your money and I would like $500,000, but if I reach $1,000,

0:39:12you're all getting charged."

0:39:13That scares people away. I should probably revise my little write-up and emphasize that part that yeah

0:39:18Kicking in 50 bucks is is definitely not and it you know 50 bucks is not a cup of coffee

0:39:23That's that's a significant. You know right no. I mean. I don't know maybe there's somebody out there

0:39:28I guess there's some people who throw 50 bucks around like loose change, but you know 50 bucks to me is something you really think about

0:39:34But you're it is sort of no risk in terms of you're only gonna get charged if you're going to get a

0:39:42a app.net service that will work. You're not going to throw your $50 in and, ooh, they fell short,

0:39:49your $50 is gone and you don't even get the app.net. Well, before you write that up,

0:39:53you should actually look it up because I didn't bother looking it up either. You go to their

0:39:56website and look at the little fine print and it says what actually happens here. And the thing is,

0:40:00even if they're fully funded and they get 500K, that still doesn't guarantee that their service

0:40:04will ever come to the hill of beans. You know, like they could make the service and then no one

0:40:08shows up and it just kind of fizzles away. But the fact that we're all willing to put

0:40:12money behind this thing means that we want – not so much that we want something like

0:40:16this but it's like we wish Twitter had a monetization strategy that made us feel more

0:40:21comfortable. We all hate the scary stuff with the third-party clients going away. We don't

0:40:25like ads. We didn't like the dick bar. There's so much about Twitter that's just bugging

0:40:30us.

0:40:31The way that in all of their first-party interfaces, the web, their apps and everything where they're

0:40:37putting all this emphasis on the trends.

0:40:40And also the card interface where you have these expanded tweets with all sorts of other

0:40:45data.

0:40:46Right, right.

0:40:47Where all of a sudden one tweet can take up the whole length of your screen.

0:40:49Yeah, it's like a little miniature webpage.

0:40:52That's not what we want out of that.

0:40:54The only time I want that is when Merlin Mann tweets one with a bunch of returns.

0:40:59Once a month I'm going to put 40 carriage returns in here before the punchline tweet.

0:41:03Yeah.

0:41:04Yeah, he likes the vertical space.

0:41:06He's a small man, though.

0:41:08He may be compensating.

0:41:09Well, and the big difference – there is actually a big difference in there, no joking

0:41:12aside, which is that if that gag from Merlin truly annoys you enough, you just one –

0:41:17You just unfollow him.

0:41:18Your one click away from – the unfollow button is right there.

0:41:21Whereas when promoted tweets and embedded – what do they call them?

0:41:25Cards?

0:41:26Whatever they call them.

0:41:27Yeah, I think it's called cards.

0:41:28Right.

0:41:29If they annoy you, tough luck.

0:41:30That's coming right out of Twitter HQ.

0:41:32I think the cards are also for like,

0:41:34say you have someone that you follow and they post,

0:41:37they say, "Check out this funny YouTube video."

0:41:39Instead of that being like a two line text email

0:41:42with a link, now it'll embed the YouTube video

0:41:46right there in your timeline

0:41:47if you're using one of their clients.

0:41:49And you're like, "I don't want, I like that guy.

0:41:51"I like his links, I like the videos he provides,

0:41:52"but I don't want that video embedded

0:41:54"and to start downloading and taking up seven inches

0:41:57"of vertical screen space on my device.

0:41:59"Like that's not how I wanna consume Twitter."

0:42:01Because that just start like,

0:42:02What if they just started previewing all web pages that way?

0:42:05People are writing less than 140 characters

0:42:07and what they're producing is, you know,

0:42:09on an iPad an entire screen full of crap.

0:42:11It's like, I'll tap the link if I wanna see it.

0:42:13Don't inline it.

0:42:14Like that type of interface where individual websites

0:42:17pay to have tweets that reference their URLs

0:42:20expanded into this big monster thing.

0:42:22Like say IMDB paid them

0:42:23and anytime I ever mentioned Tom Cruise,

0:42:25it put four inches of information about Tom Cruise

0:42:27and a little headshot and links to other stuff

0:42:29underneath it.

0:42:30And like, you don't wanna unfollow somebody

0:42:31They mentioned Tom Cruise, but now all their tweets are annoying the hell out of you because they because of this IMDB connection

0:42:36That's the Twitter's monetization strategy don't charge the customers charge these websites to crap up everyone else's timeline, but their stuff all right

0:42:44And I like you know there's certain ways that tweet tweets obviously even in the third-party clients that we like they've they've grown past

0:42:53Just pure text

0:42:55Like most most of the clients I know of like if you embed a picture from known services

0:43:01because the picture can be right there in the tweet, but they don't show you the whole

0:43:04thing. It's always like a thumbnail, right? At least the ones I use, like Tweetbot and

0:43:08-- well, I just use Tweetbot, really.

0:43:11>> And that's up to the client software.

0:43:13>> Right. It's up to -- that's the other thing. It's up to the client software, and they can

0:43:17add a feature. So, like, Tweetbot -- and I think -- but I think, like, you know, I think

0:43:21Tweety used to do this in Twitter's client, is they'll just show a little thumbnail of

0:43:24the image, and if you want to see it, you tap it, and then you see it big. But that

0:43:28if you're just scrolling through your tweets, even a tweet with a pictured link in it isn't

0:43:32going to take up more room than a regular tweet.

0:43:36That's the Twitter's big thing about making a consistent experience.

0:43:39What that means is like in the current scenario, if you don't like how Tweetbot puts a thumbnail

0:43:43image in because it makes your timeline too big and annoying, you try a different client

0:43:47that doesn't do that, right?

0:43:48You have choice, whereas consistent client experience means no, no, no, if the clients

0:43:53even exist, they don't get to choose how that appears.

0:43:55We choose how it appears and all clients must obey.

0:43:57Like on this Twitter cards page, it's dev/Twitter.com/docs/cards.

0:44:01It shows someone linking to a New York Times story.

0:44:04And the thing, the tweet they show is, "That's a whole lot of people..." and then a New York

0:44:09Times short URL, right?

0:44:11But then underneath it, it has the headline, the byline, a picture, a link to the New York

0:44:15Times, and the first paragraph of the story.

0:44:18And the date, the thing, you know, like, "Why?

0:44:21If I want to go read that story, I'll go read it."

0:44:24But if every single client did that, I mean, I would not like that because a lot of the

0:44:29tweets that I see have links in them, and I don't want to see the links in line like

0:44:33that.

0:44:34And I would be very upset if I had no choice.

0:44:36Well, it would ruin – it just would spoil what I think Twitter is.

0:44:40I mean, it really would start to lose the whole appeal to me.

0:44:47And I know that that Michael Sippy blog post from a month back or so that sort of gave

0:44:52everybody the chills about the direction they're heading with this where he reiterated that

0:44:58the way they see their developer relationships going forward isn't with developers writing

0:45:02client apps that show you Twitter. It's developers creating, I don't even know what they want

0:45:08to call it, but it's these embedded iframes more or less that you put inside tweets.

0:45:12Yeah, it's like an RSS reader only you always have to use the preview pane and that like

0:45:21Like you don't have just a view of the articles.

0:45:23Every single thing you see expands out to some big blob of it.

0:45:27It's basically forcing you to go to a web page every time you read a tweet.

0:45:31And it's a way for the people on the receiving end of those links to shove their crap in

0:45:35your face.

0:45:36Like, "Oh, websites come and develop to our interface, and then anytime anyone references

0:45:40a URL anywhere, you can just shove a big giant square of stuff in their face.

0:45:43But whatever you want there, and we'll charge you money for that."

0:45:46It's just terrible.

0:45:47So for anybody out there who's on the fence and who agrees with me and you, John, that

0:45:54just don't like the direction Twitter's going with their relationship with developers and

0:45:59the way that they're -- the monetization strategy that they're clearly taking, the only thing

0:46:06that you can do about it, the one and only thing that you can do as a user that would

0:46:10have any -- you know, sure, you're just one user against 100 million who are using it,

0:46:14But the only thing you can do is throw your support to some kind of competitor.

0:46:19That's the only thing you can do that would have any kind of effect.

0:46:21You know, complaining about it isn't going to do anything.

0:46:24Of course, when I talked about app.net, I had all these pessimistic things to say about

0:46:28it because don't you kind of get that feeling that the reason Twitter is doing this is that

0:46:32the only people who care are nerds like us, and maybe there's not enough of us to make

0:46:36a difference?

0:46:37Right.

0:46:38No, I do have that fear.

0:46:39Absolutely.

0:46:40And even if there was enough of us, like, because in the beginning, in, you know, 2006,

0:46:442007 like Twitter was just nerds like us and there was a definitely different vibe back then but now

0:46:49If even if we got critical mass to go over app net it got funded all the nerds went over there

0:46:55And they had some sort of gateway and clients could read both of them and murder like you can imagine a scenario where nerds are

0:47:00On app net but like wouldn't you miss?

0:47:02The the pop culture celebrity people that you happen to follow on Twitter not that I follow a lot of them

0:47:09But it would be weird like oh, we're over there

0:47:11But everything else is happening in that other place. Twitter has just become so pervasive like on

0:47:16television news even which drives me nuts for like the noise reads tweets and stuff like that, but it's like that is the network for

0:47:22Everybody and we'd be on this other little thing

0:47:25That's just never gonna get critical mass and even though it would feel cool and we'd have our own little thing

0:47:28We'd feel kind of like left out, you know, and it's kind of

0:47:33I'm of two minds about this this the bias maybe it's the same type of thing where it's up

0:47:39We had Myspace and Friendster and all those other things.

0:47:43Every time one of those looked like it was dominant, something else came along and wiped

0:47:46it out.

0:47:47Now we have Facebook.

0:47:48My big fear with Facebook is, unlike Friendster and Myspace, Facebook has just gotten too

0:47:52darn big and now it's too big to fail.

0:47:56Something can't come along and wipe out Facebook the same way Facebook did to Myspace because

0:48:01it's reached some...

0:48:03It's gone over some line.

0:48:04It's just too darn big.

0:48:05My fear about Twitter is the same thing.

0:48:07Even if something better comes along, it's too late.

0:48:10Twitter is just too darn big and it's going to take a really long time.

0:48:13It's kind of like Windows.

0:48:14Windows got so big that it didn't matter how much better something was, you basically had

0:48:17to wait for it to become irrelevant and the future to be in mobile and Microsoft to not

0:48:22be there.

0:48:23And then that's what makes Windows go away.

0:48:24It's not because Mac operating system was better and Windows goes away.

0:48:27It goes away because who cares about desktop operating systems anymore?

0:48:30We only care about mobile and the people who went in mobile were not Microsoft.

0:48:33So is that what has to happen here for Twitter and Facebook to, you know, nothing can defeat

0:48:38them until they become irrelevant?

0:48:40That's scary.

0:48:41I don't know.

0:48:42Maybe defeat is the wrong term.

0:48:44My optimistic take on app.net would be something along the lines of the comparison between

0:48:50commercial TV and HBO.

0:48:54And the idea is that I think most people, I think a lot of the people who don't really

0:48:58like the way Twitter is growing also have a lot of complaints about commercial TV, the

0:49:03themselves, the number of commercials that are shown, and the just the way that the nature

0:49:11of commercial TV sort of has a never-ending decade after decade drive towards lowest common

0:49:18denominator content. Right? I mean, I think a lot of the shows that are on TV now, the

0:49:25reality type shows, are not really even any further, they're not, they're even worse maybe

0:49:31then like the dystopian future oh my god look how bad TV is from like RoboCop

0:49:37right yeah great the accuracy al my balls right you know idiocracy is still

0:49:42a little bit out ahead but well the America's funny time videos was

0:49:45basically out my balls and that was like in the 90s right right but as the years

0:49:50go on that the idiocracy future idiocratic future doesn't seem as

0:49:55far-fetched, it seems less and less far-fetched as time goes on.

0:50:01Well that's the case where I think it's not so much that entertainment is appealing to

0:50:07base instincts, because that's been around forever, and I think there's the counter-examples

0:50:12like Lost was on ABC and no one's going to say that that was trashy reality show, that's

0:50:17the opposite of high-budget, single artistic vision, high production value, stuff like

0:50:24But the thing about people hate about TV is that there's an entrenched business model

0:50:28that hasn't kept up with technology and it's difficult to dislodge that.

0:50:32So what we're looking for on HBO is like, one example is that, well, on HBO shows, they

0:50:37can make shows for adults because they're not burdened by these legacy things when the

0:50:40airways belong to the people and you had to license them through the government, but then

0:50:44you had to have decency rule, like all that stuff that burdens the networks doesn't burden

0:50:49HBO.

0:50:51And so that's why you get content that's more appealing there, because what can you really

0:50:54do?

0:50:55Within the confines of the decency rules of network television, you're limited in terms

0:50:58of programming for adults, because not all adults want just everything that's Pollyanna

0:51:02all the time.

0:51:06And it's the same situation with Twitter.

0:51:07I don't know if there is...

0:51:11What is the equivalent of being able to show nudity and curse and having people pay you

0:51:16directly lots of money?

0:51:19What is the equivalent of that in App.net?

0:51:21I think the equivalent is more about the overall experience that you're not being badgered

0:51:26by promotional garbage and that there aren't idiots.

0:51:36I think maybe the equivalent...

0:51:37It's a hard analogy because it's a social network versus just TV broadcast.

0:51:42But there aren't going to be as many idiots on App.net as there are on Twitter because

0:51:48Because at least for now, it seems like the plan is that everybody who's on there has

0:51:51to pay at least something to get in.

0:51:52So you're not going to have...

0:51:55There's not going to be idiots there that you can assume that there's a higher level

0:51:58of discourse.

0:51:59I mean, one thing...

0:52:00I mean, and it's super, super early days.

0:52:01I mean, in fact, I mean, they just let me...

0:52:03I got in today.

0:52:04I'm in on the alpha.

0:52:07I don't know how many users are in there already.

0:52:09But I posted one...

0:52:10I was going to call it a tweet, but I guess you have to call it a post to app.net.

0:52:15And the post ID was like 8,200 something.

0:52:18So there's only been, you know, just with all the tests that they've, you know, whatever

0:52:22else, I don't even know how many of those are from actual users and how many are automated

0:52:26things that they've tested while building the thing out.

0:52:28But there's only been 8,000 posts so far.

0:52:30Whereas Twitter is up at like, you know, 12 quadrillion.

0:52:33You're already at 8,000.

0:52:34I knew I should have checked that out.

0:52:36I got the email too and I'm like, "I'll check it out."

0:52:38But that's not my user ID.

0:52:39It's my, it was the tweet ID or post ID.

0:52:41I have no idea what my user ID is.

0:52:43Well, I guess the equivalent is that no ads.

0:52:49There's no ads on HBO and there'd be no ads on the Twitter replacement thing and there'd

0:52:54be no ads and no fear of ads because everyone pays for it outside of my game.

0:52:57And it's not just ad ads either because clearly the stuff like having embedded New York Times

0:53:04stories show up as a card instead of just a URL, it's not really an ad but there's a

0:53:10financial thing in there where they're getting money, they're sharing money with the New

0:53:13York Times to have New York Times stories treated specially, and there's not going to

0:53:17be anything of that.

0:53:18You know?

0:53:19It's not, you know, so advertising is the wrong word for that, but it's favoring the

0:53:24interests of somebody other than me for financial reasons.

0:53:27Me as the user.

0:53:28Yeah, their big thrust is like whatever makes our service more desirable to customers, that's

0:53:34what we'll spend all our time on.

0:53:36features, making it like whatever users of the service want, that's what we communicate

0:53:42with. Whereas you get the feeling that people on Twitter are not worried about what the

0:53:46users of their system want. They're more worried about how do we get money from somebody to

0:53:50keep us in business before the VC runs out.

0:53:52Right. So my thought too is like HBO. Most people don't have HBO. Everybody watches commercial

0:53:58TV, but only some people have HBO. I'm guessing at this point I probably wouldn't abandon

0:54:05Twitter for App.net, but maybe I would use App.net as the thing I'm logged into all day

0:54:09and only check Twitter once in a while. But in the same way that when you get HBO, it's

0:54:13not like your commercial TV turns off.

0:54:15Yeah. The thing I wonder about Twitter is they have all these... They've been hinting

0:54:20at the, "I wouldn't write third-party clients that I were you. If you're gonna write clients,

0:54:24don't write a general purpose one." They've been making scary, vague moves in that direction

0:54:31for a long time, but they never actually pull the trigger.

0:54:34And I kept thinking, how are you going to stop somebody?

0:54:38I guess you can use OAuth on the API to reject clients, but that's like an arms race in terms

0:54:43of illicit Twitter clients.

0:54:45And what I'm thinking of is, if App.net took off and was popular, wouldn't there be hacked

0:54:53clients that merge Twitter and App.net into a single thing or some sort of proxy gateway?

0:54:59I guess it's within their power to reject requests that aren't authenticated with some

0:55:03digitally signed.

0:55:04But that's just that arms race of client side software versus server side.

0:55:10You don't want the nerds on the other side of that to be your enemy.

0:55:13I'm not saying it can't be done, but that's a lot of time and energy fighting against

0:55:17that.

0:55:18And really, do they really care?

0:55:19Was it you who came up with the stats for what percentage of Twitter users use third-party

0:55:25clients?

0:55:26asked about it and somebody who reads during fireball linked to you know

0:55:28figured it out I think he I think is his methodology was pretty pretty good he

0:55:34he like slurped like a million random tweets from the there's still some way

0:55:39that you can get that you can get like just show me like tweets to show me a

0:55:44random tweets that people are tweeting from around the world and he grabbed

0:55:46like a million of them and analyzed where they were from and it's you know

0:55:50the the biggest hole in his methodology is it because there's no other way to

0:55:55get the real information, what people are using to see Twitter.

0:55:58What you can do is you can see what people are using to post to Twitter, which is different

0:56:03because I would guess that there's an awful lot of people out there, now that Twitter

0:56:07has hit, like you said, CNN shows hashtags 24 hours a day.

0:56:12I think there's an awful lot of people out there with accounts that have two followers

0:56:16and they've only tweeted three times themselves, but they actually do use Twitter.

0:56:21They use it and just consume.

0:56:23Just pure consumption.

0:56:24It's like something that they look at but don't post to.

0:56:28But I would guess that would only skew it more towards the official Twitter clients

0:56:31and the Twitter website, not less.

0:56:33Yeah, and do you remember what the number was?

0:56:35It was like 23 percent, 20 percent.

0:56:37I remember thinking it was way higher than I thought it would be.

0:56:40I think it was close to like 20 or something.

0:56:42I would have thought it would be like 3 percent.

0:56:44And I think that's skewed by the fact that people who create content and have a lot of

0:56:49followers are more likely to need something like that.

0:56:53For example, just as an – and I have never seen the appeal of this software, but I know

0:56:57that a lot of celebrity people use TweetDeck.

0:57:00That's a way for them to be able to – TweetDeck lets you have some chance of managing an awareness

0:57:09of people who are talking to or about you when there are so many people.

0:57:12It's the same reason you don't use Unified Timeline, because your @ replies, anytime

0:57:16you say anything, would just swamp your ability to read the three posts from the people you

0:57:20reply to.

0:57:21So can you imagine if you had 20 million followers or something they were just it just becomes untenable so I think

0:57:26Tweet bot is a way

0:57:28Like I don't even know if they look at their replies and then just doing like a bunch of canned searches

0:57:32You know and then they can kind of get a big overall picture

0:57:35But but yeah for someone who just wants to read Twitter tweet deck is not that's a tool for the Twitter power user or whatever

0:57:40You want to call them, but there's also you know they are pulling the plug on some people

0:57:44I know that they just pulled the plug on Instagram connecting to Twitter

0:57:48Well, I mean they got bossed by Facebook right and you know famously, you know people have observed that Jack Dorsey, you know Twitter

0:57:55Inventor and CEO or whatever his title is. I guess he's not the CEO, but you know, he's like chief designer at Twitter

0:58:02Had been a active Instagram user and hasn't posted an Instagram since their Facebook acquisition

0:58:14But ultimately though you know and you can say well it makes sense that they'd pull the plug on you know

0:58:19Somebody owned by Facebook or whatever, but really it's like you said though

0:58:22It's just an API you know if your API is there you know I mean they're gonna play favorites like that

0:58:27I wouldn't be surprised if they started doing it to

0:58:29Desktop clients yeah, I mean I've won. They'll end up with I would imagine if they do

0:58:34Lock it down is similar to what Apple uses for push notifications and iCloud and everything where there's like a cryptographic

0:58:39connection between like you are allowed to send push notifications and

0:58:44And the only reason you're allowed is because it's, you know, configured through your developer

0:58:48ID and connected to your Apple ID, and we have the information about you, and if you

0:58:53violate it, we pull the plug on you, and the barrier to getting up and running again is

0:58:57making a new fake Apple ID from a different IP address and pay the $99 again and get everything

0:59:02configured and deploy a new version of an application from a different Apple ID and

0:59:06make your customers download on the store, and then we lock you down again.

0:59:08And so like, you could go cat and mouse like that, or you could just try to crack the encryption

0:59:12somehow or whatever, but I don't know who is more motivated to stop that.

0:59:17I haven't seen any cases of Apple's push notification thing being hacked or gained, because I don't

0:59:23think there's any financial gain for that.

0:59:26There's probably not any financial gain for breaking through the prohibition on third-party

0:59:32Twitter clients, but there's definitely geek, like, "There's no financial gain, but I really

0:59:36want to use a third-party client."

0:59:38So maybe the hackers are just motivated to find their way to crack it just for the hell

0:59:42of it right now yeah I don't know but anyway I'm a little depressed though

0:59:47because I kind of was rooting for app dotnet hopefully hopefully maybe you

0:59:51know maybe maybe they'll turn it around in the last five days I don't know what

0:59:55do you think about what did you think about when I was my son like a points

1:00:00about out the net is remember the whole big thing with a robo not robo tweeting

1:00:02but the wanting for you to tweet and stuff like that yeah they were very

1:00:06quick to reply to him at my point when I talked about in the show it's not so

1:00:09much that they did this because they've responded quickly and they were cool

1:00:12about it and everything like that.

1:00:13Just that it gives you that doubt that like, why did they think this would be okay?

1:00:18Like it makes you question their judgment.

1:00:19It doesn't make you question like their motivation and like they're clearly like they're motivated

1:00:24for the right reasons and they really want, our goals are aligned with their goals, really

1:00:28want to do the right thing.

1:00:29But it's like, man, how did something like that slip by?

1:00:32Not that it's that important, but it's like, am I being fooled here or do we really not

1:00:36share the same values, you know?

1:00:38And that's-

1:00:39Right.

1:00:40And what you're talking about is when you first signed up, I don't even know what they

1:00:41do anymore. But when I signed up like a day or two in, part of the appeal of signing up

1:00:47was that you get to reserve your existing Twitter username. But the way that they did

1:00:53it was they needed you to tweet like a pre-generated tweet that said something corny like, "I'm

1:01:00supporting app.net. You can too. Here's the URL and there's a hashtag in there." And you

1:01:06tweeted that and you're tweeting that was what their bot would look for to see the tweet

1:01:12and then say, OK, this guy did it. And there's like a little like a little unique token in

1:01:16there too somewhere. And then they would say, OK, so now at Gruber is is verified as a backer

1:01:22of app dotnet. So this guy has the at Gruber name reserved for our thing, too. But that's

1:01:28cheesy. I mean, you know, I don't I never tweet hashtags and I don't I don't like anything

1:01:34like that that asks you to tweet on their behalf.

1:01:38Yeah, and that's…

1:01:39Because I remember there was one time one of those Mac software bundles had a thing

1:01:43like that where it was like you got like a free app if you gave them your Twitter name.

1:01:48Instead of getting 10 apps for 50 bucks, you got 11 apps for 50 bucks.

1:01:51It's an even better deal.

1:01:52Just give us your Twitter name and people are doing it.

1:01:55And all of a sudden your Twitter stream was just full of like 37 people who all were promoting

1:02:00the such and such Mac bundle.

1:02:01And it's like, man, that is so cheesy and just wrong.

1:02:05And exactly, I had that thought too.

1:02:08It really was like a bad taste in the mouth, as like my first experience with App.net.

1:02:14Yeah, and again, it didn't make me question the point of the project or anything they

1:02:18say about it.

1:02:19It just made me think about, like, you want to feel when you're supporting someone like

1:02:24this that they share your values and tastes, I guess.

1:02:28And part of it is just misunderstanding and an experience because you didn't have to tweet.

1:02:32I think even from the very beginning, you didn't have to tweet that corny signing promotional

1:02:35thing.

1:02:36You just needed to have the few bits of information in there.

1:02:38But they didn't make that clear.

1:02:39And to that credit, they didn't do the thing that so many sites do where they want you

1:02:43to sign up and you go to the OAuth screen or whatever.

1:02:46It's like, "This company would like to read tweets in your timeline, see your followers,

1:02:53and there's always tweet as you."

1:02:54And it's like, "Hell no.

1:02:56Hell no.

1:02:57Who would ever say yes to that?

1:02:59And yet so many people do, because as soon as you check that, you know two seconds later

1:03:03there's going to be one of those blah, blah, blah signed up for the whatever.

1:03:08And this was better in that it didn't want the power to tweet as you, which is crazy.

1:03:13No one would say yes to it.

1:03:14It just wanted you to tweet something on their behalf.

1:03:19And part of it is like social promotional like in the meaning.

1:03:21Like if we could just get all these guys to tweet to each other.

1:03:24But it was so corny.

1:03:25And that's why I was so shocked to see it from, I think, you and Marco.

1:03:28I was like, "Has someone hacked their account?"

1:03:29Because I know you guys don't sign up for things that they'll let you tweet as you.

1:03:32It's funny.

1:03:33I got a couple.

1:03:34You were not the only one.

1:03:35I got a couple of, "Hey, was your Twitter account hacked?"

1:03:38Like just not a bunch, but at least more than one.

1:03:41I got two or three like, "Dude, is your Twitter account hacked?"

1:03:45I remember Guy, Guy English, his came out and he immediately tweeted an apology.

1:03:51He was like, "I'm really sorry about that last tweet, but I'm kind of hoping to see

1:03:54this."

1:03:55He apologized on both his and App.net's behalf.

1:04:00By the time I decided to fund it, I'd seen all you guys do this, and I had read enough

1:04:06about the backlash that you didn't have to tweet what they told you to tweet, and so

1:04:10I just replaced that text with something scolding them for doing this.

1:04:16One of your tweets is featured on their homepage.

1:04:20tweet is not. But like I said, I still funded them because I want the same thing that they

1:04:27want. And no one else is like... This is what I was talking about earlier today when I was

1:04:31talking to my friend and trying to convince him to fund this thing. It's kind of weird

1:04:35to me that we want this thing, but the traditional way is, I guess, you max out all your credit

1:04:42cards or you get a business loan or you launch it at being partially supported by some existing

1:04:47line of business. We're in this weird time period where the thing to do is not to do

1:04:53any of those other traditional ways of starting up a business that requires capital and time.

1:04:57Like we need a certain amount of time to make this product to try to get, you know, we're

1:05:01going to start a business and we got to start from nothing. So you need seed capital, you

1:05:04need to go into massive debt. Those are the traditional ways to do it. Now we have this

1:05:08new way, which is, hey, if there's a bunch of other people who want this, get the money

1:05:10up front. And it's exciting and interesting and it's the Kickstarter phenomenon. But part

1:05:15Part of me says, "Isn't there someone who wants to do something like App.net who either

1:05:19has the capital to do it or can be a business that can be funded in traditional ways?"

1:05:24I guess the traditional ways suck.

1:05:26Getting a business loan sucks.

1:05:27Maxing out all your credit cards, I can imagine that sucking too.

1:05:30So many businesses have been started that way.

1:05:33Or start from nothing, like grad students who have crappy retail jobs doing it in their

1:05:37spare time until it takes off.

1:05:39There's so many other ways that businesses start.

1:05:41I don't like feeling like, "Oh, if App.net doesn't make it, well, that was the one way

1:05:45way this could have happened. There's so many other ways I feel like this could happen.

1:05:48Not that I wish them—don't wish them well, but if this doesn't make it, I hope someone

1:05:54else out there looks at this and says, "Well, there was a lot of people who wanted to give

1:05:58money to make this happen." Maybe the same people will say, "All right, well, we've

1:06:02got to give all this money back, or we can't charge these people." But maybe we'll find

1:06:06some other way to do this, because clearly there's, you know, whatever, $200,000 worth

1:06:09of people who think this is a good idea.

1:06:11Right. And the other thing too is it really does require some imagination up front to

1:06:15imagine that it could be how it could make the world a better place if it existed. Whereas

1:06:19once it was off the ground, and there were I mean, and clearly, like, you know, if they're

1:06:24already even if they don't raise another dollar, they've already got $220,000 raised or something

1:06:29like that, which at like 50 or 100 bucks apiece is, you know, thousands of people that if

1:06:36there were thousands of smart people on there, then and they were using it already. People

1:06:40who were like, "Well, maybe I should sign up too," wouldn't have to imagine what it

1:06:43was like. They could see, "Well, look, here's people writing clever posts on this thing.

1:06:48I can actually see the appeal." It's a lot more easier to get people to sign up once

1:06:53it exists than before it exists.

1:06:56Yeah, and I'd be willing to say, I wonder if they asked everybody, again, I still haven't

1:07:00looked this up on their side, but if they said, "Look, guys, we didn't make our funding

1:07:02goal. How would you feel about just giving us the money you pledged anyway?" I would

1:07:06say, "Sure, go ahead." I wouldn't be grudging the money because I think, like, whatever

1:07:10If if you get this thing out there and we start using it and you can actually make it cool

1:07:14Then you can win based on your features like it's you know, make a cool thing that I can show people

1:07:18Hey check this out. Isn't this cool add features that Twitter doesn't have it doesn't have time to have or

1:07:23You know or just make it a better experience in Twitter

1:07:26It almost would be better if they waited to do this project until after Twitter screwed everybody and killed the third-party clients because then they'd

1:07:32Get funded. I'll tell you. Yeah, I do think that I do wonder about I've had that same thought too that

1:07:38And maybe just one more like a straw that broke the camel's back type thing like where the next big rumored

1:07:44Breakup is flipboard, you know where the flipboard CEO resigned from Twitter's board was on Twitter's board, but now he's off and

1:07:51You know like a week or two ago as of a week or two ago, and there's I know Dustin Curtis

1:07:57Reported it. I've heard the same thing. I can't you know, I don't really report rumors, but I've heard the same thing though that

1:08:03like through the grapevine that that Twitter might be about to pull the plug on flipboard and I know that a lot of people I

1:08:09Don't use flipboard that much

1:08:10But I know that Twitter is a really good source for it is you hook up your Twitter to your flipboard and then?

1:08:15Urls that are posted from the people you follow on Twitter

1:08:19Which is a really really high hit rate of things you're interested in show up as flipboard articles

1:08:24You know so if they pull that you're gonna lose a really good source for

1:08:30Sort of the way that flipboard can get serendipitous articles not just you know

1:08:35It's like the one of the things that I think is appealing about flipboard compared to RSS is RSS just gives you things

1:08:40You know you want whereas flipboard can sometimes give you things you do enjoy

1:08:44But that you would didn't ask for and Twitter is a big source for that

1:08:48I can't help but think I really think I think that if Twitter does that I think it's really gonna

1:08:53My prediction is it's gonna infuriate flipboard users because I really do think that that's a big part of flipboards

1:09:00appeal.

1:09:01Well, I think they're going to do the calculation and say there aren't enough Flipboard users

1:09:04for that to matter.

1:09:05But I was thinking the other day about how I use Twitter and how it has become—I was

1:09:09thinking of someone's blog and I'm like, "Boy, I wonder if this person has done a blog post

1:09:14lately."

1:09:15And I was thinking, "You know why I don't know if they're doing blog posts and I haven't

1:09:18seen them?

1:09:19It's because they don't tweet their blog posts and Twitter has started to replace RSS for

1:09:22me."

1:09:23Before, when I was living in that news bar all day, I always knew if someone, you know,

1:09:26someone posted their blog once every two months.

1:09:28But I would see that post because it would come up in my feeds.

1:09:30But now if they don't tweet about it, I'm using Twitter like RSS, and that's why it

1:09:33burns me so much to think that that would go away because it's replaced or mostly supplanted

1:09:38so many other services in my life, and then they're going to change the rules on me, and

1:09:42I'm going to be like, "Ugh."

1:09:43My refer is a daring fireball.

1:09:44The refer listings are almost useless anymore because it's all just Twitter.

1:09:48Yeah.

1:09:49I mean, it doesn't matter.

1:09:50It's not like everything I've posted during Fireball, the number one refer to it by far

1:09:55is Twitter.

1:09:57And I don't even know how much, it's not, you know, presumably a lot of it is the Daring

1:10:00Fireball, @DaringFireball account Twitter account, but if I actually like poke into

1:10:05it, it's, you know, it's other people of course, you know, people who just like, you know,

1:10:08here's an article at Daring Fireball.

1:10:09Huge, huge, huge source.

1:10:11Yeah, I can tell you that that's basically how I read Daring Fireball.

1:10:15Why do I follow the Daring Fireball account?

1:10:17Because I have to know, you know, like don't I know that just go to the Daring Fireball

1:10:21site and read stuff?

1:10:22The way I go there, 99.9% of the time, is the Daring Fireball account tweets something,

1:10:27and I click on it, and that's how I read it.

1:10:30That's how it happens.

1:10:31I used to, I still subscribe to your feed, but I do that for all these things.

1:10:38I subscribe to the Twitter accounts of things whose feeds I also subscribe to, and whose

1:10:42websites I also see.

1:10:43Only for sites that are like, you can't do it for The Verge or something that's posting

1:10:4720 million things every day, because that would just be ridiculous.

1:10:49But for sites that update once or twice or five or ten times a day, that's how I see

1:10:54their stuff.

1:10:55And if someone doesn't have an official Twitter account like that person's blog that I'm thinking

1:10:58that they post anything, I'll just forget it exists after a while.

1:11:01Yeah, same here.

1:11:02I agree.

1:11:03You know what?

1:11:04Let's take a break.

1:11:05I should do the first sponsor.

1:11:06The first sponsor?

1:11:07It's like an hour in.

1:11:08Oh, Jesus Christ.

1:11:09You know what?

1:11:10And I swore to the Mule guys I was going to get this done in an hour.

1:11:13Last week's show is about an hour.

1:11:16Christ.

1:11:17Anyway, Macworld Superguides.

1:11:18guides. You ever hear these super guides? The people at Macworld, these guys, they're

1:11:21my friends, but they're really the best in the business when it comes to covering Apple.

1:11:26So many smart writers and editors, and they don't just do, it's not just the magazine

1:11:30and the website. They've got a whole series of ebooks, and some of it's compiled from

1:11:35the best information that they've published on the web, a lot of it is original content,

1:11:40and they cover these topics in super good, super deep depth, and with the same sort of

1:11:46high quality of writing and editing that you expect from Macworld.

1:11:52And they're available just about anywhere you could want them.

1:11:54You can get them at the iBook store.

1:11:55You can buy them directly from Amazon at the Kindle store.

1:11:58You can get them from Macworld if you want.

1:12:03Who writes for Macworld?

1:12:04We've got Chris Breen, Dan Frakes, Lex Friedman, of course Jason Snell.

1:12:10I don't even know.

1:12:11Does he even work anymore?

1:12:12like a new job as the IDC whatever, director of whatever.

1:12:16You're the vice president.

1:12:17Don't forget Dan Morin.

1:12:18I was going to forget Dan Morin on purpose and you blew it.

1:12:23And of course Serenity Caldwell who I think not only writes for them but she also does

1:12:28a lot of the production work on putting these ebooks together.

1:12:32And so their newest one, no surprise, and ties right in with having Syracuse on the

1:12:38show it's their total mountain lion five bucks five dollars that's all it costs

1:12:44and you get all the detailed information everything Macworld knows about

1:12:48mountain lion all the new features and for six bucks you just throw one buck

1:12:53more you can even get a bundle and it contains DRM free ePub and Kindle files

1:12:58and a PDF version you get it all DRM free other books in the Macworld

1:13:04Super Guide series you might be interested in Mac gems second edition for bucks

1:13:08Master iPhone photography I had that you know what I should read that one three bucks three bucks

1:13:15And it's all everything you want to know about the iPhone camera and photography

1:13:19They got the I've iPad Super Guide ten bucks the URL. It's macworld.com

1:13:25super guides

1:13:28Go get them. They're great books. I've read a bunch. I've gone through the

1:13:33the Mountain Lion one and I've learned new things. I can't imagine that anybody

1:13:37wouldn't except maybe maybe John. macworld.com/superguides. So your

1:13:44your your your Mountain Lion review is out. Yeah. And I know I know you've

1:13:49covered it extensively on Hypercord. We don't have to go through it. Yeah I'm gonna talk

1:13:53about it more this week. I can't be the only I love it and I wrote this when I

1:13:59linked to it as I know that for a lot of us we look forward to release day of

1:14:02of Mac OS X versions as much for--

1:14:07and as the time goes on, too, because I get access

1:14:09to the seeds now, I have developer accounts.

1:14:11So I kind of know the software.

1:14:13I'm not like a Joe user who needs to go to the Apple Store

1:14:15and buy it and install it.

1:14:17I kind of know it.

1:14:17It's like the thing I have to look forward to is your review.

1:14:20Well, the good thing about the review

1:14:22is it won't screw up your computer

1:14:24and make your Skype break and do other things.

1:14:26Exactly.

1:14:27It's risk-free.

1:14:28You just read it.

1:14:29And the other thing about it is that with these releases,

1:14:31is like, you know, the initial mountain lion reel was a surprise because we didn't know

1:14:35they were going to yearly release cycle and it just seemed to come out of nowhere. But

1:14:38they paraded that OS around so much and just showed every possible feature of it. Like

1:14:44there was nothing held in reserve for the longest time. And if you wanted to know about

1:14:48this, just from Apple's official keynotes, you felt like you knew the whole operating

1:14:53system and then forget about like the rumor sites that just would download the seeds and

1:14:55show you everything. So certainly it's not like, oh boy, I can't wait to see it, read

1:14:59this review so I could figure out, so I could see what's in this operating system. Because

1:15:02if you cared, you could have found out. It's all just, you know, okay, so we know what's

1:15:07there, let's hear some people's opinions about it. And that's why I think people read, not

1:15:11just my review, but any review you want to hear. All right, we know about all these features,

1:15:14but let's hear from someone who's used it. Is it good? Is it bad? Does it work the way

1:15:18they say it should? How does it feel to actually use this thing? Stuff like that.

1:15:21Do you ever think about doing this for iOS?

1:15:24I get so tired thinking about just doing it for like, during the WWC keynote, when they

1:15:30were going through like, you know, they did the Mac section, they did the iOS section,

1:15:34and during the iOS section, I was like, "Oh, thank God I'm not running a review of iOS,"

1:15:37because I'm not gonna say that I like the Mac better, but that's like where my history

1:15:41is.

1:15:42Like the Mac is my first love, and I have this deep background and context to speak

1:15:46about iOS, whereas the number of people who have been using, not iOS, Mac, the Mac operating

1:15:52The number of people who've been using iOS since day one, there's plenty of those people.

1:15:57But how many people are still around who've been using the Mac since day one and have

1:16:00all that history behind it and can talk about it?

1:16:03And really, the other thing about it is so much of my Mac OS X reviews have become tangentially

1:16:10about or indirectly about iOS anyway.

1:16:13It's like I get to comment on iOS even though I'm not writing a review of it.

1:16:16But really it just comes down to, you know, if this was my full-time job, sure, maybe

1:16:21I'd do an iOS review, but it's not and these Mac ones almost kill me as it is.

1:16:27From a practical standpoint, I don't even know if it would work out.

1:16:29I mean, I know.

1:16:30I mean, nobody really knows how much work you put into it other than you, but that is

1:16:34one of the things, too, with you having the podcast now with having Hypercritical where

1:16:38you do comment on it as you're going.

1:16:40Like for the last several months, it's been one of the recurring bits up front is how's

1:16:44the review going and you give some background on it and you get an even greater sense of

1:16:48how much work it is to do this.

1:16:53Not just the writing, but the fact that you've pointed out that you've always copiously illustrated

1:16:59the reviews with screenshots and that it's really, really hard to get good screenshots.

1:17:06You've pointed out just stupid things like if you're going to take screenshots of the

1:17:10contacts app, you've got to make sure you've got a set of dummy contacts set up so you're

1:17:14not putting your mom's address there, which would let you get hacked in addition to violating

1:17:21your mom's privacy. And then when Apple changes the color of the leather in the address book

1:17:28theme that the contacts app uses, now you've got to retake the screenshots.

1:17:34Yeah, the worst part about it is that it's loaded all on the back end where no matter

1:17:41how much preparation you do, you are at the mercy of their releases.

1:17:44And so there's necessarily going to be this crazy mad scramble for the last build, the

1:17:49second to last build, leading right up to when they do the release.

1:17:51And you just can't do that ahead of time.

1:17:53Like I start preparing like, you know, months and as soon as I know the new cat name practically,

1:17:59that's where I'm starting.

1:18:00And like, it's not like your homework where you're like, "I did all my work, reading for

1:18:04the entire year and the first week of school."

1:18:05You can't do that.

1:18:06You're just at the mercy of their release schedule.

1:18:09And so it just adds a tremendous amount of pressure.

1:18:11But of course the main problem is that it just takes me forever to do this.

1:18:14I'm not a fast writer.

1:18:15I don't know how these guys who write for a living just churn out article after article

1:18:19every day.

1:18:20I can't do that.

1:18:21That's not the way I work.

1:18:22It's like blood, sweat, and tears.

1:18:26And it's not because what I'm writing is so difficult or profound.

1:18:29I couldn't do just a simple five-paragraph summary of an event.

1:18:34It would still take me forever.

1:18:37I'm no good at that.

1:18:38So it really is very painful for me to get this amount of content out and have all of

1:18:44it be correct and fact checked.

1:18:45And that's why the day the article goes out, I get crowd-sourced corrections from everybody.

1:18:52And the beauty of the web is that I can fix those things so that within the first hour

1:18:56or two, almost everyone has been fixed because they've been found by people where I put the

1:19:00wrong year on something or put the wrong cat name somewhere.

1:19:03How long does it take to push the changes to the ebook versions?

1:19:07That's going to be a show that I do.

1:19:09This week on Hypercritical, I'm going to talk more about the review, and then next week

1:19:12I'm going to talk exclusively about the pain of doing those ebooks.

1:19:16And that is just so terribly painful.

1:19:18Speaking of Macworld Super Guides, I enlisted the help of my friend Ren, who does the ebooks

1:19:24over there.

1:19:25I should have enlisted her help much earlier.

1:19:26In fact, very early on, months before, I said, "You know what?

1:19:29I should just pay her as a contractor to make this book for me, because she knows what the

1:19:32hell she's doing, and I don't."

1:19:33She really does.

1:19:34She really does.

1:19:35I was like, "But you know what?

1:19:37I should learn how this stuff works anyway.

1:19:39I should do this on my own."

1:19:41I'm not going to say there was a mistake because I did learn a lot, but I should have contacted

1:19:46her sooner.

1:19:47I did contact some other people I knew who knew stuff about eBooks, but the thing that

1:19:50she knows is, "Here's what the spec says, and here's how to do this, and here's what

1:19:56the best practices are, but here's where the bodies are buried on iBooks.

1:19:59Oh, so you're getting this one particular problem?

1:20:02Yeah, I had that problem six months ago, and here's what you have to do to fix it."

1:20:05stuff like that that you won't find in any documentation anywhere, just real-world knowledge.

1:20:10And so that was a painful learning experience on my part.

1:20:12But the other part is, if you want to make a correction, it's not like on our sector

1:20:18where I just go into the CMS update thing, click a button, 30 seconds later it's up on

1:20:23the web.

1:20:24It's an ordeal.

1:20:25So then you got to do this batch thing where you're like, "All right, I don't want to send

1:20:28an update until I've got..."

1:20:30You're waiting for them to slow down to a trickle, but all the while you know that there's

1:20:33egregious double word sitting there in the first three paragraphs that you just wish

1:20:37you could fix.

1:20:38You're like, "No, no, no, just wait."

1:20:39It's like the Mac App Store updates.

1:20:41You know you've got a bunch of bug fixes, but the longer you wait, then you put it into

1:20:45review.

1:20:46As soon as it goes into review, you find some other crashing bug.

1:20:48You're like, "Goddammit, should I wait?

1:20:49Should I resubmit?"

1:20:51That kind of delay just kills you, especially with something like this.

1:20:54This is weird.

1:20:55It's not like a novel where...

1:20:58It's practically news.

1:20:59It's time-sensitive material, where a week after it's out, no one really cares anymore.

1:21:03So you really have to strike while the iron's hot.

1:21:05And that's why through a series of bad things that happened, the various delays in getting

1:21:11the first ebook up on Amazon and then doing updates to it just was very painful.

1:21:15Right.

1:21:16And it's sort of like with just shipping apps, where shipping apps used to be really required

1:21:22in a tremendous amount of attention and QA and focus.

1:21:27And the stakes were really high because when you said go, there was like a guy at a factory

1:21:32who was pressing CDs or before that was making floppy disks and

1:21:36you've got boxes and boxes of these things that take time to stamp and

1:21:42store and a ship and it costs money to ship them and

1:21:46Now you want to do an update you want to do a 4.1 update and you're gonna have to do all these

1:21:51You know

1:21:51You really do want to queue these things up so that you get as much you when you draw that line

1:21:56It's in there and then you know digital distribution nobody, you know, it's not like like well, there's Firefox

1:22:02I guess who ships an update every day, but most app developers, you know shipping stuff over the web

1:22:07We aren't doing like daily updates to their software

1:22:09But as soon as they feel like you know what this is better for customers right now

1:22:13Then then what they had before it led to do a production build and get it out in a web

1:22:18You just did it without really thinking about it that much but the App Store is sort of taking things back the other way

1:22:24we're exactly like you said like you kind of want to

1:22:28You don't want to get a submission in there and then find another bug tomorrow

1:22:32Because then you're gonna have to start the whole thing all over again. You're back at the end of the line

1:22:37You'll never actually release anything

1:22:38So you just have to pick these arbitrary and breaking points to and then and then endure the unknown delay

1:22:43That comes along with that

1:22:46It's like going to the bank to deposit your money and every time you get almost up to the teller you get a phone call

1:22:51That says hey, we've got another check come hurry up

1:22:53Get out of the bank come pick it up and go get back in them get in the back of the line only instead of checks

1:22:57It's it's typos right exactly yeah, and again like with with a book or something where you've got lead time

1:23:03Then just give yourself three weeks to copy edit

1:23:05It just like crowdsource that you know do do you know you can't but you can't do that with news because

1:23:09Right up to the last second information is being at like you know

1:23:12I had my call with Apple three days before the release like you know

1:23:15It's not a lot of time to spare there - you know I added I added the entire Facebook section in like the last two days

1:23:21Just because you know after talking to Apple

1:23:24They they felt like they wanted to promote it and they gave me some good information on so I'm like yeah

1:23:27I'll add that in.

1:23:30It's a difference between the Macworld website and the Macworld magazine.

1:23:33The Macworld magazine's got to be laid out, written up, copy-edited, and just going through

1:23:38the whole printing process and mailed out to people.

1:23:41That's very different than the Macworld website.

1:23:42The Macworld website can say, "Oh, there's an earnings call.

1:23:46We were on the earnings call.

1:23:47We transcribed it.

1:23:48Here's our summary of it."

1:23:49They can do that that day when people want to read about it.

1:23:50But there's not going to be a story in Macworld magazine with a transcript of the earnings

1:23:54call because it's all news by then.

1:23:56So it's just two different contexts.

1:24:00I guess what I wish-- and like I said, in theory,

1:24:02I wish that you did the same thing for iOS

1:24:04that you do for Mac OS X, just because I'm selfish

1:24:06and I enjoy it so much and it would be good.

1:24:09But I would settle for somebody else doing it.

1:24:11But now I had this thought before we did the show

1:24:13that I was going to say that.

1:24:14And then I thought, you know what?

1:24:15The obvious answer is that I should be the one to do it,

1:24:18because I've got all the time in the world.

1:24:20That sounds like a lot of work, doesn't it?

1:24:22It does sound like a lot of work.

1:24:23You haven't done one of those in a while where

1:24:24you do screenshots and stuff?

1:24:25You used to do that more, but you'd have maybe seven screenshots.

1:24:30And even just the minimal number of screenshots, the most screenshots I've ever included in

1:24:35an article, still, to me, it's a pain in the ass.

1:24:37Yeah, because each screenshot is a pain.

1:24:39Anybody out there who's never done that, never written up an article where you'd really illustrate

1:24:43it with screenshots that you intend for lots and lots of people to see, and so you want

1:24:48them to look their best at you, it's really, really hard.

1:24:51Especially where you're doing stuff like a couple of ones you've had about text selection

1:24:54or like what UI elements, and you're trying to arrange the screenshot just so where you're

1:24:57holding down the mouse cursor and you have the selection going or a context menu is up

1:25:01and you got to screenshot it at the same time.

1:25:03Right.

1:25:04And you do end up thinking about things.

1:25:05Once you're paying attention to the details, like where is the blinking eye beam cursor

1:25:08going to be?

1:25:09Is it on or off?

1:25:11Do you want it in there?

1:25:12And if you do, whichever one you want, it still is hard to time, you know, all sorts

1:25:17of things like that.

1:25:18Yeah.

1:25:19And then when you take it again, you want to take it again because it was mistaken the

1:25:22the first one, but now you've got to frame it the same way.

1:25:24Yeah, and you've got the desktop background that's there, and with all the transparent

1:25:28shadows it's so difficult to, like, if you miss something, you can't really erase it

1:25:31because everything is transparent, including, like, the little edge of the windows.

1:25:34So that takes it out of you, and, like, multiply that by 150.

1:25:38I can only imagine doing it on iOS.

1:25:39I'd be, you know, hammering on the little, you know, home button, power button screenshot

1:25:43combo constantly, and then filling up my camera roll with all these iOS screenshots.

1:25:48And then they'd all be at 2x on the big device, and I've got to figure out how to display

1:25:51That was another thing that was new this year, which is like, all right, about a quarter of the way through

1:25:56I realized, you know what? I should be doing all these screenshots in a retina resolution.

1:25:59I don't know why I didn't think about that from the beginning, but I didn't.

1:26:03But then, you know, I guess it was probably because I, you know, the retina macro pro didn't come out until

1:26:07WWDC, so it just wasn't on my mind. I was like, yeah, people, I'm writing about the Mac,

1:26:13I assume people read it on the Mac, I don't need to do 2x screenshots. Plus, I don't have a retina screen,

1:26:17so I have to do that, you know, high DPI mode where I'm looking at this tiny little

1:26:20Thing that's not even my screen is not even big enough to hold like the system preferences window and high DPI

1:26:25All right, it's very difficult to arrange screenshot all of a sudden. It's in mr. Magoo mode

1:26:28Yeah, and like I can't sometimes you can't even get the whole window on the screen all right

1:26:32But then the file yeah, so I started taking my screenshots in high DPI where I run into all these problems

1:26:38But I'm like you know what how do I even display these on the RSC ms?

1:26:41Because you got to do that you know one of the 17 techniques you can use to show retin images to the right people

1:26:45but not have everybody download them because it makes the pages too big and all that stuff and

1:26:50And the RCMS just wasn't ready for it because it was a new type of thing.

1:26:53I figured out how to get it done on the ebooks, but only for two images.

1:26:57One was the actual retina screenshot, which shows up as retina resolution on your Kindle,

1:27:02if you read the Kindle book on your Mac, or on the iOS device, or in iBooks.

1:27:09And I did that for one image and it almost killed me because I had to try the 8,000 different

1:27:12techniques to get it to work. And I also did my author picture in the back for retina resolution.

1:27:18And that was enough, right?

1:27:21Because there's no easy way for you to do it.

1:27:23Every way is a hack, because you've

1:27:25got to use these bogus CSS selectors to exclude

1:27:29the old Kindle readers.

1:27:30And it's a nightmare, right?

1:27:32So I can only imagine doing that for every single image

1:27:35would have required a much more robust solution than I had.

1:27:40But maybe next year, will I have a retina Mac?

1:27:44By next year, will the RCMS natively

1:27:46support red in the images where I can upload a 1x and 2x and it'll serve the right one.

1:27:50I mean if you go to one of the image URLs in my review and you shove the @2x into the

1:27:56file name in the right place and load that image URL, a lot of them you'll get a 2x version

1:27:59but you just won't see them on the website.

1:28:03I mean you've been doing that on Daring Fireball, you've been trying to make the retina version

1:28:07of your favicon and stuff.

1:28:08Oh my god, I spent a whole day on that.

1:28:11Right, and that's one image the size of your pinky nail.

1:28:1416 pixels 16 points. Yeah, so that's a particularly annoying one

1:28:19But like even just like you know

1:28:20The your logo at the top and stuff like that you have to come up you have to kind of decide on the technique and the

1:28:25browsers haven't really settled on if they're using image with source setter I

1:28:29Do the lazy thing with the logo I do I did that. I actually did this a while back with the logo

1:28:34I did it. I think when the iPhone 4 shipped, but I just made it 2x and maybe it's even 3x

1:28:41I don't remember but I might have made it even bigger

1:28:43But I made it like twice as big and I just sized it with the image tag and just said, you know

1:28:48it's if it's 400 if it's really 400 pixels and then in the image tag, it says 200 and

1:28:54And that does the right thing

1:28:58Yeah, just to show you what it means though

1:29:00But it doesn't mean though that inefficiently

1:29:02Everybody gets the big version whether whether you're on a machine that that can has a retina display or not

1:29:08You're not it's not like you're running the verge and I don't have an image heavy site

1:29:11So just doing that one image is probably not a big deal, but just to show you how crazy the the iBooks

1:29:16or the ebook version of the world is the

1:29:19The advice for doing images and iBooks is not to put width and height

1:29:24in your image tags at all hmm and

1:29:27Like when you have screenshots you're like, but no seriously

1:29:32I really want this thing to be displayed in its native pixels because I'm trying to show this is what it looks like on your

1:29:37screen and even when you have a retina version that you want to tell them some measurements

1:29:41so it doesn't just say oh we're just gonna take this image and stretch it to the full

1:29:44width of the current viewing device or book like no don't do that please don't stretch

1:29:49it for me like because that's the big thing about my screenshots that's why I was so happy

1:29:52when I could finally start using pings is you want to know what like the new doc looks

1:29:55like I'm going to show you an exact pixel accurate representation of the new doc no

1:29:59jpeg compression no gif 256 color things here's the actual pixels and if I can't even tell

1:30:05you what width it is and you're just gonna take it and stretch it to the full width of

1:30:07the reader and I don't know what width that is?

1:30:10It just pains me.

1:30:11It's like that's not... obviously ebooks are not meant for operating system reviews with

1:30:15pixel art in them.

1:30:16But that's what I'm making, so it's a real mismatch there.

1:30:20The web is a little bit better, at least the web, they do want you to write the size in

1:30:24points or whatever and then show the 1x or the 2x version, but if your stuff was just

1:30:28arbitrarily scaled, that's very sad.

1:30:32Yeah, that's it's funny.

1:30:35I think that's not happening to you.

1:30:39No, definitely not.

1:30:41No.

1:30:42The other thing too, and I think like, and it didn't occur to me until years in.

1:30:46It occurred, this isn't the first year where I thought I wish that John or somebody were

1:30:51doing what, you know, to iOS releases, you know, this copious documentation, opinionated

1:30:58documentation, like telling a decade long story of the evolution.

1:31:02that's really what it is. I mean, that's the thing that really makes the reviews,

1:31:05your reviews celebrated is it's each one in and of itself does stand by itself

1:31:10and you can just read it and as if you're just got on board with the Mac now

1:31:14and don't care about what happened before you can just read it and learn

1:31:18something and get you know appreciate your take on it but it's a it's a piece

1:31:24of a greater single work which is the whole all of them together back-to-back

1:31:29telling this like 10 11 12 year old story at this point I guess it's like 12

1:31:33years 13 is it 99 was the first DP - because that's part then that's the

1:31:39genius is that you somehow had the foresight at the beginning to say I'm

1:31:43gonna start writing these articles I don't know if you had the idea at the

1:31:46beginning that you'll do it for everyone going forward but you had the idea right

1:31:51at the beginning two years before it ever even hit the consumers I mean did

1:31:58Did you get, is the first one you wrote the first release?

1:32:01There was Developer Preview 1, which I don't even know if I ever even ran that, but I wasn't

1:32:08writing for ours at all.

1:32:09The first thing I wrote for ours was a review of the book Infinite Loop, which is still

1:32:13a pretty good book about early Apple history.

1:32:16That was the first thing I wrote.

1:32:17That was in 1999.

1:32:19And then the next thing I said, "Hey, you know, there's the Developer Preview 2 of this

1:32:25thing called Mac OS X coming out, which is supposed to be Apple's next generation operating

1:32:28system strategy.

1:32:29Ha ha, yeah, the number five in the series, collect them all.

1:32:33But I think it's kind of interesting.

1:32:34Why don't I write something about that?

1:32:37And if you asked, did I think I would be still doing it 13 years later?

1:32:40I didn't think Apple would be in business 13 years later.

1:32:43This was not, I guess, 1999, it's pre-iPod, right?

1:32:49It's post-iMac, so there's a glimmer of hope, and Steve Jobs is back.

1:32:53But there have been so many next generation operating system strategies and so much sadness.

1:32:57And then this new thing they were doing, the main reason I wanted to write about it, because

1:33:00this new thing they were doing seemed so un-Mac-like.

1:33:02Like BOS, I was all on board with that.

1:33:05That it was kind of the sum of the same guys, it was Gase, it looked like, yeah, that's

1:33:11what we think the next generation of the Mac should look like.

1:33:13But then they bought Next, and you're like, I know Next.

1:33:15But Next is like, that's not Mac-like.

1:33:18And it was just weird to me.

1:33:19And so it seemed like, but it also had a crossover with Unix, which I was heavily into, and I'm

1:33:25like, well, this could be interesting, but it's definitely weird.

1:33:27It seemed like something Mac users should know about, because I didn't think anyone

1:33:29was paying attention.

1:33:30I'm like, hey guys, look what's going on over here.

1:33:32They're taking like Next Step and trying to make, you know, putting some weird Mac graphics

1:33:36on it, but it still looks all weird.

1:33:37Remember, this is pre-Aqua, right?

1:33:39So no one knew what the hell this was gonna be.

1:33:40It looked like a Platinum OS laid on top of Next Step with this weird, badly behaving

1:33:45thing and none of your Mac apps ran right and it was just, it seemed like something

1:33:51that people needed to know about it.

1:33:52And even when I wrote about it, I was amazed that people said, "Wow, I didn't even know

1:33:56they were doing this."

1:33:57It's like, people weren't following Apple like they are now.

1:33:58Nobody was following them.

1:33:59No one was like looking at every WWC keynote.

1:34:02They announced this at WWC, they said, "We're doing this thing called Mac."

1:34:05First they were doing Rhapsody and that kind of fizzled, which was based on similar technology.

1:34:09And then, "Oh, actually we're doing this thing called Mac OS X and we're going to have enhanced

1:34:12QuickDraw."

1:34:13And everyone was like, "Yeah, yeah."

1:34:14Like people weren't following it.

1:34:15So I was the only person on the web writing about this at all, you know, because who else

1:34:18was even paying attention?

1:34:19So Rhapsody was a much more easily understood story where long story short, the pitch on

1:34:26Rhapsody was, okay, forget the Mac OS, just forget it.

1:34:29That's old.

1:34:30And it was running the country on the ground.

1:34:33Now you've got this new thing from next.

1:34:35We called it next step.

1:34:36We'll just give it a new name now because the name never really, you know, we'll get

1:34:40rid of the next name over.

1:34:41Just call it Rhapsody.

1:34:42make it look better and you're gonna we're gonna replace in your next computer will be running

1:34:47the next version of what was next step more or less and then there would be like a you know

1:34:53a compatibility layer where you could run mac apps in a classic thing and it just didn't fly

1:35:00it just didn't fly at all because apple just didn't have the the they weren't in a position

1:35:08of leverage over third-party developers they were at the other end of it where like they announced

1:35:12this thing at WWDC and that everybody at WWDC was like, "Nope, we're not going to support

1:35:17that." And instead of, "Yeah, yeah, yeah, good luck, you're going to be doing it," it

1:35:23was actually at that point in '97 when people like Adobe and Microsoft were like, "Well,

1:35:28we're not rewriting our apps for that." That meant that's not going to fly. And that was

1:35:33it. Effectively, I would even go so far as to argue that at that point, Adobe probably

1:35:39single-handedly had the ability to shit-can it.

1:35:43If Adobe said-- well, Adobe combined with Microsoft.

1:35:47That if Adobe-- if Office-- and it wasn't called the CS suite

1:35:51yet, but Adobe's professional graphic design tools,

1:35:55Photoshop and Illustrator and the other ones like that.

1:36:01If they weren't going to run on it, then it wasn't going to fly.

1:36:04Because Apple financially depended upon--

1:36:07I mean almost completely people who were buying Macs to run Adobe software and/or off Microsoft

1:36:15Office.

1:36:16John: Yeah, at that point there was nobody who cared as much about Apple's thing business

1:36:20as Apple did.

1:36:21Like no one's business was dependent on them.

1:36:22Even Adobe, most of their sales had gone to Windows, Microsoft.

1:36:25I mean Bill Gates famously said about Next Step before it was acquired by Apple, "Are

1:36:29you going to develop for the next computer?

1:36:31Develop for it?

1:36:32I'll piss on it."

1:36:33That's one of the better Bill Gates quotes.

1:36:37No one wants to rewrite their apps for a new platform unless their business is so incredibly

1:36:40tied to yours, like, "Oh my God, all of our customers are on Macs, and if this is where

1:36:44the Apple operating system is going, that's where all of our customers are going to get,

1:36:47and we need to port our application to that."

1:36:50Nobody was in that position.

1:36:51Important guys or little guys, you know?

1:36:52And you know, I can see, I actually don't even blame...

1:36:55At the time, I thought it was cute, and I wasn't really on board with the whole next

1:36:58thing.

1:36:59I mean, you know, I saw it as arrogant, I think, more at the time.

1:37:03Foolishly arrogant.

1:37:04I can kind of see in hindsight where they were coming from,

1:37:07where it surely would have been a lot easier,

1:37:10and it would have shipped a lot sooner,

1:37:11if, let's say, Adobe and Microsoft had said,

1:37:14you know what, this does look good.

1:37:16And we've always been a little intrigued by the whole,

1:37:20you know, what everybody now calls cocoa,

1:37:23you know, this whole development thing,

1:37:25and it looks pretty good, does look fast,

1:37:26but we couldn't get on board before

1:37:28because the next user base was so small.

1:37:30But now that you're bringing this

1:37:31to the tens of millions of devoted Mac users,

1:37:34this does look good, we're happy to do this,

1:37:37let's help us, let's all work together

1:37:39and make Coco Photoshop in 1997.

1:37:41That it would have been a lot easier for Apple

1:37:45and it would have been a simpler system

1:37:47and it would have been a smaller,

1:37:50effectively it would have been a lot like what we think

1:37:52of what iOS has turned out to be.

1:37:55- But it kind of turned out to be a blessing though

1:37:57because it wasn't ready.

1:37:59It was not ready for people to use it.

1:38:01It was slow, all the APIs we take for granted

1:38:03not there, didn't exist at all.

1:38:06The quartz display layer was just dog slow.

1:38:09There was no core data, no core animation, no core, but none of the core APIs really

1:38:13existed.

1:38:14I guess it was core audio maybe back then.

1:38:17Everything was just in shambles there.

1:38:18They built bundled applications where ugly ports of their next versions.

1:38:23If you had tried to bring Microsoft Office to Rhapsody, it would have been like Word

1:38:306.0.

1:38:31It would have been like a disaster.

1:38:32They just weren't ready.

1:38:34And so this more gradual transition where they had to go back to the drawing board and

1:38:38they had carbon, carbon was super important to not just the success of the operating system,

1:38:43but just to making it pleasant for people.

1:38:45I mean, IE5 for Mac OS X was a carbon application, right?

1:38:49And it was omniweb and everything, but you needed IE to do your quote unquote "real web

1:38:55browsing" because who the heck is going to use omniweb and things didn't quite look right.

1:38:58all these these carbon apps, you needed them not just because that's how you got developers on

1:39:03board, but because those were the apps people knew and loved. And even if they could port them

1:39:08overnight, it wouldn't be the same, like, it just wasn't ready. Right? No, and, you know, and I do

1:39:14think that that in the long term, you could see it as a blessing in disguise. And maybe, you know,

1:39:18because effectively, they did eventually get what they wanted, but with iOS, I think, but I think it

1:39:23was a lot better off. And maybe, you know, it was so much better off, because all of those other

1:39:28technologies were ready by 2007 when I was shipped. And they could do things like have

1:39:35really, really fast, fluid scrolling and response times.

1:39:40Yeah, they got, they basically they took this this operating system that was slow bloated

1:39:44piece of crap in 1999. And they got it so it's fast enough and tight enough that it

1:39:49runs on a phone. And that's that's a quite a quite a transition.

1:39:52Alright, let me do the second sponsor and then we'll wrap up.

1:39:58Our second sponsor is IdeaBucket.

1:40:02IdeaBucket is an iOS app.

1:40:05It used to be an iPad app.

1:40:06The new version, I think it's out today, is universal for iPad and iPhone.

1:40:13And it's an app for helping you make decisions.

1:40:17Really, really cool UI, really, really neat idea.

1:40:21The idea is you could use this for something like picking your next job, choosing which

1:40:27TV to buy, picking a name for a pet or even like name for your next child, choosing where

1:40:33to go to vacation, anything like that where you have a whole bunch of choices to make.

1:40:38And so the flow is simple.

1:40:39It's a simple orderly thing.

1:40:41You create a bucket for a decision you have to make and you add all of your ideas.

1:40:47then you create criteria to rank these ideas and you rate them.

1:40:51So you create a criteria and you can say which end of it is bad, which is good, like for

1:40:56a vacation place you could say temperature, whether a thing is too hot or too cold, a

1:41:01place is too hot or too cold for the time you're taking a vacation.

1:41:06And then you rank these criteria, which criteria are more important for you.

1:41:11Once you've set that up, you can create custom reports based on the weight of the criteria

1:41:16and the rankings that you've applied to each of these criteria for each of the choices

1:41:20in your decision, and you get these custom sliders to let you adjust them.

1:41:26And then you see your results with three different reports.

1:41:28The first is an overall highlight of your results displayed on a cool sort of slanty

1:41:33line thing.

1:41:35You kind of have to see it to understand it, but it's really, really cool.

1:41:37If you see the movie on their web page, you'll see exactly what I mean.

1:41:43The second is sort of a straightforward bar chart that ranks them, and the third is the

1:41:47most powerful.

1:41:48It lets you view a sort of scatter chart based on two selectable criteria at a time.

1:41:54So anytime you want to make a decision, this is a great app to fire up and do it.

1:41:59I have not seen any other app that tries to solve this exact same problem.

1:42:03Really, really cool.

1:42:06They just launched the Universal today, like I said.

1:42:08It's in the App Store for the iPhone and the iPad and for a very limited time it's only

1:42:1399 cents.

1:42:15One buck.

1:42:16So if you want to support the show, you want to support cool apps for the iPhone and iPad,

1:42:2099 cents.

1:42:21Go get IdeaBucket.

1:42:23You can find out more at ideabucket.me.

1:42:27It's a .me domain.

1:42:29IdeaBucket.me and you can find it in the App Store for 99 cents.

1:42:34That's it.

1:42:35One buck.

1:42:36Great app.

1:42:37So the thing I've gone back to the why doesn't why isn't there someone doing

1:42:42what you do with Mac OS 10 reviews with iOS the other thing that occurs to me is

1:42:45that it wasn't so clear at the beginning that iOS was an OS I mean we knew it I

1:42:50knew it was I mean I'm technically savvy enough you know that I know that there's

1:42:53a different OS I know it wasn't OS 10 it was this other thing that was an offshoot

1:42:57based on similar technologies but I didn't really think of it as an OS like

1:43:02in the abstract way that Mac OS 10 has always clearly been an OS where it was

1:43:06this software that you could buy on a disk. It was on a disk. It was pure software. And

1:43:12that in theory, Apple could have, you know, and for years and years and years, people

1:43:17used to tell them they should do it. They could make it a version that ran on any PC.

1:43:21And you could just go to a store and buy this Mac OS 10 and have a version that you could

1:43:26put in a Dell shitbox and install it. It's an OS. It's a software that runs a computer.

1:43:34You know, and even the early DP reviews, it was very clear that it was abstracted from

1:43:39the computers it ran on.

1:43:40Because you never, you didn't buy computers that ran Rhapsody Developer Preview 2.

1:43:45You bought computers that came with Mac OS 9, and then you would get this disk from ADC

1:43:50and put it in and install it.

1:43:52It was clearly an OS.

1:43:53Whereas like circa 2007, it was like the iPhone that we were writing about.

1:43:59And we sort of, at least I did, I just sort of took it as a whole.

1:44:03You know like everything I wrote about the iOS wasn't or about iOS was really in the context of writing about the iPhone

1:44:10Remember where they call the updates it was a firmware update. I do remember that I do

1:44:14500 megabytes of firmware right and I remember kind of rolling my eye at that and I remember thinking like I

1:44:20Remember thinking that it was it must have been a curious behind-the-scenes

1:44:23Discussion as to what to call that

1:44:26I mean like and I knew that it wasn't really firmware in the sense to call it whatever you want

1:44:31But it's you know it's an OS update

1:44:33But it just wouldn't have occurred to me to do that at the beginning well

1:44:38It didn't become an didn't become an OS in most people's eyes until it accepted third-party applications because then you've got a platform

1:44:43All right who cares what OS the iPads are on that pics at pixio thing no one cared about that because if you can't write

1:44:49Apps for it. That's what it's not so much that we thought as pure software

1:44:52But like once you can write apps for it all now you've got an OS on your hand so as soon as the app store

1:44:57But all this is an OS you know you're writing an application on an OS

1:45:01And they had that naming stuff. Oh, that's such a weird

1:45:04You know iPhone OS makes some sense, but you know, it's gonna be on more than iPhones

1:45:09I mean it was always an iPod touch right? So why is it called iPhone us? Well, whatever and

1:45:14There was like for like five minutes. They wanted to call it OS 10

1:45:19Which would be distinct from Mac OS 10. Do you remember that fine? Yeah, I do remember that. No, I do remember that

1:45:25I think even wrote about it on during fireball when I was like and this is getting really really confusing because

1:45:30everybody I know just calls Mac OS X OS X. They already call it that, even if

1:45:36Apple doesn't officially call it. And then just two years later now Apple

1:45:41calls Mac OS X OS X, which was the name that for, yeah like you said, for five

1:45:45minutes they were using to call. It wasn't so much, was it that they were

1:45:50calling iOS OS X? Yeah, they hadn't come up with iOS yet, it was iPhone OS and

1:45:55you should look back in the post, but I'm pretty sure it was like they was

1:45:58distinguishing OS X, which runs on things that aren't Macs, and then there's Mac OS

1:46:03X, which runs on Macs.

1:46:04Right.

1:46:05It was very confusing.

1:46:07It was like – OS X was like the umbrella term that encompassed iPhone OS and also the

1:46:11thing that ran on iPod touches.

1:46:12Right.

1:46:13That's the way I more saw it.

1:46:14It was OS X was like – was a parent umbrella technology.

1:46:21And from OS X came two children, Mac OS X and iPhone OS.

1:46:27Yeah, it was definitely confusing.

1:46:32It definitely helped sort of avoid, it helped keep me from thinking about it distinctively

1:46:37as just an OS.

1:46:40And there are other little things too that if someone, if I had been trying to do this,

1:46:45trying to do to iOS what you do to Mac OS X as it goes and write about each release

1:46:52like mini book length form like what I buy it would I would it have occurred to

1:46:56me to do a version of it a release for the iPad the original iPad which had

1:47:01like a really weird version number it was like through a three to two or

1:47:05something like that yes something like that it was like the original iPad key

1:47:10I ship with like version 3.2 to of iPhone OS but the iPhone never got 3.2

1:47:15anything the iPhone was on 3.1 and then the iPhone got 3.3 and the iPad was still

1:47:20on 3.2.4. And it was, you know, it took them quite a while to get them squared up onto

1:47:28one release. But, and, you know, technically it was like they kind of temporarily forked

1:47:32it.

1:47:33It's like when you used to get like the new Mac hardware in order to come with a special

1:47:36enabler.

1:47:37Yes.

1:47:38Remember the enablers? Just for that piece of hardware, because they just released the

1:47:40new Mac.

1:47:41Right. And it would be like, you'd be running like, there's one Mac that can run System

1:47:477.52 enabler B. I forget, it was like enabler something. It was a little thing. But there

1:47:53was only one Mac in the world that could run it. And at least until the next version of

1:47:58the OS came out, that Mac could run no other software. If you booted from an external hard

1:48:03drive that had a generic system 7.52 installed, it wouldn't even get to the Happy Mac.

1:48:13I think there are people out there who do every kind of review you could imagine for

1:48:20every operating system. This year was one of the first years that people were putting

1:48:23out reviews that were actually longer than my reviews. Not by much, but still longer.

1:48:29That's always bothered me when people... The thing people remember about my reviews or

1:48:33tease me about is how long they are, but as far as I'm concerned, it's not the length

1:48:37and certainly not the comprehensiveness, because I'm keenly aware of all the things I omit.

1:48:43So that's a double-edged sword, like, "Oh, your thing is so long.

1:48:45Yeah, right, it is long."

1:48:46But then they say, "Yeah, but why didn't you talk about this, and why didn't you talk about

1:48:48that, and you missed this?"

1:48:49It's like, sometimes they did miss it, but sometimes, like, "Geez, it's so long already,

1:48:52you think I should have put more stuff in?"

1:48:54And that's always not been the emphasis of my review, is not a comprehensive tour of

1:48:58the features that are available, or "Let me show you every single pixel that changed in

1:49:02the entire operating system."

1:49:04It seems like that if you don't yourself know everything that changed, and I'm pointing

1:49:08out some minute thing, but the minute thing that I choose to point out is based on what

1:49:13I think is important, and just because I point out that minute thing doesn't mean that everything

1:49:16less minute, anything larger, I caught as well, you know?

1:49:21And it amazes me how I can get away with that.

1:49:23For example, in my Lion review, I did not mention airdrop once, and nobody asked about

1:49:28it.

1:49:29That is a major headlining feature of the operating system on Apple's website, and I

1:49:32didn't mention it once.

1:49:33There's a variety of reasons why I might leave something out, but if you want that where

1:49:37someone goes through every single thing and screenshots every single app and finds every

1:49:40single new thing, you can find that out there.

1:49:43And that's not what I think I'm delivering.

1:49:45So for someone to do a similar review to mine to iOS, it wouldn't necessarily have to be

1:49:49long or cover every minute detail.

1:49:52It would have to be somebody who has been with iOS since day one, which, like I said,

1:49:56is not hard to find, and is really invested in not just iOS, but in the entire history

1:50:01of mobile operating system and what iOS means in that context, all the way going back to

1:50:06like they were a heavy Treo user and they had to, you know, they're using a

1:50:10razor and a StarTAC and like just their hardcore mobile handheld operating

1:50:15system device aficionados who happen to have a keen interest in iOS and like are

1:50:21gonna put everything in context because that's what I think I'm bringing to the

1:50:24Mac reviews is perspective and history and all the things you get when you're

1:50:29old I guess. That's what I've got to provide now is wisdom and

1:50:32experience. And I guess I'm speaking to other people who are similarly decrepit

1:50:38and old and have those similar experiences and they can understand that

1:50:42context. And maybe I'm losing my audience for people who are younger and

1:50:45just want to know what the new features are or whatever, but for any type

1:50:50of thing that's what I'm looking for. Somebody who I can tell, you know,

1:50:53if they're reading washing machines, they are a washing machine

1:50:57aficionado and they've been writing about washing machines for decades and

1:51:02know the history of washing machines, they know where this one falls in the pantheon

1:51:05of washing machines. That's what I want to read, you know?

1:51:08Right, and it's definitely more about the story. Like I said, it's the connection between

1:51:13the previous reviews, where you combine them and you get a sense of a story. There's a

1:51:19why as to, you know, here's the direction they're going. And I think it's best exemplified

1:51:24by your writing about the file, not file system, but the document saving changes, which haven't

1:51:34it they haven't all come at once. And they've been sort of like, well, here's sort of where

1:51:39we're going to start going with it. And maybe the high DPI stuff is sort of like that, too.

1:51:43Where, you know, although I think Apple kind of changed direction on that, from where we

1:51:49envisioned it years ago being more like an arbitrarily resizable thing, where all the

1:51:53Graphics or PDFs or some kind of you know vector graphics to the no no. No, we've that that was all problematic

1:52:00We're just gonna go to X everything's twice as big

1:52:03Yeah, but with the document saving stuff and the the way that because you you know

1:52:09Like Matt Newberg had an article I linked to that did a really really good job of going into some of these details of the

1:52:13way this new

1:52:15Whatever you want to call the whole collective thing the new modern document Mac system

1:52:22Thing works, but the thing you've covered well is

1:52:24addressing the what's the problem Apple is trying to solve and

1:52:28It's the fact that I think this was in your mountain line review, but I know that you wrote this where it's specifically that

1:52:35This whole paradigm of how Mac OS X interface starts works with and how people interact with documents started in

1:52:431984 and really they started planning it before that at a time when everything was being saved to 400 kilobyte floppy disks

1:52:51where literally every single byte was precious and almost every floppy disk you owned was like filled up to the rim and

1:52:57You really kind of needed to have the user in charge of every single thing that was going on to the disk because the space

1:53:04Was so precious and it took good thing like 10 15 seconds to save your word document a little

1:53:09Right, right, you'd say, you know, right it really and it really kind of required that the you know

1:53:16I overuse this analogy, but it's you know required you the the

1:53:21file system saving equivalent of a stick shift on a car, where you were in complete control

1:53:26over what gear, you know, the car is in it every time. You really kind of needed to be

1:53:30in charge of everything that got written to disk and when. Not yet, like you point out,

1:53:35because you didn't want to go too long without saving because a crash, you'd lose everything,

1:53:40and you didn't want to save too frequently because a save would take time.

1:53:44And you can't, you couldn't do anything while it was saved.

1:53:46No. You couldn't watch cursor.

1:53:47You couldn't type, you couldn't pull down a menu, you couldn't, you know, sorry.

1:53:50Go to another app.

1:53:51No, you're waiting.

1:53:51- This guy was happening.

1:53:53- Right.

1:53:53I remember when copying--

1:53:58- Multiple files at once, yeah.

1:53:59That was a hell of a WAC demo.

1:54:01- I remember when copying files was modal.

1:54:05- Oh yeah, no, I remember the first time

1:54:07I was ever technically impressed

1:54:09by another desktop operating system,

1:54:11being a smug Mac user that I was

1:54:12in the '80s or whatever, is when I saw a friend of mine,

1:54:17He had OS/2, and he copied a document onto a floppy disk

1:54:21and then went off to do other things

1:54:22while the file copied onto the floppy disk.

1:54:24And it was like, that's amazing.

1:54:25How do you do anything else while something's

1:54:28copying to a floppy disk?

1:54:29And he's like preemptive multitasking.

1:54:30Wow, on a desktop operating system.

1:54:33And you really, really don't appreciate it.

1:54:35That's one of those things where you just

1:54:36don't appreciate how slow those disks were

1:54:38until your attention was completely focused

1:54:41on the screen and there was nothing

1:54:42you could do until it was finished.

1:54:44But you really needed that.

1:54:45And all of these paradigms of how this works

1:54:47and that you say command N to make a new document

1:54:51and nothing is saved or blah, blah, blah,

1:54:54nothing is written to disk until you do command S

1:54:57and you pick a place and you pick a name

1:55:00and you hit return in that dialogue box.

1:55:03There was a reason for that,

1:55:05but there is no reason for that

1:55:06to be the dominant model today where people, you know,

1:55:11I would be curious to know,

1:55:14I think it'd be like a really interesting stat

1:55:16is what percentage of their startup disk

1:55:18is free space of an average Mac today?

1:55:22It's not just a free space.

1:55:23It's like, you know how long it takes

1:55:24to save your text document?

1:55:27It's like fractions of seconds.

1:55:29Especially with an SSD?

1:55:30Especially with an SSD.

1:55:32With any of the modern Macs that ship with an SSD,

1:55:36I don't even know that you could measure it.

1:55:38Yeah, it's incredibly fast.

1:55:40And most of the time, what it has to do with things

1:55:42that don't have to do with actually writing the bits

1:55:44It's just almost infinitely fast.

1:55:47So it's like it's a situation where there's a paradigm for dealing with documents developed

1:55:51at a time when the paradigm was appropriate, and then all the conditions surrounding it

1:55:55changed with the exception of the users who still have that original paradigm in their

1:56:00mind.

1:56:01And so the paradigm makes no sense anymore, but that's like it's the -- it gets back to

1:56:04that Joel Spolsky usability book, and I don't know if he originated this idea, but like

1:56:09when the user's mental model doesn't match the program's model of how things should work,

1:56:13you have, it's a usability problem.

1:56:16And tons of users have that old model, tons of technically savvy users have that old model

1:56:21in their mind of how things are supposed to work.

1:56:23But that old way has all the problems that, this was actually in my line of view, I listed

1:56:27all the problems that the old way has of like accidentally forgetting to save, thing crashing

1:56:31in the middle, you saving over an old version on top of a new one, people reinventing versioning

1:56:35by putting my document, my document two, my document three, my document final V2.

1:56:39I mean, you've all seen these file names, right?

1:56:42these anti-patterns that have to do with the old model and people just are wed to those.

1:56:48And so even though they make no sense anymore and the operating system could do something

1:56:51for you, now you have a situation with Lion and Forward where the mental model of the

1:56:55technically savvy users does not match the model of the operating system.

1:57:00And that's a bad situation.

1:57:01It makes people unhappy.

1:57:03They just want it to go back to the old way.

1:57:04But Apple is trying...

1:57:05I mean, Apple, it's so great that iOS exists because if the iOS didn't exist and they were

1:57:10doing these same things, it'd be so much harder for me to convince people.

1:57:13It's already hard, but now I can just say, "Look, look at iOS.

1:57:17Have you ever been in an iOS app?"

1:57:18And you're like, "This app would be awesome if it only had a save button."

1:57:22Nobody ever says it.

1:57:23Apple proved that because there was no existing mental model, like, "This is a new thing.

1:57:28You've never used it before.

1:57:29Look at this crazy thing that you swipe your little thumb on.

1:57:30It's all touch screen."

1:57:31And they decided, "No saving.

1:57:33Sorry, it doesn't exist.

1:57:35No quitting apps, no saving.

1:57:37All that stuff is out the window because they knew that we had the technology for those

1:57:40things to be pointless.

1:57:42It works and people love it, but why do people hate it so much on the Mac?

1:57:45Because they have a different mental model over there.

1:57:47Apple's just trying to get over that hump to say, "Come on, guys.

1:57:49We know this can be better.

1:57:51You all love your iOS apps, right?

1:57:53No saving there.

1:57:54Isn't that awesome?

1:57:55Yeah, but on my Mac, but no."

1:57:57I just have to wait for all of us to die before they get over that hump, or does the Mac just

1:58:02go away?

1:58:04It's a tough situation for them to be in, but I'm totally on board with what they're

1:58:07trying to do.

1:58:08I see all the benefits of it.

1:58:10I just sympathize with the problem they face.

1:58:14They've proven that the better way can work, and it's the same people who are using these

1:58:19Macs probably love their iOS devices, and yet they can't get people to accept anything

1:58:23close to that model.

1:58:24The other problem, of course, that I go into more in the Mountain Lion review is that MacOS

1:58:2810 isn't iOS, and stuff that works on iOS is partly because it's a clean sheet, and

1:58:33And the Mac is like in this in-betweeny stage where some stuff kind of wants to work on

1:58:36the iOS model, but a whole other parts of the operating system don't want to work that

1:58:41way.

1:58:42And so you're like, "I'm not sure how this is going to behave.

1:58:44Is it going to behave like this new crazy iOS way, or is it going to behave like the

1:58:47old Mac way?"

1:58:48And people can't suss it out.

1:58:50So...

1:58:51Yeah.

1:58:52And I do think, too, that the whole new style document model and all these rules, and it's

1:58:57not just one simple thing that you have to sign on for as a developer, but if you're

1:59:00on board with it. All of it works way better, in my opinion, with iCloud documents, documents

1:59:07in the cloud, whatever they call it, than documents on your file system. Even though

1:59:12technically the iCloud documents are somewhere in your file system, in your library folders,

1:59:17you know, something, something. But they're all, you don't see it. You're not supposed

1:59:20to see it. It's, you know, it's an implementation detail. And it makes more conceptual sense

1:59:25there than when you mix and match it with the, but I still want to be able to get to

1:59:29it through the finder because then you're still doing half of the things that are based

1:59:35on the old model which is…

1:59:37Yeah, because the finder still exists, you know.

1:59:39So they didn't make it go away which I think is good but then you've got this weird situation,

1:59:44you know.

1:59:45Right.

1:59:46The OpenSave dialog by itself is schizophrenic.

1:59:48Here's the iCloud version.

1:59:49Here's the regular version.

1:59:50Right.

1:59:51Because it used to be that if you knew where the file was, it's in your documents/project

1:59:57folder and you had created it with bbedit but now you want to open it in

2:00:02this other app you knew what you could do is you could just go in the finder to

2:00:07that folder and then there's the file and you could drag it on the app or you

2:00:10could go to that other app and hit command O and navigate to that location

2:00:14there now all of that's gone but you can still open it you can still open a

2:00:18document that was made and let's say text edit because text edit does I you

2:00:23know iCloud documents but you have to go to just like iOS it's not where is it in

2:00:29the file system it's what app is it in and you go to that app and you go to

2:00:33your iCloud documents for that app and then you drag it out of there and this

2:00:37is all to get around the fact that people who are not listening to the show

2:00:40have no idea where their stuff is in the file system like we all know how to

2:00:43navigate the file system but experience has shown that you know like it no

2:00:47matter how much you can't solve this with education there's just something

2:00:50about the hierarchy that we've had it for decades

2:00:52and that most people still don't get it.

2:00:54And so that's why at iOS they said,

2:00:56"Forget about it, that doesn't even exist.

2:00:57"We're not even showing it anywhere."

2:00:59And lo and behold, people love iOS,

2:01:00feel like they can use it,

2:01:02and just like regular people

2:01:03have a better experience with iOS.

2:01:05There's nothing you can do to make the ease of use better

2:01:09to make that the paradigm of documents

2:01:12in an arbitrary hierarchy

2:01:13that you can open with various applications.

2:01:16It's just, it just doesn't, people just don't get it.

2:01:19So Apple showed that the other way can work

2:01:22and now they've got this other platform

2:01:23that's back in the old way

2:01:24and they would like to move it forward into that way

2:01:25while also not angering the existing people too much.

2:01:28It's like I said in this year's review,

2:01:31it's an operating system in transition.

2:01:33- Right.

2:01:34They don't even think about,

2:01:35I think the big difference is that

2:01:37it's not that they struggled,

2:01:38that people, like we tend to think,

2:01:40I tend to think of the file system as like a where.

2:01:43Where is it in the file system?

2:01:45Where?

2:01:46And I think for the people who don't get it,

2:01:48don't even get that far. It's just to them, it's just all they see is a jumble of complexity and

2:01:53and maybe they can get that it's a hierarchy, you know, that there's things folders within folders

2:02:00and stuff like that. But the whole conceptually it just never even clicks as a where thing.

2:02:04And now I tend to think of the iOS style and the iCloud document style that still is where,

2:02:11where is the document? It's in the app. Right? But I don't think most people most people don't

2:02:15don't even think about that. They just go to the app. They just go to the app and they

2:02:19know that the document is there. But they don't really think of it in terms of asking

2:02:23the question where.

2:02:24Yeah, I think iOS is also insulated by, somewhat by, the typical purpose of mobile applications.

2:02:31You know, communication, or checking your email, and stuff like that. There are other

2:02:36tasks that I still think regular people do, like basic word processing, or printing out

2:02:40a picture for your lost cat, or something. Like, there's still computing tasks that regular

2:02:45non-technically savvy people do that nevertheless are beyond the typical realm of things that

2:02:52people do even on an iPad.

2:02:54And so that's why personal computers still exist and still need to exist.

2:02:58And if iOS was faced with those problems of like, how do people collaborate working on

2:03:03a project where they're just building a family tree together?

2:03:06There's so many tasks that I've seen regular people pull off with a Mac or a PC that using

2:03:14a document model and a paradigm for data sharing that simply does not exist in iOS and would

2:03:19be difficult to pull off because you're like, "Geez, how do you create something using more

2:03:25than one application to help create it on iOS?"

2:03:27There's just no solution for that right now, no good solution, no solution that anyone's

2:03:30going to figure out.

2:03:31But on a Mac or PC, a bunch of kids at the school newspaper can figure out how to put

2:03:35together a newspaper using seven applications.

2:03:38You can't put together a newspaper using seven applications on an iPad.

2:03:41You can do it with one awesome application maybe, and maybe that's the model Apple wants,

2:03:44but iOS kind of gets a pass on this,

2:03:48but it's like the things it's designed to do,

2:03:50it does so amazingly well,

2:03:52and the things that it's not quite designed to do yet,

2:03:55oh, well, the trucks can handle out the Macs or the PCs,

2:03:58and so it's a tough spot for the desktop.

2:04:01- Yeah, I wrote a piece for Macworld

2:04:04on sort of along similar lines, I think about two years ago,

2:04:06and I think the line I use, I could Google it,

2:04:08but let me see if I can Google it.

2:04:11- What was the article?

2:04:13I'll quote it back to you.

2:04:14I think it was the heaviness of the Mac is what allows the iOS to be so light.

2:04:19HOFFMANM: Yep, I remember that one. That's about as close as I would get to the quote, though.

2:04:23STEWART: But the sentiment was there. That it's the Mac's willingness to

2:04:27at least allow this complexity is what allows iOS to disallow that complexity,

2:04:35which complexity is occasionally very, very useful or even essential to certain workflows.

2:04:40And I do think, and I also think that fundamentally, I mean, we can't get into a huge discussion of,

2:04:44we got to wrap this up. But I do think that's the thing that makes me so deeply skeptical about

2:04:50Windows 8. And it's sort of, we can do it all in one OS idea is that it's not going to have

2:05:00any of the appeal, it might be a better version of Windows as we know it, but it's not going to

2:05:05to have any of the things that make iOS so appealing.

2:05:09Yeah, it's not going to have that comfort and simplicity and just like, you know, clean

2:05:17sheet breath of fresh air.

2:05:20Right.

2:05:21I'm not bringing any of my baggage with me.

2:05:22Because that's the difference.

2:05:24The user is different in that case.

2:05:25The same user goes from a Mac to an iOS device and they bring with them a different mindset,

2:05:29and that's what makes iOS work, because their mind is changed.

2:05:32I really do think it's lost among the tech set, the real nerds like us and the people

2:05:38who listen to our shows and stuff like that.

2:05:40And even the people, not even going to people who tend to be sort of against Apple or you

2:05:46know, whatever you want to call them, Apple haters, whatever.

2:05:50But even people who like Apple but are technically minded.

2:05:53We just tend not to think of the iPad as a computer and it's not even getting into things

2:05:58like whether it should count in IDC market share numbers or something like that.

2:06:01We just do think of it as something else

2:06:03But I really do think that you know, you have to understand that profoundly for most people really is a computer

2:06:08It may not be their only computer

2:06:10But they're doing things on it that they associate with computing and they're reading PDFs and they're doing their email and they're surfing the web

2:06:17A lot. I mean that's one thing that we have metrics on that

2:06:20We know that people are surfing the web a lot on iPads

2:06:23and

2:06:25It is I mean it's I just don't think there's any way to deny it

2:06:29It's the first OS that's broken the Windows--

2:06:34what's the word-- hegemony?

2:06:36How do you pronounce that?

2:06:37I'm not even going to attempt it.

2:06:38I like to hear you mispronounce words.

2:06:40Well, I'll mispronounce it.

2:06:41The Windows hegemony.

2:06:43It's the first one.

2:06:44And just in the numbers alone, even if the growth of iPad sales

2:06:48starts tapering off, which I don't think is going to happen,

2:06:50it's already done it.

2:06:52It's already achieved a-- even if it only maintains the market share

2:06:56It currently has a PC sold it's achieved levels that no OS has ever achieved since you know

2:07:03DOS first took off in the 80s

2:07:07It makes me wonder what they're like so people keep quoting back the sold Apple line

2:07:11Which I think is very appropriate the computer for the rest of us remember that one

2:07:14Yeah

2:07:14and so like I you know

2:07:16It seemed like that Mac was the computer for the rest of us because it's not it doesn't have a DOS prompt and you can

2:07:20Actually use it and that was just such an incredible break

2:07:22you know the difference in a DOS prompt and the Mac GUI which were just so incredibly seamless in fact

2:07:27I would say more seamless than the Mac OS 10 GUI like there was nothing else. That was it

2:07:31It was the iOS of its day and then iOS comes along and does that same thing for the Mac

2:07:35What do you think the computer for the rest of us like assuming Apple is still around or whatever?

2:07:40We're 75 years old and something comes around remember that iOS how complicated it was finally

2:07:45Yeah, the computer for the rest of us is here and now anybody can really use it because that's what it is

2:07:50It's a series of

2:07:52Making this technology more accessible and you know when I first saw the Mac

2:07:55I thought like wow this is such an amazing leap and then in iOS you see oh my god

2:07:59Look at all the crap they left behind and that's why like

2:08:01That's why you can just throw this pad in front of a two-year-old or an 80 year old and they get it like finally the computer

2:08:06For the rest of us. I'm trying to think of what is the thing that's gonna do that to iOS?

2:08:10Because you know you've got to give it 20 30 years something else will come along and people will say oh iOS

2:08:16What a technical nightmare that was so hard for people to use finally the computer for the rest of us

2:08:21It's QoS. History suggests it's about 20 years I'd say.

2:08:24Unix was like a 60s thing and

2:08:28Unix is you know that sort of that sort of put the idea that a computer is a thing that boots up with a

2:08:34Command line prompt. Well 70s maybe.

2:08:36Well, yeah, it was probably like 69 is when they started the epoch so I guess that's that's multi-user computing

2:08:44Yeah, and then personal computing was like the Apple 2 where you could

2:08:47I'd just say roughly though that the Mac came 20 years after command line computers.

2:08:53Maybe a little less.

2:08:54And maybe you could argue that iOS was delayed a little bit.

2:08:57You know, I mean, that was sort of, there was a Steve Jobs article or interview before

2:09:02he came back to Apple where he talked about Microsoft introducing a dark ages of computing

2:09:07that set.

2:09:08And in hindsight, he might have a really good point that there was like a dark ages of innovation

2:09:13where there was no room for innovation,

2:09:15and maybe that set progress back five to 10 years,

2:09:20that maybe we should have had the equivalent of iOS

2:09:24five or 10 years earlier.

2:09:25- Oh, that was called Newton OS.

2:09:27- Yeah, there were definitely attempts at it, and it was--

2:09:29- And it was close, Newton was close,

2:09:30it just made a couple wrong bets there.

2:09:32- Right.

2:09:33So I would say, and given that we're already five years

2:09:39into iOS, that would, even if it's 20 years,

2:09:41it's 15 years from now.

2:09:45And maybe 10 or 15 years from now.

2:09:47Start thinking about the things in iOS

2:09:49that are equivalent to direct access to the file system

2:09:52and all sorts of other things that are just too complicated

2:09:54for people to handle.

2:09:55And I bet you could think of some.

2:09:57Maybe working-- I don't know.

2:10:00What is the equivalent of something

2:10:02that's just too much of a pain in iOS

2:10:04and that involves technical details

2:10:06that we shouldn't need to be concerned about, but we do?

2:10:09Installing apps.

2:10:10Maybe.

2:10:11They've made that pretty darn simple.

2:10:12I know.

2:10:13You know, installing.

2:10:15What I was thinking is maybe the idea of document storage

2:10:21and media access and how you were-- tying things so tightly

2:10:25to the app, the things that we're complaining about it.

2:10:28We all know we want something that's more flexible,

2:10:30but every more flexible system that we can think of

2:10:32is also more complicated.

2:10:33Is there a system that's both simpler and more capable?

2:10:37I don't know.

2:10:39That's what I'll be watching for in my in my dotage

2:10:41What is the real computer for the rest of us? Maybe they'll have to involve neural implants or something

2:10:47Yeah, and I think if you know, maybe maybe a lot more AI

2:10:50Yeah, maybe maybe it's all about input method now is it kind of a kind of was with iOS, you know? Yeah, definitely

2:10:55But I do think though I do think and and you mentioned this earlier in the show when you said that it didn't really matter

2:11:02How good Mac OS X was or even how good it was directly compared to Windows. There was nothing

2:11:07that was at that point that was going to

2:11:10Unshake windows as this 90 plus percent market share of the PC market

2:11:16thing because of other factors other than the quality of it whereas iOS like

2:11:22Went in this entirely other direction where it's not better in the sense that we always compared Mac OS 10 to being

2:11:29Windows being better in terms of doing the exact same things in a better more elegant more efficient better designed way

2:11:37It that it was better in this other weird way, which doesn't even maybe never even occurred to us

2:11:42Which was it it is completely understandable and puts normal people at ease

2:11:47By not even allowing them to do these things that that we just take for granted in a computer

2:11:53That's what the Mac was posted or two and then whether Mac kind of did as well

2:11:56But it all gets back to Steve Jobs saying, you know, what would you do if you're running Apple before I came back?

2:12:01He said I would you know

2:12:02milk the Mac for all its worth and get working on the next big thing.

2:12:05And that's, I think when as a Mac user, that, that scared me a little bit.

2:12:08It's like, Oh, geez, if he comes back, he's just going to use the Mac as a

2:12:11cash cow and chuck it on the curb.

2:12:13And I couldn't get excited about and get working on the next big thing.

2:12:17Cause I couldn't see what the next big thing would be.

2:12:19So that's like, you're going to take the thing that I love and kind of screw it.

2:12:23And you're going to get working on the next big thing, which I

2:12:25think is probably going to fail.

2:12:26Well, when he came back to Apple, he, you wouldn't say he milked the Mac for all

2:12:31was worth, but he certainly tried his best to improve the Mac. Like, he gave it the love

2:12:35it deserved, and he also got working on the next big thing, and that next big thing turned

2:12:38out to be a friggin' phone.

2:12:40Right.

2:12:41So, who saw that coming? But that's apparently not Microsoft.

2:12:43Well, you could argue maybe the next best thing. I remember thinking, though, that for

2:12:47a while, I remember thinking about that interview and thinking that it's funny that the next

2:12:50best thing was a Walkman.

2:12:52The next big thing, yeah.

2:12:53The next big thing.

2:12:54Well, I mean, that was kind of creeping up on it. Like, the idea of portable devices

2:12:57and consumer electronics and moving in that direction. I didn't see the... Maybe when

2:13:03they started making money off it, like, "Is that the next big thing? Are they gonna become

2:13:06Sony?" But iOS really convinced me. And I always got the feeling that the iPad, basically,

2:13:12a computer that that size and that easy to use is what Jobs had in mind his entire life

2:13:19about it, what personal computing should be like. And he didn't think of it as a music

2:13:22player that can hold a lot of songs. That was just cool. That was like on the road.

2:13:27And you know what, and we'll wrap this up, but there's a perfect place, because I didn't

2:13:31write this down in my notes, and I'm so glad you just said that, because it reminded me

2:13:34of it.

2:13:35And you're the only person who I wanted to talk to about it, which is that the early

2:13:41clue to the iPad being the sort of thing Jobs wanted to get to, and maybe he was trying

2:13:48to get there, well, in fact, definitely he was trying to get there way too fast at the

2:13:51time that that purple button in the early pre-release Mac OS 10 single window mode single

2:14:00window mode up in the upper right of every window and they you know was a purple tic

2:14:06tac you know you had the red yellow green in the left corner for close minimize zoom

2:14:14and in the upper right corner and this was controversial at the beginning because in

2:14:17the old Mac OS only closed was top left and the zoom and minimize were top right

2:14:22and they moved it all that the top left and we all complained because they moved

2:14:26something and we made up these arguments that well now people are gonna the

2:14:30reason you want close all by itself is because it's destructive and you don't

2:14:35want to put other things nearby because people could accidentally click them on

2:14:39blah blah blah and really the only reason we complained about it was

2:14:42because they moved it but what they put instead in the top right was a purple

2:14:45button, which I don't even remember exactly how it was supposed to work, but it was called

2:14:53single window mode.

2:14:55And it was, you would say this is at one window at a time.

2:14:59And it just didn't work.

2:15:01I mean, it just didn't work because the Mac had already, they were building on this system

2:15:06that was completely designed from the outset to be a bunch of overlapping windows.

2:15:10Yeah, I mean it was kind of like, they're doing this radical new user interface, so

2:15:17like it all looks different, it has these candy colored buttons, and it's based on Nextstep,

2:15:21which is the thing that Jobs liked from his company, but you can see him looking over

2:15:26the shoulder, but everyone's doing it like, "This is great and all, but do we need to

2:15:29have all these windows, all of this, it just looks so messy.

2:15:31What if we had a thing that just showed one window, and then when you showed the next

2:15:35window, the previous one hit, like wouldn't it be easier to just focus on one thing at

2:15:38at a time.

2:15:39And so, you know, I can see him saying that and then them going, "I guess we could put

2:15:43a thing."

2:15:44Maybe if you had a button and just put it into a mode where you only saw one when you

2:15:49just focus on one thing, you know, not have all these distractions and everything.

2:15:51And it would just be a mode for the whole OS.

2:15:53Anytime you switch to a different window, the previous one would hide.

2:15:55Like, "All right, I guess we can..."

2:15:57And they put it in and just people scream bloody murder because that's not how you use

2:16:00a Mac.

2:16:01But he wanted something that was like that, where you just do one thing at a time.

2:16:05And even if it doesn't fill the screen, it's the focus and there's no distractions.

2:16:09And the Mac was not the place to do that.

2:16:11But we all said that about the iPad in particular is that there are many activities people say

2:16:16they prefer to do that because there's fewer distractions.

2:16:18You can zoom any window into covering your whole screen and now they have a legitimate

2:16:23full screen mode.

2:16:24You can do that on the Mac, but that's not the mode we're in on the Mac.

2:16:27In fact, the full screen mode goes back to the button to do it is up in the upper right

2:16:31corner.

2:16:32Yeah.

2:16:33kind of like single user mode and you use the swiping gestures between it, but the whole

2:16:36focus was, "There's just too much stuff. Why is all this stuff here? Why do we all have

2:16:41these little things?"

2:16:42Why are we looking at all this clutter at one time?

2:16:45Yeah. I mean, in Mac OS 9, at the end of its life, you had the control strip and you had

2:16:50the little program switcher and then you had a menu and then you had pop-up tab folders.

2:16:53Remember those at the bottom of the screen? I still love those things. It was just so

2:16:56much stuff. The menu bar and the little giga well thing, he tried so much with Mac OS 10

2:17:01get all that crap out of there. You know, just the dock, one

2:17:04unified interface element, no pop up folders, no Apple menu, if

2:17:07you could help it, no little palette coming down the side,

2:17:10but running applications, no control strip, just get that

2:17:13crap out of there. But you know, the limit, there was still too

2:17:16much stuff there. And so iOS was seriously now, everything off

2:17:20the screen, except what I'm doing right now. And that's what

2:17:23it took a new platform and a new new form factor new everything.

2:17:26Right. And it was so much it's actually more way more in that

2:17:30direction because it's not well sometimes you can be in this mode but then you can go

2:17:34in the other mode and have all your overlapping windows. It's no. All the time, every time,

2:17:40there's one app at a time and that app is the screen and has the whole screen and nothing

2:17:45but the screen. And there's no other, there is no other state.

2:17:49Yeah, I just had to look this up in my own review because I forgot. When you activated

2:17:53single user mode, all but the frontmost window would minimize to the dock. And then when

2:17:57and you un-minimized any other window from the dock,

2:17:59the previously un-minimized window went back down.

2:18:01So it was they all went into the dock,

2:18:03again, that one user interface element,

2:18:04and any time you look at a different one, they swap places.

2:18:07- Right.

2:18:08- It's no good.

2:18:09- No.

2:18:10But it was weird, and the difference with full screen mode

2:18:12is they didn't really go full screen.

2:18:14They were still a window that you could drag around.

2:18:15It's just that you could only have one window

2:18:17on screen at once.

2:18:18- Yeah, and the rest of them were jamming up your dock,

2:18:19making all your icons tiny.

2:18:20Imagine if I did that on any of my machine

2:18:22on any given day, all minimized to the dock,

2:18:24my dock would be microscopic.

2:18:26You know, it's just one of those...

2:18:28It would have a lot...

2:18:31If I had all my windows minimized there, it would be a pretty microscopic dock.

2:18:38There was a way to do that.

2:18:39I remember with the old dock, when you had the windows in there, you could...

2:18:42You could...

2:18:43Option click the minimize widget.

2:18:44I think it'll send at least all the windows from that app down to the dock.

2:18:48But now you don't see them in the dock anymore.

2:18:49Yeah, I think you can still see them in that mode.

2:18:51Isn't it an option in preferences?

2:18:52We can say minimize windows into applications.

2:18:54Yes, no.

2:18:55Definitely a PLS tack, but oh is it I didn't I haven't looked at that in a long time

2:18:58I haven't minimized anything, and I don't know how many years ever I haven't minimized anything since they got rid of window shade

2:19:03Yeah, I just option clicked the minimize widget on Safari and all my safari windows went down

2:19:07I can see them all lined up next to the trash can oh

2:19:09My god, so if I option click this one in Safari you're saying they're all gonna jump in there yep

2:19:14All right, I just option clicked it and nothing happened because I have so many windows

2:19:20And there they are wow that is great

2:19:24My icons the icons are about four pixels

2:19:27Don't do that in every other app you have open. All right

2:19:30That's pretty great. Did they stay grouped together?

2:19:33Yeah, I

2:19:36Forgot about that preference man talk about a trip down memory line

2:19:39Well, anyway, John Sir Q said thank you very very much for doing the show very welcome. This was a lot of fun

2:19:45I want to thank our sponsors these these sponsors the only only reason this show even exists. I want to thank

2:19:49Mac world super guides

2:19:53including the new one, the Total Mountain Lion.

2:19:57Six bucks, you get it all DRM free.

2:20:00You're nuts if you don't buy it.

2:20:01IdeaBucket, a fantastic 99 cent app

2:20:04for iPad and iPhone at ideabucket.me.

2:20:08Go check them out.

2:20:09Buy that app.

2:20:11Help support the show.