Podcast Search

The Talk Show

367: ‘Slow Moving Hurricane’, With Craig Hockenberry

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00Well, Craig, how's your weekend?

0:00:02- Oh, pretty uneventful.

0:00:06Hey, how about if I start it up, Elon Musk?

0:00:11- There you go.

0:00:12You know, I know a lot of people,

0:00:15to me, a surprising number of people on Mastodon

0:00:17do not wanna use the word Twitter even,

0:00:20and they call it the bird site.

0:00:22- Yeah, that's the similar.

0:00:23- I don't get--

0:00:24- I'm a little looser on that, yeah.

0:00:26- I don't get that.

0:00:27But again, one of the weird things, not weird,

0:00:29I think good things about me growing older is I have way more, I think I've always sort

0:00:36of been a, I've tried to be from my youth onward, a live and let live type person. And

0:00:43I've hopefully only grown more open minded. And so something like that, I think 15, 20

0:00:48years ago, I'd have really rolled my eyes at calling it the bird site. And now I just,

0:00:53I don't pass judgment on it. You don't want to use the word Twitter. You don't have to

0:00:56use the word Twitter. I'm not going to avoid it.

0:00:58Right. It's everybody's personal call, right? It's like, you know, pronouns or whatever,

0:01:03you know, do what you feel is right. I'm okay with it.

0:01:06Stephen Colbert, who showed my wife and I watch pretty frequently, or at least we, you know,

0:01:10watch like the first half of the monologue and everything. I don't know exactly when he stopped.

0:01:15I don't know if it was upon Biden's inauguration or if he even, it might have even been like with

0:01:22January 6th when he was still president, but he hasn't said Trump's name in two years. And

0:01:29they won't print his name either. A modern TV monologue has sort of like a PowerPoint

0:01:38or a keynote presentation next to the... You know what I mean?

0:01:41**Matt Stauffer** Right, right, right. The scrolling thing.

0:01:43**

0:01:43Just a you know, like slides really next to him parents. Oh, right, right, right. Okay. I see what you know what I mean

0:01:49We're instead of putting yeah. Yeah the host right in the center

0:01:52The host is off to the right and there's sort of a right corner

0:01:55It's actually I think a very nice subtle innovation to the to the late-night

0:02:00comedy thing I would give credit to the the daily show with Jon Stewart for

0:02:06Popularizing it but I'm sure there are things who've done it before but anyway, he doesn't print his name either

0:02:13I forget you know in there and they have like a thing. It's actually a

0:02:16Going back to Twitter. It is late late night with Stephen Colbert

0:02:20listeners suggest

0:02:23nicknames for him, you know

0:02:25You know to be used and it is interesting and but he doesn't call out. He doesn't emphasize over and over

0:02:32I'm not saying this guy's name

0:02:33You just have to pick up that he doesn't say his name even though he's still frequently the butt of his jokes

0:02:38So anyway, we can do something like that. What's your name good for?

0:02:42for Elon.

0:02:43Tim Cynova I think that the person who came up with Space

0:02:47Karen was kind of that it's, you know, it's not really offensive. And, you know, I guess

0:02:54unless your name is Karen, but and it kind of evokes, you know, it's deprecating, but

0:03:00not offensive. And, you know, my view there is that, you know, guys like Elon and Trump,

0:03:10thrive on the attention, right? At heart, I think they're both narcissists. So, you

0:03:20know, the best thing you can do is just kind of ignore them. And I'm fully on with Colbert.

0:03:25I mean, I don't mention his name either, right? There's no reason to. In fact, you

0:03:31notice that he looks like a wreck these days because he's getting starved of attention,

0:03:37right? The media doesn't follow him as much. What he says is not as important anymore,

0:03:42right? He's not leading the United States of America. So…

0:03:45Jim: Well, and you mentioned it in your, you know, one of the… I think you published last night

0:03:50a blog post on your personal blog, not on the iconometry site. But, you know,

0:03:56you don't have to get your license for armchair psychology to figure out that there are some

0:04:01similarities between the two in terms of their insatiable desire for attention at any cost.

0:04:07Yeah.

0:04:08And so I therefore think if you are genuinely and as a lot of us are certainly with the former

0:04:17president, and I think a lot now, and ever more so those of us who care about Twitter, and

0:04:24It's not just Twitter itself, of course, it is the veering into right-wing nutjob promotion.

0:04:32I don't want to go too far off on the politics, but lots of people are doing it and can do it

0:04:41better than me. But you can also make the argument that this is not just an argument about the

0:04:46service and is he making bad product decisions with the service. In general, there's also a

0:04:53greater political argument to be had about the direction he, some of the changes that he's making.

0:05:00John: Well, and it leads into a broader discussion of how social networks affects

0:05:06that political system. Right? Yeah. Talk about another four-hour podcast if we get into that.

0:05:13Dave: All right. Let me take a break here and thank our first sponsor, and it is our good

0:05:18friends at Trade Coffee. I can literally say that this podcast is partially presented by

0:05:24Trade Coffee, not just because they are sponsoring the show in this episode, but because my blood

0:05:30right now is filled with caffeine delivered by Trade Coffee on a mug. Here, listen, here,

0:05:36I'm going to tap my pen on it right now. Can you hear it? That's my coffee mug with Trade

0:05:40Coffee in there. Well, the remnants of it. It's an easy way to jumpstart your New Year's

0:05:44resolutions by starting your mornings with better coffee. By upgrading your coffee with a trade

0:05:49subscription, you can boost your morning energy, save money by brewing at home, and even support

0:05:54small local businesses. Trade Coffee is a coffee subscription service that makes it so simple

0:06:00to discover new coffees and make your best cup of coffee at home every day. Trade partners with the

0:06:07nation's top-rated independent roasters to send you the best quality coffee you can get, all

0:06:13handpicked by their coffee experts. I've been having it delivered for months and months

0:06:17and months, better part of the year, I think. And I don't know that I've gotten coffee from

0:06:21the same roaster twice. It is an unbelievable variety of roasters and it just keeps coming

0:06:27from different places. It just makes it so easy and convenient to discover new coffee

0:06:32and to keep the coffee in your house fresh. You just start out with the subscription,

0:06:38you know, maybe one bag every two weeks. And if that's not enough, you can change it to

0:06:42once a week or you could change it to like once every 10 days or something like that or

0:06:46three times a month. Have you ever been to an Airbnb and pulled out the coffee that's been

0:06:50sitting in there for a while? Oh yeah forever. That's that's not a that's bad. Yeah and it's it's

0:06:57fresh coffee. That's a good thing. Yeah some you look at the date and it's like Barack Obama was

0:07:02the president. It's like oh that's a long time ago. Oh my god. Look they'd send it to you at

0:07:07your house on your preferred schedule. You can adjust that schedule at every time. Pause it if

0:07:12you're going away on vacation or something like that. It is so easy. They have a terrific website.

0:07:16Have a better year by upgrading your morning routine with Better Coffee. Right now,

0:07:20Trade is offering listeners of the talk show a free bag of coffee with any subscription

0:07:25at www.drinktrade.com/the-talk-show. That's www.drinktrade.com/the-talk-show for a free bag

0:07:36of coffee with any subscription purchase. My thanks to Trade, DrinkTrade.com/TheTalkShow.

0:07:42Just in case there are listeners who are not familiar with the saga, and it's possible

0:07:47because there might be some who either went into Twitter in the first place or tuned wisely,

0:07:52I think in hindsight, tuned out, closed the doors, locked the shutters, got out early.

0:07:59I sort of feel in some ways like I'm trying to think of this, you know, I love my analogies,

0:08:06but I sort of feel like the person who like blew off the hurricane warning, you know?

0:08:11Imagine if a hurricane, instead of being like a one-day event that you get like 48 hours notice,

0:08:18like a slow-moving hurricane, and I was like, "Ah, this is gonna be fine."

0:08:23- And it'll blow over. It's just a little rain.

0:08:26- Anyway, what happened was, I believe it was Friday the 13th.

0:08:31- Yeah. At about 4.20 Central European time.

0:08:36So I don't know about that. I don't know either, but it's just like,

0:08:40well, I could not put it past it. He loves his 420s for stock prices,

0:08:46like, you know, and stuff like that. I mean, he's made two of those jokes. He once, well,

0:08:51joke, you know, the Twitter one turned out not to be a joke, but his acquisition price for Twitter

0:08:57was $54.20 a share. And years ago, he made an idle threat to take Tesla, which had long,

0:09:05you know, at that point long been a publicly held company to take it private at $420.

0:09:10Well, I don't know, Friday evening, it was late here on the East Coast, I think around

0:09:17seven or something out there in California, all of a sudden, third party clients stopped working

0:09:24with an authentication. And yeah, I got a, I got a text from Sean who's Sean Heber. He's the one

0:09:31actually does the most of the development on Twitterrific in the past few years. And he

0:09:36texted me, it's like, what does our app look like in the, in the dashboard? Are we suspended?

0:09:41I was like, what? I logged in and immediately saw, you know, the little red banner and, you know,

0:09:48it's like, oh, we sent you an email with details. Of course, there's no email with details.

0:09:52(laughs)

0:09:54- From the outside, it was a real mystery.

0:09:56I had a friend, the first I heard about it

0:09:59was a friend who purely, I think just genuine coincidence,

0:10:03like me, a fellow nerd, there's a friend who's ex-Apple

0:10:06now working somewhere else, but like me,

0:10:09manages iOS app updates manually.

0:10:12Like what I like to do, I don't have it automatic.

0:10:14I just, you know, whenever I, you know, once a day,

0:10:17I, at this point, I have so many apps

0:10:18and updates are so common, you know,

0:10:20it's sort of like a daily tour, but I just go in

0:10:22and I want to see what's new.

0:10:23And that's the thing, you get to get you a chance

0:10:25to read the release notes if there are any

0:10:27and that kind of thing, yeah.

0:10:28- And it's, you know, and often sometimes

0:10:30it's a good reason to think, ah,

0:10:32there's an update for this app.

0:10:33I don't use that one anymore, I'll just delete it.

0:10:35You know, sometimes I just say that.

0:10:36Anyway, he manually applied a Tweetbot update

0:10:40and then couldn't log in and thought that the,

0:10:43you know, the update was--

0:10:44- Yeah, made the correlation.

0:10:47- And I said, oh, I haven't uninstalled any updates

0:10:49and ooh, I can't get in either, authentication error.

0:10:52And then the wheels started turning.

0:10:55So, background, so what we now seem to know

0:10:59as we record here on Monday is that it's exactly

0:11:02what we feared, that Twitter made the decision

0:11:06to kill popular third-party clients

0:11:09like Tweetbot and Twitterrific and--

0:11:12- Yeah, it's pretty clear that they had some sort

0:11:14of internal threshold of usage,

0:11:17that if an app was over a certain number, they got the axe that they were under. Because,

0:11:23for example, our iOS client got the axe, but our macOS app, which is the same code except

0:11:29for the UI bit, it's fine still. And for the moment, they'll probably hear this podcast

0:11:36and go, "Oh, shit, we missed one."

0:11:38Yes.

0:11:39But...

0:11:40So, it is...

0:11:41Yeah.

0:11:42Yeah, let's... I would love to hear an explanation for this to make, because I don't know the

0:11:45exact details. But the gist of it is they didn't shut down the API servers. And I think they can't,

0:11:52because I think your apps like Twitterrific are using APIs that are used by posts.

0:11:57Tim Cynova They use them in their own apps for some of the stuff. Yeah,

0:12:00there are some of the, in fact, they have their own private OAuth keys that let them

0:12:07access the normal API plus extra stuff. So it's, you know, it's, there's, and because, you know,

0:12:16Twitter has evolved over so many years, right, I'm sure that the mixture of, you know, the private

0:12:21and the public in their code base is pretty, it's probably pretty well entangled. So if, you know,

0:12:30I don't think they will ever be able to completely pull the public API,

0:12:37but they certainly can can kneecap it, you know, with rate limits.

0:12:42Yeah, so basically what they did is just instead of shutting down API servers,

0:12:48which they effectively can't do and probably wouldn't want to do, but they don't have to,

0:12:52what they did was revoke the OAuth credentials. Each app has effectively an ID within Twitter.

0:13:01Brian Kardell Yeah, every app has basically a public key and a private key,

0:13:07and each one of those tokens has a secret. So, you know, there's a handshake that happens there,

0:13:13and if at any point during the handshake, you know, somebody says, "No, this is no good," then

0:13:19you're not going to be able to connect. And I mean, we could have blocked off access to Twitter

0:13:24if, you know, we'd done a similar thing on our end, but there's no reason for us to do that.

0:13:29But, yeah, that was the point of OAuth, you know, it gives power to the individual who has,

0:13:37you know, you can go on Twitter and look in your apps section of settings and see the apps that

0:13:43have requested tokens. And if you see one or there's an app that you think is misbehaving,

0:13:47you can go remove it. That's another one of the ways to cut off access to the API.

0:13:53And essentially what Twitter did is they did that across the board. They basically, in fact,

0:13:59if you go look in your app section of, you know, twitter.com and the settings, you won't see

0:14:05Twitterific, you won't see Tweetbot, you won't see any of the apps that were previously granted access.

0:14:10Ah, as a user you're saying? Yes. Gotcha. Yeah. Yeah. If you opened up, you know,

0:14:16the Twitter website right now and navigated the settings, you will not see Tweet.

0:14:20You will not see Twitter. And because it just removed.

0:14:24And Twitterrific for Mac, like you just said, somehow escaped the reaper, almost certainly

0:14:30because they set some sort of threshold and Twitterrific for Mac must be under the threshold.

0:14:36But the other key difference is that you guys use a different ID for Twitter Effect for iOS

0:14:42than Twitter Effect for Mac, whereas Tweetbot, I think, uses the same ID?

0:14:46Yes, they have, they use the same key pair for their Mac and their iOS apps,

0:14:55which I don't remember, honestly, why we did that, but there was probably a reason at some point

0:15:01where we needed a separate one just maybe. But I probably went back to the Kickstarter

0:15:06because it was kind of a separate thing.

0:15:07Yeah. I remember that. Right.

0:15:09Yeah. But, you know, it's... And honestly, I do not see long-term. I don't, you know,

0:15:18but a lot of people have been noticing that Twitter for Mac still works and are downloading

0:15:24it and buying it. And, you know, we're going to eventually hit our heads on that, whatever

0:15:30that limit is and have to shut it down there too. So, which...

0:15:35So part of the frustration here, I mean, number one, those of us who use these

0:15:41clients or like in your case, make them, love them. I mean, truly, truly do love them. And

0:15:48to me, it's not just like a minor convenience or nicety versus the official Twitter app. It's

0:15:57almost an altogether different experience. And to me, and I've written about this maybe not

0:16:03recently, although I guess now is the time to revisit the theme of Twitter clients as a UI

0:16:10playground. And I've used that too with weather apps where I think because the, and I'm not,

0:16:20I think you understand that I'm not underplaying how significant Twitterific is and how complicated

0:16:28big and how many features it is and how difficult a lot of it is. I'm not trying to say, "Ah,

0:16:34just a Twitter client. It's easy." But the scope of Twitter is so minimal.

0:16:40David Schanzer Right. Right. Right. It's a small API footprint,

0:16:44really, when you look at it. There's not a lot there. But there is a lot.

0:16:49- Right, well, and in part, it's part of what makes,

0:16:52to me, Twitter, a brilliant idea.

0:16:56The original concept is so brilliant

0:16:57because it is conceptually so simple.

0:17:00And even with such a simple concept,

0:17:03it eventually evolved to be truly complex and wide-ranging.

0:17:08And it just shows you how, you know, compared to,

0:17:17Well, at this point, even Instagram, right, Instagram is so wildly, you know, it's it's

0:17:22effectively three or four social networks crammed into one app in one service and one

0:17:28namespace, right?

0:17:29There's the traditional Instagram that is sort of like Twitter, but for images and video.

0:17:35And now there's the whole thing with the fleeting stories at the top, and the vertical videos

0:17:43in the middle, and it's also an instant messaging client, and blah, blah, blah. And, you know,

0:17:49go even more complex to Facebook's blue app. And they've never had third party clients,

0:17:55but if they did, it's to encompass all of Facebook is it's almost impossible.

0:18:01Because that's one reason I the Facebook even before all of the reasons people may,

0:18:08including me, don't like Facebook today existed. I never got onto it because I never understood it.

0:18:14Whereas Twitter, it was so easy to understand, and that's what made it so rich as a playground

0:18:21for tinkering with the presentation. The key word there was a playground, right? Especially in the

0:18:30early days, we had no idea what we were doing, right? In fact, all there was on the Twitter

0:18:35website was, you know, "What are you doing?" You know? And a lot of those early tweets

0:18:41are just like, one of my early ones is "Is experimenting." Because it's like, and

0:18:47it was presented on the website as "Craig Hockenberry is experimenting," or "Is

0:18:52having lunch," or it was just kind of a, "Wow, this is an interesting way to let

0:18:58people know kind of what I'm thinking right now. And, you know, then it involves, you

0:19:05know, with, you know, you needed a way to identify people. That's where the whole

0:19:11@screenname thing started. That wasn't even a part of it, right? It's like, you know,

0:19:17one of my early tweets was @Dan, right? Well, which Dan? It turns out it was Dan Benjamin

0:19:23because, you know, he was the only Dan I knew on Twitter.

0:19:25It might have been the only day. It was like two Dans on Twitter.

0:19:28Right. Yeah. And then Dan Morin joined up and was like, "There's two Dans now."

0:19:34And, you know, the hashtags. I think it was Christmas scene that came up with that.

0:19:43And then Robert Anderson came up with the @Reply thing, you know, a reply change report.

0:19:53And it was just like the thing that was so important and exciting at that time is how

0:20:00it was evolving. Right? And that's kind of one of the frustrations over the, you know, the last

0:20:07maybe 10 years or so is there hasn't really been a lot of evolution on Twitter.

0:20:14Tom: Well, it is wild, you know, and now is the time to look back and

0:20:20pour one out for Twitter, but it is wild how many of the,

0:20:23I'm sure there are others, but hashtags and mentions

0:20:27are certainly two of the ones that it's hard to conceive

0:20:30that the product didn't have those as first-class citizens.

0:20:33They were just user conventions.

0:20:36And nothing, they weren't treated specially.

0:20:40So if you made a joke and I replied @ChalkenBerry,

0:20:45and here's my witty comeback, that was just a tweet

0:20:49that happened to start with the characters

0:20:51at sign Chalkinberry.

0:20:54- Right.

0:20:55- And it would just show, you know, it would go,

0:20:58anybody who followed me just got that tweet

0:21:00as a regular tweet.

0:21:02And there was no, there were no APIs to tie stuff together.

0:21:06So you couldn't, if you tapped on your original tweet,

0:21:09I mean, there was no concept really of replying

0:21:12to a specific tweet.

0:21:13You were just entering the--

0:21:15- You're just throwing it out there.

0:21:17Yeah, everybody could see it.

0:21:18But you know, and fairly, in fairly short order,

0:21:21that really took off.

0:21:23And you know, and then I guess,

0:21:25I think before Twitter adopted it,

0:21:27clients like Twitterrific could do things

0:21:29like filter those, you know, you could do it on your own

0:21:32once you had those tweets sucked in through the API.

0:21:35But then Twitter, you know, embraced it.

0:21:37And it's obviously, you know, famously with hashtags, right?

0:21:41I mean, it's, you know.

0:21:43- Yeah, well, the hashtags and the, you know,

0:21:45the in reply too, that was actually a field

0:21:47that they added to the API response

0:21:50that allowed us to do interesting things, right?

0:21:53And that was something that,

0:21:56where we had to work with Twitter engineering

0:21:59to make that happen, right?

0:22:01That was not something that we could do on our own.

0:22:03That's not something that Twitter could do on their own

0:22:04because it needed kind of both the front end

0:22:07and the back end to work simultaneously on this thing.

0:22:10And that was great.

0:22:13I mean, but that hasn't happened for years, right?

0:22:16just not been a collaborative thing between... The thing that kills me is that in...

0:22:24Prior to the purchase by Elon Musk, the Twitter API people were starting to open things up.

0:22:34Pete: Yeah.

0:22:35Tim: Right? In fact, after the purchase was announced, or, you know, he put a bid in,

0:22:42And I got an email from one of the people working on the Twitter API stuff, and they

0:22:50were opening up group DMs.

0:22:53They wanted to provide third parties with the ability to do group DMs, which is something

0:22:57that people have been asking us for for years, right?

0:23:00It's like the official client can do it, why can't we?

0:23:02Well, we don't have API.

0:23:04Well, so they started to open things up, and that was like—

0:23:07And when there's—

0:23:08couldn't say to him, it was like, "We're going to wait and see on this because there's this guy

0:23:14named Elon Musk and I don't trust him." And the guy who was working on that was one of the,

0:23:23I think he was a part of the first round of layoffs. So, you know, they were so close.

0:23:31They were really close to getting it again.

0:23:34It cracked me up from your blog post about the, as you called it, the shit show.

0:23:42You mentioned and put a link to the first tweet you posted through their APIs back in

0:23:49December 2006.

0:23:52And again, it made me laugh twice because first it just says, the whole tweet is, thinks

0:23:58he's finally gotten the posting code right.

0:24:03that made me laugh because like you said in those or in that at least for that first year

0:24:08that that was the convention to pat to to tweet in the sense of that you you it was personal

0:24:16right it was usually it was your personal status and it was i i think largely inspired

0:24:21by like aim statuses right and all yeah yeah yeah i chat i chat was what was it what did

0:24:27they call it was i chat messages or no i i chat was the original client that apple made

0:24:32to talk to AIM and yeah yeah yeah yeah who had one and there were a couple of others that were

0:24:39they were all effectively had the same features but one of the things that that they had that

0:24:48modern messaging like iMessage and WhatsApp and all the other modern ones have don't have is a

0:24:55status right and you could set your stats the defaults were like available was green away was

0:25:02was red. It meant like, "Hey, I'm here and my client is running, but I'm busy, so don't

0:25:10bother me." And then you could—

0:25:12Yeah, I probably had one at one point, because it was a point of creativity, too. I probably

0:25:16had one at one point, it was like, "He's locking the chalk," something like that,

0:25:20right?

0:25:21Right, so you could make a custom one and set whether that's green or red. And Jack

0:25:26Dorsey's idea was, well, what if there was a universal service for those sort of things,

0:25:29could just say, you know, that you're, you know, you could just post an update that you're eating

0:25:34lunch at such and such cafe and your friends who are nearby could maybe see that and say,

0:25:41"Oh, I'll go stop by and see Craig. It was like a live, what are you doing?" And that convention

0:25:47of posting with like an active verb with your name implicitly filled in as the beginning was

0:25:56part of the presentation of tweets, like you said. It would look like that as you looked at

0:26:01Twitter's interface. And it's just, to me it's a sign, the fact that that's not how Twitter turned

0:26:07out to be isn't a failure. It's the, usually the sign of a great idea is when it expands into

0:26:14something that the creator didn't originally envision, but it works well.

0:26:18Right, right. The evolution. In fact, it was interesting to me that it was things like

0:26:24South by Southwest where Twitter really kind of got its foothold because it's a group.

0:26:29It's a place where a lot of people group together, right? And you need that ability to know

0:26:35where people are, what they're doing. Same, you know, the early WWDCs. I mean, we were fighting,

0:26:42you know, getting a connection on the Wi-Fi, number one. Number two, we all had new iPhones

0:26:47and the batteries were running low and we needed to know where everybody was.

0:26:51Yeah, I don't remember exactly how we used it. So I used to, yeah, I don't either. But I know we

0:26:58did. I remember I was very, you know, I forget which years I was at South by Southwest, but it

0:27:04encompassed at least March 2006, maybe 2005, too, but before Twitter, then there was March 2007.

0:27:14And that's that was the South by Southwest where Twitter exploded and the fail whale came up

0:27:19multiple times during the conference. And the Twitter crew was at South by Southwest, so God

0:27:27only knows how they were fixing it. But they did a good job. But we didn't have iPhones yet. The

0:27:35iPhone had been announced in January but wasn't coming out until June. And South by Southwest

0:27:42took part in the middle, but somehow even without iPhones yet, we broke Twitter during I think,

0:27:49honestly, if my best guess is because I remember doing it a lot is when you would go to a conference

0:27:54back then, you'd have your laptop in a backpack and every you know, in between sessions, you just

0:28:00sit down in the hallway with your laptop on your lap, literally, you know, right, your email or,

0:28:06you know, and check Twitter and you could, you know, so we were effectively using our powerbooks.

0:28:11I think they were powerbooks at the time. Maybe the MacBook had come out, but you know,

0:28:15we were using our laptops as cell phones. Yeah. It was mind blowing, though, what it enabled in terms

0:28:23of like you're saying, like, where we could say, hey, we're gonna have beers at paradise at five.

0:28:29And the people who followed me on Twitter, and we're there with Gruber and Krager, Gruber and

0:28:36and whoever else are gonna be at paradise at five.

0:28:41And then, you know, they could meet in there.

0:28:43- Yeah, it was connections, right?

0:28:44It was just, it was a way to connect with people.

0:28:47I remember that between the release of the Mac client,

0:28:52then it was just like, oh, less than a month later,

0:28:58the iPhone was announced.

0:28:59And it was again, you know, it was announced

0:29:01and then we had to wait until June

0:29:04in order to get the devices.

0:29:05And I, by the time that WWDC rolled around, I had had jailbroken.

0:29:13I had that first version of Putter effect running on the phone.

0:29:17And my battery was dead before I got to San Francisco.

0:29:21It's just like, because it's like, I had no idea that the radio used so much power.

0:29:28And you know, I'm just like, I'm leaving the radio on all the time.

0:29:32I mean, even like, you know, the shut down in my pocket radio was on.

0:29:36So which and you know, it was it was that that was part of the evolution, part of the learning process, part of, you know, making a product that that would work in extreme environment.

0:29:47So while we're while we're going down this style, Jelena, I'm trying to think of the timing of when so the iPhone came out in June, end of June, 2007.

0:29:58Jailbreaking started very soon thereafter.

0:30:02And it's shocking, really, to me, it still is, how without any help from Apple, that developers,

0:30:14a small crew of very, very clever developers were able to sort of backwards engineer how to get Xcode to generate binaries

0:30:24that you, if you had a jailbroken phone that you could install and then all of a sudden we had

0:30:31native third-party apps without any native third-party app support from Apple. And they were

0:30:38good. I mean, yeah. No, again, back to, you know, conferences and people getting together,

0:30:45and it was at C4 in Chicago where I met Lucas Newman and saw his lights off or lights out. I

0:30:52I can never remember what it is, but that was like, okay, this takes an iPhone.

0:31:00It's very Apple-like.

0:31:02Oh, by the way, he used the Apple APIs that we all knew, right?

0:31:08It was, they had a UI table instead of an NS table, right?

0:31:13It's like that, it was pretty clear to me that the Apple had done a smart thing, right?

0:31:18They had basically taken APIs and ways of programming that they knew worked really well

0:31:26because they've been using them on the Mac since, you know, or they've been using them

0:31:30actually since Next.

0:31:31And got those running on a mobile device.

0:31:36And that was one of the reasons why things took off, right?

0:31:40Because it was something familiar, right?

0:31:43It was just something that people latched onto.

0:31:45And then that's, you know, I basically came home from Chicago from that conference and

0:31:50started working on a Twitter client.

0:31:52I was that, you know, that enthused by it.

0:31:57And got a bit of a head start, you know, and at that point there was no SDK either, right?

0:32:00You know, as you were saying, there was, Apple had said nothing about how you build these

0:32:04things.

0:32:05We kind of figured it out.

0:32:06You know, basically there's this thing called Class Stump that lets you take any Objective-C

0:32:13binary and suck all the strings out of it and put those strings in a format that is

0:32:21familiar for people who code against those APIs. So, you know, it was, I mean...

0:32:28And basically...

0:32:29Twitter at that point only supported an XML API. There was no JSON. That was like, you

0:32:35know, that shows you how old the API was, right?

0:32:40And the only way I could get on the jailbreak, the only way I could decode the XML was to

0:32:47call something in the framework that was used by the Microsoft Office file viewers, right?

0:32:55Because, you know, at that point, Office was using XML-based files and, you know, they

0:33:01needed them.

0:33:02to on your iPhone you wanted to preview a Word document, you needed to decode that XML.

0:33:06So I was, I'd found that and I was like, okay, now I can do it. So I'm, you know,

0:33:12I'm using the Microsoft Word code to, you know, display tweets.

0:33:17It was kind of, but that was, that was, it was fun and exciting because you could put

0:33:24that in your hand and take it with you, right? I'm probably the first person in the world

0:33:29who knew how great it was to be standing in line, you know, to check out on groceries

0:33:35and look at Twitter. Right? You know, or just, you know, those moments where, you know, you

0:33:41got nothing else to do. You're just kind of waiting for something, you know, you're,

0:33:45you know, getting your car repaired or something like that. And you're just sitting there,

0:33:49you know, where as you said, we're saying, you know, we used to break open the laptops.

0:33:53Now you just pull out the phone and, you know, do some stuff. And I think that affected the

0:33:59evolution of the service and the product a lot. It was originally conceived as being usable from

0:34:07phones and I've talked about this on the show before it's actually why there was a pretty

0:34:12character limit of 130 because SMS was limited to 160. I think I always get this wrong a little bit.

0:34:20It's 160 or 180 something like that yeah they needed some space for for screen name and stuff

0:34:26or metadata. They were like, so if we're maxed out by SMS's limit of 160, let's say that we'll

0:34:33claim 20 characters for ourselves if we ever need them, and tweets will be limited to 140 characters.

0:34:40And of course, it being 2006, there were issues then about, well, what's a character, right?

0:34:48Right? Because...

0:34:50- Yeah, ask somebody in China what a character is.

0:34:52Or, you know, and I don't, you know, emoji hadn't really, I know that they existed in Japan,

0:34:56but like the explosion of emoji and the modern emoji of thousands of emoji that are available,

0:35:04which are actually, I think you can have up to eight bytes for a single emoji, you know,

0:35:08or maybe more, probably more with the combining characters. So if you tweet a Santa Claus emoji,

0:35:17but set this skin tone to like one of the darker skin tones. There might be like eight bites,

0:35:23which is eight. Yeah, yeah, yeah. There's the original character, the variation selector.

0:35:27All sorts of fun. It adds up. Anyway, all sorts of fun with that back then. But the other thing,

0:35:32though, was that the idea, you know, the, but this is how. And people were using that weird input

0:35:37mechanism to do this, right? You know, that, that you're going to go one, one, one, two, two, three,

0:35:42"333-345-3545."

0:35:43I could never do that.

0:35:45And that was, again, when the iPhone came along,

0:35:47it's like, "Oh, wow, keyboard now."

0:35:49- I jumped on Twitter very early,

0:35:51but only as a web interface.

0:35:53And I don't know that Jack Dorsey,

0:35:55I mean, of course you'd make a website,

0:35:562006 was late enough in the web era

0:35:58that of course there was a website,

0:36:01but when you were on a phone before the iPhone

0:36:04and before Twitterrific and before the modern concept

0:36:07of how you would tweet from a phone,

0:36:09The idea was you would just have an old fashioned keypad phone, not even a smartphone type thing,

0:36:18and you could get text messages from the people you follow.

0:36:22And so instead of a...

0:36:23There was no timeline.

0:36:25It would just be a text message from 011738, which was like Twitter.

0:36:30I don't know what...

0:36:31I'm making the number up, but they had like a five digit number.

0:36:34get it and it would just say, you know, @chockenberry, you know, eating a sandwich. And that would

0:36:40be it. The idea that you would do a timeline, and obviously their website had what we would

0:36:46consider a timeline from the beginning, but the idea that you might, that one might have

0:36:51a timeline like that on their phone was, it took Twitter to the next level. And because

0:36:59obvious reasons. It's these little snack sized nuggets of text tweet length were the perfect

0:37:08size for consumption on a phone. And you could put many of even on the old original 3.5 inch iPhones,

0:37:17you know, you could put quite a few of them on screen, the iPhone scrolled so well, and so

0:37:23smoothly that, you know, for things other than tweets too, but you can just, you know,

0:37:29you could consume Twitter and it was one of the few things where it felt like it was just as good

0:37:36to use Twitter on an early iPhone as it was on a desktop. Whereas…

0:37:40Tim Cynova Yeah, it actually was actually probably better, I would say.

0:37:43David Schanzer Yeah.

0:37:43Tim Cynova Because the whole scrolling thing was very visceral, right? It just like, it just kind of…

0:37:47David Schanzer Yeah.

0:37:47Tim Cynova Your, the physicality of it. That, in fact, that's what excited me, right? It's like,

0:37:53oh, this thing is physical and this thing that I work on works great with that physical input.

0:38:00Trenton Larkin I remember there was Twitter itself by 2008.

0:38:04That was, you know, a, you know, another groundbreaking, very memorable specific

0:38:10South by Southwest. It broke Twitter again. Twitter was already huge, but everybody at

0:38:15South by Southwest had iPhones. And it was m.twitter.com, not mobile, just the letter m.

0:38:23But what it gave you was a web-based interface to Twitter through them that was optimized,

0:38:31effectively optimized for the iPhone, let's face it.

0:38:34But what that meant in 2008, when our iPhones were on the edge network, which if you're

0:38:42not, you might think, oh, yeah, I'm sure edge was slower than...

0:38:46Yeah, you got no idea.

0:38:47Edge was slower than 3G, I'm sure, but it was so slow.

0:38:51I mean, you can look this up. I guess I'll put a link in the show notes to like Wikipedia's entry,

0:38:56but everybody was using it. Everybody was everybody had it. Everybody was like thirsty

0:39:02for it. And it's like, you know, there's one cup of water for you know, 1000 people, right? So

0:39:08they're all in all everyone has a little straw. They're like, so in addition to Twitter breaking

0:39:14during South by Southwest, because of that AT&T's coverage in the convention center area in Austin

0:39:21was flaky wiped out. And yeah, and the best possible edge connection you could get was

0:39:28really slow. But so m dot twitter.com did not show avatars because even if they like compress

0:39:34the hell out of them, it would be all sorts of extra data. It was just the text, but it's all

0:39:42you needed. Right. And right now in some ways, your distinctive username, you know, it worked

0:39:48for you. And that carries back to the text-based era of the internet, right? When we were doing

0:39:55everything through Telnet and everything was in a terminal window, you just recognize people's email

0:40:01addresses or like on a BBS, everybody just had a nickname or IRC still to this day. IRC is a

0:40:09handle-based file. That's how you identify people, by their handle. And Twitter worked great for

0:40:14that. It really did. And again, it's super primitive by what we expect today with LTE and 5G

0:40:23and the ability for those things to stay up, even when you're at like a football game with 70,000

0:40:29fans. You know, we expect our phones to continue working, and they do. But by…

0:40:35David Schanzer 0 Yeah, no, there's been a lot of technological change

0:40:39in the last 16 years that we've been working on Twitterrific.

0:40:43They're an immense amount, you know, phones, network speeds, CPUs, you know, that, you

0:40:51know, you think about the first CPU that was in the first iPhone versus, you know, what

0:40:55we've got now with the A, I even forget what the number is, 16, 18, something, you

0:41:00know, it's just like so fast.

0:41:03What hasn't changed, though, is people, right?

0:41:06The humanity behind it, the need to connect with other people, the need to kind of know

0:41:11what your friends are doing. That's important to a lot of people. And that hasn't changed in that

0:41:17period of time. So you had, while we're on memory lane, you had Twitterrific running, I mean, and it

0:41:23was good before the SDK was out. And it was like on Cydia or someplace too. And it was very much

0:41:32a niche kind of thing. But it wasn't just my favorite third party app. It was probably, you

0:41:39it instantly became my favorite iPhone,

0:41:42more favorite than all of Apple's own,

0:41:44maybe other than Safari, of course,

0:41:46'cause having the web on--

0:41:47- Yeah, that was killer. - On the phone was killer.

0:41:50- Yeah, that was the best.

0:41:51- It was nice to have mail, but email is so verbiage.

0:41:56Most emails I write are longer,

0:41:59you don't wanna peck 'em out with your thumb.

0:42:01It still is great to have email on the phone,

0:42:03but it's not better on the phone

0:42:06than on a desktop with a real keyboard.

0:42:08And messages was obviously,

0:42:11people forget how the presentation,

0:42:13the modern presentation of a messaging app

0:42:16was pioneered by messages on the iPhone.

0:42:20- Yeah, green bubbles.

0:42:22Everybody complains about green bubbles.

0:42:24For a while, that's all you had.

0:42:25- Well, and that they're conceptually sorted

0:42:28by who the chat is with, right?

0:42:30Like on those old Nokia T9 phones,

0:42:33you just had a list of the messages.

0:42:35And so like, if I got a message from you,

0:42:39then a message from my wife,

0:42:41and then a message from my wife,

0:42:44and then a message from you,

0:42:46your messages would be like numbers one and four

0:42:49in a single list with two from my wife in between.

0:42:52And it was just, you know, just showed as--

0:42:54- It was hard to read, right?

0:42:55Yeah, it was not good.

0:42:56There was no-- - No threading.

0:42:58There were no threads. - Yeah, well,

0:42:59there was nobody thinking about user interaction, right?

0:43:02the phone companies were never good at making usable software. They still kind of aren't,

0:43:08but you know. But the concept was effectively like, like remember those pink pieces of paper

0:43:14that we used to use for phone calls when you were out at work? Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. So,

0:43:19you had a stack of these and if the phone rang in and somebody wasn't there, then somebody,

0:43:24you know, it was like phone call and then you'd write who it was, what time, what date,

0:43:29and what they said to tell you,

0:43:31and then you'd get back to your desk

0:43:33and there'd just be a stack of these pink papers

0:43:36from maybe two of them are from the same person,

0:43:39maybe they're from seven different people,

0:43:41but that was the concept of SMS on phones before iMessage.

0:43:45I mean, I know that Apple didn't,

0:43:46Apple actually just called it SMS originally,

0:43:49but I'll call it Messages,

0:43:50'cause it's obviously the same app.

0:43:52- It was the messaging app, yeah.

0:43:53- So that was a big one, but Twitter was just mind-blowing,

0:43:56'cause like you said, I honestly think Twitter

0:43:58on the phone was better than Twitter on a desktop. It was the one thing that was better

0:44:03on the desktop. 'Cause, and—

0:44:05Well, the thing too is because it was better, I totally agree that it was better on the

0:44:10phone than on the desktop. But even in those very early days, right, in the jailbreak days,

0:44:16there were actually a couple of different apps. There was another one called Twinkle,

0:44:21which was—they took a totally different approach. So that whole UI playground idea

0:44:27started really early. In fact, back then there were also websites that people were using the

0:44:39quote unquote sweet solution to get Twitter, and they were making their own, they were hitting the

0:44:46API, doing their own thing, XML HTTP requests, filling in a timeline, and we were kind of all

0:44:55seeing what this new thing could do. And yeah, it was...

0:45:00Well, so what happened? And then once they announced the SDK, you were already working

0:45:05on Jailbreaking and Steve Jobs said, "Okay, okay, we hear you. We're going to do an SDK in a couple

0:45:11of months. Give us some time to get it right." And then they announced it in March. I believe that

0:45:16was the first event JAWS ever hosted. JAWS, I remember, hosted the... Here's our keynote

0:45:23introducing the developer SDK. And then you did the smart thing and adopted the official SDK as

0:45:31opposed to staying jailbroken, even though in some ways it was more limited because instead of having

0:45:38access to all of the private APIs that you had figured out, it was like the first public APIs

0:45:44were the, here's the subset of them. Yeah, I was pretty happy to stop digging around in the

0:45:51Microsoft XML parser. It was obviously a better way to go. It was worth the wait.

0:45:59It also gave us some time to sort of step back. And I view that the original jailbreak one is just

0:46:10the experimental phase. All of our products kind of have a experimental phrase. We typically don't

0:46:17do those in public. With the jailbreak, we were kind of that we that was the only option to do it

0:46:23in public. So, yeah, we kind of stepped back and thought about, okay, what do we want to do given

0:46:30the constraint to the phone? You know, like my experience of, you know, killing the battery by

0:46:34keeping the radio on, that was like, okay, how are we going to deal with that? Right? There are,

0:46:40you know, you search it when you experiment with something new, you quickly learn what

0:46:46constraints are. And that, for software development, is hugely important.

0:46:50Yeah. Yeah. You got to play test to figure it out. You had to make it.

0:46:53Yeah. Yeah.

0:46:54You know, start with an idea, but then don't be, you know, strong ideas loosely held, right?

0:46:59Right.

0:46:59Here's how I think it'll work. Let me get it working. And then you start using it,

0:47:02and you're like, oh, this would be better.

0:47:05Well, remember that early version also had a transparent background because we thought

0:47:09it'd be nice to see your – and then it's like you take it out in bright sunlight and go, oh,

0:47:13this is a bad idea.

0:47:15Then by 2008, June, you know, one year into the iPhone, there was already an Apple design

0:47:23awards for the iPhone, right? It was the very first year the SDK was literally only four months old,

0:47:32April, May, June, maybe three months old.

0:47:35I seem to remember we had very little time from the SDK drop to the point of,

0:47:41you know, submitting the stuff for the App Store. It was just like, how are we going to do this in

0:47:46three months? Well, we did it. Here's where my memory is, you know, well, it's halfway like

0:47:53Swiss cheese at this point. And yeah, it's funny. It's funny because as my memory gets fuzzier,

0:48:00it's not just that I don't remember certain things. It's that I'm not 100% sure if what I

0:48:06remember actually happened or not, or if my mind sort of turned the way you wanted it to be.

0:48:13It's sort of like what you're, well yeah, it's like an adaptation, right? So like,

0:48:17if you take a 500 page novel and you want to make a two-hour movie out of it, you've got to

0:48:23consolidate some characters, right? So instead of having three police detectives, you just make one,

0:48:30and it's that character has all three of the roles from the the novel and but here's here's a memory

0:48:37I have I remember that when when you won when when icon factory won that apple design award in 2008

0:48:45for the twitterific three months into the app store it it was so joyous I can't remember if

0:48:52it's if you were my first friend to win an ada or not probably not because you know no I think

0:48:58cable. Yeah, those guys. Steven probably. Yeah, the Panic guys. Yeah, they were the pros at that point.

0:49:04But it was always, you know, the ADAs are still, you know, prestigious, but man, in that

0:49:11in that 2010-20-2000s decade for our indie pals, the ADAs, that it was just so joyous whenever

0:49:21somebody we knew won, and it was so, again, it was just, oh my god, this is awesome, and it should be

0:49:27no surprise because the Twitter effect was just so amazing, but you never know. Apples taste in the

0:49:36ADA, like everything else about Apple, can be inscrutable. But you won. And what I remember

0:49:41was that was the night where me and you and the panic gang went to...

0:49:48to...

0:49:49Cory.

0:49:50Chevys.

0:49:51Oh God, yeah.

0:49:52Chevys.

0:49:53And had those giant margaritas.

0:49:54Yeah, Chevys was a Mexican, big, big Mexican restaurant.

0:49:59The type of big Mexican restaurant that was exactly at the right location.

0:50:04Cat-A-Corner from a convention center.

0:50:06Yeah.

0:50:07And they served margaritas the size of Craig's hands.

0:50:12Margaritas.

0:50:14Margaritas that looked big even in your hands.

0:50:18And we were all on cloud nine, of course you especially.

0:50:21- But I remember getting off the stage

0:50:25and I just, I tweeted just holy shit.

0:50:30And that was it.

0:50:31And everybody who followed me knew what that meant, right?

0:50:35It was like, I didn't have to say,

0:50:36oh, I just won an ADA award.

0:50:38Here's me, it was just like, it was very raw at that point.

0:50:41- Here's the other thing that I remember.

0:50:43I think it was when we were coordinating,

0:50:45where should we go?

0:50:45And before we just said, hey, you know,

0:50:47the panic eyes are going over to Chevy's, let's meet them.

0:50:49I forget, it was about, I don't know, about 10 of us there.

0:50:52But I remember, and this could be a false memory,

0:50:55but I seem to recall that you and I were in the,

0:50:58at the bottom level of, street level of Moscone West,

0:51:01like in the lobby, waiting to figure out what should we do,

0:51:05where should we go, and people were coming up

0:51:07and congratulating you, people easily recognized you.

0:51:10And even people who maybe didn't know

0:51:12that what you look like or that you're rather tall,

0:51:16They knew you after they had just seen you go on stage

0:51:19to take the award, right?

0:51:20You had just been on stage.

0:51:21- They go, "Holy shit, that guy's tall."

0:51:22- And a mutual friend of ours who was at Apple

0:51:27on the secret iPhone team on their performance team,

0:51:31and I believe is still there

0:51:33and might still be on the same team,

0:51:34so I'm not going to say his name,

0:51:36but I think you know who I'm talking about,

0:51:38came up to you to congratulate you

0:51:41and then dropped like a bomb on you,

0:51:44like, hey, and by the way, for scrolling,

0:51:47what you really probably wanna do is embed a UI view

0:51:52in a UI view instead of using a table,

0:51:55something like that, right?

0:51:57Like, you had been doing a certain thing.

0:52:00He knew exactly what you were doing, and he--

0:52:03- Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah.

0:52:04Well, they had like a two or three year head start

0:52:06on the scrolling.

0:52:07- Right, and he knew exactly what you were doing

0:52:11and said, yeah, we ran into that with this,

0:52:15two or three of them,

0:52:16named some of their first party apps.

0:52:18And what we figured out is if you embed sub views

0:52:21and do this, and it was gibberish to me.

0:52:24- It was all, yeah, for the technical listeners,

0:52:29it's all about flattening the view hierarchy, right?

0:52:31It's like, there was actually Azure scrolling,

0:52:33those views had to be created and views that contained views

0:52:37were less performance, less performant

0:52:39than if you just created a snapshot,

0:52:42basically created a snapshot of the view, right?

0:52:44Let the GPU do all the work.

0:52:46And I was like, oh yeah, of course.

0:52:51And a while later, met up with Lauren Brikter

0:52:55and he kind of relayed the same thing.

0:52:58It's like, that's one of the reasons

0:53:00why Tweety was so awesome.

0:53:02Because I mean, Lauren actually did the cover flow

0:53:05on the original iPod app.

0:53:07Was it the iPod app?

0:53:08I think it was called the iPod app or iTunes.

0:53:11- Yeah. - Way back,

0:53:12whatever it was called.

0:53:13- Yeah, it was called iPod. - I think it had the cover flow.

0:53:15And you know, the guy who makes cover flow

0:53:19is probably gonna make a pretty good Twitter kind,

0:53:21you know, scrolling, so.

0:53:23- But I just remember the, yeah,

0:53:24that I understood the, you know,

0:53:26I know enough about programming

0:53:28and I understood the idea of flattening the view

0:53:30and then therefore having way fewer

0:53:33of these object instantiations for each one.

0:53:36And while you're scrolling fast,

0:53:38And one of the things that's still fun to do on an iPhone

0:53:40is just scroll fast as like a fiddle toy.

0:53:44I just remember though, when he dropped that on you,

0:53:47it like, you instantly went from the euphoria of,

0:53:52holy shit, we just won an ADA to,

0:53:54oh my God, I know exactly what he's talking about.

0:53:58And it's really bugged you all along

0:54:03that Twitterific wasn't scrolling as smoothly

0:54:06as like say, Messages was, right?

0:54:07That's true.

0:54:12You weren't there the next day.

0:54:13I met a guy named Rizwan Sattar, who was at that point working on the AOL app, I believe

0:54:19it was.

0:54:20And he's like, I was asking all these questions about the scroll view because I was having

0:54:26trouble making things snap like the Photos app did, you know, when you scroll a photo,

0:54:32kind of snaps into place.

0:54:33And I had written a bunch of code to try to emulate that.

0:54:37And I was like, this is really hard.

0:54:40He came up to me after one of the presentations

0:54:42and said, you know, there's just this flag you can set.

0:54:46I was like, I literally spent like, you know,

0:54:49probably three or four weeks on doing my own implementation.

0:54:53- Right.

0:54:54- And again, it was because I missed the documentation.

0:54:57Right, it's like the, you know,

0:55:00I was doing a lot of this stuff before even the, you know,

0:55:02Apple was publishing the SDK, but it wasn't, you know,

0:55:06like, you know, description forthcoming kind of thing, right? It's like, they had a lot of work

0:55:10to do as far as documentation. So, yeah.

0:55:13John Greenewald So in addition to missing documentation period,

0:55:16there was also the fact that a big part of it was the best practices for how to use them.

0:55:21Tim Cynova Yeah, yeah.

0:55:22John Greenewald So you could read, let's just say if you're a

0:55:25superhuman developer and you could read the API documentation from start to finish and memorize

0:55:33at all. That still didn't tell you how best to do something to get like performance scrolling.

0:55:38But you, but it was so good as it was that you won the Apple Design Award and it was

0:55:45and revolutionized the way people think of Twitter. Other things, and I know we've covered them before,

0:55:50but why not cover them now? Twitter-ifics use of Ollie the bird as the icon predates Twitter having

0:56:00a bird as its logo. Like, and you guys mentioned it and rightly so, you know, that the, it,

0:56:06it, it, the, the story behind that is the Mac app, which we started working on late

0:56:132006, released early 2007. Now I'm a developer, right? And I just put this crappy little icon

0:56:20in the app that, that, you know, I knew it was a placeholder and we were all using the

0:56:25app and David Lanham just one day sent me this little blue bird.

0:56:32Now David is one of your colleagues at iConfact.

0:56:36He was a colleague. He's now out on his own, but yeah, he's a super talented artist, great guy,

0:56:44and he sent me this icon and I could not get that into our software repository fast enough. I mean,

0:56:49It's just obviously this just works. And yeah, that predates Twitter's icon for, I mean, at the

0:56:59time, all they had was the wordmark. You know, the big fat round Twitter letter. And that was it.

0:57:05Pete: And then as a, if they needed something smaller and square, they just used the T from

0:57:12- Yeah. - It's like Twitter, Walmart.

0:57:14- And that whole, you know,

0:57:17David coming up with the Bluebird, that was the first step.

0:57:22And one of the challenges I had in that early app

0:57:26was coming up with verbs and nouns

0:57:29because we had no name for these things.

0:57:31- Right. - Right?

0:57:32It's like, you know, they were SMS posts,

0:57:37they were posts of some other kind.

0:57:41And they, and in developing the UI, it's like, I needed to say, you know, something

0:57:46that, you know, refresh what we call, well, okay, let's call it a timeline, you know,

0:57:52post what am I going?

0:57:54I'm not going to say post a post.

0:57:55I'm not going to, you know, you know, I'm not going to say send a post.

0:57:59It's just, it was really kind of, I was just like, okay, I'm going to put a

0:58:03placeholder in here.

0:58:03I'm going to call them twits.

0:58:06So the first version of Twitter, if it used Twits, and it had the, the, the bluebird icon

0:58:16and folks at Twitter were actually using this app.

0:58:19They loved it, right?

0:58:20That they were like, Oh wow, this, somebody's making something awesome with our API.

0:58:25They were all into it.

0:58:26And Blaine Cook, one of their, he was actually the guy that was helping scale the app, getting it, you

0:58:33you know, so they wouldn't fail whale and all that.

0:58:36Just sent me an email one time, he says,

0:58:38you know, tweets is not a very good name, you know,

0:58:41if you thought about maybe calling them like tweet,

0:58:43and I was like, that was fucking,

0:58:45- Yeah. - The bird tweeting.

0:58:48Yeah, okay, great. - Right.

0:58:49- And that was the first, you know,

0:58:51first time anybody called them a tweet.

0:58:53- So the bird came first, and then from the bird

0:58:57as the icon came the verb and noun tweet.

0:59:01- Yeah. - That's amazing.

0:59:02It's unbelievable.

0:59:03Yeah.

0:59:04All right.

0:59:05Yeah.

0:59:06No, and see, it was very experimental at that point.

0:59:08It was just everybody...

0:59:10Nobody knew what they were doing, right?

0:59:12It was just...

0:59:13We were just kind of all like...

0:59:15But you knew when it was right.

0:59:17Like I knew when that Bluebird came along.

0:59:20That was it.

0:59:21Well...

0:59:22That was what we were missing.

0:59:23And among...

0:59:24And then Tweak came along.

0:59:25It's like that's another thing we were missing.

0:59:27And among other things, in terms of innovations that were driven by third party...

0:59:32And it speaks both to the role of third-party developers on iOS, moving iOS forward in the

0:59:38idioms and also Twitter itself right at the intersection of it was that in his, after

0:59:46Lauren Brikter left Apple and struck out on his own, he made Tweety and invented pool

0:59:52to refresh.

0:59:53Yeah, that was another thing.

0:59:55I was like, oh, I wish I thought of that.

0:59:57So we, one of the things...

1:00:00One of the things…

1:00:01That was a really good thing.

1:00:02And then it kind of goes back to, you know, these innovations in Twitter were far-reaching,

1:00:08right?

1:00:09You know, there are screen names at GitHub.

1:00:11There are hashtags.

1:00:13Anywhere you look, there's a hashtag.

1:00:15You know, the notion of replying to somebody's thing, right?

1:00:20There are these linkages between, you know, thought.

1:00:23This stuff is spreading, right?

1:00:24You know, it's like they're, you know, pull to refresh.

1:00:28If you're on App to .NET pull to refresh now,

1:00:30it's like, what the hell are you thinking?

1:00:32- It reminds me of like back in the classic Mac OS era

1:00:36when Mac TCP was like shareware, right?

1:00:39And so the extension that you installed on your Mac

1:00:44to do TCP/IP networking didn't come from Apple.

1:00:48It was like a community project.

1:00:51And the idea that pull to refresh in a list

1:00:55on these touchscreen devices didn't come from Apple.

1:00:58But I think easily, it was so obvious

1:01:01that even within a year, Apple adopted it

1:01:03and had APIs and figured out,

1:01:05here's how this can be part of it.

1:01:07It did not take long. - Yeah, that little segment,

1:01:09they even came up with the little segmented control

1:01:11that kind of spins as you pull down.

1:01:13And that was all they,

1:01:15it was clearly, they had the same reaction that I did.

1:01:18It's like, ah, geez, I wish I thought like that.

1:01:20- It was just such an exciting time

1:01:22and innovations were coming left and right.

1:01:24All right, let me take another break here

1:01:25and thank our next sponsor.

1:01:26It is our good friends at Nebula.

1:01:30Nebula is a streaming service created and owned

1:01:33by some of the internet's most thoughtful creators.

1:01:36And that's, it really is true, it's important

1:01:38that they are in fact owners, they have equity

1:01:41in the service, and they offer full length

1:01:44and ad-free videos earlier than anywhere else,

1:01:47as well as Nebula exclusive content.

1:01:51Fully produced Nebula originals like Anita Sarkeesian's

1:01:54that time when or impact.

1:01:57Rene Ritchie, friend of the show,

1:01:58I don't know if you've ever heard of him,

1:02:00Rene Ritchie has a channel on Nebula.

1:02:02For example, he's got like a feature length retrospective

1:02:04on the launch of the iPhone.

1:02:06He also posts a lot of his stuff,

1:02:08and a lot of the creators on Nebula do the same thing,

1:02:11where they'll post the same stuff that they post to YouTube,

1:02:15but put an extended version on Nebula.

1:02:17And if you've ever been listening

1:02:18to a lot of YouTube channels,

1:02:19you might hear them say at the end of their YouTube videos

1:02:22that you could check them out on Nebula.

1:02:23You don't just get them ad-free

1:02:26as opposed to YouTube on Nebula,

1:02:27but you get extended versions.

1:02:29And it is to YouTube what HBO was

1:02:34to regular commercial TV back in the day.

1:02:38It's the best of the best.

1:02:40And it is, you know, you get what you pay for.

1:02:44They've also got Nebula classes.

1:02:46So like this whole online learn at your own pace

1:02:49through video expertise in small nuggets

1:02:53and have them be professionally produced and edited

1:02:59and so that it doesn't feel like doing homework.

1:03:01It actually, while you're learning,

1:03:03it actually feels more like entertainment.

1:03:05So they've got nebula classes for all kinds of stuff,

1:03:08including an introduction to programming

1:03:10called What Is Code from creator

1:03:12and NYU professor Daniel Schiffman.

1:03:15So that might be of interest to people

1:03:17who listen to this show.

1:03:17bonus and exclusive content, all sorts of other stuff.

1:03:20I really love it, it is so great,

1:03:23and you might think, ah, you know, YouTube's good enough.

1:03:25I'm telling you, try it out,

1:03:27they've got so much good stuff there.

1:03:29It is normally just five bucks a month,

1:03:32or 50 bucks a year, but listeners of the talk show,

1:03:34you can get a whole year of Nebula for just 40 bucks,

1:03:38that's cheap, for a whole year of this,

1:03:41by going to nebula.tv/thetalkshow.

1:03:45That's nebula.tv/thetalkshow.

1:03:49Go check it out.

1:03:50Watch a couple of the videos and you'll see how good they are and you'll see what a bargain

1:03:54it is at 40 bucks a year.

1:03:55My thanks to Nebula.

1:03:56I can't imagine how great it must be to be able to watch somebody code and watch along

1:04:03with somebody who knows what they're doing.

1:04:07I mean, I'm old enough to...

1:04:10When I first started coding, right, it's like we had magazines.

1:04:13I know.

1:04:14We had no bulletin boards. It was just like, you know, you copied and pasted code out of,

1:04:20you know, Byte magazine.

1:04:21Well, what I remember when they started, I don't know, floppy disks were always so expensive,

1:04:26or at least they were back then. That in the early days, you would literally have to retype

1:04:31the program. You know, it was the only thing they'd give you is the print out, you know,

1:04:35they'd say, here's a sample program.

1:04:36And there was no OCR or anything.

1:04:38No, no OCR. Definitely not.

1:04:40you'd get an O for zero or something,

1:04:44and it's like that one character screwing you up

1:04:47and it'd take you hours to find it.

1:04:49- It was a breakthrough when those programming magazines

1:04:52could start shipping CDs,

1:04:54or maybe they did have floppies at some point

1:04:56and they just charged, it was like a $15 magazine

1:04:58or something, but you'd get a floppy disk

1:05:00and then you could actually have the sample programs

1:05:03without retyping them, it was groundbreaking.

1:05:06- And then you could download them from the internet.

1:05:09- Yeah, I'll just say this about Nebula.

1:05:11The sponsor reads over, but I'll just point this out too,

1:05:13that it does fit with the theme of the show,

1:05:16which is that this idea or situation of indie developers,

1:05:21the wide open world of creativity that the internet enables,

1:05:30being dependent on one choke point corporate overload.

1:05:34And people are certainly a lot happier with YouTube

1:05:38than they are with Twitter, but still, YouTube is YouTube.

1:05:43And if they pull your ads or something for some reason,

1:05:47or they pull the whole video because somebody said

1:05:49that some algorithm detected that there was

1:05:52a copyright violation of some music or something like that,

1:05:56YouTube's in charge there.

1:05:58On Nebula, the creators are in charge.

1:06:01If everybody is sort of having a reckoning,

1:06:06I certainly am, and sort of looking at certain

1:06:11dependencies we've had on things like Twitter

1:06:15as opposed to the openness of Mastodon

1:06:17and rethinking my priorities and not being lazy.

1:06:21Nebula is to YouTube what, you know,

1:06:24something more federated or more in control of the creators

1:06:27than a service is for truly professional video.

1:06:31So anyway.

1:06:33- Yeah, there's a silver lining in all this for me.

1:06:36It's the outpouring of support,

1:06:40people saying how much they've appreciated our work,

1:06:45people saying, I got into design

1:06:46because that first version of Twitter,

1:06:48I think kind of inspired me.

1:06:50I've had people tell me,

1:06:53it's like they got into iOS programming

1:06:55because they saw what I was doing.

1:06:57I mean, that to me is so rewarding.

1:07:00that's kind of the dream of indie development. You're doing something for somebody else,

1:07:06not for an advertiser, a corporate client, or business to business bullshit.

1:07:13Jim Collins Right. Well, that exactly, though, is what

1:07:16in that era, the indie developers I knew were only working on two platforms. I mean,

1:07:23I didn't know that there were Windows, of course, Windows indie developers. I'm sure more of them,

1:07:29because Windows was and remained so much bigger. And of course, there was the indie games market,

1:07:34which was already, you know, has been a thing as long as you've been able to.

1:07:37David Schanzer Yeah, games are a separate thing.

1:07:39David Schanzer But in people I knew, I knew web developers and I knew Mac developers,

1:07:44and I didn't know anybody who wrote phones, phone software. It never even I don't even know anybody

1:07:50who thought, hey, should we write something for a phone? Because there was no way to write.

1:07:55even if you... Well, there was some Java stuff, you know, it was just like it was clunky.

1:08:02Well, you could just like, "Oh, I'm not doing this." Right. A, even if you did it, you weren't

1:08:08going to make something that was actually joyful or joyous or well-designed. B, you couldn't

1:08:13distribute it to anybody because everything... You had to go through the phone company.

1:08:17As Steve Jobs famous called them the orifices, but it was this bureaucratic, like, Terry Gilliam's

1:08:24Brazil nightmare of the and they just they didn't see a problem with it because they I don't think

1:08:29that the carriers ever envisioned anybody else would just the only only only other major

1:08:37corporations you know like apple deserves a lot of credit for cracking that right so it wasn't

1:08:43it wasn't a deal with singular it wasn't just writing touch screen software which was new or

1:08:49or having a bright colorful 3.5 inch screen,

1:08:52which seemed huge compared to the phones

1:08:55that only had a little tiny, you know,

1:08:57postage stamp screen above a keyboard.

1:09:00It was the idea of writing for phones at all.

1:09:03And we just started with these devices

1:09:06that were so much more amazing

1:09:08and could enable incredibly beautiful software.

1:09:12Software that wasn't like,

1:09:13"Hey, that looks pretty good for a phone."

1:09:16It was actually, hey, that looks better than Mac apps,

1:09:19you know, like the,

1:09:20- Right.

1:09:20- 'Cause the iPhone had smaller pixels and it was,

1:09:23you could make an iPhone app that looked better

1:09:27than Mac apps even looked.

1:09:28Let, you know, whereas,

1:09:31- Especially at a distance, right?

1:09:32You know, that was, you know, everybody, you know,

1:09:34it's like the retinal display is awesome.

1:09:36- Right.

1:09:37- But at the distance you were typically holding the screen

1:09:39of the original iPhone, the pixels kind of disappeared

1:09:43and that's how they got away with all those rich textures

1:09:45question. Question for you. Do you think Apple knew that the App Store was going to be a thing

1:09:55at the time that the iPhone came out? Do you think that they were happy with just having that one

1:10:02screen of their own apps and that was it? I think that, you know, having read enough of the jobs

1:10:08biographies. I think, you know, like, I think it's what most people would guess was the truth,

1:10:14which is that there were some people in Apple who felt like it's, you know, before the iPhone

1:10:21was even announced, that, oh, it's inevitable that we're, this is going to be a thing sort of

1:10:27at some way like the Mac, where these, these apps that we're making with the UI kit will be made by

1:10:34third-party developers, just like third-party developers can do things for the Mac. And then,

1:10:39you know, I think Steve Jobs himself was...

1:10:42I think sort of had a "we'll see" attitude towards it.

1:10:48Yeah, that's my guess too. It was like, you know, this is a possibility, let's not discard it,

1:10:54let's see how it plays out. I mean, launching a product of that scope,

1:10:59you know, you know you're going to be busy with it for a year.

1:11:02Right.

1:11:03At least.

1:11:04Right. And, you know, the thing about Jobs was that he was one of his very, very best abilities

1:11:11was his unbelievable ability to change his mind. And famously what he would often do, I mean,

1:11:18so many people have the exact same story. And Andy Hertzfeld, I think, probably told the earliest

1:11:22versions of it in his wonderful, wonderful Revolution in the Valley book, which is also at

1:11:28the website folklore.org. It's kind of weird that the book is Revolution in the Valley and the

1:11:33website is folklore.org, but it's the same content. But the story that would happen over and over

1:11:39again is someone would come up to Steve and say, "Here's my idea. I want to do X." And he'd think

1:11:44about it and say, "That's the dumbest thing I ever heard." No, we're not doing that. And then the next

1:11:48day, Jobs would come in and go to the same guy and say, "Hey, I had a good idea yesterday. I think we

1:11:54we should do. What if we do X?" And it's the exact same thing. But he would say it like

1:12:00that the, you know, it's like he slept on it, his brain absorbed the idea, and then

1:12:04he thought it was his idea. And then, you know, the engineer, you just learn to go with

1:12:08it. That's how you got your ideas approved. And I think it could be like that, where he

1:12:12was thinking, you know, because the other weird thing about being Steve Jobs is he could

1:12:18get every single app he wanted onto the phone because he was Steve Jobs, you know, and,

1:12:23know, if it was him who said, "Oh, I definitely want a YouTube app built into the original iPhone,"

1:12:28he could make that happen. He could call Eric Schmidt and they could, you know, work out a deal

1:12:32and they'll give, you know, that YouTube app was written by Apple, but obviously with APIs and

1:12:39permission from Google. Yeah, thank God he didn't want a Twitter app. I know, right? Exactly. But it

1:12:46would have been totally different. My whole career trajectory would have been totally different. Right,

1:12:50If he did, he would have had it. So that is the one thing where everybody else is looking at the

1:12:55original iPhone and people like me and you and you know are looking and thinking, "Oh, I would like

1:13:00to put blank on the iPhone." Whereas Steve Jobs already had everything. Yeah, he had that ability.

1:13:05No, I think that they knew that. And the fact that he made that announcement that, "Okay, we're going

1:13:10to do an SDK by September." I mean, the phone was only three or four months out. I mean, and it was,

1:13:16you know, it's clear from, I remember you guys saying it, of course, Apple wanted their own,

1:13:21even if it had remained first party only for a year or two longer, which I think is the most

1:13:28it could have possibly lasted before they opened the gates. Of course, Apple wanted for their own

1:13:34apps the best APIs possible, right? That was, you know, the best, some of the best.

1:13:39that yeah, and it was pretty obvious from working with the jailbreak API is that, you know, if they

1:13:46all engineers do it, right? You cut corners on that first version.

1:13:50Right. Because they had to ship.

1:13:51Natural thing to do.

1:13:52Right.

1:13:53Yeah. You're more interested in the ship date than the code being a hundred percent beautiful

1:13:57and perfect.

1:13:58Right. We could do this in a way where it might blow up if you do it wrong,

1:14:01but we will just know not to do it wrong.

1:14:04My, my, yeah, my favorite was that you could feed a little snippet of HTML to any label view

1:14:10on, on the first SDK that, you know, the, the jailbreak SDK. And, you know, they obviously

1:14:17knew that they had to limit themselves, you know, to bold or italic or, you know, color changes,

1:14:22you know, but, you know, you could put a table view in that label and all hell would break loose.

1:14:29you know, you could do an iframe because it was just webkits invited. It was like,

1:14:34yeah, we're not going to release that.

1:14:36All right, enough of sunshine and happiness and fond memories. Let's recap where we are. So,

1:14:46with this shutdown last week. So, things that I want to mention. This is not,

1:14:53it was not a surprise, right? And even predating SpaceKaren taking, how do you like that?

1:15:00Oh, there you go. You meant to say Elon Musk, right?

1:15:03Even predating SpaceKaren, this entire SpaceKaren saga, we've had, it has been, I guess,

1:15:11for a longer period of time than when it seemed like whatever period of time when Twitter as a

1:15:17company fully embraced third-party clients and, like you said, celebrated them and loved

1:15:23Twitterific. And you know, you had access to Blaine Cook and could, you know, talk to the

1:15:30people at Twitter and they loved it. It's been a longer period of time where they, we've all,

1:15:37those of us who love these third-party clients have been worried that they were going to just

1:15:40go away because they started limiting them, you know, famously at some point, I don't know what

1:15:47year it was when they said the, it was sort of Apple like where they didn't say we're going to

1:15:52stop accepting new Twitter clients, but they more or less said we these API shouldn't be used to

1:15:56replicate the Twitter experience, something right, right, right. So if you want to use them just to

1:16:01write a bot that auto posts your headlines, like I have a script bot that does that for

1:16:06for Daring Fireball. That's fine because that's not a client. But in terms of how should users

1:16:11be viewing Twitter, they shifted to we want people to use the twitter.app. And the twitter.app

1:16:18and the Twitter website started gaining a lot of features that never made it to the

1:16:23third party APIs. They started, I guess, sort of.

1:16:28>> Yeah, for me, I started worrying when Twitter bought Tweety.

1:16:33>> Yeah.

1:16:34>> That was like the first change that was like, okay, this is not going our way.

1:16:40>> Yeah. >> This is their companies.

1:16:41And Ben Thompson's Stratechery this morning talked about that.

1:16:47And he's right, they should have just shit canned us all at that point.

1:16:51>> Mm-hm. >> That would have been,

1:16:52rip the Band-Aid off early.

1:16:55I would have been okay with that, right?

1:16:56It's just like, okay, it's their company,

1:16:59they can do what they want.

1:17:00- I think it depends what their goal was.

1:17:03And I think Jack Dorsey, he can be inscrutable.

1:17:07He sort of communicates almost like a guru, right?

1:17:11Like via Zen Con. - Read between the lines.

1:17:14- Right, but if the idea was that Twitter should be,

1:17:19aspires to be as a company,

1:17:23a multiple tens of billions of dollar

1:17:27publicly held company, which they are.

1:17:30Space Caron bought them for $44 billion.

1:17:35Their aggregate, what do you call it, the market cap,

1:17:38I don't know where they peaked.

1:17:41I don't know how close to 100 billion they ever got.

1:17:43They might have been over 100 billion at some point.

1:17:46If that's the idea, then having third party clients

1:17:50probably wasn't ever a good idea.

1:17:52I still think though that if the idea was that they never tried putting ads in the timelines

1:17:58that the third-party clients deliver, and I get it that I guess it's all about tracking

1:18:03that if they were to…

1:18:04Yeah, that's…

1:18:05That's…

1:18:06I think that's the bottom line, right?

1:18:07Right.

1:18:08Is that they had no… a couple of things, right?

1:18:11You know, if they're… they want to control the presentation of the ads, right?

1:18:17They want to tell the advertisers, "This is what your ad is going to look like,"

1:18:21they also want to be able to tell the advertisers, oh, this is the metrics we can get from that

1:18:25ad. And I'm, first off, it would have been hard for them to get that tracking information

1:18:34from third parties. And secondly, I'm not sure I would have gone for that. I'm very

1:18:40much anti-tracking, you know, people have the right to privacy, that kind of thing.

1:18:46I guess the thing that to me gets lost and and and in tech has really gotten lost and in in that and twitter to me

1:18:53Epitomizes it is the idea that certain ideas can be very good ideas

1:18:58Excellent. I mean like Hall of Fame ideas

1:19:01but may not be you know, the the overall full path and

1:19:06and execution

1:19:09May not be a hundred billion dollar business, right? So

1:19:15Daring Fireball, I'm very proud of it. I think it's a good thing, but there's no way that Daring Fireball could be a

1:19:2120 million dollar a year enterprise. I mean it I

1:19:25There I could have tried to say you wouldn't want it to be right

1:19:29I could have made decisions hired more people to work with me had multiple

1:19:34Bylines on the site and have a small staff not even huge, but you know, I could hire, you know

1:19:40I could have hired five people and

1:19:44multiple done something more like the ringer network and have multiple podcasts under the talk show brand or the daring fireball brand and

1:19:51Have multiple people there and that might have been good and it might have been 20 million or more

1:19:56You know 20 times the size that you know that it is now in terms of revenue

1:20:02But it wouldn't be what it is. It would be something different and I think what it is is worth doing even if it's small

1:20:08Think about like restaurants. It's a perfect example. There are many of everybody I'll bet

1:20:13everybody listening, some of your favorite restaurants are one-off institutions, you know,

1:20:20where the owners of the restaurant are. There is, there's no two locations, it's just one location.

1:20:26The owners are there and they run the place and that's what it is and there is no way to

1:20:32turn it into a chain without really what it is. There's a sushi restaurant here in town who the

1:20:39the head chef owner passed away last year and everybody in town is was like oh my god

1:20:47mickey's gone that that was yeah first thing and the second thing is are they going to reopen

1:20:55and thankfully mickey was one of those people who taught her crew how to make the awesome sushi they

1:21:03all and they're carrying on, right? Because it's beloved by them and it's beloved by the community.

1:21:11But it's never going to be a chain, right? So it's a minor miracle and a fortune of planning

1:21:17and staff loyalty that the one place could outlive the owner, but it just is what it is.

1:21:25Being small. Being small is a gift, right? You being small is a gift to you. It lets you

1:21:33do things that you can't, wouldn't normally be able to do. If you're working for the New York

1:21:36Times, there's things you could not do. It's the icon factory, right? There are just a handful of

1:21:41us. We're doing things like Wallaroo that it, you know, it makes no sense for us to make a wallpaper

1:21:47app. There's a shitload of wallpaper apps out on the store, but we love making wallpapers.

1:21:51>> And you want people to get them in the best possible way.

1:21:55>> We're doing it as much for us as we're doing it for the community. Well, it turns out there

1:21:58are other people out there who like cool wallpapers too, so hey it works out.

1:22:03But I think if you read between the lines of what Jack Dorsey has said in the last year

1:22:06during this whole Space Caron takeover saga that he thinks in hindsight that Twitter should

1:22:11have been a public service type thing, and I think what he's saying is instead of trying

1:22:16to build something that would justify a hundred billion dollar value, you know, they could

1:22:23have done something altogether different and made it more like an API and a plumbing for

1:22:29this type of messaging and to run the namespace of usernames and to run the content moderation

1:22:39and make some money or like Wikipedia, like a foundation. Wikipedia obviously is probably

1:22:46the single triumph of the web. It is, in some ways, it's a total tangent here. I was thinking

1:22:51over the weekend, that in some ways, Wikipedia all by itself is what the Tim Berners-Lee concept

1:22:59of the World Wide Web would be, where there's these pages. There's like a page for everything

1:23:05that you think there should be a page for, and they link to each other. And it's essential.

1:23:11It doesn't—there's no page. Every time those things come up, it's like, "Oh yeah, I'm gonna

1:23:16donate." There's no paywall. It's the same thing. You know, we probably donate twice because it's

1:23:20It's like, we need that thing.

1:23:22- And even when they do ask you for money,

1:23:24they just put a banner at the top and push everything down.

1:23:27They don't cover their goddamn content

1:23:29with a banner telling you to do it.

1:23:31So if Twitter had gone, been something like that,

1:23:34and again, Wikipedia raises money, they pay a staff,

1:23:37they obviously have huge server cost needs,

1:23:39but they're not making $100 billion a year,

1:23:43or they're not justifying $100 billion value,

1:23:46'cause that's not their goal.

1:23:47Their goal is to be a thing.

1:23:48Twitter had been set up like something like that, then I think the third-party clients were

1:23:52obviously the way to go. So, you know, and I'm sure Ben is talking about Twitter as a company,

1:23:58the company that it is and what the goals are. Yeah, exactly. He's looking at it from the

1:24:03business point of view, which, yeah, I would love to have a, like a DNS for usernames. You always

1:24:12want @Gruber. I always want @Chalkenberry. Right. Why do I have to go sign up for all these friend

1:24:18services just to kind of plant my flag. Because it might be useful.

1:24:21Dave Asprey I bet you don't have as much trouble getting

1:24:24Chockenberry as I do Gruber, because Gruber is shockingly, it's the most popular surname in

1:24:29Austria. Hello to all of our Austrian Grubers out there.

1:24:32Tim Cynova I have a different problem with Chockenberry.

1:24:35It's called autocorrect. It always comes out chickenberry.

1:24:38Dave Asprey Chickenberry. I like that. But anyway,

1:24:41it's, it is, it has been many years that we've all been dreading that, hey, they might just pull the

1:24:47plug, right? And the third-party clients for the last, I don't know, five, six years sort of were in a...

1:24:54Living on borrowed time.

1:24:56What's the limbo, right? Limbo was the religious...

1:25:00That's what I mentioned earlier, right? It was like we were kind of coming out of limbo.

1:25:04Right.

1:25:05Kind of, you know, that you could see a glimpse of a bright future.

1:25:09Yeah. Can you?

1:25:10And I think that they were kind of thinking along the lines that Jack had set out there, right?

1:25:15Yeah.

1:25:16It's like, okay, how do we become something that is a resource that businesses need, consumers need,

1:25:24developers need, you know, all of these, how can we satisfy all these people? And they were thinking

1:25:31hard about it. I know for a fact they were thinking hard about it. As much of a loudmouth

1:25:35as that Musk is, one thing we don't know, and he, you know, he supposedly, you know, I, he,

1:25:42at this point you can't I can't take him at his word on anything but you know some of the things

1:25:48he said he wanted he's he's it's the thing that's interesting right it's that that blog post I wrote

1:25:55I didn't mention his name at once but everybody knew who I was talking about when I was talking

1:25:59about you know shitheads yeah you know bozos and all that yeah he's ruining his his reputation

1:26:06right now right well I don't he might be noticing it I don't know but we're certainly noticing

1:26:12we don't know we never for all the things we do know we know he wanted to

1:26:17reinstate a bunch of previously banned accounts and his you know and again i and i i knew that

1:26:23and when i was optimistic about his ownership of twitter i i was on the impression this possibly

1:26:28even though a lot of those banned accounts are people who i literally despise and you know and

1:26:34i think some of them should not they don't affect you though you don't come in contact with them

1:26:39You know, yes, they're spreading filth and lies and, you know, but there's a lot of ways for people to spread filth and lies, not just Twitter.

1:26:48But it is sort of, it's sort of like, you know, in some ways what I thought Musk was talking about was aligned with Dorsey's idea of Twitter as more of a public service.

1:27:00and in a way that any dirt bag hate speech type thing,

1:27:05person can go and register a domain name

1:27:11and if they can find a web host who will host their stuff,

1:27:14have a domain name, I don't, you know,

1:27:17and it just, you know, I wish those people

1:27:20weren't out there, but the fact that they can have a website

1:27:23and it's on the same web as my website is, you know,

1:27:27That is, in some sense, not in a legal sense, but just in a theoretical sense, free speech.

1:27:33And I could see, I still can see, how Twitter having a more light-handed approach to banning

1:27:43people for that type of speech, so long as they provide everybody with tools so you don't have to

1:27:49see it if you don't want to, right? So... So... Right. That's the thing. I have the right to

1:27:53ignore it. You have the right to say it. I have the right to just say, "Fuck you. I'm not listening."

1:27:57to this. You know, in the same way that I just, I literally never just stumble upon Nazi websites.

1:28:04I should never stumble upon Nazi tweets in my, you know, in my timeline. Yeah, exactly. It should not

1:28:11be boosted or retweeted or whatever. But we didn't, so he, you know, he said he was gonna do that. He

1:28:17said he's gonna do some other things. He said he was gonna take out, you know, this was... He says

1:28:21a lot of things. But he never really talked to me, as far as I know, never said anything about third

1:28:26party clients. So what does Elon Musk think about the third party clients? Was he against them?

1:28:32And a lot of us were like, maybe he doesn't really think about it. He surely knows they exist,

1:28:37but does he care? Are they so small that he's fine? This can be a thing that even though he's

1:28:47not into it and it's not one of his priorities, keeping them running wasn't going to draw his

1:28:54attention. The one red flag all along that had me worried was the fact that he has long been opposed,

1:29:04even before he owned the place, opposed to the attribution on tweets that would say,

1:29:10you know, like in small gray text posted from Twitterrific on iOS. It would, you know, and

1:29:16some clients showed them, I think Twitter's own first-party client hasn't been showing

1:29:22him for a long time, but most third-party clients do. And of course the one thing...

1:29:25**Matt Stauffer** Yeah, we show them if you tap on the date, right? It just toggled it and,

1:29:29you know, it showed it. But it's not a mainline piece of information, but it's still kind of

1:29:35important. **Trevor

1:29:35important. But for some reason he'd been opposed to that and said we're going to get rid of it and

1:29:40lo and behold they did get rid of it. The API stopped delivering that info. You know, like I

1:29:45forget what Twitterrific showed but like when they changed the API data so that that info was no

1:29:51longer in each tweet's JSON, some of the clients I saw just had like null, you know, like where it

1:29:59used to say posted from tweetbot on Mac OS, it now just said null or something like that. And then,

1:30:05you know, the all the third party apps that are actively developed just stop trying to show it.

1:30:09But that was the red flag to me that said he's not into third party. He's not just

1:30:15ambivalent but against third party clients. The one thing that was famous, those strings were

1:30:20famous for and Marques Brownlee I think was the best at spotting it was be like when Samsung would

1:30:27be promoting the new Galaxy phone. And the tweet, you know, like never...

1:30:33obviously coming from a PR person with an iPhone. Right, like when the iPhone 10 came out and they

1:30:38had a whole bunch of and whole ad campaign about how stupid the notch was because they didn't have

1:30:42not yeah and then a year later came out but in the meantime they'd have tweets dunking on notches

1:30:48and then the the tweet would say posted from Twitter on iOS and then you know and then all

1:30:54of a sudden there's 5,000 retweets and everybody's dunking on them so you can't do that anymore but

1:30:59So he doesn't have to worry about advertisers anymore, right? He's giving them away.

1:31:04So I think we fans of the clients were worried in two ways. We were worried,

1:31:09A, that he would do what he in fact did do, which is say pull the plug on these apps that just kill

1:31:15them. And then B would be if the API servers fell apart and nobody was there who knew how to

1:31:24kick them to turn them back on and it would just fall apart. And even though they that that that

1:31:29that lack of resources, the of people resources was really my first thought, right? You know,

1:31:36in my first round of layoffs, it's like all the Twitter API, developer relations people,

1:31:41the people working on it, they they got shit. Right. And that was like, okay, how well is this

1:31:47API gonna work? And you know, a month. And so we spent Friday night when this first happened.

1:31:53And you, of course, as you know, and like our friends Paul and Mark over at Tapbot.

1:32:00Paul and I have been texting each other quite a bit in the last few days.

1:32:04Well, and that's, but isn't that great though? It's like part of the great part about our community

1:32:08is that I respect his work. He respects mine. Right. And like, you know, I told him about the

1:32:13blog posting. He goes, holy shit, 16 years. Yeah. Right. There's respect there, right? Because

1:32:18it's like, he knows what it's like to keep a product on that wall.

1:32:21Right. It's like Larry Bird and Magic Johnson going arm in arm into the Hall of Fame together,

1:32:27you know, and having Michael Jordan there to toast them and say how great it was to play again.

1:32:32You know, rivals who love each other. So Friday night, though, it really was up in the air,

1:32:37whether is this an accident and the API fell apart and because it's a Friday night and they're on a

1:32:44skeleton crew. And on Friday night, I was leaning towards, I think this is an accident because

1:32:50there's no messaging about it at all. And then by Saturday morning, you had shared on a Slack that

1:32:56we're in, a group Slack, that screenshot that showed that red banner on Twitter-ifics

1:33:02developer credentials from Twitter saying you don't have them. You're suspended.

1:33:09Which that to me was the, oh, this is...

1:33:12Yeah, that was, in fact, we were all holding out hope that it's like, okay,

1:33:18you know, is this, okay, yes, it says we're suspended, but, you know, is this intentional?

1:33:25Is this like, you know, some, but who doesn't necessarily know what they're doing with the API

1:33:30if we have to switch on something? And as we record right now, have they still,

1:33:35they've still said nothing? Is that true? They said nothing. It's totally chicken shit,

1:33:40you know, I'm sorry. It's like, if you're gonna do something, come out and say you're doing it.

1:33:46Right. And it is-

1:33:47It's really that simple.

1:33:48Right. And it's like I wrote on Daring Fireball over the weekend. It is their call to make. We've

1:33:54all been dreading this for years, that they would say, "Hey, we're going to, you know, end of life

1:33:59for third-party clients. Everybody should move to the first-party client. This is what we- and

1:34:03here, you know, and they- if they would like to explain why they could, that would be appreciated.

1:34:08They don't have to, but you know, say something, post something, give some sort of notice, right?

1:34:15And you know, how, you know, the more notice... It's totally disrespectful, right? You know,

1:34:22we've got, we've got customers that we need to let know what's happening. I mean, we need to let

1:34:28Apple know what's happening. Right. And there's people... Hey, how many, how many, you know,

1:34:34award-winning, high-grossing apps with thousands or tens of thousands of subscriptions

1:34:42have been removed from the App Store. We have no idea what the fuck's gonna happen.

1:34:49Pete: I don't know.

1:34:50Chris: How do we pull this product?

1:34:51Pete; I'm looking at the official Twitter account right now, twitter.com/Twitter,

1:34:59and they haven't posted anything since December 10th.

1:35:02Chris; Yeah.

1:35:03So talk about, you know, and Elon Musk-

1:35:06Well, they have no comm steam, right? You know, he's famous for, you know, "Oh, we don't need comms."

1:35:10Right. So even-

1:35:12You're a consumer product now. You're not selling rockets. You're not selling cars.

1:35:16Right.

1:35:16I guess cars are a consumer product.

1:35:17No, but it's crazy. And I was somebody, I mentioned it, and a couple of people who write,

1:35:22you know, some of the people in the tech sphere are more like, some people have one foot in the

1:35:27car world too. You know MKBHD again, a prime example, right? Where he's in addition to being,

1:35:33in my opinion, the world's best tech YouTuber is also a great car YouTuber. But the lack of an

1:35:41actual comms team at Tesla, it drives the people who cover Tesla crazy. I can't imagine. I think

1:35:47Apple actually has fantastic PR. I really do. I've said this over the years. One thing about Apple PR,

1:35:53it's true for the company in public too is they won't always answer your questions of course

1:35:59famously I mean there's the you can anybody can think of dozens of interesting questions you'd

1:36:03like to ask Apple PR that they're not going to answer but they'll just say no comment you know

1:36:09they will answer that they will answer your question if I could ask them anything and I will

1:36:13get an email back or a phone call back they may not answer my question but they will you know

1:36:19paying them to respond. They give you feedback. That's all you need.

1:36:23Right. They might commit at times what we would call lies of omission, where they won't talk about

1:36:29something that you wish they would. I wouldn't, I think lie is probably a strong word. But if they

1:36:33tell me something, it is true. I've never been told anything by Apple PR that is not true.

1:36:40The one time the exception approves the rule, and I wasn't involved in it personally as a reporter,

1:36:46But during Steve Jobs' health saga, when it really took a turn for the worse and he had to have the

1:36:54liver transplant and took the second leave of absence from the company, and their messaging on

1:37:00that was inaccurate. And it was because he didn't want to tell people because he thought it was

1:37:08private and what's the obligation of a publicly held company when the CEO,

1:37:13any CEO, their health status is of interest to shareholders, but obviously Steve Jobs was not

1:37:21just any CEO to Apple. That's a mess and that's a side story, but that is not about Apple. That

1:37:28was about Steve Jobs personally and Katie Cotton who was more or less his personal PR spokesperson

1:37:34and what they, you know, the way they handled that. That was very much about them, not Apple.

1:37:39So Apple is very, very, you know, I, but even if Apple had a bad comms team, and I, you know,

1:37:44I deal with other companies too, who have lesser comms teams, I don't know, it's insane that you

1:37:49can't write to Tesla and get an official response. It's, it really is. I mean, it's, I guess he is

1:37:56proving that you can not have it, but it's never not going to be missed.

1:38:05I would say that it's eventually going to bite you in the ass.

1:38:07Yeah, well, is it going to be the doom of the company? Maybe. But the other thing too,

1:38:12I think the lack of a comms team at Tesla is why Tesla is getting hit so hard. Their stock

1:38:17is way down compared to the... Exactly. Exactly. That's what I mean. It's going to hit you in the

1:38:22It's way down compared to the market. It's way down compared to their competitors in the car

1:38:29space. It's way down compared to their competitors just in the electric vehicle space. And there's no...

1:38:36I have a lot of...

1:38:38There's no...

1:38:39I know a lot of people who have Teslas that are like, "I don't want this car anymore."

1:38:44I know people. We have mutual friends. I know people who've cancelled orders for Teslas in

1:38:50in the last three months. There's no I generally don't give

1:38:54stock advice or analysis. This isn't really advice. But but I

1:38:59also but I really do think that the the market quote unquote is

1:39:03largely inscrutable and things move up and down for reasons that

1:39:07you're never going to really know why exactly except

1:39:10sometimes it's pretty obvious. I think it is extremely obvious

1:39:13that Tesla stock over the last three months during the Twitter

1:39:17as owned by SpaceKaren era, is way down because he's revealed himself to be a jackass in a way

1:39:27that I, this is, you know, I really just had no idea and and the signs were all there. I should

1:39:32have known so the people, you know, my famous optimistic... It didn't affect you though. It

1:39:37didn't really affect you. Yeah and I didn't think... For me it was like, yeah, this guy is,

1:39:42I don't really get him. What's his deal? But you know, it's like, I don't own a Tesla. I'm not

1:39:47going to be launching a rocket anytime soon. I'm just going to kind of let it fall by the wayside

1:39:52and well guess what now it affects me. It's obvious that a significant amount of Tesla's

1:39:58market value was faith in Elon Musk personally. That you know that he you know and and I think

1:40:04there is something to that that the I know we didn't technically found Tesla but the you know

1:40:08he's been there a long time that that type of visionary charismatic CEO the Henry Ford type

1:40:16the Walt Disney type, the Steve Jobs, you know, you know, when Steve Jobs came back, that gave us all

1:40:22hope. The Bill Gates, the, you know, Zuckerberg, that these, that a certain type of CEO is so

1:40:31visionary and effective that they're worth betting on, right? That you don't need, you know, I'm just

1:40:36going to place a bet on this company because I believe this person and I think that, you know,

1:40:40it's like if, you know, you don't know anything about basketball, but you know Michael Jordan,

1:40:45so you're going to bet on the team that has Michael Jordan or LeBron, right? Like all of a sudden,

1:40:49LeBron goes to the Lakers and you're like, "Ah, that's enough for me. I'm going to place a bet

1:40:54on the Lakers to win." I bought some stock after Apple released the iPhone because it was like,

1:40:59"I believe in this." And that's turned out to be a pretty good thing. I think that he's revealed

1:41:06himself to be so independently and flaky and making such terrible decisions that people who

1:41:14had faith and had no interest, don't really care, you know, they can't, you can't invest in Twitter

1:41:18right now because it's no longer publicly held, it's privately held. That's the whole thing that

1:41:23he did. But like for Tesla, people whose money was in Tesla because they had faith in Elon Musk

1:41:29are looking at what he's revealed himself to be and how, what his leadership style is like.

1:41:34And they're like, oh, I guess maybe he is just making up the, you know, how far advanced their

1:41:41full self-driving is and how far, you know, what type of a mote they have around their business.

1:41:46And you're absolutely right when you say that they have to be better than the humans.

1:41:52Oh, that's a side.

1:41:53You can't just equal it. Yeah, that's a separate thing, but I totally agree there, right? It's like,

1:41:58you know, if you're going to claim that something works, it's got to work really well.

1:42:02But if they had a professional comms team, they could be managing that and getting word out and

1:42:08and trying to separate, try to get the press to buy,

1:42:13whether it's true or not, but to put the spin on it

1:42:16that the Musk who runs Twitter is not,

1:42:18that's not how he runs Tesla, you know?

1:42:20- Right, there's really somebody else

1:42:22that's pulling the strings. - But without a comms team,

1:42:25and with his own singular genius being the comms for Tesla,

1:42:30well, guess what?

1:42:31He is a jackass, and so he's bungling that too.

1:42:34It's just infuriating that this is how they've done it,

1:42:37that here we are three days later

1:42:39and they've literally just ghosted us.

1:42:41It's like somebody breaking up with a significant other,

1:42:44not by saying I break up with you,

1:42:46but just by never returning their calls, right?

1:42:49And it's like all of a sudden your text just, you know,

1:42:52and you're not getting read receipts anymore.

1:42:54They're just like, are they seeing my texts?

1:42:56What's going on?

1:42:57And it's like, it's just so profoundly disrespectful.

1:43:01- We, it really is the disrespect.

1:43:05We all know what's happening.

1:43:06The fact that Tapbot's turned on some other API keys yesterday, and people were kind of able to

1:43:14use Tweetbot for a little bit, and then it was broken posting, and you couldn't see old tweets

1:43:20and stuff like that. And it was just kind of limping along, and then they killed that.

1:43:25Well, did they kill that? I didn't notice that.

1:43:27Yeah, they killed it a couple hours later. And Paul did that just, you know, it's like

1:43:32that's the only way we can prove that they're really shutting us down is to actively,

1:43:39you know, shut us down. And again, it comes back to we've got other stuff we need to deal with

1:43:45as a result of it. It's not just them that has, you know, that shuts the API off. We've got to

1:43:51shut off products. We've got to let customers know, you know, it's got subscription renewals

1:43:58coming up. They don't want to deal with, you know, thousands and thousands of refunds.

1:44:03The fact is going to cost them money. The fact that Paul had built into Tweetbot the ability for

1:44:10them to remote change their OAuth credentials with Twitter without submitting an app update

1:44:17just shows that shows you how worried developers like you guys have been.

1:44:24our app has a little built in web view that looks at a file on our server that, you know,

1:44:31popped up a little web view that says, you know, something bad has happened to Twitter.

1:44:36And it explains the state of things. And we did that release, so a couple months ago, I'd say,

1:44:43I don't remember exactly, but that was really, that and what was in it? It was like that and

1:44:48a copyright date. That's it. And we knew because you know, it, you, you, after dealing with this

1:44:57unstable API situation for, you know, years and years, you're a little gun shy and it's like, okay,

1:45:07this may not happen. We may never need to use this, but if it does, we want to be prepared. And,

1:45:13and the Tapbots, switching the API keys

1:45:17may have been a test thing for them, maybe not.

1:45:21I don't, we never talk about that,

1:45:23but yeah, we're all gun-shy about the Twitter

1:45:28after Elon took over.

1:45:30- So what are you gonna do?

1:45:33So Tapbots famously, I mean, everybody I'm sure

1:45:36who cares about it knows that they've been hard at work

1:45:39on a Mastodon client called Ivory,

1:45:42which is in test flight beta right now.

1:45:45Super, super, they keep opening--

1:45:48- It's super quality app too.

1:45:50- Yeah.

1:45:51- It's what you would expect from them, right?

1:45:52- Right.

1:45:53- You know, they did something really smart,

1:45:57I think probably because of back in the days of app.net.

1:46:01- Yeah, that's what I--

1:46:02- Probably because they kind of,

1:46:04I think what they did is they kind of abstracted

1:46:07their backend, you know, fetching the data from the UI,

1:46:10presenting it kind of situation.

1:46:13I think probably version two of the Twitter API

1:46:16helped bring that along.

1:46:18And you know, they're building,

1:46:20I haven't talked to Paul about this,

1:46:23but just looking at it from somebody who knows

1:46:25how apps are built and how social media apps work,

1:46:30it feels very much like me that they're taking Tweetbot

1:46:33and massaging the bits that need massaging

1:46:37to work with that new Mastodon API.

1:46:40which is great because it gives people a UI

1:46:43and an environment that they're used to.

1:46:48Really, you know, that's it.

1:46:50- So let me put on my journalist hat here

1:46:53and ask the hard question.

1:46:54Is there going to be a Mastodonrific?

1:46:58- Mastodonrific.

1:46:59- Mastorific, I don't know, that doesn't sound good.

1:47:01- Well, we looked at it back in 2018,

1:47:09and we actually called it Fantasadon.

1:47:11And--

1:47:13- I've put you on the spot here.

1:47:14- Well, no, it's something that we're interested in,

1:47:17for sure.

1:47:18And we have some prior commitments now

1:47:22that we're working on that kind of prevents our small team

1:47:25from looking at it full time.

1:47:27- Right, Icon Factory is a small team.

1:47:29How many developers are there?

1:47:31- There's me, Sean, and Shannon Hughes,

1:47:34who works on Linnea.

1:47:35- Right, so it's, and that's, it's, you know,

1:47:38Tapbots is two people, Mark Jardine and Paul Haddad.

1:47:42- And I think Todd Thomas is working with them.

1:47:43- Oh yeah, yeah, that's right.

1:47:45- In a little bit on the Mac side.

1:47:47- Yeah, he's doing the Mac version, right, that's right.

1:47:49- Again, we don't talk about teams, you know,

1:47:51it's just, we're both small, we both know it.

1:47:54- Right, right, right, but like small, small,

1:47:57not just, you know, like small,

1:47:58you could put the company into a van, you know, small.

1:48:02- The one difference is that the Icon Factory

1:48:06is more diversified than--

1:48:08- I was just gonna say, right?

1:48:10- So Tapbot has a few other apps.

1:48:12They've got the Calcbot, which is a fine calculator,

1:48:15and I actually use it.

1:48:18They did, Waitbot, what did Craig Federighi say

1:48:22that the Mac Mini is a product in our lineup or whatever?

1:48:26Waitbot is an app that they had.

1:48:28It was like a weight tracking app,

1:48:29but I don't think it's an active development anymore.

1:48:32No, the other one is that's active

1:48:33and I personally use it and love it as PasteBot,

1:48:36which is- - Oh, right, yeah, yeah, yeah.

1:48:38- And I know that there's- - Right.

1:48:40- It's- - Todd had some problems

1:48:42with PasteBot for a while.

1:48:43I've had some stuff and I talked to Paul about that, yeah.

1:48:46- Yeah, it's funny because it's like

1:48:49there's dozens of good, seriously,

1:48:51there's like over a dozen good Twitter clients for iOS.

1:48:54So it is a crowded space

1:48:56and there's probably even more clipboard managers

1:49:01for the Mac, 'cause there's also a bunch of apps

1:49:04that primarily do other things that have clipboard managers.

1:49:08Keyboard Maestro is mostly a macro utility

1:49:11for automating your Mac in ways,

1:49:13but it also has a very good clipboard manager.

1:49:16And Launch Bar and Alfred,

1:49:19which are really command space launchers primarily,

1:49:22also have clipboard managers, but I like Payspot.

1:49:25But they're, I don't think there's,

1:49:29I know nothing about their internal revenue pie chart, but you don't have to be a genius to think

1:49:35that Tweetbot for iOS is the Pac-Man of their pie chart in a way that Twitterific, I guess,

1:49:42I don't think is for icon factory?

1:49:45Tim Cynova No, no, we've been, you know, again, when we,

1:49:48you know, saw what was happening, it's like, okay, we need to come up with other products,

1:49:52you know, we have Linnea for drawing on your iPad, which is, get to, people love it.

1:49:58is another one that people love. It's just, you know, a really simple way to keep notes on

1:50:04your iPhone and iPad and watch.

1:50:07Right. Tod is for sale, right? I know.

1:50:10Yeah, it's free on the Mac and it's paid on iOS and paid on the watch too.

1:50:18So, but yeah, and you know, we've got Wallaroo now. It's just a new product that does the

1:50:24the wallpapers and we've been actively trying to diversify so you know but I'm

1:50:30not gonna lie it's it's gonna hurt to lose some Twitter if ik revenue I mean

1:50:35we had our own ad server and you did not mention forensic the oh yeah yeah wood

1:50:40forensics on the Apple arcade right so forensic and again to just go down

1:50:45memory lane was a one of the first games on the iPhone one of the first games on

1:50:50the iPhone and was super one of the things that was so super key again I

1:50:54don't want to, this could be a whole show about forensic, but it was so super cool. One of the

1:50:58things that was so cool about forensic was that unlike so many of the other first round of games,

1:51:04it was, it only makes sense on a touch screen device on your hand.

1:51:08It was like forensic and Trism were like, they were meant for this device.

1:51:13Right. And they're very, very tactile.

1:51:16Right. And it's a very fun story that one of these original iPhone games that had a nice run and was

1:51:21a big hit at the time, it then fell by the wayside. It came back and now it's on Apple Arcade. So,

1:51:27anybody out there who's got an Apple One subscription or just an Arcade subscription,

1:51:32you go check out Forensic on your phone. It's back. It's better than ever without question.

1:51:37But yeah. But...

1:51:37**Matt Stauffer** We love working on that product. And

1:51:39the thing is we love everything we do, right? And that's kind of the... That's the problem.

1:51:49Twitterific right now. We're losing something we love.

1:51:52Right, so what I'm hearing in so many words is that the fantastadon idea,

1:51:57don't never say never, maybe, but not at the moment that you guys have your plates are full.

1:52:02Well, the thing that right now is that I think it's a time to kind of take a step back, right?

1:52:10I think, you know, having these clients on Mastodon is a good thing, right? I'm not against,

1:52:16Mastodon client, but it's the, you know, how can this new web standard called ActivityPub,

1:52:25which is basically the underlying infrastructure for the Fediverse, you know, Mastodon instances

1:52:32talking to each other, you know, Tumblr's talking about adding it, Microblog does it.

1:52:37that there's a place for photos called PixelFed

1:52:42that uses it.

1:52:43I'm kind of thinking that maybe the direction

1:52:49that we need to head is how do you pull

1:52:52all these different various sources of information together

1:52:56and kind of make them work together as a whole

1:53:02and be interactive?

1:53:04But basically, you know, it's like imagine your RSS reader being interactive, right?

1:53:10You know, you read something in, you know, NetNews Wire and, you know, you can post immediately

1:53:15and you start a conversation.

1:53:18And this is, I mean, I hate talking about this actually because it's kind of not well

1:53:24formed in my mind yet.

1:53:26You know, it's not even at that point where I start to experiment.

1:53:31got a delicate little idea in your head.

1:53:34And you don't want to, if you expose it to…

1:53:37You don't want to fuck it up by letting people know.

1:53:41I hear you.

1:53:42I hear you.

1:53:43But that to me is, it's exciting.

1:53:48Like Twitter was, you know, the first time I posted, you know, that little XML snippet

1:53:53to their API and saw something show up in my web browser, it was like, oh, this is cool.

1:54:00Right?

1:54:01And, you know, I'm gonna, I think I'm gonna start poking around at this stuff and, and

1:54:08get it to the point where I can have an intelligent conversation with the designer.

1:54:13That's also a really important part of what we do is, is we prototype to the point where

1:54:22you can start to understand it as a normal person, right?

1:54:25You know, if I start talking about activity pub and, you know, having these, you know,

1:54:28sources and publishers and consumers and you know the designer rightfully so their eyes are just

1:54:35going to glaze over and go what are you talking about right it's like if you're it's like if

1:54:39you're just talking about an r or a feed reader trying to talk about the the xml differences

1:54:44between rss and the atom feed format right or or how does that differ from you know the the jason

1:54:52feed right and it's like worked on it's right right and all of a sudden the designer is just

1:54:57just like, "What are you talking about?"

1:54:58You're like, "Oh, it's gonna be a list of articles.

1:55:00Oh, okay, I know how to style that."

1:55:01- It's gonna look like a news reader.

1:55:03- Right.

1:55:04What are you going to, what happened?

1:55:05I don't think this is going to happen.

1:55:06I think the best, honestly, I think at this point,

1:55:09the best we're gonna get is at least some sort of,

1:55:12yes, we killed the third-party clients,

1:55:14everybody should use the first party.

1:55:16Just give us a goddamn statement.

1:55:17And maybe by the time this episode airs,

1:55:20that will have happened in between this moment

1:55:23when you and I are talking.

1:55:24- I'm guessing that's actually pretty likely.

1:55:25But you know, you hear rumors and you know.

1:55:30- What are you gonna do though if,

1:55:32what if they just completely change their mind

1:55:34and say nevermind and all of a sudden.

1:55:36- Oh, that's a long discussion.

1:55:39A long internal discussion.

1:55:40It's like, you know.

1:55:41- What happens if Twitter--

1:55:43- Once burned, twice shy, you know.

1:55:44Honestly, I don't know the answer to that question.

1:55:50You know, again, we're gonna miss the source of revenue,

1:55:53but is it really worth the grief and the,

1:55:58it's an abusive relationship at this point, right?

1:56:01Do I go back with the girlfriend who beat me every night?

1:56:06- I'm in a group discussion, not even a group chat.

1:56:11These aren't necessarily friends,

1:56:13but it's a small private thing.

1:56:15And one of the topics was about,

1:56:17like a recurring thread is Twitter and Musk

1:56:22and what's going on.

1:56:24And somebody posted last week, it was before this,

1:56:27so it was in the context of something else about this.

1:56:30One of the stories is that, widely reported,

1:56:33this isn't like a rumor,

1:56:35but that Twitter has stopped paying their rent

1:56:37in all over the world, like San Francisco

1:56:40and other places. - Yeah.

1:56:42- And somebody posted,

1:56:44not somebody who's like an Elon Musk fan,

1:56:47but just was like, ah, that's just good negotiating.

1:56:49That's, you know, negotiating with landlords

1:56:51just good business and it's, you know, real estate's a tough business. And I wrote back and I was like,

1:56:55yeah, it is. But when you negotiate with your landlord before you sign a lease, that's what

1:57:01the lease is. The lease is the agreement you come to. And so, you know, whether you're renting a

1:57:06home or apartment or a 12-story office building, you, you, you know, you negotiate.

1:57:14The lease is a legal document. You break that lease. You're breaking

1:57:17breaking a legal document and you're gonna have contract problems.

1:57:20Right, so yeah, and yes, a good business person does negotiate hard on stuff like that and does

1:57:27get good terms. There's a story out this week that Goldman Sachs lost $1.2 billion last year

1:57:33on their credit card business and their credit card business is effectively Apple Card. So,

1:57:37somehow, I mean, now whether that's a long term, they're never gonna make money, well, then Apple,

1:57:42you know, Goldman is not gonna stay in the business if, but maybe, maybe that was the plan

1:57:47all along. No one seems to know whether they expected to lose money last year,

1:57:51but it just shows how well Apple, you know, Apple's not the one taking the 1.2 billion dollar loss.

1:57:56It's Goldman. That is that, you know, and Apple is...

1:57:59Apple is a tough negotiator. They are very good at it.

1:58:03Tim Cook is a famously good negotiator. Eddy Cue is the one... what I've heard this story multiple

1:58:09times is that it was like Eddy Cue's the one person at Apple that Steve Jobs thought was a

1:58:14a better negotiator than himself or at least always took, Eddie Q was the guy who Jobs always

1:58:20took with him. His side man, yeah, his backup. But you know what they are? They're honest

1:58:26negotiators, you know, if they say we're going to pay 30% and we'll pay 70%, we'll give you 70%

1:58:34and we'll keep 30% and, you know, that NFL deal that they backed out of, right? Right.

1:58:39It's just like, it doesn't make sense for us.

1:58:42It's been nice chatting.

1:58:44- Right, but they're not going to make an agreement

1:58:46on terms X, Y, and Z,

1:58:48and then once the agreement is made, say,

1:58:50"Oh, remember A, B, and C that you said we couldn't do,

1:58:52or we're gonna do them anyway."

1:58:53- Just kidding.

1:58:54- Right.

1:58:56And to me, this rent thing,

1:58:57it's exactly the same mindset with this developer thing,

1:59:00where, yes, they had the right to pull the APIs.

1:59:04That's their company.

1:59:05But this is not the way to do it.

1:59:08This breaks trust.

1:59:09There's, you know, so if they did turn those certs back on,

1:59:13I don't see any, I mean, I would guess you would allow

1:59:16Twitterrific to keep going, but would you keep investing

1:59:19development resources in Twitterrific knowing that they

1:59:22might just do it again at any time?

1:59:24- Yeah.

1:59:25Trust and respect are like the easiest,

1:59:31are the hardest things to earn

1:59:33and the easiest things to lose.

1:59:34- Why would you, let's say you and I co-owned

1:59:37an office building in San Francisco.

1:59:39And now, I think as we all know,

1:59:43Twitter needs less space than they did before.

1:59:45- Yeah, they're gonna convert it into a hotel.

1:59:48- If Twitter came to us in our building and said,

1:59:51"We would like to lease your smaller building

1:59:53for the next five years,"

1:59:54I would tell them to go pound sand.

1:59:56I don't care, and if we had a price on it,

1:59:59I would turn them down even if they were willing

2:00:01to just pay the asking price per square foot

2:00:03because they've proven themselves to be a company

2:00:06that if they want to, will stop paying the rent.

2:00:08You know what I mean?

2:00:09- Yeah.

2:00:10- When you're, you know, you're a person--

2:00:11- What does the stock market work on?

2:00:14There's a lot of trust in that whole market.

2:00:18You know, you trust the company's, you know,

2:00:21gonna do right by you as a shareholder.

2:00:23- Unless I--

2:00:24- And all of a sudden they don't?

2:00:26- Unless I literally thought I can't find anybody else

2:00:29to take this space, I would never lease the space to Twitter.

2:00:33So I, you know--

2:00:34- And it's that way around the world.

2:00:36- Why would anybody trust Twitter as a platform vendor again?

2:00:41And again, we all have these frustrations with Apple

2:00:45and their position over the App Store.

2:00:48- But they're consistent about it, right?

2:00:50Apple set some rules long ago that they're...

2:00:55And they, from those internal emails,

2:00:58they struggled with what those rules were.

2:01:01- They do what they say.

2:01:03Exactly. They do what they say. We may not like a lot of the stuff they say, but I think it's

2:01:09absolutely wrong that you can't mention your website in an app. That's just, that's just,

2:01:14I don't get it. Or that you can't, and my pet bugaboo that you're not even allowed to explain

2:01:20the rules of the app store, which is nuts. All right, let me take a break here and thank our

2:01:24third and final sponsor of the show. It's our good friends at Squarespace. You guys know Squarespace.

2:01:29It is the all-in-one platform for building your brand and growing your business online.

2:01:34You can stand out with your own beautiful website, engage with your audience, and sell anything.

2:01:40You can sell products, you can sell your content, and even your time

2:01:45booked through a Squarespace website. They make it easy for creators to monetize their

2:01:49content and expertise in a way that fits their brand. They have member areas where you can

2:01:55unlock a new revenue stream for your business and free up your time in your schedule by selling

2:02:00access to gated content to your audience like videos, online courses, newsletters, email

2:02:06newsletters, that sort of thing. Everything you want. Domain name registration, templates to

2:02:10choose from, design tools to tweak those templates to look just the way you want to fit your brand

2:02:16with no HTML, CSS, JavaScript technical expertise involved at all. WYSIWYG. But if you want to

2:02:24get in there at the code level. You can do that too. You can go from the nerdy end, you can go

2:02:29from the visual design end. It's all there built into Squarespace. And even if it's not you,

2:02:35the listener of the talk show who needs a new website, you as like the family nerd or

2:02:43nerd in the group, when people come to you like, "Hey, I need a new website. What should I do?"

2:02:47Send them to Squarespace, give them the code, even if they don't listen to the talk show,

2:02:50you know, you know, let them think they came from here that that URL squarespace.com/talkshow

2:02:57squarespace.com/talk show, go there, send people there, send your friends and family there, they

2:03:03get a free trial 30 days, no limits, no watermarks on the website. And when they're ready to launch,

2:03:08just remember that code talk show no the just talk show, you save 10% off your first purchase,

2:03:14which can be for up to a year pay for a year at once save 10%. My thanks to Squarespace.

2:03:20An underlying theme of this show is nostalgia and oh my god, getting started on the web

2:03:28these days is so much easier, you know, collecting money. I mean, the early days,

2:03:33I mean, we were, you know, FTPing files, you know, hooking up payment gateways with CGI.

2:03:39It was a total...

2:03:39It was a mess. It was a hard thing to do and it was a mess.

2:03:46I remember I bought my first copy of BB Edit. I think I called and gave my credit card over the phone

2:03:53I know I have the receipt. I have my BB Edit 2.5 user manual on my did you download it off a usenet?

2:04:00Almost certainly. Yeah or from the info Mac archive, right?

2:04:04Yeah

2:04:04which I sometimes peruse by email and sometimes peruse by info Mac was a it was both an email newsletter and a posting to

2:04:14CompSis MAC, right? A CompSis MAC something on Usenet. And it would just be like a daily list of

2:04:20what new apps were out and updates, you know. That was one of my first releases.

2:04:27It was sort of like a blog before blogs because it would just be like, you know, like here's 10

2:04:33utilities that have a new version today. But I remember also sending checks to people, you know,

2:04:39for shareware because I liked paying for it. Even on the low budget of a college student or a

2:04:46recent college grad, I wanted independent developers to thrive. I remember mailing

2:04:51checks to people. But yeah, I used to have a stack of postcards that I would mail,

2:04:55you know, the Laguna Beach postcards that I would mail back to people with their serial number on it.

2:05:00And it was kind of a nice thing, right? It's like I was sharing a little bit of where I live.

2:05:06and my home to your home.

2:05:11- You have been very kind with your time today,

2:05:13but I have one more topic I wanna talk to you

2:05:15and I know you care about it and I know you're busy,

2:05:17but we'll try to keep it brief.

2:05:18But there was a story last week

2:05:20from our Scoopster extraordinaire, Mark Gurman,

2:05:23that Apple is working, has engineers working

2:05:27on touchscreen MacBooks.

2:05:28Now, he did not say Apple is coming out

2:05:31with touchscreen MacBooks.

2:05:32He said Apple has engineers working on touchscreen MacBooks.

2:05:36It's a real project.

2:05:38And if it comes to fruition,

2:05:40they wouldn't arrive until 2025,

2:05:43which is, you know, and I famously love to remind people

2:05:48that Apple's hardware pipelines, even for Macs,

2:05:50which aren't quite as rigid as iPhone

2:05:53because of the insane numbers of iPhones they make,

2:05:55but they are set in advance.

2:05:57And so- - Oh, way in advance, yeah.

2:05:59- You know, it's not, it is not outlandish, you know,

2:06:03that the earliest we might see,

2:06:06if everything Germin says about these touchscreen MacBooks comes true, that we won't see them for

2:06:11another two years, probably more than two years, because what are the odds that if it does happen

2:06:16in 2025, it's going to happen in the first two weeks of January, slim to none.

2:06:20Tim Cynova Right, no. And it's probably going to

2:06:24affect a manufacturing line a lot, right? You know, the way that LCD screens have been produced for

2:06:32for the last, say, 15 years,

2:06:35it's gonna fundamentally change, right?

2:06:37It's gonna have some new sensor in it,

2:06:40new bezel, new, new, new.

2:06:42- Right, so he says 2025 at the earliest,

2:06:44and the other practical concern, which says to me,

2:06:48second half of 2025 at the earliest

2:06:52would be that there's gotta be some sort

2:06:54of WWDC message about it,

2:06:57for developers to have some kind of APIs

2:07:00to access the touch in a Mac app

2:07:02where there obviously is none.

2:07:04- Yeah, and probably some sort of a simulator

2:07:07that runs on the Mac.

2:07:09And maybe that simulator uses

2:07:11the new virtualization framework.

2:07:15Yeah, there would be a lot of pieces

2:07:17that had to fall into place for this to be.

2:07:20- Yeah, I actually, I guess what you,

2:07:22maybe what you would do is instead of a simulator

2:07:25is use the, what's that sidecar with your iPad and move?

2:07:29Yeah, yeah, that would be another approach to it to actually get physical. But, you know,

2:07:33everybody's using an iOS simulator, which, you know, simulates touch.

2:07:36But you could do something.

2:07:38To do something similar to that. The only thing to take away from that is that there

2:07:44would be a lot of work from both Apple's developers' tools team and developers themselves,

2:07:50third-party developers. It's not just like, oh, let's just put this thing on the Mac and away we

2:07:56go. You know this.

2:07:59Anybody, do you use screens at all? The VPN app for IO?

2:08:03From Evovia.

2:08:05Yeah, yeah. Luke VanDell has been making this product forever. And I've got a little Mac Mini

2:08:12server that I run that does our backups from the web server and all sorts of stuff. And yeah,

2:08:18I control, I need to control that from my iPad every once in a while.

2:08:21E-dovia.

2:08:22Right? So I spring up.

2:08:23I'm sorry.

2:08:23E-dovia. Yeah, edovia.com.

2:08:26Yeah.

2:08:27and fantastic little tool and it shows you within a couple of minutes the problems with

2:08:34a touch UI on the Mac. I'm not going to enumerate them all but it's pretty obvious once you actually

2:08:43start doing it. But basically anybody who's out there listening and you're super enthusiastic

2:08:49about this and every time I start complaining about the things I'm dreading about it if it

2:08:54if it ever comes to fruition.

2:08:55And you roll your eyes and say,

2:08:56"No, no, no, you just touch, it's not that big a deal.

2:08:58"You don't have to resize and space everything.

2:09:01"Just keep the Mac interface the same

2:09:03"and just let me touch the things to scroll them."

2:09:07Go fire up screens and log into your Mac on an iPad

2:09:12and start poking around with your finger

2:09:16at a Mac on an iPad and you'll see,

2:09:19oh yeah, those red, yellow, green buttons

2:09:22in the top left of the window,

2:09:23They really are very small and very close to each other.

2:09:26- Navigating menus is kind of a pain in the ass.

2:09:28- Right, and I know that people,

2:09:33when is Apple finally gonna put touch screens

2:09:35on a MacBook has been, it's over 10 years, right?

2:09:38Ever since touch blew into the world.

2:09:40- It was around before the iPad, right?

2:09:42You know, we had the iPhone, oh, great touch screen.

2:09:46Oh, we should put this on our Macs.

2:09:48Nobody was thinking of the iPad.

2:09:50They were thinking about, put touch on a Mac, no problem.

2:09:53Ever since the iPhone shipped, there's never been a day where people aren't hunting for signs that maybe Apple is going to add touchscreen support to the Mac.

2:10:03And so like with last year's update to macOS, or maybe it was the year before, but when they sort of made it look even more like iOS, the iOS visual UI style,

2:10:17style and things like the wi-fi menu now had like a touch style toggle you know a little blue white

2:10:26switch for turning wi-fi on and off very famously and controversially this year with mac os 13

2:10:33ventura with the complete redesign going from the old system preferences to the new settings app

2:10:40This visual style of the settings app is obviously iOS inspired and so lots and lots of people looked at that said see

2:10:48They are definitely going to move to touch

2:10:50But the settings app is actually a really interesting

2:10:53Example i've been as we record I am as yet unpublished. I have a big long

2:11:00Well, not too long but a daring fireball piece about this. We're what i'm talking about. Why why this

2:11:05Just adding touch is not that easy easier said than done to the mac

2:11:10And the Settings app is a perfect example because it just look at the sidebar, just the list. And

2:11:16again, not complaining about the Settings app, just take it for what it is, but compare it side

2:11:20by side with an iPad, right? A Mac and an iPad right next to each other, open Settings, and look

2:11:27at the list of panels on the left. On the iPad, they're way further apart. The row height is higher

2:11:34significantly because they're optimized for touch. And on the Mac, they're not because they're

2:11:39They're optimized for a pointing device.

2:11:41And it's a more information dense interface.

2:11:46It always has been.

2:11:47- And they could lower that density

2:11:49and do something like they've done on the iPad OS

2:11:53with the touch pad, the focus kind of driven UI

2:11:57where you move the little dot around on the screen

2:12:01and it does different things

2:12:02depending on what it's hovering on.

2:12:04They could do something like that,

2:12:05but then think, okay, that's gonna make Mac OS

2:12:09kind of modal at a system level.

2:12:12It's like, oh, am I using touch mode

2:12:15or am I using mouse mode?

2:12:16- Yeah, I can't see them making--

2:12:18- That's a weird thing, right?

2:12:19- Well, and when you're on a MacBook,

2:12:22you're always in both modes, right?

2:12:24'Cause a MacBook, unlike an iPad,

2:12:26an iPad at least does have the two states

2:12:28of being connected to the Magic Keyboard

2:12:30or you pull it apart from the MacBook.

2:12:32- Yeah, it knows, it knows, yeah.

2:12:34know, Gurman's report, and I think this makes all the sense in the world, is that Apple,

2:12:38they're just talking about laptops, you know, with a permanent hinge, not a detachable,

2:12:43where you can snap it apart from the keyboard. And I, you know, that would be, I just don't,

2:12:49that's a whole… Well, it would, yeah. And then you think, okay, well, they've got these new,

2:12:53beautiful, you know, studio displays. What's going to happen there? Yeah, it's…

2:13:00And among the classic thing is I tell people who say, "Oh, you know, touch on my iMac display or my

2:13:07studio display will be awesome." I say, "Hold your finger out in front of you, you know, at a, you

2:13:13know, 90-degree angle to your body and hold it there for five minutes. And you'll know within a

2:13:21couple of minutes why that's a bad idea. Your arm starts to hurt." So if you're doing that all day

2:13:27long, you're poking at the screen all day long, and it's not very ergonomic.

2:13:31Right, but the devil's advocate argument, and I'm amenable to it, and I don't

2:13:35think Gurman's news, let's just say it's true and they are, I mean I'm not

2:13:40surprised that they're working on it just as an idea, and let's just say they

2:13:44do ship it. I think it may not be disastrous or and maybe doesn't, won't

2:13:49actually require a significant rethinking of the Mac UI if the

2:13:54intention is we don't expect anybody to do more than like just poke an OK button once in a while

2:14:01or just if you just scroll. I mean this all makes me sick because I you know you know me I don't

2:14:08want you know as far as I know I have a studio display I mean this is because I don't have little

2:14:12kids anymore. Well actually my son never touched my screen so you trained him well but I have a

2:14:17I have a one-year-old 14-inch MacBook Pro and a like eight-month-old studio display with the

2:14:26nano texture and as far as I know neither display has ever been touched by a human finger.

2:14:33- Yeah.

2:14:33- Yeah.

2:14:34- So because nobody else, nobody, I don't have colleagues, I guess colleagues are the big problem

2:14:40coming up to your laptop and just touching the screen to say, "Here, make this bigger."

2:14:44- Yeah.

2:14:45I know people who will break your finger if you try that.

2:14:49I'm not, it's not a germ thing.

2:14:51It's a, you can't, you know, like...

2:14:53I get upset when the little oils on the keyboard sometimes transfer to the screen.

2:14:58That's like, oh my God, I got to clean my keyboard, clean my screen.

2:15:01Clean my screen, clean my keyboard.

2:15:02I'm very, I'm not a very fussy person, but I keep my screens very clean.

2:15:06Well, these are the ones that have great vision, right?

2:15:08It really, I think there's an advantage to having a clean screen, right?

2:15:13It's like a figure to see.

2:15:14Right.

2:15:15The devil's argument take though about that gorilla arm argument and that is what apple

2:15:19I think it goes all the way back to steve jobs because people like I said people have been

2:15:23as soon as they got to know and love the iphone they're like when is this going to come to the mac

2:15:28and the steve jobs argument which is more or less apple's line like you know they obviously don't

2:15:34talk about things they aren't doing often but like on stage with me at the talk show or anywhere else

2:15:40in public where they might get asked is this is ergonomically not great. And you know, and John

2:15:46Turnus, I think during a keynote or somewhere in some interview, has talked about the information

2:15:52density of the Mac and that they're very happy with the, you know, and they keep reiterating it

2:15:58because the other thing people say is, you know, what about just merge, you know, this is the other,

2:16:02it goes hand in hand with the idea of touchscreen Macs is quote unquote merging the iPad and Mac OS's.

2:16:07why have two operating systems for these same size devices just merge them into one? And it's

2:16:13honest, you know, as a lay person that sounds like common sense, it's like why have why did GM have

2:16:19both the Buick and Oldsmobile brands, right? That makes no sense. They should just get rid of one

2:16:24and just have one. Why, you know, but when you get to the nitty gritty details, it makes no sense

2:16:29whatsoever. Because if you got rid of iPadOS and just ran macOS on the iPads, everybody who loves

2:16:35the simplicity of iPadOS is going to be disappointed. And if you did it the other way

2:16:39and got rid of macOS and made all these machines run iPadOS, iPadOS is lacking so much complexity

2:16:48that the Mac has to be able to do that they would just have to re-implement the Mac and iPadOS anyway

2:16:53and it would clearly be more work than just keeping them both separate, right? So that's not going to

2:16:57happen. But I do think that there's an argument to be made that the real world evidence, because the

2:17:02PC world has had touchscreen laptops for over 10 years is that it's just nice to have this is the

2:17:08Ben Thompson take Ben Thompson yeah like yeah I wish you could just have it yeah he's he he's the

2:17:13one that I always hear from when I say no no no and the idea it's kind of nice and I think in

2:17:19if you don't mind it's like scrolling a web page sure I can see touch working with that you know

2:17:24right pinching on a photo in photos the photos app on the mac sure I could see that right can

2:17:30I see using BB Edit with my finger? Or Xcode, right? Like look at Xcode. Oh God, Xcode.

2:17:36So just go. Oh, I meant, instead of stepping over, I stopped the debugger.

2:17:42So three things I can think of off the top of my head. Look, or four. BB Edit would be one,

2:17:47Xcode would be another, Final Cut, go just take a look at a screenshot of Final Cut or Logic

2:17:55or anything like that in a pro media tool sense and think about touching those things.

2:18:00or in Safari open up the developer panel, you know, right with the web inspector. Yeah,

2:18:05the web inspector. Yeah. And start thinking, just pretend like you could try to touch those things.

2:18:10Or my, one of my, perhaps my canonical example, look at those red, yellow, green buttons up in

2:18:15the top corner and think about it. Think about trying to hit that yellow one to minimize a window

2:18:20without hitting the red one, which will, does something very different.

2:18:26There was a reason why the touch points on the original iPhone were 44 pixels tall, right?

2:18:35And that was one of the things, you know, it was a very inventive time, you know,

2:18:41you kind of exploring what touch meant. One of the first things I did was I put my finger,

2:18:46which I have a fairly large hand as you know, and I held it up against the ruler. And guess what?

2:18:53That 44 pixels was just about the, the, the, you know, a medium pressure of my.

2:18:58Index against the, the ruler.

2:19:01And it was like, okay, but some, somebody had thought about this.

2:19:05I know the people that, that worked on that original iPhone and you know, there's,

2:19:10they were smart group of people and they obviously made it 44, you know, cause

2:19:15it's a weird number, right?

2:19:16Why 44?

2:19:17Wow.

2:19:18Right.

2:19:18And nothing on the Mac is 44.

2:19:21No.

2:19:22the controls, they're like 20 or 22 or something like that. So they're like half the size.

2:19:29Right. And the other interesting thing is, you know, and one of the things people took,

2:19:33I think mistakenly, is a sign that touchscreen support was coming to the Macs is Catalyst,

2:19:37and that you can run iPad apps on macOS now, and obviously look like they're more meant for

2:19:44touch because on the iPad they are. But one of the things about Catalyst is that by default,

2:19:49everything has shrunk. I think the scale is 77%, which is a very strange number, but just call it

2:19:5575%. And if you've never noticed it, just take an app like a third party app, like Overcast is one

2:20:02that I know runs on the Mac. Just open it on your Mac, open it on your iPad and look, not screenshots

2:20:10in comparing, but just look at the physical devices. You'll see that it is much smaller on

2:20:15on the Mac, 'cause the Mac is an information dense interface.

2:20:18So I can see at a very high level,

2:20:20two ways that Apple could go about this.

2:20:23And the first way would be,

2:20:26I will call it the Ben Thompson route,

2:20:28which is just add touch screens to the Mac,

2:20:31don't really rejigger anything.

2:20:32And if a whole bunch of the interface

2:20:35is not really touch friendly,

2:20:37then just use the mouse pointer for all that stuff.

2:20:39Like if you wanna hit that yellow button,

2:20:41you know to use the track pad.

2:20:42But if there's a big okay button

2:20:44and you just want to tap it with your finger,

2:20:46and you just want to flick to scroll safari with your finger

2:20:49and you don't care about the smudges on your screen,

2:20:52go ahead and touch, you know, so what?

2:20:55And you'll just learn what's good and what's bad.

2:20:58And I think the argument for this is not,

2:21:02it's clearly, Gurman's always wants to,

2:21:06part of the thing's not frustrating,

2:21:07but it's like, I can't read his stuff

2:21:10without being mildly annoyed by it,

2:21:12is that there's always a narrative attached.

2:21:15But the narrative is always built around the facts.

2:21:19So if the fact is he heard they're working on a touchscreen,

2:21:23then he builds a narrative that is this could help Apple

2:21:27because its competitors all sell touchscreen laptops.

2:21:30But the truth is Apple clearly won that argument.

2:21:3410, 11 years ago, Samsung had an enormous,

2:21:38years-long marketing campaign.

2:21:40Microsoft, who has a very, very well-regarded hardware business now with the Surface line,

2:21:45spent years where the primary ads I saw for Surface laptops were all targeting the MacBook Air,

2:21:53either by name or obviously implicitly. And the message was ours look the same, you know,

2:21:59they look like the same sort of aluminum little thing, and there's felt and small and lightweight,

2:22:04and ours have touch and theirs don't.

2:22:07And you know, that's worth trying as a marketing campaign.

2:22:10But the Mac is more popular now than it ever has been.

2:22:14It is, they're record-breaking quarters.

2:22:17And the Macs that most people buy are MacBooks by far.

2:22:20And the fact, so you know, you can make the argument

2:22:23that if they had touch screens, they'd sell even more.

2:22:25Maybe that's true, but it's obviously not hurt them at all

2:22:29that they don't have them.

2:22:30I think though there is an argument

2:22:33that the world in the last 10 years has grown and changed and that fundamentally people,

2:22:40especially younger people, I hear this from people with young kids all the time now, kids

2:22:44can't get it through their heads that Macs don't have touch screens. They just touch them and it

2:22:48feels broken. They've grown up with it. Yeah. It's like that's their first. Right. That was the

2:22:54problem with Apple TV too, right? Kids were walking up to the Apple TV and it's like, "Oh,

2:22:59Well, why isn't this working?

2:23:00So, you know, so that's the Ben Thompson.

2:23:03Just add touch and if some of the things are too small, then just learn not to use touch for those

2:23:07things and it's a totally secondary, just nice, nice to have thing. The other route that they

2:23:14could go would be to rejigger the Mac interface to make, you know, to really iPod size it,

2:23:21everything and all of Apple's own first party apps. And just think about this. Here's another

2:23:28example, Safari. I'm a diehard Safari user. It's my favorite browser. I've been a Safari user for

2:23:32years. How do you close a tab on Safari? You move the mouse over the tab to the right or left side,

2:23:40of course, left side for the close button on Mac. The right side that Chrome uses is

2:23:44idiomatic wrong, in my opinion, even though I know lots of people use Chrome. But you hover

2:23:50over that thing, and then the X appears, and you tap the X button to close the tab.

2:23:54Well, how do you do that with touch, right? If you look at the iPad, it's very different. They

2:23:59have to keep the X button visible at all times because…

2:24:02And again, it goes back to that information.

2:24:08And they only let you, on iPad, they only let you close the frontmost tab because that's the

2:24:14only one that changes the favicon to an X. So you can't close a background tab because of this

2:24:20problem. So if Apple did that, I would be heartbroken if they changed the entire Mac

2:24:25interface to be iPod or touch-sized and touch-friendly. And I think this is…

2:24:30Well, the problem is both approaches don't seem like something that Apple would do, right?

2:24:35That first approach, it's like this is coming from the company that spent all that time and

2:24:40engineering resources to come up with that awesome, you know, touch pointer on the iPadOS, right?

2:24:47They could have just put an arrow there and people would have gone, "Oh, cool. I can now point at

2:24:52stuff with my arrow on my iPad." But they made it Apple-esque. I don't see an Apple-esque solution

2:25:00for either one of those scenarios. And I know there are exceptions because no company is

2:25:05perfect, including Apple, certainly. But the Apple ethos is that everything should be nice.

2:25:12everything. The packaging, the tape, the little green pull tab that you pull apart.

2:25:17No rough edges, no rough edges.

2:25:19No rough edges. The packaging should be nice. The plastic that's wrapped around the device

2:25:25inside the packaging should be nice. Everything in the interface should be nice. And so if you

2:25:29have touch, everything should be touch friendly. And when they added mouse pointer support to

2:25:35iPadOS, they didn't just put a Mac style arrow cursor on screen that moves around.

2:25:41They made it nice and they made it very iPad. It's incredibly inventive and so natural and

2:25:48I like I seamlessly move back and forth between an iPad and a Mac and I just know where it is,

2:25:53but with that, what do you call it? Focus, you know?

2:25:55>> Yeah, the focus interaction is a typical, yeah.

2:25:57>> Focus interaction and that you have this round eraser-sized thing instead of an arrow cursor and

2:26:04it's kind of instead of being precise with a point, it is kind of sloppy like a small fingertip.

2:26:10Well, you know, look at Stage Manager, right?

2:26:13That's Apple's current attempt to kind of span the, you know, the window management on a Mac with window management on the iPad.

2:26:22And it's got a ton of rough edges, right?

2:26:27I don't think the people who want it are happy with it.

2:26:32The people who are making it probably aren't happy with it.

2:26:35It's a hard problem, right?

2:26:37Right? It's not, it's not something you can just wave the magic wand and go, "Oh, here you go."

2:26:42Right? You've got Stage Manager and it works awesome across all platforms.

2:26:46And Stage Manager doesn't work awesome across all platforms.

2:26:51I think back to the even probably a longer argument than the "should Macs have touchscreens" argument

2:26:58is the "how many buttons should be on a mouse" argument.

2:27:02And Apple stuck with a one-button mouse

2:27:06well past the point where everybody was like,

2:27:08they obviously should have a two-button mouse.

2:27:11And even today, really shipped with one button,

2:27:14but found a clever solution where they can enable

2:27:17the things that you used secondary buttons for

2:27:22in a way without adding the complexity of another button.

2:27:25And the argument against the two-button mouse,

2:27:29the argument on the one side is always,

2:27:31it's sort of the Microsoft mindset, in my opinion,

2:27:35and it's more the typical nerd mindset

2:27:39as opposed to a designer's mindset,

2:27:41which is that more is always better.

2:27:43- Yeah, absolutely. - More features.

2:27:45An app with more features is better than--

2:27:49- More settings, need more settings.

2:27:50- More settings, more features.

2:27:53Famously, it's the way most software was advertised

2:27:56in the early decades of the PC industry,

2:27:57with full-page ads, with here's our app,

2:28:01and here's a list of features,

2:28:02and there's a pretty green checkbox,

2:28:04and oh, wouldn't you believe it?

2:28:06Every single thing has a green checkbox for our app,

2:28:09and our competitors app has, oh, the first two, sure,

2:28:13green, oh, red X, red X, red X.

2:28:16- Only one button on this Mac.

2:28:18- Yeah. - You better buy a Windows 95.

2:28:20- Right, and it is, and some, that does appeal to people.

2:28:23I'm not saying that that's wrong.

2:28:25Obviously, there are some people who truly believe that,

2:28:28that more is better,

2:28:29And so having more buttons on a mouse is better

2:28:32than having fewer. - Having more options

2:28:33on a screen is better.

2:28:34I mean, that's Ben's thing, right?

2:28:36He wants more options.

2:28:37- And if you only want to use the left most main button,

2:28:41then just click that one button on your mouse all the time

2:28:43and ignore these other buttons.

2:28:45You can do that.

2:28:46And it is, that is true.

2:28:48- I just retired a mouse and I looked at it

2:28:51as I was putting it in the trash.

2:28:53And it's like, that left button was just like,

2:28:55it was just shiny, you know?

2:28:57- Yeah, yeah, yeah.

2:28:58- Ed covered in finger grease,

2:29:00and the right one, a little bit,

2:29:02but it was kind of as new.

2:29:05- Right, it's like when you have an old keyboard like I do,

2:29:08you can look, you know, you can definitely see.

2:29:11- Where do you hit the space bar?

2:29:12- Right, where do you hit the space bar?

2:29:13Erosion, it's a real thing.

2:29:15So, you know, I don't know.

2:29:16I think it's, but I do think that this--

2:29:19- I absolutely agree that there's a,

2:29:22we're gonna hear about it at WWDC.

2:29:25There's probably gonna be a lot of tooling involved.

2:29:28There's probably a lot, unless it's like Ben's just,

2:29:31you know, hey, let it roll.

2:29:33There's some rough edges, but you can deal with it.

2:29:36- In the way that I had a bad feeling

2:29:38about Twitter and third-party clients

2:29:41just for weeks at this point,

2:29:43and that it was a growing sense of dread

2:29:45and that it was not surprised on Friday,

2:29:47on the opposite side, I have a good feeling

2:29:49about if it comes true that touch screens

2:29:52come to MacBooks two or three years from now.

2:29:55I have a good feeling that it'll be done in a way

2:29:58where at every step of the way,

2:30:00it's done by people at Apple who feel just like we do

2:30:04about information density of macOS being a strong point

2:30:09that cannot be sacrificed.

2:30:11And that they'll, you know,

2:30:12and maybe that's also one of the reasons this is years ahead

2:30:15is that there's work to be done to do it the way they want.

2:30:18And I'm, you know, I'm not thinking-

2:30:20- Yeah, and it's gonna respect me

2:30:23as a user of that platform, right?

2:30:26It's like, I don't have to use Stage Manager.

2:30:29I have nothing to do with it, you know?

2:30:32But some people may want it, right?

2:30:35And I'm more power to 'em.

2:30:36- I certainly never would have anticipated,

2:30:4015 years ago, the way that Apple has magic track pads

2:30:45and magic mice now that have one button,

2:30:49or, you know, literally with the track pads, no buttons,

2:30:52right, no actual buttons, but that enables

2:30:55not just right-clicking, which was the whole argument,

2:30:58right, the whole argument with two-button mice

2:30:59is regular click versus a right-click for a contextual menu

2:31:02and you want two buttons for that.

2:31:04The Magic Trackpad does dozens of things, right?

2:31:07You can zoom and of course scroll, right, the two things.

2:31:11I would have never, I don't have, you know,

2:31:15this is why I write about stuff that,

2:31:18my job is writing and blabbing on this podcast

2:31:21about stuff, creative, inventive stuff that people make,

2:31:25not thinking of it.

2:31:26Like I never would have thought of it.

2:31:28And there might be something like that, you know,

2:31:30or multiple solutions like that.

2:31:31- And you know, to tie it back into Twitter, right?

2:31:34It's all kind of, you know,

2:31:36you have that initial innovation called Attract Bad.

2:31:39And then you start adding things like, you know,

2:31:42the haptic feedback, you add the different gestures,

2:31:45you add all of this stuff.

2:31:47And it's a keyword there is additive, right?

2:31:50You make that initial thing better and better and better.

2:31:54And Apple is so good at that.

2:31:57- Right.

2:31:58- That article you wrote long ago, you know,

2:32:00how Apple rolls, it's just, you know,

2:32:04take that nut of the idea and increment and increment

2:32:08and increment and, you know,

2:32:10just make it better year over year.

2:32:12- Yeah, I'm glad Apple doesn't spend much time

2:32:15explaining over and over again officially, you know,

2:32:18why iPadOS and macOS are not merging

2:32:21and why they are separate platforms.

2:32:23I'm glad because it gives me all the time in the world

2:32:27to write about it at great length on my website

2:32:29and talk about it on the show.

2:32:31But I really do believe from everybody I know

2:32:34there behind the scenes and what they have said,

2:32:38what John Turnus and Jaws have said about it,

2:32:41that they get, and Federighi, Federighi has spoken eloquently.

2:32:44- They're very open about it.

2:32:46And people like that, they don't want to hear it.

2:32:49Federighi of all people is the one whose life would be tremendously simpler if he had one

2:32:57less OS team to manage.

2:32:59And he's the, you know, merge teams and do all sorts.

2:33:02Yeah, you could do that.

2:33:03That would be awesome for him.

2:33:08In terms of decreasing the amount of work he has to deal with, he'd be the number one

2:33:13beneficiary in the world, and yet he's one of the most eloquent and ardent

2:33:17supporters of the separation of Mac OS and iPad OS.

2:33:21Well, he's one of us. He's one of us. He's been using Next Step since it wasn't even Next Step, right?

2:33:27Right, well, you know. So anyway, I'm optimistic that even if it comes true,

2:33:32it'll be fine, and that people like me and you can just ignore it and never

2:33:35touch my screen still, and it's not going to fundamentally

2:33:40changed the macOS interface.

2:33:41That's.

2:33:41But, but there, but it, you know, it's going to be something that Apple can leverage, you

2:33:46know, at a point of sale, right?

2:33:48That you, you know, that you're gonna be able to walk into an Apple store and it's gonna

2:33:51have some demo that says, you know, Hey, touch me here.

2:33:54And it's going to do all sorts of cool things.

2:33:57And you're going to be like, Oh, this is great.

2:33:58This is better than my iPad or whatever.

2:34:01Right.

2:34:01You know, it's just, you know, that's going to happen.

2:34:04It's going to, it's going to have a, it's going to have a cool name.

2:34:08I don't know what that name is gonna be, but it's gonna be marketing people.

2:34:13The marketing people and the manufacturing people probably start thinking about this

2:34:17new thing at the same time.

2:34:19And they're going to act as though they've invented it.

2:34:22And it's gonna be dry.

2:34:23All the people who've been thinking it's insane that they haven't had it for 10 years and

2:34:28that they should have just made it a touchscreen, when they come up with their name for it and

2:34:32act as though they've invented it.

2:34:34Which I'm sure there will be aspects that they didn't invent, but everybody in the

2:34:38and then Samsung six months later is gonna have their copy of it.

2:34:42Craig, thank you so much. I know obviously it's been a rough week. You have my sympathies,

2:34:46but also you have my profound thanks. And you know that I love Twitterrific,

2:34:51and you know that I love... Yeah, you were an early supporter. I mean,

2:34:53that first blog post mentioned you. There was a reason for that.

2:34:57You kind of gave me the idea, right? You said, "Oh, I want this thing to be a dashboard widget."

2:35:05I was like, oh, and then I was like, yeah, that's literally the, I, it's so long ago.

2:35:12This again, maybe one of those I'm constructing the memories for what I want them to be, but

2:35:16I'm going to say I read that tweet, got in the shower and then had the idea for Twitterific.

2:35:22Let's say where, and where did you write about this? Is this an old Furbo post?

2:35:25Yeah. Yeah. Well, when you, was it when you announced Twitter?

2:35:29Yeah. Yeah. It's in that it was January. In fact, it was yesterday, 16 years ago.

2:35:35So yeah, we it's, you know, we, at the end of the thing, it's like, oh, hey, you know,

2:35:41this is a new thing, you know, go follow us. It's, you know, Chalkinberry, you know,

2:35:45Gedianim, Talos, you know, all of us. And then, and you can even follow some famous people. And

2:35:51the link for famous was to you and somebody else who I've forgotten to, but you know,

2:35:57the Digirati. Yeah. Well, that's, that speaks to how small Twitter, that's really speaks to how

2:36:04small Twitter was back then. We did that on our internal Slack the other day. Back when

2:36:09Groover was famous. There was a time when my follower count was... I was never at top

2:36:17of the list, but I was, you know, maybe it was some... maybe at one point I was in the

2:36:21top 100 or something. Yeah. But now, you know. And you know, follower count doesn't matter.

2:36:27You know, it's quality versus quantity. Oh, of course. Honestly, I wish I had a lot fewer

2:36:32followers. It's one of the reasons I'm enjoying Mastodon. That is very true. One of the things I

2:36:37will say about Mastodon is that the level of discourse is a lot, you know, I can't reply to

2:36:43everything, but there are things that I want to reply to, right? And that wasn't always true on

2:36:49Twitter recently. I've been given a lot of thought that I know, and I've talked about it last

2:36:53word, the last episode of the show with Glenn Fleishman, and we've gone on too long. I'm not

2:36:57going to go on too far, but I've been thinking a lot about where's Mastodon going. It's obviously

2:37:01a good place. It feels very much like early Twitter, but it's also very, at least my circle

2:37:06on Mastodon of people I've followed, is very nerd-centric. Yeah, there's not a lot of the

2:37:13political information or people talking about COVID or whatever. It is important on Twitter

2:37:19for the last, you know, 10 years. It is much nicer, but I'm optimistic that Mastodon is going

2:37:25to stay that way because I do think Mastodon is what I was saying about with Twitter. Mastodon

2:37:29isn't run. You can run a commercial instance of it if you choose, but it's open source project.

2:37:34It is sort of a foundation or it's just trying to be good, but therefore it's not trying to be

2:37:41profitable. And so therefore, none of their decisions are geared towards profit or engagement.

2:37:49Tom: Right. No algorithms.

2:37:52Right, and so famously there's this, you know, one of the things people that love, the third-party

2:37:57Twitter clients love about them, including me, but is the non-algorithmic timeline. Just show me the

2:38:03tweets from the people I follow in the order they were posted and that's all I want. And you can

2:38:07kind of get that in Twitter on their following tab in the Twitter app, but the point is...

2:38:12Right, but the point is that Twitter shifted towards the algorithmic timeline years and years

2:38:19ago because when they wanted to grow and it's that whole thing where their idea was let's

2:38:27let's we want to be a hundred billion dollar company we want to be a peer to facebook and so

2:38:33we need facebook size appeal and for the not just slight majority but overwhelming majority

2:38:43of regular people out there, the Twitter of old, the old original Twitter that was only a non-algorithmic

2:38:52timeline and only the people you chose to follow with no suggestions at all, other than what you've

2:38:58chosen to follow, was baffling to most people. That was not confusing that they didn't understand it,

2:39:05but confusing why would I want to use this, right? They would, and so, and Twitter had these metrics.

2:39:10they were very obvious to see that people would say, "All right, people keep saying I should get

2:39:14on Twitter. Now I'm on Twitter. Here I'll follow, all right, Barack Obama and here's somebody else."

2:39:21And, you know, they did—one thing they did algorithmically even back then was suggest

2:39:25people to follow, right? That's how my wife got so many followers because she made that list of—

2:39:29- Oh, really? I didn't know that. - Yeah, she's got like tens of thousands of followers,

2:39:34you know, not because she's my wife. Like, people are like, "Oh, I know—"

2:39:37- Well, you're famous, John. - I know. But no,

2:39:39but people followed her because she and Anil Dash and I forget who else but back in those early days

2:39:45somebody at Twitter liked her jokes and put her on that list of like 50 people you might want to

2:39:51follow. I don't even know that that was algorithmic. I think they just had like a list of here's 50

2:39:55people we at Twitter think are good, general, like you know friendly, funny, interesting, insightful,

2:40:01maybe you like politics, maybe you like sports, maybe you like jokes. Here's some people to follow.

2:40:05Just to prime the pump basically.

2:40:07Right, but people exposed to that, they'd sign up, they'd follow some people, they'd

2:40:11look at their timeline, they'd say, "I have no idea why I would ever want to come back

2:40:14here," and then they wouldn't come back and they went away.

2:40:17And then they shifted towards using algorithms to suggest content and to promote engagement

2:40:24and test, "Oh, this hashtag is getting lots of engagement.

2:40:28Let's show it to more people and, oh, everybody who has liked tweets from Al Franken seems

2:40:34to want to engage with this hashtag about a new political issue. And so let's show it

2:40:42to those people. And that did increase engagement. And but to me, the the downs obvious downside

2:40:50to it is it drew people who are looking to fight or even people who weren't looking to

2:40:55fight the engagement would make them emotional and angry. And now they're in a bad mood and

2:41:00they are snippy and rude and curt on Twitter. The culture grew shifted.

2:41:06Tim Cynova Yeah, at the risk of diving into talking about

2:41:12social networks for hours and hours, to me the thing that's problematic with algorithms

2:41:19is that they show you what you like, right? And the thing is that life is full of things

2:41:28that you don't like and you need to be exposed to them. You know, one of the beautiful things

2:41:33about Twitter, I've learned about like for things like the Tulsa massacre on Twitter,

2:41:38right? I had never, I mean, I grew up, you know, in a school filled with other white

2:41:45people, right? And I'd never heard of this and never been taught in my history. And I

2:41:49was like, I read that and I was like, holy shit, right? And that's something that an

2:41:54algorithm would not because, you know, I don't express any like of that. But it's the diversity

2:42:01of things that algorithms don't help at all with. It just shows you what you already know and what

2:42:10you know already like. And, you know, some people want that. That's one of the reasons why Facebook

2:42:15is so wildly popular. And all sorts of things that I loved or used to love are like that. I think RSS

2:42:23feeds are like that. I think there's an RSS feeds are having a nice resurgence, but they're never

2:42:28going to be as popular as like Facebook, right? They're not because the most people don't want

2:42:32to curate. Usenet, I loved it back in the day. It was never something that was going to explode in

2:42:38popularity. There's a reason that all these modern social networks replaced it because they don't

2:42:43engage people who aren't looking to do the curation and hunting themselves. Mastodon is like that. It

2:42:49has that appeal. And so for some of us who liked the old Twitter better than new Twitter,

2:42:55everybody has the same reaction. You go to Mastodon, you use one of these tools to find

2:43:01the people you followed on Twitter on Mastodon, and you say, "This is better than Twitter," because

2:43:06in most ways, because I'm seeing better content, having better engagements, everybody is friendlier,

2:43:12this is just a total win. And most people who use Twitter or have ever used Twitter,

2:43:18if they tried Mastodon, they would be like, not confused, I think per se, although some of the

2:43:24Federation and which server you're on is confusing. And that's a barrier to entry to. I just think

2:43:29though that they could get talked through the pick a server, find a name, find people you want to

2:43:34follow and still look at it and say, this is not engaging. I don't get it. And that's fine. And

2:43:40that is fine. But I think if I'm right, the good news is I think Mastodon can continue to grow and

2:43:47thrive and will stay the place that is making us happy, those of us who are happy on Mastodon,

2:43:54in perpetuity. I am genuinely optimistic about that.

2:43:58And so—

2:43:58Tim Cynova The thing that's gonna make me happy is being able to combine some of those things that

2:44:05make me happy, right? There's certain things I absolutely love Michael Tsai's RSS feed, right?

2:44:14It just tells me about stuff that's happening in the Mac industry and, you know, has good

2:44:21links, has good commentary.

2:44:25It's just, it's like, it's one of the things I follow, but you know, if I'm looking at

2:44:28Sidon, I may or may not see his toots about these things.

2:44:33So, you know, it's like, there's a lot of things that interest me.

2:44:39How do I get all of those things that interest me kind of into one place?

2:44:43Right.

2:44:44the freedom to do that because there's no gatekeeper rules, right? Like one of the things I think...

2:44:48John "Slick" Baum: The open web, man.

2:44:49David "Slick" Baum" Kammerer One of the things I think people don't...

2:44:51John "Slick" Baum" Kammerer That's a lesson learned now, right?

2:44:52David "Slick" Baum" Kammerer One of the things I think people don't know

2:44:56is that the Twitter API rules prevent a Twitter client from federating information from other

2:45:02services. So, for example, why was Tapbot working on Ivory before this happened? Because they weren't

2:45:10allowed to turn Tweetbot into a, oh, you can have Twitter accounts and Mastodon accounts side by

2:45:15side in the same app. The Twitter APIs forbid you from doing that, right? And so there's all, and

2:45:21there's, you know, all sorts of other things that are therefore impossible. So not just separate

2:45:25accounts with separate timelines, you therefore obviously therefore can't merge them into one

2:45:29timeline, which is what you're talking about, right? And doing clever original things with

2:45:34presentation. Nope, not allowed. So anyway, by conclusion on this last digression of this

2:45:39digression-filled episode, is that perversely, in some ways, SpaceKaren might have saved Twitter

2:45:47and restored it to former greatness, but not by saving Twitter itself, but by wrecking Twitter

2:45:54itself. And by wrecking it, creating a critical mass of people like me who were sort of skeptical

2:46:03about Mastodon and were lazy and more willing to stay on Twitter than do the right thing and go to

2:46:10the open thing. But by pushing so many people away and moving them to Mastodon by wrecking Twitter,

2:46:17he's added critical mass to Mastodon that was lacking, right? Like three months ago. I've had

2:46:22a Mastodon account since 2018 during this. Yeah, me too. Right, there was something that they did

2:46:28it was like oh shit.

2:46:30- Oh boy, we better.

2:46:30- Mastodon, this has gotta be a backup.

2:46:33- Yeah, let me go get my Gruber

2:46:35and let you go get Chickenberry, right?

2:46:38We all signed up, everybody signed up in my crowd

2:46:40at 2018 during some API.

2:46:43- Yeah, I don't even wanna go back

2:46:45and think about what that was,

2:46:46but it was certainly something.

2:46:48- And I thank everybody who's been working

2:46:51on Mastodon for years.

2:46:52I thank them and Open, what's the thing,

2:46:55the activity pub and these APIs. I thank all of those people who had the vision to say

2:47:01to know five years ago that this Twitter thing was a bad idea and that we should forge ahead

2:47:08with this. I thank them profusely and sincerely and it's so wonderful that Mastodon is here

2:47:14thriving, working, and you know, obviously there's lots they can add and it can be better

2:47:19and faster.

2:47:20And they've got scaling issues like when we have to fail well.

2:47:23But the fact that they had the foresight to say, "Yeah, okay, this is a walled garden."

2:47:31Right.

2:47:32But it's—yeah, let's celebrate the fact that here we are toasting to the third-party

2:47:37Twitter clients that we previously loved and are now shut off, and Mastodon is already

2:47:42here.

2:47:43We're not stuck at the point of, "I guess we should make something open that's like

2:47:48Twitter.

2:47:49Let's get started and see what sticks."

2:47:51No, it's already here because these people had the foresight to do it years ago, and I thank them profusely

2:47:56But the truth is the truth is pre Space Caron acquisition of Twitter mastodon

2:48:01Was not a ghost town and I know that there are people who've been actively using it for years

2:48:07But for me it was I would check in every couple months or you know once a year or something and it was like it

2:48:14Was like crickets chirping for me

2:48:15It's thanks to SpaceKaren that Mastodon has this massive infusion of critical mass to make it active enough

2:48:23Even though it still is a tiny size of Twitter. It's it's it went from too small to enough to be interesting and

2:48:30I think is never going to grow too big to be problematic which is kind of a neat place to be. Yeah

2:48:37Yeah, you know people talk about the barrier to entry for Mastodon and that's not necessarily a bad thing, right?

2:48:42I mean, I don't see many bot accounts.

2:48:45- It has a flip side.

2:48:47- Yeah, so it's, you know, of course you want that diversity

2:48:52and that's one of the things that worries me

2:48:56a little bit now, but I think over time

2:48:59it'll probably work itself out.

2:49:01But yeah, there's, you know,

2:49:03it's a lot of tech dudes at this point.

2:49:05- Right, well, but that's also who we follow.

2:49:08There are thriving communities and entire instances

2:49:11you just saw like massathon.art and you know a couple of people icon factor big big over there

2:49:17and and you know it's like it's a bunch of artists hanging out and doing their thing many many

2:49:23there's no maybe a dozen popular servers that are focused on the lgbtq yeah yeah community yeah

2:49:30even the url is you know yeah right in the url yeah yeah awesome yeah yeah so there's you know

2:49:37It'll work itself. I think I have hope that it'll work itself out and that it won't become too much of a trash fire like

2:49:44I am op. I am optimistic. Let me thank you for your time. I it's been a pleasure

2:49:49I'm going to put links in the show notes to all of those fine icon factory products that

2:49:53Haven't had their o-off credentials yet over the weekend. So there's all sorts of places. I will put some links into furbol

2:50:00I thank you craig. It's good to talk to you. Cheer cheer up and thank you for everything

2:50:05We've, this is not the first time we've had a setback,

2:50:09and we'll figure out what we're gonna do

2:50:13and start doing it, make something we love.

2:50:16- Let me thank the sponsors for today's episode,

2:50:18our good friends at Squarespace,

2:50:19where you can sign up for a website,

2:50:21and Nebula, where you can subscribe

2:50:23and get amazing original content and video,

2:50:27and our good friends at Trade Coffee,

2:50:29where you can sign up for a subscription

2:50:30to coffee and drink it.

2:50:32Thanks, Craig.

2:50:33- Yep, thank you, Jon.