Podcast Search

Upgrade

382: Hey Car, Stop

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00[Ding!]

0:00:00[music]

0:00:08From Relay FM, this is Upgrade, episode 382, and today's show is brought to you by ZocDoc,

0:00:16Membrful, and DoorDash.

0:00:18My name is Myke Curley and I am joined by Jason Sonnell.

0:00:20Hi, Jason.

0:00:21Hi, Myke.

0:00:22How are you?

0:00:23I'm good, my friend.

0:00:24I've got a lot of stuff to talk about today.

0:00:26Oh, packed show today.

0:00:27Packed show.

0:00:28Recording from an undisclosed location. So please don't write in and wonder why I sound different. It's because I'm in a different place. That's all I

0:00:35Have a hashtag snail talk question comes from Chris Chris wants to know what is your screensaver?

0:00:41my screensaver is

0:00:45Called Ariel and it is literally the aerial screensaver from the Apple TV

0:00:50put on the Mac and we talked about this a while ago and I acted like it was

0:00:57The bill or more, you know, and then people pointed out that you can't actually get that on the Mac

0:01:02and so you have to go to aerial screensaver dot github.io and

0:01:05there's a github project and it's a screen saver module for the Mac and then it loads all of the aerial

0:01:12Imagery imagery that's on the Apple TV, you know, this is different the last time that we did speak about this

0:01:18It was all just like just took to a github page and it was it but now they at least have like a download thing

0:01:25Well, it's a GitHub hosted page, but it's like the project page and it's all pretty

0:01:32and stuff now.

0:01:33So it looks more like a normal piece of software and not just a GitHub project.

0:01:39But yeah, that's what it is.

0:01:42It's just taken that imagery and I don't really understand why it's not available on the Mac

0:01:47via an Apple thing.

0:01:49I did that ages ago and I'm probably still using an ancient version of it, but that's

0:01:54what I have on my iMac.

0:01:55So if I, it doesn't stay on for very long, but if I wander away from my iMac for a while

0:01:59and then come back, there'll usually be some sort of a flyover happening.

0:02:03Where does it get the videos from?

0:02:06Apple, there is a, you can download these videos, there's a known URL that is the, I

0:02:13believe there's like a JSON file or something that shows you, it's the stuff the Apple TV

0:02:18downloads.

0:02:19Because they do pull them down from the web, right?

0:02:21So they are existing on the internet somewhere.

0:02:23It's just weird to me that Apple didn't lock that away, you know?

0:02:27But hey ho, it's great that they didn't.

0:02:29- Yeah, no, it's a known URL, so they just load that

0:02:32and it gives them a list of what's available

0:02:33and then they pull from there.

0:02:35- Think I'm gonna put this on my MacBook Pro, I think.

0:02:38On my iMac, I use the Hello screensaver

0:02:43in the matching color of my iMac.

0:02:45I don't know if that one is available on non M1 iMacs.

0:02:51I don't know.

0:02:52It's the one that draws the word "hello"?

0:02:55I think it's in Monterey.

0:02:57Okay.

0:02:58I think before Monterey it wasn't available.

0:03:01I think that's right.

0:03:02It's probably available now.

0:03:03But at least on mine, it's in yellow.

0:03:05This is the default one that it shipped with.

0:03:08So I just like it.

0:03:10I think it's fun.

0:03:11And it reminds me of how much I love

0:03:13my little yellow computer.

0:03:15Thank you to Chris for that Seltor question.

0:03:17If you would like to send in a question

0:03:19for us to open an episode of Upgrade,

0:03:22we will answer it. Just send out a tweet with the hashtag #snowtalk or use question mark

0:03:25snow talk in the relay FM members discord. I have a couple of follow up things that we

0:03:30can go through Jason. The first is that Qualcomm have divulged to their investors on an investor

0:03:36call that they expect 80% of their modem chip supply to Apple to fall away in 2023. So that

0:03:44will only be what they have now, what they're currently supplying. They're expecting to

0:03:48just be supplying 20% of that in 2023 and onwards.

0:03:53So I think it's clear that we can assume from this,

0:03:56as you wrote about in "Six Colors,"

0:03:58that we can expect that this is the time

0:04:00when Apple will be making their own modems,

0:04:02which was something that was expected as a refresher.

0:04:06You may remember Apple were in court with Qualcomm

0:04:08over a payment dispute for patents and stuff,

0:04:12when they, at that time, in one fail swoop,

0:04:15bought Intel's business, like their modem business,

0:04:19and settled with Qualcomm.

0:04:21And part of that settlement is that they would maintain

0:04:23a relationship in the meantime,

0:04:25probably whatever price Qualcomm wanted them to pay

0:04:27but Apple didn't want to pay, and it will come to an end,

0:04:31and it seems like it's gonna be coming to an end in 2023.

0:04:34- And they have some agreement in there

0:04:35about what patents or patent payments are owed and all that,

0:04:39because just because Apple's not going to be,

0:04:41in the end, a customer of Qualcomm directly,

0:04:44they're probably going to still pay them for whatever patent licensing, although Apple's

0:04:50got some patents too that were part of the Intel thing.

0:04:52Like it's, I don't recall exactly the details and I'm not sure how much of that is public,

0:04:57but I would imagine that there will be some amount of payments that Apple's still going

0:05:03to have to make to Qualcomm because Qualcomm has these patents.

0:05:06But in terms of buying the silicon, buying the radios from Qualcomm, I just enjoy that

0:05:15this story came out in a Qualcomm event because Qualcomm doesn't care.

0:05:21That was the thing that made me laugh about this story.

0:05:23This story is not unexpected at all, but Qualcomm saying, "Oh yeah, Apple's..."

0:05:28And they're telling people, they're warning about losing a customer, a big customer, saying,

0:05:31yeah by fall of 23, 80 percent of their modem chip business or 20 percent of their modem

0:05:41chip business will be Apple and the rest will be gone and the whole idea there is they don't

0:05:46care to an Apple partner that wants to keep Apple's business is going to keep quiet, right?

0:05:54That's the rule.

0:05:55You know this.

0:05:57is the rule of Apple is don't cross me. Secrecy is the word of the day. Well, Qualcomm doesn't

0:06:05care. Qualcomm doesn't care. So Qualcomm is happy to go out and say, "Oh yeah, Apple's

0:06:10going to be using their own chips in the new iPhones really by 2023." And they say they'll

0:06:18still have some. I imagine that is their estimate about how many they're going to be supplying

0:06:23for older products that are not yet discontinued, a brand new legacy node.

0:06:29So here's our time frame for Apple doing 5G.

0:06:32We may see, or 5G using their own silicon, we may see it in products before this.

0:06:37It's a little unclear too, they're talking about Qualcomm's fiscal year, so the question

0:06:40of will it be next fall that they start this process or will it really not be until 23?

0:06:45Will it premiere in maybe a laptop or maybe an iPad before it goes in the iPhone?

0:06:50sort of up to Apple to decide how it wants to do it. Honestly, I can sort of see it make

0:06:57sense that it might debut in a non-iPhone product just to tie it out.

0:07:01I really hope they don't debut their first ever modem chip in their iPhone.

0:07:08In an iPhone? In a big high-volume iPhone?

0:07:10This is something that's new for Apple, right? Like it will be new. They might have done

0:07:14a bunch of testing but it is gonna be new and this like the modem that is a

0:07:19cannot be an error there is no room for error in the modem of an iPhone right

0:07:25remember when there was the there were Intel and Qualcomm chips and one of them

0:07:30was like faster than the other one and every people were like trying to figure

0:07:32out if they could shop for the iPhones that had the faster chips and

0:07:36then all it's no good so yeah I would not I mean who knows Apple could do

0:07:43whatever it wants but I wouldn't be shocked if it's in some lower volume product and literally

0:07:47everything that's on iPhone is a lower volume product for Apple that it show up in an iPad

0:07:52or something like that before beforehand. But Qualcomm is basically like yeah this is

0:07:56going to happen and this is the only time you get kind of this long-range thing is when

0:08:00a supplier who is not going to be a supplier anymore is happy to say yep Apple's taking

0:08:05their business elsewhere or in this case taking their ball and going home with it because

0:08:11going to build these things themselves or we assume maybe integrate them onto the chips,

0:08:17although that's not necessarily the case.

0:08:20So Apple's going to build them, it's going to happen, and Qualcomm says that by fall

0:08:24of '23 it will be in full swing.

0:08:27So that gives us some extra data about what Apple is doing building its own modems.

0:08:34Thanks, Qualcomm.

0:08:35Yeah, thanks a lot.

0:08:37It's great to have someone who just doesn't care and Qualcomm, which is funny because

0:08:43there's that interview with the CEO of Intel who it was almost the reverse of that where

0:08:51Apple has gotten away from Intel and the CEO of Intel is like, "Well, we just got to work

0:08:56to get their business back."

0:08:57And like, "Really?

0:08:59Yeah, our chips, if we make better chips, they'll come back to us."

0:09:03It's like, "I don't think that's ever going to happen."

0:09:06And then he sort of hedged and like, or, you know, maybe, you know, if we can make their

0:09:10chips for them, right?

0:09:11And it's like, oh, okay, well that is more possible as a scenario that if you catch up

0:09:17to TSMC at fabrication that you could compete with them for Apple's business.

0:09:22But it was just this really kind of cockeyed, optimistic, unrealistic kind of like, we're

0:09:27going to compete for their business.

0:09:28And Qualcomm's like, yeah, they're gone.

0:09:30Bye.

0:09:31I feel like that's surely something that they said to make a positive message to shareholders.

0:09:38They know that surely there's nothing they can do.

0:09:42I don't think Apple necessarily cares about having the fastest chips on the market.

0:09:47They just so happen to have them.

0:09:50It could become having lived through the PowerPC era, it can become a burden for your platform

0:09:56but it would take a while and Apple would still have their control.

0:09:59There's no sign of that really happening.

0:10:01Qualcomm did make some, speaking of Qualcomm, make some statements about their, they've

0:10:05got a next generation processor coming from the company that they bought that was founded

0:10:09by people who used to work at Apple doing chip design and that that is targeted at a

0:10:14PC level kind of performance thing.

0:10:16Interesting, but like, let's, and they may be able to match or beat Apple or it may change

0:10:23the game in some way.

0:10:24But thus far Apple's already been more than a year ahead of Qualcomm's chips on smartphones

0:10:30in terms of performance and we've seen where Apple's chips on the Mac are compared to Intel.

0:10:35So right now Apple's just got a big lead and it may change but I think the Intel CEO first

0:10:44off I think maybe learned his lesson when about that whole lifestyle company from Cupertino

0:10:50joke that he made but also I think that he's sending a message that Intel is gonna try,

0:10:56right? Like Intel is gonna keep working at it and they're gonna be able to compete with

0:11:02Apple and even if Apple doesn't switch like we're gonna be competitive which I'm not sure

0:11:06anybody believes right now but it take the long view you know give them they're gonna

0:11:11try good for them and then more realistically Intel which famously wouldn't fab chips for

0:11:16anybody else that weren't Intel's own chips. I think that is a major area of growth for

0:11:23Intel and that Intel would love to be able to take chip manufacturing business away from

0:11:30TSMC in terms of Apple. That's an area where Intel could really grow. Intel is talking

0:11:36like a company that wants to do business with Apple in the future and Qualcomm is not.

0:11:41South Korean lawmakers are unhappy with Apple's efforts to meet their ruling over third-party

0:11:47payments.

0:11:59Yeo Seung-Le, who is one of the lawmakers in South Korea, has a great quote from them.

0:12:04"Frankly, we are not satisfied.

0:12:05Apple's claims that it's already complying is nonsensical.

0:12:09"Excessive fees take away developers' chances for innovation. Parliament is to be

0:12:13closely informed as the government's draft detailed regulations to make sure there is

0:12:16accountability." This is coming into effect pretty soon next year. And it is kind of hilarious,

0:12:23really, when you look at what we were talking about with what Google did to comply. And

0:12:27Apple has so far said, "They are already complying." And I don't understand. I don't

0:12:35get it? I don't know what they're particularly hinging this on, but that's kind of where

0:12:40they are and understandably South Korea's pretty peeved about it.

0:12:45Yeah, it's like a weird game of chicken where it was like, "Alright, we passed a

0:12:50new law, you gotta do it." We already did it.

0:12:52They're gaslighting.

0:12:53What?

0:12:54Which is so strange as a thing to do. I don't really know what the plan is here, but this

0:13:00is where they are right now.

0:13:02Amazing. Well, I think our notes from last week can be replayed here. Basically, if Apple

0:13:10is forced to comply with like alternative payment routes, we know what they're going

0:13:14to do. They're going to do what Google did, which is they're going to charge a fee regardless

0:13:20of whether you use their service or not for payment and it's not going to save anybody

0:13:23any money and so nobody's going to do it. That's what's going to happen. So, they're

0:13:28They're going to have to try something else.

0:13:30Yeah.

0:13:31Yeah, I think if they are forced to do alternative payment methods, I think that's absolutely

0:13:35what they're going to do.

0:13:36Because they could use the developer account as a proxy and charge people for their annual

0:13:45developer thing, but I feel like the simplest thing to do is just say, "We've changed the

0:13:51terms of service of your Apple developer agreement, and if you use an alternative payment mechanism

0:13:55in a country where that is available, then you owe us this percentage as part of your

0:14:00developer agreement.

0:14:01Done.

0:14:02Right?

0:14:03And, uh, and that may know what that effect will be, which is everybody will look at the

0:14:09cost of implementing an alternative payment mechanism and realize it's as expensive or

0:14:14more expensive or only very slightly less expensive than using apples.

0:14:18And most people will just give up and not do it.

0:14:21And then there'll be another round of legislation that'll say you can't charge more than this

0:14:27for your fee.

0:14:29And that'll be argued and, you know, but that would be the next round.

0:14:33And you have a orange HomePod mini.

0:14:37I do.

0:14:38I wrote about this on Six Colors last week.

0:14:39It's been in my office for a little while.

0:14:43Apple sent me an orange HomePod mini.

0:14:45I mean, HomePod mini is not new.

0:14:46They never sent me a HomePod mini to review, by the way.

0:14:49But they sent me an orange HomePod Mini to look at the color, right?

0:14:54Which is interesting.

0:14:55I appreciate it because I had, I bought a HomePod Mini.

0:14:58I have a space gray HomePod Mini.

0:15:00And so I was able to do a HomePod Mini stereo pair for the first time.

0:15:05I have two HomePods and in a stereo pair.

0:15:10So I know about that.

0:15:12But I hadn't done it with the HomePod Mini before.

0:15:14And so I hadn't really been able to hear how it performs as a stereo pair.

0:15:18And so that was fun.

0:15:21It sounds pretty good.

0:15:22I tried it out in place.

0:15:24So I have a Sonos One pair that I used to replace my iPod HiFi, which was wired into

0:15:28my iMac, because I wanted to get the iPod HiFi off the desk, and it gets a little more

0:15:34stereo separation to have the speakers on opposite sides of my office instead of just

0:15:39kind of off to the left of my iMac.

0:15:42And the Sonos's sounded good, but I have had problems.

0:15:45I've been bedeviled with airplay problems, where sometimes it loses the connection, sometimes

0:15:54it can't see the speakers briefly, sometimes when you press play, one starts playing and

0:16:00then the other one catches up after a second or two, so every song starts off in the left

0:16:06and then becomes stereo.

0:16:08I've had it where you pause it and walk away for a while and you come back and you press

0:16:13play and it won't play and it until you replay the song it just won't play.

0:16:21Lots of frustration there and I've been unclear on whether that it was Sonos's fault or whether

0:16:26that was Airplay's fault.

0:16:28And I can report now that I've used the HomePod minis that it's Airplay's fault.

0:16:32The HomePod minis are probably, I forget how I phrased in the article, basically they're

0:16:37more stable a little bit maybe than the Sonos's but not a lot and it's still not great.

0:16:43Is this an issue you are finding on the Mac or on all devices?

0:16:47On the Mac, it is the worst.

0:16:50There are issues, and I think last week ATP talked about this, Marco talked about it a

0:16:54little bit, and I hadn't listened when I wrote my piece, and it was sort of like we were

0:16:58thinking along the same track at the same time.

0:17:00It's pretty funny.

0:17:02There are AirPlay issues.

0:17:04AirPlay has, and it has gotten worse.

0:17:06I noticed this with my regular HomePods too, where, and I don't know if it's a new version

0:17:12of Airplay or iOS or whatever, but I've noticed on my other home pods, my big home pods, that

0:17:17sometimes it just takes the playback away from me, so I'm playing it from my phone,

0:17:23and then I go to my phone to pause it or go to the next track and my phone is no longer

0:17:27playing.

0:17:28It's no longer connected to the home pod.

0:17:31So you know, because they get in this weird synergy where like you're on your phone, but

0:17:37the now playing is the HomePod and you can pause it and go next and change the

0:17:41volume. It's very nice when you initiate that from the phone that you get to

0:17:45control it. But I found that increasingly the HomePod basically disconnects from

0:17:50my phone and now I have to either go try to find the HomePod and reconnect to it

0:17:54which is a challenge and doesn't always work. A lot of times I'll press

0:17:59what I think is pause but it's actually play and what happens is it's gonna play

0:18:03that same thing that I'm playing on the HomePod on my iPhone at the point where that disconnected so I often get like

0:18:09Two versions of the same song shifted off by 30 seconds one's playing out of my phone and the other still playing on the HomePod

0:18:16very weird

0:18:18Home play or very weird airplay stuff going on

0:18:21I

0:18:23will say though that

0:18:25Clearly it is more reliable to play things on the HomePods mini or big or the Sonos's

0:18:33honestly, from an iOS device.

0:18:35On the Mac, it's really weird.

0:18:38And there is this like system output setting for the Mac

0:18:43that lets you use your HomePods or any other AirPlay device

0:18:47theoretically as a system output.

0:18:49But I don't-- and first off, that's not reliable either.

0:18:52But I also don't want that.

0:18:54Because that means that every alert, anything else that

0:18:57is playing out of the Mac is two second

0:19:00delayed playback via AirPlay.

0:19:03And I don't want that.

0:19:04I want that stuff to come through my iMac speaker and be instantaneous.

0:19:08So it's a weird situation.

0:19:11I like the sound of the HomePod Minis.

0:19:13They don't sound quite as good as the Sonos', but the Sonos' cost twice as much.

0:19:19And honestly, for my use, where they're sitting on basically the edges of my desk, the HomePod

0:19:24Mini would be good enough.

0:19:26It can't get as loud as the Sonos', but the loudest of the HomePod Mini is good enough,

0:19:31again, good enough for my use sitting on my desk in my office.

0:19:34I've had a bunch of people write in and say, "Well, what you really need is a USB amp and

0:19:38wired speakers, wired bookshelf speakers."

0:19:40It's like, that's not what I want.

0:19:43Wired would be better, but I don't want wires, and I don't want big speakers sitting on my

0:19:48desk.

0:19:49So, I'm trying to find some other method here, not entirely successfully.

0:19:56enough that I haven't bagged it and got back to the iPod Hi-Fi, but it's not as good as

0:20:00I wish that it was. And I think the bottom line is the software is a little messed up

0:20:06right now. And the fact that the Mac is not a first-class citizen of AirPlay, and even

0:20:12on the number one platform, iOS, AirPlay is kind of sketchy right now. We're in a weird

0:20:19place. I know you've complained about HomePod issues with yours, too. So you've seen it,

0:20:25that, and I agree with Marco, that I feel like the HomePod, the big HomePods were more

0:20:31stable. There was a really nice era of stability that I had with them last year, but that now

0:20:39things are really weird.

0:20:41It might have been completely rock solid since…

0:20:44Since you did the tvOS update?

0:20:45Yes.

0:20:46Yeah, but you've got them in that, you've got them locked as tvOS speakers, right?

0:20:50Yeah, I can play music on them whenever I want.

0:20:53Alright.

0:20:54to them, you know, like as you normally…

0:20:56Oh yeah, well, and talking to them is a different thing, right? Because then it's not airplay,

0:21:00then it's them playing for themselves and that would be the other argument is I could

0:21:05just forgo controlling my music on my Mac at all and just use voice, but I don't want

0:21:13to, like, I don't want to do that.

0:21:15Yeah, it's a shame because you can still, on iOS, you can still control them even if

0:21:21they're playing on their own but you can't do it on the Mac.

0:21:25Right, and I will also say the Sonos thing like there's a Sonos app on the Mac.

0:21:30I could go all in on controlling my and it's got Apple Music integration so I could go

0:21:34all in on controlling my stuff on the Mac using the Sonos app.

0:21:37The Sonos app is a weird app too.

0:21:39I don't really want to use it.

0:21:41I don't like its interface.

0:21:42It's kind of unpleasant.

0:21:43It is more stable with the Sonos speakers than using AirPlay.

0:21:47There's no doubt about it.

0:21:48But again, I don't wanna, right?

0:21:51I wanna use the music app on my Mac.

0:21:53- Like it feels like what the Mac music app needs

0:21:56is something like the Spotify Connect thing,

0:22:00where Spotify Connect, you can just tell

0:22:03any connected device, play whatever I'm asking you to do,

0:22:08but it's not streaming it to it.

0:22:10It's pulling it from the web.

0:22:12- If I were giving advice to somebody at Apple

0:22:14who's involved with this stuff,

0:22:15which I guess technically I am,

0:22:17because I am a person on a podcast,

0:22:19but probably not with a direct line.

0:22:22Anyway, my advice would be a version of what you just said,

0:22:25which is you need an airplane mode

0:22:29in the music app on the Mac that just says,

0:22:33use this as my speakers, and that is solid.

0:22:38The challenge is you can go to the airplane icon

0:22:42and choose an airplane speaker and say, okay, here we go.

0:22:47And it is persistent across quits unless it goes through its thing where it

0:22:51decides that it can't, you press play and it goes, I can't find it.

0:22:54And then you press play again and it goes, now I can find it. Yeah. Which is,

0:22:58you know, great. Um, so that if,

0:23:03if you get in a mode where I can say, look, these are my speakers,

0:23:05always play to them. And now I'm playing to them. I would be happy.

0:23:10The problem is that that very basic scenario

0:23:16doesn't work. It just doesn't work reliably. It is really frustrating to me as somebody

0:23:23who listens to music on my Mac all the time and wants to embrace airplay because I really

0:23:28like the fact that I can put speakers on the far walls of my office. I can get really nice

0:23:34stereo separation. It's really quite pleasant. And in fact, getting speakers off my desk

0:23:39also means my desk doesn't vibrate when something is vibrating in the music, right? I like it.

0:23:43I can play things louder without it bugging me.

0:23:48But I can't.

0:23:49I mean, I'm doing it, but I'm suffering and I get frustrated because multiple times a

0:23:54day I have to click on the little AirPlay thing and like go back to my...

0:23:58It's like it's playing, but I can't hear anything.

0:24:00And then I click on iMac speakers and then it starts to play, even though it said it

0:24:05was playing before, but it's playing nothing to no one.

0:24:09And then I have to click back and maybe it will go...

0:24:12Sometimes I also get in a position where it's playing to multiple speakers.

0:24:15I've had several hilarious moments where the Sonos's and the HomePod Mini's are all playing,

0:24:20which I guess is a thing you could do.

0:24:22You could get that quadraphonic sound of four little speakers in two stereo pairs playing

0:24:27at once.

0:24:28But it's not what I want.

0:24:29It's not what I'm trying to do.

0:24:30It's just I end up there because the AirPlay experience is so frustrating.

0:24:34This week's episode is brought to you in part by ZocDoc.

0:24:38When you need a doctor, you need a doctor now.

0:24:40Not in a few days, not in a few weeks, and definitely not in a few months.

0:24:44If you need to see an MD ASAP, you need ZocDoc.

0:24:47Just download the free ZocDoc app, which is the easiest way to find a great doctor and

0:24:52instantly book an appointment.

0:24:53With ZocDoc you can search for local doctors who take your insurance, read verified patient

0:24:58reviews and book an appointment in person or via video chat so you never have to wait

0:25:03on hold of a receptionist again.

0:25:05Whether you need a primary care physician, a dentist, a dermatologist, a psychiatrist

0:25:09and iDoctor or many other specialists, ZocDoc has you covered. Go to ZocDoc.com/upgradefm

0:25:17and download the ZocDoc app to sign up for free. Every month millions of people use ZocDoc.

0:25:22And it's pretty simple, why? Like when I want to see a doctor or a specialist or something

0:25:27like that, one thing is I never really know where to start. Like where do you go to find

0:25:31these people? How do you know if they're any good? How long are we going to have to wait

0:25:33for treatment? And what I think is super cool about ZocDoc is that you get this information,

0:25:37get that all there right at your fingertips it's easier to find someone. This is the way

0:25:41healthcare should be working in the modern day and especially the wait time thing. That

0:25:45can be such a problem so this is super cool.

0:25:47ZocDoc makes healthcare easy and now is the time to prioritize your health. Go to ZocDoc.com/upgradefm

0:25:54and download the ZocDoc app to sign up for free and book a top rated doctor. Many are

0:25:59available as soon as today at ZOCDOC.com/upgradefm. Our thanks to ZocDoc for their support of

0:26:07this show and relay FM. Zedd means Z. Yeah Zedd or Zee, whichever you prefer.

0:26:13Apple have announced to employees that they are once again pushing back their

0:26:17return to the office plan and they are now expecting this to be February at the

0:26:22earliest. They had mentioned before I think January was the plan with a one

0:26:26month notice so now they're saying February and it will be the notice is now

0:26:30but could be February could be later but won't be expected to be any earlier.

0:26:36For month 1, employees will be expected to be back in the office 2 days a week.

0:26:44From March it will be Monday, Tuesday and Thursday for the majority of employees.

0:26:50Apple is going to increase remote work allowance from 2 weeks to 4 weeks a year.

0:27:04Some employees will have different requirements if their work needs more in person time.

0:27:07There will be some members of different teams that will have to be in every single day.

0:27:11Hardware engineering.

0:27:12Yeah.

0:27:13And design, I'm sure, is another one.

0:27:15Probably, yeah.

0:27:16All of that kind of stuff.

0:27:17Apple has not yet, on top of this, mandated vaccinations that are in place.

0:27:22A bunch of tech companies have done this.

0:27:24Apple has not yet done this.

0:27:26It's unknown if they will require this when people are expected to be back in the office.

0:27:32Frankly, I am a bit surprised about that,

0:27:35that this hasn't become a thing that they've mentioned

0:27:38or have not already required.

0:27:41Yeah, so this is where they are.

0:27:42This is a bit better, right?

0:27:44They've doubled their remote work allowance

0:27:48from two to four weeks.

0:27:50It's better than two weeks.

0:27:51It's, I would understand many people would say,

0:27:54still not enough.

0:27:54There'll be a lot of people now, as we said before,

0:27:57that have spent this last two years working from home

0:28:00have realized that they don't need to be in the office for their job and would like the

0:28:03ability to not be in the office for their job, but that seems to not be a thing that

0:28:08Apple's doing. I will say I'm at least happy. One of the things we were saying is we want

0:28:12them to listen to their employees. They have shown that they've listened. They've come

0:28:16up with something that maybe still isn't good enough, but they at least I think have shown

0:28:20that they understand that people thought that the two weeks wasn't enough. We'll see. What

0:28:26is your read on this?

0:28:27Well, I'll throw in too in terms of listening to the employees something that that is a development that I think

0:28:32So we should for who's to be at the verge

0:28:34but now is it NBC News reported that they had a memo that basically said you can talk about your

0:28:39You can talk about your compensation and your feelings about Apple and we can't tell you not to and that can be public and it

0:28:45Was an interesting sort of moment of Apple saying we can't we can't

0:28:49We can't legally stop you

0:28:52But I think that that's an interesting

0:28:57interesting little thing. I hope I'm characterizing that right. But the idea there is that there's,

0:29:01there's a little more understanding of, uh, what's that Zoe's thing? I don't know. I'm not finding

0:29:08the, uh, I'm not finding the link now. Hmm. Well, it's live podcast updating. So that's,

0:29:14that's what happens. Anyway, my understanding is that, um, that they're, they acknowledged

0:29:20that discussion of employee issues is allowed. And, and that's interesting. I mean,

0:29:27whether that makes any difference remains to be seen.

0:29:29But I thought that was like an interesting moment too,

0:29:32where Apple is doing this bend, but not break strategy,

0:29:35right, which is like, yeah, we'll listen,

0:29:37but you're still gonna do what we say, but we'll listen,

0:29:39which I mean, that's a management choice.

0:29:41I think they're showing some flexibility here.

0:29:45Obviously you and I have been very strong,

0:29:50I guess, advocates for the idea

0:29:52that not all work needs to be in person.

0:29:54and that Apple is perhaps gonna lose good people

0:29:59because they're so limited

0:30:02and they've always been this way

0:30:04where there are a lot of parts of Apple

0:30:06where they're like, no, no, you have to be in a desk

0:30:10at a computer in Cupertino.

0:30:12And that's where this job is because of reasons,

0:30:16because of history, because of collaboration,

0:30:17because of whatever.

0:30:19And that after two years,

0:30:21you would think that certain parts of that business

0:30:23realize they actually get along just fine and they don't need to be in person.

0:30:27And what happens when people don't need to be in person is it's not just that people

0:30:30with Silicon Valley jobs can move out of Silicon Valley where the commutes are terrible and

0:30:33the cost of living is awful.

0:30:34It also means that Apple can hire really talented people who will never move to California or

0:30:40wherever their offices are that they're hiring for.

0:30:42They have a bigger base.

0:30:44So I think Apple is actually stronger when it comes to jobs that don't need to be in

0:30:48person.

0:30:49That's the argument, right?

0:30:51What job needs to be in person?

0:30:53But I would argue that there are lots of jobs, and I know this from personal experience,

0:30:57talking to people, there are lots of jobs at Apple that are sitting at a desk looking

0:31:00at a computer and collaborating using a Slack channel or something that don't need to be

0:31:08in Cupertino where it's incredibly expensive to live and yet those jobs are there because

0:31:16of those reasons.

0:31:17So I think by doing it this way and saying you can work from home a little bit, they're

0:31:23addressing some of the kind of work-life balance issues of like we don't need to be in the

0:31:27office every day and we know you have a long commute and we know that you've got kids at

0:31:32home and things like that.

0:31:33And I think in isolation as a humane policy, I think it's good.

0:31:39My problem with it is there's another aspect here which is jobs that should probably not

0:31:47need physical offices and the proof is the pandemic that they have happened fine without.

0:31:54Now again, I'm not saying all of them have, but there are some certainly that could be remote

0:31:59forever. So I think, I mean, and again, they don't want to make a blanket policy. So it may be that

0:32:06very slowly in the background, those groups that don't need to be in person are made remote groups,

0:32:14but it's not a blanket policy and it just sort of happens.

0:32:17I do think that by making this policy the way that they have, the risk is that they're

0:32:24going to turn people off, but I think the reality is going to be that person by person,

0:32:30whether it's retaining an existing employee or it's a new hire, Apple's policies here

0:32:37will still change.

0:32:39they will be eroded person by person, group by group, star by star, as they realize that

0:32:47if they want this person, they're going to not be able to hire them and make them move

0:32:52to Cupertino. But they really want them. And well, you know, we saw in the pandemic, this

0:32:58person doesn't actually need to be here. And that's, or this person, we really want to

0:33:02retain this person, but they don't want to live in the Bay Area anymore. And their job

0:33:05doesn't really need to be here. So I mean, that happened. I had people at Macworld move

0:33:10and we kept paying them and they kept doing their job and it was great, right? That's

0:33:17not quite, I mean, the truth is that barring some real conversion on the part of Apple

0:33:23Supper Management, that's how the change happens. And I think it is going to happen. I think

0:33:27that the pandemic has fundamentally changed how a lot of people view these kinds of jobs.

0:33:31I think that for companies like Apple to retain talent, they're going to have to make exceptions.

0:33:37They'll be forced to be flexible.

0:33:39And eventually the exceptions will become the rule, which is, "Oh, you'll turn around

0:33:44in five years and realize that that group that used to have an office at Infinite Loop

0:33:52is remote now." And it'll just happen like that. But I think it will happen regardless

0:33:59because otherwise they're going to lose too much talent and fail to acquire new talent

0:34:04and that's just the truth of it.

0:34:06So you were remembering correctly it was the second Zoetia first story at NBC News where

0:34:12Apple have sent out another memo saying our policies do not restrict employees from speaking

0:34:18freely about their wages, hours or working conditions. We encourage any employee of concerns

0:34:23to raise them in the way they feel most comfortable internally or externally including through

0:34:27their manager, any Apple manager, people support, people business partner, or business conduct.

0:34:32And we also have a link to a Bloomberg article that says that Cher Scarlett, who was one

0:34:36of the people who was involved in this movement, is leaving Apple but reached a settlement

0:34:41with them, and that regarding a complaint she made with the National Labor Relations

0:34:46Board. So these things are probably connected, right? Which is Apple reacted in a very aggressive

0:34:52way toward employee criticism and discussion about Apple and then was reminded that there

0:34:57are certain things that people are allowed to do and sent out a memo saying, "Okay,

0:35:03just to clarify, probably a condition of the settlement." You have rights.

0:35:07I mean, I cannot for a moment assume that all of Apple forgot this existed, right? Like

0:35:14there are legal people that knew about this, right? Or like people in some people in HR

0:35:18it knew about this, but it may have been a selection of overzealous managers who were

0:35:22forcing people not to talk, right?

0:35:25Or not aware. I think that happens a lot in business. There are the people who are aware

0:35:30of employment law and the rights of the employees, and then there are managers who think that

0:35:34they own their employees.

0:35:35Then there are the managers, which by and large are not those people, right? Because

0:35:38that's not what they do, right? So that can be the issue. There's something I wanted to

0:35:42bring up, which I found kind of weird. The fact that they're going to make everyone be

0:35:46in the office on the same days. It's like Wednesday and Friday Apple Park will be a

0:35:50ghost town and I don't understand the thinking behind that. Like one of the reasons you do

0:35:56this kind of thing is that you spread out your employees a bit.

0:36:01Yeah the idea that you do have meetings so you want to have common meeting days I get

0:36:06that, but I wonder if within different groups you could say well we're not going to do Monday,

0:36:09Tuesday, Thursday, we're going to do Tuesday, Thursday, Friday and you know and other people

0:36:15People are like, "We love Wednesdays. We're going to do Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday," or

0:36:19whatever. Although Apple has structured this in a way that you can't take a long weekend.

0:36:24Again, they're trying to structure this in a certain way. But I agree, it is a little

0:36:28bit weird. But I think in practice, again, they are making a blanket policy here, but

0:36:33it's an enormous company and it would not surprise me if that within individual groups,

0:36:39there's more variation, but that's not the policy. But you're right. If the goal here

0:36:44is to spread out your employees so there's a little less employee density during an ongoing

0:36:48pandemic, that this doesn't do that. But alright, I guess you can clean the pool on Wednesday.

0:36:57Apple also announced the Self Service Repair Program last week, which is a program that

0:37:04Apple will be selling to individuals, parts and tools so they can make their own repairs

0:37:10on their devices, starting with iPhone 12 and 13 lines, and later on M1 MacBooks.

0:37:18This will begin in early 2022 in the US, rolling out into different territories and potentially

0:37:24different products throughout the year.

0:37:27What do you think about this?

0:37:29I think I actually recycled that Princess Bride quote from last week about getting used

0:37:35to disappointment when I talked to Micah about this on TechNews Weekly last week because

0:37:42I think that we get this news about Apple changing and we're like, "Ah, Apple changed.

0:37:49It's going to be so much different."

0:37:50And it's always, it's a little bit like my thing about how you get excited about a product

0:37:53and then you got to add money to how much it's going to cost because it's always going

0:37:57to disappoint you.

0:37:58It's a little like that which is like it's never going to be quite as liberal a policy

0:38:01as you would like it to be.

0:38:02It's going to be a little narrower and it's not going to change the world as much as you

0:38:06want it to be, but it's a positive step.

0:38:09Apple has been taking these positive steps to get its manuals and its parts in the hands

0:38:13of independent service people, independent service companies, and now individuals on

0:38:18top of that.

0:38:20Is it going to be something that everybody's going to want to do?

0:38:23No.

0:38:24Will there be...

0:38:25I see two scenarios here.

0:38:26One scenario is the thing that is also true about the independent businesses that do repairs

0:38:33and stuff, which is a lot of people don't live anywhere near an Apple store.

0:38:38I'm fortunate enough to live one exit on the freeway away from an Apple store, but there's

0:38:43a guy there who spots me and knows who I am, which is very nice.

0:38:48I need one of those people right now.

0:38:50I got a hole in my t-shirt and I'm wearing a hat because I haven't showered yet and there's

0:38:54somebody who's like, "Jason, I don't know."

0:38:56I grew up in rural California.

0:39:00A lot of people live nowhere near an independent repair shop, let alone an Apple store.

0:39:08Maybe they've got an independent repair shop.

0:39:10That's good if you do.

0:39:11But there are a lot of people who live nowhere near, like hours drive away from help.

0:39:19I think it's good that Apple is providing access to people who do repairs, but also

0:39:23now to individuals because sometimes that's the best option is help me.

0:39:28I just need to do this and I'm not gonna I don't have the time to drive two hours away.

0:39:34Leave my phone not have a phone drive two hours back then spend days without a phone

0:39:40and then two hours drive and like it's not practical and I know there's like mail in

0:39:45there's mail in service and stuff you can do too but it's not it's not ideal and you're

0:39:50potentially without your device for some amount of time. The second category is people who

0:39:56are comfortable with tech stuff like this, and I guess that would be you and me.

0:39:59I'd give it a go, for sure. I would give it a go.

0:40:02Depends on how hairy it is. So my experience with this is not -- I mean, back in the day

0:40:07I did computer stuff, back when computers were a little more open, but my experience

0:40:11now is with stuff I fix in my house. It's like appliances and stuff, where there's YouTube

0:40:17videos that say, "Okay, here's how you do this." And, you know, I've had this experience

0:40:20multiple times where something breaks in an appliance in my house. I figure out what the

0:40:24broken thing is. I order the part on the internet. The part shows up. I look at the YouTube video

0:40:30and I fix my appliance. Yeah, I did it with my washing machine, did it with my dishwasher,

0:40:34did it with my refrigerator. It's great because I would have previously had to try and find

0:40:39a repair person and wait and spend a lot of money and maybe they would show up and sometimes

0:40:44Sometimes they call and say, "Well, no, we're not going to service that particular brand

0:40:48and you have to be back at Square Run."

0:40:51It's really frustrating and I map that experience to this a little bit and think, "Well, now,

0:40:57if you are so inclined or you don't have any other options, you will be able to get the

0:41:02part from Apple and get the tools and get the instructions and probably, if not already,

0:41:09very soon, watch the video on YouTube.

0:41:11We're a very friendly guy in Nebraska."

0:41:14I think it's the KitchenAid mixer guy in Nebraska, or maybe he's in Oklahoma.

0:41:17I did a KitchenAid mixer thing too, right?

0:41:20Very friendly guy who all he does is fix KitchenAid mixers in Oklahoma and like you'll find that

0:41:26video and he'll be like, "Hey everybody, we're going to replace this iPhone 13 Apple screen

0:41:33with the official Apple repair and here's how it works."

0:41:38Some people are going to be like, "Oh Lord, no.

0:41:39I'm never going to want to do that."

0:41:41Other people are going to be like, "Great.

0:41:43That's what I want."

0:41:4450 bucks by returning my old screen or whatever. Fantastic. Let's do it. So I think it's great.

0:41:50I think it's not earth shattering in the same way that maybe people had hoped, but I think it shows

0:41:55you a trend of Apple being more open to this kind of thing. I do think it speaks to the more

0:42:02advanced or stable era we're in with smartphones and with all our devices where

0:42:13There was a period where every single iPhone was engineered with zero tolerances because

0:42:21they were in an arms race with Google and they were inventing the stuff as they went

0:42:26and we're kind of out of that now.

0:42:28So I think that there's a little more comfort factor in terms of doing this stuff.

0:42:32And I think that also means Apple has also realized how much, how expensive it is to

0:42:37service its own hardware even in Apple repair and Apple care and is is also sort of slowly

0:42:45making if you look at the iFixit teardown of the MacBook Pro for example there's I think

0:42:50slowly making their products more repairable when they can.

0:42:54Yeah they put poor tabs on the batteries now which is which is actually quite a big deal.

0:42:58Because never forget the number one repairer of Apple stuff is Apple and that means that

0:43:04if they have to repair something that's under warranty, they got to eat the price of the

0:43:07repair and they got to eat the labor of the repair.

0:43:12So Apple is motivated within limits to make their products a little more repairable and

0:43:18I think that we're starting to see that too.

0:43:20So I think it's good news.

0:43:23I don't think it's earth-shattering news but I think it's good news and I'm not sure I

0:43:28would ever do this but I might.

0:43:29I mean, I'm more interested in the Mac side

0:43:32and they're starting with the iPhone,

0:43:33but like I've bought the third party batteries

0:43:36and try to put them in and all of that.

0:43:37And like, would I do Apple approved battery repair

0:43:41of my MacBook Air down the road?

0:43:44I would seriously consider that, right?

0:43:46I would feel very comfortable doing that

0:43:48'cause I've done it before.

0:43:50And I might like the fact that it was all kind of like

0:43:52under the auspices of Apple and that Apple had approved it.

0:43:55- Also, you know, just, I know you,

0:43:57I'm sure you're aware of this,

0:43:58but just to have a full conversation on it.

0:44:01This is also getting out ahead of potential right to repair

0:44:04or just legislation, right?

0:44:06- For sure.

0:44:07- It helps them to expand it

0:44:09because for all the reasons you mentioned,

0:44:11they are genuine reasons.

0:44:13And I'm sure we're in the pro column,

0:44:15but another one in the pro column was,

0:44:17let's not get governments on our case about something else

0:44:20that is actually easier for us to fix.

0:44:23And I actually think it goes a long way.

0:44:27I think a lot of people that were anti-Apple

0:44:29on the right to repair stance,

0:44:32it was focused around Apple just wants to

0:44:34gouge every dollar out of you.

0:44:36They want you to pay for expensive repairs

0:44:38and or they want your product to break

0:44:41so you'll buy a new one.

0:44:43And I think that this shows that that's not the case so much

0:44:47because they are very protective of the App Store, right?

0:44:51We've been talking about it for months now.

0:44:53They are in so much more trouble

0:44:56and they will not let it go, but with this,

0:44:59they're just letting it go.

0:45:00And considering how much more money they make in iPhones

0:45:03than services right now,

0:45:05I think that is a pretty clear indication

0:45:07that the amount of people that buy new devices

0:45:11just because they broke an old one,

0:45:12I think shows, I would say that Apple would believe

0:45:15it would be pretty slim.

0:45:16- And like I said, I think it's more

0:45:18extenuating circumstances that repairability

0:45:20has just not been a priority with them.

0:45:22- Yes.

0:45:22- And that they've been more worried about

0:45:24the building of them and getting them out there and the cost of the parts and getting

0:45:28all the parts to fit.

0:45:29And making them look as good as they possibly can.

0:45:31Right, look as good, be as thin and light and all of those things.

0:45:35But I do think that these products have matured now too and so they've got a little more

0:45:40room to try and say, you know, you realize how much money we lose every time we have

0:45:45to fix a phone under warranty.

0:45:47Can we do something about that?

0:45:48And maybe for five years they're like, no, no, no, no, no, no, no.

0:45:51And now they're like, yeah, okay, we can make it more repairable.

0:45:54we can put that on our priority list too.

0:45:56- And like the maturity thing is also in the,

0:45:58you know, the phones get a little bit thicker now

0:46:00for bigger batteries and stuff like that

0:46:01'cause there's just less of a requirement

0:46:03to continue going down the same paths.

0:46:07- You mentioned right to repair.

0:46:08The other motivator here, I think,

0:46:09in terms of external factors, in terms of like the PR,

0:46:12is Apple's commitment to the environment.

0:46:14Like the making disposable things

0:46:18is not environmentally friendly.

0:46:20And they can talk about they've got a machine

0:46:22disassembles them and all of those things but you know what really is

0:46:27environmentally friendly is not having to buy a new phone because you can fix

0:46:32your broken phone not having to throw away a motherboard because everything is

0:46:35attached to the motherboard and without it you can't you can't you see you just

0:46:40have to oh we got to replace the whole thing right that's not environmentally

0:46:44friendly and I think that that is something that Apple legitimately cares

0:46:48about as a company but was in conflict with the other priorities that they had

0:46:52So that again not alone in driving a decision like this or a direction that they're going

0:46:59But I think it's one other thing on the pile in terms of weighing how they approach this is it is

0:47:05because you know they can get Lisa Jackson up there on the roof and all that but like if you if you make your

0:47:10Products so that when they break you have to throw them away

0:47:13And I know that they can be recycled and all that but just on a simple level

0:47:17If there's a part that broke and you could fix it and keep using it or you could dispose of it

0:47:22Even if you've got the best recycling system in the world

0:47:26It's not as effective as fixing the product in terms of the environment

0:47:32the best thing to do is to keep that phone in circulation and

0:47:35Hand it down to somebody else and that might lose you a sale in the short term

0:47:41But Tim Cook has extolled the virtues of the long life of their products and how it increases their install base

0:47:47time and again. So it does fit in with that part of the philosophy to do something like

0:47:52this. So I think that that's the environmental stuff is also a part of it where they were

0:47:56not really walking the walk with this with this stuff. Now it remains to be seen like

0:48:01if push comes to shove and Apple has to make a decision do I worry about repairability

0:48:05or do I worry about making this product you know that we absolutely have to make whatever

0:48:10the reason behind that is they're going to go for the product. But I feel like they're

0:48:14in a place now with the iPhone where they feel less pressure to do that.

0:48:19This episode is brought to you by our very good friends over at Memberful, the easiest

0:48:23way to sell memberships to your audience used by the biggest creators on the web. You can

0:48:28generate sustainable recurring income while diversifying your revenue stream. Maybe your

0:48:33business's financial situation has changed in the past couple of years and now you need

0:48:37a proven solution that's quick to launch so you can stabilize your business and grow.

0:48:42Memberful handles all of the hard stuff so you can focus on what you do best while earning

0:48:46revenue quickly, while leaving you with full control and ownership of everything that relates

0:48:50to your audience, brand and membership.

0:48:53Memberful has everything you need to run your own membership program, including an optimised

0:48:57checkout, Apple Pay, easy member management, dashboard analytics, free trials, gift subscriptions

0:49:02and more.

0:49:03And Memberful seamlessly integrates with the tools that you already use, including lots

0:49:08of fully managed integrations with the most popular services like WordPress, MailChimp,

0:49:12Discord and tons more.

0:49:15And now you can send paid email newsletters directly through Membrful without needing

0:49:19to connect to a third party email provider.

0:49:21You can even publish your paid newsletter content to a Membrful hosted members only

0:49:25website and there's no additional fee when signed up for Membrful's pro or premium

0:49:30plans plus you'll save money compared to other popular hosted newsletter platforms.

0:49:35So we are big users of Member4 here at Relay FM.

0:49:38We have all of our membership stuff runs through them and they have been absolutely amazing

0:49:42for us over the last couple of years as we have expanded our offerings.

0:49:45So Upgrade Plus for example, if you go to getupgradeplus.com you can sign up and that's

0:49:49all Member4 powered which is fantastic.

0:49:52And we have just started using their email newsletter thing.

0:49:54So we had previously we were using a third party that integrated with Member4 so we could

0:49:59send that out.

0:50:00But now we got it all in house.

0:50:02We don't need to have all of that system to manage over there.

0:50:05We don't need to pay the fees for another company to do all that stuff.

0:50:08And now we're using Membrful's email newsletter system and it's absolutely fantastic.

0:50:12It's one of the things we love about Membrful is over time they're giving more and more

0:50:16and more to us and we have many more features that we're going to be taking advantage of

0:50:19over the next couple of weeks as well.

0:50:22Get started for free at membrful.com/upgrade with no credit card required.

0:50:27That's membrful.com/upgrade.

0:50:29there right now and check it out and see what it could do for your business. Our thanks

0:50:33to Memefool for their support of this show and Relay FM.

0:50:36We're going to come back to the rarely used segment, Upshift, where we talk about Apple's

0:50:44car project. Jason's doing donuts in the studio over there. Mark Germen reporting for

0:50:53Bloomberg. Okay. In recent years, Apple have been exploring two paths when it comes to

0:50:58their car project. One is limited self driving, this is like features that we see on many

0:51:03modern cars, think of your Tesla autopilot or you know like automatic cruise control

0:51:08and lane guidance and all that kind of stuff. Or full self driving that requires no human

0:51:14intervention. They have refocused their efforts on the latter, so Apple is now aiming for

0:51:21their car project to be a full self driving car as the goal, that is what they want the

0:51:26product to be. Kevin Lynch is now leading the team. Kevin Lynch came over to Apple to

0:51:33run the Apple Watch project. Did a good job there. But this makes Lynch the fifth person

0:51:39in charge of this team in the last seven years.

0:51:42Oh no, Kevin Lynch, what have you done? What did you do to anger them that they put you

0:51:46in charge of this thing?

0:51:48Or do they want Kevin to leave? I don't know because everyone seems to leave. They've had

0:51:52people retire.

0:51:53Yeah, Kevin, congratulations. We think the world of you were putting you in this thankless task. Okay, good luck

0:51:59Well, maybe it is what what it probably seems to be or like it the other option is they're struggling with this project

0:52:04They need someone for proven track record internal because they brought in some external hires to run this and stuff. It hasn't the real

0:52:09Internal to get this take it across the finish line right like like Kevin did with the Apple watch

0:52:15Yep

0:52:16quote from Mark Gurman Apple's ideal car would have no steering wheel and pedals and its interior will be

0:52:22be designed around hands-off driving. They have discussed equipping the car of an emergency

0:52:27takeover mode.

0:52:28Okay, let's stop right there. I'm sorry, do we have to say, "Hey car, stop because I can't

0:52:36stop it myself"? Here's the thing, self-driving as a goal is great.

0:52:42Sounds great. Future. Sounds amazing.

0:52:46And Germin's report talks about how they're building a processor with a zillion neural

0:52:51engines in order to do this and it's going to run hot so they're worrying about cooling

0:52:56them. Like, folks, cars are really good at cooling. There are lots of hot things in cars.

0:53:01It'll be fine. Engines. Yeah, I mean, well, our engine is not that hot, but our processor

0:53:06is. It's like, we work it out. We'll put the radiator next to it. It'll be fine. So I'm

0:53:11not worried about that. I love the goal being full self-driving. Now, Google's waymo is

0:53:18trying to do it, Tesla's been trying to do it, Elon Musk keeps talking about full self-driving,

0:53:23they haven't figured it out. It's hard. It's really hard. I think it's a good goal. I think

0:53:29obviously though, the way, let's assume that something resembling full self-driving does

0:53:36eventually exist. It's hard to imagine that it's not going to be in stages where it's

0:53:43like well on freeways in California and then eventually everywhere it'll work.

0:53:50So when you're on the freeway you can now put it into full self-drive and lean back

0:53:55and relax and do not have to worry at all.

0:53:59It is going to be completely safe.

0:54:02That's a big leap by the way but I could see that as a first step.

0:54:05And then the next step is going to be like at certain times of day or in certain areas

0:54:10that are super mapped and we've got all the knowledge, you will be able to summon your

0:54:15car and have it come to you or tell it to go somewhere and it'll drive you there. And

0:54:20then over time it will grow and it will grow and maybe someday you'll be able to, that

0:54:26all cars will be able to drive themselves everywhere. Probably not.

0:54:29I don't even think this is a maybe someday thing. I think this is an inevitability at

0:54:33some point in the future.

0:54:35On an infinite time scale, maybe. Although even then you would probably need what this

0:54:39story says is like emergency takeover mode in case you get your wheel gets stuck or something

0:54:44like that right where it's like oh no the computer doesn't know what to do.

0:54:47At first.

0:54:48But here's the problem.

0:54:49This report saying that their ideal car would have no steering wheel and pedals.

0:54:56Okay.

0:54:57No one's gonna buy that car.

0:54:58It doesn't necessarily mean that there wouldn't be controls.

0:55:01You might be able to control it with a touchscreen or something or a joystick.

0:55:05I don't know.

0:55:06Not a steering wheel and pedals.

0:55:07But this is where this report runs off the road and into a ditch, which is, I am open

0:55:17to the idea of self-driving.

0:55:20And he's saying 2025 is their target date for this car.

0:55:24I am not open to the idea that self-driving will be so foolproof that you won't need

0:55:28controls in your car.

0:55:32Not to be too aggressive here about this, but let me put it this way.

0:55:37this is what I said on six colors this I want to call this kind of idea like a

0:55:42moonshot except for one thing which is the other guy who's trying to do this is

0:55:47literally trying to send people to the moon shot and that's gonna happen this

0:55:51decade this isn't so I like it's I maybe it's just a goal like what if we had no

0:56:00steering wheel and pedals what if we built it that way but I am telling you

0:56:03you, if Apple doesn't want to do a car unless it doesn't have a steering wheel and pedals

0:56:10or other like user controls, Apple will never ship a car. Period. Never this decade, let's

0:56:18say. Never in the next 10 years will ship a car.

0:56:21So Apple are targeting this project to be within the next five years, I think. Or within

0:56:28the next, I think it's within the next five years, I believe. I'll check this out. For

0:56:32for some reason I didn't pull this out.

0:56:34- Targeting I think 2025 is what they said,

0:56:37which is really soon.

0:56:40- Even if it works, right?

0:56:43Let's imagine it works.

0:56:45Like they have created the technology

0:56:48and Apple can have built a car

0:56:50which unbelievably fully self-drives

0:56:52everywhere on the planet.

0:56:54People would not buy a car in four years from now

0:56:58that does not have a steering wheel.

0:57:00- I think you're right,

0:57:01but I don't think it even gets to that point.

0:57:03Because my point here is,

0:57:05I'm not as negative on full self-driving

0:57:07as some people are, John Siracusa.

0:57:09I think that there are levels of it

0:57:12that are probably gonna happen

0:57:14and even happen pretty soon.

0:57:15Even like Tesla, I think that Tesla will ultimately

0:57:18get to the point where they feel confident

0:57:22in saying you can be on the freeway

0:57:25and the car is gonna do the right thing.

0:57:27It'll probably take them a lot longer than they expect.

0:57:29But I think it will happen at some point

0:57:30some degree in certain locations, in certain situations will be drivable. I'm not 100%

0:57:38confident but I'm like, I think that'll probably happen. But it is an enormous leap to say

0:57:44we don't need controls anymore because it's all going to be so good in so many places.

0:57:48And we'll have a little emergency thing that, I don't know, is that like a little steering

0:57:52wheel like pops out of the dash in case of an emergency and the lights go red and now

0:57:56you're in weird driving mode. It seems like a fantasy to me. So I read this German article

0:58:03and I think to myself, "Well, that's interesting." And then I get to this point and I'm like,

0:58:06"Well, that's never going to happen." It's a Mark German report. Maybe it's aspirational.

0:58:14But I look at this and I think, "If you're motivating your employees and be like, 'We

0:58:18want to build this so good that you don't need a steering wheel,' that's fine. But

0:58:21if you really think you're going to make a car and sell it and it's not going to

0:58:24have controls because your full self-driving is going to be so good that people don't

0:58:28need controls. You're, you're, you're, it's a fantasy. It's just a fantasy. It's

0:58:34ridiculous. Come on. It's ridiculous. So I don't know. I don't know what to say.

0:58:38As somebody who's been sort of like neutral on the Apple car, I look at this story and

0:58:42like part of the story makes me think, oh, maybe they'll be able to pull this off.

0:58:46And then I get to that part and I think this is a joke.

0:58:48I think I agree with you actually. Uh, just to continue and then we've got a little bit

0:58:53I've got a little bit more I want to say on that.

0:58:54Naturally, an Apple car product would feature touch screens

0:58:57to be heavily integrated

0:58:58with its existing range of products and services, right?

0:59:01It's said that, as you mentioned,

0:59:02they've finished the groundwork for a CPU,

0:59:05and they're actually planning to equip

0:59:06a current fleet of Lexus vehicles

0:59:09that they're using for testing with this CPU,

0:59:11they're gonna retrofit.

0:59:13And Apple are continuing to hire lots of people

0:59:15from all across the auto industry to make this project work.

0:59:19So one of the things for me,

0:59:22like building on what you were saying,

0:59:24is I'm not sure that any company could all of a sudden

0:59:28offer this kind of product, a self-driving product.

0:59:30Forget the wheel.

0:59:31Imagine they put a wheel and pedals in it, right?

0:59:33- Sure.

0:59:33- Or like, you know, the wheel and pedals

0:59:35are hidden behind the dashboard and you press a button

0:59:38and they come out and you're in emergency mode, right?

0:59:39- It's like the Batmobile, yeah, exactly.

0:59:42- Even if like all of this existed, like, and worked,

0:59:48I just can't imagine people would buy Apple's product.

0:59:52And actually, I don't even think it's possible for Apple

0:59:54to all of a sudden be like,

0:59:56here's our full self-driving car.

0:59:58Because like a company like Tesla would be first

1:00:02to be able to do something that is in theory

1:00:04because they already have hundreds of thousands of cars

1:00:07driving on real roads collecting data for them.

1:00:11Apple currently have 69 Lexuses driving in California.

1:00:16- Yeah, this is the,

1:00:19I think this is one of the big questions,

1:00:20which is Apple's MO is don't ship it until it's ready

1:00:24and don't do your research in public.

1:00:27I mean, they do ship it eventually

1:00:29and then obviously like the first Apple Watch

1:00:30was very limited and then they iterate.

1:00:32But there's this feeling philosophically at Apple

1:00:35that there are certain products that are so early

1:00:38in the lifespan of the technology

1:00:40that you can't subject the public to it

1:00:43and you can't charge them for it.

1:00:45And this is when we talk about the AR stuff,

1:00:48AR and VR stuff.

1:00:49That's why we came up with our idea that the first one will be more like a developer kit,

1:00:53is because they may not want to subject the public to this thing, or subject the product

1:01:00to the scrutiny of something that's not really ready and doesn't really fulfill all of Apple's

1:01:04goals, but you've got to start somewhere.

1:01:07The challenge is, with the car, that I think you're right, you kind of do need to learn

1:01:14a lot out in public.

1:01:17And I don't know if Apple could pull off just saying, "Well, our test cars are now

1:01:23at 100% and so here's the product.

1:01:25Enjoy!

1:01:26Here it is!"

1:01:28And first off, people are going to need to see it work and they're going to need to

1:01:32find trust with it, which is why I keep thinking the most likely scenario here is they will

1:01:36get to a point where they will think their technology stack is so amazing, including

1:01:40this processor, that they go to a partner and they either build a traditional electric

1:01:46car with a partner or something like that.

1:01:51- They have to partner with someone.

1:01:53- Right. - They have to partner

1:01:54with someone. - But it's hard to imagine

1:01:56that their first step is not getting a car body

1:02:00from essentially from another manufacturer

1:02:03and doing a special version of it

1:02:05that's got Apple's brains in it

1:02:07that is either branded as an Apple car

1:02:10or is branded as a Lexus with Apple inside.

1:02:14- So what you're saying is they're gonna make

1:02:16a Motorola rocker on wheels. No, because they would control the inside,

1:02:21it would be, you know, in a way that the rocker wasn't. But, but it is, although that's a

1:02:27terrifying, a Motorola rocker on wheels is terrifying, and don't even try to imagine

1:02:31what that would look like. It is, like that is the logical step, and I don't know whether

1:02:37they will get there or not, but clearly the first step if you're going to do Apple cars

1:02:42is to put it out there in something that's more like a traditional car and get time with

1:02:50it.

1:02:51And if that doesn't need to be an Apple branded car and it's more like an Apple brains inside

1:02:56this electric car from whoever the manufacturer is, that seems to be the next approach, which

1:03:01is why this report is so perplexing because it's talking about this.

1:03:06It's just, not to mix my transportation metaphors, but it's putting the cart before the horse.

1:03:10It is not the full self-driving horse.

1:03:13The cart before the self-driving horse, yes.

1:03:15Full self-riding.

1:03:16It is the end point.

1:03:20It is the end goal, not the beginning goal.

1:03:22The beginning goal has to be something that's less ambitious.

1:03:26Not saying kill your ambition, I'm saying start, be a little less ambitious because

1:03:32it's never going to happen if the way you get this product out there is with no controls

1:03:37in it.

1:03:38It's never going to happen.

1:03:39So be realistic.

1:03:40I'm all for setting goals.

1:03:41- Yes, but like writing this on a whiteboard

1:03:44in the design room, right?

1:03:45And it lives there.

1:03:46And it's like, it's like believe, right?

1:03:48Like this is what we are going for.

1:03:51But this is not version one.

1:03:54- No.

1:03:55- It's way too much.

1:03:57Way too, that's how it feels to me.

1:03:59I will never discount Apple's ability to surprise me, right?

1:04:03Like over the last, I don't know how many decades now

1:04:07I've been following this company.

1:04:08you know, maybe 15 years for me, right?

1:04:11They've always, every now and then,

1:04:13many times they have surprised me with their ability.

1:04:17But this is a big leap.

1:04:18This is a big, big leap.

1:04:20Because ultimately, an iPhone going wrong

1:04:24doesn't kill someone.

1:04:26- Yeah. (laughs)

1:04:28Yeah, I think, I wanna give, you know,

1:04:30Mark Gurman says, "Apple's ideal car."

1:04:33And the way he phrases it,

1:04:35it makes it sound like that's what they want,

1:04:37but it may very well be that it really is like,

1:04:40they know it's the ideal,

1:04:42and they know they're not gonna be able to do that,

1:04:45but they want it, you know,

1:04:46the way we motivate our engineers

1:04:48to work on this self-driving thing is,

1:04:49imagine if nobody ever needed to use a steering wheel.

1:04:52That's okay for motivation,

1:04:54but the way it reads in the German story

1:04:56is a little more like they might actually believe

1:04:58that they could do it,

1:04:59and if that's the case, it's a fantasy and it's ridiculous,

1:05:01but it may just be the believe sign, right?

1:05:04Like you said, every time they leave Apple Park

1:05:07on a Monday or a Wednesday or a Thursday,

1:05:10or what is it, Monday, Tuesday, Thursday?

1:05:12They leave and they tap the sign

1:05:15of the driverless Apple car on their way out.

1:05:17It's slightly askew, it has no steering wheel,

1:05:19they tap it and they go on their way.

1:05:21But the reality is gonna be a little different.

1:05:24- This episode is brought to you by DoorDash.

1:05:27Maybe you're hungry for Chinese tonight,

1:05:29you know, flatmate wants pizza,

1:05:30someone else is craving for you.

1:05:31Well, there's something for everyone on DoorDash

1:05:34because DoorDash connects you with the restaurants

1:05:37you love right now and right to your door. And you can also get the grocery essentials that you need

1:05:42DoorDash too. You can get your drinks, snacks and other household items delivered in under an hour.

1:05:48Ordering is super easy. You just open the DoorDash app, choose what you want from where you want it

1:05:52and your items will be left safely outside your door with the contactless delivery drop-off

1:05:57setting. With over 300,000 partners in the US, Puerto Rico, Canada and Australia, you can support

1:06:03your neighborhood go-tos, or choose from your favorite national restaurants like Popeyes,

1:06:08Chipotle, and the Cheesecake Factory. For a limited time, our listeners can get 25%

1:06:12off and zero delivery fees on their first order of $15 or more when you download the DoorDash app

1:06:18and enter the code UPGRADE2021 if you're in the US and UPGRADEAUS if you're in Australia.

1:06:23Jason, can you tell our listeners why they might want to do this? Why would people want

1:06:27to order with DoorDash? I'm going to give you a contrary example to my usual example. I'm going

1:06:32I'm going to say you are sitting at home and it's dinner time or it's just about to be

1:06:36dinner time and you do not want to leave the house. You have no energy. You hate everything.

1:06:41You're just hungry. Somebody please feed me and there's nobody there to feed you because

1:06:46the people who would make the food don't want to move off the couch. They're tired. They

1:06:50worked all day. They're miserable. Do you have an iPhone with you? Do you have an iPad

1:06:54with you? Do you have a web browser of some kind with you? That's the beauty of DoorDash.

1:06:57You can go there and say like, "Well, what kind of food do we want?" And then in my neighborhood

1:07:01But what I end up with is like a list of restaurants that offer it and you can view how long it

1:07:06will be until they can get you food.

1:07:09Find the shortest amount of time, go to that restaurant, check a bunch of boxes and somebody

1:07:14brings you food and you never had to leave the house.

1:07:17And you know that happens sometimes.

1:07:18You only have to get up off the sofa once which is to go to the door.

1:07:21Only the one time which is to get the food.

1:07:23Which is way less times than if you were cooking.

1:07:26Otherwise you can just lay there and doze and ponder your life.

1:07:30So that's a thing that happens sometimes and it's okay.

1:07:34And that's the beauty of DoorDash is that somebody will bring it to you from those local

1:07:39restaurants.

1:07:40And you never know, that restaurant that's a little further away might be able to get

1:07:43you the food sooner.

1:07:45And DoorDash will tell you that.

1:07:47So that's 25% off, up to $10 of value and zero delivery fees on your first order when

1:07:52you download the DoorDash app in the App Store and enter the code UPGRADE2021 if you're in

1:07:57the US and upgrade AUS for Australia.

1:08:00Don't forget that it's upgrade 2021 for the US, upgrade AUS for Australia and you will

1:08:05get 25% off your first order with DoorDash.

1:08:08Subject to change, terms apply.

1:08:10Our thanks to DoorDash for their support of this show and Relay FM.

1:08:14Let's finish up the show today with some #AskUpgrade questions.

1:08:19First one comes from Martin.

1:08:21How often do you take screenshots by accident with your iPhone when you just want to hit

1:08:26the power button?

1:08:27seems to happen to me every day to cite someone, I might be holding it wrong.

1:08:32It's endless. I do this all the time.

1:08:33Oh, okay. Like all throughout the day?

1:08:36Well not throughout the day but there's certain -- it just happens. It happens when I'm reaching

1:08:42for the phone or I'm trying to do something in particular. Sometimes it's that I'm trying

1:08:45to adjust the volume but I unwittingly have my hand on another button or I need to squeeze

1:08:51the phone a little bit so that my volume button will be registered, but I unfortunately am

1:08:57squeezing it on the other button and so you end up with a screenshot. I wish there was

1:09:01a gesture that was "forget that screenshot", right? You've got the gesture to tap and bring

1:09:08it up at which point you can delete it. And you've got the gesture to just get the little

1:09:11floater off the screen. Oh, you can just swipe it away, but that saves it. That saves it,

1:09:16right? So I want, I wish there was some sort of a gesture, I don't know, I grab it and

1:09:20I like spin it around and chuck it off the side or something.

1:09:23I want the like away with you screenshot.

1:09:25No, I begone with you gesture.

1:09:29But failing that, yeah, it totally happens.

1:09:31Again, I remember when the first iPhone shipped

1:09:34and it didn't have a screenshot shortcut

1:09:36and we had to like jailbreak the iPhone

1:09:39and attach it to a cable.

1:09:43And when you got the screen the way you wanted it,

1:09:44you had to issue a shell command on the iPhone,

1:09:47which would grab it.

1:09:48and then you had to use a file transfer thing

1:09:51that you had uploaded to the iPhone

1:09:52to basically FTP it back across the line

1:09:56to get screenshots.

1:09:57So what I'm saying is,

1:09:59I'm glad we can take screenshots on the iPhone.

1:10:02I just do it by accident a lot.

1:10:05- I tend to only do it when I'm trying to turn my alarm off.

1:10:10Oh, so it's my alarm? - Oh, interesting.

1:10:11So you get a lot of screenshots of your alarm.

1:10:13- I get a lot of screenshots that just say alarm.

1:10:16You know, like the alarm?

1:10:18like screen that I get a lot of those ones because usually I'm just grabbing for my phone

1:10:25and just squeezing it. That's my typical task.

1:10:29Yes, make it stop, make it stop. Oh God, make it stop.

1:10:33Rajeev asks, this is actually a tangential question, "Do either of you use sleep tracking

1:10:37of an Apple Watch? If you do, what benefits or metrics do you get out of it?"

1:10:42I tried it with the new watch that I got, which has longer battery life and it has the

1:10:49fast charge and all of that.

1:10:51I've tried it.

1:10:52I turn on the sleep thing so it now buzzes me at 10 at night and says, "You should start

1:10:56winding down," and all of that.

1:10:59One night I wore it, and although I think I could probably wear it every night, I'm

1:11:03unclear on what the benefits are too.

1:11:06It feels weird to sleep with a watch, and so I would need to get over that.

1:11:11I'm open to the possibility of doing it eventually, but I haven't done it consistently.

1:11:16I just tried it a couple of times and it told me that I wasn't sleeping enough and I agreed.

1:11:21I knew that already.

1:11:24So I haven't done more than that.

1:11:27It did tell me like it's doing some monitoring of my oxygen and my heart rate and stuff overnight

1:11:33and it's logging sort of like when I'm awake and when I'm asleep.

1:11:37It sets modes in focus, right?

1:11:39So it puts you in sleep mode, so it doesn't bug you as much when you're asleep, which

1:11:44is good.

1:11:45So there are advantages of it, but I haven't stuck with it.

1:11:47Yeah, I don't do this.

1:11:49It's like a combination of things.

1:11:51One, I wouldn't want to, and I would hate to sleep with a watch on.

1:11:56I would not find that comfortable at all.

1:11:57Yeah, it's weird.

1:11:59I don't want to have to manage the battery of my Apple Watch, right?

1:12:06Right now, I just take my phone, my watch off the charger in the morning and I put it

1:12:12on the charger when I go to bed.

1:12:13I don't want to have to think about charging my watch through the day.

1:12:15I'm not interested in that.

1:12:18And you know people say, "Hey, just get up and get written up."

1:12:20I just, one of the first things I do every day is take my watch off the charger and put

1:12:24my watch on.

1:12:25That is the way I want to live my life.

1:12:27I don't want to have to not do that.

1:12:30That's just how I live my life.

1:12:31It's my choice.

1:12:33I also honestly like just from a basic level,

1:12:38I don't know what I'm supposed to get out

1:12:41of the idea of sleep tracking.

1:12:42Like I don't know what it's supposed to give me

1:12:44because if it's telling me like, hey, you're not rested,

1:12:47I can't do anything about that, I'm sleeping.

1:12:50Right, like I'm already sleeping.

1:12:52- Do it. - And I also like you.

1:12:53- Sleep more.

1:12:54- I know I have a weird sleep schedule

1:12:57and it's not good enough.

1:12:57The Apple Watch doesn't need to tell me that,

1:12:59I already know that.

1:13:00So I am not saying it is not good for people.

1:13:04I just don't see why I would want to do it for me.

1:13:08- Yeah, I'm a big fan of getting stats about yourself,

1:13:13but having to commit to wearing my Apple Watch every night

1:13:16in order to get sleep stats

1:13:18is not something I'm willing to do at this point.

1:13:22If I was having a sleep problem, I would consider it,

1:13:25but I'm not, so I don't.

1:13:27- I would be open to some kind of device

1:13:29that monitored my sleep. I mean, like, not massively, but.

1:13:31- You know, I bought a Bedit.

1:13:33- Yeah, yeah, yeah. - I bought a Bedit,

1:13:34which is a passive, it's a little strip

1:13:36that you put on your bed, and it basically monitors you

1:13:39and when you're sleeping and all of that,

1:13:41and it's just, it's totally passive.

1:13:43And the problem that I had with it was,

1:13:45you have to place it, every time you change the sheets,

1:13:47you've gotta replace it.

1:13:48It's gotta have, it's gotta be within Bluetooth range

1:13:51of your phone, and as you know,

1:13:52I don't actually keep my phone.

1:13:54If they did a WiFi version, 'cause the Apple Watch

1:13:56is on the WiFi, so it talks to my phone when I'm wearing it.

1:13:58They did a Wi-Fi version of something like that or something I could put in a pillow

1:14:02or something like that.

1:14:03Something that was a little even more kind of fuss free but you know I used that Betit

1:14:07for a little while and it was it just didn't kind of work right.

1:14:10Apple bought that technology so who knows what they'll do with it.

1:14:14But I would be open to something like that but that's it.

1:14:16This is one of those like wholly owned subsidiary companies and I bet it you can still get it.

1:14:22It's still a thing that exists.

1:14:23Apple owns it which is very weird.

1:14:26- Yeah, and in the end I was not willing to move

1:14:29where my iPhone lives to be by my bed

1:14:32in order to use the bedded, so I just sort of gave up.

1:14:35- Roger asks, "Do you think it's worth getting

1:14:37"the AirPods Max dedicated mostly

1:14:39"for surround sound movie watching?

1:14:41"I've got small kids and can't really have my pair

1:14:43"of HomePods blasting away at night."

1:14:45I'll say yeah, I really like the AirPods Max,

1:14:48I think they're great and they do a good job

1:14:50of the spatial audio stuff, they sound really good.

1:14:53If this is something that you really care about

1:14:55and you can afford it, I recommend doing it.

1:14:59Like it just seems like an easy recommendation to me.

1:15:01- Yeah, I don't have AirPods Max.

1:15:03You can use AirPods Pro to do this too

1:15:05and they don't leak too badly and they're cheaper.

1:15:10So it really depends on your comfort level.

1:15:13But I do watch shows at night sometimes

1:15:16with the AirPods Pro in and they're great.

1:15:19- Yeah, will also work.

1:15:21Like it just depends on what you're looking for,

1:15:22but they will both do a good job.

1:15:24And finally today Sims asks have both of you been able to keep the same second gen Apple pencil since you bought it originally in

1:15:322018 or have you had to replace any of them since then? Huh? I haven't had one die

1:15:38Yep, but I ended up I ended up with two. Yep, and

1:15:42I I can't tell them apart. They're not labeled. They're just Apple pencil

1:15:47But they float around the house and sometimes I use one and sometimes they use the other and I looking I'm like

1:15:53I know that I left that one out there.

1:15:54Oh, there's one right here.

1:15:55And so I ended up with two of them

1:15:57and I just kind of used them interchangeably

1:15:58and I can't tell them apart.

1:16:00So that happened.

1:16:03They just keep multiplying.

1:16:05That's it though.

1:16:06They both work fine and I haven't had any trouble.

1:16:08In fact, at some point I wanna write a thing about this.

1:16:11I'm not quite sure what I'll say

1:16:13because that's sort of the point is the Apple Pencil,

1:16:16I know we said this at the time,

1:16:17but just I still use it to edit podcasts.

1:16:21I love it.

1:16:22It is the most non-technological tech product I've ever used.

1:16:27It feels like a solid object that has, there's nothing.

1:16:34Like the other day it wasn't working

1:16:36and I realized I had to screw the tip in a little bit more.

1:16:38It had come unscrewed a little bit.

1:16:40That's the most effort that I've ever put

1:16:43toward the Apple Pencil

1:16:44other than snapping it on the side of my iPad.

1:16:46And I just think it's remarkable.

1:16:49I think it's remarkable that it feels so non-technical.

1:16:53There's no light on it.

1:16:54There's no button on it.

1:16:56There's just nothing.

1:16:57I think it's great, but I have not had a failure

1:17:00of any kind with one.

1:17:01- Same.

1:17:02I mean, I think the second gen Apple Pencil

1:17:04is one of the best things Apple's ever made.

1:17:06Like just from a like,

1:17:08hey, what is this thing supposed to do?

1:17:10And like its ultimate execution.

1:17:12It's like, it's perfect.

1:17:13It's absolutely perfect.

1:17:14- The first one's got weird things about it, right?

1:17:16with the lightning thing and the tip and all of that,

1:17:19but the second generation one is just kind of flawless.

1:17:22- Gen one was fit for purpose, retrofit into a product

1:17:26that already existed, you know,

1:17:28like a form factor that already existed.

1:17:30- How do we charge this thing?

1:17:32- Gen two, they designed them together.

1:17:34- Yeah, exactly right.

1:17:35- And it's just fantastic for that.

1:17:36- Yeah, the only, and I, my only complaint about it

1:17:40is that I think the accelerometer that they put in it

1:17:43is not accurate enough for me to use those features.

1:17:46- The double tap thing?

1:17:48- Yeah, I miss double tap,

1:17:49so I basically turned it off where I use it

1:17:52because I just do it by accident.

1:17:54I can't trigger it reliably and I trigger it by accident.

1:17:59So in neither case is it worth having it.

1:18:02So I would say if they update this at some point,

1:18:05I would love there to be an alternate gesture of some sort.

1:18:08I would prefer it to be,

1:18:12I mean it needs to be engineered differently than it is.

1:18:14I don't know whether that's a button or whether it's a touch sensitive area or whether it's

1:18:17just a better accelerometer or what it is.

1:18:23But I would really like to, I like the idea of having a gesture on the device but the

1:18:30gesture that they built I don't use because it's not reliable.

1:18:33Yeah, I would like to see two things if we're going to go button, programmable button and

1:18:38touch sense like a not not touching a sensitive area on the opposite side for a racing. Oh, yeah

1:18:45Yeah, that would be that would be a lot of fun to have the alternate basically an alternate input side on the other side

1:18:51Little two-headed pencil the two-headed pencil, but like a great just a fantastic

1:18:55Racer you could you could have apps could use it as a different type of pen, right?

1:19:00There are lots of different things you could do programable like the double-tap thing is exactly different apps can use it different ways

1:19:07But like these things would they would just be nice to have for me that they don't need to do either of those like because

1:19:12It really is is so it's just such a good thing. It's so well

1:19:16Simplicity just it's amazing

1:19:18If you'd like to send in a question for us to answer on the show just send out a tweet with the hashtag

1:19:23Ask upgrade or use question mark ask upgrade in the relay FM members discord that you can get access to

1:19:28If you sign up for get upgrade plus go to get upgrade plus calm and you will also get longer ad free

1:19:35versions of every single episode of Upgrades.

1:19:39If you enjoy the show, you get more of it with no interruptions.

1:19:43Thank you so much to everybody that has signed up.

1:19:45All of you Upgradients, we really, really appreciate your support.

1:19:49Also thank you to DoorDash, Member4 and ZocDoc for their support of this week's episode.

1:19:54But most importantly, as always, thank you for listening.

1:19:58If you'd like to find Jason online, you can go to SixColors.com, TheIncomparable.com,

1:20:02He's @JSnell on Twitter.

1:20:04I am @imike, I-M-Y-K-E,

1:20:06and we both host here many shows at Relay FM.

1:20:09You go to relay.fm/shows and check out all of the great

1:20:12shows that we have to offer for you.

1:20:15So until next week, say goodbye Jason Snell.

1:20:18- Goodbye Myke Hurley.

1:20:19(upbeat music)

1:20:21[MUSIC PLAYING]