0:00:00*BEEP*
0:00:00From Relay FM, this is Upgrade, episode 163.
0:00:12Today's show is brought to you by Balance, Squarespace, and Macworld.
0:00:16And my name is Myke Hurley, and I am joined in person across this breakfast counter by Mr. Jason Snow.
0:00:21Happy breakfast counter, Myke.
0:00:23Happy breakfast counter to you, Jason Snow.
0:00:24We're in Chicago right now.
0:00:25We are.
0:00:26We even have a tiny, tiny, tiny audience.
0:00:29But nobody cares about that because it's time for Snell Talk.
0:00:32That's perfect. Nice. I like that. We actually have a really fun Snell Talk question today
0:00:36from Josh. Josh misses the old small talk, so how's the weather today?
0:00:40It's sunny today.
0:00:41It is sunny. We are in Chicago. We're in Airbnb right now. There's a train that goes by sometimes,
0:00:47which you may get the pleasure of hearing.
0:00:48Yeah, just pretend we're Merlin.
0:00:50Yeah, we've got a streetcar. And we are at Release Notes.
0:00:53Yes.
0:00:54So at least that starts today.
0:00:56We've been doing some stuff in and around.
0:00:58We had a bunch of live episodes.
0:01:00We had a live episode of The Pen Addict,
0:01:01which is coming out later this week at Field Notes.
0:01:04We had a live episode of Connected,
0:01:06and a live episode of Ungenius.
0:01:07Connected's out, Ungenius took me out today as well.
0:01:09We've been doing some fun stuff, bunch of meetups.
0:01:11It's been a really, really great week so far.
0:01:13- And now we have a live episode of Upgrade,
0:01:14live before a studio audience.
0:01:16- Of two people, Federico and Steven.
0:01:18Say hi, guys.
0:01:19- Hey. - Hey, guys.
0:01:20- You probably can't hear them, but they're there.
0:01:22They're there, they're working on their iPads.
0:01:23They're not imaginary. They're real. Yeah.
0:01:25You can't work on an iPad, Myke. What are you talking about?
0:01:27That's very true, actually. That is very true.
0:01:29So, how's the Spider Mac?
0:01:32Uhhhhh...
0:01:34The Spider Mac is... The Spider is gone.
0:01:37The Mac has returned.
0:01:39I cannot tell you how relieved I was to get my iMac back.
0:01:43I was so sad.
0:01:46I mean, I think I mentioned this last week.
0:01:48I was so sad to have it gone and have my little monitor arm
0:01:52Just standing there at attention with nothing on it. It was like but my computer. Where is where did it go?
0:01:58But it has been returned from its repairs
0:02:01with
0:02:04With no spider in the in the glass
0:02:06They give you the spider back like, you know
0:02:08If you have some like some kind of medical procedure that like kidney stones or put them in a little jar for you or something
0:02:13No, this is more like when a pet dies that does not give you your dead pet. They they flushed it
0:02:17they use a lot of I'm sure a lot of care and and
0:02:22to see how they did that like just the whole process taking the screen off just to remove
0:02:27the spider and then put it back again. I assume they pulled off the entire screen and replaced it.
0:02:34It's the only way to do it right? Yeah and those iMacs are hard to do but anyway it's it's uh
0:02:39it's done it which allows me to work undistracted and also to sell it or give it away
0:02:47Handed down when I decide to upgrade upgrade my iMac which I think is gonna happen
0:02:52I think it's just a matter of whether I'm gonna do the
0:02:56Latest and greatest iMac this fall or whether I will I really want to see about the iMac Pro
0:03:02I think this is my decided. I think you've decided this in your brain. You're getting an iMac Pro
0:03:06I think you've decided I have decided to get an iMac Pro with one exception
0:03:10Which is I know there's gonna be a moment
0:03:12When I'm on the shopping page for the iMac Pro once the orders open up where it's gonna say
0:03:17Here's how much it costs and it's gonna be $5,000 and I'm gonna be like really do I want to do this?
0:03:24We I mean, I think everybody used to do this you'd go to the old Mac Pro page and you'd price up
0:03:31How expensive can you make this?
0:03:33You know like you get it like 10 grand 12 grand this probably gonna be like that
0:03:37I reckon not that you'll pay that no
0:03:38But you could if you wanted to it will be the base model if I get one of these let me tell you that base model
0:03:44Will be very very very good. Yeah, I mean there's no doubt that logically
0:03:49it would be good for me doing my job to have that but not the writing part, but the
0:03:53denoising files part
0:03:56audio files, so yeah, we'll see
0:03:58Last week we spent some time talking about emoji. Let the eleven point one beta came out
0:04:04After the after we recorded so you can get the emoji now and they're great. There's a bunch of new great emoji in there
0:04:09And I got some feedback some follow-up from Mark Bram Hill who is the creator of welcome to Macintosh
0:04:16And he just did a big emoji series. He has a lot of thoughts about emoji. So I was talking about
0:04:20that I believe that Apple hold off the emoji releases until after the main release to try and
0:04:27Spare on adoption and mark said that Unicode finalizes emoji in the summer
0:04:32Giving a fairly short timeline to illustrate and that Unicode are now switching to an earlier timeline
0:04:38Finalizing three months after in the spring so we may see next year's new emoji in iOS 12 because vendors have complained to Unicode
0:04:46Which is why they switched their timeline so it could be the reason for the wait
0:04:50so we'll see I mean that is a I still believe that they hold it off because
0:04:54Other vendors like Google have supported them already
0:04:57But it could be like if they want to spend time really illustrating them and that kind of thing
0:05:01But it's good to see that it is funny to see how the Unicode consortium which is this big thing
0:05:06Is basically the emoji house now, right like and that they're making all these changes now
0:05:11So emoji can be better prepared and stuff like that. But yeah, so that's what they're doing going forward. Yeah
0:05:16It's it's a funny example of an organization that
0:05:20Was not made to do this, but they've kind of become fallen into it. So they yeah, they have to deal with this
0:05:26Is what they do. Yeah, you know
0:05:28so
0:05:30when we were in
0:05:32Chicago we planned to go to the cinema together. Unfortunately, you had a plane that got cancelled so you didn't make it
0:05:37Yeah, there was a it's sunny now, but over the weekend there were torrential rains
0:05:43Chicago big thunderstorms for a whole day on Saturday and so my flight got cancelled
0:05:48So I came in Sunday which meant I didn't get the chance to do Myke at the movies in person
0:05:56with you on Saturday night.
0:05:57Because we wanted to talk about, I went to see Blade Runner 2049 which we were going
0:06:01to talk about together but we can't now so I just want to give some completely no spoilers
0:06:06opinions of Blade Runner 2049.
0:06:09Here we go.
0:06:10I just wanted to say that I really like this movie a lot.
0:06:14It gave me what I liked about the first one, the visuals and the music are incredible,
0:06:18just so beautiful.
0:06:20One of the most visually beautiful films I have ever seen.
0:06:25It was stunning.
0:06:26And it also gave me less of what I didn't like about Blade Runner.
0:06:31So I found the story to be easier to follow and there was more action.
0:06:35Like there was more stuff going on in the movie.
0:06:37So you just made Blade Runner fans happy and then like reluctant because they're like,
0:06:42But wait, Myke is saying that he likes Blade Runner 2049 better than Blade Runner in some
0:06:49ways because it has more of the things that you like, which is going to be heresy.
0:06:53I prefer this movie.
0:06:54But as I mentioned to you I believe last night, there is literally nothing you can say about
0:06:57Blade Runner now that will not anger somebody.
0:07:00If you like Blade Runner, you already don't like what me and Jason have to say about anything
0:07:03to Blade Runner.
0:07:04Even though, we've got this reputation now, even though we both pretty much came out in
0:07:10our revision with John Syracuse in being much more favorable to Blade Runner after watching
0:07:15the final cut. Yeah, but I prefer this movie. I really like Ryan Gosling in general, so
0:07:21that was a big win for me, like he's great in it. I really re- I recommend it. I know
0:07:25it hasn't done very well in the box office. Um, which it- in a way, like it doesn't surprise
0:07:32me. Like I understand that like it's a huge cast, but it is a sequel to a movie that is
0:07:38kind of a cult movie Blade Runner. I feel like it was not a hit.
0:07:43So it is not surprising to me that the the sequel to this movie which maybe
0:07:48never should have been made right like by a lot of people's standards it kind of
0:07:52has not doing so well but I do recommend it like I actually don't really feel
0:07:58like you even need to have seen Blade Runner to go and see this movie like
0:08:01they set things out pretty simply with text and it's like it's kind of like
0:08:05they have like a crawl at the beginning kind of thing and that's it. But yeah I
0:08:09really liked it. I'm just ashamed we can't talk about it in more detail. Maybe
0:08:12one day. Maybe. One last thing. I just wanted to mention because I've been
0:08:17spending more time with Apple nerds in different locations over the last couple
0:08:22of days. The iOS 11 Wi-Fi password sharing thing is amazing. So this is when
0:08:27you're somebody's connected to a Wi-Fi network and you try to connect to the
0:08:31same network, it gives them a pop-up on any device, Mac or iOS. They can say yes, allow
0:08:37this person, share the password with them and it just pre-fills on your device and you
0:08:42just have to be in somebody's contact book. So it's quite funny like if there's a bunch
0:08:44of people in a room and you try and connect to the Wi-Fi, it pings all of their devices
0:08:50and someone will just let you on. But it is so much easier to go like, "Hey, what's the
0:08:54Wi-Fi password?" It's really good. It's a really good feature.
0:08:56Yeah, and it doesn't need to be secure in that way, right? Because the idea is not,
0:09:03well, they're not the owner of the Wi-Fi network, so should they be giving that out?
0:09:08The fact is, once you know the Wi-Fi password, you know it, theoretically, and you can share
0:09:13it, so why not just share it?
0:09:14Yeah, these people have to be in your contacts. Like, I like that kind of security. They just
0:09:17have to be a friend of yours, and you can give them the Wi-Fi password. I think that
0:09:21works really well. It's a good feature.
0:09:23That's great. I look forward to using that sometime.
0:09:25So I didn't say, I want to, because we kind of skip all the way through the Snell Talk
0:09:29question. Thank you to Josh for submitting his Snell Talk question. If you have a question
0:09:32you'd like to open the show, #snelltalk and they'll go into a document and we can pull
0:09:37those out.
0:09:38That's right. And who knows, maybe there'll be more Snell Talk questions about Small Talk,
0:09:42about the weather.
0:09:43Maybe there will be.
0:09:44Then it'll be directed by the listeners. We'll have to talk about Small Talk because they
0:09:47demand it.
0:09:48I think it kind of all is Small Talk.
0:09:49Yeah, I suppose so.
0:09:50Why is it called Snell Talk?
0:09:51It's just directed instead of random. It is a little weird, I have to say, not just,
0:09:57it's very nice to be across the table from you. We do this really a shocking amount,
0:10:01given that I live in California and you live in London, we do this two or three times a
0:10:06year it seems, which is great. So high five. Yeah, there it is. That was good podcasting.
0:10:13You spit out some water and did a high five. It is a little disconcerting, I realize, as
0:10:18I'm sitting here because I keep looking up and to my left expecting to see the oak tree
0:10:26out my window and it's not there. There's no oak tree over there. Where's the oak tree?
0:10:30Where's the squirrel that is running along the fence? They're not out there.
0:10:34I can see him at McDonald's.
0:10:35It is Monday morning though. So that is, that feels, and I'm sitting here kind of unshaved
0:10:40and in my shirt from yesterday because I haven't taken a shower yet this morning. And in that
0:10:45way, it feels like upgrade.
0:10:47There's a lot of information for the listener.
0:10:50Today's show is brought to you by Mack Weldon.
0:10:52They make the most comfortable underwear, socks, shirts,
0:10:54undershirts, hoodies, and sweatpants
0:10:56that you're ever gonna wear.
0:10:57Mack Weldon is better than whatever you're wearing
0:10:59right now unless you've already been smart enough
0:11:01to buy Mack Weldon clothing.
0:11:02- Yep.
0:11:03- You're wearing Mack Weldon right now?
0:11:04- Speaking of what we said earlier, absolutely.
0:11:06- Way too much information.
0:11:08This is just all of the information I've got today.
0:11:09- Did you wear your Mack Weldon sweatpants on the plane?
0:11:11- Of course I did.
0:11:12- Of course you did. - Of course I did.
0:11:13- It was a little chilly the other day at home
0:11:15and I put on my Mack Weldon sweatpants
0:11:16and then I saw that you were flying with Federico
0:11:18and I thought, oh, we're Mac Walden sweatpants twinsies.
0:11:21- We were Mac Walden buddies that day.
0:11:24Mac Walden have a no questions asked return policy.
0:11:26If you don't like what you buy for them,
0:11:28like for your first pair, you just keep it
0:11:30and they'll refund you no questions asked.
0:11:31That's how confident they are that you're gonna love.
0:11:33They have fantastic clothes.
0:11:35They have meticulous attention to detail,
0:11:37a simple shopping experience, and premium fabrics.
0:11:40They deliver a new level of daily comfort
0:11:41straight to your door.
0:11:43Mac Walden also have a line of silver underwear and shirts
0:11:46and naturally antimicrobial.
0:11:48This is some super cool science stuff,
0:11:49which basically means that they eliminate odor.
0:11:52Not only do Mac Walden's underwear, socks and shirts
0:11:54look good, they perform well too.
0:11:56They're good for working out, going to work, traveling,
0:11:58especially internationally or for everyday life.
0:12:01The winners of this show can get $20 off at macwalden.com
0:12:05with the code upgrade.
0:12:06I should say I'm also wearing Mac Walden today, Jason.
0:12:08- Woo!
0:12:09- Just so you know, some information for me too.
0:12:10- We are still Mac Walden buddies.
0:12:11- Thank you so much to Mac Walden
0:12:12for their support of this show.
0:12:14And Relay FM, Jason, your favorite topic.
0:12:18There's a new Kindle.
0:12:20- What?
0:12:21A new Kindle?
0:12:22- A new Kindle.
0:12:23So this is it.
0:12:24This is still the Oasis, right?
0:12:26Which is weird because they seem to come up with names
0:12:29for new stuff all the time.
0:12:31- Yeah, they--
0:12:32- And this seems like a pretty significant update.
0:12:33- Well, they've revised the Paperwhite.
0:12:35- Okay.
0:12:36- So this is, and they've revised the Kindle,
0:12:39I guess is what they call it. - Paperwhite
0:12:39is a terrible name.
0:12:41Like that, for me, is not aged.
0:12:43That is just a bad product name, Paperweight.
0:12:45- Well, the idea at the time was that it is
0:12:50a high contrast screen.
0:12:52Instead of being a kind of medium gray,
0:12:54it's a very light gray and it's got the backlighting on it.
0:12:56And it's actually the best Kindle to get
0:12:59in terms of being a good buy with the features that it's got.
0:13:02- Still?
0:13:03- Well, we'll see how this new one.
0:13:04So this new Oasis, this is the old Oasis
0:13:06was more expensive than this one and kind of weird.
0:13:11It came with a case with a battery on it, and you had to get the case because it was
0:13:16very small and very thin and had not great battery life, although e-ink, e-book readers
0:13:21are really good at using battery lightly.
0:13:26But you could put the case on it and then it would use that battery or recharge its
0:13:31own internal battery.
0:13:33So with this, they've kept the kind of wedge shape of that.
0:13:37It's got a kind of a thick part and a thin part, but the case is gone, the mandatory
0:13:42battery case.
0:13:43It's got bigger battery inside and it's heavier than it was because that battery weighs a
0:13:52couple ounces, so it's heavier.
0:13:55And it's got a larger screen, it's got a 7-inch screen, so it's kind of going outside of the
0:13:59previously common 6-inch Kindle screen.
0:14:04So it's still their premium, most expensive Kindle, but it's no longer their light Kindle
0:14:10because it's gained that weight.
0:14:12And it's cheaper, so that's good, it starts at $250.
0:14:17And we'll see how it goes.
0:14:20They're doing some interesting things, they're now doing a storage tier, which they didn't
0:14:26do before, which I think is really funny because ebooks are very small.
0:14:30I think they're doing this because they've added audible support.
0:14:33So Amazon owns Audible and you can buy Audible bundles of ebook and audiobook and they've
0:14:41added to this new Oasis and I think they're rolling it out to a couple of existing models
0:14:45including the old Oasis and maybe there's one more where they're going to add Bluetooth
0:14:51support that apparently there's Bluetooth in those devices and it's just turned off.
0:14:55Bluetooth audio support so that you can also use it, pair it with headphones and listen
0:15:00to your audiobook if you want to stop reading but keep going. Which is funny because that's
0:15:05a throwback to the original Kindles. The original Kindles had headphone jacks and you could
0:15:09put audiobooks on them. So this is like the next generation of that which I think is kind
0:15:13of interesting. And then the other big thing which has never before been in existence on
0:15:18a Kindle unless you used a Ziploc bag in the bathtub like Jeff Bezos apparently did. He
0:15:24doesn't need to anymore because it's waterproof.
0:15:26Yeah, why would you want a waterproof Kindle?
0:15:29To read in the bathtub.
0:15:31Is that the main reason that they've done this?
0:15:33Yeah.
0:15:34That's interesting.
0:15:35Yeah, people, and I know, so I realized, I was talking to Aline Sims actually about this
0:15:40who is here, and she said she was excited about the bathtub thing, and I realized your
0:15:48feeling about reading in the bathtub has a lot to do with whether you have a good bathtub,
0:15:52and I do not.
0:15:53Our bathtub is uncomfortable.
0:15:54You can read in the shower.
0:15:55Is that a thing you want to do?
0:15:56- No, that's not gonna happen.
0:15:58When we were in Hawaii, I did read in a,
0:16:01there was a hot tub at the place we were staying, out back,
0:16:04and so it's just, you know, it's out there in the fresh air
0:16:05in a beautiful view in a hot tub, and I did read there,
0:16:08and I had the Kindle Oasis, the old one,
0:16:11so I would just, you know, hold it very carefully
0:16:14so as not to drop it in the water and destroy it.
0:16:16But I think there are people who read in the bathtub,
0:16:20including Jeff Bezos, who, I'm not kidding,
0:16:22famously said that he used a Ziploc bag around his Kindle.
0:16:26It's funny because it's IPX8 certified for waterproofing, which is just funny to me because
0:16:32of what this certification means, like what you can do. You can submerge a Kindle for
0:16:38up to 2 meters for 60 minutes. I don't think that's ever going to happen.
0:16:43What I was thinking is that's the rating for "Mom, I dropped the Kindle in the pool,
0:16:48we'll go get it now." How long does it take to fish it out of the bottom of the pool?
0:16:54This is, I feel like Amazon is shifting their tactics here.
0:16:58And this is, look, e-book, e-ink readers are a niche product category, but they're actually
0:17:05popular.
0:17:06We've talked about this.
0:17:07Every time we talk about the Kindle, I have to do this disclaimer, which is tech nerds
0:17:09think it's dumb because it's black and white and you should just get a tablet.
0:17:14But the fact is, tech nerds are not the main audience for this product.
0:17:18It is people who are the demographic of Kindle users.
0:17:21I'm sure if Amazon actually would release this data, which they never will, but I would
0:17:25say the demographic of Kindle, it's older. There are probably more women than men in
0:17:32this demographic. It is the book reader demographic, which is a very different demographic than
0:17:39the tech nerd demographic. And these are great for reading books. That's why I have them,
0:17:43is they're great for reading text on a page. That's what they're good for. And Amazon
0:17:50this time is like storage tier, audiobook integration direct, waterproofing, bigger
0:17:57screen which is new, it probably is going to be, I have the Kobo Aura 1 which is a pretty
0:18:03good ebook reader and it's like the difference between reading a paperback and reading like
0:18:06a hard cover book or something where it's like got the bigger screen. I imagine the
0:18:10Oasis is going to kind of be like that. So it shows that Amazon is still trying stuff
0:18:16with the Kindle which I like.
0:18:18- They don't have a color one, right?
0:18:20- No, I mean the color Kindle was basically
0:18:22the Fire tablet. - The Fire.
0:18:26- Right, the Kindle. - It's still black and white.
0:18:28- Yeah, it's just, I think they make color ink,
0:18:31but there are issues with it and it's not important.
0:18:34- You don't need it.
0:18:34But I think that adds to what you were saying
0:18:37about who this product is for.
0:18:39Like if they were making this for the tech audience,
0:18:41they probably would put color in it
0:18:42just because it would be fancy.
0:18:43- Yeah, it would be a checkbox and all that,
0:18:45But this is an uncool product.
0:18:47This is not a product that needs to be cool.
0:18:49- This isn't an echo.
0:18:50- No.
0:18:51- You know, it's not cool.
0:18:52- I have an iPad and I read on my iPad all the time
0:18:54and when I read novels, I read them on a Kindle.
0:18:57I prefer to read them on the Kindle.
0:18:58I prefer the reflective screen.
0:19:00- It's comfortable.
0:19:02- It is easier on my eyes.
0:19:04It's nice to not be distracted.
0:19:09Just, you know how I say working on the iPad
0:19:11feels less distracting than working on the Mac
0:19:13because mostly I'm in one app at a time. Reading on the Kindle is way less distracting
0:19:18than reading on the iPad because there's no notifications coming in or anything like
0:19:21that. I'm just reading my book. So it's, yeah, it's not for everyone and I think
0:19:26that for people who are sort of more vaguely interested in a Kindle, the Paperwhite is
0:19:32probably still going to be the better buy because it's way cheaper and like if you're
0:19:35going to buy an e-reader that's kind of disposable and you use it at the beach a
0:19:38couple of times a year. The Paperwhite is the one I choose because it does have the
0:19:44lighting so you can read it at night without a light.
0:19:47Does this have a light?
0:19:48Yeah. They all do now. This has like eight. It's something like their nine LCD or nine
0:19:54LED backlights in the Paperwhite and this one's got like 15 or something.
0:19:59This is bigger, right? It makes sense.
0:20:01Yeah, and it's more evenly lit when they do it that way. So yeah, I think it's cool.
0:20:06You want one?
0:20:07Well, so I like the Oasis, the current Oasis a lot and one of the things I like about it
0:20:12is you can pop that cover off and it's super light. It's like not, like there's nothing
0:20:17in your hand. It's just, there's no weight to it. It's great.
0:20:20But this isn't that.
0:20:21And this one is, is I think basically the same weight as the one, the current Oasis,
0:20:27the old Oasis in a case. But without the case, it's way heavier. It's like several ounces
0:20:31heavier. So when this was announced, I thought to myself, yeah, you know, I think as a user
0:20:36of the Kindle. I, Oasis, I'm not sure I really want to have this. As somebody who writes
0:20:43about this and talks about it, I totally ordered it because I decided it was worth it to me
0:20:47to try it out and talk about it and review it and figure out where it fits in my grand
0:20:51which Kindle should you buy scheme.
0:20:53I think the waterproofing might edge out the weight. Like the benefit of the waterproofing
0:20:59for a lot of people will be like I don't care that it's heavier. Like I really need it to
0:21:02be waterproof.
0:21:03If you are somebody who takes your Kindle to the beach or the pool or anything like
0:21:07that or reads in the bathtub or a hot tub or something like that.
0:21:10I should have called it the Kindle bubbles or something.
0:21:13Oasis, I get it.
0:21:16It is weird to me that they did all of this and didn't give it a new product name.
0:21:23That is strange to me.
0:21:24Well I think obviously it was the successor to the Oasis.
0:21:33when they were developing it, the fact that it's got that kind of wedge shape where the
0:21:36battery's on one side, so you've got your sort of side you grip that's a little bit
0:21:40thicker and then there's the other side which doesn't have that which means it makes it
0:21:43lighter overall and less bulky overall. Obviously it originated from that same idea so it's
0:21:49they think about it as an evolution. I think there are too many kindles and that there's
0:21:55probably a kindle in there that they should probably get rid of but that's where we are.
0:22:01So there's also going on to more kind of entertainment-y news in technology.
0:22:05There's a few things going on this week that are all relating to movies and how technology
0:22:12companies are evolving their movie efforts.
0:22:16The first is a service called Movies Anywhere, which is something that's existed for a while
0:22:20but wasn't massively useful.
0:22:22Yeah, Disney Movies Anywhere is what it was.
0:22:24Yeah, because it is a Disney-owned property and it was you could buy, say you bought a
0:22:29Disney movie on iTunes or Amazon or Google Play, you could link these
0:22:33accounts to Disney service and then these movies would be available for you
0:22:37everywhere both in the Disney movies anywhere app and this is this is the big
0:22:43part this is the the really mind-boggling part if you bought a
0:22:48Disney movie on Amazon you could download it on iTunes yes and vice
0:22:53versa across all of these services this week Disney extended this to other
0:22:59major studios. It's now called Movies Anywhere, right? They removed the Disney branding from
0:23:03the name. And it includes Warner Brothers, Universal, Fox, and Sony. I think Paramount
0:23:09is the big holdout.
0:23:10Paramount is the big holdout.
0:23:11But this, so this is wild. So you can buy movies wherever they're cheapest and watch
0:23:17them wherever you want.
0:23:19Yeah, I suspect that their, the pricing's going to be the same everywhere.
0:23:23I'd like to imagine this because you know you can go to to iTunes sometimes and there'll be a
0:23:28Like a movie of the day. Yeah, that's possible. It's possible, but they'll they'll sink everywhere and and I
0:23:34had this experience with the Disney stuff where we were visiting my mom in Arizona, and I threw a
0:23:39fire TV stick in my bag
0:23:42just for the trip because she doesn't have any Netflix down there and
0:23:47I thought we might want to watch movies, and I realized that I had Disney movies anywhere
0:23:53and we brought up the Amazon movie list and in the purchase movies was all the
0:23:59Marvel movies that I bought on iTunes it was like oh my god that is amazing what
0:24:04it does is it's really good for so the the background here is that the movie
0:24:09studios are concerned that with the rise of streaming services people aren't
0:24:13buying movies anymore because you can just just whatever is on wait wait for
0:24:18it to be on streaming and they want to so it used to be they were more hostile
0:24:22to us, but now they want us to, they're motivated to make us happy. And so this is,
0:24:30I mean, with that motivation out there, this is a consumer friendly feature. It's them
0:24:35trying to coax us into continuing to buy or resuming buying movies by saying, "Guess
0:24:41what? We've decided that despite Apple and Amazon fighting over you, if you buy our movie,
0:24:48You just get it everywhere. You buy a disc with a code, you get it everywhere and it's
0:24:52not like use the ultraviolet app which links to this voodoo service you've never heard
0:24:57of. It's like no, no, no. You will get this on all services. If you want it on Google
0:25:03Play, if you want it on iTunes, if you want it on Amazon, we don't care. We don't care
0:25:06if you have an Apple TV or an Amazon Fire TV.
0:25:08Adam: Both, all of them.
0:25:09Scott: We literally just, you get the movie when you buy the disc or you do a download,
0:25:14you get the movie. And maybe that'll work. They're trying to make your investment in
0:25:19buying a movie more valuable because they know that if you're, even if you're not going
0:25:24to Netflix and watching movies, but you're starting to watch movies on set top boxes,
0:25:28that stops Blu-ray sales because you can't do anything with the Blu-ray. And if you're
0:25:33like, you know, us, right? I definitely had this where I will buy an iTunes download.
0:25:38And one of the reasons is that it's available everywhere on my iPad without me having to
0:25:43rip the Blu-ray and copy it to Plex and then put it on my iPad. I can literally just go
0:25:48download in the TV app and it'll download. That is so much more convenient. And so if
0:25:56you are somebody who might buy a Blu-ray otherwise, this gives you an out, which is no, it's covered
0:26:01now. No matter what device you want, it's covered. It's super smart. I get why they're
0:26:06doing it, but it is a really positive, good news for consumers kind of thing. And it works.
0:26:12a kind of magical and you get some movies when you sign up for it too.
0:26:15You get Ghostbusters, The Lego Movie and Beaker 06.
0:26:18Yeah.
0:26:19Good movies.
0:26:20Yeah.
0:26:21And so I signed up and you link your accounts, you sign up to Movies Anywhere.
0:26:25If you were a Disney Movies Anywhere person you put in that password and stuff at some
0:26:29point and it like relinks, it copies that data over.
0:26:32So it's sort of a new service but it'll copy your data from Disney Movies Anywhere.
0:26:36you log in to iTunes and Amazon and Vudu and Google and like all the services they've got
0:26:43if you've got accounts there. So if you've got a bunch of ultraviolet movies that are
0:26:47synced to your Vudu account which I did. I had two. Well, the ultraviolet codes are so
0:26:53stupid because the app is so bad but there are some digital movies that are over there
0:26:57and that's actually one of these kind of pro tips is if you've got movies in that stupid
0:27:00ultraviolet locker and it's linked to Vudu, then you link the Vudu account to movies anywhere
0:27:06and they all come over. So I've got these ultra violent movies that are suddenly in
0:27:09my iTunes account.
0:27:10- I read on the Verge that Apple will give you the 4K HDR versions as well.
0:27:16- Yeah, it seems like the, one of the things that's happening here is, I think it depends
0:27:24on every studio's deal, because like, Disney's not on in 4K HDR.
0:27:28- Disney doesn't have it at all, but like if the movie exists and you bought it somewhere
0:27:31else.
0:27:32a resolution blind service.
0:27:37So like I had some movies that I bought,
0:27:40not in HD a long time ago, they're all in HD now.
0:27:44Like that's another thing that the service seems to do
0:27:46is just grant you like look.
0:27:48- If you get the best version.
0:27:49- You bought our movie, you get it in the best version
0:27:52that's available, yeah.
0:27:54- How did Disney convince Apple
0:27:59and Google and Amazon to do this?
0:28:02- That's a good question.
0:28:03That's the part that makes me wonder because
0:28:05- I can't work it out.
0:28:06- This goes against their business model of erecting walls
0:28:09that make it harder for people to switch.
0:28:11- Like I can see how Disney convinced the other studios
0:28:15because they probably had data that showed
0:28:17this is good for you, it's been good for us.
0:28:19- Yeah, and they saw, I mean,
0:28:20Disney just built this thing, right?
0:28:22I don't know if Disney built it
0:28:24and already had talked to the other studios
0:28:26and they're like, no, no, no, or, but whatever.
0:28:29Disney built it, they showed that it works
0:28:31and all the other studios are like, that's good.
0:28:34And at some point somebody had a conversation
0:28:36which was, you don't even need to,
0:28:38don't try to reinvent this.
0:28:40Let's just do it.
0:28:41- Let's do it altogether.
0:28:42- Let's just turn it into something for everyone.
0:28:43- Yeah, and we'll take our branding off it.
0:28:45We're gonna make this a consortium deal.
0:28:47Don't worry about it.
0:28:48- Yeah, you kick in some money for the development efforts
0:28:49and we'll turn this into a consortium.
0:28:52- I just assume that either Disney
0:28:54or one of the other studios,
0:28:55when going to these companies for deals,
0:28:57they're just like, yeah, we're gonna do this,
0:28:58but you're gonna have to do this now.
0:29:00- Yeah, 'cause that's the thing is that Amazon and Apple
0:29:05and Google all had to build in support for this.
0:29:08- Which is, boggles my mind as well, right?
0:29:10That it's not just like you have to give us,
0:29:13you have to give people the movies for free, right?
0:29:15So you're not getting any money out of it.
0:29:17You also have to develop hooks
0:29:19into your existing infrastructure,
0:29:21which given everything I kind of know about iTunes,
0:29:24was probably a very difficult thing to do.
0:29:27- I could see the argument if you're Apple
0:29:30that it's getting people into your ecosystem too because anything that happens at Google
0:29:40or Amazon or Voodoo or Ultraviolet or whatever is just kind of swept into iTunes which makes
0:29:48it super convenient on the Apple TV.
0:29:49It makes Apple bodies boxes more appealing.
0:29:52But the argument, the counter argument is all those iTunes movies that people have invested
0:29:56in that's the only reason that they're still using an Apple TV.
0:29:59they can get a fire stick. They can just get the fire stick and they're gone. So that's
0:30:04the risk. It may just be that they're all like, don't forget that the studios have some
0:30:09leverage here, right? Because they own the content. That's what I assume has happened.
0:30:13So it may be that just part of the deal here is that the studios have all said, one of
0:30:19the conditions of us being on your services is that you need to provide this feature that
0:30:25allows our customers to have the freedom to move among services.
0:30:30And it is interesting to me, considering Disney is the forerunner of this and Apple don't
0:30:35get 4K Disney movies, but they've still been able to convince Apple to do this.
0:30:40It's like it's a weird bargaining thing going on right now.
0:30:44This may have been a condition of Disney a while ago or even of other studios even before
0:30:48this got built.
0:30:49It might have been in the contract.
0:30:51Which is a provision.
0:30:52For the 4K stuff.
0:30:53thinking it's like a provision that says if we bring you a customer for our movie and
0:31:00say give them this movie you have to do it essentially in the contract. If the contract
0:31:05is read that way which is we get to arbitrarily designate people as owning a movie for based
0:31:14on codes or whatever. Which might be like you know you'd buy like a DVD and it would
0:31:19have an iTunes code in it. Yeah exactly. Something like that. That's like a redemption code but
0:31:22So it's possible that legally it was in the contract. Yeah.
0:31:25And the movie studios came to Apple and Amazon and Google and said,
0:31:31here's how,
0:31:31here's what we're building to enforce this part of the contract. So we,
0:31:36you need to do this. So it may be that it wasn't even a negotiation.
0:31:39It may have already been in the deal and that they decided this is how we want
0:31:43to implement this. Now here's a date, you know, please. And, and for,
0:31:47for Apple's part, it sounds like, you know, or any of these companies part,
0:31:52They have to do some authentication and they have to accept some like movie IDs as being
0:31:59granted. It's a development project though. Somebody at Apple had to spend time building
0:32:04this stuff and that allows people to take content out of their ecosystem and likewise
0:32:08for Amazon and Google.
0:32:09And as you can imagine, US only.
0:32:12For now. For now.
0:32:14But those for now's are infinite.
0:32:16Well the fact is yeah, we talk about contracts. It's a different contract.
0:32:21in every single region and so that's a mess. It is a mess. But I think there's hope here
0:32:28because what this suggests is that the big players in digital distribution and the studios
0:32:36all feel that this is the way forward or mostly feel that this is the way forward. So it may
0:32:43end up everywhere over time just because nobody wants to do it the old way.
0:32:49the old way. This just becomes the way. Yeah, you get a movie, it's got a code inside, you
0:32:55put that code in at Movies Anywhere and it pops up in your library. Right? You just buy
0:33:01a movie on iTunes and it's on your Fire Stick. Yeah, I'm interested to see since Blu-rays
0:33:07are physical objects, they're going to have to print inserts and put them in there, how
0:33:10long that takes to turn over but I assume every Blu-ray is going to have a code in it
0:33:15now for this purpose using Movies Anywhere and that'll be an interesting experience too.
0:33:22But I'm much more inclined to buy a Blu-ray knowing that I get the full HD version on
0:33:28all the services. The problem is that these guys are also working against themselves if
0:33:33they really want to sell Blu-rays instead of digital copies because I almost always
0:33:37buy the digital copy now because it comes out like a month before Blu-ray does. And
0:33:43And I'm not as obsessive with the Blu-ray quality as John Syracuse is.
0:33:47I don't want boxes in my house. I don't want more boxes.
0:33:49Well, and I'm ripping all my Blu-rays and putting them in Plex, right? And so the goal
0:33:54there is that those Blu-rays are going to end up in a box in the garage. They're not
0:33:58going to be in my house anymore.
0:34:00But then it's like, I don't want that. I just want the digital movies.
0:34:02Yeah. Well, it's a lot less clutter if you do that, which is usually what wins the day
0:34:07for me. It's like Wonder Woman, Spider-Man Homecoming. I just bought the iTunes version.
0:34:11And now, I got them everywhere.
0:34:15Today's episode is brought to you by Squarespace.
0:34:17Use the offer code upgrade at checkout and you'll get 10% off your first purchase.
0:34:21Squarespace lets you easily create the website that you have for your next idea or project.
0:34:25You can make your next move with Squarespace.
0:34:27They have all of the tools that you need.
0:34:29You can take advantage of beautiful award winning templates, let your ideas shine.
0:34:33You can grab a unique domain name for your website so you can give it the brand and identity
0:34:36that you're looking for.
0:34:37You have 24/7 customer support in case you need any help.
0:34:41nothing to install, no patches to worry about, no upgrades needed for Squarespace.
0:34:45You don't have to worry about it.
0:34:46They've got it covered.
0:34:47All of the hosting is taken care of.
0:34:49They're adding new things to the platform all the time.
0:34:51You can add a store to your site.
0:34:53You can have portfolios, blogs.
0:34:54It doesn't matter what type of website you're looking to build.
0:34:56Squarespace have the tools to let you do it.
0:34:58You can sign up for a free trial today with no credit card acquired
0:35:01just by going to squarespace.com and their plans start at just $12 a month.
0:35:05When you decide to sign up, use the offer code upgrade
0:35:08and you'll get 10% off your first purchase and you'll be showing your support for this
0:35:12show. We thank Squarespace for their support of Relay FM. Squarespace, make your next move,
0:35:16make your next website. So last week it was announced that Steven Spielberg's Amazing
0:35:22Stories is to be rebooted for Apple's video efforts project. I don't really know how
0:35:28to reference that right now but Apple's video thing. Yeah I struggled in writing like
0:35:33through 4,000 words about this last week to describe it this way but it's Apple's presumably
0:35:39forthcoming video service or video offering. We're going to talk about it like it's happening
0:35:45mostly because there's no way it isn't because they hired those two executives and according
0:35:51to the Wall Street Journal gave them a billion dollar budget and now they're signing on Steven
0:35:57Spielberg properties like these aren't going to be in we're going to get these just aren't
0:36:01gonna be in Apple Music anymore. We'll get to that in a minute.
0:36:03Yeah, Zach von Amberg and Jamie Ehrlich.
0:36:08Mm-hmm. The Breaking Bad guys, right?
0:36:10Are the guys, well they're Sony.
0:36:11Sony.
0:36:12Which did Breaking Bad, they're not writers, they're, you know,
0:36:16they're development executives.
0:36:17They bring the deals in.
0:36:18And, yeah, exactly. And then they hired somebody from, I think,
0:36:21WGN America, and they've got a whole...
0:36:25A serious team.
0:36:25And apparently in Culver City in LA, so they're like, that's the Apple
0:36:30Powered
0:36:32Service office that's got all these TV producers. They're in the industry. This is not
0:36:36This is not carpool karaoke and Planet of the Apps and it's those are easy jokes to make
0:36:44But that was like that was literally like Eddie Q and his and the and the beats people
0:36:49Messing around with that way. That's what Eddie did right? That's what they did. That's what Jimmy Iovine did
0:36:56Yeah, and then they were like, oh these suck
0:37:00Yeah, and we need to be serious about this and we're gonna do this that was their test stuff
0:37:05But we need to be serious. So so it was like version one. Yeah, so people who try to say
0:37:10Oh, well, they got to do better than carpool karaoke
0:37:12Yeah, this is all about that
0:37:14And this is not gonna be like the next one will be amazing stories and then in six months
0:37:19There will be another Apple video product. That's also not gonna happen
0:37:23giving these guys that budget is a
0:37:28Giving these guys that budget is a sign that they're they're gonna make lots of deals lots of deals
0:37:34So let's talk about this one
0:37:36What is amazing stories because it's this is a reboot of an existing property right what what is amazing stories
0:37:44I've never heard of it amazing stories is
0:37:46an anthology series from the 80s
0:37:50based on
0:37:53Basically a the name of a science fiction magazine from the 50s that's still being published
0:37:58So it was kind of like the Twilight Zone except
0:38:02Lighter and not as good
0:38:07I would say there are a lot of people who have who have very fond
0:38:10Memories of amazing stories my understanding is that those are the people who were sort of 10 years old when it premiered
0:38:15Yeah, I was 15. I was not impressed
0:38:17But some people liked it, but the idea is it's an anthology series
0:38:21So I think Black Mirror except not as dark as Black Mirror because there's nothing as dark as Black Mirror
0:38:26It's the black, but it's it's a little black so every yeah, so every episode is going to be
0:38:31different a different story okay, and
0:38:34It's like that um they say that Brian Fuller is gonna be the showrunner on it
0:38:38Is it American Horror Story? Is that like that? No that's anthologized across seasons, so you have one story across a season
0:38:44This is all right the the Iron Mankey show that's that's different things every episode. Yes
0:38:49I'm Amazon Black Mirror. I think it's like the most
0:38:52Relevance modern example although there's also a room something or other on HBO. That's like this showtime
0:39:00I don't want scary things. I don't know so this is this is that this is
0:39:04genre stories science fiction fantasy horror in
0:39:08Basically short stories so one episode tells a story and then the week type deal
0:39:14And that also means director and writer and stars of the week so that presumably they'll have
0:39:19well-known actors Black Mirror has a lot of very well-known actors in it because they're
0:39:22not committing to being on a series they're shooting a 60-minute movie and then they're
0:39:28gone. So it's gonna be like that. That's what that that's what that show is. Brian
0:39:32Fuller who created Star Trek Discovery who is the showrunner on American Gods. He did
0:39:37Hannibal he's done a bunch of other stuff. He's apparently the showrunner which is
0:39:42interesting because he's always sort of said his story for why he left Star Trek Discovery
0:39:49was that he was too busy running American Gods which always was suspicious but now it's
0:39:53like extra suspicious. Then again this is an anthology show so Brian Fuller is a good
0:39:59name.
0:40:00Steve: He was given a lot of money by Apple.
0:40:01Chris: Brian Fuller was given a, he's a good name to attach to it creatively and since
0:40:06it's an anthology series it may be a matter of like let's have Brian Fuller come in and
0:40:11define what this show is and pick what the stories are. But he doesn't necessarily have
0:40:17to, maybe he writes the first episode, but otherwise he's finding the writers and the
0:40:21directors and the stories that they're going to do. And then we'll see. But it's five million
0:40:26an episode for 10 episodes. That's, that feels like a big budget. Is that big? That's 50
0:40:31million, but it's out of a billion. So, you know, 20 of those, I mean, you know, obviously
0:40:35you know, I'd say that's a standard like big budget TV show thing. It's not, it's not cheap
0:40:41cheap. But I think the Star Trek Discovery episodes cost like 7 million an episode, 8
0:40:46million an episode. Game of Thrones is probably more like 10 million an episode.
0:40:50A billion an episode.
0:40:51So the dragons are really expensive is my understanding.
0:40:54They eat a lot.
0:40:56It's been reported as well that Apple are in lots of bidding wars. I mean there's lots
0:41:01of rumbling about all the bidding wars that they're in.
0:41:03So they got a billion dollars, right? So they are talking to people and they're bidding
0:41:08on content. And so the best example, Ryan Murphy who did American Horror, does American
0:41:14Horror Story has, and Glee and I mean a bunch of stuff.
0:41:19What a tone shift.
0:41:21Glee is the outlier for him, I gotta say. Most of his stuff is…
0:41:24It's like a little dark and then the happiest, happiest ever.
0:41:26Nip/Tuck was him too, which is a super weird show.
0:41:29Wow, okay. What an interesting portfolio.
0:41:32- Yeah, oh yeah, he's an interesting guy.
0:41:34I don't love his stuff, but he is, he is,
0:41:36he knows what he is doing and what he's good at.
0:41:41So he's got a show called "Ratchet," which is based,
0:41:44it's like, it's a little, you know how they did
0:41:46the Psycho prequel, which is called "Bates Motel."
0:41:50This is like evil nurse Ratchet from "One Flew Over
0:41:54the Cuckoo's Nest," and it's like how she became
0:41:57- Oh wow.
0:41:57- Evil nurse Ratchet.
0:41:59That's the show, bidding wars over it.
0:42:02Apple was apparently strongly involved
0:42:05in bidding for that show and didn't get it.
0:42:08- They lost to Netflix.
0:42:09- Apparently Netflix got it by packaging together
0:42:14a super sweet deal for American Horror Story
0:42:17to continue streaming on Netflix
0:42:19and a two season commitment to Ratched.
0:42:24So they put, basically they were like,
0:42:25we're gonna give you all the money up front.
0:42:27And Apple kind of was like, no, we're not gonna,
0:42:29feels rich for Netflix maybe made a deal to push Apple out right like they're
0:42:33trying to make sure that Apple isn't get that say and we should say Netflix is
0:42:37content acquisition budget is about seven billion dollars next year so
0:42:41Apple's only Apple's not leaping to that you can't I mean you can't go from zero
0:42:47to seven you can't go to the millions that doesn't you can't come through one
0:42:51billion is stage one of this but the point is they're playing in this game
0:42:54and they've got money to spend which is why the Spielberg deal is interesting
0:42:58So on the podcast I do with Tim Goodman on the Uncomfortable TV Talk Machine, we've been
0:43:03talking about this a while. And in fact, for a couple of weeks we've been saying, "Wait
0:43:07for it. There will be a big name attached to Apple. They will make a splash." And this
0:43:14is it, I guess I would say.
0:43:16Steven Spielberg's a pretty big splash.
0:43:18But this is the first in a series of deals. Like, there will be another one in a few weeks.
0:43:25There will be another one after that. They will make with a billion dollars, they could
0:43:28buy 20 shows. They're not going to do that. They'll probably buy 10 shows and like HBO
0:43:33has got probably 15 shows going over the course of a year. I think Apple wants to get to maybe
0:43:39that level. Probably won't get the right off. They'll probably fund some original movies
0:43:44too. They'll buy some movies. We'll see in the next, I mean I feel like I can tell you
0:43:48what is going to happen in the next six months. They're going to make a deal with an actor
0:43:51that you've heard of. They're going to make a deal with the creator of a show that you
0:43:55It's a Boardwalk Empire type deal, right? Let's find a big movie actor and put them
0:43:59in a TV show.
0:44:01Yeah, I mean, and there was a rumor that they're talking to Vince Gilligan who did Breaking
0:44:04Bad.
0:44:05Jennifer Aniston apparently as well.
0:44:06Yeah, well there's a show with Jennifer Aniston and somebody else that has been shopped around
0:44:10that they've been talking about. Vince Gilligan and Bryan Cranston from Breaking Bad have
0:44:16both apparently been like talking to them. Apple's also trying to talk to people and
0:44:20these guys who… these guys have a relationship with the Breaking Bad guys, but they're
0:44:24also talking to people who they like but they've never worked with before. So, Hollywood Reporter
0:44:30did a good story about this. So, those are going to pay off. Some of those deals are
0:44:34going to get made and people are going to be all of a sudden people are going to look
0:44:37in like six months and they're going to be like, "Oh, Apple's already got five shows
0:44:41in production." It's still going to take until like the end of next year before they show
0:44:44up but that's going to happen and because they got a billion dollars to spend and they
0:44:50will go to film festivals. That's going to happen. They're going to go to a film festival
0:44:53and they're gonna buy some movies. And people are gonna go like, "Where are those going?"
0:44:57And the answer is going to be, they're going wherever all this other stuff is going on
0:45:01Apple's stuff. And they will buy some catalog stuff too. They'll buy streaming rights.
0:45:06Do you think so?
0:45:07Yeah, they'll, I feel like, there's a question about what this service is, but I feel like
0:45:14if it's only these originals, it's gonna feel kinda skimpy. So I would imagine that they
0:45:19will buy some films and they'll probably play it as, you know, these are some of the most
0:45:28popular movies on iTunes and now you can stream them for free with your subscription.
0:45:33Do you think just movies? Do you think they're trying to do TV?
0:45:37Maybe.
0:45:38Why, like, you wrote a great piece which came out from like a long Twitter exchange which
0:45:44I was unfortunately swept off into that you had over the weekend and brought about a lot
0:45:49stuff and there's one thing you mentioned in here it's like why not just buy Hulu?
0:45:53Well so Tim Goodman says that he thinks that's what they should do.
0:45:59Hulu is owned by three TV networks and a cable company.
0:46:05The TV networks it's a real question whether they want Hulu, they're almost like frenemies
0:46:11to Hulu like they all probably want to do their own streaming services like ABC Disney
0:46:16owns part of Hulu. But they're going to launch their own streaming services. So why are they
0:46:22in Hulu? The idea was Hulu was a thing that networks could do to claim that they were
0:46:28doing something in streaming video when they weren't.
0:46:30It was an as well thing. Like we're also here as well.
0:46:33We also were present, right? It was a tough thing for them to do. They've always had this.
0:46:38So what Tim has suggested is if Apple buys Hulu, they get Hulu's original content, they
0:46:44They get Hulu's streaming deals, at least for a while,
0:46:47'cause those are all renegotiable.
0:46:49They get Hulu's infrastructure.
0:46:51If you think about Beats Music,
0:46:53Apple Music is built on the back of Beats Music,
0:46:55'cause it's already built.
0:46:56- That's the example to push.
0:46:58You'd be like, "Oh, why would they do that?"
0:47:00Well, they did it already, right?
0:47:01Apple wanted to launch a streaming music service,
0:47:04so they bought one, and then changed it into their own.
0:47:07- And Hulu actually has a live TV service, too,
0:47:09that could be integrated directly into Apple TV.
0:47:11Because the real key is like, okay so let's just say this thing costs $10 a month. There
0:47:17has to be stuff there. You can't start charging $10 a month when you have just one show, right?
0:47:23Because CBS All Access is charging $5 a month for essentially Star Trek Discovery. Although
0:47:28they've got, even they have their CBS back catalog.
0:47:31The stuff.
0:47:32That's why I think they have to have catalog stuff. So even if they don't buy Hulu, which
0:47:36would cost them like $25 billion. It would be a very expensive purchase, but Apple might
0:47:42be actually a better owner for Hulu than the networks and cable companies that own it now.
0:47:48Counter argument to Hulu, Apple buying Hulu is if they bought Hulu, Hulu's got its own
0:47:51programming executives and their own original content. They wouldn't necessarily have needed
0:47:55to hire these guys, but it doesn't preclude them from still buying Hulu.
0:48:00When I think about buying, they're really buying it for technology if they want to use
0:48:05it but they're buying out the contracts that's that's the value is yeah he's
0:48:09buying and they would they would own the Handmaid's Tale which won the Emmy for
0:48:13Best Drama they would just own it like they want Apple won awards so bad oh oh
0:48:18sure well that's definitely gonna be part of the part of the story right is
0:48:20that the Apple wants to is gonna want to win an Emmy Award for something so good
0:48:24for Amazon yeah it's done really well for Hulu yeah Hulu is on the map now
0:48:27because of the Handmaid's Tale in a way that they weren't like I think like
0:48:30transparent and stuff like the amount of awards transparent one it's like it it's
0:48:34It's legit.
0:48:35And what's that thing?
0:48:36Yeah, man, the high castle did that too.
0:48:37Is that the quote from Bezos?
0:48:38"Every time we win an Emmy, we sell more shoes" or something like that?
0:48:42Like it's, you know, I love that quote.
0:48:44It makes total sense, but like it's funny.
0:48:46That's the way he thinks too.
0:48:48So if they don't buy Hulu though, I do think that they need something.
0:48:50So maybe it's old TV shows.
0:48:53Old TV shows seems like a weirder fit for them than old movies.
0:48:59But yeah.
0:49:00You throw The Office and Parks and Rec and 30 Rock, you know.
0:49:01They can also buy a lesser streaming service and throw those or a few and throw them all
0:49:07together so like exists like like acorn is a good example acorn. Well you wouldn't because
0:49:13you get it in Britain. It's called television. Acorn is a a primarily British TV streaming
0:49:20service that's got some European TV as well, but it's primarily like British current and
0:49:26classic British TV and that it's a niche streamer and they could buy some little streamers and
0:49:34put them together, make some deals for some movies and call it a day and have a better
0:49:40package of stuff to show. But I do, I agree, if they do ten original series, they're not
0:49:46going to roll them out at once, right? Because then they'll run for ten weeks and then they'll
0:49:50be done and then what? Then there's nothing. The crickets are dripping on the surface.
0:49:54get no push on any of them when there's too many.
0:49:56So think about HBO's originals, right? HBO's got two or three originals on, maybe four
0:50:01at a time, and they are staggered across time. That's kind of the level they need to offer.
0:50:06It would, if that was all, would it be enough? Maybe, but I feel like there's, you know,
0:50:10I don't want to overstate this, but I think it's important for them to have some catalog
0:50:14stuff too. And the movies make sense to me from a, like a PR perspective of like, also
0:50:18we've got these, this great selection of movies that's favorites from the iTunes catalog that
0:50:22you can watch for free. That's how you spin it, but in reality it's like we made some
0:50:26content deals for some old movies just like HBO does. Because HBO's got, you know, some
0:50:31recent releases and then they've got a catalog of old, weird old stuff. Like I watched Batman
0:50:36Forever on HBO because we were doing it for the incomparable and I went to Fan TV, which
0:50:44is like a streaming catalog, and they're like, "Oh, it's on HBO Go." I'm like, "Great." And
0:50:48terrible but it was there so I could watch that so free do you think do you
0:50:53think this is a separate service this is gonna be Apple music right big question
0:50:57because it really feels like you put in a billion dollars into this don't call
0:51:00it music when it's not music well if they if they rolled into Apple music
0:51:04they'd have to change the name I think that would be bad for everything if I
0:51:08had to pick I would pick if I had a guess about what's gonna happen I'd say
0:51:12it's a separate service because music consumers and video consumers are
0:51:16different. Apple wants more money from consumers. Maybe they offer a bundle or something. But
0:51:21it's like it's a separate service. Amazon you get video when you get Prime. You still
0:51:25have to pay extra if you want the full music library. They still have that as a separate
0:51:28service. Google is talking about rolling Play into YouTube Red. Google Play All Music, All
0:51:37Access Music.
0:51:38Geoff - Now they're like saying if you get YouTube Music is what they're really pushing
0:51:43now.
0:51:44Well, the Google Play Music is going to get rolled in there too. But it's like $15 a month.
0:51:51It's not a $9, $7 a month video service at that point. So, my gut feeling is it will
0:51:56be a, we'll say $10 a month, maybe it's $7 a month or $5 a month with a 90-day trial.
0:52:03So when you get an Apple TV, you get three months of it for free and all of that is there.
0:52:08They'll do that and then maybe there's a bundle where you can get the package deal for both
0:52:14Apple Music and Apple whatever.
0:52:16Yeah, they already used a good name. So, Apple TV is taken.
0:52:21I think Apple TV is a good name for it anyway. I think that Apple, why not just, the TV app
0:52:27is already there, right?
0:52:28Yeah, it just becomes Apple TV Box and the Apple TV service.
0:52:31And there's an argument about like, well what about movies? Movies aren't TV. It's
0:52:34like Apple has, with the TV app, Apple has already said that they consider any video
0:52:39that you watch on a device that you own TV.
0:52:41But you're watching it on even the movies you watch them on the TV.
0:52:44Yeah, right. Or on your iPad but there's a TV app on your iPad so you're either watching
0:52:48it on your TV via an Apple TV or you're watching it on your iPad or iPhone via the TV app.
0:52:53It's all TV. So I think the Apple TV as a product you know conflating it with Apple
0:53:00TV as a service maybe that's I don't know maybe that's been the plan all along but I
0:53:04feel like…
0:53:05It's a way to help sell Apple TV.
0:53:06But I feel like that's the idea and then and then it's only available on the Apple
0:53:10TV as a streamer box. And so if you want Apple TV, you get an Apple TV and then you get Apple
0:53:16TV.
0:53:17Is that a problem? Because like if I want Netflix shows, if I want Amazon shows, I can
0:53:21get them mostly anywhere. If Apple creates their own TV shows, should they restrict it
0:53:28on the Apple and iOS devices and TV devices?
0:53:32Depends on what they want to do, right? I think Apple has this kind of vision of their
0:53:37revenue as a combination of things. If this was a pure services revenue thing, they would
0:53:46put it everywhere.
0:53:47MATT: Make an app for Android.
0:53:48JASON: But they want…
0:53:50MATT; Apple Music's on Android.
0:53:52JASON; Yeah, but is that the legacy of there being beats on Android?
0:53:56MATT; I don't know. I don't think so.
0:53:58JASON; They had an existing app…
0:53:59MATT; They could have just shut that down.
0:54:00JASON; An existing developer. They could have. It's a good counter argument and I thought
0:54:05about that and it's possible. My gut feeling is the most likely scenario is Apple wants
0:54:11this to be a revenue generator for services but their whole services strategy is to get
0:54:16more revenue out of people who are their customers, not get random services revenue from people
0:54:23who don't have Apple products. So that they, I think they want to view this as a way to
0:54:27drive people to buy an Apple TV.
0:54:29I think that would be a mistake.
0:54:33I don't know. I could go either way. I mean...
0:54:35Because the Apple TV is too expensive.
0:54:37Does Apple... The question is, does Apple want this service,
0:54:41does Apple want the Apple TV service to be everywhere and...
0:54:47Or do they want it to be a lever to use to get people to buy an Apple device?
0:54:52I think if the plan is, which I think it's obvious is more services revenue,
0:54:57I think the best thing you do is make it available to everybody.
0:55:02If your goal is we want to get more recurring revenue the easiest way to do that is to put it on Android as well
0:55:09I think it's a good argument. You open it up to anyone with a device. Yeah, it's a good it's a good argument
0:55:14I see they're good arguments on either side. Yeah, so I
0:55:17Don't know what the right thing to do from a business standpoint is
0:55:21I do know that if I put myself in the mind of Apple. Mm-hmm
0:55:28Restricting it to Apple hardware seems most likely thing to do
0:55:32Yeah
0:55:33But the precedent of Apple music on Android is what puts a question mark over my head because Apple music is the same
0:55:39strategy it's the strategy of we need recurring revenue so what I would also say is
0:55:44This is a video service it wouldn't shock me if what they do is they put it on
0:55:51Android and
0:55:54They put it in iTunes on Mac and PC
0:55:58but restricted to Apple TV as a streamer box
0:56:02and say look if you want our TV service on your TV
0:56:05- No that's what I think they would do
0:56:06they put it on Android so you can watch it on the go
0:56:08but if you want to watch it on the television
0:56:10the only way to watch it
0:56:11- Buy our box
0:56:12- Yeah they won't be on
0:56:13they won't make an Amazon Fire app
0:56:15they won't make a Chromecast compatible thing
0:56:17but I think they would make an Android app
0:56:19to watch it on the go
0:56:20- And people will say oh well this is ridiculous
0:56:22I'm never gonna pay money for this
0:56:23I'm never gonna buy an Apple TV for it
0:56:25Okay, but when they announce that fill in the blank creator of your favorite show has
0:56:33a new show with fill in the blank star that you love.
0:56:37Breaking Bad 2.
0:56:38Yeah, from the producers of Breaking Bad starring this amazing set cast that you love and then
0:56:44there's this other show that also sounds really cool that they're doing and they're only on
0:56:48Apple TV, then you start to go, "Well, Apple TV also does do Netflix and Amazon. It's a
0:56:55little expensive but it's the only way I'm going to get to watch the show and will everybody
0:57:00do that?" No, of course not. There's a lot of arguments in the tech world are, "Well,
0:57:04everybody won't do it and therefore it will be a failure." And it's like, this is what
0:57:07I hear about the Star Trek being on CBS All Access instead of Netflix in the US. And they're
0:57:12like, "Oh, well, not as many people are going to watch it so it's a failure." It's like,
0:57:16actually, they're going to make…
0:57:18CBS will make more money this way.
0:57:19They're building an entire streaming service on the back of this thing. It's probably
0:57:23going to work for them. They probably don't care that it's going to be 10% of the viewers
0:57:28that they would get if they put it on television because that's not the point. The point
0:57:32is the money and the ongoing subscriber revenue and all of those things. So, that's what
0:57:39I come back to with the Apple thing is, yeah, they're going to suppress viewership. The
0:57:42The only people who care about the fact that that amazing new show is not going to be seen
0:57:46potentially by as many people because it requires you to have Apple hardware are the people
0:57:51who are creating the shows because they want to be seen.
0:57:55And that's Tim Goodman wrote this piece of the Hollywood Reporter.
0:57:57It's a really great piece.
0:57:58Part of the deal here is money talks in Hollywood but they also care about the things they make,
0:58:05the creators and there is some risk that if Apple's service is perceived as being super
0:58:15limited then it will make deals go sour.
0:58:25When do you think we're going to start to see some of this stuff happening?
0:58:31Next fall.
0:58:32- Okay.
0:58:33- I can't--
0:58:34- So you reckon a couple of shows
0:58:36will be announced as in development?
0:58:37Like was this--
0:58:38- Well no, I think in the next six months,
0:58:42Apple will make, will close like--
0:58:44- Lots of deals.
0:58:45- 10 deals.
0:58:46- So was this 12, 15 deals? - 12, 15 deals.
0:58:48- Officially announced or was it--
0:58:50- Just reported.
0:58:51Although it's been reported for a while
0:58:53that they've been talking and talking to Apple,
0:58:56but this is the Wall Street Journal reported this.
0:58:58- But like, was this reported as a rumor
0:59:00or was it like, this is an official release, this is done?
0:59:03- Both, it was, it was, oh, it hasn't been official.
0:59:05- Oh, okay, okay.
0:59:06- It is reported by the Wall Street Journal
0:59:07as having happened.
0:59:09- Okay.
0:59:10- Not as rumored, but as a fact that they made this deal.
0:59:13- Right.
0:59:14- Previously in the Hollywood Reporter,
0:59:15it was rumored that they were talking.
0:59:17But Wall Street Journal anyway says it happened,
0:59:19deal is done.
0:59:21So, but they haven't said anything about it.
0:59:23And I think that's one of the challenges here
0:59:24is that Apple probably doesn't want to say anything
0:59:26about this until they have a service to launch.
0:59:29So we may just get a lot of leaks from,
0:59:31Wall Street Journal's a little surprising,
0:59:33I think we're gonna get a lot of leaks from Variety
0:59:34and the Hollywood Reporter and Deadline.
0:59:36- I mean, Wall Street Journal would have been surprising,
0:59:39but it's technology, it's technology related, right?
0:59:41They can just do our sources, they're gonna get it.
0:59:42- At some point-- - But it is better for Apple
0:59:44to be in Variety and the Hollywood Reporter,
0:59:46'cause that's where the industry is and cares.
0:59:49- So the deals are gonna happen over the next six months.
0:59:53I would say you're gonna see rolling thunder from Apple.
0:59:56Like it's gonna be-- - It's very serious.
0:59:58It's going to be a lot of deals. People are going to, it's not going to be just amazing
1:00:02stories, right? I feel like these guys are there to make deals and they've been given
1:00:07money according to Wall Street Journal. They've been given a billion dollars to make deals.
1:00:10They're going to make deals.
1:00:11And I bet if they needed more money, they'll get it, right?
1:00:13My guess is that Apple has an idea of like, we want to launch this in the fall. We want
1:00:16to announce it in June at WWDC and we'll launch it in the fall or we'll announce it. They'll
1:00:22probably announce it in June and we'll announce the launch date at the iPhone event in the
1:00:27fall and it will launch sometime in the fall. And that sometime will probably be determined
1:00:31by when the shows are ready, but that's about how long it takes. Like to go from making
1:00:38a deal to doing, having a script, doing the casting, setting up the production, shooting
1:00:44the show, editing the show, that takes time. It takes a lot of time to make a TV show.
1:00:49So I think it's most likely that it'll be a new Apple TV service next fall.
1:00:57What do you think about originals versus existing properties?
1:01:07For Apple launching this now, does it make sense for them to try and create purely original
1:01:13things or is it more sensible for them to do stuff like buying an old series and rebooting
1:01:17it?
1:01:18Well, this is a programming question and it's the same with Netflix. Netflix's strategy
1:01:23is get something for everyone and Netflix releases so many shows because they're paying
1:01:28seven times as much as Apple is going to pay.
1:01:29I can't believe the amount of originals they have. There's so many that I've never heard
1:01:33of.
1:01:34Yeah. And it's so easy to miss them. And they will also do, they'll do Fuller House, right?
1:01:40They'll do a broad sitcom that's not going to appeal necessarily to the same people to
1:01:45whom Stranger Things appeals.
1:01:47Or Knuckles or something.
1:01:48Or yeah, exactly, or Bloodline or Master of None.
1:01:52- Or BoJack.
1:01:53- That would be a great game show is like,
1:01:56we go back and forth trying to name
1:01:58as many Netflix originals as possible,
1:02:00but it might be too long, it goes on forever.
1:02:02- But my favorite thing about Netflix
1:02:05being outside of the US is all of the deals
1:02:07that they do with US networks.
1:02:08So we love Jane the Virgin.
1:02:10- So, right.
1:02:11- And now it is streaming weekly on Netflix.
1:02:15- Which Netflix, and that's counter to Netflix's brand,
1:02:17because Netflix's brand is about dropping a whole season and binging it, but Netflix
1:02:21has made a lot of deals. They're doing that with Star Trek Discovery too. And it comes
1:02:26out every week and there are a lot of US shows that instead of making a deal with a British
1:02:29TV channel and then a French TV channel and a German TV channel, they just make a deal
1:02:34with Netflix. Netflix buys it for the whole world and you get it the next day everywhere
1:02:38in the world and it releases weekly. It's really good. So that's a nice sidebar which
1:02:44is I expect that Apple will roll this service out if not initially then very rapidly internationally.
1:02:51This is a thing that Apple has over Amazon and Google which is they really try to play
1:02:57internationally with their entertainment services and like Amazon is bad at that. Amazon is
1:03:03in like a handful of countries. So I imagine these deals that they're making, they're going
1:03:07to make for the originals anyway. They're going to make for worldwide.
1:03:09Adam: Yeah, because they own the content so they can put it wherever they want, right?
1:03:13And they already have the distribution method.
1:03:15Right.
1:03:16But like if all the original stuff, it would be easy.
1:03:17There's well, we're making the deals.
1:03:19So like we'll just decide it's going to be worldwide.
1:03:21So in terms of what the programming is, I don't think they don't have a $7 billion budget.
1:03:25I don't think they're going to cast a wide net like Netflix.
1:03:28I don't think they're going to make Fuller House.
1:03:30HBO is what I keep coming back to.
1:03:32You could say Showtime, you could say Stars.
1:03:34But I feel like Apple, Apple feels like a premium cable to me, like in terms of their
1:03:41brand.
1:03:42Yeah, so far they've not done a good job of that, but it's all Apple Music though, right?
1:03:46So that's a good thing. So they didn't launch the TV service with Carpool Karaoke.
1:03:51So this is the question is in that meeting with
1:03:54Eddie Q and maybe Tim Cook and
1:03:56And Zach and Jamie the TV executives. What did they say about the brand of Apple?
1:04:02Like what did they say? We want to be family-friendly. Did they say we want to be like HBO?
1:04:06Did they say we want to be like Netflix? What did they say? My gut feeling is they want to be HBO
1:04:11They want prestige they want to win awards, but they also want Game of Thrones
1:04:15Everybody in the TV industry wants Game of Thrones Jeff Bezos wants the names next Game of Thrones
1:04:20Netflix wants the next Game of Thrones everybody wants that so of course they said that but that's my gut feeling is like HBO is a
1:04:27Good model because they have huge international hits. They've got prestige
1:04:31They win awards they got comedies. They got dramas. They got some docu series and
1:04:39They wrap all that up and that's their service that they sell to cable subscribers or over the top with HBO now
1:04:47So that's my gut feeling is that is that maybe it'll be a little different
1:04:51There's a question about like how how gritty will they get if they get like a really grim and gritty thing?
1:04:56Will Apple be concerned about that being part of the Apple brand?
1:04:59I think that gets overplayed where people talk about Apple and Disney and Pixar
1:05:02I think I think it gets overstated sell the movies and TV show will be tea
1:05:06- Yeah, there will be rated R, TVMA content.
1:05:11- You can buy Game of Thrones on iTunes.
1:05:14- Yeah, you can buy the underrated versions
1:05:17of movies on iTunes.
1:05:18- Didn't know that.
1:05:19- So I don't think, but those aren't from Apple, right?
1:05:22Those are from a studio in Apple's The Reseller.
1:05:24This is like from Apple, Apple Presents.
1:05:27But I still think, my gut feeling is,
1:05:29it's still gonna be stuff like HBO.
1:05:30- Because the thing is, if the plan is you want the awards,
1:05:34well, sometimes people are gonna get naked.
1:05:36'Cause that's what happens in award-winning TV shows.
1:05:39- It's true.
1:05:40- You're just gonna have to deal with that.
1:05:41Like it can't, these two things come together.
1:05:43- They're not all gonna be like that.
1:05:44But I think they will push the envelope with some stuff
1:05:46and then they'll have some other stuff that is less so.
1:05:49It wouldn't surprise me if they're not quite as aggressive
1:05:51with the adult content as HBO,
1:05:54that some of their stuff will be more adult
1:05:56and some of the stuff will be more kind of like TV level.
1:06:01- Yeah.
1:06:02- They'll lose some TV and some cable TV
1:06:03a balance. Because not everybody wants stuff like that.
1:06:08But that's my gut feeling is that they'll do that and that the first slate will reflect
1:06:13that. But we'll see. We'll see what the marching orders are that these execs have been given
1:06:17because that's part of the deal. That's their magic stuff is they know people but they also
1:06:21are trying to adhere to what the promise of the brand is. What are they trying to bring
1:06:28to people because in the end Apple does want to build a service where people know it has
1:06:34an identity like I know what I get when I subscribe to Apple TV like I know what I get
1:06:39when I subscribe to HBO or Showtime.
1:06:42I bet you're so happy about this because this is just like Jason's wheelhouse.
1:06:47My world's colliding here.
1:06:48TV and technology.
1:06:49It is pretty awesome.
1:06:51Well it's fun.
1:06:52I mean I love talking about it.
1:06:55I will say it does frustrate me when I hear the carpool karaoke jokes because they are
1:07:02justified. Planet of the Apps jokes are the best too because that was not a show I liked.
1:07:09They are justified to joke about that because Apple's flailing kind of attempts at TV have
1:07:14been not great. But they hired these guys.
1:07:19All of this was done before they hired these people.
1:07:21Right.
1:07:21Like it was done.
1:07:22Yeah, they hired these guys in June. That was the day. That day in June. That was the
1:07:29day that Apple got serious about this.
1:07:30That was the time that Eddy got taken off the project, right?
1:07:32Yeah, well I think they report to Eddy, but one of the good things about Eddy Cue, I think,
1:07:38is that he knows to put the professionals in charge of their business. And this is like,
1:07:44these guys are set up in Culver City and they're doing Apple TV. And that's what they're doing.
1:07:48And that was the day that Apple got serious about video.
1:07:50And all the jokes are totally earned, but if you're analyzing Apple making a deal with
1:07:56Spielberg using the lens of Planet of the Apps...
1:07:59You're looking at it wrong.
1:08:01Yeah, that's malpractice.
1:08:02You're looking at it wrong.
1:08:03So the downside of this is I've been paying attention to this long enough that I see those
1:08:08takes, I've seen those takes in the last week, and they infuriate me.
1:08:12Because that's somebody who is either willfully misunderstanding or just completely doesn't
1:08:20get it.
1:08:21It's just dying to make the joke, right?
1:08:22Yeah, the joke is more important.
1:08:24And it's like, hey, we should all laugh at Planet of the Apps.
1:08:26Do you know what?
1:08:27I bet there were some really bad Netflix originals, like at the start.
1:08:30I bet there were some terrible ones.
1:08:32Sure.
1:08:33But this is like even before, imagine like Netflix made its own TV series and put it
1:08:37out on DVDs before they had streaming.
1:08:40It's like the before time.
1:08:41is a hard line between when they hired these guys and what came before because that was
1:08:47the moment that Apple became a Hollywood player and those guys were hired in June but they
1:08:52didn't start until late August. So now is when this is all going to happen. Now they've
1:08:57taken, they started taking meetings and planning their attack. They've made one acquisition.
1:09:02There will be many more. Apple has enough money to buy 20 original series at an average
1:09:07of 50 million per. I don't think they'll do that and I think that the cost will be
1:09:12up and down. I think they'll buy some documentaries and I think they'll buy some movies and
1:09:16I think they'll do some other stuff but it'll be fun to see what they are. That's
1:09:20the thing that fascinates me about this too is like what is an Apple video service? What
1:09:24does it mean? Who is it for? What's it going to look like and what big names that are familiar
1:09:30to us are going to be attached to the Apple brand for the first time? That's kind of
1:09:34fun right like some matter you love who suddenly is going to be showing up on
1:09:37stage at an Apple event somewhere to promote their TV show they're all gonna
1:09:40be on stage oh yeah this is a life now Spielberg with King no bingo man with
1:09:48art with our keynote draft we're gonna have to start we're gonna have a whole
1:09:50section of our draft oh they're gonna Apple where they start a big TV shows
1:09:55they're like oh we have a new show with an in Bryant Cranston comes on the stage
1:09:59and he's vintage Apple jacket and he spends a few minutes talking about I
1:10:03I think you stole that from Drake.
1:10:05Today's show is brought to you by Balance.
1:10:08Balance have just launched Balance Open.
1:10:10This is a free open source Mac app for checking Coinbase.
1:10:13You may be familiar with the Balance team as they made Balance for Mac, which is an app
1:10:17that can monitor all your bank balances and card transactions.
1:10:20Coinbase, which is a popular marketplace for cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin and Ethereum,
1:10:25is what you use when you're looking at Balance Open.
1:10:28Balance Open is the best open source digital wallet
1:10:31to help you keep track of all of the cryptocurrency
1:10:34that you've got your fingers in.
1:10:35If you don't know anything about all of this stuff,
1:10:37it's totally fine.
1:10:38It's totally fine, don't worry about it.
1:10:40Balance are gonna help you.
1:10:41They wanna teach you about cryptocurrencies
1:10:43and they wanna give you a little head start
1:10:44to get you on your way.
1:10:46The first 1,000 people that go to bal.money/relay
1:10:49will get $2 in Ethereum, the Ethereum,
1:10:52I think it's called Ether,
1:10:53it's the Ethereum currency called Ether,
1:10:55for free as a gift from Balance.
1:10:56Go check it out today, find out more
1:10:58and try out Balance Open,
1:10:59and you can dip your toes into the world of cryptocurrency.
1:11:03Our thanks to Balance for their support of this show.
1:11:06Jason, it is time for #AskUpgrade.
1:11:09So people send in their questions every week,
1:11:11use the #AskUpgrade and they go into a lovely document
1:11:14which we can pull out.
1:11:15And today we will start with Andrew.
1:11:16And Andrew asked, "Mac desktops have the option
1:11:19"to get a magic mouse and a magic trackpad
1:11:21"when you buy them.
1:11:22"Is there a reason to do this?"
1:11:24- Well, this should be for you, right?
1:11:26Don't you have two input devices?
1:11:29So I use a Wacom tablet and a trackpad.
1:11:33So what I do, and I have and did use a mouse and trackpad,
1:11:37and I've got some RSI problems.
1:11:37- Yeah, I know other people who do the same thing
1:11:39because of RSI.
1:11:40They use certain movements they use on their off hand,
1:11:43and then they have another hand for other movements.
1:11:45- To find movement.
1:11:46So what you get to do is, by having two input methods,
1:11:49you get to give dominant hands a break,
1:11:53which is really good for RSI,
1:11:54so you're kind of moving around what you're doing.
1:11:57So say for example, just in general web browsing,
1:12:00and moving around the machine,
1:12:01if I'm panning around, I use the trackpad.
1:12:04If I'm trying to click something, I use my Wacom tablet.
1:12:07When I'm editing, my trackpad is used
1:12:09for navigating the timeline of logic, right?
1:12:12So I zoom around, zoom in,
1:12:13that's all with gestures with my right hand,
1:12:16and then my left hand is doing all the important work
1:12:18with Wacom tablet.
1:12:19So the reason to do this is that it gives you a way
1:12:22to kind of mix everything up, and if you get used to it,
1:12:25it's a really efficient and kind of cool way.
1:12:28It kind of feels a bit minority report like
1:12:30to have your hands doing all this stuff at all times.
1:12:33So yeah, that's probably why they offer it
1:12:35because it is actually a nice pairing to have.
1:12:38Josh asked, "Will we ever see mouse pointer support
1:12:41on iOS or just the iPad?"
1:12:43Do you think we're ever gonna get a mouse for iOS?
1:12:46- Oh.
1:12:48- I feel like it's getting closer all the time.
1:12:49- I feel like it's getting closer
1:12:50and that anything that we would assume Apple
1:12:53would never do on the on iOS we need to throw away because they've done all sorts of things
1:12:58that we assume they would never do. I you know I posted my friend Chip wrote a story
1:13:03on six colors a couple years ago about Bluetooth pointing device support in iOS and I agree
1:13:11with him and I I feel like ever since they did the text insertion cursor thing that I
1:13:18I wish they would just support Bluetooth pointing devices.
1:13:21Just like support them for that.
1:13:25And maybe for some other gestures, right?
1:13:27Like it doesn't have to be a big thing,
1:13:29but I don't want a mouse,
1:13:32or I don't want a cursor on screen all the time
1:13:36that you click around on.
1:13:37I don't think that's the right interface for iOS.
1:13:40But I think that they could do more.
1:13:44I think that there are cases
1:13:45where a pointing device is useful.
1:13:47Selecting text. Let me tell you as somebody who writes all the time
1:13:51Selecting text that that that I beam cursor that they have where you put two fingers down on the iPad or your 3d touch on
1:13:59The on the iPhone it's great
1:14:02It frustrates me that I can't just have a trackpad
1:14:06When I'm sitting on my iPad sitting at my at a table looking at my iPad
1:14:13To do that like that would be great. Just the little text selection cursor. Yeah would be enough right? I don't need a
1:14:19Whole windowing system. That's all I need. So I hope they do it. The other thing is
1:14:25virtual like like
1:14:28Consoles like screens and all of that some of those there you can buy
1:14:32Citrix has a while ago
1:14:36You have to buy that special mouse Citrix have it and then jump desktop and the Citrix X1 Citrix X1 maps
1:14:42which I bought to try out and it works really great.
1:14:45Like, I would love to be able to use a mouse with Google Sheets
1:14:48because Google Sheets can get real complicated.
1:14:51Yeah.
1:14:51And if I could use a trackpad built into it,
1:14:54like just a trackpad built into the smart keyboard,
1:14:57I would be very happy with that.
1:14:59Also as somebody who has, who uses the iPad in a stand with a keyboard all the time.
1:15:04Yep.
1:15:04And you do too.
1:15:05Yep.
1:15:07I'd really rather when I'm, when all I'm doing is like scrolling and swiping,
1:15:11I would really love to be able to do that with while keeping my hands down.
1:15:15Yeah.
1:15:17I'll wait to score a webpage without scoring the screen.
1:15:19And this is nice, right? Please don't tell me to buy a laptop. No, no,
1:15:22don't do it. Don't, don't email Myke. Um, the, the, uh,
1:15:27the fact is you should not have to buy a Citrix mouse, right?
1:15:33Yeah. You should be able to use, again,
1:15:37individual apps could support it.
1:15:39It doesn't have to be that there's a big black arrow
1:15:41on the screen all the time.
1:15:43But like, yeah, if I'm in screens and I have a,
1:15:46I shouldn't, like screens has a mode
1:15:48where you use your iPhone as a track pad.
1:15:50And that's cool, but you know what's better than an iPhone
1:15:53as a track pad?
1:15:54- Track pad. - A track pad.
1:15:56- Funnily enough.
1:15:56- So if I have to do that, there are certain circumstances
1:15:59where I think it would be useful.
1:16:01I think the fear is that you're opening Pandora's box
1:16:04and turning it back into a Mac,
1:16:05but that's not what we're saying.
1:16:07Just like drag and drop and multitasking
1:16:10and all of these other things
1:16:11that they brought from the desktop,
1:16:13don't turn it into a Mac.
1:16:14It's a different take on it.
1:16:16I don't think iOS is a platform
1:16:18that can't take advantage of pointing devices
1:16:23because we've already seen that in certain cases it can.
1:16:27So why not just embrace that for the edge cases?
1:16:30It's not gonna be a fundamental part of the product,
1:16:32but for the edge cases, why not do that?
1:16:34Why not let the, here's the crazy ones
1:16:37who want to pair a trackpad, let's do it.
1:16:38And I will say, one of my thought exercises
1:16:42that I like to do is imagining a desktop iPad,
1:16:47you know, imagining a 24 inch iPad.
1:16:49Even if it's in a position where you can touch it
1:16:55and all of that, you're probably gonna have
1:16:57an external keyboard and a pointing device
1:17:00would be really good in that scenario too.
1:17:01- It might be a bit too big to be like
1:17:03just pulling stuff around on the screen all the time.
1:17:06- Yeah, but for gestures and flipping around and all that,
1:17:08yeah, you may not wanna always be touching the screen.
1:17:10- But like reaching the top right-hand corner of the screen,
1:17:12you know, if it's 24 inches,
1:17:14'cause it's probably gonna be suspended
1:17:15or like on the table or something.
1:17:17- And again, not asking for a Mac solution here
1:17:19where it just turns it into a Mac.
1:17:20I'm saying maybe products like that,
1:17:23and even an iPad that's sitting upright
1:17:25with a external keyboard could be improved
1:17:29by having the ability to add a pointing device.
1:17:32So Josh, the answer to your question is,
1:17:35I don't know if we're ever gonna see it,
1:17:37but I hope we do.
1:17:38I feel like the genie is out of the bottle
1:17:40with the iBeam cursor for text selection.
1:17:43Like if you're gonna allow us to move a cursor
1:17:45on the screen, Apple,
1:17:47let me have a device that lets me do it more easily.
1:17:50- Adam says, you guys both often discuss
1:17:53your frequent use of Dropbox and Google Docs.
1:17:57Why not do both files and docs in Google Drive?
1:18:00So one of the reasons for me is I forget that Google Drive is a storage solution
1:18:07for anything other than Google documents and photos.
1:18:11Which aren't really stored there.
1:18:13No.
1:18:13Right. It's just a link to the cloud.
1:18:14So this is why. Because the documents don't really exist in Google Drive,
1:18:18like the Google Docs stuff, I forget that I can put anything in it.
1:18:22Right? Because it's just like, well, this is just the place where files that don't exist exist.
1:18:28Yes, that's right.
1:18:29And the people that I collaborate with, everybody uses Dropbox.
1:18:33I'm not going to say to someone, "Hey, use Google Drive instead."
1:18:36And apps integrate better with the Dropbox API. That's why.
1:18:40So Google Drive is just where my docs live.
1:18:43It's not my storage solution.
1:18:46Yeah, I have not tried to do, like, shared folders and all of that.
1:18:50You're right, everybody's got Dropbox.
1:18:53It's the power of freemium too in a way that, like,
1:18:55even though you can get Google Drive with free space too, it's like,
1:18:58Everybody's got the Dropbox app installed everybody knows how to how to do that
1:19:02and so it's sort of like I've already adopted it and
1:19:05It and I think it's powerful. Also. It has the strength like so many apps do of being what Dropbox does
1:19:13Whereas Google Drive is not what Google does it's a an adjunct and so I feel like Dropbox is always going to be hungrier at
1:19:22Building features and reliability for Dropbox then Google is for Google Drive. They're very hungry with the design
1:19:29Have you seen my concern is that Dropbox is losing focus? Yeah, and now they're saying well, we're a
1:19:35We're really not a company for storage
1:19:37We're a place to
1:19:38Collaborate to collaborate and design and all that with Dropbox paper and all that's like no that's not what you are. Sorry
1:19:44Adrian wants to know Jason you still using todoist I am
1:19:51I went through a period I went through about a week where I forgot to open it
1:19:56But it was a weird week it was a and I was traveling and it was weird
1:20:02But yes, I am using it is I've got a bunch of monthly tasks in there for the six colors magazine
1:20:08I've got a bunch of weekly tasks, especially for download having to
1:20:11schedule
1:20:13Download podcast guests and make sure that the download topic list is is up and running. How's that going Steven?
1:20:20He's away doing it now. He's gone already
1:20:23and I have
1:20:25Podcast posting to do's in there now where I've got like free agents every other week
1:20:31There's a post so it's it's still on my calendar, but it's also in my to-do list
1:20:36My my complaints my issues with to-do lists are still
1:20:40that I
1:20:43Keep thinking of things based on that. I need to do them by a certain date, but they take more time and get frustrated
1:20:50that I can't say like I have this I have to watch so like I have to watch these movies
1:20:57for an incomparable episode recording on Friday. So I want a thing that says remember you have
1:21:02to watch two movies by Friday. Todoist doesn't want to do that. Todoist wants me to either
1:21:08put that on Friday in which case I'm not going to see it until it's too late or I have to
1:21:12create it earlier which is not the real deadline in order to tell me I could do that and have
1:21:17So you want like start dates. Yeah, yeah, this is, and we talked about this before,
1:21:21it's like that's one of the challenges I've got with it is it really thinks of like todoist
1:21:25as this is a relatively small thing you can check off on a certain day and that's not
1:21:32quite what I want. I wanted to kind of hover over me and say remember this needs to be
1:21:36due by Friday and it will take four hours. Due by Friday, D-U-E by Friday. It's totally
1:21:43different. But yes I am. I am trying to integrate it. I am trying to find ways to, what's
1:21:49happening now is that I have things that fall out of the Snell filing system which is my
1:21:52brain and I'm like, "Oh yeah." And I think this is the sort of thing I should
1:21:58put into Do-It. So we'll see how it goes. But I am sticking with it for now along, you
1:22:03know, the calendar still is a thing that I use because it is how my brain works but Do-It
1:22:08is helping out.
1:22:09It's a compliment.
1:22:10It's helping me out for now.
1:22:11Dalton asked, "Why is the Chromecast usually left out when talking about TV Box competition?"
1:22:17It's true, when we talk about TV Box competition, we just did it, we didn't mention Chromecast
1:22:21at all.
1:22:22Now the reason I don't is because it's not a TV Box.
1:22:25It is not a box that has an interface.
1:22:29It's like AirPlay.
1:22:30It's just a way to stream stuff.
1:22:32I think that's why I leave it out.
1:22:34It doesn't feel like the same product to me as an Apple TV or Roku or Fire TV.
1:22:40don't build apps for it. It's like does it do just the support for Chromecast already
1:22:45exists in other places? If it does you can Chromecast to it, right? You can do the casting
1:22:50thing and you can watch it on the TV. That's why I leave it out because it doesn't have
1:22:54that same feeling of like is Google going to do deals for Chromecast? Like it doesn't
1:22:58feel that way, you know? What do you think?
1:23:01>> Yeah, you said it. I think that's the, okay, I'm going to be a little impolitic here,
1:23:10but I feel like this is one of those examples where Google is run by people who don't understand
1:23:17how people think. And I know there are a lot of tech nerds out there who love Chromecast.
1:23:23Of course there are. It's a dongle that you attach to your TV and then control everything
1:23:28from your phone. That's a tech nerdy kind of thing. I think most people, like there's
1:23:35no there there. There's no home there. It really is. I, I'm a tech nerd. I do not want
1:23:41to sit down in front of my television and then pop around on my phone looking for an
1:23:47app to stick on the television and then find the button. I don't do that. I, this is why
1:23:53I don't like to airplay. Airplay is a last resort. I will airplay if I have to. If there's
1:23:57an app that lets me airplay that isn't available on the Apple TV, I will do it. But I hate
1:24:02it. I hate it because now I've got a device that is streaming over my network. Is it going
1:24:06to be reliable? How's that going to work? I know that Chromecast will pick up the URL
1:24:10and will go out and find it itself so it's not like that but it's like suddenly my phone
1:24:15is a remote. And if it works for you that's great but it's not the same as these other
1:24:21products and that's why. That's right or wrong. That's why.
1:24:25it doesn't feel like they're doing deals. They just like open this up as a way to
1:24:29say to developers "oh you can integrate with this?" So it's like a different
1:24:33strategy and I think that's why we don't bring it up because the Apple TV and the
1:24:37Fire TV, they are backed by companies that are trying to make original content.
1:24:42Right? Like that's what makes that interesting is that it's more than just
1:24:47the thing you plug into the television and I think that's why Google kind of
1:24:51gets left out of this in places. Yeah, their thing is, um, turn your,
1:24:55your device is the best remote, they say. And I don't agree.
1:25:00Promotes are really nice. And in general, and there's, there's no,
1:25:05they're there. I just, I believe that
1:25:07I mean, Google Chrome cast, as far as I know, and forgive me,
1:25:13I'm sure there are exceptions here, but to me,
1:25:15Chromecast is a wireless video
1:25:19adapter. Like it's a plug. It's not a place for stuff like the Fire TV and Roku and the
1:25:29Apple TV. It's, and it, if it works for you, again, I'm not saying you're a bad person
1:25:35if you like Chromecast. Chromecast has a lot of things going for it, but it's not, one
1:25:39of these things is not like the other and, and, and that's why, and I, it, it, to me,
1:25:46It's like one of those things that I point out and I say Google like you're so weird.
1:25:52Like why is this your strategy that everything is an app, everything is an Android app on
1:25:59your phone and the Chromecast, well we don't need an interface on it.
1:26:03We don't need a remote.
1:26:04Your device is the best remote.
1:26:05I'm like yeah, I don't agree with that.
1:26:07Just like I don't agree when Vizio put out those TVs that didn't have remotes because
1:26:13you're supposed to use your phone.
1:26:14It's like no, uh-uh, no.
1:26:16- And lastly today, Simon asked,
1:26:19"At $199, is the Sonos One the HomePod Killer?"
1:26:23So the Sonos One was announced a couple weeks ago.
1:26:26It is the Sonos Play One, which is their little speaker,
1:26:29but it has Amazon Echo support.
1:26:33It's going to get Google Home support,
1:26:35and AirPlay Two, it's $199.
1:26:39So that's $200 cheaper than the HomePod.
1:26:43I don't like the phrase "the killer" because it never worked.
1:26:47Anything that's called the something killer never killed anything?
1:26:49Yes.
1:26:50But is the Sonos One serious competition for the HomePod?
1:26:55Ah, yes, but...
1:27:00Are people gonna buy it?
1:27:01My guess, because I've got to play one, which is basically the same,
1:27:04other than the voice support.
1:27:07And it sounds good.
1:27:09The HomePod sounds better.
1:27:13HomePod sounds better than the Play 3 let alone the Play 1.
1:27:16The HomePod has Siri integration which is problematic in many ways, but it also is going to let you
1:27:23voice control Apple music.
1:27:25So if you're an Apple music subscriber,
1:27:28you can't do that on the Play 1, whatever it's called, the Sonos One, right? Because the
1:27:33Amazon Echo stuff, I almost said her name, the Amazon Echo stuff
1:27:37will let you voice control Amazon's music stuff.
1:27:41Yeah, and maybe I think Spotify down the road but not we were talking about some connect
1:27:46It's so confusing is there is a potential that the airplay to integration will let you control Apple music
1:27:52Via Siri it's but then but then it's from via Siri from your your phone not on the device and it's streaming to the device
1:28:00yeah, so
1:28:02so I think I think
1:28:04My answer here is no because I think the home pod exists in this weird space where?
1:28:09People are gonna buy it because they love Apple and they've got and they are using Apple music and that they think it's gonna be
1:28:15A good product and the Sonos one is weirdly complicated by what assistants are on it
1:28:21It does sound good
1:28:22I think I guess what I'd say is the real challenge for the home pod is that it has it is expensive and
1:28:28There are speakers that are cheaper that have similar features
1:28:32That sound pretty good. Yeah, I mean I I
1:28:36I still, I think the jury is out on whether the HomePod is even going to be worth it for anybody.
1:28:42Oh, I agree. I agree. It's a weird product.
1:28:44It has a real risk to be the iPod Hi-Fi 2, in my opinion. It's a very expensive,
1:28:50very limited use case device. I think there's a real scenario where next fall there's an all-new
1:28:56HomePod. Which is $199. That's smaller and cheaper and not, yeah, not what this current HomePod is.
1:29:05we'll see but I think I think that's the challenge I don't think it's so does
1:29:08one's entrance is love the jig is up for the home pod because I think it's it's
1:29:13just another entrant in this in this field that talk that exposes the issues
1:29:19with the home pod if you like to find a show this week or it really that a fan
1:29:24such upgrade such 163 thank you to everybody that some questions as always
1:29:28you can submit snow talk questions with a hashtag snow talk for the beginning of
1:29:31the show and #AskUpgradeQuestions for the end of the show. If you want to find Jason online,
1:29:37he's at SixColors.com, TheIncomparable.com, he hosts a bunch of shows over at relay.fm
1:29:42as well and he's @JSnell on Twitter, I am @imike. We'll be back next week as normal,
1:29:48we're at the Release Notes Conference, if you are at Release Notes, we're going to be
1:29:51there for the next few days, so please come say hi, we'd love to speak to you and, I don't
1:29:56know, talk about pineapple or something. Sure, probably. But we'll be back next time, until
1:30:01Until then, all thanks to our sponsors this week,
1:30:04the great folk over at Balance, Squarespace, and Macworld.
1:30:07We'll be back next week.
1:30:08Until then, say goodbye, Jason Snow.
1:30:10Goodbye, everybody.
1:30:11High five!
1:30:12Woo!
1:30:13[BLANK_AUDIO]