0:00:00[Music]
0:00:08From Relay FM, this is Upgrade episode 113. Today's show is brought to you by
0:00:14Pingdom. My name is Myke Curley and I am joined across the table from Jason Snell.
0:00:19Top of the morning to you, Jason Snell.
0:00:21Hello mate.
0:00:22That's no- that's the wrong-
0:00:23That's the wrong one.
0:00:23It's a podcast.
0:00:24We're in Ireland at the All Conference. We're back together again.
0:00:29Again. And we're recording... I see you an awful lot. This is like the fourth time I've seen you this year?
0:00:35Something like that. You just can't quit me, Snell.
0:00:38No.
0:00:39We have some very important follow-up to start off this week's episode.
0:00:43We have the draft results. Oh yes.
0:00:45Now, it is safe to say, you destroyed me in the draft. Turns out...
0:00:51I made a fatal flaw in my draft picks. I expected Apple would release more than one computer.
0:00:57and I based many of my picks around that.
0:01:00You took many of your picks around
0:01:02what would happen to the MacBook
0:01:03and that really edged you out ahead
0:01:06in a very significant way.
0:01:08- I didn't have a lot of confidence
0:01:13in the iMacs and the Mac Pro and the MacBook
0:01:18and it turned out that was good.
0:01:20- Turns out that was definitely the right move
0:01:23because you absolutely destroyed me.
0:01:25I wanna run through them very quick
0:01:26so we can just talk about what you got.
0:01:28And there was just a couple of points
0:01:29that I wanted to discuss with you.
0:01:31So new MacBook Pro.
0:01:33- Yep.
0:01:34- MacBook Pro with touch ID sensor.
0:01:36MacBook Pro has no traditional USB ports.
0:01:38These are all--
0:01:39- I thought I was gambling on that one, but I got it.
0:01:40- You got it.
0:01:41MacBook Pro has P3 color gamut.
0:01:44- Another gamble.
0:01:45- We're taking that.
0:01:46They didn't say P3, but you confirmed it.
0:01:47They did say wider.
0:01:48They just didn't go into details.
0:01:50I consider that a tick for you.
0:01:51- Yes, I agree.
0:01:53- All updated Macs have USB-C or Thunderbolt 3 ports.
0:01:56That's a great one because there was only one Mac.
0:02:00Developer API for Magic Toolbar/Touchscreen on MacBook Pro.
0:02:04They did mention it on stage.
0:02:05They did.
0:02:05This is the one that I wanted to discuss with you.
0:02:08Now, our independent adjudicator--
0:02:09Mr. Steven Hackett.
0:02:10--gave you a half point.
0:02:12I gave a question mark for this.
0:02:14New retina external display.
0:02:17I didn't say from Apple, I suppose.
0:02:19No.
0:02:21And I don't know--
0:02:22Who knew that they would partner with LG
0:02:24to make a special display, basically.
0:02:26- And once the resolution is good,
0:02:27like it's not called a retina display, is it?
0:02:29It's just called like a 5K display.
0:02:30- It's a 5K, I believe the same panel as in the 5K on there.
0:02:35- So I would, I mean I agree with the adjudicator,
0:02:37half point works here, 'cause it's kind of,
0:02:39it's like a technicality, like this is a display,
0:02:41but it's not the one we were thinking it was gonna be.
0:02:43- No, I think that's fair, I think that's fair.
0:02:45- So the only point that I got was MacBook Pro
0:02:48includes touchscreen function row.
0:02:50That was my--
0:02:51- Right, you got the touch bar.
0:02:53- Got the touch bar.
0:02:54So AirPods shipping, that was broken like two days before
0:02:58Apple said it was delayed.
0:02:59- Yes.
0:03:00- Then this one's so close, I'm so upset about this.
0:03:02The 13 inch MacBook, not MacBook Air.
0:03:05It actually is a MacBook Pro.
0:03:06- Yeah.
0:03:07- Right, the one that you have right in front of you.
0:03:09- Right in front of me right now, yes.
0:03:10- Which Marco has dubbed, which I think is his greatest
0:03:13naming, the MacBook Escape.
0:03:15I think it's the best name that Marco has come up with.
0:03:18- I'm not a fan.
0:03:19- It's just funny to me, watching it, I was like,
0:03:22Like it they even Apple caught it out. It's like this is the next generation of the MacBook Air, but now it's a MacBook Pro
0:03:27Yeah, I was like if I was so close they're very much making the argument
0:03:31We'll get into it later that it's sort of the follow-on to the 13 inch MacBook Air, which is a strong
0:03:35Just never strong man several hundred dollars more. That's all refreshed
0:03:38I'm axed it don't get refresh MacBook Mac Pro did not get a MacBook adorable speed bump did not get refresh MacBook Air without retina
0:03:45Display did not get I tied with the upgrade Ian's. Yes, you did because they got colors on the MacBook Pro
0:03:51which we just I think the chat room suggested that right at the end right at
0:03:55the very end I was terrified when they started with Apple TV I really thought
0:04:00that the Joe was gonna get his 4k Apple TV so did I but they ended it without
0:04:05that I was relieved but yeah so I was absolutely decimated in the draft so
0:04:13Jason congratulations your 2016 draft champion thank you Myke it's an honor
0:04:18and a privilege to defeat you. But you tied with the Upgradients, so you got that going
0:04:23for you.
0:04:24I did.
0:04:25Your optimism, your boundless optimism about a Mac line refresh at that event was your
0:04:30undoing.
0:04:31Yeah. I mean, just looking at it, it seems, looking at it now, like even back at it, it
0:04:38still seems like I would have made those picks again, right? Like, it was like, oh, you would
0:04:41expect, considering nothing had been updated all year, that something might be? But no.
0:04:48We just got the MacBook Pro.
0:04:50Yeah, I think there's some timing issues there, it sounds like, in terms of Intel chip availability.
0:04:55Seems like there's lots of issues.
0:04:57I'm sure, I would actually say, I'm sure that if Apple felt like it could ship updated iMacs in the fall, it would do it, because it's done in the last two years.
0:05:05But I think that they, I think that they couldn't.
0:05:08Yeah.
0:05:09Before we talk about the Mac event in a bit more detail and the MacBook Pro, also last week, very busy week, were Apple's fiscal fourth quarter results.
0:05:21Buzzfeed summed this up in a great tweet for me. It's like they basically distilled all of the earnings into one tweet.
0:05:29"Apple's annual sales fell for the first time in 15 years. It's also making $100 million in profit every day."
0:05:34I just love that.
0:05:35That is the both things.
0:05:37Yes, they had another, was it maybe the last quarter or the quarter before, another bad
0:05:42record-breaking thing?
0:05:44This time, what was it, last time was a profit decline.
0:05:47Was it the first profit decline or the first time they hadn't excelled on the previous
0:05:52quarter?
0:05:53Now, this one is a sales fall for the first time, 15 years.
0:05:57Can you explain that a little bit?
0:05:58What does that actually mean?
0:05:59In this case, it's annual sales.
0:06:02So basically, they're looking at the revenue.
0:06:05This was the last quarter of Apple's fiscal year.
0:06:07So if you total up the sales, the revenue for the year and compare it to the previous
0:06:14year, it's the first time that it has gone down from the previous year in 15 years.
0:06:19And this is the story of fiscal 2016 for Apple.
0:06:22Fiscal 2016 for Apple, quarter one was slightly up year over year, and then the next three
0:06:28quarters were way down year over year because of the huge second, third, and fourth quarters
0:06:34of fiscal 2015 owing to the success of the iPhone 6 and 6 Plus. And that was it. And
0:06:44they forecast a year over year increase in Q1 for 2017, which is the holiday quarter.
0:06:51They think that this holiday quarter will be better than the last holiday quarter for
0:06:54them. So that's a return to growth for Apple.
0:06:57It's how they do that. I mean, they know what they're doing. That will be good. That
0:07:00will be a good way to start next year, right?
0:07:03Right, and then their year-over-year comparisons become 2016 instead of 2015, and it gets a
0:07:08lot easier. Those of us who have been arguing for a while now that if you take 15 as an
0:07:14aberration and you map 14 to 16, what you really see is growth, because 16 is higher
0:07:21than 14. It sort of goes 10, 11, 12, 13, 14. And then if you pretend 15 doesn't exist
0:07:29and then draw the line to 16, the growth actually kind of tracks. It's that 15 was this aberration
0:07:35to the positive. And after this next quarter, they're going to be comparing themselves
0:07:41to 16 instead of 15 where they were lower. And now they'll be higher again. So they
0:07:47may post year-over-year growth the whole year. We'll have to see. But they're forecasting
0:07:53it for quarter one, which was a little surprising to me.
0:07:56Were there any other highlights for you? I mean, the iPad is still going down, right?
0:08:01You know, it's what we've talked about in the past. The iPad is… It may have hit
0:08:05bottom now, but every time we say that, I'm then disappointed the next time. I would really
0:08:09like to see some growth in the iPad. And it's decline is not great at this point year-over-year.
0:08:17year and they're still selling a bunch but I would really like to see the iPad reach
0:08:24a level where we're out of the cycle of everybody bought them at the beginning and then they
0:08:30just stop buying them because they had them and they last for a long time. I would like
0:08:34to see signs that it's now kind of a normal product that just kind of does even a relatively
0:08:40slow growth over time and it continues to grow and it's still, you know, the results
0:08:46haven't been that consistent.
0:08:47That might be a better thing for 2017, because looking at the graphs, the decline is slowing
0:08:53down through 2016 compared to where it started to fall down from the start of 2015.
0:09:00The gaps are hundreds of thousands of units difference rather than millions of units difference.
0:09:05So maybe 2017, I feel like we say this every time though, will be the year where we start
0:09:09to see some stability in the iPad sales.
0:09:11I agree with you and I think it goes back to saying that Apple will look a lot better
0:09:15year over year in 2017 because of 2016, right? And that goes across a lot of different product
0:09:20categories. And I said this maybe in my article or maybe on Twitter and I got some pushback
0:09:26from somebody who is a big iPad fan suggesting, "No, no, no. It'll be fine. There's a long
0:09:30buying cycle," all these things. And what I had to say to him was, "I agree with you.
0:09:35These are the things that we've been saying all along. The problem is it's very hard to
0:09:40keep saying that, "Oh no, now it's hit bottom," and not realize after a year or
0:09:45two that it still hasn't. You can have that optimism and the feeling like it's about
0:09:51to turn it around, but at this point I've said it too many times, I want to see it actually
0:09:56turn around before I say it because how many quarters have we thought, "This is the one
0:10:02where it's going to show that the iPad is stabilized," and it still hasn't. It's
0:10:06still dropping.
0:10:07So, again, the amount it's dropping is lessening, but it's still going down.
0:10:12So…
0:10:13That's what we have to scratch for at this point.
0:10:14This has been true the last couple of quarters.
0:10:16It's slowing down its fall, but it still hasn't stopped falling.
0:10:22Every time, I think I wrote, every time you think that the iPad has hit bottom, you realize,
0:10:26"Nope, it's still got a little bit further to fall."
0:10:28Maybe it's settling down at the bottom now and will finally turn around, but I would
0:10:31like to see the turnaround before I trumpet the turnaround of the iPad.
0:10:36I can't, the hit bottom thing isn't working for me anymore because we haven't, still haven't.
0:10:42- But like the one thing that I like to hang on to is it sells more to the Mac.
0:10:45It's weird that we don't really put any focus on the Mac with this because it's stable,
0:10:49and that's the reason with the iPad is it's not stable.
0:10:52So it could dip below Mac levels, like it could.
0:10:54- I've had revenue is below the Mac now,
0:10:57and that's a little surprising.
0:10:59And there's a question of where it ends up when it stabilizes,
0:11:03But that's my question is, we thought, if you would ask me a year ago, I said, "Well,
0:11:08it'll stabilize to be a little bit above what the Mac sells." And it's not now.
0:11:13So is it not? Is the iPad market actually less than the Mac market? I don't know.
0:11:18Well, to follow the meme through, the average selling price of the Mac must have gone up
0:11:21this year because they didn't update them. Right? Like, the amount of money Apple is
0:11:26making, their margins on the Mac throughout 2016 must have been fantastic because…
0:11:30- Right, so the average selling price wouldn't have changed
0:11:33because of that, but the profit per Mac would have changed.
0:11:36- Yeah, that's what I'm looking for, yeah.
0:11:37- I think that's probably true.
0:11:38- I mean, that must have been the case.
0:11:40You know, they continued to make all the same products
0:11:42with all the same components for a year.
0:11:44- Right, and the margins, yeah, but the sales were way down.
0:11:46Boy, I did a chart of the Mac sales, and it's just,
0:11:51you know, it was a, like so much of fiscal 2016 for Apple,
0:11:55it was a really bad year for the Mac.
0:11:57Not like the sales like vanished, but as we all know,
0:12:00They didn't release any new Macs after first quarter basically, which was the 4K iMac along
0:12:08with a refreshed 5K iMac.
0:12:12And then they did the MacBook in the spring and that's about it.
0:12:14So I don't know.
0:12:15We'll see what happens next year.
0:12:18Yeah.
0:12:19Before we kick off with more MacBook stuff, I keep teasing this, but as of last night,
0:12:2510.2 beta 1 was released to developers and it includes a huge emoji overhaul as well
0:12:32as Unicode 9 introductions. So of course the guy on the scene, a good friend of the show
0:12:39Mr Jeremy Burch has a great post over on Emojipedia where he goes into detail and explains and
0:12:45shows off some of the stuff. So Apple was added, they're at parity with Microsoft and
0:12:49Google now in that they have Unicode 9 support so that adds things like clown
0:12:55faces, avocados, foxes, owls shrugging people and as well as like a bunch of
0:13:01new professions like artists and rockstar and astronaut in both genders
0:13:06and they've added a lot more gender parity emoji like a mrs. claws for
0:13:11example so there's a lot more going on there but with that I think surprisingly
0:13:17Apple took this as a time to redesign vast amounts of their emoji. So they've
0:13:24they've kind of brought a lot of the emoji to look like the more recent ones
0:13:29that have been added. So they've made things a bit more shiny, a bit more
0:13:32lifelike, a bit more cartoony. And I've been kind of, I installed the beta this
0:13:37morning and I've been looking around and some of them look really really good and
0:13:42And it's a new, fresh look that I quite like a lot.
0:13:45- Okay, I'll have to check that out.
0:13:47I was impressed with your immediate download
0:13:51of a beta operating system onto your iPhone
0:13:54while traveling at a conference,
0:13:55but emoji are that important to you.
0:13:57- But like, there's things like, you know,
0:13:59things that I've wanted for a while are in there now,
0:14:01like there's a whiskey, there's bacon,
0:14:04there is a green face to show that somebody is sick.
0:14:07You know, all these, you know,
0:14:08so I wanted to check out some of these
0:14:10because a lot of the Unicode 9 is stuff
0:14:14that I've been waiting for for a while.
0:14:15Like, fingers crossed, it's in there as well.
0:14:17So, yeah, that is, I mean--
0:14:20- So when people send you emoji that look like a box--
0:14:23- That's what it is.
0:14:24- They're on the 10.2 beta.
0:14:27- I mean, many people roll their eyes at this stuff.
0:14:30- Indeed, they're doing it right now.
0:14:32- But this is massively important for OS adoption now.
0:14:36- Yes.
0:14:37- Which surprises me that Apple didn't put these in 10.
0:14:40It surprises me that it's taken them until 10.2.
0:14:43So I'm wondering what else 10.2 might include
0:14:46by the time it's released.
0:14:47Because emoji are like a Trojan horse now.
0:14:52Like if you want people to upgrade their operating system,
0:14:55put the new emoji in there and people will do it.
0:14:58So I'm intrigued to see like would 10.2 just be these emoji?
0:15:02Or will there be some other features in there
0:15:04that we haven't seen yet?
0:15:05Also in 10.2 there's some new backgrounds,
0:15:07like some new wallpapers.
0:15:08and I think there's a new celebration effect in iMessages.
0:15:11So that's all there is so far,
0:15:14but it's just the beta one of 10.2.
0:15:17All right, let's take a break
0:15:19and then we'll talk about the Mac.
0:15:20So this week's episode is brought to you by Pingdom.
0:15:23You can start monitoring your websites and servers today
0:15:25at pingdom.com/upgrade.
0:15:27When you go there,
0:15:28you'll get yourself a lovely 14-day free trial
0:15:31so you can dig in and see what Pingdom's all about.
0:15:33And then when you enter the offer code upgrade at checkout,
0:15:35you'll get 20% off your first invoice.
0:15:39Why do you need Pingdom?
0:15:40Well, let me tell you.
0:15:41Things break on the internet all the time.
0:15:44Pingdom actually detects around 13 million outages
0:15:49every single month.
0:15:51That's more than 400,000 outages a day.
0:15:54Now these outages can be anything.
0:15:55They can be your website going down completely,
0:15:58or it could just be key functionality breaking,
0:16:00like your checkout or your login form.
0:16:02Well, this is what Pingdom is here to help you with.
0:16:04They can monitor all of this.
0:16:06They can monitor your availability of your entire website or just these key interactions
0:16:10that people might be accessing that are super important.
0:16:12Like if you have a store as part of your website and the store functionality goes down, you
0:16:18really want to know that your website might be up so it can be difficult to tell.
0:16:22Well Pingdom can monitor it all.
0:16:24They take care of all of this by using more than 70 global test servers that emulate visits
0:16:28to your site, checking its availability as often as every single minute.
0:16:34All you need to do is give the URL to Pingdom that you wish for them to monitor and they
0:16:39take care of the rest.
0:16:40When Pingdom detects an outage you'll be immediately alerted and there's a myriad
0:16:44amount of ways in which you can choose for them to alert you so you can get just the
0:16:48right alert at just the right time in the way that you need it and then you'll be
0:16:51able to fix that error before the downtime affects you.
0:16:54You don't want to be caught out when someone wants to access your site.
0:16:57You don't want to get tweets, you don't want to get emails telling you your website
0:16:59is down.
0:17:00Pingdom to tell you before anybody else can and that's what they do. Check it out today
0:17:05and you'll be the first to know when your site is down. Go to Pingdom.com/upgrade for
0:17:09a 14 day free trial and use the code 'upgrade' at checkout to get 20% off. Thank you so much
0:17:14to Pingdom for their continued support of this show and all of Relay FM. So you were
0:17:20at the Mac event. Overall opinion of the event? This is now I believe the last event in Town
0:17:26Hall.
0:17:27No, not until they bulldoze Town Hall.
0:17:31- Poor Town Hall.
0:17:32- But yes, this seems to be probably the last media event.
0:17:35It sounds like Apple will be ready
0:17:37with their new facility next year
0:17:39for any events that they do.
0:17:40But never say never, you never know.
0:17:42Anything is possible.
0:17:43But yeah, this seemed to be the encore event at Town Hall.
0:17:47So we all went to Infinite Loop and parked
0:17:51and walked through number one,
0:17:53and they usher you through into the lawn in the center of the circle and you walk along
0:18:01a path over to number four which is where Town Hall is.
0:18:04- Overall opinions of the event?
0:18:06It seemed like it was weirdly paced, slow in points, fast in others.
0:18:09- Yeah, I often will, in an Apple event, I'll think to myself, this is going fast or this
0:18:18is going slow and I'll look at the clock and think, is there more to come?
0:18:22How much more is there to come?
0:18:24Is this the last thing?
0:18:25And I'll be honest, I looked down at one point and thought they got to have something
0:18:29else and they didn't.
0:18:31I mean, they usually – Apple will usually fill two hours.
0:18:34If you give them two hours, they will fill two hours and they usually give themselves
0:18:37two hours.
0:18:38And this was a 90-minute event.
0:18:40That just wasn't enough.
0:18:42They were just – they were done.
0:18:44And you can see – so, all right, we could speculate.
0:18:49Maybe there were other things that they wish that they could do and the chip availability
0:18:52wasn't there.
0:18:54Maybe they are ready to ship an updated iMac and they can't get the chip availability
0:19:01from Intel.
0:19:02We'll talk about this more in some of the reaction to a lot of the stuff that people
0:19:05have had out there, but so much gets subscribed to Apple and Apple's demeanor toward a product
0:19:11category or a particular product or a particular brand of user.
0:19:16And I'm not saying it's all out of Apple's hands.
0:19:20Apple has to own the decisions it makes about its products, the design decisions it makes.
0:19:25But there are some things that Apple doesn't own.
0:19:29Do we not think that there is a Thunderbolt 3 iMac using the latest generation Intel processors
0:19:38designed in the lab at Apple?
0:19:40Of course there is.
0:19:41they ship it in volume so that they can fulfill all iMac orders over the holidays? I think
0:19:49clearly not.
0:19:50Because why wouldn't they want to do that?
0:19:53Exactly.
0:19:54They're already selling this computer.
0:19:56I see so many people on the internet saying Apple doesn't care. It's like, do you,
0:20:03like you said, do you really think if Apple was capable of shipping in volumes so that
0:20:08they don't run out and make people angry that they can't buy an iMac. An updated iMac.
0:20:15Of course they would rather do that, but that requires them to have the chips in volume.
0:20:20And again, there may be decisions that they made, but that iMac, I'm sure they wanted
0:20:24to update it like they updated it last year, and they didn't get a chance. I'm sure they'd
0:20:28like to turn over their whole product line to Thunderbolt 3 right now, but it's not always
0:20:35that. So that's part of it for me is maybe they intended there to be more here and they
0:20:40just couldn't do it.
0:20:42Let me ask you a question on that though, because I'm majorly agree with you. It's like
0:20:46it's not a neglect thing. There are reasons because it's just bad business to not do this.
0:20:52Right.
0:20:53However, on the other side of it, they're selling really old computers for high prices.
0:20:55Oh yes. Well, we'll get to the other ones. The iMac's not a really old computer though,
0:20:59right? The iMacs were updated a year ago.
0:21:01Yeah. I mean that one's kind of fair.
0:21:03- Yeah, and that's why I say Apple's responsible
0:21:06for the decisions it makes.
0:21:08So like, if we wanna talk about the Mac Pro
0:21:10and the Mac Mini, especially the Mac Pro,
0:21:13and we would talk about the MacBook Pro
0:21:15and why it took so long, I think it's Apple's decisions
0:21:20coupled with Intel's product issues.
0:21:26And so it's one of those things, I don't know,
0:21:31You make, Myke is looking at flying,
0:21:33- There's a wasp.
0:21:34- There was a wasp outside the window.
0:21:36Maybe we'll get visited by the ghost of Ool
0:21:38that we got last year here too.
0:21:40If you've ever had this in your life
0:21:43where you make a decision and you realize
0:21:46that you're sort of making that decision
0:21:48based on a gamble like, well, I think we can do this
0:21:51unless this other person doesn't come through,
0:21:53it'll all be fine.
0:21:54And then that person doesn't come through.
0:21:56Now is it all their fault
0:21:57if you could have made a different decision?
0:22:00I think that's sort of where it is with Apple, is Apple thought it could get away
0:22:03– I've said this before – Apple thought it could get away with skipping a generation
0:22:07in some of the Intel processors and it would be fine because the next generation was coming
0:22:10and that timing worked better for them and then the Intel processor timeframe slipped
0:22:15and oops.
0:22:16And made a bad gamble.
0:22:17Yeah, well yeah, that's right.
0:22:19So it's a combination of things.
0:22:21But I think for the iMac it's not like that because for the iMac, is it a huge deal if
0:22:26the iMac gets refreshed in the spring instead of the fall?
0:22:29Not really. I'm sure they'd rather have done it in the fall. But I don't think it's Apple
0:22:34saying we don't care about the iMac and so we're not updating it today.
0:22:38Does Apple care about the Mac Pro?
0:22:41I think Apple cares about the Mac Pro slightly more than they care about the Mac Mini. But
0:22:46only slightly. I think it's an edge product.
0:22:50The Mac Mini is way less important.
0:22:52Those are the edge products though. Those are the edge products in terms of overall
0:22:57Mac sales. Now they are very important and the Mac Pro is extremely important when it
0:23:02comes to a certain kind of user and we know them, we love them, many of them listen to
0:23:07this show. And I'd say that it's important to Apple too to have that power computer at
0:23:14the high end of the line. But how many cycles do they spend on Mac Pro updates? And like
0:23:21I said, I think they got caught in between product cycles, between processor cycles for
0:23:26for Mintol and they thought they could skip a refresh and then get the next refresh and
0:23:34everything got delayed and you know I can't, I mean they blew it, they blew it because
0:23:39that Mac Pro should not be for sale now. It was not worth buying a year ago.
0:23:49Geoff - And then you know because of things that have happened in my part of the world,
0:23:53put the price up. It's £500 more expensive now for an older computer. I know the reason
0:24:00they've done it blah blah blah blah blah.
0:24:01Yeah, they talked about it a lot during the financials.
0:24:03But it's still been done.
0:24:04One of the things that people hit them on a lot of their sales drops and in some countries
0:24:09they said, "We're also fighting a major currency problem." And their result is that they did
0:24:18reprice things in a lot of markets.
0:24:20Significant price increases in the UK.
0:24:23And that's, you know, that's Apple, you know,
0:24:27the pound isn't worth what it was worth.
0:24:31- It's funny, like, what it's gone back to is interesting,
0:24:34'cause it's gone back to the kind of prices
0:24:36when I started buying Apple computers.
0:24:39When like, the economy was very different,
0:24:40but Apple just were different.
0:24:42You know, and it was closer to like,
0:24:44take the dollar number and change the sign to a pound.
0:24:47That's what you paid.
0:24:49And it's way closer to that again,
0:24:50which is, it's interesting to see Apple go there,
0:24:52So if you've been buying Apple computers in the UK for long enough, we've had our
0:24:56glory days now.
0:24:58We got cheaper computers for a while.
0:25:00So now, for me, I'm going to buy computers in America again.
0:25:04I'm not going to buy them in the UK.
0:25:06This is what I used to do.
0:25:07I used to buy stuff in the States and I'm just going to go back to doing that.
0:25:10Or hop over to anywhere in Europe.
0:25:13I saw somebody saying you could go to Ireland and buy an iPhone and come back again and
0:25:17you'd still be like 80 pounds up.
0:25:20This is just the reality that we're in again.
0:25:22So let's talk about the MacBook Pro.
0:25:27So you have with you the MacBook Pro
0:25:33with the function row.
0:25:34- Right, the non-touchbar version.
0:25:36- But you've tried the touchbar version.
0:25:39- Yes.
0:25:39- And I wanna kinda get your opinion on this.
0:25:42We spoke about this in Memphis in August,
0:25:44about the idea of the types of things you can do with it,
0:25:46and you were kind of pontificating what you'd like to see.
0:25:51focusing on the touch bar, because it is the key thing that Apple announces, that it's
0:25:54the jewel in the crown of the product. What do you think of it?
0:26:00I think it's interesting that Apple has, and probably right, to approach it as an input
0:26:07device. And I talked to people at Apple who kept hammering that message home, that this
0:26:14This is an input device.
0:26:16It's not a screen.
0:26:18Don't think of it as a display.
0:26:20It's an input device.
0:26:24The way it's built, the coating on it that makes it kind of feel like a trackpad, the
0:26:30angle, it's meant to be viewed at a 45-degree angle.
0:26:34So the screen's not angled, but the glass and all of that is optimized.
0:26:42optimal viewing angle for it is 45 degrees.
0:26:44I love that.
0:26:45Right?
0:26:46It is so Apple.
0:26:47But at the same time, right?
0:26:48I mean, you're not going to be viewing it from above, unlike every other screen where
0:26:52you're looking at it straight on.
0:26:54This is something that you're viewing at an angle.
0:26:56So they optimize for that view.
0:26:58The screen itself is not angled.
0:27:01But they know the eyeballs that are looking at that screen are coming from an angle.
0:27:05So the last thing you want to do is have the optimal viewing angle be right up above.
0:27:10So it's an input device.
0:27:11like the first time I saw it, I really was taken aback by the fact that the virtual keys
0:27:16looked very much like the real keys. Like, almost like to having a matte kind of finish
0:27:22on it, the way that it looked. And I was impressed by that. You can't adjust the brightness
0:27:28of the display. It automatically does the right thing. It uses the light sensor, I suspect.
0:27:32It also uses the status of the backlighting and various other things to figure out how
0:27:38to sort of match the keyboard. It really is supposed to blend in with the keyboard, not
0:27:44the screen. Interesting. It goes back to that whole, I wrote a piece on Six Colors about
0:27:50it this week, or last week, I don't know what week it is Myke, I flew for a very long
0:27:55time. It's about perpendicular surfaces on the computer. Apple has defined the difference,
0:27:59what's the difference between an iPad and a Mac? iPad is a single surface that you can
0:28:05touch, you interact with it directly. A Mac is two perpendicular surfaces, a display surface
0:28:12and an interaction surface.
0:28:13- Top and bottom.
0:28:15- Top and bottom. And so this is on the bottom. This is an input device. There are now three
0:28:23input devices on those MacBook Pros. There's a trackpad, a keyboard, and a touch bar. And
0:28:29they're all, that's where your hands are, that's the plane you're reaching out with
0:28:32your hands and resting them on that surface and that's where all your controls are and
0:28:37then your content is in the screen up above. And that separates them from Microsoft, which
0:28:45believes that Microsoft doesn't have an iPad per se. Instead, it believes that there's
0:28:52a commingling of PC and touch interface and that what you really want to do is be able
0:28:58to touch the screen.
0:28:59- Yeah, it's like they see the top and bottom,
0:29:02but they put different functions on them.
0:29:04Right, so like, for Microsoft, touch goes on the top,
0:29:07and keys go on the bottom, right?
0:29:09Where like for Apple, it's like no,
0:29:11nothing touches on the top.
0:29:13- Yeah.
0:29:13- But the hands just stay on the bottom.
0:29:15- Apple's philosophy is that nobody wants
0:29:18to touch their laptop screen.
0:29:19- Yep.
0:29:20- And Microsoft doesn't believe that.
0:29:22Now, you can argue that.
0:29:23I mean, I think it's perfectly reasonable.
0:29:25Sometimes I get in, people start to argue with me
0:29:29on Twitter especially about how it's perfectly fine to touch a screen. I have to say, I'm
0:29:37open on that question. I'm just trying to explain to you, Apple's philosophy will
0:29:44say, it's almost like a dogma at this point, is zombie arms don't touch the screen. You
0:29:51don't want to touch the screen. It's no good. That's what they believe. I think
0:29:57a question, and they've been saying this for years now. I do wonder sometimes how often
0:30:01do they revisit it. I hope they revisit it regularly and say they still believe it, and
0:30:06that it hasn't just become like, "Five years ago, we decided touch screens were bad.
0:30:10Never speak of it again."
0:30:11I think that it isn't true anymore, because they sell keyboards for iPads. At the point
0:30:18where Apple makes their own keyboard for an iPad, then they are saying zombie arms are
0:30:23okay. It's like, "The iPad, it's okay. The Mac, no, no, that's crazy talk."
0:30:27I think the challenge would be that if they do it in the Mac, they have to revise the
0:30:31Mac interface to have touchable targets.
0:30:34Well, I think that's what it is.
0:30:35I don't think that the idea anymore is no one should reach out because we do that.
0:30:40I think the idea is we don't want to redesign Mac OS for touch because at the point we do
0:30:45that, we may as well just make it all iOS.
0:30:48And I think that is, when we talk about philosophies of Apple and Microsoft, bottom line, I do
0:30:53believe that they believe these things internally, but it is a belief that is driven by what
0:31:00their assets are.
0:31:01I just think it's changed.
0:31:02Yeah, Microsoft failed with the concept of having a separate thing for touch and for
0:31:08traditional computer. It failed. All of their Surface, their ARM version of Surface and
0:31:15all of that, and the Metro thing, they're like, "Oh, right. It's all one thing.
0:31:19It's all one device.
0:31:21Apple has an incredibly successful touch-based operating system.
0:31:26And so Apple's take on it really is like, "Look, if you want a big touchscreen, use
0:31:33an iOS device.
0:31:34Why would we make the Mac into iOS?
0:31:37We already have iOS."
0:31:38So the Mac is now the traditional computer interface for people who want it.
0:31:43And if you want a touch interface, I mean, Apple is far more likely – put it this way
0:31:47Apple is far more likely to continue progressing the iPad forward to allow it to do all the
0:31:54things that prevent people from switching from the Mac to an iPad than it is progressing
0:31:59the Mac to be more friendly with touch.
0:32:03Why would they do that?
0:32:04I mean, I wrote a piece a couple of years ago about this and I think it's still true,
0:32:07which is you've got to view the Mac, and I don't mean this to be insulting, and I'm
0:32:12a Mac user, I use the Mac all the time.
0:32:14You've got to view the Mac as like, I was going to say legacy product, but it's like
0:32:18classic.
0:32:19It's like a classic interface and a classic metaphor, and it's for people who want to
0:32:26use a computer.
0:32:28Adding a whole bunch of touch interface and stuff like that, they're not going to do
0:32:33it because it's not a computer anymore.
0:32:36It's that's the act there is trying to upgrade the Mac into being a new 21st century
0:32:42operating system with all these different interactions.
0:32:45And Apple's already got that operating system.
0:32:47So it's far more likely that Apple will build the iPad
0:32:50and the iPhone to be more, to add all of these technical
0:32:55and flexible things that people say,
0:32:56but I can't use that, I have to have my Mac because,
0:33:00than it is that they're gonna iPadify the Mac.
0:33:03The Mac exists to be the Mac, to be familiar,
0:33:06to be the thing that we know it to be with it.
0:33:08And when they add something like Touch Bar,
0:33:10They're like, "What can we do to enhance the Mac
0:33:15"without breaking what makes it a Mac?"
0:33:18- They're bringing, it's like,
0:33:20the touch bar is the continued march
0:33:23of the iOSification of the Mac.
0:33:26Like it is the, what can we bring to it without breaking it?
0:33:29- Without breaking the metaphor.
0:33:31- And it was like, it started with Back to the Mac, right?
0:33:33The Back to the Mac event was the first time
0:33:35that they did this, and because a large amount
0:33:38but the functions that they showed that the Touch Bar could do were things that the iOS
0:33:44keyboard does. Like QuickType, like an emoji picker, like it is bringing that stuff, right?
0:33:49Like there is a big meme right now, which I can kind of see, of like over time that
0:33:55keyboard is going to become a not keyboard, right? Like a software keyboard or an all
0:34:00screen keyboard or whatever, because it enables Apple to follow through with the original
0:34:06vision that Steve presented in the iPhone introduction of why there isn't a physical
0:34:10keyboard on the iPhone. Because then you are not restricted by the keyboard, you can do
0:34:15anything, you can add anything. Which is what makes the, is it called the touch bar? The
0:34:20touch bar is so interesting to me because it makes the keyboard a more interactive experience.
0:34:30And with a lot of the things that I do on a Mac, the idea of having these functions
0:34:35and shortcuts and bars and tools available to me where my hands are and where my eyes
0:34:41are looking because of how I use a keyboard is incredibly exciting to me. So much so I
0:34:48could never buy one of these. The Touch Bar is so interesting to me as a product. I cannot
0:34:55buy the MacBook Pro because I don't work on it all the time. And when I'm not using it,
0:34:59I would be very, very sad.
0:35:01Because this is like, for a user like me,
0:35:05this is a fantastic product,
0:35:07because it is something that surfaces hard to find controls
0:35:12and is also really, really useful to somebody
0:35:15who looks at the keyboard a lot, like I do.
0:35:17So I think that this product is very interesting.
0:35:20So much so, like Federico said this,
0:35:22I hope that they find a way to build this
0:35:24into a iPad keyboard at some point, right?
0:35:27'cause these functions are just very interesting.
0:35:31Like, what apps did you play with
0:35:33and what sort of functions did they have?
0:35:36- Oh, let's see.
0:35:37I mean, I used like Mail and TextEdit.
0:35:41I used Final Cut a little bit briefly.
0:35:46Photos, it was all over the map.
0:35:49And then the demo showed, I do believe that this is
0:35:54gonna be a year of real exploration for Apple
0:35:57in terms of what the interface of a touch bar
0:36:01really should do, because even on screen,
0:36:03I found like the way Adobe approached the touch bar
0:36:06in Photoshop versus the way that Apple approached it
0:36:10or Microsoft Office or something like that
0:36:13was very different, and I was thinking
0:36:17that the Photoshop touch bar looked better
0:36:20than the Final Cut touch bar.
0:36:25- Why so?
0:36:26I don't know, it felt like, it's hard to say.
0:36:31I mean, it felt like they had a better sense
0:36:34of why you would use that Surface
0:36:36and how you would apply commands on that Surface.
0:36:40But what really just struck me is, I mean,
0:36:42I don't wanna, I shouldn't judge them.
0:36:44They were different.
0:36:46I liked the Photoshop one better,
0:36:47but the bigger point is they seemed to take
0:36:50different approaches with their touch bar interfaces.
0:36:53And that leads me to believe that we're gonna spend
0:36:56next year learning what a good touch bar interface is and what a bad touch bar interface is.
0:37:01My only problem with that is that it is, like you said, going to be this subset. It's
0:37:06going to be only the people who buy the high-end MacBook Pros who have this functionality and
0:37:11nobody else is going to have it. And that will slow adoption and that will limit who
0:37:18gets to kind of shape what this is like. But I think over the next year, I suspect that
0:37:24feels to me like, you know, Apple had its first take on this. Like, "Oh, well, look,
0:37:28you can use it to do this and this and this." And then you can already see with some of
0:37:31these developers that they're pushing it a lot further and that might make Apple revisit
0:37:36it.
0:37:37Like the DJ guy was doing his whole thing. Like, he did the whole thing. Like, he mixed
0:37:40the whole track. I don't know if he liked it or not. You know, that's another thing.
0:37:43But he was doing a lot on that thing. And I'm really interested by the fact that they
0:37:49made it a ten finger multi-touch because that's unnecessary. But what it does is it means
0:37:54that people can really build some interesting things
0:37:56into it.
0:37:57You know, you can have like four fingers on this thing
0:37:59doing all sorts of stuff and you're good.
0:38:02How long is it gonna be before I get one on a keyboard?
0:38:06Like an external Magic Keyboard?
0:38:07Or even just an external touch bar, just the bar?
0:38:10- I, right, I, I don't know.
0:38:12I have, there's a lot of despair out there.
0:38:17And people who say Apple doesn't care about the Mac Pro,
0:38:23Apple doesn't care about the Mac, Apple doesn't care about people who use the desktop.
0:38:28I don't know. I kind of don't believe it. I think that if Apple can make a Magic
0:38:33Keyboard with a Touch Bar, they will. Or just a Touch Bar. Like you said, it feels to me
0:38:39more likely that they would make a Magic Keyboard with a Touch Bar than just a bar and say,
0:38:46"Good luck. Stick this on top of your Magic Keyboard." But I think if they can make
0:38:52one they will. I think the question is going to be about battery life on that device most
0:38:58of all. Because they'll have to embed, it'll be like an Apple Watch, right? I mean, they'll
0:39:02have to embed the processor in there.
0:39:05The T1?
0:39:06T1 and a Touch ID processor and a Touch ID sensor and all of that. And then can they
0:39:11do that wired or wireless? And if they can do it wireless, which Apple loves, then they
0:39:16have to, you know, you have to charge it. How can it go a week? Does it have to be charged
0:39:21every day. I think these are the questions about it. I think if they can do it, they
0:39:27will do it because I think having that consistency across the platforms, letting everybody no
0:39:32matter where they are have a touch bar even if they're at their desk, I think that's
0:39:40the way that they should do it. I don't feel that to spare.
0:39:43Scott
0:39:43- I would take a wired one.
0:39:44- I would love a wired one.
0:39:45- If that's what it had to be.
0:39:46- I don't have a problem, you know,
0:39:49Apple and wireless keyboards.
0:39:51- It's staying in one place, right?
0:39:52It's staying in one place, it's not going anywhere.
0:39:54It doesn't bother me.
0:39:55You put a battery in it, it lasts for a couple of hours,
0:39:57you charge it by lightning, but just leave it plugged in.
0:40:00I really want this.
0:40:02Just looking at the controls for Final Cut,
0:40:05there's so many things that they were showing there
0:40:07that I was like, I don't know how to do that.
0:40:10I'm googling things constantly,
0:40:13and the idea of creating this amazing toolbar,
0:40:15which is right in front of my hands all the time,
0:40:17which allows me like control, like gesture control,
0:40:19which I'm currently doing with a track pad,
0:40:21but I could move everything with a bar,
0:40:22it really would work for me.
0:40:23- I was thinking of you when they were showing,
0:40:26and people were poo-pooing it again,
0:40:29about the two-handed interface,
0:40:32where you're using the track pad and the touch bar together,
0:40:37and I thought, "I know multiple people,"
0:40:39and you were the person who came to mind
0:40:41who have two input devices when they're working
0:40:45on their Macs.
0:40:46- Three, when I edit, it's a keyboard,
0:40:50way calm and trackpad.
0:40:51- Yeah.
0:40:52- And when I'm editing, I use both hands.
0:40:54So something like the touchpad,
0:40:56giving me those keyboard shortcuts on a programmable bar
0:40:59would be amazing for me.
0:41:01- So let's throw in too, if you're using a desktop computer,
0:41:06like an iMac or a Mac Pro with an external monitor
0:41:10or whatever, you're actually further away from your screen
0:41:15than you are on a MacBook Pro.
0:41:18So I think the touch bar is more relevant
0:41:22because its place in the input device surface
0:41:27of your workspace is further removed from the screen.
0:41:35I would never touch my iMac screen.
0:41:39It's far away.
0:41:40And I don't even feel the thought of like,
0:41:42"Oh, what if it were a touchscreen?"
0:41:44It's like, "No, no, it's far away."
0:41:46All of my stuff is on my keyboard tray.
0:41:49And so if I had another input mechanism down there,
0:41:53that would actually make more sense to me.
0:41:55- So I'm really excited about the future
0:41:58that means I could have this product,
0:42:00like this part of the product in my arsenal.
0:42:03I think that it is a really exciting move for keyboard entry.
0:42:10This is a dynamic, a live thing for 2016.
0:42:15I'm really excited about it.
0:42:18The MacBook Pro, that machine looks like a great machine, but it's just not a machine
0:42:25for me anymore because of how I work.
0:42:28If I wasn't so iOS focused now, I would buy one of those as my portable machine.
0:42:37Not just my travel machine, but like the machine where I use all over the house and do all
0:42:41the work that I did.
0:42:42Like the MacBook Pro that I brought with me, the MacBook Pro I have with me right now,
0:42:44that's where its function used to be, but it got replaced with the iPad.
0:42:48Because it looks like everything I kind of want.
0:42:51You have the one with me.
0:42:52These are the same dimensions.
0:42:54The MacBook Pro that you have with the actual physical keys is the same product dimensions
0:42:59as the 13 inch MacBook Pro with the touch bar.
0:43:02So this thing is lighter, thinner, which is key, looks really nice.
0:43:10This is a great looking machine.
0:43:12It looks like the MacBook very much and just a kind of bigger version of the MacBook.
0:43:17But one of the things that struggles for me is the idea of using this as a desktop machine
0:43:23is weird because you'd want to use it with the keyboard open and visible, like the thing
0:43:28open so you can use the touch bar, but then you connect it to these big LG displays. And
0:43:33that's just like a weird mix because ideally you want to use an external keyboard at that
0:43:37point.
0:43:38- Yeah, and they're showing it open and in front of you.
0:43:40- And it doesn't really work.
0:43:41- And I agree with you. The problem with this is it's a kind of interaction you want to
0:43:46have, but the only way you can have it is with a MacBook Pro open in front of you.
0:43:50I know why the touch bar is on this machine first.
0:43:54It makes sense.
0:43:55Like if you, like in an ideal world,
0:43:58that should have come on an external keyboard first
0:44:01and then it's also available on the laptop
0:44:03when you take it with you.
0:44:04But like this is a thing for sitting down
0:44:07on the desk working like ideally.
0:44:09And that's why Apple show like in all the images,
0:44:11like here is the touch bar as part of the MacBook
0:44:14as part of this desk.
0:44:15But that's not the way, nobody works like that
0:44:17if you have external monitors.
0:44:18- I don't think so.
0:44:19- Well not a lot of people.
0:44:20- Not a lot of people.
0:44:20- Even the people that work with their laptop open,
0:44:22they still use an external keyboard
0:44:24which connects with that whole setup.
0:44:26- Yeah.
0:44:26- But I understand why they're showing it that way
0:44:28because if you own that computer--
0:44:29- How else can you show it?
0:44:31- You wanna use the touch bar all the time.
0:44:32- Right.
0:44:33- But I don't know if it works that way.
0:44:34But let's talk about the MacBook Pro.
0:44:36- Okay.
0:44:37- So you have one.
0:44:38- Right here.
0:44:39- What do you think of this computer?
0:44:41- Well it is one ounce heavier than the 13 inch MacBook Air.
0:44:45As an 11 inch MacBook Air user, it feels heavy to me.
0:44:48but it is only slightly heavier than the 13-inch Air.
0:44:53It is less volume, as they said,
0:44:55and that's because the footprint is a lot less.
0:44:57- It's really nice size-wise.
0:45:00- Yeah, the bezel is a lot smaller around,
0:45:03and as a result, it's a smaller computer than the Air,
0:45:06and it feels denser.
0:45:10And it looks, like I said, it looks like the MacBook.
0:45:12There's no-- - You have it in the gray,
0:45:13and it's really good looking, 'cause it's not too dark.
0:45:16it still looks like a Mac, it still looks silvery,
0:45:19but it's darker, and I really like the color.
0:45:22I think it's a nice color.
0:45:23It's one of the many variations of space gray color
0:45:26that Apple have made.
0:45:27- Space is variable color.
0:45:30- Key question, I can't believe I haven't asked you this yet.
0:45:32This is what everybody wants to know.
0:45:34- Key question.
0:45:34- The key question.
0:45:36So the keyboard is not the keyboard that you're,
0:45:39it's not an evolution of the MacBook Pro keyboard,
0:45:42it is an evolution of the MacBook Adorable Keyboard.
0:45:45it is the second generation of that.
0:45:47- Yes.
0:45:48- It is not the magic keyboard.
0:45:49- It is not.
0:45:50- It is the MacBook keyboard.
0:45:53- Bad news everybody.
0:45:55- You hated the MacBook keyboard.
0:45:57How do you feel about the MacBook Pro keyboard?
0:45:59- Similarly.
0:46:00- Oh no.
0:46:01- Yes.
0:46:02- So Apple spent a lot of time saying
0:46:04that it was new and improved.
0:46:06- Well, you know what?
0:46:07I don't have a MacBook with me.
0:46:09- I'm touching it for the,
0:46:11I haven't actually pressed the keys.
0:46:15I don't like that keyboard very much. The keyboard that I'm using on my Logitech Create
0:46:22for my iPad feels nicer than that. Now, I personally could use that keyboard and would
0:46:28be fine with it.
0:46:29Oh, and I can, I mean, I think what I said when I reviewed the MacBook is, I would say
0:46:33again, I've had this for the last few days, I can type on it. Like, I can type on it at
0:46:39full speed. I don't really like it when every time I start typing on it, I'm like,
0:46:44- Yeah, it's this one again.
0:46:45- Like I can write some emails out on that, and it's fine,
0:46:48but it doesn't feel good.
0:46:49- Yeah, so what I would say is,
0:46:51if you're a user of the 12-inch MacBook and you try this,
0:46:54you may say, "Oh, it's different."
0:46:57And I've seen some of that.
0:46:58And we saw, like I saw Stephen Hackett
0:47:01made some comments about that,
0:47:04that it's better.
0:47:05And what Apple said was,
0:47:07"It feels like there's more movement," I think they said.
0:47:10It was something where they, I was waiting, right?
0:47:13I was hanging on every word that Phil Schiller said about,
0:47:16tell me what this is,
0:47:17'cause you just said it has the butterfly mechanism,
0:47:19and it's like, oh no, that means it's a MacBook keyboard.
0:47:22Then he said, well, but we changed the dome switches
0:47:24underneath, the stainless steel dome switches,
0:47:26to be more responsive, and it has a better feel,
0:47:29and you feel more movement or something like that.
0:47:32He made lots of things, and what that sounded to me
0:47:35was like, oh, so it doesn't actually have any more travel
0:47:39than the MacBook keyboard, but there's something about it
0:47:43that there's more of an effect
0:47:45when you press down on the key.
0:47:46So it's almost like a haptic.
0:47:49They trick you into feeling,
0:47:52'cause that's how I read it
0:47:53when they said it feels more responsive.
0:47:55- MacBook Pros are smokey mirrors.
0:47:57It's all smokey mirrors now.
0:47:58The track pad doesn't do anything.
0:48:00The keyboard feels like it's popping up more than it is.
0:48:02- So in my briefing, I asked point blank, I said,
0:48:06is it the same key travel as the MacBook?
0:48:08And they said, "Yeah, it is.
0:48:10"It's the same key travel as the MacBook."
0:48:11So don't let anybody tell you
0:48:14that the keys move up and down more on this.
0:48:17- It's just more of a springy feeling.
0:48:19- Yeah, because I don't have a MacBook at home,
0:48:23I couldn't do a one-to-one comparison.
0:48:26I have no doubt that Apple is not making it up,
0:48:29that it is more responsive than the MacBook.
0:48:32But what I would say is this.
0:48:34If you're somebody who rejected the MacBook keyboard,
0:48:39I don't think you're going to turn around on this keyboard.
0:48:45I think if you, your feelings about the MacBook keyboard
0:48:48will be the same about this keyboard.
0:48:50If you like it, then, or don't care,
0:48:54then you'll like it and not care.
0:48:56I can't envision more than like a very small,
0:48:59you know, what, 1%, 5% of people changing their opinion
0:49:02because of the slight variation between this
0:49:04the other one. This is fundamentally the same concept. And if you are somebody who really
0:49:09likes the MacBook Pro and MacBook Air keyboards and doesn't like the direction Apple took
0:49:13with the MacBook keyboard, you're going to have to ask yourself how much you care about
0:49:18getting a new MacBook Pro because you're going to have this keyboard.
0:49:20This is the future of all Apple keyboards.
0:49:22I think that's the case, yeah. I'm wondering now why the Magic Keyboard even existed.
0:49:27That will change. The next Magic Keyboard will be like that. That's my… I would
0:49:31because this is how Apple have done things over the past, right?
0:49:34Like, the laptop keyboards inform all keyboards that Apple make.
0:49:38- Yes.
0:49:39- And so this is clearly what they're doing now
0:49:42because it allows them to put more stuff in the case.
0:49:44That's what it makes it--
0:49:45It allows the whole thing to be thinner
0:49:48and they can still keep battery and they can still put their stuff in.
0:49:50So they take up their space with the keyboard.
0:49:52So my thinking--
0:49:54They find a way to put the touch bar on a keyboard,
0:49:58they need as much battery in that keyboard as possible.
0:50:00The way you do that is by putting the really, really shallow keys in there.
0:50:03- Yeah. - Like, that is the future.
0:50:05Sorry, Casey List, you're going to lose your amazing keyboard.
0:50:07- Well, and I got to tell you, if I have to choose between good keys or the touch bar,
0:50:13I'm never going to choose the touch bar. - I know.
0:50:15- Ever. - But I will choose the touch bar.
0:50:17- I know you will. - And this is the thing.
0:50:19- Traitor. - What do you do?
0:50:21You write for a living. - I do.
0:50:22- What do I do? I manipulate things for a living.
0:50:24- Yeah. - Right?
0:50:25Not people. - Things.
0:50:27- But like, UI, right? That's what I do.
0:50:29I move UI around. Well, I really want to see logic, which I use a lot. I want to see what
0:50:35the touch bar interface is, and I'm very excited about that. But yeah, if I end up having to
0:50:40accept. Now, it is possible. I'll just be devil's advocate here a little bit. It is
0:50:44possible that what Apple's really decided is that they have two keyboard experiences,
0:50:50and one is the laptop and one is the desktop, and the desktop is Magic Keyboard, and the
0:50:54the laptop is this thing. Because otherwise, why does the Magic Keyboard even, why did
0:51:00they do that? Why did they make that? Because that's an entirely new key style from either
0:51:06the Macbook, the old Macbooks, or the new Macbooks.
0:51:09- I think it makes sense in the world in which they don't need more battery inside of the
0:51:13keyboard.
0:51:14- Yeah, well, I'm not sure their keyboard needs to be thin and light, so maybe they
0:51:18will keep it that way. I don't know. I don't know. Because that was always one of the advantages,
0:51:22Like you said, one of the advantages of all the Apple keyboards being the same is that
0:51:26they were the same everywhere. When you switch to a laptop, you didn't go, "Oh, now I'm
0:51:29on a laptop." It was the same keyboard everywhere.
0:51:32- So that's why I think they'll do it, because they will standardize the keyboard feel, and
0:51:36the laptop will drive that, because it has done over the last few years. Something really
0:51:40weird over the last few days came out. The startup chime is missing from this MacBook
0:51:45Pro. Apple have removed the bong from this.
0:51:49- Apparently there is a terminal command you can issue.
0:51:52way to bring it back. Why would they do this? I would say it fits with Apple's tendency
0:52:00to ask about, to question assumptions about their products and when you think that the
0:52:07iOS devices just start up silently with a white apple on a black screen and that's
0:52:12now what the Mac does, that this is consistent. I also saw several people say on Twitter and
0:52:19I thought this was pretty good even though they knew they were swimming against the tide
0:52:23and they were being troublemakers was to say, "Yeah, you know when I start up my iMac in
0:52:27the middle of the night, I totally love the loud chime that wakes up my entire family."
0:52:32So…
0:52:33I mean it's nice that it, you know, but it's just… it's just weird.
0:52:41Also I think if you're living in a world where two-thirds of the Macs sold their laptops,
0:52:47The interaction you have with a laptop is you close the lid and you open the lid.
0:52:51That's all you do.
0:52:53People don't shut down their laptops usually.
0:52:55They just open and close them.
0:52:57In fact, with this new MacBook, when you open it and it's shut down, it starts up.
0:53:07That was a change too.
0:53:09Maybe they decided they really liked the interaction of if you open it, it starts up.
0:53:14didn't want it to be, if you open it, it chimes and then starts up.
0:53:20It's like, it's going to upset some people, right? And I'm kind of like, whatever. But
0:53:24like I just think it's weird, like it's just like, it's just a strange thing to
0:53:30decide to do. I think Apple has decided that the way that
0:53:33these devices, the right way for these devices to operate is silently.
0:53:37But like, in my mind, because the iPhone is silent, the iPad is silent.
0:53:40You remove the chime when the startup is instant.
0:53:43Right. Well, it's getting closer, but it's still not there.
0:53:47Because, like, why even do it? I know there are reasons, but it's like, why this device
0:53:52did you choose for this to be the one? I mean, because then there's like the MacBook. I
0:53:57don't know if this does it, but the MacBook, it makes a sound when you plug it in, right?
0:54:00Yes. Same.
0:54:01Does this do this?
0:54:02Yeah.
0:54:03You know, it's like these strange things. It's like it's still the same operating
0:54:06system, but this version of the machine doesn't make the sound.
0:54:09I think they've decided that Apple products behave a certain way in certain situations.
0:54:13- IOS or Mac, and they have the Apple.
0:54:16So for every person who's saying,
0:54:19"Oh, I can't believe they don't start up with a chime.
0:54:22"Every Mac I've ever owned has started up with a chime."
0:54:25- Some people are like, "Finally."
0:54:26- Well, I think there are a lot of people
0:54:28who are expecting their Mac to behave
0:54:30like their iPad and their iPhone behave,
0:54:33which is chirp when I plug it in, and--
0:54:36- Stay quiet.
0:54:39- When I open it up, have it spring into action.
0:54:43and not ever chime, right?
0:54:45And I think that would be the argument,
0:54:48is it's consistent across the product line
0:54:50of all of Apple's products now and the Mac.
0:54:53You know, also the chime, you know,
0:54:55the chime was meant to be a differentiator
0:54:58over the little stupid beeps that PCs started up with.
0:55:02It was sort of like from that tradition
0:55:03of when your computer starts up,
0:55:05it has a beep to tell you that it's, you know,
0:55:07now initiating the startup process and all of that.
0:55:10And it's an old way of approaching it.
0:55:15And yeah, I don't know.
0:55:17- Apple is out of the standalone display business.
0:55:23- Yeah, this was funny.
0:55:24I actually wrote a piece about all my notes of the event,
0:55:29and I mentioned that they had this LG display,
0:55:32and I asked them about it, and they said,
0:55:33"Yes, it's P3, and it's a 5K display.
0:55:37"It's, I believe, the same panel
0:55:40that's used in the 5K iMac.
0:55:42- Just cuts smaller.
0:55:43- And you can attach it with one cable,
0:55:46one Thunderbolt 3 cable, and it will power your computer,
0:55:50it will charge your laptop,
0:55:52and it has multiple USB ports and a webcam on it,
0:55:57so that you can, it's like a docking station,
0:55:59it's like the Thunderbolt support.
0:56:00- It's like what we would have expected Apple to make.
0:56:02- And in fact, Apple worked with LG on it
0:56:04to the point where your keyboard controls and stuff,
0:56:07your system controls, will control the brightness
0:56:10and on the LG display and stuff.
0:56:12Instead of having to press a menu button
0:56:14and move through the menus,
0:56:15you can do all of that from the computer.
0:56:18So I wrote that it sounded to me like this means the end
0:56:23for Apple being in the display business
0:56:25because they just worked with a partner who makes displays
0:56:28to have it do all the things that they would have built in
0:56:30and Apple doesn't have to worry about it.
0:56:32And Neely Patel at The Verge tweeted a link to my,
0:56:37like retweeted my story link, which is very nice of him, and said, "This is a nice story."
0:56:43And for the record, Apple told me they're out at the display business.
0:56:47So Neil got the confirmation.
0:56:48Not a surprise.
0:56:49Not a surprise.
0:56:50I mean, and people have shown this as an example of Apple not caring about the Mac.
0:56:54And it's like, first off, the Thunderbolt display, I mean, Apple was kind of, you could
0:56:59argue out of the display business, what, five years ago?
0:57:02Because they released the Thunderbolt display and then that was it.
0:57:04They haven't made a monitor in a long time.
0:57:06They removed the Thunderbolt display this year, but it's been irrelevant for several
0:57:10years before that.
0:57:11The thing is, like the not care thing, you could have made that argument when they cancelled
0:57:16the Thunderbolt display and they said, "There are great options available.
0:57:19Go find them."
0:57:20Yes.
0:57:21But this time, they've worked with a company to make sure there's a really good monitor
0:57:25option.
0:57:26A company that makes monitors and cares about it and will sell them at whatever their margins
0:57:31are.
0:57:32And Apple doesn't have to have it be Apple branded.
0:57:35I don't know.
0:57:36Maybe this is a silly parallel to make,
0:57:41but did everybody freak out
0:57:43when Apple got out of the printer business?
0:57:46- Probably.
0:57:47(laughing)
0:57:48- Probably, but you know,
0:57:50does Apple need to be in the monitor business?
0:57:52No, it absolutely does not need to be in that business.
0:57:56So it's not gonna be in that business.
0:57:58- Like just imagine that this is a slightly less
0:58:00good looking Thunderbolt display
0:58:02and you're all good to go.
0:58:03- Yeah, put some tape over the LG logo if you want,
0:58:05but this is it. I mean, I think people should be excited because this means that when that
0:58:10new Mac Pro comes out next spring, let's just cross our fingers, but I think it's
0:58:15got to happen, and already with these new MacBook Pros, you got it now. You want a laptop
0:58:21and a 5K display like that 5K iMac. You bought a 5K iMac because even though you're a laptop
0:58:27person and you'd much rather have one computer, you bought the standalone computer because
0:58:31you wanted that beautiful 27-inch 5K display,
0:58:34and were willing to pay for it,
0:58:36and now you've got two computers, oh well.
0:58:39Guess what?
0:58:40As of now, you can go back to being that laptop person
0:58:44and running it docked.
0:58:46You can do clamshell mode if you want,
0:58:48and one plug, and you're plugged in,
0:58:50and you're on a 5K display that is the same display
0:58:53as on that iMac.
0:58:54It exists today.
0:58:56This is the dream, right?
0:58:57This is the dream, external 5K display with one cable
0:59:00from your Mac. We're living the dream. So I think it's all good news.
0:59:06Last thing I want to ask you about the Mac work. Should they have included a USB A to
0:59:11C dongle in the box? Four USB C ports.
0:59:16Yeah, or two on my 13 with the function row.
0:59:21Yeah, exactly. You need dongles. Dongles are the word. Everybody is going to need them.
0:59:28they have like with the headphone jack put one of these in the box? With the difference
0:59:34being there's no other option, right? Like it's not like Bluetooth, there was another
0:59:39option. It's like all you can do is plug stuff in.
0:59:42I'm gonna say yes for one reason, which is every iOS device Apple makes ships with a
0:59:53- And the USB-A.
0:59:55And I know that the primary goal of the iPad and the iPhone
0:59:59is not to connect it to your computer,
1:00:01but sometimes you gotta.
1:00:03And if you're in that situation where you've gotta connect
1:00:10to your computer, you can't now without another adapter.
1:00:14So I think it would've been a nice thing for them to do,
1:00:17to just ship that adapter in the box for a generation.
1:00:21But you can get it for whatever it costs.
1:00:23I have the Thunderbolt adapter.
1:00:25It's amazing.
1:00:26It's like a block of cheese or something.
1:00:29It's like a tube attached to a wire.
1:00:33It's fascinating the amount of electronics
1:00:37that must be in there in order to convert--
1:00:38- What is that, Thunderbolt to what?
1:00:40- It's a Thunderbolt.
1:00:41- Oh.
1:00:42- Thunderbolt 3 to traditional
1:00:44like mini-display port shape Thunderbolt.
1:00:47That's a weird adapter, but it works.
1:00:49I actually transferred my data to this computer
1:00:51from my MacBook Air by putting my MacBook Air
1:00:54in Thunderbolt target mode and attaching
1:00:57a Thunderbolt cable to that adapter
1:00:59to the Thunderbolt 3 on here.
1:01:01Let's talk about Thunderbolt for a second
1:01:02just because, I mean, this is true,
1:01:04we've been anticipating this day, but now it's here.
1:01:07These ports are Thunderbolt 3.
1:01:09- Yeah, they're not actually USB-C.
1:01:11- Yeah, I mean, they use the same connector.
1:01:13- Yeah.
1:01:14- And they emulate USB-C in the same way,
1:01:16and I know this is a weird parallel,
1:01:17but I'm making weird parallels right now.
1:01:20If you think about, Mini DisplayPort used to be the port
1:01:22on some Mac laptops.
1:01:26It was just a monitor port.
1:01:27And then it became the Thunderbolt port.
1:01:30But it was the same plug.
1:01:31And if you plugged a Mini DisplayPort monitor into it,
1:01:33it just acted like a Mini DisplayPort.
1:01:36That's what's on these new MacBook Pros.
1:01:38They are the shape of USB 3.
1:01:40If you plug in, or USB-C,
1:01:42if you plug in a USB-C something, it works.
1:01:46- It's kind of awesome.
1:01:47- Yeah, it's great.
1:01:48But if you plug in a Thunderbolt 3 something,
1:01:53it gets all of the power of Thunderbolt 3, which is more.
1:01:55It's like a super set of what's in USB-C.
1:01:57And that's how you drive the 5K displays
1:01:59with Thunderbolt 3.
1:02:01But what it does mean is like that Thunderbolt 3
1:02:05to Thunderbolt 2 adapter that I bought,
1:02:08or Thunderbolt 3 to Thunderbolt like old,
1:02:10because I think it works with one or two.
1:02:12If you try to plug that into a MacBook, it doesn't work.
1:02:16Because it's Thunderbolt.
1:02:18it needs Thunderbolt.
1:02:19- 'Cause the MacBook is USB-C.
1:02:20- Is USB-C.
1:02:21Now I imagine next spring's MacBook
1:02:24- Will be Thunderbolt 3.
1:02:24- Will be Thunderbolt 3.
1:02:26- Well maybe, 'cause the problem is the chipset
1:02:28and blah blah blah blah blah, ATP.
1:02:30- Yes, ATP will tell you.
1:02:32But I would imagine as soon as they can possibly
1:02:35convert that thing into Thunderbolt 3.
1:02:37- It will be, it's a better connector.
1:02:38- They will.
1:02:39- It's just like I appreciate how good that connector is,
1:02:42but all I know is the 2016 is not a USB-C world yet.
1:02:46- Things are moving.
1:02:47- Yeah, this is gonna help.
1:02:48This is gonna help a lot.
1:02:49I mean, Apple only having one USB-C product
1:02:52for a year and a half
1:02:53was not gonna make things move a whole lot.
1:02:55There's more that's out there when the MacBook came out,
1:02:57so that's a good start.
1:02:59- The hope is that Apple now give
1:03:01an excuse to the PC industry as well.
1:03:06That like now the PC industry say,
1:03:07"Oh, well Apple's done it, so we'll do it too."
1:03:09Which is how things tend to go.
1:03:10- Yeah, and I mean, it's already happening on the PC side,
1:03:12but I think that this will probably
1:03:14make it that much easier for everybody on the PC side to push to USB-C, if not Thunderbolt
1:03:193. I mean, they can pick up Thunderbolt 3, that's an Intel thing, but if they don't do
1:03:24that, then there's USB-C at least. And it's a much smaller connector and, you know, it's
1:03:31reversible so you can stick it in either way. As you said, ATP, they've been talking about
1:03:34this over there for ages. But bless them. I enjoy those conversations a lot.
1:03:41- I learned, that's how I knew that the MacBook
1:03:44wouldn't work with Thunderbolt 3,
1:03:45'cause the Intel chip says wrong.
1:03:47- And in reality, I don't think this is gonna be
1:03:49a conversion nightmare, because I think
1:03:52if your device doesn't need the power of Thunderbolt 3,
1:03:57it won't be a Thunderbolt 3 device.
1:04:00There's not gonna be, if you're like a MacBook person,
1:04:02you're like, oh my God, now everything I have to do,
1:04:04everything I buy, I gotta be careful
1:04:05that it's not the wrong thing.
1:04:07I think it'll be devices that require the extreme speed of Thunderbolt 3 that will build
1:04:14in Thunderbolt 3, because there's a lot of overhead in Thunderbolt 3 that I think isn't
1:04:18there in USB-C. So most things will probably be USB-C. And on the MacBook Pro, it doesn't
1:04:23matter. You'll just plug them in. You won't worry about it, because they'll all work,
1:04:27and it'll be fine. But I think it's good. I think it's great. That's why I did the draft
1:04:31I Apple Apple decided to rip the mandate off and just say everything you know there will not be here's another bold prediction
1:04:38I'll just throw it out there. I think it's obvious so how bold could it be there will not be another Mac
1:04:43released with Thunderbolt and
1:04:46USB a
1:04:48Yeah, it's all it's all USB. It's all Thunderbolt 3 now
1:04:51Yeah with a possible exception being like a MacBook it might have to have a USB C
1:04:56But I can't keep doing that cuz it's too confusing
1:04:58I feel like this is the end of the old connections and they are just moving on to the new world
1:05:05All right, let's wrap up today's episode with some ask upgrades
1:05:08Andy wanted to know if he judged your mood correctly. Yeah, I see I saw this picture
1:05:13I'm gonna put it in the show, you know, my mood my mood was this is during the TV
1:05:19introduction my movie my mood was that I was in the third row and I figured I was probably on gonna be on camera and
1:05:24And so when I looked up, I would try to appear personable
1:05:28and not angry.
1:05:29I wasn't angry, I'm working.
1:05:33The answer to every question of when I saw you
1:05:36on the live video stream, what were you thinking
1:05:38or what were you doing or why did you look that way,
1:05:41the answer is always, I was working.
1:05:43I was doing my job and working, that's what I was doing.
1:05:46- You didn't look very happy with that.
1:05:48- I was not angry, I was not unhappy, I was working.
1:05:51That's just how it is.
1:05:52I'm not sitting there.
1:05:53But you know what, if I could just lay back and enjoy an Apple presentation, also I will
1:05:58say this about these Apple presentations, I'm not usually in the third row, I'm usually
1:06:01toward the back.
1:06:02- It's fancy.
1:06:03- We just sort of ended up at the front.
1:06:08And everybody in front of us was Apple employees, so I can say this, first off, all the applause
1:06:15that happens in Apple events starts in the first row.
1:06:20The first person to clap at all the clap lines is somebody in the first row.
1:06:24At least once I noticed that it was Eddie Q. I could see Eddie Q start the clapping
1:06:29and I was like, "All right, that's where it's starting from."
1:06:32Eddie's on clap duty today.
1:06:34And it's a little bit awkward because I will clap at an Apple event for a person who did
1:06:42something impressive or something.
1:06:43I'll do a polite clap for some things, not for very long.
1:06:47But I do not participate in the "Here's a feature, clap, clap, clap, clap," especially
1:06:54when I'm sitting there and I can see how it's Apple executives who are starting the
1:06:59clap.
1:07:00So it's fine.
1:07:01It's a show.
1:07:02It's marketing.
1:07:03It is what it is, and that's fine.
1:07:06So when you see me on the video of the Apple event, I'm doing my job and trying to pay
1:07:11attention and trying not to look like I'm rolling my eyes and being mean to them because
1:07:16Because I'm really not, I'm just paying attention and trying to do my job.
1:07:20Richard asked, "Considering the high prices of the MacBook Pro in the UK, would it be
1:07:24wise to buy the current iMac right now or just wait?
1:07:28Like would it be, should you buy that?"
1:07:30I think it's worth waiting because the iMac price will probably not go up when they introduce
1:07:37the next one.
1:07:38So I would wait.
1:07:39If you can wait, I would still wait because it's more expensive now for the same computer.
1:07:44But if you are able to wait, wait until they actually make that money worth it for you
1:07:48by giving you some new internals.
1:07:49And that's the same old thing that we always say, which is if you can afford to wait, you
1:07:52should generally wait.
1:07:54And in this case...
1:07:55Although, like, you know, this is like a Godot situation with the Mac, but...
1:07:58Yeah, I just, I feel fairly confident that there will be an iMac update probably in the
1:08:02spring.
1:08:03So if you can wait until the spring, and to your point about UK prices, price is up now.
1:08:08So why not get a new computer without that larger price instead of an old computer?
1:08:13Lucas wanted to ask, considering that you can charge the MacBook Pro from any of the
1:08:19Thunderbolt 3 ports, can you put in multiple chargers for quicker charging?
1:08:24No.
1:08:25It picks, you could plug, you can plug in four chargers.
1:08:30And what happens is, it looks for the one that's supplying the most power.
1:08:36So if you've got like the big brick, cause like the 15 comes with a bigger brick than
1:08:39and the 13, which comes in a bigger brick than the MacBook.
1:08:44There are gradations of wattage.
1:08:46And it will look for the one that's supplying
1:08:50the most power and use that.
1:08:51It does mean that you can charge on either side
1:08:55of those MacBooks that have the four ports,
1:08:58which is kind of flexible if you're like,
1:09:03oh, it would work better in my setup
1:09:06if I plugged it in the right side.
1:09:08you can do that now, which you couldn't do when there was only the MagSafe connector.
1:09:12But yeah, it will look, and if they're all the same, supplying the same amount of power,
1:09:16I don't know what it does, it probably has a sequence that it goes in and it chooses
1:09:19which one. But in the end, that's what it's doing, is it'll try to find the one that's
1:09:24supplying it with the most wattage, and then it takes that one.
1:09:27All right, that wraps up this week's episode. If you want to find our show notes for today,
1:09:32go to relay.fm/upgrades/113. If you want to find Jason online, he is at @jasenel on Twitter,
1:09:41he's at 6colors.com. I am @imike, I-M-Y-K-E. Thank you so much to Pingdom for supporting
1:09:48this week's episode. We are at the OR conference this weekend, so this is like basically these
1:09:54next things are if you're here. But even if you're not, Jason is participating in something
1:10:00called All Radio this week, which is a kind of a interesting podcast type thing that you're
1:10:07going to be running people through. Do you want to say what people can listen to this?
1:10:14Right? Yeah, so you can search for All Radio, U-L-L, radio on iTunes, or go to the RSS feed
1:10:21is at feedpress.me/allradio. Of course, that would be in the show notes as well. And what
1:10:28can people expect from that? Well, the conference hasn't started yet, so I haven't really decided.
1:10:34The goal is for me to talk to people who are here, to talk to speakers and other presenters
1:10:41and maybe even some conference participants and have some chats and put them in the feed
1:10:46and provide sort of some combination between sort of supplemental information for the conference
1:10:54as well as an opportunity for some of the great conversation that happens here at this
1:10:59conference to be accessible to people who aren't here.
1:11:03And just as another note, I wonder if people who are attending these conferences listen
1:11:07to the podcasts that we make at them. So, the password is "bananas". If you're at the
1:11:13All Conference and you come to me and say the password "bananas", I'll give you some
1:11:18kind of special prize, just because I'm interested to know.
1:11:21I've got stickers.
1:11:22Jason has stickers.
1:11:23So come to me and say bananas and I will make sure you get stickers.
1:11:25There you go. So that is the secret code word if you're at the OAR conference.
1:11:29I just want to see if anyone, if it will happen then.
1:11:31Yeah.
1:11:31So that's why I want to put right at the very end to people get right to the end whilst here.
1:11:35So bananas is the password.
1:11:38Thank you so much for listening to this week's episode of Upgrade.
1:11:40We'll be back next week and there will be a big big ocean in between us.
1:11:44Until then, say goodbye, Jason Stell.
1:11:46Goodbye, Myke Hurley.
1:11:47[Music]
1:12:00Only all the gods have returned!
1:12:02(laughing)