Podcast Search

Upgrade

38: Titles Are Not Jobs

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00[Music]

0:00:10From Relay FM, this is Upgrade, episode number 38.

0:00:13Today's show is brought to you by Hover, simplified domain management.

0:00:17Mail route, a secure hosted email service for protection from viruses and spam.

0:00:22And, go to meeting.

0:00:23Make it easy to meet with your team, whenever you need to, wherever you are.

0:00:28My name is Myke Hurley and I'm joined as always by the man behind Six Colors, Mr. Jason Snell.

0:00:34Hello, Mr. I'm Michael. How are you?

0:00:37I am very well, sir. How are you?

0:00:38I'm doing good. We had the long weekend, which in England is called the, a very bureaucratic

0:00:45name, the Spring Bank Holiday.

0:00:47We have many bank holidays. This one doesn't really have too much of a purpose. So it's

0:00:51just called the Spring one.

0:00:53And the bank is just because the banks are closed and they felt that that was the most

0:00:58important thing was that the banks are closed.

0:01:00I have no idea why they're called that. I feel like I've looked it up once or twice,

0:01:04but they're just called bank holidays. I mean, sometimes when I used to work in a bank, sometimes

0:01:10the banks were open, which didn't make any sense, but they were.

0:01:13That's a crime, the banks open on a bank holiday. That's madness.

0:01:17You can imagine how we felt.

0:01:19I was in, on this weekend, which I was in Europe, I forget when that was, 2004 or something

0:01:27like that. We ended up in Bruges in Belgium and it was also a long weekend there. I think

0:01:34it was something related to a church calendar thing, but I think everybody sort of agrees

0:01:37that they're going to find a way to have the last Monday in May off as a kickoff to summer.

0:01:44It was funny because the banks were definitely on holiday in Bruges because there was no

0:01:48money in the ATMs. So we were like, "We don't have money and we can't get money." It was

0:01:54interesting. And we finally found an ATM somewhere, like our fifth ATM, finally we found some

0:02:00ones that would send some euro to us. It was weird. Belgium, what are you going to do?

0:02:06Anyway, yes, Memorial Day here in the US. And so, my daughter marched in a parade yesterday,

0:02:12and yeah, it was nice. It's the official kickoff to summer in San Francisco, which

0:02:16means that it was like 60 degrees and foggy all day, as it usually is on Memorial Day.

0:02:23So you know, stand outside and shiver.

0:02:25Woo, summer.

0:02:26Woo hoo.

0:02:27I'm hoping for a little bit of sun in a couple of weeks' time.

0:02:31I hope, well we haven't had any so far, but I hope that it turns nice so that we can put

0:02:35on a nice show for you people when you're all out here in two weeks.

0:02:38Two weeks, Myke.

0:02:39Two weeks.

0:02:40So you know what that means next week, right?

0:02:43I don't know.

0:02:44No, what does that mean for next week?

0:02:45Predictions!

0:02:46Oh no, okay good.

0:02:48I was worried that, I was worried you were going to say something like it's the mid-year

0:02:52Upgrady Awards! No! I have ideas about the Upgradies by the way for the end of the year.

0:02:58I have ideas.

0:02:59Steve: See? I told you. I told you it would kick in.

0:03:02Adam; I do have some ideas. They will actually be the second annual Upgradies, which is you

0:03:06can't do annual unless you do them again. So it will actually be legitimately annual.

0:03:12Anyway, yes, we'll do some predictions next week and then we will be together for our,

0:03:18I guess this will be our third live in-person upgrade in two weeks after the keynote.

0:03:25So that will be exciting.

0:03:26We'll be recording on Monday as well which is fantastic.

0:03:28So we'll be live from San Francisco which I enjoy.

0:03:32This is where the Monday broadcast pays off.

0:03:35Although today it's on Tuesday.

0:03:37And also whatever day, podcasting, whatever day you choose to listen to this, it might

0:03:41be Thursday where you are.

0:03:43Hello Thursday.

0:03:44Should we do some follow up?

0:03:46I think that's a good idea.

0:03:47A couple of things this week.

0:03:49So we had something from listener Eric who wanted to kind of just... we were talking

0:03:54about pronunciations again last week in Ask Upgrade about trying to teach Siri pronunciations

0:04:01of names.

0:04:02And we were saying that where you can't necessarily teach it, pronunciations of different words

0:04:07for the text dictation, you can teach it to learn your name and to say your name back

0:04:12to you correctly.

0:04:13However, Eric has had some problems with this.

0:04:15cannot teach Siri how to pronounce his name. His last name is spelled R-A-U-C-H. It has

0:04:24a silent C-H. So I'm going to say it's like Rau or Raul or something like that. He

0:04:30says he cannot get Siri to learn his name in any fashion, which is so unfortunate. I

0:04:36guess you'd have to like put it in as like R-A-W or something like that.

0:04:40Well, this is my understanding is that there is a field in contacts for pronunciation.

0:04:44And I think, but I don't know where it gets used, but it might get used in this way, where

0:04:50you can put in the pronunciation and you can have that be a phonetic, you know, pronunciation,

0:04:54something ridiculous. Like when I do the incomparable intros and the little computer voice reads

0:04:58the number and sometimes those are bizarre phrases that I put in there in order to get

0:05:04it to sound the way I want it to sound. And I think you can do that with any contact is

0:05:10have a pronunciation field and it gets used in some places, but it's inconsistent and

0:05:14yeah, Siri, you know, she's going to do what she's going to do or if you're in other parts

0:05:19of the world, he's going to do what he's going to do. But, you know, Siri is just, Siri is

0:05:22going to Siri, is what I'm saying.

0:05:25-Siri is a dude here.

0:05:27-Yeah, I know.

0:05:28-I think that there is a female voice now, but I'm very used to British Siri being a

0:05:33guy, so I kind of just leave it as it is. But I think that we got the female voice in

0:05:38and like, you know, a seven or something.

0:05:40- Nice.

0:05:41- But, you know, it takes on a certain personality, so.

0:05:43- Yeah, oh yeah.

0:05:44- So we were talking about Letterman a bit last week.

0:05:48We were talking about your "Encompro" episode,

0:05:50and I'd kind of just wanted to get,

0:05:51'cause I don't know if you're gonna talk about it

0:05:53anywhere else, I wanted to just get a brief feeling

0:05:55for were you happy, did you watch Letterman finale?

0:05:59How did you feel about it?

0:06:00- Yeah, we watched it on broadcast,

0:06:03stayed up late and watched it,

0:06:04I talked about it a little bit on the TV podcast I do with Tim Goodman, the TV critic at The

0:06:11Hollywood Reporter, which is on the Incomparable. It's called TV Talk Machine. I talked about

0:06:15it a little bit with him there. You know, it was a good sendoff. It wasn't Weepy and

0:06:20Maudlin. It was lots of montages of stuff. And it ended with this crazy montage that

0:06:28the producers have been working on since December. Basically, Foo Fighters comes out, starts

0:06:32playing Everlong live on stage, but then instead of showing them, they run this montage. Somebody

0:06:38annotated it on Facebook. It's like 500 different clips over the span of four minutes or something.

0:06:44It's super crazy. I literally felt like my life was passing before my eyes, especially

0:06:50for the first half of it because I remember almost everything in the first half, certainly

0:06:55in his NBC days. Suddenly, I had that moment of like, "That is my life from 1985 to,

0:07:021995 at least. It was pretty crazy. So it was good. I think it was a good send-off to

0:07:10just say goodbye and talk about stuff, memories and do some funny bits and have it be done.

0:07:18And it wasn't one of those kind of teary finales and I think that was fitting. And so yeah,

0:07:24it was good. Beyond that, I mean I didn't watch the show. I wasn't watching the show

0:07:30show regularly the last few years anyway. So, you know, it's just a passing of a moment

0:07:37then. And I said that in the incomparable episode that I did about it is, you know,

0:07:41when I thought about it, you know, this is something that I moved on from this a long

0:07:45time ago. And so it's not as if something was taken from me so much as it was a moment

0:07:50to think about those good times in the past. And I think the finale did that too. So, yeah.

0:07:57So thanks for asking, but it was good. Yeah.

0:07:58- So when I saw everybody talking about it,

0:08:00I decided that I would go to YouTube

0:08:03and I watched a few clips from the finale.

0:08:05But it was one of those scenarios,

0:08:07like I just wanna watch the whole thing.

0:08:08Like just give me the whole thing.

0:08:11However you need to do that, just let me watch it.

0:08:13Like I've never wanted to watch Letterman before

0:08:16because it's just never been something

0:08:17that was on my radar too much.

0:08:18Like I know of him, I know about all the late night shows.

0:08:23But I didn't really particularly have an interest

0:08:26in watching it before.

0:08:27But I wanted to watch that episode.

0:08:28Couldn't like just watch these little snippets of it, which was fine

0:08:32But I kind of wanted to see the whole thing and plus like they were you know

0:08:36The snippets that I watched were good

0:08:38But like they weren't I mean and I had heard people talking about this like they weren't like the kind of snippets that you see from

0:08:45other

0:08:46Talk shows where they're like you can just take that one little bit and you're good, right?

0:08:50It felt like that there was more to it than that because I know like, you know

0:08:54I'd heard like in some profiles that maybe one of the reasons he's decided to go away is because shows like

0:09:00Jimmy Fallon and James Corden and people like that they make their bits to be shared right to go viral, right?

0:09:08And he wasn't too interested in doing that

0:09:11Well, I think there is a full show up there

0:09:14You may have to do your magical things to make it think that you're in the US

0:09:19but there is on the CBS comm slash late show there's a

0:09:22The leftmost in their list of latest videos is full episode, and it looks like that's

0:09:30the final episode, so it may be there.

0:09:32>> So I was just going to YouTube.

0:09:34>> Oh yeah.

0:09:35>> I don't know why not just put it on YouTube.

0:09:38>> Well I'm sure they have their reasons, but I think there's a way to get it.

0:09:41>> I can't watch it because of my geographical reasons, although I can if I do some stuff.

0:09:46>> You can do your magic tricks anyway, but yeah.

0:09:51It's funny because they're done now and they were ripping the seats out of the theater

0:09:55and they asked him about it actually. He was at the Indy 500, the auto race this weekend

0:10:01because he's from Indianapolis and he is a co-owner of cars that race in that race actually.

0:10:09He said, "Yeah, day later they're tearing the seats out of the theater." So that pretty

0:10:14much says it all about show business, right? So they're done. They're moving out the staff

0:10:20and it's just over. It wasn't just, "We're going to have some time to tidy up." It's

0:10:26shows over, folks. So that's kind of interesting, that website on the CBS site. It presumably

0:10:33is just abandoned now and then at some point, it will get turned into the Stephen Colbert

0:10:37site. And I have this question about contractually, at what point are they on their own and that

0:10:43Letterman's company owns all that material and are they going to… Is there a staff

0:10:48at his company because Worldwide Pants is his production company. Are they building

0:10:52a David Letterman.com or something like that that's got old clips or archives or things

0:10:57they post on YouTube? Johnny Carson's estate actually has that. So I wonder if they'll

0:11:01do that. But it's interesting. This is one of those cases of like digital permanence

0:11:05and impermanence where I feel like a lot of these clips that are on the official site,

0:11:09they're just going to go away because CBS is going to want to promote the new version

0:11:14of the show hosted by Stephen Colbert and I'm not sure whether that all the Letterman

0:11:18stuff won't just get thrown in the trash you know digitally like the like the set and the

0:11:23seats were thrown in the trash the next day.

0:11:25David: You don't want to like you know from that perspective you don't want to revel in

0:11:28how great the past is when you're trying to promote the new show.

0:11:31Tim: CBS's job is to promote the new show plus I'm not quite sure what CBS's rights

0:11:35to that stuff are contractually after some period of time like it may be that the moment

0:11:39Colbert premieres, the Letterman stuff has to go off because it's not theirs anymore.

0:11:44It belongs to Letterman and not CBS. That is probably the case. So it's a weird thing,

0:11:50but it made me think about the fact that NBC and David Letterman, they have never made

0:11:58much effort to show old clips. There have been reruns a couple of times of old David

0:12:03Letterman shows and those got nipped in the bud pretty quickly. And so that stuff is not

0:12:08available anywhere except on YouTube where huge amounts of it are available. In fact,

0:12:12I was seeing people, even Jimmy Kimmel, I think, when he said goodbye to Letterman on

0:12:19the same night as Letterman's last show, he played a clip from YouTube of a favorite

0:12:25moment of his. So these people just put, you know, and I was going to do it and I discovered

0:12:29that every clip that I saved on an old VHS tape that I got out and I was playing and

0:12:33all that, they're all already on YouTube. So in the end, that's your digital permanence.

0:12:37It's like people going outside of the law in order to get this stuff around and then

0:12:42that becomes this incredibly valuable resource.

0:12:45Whereas the official channels, you know, that stuff is inaccessible like you said, you didn't

0:12:50even look on CBS.com and then it goes away because their, you know, their contract expires

0:12:55and it's just all gone.

0:12:56So you know, bless you YouTubers for uploading things you don't have the rights to so that

0:13:03we could actually see this stuff.

0:13:05So, otherwise it's just lost.

0:13:09Yeah. So many of the Farewell Letterman pieces in the last couple of weeks have had YouTube

0:13:14embeds in them. Those are all not authorized by David Letterman or NBC, but that's also

0:13:20the legacy of the show. I mean, thank goodness those things exist because otherwise… Well,

0:13:24I sent you… We were talking last week, not to spoil a future episode of a different podcast,

0:13:30we were talking last week about off of this show about music and I sent you a still of

0:13:39David Letterman holding up the record of my favorite album of all time.

0:13:43David Why would we have been talking about that?

0:13:45Tim I don't know why that would be. It's for

0:13:47a future episode of Clockwise obviously. So that was just, that was just, you know, that's

0:13:53on YouTube. I searched for the band and Letterman and I got all of their performances on Letterman

0:13:59they're all on YouTube so yeah shine on you crazy pirates.

0:14:06So you released your photo book. It's out now. It's finally all done.

0:14:14Yeah I think they're calling it version 1.1. I would say it's the real final version of it.

0:14:18We released sort of the first half and yeah yeah so it's a Photos for Mac, a Take Control crash course is the name of it.

0:14:27can get it at TakeControl.com. Or no, TakeControlBooks.com, sorry. Don't go to... that's like that dash.com

0:14:34that's laundry detergent. Don't go there. And don't go to TakeControl. TakeControlBooks.com.

0:14:40And so it's part of the Take Control Books line, so what you're going to get is it's...

0:14:44I think the page count is like 60-ish. It's this like super boiled-down design, lots of

0:14:51screenshots, lots of references. It is me trying to boil down everything like you need.

0:14:56kind of dense. I think it's visual, so it's easier to get through. I was thinking about

0:15:02it. If I had written a traditional book, I probably would have written four times the

0:15:07amount of words, but I'm not sure it would have been any more informative, and I'm pretty

0:15:14sure it wouldn't have been as easy to read. It's an interesting format. I wrote this to

0:15:20to fit their format, but their format is interesting in that the Crash Course format is, you know,

0:15:26it's kind of no nonsense. The chapters…

0:15:28David: Not a lot of voice in there, I assume.

0:15:31David Tzemba-Lemmich Yeah, there's some jokes in there. I tried

0:15:34to put some voice in there, but you know, there's not a lot of room for it. You know,

0:15:37the chapters are of a fairly constrained length. You've got a column running down the side

0:15:41with sidebars and images in it. It is a format that you're fitting, but I think what's

0:15:45powerful about it is it's really no nonsense. It's like, you know, if you want to read

0:15:50a book that is thousands and thousands of words about some piece of software because

0:15:53it's fun. This is probably not the book for you. This is a book that is like, "Let's

0:15:58get down to business. Here's what you need to know. Here's some tips. Here's what

0:16:01these different tools do." And I kind of appreciate that because I think there's

0:16:05probably more of an audience for that than there is for sort of recreational reading

0:16:08about software. So that's what they're… and Adam and Tanya Anx to do it. You know,

0:16:13they know their business and they know their audience. But it was an educational experience

0:16:18to write it. I feel like I've learned a whole lot about photos for Mac and I like it. I'm

0:16:23not going to ditch it. I do like it, although it's got some serious limitations that hopefully

0:16:29Apple is already working on.

0:16:30I think having a short book that gives you all the information you're going to need is

0:16:35good if what you're trying to do is just learn how to use a program. As nice as it is to

0:16:40get a lot more of the character around it, if a crash course is what you're looking for,

0:16:4560 pages seems about right.

0:16:47Yeah, I mean, and you can jump around and it's got, you know, it's very visual.

0:16:51They do some nice things like when you say click on this button or look at this icon,

0:16:55the icon is in the text, like you put it right. I mean, it was a lot of work for me to take

0:16:59the screenshots and all that, but it ends up being, yeah, so it's interesting. It's

0:17:06been interesting. I've gotten some feedback already from people, you know, and some of

0:17:10it is why did it take so long and the answer is because Apple like sort of unveiled photos

0:17:16really much earlier than I think anybody anticipated. And I started writing it when it was in that

0:17:21first beta. And it just with my travel and a bunch of other production issues with them,

0:17:26it took until now for us to get the final final. But that's what we got the first half

0:17:29out when we did is we wanted to get as much as we could out as soon as we could. And then

0:17:34again, like the format, you know, I think it's actually a really clever format and I

0:17:40think it's a very useful format. If you are expecting, you know, Jason's 20,000, you know,

0:17:46word essay on the meaning of photos, you're not going to get it because that's not the

0:17:49point of the book. The book is really, you know, what are all the tools and how do I

0:17:53use it? And I think it's very useful in that.

0:17:56- Cool. We have a ton of stuff to get to today.

0:17:58- Yeah.

0:17:59- So we should probably do that. But before we do, let me take a moment to thank our friends

0:18:03over at Hover. Hover is the best way to buy and manage domain names. Me and Jason were

0:18:09talking before we recorded today about the fact that we're both coming up to about a

0:18:13a year on our projects like Six Colors and Relay are both coming up towards a year old.

0:18:19And I'm getting, and I know Jason is as well, a lot of domain renewal notices right now.

0:18:23So I'm getting some stuff coming from Hover where it's like, you know, it's coming up

0:18:28to a year, do you want to renew?

0:18:30And you know, the only thing that I ever hear from them is just these renewal notices, which

0:18:34is great, they don't send me a bunch of spam.

0:18:36But what it's doing is reminding me of like a year ago about all of the stuff that I was

0:18:42trying to buy to think of names for Relay when me and Stephen were thinking about this

0:18:46stuff and it reminds me of the process like so we would have an idea for a name so we'd

0:18:51go over to hover it was like the first place that we'd go is the domain available if it

0:18:56was we'd buy them and it was really simple to do and what it will allow you to do is

0:19:00to collect up these names that you could then maybe use other stuff or just to make sure

0:19:05that you have them in place and then once you get the domains that you want they sit

0:19:10there and they're very easy to manage, they have great domain management tools but their

0:19:14buying process is just so simple and so easy. You don't have to go through a thousand screens,

0:19:20it shows you what's available. If the domain that you want isn't available they'll show

0:19:23you some really smart recommendations and all of the TLDs that are available. So .com

0:19:28might not be but they have .net, .me, .co.uk, .plumbing, .coffee, .fish, anything you need

0:19:34they have it. Hover have got them all. They give you who is privacy for free, that's one

0:19:38of my favorite things about hover because when you buy a domain you don't

0:19:42necessarily want the whole world knowing your home address that's what hover makes

0:19:46sure that you get for free of all of your domains and I was registering a

0:19:49domain a couple of days ago with hover and I like is it's automatically checked

0:19:53you can't miss it right they check it for you the who is privacy which is

0:19:57fantastic of course you don't have to have it but you should have it because

0:20:00it keeps your private information safe however have great customer support

0:20:04including a no hold no wait no transfer telephone support policy you give hover

0:20:08a call you're going to speak to somebody that's going to be able to help you. They

0:20:11have great email support as well, they have great guides and support

0:20:15documents on their website in case you want to do stuff on your own and don't

0:20:18forget Hover's valet service where they can take all the domains you have as a

0:20:22number provider and move them to Hover for free for you. They'll just do it all

0:20:26it's fantastic it's absolutely fantastic they'll just do that for you. So head on

0:20:30over right now to hover.com and you should be trying them out for yourself

0:20:33yourself, you can get 10% off your first purchase at Hover if you use the code "dubdub".

0:20:39D-U-B-D-U-B. People are going to hate me for that one. So that's "dubdub" D-U-B-D-U-B.

0:20:45You're going to get 10% off your first purchase and show your support for Upgrade and all

0:20:48of ReadAFM. Thank you to Hover for sponsoring this week's episode.

0:20:52Myke, Upgrade.fish is available by the way.

0:20:55I don't know why I haven't bought it already.

0:21:00So yesterday as we record this, so it was Labor Day in the States.

0:21:04No.

0:21:05No.

0:21:06Memorial Day.

0:21:07That's it.

0:21:08Memorial Day.

0:21:09I was getting those ones mixed up.

0:21:10I don't think I need to worry about it.

0:21:12It's not my country.

0:21:14I know it's a holiday.

0:21:16I apologize.

0:21:17Well, judging by your accent, it's rapidly becoming your country, so watch it early.

0:21:21We'll wait until I actually get the visa and make the move.

0:21:25All right.

0:21:26So it was Memorial Day.

0:21:27There we go.

0:21:28We got it right this time.

0:21:29Good job. And Johnny Ive got a new job.

0:21:34Apparently, or has he had it for a while? He told Stephen Fry about his new job.

0:21:39Yes, this is really interesting. So it was announced in the UK, in the Telegraph, in

0:21:44a profile by Stephen Fry. That was how it came to the world.

0:21:48And then Tim Cook sent a memo. Yeah.

0:21:51Yeah, which then leaks out, as these things tend to do, and I believe they're written

0:21:55that way. They've got to be, right? You've got to write those knowing that the world's

0:21:58going to see them. Like, "Oh, by the way, everyone, secret project X is coming along.

0:22:03It's coming along nice and I don't tell anyone."

0:22:06Shh! Keep it under your hat.

0:22:09So he is now Chief Design Officer. So he is what is now known as a C-level executive.

0:22:15C-level. That's right. He's living in C-level. He's pivoting with brands at C-level.

0:22:21So this puts him with… is Phil Shiller like a CMO or is he just…

0:22:29I think he's senior vice president, executive vice president, yeah.

0:22:34So this puts Ive at a very, very strong position in Apple now, at least from a title perspective,

0:22:41because in theory, as people have said, he's probably one of the most strong people.

0:22:46It effectively goes Tim Cook, Johnny Ive, everybody else.

0:22:50else is senior vice president. So the only, that we know of at this point, the only C-level

0:22:57executive is Johnny Iff.

0:23:00Yeah.

0:23:01Well, so we have what, Tim Cook and then we have the COO as well?

0:23:09Is there a, there's a, you know, do they call that, do they call that person the COO?

0:23:16I have no idea anymore.

0:23:17I'm looking at the executive profile list and I don't see anybody with a chief title

0:23:22other than Tim Cook.

0:23:25Well, there we go.

0:23:27There are now two people that are working underneath Johnny.

0:23:31So if you remember, when Forstor left, they pushed the industrial design and user interface

0:23:40teams together and Johnny was running them both.

0:23:44Now they've split them apart again with Johnny overseeing everything.

0:23:49They now have a vice president of industrial design and a vice president of user interface

0:23:54design which was how, if I'm remembering correctly, kind of how it was before and then Johnny

0:24:00took them both over but now there are officially people that are heading up those two departments

0:24:05with Johnny sitting above them.

0:24:06That's a different structure but it reminds me of how it was before.

0:24:11I'm not sure if it's different. And this is the thing, I don't have any insider information

0:24:17about this, but my gut feeling about this is this is... So one of the things that I

0:24:22learned in my years doing some media company stuff, but anyway, is you get the job and

0:24:31then you get the title a lot of the time. That's just sort of how it works. Putting

0:24:35Jonny Ive in charge of software design means he was doing, I mean, that's when his job

0:24:41changed. That's when his job changed. Because that's too much. Either he didn't change anything

0:24:47at which point he wasn't in charge of it, or, let's be serious, he was in charge of

0:24:50it, which means he was not able to spend the amount of time he was able to spend on other

0:24:54things. I'm sure he had trusted lieutenants. Maybe these two people were the trusted lieutenants

0:24:59at the beginning, Alan Dye and Richard Howarth. Maybe they were not. Maybe they emerged as

0:25:07this went along. I don't know that. But let's just assume they more or less were.

0:25:16This strikes me as being the quantification of that, that this was part of the plan. Now,

0:25:21it may be that this is moving the story forward in the sense that this is also Johnny Ive

0:25:26saying, "Now that we've got this ship running more like we talked about, Tim, I don't want

0:25:33to be a manager who's doing day-to-day stuff because I'm a designer. These guys are my

0:25:42managers."

0:25:43Boy, first off, I can identify with that because I had those same feelings, which is you get

0:25:49to that point where you're like, "I'm not doing the thing that I am good at and that

0:25:52you hired me to do, I'm now doing all of this other stuff. But he's so talented that you

0:25:57don't want to lose him, and you trust him, so how do you structure it? And I feel like

0:26:03my gut feeling again with no inside information, this is Apple outsider territory, me and Matt

0:26:07Drance, we're on the outside. But I view this as being Johnny Ive saying, "I'm in charge

0:26:15because you trust me, Tim, but I don't want to be the day-to-day manager of these giant

0:26:20groups because I'm a designer at heart and I want to follow, you know, Steven Fry called

0:26:25it like blue sky stuff. I don't view it that way. I don't think that he's saying I like

0:26:29to just imagine crazy things that will never be built. I think it's more like I want to

0:26:34get back to the business of focusing on products. So I read this as being Johnny I'm saying,

0:26:39"Look, I have two jobs. I have to be the leader of this giant group and with that I'm going

0:26:43to have a couple of people who I manage who are going to be worried about the nuts and

0:26:48bolts day-to-day and then I'm also going to be an active participant in product design

0:26:53and because that's what I love and that's what you want me doing anyway. So I'm fairly

0:26:57positive about this. It could be that this is corporate speak for the fact that Johnny

0:27:01Ive is getting burned out and wants to spend more time in England and you know or in his

0:27:08mansion in San Francisco and not coming. It could be that but I think it could easily

0:27:13be, and I think a perfectly reasonable scenario that I've seen happen in other places is,

0:27:19this is allowing your super creative, talented guy to not get lost in being the head of two

0:27:28giant groups. So that's my take on it, is that this could easily just be a formalization

0:27:37of how this has already come to be that explains how they're functioning gives these two

0:27:45other guys the authority and visibility to be part of it while Johnny Ive can go back

0:27:51to being, you know, kind of like totem of design at Apple plus work on projects because

0:27:59he's really good at that. And honestly, you know, that makes sense to me because if

0:28:06whatever the next hard super important design project is at Apple,

0:28:10you kinda want Johnny Ive on that, right? You kinda don't want him being like, "Nah,

0:28:13I'm too busy. We got a reorg in the software design group over here." It's like,

0:28:18no, you don't want him doing that. You want him on those projects. So,

0:28:22you know, maybe I'm being a little optimistic here and it's entirely

0:28:27possible that this is just a bad sign that Johnny Ive is leading

0:28:29and we want to get these guys in place so that when he goes,

0:28:32you know, will have people who are visible, but I think it's very easily

0:28:36explained as just being that. That he's a really talented guy,

0:28:39this is too much for him to manage day to day, they feel like the ship is kind of

0:28:44righted from where it was when they made this move,

0:28:46and this way those guys get to be seen as leaders while Johnny Ive gets to be

0:28:50seen as the

0:28:51the guy who does design and also go back to

0:28:55formally to working on the most important design projects that Apple has.

0:29:01So I actually think of it as being a little bit of all of those and kind of in a reverse

0:29:07order to the way that you mentioned them.

0:29:09So I think that probably first and foremost this is succession planning.

0:29:15And that should start in theory 15 years, 20 years before Johnny Ive's going to go.

0:29:21You need to know, because it's like the Steve Jobs conundrum all over again.

0:29:25Like Apple has to know that they have people that can make stuff without Johnny Ive making

0:29:29it.

0:29:30That is a thing that needs to happen and that should start now.

0:29:33It does happen but they need to… they've over messaged Johnny Ive just like they over

0:29:38messaged Steve Jobs and again Steve Jobs was responsible for a lot of that himself. But

0:29:44I think you're right that this is the… we already have a good team here. You risk

0:29:49when one guy has everything invested in him that if he leaves then people are like freaking

0:29:55out. Oh my God, he left. He did everything. And so some of this is sending the message

0:29:59that no no there's very talented teams here that are also working on this stuff.

0:30:04That's a PR thing I think that's right. Yeah and then I think it's like going

0:30:08back from that is like it is so they just take the managerial stuff away

0:30:14because we like to think of Apple as a beautiful incredible place but it is a

0:30:21company big company stuff and as the head of a division he will have been

0:30:27bogged down in HR stuff. Well, and the people who rise to this level are not rising to that

0:30:33level because of their greatness at that stuff. Maybe some of them are great at it. Maybe

0:30:36some of them are good at it. Maybe some of them love it. My old boss at IDG, my last

0:30:41boss at IDG, was a C-level executive. He was the chief content officer for IDG. And he

0:30:48used to be an editor, but he was, he loved being a manager and doing all the political

0:30:52he loved it. And I liked him. I like him. He's a good guy. But he took to it in a way

0:31:00that I just never—I could not imagine doing that job where he just didn't make stuff

0:31:07anymore. His job was to be a manager. So different people react to it differently. I look at

0:31:12Johnny Ive, too, and I say, "Well, first off, he doesn't need to do this," right?

0:31:19than the excitement of changing the world and making great products. He doesn't need

0:31:26the money. He doesn't need the acclaim. The queen has bestowed some accolades on him.

0:31:34He will be honored regardless. So what keeps him at Apple? It's the opportunity to make

0:31:39cool stuff, and it's probably the opportunity to be involved in designing this stuff in

0:31:45detail. So if you're Johnny Ive, I cannot imagine that he wouldn't have a moment where

0:31:50he'd say, and maybe this was when he was given this division in the first place, where

0:31:54he would say to Tim, "Yeah, I'll get the act together, but at some point I want to

0:31:58go back in the design lab, and I'm happy to do it at a high level, but I'm going to

0:32:03need to bring in some managers because I don't want to do that job." I mean, that's just

0:32:07my gut feeling about him, is that he's not the kind of person who just would be happy

0:32:14to give up design altogether and just manage a design group. That doesn't make any sense

0:32:17from anything we know about Jonathan and I.

0:32:21And then my other thought, you know, working back from that, is if you take those responsibilities

0:32:26away from him, he can then spend a bit more time living his life how he wants to live

0:32:31it. Because he will continue doing everything he's doing now minus some stuff. He's not

0:32:38going to do more, right, in theory. Because from the profiles that we've seen about him

0:32:43everything that Stephen Fry talks about is stuff we already knew he was doing.

0:32:47So if you take away the vice president, like the SVP and the EVP stuff from somebody and

0:32:54allow them to do the free thinking, right, that he should want to be doing and/or work

0:33:01on the projects that he wants to work on delegating the rest to his new teams, that is the path

0:33:09to someone who has a job that they really want to do and they really love. Because he

0:33:15has a, in theory, one of the best jobs in the world, in theory. If you are a designer,

0:33:21you want Johnny Ive's job.

0:33:22And he, you know, I don't know Johnny Ive. I would imagine that he loves that part of

0:33:28his job. And if, I think one of the challenges of all of these incredibly talented people

0:33:33who have made a huge amount of money at Apple is how do you get them to stay? You get them

0:33:38to stay because where else in the world will they have the opportunity to have the kind

0:33:42of impact they can have at Apple and because they're doing things they love. And if somebody

0:33:48as a manager, as somebody who used to manage a lot of people, I look at that and say, "Okay,

0:33:53you're really talented and we don't want to lose you. We don't have like leverage on you.

0:33:57You didn't just buy a super expensive house and now have a big mortgage and there's no

0:34:01way you're going to leave your job. You know, you are just, how do I motivate you?" I never

0:34:06really liked it when people congratulated you on buying a house because they knew you

0:34:10wouldn't quit your job by the way because they did that to me. I never liked that. We

0:34:13got you right where we want you, worker. But I look at Jon Yann and it's like, "How do

0:34:21you motivate somebody like that?" Well, you say, "I'll unburden you from some of this

0:34:26stuff. You've got lieutenants. You already can't do it all. You've got lieutenants who

0:34:31are doing this and doing a good job at it and maybe you know those lieutenants hopefully

0:34:36and you're like, "Oh, and those guys love that stuff and are really good at it. So let's

0:34:40take it off your shoulders." I mean, that makes a lot of sense. And that could very

0:34:44well be the whole story here is it's not good for Johnny Ive. It's not good for Apple to

0:34:51have Johnny Ive worried about things that aren't designing products, quite honestly.

0:34:56Designing products or determining the overarching design philosophy at the company. I feel like

0:35:00those are his two jobs and they are bracketed by all of this management junk that he doesn't

0:35:05need to deal with.

0:35:06Yeah, and there's other things that I think about, like,

0:35:10potentially, and I mean, I think this is, there's a good chance that this is the

0:35:16case. Stuff like designing the campus is to keep him interested.

0:35:20I think, yeah.

0:35:21There's no reason in the world that he would be involved in designing

0:35:27the new building, because that's not what he designs.

0:35:30Yeah.

0:35:31but if you are a designer, like, that is an incredible project to work on.

0:35:37- As somebody who has done a slightly smaller project on the new Apple Campus,

0:35:42which is we redid our kitchen.

0:35:43- Slightly.

0:35:47- I will say, if you view the architect and the...this isn't entirely accurate,

0:35:57but if you view the architect and the builders of this as sort of your

0:36:00contractor. The fact is that when you're building something like this, there are a million little

0:36:04decisions that have to be made. And if you're the client, if you're the person who's paying

0:36:11to do the work, they will come to you with those decisions. So who at Apple is going

0:36:15to make those decisions? And I think that's sort of what's going on here too, is like,

0:36:20"Look, Steve's not here anymore to make these decisions. He got the ball rolling here. Johnny

0:36:24probably knows what Steve was thinking. He's got his own thoughts." Maybe if you really

0:36:29want this thing to have the attention to detail that they want to have it. It is an Apple

0:36:32product that they're designing here. Then I feel like maybe that's the role he's in.

0:36:37I don't think he's doing architecture, right? They have a prestigious architecture firm

0:36:41to do that. But I think he and his people may be the ones who are like making those

0:36:45decisions of, you know, for us it was like, "What color do you want the outlets to be?"

0:36:50We can put white outlets here, but the material on your wall here is green, so we could custom

0:36:57order some green outlets, which was the point where my wife and I melted down and were like,

0:37:01"Just put the white outlets in! Ah!" Because there's so many decisions. But that seems

0:37:05to me to be the place where Johnny Ive might be fitting in is, "Oh, we need tables. We

0:37:11need carpet," or whatever, and being like, "All right, what do we want that to be at

0:37:16a high level?" And I know that seems ridiculous because maybe it is not at a high level, but

0:37:21I think you're also right that it keeps him engaged, and it also invests in him the idea

0:37:26that everything Apple does regarding design is his purview. He's setting the tone there.

0:37:31And I think it's also good for Tim Cook because it lets Tim Cook say, "Look, I got this guy.

0:37:35This is my guy. I'm not designing products, but I got the best guy at it. I got Sir Jonathan

0:37:40Ive doing it for us. He's my chief design officer." I think that's good for Tim Cook

0:37:46too.

0:37:47Because you know, they say, it says in the profile that like, he is even designing chairs

0:37:55and stuff like that.

0:37:56Tim Cynova Yeah, yeah, it is a little bit of whatever

0:37:59you want, Johnny, just don't go.

0:38:02Whatever interests you, let's do it.

0:38:06But at the same time, I mean, I do believe that they view that Apple Campus as an Apple

0:38:11product.

0:38:14It's their new home and they want it to be… the last thing you'd want to do is spend

0:38:19all that money and then have it be let down with lots of like, you know, crappy chairs

0:38:24from Ikea.

0:38:27You know, it would be… you want to take it the last mile.

0:38:30I think that is a sign of Apple's design philosophy is you want to take it the last

0:38:34mile.

0:38:35You want to get it all the way there and not have this great idea that then doesn't come

0:38:38through in the final execution.

0:38:40So just to try and save some follow-up, Luca Maestri is the CFO.

0:38:47Oh, Luca.

0:38:49So there isn't a COO, which is interesting to me because Tim was, wasn't he?

0:38:55He was a COO.

0:38:57But Jeff Williams is just an SVP.

0:38:59Oh yeah.

0:39:00Well, Luca is Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer.

0:39:04Chief Financial Officer, yep.

0:39:05But he's the only one looking at that page that has that.

0:39:08there will be three C-level executives. That is so interesting to me that

0:39:14it's just that. Like you think about Phil Schiller and he's not the CMO, right?

0:39:20Well maybe he will be. Maybe he will be but you know it's just so

0:39:24interesting to see. I mean it feels obvious in a company like Apple that you

0:39:30would give someone a title like that because design is what they have. That is

0:39:36is all they have. They are the company that designs things incredibly well, top to bottom,

0:39:41inside and out. That is what they are. So it makes sense that you would create a position

0:39:46like that.

0:39:47And Shiller used to be worldwide product marketing and now he's worldwide marketing, which I

0:39:52think is also kind of interesting. I don't know when that happened. That might have been

0:39:55years ago. But yeah, it's a one step from there to be CMO. I think if you're Phil Shiller

0:40:00also, he might just say, "I don't like that title. I'd rather just be SVP."

0:40:04Maybe. Maybe. This is an interesting thing to me. I think there's a lot of...

0:40:13Titles... It's dripping. It's dripping with subtext. Yeah, titles are not jobs. Titles

0:40:20are not jobs. Titles are... They're statements. They're communication. Titles are communication.

0:40:25You communicate your role and your importance with your title when you're talking to your

0:40:29peers or you're applying for another job. And your company is communicating your importance

0:40:34and visibility within the organization with the title. But titles aren't jobs. Jonathan

0:40:39and I could be, and this is the thing, Phil Schiller's job, if Phil Schiller wanted

0:40:44to be CMO, maybe they'd make him CMO. Maybe he would prefer not to be. But it doesn't

0:40:49change his job. And you can have, again, just to bring my history in here, when I got, let's

0:40:58When Macworld was sucked inside of PC World, my boss Rick LePage was let go because he

0:41:08was the president of Macworld at that point. The guy named Jeff Edmond was put in charge

0:41:13of PC, was in charge of PC World, was now also in charge of Macworld. And I had the

0:41:17conversation where I went up to see upstairs to see Jeff Edmond and he said, "Here's

0:41:22what's happening. Rick is leaving. We're going to take care of him. I'm going to

0:41:26in charge, you know, you're going to sit on my management team." And then he said, "And you're

0:41:30now senior vice president and editorial director of Macworld." And I was like, "Okay." And I got

0:41:37promoted. Why did that happen? Because I didn't do anything. My boss lost his job. And the answer was,

0:41:44they wanted to send a message. They wanted to send a message of importance of Macworld. They wanted

0:41:50wanted to make me feel better, I guess. I'm not sure. I guess it did. I don't know.

0:41:55But it was all about communication. It was about—because it was kind of unbidden. It's

0:41:59not like I went to him and said, "Well, I don't know about this." It's not like

0:42:02it was the annual review process. It was there to communicate some things to me and to the

0:42:09staff and to maybe other observers. And so that's what this is all about. I feel like

0:42:16this is communicating changes that have already happened or changes that need to happen, but

0:42:24the titles themselves kind of, I mean, Johnny Ive's title could be, you know, he could have

0:42:32no title. He could be like, "I prefer to be titleless," and he would be on the executive

0:42:35profile page and there would be nothing. He could do that, right? And that would just

0:42:41be, we would all just accept it. Well, it's quirky designers, whatever. Yeah, so titles

0:42:47are not, titles are about communication with other people and what it, so it's always good

0:42:52to ask the question, what is Apple trying to communicate here? It may or may not be

0:42:56about us. It may be about those people, but it's probably about us. It's probably about

0:43:02everybody observing Apple too and wanting to know what the deal is with, you know, and

0:43:06stop whispers of like, "Well, you know, Johnny isn't doing day to day." They're like, "Yeah,

0:43:10Donnie isn't doing day to day. You know, we already announced that. Gets in front of that

0:43:15change that they want to make.

0:43:17But do you think, I mean, a lot of people speculated that they announced it on a day

0:43:22that the markets were closed because it could potentially have had a bad effect on the market.

0:43:26I mean, any change, right, affects the market, like will affect the market.

0:43:31Sure. Any change involving a member of your staff, sure. Sure. It softens the, yeah, it

0:43:38also softens the rather than being a knee-jerk reaction right of like oh god

0:43:42Jonathan I've what what's happening out fear fear fear instead it's like it

0:43:46trickles out people are like eating a hot dog their barbecue in a hamburger and

0:43:50they're like Oh Jonathan I and they have time to process and there's nothing they

0:43:53can do and it doesn't you know like everything Apple does now as an effect

0:43:58like this it's interesting they did on the Monday though they don't Monday

0:44:02where like plausibly people at Apple who don't observe holidays were back to work

0:44:06instead of doing it Friday evening, which is the traditional bad news time.

0:44:10So what they didn't want to do is send the message that this was bad news,

0:44:13but they still, I think, wanted to mute the response.

0:44:17- Yeah, yeah, that makes sense. But it was interesting news nonetheless, I think.

0:44:23- Yeah.

0:44:23- And I'm interested to see how this plays out. Like, are we going to see more of these other

0:44:28people, you know? How is that going to work? I think that would be interesting to see.

0:44:33- Yeah.

0:44:35I hope that we do. I hope that we do. Yeah, I imagine we'll be seeing those people at

0:44:39WWDC. Yeah, that'd be interesting. Maybe in some videos or something. We'll see.

0:44:45Alright, should we take a break and then talk about some Google stuff?

0:44:48Great idea. Let's go on a skewer. This week's episode

0:44:52is also brought to you by GoToMeeting from Citrix. We've been talking about businesses

0:44:58and corporations and meetings are a thing that happen in businesses and corporations

0:45:03with executives. This is probably the type of thing that Johnny's trying to get rid of.

0:45:07But you know what he could do from England, Jason? He could use GoToMeeting to talk to

0:45:11his team. Because he can be anywhere in the world, anybody can be. And you can connect

0:45:17with your team via GoToMeeting. It is a smarter way to meet. You can meet with your clients

0:45:22and coworkers online with Citrix GoToMeeting. It makes it easy to meet with your team wherever

0:45:28you need to, wherever you are, because you can use any device. You can use a computer,

0:45:32tablet smartphone you don't have to think about travel expenses or travel

0:45:36time you have to worry about the traffic you can just do whatever you want you

0:45:39can be in your front room you can be in your garden and you can meet with

0:45:43whoever you need to you can even be on a different floor of the building and you

0:45:46just don't want to walk up and down the stairs today because you've already

0:45:49filled in your activity ring so you're just gonna sit at your desk and have a

0:45:53go-to meeting with somebody it is that easy you can just join a meeting by

0:45:58clicking a link you don't need to sign up you don't need people to sign up like

0:46:00your clients, no speed bumps, you just turn on your webcam and with HD quality you can

0:46:05be in the room with other people.

0:46:08You can even share screens to present, review and get feedback all in real time.

0:46:13Because with GoToMeeting everyone sees what you're seeing so your team can get on the

0:46:17same page and just get going.

0:46:19I want you to go and sign up for GoToMeeting today, try it free for 30 days with nothing

0:46:23to lose.

0:46:24You can visit GoToMeeting.com and click the try it free button.

0:46:28it now and you'll have your first meeting up and running in minutes. That's go2meeting.com

0:46:33for your free 30 day trial. Thank you so much to Go2Meeting for sponsoring this week's episode.

0:46:43So Jason, it is Google I/O this week. It's Google time. So we have all of that to think

0:46:50about before WWDC, which is, you know, that's that. So Google tends to do this. I don't

0:46:56know if they do it purposefully, but I would if I was them. Just get your news out quickly.

0:47:00Get it out first because if you and Apple are working on a similar thing, at least you

0:47:03can get the news cycle for a few days. Because otherwise, your product launches are just

0:47:08ruined by everybody talking about how it's not Apple's one.

0:47:11It's very--also, you know, Google will have some hardware partner announcements and all

0:47:15that, but they don't necessarily dazzle--have all the tools to dazzle like Apple does because

0:47:20they, you know, they're talking very much about cloud and software and operating systems.

0:47:25and Apple has some hardware to, you know, glint a little bit and people are like, "Ooh,

0:47:31shiny."

0:47:32It's funny, Google I/O is very different. It's shorter than WWDC and the keynote is

0:47:38much longer, traditionally. We'll see if it is this year. But in the past, the Google

0:47:42I/O keynotes have been endless because there seems to be -- I mean, Google is doing a lot

0:47:48of stuff, but there seems to be a reluctance to let parts of Google that don't have anything

0:47:56that merits being on stage, a reluctance to not have them be on stage. So for the last,

0:48:03I think, what was it, two years ago, there was a maps demo at Google I/O keynote that

0:48:07was like, "Hey, maps. You like maps, right? Yay, maps." And goodbye. And that was what

0:48:13just happened. And it was just a waste of our time. So it'll be interesting to see that's

0:48:18one of the ways where Google I/O's keynote differs often from Apple is even though so

0:48:22many companies, including Google and Microsoft, now are like using the Apple playbook in terms

0:48:27of their event structure, they really have been inspired by the kind of classic Steve

0:48:32Jobs event structure, there are still moments where as a close Apple follower you look and

0:48:37you say, "Oh, that's not, you know, they're not doing it the same way." And with Google,

0:48:42I feel like some of it is just the discipline to say you're out of the keynote person who's

0:48:47got a whole fiefdom that, you know, you're really excited about this product, but you're

0:48:51out of the keynote because we're going to keep it to two hours. And so it'll, you know,

0:48:54be three and a half hours or whatever. But there's always really interesting stuff announced

0:48:59at the Google I/O keynote because it is Google's chance to do that thing where they get a big

0:49:04event and the developers are excited and they can sort of set the direction for where they're

0:49:08going with their platforms for the next year.

0:49:11Yeah, I mean, it's interesting to think about them in these kinds of terms now, because

0:49:19they're definitely trying to pump up the showmanship a little bit, right?

0:49:24I think when I/O originally started, it was very much a developer conference, and they

0:49:28still are more heavy on that than Apple, but when you see them come on stage, they are

0:49:35trying to give a bit of lip service to all of the different departments, showing how

0:49:39how much of a corporation they are, but I think they are also now trying to do more

0:49:43to dazzle because they're aware that it's a public event. So that's one of the things

0:49:47that I think makes IO more and more interesting to tune into. Because I do think that Google

0:49:52do some very interesting things, and I actually look forward to this presentation.

0:49:57Yeah, I am always interested to see that you're guaranteed to get some, like I said, some

0:50:02boring things that you wonder why they're there. Some things that are interesting from

0:50:08an impact standpoint where they will talk about something new that's coming in the next

0:50:12version of Android and you'll say, you know, "Oh, that's interesting." Although, I feel

0:50:16like with Android and iOS, we've left the period of, "Oh my God, they added 80 new features

0:50:23that totally we need and that we've been clamoring for." And, you know, it's much more sort of

0:50:27the steady development of it. And the fact that Google has changed their version numbering

0:50:32to reduce the gap, perceived gaps between this year's model and last year's model because

0:50:38they got tired of getting beat up over, you know, it doesn't even run Android 4. So they're

0:50:43like, "Fine, we will just do 4.1, 4.2, 4.3 and we'll call them all Android 4 and, you

0:50:48know, if you want to cite it more specifically, you'll look like a jerk. So, ha-ha, we win."

0:50:53I mean, that's actually a Google strategy. So, you know, that stuff will come through

0:50:59and be interesting. Although, I'd say mildly interesting, there'll be those moments where

0:51:04you'll be like, "Oh, that's a thing that Apple does." And there'll be other moments where

0:51:07you're like, "Oh, Apple doesn't do that," because those inevitably happen. And then

0:51:11there will be some announcements that we're not really expecting where we will all be

0:51:15like, "Whoa, what just happened? That's crazy." And all of those things are guaranteed for

0:51:20a Google I/O keynote. I'm really interested to see the intersection of Android and Chrome

0:51:25OS because I feel like, you know, Google's pattern lately seems to be you do lots of

0:51:32crazy stuff and then at some point you evaluate the crazy stuff and you start to decide what

0:51:36works and what doesn't and you kind of bring it together into a strategy. And I feel like

0:51:41Android with Android and Chrome OS, we've got this strange kind of question about what

0:51:46is Chrome OS for? What is Android for? Do they do they connect? Why do you have these

0:51:50different operating systems? You've got a computer operating system without apps and

0:51:56then you've got a mobile operating system with apps and they've talked about bringing

0:52:01them together and I wonder if that I'd like to see their their current thinking on that

0:52:05like how close do they come together? Does Chrome OS combine with Android and

0:52:10just sort of have an Android computer experience versus an Android tablet and

0:52:15phone experience? I don't know but I'm interested to see so much of it with all

0:52:19these keynotes is reading the tea leaves of like what are they thinking?

0:52:22Not even so much the specific announcements as much as that what those

0:52:26announcements tell us some things about their philosophy.

0:52:28I mean I do every Apple keynote is like that too which is like what what does

0:52:32Apple think of the Mac?

0:52:33One of the ways we find that out is what they say about what they're doing on the Mac versus

0:52:37what they're doing on iOS.

0:52:38And Google, this is a good way to get that read out of Google.

0:52:41And sometimes you can't, Google, it's harder to read it from their product announcements

0:52:45because they make lots of crazy product announcements and it's hard to judge whether they're meaningful

0:52:50or just another crazy project that they thought they would try.

0:52:54Yeah.

0:52:56So do you have any kind of feeling for what you think might come out?

0:53:01I mean, I know we were talking about this a little bit on Clockwise last week.

0:53:04Yeah.

0:53:05I mean, I've kind of got my eye on something TV related, you know, more on Google TV.

0:53:12I do like the idea and I am also very interested in seeing about where Chrome and Android begin

0:53:20to overlap, you know, if at all.

0:53:22Yeah, yeah.

0:53:23And they've kind of gone both directions with that.

0:53:27so it'll be it seems like right now they're coalescing a little bit more but will that

0:53:32continue or will they say no no we rethought forget it forget about that that could that

0:53:37could entirely happen the TV stuff is really interesting and and I would say beyond that

0:53:41also home automation stuff they've got they've got nest and when they bought drop cam they

0:53:47put them inside nest so I wonder if nest is officially Google's like incubator for all

0:53:52home tech and will there be a nest segment and will they talk about what they're doing

0:53:56with Nest and is that confused with what Google is doing or is Google going to

0:54:00say no all of our home automation stuff is here it's part of this nest thing

0:54:05we're going to call it whatever we're going to call it because I think that's

0:54:07one of Google's weaknesses is sometimes you get confused about you know well

0:54:11what's your initiative is it this one that's over here or this one that's way

0:54:14over here so some clarity on what nest is doing and what their ecosystem is for

0:54:22home automation I think would be good and the TV stuff related to that sort of

0:54:26you know you get Chromecast you've got app platforms Google TV Android TV you

0:54:33know all these different things

0:54:34what's the next step there you know they're going to build their own box are

0:54:38they going to have like a partner that's demoing a box that's going to come out

0:54:41what what's their take on it is voice control the big thing for them you know

0:54:46or is it something else I just it'll be interesting to see because sometimes

0:54:52it's unclear, like I said, from the signal. Like, "Hey, a product, what does that tell

0:54:56us?" And with Google, it's hard to tell sometimes.

0:54:59It is interesting when you look at some of their products and realize how much they compete

0:55:03with themselves. And I wonder if that's something that is a little bit inbuilt in their corporate

0:55:10culture. Like, you know, you mentioned a couple, right? So if you think, like, for years, Android

0:55:16didn't have Chrome, it had a different web browser, which is called Browser. Like, you

0:55:20you think you're Google TV and you've got Chromecast,

0:55:23like in theory that should be one product,

0:55:25you know, like how Apple have AirPlay.

0:55:27And I know that Chromecast is more,

0:55:29but it should be one product.

0:55:30There should not be two products here.

0:55:33Like it is very interesting to see

0:55:35how some of that stuff works.

0:55:36And I agree, like if they do something home automation

0:55:39and it's not all under the Nest umbrella,

0:55:41that'll be madness.

0:55:42Like pick something, just pick one thing,

0:55:46give it all one name and get people to work together

0:55:49rather than working in their own silos, which it seems to be there is a little bit too much

0:55:53of that going on at Google. At least that's how it appears to be from the outside.

0:55:57I think Google culturally the biggest difference between Apple and Google is probably the idea

0:56:02that Google has these different groups that are doing different things. There is no, you

0:56:09know, it's let a thousand flowers bloom kind of thing. Like we will have crazy stuff happening

0:56:15over here and over there. It's completely I would say I'd say the history of Google

0:56:19is it's become more disciplined over time. It was originally completely undisciplined

0:56:25in terms of you know what's our corporate strategy was a lot of brilliant engineers

0:56:31making things up and trying things out and then we'll figure out what to do with them

0:56:34later and and that that is still culturally part of Google and if they if they completely

0:56:38lock that down I feel like they wouldn't be Google but at the same time sometimes you

0:56:44look at Google and you get frustrated and you say, "Can you guys act like grown-ups

0:56:48for a minute?" I don't want to clamp off all of your creativity because one of the things

0:56:55that makes you an interesting company is that you do crazy stuff and try to see where it

0:56:59leads you. Good for you. The world doesn't need everybody to behave like Apple and be

0:57:03completely locked down. So that's great. But there are those moments where you're like,

0:57:08"God, will you guys just settle on something to do on TVs? Will you guys settle on what

0:57:12you want to do in home automation? Will you settle on your operating system strategy?

0:57:16Please, right? And that's the give and take, I think, of managing Google. And when Eric

0:57:24Schmidt stepped aside and Larry came back into a more active role, I feel like that

0:57:32was sort of what was implied was, "We're going to try to lock this down a little bit

0:57:37more and I'm gonna try to be a little more Steve Jobs like and give us a little more

0:57:43focus and a little more discipline here. And I'm not sure, I mean Google is such a huge

0:57:48company and they have so many projects that I think adding more of that to the equation

0:57:51is good for them because it frustrates the market, it frustrates their partners, but

0:57:56at the same time I wouldn't want them to be so locked down that they became another

0:57:59Apple because it's good to have Google be the wacky, you know, the place where wacky

0:58:03ideas come from because some of those wacky ideas are going to be great and I'd hate to

0:58:07stifle them.

0:58:08Should we talk about Google a little bit about how we feel about them and use them?

0:58:14Yeah, I mean, when we were talking about previewing a Google I/O and I guess I should say that

0:58:19we're going to delay clockwise this week as well from its usual Wednesday slot and we're

0:58:23going to do it after the Google I/O keynote and we're going to have a couple of smart

0:58:28people who know a lot about Google stuff, especially Android, Andy Anako and Angé Tomich

0:58:36are going to be our guests. So it will be a little later than usual but we're going

0:58:39to do it after the Google I/O keynote. But every time we talk about Google on shows that

0:58:43are populated by people who focus so much on Apple, you know, you definitely get feedback

0:58:47of like, "Oh, Google, I hate them. They're the enemy." Just like with Microsoft in the

0:58:50old days, right? "Oh, they're bad. They're the enemy. Why would you, you know, they're

0:58:55just gathering all our information and you know all those arguments and I find it funny

0:59:01and I put it in our document that we used to plan the show our Google doc if you will

0:59:09because that's where it is that I use Google stuff all the time and I think you do too

0:59:13and I find out I actually Derek Walter wrote a piece who's a freelancer who actually writes

0:59:19for IDG's Android site, Greenbot, among other places, about how he's actually an Android

0:59:25user who's going back to the iPhone because he loves Google's apps on the iPhone, and

0:59:31that gives him the best of both, which is he gets the iOS ecosystem plus he gets to

0:59:36use Google's services. And, you know, I use a lot of Google services too, and I don't

0:59:42have a problem, I don't feel like it's an either/or, but I think it's interesting that

0:59:47For some people it really is, like, you know, Google is the enemy, you can't use anything

0:59:51involving Google, and I am firmly in Google's ecosystem as a Mac and iOS user.

1:00:01I am across, and I think you are too, right?

1:00:03>> Yup, I both use and love Gmail.

1:00:09We use the Google Apps and personal Gmail.

1:00:13I use Google Maps, even though I've been using the Apple Maps more recently because of the

1:00:20Apple Watch directions.

1:00:21But I'm just excited for whenever Google have a good app, but that might be like 2.0 if

1:00:28they really want to make it something that's worthwhile, because I don't think they could

1:00:31do too much of WatchKit.

1:00:34So I've been using the Apple Maps more even though I prefer Google Maps.

1:00:39I use Google Docs.

1:00:40I love Google Docs.

1:00:42a lot of our business is run using Drive.

1:00:44- Yeah. - It's actually,

1:00:45you know, I'm a big fan, I'm just a big fan of it.

1:00:48And I have this feeling about how I am with Google products

1:00:53and I think it's something that people need to consider

1:00:56how they feel either way.

1:00:58Like, I am a firm believer that I get genuine use

1:01:02from Google stuff, right?

1:01:05The products that I use I find very useful

1:01:08and I've tried competitors, you know,

1:01:10because I'm a nerd and I try stuff out.

1:01:12and the competitors of Gmail, Maps, and Docs,

1:01:15in my opinion, are inferior.

1:01:16- I agree.

1:01:17- I've tried so much other stuff--

1:01:19- They're better than they used to be.

1:01:20It used to be no competition at all,

1:01:23but now there's competition.

1:01:25- Some.

1:01:26- The iOS, have you used the iOS apps,

1:01:29especially on the iPad, the Google iOS apps for Docs sheets?

1:01:32And I mean, I don't do slides, but they're really good.

1:01:36- They have some employables that really annoy me,

1:01:38but they're good.

1:01:40I use them all the time, actually.

1:01:41That's one of the things like, you know,

1:01:44gone back and forth trying to use iCloud, right?

1:01:48And I know people are gonna come and say,

1:01:50"iCloud on the web is so good."

1:01:51Yes, but there is one massive, massive,

1:01:54fundamental problem with trying to collaborate

1:01:57with people using iCloud.

1:02:00Try and do it on iOS.

1:02:01Just try, 'cause you can't.

1:02:02Can't do it.

1:02:03It's not possible for Jason, you to share with me

1:02:06a document and me make changes to that document

1:02:09on iOS that you will see.

1:02:11All I can do is download the document and make changes and they're offline.

1:02:16I cannot.

1:02:17I just don't understand.

1:02:18It drives me insane.

1:02:20Well, you know, the Microsoft apps are very good on iOS, but it's the same story that

1:02:27you can edit a document and save it back, but it is not -- and go back into your OneDrive

1:02:37and other people can see that there are changes, but it's not the same.

1:02:40It is not that sort of completely seamless experience that you get with what Google is

1:02:47doing.

1:02:48So, obviously, I also use Google Search, right?

1:02:51I feel like I always miss that one off, but yes, of course I use Google Search.

1:02:55So I feel like I really enjoy using the products and I get a lot of use out of them.

1:03:01So I personally am happy for Google to take my data and create ads that they'll serve

1:03:07back to me.

1:03:08I know that's the trade-off, and I'm happy with that.

1:03:12I feel like you just need to think about it.

1:03:15Like, yeah, they're doing all this stuff,

1:03:16and people think that they're like big evil,

1:03:18and they're like creeping on you,

1:03:20and they're gonna try and ruin your life.

1:03:23People feel that way, genuinely.

1:03:25And if you feel that way, that's fine.

1:03:27But I get a lot of use out of Google's products,

1:03:31so I'm happy with that trade-off.

1:03:33Like, that's fine for me.

1:03:35Like, I don't care.

1:03:37I would be happy to pay and that's just not in their business model, but I mean it is

1:03:44in some places, but I would be happy to pay and I don't love the fact that it's just all

1:03:49free and we want your data, but I'm kind of okay with that tradeoff like you are because

1:03:55I feel like they've got the best products.

1:03:58Like the best products and I don't feel like what they're asking in the exchange is so

1:04:02so compromised that I can't pay that price because it's a fairly painless thing right

1:04:06now. And I realize there are lots of arguments to be made here about, "Well, that's how they

1:04:10get you and they're driving other people out of the market that would be better." This

1:04:15is all true and yet, you know, boy, those products, the products are good. And I don't

1:04:20use them because they're free. I use them because they're good.

1:04:23Yeah, they are just the best.

1:04:27Like, I'm not one of the people that would rip a thermostat off a wall because Google

1:04:33like, you know?

1:04:36And it's a joke, but like when Nest were bought by Google, there were people that were saying,

1:04:41"I'm taking it down."

1:04:42Like, what do you think they're going to do to you?

1:04:44Like, they're not evil.

1:04:45They're just a company that makes money by selling ads.

1:04:48I don't understand why people are so terrified of them

1:04:52and I can't wait for the email that I'm gonna get.

1:04:55But I just don't understand it.

1:04:57If you don't like that,

1:04:58if you don't like them looking at your data

1:05:01and selling you ads, that's fine.

1:05:03But what are you scared of?

1:05:06That I don't understand.

1:05:08The fear of they must be an evil company.

1:05:11They do things that are not good.

1:05:14And Google have been caught up

1:05:15and they've been dragged through the courts.

1:05:17That is true.

1:05:18They've done stuff like they were doing this weird thing with Wi-Fi by using Google Street

1:05:24View or something.

1:05:25There are loads of things they do that aren't good.

1:05:26But you know who also does really terrible things?

1:05:28Apple do really terrible things.

1:05:30They do things that they get dragged through the Supreme Court of Justice for because they

1:05:35price fix on e-books.

1:05:36That is not good stuff.

1:05:38Steven: Supreme Court of Justice is not a thing, but okay.

1:05:41That's fine.

1:05:42You're not an American yet.

1:05:43So we haven't forcibly moved you to our shores.

1:05:46So I'll let you have it.

1:05:48Do you understand what I'm saying?

1:05:50All big companies do bad things.

1:05:53And it doesn't necessarily prove that they're intentionally malicious.

1:05:58Yes, Apple has done some interesting things.

1:06:03Google has done some interesting things.

1:06:04I think we can quibble about some of Google's stuff.

1:06:09They're not saints.

1:06:10You're right.

1:06:11Apple's not a bunch of saints either.

1:06:14the end, yeah, for me, I mean, every consumer has the right, you absolutely have the right

1:06:17to not like them and not want to use them, but I think, you know, the flip side of that

1:06:21is that we have the right to use the products if we like them, and I do like them, and I

1:06:24just have not gotten caught up. But you know what? I, our friend John Syracuse, I won't

1:06:28buy an Xbox because it's made by Microsoft. He just won't because it's Microsoft. He won't

1:06:33do it. And I get that on one level, but on the other level, I'm like, you know, I just

1:06:38don't, I just don't care enough about that. I just don't get caught up in that because

1:06:43I think it is what you said, which is, you could demonize them, but I hate to say, "Let

1:06:53he who is without sin cast the first stone," but it's like, these are big corporations.

1:06:59Apple may be better than Google, but they're not without sin. There are probably other

1:07:05products that you use from companies that you don't like, but you use them because you

1:07:08like them, but you can afford to get away with not using Google's products or not using

1:07:12Microsoft products, that's fine. I just have never gotten that. It's like, I'm not, no,

1:07:16I'm not going to buy any blood diamonds, okay? I'm not going to do that. But for something

1:07:21like Google stuff, it's like, I think it's good. It doesn't creep me out when I use it.

1:07:27You know, it feels like the best in class. And so, you know, and that is why I'm using

1:07:34it. It's not because it's free, but because it's good, like I said. So I'm not going to

1:07:38tear my nest off the wall. And I do have a nest. The reason I would tear my nest off

1:07:41the wall is if there's a war over home automation between Google and Apple, and it means that

1:07:47like my Nest stuff just can never integrate with my other stuff in my home. That's the

1:07:52part that actually really does bother me about the Apple-Google relationship is that they're

1:07:57fighting for turf, and I feel like consumers, including me, are going to be potentially

1:08:01hurt by that. I don't want to live in a world where you have to think about what your long-term

1:08:07smartphone platform preferences before you buy a light bulb. And we've had home automation

1:08:14in the show notes for weeks now. It's our new Kindle of the topic we never get to, maybe

1:08:18next week. We'll just keep saying that forever. But that was one of the points I wanted to

1:08:24make there and I can make it briefly here, which is when you get these format wars, the

1:08:31consumers all get hurt. And I'm really concerned that we're headed that way with some of this

1:08:35home automation stuff. Now, fortunately, Google is not like Apple in the sense that Google

1:08:40is happy to put its stuff on Apple's platforms, and Apple has no reason to do the reverse

1:08:44for lots of good reasons. You know, they sell hardware. They're in a different business

1:08:51than Google, so I understand that. But that doesn't mean Google stuff is operable on iOS,

1:08:54and that's great. But still, the point is, you shouldn't have to buy a car or a light

1:09:00bulb or a thermostat thinking, "Well, does this commit me to using one, you know, using

1:09:06an iPhone or the reverse which is I can't buy that light bulb because I use an iPhone?"

1:09:10That's crazy, but I worry that that may be where we're going with some of this stuff.

1:09:14So that's when I would get angry at Google and Apple is if they start erecting barriers

1:09:20like that. That's where my interest in Google services and my reason why I might rip the

1:09:26nest off of my wall, it would be stuff like that. Where if they're like, "Oh yeah, thanks

1:09:31for buying a nest, but we decided that it's just not going to work with any of your other

1:09:36stuff." That would be where it would get me, and it would be some sort of spiteful cooperation

1:09:43competition thing between Google and Apple.

1:09:46Tim Cynova Yep. "Oh man, I'm worried about the email

1:09:49I'm going to get. I got on my high horse. It's one of the things I get on my high horse

1:09:53about."

1:09:54you are way up there on that horse. Who's on the pillar in Trafalgar Square? Is that

1:10:01Nelson?

1:10:02Jason: Nelson's column.

1:10:03Tim Cynova Is he on a horse? Or not? He's just standing

1:10:07there. He should get a horse. All right, that would be a high horse is what I'm saying.

1:10:10Jason: Yeah, it would be. But yeah, I don't know.

1:10:13Tim Cynova No, no, I want to hear.

1:10:14Jason

1:10:14something that frustrates me. I want to hear from people, I mean, look, if you don't, I'm

1:10:18not saying please deluge us with email, but if you would like to make points about why

1:10:21you don't use Google services or why you do and don't think it's a problem, I would love

1:10:25to hear those because I think there are perfectly good arguments. What I would say is don't

1:10:30try to prove that we shouldn't because I'm not interested in that. I'm not interested

1:10:34in you telling me why what I'm doing is wrong. I'm interested in why it's wrong for you.

1:10:41the distinction I would make there. But I am in, I think there are lots of valid reasons

1:10:45why people would be like, "Yeah, I'm not going to use Google stuff or Microsoft stuff

1:10:49or whoever stuff because X." And I think that would be interesting because I think

1:10:53there are probably some very interesting reasons why people don't or do use services by,

1:10:58you know, if you're an Apple person and you're using Google stuff, why or why not

1:11:03if you're not. I think that's perfectly good there. But yeah, don't get mad at Myke.

1:11:09I'd like to hear other perspectives, but all, you know, it's a personal choice about

1:11:14whether you're okay with it or not. And I'm okay with it because, like I said, because

1:11:19their products are good. That's the bottom line for me. I hate to say it. I mean, again,

1:11:22I'm not going to use blood diamonds, but the products are good and they work for me.

1:11:27And I don't feel like I'm giving up. I'm happy to spend money. I am spending $100 a

1:11:32on Adobe Creative Cloud Photoshop and I'm spending $100 a year on Office 365. But, and

1:11:39I would do that for Google stuff, but I don't have to because that's not their business

1:11:43model and their stuff is good so I'm still using it.

1:11:45David: I know that we pay for Google Apps Email for Relay.

1:11:48Tim Cynova Oh, good.

1:11:49David; We pay for that.

1:11:50Tim Cynova Right, that's like $5 per user per month or

1:11:52something like that.

1:11:53David; Yeah, something like that. Yeah, we pay for that.

1:11:55Tim Cynova Yeah, see?

1:11:56David; They do have stuff and we pay for it.

1:11:58Tim Cynova They do. I don't pay for that but that's

1:12:00because I'm grandfathered because I had a Google Apps account before they started charging

1:12:03for it. But that's the only reason that I'm not paying for it is that I don't have to.

1:12:08They said, "You don't have to pay. It's fine." But otherwise, I would.

1:12:11- Talking about email, should we get onto AskUpgrade and that means our friends at MailRoute.

1:12:17- Let's do it. Oh, yes. Yes, our friends at MailRoute have sponsored AskUpgrade against

1:12:22this week. We love MailRoute. Speaking of mail, so I do use Google Apps for domains.

1:12:27But before my mail comes to me, it's already passed through MailRoute, and MailRoute has

1:12:32taken out all the bad stuff. Before it even gets to Google, the bad stuff is gone. It's

1:12:37in a holding bin. It can stink up the holding bin all it likes, but I don't have to see

1:12:42it. And it does do a better job than Google spam filters. When I've turned MailRoute

1:12:47off, I'm like, "What is happening?" Because Google spam filters don't catch the stuff

1:12:50that MailRoute catches. This is how MailRoute works. You sign up. It's a risk-free trial,

1:12:56credit card necessary. You change your MX records, which are the things that tell mail

1:13:01servers where to send mail for a particular domain. You point those at mail route instead

1:13:05of your mail server. And that's it. Your mailbox and your hardware are completely protected.

1:13:11All the mail goes to mail route first. Mail route uses its intelligence software to sort

1:13:15through your mail and say, "That's good. That's bad. That's good. That's bad." They

1:13:18see a lot of spam. They see a lot of viruses. They see a lot of email bounces. They know

1:13:22how to detect it. That stuff gets put in a holding bin. You can get an email every day

1:13:27or every week that says, "Here's what we filtered out." You can check it if you want

1:13:30to see if there's something that you did want to receive. And with one click, you can have

1:13:35delivered or even whitelist the sender so that all their mail forevermore will be passed

1:13:40through to you and not go through the filters, which is really great. So you set that all

1:13:45up and that's it. You don't have to install any hardware or software. You don't have to

1:13:49put anything on your email server that's doing auto-filtering. MailRoute does all that for

1:13:53you, and then it connects to your server, passes all the good mail through. It's easy

1:13:58to set up, reliable, trusted by large institutions like universities and corporations. If you're

1:14:03a desktop user, you'll find the interface simple and effective, like I do. And if you

1:14:08are an email administrator or IT professional, we've said it before, they've got all the

1:14:11buzzwords, they've got all the tools you need. There's an API so you can do account management,

1:14:16support for all of that stuff. LDAP, Active Directory, TLS, mailbagging.

1:14:21Mailbagging?

1:14:22Mailbagging. Outbound relay, everything that you'd want from the people who are handling

1:14:26your email and the good stuff gets passed along to your server. So, like I said, risk-free

1:14:31trial, no credit card required. It's simple, effective, there's no good reason not to try

1:14:36it. All listers to upgrade get 10% off for the lifetime of your account. Not for six

1:14:42months, not for three months, not for seven days. 10% off for a lifetime, but you have

1:14:46to go to mailroute.net/upgrade. Now that's mailroute.net/upgrade and thank you to MailRoute

1:14:53for sponsoring. #AskUpgrade.

1:14:58So we have some Ask Upgrade for you. For both of us. This comes from Dave first. How much

1:15:05do Bluetooth headphones affect the Apple Watch battery? Jason, have you tried this yet? I

1:15:11haven't.

1:15:12I don't even have any Bluetooth headphones. I do have, I bought some Bluetooth headphones. I have used them briefly with the Apple Watch.

1:15:17I don't know. I imagine that they have some effect.

1:15:22I don't know if that was why Apple, you know,

1:15:25we had a whole bunch of people say, "Well, Apple, the battery lasts so long

1:15:29because it's gonna,

1:15:29it's gonna reduce battery life over time," which is true. Maybe it's something like

1:15:33Bluetooth headphones, that's true. I haven't,

1:15:35I haven't done a battery test, like, while listening to a playlist

1:15:38on Bluetooth headphones, how long does the Apple Watch last?

1:15:41I'm sure it has an effect because everything does, but I don't know the details of it.

1:15:46I bought the Bluetooth headphones specifically because I wanted to try them with the Apple

1:15:50Watch and I have tried them, but when I've gone running, I generally like to bring my

1:15:54phone with me because then I get the GPS tracking and I like to listen to podcasts and really

1:15:59the right now music playback is kind of what it's built for when you've just got the watch,

1:16:04so I need to test it more.

1:16:07As an aside, what I found is that I love the Bluetooth headphones when I'm doing stuff

1:16:10in the kitchen because I would always get my wired headphones would get yanked out of

1:16:15my ears because they would snag on a knob on one of the drawers and now I use the Bluetooth

1:16:21headphones when I'm doing stuff like cooking something or emptying the dishwasher and it's

1:16:26there great. So I'm glad I bought them but I haven't spent enough time with them on the

1:16:32watch.

1:16:34And now we have from Danny. Have you noticed any digital crown stickiness in your day-to-day?

1:16:41Danny notices it after workouts mainly on the sport edition.

1:16:45I haven't. Have you?

1:16:48Not at all.

1:16:50Nothing.

1:16:50No, I mean I saw, what was it, was it David's Park?

1:16:52Somebody said that they had they had gotten it where it started to feel gritty and the the

1:16:56stated instructions are basically run it under warm water and spin it and it'll like wash out.

1:17:01It seems horrific.

1:17:01But you know, it's covered.

1:17:04Like, you know, people won't believe me

1:17:05that you can take a shower with the Apple Watch,

1:17:07but it's in the Apple Watch manual

1:17:11to run the crown under warm water

1:17:14and spin the dial around and just get the junk out.

1:17:16So do that.

1:17:17- Ah.

1:17:18I did notice something, and I wanted to mention this

1:17:23because we're talking about Digital Crown,

1:17:25where my mind was kind of twisted a little bit

1:17:28a couple of days ago.

1:17:30You know when you do things with the digital crown, like for example, if you zoom out really

1:17:34far on the app screen and let go, it like pings back into focus, right?

1:17:39So you're like scrolling, scrolling, and then the apps fly back at you.

1:17:43For some reason, my brain assumed that the crown spanned back.

1:17:48Oh, interesting.

1:17:50That's a little mind hack they're doing on you.

1:17:53Yeah.

1:17:54But it doesn't.

1:17:55Like the same with like, no, it doesn't.

1:17:56Software can't control the crown.

1:17:57The crown is entirely physical.

1:17:59And the same with the rubber banding.

1:18:02For some reason, in my mind,

1:18:04it felt like, as it probably should,

1:18:08that the crown was having a manipulation over the software

1:18:12and that the software was manipulating the crown.

1:18:14And it was just this very interesting thought.

1:18:16I was like, "Hang on a minute, that doesn't move."

1:18:18- No.

1:18:19- And it was just very interesting to me to see that

1:18:22and like, "Okay, you did something very smart here

1:18:25"because you found a way."

1:18:27Because when I'm looking at it,

1:18:29and I'm spinning it, it doesn't, but again, it feels to me like there's resistance

1:18:34of some description that increases. That is not the case. But that's how I feel, and

1:18:39I find that very interesting.

1:18:41Tim Cynova I think also the way they expect that if you

1:18:45zoom out, then you're going to let go, that you're not going to hold on to the crown.

1:18:50And so the way after a certain amount of time, you're going to let go. And so the way it

1:18:55is you scroll it back and if you then hold your finger there and on the crown you have

1:19:00to wait like half a second and then it snaps back. So the illusion is broken but that's

1:19:06what they're intending is they think most people aren't going to do that they're going

1:19:09to scroll back and then they're going to let go and then the snapback effect makes you

1:19:12feel like the metaphor is still intact but if you hold on to it which I have to be honest

1:19:17I've never done. That totally does happen. It's funny. That's the power. It's just like

1:19:25with the haptic stuff on a force touch trackpad. You don't even realize that you're buying

1:19:34into the metaphor until something happens that breaks the metaphor. And the crown, that's

1:19:40a good example where there are certain cases. I think the rubber band on scrolling is a

1:19:46good a more likely example right but even there what they try to do is just

1:19:50stop it so you keep pushing the crown and it just doesn't scroll and then you

1:19:53let go and it rubber bands but in reality it's not that you letting go

1:19:57it's you stopping the scroll and if you hold on to the crown the the magic is

1:20:02broken a little bit cool very cool mind control so this comes from Doc Elliot on

1:20:09Twitter do you use Mac macro software and if so what do you use why don't you

1:20:15answer this one Myke? So I have used Keyboard Maestro in the past to make

1:20:20like a really rudimentary soundboard like it was madness pressing a different

1:20:24function key played off the sound that was coming through it was this crazy

1:20:29setup I had of a mixer and I did it for that but and I also use I don't know if

1:20:33it counts I use Hazel to basically to file photos for me this is like a thing

1:20:40that Federico came up with in Dropbox I'll put a link in the show notes so like

1:20:43Dropbox automatically uploads pictures from my iPhone, they go into a camera uploads folder,

1:20:49Hazel takes them, puts them into folders by month and date, like month and year, it's

1:20:54very cool. And I also use it to do some stuff like a Skype call recorder that I use to record

1:21:01the shows or to make backups of the shows. It keeps a history of all the calls and I

1:21:09I have it dump those out after a couple of months when they're a couple of months old.

1:21:12That's all I use, kind of macro-automation-y-wise. Do you use anything different?

1:21:18Yeah, I have grand plans of using more of this stuff and I just haven't. And so maybe,

1:21:27again, I'll make some grand plans, maybe I will sometime. I would say the things that

1:21:30I use that are most like this are LaunchBar, which has some ways to kick off scripts and

1:21:38it has some various actions that it will do. I'm not sure it counts but I'm gonna

1:21:42throw it in there. And then I'm actually, I have to say, I'm using Automator to do

1:21:49some stuff mostly because I know people, and I think I might have mentioned this in a

1:21:54previous show, I know people who are programmers. We know people who are

1:21:58programmers and oftentimes they come up with these very clever, very clever

1:22:04solutions to problems that involve shell scripting or terminal commands because

1:22:08that's where they live and that's how they think. And I look at those and think,

1:22:12"Okay, I understand these terminal commands. I would rather not type them

1:22:15every time." And so what I'll end up doing is writing is building an automator

1:22:20service, which is something that you can basically get with a keyboard shortcut

1:22:25or a contextual menu, and I will wrap the terminal command in that or I

1:22:32will wrap it in an Apple script that generates the terminal command and then fires it off.

1:22:37And I have a bunch of those. I have one for a thing that Dr. Drang wrote that's about

1:22:41Southwest Airlines, uh, uh, iCal files that they send you for your confirmation, fixing

1:22:48them so that they're better and adding them to your calendar. And then Marco Arment wrote

1:22:53a script about MP3 encoding for podcasts that I adapted. And there's another command line

1:22:59thing that Marco did and I built that into a service. And so all of those I can now when

1:23:05I'm building a podcast I can select a couple of files and do a keyboard shortcut and it

1:23:10turns them into from MP3s or AACs into WAVs because I need to use those for editing and

1:23:16then I've got a couple of other keyboard shortcuts or submenus based on a control click. So you

1:23:24know that's what I'm doing. I wouldn't say Automator is really a macro utility but those

1:23:29are the automation things that I'm doing right now. I keep telling myself to use keyboard

1:23:33maestro and text expander and I have most of these things.

1:23:37I use text expander, of course, yeah, I use text expander.

1:23:39I have it, I don't use it very much and I don't know why. I just, it's, and I've got

1:23:43a bunch of clippings in BB edit and I don't use those either. So I realized the other

1:23:47day that I have a keyboard shortcut that if I've got a URL on my clipboard and I select

1:23:52text in BB edit, I do a keyboard shortcut and it makes the markdown link structure for

1:23:56me and I never use it. I just type them out manually. I think there's, I've just got a

1:24:00block there. So I'm recommitting now. I will try in the next few weeks to look at some

1:24:06of my workflow and identify the places where I could, I think I could save time and make

1:24:10my life better. But right now, I've got access to all this stuff and yet I'm not really using

1:24:14it.

1:24:15It really does blow my mind that you don't use TextExpander. Like that is just one of

1:24:19those ones where I'm like, "You're a writer!"

1:24:22out there is going to be mad because they sent me an email saying stop talking about

1:24:27it but I'll just say again I type really fast and that means that I feel less needed, less

1:24:33of a need to use TextExpander because I type really fast. I'll just type it. And I realize

1:24:40that's kind of insane and yet there it is. I keep trying to think of phrases that I use

1:24:46over and over again that I could just put into an expansion and I just I can't come

1:24:50up with them and then I move on. I use TextExpander all the time for live blogging. When we were

1:24:58doing live blogging, especially in a text document, I used it all the time because it

1:25:02was really great in that scenario because you just type a couple of letters and things

1:25:06would happen. You were typing really fast and furiously so that was good. But in my

1:25:11day-to-day kind of writing life, I have a hard time imagining things that would require

1:25:16that kind of thing. And like I said, I think that my perception is that I wouldn't save

1:25:20quite as much time because I could just type it. I don't know. It's great and I have a couple things in there but it's just, you know, like

1:25:29Keyboard Maestro, I've been writing about that for ages and, you know, I just have never, it's just never happened. So maybe someday.

1:25:39Adrian wants to know how do you use overcast playlists?

1:25:45So for me I have an all unplayed list

1:25:48right so it has everything that's unplayed and I have some priority podcasts in there

1:25:52so

1:25:53they basically come to the top right so I have a few shows in there that I want

1:25:57to be at the top so I know when they're there so they don't get lost in the shuffle

1:26:00because I have lots and lots of stuff I don't listen to everything that's in my

1:26:03all unfinished some stuff just gets deleted you know pick and choose some shows

1:26:07I have a classics playlist for some episodes of old shows that I love and want to keep

1:26:13in case the mood ever strikes and I want to listen to them.

1:26:17That includes certain episodes and just certain shows in general, right?

1:26:20Like "You Look Nice Today" used to be in there, but it seems like things might be changing

1:26:25there.

1:26:26I don't know what's happening, but it's very exciting.

1:26:27I also have playlists for shows that I enjoy that I have a back catalogue that I want to

1:26:32work through.

1:26:33So I put them in there as well, which is quite cool.

1:26:36I have one playlist. It's called The Playlist.

1:26:40The Playlist?

1:26:42The Playlist in honor of the magazine and other things named by Marco. It is The Playlist

1:26:48and it has, there's some priority ones that are, you know, because you can set a priority.

1:26:53So I've got some that are prioritized and then the rest of them are all just in there.

1:26:56So I have a single playlist and I will slide things up and down and I've got stuff in there

1:27:00that I've been meaning to listen to. I think about creating, like, for The Flop House.

1:27:06I've got a bunch of old episodes of The Flop House downloaded because I haven't listened

1:27:10to all of them yet. I'm very slowly going through the ones that I never heard because

1:27:15I don't want to, you know, it's going to be sad when I've run out. But right now, I've

1:27:19got extra episodes of The Flop House. I've thought about creating a classics playlist

1:27:23like that. The problem is that just so often, I want to say, "Well, this podcast has 10

1:27:29minutes left, what do I want to have come next? And I'll order them like that. And

1:27:32I want there to be some of those classic episodes hovering down there for either when I'm

1:27:37in the mood or when I'm out of the stuff that I really want to listen to. And I want

1:27:43to move on to the classic thing because I've run out. And if I have them in different

1:27:46–

1:27:47David: You can have them in two places though.

1:27:48Craig; I guess. I suppose.

1:27:49David; Which I do.

1:27:50Craig; I suppose.

1:27:51David; Like for example, I have a Flop House playlist for the same reason. But they still

1:27:54live in the all unfinished as well in case I'm flying around to see something. But

1:27:58I just want to see flophouse shows, they just go there.

1:28:01- Yeah, yeah, well, I'll explore that,

1:28:02but right now, a single playlist, but it works for me.

1:28:05It works, that's why I use Overcast,

1:28:07is not only do I think the sound effects are better

1:28:10than any other podcast player I've listened to

1:28:13in terms of being able to listen at more than 1.0 speed,

1:28:18which I was never able to do on other podcast apps

1:28:20because of the weird artifacts, and they're not there,

1:28:24but also the way the playlist is set up works for me.

1:28:28So that's why I use Overcast.

1:28:30- Troy wants to know what is the best way

1:28:35to keep the Apple Watch from lighting up

1:28:38at the movie theater?

1:28:40Turn it off.

1:28:41- I guess.

1:28:44Or put it in the battery mode or something.

1:28:47Yeah, if you're, first off,

1:28:49almost everything on the Apple Watch

1:28:50is a black background with a little bit of stuff on it.

1:28:55So I think you could probably have a face

1:28:57that was like the extra large or modular with red as the color and no complications just

1:29:05the time, you could probably switch to that face when you're in the movie theater and

1:29:09nobody would notice if your watch came on. It's only going to come on when you move your

1:29:14wrist. It's not going to come on when you get a notification. So I'm sure you can minimize

1:29:19it but yeah, if you absolutely don't want it coming on, I would say you put it in the

1:29:24battery-saver mode and then reboot it when you leave the theater or you wear

1:29:28something with sleeves and you just make sure that it's under the sleeve. I think

1:29:33that's it. But try to the red because you know the red wavelengths don't don't

1:29:37broadcast so much and it's the black background on the OLED screen so it's

1:29:41gonna be emitting very little light if you do it that way so that might be a

1:29:45thing. You can set any number of different presets for watch faces even

1:29:49of the same face with different settings so create a movie theater preset maybe.

1:29:54I guess do not disturb is your friend I suppose.

1:29:58Yeah sure.

1:29:59To stop it from lighting up when it's not bothering you but yeah if it's not lighting up I don't know what you'd do.

1:30:04I think the issue is just if you know you move your wrist a little bit and it turns on because it thinks it's you know wrist raised but you're actually just hiding covering your eyes because it's a horror movie and you're afraid of what's going to happen next that would be annoying.

1:30:15I think it's very bright though.

1:30:17It's not. Having been to a couple movies since I got it, I've not found it to be an issue at all.

1:30:23Make sure your brightness is down. There you go. That's one tip.

1:30:26Just go into the watch app on your phone. Turn your brightness all the way down. That's going

1:30:32to help a lot. And finally today, Thomas wants to know which grocery apps would you recommend

1:30:38for the iPhone and watch has to be able to sync between two people. So I have a suggestion that

1:30:44that doesn't fulfill everything in this list. So I have an app that I use, it's

1:30:48not necessarily a grocery list app, but it's a shared, it's a

1:30:54list app that allows you to do shared lists. It's called Silo and it's only on

1:31:00the iPhone, they don't have a watch app so I can't help you with that part. I

1:31:04don't know if there are any, I'm sure there are but I've not come across any,

1:31:08but Silo is the best joint list app that I've tried and I tried a bunch and me

1:31:13my girlfriend has some shared lists in there but they don't yet have a watch component.

1:31:19They do have an iPad app.

1:31:21All right. I have, yeah, again, I don't, I haven't done shopping lists on the Apple Watch

1:31:25either. My wife and I are still using Grocery IQ which is not great but it works. It syncs

1:31:32shopping lists between us and lets you scan in barcodes and is attached to a database

1:31:37of various products at the market. I keep meaning to do a final like official test of

1:31:44our groceries, which I had recommended to me, but I haven't tried it enough to move

1:31:50us over to it so I can't endorse it yet. And then also I had Anylist recommended to me,

1:31:57which is another grocery list app that has a little bit of meal planning on top of it,

1:32:03which I'm not sure works with how we shop,

1:32:05but I'm looking into that, too.

1:32:07So I'd say stay tuned.

1:32:09Still using Grocery IQ because it works,

1:32:13but not 100% satisfied with it and looking around.

1:32:17It would be cool.

1:32:19My wife does most of the shopping, though,

1:32:21and she doesn't have an Apple Watch,

1:32:22so it would be less of a big deal for her.

1:32:24I think that, you know, taking out the iPhone

1:32:25and using it as a shopping list, though, that is a thing we do.

1:32:28We absolutely do that.

1:32:30-I do use Clear when I'm in the grocery store,

1:32:32but you know you then kind of have to move things around that it doesn't work too well but

1:32:36Yeah, hey, huh

1:32:38All of those will be in the show notes along of a bunch of other stuff that we've spoken about today

1:32:42And you can find all of that over at relay.fm/upgrade/38

1:32:46If you want to find us online there's a couple of ways you can do that

1:32:49You can find Jason's great work over at sixcolors.com and he is @jsnell on Twitter J S N E double L

1:32:56I am @imike and don't forget you can ask questions

1:33:00but also send us follow up if you like through the #AskUpgrade. We love to see your stuff

1:33:06there. But you know if you want to send us tweets or if you really want to send us an

1:33:11email you can find out all that information out on our show notes page as well. Did you

1:33:15see how I waited that? If you really want to send us email, you can. You know, go for

1:33:22it. Go for it if you like.

1:33:23Steve McLaughlin You can also see our show notes probably by scrolling in the podcast

1:33:26app you're listening to right now.

1:33:28Most definitely, but you do not see an email link there.

1:33:30You do have to go to the website to find that, so you can do that if you so desire.

1:33:34But we'll be back next time.

1:33:36Sure, we'll have some Google stuff to talk about and maybe have some predictions as well

1:33:40for WWDC.

1:33:41To an end, thanks so much for tuning into this week's episode of Upgrade.

1:33:46Thanks again to our sponsors this week, MailRoute, GoToMeeting and Hover, and we'll be back

1:33:50next time.

1:33:51Say goodbye, Jason Snow.

1:33:52Goodbye, Myke Hurley.

1:33:53I'm Myke Hurley.

1:33:54[MUSIC PLAYING]

1:33:57[ Music ]