Podcast Search

The Accidental Tech Podcast

196: Roasting Your Own Beans

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00anything we talked you don't talk

0:00:01politics for a while oh my god John

0:00:05siracusa tell me about your 4k display

0:00:07or displays if you please

0:00:09yeah this is not really related to the

0:00:12mac pro and apples getting out of this

0:00:14play business and all that business but

0:00:17it's strangely connected so I've got the

0:00:19got a ps4 pro now and one of the

0:00:22features of the ps4 pro is that it

0:00:24theoretically supports 4k four games

0:00:27four games that are updated to support

0:00:28in that actually do support it and I

0:00:32figure since i am keeping my all ps4 and

0:00:35they have a game are with it as well I

0:00:37needed a new monitor for the new one

0:00:39because neither one of these is gonna be

0:00:41hooked up to my TV for display burn-in

0:00:43reasons so when I was going to get new

0:00:46monitor think I get a 4k one because hey

0:00:48this the playstation 4 pro is supposed

0:00:50to be all you know for Campbell so

0:00:51that's what i should do it so I shopped

0:00:53around for 4k monitor that support HDR

0:00:55which is another feature of the ps4 pro

0:00:58actually maybe they packed back part of

0:00:59that to the beautiful psy remember

0:01:01anyway apparently it's impossible to

0:01:03find an HDR capable 4k computer monitor

0:01:07you can find TVs obviously but I wasn't

0:01:09looking for TV and and/or and also the

0:01:12size inflation of tvs that happened

0:01:15maybe three years ago four years ago

0:01:17where any decent TV is now I get at

0:01:20least 55 inches you I'm fearing the day

0:01:23that someday you won't be able to get

0:01:24one less than 65 inches like the minimum

0:01:26size for a decent TV is gonna have to

0:01:28move you get you can buy yourself

0:01:30can I get a 27 inch 4k TV with HDR the

0:01:34answer is no no you can't you want a

0:01:3655-inch got one of those for you anyway

0:01:39no HDR but he didn't get 4k so I shopped

0:01:42around a little bit i hate doing this

0:01:44cuz I don't like a million different

0:01:46products and then the in the non-apple

0:01:48world so much selection is overwhelming

0:01:50ended up getting a viewsonic great

0:01:55programs XG 2704 k display which is

0:02:01really nice especially like the the

0:02:03stand it came with his like

0:02:05height-adjustable was very sturdy get

0:02:07the water itself is a little chunky and

0:02:08a little bit gamer looking like

0:02:10jessica is black with like a red stripe

0:02:12and he's silly my wasn't word this is

0:02:14not only expensive but your whining

0:02:18about the LG display and the way that

0:02:21looks and this has freakin red trim on

0:02:23it are you serious John Syracuse's the

0:02:26racing stripes that make it go faster

0:02:27man this is not my mac obviously with

0:02:29playstation 4 have you seen with the

0:02:31playstation 4 itself looks like this is

0:02:33hitting don't care this is truly

0:02:35terrible call it the LG ultra fine is it

0:02:38is not a pretty monitor I'm not trying

0:02:40to say it's pretty but it's positively

0:02:42understated compared to this atrocity

0:02:44and does not that I mean if you look at

0:02:46it it's basically just completely black

0:02:48around the display and all you can see

0:02:49when you're sitting in front of it is

0:02:50the two little red side things

0:02:52understand and you can't even see the

0:02:55red stripe on the vertical thing because

0:02:57it gets covered up i have a monitor

0:02:59anyway that's what I got all and it was

0:03:01alright all of these pc gaming monitors

0:03:04have been like on screen you know

0:03:07adjustments on the device itself that

0:03:10had nothing to do with things connected

0:03:11to it so on the device itself you can

0:03:12adjust like brightness and contrast but

0:03:14also a million other settings some of

0:03:17which are strange through every way you

0:03:19can imagine to be like the worst

0:03:21on-screen controls you know you know

0:03:22what they put the grainy sort of

0:03:24bitmapped little menu thing and only

0:03:26have like a the viewsonic has like a

0:03:28one-in-two button like the one brings up

0:03:29the menu the two goes into it and

0:03:31there's up and down arrows so bad it's

0:03:34terrible interfaces it's kinda like

0:03:36going back in time to like when

0:03:37televisions first got on screen displays

0:03:40OSD they call them on-screen display

0:03:42which doesn't really mean that stands

0:03:45for on screens but anyway I believe

0:03:46that's right it doesn't make it on where

0:03:48else with the display be on screen

0:03:50display and this is very i'm still

0:03:53looking this monitor i mean like i

0:03:54should point out like I like many

0:03:58tastefully designed pc monitors I like

0:04:01viewsonic and you so i have owned

0:04:03multiple viewsonic monitors they are

0:04:05really good usually I like red even read

0:04:09is one of my favorite colors for things

0:04:11to be in even though Trump ruined

0:04:12red-hats forever but I look at this

0:04:14monitor and i cannot even imagine buying

0:04:17this thing and having this on my desk I

0:04:18could not agree more you should look at

0:04:20just look at the monitor part of it like

0:04:21that the stand but just the

0:04:23monitor from the front it is literally a

0:04:24matte black rectangle with the word you

0:04:26sonic on the bottom like that's pretty

0:04:28much as plain as you can get

0:04:30well if but you you will know that I and

0:04:32if you're not seeing the red stripe on

0:04:33the back your monitor is probably too

0:04:35low

0:04:36well i mean i guess you can see a little

0:04:37tiny bit of it but you don't notice it

0:04:39and then like the stand among stands you

0:04:42don't know how how deep this thing goes

0:04:44go look at some of the stands of other

0:04:45pc and gaming monitor just do do me a

0:04:48favor do me a favor get get up get her

0:04:49face arm and have that hold this up and

0:04:51today I know I'm getting to that

0:04:53I'm getting to the beasts are ok I'll

0:04:55get that is it visa right visa at all

0:04:58these lives

0:04:58I'm gonna save ISA and it's definitely a

0:05:00move file and you mispronounced

0:05:01everything so I don't understand how you

0:05:04besmirch the the 5k monitor as an

0:05:08atrocity that you would never be able to

0:05:10use ever and then you buy this piece of

0:05:13garbage

0:05:14how do you think do you think I would

0:05:15never take this to my Mac what

0:05:18difference does it make oh it makes a

0:05:19difference i would never connect this

0:05:21time academia to be on the same desk is

0:05:23my mac i love you have lower standards

0:05:24for the other like the pc but maybe we

0:05:27won't show you before and not only

0:05:29before i do i don't i don't disagree but

0:05:31you really have no choice like you have

0:05:33to happen

0:05:34I understand me but you have no choice

0:05:36if there is no like nice tasteful pc

0:05:39hardware for the most part even even

0:05:42things like the HP spectre are really

0:05:44you know I see they're putting in an

0:05:46effort but it's not

0:05:47not to my taste anyway let me continue

0:05:49my story here so i got this thing and

0:05:52the adjustments on over are very strange

0:05:54i'm trying to get it sort of calibrated

0:05:56to something reasonable but they have

0:05:57all sorts of settings most of which fly

0:06:01in the face of my television snob

0:06:04sensibilities because the television you

0:06:06want to adjust like you trying that

0:06:08there is a goal there is like you can

0:06:10get reference images and say it should

0:06:11look like this you know because it

0:06:12television content is produced with the

0:06:16expectation that here is the color range

0:06:17of your display here is the the the

0:06:20brightness Behavior all sorts of other

0:06:21things like that whereas for a gaming

0:06:24monitor specifically games are not

0:06:27produced with any sort of reference

0:06:29viewing environment right because there

0:06:33is no real standard for that

0:06:35things are produced I don't know how

0:06:36they decide like how dr. the textures be

0:06:39and you know what color range we use I'd

0:06:42I really don't know what they use but i

0:06:43can tell you that everybody's pc

0:06:46monitors are not calibrated like

0:06:48quote-unquote correctly and are all over

0:06:49the map and there is a setting that

0:06:51seems to be pervasive on all pc monitor

0:06:53especially with the game bet they call

0:06:54black stabilization have you ever even

0:06:57heard of that know what why why is black

0:07:00changing yeah so in games a lot of games

0:07:05are made where they will be dark

0:07:06sections were you like in a cave or

0:07:08something but if you're playing a game

0:07:10especially a competitive game you don't

0:07:11actually want to quote unquote

0:07:14faithfully reproduced the blacks because

0:07:15you won't be able to see anything is it

0:07:18is an advantage for you instead to have

0:07:20the monitor so that kind of i'm assuming

0:07:21assuming it's like squashing everything

0:07:23down psycho i can see the subtle

0:07:25difference between a hundred percent

0:07:26black and ninety-nine percent black

0:07:28ninety-eight percent black and this cave

0:07:30is important for me to see that so i can

0:07:32pick out the edges of the cave walls

0:07:34find where the enemies are whatever like

0:07:36it

0:07:37have you ever seen anyone do that

0:07:38competitive first-person shooters in pc

0:07:40gaming they're not trying to get visual

0:07:42fidelity as if it's a movie or

0:07:45television show what they're trying to

0:07:46do is can I see everything clearly

0:07:49so a lot of the monitors have settings

0:07:50that make the picture worse like by

0:07:53reducing the the dynamic range and

0:07:57making areas that would be black less

0:07:59black which looks looks bad it's like a

0:08:01bad black level in your TV and also all

0:08:04the settings that are involved like

0:08:05response time because that's the big

0:08:06thing you a lot of gamers use TN panels

0:08:08which nobody uses anymore because they

0:08:10look terrible the viewing angles are

0:08:11terrible but they have better response

0:08:14time I've never gone that far i couldn't

0:08:16get a tee and display because that's

0:08:17like that means like going back to the

0:08:19macbook air like no I mean you aren't an

0:08:21animal right

0:08:22so again I got an IPS display which does

0:08:24it has a 25 times response time but even

0:08:26on these displays a way you can change

0:08:28the response time to be as good as it

0:08:31can be doing what I assume is

0:08:33sacrificing sacrificing visual quality

0:08:35I'm trying to strike the right balance

0:08:36between don't look terrible monitor but

0:08:40also i do feel there's a benefit to not

0:08:42having everything be black when i'm

0:08:44doing the raid and one of the raids in

0:08:45destiny

0:08:46a lot of dark areas and I'm doing some

0:08:48jumping puzzle in the dark

0:08:50try to do something i like you know I do

0:08:52have it adjusted quote-unquote wrong so

0:08:54i can so the games play better

0:08:57um so anyway I had a lot of trouble

0:08:59trying to get the viewsonic set up that

0:09:00way but the real problem was that for a

0:09:02while my playstation 4 pro did not show

0:09:05me a 4k output option that would just

0:09:07output 1080p I'm like well that's not

0:09:08what i want to i need you to output for

0:09:10k so i did a bunch of googling the

0:09:13PlayStation says you know count-out

0:09:15porque and it would say hdcp 2.2 not

0:09:18available

0:09:19I don't know if you guys are familiar

0:09:20with hdcp but it's another one of those

0:09:22stupid things that make you mine Morris

0:09:23for no good reason

0:09:24m and this monitor probably predates

0:09:26hdcp 2.2 only sports like I figure with

0:09:29the earlier standard is maybe 1.1 thru

0:09:311.4 I don't know

0:09:33anyway I had had a quote-unquote hdmi

0:09:352.0 cable and everything it was good but

0:09:38it didn't work with it and did some

0:09:39googling you find people asking

0:09:40viewsonic on Twitter hey does this

0:09:41monitor support hdcp 2.2 they sorry no

0:09:44oh my god only have to return this thing

0:09:46get over monitor now it turns out you

0:09:51can get it two games to display 4k on

0:09:53this it has a bunch of hdmi ports on the

0:09:55back and like so many televisions and

0:09:57monitors before only one of the ports is

0:09:59like the good one

0:10:00so once i move the cable to the good

0:10:02part the one and only good part which

0:10:04isn't labeled with anything that says

0:10:05hey this is the only one that does hdmi

0:10:082.0 hey this is the only one that this

0:10:104k but turns out there's only one that

0:10:11does it

0:10:12so I could display games in 4k on this

0:10:14but I still wanted to get into the

0:10:16monitor because this one still doesn't

0:10:17support HD people to point to which

0:10:19probably isn't a factor of playing games

0:10:21but it doesn't mean like Netflix and

0:10:22other stuff like that they want to

0:10:23display video content won't do it on 4k

0:10:25because it doesn't do the stupid

0:10:27intellectual property copy-protection

0:10:30dance just the right way for stupid

0:10:33reasons so I return this one and grand

0:10:36Marco fashion although this is just

0:10:39plain all my fault of like I didn't I

0:10:41didn't even think to look for hdcp 2.2

0:10:42Mike actually a gaming monitor this is

0:10:44one of those has hdmi input i should be

0:10:47good to go but and by the way I don't

0:10:48usually return things usually i sell

0:10:50them I thought about selling this is

0:10:52because like the stupid restocking fee

0:10:54on this was going to be a lot of money

0:10:55online well i can sell it for more than

0:10:57the restocking fee then there's

0:10:59restocking fee i'll return for sure

0:11:00it's just an issue of like I don't want

0:11:02to like like I feel bad returning things

0:11:04when I know someone else is gonna be

0:11:05even the cost but if I'm definitely

0:11:07eating the cost then i won't feel bad

0:11:09about that anymore

0:11:10yeah I was okay if i sold it to someone

0:11:12else like a brand new monitor that it

0:11:14like barely even touched the pic the

0:11:15little plastic films were stolen

0:11:16thinking of the PLA plastic stuff that

0:11:18protects yeah that was the one that's a

0:11:20brand-new you but if I could have sold

0:11:22it for somebody for like maybe eighty

0:11:24dollars less than i paid for it then I

0:11:27still want to come out ahead anyway so I

0:11:30returned that one and in its place

0:11:32I got done and LG 4k display I don't

0:11:36have an LG 5k display I now have an LG

0:11:394k display doesn't have that weird

0:11:41little head with the camera in it it is

0:11:43not a fivehead take a look at it

0:11:46hey what model is it the ridiculous i

0:11:49just put the blanket ronson it is not a

0:11:51fivehead it is more tame looking well

0:11:55there's no edge there is it's just it's

0:11:58just it's very thin but that it's you

0:12:00know so you notice this one is smaller

0:12:02overall it comes in a very small boxes

0:12:04case he noted the frame around it is

0:12:06very small the panel is probably the

0:12:09same panel that's in like every LG 27

0:12:11inch 4k display that you can get right

0:12:13now because they sell a whole bunch of

0:12:14them with different letter suffixes on

0:12:16them the little stand that it's on is

0:12:19where the view sidekicks it's but

0:12:20because the viewsonic stand was big

0:12:23chunky height-adjustable and red and

0:12:26stable right and this monitor if you

0:12:29take your finger and put it into the

0:12:30corner and tap upwards the monitor

0:12:32baubles this little bobble head like

0:12:33it's one of those little hula dolls you

0:12:35put on dashboard or bobblehead figures

0:12:37right it is the worst design standard

0:12:40just connect with two screws that you're

0:12:41screwing yourself to this little tight

0:12:43you know thing in the back of it

0:12:45terrible stand its ugly too i think that

0:12:47little semicircle thing is ugly

0:12:49it takes up more room on your desk with

0:12:50wise and then that square thing that the

0:12:52viewsonic know there's no red stripe but

0:12:54it doesn't perform adequately the

0:12:57function of keeping the monitor still so

0:12:58if I bump my desk with my neon playing I

0:13:01gotta watch stupid bobblehead bobble in

0:13:02front of me now it does have a vesa

0:13:04mount on the back and so I said all

0:13:06right well whatever who cares about that

0:13:07stand it's got you know

0:13:08the hundred millimeter recent on the

0:13:10back of the thing all i have to do is

0:13:12find a sturdy vesa mount get rid of that

0:13:15stupid foot and it used that but I don't

0:13:18want an arm is that I want to clamp it

0:13:20to my desk because I've glass on top of

0:13:22my desk and I want to clamp onto my desk

0:13:24isn't that you know and I just don't

0:13:26want armed too much stuff going on back

0:13:28there just want to stand and every

0:13:30single visa stand i could find was

0:13:32uglier than this foot

0:13:33yeah you're not gonna not gonna have a

0:13:35good time there they're terrible like

0:13:37the metal ones look like giant metal

0:13:39horseshoes the plastic ones look just as

0:13:42bad as this so I'm just gonna I'm just

0:13:45you know not hitting my desk and being

0:13:48careful and by the way the on-screen

0:13:50controls those ones are better than the

0:13:51viewsonic but still pretty grim this one

0:13:52has a tiny little joystick under the

0:13:54middle that you move around

0:13:56it's like kind of like a 5-way switch

0:13:57you know you got up down left right and

0:13:58press in but what boy what a terrible

0:14:01interface and because it's the bottom

0:14:03and you're wiggling a joystick

0:14:05that'sthat's like pointing down but

0:14:06you're trying to move controls on the

0:14:08screen that are going you know a

0:14:10different plane up down left and right

0:14:11and anyway i think this one looks a

0:14:14little bit better the view sonics panel

0:14:17quality wise or maybe it's just that I'm

0:14:20having had more time to tweak it because

0:14:22the adjustments are not so painful to

0:14:23use in the menu but has all the same

0:14:25crap including your response time

0:14:27adjustment in which the value that you

0:14:29want is high i don't want high response

0:14:32time and but yet because of the way they

0:14:34named these features and probably the

0:14:35decor translation of the options i have

0:14:37to look at the manual and say which one

0:14:38do I want for the thing with the

0:14:40response time numbers a lower number of

0:14:42milliseconds so high that makes sense

0:14:44why would you ever want to be slower i

0:14:46was i think it decreases uh you know the

0:14:49the quality of the display decreases the

0:14:50added something i'm assuming the color

0:14:52quality or something like it it's doing

0:14:54less processing on the display and

0:14:55probably you know it's it's trying to

0:14:58not put as much computation between the

0:15:01signal and the screen

0:15:03same thing with is like a sharpness

0:15:04thing that apply a sharpness filter and

0:15:06especially when playing games in 1080

0:15:08like destiny is still just 1080 sharpen

0:15:11filter does help make the text look

0:15:12better but it adds processing overhead

0:15:14so if you really want the best response

0:15:15time i'm assuming that the best option

0:15:17is to turn the sharpest all the way down

0:15:19which is what I've done anyway i was

0:15:20able to adjust this to get a look

0:15:22little bit better to my eyes then the

0:15:23viewsonic and now i'm just patiently

0:15:25waiting for 4k games to come up so i do

0:15:29not have this exact same honor I was

0:15:30mistaken for a couple different reasons

0:15:321i i'm pretty sure two different models

0:15:34so you got the ud 68 hyphen p

0:15:39I got the ud 58 hyphen be and that's the

0:15:43key bozell on mine is considerably

0:15:46larger than the bozell on yours also you

0:15:50chose poorly

0:15:51if this is ever going to get connected

0:15:53to a computer if you're if you're ever

0:15:55going to connect to computer 4k is not

0:15:57enough DPI for 27 inches

0:16:00you should have gotten 5k yeah i'm not

0:16:02american gangster computer computer

0:16:04connected to my gaming pc well you could

0:16:06connected to your piece of garbage mac

0:16:09in theory and then actually have a

0:16:10random act no I would this also is never

0:16:13going to be connected to a mac i love

0:16:15that all this trouble you're going

0:16:17through I mean this is all like this

0:16:19crazy stuff you're going through and

0:16:21having this whole separate desk setup

0:16:23that of course this one going to your

0:16:24mac and everything and having this pc

0:16:26monitor all this and yet you won't build

0:16:29a gaming pc like you're basically doing

0:16:31equally you're putting in all the effort

0:16:33that it would take to have a game no CA

0:16:35the PlayStation is way less effort than

0:16:37a gaming pc way less than all I mean

0:16:40once you get into all this crazy monitor

0:16:42twiddling you're doing I mean really

0:16:44like you might like why is there not a

0:16:46gaming pc on this second second to your

0:16:49desk that you have the game bc would not

0:16:51do it there's no destiny for pc yellow

0:16:53destiny to maybe coming to pc fans

0:16:55anyway there's no destiny for bc us

0:16:57guardian for pc there's no uncharted 4

0:17:00BC that like I need to have this this is

0:17:03the thing that I need their gaming pc

0:17:05does not replace this in any possible

0:17:06especially since the only thing I do

0:17:08with my console players play like a

0:17:09handful of games that are essentially

0:17:11console exclusives even on my nintendo

0:17:13consoles there's no gaming pc is going

0:17:15to play an XL the game right that's what

0:17:17i buy these things for so i would have

0:17:19to have a gaming pc in addition to this

0:17:21and there's no report and it's way more

0:17:23headache honest you know I didn't mind

0:17:25the 4k think i was excited to get a 4k

0:17:27monitor and play games that resolution i

0:17:29do a few games that have

0:17:30that had updates that came out which

0:17:32really just makes things a little bit

0:17:33sharper because i like they redid all

0:17:34the textures for the most part I think

0:17:36over watches for can now I haven't

0:17:38looked at yet but anyway there's a bunch

0:17:40of games there and having been a the

0:17:43playstation vr yet but i'm considering

0:17:45getting that but now i'm i'm pretty

0:17:47happy with the setup

0:17:48oh my mom about the ps4 probe the only

0:17:51complaint I have about it and I realize

0:17:52you probably just complain to sony and

0:17:55get this fixed the one controller that

0:17:58the ps4 pro came with the left analog

0:18:00stick if you look at it like from the

0:18:02side is tilted in the neutral position

0:18:04ever so slightly and then I'm gonna have

0:18:06any of that so i'm using my old i'm

0:18:10using my old girl shocked because they

0:18:12didn't change the controller anything

0:18:13has changed like the buttons are now

0:18:15like ugly gray instead of a black and

0:18:17thick maybe triggers might be a little

0:18:18bit better anyway I'm gonna complain to

0:18:20Sony's look at this thing out of the box

0:18:22I've never touched it

0:18:23the in the in the neutral position all

0:18:25these analog sticks should be straight

0:18:26up and down this one is tilted to give

0:18:28me a new thing I'm sure Sony will be

0:18:31happy to do that for me

0:18:33oh I'm sure on the one side John I truly

0:18:37genuinely admire how perceptive you are

0:18:41and how you can notice these little

0:18:43things

0:18:43oh you would notice it's not like oh

0:18:45this is obscured only notice that

0:18:47they're like a out of level or a plumb

0:18:49bob you've noticed with your eyeballs it

0:18:50is not not subtle but with that said I

0:18:54am so glad that i am at worst mildly

0:18:58critical and hypercritical pqr this

0:19:03little conversation i'm sitting here

0:19:04thinking thank God

0:19:06this is one area I don't really care

0:19:08about like I don't care about gaming

0:19:10really at all i'd like to but i don't i

0:19:12barely care about tvs i barely care

0:19:16about TV adjustments in picture quality

0:19:18judgments and everything I am just I I

0:19:20certainly don't care about analog sticks

0:19:22being slightly tilted from neutral i am

0:19:25just so happy that I'd like there's so

0:19:27many areas that I care way too much

0:19:29about at least here's one that I don't

0:19:32yep i'm not i'm not carving my own

0:19:35analog sticks out of plastic that be the

0:19:37equivalent of you roasting your own

0:19:38beans a person remains is really not

0:19:40that hard and it's really good i know

0:19:42but like it

0:19:44it is one thing to be picky about the

0:19:46things that you buy but at a certain

0:19:47point you said there's nothing I can buy

0:19:48I must I must make it myself and that

0:19:50would be going to be carving my own

0:19:52controllers and I got a controller

0:19:53assembly kit and like making my own

0:19:55analog sticks in like assembling

0:19:56different pieces you try to find good

0:19:58coffee on this half of the county i

0:20:00guarantee you can't find it

0:20:01there's no good control is either but I

0:20:03just accept what they only ones i just

0:20:05wanted to be like you know correct as a

0:20:08when it comes out-of-the-box everything

0:20:10should be straight if you could make

0:20:11your imperfect controller for five

0:20:12dollars in 20 minutes when you do it it

0:20:14and then i have to drink it and it's

0:20:15gone i gotta do it all over again and

0:20:17the analogy is breaking down all right

0:20:19so anyway um this this monitor that you

0:20:22bought John is not HDR is that correct

0:20:25now it's not it's not one of the because

0:20:27that's why you bought that god-awful red

0:20:29racing stripe to be Sonic was to get are

0:20:32none of them are no you can't get as

0:20:33performers are there there are none for

0:20:35sale there is no there is no gaming

0:20:37monitor like that you can get a TV with

0:20:39HD are you get a 4k TV with hdmi port

0:20:41for ps4 pro but as far as I was able to

0:20:43determine there is no monitor computer

0:20:46monitor that you can buy as in the thing

0:20:48that's 27 inches not 55 you put a desk

0:20:51as a CR support this episode is brought

0:20:55to you by Squarespace start building

0:20:57your website today at squarespace.com

0:20:58enter offer code ATP at checkout to get

0:21:02ten percent off

0:21:03Squarespace sites look amazingly look

0:21:06professionally designed regardless of

0:21:08your skill level and you don't have to

0:21:09code although if you want to you can

0:21:11jump in there and edit the code you can

0:21:13do things like inject JavaScript or

0:21:15inject your own CSS move around the

0:21:17blocks to customize your theme but if

0:21:19you don't want to you don't have to you

0:21:21can drag and drop things if you want to

0:21:22you can just change colors and stuff or

0:21:24you can change nothing

0:21:25it's totally up to you with squarespace

0:21:27with their intuitive easy-to-use tools

0:21:29for building websites it is such a huge

0:21:32difference from the way we used to build

0:21:34websites it is so much easier today with

0:21:37squarespace you've got to check it out

0:21:38if you're making this site for yourself

0:21:40or even better if you're making a site

0:21:42for somebody else if you don Squarespace

0:21:44they support it

0:21:46you don't have to be involved it's

0:21:48amazing

0:21:49so if you're making up for somebody else

0:21:51or if you just want to save time

0:21:52yourself which is usually the right move

0:21:54because you know what

0:21:55these days the worst use of your time is

0:21:58updating a website CMS you need to

0:22:00outsource that to squarespace whether

0:22:02you're making the site for yourself or

0:22:03somebody else let them handle that

0:22:05so you couldn't do your project you can

0:22:07do you can show your photos you can make

0:22:09your store you can make your portfolio

0:22:11you can make a blog website for your

0:22:13business or anything else you can do

0:22:15everything you need to do with

0:22:17squarespace so check out today to

0:22:19squarespace com start free trial when

0:22:22you decide to sign up but you probably

0:22:23will because amazing use offer code ATP

0:22:26to get ten percent off your purchase

0:22:28things like the squarespace for

0:22:30sponsoring our show

0:22:31ah can you guys see the difference

0:22:37between wide color and not because maybe

0:22:40I've just never really had a good

0:22:43example photo and like two screens next

0:22:46to each other but briefly before I gave

0:22:48up my success when I have but I did have

0:22:51my seven i held the two of them

0:22:53side-by-side and damned if I could tell

0:22:54the difference not office in my eyes are

0:22:56crappy which they unequivocally are if I

0:22:58just don't appreciate it which is

0:22:59possible or it did is it just not that

0:23:03big a deal if you're not like a designer

0:23:05like Marco for example do you are you

0:23:07able to tell the difference when you

0:23:08just look at arbitrary photo on a wide

0:23:12color display vs a not white color

0:23:14display not yet i suspect as wide color

0:23:19displays become what I'm looking at

0:23:20every day is like right now I do most of

0:23:22my computing on a 2014 5 k iMac which

0:23:25does not have the the high color display

0:23:27and so I now have it on my phone and my

0:23:30ipad but really i'm doing almost all of

0:23:32my you know looking at things on my imac

0:23:36but it's not it's not doesn't matter

0:23:37where you look at them it's the source

0:23:39material so Casey if you have something

0:23:41you look at if you look the same picture

0:23:43that you took in a pre wide color world

0:23:46of course is gonna look the same because

0:23:48there's no white color information in it

0:23:49you have to take the picture with a

0:23:51device capable of capturing that and

0:23:53then look at that same picture 1 unlike

0:23:56your iphone 7 that you took it on the

0:23:57took a white color picture and the other

0:23:59one that I thought that's what I did but

0:24:01but but truth be told it was right when

0:24:04i first got the seven

0:24:05I wouldn't put it past needed to

0:24:06accidentally have taken like an old

0:24:08picture

0:24:08and so I don't see anything but and I've

0:24:11seen like the sample images like where

0:24:13there's a like a big red blob and

0:24:15there's an are hidden in there that you

0:24:17wouldn't see unless its wide color you

0:24:19don't stuff like that but nevertheless

0:24:22on a regular picture I've not noticed

0:24:24the difference and as a corollary

0:24:25question is is my two-year-old micro

0:24:30four-thirds I presume that's not wide

0:24:32colors that fair to say most cameras

0:24:35have well most cameras don't have this

0:24:37option middle and high end cameras often

0:24:40will have an option to save the colors

0:24:42in adobe RGB maybe instead of like srgb

0:24:45but as far I haven't looked too much

0:24:48into this as far as i know that i think

0:24:50the conversion happens after raw anyway

0:24:53so you might be able to fix this with

0:24:55just a different Rock conversion process

0:24:56and John do you know about this i was

0:24:59gonna say what you said like there are

0:25:00other color profiles that are not called

0:25:01p3 that nevertheless have a larger range

0:25:03than srgb ya kiddo BRB he's one of them

0:25:06yeah I don't know which what the little

0:25:07envelopes looks like an all of them but

0:25:09and especially if you capture all I

0:25:11Kevin that's all the information you're

0:25:12going to get and if you can pull myself

0:25:14out of it i don't know but yeah I would

0:25:15like your best source for images with

0:25:18white color is your iphone 7 because

0:25:19it's you know but it's all connected up

0:25:22and then there if you actually look like

0:25:25cranberries page where he has a bunch of

0:25:27sample images if you really can't tell

0:25:29the difference between the sample images

0:25:30because they're made to like emphasize

0:25:32the areas where humans can perceive the

0:25:34p3 color difference more but those

0:25:38really emphasize those are kind of like

0:25:39artificial but i have seen some other

0:25:41pictures where it's like just a picture

0:25:43of like a park like grass in a tree and

0:25:46some sky and if you see them

0:25:48side-by-side like I do on my iPad pro

0:25:49and i go to that page like all right i

0:25:51mean it's not doesn't jump out at you

0:25:52but if you look you're like like is this

0:25:55really the same picture it's like yes

0:25:56this is literally the same picture

0:25:58because one is srgb and the other one is

0:26:00showing the four white color in the full

0:26:02what color one that it's it's almost

0:26:05like contrast is turned down the other

0:26:07one like there's not like the Greens

0:26:09don't look as green like most you know

0:26:11on the grass type situation like all

0:26:12that tree looks a little bit more past

0:26:14le and washed out now

0:26:15not a lot but you have to see them

0:26:17side-by-side to see it i don't think i

0:26:18could pick one out alone but if you

0:26:20literally show me the same picture and

0:26:21why

0:26:21not why'd you go all the wide looks a

0:26:23little better that's about it ok ok so

0:26:25I'm not entirely crazy then because i'm

0:26:26looking at this link on WebKit will put

0:26:28in the show notes and they have like

0:26:30this is what i was thinking of the

0:26:32WebKit logo which is like this big red

0:26:33blob that in srgb you don't see the logo

0:26:37and then if you go into p3 you can see

0:26:40the logo well if you scroll down on that

0:26:41same page they have yellow flower and if

0:26:44you click with this is like what you're

0:26:45saying John if you click between the

0:26:47sRGB only and the p3 unequivocally I can

0:26:51tell that the p3 is much more vivid and

0:26:54looks more real

0:26:55but if i were to look at either of these

0:26:57images like you said John without the

0:26:59other side by side

0:27:01unlike say a Retina screen versus a non

0:27:04retina screen were just words just

0:27:05unbelievably obvious with these i don't

0:27:09think i would notice the difference

0:27:10unless they're side by side

0:27:11I mean that's how I'm with most of these

0:27:12to it you know that like the example

0:27:14things if I look at it like I'm ipad pro

0:27:16which is my current biggest mp3 screen

0:27:18it the these pictures look great Shirley

0:27:21like that the big orange Sun sets like

0:27:23yet they do look a little more saturated

0:27:25in in those like orangie reddish tones

0:27:27but you can look at a non retina screen

0:27:30or a non-retina image our asset on a

0:27:33webpage on retina screen and you can

0:27:34tell that difference immediately

0:27:36the very first thing I see that is

0:27:38non-retina if you after your custom

0:27:41retina you notice that immediately

0:27:42whereas if I am scrolling through web

0:27:44page and I see a picture of an orange

0:27:46sunset that is not p3 after used to p3 i

0:27:49don't think i will notice because it

0:27:51could just look like it wasn't as

0:27:52saturated a picture as it could have

0:27:54been and so it's not you know it's a way

0:27:57smaller advance for everyday casual

0:28:00observing and for most people it's nice

0:28:03to have i'm glad they're doing it and

0:28:06it's especially nice you know if you

0:28:08actually shoot a lot of pictures of

0:28:09orange Sun sets and things but it's it's

0:28:12a very you know in in general use it's

0:28:14the kind of thing you can very easily

0:28:15forget that you even have ok that was my

0:28:18experience as well when I was curious

0:28:20because I feel like maybe it's just

0:28:22because I follow people like Hockenberry

0:28:23and Mark Edwards and and that you know

0:28:25they're really revved up about it but to

0:28:27me I was like man I barely see the

0:28:29difference and I'm glad to hear that

0:28:30that's not necessarily unusual the two

0:28:32more things on the monitors first Casey

0:28:34when you get back

0:28:35the work you should tap the underside of

0:28:37one of the corners your monitor and see

0:28:38if you got a bobblehead to because I

0:28:39think you owe I definitely do

0:28:41oh yeah but it's like what a bad job

0:28:43like the stand as one simple function

0:28:45just put the monitor up off the desk off

0:28:47the ground and keep it still

0:28:48and it fails that thing not the other

0:28:50thing is the one thing even though the

0:28:52LG monitors you know it's not much to it

0:28:54like it is just black everywhere it's

0:28:56not mad it's not shiny doesn't have much

0:28:58of a frame around it is not a fivehead

0:29:00the part of the bottom is the biggest

0:29:02part so like its proportions that the LG

0:29:04logo is small and subtle but if you go

0:29:06to that Amazon page from my thing and do

0:29:08the little do me thing you can you zoom

0:29:10in and see the LG logo right move over

0:29:12to the right from the LG logo what do

0:29:14you see there lurking in the corner

0:29:16because this is a pc products just got

0:29:19to be ugly in some stupid way what do

0:29:20you see there this stupid energy star

0:29:23and it's small it's not a big energy

0:29:25star badge and it's black and white like

0:29:27it's not colored and weird but like the

0:29:30whole front of this thing has nothing on

0:29:32it i will accept the LG logo is small

0:29:34and tasteful and centered why the hell

0:29:36is an NGO store and so I'm like I'm just

0:29:38going to peel that sticker off but it's

0:29:40one of those stickers we're gonna have

0:29:42to think on it for a while because it is

0:29:44clearly not one of the ones that comes

0:29:45off easy

0:29:46you know the ones that like made to come

0:29:47on like the metal one it's not metal

0:29:50it's not plastic like here's that is the

0:29:52math happened like I know I could get it

0:29:55off but after i get it off

0:29:57what's the left underneath the square

0:29:59where it used to be

0:30:01well that look worse than the sticker

0:30:02because the sticker for all its ugliness

0:30:04looks like a sticker right it's the

0:30:06Energy Star logo that peel it often is a

0:30:08bunch of like sticky crap or I damage

0:30:10the plastic underneath the business

0:30:12cheap plastic this is not an aluminum

0:30:14apple display or anything right

0:30:15if I damage it somehow or get sticky

0:30:18stuff in there that I can somehow can't

0:30:20get off with you know careful

0:30:21application of skin so soft on it which

0:30:23by the way that's a secret for all you

0:30:25out there if you get sticky crap from

0:30:27stickers on them

0:30:28one of the many things that will remove

0:30:29it i know there are many products but

0:30:30the one of the ones that I've used for

0:30:31years is Avon skin so soft which I think

0:30:34was supposed to be a thing that softens

0:30:35your skin

0:30:36the only thing i've ever used it for

0:30:38takeoff sticker scope and it's got a

0:30:40pleasanter oh my god why I i love the

0:30:44extent to which we will avoid talking

0:30:46about the microsoft surface to do

0:30:48no get there get there anyway energy

0:30:53star sticker uh it's you know it's got

0:30:55to be ugly in some way and i said i

0:30:57don't like that semi circular or stand

0:30:59on no no that was nice but it's not so

0:31:02that energy star sticker that on your

0:31:04monitors on the bottom right i have what

0:31:07appeared to be an identical one but if

0:31:09you look at the stand and you know how

0:31:11its kind of tilted at a sort of not a

0:31:1445-degree angle like a 30 degree angle

0:31:16maybe well mine was all the way on the

0:31:18left on that stand and I let it sit for

0:31:20a week or two before even noticed it and

0:31:22I was like all this crap in and you know

0:31:24what i did i immediately ripped it off

0:31:25because I don't worry about things like

0:31:27you do and there was no residue or if

0:31:30there's residue I like rub data with my

0:31:31thumb for a second that you don't know

0:31:33if there's residue you probably just

0:31:35that I don't even see them in the Amazon

0:31:37picture of your mother I don't see the

0:31:38energy star sticker anywhere I you're

0:31:40right i don't see it either but it was

0:31:42there for sure

0:31:43yeah so anyway I'm i might make a run at

0:31:46sticker eventually just rip it off John

0:31:48it's like a band-aid just rip it off

0:31:50yeah I all right speaking windows stuff

0:31:54we got a series of tweets from Jordan

0:31:57who is nerdy Oh phage on Twitter and he

0:32:01tweeted uh five things I'll read them in

0:32:04series he says I spent a week with a

0:32:06macbook pro escape after two solid

0:32:08decades of windows use I was of the

0:32:10opinion that Marcos on a batch dislike

0:32:12of Oh of the OS of windows was equal

0:32:15parts adoptive culture / fanboyism /

0:32:18certain showmanship

0:32:19I stand corrected in a little bit

0:32:20humbled the windows the windows path

0:32:23from neophyte power users shaped by red

0:32:25registry at its decoder rings and secret

0:32:28knocks which is arduous mac OS x

0:32:31comparison feels inviting friendly and

0:32:32intuitive like a late-night conversation

0:32:35at a dinner party with good friends so

0:32:36tldr this is still Jordan mac OS holy

0:32:40crap I get it

0:32:41transition costs will be very high but

0:32:43seriously considering it and this echoes

0:32:46my experience in 2008 of switching from

0:32:48windows 2 20 s 10 at the time there were

0:32:51two weeks where I doubted my life and

0:32:54thought I'd made a terrible awful

0:32:55horrible choice and then then I'd never

0:32:57look back

0:32:58I'm not saying that Jordans experience

0:32:59is true for everyone because now we're

0:33:01gonna have all the windows

0:33:02all just writing in telling us how

0:33:03Windows is good and we're a bunch of

0:33:05jerks and blah blah blah but they still

0:33:06really listen to us as some do because

0:33:09we still get emails i'm not saying that

0:33:12this is true for everyone i'm not saying

0:33:13windows isn't better in some way or

0:33:14another but I am saying is that we are

0:33:16not the only girl here not the only ones

0:33:18that seem to think that there's a better

0:33:20way so just thought i'd share those

0:33:22series of tweets from Jordan so thank

0:33:24you jordan for writing us uh we had an

0:33:27interesting conversation in slack Marco

0:33:29and I'd like to air agreements let's

0:33:33back up to circa january maybe december

0:33:37so almost a year ago now and the two of

0:33:41you but my recollection was that it was

0:33:43mostly Marco we're saying you know what

0:33:47Casey you should never put personal crap

0:33:49on your laptop on your work laptop you

0:33:52should really have a nice powerful

0:33:55machine for home use

0:33:56you probably shouldn't be ignoring Aaron

0:33:59and using your laptop while you're

0:34:00sitting next to her on the couch you

0:34:02know what you need you need my Mac I've

0:34:04tried the laptop dance Casey it's no

0:34:06good it's no good man get the imac think

0:34:09about that 27-inch beautiful at 5k

0:34:11display with white color blah blah blah

0:34:13i'm telling you it's the way to go

0:34:15this is there are some I've seen that

0:34:17picture with your summary already but go

0:34:19ahead but then fast forward to I don't

0:34:23know a few days ago when Marco is

0:34:25talking in slack that private place that

0:34:27we really shouldn't bring up publicly

0:34:28but here I am because I'm annoyed coach

0:34:31is talking into black and saying hmm you

0:34:34know what maybe I'll get a new macbook

0:34:37pro in a 5k display and i'll be back to

0:34:40a one machine man again and I won't even

0:34:42have to have a stupid desktop anymore

0:34:44mm that's not okay okay so here's what I

0:34:50said

0:34:51so basically looking looking at

0:34:53performance of everything and and

0:34:55figuring a a potential and maybe even

0:34:58likely future that does not include the

0:35:01mac pro existing and also includes

0:35:04standalone 5k retina displays that can

0:35:07plug into laptops that have

0:35:10not not matching but maybe ninety

0:35:13percent of the performance of imax or

0:35:16eighty percent of the performance of

0:35:17imax i always say the reason I by the 15

0:35:21inch laptops is because when I'm

0:35:24traveling I either need almost nothing

0:35:27in which case doesn't matter what I

0:35:28haven't that left me there like you type

0:35:30emails faster more like browse Twitter

0:35:33or I'm doing serious work whether it's

0:35:36xcode or like lightroom photo it raw

0:35:39importing and stuff and editing either

0:35:41way like usually when i use a laptop

0:35:44during travel I i want a lot of screen

0:35:48space and I want a lot of horsepower

0:35:49I also now have an imac as my main

0:35:54computer and looking at the specs of

0:35:56these computers these days and we'll

0:35:58compare you know comparing the the new

0:36:00MacBook Pros with LG 5k display you know

0:36:04assuming it's good we don't actually

0:36:05know yet but it will soon as good as the

0:36:07probably is comparing that against the

0:36:10imac you know basically I am maintaining

0:36:12and upgrading and paying for two

0:36:15different computers with overall fairly

0:36:18similar hardware and fairly similar

0:36:21performance and so I thought you know

0:36:24what I probably should do but won't and

0:36:28I bolted won't but I said what I

0:36:32probably should do is stop having two

0:36:35similar respect max that I pay for and

0:36:39and maintain and everything or just have

0:36:41a case a top-of-the-line 15-inch macbook

0:36:44pro that I use like many people do in

0:36:47clamshell mode

0:36:49next you know on my desk most of the

0:36:50time but then when I travel I can just

0:36:52take that with me and have all the power

0:36:54of this maxed-out computer with me that

0:36:58is what i should do it is not what I'm

0:37:00doing that and maybe in the future i

0:37:03will do that you know you know me I

0:37:05always change everything up never happy

0:37:06so maybe in the future i will do that I

0:37:10think I really want to wait and see what

0:37:12happens to the mac pro next year first

0:37:13you know if it turns out the mac pro is

0:37:15really dead and that the best weekend

0:37:17ever hope for in desktops is imac

0:37:20hardware that's ten twenty percent

0:37:22faster than the macbook pros

0:37:23the day then that might make a lot of

0:37:26sense actually for me but I really

0:37:28handle the fan noise I guarantee it

0:37:30you just think about the imac also has

0:37:32family that's the problem when as loud

0:37:34as a 15-inch no way

0:37:35well so so again i want to see the new

0:37:3715 inches first I want to know I want to

0:37:39have some experience with them hopefully

0:37:40to see like you know is this really you

0:37:42know how are these machines they really

0:37:44did reduce the fan noise noticeably when

0:37:46they move from the old crappy

0:37:48symmetrical fan blades to the retina

0:37:51macbook pro and 2012 when when Johnny

0:37:53first talked about the asymmetric family

0:37:55they showed this show the waveform yeah

0:37:56it's not louder but it did the like the

0:38:00annoying this other Diana asymmetrical

0:38:02really help with the annoying this it

0:38:03turned into a white-noise thing but I

0:38:05think it's still dark honest I i'm

0:38:07annoyed that i can hear the imac at all

0:38:09i'm annoyed at what I hear what i hear a

0:38:12laptop going with the is having are the

0:38:14new ones obviously but the asymmetrical

0:38:15fan ones they still I don't like the

0:38:18sound of like a white noise generating

0:38:19machine yet neither do i and III don't

0:38:22like cc1 my imac fan spin up i consider

0:38:25that like something that idea to put

0:38:27headphones on right now and stop here in

0:38:29this order to find the process that is

0:38:31using all my cpu power and just kill it

0:38:33because I I can i I really don't like

0:38:35hearing fan noise while I work

0:38:37it's simple as that so you know it a

0:38:39macro is silent under load in most rooms

0:38:42and that's one of the reasons i love it

0:38:43and that's one thing that will greatly

0:38:45miss if it is truly dead forever which

0:38:47you know again I i think it's looking

0:38:49increasingly likely we'll see what

0:38:50happens next year but anyway so all I

0:38:53was saying was it doesn't make a lot of

0:38:55sense for me to maintain two different

0:38:59fork or mid-range to high-end machines

0:39:02from Apple when I occasionally need one

0:39:05on the road but most of the time it's at

0:39:06my desk

0:39:07it would make more sense to consolidate

0:39:09into one computer and maybe even pull an

0:39:12imax I should be great and have two

0:39:15laptops maybe I have that crazy one and

0:39:17also a very small one like either an

0:39:20escape or macbook 144 the travel needs

0:39:24during which i don't need a lot of power

0:39:26and I just want to have the smallest

0:39:27thing possible and that would hardly

0:39:28ever get upgraded but that is a world

0:39:31that I probably should go to but

0:39:34currently i am not going to that

0:39:36because currently i'm still waiting out

0:39:37the potential mac pro of the future so i

0:39:41will see

0:39:42ATT says pointing out in the chat room

0:39:44that I should not forget that six core

0:39:47chips will be coming to the imac

0:39:50consumer core i7 line

0:39:52presumably you know in in the near

0:39:55future a six core imac would be awesome

0:39:58i would really prefer more you know it

0:40:01isn't gonna upgrade from for I want to

0:40:04pick up where i want to go to eight or

0:40:05twelve even or even more if i can get it

0:40:07and so I'd be nice to have even more but

0:40:11you know we'll see again at this this

0:40:13all depends on what the hardware brings

0:40:15over the next year or two and whether

0:40:18Apple even makes computers that use

0:40:20these chips are coming out we don't even

0:40:21know that so we'll see time will tell

0:40:24but right now i am not going all laptop

0:40:26but all I was saying that if I were more

0:40:29sensible it would probably be a better

0:40:32allocation of resources to just do that

0:40:34which is probably the reason why so many

0:40:36people do exactly that

0:40:38indeed I just wanted to grumble at you

0:40:41publicly for a moment so I feel much

0:40:43better now thanks everyone responds to

0:40:47tonight by betterment to go to

0:40:49betterment calm / ATP for investing made

0:40:52better betterment is the largest

0:40:54automated investing service out there is

0:40:56independent managing more than 5.5

0:40:58billion dollars for over a hundred and

0:41:00eighty thousand customers as of this

0:41:02past September Betterman has changed the

0:41:04investing into making investing easier

0:41:07and a lower cost and traditional

0:41:09financial advising services better it

0:41:11manages your investment with the same

0:41:12strategies the financial advisor is used

0:41:14with clients who have millions of

0:41:15dollars and you probably heard about

0:41:17them in the press such as the wall

0:41:19street journal Bloomberg and techcrunch

0:41:20defense service industries embrace

0:41:23technology and innovation to the

0:41:24creation of automated investing

0:41:26platforms like betterment me that you

0:41:28keep more of your money with fees that

0:41:30are a fraction of what you pay for

0:41:31traditional financial services excess

0:41:34cash that generator is automatically

0:41:35reinvested so every dollar you invest is

0:41:38put to work your portfolio is also

0:41:40automatically rebalance as necessary now

0:41:43investing involves risk but right now

0:41:45you can get up to six month no six

0:41:47months of no fees by going to betterment

0:41:49duck

0:41:49/ ATP that's betterment calm / ATP

0:41:54betterment investing made better

0:41:56ah apple has released a new mac book and

0:42:05things there's a new design book and

0:42:09half of me thinks I'd really don't see a

0:42:12problem with it and half of me thinks my

0:42:15word have they lost all sense of reality

0:42:17and I haven't decided which ones which

0:42:20ones which

0:42:21did anybody see this coming I didn't

0:42:23ride and I think it's a totally

0:42:25reasonable and to be expected thing for

0:42:28them to do in fact I'm surprised they

0:42:30don't do more of it i mean they sell

0:42:32they sell shirts with their things on

0:42:34them they sell all sorts of merchandise

0:42:36but it's Apple that apple stuff on it

0:42:38they they love having giant posters of

0:42:41all they're you know they're proud of

0:42:44their design and this particular thing

0:42:46as sort of a capper to johnny is career

0:42:48at Apple like it makes total sense i

0:42:49don't i don't think it's all that weird

0:42:51there are a few things are different

0:42:52about I mean first of all like the the

0:42:54t-shirts mugs everything you can only

0:42:56buy their company store or at their

0:42:58conference so it like you can't just go

0:43:00into any apple store go online and order

0:43:02an apple t-shirt like you like this kind

0:43:05of like a limited thing they keep only

0:43:06to like their store i'm assuming this

0:43:08will be limited to like how long do you

0:43:10think they'll sell its gonna be selling

0:43:11it for five years unless maybe maybe Tim

0:43:13Cook says you know we can keep selling

0:43:14the same design book for 10 years and

0:43:16there are the lower the price

0:43:17sure but like the other stuff is more

0:43:19like a slight it's like a gift shop at a

0:43:20museum like I went to apple 22 either

0:43:23WBC or to their campus and so I got this

0:43:26this expensive t-shirt because i went

0:43:28there and that's that's a little bit

0:43:30more justifiable if you have a problem

0:43:32this by the way I don't necessarily have

0:43:34a problem with this I i'm still I mostly

0:43:36indifferent on it i mostly don't care

0:43:38that exists i do think it shows a few

0:43:41things worth worth considering you know

0:43:43things like possible China of retirement

0:43:45overall though it seems poorly timed at

0:43:49a time when Apple is being criticized

0:43:52for neglecting a lot of their product

0:43:55line and their new release is being

0:43:59criticized for being especially poor

0:44:01value for the money

0:44:03and they and they appear to have cut

0:44:05Donald prices in an effort to show maybe

0:44:08they're not just trying to get a whole

0:44:09bunch of extra money from from accessory

0:44:11sales so is kind of an unfortunate time

0:44:15even if you ignore the election which I

0:44:16I I don't think you should

0:44:18but even if you ignore that this is kind

0:44:21of a weird time for Apple to release an

0:44:23incredibly self-congratulatory

0:44:24highfalutin to three-hundred-dollar book

0:44:27about themselves

0:44:28it's just it's a little bit poorly timed

0:44:30i think but it even if you don't agree

0:44:32with that he stepped aside I think it's

0:44:34mostly fine i do think it it is one of

0:44:37many signs pointing to Johnny I've is

0:44:39probably not that far off departure or

0:44:42retirement from apple or middle just

0:44:45descend further into the clouds of

0:44:47bizarre titles that that mean he doesn't

0:44:48actually do any day work but that might

0:44:51be the same thing I don't know but I'm

0:44:54not sure if I want one or not and i

0:44:57might be one of the ideal customers for

0:44:59it i buy stupid expensive things all the

0:45:01time that I like apple stuff usually a

0:45:04lot as i was looking at some of the some

0:45:07of the pages that they have on their

0:45:09sample site and everything they just

0:45:11kind of make me sad because they show

0:45:13like like other store the sample show

0:45:16the mac mini case and and like the the

0:45:18big cutting wheel i'm sorry i don't know

0:45:20the terms these various manufacturing

0:45:21tools like some giant spiky wheel that

0:45:24presumably carves out part of the inside

0:45:26of the mac mini case and its really nice

0:45:28that you care so much about the mac mini

0:45:29that people take this picture but the

0:45:31machine that makes this case what about

0:45:34the product that's been pretty neglected

0:45:36pretty badly or shit shows like it like

0:45:40a picture of the of the bottom assembly

0:45:43with the lid popping off of the previous

0:45:46generation non retina macbook pros like

0:45:48that might even be the one exactly and

0:45:51it shows that the macbook pro bottom lid

0:45:53taken off and you have the removable

0:45:54battery and you have the removable

0:45:56upgradeable hard drive is like oh yeah I

0:45:58remember one laptops for upgradeable and

0:46:01easily repaired like Kate I i think this

0:46:04book would mostly just me he said

0:46:06obviously about like about either either

0:46:09computers that Apple has neglected and

0:46:11that I that I am sad about like the mac

0:46:14pro which i assume is in there

0:46:16or it features of computers that are no

0:46:20longer present that have been cut

0:46:22through the the marks of quote progress

0:46:24over the years some of which is real

0:46:26progress I'm which is just cutting

0:46:27things so I i don't know how i feel

0:46:30about this for myself but if other

0:46:33people want to have this book and enjoy

0:46:34it that's fine really i again i do think

0:46:37that releases poorly timed but other

0:46:40than other than that I don't really have

0:46:41a problem with it i think i'm mostly

0:46:43agree but I already have a copy it's

0:46:45just called iconic back and i have

0:46:49iconic somewhere I think too i have the

0:46:51the old apple design book from the

0:46:53nineties it's called the let me check

0:46:56the island while you're checking out

0:46:58there is one a pic i do want to I i do

0:47:00want to not forget about though and that

0:47:02is so so Steve Jobs his name is all over

0:47:04this book they they

0:47:06his name's all over the press release

0:47:07their very prominently dedicated to him

0:47:10and everything I I think enough people

0:47:12have said that I don't need to say too

0:47:14much about that it's questionable

0:47:16whether jobs would have actually

0:47:18approved this project and and used it i

0:47:22will so that a lot of people keep saying

0:47:24that this project was started eight

0:47:25years ago and therefore that was back

0:47:27when Jobs alive and therefore he must

0:47:29have implicitly approved it and that's

0:47:30not entirely clear when Johnny idea the

0:47:34interview 2w something wallpaper

0:47:37whatever I forget I'm sorry

0:47:38it mentioned that they started

0:47:39collecting the products to photograph 8

0:47:42years ago that doesn't mean they started

0:47:45photographing for this specific project

0:47:46that was approved by jobs eight years

0:47:48ago so I do want to make that clear that

0:47:50I don't we don't know that jobs new this

0:47:52at all and I think I can't imagine that

0:47:57he would have appreciated it but well

0:47:59you know it's always risky for protect

0:48:02people like us to say well Steve Jobs

0:48:03wouldn't have done this wouldn't like

0:48:04this because you don't really know the

0:48:06guy change his mind a lot and he's not

0:48:07here anymore to to refute it so that

0:48:10it's not a great thing to rest on but it

0:48:11but i do think plastering his name all

0:48:14over it is maybe not so we just

0:48:17dedicated to him it's not like they're

0:48:19trying to like you know build on his

0:48:22the image to make to sell this book like

0:48:24the book sells that itself on its merits

0:48:26dedicated to the memory of their friend

0:48:29I think that's fine and if we can say

0:48:31one thing about this book it is steve

0:48:33jobs would like to have it in his house

0:48:35whether or not he thinks it's the

0:48:36product apple should sell I guarantee

0:48:38you he would love to have this book he

0:48:40would sit there on his his couch with

0:48:42his bare feet and leave through it and

0:48:44look at the great work that he's done

0:48:46whether anything is an example should be

0:48:48selling is a whole other story where the

0:48:50example should have a museum of all the

0:48:52old stuff is a hold of the story but he

0:48:54so clearly took pride in all the

0:48:56products that are in this thing that he

0:48:58himself just personally would surely

0:49:00love to have the best possible

0:49:02photographs on the best possible paper

0:49:05made in germany with them you know

0:49:06special gilding around the edges and he

0:49:10would love this book this you look

0:49:11really cool thing to make for your

0:49:14employees you know or or to maybe sell

0:49:17for a limited time at your campus store

0:49:19but to sell it as like a whole product

0:49:22that I think it kind of raises the bar

0:49:24and raises the level of criticism a bit

0:49:27a little bit of an unnecessarily maybe

0:49:29but you know because like I think will

0:49:31be a lot cooler if this was a thing for

0:49:34all the employees Vegas all got for free

0:49:35we probably aren't even getting for free

0:49:36probably not it's charging two

0:49:38particular always work but imagine if

0:49:40they gave us to all the employees and

0:49:42the handful of Apple collectors who

0:49:44really want it would have to like go

0:49:46find on eBay or something that will be

0:49:47so much cooler if you had one if that

0:49:49was the case it i don't know is it just

0:49:52seems like that might have been a better

0:49:53way to go here

0:49:53yeah I tend to agree so I just reached

0:49:56out into the bookcase behind me and grab

0:49:59my copy of iconic and i started paging

0:50:02through it and I landed on page 130 of

0:50:06iconic and it has a quote which i will

0:50:09read to you if you never change anything

0:50:12then what what you can really engineers

0:50:14kind of incremental but when you're

0:50:15willing to change things then you kind

0:50:17of open up a whole new world of design

0:50:19this is Big Bob Mansfield at the launch

0:50:22of 2012 macbook pro in the accompanying

0:50:24picture is a macbook pro that has

0:50:27magsafe ethernet firewire Thunderbolt 2

0:50:31USB ports in SD card slot line in ahead

0:50:34on Jack just thought that was kind of

0:50:35funny that's pretty cool so yeah so when

0:50:40you're willing to change things and you

0:50:41open up a whole new world of design like

0:50:42fewer ports so the book next to me is

0:50:45called apple design all one word capital

0:50:47capital D colon the work of the Apple

0:50:50industrial design group and it's where

0:50:51is an older book so it's got the stuff

0:50:53from before you guys are Mac users it's

0:50:55like mostly the error

0:50:57well i can expand the whole range but

0:50:58anyway it's definitely earlier than the

0:51:01stuff that's in this book and i could

0:51:03say i would like to own this book to i

0:51:06would totally like this book but i would

0:51:09like two or three jobs where at this

0:51:11point because and here's what here's the

0:51:14thing like it's not three hundred

0:51:15dollars for a really super high-quality

0:51:17photo book is that big a deal it's just

0:51:18that for me personally with you know

0:51:20having just bought a monitor and

0:51:22playstation 4 pro and also other stuff I

0:51:26would spend three hundred dollars in

0:51:27this if it was like the making of the

0:51:29star wars books that i bought which by

0:51:30the way Warren $300 like basically if it

0:51:33was lots more words now that I don't

0:51:35like the pictures i do i want the

0:51:36pictures but if it was the pictures but

0:51:39also pages upon pages upon pages of the

0:51:43designers including John himself telling

0:51:45the story of how they came up with these

0:51:47designs in as much detail as they can

0:51:49possibly remember again like the making

0:51:50of the star wars books which are not

0:51:52first-person accounts but it's like some

0:51:53research and talk to all the people

0:51:55involved and tried to lay out here's how

0:51:58each of the three original trilogy star

0:52:00wars we just made from conception

0:52:02through the production design talking to

0:52:04all the people involved in getting

0:52:05quotes from them and putting it all

0:52:06together

0:52:07that's what i would like to read and my

0:52:09impression is this book is either

0:52:10entirely or at least mostly pictures and

0:52:13not so much about Apple's gonna tell you

0:52:15you know how the sausage is made

0:52:17I mean I'm sure lots of pictures of

0:52:18prototypes and you know like things with

0:52:20a tool that Marco talk about whatever

0:52:21but it's not really like tell us how did

0:52:24you come up with this is I would love to

0:52:25read that but that is not that simple

0:52:27and what I'm saying is basically those

0:52:28those words were in this book i would

0:52:30pay 300 dollar store in a second but

0:52:31just the photos I i have a longing to on

0:52:35this book but cannot bring myself to

0:52:38part with Randy dollars were quite yet

0:52:40maybe maybe I'll break down into how

0:52:42long they sell this maybe I'll succumb

0:52:44to it at some point because I

0:52:45really do want this book i mean i have

0:52:47tons of books like this but both range

0:52:49of dollars that stuff and no i don't

0:52:51want the small one because come on it's

0:52:52nothing why are there two sizes like

0:52:54that's such a good thing just making

0:52:56sure they should have called the big 12

0:52:58plus some people want a larger obviously

0:53:00the big one is huge i like the big 1i

0:53:03think I'm think about if I had that in

0:53:04my house how the hell would I even fit

0:53:05on my shelves i don't think i even have

0:53:07any shelves at the making of star wars

0:53:08books are a little bit too big for my

0:53:09shelves too but you know it's photos

0:53:11come on you gotta get the big yeah i

0:53:13just gotta say this iconic book I'd

0:53:16forgotten page through a long time man

0:53:18is this a nice book it really honestly

0:53:20is and its cheapness like 50 bucks on

0:53:23amazon right now it's definitely worth

0:53:25it i wonder if i can get the business

0:53:26rep discount ok fifty percent of you

0:53:30threw a book at my apple ibook is right

0:53:34next to the art of kiki's delivery

0:53:35service the complete works of Larry a

0:53:37lot more but also i have a higher or

0:53:41astoria legend of zelda book all of

0:53:43which are about the same size big kind

0:53:45of glossy photo book things but none of

0:53:47which costs three hundred dollars now I

0:53:49mean it's you know people who know more

0:53:51about art books are end you know as you

0:53:53said John like the I don't think it's

0:53:55outrageously priced for what it is but

0:53:58it certainly doesn't contribute it

0:54:00certainly doesn't help the the recent or

0:54:03possibly forever reputation of apple for

0:54:06this like elitist company making

0:54:08expensive things that only for rich

0:54:10people like that's this doesn't really

0:54:12help that image at all in this really i

0:54:15don't know again this is not a big deal

0:54:17i don't feel that strongly about this

0:54:18book either way I might even buy one who

0:54:20knows but i do think it was a little

0:54:23poorly timed for for image sake I think

0:54:25and see the weird thing about this book

0:54:27is its i like the idea that Apple itself

0:54:31is the one doing it because it's great

0:54:33as iconic is the apples line books or

0:54:35whatever Apple presumably I mean you

0:54:39would think they would have access to

0:54:40all the stuff apparently they didn't

0:54:41have to go out and buy it or whatever

0:54:43but either way like they was really good

0:54:47at taking pictures of its products they

0:54:48have the most experience of anybody in

0:54:50the entire world taking pictures of

0:54:51apple products because that's what they

0:54:53do and they do it really really well and

0:54:55because they're all obsessive detailed

0:54:57people about like the printing and the

0:54:59color in the paper I bet it's a really

0:55:01nice book right but the one thing the

0:55:05Apple can bring to this book above and

0:55:08beyond those two things that i just

0:55:10mentioned that nobody else can

0:55:13is that they have the best access to the

0:55:15people who were involved in making me

0:55:17some of those people may be gone all

0:55:18those supposedly there's very little

0:55:19turnover and Johnny absolutely design

0:55:21group there that's the value they can

0:55:24bring this was the whole I know you're

0:55:25getting a market like apples making a

0:55:27book about how great their right there

0:55:28making a book about themselves and

0:55:29saying we are awesome or just look at

0:55:31all these cool things that we made which

0:55:32i guess is ok but if you want a blunt

0:55:34that it's like don't just make it look

0:55:36at these awesome things that we made

0:55:37bring the value that only you have tell

0:55:39us the stories people who worked on

0:55:41these products

0:55:42tell us about how you made them because

0:55:44no one else can tell us how they made

0:55:45them other people can take pictures of

0:55:47them other people can make a big glossy

0:55:48photo book other people can probably

0:55:50find the right kind of paper and do the

0:55:52cool printing and do all the things but

0:55:54nobody but you guys can tell us the

0:55:57story of how these products are made and

0:55:58they're not doing that so they're like

0:55:59saying how great they are but like yeah

0:56:02I don't want to tell you too much about

0:56:03it just look at the stuff we're pretty

0:56:04great huh don't nevermind that was made

0:56:06and that's that definitely shades more

0:56:09into the event that makes it less

0:56:11forgivable as an act of you know

0:56:13self-congratulations because if you are

0:56:16describing how you did it

0:56:17you're not just congratulating yourself

0:56:18even if the whole book is like we had

0:56:20heart problems then we solve them

0:56:21because you're super smart you're you're

0:56:23passing on your knowledge your telling

0:56:25the rest of the world learn from our

0:56:27lessons which you can still do with a

0:56:29lot of ego and you know back padding but

0:56:32i think that would offset the look how

0:56:35great we are angle of it and and like

0:56:38you said and I can only goes like and

0:56:40like we talked about with the actual the

0:56:41the new macbook pros the past several

0:56:44shows it's not so much the thing itself

0:56:46it's the context into which is

0:56:47introduced and so like Marcus at the

0:56:49timing is bad and at this point almost

0:56:52anything you introduced into the context

0:56:54of a certain set of grumpy Apple fans is

0:56:57going to be looked upon with the you

0:57:00know a very critical eye and people are

0:57:04generally in a bad mood for reasons that

0:57:05are made some which may be outside

0:57:07apples control whatever like if they've

0:57:09been if they've been building towards

0:57:11right years

0:57:12fine whatever release it like a holiday

0:57:14season it's a good gift idea for the

0:57:16Apple nerd in your life you know like it

0:57:18that I don't fault them i don't think

0:57:21it's that big a deal

0:57:22I just wish it wasn't three dollars

0:57:24because I really want this book I you

0:57:26know and one thing like I think you

0:57:28nailed it about like that you know part

0:57:30of this number of people the wrong way

0:57:31is the fact that there is there are no

0:57:33no words or as you said like you know

0:57:35that they have access to the people they

0:57:38could have added the human more human

0:57:40function and it seems like they mean we

0:57:42haven't read the book yet but from the

0:57:44few sample pages we've seen it really

0:57:46does seem like they didn't you know

0:57:47there's no words in it and i think if i

0:57:50had to summarize I i guess the the main

0:57:55disappoint when I have with apple

0:57:57recently which i think a lot of people

0:57:59feel but might not have put into words

0:58:01is that it seems to just lack humanity

0:58:04recently like it and I don't like this

0:58:08might be a Steve too Tim thing i don't

0:58:10know i haven't given a ton of thought to

0:58:12this year it's hard to put into words

0:58:13but you know Steve even though we knew

0:58:17he could be like cold and ruthless to

0:58:20people when he had to be his public

0:58:22persona which which really did reflect

0:58:24upon the whole company you know to the

0:58:26public was really quite warm and and

0:58:29human and we end with with the

0:58:32transition to Tim Cook sample and and

0:58:35jony ive's apple which is you know

0:58:36that's really this is what this is these

0:58:38days

0:58:38Apple that the public image that we get

0:58:41even though most of the same people are

0:58:43still there but the public image that is

0:58:45shown to us what gets out there's a lot

0:58:48more cold and they're like the humanity

0:58:51has been stripped out of it and as and I

0:58:53think part of what bug people about

0:58:55things like removing the startup chime

0:58:56on a new macbook pros and removing the

0:58:58lineup logo on the back is like that's a

0:59:01little bit more of this humanity to just

0:59:02being pulled out of the products and and

0:59:05we don't see warmth and humanity as much

0:59:09as we used to anymore you know a promo

0:59:11video showing what people are doing with

0:59:13the product is different its you think

0:59:14its humanity

0:59:15I I do i do think its humanity i think

0:59:18we do i would say you don't think whimsy

0:59:20is a better word because the wind is a

0:59:22stronger case for whimsy because

0:59:23humanity I think of like to

0:59:25Cook is much more into you know the the

0:59:28human aspects are social aspects of both

0:59:32the products and the company then Steve

0:59:34Jobs ever was and tim cook in the Tim

0:59:37Cook era he's the one who's constantly

0:59:38starting presentations with videos about

0:59:40accessibility and people who are being

0:59:44you know he's a human story of being

0:59:45empowered by apple products i would call

0:59:48that human too but whimsical is you know

0:59:51we're like it is dorky maybe hit you

0:59:56know it wimzie's just like that the

0:59:57little happy mac and and and the child

0:59:57little happy mac and and and the child

1:00:00and then a little poof animation stuff

1:00:01silly things like that seem to not be

1:00:04too Jony Ive's taste because he's not

1:00:08into the proof right he's not into the

1:00:10this happy Mac the smile and the time

1:00:13he's into the the iphone that doesn't

1:00:15even have a logo that you can see when

1:00:16you look at it right and Tim Cook is

1:00:19deferring to drive in that way so I

1:00:20think you're right to refer to the same

1:00:22cook / Jony ive apple so there is

1:00:24definitely less sense of whimsy and

1:00:27whimsy can be seen as warmth in his

1:00:29design is that it can be thought of as

1:00:30cold but I think Tim Cook's apple and

1:00:32Tim Duncan specific specifically are all

1:00:35about humanity just not about darkness

1:00:39and whimsy

1:00:40yeah it's I'm not again i'm not saying

1:00:42that like the company like because we

1:00:44know the same people are mostly they're

1:00:46right especially look at the upper

1:00:47levels not a lot of change their they

1:00:49need a week we know that they do good

1:00:51these are good people and they do good

1:00:54things for the world but you did doesn't

1:00:57come across it

1:00:58the the amount of warmth and and you

1:01:01know and maybe humanity might be exactly

1:01:03what I do think whimsies partner but I

1:01:04don't think whimsy covers all of what

1:01:06I'm what I'm missing

1:01:07well what about the ads like when they

1:01:09show their a lot of their recent ads

1:01:11have been all about showing people using

1:01:13the product remember the one with like

1:01:14the kid with his nose buried in his

1:01:15phone during the holidays Christmas

1:01:18thing at the end he's made the video of

1:01:19them making this stuff like or just like

1:01:21the people who are like with your watch

1:01:22you get up as early in the morning it's

1:01:24still dark calculates the sneakers to

1:01:25put on your watch is not running or

1:01:27you're running through the rain with

1:01:28your now water-resistant phone like

1:01:30they're adds even more than they used to

1:01:32be

1:01:33had been less about glorifying the

1:01:34objects is beautiful totems of

1:01:36technology as like look how smooth and

1:01:38sleek is which they still doing like the

1:01:39presentations to hospital on television

1:01:41it's all about the people it's all about

1:01:44I am a runner i like to take photographs

1:01:46i'm on a family vacation and you know

1:01:48come by this device in your kid will be

1:01:50it will look like a socket into really

1:01:52he will be loving wonderful creative

1:01:54child which is false advertising but

1:01:56anyway I'm here to suck and won't

1:02:00actually make a video for you just

1:02:02texting his friends although not that

1:02:04like we add seem to be focusing on again

1:02:06the humanity of uh like that it's not

1:02:10about the product

1:02:11about the people and what the products

1:02:12enable the people to do so and again

1:02:14that's you know Apple choose what kind

1:02:16of adds an extra the advertising company

1:02:17makes them but Apple can give them

1:02:19direction and it is less like that you

1:02:22know in the steve jobs are you had a

1:02:24series of commercials that were all

1:02:25about showing you the card the hardware

1:02:27like the lifesavers imax flying across

1:02:28the screen look they're shiny and color

1:02:30and look at the on the imac SE came out

1:02:33it's all sleep in graphite he liked

1:02:35those were more obsessed obsessed with

1:02:37the objects because that was all about

1:02:39like hey hardware can be fashioned and

1:02:41look at these things and I think it

1:02:43started to shift with the ipod where was

1:02:45like yeah there's silhouettes dancing

1:02:47and you can see the ipod with the white

1:02:48cord but it's all about people dancing

1:02:49and music and at this point they're

1:02:51selling phones by showing you people

1:02:54jogging right so it is so far from i

1:02:56think it is definitely a very human

1:02:58approach but again i would say that the

1:03:02product designs themselves and what

1:03:06things the company decides to do

1:03:07definitely seem less whimsical and less

1:03:10dorky and I could see that is being said

1:03:12more cold unless more the ads you know

1:03:14you're right the a defined but their ads

1:03:16their commercials you know you know I

1:03:18i'm referring to mostly the products and

1:03:21then some also of the presentations you

1:03:24know by the actual humans on stage at

1:03:27the events you know so again it's it's

1:03:30hard to to not make this about Steve

1:03:32because steve was really good at at

1:03:34really being you know personable up

1:03:37there onstage and whether it was

1:03:38rehearsed or or fake or real or whatever

1:03:41I don't know it didn't matter its see it

1:03:43really did come across as genuine and

1:03:45real and and warm and that's what I

1:03:48missed both onstage I don't care what

1:03:50the videos the the use of more videos

1:03:52actually to me feels colder i feels more

1:03:55artificial but you know that's that's

1:03:57beside the point for now at all i'm

1:04:00saying is I i miss this level of warmth

1:04:03that that we used to get from them in

1:04:06these presentations and then I think

1:04:07that the whimsy and the product is part

1:04:09of that I you know that showed the

1:04:11product and it seems like modern apple

1:04:14is all about really editing that out as

1:04:16as part of a march towards quote

1:04:19simplifying or quote progress but but I

1:04:22we're losing a lot of that and where we

1:04:24don't seem to be gaining any in many

1:04:26areas anymore it seems like we've been

1:04:28coming just moved on past that and just

1:04:30now it's just a lot more like cold and

1:04:33and almost robotic so this book coming

1:04:35out with all pictures of Johnny I'd

1:04:39robotic tools in stark white background

1:04:42with no words i think is kind of like a

1:04:45culmination of of that cold process and

1:04:49at that's what kind of rubs me the wrong

1:04:50way about about the book and about apple

1:04:53today if I had to summarize it down and

1:04:55again i I'm sorry if I'm not expressing

1:04:57this well this is really still a very

1:05:00you know squishy thought in my head but

1:05:02just I'm trying to put into feel it put

1:05:04into words a complex feeling lemon

1:05:07filling over a while but I just miss

1:05:10that warmth that we used to that we used

1:05:12to get whether it was real or not from

1:05:14from both Steve and the products that I

1:05:16think we're really missing a lot of that

1:05:17recently so if you were to get this book

1:05:20and it was chronological which i'm not

1:05:21sure that is but if it is chronological

1:05:23you could flip through it and watch the

1:05:25whimsy slowly draining out of the

1:05:27products that you started with tangerine

1:05:29imax and all these brightly colored

1:05:32things that it like you know the the

1:05:34toilet but see I books and all these

1:05:37things that just look so exciting and

1:05:40dr. Susie and slowly but surely

1:05:42everything turned silver and glass and

1:05:44uniform and not shiny not mad just in

1:05:49between e and you know just it smooths

1:05:52out which I you know I like both those

1:05:55athletics is why I think like this book

1:05:57is this book highlights some of Apple

1:05:59best work in terms of industrial design

1:06:01because it does include all away from

1:06:04you know the the the the vibrancy of the

1:06:08original imax and even like the one with

1:06:11the big neck and all the stuff all way

1:06:13up to the modern era of everything being

1:06:16sleek and clean those are both great

1:06:18aesthetics but chronologically speaking

1:06:20you know you can see the trend i could

1:06:23read the book backwards and make myself

1:06:24feel really happy

1:06:26benjamin button it but you know I

1:06:29I think I'm i agree with you Marco I I

1:06:32just can't shake this feeling that Apple

1:06:35is reluctantly moving closer and closer

1:06:38to being the IBM that they fought so

1:06:42hard against when when you and I were

1:06:44like a really little

1:06:46let's not go crazy here well no I don't

1:06:48think they're there but if you look at

1:06:52the IBM of the early to mid eighties

1:06:55probably ladies it was not boring but it

1:06:59certainly did not have whimsy and I

1:07:02would not say that Apple's products

1:07:03they're boring many such an imagination

1:07:04but i agree that they've lost some of

1:07:07that and I actually think humanity is a

1:07:10is a good word for it if a bit overblown

1:07:13but I can't come up with a better one

1:07:15and i think i like humanity more than

1:07:17wednesday but anyway it just doesn't

1:07:19feel as happy go lucky as they used to

1:07:23and I think part of that is being is is

1:07:25no longer being the underdog is now

1:07:27being king of the hill which maybe

1:07:29that's our perception

1:07:31maybe it's that because we perceive them

1:07:34as king of the hill we perceive them is

1:07:35boring and they're anything but but i

1:07:38don't know i don't i don't think that's

1:07:39the case in and i agree with you and

1:07:41it's funny because on the one side I i

1:07:43love the look of the new macbook pro at

1:07:45least in in photographs i haven't seen

1:07:46one in person yet but in in photographs

1:07:48it looks phenomenal

1:07:49I i love it i think it looks really

1:07:52great and I think that's in part because

1:07:53you know a very black aesthetic appeals

1:07:56to me but yet I i miss the fun of all

1:08:01these different colored imax you know it

1:08:03the computers that is all running around

1:08:05campus when I was in school in the early

1:08:07two thousands they just looked fun and I

1:08:09wouldn't say a new macbook pro looks fun

1:08:11it looks really damn good it looks more

1:08:14aesthetically good I'd say than perhaps

1:08:17any other laptop on the market today and

1:08:20in fact I've said before and I'll say

1:08:21again this iphone 7 holding in my hands

1:08:24right now that this matte black iphone 7

1:08:27i think is the best-looking iphone I've

1:08:29seen yet however i wouldn't say it looks

1:08:33fun despite it looking really good and i

1:08:35miss that kind of fine ass

1:08:37fact yeah and this and i'm not saying

1:08:39the products are bad or like the

1:08:42products are in many ways better than

1:08:44ever now you know like by most measures

1:08:47most of the products are better than

1:08:50ever

1:08:50they're still good products in many ways

1:08:53they're still great products but but

1:08:55again just like it's this feeling that

1:08:57I'm missing that I'd that we used to

1:08:59have here and maybe I'm just old and

1:09:02jaded and boring i I don't know maybe

1:09:04I'm just mad with the mac pro still I

1:09:05don't know but but this I I just feel

1:09:08like I'm missing this feeling I'm not

1:09:10well I am old and jaded but I'm not

1:09:12jaded about mac pro specifically an area

1:09:14and I'm not jaded at about the macbook

1:09:17pro specifically and I i do largely

1:09:19agree with you that it just it's not as

1:09:22fun as it once was and again maybe is

1:09:24that just by virtue of them being no

1:09:27longer the underdog so so you know that

1:09:29it's fun to root for the underdog it's

1:09:31not fun to root for the king of the hill

1:09:32so maybe it's misplace maybe the problem

1:09:35is us but but i agree with you

1:09:37nevertheless I think the design trend

1:09:39that is described from the the more

1:09:42whimsical computers that varied more

1:09:44widely in shape and color and texture

1:09:46and everything about them to the current

1:09:48design is a natural consequence of the

1:09:50advance of the technology because as we

1:09:54acquire the technology to to to make the

1:09:56products that we have now that you know

1:09:58in the case of I devices are essentially

1:09:59rectangles that are screens that get

1:10:02increasingly thin and for the case of

1:10:03laptops a screen rectangle and then a

1:10:06rectangle with the keyboard an

1:10:08increasingly large trackpad your options

1:10:10for industrial design uh start to be in

1:10:14conflict with the advances that you're

1:10:16you know the reaping the benefits of

1:10:17actually be able to make it smaller like

1:10:19if you look at the size of the the

1:10:21plastic that surrounds the screen on the

1:10:23toilet seat imax it is its vast right

1:10:27and that allows you to make this

1:10:28cool-looking strange oblong kind of

1:10:30person like design and everything like

1:10:32gives you the room to make those big

1:10:34scoops and colors and contrast but there

1:10:37is no there's no more room for that in a

1:10:39world where it's basically a screen with

1:10:41the margin slowly shrinking around it or

1:10:43like the laptops is you know getting

1:10:45thinner and thinner and smaller and

1:10:46tighter and tighter and you know why

1:10:48fight that the correct direction is

1:10:50aesthetically

1:10:51meeting Tuesday embrace that and embrace

1:10:54anesthetic that can work with

1:10:56increasingly smelt devices and that is

1:11:01get another reason to add to the list of

1:11:03why the mac pro be great because the mac

1:11:05pro it does not have a screen on it

1:11:07you do have the freedom to make it you

1:11:09they can make it shaped like a soccer

1:11:10ball can be shaped like a spiral

1:11:12apparently can be shaped like garbage

1:11:13can be shaped like a cheese grater it

1:11:16actually gives them the most options in

1:11:19terms of industrial design because there

1:11:20are no longer constrained by the fact

1:11:22that you have to carry it and that

1:11:23making it smaller and thinner and

1:11:25lighter is such a benefit in the long

1:11:26run that they can't afford to put a

1:11:28giant plastic handle on it and a huge

1:11:29three inch border around the entire

1:11:31screen because that's ridiculous like no

1:11:32one wants that anymore its it looks old

1:11:34and it is old and it's bad but when it

1:11:36says on your desk or under your desk a

1:11:38lot more options open up and so it's

1:11:40just another reason that it would be a

1:11:41shame if they totally gave up that form

1:11:44factor or if they said even that form

1:11:46factor you wanted to be its small and

1:11:48and minimal as possible and so that you

1:11:50get the current mac mini in the apple TV

1:11:51which are just the most you know it's

1:11:53and it's not appropriate I think for

1:11:55those things to be only the apple TV

1:11:57because I should be boring cuz you don't

1:11:58even see it but the mac mini you have a

1:12:00little bit more fun with that maybe put

1:12:02some events and strikes on and make it

1:12:04look like a Ferrari I don't know there

1:12:06was no reason for it to be as boring as

1:12:07it is but there are reasons for the

1:12:09phone to be as boring as it is and for

1:12:11the laptop speed not as boring like for

1:12:13them to look like a do I think they're

1:12:14very good reason to do that I think have

1:12:16to hit that they had tried to keep the

1:12:17old aesthetic while going along with the

1:12:20market technology that allows you to

1:12:21make it thinner and lighter it would be

1:12:23a bad tension between those two things

1:12:25you can't make a modern laptop that

1:12:28looks like the toilet seat I book you

1:12:29just can't be would youwould is not the

1:12:31right design approach back then it was

1:12:33now it's not now you can take the

1:12:34current ones and make them in candy

1:12:37apple red with the same form factor make

1:12:39it like polish glossy candy apple red

1:12:41and that would be fun but it's still you

1:12:44know like color and texture is basically

1:12:46all they have left to play with because

1:12:48shape-wise it's not like they're going

1:12:50to be adding friends and strikes you

1:12:52know tailfins on the next iPad pro or

1:12:54whatever

1:12:55yeah i agree like why couldn't we have

1:12:58all the colors of the 5c on the seven

1:13:02you know because those were fun I

1:13:04thought

1:13:04in and I think they pee they appeal to a

1:13:07lot of people that perhaps weren't is

1:13:08you know technically minded in terms of

1:13:11of stats and like having to have the

1:13:13latest and greatest i still see 5 c's

1:13:16floating around from time to time so why

1:13:17not have that color range on the

1:13:19top-of-the-line phone

1:13:21well because it's not proper I mean I

1:13:23don't know I just I do kind of Miss that

1:13:24even though even though the one side I

1:13:27wouldn't ever pick any of those I guess

1:13:30this is my halo car like I don't really

1:13:31see the need for mac pro and I'm not

1:13:33trying to open up that conversation

1:13:34again but to me I don't see the need for

1:13:36a mac pro but i do like I would notice a

1:13:40array of colors on the iphone 7 and be

1:13:44pleased that they exist even though

1:13:45there was no freaking way I would choose

1:13:47anything but matt black or maybe

1:13:49jet-black my god like the negative

1:13:50robotic or again it's like you know real

1:13:52life you see phones that are all sorts

1:13:54of colors that's just not the color of

1:13:55the phone is the color of people's cases

1:13:56IC phone cans

1:13:58this is a huge range of colors textures

1:14:00sizes features ones that you put your

1:14:02credit card into ones that have a place

1:14:03for a stylist to go into like the huge

1:14:05things with mirrors on the back of them

1:14:06they just think clamshell ones ones with

1:14:09the covers not just a huge range but

1:14:12that's the Apple not doing any of that

1:14:13they're just giving you think about it

1:14:15for this episode is sponsored by

1:14:18audible.com with an unmatched selection

1:14:21of audiobooks original audio shows news

1:14:23comedy and more get a free 30-day trial

1:14:26at audible.com / ATP if you want to

1:14:30listen to it audible has it you can

1:14:32listen to audiobooks from virtually

1:14:33every genre anytime anywhere you can

1:14:36play audibles audiobooks on every device

1:14:38you have phones tablets computers even

1:14:41ipods if you still have an ipod audio

1:14:44books are great for flights long road

1:14:46trips or even your daily commute you may

1:14:48think you have time to read books but

1:14:49you'd be surprised how many audio books

1:14:51you can hear each year even listening to

1:14:53and from work every day

1:14:55audiobooks bring books to life maybe

1:14:57they were ready by the author's

1:14:58themselves adding an extra dimension to

1:15:00the text and you can take risks and try

1:15:02new authors and drivers without regret

1:15:04with audible because they offer the

1:15:05great listen guarantee if you start an

1:15:08audiobook and don't like it you can

1:15:09exchange it for another one for free

1:15:11see and listen for yourself today when

1:15:14you begin your 30-day free trial if your

1:15:16first audio book for free

1:15:18and there's no stress or obligation you

1:15:20can cancel your membership at anytime

1:15:22so with audiobooks and spoken word audio

1:15:24products you will find what you're

1:15:26looking for with audible.com get a free

1:15:2830-day trial by signing up today at

1:15:30audible.com / ATP that's audible.com /

1:15:35ATP thanks to audible for sponsoring our

1:15:37show we've been putting off for a long

1:15:41time talking about this Microsoft

1:15:45Surface studio and I think that we

1:15:49should probably talk about the Nintendo

1:15:50switch we don't actually have to do that

1:15:54but I couldn't sell it we should return

1:15:56to the surface to do first in fact it's

1:15:58been it's been so long since the service

1:16:01studio event whatever that was that I

1:16:03think we need the chief summarizer and

1:16:05chips to remind everyone what the hell

1:16:06the Microsoft Surface video is hosted at

1:16:09the to summarize in chief doesn't

1:16:10remember any more like I can get as so

1:16:14this was i don't recall exactly what it

1:16:16was but it was a few weeks ago that

1:16:18microsoft had some sort of product demo

1:16:22where they debuted the surface studio

1:16:26which at first appear to be an imac in

1:16:32many ways it just seemed like an imac an

1:16:34imac but well I guess I should say my

1:16:36mac mac mini right because it's the

1:16:39screen of an imac it appeared it's 28

1:16:42inches and this in the computer bits are

1:16:46in a base that looks very much like a

1:16:49mac mini it's all black and aluminum or

1:16:52at least aluminum colored and it all

1:16:54looks very snazzy and i don't mean that

1:16:55sarcastically really honestly does look

1:16:57good and at first it was like okay great

1:17:00you're doing i'm a clue but then they

1:17:02mention that

1:17:03oh this is a touchscreen a 28 inch

1:17:05touchscreen and suddenly people start to

1:17:07go

1:17:08mm okay tell me more I and then the real

1:17:13party trick happened which was microsoft

1:17:16explained why there are two arms going

1:17:18from the mac mini to the imac

1:17:20and those arms allow you from what they

1:17:23showed allow you to very effortlessly

1:17:26turn this imac into kind of an easel so

1:17:31it's a day very very shallow angle such

1:17:34that you could use it as though it's a

1:17:35writing surface and it has with it their

1:17:38equivalent of an apple pencil and even

1:17:41more importantly it has or maybe not

1:17:44more importantly but differently

1:17:45it also has a surface dial and so what

1:17:49this is is a little puck sort of thing

1:17:52it's actually not on that dissimilar

1:17:54from the park mouse that everyone hated

1:17:56but much taller and you can sit that on

1:17:58your desk and you can spin it in order

1:18:00to manually change volume or get

1:18:02different you know tools as you're using

1:18:05the pen but where it gets even cooler

1:18:07still and you have to understand that

1:18:09this hinge that they have genuinely is

1:18:11is really need it looks really really

1:18:13clever but what's cooler still about the

1:18:15surface style this park is that you can

1:18:17drop this thing right on the display and

1:18:19the display recognizes that it's there

1:18:22and where it is and allows you to treat

1:18:24that is another control surface so in in

1:18:28the way that the naked robotic core is

1:18:31the like most pure realization of what

1:18:33what somebody would want for a computing

1:18:35device you know that that was what Apple

1:18:37would want for an iphone i think not

1:18:40that this is a naked robotic or but I

1:18:41feel like this is the most pure

1:18:43realization of what Microsoft hopes for

1:18:46for this world that to me is a little

1:18:50bizarro where you have a touch-based or

1:18:53touch permitted if nothing else desktop

1:18:56OS so Microsoft strategy for many years

1:19:00now with its windows thing especially as

1:19:02the windows phone stuff has been fading

1:19:04has been to have a single OS for all

1:19:08their platforms and because that single

1:19:09OS as part of its family tree is phones

1:19:13and tablet devices that of course it

1:19:15supports touch which is why you can you

1:19:17touch in windows with you know windows 8

1:19:19that started and there the windows 10

1:19:21now and so they've been changing windows

1:19:23to be an interface that you can use with

1:19:26the mouse and keyboard you can use with

1:19:27a pen you can use with your fingers and

1:19:29I've been doing this for a long time

1:19:30and to varying results i know some

1:19:33people have the microsoft surface tablet

1:19:35product that is basically like you can

1:19:37use like a pc with a keyboard attached

1:19:38to because it's got a hinge thing you

1:19:39can use it kind of like a tablet if

1:19:41you're using like a laptop you can also

1:19:42just poke your finger at the screen

1:19:44which I'm sure we've all seen this many

1:19:46people just expect to be able to do that

1:19:47especially younger people or anyone even

1:19:49just use a touch device for a long time

1:19:51they'll switch from an environment where

1:19:53they're using a tablet or phone to

1:19:54laptop and instinctively touch the

1:19:56screen i know i used to do with candles

1:19:58before the touchscreen candles because I

1:20:00spent so much time with iPads I would

1:20:02touch the screen to try to do something

1:20:03on the kindle and of course nothing

1:20:05would happen because they were totally

1:20:06inert like there was no this is before

1:20:07the touch-sensitive ones it is natural

1:20:09to get into that habit and Microsoft has

1:20:11built his entire interface strategy

1:20:14around the idea that all form of input

1:20:17are welcome then it should be supported

1:20:18they've been changing they've been

1:20:20changing windows do not require a

1:20:22perfectly precise mouse pointer or even

1:20:24a stylist to do things to try to make

1:20:26bigger chunkier controls and gestures

1:20:28and stuff like that and this service

1:20:31studio is the biggest this has gotten

1:20:34because previously was like you get

1:20:35tablets and you got these convertible

1:20:37laptop eat things that are like a tablet

1:20:38with the keyboard and yeah of course you

1:20:39can touch the screen and and they have

1:20:42the pen input and all that stuff but

1:20:44this is like 20 inches like this is not

1:20:47a big table this is a full size bigger

1:20:50than most people have is most people do

1:20:52not have 28 inch screens on their pcs

1:20:53full-size personal computer running

1:20:56Windows doesn't pretend to be a tablet

1:20:58you can't take it off and carry like a

1:21:00tablet it's not a big phone like it is a

1:21:02personal computer how that has all the

1:21:06normal inputbox you would want including

1:21:08a pen but then also accepts not just

1:21:12touch but like stop thinking of it as

1:21:14like I'm touching the screen but more

1:21:16like removing in direction because the

1:21:19the mouse and keyboard or indirect input

1:21:21devices and their their wonderful input

1:21:25devices and the very precise and

1:21:27especially the mouse i feel like is the

1:21:29least in directive in direct input

1:21:30devices because if you use the mouse for

1:21:34any appreciable amount of time the

1:21:36interaction disappears very quickly you

1:21:38don't feel like you're driving the mouse

1:21:39vs like say you had a joystick you got a

1:21:42joystick you would feel like you're

1:21:43driving the mask

1:21:44pressure around the screen like it's a

1:21:45little car to get the things you want

1:21:46but if you have a mouse you just

1:21:48basically feel like you're grabbing

1:21:49things on the screen and yes it is

1:21:51indirect you're not touching it is not

1:21:52as direct as touching the screen as

1:21:54anyone who uses an ipad or iphone no

1:21:56it's not that kind of direct but it is

1:21:58like really good video game controls in

1:22:00that very quickly disappears and you

1:22:02stop thinking about the control and just

1:22:04start thinking about the task but the

1:22:07ultimate direct input is like literal

1:22:09direct input as in you see something on

1:22:11the screen

1:22:12you manipulated on the screen with your

1:22:14hands and your fingers or your pen like

1:22:15the same way you would in the

1:22:17pre-computer age if you're doing

1:22:19something that involves putting marks on

1:22:21a piece of paper or shuffling things

1:22:23around put marks on the piece of paper

1:22:25or shuffle things around like do it

1:22:27don't move something that moves another

1:22:28thing on a screen that represents the

1:22:30things you're moving around just get

1:22:31right on that screen and this thing

1:22:33tilting down to like a drafting table

1:22:35type you know angle saying like if

1:22:40you're not doing text input you're not

1:22:41writing a program but instead you're

1:22:43doing anything having to do with visual

1:22:44arts or anything like that

1:22:46turn it down set aside your your

1:22:49keyboard and mouse for now and just get

1:22:51right on that screen it's a huge screen

1:22:53just get right down there you gotta pin

1:22:54you got your fingers you got the little

1:22:55daily thing i can imagine them adding

1:22:57more types of tools so that that to me

1:23:00is the culmination of their strategy of

1:23:04allowing all forms of input by saying

1:23:07here's a form of input that not only do

1:23:09we accept all forms impetigo you can't

1:23:10decide you should concentrate on one

1:23:12it's kind of weird to type and then use

1:23:13a mouse but also touchscreen make remind

1:23:14my click on the button of the mouse

1:23:15person I'm touching my finger my drawing

1:23:17pen what am i doing there are many tasks

1:23:19in which directly interacting with a

1:23:23gigantic screen is the best interface

1:23:25into the task where you put aside all

1:23:28those other tools and say I just want to

1:23:30get right to it and obviously there's a

1:23:31short like artists like that's the most

1:23:33obvious one and this is their first

1:23:35crack at this so maybe it's not as good

1:23:36as it could be

1:23:37people said that this too much parallax

1:23:39because your pen is too far away from

1:23:41like where the pixel are and that

1:23:43there's lag and some of the applications

1:23:44but I really feel like this is almost

1:23:47inevitably the the future of digital art

1:23:51whether Microsoft is going to be the

1:23:53future of digital I don't

1:23:54but like we've gone through the whole

1:23:55thing of using you know using mice to

1:23:58using you know tablets that are in

1:24:01direct input device to do the wacom

1:24:03cintiq which is like a tablet that's

1:24:04also screen it's like just just keep

1:24:07going because people love all those

1:24:09tools and get used to those tools but

1:24:11direct input if you can raise a

1:24:13generation with the expectation that you

1:24:15do your artwork on a giant 28 inch

1:24:16monitor by directly manipulating it that

1:24:20that's going to win in the end with a

1:24:22micro whether it's microsoft for

1:24:23somebody else and Microsoft getting

1:24:25their first is it's nice to see even

1:24:29this is a product is not great and it

1:24:31should be worrying to apple because

1:24:33apple doesn't have anything to compete

1:24:37with this like at all and I don't think

1:24:40Apple can say we really believe that the

1:24:42future of doing digital art is using a

1:24:44cintiq because apple doesn't make those

1:24:46either

1:24:47we really believe the future part is

1:24:48using a mouse or doing everything on you

1:24:51know they have ipads all right so

1:24:53where's your 28 inch iPad that doesn't

1:24:54that you need to plug into the wall like

1:24:56whatever happens going to do i'm not

1:24:57saying they have to make max touchscreen

1:24:58or anything but if they care at all

1:25:00which maybe they don't about the

1:25:02creative arts that involve drawing

1:25:05things even things from like I can

1:25:06imagine cat architectural drawings not

1:25:08just fine arts and and illustration and

1:25:10stuff like that they need to be doing

1:25:14something about this and I was so

1:25:15excited when I can't with the ipad

1:25:16probes like yeah that's what I was

1:25:18talking about you need a really big ipad

1:25:19and go back to listen all those shows

1:25:21from years and years ago I think at some

1:25:24point i did talk about the whole

1:25:25drafting table thing I think we talked

1:25:26about it on this very podcast but also

1:25:28on hypercritical this is it

1:25:30microsoft made it before Apple did Apple

1:25:32did make their ipad bigger but it took a

1:25:34long time to do it and they didn't make

1:25:35it bigger bigger and the idea of an iPad

1:25:38you can take off your desk

1:25:39I remember being laughed at perhaps in

1:25:41the show craft all that was like what

1:25:42the hell's the point an ipad we can move

1:25:43it anywhere this is the point

1:25:45this is the thing so I'm super-proud of

1:25:47microsoft for making this I hope they

1:25:51keep at it i hope they don't say well

1:25:53not a lot of people because i guarantee

1:25:54you now people are going to buy this

1:25:56because it's really expensive and it's

1:25:57like the first generation product and

1:25:59you know truth be told most people don't

1:26:00do fine arts in our computer right but i

1:26:03think this is the right idea for that

1:26:05class of problems

1:26:06and if Apple cares about that class of

1:26:09problems with Apple cares about keeping

1:26:11those creatives and I think to totally

1:26:12think they should because they are

1:26:15another branch of sort of the founding

1:26:16bedrock of Apple's products like

1:26:18creative professionals they need to

1:26:21start putting the air pump into those

1:26:24ipads and cranking up pronto because if

1:26:28they don't someone else is gonna get

1:26:29there first

1:26:30do you have any idea how much I wanted

1:26:32Reebok pumps as a kid my goodness I

1:26:35wanted this so bad

1:26:36you know I don't know I i really i

1:26:39really admire this like you said John I

1:26:42also think that this solves a class of

1:26:44problems that i just don't have which

1:26:47which I mean you kind of set as well but

1:26:48i have a slack team that I mean that's a

1:26:54handful of people that are either

1:26:56current or former employees of my last

1:26:58employer the consulting gig and we were

1:27:01actually when I feel like we have very

1:27:02cyclical conversations and one of them

1:27:05is 0 are touchscreen devices stupid or

1:27:08not

1:27:09and since most of these people are our

1:27:11windows developers most of them have

1:27:13touchscreen windows laptops and all of

1:27:14them swear all my god case you have no

1:27:16idea it's so good and that very well

1:27:18could be the case may be it is that good

1:27:20but having used a handful of touchscreen

1:27:23laptops admittedly very very briefly i

1:27:27have yet to really have it click I've

1:27:30yet to say how oh yeah this does make

1:27:34sense and may be given given a fair shot

1:27:37maybe it would but I don't feel like I

1:27:39want a touchscreen computer to begin

1:27:42with and now you're saying well why

1:27:44wouldn't she want you why not have a

1:27:45touchscreen imac if I was an artist heck

1:27:48yes but as me

1:27:50nay no thanks it's a cool thing to look

1:27:52at you don't want to touch screen laptop

1:27:54like when you phrase it that way like no

1:27:56no

1:27:56who wants to want to touch me I'm just

1:27:58think people find themselves compelled

1:27:59such a screen but no like those things

1:28:01the surface i would say is not a

1:28:03touchscreen laptop it is a tablet with a

1:28:06keyboard apple makes one of those

1:28:07already it's called the ipad it that

1:28:10that's not the ipad is not a touchscreen

1:28:11laptop it is a tablet that comes with

1:28:13the keyboard and using what's the

1:28:14difference well they're both they're

1:28:16both basically the same in use like it's

1:28:18they're open to the same angle this

1:28:20keyboard horizontally and a screen kind

1:28:21of vertically and yes you can touch the

1:28:23screen but you use them in such

1:28:25different ways like well when i'm just

1:28:27using with my hands just not bad but the

1:28:29monitor typing i use the keyboard like I

1:28:31don't know what you want to call that

1:28:32but phrasing it as a lap top of the

1:28:35keyboard sounds like I want to poke my

1:28:37finger is it's not comfortable as

1:28:38Apple's point a million times to to poke

1:28:40a vertical screen is better to use the

1:28:41indirect input devices but i think it's

1:28:44looking at the wrong way he's taking the

1:28:46old the old thing and saying I'm taking

1:28:48the whole thing and modifying by a

1:28:50touchscreen when we take the new thing

1:28:52which is a tablet and modified by adding

1:28:54back a keyboard everyone's okay with it

1:28:55and it's basically the same result and

1:28:57this thing the surface to do i think is

1:28:58like this is not a touchscreen laptop

1:29:01this is also not a touchscreen I'm max

1:29:03I'm max doesn't lay down on the table

1:29:04for you like there's no way he'll you've

1:29:06got in touch screen time that you can't

1:29:07draw on it on an imac the thing doesn't

1:29:09go until it's like 15 degrees and most

1:29:11of them are you know it's close to

1:29:12straight up and down the whole time that

1:29:14is not the service to do the key feature

1:29:16the surface to do that says when you

1:29:18want to do the thing like just like an

1:29:19iPad when you just want to use it like

1:29:20an iPad you don't need the keyboard and

1:29:22the services like when you want to do

1:29:24stuff doesn't involve text input at all

1:29:26like a drawing a picture and doing

1:29:27architectural drawings or like

1:29:29manipulating lines are things in space

1:29:32or whatever and you don't have to use

1:29:34the keyboard lay the whole thing down I

1:29:36think like in the pictures they don't

1:29:37like laying down on top of the keyboard

1:29:39like you doing that see the keyboard

1:29:40it's not there anymore it's like it's

1:29:42the same way the keyboard goes away when

1:29:44you use your iPad like I'm not using the

1:29:46keyboard part of my ipad now i'm just

1:29:47using the ipad part of it and that's in

1:29:49a portable contacts this is the just

1:29:50simply the desktop equivalent of that so

1:29:52i'm not sure what you want to call it

1:29:54and it is weird that Apple's most likely

1:29:56response to this would have to be iOS

1:29:58device and not a mac which is strange

1:30:00because as we talked about in the past

1:30:02Apple's thus far their inability to

1:30:04really get pro level applications to

1:30:07flourish on iOS devices whereas there

1:30:10still kind of doing okay on the mac like

1:30:12that's apples challenge to solve but

1:30:14understand like writ large universe into

1:30:17the future of computing direct

1:30:18manipulation of her task that required

1:30:20on a big gigantic awesome screen the

1:30:23only way that's not going to happen is

1:30:24if a CRNA our advanced to the point

1:30:27where

1:30:28this approach never has a chance to be

1:30:30in you know there's never had this day

1:30:31in the Sun because they are NVR if they

1:30:35get good enough make having a big giant

1:30:37thing that lights up in front of you

1:30:38like archaic but I feel like there will

1:30:40be a time before AR and VR get good

1:30:43where it will be the time of the

1:30:45gigantic touch screens and lay down in

1:30:46front of you and when i'm super old and

1:30:50I'm you know doing computing stuff that

1:30:53doesn't involve typing i would like to

1:30:55have a big gigantic gorgeous screen lay

1:30:57down for me so that I can do stuff on it

1:30:59and also have a keyboard when I do text

1:31:01input and also have to be to recognition

1:31:02also have a bunch of things like pens

1:31:04and stuff I could do on it

1:31:05I'm ready for the Microsoft service to

1:31:07do with 20 years and advancement

1:31:10probably also not a Microsoft you know

1:31:13one thing you mentioned a briefly

1:31:15earlier John is like if they stick with

1:31:18this and that's because of Microsoft you

1:31:21know they throw a lot of spaghetti at

1:31:22the wall they they change strategies

1:31:25often the end and they change desktop

1:31:28initiatives often this product line like

1:31:31many other things Microsoft just tried

1:31:33in recent years might not be good enough

1:31:37for them i might not sell well and offer

1:31:38it might not get a software support it

1:31:41won't sell enough but like you don't you

1:31:43see this is as a like the trend like

1:31:45they've spent all these years making a

1:31:48single OS that accepts all these kinds

1:31:50of input like that's not like a fluke

1:31:51that's not like that's what they've been

1:31:53doing and that's what gives them the

1:31:55option to do things like this I feel

1:31:56like this like that is is this is the

1:31:58culmination of years and years and years

1:32:00of work you can't make this on day one

1:32:01you have to do all the work to make the

1:32:04unified windows it does all the kinds of

1:32:06input to change the windows you want to

1:32:08even be usable with touch to make the

1:32:10device that has a pen that you know that

1:32:11looks like a laptop of the touchscreen

1:32:13you have to do years and used that

1:32:14before you can make this thing so I feel

1:32:16like it's not a fluke sticking with it

1:32:18merely means maybe they were retreat

1:32:20from making their own pcs like maybe a

1:32:22retreat back to the surface or retreat

1:32:24back to tablet or phone sighs things or

1:32:27get out of the business entirely and

1:32:29just do microsoft azure and the license

1:32:31windows the climate because we don't

1:32:32know but I don't I I don't think like

1:32:35they're going to say I actually touching

1:32:37the screen is not a big deal because

1:32:38they just spent so long coming to this

1:32:40point like

1:32:41I feel like they worked hard to to be

1:32:43able to produce a machine like this and

1:32:45this one won't sell well enough to be

1:32:47significant but i think i really think

1:32:48they will take a second and third crack

1:32:50of it and I think of the best microsoft

1:32:53to think of it pains me as I think the

1:32:55head of the company that made the xbox

1:32:57which was a gigantic you know ugly piece

1:33:01of crap but they stuck with it and every

1:33:03new xbox they made it has been better

1:33:04than the previous one and at first i was

1:33:06a really good system but I mean like so

1:33:08i select was huge LOL yep

1:33:10no I i think just because they they've

1:33:13built in all this all this capability

1:33:15for things like touch and pen input you

1:33:18know if if you would have looked at the

1:33:20TV market five years ago you would have

1:33:22thought that 3d TVs were just what

1:33:25everybody wanted and they were taking

1:33:27off like crazy and the novel never

1:33:29thought that obviously the future of TV

1:33:31was going to be 3d but it because if you

1:33:34look at every TV every high-end to even

1:33:37mid range TV you could buy in a store

1:33:39they were all 3d supported TVs but in

1:33:43practice that the reason that feature

1:33:45was being put there was because a

1:33:46stagette industry was trying to add more

1:33:49hardware things to make people upgrade

1:33:51because they weren't upgrading their TVs

1:33:53fast enough so Microsoft i'm putting in

1:33:56all this crazy capability and stuff in

1:33:58the service line all the different input

1:34:00method and everything else it doesn't

1:34:02necessarily mean that everyone is using

1:34:05them or that or that this will be what

1:34:07people how people use their their

1:34:09microsoft computers in the future it

1:34:11might turn out that way but just because

1:34:13the capabilities there just because

1:34:14Microsoft is building all this support

1:34:17and everything is building this hardware

1:34:18that doesn't mean that pc users are

1:34:22going to meaningfully adopted the again

1:34:24they might but that's not a foregone

1:34:27conclusion now is that it's not PC users

1:34:29that are spying this it is creative

1:34:31professional specifically which is a

1:34:32tiny market and out of those people

1:34:34they're not going to buy it because this

1:34:36is like this is like you trying to enter

1:34:37a market that another another company

1:34:40owns or like they're there is already a

1:34:42way to set way to do things and you have

1:34:43a totally different way to do it

1:34:45some people are going to try it but

1:34:46professionals are the least likely to

1:34:48change their ways even if they're

1:34:50already using a Microsoft Windows PC

1:34:52running Photoshop

1:34:53with a tablet whether it's a cintiq or

1:34:56just a plain old tablet even those

1:34:58people aren't gonna buy the surface to

1:35:00do except for on a lark or to be curious

1:35:02about it because they're set in their

1:35:04ways using the Microsoft Windows PC

1:35:05running adobe photoshop with the tablet

1:35:08and they've been doing that the whole

1:35:09career and that's what they like and

1:35:10maybe the curious about this but it's

1:35:12not a big deal but the thing about the

1:35:14future is this is if they stick with it

1:35:16and keep selling this even though

1:35:18they're not making money on it because

1:35:20not enough people buy it

1:35:21eventually i think the market will come

1:35:23around to it because people who start

1:35:25out new might be interested in and try

1:35:27it out and they never got used to using

1:35:28uh you know an online up tablet or the

1:35:32people use antiques might view this is a

1:35:33better cintiq until they try to realize

1:35:35like this antique is a little better

1:35:36visit all these buttons on that they're

1:35:37used to and so that's what it's gonna be

1:35:39a long road and that the other x factor

1:35:42is that people don't like windows or

1:35:44market doesn't like it anyway

1:35:45some people don't happen the way or not

1:35:47and so those people who don't like

1:35:50windows are going to be like well this

1:35:51looks great and all but I don't like

1:35:53Windows i'm not going to do that all the

1:35:54professionals who are using Mac's for

1:35:56example i use photoshop on a mac with

1:35:58the wacom tablet or whatever like you

1:36:01even just talking to see the tweets from

1:36:03dr. wave on on Twitter like is this

1:36:05perfect pixar it's like well actually it

1:36:06picks are people who have these giant

1:36:09tablets drawn to do their 3d work there

1:36:11on like articulated arms and so it's a

1:36:14non-starter for this thing to just

1:36:15beyond a simple hinge that goes on just

1:36:16like that this is just one product and

1:36:18that it doesn't is not as flexible as

1:36:19the products they're already using and

1:36:21they already have a system that works

1:36:22and so this may be novel and interesting

1:36:24but it's not it doesn't work for pics

1:36:25are right but this is this is early days

1:36:29this is a single product from a single

1:36:31company with lots of caveat that are

1:36:32associated with it so i'm not i'm not

1:36:35going to say that this is going to make

1:36:37microsoft the king of the creative

1:36:39professionals but they do have a head

1:36:41start on people and if they keep

1:36:42iterating on this product in this idea

1:36:44and this concept for years and years and

1:36:45years and keep going with this whole OS

1:36:47strategy with touch and maybe make

1:36:49Windows little bit nicer and the process

1:36:51and no one else does anything because

1:36:54who else is there is like linux is going

1:36:56to take over the creative professional

1:36:57market right it's them an apple

1:36:59basically at this point and if apple

1:37:01doesn't move it gives Microsoft time to

1:37:04try and fail and try and fail and try

1:37:05and fail over and over

1:37:06again eventually they'll get pretty

1:37:08decent and now basically win by default

1:37:10if Apple never makes an ipad bigger than

1:37:1212.5 inches and never makes it back like

1:37:14this

1:37:15thanks 143 sponsors this week betterment

1:37:18audible and square space and we will see

1:37:21you next week

1:37:23now the show is over they didn't even

1:37:28mean to be in because it was accidental

1:37:31death was accidental

1:37:34Jonathan

1:37:36research Marco and Casey would know

1:37:40because it was accidental was accidental

1:37:44and you can find the show know today p

1:37:48dot and if your twitter follow them

1:37:57yes byl ISS so that's Casey list and a

1:38:01co-pay rm20 Marco Arment and our AC

1:38:08syracuse it

1:38:22you wanna talk about salads ago and I'm

1:38:27sorry that's not how you pronounce that

1:38:28I had time to research this news broke a

1:38:32couple hours before we started recording

1:38:33that Sal's to go in who he was he was

1:38:38the kind of product manager the head of

1:38:42of mac OS automation technologies so

1:38:45that would include things like Apple

1:38:46script Apple events automator and

1:38:49apparently he has he has been let go of

1:38:52Apple his position has been eliminated

1:38:53so that basically it sure seems like

1:38:56Apple is no longer going to have a head

1:39:00of automation of of apps on Mac OS and a

1:39:03lot of longtime mac users are taking

1:39:05this news to be possibly a pretty bad

1:39:08sign

1:39:09do we wanna talk about this i mean we

1:39:10haven't had time to look into it much I

1:39:11liked it I know it and I know Sal from

1:39:14my reputation and by all the WBC

1:39:17sessions I've seen with them and i have

1:39:18met him in person a couple times a long

1:39:20trade remember me but yeah i'm pretty

1:39:22sure i have to he looks very familiar

1:39:24yeah he knows people you recognize their

1:39:27couple aspects that one is it Sal is

1:39:30just a very nice gregarious charismatic

1:39:33smart person he's got charisma UCM

1:39:36especially if you're a nerd and you're

1:39:38like attracted to smart people right who

1:39:41are interesting and dynamic and have had

1:39:43opinions and can express them well

1:39:44that's out so people who are longtime

1:39:49Apple fans and who have you know knowing

1:39:51him professionally or by reputation or

1:39:53buy his products or presentations are

1:39:55sad to see somebody that everybody liked

1:39:57not be at the company right that so that

1:40:02that's not you know unquestionable

1:40:04aspect of this entire thing because if

1:40:05he was a jerk that everybody hated this

1:40:07would not be as big a story right and

1:40:08then the other part is what you just

1:40:10said about automation automation on the

1:40:13mac which people too short to say like

1:40:15Oh Sally is that Apple script guy that's

1:40:17a reasonable summary of him if you want

1:40:19to go there there's much more to it than

1:40:20that you can read all the stuff one has

1:40:21a website that will put a link in the

1:40:23show notes it's not just Apple script is

1:40:25also shell scripting and apple events

1:40:27that Apple scripting is based on you can

1:40:29do it also different languages and

1:40:30there's the the tooling and involved

1:40:32with that even as recently as like last

1:40:34year the year before that they finally

1:40:35had like a library / framework support

1:40:38for apple scripts you can write

1:40:39applescript libraries and use them like

1:40:40it was kind of stuck in amber for a long

1:40:43time not really getting any better but

1:40:44not really getting any worse but was

1:40:46still an essential part of so many

1:40:47professionals workflows like they would

1:40:50use Apple script to automate the things

1:40:52that they did and it was important to

1:40:54them for their professional applications

1:40:55that were using to have apple script

1:40:57support to be able to do this

1:40:58automator and in you know in the US 10

1:41:00age was this other thing like regular

1:41:03people design sets of actions without

1:41:08having to be programmers you know so

1:41:10automatically that you string together

1:41:11do this and do that and do that without

1:41:13having to like learn languages even the

1:41:15languages as simple as Apple script and

1:41:18his position being eliminated

1:41:22I don't know enough about the internal

1:41:24arrangement but it could just be that

1:41:26like the division has merged for some

1:41:29other division there was another person

1:41:31that Apple likes better who's setting

1:41:32that division so he's out and that

1:41:33person is in but it could also be that

1:41:35and this would totally fit with Apple

1:41:37recent moves and hasn't collecting the

1:41:40mac pro and having difficulty making pro

1:41:42apps and canning aperture and although

1:41:44the stuff that they see using our users

1:41:50creating automations win anything even

1:41:52approaching a programmer like

1:41:54environment whether it be HyperCard rest

1:41:56in peace or automator or writing apples

1:41:59your people skills that is not the

1:42:00future of computing it's too complicated

1:42:03regular people don't want to do it the

1:42:05professionals who want to do it really

1:42:06causing more problems themselves and

1:42:08they're solving really should just allow

1:42:09us to define the workflows by

1:42:10hard-coding into our applications or

1:42:12just buy another application does what

1:42:13they want to stop trying to program it

1:42:15or whatever therefore having an

1:42:17automation division and a product

1:42:18manager of automation that's not the

1:42:20future of the company that's not the

1:42:22future of the mac we don't need that

1:42:23anymore it's a waste of time and

1:42:24resources and it's holding back our

1:42:26other partners that's like the doomsday

1:42:27scenario most pessimistic scenario is

1:42:30that automation is being the emphasized

1:42:32in the same way that writing batch

1:42:34scripts would be emphasized or or you

1:42:36know having to provide programs yourself

1:42:38would be de-emphasized right home and in

1:42:40some it makes some sense like

1:42:42that the market progress has been be

1:42:45emphasizing the need for people who use

1:42:47computers to do stuff like that it used

1:42:49to be you had to enter your programs by

1:42:51typing from the back of a magazine and

1:42:53basically that's how you got your

1:42:54program to run right and no one does

1:42:55that anymore now we have the app store

1:42:56right and a lot of the things that we

1:42:59use automation for hopefully are moved

1:43:02by the fact that programs are just

1:43:03better or the internet does it better or

1:43:05even something as simple as like to

1:43:07thank for iOS workflows get workflow

1:43:11right its third-party opportunity

1:43:13workflows just fine apples need to do we

1:43:15just need to provide the capabilities

1:43:16and apple event itself you can argue

1:43:18with the fact that Apple that's pretty

1:43:19damn old and creaky hit this if you know

1:43:23it could be that it's all being replaced

1:43:24by some bold new vision of automation

1:43:26for the modern age in the same way that

1:43:28Apple script replaced everything that

1:43:29came before it but as with all things

1:43:32apple we don't know big black hole

1:43:35you have no idea what they're planning

1:43:36and we just have fear uncertainty and

1:43:38doubt and once again this is all in the

1:43:40context of Apple fans being grumpy for a

1:43:45bunch of related reasons so it can feel

1:43:47bad but i'm not entirely ready to go all

1:43:50doing loom on this just because it could

1:43:53just be that it's time to turn a new

1:43:55page because Sal and all the texts tech

1:43:58that he was working on and especially

1:43:59foundational attack like Apple events

1:44:01has never really felt like it is fit

1:44:02into the OS 10 world so best-case

1:44:06scenario they're rethinking this all and

1:44:08saying what is automation mean you know

1:44:10from here going forward doesn't mean

1:44:12Apple events or is there better overall

1:44:14system for automating things on the

1:44:17computer so worst-case Tim Cook says

1:44:19anything stupid when you do that anymore

1:44:21people just tap their me little fingers

1:44:23on screens and not worry about it

1:44:25yeah I never really i never really wrote

1:44:27much apple script I did real early on

1:44:31when I first got my mac to do i don't

1:44:35know like some silly basic things I

1:44:37forget exactly what it was for was like

1:44:38maybe setting default printer or

1:44:40something like that and this was like in

1:44:42two thousand eight ish and I personally

1:44:45never really gone back and had a need to

1:44:47write more now I know there's tons of

1:44:49people who write it a lot and use it

1:44:52heavily but

1:44:54for me this this is not something I'm

1:44:57terribly worried about and not something

1:44:58that i use terribly often but it also

1:45:01does make me a little bit that if this

1:45:02is a canary in a coal mine in the coal

1:45:04mine for automation in OS for mac OS it

1:45:08bummed me out if that went away but I

1:45:10wouldn't say would necessarily affect my

1:45:12day-to-day either

1:45:13I mean it's more about like it's a it's

1:45:17a very very powerful set of features you

1:45:20know what Apple script the language is

1:45:22kind of you know that's just the

1:45:23implementation detail of it there's but

1:45:25the the system on which it's based that

1:45:28exposes Apple events and and control of

1:45:30applications automation about of other

1:45:32applications you know through this

1:45:34entire API that can be any language you

1:45:36need to be and there's a there's many

1:45:37things that that exposed to as different

1:45:40languages like like at the jazz talk

1:45:42makes it javascript there's a few other

1:45:44things like that you know it's it's more

1:45:47than this that feature set while it is

1:45:51used by probably a very tiny percentage

1:45:53of mac users the amount of power it

1:45:57gives is so great that you know this

1:46:01really the mac OS one of the things i

1:46:03love so much about mac OS is that it is

1:46:06just so incredibly powerful

1:46:09I mean that it deeply like it is

1:46:12incredibly powerful if you know how did

1:46:16how did how to use its power like there

1:46:18isn't there it is it is in every sense

1:46:20of the word a true workstation OS and as

1:46:23I said my macpro post like OS 10 is

1:46:26awesome and to remove or or two to let

1:46:32rot or to deprecate a major area of of

1:46:36power from it

1:46:37I can see why people are worried about

1:46:39that and Johnny no I agree it it does

1:46:42seem like things are moving away from

1:46:44that and from that direction in consumer

1:46:48software design mostly by Apple's doing

1:46:51by the way I expected it's not like the

1:46:53whole interview is mostly Apple doing

1:46:55this but it was in many ways there's to

1:46:58lose and they really had amazing

1:46:59automation features that were fairly

1:47:02accessible to people like programmers

1:47:05will always find ways to automate things

1:47:07the most extreme power users will always

1:47:09find ways to automate things but one of

1:47:11the things that made this area of OS 10

1:47:14so powerful is that it was really quite

1:47:17accessible to lots of people a whole lot

1:47:19of people who are not programmers were

1:47:21able to use things like automator to

1:47:24automate really you know really

1:47:26time-consuming tasks that then freed

1:47:29them up to to have the computer do with

1:47:31computers supposed to do you know that

1:47:33the kind of power that usually you have

1:47:34to be a programmer to have many people

1:47:37were given this power by the by this

1:47:39system is infrastructure so the loss of

1:47:43it I i think is certainly cause for

1:47:46concern if if you love the mac operating

1:47:50system as much as i do for for the for

1:47:52this power that it's always had and you

1:47:54know as like I'll be fine because i'm a

1:47:56programmer i can use bash and scrape

1:47:59something up or actually write a write

1:48:01an app to do things if I need to

1:48:02automate them which i do all the time I

1:48:04hardly ever use these technologies

1:48:05because i usually just right shell

1:48:07scripts and stuff instead but a lot of

1:48:10people use these I think and even get

1:48:12percentage-wise I'm sure it's very small

1:48:14but still that still could be like

1:48:17thousands of people who rely on this to

1:48:19to save them like hours of time a week

1:48:22or two do something that would just be

1:48:23impractical to do otherwise

1:48:24so yeah you know I I feel the word this

1:48:28that being said we still there's a lot

1:48:31about this that we still don't know you

1:48:33know all we know is that this this guy

1:48:36with his job was cut apparently we don't

1:48:39know why we don't know you know maybe

1:48:42they're just reorganizing the Department

1:48:45of whatever it said I don't know how

1:48:47this is organized decide maybe that

1:48:48maybe just you know a reorg maybe it's

1:48:50like you know weird cost-cutting

1:48:52measures maybe it might come back to

1:48:54later who knows it

1:48:55maybe it was just like a personal

1:48:56conflict maybe there's a new team doing

1:48:59basically like maybe also there's

1:49:00overlap because right you know we have

1:49:02this automation system but maybe this

1:49:04with people like I told you want you to

1:49:05be able to script your applications with

1:49:07weapon we have this project and maybe

1:49:08that project wins and so this will be

1:49:10the legacy version of automation and

1:49:12then this will come another one I was

1:49:13thinking about in terms of how do you

1:49:15get people who can't program to be able

1:49:16to do simple automation stuff

1:49:18I always feel like the people who are

1:49:20good at using automator an apple script

1:49:22are either basically programmers are

1:49:24ready and they don't know it or could be

1:49:26programmers within 15 minutes because to

1:49:29use even though the automator is way

1:49:30easier than coding the people who use it

1:49:33as part of the job they they eventually

1:49:35can't avoid basically becoming programs

1:49:38they don't know their programs i think

1:49:39they just click buttons but they're

1:49:40learning conditionals loops logic

1:49:43input/output like that they're just

1:49:46learning what programmers would consider

1:49:48to be an awful programming languages

1:49:50just clicking a bunch of buttons around

1:49:51right which is like let me just write

1:49:52the code right but that's because he

1:49:54also excel Wizards yeah exactly right

1:49:57but another way you could do that is how

1:50:01do you have how do you get

1:50:03non-programmers to be able to make the

1:50:04computer to do busy work that

1:50:06programmers know how to make them do

1:50:07another way to do it would be to have a

1:50:10conversation with the computer and

1:50:11describe what you want to have the

1:50:12computer do it so a much much much much

1:50:14much much much more advanced Syria you

1:50:19could say serious discussion i want you

1:50:24to take all the when photos arrived in

1:50:26his folder i want you to take all that

1:50:27your lieutenant named them yet

1:50:29rename them with the date and and you

1:50:34know tag them with this label and put

1:50:36them into this folder something you

1:50:38could do with hazel or with automator

1:50:39resize them all to be this size or

1:50:41whatever blah blah and Syria we go back

1:50:44and forth you mean like this giving you

1:50:45a preview what you're going to say ok if

1:50:47i was to do it this is what i would do

1:50:48is the book what you wanted like all it

1:50:50would be doing behind the scenes using

1:50:51the automation machinery that's already

1:50:53there and all the automation you're able

1:50:55to do for like images easy because they

1:50:56have so many tools like resizing images

1:50:58or are you know changing the EXIF data

1:51:00or renaming files like that's all

1:51:03easy to do all you need to do is figure

1:51:05out a way to express the computer what

1:51:07you want and if you can have a

1:51:08conversation with even a pretty stupid

1:51:10series that is never less hundreds of

1:51:11times smarter than it is now to go back

1:51:14and forth eventually series could figure

1:51:16out essentially here's the automator

1:51:18action would have built only we built it

1:51:20together by having a conversation that

1:51:21is certainly a much more advanced much

1:51:24brighter and I think attainable future

1:51:26of letting all people automate stuff so

1:51:28for all we know maybe the future

1:51:30automation is

1:51:31and we're all wrapped up in the series

1:51:33team and they have grand plans to do

1:51:34that I wish them luck because so far

1:51:36they haven't really shown me anything

1:51:38but it could be done and so maybe you

1:51:41know like things that we don't know

1:51:42what's going on Apple it could just be

1:51:44rear or we could just be emerging type

1:51:46thing it but I i have i have hope that

1:51:51even if Apple has decided that every

1:51:54single technology the salads on his

1:51:55website is the past of automation that I

1:51:58have some hope that Apple believes that

1:52:00there is something else that is the

1:52:01future of automation because like you

1:52:03said Marko people want to use their

1:52:05computers to do complicated things but

1:52:08if they're not programmers don't want to

1:52:10become programmers that we have to find

1:52:11a way to let them do that like a gentle

1:52:13slope to get them to be able to do that

1:52:16because they will be happier with their

1:52:17computers and we'll find more

1:52:18indispensable even if they good for

1:52:20something as simple as you know when i

1:52:24get an email like this extract the image

1:52:26attachment put in this folder rename it

1:52:27this way and then send me a text message

1:52:30about it or do whatever like when you

1:52:33show

1:52:34normal people that they can make some of

1:52:36that work they think it is the greatest

1:52:37thing in the world because they're

1:52:38basically like someone's on the chat

1:52:40rooms like a gateway drug to programming

1:52:42or they never actually go through the

1:52:44gate they just stay outside of and go

1:52:45this is great my computer knows what I

1:52:46want

1:52:48which i think is great so I I think

1:52:50they're still need for non-programmers

1:52:52to be able to automate things in their

1:52:54computer but i'm willing to believe that

1:52:56there is a better way