0:00:00are either of you watching a new top
0:00:02gear know what I want to do that so I'm
0:00:06just very slowly and I watched episode 2
0:00:09I think i'm on 322 is no good
0:00:12three is where it starts to take a turn
0:00:13in a good one but two is to is the one
0:00:15where they review the big yellow Ferrari
0:00:17right I yes I believe that's right away
0:00:21and Rose well yeah but this the Epsom
0:00:23still no good
0:00:24however the 3 through 5 are much
0:00:28improved was watching so Marco
0:00:31definitely don't even bother with 123
0:00:335050 i would say yes so 60 40 45
0:00:38definitely if you have time worth
0:00:40watching
0:00:41I think I'll just start like this season
0:00:43this plus 1 and just tell me when that
0:00:46Tony that's good parent
0:00:48we should probably start with some
0:00:51follow-up and is it
0:00:53linux or Linus always get it wrong
0:00:55Torvalds heads them said some things to
0:00:57say to you John of all people about hfs+
0:01:00wasn't to me really this was the thing I
0:01:03was looking for a last week I said that
0:01:05a contestar walls had said unkind things
0:01:07about hfs+ because he had a run-in with
0:01:10it as it relates to the good version
0:01:12control system and I googled for it and
0:01:16I found this exact URL but I mean it's
0:01:18like a bear blind is a google plus
0:01:19blindness this is a google but all that
0:01:22that can't be it i thought he had a blog
0:01:24post or something I just ignored this
0:01:26this google busing it turns out that his
0:01:28little I don't know if this is the
0:01:30origin but this is another place where
0:01:32he complained about isn't a comment on
0:01:34google+ page so it's basically invisible
0:01:35as far as the civilized world is
0:01:37concerned anyway I think I noticed it
0:01:40because I think he did with the
0:01:41equivalent of at mentioning me there and
0:01:43I probably got some notification and
0:01:44google+ back when I was still paying
0:01:45attention to google glass and we'll put
0:01:48a link in the show notes remember when
0:01:50you go to the link
0:01:50there's no way to directly link to this
0:01:52comment as far as i could tell you just
0:01:53have to scroll until you see his name
0:01:55and the substance of it doesn't really
0:01:58matter that much as we talked about last
0:01:59week it's more if you want to see the
0:02:02things that people both love and hate
0:02:04about the linux kernel and linus
0:02:08torvalds and and just those communities
0:02:11how he just says everything in sort of a
0:02:12rude dismissive way like the HMS pluses
0:02:15actively designed to be bad by people
0:02:19who thought they had good ideas and they
0:02:20should just very pasty eaters and they
0:02:23have no idea what they're doing
0:02:24it's it's very rude like you can say all
0:02:27the same things about being rude and
0:02:28that's a topic that's come up a lot and
0:02:30open source communities like some people
0:02:33enjoy that like drawn to keep it real
0:02:35and other people like I don't want to
0:02:36hang out with a bunch of people who are
0:02:38jerks to each other right can we not
0:02:39talk about technical issues without
0:02:41calling people names
0:02:43i stalled can't that's too bad
0:02:47anyway they're so just following up from
0:02:50last weekend closing the circle on why
0:02:52hfs+ makes people angry and you can see
0:02:55it's basically about he really doesn't
0:02:57like NFD to do the decomposed normalized
0:03:00form from unicode even though address
0:03:02what plus doesn't use the exact NFD
0:03:04format used actually a variant but he
0:03:06really hates that entirely like you
0:03:08think that just shouldn't exist and no
0:03:09one should ever use it and he doesn't
0:03:11like the fact that normalize and he
0:03:12doesn't like the fact that this case
0:03:13insensitive so he's really got a lot of
0:03:16complaints about hfs+ go figure
0:03:19but because he liked the king of not
0:03:21invented here syndrome not invented here
0:03:23is just like he's totally he would i
0:03:26would imagine he would be in the camp
0:03:27for it's like why the process of doing
0:03:29anything to my finally why is it trying
0:03:31to do something stupid it should not be
0:03:33messing with my file name it should just
0:03:35do it should just be simple and then
0:03:36unix-like and sort of worse is better
0:03:39all of your system call fails just tried
0:03:41again you'll get an error code that
0:03:42tells you that you better check the area
0:03:43code just check it so simple i think
0:03:45that's you know it's a bag bites just
0:03:47put whatever but you want and you don't
0:03:48know what it means your own stupid fault
0:03:50now i'm doing my weird pretend my star
0:03:53walled voice but that would be my guess
0:03:55is that you have a voice but yeah
0:03:58philosophically he seems to be in the
0:04:00camp that things should be simpler and
0:04:04it's kind of a violation of the contract
0:04:07for the file system to take your
0:04:08filename and do something weird with it
0:04:10fair enough tell me about integrity
0:04:12checker this is the program I was trying
0:04:14to think of the already existing
0:04:15long-standing program that will wander
0:04:18you get your mac discs and
0:04:20write out a bunch check some files and
0:04:23then check that your files haven't
0:04:24changed its from digital Lloyd tools
0:04:27from Mac performance guide will put a
0:04:31link in the show notes i believe it's
0:04:33sprinkles a bunch of dicey files all
0:04:36over your disk a lot of these things
0:04:37that you check sums do something like
0:04:39this that they'll either want to modify
0:04:40your files by adding an extended at read
0:04:42although want to sprinkle a bunch of
0:04:43files all of your disk with check sums
0:04:45in them and there's advantages and
0:04:47disadvantages that the advantages that
0:04:48you can't lose like all your check sums
0:04:52at once like the checksums go along with
0:04:54the directory can move the directory to
0:04:56check something that goes along with it
0:04:57if one of the files gets corrupted you
0:04:59don't lose the all your check sums like
0:05:01it has advantages over a central
0:05:02database but the disadvantage of course
0:05:04is that you get a bunch of these little
0:05:05turkey file sprinkle over your hard
0:05:07drive so you'd be hesitant to point it
0:05:10just an arbitrary directory tree because
0:05:11you'd be like am I going to make some
0:05:13program angry or confused by putting a
0:05:15bunch of these files in the directory
0:05:17that they don't expect to be there but
0:05:20you can check it out it apparently uses
0:05:22sha-1 check sums and in my quest to
0:05:26remember this this to lots of other
0:05:28people sent in other tools saying is
0:05:30just one you're thinking of is when
0:05:31you're thinking of integrity checker was
0:05:34the one I was thinking about a few other
0:05:35ones came up
0:05:36there's a chick bit which is a a note of
0:05:41module that does something similar and
0:05:43apparently they ran out of vows so it's
0:05:45eh kbit will put a link to that in the
0:05:47show notes if you want to use a
0:05:49javascript to do you check something I
0:05:50hear your snark there
0:05:52yeah well it's not bad that is a bunch
0:05:54of tools around par to move based on the
0:05:58P archive format and party was just a
0:06:01second version of it and this is sort of
0:06:04a next step up where instead of just
0:06:06writing a check sums it will write out
0:06:08parody files to correct errors that
0:06:11defined so won't just write the check
0:06:13something know there's an error to
0:06:14essentially do sort of like the same
0:06:15thing that like a raid5 does not the
0:06:18same algorithm or more fancy algorithms
0:06:21for adding parody information so that if
0:06:23you do detect some corruption you can
0:06:25correct it and you just tell it what
0:06:27percentage of your disk space you want
0:06:28to dedicate the parity information so
0:06:30you could dedicate say five percent of
0:06:32of
0:06:32the of your disk space like if you have
0:06:34a director as a hundred megs you can say
0:06:35okay I'm allowing you to use five
0:06:37megabytes just or parody information so
0:06:40that you can recover from one or two or
0:06:41three bit errors or whatever that you
0:06:43find in corruption so that's that's
0:06:44again it's like a user space version of
0:06:46the kind of protection rate might
0:06:49provide you or or something like CFS
0:06:51with a duplicate the data and duplicate
0:06:53the check sums and all that stuff now so
0:06:55if you hypothetically have ever found a
0:06:58file that's fallen off the back of a
0:07:00truck
0:07:01you might have seen parts use associated
0:07:03with that depending on which truck you
0:07:05happen to have found that file on the
0:07:06backup for falling off the backup well
0:07:08only only if you found it on the back of
0:07:10a really old truck he had a very very
0:07:14old truck it were talking like model
0:07:16Tiero even though those old trucks are
0:07:18still running and no one really knows
0:07:19about them and it's amazing but yeah
0:07:21it's a really old truck ahead it's true
0:07:24just talking about pirated files on
0:07:26usenet why would they use the use the
0:07:28original part of why would they use
0:07:29parody information are they trying to I
0:07:32know nothing of this John but if I did
0:07:34know just know something of this i
0:07:36believe its part to me and i believe the
0:07:38rationale is suppose you split up your
0:07:40file on a whole bunch of little ancient
0:07:42trucks you're missing one truck one
0:07:44truck didn't make it that you have like
0:07:46400 other trucks and you have like two
0:07:48part trucks and hearts can replace any
0:07:53of the missing other four hundred trucks
0:07:54yeah so then you can put back together
0:07:56you're really big truck you're trying to
0:07:58assemble so you can finally watch the
0:08:00new top gear america this is the best i
0:08:05love you guys
0:08:06alright what is that Tony gray have to
0:08:08say and hungry tweeted that he
0:08:10apparently is is in the process of
0:08:13trying to make ahfs check some utility
0:08:16as well so he was when he heard us
0:08:17talking about it is like so this is
0:08:21again I said it's not a new idea their
0:08:23existing applications that do it and
0:08:25they're even applications that have not
0:08:26given recent release to do it and of
0:08:29course all which makes me even less
0:08:31inclined even start this project but i
0:08:33can tell you that all these different
0:08:35tools that i looked at none of them does
0:08:37it exactly the way I want
0:08:38do it but it doesn't mean i'll ever
0:08:39actually find the time to make this
0:08:41program will see how is it possible that
0:08:44like I'm going to be a mac programmer
0:08:45before you are no i-i've good
0:08:48programming on the mac toolbox back in
0:08:51the day and made a silly little programs
0:08:53that did nothing so i think i'd be to do
0:08:54it
0:08:55you're probably in what elementary
0:08:56school anyway yeah most likely
0:08:58you haven't seen ya the handle window
0:08:59dragging yourself when he didn't get it
0:09:01free
0:09:02mark what do you want your winner to be
0:09:04draggable you better get the dragon vent
0:09:06talk about barbera otherwise you'd want
0:09:09your application will be a window on the
0:09:11screen you couldn't move it grab a towel
0:09:13bar and wouldn't rush Mac toolbox yay we
0:09:17respond to this week by Casper and
0:09:19obsessively engineered mattress and
0:09:21shockingly fair price go to Casper calm
0:09:23/ ATP and use code ATP for fifty dollars
0:09:27towards your mattress castro created one
0:09:30perfect mattress sold directly to
0:09:32consumers eliminating Commission driven
0:09:34inflated prices
0:09:35its award-winning mattress was developed
0:09:37in house with a sleek design and is
0:09:39delivered in a remarkably small box you
0:09:41can get it up narrow stairs and now in
0:09:44addition of the mattress they also offer
0:09:45an adaptive pillow and soft breathable
0:09:48sheets all from Casper now the mattress
0:09:50industry has forced consumers into paint
0:09:51aureus lehigh markups Casper is
0:09:54revolutionising the industry by cutting
0:09:55the cost of dealing with retailers and
0:09:57showrooms and pass that savings directly
0:09:58onto you and in-house team of engineers
0:10:01spent thousands of hours developing the
0:10:03Casper mattress it combines springy
0:10:05latex and supportive memory foams for
0:10:08asleep service with just the right sink
0:10:09and just the right bounce and it's
0:10:11breathable design sleep school to help
0:10:14you regulate your temperature throughout
0:10:15the night all this is available for a
0:10:18shockingly fair price now good
0:10:20mattresses usually cost above $1,500 but
0:10:23a caster mattress cost just 544 twin 854
0:10:27Queen 954 king and these even if those
0:10:31prices are made in America now Casper
0:10:34understands buying a mattress online
0:10:36sounds a little bit crazy how do you
0:10:38know if you're gonna like it what
0:10:39happens if you don't like how do you
0:10:40return it how does it deliver so
0:10:42delivers as mentioned in a very small
0:10:44box you can get it up steps you can move
0:10:45in the house it is very small and then
0:10:47you open the box and expands outward by
0:10:49sucking all the air in the room
0:10:51so don't worry there's still some for
0:10:52you but it's done it's looking a lot of
0:10:53them into that mattress that's a really
0:10:55nice compressed box and free delivery
0:10:58you want that you don't pay for that
0:10:59amazing little box or the delivery and
0:11:02you sleep on it for a hundred knights
0:11:04and if you don't like it you call them
0:11:06up and they will pick it up at your
0:11:09house and give you a full refund
0:11:11it's a hundred knight risk-free trial
0:11:13period and a free painless return if you
0:11:16need it
0:11:17they understand the importance of
0:11:18actually sleeping on a mattress before
0:11:20you commit especially continue going to
0:11:21be spending a third of your life on it
0:11:23so try today go to castro calm / ATP to
0:11:27try the casper mattresses for a hundred
0:11:29Knights risk-free in your own home sleep
0:11:31on it for over three months free
0:11:33delivery free returns with home pick up
0:11:36once again go to Casper calm / ATP and
0:11:38use code ATP for fifty dollars towards
0:11:41your mattress thanks to capture for
0:11:42sponsoring our show
0:11:43ah alright kids we did not cover all of
0:11:49the Apple platform filesystem no stop
0:11:53saying platformers Apple file says them
0:11:54why is that why is that still alive
0:11:56because there's a pee in there it's at
0:11:58Paul a mac OS a nap pool file system
0:12:02Nicolas Cage come on you don't you don't
0:12:06get that don't pretend you get that
0:12:07anyway tell me about space sharing John
0:12:09while we talk about these last remaining
0:12:11a PFS topics you guys to think of some
0:12:13of us the show otherwise we're going to
0:12:15do how to handle email or screen time
0:12:17for kids we can talk about top here some
0:12:19more that just I think we did actually
0:12:21talk about these in a post deputies you
0:12:22think I thought about them a little bit
0:12:24more space sharing is the first one
0:12:27where I forget the terminology like a
0:12:30container for a PFS then you can put a
0:12:32bunch of different volumes in it but you
0:12:33don't have to partition it just make one
0:12:36big giant container and then you can
0:12:38make as many volumes as you want and
0:12:39every single volume seize the entire
0:12:41size of the container which seems weird
0:12:45but it's it's great so you don't have to
0:12:48do that you know in your experiment
0:12:49still think of how big should i make the
0:12:51user partition how big their make the /
0:12:53partition you don't have to think ahead
0:12:55of time about how much room something is
0:12:58going to take up if you have a large
0:12:59volume you want to divide up between
0:13:01multiple uses you
0:13:04just let them go at it and they will
0:13:05find their natural equilibrium or one of
0:13:07the mold grow too fast you'll be
0:13:08disappointed you wish you could
0:13:09partition it but I think you'll still be
0:13:11able to make multiple containers like
0:13:12old style partitions I'm tried it anyway
0:13:16that's interesting from a UI perspective
0:13:19because got the same problems drobo had
0:13:21like Woodrow would show you how much
0:13:23space would show much larger amount of
0:13:25space that was actually available like
0:13:27to for example the time machine if you
0:13:28doing time machine to a drobo and as
0:13:30time machine ran eventually you know the
0:13:32driver would just run out of space but
0:13:33time machine can't predict that because
0:13:34i can't really get an accurate read on
0:13:35how much space there really is because
0:13:37of the similar space sharing type thing
0:13:39that was a multi-disc situation but
0:13:40anyway I don't know how you show space
0:13:44sharing to the user you just show them
0:13:45and I'm assuming like oh I've got one
0:13:48terabyte drive with three volumes on it
0:13:493 1 terabyte volumes and if you get info
0:13:51on each of those three volumes they also
0:13:53yep I'm am one terabyte volume and I
0:13:55have this much free I don't know you can
0:13:59show that in a sensible way but i'm glad
0:14:00the future exists because i like the
0:14:02idea of not having to think about it
0:14:03ahead of time and make fixed-size
0:14:06partitions although I'm not sure that's
0:14:07the thing people do anymore d the
0:14:09morning you have any of your disk
0:14:10partition or do you have more than one
0:14:12disk i do have more than one disk i
0:14:14don't have the partition at all and i
0:14:16think one way you can do this maybe is
0:14:19with the with network drives at least
0:14:21they have the quota system but this is
0:14:23how this is how technologies time
0:14:25machine hosting module works where and I
0:14:29should point out again i think i've said
0:14:30this before but I've done many different
0:14:32ways of time machine backup from direct
0:14:34attacks discs to a mac mini server
0:14:36running OS 10 server with Time Machine
0:14:38server on that to this analogy thing
0:14:41I've never used a time capsule but
0:14:43otherwise everything else I've done and
0:14:45the the synology system is by far the
0:14:49most reliable with time machine I've
0:14:50never had to like format the whole
0:14:52partition and start again because time
0:14:54machine kept thinking it was full look
0:14:56at that happened with literally every
0:14:57other method tried never happened with
0:14:59the synology one and what i have is but
0:15:02what seems like a pretty complex setup
0:15:03which is a single i believe a terabyte
0:15:06volume that is split between me and tiff
0:15:10and each of us connect to it with a
0:15:11different username and each user name
0:15:13has a 50-percent space quota on that
0:15:15volume
0:15:16and we both Phillip or become very close
0:15:19to filling it much of the time and it's
0:15:22fine like it has never aired out time
0:15:25machine always keep up-to-date so you
0:15:27know what I do this is a complete
0:15:28diversion but huge recommendation for
0:15:31using the time machine thing on
0:15:32technologies because it's amazing
0:15:34although one better i have the same i
0:15:36have not a single but i have a time
0:15:38machine volume and I think Sal channel
0:15:40if you have one time machine volume i
0:15:41think that's actually like a rate a raid
0:15:43set at this point because it's bigger
0:15:44than any one of my single discs and i
0:15:47have three or four different computers
0:15:50back after time machine and I'll do
0:15:51anything with quotas I just let them run
0:15:53interesting they just kind of fight it
0:15:55out
0:15:55I don't know what they're doing all i
0:15:57know is it never bothers me the backup
0:15:58is complete successfully you can recover
0:16:00files from it
0:16:01I I think they just you know when one of
0:16:03them sees that the thing is filling the
0:16:04trim they're all backups you know like
0:16:06it's as far as I'm concerned it's magic
0:16:09yes I don't do anything with the quotas
0:16:10it's a free-for-all it's just like
0:16:11whoever whichever time machine backup in
0:16:14the pit getting close to the end of the
0:16:15disk it says it's time for me to trim
0:16:17some all backups and it does that it's
0:16:19cooperative time machining nice yeah i
0:16:23would i would double down what you guys
0:16:25said as well i have to physical disks
0:16:27that are joined in whatever the raid is
0:16:29that is non redundant because it's 0
0:16:32yep and so so i have two discs joined
0:16:35raid0 yeah i do the quota thing that
0:16:37Marcos talking about i have yet to have
0:16:39an issue outside of a disk failure which
0:16:42is beyond serologies control but not
0:16:44it's worked really well for me
0:16:46well how did we get on this subject
0:16:47weirdo Johnny asked if we partition
0:16:49stuff i have not partitioned any mac of
0:16:53owned ever to the best of my
0:16:55recollection I've never done even boot
0:16:58camp which you would think i would have
0:16:59given my prior profession but I always
0:17:01just used the m's I used to aggressively
0:17:04partition my my actual physical windows
0:17:07machines in the past i remember since
0:17:10ever I would have liked my OS drive and
0:17:12then my like data drive and then
0:17:14applications drive thinking that if I
0:17:17ever wanted to put on a different OS
0:17:18like a new version windows whatever then
0:17:20all that other stuff could just remain
0:17:21where it was and in reality that has
0:17:24never been the case ever ever ever
0:17:26ever yeah i mean with Windows I would do
0:17:28the same thing because if your windows
0:17:30power user you you get into the habit of
0:17:33like just maybe once a year just
0:17:35reformat your system drive and put it
0:17:37all back and start start clean because
0:17:38with Windows you basically have to do
0:17:41that to have a welcoming system and once
0:17:43I moved to max I i think i've done that
0:17:45literally like since the time I started
0:17:47using Mac's in 2004 i think i started
0:17:51clean twice in an entire time
0:17:54yeah i think my first time since 08 was
0:17:57when I got the imac and then I was much
0:18:00more piecemeal about it rather than just
0:18:01transferring everything but let you know
0:18:03they doing that migration system style
0:18:05thing but anyway yeah so that was an
0:18:08extraordinarily long answer the question
0:18:10John asked which ones do you guys
0:18:11partition your drives and john i'm
0:18:13assuming use you you did so you do or
0:18:15you you're going to say you do I assume
0:18:17yeah I do I'm not my main drive but i
0:18:20have somebody drive to accept this
0:18:21they're all split up into little pieces
0:18:22mostly because the drives are so big
0:18:24it'd be a waste to dedicate think I'm
0:18:26not gonna dedicate one terabyte boot
0:18:28camp right so that drivers split up and
0:18:30other drives like I just divided into
0:18:32two pieces and it i I've never done a
0:18:35separate user directory a lot of people
0:18:37do that like they have their home
0:18:38directory and all their files on
0:18:39onedrive and then like basically a boot
0:18:41drive with the OS on it in their
0:18:44applications and I never quite
0:18:45understood that split and any time I
0:18:47ever try to spell like that back in the
0:18:48old days very tiny hard drives
0:18:50I always got it wrong like you try to
0:18:52guess how big everything is and give
0:18:53room for growth and if you guess wrong
0:18:56on the operating system is like you know
0:18:57system 7.5 point 5 comes out and it's a
0:19:01little bit bigger and you know just it's
0:19:03so easy to get that messed up so i i'm i
0:19:07think i will use something like this
0:19:08because i have things partition now and
0:19:10I realize if I ever got close to you
0:19:12know my space constraints i would have
0:19:14all this wasted space and you can resize
0:19:15partitions to some degree but it's not
0:19:17as flexible as you want so i think i
0:19:19will use spacefaring I won't be confused
0:19:20by the size stuff and I suppose other
0:19:24people normal people who would be
0:19:25computed just never partition anything
0:19:26so maybe it's a non-issue
0:19:28but speaking of time machine that's
0:19:30doesn't aps thing related that first of
0:19:32all you can use time machine with a BFS
0:19:33right now but that's obviously a
0:19:34temporary condition a PFS doesn't
0:19:37provide any
0:19:38particular new features that make it
0:19:40easier for you to answer the question
0:19:43hey what's happened since the last time
0:19:45I ran a backup in a little bit like it's
0:19:48basically still going to have to use
0:19:49something like as events where any i/o
0:19:52that goes through the colonel is logged
0:19:54in some fashion and then you can find
0:19:55out what has changed since the last time
0:19:57you ran I and you probably the same API
0:20:00is put in a similar fashion so it
0:20:01doesn't have something like CFS is a
0:20:03give me the block tips since last time
0:20:05and even if it had that even though the
0:20:07super-efficient doesn't quite work with
0:20:09time machines you why because time you
0:20:10want to exclude things and if you do
0:20:12anything at the block level you don't
0:20:13you can't be excluding as easily as you
0:20:16know based on file path or whatever so
0:20:19AP US doesn't give any advantages time
0:20:21machine in terms of that kind of
0:20:23efficiency but it does give lots of
0:20:24advantages in terms of making a
0:20:27consistent backup we talked about this
0:20:28before and every researcher with
0:20:30snapshots where time machine can take a
0:20:33snapshot of the drive as exists in a
0:20:35certain state and then just slowly back
0:20:36up front from that snapshot so it won't
0:20:39have to worry about like time machine
0:20:40ran for three hours and it's the run
0:20:43started backing up backed up these files
0:20:45but these files at backup three hours
0:20:47later so you have this weird mixture of
0:20:49different time periods and then it's
0:20:51like painting the golden gate bridge or
0:20:52whatever you got to go back to the
0:20:53beginning and find any towels to change
0:20:55you
0:20:55you're waiting for this period this sort
0:20:57of period of quiet when things have
0:20:58settled down
0:20:59don't worry about that was not just take
0:21:00a snapshot backup from their destroy the
0:21:02snapshot when you're done that will be
0:21:04great and also for the purpose of this
0:21:09is the next thing for the purpose of
0:21:10making multiple backups where the files
0:21:14that haven't changed the same sort of
0:21:15the time machine models you can go to
0:21:16the finder and browse your backups and
0:21:18they all look like complete copies of
0:21:20your data but of course they're not
0:21:21storing the unchanged data multiple
0:21:23times using hard links so hard links to
0:21:25files and harlington directories but
0:21:27you're gross and weird
0:21:28you don't have to have those anymore
0:21:29because of the the copyright stuff that
0:21:32a PFS has and you can do clones where
0:21:35you can clone an entire directory and so
0:21:38this entire directory tree make a copy
0:21:40of it but not really like it you can do
0:21:42it like basically in constant time
0:21:43you're not actually copying everything
0:21:45you just saying now there are two of
0:21:46these and they are independent copies if
0:21:47you would go into the copy and modify a
0:21:49file you're not modifying the file in
0:21:51both places like you would
0:21:52with a hard link or something it's
0:21:54copy-on-write so as soon as you modify
0:21:55one of the change files then they start
0:21:57to diverge but the actual copy operation
0:21:59is just a clone operation it'sit's very
0:22:02very fast one of the demos they did in
0:22:03the wwc session something that some
0:22:07people paranoid because they're like
0:22:08well frequently when I'm working on
0:22:10something i'll go to the finder and like
0:22:11duplicate it and like put the other one
0:22:13off to the side like poor man's version
0:22:15control you ever do that where you just
0:22:16make a copy of a folder just in case and
0:22:18put to the side all the time and it's
0:22:21like well but but sometimes i do that
0:22:23like what if one of the things gets
0:22:24corrupted this is a bad sector on disk
0:22:25well if my clone is an actual clone the
0:22:29bad sector and disc is going to blow
0:22:30away both of them are you know corrupt
0:22:32both of them because they're they share
0:22:33the same storage under the covers well
0:22:35if US doesn't dictate that every single
0:22:38copy is a clone
0:22:39there'll be two different API is I'm not
0:22:40sure which one the finder will use i'm
0:22:42assuming you will use the fast one
0:22:44but even the finer doesn't offer this
0:22:47feature there will be a way I'm sure
0:22:49from the command line but if not you
0:22:50write a program to be no dude like a
0:22:52regular copy where you just copied don't
0:22:54do the clone thing so that's another you
0:22:57I nuance that Apple have to decide how
0:23:00to navigate in the users we got to take
0:23:02advantage of and honestly I think it I
0:23:03think it's good that both feature
0:23:04sometimes i do want to make a clone of
0:23:07this gigantic directory tree for free in
0:23:10constant time and other times i want to
0:23:12say no actually copy every single one of
0:23:14this piece of data to a new play some
0:23:15disc because that's what i want and i
0:23:18look forward to hopefully it's like a
0:23:20modifier key you can hold down or
0:23:21something I look forward the that being
0:23:23exposed in the finder but I'm resigned
0:23:25to the fact that probably end up having
0:23:26to do it from the command line and the
0:23:28other fun thing about clones this is
0:23:30sort of travel purposes again this whole
0:23:32this whole file systems problems
0:23:34purposes is that it can be atomic Apple
0:23:37has a lot of things in the system
0:23:39including some file formats
0:23:40quote-unquote file formats that are
0:23:41actually directories full of files like
0:23:43dot RTF d is actually a directory full
0:23:46of a bunch of other things and in a
0:23:49simple application like USA teach text
0:23:52geez what the hell's a call text edit
0:23:55yeah i'm not going to text that it can
0:23:58make our tfd quorum court files which
0:24:00are really directory trees and when you
0:24:03save it's trying to do like a safe save
0:24:05where
0:24:05if the the plug gets pulled in the
0:24:07middle of your save operation you either
0:24:08have the new version of the file the old
0:24:10version you don't have like half and
0:24:11half so the atomic save operation now
0:24:14will do like this is also in the the WV
0:24:17session if i recall correctly it will
0:24:20like write the new version of the file
0:24:22to a new location rename the old one-two
0:24:24a weird name and rename the new
0:24:26directory on top of the old one but
0:24:28there's still a period in which things
0:24:29are inconsistent when you rename the old
0:24:31one-two to a new name but you haven't
0:24:33yet renamed the new one on top of it now
0:24:35you have two files neither which is
0:24:36named like the old one and they might
0:24:38both be hidden because you don't want
0:24:39people to see this weird stuff going on
0:24:41so it's not great a PFS you can do an
0:24:45atomic loan and so you can sort of her
0:24:48in one operation one atomic operation to
0:24:51completely do it completely not do it
0:24:52you have the old file you have the new
0:24:54file and of course it's superficial and
0:24:56all the stuff so that's that's going to
0:24:59mean it's gonna be four people writing
0:25:00applications that they have similar file
0:25:02formats it'll make those file formats
0:25:03more tenable because before was just
0:25:05kind of such a pain and you knew you had
0:25:06this race condition where things could
0:25:07be a weird weird state for a small
0:25:10period of time you can even see the
0:25:11finder sometimes because the finders now
0:25:13actually reactive to changes where if
0:25:15you watched when like text that saved
0:25:17you'd see these weird temporary files
0:25:19and a double file and rename on top of
0:25:21the other one and with cloning hopefully
0:25:22that will go so fast that you don't see
0:25:24it anymore
0:25:24yeah my favorite is since I've been
0:25:26doing a lot of switch development lately
0:25:28I just like Marco I've had a playground
0:25:30on my desktop and every time that the
0:25:33playground goes to save itself or if I
0:25:35save it it'll flash from the playground
0:25:37icon to the jit the gym generic folder
0:25:40icon and then back to the playground
0:25:42icon once finder catches up and realizes
0:25:44it's one of those like bundles is
0:25:46actually remember my future came to the
0:25:48fire like having having an efficient way
0:25:50to sort of tell the colonel hey I'm
0:25:52interested if anything happens to anyone
0:25:54of these files of anything changes one
0:25:56of these files I don't care what process
0:25:58it is analysis then let me know so i
0:26:00have to pull like the old model was like
0:26:02if you had a finder window open other
0:26:04applications were changing its like the
0:26:05Finder window periodically and it was
0:26:07pulling you would never catch changes
0:26:08that fast but because it's using KQ or
0:26:11FS events or some other system that is
0:26:13you know that's not pulling that the
0:26:15colonel will notify the finder
0:26:17it's fast enough to catch almost any
0:26:19changes that might still catch the clone
0:26:21but hopefully it will only like flash
0:26:24briefly and you'll see the old file and
0:26:26then blink in the new file and never
0:26:27will you see the the weird
0:26:29I've rename this to not be an RTF d
0:26:31anymore or not it not be a playground
0:26:33anymore or whatever i guess the final
0:26:36item of snapshots we talked about
0:26:38I wonder if there'll be any UI to that
0:26:40probably not because it's more like a
0:26:42programmatic thing time machine will be
0:26:43will be creating the leading snapshots
0:26:45behind the scenes but you don't need to
0:26:46see that programs like SuperDuper might
0:26:49create snapshots to to backup from but
0:26:50you don't need to see that either it'll
0:26:51probably do it through an API there will
0:26:53be a command line i'm sure i can't
0:26:55envision any particular reason for their
0:26:58to ever be a GUI for doing snapshot so I
0:27:01guess another third-party opportunity
0:27:02because it's a straightforward API you
0:27:05can make a cool third-party thing that
0:27:06lets you view and create and destroy
0:27:11snapshots I'm not making that up another
0:27:14idea for people who want to make an
0:27:15application that three people will buy
0:27:17you know John there's a lot of app ideas
0:27:20that I'm like you know I would love for
0:27:22this app to exist and you look around
0:27:24and just doesn't exist and at some point
0:27:28you got you know you're a programmer
0:27:29some point you gotta be like you know
0:27:30what i find i'm gonna make it
0:27:32well I i imagine someone will make
0:27:35that's not something like that you ever
0:27:36see like backup loop or the time machine
0:27:38browsing things let you like look at
0:27:40your time machine backup set or like
0:27:42their fancy interfaces to the TAMU tail
0:27:44command line there's lots of google apps
0:27:46like that i'm sure someone will make one
0:27:47just because if an app like this is easy
0:27:49to make all you're doing is making it
0:27:51more convenient to do stuff that you
0:27:53could do from the command line someone
0:27:54will make it so I feel like just by
0:27:56talking about it will it will come into
0:27:57existence
0:27:58yeah but you know what else though even
0:28:01if somebody makes it they're not going
0:28:03to make it your way
0:28:04truth that's true so you have to do it
0:28:07John it's obvious
0:28:08I'll say I I don't understand why when I
0:28:11would do any of these things like it's
0:28:13not like I have a lot of a time that's a
0:28:15knock your pipe with other stuff that i
0:28:17would rather be doing Brian ash the
0:28:20chapters made an excellent point he said
0:28:22that underscores listening and he just
0:28:24completed it which is probably accurate
0:28:26but he made the iOS version sauce
0:28:29good for me fair enough
0:28:32all right are we done with a PFS is that
0:28:35it yeah i think so like this we just do
0:28:37things we already talked about the WTC
0:28:38thing I don't think there's anything new
0:28:40we didn't have many questions from
0:28:42listeners about itself although i did no
0:28:45one has yet called me on the the
0:28:47mistakes i made about a ascii 7-bit
0:28:50ascii versus a bit ascii and utf-8 but i
0:28:54guess no one cares that's why I know I
0:28:57made the mistakes people who no no I
0:28:58made the mistakes is it really not
0:29:00mistakes just their errors of omission
0:29:01because doesn't make any sense I kept
0:29:03saying to 55 but obviously if you're
0:29:05going to use all 255 combinations of a
0:29:09bits you have no way to implement utf-8
0:29:11and that's obviously not how it works
0:29:13so anyway we're sponsor this week by
0:29:17Harry's now Harry's is the only shaving
0:29:20company that has amazing quality low
0:29:22prices and modern convenience they sell
0:29:24razors and blades and you look at this
0:29:26stuff and it's great they recently sent
0:29:28me one of their newest kits like they
0:29:29say seasonally update their designs and
0:29:32stuff sometimes I like a special and
0:29:33they sent me some of their new stuff and
0:29:35this just this stuff to keep getting
0:29:37better and better at the handle is I got
0:29:39that that orange i believe the Truman
0:29:41set that the orange big on channel one
0:29:43and its like before at the silver one
0:29:46and they're both so nice like it's
0:29:47almost like actually seasonal cycle my
0:29:50razor handle these things are so nice
0:29:52they're classy looking they're nice and
0:29:54it's almost like a like a modern take on
0:29:57like madmen kind of aesthetic almost
0:29:59like mid-century but updated modern look
0:30:02for this stuff and this is such sharp
0:30:03such stark contrast to what you usually
0:30:06see in shaving equipment design from the
0:30:09big brands which is why I often describe
0:30:12it as like android commercial design or
0:30:15like weird like transformers but Harry's
0:30:20is not like that hair is nice and classy
0:30:22and the hairies blades are such good
0:30:25values i have not found a better value
0:30:28in the shaving world than the hairies
0:30:29blade so these are german-engineered
0:30:31five blade cartridges now you've seen
0:30:34five blade cartridges from other big
0:30:36brands Harry's is about half the price
0:30:39or less of these leading brands the
0:30:42starter set is an amazing
0:30:43deal also for just fifteen dollars you
0:30:45get a razor handle moisturizing shave
0:30:47cream and three razor blade cartridges
0:30:49so check it out today go to Harry's
0:30:52dot-com right now
0:30:53har ry s.com if you use code ATP at
0:30:58checkout you'll get five dollars off
0:30:59your first order once again harrods.com
0:31:01code ATP for five dollars off your first
0:31:04order you will not believe the quality
0:31:06you get for the price and quality is
0:31:09guaranteed full refund if you're not
0:31:10happy
0:31:11check it out today harrods.com promo
0:31:13code 84 five dollars off thanks a lot i
0:31:19have some important follow-up actually
0:31:22that surprise follow-up that you missed
0:31:24that part of the show but go ahead i
0:31:27have follow-up on hdmi-cec your favorite
0:31:31topic
0:31:32oh god oh I your hdmi-cec unicorn are no
0:31:36longer ever since i got the new Apple TV
0:31:38so what was that october november
0:31:40whatever whenever that was my TV is very
0:31:43old
0:31:43it's like a two thousand six ish
0:31:46panasonic plasma the appletv was not
0:31:48able to do anything else to it except
0:31:50any input given the opportunity remote
0:31:53it would automatically switch the input
0:31:56over to the apple TV so it was able to
0:31:58like steal the input the video input
0:31:59from the TV so which is really fun like
0:32:01if it's like playing a game on the
0:32:02playstation and then you like brush the
0:32:04remote and all of us on the inputs which
0:32:06is that was fun yet but so that and it
0:32:08couldn't turn the TV on but it could
0:32:10turn the TV off which was really nice
0:32:13every night you know we're not watching
0:32:15TV hold down the home button for a few
0:32:17seconds you put you hit sleep and both
0:32:19things turn off
0:32:20it's awesome and that worked flawlessly
0:32:23and now it just doesn't and it's so much
0:32:27worse and I've tried power cycling
0:32:29everything I have no idea what to do
0:32:32like nothing changed
0:32:34it's exactly like what you said it was
0:32:35like you know it'll work and i'll just
0:32:37stop working and you have no idea why
0:32:39and nothing fixes it like it just
0:32:42stopped and uh it's so frustrating now
0:32:45now like once you have that convenience
0:32:47to have to then go back and now I have
0:32:49to turn my TV off separately which means
0:32:51after like have the road out and
0:32:53everything it's uh
0:32:54this is like the worst like first world
0:32:57problem ever but I just wanted you to
0:32:59know John that hdmi-cec that your your
0:33:02your prediction came true that it never
0:33:06it never works all the time for
0:33:07everybody and if it does just wait
0:33:10well the good news is it'll start
0:33:12working again eventually to experience
0:33:15one day because like who knows what
0:33:17it'll be like you're disconnected or
0:33:18you'll reconnect something else or just
0:33:20it'll start working again I and back
0:33:22when we were discussing this I did hear
0:33:23from a lot of people like CC works fine
0:33:25to me sometimes I would hear from them
0:33:27again a couple months later go it
0:33:29stopped working exactly but not always i
0:33:32bet i like I just like their tactic
0:33:34Wizards their RCC unicorns who just have
0:33:36never had a problem and so like you know
0:33:39if they their luck continues it's
0:33:41possible to live a life force easy
0:33:43always works it just seems highly
0:33:44unlikely to me I've never met one of
0:33:46those people i'm sure they exist summer
0:33:48I mean someone's a lottery to write
0:33:49serious ? Oh have you gone into the
0:33:53settings to see because I could swear
0:33:56that in settings that has an option
0:33:57whether or not to UCC of course it's not
0:33:59labeled that way but it's like turn off
0:34:02the TV power when this when the appletv
0:34:04power turns off or something like that
0:34:06and not to say that you changed it but
0:34:08maybe like a software update flip that
0:34:10on you or something like that and maybe
0:34:12that's what did it you can you just
0:34:14check to make sure it's plugged in not
0:34:15to say that you unplugged it just maybe
0:34:18take out the plug
0:34:19sometimes sometimes as dust in the plug
0:34:21yeah he just wanted yeah just blow on
0:34:23the plug yeah the worst here here i have
0:34:25tried to help you and that's what I get
0:34:26fine i actually haven't checked the set
0:34:28there for the power thing though isn't
0:34:30there I are still in the remote
0:34:32yes yes so you can't you just do you use
0:34:35that for the power like take CC out of
0:34:36the equation just use the IR for the
0:34:38power for your TV I don't think there's
0:34:40a way to tell the apple TV like send the
0:34:42IR thing now I think it only works for
0:34:44volume control that's a little too but
0:34:46did might be worth looking into
0:34:48I know Joe steel loves his apple TV can
0:34:51ask him about it i mean honestly like
0:34:52I'm i'm very happy with the apple TV in
0:34:55most other ways like yeah the remote
0:34:57stupid but you know they're like the the
0:34:59software environment
0:35:00yes there are many flaws however having
0:35:02used the other TV boxes that are
0:35:05competing with this and you know even
0:35:06compared to the old Apple
0:35:08TV ice this is still the one I prefer
0:35:11and i still use it for you know very
0:35:14very heavy use everyday and it's
0:35:17unfortunate that it is not perfect of
0:35:19course but nothing ever is that it can't
0:35:21be complained about trying to try
0:35:25yeah also my world i mean you don't know
0:35:28if you remember you see my table with a
0:35:30thousand motabhai sec is against my
0:35:32religion
0:35:32I did not have it everywhere and i also
0:35:36have a thousand remotes and I don't have
0:35:38universal remote but here's the thing
0:35:39about thousand marks and never told work
0:35:42and I use the correct remote to do all
0:35:44the things they always work and there
0:35:45never any word interactions and the
0:35:47boxes don't know each other exists and
0:35:48that's the way it should be
0:35:50I didn't able it at 1.4 like my entire
0:35:52setup my setup is way too complicated
0:35:53for like I could barely get to work
0:35:56momentarily and like this is this
0:35:58untenable and I would see it break like
0:35:59within minutes because of me not turning
0:36:02things on the right or so i'm really
0:36:04turned it off everywhere with the shame
0:36:05because they're a couple of features
0:36:06features that i would like but i get x
0:36:08pretty well with all my remotes knowing
0:36:10how to do I our stuff so i can do volume
0:36:12up and down the TV and power on the TV
0:36:14from a bunch of different remotes but I
0:36:16are learning is fairly stable technology
0:36:19not like the sea stuff
0:36:21yeah and I'm also a guy i think i'm on
0:36:23your side in regards to the what appears
0:36:25to be your position on universal remotes
0:36:27I we we have a logitech harmony
0:36:30something or other and you know it when
0:36:32we when we bought it a few years ago to
0:36:34try to combat this this issue and i just
0:36:37had never we've never found a universal
0:36:40remote that is what that is actually
0:36:43like worth it's actually a net Dean you
0:36:46know like it's almost like like the xkcd
0:36:48comic of like you know all these
0:36:50standards are a mess
0:36:52what we need is a new standard like
0:36:53that's kind of what like it's like all I
0:36:56have too many remotes what I need is
0:36:57another remote and then you just have
0:36:59more remotes like and it and you can
0:37:01actually get rid of all the remotes
0:37:03because you still need them sometimes to
0:37:04do certain things and sometimes the
0:37:05universal remote like gets like one
0:37:08synced with the state of the things and
0:37:10so it thinks things are in a certain
0:37:11state that they're not in and it's just
0:37:14such a pain and then my mom I remote has
0:37:16firmware that needs to be updated it
0:37:18needs to be on my Wi-Fi network and then
0:37:19it's just like it
0:37:21mr. Payne it's it's such a pain I
0:37:23couldn't agree with that more we had a
0:37:25very old harmony or equivalent I don't
0:37:29know 34 years ago now and I didn't
0:37:31understand how it could possibly work
0:37:33until I realized that it was tracking
0:37:35the state of the system as best it could
0:37:37but just like you said it can't actually
0:37:40know the state of the system so it was
0:37:42constantly losing track of things and it
0:37:45would when it worked it was brilliant
0:37:47but it almost never worked and it was
0:37:50very frustrating and I continue to
0:37:52believe that a good universal remote
0:37:54would actually simplify things
0:37:56especially for the members of my family
0:37:58who are not me but as we discussed at
0:38:00some point about car stuff i'm a climate
0:38:03control a micromanager in the car
0:38:06like I want the individual controls for
0:38:08fan speed and temperature in which
0:38:09direction the air is flowing and I'm
0:38:11exactly the same way with TV i have a
0:38:13million remotes I know what all them do
0:38:15i know which things I want on for which
0:38:18shows at which time depending on my mood
0:38:20and just I you know as to exactly it it
0:38:24feels to me that the part of my brain is
0:38:26activated exactly the same part of my
0:38:27brain is activated by messing with
0:38:28climate controls in car and so I don't
0:38:30pretend this is an optimal setup but it
0:38:31has the advantages of being completely
0:38:34understandable to me and deterministic
0:38:36and I you know I micromanagement I I
0:38:40just you know when do I want the big
0:38:42speakers on your little ones do I want
0:38:44surrounding coding or is this thing
0:38:46stereo and then I want to turn on the
0:38:47dolby digital thing and don't want it
0:38:50down to like the apple TV apps like
0:38:51don't want to use infuse to try to get
0:38:53it descended the unmodified DTS and do
0:38:55the decoding on the appletv or do I want
0:38:57to let the imac do it and do it reflects
0:38:59and that's that's how i wish it was
0:39:02simple i wish there was one app in one
0:39:04box and one interface and all my stuff
0:39:06was in one place but that's just not the
0:39:07case and so since things are in a
0:39:09million other places having a million
0:39:11remotes in a million things to just
0:39:12seems like an honest representation of
0:39:14the reality where the hell my media is
0:39:16and I don't think it's unlearning able
0:39:18think I'm trying to see who was a
0:39:21second-place person in the family who
0:39:22understands the system it's probably one
0:39:25of my kids maybe my youngest I don't
0:39:27know nobody really understands fully
0:39:28except for me which is potentially a
0:39:30problem relation write something down
0:39:32like it hit by a bus here's how to watch
0:39:33TV
0:39:34and you and make fun of me for about 100
0:39:40something that was vinyl this is just
0:39:43the interface was like I i I've never
0:39:45bought a universal remote but i assume i
0:39:47assume it would make things easier
0:39:48especially if you have universal remote
0:39:51to turn on CC everywhere then maybe
0:39:53would have a way to detect it could
0:39:55repair see screwed up in this but who
0:39:57knows maybe not have I still do have
0:39:59devices that are I are only ends you
0:40:02have that like ir blaster is another
0:40:03crack like that so you just like it for
0:40:05the ceremony it's a terribly inferior
0:40:07standard but you just like it's not it's
0:40:09not about ceremony so just like it's
0:40:10there's no ceremony to micro managing
0:40:13the climate control the cars just like
0:40:14well I know how I want the fan speed and
0:40:16I know what I want the temperature set
0:40:17to and I know if I want the coming out
0:40:19the top 10 to the bottom answer both of
0:40:20defroster I know all those things so i
0:40:22can just set him directly
0:40:23I am so happy that I don't stress about
0:40:26those sorts of things you know what I do
0:40:27in my car I hit the auto button and then
0:40:29I usually hit the All button that Marco
0:40:31wishes tips car had and then i set a
0:40:35temperature and then I don't friggin
0:40:37think about it anymore
0:40:39it's like the automatic transmission of
0:40:40climate control hey you okay see if you
0:40:43manage it yourself then it would just it
0:40:46would it would feel warmer and less
0:40:48artificial it would remind you of your
0:40:50childhood but this note there is no
0:40:52final analogy to be had here there's
0:40:55absolutely no kind of vinyl whatsoever
0:40:57because it's not like this
0:40:59the dead to the video or sound changes
0:41:01quality depending on what remotes I used
0:41:03to understand this is the violin algae
0:41:04go get thrown out the window you can't
0:41:07even throw back the suspense face to
0:41:09make fun of it makes no sense i can try
0:41:12visiting you know the employee you may
0:41:15not but the emoji of the woman with her
0:41:17arms like an across in front of her face
0:41:19I'm envisioning John doing that sitting
0:41:20in front of his his computer
0:41:22that's exactly what i look like we are
0:41:25sponsored tonight by amazon music now
0:41:28you might not know that if you have an
0:41:30amazon prime subscription to get fast
0:41:31shipping and stuff they have prime music
0:41:33and prime music is Amazon music service
0:41:35that you get unlimited access to over a
0:41:38million songs curated playlists and
0:41:40ad-free stations for all prime members
0:41:43and they have created a little looking
0:41:45like a trial playlist for you to hear
0:41:47yourself you want
0:41:48it's kinda tied into the rest of amazon
0:41:50music so that you can purchase songs
0:41:51individually you can stream for most
0:41:53devices ipads iphones android phones
0:41:56even sonos players of course amazon fire
0:42:00devices and of course amazon echo in
0:42:02fact they've created a cool playlist now
0:42:05if you go to Amazon songs of summer
0:42:08dot-com at amazon songs of summer calm /
0:42:11ATP they've created a playlist called
0:42:14songs of summer and you can go there to
0:42:16hear it or if you have an echo
0:42:18alexa play songs of summer and you'll
0:42:21start hearing it then and what they've
0:42:23done is they've gone out and they have
0:42:24commissioned a whole bunch of artists to
0:42:27create critically acclaimed new songs
0:42:30and unique covers of existing hits so
0:42:32they've come for this eclectic playlist
0:42:34of exclusive original songs and covers
0:42:36that love like you know various summer
0:42:38themes and these appeal to a wide
0:42:39audience
0:42:40now this is perfect for summertime
0:42:42listening in fact i listen to it Tiffany
0:42:44listen while you're cooking for dinner
0:42:45tonight because it is summertime I said
0:42:47that to my echo and it started playing
0:42:49and it was great
0:42:50you can check it out to with amazon
0:42:52prime music or just go to that link
0:42:55amazon songs of summer calm / ATP to
0:42:58hear it for yourself if you want to try
0:43:00out amazon prime music nice and easy to
0:43:02do that there to check it out they have
0:43:04a bunch of cool stuff there like I think
0:43:05they have all of weezer which is pretty
0:43:06cool that they have like their entire
0:43:07collection i think and of course you
0:43:09know if you have an echo
0:43:10it's even better and this is this is one
0:43:12of the biggest reasons to get an echo
0:43:14so check it out today go to amazon songs
0:43:16of summer dot-com / ATP to listen to the
0:43:20entire songs of summer playlist
0:43:22thanks a lot to Amazon music for
0:43:23sponsoring our show anyway we talk about
0:43:29email we talk about parenting what do
0:43:30you--what pick your poison
0:43:32oh man that's a tough one we did get a
0:43:34lot of feedback after the legs so at
0:43:37last episode we we kind of joked in the
0:43:39after show that if we weren't on the
0:43:40topics we're gonna have to talk about
0:43:41those things and then we got a lot of
0:43:44responses from people saying please talk
0:43:46about one or the other of those things
0:43:48and I think if i had to take a guess I
0:43:50think parenting might come out ahead i
0:43:52think so not parenting and specifically
0:43:54screen time for kids that's right yeah
0:43:56very very old piece of followed by and I
0:43:58think that was the one that's in the
0:43:59most Americans not like it's not stuff
0:44:00below it but Intel making chips for
0:44:02phones and Chromebooks outselling max
0:44:04and letterpress moving of Game Center
0:44:05there are other things but I feel like I
0:44:07don't feel like we're scraping the
0:44:08bottom of the barrel for this I think
0:44:10this is just a better topic than those
0:44:11other ones both of these I think are
0:44:12better topics the the quite the request
0:44:15was what exactly I let's say Peter
0:44:17Beardsley wrote in we still have this i
0:44:21was joking
0:44:21is he is no longer listening to the show
0:44:24but here and a half ago Peter Beardsley
0:44:26road and he has since retired it no
0:44:29longer even use computers anymore as
0:44:31kids are in college
0:44:33that's very true he had written in and
0:44:36said John has been talking about playing
0:44:37destiny with his kid marco post pictures
0:44:39of him playing games on an iPad the
0:44:42topic of quote-unquote screen time is a
0:44:44controversial one in my household how do
0:44:46you determine what is an appropriate
0:44:47amount my wife has her opinions and I
0:44:49have mine but i'd love to hear yours as
0:44:51well so at this point this is when we
0:44:54really anger anyone who we haven't
0:44:56angered yet in the entire course of the
0:44:58show now my most parents don't get angry
0:45:01like I think most parents are beaten
0:45:03down by reality and actually realize
0:45:04people have the parenting idea so it's a
0:45:06tiny minority of parents that are all
0:45:07high and mighty about was having kids is
0:45:09the best thing to teach you that you
0:45:10don't know the first thing about having
0:45:11kids but what happens after the as for
0:45:15the framing of this topic like it I i
0:45:17don't really and like not that I don't
0:45:20accept the premise but the premise
0:45:21itself it contains some opinionated
0:45:25information which is that screen time in
0:45:28quotes which is a phrase I think we've
0:45:29all heard from either from ourselves
0:45:30saying that other parents and stuff that
0:45:32there is the category of activities that
0:45:36your kid can do that involves them
0:45:38looking at a screen which is basically
0:45:40an electric
0:45:41sonic thing that shows moving images on
0:45:43it that that is a valid categorization
0:45:45like we don't talk about yellow sock
0:45:48time how much time you let your kids
0:45:49wear yellow socks how much time to let
0:45:51me touch the floor floor time like its
0:45:54screen time specifically and encoded in
0:45:56that is sort of a an unquestioning
0:46:01demonization to some degree of
0:46:03technology in that like why is reading a
0:46:06book not screen time if you read a book
0:46:08on an iPad does it become screen time
0:46:10because it's on a screen like that
0:46:12screens themselves like again I don't
0:46:14think this is it's not it's not like a
0:46:16heavy message but in in this in this
0:46:18word and this phrase in this entire
0:46:20concept in this question that comes up
0:46:21the idea of looking at a screen is a
0:46:25fundamental aspect of an activity i'm
0:46:28mostly rejected the book one is the best
0:46:30example because you know these days ago
0:46:32my kids are reading a book it's a
0:46:33wonderful feel great about it but if
0:46:34they're reading that same exact book on
0:46:36their iPad screen suddenly they're
0:46:38writing their brains and they're just
0:46:39gonna become little zombies in there
0:46:41staring at screens all the time
0:46:42same activity but one has a screen one
0:46:45doesn't so at least for me I don't
0:46:47categorize activities based on the piece
0:46:52of technology they're using I would more
0:46:54categorizes like what is the activity
0:46:55are they watching video what kind of
0:46:59video with this fiction and nonfiction
0:47:00you know and sometimes you throw
0:47:02something like oh they're watching
0:47:03YouTube but it's really just shorthand
0:47:04for categorizing the types of things
0:47:06that are on youtube in general they're
0:47:07not watching a feature-length movie on
0:47:09YouTube and mostly not watching like
0:47:11cereal TV show style things on youtube
0:47:13so YouTube was you know as kind of a
0:47:15definition but reading books watching
0:47:17movies many things happen in front of
0:47:19screens writing my daughter writes a lot
0:47:21and you know word processors right
0:47:23section and writes down lists and stuff
0:47:24that's also in front of a screen i
0:47:26categorize that entirely differently
0:47:28than her watching you know ever after
0:47:30high or whatever so that's that's my
0:47:33that's my opening statement i guess on
0:47:35screen time and how you guys do that a
0:47:37phrase that is used ever in your house
0:47:38or is that how you think about things at
0:47:40all
0:47:40yes some so it's a little bit different
0:47:43for me as compared to you guys because
0:47:45Declan is just today actually 20 months
0:47:47old and so he's not even two years we
0:47:51generally speaking
0:47:53avoided show well he had no interest in
0:47:56the TV for a long time and once he
0:47:57started to show an interest we and we
0:47:59avoided having the TV on when he was
0:48:02awake and around that still mostly the
0:48:05case we have started or Aaron because
0:48:08i'm at work at the time it has started
0:48:10showing him sesame street every day
0:48:11which he very very much enjoys and then
0:48:14we have my old iPad Mini that we have
0:48:18put a bunch of daniel tiger and sesame
0:48:22street episodes on and we'll use that
0:48:24only in desperation scenarios typically
0:48:27only when we're in the car because he
0:48:28doesn't particularly like the car but
0:48:31other than that we he's very rarely
0:48:34looking at a television screen or an
0:48:36iPad and i'm not saying that that's
0:48:37right but it feels for us like we should
0:48:41probably avoid it at least for now but
0:48:43again it's a little weird because he's
0:48:44only 20 months I mean he doesn't ease
0:48:46into it like Adam more like your kids
0:48:48would be I mean for us you know adam is
0:48:51in my kid is as for and he you know
0:48:56we've we've had we don't really draw the
0:48:58distinction we don't we don't use the
0:48:59term screen time or any any other a
0:49:01replacement term for that concept and
0:49:04yeah i think it's you know like so many
0:49:07things in parenting it depends on your
0:49:08kid in our case we never like
0:49:12specifically glorified think the screens
0:49:15or maid the maid forbidden thing or
0:49:17thing that was that was saved for like
0:49:18only special occasions
0:49:19you know it's like one toy with many in
0:49:21the house and Adam could choose to play
0:49:23with the ipad or can watch TV for a
0:49:26while or he can do other things and we
0:49:29haven't really had to set limits because
0:49:31the kind of kid he is at least so far he
0:49:34treats it like any other toy so I kill
0:49:37will be happy to play with the ipad for
0:49:38like you know maybe 20 minutes half hour
0:49:41and then want to do something else and i
0:49:43think that's that's kind of a healthy
0:49:44attitude for it because I mean our
0:49:47philosophy on this you know if it ever
0:49:49came to having to put in any kind of
0:49:51limits in 22 min healthy balances our
0:49:54philosophy is this is a world full of
0:49:56screens that we live in
0:49:58it's only getting more in that direction
0:50:00as we move forward you know
0:50:02time so Adam is growing up in a world
0:50:04full of screens to try to like keep him
0:50:09from that or limit that artificially in
0:50:11a way that would like you know make it
0:50:13weird like to deal with screens for him
0:50:15or two to make it like a rebellion is of
0:50:18sorts or like only a special treat
0:50:20doesn't really seem like that fits into
0:50:22the road we actually live in today you
0:50:24know I I get the idea of why people want
0:50:26to limit that and the end the and what
0:50:28people want their kids to do instead I
0:50:30guess be social or go outside whatever
0:50:32but I think if you're if you already
0:50:34have a reasonable balance and of of
0:50:39activities for your kid having having
0:50:41screens and things for screens be a part
0:50:44of that i don't i don't see it as any
0:50:45different from any other toys that he
0:50:48has so as kids get older like you said
0:50:51it really depends on your kid you the
0:50:53kids will start picking up more of their
0:50:55own interests like this especially young
0:50:56ages you can basically control
0:50:57everything we do you control the toys
0:50:59they play with because you buy the toys
0:51:00you can you can even control by not
0:51:02bringing them down the toilet you don't
0:51:03want them to see the toys that you're
0:51:05not going to buy them like when they're
0:51:06very young you you have a lot of control
0:51:09and so you can sort of provide the
0:51:10balance silly by-product providing a
0:51:11balance of things that you all approve
0:51:13of course kids get older starting minds
0:51:15of their own and depending on your kid
0:51:17they have different you know different
0:51:19preferences and they will gravitate
0:51:22towards something and then no matter
0:51:24what they gravitate towards maintaining
0:51:25what you think is a healthy balance may
0:51:28require some intervention but again i'd
0:51:32say that doesn't specifically apply to
0:51:34screen so for example if your kid starts
0:51:37getting older and becomes really into
0:51:40books and all they want to do all the
0:51:42time is go up to the room and read
0:51:43you're like oh I would be overjoyed if
0:51:45my kid read all the time but at a
0:51:46certain point they need to learn how to
0:51:48deal with other people and be social
0:51:50that's part of growing up too so you
0:51:51would may find yourself limiting book
0:51:53time because did you need your kid to
0:51:55socialize with other kids to learn how
0:51:57to deal with other people like you're
0:51:58trying to find the right balance for
0:52:00your kid which the balances in the same
0:52:01for everybody but most people would say
0:52:03like learning to deal with other people
0:52:05is part of growing up and you can't
0:52:06avoid it even if you're really really
0:52:08into whatever is your interest in making
0:52:11models are reading books are all these
0:52:12activities people think like a healthy
0:52:14and you know
0:52:14well that's a good thing to do like
0:52:15that's that's why i hate the screen the
0:52:18categorization of screens like they're
0:52:20certain activities are accepted by most
0:52:23parents as on a continuum of evil right
0:52:25so reading is one of the best you can do
0:52:27making models kind of in the middle
0:52:30making models that have electronics
0:52:32maybe getting a little worse
0:52:34anything that involves a television bad
0:52:36anything that involves computers could
0:52:38be good probably also bad video games
0:52:41universally bad right and that that that
0:52:44sort of a continuum that we all sort of
0:52:46agreed upon before we begin talking
0:52:48about balance
0:52:49I totally disagree with most of the
0:52:50reasons Marco said like we live in a
0:52:53world the screens we live in a world
0:52:54television we live in a world with
0:52:55recorded music like oh don't listen to
0:52:57those direct recorded music it's live
0:52:59music or nothing you'll rot your brain
0:53:00like as not the novel was condemned as
0:53:03something that will be the debt would be
0:53:04the downfall of humanity when it was
0:53:06introduced to sew through the lens of
0:53:09history it's obviously ridiculous to
0:53:10think about things that way but all of
0:53:12those mediums have things that that can
0:53:15provide your kid with something so if
0:53:17your kid is only reading is hard for me
0:53:20to find like it if they're only reading
0:53:22the same kind of simple story over and
0:53:25over again they're not really growing as
0:53:28a reader right if they're only watching
0:53:30the same kind of television show over
0:53:32and over again they're not really
0:53:33growing as a viewer of you know of
0:53:35moving pictures or whatever like and if
0:53:37they're only playing the same computer
0:53:39game over and over again they're not
0:53:41expanding outwards into that like that
0:53:43every medium and every form of input an
0:53:46activity has like your kids should be
0:53:49crawling up that ladder and becoming
0:53:51more sophisticated and learning and
0:53:53growing in all the activities that they
0:53:54do and if they're not thats you know
0:53:57something has to be aware but there's
0:53:59nothing inherent I believe in any of the
0:54:01specific activities makes them better or
0:54:03worse like I would rather my kids watch
0:54:06a YouTube video like a science youtube
0:54:08video then like read a silly book about
0:54:13fairies and rainbows that is two years
0:54:15below their grade level that they read
0:54:1650 times before like one of those uses
0:54:19screen and one of them is a book and
0:54:20suppose like the perfect thing we want
0:54:22our children to do but then you can't
0:54:24you can view them that way
0:54:25can slap them in by the by the media so
0:54:28that's definitely how I look at things
0:54:29and and I but I'm really for my kids
0:54:33mostly looking at what they are drawn to
0:54:35and figuring out what I have to put
0:54:37limits on based on what if I didn't put
0:54:39limits they would just do obsessively
0:54:40and it's not always watching television
0:54:44show or play video game it could be any
0:54:46activity they do obsessively one of my
0:54:49kids always wants to go and hang out
0:54:51with friends and my son mostly will stay
0:54:54inside and not see anybody so we're
0:54:56trying to push one out of the house all
0:54:57the time and the other one trying to get
0:54:59the calm down a lot so everything is
0:55:01different
0:55:02yeah I don't know what we're going to do
0:55:05in the future I think it's funny because
0:55:08i was very resentful of my parents or or
0:55:15extended family putting limits on our
0:55:16screen time like I think mark and I have
0:55:17talked about although maybe it never
0:55:19made it in the show when we were kids we
0:55:21want when we hung out so we are 108 1012
0:55:24something like that yeah we would meet
0:55:27up and we would hang out and then my
0:55:28grandmother would inevitably or here or
0:55:30marcos momentarily tell us okay you've
0:55:33you've played enough on the computer
0:55:34it's time to go outside now
0:55:35yeah and I remember being really really
0:55:38resentful of that because i was happy we
0:55:40were having a great time and we were in
0:55:42some cases doing things that you could
0:55:45argue were productive like I vividly
0:55:46remember spending hours on the world's
0:55:49crappiest choose-your-own-adventure
0:55:49visual basic one-point game in in it
0:55:54wasn't always transport tycoon although
0:55:56damned if we didn't play like it's
0:55:58perfect but yeah that might have been
0:56:00more than half it nevertheless I've
0:56:03never i remember being so resentful of
0:56:05the of the get outside stick but here I
0:56:08am now apparent and i feel like i'm
0:56:11reverting into that same mindset of oh
0:56:15you probably shouldn't be playing on the
0:56:17ipad constantly which again he doesn't
0:56:20because he's so young but I could see it
0:56:21happening
0:56:22you probably shouldn't be on the ipad
0:56:24constantly should probably go outside in
0:56:26you I feel like it now is the time to
0:56:29instill within him that he needs to be a
0:56:31well-rounded person but I agree
0:56:34completely with what both of you said
0:56:37that the reality of the situation is
0:56:38that part
0:56:38being well-rounded in today's society is
0:56:40being comfortable in front of a screen
0:56:42so i don't know what the right answer is
0:56:45obviously and i'll have to kind of fake
0:56:47it til we make it
0:56:48well I guess you never really making
0:56:49parenting but you know what i mean and
0:56:52we'll see how it shakes out fake until
0:56:54they go to college
0:56:55yeah right it will see how it shakes out
0:56:57as he gets older and perhaps starts
0:56:59requesting these things but it's nice
0:57:00because like John it said we have that
0:57:02control now where he doesn't ever really
0:57:04see the ipad and so it's not it
0:57:09he won't know where ask for it unless we
0:57:12say to him do you want to watch Daniel
0:57:13Tiger do you want to watch Sesame Street
0:57:15or what have you
0:57:16I think it's also worth pointing out
0:57:18that you know we we as parents like it's
0:57:22the kids can look and see what we do and
0:57:26it it would be awfully hypocritical of
0:57:28us to say you know you need to limit
0:57:30your screen time while we sit there
0:57:33using screens for way more time during
0:57:35the day than that and like they know
0:57:37that they can see that like they're not
0:57:38gonna respect the rule or the parents
0:57:41making that rule if the parents
0:57:42themselves are blatantly violating it
0:57:44all the time
0:57:46yep I'm guilty of that well like I said
0:57:48you looking at the screen doesn't mean
0:57:50you're doing the same thing like I think
0:57:51my kids do differentiated roughly like
0:57:53they know what I'm working you know
0:57:55sometimes i'm working on my is I can
0:57:57tell the difference between between me
0:57:58working versus me reading Twitter resume
0:58:01watching youtube video which I might
0:58:02invite them to join to like oh it's it's
0:58:06the specific activity that's the issue
0:58:08an idea
0:58:08Casey mentioned in terms of like then
0:58:10becoming competent with screens and for
0:58:13the most part I don't think that's
0:58:14something we need to put an effort into
0:58:15it because it's it will be very unless
0:58:17your kid like it really doesn't like
0:58:19them at all and then you might want to
0:58:20make sure they have some minimum
0:58:21confidence but i don't think there's any
0:58:22effort we need to make this was going to
0:58:23happen right
0:58:25this day they can't help but be
0:58:26competent exist around by then because
0:58:28we have a million of these devices at
0:58:29home and then they'll see them at school
0:58:31and so that's gonna take care of itself
0:58:32but really what I'm thinking of is what
0:58:35are they doing like the fact that the
0:58:36screen doesn't doesn't is not a factor
0:58:38as far as I'm concerned because i don't
0:58:40think there's magic radiation writing
0:58:41their brains coming out of like back
0:58:42flat screens
0:58:43it's what are they actually doing are
0:58:46they learning something are they reading
0:58:47wikipedia pages are they if they're
0:58:50watching some kind of video is
0:58:52is it a television show that I approve
0:58:54of in terms of you know is it
0:58:57constructive in some way are they
0:58:58playing a game that is teaching them
0:59:00something instead of you know just being
0:59:02is you know is it age-appropriate a lot
0:59:03of you know is it should you be watching
0:59:05this television show this movie this
0:59:06youtube video whatever what are you
0:59:08getting out of this
0:59:09are you watching the same kind of thing
0:59:11over and over again are you playing the
0:59:12same kind of game over and over and of
0:59:15course as you'll see this is your kids
0:59:16get older I imagine this will not be a
0:59:18thing that goes away but anyone who has
0:59:19kids and double-digit ages knows that
0:59:22the thing of like multiple screens
0:59:24they're not my son is forever has his
0:59:27ipad playing youtube videos you know in
0:59:30a loop based on a loop like it with on
0:59:33autopilot like he doesn't pick the
0:59:34videos you just accept whatever plays
0:59:36next is the amazing power the YouTube
0:59:37has over our children listening to that
0:59:40on headphones while playing a video game
0:59:42on the television or on unlike the
0:59:45PlayStation on the monitor like so he's
0:59:47hearing audio from a youtube video while
0:59:50playing a video game and then I guess
0:59:51occasionally glancing down at that thing
0:59:53and his phone is also on the desk and so
0:59:54is getting texts from friends at the
0:59:55same time that you haven't
0:59:57how do you even parts that but that's
0:59:59the thing that people
0:59:59the thing that people
1:00:00all the time could do all the time these
1:00:01days so now you have to look at like the
1:00:03three things that they're doing is he
1:00:06communicating well with his friends
1:00:08what are the youtube videos that are
1:00:09playing are the youtube videos related
1:00:11to the game that he's playing he's
1:00:12trying to learn strategies and then
1:00:13implement them like for people who
1:00:16demonize video games that they may be
1:00:18like oh that's double bad that he's
1:00:20playing a stupid video game which I
1:00:21don't like and he's watching a video
1:00:23about how to play the video game what an
1:00:25incredible waste of time but essentially
1:00:27what he's doing is like skills that
1:00:29coming you know and not just for
1:00:31schoolwork but for regular work like
1:00:33where you have to learn how to do
1:00:34something sort of on the job while
1:00:36you're doing it and you want to be able
1:00:38to do the thing that you're doing better
1:00:39and so you're essentially doing research
1:00:41to 15 minutes it's very similar to
1:00:43programming and then just like going to
1:00:45the website looking at the documentation
1:00:46and having the code another window and
1:00:48having the web browser open over there
1:00:49like we all do that all the time
1:00:51this is the video game thing is the
1:00:53equivalent of that and I mean it really
1:00:55helps your game when you understand that
1:00:56these things aren't just all mine list
1:00:58that they're actually fairly complicated
1:01:00and you know i mean you know from
1:01:02transport tycoon like you learned things
1:01:04about it you don't have the internet
1:01:05probably in those days where you could
1:01:07look up awesome strategies for
1:01:08transporting texting and stuff but
1:01:09they're surprisingly deep in the skills
1:01:11you learn of able to like juggle
1:01:14strategies and write things down with a
1:01:15pencil paper and use them to excel this
1:01:17thing you're doing which is integrated
1:01:19kind of pointless but that's exactly
1:01:20what play is like it's supposed to be a
1:01:21sort of a trial run in a safe
1:01:23environment of skills that will come in
1:01:25handy later in life and more important
1:01:27situations or you become game developer
1:01:29and they transfer exactly so
1:01:31and you know I i would argue like school
1:01:33is pointless
1:01:34like most of what you do in school is
1:01:36pointless but the reason you do it is
1:01:37that it's it's an educational exercise
1:01:39to develop your brain in certain ways
1:01:41and games are often that same thing and
1:01:44even like things like television shows
1:01:45and movies like a lot of what i want my
1:01:47kids to learn when they watch media that
1:01:49I hopefully is constructed in some way
1:01:51is you see interpersonal relationships
1:01:54like you you have a certain amount of
1:01:55interpersonal relations that you get to
1:01:56try out when you go to school in your
1:01:58hair with your friends but you also
1:01:59learn from the media that you see how do
1:02:02people relate to each other
1:02:03what are the various anti-patterns how
1:02:04they relate how will i be treated if I
1:02:07act like this a lot of fiction sort of
1:02:09plays out those things especially kids
1:02:10fiction where the show
1:02:11the kid who's to concede or the the kid
1:02:14who's shy or bullying or like all you
1:02:16know very a lot of media for children
1:02:19eventually gets into all those topics
1:02:22and they're just like oh I'm just
1:02:23watching a TV show but i think people
1:02:25don't realize how much people and even
1:02:26reading books and stuff like that like
1:02:28fiction provides a way to try out
1:02:32activities you're not gonna actually try
1:02:34yourself but to see pretend people try
1:02:36them out and see the consequences which
1:02:37is why you have to keep your eye
1:02:38infection because if you fed your kids
1:02:40the wrong kind of pictures they couldn't
1:02:41get the wrong kind of idea about the way
1:02:44the world works so you have to that's
1:02:46what you have to sort of be on top of
1:02:47what they're look into or whatever and
1:02:49that's why you know when you're young is
1:02:51easy but later on they will start
1:02:52picking things on their own you have to
1:02:53sort of take an interest in what are you
1:02:55watching and you will have to watch a
1:02:57bunch of episodes of shows that you're
1:02:58not actually interested in because
1:02:59they're for kids but if you don't do
1:03:01that you have no idea what it is they're
1:03:02they're learning and taking away because
1:03:04they you know the same way they want you
1:03:06to learn how interpersonal relationships
1:03:08work they also learned that from fiction
1:03:10night I I think back to the number of
1:03:12things i learned about learned or miss
1:03:15learned about human nature from
1:03:16television movies and books from my
1:03:18childhood and it's surprising amount
1:03:20perhaps more than I learned from you
1:03:23know my parents actually telling me and
1:03:25sort of the sort of traditional
1:03:26parenting away like let me tell you why
1:03:29you should not be a bully and why you
1:03:30should be nice to your sister or
1:03:31whatever but when you bring all this up
1:03:34because I just the other day Aaron sent
1:03:36me an article she had found and we'll
1:03:37put in the show notes and the titles
1:03:39research shows preschoolers to watch
1:03:41daniel tiger's neighborhood develop
1:03:42social and emotional skills and this is
1:03:45a study by texas tech university
1:03:47apparently and what they did was they
1:03:50gave they had preschoolers watch like a
1:03:52nature show for a couple of weeks or
1:03:54watch Daniel tiger which if you're not
1:03:57familiar it's it's the spiritual
1:03:59successor to Mister Rogers which i
1:04:01assume is relevant even to like grits as
1:04:05well but mr. Rogers like an institution
1:04:08for kids in the u.s. well anyway so they
1:04:11the key quote here is in the study which
1:04:13will be published an upcoming issue to
1:04:14the journal of children and media
1:04:16hundred twenty-seven people preschoolers
1:04:18watched ten episodes of either daniel
1:04:19tiger's neighborhood or nature show /
1:04:21two-week period should we watch Daniel
1:04:23Tiger exhibited higher levels of empty
1:04:25cell
1:04:25if efficacy basically confidence in
1:04:27oneself in social situations and the
1:04:29ability to recognize emotions from a bar
1:04:32better ability to recognize those
1:04:34emotions then the kids who watch the
1:04:36nature show there's a kicker though in
1:04:38order for the kids to benefit from
1:04:39watching the show their regular TV
1:04:40watching experience has to be company
1:04:42accompanied by frequent parent-child
1:04:44conversations about the media content
1:04:45which is a part that i found most
1:04:47interesting it was yeah the show may not
1:04:49be a complete disaster in and of itself
1:04:52but for to really sink in and hit home
1:04:55it's up to Aaron and I to pay attention
1:04:57and talk to him as best as we can with
1:04:59the 20 month old about what he just saw
1:05:02and and that's something that we've
1:05:03taken a heart and although he hasn't
1:05:05seen Daniel tiger in the couple of days
1:05:07since since we found this article it's
1:05:10still something that we plan to do in
1:05:12the future and have something we're
1:05:13going to try to be better about the
1:05:15parenting institution of reading an
1:05:17article and then deciding this is how we
1:05:18have to parent differently because the
1:05:20article says it's a fair credit no it's
1:05:22a fair criticism but that's not a
1:05:23criticism we all do it like that because
1:05:25the end we all do it because we're all
1:05:26looking for well you know where we're
1:05:28looking for help right it's like someone
1:05:30have some ideas that i haven't tried
1:05:31i'll try those like we did exactly the
1:05:33same things like and speaking of his
1:05:35same same things about all the studies
1:05:36about how you shouldn't show your kid
1:05:38any sort of video very early in life
1:05:41which always made sense to me I mean we
1:05:43didn't need articles tell us that for
1:05:44the most part but like when your kid is
1:05:46changing from a little squishy larvae
1:05:48into like that does nothing and just
1:05:51pooped his pants all the time and you
1:05:53can barely hold its head up like that
1:05:55you they have to learn how to interact
1:05:57with the world and if kids very very
1:06:01young can be distracted by moving images
1:06:03that's taking time away from them
1:06:05learning like where's the floor where
1:06:07this is sealing what are these things
1:06:08poking out of my body and how do I
1:06:09control them right and so that's why i
1:06:12would imagine part of the rationale
1:06:14behind don't show very very young kids
1:06:16television or movies or other things
1:06:18that are irresistibly attractive and yet
1:06:21don't teach them anything about how to
1:06:22exist in the world because you're
1:06:25distracting them from important
1:06:27developmental milestones but once kids
1:06:29can actually walking talking and do
1:06:31stuff like that then moving pictures
1:06:33just part of the part of the same world
1:06:35as learning to read and
1:06:36learning to be more information and
1:06:37speaking of discussing things with your
1:06:39kids doesn't have to be after school
1:06:40style like I remember a lot of the shows
1:06:43i wanted my kids to watch my shows in
1:06:44which characters were similar ages and
1:06:47facing similar challenges i gotta know
1:06:49everyone hates Caillou but i would
1:06:50always be like remember that episode
1:06:52work I you found his shoes and tied them
1:06:54himself like you would reference things
1:06:56that I know he's seen on TV to give him
1:06:58a framework and like he would have two
1:07:00great as the first child and you know
1:07:01you both have your first child there at
1:07:03the grudgingly admit that yes I suppose
1:07:06it is it is reasonable for a child my
1:07:08age to be able to do this whereas
1:07:09depending on your kid maybe like this is
1:07:11an injustice I could never put on my own
1:07:13socks this is not a thing that happens
1:07:14my entire life you've been putting on my
1:07:16socks I was like do you want me to put
1:07:18on my socks
1:07:19that's ridiculous things I want Caillou
1:07:21doesn't he's your age and like hmm like
1:07:24it's kristen Caillou as real as anything
1:07:25else in the world right to discuss like
1:07:28a discussing what you seen but
1:07:30referencing what you know they've seen
1:07:31it in a way that's like it's like shared
1:07:34culture with your child in our stories
1:07:36you know they've read like it was just
1:07:37like in this book when that happened
1:07:39that we can apply the steer like not
1:07:40that listen to yours like oh you're
1:07:42totally right dad but at least you know
1:07:43you make your point and so if you just
1:07:45keep doing that eventually it will sink
1:07:47in and you have thoughts on screen time
1:07:51well so it sounds like none of us are in
1:07:53the camp of like oh I really limited and
1:07:55it's really important and I think it's
1:07:56worth saying that like like so many
1:07:59other things in parenting if people
1:08:00decide to do that in the grand scheme of
1:08:02things I don't think that makes like I
1:08:04don't think that's that's harmful like
1:08:06oh you know we we limit our kids to one
1:08:08hour screen time a day in the grand
1:08:09scheme of things
1:08:10that's probably fine like it everyone
1:08:14does has something that they have a
1:08:15hang-up about everyone thinks the
1:08:17correct balance is a different balance
1:08:19obviously you can go too far by
1:08:20demonizing and making a treat or
1:08:22whatever but bottom line is in the world
1:08:24we live in unless you are Amish and live
1:08:26away from everyone else and don't have
1:08:27electricity there's nothing you can do
1:08:29to stop your kids from learning to that
1:08:33learning to use screens wanting to use
1:08:35screens are going to be forced to use
1:08:36the most schools even public schools
1:08:38have integration with Google Docs and
1:08:40stuff they're going to use computers
1:08:43they're going to use smartphones they're
1:08:45going to want a smartphone they're going
1:08:46to get a smartphone eventually when
1:08:48there
1:08:48it's like there's nothing you can do to
1:08:49stop them from it's like trying to stop
1:08:52your kid from learning how the wheel
1:08:54works like you can't do it like it's
1:08:57going to happen so I don't much mind
1:08:59people who have particular policies
1:09:01about how long any activity should be
1:09:03doing how long should we spend on
1:09:05homework every night no screens after
1:09:088pm know bringing your cell phone into
1:09:11your bedroom one hour using screen time
1:09:14is every Ward using out there are many
1:09:16things you can do to any activity to
1:09:19demonize there to make it the forbidden
1:09:21fruit or like it all really depends on
1:09:23your kid like my parents never let us
1:09:25have soda you would think all they had
1:09:26soda from you when you become an adult
1:09:28to be a soda fiend nope don't like it
1:09:30don't have it right don't have any sort
1:09:32of my house but I different kid being
1:09:34raised in exactly the same way that I
1:09:36was could have come out of that and say
1:09:37oh my god as soon as I get to live a
1:09:39mountain just breaks out all day
1:09:40same exact parenting different kid so as
1:09:43with everything in parenting they're
1:09:45only a series of differently wrong
1:09:47answers there's no right answer
1:09:49you sure you don't have like 37 or so
1:09:53tiny cans of sprite in your house i
1:09:55think i still do have 37 you know why I
1:09:57don't drink them
1:09:58okay we're gonna have to check out there
1:10:00still in the basement but believe me I
1:10:02if I wanted them they would be gone like
1:10:05the samoas were gone because those i do
1:10:07want
1:10:08alright thanks to our three sponsors
1:10:11this week
1:10:12Casper Harry's and amazon prime music
1:10:14and you'll see you next week
1:10:17now the show is over they didn't even
1:10:22mean to begin as it
1:10:25that's a dental death was accidental
1:10:29John racer Margo and Casey would like
1:10:34because it was accidental was accidental
1:10:39and you can find the show know today
1:10:43DP die and if your twitter follow them
1:10:50yes byl ISS so that's Casey list and a
1:10:56co-pay RM Angie Marco Arment and our AC
1:11:03at Syracuse
1:11:18not caramel Delites like some others
1:11:21better firmly in this small camp since
1:11:25Moses it there
1:11:25they're good but they're just I think
1:11:27there's a little bit too much coconut
1:11:28too much coconut is all about the
1:11:30coconut the smallest have darker
1:11:31chocolate and then the coconuts roasted
1:11:33a little bit darker tone and they're
1:11:34actually around an octagon I don't
1:11:37remember what these are certainly heard
1:11:38of them but i know i don't like dark
1:11:39chocolate terribly much I don't like
1:11:41coconut terribly terribly much and I
1:11:43don't like caramel terribly have this is
1:11:44not that is not the cookie for you
1:11:45no definitely not these are girl scout
1:11:47cookies by the way oh yes that's right
1:11:49you're not in America Girl Scouts as a
1:11:52but how would you describe the Girl
1:11:54Scouts the thing little girls go to
1:11:55learn stuff that sounds dismissive but
1:11:59it's actually a reasonable summary
1:12:01yeah anyway they sell cookies to raise
1:12:04money for their girl scouting and those
1:12:07cookies are made by different
1:12:08manufacturers and cookies that look
1:12:11almost the same have different names and
1:12:13are made in a by different makers in
1:12:15different parts of the country and yeah
1:12:19I I you would think it's like whatever
1:12:21girl he grew grew up with those the ones
1:12:23that you love but I don't think that's
1:12:25entirely the case I think you just have
1:12:27to a/b test every single one of the
1:12:29cookies and see which version you like
1:12:31it's not it's not a clear victory for
1:12:32either one of the two manufacturers but
1:12:35small was definitely there everyone kind
1:12:37of like obsess over them but it's more
1:12:39like an artificial scarcity situation
1:12:41where like it only by the certain times
1:12:42a year like that's like and the reality
1:12:45is like almost all of them are delicious
1:12:47because they're really sugary unhealthy
1:12:49cookies like so of course it will be
1:12:51delicious like people obsess over
1:12:52certain flavors like I know I if I had
1:12:55to get the most popular ones are
1:12:57probably thin mints followed by samoas
1:12:59and followed by those are the peanut
1:13:02butter ones that the tagalogs tagalongs
1:13:04I think they may have different names
1:13:07those are very good too but there's not
1:13:09much scarcity in my house i can tell you
1:13:10the artificial scarcities like all the
1:13:12only sold certain times the BBQ by a
1:13:14billion boxes they never run out
1:13:16so according to wikipedia it's thin
1:13:19mints at twenty-five percent of the
1:13:20sales
1:13:21Wow caramel Delites I'm sorry some hours
1:13:24my bad
1:13:25same thing just different name samoas
1:13:27are nineteen percent dough sedo's which
1:13:29are peanut butter sandwiches are 16
1:13:31% and peanut butter patties which are
1:13:33tagalongs are thirteen percent sure
1:13:36which are the ones that is the the the
1:13:38cookie and the peanut butter with
1:13:39chocolate wrapped around it that's
1:13:40tagalongs yeah those are good tagalogs
1:13:43crispy crispy vanilla cookies layered
1:13:45with peanut butter and covered it with a
1:13:46chocolaty coating those cold are amazing
1:13:49my particular favorite is the one that
1:13:51nobody ever buys or like swishes
1:13:53shortbread cookies which are trefoils
1:13:55for truffles I'm not sure you pronounce
1:13:57that but i like those yeah that's good i
1:13:59love those
1:14:00although i think i think all of them
1:14:02like I don't know I'm my cookie snob now
1:14:05I think all of them still basically it's
1:14:07like pre packaged cookies like they do
1:14:10the only ones that I think come close to
1:14:12being elevated to the level of something
1:14:13you might buy like a like a handmade
1:14:15thing in a bakery or the samoas and even
1:14:17those still more or less tastes like
1:14:19just manufactured cookies that I and my
1:14:22old age I get even more expensive tastes
1:14:24and now it's not like handmade in the
1:14:28end a bakery I'm gonna lie i kind of
1:14:31like well I I think of in the sense of
1:14:34do I want to spend my calories on this
1:14:36cookie or do I want to spend it on the
1:14:39most expensive ice cream i can possibly
1:14:41by the ice cream was it was it was
1:14:45incredible waste for facebook gelato
1:14:47things in the hard plastic containers
1:14:49who came up who came up with that idea I
1:14:51I feel terrible everytime i buy one of
1:14:53those terrible because they cost like
1:14:54six blocks terrible because they come
1:14:55with a hard plastic shell that I try to
1:14:57find some reason to use in the house but
1:14:59I don't put those in the dishwasher
1:15:01yeah learn that he isn't guess maybe I'm
1:15:05not maybe the kids will suffocate on
1:15:07those like you put kids toys & them or
1:15:08something or that the jar itself could
1:15:10be a kid's toy but kids can really
1:15:11suffocated on not be any we have we have
1:15:13a few of them around the house like that
1:15:15we've washed out and just like used for
1:15:16containers but the problem is it's kind
1:15:18of like you know those like when you
1:15:20order thai food and you get like 45
1:15:22those black circular containers with the
1:15:25quick like the translucent white lids
1:15:27mmm
1:15:28you know we for a while we would watch
1:15:30those out and save them and reuse them
1:15:32for things
1:15:32yeah but the problem is like the rate at
1:15:34which we would order thai food
1:15:35dramatically outpaced the rate at which
1:15:37we could find user reviews and we have a
1:15:39similar problem with utility gelato
1:15:40containers we probably empty you roughly
1:15:43one or two of those a week so there's
1:15:46basically no way we can find another use
1:15:48for them around the house III said I
1:15:50seriously I seriously don't buy that
1:15:51because of the container like that
1:15:53there's literally stopping me from
1:15:55buying that product more right that and
1:15:57a couple of their their flavors so I
1:15:59feel I could be improved but that but I
1:16:00i go to the store and I'm like I'm kind
1:16:02of in the mood for that but I don't want
1:16:03that container is it just feels wasteful
1:16:05it's like speaking of buying take out
1:16:07like when i get food from one of the
1:16:08local Chinese would take out places and
1:16:10I really give you like a giant styrofoam
1:16:12container from the eighties Miami least
1:16:1318 but it's just like a big white giant
1:16:16thing of styrofoam this is not good for
1:16:17the environment there maybe it's better
1:16:19if I may be so made from like cornstarch
1:16:20and stuff and it's not like the Bad star
1:16:22from former your kids but it just feels
1:16:24wasteful like yeah i know that's if the
1:16:27people from delhi india are listening
1:16:29make more environmentally friendly
1:16:32containers and you'll sell more of your
1:16:33incredibly overpriced ice cream to me
1:16:35wait what is the name of this light
1:16:37screen its twenty how do you spell that
1:16:39tal enti ok so I'm actually like making
1:16:43an environmental statement by buying ben
1:16:45jerry's most of the time for myself
1:16:46because tiff is a tip is mostly tool NT
1:16:49i'm mostly ben jerry's you would you
1:16:52would the Avengers has the docks and
1:16:55sent bench you know the problem is like
1:16:57I i am happy to try other ice creams but
1:17:01ben & jerry's is it i just always go
1:17:03back to that like it is just so much
1:17:05better tasting to me than almost
1:17:06everything else and not just any like
1:17:08one particular flavor like just like
1:17:10their base ice cream is better tasting
1:17:12the most of them know that whatever
1:17:13chemical they're putting in this is as
1:17:15addicting you a guy I am I i do not i'm
1:17:19not don't have a particular brand mildly
1:17:21but I think haagen-dazs probably I think
1:17:24I'm probably more into haagen-dazs the
1:17:25most people at specific flavors but hard
1:17:28as I feel like if you that who has the
1:17:30best of analogy just have plain vanilla
1:17:32ice cream
1:17:32I think has the best vanilla yeah I go
1:17:35with you on that and so so else almond
1:17:38which is basically organized
1:17:39Noah with a little chocolate covered
1:17:41almonds is one of my favorite things
1:17:42ever but Ben & Jerry's new york super
1:17:44fudge chunk talking about has no flavor
1:17:46that competes with that so I'm equal
1:17:49opportunity overpriced ice cream eater
1:17:51so I have a controversial opinion about
1:17:54this and I'm surprised dryers dryers
1:17:58slow churned low-fat vanilla ice cream
1:18:01is the best Manolo found and i should
1:18:03say that was a Bluebell I think it's
1:18:07blue bell ice cream recently arrived in
1:18:09Virginia which I think started somewhere
1:18:11south of here and it was one of those
1:18:13things like 12 cheerwine which doesn't
1:18:16mean anything to you but to a
1:18:19chick-fil-a is a better example so only
1:18:21in South crawling northwards and every
1:18:24or sonic is another great example and
1:18:28everyone I knew had like known someone
1:18:31that that had had Bluebell and swore
1:18:35that it was the best ice cream in the
1:18:37entire world and I've had a few flavors
1:18:41of Bluebell I screen and I actually
1:18:42don't find it to be particularly tasty
1:18:44the dryer slow turn vanilla as stupid as
1:18:48that sounds I mean hey I loved I coke so
1:18:50I know everyone surprised love that I
1:18:53think my only ice cream snobbery is and
1:18:56it only extend so far is that I don't
1:18:58like ice creams that have things in the
1:19:00other than ice cream and i know ben &
1:19:02jerry's falls into that category like it
1:19:04doesn't you should just be like the old
1:19:06briars commercial sudden I really do
1:19:07like briars milk cream sugar they should
1:19:10know camino guar gum there should be no
1:19:12like other things and i know i know ben
1:19:14& jerry's has those like it's another
1:19:15reason i give a little bit of a noggin
1:19:17target has them to some degree as well
1:19:19but a lot of the non super premium
1:19:22brands have all sorts of crazy ass
1:19:24killers and then you can't stand them
1:19:26no i mean like a haagen dazs is really
1:19:28good for keeping the ingredient
1:19:30countdown but usually only for their
1:19:32basic flavors like once you have like
1:19:34you know fillings and like you know like
1:19:36other objects in the ice cream like
1:19:38almonds and stuff or you know or the
1:19:39flavors get more complicated that
1:19:41ingredient was climbs pretty fast and to
1:19:44follow briefly i'm on Casey's Bluebell
1:19:46thing i have not tried Bluebell but i
1:19:49have tried jen use which is i believe
1:19:52the Ohio
1:19:53version its je mi casa es this is like
1:19:56it's also like like a boutique ice cream
1:19:58maker and you can have to order them to
1:20:00be shipped to you in a frozen box
1:20:02I and I had them originally in a store
1:20:05in Ohio and i was visiting their few
1:20:08years back and it in the stores are just
1:20:11amazing their flavors that are really
1:20:14weird and so we ordered them like one
1:20:16time like first from spending
1:20:17Valentine's Day if you a couple years
1:20:19ago we ordered some like a Zach to treat
1:20:20ourselves and so I kind of try to bring
1:20:22back the experience of going to the
1:20:23stores and when you order little pints
1:20:26of of premium ice cream to be shipped to
1:20:28you in a truck
1:20:30it gets pretty expensive it ended up
1:20:32being something like eight or ten
1:20:34dollars a pint
1:20:35so you know and and it just wasn't it
1:20:37like some of the flavors were great some
1:20:40of them were just kind of weird so just
1:20:41like it wasn't really worth it if you if
1:20:44you can go to jenny's store i recommend
1:20:45it but i would not recommend ordering
1:20:47fancy ice cream on the internet it's
1:20:49just not worth it
1:20:50that's our dryer is a as I I don't not
1:20:53that familiar with that name but looking
1:20:55at the packaging I'm like that song of
1:20:56the ones that cellar I can't find the
1:20:58ingredients list for your particular
1:20:59slow churned thing but dryers grande
1:21:01vanilla bean milk cream sugar skim milk
1:21:04looking good so far corn syrup cellulose
1:21:06gum mono and diglycerides not good
1:21:09guar gum dextrose like lots of I don't
1:21:13need all that crap you can you can make
1:21:14good ice cream with just milk cream and
1:21:16sugar and vanilla bean like that dykey
1:21:19Marco said ben jerry's does it too
1:21:21I know they'll do it as soon as you
1:21:22start adding like feeling like oh this
1:21:24heath bars in here he's borrowed just
1:21:25full of crap like obviously and i go
1:21:27ingredients list because guess what
1:21:28these bars in there even just the sugar
1:21:29always has some weird stuff in it but uh
1:21:32I try to try to limit that's why I've
1:21:34always been a briars friend that priors
1:21:36for the most part especially if you
1:21:38don't do like extra creamy or light or
1:21:41any other type of thing where they need
1:21:43to add fillers to try to make the
1:21:44texture back to normal
1:21:45you just buy plain old full fat ice
1:21:47cream or make it yourself we have a nice
1:21:49Commission to make it occasionally it
1:21:50like seriously you just need you just
1:21:53need milk cream sugar and it makes ice
1:21:55cream and is really good and vanilla
1:21:56beans so there's no reason for anything
1:21:58else unless you start taking stuff out
1:21:59or
1:22:00want to make it seem creamier than it
1:22:02actually is this was from a grocery
1:22:04store
1:22:04this is for my slow churned vanilla bean
1:22:07nonfat milk cream sugar corn syrup when
1:22:09I think that at this point I'm out
1:22:11that's all it takes the corn syrup is
1:22:13all right now I mean you know it's sure
1:22:15but you keep going on this is that other
1:22:17fillers that I think more objectionable
1:22:18corn syrup whey protein buttermilk
1:22:22molasses acacia gum carob bean gum guar
1:22:26gum natural flavors grande vanilla beans
1:22:28and whoa carrageenan yeah that's that
1:22:33there's the red stuff to squeeze out of
1:22:34bed bugs weird that's kind of gross
1:22:37anyway that's the entire ingredient list
1:22:40so does that's real time follow-up
1:22:43Carradine and is from edible red seaweed
1:22:45not from red bugs the different thing
1:22:47that comes from red bugs important
1:22:49research on a TV that that's that's too
1:22:52much try breyers vanilla and to see what
1:22:54you're missing
1:22:54I'm sure it's good and i'm not saying
1:22:56that this is the best ever but this is
1:22:58like my go-to ice cream and partially
1:23:00because it is slightly lower fat but you
1:23:02can change your go-to ice cream right
1:23:04that I could I could you could start
1:23:06drinking sprite you know I mean Saturn
1:23:08used to be your go-to car right
1:23:10oh those were the days til the wheels
1:23:12fell off yeah it was great car until
1:23:14then great stereos who