0:00:00We're in luck though, Dan.
0:00:01I mean, it's, we've been, we've both been in this wreck a long time.
0:00:04And, uh, in the years since Mac world rest in peace, pour one out for old Mac
0:00:09world January announcements have been few and far between it's usually sort of a
0:00:15dead zone before spring, which I think honestly is one of the reasons, one of
0:00:20the Apple was not going to stick with macro expo for long anyway, they want to
0:00:24They were shifting from a, we're one of many companies in this industry and we do things
0:00:34that normal companies in this industry do to we're Apple.
0:00:42My favorite story about the year we were at Macworld Expo when Apple had pulled out, I
0:00:46was actually doing a talk on the show floor with our pals, Paul Kvassus, John Moltz, and
0:00:52a guy stopped us after our little talk on the floor,
0:00:55and he was from Germany,
0:00:57and he asked us where the Apple booth was.
0:00:59(laughs)
0:01:00And we're like, "Sorry, bad news."
0:01:02And in the year since, I think Paul ad-libbed this,
0:01:04but he had the, "But I have flown all the way from Germany
0:01:07to see the Apple booth."
0:01:08He just looked very forlorn.
0:01:11We were like, "Sorry to break it to you,
0:01:13but there's an Apple store, you can walk there,
0:01:15it's pretty much the same thing."
0:01:17- It was very sad, sad but funny at the same time.
0:01:22Apple, you know, who knows we might still get some springtime announcements in recent years
0:01:27There's often been something in the march april time frame, you know, and and because they don't have these
0:01:34uh set in stone
0:01:37conferences like macworld to worry about they you know,
0:01:40They just announce them when they're ready and if it's you know
0:01:43The last week of march or it's the second week of april. It doesn't matter
0:01:46there's no tradition really the only two things that seem to be on a dead set annual schedule are
0:01:53WWDC somewhere in like with a starting date on a Monday with single digits in June right might be
0:02:02the first Monday might be the second Monday but it probably starts with a single digit and an iPhone
0:02:09event in like the first Tuesday after Labor Day in September roughly you know
0:02:15one of those first Tuesdays in September and everything else has some float
0:02:21that's based on their schedule but I can't help but think that when they did
0:02:26pull the pull on pull the plug on Mac world or their participation in Mac
0:02:30world January is just never a good month for Apple it just it's just not you know
0:02:35Why in the world would you come out with new stuff in January on the whole right? Because you want to get it out for the holidays
0:02:41Else you don't want to spend your holidays preparing getting something out. But here we are was right. Yeah
0:02:48Well, it was weird too because I mean also in the past like, you know Mac world and CES always collided like and that was kind
0:02:55Of weird and it felt like maybe yeah, you want to be it like be in the CES timeframe
0:03:00but they weren't usually at CES or even if they were,
0:03:03they weren't doing anything official there.
0:03:05And as you said, you don't wanna do stuff
0:03:08after the holiday quarter.
0:03:10This one is a little weird too,
0:03:11because the supposition around it seems to be
0:03:13that they wanted to do it in the fall.
0:03:16Like, it just wasn't ready to go,
0:03:18so they pushed it off to the next best time, I guess,
0:03:22whenever they're ready to ship in the quantities
0:03:24they need to, which was January.
0:03:26- Yeah, I pointed out, I think I might have been first,
0:03:29I'm never first for anything anymore, but that the URL for the event video had like two 2022s in it.
0:03:38Somebody else once... somebody else would have noticed that anyway, but once the internet was
0:03:46off to the races on that, some people looked at those AR widgets. I don't know what we call...
0:03:53what do we call those things? Whenever they come out with a new product and there's like,
0:03:57Hey, you know, you can pretend you have, is there a word? Yeah, I don't know. But it's like they
0:04:03make little, when they make new, you know, it's like a tradition they've been doing for
0:04:07several years now. It's not just like, oh, it's because the headset's imminent, but for several
0:04:11years they have a new product. They'll put these, they'll make these AR models of the thing,
0:04:16whatever it is. And then you can use your phone and project it onto a tabletop in front of you.
0:04:21And anyway, somebody poked around those AR models and or scenes, maybe you'd call them AR scenes,
0:04:28but it's really more... But it's not really a scene. It's like putting a virtual object in
0:04:32front of you. Yeah, anyway, they were compiled, if that's the right verb, in October 11th. And
0:04:39people who look at such things snooping for details claim that almost inevitably
0:04:47those AR models final compilation date is within like the final week of the event or when they come
0:04:54out which leads you know you know and and it is interesting anyway that the the products we're
0:05:01talking about are the new uh m2 macbook pros the real macbook pros 14 and 16 inch with the m2
0:05:11Pro and M2 Macs chips and the M2 Mac Minis which aren't quite limited to the Pro and
0:05:21Macs because there's also the just plain M2 Mac Mini.
0:05:25It's all, it's not confusing when you lay it out.
0:05:28It's a little confusing to talk about.
0:05:30And yeah, yeah, well, and HomePod second generation, which will...
0:05:36And HomePods, yeah.
0:05:38Right.
0:05:39Everybody knew that the MacBook Pros were going to move to the M2.
0:05:46That was money in the bank.
0:05:47I think that the first 14 and 16-inch M1 Pro and MacBook Pros were so well received and
0:05:54were a hardware refresh, it's unsurprising that they are true speed bumps in the classical
0:06:01sense where it's almost impossible to tell them apart other than by booting them up and
0:06:07going to About This Mac to see what the hell Chip is inside. The Mac Mini was more a little
0:06:15bit more of a question mark, right? Because, you know, the Intel one was hanging around
0:06:23there for a little while. I mean, they had that M1 and so it seemed logical, obviously,
0:06:27that you get an M2, but then the question was, why is there an Intel still? What are
0:06:32you doing with that? Right. And it's, you know, this is why it's fun to have a podcast
0:06:36in this space because it gave us plenty to talk about. But the basic thinking is, okay,
0:06:40the old way, and there's a very clear division between old and new, which is going from Intel
0:06:46to Apple Silicon, the old Intel way. At the very end, it was only for like maybe the last
0:06:52three years, two years of the product life, but they effectively had two versions of the
0:06:58Mac Mini, which I would describe, they didn't call it the Mac Mini Pro, but I'll say with
0:07:05a lowercase P not as a product name, but just as an adjective. There was the pro version
0:07:10with four USB ports or Thunderbolt ports, whatever the hell they are, and the lower
0:07:16end version with only two ports. And at the end of the Intel era, they were all they were
0:07:21easily discerned because the higher end ones with four ports were space gray and lower
0:07:27end ones were silver, aluminum, same footprint, but more ports and a cooler space. In my opinion,
0:07:34space gray color and if you're man and at lots and lots of you know there's
0:07:40lots of people who just buy a Mac Mini as a consumer and hook it up to a
0:07:44display and it's there that's their desktop Mac and then you know as Apple
0:07:49is now very happy to point out there's lots of professional uses of the Mac
0:07:55Mini audio and video production and the Mac Mini colocation with companies like
0:08:03Mac Stadium who are not sponsoring this episode but have sponsored my show for years and years,
0:08:08great company, where you might have lots and lots of Mac Minis together. I can't help but think the
0:08:13color coding was a nice something, you know, a nice little way of knowing what you're looking
0:08:18at if you're looking at like three or four of them or a dozen of them all together.
0:08:22Yeah, yeah, well, I think it hits the nail on the head, which is that essentially it was two
0:08:29products. And I think that's the through line has continued, you know, now to the M2 and
0:08:35M2 Pro variants, that it's essentially like your low cost intro level computer, which
0:08:39is what the Mac mini was originally introduced as when they, you know, came out with it almost
0:08:4320 years ago, was like, hey, we need to convert PC users. Here's a cheap, which was at the
0:08:49time kind of, I think, unprecedented for Apple, like let's make a cheap entry level computer
0:08:56And then not say it's cheap in terms of the way it's put together, but like it's at a
0:08:59low cost, which is not a market that Apple traditionally played in.
0:09:03They were not competing with a $500 Dell that you bought.
0:09:07They were playing in the $1,000 plus space.
0:09:09And so they cut their costs by not having it, doesn't have a display, doesn't come with
0:09:13a keyboard, doesn't come with a pointy device of any kind.
0:09:15And so that was always sort of like, "Hey, you claim Macs are too expensive.
0:09:19Well, here's one for 500 bucks that you can get."
0:09:22it use it with whatever keyboard you have laying around or exactly buy a cheap third-party keyboard
0:09:27if you want or whatever um yeah i guess you know we now know the answer so we're working backwards
0:09:35but it was an open question with the existence of the mac studio from last year whether they ever
0:09:42would do the more pro tier mac mini again because the m1 version had no pro variant it only had a two
0:09:51port version it came you know this specs ranged a little bit within the m1 range
0:09:56but you know only up to where wherever the m1 went without being the m1 pro or
0:10:03or whatever and I guess the question was does the max studio start right above
0:10:10that and that's why or were they going to do this well they you know obviously
0:10:17wanted to. Why they didn't have a four port version in the M1 generation is one of those
0:10:23things we'll never get an answer to. But yeah, I feel like they fell prey to timing a little
0:10:30bit on that one just because the M1 Mini came out at the same time when the M1 debuted, right?
0:10:35It was the first one with the Air to make the transition. So they obviously didn't have the
0:10:39M1 Pro ready to go at that point. That didn't happen for another nine months. Right. And I
0:10:45Yeah mid-stream is weird to to change it too
0:10:48And I I wonder you know and again
0:10:51This is one of those things apple never makes excuses about everything that happened during covid or even the continuing to this day
0:10:58supply chain
0:11:00repercussions of that whole stretch
0:11:02Was that if covid hadn't happened might there have been?
0:11:08m1 pro mac mini when
0:11:12the 14 inch and 16 inch MacBook Pros were first introduced a year after the M1 Mac Mini,
0:11:19maybe, you know, I just wonder if their prioritization of we're only going to make so
0:11:26many of these M2 Pro chips, we've got to allocate them all to the MacBook Pros, the MacBook Pro is,
0:11:32you know, Apple loves the Mac Mini more than they've ever loved it in its entire existence,
0:11:38but clearly, but let's face it, the MacBook Pro.
0:11:41- It's not the MacBook Pro, it's not the MacBook Pro.
0:11:43That's like the flagship, right?
0:11:45- Right, the flagship Macs are the MacBook Pros,
0:11:47the real ones, the 14 and 16 inch,
0:11:49and the tried and true single most important Mac
0:11:54in the world is the MacBook Air.
0:11:56Everything after that is second fiddle at best,
0:12:00even if it's getting love.
0:12:01So I don't know.
0:12:02The other thing Apple definitely has always done
0:12:06is they they hold spots in the lineup when they want to come back to them even it when it gets
0:12:12awkward so i thought that continuing to sell the intel four port mac mini up until these machines
0:12:21came out yeah i thought it was more of a sign that they were going to eventually fill that spot in
0:12:28with a mac mini with apple silicon which is what they've done and not about we need something we
0:12:36We need to keep selling something Intel-based
0:12:39that's not crazy expensive like the Mac Pro.
0:12:43Something in that price range for our pro people
0:12:48who have, for whatever reason, they need Intel.
0:12:53That it's scientific computing
0:12:55and they're using Intel compilers
0:12:58or just they need to plug and play with an Intel workflow
0:13:05they've already got, who knows? I think it was a nice side effect. I think it's primarily just that
0:13:10they wanted to hold the spot and they always wanted to fill it with Apple Silicon.
0:13:13Yeah, yeah. I mean, if they had been moving to something else, like the Mac Studio or something,
0:13:19I think they would have had no qualms about just discontinuing that Intel Mac Mini. I think they
0:13:23just would have been like, "See, here's the Mac Mini. It's an M1. That's it." And people would
0:13:27have been like, "I guess that's the writings on the wall for that higher-end Mac Mini." And I don't
0:13:31think they have so much nostalgia. Nostalgia is not quite the right term, but I don't think Apple
0:13:37cares enough about Intel to want to leave one around just for that safety's sake or what have
0:13:43you. I don't think they really care. I think they want it to be an all-in on Apple Silicon,
0:13:47obviously. And that's what we're seeing now with the exception, the asterisk of Mac Pro.
0:13:52So having that there, I think you're totally right, was a placeholder for, "This is coming.
0:13:57it's just not ready yet. But it was weird too, because it left this weird gap in the lineup when
0:14:03the Mac Studio did come out, right? Because you could buy an M1 and it would be, I think it went
0:14:09up in the, what, close to 1,000 if you maxed out your M1 Mac Mini or whatever, maybe slightly over.
0:14:15And then it was like, you got to go all the way to the Mac Studio, which is two grand for a base
0:14:20level configuration. And everyone's like, "Well, if I want something better than an M1, but I don't
0:14:25want to drop two thousand dollars on a m1 max max studio there's nothing there's nothing in that
0:14:31area at all in apple silicon which always felt weird and i felt like another compelling reason
0:14:35that there would be a higher end mac mini is just to bridge that slightly yeah i thought so too um
0:14:42so you wrote for six colors the uh you handled the mac mini jason snell handled the macbook pro
0:14:49how would you summarize your review of the Mac Mini?
0:14:52I think what the most important thing about the Mac Mini is,
0:14:56kind of like you described the MacBook Pros as speed bump, this is exactly what we kind of expected,
0:15:01right? Like we said, the Mac Mini is two products. It's that lower end Mac, but it's also this pro
0:15:06level Mac. And of course, the ones they sent out to the reviewers were the M2 Pros, which is on my
0:15:11desk here. So, you know, it's an attempt to sort of provide a professional level desktop that is
0:15:18somewhere in between. You need something more than a vanilla M2 and not as much as a Mac Studio.
0:15:25But unlike the Mac Studio, the Mac Mini has been around so long that Apple's gotten really good.
0:15:30They know what this device is, they know what this product is, they've made it for over 20 years.
0:15:37And it's not going to surprise you in terms of what it's offering. The specs are pretty much
0:15:43exactly what we expected.
0:15:45But it delivers on all of that.
0:15:47And I will say the it really impressed me,
0:15:49the performance of the M2 Pro.
0:15:51I have an M1 Air.
0:15:54That's what I was using as sort of my daily driver before this.
0:15:57And, you know, the M2 Pro kind of knocks its socks off
0:16:00in a bunch of different directions.
0:16:03And then I think one of the, you know, it does it
0:16:05in not only handily, but also super quietly.
0:16:08That's the thing that really impressed me about this is like
0:16:11I was running tests where I was like, you know,
0:16:13getting all the CPUs, all the performance cores,
0:16:16maxing them out, whatever, running graphics tests.
0:16:18I swear I never heard the fan on this thing.
0:16:20It is so quiet.
0:16:22It's kind of bananas that they,
0:16:24like I checked at one point and downloaded an app,
0:16:26I'm like, there is a fan in this, right?
0:16:28Let me make sure.
0:16:30- One of my favorite reviews was iJustine's on YouTube,
0:16:35and she, I don't have it handy,
0:16:39but she invited a friend of hers
0:16:41who is a out in Los Angeles, a professional colorist,
0:16:45color grading expert for video.
0:16:47And they were grading
0:16:504K or 8K footage, I don't know,
0:16:53but it might have been 8K footage.
0:16:55And very, very just a stressful, stressful test.
0:17:00And watching some of the video pros like her and MKBHD
0:17:06is for me a great way of getting practical feedback
0:17:09from people who really push machines in ways that typically would engage fans
0:17:16without artificial benchmarks and it was the funniest part of the video was her
0:17:20and her friend after they'd went through it and they were impressed by the
0:17:24performance they weren't waiting for anything and then they were like trying
0:17:27to figure out if the fans were on this yeah right yeah and no and the guy was
0:17:32like I think it is and she's like no that's the key light and he like listen
0:17:37like, "Oh, you're right, you know, they had like a light in front of their studio," and he's like,
0:17:40"Yeah, it's up there. That's the light," and he's like, "Yeah, I don't think it's up."
0:17:43It's like, "You don't know," and it's like, "You think? Well, it's, I don't know, it's gotta be.
0:17:46We were just, we were just crushing this thing."
0:17:49Yeah, I like put my, I put my Apple Watch, like, the decibel meter up to the back of it to see if
0:17:55it would make a difference. Couldn't tell it, and I had the same thing where I'm listening like,
0:17:57"Okay, I hear something." It's like, "No, that's my Synology in the corner. Like, it's not even,
0:18:02it's not even coming from this area." It's, it's good. I do think
0:18:07think you know I think that your m1 air is probably I would define as the baseline that
0:18:12would be like the 1.0 or the squared is a zero on you know the the rating scale for apple silicon
0:18:23that's the baseline for apple silicon it's a great machine and we're you know to me it's impressive
0:18:28that as much as we raved about the just plain non-pro M1 Macs from 2020 and to 2020 and
0:18:37how what a breakthrough they were in performance and the ways that you really can see you could
0:18:47feel and measure the benefits of unified memory architecture and that having this memory that
0:18:55is shared is not, it's an advantage as opposed to being the cheaping out in the back Intel days
0:19:03with integrated graphics. When you're doing these things that are video intensive, being able to
0:19:09share the same memory is just, you're just, the computer isn't doing the shuffling between cache
0:19:17and this memory and that memory that had to be done before. It's just there, it's all on a fast
0:19:23bus, everything that you'd want to be fast in production, not just artificial benchmarks,
0:19:28but in actual production, doing real things that you really do, man, you just not waiting for it.
0:19:34And now here we are. And we're already like, I could see how slow those were.
0:19:38Well, it's funny to the RAM thing, particularly, I think for a long time, you know, computer users,
0:19:45Mac users, like you and me, like, are the conventional wisdom for so long was like,
0:19:49like, you know, you buy as much RAM as you can afford.
0:19:51And I feel like this has thrown me for a bit of a loop
0:19:54in the modern era when I'm actually speccing out machines
0:19:56like, do I really need 32 gigs?
0:19:58I mean, the 16 gigs are pretty good.
0:20:01And with the unified memory architecture,
0:20:03it really doesn't feel like I'm running out of memory
0:20:05all the time or running into that as the ceiling.
0:20:08And I struggle with it because it is still expensive, right?
0:20:11You're spending a few hundred bucks to go up in RAM costs
0:20:14and you're like, oh, is it worth it?
0:20:15I just, it has kind of thrown for a loop
0:20:18this, you know, my conventional wisdom for buying Macs.
0:20:22And, you know, I guess we shouldn't be surprised
0:20:25to see the year over year improvements.
0:20:26We've seen them, you know, with the iPad and the iPhone
0:20:29for the last decade plus, like, you know,
0:20:32Apple just continually every year comes out with a chip
0:20:34that's just a little bit faster.
0:20:36And, you know, it seems like the Mac is kind of
0:20:38on the same trajectory, like, yep, that M1, you know,
0:20:41the M1 from Intel is a huge jump, right?
0:20:43That's night and day.
0:20:46But, you know, little incremental improvements
0:20:48year over year and all the other stuff they've added in,
0:20:51right, the improved memory bandwidth,
0:20:54the neural engine, graphics cores out the Wazoo, basically,
0:20:58like all that stuff has added up.
0:21:01And so, yeah, I mean, it is kind of wild that, you know,
0:21:05a couple years later, it was in like, yeah,
0:21:07that M1's old hat, it's time for the M2.
0:21:11- I think, you know, it's very safe to say,
0:21:13and I know some people, I'm not gonna name names,
0:21:16but there are reviewers and commentators out there
0:21:20who always poo poo speed bumps
0:21:24because they're not exciting, right?
0:21:25There's some people whose brains are wired up
0:21:29to only get excited with the dopamine hit
0:21:32that comes from an altogether new design.
0:21:36But I think speed, I've always thought
0:21:39that speed bumps are great because they're,
0:21:43or at least they are when you're,
0:21:45you've got a hardware foundation that you're happy with.
0:21:48And I think, you know, for what it is,
0:21:51the Mac Mini is pretty simple hardware to describe.
0:21:55It's, you know, small footprint, small height,
0:21:57and, you know, fewer or more ports,
0:22:00depending on how much you pay.
0:22:02I think the 14 and 16-inch MacBook Pros are fantastic.
0:22:05I bought last year, or the very end of the year before,
0:22:10whenever, the 14-inch M1
0:22:12uh m1 macbook pro and i i'd same as you i i did
0:22:19my pet thing is yes buy as much ram as i need
0:22:23and my main ram need is my terrible terrible safari tab hoarding
0:22:29problem where i literally have and i know this
0:22:33bothers some people who are habitual tab tidiers
0:22:36um literally hundreds of open safari tabs at a time and safari deals with
0:22:42that far better in my experience than any Chrome-based browser, not to get into a Safari
0:22:48versus Chrome argument, but Safari does a very good job of keeping background tabs from running
0:22:55a muck CPU-wise, but the RAM adds up. And I do hunt for those tabs. I keep them open for a reason,
0:23:03and it's like with the old days when I was swapping because I'd run out of real memory
0:23:09because of all my tabs and I'd go to a tab that had been swapped out, then you'd get the beach
0:23:14ball for a second or you know or even if the beach ball didn't appear it just took a while for that
0:23:19tab to come forward whereas now it's just instantaneous. I did buy mine with the full
0:23:24last year's maximum 64 gigs of ren. I have checked every so often. I was going to say have they made
0:23:30enough ram for no safari they have and I and I've also noticed and I will say this as a you know as
0:23:39compliment as somebody who's known you know and openly criticizes the
0:23:46reliability of Apple software on a regular basis that with Mac OS the later
0:23:56versions of Mac OS 12 and all of I switched to Ventura on my my real Mac
0:24:01the one I work on when 13.1 came out I kind of think I could have gone with
0:24:0613.0 and I wouldn't have been unhappy.
0:24:08It's just that I'm a little conservative
0:24:11just because you can't go backwards easily.
0:24:14And I just, it literally depend on it.
0:24:17But just a couple, I don't know, a week or two ago,
0:24:20or probably about a week ago, I checked
0:24:23and my uptime was like 29 days.
0:24:26I hadn't restarted my Mac in 29 days.
0:24:28Didn't notice, went to Activity Monitor
0:24:32and still swap, was it zero?
0:24:34it still hadn't swapped any memory at all with hundreds of tabs open for 29 days. So 64 is
0:24:41obvious. That's pretty impressive. Well, and the other thing that's really nice about that
0:24:45is it's the, you know, out of RAM, CPU, and GPU, RAM's the one where I know that I can use it.
0:24:53So now that this year's new models go up to 96, I have no temptation because I couldn't,
0:24:58I if I couldn't swap at all in a month with 64 I guess 64 is enough for me so yeah no that's good
0:25:07logic I don't think I guess the other thing that I always I try to concentrate on reviews I know you
0:25:14do too is knowing that most almost every product that Apple makes is not really intended for the
0:25:23owners of the previous generation one to immediately upgrade to it and that's
0:25:30part of the thing where their products are not super low price there you know
0:25:33widely regarded as premium price but when you buy a $400 Apple watch you're
0:25:40supposed to get several years of life out of it it's a $400 watch most people
0:25:45most Apple watch users have never bought a watch probably even half the price of
0:25:50of their Apple Watch. It's expensive for a watch by most peaceable standards.
0:25:55So it should last years and years. You're not supposed to compare the Series 7 to the Series 8
0:26:00other than just showing what is, you know, it's interesting to see what the year-over-year
0:26:05improvements are, but that's not really the buying guide part. The buying guide is more
0:26:09for people who own like a Series 4 or Series 5, right? MacBook Pro, if you bought a $5,000,
0:26:16four or five thousand dollar m1 MacBook Pro with lots of RAM and maybe the extra SSD and whatever
0:26:23else you're supposed to get more than a year or 18 months out of it for sure like I love getting
0:26:29a Mac setup just the way I like it and then using it for years and not having to worry about
0:26:33upgrading this or that is so you know our m1 MacBook Pro users going to want to upgrade to
0:26:41this almost certainly not unless you know you do unless you know that a 30% difference in GPU
0:26:49is going to save you noticeable time because you're doing 8k video exports on a regular basis
0:26:56that peg all of the GPUs or as best that the software you're using can and a 30% improvement
0:27:02would be noticeable. Yeah, I mean, and I think I was in some ways really well situated for dealing
0:27:10with the Mini in particular, because I had a 5K iMac, an Intel 2017 model that basically
0:27:18went belly up over last summer. So I was left with just my air, which is the reason it was
0:27:23sort of my only computer for a while there. So I'd been in the market already. I was like,
0:27:27"Well, I know I've got my Intel iMac. I'm going to replace this with Apple Silicon,
0:27:31obviously, because it's only a matter of time." And I found myself thinking, "Well, all the
0:27:36Apple authors in the iMac department is an M1, and they're not seemingly making a larger
0:27:42version any time soon. So it seems like the Mac Mini or Mac Studio is something that I
0:27:47am really well situated to review, because that's probably what I'm going to end up replacing
0:27:54with. And so comparing the M2 Pro Mac Mini with stuff that I was doing on my iMac, like
0:28:00you said, you get that multi-year benefit. Not only is it like five, six years newer,
0:28:05But it's also got the transition from Intel to Apple Silicon.
0:28:09If you're coming from an Intel computer to the Apple Silicon, it is just bananas.
0:28:14The biggest test that kind of blew me away on the M2 Pro Mini was I did some video streaming
0:28:19stuff.
0:28:20Not a lot, but I used OBS and I've used Ecamm Live to do some video streaming for our actual
0:28:25Play D&D podcast over at The Incomparable.
0:28:28And I handle a lot of the streaming on that.
0:28:30And running that on my Intel iMac was painful.
0:28:33OBS was not well, you know,
0:28:36it wasn't really taking advantage of all the Apple frameworks
0:28:41that were available. I don't think the hardware,
0:28:44like encoding a video or anything ever really worked.
0:28:47They were actually using the wrong framework for display capture stuff.
0:28:52Apple had to check in a code fix for them,
0:28:54which is my favorite.
0:28:56They went like, "Yeah, guys, you're not supposed to be using this.
0:28:59That's why your frame rates suck."
0:29:01So I finally, I'd switched to Ecamm Live because, you know,
0:29:05those guys, they know what they're doing.
0:29:07They're Mac guys, right?
0:29:07Like everything is optimized,
0:29:09ran on Apple, Silicon, Native, all that.
0:29:11And I was pretty happy with that.
0:29:12But for this test, I downloaded OBS to do some light
0:29:15streaming just to test it out.
0:29:17And I went through and like set it all up.
0:29:20And I'm, you know, running, streaming like a,
0:29:23playing like a game for my PS5 via the app on my Mac.
0:29:26And I'm streaming that and I'm streaming continuity camera
0:29:28from my iPhone and the CPU meter down at the bottom
0:29:32is at 5% and I'm like, what the hell?
0:29:37This would heal my iMac.
0:29:40It would just leave it chugging along
0:29:42and I would have terrible performance
0:29:43and this was incredibly smooth
0:29:46and you got the feeling that Apple really spent some time,
0:29:48like, you know, game streaming is kind of a niche audience
0:29:51but it's something that shows off performance well
0:29:53and I think Apple spent the time to try
0:29:55and make sure that something like OBS,
0:29:56which is one of the sort of standards in the industry,
0:29:59works well on Apple Silicon, and it does.
0:30:02I mean, it still looks kind of crappy
0:30:04'cause it's an open source app that's cross-platform,
0:30:07but it performs really nicely on a M2 Pro.
0:30:11So that to me was kind of the moment that I was like,
0:30:14all right, this can handle pretty much anything
0:30:16I can throw at it.
0:30:17- You pointed out in your review what I alluded to earlier,
0:30:22that they still have not brought back Space Gray.
0:30:25You can get, as you said, you can get your Mac Mini in a wide range of specs,
0:30:30but you can get it in and any color you want, so long as the color is silver.
0:30:34I find that a little disappointing, especially since
0:30:38they have so few colors in the Mac lineup already,
0:30:43you know, and everybody, you know, midnight was exciting.
0:30:46Midnight is the the midnight MacBook Air's
0:30:49is the most exciting new Mac color in a long time.
0:30:52And that's not saying much because that's a pretty close to dark gray blue, the midnight.
0:30:59But the iMac, why the iMac has great colors?
0:31:03The iMac has great colors, right. I'll just say that's great colors and there's a lot of people
0:31:09who would like to see that spread throughout more Macs. You know, is the Mac Mini going to get iMac
0:31:17style colors? Why not? I don't know. But at the very least though, going, it not only
0:31:23didn't get any fun colors like, you know, red, yellow, green type pink colors, it actually
0:31:30lost space gray, like which is really pretty sad.
0:31:35I don't know. Yeah, I mean that is one of my few dings I think on them. The other one
0:31:40being the Mac studio showed that Apple was willing to sort of mar the design of their
0:31:47beautiful hardware by putting ports on the front, which I think everybody was a big fan of. And it
0:31:52disappoints me that the Mac Mini did not follow in that I could have used just one, you know,
0:31:57Thunderbolt or even a USB C port on the front. Like, I was testing out that feature they rolled
0:32:01out where the security keys hardware security keys for your Apple ID. And I'm like, I've got one of
0:32:07these Yubico keys. And I'm like, I gotta go behind the computer to like plug this in. This is super
0:32:13annoying like i i don't understand why you aren't willing to put even on just
0:32:16the m2 pro version like stick a port on the front there it kind
0:32:20of that that drives me a little nuts yeah
0:32:23especially since like you said the studio
0:32:27you don't have to even be a mac user let alone a sort of mac pundit reviewer
0:32:35to look at the two and say oh that's like the big
0:32:38brother and that's the little brother you know that's this is the big version
0:32:42big tall version of the mini, they're obviously from the same company, you know instantaneous,
0:32:50you know they're siblings. And so that sort of, yeah okay for years we've avoided putting ports
0:32:57on the front, you know and the argument against ports on the front is, I can't see how it's
0:33:02anything other than aesthetic. The people who buy a Mac Mini, it's not really a showcase device
0:33:09and it's so practical to have easy access to the front case, you know, for plugging in.
0:33:15And then, you know, that's the whole point of it's the whole point of thunderbolt in these ports is
0:33:21that you can you can have a literally mini form factor and expand it and you can have additional
0:33:31SSD storage or if you want to go even bigger, you know, some kind of still use the spinning hard
0:33:37disk to get it you know enormous capacity cameras right plugging in a camera or plugging a card
0:33:46reader in so you can read photos from a camera and it's like there's a lot of people who shoot
0:33:52photos with cameras that use cards and they need to connect it and it's not like oh one time i got
0:33:59a new keyboard after three years i need to reach around the back and plug it in it's something they
0:34:03do every day. So I... Yeah right and the aesthetics thing doesn't even hold up then because like if
0:34:09you're sticking a card reader on it it's like I've already marred your perfect setup by having
0:34:13a card reader hanging off of it so you might as well at least let me do it easily. I don't know,
0:34:19it strikes me as strange. I understand like they've got the whole you know machine tooling
0:34:23process down and they don't you know stick in a couple more holes in the case or wiring those
0:34:28ports at the front, I'm sure it's an added cost. But if you're going to at least offer ones that
0:34:34have four Thunderbolt ports instead of just two or whatever, it feels like it wouldn't be a huge
0:34:40stretch to at least offer something that's a little more accessible. But I guess they are
0:34:45committed to that being a pro-level luxury. If you want parts in the front, that's $2,000.
0:34:52Yeah, whether you need that performance or not or whether it's in your budget or not
0:34:56It's you know, and so there's a lot of people who if if the mini really suits their needs they'll just put up with
0:35:01Reaching around the back every single time they need to be on the card or whatever
0:35:08Do think from Apple's?
0:35:10Messaging and this is where we get into the Kremlin ology part of it
0:35:18Seems to me, you know one of going from the old Intel era to this era
0:35:23Obviously, we're still waiting to hear the Mac Pro story, right?
0:35:27And you know, we know it's coming because they went out of their way and in a very unusual edit
0:35:31Yeah, John Ternus finished the studio announcement last year with we've got one more to go
0:35:36Something I think obviously went wrong from their original
0:35:42Plan because they did say it would the whole transition would only take two years and it's obviously going to take three years
0:35:49And I guess and you know without delving into rumors of what the Mac Pro
0:35:56Is going to be too much. It's you know, I think more or less it just skipped the m1 generation
0:36:03It would be shocking if it came out with an m1 ultra or m1 extreme then that's the Mac Pro at this point
0:36:09You know almost you know it just skip the m1. I guess it's gonna come out with an m2
0:36:14Something I don't know what they're gonna call the chip
0:36:17but the other
0:36:20computer from the Intel era that
0:36:23People so people who love it love it is the 27 inch I'm and
0:36:29Didn't make it they you know they call the 24 inch m1. I max just the I max
0:36:38There's no other name to them. I mean obviously they could come they could come out with a 27 inch model
0:36:43And it would be like the MacBook Pros to get the iMac in two sizes 24 or 27
0:36:47I wouldn't be surprised if they do that. I mean it wouldn't be shocking. I know it would make some people happy
0:36:52but reading between the lines of Apple's marketing material and the
0:36:58Briefings that we were offered is as as reviewers. You know which are off the record. I can't quote them
0:37:07But reading between the lines of what they said, it seems like they're
0:37:12steering people to think of a Mac Mini connected to a Mac Studio display as the
0:37:18new lot, you know, larger than the iMac 24 inches 5k display. That's the answer. And
0:37:29honestly, I know there are people who love those iMacs. I owned and used the
0:37:34heck out of a 2014 5k iMac and it was um I loved it it was just one that you know
0:37:40probably my favorite into definitely my favorite Intel error desktop but I
0:37:44actually like this better because I still feel bad about the fact that I
0:37:50I've got my my 2014 iMac is just sitting in a box now because the display is
0:37:59still fantastic it is absolutely you know right I don't I don't want to use a
0:38:032014 Intel computer at all but the display is fantastic I'd still have bought the Mac
0:38:10Studio last year display because I wanted the nano texture and I but it's a real weird shame
0:38:18that I wasn't able to use my 5k gorgeous display just as a display I'm looking I'm looking at my
0:38:2627 inch from 2017 it's on the floor in my office because I haven't figured out what to do with it
0:38:31But I have the same feeling because it's like for a while there.
0:38:33We had that the target display mode where you could use an iMac
0:38:37as a display. It was a very small window.
0:38:39Yeah, let you do that.
0:38:40And it does feel like a shame because I'm sitting here thinking like,
0:38:44I mean, the panel is basically the same in the studio display is in this iMac.
0:38:48Like I went out and spent a lot of money and, you know, had to buy
0:38:51another thing to duplicate that where it would have been nice
0:38:54if I could have just plug this Mac mini into that iMac and been done with it.
0:38:57But yeah, it's not.
0:38:59I guess that's just too expensive to do as a piece of technology. I don't know. It struck me
0:39:07as strange as well. You could see even in the press releases when they talked about the M2 Pro
0:39:12Mac Mini and the announcement press release they put out, they compared it to a 27-inch Intel iMac
0:39:18as a performance thing. Clearly, yeah, this is how we're positioning this. So I can't argue with it.
0:39:25And I agree, I like the idea that at least when I,
0:39:28you know, if I buy an M2 Pro Mac Mini
0:39:30and I use it for a few years,
0:39:31I can swap it out and keep the display.
0:39:33That's assuming they haven't made, you know,
0:39:35another fancy new display,
0:39:36but I'm sure this one will keep working for the interim.
0:39:39So I'm invested now, and it does raise the price too, right?
0:39:42Like buying a Mac Mini and an Apple Studio display.
0:39:45If you're buying an M2 Pro and a Mac Mini,
0:39:47so you're talking a couple thousand dollars, $2,500,
0:39:50which is, I guess, around the price you paid
0:39:51for a 2070-inch iMac, but it, you know,
0:39:53Hopefully the investment pays out a little bit longer
0:39:56and you can keep these hardware sort of rotating through.
0:39:58- Yeah, I don't think it's any exaggeration.
0:40:01I know in our racket it's pretty hard to say
0:40:03blank is gonna still be useful in 10 years,
0:40:05but I think a MacStudio display you buy now
0:40:08is very likely to be a very good,
0:40:09credible display 10 years from now.
0:40:13And so who knows how many Mac Minis you might upgrade
0:40:16between now and then, and you're saving
0:40:19tremendous amount of money by just plugging it back
0:40:22into the MacStudio display you already own.
0:40:24- Yeah.
0:40:25- And it's not just, it is environmentally sound, right?
0:40:29Not to be making all these displays that you, you know,
0:40:33just put in your basement like mine
0:40:35or put on your office floor like yours.
0:40:37But it's just more cost effective to think of the display
0:40:42as a modular part of your desktop.
0:40:44And I know, you know, people who really, really love
0:40:49the all-in-one don't wanna hear it,
0:40:50But to me, that's a better solution.
0:40:53I don't think they're ever gonna come back
0:40:55with a bigger iMac again.
0:40:57I wonder, I guess rumors say there's going to be M2 iMacs.
0:41:02I wonder, I don't know, I guess I've seen some rumors
0:41:05that say the iMac might wait 'til the M3.
0:41:07I wonder about the iMac period,
0:41:09whether or not it has a future.
0:41:12Is all-in-one, does it really make sense
0:41:15for a desktop anymore?
0:41:16I'm not sure that it does.
0:41:19I think there's still a niche there, right? Because, I mean, and this is evidenced by
0:41:23the fact that the iMac, like the Mac mini, was an M1 only machine, right? There's never
0:41:27an M1 Pro variant. And it doesn't, we don't know whether there will be one in the future,
0:41:32but that really firmly put it in the consumer level camp, right? This is not,
0:41:36you can't even spec up an M1 iMac to be like, "Hey, I just want an M1 iMac with some more juice."
0:41:40Like, nope, that's what you got. So I think that kind of will tell us to a certain degree,
0:41:46if Apple decides whenever it does the next reversion of the iMac to say, "Okay, we also
0:41:52offer an M1 pro," or, "No, it's still a pro-level chip," or whatever generation we're on, or
0:41:57it's still just the vanilla base-level chip, I think that's a pretty good indication of
0:42:01where the future of that product might be.
0:42:04The other reading between the lines thing that I detected that I'm very intrigued by
0:42:09is to me, and again, this is all gut feeling. I can't prove it. I don't, my notes from,
0:42:17I have all my notes from 15 years of briefings with Apple people, but my notes aren't proof of
0:42:24it. But it feels to me like Apple themselves represent, you know, product marketing folks
0:42:30in the Mac division are talking about games on the Mac more than ever, ever in my career.
0:42:36you'd have to pre-date my writing during fireball and having press access to apple
0:42:41may i don't but maybe even going back forever that maybe they're talking about games and
0:42:48these are good for games since at least steve jobs came on stage to talk about halo back yeah
0:42:53macworld expo yeah thousand or whatever uh you know the gaming thing you know i i played a lot
0:43:01of games on the Mac and other various platforms. I've built gaming PCs. I have a, I think I have
0:43:07every major console currently. So I, you know, I've played a lot of games and the gaming on the
0:43:14Mac problem has always been this, this tough, weird nut to crack. I think the fundamental issue
0:43:19for me is that Apple does not, as much as they talk up gaming, they don't really get it. When
0:43:24Steve Jobs would talk about the iPod and he would talk about music, you could tell that Steve felt
0:43:30personally passionate about music, right? He was into music. That was a product that, like,
0:43:36I think really resonated with something in the soul of Apple and of the way that he saw the
0:43:41business going. Then you could tell, like, when he would talk about, like, buying TV shows or renting
0:43:45movies, he's like, "Yeah, it's fine." He doesn't really care. It's like a box to check. And I think
0:43:49gaming is a thing that, despite the fact that, you know, there are so many gamers out there and
0:43:54everybody of a certain age now, including, I assume, majority of people who work in Apple
0:43:59in many of the roles, at least below the C-level, are gamers or have played games in their lifetime.
0:44:05But you never got the sense from a cultural standpoint that they really got it. Like,
0:44:11I think there's always a little degree of snobbery around it, like, "Oh, games, that's fine if you
0:44:16want to." And it's not because these machines are not very capable gaming machines. If the developers
0:44:23spend the time working with the tools that Apple provides, and they showed off a few games during
0:44:28during their keynote, little keynote video.
0:44:31They run really well.
0:44:33I ran the Resident Evil Village,
0:44:35which has been really optimized to work with Metal
0:44:37and all that.
0:44:38And it looks great, honestly.
0:44:40Like, yeah, I put it up against a console, no problem.
0:44:43But the issue is that there aren't that many,
0:44:45like that's one title among hundreds, right?
0:44:49If not more.
0:44:50And it's just that most game developers
0:44:53are not spending the time investing in the tools
0:44:56that Apple is offering.
0:44:57They want to build stuff that works on the PCs
0:45:00and works on consoles.
0:45:01And if you were a gamer, even if you were a diehard
0:45:05Mac user and a gamer for the last 20 years,
0:45:08at a certain point you probably gave up, right?
0:45:10It was just like, ah, it's just too much trouble.
0:45:12Like there's not enough stuff and I can't get it.
0:45:14You probably went to a console or maybe built a gaming PC.
0:45:17And I think then you end up with this chicken
0:45:18and egg problem, which is like, there's not enough games
0:45:21because there's not enough demand,
0:45:22but there's not enough demand
0:45:23because everybody left the platform.
0:45:24So it's tough and I think Apple wants to get out of it,
0:45:27but it's a really hard nut to crack.
0:45:28- Yeah, it really is a chicken and egg problem.
0:45:30Let's see, there's the Resident Evil,
0:45:32what's it called, Resident Evil blank village.
0:45:35And the other one there--
0:45:37- Which was written by Antony Johnston,
0:45:39who you may know, who's a frequent in-com,
0:45:41in-com poll panelist, he did the,
0:45:42wrote the script for that one.
0:45:44- Huh, I did not know that.
0:45:46- Yeah, yeah, yeah, he won some awards for it too, I think.
0:45:49So I started playing it, I only got through,
0:45:52I don't do horror games, really,
0:45:53I only got through like--
0:45:54- Oh, I hate that.
0:45:56made me go into it like I do like a creepy cabin. I didn't
0:45:59even see a zombie john I went to a creepy cabin I was like I'm
0:46:02done I used to play a lot more games never liked horror games
0:46:06for that reason I do watch horror movies I've said this
0:46:08before my family and I we my wife and son like them much more
0:46:12than I do I'm I'm I'm not embarrassed to admit I get I get
0:46:16really creeped out and I I could I don't like watching them by
0:46:20myself for sure I wouldn't do it and but that's what playing a
0:46:22god video game is like right you don't play a video game with
0:46:25your family. It's immersive, too. But it's like, I need my son and my wife next to me
0:46:29on the couch so I can grab them. I need somebody to squeeze a hand or something. I really do.
0:46:36Play it in daylight, too, let me tell you. Otherwise...
0:46:38What's the other one that they're talking about? I think it's No Man's Sky.
0:46:41It's talking about No Man's Sky, but here's the thing with No Man's Sky, and I've played
0:46:44that game on my Xbox. It's not new. It's several years old at this point, and it's a game that
0:46:52iterated like they've come out with updates to it and stuff like that.
0:46:55And it's still a very demanding game, but it's also, I want to say it's like 2016.
0:47:00Yeah, maybe, maybe a little later, but it's not new.
0:47:03Right. It's demanding.
0:47:04It's open world. I mean, literally open worlds, right?
0:47:07The whole idea is it's like a galaxy full of planets and each planet is different.
0:47:12And the demos I saw of it,
0:47:16it looks visually impressive on the Apple Silicon.
0:47:20But No Man's Sky is all my understanding, this is very much informed by my son,
0:47:24who's, you know, very much a real gamer, that No Man's Sky is a very odd game. It's just sort of
0:47:30on its own in the industry. It's not like a typical AAA title. It's sort of, they've been
0:47:36marching to the beat of their own drummer forever. Had sort of a rocky launch, you know, it's like
0:47:43many games took longer to launch than they wanted to. Launched in a sort of incomplete shape and
0:47:49and maybe left a poor first impression because of that,
0:47:53but have spent nonstop for those five or six years
0:47:58iterating and improving on it.
0:48:01But they're out on their own,
0:48:02and so it's not surprising to me
0:48:04that because they're different
0:48:06than the typical PC and console AAA titles,
0:48:11that they've also got a source code base
0:48:14and backend engine that is amenable to this,
0:48:19Whereas the problem with so many AAA titles,
0:48:23the chicken and egg problem, is that these,
0:48:26like Unity and what's the other one, the big game engine,
0:48:31Unreal, the Epic one, are just,
0:48:34and yes, they have a story, there's a path,
0:48:38because you can make these games and they run on iPhones,
0:48:42because the iPhone is this huge market, so there's a path.
0:48:46But when it comes to desktop-type hardware,
0:48:49the tooling is all based on the Intel world,
0:48:53including if not even more important than,
0:48:56certainly more important than CPU.
0:48:57I shouldn't even speculate.
0:48:59The GPU world of--
0:49:01- GPU, yeah.
0:49:02- You know, NVIDIA video cards,
0:49:04which is a different world.
0:49:07And also, unfortunately for Apple,
0:49:10Apple Silicon has a much stronger lead
0:49:14just objectively, by any measure, over the Intel and the whole x86 world CPU-wise than
0:49:28the Apple Silicon GPUs do versus the state of the art from Nvidia, where, okay, Apple's,
0:49:35I think, clearly leads on performance per watt, but Nvidia clearly leads on performance
0:49:42period, who cares how hot it is,
0:49:45get a liquid cooling system and, you know,
0:49:47make your neighbors' lights blink
0:49:50when you're pegging all the GPU cores.
0:49:53Apple doesn't have an answer for that yet,
0:49:56and therefore, you know, and one of the things
0:49:59that pegs video cards are games, right?
0:50:02So if you're writing a game to squeeze out
0:50:05the best possible graphics at the highest
0:50:08possible frame rates, there's a reason
0:50:12that your tooling was optimized for that world.
0:50:15And it doesn't, there is no way to just,
0:50:17oh, just flip a switch and spit out a version
0:50:19for Apple Silicon.
0:50:20- Right, yeah, yeah, that's always been the challenge,
0:50:23right, back in the days of DirectX and stuff
0:50:25when Microsoft had really sort of invested in,
0:50:28like, let's sort of build this out, this architecture,
0:50:30and make it interesting for gaming.
0:50:32I mean, I think you're also, the point about, like,
0:50:34games being something that really challenges the GPU.
0:50:37I'd argue they're the thing that, you know,
0:50:40most people is going to encounter, right?
0:50:42Like, there are other uses that will peg a GPU,
0:50:45but for the average Mac user slash computer user,
0:50:50the amount of GPUs that's in any Apple Silicon chip
0:50:54is overkill.
0:50:55- Zillions more people are playing video games
0:50:57that press their desktop PC GPU
0:51:02compared to how many people whose video export needs
0:51:06are doing the same.
0:51:07It's orders, several if not many,
0:51:11orders of magnitude difference.
0:51:13But it's interesting to me that Apple seems to care,
0:51:15and I don't think it's a passing fad.
0:51:18I've just, over the last couple years,
0:51:20I've just heard, just here and there,
0:51:25and just sort of offhand, off the record remarks
0:51:28of people at Apple who've heard me talking on my podcast
0:51:32that I have had, or still have a teenager,
0:51:34I guess he still is a teenager, he's 19,
0:51:36teenage son in my family who still wanted a gaming PC and you know and people at Apple who found that
0:51:44curious and wanted to know more about it but I think that also speaks to what you said about
0:51:49that there's a lot of people at Apple who just are that whole world is so foreign to them whereas
0:51:53there's a lot of other people I'm sure there's thousands and thousands of people listening to
0:51:58this episode of the show who are gaming enthusiasts who know they don't need me to explain why my
0:52:04teenage son wanted a gaming PC. They're like, "Of course he did!"
0:52:07Right, I mean, yeah, yeah. I mean, you look at the, you know, Apple executive bio page,
0:52:13and you try to figure out, okay, which one of these people is a gamer? It's not Tim Cook,
0:52:17it's not Jeff Williams, right? Like, the feeling, I don't know, maybe Schiller played some games in
0:52:22his day, probably, but I think probably not recently. You know, Schiller might be the one,
0:52:26because Schiller, wasn't there a story? Like racing games? Yeah, no, and that he, somehow,
0:52:30it can't forget how this came out it wasn't like a but he's got like uh some kind of like uh
0:52:37like a formula one simulator like a dedicated setup like with a like a like a car seat and a
0:52:44car steering wheel and like a wraparound display you know which is almost certainly got a
0:52:49pc under the hood somewhere um right right yeah so maybe he's the answer yeah all right yeah i guess
0:52:56i guess no i like you need that's what you need you need somebody in there who is going to take
0:52:59like is the evangelist for gaming. I'd love to see it because the Mac is great.
0:53:02Well, and the other thing too is I think, you know, Apple's been so successful in so many ways,
0:53:07but they're at their best like anybody when they're the upstart and they've got something
0:53:11to prove and there's somebody who's clearly ahead of them, right? So, you know, an Apple that's
0:53:18focused on trying to make the Mac relevant to desktop gaming is an Apple I like, not just,
0:53:24not because I personally foresee myself therefore getting back into desktop gaming,
0:53:28but I just think it's good for Apple to see where it's behind and to try to attack it.
0:53:33One last thing on these M2 Macs from this month is the
0:53:39sad trombone, sad news, is this thing about the slower SSDs compared to the preceding
0:53:48model at the same storage or price. I forget which ones. It's like at the lowest.
0:53:55maybe correct me with details if you know them off the top of your head, but basically it's like if
0:53:59you get like the 512 gigabyte one, it used to be two 256 gigabyte SSDs on the board. You don't know,
0:54:10you know, you wouldn't know that you never look at it, right? But that's how it's implemented.
0:54:13And now it's just one 512 SSD. And you get performance advantages from having two of them
0:54:24that can work in parallel and you could be reading from one while writing to the other and
0:54:29basically there are first disc intensive tests the new ones might be at the lower end slower than the
0:54:38old ones and some people i take this as a well that sucks that's unfortunate but i'm sure that
0:54:45apple knew that and i'm sure there's good reasons for the total cost of goods for the device and
0:54:51It's only true for these lower end storage models.
0:54:54And it sucks if you're on a budget and you want the disk speed, but your budget is capped.
0:54:59And now you've got to choose between like finding an old M1 one that's still available to sit to buy
0:55:06somewhere to get slightly better SSD performance or having to take a downgrade in SSD performance
0:55:14compared to the first generation of these Mac minis. But it doesn't affect the people who are
0:55:19buying like the one terabyte and over ones, which I think are more typical for people who care at all
0:55:25about their SSD. Right. Yeah, that's, I mean, that's the kind of the nut of this. I mean,
0:55:30there's a couple things happening here, one of which is, you know, I was listening to Jason
0:55:35Snell and Mike Hurley talking about this and, you know, saying that if Apple had just said,
0:55:42"This is fast SSD and this is a faster SSD," no, there would be no issue, right? Like, they know,
0:55:47And, and, you know, it was going to come out because people are going to benchmark this.
0:55:51Didn't come out immediately because as we mentioned earlier, the reviewers got the M2 pros.
0:55:55But I don't think anybody got the M2 pro with the base level,
0:55:58right? Wrong. No, I don't think so. I think most of us got ones were kicked up a bit.
0:56:03And so, you know, obviously it's not going to show up until like people start getting them.
0:56:07Two, is it that big a deal? Like you said, it's really for disc intensive tests. I think the best
0:56:13analogy you could come up with is if you bought a car and the advertiser said, "This car will go
0:56:17150 miles an hour," or top out on 150 miles an hour, and you got it, it's like, "It only goes
0:56:21to 120," which is a difference, right? You paid for it thinking it would go to that higher speed,
0:56:27but you're also not going to be driving even 120 miles per hour, much less 150 miles per hour,
0:56:32unless you're doing some serious specialized racing or something like that. So, both is
0:56:38something they should have disclosed and a real-world performance. It's probably not
0:56:42it's not gonna matter for most people.
0:56:44But that is frustrating,
0:56:45'cause it feels like an unforced error.
0:56:47Like Apple, you mentioned this thing's got,
0:56:49you know, 200 megabits per second,
0:56:51I don't remember, give it memory bandwidth, right?
0:56:53You're giving the feature and saying,
0:56:53"The Pro's got twice as much as the vanilla M2."
0:56:57You could've just added a line in specs,
0:56:58and then nobody would've cared.
0:57:01- Yeah, and I think that's the thing
0:57:02that gets lost in the criticism.
0:57:04It sucks, it's a minor, like I said,
0:57:06a little sad trombone, wah-wah, sorry.
0:57:10I'm sure Apple wishes it weren't so,
0:57:11But we're still talking about overall fast SSD performance
0:57:16anyway, that the slowest SSD Apple sells in any of these
0:57:18Apple Silicon Macs, Alfred is a very good IO
0:57:22for reading and writing, and at those price points,
0:57:25it's almost, it's gonna be extraordinarily rare
0:57:29that anybody who owns one is going to notice, I think.
0:57:32So I don't think it's a big deal.
0:57:33But worth mentioning.
0:57:35All right, let me take a break here
0:57:36to thank our first sponsor of the show.
0:57:38It is our good old friends at Squarespace.
0:57:42You guys know Squarespace.
0:57:43It is the all-in-one platform for building your brand,
0:57:47growing your business online.
0:57:50You can stand out with a beautiful website,
0:57:52engage with your audience, and sell anything.
0:57:55You can sell products,
0:57:56you can sell the content you can create.
0:57:58You can even sell your time
0:57:59right through your Squarespace website.
0:58:01You go to, what do you do?
0:58:03You go to squarespace.com/talkshow.
0:58:05Go there to get started.
0:58:06You get a 30 day free trial.
0:58:08The 30 day free trial is unlimited.
0:58:10It has no limits just because you're on a free trial.
0:58:12There's no watermark on your site.
0:58:15You're just full fledged Squarespace user
0:58:17for 30 days free of charge.
0:58:20They have hundreds of templates to choose from.
0:58:22They look great.
0:58:24You can just use one, boom, you're done.
0:58:27You can start from scratch with your own design
0:58:30if you know how to do web design.
0:58:32You could take one of their templates
0:58:33and adjust it to your heart's content.
0:58:36Anything in between, do it all WYSIWYG in your browser,
0:58:41what you see, what you get, dragging stuff around,
0:58:44adding features to your website through drag and drop,
0:58:47taking ones away from a default template
0:58:49'cause you don't need them or want them.
0:58:51Or if you wanna get in and mess around,
0:58:53roll your sleeves up, get in there with the CSS,
0:58:55the JavaScript, the actual HTML, you can do that too.
0:58:58Whichever level of code you want,
0:59:01including none, you can do.
0:59:04They've got everything else you need.
0:59:06Domain name registration, they can do it.
0:59:08Member areas where you can monetize your audience
0:59:12right there on your Squarespace website
0:59:14and create things like newsletters or have videos
0:59:19that are only available to the paying members of your site.
0:59:22They handle all of that, the payments, the gating,
0:59:25the access, all of that they handle for you.
0:59:28Built-in analytics, online stores, you name it,
0:59:32they've got it.
0:59:33It is a great place to build a website.
0:59:35It is a great place to send the people you know,
0:59:38when people you know in your life,
0:59:39your friends and family need a new website.
0:59:41Send them to squarespace.com/talkshow.
0:59:46Free trial, 30 days, and when they're ready to launch,
0:59:49just remember that same code, talk show.
0:59:51Know the, just talk show.
0:59:5410% off your first order,
0:59:55and you can prepay for up to a year.
0:59:5710% on a whole year, just because you listen to the talk show.
1:00:00Home pods, Home Pod 2.
1:00:03I got I got review units last week the reviews dropped
1:00:07I believe as we list as this show will air this morning. The reviews are supposed to drop on
1:00:13Tuesday the 31st
1:00:16More interest I have more to say about the weird two-year gap
1:00:23Between the old one being discontinued and no longer being for sale than the new ones. The new ones are
1:00:30The home pods back, you know, I don't know what else to say about it other than I'm delighted as a as a
1:00:36home pod fan and
1:00:39Someone who's was terribly upset that they just continued them
1:00:42To my ears they sound as good or better
1:00:47I know that some people looked at the tech specs and I think the old ones had seven tweeters and the new ones only had
1:00:54Five and the old ones had more microphones and the new ones have fewer
1:00:59To me, it's the sound quality is as good or better. I think counting tweeters as a measure of
1:01:06Yeah, audio quality is a fool's errand
1:01:09Really? I just ridiculous
1:01:14Think it's like it's like counting megapixels is your yes exactly, you know, yeah, and maybe even worse though, right?
1:01:20It's like at least with megapixels. There's some technical argument
1:01:24There's a translation.
1:01:25- Right, if you really are shooting a photo
1:01:27that you wanna blow up to billboard size,
1:01:29the megapixels might matter in some way.
1:01:31But yeah, I would say with the tweeter count,
1:01:35I think it's possible that someone
1:01:38with audio file style hearing,
1:01:40which I don't have or taste, might decide,
1:01:43I wouldn't be surprised when I read these reviews
1:01:46that some people say, I mean, who knows?
1:01:48Maybe they're gonna say it doesn't sound as good.
1:01:50To me, they sound as good,
1:01:51and I have got several pairs of OG HomePods here
1:01:54that I've played mine against,
1:01:57seems to sound the same to me at the volumes
1:01:59that any reasonable volume I would use in my house.
1:02:03I wouldn't be surprised if people say they sound better,
1:02:07you know, that Apple's audio wizards,
1:02:09their hardware speaker team has made it sound better.
1:02:12It seems to me this is something that is impossible
1:02:17to put your finger on, could easily be the placebo effect.
1:02:20It seems to me that Siri responsiveness is in fact better than on the OG home pods that
1:02:27it's, you know, some combination of upgrading to the S7 chip.
1:02:32Yeah, I'm not, I'm not sure it could be worse. I say as somebody with a stereo pair of original
1:02:39home pods in my office and I've got a home pod mini downstairs and I, Oh man, the number
1:02:43of times I've asked these home pods to do something and they just completely misinterpret
1:02:47I mean, I don't think any, nobody has ever, I think, really thrown shade on Apple for
1:02:51the sound quality of the HomePod, right? Like, that was not the problem with Gen 1. They
1:02:54always sounded great. It was everything else.
1:02:57>> Right. I think there's, you know, a couple little details are nicer. Did you get it?
1:03:05Did you have them yet or no? I don't even know.
1:03:07>> No, I do not know.
1:03:08>> I will answer what was one of my top questions is what does Midnight look like? The pair
1:03:14that I got from Apple. One was white, one is midnight, so I can see both, which I'm
1:03:19glad. I'd certainly never buy them this way to pair them, but uh...
1:03:23Mix match, yeah, sure.
1:03:24It is... oh boy, it is... it does not look blue to me at all, unless, depending on the
1:03:34exact... if it's in the exact right nice neutral light, I can pick up a slight amount of blue,
1:03:41but the ever so slight, I mean it is a very dark gray. Side by side with the old one in space gray
1:03:49to me in most of the lighting, and I carried it around my house like an idiot, one in each hand,
1:03:55you know, like I'm carrying two pineapples around or something. In most of the rooms of my house,
1:04:03under most lighting, it just looks darker than the old space gray from the first generation. Just
1:04:08looks like even closer to black which is great for me I don't want one there with
1:04:13a bluish tint I think I think you want something like a speaker to be neutral
1:04:17to me it's very neutral the compare and contrast with apples use of you know
1:04:23they love midnight right now midnight's having its moment right yeah the the
1:04:29MacBook Air to me is as a noticeable blue tint on the other hand some of the
1:04:37The Apple Watch straps that they call Midnight are very...
1:04:41Boy, you really gotta look to see the blue in 'em.
1:04:45They're just sort of the new black.
1:04:47The HomePod is like that.
1:04:48It is close to black.
1:04:50The plug, the power plug, now comes out of the back.
1:04:55- Oh, thank you.
1:04:56- I don't know why I care, but I do care.
1:04:58I don't know why it--
1:05:00- It was just, it was annoying to think
1:05:02your cable would die or like it frayed or something,
1:05:06be like I got my own you open otherwise it's a home pod and it's back and so
1:05:12does it I I'm just going by you did share picture I'm just going by the the
1:05:17so the screen is like it's it's it's mini style where it's slightly some yeah
1:05:21I think compared well the old one was like yeah whatever you want to call that
1:05:25thing on top the touch panel because it's not a screen is is generate it's it
1:05:30is no more of a screen than the other one it just shows the same sort of fuzzy
1:05:34animation it is sunken now for some reason I don't know I don't know why you
1:05:40know it I don't think it really makes sense to try I don't think you can
1:05:44either pair an eight an old one old time pod with a new one yeah no in fact now
1:05:50that I think about it Apple told us that in a press briefing yeah so to make a
1:05:55stereo pair it has to be two of the same models I had the sunken thing is
1:06:01slightly different. The other thing they do now is the plus and minus indicators
1:06:07for volume are screen printed on the touch panel. Yeah, the same as the mini
1:06:13and which is nice because it was always hard to find it on the original ones.
1:06:17They would go away and you... Yeah, or like when there's people in your house like
1:06:21guests who don't know how they work and they actually, you know, we keep ours near
1:06:25the paper towels, one of them in the kitchen, and people would touch it with
1:06:29palm and it would start playing music and they wouldn't know what to do. I'm not quite sure that
1:06:33just starting it, you know, this will help that much, but at least the plus and minus, the permanent
1:06:37plus and minus will help people figure that part out, right? So even if you're panicked and you've
1:06:43instantly started playing music you didn't want to, you can at least tap tap tap on minus to make
1:06:47it quiet before you figure out what else to do. The bottom is different. If you turn an old
1:06:56original HomePod upside down, there's a concavity on the bottom. The new one's just flat. Who cares?
1:07:04I guess you never really look at the bottom, but it just shows me that it's a complete redesign.
1:07:09As similar as they look, it's truly a new acoustical device.
1:07:15[Music]
1:07:15[Music]
1:07:15[Music]
1:07:15[Music]
1:07:15[Music]
1:07:15[Music]
1:07:15[Music]
1:07:15[Music]
1:07:15[Music]
1:07:15[Music]
1:07:15[Music]
1:07:15[Music]
1:07:15[Music]
1:07:15[Music]
1:07:15[Music]
1:07:15[Music]
1:07:15[Music]
1:07:15[Music]
1:07:15[Music]
1:07:15[Music]
1:07:15[Music]
1:07:15[Music]
1:07:15[Music]
1:07:15[Music]
1:07:15[Music]
1:07:15[Music]
1:07:15[Music]
1:07:15[Music]
1:07:15[Music]
1:07:15[Music]
1:07:15- Such a fascinating choice to redesign it
1:07:19and yet leave it so close to the original.
1:07:22- Right, that they must like the way it looks.
1:07:24- I don't quite understand.
1:07:25- I don't know.
1:07:26- I guess so, but like, yeah, I mean,
1:07:28I feel like, you know, having had the HomePods for a while,
1:07:31like, if you gave me an option, like, all right,
1:07:34give me your top five things that we should fix on the HomePod.
1:07:37I don't think any of them have been addressed in this,
1:07:40and it's not that I think they're bad,
1:07:41it's just like the things that I looked for in like,
1:07:44oh, this is great, and if you were building on this,
1:07:47I would like the screen to be a little more functional,
1:07:50and it may be bringing the price a little bit down,
1:07:53which they did do, but I think that was the price
1:07:54when they discontinued it, it was already down to $2.99.
1:07:57And it's like, lots of little things,
1:08:00but they also are like, all right, we've heard you,
1:08:02we've revised the HomePod, here it is,
1:08:03and you're like, is this the same thing?
1:08:06You just pass off your homework
1:08:07and write the same essay again?
1:08:09But yeah, I don't know, I guess they liked it.
1:08:12- I wonder how it's going to do.
1:08:14I don't know, I think in hindsight,
1:08:16and I wrote about this on "Daring Fireball,"
1:08:21even I got, when they discontinued it,
1:08:23I got caught up in the conventional wisdom
1:08:26that the damn thing was just too expensive
1:08:29and with all these competing smart speakers
1:08:32from Amazon and Google and whoever else
1:08:34that are, you know, 100 bucks or less,
1:08:37people just didn't wanna spend $300 for it.
1:08:41And I don't think that was the problem with it.
1:08:44I know it didn't sell in great quantities apparently,
1:08:47and presumably if it had, they wouldn't have had
1:08:50this two-year gap in between.
1:08:52But I do think though, like why didn't they Mac Pro it?
1:08:58Remember with the Trashcan Mac Pro
1:09:00where it just stayed in the lineup forever,
1:09:03and they even had that weird, well, unusual briefing
1:09:06with me and Panzarino and a couple of other writers
1:09:10for the Mac round table.
1:09:11- Serious about the Mac, yeah.
1:09:13- And said, look, we painted ourselves
1:09:16in the thermal corner with this.
1:09:17We didn't anticipate the rise of swappable GPUs
1:09:21and we're gonna address this.
1:09:24We wanna be in the pro market.
1:09:26We're going to be in the pro market,
1:09:27but for now, this is it.
1:09:29But they still kept selling the Mac Pro.
1:09:31And like we were talking about with the Mac Mini before,
1:09:34Apple keeps products in the lineup
1:09:37and they don't lower the price
1:09:39because they want to hold that spot, right?
1:09:42And the Mac Pro is a $5,000 computer.
1:09:47So even when the 2013 trash can was years out of date,
1:09:53in terms of the latest and greatest from Intel,
1:09:55the price never went down
1:09:58because they wanted to hold that price
1:09:59so that when they did introduce the new Mac Pro,
1:10:03it could start at that price and go up
1:10:05without seeming like a massive price increase
1:10:09from a thing that had been discounted.
1:10:11Compare and contrast with Dell,
1:10:13who like you'd spec out a Dell XPS laptop today,
1:10:18sleep on it, go back tomorrow, it might be $27 cheaper,
1:10:23it might be $17 more expensive,
1:10:25based on component prices,
1:10:27they'll just change the price tomorrow,
1:10:29change it again the next day.
1:10:31Apple does the opposite, they hold a price.
1:10:32Why not hold, just keep selling the HomePod
1:10:35until this new one was ready?
1:10:37I can't help but feel that there was a fundamental flaw
1:10:42that led those original HomePods to fail at a rate
1:10:46that was unacceptable to Apple.
1:10:48- Well, except it's a little weird
1:10:50because for a long time afterwards,
1:10:53you could get them at retailers for cheap, right?
1:10:57Like they clearly, and people were doing the thing
1:10:59where you would look at the specs or whatever,
1:11:01whatever you could pull up,
1:11:02and the manufacturer dates on them were like,
1:11:04the lot numbers were like, it's like the same lot.
1:11:06And I think two things, here's my theory.
1:11:09Like one, I mean, obviously,
1:11:11and I think you mentioned this as well as some other people,
1:11:13the fact that the HomePod Mini always stuck around
1:11:15kind of implied the existence of a non-mini HomePod.
1:11:19And so the fact they were selling that
1:11:21while there was no larger HomePod,
1:11:22everyone was kind of like,
1:11:24oh, it seems like there's still room.
1:11:25And I think honestly,
1:11:27the HomePod Mini is the best argument for the HomePod
1:11:30because people would buy, oh, $99.
1:11:34I'll take a flyer on that and give it a try.
1:11:36And they're like, oh man, this is great,
1:11:37but you know, I'd like something where the sound
1:11:39was just a little bit better.
1:11:40Like in some ways it was a good way of getting people
1:11:43into the idea of using a smart speaker
1:11:46or having a wireless speaker in their house.
1:11:48And then you could sort of turn around and be like,
1:11:51well, here's one with better, even better sound quality.
1:11:53You're like, you use it now, right?
1:11:54Like you've gotten used to it.
1:11:55You've made it part of your life.
1:11:56And now wouldn't you like a version
1:11:58that sounds even better?
1:11:59So I think it will do better
1:12:01because of the existence of the Mini,
1:12:03which feels counterintuitive.
1:12:05- Yeah, yeah.
1:12:06- But I think there's something there to it.
1:12:08- Yeah, yeah, I think you're right,
1:12:10that you kinda needed, they,
1:12:12maybe they didn't know it when they started,
1:12:13but they kinda needed a friendly,
1:12:16ah, what the hell, I'll buy one,
1:12:17and then you find out how much you like it,
1:12:19and now you're like, yeah, I want one with the big bass,
1:12:21and I want a stereo pair, and et cetera and so forth.
1:12:24It's a great product.
1:12:25I still think the other problem that they face
1:12:28is that to me, the true HomePod experience
1:12:30is $600 with a pair.
1:12:33- Yeah. - And it's great
1:12:34that if you really only need one for a smaller room
1:12:38or whatever the purpose, that you can just buy half
1:12:42of a pair, but that's what I think.
1:12:45When you just buy one, you should be thinking,
1:12:47I'm only buying half of a true HomePod,
1:12:49and maybe that's what you need.
1:12:51But fundamentally, the real experience of the product
1:12:54is a $600 pair of two of them,
1:12:56whether it's in your TV or filling up a room.
1:12:59- Yeah. - It is--
1:13:00- I feel like there is a, you kind of,
1:13:04this is not how Apple operates and never say never,
1:13:06but if they were like, oh, or buy two for 500,
1:13:10I think you'd get a ton of takers.
1:13:11I gotta be honest. - Yeah, and get 'em
1:13:13in a box where they're paired together already.
1:13:15- Yeah, exactly. - And then--
1:13:17- I mean, people, I have a Sonos Arc hooked up to my TV,
1:13:20and that is a not cheap soundbar,
1:13:23and I feel like people will drop 600 bucks
1:13:26on some nice home theater speakers or what have you.
1:13:29I don't think that's out of the question at all.
1:13:32I think it just, and that was the other thing,
1:13:34was like I think the sort of,
1:13:35the proof of concept for the home theater angle
1:13:37came later, I wanna say, like,
1:13:39and I think maybe you needed,
1:13:41still need like a newer Apple TV
1:13:43to get like the full effect out of it, I don't remember.
1:13:45But I think that's also a selling point as well,
1:13:48is the home theater angle,
1:13:49and it did not start out of the gate
1:13:51that they pushed that.
1:13:52- I also think they're up against it,
1:13:54because I don't think the typical person out there,
1:13:56even if they're a fan of Apple
1:13:57and you buy lots of Apple stuff,
1:13:59I don't think people really believe how good a stereo pair
1:14:03of HomePod sounds, and that I've seen people and readers
1:14:06who write to me and they'll be like, you know,
1:14:09I'd do it if it were better than my $500, $800 Soundbar,
1:14:14but I'm sure it's not, and it's like,
1:14:15I actually, I think it probably is, I really do.
1:14:18And I think it's sort of the thing,
1:14:19that the solution to that chicken and the egg problem
1:14:23is to get it started and get, you know,
1:14:26people come, go to somebody's house like mine
1:14:28where you can watch a movie with a HomePod pair
1:14:30to a nice TV and be like, wow,
1:14:34I can't believe that sound is coming from two HomePods.
1:14:36That's amazing.
1:14:37And it does sound a bit like surround sound.
1:14:40It does sound like stuff is coming from behind
1:14:43and from way further to the side
1:14:45than the HomePods actually are.
1:14:47And then you're like, then it puts it in your head
1:14:50that this really is a credible,
1:14:53this is a bargain for $600.
1:14:55I really do think it is.
1:14:57- One of the things that kills me on this is,
1:15:00if all I did on my TV was watch stuff via my Apple TV,
1:15:05I probably would use a HomePod stereo pair there.
1:15:07But if you have anything else connected to your TV,
1:15:10like a gaming console, it's a non-starter.
1:15:13And it's just that to me is the bummer part is like,
1:15:15it's great that it has the wireless connectivity
1:15:18with the Apple TV and it does use the eARC standard,
1:15:21but I don't think there's any way.
1:15:23- Yeah, I think as time goes on,
1:15:26I think this eARC is going to, it'll eventually work,
1:15:31but I don't think that with existing consoles and TiVos
1:15:35and other things, anything HDMI that you have hooked up
1:15:39to your TV, the odds are somewhat good
1:15:42that you'd still need some other audio solution.
1:15:44- Yeah, and I have to ding it slightly too,
1:15:48and I have it in my office, and I have used it
1:15:51for output from my Mac, but it,
1:15:54It's flaky still, and that's my biggest issue.
1:15:59Why is it not just a great pair of Mac speakers?
1:16:03And there's also some latency.
1:16:04So for example, if I'm editing a podcast,
1:16:07I can't, you can't do it.
1:16:08It just doesn't, it doesn't work.
1:16:09It's not, 'cause it's going over wifi, right?
1:16:11Like there's gonna be some latency
1:16:14and some traffic issues there, which is a bummer.
1:16:16- Ah, all right, let me take a break here
1:16:18and thank our second and final sponsor of this episode,
1:16:21our good friends at Collide.
1:16:23If you're listening to this podcast,
1:16:25the odds are good that at some point you're gonna go,
1:16:27you or your company is gonna go through an audit
1:16:30like SOC 2 or ISO 27001.
1:16:35If those ring a bell to you,
1:16:38then you really oughta look at Collide.
1:16:41'Cause you're gonna have to answer some tough questions
1:16:43about endpoint security when you get audited.
1:16:45Questions like, do all of your company's laptops
1:16:48have their disks encrypted?
1:16:50Does everyone have the company's password manager installed?
1:16:53Do you have a system in place to monitor and maintain compliance throughout your cross-platform
1:16:58fleet?
1:16:59Even if you're confident the answer to all of those questions is yes, the question when
1:17:03you're audited is, can you prove it to the auditor?
1:17:08If you're not quite sure how you'd go about proving compliance across your fleet of devices,
1:17:12then you need Collide.
1:17:13Collide, K-O-L-I-D-E, is an endpoint security tool for Mac, Windows, and Linux devices that
1:17:20that does things MDMs cannot,
1:17:22and it gives you the visibility you need
1:17:25to maintain compliance.
1:17:26And best of all, Collide does not resort
1:17:28to surveilling employees or locking down devices.
1:17:32Instead, it works with end users to resolve issues
1:17:35and relies on their cooperation and informed consent.
1:17:39Where do you go?
1:17:42Look, you can meet your security needs
1:17:46and pass your audit without compromising on privacy.
1:17:49visit KOLIDE, K-O-L-I-D-E, kolide.com/thetalkshow
1:17:54and find out how.
1:17:56If you follow that link,
1:17:57they will hook you up with a goodie bag,
1:17:59including a T-shirt, just for activating a free trial.
1:18:02That's K-O-L-I-D-E, kolide.com/thetalkshow.
1:18:07My thanks to Kolide.
1:18:09You added a note to our little show notes thing here.
1:18:13I don't know what you're talking about.
1:18:14A foldable iPad with a kickstand.
1:18:16What's this?
1:18:18This was a rumor, so I didn't know how much credence to give it, but I think it was Ming-Chi
1:18:22Kuo who was saying in 2024, Apple will be putting out a foldable iPad with a kickstand.
1:18:30And I'm just, I don't even know what's happening here.
1:18:36This has been in the, I think he posted on Twitter, but it's been showing up on all the
1:18:40usual suspects and saying basically there may be no new iPad releases in the next nine
1:18:46to 12 months, which I think there have been a lot of speculation that the iPad is going
1:18:51to have a quiet year, unless maybe there is a larger or a bigger change to come. I know
1:18:59we've heard about other stuff taking a bigger change in the next few years, rumors about
1:19:05touchscreen Macs and all that. I just think the foldable market is such a weird idea and
1:19:13yet something that does not seem like it's going away. And I have to believe Apple is at least,
1:19:19you know, experimenting and investigating whether these things are plausible. I just, I'm,
1:19:24I don't know. There's what, the Surface? What's the Surface one? There's a Surface one that has
1:19:29two screens. This is weird. I don't know. They're all duo. All of their products are named in a way
1:19:35that I, they all sound like they could be the other. The names don't get, so the, the, the
1:19:40surface that folds yes there you go the surface that they should have called it that that's a
1:19:46great fold i don't know at least yeah at least samsung names their foldable ones the galaxy fold
1:19:51or something like that so you know what's there you go it is um speaking of anyways i i thought
1:19:57speaking of speed bumps the ultimate speed bump product in the lineup is got to be the ipad pros
1:20:02which are pretty much unchanged since 2018 i know that the big 12.91 at now starting last generation
1:20:10has the micro LED screen so it has a better screen technology but again side
1:20:18by side a 2018 iPad Pro of either size compared to one that you buy today same
1:20:24size same weight same more or less thing but on the other hand the chips keep
1:20:29getting faster for people who use them and it is a good design it is very thin
1:20:34it's very light I decide so it you know is is it a five-year design that is
1:20:39is worth five years? Yeah, I think so.
1:20:43But it... - Yeah, I'm fascinated by it
1:20:45because it's like the Mac, you know, I think Apple has run into this issue of
1:20:50their hardware being so good that it feels like, okay, we've come out with a new iPad,
1:20:57we speed bumped it, and everyone's like, oh, this one, this one, this one. It's like your RAM,
1:21:00you know, you know, your 64 gigabytes of RAM and not paging out, like, you know, okay, it's great.
1:21:05Like, I mean, but now that I've hit this point, like, what else, what else do I need, right?
1:21:11And I think that's an interesting challenge for Apple to be in, is having this, the hardware that
1:21:15is so good that it feels like, well, you've kind of, you kind of nailed it, right? Like,
1:21:21there's surely, there's always room for improvement, but I don't know what that is.
1:21:24I always pull out to, as my example of a purely fictional purpose for foldable devices, the,
1:21:35the tablets and phones, whatever you want to call them on HBO's Westworld,
1:21:39which if you've never watched, you can, I'm pretty sure you should be able to YouTube
1:21:44clips of people using them. Obviously, that takes place in the future and they're super thin. They
1:21:51don't have any frame. They're just clear pieces of plastic that light up when they turn them on, but
1:21:56they fold to what we consider phone shape and you could put them in a pocket where you would hold
1:22:03what we today consider smartphones,
1:22:06but to unfold them to a very nice tablet size.
1:22:10And putting aside all technical difficulties,
1:22:15screen technology, hinges, where do you put batteries?
1:22:23The ones in Westworld don't seemingly have batteries.
1:22:28But in theory, the appeal of that is tremendous.
1:22:31It's like, you know, think back to the old days
1:22:35when we had paper maps in our car, you know,
1:22:37and of course it was very difficult
1:22:39to fold them back up the right way,
1:22:40but you certainly wouldn't want a road map
1:22:44of your state or the country or half the country
1:22:47that was the size that would fit in your dashboard,
1:22:50but you certainly wouldn't want to keep the map out
1:22:53if you couldn't fold it up, if it's big.
1:22:56Folding is great.
1:22:57There's a reason folding has been around with paper products
1:23:00as long as there's been paper.
1:23:02So can't help but think eventually folding
1:23:06is going to come to the Apple universe
1:23:08and that they've just been waiting
1:23:10until they can do it right.
1:23:11Because in my opinion, all the ones I've seen,
1:23:14like from Samsung with their phones,
1:23:16the ones that are actually available for sale,
1:23:19don't seem, the trade-off doesn't seem worth it.
1:23:22It's like, you know, they fold up
1:23:23and they're twice as thick.
1:23:24Why would I want a phone that's twice as thick?
1:23:26Why do I want a, you know, now,
1:23:28and the good screen is now folded up inside
1:23:31and there's another extra screen on the outside
1:23:33just so I can look at it without unfolding it?
1:23:36It all seems convoluted.
1:23:38I don't know many people who use them.
1:23:41They must sell well enough that Samsung keeps making them,
1:23:46but I guess Apple will get there.
1:23:48- Well, it's the whole thing we always say,
1:23:51is Apple doesn't do its data tests in public, right?
1:23:54When they're ready, they're ready
1:23:55and they're not gonna show off anything
1:23:57until they feel like it's good enough that they wish.
1:23:59- But it certainly would be at a basic level
1:24:01if Apple thinks they have a good solution.
1:24:03Certainly a big way to take the iPad to new territory
1:24:08by I guess two ways it could go, right?
1:24:12You could take iPads with a maximum screen size
1:24:17like we know now in that 11 to 13 inch range
1:24:21and have them fold up to be far more portable
1:24:24than they are now, possibly pocketable,
1:24:27that would be kind of amazing,
1:24:29to be able to put an iPad in your pants pocket,
1:24:32or like a jacket pocket.
1:24:34Famously, Apple loves to talk about
1:24:37how their iPads are used in medicine.
1:24:39It's actually a known fact now
1:24:43that the doctors wear those white lab coats,
1:24:45that all the pockets on all lab coats
1:24:47are now meant to hold iPads,
1:24:49because iPads are so often used in medical situations.
1:24:54Most of us don't wear lab coats all the time.
1:24:57- Awkward for everybody else, that's true, yeah.
1:24:59- So pocketability would be amazing for an iPad.
1:25:02It really, really would.
1:25:04Or I guess the other way they could go
1:25:06would be to make a much larger maximum size,
1:25:09but have it fold up to be as portable as the iPads today.
1:25:12You could have a 16 inch, or I don't know, even bigger,
1:25:1520 inch unfolded iPad display.
1:25:17I'd like to see it.
1:25:18I'm sure it's coming.
1:25:20I don't know.
1:25:21Other than CES demos of products
1:25:23that are not meant for the market.
1:25:25I've never seen a foldable phone that I've thought,
1:25:27oh, I would buy that.
1:25:28It's still, they're too thick when folded.
1:25:30The hinges are too obvious.
1:25:32Doesn't seem reliable.
1:25:33But CES always, every year, CES has something,
1:25:36and they work as prototypes,
1:25:39and there's people touching them,
1:25:40and they light up, and they work,
1:25:42and it's like, wow, that would be pretty cool
1:25:43if it was practical to actually sell
1:25:45in the mass market this year.
1:25:46- I remain convinced it's all just,
1:25:50it's all special effects now.
1:25:51Todd Vaziri is out there making foldable phones and tricking us all into thinking they're
1:25:55real. Other than that though, I'm done for the week. Anything else you wanted to talk
1:26:00about? Are you on the Mastodon? I am on Mastodon. I knew that answer. That was a cheat question.
1:26:10I follow you there. Are you happy? Yeah, I've dialed way back on Twitter. I still check
1:26:17in every once in a while just to like keep my finger on what's like going like check
1:26:21my mentions that kind of thing but I honestly you mentioned at some point that you were
1:26:26not really even seeing much engagement at all. It's something that's yeah, yeah, me
1:26:30neither. I've also it's been very quiet over there and I can't tell is like, is it really
1:26:34just everybody who was actually like not a bot following me is is gone? Or is there something
1:26:41screwed up with their infrastructure? I don't know. But I, you know, I think the only thing
1:26:45right now that I'm not as, you know, kind of full-throated on Macedon is I just, I still
1:26:52need a better Mac client, but I've been using Ivory on my iPhone and my iPad and I love
1:26:56it. I'm a Tweetbot user, so that is, it just feels like home to me. So I'm very excited
1:27:02about that Mac app that they're doing. But yeah, it's nice if it feels good.
1:27:10I can report, I'm allowed to say,
1:27:11that Mac Iberi is coming along.
1:27:14I'm lucky enough, I was invited,
1:27:17as of this weekend, using, I don't even know,
1:27:20I don't even know what they're describing it as.
1:27:22They're describing it as not even alpha.
1:27:25But it is already, everything, you know,
1:27:28if you used Tweetbot for Mac, it is,
1:27:30it'll make you feel at home,
1:27:32even though it's slightly different.
1:27:34Can't come soon enough for everybody else.
1:27:36They know it, God bless them,
1:27:37they're getting some sleep over there. It is super exciting times UI-wise though, and
1:27:44you know there are other ones coming, some of these other ones all through so far through
1:27:49Catalyst, but Mammoth, which is still in test flight as we record but might be out by the
1:27:56time the show comes out, has got a pretty credible Mac thing.
1:27:59Yeah, I've been using it from the Mac for a while, and it's pretty good.
1:28:04I mean, there's lots and lots of little things like the keyboard
1:28:07navigation. Yeah, well, it's still it's still an iPad. It's
1:28:10fundamentally still an iOS app and like it, but it works.
1:28:14There's a while there during the beta where every time I tried to
1:28:16post something, it was like, well, that's, that's a non
1:28:20starter, but Oh, well, but it was still good for reading. But
1:28:23it is kind of fun when you're a nerd and you're willing to put
1:28:26up with stuff like that. It's kind of fun to be in on it such
1:28:29early days. I
1:28:32Yeah, it's got a nice bleeding edge feel to it. I mean, I don't know, lots of people have compared
1:28:36the current Mastodon to feeling like Twitter circa 2007 or 2008. It does bring me back to those
1:28:43times. I think the best thing I've sort of said about Mastodon is that I think it's a really good
1:28:50place for interacting with people. Twitter became a place where it was about interacting with,
1:28:55there are brands and there's news and there's public figures and all of that.
1:29:00And I feel like that's a niche that's been carved out and I don't know that Mastodon will replicate
1:29:05that, but for just sort of straight up talking to people that you might be interested in talking to
1:29:09or hearing from, I think it actually is pretty great. And I told my wife the other night,
1:29:16because I've been trying to convince her to use it more, the best thing about Mastodon is there
1:29:21is no way that Donald Trump will ever figure out how to sign up for it.
1:29:24It's true. I hate to say it sounds elitist, but I don't mean it in an elitist way. I just spoke
1:29:31about this at length last episode of this show with Craig Hockenberry, so I won't go too deep, but
1:29:35it sounds elitist, but I don't mean it that way. But I think that the higher barrier to entry
1:29:42conceptually works in Mastodon's favor for the type of people who, for lack of a better catch-all,
1:29:50listen to podcasts like the talk show or upgrade or
1:29:53a slightly nerdy, you know, and you have to make this level of conceptual
1:29:58leap to a two-level namespace where you're at username at instance server.
1:30:04Um, and you have to I, you know, I really, I'll repeat myself a little, but it's like,
1:30:13I think that back when Twitter switched,
1:30:16it made that big pivot in 2013 or so
1:30:19to move away from fully embracing
1:30:23and supporting third-party clients
1:30:25and moved away from just having a chronological timeline.
1:30:29That they did it because they knew
1:30:31to justify their existence financially
1:30:34and the goals they'd set and the money they'd raised,
1:30:35they needed hundreds of millions more users
1:30:38and they weren't gonna get them with Twitter as it was
1:30:41because most people looked at it
1:30:44and it just didn't appeal to them.
1:30:46And an algorithmic timeline that suggests things to them
1:30:51made hundreds of millions or at least tens of millions
1:30:54of more people see Twitter as, oh yeah,
1:30:57this is something I would use on a regular basis.
1:31:00It just, it worked.
1:31:01And as frustrated as many of us are
1:31:04who like what Twitter was before that,
1:31:06I get it, it wasn't popular to those people.
1:31:10So forget even the, do I even understand it?
1:31:13I think people who got on, hundreds of millions of people
1:31:16who use Twitter and at least find it engaging enough
1:31:19to keep using, will never like Mastodon,
1:31:21'cause Mastodon is never gonna present them
1:31:24in the algorithmic timeline,
1:31:25and the non-algorithmic timeline isn't something
1:31:29that entertains them or engages their brain
1:31:31or feels entertaining.
1:31:32And so for those of us who do, Mastodon is it,
1:31:34and it really is, it's backwards, it's stepping into it,
1:31:39But in some ways Elon Musk did save Twitter
1:31:43by ruining Twitter and therefore creating
1:31:46a critical mass of millions of people
1:31:49who are like in what I see on Mastodon now
1:31:54who otherwise were never going to go through the hassle
1:32:00of closing up shop on Twitter and moving to Mastodon.
1:32:03It's really exciting times and it's so exciting.
1:32:07It's been a very long time since something grassroots, open, and nonprofit has experienced
1:32:15commercial explosive growth as a platform on the internet.
1:32:19And it sounds it's depressing that it's been so long, because that used to be what the
1:32:24internet was all about one thing after another some new open thing, and you can anybody can
1:32:28write a client for it.
1:32:30And it's a new stuff is happening.
1:32:34"Oh my god, here's a new client that does things in an altogether different way. Wow,
1:32:38that's really clever. I don't know, maybe that's for me, maybe it's not, but I'm glad
1:32:41someone's trying it." And, you know, here we are again, and it's very exciting. So I'm
1:32:47not going to shut up about it.
1:32:48If nothing else, it's not static.
1:32:49Yeah, I'm not going to shut up about it.
1:32:51No, I like this stuff changing.
1:32:53I will answer this. It's a frequently asked question at this point, and I'm sorry I'm
1:32:56not there yet. Will there be an @DaringFireball and @TheTalkShow accounts that auto-post new
1:33:03episodes and posts on Mastodon, yes, 100%, I guarantee it.
1:33:08Are they ready yet? No. So, coming soon.
1:33:12Let me just say this, let me give a shout out to your work.
1:33:18You're a novelist, god damn it.
1:33:20It makes me a little jealous.
1:33:22It's in the back of every writer's mind
1:33:24that you should someday write a novel.
1:33:27- It's a lot of time, not always the best return, but--
1:33:33I heard that it pays great. Well, it does. I mean, it's no podcasting money. Don't get
1:33:41me wrong. But what are you up to? You're up to three novels? I've written four novels.
1:33:52The Galactic Cold War series is my current going concern. Most recent one, the NOVA incident,
1:33:56out last summer. Working on a couple other things right now and I should have something
1:34:03coming out. I don't exactly know when but I think in the first half of this year there
1:34:08should be something that is a different thing which I don't know how much I can say about
1:34:13it at this point other than it's well I'll give a quick overview. It's actually a supernatural
1:34:20detective novel that's set in Boston and involves spooky goings on at a giant technology company.
1:34:27So maybe a little more in my wheelhouse and perhaps even in the wheelhouse of some of the
1:34:31listeners here. So look for that. I'm sure I'll be writing a lot about it when it comes out.
1:34:35You're saying you have more real world actual experience with technology companies than you do
1:34:40with intergalactic cold wars? Slightly. Plus, you know, spooky ghosts and stuff too.
1:34:47let me ask this, here's my question. The three novels so far in the series are titled The Caledonian
1:34:56Gambit, The Bayern Agenda, and as you said the latest one, The Nova Incident. There's one more
1:35:05in there as well, there's the Aliph extraction. Oh yes, right, all right, extraction. But so I see the
1:35:09pattern. One of them was it--everyone says they see the pattern. There's a gambit, there was an agenda,
1:35:17there was an extraction, there was an incident. How many of those do you have in the can for the
1:35:24future? You gotta have a couple. I don't want to hear them. I'm not asking. Oh yeah, there are a
1:35:32couple. There are a couple. There are at least a couple in the can. I will say this. When I wrote
1:35:36my first book, no title I've ever come up with for my book. No first title has ever survived
1:35:42to the final publication. They always get changed. And the first time when I was doing my first book,
1:35:49they didn't like the title I had, and so they asked me to brainstorm some other ones.
1:35:53And I was coming up with joke titles, and the Caledonian Gambit was my Robert Ludlum,
1:35:58I literally called it my Robert Ludlum title, like "Born Identity." All his books are the
1:36:03something something. And then I just got stuck. Once you start a pattern, once you start the way
1:36:11you're doing something, you just keep going with that same pattern. You kind of fall into that
1:36:15trap. So yeah, so I have come up with ones for future installments if need be, and yes, they do
1:36:22all sort of fall in that same the something something. So people can find out more about
1:36:28your books at your personal website dmorin.com and you've got, as somebody would expect,
1:36:39all of the links you could possibly want to buy them in any form you want. I would have to think
1:36:43the queen of that sort of novel titling pattern/conundrum of "Where do you finish?" has got to
1:36:50be Sue Grafton, right? Oh yeah, and she died before she could finish. So what are the... It's terrible.
1:36:57She got like within, I think she was on like X or something. It was pretty close to the end. Well,
1:37:01I'm looking at her website and there's a Y is for yesterday. Okay, so maybe that's the last one she
1:37:07got. So that's killer. You'd die before you get to that last letter in the alpha. You get 25!
1:37:12And then you... I mean, and I was in high school when those first started coming out. That's a long
1:37:18time ago. Yeah, my mom had a bunch of them because she's a mystery. Yeah, and at some point that was
1:37:22one of those novels where I was like, "Ah, I don't read mysteries, and I don't know." But somehow,
1:37:26at some point, I was bored and there was one, and I read it, and I was like, "Hey, these are pretty
1:37:29good!" And then I got all caught up in, of course, everybody, you know, like any series novel, the
1:37:35the fans cannot wait for the next one.
1:37:38But of course with hers, there was this whole cottage
1:37:41industry of people trying to predict what the title
1:37:43for each letter would be, right?
1:37:45- Right, yeah.
1:37:48It was like when Android, they're doing all the candies
1:37:51or whatever, right?
1:37:52- Exactly, and people would try to guess,
1:37:54what's the candy?
1:37:55J for jelly bean, that seems pretty obvious,
1:37:57but what the hell do you do with X?
1:37:59And they gave up on it.
1:38:04- Yeah, right, well, they've kind of painted themselves
1:38:06into a corner.
1:38:07- Anyway, people can find that there.
1:38:10Of course, in terms of Mac nerdery,
1:38:14you are the, what's your official title?
1:38:15The East Coast--
1:38:17- Bureau Chief, which is a title I have
1:38:20because I told Jason, man, Bureau Chief is a title
1:38:23that doesn't get used enough anymore.
1:38:24Is you wanna be a Bureau Chief, be a Bureau Chief.
1:38:25It's like that's what I meant.
1:38:26- East Coast Bureau Chief at sixcolors.com,
1:38:29and it's just fantastic ongoing work there,
1:38:34including your review of the Mac Mini this week.
1:38:36So keep it up.
1:38:37And do you do any podcasts?
1:38:39- I got a couple with some people
1:38:43that you may be familiar with.
1:38:44I do a clockwise over on Relay FM with Micah Sargent.
1:38:49We do two, basically a round table every week
1:38:53with two guests and we talk about a certain amount
1:38:55of topics and it's never over 30 minutes.
1:38:57So it's nice to-
1:38:58- So you can never have, you'll never have me on.
1:39:01- You can be, we had Syracuse on.
1:39:03Keep Syracuse down to half an hour.
1:39:06You're welcome. You have an open invitation.
1:39:08Well, we'll just do introductions.
1:39:10Then there we go, 30 minutes.
1:39:12Get it and quit it. I do a bunch of stuff over the incomparable with
1:39:17Jason Snell and a couple of your other frequent collaborators,
1:39:22John Moltz and Guy English and I do a podcast on superhero stuff called Biff.
1:39:25Never heard of you.
1:39:26It's currently biweekly.
1:39:27Never heard of you.
1:39:28They're not that important. Then I do one called The Rebound with John Moltz and
1:39:33Lex Friedman, who I gather is heavily--
1:39:36- Yeah, that son of a bitch.
1:39:38But I'm all in on the Eagles at this point.
1:39:41You gotta root for somebody, so.
1:39:42- Well, it's a hometown team, too, come on.
1:39:46- Well, I hate the 49ers.
1:39:49I hate the 49ers more than just about anybody,
1:39:51so that was pretty good yesterday.
1:39:54Well, thank you, Dan.
1:39:55Have a good time, and talk to you soon.
1:39:58- Thanks, John, appreciate it, take care.