0:00:00Over the weekend, my coffee grinder broke.
0:00:03- Oh. (laughs)
0:00:04- And this is, I've never lost a coffee grinder before.
0:00:08And I quickly realized this is a single point of failure
0:00:10at my setup because I only have one.
0:00:14I have never, I've never had any reason
0:00:16to have a backup coffee grinder.
0:00:18I have many different ways to brew coffee.
0:00:21I have many different collections of coffee beans.
0:00:25I have redundancy everywhere else in the system.
0:00:27But the grinder is a single point of failure.
0:00:29And after 12 years of solid use,
0:00:34including the last six years
0:00:35in a highly corrosive saltwater air environment,
0:00:38it finally kicked the bucket.
0:00:40- And I believe it's the same grinder I have,
0:00:43the Baratza Virtuosia.
0:00:49I just like every single piece of equipment
0:00:52I'm using to record this podcast,
0:00:55I just said, "What should I buy, Marco?"
0:00:57And I bought it.
0:00:58and I have the same coffee grinder, which I still love.
0:01:02I don't know what I, you know.
0:01:05- Yeah.
0:01:05- I've got more local options.
0:01:06- And there's nothing against them,
0:01:07'cause I mean, look, it lasted 12 years,
0:01:09and you know, again, like the last six
0:01:10were in a pretty harsh environment
0:01:12for any kind of electronic thing made of metal,
0:01:15so I give it full credit, and nothing against them.
0:01:19But now, see, they don't make this model anymore.
0:01:20They make a few that are kinda different,
0:01:23and I don't know, like, they're different in ways
0:01:25that I'm not sure would be better for me,
0:01:27So I actually ordered, so first of all,
0:01:29I overnighted a replacement.
0:01:30(laughs)
0:01:31'Cause I'm like, first of all,
0:01:32this would, you know, it broke on a Sunday.
0:01:35And I'm like, well, this is gonna be a long time
0:01:37before I can get a coffee cracker in my house.
0:01:40And I could also just, you know, go buy pre-ground beans,
0:01:43but you know, I'm not gonna do that.
0:01:45So I'm lucky though, I, you know,
0:01:49because I live in a beach town and it's the winter,
0:01:53all of my neighbors are gone for the season.
0:01:55It's basically an abandoned town.
0:01:57- Right, it's like--
0:01:58- And I know my neighbors there,
0:01:59and we all have keys to each other's houses,
0:02:01so I actually asked,
0:02:03and I was able to go borrow my neighbor's coffee grinder,
0:02:06you know, getting it out of their abandoned house
0:02:07for the next few days. (laughs)
0:02:09So I have, like, you know,
0:02:11back to the regular spinning blade kind of,
0:02:13you know, the little whirlybird grinder, the old kind,
0:02:16and I'm really happy that I have it.
0:02:19It's better than nothing,
0:02:20but man, do I appreciate bird grinders more now. (laughs)
0:02:25It's a big difference, turns out.
0:02:26(laughing)
0:02:29Yeah, so what's your best local option off season?
0:02:33I mean, you can't, there's nowhere to go really
0:02:35for decent coffee, right, or is there?
0:02:38- Not really, well, I mean, there's like towns on Long Island
0:02:43that I could drive over the bridge.
0:02:45- No, that's too far.
0:02:46- But it's, yeah, it's like a half hour drive,
0:02:48so it's not something I wanna really do day to day.
0:02:51So I just normally just brew my own, and it's fine.
0:02:54I get the beans from Yes Please usually,
0:02:57or from some kind of rando roaster from Trade.
0:03:00But I will say that the coffee frozen cylinder thing,
0:03:04that that's Cometeer.
0:03:06And I'm really frustrated by Cometeer,
0:03:09because I first heard about it on All-Consuming,
0:03:12and I thought, you know, that's probably really stupid.
0:03:16It's like frozen little capsules of coffee,
0:03:21and you basically just pour hot water on them.
0:03:23It's one of those companies that you'd see
0:03:24on Instagram and you'd be like, that's really fancy,
0:03:27but that's probably not very good.
0:03:29And for some reason, I forget why,
0:03:31but for some reason I decided to try it
0:03:33after I heard it on All-Consuming.
0:03:35And it's like stupidly good.
0:03:39And it's totally ridiculous.
0:03:40Like it's not super cheap and they have to mail you
0:03:43this box with a absolute ton of dry ice in it.
0:03:47Like it does stay frozen, you know, good for them.
0:03:49Not a sponsorship.
0:03:50Although I'm kind of hoping they'll sponsor my show
0:03:52at some point, but it's the most ridiculous way
0:03:56to get coffee, 'cause they have to basically ship you
0:03:58this extremely frozen box with these little,
0:04:01you know, aluminum capsules in it that you, you know,
0:04:03you defrost, and they're single serving,
0:04:06but it's frustrating because it's way, way better
0:04:09than any coffee I've ever made myself.
0:04:11Like, they just, it's a really, whatever their process is,
0:04:14it's like a fancy, like, hipster coffee shop made it,
0:04:18you know, like with the fancy pour-over,
0:04:19but with actual strength of flavor,
0:04:22'cause you get to control how much dilution there is.
0:04:24So it's stupidly good.
0:04:25And I treat myself to that every so often.
0:04:29Maybe a couple times a year, I'll get a box of those
0:04:32and I'll slowly dole them out to enjoy them.
0:04:35But to be your everyday pick,
0:04:37I think it'd be kind of ridiculous.
0:04:38So normally I'm just using beans, mostly from Yes Please.
0:04:42- We may have to scrap this.
0:04:47- What happened?
0:04:49Trade's one of the sponsors.
0:04:51No, I mean, that's… I said I also use beans from Trade.
0:04:57Well, let me take a break here and tell you about our first sponsor,
0:05:07who Marco seredipitously… is that the right word? … mentioned.
0:05:11Yeah, something like that.
0:05:13it's trade coffee. This is not a joke. This was not set up. This show has…
0:05:19Jared: No, see, what they're good for is variety because like normally, like my usual go-to is Yes
0:05:24Please! And Yes Please! is really good for if you want consistency. They basically give you the same
0:05:29thing all the time and it's good. But where I like trade is they give you variety. Like if you want
0:05:35to like mix it up, get something fresh, get something new. That's why I maintain subscriptions
0:05:41to both services, and I just have them come in alternate weeks.
0:05:43Pete: I have had Trade Coffee at your house. That was actually, I remember the first morning over
0:05:51the summer, I was, you were kind enough to have us over for a couple of nights and I had it there,
0:05:57but I'd already been subscribed. Often, when I talk about Trade Coffee, I say I'm drinking it
0:06:03right now, but I can't say that right now because we're recording at eight o'clock at night and I
0:06:08I no longer am capable of drinking coffee
0:06:11at eight o'clock at night.
0:06:13And-- - I mean, you gotta sleep
0:06:14sometime. - And getting to bed.
0:06:16I used to be able to.
0:06:18I used to think I was like one of those,
0:06:21and they always said that that was one of the things
0:06:24the Russians used for jet fighter pilots.
0:06:27Everybody always knows fighter pilots
0:06:29have to have great eyesight and reflexes and stuff,
0:06:31and the Russians chose pilots
0:06:33who had a very low susceptibility to caffeine
0:06:36so that they could dose them with caffeine
0:06:39to keep them up for 18-hour bombing missions.
0:06:42I used to feel like maybe I was like that,
0:06:46and now I realize I'm not,
0:06:47and if I drink coffee after five o'clock,
0:06:49I'm usually up until five a.m.
0:06:52So I'm not drinking it as we speak.
0:06:56I'm drinking Hal's Fizzy Water,
0:06:57but I did have trade coffee here,
0:07:00which was ground today through a, what is it?
0:07:05I always forget the name of the goddamn bar.
0:07:07- Baratza Virtuoso.
0:07:07- Baratza Virtuoso, which I do, it's beloved.
0:07:11What is trade?
0:07:12Trade Coffee is a coffee subscription service,
0:07:17just like Marco was talking about.
0:07:18And they make it simple to discover new coffees
0:07:21and make your best cup of coffee at home every day.
0:07:24They don't make all this coffee.
0:07:26They don't think they roast any of it.
0:07:28What trade does is partner
0:07:31with the nation's top-rated independent roasters.
0:07:34And I mean, dozens, maybe hundreds, I don't know,
0:07:38but certainly dozens.
0:07:39I've been subscribed to them pretty much all year,
0:07:43and I'm not sure I've gotten coffee
0:07:44from the same roaster twice.
0:07:46And they send you the best quality coffee
0:07:50as a subscription service exactly at the pace that you want.
0:07:54You want a bag a week, you want,
0:07:56maybe you are like in an office,
0:07:57or you have a family full of coffee drinkers,
0:08:00you need multiple bags a week.
0:08:02You want it every two weeks,
0:08:03You want it every month.
0:08:05Whatever schedule you want, you can set it.
0:08:07And whether you already know what you like,
0:08:11or if you're new to specialty coffee and need help,
0:08:14Trade's website makes it easy and convenient
0:08:18to discover new coffees.
0:08:19They send it fresh to your home on your schedule.
0:08:24I love their coffee.
0:08:25I stay subscribed to it, and I would stay subscribed to it,
0:08:27even if they weren't sponsoring the show.
0:08:30It is terrific.
0:08:31I do it for exactly the reason Margo said before,
0:08:34it's variety, it tastes different,
0:08:36and it's good, and I like it.
0:08:39So what do you do to do this?
0:08:41And again, I mention this every time I talk about coffee.
0:08:44Coffee is produce.
0:08:46It is like, coffee beans don't look like fruit or apples,
0:08:51apples or oranges or something that goes bad,
0:08:54but they really do.
0:08:56Even though old coffee beans
0:08:59don't really look that different
0:09:01than fresh roasted coffee beans.
0:09:03The taste difference is dramatic,
0:09:05and the stuff you buy like on a supermarket shelf,
0:09:08even from a good brand, is way, way older than,
0:09:12yeah, you wouldn't buy fruit that's just bagged up
0:09:15and is not in the produce section
0:09:17where they're refrigerating it and stuff like that.
0:09:19Coffee is exactly like that.
0:09:21It is, among all the other factors
0:09:23of what makes good coffee different
0:09:26from mediocre or bad coffee.
0:09:29Freshness is gotta be number one,
0:09:30and the stuff you get from trade is super duper fresh.
0:09:34It is like as soon as it's roasted, it's sealed,
0:09:36goes into the mail, and is ding dong,
0:09:40two days later, it's at your door.
0:09:42Three days for Marco, because it takes an extra day
0:09:44for everything to get to the sun.
0:09:46- I'll tell you what though, like the difference,
0:09:49like you were just saying, like,
0:09:50oh, the grocery store coffee is much more stale.
0:09:52I don't think people will fully appreciate to what degree.
0:09:55So with trade coffee, you're getting it mailed to you,
0:09:58and by the time it arrives to you,
0:10:00even when it arrives to me in my crazy place,
0:10:02it has been roasted maybe four days ago at most.
0:10:06If you look in the grocery store,
0:10:08I just did this, 'cause just last week I was out of town,
0:10:11and I wanted to buy a bag of coffee,
0:10:12and it was like a Whole Foods or something.
0:10:14And so, you know, looking at all the fancy brands,
0:10:16this one's local, this one's fresh,
0:10:18this one's in New Jersey,
0:10:19like you know, all these nice local things,
0:10:21that roasters, some of which I even knew
0:10:23where their roastery was, and I was looking,
0:10:26and you turn the bag over, and you can usually see,
0:10:28there's usually a sticker on any kind of good coffee bag
0:10:31to see when it was roasted.
0:10:33I could not find any that were roasted
0:10:35less than three weeks ago.
0:10:37And compare three weeks, at the best case,
0:10:39was three weeks ago, there were many
0:10:41that were much older than that.
0:10:42Three weeks ago, compared to three or four days ago.
0:10:45It's a massive difference.
0:10:47- What do you do to get started?
0:10:48Upgrade your morning routine with Better Coffee.
0:10:51Right now, Trade is offering a free bag of coffee
0:10:54with any subscription at drinktrade.com/thetalkshow.
0:10:59That's drinktrade.com/thetalkshow
0:11:05for a free bag of coffee with any subscription service.
0:11:09Drinktrade.com/thetalkshow.
0:11:12I would dare you, dare you to,
0:11:17you know how like on your show,
0:11:18you got like a little banjo
0:11:20that separates the official markers
0:11:22between the sponsorships and the show.
0:11:24I would dare you, that was actually Merlin-esque
0:11:28(laughs)
0:11:29in terms of blurring what is the show
0:11:32and what is the sponsor read.
0:11:34Merlin, with Merlin, I know you listen to my show,
0:11:38but I think you'd listen, I hope you listen to my show,
0:11:40but you know with Merlin, I honestly,
0:11:43to me, it's like I lose track of the show
0:11:45and the sponsor read just becomes the show.
0:11:48us talking about those slippers from Mack Weldon.
0:11:52(laughing)
0:11:53Honestly, God, I mean, that was like a 45-minute sponsor
0:11:55read the one time.
0:11:56(laughing)
0:12:00Couple of things I wanna talk about.
0:12:01A main reason I wanted to have you on this week
0:12:03is I wanna talk about the new HomePods,
0:12:05and I loved your review of them on ATP,
0:12:08and more or less just wanna steal it
0:12:10(laughing)
0:12:11and put it on my show.
0:12:12And I've been struggling to write my own.
0:12:17But on the news front, I wanted to talk first.
0:12:22I've actually spent my whole weekend working.
0:12:25I haven't written anything about it yet,
0:12:27but Joanna Stern and Nicole Nguyen
0:12:31at the Wall Street Journal
0:12:32published an amazing piece on Friday, a story.
0:12:36You saw this, right?
0:12:39- Yeah, I would call it a bombshell.
0:12:41- Yeah, I really, and I spent all weekend working on it,
0:12:45But the gist of their story in the Wall Street Journal
0:12:48is that they found about a dozen people in New York,
0:12:53maybe some of them are from outside New York,
0:12:57who had their iPhones stolen.
0:13:02Like, I think almost all the ones they talked to
0:13:05when they were out at night socializing at bars
0:13:08or something like that.
0:13:10iPhone is stolen, and they realize the iPhone's stolen,
0:13:14and next thing you know, in addition to being stolen,
0:13:18they're locked, they're completely locked out
0:13:20of their iCloud account.
0:13:21So even if they have a friend
0:13:24and they can get to a Find My iPhone
0:13:26or they can get home and get to their iPad
0:13:31or a MacBook that they might have,
0:13:33those devices are also locked out of iCloud.
0:13:37And it's effectively game over.
0:13:42that the thief has access to everything on their phone,
0:13:47everything in iCloud, and they can't get it back
0:13:53or restore it.
0:13:54This sounds so horrific that my first thought
0:14:00when I read it was there's got to be some hole
0:14:03in this story or some,
0:14:05these victims did something incredibly foolish
0:14:10reckless or something like that. But the basic gist of what I just said, it is completely true.
0:14:17And with some caveats, it in theory could happen to anybody. And then in addition to the people
0:14:27they found in New York and talked to firsthand, they talked to a police detective that she got
0:14:33in contact with in Minneapolis who has investigated dozens of these cases, maybe more. I forget. I was
0:14:43talking with Joanna last night. It's not like, oh, a handful. It is like dozens of cases.
0:14:49Again, like you said, it's a blockbuster.
0:14:53Jared Ranerelle - It seems like the biggest surprise to this,
0:14:57because even people like us who are like Apple power users, it's our job to know this
0:15:03stuff, we think we know it really well. The biggest surprise to me, which I think surprised
0:15:07most people like us, is that, so you know, the main method of the theft here was that
0:15:13the thieves would basically like look over their shoulder and see what their passcode
0:15:18was when they entered it. And then go ahead and steal the phone. And to some degree you
0:15:23can say, well, that's going to be pretty hard to protect against. But the big bombshell
0:15:27for this is that you can re, apparently you can reset
0:15:31an Apple ID password only knowing the passcode to the phone.
0:15:36- Right.
0:15:37- So what they're doing is they are shoulder surfing
0:15:40the passcode, stealing the phone at some point,
0:15:43and then quickly going and changing the Apple ID password,
0:15:46and then being able to then log into the Apple ID,
0:15:48do all the same secure stuff you can do from an Apple ID,
0:15:51remote change devices, remote revoke devices,
0:15:54and then have full access to your Apple account.
0:15:56I mean, that to me, that's the hole right there,
0:15:59is no, I don't think anyone in our circles knew
0:16:03that you can reset an Apple ID password
0:16:06by just knowing the passcode to a phone.
0:16:07- Right, I don't think so either.
0:16:10And I knew that there's a lot that you can do
0:16:12with just the passcode.
0:16:13And the one thing that's been on my mind for a while
0:16:16is that with just the passcode,
0:16:18it gives you access to the keychain,
0:16:23or on the iPhone, you go into settings and passwords
0:16:28and anything that's in passwords is visible
0:16:32and you can see all the passwords,
0:16:34you can see all the authenticator codes.
0:16:37There's no other factors involved just to get into Keychain.
0:16:43But the truth is, so like, again,
0:16:47trying to explain this out the way my mind works
0:16:51How I always want to know what these stories how exactly does this work because this seems so fantastic out so fantastic
0:16:59That it there's got to be some step in here where you're like
0:17:02Oh, that's the step where it wouldn't affect me because I'm smart and I've turned on blank, you know
0:17:09like a smart person does
0:17:11Yeah, like
0:17:14go back in time to like the original iPhone and
0:17:19passcodes weren't even a thing. One of the biggest demos of the original passcode was slide to unlock,
0:17:25right? Because with nobody passcoded their phones, right? They're pre-iPhone. You just opened up your
0:17:32phone and started doing stuff. And there, you know, maybe there would be like a button you would hold
0:17:38for a couple of seconds to make sure you don't like pocket dial somebody. And I guess some people
0:17:45could put a code on their phone if they had like a secure job or something like that, but I don't
0:17:50recall ever putting a code on my phone pre-iPhone. It was not the norm. Most people didn't do it.
0:17:55So, we went from, you know, and it makes sense that Apple designed the original iPhone to fit
0:18:04in that world where it's like a phone and like an iPod where you just take it out of your pocket
0:18:10and do something to make sure you're not pocket dialing or pocket playing songs or whatever else
0:18:15could happen accidentally and slide to unlock was the their solution to it like okay this phone
0:18:23won't do anything yet but here's slide to unlock and it was a in those terms of the pre-ios7
0:18:31flattening a totally lickable interface like they spent time you know some designer like mike madis
0:18:39spent like full effort and full power of a great graphic designer designing a little button down to
0:18:47the pixels and like a little three-dimensional looking channel for that thing to go across and
0:18:53that got you into the phone and you could do anything right so like if steve jobs had lost
0:19:00his phone in 2007 and you found it you know like there was a picture of him one time at like one
0:19:08one of his kids' soccer games or something,
0:19:10just standing there with an iPhone.
0:19:12I think it was a famous picture
0:19:13because it was before the iPhone,
0:19:15after it had been announced, but before it came out.
0:19:18And it's like, holy shit, there's Steve Jobs' soccer,
0:19:21a high school soccer game with an iPhone.
0:19:25But if he had lost it, you could've gotten
0:19:28into Steve Jobs' phone with just sliding your thumb
0:19:31across the screen.
0:19:33And then we've gone from there to here,
0:19:37where we've realized, you know, there's, you know,
0:19:40people have their entire digital lives on these phones
0:19:44and we've protected them more.
0:19:46And Apple has developed
0:19:47Face ID and Touch ID
0:19:53as these biometric things to encourage people
0:19:58to have some protection.
0:20:00Like a big problem Apple solved over these years
0:20:04was encouraging people to put codes on their phone at all.
0:20:08Right, like when it first started to become a thing
0:20:10and Apple clearly realized, oh, everybody,
0:20:13we should try to encourage everybody to have a phone
0:20:17or a code on their phone.
0:20:19I knew people who resisted it.
0:20:20I'm not gonna name names, but there were people
0:20:23in my household who didn't see the need.
0:20:28And they did-- - Well, even now,
0:20:30like you can still set up a phone without a passcode,
0:20:33And it's funny 'cause I do it on a regular basis
0:20:35because all my developer phones that are just,
0:20:37I need a device that runs iOS 15,
0:20:40so I have an old iPhone that I use for that.
0:20:42And I always set those up without passcodes.
0:20:44And they make it increasingly difficult
0:20:47if you find the little hidden option to do it
0:20:49and they yell at you a whole bunch,
0:20:50like you really shouldn't do this.
0:20:53You have to try pretty hard.
0:20:54- It's almost like an anti-dark pattern.
0:20:56It's like a light pattern of bad user interface,
0:20:59or not bad user interface,
0:21:02but obtuse user interface,
0:21:06where this should be obtuse and discouraging, right?
0:21:10And we typically think of those techniques
0:21:12of being ways to like make it hard to unsubscribe
0:21:17from a service you've already subscribed to,
0:21:19and they were a real jerk about it,
0:21:21and they, or just to think about the way,
0:21:25the dark pattern I run into every single day
0:21:29is you get a marketing email from somebody,
0:21:31and the unsubscribe link is in six point type
0:21:36and it's set to 40% gray at the bottom of the email, right?
0:21:40It's like, I don't know that the email clients
0:21:46would render typeset at a smaller CSS point size
0:21:50and it's gray text on a white background.
0:21:53They definitely do that to discourage people
0:21:56from trying to set up a phone without a passcode.
0:22:00was famous back when Trump was president.
0:22:04He had Kanye West in his office for some, you know,
0:22:09of course, nonsensical meeting and clown show,
0:22:13and with cameras and press and people,
0:22:16and Kanye had his phone and wanted to show something,
0:22:20and his passcode was 1111.
0:22:22(laughs)
0:22:23And it was completely visible.
0:22:25Hold that thought, but completely visible to the world,
0:22:28and I think it was one.
0:22:30It was either 1111 or 1234.
0:22:32I'm pretty sure, though, it was 1111.
0:22:34- That's probably the most common passcode.
0:22:38Like if you actually had the numbers,
0:22:40like what are the most common passcodes?
0:22:42I bet 1111 is by far the most common.
0:22:44- I don't know that it's, so I haven't done it in a while,
0:22:46but while doing things like testing review phones,
0:22:51I've set up phones and tried to make it stupid easy.
0:22:53Like here's a review phone that I'm not actually
0:22:55going to put a SIM card in.
0:22:57I'm just gonna play around with it in my house,
0:23:00so I'm not even gonna leave the house with it.
0:23:02And if you try that, it actually will tell,
0:23:04I think, at least the last time I tried it,
0:23:07with certain of those passcodes, the iOS will tell you,
0:23:12that's a weak passcode.
0:23:15Do you wanna maybe try something that's not easily guessed?
0:23:19You know.
0:23:19- You wanna try literally anything else besides 1111.
0:23:23(laughing)
0:23:25So we're in a world now where everybody has these passcodes,
0:23:30but the thing that's not obvious,
0:23:33it's sort of mind-blowing to me and to you,
0:23:40probably everybody who's listening,
0:23:41and I suspect a lot of people who are listening
0:23:43who didn't spend their entire weekend researching this
0:23:48are still listening to us thinking, it can't be this bad.
0:23:53I can't be this exposed if somebody knows my passcode.
0:23:57But the truth is, if you have the phone
0:23:59and you know the passcode, you're in God mode.
0:24:05You have access to anything and everything on the phone.
0:24:09There is nothing on the phone
0:24:11that you can't do or change, nothing.
0:24:15There's every single thing on the phone.
0:24:18Now, you might use an app, a third-party app,
0:24:22like a bank app or like a password manager,
0:24:27or even a notes app.
0:24:30I remember getting the feature requests from Vesper users.
0:24:34You know, a notes app sometimes will let you set
0:24:38your own password within the app,
0:24:41and that has nothing to do with your key.
0:24:43It doesn't go in your key chain.
0:24:45And so something like that,
0:24:48you still would be protected from.
0:24:50- No, you wouldn't.
0:24:51See, I was just thinking about this,
0:24:53'cause one of the security things that I do
0:24:55is I don't store my main banking password
0:24:59in a password manager.
0:25:01I don't store it anywhere, I just know it.
0:25:03And it's a very secure password
0:25:05and it never goes in a password manager.
0:25:07'Cause I figure that's, of all the important passwords
0:25:08I have, that's probably the most important.
0:25:10And so I was just thinking, like,
0:25:13oh, well, at least I'm protected there, but no, I'm not.
0:25:15Because I've set up Face ID for that app, for convenience.
0:25:20- And face--
0:25:21So, face ID, that's the passcode, right?
0:25:24So if you had my phone and the passcode,
0:25:27I realized like five minutes ago, I was thinking about this,
0:25:29I'm like, oh my god, wait a minute, I'm exposed there.
0:25:32Because if you have my phone and you should reserve
0:25:33my passcode and you get my phone,
0:25:35then you could log into my bank app.
0:25:38Because I have a face ID log in there.
0:25:40And anything like that, anything where you have face ID
0:25:42or touch ID protection, that is only as good
0:25:45as your passcode, and if your passcode is known to somebody
0:25:48and then they gain physical access to the device,
0:25:51can get into anything protected by face ID, including not only, you know, any apps that
0:25:55have it, but also, as you mentioned earlier, all of your saved passwords and Apple's password
0:25:59thing. Or if you use a password manager like 1Password and you have face ID for that, there
0:26:03you go. That's also then exposed.
0:26:05Right. So you're only anything, the only thing that wouldn't be protected would be something
0:26:10that's protected by a third party separate password and you don't have face ID or touch
0:26:17enabled to get into that.
0:26:20I'm gonna just say face ID,
0:26:21because I think that's what most everybody's on now.
0:26:24I'll get to, there's some specific differences
0:26:27with touch ID on some of the implications of this.
0:26:29But for brevity, I'll just say face ID.
0:26:34Face ID, the other thing I've learned over the weekend,
0:26:40and I guess I knew this, but now I know it,
0:26:44is that Face ID is only an accelerant for your passcode.
0:26:49It's not two things, like a left hand and a right hand.
0:26:57The only thing that protects your phone is your passcode.
0:27:06And Face ID is a layer above the passcode
0:27:10that gets you into the passcode.
0:27:12They're not two equal methods of getting it.
0:27:17And therefore, every time anything that you do with Face ID,
0:27:20and I learned this daily during COVID
0:27:25while I was out wearing a face mask in public,
0:27:28and at most, 90% of that time
0:27:32before Apple had enabled Face ID to work with a mask on,
0:27:37where I'd bring my phone up and Face ID fails,
0:27:41and then immediately gives you to the passcode entry
0:27:45as an option.
0:27:45Everything, anytime you ever are prompted for face ID,
0:27:49if it doesn't work, you have the option
0:27:51to use your passcode instead.
0:27:54And that's because those biometric methods
0:27:59are just accelerants for the passcode.
0:28:02So if you have the phone and you have the passcode,
0:28:05you're in God mode on the phone.
0:28:07Everything is possible.
0:28:09The other thing that to me I just didn't know, I really didn't, is what you mentioned
0:28:16before. And this is the level that takes you out of God Mode just on the phone and lets
0:28:24you take over the account is you go to Settings, iCloud, which is that thing at the top with
0:28:32your picture, right? And your name.
0:28:34and get the terrible UI where you never think
0:28:37to look there at first,
0:28:38'cause it doesn't even look like a button necessarily.
0:28:40- Right, so you're at the very top of settings,
0:28:43it has your name, and it says Apple ID,
0:28:45iCloud, median purchases.
0:28:48Second level down is password and security,
0:28:50and, or I think that's where this is.
0:28:55Is that where this is?
0:28:56Or no, you have to go down to, where do you do it?
0:28:59I just did it three times over the weekend,
0:29:01but I can't figure out exactly where it is now.
0:29:03But anyway, there's somewhere on the--
0:29:05- Somewhere it's in there. (laughs)
0:29:07- You go down there and it says password
0:29:13and you can go reset password
0:29:17and then you just enter a new password
0:29:20and reenter it to confirm it's the same one
0:29:23and boom, you've changed the iCloud password
0:29:26without ever entering or being prompted
0:29:31for the old password, right?
0:29:33And the surprise thing to me about that
0:29:37is that I just, I don't think I've ever done it that way
0:29:40'cause I don't, I don't know,
0:29:42I've probably only changed my iCloud password
0:29:45a handful of times in, I don't know, 20 years, right?
0:29:48I mean, I've been using it since it was mac.com.
0:29:51- Yeah, and if I wanted to change my iCloud password,
0:29:54I would do it on the website, like from a computer.
0:29:56- Right. - Like I would never,
0:29:57I would never think to do it on,
0:29:58I mean, of course you can do it on the phone,
0:30:00that makes sense, but I would never have thought
0:30:01to do that, so I would never even
0:30:03thought to look for this feature?
0:30:05- Oh, here it is, it's right at the top.
0:30:08So you go to, at the top of settings, into iCloud,
0:30:11second level down is password and security,
0:30:14and the very first item at the top is, it's blue even,
0:30:19it's even more prominent.
0:30:21You just hit change password, and it spins for a little.
0:30:28- And as with everything iCloud.
0:30:30- But then all you have to do,
0:30:31it does just let you change it.
0:30:33What it asks you for is your iPhone passcode.
0:30:37And you type your iPhone passcode,
0:30:39which is the only two factors the thief needs,
0:30:43physical possession of the device
0:30:45and knowledge of the passcode.
0:30:47You enter it, here I am entering it.
0:30:49And boom, I have a field
0:30:55where I can change my iCloud password.
0:30:58- Without knowing the old one.
0:31:00- Right, without knowing the old one.
0:31:01And the second you complete that,
0:31:05the second you've entered a new iCloud password,
0:31:11the very next thing the iPhone does is prompt you,
0:31:15do you want to lock out all the other devices
0:31:18that are currently logged into this iCloud account?
0:31:21- Oh, God.
0:31:24And there's two options, like decline or accept,
0:31:29or lock 'em out.
0:31:32And you hit lock 'em out, and then boom,
0:31:35the other devices are locked out.
0:31:38And then that's it, game over for the victim.
0:31:43And there's no way for them to get back,
0:31:47certainly can't get back the iPhone,
0:31:49can't control that the person who has the iPhone
0:31:53has access to everything on your iPhone but they can't get back their iCloud
0:31:58account there's nothing they can do nothing Apple can do and you could say
0:32:04oh but I set up the recovery key and I have it I know I know I have that stored
0:32:14safely I printed it out and put it in a safe place in my house it's too late the
0:32:20The recovery key is only for, I tried this over the weekend.
0:32:25There's no way to get to any area
0:32:27where you can just use this recovery key.
0:32:30- Oh, that's interesting.
0:32:31So you can't go to like a forgot password thing?
0:32:34- No, you can go to the forgot password thing,
0:32:36but there's no path at that point
0:32:38to use the recovery key to get your account back.
0:32:43Same thing for a recovery contact.
0:32:47Like if I say I trust Marco so much
0:32:50that I'm gonna make Marco Arment my recovery contact.
0:32:54And vacationing in Hawaii,
0:32:59and while I'm taking a picture of a volcano,
0:33:01drop my iPhone right into a volcano and it just melts.
0:33:05And now I don't have an iPhone.
0:33:07And I've forgotten my,
0:33:14I've also forgotten my iCloud account password.
0:33:17So I can't even get into iCloud.
0:33:19There, you could help me, because what I could do
0:33:25is go back to, I could go to Verizon,
0:33:29tell them what happened, and I'll prove that I'm still me,
0:33:33and I'll get a new phone, and now I've got
0:33:35my phone number again.
0:33:37And I can go to IForgot.apple.com, and there's a path.
0:33:42I won't go through all the DB good. You know, it's not easy, you know, it's not supposed to be obvious
0:33:47But I go there but they'll say at some point and and they'll say you know, well what you you don't know your password, huh?
0:33:53Well, how about we'll send?
0:33:55code to your trusted phone number and then I get the trusted phone number and that lets me into my
0:34:04my
0:34:05iCloud account
0:34:06But I won't have access to any of my encrypted stuff
0:34:11So I won't have access to my keychain. I won't have access to my health data
0:34:17They've start right on my right. They've started encrypting your photo library now, right?
0:34:22Is it that way by default or do you have to opt into the the whole encryption thing?
0:34:28I can't believe I forgot about this because I've written about it so much
0:34:32But you don't get access to any of your encrypted stuff if you read it keychain
0:34:40But what I can do to get access to that
0:34:43encrypted stuff and then get full access is I can I can say I have recovery contact or I have that
0:34:51recovery key the 28 digit and number mixed character thing and
0:34:57I can use that
0:34:59To as a
0:35:03Key to decrypt to give you know, I can give that to Apple
0:35:08Digitally type it in and then that will decrypt my encrypted stuff that they have an iCloud and now I'm back to having a full thing
0:35:15But you can't do that if you don't have the phone number
0:35:21There might be I'm not quite sure maybe there's a path here where the thief
0:35:29You can go to Verizon and prove that somebody stole your phone and you could still get your phone number back even though
0:35:36you know, even though the thief still has your phone, right?
0:35:41I think that, you know.
0:35:44- Oh yeah, that, I mean, that's the whole thing
0:35:46with like, you know, SIM card cloning attacks
0:35:48is you go to a carrier store and you say,
0:35:50oh sorry, I lost my phone, give me a new, you know,
0:35:53clone my SIM onto this new phone I'm buying,
0:35:55and that's why like two-factor stuff
0:35:59to a phone number is not super secure.
0:36:03but it's calm. So I'm not quite sure. So I'm not quite sure why some of the victims that Joanna
0:36:08and Nicole talked to still are locked out of their iCloud account. It might be that I'm not
0:36:14100% sure on some of these details. Yeah, that's why, like I said, I've been working on it all
0:36:18weekend. So it might be that that gets you, it might be that that still doesn't help you because
0:36:24the thief changed the password. It's still, you still might be screwed. I think that that's the
0:36:31problem. Yeah, that's right. That's the problem. The problem is in my scenario where I dropped my
0:36:35phone in a volcano, my iCloud password hasn't been changed. And so your recovery key that has my
0:36:42trust, that's is this is right. You still are, you're fucked. Even if Verizon gives you your
0:36:47phone number back because in the, in the innocent scenario where the phone was destroyed or lost off
0:36:54a bridge or whatever, the iCloud password is still there. You just forgot it in your head.
0:37:02And so your recovery key will still decrypt my stuff or the recovery key that I've printed out,
0:37:08the 28-digit thing will still work. But in the case where the thief has changed the password,
0:37:14that invalidates all of those previous things. Oh, and the other thing you can do, once you're
0:37:19in the phone with this is this is the other thing once this is where it is i should back up i've
0:37:27just forgotten it there's so many little details here this is why i've been working on it all
0:37:30weekend this is the thing because you got access to everything on the phone the checklist of things
0:37:36that a thief and one of these rings will do is immediately go in and when after they've changed
0:37:42their password they'll go down and just delete the recovery keys because you can always you can
0:37:47always revoke a recovery key and you can always revoke a recovery contact, right? So, you know,
0:37:56you and I break up as friends and I no longer trust you, then I, you know, of course I can
0:38:02remove you as my recovery key, right? Or contact, right? If you get a divorce, of course you can
0:38:10change your recovery contact so it's no longer the spouse who you've broken up with, right?
0:38:16Of course, and so it's, you know, there's like a checklist of like seven things that a thief in
0:38:22one of these rings would do, and one of them would be revoking those recovery keys, which all you need
0:38:27to do is know the passcode. This is all. Yeah, because if you have a phone with a passcode,
0:38:35and then you have control of the Apple ID from that, the phone is also a two-factor device,
0:38:39so you have any two-factor code from Apple. Like, it's just, you have everything at that point.
0:38:44if you have the Apple ID and a logged-in phone, that's it. That's everything.
0:38:49Dave: Yep, that's everything. And this is all by design. This is not an oversight or a bug,
0:38:56right? Remember back in the early days, I mean, like early years, because it would,
0:39:02every couple, I don't know, once a year or so, one of these glitches would come up.
0:39:06Remember, there'd be like these lock screen hijacks where it would be
0:39:10just some kind of weird bug in iOS where if you entered the numbers super fast,
0:39:18you could somehow get through even if it wasn't the right number.
0:39:20Some sequence of events you could operate some part of the phone that was supposed to be locked
0:39:28without unlocking it. Right. Or it was like if you did it right when a notification first arrived,
0:39:35you could get through without it or the head, you know, something that you would do like
0:39:41there's always been a handful of things you could do with a locked phone, like the way that you can
0:39:46take pictures without unlocking it. And you'd go into that mode and swipe up, swipe down,
0:39:55and then all of a sudden you're in. And they've, you know, they seem to have closed most of those
0:39:59bugs. This whole scenario we're talking about is not some kind of oversight. It is something that
0:40:06Apple designed to work this way. And this is simply a known danger in the design. And you
0:40:19might say, "Well, why in the world would they design it this way?" And the reason is there are
0:40:28vastly more people who forget their iCloud password,
0:40:33but of course still know their phone passcode
0:40:40'cause they have to, almost nobody forgets that.
0:40:43So they know how to get in their phone,
0:40:45they don't know their iCloud password,
0:40:47and there are vastly more of these people,
0:40:50and being able to change it this way is by design.
0:40:55is by design.
0:40:57And knowing though, so there's like, let's say,
0:41:02hundreds of people, I don't know, a year,
0:41:05hundreds or thousands of people who get their phone stolen
0:41:09and lose everything this way to a thief
0:41:14and tens of thousands of people or more,
0:41:17I don't know if it's orders of magnitude or what,
0:41:19but what I have been told by people who would know,
0:41:24It is vastly more people are saved and regain access
0:41:29to their iCloud account than who are victims of thieves
0:41:35through this, which is why it's designed this way.
0:41:38And it is the true, and it is the case
0:41:42that with an Android phone, you can do the same thing.
0:41:46You can reset your main Google account password
0:41:51knowing nothing but the passcode to the Android phone.
0:41:55- I mean, that's the hard part, right?
0:41:58Like, you know, when you're designing these things,
0:42:00especially for the mass market,
0:42:01and especially for something as important
0:42:02as someone's phone, you know,
0:42:04there's huge trade-offs with security
0:42:07that you have to account for the humans being forgetful
0:42:10and making mistakes, and this is always such a hard balance
0:42:14in security design, and, you know,
0:42:16I don't envy Apple's position here,
0:42:18and I'm not looking at this saying like,
0:42:21oh, what idiots they were.
0:42:23Instead, it's more like, oh, wow,
0:42:25I did not know this hole was there.
0:42:27And it makes sense, if you think about it,
0:42:29it makes sense why it's there, as you were just saying,
0:42:31'cause lots of people forget their passwords
0:42:33and passcodes all the time.
0:42:34And they are more likely to forget the Apple ID password
0:42:38than they are to forget the passcode of the phone
0:42:40they're typing in three times a day.
0:42:42But the big shock here is like,
0:42:44during COVID, as you mentioned earlier,
0:42:47when we were all first having a grocery shopping,
0:42:50all masked up and everything before Apple had face ID
0:42:53recognizing mask, which really came fairly late
0:42:56in that process.
0:42:57We were all having to type in our passcodes all the time.
0:43:01And before that, I had switched to an alphanumeric passcode,
0:43:04like a password.
0:43:05And when that happened, I was having to type it in so much,
0:43:10oftentimes like wearing plastic gloves
0:43:12in the grocery store and everything.
0:43:13It was such a pain that I would,
0:43:16I had switched pretty early in COVID,
0:43:18but I switched back to a numeric passcode.
0:43:22And I had kept that numeric passcode until today.
0:43:26When I heard about this story, I'm like,
0:43:29"Oh my God, wait a minute."
0:43:30Because if you can reset the Apple ID password
0:43:33by knowing the phone passcode,
0:43:34then effectively, my Apple ID password
0:43:37was just a six digit number.
0:43:39And that's not the level of security that I want for that,
0:43:42or that I think is warranted for that.
0:43:43And so, Apple has all these requirements.
0:43:46The Apple ID password has to have certain characteristics,
0:43:48has to be a certain minimum length,
0:43:50has to have letters, numbers, whatever the requirements are,
0:43:53because that's a really high security password.
0:43:56The Apple ID means a lot.
0:43:57It's a huge risk surface, right?
0:43:59But if you can have a phone with a few numbers on it
0:44:03that might be 1111, and you can then take the Apple ID
0:44:07from that, well then that's effectively
0:44:08the Apple ID's password security level.
0:44:11And so, like many security loopholes or security rules
0:44:15loopholes or bugs or tricks, you learn,
0:44:19oh, you have this big wall of security over here,
0:44:22your Apple ID password, it's really secure.
0:44:24But you didn't realize that you could just walk around
0:44:27the wall in this way and have a much lower security version
0:44:30of something get right around that.
0:44:32So I think it's wise for nerds like us
0:44:35to treat your phone passcode the same way you'd treat
0:44:39your Apple ID password in terms of security,
0:44:41because they are effectively, one leads to the other.
0:44:44- Yeah, so I looked it up just for people
0:44:47who are gonna email me, I've done it.
0:44:49So it was just a few months ago,
0:44:51which is why I'm surprised I forgot it already,
0:44:54where Apple announced advanced data protection for iCloud,
0:44:57end-to-end encryption for backups, photos, and more.
0:45:01So if you have that turned on,
0:45:03that that's included in the stuff that you lose access to
0:45:07in the case where you would need like a recovery key
0:45:13recovery contact. So, photos are included. All of this is. I have an alphanumeric password on my
0:45:23phone and I have for a while. I did the same thing during COVID during the mask. There was just no
0:45:27way I was going to type that in all the time. Not out of paranoia, but because it's very, this is a
0:45:36very personal look into my psyche and my chronic procrastination is I've been
0:45:43meaning to write for probably over a year a daring fireball piece
0:45:50declaring that a six-digit passcode is actually more than secure enough for an iPhone,
0:46:00even though you might not intuitively think it is. Thinking only about crackers,
0:46:08somebody who just has the phone and is using one of those black market devices that can enter
0:46:13passcodes very quickly. Because once you enter enough passcodes incorrectly, the phone gets
0:46:23locked you can't try them that often and even if you somehow break the phone with
0:46:31a jailbreak and get past that circumvention the iOS level of
0:46:37preventing more than ten attempts the way that the secure enclave works
0:46:47fundamentally, not in software, but cryptographically, is that I think there's like a theoretical
0:46:55limit of only six attempts per second or something. I forget. The piece I want to write would
0:47:00explain it and it would all make sense. But the gist of it is that for somebody who falls
0:47:06into some trap and somebody with complicated apparatus, some kind of device and a jailbreak
0:47:15that Apple doesn't know about and hasn't closed to get past iOS and has access to your secure
0:47:21enclave.
0:47:22I mean, obviously at this point, almost how many people would anybody target like this?
0:47:27But let's say you're one of them.
0:47:29They still a six digit passcode would take like on average, I don't know, like 50,000
0:47:36years or a million years, some unbelievably safe number.
0:47:41perspective of an attacker, a six digit passcode is really actually pretty secure.
0:47:46Well that assumes that you have like you know six random to which most people don't like you know
0:47:54like if you're making something like people often will overestimate the security value of certain
0:48:00length strings or numbers whatever because they assume that somebody who's trying to brute force
0:48:05it would just try, you know, AAA, AAB, AAC, and that's not how they do it. They, you know,
0:48:13use databases of most common values that people actually use, and they try the most common
0:48:18ones first. And so oftentimes you have way less entropy than you think you do if you've
0:48:23chosen something that's, you know, beyond just pure randomness.
0:48:29So what, here's the look into my psyche. My thing to myself was about a year ago, or
0:48:35time at right after the mask thing was over. So it's probably been more than a year. But I changed
0:48:41back to this alphanumeric passcode. Then I decided I looked into this and did the math and proved the
0:48:48math and thought, "Ah, a six-digit passcode is safe enough for me. And I'm going to encourage
0:48:54my readers that it's safe enough for them. But I'm not going to change it on my phone until I
0:49:00write that article. It's like, that's the carrot to prompt me to do it. And obviously,
0:49:06I haven't written that article. And so I've been using the harder to type alphanumeric
0:49:13password to get into the phone ever since. And now we're here talking about this story.
0:49:22And I'm like, huh, I've been feeling bad about this every single time I type my password to get
0:49:29into my phone every single time I do it every time every time I restart it every time I
0:49:35you know you don't have to enter it that often when you use face ID but every time I do
0:49:41every single time I think god damn it I should freaking write that article so I
0:49:45can't want to stop doing this I want to go to a much easier to type and you know
0:49:51thumbable passcode and now this story's come out I'm like huh I'm kind of glad I never
0:49:57encouraged people to switch to a passcode if they already had a password, alphanumeric password,
0:50:04because I don't think that's a good idea. I really don't. I don't know. I mean, it seems like you
0:50:16agree since you changed, right? Jared: Yeah, because, you know, I think in addition to the,
0:50:23you know, probably better security in most ways
0:50:26for most people for it being a password style,
0:50:29I think, an alphanumeric password style.
0:50:31I think it actually helps this particular problem
0:50:34of somebody like shoulder surfing your code.
0:50:36It helps if your code looks and works
0:50:39like typing in a password because, you know,
0:50:42people, I think, people don't necessarily think
0:50:45when you're typing your passcode in public
0:50:48if anyone's looking at them.
0:50:49- Right.
0:50:50- You know, if you're just typing in the numbers,
0:50:51you know, one, two, three, four, you know,
0:50:52you're used to having it so fast and the buttons are so big
0:50:55and the screen is visible from all angles.
0:50:58- Kanye West typed his 1111 in the Oval Office
0:51:02surrounded by cameras.
0:51:03- Right, so I feel like people will oftentimes
0:51:10kind of more casually hit the buttons
0:51:12for the numeric passcodes and not think too much
0:51:16about who can see this, whereas when you're typing
0:51:19in a password field for the alphanumeric one,
0:51:22Not only is it just physically smaller
0:51:24and a little bit harder for someone
0:51:26to see what you're typing,
0:51:28but also I feel like you might just psychologically
0:51:31treat that like a password in the sense that
0:51:34if somebody was looking over your shoulder
0:51:38at your keyboard as you're typing,
0:51:40you're not gonna type in your password.
0:51:41You're gonna be like, "Excuse me,"
0:51:43or you're gonna move to your back as to them or whatever.
0:51:45And I feel like if you make your phone passcode
0:51:49look and work like a password entry,
0:51:52the way the alphanumeric ones do,
0:51:54I think you will just kind of automatically,
0:51:56behaviorally have better physical security around yourself.
0:52:00You might turn your back to somebody,
0:52:01or hold it closer to your chest
0:52:04so no one can see it or whatever.
0:52:05Like you might just kind of instinctively treat it
0:52:07like the password that it is.
0:52:09- I don't think that people,
0:52:11I still think you could be safe with a numeric passcode.
0:52:15I really do.
0:52:16And I'm still thinking maybe after doing,
0:52:19talking about all this, I still might switch. The thing that I think everybody—the number
0:52:23one takeaway, to skip to the end, that I think everybody should take from this is that you
0:52:29should be—and you just touched on it—you should be overly paranoid every time you enter
0:52:37your iPhone passcode or password in public. Any time you do it, you should treat it as
0:52:45secret and be a little creepy about it, you know, or reverse creepy about it. I remember,
0:52:50I'm old enough that I remember when atms were a new invention, or at least newly
0:52:57universal. I was like an elementary school and all of a sudden atms became a thing and you could just
0:53:06if you need you know, your dad needed money at the at the mall, there was like a machine over
0:53:11there and he'd added a thing that looked like a credit card that went in and then type a number.
0:53:16And when I first got a bank account in high, like a savings account in high school
0:53:22before I went to college, you know, they were new. And they were actually better machines because
0:53:28they had like clicky buttons. You know, it's like my clicky keyboard thing. They had really,
0:53:33they always, they had really good buttons back then. But everybody, it's just instinctively back
0:53:40in the 80s and 90s or more of a 90s thing when I was actually using it, but I remember them in the
0:53:4780s. But it was like a cultural thing. And I remember Amy and I were talking about it this
0:53:52weekend as I was obsessed with this story when people entered their ATMs codes back then, they
0:53:58would really physically hunch over the machine and really, really sort of obscure what they were
0:54:06typing, I mean, as best you can physically. And it was also a cultural norm then, if you were next in
0:54:13line for the ATM to stand like six feet away, like COVID distance, really. But it was a total social
0:54:21thing, where if you were closer than about six or seven feet, as the next customer, it seemed like
0:54:29you were weird. And it was just complete strangers, but the person who was up would look over their
0:54:37shoulder and the person would be like, "Oh, sorry, sorry," and take a couple steps back.
0:54:41It was always like, "Oh, somebody who was just like…" I wasn't really thinking, "Sorry, sorry."
0:54:47And they'd back up. And everybody treated those numbers super secretly because this whole idea of
0:54:53getting your cash out of a machine, having nothing but a credit card and a four-digit number
0:54:58seemed so weird. Even though, and again, like all sorts of things,
0:55:05people freak out when they buy anything financial happens new. I remember when buying
0:55:13stuff over the web was like, some people thought it's crazy. They're like, you're nuts. You're
0:55:17typing your credit card into a webpage? You're insane. Meanwhile, they go out to lunch and hand
0:55:22the credit card to the waiter, you know, when the bill comes. And he walks away with it.
0:55:27But something novel is naturally—it triggers something in the human brain. And when ATMs were
0:55:35novel, people treated it like that. That's the mentality, I think, though, that everybody should
0:55:40internalize permanently for their passcode for their phone. Treat it like we did back then.
0:55:47Don't enter it within six or seven feet of anybody if you get a lot
0:55:51You know somehow you need to enter it in public because you know like I don't know
0:55:55it whatever reason you know or
0:55:58Go to the bathroom if you're at a bar if somehow like you're you're you're at a bar and you had your phone sitting on
0:56:05The bar because I think one of the tricks I'm trying I spent the weekend thinking about this is how did the how do you?
0:56:13Get someone to have to enter their passcode when?
0:56:16In a normal night out you just you'd never need more than face ID
0:56:20It's it's unusual
0:56:22but it's like a it's a classic social engineering thing where the scammers would do things and Joanna even had a
0:56:29reference to the one guy where one of the tricks was to try to you know
0:56:34Get get the victims to let let the perpetrator take a picture of them, right?
0:56:38So like you meet a couple of women who are out celebrating and and you you know
0:56:44You're there and you're the criminal and you're talking them up and it's cheerful and everybody's having a good time and you find out that
0:56:50They're you know, it's one of the one of the women's birthday and you're like, let me take a picture of the three of you
0:56:55For the night here. Give me your phone
0:56:57I'll take a picture of you and you can the guy your phone and it's locked right?
0:57:01It's you haven't unlocked the phone. You can just hand them the phone
0:57:04that's why the camera is there and he can hit the camera button and
0:57:09Take the picture or take a couple pictures and then as he hands it back all he has to do is squeeze the two side buttons
0:57:17For two or three seconds and it puts it into the hard lock mode
0:57:21I've written about this hard lock mode all the time where you squeeze the power button and either of the volume buttons for here
0:57:28Let me do it to myself
0:57:30It takes like two seconds maybe two maybe less than two seconds
0:57:36It's the easily less time than it takes to hand the phone back and your hand positions on the phone
0:57:43Don't look unusual, right?
0:57:45it look it's exactly how you'd be holding the phone as you
0:57:48politely hand it back to the person and they hand it back and now it's on this slide to power off and
0:57:54You can or you can it maybe you hit cancel if you're clever so they don't yeah
0:57:58You just hit the hit the sleep wake button again
0:58:00I think then I think it you know, it'll dismiss that screen
0:58:03but it's still then locked.
0:58:04Right. And then all of a sudden, and that's a powerfully great feature of the iPhone,
0:58:10and everybody should know that feature. I always recommend every time you go through
0:58:14TSA or any time you go through customs, any time you deal with any kind of law enforcement,
0:58:20just squeeze those buttons for a second or two. You get a little bit of haptic feedback
0:58:25when you know that it's kicked in. You don't have to look at the screen. You could do it
0:58:28when it's in your pocket or your purse. But at that point, the phone needs the passcode to do
0:58:35anything. And then, you know, then you just, that's when you shoulder surf. And the next time
0:58:41the person you're trying to steal the phone from unlocks their phone or wants to, it's like,
0:58:47huh, I have to enter my passcode, huh? There it is, passcode. Joanna's story said that some of them
0:58:53worked in pairs. The group in Minnesota was a group of 12. So you could imagine it might be
0:59:01easier to have the person who took the photo on one side hand the phone back, have the shoulder
0:59:09surfer on the other side, and say like, "Hey, look at the photos. What do you think? Did I get
0:59:15it right?" And, "Oh, I have to unlock my phone first before I can even see this photo. I'll
0:59:21unlock it and the shoulder surfers right there. Yep. Oh, man. I think that scenario, the "let me
0:59:29have your phone to take a picture and then squeeze the buttons as they hand it and then the shoulder
0:59:35surfer is right there" is probably the most common way of doing it. You know, there might be
0:59:42other scenarios, but I think they all rely on similar things. And like I said, people like
0:59:49sometimes leave their phones on the bar or on a tabletop, you know, when you're at like a,
0:59:54you know, sitting at a four top. And if all you have to do, you don't have to take the phone
1:00:01and people put their phones face down. All you have to do if you can surreptitiously just get
1:00:05your hand on those buttons and squeeze them for like a second and a half, the phone suddenly
1:00:10locked and then the next time that person picks up the phone, that's when you're looking to see
1:00:14if you can glean the number and you can get a couple guesses. So if you think it's 1234,
1:00:20but it's really 1233, you know, it might be, you know, you'd still have a good chance
1:00:26of getting the guess. So my that's my top recommendation for anybody like me, who's
1:00:33completely freaked by this is to treat entering your phone passcode as like state secret when
1:00:40you're out in public, just if you ever need to do it. And I think back to how many times
1:00:44I did it in line during COVID. And it's—
1:00:48Oh, yeah. So, so often.
1:00:50Oh, my God. It is—
1:00:51Because we had to, you know?
1:00:52Right.
1:00:52And, you know, everyone—you know, the only thing is nobody was seeing our code because
1:00:56they kind of had to look down at their phone and have them in their code.
1:00:58Well, the other—the only thing we had going on in COVID to protect us from this was that there
1:01:02was—all the stores had those, like, tape markers six feet apart. So everybody—your next customer
1:01:08was six feet behind you. But the number one thing you can do to protect yourself—well, I mean,
1:01:13I guess a longer passcode or an alphanumeric passcode would help too because those are
1:01:19certainly harder. Something you type on the keyboard is sort of hard to glean.
1:01:23There's talk of, I don't think anybody that, you know, none of the criminal cases that she
1:01:30uncovered seemed to do it, but there's talk of what if, you know, can you use a camera to record
1:01:39the person doing it and then zoom in and see it and do it in slow motion. In a bar scenario where
1:01:45the the crooks hopefully don't own the bar, I think a camera would be tough, right? It's not
1:01:54like you're going to get in there and place a camera in the bar and it would look weird if
1:02:00somebody you just met is standing there with their phone camera on shooting video at a way
1:02:08that would look at the level of your hand. Maybe though, if you practice and do it, and
1:02:15then you can use that video footage to decode it. But an alphanumeric password would be
1:02:22really hard to get, even if you had video of it. Although, as you type on an iPhone
1:02:29keyboard, every letter you press pops up the letter you hit.
1:02:34Yeah, that's not great. It's not. It's great for the innocent case of knowing that you typed the
1:02:42right letter. It's not great for the case of somebody shooting 4K video of you typing
1:02:49your password and figuring out exactly which letters and replaying it in slow motion, right?
1:02:564K 60 video and then replaying it in slow motion. Really, really just mind blowing.
1:03:04And what should Apple do differently?
1:03:07- That's the thing.
1:03:09- Right.
1:03:10- It's really hard to, 'cause again,
1:03:12they have this massive support and data loss issue
1:03:16for people who are forgetful of their stuff,
1:03:18so they do have to make these things easy to recover from.
1:03:21They have to make password forgetting easy to recover from.
1:03:25I've developed a lot of web login stuff,
1:03:30and one of the things that surprised me over the years
1:03:33was quite how many people just hit forgot password
1:03:37every time they log into something.
1:03:39Because they don't even bother trying to remember it.
1:03:41And, or they have so many passwords to remember,
1:03:44they're just like, ah, this will be faster
1:03:46than me trying a bunch of passwords
1:03:47and forgetting anyway, you know.
1:03:48So they just go straight for forgot password.
1:03:50Like, people don't remember passwords, it's simple as that.
1:03:52And especially, you know, your Apple ID, you figure,
1:03:55well, that's, again, they have all those security
1:03:57requirements for the Apple ID password,
1:04:00and so that makes it easier to forget.
1:04:02and it makes it more likely that you won't be able to use
1:04:07your one password in your head that you use for everything.
1:04:10I know that's bad, but that's what everyone does.
1:04:12So they need ways for people to easily reset
1:04:16their Apple ID passwords, and man,
1:04:19this is just a hard problem.
1:04:21And I think, did your research indicate,
1:04:24I think I saw floating around earlier that like,
1:04:27even if you have your account in the full encryption
1:04:30end-to-end mode, whatever mode you can put your Apple ID in,
1:04:34there is no mode that disables that, right?
1:04:35- Nope, there is no mode that disables that.
1:04:39- And I think that would be like,
1:04:40the one thing I can think of is what Apple should do here
1:04:43is maybe if you have end-to-end encryption on,
1:04:46maybe that can be one of the things
1:04:48that's different about your account,
1:04:49that you cannot reset your Apple ID password
1:04:52with a phone passcode.
1:04:53- Maybe, and I can confirm that,
1:04:57And I can confirm that Apple from, you know,
1:05:02I reached out, I had some questions.
1:05:06In addition to questions about this story
1:05:10that Joanna reported, I was very confused over the weekend
1:05:16by the fact that I could not figure out how to
1:05:20even enter a recovery key or use a recovery contact.
1:05:26Like I have a, not fake, but a testing iCloud account
1:05:31that I've used for years to have like,
1:05:34if I'm reviewing two iPhones at once,
1:05:37or just wanna set one up with default settings
1:05:41for everything, so I have a sort of throwaway
1:05:44iCloud account, so I was trying to,
1:05:47I set myself, my real iCloud account
1:05:50as the recovery contact for that phone,
1:05:52pretended that phone was stolen,
1:05:54and I couldn't even enter those things.
1:05:56There was no, I couldn't, there's no path to get to
1:05:59where you just type the 28 characters
1:06:02or use the recovery context, say I vouch for this person
1:06:05and give it back to them.
1:06:06So I had questions about that.
1:06:08And talking to people at Apple,
1:06:10I can confirm that they are thinking of,
1:06:13and I've long been thinking about
1:06:16things they could do for this,
1:06:17but at the moment, this is the best balance
1:06:21between the needs of the vast number of people
1:06:26who forget their iCloud account password
1:06:30and the terribly unfortunate but lower number of people
1:06:35who fall victim to this path for crime.
1:06:39It's really, it's, and I think the fact
1:06:44that Google does it the same way with Android
1:06:47is, you know, two doesn't prove it,
1:06:51But both companies are known for,
1:06:55justly so, for very good security policies towards users.
1:06:59Google perhaps even more so.
1:07:03And they do it the same way.
1:07:06It's just sorta, and I think one of the reasons
1:07:10we don't know about it is that we just didn't think about it
1:07:15but the people at Apple who think about these security things
1:07:19known this. This is not a surprise to them. But I think that, you know, for obvious reasons,
1:07:26they don't like warn people about it because they'd rather, maybe they'd rather people
1:07:32don't, the general public doesn't know how dangerous this is, right? It's like finding
1:07:40out that we've been…
1:07:41Jared: They know now.
1:07:42Michael O'Toole Right. It's like finding out we've been
1:07:43walking around with a powerful M80 firecracker in our pocket all the time, unbeknownst to us,
1:07:50and it might go off. Again, protecting your passcode and not entering it in front of somebody
1:07:58is the best thing I can say. The downside to that or the hole in that is the other scenario,
1:08:09the mugging scenario where you are out in the street
1:08:13and somebody, a mugger comes up with a weapon
1:08:18and demands your phone and demands your passcode,
1:08:23right there on the street corner.
1:08:25Give me your phone, give me your passcode right now.
1:08:30It's catastrophic.
1:08:37That's always, like a week ago, I would have said,
1:08:40"Yeah, you're kinda screwed at that point.
1:08:42You're really screwed."
1:08:44Now I realize you're really, really screwed
1:08:49in that scenario.
1:08:50I don't know, what do you do?
1:08:53It's worrisome.
1:08:57It's had me obsessed for like 72 hours.
1:09:01The good news is, at least from the people Joanna
1:09:05Nicole talked to. I don't think any of them had their phones taken by force that way. They all
1:09:11had them, you know, in this or at least not their passcode. Sometimes, you know, they'd take the
1:09:18phone by force but not the passcode. And the other thing about this is all these victims were
1:09:23so confused because they didn't understand how this happened. They didn't know their passcode
1:09:29had been gleaned over their shoulder. All they know is their phone was missing. I don't know
1:09:32where my phone is, where is it?" And next thing they know, $10,000 have been taken out of their
1:09:41bank account. And they're like, "How did that happen? All I did was lose my phone,
1:09:45and all of a sudden I've lost stuff in my bank account." I wrote a story, and Joanna told me,
1:09:51it sort of inspired part of her obsession to dig into this. This was in August of 2020.
1:09:58So, actually, in the middle of COVID, there was a guy named Anriq Prong—I hope I'm pronouncing
1:10:04his name right, or probably not—but on Twitter. I swear to God, I will put a link to this thing
1:10:10in the show notes. The headline on Daring Fireball was "Can Thieves Crack 6-Digit iPhone Passcodes?"
1:10:17On Twitter, this guy wrote, "Stop using 6-digit iPhone passcodes. Do you think I am overly paranoid?
1:10:23Keep reading. Last week, a friend of mine had his iPhone stolen. What follows is the secret
1:10:27events that started as an unfortunate event and ended up with $30,000 in unauthorized wire
1:10:32transfers, $2,500 spent on the App Store, and accounts of multiple services compromised. So,
1:10:39how could the wrongdoers do all of that in less than five hours? After considering many options,
1:10:44the only reasonable explanation is they cracked the six-digit passcode on the stolen phone using
1:10:49some kind of device like GrayKey. The passcode gave them access to the keychain. They searched
1:10:55for iCloud credentials, disabled the lost mode, and turned off the fine line. That's this guy's
1:11:01story of his friend. And what I wrote was, "Did the thieves really crack his passcode with a gray
1:11:10key or a gray key-like device? Impossible to say. We know it exists. Blah, blah, blah." But I wrote
1:11:18all this, and it never occurred to me that I think it's exact. I think what happened to this guy's
1:11:24friend on Twitter is exactly what is I think somebody probably just saw him enter the passcode.
1:11:30That's it. It wasn't. Yeah, we all jumped to so I did we all jumped to some kind of mission
1:11:36impossible style thing where the thieves have this complicated device and those devices do exist
1:11:41right these these there's that a great keys I think the Israeli company there's a Florida
1:11:47company you know and they make these devices and supposedly only sell them to law enforcement
1:11:53And we all jump to this Mission Impossible scenario
1:11:55where the thieves have this complicated thing.
1:11:58And it's so much easier to think about the scenario
1:12:01where you just saw the shoulder swipe,
1:12:05shoulder glean the guy entering his passcode
1:12:08and then stole his phone and now you've got his passcode
1:12:10and now you've got all of this.
1:12:12- Yeah, 'cause again, that's the hole
1:12:16that most people I don't think knew about,
1:12:18that you could turn an iPhone passcode into an Apple ID.
1:12:21No one, I don't think any of us knew that.
1:12:23- Yeah.
1:12:25Yeah, I was onto it, honestly.
1:12:27This article makes me so mad.
1:12:28It's like here, I wrote, it never simply,
1:12:31this is my words from August 2020.
1:12:33It simply never occurred to me that if a thief
1:12:35or law enforcement or any adversary has the device passcode
1:12:40and your iCloud password is in your keychain,
1:12:43they can get your iCloud password from your keychain.
1:12:46That's what we were thinking.
1:12:48All you need is the device passcode to access
1:12:52all of the passwords in iCloud Keychain.
1:12:55Try it, you can.
1:12:57Now where I'm wrong there is you don't even have to go
1:12:59into passwords, there's that feature we talked about
1:13:02a couple minutes ago where you don't have to even
1:13:05get the old passcode.
1:13:06That's how ignorant I was though in August of 2020.
1:13:12I thought you had to get the old iCloud passcode
1:13:15to change it to a new one.
1:13:18You don't, you just go into the top part,
1:13:20the top thing in settings and the top thing in iCloud,
1:13:25passcode and security,
1:13:27and the top thing in that is change passcode.
1:13:30And you just change it to something new and that's it.
1:13:33Although I do know, this is a nice reminder,
1:13:36I am now reminded, here's what I wrote.
1:13:38So now I'm back on an alphanumeric passphrase,
1:13:41inconvenience while wearing a mask be damned.
1:13:43So that's what I did.
1:13:45I changed back to an inconvenient alphanumeric passcode
1:13:48in August of 2020 because of this story.
1:13:51But I was thinking about, again,
1:13:56Mission Impossible-style complicated villains
1:13:59and not common street criminals
1:14:02who just saw me enter the passcode.
1:14:04But that's how long I've been using
1:14:05an alphanumeric password.
1:14:08Really, really unbelievable story.
1:14:11I just can't stop thinking about it.
1:14:14- Yeah, that's why I said this is a bombshell.
1:14:18Like this, no one knew this, and this is very,
1:14:22you know, this changes things.
1:14:24- You know what it reminds me of,
1:14:25and I don't mind the catastrophe,
1:14:28and you know, you can go to your bank
1:14:29and get the charges returned and, you know,
1:14:32overturned and, you know, fraud detection
1:14:35and stuff like that.
1:14:37So I'm not drawing, I swear to God,
1:14:39I'm not drawing any kind of comparison
1:14:42to the repercussions.
1:14:44But it reminds me of 9/11 in the sense of
1:14:49that before 9/11, it just never occurred to anybody
1:14:54that our airline policies for decades,
1:14:59because like in the '60s and '70s,
1:15:01there was a rash, it was common for
1:15:04protest groups to hijack airplanes.
1:15:08There were airplane hijackings
1:15:12happened you know cup like every year in the 60s and 70s and they you know they'd
1:15:19you know some group would want some somebody who's in prison in some country
1:15:24released or something like that some kind of protest type thing and every
1:15:28time all of these times when airplanes were hijacked they just the policy was
1:15:33you just placate the hijackers land the plane keep everybody safe tell them you
1:15:40will listen to your demands and every time they'd get out of it without people being killed.
1:15:47I don't know if every time they didn't kill any passengers. But that was the policy. If somebody
1:15:54tries to hijack the airplane, you say, "Okay, okay, how about this? We'll land the plane,
1:15:58blah, blah, blah." You don't fight them. You don't do anything like that.
1:16:05So it just never even occurred to anybody that all these all you'd have to do is go on an airplane
1:16:11with box cutters
1:16:14and
1:16:16Demand that the that the flight crew comply with you
1:16:20And if they do that and they know how to steer an airplane
1:16:25That all of a sudden they could use a
1:16:30Boeing 747 full of cross-continental tank of jet fuel as a bomb. It just never occurred to anybody.
1:16:41Yet after they did it, it seemed like, "How did nobody ever think of this?"
1:16:48How did nobody ever think of that? And to me, this is sort of that sort of psychological…
1:16:57it's like the way optical illusions work. Like our brains just weren't hooked up
1:17:01to see what was right in front of us. This is right in front of us when you look at the way
1:17:05the settings app works on any iPhone or any Android phone.
1:17:10Jared "Seth" Johnson Yeah.
1:17:12Pete "Seth" Johnson I hope I know. You don't think I'm
1:17:14going to get in trouble for comparing it to 9/11, do you? Because it's not the 9/11.
1:17:18Jared "Seth" Johnson No, well, it's,
1:17:18right, but it's a, yeah, like, it's, it reveals a vulnerability that we didn't know about,
1:17:25really or that we didn't think about right it's just the most bizarre thing
1:17:30all right let me thank talk about our next our next sponsor it's our good
1:17:35friends at Squarespace ever heard of Squarespace Marco a couple times I think
1:17:39it is and it's an all-in-one website publishing service I mean everything
1:17:50Everything, including registering the domain name
1:17:55for the website.
1:17:56You could do that at Squarespace.
1:17:58Choosing a template for how the website works.
1:18:01They've got hundreds of them,
1:18:03and they're all professionally designed,
1:18:05they all work great,
1:18:06and they're all completely customizable.
1:18:10All the way down to the fact that if you wanted to,
1:18:13and you have the skills,
1:18:15you can just design your own website from scratch
1:18:18without using a template.
1:18:20You can do that.
1:18:22Analytics, built right in.
1:18:24Online commerce, selling stuff, selling items,
1:18:29you wanna build a store, you could do that in Squarespace.
1:18:32If there's something else you wanna sell, like your time,
1:18:35like if you are some sort of professional
1:18:38who sells sessions, training sessions,
1:18:43or something like that, and you wanna build a website
1:18:45where you can charge your customers for that sort of thing,
1:18:48You could do that right there in Squarespace.
1:18:52Custom templates, SEO tools,
1:18:55if you want to optimize your site for getting it noticed,
1:18:58getting stuff like that,
1:19:00hits getting recognition in a search engine,
1:19:04they help you with that.
1:19:05If you need help, it is all done right in a browser,
1:19:11it's all WYSIWYG, you drag it right there.
1:19:13But if you need help, they've got 24 hour a day tech support
1:19:17and it's right there for you if you need it.
1:19:20Anything you can think of to build a website, they have it.
1:19:25So where do you go to find out more?
1:19:27Go to squarespace.com/talkshow for a free trial.
1:19:32And when you're ready to launch,
1:19:35use the offer code talk show to save 10%
1:19:39off your first purchase of a website or a domain.
1:19:44That's squarespace.com/talkshow.
1:19:47And remember that code, talk show,
1:19:50save 10% off your website or domain.
1:19:54My thanks to Squarespace
1:19:55for continuing to support this show.
1:19:58I think they sponsor other podcasts,
1:20:00but I know they sponsor this one a lot
1:20:01and I appreciate it.
1:20:02The only funny thing about this whole,
1:20:06that whole iPhone, this whole iPhone,
1:20:09hey, if you've got the passcode and the phone,
1:20:11you're totally screwed.
1:20:13if a thief has that, you're totally screwed. It's that. It works exactly the same way on Android,
1:20:23but all of the victims had iPhones in Joanna's story. And when she talked to this detective in
1:20:29Minneapolis, I docked it up. It was 40 cases. Just one detective had dealt with one detective
1:20:37had dealt with 40 cases of the exact same thing. And he told her 99% of them are iPhones.
1:20:43And that he thinks it's because iPhones have resale value and nobody wants to steal Android
1:20:52phones or thinks that the people who have Android phones have anything worth stealing.
1:20:57Oh God. Wow. Yeah, that's, I mean, that is both funny and also, you know, probably not
1:21:08entirely untrue. It's not that, you know, obviously, yeah, we can poke fun as Apple
1:21:13fans and, you know, but there is, you know, the markets are not equivalent. We know that.
1:21:19We know in lots of ways they're not equivalent. It isn't just like, you know, a random selection
1:21:24of whatever the market share is, 60, 40, 70, whatever it is.
1:21:28It isn't a random selection of people
1:21:29that go to one side or the other.
1:21:31It's actually very different markets.
1:21:33This is why I have a podcast app that is iPhone only.
1:21:37And that doesn't really hurt me at all
1:21:39in any meaningful way because
1:21:42while there are more Android devices in the world
1:21:45than there are iPhones,
1:21:48the reality is that the podcast listening market
1:21:51is extremely iPhone dominant still.
1:21:54And so even though it is a bigger number
1:21:59over on the Android side, it's way fewer
1:22:02of my actual potential customers there.
1:22:05And the markets aren't the same.
1:22:07(laughing)
1:22:10- There was, I think 9to5Mac had the story
1:22:13that Apple should make an ad campaign out of it.
1:22:15I know you're not heavily into sports,
1:22:17but you might have seen the news
1:22:18that LeBron James broke the all-time scoring record
1:22:22in the NBA a week or two ago, which is a major record.
1:22:27In other words, to be the one basketball player,
1:22:29more than Kareem Abdul-Jabbar or Wilt Chamberlain
1:22:33or Michael Jordan, the most points any player's ever scored.
1:22:37And there's this picture, a really great picture
1:22:39of him taking the shot that wound up
1:22:44putting him over the record.
1:22:46and of course a full crowd in the LA arena.
1:22:51And you look, you can see the picture's big enough
1:22:55and crisp enough and you can see that almost,
1:22:58everybody's got their phone out there,
1:23:00everybody's trying to take a picture of it
1:23:01and they're all iPhones.
1:23:03Or if they're not, or they're,
1:23:07there aren't many of these.
1:23:10But I think there's more of them in China.
1:23:13but in theory they could be the rare Android phone
1:23:17that is designed to have an iPhone lookalike camera array,
1:23:21but as many ways that Android phones copy
1:23:26or follow Apple's lead in design,
1:23:29like oh, Apple's gone to flat sides,
1:23:31we're gonna start making our phones with flat sides.
1:23:33Oh, Apple's going back to rounded sides.
1:23:35Next year all the Android phones have rounded sides,
1:23:37but the camera arrays usually look very different.
1:23:42It's, you know, and again, it's just the sort of people
1:23:46who pay the tickets to that event were,
1:23:50I don't know what they cost.
1:23:52You know, they were hundreds and hundreds of dollars.
1:23:54It was super expensive.
1:23:55- More than the phone, probably.
1:23:56- Oh yeah, but the ticket, oh, the tickets down close enough
1:24:00to the floor that you would be in this photo
1:24:03were probably thousands of dollars.
1:24:05All of them were, you know, unless you had
1:24:08like season tickets, but LA Lakers tickets,
1:24:11Season tickets are very expensive anyway.
1:24:13So the sort of people who get really good seats
1:24:16to a Lakers game all have iPhones.
1:24:19It's really, you know, like you said, a different market,
1:24:24but kind of funny.
1:24:27All right, HomePod.
1:24:30HomePod 2, what should we call it?
1:24:32What do we wanna call the new HomePod?
1:24:33- Yeah, the new HomePod.
1:24:36- How many do you have?
1:24:39- Only two so far.
1:24:41- Okay, but you have to,
1:24:43you did side-by-side testing, same,
1:24:49you set up a thing, did you do it in the kitchen?
1:24:54- Yep, sure did.
1:24:54- 'Cause that's where you listen to music.
1:24:55- Yeah, I did, side-by-side.
1:24:57Yeah, it's like, as much as a fan as I am of the HomePods,
1:25:01you use different speakers for different purposes
1:25:04and in different environments, and for me,
1:25:06where the HomePod is by far the class leader,
1:25:11where it defeats all of the competition,
1:25:13is as a kitchen counter speaker.
1:25:16It is so much better than everything else in that market
1:25:20for a kitchen counter speaker.
1:25:22And it's also good in lots of other ways
1:25:24and lots of other uses, but that's where I use mine,
1:25:26and that's where I've had the least luck
1:25:30with anything else trying to replace it.
1:25:32And that's where the HomePod really kicks
1:25:34to everyone else's butts really pretty significantly.
1:25:37- So what do you think?
1:25:40- It's pretty good.
1:25:42(laughing)
1:25:44Yeah, so basically, I've used lots of things in this role,
1:25:49I've tried them out.
1:25:50I have, obviously I have the current HomePod,
1:25:53I had the previous HomePod, I've had the HomePod Mini,
1:25:57I've had stereo pairs of all of those,
1:26:00I've had the Sonos One,
1:26:02and a couple of ridiculously expensive things
1:26:05from B&O that I briefly tried and quickly returned.
1:26:08And I think I tried a couple of things.
1:26:11Oh, and the original Amazon Alexa, or Amazon Echo, rather.
1:26:17And then one of the, I think the current mid-range model,
1:26:21Amazon Echo, which is kind of the big ball-shaped one.
1:26:23So I've tried all of those.
1:26:25- You had the B&O one when we were there this summer.
1:26:28- I did, yeah. (laughs)
1:26:29- It wasn't bad.
1:26:31- It wasn't bad, but it sounded about as good
1:26:35as the HomePod Minis, and it was substantially
1:26:38more expensive than them, and so it wasn't really worth it.
1:26:40So, and B&O had like, they had like a larger one
1:26:43that actually sounded about as good as the HomePod,
1:26:45but it was way bigger and way more expensive,
1:26:48and so that also did not stick around.
1:26:51So, you know, in other areas of the house,
1:26:54I think you can find things that are a little bit
1:26:57competitive if you're willing to adjust things a little bit. If you want great sounding speakers
1:27:04for your TV, you have lots of options. They're mostly going to be way larger and they're
1:27:10going to require a receiver or some kind of amplification setup that's going to be larger
1:27:15or more complicated. If you want something on your desk, I actually don't use HomePods
1:27:20on my desk because there is no good way to have them be speakers for your Mac. There's
1:27:24There's a few bad ways, but there's no good way.
1:27:28And so on my desk, I have regular speakers
1:27:31with a little amp stuck to the bottom of the desk.
1:27:34And so there's places where HomePods are not as competitive.
1:27:38But when you want to beam sound in all directions
1:27:42from a kitchen counter where you're frequently
1:27:44going to be working to the side of it,
1:27:46not right in front of it, and you want to fill a space
1:27:51like that with good quality sound,
1:27:53nothing is like the HomePod, the full-size HomePod.
1:27:56The HomePod Mini actually does better
1:27:58than most of the competitors do at any price
1:28:00for that kind of use, but the full-size HomePod
1:28:03really takes it to another level compared to the Mini also.
1:28:06So it's a really great product line
1:28:08for a few areas of my life that I really want them.
1:28:11They're also really good as bathroom and bedroom speakers.
1:28:15If you want just something to play a podcast
1:28:17while you're in the shower, or you want to listen
1:28:20to some music in your bedroom quietly
1:28:21before you go to bed for some reason.
1:28:25They're great for that as well.
1:28:26And again, they're small and they're low needs.
1:28:29You don't need a big box.
1:28:31You only have the one power cable come out of it.
1:28:33You have nothing else to deal with, no other wires.
1:28:35And the HomePods themselves are small and tasteful looking.
1:28:39If you have anyone else in your house
1:28:41that has to approve of the look of things
1:28:45that are going into these areas of your house,
1:28:47the HomePods are pretty inoffensive looking.
1:28:50come in the two different colors. We are a white HomePod family. I think they look very nice,
1:28:55and it's just great for that. And there are alternatives from other brands. Most commonly,
1:29:03people tell me to try the Sonos series, and I have. And they are good at many things. They are
1:29:10not competitive on sound quality. And that's really important to me.
1:29:15Right your pal Casey is on Team Sonos now newly
1:29:19So I've been a huge fan of the home pods ever since they came out now. I don't have
1:29:25Good taste in audio like you do. I just know that I don't you know and
1:29:31In the way that I
1:29:35Think you would probably admit I have a finer-tuned taste for
1:29:41Autography than you do right? Oh, yeah, you might come to me and ask and you well that I actually you have come to me and asked
1:29:48Yeah, typographic taste questions. I
1:29:51Would come to you and I have for audio
1:29:56Taste questions. It's it's it's almost it's not even that I have bad hearing
1:30:01It's just that I don't my taste doesn't run that way and I've long been obsessed with the fact that people who?
1:30:08lack taste in an area
1:30:11sometimes fall into the trap of thinking who anybody who does have good taste in
1:30:17that area is actually just full of shit and pretentious even though sometimes
1:30:20that's true right like the people who buy thousand dollar gold cables to hook
1:30:26up their speakers and think that that makes them sound better than copper
1:30:30cables right the cables you know it's just running electricity it's you know
1:30:35that there's there's scams in audio right there's audio many right I mean we
1:30:41We could do a whole show about the scams in audio.
1:30:43But there actually is refinement in headphones
1:30:49and you've written super extensively about headphones.
1:30:54But I do know what sounds,
1:30:56I'm not completely without taste in audio quality.
1:31:01And I think HomePod sound great.
1:31:03One area, and I've been listening to you guys on ATP
1:31:06talk about them for weeks now.
1:31:08One area where I disagree, or at least I disagree personally, is I've been using HomePods for my
1:31:15living room home theater since early 2020. Yeah, a while.
1:31:20Yeah, we completed a home renovation by coincidence. Well, 98% completed a home renovation
1:31:28before the world shut down for COVID, or 99%. It was, you know, literally like,
1:31:35our contractors were in on the Friday that was the last day where it was legal
1:31:41to be out in the world cleaning up some stuff and doing some final work. Now, one little bit of that
1:31:49work is actually very specific to HomePod by pure coincidence. But on the last day, that Friday,
1:32:02in March 2020, one of the last things I had the contractors do was we've got the living room,
1:32:12the couch faces a wall, and that wall is very obvious. The whole design is that's where a TV
1:32:18would go. I guess you could hang a big, somebody who doesn't watch TV and bought our house could
1:32:24put some kind of very large painting there, but it's a wall with an inset, and in the inset goes
1:32:32the TV. And then underneath it is a built-in cabinet, like knee-high, where the components
1:32:40can go. And I knew that all of the components that we use now don't require line of sight for
1:32:47the remote controls. So none of them, they slide and they can be covered up and it's nice and neat
1:32:53looking and you don't see the TiVo, you don't see the Apple TV, you don't see the switch. It's all,
1:32:59you know, you just slide a thing open. But what I wanted was on top of that cabinet,
1:33:04I think they're called grommets or maybe the grommets are the things you put on,
1:33:08but you drill holes on the top so that I could put cables through.
1:33:13Yep.
1:33:15And I had them already on the built—I have a desk in my office that's built into the wall,
1:33:21and it has holes that are drilled in the top where I can snake cables through them because the
1:33:28cabinet is built into the wall. You can't go behind the wall. And the guy said, "Okay, I got
1:33:36and did them. Well, they are just not quite big enough to put the power cable of a HomePod through.
1:33:51Because I was thinking of things like HDMI cables and power cables and every cable I could think of,
1:34:02I thought, well, I thought he was like, how about the, you know, I was there with him.
1:34:06I right there over his shoulder. He was like, how about this big? And I thought, I thought
1:34:10of all the things I thought I'd ever want to go through that would easily be a big,
1:34:15large enough diameter. And I was like, sure, because I'm also thinking I don't want it too
1:34:21big. I don't want Amy to come in here and say, well, why the hell did you put a, you know, a
1:34:27a golf hole size, grapefruit size hole on this thing, right?
1:34:32And it was a hurry.
1:34:35Like I couldn't like double check with her.
1:34:38I couldn't wait.
1:34:39It was, you know, we weren't like in a mad dash,
1:34:42but it was like the guy was here.
1:34:44He wasn't gonna be able to come back for,
1:34:46well, at the time we thought weeks.
1:34:48Turned out it was forever.
1:34:52I was like, sure, that's big enough.
1:34:54And then when I didn't know at the time
1:34:57that I'd use HomePods for the audio,
1:35:00it was weeks, a week or several weeks later during COVID
1:35:03where I thought, let me try using a HomePod
1:35:05as the home theater.
1:35:07And lo and behold, the goddamn power cable
1:35:10wouldn't go through the hole.
1:35:12Just not quite enough, right?
1:35:14But like definitely not the sort of thing
1:35:19where there was like, oh, this is so close
1:35:21I could maybe shave off plastic on the power cable or you know, no it just wouldn't fit and
1:35:27One of the design aspects curious design aspects of the original home pods is that the power cables are built into the home pod
1:35:35Well, they're not really removable right not not not reasonably so at least I don't know
1:35:42I don't I forget if I pointed this out to you when you were at my house, but so one of the
1:35:46Things I've heard about from other people in the house
1:35:51is that our power cables for our home pods have to be pretty visible, even though the home pods are
1:36:00literally sitting inches away from those grommets or holes. They're inches away from them. Those
1:36:07holes are in the corners where the home pods sit, but the power cables have to go around them,
1:36:15you know, in four or five feet away to the nearest power outlets that are not inside this cabinet.
1:36:22So if…
1:36:23Oh my god.
1:36:23So my very favorite feature of HomePod 2, very favorite of all the differences,
1:36:30is the fact that the power cable is removable. It's just a standard little… that figure
1:36:36eight style power cable.
1:36:38Yeah, like a C8, I think, or C7.
1:36:41Right. So I can go the other way. I can now plug the power thing into the power outlet
1:36:49that's hidden inside the cabinet and then snake the cable out and then replug it into the HomePod.
1:36:55And if they had changed nothing else, it just brought back the one that they discontinued
1:37:03two years ago with no other changes but that, I would still buy two new ones
1:37:10because it would make some people in the house very happy.
1:37:15(laughing)
1:37:16- So that's amazing.
1:37:17- So that's one thing.
1:37:19- Like at no point did you figure like,
1:37:21why don't I like, you know, just widen the hole a little bit
1:37:24like I know aesthetically it's tricky,
1:37:26but like look, I'm not a handy person.
1:37:28- See, I'm not a handy person.
1:37:30It just doesn't--
1:37:31- But one of the few tools I know how to use is the drill.
1:37:35And I learned a few years ago
1:37:37about this thing called a hole saw,
1:37:39which is basically like a circle of teeth
1:37:41you attach to a drill to make holes
1:37:43that are bigger than drill bits.
1:37:44And I figured out how to do that,
1:37:46and so I went, the first thing I did
1:37:48when I learned how to do that
1:37:49was I went to our TV stand, which is made of wood,
1:37:51and it has this cabinet under it,
1:37:53and I went in the back, and I drilled some giant holes
1:37:56to snake a bunch of cables through.
1:37:58You know, it was glorious.
1:38:00- You know, if I had heard more about this exposed,
1:38:04these two exposed power cables,
1:38:06I probably would have looked into it,
1:38:08but eventually I stopped hearing about it.
1:38:10And so I didn't look into that.
1:38:12But who's the smart guy now?
1:38:14I don't need it 'cause I'm gonna buy two new HomePods.
1:38:17I have been a happy user of HomePod.
1:38:22Now, again, maybe it's because my taste in audio
1:38:25isn't good enough, but I previously,
1:38:28and our other home theater setup,
1:38:30which is upstairs in our guest room study area,
1:38:34which we had used for years, had a Sony audio system.
1:38:39It has a receiver.
1:38:41It's the traditional home theater type thing.
1:38:44It has a Sony receiver.
1:38:46It has two left and right front speakers,
1:38:51a separate subwoofer, a center speaker,
1:38:56and two rear speakers for surround sound,
1:39:02which I'd given up on at some point
1:39:04'cause I never, I actually thought it was less pleasant.
1:39:08It actually, to me, movies and TV shows sounded better
1:39:13with everything coming from the TV in the front
1:39:16and then from the rear.
1:39:17But it's, you know, I don't know what I,
1:39:19I didn't spend a fortune on it
1:39:20'cause I bought it a long time ago
1:39:22and didn't have a fortune to spend.
1:39:23But I mean, it's, I don't know,
1:39:24probably a thousand dollar system or, you know,
1:39:27maybe more, I don't know, all told.
1:39:29And it was good and I was happy with it
1:39:32for many, many, many years.
1:39:33all the years I used my pioneer,
1:39:36I can't believe I forgot Pioneer's name,
1:39:37my beloved Pioneer Plasma TV.
1:39:41You ever hear of any? - Those are so good.
1:39:44- Do we have any mutual friends
1:39:45who are fans of Plasma TVs?
1:39:47I'm drawing on the tip of my tongue.
1:39:49- We might have a few.
1:39:51So but like, what often gets lost in that
1:39:53is that I also had one just a long time ago
1:39:56and it was amazing.
1:39:58It wasn't amazing as John's, of course,
1:39:59but it was, oh man.
1:40:02Plasmas were great and for the time,
1:40:04just so much better than everything else.
1:40:08- They really, really were.
1:40:09So much better than generations of elves.
1:40:11I skipped, so I've never owned an LCD TV.
1:40:14I went from plasma to OLED.
1:40:17- Yeah, that's the wise move, LCD is awful.
1:40:20- Which again, I think is exactly what Syracuse did, right?
1:40:23Is he went directly from plasma to OLED.
1:40:26But I had-- - 'Cause he knew
1:40:27LCDs are awful.
1:40:28But I had this Sony home theater system,
1:40:32and I had been complaining,
1:40:34I've mentioned it on the show for years,
1:40:36that especially with like HBO shows,
1:40:38as like I could never understand
1:40:40what the hell people were saying.
1:40:41And I had a center, I had it,
1:40:43and people would say,
1:40:44"Oh, it's 'cause the dialogue's on the center channel."
1:40:47And it's like, "I got a center speaker.
1:40:50"I still get the,
1:40:50(mumbles)
1:40:52"you know, and I'm like, what the hell did they say?
1:40:55"I can't understand it."
1:40:56And then after COVID for a while,
1:40:59what we did is we were only using the speakers that were,
1:41:03'cause I wanted to get a good home theater system
1:41:06'cause this was all part of the plan.
1:41:08We spent a lot of money to redo the living room
1:41:10and get it exactly the way we wanted.
1:41:12And I got exactly the LZG OLED giant 77 inch
1:41:17or whatever the hell big it is, OLED,
1:41:21whatever the biggest OLED they make or made in 2020.
1:41:25it was the best TV I could buy. It was great for me as somebody who's paralyzed by choice,
1:41:32because all I knew was I wanted the biggest OLED I could get, and LG was the only company that made
1:41:40one like that. And I didn't want a Samsung. I knew I didn't want Samsung. So it was this model from
1:41:45LG, that was it. And I got it, and it's beautiful. But for months after we got back into our living
1:41:52room when COVID started, we just played all the audio through the TV speakers. And they're not
1:41:59bad. They really—and my wife and son agreed that the audio quality was really surprisingly good for
1:42:08just coming out of the TV. Although I guess when you spend a lot on a TV, maybe that's not
1:42:13surprising. But I was like, it wasn't good enough. And so I thought, well, let me try the HomePods
1:42:18before I go and buy something expensive and tried the HomePods. And I was like, "This is fantastic.
1:42:27I love it." And to me, this is the thing that I think—maybe I'm not 100% caught up on the very
1:42:33latest ATP. I forget if I finished it or not. But I don't think—no, you're in the after show talking
1:42:37about Rivians. So the thing that you guys were talking about and that Syracuse was talking about
1:42:47Is if you only have two home pods something something blah blah blah the center and the center is where you get the dialogue
1:42:52Mm-hmm. I'm telling you with two home pods and I have a big living room pretty big living room in an open floor plan
1:43:00The whole it's a big because our dining room is right behind us. So it's not a contained room. It's a it's a
1:43:07harsh audio scenario and
1:43:09Because the TV is so big and it is a fairly big room. I
1:43:15I think it's acoustically challenging. Two home pods left and right of the TV,
1:43:20it sounds like stuff comes from the center. And I think that the complexity of modern
1:43:28prestige TV and movies, audio mixes, and then just watching generic stuff on TV like sports
1:43:38or whatever, whatever the home pods are doing computationally in the same way that they compute
1:43:45the echo acoustics of the room. They fake the center better as good. There's no way that I
1:43:56could spend $5,000 on an audio system and I wouldn't, it certainly could be louder I'm sure,
1:44:03but I don't think it would sound better. And I'm sure I could get a lot more bass with an actual
1:44:08subwoofer, no doubt about it. There's no question about that. And I know that we used to have more
1:44:13bass with our previous system that had a dedicated subwoofer that wasn't even like super premium
1:44:19model. I know we're missing out on bass.
1:44:21Jared Ranerel And that's, and that's, by the way, that's
1:44:23not really a fair comparison. It's like, the HomePod is really small. Like people, I don't
1:44:28think people realize who don't have them, how small they are for the amount of audio
1:44:33and quality you get out of them. Like, they have a four inch woofer, you know, a subwoofer
1:44:38for a home theater, you're gonna you're looking at at least six inches and usually much larger
1:44:42of a driver. For what it is, it's incredible, and you can't get anything that has that kind
1:44:51of sound in anything that is that size or smaller. It's the same way in the 90s when
1:44:59everybody was blown away by Bose and how Bose managed to make these really tiny speakers
1:45:05that had really big sound, and part of that was good engineering, part of that was they
1:45:09introduced the external subwoofer to the world for the most part. And so they have these
1:45:14little tiny tweeters that would be your surround feeders and they have the giant subwoofer
1:45:17that you tuck in the corner somewhere. But you know, for home pods are incredible for
1:45:23their size. They're also really good in absolute terms. But of course, you know, when you have
1:45:28a bigger room or when you when you're comparing it's much larger speakers, yeah, you can get
1:45:32better than a home pod. But you cannot get anywhere near what the home pod offers. Anything
1:45:38close to its size. Right. And you remember, you might remember this, but while I was doing this,
1:45:45I was, of course, picking your brain over what I should be, might be, maybe should be looking
1:45:52at speaker-wise for this setup. And you had sent me multiple selection, multiple possible things,
1:45:59and I'd show them to Amy and got some pretty quick thumbs down.
1:46:06Yep.
1:46:08Visually now and I'm not making fun, you know, nobody's pickier about the way some things look than me
1:46:13I'm pickier than I'm pickier about things
1:46:16I'm picky about then Amy is about a way our living room looks so I'm not making fun of her. I love her for it
1:46:22I love that. She's that you know, I I appreciate it, but some of them were very tall
1:46:28and they all were
1:46:31Forward and would have to be on the floor in front of it and the way that our living room is set up
1:46:38up, it's not how it was designed.
1:46:41And so visually, two white home pods
1:46:46in the corner on this cabinet under the TV,
1:46:51it looks like the room was designed for that to be,
1:46:56in terms of the visual effect,
1:46:59it wasn't just, okay, that's fine, we'll go with that.
1:47:02She was like, that would be great, that looks awesome.
1:47:06But I'm 100% satisfied with the sound
1:47:10that I get out of them.
1:47:11And especially the simulated center channel
1:47:16that they produce for dialogue
1:47:19and the what the fuck did that person just say
1:47:23is it only happens to me now when I know that it's a show
1:47:28that is deliberately produced to have mumble mouth dialogue
1:47:34like Game of Thrones, right?
1:47:36like famously, for whatever reason,
1:47:38Game of Thrones makes everything way too dark.
1:47:42I like the show, I don't like the new one that much,
1:47:44but I like the other one.
1:47:46But it's a very dark show, your TV isn't busted,
1:47:50you don't have to turn the brightness up,
1:47:51it's supposed to be that dark,
1:47:53and they deliberately garbled the dialogue.
1:47:56I don't know why, I don't know why you would do that.
1:47:58It's like, to me, it's like there's certain,
1:48:01there's always certain cinematic trends
1:48:04that you can look at a movie,
1:48:05if you've even if you've never seen the movie before you can say oh that movie was made in the
1:48:10early 80s 100 you just know it you don't have to look at hairstyles you just there's just certain
1:48:16you know cinematic things and mumble mouth dialogue is going to come across as like oh
1:48:24that was like in the late 2010s guaranteed yeah so other than that though i love the center channel
1:48:31for it. I think it's a fantastic home theater thing. And I do love and appreciate, and this
1:48:39is like the sort of Casey List angle, I love the 100% simplicity of setup. One cable, it goes to
1:48:49power, and that's it. I've always been, it's always been in the back of my mind with my other stereo
1:48:56that I was never sure if I was hooking it up the right way, right? Because you can hook up like the
1:49:02red, yellow, and green cables, or you could go buy an optical cable, optical lens. Should I use
1:49:09optical? What am I doing? And it, okay, I've hooked this up, turned it on, and it sounds
1:49:15great to me, and it's loud, but should I use the other type of cable? And then you've got all these
1:49:23cables. There's all these cables running all over the place. And what do you do with them?
1:49:28I love the just, and it, to me, it is epitomizes the Apple mindset towards things where it's just,
1:49:39there's, there's just one way that's it. It's, and then you just hook it up to your Apple TV,
1:49:46you know, through the Apple TV interface. And for me, and it might, here I am knocking on wood,
1:49:53although I think this IKEA desk I sit at for the podcast isn't really wood, but you know, whatever
1:49:59IKEA made this out of. I've had no problems with any, with like the Apple TV maintaining
1:50:08connectivity to the HomePods. I think there was one time, so what was it, sometime in the spring
1:50:15a 20 20. So we're just call it three years. It's short of three years. But in three years,
1:50:22there was one time where one of the two home pods was sort of lost,
1:50:29sort of confused and off, you know, unpaired and somehow refused, started wandering away. Yeah.
1:50:39And the trick was to unplug both of them, because maybe the problem was with the other one,
1:50:46and you know, the one that didn't seem to be, you know, was still playing the TV audio. I don't know,
1:50:52unplugged them both, plugged them back in, and that's one time in three years where I had any sort of
1:50:57reliability of, you know, does this thing still work? Really fantastic for home theater. Now,
1:51:08We also have a pair in our kitchen that the kitchen one we put you that's where we play music and that's where I listen to
1:51:14podcasts
1:51:16And do those sort of things with home pods
1:51:18Those have been pretty reliable to more than most in my testing
1:51:24I've had a pair of the home pods to ever, you know since before they came out whatever they announced them and I've been testing them
1:51:30I haven't written a review because I've I
1:51:33Struggle because I feel like I don't have the audio
1:51:37taste to review that aspect of them properly
1:51:40These two have a hundred have been a hundred percent reliable for me once they were paired and I've had them paired non-stop ever since
1:51:48and I've been
1:51:51Doinking around with them testing things
1:51:53100% reliable and I will say this
1:51:58The Siri response time really is faster. Yes, definitely. I
1:52:05I guess that's going to the S7 chip or whatever the second generation chip is.
1:52:12Skipping a few years in chip to get a faster CPU and faster whatever else,
1:52:20whatever audio signal, whatever they're doing to make it faster. They absolutely did. It's not
1:52:27marketing trickery or that Apple set up optimized ones. It is noticeably faster. And I know that
1:52:34that it's faster because I'm testing these new ones
1:52:38in my office and I've got the old ones upstairs.
1:52:42And so I'm, you know, it's like having,
1:52:46spending half your time on a brand new iPhone
1:52:49and half your time on a five-year-old iPhone every day.
1:52:53Every day you're like, "God damn, this old iPhone is slow."
1:52:58So for me, for me, I wanted,
1:53:03I want you to talk more about audio quality,
1:53:05'cause I don't notice it.
1:53:06I can't tell any, to me it sounds just as good
1:53:10as the original HomePods.
1:53:11What I notice is it's faster.
1:53:14And so that's enough for me.
1:53:18But it sounds to me like, or from your review on ATP,
1:53:23that you think they sound better.
1:53:25- Yeah, and they do sound different.
1:53:29Overall, they sound, they're in the ballpark of each other.
1:53:34If you don't have them side by side,
1:53:38if you just upgrade from the first one to the second one
1:53:41and just start playing stuff,
1:53:42you might not notice the difference.
1:53:44It's that relatively small of one.
1:53:48What you will most likely notice
1:53:50is that the new one has less bass than the old one.
1:53:54And that, honestly, I wish they would have that be
1:53:58kind of EQ control because I would love to turn it up a little bit on the new one because
1:54:03the old one, the old one, they often got complaints that it was too bassy, especially if you live
1:54:08like in an apartment or if you're putting it in a smaller room where you'd really hear
1:54:12a lot of that bass resonance or your neighbors might hear it. So it was good that they had
1:54:17a setting called reduce bass that they added shortly afterwards, which basically is just
1:54:21like a hard low pass filter. So it just cuts out all of the bass. It's a pretty coarse
1:54:27I would love to have that be an actual, you know, a setting.
1:54:32Maybe a slider that has like three or four positions on it,
1:54:35you know, so that you can have a little bit less
1:54:38or a little bit more.
1:54:39I don't know, people have developed EQs and bass knobs
1:54:43for decades and, you know, I know Apple doesn't like
1:54:47adding unnecessary settings, but I think this is such
1:54:50a situational and taste variable here of how much bass
1:54:54you want your HomePod to have.
1:54:56I would love to see a setting for that.
1:54:58- Well, and--
1:54:58- The new ones are a little bit lighter.
1:55:01- They give you a little bit of that with AirPods, right?
1:55:03And AirPods have a little bit of EQ settings, right?
1:55:08- There's like a few things you can do,
1:55:10but they're pretty limited.
1:55:12- Right, but that's what I would imagine
1:55:14they might do with HomePod,
1:55:16would be a limited, very limited number of tweaks.
1:55:20And like, a little more bassy, a little less bassy,
1:55:25or just two settings, you know, like a little less
1:55:28or a little more, I could see them doing, you know.
1:55:32Just AirPods like, right?
1:55:34AirPods certainly aren't fiddly
1:55:37in terms of the amount of control you get
1:55:39over their sound quality.
1:55:40Just a little bit, I agree, would be nice.
1:55:46- Yeah, and they still won't add my,
1:55:48the one setting I want AirPods to have so badly
1:55:54is I want to be able to, for a particular pair of AirPods,
1:55:58to say never automatically jump to any other device.
1:56:02(laughing)
1:56:03- Oh, yes.
1:56:03- 'Cause right now, the way AirPods work is
1:56:08each pair of AirPods, by default,
1:56:10will intelligently connect to any of your devices
1:56:13that are nearby and the things you might be wanting to use.
1:56:15And it'll also offer, it'll put that little dialogue thing
1:56:18in the corner saying, hey, connect to, you know,
1:56:20Marcos AirPods number two or whatever.
1:56:21Like it'll offer that on Apple TVs, on Macs.
1:56:26And it currently, if you want to have your AirPods
1:56:30not auto switch, you have to go to every single device
1:56:35that they might pair to.
1:56:37Every phone, every iPad, every Mac, every Apple TV
1:56:41I think even, like you have to go to every single device
1:56:43they might pair to and go and connect to it first
1:56:47and then go to the AirPod settings
1:56:48and the Bluetooth settings and say,
1:56:50Don't automatically connect this device,
1:56:51like only when it's last paired or whatever.
1:56:54And you have to go through that for every single device.
1:56:56If you get a new pair of AirPods,
1:56:58or if you get a new Apple device
1:56:59that the AirPods might connect to,
1:57:01you have to do it again.
1:57:02Watch, you have to do it for everything.
1:57:05And also, that setting conveniently
1:57:08seems to get forgotten sometimes.
1:57:10That's the most infuriating part,
1:57:11is that you can go through the hassle
1:57:13of setting this all up to say,
1:57:15all right, I never want my AirPods
1:57:16to automatically guess what I want them to connect to.
1:57:18just connect to the last thing I had them connected to
1:57:20all the time.
1:57:21- Well, and the-- - You can do all that,
1:57:23and then two weeks later, it'll forget that setting.
1:57:25- Yeah. - And then you have to do
1:57:26it all again, or just eventually give up and say,
1:57:28fine, I'm just gonna have these be buggy.
1:57:30Like, I cannot tell you, as an AirPods user myself,
1:57:34how often it connects to the wrong thing,
1:57:36and then also, again, being an audio app developer,
1:57:39I get bug reports from people all the time,
1:57:41saying something to the effect of,
1:57:44Overcast just randomly stops playing sometimes.
1:57:48And I actually, and I went and I added logging to the app,
1:57:52and there's like, you know, when you send in a feedback
1:57:54email to me, you can attach the logs if you want to.
1:57:57And part of the logs, I log every play and pause event
1:58:02for the last, you know, couple hours or whatever.
1:58:05I log every play and pause event,
1:58:07and I started logging what caused them,
1:58:10why did this pause?
1:58:11And there's different things like,
1:58:12you tap the button in the UI, or a phone call came in,
1:58:16or different, you tap the control center button,
1:58:20and I can tell when it's most likely AirPods
1:58:23disconnecting and reconnecting to something else,
1:58:25because the most common case is someone has their AirPods in,
1:58:29they enter their house or a device becomes available
1:58:33within range, just barely or something,
1:58:35and then the AirPods get automatically taken off
1:58:38of their phone that was playing Overcast,
1:58:40and it goes in pairs to their computer or something.
1:58:44and I can see right on my log that it says their device name
1:58:47and it's like, you know, Joe's AirPods, no longer available.
1:58:51And I see that and people are emailing me constantly.
1:58:54- 'Cause they don't know how it happened.
1:58:55- Blaming me, blaming my app, saying that it's buggy,
1:58:57it just stops randomly, when really,
1:59:00it's AirPod auto switching doing something
1:59:02that they didn't expect or want.
1:59:04And I just, give me a setting so I can say,
1:59:08on a particular pair of AirPods,
1:59:10never auto connect to other devices.
1:59:13just stay connected to whatever I last connected you to.
1:59:16That's it.
1:59:17And I, God, that one setting would make AirPods
1:59:21so much better.
1:59:22In the same way, I want one setting on HomePods,
1:59:27in addition to the base boosting, that's one thing,
1:59:29but HomePods have this mode that,
1:59:32by far the most bugs that I've seen on HomePods
1:59:36relate to this behavior, that if you are playing
1:59:40from your iPhone and you wanna play something
1:59:43on your HomePod.
1:59:44There's two different modes this can be sent in.
1:59:47There's AirPlay and there's Handoff.
1:59:49Or I think, I don't know if they,
1:59:50they don't really describe it,
1:59:51so I'm gonna call it Handoff
1:59:53because it seems to work like Handoff.
1:59:56But so in AirPlay mode, your phone continuously streams
2:00:00the audio of whatever you're playing to the HomePod.
2:00:03Your phone remains the source, it remains in full control.
2:00:06And there's a buffer, you know, so you can like,
2:00:09you know, take the trash out, come back in
2:00:10probably won't skip because it's a buffer of about two minutes, but your phone is still
2:00:15in control. So if your phone has to reboot or something or whatever, the music will stop.
2:00:23Then there is handoff mode where if you have something from Apple Music in particular,
2:00:32not the service, the app, if you're using Apple's Music app and you tell it to play
2:00:37on a HomePod. Your phone does not keep that connection alive itself. Your phone tells
2:00:43the HomePod, "Hey, go play this thing from Apple Music or from my Apple Music collection,"
2:00:49or whatever it is. It works with iTunes Match and stuff too, but it's, you know.
2:00:52- But how-- - Go play this thing using Apple Music. And
2:00:53then the HomePod kind of like wakes up its own software stack to launch some version
2:00:59of a music app on the HomePod, and then your phone is out of the picture. So your phone
2:01:04is then your phone is, your HomePod says,
2:01:07"All right, I got this from here,"
2:01:09and it takes over and it plays.
2:01:10And then this does allow some convenient behavior.
2:01:13So for instance, when the HomePod has taken over
2:01:15the session like this for Apple Music playback,
2:01:19anyone on your WiFi network can go into Control Center
2:01:22and take over the HomePod and see all the things
2:01:25it's playing, what it's about to play.
2:01:26You can take over the whole session,
2:01:27the same way like when you connect to a HomePod
2:01:31from Control Center and it opens it up in your music app
2:01:34and then you're controlling it.
2:01:36Anyone in your house can do that.
2:01:37So it doesn't have to have been the phone that started it.
2:01:39Anyone can do it.
2:01:40And you can also do it if you have it play
2:01:43through a Siri command.
2:01:44If you tell it via Siri,
2:01:47hey, go play the Rolling Stones,
2:01:48and Apple Music is not down that hour,
2:01:51if it actually works,
2:01:53then anybody in your house can then connect to it
2:01:56from their phone, take over the session,
2:01:57and direct it or edit it or change what's up next
2:02:00or whatever else.
2:02:01The problem is, this behavior is really slow,
2:02:06and historically has been really buggy.
2:02:08Now it is less bad on the new HomePods,
2:02:11because they're faster, and they might have
2:02:13a newer software stack in some way,
2:02:15'cause it's kind of a different situation there,
2:02:17but for the most part, they're just faster,
2:02:19and that makes a lot of these problems less bad,
2:02:20but that is by far the biggest source of bugs
2:02:24that I've seen, where, you know,
2:02:26and not just with the new ones,
2:02:28I haven't had the new ones for long enough
2:02:30to really have a good idea yet of how big of a problem it is on them. On the
2:02:33old ones and also on the HomePod minis, which are much newer, this has been a
2:02:39big problem where so often a stereo pairing will fail that way or where one
2:02:44of them will drop out or it will you'll you'll try to send it over to the
2:02:49HomePods and it'll attempt the handoff and it will fail and then and
2:02:53and the HomePod will then not play the music or it'll play the music but then
2:02:58it'll like reset your phone's situation in the handoff and then like your phone
2:03:02will have the wrong track showing and will not be able to control the home pod
2:03:05like there are so many ways that fails so in addition to my air pods setting
2:03:10request of never auto connect to anything please for these air pods I
2:03:13would love a home pod feature a checkbox in the home pod preferences to disable
2:03:19handoff to make it never do that because there are ways around this so if the app
2:03:25that you're playing music from on your phone is not Apple's music app. It won't do this.
2:03:30So I'm constantly going between Apple's music app and Overcast. And so with Overcast, this
2:03:35problem never happens because it's never, the HomePod is never taking over the session.
2:03:41It's always streaming it from the phone. And so it's always rock-solve reliably. You'll
2:03:44also notice, like when you're in this mode, it's when you are on the phone and you say,
2:03:48go play this on, you know, Kitchen or whatever, whatever the HomePods are, it's way faster
2:03:52to connect and start playing.
2:03:54And then when you're done, it's way faster to disconnect.
2:03:57When you go back to the AirPlay Picker on your phone
2:03:59and say switch back to iPhone, way faster to disconnect.
2:04:03And way more reliable as well.
2:04:05- Yeah. - There's tons of benefits
2:04:06to this, and so, you know, I could just use Spotify
2:04:08or something, but I don't want to, it sucks.
2:04:10So I'd rather stay with Apple Music apps, which sucks less,
2:04:13still sucks if I'm honest, but it sucks a lot less,
2:04:17or at least in different ways.
2:04:19But, so, and there's also, if you make a shortcut,
2:04:22You can make a shortcut that says set playback destination.
2:04:27And then you can have it either pick from a menu or you can set a particular one.
2:04:30If you do that while playing from Apple Music, I actually have these shortcuts configured
2:04:34on my phone to do this, you can force Apple Music to stream the behavior, to do the stream
2:04:40behavior and not do handoff.
2:04:43And it is so much better.
2:04:45And the way you can tell whether you're in this mode is at the bottom of the music app
2:04:49where you have a little AirPlay picker,
2:04:51and it shows you the destination name right on top of it.
2:04:54So it'll say, you know, Marco's AirPods,
2:04:57or if you're playing to an AirPlay thing called Kitchen,
2:05:00it'll just say Kitchen.
2:05:02If the Apple Music app just says Kitchen,
2:05:04it's doing handoff mode.
2:05:06If you use a shortcut to say set playback destination
2:05:08to something else, that, instead of saying Kitchen,
2:05:11it will say iPhone, arrow to the right, Kitchen.
2:05:16And when you see that, that's when you know
2:05:18you're in the streaming mode, that it's not doing handoff, and try that and you will see
2:05:23it is so much faster to connect, to disconnect, to do anything. It's so much more reliable.
2:05:30And so all I want is a checkbox in the HomePod settings to always make this the behavior
2:05:34so that it will not try to handoff music app playback. It will just stream it from the
2:05:40phone because it is, again, it's just like AirPods auto-connecting where it's like, it's
2:05:46It's a smart feature that sounds like it's really magical and convenient, and maybe much
2:05:50of the time it is, but for so many people like me, the 30% of the time it's not what
2:05:57you want is too severe a penalty.
2:05:59I'd rather have it not try to be smart in those ways.
2:06:03And I know Apple won't stop trying, so at least give me a second to turn it off.
2:06:06Darrell Bock Yeah, I was going to ask, how do you do that
2:06:10from Apple Music?
2:06:11But it's just by doing the obvious thing and going down to what I think of as always
2:06:15being the AirPlay picker, but in other words, it's not always AirPlay, even though that's what I think
2:06:19of that picker as being. Yeah, it's called, I mean, it has its own name in the API and stuff,
2:06:27it's like the output route, basically. Right, right. Yeah, I guess that's what the icon
2:06:33represents. Big picture, it's very clear, I think the thing that makes the HomePod 2 so fascinating
2:06:43is it's it's not a rethink of the HomePod at all right like whatever went
2:06:51wrong with the first HomePod they the people who made HomePod 2 are clearly
2:06:59the same people I think I mean they seem to have the same taste in everything
2:07:03same taste in design this physical design it's the same basic concept right
2:07:09There's nothing other else
2:07:11Almost nothing different like if you didn't take it apart and look at the insides you'd think it's version
2:07:181.1. I think you even said on ATP. It's like 1.5, but it is a 2.0
2:07:24it's like an altogether different interior design and
2:07:27The the people who made it art remains
2:07:33Clearly remained as convinced as they were with the 1.0 that this is what the product should be
2:07:39That it should have one way of connecting which is over the air through airplay
2:07:44No line in and I know you know a lot the lack of a line in is is you know?
2:07:51You know maybe not even a complaint, but just like a jeez you know or just a
2:07:57Headphone jack input you know so that you could use a home pod to play the audio from any device
2:08:03You know from the last that's a line in oh, that's line
2:08:06- Yeah, whatever, I don't know what they, but just--
2:08:08- Well, I mean, technically it's slightly different,
2:08:10but yeah, it's basically, anyway.
2:08:11But no, I mean, the line in also,
2:08:13like that's not just a nice to have
2:08:15if you're Neil A. Patel and like headphone jacks,
2:08:17it's also, it gives you longevity to the product.
2:08:21- Right. - Like long after
2:08:23the electronics of this product are outdated
2:08:25and they no longer run the latest version of Audio OS
2:08:27or whatever they're calling it,
2:08:28or try not to call it in public, whatever they,
2:08:32long after the technology in it is obsolete,
2:08:35still a really good speaker and it could stand alone and just dumbly play a line source if
2:08:41it had an input and it doesn't.
2:08:44I see why they didn't do it though, you know, and it is it's it's it's not spite. It's like
2:08:50an aesthetic thing. It's the fact that like I said, like there's it gives you no other
2:08:56no options of how to use it. It's just you use it the way it's meant to be used. If there's
2:09:01a longevity angle, perhaps they're thinking… I mean, it also does lock you in, not even
2:09:07longevity-wise. It certainly 100% locks you into the Apple ecosystem. And there, you can certainly
2:09:15surmise maybe there's some amount of product marketing spite, for lack of a better word,
2:09:20that it's designed to only work with it, as opposed to… AirPods are a good example, which
2:09:27do work as generic Bluetooth headphones if you want them to. I really doubt that they sell
2:09:35very many of them at all that aren't used by people who don't own iPhones and other Apple
2:09:43products. But there's certainly a longevity angle there where you could, you know, a hand-me-down or
2:09:50used pair of AirPods or something, you know, can be given to somebody who doesn't even have
2:09:55an iPhone and they can use them. But that's Bluetooth and as much as everybody hates Bluetooth
2:10:01and probably the people who work on AirPods probably hate Bluetooth more than anybody,
2:10:05I'm guessing they hate it more than anybody in the world. It is wireless. So it fits in the Apple
2:10:11aesthetic where wires are bad and plugs for wires are bad and should be minimized.
2:10:20and being able to make a product that only has a power cable is, you know, aesthetically pleasing
2:10:27in a way. It's just that, but overall, it's just that they're very hard to tell apart side by side,
2:10:34you know, the graph or what are they not graphite slate, what do they call it? I forget,
2:10:38I keep forgetting what they call the black one because it looks black. It is now it's midnight,
2:10:43right? Midnight, midnight, midnight. That's the color, right? But of all of the, it's so weird
2:10:49that they keep calling everything "midnight" in 2022 because some of the midnight things look
2:10:54very blue. That's not black, right? Like the MacBook Air with the M2 is definitely not black.
2:11:02It is a bluish dark color. It is a decided blue. Some of the Apple Watch straps that are called
2:11:11Midnight are definitely blue, but others like the leather link bracelet that I convinced
2:11:19you to buy one of. I don't know which color you got. Which color leather link did you
2:11:22buy?
2:11:23I got ink, which is mostly, it's a pretty dark blue, but you would not confuse it for
2:11:30black.
2:11:31All right, but that's why, yeah, but it's very slightly blue. This HomePod, which ones
2:11:39did you get? You're a white family, you said, right? So, what Apple sent me was one midnight
2:11:47and one white, so I could see them both. The side by side with my old black one, you can see it
2:11:54in most light, but at nighttime, you can't even see the difference. You can get right up next to
2:12:00it and it is so close to black. I have no idea why they did this. But it's like the most appley
2:12:08of Apple Things. So, it's the same two colors effectively. The same basic concept with what's
2:12:17the thing on the top. Is it a screen? Nope. It's just a swirly, Siri-looking, diffused,
2:12:27whatever you want to call that thing. And they added hard-painted, hard-screen-printed
2:12:35plus/minus buttons for the volume, which is a nice change and a nice concession against the
2:12:41visual purity of it. You know, it's actually useful.
2:12:48Yeah. Yeah. Well, and we can argue, you know, and who knows? It's a mystery, you know, but
2:12:52it fits with the pre-Johnny Ive, post-Johnny Ive, you know, return of a couple more ports,
2:13:04put some SD card slots in the expensive MacBook Pros, sort of, you know, relax, putting an actual
2:13:12plus and minus. Who knows if Johnny Ive had anything to do with not putting plus and minus
2:13:16on there. But it's, you know, it's funny how all of these subtle little changes like the old HomePod
2:13:25didn't have plus and minus screen printed onto the hardware on top. And the new one does.
2:13:33And that one was in the Johnny Ive era. And this one is clearly post Johnny Ive. All of those
2:13:42changes have happened in one direction, right? There's not a single Apple product that has
2:13:49gone the other way and has less things printed on it and fewer ports. So I think it's probably true
2:14:00that some of those things, you know, Johnny Ive was obviously very influential there.
2:14:05You know, it's a little less Johnny Ivey, but I mean, it is like 99% physically identical.
2:14:11I think to me, the acoustics, I mean, would you at least agree they're very similar? I mean,
2:14:18I mean, you hear a difference, but it's,
2:14:20would you, put it this way, it's designed by people
2:14:24with the same acoustic taste.
2:14:27- Yes, and so, you know, the bass got weaker,
2:14:30and the other large difference in the sound quality,
2:14:34relatively, is that the mid-range and treble ranges
2:14:39are substantially smoother and nicer and clearer
2:14:44with less distortion and just kind of nicer responses.
2:14:47So vocals sound really nice, very smooth, very clear.
2:14:53It's a very good sounding speaker.
2:14:56You can spend a lot more and get speakers that don't sound nearly this good for vocals.
2:15:01Yeah.
2:15:02I think that the acoustic taste of the HomePod team is very similar in spirit to the photographic
2:15:12taste of Apple's camera team for the iPhone, where they value looking like reality, you know,
2:15:20and sort of good, high quality. Quality, of course, being the most important thing,
2:15:26but without exaggerating. And also, maybe even better than the camera team would be their
2:15:33screen team and the way that they calibrate the colors for their displays.
2:15:40You don't see it as much anymore because I think display technology has sort of coalesced around
2:15:45very high quality OLED displays that all phone makers can have. But like, you know, like 10 years
2:15:52ago, eight years ago, there were high end, you know, like Samsung phones, you know, their biggest
2:15:59competitor, high end, high quality Android phones where the colors were punchier on the displays.
2:16:07And Apple just doesn't like that.
2:16:09People who work at Apple value, you know, we're not trying to wow you with this, you
2:16:15know, the emphasizing the trouble in the base, right?
2:16:21What's that called?
2:16:22The U curve or the smile curve?
2:16:25Yeah, the smile.
2:16:26Yeah, yeah, yeah.
2:16:27The smile curve, where you pump up the extremes and it is exciting and it's the sort of thing
2:16:33like pumping up the extremes is what you might want to do in the entranceway of like a theme
2:16:40park ride where it's like you come in and it's like you just want like boom wow exciting and
2:16:46you've got like three minutes to wait before you get into the cart and go on the ride but it's to
2:16:53me not definitely not what you want for like two hours of a movie or you know a you know hours of
2:17:00of working while you listen to music.
2:17:02You know, you want it to mean, and again,
2:17:05that's not, it's not like boring,
2:17:07it's just also not exaggerated.
2:17:09And I think the acoustic, their acoustic take
2:17:11is like that too.
2:17:13I think it sounds good.
2:17:16I think the Siri response time is noticeably better,
2:17:20which was my biggest complaint about the old ones.
2:17:22And now it's my super biggest complaint,
2:17:24'cause I'm used to these.
2:17:28And I just, the only other thing I don't know.
2:17:31Like what the hell happened with the original HomePod, right?
2:17:35What explains this two year discontinuity in availability?
2:17:40It's not the most important mystery or curiosity
2:17:44about Apple as a company,
2:17:45but it's to me one of the most inexplicable.
2:17:49Like if I have any gifts as a pundit,
2:17:53it's that I'm often, I think, pretty good
2:17:56explaining things that Apple itself doesn't want to explain. You know, I think people read me and
2:18:04listen to the show because I'm pretty good at figuring that out. For the life of me,
2:18:11can't figure out what the hell happened to the original HomePod. My best guess, and I have no
2:18:19little birdies who've told me this. None. So this is totally my imagination. The only
2:18:26way I, the only thing I can think of is that there was some sort of disastrous hardware
2:18:34failure problem with the original design that they did not foresee and did not pick up in
2:18:42pre-production, something that perhaps only manifested itself in actual production, right,
2:18:49which can be, as anybody who knows what deals with the word production in whatever you do,
2:18:56whether it's hardware or software, going to productions sometimes reveals problems.
2:19:01Most famously I can think of would be the white iPhone 4. Was it the first white one?
2:19:11Well, but they had a white 3GS, right? But that was just plastic. It was the white.
2:19:17That was different. Yeah.
2:19:18The white iPhone 4 was announced and came out ten months late. I mean, bananas. That
2:19:30they announced it in June and it didn't come out until like April of the next year.
2:19:35Apparently because when they went into production, it was like yellowing or something like that.
2:19:41- Really, really weird.
2:19:42My favorite side note about that, I think it was,
2:19:46yeah, I think it was that,
2:19:47and the iPhone 4 was the Antennagate phone, right?
2:19:50- Yes. - Yeah.
2:19:52So my funny story about that is they announced this phone
2:19:55in June in white and black,
2:19:58and they take pre-orders, blah, blah, blah,
2:20:00and then they're like,
2:20:01well, the white one's gonna be delayed,
2:20:02and they don't wanna say how much,
2:20:03and the black one comes out,
2:20:04and then this Antennagate thing happens,
2:20:07I forget what date, when the Antennagate thing was.
2:20:11Maybe I can look it up.
2:20:13I'm gonna guess it was August.
2:20:15So, you know, like six weeks after the phone came out,
2:20:20but the white one is still not available.
2:20:22I go out to Apple for the Antennagate press conference,
2:20:25and it's on Apple's campus,
2:20:27and they're guiding us in the press.
2:20:30You're not like free, you're of course not free
2:20:32to just wander around,
2:20:33but the way Apple's Infinite Loop campus was set up,
2:20:36certainly get to do see Apple employees. And there were white iPhone fours everywhere,
2:20:40like employees had them. And it's like, Whoa, that is weird. And it but it had been announced
2:20:47it was supposed to be on sale. But they were there. But you know, obviously, something
2:20:52went wrong in production there. Something like this is my guess something like that
2:20:56was wrong with the original HomePod design. And they didn't foresee it. There are reports,
2:21:03know, and you had some that got flaky and never got unflaky. But there are other people
2:21:09I've seen who've had reports of ones that just stopped playing audio and stuff, right?
2:21:13I think they they added,
2:21:14Jared Ranere: they were actually they were pretty widespread reports of certain electrical
2:21:19components, like slowly frying themselves inside. Right there. There was something there
2:21:23that was wrong. I don't think that's what happened to me because I didn't have the same
2:21:28symptoms as those. So I don't think that was a problem with my other with my my main pair
2:21:32of HomePod ones, but certainly I had other problems.
2:21:37- Just, yeah. - Slowly flaking out.
2:21:39But it was hard for me to tell with mine
2:21:41whether they were flaking out
2:21:44in some kind of hardware flaw way
2:21:46or whether they were just slow and buggy,
2:21:49which they always were.
2:21:51So it's a little hard,
2:21:52and the new HomePods are fast and buggy.
2:21:55So it's hard to tell, like, what's the real fault here?
2:22:00- Yeah.
2:22:02something like that and that it wasn't fixable with like a tweak and that they
2:22:07engineering wise weren't prepared at all to do it to have a 2.0 ready to go and you know studied
2:22:15it and when they ran you know everybody one of the famous things about the home pod was that
2:22:19people could tell from the production numbers that they were all from like the original batch
2:22:23you know that they never really made more they sold the ones they had and stopped making them
2:22:28and that the team was already newfound,
2:22:33once they found the problem, was heads down,
2:22:37working as fast as they could to make one
2:22:41that didn't have a new design, that didn't have a problem.
2:22:45And this is how long that takes.
2:22:48That something like two years is how long it takes
2:22:53to go from, okay, let's start all over
2:22:55and make an all new design that doesn't have this problem.
2:22:57But that is still the design.
2:23:02This is still the product we want to make.
2:23:04We want this product.
2:23:06We think this is the way HomePod should be,
2:23:08that it takes two years.
2:23:10And they didn't want to keep making the old one
2:23:13with the problem.
2:23:14Maybe they were losing money on them with the failure rate.
2:23:17I don't know.
2:23:18- Yeah, 'cause they were,
2:23:20many of them were still under warranty
2:23:22and were getting replaced by having whatever
2:23:24the blown capacitor or whatever the problem was.
2:23:26they were doing a lot of replacements.
2:23:28- Yeah.
2:23:29- I mean, but I think it's important too,
2:23:32like you said, they didn't change the product much.
2:23:37It's still a 300-ish dollar,
2:23:40you know, technically they lowered the price
2:23:43from 350 to 300, but for most of the lifetime
2:23:46of the first one, you could always get it for 300
2:23:48from Best Buy or whatever.
2:23:50They were clearly doing a kind of out the back discount
2:23:54certain preferred partners because that was like the price it was actually selling better.
2:23:59So that was effectively the price it was for most of its life. And that's not a huge price
2:24:04difference anyway. 350 versus 300, it's still a premium priced speaker. It's still way more
2:24:08than an Amazon Echo and the Google whatevers. And so obviously they decided price wasn't
2:24:15a problem. And also again, the existence of the HomePod Mini also changes things in the
2:24:19sense that when it's not the only product in the HomePod lineup and there is one that
2:24:24that is way less expensive, you know,
2:24:26the HomePod Mini's 100 bucks, which I think is,
2:24:29by the way, I think that's one of the best values
2:24:31in Apple's entire lineup, but, you know,
2:24:33when you have one that's 100 bucks,
2:24:35it takes a lot of the pricing pressure off the $300 one.
2:24:38But regardless, they clearly said,
2:24:40okay, you know what, price obviously wasn't the problem.
2:24:44So they didn't cancel the old one for price.
2:24:47They didn't cancel it because it didn't have a line in,
2:24:51'cause the new one doesn't have a line in either.
2:24:53- Right.
2:24:53know it did apparently lacking Bluetooth also didn't hurt it nope or lacking
2:24:58lacking lacking a real screen on top that you know shows like a user
2:25:02interface that wasn't it it's it's the same friggin product I mean yeah normal
2:25:07did the same thing with minor modifications yeah I mean a normal
2:25:11person most people if you put them side by side with the two of them you know
2:25:15and we're not quite side by side but one on one side of the room on one on the
2:25:19other side of the room would have a really hard time it'd be like one of
2:25:22those puzzles, what's the difference between these two drawings? They would think they sound the same,
2:25:27they work the same, they have all the same features. It's the same thing, but there was a
2:25:31nearly two-year discontinuity in availability. And Apple being Apple left those of us who
2:25:39loved the original HomePod worried nonstop until they announced the damn thing that we'd never have
2:25:47one again. I mean, I was about to say her name, but I'll just say somebody in the house has
2:25:53given me a hard time about the fact that I've squirreled away two more just in case,
2:26:03because I was really worried that one of mine would blow and I wanted to replace it,
2:26:09and I didn't think they'd ever make it again. Here's an update. I got an update from the
2:26:13control booth. They say the Antennagate press conference was July 16. So it was only a few
2:26:20weeks after the iPhone 4 had shipped. But…
2:26:23Right, because the phone came out probably in June, right?
2:26:25Right, right. But still, I also thought… In hindsight, that makes sense because I remember
2:26:29thinking as I saw Apple employees with white iPhone 4s walking around, I remember thinking
2:26:35that it was a clue that, you know, whatever was wrong, it would soon be unronged and they'd
2:26:42out soon. Wrong. Yeah. You were only off by like seven months. Yeah. But anyway, the only
2:26:49other thing about the HomePod set, I emphasize when I write about them is, and I don't know
2:26:55how I, you know, I'm not Jaws, I'm not Phil, you know, and I wouldn't be good in their
2:27:02jobs. I'm not a marketing person. But so maybe I'm wrong about it. But I it frustrates me
2:27:09because I think the true HomePod experience is the $600 pair of two and it's great that
2:27:16you can spend $300 and just get one.
2:27:20And if you're in a dorm room, that might be all you need.
2:27:24And if you're on the college budget, that might be much more amenable to your budget.
2:27:30It's great that one of them sounds as good as it does and fills a room as well as it
2:27:36does.
2:27:38But two of them are so much better than two times better than one.
2:27:45So much better.
2:27:46I mean, I don't know.
2:27:48They're like, two HomePods are like, to me, five times better than one HomePod in terms
2:27:53of the audio quality.
2:27:55Because it takes two of them to do the computational magic of making it sound like some sound is
2:28:02coming from places where there isn't a HomePod.
2:28:06When you only play one, the direction, there's no way to fake it.
2:28:11You can close your eyes and you can tell exactly where that one HomePod is in a room.
2:28:16When you've got two paired and you close your eyes and you're listening to a modern song
2:28:22with spatial audio or modern mixed movies and prestige TV shows, you really cannot believe
2:28:29that the sound is only coming from those two sources.
2:28:33And it's so much better than two times better.
2:28:37And I just don't think Apple markets it that way at all.
2:28:42And therefore, I think people miss out on it.
2:28:45And I really think that people think that buying two is spending $600 on a smart assistant,
2:28:54which seems ridiculous.
2:28:56Whereas what I think – and again, I'm not an audiophile, but just as someone who
2:29:01who just wants the shows and movies I watch to sound good
2:29:04and to have the music in my kitchen sound good.
2:29:07$600 as home theater equipment is a bargain,
2:29:14a bargain compared to what you would get
2:29:17from Bose or Bang & Olufsen or Sony even.
2:29:22And you have no wires cluttering and stuff like that.
2:29:25It's a bargain.
2:29:27And I think the lack of marketing and Apple's reputation
2:29:32for selling stuff that's more expensive
2:29:35than the comparable product categories
2:29:38from any other company,
2:29:39it's just a complete blind spot
2:29:42to anybody who might otherwise,
2:29:45or I would just say should,
2:29:47just spend $600 on two HomePods
2:29:49and save hundreds and hundreds of dollars
2:29:53versus the equivalent audio experience
2:29:56other equipment. Yeah, it really is extremely competitive in that space with me when you have
2:30:05two of them. And yeah, you're right comparing to any kind of home theater setup like, yeah,
2:30:10you know, a full blown home theater setup can fill larger rooms better. You can get, you know,
2:30:14true surround and everything. That's all true. But yeah, you're going to be way past 600 bucks to,
2:30:19you know, for something that sounds anywhere near this good. But yeah, like I think, you know,
2:30:25You know, the huge advantage it has when you have a stereo pair is it just fills the space
2:30:31better.
2:30:32You know, it's very, very hard with just physics to have one speaker in the middle of a space
2:30:38fill that space with sound.
2:30:39It's always going to sound like it's coming from that one point.
2:30:42You know, they can play tricks with, "Oh, we're going to bounce some of it off this
2:30:45wall," or whatever, and that works a little bit, but it doesn't make a huge difference.
2:30:50A stereo pair always sounds better in every case.
2:30:54it always sounds better, and to the point where like,
2:30:56I wish they would sell like a bundle of two
2:31:01for some small discount. - Yes, yes.
2:31:03- Even if it's only like 50 bucks.
2:31:05Whatever the discount would be,
2:31:07some small discount to sell a bundle of two
2:31:09just to give people the idea,
2:31:11maybe I should consider buying two of these.
2:31:13- Yep, yep, that's exact,
2:31:15I think that would make such a big difference.
2:31:17Even if they didn't discount it,
2:31:18even if it was still 600 bucks,
2:31:20but it was called HomePods, but two at once.
2:31:24I think in hindsight too, maybe something,
2:31:27something to do with the way that this has worked out
2:31:29in the market is maybe if they could do it all over again,
2:31:33they should have shipped the HomePod minis first
2:31:36and called them HomePods and said,
2:31:39this is a HomePod and you can talk to it
2:31:42and it sounds great and look how tiny and acute
2:31:44and adorable it is, and then come out with the HomePod
2:31:48plus the HomePod.
2:31:50Ultra Max, you know, I don't know which which of their max ultra yeah home pad pro max ultra
2:31:57And you know and and get you in the door with the
2:32:03You know, I don't want to spend more than 100 bucks on you know
2:32:08One of these things and okay. I'll buy this one and then oh man, I really like this but boy
2:32:15I wish it sounded bigger and richer, you know, maybe
2:32:18Maybe they've you know
2:32:19They've mixed up
2:32:21Calling this one the normal one and the other one the mini and should have called the other one the normal one and this one
2:32:27The max or whatever they would call it. I don't know I again
2:32:31Apple's naming is a black magic and it they've certainly been successful with it as as
2:32:38Confusing as it is to us who love to analyze it and nitpick it. It's obviously been successful
2:32:43So maybe not, but I can't help but think that that would help emphasize how good the product is,
2:32:49right? Because that's the other thing. If they called it the HomePod Ultra,
2:32:53it would emphasize this thing sounds surprisingly good. Anyway, let me take a break here. Thank our
2:33:01third, our final sponsor of the show, our good friends at Memberful. Look, Memberful
2:33:06has a world-class support team that is ready to help you, a creator, simplify your memberships
2:33:12and grow your revenue. They are passionate about your success. And you will always have access to
2:33:18a real human. What did you do? You're a creator, you run something where you want to start some
2:33:24kind of membership system, you monetize your passion with membership. With memberful,
2:33:30you maintain full control and ownership of your audience and your brand. It doesn't your your
2:33:37members don't go through a thing that makes it sound like they're signing up for Memberful
2:33:42and then as a subcategory picking you. No, it's not that sort of thing at all like sub stack,
2:33:50right? Where you're like a sub stack and you're in sub stack and then which one are you in?
2:33:55With Memberful, your brand is the primary thing that people see. Memberful just sits there
2:34:01quietly and humbly behind the scenes. And it just that it gives you control over the brand and
2:34:08control over your membership. If you ever decide to leave, you just take your whole member list
2:34:13with you. It's all there for you. And they do it. They have it set up that way because they're
2:34:18confident that you're not going to want to leave. They've got analytics that give you an easy to use
2:34:24in depth view of what's working, what's not and where you might want to double down. And that
2:34:28Support team is there to help steer you towards the things that will work like for your category of creation
2:34:37They know which type of offerings to members get people to sign up
2:34:44They only make money when you make money and says all and people only sign up the customers the members
2:34:51When they're happy to do it happy to support you as a creator
2:34:56It's it's a great great thing this move towards membership systems for creators because it's just win-win-win
2:35:03for everybody happy customers happy
2:35:07Listeners happy readers happy whatever it is that it is viewers if you're a youtuber or something like that
2:35:13They're happy to sign up to support you
2:35:17you're happy to have the income from membership and memberful is happy because
2:35:23They just make a little bit of money through the system and keep growing with more and more creators going this way
2:35:30It's it's just a great system. I'm a member of more member full
2:35:35Creators than I would like to count
2:35:40It's just a great system, and it just they can't say enough about it. I you know just off the top of my head
2:35:48six colors
2:35:52Mac stories you name it it almost everything that I am a member of goes through memberful
2:35:59Look you can get started for free with no credit card required go to memberful.com
2:36:07Slash talk show that's memberful.com
2:36:11Slash talk show monetize your passion with membership start your free trial today
2:36:16Last thing I know we've already talked a long time probably not a record for you and me but
2:36:21No.
2:36:22Just to wrap it up.
2:36:25Just to wrap it up.
2:36:26Out of the Blue, your last episode of ATP.
2:36:28Let's do an ATP follow-up here.
2:36:31You drove a friend's Rivian.
2:36:34Yep.
2:36:35And I drove a Rivian, and I never wrote about it.
2:36:40I have somebody who, Andy, a guy named Andy Bowman, who used to work at Apple PR, left
2:36:46Apple for Rivian because this is a really interesting idea to have an electric vehicle
2:36:55company making a really groundbreaking electric vehicles and to have a professional press
2:37:06team for PR so that they could deal with the media. I mean, it's a revolutionary idea.
2:37:16I think perhaps other electric car companies should consider having PR professionals handle
2:37:28press.
2:37:29Tim Cynova Yeah, you know, you can maybe say that. There
2:37:33might be some benefits there.
2:37:35Jay Haynes Yeah, I mean, I could think of numerous ways
2:37:37that it might help and that maybe, you know, hiring professionals. But through because
2:37:42I'm not known, obviously, I am not known for my reviews of cars or electric vehicles. But I got
2:37:49through, there was a, they had a media thing in New York, I think it was last summer. There's a
2:37:55Brooklyn, you probably didn't even know where it is if you're even considering it, but there's a
2:37:59Rivian dealership in Brooklyn. And you know, they have like a big garage where they can do service
2:38:05and stuff like that. And I got to take an extensive test drive. I forget how long it was. But it
2:38:11started in Brooklyn, went through Manhattan, and we got out on the highway.
2:38:15And I was—I didn't write about it because, again, I often have these things I want to write about and
2:38:25get stuck trying to do it, and they're stuck in my head. But I was floored by how great the
2:38:32experience was driving a Rivian. I've driven briefly, more briefly, electric vehicles before,
2:38:39and I get how different the acceleration curve is on an electric motor, how much better in every way
2:38:48it is than with a gas engine. But what wowed me the most was the, what's it called, regenerative
2:38:57braking? Yeah, it's very strong in the Rivian. Right, so for people who haven't done this,
2:39:03I mean, I probably have a lot of listeners who have electric cars, but I knew about it.
2:39:08But basically when you take your foot off the gas, it doesn't coast like a gas car.
2:39:15It starts breaking and that breaking is taking the momentum of the car to recharge the battery.
2:39:23I mean, basically it's sort of similar.
2:39:26Yeah, like instead of actually applying the brakes, because you know, I mean, you know,
2:39:30when you hit the brake pedal, it applies to brakes, of course. But when you just let off the gas,
2:39:34the car will engage effectively a generator. And it'll take some of the energy from the wheels
2:39:40to turn a generator, which causes resistance and slows the car down. And you're converting
2:39:47the momentum the car had, you're converting some of that back into generated electricity
2:39:51for the battery. So, what they told me was we took off and they explained this to me.
2:39:58And they showed me all sorts of other things about the truck, I guess. I keep wanting to call it a
2:40:05car. I drove the one, I guess it was the pickup truck one. What's that one called? The R1T.
2:40:10But it's basically the same vehicle as the SUV. It's just what shape the rear has. It's the same
2:40:19cockpit, same cabin, same interface, same engine. But they explained this to me and said,
2:40:27once you get used to it, you won't need to use the brake for most part, even as you drive like
2:40:33through Brooklyn, which it you know, or Manhattan, right where the sort of city driving, where
2:40:40even if you're not gas pedal happy, it's you know, lots of gas, lots of braking, lots of gas,
2:40:47lots of braking, gas, brake, gas, brake, and I've been driving for a long time. And I do like to
2:40:52drive a little fast, although I don't drive fast in the city. And they said, "It'll take a little
2:40:57bit of time to get used to, but you'll get used to it. And when you do, you won't need the break,
2:41:01even as you drive through the city." And I just, you know, I was like, "Okay, I'll, you know,
2:41:06I hear the words you're saying, but once I started driving, I couldn't help but put my foot on a
2:41:11break." But you know, then I got, I was like, "Okay, okay." And then it's like, this is amazing
2:41:19that it is so pleasant to drive through stop-and-go city traffic like this. It is amazing.
2:41:28And it's—of all the things I thought I might prefer about an electric car compared to my gas
2:41:36car experience, I didn't—that wasn't even on my list. And it's—after one, like, two-hour
2:41:43experience driving a Rivian, it was by far and away my favorite thing about it.
2:41:48by far. It's amazing. And if every car had always worked like that, and somebody invented a car,
2:41:56all the other ways that you wouldn't invent a gas-powered car, you know, after everybody was
2:42:00used to electric. But the way that gas-powered cars don't do that, and you take your foot off
2:42:06the gas, and they just keep going, no one would ever do that. It would be, it is the,
2:42:14It's one of those things you have to experience to drive it and it didn't again
2:42:18I only had like a 90 minute or two hour two hour tops test drive, but I got so used to it and
2:42:25Then you know we shook hands
2:42:27And I thank them for their time and they answer all my questions
2:42:29And then I got back on a train and came home and I'm on the train coming home to Philly
2:42:34And I'm thinking oh my god am I gonna kill somebody as I get back in my Acura
2:42:38Because I'm just gonna pick my I already used to this
2:42:42I'm just gonna take my foot off the gas and just smash into the back of the car in front of me
2:42:47Because I thought I might already be broken. I wasn't but
2:42:50It's a very different way of driving
2:42:53It really is like like, you know, I drove a Tesla Model S for
2:42:58geez, six seven years something like that and
2:43:02One of the characteristics of that is like it has pretty strong region not as strong as the Rivian pretty pretty strong regen breaking
2:43:09when you let off the accelerator,
2:43:10except if the battery is like 100% charged,
2:43:15or 99% charged, or if I think it's extremely cold,
2:43:19like if you go in the middle of the winter,
2:43:21during certain conditions,
2:43:23the regenerative braking doesn't function.
2:43:26And so I would occasionally have times
2:43:29where I would drive my car
2:43:30and it wouldn't do the regen braking,
2:43:32and you let off the gas and you're like,
2:43:34"Oh my God, why am I still going?"
2:43:36And all it's doing is acting like a gas car at that point,
2:43:38drove for over a decade before that and it was fine because that's what I was used to,
2:43:43but once you are used to that feeling, it's really disorienting. I have since had to go
2:43:48back to a gas car because my Rivian reservation is not in yet and I had to go somewhere off
2:43:53road. So I had to buy a Land Rover Defender for beach access here and it's a regular gas
2:44:01car and going back to gas, that was the most jarring thing about it, besides the fact that
2:44:07you step on the gas and nothing happens for a few seconds, and the gear changes, and having
2:44:12to actually get gas, which is horrific and terrible when you haven't done it for seven years.
2:44:17You're like, "Oh, wow, gas stations are stinky and inconvenient and not to mention terrible for the
2:44:23environment." And the cleanest-
2:44:25The cleanest-
2:44:25"Sylvian, please hurry up on my reservation. I've been waiting a long time."
2:44:29The cleanest-
2:44:30But yeah.
2:44:31The cleanest gas station you go to is filthy.
2:44:34I mean, it's just-
2:44:35Yeah, exactly.
2:44:35because it's just full of cars which are filthy and gasoline which is a filthy liquid and you know
2:44:43like i i love like there have been a couple of really good essays written over the last few years
2:44:48um written from the point of view of someone who is accustomed to electric cars describing the
2:44:54weirdness of gas cars because you know and they're like they're like satires of like you know people
2:44:58write these articles about like well you know with electric cars you have to worry about your range
2:45:02and you can't just get gas anywhere.
2:45:04And so there's a few great essays,
2:45:06I'll try to find some, it's in the links.
2:45:08There was a good one recently that went around Mastodon,
2:45:11where people talking about how weird gas cars are
2:45:16once you're accustomed to electric.
2:45:17And there's multiple things about that,
2:45:18one of which is like, yeah, when you're slowing down to stop,
2:45:21the gas car just wastes all the momentum you have.
2:45:24Like you just don't get to recapture it,
2:45:26you can't convert it back to gas.
2:45:28Also, one of the greatest convenience additions when you get an electric car is something
2:45:36you don't think about.
2:45:37Before you get your first electric car, all you're thinking about is range.
2:45:39And you're thinking about those long highway trips when you're going to have to stop at
2:45:42a charger somewhere and you're worried about that.
2:45:44And that's understandable to be worried about because it's unfamiliar to you.
2:45:47I was too.
2:45:48Before I got the first Tesla, I was very worried about that.
2:45:52And then when I got the Tesla, I realized that's pretty well handled by fast charging
2:45:56stations, long highways and stuff.
2:45:58that's actually not a big concern.
2:46:00And the other side of that is because most of the time
2:46:03you're plugging in at your house,
2:46:06you are leaving the house every day with a full tank.
2:46:09- All the time, right.
2:46:11- Yeah, so all the, the rest of the year
2:46:13when you're not taking long highway trips to go somewhere,
2:46:16you never have to stop anywhere.
2:46:18So you never, like, you know, now that I'm back on gas
2:46:21for hopefully a short time, please get my reservation
2:46:23in soon, River Yoon, please.
2:46:25Now that I'm back on gas for whatever time
2:46:27going to end up being, I have to keep going to get gas.
2:46:30And so every so often, I'll have to take 10 minutes
2:46:34out of my trip or whatever and go stop somewhere
2:46:37and go to these special stinky places and get gas.
2:46:39Whereas when you drive electric,
2:46:42you are almost never having to stop
2:46:45because you're charging at home.
2:46:46So every day you're leaving with a full tank.
2:46:48Maybe you can even plug in at work or wherever you're going.
2:46:50So you're always charged.
2:46:53So you only have to think about range
2:46:56when you're going on those occasional very long,
2:46:58you know, multi-hour driving trips.
2:46:59The whole rest of your life, you're just always full.
2:47:03It's incredible.
2:47:03And so, to go back to gas and be like,
2:47:05you can only get gas at these certain places,
2:47:07none of which are your house,
2:47:09and it's a very different experience.
2:47:12And yes, gas is more convenient on those long trips,
2:47:15but all the rest of your life,
2:47:17electric is so much more convenient.
2:47:20- I was super impressed with Rivian's build quality
2:47:24and design choices. Usually every time I read, in my experience, driving unfamiliar cars is rentals,
2:47:32and every time I rent a car, you almost never get the same model twice or even vaguely so.
2:47:40And I'm instantly, of course, surprise, surprise, very picky and upset about certain choices of
2:47:45where certain controls are and which sticks are where and even what font they used for this and
2:47:51that instantly. I have never sat behind a steering wheel for the first time and thought, "Boy, that's
2:47:57in the right spot. That's in the right spot." I like where they put that. Never, ever more than
2:48:03with Rivian. And again, it's like if you stick with the same brand and you buy an Acura after
2:48:11an Acura or a Honda Accord after a Honda Accord, there's a... Or if you shift from a Honda Accord
2:48:18to a Honda SUV, the controls, you know, there's a brand similarity there. Or if you stick within BMW,
2:48:27you know, you don't get confused about where controls are. But Rivian doesn't have any heritage
2:48:34like that. They're not derived from any other thing. And it's not at all like the Acura that
2:48:39I'm used to. But I have never sat behind a cockpit and thought this is really well arranged, and
2:48:46nothing annoyed me as much it and just all the little things and there's so
2:48:51many little things that I personally do not like about Tesla's that I feel I
2:48:55think feel cheap or I think feel poorly designed I can't stand their friggin door
2:49:00handles I just can't I honestly god admit they've never made a good door
2:49:04handle never made a good door I've never seen it they're all and they're all bad
2:49:08in different ways and it all bad in different ways and then they've gotten
2:49:11worse and to me I don't know that I can I honest it's in a way you know this
2:49:17about me and my taste on watches I could never buy a wristwatch that has any any
2:49:23bit of typography on the dial or the back of the case the back of the case
2:49:29that I disagree with there been watches I've almost bought where that on the
2:49:33back of the case there's like you know assembled in Switzerland or whatever is
2:49:38and they typeset it in Arial, and therefore I will not buy it. It's out. I will not buy it and put it
2:49:45on my wrist. To me, the Tesla door handles might be like that. I don't know. But I just think the
2:49:50build quality is better. I think Tesla's interiors have a mid-range, you know, Honda Toyota sort of
2:50:00Quality to them and the Rivian is the Lexus Acura
2:50:04Even BMW I honestly I it's a really it's just great great interior
2:50:12I just blown away by it from a new company that and you guys covered this on ATP the big sticking point for nerds
2:50:19Is that like Tesla their?
2:50:22Computer stack is all their own and so they don't support airplay
2:50:29Are not a car play so it's their maps. It's their stuff
2:50:34I mean you can obviously connect your phone to play music. Yeah, it has Bluetooth right it has Bluetooth. I
2:50:40Don't know how I feel about that but you
2:50:44Seem having used both recently to be not
2:50:48surprised to me surprisingly
2:50:51Not that mindful of not just because you owned a Tesla for a long time
2:50:56But you know having driven this Land Rover now for a while that does have carplay and you're literally a carplay developer
2:51:04I mean, I mean car plays carplay support is a very significant part of making
2:51:09an iOS podcast app, I mean, well, it's the thing it actually isn't because
2:51:16You know the the way carplay is implemented for developers like me who are not Apple
2:51:21You basically have like, you can choose from certain
2:51:25templates that different screens will use,
2:51:27and you can, you kind of like give it, you know,
2:51:29structured data to say, okay, well, you know,
2:51:31show the list template, and then show these cells
2:51:34with these things in them, and here's title and artwork
2:51:36for each one, but you don't have a ton of control
2:51:39over all those little details.
2:51:40You don't have a ton of options, you don't have,
2:51:42you can't do a full, complete UI.
2:51:44It gets limited in many ways, like, for instance,
2:51:47the length of lists is limited by certain jurisdictions
2:51:51for regulation reasons. So like sometimes you only see like the first 12 items in a
2:51:56list and it'll cut it off. Like there's a whole bunch of limitations like that. And
2:52:00of course there's rules also like you aren't allowed to use the CarPlay interface elements
2:52:05to make some kind of game. Like you can't make a CarPlay game basically by you know
2:52:09whatever you do with the list. You can't make like a you know a card flipping game
2:52:13or whatever else. Like you could technically make one but it's disallowed by the rules.
2:52:18But anyway, so CarPlay's a very limited environment
2:52:21for developers to really do much.
2:52:23What you're doing is pretty basic there.
2:52:25And so I was fine, you know, I've only had
2:52:28a CarPlay vehicle myself for the last seven months
2:52:31or whatever, before that I just had these little
2:52:34CarPlay test unit on my desk and that was enough,
2:52:37combined with user feedback, that was enough
2:52:39for me to develop it.
2:52:41But for the Rivian, not having CarPlay,
2:52:44again, it's something that I would like to have it
2:52:48as an option. I hope they add it. They could add it via software if they wanted to, as far as I know.
2:52:53So I would love to have CarPlay as an option, but the lack of CarPlay is not a deal killer for me
2:53:01to buy the vehicle. Why do you think they don't? Why do you think they don't? Well, I know I always
2:53:08heard that with Tesla, it was it was very much that kind of like the the arrogant engineering
2:53:15culture of we want to own everything, which I get to some degree, you know, I do that
2:53:20myself, so, you know, we want to own everything, but also the, I think where the main arrogance
2:53:26comes in is you won't need it. That's the big, that's where like the attitude at Tesla
2:53:31was always, why would you need CarPlay? You have our system and it's so much better and
2:53:36look you can even play these dumb games in it and, you know, so that's, and that's,
2:53:42there's many problems with Tesla.
2:53:44So I get the feeling that Rivian probably has
2:53:47that same degree of opinionation, if that's a word,
2:53:51of like, they are, their screen design, their UI design,
2:53:55the whole way their center console screen works,
2:54:00the design is very much in the realm
2:54:03of what Tesla strives to be.
2:54:06I think Rivian does a better job of it, frankly.
2:54:08And I think, you know, the experience of being
2:54:10a Tesla owner is you get an amazingly driving car
2:54:15with some really great, amazing features.
2:54:18And there's a bunch of quirks that you
2:54:22have to tolerate in order to access those features.
2:54:25For instance, the door handles having to access your car.
2:54:28But also, the design of the screen,
2:54:33they'll send out over-the-air redesigns at the drop of a hat.
2:54:36And all of a sudden, you'll get into your car,
2:54:38you can't find the defroster.
2:54:40And they have mixed success with Tesla over the years.
2:54:43Some of their UIs are okay, some of them are terrible,
2:54:47some of them are great, but for the most part with Tesla,
2:54:50you're rolling the dice constantly
2:54:52and they're all over the map.
2:54:54Rivian so far seems to be much more disciplined
2:54:57with their design and much more successful with it.
2:55:00And Rivian seems to have the confidence
2:55:05do not attempt things like stupid door handles.
2:55:08'Cause Tesla is desperate to prove to the world
2:55:12how innovative they are.
2:55:14- Right, well look how different their trucks look, right?
2:55:16So the best comparison is the Rivian,
2:55:18both trucks versus the Cybertruck,
2:55:22which honest to God, I think it's hard to believe
2:55:26is not a, I still think it's hard to believe is not a prank.
2:55:29And-- - I know, well until it's out,
2:55:31we don't really know that, right?
2:55:33those those real-world pictures that somebody snapped recently of a cyber
2:55:39truck on the street where it's not photographed by Tesla's photographers in
2:55:44a product product marketing scenario but just real world on the street the sheets
2:55:50of what is it it is stainless steel is I believe so yeah that they're all warped
2:55:58in a way that you would think they were it looks it looks like it looks like a
2:56:02fantastic senior college student project
2:56:07from the University of Michigan,
2:56:09where these budding car engineers built this thing, right?
2:56:13It doesn't look like a premium truck.
2:56:17I know some people out there seem to love it,
2:56:19but to me, it's, to me, the people who seem to love it
2:56:22are these Elon Musk fanatics who also seem to think
2:56:27he insists he's doing a good job running Twitter.
2:56:31- Yeah, right. - I don't know.
2:56:33But I mean, in terms of--
2:56:34- You know, a few years ago, like I,
2:56:36this is pre-pandemic,
2:56:38during one of our California trips for an Apple thing,
2:56:42I had the opportunity to visit the Facebook campus,
2:56:45and I'd never been there before.
2:56:47And overall, the feeling I got from the Facebook campus
2:56:51was A, I don't belong here,
2:56:54and B, I find it almost creepy in a lot of ways.
2:56:58Like, it was very young people
2:57:00who really thought a lot of themselves doing things
2:57:04in ways that seemed a little bit immature,
2:57:08a little bit unwise maybe,
2:57:11kind of making this weird fantasy world
2:57:14where everything they did was great,
2:57:16but there were always like weird undercurrents of like,
2:57:17well, if you actually use the baseball shop on campus,
2:57:22you'll be fired for not working hard enough or whatever.
2:57:25Like there's all sorts, it was a weird vibe.
2:57:27And then I think it was that same day,
2:57:29at least it was that same trip,
2:57:31I also got a chance to visit the Apple campus.
2:57:33That was back in Infinite Loop.
2:57:35And I remember the vibe was so different.
2:57:38It was striking, these two such different places,
2:57:43such different cultures.
2:57:45And you looked around the Apple campus
2:57:46and it was very clear like,
2:57:47oh, this is where the grownups work.
2:57:49Like this is like, you go to the Facebook campus
2:57:52when you want what you think of your college life,
2:57:55whatever you think that is, you want that to last forever.
2:57:58or you think it always will last forever,
2:58:00or you think that's the best it'll ever be or whatever.
2:58:02That's what Facebook is for.
2:58:04And then when you, those people who don't want that
2:58:07and who just want like a nice grown up job
2:58:10where you do good work and then you go home at night,
2:58:12that's Apple, right?
2:58:13That's the feeling I got.
2:58:14Whether that's actually true, I don't know,
2:58:15but the feeling I got visiting those two campuses,
2:58:18that's what it was like.
2:58:19And to me, being a Tesla owner for so long,
2:58:23I think it's much more like the Facebook culture
2:58:25where it's like, you know, move fast, break things,
2:58:29surely to a fault, and you know,
2:58:31and everyone's like trying like, you know,
2:58:34these big moonshot kind of ideas,
2:58:37trying to prove that they're innovative,
2:58:39and the thing is, they are innovative.
2:58:42They don't need to prove it by things like
2:58:43dumb door handles and weird UI designs.
2:58:46Like, they don't need to do those things.
2:58:48The cars themselves, without those things,
2:58:50even if they had regular boring door handles,
2:58:52are very innovative.
2:58:53Rivian seems like they are much more confident
2:58:57that their cars are good, and Rivians are very innovative
2:59:00in lots of other ways.
2:59:02Some of their useful utility features,
2:59:05and the more adventure camping features,
2:59:08the utility features, like even stupid things,
2:59:10like their roof rack, their roof crossbars.
2:59:13Super innovative, like the way you can just pop 'em on,
2:59:17pop 'em off, you can stick 'em in the frunk.
2:59:20They have thought of so many little details of that car.
2:59:22These cars are extremely innovative from Rivian,
2:59:25but they don't feel the need to show it off
2:59:29in ways like weird door handles.
2:59:31- Right, 'cause they're-- - Or quirks of the interior.
2:59:33They just made a nice car that's really useful,
2:59:37and it's designed in a more confident, restrained way
2:59:41in those kind of flashy areas,
2:59:44because they know they don't need to show off there.
2:59:46They just made a nice car that works really well,
2:59:48and they've thought of all these details
2:59:50in a very Apple-like way.
2:59:51It's like, we've thought of the nice things,
2:59:53we've thought of the nice details, it works,
2:59:55it has all these little clever features and nice designs,
2:59:57and it won't get in your way,
2:59:59and the door handles aren't gonna freeze,
3:00:01and they're not gonna fail,
3:00:03and all this problems that Tesla has.
3:00:05- Yeah, I wouldn't say, like,
3:00:07if you blindfolded me for a couple of years,
3:00:09and then took me away, and then brought me back,
3:00:12and put me in a unmarked, unlabeled Rivian,
3:00:15and said, "This is the Apple car,"
3:00:18I don't think I would quite believe it.
3:00:20It's not quite Apple-y,
3:00:21but I might believe it, right?
3:00:23- Now there's too many buttons for it to be the Apple car.
3:00:25- Yeah, exactly. - Which I consider a good thing.
3:00:27- Right, exactly.
3:00:28It wouldn't quite pass the sniff test for me,
3:00:33but it would have me thinking maybe, I don't know.
3:00:37But there is a similarity,
3:00:40and I think it's why they invited me to drive it.
3:00:44It's a similar, and again, I think what you're saying,
3:00:46the thing I remember is I don't want a pickup truck at all.
3:00:50If I were to buy a Rivian, I'd buy the other one.
3:00:52But some of the things in the bed of the truck
3:00:55that are clever, they're all,
3:00:57none of them are clever for cleverness sake.
3:01:00They all have obvious utility in some obvious way.
3:01:04It's, anything that is different or original
3:01:07is different or original in the name of a utility,
3:01:11an obvious utilitarian purpose that maybe you won't use,
3:01:15but you can imagine somebody would use.
3:01:17And the other thing that comes to mind with that,
3:01:20and to me is Apple like,
3:01:22hey, what if the door handles were completely normal,
3:01:25and nobody's gonna say anything about it,
3:01:28is the mentality that Apple has
3:01:32that they will ship iPhones
3:01:36that look to most people exactly the same
3:01:42for three, four, five years maybe, right?
3:01:46iPhone 6, 6S, 7, 8, you know,
3:01:50all looked exactly the same,
3:01:52and aren't worried.
3:01:55They're so confident that this is a good design
3:01:57and this is good that they'll just keep selling it
3:02:01for three, four years,
3:02:03even though that's totally not exciting
3:02:05and not gonna get a lot,
3:02:07a lot of the tech press is going to ding them
3:02:09for it immediately.
3:02:10Like every single iPhone
3:02:12that isn't an all new original design,
3:02:14A lot of the reviews immediately ding it
3:02:16because it looks just like last year's phone.
3:02:19And they're confident that no,
3:02:20'cause this is a good design.
3:02:22I have been told by someone whose name
3:02:27rhymes with Johnny Ive personally
3:02:31that they will never make a change just to make a change.
3:02:38That they will only make a change
3:02:42if they're 100% sure that it's better.
3:02:47Now, there are times where they've made changes
3:02:50that I think all of us would agree are not better,
3:02:52but they thought, someone at Apple thought it was better.
3:02:55Someone thought it was better
3:02:56to switch to butterfly keyboard.
3:02:58Someone thought it was better overall
3:03:02and the overall balance of things
3:03:03to ship a MacBook that only has one USB-C port.
3:03:11But that was, you know, mistakes are made, right?
3:03:15Nobody's perfect.
3:03:17But there's never any sort of ostentatious,
3:03:19we're just going to radically change
3:03:21the shape of the phone every year
3:03:23just because we want new, new, new, right?
3:03:27And Rivian to me has that sort of humility
3:03:30of we'll show off, you know, we'll make it nice
3:03:33where we will, but I don't know.
3:03:36It's a product, I haven't spoken about it a lot,
3:03:38and I wish I had, but I thought,
3:03:39you on recently driving I bring it up the only other thing I'll mention to you
3:03:44and I it's you know I you're probably gonna fucking buy ones knowing you so I
3:03:51literally waiting to go no no I know I know I know you you're gonna find
3:03:56someone who's selling it used one and you know probably have one by the time
3:04:00the show's done editing but if I could I would I know that's I know you so you'll
3:04:06get more experienced with this than me but you I believe you said on ATP did
3:04:12not get to take it out on the highway that's correct right I did and and dates
3:04:17and I said can I go as fast as I want and they said sure and I so I got it in
3:04:22sport mode number one the sport mode on the Rivian is not like a do-nothing
3:04:27button you know like when you press the the button you cross the street you know
3:04:31it's like or you know yeah the door closed button in elevator yeah the door
3:04:35close button and elevator that or something that just makes noise the sport mode in Rivian
3:04:44is like in the Incredibles when Mr. Incredible turns his car into the Incredibles car you
3:04:52know it it really does something it lowers it noticeably which I like as someone who'd
3:04:57rather drive a car than SUV and holy shit does it does it change the way that it performs
3:05:05when you go, let's say, not that anybody in the state of New York can give me a ticket
3:05:11seven months later, let's say a little north of 100 miles an hour. It is unbelievable.
3:05:22Oh, it is. I mean, honestly, if I could have bought one, I might have done it, but you can't.
3:05:30you know, on the spot, I just thinking I was going for a press test drive. I came back to Brooklyn
3:05:37and it was just like, I need to get one of these and somehow got talked out of it. It is unbelievable.
3:05:44You can't buy them. I know, that's the whole problem. So, I hope that they succeed because
3:05:49I really like what they're doing and I like their aesthetic. I worry that a company that, you know,
3:05:55there's a limit, you know, when they need to get to a certain critical mass of production, I think,
3:06:01to make, to be a successful company. It's frustrating. I, you know, we have, we both,
3:06:08I know, we both already, not just you, I know several friends who are on the list.
3:06:12And I don't know anybody who's gotten it off the list, even though they're obviously out there on
3:06:17the road. The list is longer than the number of people who've already got them, which is
3:06:22frustrating but understandable. But I really do hope that they succeed and can ramp up
3:06:28production and become more of a name. It's a remarkable product.
3:06:34Jared: Yeah, and what they're doing, I'm more excited about them than I am about most
3:06:40or all other car makers right now. Because, you know, and I said this in ATP too, so forgive
3:06:45me if you listen to that. But if you looked at the car market, there's like the old
3:06:51way of doing things, where everything is like these different components everyone buys from
3:06:54somebody and you know, you buy a computer module from this company, you know, you buy
3:06:58your this module from this company and then you put the car together and it's exactly
3:07:03like what you'd expect from something that's built from a whole bunch of components from
3:07:07different vendors that no one was really integrating them that well. And it's like building a
3:07:12PC and it's like the world of PCs.
3:07:14Right. And that.
3:07:15Where everything is like more complicated than it needs to be, doesn't really quite
3:07:19work together as well as it could.
3:07:21And then you have Tesla and Rivian,
3:07:24who are doing everything like super custom,
3:07:27a lot more in-house stuff, at least in-house designs,
3:07:31a ton more integration work, custom UI and all the stuff.
3:07:36The level of integration they have
3:07:38and the way they're doing things,
3:07:40and even some of the features they have
3:07:42that no one else is really doing.
3:07:44Like I was saying, one of the things I miss most
3:07:45about not having an electric car right now
3:07:48is the Tesla dog mode.
3:07:51- Yeah.
3:07:52- Where I can go on, like, we use this so much
3:07:54'cause we're constantly driving back and forth
3:07:57between different places.
3:07:57So, like, the whole family will go,
3:07:59we'll have the dog with us,
3:08:00'cause we're going for like a weekend,
3:08:02and oh, we wanna stop on the way
3:08:03for a restaurant or something.
3:08:05And then you gotta leave the dog in the car.
3:08:07And like, okay, well now you have to get out of the car,
3:08:11get out of the gas car, lock it, turn the remote start on.
3:08:15The remote start gives you 30 minutes,
3:08:16and you gotta run it.
3:08:17"Okay, we have 30 minutes of heat for the dog."
3:08:20And then the car is running,
3:08:22spewing gas at the back the whole time.
3:08:23And it's just, it's a mess.
3:08:26And then you look at what you could do with Tesla and Rivian
3:08:28you could put it in dog mode.
3:08:29And it's, you could do it from, it's indefinite
3:08:33and well until the battery runs out at least
3:08:34but that's a very, very long time.
3:08:36- Right, just-- - And it's such
3:08:37a better feature.
3:08:37Like, there's stuff like that.
3:08:39So like, what Rivian and Tesla are doing
3:08:42is so much nicer and better and more forward looking
3:08:45than what almost anyone else is doing.
3:08:47- And Rivian's doing a way better job than Tesla
3:08:49at being that kind of company right now.
3:08:52And unless Tesla has a major leadership change,
3:08:55I don't see them solving the flaws they do have.
3:08:59And look, I've been a huge Tesla fan
3:09:02for most of the last seven or eight years, whatever it's been
3:09:05I'm not saying Tesla's bad,
3:09:07Rivian's just doing that playbook much better
3:09:10in a much more mature and deliberate and controlled way.
3:09:16And so I'm very excited for Rivian's future.
3:09:19I really, really hope that they,
3:09:21I don't really follow the financials
3:09:24and stuff like that of these companies.
3:09:27So whatever stage of the company that Rivian's in right now,
3:09:31I hope they're on the good path
3:09:33and that they scale up whatever they need to scale up
3:09:36because they're doing such great work
3:09:40with what they have so far.
3:09:42And I really, really hope that they are rewarded for it.
3:09:46- Well said.
3:09:48I say we call that a wrap.
3:09:51Thank you very much for your time as ever.
3:09:54And thank you also for all of the advice
3:09:56you give me on what to buy.
3:09:57(laughs)
3:09:58- Yeah, no problem.
3:09:59- Although I guess I gave you some camera advice recently.
3:10:04- Yeah.
3:10:05- So I got to return the favor a little bit.
3:10:09And let me thank our very fine sponsors,
3:10:13our good friends at Squarespace,
3:10:14where you can build your own website, make your next move,
3:10:16use the code TALKSHOW for 10% off your first order.
3:10:20Trade Coffee, get a free bag of fresh coffee
3:10:22with any trade subscription at drinktrade.com/thetalkshow.
3:10:27And Memberful, where you can monetize your passion
3:10:31with membership at memberful.com/talkshow.
3:10:35Of course, Marco's show with his fine co-hosts, John Siracusa and Casey Liss, is ATP at ATP.fm.
3:10:45You're over on Mastodon now. How do we do this? What's your handle?
3:10:53Tim Cynova I am @marcoarmint@mastodon.social. It's so awkward.
3:10:58- Right, but if you're using any of these budding,
3:11:02burgeoning clients, if you just search for Marco Arment,
3:11:07you are guaranteed to find him,
3:11:08which is perhaps the better way to do it.
3:11:10It's like instead of, that's why I said,
3:11:12how do we do this?
3:11:13It's less, it's almost a better way, right?
3:11:18In a sense, where the handles on Twitter
3:11:21is an awkward sort of techy looking thing,
3:11:24just search for Marco Arment
3:11:27in your favorite Mastodon client and you'll find Marco
3:11:30in the same way that you'll find me.
3:11:32And you should, by the way, we didn't talk about it,
3:11:34but join us there, it's friggin' awesome and fun
3:11:38and doesn't seem to have any jerks.
3:11:42I don't know, I don't know how long it's gonna--
3:11:44- It has some, but it's such a smaller percentage.
3:11:47You can just easily mute them.
3:11:48- Yeah, it is like Twitter of old and it's wonderful.
3:11:53That however long it's lasts, I'm all in.
3:11:56So thank you, Marco.