Podcast Search

The Talk Show

370: ‘Fine Hypertext Products’, With Jason Kottke

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00- Jason, how you doing?

0:00:01- I'm doing all right, John.

0:00:02Thanks for having me on the show.

0:00:03- How's the weather up there?

0:00:04- Well, it's cold 'cause it's winter.

0:00:07It's getting lighter though, which is great.

0:00:10Late December, January here in Vermont is kind of bleak,

0:00:13to be honest.

0:00:14So I'm glad the light is getting more towards spring.

0:00:17- I hate winters, I do.

0:00:19And my wife and I, we've been talking about it.

0:00:21Like why the hell do we live here?

0:00:22And I live in the tropics compared to you.

0:00:25- Yeah, darkness is the worst thing up here

0:00:27because it's significantly darker for longer here

0:00:31in December and January than it is in New York

0:00:34or down in Philly.

0:00:36- And I've also found as I've gotten old,

0:00:40I was gonna say older, but let's face it, old,

0:00:42you would think it would go the other way,

0:00:45that the older you get, the more you just get used to it.

0:00:49And I find the opposite.

0:00:51When I was a kid, I knew that it got dark earlier

0:00:56in the winter.

0:00:57I mean, just open your eyes.

0:00:58And I knew I had to come home from playing outside,

0:01:03because we're so old that, fairly, we would just

0:01:06come home from school, and we'd be set loose to go run around

0:01:11with no parental supervision.

0:01:13It wasn't just my parents.

0:01:14It was like the neighborhood rule for all the parents.

0:01:16You have to come home when the street lights come on.

0:01:19We didn't wear watches.

0:01:21That was the rule.

0:01:22If the street lights are on, it's time to come home.

0:01:24and I knew that, boy, this kinda sucks in December.

0:01:28We don't really get much time after school.

0:01:30But on the other hand, even like college,

0:01:33I don't really remember being like bummed out

0:01:35that it's dark early or anything,

0:01:37I guess because also in college,

0:01:39you kinda just live and sleep on whatever cycle you want

0:01:43as long as you can submit your homework.

0:01:46I was gonna say go to class, but I skipped a lot of classes.

0:01:49But now that I'm an adult,

0:01:52I really get bummed in December, even November, I do.

0:01:56And I know they call it seasonal affect disorder or whatever.

0:01:59I don't know if I have any disorder, I just get bummed.

0:02:03- Yeah, yeah, I mean, me too.

0:02:05I mean, so I grew up in Wisconsin

0:02:08and was fine with it as a kid.

0:02:11I never remember being bummed out.

0:02:12And even when I lived in New York from,

0:02:16when was it, 2002 to 2016, I guess,

0:02:21It didn't really bother me a whole lot there either.

0:02:23And then when I moved up here,

0:02:25like the first winter was okay

0:02:27and the second one just totally just kicked my ass.

0:02:30I was just like, what the hell happened?

0:02:32I feel like I got hit by a freight train.

0:02:34- I also do notice though, the flip side of it

0:02:37is I do notice the expanding daylight hours more.

0:02:42So it's like, I get more bummed.

0:02:44I do, I really get more bummed in November and December.

0:02:48I find January and February,

0:02:50or at least early February to be dreary,

0:02:52but right around now, late February,

0:02:54or recording on March 3rd, it's like looking up.

0:02:58And I also find that when daylight savings time

0:03:02finally kicks back in, it is,

0:03:04it's like the best gift of the year to me.

0:03:08I mean, no offense to my family

0:03:10and all the actual gifts they give to me,

0:03:13but the day where I look at my watch

0:03:16and it's six o'clock, seven o'clock,

0:03:18and it's still plenty of light outside, I'm like, woo!

0:03:21- Yeah, it's amazing.

0:03:24Here in Vermont, I've noticed the last few winters,

0:03:29the first day where it's sunny

0:03:33and the thermometer's pushing like 65, 70,

0:03:36it feels like nothing else.

0:03:38I will go outside in shirt sleeves and shorts,

0:03:43and I work outside and I'm just like, this is awesome,

0:03:46And I can't believe I was this depressed for the last three months.

0:03:50Right, you mean like just--

0:03:51Yeah, you feel like a million bucks.

0:03:52Right, you're sitting there working on cocky, the laptop, you know,

0:03:55outside and breathing that fresh air.

0:03:59Exactly.

0:04:00Yep, and there's like literally like still probably like three feet of snow

0:04:04out in the yard or whatever, but it's because we have global warming now,

0:04:08every once in a while in March, you know, like mid-March or whatever,

0:04:10it's oh, it's gonna be 70 degrees for a little bit.

0:04:12And then it goes back to, you know,

0:04:14we're gonna have an ice storm three days later.

0:04:16- Yeah. - So.

0:04:17- Yeah, we had that a few weeks ago

0:04:19where there was a stretch here in February,

0:04:21which is always the worst month from New York.

0:04:24It's way worse than January, in my opinion.

0:04:26We had a couple days in the '60s.

0:04:28I've lived my whole life either outside Philadelphia

0:04:31growing up or in Philadelphia

0:04:33other than two years up in Massachusetts,

0:04:35but I'm super familiar at this point

0:04:39with the annual temperature.

0:04:41What's a nice day?

0:04:42what's a bad day for any day of the year.

0:04:45And it's like even if I didn't know logically,

0:04:50if I had never read the news

0:04:52and had never heard of climate change,

0:04:54I would know something is up.

0:04:56You know what I mean?

0:04:57It's like you could literally be a hermit,

0:05:01like a Ted Kaczynski living in a shack with no internet,

0:05:04no newspapers, and you'd be like,

0:05:05"Hey, what's up with the weather?

0:05:06"Am I wrong about what date it is?"

0:05:09- I've been coming up here to Vermont since,

0:05:11I don't know, 2003, something like that.

0:05:14And you can tell by the ski areas,

0:05:17and you can tell by how much snow there is at the ski areas,

0:05:20and how much they're able to be open,

0:05:22and when they can open for the season initially,

0:05:25and when they close at the end of the season,

0:05:28and it's that season is just getting shorter.

0:05:30And you get these weird warmups in the middle of January,

0:05:33in the middle of February,

0:05:34where it rains and it's 55 degrees,

0:05:38and you just get fewer days,

0:05:40you get fewer people, you know, coming up and doing things and spending their money

0:05:45here and stuff like that. And it's just, yeah, you would totally be able to tell, even if

0:05:50you had never, you know, never heard of climate change or whatever. It's just different.

0:05:54I should know this as a long time, as we're about to get to, very long time,

0:05:59reader of your website. Are you at, I feel like I should definitely know this because I'm,

0:06:04it seems like total katky fodder, but are you at daylight savings time year-round man or not?

0:06:11I mean, I don't think they should switch back and forth.

0:06:13So which one do you think? I mean, obviously, if they're only going to have one, it's going

0:06:17to be daylight savings time, because we're already at eight months, four months.

0:06:20And the legal proposals are only for... nobody's proposing we go standard time year-round,

0:06:27I don't think.

0:06:29Right, no, I mean, yeah, I mean, I would choose that, yeah.

0:06:34It's awkward for me, or at least unexpected, because I forget who it is who's sponsoring

0:06:38the bill. It's either Marco Rubio or Ted Cruz, but it doesn't matter which one. It doesn't matter.

0:06:44- Yeah. - The point is,

0:06:46I can't believe I'm here on the side of legislation being proposed by whoever it is. But yeah,

0:06:51the switch sucks. But also, it's like, "F you morning people." And it's the morning people who

0:06:59bitch and moan about, "Well, but if we switch to daylight savings time, it'll be so dark until like

0:07:05830 or 9 in the morning, you know, in the middle of winter." And they always bring up the kids at

0:07:11the freaking bus stop, right? What about the kids going to school? But that circles back to my point

0:07:17about the way we raise children today. Kids aren't unsupervised at bus stops anymore, right? Like,

0:07:23when we were kids, your mom wouldn't even get dressed in the morning. Your mom would still be,

0:07:27you know, in her whatever she slept in and just get you out the door and, you know, whether you

0:07:32were going to a bus stop or walking to school or whatever, you were on your own. Nobody does that

0:07:37anymore. It's not a good excuse. The switchover is insane. The thing about early school times anyway,

0:07:44like, we should just move the school time. Yes. Not futz around with actual time. Just like,

0:07:49school should start later because, like, it's better for kids. Yeah, absolutely.

0:07:55There is actual research. This is not just me spouting off with my personal opinion

0:07:59and my vivid memories. My vivid memories from high school of being a total zombie.

0:08:05Yeah, exactly. Exactly.

0:08:06My best friend and I in high school, we both mastered the technique of sleeping in class

0:08:11with your head not on your desk, but like a certain pose where you could like get your chin

0:08:19in on your palm and we would choose seats in the back, not just, I always say I like

0:08:25to sit in the back for most of my classes just so I could screw around, but you had

0:08:29to go back corner and then you could like kind of turn your head away from the teacher.

0:08:33I got solid sleep in classes my whole like probably junior and senior years, but it's

0:08:40because it's terrible. I mean we used to have to, I think it was like 8 a.m. and it's like

0:08:44the real world doesn't start at 8 a.m. The adult world.

0:08:48Yeah, exactly.

0:08:49Anyway.

0:08:50Well, as I hinted, we are here to talk about the fact that you've been writing your website

0:08:56for, well, let's just say it, 25 fucking years.

0:09:00Yes, 25 fucking years.

0:09:04When is the official anniversary?

0:09:05Do you know the date?

0:09:07Yeah, so it's March 14th.

0:09:09All right, so we'll be out before.

0:09:12We're a little ahead of your anniversary, but...

0:09:16I'll just start by saying congrats.

0:09:18I mean, I don't know what more to say.

0:09:21I mean, I'm glad you're at it.

0:09:22I was looking as research.

0:09:24I actually did some actual homework for this show

0:09:27on every other episode of this.

0:09:29All 369 preceding episodes.

0:09:34- Right, this is the first one.

0:09:36- I found your 10th anniversary post.

0:09:39Well, I found, like it's hard to find.

0:09:41But you said see you in 2008, or no, 2018.

0:09:45So let me start by saying this, let me ask this.

0:09:48In the early years, when you first started kaki.org,

0:09:55did you have a sense that even then that you'd be doing,

0:10:00if all things go well, knock on wood, health stays up,

0:10:05nuclear war doesn't happen, the internet stays open,

0:10:09that you'd still be doing this now?

0:10:11- I would say no.

0:10:13There's rarely been a plan.

0:10:14I think the whole thing has just happened really organically.

0:10:17I started it because, like, oh, you know, I wanted to have a place to write things down.

0:10:22And so at the time I was doing this other website called Oscillate, and that was more

0:10:27sort of visual and it was, like, episodic.

0:10:30Like every one, you know, every few weeks I would release a new, like, episode.

0:10:33But people had started blogging and, you know, there were online diaries and all this sort

0:10:37of stuff.

0:10:38And, you know, I decided, oh, I want to try this out.

0:10:42And people read it and liked it, and so I kept writing, and it became slowly sort of

0:10:48like more and more of kind of my online life.

0:10:52And even the decision to like, you know, I went full-time like as a job in 2005, and

0:10:57even that wasn't, you know, like that was like a few months before I had lunch with

0:11:02Anil Dash.

0:11:04And we were just talking about this and that, and he sort of like, I can't remember what

0:11:08we were talking about exactly, but he was kind of like, "You know, I bet if you really

0:11:12wanted to do it, you could do your website as a full-time job.

0:11:15You could find advertising or get people to pay or whatever."

0:11:19He's like, "I bet you could do it."

0:11:20And I was like, "Huh."

0:11:22And then I was thinking about it after that, and I was like, "Wait a minute.

0:11:26That might be cool."

0:11:27So yeah, so there was never any drive to be sort of long-lasting or anything like that.

0:11:35It's just sort of what's happened.

0:11:37That's interesting because I wouldn't say immediately when I started during

0:11:46Fireball, but maybe very close.

0:11:48I at least had the hope when I started that maybe I could eventually figure out

0:11:56immediately figure out a way that I could do this as a living and had a sense that

0:12:01I think I could do this forever.

0:12:05And by the time I went full-time in 2006, largely inspired, you know, well, I mean,

0:12:13it was my plan before, but sort of— I don't know that I would have taken the jump, though, in 2006

0:12:20if you hadn't already done it. Like, you made me—you doing it full-time made me so insanely jealous

0:12:25that it—it did! It really did, but in a good way, where it broke through my natural procrastination.

0:12:35Like the reason, Daring Fireball's 20 as of last August,

0:12:39so five years behind you.

0:12:41But it's funny because, let me put it this way,

0:12:44for a very long time, I felt like I was a newcomer

0:12:48and you were established

0:12:50because I started five years after you, right?

0:12:53So when you're five or six, seven years old into katki.org

0:12:57and I'm one or two years into Daring Fireball,

0:13:00it feels like I'm the newcomer.

0:13:02And when you start comparing 20 to 25,

0:13:06it feels like, what's the difference?

0:13:09We're both like last people standing

0:13:12and old men and stalwarts.

0:13:15But I, when I started, I was hoping

0:13:19this is like a thing that would stick.

0:13:21And I remember I had like a list of 10 or 12 articles

0:13:25that I felt like, here's 10 or 12 things

0:13:28I knew I wanted to write.

0:13:29'Cause I didn't have my short form links at the time.

0:13:31All I had were full posts, more.

0:13:34Every post is an article sort of blogging,

0:13:39which was more typical.

0:13:41Well, you know, there's a mix back then.

0:13:42But I had 10 or 12, and I felt like I could keep this going.

0:13:47And I forget where I kept the list.

0:13:50It was probably already, well, I'm not sure

0:13:53which app I had it in.

0:13:54But the list kept growing faster

0:13:58than I was writing articles.

0:14:00There have always been more ideas for posts,

0:14:03or even things I want to link to,

0:14:04than things I actually link to, right?

0:14:06It's, you know, and it's so weeks into it,

0:14:11I realized, you know, at least in terms of having things

0:14:15I want to write about, this seems 100% sustainable,

0:14:18because that's, you know, I'm always coming up

0:14:21with more things that I could or would write about

0:14:23than I actually have time to or actually get to.

0:14:26And it really did not take me long to realize

0:14:31that I would like this to be my life's work.

0:14:33So I'm-- - Yeah.

0:14:33- You know, and I, you know, at least,

0:14:37I've always subscribed to the strong ideas,

0:14:39loosely held mantra for everything in life.

0:14:43So I mean, I've all, you know,

0:14:45it wasn't like I would've bet the house on it,

0:14:48even though, of course, I didn't own a house back then.

0:14:50But figuratively, wouldn't have bet the house on it

0:14:53because I would've been open to new ideas and wonder.

0:14:56but I had that sense though,

0:14:57that this is what I was meant to do.

0:14:59And in hindsight, I find it interesting

0:15:04that you didn't have that sense early on

0:15:05because it seems to me very clearly

0:15:08that what you're doing is what you were meant to do.

0:15:10- Yeah, I mean, at the time,

0:15:14like I was still doing web design stuff

0:15:16like back in the early 2000s.

0:15:18And that was the thing that was really

0:15:23capturing my sort of imagination back then.

0:15:26And like that, you know, that started to change.

0:15:27I feel like, you know, I had this,

0:15:29I had this very corporate web design job in, in 2000,

0:15:33like right after I moved to New York actually,

0:15:35like 2003, 2004.

0:15:36And you know, and that was during a time where, you know,

0:15:40like not everybody that I knew had a job then

0:15:43because of the whole dot-com bust,

0:15:45the sort of the hangover from that, you know,

0:15:48but it was this really corporate job.

0:15:49And I was just sort of like, you know,

0:15:51would go to work and I would-- the work was fairly easy. I'd spend a couple hours a day blogging,

0:15:58just at work. And I'm sure that this is something that will resonate with early bloggers too. They

0:16:04just stole time here and there from their day jobs to write on their sites. And at a certain point,

0:16:11I was just like, "Oh, this is the thing that I'm actually interested in. Why don't I try and do

0:16:16this for a while, you know, and it just, you know, it was, and after a while it was so,

0:16:22it just worked really well, I think, and it worked really well for a number of different reasons,

0:16:28you know, it's, you know, the most flexible job in the world. You just move your time around almost,

0:16:33you know, infinitely, which is like fantastic, you know, when you've got a lot going on,

0:16:38or you want to do different stuff in your life, or you've got little kids and you want to be home for

0:16:43for dinner every night and all that sort of stuff.

0:16:45And it just fit really well.

0:16:47And like it had momentum and I just let it go.

0:16:50It dragged me along almost instead of the other way around.

0:16:55- Well, and I feel that I've always been naturally suited

0:16:58to that aspect of it.

0:16:59I've never been a nine to five person at all.

0:17:02Infamously bad with deadlines.

0:17:04Even now, I mean, my iPhone reviews are always hours

0:17:08after everybody else has come out.

0:17:10If not end of day.

0:17:13And like and it's come full circle where

0:17:17there's a flourishing independent publishing

0:17:22of the last few years, a resurgence,

0:17:27but it's all or at least mostly in the newsletter space.

0:17:32And my friend and dithering colleague cohost Ben Thompson

0:17:37is coming up on 10 years at Stratechery,

0:17:41which blows my mind because I also think of his right.

0:17:44Stratecheries being new, but I love his work.

0:17:50He loves doing it, but I couldn't do what he does because he's

0:17:55he's effectively got a deadline for like 8 AM Eastern every day,

0:17:59even though he's writing from Taiwan,

0:18:01he's got a deadline where his subscribers on the East Coast

0:18:06expect today's issue of Stratechery in the morning,

0:18:11you know, as they have their coffee and breakfast and before they get to work.

0:18:15And I say couldn't all the time for all sorts of things in my life,

0:18:21which means wouldn't, but I wouldn't enjoy it.

0:18:25And then I would grow resentful.

0:18:29That's one thing that's never happened to me is I've never grown resentful of the work

0:18:35and my obligations, the pressure,

0:18:37whatever pressure I feel to keep going, publishing,

0:18:40and do this or that.

0:18:42Whereas if I had that,

0:18:43everybody expects a newsletter at blank time.

0:18:46Doesn't matter what time of day it is, right?

0:18:48Even if I send them out at midnight or whatever,

0:18:51eventually I would be like, well, this is irritating

0:18:53because I wanna go out with friends tonight.

0:18:56And I'm not finished yet, but I have to sit here

0:18:59and finish, you know.

0:19:01All right, let's go back to oscillate.

0:19:02It was spelled with a zero,

0:19:06S-I-L and then the digit eight, which I'm not mocking,

0:19:10but just for people Googling it and looking for it.

0:19:13But that sort of trickery was very, feels a little 90s.

0:19:18- Oh yeah, very 90s, very 90s.

0:19:23- Right, and so when did Oscillate start?

0:19:27And now that the website is defunct, right?

0:19:29It's like, I looked it up, it's the domain's gone, right?

0:19:35Well, I so I still own the domain, but it went on. I can't even remember when it went offline. It was. I mean, it was years and years ago, like more than probably more than 15 years ago already.

0:19:45Right, but it went offline again. I should have done more research is are there old episodes still in the like the way back machine?

0:19:52On the Internet. Actually, no, I've I don't know. I don't know that I've actually looked well. We might be. We'll leave that as a surprise for the show notes.

0:20:02sounds good. All right, but you mentioned that it was episodic, and literally the URLs were like

0:20:09oscillate, was it dot com? I forget what the domain was. Yeah, oscillate.com/episodes/...

0:20:15and then it was the date, and then it was like whatever the name of the episode is.

0:20:20Right, and the idea in the late 90s that was very common on the "I'm just a person with a

0:20:29personal website and I love the web and this isn't this cool that I can just edit HTML which

0:20:37requires very little technical acumen for a technical thing, right? I mean, it's, you know,

0:20:43and I realize not there's still a slew of people who get confused even by the simple HTML of the

0:20:49late 90s where almost everything was hand edited. But for the most part, a non-technical person

0:20:55could just look at the source code. I mean, it was the genius of the mid-90s web was that browsers

0:21:01were built with the view source command, and you could look at it and honestly figure out the basic

0:21:09gist of HTML just by looking at it, right? You know, I aimed for that with Markdown, right?

0:21:15Where you could get the basic gist of Markdown just by reading existing things written in

0:21:24markdown. Oh, I get it. The asterisks mean, I don't know, italics or bold or something,

0:21:29and then look at the output and say, "Oh, I see single asterisks or italics and double asterisks

0:21:35or bold." You know, you could figure it out by looking at it. I hope with markdown even more so,

0:21:42because it's simpler, but HTML was very close to that in the 90s and you'd hand-edit it.

0:21:46And what a lot of people did was this sort of, you know, you calling them episodes is very clever,

0:21:53because it's exactly what people did. They'd just occasionally make like a new toy and it would be

0:21:59like a page or a thing and then they would, you know, put it out there and start spreading the

0:22:05word, you know, however it was and people would have like bookmarks of their favorite sites and

0:22:10they'd come back once in a while and oh here's a new thing from so-and-so, here's a new thing from,

0:22:15yeah, yeah, you know, oh here's a new thing from Kotke at Oscillate, it's an episode, you know,

0:22:20right and you might have one one week and another the next week and then maybe it's a month before

0:22:26you come up with another one yeah exactly there was no like publishing schedule there's no rss

0:22:32that you have to keep there was no sense really that you had to kind of keep feeding the beast

0:22:37right in addition to the episodes that i did i also almost every time not every time but almost

0:22:42every time i redesigned like the interface to get into the past episodes and stuff so there was a

0:22:48new sort of like UX or UI with every episode. And that's the thing that I love doing. We're using all

0:22:59these new tools, and there was new stuff coming out all the time. It's, "Oh, you can do JavaScript

0:23:03now and rollovers, and you can change one image to the other image." I remember when that came out,

0:23:08and that was a huge thing. And so I had to go experiment with that. And so it's all these

0:23:12technologies and everybody, it just felt like this huge bubbling cauldron of creativity.

0:23:20And everyone was trying to like, "What about this cool thing? What about this cool thing?"

0:23:24And just trying to demonstrate through this HTML and through design and stuff like that,

0:23:29what you could actually do, and also what the web could actually do. Because in 1996,

0:23:351997, we didn't really know what the web was capable of completely.

0:23:40All right, when did oscillate start?

0:23:42And everyone was trying to figure it out.

0:23:44When did oscillate start?

0:23:45Like 90, I think early 96.

0:23:47And I'd had a couple of personal sites before that, but oscillate I think started properly in early 96.

0:23:56Yeah, see that?

0:23:57That's what I mean though about you being meant to do this, because that's so early.

0:24:04I don't think you even realize what a sense for the web you have that was innate.

0:24:10because I didn't have a website anywhere close to then. I learned how to make websites and then when

0:24:15I graduated college in 1996, was doing freelance, you know, so-and-so needs a website and make

0:24:22a website for them, but wasn't self-publishing or, you know, and wasn't thinking about that.

0:24:30I guess I was sort of thinking about it, but

0:24:34I was too obsessed with form,

0:24:36but not the form of an individual page,

0:24:42but the form of the publication,

0:24:45which to me is what that episodic nature of Oscillate

0:24:49was sort of, you know, that was the form.

0:24:51It was just periodic episodes.

0:24:53And coming from my only true public publishing

0:24:57The only true public publishing background

0:25:01was the student newspaper at Drexel,

0:25:03and it was a weekly, and I've always been

0:25:06a media junkie of all kinds.

0:25:10I know you are, too.

0:25:12But that concept of issues was so deeply ingrained

0:25:16in my brain that it took me a long time.

0:25:20I couldn't get around it, because it didn't seem

0:25:23like issues were right for the web,

0:25:26I couldn't figure out what was right for the web and it paralyzed me from doing anything

0:25:35for years.

0:25:36And then when would you say blogs started?

0:25:40I know this is history I could theoretically look up, but...

0:25:44Yeah, I mean, I think, you know, Robot Wisdom, like he called it a web blog in 1998, maybe

0:25:53probably '97, I would say. But people had diary-ish sort of things, like online diaries,

0:26:00going back to Justin Hall, Justin's Links from the Underground. He started that in 1994,

0:26:06and it was basically like a stream of consciousness diary of his life and what he was up to. And

0:26:12I think that people experimented with all sorts of different forms. There were definitely

0:26:16web publications that had issues. And I think that later it became like, "We're not going

0:26:23to worry about an issue. We're just going to publish whatever we want as we go along."

0:26:28And then blogs came along and just supercharged that, and everybody was sort of off to the races.

0:26:34JS Does anything that you did, any of the episodes that oscillate, stand out to you as a favorite?

0:26:40it.

0:26:41Oh, man.

0:26:42I mean, honestly, it's been a long time since I've even looked at or, you know, I have all

0:26:47the files or whatever, like, sitting on my hard drive.

0:26:50And it's just been, like, a long time since I've looked at those.

0:26:53I remember there was one where I wanted to do this, you know, this was, like, right in

0:27:02the age of sort of the early JavaScript experiments.

0:27:05And like, I had these conceptual ideas that I wanted to do.

0:27:08I was like, this should be possible,

0:27:10but I don't have quite the technical ability

0:27:13to figure out how to do it.

0:27:15And so I worked with a friend of mine.

0:27:17We constructed a page of frames.

0:27:21Remember frames?

0:27:22- Of course.

0:27:23I never actually used them.

0:27:25I never built a website with them

0:27:26because I hated them from the start.

0:27:29But I do remember-

0:27:29- Yeah, no, I couldn't stand them.

0:27:31I couldn't stand them.

0:27:32But for this, it was like,

0:27:33I'm gonna make this thing out of frame.

0:27:35So it was out of frames where the scroll bars spelled out oscillate, and then the scroll

0:27:42bars moved randomly up and down, so the whole thing was kind of like this pulsing scroll

0:27:47bar logo thing.

0:27:49And that was, yeah, that's one of my--yeah, I like that one a lot.

0:27:53Because it was one of those things where it was like, "I haven't seen this done, and

0:27:58people are gonna lose their shit a little bit when they see this."

0:28:01- Right.

0:28:02It's a total abuse of the purpose,

0:28:04but it's extremely clever.

0:28:05And that's a perfect example for you to recall,

0:28:09'cause that's the sort of thing that I'm calling a toy,

0:28:12that that's what we did back then, right?

0:28:14And you would figure out something like this,

0:28:17and then if it was clever like that,

0:28:18I vaguely remember that.

0:28:20I don't know if that's a false memory or not,

0:28:22but I know I read "Ossolate,"

0:28:24and I kinda think I remember it.

0:28:27I remember thinking, yeah,

0:28:28that's finally a good use of frames.

0:28:30(laughing)

0:28:32Yeah, all right.

0:28:34- I mean, the whole atmosphere back then

0:28:35was like it was so playful.

0:28:38It was so playful.

0:28:39- Oh, hold that thought.

0:28:40Let's hold that thought.

0:28:41Let me take a break here and thank our first sponsor.

0:28:43It's our very good friends who are in,

0:28:46I got an iPad in one hand reading this,

0:28:48and I've got some of their product in my right hand.

0:28:51Right now, it's our good friends at Trade Coffee.

0:28:55If you love drinking coffee every morning,

0:28:57and who doesn't, what kind of a sicko,

0:29:00You have to check out Trade Coffee.

0:29:01Trade makes it effortless to brew

0:29:03better coffee every time at home.

0:29:05Trade empowers coffee lovers to discover better coffee

0:29:08'cause it's delivered fresh to your door.

0:29:11Trade is not a roaster themselves.

0:29:14It's not like Trade is a coffee company

0:29:16and you get bags of coffee that say Trade Coffee on it.

0:29:19Trade is a coffee subscription service

0:29:21and they connect to the nation's top-rated,

0:29:25independent roasters all across the country.

0:29:28I mean, dozens and dozens and dozens.

0:29:30I've been subscribed to them for, I think,

0:29:33almost a year now at this point.

0:29:34And I don't know if I've gotten coffee

0:29:36from the same roaster twice.

0:29:38That's how many independent roasters they have,

0:29:40and that's how much variety you get from trade.

0:29:43It's a subscription service, and they make it super simple

0:29:46to both discover new coffees that are excellent

0:29:50and never run out of fresh beans at home

0:29:53without ever going shopping.

0:29:54Whether you know what you like or are new

0:29:57to specialty coffee, their website will make it easy and convenient to discover new coffees.

0:30:01They send it fresh to your home on your preferred schedule. And the scheduling flexibility,

0:30:07I can't imagine it's the exact perfect balance of it's very simple. It's a simple interface

0:30:12to figure out how often you want to get it. But it's also got all the flexibility you

0:30:18would want a bag a week, a bag every other week, a bag every three weeks. More than that,

0:30:23if you're buying coffee for an office

0:30:25or some kind of large group thing.

0:30:28Take a pause when you go on vacation.

0:30:31Adjust it on the fly.

0:30:33If you figure out, hey, I keep running out

0:30:35before I get my next bag,

0:30:37I should get it a little bit more frequently,

0:30:38or let me get it less frequently

0:30:41because I'm starting to stockpile it.

0:30:43It is so easy to manage.

0:30:45Once you sign up, you never run out of fresh coffee beans.

0:30:49And the freshness, I'm telling you,

0:30:51I always emphasize this when I talk about trade,

0:30:53It is the most important factor in coffee,

0:30:55more important than anything else.

0:30:57Coffee, roasted coffee,

0:30:59even though it doesn't look like a produce,

0:31:00it is a produce.

0:31:02And when trade coffee arrives,

0:31:04there's always a date when it was roasted,

0:31:05and it's usually three or four days

0:31:07before it's in your hands.

0:31:08It's that fresh.

0:31:09You will never get three or four day old coffee

0:31:12off the shelf in a supermarket,

0:31:14no matter how good your supermarket is.

0:31:16So upgrade your morning routine with Better Coffee.

0:31:18Right now, Trade is offering listeners a free bag of coffee

0:31:21with any subscription at www.drinktrade.com/thetalkshow.

0:31:26That's www.drinktrade.com/thetalkshow

0:31:31for a free bag of coffee with any subscription purchase.

0:31:34www.drinktrade.com/thetalkshow.

0:31:37One difference between podcasting and blogging, Jason,

0:31:43is that you gotta repeat the URL multiple times

0:31:46when you're podcasting.

0:31:47(laughing)

0:31:49- Yes, very important.

0:31:51And I think about that every time I do a sponsor read,

0:31:54which is, I don't know, nine, 10 times a month.

0:31:57Every single time, I think, "Goddamn it, if I were writing,

0:32:00"I wouldn't have to do this."

0:32:01'Cause I'll tell you, the one thing,

0:32:03I enjoy doing this show,

0:32:04and I especially enjoy doing special episodes like this.

0:32:06I'm already having a lot of fun.

0:32:08So I'm not trying to bitch and moan

0:32:10about my second job as a podcaster,

0:32:12but I will never, ever, ever, no matter how long I do this,

0:32:15and again, this is episode 370,

0:32:18and there was a whole slew of shows

0:32:20with Dan Benjamin before that that don't even count

0:32:22in the numbering.

0:32:24I will never ever not think of myself

0:32:26as a writer/blogger, whatever you wanna call

0:32:30what I do at Daring Fireball, who podcasts on the side.

0:32:33That's how I view myself.

0:32:35It doesn't matter how long I do.

0:32:37So we were talking about those early, the mid-90s

0:32:41and this sort of episodic and this sort of

0:32:43coalescence around the idea of blogging.

0:32:47And I know it has nothing to do with either of us.

0:32:50We didn't contribute.

0:32:51But for people who are either too young

0:32:54or just don't remember or weren't paying attention to it,

0:32:58it's impossible, I think, to overstate

0:33:01the influence of suck.com.

0:33:03- Oh yeah. - Right?

0:33:06Suck.com was the first thing

0:33:10that I looked at and

0:33:15Like, I'd look at things like the web toys people were making and other independent websites,

0:33:22and all I would think is, "That's fun," or "I wonder how they did it," and "View

0:33:26Source," or "Oh, I'd love to learn that trick so I could do it," you know.

0:33:31Oh, you just hover over a picture, and as soon as you hover, it substitutes a different

0:33:35picture.

0:33:36You think of all the things we could do with that, you know.

0:33:38How do you do that?

0:33:39Oh, that's how you do it.

0:33:40suck.com was the first website where I got like jealous and I thought, ah shit, I wish I was,

0:33:46I wish I were doing something like that. Yeah, I mean suck suck was a huge, like a huge influence

0:33:53on me. And you know, it was this thing where it was like, oh, this is, I don't think you could do

0:34:02this offline, what they're doing. And it was just so interesting and just so like, not only

0:34:11like the writing, but like how they were writing and how it was designed, and just like the whole

0:34:18package. It was just like, I can't believe like there are people who are like doing this like just

0:34:23in their spare time, you know, at Wired magazine or whatever, or Hotwired, I guess it was.

0:34:28Right for people who don't remember suck.com number one it

0:34:32also to me the name itself captured the

0:34:36The gestalt of our generation to gen x generation at in that mid in the 90s

0:34:45Right. It was totally

0:34:47And it wasn't

0:34:52Even though suck.com doesn't sound like a serious effort it was

0:34:58right? Like the writing was top-notch, right? Like my favorite suck.com writer

0:35:02was Heather Havrileski, who's still writing independently. Now she's, you know,

0:35:07she's floated around, she's written books, and she was at New York Magazine

0:35:12or one of the sub brands, and now she's got a subset. Still going strong as an

0:35:16independent writer, but man, when I saw her byline at suck.com, I knew it

0:35:21was gonna be good. I just loved her style. But exactly what you said, too, where

0:35:26she just instantly got a style and form of writing that had no real analog in print,

0:35:34right? Like, the hyperlinks were part of the style.

0:35:38Yeah, exactly, exactly. There was information to be gotten from not only what they linked to,

0:35:48but how they linked to it, which word they decided to make the hyperlink. It was fascinating.

0:35:54It was fascinating.

0:35:55Right. Imagine if you lived on an island where all you had were manual typewriters,

0:36:03and the only form of writing that anybody had was with a typewriter, and then somebody comes up with

0:36:13a way to do italics. Well, then you can put in flat--I use italics liberally, as in--I've always

0:36:21done it in my writing as to emphasize, you know, inflect words that I hear in my head as I'm

0:36:31writing. If I were speaking them, I would raise my voice or do something with my voice to add

0:36:36inflection to that word. And I would feel hamstrung without italics. I would feel like my writing was

0:36:46missing something. Hyperlinks are like italics on steroids, on superpowers,

0:36:54because, right, but like you're saying, like mid-sentence and something

0:36:58something suspiciously blank and if you just the word suspiciously at suck

0:37:02they might link to something and it would just be a link to who knows I

0:37:08don't know what the example is but you know you know some random thing but it

0:37:12would add context and it might not even be directly related to the subject that

0:37:16was being written about, but it would be interesting and it adds context to what they meant by

0:37:20the word suspiciously, way more than just mere italicizing it or bolding it would. And

0:37:28it adds a dimension to writing that not only didn't exist before but couldn't exist in

0:37:35print.

0:37:36Yeah, exactly. And what's interesting is that I took so much influence from that is that

0:37:43When I write my posts still, I use a text editor to write my posts, and then I paste

0:37:47them into my CMS.

0:37:49Very old school.

0:37:51And when I'm writing the posts, I insert hyperlinks as I go.

0:37:55I don't do them at the end.

0:37:57I can't do them at the end, actually.

0:37:59I have to do them while I'm thinking about how I want whatever paragraph or sentence

0:38:07or whatever to communicate.

0:38:10hyperlink is part of the communication. It is doing like part of the work of the writing,

0:38:17part of the work of the communication to the audience. And I just, I have to do it.

0:38:22Yeah, I don't know what it would be like to read Jason Kotke without hyperlinks mid-sentence.

0:38:29Yeah, I really don't. The difference though is that, or the difference between Suck and a blog,

0:38:37was that it would be like, I think Suck was, as I recall, a three—it was like Monday,

0:38:41Wednesday, Friday, I think. It was like three times a week.

0:38:45Tim Cynova Yeah, something like that.

0:38:46Michael Gentry And you would just go to the homepage,

0:38:49and if it was Wednesday, it was the Wednesday issue, episode, just, you know, but it was like

0:38:56just@suck.com. Like, you didn't really go to suck.com/—I mean, maybe they had—I guess they

0:39:03They did have archives and you could go back

0:39:05and look at the old ones, but the point was really,

0:39:08you would just go to, you'd just type suck.com

0:39:11in your browser and read the homepage,

0:39:13and the homepage only had that episode.

0:39:15You could click a link to get to the archive,

0:39:18but it wasn't a scrolling list of,

0:39:20oh, just keep scrolling down and you get to Monday

0:39:23and then you scroll down and you get to last Friday

0:39:25and you scroll down.

0:39:26And it was the nature of Suck.

0:39:30I can't even imagine if Suck were that way.

0:39:33you know it had a very like I said I was I've always been obsessed with form in in media

0:39:40so that gave suck a form it was like you'd go to the home page and there'd be a new article

0:39:46three times a week and that's where you read it on the home page and then you'd close it and

0:39:51you know go to the next bookmark in your favorite sites and see what else was there and until you

0:39:56were done dicking around on the web for the session you know or until somebody yeah until

0:40:02somebody picked up the telephone in another room and kicked you off line.

0:40:05There you go.

0:40:07Yeah.

0:40:08But the revolution and the coalescence is in

0:40:13blogging and it seems so obvious now it's, you know, here we are a quarter century later

0:40:18and it's, you know, it's hard to imagine that it had to be invented.

0:40:24But it is like that, that Justin Hall, the robot wisdom

0:40:29style, new stuff at the top, old stuff at the bottom, and it just scrolls down.

0:40:36And I remember when it first started becoming a thing, kind of objecting to it because it seemed

0:40:49like it, or if not objecting to it, being confused or wondering whether it should go top down or

0:40:58bottom up, right? Because a newspaper, which is a better example than a magazine, because a magazine

0:41:04you page, but a newspaper, a broadsheet is tall and goes down and the important articles are at

0:41:12the top and the less important articles are at the bottom, you know, by the editors or whoever

0:41:17did the layout judgment. And it seemed counterintuitive to me, like, that it's just,

0:41:26if you're gonna go chronological, should it go top down or bottom up?

0:41:29And then it also seemed counterintuitive to me that it's always just newest at the top,

0:41:35whether it was more or less important. It had no—it was simply chronological. And it took me a long

0:41:43time—it took me a long time to accept that, no, this fits the web. It just chronological fits the

0:41:51web. And I'm wondering when you noticed that, and if that's when you shifted from oscillate to,

0:41:59"Hey, I should make a new thing."

0:42:01>> Yeah, I think that mirrors a lot of what I was thinking at the time. Because in retrospect,

0:42:08yeah, like chronologically is the way to do it, because blogs got people in the habit of checking

0:42:15sites more frequently. And then, of course, RSS came along and it became just sort of another

0:42:22kind of inbox, I guess, that people would check. And you could check it dozens of times a day if

0:42:28you wanted to. Just flick over to your RSS reader and, "Oh, John's got something new."

0:42:33So it kind of developed and also developed its habits in the audience as it went along.

0:42:40So chronological became the natural way to do it because you'd already read the important stuff

0:42:47down the page earlier in the day, and you just want to catch up on whatever's the newest.

0:42:52You know, it's not an ideal thing. And I think that when you see templates on Ghost and things

0:42:58like that and WordPress and things like that, you see less purely chronological ordering.

0:43:05you can call out featured posts and things like that. It looks more like an online magazine or

0:43:11an online newspaper where, like you said earlier, it's like the important stuff is at the top

0:43:17and the less important stuff is further down. But that chronological thing was like,

0:43:21or the reverse crown was the thing that really made it take off in a way because it trained

0:43:33the audience to basically come by more often. And I count myself in that part of the audience. It's

0:43:37not like I'm pulling any master strings here. It's just like we all did it at the same time

0:43:42as we went along. And eventually it's like when sites like Gizmodo and Gawker and Engadget came

0:43:52out, they were doing 30, 40, 50 items a day. And people were like, "Okay, more. Let's go."

0:44:00Oh, well, but I'm just curious what made you think, though, to switch from you doing it under

0:44:08oscillating to striking a new brand at kotkey.org. Right, so what became kotkey.org started at

0:44:18oscillate as an episode. It was like, oh, I'm going to keep a blog and do this. And it wasn't until

0:44:23maybe a year and a half later where I shifted those sort of archives over to sort of over to

0:44:28its own domain. And, you know, I think it just, you know, from the perspective of it was just

0:44:35way easier to update, you know, like making episodes it was like, okay, I gotta sit down,

0:44:40I gotta have an idea, and then I've gotta do this whole thing. It was just so easy to like,

0:44:44oh, I'm just gonna pull up a, you know, a new, you know, back in the old days it was like I had a

0:44:49file, like I had an HTML file that I would just, I would directly edit it on the server. At the end,

0:44:54when it was done, like, I would save it, you know, and that was it.

0:44:58Did you edit directly on the server, or did you edit locally, double-check, and then upload?

0:45:03Jim Kudall.

0:45:04No, no, it was on the server, I think, for longer than it should have been.

0:45:09Jim Kudall and I have talked about this, and we both felt that in that era, we did better writing

0:45:18when we were writing directly on the server, because it raised your—it, like,

0:45:23straightened your back and squared your shoulders. Right? Because it's—

0:45:27That raises the stakes, right?

0:45:28Right. I always think about the way that in the entire Star Wars universe,

0:45:32all the architecture is skyscraper-y or chasmy, and there are walkways on every planet,

0:45:40and there's never a railing. Right? You know what I mean?

0:45:48And that was blogging directly from production, right?

0:45:51Exactly. It's blogging directly from production is walking on any of those catwalks on Bespin

0:45:58or the place where Obi-Wan and Qui-Gon Jinn fought the Darth Maul and the prequel.

0:46:06It's just any one of those things. All the TV shows, they all keep it up. To me,

0:46:13it's one of my favorite traditions in science fiction is anywhere where there's a walkway in

0:46:17Star Wars. No railings. It's like, where are the regulators? Are there any regulators in the Star

0:46:25Wars universe? No, none! Right, it's like a—there's a fantastic essay in there about the libertarian

0:46:32nature of safety regulations in the Star Wars universe, but that's what it felt like. And,

0:46:38you know, it keeps you careful, you know what I mean? You're more likely to trip and fall

0:46:44on a nice safe catwalk with nice safe railings than you are on a catwalk without railings,

0:46:49and that was saving websites directly to production. I still edit things,

0:46:54some things on Daring Fireball directly on the website, and it keeps you sharp.

0:46:59Yep. You know, it's interesting though, because I still feel like,

0:47:03I don't know, I've been doing this for almost 25 years now, with Oscillate even before that,

0:47:09Like, I still feel like when I publish something sometimes I was like, "Why am I allowed to do this?

0:47:15I just push a button and it's out there, and, you know, hundreds of people read it in, like,

0:47:20the next three minutes or whatever, you know, because everyone's on RSS."

0:47:24And it just seems insane to me sometimes, like, when you actually, like, you know,

0:47:27it's one of those things where if you actually think about how things work in the world,

0:47:32like, you're like, "Oh my god, I can't believe how this works!"

0:47:34And this is, like, one of those things. It seems insane to me that, like, I can push a button and

0:47:39and all of a sudden around the world,

0:47:41everyone can read this instantly.

0:47:42- I totally agree.

0:47:45Who else was an inspiration for you?

0:47:47Dave Weiner is obvious, you know,

0:47:50and helped formulate the top-down chronological nature

0:47:55of blogging in the mid-90s.

0:47:59He's been doing scripting.com for at least,

0:48:02I think, as long as, or longer than you.

0:48:05- Yeah, longer, I think, yeah.

0:48:07- Yeah, and no surprise that he invented RSS,

0:48:11which is a chronic, by nature,

0:48:14I think best suited to be consumed chronologically.

0:48:18I mean, you cannot, I mean, part of the beauty of RSS

0:48:21is if you wanted to, you could somehow do something

0:48:23with it that's not, but it, you know, RSS in a sense

0:48:26is just a chronological, it's the blogging format

0:48:31in a more, in a structured--

0:48:34- Yeah, exactly.

0:48:36non-visual data stream format. And so it's no surprise that he invented that. You mentioned

0:48:42robot wisdom. Well, what were you saying? Sorry, I was just going to say, like on Dave,

0:48:47I'm not a regular scripting news reader anymore. But I went, I don't know, a few weeks ago,

0:48:52and he has still got a great blogging voice. It's kind of that combination between he can write,

0:49:00And it's also very casual. I mean, all writing is casual now, or most writing is casual.

0:49:06Twitter has sort of trained everybody to be this sort of very casual, but his voice is still great.

0:49:13JS You can hear it. I can hear it.

0:49:16JS Yeah, and it's funny because he came to it, he used to write—what I should do is get him on the

0:49:20show, and I've long been thinking about it—but much like Oscillate, he had written before

0:49:27scripting dot com and sort of overlapping with it these columns called Dave net for hot wire

0:49:33and they were more like traditional columns like a Dave net was like a whole article and

0:49:40it wasn't a blog but he was full of hyperlinks and it was super exuberant about the open web and full

0:49:51of ideas. But it's like he went on that same path where it's like he intuitively knew that writing

0:49:59like a once or twice a week column wasn't for him and it wasn't what he was meant to do.

0:50:07The scripting.com, also nobody else has ever blogged like Dave Weiner except

0:50:19the people who've used his blogging engine tools or CMSs, which were always meant to

0:50:26publish a Dave Weiner-style blog, but nobody else has his unique sense of timing and length

0:50:35of items. In a way, Scripting.com remains the oldest school of old-school blogs because

0:50:43his entries are mostly still just paragraphs. They're not, there's not, not headline plus

0:50:51paragraph. And it's, you know, he rants, he's ranted about it on and off for years, and he's

0:50:57right because he invented RSS, but he, you know, huge frustration for him are RSS readers that

0:51:05assume every entry has a title or a headline or whatever you want to call it. And he invented RSS

0:51:12knowing his own style and knowing that whatever the element—I forget if it's—I think it's title.

0:51:20It's like inside the entry item or it's inside a thing called item is a thing called title. And

0:51:26it's marked optional very, very, very obviously in this spec. But it's a very old-school style,

0:51:33which you used to have too, right? Like in the early days of Kottke, posts were paragraphs,

0:51:39not headline, you know, not articles or items or whatever you want to call them.

0:51:44Yeah, the reason why I started doing headlines is because of RSS. Otherwise, I

0:51:50don't necessarily think I would have. And, you know, I mean, I side with Dave on

0:51:55this. If it were better for RSS and that sort of stuff, like, I would use a

0:51:59lot fewer titles. And, you know, with the Quick Links now,

0:52:03like, that's what that is again. It's sort of a return to this titleless,

0:52:08you know, these titleless posts. Well, and you know, the reason I started doing those is because

0:52:13it works well on Twitter and Mastodon and Facebook and stuff. It's a little nugget with one link that

0:52:20you can send across social media sort of the same way, you know. I was about to say that the odd

0:52:27thing about it in the way that like, I think it's a truism for all of humanity. I mean, not just

0:52:35them our modern age but go back as far in history as we can, that good ideas resurface.

0:52:43And sometimes good ideas don't strike, right? It's somehow the matchbook got wet and it

0:52:51could have, but something happened, the match just isn't going to strike. It's going to

0:52:57resurface. And titleless blog posts never really stuck. Dave has stuck with them, but

0:53:04for the most part, almost nobody else does it anymore. But what what are tweets other

0:53:12than short titleist blog posts, right? That the idea resurface and it's become

0:53:19another one of those media or forms, whatever you want to call it, that's now

0:53:27so established that people forget it had to be invented. But that's all the

0:53:32tweets are. And with Mastodon and its variable character length limits, right? I think

0:53:38the standard out-of-the-box limit is 500 characters. It might be something else.

0:53:46CB Something like that.

0:53:47JS But because it's open source software and it's part of the,

0:53:50some instances of Mastodon have different character limits, but that's only enforced on

0:54:00the post from that server. But, you know, let's just say, but for the sake of argument and putting

0:54:07the pedantry aside, 500 characters, no title, right? It's just a 500-character blob of text

0:54:15that could be and generally often is—I would bet the average Mastodon post is still,

0:54:22or at least the people I follow, is within Twitter's 280 characters, right? It's just,

0:54:28you know? A thought. It's like the length of one thought, no title. You could do a whole,

0:54:37I think you could do a whole like 40-minute presentation at a conference on the

0:54:44psychology of not having to create a title for a post. Because it seems you would think at first,

0:54:53and most people and maybe people who don't tweet a lot or aren't writers and are just readers and

0:54:59consumers would think well that doesn't seem difficult and you know most of the things you

0:55:04read have maybe seemingly obvious titles that are just sort of descriptive and maybe you know

0:55:10certain you know written to help you understand it so isn't that obvious but I it is it is like an

0:55:17I don't know how to describe it but it is psychologically as a someone who writes such

0:55:22things. It is huge. If I had to have titles for tweets, I would have tweeted and I would continue

0:55:29Mastodon posting one tenth, one fiftieth. I don't know. I don't know that I would have ever even--I

0:55:36don't think the thing ever would have taken off. I don't think it ever would have gotten off the

0:55:40ground. Yeah. Yeah, I mean, it's interesting, the titles thing, because--so you've got what you've

0:55:47So the way that I do it is I've got what I've written,

0:55:51and then you somehow in the title also have to say what you've written,

0:55:56but you don't want to necessarily say it again in the same way as you did in the text of the thing.

0:56:03And then I also have to, so each of my main posts also has some tweet text,

0:56:10and that's the text that goes out on social media.

0:56:13So, I have to rewrite what I wrote in the title and in the piece.

0:56:19I also have to do it in less than 250 characters or whatever it is with the link.

0:56:24So it's like I'm trying to write the same thing three times with three different content

0:56:30links, and sometimes it is the last thing that I want to do.

0:56:35I'm like, "Fuck this.

0:56:36I just want to write the thing that I want to write and then move on."

0:56:40and I don't want to have to think of the stupid title.

0:56:42(laughing)

0:56:44- There's, it's possible we might be heading towards,

0:56:47by the time you and I finish up this racket,

0:56:50we might be heading towards a time

0:56:51where you could just do that and, you know,

0:56:54some kind of open AI type thing

0:56:55could do the summary for you, the tweet length summary.

0:56:59- Oh, there you go.

0:56:59- I mean, 'cause that's the sort of thing

0:57:01that these goddamn bots are good at, right?

0:57:04Doing, using them to produce summaries is shocking.

0:57:08I don't want to go on a side rant about what's impressive

0:57:11and surprising about these open AIs,

0:57:14but their ability to summarize is incredible.

0:57:17- Have you looked at any of these AI things

0:57:19and put your stuff in there and see what it makes of it?

0:57:21Hey, I'm gonna give you this post, can you summarize it?

0:57:24- No, I haven't really, 'cause I'm a little--

0:57:26- Yeah, I haven't done it either.

0:57:28- No, I've asked them what they think of me.

0:57:30- What did they--

0:57:34- Oh, it's super boring.

0:57:36They just steal from Wikipedia and say that I'm a writer, blogger.

0:57:40Actually, they're a little better.

0:57:41Actually, I think that the Bing chatbot has a better, in my opinion,

0:57:45a better brief two, three sentence bio of me than Wikipedia does.

0:57:52I forget the difference,

0:57:53but it seems to me to fit more my mental model of what I should be known for.

0:57:59But I miss the boat on the thing where the Bing one could be

0:58:04tricked into revealing the Sidney character

0:58:07behind the scenes.

0:58:08I really am so mad that I missed the boat.

0:58:11It was like, there was like this two day window

0:58:13and Kevin Roos of the New York Times,

0:58:16he's the guy who, Sidney said he should leave his wife

0:58:21and start a relationship with her.

0:58:24Ben Thompson got into an argument with Sidney

0:58:28and she told him he was a bad researcher

0:58:32and that she was gonna report him to her developers

0:58:35and get him kicked off the service.

0:58:37Wow, right.

0:58:38- Hard truth there.

0:58:39- I missed the boat on that, but no, with my tweets,

0:58:43I have to rewrite, and it's overdue,

0:58:45and again, I'm a chronic procrastinator.

0:58:47I mean, just take a look at Daring Fireball.

0:58:49I hand wrote my own Tweetbot, not Tweetbot the app,

0:58:52but my bot that tweets my articles.

0:58:55It runs on a crontask on my server,

0:58:58reads my RSS feed, and waits.

0:59:00This is part of the cleverness,

0:59:02I hand wrote it. It waits until they're at least five minutes old before it will auto tweet them.

0:59:08So if it happens, if the cron task happens to be up, the five-minute interval is up right after

0:59:15I publish, it won't tweet it because it gives me five minutes to quick fix any obvious typos,

0:59:24or if I accidentally publish before I actually meant to, or something like that. So it runs

0:59:30every five minutes, but all mine does is tweet the headline and then the URL. And the other reason

0:59:40that I wrote my own, and it's way less important now that Twitter has 280 characters, but some of

0:59:47my headlines, it's like a shtick, as I'm sure you've noticed. It's like once or twice a year,

0:59:54I will write a multi 100 character headline and you know along the lines inspired by our mutual

1:00:04hero David Foster Wallace and that sort of you know I don't know what you would even call it

1:00:09a shtick it for lack of a better word I'm sure he'd have a better word for it but I you know it

1:00:15there are many new not many but numerous posts in Daring Fireballs history that the combination

1:00:22of headline plus URL, even a shortened URL would not fit in 140 characters,

1:00:27and I wanted to write my own algorithm to truncate the headline. So of course I wrote my own thing.

1:00:33I have to update it from Astadon. I've been putting that off. That won't take much longer,

1:00:36but all I do is the headline. But I have noticed that you, yours are like handcrafted summaries,

1:00:44and I was curious. I actually was curious about it. So that's like, what is that, another field

1:00:49in movable type or?

1:00:51- Yeah, exactly.

1:00:52So I just use another field and then, you know,

1:00:54I have a custom, you know, tweet thing that I wrote

1:00:57that pushes it out to Twitter.

1:01:00And then actually I have a Zapier,

1:01:03I have a Zap like a Zapier or Zapier that reads the tweet

1:01:07and then posts it to Facebook.

1:01:09'Cause the Facebook API stuff is a little bit like,

1:01:12I don't know, I just didn't want to go there.

1:01:14And then I recently updated it for Mastodon.

1:01:16So it's doing the same thing there.

1:01:18So did you--

1:01:19- And the reason I did it is that

1:01:21I just didn't wanna use the title

1:01:24because I felt like the titles really didn't do that well

1:01:29on Twitter.

1:01:29It wasn't enticing people to click through.

1:01:33I wanted a little bit more explanation

1:01:35and I wanted to show a little bit more

1:01:36of what you're actually getting yourself into

1:01:38if you wanna click on the link.

1:01:41And I don't know, I just think they work a little bit better

1:01:44than just titles.

1:01:45It's worth sort of the extra effort.

1:01:46they come across as the way someone would hand tweet a link

1:01:51or that you would hand tweet a link to the thing.

1:01:56- Yep.

1:01:57- All right, I'm gonna keep going on this front about Kraft,

1:02:01but let me take another break here

1:02:03and thank our next sponsor.

1:02:05Sorry, good friends at KOLIDE, K-O-L-I-D-E.

1:02:11KOLIDE has some big news.

1:02:13If you're an Okta user,

1:02:16they can get your entire fleet to 100% compliance.

1:02:19How?

1:02:20Well, if a device isn't compliant,

1:02:22the user can't log into your cloud apps

1:02:24until they've fixed the problem.

1:02:25It's that simple.

1:02:26Collide patches one of the major holes

1:02:29in zero trust architecture, device compliance.

1:02:32Without Collide, IT struggles to solve basic problems

1:02:35like keeping everyone's OS and browser up to date,

1:02:38unsecured devices are logging into your company's apps

1:02:41because there's nothing there to stop them.

1:02:43Collide is the only device trust solution

1:02:46that enforces compliance as part of authentication

1:02:49and it's built to work seamlessly with Okta.

1:02:53The moment Collide's agent detects a problem,

1:02:55it alerts the user and gives them instructions to fix it.

1:02:59If they don't fix the problem within a set time,

1:03:01they're blocked.

1:03:02That's it.

1:03:03Collide's method means fewer support tickets,

1:03:05less frustration, and more importantly,

1:03:08100% fleet compliance.

1:03:11Visit collide.com/thetalkshow to learn more or book a demo.

1:03:16That's K-O-L-I-D-E.com/thetalkshow.

1:03:22All right, I broke the seal on movable type.

1:03:26My joke for this episode was that I've collected

1:03:29and we've got here in a group chat

1:03:32the entire world user base of the movable type CMS

1:03:36all on one podcast.

1:03:40- Yeah, we're all here.

1:03:41- I'm not sure that that's entirely true.

1:03:45Off the top of my head, I can't think of any friends

1:03:48who are still using it.

1:03:50I think kudal.com still runs it,

1:03:52but they don't really update the blog part

1:03:55of kudal.com anymore.

1:03:56They're really more focused.

1:03:58- Yeah, they don't.

1:03:59- They're more focused on field notes,

1:04:01and I don't think the field notes stuff,

1:04:03I don't think that runs on movable type.

1:04:05I could check with Jim, but just about everybody--

1:04:08what, six colors used to, but not anymore?

1:04:11- You know, I actually, I should,

1:04:13I always, this comes up with Jason Snell.

1:04:15Six colors definitely moved to WordPress,

1:04:17but I believe that Jason's, the incomparable podcast empire

1:04:22might still run on movable type.

1:04:26And in fact, I'm almost certain, I think so.

1:04:31Anyway, so he's got something still going with it.

1:04:34Our mutual friend, Greg Kanouse, is that how you,

1:04:37I honest to God don't know how to pronounce his fucking certain.

1:04:40I think it's Greg Nouse.

1:04:41Nouse.

1:04:42Just Nouse.

1:04:42Well, it's Canouse when you spell it.

1:04:44It is.

1:04:45But he is actually a friend and I don't know how to pronounce his goddamn surname.

1:04:50I guess I continually forget.

1:04:52I always say this,

1:04:56my problem is when I became a voracious reader as a youth,

1:04:59I didn't want to ask my parents how to pronounce words.

1:05:02So when I'd encounter a new word,

1:05:03I'd pronounce it in my head,

1:05:05And my brain was jelly back then, but my brain is now cement and all of those,

1:05:10how I guessed as a child to pronounce certain words are cemented in my head.

1:05:15And B, I also, for anything I need to learn how to spell,

1:05:22I somehow in my mind memorize a phonetic spelling.

1:05:25And that's why I, of course,

1:05:27of course his name isn't pronounced Kanous, of course not, right?

1:05:30Although Gary Gnu was Gary Gnu.

1:05:32no good news is good good news with yeah gary i love the i love that we're talking about

1:05:40what is it the great space coaster yeah the great space the name of the show gary

1:05:44new that's great yeah a prototypical carry the yeah prototypical gary ganou with the ganous

1:05:50yeah prototypical youtuber pretty much oh it was sort of like weekend update for kids really i

1:05:59I guess is a better way to say it.

1:06:00But yeah, in my head,

1:06:02and of course his name isn't pronounced Canals,

1:06:04but in my head it's Canals

1:06:06'cause that way I know how to spell it.

1:06:07But anyway, he's still a movable type expert.

1:06:09Or I'll just ask why,

1:06:12'cause people ask me all the time.

1:06:14- I mean, at this point,

1:06:17I've kind of bolted so many things onto it

1:06:20that changing would not only mean changing

1:06:22sort of like regular CMS things,

1:06:24but also all sorts of different other things.

1:06:27I took, you know, earlier, actually last year,

1:06:30I took a couple of really hard looks at Ghost

1:06:34to figure out if I could make that thing

1:06:37do what I wanted it to.

1:06:40And it's there in a lot of ways.

1:06:43And I think in some ways it's just, you know,

1:06:45it's Ghost is something, you know,

1:06:47like Substack or whatever, it's built around, you know,

1:06:51it's sort of built around like longer articles with titles.

1:06:55That seems to be the direction that we're heading in.

1:06:57Like we're, it's, it's almost come full circle in that, you know, before blogs,

1:07:01like everyone wrote things with articles with titles or whatever.

1:07:05And now it's like, we're back there with the newsletter thing.

1:07:08You have, you know, three articles that come out every week and, and that's,

1:07:12that's the deal, but like, that's not where I want to move to.

1:07:15Like I want to move, if anything, I want to move back more towards, you know,

1:07:20more of a Twitter vibe than a sub stack vibe, you know what I mean?

1:07:24just like on my personal end.

1:07:27And I just don't think Ghost,

1:07:30I think you can probably do it because it's extensible

1:07:34and open source and all that sort of stuff.

1:07:36And you can write all of this stuff around it,

1:07:38but a lot of my stuff is in Perl and PHP still,

1:07:42'cause I'm stuck in the amber of the early 2000s,

1:07:46technologically speaking.

1:07:48- A lot of your stuff or all of your stuff?

1:07:52I would say probably all of it.

1:07:54There's some JavaScript stuff going on,

1:07:57but not a ton of it.

1:07:58- Yeah.

1:07:59The only thing I have that's not written in PHP or Perl,

1:08:02and I'm in the exact same situation with you,

1:08:04and I've often described my movable type setup as,

1:08:07my analogy is Han Solo's description

1:08:09of the Millennium Falcon that I've made.

1:08:11She may not look like much,

1:08:15but she's got it where it counts.

1:08:16I forget the exact quote, but I may--

1:08:17- Yeah, yeah, exactly.

1:08:18- But the key part is,

1:08:20I've made a lot of special modifications myself.

1:08:23- Exactly.

1:08:25- And combining with the fact that Han Solo

1:08:28doesn't seem exactly like the sharpest mechanic

1:08:32in the galaxy.

1:08:33And this shit keeps breaking down.

1:08:37And it isn't exactly a bulletproof architecture,

1:08:41but it's really cool shit, right?

1:08:44Like the stupid little gun that can come out

1:08:46and shoot some stormtroopers if they come out

1:08:48before you take off.

1:08:49that's my movable type.

1:08:50My movable type and my publishing system

1:08:53doesn't resemble the out of the box movable, and never did.

1:08:57I mean, from day one, didn't really resemble

1:09:01out of the box movable type.

1:09:03It's, to me, it's a static website.

1:09:06It's not a publisher,

1:09:07and the public never touches movable type.

1:09:10It was a static web generator before that was even a term.

1:09:16And there's a, if it's not broke,

1:09:19don't fix it part. There's the I know Pearl and Pearl. I wouldn't recommend it. I've never

1:09:26been a Pearl evangelist, but the way my brain works as a programmer, it's the language that

1:09:31best suits the wavelengths of my brain. And PHP is just stupid Pearl, in my opinion. You

1:09:42know what? Let me take that back. Well, let me put that back. Let me take that back because

1:09:46Because I know that PHP has continued to evolve and there's modern PHP with all of this object-oriented

1:09:52stuff and the language has evolved, but the original PHP was even advertised as stupid

1:10:02Perl.

1:10:03And that's why there's dollar signs in front of the variables and stuff like that.

1:10:06So the way I write PHP is just I write it almost like Perl and then just keep banging

1:10:12head against the way that of it this would be easy in pearl but you know to put a regular expression

1:10:17in php it has to be in a string and so i've got a backslash escape on blah blah blah the only thing

1:10:21i've done that's not php or pearl is way back when custom link shorteners were a thing i i didn't want

1:10:28to use bitly because of course i wanted to do it myself and i wrote and i wrote my own link

1:10:35shortener and I had I even had a fancy domain name with the star in it it was

1:10:41DF and then the Unicode symbol for a star dot us which I don't remember that

1:10:47and I thought that was the fucking shit I just like damn that is sweet DF and

1:10:54then a Unicode star dot us well guess what it broke in just about everybody

1:11:02else's CMS's you know it was all over the place and a oh and the other thing

1:11:07it really broke were this I remember why I changed the biggest reason it broke

1:11:13wasn't CMS's it was link detectors so in other words you know anything that where

1:11:19you paste a URL into plain text and it automatically link affies the link you

1:11:25know and most URLs are easy to determine all of the almost all of them broke

1:11:30because that star character didn't look like a character and they were using

1:11:35everybody was using regular expressions and irregular expressions broke yeah and

1:11:39I would go to people because I'm so my weird bizarre super talent and

1:11:44programming is creating regular expressions I have a gist that is like

1:11:48one of the most popular just out there of a liberal it just a regular

1:11:54expression but it's like this huge crazy long regular expression to match URLs

1:11:58And it's pretty good. There's better ways now

1:12:00And in fact mine has some bugs where you can put a bad URL at it and it'll get caught in an infinite loop in

1:12:06Some like in Python or something like that

1:12:08But anyway, hmm, I would send people a better URL that would help match the star

1:12:13But it didn't help and I was like, alright

1:12:15I give up and I but I couldn't find a good to some I my the one I the long-term domain I settled on was

1:12:22for dot us because I couldn't get something better or no my my ones with the fancy Unicode weren't dot us they were dot

1:12:30ws which I don't even know what that stands for but it was one of the few top it was but the reason I went with

1:12:36Ws was a it was two characters and B

1:12:39It was one of the few top-level domains that would accept a Unicode character in

1:12:44The string of the domain itself most wouldn't like you couldn't register

1:12:49DF star.com you just the.com wouldn't accept it for the good reason that it doesn't really work. So I

1:12:57but anyway, I wrote my custom link unshortener in Sinatra, which is Ruby and it's it. Oh,

1:13:06it's and I taught myself Ruby just because I at the time and I guess I don't know what was this

1:13:11like 2008, 2009. My brain was just quite not cement enough that I could—I felt like I could

1:13:19learn a new language. And so I wrote the whole thing myself in Sinatra with Ruby, and I was like,

1:13:24"Hey, I could tell that this is joyful. I can see why people love this Ruby language. This is a lot

1:13:29of fun." And then I wrote it, and then I fixed the bugs, and then I've left it running. I literally—I

1:13:35haven't restarted or touched that. It runs on a different server, of course, because it has to

1:13:40answer the DF for that us domain Sinatra is awesome because it just runs and

1:13:45runs and runs and you never have to kick it kick the tires or do anything but

1:13:50I've completely forgotten everything about how it works I don't even know I

1:13:54don't know the line oh I've completely forgotten everything about Ruby I've

1:13:57completely forgotten how you actually make Sinatra work so if it ever does

1:14:01break I don't even know if I know how to restart yeah and in hindsight do you

1:14:05even though like the login.

1:14:06- Oh, I do, I should check.

1:14:09I'm actually, one thing I'm good at pack ratting

1:14:12are passwords, so I'm pretty sure I've got the login,

1:14:14but it's not gonna work.

1:14:15But anyway, I'm in the same boat.

1:14:18I've looked at other things, Matt Mullenweg,

1:14:21you know Matt, right?

1:14:22I mean, you've got to.

1:14:23One of the great mentions of the entire world,

1:14:28one of the best people I've ever met,

1:14:30creator of WordPress, which he forked from something else,

1:14:34He'd be the first person to admit but and and CEO of the whole WordPress tumbler slash whatever else they've got under their umbrella

1:14:41I'm sure I bet they still have it going. I don't know like

1:14:44six seven eight years ago he and me and um, oh Malek went to a Yankees playoff game and

1:14:52Matt told me at this game

1:14:55It's just the three of us that he'd he'd had a team build a clone of daring fireball at WordPress in

1:15:02WordPress that looks just you know just just like daring fire home and just uses

1:15:07the RSS feed to keep it populated and he's anytime you want to switch over

1:15:11just to say the word and I'm like that's you know that's very nice of you but my

1:15:16problem with that is I don't know I would never I don't like it's not that I

1:15:19don't like WordPress it's just that I know that I would never figure out how

1:15:22it works under the hood it's very very complex I've looked at it I and I it

1:15:27wouldn't therefore I wouldn't be able to do my own weird things my special modifications yeah exactly

1:15:33yeah and the other way I always describe my site is you know it's held together by bailing wire but

1:15:40it's it it's so like the the fact that it's like a flat file generator and you can generate any

1:15:46type of flat file you want including like php so you can generate files that are gonna then

1:15:52do other things. It's just it's so it's so flexible and so once you get your brain around it,

1:16:00which is, you know, my brain has been around it for for years and years now, it is just it's so

1:16:06powerful. That's exactly how daring fireball works. It is it. I go through movable type,

1:16:12which is written in pearl and I publish and it spits out PHP files and those PHP files based

1:16:20on a template have I mostly use PHP as like a fancy server side include and

1:16:26they just include things like the sidebar and the thing at the top and so

1:16:32if I want to make a change like I want to add which I will do soon once I get

1:16:38my bot updated a mastodon link in my sidebar in addition to or perhaps

1:16:43replacing the Twitter link I'll just update one file which is my sidebar and

1:16:48and it'll instantly appear on all my pages.

1:16:51I don't have to do the movable type republish thing,

1:16:54which is like the was back in the day,

1:16:57the big knock against it.

1:16:58'Cause everything that could be a server side include

1:17:00is just a server side include that I do in PHP.

1:17:03And then I have a little bit of other stuff

1:17:05that I do in PHP to make things dynamic

1:17:08or something like that.

1:17:09But yeah, and the whole world's moved on

1:17:12in I don't know what web's,

1:17:14the Node.js thing does, I don't understand it.

1:17:17really don't. I don't understand how it works. I don't. I don't get it. I don't understand the

1:17:21concept. Whereas Apache, I totally understand. I think that's what Ghost is written in, right?

1:17:29Yeah, I think so, yeah.

1:17:30So when I was looking at Ghost, I was like, okay, so I'm going to have to learn Node.js,

1:17:33it works in the browser, but it's also on the backend. And I was just like, okay,

1:17:39this is a lot for me, I think. Brain stuck in cement.

1:17:43Right. So as a thing that just spits out flat text files, right, and movable type therefore,

1:17:50and you can have it emit as many for a post, as many flat text files behind the scenes as you

1:17:57want. So I've always had this trick where it spits out a .php file, but nobody ever sees those .php

1:18:05URLs. I use Apache Turkareach so that it looks like that's not there.

1:18:10Yep.

1:18:11but you can add .txt, .txt, to any Daring Fireball URL, and you can see it in Markdown format,

1:18:20which is plain text. That's not done dynamically. So every time I publish any article, it spits out

1:18:26whatever the slug .php and whatever the slug .txt. The .php files get served without any extension,

1:18:37and if you try using the extension it'll just redirect you to to the URL without that dot PHP

1:18:43and the dot text just gets served as text slash plain or is it plain dot text I think it's text

1:18:49text slash plane as the content type and right you know and it is a template though so it you know

1:18:57it's not just the dump of the markdown format there's you know a little bit of formatting and

1:19:04I've got my name in there and the headline has the exact right number of equal signs underlining it

1:19:11to make a markdown h1, you know, which of course I did with a fancy regular expression. But, you

1:19:20know, but basically I just use movable type as a front end to spitting out text files. And it's,

1:19:27it remains, that's my, my, when people are like, how can you still be using this ancient technology?

1:19:34it works perfectly for for my needs. Yep. So there there so ends the movable type

1:19:39user group meetup. Yeah, the meetup of every single person. You know it's bad when Anil

1:19:47stopped using it, right? Or not bad, but yeah, because again, I don't think it's bad. I'm not

1:19:51I'm not in the least bit embarrassed that I use it because like I said, it fits and it's so funny

1:19:55that you and I use it the same way. But you know, we're the last one standing or nearly so when Anil

1:20:01switched. Yeah, because yeah, exactly. Guy used to be an executive. It's six apart.

1:20:06It's six apart. Yeah, exactly. Yeah, I think he's on ghost now. Maybe. I don't know. I think so. I

1:20:11think he is actually. So here we are 25 years in. I'm trying to think what else there is in there.

1:20:16So the one difference, one difference between over the decade, can you believe it's decades

1:20:22between decades between me and you is you've changed your design from time to time.

1:20:29and I not so much, but it does seem like you change it less frequently. I mean, I think that's pretty

1:20:38clear. I think, you know, and I looked back when you I mentioned previously on the show, your 10th

1:20:44anniversary post and your 10th anniversary post, I swear to God, I've got it noted here, it's going

1:20:49to be in the show notes, is great both to hear your thoughts a mere 10 years in and because what

1:20:58you did in that 10-year anniversary post was collect screenshot or—and post—screenshots of

1:21:04all of the designs of kottke.org theretofore. And there, you know, and there were all over the

1:21:11place, right? It's not, you know—so I'm curious to hear your thoughts about that. And, you know,

1:21:15the fact that you did change it so wildly in the early years and the fact that it's seemingly

1:21:22slowed down to some degree.

1:21:23>> Yeah, I think sort of the experimentation in the early days was sort of a leftover from

1:21:31Oscillate. And one of the reasons I started blogging was that I wanted something, like I

1:21:41wanted content to design around. Like the designing bit was the thing that I was kind of excited about.

1:21:49And it was fun to come up with different ways to present, you know, the...

1:21:55like different ways to design blogs. And I think as time has gone on, the actual blogging

1:22:03piece has gotten to be more important. This is the thing that I'm interested in doing,

1:22:08this is the thing that people are here for. You know, I'm sure the same thing with your site.

1:22:13A lot of people don't even go to the site, they just read it through RSS. You know,

1:22:18I'll hear a comment every once in a while,

1:22:20it's, "Oh, I haven't been to your site

1:22:21in a couple of years."

1:22:22I'm like, "Really?

1:22:24Never clicked through?"

1:22:25And now it's just part of the flip side, I think,

1:22:28of having sort of a bailing wire situation

1:22:31on the backend with movable type

1:22:32is that it becomes more and more difficult

1:22:34as you bolt more and more things onto it

1:22:37to redesign or rework how things function.

1:22:40And that's kind of where I am right now.

1:22:42I came back, I took a sabbatical last year

1:22:45from May until, what was it, October, November?

1:22:49No, December, actually.

1:22:50- You tell me, you're the one who took the sabbatical.

1:22:53- Yeah, exactly, I can't even remember.

1:22:55It's like eternal sunshine of the spotless mind here.

1:22:58It's like I've just,

1:22:58it's completely, completely gone from my brain.

1:23:01But when I came back, one of the things was this like,

1:23:03oh, like this thing, how this,

1:23:07not so much how it looks, but like how it functions,

1:23:10how it works is a little,

1:23:11getting to be a little bit long in the tooth.

1:23:14And I've been a little frustrated with it since I came back.

1:23:17But at the same time, it's, you know,

1:23:20I don't have a lot of time outside writing the site

1:23:23and like curating stuff and doing that stuff.

1:23:25And it's hard to, you know, it's hard to find the time,

1:23:28especially like long stretches of time

1:23:31to really dig in and knuckle down and say,

1:23:33okay, I'm gonna make these changes and do it in this way.

1:23:36And it's gonna require some HP

1:23:38and it's gonna require some design,

1:23:39which I'm so far removed from being a web designer

1:23:42that those skills are very atrophied at this point.

1:23:45And it just takes a long time to get going

1:23:47and get into that sort of groove.

1:23:51And it's hard to do that at the same time

1:23:53where you're trying to like,

1:23:54oh, I gotta find some interesting stuff today

1:23:57and I read this thing and I'm gonna write this thing

1:23:59and all that stuff.

1:24:00So I would very much to switch up more or less wholesale

1:24:04how the site looks and works,

1:24:06but limited time and limited energy.

1:24:09And I spent a lot of time on the site

1:24:11and that's where a lot of my energy goes.

1:24:13And so it's looked the same for a while,

1:24:15but I don't know, hopefully in the next,

1:24:18I'm not even gonna say it.

1:24:19I'm not even gonna say it.

1:24:20- Right, right, yeah, don't say it.

1:24:21Don't, I've made that problem with,

1:24:23I've made that promise with the mobile optimized layout

1:24:28of Daring Fireball too many times to do it again.

1:24:31I know that I have terrible podcast amnesia.

1:24:35I always say this.

1:24:36I will literally forget most of this conversation

1:24:39within an hour of us clicking stop

1:24:41thanking each other. I forget what I say on a podcast as soon as I'm done recording it,

1:24:47but I suspect—so it's even worse for long-ago episodes. I forget how long ago your last

1:24:54appearance on this show was, but I'm pretty sure I asked some of these questions before.

1:24:57But I'll say it again, because that's, you know, why not? I think that's what podcasting is for.

1:25:03I've noticed—I listened to—

1:25:04Exactly.

1:25:04I listened to Keith Olbermann's Countdown, which is now a weekday—week daily podcast version of

1:25:11his old show, and I love his podcast. I mean, I just love his take on politics, and it's just the

1:25:17right length for me running errands when I'm out and about. But he's got certain recurring things,

1:25:23like he's got a thing at the end called Stories I Promise Not to Tell, where he gossips about his

1:25:27media life, and he's had a tumultuous career where he's been fired and come back and

1:25:34left ESPN and Fox Sports and MSNBC. He did two stints and he just tells these amazing

1:25:41inside stories about like the executives of MSNBC. But even though his podcast is only

1:25:47like six months old or something like that, he's already repeated some of them multiple

1:25:51times. And it's like, ah, you know, you know, you can do that with a podcast. So I'll just

1:25:55repeat myself. To me, still, I'm not saying you should go back. But the kotke.org of my

1:26:01mind is the two or three layouts that had the yellow at the top. I call it

1:26:07yellow, I don't know, is it chartreuse? It was a very... but to me it's sort of like,

1:26:12it was similar to Daring Fireball's 4A, 5A, 2A, slate blue, slate gray, bluish gray,

1:26:19whatever you want, it's a hard color to describe. And the katge.org of my

1:26:24mind is of that era. And I'm not saying you should go back, and I know that at

1:26:28this head no but i know that at this point the current layout has is has lasted longer right if

1:26:35there's a if you go by length of time the current sort of and again it's hard to describe this sort

1:26:41of gradient what would you call those colors they're not quite pastel they're yeah they're not

1:26:49they're not like traditional rainbow colors but they're not quite pastel they're kind of like

1:26:53something in between right but it's that's that layouts lasted longer but the katky.org of my mind

1:26:58is has yellow at the top and I'm not even sure which one because I have genuine deep affection

1:27:04for all of them and rereading that post and looking at them all I'm like oh I remember when

1:27:09he switched to make it more compact at the top and I remember and every time every one of those

1:27:14switches you made I loved and when you abandoned the yellow is the only time I I was like oh

1:27:20and I remember thinking and I here's where I remember thinking is he'll come back to that

1:27:26He'll come back

1:27:27It'll be it'll be yellow again

1:27:29And of course it is right the other thing and I know I mentioned this the last time too, but I'll mention it again is

1:27:34that

1:27:35The site technically doesn't have a name. It's cocky.org. Our name is our address

1:27:41Right. Yep. I used I know it's true and I think I'm repeating myself one more time

1:27:48But I because I can't help but think my brain would go there. There was a

1:27:53famous Philadelphia jeweler who advertised on TV all the time when I was a kid, like,

1:27:58and the sort of local TV ad that—because I lived in the Philly TV market, and they would be the—they

1:28:05wouldn't be like in prime time, they would advertise on those four in the afternoon shows,

1:28:10or The Price is Right, like on a snow day or whatever, you know, whenever we could,

1:28:14you know, we're home and could watch The Price is Right at 11 a.m. And their jingles were famous.

1:28:20the two brothers who owned it would sing songs and stuff, but the name of the jeweler was

1:28:25"Robbins, Eighth, and Walnut." That was the name of their thing. And the jingle was "Robbins,

1:28:32Eighth, and Walnut, our name is our address." And, you know, it goes on from there. But that was it,

1:28:37over and over again. "Robbins, Eighth, and Walnut, our name is our address. Robins,

1:28:41Eighth, and Walnut, our name is our address." And every time I think of this aspect of kottke.org,

1:28:47I instantly think Robbins, 8th and Walnut. Now, Robbins, 8th and Walnut is now a French bakery.

1:28:52And I think they might still be in business, but they're only in Delaware for sales tax purposes,

1:29:02but it's just Robbins now, you know, because their name can't be addressed. They can't be,

1:29:07you know, Robbins, 8th and Walnut has a bit of a ring to it. Robbins, 1444, whatever, the highway,

1:29:14you know, obviously doesn't sound like a good address, but maybe they're out of business.

1:29:17It doesn't matter. I wonder about the name of the site because it is just katte.org. I wonder

1:29:23if it's been like, if that's a good thing or if it's been a liability in some ways. I feel like

1:29:29in my mind, maybe it's made it harder to thinking about like, well, you know, maybe I should expand

1:29:37the site, expand what I'm doing and bring other people on. And, you know, I have guest editors

1:29:41and stuff like that, but it's always sort of temporary. I mean, I had my friend Tim Carmody,

1:29:45he was writing a newsletter for me for a while, and that was, you know, it was under sort of the

1:29:51same general umbrella, but it had its own sort of identity and brand and stuff like that. You know,

1:29:56but it's hard to, I don't know, it's hard to bring someone else on when it's like the name on the

1:30:00masthead is mine. I've thought about changing the name, like, through the years. I've thought about

1:30:06it. Maybe I should just get an actual name for the website instead of just kottke.org.

1:30:11Maybe it would change the vibe a little bit in a way that would be more...

1:30:18I don't even know. I guess this is why I didn't get that far in pursuing it. I don't know what

1:30:25the benefit would be necessarily.

1:30:28Now, and I think people just think of it as "Kotki," right? In a way, it, you know, it's so—

1:30:33saying it doesn't have a name isn't quite right. It's effectively "Kotki." But you do say, you

1:30:39know, in the actual, you know, when you look down, it says "Kotki.org heart emoji home of fine

1:30:46hypertext products." I mean, it does say "Kotki.org." So I think technically the title is

1:30:51"Kotki.org," but I think in most people's minds they would say, "Oh, I read it on Kotki," right?

1:30:56They're not going to say I read it on kaki.org. Home of Hypertext Products has, that's the one

1:31:02consistent thing, right? I don't know that it's ever not been there. Has that been the slogan

1:31:06since day one? Or it's certainly been the slogan for 20-some years, I think.

1:31:11Yeah, it's been the slogan for quite a while. It was back and forth for a while. It was not on the

1:31:17site for, I don't know, for stretches of months and maybe even years here and there. But most of

1:31:24of the history of the site it's said home of fine hypertext products and I

1:31:28can't remember I don't know how early on that was but I kind of I just kind of

1:31:33liked it when I picked it because it sounded kind of old-timey but also like

1:31:37new as well because it's got the word hypertext in it but it's you know it's

1:31:41like it's like I'm a dry goods store but you know online I I often are in fact

1:31:46generally I altered up sometimes but usually when I post links to the show on

1:31:51on Daring Fireball, I mean, I link to the sponsors,

1:31:54I say brought to you by these fine sponsors,

1:31:56which is, I both mean, I both mean genuinely,

1:32:00I'm very proud of the sponsors that we have

1:32:02for the podcast and for the site, and I'm picky,

1:32:04and I really, you know, it doesn't happen often,

1:32:06but we really do reject some sponsors.

1:32:09And also, I like the old-timey feel of it.

1:32:12- Yeah.

1:32:13Do you remember the dearly departed Dean Allen?

1:32:17One of his sites was Cardigan Industries.

1:32:20- Yes.

1:32:21And I always really liked that.

1:32:23And it had sort of a, like an industrial letterhead

1:32:27sort of aesthetic to go with it as well.

1:32:29And I always just really liked, I liked that whole vibe.

1:32:34- Dean, I don't wanna go on a side rant,

1:32:38which I could do and maybe should someday.

1:32:40Dean's influence on what I do at Daring Fireball

1:32:45cannot be overstated because textism,

1:32:48textism came out first.

1:32:50I mean, honestly, if you look at Textism circa August 2002,

1:32:55when I launched, if you go back to the Wayback Machine

1:33:01and look at, Daring Fireballs layout actually has changed.

1:33:06I forget, it was about two years in.

1:33:10There was an actual redesign.

1:33:12It wasn't drastic, but it was redesigned once,

1:33:17or tweaked, you know, call it a 1.5 instead of a 2.0.

1:33:21But the 1.0 version was so, to me,

1:33:25still looks so clearly inspired by textism, you know,

1:33:28like that in my mind it bordered on a ripoff.

1:33:31And then when I, and that was one of my biggest concerns

1:33:34when I first went public and started my first post,

1:33:38I, here it comes, people are gonna say

1:33:39it's a textism ripoff, and nobody ever said that.

1:33:42And then I, a couple of months in,

1:33:44got a really nice note from Dean about my writing and I was just like and then you know we became

1:33:53friends he wrote to me and said that he'd noticed that after a few months I'd zeroed in on my voice

1:34:00and that it's really good and I was like oh thank god he's not mad.

1:34:05And you know I guess most other people I think when you're a designer and you've got

1:34:13something that really inspires you, you the design, and if you're worried, if you're an

1:34:18honest designer who doesn't want to rip anybody off, you see a ripoff that other people don't see.

1:34:24But yeah, Dean's Cardigan Industries, again, was more, as I recall, a little bit more episodic,

1:34:31too. You know, it was—

1:34:32Tom: Yeah, I think so.

1:34:33Michael O'Brien I mean, textism was a blog block,

1:34:36just exactly what we've been talking about. Chronological posts, top to bottom, period,

1:34:41you know, once a day, every other day, something like that. But Cardigan Industries was in that,

1:34:46I don't know what we would call it, Neolithic period. I don't know if that's the right word,

1:34:50but that gestational period of self-publishing where nobody knew what the form was supposed to be.

1:34:58Right.

1:34:59But yeah, I totally agree about the aesthetic at the time. And I always loved his aesthetic.

1:35:03Yeah.

1:35:04Even when he went minimal, when he relaunched text-ism towards the end and it didn't really

1:35:09last long. He totally changed. Although I don't love that last textism, that super minimal one.

1:35:14I don't love it. But I got it, and I do think he foresaw where things were going. Like, it was

1:35:23super prescient about where graphic design was going at the time and ahead of his time. And of

1:35:31course he noticed that trend, but I don't have the affection for it that I did for his ornate

1:35:37earlier style. I mean, God, that text-ism thing with the guy at the top sweating and the little

1:35:43sort of copper plate—I know it wasn't copper plate, but copper plate style all cap slogan,

1:35:48"Make haste slowly." Which again, I was like, "God damn it, that should be my slogan,

1:35:56"Make haste slowly." Fuck! I was like, "God damn it!" And again, you and I are not exactly alike,

1:36:05you know, nobody's going to confuse me for you or you for me, but we share a lot of similarities.

1:36:11And in the same way, nobody was going to mistake me for Dean or Dean for me, but there are, you know,

1:36:16the large Venn diagram overlaps, and "Make haste slowly"? God damn, that was a good slogan.

1:36:23Yep. Dean was one of those people along with, I don't know, I would say like him and Paul Ford,

1:36:31Like, they had really good design sense, they had a great voice, they could write just so well,

1:36:40so beautifully, so it just made me so angry. It's just like so angry. I was like, you know,

1:36:46if these guys, if they wanted to, for whatever reason, become like the best bloggers in the

1:36:51universe, like, they totally could. And there was nothing I could do about it. They would just be

1:36:55be like, "boop, you're done."

1:36:57- Dean's biography page, his about page,

1:37:00whatever he called it, is one of the great pieces

1:37:02of writing of all time.

1:37:04I mean, it was just unbelievable.

1:37:07While we're throwing it out, I should go back.

1:37:09I actually, and I just saw him a few months ago.

1:37:12I actually don't remember if I asked him this.

1:37:14I should mention Andy Baio and waxy.org as, again,

1:37:19came out before "Daring Fireball."

1:37:22He's still going, and I wonder,

1:37:24I don't know if he's still on movable type or not.

1:37:26- Maybe.

1:37:28Oh, that's a good question, I don't know.

1:37:30- I'm gonna have to find out.

1:37:31I'm gonna have to ask Andy and find out.

1:37:33He might be the missing member

1:37:35of the movable type users group, or maybe not.

1:37:37His format hasn't changed.

1:37:39Andy, he posts full articles far less frequently,

1:37:44but when he does, they're gold,

1:37:46and they're more pulled straight from Andy's id

1:37:51than ever before.

1:37:53I'm looking at his site right now,

1:37:54and his last one was from the end of January.

1:37:57Lost media finding Bill Clinton's

1:37:59Boxers or Briefs MTV moment.

1:38:01Tell me that's not, right there,

1:38:05it just happens to be the most recent article.

1:38:07Tell me that's not Andy Baio.

1:38:09Finding Bill Clinton's 1991 or '92 appearance on MTV

1:38:14where somebody in the audience asked him

1:38:17where he wears Boxers or Briefs

1:38:19and finding the video from the pre-web era.

1:38:22But his format hasn't really changed

1:38:24where he's stuck with the two column layout

1:38:27of big articles on the left

1:38:31and then a sidebar with his links.

1:38:33He's re-CSSed it, the type is all new,

1:38:38but that fundamental layout structure is the same,

1:38:41which I now think of as the Andy Baio layout.

1:38:45I believe you have one time, at one point though,

1:38:47did you have your short links in a sidebar or no?

1:38:51did yeah i did but yeah and i think the first place i remember seeing it was probably in anneal doing

1:38:57it like he had the links in the sidebar and then he had the the regular stuff on the left yeah yeah

1:39:03i had it that way for quite a while i don't know and i've been thinking like maybe i need to go

1:39:07back to that oh i i was oh let me steer you the other way i i think no i think andy i think it

1:39:13works for andy no i think it works for andy though but it works for andy because to me even though

1:39:18it's width-wise his sidebar, it's his main blog to me. And his left column is periodic.

1:39:28It works for him. I don't think it would work for you because you post too frequently. I think the

1:39:33single stream is the way to go, which I've always had because I puttered around before I'd started

1:39:40adding link items. And by that time, I think you'd gone to single column and I just ripped it off

1:39:45from you. Yeah, shamelessly, but he might everything is remix before we keep going.

1:39:50I wanted to bring up stellar S T E L L A R. That was your what you described stellar.

1:39:57So stellar was a site that you could pull. When did when did you start your.

1:40:04Oh Jesus. Just to put it in our timeline. 2000. Hmm.

1:40:12hold a bit like 2007 2008 somewhere in that arena somewhere in that area maybe later than that no

1:40:18you're wrong i don't even remember you know what i've got a bookmark in my notes here at the

1:40:21atlantic jason cockey launches stellar a new social bookmarking site 2011 oh 2011 okay there you go

1:40:28well um so much for our memory yeah and i was inspired by that site that dean allen had called

1:40:35favored or farved or however you're pronounced it do you have that site yeah of course we talked we

1:40:41or some friends and I were just talking about it. Favord? Favord?

1:40:44Yeah.

1:40:45F-A-V-R-D?

1:40:46Yeah, I don't know. Yes, exactly. And so that was, it collected like what the most sort of

1:40:53favorited posts on Twitter were, the most favorited tweets on Twitter within sort of

1:40:58a certain like universe.

1:41:00Right. Right. Dean kept a hard-coded list of Twitter accounts that he thought were in the

1:41:07universe and of the tweets from those accounts it was a popularity list of favorites by the day or

1:41:16the last rolling 36 hours or something like that right right and it was gold it was gold yeah yeah

1:41:27it was it was really good it was really good but you know at some point he i can't remember if he

1:41:31shut it down before i started seller or after i launched or or what but at some point he shut it

1:41:37down and, but you know, I, I thought, I thought with the favorites thing, like he

1:41:43was kind of onto something and so I was like, okay, I'm gonna, I'm gonna do.

1:41:48I'm gonna do a site where you can sign up and sort of authenticate

1:41:52with different services.

1:41:53And I think I launched with Twitter, Flickr, YouTube, and Vimeo.

1:41:58And so you could collect your favorites, you know, all in one place, and then you

1:42:03could follow other people's favorites and that sort of became your main so it

1:42:08was like a you know it was like a instead of Dean just having a hard-coded

1:42:12list you could have your own list of people that you wanted to follow follow

1:42:15in their favorites and then I did some stuff I pulled out okay what are the

1:42:19like within the community within the stellar community like what are the

1:42:23trending links and what are the trending like videos and and things like that so

1:42:27I did some stuff like that too and yeah and I think it lasted for two three

1:42:32years, four years. I don't know how long as I recall though you you always

1:42:36described it as an experiment. Like it was never I don't know if you said beta

1:42:40I don't know if you said experiment but it seemingly never really officially

1:42:46went out. Not not that it wasn't public. Yeah I mean secret but

1:42:50yeah it was it was public but basically like I think I let the first like

1:42:56few 1000 people in like there was a waiting list of I think 15,000 people or

1:43:00something. And I let the first few thousand in, and at that point, like, my

1:43:05technical ability ran into problems with trying to figure out how to scale this

1:43:10damn thing, because it was like, you know, like, tens of thousands of new items a

1:43:14day streaming into the database, and it's like, oh crap, like, I don't really

1:43:18know anything about how to design a database for this. And at some point it

1:43:23became too much for me, and also, like, the writing was on the wall for, like, open

1:43:28APIs. Instagram had come out and it was obvious that Instagram was

1:43:33never really going to have an open API in the way that Twitter did.

1:43:38And I think that, you know, TikTok maybe--no, it wasn't TikTok, it was Snapchat.

1:43:42And like Snapchat, there was no API in sight, and I was like, "Oh, okay, so this is

1:43:47where things are going, and I can't have a whole service that relies on these

1:43:53open APIs when there aren't going to be any open APIs going forward, perhaps."

1:43:58And now we're seeing that with Twitter.

1:44:00I mean, Twitter's always been back and forth with their API, right?

1:44:03It's, "Come on in, you can do anything."

1:44:05And it's like, "No, go away, we hate you."

1:44:07And then it's like, "Oh no, come on in."

1:44:08And then it's like, after a while, it's like, "Fuck you, I'm gonna do something else."

1:44:13So.

1:44:14Yeah, it's funny.

1:44:16And everything starts small, right?

1:44:19Apple famously, but it's true.

1:44:21It's absolutely true that Apple started with two Steves in a garage, an actual garage,

1:44:27and it was two guys who were both, happened to be historic level geniuses in their own

1:44:35very different ways and got along. But it was two guys putting boards together and then selling them

1:44:42at hobbyist meetups. You know, Facebook famously started as one kid in a dorm at Harvard, right?

1:44:52So at some point Facebook was the size of Daring Fireball or kottke.org, right? It's a guy typing

1:45:00PHP and publishing stuff by himself. And Twitter never was one person. It wasn't an indie thing.

1:45:09But when Twitter debuted and spun out of audio, it was tiny, right? I just was telling this story

1:45:18to Ben Thompson, I think on dithering the other day, that in 2007, I believe, I think

1:45:25Twitter started in 2006, and I got on it right away, because I just got it right away, and

1:45:31I was like, "Oh, this is awesome." And in 2007, I was in San Francisco for WWDC, and

1:45:36somebody invited me to Twitter headquarters, which was right down the street from WWDC,

1:45:40for lunch one of the days with the whole staff. And they wanted to talk to a semi-popular

1:45:47Twitter user, which tells you how early it was that I counted as semi-popular on Twitter.

1:45:54But the whole company, we all had lunch together, and it wasn't like I needed a microphone or

1:45:59it was about, I don't know, I'd say about 20 people. I mean, I don't know if there was

1:46:02somebody who knocked off that day, but as far as I could tell, the whole company was

1:46:0620 people. So the scale was, that's still like the same ballpark, right? Like, I can

1:46:11comprehend 20-person staff. And there was one guy, I think it was Blaine Cook, I think

1:46:18Craig Hockenberry has been writing about it in the RIP Twitter Clients thing, where it was like one

1:46:26guy who was doing the APIs for Twitter, and he was just taught at a personal level. It wasn't like

1:46:32you're interacting with the Twitter developer connection board and posting tickets and stuff.

1:46:39Craig wanting to write the Mac app instead of interacting with the website, and then the iPhone

1:46:43gets announced and he's, "Oh, I could take this thing I've been writing for the Mac and put it on

1:46:48the iPhone." But like when he was making Twitterrific for the Mac, which was before the iPhone was

1:46:52announced, he just talked to Blaine Cook and Blaine would be like, "Well, what do you need?" And he'd

1:46:56be like, "Oh." You know, because Blaine was thinking, "Oh, we never really thought about

1:47:01somebody doing like a Mac or a Windows client for this, but that's an awesome idea. Wow." Instantly

1:47:07got it and was like, "Oh, that would be an awesome idea." He was like, "Well, what

1:47:11would you need?" Because you never thought of it as something that someone would make

1:47:14an app for, this is what's missing from the API. And the next day, Blaine is like,

1:47:20"Here, how about this? Does that work for you?" And it's there, and he could use

1:47:24it. And so it was like that level of indie spirit in the early days. And then it's

1:47:30Lane Bennis's famous words yada yada yada then and then it's a multi-billion

1:47:37dollar public corporation you know and it's yes it's an orifice in terms of

1:47:42interacting with them but it was a slow boil though and it's hurt what you and I

1:47:49do terribly in my opinion because most of what we used to I think it's true I

1:47:55I know most of what I used to link to in the early days

1:47:59or what I was happier linking to

1:48:01was other people's blog posts.

1:48:04And it felt more social in a way, right?

1:48:09'Cause it's of somebody else's voice.

1:48:13And it just, I don't wanna call anybody,

1:48:15but it could be Andy, it could be you,

1:48:17it could be Mark Pilgrim who stopped,

1:48:19and just dozens and dozens and dozens of people,

1:48:22including people who weren't blogging to become popular bloggers, but maybe only posted

1:48:29once a month, but they did post once a month, but they had their own blog.

1:48:35And if it was just a clever solution to a CSS problem, and then you'd publish it,

1:48:42and then I'd link to it.

1:48:44And it really is just the slowest boiling of slow-boiling frogs in a pot of water problem

1:48:53that I just kind of saw it happening, but in hindsight it's so crystal clear that the

1:49:00Pied Piper song of the ease of tweeting and in the universe of people I would have linked

1:49:06to back in the blogging days, pre-Twitter, it's Twitter that took all of their posting,

1:49:15not Facebook. I've never even been on Facebook, and I've never—I can count literally all—maybe

1:49:21on one hand, certainly on both hands, the number of times that there's been something

1:49:27on Facebook that I'd wished I could link to from Daring Fireball but can't because

1:49:32behind the Facebook sign-in thing. Literally only a handful of times. It's Twitter that took up the

1:49:38gas there, but all of them – Facebook, Twitter, Instagram – all of them aren't on the open web.

1:49:46They're not the web, and they just sucked up so many other people – the people who aren't trying

1:49:53to do it as a living or a vocation because it's so much easier, right? There's no blame whatsoever

1:50:00for people who faded away from blogging and put all of their public posting onto Twitter,

1:50:05because I see how much easier it is, and I know that's how human psychology works. It's exactly

1:50:11like what we were talking about earlier about not having titles, right? Which is also exactly why—they

1:50:17don't call it a title, it's called a subject—but it's exactly why it's so much easier to text

1:50:22someone than to email them, even if it's the same text, right? Like, you and I setting up this

1:50:28podcast. We did it entirely through messages. We didn't send a single email to each other.

1:50:32I never send email to friends for things like that anymore. And part of it is email is worse,

1:50:38and email, my inbox is noisy and my messages app isn't noisy at all. But part of it is the

1:50:45lack of a subject, right? It's just less effort for something that I don't really care about.

1:50:49It's my professional, you know, my text messages through messages aren't my work, right? So they're

1:50:56dashed off and casual and it's a huge decrease in cognitive load. So I don't blame them. But my god,

1:51:03it's made all of these things so much harder to link to. I mean, and I dread it now. I dread,

1:51:09I think it's inevitable at this point, the coming disappearance of Twitter's archives,

1:51:15because there's an awful lot over the last 10 years where people, you know, and people,

1:51:22it's a misappropriation of the form posting a tweet thread instead of a blog post. But again,

1:51:28if you don't already have a blog, posting a tweet thread is way easier than setting up a blog just

1:51:36to post this one thing. But I don't—untold number of tweets that I've linked to and tweet threads

1:51:42that I've linked to I think are—now I have no faith that they're going to persist into perpetuity.

1:51:48Yeah. It's not only sort of the ease of use, but it's the network, right? So you, like,

1:51:54when you tweet, you have a built-in sort of, people have a built-in way to read, people have

1:51:58a built-in way to respond. And when you're talking about sort of the threads instead of blog posts,

1:52:03sure, you could post it on your blog, but, you know, and some, you know, through RSS and stuff

1:52:08like that, like, we've sort of cobbled together the network stuff. And when Google Reader was a

1:52:14There was a sort of a built-in network effect there.

1:52:17But, you know, the thing about Twitter is that you post a tweetstorm or a thread.

1:52:21People can respond immediately and individually to every single sort of point that you make along the way.

1:52:28That's the case with Facebook as well.

1:52:30You can comment, you can like, you see things that other people have liked in your feed.

1:52:36There's discovery mechanisms as well.

1:52:38The world of blogs, they had that cobbled together a little bit with things like RSS

1:52:43and with things like Technorati and like web log search engines and all that sort of stuff.

1:52:49But Facebook and Twitter just came along and were like, "Hey, we're going to do this all

1:52:53in one basket. It's going to be super easy. Here you go." And it's kind of no wonder that

1:52:59it took off the way it did for both of them. Theoretically, Facebook is the biggest blogging

1:53:03company in the world. They were the ones who really figured out how to monetize blogging

1:53:09and it made them a $500 billion company for a while.

1:53:13They figured out two things, and again,

1:53:16I've never even had a Facebook account,

1:53:18but I do recognize the genius of it in some ways.

1:53:22They figured out the monetization there.

1:53:24I mean, they're one of the five biggest companies

1:53:25in the world.

1:53:26And the other thing that they did,

1:53:29and this is the part where I give them full credit

1:53:32and actually admire it, is they're the first

1:53:35and perhaps still only company that cracked the nut

1:53:39of getting regular people to blog,

1:53:43whether they think of it as blogging or not, right?

1:53:46Just regular people and they're posting things

1:53:49like their kids' graduation pictures

1:53:51and just an update about somebody's health

1:53:55or something like that.

1:53:56And again, saying positive things about Facebook

1:54:00and privacy seems counterintuitive

1:54:02'cause I rant and rail about the negative aspects

1:54:06of their regard for privacy in other regards.

1:54:10But from the perspective of users,

1:54:13the literally multiple billions of users that they have,

1:54:17they solve the nut of people feeling comfortable

1:54:21and understanding the circle of who things are going out to

1:54:25so that they could do things like if somebody's mother

1:54:30is ill and posting it in a way that they know

1:54:34is only going out to the people who they want it

1:54:36to go out to with updates.

1:54:38And I have all the admiration in the world for that

1:54:41because it's useful, right?

1:54:42they turned literally almost everybody in the world

1:54:45into a blogger, which was the original dream, right?

1:54:48That's the Dave Weiner dream, except for the fact

1:54:51that they were doing it in this locked ecosystem

1:54:55that's not on the open web.

1:54:57But I admire that greatly.

1:54:58But it's for us wanting to link to things, it's terrible.

1:55:02The average thing I link to now is a post

1:55:04at a professional publication.

1:55:06- Yep, that is probably behind some sort of soft paywall.

1:55:12Right and that's the other thing that's risen and I was it's on my list again part of my homework

1:55:17I've actually got an agenda here. I want to talk about paywalls

1:55:20The other day and again bringing up Dave Weiner Dave Weiner mentioned this as a use for the chat

1:55:27Gpt that the chat.open ai thing. Um

1:55:31He said that he asked the chat gpt the question

1:55:36What are the best non-paywalled news sites?

1:55:41and got, said he got a great list. And so I tried the same query and it's astonishing. It's like

1:55:48number one BBC, number two Reuters, number three, I forget. I might be CNN, I forget, but it was a

1:55:55good one. Number four, number four or number five was the New York Times. And the chat thing,

1:56:02after New York Times, it was like, it gave it an ordered list, one through 10. And after the New

1:56:08New York Times in parentheses said, "The New York Times does have a paywall, but with

1:56:12a very generous allotment of monthly open views." And so it effectively wrote a footnote,

1:56:20right? And I think, and I honestly think that's a fair description of the New York Times.

1:56:26I think that the New York Times, the way where they put their paywall is genius and generous

1:56:33and good enough with the understanding that they needed and continued to need a subscriber base

1:56:39that wants to burst through that and is willing to pay rather than stick around with deleting

1:56:45their cookies every two days or whatever. But it was an astonishingly good answer.

1:56:49But the fact that it's even a question, like, how do you get to non-pay, you know,

1:56:56what are the best non-paywall news, is so antithetical to the concept, the original

1:57:02concept of the World Wide Web that it's flabbergasting and downright from the perspective of 1996,

1:57:12I would say it's dystopic. It's a dystopia to think that the—I don't know that the

1:57:21idea that a paywall on the web would have been laughed at, I think, in 1996. It's

1:57:26what are you talking about? You don't get it. You're like somebody who wants to use

1:57:31QuarkXPress to publish their website. You know, like, QuarkXPress, I loved and it's a wonderful

1:57:37tool, but it's not for publishing to the web. So the idea that you want to make people pay to see

1:57:42the stuff, but here we are, right? And what is it, how frustrated are you by that trend?

1:57:47Tom: I mean, purely as someone who wants to point people to things that they can actually read

1:57:54without paying money, it's very frustrating. But at the same time, if you look at the New York

1:57:59times or you look at the Atlantic or any of these other publications, it's like,

1:58:03that's where those paywalls or those, you know,

1:58:07membership programs or however you want to put it,

1:58:10like they're paying for a lot of good writing and a lot of good journalism.

1:58:15It's also paying for a lot of garbage,

1:58:17but I'm interested in linking to the good stuff and you know,

1:58:20and I get email all the time from people who are like, this stuff is paywall.

1:58:24What are you doing? And it's like, well, like I would love it if it weren't,

1:58:28But this is where this particular piece of writing was.

1:58:31And I think it's worth your attention.

1:58:33If somehow you happen to have a subscription or if you can somehow

1:58:37get around it with incognito window or deleting your cookies or right.

1:58:42But it's, it's really frustrating from my standpoint as a blogger who likes

1:58:46to, you know, link to a lot of different things, I think that there's

1:58:49a couple of things going on here.

1:58:51It's like there's consolidation and then there's paywalls and

1:58:54increasingly that consolidation is happening behind paywalls.

1:58:57And so you get this double whammy where people aren't writing for a lot of different crazy things,

1:59:03although now, you know, with sub stack is, is I think trying to push back on that.

1:59:07But, you know, sub stack is itself paywalled for the most part.

1:59:11And medium is that way too.

1:59:14And you know, it's, it's, so you're, you're, you're getting kind of this double whammy squeeze from both ends.

1:59:19I at least admire more when a paywalled site, and I don't want to, I don't want to speak poorly of sub stack

1:59:25substack because overall I think substack has been a force for good and is pushing in the right

1:59:34direction. It is pushing back, pushing the web and independent solo or like two people or three

1:59:41people teams or whatever back towards where I think it should be and where I think we lost this

1:59:47opportunity. So overall I'm two thumbs up on substack. But one thing that irritates me about

1:59:52substack is when a post is paywalled it's usually below the fold and it so I'm like oh this was a

1:59:59free post great I can link to it and then I then I hit the spacebar to scroll down and it's uh

2:00:05so in some ways I admire a paywalled site that at least covers up my whole browser window right away

2:00:14like the Financial Times like I hate it right but at least the Financial Times tells me right away

2:00:21this whole thing is paywalled. Huge frustration. And the FT in particular has also been very

2:00:26consistent. Like they've had a paywall for I think a long time. And Wall Street Journal too,

2:00:31right? Wall Street Journal famously kind of broke the nut of it with $100 subscriptions,

2:00:39like a lot of money. And everybody was like, well easy for them because the people who want to read

2:00:44the Wall Street Journal are business people who can write it off to work. Which is true,

2:00:49but still just knowing your audience isn't a fault, right? But they've had that paywall from

2:00:54the beginning. They never yanked it out. The Wall Street Journal was always like, "Fuck you, you're

2:00:58gonna pay." But I get around it with the Wall Street Journal and I don't know what. I should

2:01:02probably someday, I've still never done a reader poll. I should because there are many questions

2:01:08I have about my audience that I don't know. I think I know my audience, but one thing I suspect

2:01:13is that a lot of them subscribe to the Apple One,

2:01:18just give us $30 a month and we give you everything,

2:01:21more iCloud storage, and Apple Music, which is the big one,

2:01:25and you get it, your Apple TV,

2:01:27so you can watch all the Apple TV shows,

2:01:29you get the Apple Fitness, and you get Apple News.

2:01:32I don't like Apple News, 'cause it's too many ads,

2:01:36but the Apple News includes the Wall Street Journal,

2:01:40so when I link to the journal,

2:01:42I almost always include an Apple News link,

2:01:44thinking at least some decent chunk of my readers,

2:01:47being Apple nut jobs, probably have,

2:01:51if they don't subscribe to the journal,

2:01:52they have an Apple News link and can click that and read it.

2:01:55But the journal still has so much original reporting,

2:01:59especially in my, the areas I'm hyper-focused on,

2:02:03and I wanna give credit to original reporting

2:02:07rather than link to somebody's regurgitation of it,

2:02:09which annoys me, but on the other hand,

2:02:12I know that most people don't subscribe

2:02:14to the Wall Street Journal, so it's frustrating.

2:02:17The other thing about that that I think the trend is

2:02:21subscriptions and memberships

2:02:25and whatever you wanna call it work,

2:02:29and people like them because once you're in,

2:02:34you get this premium experience.

2:02:36I have this theory, and I would,

2:02:40I think I'm exactly right that the resurgence in email newsletters, which is absolutely a resurgence,

2:02:48right? It was like, because like email newsletters were a big thing before the web or when the web

2:02:52was like a thing that people didn't know what to do or it was so friggin slow, but people got email

2:02:58in the early 90s and then like somebody figured out, well, we could write like a publication and

2:03:03just email it to people and it was awesome, right? There was like the longest standing independent

2:03:08publisher I can think of is Tidbits, tidbits.com, which started as both an email newsletter

2:03:15and a weekly hypercard stack.

2:03:17[laughter]

2:03:18>> TARADINO Wow.

2:03:20>> BRIAN KARDE Right?

2:03:21It was like once a week they'd put out an issue and you could go to the InfoMac archives

2:03:26and there's like an FTP address and they'd post it to Usenet and you would download the

2:03:31hypercard stack.

2:03:33And I think the way it worked, it was very clever.

2:03:35You didn't have like a folder full of stacks.

2:03:37It's like whatever you downloaded,

2:03:39it would add to your tidbits hypercard stack, right?

2:03:42So you just get the new issue,

2:03:44and it didn't clutter up your drive.

2:03:45But they were a plain text email newsletter

2:03:48in the early '90s, I think literally before

2:03:51Tim Berners-Lee invented the web,

2:03:53or at least before he made it public.

2:03:57And now it's a big thing again.

2:03:58But my theory is very simple.

2:04:00People like email newsletters because the email,

2:04:03it's not because it shows up automatically

2:04:06in their inbox, which is, you know, it's a factor.

2:04:09But it's that once it's there,

2:04:11you just start reading and you scroll down

2:04:14and then you get to the end and you're done.

2:04:16And there's no ads in the middle, nothing ever, ever,

2:04:21it technically can't even happen.

2:04:22Nothing ever pops up while you're reading

2:04:25and says, "Would you like to subscribe to our newsletter?

2:04:28"Here's an X," you know,

2:04:30because you're already on their newsletter, right?

2:04:32It sounds like the dumbest thing in the world,

2:04:34But it turns out in today's web, it's so corrupt with ad tech

2:04:39that just being able to read from the beginning to the end

2:04:43without any interruption in the stream of the text

2:04:46is actually a premium reading experience.

2:04:49And for the most part,

2:04:50you can only get it now in email newsletters.

2:04:52You can't get it on the web, which is bananas.

2:04:55Like the fact that you and I don't interrupt our stuff

2:05:00with ads in the middle, it makes us unique.

2:05:03I mean, which is crazy.

2:05:05- Yeah, no, it does.

2:05:07It does.

2:05:07Yeah, I mean, there's a blog that I read regularly

2:05:10that started adding an email pop-up,

2:05:12and I'm just like, "Dude, come on, seriously?"

2:05:16Like, I know it juices your numbers, but--

2:05:17- Don't.

2:05:18I think the New York Times has always been forward-thinking.

2:05:22They've always had a pretty good website

2:05:24for a newspaper, always,

2:05:26and I think it's why they're thriving

2:05:28when other newspapers, or at least succeeding,

2:05:31not thriving, while other newspapers haven't. But even them still, to this day in March 2023,

2:05:39clearly value their print edition more than they do the web edition in terms of design and in terms

2:05:50of what they're willing to do. They never put an ad in the middle of an article, in the middle of

2:05:55of a column in the print edition. They never have and they never will, but they do it on

2:06:01the web. Every article has, as you scroll down on your phone, there are ads in the middle.

2:06:06And even if you're using an ad blocker that blocks the ads, it puts gaps in the article.

2:06:12And they also add stupid things that aren't ads and don't get blocked elsewhere on the

2:06:17web or elsewhere on this topic, or here's a carousel or something that isn't part

2:06:22the article, right? They're like, "Why in the world are you trying to keep me from reading to

2:06:28the end of this article by making me click to a different article in the middle of the article?

2:06:32Why are you doing this to me? Thank God I've got a strong enough attention span to do this."

2:06:37And it would infuriate me if I'm the one who wrote the article. And I write this article,

2:06:43and I want people to read it from the beginning to the end, and my own publisher is trying to

2:06:49steer people away from it halfway through. And the New York Times does it, and they're one of the

2:06:54best. It's—do you want to get really angry? Here's also on my topic list, 404s. 404s.

2:07:03Okay, good about 'em.

2:07:06How many do you think you have in the kakidat org archive?

2:07:10Links to—

2:07:11Oh, you mean the entire—oh, geez.

2:07:13Dead links. In other words, dead links.

2:07:15Oh my god. Yeah, I mean, thousands?

2:07:19Most of what? Probably over 50% I would say, the majority.

2:07:25I could probably do it and maybe it's the sort of thing Andy would probably want to do,

2:07:29Andy Baio would probably want to do. I bet if we exported our sites, I bet there's a very smooth

2:07:37curve that is very consistent and has never changed that there's about a four to five year

2:07:45year horizon where links start going 404 or dead, whether the whole website's defunct or just they

2:07:53change their CMS or their URL structure and don't add redirects that from the beginning, so like

2:08:01starting around 2006, 2007 for me, but probably starting around 2002, 2003 for you, four or five

2:08:08year old links start going bad and then by the time you get to 10 years it's a majority of them

2:08:14And the longer you know, the early years of Daring Fireball almost every it really is sickening to me

2:08:20how much of it is dead. So I built this thing, I don't know, a few years ago. It's not

2:08:24active anymore, but it was called like the what did I call it? Oh, the accidental bookshop.

2:08:29And basically I went through and I crawled all of my archives for every single book that I've

2:08:34ever linked to at Amazon and then compiled, you know, basically most popular links and

2:08:40all that sort of stuff. And the very first links I ever posted to Amazon, they still all work.

2:08:46Back in 2000, I think 1999 was probably the first time I linked to Amazon. Those links all still

2:08:53work. If you click on a link to the Matrix DVD, it goes to the page for the Matrix DVD.

2:08:59JS It might be out of stock, but it's still there.

2:09:02Exactly. Exactly. But even stuff like I will go back, I'll be writing a post or whatever,

2:09:11and I'll have to go look at a tag page of mine to figure out what I've written previously about it,

2:09:16and I'll see YouTube embeds from six months ago. They're already dead.

2:09:20Yeah. Yeah.

2:09:22Because the channel goes private or the thing gets deleted or just like whatever. But yeah,

2:09:28it's a problem.

2:09:31Yeah, well like with youtube and I know you link to a lot more youtube than I do, but I do

2:09:36But with youtube, I think what happens is a lot of times archived and again

2:09:41Archived meaning like six seven months ago stuff then gets hit with a copyright challenge or something

2:09:48And gets pulled and whether it was a legit challenge or not the channel creator

2:09:53Isn't doesn't really care because the youtube game is so much about

2:10:00your latest post is, your latest video is the only one that really matters and is the only one

2:10:05getting any traffic. And it's much more like surfing, right? It's just you're in the moment

2:10:12and all they're trying to do is keep from the wave knocking them off, you know? It's, you know,

2:10:17it seems very nerve-wracking to me, honestly, and I don't think I would do it, you know,

2:10:22even if I were younger. But they're just, they don't care, you know, not that they don't care,

2:10:27You know, and some obviously some channels do care, but yeah, even YouTube links go bad sometimes

2:10:33surprisingly quickly. Yeah, I've long had and again, you know, I'm running out of time here

2:10:38and for all these ideas I've had, but I've long had an idea to automate somehow finding dead links

2:10:45in my archive and then trying to find if there's a archive.org archive that I can then rewrite the

2:10:53link or add, you know, append at the bottom of all those posts, this link is dead, but here's

2:10:59an active link to archive.org, which I, you know, at this point, it would be—I would never,

2:11:07I could never do it, even in my wildest dreams of productivity and un-procrastination,

2:11:13I could never do it by hand. I could either—

2:11:16AO: Yeah, no.

2:11:16I could either automate it or I could hire somebody to do it by hand, but it would be

2:11:22a month. It would surely be a months-long project even if I hired someone who was very productive

2:11:29for eight hours a day. It's that many links. And the other part that makes me so queasy

2:11:38and ill and angry is that even that pipe dream of rectifying those dead links from literally

2:11:48sometimes just five years ago or less, but certainly the ones from 10 years ago and the

2:11:5315 and 20 year old ones are mostly dead. Even that pipe dream of doing it is all hanging by the

2:12:01single thread of archive.org and the internet archive. One thing that's a nonprofit foundation,

2:12:11volunteer, or not volunteer, I know Jason Scott is paid, and volunteer's not right, but funded by

2:12:18volunteer contributions. They don't have ads, they don't seem to have a huge benefactor or

2:12:25something. I don't know. I have no—zero idea why somebody like Google doesn't just give them

2:12:31more money to make it faster, you know, because Google could give them a literal couch change,

2:12:41and it would probably make a huge difference to them. But if not, if something ever happened to

2:12:46the—you know, the Internet Archive is literally our modern library of Alexander in terms of its

2:12:53singular nature as an archive of all that stuff on the web. Even Wikipedia, which is awesome,

2:13:01because of its open nature, there's copies of that database, right? So if something happened

2:13:07to the Wikipedia Foundation, at least a copy of where it stands would be all over the place.

2:13:14It wouldn't be lost. I don't know if the culture of it and the—you know, somebody could pick up

2:13:23where they left off culturally and internal culture-wise in terms of the way that they

2:13:29somehow have made it work with their rules on editing and style and stuff like that.

2:13:35I had an idea and, you know, I'll blurb it out here. I might have blurbed it on a previous

2:13:41podcast. So I used to be more precious about my—I would like to write an article about X,

2:13:45so I'm therefore not going to talk about it because I don't want anybody to steal it.

2:13:49But as I've got, you know, I told you my list of "I would like to write about X and never get to it,"

2:13:57you know, is an entire second copy of Daring Fireball of original content, never written

2:14:03content. But I have an idea for an article that Wikipedia in a way as a standalone entity is the

2:14:11original vision for the web because it's easy to read, the articles link to each other where it

2:14:23makes sense. It's not quite because I do think Tim Berners-Lee's original vision for the web

2:14:31included things like your site and my site where we have a personal voice, right? Like,

2:14:36It could be a personal voice. It could be an institutional voice. And one thing lacking from

2:14:42my analogy of Wikipedia is the web as it was originally envisioned is nothing has a personal

2:14:48voice. It's all written in the institutional voice of Wikipedia as it should be, right? But in spirit

2:14:54it is. But the rest of the web is absolutely antithetical to the original spirit of the web.

2:15:02including the fact that, I mean, 'cause one of the,

2:15:06I think Tim Berners-Lee himself wrote it,

2:15:08the famous cool URLs don't change mantra.

2:15:12All right, let me take one more break here.

2:15:14Thank our third and final sponsor of the episode.

2:15:18It's one more fine sponsor,

2:15:20and it is our good friends at Memberful.

2:15:22Memberful has a world-class support team

2:15:25ready to help you simplify your memberships

2:15:28and grow your revenue if you're a creator

2:15:31who wants to use memberships and subscriptions

2:15:34to grow your business.

2:15:36They are passionate about your success

2:15:38and they always give you access to a real human being.

2:15:41If you need help or just want advice

2:15:43on like how to price things,

2:15:45how to section off what you,

2:15:48as Jason and I have just been talking about,

2:15:50where stuff goes for free

2:15:52and what goes behind the member paywall,

2:15:55you can monetize your passion with membership

2:15:57and you keep full control and ownership

2:16:00of your audience and your brand.

2:16:02It doesn't look like you're publishing through Memberful

2:16:05and you're a Memberful site.

2:16:07Memberful's just sort of a silent partner on the back end

2:16:10and they give you analytics.

2:16:11It gives you an easy to use in-depth view of what's working.

2:16:15What are the things that you're doing

2:16:16that people are actually using, consuming, reading,

2:16:18and what's not, and where you might wanna double down

2:16:21and go in a different direction to grow.

2:16:23It's the easiest way to sell memberships

2:16:25to your audience and it lets you build

2:16:27sustainable recurring revenue and it's used by some of the biggest independent

2:16:31creators on the web and they have everything you need to run a membership

2:16:34program including a streamlined and powerful checkout, easy to use member

2:16:39portal so people can go there and like change their email address, change their

2:16:42credit card, cancel their membership, renew their membership, anything they

2:16:47want to do they handle all that or change their password right that sort of

2:16:50thing very very tricky to get right they handle all of that and it also a

2:16:55membership management dashboard and you could use that membership management

2:16:58dashboard to export your membership database or list anytime you want if you

2:17:03want to move away from memberful it's your whole member list is yours to keep

2:17:09and take that's how confident they are that you're gonna stick with memberful

2:17:13they seamlessly integrate with the tools you already use including things like

2:17:17MailChimp WordPress stripe discord and more it's a great service I subscribe to

2:17:22more I keep saying as I subscribe to more memberfuls than I should it's it's

2:17:26racking up to a lot of month but it's a great great service six colors max

2:17:31stories the list goes on and on of the ones that I subscribe to and I know that

2:17:36the people who run those sites I know them personally and I know they're happy

2:17:39with memberful where do you go to check it out go to memberful M E M B E R F U L

2:17:45Memberful.com/talkshow. Know the just /talk show memberful.com/talk show.

2:17:53Monetize your passion with membership. You can get a free trial, no credit card required.

2:17:59Just go check them out. Speaking of memberships, I had a membership system in 2006.

2:18:06And it really helped me. It helped me get Daring Fireball off the ground as a full-time

2:18:13proposition. And then Google Reader, my shtick was, or not shtick, but my, the deal was, well,

2:18:20what do you get as a member of Full Other than the good feelings of supporting me was you got

2:18:25full content RSS feeds instead of truncated RSS feeds that required you to click through to go

2:18:31to my website to read it. And then originally, I even ginned it up again with one of those special

2:18:37modifications to my publishing system. My linked list items went out in that member RSS feed

2:18:46as soon as I hit publish, but only hit the website 24 hours later.

2:18:52Darrell Bock Oh, interesting. I don't think I knew that.

2:18:55John Green Well, it didn't last long,

2:18:57because I think it was a good idea to get people to pay, but it drove me nuts because I would post

2:19:04to some things that were timely and how could I post to like what if what if it came out I don't

2:19:09know what if I wanted to post to something that was about something that was going to be on tv

2:19:13tonight you know I mean that doesn't happen often but the one thing I never wanted to do and I still

2:19:17never want to do is write behind a paywall because and again it I value like an idiot I guess I I'm

2:19:26selfishly more interested in having everybody freely able to read what I write than make money

2:19:32So even though I almost certainly could make more money by having some kind of membership system

2:19:39and putting some of what I write every week behind it so that you can only read it there,

2:19:43I just can't bring myself to do it. But I thought that the 24-hour delay

2:19:47wasn't really a paywall. It was just a delay wall, and I could live with that. And when I tried it,

2:19:56I couldn't live with it. I was like, "No, I want everybody to see this right away."

2:19:59And then I just made it the full feeds and I did a whole talk at Andy's XOXO about how I got here.

2:20:06But the basic gist was Google Reader killed that because Google Reader became the biggest RSS

2:20:13reader by far. And even if you weren't using Google Reader to read your feeds,

2:20:17it became the sync engine that you'd use with that news wire. And you'd hook it up with your

2:20:22Google Reader to sync. And Google Reader didn't work with password authenticated feeds or

2:20:28what I did instead of passwords at the HTTP level was just give everybody a

2:20:34unique URL that and tell them not to share it but Google Reader was only

2:20:40built for sharing and it wasn't built from who if you know if I had 10,000

2:20:45members it wasn't meant for hitting my feed 10,000 times for each person it you

2:20:50know Google is a crawler they want to hit it once and then deliver that one one

2:20:55read to 10,000 readers and what would happen is everybody would go to Google

2:20:59Reader and search for daring fireball and it would show up a it was just

2:21:03confusing because it would show up hundreds and hundreds of feeds right and

2:21:07B they all had ugly URLs because they had these unique tokens in them and C

2:21:14they had the full contents so then all these people who weren't paying members

2:21:18and they I did you know if I'm sure some of them did it actually did do it

2:21:22deliberately to pirate my feed, so to speak, or whatever bootleg. I always like to use bootleg as

2:21:28a pirate bootleg without paying, but most of them were completely innocent, right? It's they're just

2:21:34looking to subscribe to Daring Fireball. Here's a URL. It has the full content of the site. So yeah,

2:21:39that's the one I want and they were subscribed. And I was like, oh, that's not going to work.

2:21:43Huh? How about I try selling a weekly ad and I'll put that in the RSS feed. Well, that

2:21:50worked great and here I am today still effectively doing it and monetizing that way. But then at that

2:21:57point I sort of silently sunsetted the membership thing. Lo and behold, a decade later, it, you know,

2:22:03I looked pretty dumb that I didn't figure out some way to keep it going. What about you? What about

2:22:09you with memberships? What's your history there? So I had a membership thing back in 2005 when I

2:22:16first started doing katky.org as a full-time thing, and I did it sort of

2:22:21like a PBS-style thing where it was like a whole like pledge drive kind of thing.

2:22:27I had a bunch of things to give away for people who decided to support the site. I

2:22:32had books and I had a lot of books. I can't really... I don't know, it's been

2:22:37a long time so I can't remember the other stuff that I had, but I had a bunch

2:22:40of like swag to sort of give away. Some of the books were like, you know, like I

2:22:44I just like cold emailed Malcolm Gladwell's publisher and said, "Hey, can I get some signed

2:22:52books to give away for this thing?" And they were like, "Okay." I did that for about a

2:22:55year. And after about a year, I was like, "Okay, I'm not sure I'm going to do this again

2:23:02this way," because I felt like at the time that it was this weird pressure that I had

2:23:07put on myself. I felt like I had about, I think it was about 1,500 members I had, maybe

2:23:13a thousand. I can't really remember, but I feel like I had 1500 bosses and it was stressing me out

2:23:20and I just, you know, and I think it by that time, like the deck was, was a thing or was soon to be

2:23:28a thing that you and Jim and was it Jason freed to come up with like, no, the original three were

2:23:37Crudall, Fried, and Zeldman. I was fourth. Oh, okay. Oh, okay, I see.

2:23:43But I remember it very vividly because they were the original three,

2:23:48and I thought, "Oh, I wish they would let me in."

2:23:50Yeah. I think for me it was like, "I wonder if they'd let me in." But of course, Lee,

2:23:57you were like, "Come on." Were you at the dinner at the Vietnamese place in Austin

2:24:03at South by Southwest the one year because it was sort of there used to be a deck dinner.

2:24:09That sounds familiar.

2:24:10There used to be an annual deck dinner at South by Southwest and I was fourth and then Jim told me,

2:24:17"Yeah, we always thought if it worked, we'd ask you next." The three of them got together,

2:24:21I think it was Jason's spitball. They thought, "Let's see if it worked." Jim said, "I'll take

2:24:27care of the selling. I know lots of advertisers," and Jim was very, very good at it.

2:24:32And Jim then told me, "Yeah, but we figured, well, let's see if it works before we ask

2:24:38Gruber." And then they got me in, and then there was a dinner at a Vietnamese restaurant,

2:24:43and it was really good. Somewhere in Austin, I don't know what year it was, but I think Andy

2:24:49got in then, and you, you know, but it was sort of like, "Let's let this, you know, let's expand

2:24:55to all the other obvious people who we should have in this thing." Yeah. Yeah, it was around then.

2:25:01Because if you went full time in 2005 and tried memberships, felt like you had bosses,

2:25:07it was probably either 2006 or 2007 in Austin where you were added to the deck.

2:25:13Yeah, exactly. And the deck was like, for what I wanted to do, the deck just seemed a lot easier

2:25:22because it was like... I think it worked this way for other people, maybe it didn't, I don't know.

2:25:29It was basically like a guaranteed amount of money every month.

2:25:32And like the ad it was just a little bit of JavaScript and I put it in my sidebar.

2:25:37And that was it.

2:25:38That was the extent of thinking about the economic and

2:25:41financial aspect of my site.

2:25:42And for me, like at the time, like that was fantastic.

2:25:47I could just write and focus on that and not have to worry about anything else.

2:25:53And there was no ad tech.

2:25:55like the little bit of JavaScript was literally just to insert a like a div tag with the image

2:26:02and a tag and there was never any tracking. I remember the one the closest we ever got to

2:26:07tracking was Adobe wanted to put an invisible pixel gif in and I think we let them it was like

2:26:15we put it up to a vote and we voted okay that's fine but that's all it was was a pixel like a

2:26:21It was no JavaScript, it wasn't setting a cookie. All they wanted to do was see how many times,

2:26:26instead of the image that was served from the deck.com or whatever the

2:26:31decknetwork.com or whatever the URL was, they just wanted to put their own image in with the text

2:26:37and just to see how many times they were loaded. That's the closest we ever got to tracking.

2:26:41- I mean, it sounds too good to be true. - It was great. I mean, it was great for

2:26:49publishers and I think it was good for readers too because like I think Jim worked really hard

2:26:55to keep those ads relevant and it was as unobtrusive as you can get without actually not

2:27:02having an ad. I would honestly say I still feel that way about my own ads but of course I would

2:27:07say that myself but my own ads are clearly just copied from the deck blatantly but I would say it

2:27:12actually came as close as ads could possibly come to being content that contributes that they were

2:27:17that good sometimes, right? I remember, oh crap, what was the stock footage place that was a

2:27:22frequent deck advertiser? Oh, like iStockPhoto maybe? Oh, it was something else. It was better.

2:27:28Veer? Yeah, Veer, right? Veer.

2:27:31Yeah. Veer, which was made by, like,

2:27:34people who had worked at one of the earlier stock photo places from, like, the graphic design era,

2:27:42and got, I don't know if they had stock and then it vested and they were like, okay, let's leave

2:27:51this place because it's gone to hell and let's do stock photography and illustration right and made

2:27:57Veer. But their ads, they were just beautiful. I was like, this makes my website look better,

2:28:02having this ad here. Yeah. So the membership thing, so you don't really have anything either

2:28:09right now, right? Yeah, no, no, no, of course not. Well, not of course not. Yeah, so...

2:28:16You can't say that! We just had Memberful as the sponsor.

2:28:19No! No, no, but it's not, it's not, it's not untoward though. No, it's just because we don't

2:28:26want anything behind, you know, like Jason Snell's Six Colors. It's not like Memberful has made his

2:28:31site any less. If you have no idea about the membership part, it's just that you get extra,

2:28:35You get like an extra newsletter at the end of the week and there's a members-only podcast that's

2:28:40different than the free and open podcast that he has. It's just gating some of the material.

2:28:46Like Jason and Ben Thompson are sort of at opposite ends, right? Where most of what

2:28:51Jason and Dan Morin do at Six Colors is all free and open and unobtrusive and uninterrupted.

2:28:56And then there's a little bit of stuff that you get if you're a member. And Ben does the opposite,

2:29:01where there's one weekly article that's free for everybody to read and the other four updates a week

2:29:06are for the paying subscribers and both work but both involve putting at least something behind a

2:29:12paywall which I feel like is that this is where you and I are like complete overlaps on the Venn

2:29:18diagram. We can't stand having a boss. We can't stand having 1500 bosses and we kind of don't want

2:29:24to put anything behind a paywall. Whereby kind of, whereby kind of, I mean I'd rather pull my

2:29:29fingernails out. Yeah, so several years ago I relaunched a membership program with Memberful,

2:29:41and I will echo everybody that you seem to know that has Memberful. It's great, I really like it.

2:29:47I like how it's lightweight and unobtrusive, but behind the scenes there's a lot of different

2:29:53things you can do to slice and dice things and move stuff around and administrate and all that

2:29:58sort of stuff. But so I relaunched the membership and the deal was that people would become members

2:30:04and they wouldn't get anything different than anybody else. And so it was the pitch was

2:30:12basically like katki.org is the tote bag, so what you're paying for is the site and if you

2:30:18if the collective readership does not feel like this is something worth paying for then the site

2:30:24will probably either cease to exist or it will exist in a vastly different format or form,

2:30:31probably like going back to being an occasional thing that I do while I have other work that I'm

2:30:38pursuing. And I didn't really know if that pitch was gonna land or not, and it did. Like,

2:30:46it really kind of resonated with the readership. And so this is like year six or I think this is

2:30:52year six of it, maybe seven where I've got a paying membership that is basically like

2:30:57supporting at this point, it's probably 70 or 80% of my revenue. I would say is the membership

2:31:04and everything that I write is in the open. So there's, there's nothing that I publish

2:31:08behind the paywall, right? It's sort of like a one, one man Wikipedia model. Yeah. Kind of,

2:31:15yeah. And which is great. There's there's different. No. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, I, I really

2:31:19like it. It's sort of that old feeling that I had about 1,500 bosses. I don't feel like that at all

2:31:24now. I feel like I have thousands of supporters, people who are like, "They really want this to

2:31:32exist." And it's like, I have a really good feeling about that because it makes me feel good that

2:31:36people want to read my stuff. But it's also, I feel a genuine responsibility to keep going on

2:31:43on that basis to, I don't know, to like prove that this works. Like, you can

2:31:48publish things to the web without having paywalls, and like, people will support

2:31:53that. People want to support other people doing this stuff. They want to support

2:31:57people keeping things open. So I mean, for me it's been great. I think if I

2:32:02probably had a more traditional like membership thing, like a substack or

2:32:06something like that, where it's like I have a few things a week that are open

2:32:09and most everything else is behind the paywall.

2:32:12I think I would probably be making more money,

2:32:14but I don't want to,

2:32:17like I just don't, I want it to be open.

2:32:22- I'm right there with you.

2:32:23All right, so let's talk about the sabbatical.

2:32:26- Okay.

2:32:27- I missed you.

2:32:29I really missed-- - That's good to hear.

2:32:31- I missed, I missed, I would, and I,

2:32:35you know, you and I are friends.

2:32:37We're not in frequent communication.

2:32:39Maybe we should be, maybe we should be frequent.

2:32:41We should be, we should be frequent texters.

2:32:43- All right.

2:32:44- But I didn't wanna ask you,

2:32:46I wasn't quite sure why you were taking the sabbatical,

2:32:49but every week, at some point during the week,

2:32:51I would wonder, is Jason back?

2:32:55And I would type the K,

2:32:56and it never stopped autofilling to kotke.org,

2:33:00and then I'd look, and it hadn't been updated,

2:33:02and I'd say, okay, maybe next week,

2:33:04and then I'd close the tab.

2:33:05Do you wanna talk?

2:33:06I mean, you've still, you promised, your readers,

2:33:08promised on khaki that you'd write extensively about your sabbatical, but you still haven't?

2:33:13Are you still planning to? Is this—are you John Gruber-ing this with something you wanted to write

2:33:18and it's never going to come out?

2:33:20JS I don't know. I have a lot of notes for this

2:33:24mythical long post about the sabbatical, and there's like some stuff that's sort of half-written.

2:33:29It seemed really urgent to me when I got back that I wanted to get it all down and

2:33:33write about it and stuff. I was having a really hard time with it because there was a lot of it

2:33:40that just required some distance from it. I had just come back, and I think in some ways there's

2:33:48some of the stuff that happened or didn't happen or whatever during the sabbatical that just,

2:33:52you know, I just need some time to think about it and process it. I'm still doing that.

2:33:57It ended up being seven months. I thought maybe it was going to be four to six and it ended up

2:34:02being seven and yeah. So the answer is, you know, I don't know if I'm going to write it or not.

2:34:11I think part of being on the podcast was, you know, getting a chance to like

2:34:15talk about it a little bit and maybe that will kickstart some interest and things like that.

2:34:21So. Well, I'm here for that. I did not have the exact date written down because I didn't want to,

2:34:27But I had a spidey sense of when six months rolled around

2:34:30And when you didn't come back at six months, I got a little worried. I never really I never really I would have still

2:34:37To reuse the analogy. I would have bet the house you'd come back

2:34:42But I maybe maybe after six months I would have started maybe betting the spare bedroom

2:34:48Because I got a little I got a little worried yeah, so would you want to talk about why you took a sabbatical?

2:34:55cool. Yeah, I mean, yeah, just a lot of a lot of years without a break and you know,

2:35:08I'm sure you can empathize with that. I've never even had, I've never even had a guest

2:35:12writer. Right? Yeah. So I understand you're you're you're hardcore. You're hardcore. I

2:35:19think for me it was like I just felt burned out and I had felt burned out for quite a

2:35:24while. And there were things in my life that just really felt like I was neglecting in a big way

2:35:30and really letting slip. My kids are both teenagers now, and before I know it, they're

2:35:35going to be gone, out of the house, although who knows, maybe they'll be right back.

2:35:40So...

2:35:42JS I know the feeling. Jonas is a freshman in college and he's in Boston.

2:35:47Yeah. Oh, wow. Yeah. So there was an opportunity there to spend a little bit more time on some

2:35:55other things in my life. And, you know, being very online for 20, 25 years is it's, um,

2:36:03maybe it's a thing that people shouldn't be doing and reading the news and reading Twitter

2:36:11and being really online and being really on social media. I don't know if it's good for

2:36:16people. And I was finding that it just wasn't good for me. Like it didn't feel good. It

2:36:23didn't. Yeah, I just needed to like, I think I needed to get away from it. Yeah. So I mean,

2:36:31so long story short, burnout. Yeah, I suspect. And it's one of those things as I've gotten

2:36:38older and I hopefully have kept as open a mind as I could hope for. And you know, like

2:36:44Like I told you before, strong ideas loosely help.

2:36:49And I've changed my stance on all sorts of things

2:36:53over the years, social stances, almost all or maybe all,

2:36:58to become even more liberal, more empathetic

2:37:03to other people and certainly to more groups of people.

2:37:08But one thing I've learned, especially I think

2:37:13In the last 10 years, from 40 to 50, part of the wisdom of age is that there's an

2:37:23awful lot of things that I rolled my eyes out in my youth and thought, "Ah, what kind

2:37:30of—that's weak," that you just have to experience it to understand it.

2:37:36And then when you do experience it, every single thing you say about it, or I would

2:37:42say about it, for aspects of my personal life or, you know, whatever. All are using the same canards

2:37:51and things that sound trite and obvious and a billion people have said before about the same

2:37:57thing, but that's because they're true, right? And that you just, sometimes you just have to

2:38:02experience it and then use the things you say about it are the things everybody else has always

2:38:07said about it, but those are the things that in my youth I rolled my eyes out. And the concept

2:38:12of burnout is one of them. And when there now there's certain examples like when NFL coaching

2:38:18is notoriously a long hours job there's the he just I think he just got entered in the Hall of

2:38:26Fame actually when I was a little kid the head coach of the Philadelphia Eagles was a guy named

2:38:30Dick Vermeil and he went on and he disappeared he wasn't coaching for a while he was like announcing

2:38:37games and then he came back and coached the St. Louis I think they were still in St. Louis

2:38:41yeah, St. Louis Rams to a Super Bowl when Kurt Warner was—and he finally won a Super Bowl.

2:38:46But when he was the coach of the Eagles in 1980, they went to the Super Bowl and lost to the

2:38:51Raiders in 1980. And I think he coached another year or two for the Eagles and then resigned. He

2:38:56wasn't fired. He resigned in "burnout." And he was in his late 30s? He was like a prodigy, you know,

2:39:03sort of like a Sean McVeigh, like a super young coach. He looked young. You look at the pictures,

2:39:09I can't but you know, he's might have been younger than the punter. You know what I mean?

2:39:12It's what do you mean he burned out?

2:39:13How the hell do you burn out as a coach and then I'd you read and he was only sleeping three or four hours a night

2:39:18And wasn't leaving the stadium seven days a week

2:39:21he just had a cot in his office and was sleeping three to four hours a day and

2:39:26just

2:39:28Making game plans and watching film of his own team and film of his opposing teams the whole season, you know

2:39:35And then in the offseason doing it, you know, and it's like okay

2:39:38I could you know then even as somebody was skeptical of the concept of burnout I was like, okay

2:39:43I get that, you know three or four hours of sleep a night and the other 18 hours all

2:39:49Focused on the work in a high-pressure public job. Okay, I get it. I get how that's not sustainable

2:39:55I'm kind of surprised he lasted as long, you know, five years or four years or whatever it was. I

2:40:02It would have been in my youth. I would have been very very skeptical of Jason Kottke's need for sabbatical

2:40:09No, I would have I I was just being honest and I will say I I don't feel like what I do at daring fireball

2:40:17I don't feel like I'm close or any closer to the to a burnout than I was 10 years ago or 15 years ago

2:40:23I also at this point in my life

2:40:26life, don't doubt that it could happen.

2:40:29Because the one thing I do know from the similarity

2:40:31of what you and I do is the relentlessness of it, right?

2:40:35And there are some times where my sight goes quiet

2:40:39for three or four days and that's,

2:40:40maybe it's like a mini sabbatical, right?

2:40:42There are times where I just, I do feel that.

2:40:45'Cause it is, it's relentless.

2:40:46It never stops, there's always more,

2:40:49the fact like it's good in the broad terms

2:40:52that there's always more stuff I wanna write about

2:40:54and more stuff I want to link to,

2:40:56then I will get around to writing about or linking to.

2:40:59It's better than the other way around.

2:41:01But on the other hand, it makes it relentless

2:41:04because there's never a constant sense

2:41:07in the back of my head that I didn't write enough today,

2:41:09I didn't get to that thing I wanted to link to,

2:41:12or by the time I get to it, it's too late, it's stale.

2:41:16I delent into a thing just yesterday

2:41:18about this fantastic investigation Reuters did

2:41:21over in Singapore and Indonesia,

2:41:24where there was this scam run by Dow,

2:41:27did you see me link to it?

2:41:28It's Dow Chemical said that they were gonna

2:41:30take used sneakers in Singapore,

2:41:34which is like a first-- - Yep, I did see that.

2:41:36- A first nation world,

2:41:37and they're gonna take these used sneakers

2:41:39and turn them into running tracks

2:41:41and playground soft material for kids.

2:41:44And then Reuters had the wisdom to say,

2:41:48"Hmm, Dow Chemical, not sure I trust them,

2:41:50put a bunch of air tags into 11 pairs of sneakers, and lo and behold, they're shipped over

2:41:56to Indonesia, which is more of a third-world country. So it's literally just publicly

2:42:03greenwashing. It's Dow saying, "Hey, plastics and rubbers are great because we take them

2:42:08and reuse them and turn them into things like soft mats for playgrounds." And in truth,

2:42:13all they were doing was taking garbage from a rich country, Singapore, and dumping it

2:42:17into a poor country, Indonesia, against, explicitly against the laws of Indonesia,

2:42:23which set up laws for health and safety about the import of

2:42:27unexpected or unclean used clothing, exactly to prevent this.

2:42:31Dow Chemical, you know what I mean? It's, but it came out seven days ago, and I, somebody sent it

2:42:37to me and I was like, "Oh, that is perfect fodder for Daring Fireball." I'd be interested in it

2:42:41without the air tags angle, but combine it with the air tags and, you know, I sometimes write

2:42:45about Apple stuff. I was like, "This is perfect!" It took me six days to link to it, and I was

2:42:50kind of bummed when I linked to it yesterday, because I was like, "It's kind of stale."

2:42:54But that's nonstop. That's one example from one post. Nonstop, seven days a week, 52 weeks

2:43:02a year, 365 days a year. You know, maybe not 365, right? I got to feel so bad when I go

2:43:08quiet on Christmas Day. But it's certainly 52 weeks a year every year for 20 years. It

2:43:15is relentless. And I could, you know, maybe, you know, maybe it's the fact that you're

2:43:18five years ahead of me, my sabbatical's coming up in five years.

2:43:21[laughter]

2:43:21Tom: Yeah, it could be. It could be.

2:43:24David: Well, let me tell you. So—

2:43:25Tom; Yeah, I mean, for me, for me, like, the—there's a couple different things that I sort of

2:43:33identified, like, as problems, and one of them is that relentlessness that you mentioned,

2:43:40where I, especially for my stuff, which is sort of more sort of general, like you, you know,

2:43:46you have your, your sort of Apple wheelhouse and that sort of stuff. And, but like my site is more

2:43:53like just anything interesting. I mean, your, your site's a little bit like that actually,

2:43:57but like my site, it's like anything that's interesting. So it's like, I am always sort

2:44:01of working because like I am always sort of moving through the world. And so that's an interesting

2:44:06observation, or this is an interesting little fact thing that I, you know, I'm talking about

2:44:10with a friend or something like that. So there's this sense of, "I am never off work."

2:44:14And then the other thing is, what was the other thing I was going to say?

2:44:19JS Well, I'll just say that before you think about it, but I describe my site as being the

2:44:25guy at the gym who only works his arms. So it's, yeah, I do my legs a little, but it's lopsided.

2:44:33It's severely lopsided in the interest of Apple stuff. But then during the Trump years,

2:44:39it semi-evolved into the semi-political site that I thought about writing back in 2002 instead of

2:44:46writing about tech and design. Yeah, so the other thing that I remembered is that it's the constant

2:44:54feedback that you get on, like, every single thing that I write there is some little bit of feedback.

2:44:59Like, it's, you know, likes on Twitter or Mastodon, it's people replying, it's emails that I get,

2:45:04And it's sort of this constant judgment coming at you that for me kind of got to be a problem,

2:45:11I think. You know, I think over the years, like, you develop a thick skin and it becomes something

2:45:17that you're just like, "Oh, yeah, like, people are going to be angry about this thing and, like,

2:45:20I can judge. Like, if I write something, like, I know what the feedback is already going to be.

2:45:26And I'm sure you have this too. Oh, people are going to try and argue this or argue that or

2:45:32whatever. And I know what the feedback is, but somewhere in the last four, five, six years,

2:45:38that skin got a lot thinner and it started affecting me a lot more. And I think that part

2:45:46of the burnout there was just sort of this subjection of my psyche or soul to all of this

2:45:53feedback. Negative or positive, it doesn't really matter, it's just feedback. I don't think it's

2:45:58natural for people to get that much feedback during a day, day after day after day. And I

2:46:04think after a while it just really kind of ground me down, you know?

2:46:07JS That's really interesting because I do think, and I've thought about this, it's something that

2:46:14wasn't obvious to me at the start. Like when I started, all I wanted to do is I wanted to be

2:46:19a writer, I wanted to write, and I didn't want to answer to anybody or work my way up any ladder.

2:46:23And I already knew web technology and I was already so excited about people like you and

2:46:28Dave Weiner and all the people we mentioned earlier and Dean Allen. And I knew that I knew

2:46:32that I could do it. And I could do it technically. And I knew that it was, I think, where I wanted my

2:46:37writing to be. And I just wanted to get it out there. And it's that ego part of, you know,

2:46:42wanting to do stuff in public. There's, you know, it, there's no work around it. You have to have

2:46:47an ego, right? Nobody runs, nobody runs for political office without some sort of ego and

2:46:53self-centered. And I've always had that drive to create little things. I used to, you know,

2:46:57as a little kid draw little comic strips and write stories and just slip them under my mom's door at

2:47:01night. I just have always had a need to make things for other people to see. And that's all

2:47:06I really thought about. And I didn't think about the thick skin nature that's required. But as I've

2:47:14gone over the years, especially in the Twitter years, and especially in the late Twitter years

2:47:20where Twitter got angry, culturally. And I don't see how anybody could deny that. And that's pre

2:47:26Musk. I realized that, oh, this is the reason, one of the reasons I've been able to keep going

2:47:34and so, you know, as you and I, me and you, Jason, look around and we're like, where the

2:47:39hell is everybody else? You know, I mean, I really anticipate that I've said this numerous times,

2:47:45probably the last time you were on, I thought in the early days that this was the future and every,

2:47:51this is what everybody would be doing, you know. I thought there'd be more, more people doing what

2:47:56we do because I thought the tools are only going to get easier and the fact that me and you and

2:48:00Heather Armstrong know how to write HTML code and we know how to design our own stuff and we

2:48:08know how to set up something as, you know, not that setting up movable type was all that hard,

2:48:13but it's certainly beyond the ken of most people. There's many, many reasons that you,

2:48:16you and I are among the last people standing doing this as a full-time job, but the thick skin part

2:48:23I didn't anticipate, but I realize in hindsight that somehow came and comes very naturally to me.

2:48:31And mine hasn't worn thinner, and I don't know why. And I think that might explain the sort of

2:48:39difference there. But I can imagine there are times where my thick skinned—something

2:48:47starts sanding down on it. And I—yeah, you know, it can get to you. You know, the one—

2:48:55Yeah, and like I was saying, it's not even necessarily negative feedback. Like,

2:49:00you can get positive feedback and that warps your deal in a whole different way.

2:49:07Right, no, that's true because then it steers you towards writing for what people want to read,

2:49:14which isn't necessarily what you should be writing. I mean, certainly in my racket, in

2:49:19Apple-focused, hyper-focused part of Daring Fireball, the trap to fall into is only writing

2:49:27positive things about Apple because there are so many people, so many people out there who do their

2:49:36fandom of Apple is sort of dogmatic, religious, I don't know how to describe it, but they only

2:49:43want to hear good things about Apple. And you can see it on sites that have comments. I think Mac

2:49:51Rumors is a great sort of id of the Apple universe in their comment section, where if you read,

2:50:00if you ever look on Mac Rumors when there's a story that, you know, is more or less,

2:50:04or obviously negative about Apple. So take, for example, last week there, Joanna Stern and

2:50:09Nicole Nguyen at the Wall Street Journal had a blockbuster story, truly blockbuster story. I

2:50:14won't get into it. Marco Arman and I talked about it for over an hour on my last episode of my show.

2:50:18But the basic gist is if somebody has your iPhone and the passcode to the iPhone, they not only can

2:50:25access everything on the iPhone, but they can just go right into settings and change your iCloud

2:50:30password without knowing your existing iCloud password, and then they own your iCloud password,

2:50:34too. And this is by design. It's not a bug. It's there because so many people forget their

2:50:39iCloud passwords that it's built in as a feature. And Google does the same thing with Android,

2:50:44and I proved it with my Android phone. But that's obviously a negative story about Apple.

2:50:49And thieves have picked—the Joanna Stern and Nicole story was about the fact that

2:50:55thieves have picked this up, and they're snooping people's passcodes in bars,

2:50:59and then when they steal their phone, they've already got their passcode, and then they

2:51:02they steal this and they use it and take money out of their venmos and their bank accounts and

2:51:07they open up apple cards and quick charge things and people don't even know and the worst part is

2:51:12the victims don't even know what the hell goes on all they know is they lost their phone they lost

2:51:15their phone and they next thing you know they're they can't even get into iCloud when they get home

2:51:21on their MacBook what the hell I can't get why can't I get into iCloud and next thing you know

2:51:25they're getting emails from their bank saying that, you know, they lost $10,000, blah, blah, blah.

2:51:30You read, like, the MAC rumors story that linked to and summarized that story, you'll find people

2:51:36in the comments who will defend Apple. And again, there is a defensible angle here on the customer

2:51:40support, but you'll find these people who are angry that this article was posted in the first

2:51:44place, right? And an awful lot of Apple sites, not ones I've read, but—and especially Apple sites

2:51:51that have come and gone because also I think that catering to that crowd makes it unsustainable,

2:51:57right? You're not going to last if you're trying to do that, although I guess Fox News has made

2:52:02it work, but you know, that's a perfect example, right? You don't want to be the Fox News—nobody

2:52:07should be the Fox News of anything, right? Fox News shouldn't be the Fox News of conservative

2:52:12U.S. politics, but there have been an awful lot of Apple-oriented sites over the years

2:52:17that are certainly not detrimental to democracy. But it's not a healthy way to do things, right?

2:52:27And you know, in that feedback cycle, even if you don't have a central theme or topic other

2:52:34than the general interest of modern life and art and whatever you want to say, you're right though,

2:52:40I could see it. It's not healthy to be getting the sort of ding ding ding, you know, there is

2:52:45is like a sort of gamification and slot machine, you know, "Oh, they make these dings really

2:52:51pleasant and they're all at a pitch that has been studied to be pleasant to the human."

2:52:56Every single little thing about a slot machine is designed to keep you doing it, right?

2:53:02Yep, yep. All right, so tell me about during the sabbatical. See, here's the thing I don't

2:53:08understand is you knew you were going to take three or four months, but didn't I, as I thought

2:53:14about it, I was like, well, what happens like one month in when you're, you are reading

2:53:18something, right? You still read some stuff on the web or did you, you didn't like, no,

2:53:22you didn't read anything? You, you, Ted Kaczynski did? I basically, basically for seven months,

2:53:28I probably read no more than 10 articles on the web.

2:53:33- Huh, well then that answers my question,

2:53:36which is how could you possibly resist linking

2:53:38to something that you read

2:53:39that you felt like you had to link to?

2:53:41You just didn't read it.

2:53:43- No, I just didn't read it.

2:53:45John, the extent to which I dropped doing the website

2:53:50like a hot potato would just astound you.

2:53:54Like it was gone.

2:53:56It was just gone.

2:53:58And I, because I knew that that's the way it had to be. Like I,

2:54:02I knew I just needed to completely set it down. I read books instead.

2:54:06I kept up with Instagram.

2:54:08I completely dropped Twitter and actually I haven't really picked Twitter back

2:54:11up again. Even, even since then I.

2:54:14Are you mastadonning though? You're mastadonning.

2:54:17I am. I am mastadonning. Yeah. Mastadonning is interesting. I like it. It's,

2:54:21it's, you know, it reminds me a little bit of Twitter in the earlier days,

2:54:24but also of a sort of a different thing.

2:54:27Yeah.

2:54:29- That's fascinating.

2:54:31And it really, seriously, it was my single biggest,

2:54:35I mean, here we are three hours, 20 minutes into this.

2:54:38And it's honestly, the whole reason I wanted to have you

2:54:41on the show is how did you not link to,

2:54:43how did you not break the sabbatical to link to something?

2:54:45'Cause I don't think, that's the thing

2:54:47I don't think I could do.

2:54:49But I guess I could do it if I completely unplugged, right?

2:54:53- Yeah, I mean, I think there were a handful of things

2:54:57that I did, there were a few quick links,

2:55:00like maybe three, four that I linked to.

2:55:03I can't even remember what they were now,

2:55:04but it seemed like the type of thing,

2:55:05it was like, oh, okay, I'm just gonna post this one thing

2:55:08and then put it back down.

2:55:10And then I made a post in October,

2:55:13because like you, people were getting a little bit antsy

2:55:16about, hey, are you coming back, what's going on?

2:55:19So I just kind of made a post, I'm like, I'm not back yet,

2:55:21I will be back at some point.

2:55:23And, and, you know, I think your guess was correct.

2:55:26I don't think there was any, I don't think I ever seriously entertained not coming back.

2:55:30I was always going to come back, but it was just a matter of like, I just, I really just need to decompress completely from this so that I can start with.

2:55:39Not quite a blank slate, but somewhere in the ballpark of that.

2:55:43Do you feel rejuvenated?

2:55:45I did when I came back.

2:55:47It's a couple, let's see, it's three months, three months into it.

2:55:50because I think I started at the beginning of November.

2:55:53The winter has been like we started at three hours ago,

2:55:57three and a half hours ago, whenever the hell it was.

2:55:59- Yesterday.

2:56:00- Like winters are hard.

2:56:01Yeah, exactly, yesterday.

2:56:02Winters are tough for me.

2:56:03And like this winter has been more tough than usual

2:56:07just because of there's a lot of family

2:56:09sort of stuff going on

2:56:11that I don't really care to talk about,

2:56:13but there's a lot of going on,

2:56:16and I did not really get the opportunity

2:56:20to sort of come back and really think about like how I want to do this differently going forward.

2:56:27I kind of fell back into old kind of ruts and old kind of habits.

2:56:31So, you know, three, three months down the road here, I'm, I'm, I am not burned out by any stretch of the imagination, but I am like, crap, I see that stuff coming in the rear view mirror, like sooner than I thought I would.

2:56:43And hopefully things are starting to even out and level out in, in my life right now

2:56:49so that I can spend some more time focusing on that stuff.

2:56:53It's focusing on work.

2:56:55Focusing on the site.

2:56:56What not only like writing the site, but like how I might want to go about it

2:57:00differently in order to make it more sustainable because at this point, I want

2:57:05to hit 30, I want to hit 35, 40, who knows, but like, I want to keep it going.

2:57:11And I want to keep myself going.

2:57:13I don't want to be 55, 60 years old

2:57:16and I am a husk of a human being.

2:57:19But God, he had a great website.

2:57:20I don't think that's a very good trade off for me

2:57:25or for the world or for anybody.

2:57:27So I gotta try and figure it out.

2:57:30- Before I forget, I did,

2:57:32I don't wanna let your homework go to waste.

2:57:34I asked you, it's minimal homework for the show,

2:57:38how many posts you've posted to kotke.org over the years?

2:57:42and the answer is about 40,000.

2:57:44- All right, so 40,000.

2:57:45And again, this speaks to the relentlessness

2:57:49and the sort of body of work.

2:57:52So my count is 32,000-ish,

2:57:56and that's not counting like the sponsor ads,

2:57:58which I technically go through movable type,

2:58:00but I'm subtracting, which is fascinating

2:58:03because you're at 25 years and I'm at 20,

2:58:06and that 32 to 40 is pretty much exactly the same ratio.

2:58:11It's kind of freaky.

2:58:13It's a lot, you know.

2:58:15Five years ago, I did a word count.

2:58:19It is not, that's not easy to do,

2:58:21or it's not hard, but there's no automatic feature

2:58:24in movable type to do it.

2:58:26I like did an export to like a single file,

2:58:30or I forget how movable, I think that's how it works,

2:58:32which is crazy, it's like, but you know,

2:58:34computers are very, you know.

2:58:36It's one of those things that you,

2:58:38my broken grew up in the 80s and 90s mind thinks well you can't export all of that to one text

2:58:45file but of course you can and it's not even fit yeah it'll fit and it doesn't take that long but

2:58:51i i wrote like a script and it omitted my block quotes which are extensive at times and so it was

2:58:58only counting original words i forget if i counted my headlines or not i think i didn't because a lot

2:59:04of the times I lazy out and just use the other site's headline as my headline, you know,

2:59:09Wall Street Journal colon, just publish their headline. So just counting my words,

2:59:14I forget where I was at, but it was either a million or two million words of original writing.

2:59:20My word count might be higher, probably is higher than yours on average, but yeah, maybe not by,

2:59:25maybe not as far ahead as you think though, but it's the post though that counts, like, okay,

2:59:32I'm going to send this to all the people who read my site, and there's a certain responsibility

2:59:37for that. And it's uncanny how similar the pace we're on is. That's weird, it's weird.

2:59:43I noticed--

2:59:44It's also weird that you-- that like, both of us write like, several books a year worth of like,

2:59:50words, like every year, but yeah, that's--

2:59:55I-- but I don't--

2:59:56I feel like I couldn't sit down and write a book.

2:59:58I don't think so either. I could, I guess, you know, I've often said, in theory, I could do a

3:00:05collection, although I would probably pay someone else to pick the ones to choose, because I don't

3:00:10know that I'm the right person to choose them. But that's not writing a book, a collection of

3:00:14the greatest hits of Daring Fireball with commentary. I mean, it's a book, it is a book,

3:00:19but it's not writing a book, right? I mean, it honestly feels to me like, I don't know,

3:00:26telling me to put together an airplane, you know, or fix an airplane, you know, this airplane

3:00:30doesn't start. What do you do? I don't know. I mean, I write every day and like you said,

3:00:36we write books, lengths of words every year, but to sit down and write one 60,000 word plus

3:00:44narrative, it's not the way my brain works. It's, I feel like I found the medium for my writing

3:00:51brain. I often wonder, here's a question for you, I wonder what I would do if I had been born a

3:00:58generation earlier, you know, pre-web. Because I absolutely, I can't help but think I have had the

3:01:05itch to write. And I probably still would have gone to the student newspaper at whatever college

3:01:12I would have gone to, born 25 or 30 years earlier. But I don't know what I would have done afterwards.

3:01:18I really don't. I think I would have wanted to be a writer. I don't know though. I may not,

3:01:25I don't know. It might be that I'd be doing something else and in the back of my head,

3:01:29gone to my grave with a regret. Boy, you know, maybe next year I'll try writing a book or

3:01:35writing something or something and never doing it. I don't know. I don't know what I, honest to

3:01:39God, don't know what I would do other than this. Nothing else I don't think would have stuck.

3:01:45Yeah, I'm I'm not sure that I would be a writer because for me the the the attraction of it

3:01:54initially certainly and I think still to some extent is like that it's writing on the web

3:01:59and it's and it's not only writing but there's this curating part of it too that I really

3:02:05focus on. I was going to be a scientist before I decided to pivot to trying to figure out

3:02:12how to make a living on the web. I went to grad school, I was gonna get a PhD in ceramic

3:02:17engineering. Yeah. I don't know why, I'm not laughing. Like making gorilla glass, maybe.

3:02:25Right. I don't know. I'm not laughing at the field, I actually think it's fascinating and I

3:02:29just was bitching on Mastodon yesterday because I cracked the back of my iPhone for the second year

3:02:34of a row that I cannot believe we make these things out of glass, which is the dumbest material

3:02:40Did you go boss? We make them out of and so I hope there's some ceramic engineer out there

3:02:44Literally a ceramic engineer who's who's got an idea for a ceramic that won't crack

3:02:49But will pass through the the pass through charging which is why they shifted to glass in the first place

3:02:54So i'm not laughing at the field of ceramic engineering. I think there's

3:02:57It's as essential and as bright a future as ever. I'm just laughing at the idea of

3:03:03You know missing you as a voice in my life on a daily basis while you're out there baking

3:03:10the seventh generation gorilla glass in an oven.

3:03:13- Yeah, exactly.

3:03:16- The live, before we got, I mean, we've gone too long,

3:03:18but I have noticed though, I mean,

3:03:20to circle back to design and stuff like that,

3:03:22you've subtly, not redesigned,

3:03:25but tweaked the Kottke layout where your,

3:03:29what you call quick links, instead of,

3:03:32for a couple of years what you were doing

3:03:34was sort of batching them up,

3:03:37I don't know if they were by the day,

3:03:39or how were you doing that?

3:03:40You'd sort of put them in a multi-column pool

3:03:44in between true posts.

3:03:46Like you'd have post, post,

3:03:49and then a collection of quick links

3:03:52in a multi-column tag pool,

3:03:56then a post, a post,

3:03:58and then another quick link collection from earlier.

3:04:02Like how, I never quite discerned,

3:04:05I figure knowing you it was probably hand-pooled.

3:04:09This is enough to tie off as one pool

3:04:12and I'll move on to the next,

3:04:13or was it automated in some way?

3:04:15- So it worked slightly differently on the website

3:04:20and in RSS.

3:04:21So on the website, there was one main post,

3:04:24and then under that first main post

3:04:26there was a quick link section,

3:04:28and that was just the last 10 quick links,

3:04:30like reverse chronological.

3:04:32And then there was a button to,

3:04:34you could click into like the main sort of quick links archive.

3:04:37But for RSS, what I did was every few hours,

3:04:41if there were two or more quick links,

3:04:43I would bundle those up and send them to RSS.

3:04:45Manually or, or automated?

3:04:48Automated. It was all like crown jobs and PHP scripts.

3:04:52And PHP. I was going to ask what language. Yeah.

3:04:54You've unbundled that on the website and now the website is just purely

3:04:59reverse chronological. When did that happen?

3:05:02I don't think I noticed when that happened.

3:05:03- Probably, I don't know, a month, month and a half

3:05:06after I got back from my sabbatical.

3:05:07So, you know, end of December, maybe sometime in January.

3:05:10I think it was probably sometime in January.

3:05:12- I like it, I like it.

3:05:13- There's a vector here.

3:05:14I feel like I'm moving towards something.

3:05:16Like the way that the quick links worked,

3:05:19it was getting a little long in the tooth

3:05:20and I wanted to move away from that.

3:05:22And because I feel like I'm putting a little bit more energy

3:05:26these days into the quick links,

3:05:27there's more of them than there used to be.

3:05:29And they're more frequent.

3:05:30I wanted to highlight them more on the front page

3:05:33than they had been.

3:05:34So that was kind of the impetus there.

3:05:36- I like it.

3:05:37I will just say, A, I like the change.

3:05:40And I think it, I don't know why.

3:05:42I don't know, it just, it's in my ears, not my eyes.

3:05:46It just reads better to me, and it reads more like you.

3:05:50And I don't know if it's coincident or not.

3:05:53I just feel like when, my sense as a reader

3:05:57is that when you came back from sabbatical,

3:05:59you needed to warm up a little.

3:06:01I don't, I was so happy when you came back

3:06:05and it was great and it was, you were back,

3:06:08but I honestly feel like it's more recently,

3:06:13let's just say it's in 2023, like post-New Year,

3:06:18there are more stretches of kotke.org

3:06:21where I have to close the tab because it's,

3:06:26I've already ruined half my day

3:06:29with the links, you know, and I'm not even caught up yet. And it's so crack from my,

3:06:37this is all, god damn it, the next very, the next one too, son of a bitch. You know, like

3:06:44a hitting streak, you know. There's a famous story, I forget who had it, but there was

3:06:50the famous year, yeah, it's the famous year where Ted Williams hit .400 and Joe DiMaggio

3:06:56had the 56-game hitting streak in baseball. I forget which year. I should—the fact that I know most of

3:07:02this but not which year, but that's bizarre, A, that there's these two freakish stats in baseball.

3:07:08Ted Williams, last guy to hit .400. Joe DiMaggio has a 56-game hitting streak. In other words,

3:07:13for people who aren't baseball fans, 56 games in a row, he got at least one hit. But the most

3:07:19amazing stat of that season was at some point in the middle of the year, and I don't know the

3:07:24number, but Ted Williams had something like 14 or 15 consecutive at bats with a hit, which is—let's

3:07:30say you're hitting 400, so it's a little bit less than a coin flip. It's less than a coin flip,

3:07:37but like 14 or 15—or I forget what the number is, but it was freakish. But that's what—Kotke's

3:07:43been on to me, and I'm not just buttering you up because you've been so generous with your time on

3:07:48my show, but you've had more streaks like that where it's not just every day you've got like

3:07:53Something that I think is gold and I'm jealous that I'm not the one who found it first and linked to it

3:07:57but post post quick link post son of a bitch every single one of these is a

3:08:03Feature length article or a 15-minute YouTube or a thing and post post post post all right in

3:08:11My wheelhouse crack cocaine for my information

3:08:14Addled bored mind you I'd be in that to me and you've been doing this for 25 years to me

3:08:22But I feel like you've had more of those stretches of at bat post post post that are all

3:08:27Gold in the new in the new year then November December, and maybe that's just me. I don't know

3:08:33What was what's your self perception of coming back?

3:08:36Would do you feel like I needed it warm up or were you where you all right back in the saddle?

3:08:41No, I mean it took me a while to warm up my kids

3:08:45and I have this joke about if we're watching a show together or whatever and we take like a little like break and

3:08:51and we'll come back to it after a week and I'll turn it on and while I'm finding the show or

3:08:56whatever I'm like, "Okay, so what's the show about again?" And they're like, "Uh..."

3:09:01But I really felt like coming back I was like, "How do I do this again? Okay,

3:09:04so I have to do this and this." And yeah, it definitely took me a while. I think January,

3:09:09you know, I think you're right about the timing. It's, you know, like January I felt like I got

3:09:14back into the groove again. I had more time in January than I did in December. December was a

3:09:19a little bit busy with with family and some travel and it always that and January. Yeah,

3:09:25yeah, exactly. And then January actually had some time to like stretch and crack my fingers

3:09:31and like really get involved. So I'm, you know, I'm glad that's, you know, resonating

3:09:36at least with one person. Well, it's good. Yeah, it definitely took a while to get going.

3:09:41It's it. I hope it didn't come across as a backhanded compliment, but it

3:09:46Because it was good when it came back but to me

3:09:49And again to to go back to the ted williams. Well, actually I think that's a bad analogy

3:09:54I was going to say to go back to ted Williams. I was going to say it's like when he

3:09:57Left banger league baseball to go fly fighter pilot missions in korea, which is bananas, right?

3:10:03imagine if mike trout left the major league baseball now to go fly an airplane in a

3:10:09Dangerous war zone for a couple of years and then came back but I actually think when ted williams came back

3:10:15he actually started hitting great right away.

3:10:17But-- - Yeah, he did.

3:10:20- So forget that analogy, but--

3:10:22- Ted Williams is a better baseball player

3:10:24than I am a blogger, I can live with that.

3:10:26- I don't know, I don't know.

3:10:27Well, I didn't mean it as a backhanded compliment,

3:10:30but it seems to me like you agree in hindsight.

3:10:34It's just sometimes it's hard when you're the person

3:10:36creating it to have that sort of perspective.

3:10:38That's the end of my questions, I don't know.

3:10:40I mean, do you have any questions?

3:10:42I mean, do you have anything else you wanted to get to?

3:10:44I mean, it seems, you know, probably gone on long enough. Yeah, I mean, I think three hours and

3:10:52how many ever minutes we've got going here is probably good. I've actually got to go pick up

3:10:58my kids in like 20 minutes. All right. Well, to say that I am appreciative of your time to sit

3:11:05here and do this at this length with me, it's funny because we ostensibly originally had a hard

3:11:11stop 90 minutes ago and you told me yeah exactly we don't have that hard stop anymore so if we're

3:11:17on a roll we can keep going well i feel like we were on a roll and i appreciate it greatly this

3:11:23is my favorite episode of the show that i've done in a very long time no offense to any other guests

3:11:29who've been on show recently i love you all i love you all fuck them fuck them whatever i i

3:11:36Needless to say, I think at this point, I don't know that I need to repeat your URL

3:11:41for people looking to find your find iProtext products, but it is at kottke.org and on

3:11:49Mastodon, you know, I've been instead of giving addresses because it's I don't know,

3:11:53it's like at kottke@mastodon.social or I don't know which instance you're on. You know, I said

3:11:59to Marco Arman on the last episode, it's better, you know what, on Mastodon, just use your favorite

3:12:03Mastodon client and search for Kotki and you'll find both Jason and the kottke.org posting bot.

3:12:10And that's, you know, that's pretty much all you need to know. But I appreciate your time. I will

3:12:14also just toss in here an extra thanks to our fine, very fine sponsors. What do we have? We

3:12:19had Trade Coffee. Get a free bag of fresh coffee with any subscription at drinktrade.com/thetalkshow.

3:12:26collide, K-O-L-I-D-E, collide.com/the-talk-show. That's the cross-platform endpoint security

3:12:32solution for teams that value privacy and transparency. And, Memberful,

3:12:38you can monetize your passion with membership. See you in 25 years.

3:12:40All right, sounds good, Jon.

3:12:43I hope so. I really do. I think we can do it.