0:00:00hello everybody we are live from las
0:00:03vegas with our CES extravaganza
0:00:06extravaganza is it extravaganza
0:00:10not really no I'm just kidding and say
0:00:11we're going to talk about stars for
0:00:12three hours as a little exchange between
0:00:16one of our listeners and the ever
0:00:20watching ever listening up there folks
0:00:22there in the cloud that's why I see
0:00:23everything
0:00:24peter brock power was tweeting at us
0:00:28about this and he said an FYI up there
0:00:30is hosted on AWS Little Snitch told me
0:00:33so AWS Amazon Web Services and little
0:00:35stitches a firewall program to tell you
0:00:37where computers connected to ya and up
0:00:39there on Twitter responded not true we
0:00:42built our own stack from the ground up
0:00:43and host our service on this stack so
0:00:46I'm not quite sure what little snitch
0:00:47was on about maybe it's connected AWS
0:00:49for some ancillary things but straight
0:00:51from the up their horses mouse mouth
0:00:54they are not using AWS they have built
0:00:55their own stack which is what I was
0:00:56talking about the last show whatever
0:00:57mysterious technology they're using
0:00:59presumably the whole point the company
0:01:01is not to write in iOS and mac app that
0:01:04connects to s3 like that's not you don't
0:01:08I don't think for transfer layer would
0:01:10do a start-up and focus on that because
0:01:12there's a million of those things
0:01:13already
0:01:13well I mean they could have also been
0:01:15working a layer above that like they
0:01:17could have been using easy to servers
0:01:19like some other part of AWS as part of
0:01:21their overly know just like how I cloud
0:01:23uses some AWS stuff and some as your
0:01:26stuff as far as we knew forever ago
0:01:28yeah but that like what would the user
0:01:31may even even a c2 like I don't know it
0:01:34just seems it seems counter but that's
0:01:36all there is that's all the rest up
0:01:37there there's no it's a icon is built on
0:01:39top of this whole bunch of other stuff
0:01:40like that's just this you can use the
0:01:42street the storage back end or view
0:01:44movie if you don't have your own data
0:01:45centers or whatever you may be good bc
0:01:4724 compute stuff but i don't know i just
0:01:49always imagine whatever they're doing
0:01:51being more interesting than that
0:01:53fair enough any other follow-up through
0:01:56this and follow up just because it's I
0:01:58don't know if there's any information
0:01:59here but if you throw in some follow
0:02:01just because you couldn't stand not
0:02:02having me
0:02:03no i mean like i was i had this is a
0:02:05topic section before when I said you
0:02:06know we talked about this on a pet show
0:02:08so it's kind of follow-up but i'm not
0:02:09sure how filled information it is a
0:02:12friend of mine was messaging me today
0:02:14he's like so how do you feel about the
0:02:15headphone port going away from the
0:02:17iphone 7 and I said a you obviously
0:02:20don't know Claud cast and be at what do
0:02:24you know what are you talking about that
0:02:26i missed some news or something is like
0:02:28oh yeah they were talking about it
0:02:29before but it wasn't confirmed until
0:02:30today I like woody what are you talking
0:02:32about like I really thought like that
0:02:33Apple had announced that there was gonna
0:02:35be no headphone cord on the iphone 7 but
0:02:37I forget the regular people don't know
0:02:39what confirmed means so this is a former
0:02:41is a Forbes article it says the
0:02:44headlines iphone 7 leaks confirm in
0:02:47single quotes Apple abandoning headphone
0:02:49jack so they put they did the work for
0:02:51you they put in scare quotes in the
0:02:53headline at least have the decency to
0:02:54say confirm doing air quotes now confirm
0:02:57any way more so we talked about this on
0:03:00a path show more rumors more supposed
0:03:04park leaks this one has a neat little
0:03:06concept image because you can never
0:03:08remember story you gotta have someone do
0:03:09a mock-up image of the iphone 7 and i'm
0:03:12looking at this mock-up image and what
0:03:15do you guys think it looks a little thin
0:03:17to me but anyway this is more smoke for
0:03:20this potential fire of the headphone
0:03:22port going why i don't know i think it's
0:03:23too early to make any kind of call but
0:03:26if I keep it is not that forms a great
0:03:29track record but it's making me think
0:03:31about it against making you think how
0:03:33Apple could explain this inevitability
0:03:36if not this year then next to the year
0:03:38after the year after and I think a lot
0:03:40of the stuff in this article is a good
0:03:43way that they might explain it the idea
0:03:44being that the phone would be smart
0:03:47about where it sends audio output
0:03:49depending on context i wish all of apple
0:03:51slices were smarter this way all the
0:03:53Apple services and devices so if I'm
0:03:56listening on my wireless headphones you
0:03:58know my car explain to bluetooth I get
0:04:00out of the car
0:04:00it's just my wireless earbuds or
0:04:02whatever I sit down at my desk and it
0:04:05switches to outputting through the
0:04:06headphone jack of my computer or
0:04:09something I mean like situational
0:04:11awareness where you don't have to be
0:04:12plugging and unplugging things will just
0:04:14know based on your location of the
0:04:16devices there or your preferred sound
0:04:17output devices that and then you say see
0:04:21isn't that better than headphone jack
0:04:22and say yeah that actually worked that
0:04:24would kind of be better than headphone
0:04:25jack and lets you could make your phone
0:04:27thinner so everybody's happy
0:04:29I don't know if that world is in arrive
0:04:31in time for the iphone 7 but one way to
0:04:34sell the future I guess
0:04:35yeah I mean we we talked this to death a
0:04:38few episodes back so it is i don't think
0:04:39we spend too much time on it but I i do
0:04:41think the world of not having the
0:04:44headphone jack is probably on its way I
0:04:46think as we discussed last time it's
0:04:48probably still a few years off mean it i
0:04:51think the one of the biggest supports
0:04:53for this is to look at the macbook one
0:04:55and the macbook one has two ports the
0:04:58multi-purpose USB / charging port and a
0:05:02headphone jack and they couldn't justify
0:05:04any other ports on that but they can
0:05:06justify a headphone jack and i think
0:05:07that goes to show just how often they're
0:05:09used and bluetooth headphones do exist
0:05:13because it for quite some time
0:05:14there are some decent ones there are
0:05:17very few good or even great ones and
0:05:21there's a lot of trade-offs to bluetooth
0:05:22headphones that make them not only less
0:05:25good in some ways would actually
0:05:26unusable for certain applications so
0:05:29it's it is not a clean transition i'm
0:05:33guessing that that one like kind of
0:05:36crazy translated million times from
0:05:38different languages story that we got
0:05:40back then back in a month ago or two
0:05:42that one story about how they're just be
0:05:44a passive special lightning adapter for
0:05:46this new revision of the Lightning port
0:05:48that would basically have a DAC on the
0:05:52phone and have it be able to send analog
0:05:55audio through a cheap passive attempt
0:05:57earth through the port into a headphone
0:05:59jack port through like a little breakout
0:06:01cable i think that's pretty plausible
0:06:02and so if they that I think is the most
0:06:05plausible explanation I've heard for why
0:06:08this might not be a big deal if they can
0:06:10make a cheap-ass adapter like that and
0:06:13and you know just said that to you or
0:06:15even included in the box if it's really
0:06:16that cheap and passive they probably
0:06:18won't it'll be more likely they would
0:06:20sell it for thirty bucks but you know
0:06:21the weekend we can dream but i think you
0:06:25know where there's smoke there's usually
0:06:26some fire and I think there's enough
0:06:28smoke around this that I would move it
0:06:30from unlikely to somewhat likely
0:06:35and I think if we if we consider that
0:06:37that like special lightning adapter
0:06:39passive adapter thing that makes it all
0:06:42that makes it more I don't know
0:06:46digestible it's like it makes it suck
0:06:49less
0:06:49basically with all these type of stories
0:06:52like there's a build to the
0:06:53inevitability until we eventually get
0:06:55the real parts leaks especially with the
0:06:57phones you know as the date of the new
0:06:58phone approaches were pretty far away
0:07:00now so I was thinking that this next
0:07:03round of stories about this rumor
0:07:06mmm nudge it slightly more towards the
0:07:09realm of possibility but it's still so
0:07:11far out that it's within the realm of
0:07:14things that could end up being totally
0:07:15wrong but we'll keep watching keep
0:07:16watching it knowledge ever closer and
0:07:18we'll go basically know for sure when
0:07:20the real parts likes come out because I
0:07:21don't think we've had a significant
0:07:23iphone revision and a long time where we
0:07:26haven't got to look at pretty much every
0:07:27piece of this thing all disassembled
0:07:29before it arrives it will probably know
0:07:31it by april or may I mean up and
0:07:35especially like this like you may not
0:07:36know everything like this be
0:07:38can you not you can't figure out all the
0:07:40software features obviously and then
0:07:42hardware features sometimes hard to tell
0:07:44from parts but things like a doesn't
0:07:46have a hole for the headphone port to go
0:07:48and we'll be able to tell just by
0:07:49looking at cases
0:07:49yeah and like the back case is often one
0:07:51of the very first part to leak it kid
0:07:53probably that's something like we'll
0:07:55probably know this one by the spring you
0:07:56know really
0:07:58alright what's awesome these days Marco
0:07:59our first sponsor this week is
0:08:01audible.com audible.com has more than a
0:08:04hundred and eighty thousand audiobooks
0:08:06and spoken word audio products get a
0:08:08free 30-day trial at audible.com / ATP
0:08:11if you want to listen to it audible has
0:08:13it
0:08:14listen to audiobooks from virtually
0:08:15every genre anytime anywhere you can
0:08:18play audibles audiobooks on phones
0:08:19tablets computers most Kindles even
0:08:22ipods if you're Steven Hackett now audio
0:08:24books are great flight long road trips
0:08:27even your daily commute you may think
0:08:28you don't have time to read books you'd
0:08:30be surprised how many audio books you
0:08:31can hear each year even if you only
0:08:33listen to and from work every day with
0:08:35more than a hundred and eighty thousand
0:08:36audiobooks and spoken word audio
0:08:38products you will find what you're
0:08:40looking for
0:08:41we have a book recommendation don't we
0:08:42indeed believe John has one and i have
0:08:46won if you'd like one as well
0:08:47well John the time in your next time as
0:08:48that
0:08:48sounds good or you want to go first no
0:08:50no it's cool kids especially since jon
0:08:53is going to make fun of my book
0:08:53selection so we can definitely save that
0:08:55lets do yours then
0:08:56yeah shouldn't set it so i really
0:08:59enjoyed the book ready player one by
0:09:02Ernest Cline which is I made the mistake
0:09:04of listening to the uncomfortable about
0:09:05it and they basically spent an hour and
0:09:08a half talking about how terrible it is
0:09:09anyway his second book came out happily
0:09:13was in 2015 i could be wrong about that
0:09:15and it's called armada and it is not as
0:09:18good as ready player one which at this
0:09:20point John is seriously rolling his eyes
0:09:22but it is good i did like it if you
0:09:25happen to be a fan of Ender's Game you
0:09:26like this and and or ready player one
0:09:28and it is also narrated by wilwheaton
0:09:31who is kind of an Internet darling and I
0:09:34mean that may not sarcastic way and they
0:09:36not derisive way so i definitely
0:09:38recommend it's apparently just a shade
0:09:41under 12 hours so that's what like two
0:09:43ATP episodes and it's available
0:09:45inaudible so check it out today with
0:09:47more than 180,000 audiobooks and spoken
0:09:49word audio products you will find what
0:09:51you're looking for
0:09:52get a free 30-day trial today by signing
0:09:54up at audible.com / ATP that's
0:09:57audible.com / ATP thanks to audible for
0:10:00sponsoring our show
0:10:02ready player one is mostly harmless
0:10:04silly garbage like that like we really
0:10:09showed yeah we had fun we have fun
0:10:11making fun of it on the incomparable but
0:10:13it's also it's all in good fun like I
0:10:15think it I think it just because we have
0:10:17a lot of things words it's easy to
0:10:18ridicule the book and then poke added
0:10:22and and find flaws and it's still fun
0:10:25read
0:10:25like I don't regret reading like guess
0:10:28that makes me feel a little baby it's
0:10:30not i don't like to use guilty pleasure
0:10:31because i don't like that concept but
0:10:33it's kinda like it's like junk foods
0:10:34like a bag of potato chips
0:10:35whatever just chomped down on goodness
0:10:40all right well anyway I'm yeah you
0:10:42should check out that you should check
0:10:43out horrible
0:10:44alright so what else are we talking
0:10:45tonight are talking about tonight we see
0:10:48that somebody is fixed apples grievous
0:10:51mistake with the macbook one those two
0:10:54kinds of mistakes are just two things i
0:10:56just happened to see recently and I'm
0:10:57sure there's more the macbook one's got
0:11:00the one little lonely USB
0:11:02sea port on the side of it but USB
0:11:04type-c can do all sorts of stuff that's
0:11:08why it's one port you can put the power
0:11:10through it and you can do all sorts of
0:11:12things and so the first link in this to
0:11:16link said here is for a Griffin device
0:11:19that you plug into USBC port on your
0:11:21macbook one and it gives you back the
0:11:24MagSafe connector sort of basically a
0:11:27magnetic thing that someone tripped over
0:11:29the cord it would become disconnected
0:11:30now i find it interesting for a couple
0:11:32reasons when we first talked about the
0:11:34macbook one you know we would of course
0:11:37discuss the fact that this one connector
0:11:39also replaces magsafe what happened to
0:11:41my exams in makes it great doesn't
0:11:43everybody loved magsafe does everybody
0:11:44love being a literal record not have a
0:11:46yank your computer off the you know the
0:11:48thing or break your adapter whatever is
0:11:50it makes a great feature why would they
0:11:51get rid of it and my question but I
0:11:53still want to answer do because i don't
0:11:54have one of these and you do any of us
0:11:56was maybe you don't need magsafe because
0:11:59maybe the USBC connector so small that
0:12:01if you trip over it it just pops out
0:12:02anyway harmlessly like it's the
0:12:04connector is so small that magsafe is no
0:12:06longer needed
0:12:08I still know if that's the case
0:12:09obviously Griffin thinks that people
0:12:11think it's not the case
0:12:13or maybe they know themselves is not the
0:12:15case because they're saying hey by this
0:12:16adapter whose sole purpose is to provide
0:12:19a magnetic breakaway connection for the
0:12:21power for your laptop and i don't know
0:12:26like I i feel like i would buy this
0:12:27thing by the laptop by itself and i
0:12:29would see it is tripping over the i mean
0:12:31i'm not i would find out more at find
0:12:33out by yanking on to the floor watching
0:12:34the screen crack or something maybe just
0:12:36do some experiments to see but boy it
0:12:38seems a long way to go to fill the one
0:12:41only port on your thing with this giant
0:12:42adapter for dollar giant adapter not yet
0:12:45available that gives you a big magnetic
0:12:49thing we're weird product where product
0:12:53yeah this is I don't know whenever you
0:12:56know whenever there's a computer or
0:12:57technology thing that comes out and and
0:13:00lacks something that came before it
0:13:03there's always a market for third
0:13:05parties to come in and offer the
0:13:07comforts of the previous thing in some
0:13:09kind of bolt-on thing the cost between
0:13:11fourteen hundred dollars like this is
0:13:13like this is true of all technology
0:13:15whenever any progress
0:13:16made and sometimes it's worth using
0:13:18usually it's not in this case and you
0:13:21know Griffin stuff I've had honestly
0:13:23I've had mixed success with Griffin
0:13:25stuff so I i'm not even sure I would
0:13:27trust this to to work and be of high
0:13:29quality so i don't know i don't really
0:13:33see why people would want to to go
0:13:38through the hassle of this and i just
0:13:39have to kind too kind of like bulk up
0:13:40that poor ruin that port I don't know it
0:13:42doesn't seem it seems like this is a
0:13:44problem that that is not worth solving
0:13:47because the solution to it is too clunky
0:13:49itself
0:13:50I don't even know if it's a problem like
0:13:52we don't know the other thing is there's
0:13:53no USB pastor this take your one and
0:13:55only port this fills it with power and
0:13:57that's it so that you know they did I
0:14:00can't believe it even provided a pastor
0:14:02so you could be sure but that that makes
0:14:04it suck really yeah so for forty dollars
0:14:07to fill the one poor anyway it shows
0:14:09like that that's kind of how private
0:14:11companies work i'll use that your you
0:14:12hit the nail right on the head saying
0:14:13someone always makes one of these things
0:14:15that is mostly to make people like you
0:14:17said feel more comfortable i used to
0:14:19have magsafe and regardless of whether i
0:14:21need magsafe now I want to still have it
0:14:24because it makes me feel comfortable
0:14:25maybe it's needed i don't know i haven't
0:14:26done the experiment as far as I know
0:14:28nobody has but another solution to this
0:14:31would be an apple just put enough
0:14:33battery life and that laptop they would
0:14:34need to plug it in all day
0:14:36you gotta plug it in sometime even if
0:14:39you're just putting it somewhere to
0:14:40charge someone walks by your desk in an
0:14:42accent thing
0:14:42yeah but the macbook one has as pretty
0:14:45mediocre battery life on the rest of the
0:14:46lineup it's pretty small
0:14:48yeah this guy like revision will
0:14:50presumably get noticeably better but
0:14:53it's still gonna probably require being
0:14:54plugged in if you're using it all day so
0:14:56the next one is another thing that takes
0:14:58advantage of the versatility of the USB
0:15:01type-c port is even bigger it's a big
0:15:04like rectangular thing that pokes out
0:15:06the side of your macbook one but it
0:15:09gives you a whole mess of ports because
0:15:10you too big normal size USB gives us d
0:15:13car looks like a CF card and also has a
0:15:16pastor for us bc and this one is from
0:15:18hyper this looks nice to me i'm just
0:15:22talking at work today with someone so i
0:15:24think i mentioned in the past that when
0:15:25i'm working these days they're cinema
0:15:27displays everywhere are well really
0:15:29Thunderbolts
0:15:30place i should say and I've always been
0:15:31so jealous because I've always kind of
0:15:33wanted one of those so that i could just
0:15:34sit my laptop down plug in just a couple
0:15:36of cables and then I be connected to
0:15:38ethernet my microphone and and whatnot
0:15:40and and this is a fifty-dollar on sale
0:15:43you know like kind of many docking
0:15:45station and although it doesn't have
0:15:47ethernet which a little bit of a bummer
0:15:49this is the sort of thing that if I had
0:15:51a macbook one I would absolutely stick
0:15:53one of these on my desk in and make it a
0:15:55little easier to use even like what's
0:15:57promising about this too is like you
0:15:59know they're there have always been
0:15:59similar products although never very
0:16:02many of them for thunderbolt and they
0:16:04were always basically from like two
0:16:06hundred dollars and up
0:16:08mm so this it's probably the USB stuff
0:16:10is so cheap to make
0:16:12even though it is obviously a little
0:16:13more limited like technically then the
0:16:15Thunderbolt but this is nice
0:16:17what's it a few more things first of all
0:16:19this is very very small and it like
0:16:21seems to fit the profile pretty well of
0:16:23the laptop so that's nice to hear you it
0:16:25it's small but like it's compared it's a
0:16:30small laptop compared to the size light
0:16:32add significantly to the laptop
0:16:33percentage-wise i feel like i could
0:16:35changes you from your little tiny
0:16:36portable thing to something that's
0:16:38really big here is the thing that
0:16:39worries me a lot when i look at it is
0:16:41the USBC port the only mechanical
0:16:44connection between this again like small
0:16:47and absolute size but larger relative
0:16:49size is that the only connection to the
0:16:51thing like what have you tried to pick
0:16:52this thing up from the side of the
0:16:53adapter and accidentally grabbed a
0:16:55little bit below the spc but would you
0:16:57twist and crack this thing off and it
0:16:58doesn't seem to have any other means of
0:17:01connecting itself the thing other than
0:17:03the USBC but i'm sure it's it's
0:17:04lightweight and everything just what it
0:17:06looks like is extending your laptop
0:17:08sideways by an inch but it's not it's
0:17:11like I don't know it just seems like it
0:17:13is a lever made to break that connector
0:17:16yeah good point this well and again you
0:17:18can look at this stuff like I i think if
0:17:21you're going to be connecting things to
0:17:24your macbook on a regular basis the
0:17:27macbook one is probably not the right
0:17:28model for you you know because we like
0:17:30we know a lot of people who have these
0:17:31things most of whom love them and the
0:17:35the number one thing we hear from these
0:17:37people who love them whenever the port
0:17:38conversation comes up is they don't
0:17:40really are playing in
0:17:41so it's fine and I think if you're going
0:17:44to be plugging things in just get either
0:17:46an air or the presumed soon to be coming
0:17:50sky like 13 inch pro which should
0:17:53probably be pretty competitive than
0:17:55missing lightness wise to the 13 chair
0:17:58but we'll see
0:17:58yeah i think this though but especially
0:18:01the the price like you said Mark I mean
0:18:02that is stunningly cheap yeah 50 bucks I
0:18:05mean you can't get a thunderbolt cable
0:18:07four 55s seriously probably can now
0:18:10please don't even know me but you
0:18:11couldn't do first
0:18:13it reminds me of like a pc peripherals
0:18:15because it's like a CF card reader
0:18:17really no it's not it's not no it's SD
0:18:20and microSD yeah I I maybe I'm
0:18:22misjudging the size 10 because
0:18:23everything is relative to the size of
0:18:25the mackerel keep forgetting how darn
0:18:26small thing actually is so yeah but
0:18:28anyway the SD of the micro-st it if you
0:18:32took out those two slots then you
0:18:34wouldn't have such a long lever with
0:18:36which to crack off the USBC connector
0:18:37but you know there will be a it's almost
0:18:40as if I think like go full-length
0:18:42internet like seven more slots or go
0:18:44even shorter and just add the full-size
0:18:47USB you know and the pastor I don't know
0:18:50I don't know anyway people apparently
0:18:51buying them so excited you can't really
0:18:54go that far wrong for fifty bucks and
0:18:57and i would definitely recommend for
0:18:59people who have their laptop on their
0:19:01desk like not for people who are
0:19:03constantly picking it up and carrying it
0:19:04place to place or if you want to travel
0:19:06with it and like if you wanna be like on
0:19:07the plane but you have like plain old
0:19:09USB peripherals that you need to use or
0:19:12you want to be swapping SD card to do
0:19:14but you know pulling pictures of cameras
0:19:16while you're sitting in your plane seat
0:19:17I wouldn't want this thing hanging out
0:19:19the side while I'm trying to handle my
0:19:20thing on the tray anyway
0:19:22well see to me I i think this would
0:19:24actually the opposite way i would say
0:19:25for a desk you want something with like
0:19:28one cable that plugs in and have some
0:19:30kind of breakout box with the other
0:19:31stuff in it that way you can kind of get
0:19:33it away from the side of the computer
0:19:34and not have the stress on there every
0:19:36single day and kind of make a cleaner
0:19:38desk if you can if you can hide that
0:19:39stuff somewhere behind a desk or under
0:19:41ever whereas the this one I think we
0:19:44better for travel because you get
0:19:45adaptability to these three different
0:19:48port types in one small thing that
0:19:50doesn't have itself it's own cable so 44
0:19:53like sighs and
0:19:55tidiness in a travel bag full of other
0:19:57cable adapters and computer junk this
0:19:59would actually be a big win i think i
0:20:00was saying on the desk
0:20:02mostly because then there's less chance
0:20:04of meeting someone lifting up and crack
0:20:06nothing off you know because explain
0:20:08flat on the desk
0:20:09yeah and you can manipulate it and stick
0:20:11the things into it you're right like it
0:20:12is even better will be a cable that
0:20:14snakes away from the thing and it does
0:20:16work well for travel in terms of clutter
0:20:18but I don't know it just makes me
0:20:20nervous just looking at like I keep
0:20:22looking at that because of pictures like
0:20:23it really is just a little tiny
0:20:24connector it just doesn't seem the same
0:20:28right
0:20:28yeah that that would make me nervous as
0:20:30well to be honest but I mean it's not
0:20:32the thing is I think you're not going to
0:20:33break the computer with that you're
0:20:35going to break the adapter because the
0:20:36computer has the aluminum case like
0:20:38laser-cut opening around that that's not
0:20:40you're not going to break the computer
0:20:41by twisting the thing I'd feel like
0:20:42you're going to break the or maybe it
0:20:43would be just a battle between two
0:20:45pieces of aluminum see which one I don't
0:20:48know the world's least interesting
0:20:49battle
0:20:50yeah well it's exactly all these people
0:20:52are doing like the yeah was it a mkbhd
0:20:56whatever was doing his stabbing the the
0:20:59iphone 6 suppose that iphone 6 screens
0:21:01with a knife and everything we need the
0:21:03even more boring equivalent of that of
0:21:05let's that stress test the connector on
0:21:07this USB hub type thing because that's
0:21:08that's our domain if we have a youtube
0:21:10channel will be all USB hubs ok you hear
0:21:13you heard it here first type of shop
0:21:15send us one of these to review along
0:21:17with a macbook one that you don't want
0:21:18and we will do this to mr. on the air
0:21:21pretty remarkable film it on his fancy
0:21:23still image camera that's also kind of a
0:21:25video camera
0:21:26yeah all right anything else on this
0:21:31thing I can't believe this is the news
0:21:32this week it's like it's this is like
0:21:34this is why I hate CES because the only
0:21:37news that happens is either like
0:21:39pie-in-the-sky stuff that will never
0:21:41come out or like USB port news
0:21:45it's like it's not with some CS news
0:21:47like people keep sending me the stories
0:21:49about the like OLED TVs that are going
0:21:51to be shown or announced that CS and
0:21:54maybe they have been by today but i
0:21:55haven't caught up on the story said I
0:21:57basically just wait for CS to be over
0:21:59and then find the summary stories to
0:22:01pick out the three things that were
0:22:02actually good or interesting and say yes
0:22:03and then just read that that's really
0:22:05all but I CS is good for people who are
0:22:07interested in TV is you
0:22:09they find out that like it's a it's not
0:22:11an interesting year where nothing good
0:22:12has happened or you find out like
0:22:14however still obsessed with 3d or
0:22:16everyone is still obsessed with curved
0:22:17screens or some other chemical you don't
0:22:18like this year the gimmick seems to be
0:22:20identical range which I am interested in
0:22:23and I hope is an emerging standards and
0:22:25will be like this is a picture it's a
0:22:27legitimate picture quality improvement
0:22:29not something that's chemically like 3d
0:22:32and not something that's ridiculous like
0:22:34the curve so I I'm glad for that to be
0:22:39the new thing this year but if it's the
0:22:41new thing this mirror that means all the
0:22:43televisions that have any kind of
0:22:44support for this year going to be like
0:22:46the very first generation that tries to
0:22:48support and maybe they're competing
0:22:49standards and that's all I got to work
0:22:50itself out so it's still not time to buy
0:22:53a TV but i'd like to read about that but
0:22:55I haven't yet so I don't think so yes is
0:22:58a total loss is just like a ninety-eight
0:23:00percent loss
0:23:01wow what a low bar that we expect it
0:23:05God soso John your summary of the TV
0:23:09news coming out of CES is I'm ready yet
0:23:12that's my i will give next week i will
0:23:14know more but my summary is it seems
0:23:16like I dynamic ranges the thing is here
0:23:19and I don't know whether everyone is
0:23:22over the curved screen thing it freaking
0:23:24we should we should actually said i
0:23:27would love to send you to las vegas for
0:23:29this week just just to just to capture
0:23:31the misery of that trip that like I
0:23:34would be I would go for that if it was
0:23:36just to film you being there nobody
0:23:38wants to go to see nobody does that's
0:23:40the thing that I think people understand
0:23:42like for those who know a lot of people
0:23:45who cover CS as part of their job
0:23:48nobody likes it like people like going
0:23:50to back a day people like going to
0:23:52Macworld to cover it if you're
0:23:53interested in apple stuff people like
0:23:55going to w3c people like going to google
0:23:57i/o if you're interested in Google's up
0:23:58nobody likes going to see us
0:24:00nobody i'm i think a lot about who is
0:24:02this for I guess it's is it for like
0:24:04retailers or advertisers John it's the
0:24:09consumer electronics Sean
0:24:11no I mean it seems like there's a lot of
0:24:14legitimate reasons for some people to be
0:24:16there seems like there's a lot of like
0:24:17meeting with the reps that happens in
0:24:19private meetings that can be very useful
0:24:21to people but to actually be on the show
0:24:23floor I don't really know who that's for
0:24:25necessarily besides like people who are
0:24:28tasked with covering it and who as you
0:24:30said usually hate this job because it is
0:24:32grueling and and pretty pretty intense
0:24:35but even people who are meeting with the
0:24:36reps behind closed doors I think they
0:24:38like the meetings but they wish they
0:24:39could meet basically anywhere in the
0:24:41world of the CGS like all come to your
0:24:45city where is your company located i
0:24:47will fly the your city and do i mean i
0:24:48guess maybe it seems I just I just never
0:24:50heard anyone say I can't wait to go to
0:24:53see yes
0:24:54nobody not vendors not people who are
0:24:56going to meet with vendors like maybe
0:24:59the most circles on traveling like
0:25:00people who were like some a buyer for a
0:25:03big store chain like the best buy person
0:25:05or something you want to go to see what
0:25:06they're gonna buy for that maybe they
0:25:08look forward to it just seems it's like
0:25:10the worst of it I think of everything
0:25:12that's bad about conferences and
0:25:14concentrated and then i can multiply by
0:25:155 kinda like III used to be but at least
0:25:18III was exciting for people who weren't
0:25:20there like even III was at its worst
0:25:22I've ever been to three but i know a lot
0:25:24of people have even III was at its worst
0:25:25was just completely overblown and nobody
0:25:29really you know it's exhausting and
0:25:30nobody wanted to cover it
0:25:31it was exciting for people who weren't
0:25:33there because he would say I can't wait
0:25:34to see what announced at e3 so you know
0:25:37if you want you want to read the
0:25:38coverage you get excited but my
0:25:40impression of cs is that people who are
0:25:42there don't want to be there and people
0:25:43aren't there don't want to read about
0:25:44mysterious our second punch this week is
0:25:48a glue go to a glue software.com / ATP
0:25:52for internet you will actually like
0:25:54anyone has worked in a corporate
0:25:56environment knows how painful Internet
0:25:58can be the contents tail the interface
0:26:00is ugly and you can't access on your
0:26:02phone or any kind of modern device made
0:26:04after the year 2010 now igloo is an
0:26:06internet you will actually like because
0:26:08it is designed with modern technology
0:26:10and modern sensibilities for real
0:26:12usability Italy give you the flexibility
0:26:15to get your work done how you want where
0:26:17you want and whatever device you want
0:26:19their truly building a product meant for
0:26:212016 and beyond
0:26:23not the nineties
0:26:24with a glue internets you can share news
0:26:27organize your files coordinate calendars
0:26:29and manage projects all in one place
0:26:32everything can be optionally social with
0:26:34comments like buttons revisions messages
0:26:37and anyone can add content based on
0:26:39their permissions with drag-and-drop
0:26:41widgets and what you see is what you get
0:26:43editor in a blue makes use of responsive
0:26:46web design so it looks fantastic on all
0:26:49your devices whether they exist today or
0:26:51where they're going to come out tomorrow
0:26:52it will already look good because it is
0:26:54fully responsive modern web design with
0:26:56modern social and and collaborative
0:26:58features that so that you won't have
0:27:00your employees going out to use things
0:27:02like you know dropbox and Twitter and
0:27:04like all the stuff that is public that
0:27:06you that you want to keep the stuff
0:27:07inside your company inside your internet
0:27:09igloo is very corporate friendly they
0:27:12that they're very secure the vehicle is
0:27:13granting permissions all the stuff that
0:27:15you need to sell to your company
0:27:17it's even free to use forever for up to
0:27:1910 people so check it out today a glue
0:27:21software com / ATP free to use up to 10
0:27:24people and very reasonably priced after
0:27:26that and at any size you get a free
0:27:28trial so check it out today it was
0:27:30software com / ATP for that free trial
0:27:33get started now thanks a lot to glue the
0:27:35internet you'll actually like so a few
0:27:39weeks ago we started talking about Swift
0:27:41being open sourced and then we got
0:27:44sidetracked by i'm not even sure what
0:27:46but here we are again scraping at the
0:27:48bottom of the barrel so why don't we
0:27:50talk a little more about switched open
0:27:51source and actually talk about something
0:27:53that's cool which is the swift code of
0:27:54conduct or if you let me talk with the
0:27:56mac pro some more so that without the
0:27:58swift code of conduct
0:27:59yeah we got to order the equivalent of
0:28:01the ball gets a burrowing topic after
0:28:02this but the code of conduct is a thing
0:28:04that has been happening over the past
0:28:07I'd say year so has become more popular
0:28:09every sort of open source project or
0:28:11volunteer based community thing or
0:28:14conferences around sort of any sort of
0:28:16ad hoc collection of people especially
0:28:19in the tech world has been starting to
0:28:21have an actual written down code of
0:28:24conduct that is exactly what it sounds
0:28:25like it's sort of yeah
0:28:27set set of rules or expectations of
0:28:31behavior like just to give examples you
0:28:33could have a code of conduct for
0:28:35I don't know a website where people join
0:28:38want to talk about knitting and the code
0:28:39of conduct could say if you want to
0:28:41participate and admitting forms and talk
0:28:43about knitting
0:28:44we don't want you to use curse words or
0:28:47whatever and then you can decide hey I
0:28:49don't want to be part of a community
0:28:50where I can't curse so you won't join
0:28:52that knitting community right but it
0:28:54sets clear expectations like here is how
0:28:56we expect people to behave and it gives
0:28:57you something like if someone misbehave
0:28:59you can point the code of conduct hey we
0:29:01have a code of conduct here this is how
0:29:02it's going to be these are the rules if
0:29:04you don't like it you should go
0:29:05someplace that's a different set of
0:29:06rules and it's like that for open source
0:29:10projects for conferences where like I'm
0:29:12going to show this conference is going
0:29:13to be a conference my favorite
0:29:14programming language and there's going
0:29:17to be talks and everything what are the
0:29:18expectations what what kind of behavior
0:29:20isn't allowed what who
0:29:22how how are the people in this community
0:29:24expected to be a there's been minimal
0:29:27push back to the idea of a code of
0:29:29conduct is a lot of nerds are very
0:29:30literal-minded and don't really see the
0:29:33nuances and things is a well code of
0:29:35conduct doesn't actually make people
0:29:36behave in a certain way you're right it
0:29:37doesn't but by writing it down you're
0:29:39setting expectations i can do for kids
0:29:41or whatever there any sort of that it
0:29:44just it's it's more comfortable to know
0:29:46what is expected because that was
0:29:48everybody decide if they want to be a
0:29:50part of a community with this set of
0:29:53sort of rules and guidelines if you know
0:29:55we're going to get interesting thing if
0:29:57you think not being allowed to curse is
0:29:58stupid you know right away this is not
0:30:01in any community for me I should go
0:30:03someplace else where people are knitting
0:30:04and also like the curse right and on a
0:30:09minute stuff in terms of like making
0:30:10jokes other peoples expense or like any
0:30:14sort of aggressive behavior and even
0:30:18just right now stuff like no violence no
0:30:20hitting other people so I guess mostly
0:30:21like that you do for little kids you set
0:30:23the expectations of you know here's how
0:30:25you expected to behave in preschool
0:30:26no biting your friends expect you to
0:30:28share the teacher is talking expect you
0:30:30to listen you know everybody eats at
0:30:33this time and maps at this time or
0:30:34whatever you doesn't mean that's all
0:30:36going to happen but you just want to
0:30:37write it down and I said the pushback is
0:30:41mostly of people thinking that you are
0:30:46you saying if we don't have a code of
0:30:47conduct we allow those things are the
0:30:49stuff
0:30:49to go without saying or writing it down
0:30:50makes it seem like we're we're telling
0:30:54people that are coming here that are
0:30:55going to behave badly why do we need to
0:30:56write down stuff like don't murder
0:30:57people like they should know that
0:30:59already or are you trying to make it
0:31:00sound like we're a bunch of murderers
0:31:01here or really what's under the covers a
0:31:04lot of it is
0:31:05say you're just coming up with the code
0:31:08of conduct can be like especially like
0:31:10programming projects or whatever like if
0:31:14there are debates about technical issues
0:31:15which we'll get to in a second debate
0:31:18the issue don't debate the person don't
0:31:20know ad hominem attacks when you're
0:31:22discussing some features and programming
0:31:23language or open-source project don't
0:31:26call the other people other person's
0:31:27jerk or an idiot
0:31:29do not attack the person or that person
0:31:30is personal history keep your debate to
0:31:33the topic at hand and again this may
0:31:35sound like yeah these all sound like
0:31:37reasonable rules whatever it's like
0:31:38little things you do for kids but at a
0:31:40certain point people push back against
0:31:42that an example is the linux kernel
0:31:43mailing list where linus torvalds or
0:31:47penis or ever you want to set the
0:31:49creator of linux very often is that uses
0:31:53very salty language so again like
0:31:54bending form of linux kernel mountain
0:31:57was totally allowed to use curse words
0:31:58that's in there you know if they had a
0:31:59contract which i'm not sure if you do
0:32:01but if they did it would be in there
0:32:02because that's that's sort of what to
0:32:04expect and has been known to say pretty
0:32:06mean things about people not just about
0:32:09their thing you know like it's it's a
0:32:11it's a there is a fine line am i calling
0:32:14when I say this is the stupidest idea
0:32:16I've ever heard
0:32:17I'm kind of criticizing the idea but I'm
0:32:19also kind of being mean about it or
0:32:21whatever anyway that community has
0:32:23pushed back against the idea of trying
0:32:24to be more civil to each other or more
0:32:26civil to each others ideas or anything
0:32:28like that so that's you know that's the
0:32:29kind of community one if you were to
0:32:31come in there and they were to try to
0:32:32come up with a code of conduct and they
0:32:34make a set of rules that past behavior
0:32:35doesn't fit into the people with the
0:32:37past behavior feel like they're now
0:32:38being excluded from the community that
0:32:39they're important part anyway all this
0:32:42is a big grand way to say that Swift is
0:32:44doing what I think is the right thing
0:32:45which is from the very beginning having
0:32:48a go to conduct and I look at the code
0:32:49of conduct and it seems pretty saying
0:32:52and and pretty tame and i think it is a
0:32:55good thing for anybody whether it's in a
0:32:58preschool or knitting club or an open
0:33:01source project or website
0:33:02to our web form or anything to write
0:33:05down their code of conduct as early as
0:33:07possible and revisited as needed and
0:33:10amended and clarify and so on so forth
0:33:13just to have a starting point and a
0:33:15guideline instead of just assuming
0:33:16everybody will behave and all agree
0:33:18about what proper behavior is it's
0:33:20pretty sad that it's come to this point
0:33:22but i think that the one universal
0:33:26internet truth is that even if you don't
0:33:29act like a petulant child upfront anyone
0:33:32on the internet is but the smallest push
0:33:34away from being a petulant child and and
0:33:37i agree with you this is a good thing to
0:33:39have this reminds me of the post by was
0:33:42randi harper's that right that because
0:33:44that shows what happens if you don't
0:33:45have a code of conduct and if you don't
0:33:47think about these issues right so she
0:33:50had posted this is freebsd or well the
0:33:52the woman who used to be known as
0:33:54previously girl she posted recently
0:33:57really really good and not terribly long
0:33:59post about how she was treated in the
0:34:00bsd community and its really pretty
0:34:02deplorable and in its in you could argue
0:34:06just like Marco said that is in no small
0:34:08part because they didn't really have an
0:34:09established code of conduct and then
0:34:11even when they did if you believe what
0:34:13she says which I do you know they didn't
0:34:14act they didn't act fairly once once
0:34:18there were issues escalated which is
0:34:21really too bad but that will put a link
0:34:23to that in the show notes in and if you
0:34:25work in any sort of community I i highly
0:34:29recommend reading her post because it it
0:34:32was fascinating and a code of conduct by
0:34:35as many people that does not guarantee
0:34:37good behavior because there's issues of
0:34:38enforcement and those debates about how
0:34:40should things be enforced is it
0:34:42enforceable at all like another reason
0:34:44people shy away from code of conduct as
0:34:45I think it opens up this big can of
0:34:47orange nail off the debates but these
0:34:48are these are important things to talk
0:34:50about and it's better to talk about them
0:34:51before anything has happened like sorted
0:34:54out amongst yourselves not in not in
0:34:57light of some actual event because it's
0:34:59so much harder to figure it out in life
0:35:00no it's very difficult to come up with a
0:35:03good set of rules and figure out how
0:35:05you're going to enforce them and to
0:35:06follow through on it but it's so much
0:35:08better to engage in that process than to
0:35:12bury your head in the sand because
0:35:13engagement process will first of all
0:35:14people making the policies that will
0:35:16force you to think about things like
0:35:17hopefully you'll go and say let me look
0:35:19at the people's code of conduct let me
0:35:20look what they wrote down and I think
0:35:22collectively all the codes of conduct of
0:35:24various the communities and open-source
0:35:26products are getting better by looking
0:35:27at each other in the open source kind of
0:35:29way and say what are they run down how
0:35:30they phrase this what kind of all I
0:35:32didn't even think of that we should put
0:35:33that into because I believe that but it
0:35:34wouldn't have even occurred to me to
0:35:35write it because i'm not in that group
0:35:37of marginalized people and didn't
0:35:38realize that was the thing we had to
0:35:40write down but i totally agree with that
0:35:41now that i see it and you know get it
0:35:43all down ahead of time and then you're
0:35:46gonna have you no incidents and then you
0:35:49have to figure out how to deal with them
0:35:50and then you look at half of the palpa
0:35:52dealt with events and read you know it
0:35:53read Randy's thing and say here's how
0:35:55this community tried to deal with this
0:35:57event and here here's how it went badly
0:35:59how can we avoid that
0:36:01what kind of policies can we have in
0:36:02place to help with it no one's gonna be
0:36:03perfect it's not a guarantee of anything
0:36:05it just shows that you are engaged in
0:36:08the process that you are committed to
0:36:09the idea that you can manage your
0:36:12community to be what you wanted to be to
0:36:15be a more welcoming community to be a
0:36:17successful community for the kind of
0:36:19people that you want you can make a code
0:36:21of conduct that sets totally different
0:36:23kinds of rules but it's so much better
0:36:24to just think about like Who I want what
0:36:27I want here
0:36:28do I want people who are really
0:36:30technically skilled but also really
0:36:32really angry and mean all the time if
0:36:34you want that like right into your code
0:36:36of conduct like that there's an
0:36:38expectation you'll be berated and curse
0:36:40that and we only accept people who have
0:36:44the highest of skills i'd like to build
0:36:46the community you want for yourself
0:36:47whatever it is that you want but it's
0:36:50much better to to take on that task as
0:36:53an actual thing rather than falling
0:36:55ass-backwards into it's sort of like you
0:36:58just end up with this community and
0:36:59you're not quite sure how you got there
0:37:01so that that's what I think the
0:37:03important buttons and switches very
0:37:05sensible and they're coming it
0:37:06relatively late in the game to Swift was
0:37:08an open source project until recently
0:37:09and I think they're benefiting from
0:37:12all the other code of conduct that have
0:37:15come before them and at this point it's
0:37:19kind of the type of thing where if you
0:37:20are a community or an open source
0:37:22project without a code of conduct people
0:37:26are going to ask why why don't you have
0:37:29one
0:37:30maybe you should think about not the
0:37:31same your bed or anything but they're
0:37:32saying you may not have thought too much
0:37:34about this but history has shown that is
0:37:37a good thing to have and the active
0:37:39thinking about it will lead you to be a
0:37:41better community
0:37:43agreed alright what else is going on
0:37:46with Swift this is a program every topic
0:37:48enough market talks about all these
0:37:49under the radar but I save one for here
0:37:51I think you got to this one's kind of
0:37:52esoteric but I continue to follow the
0:37:55Swift evolution mailing list or try to
0:37:57follow anyway it's still still pretty
0:37:58high volume where the people talk about
0:38:00the future Swift and make proposals and
0:38:03debate them and go through all sorts of
0:38:06things this big process of evolving
0:38:08Swift is becoming more formalized with
0:38:11different phases of whatever anyway this
0:38:14one particular proposal that I thought
0:38:16started to get at the heart of what
0:38:18seems to be one of the big internal
0:38:19struggles between Swift and the
0:38:22community formerly known as the
0:38:24objective-c development community
0:38:26I guess they're still not as that but
0:38:27anyway all the people are writing all
0:38:29the code objective-c an apple saying you
0:38:32guys should think about moving Swift
0:38:34some point because we are and this is a
0:38:37debate around things that are allowed
0:38:40and disallowed static and dynamic you
0:38:43know free or clamp down and this
0:38:46particular one is about whether classes
0:38:49should be final by default in Swift as
0:38:51in if you don't say anything one way or
0:38:56the other in your defining class and
0:38:57Swift should that class b sub classical
0:39:00and commendable and be able to do you
0:39:02know extended and have things
0:39:04overwritten or by default should be all
0:39:06closed up and you can't screw with it
0:39:07and it's not really a question about
0:39:10capability because no one is saying all
0:39:13classes should be all closed up and
0:39:15final for all classes should be open
0:39:17it's just a question of what the
0:39:18defaults are in the defaults have two
0:39:21effects one is obviously affects
0:39:24the actual code because a lot of people
0:39:26just take the default right you know and
0:39:29then so if if no one does anything and
0:39:30they just do class and I don't know
0:39:32about this particular keyword don't
0:39:33think about it what do they get by
0:39:35default and the second thing is by
0:39:37choosing the default if people think
0:39:38about it for a little bit they'll see
0:39:41it's like a signal from the design
0:39:43language we think most of your classes
0:39:45should be like this it's the default but
0:39:48if you have special needs make your
0:39:51class like this and like having a java
0:39:56you know the default is not final
0:39:58I don't know my job i think that's the
0:39:59case and so what they're saying is by
0:40:01default in Java of you declare a class
0:40:03you can sub class but that that's that's
0:40:06we think that's the common case but if
0:40:07you have special needs like say for
0:40:09performance reasons or you really don't
0:40:11want people extending your class you can
0:40:13declare it to be final by adding this
0:40:14other keyword and so that means that
0:40:17most people just like a Java class blah
0:40:19blah blah blah
0:40:20they're all getting glasses it could be
0:40:21some class and extended all that stuff
0:40:23because that's the default and also
0:40:25philosophically speaking it's so clear
0:40:27the java really expect people to
0:40:28subclass your stuff and that the
0:40:30exception to the rule is all you wanna
0:40:32make you think finally all closed off or
0:40:34whatever sorry if I'm getting this job
0:40:35mrs. this job a default thing backwards
0:40:38i haven't touched job in a really long
0:40:40time somebody named job and not 13 in
0:40:43the chat says it is not final by default
0:40:45and I think they would probably know
0:40:47because their name is java nuts well
0:40:49yeah there's no way they could have
0:40:50changed their name to java not know but
0:40:52anyway yeah i think my recollection
0:40:55anyway so the proposal for swift is to
0:40:58default final and this would make swift
0:41:00one of those languages is saying most of
0:41:03the time when you make glasses we expect
0:41:05them to be like done but sometimes you
0:41:08might want someone to be able to extend
0:41:09your class and in that case we want you
0:41:12to have to put a special keyword or
0:41:14whatever in there to say all other
0:41:16people like I'm writing a base class and
0:41:18other people are supposed to subclass me
0:41:20and override these three methods do this
0:41:22other thing and this is really again
0:41:25it's not really like a technical debate
0:41:26because both things would still be
0:41:27possible this is really a sort of battle
0:41:29for the heart and soul of what Swift is
0:41:32and what objective c has been
0:41:34I i pulled a little quote here from
0:41:36Jordan row so i think is a someone that
0:41:38Apple although it's very difficult to
0:41:40tell miss evolution list when people are
0:41:42speaking for themselves as users of
0:41:44swiftor as contributors to the open
0:41:46source product and when they're speaking
0:41:48as Apple employees kind of implicitly no
0:41:51one has ever speaking for Apple because
0:41:52no one speaks for Apple except the team
0:41:54coco i guess but when there's an apple
0:41:56com in their email address like just I
0:41:58don't notice that is their opinion carry
0:42:01more weight i still haven't quite sorted
0:42:02out the sort of uneasy dance between at
0:42:07apple.com people like Apple employees
0:42:09working on swift and VA the unwashed
0:42:11masses of the Swift community and how
0:42:13that power balance works and most of the
0:42:17most part the back-and-forth has been
0:42:20very polite and mostly so i think that
0:42:22most people realize look apples doing
0:42:24most of the work here and I made the
0:42:26language Apple is going to do most of
0:42:27the work here so we can have some input
0:42:29the bottom line isn't heart you will
0:42:30never develop Swift on your own or you
0:42:32seven people are going to take swift and
0:42:34run with that
0:42:35no probably not so all you can really do
0:42:37is give your opinion anyway a lot of
0:42:40what this default final thing comes down
0:42:42to is the expectation by Objective C
0:42:45programmers that any sort of framework
0:42:47anything in the framework that's like
0:42:49not behaving correctly or that you're
0:42:51making a subclass of that you can just
0:42:53override methods that you want to behave
0:42:56in a slightly different way like you can
0:42:58even do a lot of interesting things with
0:43:01UI kit and a half get by overriding
0:43:04things in subclasses even things that
0:43:07you know overriding them in ways maybe
0:43:09that you know to turn something into a
0:43:11no operand make something happen a side
0:43:13effect when it didn't have before even
0:43:15to do things like me objective-c runtime
0:43:16reach in and do what I think they called
0:43:19methodists whistling where you just
0:43:20reach in there and you screw with the
0:43:22implementation of a base class not even
0:43:24a subclass but you say you know you've
0:43:25got a blonde method i would like you
0:43:27I'll save a reference to what the
0:43:29original blonde method was but instead
0:43:31point your entry for the blog method to
0:43:32my code that will do some other crap and
0:43:34then call your code and that will modify
0:43:35everybody uses this grass not my sub
0:43:37class but the base glass everywhere and
0:43:39those are the types of things you can do
0:43:42when classes are not entirely closed off
0:43:44when you have access to their guts
0:43:45can screw with them and then you know
0:43:47subclassing above and beyond that so i
0:43:49get back to what Jordan Rhodes said here
0:43:50he says supporting arbitrary code
0:43:53injection into someone else's framework
0:43:54is a non goal for swift perhaps even an
0:43:56anti goal if you replace a method and
0:43:59someone else's class you don't actually
0:44:00know what semantics that relying on of
0:44:02course Apple code will have bugs in it
0:44:03trying to patch over those bugs in your
0:44:04own code is one obviously not an answer
0:44:06apple support but also too fraught with
0:44:09peril and three likely to break in the
0:44:10next OS release this is referring
0:44:12specifically to third-party developers
0:44:14saying when things are open and able to
0:44:18be screwed with sometimes that's the
0:44:19only way we can ship hard a map because
0:44:21you've got a bug somewhere deep in your
0:44:22framework and sometimes we can you sub
0:44:25classes and enough for us to fix and I'm
0:44:27to the region to the guts and and mess
0:44:28with a method just to make our appt not
0:44:30crash we can't wait for you to fix the
0:44:32bug apple and a point 1 release because
0:44:34that could be two months around we need
0:44:35to ship now and our application doesn't
0:44:37run on the new OS that you're about to
0:44:39release so we love to be able to go into
0:44:42some framework thing and new
0:44:44quantitative methods are messing with in
0:44:46a certain way to work around some
0:44:48strange bug or even it's just a simple
0:44:50like an animation bug or something that
0:44:51crashes you're out but nobody else is
0:44:53that third-party developers are used to
0:44:56be having the freedom of the objective-c
0:44:58runtime to mess with these things but
0:44:59Swift really doesn't want that type of
0:45:02thing to happen Swift would like it if
0:45:04in the future that the you know that
0:45:08that is not you know get it's not
0:45:09something I want to support they don't
0:45:10want you to be able to reach into
0:45:11anyone's framework apples or anybody
0:45:13else's and say oh you have a bug in
0:45:15there I'm gonna fix your mug for you or
0:45:17I want your thing almost does what i
0:45:19want but this is one behavior doesn't
0:45:21have I would like it that if you did
0:45:22this one thing I actually didn't trigger
0:45:23this other action so I'm just going to
0:45:25reach into your guts and screw with it
0:45:26and programmers to get used to that
0:45:29freedom it's kinda like a that's the
0:45:32last resort but it's nice that it's
0:45:33there but if you are a developer of
0:45:35frameworks you don't know everything to
0:45:37the guts your craft messing with it is
0:45:39like you don't know what you don't know
0:45:40what the semantics of my framework are
0:45:42you don't know what invariance the ear
0:45:45violet your-your-your violated by
0:45:47messing with that value I don't want you
0:45:48touching my this this member variable
0:45:50you're not even supposed to exist that
0:45:51might disappear and then s next OS
0:45:53version I don't want you messing with
0:45:55ending and things that Michael because
0:45:56you don't you don't have
0:45:57source code instead even if you did is
0:45:58my framework is supposed to be like a
0:46:00black box to you just use the public API
0:46:01don't mess with my implementation and i
0:46:05thought this this battle which is linked
0:46:07to the MJ sighs blog post a link to a
0:46:11bunch of discussion and to the man with
0:46:14itself without losing my list i know
0:46:16this is country was fascinating because
0:46:17it really does get at the heart of the
0:46:20old guard vs the new guard and Swift and
0:46:23I really want to hear both of your
0:46:25opinions as I because i don't know what
0:46:28the c-sharp world is like but I do know
0:46:29what the objective c worlds like so and
0:46:31Marco if he's ever had to reach into
0:46:33some objective c framework and screw
0:46:35with it to get his application ship and
0:46:37Casey what he thinks of this entire
0:46:39battle between the the world of
0:46:41framework authors vs the world of
0:46:43application developers
0:46:45I mean I've never had to swizzle to do
0:46:48anything that to me is a is over the
0:46:52line of like you really really shouldn't
0:46:55do that like that is more dangerous
0:46:56subclassing things that that are
0:47:00intended to be subclassed in especially
0:47:03in uikit I do that a lot and or not a
0:47:06lot but I you know I've done that you
0:47:08know numerous times over the years i'm
0:47:10pretty sure overcast does it does a
0:47:11little bit of that reinventing my own
0:47:15methods to override parent methods in
0:47:18those sub classes that are intended to
0:47:19be overwritten I've done that almost I
0:47:22totally get it from the developer
0:47:24perspective of almost always there is
0:47:26something you want to do an app that is
0:47:29that there's no other way to do it
0:47:31besides sub classing up some UI kit
0:47:34thing and you know including my own
0:47:36child version of a method and and just
0:47:38hoping I call super at the right time if
0:47:40I have to at all and just hope nothing
0:47:42bad happens
0:47:43testing it on the one released that I
0:47:45had access to and then shipping and
0:47:46hoping it doesn't break in the future
0:47:47that to me and and this is all like you
0:47:51know your your subclassing but I want to
0:47:53do some subclassing public method so
0:47:55there is some documentation on them some
0:47:58public expectation of how they should
0:47:59behave they're fairly stable so that has
0:48:03never actually caused problems that i
0:48:04know of to do that that way
0:48:07and they're there really have been a lot
0:48:09of these occasions where the there's a
0:48:11limitation in the in the public API
0:48:14there's just no better way to do this or
0:48:17there is no lived with no other way to
0:48:19do this at all and so you have to do
0:48:22stuff like that
0:48:22this is one of those things where in
0:48:24theory it would be nice if you never had
0:48:26to do this and if they were if you can
0:48:28have all the technical advantages of not
0:48:31doing this in a similar way that in
0:48:33theory it would be nice if every mac app
0:48:35with sandboxed you know and then in
0:48:37practice these these strict technical
0:48:40limitations get in the way of reality in
0:48:44real-world use and they they kind of
0:48:46require a level of of competence and
0:48:50perfection and expansiveness from apple
0:48:53and it's frameworks that in reality
0:48:55probably won't come and so it's one of
0:48:58the key in theory it's great in three
0:49:01the having everything be final by
0:49:03default and having no overrides possible
0:49:05that sounds great for for academic
0:49:08theoretical safety but in practice I
0:49:12don't think modern developers with
0:49:15apples frameworks are really able to go
0:49:18that way the reality that is just not it
0:49:21doesn't support that it does not
0:49:23apple is not that great and developers
0:49:25aren't that flexible to to be required
0:49:29to avoid this entire class of
0:49:31functionality and possible bug
0:49:33avoidances and bug fixes that that
0:49:35simple things like subclass overrides
0:49:38can provide yeah you know it's really
0:49:40hard
0:49:41let me start by just quickly
0:49:43establishing the c-sharp unsurprisingly
0:49:45takes the same approach to this is javas
0:49:47except where you say final i would say
0:49:49sealed so III know it's seriously
0:49:52totally different languages where yeah
0:49:54right exactly that's why it is a java
0:49:55club no not at all
0:49:56so yeah so it's sealed classes to me not
0:50:00final but that everything else is
0:50:02exactly the same and they are not sealed
0:50:04by default and in fact it is striking
0:50:06even within Microsoft frameworks to see
0:50:08something that sealed
0:50:09that's very peculiar that being said I
0:50:13think I think the problem is that man
0:50:17and John you alluded to this earlier so
0:50:20much
0:50:20objective-c seems to be about
0:50:22subclassing and up over time even from
0:50:28my perspective of someone who doesn't
0:50:29live in it seems like that starting to
0:50:31go away between blocks between should
0:50:34something else until my tongue anyway
0:50:35it's going away but a lot of legacy
0:50:39objective-c seems to be about
0:50:40subclassing and subclassing when the
0:50:45author of that class hasn't deliberately
0:50:48decided for that to be subclass is
0:50:51inherently dangerous and so much of
0:50:54Swift seems to be about at least in
0:50:57comparison to objective-c about
0:50:59preventing danger about having stronger
0:51:01typing about doing more compile time to
0:51:04check and make sure you're not doing
0:51:05something stupid so much about Swift
0:51:08seems to be about preventing danger and
0:51:11about being safer and having
0:51:14carte-blanche access with a few
0:51:16exceptions to subclass anything is
0:51:18inherently dangerous and so it seems to
0:51:24me that the academic answer is
0:51:28unequivocally that classes should be
0:51:30final by default that being said one of
0:51:34the things I've struggled with lately
0:51:36and co-worker of mine that we we've
0:51:38worked together on a couple projects
0:51:40lately it's been a really interesting
0:51:42experience because he is extremely
0:51:45academic or at least that's the way I
0:51:47think of him he really likes to do
0:51:48things by the book and he really likes
0:51:50to do things the rightist way possible
0:51:52by comparison of course i like to do
0:51:55that too but by comparison I feel like
0:51:57I'm considerably more pragmatic or
0:51:59perhaps loosey-goosey is maybe how he
0:52:02would describe it i would say pragmatic
0:52:03and I come down I think in the same way
0:52:08that Marco does that
0:52:10yes academically everything should be
0:52:12final by default but realistically I
0:52:15don't see how that's really possible and
0:52:17what I think looking at it from my point
0:52:20of view what's what's difficult about
0:52:21this is Apple has a tendency to kind of
0:52:24assume they know better than everyone
0:52:25and so even if we had classes final by
0:52:32default
0:52:34I think it's pretty clear that Apple
0:52:35wouldn't allow classes to be extended in
0:52:39subclassed very often because they tend
0:52:41to assume we know better than you you
0:52:43shouldn't touch this and well in
0:52:46principle that should be true that Apple
0:52:48should know better than us in reality
0:52:50there's so many just minor bugs and
0:52:53issues and in things that that
0:52:54developers need to do in order to get
0:52:57around small problems that I don't think
0:52:59that's reality and so in the end the
0:53:04academic in me says yes it should be
0:53:06final by default but I i come down with
0:53:09Marco that this seems to be a little too
0:53:12broad and a little too aggressive a
0:53:14change to be to be right
0:53:16is there an objective-c like at keyword
0:53:18or something for doing the equivalent of
0:53:20final are sealed
0:53:21I don't think it's possible so my take
0:53:24on this so far from looking at this
0:53:25thread and thinking about it a lot is
0:53:27that Swift seems to be like Casey point
0:53:30out like that the whole thing with Swift
0:53:32is it's trying to be trying to be less
0:53:37open let's open to interpretation less
0:53:40open to possibilities than objective c
0:53:43in terms of world is variable
0:53:44initialized when will be initialized can
0:53:46I do what can I guarantee about these
0:53:48things do I at one point do I have a
0:53:50half initialize object floating around
0:53:52somewhere in my thing like all you know
0:53:54can I be sure that this method i'm
0:53:56calling is going to exist in this thing
0:53:57how sure can i be sure I want to be some
0:54:01of that is for performance some of us
0:54:03for safety suffice for both but that is
0:54:04definitely the the direction Swift is
0:54:06going it's trying to have its cake and
0:54:08eat it too is like how we do things that
0:54:09are safer and we do things that are
0:54:12faster and we can do it with you know
0:54:15with with less typing and less code must
0:54:17cover be fewer bugs and so you know more
0:54:20power more safety more speed
0:54:21everything's good right but less
0:54:23flexibility is kind of floating around
0:54:24in there rattling around alright more
0:54:26power more safety more speed is it as
0:54:28flexible as it used to be well how do
0:54:30you define flexibility and app kit and
0:54:33the objective-c AP is have really really
0:54:35have been built around the ideas of
0:54:37subclassing so much so that it seems
0:54:40like this is the expectation if not of
0:54:42the framework offers then at least of
0:54:44the application developers that
0:54:47if you have some kind of problem uh
0:54:49maybe you can solve with the subclass
0:54:51right maybe maybe that class has
0:54:53everything you need but you need to add
0:54:55a little extra functionality so subclass
0:54:57it and categories are like some class
0:54:59too much trouble because it million
0:55:01other places inside the framework that
0:55:02use any string and throw category and a
0:55:04string now all your strength of about
0:55:06thirty method yay like a very sort of
0:55:10open to like this is this is a giant
0:55:14world's toys and you can screw with that
0:55:16world wise and and swift rise to do
0:55:18something else which has extensions
0:55:19which are like categories like how you
0:55:21want to throw a method on on every
0:55:22string or number in your thing go ahead
0:55:24you want to make a new operator that
0:55:26works on all integers you can do that
0:55:28like ya go nuts but it tries to do it in
0:55:30a safer way so given that safety is such
0:55:33a concern of the language huh
0:55:37I think it's natural it fits the Swift
0:55:39language to say final by default and
0:55:43furthermore i think that the technique
0:55:45of building user interface libraries
0:55:48where everything is assumed to be
0:55:50subclassed able by everybody leads to a
0:55:53substantial amount of the sadness that
0:55:55we good resuscitates the weird
0:55:57subclassing and eventually in rare cases
0:55:58this whistling to happen because not
0:56:01because like the the application
0:56:03developers are bad but because the
0:56:04people making the framework aren't
0:56:07giving like when they're writing you
0:56:09know all these classes that make up the
0:56:10frameworks that people use their not
0:56:13thinking about designing for subclass
0:56:16ability versus not there there and
0:56:18whatever mindset there and it's like
0:56:20someone could subclass me so i should
0:56:22make this class of classical but they're
0:56:24also probably thinking what was going to
0:56:27subclass this one or they're thinking
0:56:29when I need to update this class
0:56:30boy I'm about the updated classic new
0:56:33major version of this OS what about
0:56:36people who subclass the old one by
0:56:38breaking their crap by changing and it's
0:56:40like well I can't no I can't really know
0:56:41what they did in their sunglasses like I
0:56:43had no real way of expressing the things
0:56:45that I didn't expect to vary versus the
0:56:47things that I did and if they over this
0:56:49method and and did some weird thing or
0:56:51there is something you know timing
0:56:52ordering thing or having to do with this
0:56:55that I don't know what the subclasses
0:56:56doing and that the thing I think that
0:56:59final default
0:57:00will force people do is especially
0:57:03framework brothers think more about
0:57:05which parts of this framework should be
0:57:08some classical like what what are the
0:57:11extension points what are the things can
0:57:12that can vary versus the things that can
0:57:14vary maybe they come to the same
0:57:17decision
0:57:17this is the thing about the final
0:57:18default maybe it turns out that the
0:57:20people who are writing uikit or whatever
0:57:22like the next swifty version you know is
0:57:25they're very core foundation Swift as
0:57:27they work their way up the stack maybe
0:57:28those people who are writing those
0:57:29families will come to the same
0:57:30conclusion that all the same classes
0:57:31that you can override in UI kit but
0:57:33you'd also be able to you override and
0:57:34some swifty equivalent of the same type
0:57:37of UI framework like they would they
0:57:40were did you wouldn't lose any
0:57:41flexibility at all but at least they
0:57:43will then forced to think about it i
0:57:45would imagine what they come up with is
0:57:47to to reduce the surface area of things
0:57:51that you can mess with to make it
0:57:54clearer what what classes you're
0:57:56expected to subclass and maybe the
0:57:59documented better like how you how
0:58:01you're expected to subclass like how
0:58:03does a well-behaved subclass of this
0:58:04thing you know is it possible to
0:58:06sunglasses in a way that makes the
0:58:08little break with the next step date of
0:58:10this thing or just making some classes
0:58:11not some classical all because you're
0:58:13not supposed to mess with that if you
0:58:14really need to mess with it you should
0:58:15instead extend it or use composition to
0:58:19make your object have one of these
0:58:21instead of be one of these and it just
0:58:25seems like a more natural fit to Swift
0:58:26roommate was I think long-term forcing
0:58:29everybody involved in by changing the
0:58:31default forcing everybody involved to
0:58:33think more about subclassing instead of
0:58:35it just being the default like well of
0:58:37course I get some glasses everything
0:58:38it's like it's my wrist it's like you
0:58:40know it's my right it's like the First
0:58:42Amendment freedom of speech and freedom
0:58:43to subclass thinking more about it will
0:58:46will cause everybody involved both the
0:58:48framework colors and the programmers to
0:58:50try to to try to reduce the sort of the
0:58:55ante pattern that we see in the existing
0:58:57frameworks where everything is up for
0:58:59grabs and anytime something updates
0:59:01nobody is really sure about what they're
0:59:03breaking because they have no idea what
0:59:04people subclass inhale so I understand
0:59:08all of that but the problem I come down
0:59:11on is I don't think Apple would be a
0:59:14good citizen of this mindset and this is
0:59:17whatever and this is what i was saying
0:59:19earlier that apple would assume no all
0:59:23of our stuff is flawless
0:59:25we don't want you to subclass this
0:59:27there's no reasonable reason for you to
0:59:29ever have to subclass this so we're not
0:59:32going to allow you to and I don't think
0:59:34that they would be pragmatic enough to
0:59:37realize well we don't see any particular
0:59:42reason that anyone would need to
0:59:44subclass this class but you never know
0:59:48and you shouldn't hurt anything if you
0:59:50do so will just allow you to what what
0:59:53is the opposite of final key word in
0:59:55Swift you know I whatever it may be you
0:59:57know so well market is not final and
0:59:57know so well market is not final and
1:00:00it and I just don't think they'll be a
1:00:02good citizen of this environment I think
1:00:03other framework authors might because
1:00:06they seem to be less aggressive for lack
1:00:09of a better word but i don't i just
1:00:12don't think apple will be good citizens
1:00:13of that environment
1:00:15no I mean modern apple is pretty is
1:00:18restricted by default and in many ways
1:00:20towards developers and in most ways that
1:00:23has worked out well for them and so that
1:00:26that pattern of being restricted by
1:00:28default is it something that is so
1:00:31ingrained in them that I don't think
1:00:34they're going to revert course in that I
1:00:37mean objective-c is only as flexible
1:00:40loosey-goosey as it is because its
1:00:43ancient and it came from a time and a
1:00:46cult and a culture and a company that
1:00:48was very different from today's apple
1:00:49and where their dynamism was was the
1:00:52goal and and was considered very
1:00:54advanced for the time now modern Apple
1:00:58does things like this we're like you
1:01:00know Swift will be all locked down and
1:01:03and rigid and and strict and final by
1:01:07default that like I see them doing this
1:01:09mostly because it just fits in with with
1:01:13the way they see the things they see now
1:01:15is being correct and in many ways these
1:01:18things go in weight and programming you
1:01:19know like what we've programming is is
1:01:22not a young practice anymore it's been
1:01:24going on for decades things go in and
1:01:27out of fashion and you know and there
1:01:29are trends and there are fashions and
1:01:31there are you know fads and everything
1:01:33and open versus closed loose loose
1:01:37typing vs strict typing dynamic vs
1:01:40statically all these things go in a
1:01:41fashion at different times often just
1:01:44reacting to what was popular
1:01:46previously I think they just go in
1:01:48cycles and we're in a cycle now we're
1:01:51what is in fashion today is strictness
1:01:55and formalism and compile time check
1:01:58compile-time safety apple is right up
1:02:01there with everyone else with with Swift
1:02:04it in that regard and also in just the
1:02:07environment that apps running with being
1:02:09sit with you know iOS being locked down
1:02:11sandboxed everything
1:02:13Mac App Store being sandbox only if
1:02:15anybody's the mac app store whole
1:02:17separate discussion having technical
1:02:19blocks in front of calling private api
1:02:22is an app store apps things like that
1:02:24like this is the direction Apple is
1:02:26going and has been for quite some time
1:02:28so I i agree that this is not i wouldn't
1:02:32expect today's Apple too if given a
1:02:35choice to redesign something from
1:02:37scratch as they have with Swift to take
1:02:39the option to say you know what we're
1:02:41going to let people so class our stuff
1:02:43no they're looking for ways to lock it
1:02:45down and I think ultimately I i think
1:02:49what we've learned as a profession as
1:02:51programmers over the last few decades of
1:02:54having popularized oo programming i
1:02:58think what we've learned is that
1:02:59subclassing really is messy and has tons
1:03:03of anti-patterns and tons of potential
1:03:06for weird unforeseen bugs and problems
1:03:09and a lot of dysfunction that becomes
1:03:11possible without programming and of
1:03:12course the strip everything but I think
1:03:15as a working programmer III don't look
1:03:18around look around my friends and I see
1:03:20you know people who are all programmers
1:03:22who are kind of evaluating like people
1:03:24who are smartly print Simmons I can you
1:03:25know kind of evaluating like what how we
1:03:27should be doing is moving forward and
1:03:29subclassing in general is going out of
1:03:32fashion very quickly among programs not
1:03:34just not just among apple and Swift but
1:03:36among all programs i know subclassing is
1:03:38really out like it is it is going out it
1:03:41is possibly out now so you can look at
1:03:45Apple you can say as I have that I
1:03:47really don't see them choosing any
1:03:49differently on this if given the choice
1:03:50i think i see them going final by
1:03:52default
1:03:53just because it's apple and that's how
1:03:55they are these days but also I think
1:03:57there's enough support from programmers
1:04:00now for that you can't really say Apple
1:04:03is exclusively at fault ignoring what
1:04:05everyone's saying I think you can say
1:04:06you can make a good case for there being
1:04:08enough support the apples kind of making
1:04:10the right call for the whole community
1:04:11yeah that's the thing so to look at it
1:04:14from the flip side you know we don't
1:04:17know the sorts of things that Apple has
1:04:20to deal with you know we don't know the
1:04:22sorts of crazy ridiculous hack
1:04:25that third-party developers do that
1:04:27aren't as skilled as the Brent Simmons
1:04:29of the world you know the what makes a
1:04:31brand Simmons really good at what he
1:04:33does is that he knows when a hack is is
1:04:36the right answer and when it's not
1:04:38typically since it's being called a hack
1:04:41the answer is not often but we don't see
1:04:44the sorts of BS they have to put up with
1:04:46by the really shoddy developers that
1:04:47that aren't really thinking things
1:04:49through properly and so I think if i
1:04:53were an apple shoes it's easy to get
1:04:56lulled into trying to lock things down
1:04:59because you genuinely do feel like you
1:05:02know better and when you're looking at
1:05:03all these really disgusting hacks you do
1:05:06know better
1:05:07it's not just a feeling of knowing
1:05:08better you do know better but the
1:05:11problem is it's just it's the bazooka
1:05:13approach to something that that really
1:05:16you need a scalpel for and I mean I
1:05:19think what makes this discussion so
1:05:20fascinating what makes me enjoy
1:05:24engineering sorry dr. drank so much is
1:05:27that it's these sorts of difficult
1:05:30decisions that make our job so much fun
1:05:33you know 22 way these options and figure
1:05:36out what is the right answer but also I
1:05:38think you can you can look at like
1:05:39modern-day Apple as you know in be in
1:05:42the position of authority if you look at
1:05:44things like the appstore restrictions
1:05:46like private api restrictions like
1:05:47sandboxing on both platforms but
1:05:49especially in the mac i think if Apple
1:05:52presented with the option of do you let
1:05:55developers ship something that needs to
1:05:57ship and and this is like as you
1:05:59mentioned like this is you know you
1:06:01might be able to say well if you're if
1:06:03you're smart enough
1:06:04you're allowed to break the rules but
1:06:05that isn't first of all that isn't
1:06:07usually true and you still generally
1:06:09shouldn't because a it's still a bad
1:06:12idea and be you probably aren't smart
1:06:14enough but even even for people who are
1:06:18smart enough they still probably
1:06:19shouldn't be doing that because everyone
1:06:22is done at some point while programming
1:06:23and you know that the idiot who wrote
1:06:27that was probably just your past self
1:06:29but anyway if you look at like that the
1:06:33problems of shipping shipping things the
1:06:35problems of like you know in the real
1:06:36world especially like so much of the
1:06:38business these days as consultant and as
1:06:40you know like from being insulting
1:06:42shipping is often of utmost priority
1:06:46above things like doing things in
1:06:49exactly the best architectural way or
1:06:51best practices you know you just gotta
1:06:53ship stuff and and that's it but that
1:06:56isn't all that is an apples problem an
1:06:57apple doesn't necessarily play by those
1:06:59rules with the way it treats other
1:07:01developers if Apple's given the choice
1:07:04of letting developers ship more
1:07:07functional stuff more quickly at the
1:07:09expense of of security or restrictions
1:07:13or calling private api's apple doesn't
1:07:15choose to let them ship things apple
1:07:17says you know what that's not our
1:07:19problem we would rather have you not
1:07:21ship a product at all or ship a lesser
1:07:24product or ship a later product then
1:07:27break any of these rules and there's no
1:07:29better example of that than everything
1:07:31that's ever happened the mac app store
1:07:32like Apple would rather lose apps to
1:07:35that to the app stores and to their
1:07:36platforms they would rather lose apps
1:07:38completely or have apps be reduced
1:07:42functionality and lose features over
1:07:44time warden or never have certain
1:07:46features they would rather not allow
1:07:48those things or have a laugh fewer apps
1:07:50or have later or worse apps then have
1:07:52apps that are better in a more
1:07:54permissive environment sure everything I
1:07:57do in the mac app store is that much
1:07:58forethought that because a lot of
1:08:00unforeseen consequences unforeseen by
1:08:02Apple as well is that they have a goal
1:08:04in mind and realize there's be difficult
1:08:06to get from there from here so i think
1:08:07that's often side of a guy getting back
1:08:10to have something both you said earlier
1:08:11about what will apple do like that you
1:08:14know we can trust Apple this because
1:08:15they're going to lock everything down
1:08:16because that's the kind of company that
1:08:19they are i think it's appropriate for
1:08:23Apple to be more conservative because
1:08:25they're not just a company that writes a
1:08:27bunch of frameworks people use they are
1:08:29the platform they are the foundation
1:08:31there the thing upon which everybody
1:08:33else built they should be more
1:08:35conservative than you are with your own
1:08:38classes and stuff that's that's their
1:08:40role like so not that Swift is just made
1:08:43for them but in any language if there
1:08:47are tools to be conservative and to try
1:08:50to reduce the surface area tried
1:08:52reduce the public API try to reduce the
1:08:54number of things that other developers
1:08:56calling to like they do with like no
1:08:57stopping private api in their app stores
1:08:59and that's all part of the same process
1:09:01they should do that
1:09:02that's because they are there underneath
1:09:04everything else so they have a
1:09:06responsibility to be more solid and more
1:09:11resilient to people doing crazy things
1:09:12on top of them then the people who are
1:09:15building on top and your application
1:09:16code be all loosey-goosey all you want
1:09:18you can get away with that because the
1:09:20people building layers below you don't
1:09:22get to be a loosey goosey and travel
1:09:25sample does that and they follow through
1:09:27on what you think is their instinct to
1:09:28close stuff up which i'm not entirely
1:09:29sure that they would because again will
1:09:30be the same people who are advocating
1:09:31uikit during the thing and you like it
1:09:34isn't any more clothes than after they
1:09:35just change the change the vectors
1:09:38change the they knew which things would
1:09:39more be more likely to vary which is why
1:09:41you like it seems like so much nicer to
1:09:42deal with a nap because they learned out
1:09:44when people use this kind of thing
1:09:45mostly they want a very x y&z and so
1:09:48we'll build our glasses to make those
1:09:49things very well anyway if i was to
1:09:51close things off in the the new swift
1:09:54frameworks or whatever that would
1:09:58basically force people like developers
1:09:59like well I can't work around this
1:10:00anymore because I can't even subclasses
1:10:02thing over i do you think is your stupid
1:10:03framework is all closed off and I don't
1:10:05have your source code it's a binary
1:10:06framework so the only thing left for me
1:10:08is to file bugs and what that will mean
1:10:10is that many more developers are forced
1:10:13essentially to like they did they have
1:10:15no workaround they have to tell Apple
1:10:17hey I can't make my button now you know
1:10:20tent color and this button blue in this
1:10:22scenario because there's you know it
1:10:24because of the way the framework works i
1:10:26have no access to that little knob to
1:10:28turn and I can't subclass it and do that
1:10:31so please like you know but I'll file
1:10:34the bug and and I can't shut my app
1:10:36you're preventing your ship map is there
1:10:37is no workaround and apple in response
1:10:40to this has added pressure to consider
1:10:43these requests because they can't say oh
1:10:44yeah no that's a bug but for now just
1:10:46you can just work around about running
1:10:48this method like there is no workaround
1:10:49both parties no Jesus no workaround we
1:10:52didn't think about this this way that
1:10:54people use the frameworks that they
1:10:56can't get that they can change this
1:10:57thing that seems i'm only reasonable to
1:10:59change that's going to force Apple to
1:11:01reconsider maybe if we don't have
1:11:05this can we have can we provide a
1:11:07supportive way to do this and this much
1:11:09more motivation to provide a supportive
1:11:11way to do this if it's really common
1:11:13thing that tons of developers and there
1:11:14is literally no workaround is no
1:11:16workaround because of what Apple did the
1:11:17workaround is a no just open that class
1:11:19up the work you know this is the fixes
1:11:21but we don't want to just open the class
1:11:22up because we know what kind of problems
1:11:24that leads to it x everyone's hands in
1:11:26the future and makes it so than SOS the
1:11:28upgrade could break your app and stuff
1:11:29but if you really want to change this
1:11:32thing we should provide a supportive way
1:11:34to change it because there is no
1:11:36workaround so you would hope like what
1:11:38you're hoping like this is like all the
1:11:40best loss that you're hoping that
1:11:41motivates everyone involved to behave
1:11:43better like this is this is something
1:11:45pressing in on a system and you're
1:11:46hoping what it causes to happen is for
1:11:48the system to shape itself around this
1:11:50pressure in this this force to become a
1:11:52better thing than making everybody
1:11:54become better it's difficult to more
1:11:56people would be easier to just do
1:11:57whatever the hell they want but then you
1:11:58just have to both chaos right and in
1:12:01general that the larger issue of this
1:12:02whole thing about Swift and frameworks
1:12:04and apple the foundation and everything
1:12:06is no less code and increased safety is
1:12:10what you need when you want to create
1:12:11large complicated systems or systems
1:12:13keep getting better and keep getting
1:12:14more complicated and one of the biggest
1:12:16tools we have to fight against that is
1:12:17reduce the number of things that can go
1:12:20wrong reduce the number of things that
1:12:21you can do make more things deliberate
1:12:24unless things accidental thing
1:12:27yeah and and i think that's that's in
1:12:30the spirit of swift and it's just a
1:12:32spirit of the advancement of technology
1:12:33market talk about this going in cycles
1:12:34and dynamic vs static whatever I think
1:12:36all like that some of that stuff does go
1:12:39in cycles but increased safety is an
1:12:41arrow in one direction very very rarely
1:12:44do we see the world of writing programs
1:12:47for that territory verse and say we have
1:12:50this kind of safety where was impossible
1:12:52to scribble over memory but we'd like to
1:12:53add that in the next language that
1:12:55because it always goes towards more
1:12:56abstraction more safety and the safety
1:12:58can take different forms will be
1:12:59misguided about what you need to provide
1:13:01that safety or how do you know because
1:13:03small talk is pretty darn safe but it
1:13:05certainly looks nothing like Swift right
1:13:06so the move towards higher-level
1:13:09languages and increase safety
1:13:11however that may manifest that is an
1:13:13arrow that is essentially always going
1:13:14at one
1:13:15action and I think just the generations
1:13:16and getting there and the different
1:13:17paths towards that goal are separate and
1:13:20so is the dynamic vs taxes you can have
1:13:22an M again like small dog and eminently
1:13:24dynamic language that is very very safe
1:13:27you can also have an eminently static
1:13:28language that is also very very safe so
1:13:32the static and dynamic I i think does go
1:13:37in cycles not just based on fashion
1:13:40based on theory and everything like that
1:13:41but increase safety everybody always
1:13:43wants that and that's the direction I
1:13:44think so what is going so I I don't know
1:13:46this i forget who proposed decided it
1:13:48might have been a third-party proposal
1:13:49or whatever but bottom line for me is I
1:13:52think that since this doesn't change
1:13:54capabilities
1:13:56all it does is make everyone involved
1:13:57think about things differently and
1:13:59because the default will be different
1:14:00than objective-c i hope we'll call it
1:14:02cause everyone involved to to think
1:14:04differently than they used to think
1:14:06about it and that apple will know more
1:14:09things down and it will cause more
1:14:10ingenious for developers and apples will
1:14:12send feedback and an apple developers
1:14:14will some feedback the apple an apple
1:14:15will be forced to think about the
1:14:17feedback and provide a way to do it
1:14:18because they're reasonable request in
1:14:20there is literally no workaround and the
1:14:21end result should be for users programs
1:14:23that have fewer bugs third-party
1:14:25applications to break less frequently
1:14:26with OS upgrades and just generally more
1:14:29solid stable code for everyone going
1:14:31forward our final sponsor this week is
1:14:34warby parker go to warby parker calm /
1:14:37ATP that make buying glasses online easy
1:14:40and risk free order your FREE Home try
1:14:42on today so worried Parker offers
1:14:44contemporary eyeglasses that are
1:14:46extremely affordable and fashion-forward
1:14:48glasses should be viewed as a fashion
1:14:50accessory not costing as much as an
1:14:52iphone where we park offers prescription
1:14:54eyeglasses starting just $95 including
1:14:57prescription lenses and they also have
1:14:59added a titanium collection starting
1:15:01just a hundred and forty five dollars
1:15:02which includes premium Japanese titanium
1:15:04and French non rocking screws
1:15:06they also offer prescription and
1:15:08non-prescription sunglasses too even if
1:15:10you're 2020 there's still something for
1:15:12you at warby parker already Parker
1:15:14classes include anti-reflective
1:15:15anti-glare coatings an excellent hard
1:15:18case we have we have one of these are
1:15:19housed things maybe like a tank that the
1:15:20hard case they come with awesome and
1:15:22cleaning cloth at all no additional
1:15:24charge whether your eyesight is pretty
1:15:26good or absolutely abysmal
1:15:28they have you covered with a wide range
1:15:30prescription options from simple reading
1:15:32glasses to advanced digital freeform
1:15:34progressive lenses for those of you with
1:15:36very strong prescriptions therefore
1:15:38ultra-thin high index lenses to avoid
1:15:40the coke-bottle look now buying glasses
1:15:42online sounds like it will be tricky
1:15:44warby parker makes it easy and risk-free
1:15:46their home try-on program which you
1:15:48order five pairs of glasses to evaluate
1:15:50for free they ship them to you for free
1:15:52and you could try them on in the comfort
1:15:54of your own home and get feedback from
1:15:56anybody around you if you want to you
1:15:57can keep up to five days then you send
1:16:00them back also for free with their
1:16:01prepaid return label and there's no
1:16:03obligation to purchase anything if they
1:16:05are if they aren't for you you can just
1:16:06stop right there
1:16:07you spent nothing you're done if you
1:16:09decide they are right for you
1:16:11they can start on your order right away
1:16:12they can get prescription glasses to you
1:16:14within 10 business days and usually even
1:16:16faster they also believe in giving back
1:16:18to the world for every pair of glasses
1:16:20worry Parker sells the distributor the
1:16:22pair to somebody in need whether you
1:16:24could use a nice pair of eyeglasses
1:16:25reading glasses or even sunglasses go to
1:16:28warby parker calm / ATP order your FREE
1:16:31Home try on today with free shipping
1:16:33both ways and no obligation to buy once
1:16:36again that's warby parker calm / ATP
1:16:39thanks a lot to warby parker for
1:16:40sponsoring our show so John what does
1:16:43the open-source Swift mean for the
1:16:45future of go and rust know just thought
1:16:48it was interesting questions so there's
1:16:50a lot of languages out there that are
1:16:51very similar in spirit and you know
1:16:54visually even are already on the ideas
1:16:56behind them make a language that is
1:16:58kinda like see but without the nasty
1:17:02pointer stuff that is fast like those
1:17:04compiled languages but that has lots of
1:17:07more safety guarantees where the
1:17:09compiler can figure out all sorts of
1:17:10stuff for you so you don't have to do
1:17:11manual memory management but you get the
1:17:13speed of a language like C or C++ so go
1:17:17rusty Swift all kind of fall into that
1:17:20family they're all relatively new
1:17:21open-source Swift as we saw from that
1:17:25the project the open and the crazy
1:17:27activity and Swift evolution mailing
1:17:29list and just the sheer number of iOS
1:17:30developers who this is this language is
1:17:32potentially for and that the just yet
1:17:35even just a journal assignment at WC
1:17:37when Swift was announced in the first
1:17:39place that so it's pretty popular just
1:17:41big
1:17:41because because it belongs to apple like
1:17:42if you had just been a project you know
1:17:44off to the side by some random person we
1:17:46wouldn't be having the shows about it
1:17:48but it's because it's coming from apple
1:17:50that it's very popular goes from google
1:17:52another big company they use internally
1:17:54that is a tractor to pull on go being
1:17:57very popular also made by some of the
1:17:59folks that made see so that has some you
1:18:01know celebrity cachet behind it rust i
1:18:04think is from Muslim focus primarily I
1:18:06don't know the full backstory and rust
1:18:08but it's so if you have to compare the
1:18:10sizes of these communities you would
1:18:12think that like Apple and Swift is the
1:18:15most powerful not because they're bigger
1:18:17or more important company Google but
1:18:19merely because google uses all sorts of
1:18:20languages google uses a lot of java
1:18:22google uses python google uses go so
1:18:25it's not as if there's like this one
1:18:27google language and if there was to go
1:18:29probably wouldn't be it but with apple
1:18:31apple with has been for a long time now
1:18:33objective-c is there one language and
1:18:35their you moving over to Swift this kind
1:18:38of speak with one voice all the the
1:18:39Applewood is behind that one arrow right
1:18:41google have to come in second with go
1:18:43and like a google does have lots of
1:18:45different languages and has always been
1:18:46kind of like encouraging of using lots
1:18:48of different and they have dark their
1:18:49own language and also something lots of
1:18:52languages are mixing around there but
1:18:54google is a big company and they write a
1:18:55lot of stuff and go is fairly important
1:18:58language and then finally google has
1:19:00more languages than I have mac pros like
1:19:01that's the they just make a new language
1:19:04like every six months you never know
1:19:06where it goes
1:19:07so it doesn't this doesn't look around
1:19:08and then rest i think is even smaller
1:19:10because like well-muscled they make a
1:19:12web browser and a bunch of other stuff
1:19:13and they're important but Andres is
1:19:16really interesting and it's not like you
1:19:18have to use all these languages the
1:19:19general-purpose language that you could
1:19:21use for anything but they all have
1:19:22communities around them they're all
1:19:24fairly open and you could in theory
1:19:25right anything you want to go Marco even
1:19:27wrote a thing for our guests and go and
1:19:28rescue could use to read any time and
1:19:30same thing with Swift right but splits
1:19:32coming on the scene and being someone to
1:19:34the two languages and having the full
1:19:36weight of Apple behind it could
1:19:38potentially do one of two things either
1:19:40it could suck people away from those
1:19:42things they can say well i was
1:19:43interested in go and rest but Swift
1:19:45seems very similar and just seems to be
1:19:47like more popular
1:19:48as a better ide and I keep hearing about
1:19:50it and whatever or I like it better
1:19:52something like that just because apples
1:19:54behind it or gonna have the opposite
1:19:55effect where it's like I wasn't going to
1:19:58consider one of these alternate
1:19:59languages but now the Swift is that it
1:20:01seems like all bets are off on what used
1:20:02to seem safe
1:20:03C C++ or C sharp or Java that's all then
1:20:06boston now it's time for me to try it
1:20:07also it's a new languages so maybe go
1:20:09and rest receive a huge influx of
1:20:11activity and pull requests and people
1:20:14contributing to their communities as
1:20:15well as well check back in the year and
1:20:17see you know I don't know you'd measures
1:20:18may be like go to github or whatever and
1:20:20see like what happened to the go and
1:20:22rest communities in you know is there
1:20:24anyway we can measure that was the
1:20:27effect of Swift to cause those
1:20:28communities to swell and importance in
1:20:30those languages to mature and become
1:20:31more popular or was the effect to sort
1:20:34of pull people away from those two
1:20:35communities and have them sort of with
1:20:37her more now that the the giant Sun that
1:20:39is Swift is shining down from WWDC every
1:20:42year
1:20:43alright alright thanks a lot 43 sponsors
1:20:46this week
1:20:47audible.com igloo and warby parker and
1:20:51we will see you next week
1:20:52now the show is over they didn't even
1:20:58mean to be in because it was accidental
1:21:01death was accidental
1:21:05John research Marco and Casey would let
1:21:09him because it was accidental was
1:21:13accidental
1:21:14you can find show know today
1:21:18DP die and if twitter follow them
1:21:26yes byl ISS so that's Casey list and a
1:21:31co-pay rm20 Marco Arment our CC Syracuse
1:21:52name itself this about Casey put in
1:21:56there rip webobjects i think i might
1:21:58have rip you mean r.i.p yes as in what
1:22:02does this mean for what objects
1:22:03yeah I don't know products is a mystery
1:22:06to me a mystery to everyone
1:22:08I mean I don't know anything about
1:22:10webobjects but I do know that it is it
1:22:13is blamed for a lot of the the
1:22:16shortcomings of apples web services and
1:22:18I i would guess it's probably not all
1:22:21about what my doctor i'm guessing that
1:22:23it's much more about like the entire
1:22:25rest of the stack and that's that is
1:22:28probably a small part of the problem if
1:22:30it's even still part of the problem at
1:22:31all
1:22:32it is probably connected to it but just
1:22:34like the consequences what does it mean
1:22:36what what are the consequences that spin
1:22:38out from the fact that using objects
1:22:39well then we have to return this plug
1:22:41well we have to run this OS and well the
1:22:43way with allergy applications are gonna
1:22:45have to factor in this way you can
1:22:46really split this up from that and you
1:22:48can't this isn't horizontally scalable
1:22:49and these are these are tightly coupled
1:22:51instead of loosely coupled we can
1:22:52replace this with the better version of
1:22:53this component you know those
1:22:55consequences that ripple outwards from
1:22:58robotics what object itself i would
1:23:00think it's not a big deal but I don't
1:23:02know I i just wonder with the technology
1:23:03like that just seems to be like the only
1:23:05person left in the world using it as
1:23:06Apple which is fine but at a certain
1:23:08point like every company even if your
1:23:11google has to be like it's going to be a
1:23:13thing we do it is we should probably
1:23:14make it open and try to get other people
1:23:16to use it was just us using it will kind
1:23:18of do a crappy job like it's better to
1:23:20get everybody else on board like they're
1:23:22doing
1:23:22swiftor go or resting and then to try to
1:23:25say we just use internally we we can
1:23:28support our own weird web framework and
1:23:30definitely can't we
1:23:31maybe not what else going on
1:23:34you wanna talk about the Chevy bolt
1:23:37that's antiques get in the chat the what
1:23:40is that though the smaller vault
1:23:42yeah its battery only it claimed up to
1:23:44do up to 200 mile range could be
1:23:47substantial thirty thousand dollars it's
1:23:50not attractive looks like the i3 yeah I
1:23:53i saw a 93 in person again in the day
1:23:55and it's one of those things like
1:23:56whenever a new model of a new like crazy
1:24:00design comes out at first it seems like
1:24:02wacky and crazy and ugly and then over
1:24:04time you can get you soon as you see the
1:24:05morning
1:24:06more and it gets you know less new the
1:24:08i3 has not followed that progression for
1:24:10me to be high three every time I see it
1:24:12is worse than the last time I said but
1:24:15it's so bad why didn't i didn't read
1:24:19anything about this
1:24:20I've thought about it in the past like
1:24:22I'm not in the market for a car but wait
1:24:24aren't you know kind of for Aaron well
1:24:27for Aaron yeah but not for me but I've
1:24:30been thinking and this would not be
1:24:31forever and it would be for me i rarely
1:24:34drive more than a hundred miles in a
1:24:37week maybe like my commute up until i
1:24:40went and did staff fog which is markers
1:24:42favorite thing my commute was like five
1:24:43minutes and so I would drive maybe 10
1:24:47miles in a day maybe you take a
1:24:49hoverboard to work
1:24:50yeah pretty much which by the way i just
1:24:52realized tonight that the hoverboards
1:24:54everyone we're talking about is like a
1:24:55segway without the handlebars I'd I had
1:24:57no idea what everyone was talking about
1:24:59and basically yeah it's a lot simpler
1:25:01and less sophisticated but that's
1:25:03basically it
1:25:04yeah I didn't realize that was a thing
1:25:06but anyway um I there's no reason for me
1:25:10not to have an electric car because I
1:25:11Drive very little it would absolutely
1:25:14charge itself overnight
1:25:15there's no reason for me not to have one
1:25:17except that every single electric car
1:25:20I've ever seen other than the Tesla is
1:25:24either hideous slow or both and I'm just
1:25:27not into that
1:25:28so good at Tesla I need to find I need
1:25:33to work like three jobs so respond to
1:25:35this week by former you exactly need
1:25:38three more jobs or you guys need to not
1:25:42take sponsorship money for the next like
1:25:44six months and then maybe we can think
1:25:46about it I don't know but uh this is
1:25:48interesting i guess the boat looks like
1:25:50a American press is what it looks like
1:25:53yeah kinda like it's small it's a small
1:25:56populace car is not like the model s
1:25:59where it's trying to be like a
1:26:01full-sized regular shape car that also
1:26:04happens to be electric the sum was
1:26:06another 1i forgot the name of the
1:26:08company was some kind of basically
1:26:09taking Tesla's and putting a different
1:26:11body on oh yeah I'm for the Faraday or
1:26:14something
1:26:14is that what that was about yeah that is
1:26:17it's like the Tesla like the little
1:26:19the thing you see in the test the store
1:26:20in the mall just like the battery and
1:26:22the drivetrain and the wheels and they
1:26:24build a different car on top of it so
1:26:26presumably more money and it seems silly
1:26:28again it was a it was like the FF 0 or
1:26:31something like that which which made me
1:26:33happy because it's a play on the FC 0
1:26:35super nintendo game which I love if it
1:26:38was they would be sued
1:26:39speaking of which how about that that
1:26:42Apple watch clone from the Swiss
1:26:45mechanical watchmaker I did you see the
1:26:48black no no neighs loop i see i saw in
1:26:51the monomer site that looks interesting
1:26:52but I mean it
1:26:55there's no reason why Apple couldn't do
1:26:57that like off the top of my head unless
1:26:58there's some kind of manufacturing
1:26:59challenge but tell you what the
1:27:01so right now you stole my mechanical
1:27:03watch thing but the the the black the
1:27:06space black link bracelet that I got I
1:27:10don't know six months ago now for my
1:27:11Apple watch that that black dlc coding
1:27:14is the real deal like it is still
1:27:17flawless and any kind of stainless steel
1:27:19band or the same steel watch itself get
1:27:22scratched to hell in like a second the
1:27:24black the space black with the dlc on it
1:27:27is just literally like it mine has no
1:27:31scratches on it at all like it is it
1:27:33like it is crazy how good that coding is
1:27:36so I I welcome Apple adding more options
1:27:41that have dlc because that is it's just
1:27:43awesome
1:27:43it is so good this mechanical Apple
1:27:46watches is not good i don't understand
1:27:49what their yeah i just looked at the
1:27:51moment you started talking it that's why
1:27:53why why Apple had to make it like that
1:27:56you don't it went to me like this it's
1:27:59like it the world of mechanical watches
1:28:01if you if you look at mechanical watches
1:28:03and the appeal they have and and you
1:28:06look at the complaints that that
1:28:07mechanical watch people have about the
1:28:09Apple watch one of the big complaint is
1:28:11that the Apple watchers isn't that
1:28:13attractive watch so why would you make
1:28:16one that looks just like it like it
1:28:19seems
1:28:20first of all apples gonna sue the crap
1:28:21out of you and make this stop
1:28:23immediately
1:28:24second of all what like why third of all
1:28:27they only selling it in gold
1:28:30so it's like 25 grand
1:28:32I didn't make enough money to pay for a
1:28:35lawyer who's gonna buy that like who's
1:28:38gonna who's gonna spend 25 grand on that
1:28:41yeah I don't know it just seems silly
1:28:44but I mean you like it's like these
1:28:47watchmakers like what what's what's
1:28:49going on what's exciting in the watch
1:28:50world this entire year we heard about
1:28:52this tuple Apple watch how can we get in
1:28:54on that excitement something how about
1:28:57we make you like it we can make a
1:28:59SmartWatch like we don't know how to do
1:29:00that how to make a regular water's make
1:29:02it look like the Apple watch right yeah
1:29:05similar like the tag heuer I don't know
1:29:09how to pronounce i'm suing its tag or
1:29:11toddler they're smart watch that they
1:29:15released a few months ago
1:29:16it's like the it looks just like a
1:29:20regular like you know round mechanical
1:29:22watch face but it is just a black screen
1:29:26like the Apple watch most of the time it
1:29:28seems like and then like you know it
1:29:29turns on and it has a face that looks
1:29:31like a tag heuer watch you know but like
1:29:34to me again like that kind of ruins the
1:29:36point if you're gonna have a watch with
1:29:37a screen black all the time and then
1:29:38eventually look at it and glanced at it
1:29:40and there's like a computer you have to
1:29:41manage then I think the apple watch is
1:29:43the one to get because if you want a
1:29:46computer watch that seems like it's
1:29:47probably the best computer watch
1:29:49right like I I don't get it like now
1:29:51that I've seen this world just a little
1:29:53bit
1:29:53I totally see the value of a good
1:29:56mechanical watch and I totally see the
1:29:58value of a computer watch and I don't
1:30:00think those things should be crossed i
1:30:02think crossing them destroys the value
1:30:04of both really this is gonna get now you
1:30:07must also watch people
1:30:08well we've already gotten by even I've
1:30:11gotten a lot of stuff from the watch
1:30:14people you know I've been thinking in
1:30:17the watch world and speaking like
1:30:18smartwatches a mechanic watching
1:30:19everything I've been impressed so far
1:30:21anyway
1:30:22still other wait another year but
1:30:23impressed with how Fitbit has reacted to
1:30:26the challenge of the Apple watch
1:30:28reacting by basically making newer and
1:30:33more capable series of things that are
1:30:35mostly featureless bands with very
1:30:37simple screens incorporated into them in
1:30:40subtle ways i saw a picture of the press
1:30:42been wearing a lot of people have the
1:30:43newer fits like they found kind of in
1:30:46the same way that the pebble didn't her
1:30:48maybe you know people had some good
1:30:50ideas to be like trying to find like how
1:30:52am i different than the apple watch but
1:30:54still a valuable product like what is
1:30:55the road that is still available to me
1:30:57to go forward and fit seems to it be
1:31:00I mean who knows there could be like to
1:31:01flip remember the flip camera back in
1:31:03those years before before the iphone
1:31:05shot video
1:31:06oh yeah the flip camera had a Grilli
1:31:07great business for like three years
1:31:09yeah right and so it is still remains to
1:31:11be seen if it will find a way like out
1:31:13of the woods but so far like their
1:31:15reaction to the post Apple watch time
1:31:17has been pretty good
1:31:18no they found it its it's the Fitbit
1:31:20blaze is a real thing yeah look at it
1:31:23that's that's how they're getting away
1:31:24from the Apple watch that's the thing
1:31:28was like an Apple watch with the
1:31:29quarters punched out and that's not the
1:31:31way i would say you would go towards
1:31:33about talking about the the other food
1:31:35products the white things activity steal
1:31:38this i think it is a more
1:31:41this is like a better competitor at
1:31:42least I haven't seen one in real life
1:31:44but on their website looks really nice
1:31:45like this is the kind of thing like i
1:31:48can see buying that valuing that rather
1:31:52than Apple watch before i could see like
1:31:54you know that the the big Fitbit corner
1:31:57cut off a watch
1:31:59it's a smart approaches it's like it's
1:32:02mostly a mechanical watch basically are
1:32:04many units of course probably know it's
1:32:05like it's mostly a regular watch with
1:32:07some very slight like activity tracking
1:32:10and sleep alarm kind of things so like
1:32:12it still has all the battery advantages
1:32:14of our regular watch its low-cost it's
1:32:17only with under two hundred bucks and
1:32:19you know long batter is it can be more
1:32:21attractive
1:32:22yeah it means to I think it from these
1:32:23pictures it looks pretty attractive who
1:32:25knows again who knows like in real life
1:32:26but but it looks pretty decent you know
1:32:29under 200 bucks activity tracking
1:32:31built-ins like that seems like that's a
1:32:34better kind of approach to to addressed
1:32:36to try to compete with the Apple watch
1:32:37rather than to be a full-featured
1:32:39computer platform because you're not
1:32:41going to do that if you're why things or
1:32:43Fitbit you're just you're not going to
1:32:45compete on that front and the blade
1:32:47looks more like a fitness like it's only
1:32:49focused on fitness gps type thing but i
1:32:52was thinking of the charge and the
1:32:53charge HR and even the Flex like the
1:32:55evolution of the Flex into increasingly
1:32:58large rubbery bands with a tiny little
1:33:00screen that that appeals to people for
1:33:03athletics like it's for activity and
1:33:04athletics just so focused on fitness
1:33:06fits right in the name like use clips i
1:33:08guess they do have a clear but like
1:33:09Fitbit like we're not going to be a
1:33:11general-purpose platform for smart
1:33:13watching everything we do is gonna be
1:33:15about fitness and so you can make this
1:33:17whole line of products with a similar
1:33:19value proposition of we track the stuff
1:33:21that you're doing your heart rate and
1:33:22your activity and we connect your
1:33:24smartphone with a nap and all that stuff
1:33:25but there's no real brains in our thing
1:33:27is just an accelerometer and a tiny
1:33:28simple screen and some magic invisible
1:33:31bluetooth that just you know make organ
1:33:32even the blaze thing looks like you know
1:33:35I like those garmin gps things like a
1:33:38really fancy version of a thing you wear
1:33:40when your exercise I do not buy the ones
1:33:41you like the woman in like with jewelry
1:33:44with her fancy purse i just do not buy
1:33:46that scenario at all for this thing
1:33:49because it is huge and I absolutely
1:33:52don't buy it as anything of boy looks
1:33:54bad
1:33:55no one really cares like that they're
1:33:56like it's a boner man going on a date
1:33:57and bring a suit and it's like he's
1:33:59wearing a suit with this watch like yeah
1:34:02I didn't know this existed might have to
1:34:03take back some of my my credit but the
1:34:06other things i see them around a lot i
1:34:08see them around a lot of regular people
1:34:09and they so clearly have is so cheap
1:34:13compared to the apple watch and they're
1:34:15so like not disposable but like they're
1:34:18made of plastic and their rugged and
1:34:20they're there they have such a clear
1:34:22purpose and they're simple and you want
1:34:26don't have to worry about like rebooting
1:34:28them are updating the OS or getting apps
1:34:31for them all you know they just know
1:34:33again remember the flip camera will come
1:34:36back to this in a year and see how see
1:34:37how this all shaken out
1:34:38yeah i mean i really i really do think
1:34:40there's going to be a healthy market for
1:34:42inexpensive more focused smart watches
1:34:47that are not full-fledged at platforms
1:34:49and because you could argue looking at
1:34:51the apple watch how like the Apple watch
1:34:53really isn't a great a platform either
1:34:55it tries to be and maybe it will be in
1:34:58the future but at the moment it isn't
1:35:00and that the and what people tend to
1:35:03like most about the Apple watch is the
1:35:05stuff that
1:35:06a two-hundred-dollar less capable watch
1:35:09with a longer battery life probably
1:35:11could do most of you know ya like it
1:35:15like this with things are wild things
1:35:16thing like it was the old as the price
1:35:18of compute drops to zero eventually
1:35:20smart cuts go into everything just
1:35:21because it's so friggin Shakespearean
1:35:23like that it's why would you have is a
1:35:25regular quartz watch without some very
1:35:28basic accelerometer step tracking
1:35:30computer smarts and wireless
1:35:31connectivity because eventually that the
1:35:33thing that does all that in one tiny
1:35:35system in the chip five years from now
1:35:36it's like that costs less than the the
1:35:39little metal bar that we used to connect
1:35:41the straps like just put it in its free
1:35:43and so everything has some amount of
1:35:44smarts in an apple is making the
1:35:46high-end one where they're always
1:35:47pushing the envelope like what kinda
1:35:48crazy computing stuff can we put in here
1:35:50but it's like you know like the Internet
1:35:52of Things eventually it's just like
1:35:54we're going to a smart chip and
1:35:55everything and we think that will make
1:35:57it better and probably one in the
1:35:58beginning but it just become so cheap
1:36:00that you just do it because you can you
1:36:03just try to like find a use for it and
1:36:05eventually hopefully we'll find in the
1:36:06same way that electricity camera and
1:36:08everything you're like everything didn't
1:36:09have electricity all I need electricity
1:36:11for a lightbulb who what about
1:36:13electricity in a thing and heat see your
1:36:15house and electricity for that you
1:36:17shovel colon what about electricity and
1:36:19the thing that cooks your food well you
1:36:21just put wood in the stove what about
1:36:23you know toasting your bread i just put
1:36:25it up and white is unless you need to be
1:36:26in everything is just gonna make
1:36:27everything worse and in the beginning it
1:36:29did but eventually everything's got free
1:36:30electricity so that's gonna be the same
1:36:33with with cpus not everything cpus now
1:36:36but it is inevitable
1:36:38they will the same way they all get
1:36:39electricity because and we'll have to
1:36:41endure the stupid years
1:36:43we're adding it makes everything worse
1:36:45you know i i'm i'm absolutely sure that
1:36:48the first electric stoves were hated by
1:36:50everybody who is used to the
1:36:52quote-unquote real stoves that didn't
1:36:54have electricity but eventually worked
1:36:55out even even today some people still
1:36:57have giant gas stoves but no computers
1:37:01coming watch out
1:37:02yeah I don't know by as I said last time
1:37:06and then a time I've been spent some
1:37:08time where mechanical watch it is really
1:37:11nice to have something that does not
1:37:13need to be charged or have software
1:37:15updates click it's so nice because
1:37:18everything else in my
1:37:20life now has to be charged and require
1:37:22software updates and and by the way
1:37:24works you know
1:37:26ninety-seven percent of the time but not
1:37:29that last three percent and even the
1:37:31crappy mechanical ones I don't talk
1:37:33about the computer comes everywhere it
1:37:34will be so small that you won't need to
1:37:35charge it all the time i get probably
1:37:37charge of stuff from the motion of your
1:37:38wrist or something and you won't need to
1:37:39update the software because it will do
1:37:41so few things and it will be a stick set
1:37:43of functionality but there will still be
1:37:44a cpu like in the same way that have
1:37:47these vacuums are testing probably have
1:37:48some microprocessor somewhere inside you
1:37:49never need to update your never gonna
1:37:51update it just does what it's going to
1:37:52do you don't even know it's there you
1:37:53have to think about charging as you plug
1:37:54it in but it's in there in the same way
1:37:58all of our cars have a design computers
1:37:59and now for the most part we're not
1:38:01running soft well Marco is now but most
1:38:03of us and our heads home for updates on
1:38:05our computer on our cars but they're
1:38:07just they're filled with cpus so that's
1:38:09the progression need if you're still
1:38:11thinking about it and having to charge
1:38:13and software update that's clearly like
1:38:14on the on the leading edge of adding
1:38:18computers to things when we stopped even
1:38:20knowing this computer in it that's the
1:38:22trailing edge of adding computers things
1:38:23like cutting off cars on the trailing
1:38:25edge his cars have this all of the
1:38:27revolution of having their interiors
1:38:29become a computerized but the engines
1:38:31have long since been computerized that
1:38:33ship has kind of sailed on our computer
1:38:34I smell rest of the card I think of
1:38:35another example something in our house
1:38:37maybe washing maybe dishwasher or
1:38:39washing machines they used to just be
1:38:41like circuit boards with a bunch of six
1:38:43circuits and stuff but eventually they
1:38:44just all got cpus and we don't think
1:38:47about it you don't update them and you
1:38:48know how to charge them then it's not a
1:38:49hassle and they don't crash because what
1:38:51they do is so stupid and so simple and
1:38:54you know for the most part and maybe
1:38:56I'll come with a better example
1:38:58yes that's fine like like the stuff
1:39:00that's basically like you know a sealed
1:39:01box where like you can't get a firmware
1:39:04update for your dishwasher like I'm sure
1:39:06it's possible for server people do it
1:39:08but like that isn't something to
1:39:09consumers are expected to ever do or
1:39:11even able to do because what they do is
1:39:14so simple and basic like you hoped there
1:39:16would be no need for such a thing but
1:39:18where were the danger of being annoying
1:39:21and reliable comes in as you have
1:39:23something as complicated as an app
1:39:25platform you know like a device that has
1:39:27an apple from like a SmartWatch like
1:39:29that that is complicated
1:39:31so now you're expected to have like this
1:39:33smartwatch a phone maybe a tablet
1:39:36certainly a computer or one of those
1:39:37things you know so like you have all
1:39:39these devices that thing and then your
1:39:41cars are getting smarter they have
1:39:42software that whether it whether it gets
1:39:45updated or not it probably needs to like
1:39:48like my car now does not have
1:39:51over-the-air updates the way Tesla does
1:39:52but it has plenty of software bugs that
1:39:55should be fixed
1:39:56yeah its biggest don't get fixed at the
1:39:58quality that they have the platform
1:40:00thing is interesting because I think
1:40:01we're in the process of trying to figure
1:40:03out what things should be platforms and
1:40:05what things should I think like for the
1:40:07most part thus far we've decided that
1:40:08washing machine should not be
1:40:10application platforms
1:40:11I think we're all pretty much in
1:40:12agreement there so far but people are
1:40:14going to try things that she watches the
1:40:16application platforms should phones
1:40:18should like should televisions we're
1:40:21finding out the answers to those things
1:40:22now I think we pretty much found out
1:40:23phones yes they should probably be
1:40:25application platforms to televisions
1:40:27carry kinda maybe still out watches jury
1:40:31still out cars i think your figure
1:40:34you're gonna figure that out for us mark
1:40:35alright mean that maybe like this is not
1:40:37really you know it
1:40:39everything is potentially one but they
1:40:41can't all be there is no future where
1:40:43everything is an app platform in the way
1:40:45that we think of that platforms today
1:40:46but everything will have cpu is
1:40:48everything for all you know everything
1:40:49could be getting magic wireless software
1:40:51updates you know again as the as the
1:40:52price of computing drops to zero as the
1:40:55power consumption of computing drops to
1:40:56zero as it becomes just so damn cheap
1:40:58and so power you know and and like
1:41:02ubiquitous net wireless networking
1:41:03everywhere with low-power you just put
1:41:05in everything and if you can come up
1:41:08with these sort of the wireless internet
1:41:11enabled equivalent of the dumb embedded
1:41:13cpu that's in your rice cooker that does
1:41:15the fuzzy logic fair when to stop
1:41:16cooking your rice if that has some
1:41:18little minor bug or even just want to
1:41:21patch something to the International
1:41:22Date authority decides we're going to
1:41:24skip january fifteenth in the year 2027
1:41:26for some reason or whatever that all the
1:41:29devices in your house will wirelessly
1:41:31get updates to handle that date thing
1:41:33and you won't think about it they'll be
1:41:35great like that's a that's a potential
1:41:37cool future and it's eminently possible
1:41:39but it still doesn't make it right here
1:41:41in a platform because that just doesn't
1:41:42make any sense you know practically
1:41:44speaking
1:41:45because what we use it for you just
1:41:47wanted to be reliable and like 70 MW it
1:41:49may have bugs and you would like it was
1:41:51Bugsy six but you don't want to deal
1:41:52with that crap nobody wants to deal with
1:41:54it you just wanted to happen auto
1:41:55magically with no possibility of error
1:41:57like the rules for embedded systems are
1:42:00so different than the rules for things
1:42:02that are at platforms and then we're out
1:42:03there on the bleeding edge like the
1:42:04Apple watch and and smartphones and our
1:42:06pcs perpetually on the bleeding edge
1:42:08that's where things get all unreliable
1:42:10and crapping this is a whole different
1:42:11set of rules there and it came back to
1:42:14the Swift discussion if they can try to
1:42:16to drag those leading edge platforms
1:42:18towards more safety at the price of our
1:42:20restrictions as long as they do it in
1:42:22the same way and understand what the
1:42:23consequences can be unlikely sort of
1:42:25unintended consequences of trying to
1:42:27drag general-purpose Mac platform to be
1:42:29like a smartphone the sandboxing then I
1:42:31think things can work out eventually
1:42:33probably will mostly be dead but i find
1:42:36a little long time so we'll say