0:00:00Guy, it's been a very long time since you've been on the show.
0:00:02It has, man! I don't... I'm not sure. I don't remember the last time it was on your show.
0:00:07Oh, but it was probably a Star Wars thing with Sir Akuza.
0:00:10Yeah, I think... I forget what the topic was,
0:00:11but I think it was not this January but last January. So time flies.
0:00:17'Cause at one point we were doing Star Wars movies every year when they would come out
0:00:22and I think our review of Rise of Skywalker is wrapped up perfectly by us just not,
0:00:29not only not doing a show, you didn't even text Sir Akuza and I. It's not like...
0:00:33It's just like nobody cared. Nobody cared to touch that. It just left it.
0:00:37It pops up on the Mastodon and Twitter and wherever people make suggestions for who should
0:00:42be on the show and it comes up, "Hey, how about doing a Star Wars to wrap it up?"
0:00:47I will say, I mean, this is not the Rise of Skywalker episode, which may or may not ever
0:00:55exist. I will say this, I was so unhappy with that movie that I've literally only seen it once,
0:01:00which I believe... I'm pretty sure I went to see it opening night. I know it was in the theater
0:01:05and I know it was at least opening weekend and we watched it and we walked out and
0:01:11I haven't seen it again. I haven't seen it again.
0:01:15Oh, all of a sudden the guy who died 20 years ago is still alive and he built 10,000
0:01:24Star Destroyers and hit them all on a planet and... what?
0:01:28Does it... I mean, it's not like Star Wars often makes a lot of sense.
0:01:32Yeah, but that's anti-sense though.
0:01:35Exactly.
0:01:36Yeah.
0:01:36Right. There's rules in a fantasy setting. They're not realistic rules, but you create rules and
0:01:4210,000 hidden Star Destroyers is not one.
0:01:46Yeah, with beams that blow up planets. Anyway, whatever. Skip that. We're following
0:01:50into the chat, man. Forget the...
0:01:52Here's the better reason to have you on this week, preceding WWDC 2023,
0:01:58is that I've got my live show coming up, I guess, not a week from today. It'll be a week from today
0:02:07as the show airs tomorrow, but a week from tomorrow as we record on the 30th.
0:02:12So get that out of the way. Everybody listening, if you haven't seen me announce it on Daring
0:02:17Fireball, tickets are available. It'll be Wednesday, June 7th, back at the very lovely,
0:02:24I mean that no sarcasm, it's a wonderful, wonderful theater in California theater in San Jose, the big
0:02:291100 seat old theater in San Jose on Wednesday of WWDC week at five o'clock. Tickets are available,
0:02:37selling briskly, probably going to be sold out soon, but probably not by the time the show airs,
0:02:43so anybody who wants tickets, go there and get them. But going down memory lane, you were
0:02:50my guest on the live episode from WWDC 10 years ago, that's 2013, which was the year the
0:03:00Mac Pro, what do we call that Mac Pro? Colloquially known the trash can. That's a shame. I really,
0:03:09I don't like calling it. I knew that that's what we were going to wind up calling it, but yeah.
0:03:14I mean, it looks like a trash can, which is fine. So I think, yes, so we were on stage there. We had
0:03:22Scott Simpson and Amy and Paul Kaposas was up there too. It was a good gang. This was prior to
0:03:26you getting great guests. You were like making do with me and Scott.
0:03:31Well, it shows how time has changed. Not that I wouldn't love to have you on stage with me,
0:03:39either, but I do believe... Oh man, that would be such a disappointment.
0:03:42It's just me and Moltz. I heard Jason lick. I haven't heard the most recent episode,
0:03:46but Jason was saying just him and Moltz on stage. I would love that. That would be great.
0:03:50Look, you're my favorite people. But whoever, if you ever run dry for like execs at Apple execs
0:03:56or anything or anybody interesting, and you end up with me and Moltz on stage, there is going to be,
0:04:01somehow, tomatoes are going to like manifest themselves and just get whipped at the stage.
0:04:06It's going to be horrible. We have nothing but a letdown.
0:04:10I'm trying to think. I think that the first one where I had an Apple exec was 2015. I think that's
0:04:18the... I think so, yeah.
0:04:20I think that's the I shit you not Phil Schiller, where it went from live shows in a mezzanine. I
0:04:28forget how many people that place fit. It was weird because it actually had a mess.
0:04:31It was like 100, 150, I think.
0:04:33No, it was 100 or 150 downstairs in front of the stage. But the reason that the place was
0:04:38called mezzanine is it had a mezzanine. And it was like, some of the seats were obstructed,
0:04:44but they had big TVs that had a live feed so that people could see it.
0:04:47It was pretty big. I was thinking of Mina, like 111 Mina, maybe?
0:04:52Yeah, 111 Mina was like the first couple of years, and that place was only like 100
0:04:56people or something like that.
0:04:57Yeah, yeah. No, mezzanine was impressive. Like, you could actually pack a room, which,
0:05:02knowing you surprises me, I guess. I don't know. Is it that interesting? I don't know.
0:05:09But yeah, no, that's great. And again, I heard you talking to Jason that WWDC is not bringing
0:05:15the same number, sheer number of people, Sarah, from like 5,000 about when it was up in SF,
0:05:21and the past couple of years being... I don't know how many. Apple's got 500, maybe a few
0:05:26hundred in? I'm not sure. But yeah, I'm confident you're going to sell out. I don't know how the
0:05:31tickets are going. Get them on that link.
0:05:33I'm looking at the history of it. So 2013 was you and Scott. I forget who else. And then the
0:05:39next year was the ATP gang. I had Marco, John Siracusa, and what's the third guy's name?
0:05:47Casey. Casey Liss. Casey Liss. That's it. That's it.
0:05:51I'm mean enough to Casey Liss.
0:05:54It is, because I've even had him on the show.
0:05:59I know. I know. He really holds that show together. He's not that he's the rug from
0:06:03the Big Lebowski, but he's like, yeah, he does a good job.
0:06:05But anyway, we did 2013. You were on stage, and the big news of the week at that WWDC was the
0:06:13then brand new Mac Pro, which was doomed in some ways. But I think it's an interesting place to
0:06:21start because while everybody is headset, headset, headset, headset for next week, and we'll get to
0:06:27that. I mean, it's unavoidable at this point, but I think we're going to get a Mac Pro announcement
0:06:34too. I don't know if it's going to go on sale because the last time when they did the last
0:06:42Intel one, the one where they brought back the big case and the $1,000 wheels that you could put it
0:06:48on. The Siracusa special. Right. That was WWDC 2019, the last pre-pandemic WWDC. They introduced
0:06:56that and it wasn't on sale yet. It was I don't think it went on sale till like late November,
0:07:01December. They were like later this year, this is coming, but here's what it's going to look like.
0:07:05We've got one that everybody here at WWDC can come and look at, but not touch. They were like,
0:07:13don't touch it. Remember? Yeah, they had like an actual case. It was just like, no, they didn't put
0:07:19it in the glass case like the iPhone years and years ago. But they they did have a very big
0:07:25security guard there all at all times to make sure nobody touched it. Also, that was where they
0:07:30debuted the, what do they call it? The studio display XDR or just pro display XDR. Studio
0:07:38display is the consumer price thing. And yeah, it's the expensive one. So I can see love. I know
0:07:43you love yours too. Like I'm, I'm, Oh, well, I don't have the XDR. I have the studio display.
0:07:47No, that's what I mean. Yeah. Yeah. I got the, yeah. I think you've got the nanotech. What are
0:07:51they called? The nanotexture display. I have to do a year with it review because I love it so much.
0:07:58And the nanotexture is like magic in my, at certain times of the year, otherwise unusable
0:08:07desk location in my office. Like until I got this display, no, it's, I'm very serious. And I know
0:08:13which time it's April and October, right? I know it's April. Cause I just got through it. May,
0:08:20June, July, August, September, October. Yeah. Six months. So every six months, April and October,
0:08:27the sun comes through my office in the middle of the afternoon, which is my prime working hours.
0:08:32And like Raiders of the lost Ark, like, like, like Indiana Jones is down there with the headpiece to
0:08:40the staff of raw on top of the stick and the sun comes through and hits it and shows the location
0:08:47of the map room. And just that somehow just follows your cursor. That is for like two weeks
0:08:54in April and two weeks in October, that is how the sun hits my display. And prior to owning the studio
0:09:00display XDR, I would just work in the kitchen for two hours. I would just take my laptop and
0:09:06do something else. And with the nanotexture display, I literally don't even notice at times
0:09:13until it's like my neck gets hot because the sun's hitting my neck. And I'm like, holy shit,
0:09:19is that how bright the sun is? And I hold my hand up and I, it, it, that is how much the nanotexture
0:09:25lets me work. I don't even notice that the sun is hitting the screen. Anyway, that's my
0:09:30mini review of that. Here's the thing I teed you up for that. Cause we were over at your place
0:09:35around Christmas time and you showed me your office and you were, you did this basically
0:09:40not word for word, but you did this little skit about like, yeah, the sun hits it and you show
0:09:44me the window where it comes in from. Oh, the nanotexture. I, I, yeah, I love mine. I think
0:09:50it's great. Like the pro thing I think is fundamentally the pro display is a pro display.
0:09:55I think it's almost foolish to buy it for yourself. I don't know Marco and Suikis,
0:10:01but that's a different thing. Whenever they want to review it, there's reasons for it.
0:10:05But I do think that it's, there's diminishing returns for anybody beyond the studios display,
0:10:09which I find really great. The camera is even fine. I don't really have a major complaint.
0:10:14Could they make a better camera? Sure. But whatever. I don't care that much. I'm there
0:10:18for the screen. So yeah. And the speakers are great too. I mean, I know they're not great,
0:10:24great, but they're better than anything I've had on my desktop. I think since I had those,
0:10:30remember the sound sticks from yeah. Wait, were they Bose Bose sound sticks? Yeah. It's like that
0:10:36little alien looking pod for the base thing and like the transparent plastic. Yeah. So at least
0:10:41since then, which was a very long time ago, and those were actually Amy's and she took them back
0:10:45from me at some point, but it's the best sound I've had at my desktop since then too. Anyway.
0:10:50Oh, also I will just add, I'll spoil my whole review. The other big complaint people had is
0:10:55because the studio display is in fact an iOS device that occasionally gets software updates
0:11:02and requires a weird reboot cycle. And a year ago when it first came out, like every six weeks
0:11:09required like a power cycling and it had no power button. And therefore you had to like climb under
0:11:14my desk and unplug it. But I will say since then, well, what happened the second time I had to climb
0:11:23under my desk and do it, I was like three strikes in your out. So after two strikes, I bought a $40,
0:11:29those things are all like 40 bucks. I bought like a $40 home kit plug to put in the plug under my
0:11:36desk where it goes so that the next time it craps out, instead of climbing into the desk, I could
0:11:43just go to the home app and restart it with a tap on my finger. I mean, that's how easy, that's how
0:11:49much I don't like getting down on my knees under the desk. Even though it's not dirty, it's clean.
0:11:56Still a pain in the ass. Yeah. I'm too good for that. So I'll spend 40 bucks. And Murphy's Law.
0:12:01On the famously reliable home kit stuff, which is actually, I use it all the time, but like,
0:12:05I know whatever it fakes out at times. It's hilarious how often we use technology to fix
0:12:10hitting this adulation of like more and more requirements in order to just turn off the plug.
0:12:17I did that though. I did that though last summer. I spent the 40 bucks to get the plug.
0:12:21And ever since I haven't used it once. So as soon as I bought a $40 thing to restart
0:12:29the studio display, every time it crapped out, it stopped crapping out. There was at least one
0:12:35firmware update since then, which came with a system update to macOS and then macOS updates
0:12:42and says, there's an update for your studio display. Yes. Don't touch it. Let it go. But
0:12:47ever since then, it's been a hundred percent rock solid. It was like the, what happened a year ago
0:12:53was like the audio would crap out. It would like, it would stop playing audio. And the only way to
0:12:57fix it was the power cycle. It hasn't happened since. So that complaint, Hey, I wish, I wish
0:13:02my display were just a dumb display. I don't want to have to restart it every couple of weeks, blah,
0:13:07blah, blah. I don't have to do that anymore. At this point, I would say for the last like nine,
0:13:1310 months, it's effectively been indistinguishable from a dumb display that just always works.
0:13:19So, yeah, I believe that I have had no problems with it. I think I might've had to unplug it once,
0:13:25but I can't remember why that was. I don't think it was because it was just jammed up. Like the
0:13:30audio was working fine. Everything, everything seemed to be going okay with me. I sort of pushed
0:13:34back against that notion that I would just wish it was a dumb display. I mean, so the world monitor
0:13:40basically just means I'm just monitoring a video feed. I feel like in the best case, you're getting
0:13:44like a raw tap into what's happening. Displays these days are not monitored. Like there's none
0:13:49of that. And I think it's a little foolhardy to just say, Hey, just put the bits on the screen.
0:13:54Cause I think it sort of misses a lot of the work that's done. It's just for color correction and
0:14:00all kinds of other stuff. You've got a whole bunch of ports back there. Something has to run those
0:14:04ports. I think because people decided, or it is an iOS derivative, therefore it's more complicated.
0:14:12That's probably true. And it may have more surface area to break kind of thing, but ultimately
0:14:17the flexibility gives it all kinds of capabilities that were not, that you would have to get. Like
0:14:25if it was like an LG display, they're going to, they write software too. It's just janky and
0:14:29crappy. And you don't think of it like a little computer. It is a little computer though. It is
0:14:33just a worse little computer. So I don't really know what to tell you these days. Everything has
0:14:37like a little piece of software in it, which is kind of the current theme that you as you,
0:14:40you'd come to that all the time. I just think, you know, and I think that the team behind it has done
0:14:45what you want them to do is sort of look, it's such a smaller surface area of what it does. Then
0:14:53when iOS is running on an actual iPhone or iPad, or even an Apple TV, the user could be doing
0:14:59anything. Whereas the sort of iOS as firmware running on something like the studio display,
0:15:07it only has to do two things or three things, right? It shows pixels on the display and does
0:15:14color. I'm not saying new scenes are easy, but you know, displays pixels, manages brightness,
0:15:20does color correction, plays sound through the speakers. And it runs the camera when the camera's
0:15:26on, or I guess the microphone, right? Microphone, camera, display, sound, power management,
0:15:32but those, it's a known surface area and it should be very stable. And I would say from about two
0:15:39months after it started shipping, it's been rock solid stable, which is exactly what you want. So
0:15:44hats off to the studio display team, a fantastic product that I'm happy to endorse. Anyway,
0:15:52Mac Pro. Yeah, but this ties into the mic. It cut. Yeah. Well, I remember sitting on the stage
0:15:58and being really excited about it and I still am. I still think that I'm a bit of a weirdo though.
0:16:03I like the Mac cube. I like the Mac. I did too. I didn't own one, but it was only cause I couldn't
0:16:08afford it at the time. I love the Mac. Yeah. The original MacBook Air was like really kind of a
0:16:14crazy expensive, but you could spend even more money and get the SSD in it, which at the time
0:16:18was like mind boggling. I found the Mac Pro 2013 to be one of those cool products that had like
0:16:25a real vision about how things are going to work and what they're going to double down on. They've
0:16:30got one board full of like pretty high end Intel chips at the time, two boards full of like pretty
0:16:35high end AMD chips, sorry, ATI chips. And it was cool. And it had a fan in the middle. I love
0:16:42turning it around and having the lights light up on the back. It just like the, the plugs, the
0:16:48sockets glow, which is cool, dumb, but a fun little neat trick. I like the way you can slide
0:16:54off the top of the case. I like the concept of the computer. I like the vision that they had
0:17:00for how it would scale and go forward. And then it didn't, and it didn't for any number of reasons,
0:17:07like the Intel chips were hot, getting the new GPUs was hot, like fitting more and more next level or
0:17:13next generation stuff into that casing proved to be like famously the thermal corner. I admire them
0:17:20for trying that computer. I think that was very cool. I think that was the one that Schiller said,
0:17:24you can't innovate anymore my ass. I think it was. Yeah. Yeah. I I'm, I'm with him. I think that's,
0:17:30that's bang on great work. I think the 2019 Mac pro is amazing and incredible, but hardly is
0:17:40innovative in terms of like, let's try a drastically new kind of take on things.
0:17:45Right. I think that there's sort of a very, at least from 2013 onward, but probably going back
0:17:54to like 2008, which I think was when the proceeding Mac pro had shipped the one that
0:18:01Syria, the one that the one that Syracuse, so you wound up using for like 40 years. Right. Yeah.
0:18:06Which was also a big case, right? A big sort of traditional case prior to that, prior to 2008,
0:18:16the compute the importance of the Mac to Apple and the overall Mac market was such that it was still
0:18:25the, the tailwinds of like the eighties and nineties where pro computers were like half
0:18:37of Apple sales, right? Just the whole era before laptops taking over the industry where desktops
0:18:43were actually laptops were the niche that were more expensive and people only spent,
0:18:49you'd spend a couple extra thousand dollars to get a laptop with comparable specs to the same,
0:18:55what you could get for the desktop with the same specs. And so the desktop was the main computers,
0:19:02every company sold, including Apple. And some of them were pro and some of them weren't.
0:19:06And then everything started shifting to laptops for all the obvious reasons,
0:19:11just once the performance. Yeah. More convenient and the performance was there and the price came
0:19:17down to the same consumer level prices. I mean, for now, one more applications were on the web now,
0:19:24right? So you didn't need quite as much local power to do your outlook. You start like your
0:19:29calendars, your Gmail, like that kind of stuff. I mean, honestly, it's like, and putting aside
0:19:34all the thermal advantages and performance at price or performance per watt advantages of Apple
0:19:39Silicon, even on the PC side with Intel, I mean, it's been decades now where it's no big deal to
0:19:46put a fine or even very nice PC into a laptop. Whereas in the 90s, that was incredibly expensive.
0:19:56You remember all those ads for the bunny suits and the Pentium with a snail, like a snail with
0:20:03a Pentium on the back when Apple was really shit talking Intel all the time. I did. They can't
0:20:10enchant, shouldn't do it now, but like I kind of missed the shit talking version of Apple,
0:20:14which was pretty funny with the power PC stuff, despite kind of getting creamed in a lot of ways.
0:20:19Like the G5 was pretty cool, could not fit in a laptop, which just wasn't going to happen.
0:20:24Right. Never. We are right. And that was really what prompted the switch when Jobs announced the
0:20:29switch to Intel. It was basically, look, I told you two years ago, we were going to put the G5 in
0:20:34a laptop and we couldn't do it. And therefore we're switching. Here's why. But I think that
0:20:39the mismatch that's happened post 2008, starting with the trashcan in 2013, is that there's a
0:20:47sizable segment of pro Mac users who just want the most performance they can get for whatever
0:20:54the reason of what they're doing, whether they're aerospace engineers doing complex models of
0:20:59wing designs for new airplanes or developers with really complex, mind-bendingly complex
0:21:08Xcode projects with just massive, massive dependencies and very long, if you do like
0:21:14a totally clean build, really long build cycle. There's precious few of those. I mean, there's
0:21:19Apple's pro stuff. There's Photoshop, I suppose, but there's big apps out there, but there's not
0:21:27that many people who really need to crunch that much stuff. The Swift compiler, people love the
0:21:32Swift language. The Swift compiler though is relatively slow compared to most other compilers.
0:21:37And it's just a trade off that you get a language that developers like more or even love and has
0:21:46these things. And it just making the language nicer for developers almost always makes it
0:21:52harder for the compiler. I think that's one of the classic computer trade-offs, like memory and speed,
0:21:59you pick one kind of thing. And C compilers are faster because C, I love how I'm telling you this,
0:22:06but C is very low to the machine. There's optimizations that will take a long time.
0:22:15I didn't look into it, but I think I saw it. I forget it. I'm calling it a tweet because
0:22:21I think it's on Mastodon, but forget it. Everything's a tweet these days. I can't be bothered
0:22:24to keep track of the tweets. Yeah, I call them tweets. I like calling them tweets.
0:22:27Yeah, I know. I liked your comment on that too. It's whatever. It's a form, not an item at this
0:22:33point. Anyway, it was like a C compiler written in some incredibly small number of bytes. It just
0:22:39didn't do any error correction. It was like, I don't know. If it doesn't do any error correction
0:22:46and just the symbols that you put, it'll turn that into code, you can write it tidy, really,
0:22:53really tiny. It's trying to figure out where you've gone wrong, which is the bulk of an actual C.
0:22:59I saw the same thing. I just made a note. I will put it in the show notes. Some
0:23:03freak of nature genius packed an entire C compiler into 512 bytes because he wanted it to load.
0:23:14There's some kind of boot loading area on an Intel PC that is limited to 512 bytes.
0:23:20So he stuffed a C compiler in there. And his follow-up message was like,
0:23:25"Well, because you're a C compiler, we just trust that you won't screw it up," which is
0:23:29hilariously... C's always going to screw up. That's kind of it, basically. You're juggling with
0:23:35flaming knives at that point. His explanation of it is 10 times longer than the actual C
0:23:43compiler. But it's a wonderful explanation if you're a nerd. We won't digress here,
0:23:48but I'll put it in the show notes, I swear. It's wonderful.
0:23:51Anyway, where I'm going though is that there's a number of Pro Mac users who just wish that Apple
0:23:58would have done the 2019 Mac Pro all along. Just keep it in a big box where Apple doesn't have to
0:24:06worry about the thermals. Just sell a big box that opens up and puts Intel stuff inside and
0:24:13runs... hopefully runs as quiet as possible and give it a lot of ports on the back and just give
0:24:18me the performance. And wish that they had done that all along. And in the meantime though,
0:24:24we'd go through these year-long gaps without any update on the Mac Pro. And people who care about
0:24:30the Mac Pro would worry that Apple wasn't interested in the Mac Pro at all anymore.
0:24:37What do you got in it's the danger of being on this one weird platform or platforms at this point
0:24:44from Apple where if you're in the Apple ecosystem and Apple isn't interested in making hardware X,
0:24:51you don't have an option to buy it, right? So like if you like the mini iPhone form factor,
0:24:57now that they've apparently stopped making it a year ago with the iPhone 13 mini,
0:25:02you're out of luck. Right? I mean, now the upside is...
0:25:04Al Moltis is a huge fan of the mini form factor.
0:25:07Yeah. The only reason it doesn't hurt so much with the iPhone mini is that there really isn't
0:25:12such a thing in the Android world either. But like with PCs, you can get any weird form factor
0:25:19you want, right? So if you still like 17 inch or 18 inch lunch tray size laptops, you can get them
0:25:25in the PC world. You can get really gigantic... The gaming ones are often really tricked out.
0:25:32Right.
0:25:32And like if... Yeah. You can't get that in the Apple world.
0:25:35Yeah. You can get weird hardware.
0:25:37Right. I think that leads to people accusing Apple of being monopoly, but that's not
0:25:42how monopolies work. They're a monopoly on Mac OS, but it's a monopoly? I don't know. It's not
0:25:48really. It just... It is a unit. And if they're not making something for you and you have different
0:25:55requirements, then it's a big ass to switch ecosystems, all right? Which is, I think, an
0:26:02oblique way of getting at what this new Mac Pro may be. One of the issues is a lot of these very,
0:26:09very custom workflows are tuned for Intel and not necessarily tuned for Apple, Silicon. And now you're
0:26:15coming out with a new Mac Pro. Let's give it fantasy specs of like it's... It probably won't
0:26:21be able to... Let's say double an M1 Studio. So an M1 Ultra, I believe, which I have. And it is
0:26:30fast as hell. I don't need a Mac Pro. For many, many years, I would buy Mac Pros.
0:26:36Mac Studio is pro enough for me. And I think I would effectively be... It's similar to the
0:26:44studio display that we were talking about, where to go up to the XDR, I feel, would be extra money
0:26:50that I don't need to spend in order for my actual use case. And I think the studio does that. So
0:26:55where does that leave the next Mac Pro? A whole bunch of Apple Silicon thrown at a problem,
0:27:00but software not yet tuned for it and may not be tuned to it for a while.
0:27:05>> Well, I just keep going back to that 2013 one from 10 years ago. And I feel like it's
0:27:12almost like what the people who love the Mac Pro were thinking is, I'm so worried that Apple
0:27:17doesn't care about it anymore. And in fact, I think it's the opposite. It's that Apple cared
0:27:22so much. And at very high levels in Mac engineering and product marketing like Phil Schiller,
0:27:32they really do value the sort of race car version of workstation computing. And they cared so much
0:27:41that they engineered this incredibly, in a way, beautiful Mac Pro, this cylinder with the highest
0:27:52finish, super shiny. I mean, it looks like something from, again, like a Star Wars movie
0:27:57or something. It's a dark, shiny thing and engineered an incredibly innovative thermal
0:28:04system to do the exhaust through the middle. They spent an incredible... I mean, it's not just like,
0:28:09oh, it's going to be small. And Johnny Ive or somebody else on his team did a sketch of a
0:28:15cylinder and handed it off. I mean, it was a monumental amount of design and engineering work
0:28:21to make that work. And it just was a bad bet on, a really bad bet on where PC computing was going
0:28:29for the rest of that decade, which was all towards big-ass GPUs that, A, physically wouldn't
0:28:37fit inside there and B, even if they somehow could be reduced in size to fit, wouldn't have the
0:28:44thermal headroom to run as hot as they do. But it's almost... I just think the people who were
0:28:53worried would have been happier if Apple cared less and it just phoned it in with the big box
0:28:58all along. Yeah. I think there's just two points to that. A, I think the suppliers that Apple was
0:29:04dealing with at the time, Intel and ATI, they did not share the incentives that Apple did. Apple
0:29:09wanted to make quiet, very, very fast computers, both laptops and in this case on the desktop.
0:29:15Whereas both Intel and ATI at the time, or very soon after, were incentivized to make the biggest,
0:29:23most power hungry chips they can because they were getting pushed up market, specifically with
0:29:29the some of the ATI and the AI and sort of crypto mining stuff that all the GPUs got sucked up in.
0:29:37The parameters under which they were expected to operate changed. Their markets were chasing
0:29:44the high-end power is no consequence kind of thing, whereas Apple really wanted what they
0:29:50ended up making for themselves in terms of Apple's silicon. And I guess the second thing with that is
0:29:55while I really admire them for making the trashcan or a different form factor, experimenting with
0:30:00stuff, is it like, did they make an El Camino? Were they like, this is a pickup truck, but it
0:30:06looks cool. Like, well, this is a pickup truck, looks like a pickup truck for a reason. And I
0:30:11don't mean the crazy over the top modern ones that are basically like, there's a limo in front and
0:30:16like, none of that, that's an obscene exaggeration of a pickup truck, but like a good old Ford pickup
0:30:23truck that you'd see banging around a farm kind of thing like that. It works. It's a flatbed,
0:30:27it's got wheels and it will last forever. Don't mess with it. All right. Don't mess with it.
0:30:33All right. Let's take a break and we'll pick it up. Let me take a break here and take our first
0:30:37sponsor though. It's our good friends at Rocket Money. Rocket Money is a personal finance app that
0:30:44finds and cancels your unwanted subscriptions, monitors your spending and helps you lower your
0:30:50bills all in one place. Do you know how much you actually spend on subscriptions every month? Most
0:30:56Americans, Rocket Money did a poll. Most Americans think they spend around 80 bucks a month on
0:31:02subscriptions, but when you tally it up, it's actually, the average is closer to $200. So,
0:31:08most people's guess as to how much they spend on subscriptions every month is off by more than a
0:31:14factor of two. And if you don't know exactly how much you're spending every month, you need Rocket
0:31:19Money. It's so easy. You sign up for Rocket Money. They analyze your finances and they report to you
0:31:26exactly every single subscription that's coming in on your credit cards and let you go through them.
0:31:33And it's a great way to either A, cancel the ones where you're like, I don't really use that
0:31:39anymore. I'm subscribed to this streaming service. Maybe you signed up for a streaming service to get
0:31:43like one specific show and you never canceled, something like that. Or subscriptions that you
0:31:49had completely forgot about and are just continuing to recur every month without you even thinking
0:31:54about it. And you're like, ah, I haven't used that in months. Cancel. Rocket Money is absolutely great
0:32:00at that. And they even let you cancel subscriptions right within Rocket Money itself. You can just let
0:32:08Rocket Money cancels subscription for you right there in the list. Save time. Just get it done.
0:32:14You don't have to like make a to do to remind yourself to cancel this, cancel that. Do it right
0:32:19in Rocket Money. Save some money. It's one of those things. You sign up for Rocket Money
0:32:24and you actually save money by paying for Rocket Money because you cancel so much stuff that you
0:32:31weren't using, didn't remember, that sort of thing. Rocket Money also helps you manage all
0:32:36of your finances in one place and automatically categorizes your expenses so you can easily track
0:32:41your entire budget in real time and also get alerted if anything looks off. Over 3 million
0:32:48people have used Rocket Money and they have saved the average user of the app up to $720 a year.
0:32:54720 bucks a year. 3 million people. Stop throwing your money away. Cancel your unwanted subscriptions
0:33:00and manage your expenses the easy way by going to RocketMoney.com/TheTalkShow. That's RocketMoney.com/TheTalkShow.
0:33:11RocketMoney.com/TheTalkShow. So that's what I here's here's where I'm going with all this. I think
0:33:20I think that I think we are going to see the Mac Pro at WWDC and I think they're going to go back
0:33:28to ambitious and ambitious design. I think so. I do not think I do not think it's going to look
0:33:36like the 2019 one and you open it up and there's a tiny tiny little... It would be pretty funny.
0:33:45Have you ever seen like by the tail end of VCRs or CD players like you'd open them up and they're
0:33:51mostly just that shape to fit in the cabinet that's designed for otherwise it's just empty
0:33:56space. What about the one alien in one of the Men in Black movies there was an alien
0:34:02and I think it was like his it was like a eight foot tall alien and his chest opened up and in
0:34:08fact there was a little a little guy the size like a like a frog and he's the outer guy was just a
0:34:16robot and a real alien was just a little like a little babu frik like the there yeah that's a
0:34:20Skywalker reference yeah the only good part of that movie yeah the only good scene in the whole
0:34:24movie babu frik a little guy like that there's some argument to be like the the new case was
0:34:29received incredibly well like people like that's awesome and I think maybe if you roll out another
0:34:35the I don't know you come out with a pyramid people gonna be like would you stop doing
0:34:38stop it just give us what we want but I don't know I do think that there may be I think there's gonna
0:34:46almost have to be something like it can't just be a bigger better max studio like what's the
0:34:51what's the point really why didn't you just make a little bit of a bigger max studio and do that
0:34:55so that brings us to expansion and and graphics cards and all of that jazz and sort of a lot of
0:35:02the a lot of the weight in that industry is on nvidia who have been having some recent issues
0:35:10but it seems more of a short-term thing and I'll leave that to you and Ben to figure out I'm a
0:35:15little bit behind on dithering but could apple work with nv yeah probably would they I don't know
0:35:21both those companies seem so headstrong then they they get a real sense they don't like each other
0:35:25the other aspect that I was kind of touching on was a lot of this lower level stuff is sort of
0:35:32very very tuned for intel things and I was joking previously about this I honestly don't think this
0:35:38is going to be the case but do you remember those 46 boards that you could plug into like max yeah
0:35:44way back in the 90s I do I would I would laugh I would laugh my ass off so there was like like a
0:35:50like a little tiny awesome apple silicon thing and then just a slot was like well we just stuck a pc
0:35:56in there because because we can for those like as an add-on you know what I mean like yeah if you
0:36:01want if you want the add-on whatever we'll give you a whole bunch of like intel chips stuck on a
0:36:06board they have the capability to do that right like mac os runs on intel they they can make their
0:36:12daughter board talk to the thing I think it's crazy I do not think this is going to happen
0:36:17I'm just spitballing weird and crazy things that you could do with a massive enclosure like that
0:36:22but and ultimately you do need to address the expandability mark somehow for that for those for
0:36:27that for those who don't remember I don't remember it was sometime in the 90s but at some point in the
0:36:3190s apple sold you could buy I think it might have been before the power pc maybe that's you know
0:36:39it could have been with the motorola x68 6000 yeah 68 000 series but you could buy a very expensive
0:36:48I forget the name of those slots new bus was a new yeah new bus might have been new bus yeah
0:36:55it might have been new bus I'll try to look it up for the show notes here but there would be a very
0:36:59expensive card that was effectively just a whole it's just a whole intel pc you put it in a card
0:37:07and then you'd launch like an app you'd be in mac os or system 7 or whatever it was at the time and
0:37:14launch an app that would run a pc but instead of emulating it was running it on the the pc of the
0:37:22card so it wasn't you didn't I don't think if I if I'm recalling I didn't own one because I had no
0:37:27need for it and it was very expensive but it wasn't a dual boot type thing it wasn't like shut
0:37:33down the mac and hold down the the p and the c keys on the keyboard and reboot into the pc no it would
0:37:38run as an app but those apps weren't being emulated they were running on a pc on a card
0:37:43it was crazy uh yeah if anything it was a little bit like classic where some I mean yeah it was all
0:37:50on the same thing but like you remember how classic was these janky cutout windows that like
0:37:54he dragged another window across it he would do the no redraw thing from windows back in the day
0:37:58yeah yeah you could see it repaint yeah I don't think they're gonna do that and I for whether
0:38:06apple is going to be able to pull this off or not I mean effectively I know nvidia has competition
0:38:12AMD has graphic cards that are that are well regarded but there's no dispute that nvidias
0:38:19are the best or the fastest if what you really need is the highest performance GPU and lots of
0:38:25people who are not video game enthusiasts are doing work that requires the fastest possible
0:38:30GPU they can get and there's also specifically kuda which is their programming model right for
0:38:37that which is sort of a sort of similar to metal shaders there were metal compute shaders
0:38:41specifically apple sort of invented and abandoned open cl which was a another take on the same kind
0:38:48of like general purpose program or general programming on a gpu style device kind of thing
0:38:54but kuda is the one that's captured everybody's imagination like that's that is the go-to
0:38:58programming model for high-end gpu stuff now so yeah not only do they need the speed but I feel
0:39:05like a little bit like intel if intel slipped a generation and they weren't the fastest chip you
0:39:12were still running the intel instruction set right but that's slowly going like that advantages but
0:39:18you know for years if they had a bad one yeah it's not the end of the world because ultimately AMD
0:39:24is still running our instruction set and so and we are holding that those remains right so like
0:39:30I think what you're saying here is so let's just say next week at the keynote John Turnus is up on
0:39:36stage and he's introducing a new Mac Pro and lo and behold apple can flat out say this whatever
0:39:46it is it's it's not a m1 ultra say m1 is too old at this point m2 whatever the name is and for the
0:39:53Mac Pro and Mac Pro only apple has their own apple silicon graphics that outperform nvidia's
0:40:02top of the line whatever so cycle for cycle outperforms nvidia at the high end yeah that's
0:40:11still they could do it given the same power budget right but that yeah but that may not be enough
0:40:16for the industry because the industry's locked into CUDA or not locked in but CUDA has so much
0:40:23momentum and those type of things if you've got this whole the thousands and thousands of
0:40:29programmer person hours into CUDA and experience in CUDA and so you've got a code base and experience
0:40:37and it's you know that you can just buy intel pcs and nvidia graphics cards going forward that
0:40:45train is has left the station and it's it's not enough for apple to say if you use our APIs
0:40:52instead of CUDA you'll get better performance they're like it it may not be enough i i i think
0:40:58that's right yeah also it's it's like the win 32 API which lasted forever there was a massive
0:41:04lock-in in windows even after into the 2000s where the mac took off right there's still a bunch of
0:41:10stuff like and the stuff that is very window centric is often this high-end performance stuff
0:41:16like like architectural software like cad software there's very like industry niche specific things
0:41:21that are tied to windows not because they couldn't run on the mac but because like well bring that
0:41:26over it's a huge pain in the ass and we're not going to get the market we can get and a lot of
0:41:30these people buy computers to run that software rather than the other way the other thing with
0:41:36CUDA is that yes people are accustomed to the API and all that but like one of the issues not
0:41:41not after the iphone prior to it was getting developers who knew objective c was a huge pain
0:41:47in the ass which limited the talent pool that you could bring in for microsoft needed to train up a
0:41:52bunch of people adobe needed to train up people apple internally needs to train up a bunch of
0:41:56people and no big not advanced had a lot of hand in right and a lot of that and like getting people
0:42:00up to standard or or knowing how to do stuff with objective c was a huge lift until maybe the iphone
0:42:06made it so that everybody wanted objective c swift came easier i think because it was a little bit
0:42:12more uh familiar but also everybody wanted to be on the iphone anyway so whatever everybody
0:42:18learned swift because they had to CUDA is where it's at some CUDA like apple only thing less so
0:42:25and if you want to hire somebody you're like okay well you know all that the basics you know how
0:42:30CUDA works it works mostly the same but it's not quite the same and having experience with like
0:42:36the particulars of the device matters in these cases because like an nvidia device well first
0:42:42of all the big thing is that the memory bandwidth like in nvidia devices they've got their ram right
0:42:46next to the right next to their gpu and on apple devices it's all shared with the cpu so the costs
0:42:53of sending something to the card on a nvidia device are greater and an apple device they're
0:42:58smaller which means you may tweak your algorithms in completely different ways for the nvidia you
0:43:03may be like i'm going to give you everything and you figure it out and get back to me and for an
0:43:07apple one you may want like a more iterative operating in place kind of algorithm which are
0:43:11totally different approaches regardless of whatever CUDA or metal shader like it's difficult
0:43:18and different and in order to make your incredible new mac pro a success
0:43:24you kind of want people to be able to do the same thing they're always doing in order to leverage it
0:43:29but you're going to need them to do something slightly different and i fear that that's exactly
0:43:34what happened in 2013 is that in order to take the best advantage of the 2013 mac pro you needed
0:43:40to program these crazy dual gpu ati boards and you sort of needed to change your programming model up
0:43:46a bit and i think that's kind of where it's stalled out beyond the the hardware failures of like heat
0:43:53and like stuff like it just presupposed that everything worked perfectly i still think you've
0:43:58got a bit of an uphill battle in terms of convincing people that this model of computer
0:44:02this model of computing is the way to go so i've yeah that it just makes me excited to see the
0:44:11announcement and i know i again we'll get to the headset but if the wwdc keynote comes and goes
0:44:17without mention of the mac pro i'm going to find it baffling i really am because i i i i know that
0:44:25it was over a year ago at this point it was like at the end of march or april last year when they
0:44:29did the little mid-cycle special i think it was all yeah it was all remote it was broadcast but
0:44:36when they announced the mac studio and the studio display and turnis said at the end of the whole
0:44:40thing we're not quite complete with our move to apple silicon we've got one more yet to come that's
0:44:46the mac pro but that's a story for another day or something like that yeah i forget exactly how he
0:44:51said it it was very carefully it wasn't dashed off right number one it's not live yeah well also
0:44:59they don't do that even live i don't think maybe they dashed off i've been like they're very very
0:45:04good at community i i know for a fact i i cannot i cannot name my source but let's say a person very
0:45:12close to the matter i can confirm that can't any innovate anymore my ass was an ad lib oh really
0:45:20oh yeah that's awesome oh i love that that's great it was not in the rehearsals or it might
0:45:26but also one of the very few people who could get away with that right yeah who could who could take
0:45:32the call from tim cook after the keynote and hey was that in the script and you know justify it so
0:45:39it did happen on stage occasionally where there'd be an ad lib but that was very careful and i re
0:45:46i also do not think that like apple like turnis thought in april last year that the mac pro was
0:45:56just around the corner i think they knew the road map and obviously something has changed since
0:46:022020 when they first announced the shift to apple silicon and said we expect we're going to start
0:46:08later this year and we expect to get the whole platform on apple silicon in one year obviously
0:46:15the mac pro has blown past that one year but so something changed at that point but i think last
0:46:22year when they introduced the mac studio they knew what was coming and i don't know what it is but i
0:46:27it's got to be something to me there's that is as as dramatically better than the mac studio as the
0:46:36mac studio is from the mac mini maybe even more so yeah and i don't know what that means but me neither
0:46:42i i think maybe to figure out or to have a better guess of what that would be would be to understand
0:46:47the markets that they're trying to serve like i don't know are you going to give these to pixar
0:46:51or are you going to give them to like who who are you building these things for is it genentech are
0:46:56you doing like crazy gene research or all of them we built a thing that will like figure out covid
0:47:02in like over an afternoon while you're drinking a cup of tea right like what is it and then you can
0:47:07maybe guess but would you i guess my question for you is if wwdc comes and goes and there's no mention
0:47:14of the mac pro and like a week later they they get you on the phone i'm like hey john we got bad news
0:47:21we're just not doing one we're happy with the mac studio obviously they're going to spin it we're
0:47:25very happy with that it showed up better than we expected yeah it's like it's like you work for
0:47:30apple pr that's exactly what they would say it's worked out better than we expected and yeah that
0:47:37would that would presuppose that they are going to announce the next generation mac studio though
0:47:43right sure and they just say here's the m2 level max studio better yeah i could see that i guess
0:47:49we had a plan it turns out our plan did not survive contact with the enemy in that we
0:47:54defeated the enemy and now we're all yeah all one big happy family and like the mac pro is awesome
0:47:59so the mac studio is awesome so why not i i guess i i i i guess that's i guess that's the second most
0:48:06likely scenario i think the most likely scenario is a incredibly innovative architecture not even
0:48:14talking and and again i think apple's long-term internal affinity it doesn't i i everybody's
0:48:24fear that apple doesn't care about the mac pros because obviously it's the least selling mac made
0:48:29by quantity because it only it's super expensive and the only way yeah i know it's not the only
0:48:35factor in how it works i know i'm preaching to the choir here right but people worry you know and i
0:48:40think a quote-unquote typical company would think that way and think there's why in the world are
0:48:44we spending any resources at all on this thing for 10 000 or i don't know how many people buy mac
0:48:50pros maybe it's more than tens of thousands but it certainly isn't millions right it's it's
0:48:56about it's somewhere in the thousands why are we spending all this time on this when we sell a
0:49:00billion iphones a year let's just there's no comparison all we care about is iphone iphone
0:49:04iphone that's not how apple thinks internally and they have a keen interest in it from an industrial
0:49:10design perspective that the trash can for all of its all the things we did complain about it
0:49:15already on this show it was a marvel of design and and shows how much they care even the 2019
0:49:22one where they're like okay okay we'll just put an intel thing in a big box but they they'd spent
0:49:26five minutes in the keynote talking about how they drilled the holes you know in a
0:49:31in a special pattern yeah yeah they they they spent five minutes on that and they really wanted
0:49:39to talk about it they spent they they engineered thousand dollar wheels but i mean yeah they do
0:49:46care but the other thing but the other thing is people think that that's apple be just wanting
0:49:50money which right sure but at the other point it's like well they they did things that they really
0:49:58wanted for themselves just to make it a work of art and they did it against a consumer body that
0:50:04is willing to pay the price like this hinge costs a thousand bucks is that dumb to delay people sure
0:50:11is that a drop in the i mean let's not get into the right of strike and how much money the studios
0:50:16have but they can afford a few stands right like so just drop in the bucket for that but i i think
0:50:22that the other thing that you it's easily overlooked is is how ambitious the whole johnny
0:50:30suruji division is on put the industrial design aside just the system architecture side for the
0:50:38m series chips there it's incredibly ambitious what they've been doing with apple silicon and it
0:50:45explains because before apple silicon at some point between the years like 2015 2016 and 2020
0:50:53when they finally announced it it was clear from just pure benchmarks that iphones were outperforming
0:51:00like on single core benchmarks outperforming macbooks backbook pros it it yeah they could
0:51:08have built max using a series chips i mean in fact they did with the developer kit thing the developer
0:51:15kit that they gave out in 2020 was based on an a series chip and it was a good computer and it had
0:51:20the same nice performance per watt advantages overall they could have just sold that they could
0:51:26have just called it a day be like you know what iphone chip and a thing here you go but they spent
0:51:30a fortune of money of time engineering talent to build this entire m series architecture which
0:51:38makes no sense for phones right you'd never put these chips into phones because of the the size
0:51:45and power characteristics a series chips are exactly what you want in a phone and these m series
0:51:51chips are what you want in pc class desktop computers and laptops and really incredibly
0:51:59innovative the you mentioned the shared memory before and it's so yeah it's such an inversion
0:52:05of the way things were before where intel had been selling integrated graphics on their lower end
0:52:12consumer pcs for years that yeah that shared memory memory and and that was like a downside
0:52:19it was like oh it's you know it's a thousand dollar laptop with shared memory and with apple
0:52:24it's the opposite where it's this tremendous performance advantage because the graphics
0:52:29are designed with the cpu in mind to work together that they can share memory and when
0:52:35something in memory goes from the cpu to gpu it's already there and you save this whole copy yeah
0:52:43over a bus like people go bananas over bus speeds but guess what right how about no bus
0:52:47speed yeah no infinite right literally infinite bus speed which is and when you're doing things
0:52:53at the speed of modern computers a million times a second or some
0:52:57incomprehensible to to human mind speed those copies matter who knows what else they might
0:53:05have up their sleeve in terms of an architectural pushing the entire state of the art forward
0:53:12that would only be in the mac pro and i've drawn this analogy on on the show before but i think
0:53:17it's a really good one is it's in very broad strokes it's why consumer
0:53:24car companies have formula one racing divisions yeah and and make race cars
0:53:31i was about to just exactly back that up which is the the purpose of the mac pro is not necessarily
0:53:38to sell units but it's to encourage people in the lab to figure out interconnects between okay now
0:53:44we've got two m1 ultras or two m2 ultras what happens to be how do we in it how do we build
0:53:49that interconnect how do we how do we make that work as fast as possible how do we deal with
0:53:54the memory contention which was a big issue i mean whatever going back in history in in the 90s like
0:53:59a lot of sun and and and similar workstations had different ways of addressing memory and working
0:54:06the details out on all that behooves the platforms lower down right like as eventually whatever you
0:54:12put in your mac pro 2023 that tech will find its way into product x whatever product x happens to
0:54:20be like no idea what it's going to be but any research that you've done in order to use the
0:54:25high end effect i don't know if it's a loss leader probably a loss leader but it's going to filter
0:54:30down right and by stretching yourself to do these obscene and crazy things you will ultimately learn
0:54:36a whole bunch that can be applied elsewhere not necessarily taking the parts but taking what you've
0:54:40learned and using that elsewhere right is invaluable if if you're single-mindedly focused on the phone
0:54:45you really wouldn't need any more graphic capability than to push a 6.7 inch display at retina
0:54:54level right and i know there's rumors that the next year's phones might be a quarter of an inch
0:54:58bigger or something like that but the basic size of a phone is relatively small you know how many
0:55:02pixels there are but if you're also have this division that's spent years trying to push the
0:55:09state of the art forward for giant 5k 6k get it up to 8k displays all of a sudden you've got this
0:55:17architecture and muscle and experience where maybe you could build something like a headset with two
0:55:248k displays in front of each eye and have it run cool on a thing that's in front of your face that
0:55:31that tech would make no sense on a phone or even an ipad really in terms of how many pixels it's
0:55:37pushing but all of a sudden here's a new product category where us having us apple having built
0:55:44these race car workstations for the mac it all of a sudden it's relevant to what ultimately is
0:55:52intended to be a mass market consumer product yeah i think there's a lot of computing or computer
0:55:57companies i don't even know if they exist i had that dell hp is gone compact there's a there was
0:56:05that that run in the 90s of sort of built to order things that did well and made a lot of money on
0:56:10basically having the the supply chain all work out like just in time manufacturing all of that apple
0:56:18doesn't wait for technology to become available from its partners apple makes the technology by
0:56:23itself and while ati and am and nvidia are stretching to try to fill gpu cordos for
0:56:32for crypto or ai or whatever the high-end massively parallel programming model du jour is or
0:56:38premise du jour is apple is left alone in some ways to like it has to be the one inventing new
0:56:47ways to use this stuff and have us to be the one pushing itself certainly games aren't doing it for
0:56:52them so they need to be the one reaching just that extra little bit further and i i admire them for
0:57:00doing it in all kinds of ways both in the thermal corners that they trap themselves in and maybe in
0:57:05a giant ass computer that's going to really confuse us or if they're just like you know what
0:57:09we got a lot of really fast compute but we can't make a product out of it so forget it and the i
0:57:15think it's directly related even though it's not a workstation class machine but the other
0:57:21overly ambitious mac design that got ahead of what the internals
0:57:29could support was the no adjective 12-inch macbook yeah right we have that one too if there's a dumb
0:57:38apple computer i bought it i don't know what i don't know what to tell you the 12-inch macbook
0:57:43makes even even today's and i still i i'm a little surprised i really thought that that bringing so i
0:57:50didn't know what name they would call it but bringing something back that is insanely thin
0:57:55was something i thought apple would do because it was clearly something they were interested in a
0:57:59decade ago but it really did and when you look at one side by side especially when you hold it
0:58:05it's like pictures on the web don't do didn't do justice to how much thinner it was than the
0:58:10macbook airs of the time it it was just so thin and light compared to anything else apple had
0:58:16ever made and the performance just stunk because that was the best that it was like what was it
0:58:22adam atom the intel atom architecture uh kind of third-rate intel thing like intentionally sort of
0:58:30spec to run in a very tight well and yeah no fans at all yeah that was very cool and i know people
0:58:36who loved it i really do especially people who for obvious reasons the type of people who have
0:58:42jobs where either they're traveling all the time or yeah even when they're quote-unquote at work
0:58:49they don't really have a desk where they spend all day they're moving around all day and they
0:58:54need to take their computer with them well obviously making it as thin and light as possible
0:58:57it means you're schlepping the least amount around yeah i really love mine i know uh our
0:59:02friend rob ryan swore by it like he would take all his meetings and just but it like it yeah
0:59:07it just shows that both at at two extremes the 2013 mac pro and the 12-inch mac macbook showed
0:59:16or proved that apple needed to take the silicon story into its own hands because left to the
0:59:24industry state of the art they they weren't getting chips that enabled them to build the
0:59:30the computers that they imagined they needed to do it and i feel like that that's where they are
0:59:35forever and i don't think nvidia nvidia is just the new intel for in terms of being
0:59:44pc-oriented the best performance but they're building things that are not commensurate with
0:59:54apple's imagination for the performance per watt characteristics of how a high-end graphics card
1:00:00should work so apple needs to do it themselves and the other thing about the trash can that i think
1:00:05makes me optimistic is that it's clear from the trash can forward that apple knew how important
1:00:12gpu's were to the future of computing and so they've which i so one of the man i think this
1:00:21is one of the first arguments i had with syracuse back in 97 something like that not a real argument
1:00:26but with os 10 or maybe yeah probably you would agree with Syracuse on this because you guys are
1:00:31both older mac people than i am but it with os 10 everything was buffered and the windows were slow
1:00:37incredibly slow to to be drawn my position was like yeah sure but they're using the gpu to
1:00:43composite all of this and the future will be better i have since getting to know you better
1:00:48and i would just my product my appreciation for products has sort of changed over the years and
1:00:54i do think that like i think it was the right thing to do and i think it stank at the time and
1:00:59i think it made a lot of sense for people to remain on mac os for the year or two that it
1:01:03took to sort of get a little bit better on the other hand the entire industry now runs like that
1:01:08everybody has like a compositing thing you all draw into a back buffer it all gets composited
1:01:12that that's how it works that it linux does it windows has done it for years and that's sort of
1:01:17when they took gpu started to take gpu more seriously i think the 2013 was a big bet on
1:01:25taking gps more seriously as general compute and that's why they introduced opencl effectively
1:01:31alongside it which was sort of their version of kuda except if kuda was direct x to to stick to
1:01:37the microsoft technology kuda was direct 3d direct x the windows microsoft only api then kuda was sort
1:01:44of equivalent on the compute side they wanted an open gl thing which was open cl to sort of like
1:01:52open that up and have a collective thing hey let's all just do open cl rather than getting sucked up
1:01:57and kuda both open gl and open cl failed for any number of reasons mostly having to do with the way
1:02:02committees work and a whole bunch of frankly and apple i'm sure plays great on committees but moves
1:02:09a lot faster when they're like you know what fuck it we've got to yeah we're gonna do what we're
1:02:12gonna do because we can build the chip and make the thing so why are we why we bother with you guys
1:02:16i i am very very curious to see how this kind of thing is gonna go and one of the things that they
1:02:25are lacking is games driving them forward in terms of gpu and i think that's been true since forever
1:02:33i know marathon has just been re-announced but it's not coming to them it's not coming to the
1:02:36mac which is heartbreaking even for me and i'm like a hold that hold that hold that thought let's take
1:02:43a break and thank our next sponsor squarespace oh our good friends at squarespace it's the all-in-one
1:02:48platform where you can build your brand and grow your business online do you need a website you
1:02:57want a beautiful website you want to make your website without any kind of fuss or any kind of
1:03:02technical know-how knowing how to code html and css and javascript squarespace is where you go
1:03:08you get a beautiful website you can pick from hundreds of professionally designed templates
1:03:13and you can engage with your audience and sell anything your products your content your time
1:03:20all of it through squarespace if you do have the technical chops you know html you know css you
1:03:26know javascript and you do want to futz with that stuff you can get in there and do it you can be as
1:03:31technical as you want or as wizzy wig drag and drop as you want with squarespace they've got things
1:03:37like member areas now where it makes it easy for creators to monetize their content and expertise
1:03:42in a way that fits their brand with member areas you can unlock new revenue stream for your business
1:03:48and free up your time in your schedule by selling access to gated content so if you have like videos
1:03:54online courses members only podcast newsletters that only go to subscribers you can do it all
1:04:00through squarespace online stores sell your products in an online store squarespace is
1:04:06great for that really great whether you sell physical goods or digital products they have
1:04:11the tools you need to start selling online what do you do if you want to find out more or if you're
1:04:18the nerd in your friend circle you're the one listening to the talk show friends come to you
1:04:22when they need a website people in your family something like that send them to squarespace
1:04:28go to squarespace.com slash talk show tell them that send them to squarespace.com slash
1:04:34talk show they get a free trial for 30 days all the features no watermarks build the whole website
1:04:42get started you'll be surprised how much you can get done in an hour you'll be even more surprised
1:04:47how polished it can be in just like two hours and when you're ready to launch your website for real
1:04:52permanently just remember that same offer code talk show talkshow you save 10 off your first
1:04:59purchase you can use that to prepay for a whole year save 10 on a year go to squarespace.com
1:05:05slash talk show marathon man oh man i just got done listening to syracuse and bemoan it on atp
1:05:13i don't know it's i'm a few weeks behind on that yeah i gotta so what so i might have just i might
1:05:18have if they've covered stuff that i've said i'm sorry i don't know i haven't were you did you play
1:05:27i i forget where you you just said you weren't as long time mac user did you ever play marathon back
1:05:32in the day like i did but i came into the mac in 97 when i didn't say it the reunification
1:05:42yeah reunification next when when yeah when they got next back yeah so during the reunification
1:05:46because steve told me that there would be uh like an open step mac running in like no time at all
1:05:52and there there was not it was 2001 so i had i had a great mac i had like a g3 266 with some av like
1:06:01i could plug in my my vcr to it that was cool and yeah so system 8 which was amazing i really like
1:06:08system 8 8.5 was great like the stuff went to all of the quickdraw i believe went to powered pc
1:06:14native and i really fell in love with what the mac was coming from effectively windows nte os
1:06:222 kind of thing like it boggled my mind that when you held down on a slider the mac would stop
1:06:29because it would be like you know what this guy really wants to scroll i'm going to use
1:06:34everything i got to make this the event loop for like mouse down actions was still from like 1984
1:06:40where it was just yeah it just it really was it was like somewhere low in the system it was just
1:06:45a while loop while button is still down there's like some and poked out freaking rat in a cage
1:06:52just like i just gotta move this cursor right and it had it i don't know i i think somebody maybe i
1:06:59know i think keith staton field still at apples he was like i think the head engineer on on
1:07:06at least the last half or the last five years of the classic mac os like some kind of talk or or
1:07:13retrospective 20 years later of where the system architecture wound up with mac os 8.5 and mac os
1:07:219 mac os 9 was really good and really really gave apple the headroom they needed to let mac os 10
1:07:28establish itself and get off the ground but it was yeah it was weird and it was nowhere near as
1:07:35crude as people think there was a kernel but it also had to support these ancient apis if they
1:07:43could have said carbon only no software except carbon they could have used a modern had a much
1:07:50more modern system architecture it's just kind of the copeland plan right which was a new kernel and
1:07:55new kernel i think there was some derivatives that took mark but yeah i i think you and i were talking
1:08:00about this at ben in a text chain how i i honestly think carbon is probably a key savior for apple at
1:08:08the time oh without question june june that during that transition right and it's and it's champion
1:08:13with scott forestall who came out for style of next came from next but was the not the voice of
1:08:18reason but the the voice of practicality like yes and nobody was more committed to the future of
1:08:23cocoa and the next technologies than forestall but as a practical matter for the late 90s and
1:08:29first few years of the 2000s yeah they needed it and they modernized it but anyway in that era
1:08:35a company who you may have heard of named bungee in december 1994 came out with a first-person
1:08:41shooter that was mac only called marathon yeah and so like the weird i don't know it was like
1:08:49the tail end of the piece the windows pc universe and a mac universe being so utterly foreign right
1:08:57like the internet the internet was the and as much as carbon saved apple the internet saved apple too
1:09:04right oh yeah web and the web because as everything moved to the as so much moved to the web as the
1:09:10to pressure off the native apps right and the lowest common denominator right so all these
1:09:14companies who were only going to write once and we're going to write against win 32 and that left
1:09:19apple mac users out in the cold when that shifted to we're only going to write it once and it's
1:09:24going to be in the web that meant it could run everywhere so that saved apple but you know floppy
1:09:29disks were formatted differently the apps were entirely different extensions man follow remember
1:09:34like right you don't get me started don't don't get me started i know i know i i think it's a
1:09:39necessary evil and i have for 30 some odd years now but whatever i i don't they're gross they're
1:09:45gross for all other reasons going to be gross os 10 basically introduced them to the mac
1:09:51gross we're now living in a we're now living in a world where top level domain is dot zip and
1:09:57that's i know that's it's bad anyway i feel like we're just tripping down memory lane you're
1:10:04the master of these digressions the dot zip thing is that google of all companies who should know
1:10:09better is also a domain name registrar and one of the new domains that they've launched you can get
1:10:15like guyenglish.zip now which don't download guyenglish.zip but that's the actual domain name
1:10:24and it's if you think about it it's horrible because if you can put together a url that's like
1:10:29redirecting and looks like it's something else it will look like it's a file name dot zip
1:10:35that you're just downloading a file where instead you're actually going to this website you didn't
1:10:41intend to go to it's a bad file extension is a horrible idea but at a time when pc users were
1:10:47celebrating doom from id software the groundbreaking first-person shooter was pc only the mac had
1:10:55marathon and it obviously is not as popular as doom because the mac was smaller but in its weird
1:11:02ways i i played both as a mac there's zillions of pc users in the 90s who never got to play marathon
1:11:10because they didn't have any they didn't know where they could use a mac whereas a mac user
1:11:14i had seen doom and played doom very different game doom was really just pure just go there
1:11:22and blow apart anything that moves and marathon had a story a really really interesting way yeah
1:11:28the bungee way yeah i think for those of you out there who were either too young or weren't mac
1:11:33users in the 90s bungee of course went on to make the halo franchise now they're best known for the
1:11:39destiny franchise which all of my adult friends who do play video games are addicted addicted to
1:11:46but hey if you played halo which i did play that was one of the last games i played halo
1:11:50was so marathon like and in fact i think i don't know if it was a different time or something but
1:11:57it took place in the greater marathon universe and they had easter eggs buried but the way that there
1:12:02was stories and they talk about relevant to today's world there was an a there were i think dueling ai
1:12:10constructs in the marathon world where you'd be running around a spaceship shooting these aliens
1:12:15and you'd get to a console and some of the ais were unhelpful yeah just a fantastic game and
1:12:25it was a great first person or single player game with a great story that was very very engrossing
1:12:31and rich the game it's the engine was innovative and powerful and had things that i don't think
1:12:37doom even had like it was meant to you had had mouse i believe you can mouse up and down yeah
1:12:41you could look up and down with the mouse yeah and so you weren't just playing on a 2d map
1:12:45you were playing 3d and where to me it's just doubt right down memory lane and it's just
1:12:55amazingly warm memories was the multiplayer now multiplayer in that time absolutely positively
1:13:03couldn't take place over the broader internet so it was the quote-unquote land party but even
1:13:09do that like the null modem like no but i only played at the school newspaper so at drexel i
1:13:15came out in 94 i graduated at the end of 96 or june 96 and i hung around for another year in the
1:13:22area and still friends with the paper so he played but the school newspaper at drexel the triangle we
1:13:27had we didn't we made real money with real ads good money nobody and all the the entire staff
1:13:35was volunteer so we didn't pay the editors or writers we just it's a good way to make money
1:13:41that's right and we do this are doing we traded we traded ad space to local restaurants in exchange
1:13:48for free food so we got instead of money so we could eat dinner four or five nights a week at
1:13:55the paper so we i got to eat food and then we would just spend all of the money we made from
1:14:01advertising printing the actual newspaper and buying expensive macintosh computers and laser
1:14:08printers that's uh that's a great scam yeah you don't have any rent to pay it's like yeah so and
1:14:14we have the off the office space was what was provided to student clubs at any university
1:14:21there's all sorts of student organizations there's amazing yeah yeah that's weird that that is like a
1:14:26that's weird we had a nice corner office i hope they're still there i haven't i haven't been in
1:14:30touch with anybody at the triangle for a long time but but we spent all the money on expensive
1:14:34macintosh hardware and we had it's a nerdy engineering school and so we had a very good
1:14:42land for ourselves and we'd upgrade the ethernet whenever we could so we had i don't know a eight
1:14:48to ten high-end max that were all so we're all in the same room with nice displays and
1:14:54we and we would just stay up all night just this just the eight ten hours like
1:15:01blowing blowing each other i want to do that now don't you want to do that now until you realize
1:15:07like i don't want to be up no i don't want to be up on that i don't know that i like that i like
1:15:12the vibe of it but like the actual effort put in is like it was just amazingly fun and it was just a
1:15:17tremendously fun game multiplayer like that with some great levels yeah and including the mouse
1:15:23look thing i don't remember the names of the levels but my favorite level was this one where
1:15:29anybody played it was sort of like a big big arena with a stage in the middle and that stage was where
1:15:37the best weapons would appear and so you'd you'd end there like these snipers coming down yeah and
1:15:43there'd be teleport spots where you'd try to teleport up there and that's where you'd go to
1:15:46get the weapons and then you'd have to like do quick jump off but meanwhile people would position
1:15:52themselves up in the you know like uh in the the last batman movie when bain sent him to some weird
1:15:59jail over in the middle east he had a climb up it was like that type of circular long you know yeah
1:16:06real big yeah the climb but but you could teleport to these alcoves that were up there
1:16:10and one of the weapons was a rocket launcher so you could just get up there point your rocket
1:16:17launcher where you knew the best weapons would spawn on that stage down below and then boom just
1:16:23blow people apart the second they got there it was so fun because and and it was one it was a
1:16:30game where the more you had memorized the maps and you knew all the spawn locations the respawn the
1:16:36other thing that you could do is you could take a guess when you killed somebody guess where they
1:16:42might respawn and already point there and that was the that was like the best would be like let's say
1:16:47i killed you and then i've still got the rocket launcher and i take a guess where you might appear
1:16:55and i'm already aimed there and then lo and behold i guessed right boom you're dead again
1:17:01one second later and it tells you there are thousands of you devoted listeners who are
1:17:06realizing that you are a jackass oh i was the worst capper man you're just capping yeah that's
1:17:11yeah and i think that's the wrong way i'm not surprised but that is satisfying when you're like
1:17:17you feel like you're in the zone like okay kill this guy i know he's gonna come back here yeah
1:17:21yeah hit him with another rocket and the and you've got no chance you literally there's
1:17:26nothing you could do you could be the best marathon player in the world and there's nothing
1:17:30you could do if the half a second after you respawn there's already a rocket coming right
1:17:36at your face because you can time it you know how long they'll take you respond if i fire now
1:17:41he'll just he'll teleport right in front of it yeah yeah so you know the way the kids today like
1:17:46when they're uh playing the fortnite or those games and they they pay the money to get the
1:17:50dance moves and stuff like that that they can do but when you were playing in a land in a room
1:17:56all together you would just stand up and do the dance for real and just put your finger right in
1:18:01the guy i mean it's amazing i didn't get beaten up i mean frankly yeah yeah i mean that's like
1:18:07a lifelong well anyway anyway what are we talking about man marathon it's coming back it's but it's
1:18:13coming back in an entirely new it's like they're using bungee is using the intellectual property
1:18:19from marathon to make a new game it's called an extraction something i don't know it sounds to me
1:18:26like you play it's sort of like a more like a fortnite type thing but fortnite is 20 randos
1:18:31around the world get put on an island together and the last person alive wins these extraction games
1:18:38i think it's like you have to you have to get to like a certain point on the map and maybe there's
1:18:42two teams or something like that and capture the flag capture the i don't think yeah i think that
1:18:47the i don't know the class of the the names of them there was a star wars game like that though
1:18:52that i think i i think this might be modeled after you could be like hans solo or darth the
1:18:58bigger yeah maybe maybe that was it i didn't play it i watched jonas play it but anyway marathon's
1:19:04coming back in name only maybe it'll be fun i don't know but the sad part about it is what
1:19:09you said it's it and it's sony sony bought bungee bungee went from being a mac only this is where
1:19:16it's sad from a mac users part they used to make only heartbreaking they used to make mac mac games
1:19:22only and they made the best mac games and were like the only company making games that if you
1:19:27could get a pc user's attention they would say uh-huh that actually does look like a good game
1:19:31they halo was going to debut as a mac game just like marathon but then a small company named
1:19:39microsoft bought bungee but then halo became what mario is to nintendo platforms halo was to the x
1:19:46box it was the exclusive and it got me honestly that's the reason i bought at the original i
1:19:52bought the original xbox in 99 or 2000 whatever year it came out instead of buying whatever the
1:19:58playstation 2 or whatever the playstation was of the time because i wanted halo i knew i wanted it
1:20:04because i knew i loved marathon it did come out for the mac eventually halo but it was bad i played
1:20:10it on my mac and it was support by another company it was fine it was good but it uh didn't have that
1:20:16magic yeah bungee's got magic when they put their heart into something it's magic and i i can't just
1:20:21ports are complicated and difficult because you want to maintain the same thing but
1:20:26you know you feel like the mac people at bungee would have put some great mac twist on it in some
1:20:32weird way yeah for reasons i still don't understand microsoft sold bungee eventually and now sony owns
1:20:38bungee it seems weird given that microsoft is interested in buying ea they obviously want to
1:20:45own intellectual property and game studios and we want to spend microsoft's trying to buy it
1:20:50wait does ea no well what's the parent company of ea whatever no no it's activision you're thinking
1:20:57of oh yeah that's right activision is but doesn't activision own ea do they oh whatever man
1:21:05god i guess you're mad at us yeah i guess no it's activision because the eu is doing
1:21:13the thing where yeah you're right it's activision i don't know why yeah okay okay and it's a weird
1:21:18whatever it shows what a dummy i am at remembering names it's activision of course but anyway no no
1:21:24i'm also but they're but yeah they want to activate but some but for some reason they want
1:21:28to spend 68 billion dollars to buy activision but didn't want to keep bungee and now sony owns bungee
1:21:34and destiny is beloved and now they're coming out with this new marathon game and it's only
1:21:39going to be for playstation xbox and pc boo but i guess i understand why right it would have been
1:21:46well would have been awesome if they said and mac but i guess the other thing that's do a great job
1:21:53of like courting game developers i really don't i like apple arcade i do but one of the big
1:22:00problems with that is if you are just some background i know but for the listeners i
1:22:05i worked at ubisoft at like the beginning of my career was all in video games and i was at ubisoft
1:22:10at one point and the console makers have very strict hig like a human interface guideline
1:22:16and they will reject you if you don't comply with it like if you in every game button x does
1:22:23y like it does it and and you don't need to be the instructions it's just i i'm on my xbox i know if
1:22:29i do this it's going to do an affirmative action if i do that it's not the menus work a certain
1:22:34way everything kind of has a formula like a hig and it's good apple lets people bring their games
1:22:41over but doesn't really provide a hig for what the game should do really and so they're kind of like
1:22:48all over the map and they don't feel unified as as a concept this is under apple arcade
1:22:53games not under apple arcade just want to upsell you but it's horrible like well it's it's just
1:23:00seems like a mess of all kinds of stuff apple arcade is good but i wish they'd have a stronger
1:23:04communication and a stronger opinion when dealing with game developers which i think would be of
1:23:10their platform and courting them and listening to them sort of the same way that they i don't want
1:23:15them to don't want them they've clearly succeeded in television and i think succeeding in games in a
1:23:22similar way would really work for the company and i think they're going to need to hire some outside
1:23:27people in order to help them achieve that if that's even something they want to achieve
1:23:33well hold that thought let's shift to the headset where i think maybe that's where that might go but
1:23:39let's hold that thought and let me thank our third and final sponsor of the show our good friends at
1:23:43collide k o l i d e they've got big news if you're an octa user they can get your entire fleet of
1:23:52devices to 100 compliance now how can they do that how does it work they patch one of the major holes
1:23:59in zero trust architecture and that's device compliance without collide it department struggled
1:24:06to solve basic problems like keeping everyone's operating systems and browsers up to date with
1:24:12security patches and updates insecure devices are logging into your company's apps right now because
1:24:18there's nothing to stop them collide is the only device trust solution that enforces compliance
1:24:24as part of user authentication and it's built to work seamlessly with octa the moment collides
1:24:31agent detects a problem it alerts the user and gives them simple easy to follow instructions
1:24:37for how to fix it if they don't fix the problem within a set time then they're blocked from logging
1:24:43in to your internal apps it's that simple collides method means fewer support tickets less frustration
1:24:50and most importantly 100 fleet compliance visit collide.com the talk show to learn more or book
1:24:59a demo that's k o l i d e collide.com slash the talk show all right onward to the headset and i
1:25:09think games are a good segue yeah because we're gonna find out what apple thinks the answer to
1:25:16the question what it okay we get it it's ahead you know they're making a headset or apparently
1:25:21i mean again we could all be in for a big surprise in a week right i i don't expect that to happen i
1:25:28really i think somebody inside apple would have started spreading the word to stop expecting a
1:25:34headset by now so let's just yeah i mean that notion's come up a few times right which is
1:25:39i forget if it was jason on the show i basically i'm just here to pitch previous episodes of this
1:25:43show but yeah basically if things are getting out of hand in terms of expectations it behooves it
1:25:52behooves apple to be like hey guess what like just chill out because don't get too excited so if if
1:25:58the other if we spend all this podcast time talking about the expectation of a headset next
1:26:02week and it doesn't come it's not us who look foolish it's apple at this point yes right
1:26:10exactly also i don't i don't i don't want to talk about it and i'll tell you why a i think you and
1:26:16jason covered it really well i love the sports stuff i know a friend chris parish and you and
1:26:21i were all texting about similar stuff earlier with regards to soccer rather than baseball
1:26:26seeing games up front is cool i like all of that notion who knows what's going to happen what i
1:26:34i am interested in is not the specifics of the product which eventually if it exists we'll see
1:26:41it it'll be announced soon enough so what's the point in really drawing on that i think that that
1:26:45gun has been covered is what new ways of interacting with computers have we do we expect
1:26:54not just with this potential device but i think the humane stuff fits into this too where the
1:27:03company the company humane you're saying the company humane yes right where and i know they're
1:27:07drastically different concepts at this point but effectively if you forget whatever the specifics
1:27:12are going to be like quinn did a great job you've had a really great you're well up until i'm sorry
1:27:18you stuck with me this week you've had it you've had it you've had a great long run you should
1:27:22definitely get joanna back on because she's amazing but i appreciate it see the mere moles just filling
1:27:27it out quinn was a me quinn nelson was awesome though it was awesome yeah it was great yeah i
1:27:31love it i haven't listened to last week but i i'm sure they're great too the the notion of the
1:27:38humane device is one that does not require a phone and it's sort of as presented fits in the lapel
1:27:46pocket and project stuff i guess my i take on this and and potential glasses are that computing
1:27:54becomes an environmental factor like if it's not clipped onto your label lapel but it's you've got
1:27:59like four of them scattered around like aerotatics in your kitchen whatever you address it'll project
1:28:03something and you can interact with or it's on your glasses and you can see wherever in the world
1:28:08that you happen to be this is sort of an ambient computing kind of take with connectivity and ai
1:28:17hopefully providing input in terms of like being able to understand what it is you want and output
1:28:24in terms of being able to hopefully find you an answer i think maybe let's put aside the
1:28:29caveats about how ai just makes shit up sometimes and and and assume that that's going to be okay
1:28:36i don't to be perfectly honest i'm not sure that that's a good assumption but let's just assume
1:28:41that the people developing this technology think that that's going to be okay and so both either
1:28:48having glasses or humane style device leads to an ambient computing sort of experience and what is
1:28:54that what does that mean like what what's different like where where's the world in 10 years not like
1:29:02hey in six months are we going to pay x amount of dollars for a couple of either a humane device or
1:29:08some potential glasses well you know that i always walk around with a notebook in my back pocket
1:29:12right i'm a field notes junkie and i i just it it's a decades-long habit at this point where
1:29:18something comes to my mind or i was like wait i got to do these three things today don't let
1:29:24me forget them i've been using it during this conversation i do i uh yeah but we're on camera
1:29:31by the way yeah but but it is something that i have to think about i think oh there's something
1:29:36i want to write down i want to make sure i go to the dry cleaner before the end of the day i take
1:29:39out my notebook i write it down and that's like in a broad analogy that's like what computers have
1:29:45been like at this point like oh i want to do something on a computer let me open my laptop
1:29:48and start typing let me take my phone out of my pocket and tap tap tap ambient computing is more
1:29:54like if you had somebody following you around who's writing everything down on a notebook
1:29:59all the time and you don't have to do it and then you're like you just turned your assistant like
1:30:04what where where the hell did i have lunch last tuesday and they're like flip flip flip through
1:30:08the pages oh you had lunch at shake shack and it's like oh yeah that's right but it's it's just there
1:30:14right and it yeah it and yes it is technology is always surprising when it comes to fruition and
1:30:22and however visionary our science fiction authors of decades past were they always miss some things
1:30:31nobody can foresee it and it's like nobody really foresaw like what how what if ai becomes a real
1:30:38thing and a practical thing people can use and it's really dumb like nobody nobody envisioned
1:30:44that nobody envisioned everybody's everybody's idea was that the ais no matter what whether
1:30:49they went bad or they didn't go bad that they were they were smarter than the humans right and you
1:30:55know c3po how 9 000 had a plan right he was like i'm going to get him out of the shift i'm going
1:31:01to close the door it's going to be it made sense he was yeah he was how was very smart c3po is very
1:31:07smart and it was original to think well what if what if he's a bit annoying what if he's a bit of a
1:31:13worry wart and and you know ultimately he is a know-it-all it's not that he he's dumb it's not
1:31:19that he doesn't know thing he's just he's a know-it-all yeah and what if an r2 was what what
1:31:23if r2 what if there's a robot and all it can do is beep but is very sarcastic and there's a bit of
1:31:28his cocky smart ass but he was smart right there was nobody envisioned the idea that what what if
1:31:33the ai comes and it's just really dumb you can spend five minutes with it and convince it to
1:31:38two plus two equals five you know what i mean like people have done that yeah but it's where we're
1:31:43going right and the headset is will be the first step or one of the first steps i still say i
1:31:49air air air pods are are one of those steps right exactly exactly that's kind of where i'm going
1:31:55with that is like it's sort of sure vr ar stuff is possibly a product it's definitely this humane
1:32:02thing as demonstrated at least seems to be the same kind of thing but ultimately the the mechanism
1:32:08through which be it air pods or whatever other kind of stuff is incidental to the actual experience
1:32:14of i can just get stuff projected in front of my eyes whether it's from a projector in the room or
1:32:19like something that i'm wearing or ambient noise detection in my my air pods which i the
1:32:25transparency mode in air pods are is pretty incredible like it'll dampen out a whole bunch
1:32:29of stuff but like when i'm about to get hit by something i i know it it doesn't happen because
1:32:34i know that it's there like it i i forget that it's on all the time and i use them as a pedestrian in
1:32:39a big city with lots of traffic all the time yeah and i think as like a truck goes by or a bus
1:32:45goes by and i hear it i think oh i should put transparency on and then i hold it to put
1:32:49transparency on and then i hear what really is going on in the real world i was like oh it was
1:32:54on and that was just letting me know it's yeah it's fantastic it's really really good but it
1:32:59really is it disappears right then it's exactly that is ambient computing where you literally
1:33:05forget you're using it you're supposed to forget you're using it when you're using them on an
1:33:10airplane and you've got the noise cancellation on you just completely forget that airplanes are very
1:33:16noisy you know that the white noise the baseline white noise on an airplane is really high and you
1:33:21just completely forget it i because i one thing i always do is i always take them out when i go
1:33:26to take a leak on an airplane because i'm super duper quadruple that's the last place you want
1:33:32to lose an airplane they never fall out of my ears i've never i i every once in a while they'll
1:33:36fall out on the sidewalk i've never lost one but i just know murphy's law says the the most likely
1:33:42place would be like i'm halfway through a piss and the airplane hit some turbulence am i right
1:33:48today flight ground against john grubber got his arms stuck in yeah oh no i'd i'd kiss it goodbye
1:33:54that's for sure 0.0 chance that i'm fishing an uh air pod out of there but i you know i worried
1:34:02i guess those those airplane toilets they have a real powerful sort of vacuum flush but i'd be
1:34:07worried that it would just be sitting there and i couldn't flush it down and the next guy would come
1:34:10in and be like uh-oh an air pod yeah so the thing is it's like sure games obviously make sense but i
1:34:18feel like games are sorry for the headset games we know what that is right and so the next kind of
1:34:24thing is well what is an ar an ar is not just glasses it's not ears it it is really sort of
1:34:33an an ambient experience and i think your explanation of ambient makes the most sense
1:34:40which is it's just constantly competing with you which presupposes or is predicated upon the notion
1:34:46of constantly recording stuff which is creepy and i i guess my thesis is that apple's investment
1:34:56both in terms of technology and in terms of communication in privacy over the past many
1:35:02many years in their brand right advertising it's their brand now right there's billboards within
1:35:09the apple logo and a lock on top do you have often you mutilate your logo yeah not often
1:35:14all right they do it with a lock because they want you to know and i think that in terms of
1:35:19whatever product lines you watch you watch it's like also like inherently very personal
1:35:24information the notion that like in order to achieve or to be trusted in this new space of
1:35:31more ambient computing you must take this very very cultural signifier seriously and i think you
1:35:39can come out with products that are maybe cool or interesting but unless you've built trust over
1:35:46years it's going to be a very difficult sell yeah i'm i'm super excited at this point i know it's
1:35:52clear from the last couple episodes of the show and jason and i talked about it and i've talked
1:35:56about it with molts and other people and quinn quinn especially is one of the reasons i had him
1:36:00on because he did such a good video projecting some of these ideas of what you could do i'm i'm
1:36:06i'm still i'm super duper curious what apple's answer to that question is but at this point
1:36:11if it's sufficiently good hardware and the latency's low i can imagine that all sorts of
1:36:16things are going to be really cool and useful on on a headset i really am i do i wonder i mean and
1:36:23the weird thing about apple and gaming is as much as the mac is perhaps as little relevant to overall
1:36:32pc gaming as it's ever been i mean i i think that's on it yeah certainly it's funny because
1:36:38it's it's more capable than it's ever been more capable at the nadir of like right actually having
1:36:44games on it you name the games that people who consider themselves gamers are playing and the
1:36:49number of them that are available on the mac is you count them on one hand i think maybe even
1:36:55even if you've lost a couple fingers and in a lawnmower accident you still might be able to
1:37:00count them on one hand yet apple is arguably maybe the most profitable gaming company in the world
1:37:06with the iphone right yeah i don't even i i'm i'm not looking up the numbers i may not even be close
1:37:13i mean honestly and and there are so there's there is a lot of game source code out there that is
1:37:21targeted towards apple silicon but it's on the phone and does that translate that's a market
1:37:27thing i mean so well it is it is a market thing right yeah i mean so yeah that's kind of what
1:37:32it's going you know this i'm not as public as it used to be but at one point back in the early
1:37:37iphone days i worked on tap tap revenge which was a right big hit and uh basically a dance dance
1:37:43revolution style game on the phone slash guitar hero type guitar hero that that style sort of you
1:37:49know like midi notes would come down you tap them and it was it was a sensation it really i'm not
1:37:54saying that just because you worked on it i mean it was absolutely a sensation yeah it really
1:38:00blew my mind yeah in fact the company tactically set up getting bought by disney right so that's
1:38:04cool i still get emails from disney telling me about just dumb internal stuff anyway long story
1:38:11short games were cool and yet never really the focus i like one of my proudest moments is jobs
1:38:20on stage playing tap tap revenge when multitasking was added it's like hey look i can get out of this
1:38:26dumb game and go do something useful and then come back and the game is still there that was the demo
1:38:30of multitasking i don't like that's very steve jobs and i i like that but it's i don't think
1:38:37the company's ever really had a strong advocate for games and i i i think it is a testament to how
1:38:44well constructed and and the culture of the company that they've had so many long-term managers
1:38:51and and they have adapted in so many ways to the changing environment in terms of computing and in
1:38:56terms of the capabilities of the chips in terms of software in terms of the internet and at the same
1:39:01time none of these people at games and i don't really play games i play fifa every now and then
1:39:06but it's like we i'm not and you're not one of those people that goes and plays land parties
1:39:10anymore but there are people there and in terms to advancing in games i think you need an advocate
1:39:16for that kind of thing well maybe it's shiller though i mean and again i did i it's not like
1:39:21phil shiller calls me up a month before wwc and tells me what's on the agenda quite the opposite
1:39:27but we do know i don't even know i think we know this from the epic lawsuit it came out in
1:39:31testimony that phil shiller number one he knows a lot more about games than you might think and he
1:39:36has yeah like a i don't know if it simulates f1 specifically but like a race a vr race car
1:39:42simulator in his house that's cool like imagine what phil shiller money could buy you in terms of
1:39:47how nice it's probably you know what i mean like it's probably got like a really nice steering
1:39:51wheel it's not just like phil shiller money without steve bomber taste right steve bomber
1:39:56would just buy right an f1 car and race it himself like yeah stark no you know it you know phil's
1:40:02setup looks good too like it looks good even before you're playing it as high level as anybody
1:40:07at apple can get who's obviously got a keen interest in and experience with vr gaming i
1:40:15guess the other thing i would just i don't want to focus too much on games just with the headset but
1:40:19i do think it's got to be a huge part of the story and in one sense i guess the way i'm looking at it
1:40:24is that old axiom that if you're going to be the upstart and take over the entrenched incumbent you
1:40:33can't just be 2x better you've got to be 10x better it's not a magic number if you could put
1:40:39a number on it and it's actually 8.5x better well that's closer it rounds up to 10 but you've got to
1:40:44be like roughly an order of magnitude better where apple's strength in gaming is clearly on handheld
1:40:50phones right and men one level up probably ipad i'll bet the second by far the second most amount
1:40:58of money they get from app store gaming revenue is on the ipad not apple tv or mac and that's the
1:41:04phone is even the biggest phone iphone you could buy is a relatively small really relatively small
1:41:12viewport it's less immersive because it comes back to i think i was talking about it with
1:41:18snell recently about how immersive going to a real movie theater is because the screen is so big there
1:41:25is a psychological aspect to it that it makes it more immersive than watching on your tv at home
1:41:31no matter how big your tv is it just is your your mind gets full pc gaming with a big pc gaming
1:41:39monitor right in front of you is way more immersive than gaming on a phone because it's
1:41:44a bigger screen and you've got better controls but what can be more immersive than even the
1:41:49nicest display in front of you is ahead that your whole field of view right and and that could
1:41:56simulate the illusion that you're looking at reality you know that it's not a big 35 inch
1:42:05display in front of you it's literally the world it's that immersive so to me if apple's ambition
1:42:11is to become like a leading gamer gaming platform not just a casual gaming platform i honestly it
1:42:20would make sense strategically to say you know what we lost this battle with the pc class gaming
1:42:25let's go to the next thing which is full immersion of vr that would make sense to me and then all of
1:42:34a sudden instead of the mac versus the pc it's okay you're stuck on a pc looking at a stupid
1:42:39display or you've got one of these janky headsets for that are out there for pcs attached to it like
1:42:45a playstation right which are i mean they're great they look great i don't have one but yeah well
1:42:50like i said i said last yeah but like i said last week in terms of how how much he's attached to it
1:42:56he didn't even take it to college with him he took he did take his playstation didn't take the headset
1:43:01i mean that's that's how much he cares about the headset what about star wars squadrons a while
1:43:05ago i don't know when it came out uh which is guess what you fly an x-wing or a tie fighter
1:43:10but it supports the headset and i like the game but i never even bought the headset i was like
1:43:16okay well i'm not really called to spend that much extra money i i do think that vr is a distinctly
1:43:26different thing than ar right oh wow and one of the great things that they do have going in
1:43:32to their advantage just i mean all of all of mac os and ios devices except the watch i guess
1:43:40support game controllers right so whatever if they strap something to your face and you can use a
1:43:46game controller that's great obviously there are playstation games where you can interact more
1:43:51physically in the environment but i feel like if you're on a long-haul flight you're not going to
1:43:56get up and dancing out the cabin imagine flailing your arms while you're sitting there and you're
1:44:01like slapping the guy next to you in the face yeah right yeah you're getting you're getting
1:44:06ejected pretty quick yeah i do like you're you're knocking your own drink off your your seat seat
1:44:11tray table no you need like right you want your hands to stay still and and be i think there's
1:44:16two different experiences there i think there was an experience like at least for the for the
1:44:19things that i've tried the the vr the playstation stuff and the oculus there is an experience where
1:44:27you are part of the world and your whole body is sort of incorporated into it and that's one thing
1:44:32there's also a concept of like oh it's just a giant ass screen in front of your face like
1:44:37is that like the game boy worked great because you could just sit there and play it and it was fun and
1:44:46it was pretty compact he didn't you could sit play it on the bus i don't know if you've seen
1:44:49that tesla's movie but man it's pretty good i did no i did see the tesla's movie i loved it it was
1:44:54i was interestingly it it's not what i expected it is not a spy thriller but it's not not a spy
1:45:01thriller it's not a comedy i like they're driving cars and when they bump they glitch which is
1:45:08weird like there was some very weird artistic things it may parts of it may as well just be
1:45:12a stage play like there was his his apartment there was a meeting room and there was maybe his
1:45:17hotel oh and a club at one point like it's so limited in terms of like what what happens it
1:45:23the great great movie well great very interesting worth checking out i guess what i'm saying is the
1:45:30way that you engage with a full you under full immersion can either be a full body experience
1:45:37or it can just be like a very personal experience one of them requires basically a room that is
1:45:44padded really how many coffee tables are you going to fall into you know and one of them could be
1:45:51like a little bit more confined and i think games need to realize like what is this platform or
1:45:59what's it doing and i i think part of the reason that it's kind of pointless to talk about this
1:46:04potential device until next week is we don't know we have no idea we can guess all we want but
1:46:11ultimately it is what is it for who knows like what's the ui who knows who knows what the goal is
1:46:19is it a game boy that you can sit and just enjoy quietly or is it like clear out your living room
1:46:25kids where we're going into vr adventure those are very different things and i think ultimately vr is
1:46:34a stop along the way to like sort of a more augmented reality thing which is where i was
1:46:40going with the humane devices at the earphones and all yeah i think if it's successful and if
1:46:46it's ambitious as i suspect it is and you know there's rumors that it's going to cost three
1:46:51thousand dollars which i know is very expensive for a consumer product but i've as i've said
1:46:56like inflation adjusted the original macintosh from 1984 it was 2500 then that's like over seven
1:47:03thousand dollars now just to get a the one and only macintosh i mean in the 90s silicon graphics
1:47:09and sun workstations it was twenty thousand dollars just to get a computer on your desk on
1:47:13those platforms and in in that era is money and so i'm not i'm not saying that three thousand
1:47:19dollar headset is nothing if that's the price but it to me is exciting if it is let's just say it is
1:47:24three thousand dollars it just means that it's got to be really exciting technology like if if an
1:47:30iphone 14 pro is a thousand dollars how much cool computing power could three times that be packed
1:47:41in front of your eyes like by apple's current engineering standards they're not even talking
1:47:46about the paradigms for how the software is going to work which is the most interesting thing to me
1:47:51but you know that they've got the silicon chops to do it like they may not have the chops to do it
1:47:57and sell it for 750 yet that's the five years in the future but if they're going to pack three
1:48:02thousand dollars of their current this is the best we can do into a headset that should be a really
1:48:08impressive hardware device like as a computer sure with that much money whatever the build materials
1:48:15is yeah if they if they yes that totally makes sense but ultimately why like right right i do
1:48:25you know what i mean it's like could you do that could you strap that much worth of compute onto
1:48:29your face or whatever it is sure but like the mac and i guess i'm going back to the mac pro the 2023
1:48:36concept of a macro why what is it you're trying to achieve what is the purpose of this and if you can
1:48:41sort of glean the purpose which i don't think we can then maybe you can sort of guess of what
1:48:47technology would be yeah but i don't think that like hey we've got this much tech let's throw it
1:48:55at somebody or at a device and see what happens i that feels a little initially backwards but
1:49:02potentially kind of like the watch like hey let's try something and see where it goes and i think
1:49:07going back to the last 15 years of major introductions like the iphone introduction
1:49:14didn't really need the why right everybody had phones and ipods and well but the cute but the
1:49:20one outlier was like an ipod yeah what was it an ipod a phone and an internet communicator right
1:49:27and everybody's like oh that's bullshit yeah just one of three you wanted the rule of three guess
1:49:32what everybody does it's like the third one but for the most part once jobs started demoing it
1:49:38everybody was just like gimme gimme gimme i need it whereas with the ipad the whole keynote was why
1:49:45why why did we build this what is the point it was very explicit it wasn't like hinting at why
1:49:50steve jobs literally said what is the the slide as i recall it was like a macbook on one side
1:49:57an iphone on the other is there space in the middle for something that is sort of like a phone
1:50:03and sort of like a laptop we think yes here's why and it was this that the other i would expect that
1:50:11would be the exact cadence of the headset introduction why i i wouldn't be surprised if
1:50:17if they actually just come right out and say it the way jobs did like what why would you want to
1:50:24do this and strap a thing on your face well we've got some answers this that the other that's a that
1:50:31does make sense and and i think if it's the question is still open for ipad right right
1:50:36well maybe now what's the point of ipad you like i don't know makes a bunch of money right but i
1:50:41think which is i'm sure ipad people are very upset with me now but clearly between the the max like
1:50:46the r max and the phone ipads are getting a little i think i'd say this is somebody who works on ipad
1:50:53so i think if they're successful it'll be the sort of thing like the the sort of broad foundational
1:51:02platform where there is no one answer meaning in the same way with the phone like so many people
1:51:10use their phones in such different ways i mean but my wife hardly uses the camera she she just has
1:51:16never been a photographer she knows i take family pictures she just doesn't take a lot of pictures
1:51:21like if you look at her camera roll of pictures she's taken it's it's mostly like products like
1:51:26things she wants to buy or something like that she just doesn't take photos other people specifically
1:51:33only upgrade their phones just to get the new camera and hardly use the other features right
1:51:37i could see the headset being that i i i if it's successful where some people are going to buy it
1:51:42and it's going to be for for work that they'll put it on and use it as like virtual displays for
1:51:47their mac or doing stuff so they can have like the equivalent of a desktop display while they're
1:51:52traveling without carrying one around and they'll never play games they have no interest in it
1:51:56other people will buy it just for the games and watching movies on airplanes or something like
1:52:01that and obviously the broader mix of people will be a little bit of everything but i could you know
1:52:05if it's a really that foundational like the mac and like ios as a platform it'll be for work for
1:52:14information for entertainment yes not not like one of those things but yes to all of them because
1:52:21it's a foundational platform and a general purpose computing system that you could do
1:52:26anything that you can imagine so i guess
1:52:29this is if that's true if all of the platforms have basically their their venn diagrams intersect
1:52:38a lot and they've all got unique capabilities like currently i can use a uh pencil have a pencil on
1:52:43the ipad that's great ipad's great for a lot of bunch of stuff max are good for a bunch of stuff
1:52:48the watch is obviously very specific airpods very specific the phone very broad but still really
1:52:54quite specific in that like you're not going to do a spreadsheet on your phone and maybe this new
1:52:59device is also like that i feel i'm harping on this a bit but is that not more of a broadening
1:53:09of computing into not quite ambient but like however you want to access your stuff you can do
1:53:16it which is an old son so i was like scott mcnally i believe his name was like a you just log into any
1:53:21computer you get your user account you do your stuff like if i can touch any computer and it
1:53:25could do anything that i needed to do in any maybe there's better form factors to doing a certain
1:53:31thing better like do i want to draw with my mouse probably not ipad's good for that is that not just
1:53:38sort of broadening computing to being like whatever the surface is that you're interacting
1:53:42with will offer you benefits by its physicality but not necessarily in and of itself like i guess
1:53:52when you buy an ipad are you buying the ipad or the ability to interact with your software in a
1:54:00new interesting way it's a very philosophical i was about to say i'm wrapping up here and you're
1:54:07getting you're getting into philip philip i do think you're right though and i guess i guess the
1:54:13other thing that's interesting about the headset as a new platform for apple is it's it and i'm not
1:54:20discounting we just talked about i i think airpods are the first mainstream ar product i think they're
1:54:26more important and more interesting as computers not as headphones but as computers than most
1:54:31people give them credit for the watch i don't underestimate at all but again ambient right it's
1:54:37most of what the watch does isn't you interacting with it most of what the watch does it's just
1:54:41doing on its own on your wrist when you're not even looking at it keeping track of all your
1:54:45vitals and your health statistics and stuff like that you have to go back to the ipad for a thing
1:54:51that you're actually looking at that has a display that's going to have a new set of apis for
1:54:55developers to write software against it's the first one though the ipad came out in 2010 which
1:55:02was early days for the i for iCloud and and stuff like that this is the one that's debuting when the
1:55:09apple broader ecosystem is established and i was going to say millions but i think by apple's count
1:55:17it's like billion active users are have their data and information and their lot their digital lives
1:55:25in the apple ecosystem i i think that's a big part of it of of the ambient part of it and i know
1:55:31people are not going to walk around with this this first headset as it's being rumored that ski goggle
1:55:37thing they're not going to be out on the sidewalk driving their cars or wearing it all day long it's
1:55:42not like glasses it's not ar glasses but i really do see obviously that's that's an end point for
1:55:49where technology is going and in the same way we talked about macro s10 launching with an advanced
1:55:56window manager years before it was ready getting the ar segment of this off the ground with crude
1:56:05hardware by ar standards right like 10 years from now when the glasses that show ambient heads-up
1:56:12displays for everything in your field of vision are commonplace we'll look back at headset 1.0
1:56:18as as being almost comical in ar because of how it it but it is what it is and to get the software
1:56:27ecosystem yeah to get people things comical in retrospect like we've just we we love praise upon
1:56:33marathon right have you played it now yeah it's totally disappointing right i was just watching
1:56:37a video of it and i was like oh that's it's actually really janky right and the original
1:56:41original macintosh was really slow and everything in hindsight is slow the the first i thought okay
1:56:47that's the nature of introducing something new it's always the worst one it's always the worst
1:56:51one but you've got to start somewhere so anyway i'm excited and you know it again i said this to
1:56:55jason and i could say to you i'm excited i'll see you next week i know i'm really looking forward
1:57:00to it yeah it's been a long time well december so not too long yeah i could do with it yeah i
1:57:05could do with a couple of months off from you to be honest well hopefully we didn't jinx the mac pro
1:57:12with like we did 10 years ago i don't think he can't jinx it hey hey i loved it that's why i never
1:57:19got invited back to the life show it's like yeah i got it yeah i got it we got guy anyway i will see
1:57:28you next literally see you next week next week i will see everyone out there listening i will see
1:57:33like a thousand of you next week in the california theater i look forward to that you get your
1:57:38tickets if you don't have one now go just go to daring fireball dot net slash the talk show the
1:57:44ticket stuff is at the top there i look forward to that so i'll see lots of people i will thank
1:57:49our three sponsors today they were let's see if i can do it off the top of my head we had rocket
1:57:54money where you can uh personal finance and find all the subscriptions you might want to cancel
1:57:59squarespace build your own website and collide fleet device management get your fleet into
1:58:05100% compliance, whatever that means.