Podcast Search

The Talk Show

383: ‘A Photocopy of a Fax’, With Jason Snell

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00I guess we should just knock out the sad news right at the beginning, Jason, and do the obituaries.

0:00:05Yeah, let's do it. Let's put them up top. That's how I like it.

0:00:13We got John Warnock, co-founder of Adobe. He died about a week ago. The Times had a good

0:00:20obituary. I was kind of taken aback. Adobe did not do the sort of "our founder died, let's devote our

0:00:29homepage to an obituary." I mean, the canonical example would be what Apple did when Steve Jobs

0:00:35died. Adobe just sort of had a statement, but they didn't really market on their website.

0:00:43They're too busy trying to sell you on doing marketing things with your

0:00:49website or whatever they do now.

0:00:51It still is the Adobe I love, but there's also the new Adobe that does stuff that I don't

0:00:58think I want to know about. The ad tech Adobe.

0:01:01Yeah, when I was at IDG, we used Omniture for a while, which is part of Adobe. It's

0:01:07like ad tech and analysis and stats and marketing tools and all of that, which I understand they

0:01:11got a lot of people who are in the advertising business and in the marketing business.

0:01:17It's one of those ways, like all this talk, I'm sure we're going to talk about

0:01:22businesses Apple is in that you would never have bet they would have been in.

0:01:27And are there going to be other weird businesses that they are going to go in that we will be

0:01:31shocked by today? But Adobe's like that, right? Where they're like, they still do Photoshop.

0:01:37They still do all of the creative apps. They're still building new apps. They still have teams

0:01:43of scientists and mathematicians working on wild AI image recognition features and all

0:01:50of that stuff. But they also have now built this whole side business.

0:01:55And, or, or maybe it's the main business. I actually don't know the size of it, but it's like,

0:01:59yeah, marketing tools for big companies. Yeah. I don't know. But, but Warnock,

0:02:02he wrote illustrator and Warnock and Geschke, the two founders Geschke passed away a couple

0:02:06of years ago, just. Pivotal knowledgeable computer people who also decided that they were going to

0:02:13just take that tech and build their own business. And PostScript obviously is the, the, the biggest

0:02:19intersection with, with Apple where Steve Jobs saw that and was like, Oh my God. And they made

0:02:25the laser writer, essentially it's a collaboration between Apple and Adobe and the laser writer itself

0:02:30changed the course of the publishing industry at the very least and probably the computer industry

0:02:37at the same time. And it's just sometimes at this point in our careers, it's like,

0:02:44we've been doing this long enough yet. We still have a long way ahead of us knock on wood,

0:02:50hopefully, but I'm blown away. And I I'll just say it, we'll get to it later, but talking about

0:02:56the iPad as a person, it can't be your main computer, the never ending topic. And it's like,

0:03:02in some ways it feels like it's moving so slow and Steven trout and Smith pointed out, I added it to

0:03:10the show notes, a 2013 article 10 years ago, I wrote an article that was pretty much covering

0:03:16the exact same stuff that you and I were writing about this week, 10 years. And it's like, no,

0:03:22I know that the iPad has gotten better to the last 10 years, a lot of ways, but not

0:03:27crazy fast. Whereas desktop publishing, the Macintosh didn't even exist until 1984.

0:03:35And the laser writer comes out in 1985 illustrator. I looked it up was the 87

0:03:42by like 1988, the publishing industry had largely moved to the Macintosh and digital publishing,

0:03:51like in four years, that'll an industry that you could arguably date back to Gutenberg

0:03:59had entirely switched to doing it on computers because it was so much better.

0:04:06And it happened that happened so fast, but because I was a kid at the time,

0:04:10I thought that was just totally normal. Right now it was a, there was a lot, I would say

0:04:14there's a lot of pent up, pent up inspiration going on there, right? Where it was like,

0:04:18we just need a computer that can do this. We just need something that can do this.

0:04:22And then all of a sudden there was this explosion and it was like, did the Mac,

0:04:26like everybody had its precursor, but like the Mac leading to that point and then having

0:04:30Warnock and Geschke at Adobe and saying, we can do postscript. And you put those together with the

0:04:36hardware, the laser writer, and you put it together with page maker and then later QuarkXPress, you put

0:04:41it together with Photoshop and illustrator. And it, that it just kept that ball just kept rolling

0:04:48for a very long time. And by the time, yeah, five years had passed, the whole industry had already

0:04:54been transformed and yeah, just like that. I wrote in my little brief sort of, I don't know,

0:05:03call it a bit, whatever you want to call it when I, you know, just add a couple of thoughts when

0:05:07somebody dies or something about the way that they did not settle. And to me, it's exactly,

0:05:13I really do think it's why Adobe and Apple continue to have, I think a pretty, pretty

0:05:19friendly corporate relationship and certainly on and off over the years, they obviously got

0:05:24along with Steve Jobs. The laser writer, as you just alluded to, was a total collaboration.

0:05:29Apple sold it and it was an Apple hardware product that connected to Apple's computers,

0:05:33but entirely based on postscript technology that was Adobe's. Totally a joint collaboration. And

0:05:41in those eighties years, if you were doing desktop publishing on a Macintosh, effectively part of your

0:05:50system software was from Adobe. Adobe Type Manager was effectively, in those days,

0:05:58extend all extensions ran. No, there was no kernel really, but so they effectively all ran in kernel

0:06:04space and infamously any kind of conflict or bug in a third-party extension could just freeze up,

0:06:10collapse your entire system or whatever. But if you were there at the time, nobody even called it

0:06:15Adobe Type Manager. It was ATM. And the extension was always spelled tilde ATM because unlike now,

0:06:26where a tilde sorts to the top A to Z alphabetically, and for some reason in Mac Roman

0:06:32text encoding in classic Mac OS, tilde sorted to the bottom. And you always wanted ATM to load last.

0:06:40So whatever other shenanigans your extensions were doing, ATM patched the traps last.

0:06:46But ATM was amazing because it rendered these outline fonts on your screen

0:06:54and they looked like the fonts, but they weren't bitmap fonts drawn pixel for pixel.

0:06:59You really did get somebody, some reader who thanked me for my post, but couldn't believe

0:07:06I didn't mention the term WYSIWYG, which at the time was whether we were writing about it

0:07:12professionally or before that, just talking about the Mac, you couldn't go two paragraphs without

0:07:18talking WYSIWYG. What you see is what you get because it was transformative. The idea that you

0:07:23actually could see on screen what you would get when you printed seems so obvious. But up until

0:07:32that point, it was nothing like that. People don't understand the idea that it used to be,

0:07:37you're writing your college term paper, let's say, because this is a true story about me,

0:07:42in Microsoft Word. It's a little short. You wrote it in 12 point, but you need to pump it up a

0:07:47little bit and you put it in 13 point. It'll print on a laser writer and look great. But on your

0:07:55screen, it looked like crap because the bitmap font that was displaying on your pixel-y screen

0:08:02only came in certain type faces. They were outlined or shadowed in the fonts menu as well.

0:08:09You knew which ones were the good ones that you could use, but when you printed it,

0:08:13it would print fine. ATM was that moment where Adobe was basically patching macOS to say,

0:08:19"If we've got an outline, we can make it look okay on your screen. It'll be fine."

0:08:25Before that, there was as different as doing any sort of typography, even just rudimentary

0:08:35word processing for a school paper where you were just happy to use Helvetica or Times New Roman.

0:08:41You weren't fussy about typefaces. You're picking one of the 12 fonts that came with the computer,

0:08:47which felt like a plethora of fonts compared to what we had before.

0:08:52So, where before it was, well, you had a typewriter or a "word processor" that was really just a

0:09:03typewriter with a couple of lines of memory, and you got 12 point courier and you liked it.

0:09:08That was it. But there was this odd similarity to setting hot metal type, where

0:09:17in hot metal type, if you're setting with little tiny pieces of type, obviously, whatever size that

0:09:24is, is the size you're going to get when it strikes the paper. Our bitmap fonts were like that.

0:09:30It was like we'd have nine pixel, we'd call them points, but the points were pixels. Nine, ten,

0:09:37twelve, eighteen, twenty-four, forty-eight, seventy-two. If you didn't like one of those,

0:09:45it's a tough one. You could set it to the others, but they looked terrible because they were just a

0:09:50mathematical expansion of it. They weren't based on the shapes, which were in the vectors, which

0:09:59was what PolkScript was all about, was creating a resolution independent vector, and no font hinted

0:10:06every point size. It also means that you couldn't zoom effectively because that's cheating. If you

0:10:13zoom in on a document that's got a 12 point font, it's not 12 point on your screen anymore.

0:10:18I remember one of my first encounters when I really fell for the Mac was at my college

0:10:25newspaper and we had PageMaker. There's that moment where you zoom in and it redraws the

0:10:31letters and you're like, "Oh my god, they're still clear." If you zoom out far enough,

0:10:38it just all turns into a gray square because it's like, "Nope, forget it. I'm not going to try."

0:10:43Then Jobs, because Jobs was so savvy, when he went to Next, one of the first things they did was

0:10:50they built their Next Step operating system on Display PostScript, which was just, "We're going

0:10:55to use PostScript as our display layer." That ended up coming back to macOS in OS X with quartz.

0:11:06PostScript ended up inspiring Next and then wrapping back around and being a key part of

0:11:11the concept of how OS X... Trust me, I don't know if you ever used a Next Step computer, but

0:11:18the processors at the time really struggled to try and render PostScript on the screen.

0:11:23I got the idea. The idea is, "Yeah, we should probably just use these fundamental resolution

0:11:29independent outlines to draw everything on the screen." By the time we got into the OS X era,

0:11:34you could do all that stuff and it looked good.

0:11:36Tom: Yeah, I was infinitely curious about the Next computers, but Drexel had, as far as I knew,

0:11:43one. There was one that I knew of in the computer lab, and I got to, I don't know, kick the tires

0:11:49on it. I mean, pretty much spent about as much time as I would have if there were retail stores

0:11:55where you could have... But I could see...

0:11:57Ben: Yeah, mine was University Bookstore had one, and I spent a good hour on the stupid

0:12:04display unit at the University Bookstore because it's the only way I was ever going to touch one.

0:12:08Tom; Yeah, it was vaguely reminiscent of the early versions of macOS X in that the screen was slow to

0:12:14refresh because you could see what it was doing, and you could see that it was elegant in doing it

0:12:21correctly in some sort of abstract notion of, "Oh, this is the way to draw everything. Do it all

0:12:26with PostScript right on the screen, and everything that could be an outline is an outline or a vector

0:12:32graphic or something like that, and everything that could be scalable is scalable." But yes,

0:12:37the computers, even though the Next was started at $10,000, way too slow really to handle it at

0:12:45the time. I do know this. I didn't mention it. Again, the guy just died. I don't know. It's not

0:12:50the time to to drudge up the unpleasant stuff, but I've talked to people, more than one person,

0:12:57engineers at Apple who more or less have been there since the Next era, and Next's use of

0:13:07display PostScript was technologically advanced and clearly the right thing to do, and like as you

0:13:13said, absolutely is why the groundwork they laid literally just goes straight through to all of

0:13:22these devices today, right up to the Vision Pro, which isn't even out yet. You can just trace the

0:13:28operating system through in this way and the way that it handles graphics, certainly, but the

0:13:33relationship between Next and Adobe was contentious. It's the way that Next kind of got pushed around.

0:13:40It bothered Jobs. Steve Jobs does not remind anybody of the sort of executive who liked being

0:13:45pushed around and bullied by bigger companies and being sort of overlooked by the press at large and

0:13:52written about in the past tense, but the basic story, and this is all never written. This is all

0:13:58stories told over beers at Macworld's and WWDC's long past, but Next didn't have the source code

0:14:06to display PostScript. They had a licensing agreement, obviously, and they were allowed

0:14:11to use it, but they only got to take like the binaries and put them in the operating system.

0:14:19And so when Next engineers needed to do work that involved actual display PostScript code,

0:14:27they had to go to Adobe and work in what effectively an air-gapped room without internet

0:14:35access. And it breeds resentment, I guess, more or less. Like, okay, you guys can come in,

0:14:44but it's like, you got to, I don't know if they went through a magnetometer, but effectively,

0:14:49just anything that Adobe could do to make sure that they weren't sneaking out the source code

0:14:54to PostScript, they would sit there, do all the work at somebody else's office, possibly,

0:14:59depending on how intense it was. It wasn't just like, oh, we need to come in and spend five minutes

0:15:04fixing a bug. It might be a major new feature. It might've been when they added color to Next,

0:15:09something super significant and difficult, weeks at a time. But it's funny because these guys

0:15:15resented that, but then what has Apple done in the decades past when they invite third-party

0:15:20developers to come and work on unreleased operating systems and unreleased products like

0:15:26the iPad and Vision Pro now? It's like, come to us, come into a room. You walk out with nothing.

0:15:34It's the exact same thing. It's just, who's got the power now?

0:15:38Yep.

0:15:40Yeah.

0:15:40Yep.

0:15:41The other thing I just, I'll bring up this story from when I was in college,

0:15:46in studying computer science at Drexel. One of my very, I guess, quite honestly, my favorite,

0:15:51in hindsight, professor, same as David Manganask, and I had him for a couple of classes,

0:15:59but he had written his PhD, I guess, dissertation on PostScript. I had him in around '93, '94.

0:16:09I don't know when he got his PhD, but he was pretty young for a professor. But he had written

0:16:14his dissertation about PostScript and doing stuff. And so he knew, and he had these amazing little

0:16:20programs. They were amazing. PostScript really is a programming language, but it doesn't look like

0:16:25JavaScript or C or the way we think of most normal programming languages. But it is,

0:16:33if you do write it as a human, you can kind of follow the gist of it. But he would have

0:16:39these amazing little 13-line programs that would draw incredibly intricate fractals.

0:16:46You know what I mean? What was that thing we had as a kid with the pencil, the spirograph?

0:16:51Or when you look at currency very close and you look at the fine-grained,

0:16:573D, etched artwork, and it would be like 17 lines of code. And you would get this amazing

0:17:06stuff out of it. PostScript was amazing like that, but it's so, as I wrote, the thing that makes

0:17:13Adobe, Adobe made Warnock and what was the other guy's name? Geschke.

0:17:17>> Chuck Geschke. >> Was that they never stopped

0:17:22when they invented PostScript. They were like, this is nowhere near enough. Illustrator is the

0:17:26perfect example because it really was just a front end to PostScript purely. And it wasn't like,

0:17:33oh, well, the smart people will just write PostScript directly and we'll build PostScript

0:17:41for dummies and put it on the Macintosh and you can click and drag and do some things.

0:17:47And if you really want to do something serious, you'll have to poke into the hood and find

0:17:51the closest person who knows how to write actual PostScript and they'll go into your Illustrator

0:17:57file and do the real hard work in actual PostScript. No, it was a complete encapsulation.

0:18:03And maybe I'm drawn to that word encapsulation because of the EPS format, encapsulated PostScript.

0:18:10EPS files still are part of the publishing industry. PDF sort of is a superset of EPS,

0:18:17but the encapsulated PostScript format was like the native format of Illustrator and Illustrator,

0:18:24the app was conceptually a complete encapsulation of PostScript. It was just a word to the millions

0:18:33of graphic designers who still use Illustrator. PostScript is just a word that they don't need

0:18:38to really know anything about. It's all there as a visual tool for visual artists working in

0:18:45visual medium. And I think most of the times in history, somebody invents something like PostScript

0:18:52and they're so proud of it and they're so focused on it because their mind works like as a

0:18:59programming language inventor, they're not the same people who have the mind to create a complete

0:19:06visual GUI tool that encapsulates it. Right. You created this amazing thing. Now,

0:19:10what are we going to do with it? And the answer is, what do you mean? We'll just make it better.

0:19:13It's like, no, no, no. You got to do something with it because artists need this. So we had

0:19:17artists in college. We had this one incredible artist at my college newspaper, and this is like

0:19:211991. So it's the very early days of this. And his medium was Illustrator. He just passed away

0:19:27a couple of years ago. His name is Mel Marcello. This guy was a genius. He was still making like

0:19:31posters that are hanging in like sports venues and stuff. He was so great with Illustrator.

0:19:37And I remember I would see these things and you would, you would see whether you were in

0:19:41Illustrator or Photoshop or no Illustrator or page maker, you'd see it actually draw

0:19:47all the objects on screen one by one. So you, because back then they wouldn't often,

0:19:54wouldn't render a preview. And so you'd have to watch it draw live with all of the shading

0:19:58and everything. And so it was almost like these videos of people making a sketch on an iPad,

0:20:04where you're seeing not just the finished image, but like all the layers and all the different

0:20:09shapes that are built up by the artist to get to the point where you get that final image. And it

0:20:15was just amazing. And that was, so his medium was Illustrator, which means essentially his medium

0:20:19was PostScript. And then the other thing about Adobe and Warnock and Geschke is right when I

0:20:25started a Mac user, my boss was Pam Piffner, who ended up writing a book that is out of print,

0:20:30but you can get it places. It's essentially the Adobe story. I mean, it was for their 20th

0:20:35anniversary. It's called inside the publishing revolution. So she was deep down in this and she

0:20:38was my first boss. And that was when they were trying to popularize PDF and release Acrobat.

0:20:44And at the time it was like kind of a hard sell, but Acrobat, the whole premise of Acrobat and PDF

0:20:48was PostScript was not actually portable PostScript. You had to rely on embedded fonts

0:20:54or fonts that were on the hardware. You didn't know I did a magazine when I was in college and

0:21:01I laid it out in page maker and I had to do it as a PostScript file. And it was like, I couldn't use

0:21:06anything but the fonts that were on every single PostScript fender printer, because otherwise

0:21:10you just couldn't do it. And so they said, what we need to do is make something that will be

0:21:15available everywhere, like a piece of paper for any document. And it'll look the same everywhere

0:21:20without the overhead. And it took them a long time. It was super hard for them to sell it at

0:21:26the very beginning. And I think about that now, because that was a long time ago, right? I started

0:21:30at Mac user in 94. So we're coming up on too many years there, right? It's coming up on 30 years,

0:21:39but like now we were trying to register my daughter's car in Oregon because she lives in

0:21:46Oregon now and graduated from college. And every DMV form is a PDF, California, Oregon, doesn't

0:21:55matter. Everything is a PDF. And that was one of those things where that was a vision thing on their

0:22:00part. Like they knew PostScript wasn't the end result. It was a pathway to a bunch of things they

0:22:07wanted to do. And it took a lot of time and a lot of effort for PDF to get where it is. But at this

0:22:13point, everybody just, it's a PDF. What is a PDF? It's paper. It's it. And that's exactly what they

0:22:20always meant for it to be is what it is now. But it took them decades of work to get it there.

0:22:26Yeah. And there really was this straddle between the history, hundreds year old history of print,

0:22:33which had hundreds of years of tradition and technological advances to get print to the

0:22:41non computerized print design printing to the point where by the eighties it had reached the

0:22:49apex in the same way that every technology is at its best, right when it's about to be replaced,

0:22:54like the very best, smoothest propeller passenger jets came right before the jet era, you know,

0:23:02made them irrelevant and print forms could be as beautiful as your ability to make them.

0:23:08Yet was print and you had to put ink on paper and tallying results if you were printing some

0:23:14kind of survey or whatever would be lots of manual labor, lots of manual labor just to actually print

0:23:20and distribute them. And computerization makes all sorts of stuff easier. But everything that

0:23:25came out of computers was ugly and or at the very least crude, if not ugly, right? Just blocky,

0:23:33visible dots even on the printed output. And it was Adobe at a large level. I mean,

0:23:40Apple obviously had an interest in it, but Adobe really more even, I think, obviously more so than

0:23:47Apple in the professional tool space for desktop publishing really pushed for, hey, this we should

0:23:54be able to use computers to make stuff that's even better looking than print because computers

0:24:01give human superpowers. They're the bicycle for the mind. We shouldn't settle for,

0:24:05oh, if it's computerized, it's easier and faster, but looks crude. It should be beautiful.

0:24:12And I remember the moment, one of those transformative moments for me is we laid out

0:24:18our college newspaper, like I said, in page maker, but we still shot all of our half tones in order,

0:24:24you're going to take a continuous tone, a black and white photo in order to make a color or not

0:24:28color in order to make it print. Well, it's like photocopying a regular thing in a Xerox machine,

0:24:34right? It comes out. It's awful. So what you do is you use a stat camera and you basically make

0:24:39a half tone of it, which is the whole thing becomes like pixels. It becomes dots, dots and

0:24:44absence of dots. And, and then you can reproduce that directly. Okay, great. We got a scanner

0:24:50my junior year, I think in college and I scanned a photo and it's like, oh my God. And you could

0:24:56place the photo, you could move the photo around in page maker. And one of the things you could do

0:25:01was click on the thing and say, put a screen on it. And then when it printed, it was, it was ready

0:25:09to go for the camera without us having to hand a print to someone who had to take it into a dark

0:25:15room, who had to use a stat camera to turn it into a half tone that would then get pasted down.

0:25:20And it was a moment that I remember it was like, can we do this? Can we take a picture and put it,

0:25:28print it out of the computer and print it? And it looked different in fact, because the dot patterns

0:25:34were finer and more sophisticated, but, but it worked. And it was just an amazing moment. Like,

0:25:40I cannot believe the computers let us do this stuff now because it was, I could feel us just

0:25:46leaving the past behind when I did that. Yeah. I was like a year or two behind you on that.

0:25:52My college newspaper time was all through the scanner and we were, we've talked about this on

0:25:58my show before, QuarkXPress, not page maker. But I remember when we got at the newspaper,

0:26:06our first 1200 DPI laser printers, and we figured out, oh my God, we could make the screens,

0:26:14these black and white photos look so much better and they were all photo ready.

0:26:19And then we sent them. And then that issue of the Drexel triangle, the photos all looked terrible

0:26:24because then it met the analog world of newspaper, ink hitting newsprint paper.

0:26:30Oh yeah. The press, the press couldn't handle 1200 DPI.

0:26:33No, we didn't actually screen at 1200, but I forget what we did, but we made what we sent

0:26:39photo ready to the printer looked way better than anything we'd been sending up until that point.

0:26:44But then when the ink blobs go that small, it looked at then all these photos that we thought

0:26:50were going to look better than ever all looked like a photocopy of a fax that had been crumpled

0:26:57up into a ball and smoothed out or something. It was terrible. Anyway, hats off to John Warnock.

0:27:03What a career. Absolutely. What a legacy. The other obituary, I think we can spend less time

0:27:08on it, but our good friend, everybody, America's TV friend, Bob Barker, the host of The Price is

0:27:14Right, died after a good long run at 99 years old. Almost, almost a hundred. He was a few months

0:27:21short, which led to a lot of funny people, bless them on the internet saying that Bob

0:27:26got as close to a hundred as he could possibly get without going over. Amazing. And you made the

0:27:31same, I actually, I was visiting my mom this week and I said, did you see Bob Barker died? I said,

0:27:36he was every kid's sick day friend because that was, that show was on in the morning for an hour.

0:27:43You're a kid, you're home sick. What are you going to do? You just watch TV. There's nothing more you

0:27:47can do. You just got to lay there. And that was, game shows are half an hour long. That game was an

0:27:52hour long. It was captivating. And then I look at Daring Fireball and you have written the same

0:27:59thing, which is he is the, he is your friend when you're a kid and it's, and you're sick home from

0:28:04school. It was definitely the same thing. Very strong memories of that snow day. A lot of snow

0:28:09days, if it was a nice snow day, we'd go out and play of course. But I guess actually we might even

0:28:15be like frozen and wet by the time that the Price is Right was on at 11 AM for us. So yeah, I think

0:28:21so. I think that was the time. Yeah. We might've actually even on snow days where we went out,

0:28:26been back in the house by the time it was Price is Right time. Ringing out your socks and having

0:28:31some soup. But a lot of, a lot of snow days weren't really snow. It was more like ice or whatever. So

0:28:36you wouldn't go out and boom Price is Right. Of course, rainy summer days where you couldn't go

0:28:40out and play Price is Right. That was the one thing. And I had a sister, my sister's two years

0:28:44younger than me. And we might've fought over every other hour of the day if we were both home,

0:28:50because it was a rainy summer day or a snow day or something. But one thing where there's never

0:28:54an argument about is 11. Well, of course Price is Right. Absolutely. And it is not to dig down too

0:29:03far into this rabbit hole, but like it was a show conceived as being for housewives. The whole idea

0:29:08of it was it's a daytime show. It's for the housewives. And the whole idea is, is you know

0:29:14what housewives know about? Shopping because they are the shoppers in the family. So we're going to

0:29:18do a whole game show based on you guessing what things cost. Okay. That's fine. And yet

0:29:23people of our generation, kids who did not know what anything cost were enthralled by the Price

0:29:32is Right. And I think it's because it had this Bob Barker, very friendly, and it had this bizarre

0:29:38sensibility in it. It was a bunch of mini games. We would say now for something like Mario party,

0:29:43right? It was mini games and they were all, they had weird. Designs sometimes elegant, mostly not,

0:29:50but weird designs of the mini games. We had the little like yodeling guy, the one on the mountain,

0:29:56you had the big, big levers that you would pull and a number would come up. You had the big Plinko

0:30:01thing where the they're all going down. Like there was some maniac who was in the art department of

0:30:06that who would invent these just bizarre little mini games and they were so striking. And I think

0:30:13that's why kids liked it is if you got bored with it, you're onto the next one. And then it also

0:30:18means, you know what they all are and they had a rotating, whatever they had like 10 or 15 that

0:30:21would rotate and then you'd see it and you'd be like, Oh, I know this one. It was magical. It

0:30:25really was. I think that was part of what made it like, it's still on. It's still as a popular show

0:30:31and in that era, people who are younger than us or whose memories aren't as good as us,

0:30:36the whole morning was filled with game shows until it, until it became soap opera time.

0:30:41And then the soap operas came on, I guess after the price is right. It was like the price is

0:30:45right ended it and you might have news at noon and then it was also after that. But that mini

0:30:51game format is what kept it fresh because every other game was 30 minutes of the exact same game

0:30:58every day. And some of them are great. I loved the, one of my all time favorites too was Dick

0:31:04Clark's, whatever. Pyramid. Yeah, but it changed over the year. $25,000, $64,000 pyramid, $100,000

0:31:12pyramid, but the pyramid was a good game. But it was still, it was two rounds and the rounds were

0:31:18exactly the same every day. The price is right had these mini games. I wonder how many they had.

0:31:24I want to say because of what, what would they do in rotation at any given time, right? How many

0:31:29would have been there? I don't, I don't know, but it was six a day, right? Because there would be

0:31:33like the first three for the first spinoff and then the second three for the second spinoff.

0:31:38So sounds about right. So if there were six mini games a day, they must've had 20 or 30 of them,

0:31:42really. Cause I think if you went all week, you'd see some maybe more than once, but it was great

0:31:48cause they, and then the other thing they had that was fantastic is most of the time, the normal

0:31:53prizes people were playing for would be like a dining room set or a brand new washer dryer,

0:31:58a big jet ski jet skis or something like that. But, but at least once a day, somebody's game

0:32:05would be for a new car and everybody would go bananas. The whole crowd would go bananas. Yep.

0:32:14Me and my sister would go bananas. We'd be like, Oh my God. And it happened every day.

0:32:20Somebody every day, but they, it wasn't like always the second spot or the seventh spot,

0:32:27or sometimes it would be the first person of the day. It would be like, Oh my God,

0:32:30the show only started three minutes ago. And already this lady's planned for a brand new Honda.

0:32:35Holy cow. It's every day. Yeah. You can't just, you can't explain it even logically. I mean,

0:32:42we could, like I said, I think I, I can understand logically what it was, but as a kid, it was just

0:32:47like, give it to me. I'm I'm I'm homesick. Give me an hour of this show. I want it. I hope the

0:32:52yodeling guys are on. I hope the big thing where you pull the handle and it tells you how many you

0:32:57got right is on because those are my, my favorites. Like there was, yeah, it was magical. And Bob

0:33:02Barker was the guy at the center of it. Game show host is a tough job. And it's funny that some game

0:33:07show hosts live on in our memories. You mentioned to Clark. I was thinking about like Alex Trebek.

0:33:13Like there is something that Pat Sajak is retiring, right? Like there was something that the audience

0:33:17is really connected those hosts in a way. And Bob Barker, certainly. That was my first thought was

0:33:22just like so many hours spent in front of the TV. Usually when I was homesick from school and

0:33:27it was a great, that's just nostalgia, pure nostalgia right there.

0:33:32It's it's a bizarre human trait to be able to spend literally thousands of hours, hundreds of hours

0:33:39a year over dozens of years for Barker doing the exact same thing. And people don't get tired of

0:33:48you. It's like all they get is they just, they just grow in affinity for your presence. I mean,

0:33:53and you and I could have wasted many, many hours on this show talking about our love of David

0:33:56Letterman and late night talk shows. I have the same thing, but it's a different kind of charisma.

0:34:01And Pat Sajak sort of proved it by trying his hand at hosting a late night show, which lasted like,

0:34:07I don't know, four months or something like that. Just didn't have it as a late night host,

0:34:11but obviously has it in spades as the host of to me rather insipid game show. But yeah,

0:34:18it's not my favorite. Merv Griffin actually, who was, had his greatest success on camera as a talk

0:34:24show host, but he invented game shows and then went out and hired. And that's how he made his

0:34:29money was he invented game shows and made huge amounts of money from them. Jeopardy and wheel of

0:34:34fortune being his babies, bringing back jeopardy, which had a much lesser known run before the Alex

0:34:42Trebek era. And I guess inventing wheel of fortune whole cloth. No. And, and jeopardy was his

0:34:48invention to begin with the original two. He and his, he and his wife, yeah, the art Fleming

0:34:52version too. He and his wife invented it. That jeopardy song. Everybody knows was written by

0:34:55Merv Griffin. It's just bananas. And then wheel of fortune. They actually brought back jeopardy

0:35:00to pair it with wheel of fortune and yeah, something about that. And I don't know if our

0:35:04kids have anything, are YouTubers comparable. I mean, like there weren't very many channels.

0:35:09There wasn't much to do. And it became this thing that you really formed a connection with. And so

0:35:13it's 99. He had a good run. Good job. Didn't go over. Nope. Didn't go over. All right. Let me

0:35:19take a break here and thank our first sponsor of the day. It's our good friends at trade coffee.

0:35:24I'm literally fueled on trade coffee as we speak. Although I'm offered for the day,

0:35:29we're recording too late in the afternoon, but it's coursing the caffeine from their

0:35:33coffees coursing through my veins. Trade coffee is a coffee service that makes it so simple to

0:35:40discover new coffees from over 55 top independent roasters. And it enables you to make your best cup

0:35:47of coffee at home every day. They have a matching algorithm that curates coffee. Perfect for you.

0:35:53And it really is true. I've honestly stopped even giving them feedback because I just know that the

0:35:58coffee that comes from them, they've already dialed it in, but you start getting coffee from them.

0:36:02They send you an email. They don't badger you. And they say like, how'd you like that last coffee

0:36:06that we sent you? And you give it like a thumbs up or a thumbs down. And as you tell them how

0:36:11much you like the coffee they've sent you, they steer your choices. You can think about how

0:36:17collectively from their users, they kind of get a sense, Oh, people who liked that also like this

0:36:22people who didn't like that one so much. Okay. We won't send them this, et cetera, et cetera.

0:36:27Totally works. I just get coffee that I don't even look, I don't even bother like smelling it.

0:36:32I just know I'm going to like it. Really, really great. And it just comes to your house on the

0:36:39schedule you set. All of their coffee is freshly roasted. And again, I always say it when I talk

0:36:45about trade coffee, coffee is produce. It doesn't look like it. It looks, and most supermarkets sell

0:36:51coffee, whether it's ground or whole bean just sits on the shelf. You don't think of it. They

0:36:56don't put it in the produce section, but my opinion, they should roasted coffee goes,

0:37:01doesn't go bad. It just goes bland very, very quickly. Coffee from trade always gets shipped

0:37:09within 48 hours of being roasted. And they always, every, every one of their roasters prints the date

0:37:14it was roasted on usually gets to my house in my hands, four or five days after being roasted.

0:37:19Can't, you can't beat it other than roasting beans yourself. I don't know how else you could beat it.

0:37:24It's just a fantastic service and it's customizable up the wazoo in terms of your frequency.

0:37:31If you're going on vacation because it's summertime, you want to pause, you want to adjust

0:37:35your schedule. All of that is so super easy. Just go to the website, say skip the next one,

0:37:41or pause for a week or switch to every two weeks instead of every week or whatever you want to do.

0:37:47You can do it at any time. Couldn't be great. And it's just hassle-free. Just shows up at your door

0:37:52on a regular schedule. Can't beat it. Upgrade your morning routine with better coffee. Right now,

0:37:58Trade is offering listeners of the talk show a free bag of coffee with every subscription.

0:38:03Just go to www.drinktrade.com/the-talk-show. That's www.drinktrade.com/the-talk-show for a

0:38:12free bag of coffee with any subscription purchase. www.drinktrade.com/the-talk-show.

0:38:19We're heading into review season. iPhone's coming up next month. I've often thought,

0:38:25and I used to think about it with speed, is in the early years of iPhone, it was super noticeable,

0:38:32but it's always noticeable with most computers. But I've always thought that it's way easier to

0:38:37tell how fast a new one is after you've gotten completely used to it and then go back to the

0:38:44pre- just one generation back and feel how much slower it is. And I always keep my old iPhones

0:38:51around for testing with, you know, oh, I've got the old last year's OS on my last year's phone

0:38:57so that I can, oh, is this new? Is this feature new? What did this look like? Oh, here it is.

0:39:02And then I'll be like, wow, this scroll's slow. This is crazy. I had that experience this week.

0:39:07I'm going to be doing a video with my AirPods. I've been using AirPods Pro 2 ever since they

0:39:13came out. And remember when I got them and I wrote, I reviewed them very glowingly. It's one

0:39:17of my favorite Apple products. I think it's as much as people love AirPods, I honestly think

0:39:23they're vastly underrated as augmented reality devices that everybody, especially with the Pro

0:39:32versions that do the, and the Macs that do the advanced noise cancellation stuff, which is going

0:39:37to be a little bit more accurate. I don't have the beta software online, but anyway, I love my

0:39:42AirPods Pro 2. I'm glad I upgraded even though my AirPods Pro 1 were fine and not lost or not

0:39:50battery deficient. But I thought this definitely sounds better, especially the noise reduction.

0:39:55And I wear them as a pedestrian walking around Philadelphia 99% of the time, as my use of AirPods

0:40:01around the city. But last week I had to go somewhere. Where was I? I forget. I don't know.

0:40:09I had a doctor appointment and it's, I don't know, like a one mile walk. So it's like two

0:40:13miles round trip. And I had to leave because yeah, that's why I couldn't go look for my AirPods Pro 2.

0:40:21I could, I didn't know where they were and I thought crap, but I knew time-wise I needed to

0:40:26leave right now and sort of briskly walk to make it on time anyway. So I took my AirPods Pro 1,

0:40:32which were still had a charge and I knew where they were. They're in my office. My office is on

0:40:38the ground floor. They were easy to grab and I'd use them for a two mile round trip walk.

0:40:43Wow, do they sound terrible? I was blown away. They sound so, and it's podcasts, not music,

0:40:52just listening to podcasts. And it's not even the noise reduction. At first I was like, well,

0:40:56it's because the noise cancellation is not as advanced and it's not tuning out the traffic

0:41:01and the buses and the city noise as well. But even when I got to the doctor's office

0:41:05and was waiting in a quiet room and I'm just listening to podcasts and I'm like, these sound so

0:41:13tinny and thin. And I couldn't wait to get home and find my AirPods Pro 2, which were just like

0:41:19up in my bedroom or whatever, and then do a side-by-side. And I'm like, I'm blown away at how

0:41:24much better I now see AirPods Pro 2 are compared to when they were brand new. And I was impressed

0:41:32by them and thought, yeah, this is worth an upgrade, but not blown away. And I just thought

0:41:37I'd tuck that into the show. Yep, they're great. I don't think I've gone back, but it's hard to see

0:41:43in the moment, right? When you switch over, I agree switching back sometimes is the really,

0:41:48you see what you lose when you go backward and you're like, oh, okay, that's the difference

0:41:53there. I love them. Yeah, they're one of my favorite Apple products, I think ever. And I

0:41:57was super skeptical originally about them. I'm like, Apple headphones, come on. And the AirPods

0:42:01were great, but the AirPods Pro are the best. Yeah, that's what I don't travel with anything

0:42:07else at this point. And talk about a product that just looking at them side by side, I mean,

0:42:14obviously they're headphones. So looking at them isn't how you're supposed to judge them,

0:42:19but looking at them, boy, they sure don't look like a major upgrade. I mean, they look pretty

0:42:25much identical. It's a slightly different pattern of black on the white buds and they're slightly

0:42:32different ear cup rubber things that go in and the case is slightly different, but at a glance,

0:42:38it's impossible to tell them apart. It certainly doesn't look like it, but boy, do they sound

0:42:43different. And now it has me excited wondering where, when AirPods Pro 3 will come out, because

0:42:48if there is much of an improvement, boy, that's going to be something. I'm trying to think here.

0:42:54What else do we have? I guess we'll start going down the list. It's just one I want to get out

0:42:58of the way. It's a weird clickbait story. I put this in the notes. I don't know if you saw this,

0:43:03but my son, my son sent me this. He said, did you see Apple? That Apple is telling people not to

0:43:10sleep next to their iPhone when it's charging. And I thought that's insane. I can't believe my son is

0:43:17so illiterate that he would think that what I don't know what he read that gave him that impression.

0:43:21I was like, send me a link. He sent me a link on Yahoo news. And the headline is Apple says,

0:43:26don't sleep next to charging on phone. And I'm like, what you go through. And of course,

0:43:33Apple said no such thing. They said no such thing. The Apple actual support document,

0:43:38which I don't believe is new at all, says, here, I'm reading verbatim, avoid prolonged skin contact

0:43:45with the charging cable and connector when the charging cable is connected to a power source,

0:43:49because it may cause discomfort or injury. Well, I don't know about that, but then the next sentence,

0:43:56sleeping or sitting on the charging cable or connector should be avoided. Well,

0:44:02I don't know. That seems like good advice, right? Like this, I don't think it's a new document,

0:44:09how that got spun into Apple says, don't sleep next to a charging iPhone. I have no idea,

0:44:17but lo and behold, I found like two or three other stories now, like including one at the

0:44:22clickbait factory, the street.com more or less saying the same thing. Of course,

0:44:26the streets headline is even more clickbait. It's Apple issues, a surprise iPhone danger warning.

0:44:36I don't know what to do. Jason, I, you talked about this recently. I feel like

0:44:43SEO and broken media business models haven't just broken like Google searches are kind of broken

0:44:55now because they're full of garbage search for anything. And you'll get all these AI articles,

0:44:59or you'll get a search for a recipe and you'll get a blog post with 3000 words. And then the

0:45:03recipes at the bottom, like, and it's all SEO or search for an old CNET article and you won't find

0:45:08it because they deleted it because they think that it's SEO. But the one that, that really makes me

0:45:13dispirited is our people, professional media people, journalists, basically have apparently

0:45:21over the last few years, had it ground into them so much that you need to write clickbait headlines

0:45:28because the business model has been so embedded that the only way we make money is if somebody

0:45:34clicks through on the headline. So we have to get them to click and trick them in any way possible.

0:45:40And, and what really infuriates me is when it happens in a place where the business model does

0:45:46not require clickbait and they still do it because they've hired people who have grown up in this

0:45:53toxic clickbait environment. And my example that I texted to you last week is the San Francisco

0:46:00Chronicle, a website that is primarily for subscribers of its newspaper and website.

0:46:07And I am a subscriber. All their headlines are like, "This Bay Area City May Be Committing

0:46:14Horrible Racist Acts." And I mean, it's just like, guys, I pay for it. Just tell me what city it is

0:46:20so I can decide if I want to read it. Headlines and subheads are supposed to be relevant. They're

0:46:26supposed to make me want to read the story because they have informed me whether it's for me or not.

0:46:31And yet, and I feel like given their business model, I doubt that there's somebody saying,

0:46:38"You got to write a clickbait headline." I think it's people who just have survived the last 15

0:46:42years in the media and they don't understand that headlines shouldn't be like that. But I feel like

0:46:48these are all examples of how broken the whole media ecosystem has gotten because of the last

0:46:5510 or 15 years of the web. And now it's like, it doesn't even matter if you need the clicks.

0:47:00You're just going to write the story as if it was clickbait. Write the headline. It kills me.

0:47:04It's so bad. It's so bad. And this sleeping next to the iPhone thing, I hope it just,

0:47:09I'm wrong and that by the time people listen to this show or like a week or two, I just have a

0:47:15sick feeling though that this coming week is going to have a dozen more of these stories because it's

0:47:20too good to pass up. Can we make that the, like, can we do a hit clickbait like headline for this

0:47:26episode of the talk show? Can we call it like my iPhone burned my pillow? You won't believe how we

0:47:32got burned recording this episode. Right. This, this, this, yes, this object was set on fire by

0:47:39my iPhone. Won't believe it. It's really a pillow. It's like on the one hand, maybe me and you should

0:47:47be like, Hey, this just makes our work look better. You know, that our work stands out at all the

0:47:57places. I feel bad for these people. Like I see a lot of these, I don't know if you saw the timestamp

0:48:03on these. I'm not sure about that, but I, some of the worst stuff I see is on the weekend. And it's

0:48:09very clearly somebody who is a low paid person. Who's trying, just trying to make it. And they

0:48:16have, you know, that they've got basically a gun to their head saying, you got to do this many posts

0:48:20on the weekend because our staff's not here. So we're bringing you in to write these posts.

0:48:25And that's when I really see the worst. And it's because those people are desperate and they will

0:48:30do anything to fulfill their quota so that they can get paid. And they're not, they're not on the

0:48:36top of their game and they don't necessarily, they don't. And some of these stories, like you

0:48:40mentioned that one story that sort of ran with this and reran it, they don't want to know, right?

0:48:45Like they don't want to write the article that debunks the story. They just want to pass the

0:48:50story on with some rewritten headlines. Nothing makes me more dispirited than when I'm in a Slack

0:48:55or a discord and somebody posts a news story and it's from a website and I click through and I

0:48:59realize that all they're doing is rewriting the original news story that came from somewhere else.

0:49:04And it's like, why just linked to the real story. Like I know that this is from, we've got this

0:49:11covered or comic book fan number one.com. And it's like, yeah, that story was at variety. Can

0:49:18you just link to variety, please? Like they have a reporter who actually reported something,

0:49:23please. Can we link to that? It's it's, and it's, it's getting worse because I know you do the same

0:49:29thing I do is you're trying to hunt through. You're like, well, let me find the original.

0:49:33And they'll say it was originally reported by variety, but that's not the link. You have to

0:49:38go to like the next paragraph and they do have a link hidden somewhere, but it's not on the phrase

0:49:44as originally reported or first reported by variety. It's like, they're, they're making it

0:49:48even harder to, yeah, because they, they, they want, cause their SEO extends to all their links

0:49:56being self links. Right. And so the, on first reference, it'll be like, it's a story about

0:50:01some actor and the link will be to their tag page about that actor with all their other stories

0:50:05about that actor, because that's how they can build up this search referral power. Or at least

0:50:11they believe a consultant told them at one point several years ago that that's what they should do.

0:50:17And it's completely broken them now. And then you, cause you do, you want to find, I ended up doing

0:50:22a lot of Google searches where I put in the subject matter and variety or Hollywood reporter

0:50:28or whatever, to see if I can find what they're talking about. And, and invariably when it's a

0:50:34game of telephone where there's a clickbait article that's based on something out of context,

0:50:38and then it's rewritten, you have to, you have to go back several steps in order to get to

0:50:44something like a boring tech note on Apple's website. Yeah. Whole world's coming to an end,

0:50:50Mallory. I I'm hopeful that the, that the, some of this will get rewritten, that some, some of this,

0:50:59like now that there are websites that are more likely getting their money from people paying

0:51:05than from people coming in over the transom, that some, some of the people in charge will be like,

0:51:11please don't write that headline that way anymore. That's not what we do here. Right. Somebody has to

0:51:15stand up and say it because you've got people who spent their career having to write those bad

0:51:20headlines or writing those blog posts that feed. It's like, I can't investigate this or I won't get

0:51:26paid. I must just take it on face value because it's the only way I can get a post out of it.

0:51:30I hope that'll, that'll heal at least in some places, but I don't know. Maybe it's

0:51:34irreparably broken. I don't know. Right. It, it, it comes back to like my, my love of outlining

0:51:41and proper outlining, not just a word processor that can, has a feature to make bullets indent,

0:51:48but like an omni outliner type app or the new app from Jesse Gross, Jean, the task paper was probably

0:51:55best known for it as a Mac app called bike named after the bicycle for the mind thing I alluded to

0:52:02earlier, which is a really, really great new newish. It's like a year old now Mac outliner.

0:52:07That's a proper outliner. But new, I love Jesse gross, Jean trivia point,

0:52:11a distant cousin of my wife. They they share a great grandfather. It's wild. It's the name.

0:52:18Small, it's the name small world. Wait, wait, wait, Mac developers, the Jesse name or the gross

0:52:23Jean. My wife's maiden name is Grosjean. But that's only because her grandfather decided it

0:52:29would sound better if it was more French. Well, her grandfather, her great grandfather is gross

0:52:35Jean and that's Jesse's too. It's yeah. We, we went through this like 10 years ago. I'm like,

0:52:39how could it, it's gotta be right. And it actually, they're totally, they're totally related,

0:52:43but so I paid attention and bike is great. And that's the bicycle for the mind thing.

0:52:47The idea of doing a proper, I dare I say it sort of Dave Weiner, ask

0:52:51outliner as a way to structure your thoughts. Right. It with the hierarchy. And that's what

0:52:57a newspaper front page was is if you really were short on time, you could just read the headlines

0:53:04and you'd, you'd, you'd basically have an idea of what was important in the world, the nation and

0:53:10your local community. Most, most newspapers aren't nationally focused. And then if you have a little

0:53:17more time or about a particular story, there'd be a subhead, which would give you like a second

0:53:22level of information that you'd be fairly well informed, at least what's going on. And then if

0:53:28you really want the details, read the details and the newspaper. It's the inverted pyramid,

0:53:32right? The whole idea of in for people who don't know journalism is yeah, you read the headline,

0:53:37are you, are you committed? You read the subhead, are you committed? You read the lead,

0:53:40the first paragraph and literally journalists were always trained. The most important information goes

0:53:46in paragraph one. The second most goes in paragraph two and so on dating to the period of time when

0:53:52you would write these stories. And when they ran out of space, they would just cut the article at

0:53:56that point. So don't save your like big revelation for the end, because nobody will read that far.

0:54:02And that's totally true, but that was in an era where you could say like, I bought your newspaper

0:54:08and now I am not going to read all 12 of these stories. I'm going to read the four that appeal

0:54:12to me the most, but you're competing with yourself and the product was already purchased. And so

0:54:17you're performing ultimately it's a customer service thing, right? It's the, it's what we

0:54:21would say in the computers. We'd say it was like the user experience, which is you bought our

0:54:25product. We want you to get the most out of it by clearly labeling what all these articles are about

0:54:31and the free web completely broke that where now it was all just like, we just need to trick you

0:54:37into your browser, loading this page so that the ads will load so that we'll get credit for that.

0:54:42Right, right. Because in the newspaper printed newspaper era, if you had the newspaper in your

0:54:47hand, it was assumed you'd already purchased it, whether you're a subscriber or you bought it at

0:54:52the newsstand you probably had already purchased it. So you already had the whole package. And so

0:54:58they could treat you accordingly, but it's pretty sad.

0:55:01I mean, it's different from like headless body and topless bar. That's literally,

0:55:06that is marketing, right? That is a huge tabloid front page that is meant to be

0:55:10caught, catches your eye and you buy a copy on the newsstand. That's a little different or a

0:55:16magazine cover or something. But once you're inside, like, don't, I don't need to be tricked.

0:55:21Just tell me what it is. I just want to know what the story's about, please.

0:55:27For people who don't know the reference, I forget the actual details, but I just read that recently.

0:55:31I think, did I even link to it? But it was like the history of that headline.

0:55:34The guy who wrote that article died last year. I wrote the headline,

0:55:38died last year. He was one of their classic Newark Post headline writers. And yeah,

0:55:45headless body and topless bar, the best headline of all time.

0:55:49Yeah. But my favorite detail of the headline, and it really was, it was like a gruesome murder.

0:55:55But they actually sent somebody from the newsroom before they started printing it.

0:56:00They knew it was the greatest, maybe the greatest tabloid headline of all time.

0:56:04But they sent somebody to confirm that there was some semblance of topless dancing in that

0:56:11bar at some times like so that they still had the integrity that they wouldn't have run it.

0:56:16If it was like, well, there was some shady stuff going on in that bar, but

0:56:20no topless dancing. Like, no, there was. And it was like payphone, like boss, we got it.

0:56:25They definitely had topless dancing on Saturday nights. Go.

0:56:28Yeah, this is it. It's got to be a topless bar. Mr. Musetto cried.

0:56:33This is the greatest headline of my career. But the Post sent a reporter

0:56:37who phoned from Queens to say to the relief of all that topless it was. Amazing.

0:56:43And getting from Midtown or wherever the Post headquarters to Queens was no easy task.

0:56:48Yeah. But set a guy out there just for that.

0:56:50Just for that. But that's the integrity that even the New York Post, here we are

0:56:54singing the praises of the editorial and journalistic integrity of the New York Post.

0:56:58But that's where we are. Yeah. And that was a, I mean, that was

0:57:02in a day where that was a really tough thought over newspaper markets. So there's a lot of

0:57:07competition. And that, I mean, it was the clickbait of its day, those covers that were

0:57:10going to sell to commuters who were going into the city or walking down the block.

0:57:15And you had the Post and the Daily News. And then probably like, if you're in Long Island,

0:57:20at least you had Newsday and you had the Times, obviously, and you're trying to figure out,

0:57:24does it catch my eye? Do I want to put down a quarter or whatever for it? And

0:57:28one of my journalism school professors was the city editor at the Daily News for many years.

0:57:32And I enjoyed the contempt he had for the New York Times and how he was really committed to

0:57:37doing good journalism and putting in the work and doing the footwork, but also realizing that

0:57:43you were trying to give people something that they wanted to see or wanted to read.

0:57:47Speaking of journalism, we can move on and talk about the Disney empire.

0:57:52Yes. ABC News.

0:57:54ABC News. ESPN.

0:57:55ESPN. Let's talk about it.

0:57:56Actual, you don't think of Disney and journalism, but it's a big part of their business as it

0:58:02stands. You and I both simultaneously, although me slower and behind you as usual, wrote about the

0:58:11sort of, what would you call it? It's not a rumor even.

0:58:14Yeah. It's speculation, possibly motivated by some insiders information, but it was,

0:58:20yeah, it's basically this piece by Kim Masters and the Hollywood reporter that basically says,

0:58:25this is an old rumor that everybody in the entertainment industry is tired of hearing,

0:58:31but it feels, I think it's a really well framed article speaking of like good journalism versus

0:58:36clickbait. She says, when I talk to insiders, this old thing that didn't make any sense

0:58:42seems like it might make more sense now. And it all is swirling around Bob Iger returning to Disney

0:58:50and being under kind of like a lot of pressure to change the business and get it back in growth mode.

0:58:56And that people within Hollywood think he might be positioning it for a sale, in which case he

0:59:02might sell off some of his assets in order to make it more, a better position for a sale, perhaps even

0:59:07to a specific buyer like Apple. And then second, this thing that I hadn't really thought about

0:59:12until the last maybe month, which is the idea that technology companies are so much bigger,

0:59:18more profitable and have so much more market cap than entertainment companies. And one of these

0:59:23entertainment industry insiders quoted in the Hollywood reporter story says, it's inevitable

0:59:29that the tech industry is going to eat these things because entertainment has now just become

0:59:34streaming content. And that's part of the tech bubble. And that they said in the end, all that

0:59:39will be left is Amazon, Apple, Netflix, and one other from an entertainment company. And if that's

0:59:45the case, I think you and I look at it and say, well, if they're going to eat the entertainment

0:59:52industry alive, Apple and Disney certainly seem like they're the best partners in terms of their

0:59:58corporate culture and their fit. And I think that is, I think that's fundamentally true. I think

1:00:04it's arguable that Iger would want Apple to buy them. I always just come back to the thing that

1:00:10I know has stopped you too, which is, but why would Apple pay a hundred or $150 billion for

1:00:17some or all of Disney? That's a harder question to answer, right? I would just want to, before I

1:00:23forget, I just want to, and this is where I was like, I got to get Jason on the show because of

1:00:28this, but I just, I saw, I was still writing my piece. I saw that yours was out because I got

1:00:35bored and was looking at my feed reader. And as soon as I saw the headline, I just go in like,

1:00:40nope. Yeah. It was like, I can't read his piece because I don't want it to pollute my thoughts.

1:00:44And I'm so glad I didn't because you tied it together with the Steve Jobs analogy of the Apple

1:00:51exists at the intersection of technology and the liberal arts and Disney does too. And it's like,

1:00:56it really, and that, I think about it, Pixar imagineers at the, at the parks, like the ILM,

1:01:03like there's so many the, the, the new ILM like stagecraft thing where they're using like

1:01:07a gaming engine to beam. They put images on an LCD screen and they shoot it like it's on a set or out

1:01:15in, in the world. But it's actually like all of that is this incredible. Our, our friend Todd

1:01:20Visserie, right. Who works at ILM. Like these are people who love film, they're creative artists,

1:01:26and they're also highly technical and understand what needs to be done on the technical side

1:01:30in order to make the creative art better. Like they are. People are like, Oh, Disney and

1:01:36theme parks and Apple doesn't make any sense. And I'm like, I don't know. Imagineering seems to be

1:01:41exactly what Apple does on an abstract level. And so like, that's why I say, I think culturally,

1:01:48they're actually pretty close. And of course jobs was a big, was when he sold Pixar, he,

1:01:53he sold it to Disney. So that is a Steve Jobs company that's inside Disney. He became a leading

1:01:59shareholder of Disney. Eiger was on Apple's board. Like there are so many connections here that like,

1:02:06I, I think that if Apple were to buy Disney, they culturally would make it work. I don't think it

1:02:14would be like an AOL time Warner thing where, where they're like, Oh my God, we can't put these

1:02:19two companies together. I think that they are, they might be the two companies. Disney might be

1:02:26the company that is most like Apple in the world. Maybe Nintendo is the only other competitor here

1:02:30that would be like that. But like they, they see the world and I think a similar way. And that's,

1:02:38I think that's interesting when you, when you're musing about this, when you're speculating about

1:02:42it, I'm not sure, again, it makes the case that they should buy them, but I think if you can see

1:02:49it right, you can see that resonance between them. There's like an unquenchable thirst for higher

1:02:56production values and it defines which company am I talking about? It's both right. And it doesn't

1:03:02matter every time there's a breakthrough, whether it's Apple with the iPhone. And it was like,

1:03:10it was only the fourth model that went to the retina displays that quadrupled the number of

1:03:16pixels per inch at a time when the first three iPhones were considered super high res, super

1:03:23smooth scrolling, beautiful displays, unquenchable. And I'll throw a shout out and I jotted it down on

1:03:30paper. I'll probably hopefully put it in the actual show notes, but there's a Neil Gabler

1:03:33biography of Walt Disney, the man, which is one of my, usually I'm either bored to tears by a

1:03:40biography and never even finished chapter three, or I gobbled the whole book up and this was one of

1:03:45them. But like the early years of animated films, they were a sensation. It was like a technological,

1:03:53I mean, motion pictures were a sensation. I mean, people screamed when the first one that was widely

1:03:59distributed showed a train coming towards the screen because nobody had ever seen anything

1:04:03like this before. And they thought people panicked and literally panicked and thought something might

1:04:08burst through the screen. People going to the movies on Saturdays gave people something to do

1:04:14and see that they'd never had before. But the way that Disney, the Disney studio never stopped

1:04:22pushing the state of the art forward technically, they did this, I think it was with Snow White,

1:04:27which again, just doing a feature length animated movie like Snow White, everybody was like,

1:04:34almost again, like Apple, nobody's going to buy that. That's pan. Everybody thought cartoons were

1:04:39something. Yes, kids like them for five minutes before the real movie, but nobody's going to watch

1:04:44a 90 minute cartoon. And of course, yeah, that turned out the opposite. Kids love big, long

1:04:50feature length cartoons, but they invented so many technological things to fake 3D and depth.

1:04:57Right. And multi-plane camera, the whole thing. They actually, I don't think it's there anymore,

1:05:03but Disney, the Hollywood Studios park in Florida used to have one of the attractions. And again,

1:05:11it's like, guess which, how many people in the Gruber family liked going to see the Walt Disney

1:05:18museum in the theme park? It was, I'll tell you it was 33%, but they had that multi-plane

1:05:29contraption. They had the actual one or one of several that they used and I'd read about it.

1:05:35And it sounded fascinating. It wasn't like, Oh, and then they invented that. And then they stopped.

1:05:39It was just onward, onward, onward. When the theme parks are the same way, there's this culture,

1:05:44you could see it. One thing I tried to look up and I couldn't find it. And so maybe I'm imagining it,

1:05:51but it would have happened around 1994, 95, 96, when Apple was the bad years for Apple.

1:06:03Obviously, I mean, it was a whole side note, but the, I think the closest Apple ever came to getting

1:06:09acquired by another company was Sun Microsystems who easily could have afforded it at the time.

1:06:15And Scott McNeely was like, but why, why would we buy a company with no technology we wanted?

1:06:20So they, they passed more or less out of ambivalence, not, not out of price tag.

1:06:25Talk about like, where, where would the whole computing world be today? Who knows? But I seem

1:06:32to recall though, that at that time when Apple was in financial trouble, that there was idle

1:06:37speculation of this sort, that was Disney should buy Apple. Do you recall that? I can't, I searched

1:06:44for it. And because 94, 95, 96 was so early on the web, nothing that was on the web persist from that

1:06:53time or very little of it. It would have been in print, but I seem to recall. And I don't think it

1:06:58was, somebody must have speculated at the time because at the time Apple was in trouble and

1:07:02they're like, well, who should buy them? I seem to recall there were some people arguing, maybe just

1:07:07spouting off, pulling it out of their own butt, but saying Disney should buy Apple. And it's like,

1:07:12these companies ebb and flow over decades and what comes around goes around. I don't think,

1:07:18I don't anticipate a time 20, 30 years from now where Disney once again would be big enough to buy

1:07:25Apple. I think that's sort of over, but it, it, it, it's been in the air for a long time. I also,

1:07:33I wonder, it was not just that Jobs sold Pixar to Disney. It's that I don't know how, how many

1:07:40studios they seriously shopped around where they're, who they were going to collaborate with

1:07:46other than Disney. Right. I mean, it was like Disney and who was second choice at the time

1:07:50for, well, they had, they had, Disney had an exclusive distribution arrangement with Pixar

1:07:56that they were going to have to run out the clock on. So I think there was this thought that they

1:07:59were the only real suitable partner since they were yoked to them. Yeah. But, but, but when they

1:08:05made that agreement, right before Toy Story even existed, I don't really think Steve Jobs and John

1:08:12Lasseter and everybody else in the Pixar brain trust really wanted to do this with anybody else.

1:08:18I mean, you know, Jobs of course is a famously good negotiator. I'm sure he did talk to,

1:08:23I don't know, Universal or Warner Brothers or whoever else might've possibly done it, but it

1:08:30just, even before they sold the company to them, just the whole idea, it just fit, it fit in a way

1:08:36that it just wouldn't have been the same otherwise. There was just a, Oh yeah, this is exactly,

1:08:41this is, this is an out of character for Disney to, to make these movies like Toy Story and Bugs

1:08:49Life and Monsters Inc. These are, these feel like they should be Disney movies in a way that even

1:08:56Disney owning Star Wars and Lucasfilm, I'm not saying that's unnatural, but it's nowhere near

1:09:01as natural as the Pixar sub-brand of Disney. Cause it's just kids and fantasy and stuff like that.

1:09:10And this has gone on. Yeah. I don't know about the certain times, but these rumors have been

1:09:15out there on both sides. And today it's more referred to as Apple buying Disney. Whereas

1:09:20back in the day, I think there was a talk about a merger. Yeah. And even Iger said that he thought

1:09:24that that might happen, but today Apple has just in the last 10 years gotten so much bigger that

1:09:30that's not how it would be. Yeah. I, I, and I think I'm sort of, I've sort of been thinking about this

1:09:36a lot broader term just as the overall, where are we as an industry and this whole big tech moment.

1:09:43Honestly, I really think it boils down to something very simple, which is that computers are

1:09:51as big at a revolution to society as the industrial revolution was it. It's not like

1:09:59a continuation of it or, or a tweak. It is that kind of step change. And I, I think

1:10:07in hindsight, everybody sees what the industrial revolution did to the world,

1:10:13but I'm sure that at the time in the 1860s and seventies and eighties, it was underestimated

1:10:21by the adults who grew up pre-industrial revolution. And it was really only the

1:10:27industrialists themselves who fully understood it. And I think the same thing's going on with

1:10:33the computerization of everything where people who don't really understand computers just

1:10:40underestimate how profoundly they're taking over everything. And naturally it's, it's almost

1:10:47inevitable that companies and very different approaches to the computerization of blank,

1:10:54Apple and Amazon are very different businesses. They all are to some extent. None of them are

1:11:00quite like the other Microsoft, Google, Amazon, and let's count meta slash Facebook amongst them

1:11:07as one of the others in there. You can't look at any two of them and say, well, those two

1:11:12are doing the exact same thing. They're just arch rivals like Coke and Pepsi. No, they're all

1:11:18sort of different, but fundamentally they're all humongous because the computerization of blank

1:11:23is just maybe two orders of magnitude at least, or Apple is a 10 or 11 times bigger than Disney

1:11:32by market cap. It's an entire order of magnitude. It's it makes sense that, that it's the computer

1:11:38companies that have the money to do it. And I just don't think, I do think if Disney were to

1:11:44continue to shrink in market cap stock price and, and investors were so up in arms, Disney

1:11:53investors were so up in arms that if sale was sort of forced upon the company, I mean, Apple makes

1:12:00more sense than anybody in terms of who Disney would want. It's really just, would Apple want

1:12:05to do it? And I just, I that's where I just go back to is it just seems out of character for Apple in

1:12:11a way that it's not for Microsoft, right? Like Microsoft does things like buys Activision

1:12:16Blizzard for 69 billion and sure it's bold. It's not like they took it lightly. It's not like,

1:12:22ah, what the heck? Sure. Go, sure. Phil Spencer, go spend $69 billion on a game studio. I'm sure

1:12:27they, they, but they do things like that. Apple doesn't, the 3 billion, only 3 billion acquisition

1:12:34of beats is by far their biggest acquisition. So I agree with you. And yet this is where

1:12:39I have to say Apple has changed. Their objectives are not necessarily what you would say as like,

1:12:47they're the most profitable company among the most in history, their most valuable company in

1:12:53history. What is left for them to do? And the answer is, well, wall street says, keep going,

1:12:57right? Like that, that, and that is just a fundamental of our economic system. So I would

1:13:02say they're huge. Where do they go from here? What other worlds do they have to conquer?

1:13:06And they have done so well with services. You and I have talked about this services has become.

1:13:11It, I die a little as an old time Mac user. I die a little inside. Every time that Tim Cook comes on

1:13:16the call and says, Apple's special brand is a combination of hardware and software and services.

1:13:21And I'm like, that third one, I don't know about that, but it is clearly a huge part of what they

1:13:26do. What I would say to you is if you're feeling the pressure of wall street to keep growing,

1:13:32and you're like, how do we keep doing that? Well, services has been a way we do it.

1:13:36Apple has taken the Apple path up to now for TV plus, which is they are putting in a lot of money

1:13:46and they're building a catalog, but there's no back catalog to speak of some movies come and go,

1:13:50but there's really no catalog to speak of. They're building it. And they, they are a nice little

1:13:55boutique HBO ask service and it's great. I think they've done a very good job. I think it is

1:14:00exceeded all expectations of what a Zach and Jamie, who they hired from Sony have done. However,

1:14:06if you, if you say, okay, you're going to still make, how do we grow that? How do we expand that

1:14:14business and how do we scale it? Cause it is not making TV shows is not necessarily a thing that

1:14:19really scales. We can give Zach and Jamie billions of dollars every year, but it's only going to be

1:14:24a pretty linear growth. And if you want to grow services massively over the next five years,

1:14:30how do you do that? The answer is probably buy a streaming service and all of their intellectual

1:14:36property, right? Or at least that's an answer. And that's what gives me pause is the idea that

1:14:42as nice a thing as Apple TV plus is they look at that and say, yeah, but you could just buy Disney

1:14:50and Hulu and Disney plus and star Wars and Pixar and, and all and Marvel and, and you've got,

1:14:58and these parks, which actually they don't scale, but they are very profitable. And you like that,

1:15:04right? And you can just go down the list. That's what gives me pause is not Apple following what

1:15:10we think of as the Apple playbook, but Apple saying, Oh, services is good is growing great,

1:15:17but what we really should do is take a quantum leap. And if they decide that that's when they

1:15:22buy, if not Disney, I think they buy some, some intellectual property and some services

1:15:29just to give them a big leap where suddenly it's not 20 nice TV shows and some movies,

1:15:35but it's literally all of Marvel and, and star Wars is in there now. And it's a much more relevant.

1:15:41They were, I think more than just rumors, but obviously Apple didn't say anything, but

1:15:47by again, probably Hollywood reporter and variety reporting, both of which again, it,

1:15:52as two long-term rivals, like Pepsi and Coke, it, it is odd to me that they both are still

1:16:02great publications, but I think one or both of them are just basically an end when Amazon bought

1:16:08United artists, Apple would apparently sniffed around it to buy that. And the key franchise

1:16:15that United artists owns is the James Bond franchise near and dear to my heart. Perhaps

1:16:21even nearer and dearer to Phil Schiller's heart. Again, I don't think those MGM,

1:16:25the MGM assets, right? Which went to Amazon. It doesn't matter how big a fan of James Bond,

1:16:31Phil Schiller is. I'm sure he wasn't advocating in their Monday morning executive meeting. We should

1:16:35buy them just so that we can get the rights to the James Bond theme song, but you know,

1:16:41Apple's sniffs around for stuff like that. I mean, it, it makes sense. You know, why not?

1:16:46They're in this streaming business and if the price is right, they would do it. I guess the

1:16:50other thing that strikes me about that with, with the services narrative and I have that same,

1:16:56it's not a queasy, well, it's an uneasy feeling, right? Because it's like, you're, you're the more

1:17:04Apple relies on the services stuff. It's towing the line with the dark side, right? And it's,

1:17:12all of a sudden, everybody who's an enthusiast has their complaints about things that is this an ad

1:17:21or not? You bought a new iPhone and you didn't get Apple care plus and 30 days after you buy it.

1:17:28Now you've got a red dot on the settings app that's saying, Hey, you've still got so many

1:17:33months left to buy Apple care plus for this. Or if you don't subscribe to Apple's media streaming,

1:17:40their own ones, Apple music and Apple TV plus and Apple one, right? Which includes the fitness and

1:17:48stuff. They put things in the operating system that you pretty hard not to call an ad, even

1:17:54though they don't look like an ad it's, it's a form of advertising to take a row of the settings

1:18:00app at the top. Where did they draw the line? And you can see, I mean, and people who complain about

1:18:06it, I think have valid points and people who think they've crossed the line may not be wrong.

1:18:12But I think even people who think they've crossed the line have to admit they haven't,

1:18:17they haven't become untethered in that direction, right? They're not flying out of control in the

1:18:25way that the latest versions of windows, there's some crazy stuff in a factory, fresh install of

1:18:31windows on like a $400 PC with the number of ads. And I they've gone back to, I think they've gone

1:18:38back to, you have to get a different version of windows to install apps from outside their app

1:18:43store. And it's like, you can just reinstall it over. It's not like with the iPad or iPhone where

1:18:50you can just install an alternate version of iOS to get a version that lets you go outside the app

1:18:56store. You can do that with windows. It's still just a PC. You can put a full version of windows

1:19:01there, but Microsoft has gone so far in that direction in a way that it's like, take a look at

1:19:08where the rest of the industry is if you really want to bitch about apples, but I get it. And you

1:19:15have to say, when you follow the, the, the, I always just complete this. I just lean on six

1:19:21colors coverage of Apple's quarterly financials. I just wait to you post and then I linked to your

1:19:27but I follow them closely enough to know that they didn't lock into this. Tim Cook. I mean, it is

1:19:36as a pure CEO move. It is a strategy that he laid out. He explained it years ago,

1:19:43eight years ago, something he was like, we're going to whatever it was triple our services

1:19:47revenue in the next four years. He said he, which they beat by a mile, but yeah, he laid it out in

1:19:52that one quarterly call where he's like, this is what we're going to do. This is our area of growth

1:19:56because it was a time when the iPhone revenue was kind of flat and everybody was like, how are you

1:20:00going to grow? Cause we want to see growth and he's like services. That's where it's going to be.

1:20:04And that's what gives me pause when people say Apple wouldn't do X, right? Cause it's like

1:20:08Apple hasn't done X so far maybe, but who's to say like this, what decisions will they make?

1:20:16And I know that when you and Ben Thompson talk on dithering about this, like it is,

1:20:21it has been learned now by every streaming service that advertising is more profitable

1:20:28than having people pay for an ad free streaming service. And that's why Disney and Netflix and

1:20:33everybody else is creating ad versions of their services and then ramping up the price of the

1:20:38ad free version, because if they don't ramp it up, they're actually making less money from people

1:20:43paying them more than from people paying them less. And I wrote a piece of Mac world about this,

1:20:48like three or four months ago, that was basically, it is inevitable that Apple TV plus will have an

1:20:52ad tier and it is, it just is. And that's so it's like, well, would Apple do that? It's like, well,

1:20:57they already have an ad business. There's already a, they have a vice senior vice president or

1:21:00whatever of advertising who is who has said that he's going to grow that business. Most of it is in

1:21:05like app store search and stuff now, but clearly they're going to go into this, into this business

1:21:11of, of TV advertising. And you think, well, Apple's never going to do that, but they are.

1:21:15And, and I also hear sometimes like people were like, Oh, they're not going to be interested in

1:21:19ESPN. They have a gambling partnership that they just did for ESPN bet. And so that takes it off

1:21:24limits. It's like, I was watching Friday night baseball this week. And not only is the pregame

1:21:30show, have a segment about your betting line, but during the game, among of the odds of like

1:21:36chance that they'll get a hit chance, they'll get on base chance. They'll strike out. One of them

1:21:40was just straight up odds on the over under of the game in progress, right? That is an Apple

1:21:48commission and you can blame it on the MLB network that produces it. But like that stats company

1:21:52that's doing those stats, they only do that on Apple TV. Plus they have a deal with Apple and,

1:21:57and Apple's not like, no, no, no, don't pretend that the gambling doesn't exist. The over and

1:22:02under doesn't matter. Like, no, it's there. It's right there. So be careful when you say

1:22:09Apple wouldn't do it or Apple has never done it because it doesn't, maybe they have, and maybe

1:22:15they're trying stuff, but also you never know, like Apple would never produce TV shows and movies.

1:22:21Apple would never have a fitness feature where they have literally Apple employees who are

1:22:26fitness trainers in a studio in Santa Monica, like Apple would never until they do. And that's the,

1:22:32that's the part that gives me pause. It's like, I know they've never done it before, but I don't

1:22:37know. I mean, given the right circumstances, they might. Yeah. And it's the best way I can put it is

1:22:42I'll use two analogies. There's dams crack and then they burst. And and then there's the

1:22:48Hemingway bankruptcy thing. How did he very slowly and then all at once slowly and then,

1:22:55and then quickly, we have all sorts of other stuff to talk about here, but we obviously

1:23:01people who are familiar with your appearances on my show here know that we love, we love sports

1:23:05and we love TV sports. It it's just unbelievable how the dam broke on gambling with professional

1:23:14sports. And again, it is the computerization of everything. It's online gambling. This never would

1:23:20have happened. There's no, in my opinion, there is no roll of the roll of the dice for alternate

1:23:28versions of the 20th century where, where sports gambling is legal in, I don't know how many states

1:23:35it's up to now, but I think it's most of the country you can gamble on sports legally. There's

1:23:41no way that that happens before the internet. It just, it just wasn't true. I mean, New Jersey

1:23:46had casinos in the late seventies at a time when the only only state in the whole country where

1:23:53you could gamble at all legally was Nevada. And then Atlantic city opened real casinos in like

1:24:001977 or 78, but left out sports, which because it, it, it was just so verboten and they were like,

1:24:10New Jersey sports gambling. No way like forget about it. There's the idea because they were

1:24:16at least the idea was, and I think it's true in real casinos. The blackjack games are on the

1:24:23level that roulette tables. They, the casinos want them perfectly fair. They, they don't want them

1:24:28to be crooked because the rules of the game, give them the edge. They don't need them to be crooked,

1:24:34but the fear with sports is that you introduce gambling and all of a sudden point shaving,

1:24:41fixing games, it's all that. And we're seeing some scandals with college sports players and coaches.

1:24:49There was, I forget which some obscure NCAA team, the coach tried to bet. Did you see that story?

1:24:55It was some, he tried it. He had like a friend tried to bet a hundred thousand dollars on a game

1:25:01where there was only like $500 grand total bet. And they were like, sir, that's an unusually large

1:25:07wager. I mean, we're going to have to call a manager. And he said to them, don't worry. I have

1:25:12inside information. Yeah. Yeah. Cause the coach had told him that the starting pitcher or something

1:25:16wasn't going to pitch. And yeah. And literally his excuse for trying to place this enormous wager on

1:25:23an obscure college baseball game was don't worry. I have, I have inside information. Yeah. That'll

1:25:29get them to accept your bet. That it's that insider info is going to make sure that you

1:25:34have to pay. I've mentioned this before, or I remember one thing I noticed for years and

1:25:40years, cause I've always been interested in sports betting. Even when I couldn't do it legally

1:25:44was Al Michaels has always obviously been interested in it. Famous, the Dean of TV play

1:25:50by play announcers at this point, but he would often at the end of a, like a football game with

1:25:56a 13 point lead. So the game isn't really up in the air, but somebody kicks a field goal at the

1:26:01end that crosses the over underline. And he'd be like, well, there's some people out there who are

1:26:06pretty happy about that field goal. And it's like, if you knew you knew, but he couldn't even say

1:26:11that's what put it over the, it was a 51 point over underline and it went from 48 total points

1:26:16scored to 51 or something like that. He couldn't say that he would just say, ah, there's some,

1:26:22some, some TV viewers out in Nevada who were interested in that field goal. And it was just,

1:26:27you just daintily touch on it. And now the halftime show is brought to you by FanDuel

1:26:32and they've got people begging you to place bets on the second half in TV commercials.

1:26:40I often brought this up. My family has gone on several Disney cruises over the years, cruise

1:26:45ships, as far as I know, every major cruise line, every cruise ship in the world has a casino

1:26:50somewhere on the ship because guess what? They make money. And once you're three miles out at sea,

1:26:56you're, you're only covered by international lawsuit. It's legal. Guess whose cruise ships

1:27:01don't have casinos? Disney. But to me, and this gets to the, Hey, if Apple did buy Disney,

1:27:10they probably keep them wholly intact as Disney. Disney, they own ESPN. ESPN is in totally full on

1:27:20into sports gambling in all the ways you, we just talked about, but there's no mouse logo on ESPN.

1:27:29Right? Exactly. Different brand, different rules. It's a different brand, different rules. And

1:27:33look at the way Apple's treated Beats headphones. Right? I there's obviously some engineer that's,

1:27:40it's not like some kind of isolated team. They get the same W one W two chips and integrate with the

1:27:47OS in the way that the only other brand of headphones that do are the AirPods that we

1:27:52talked about earlier on the show. But the industrial design of beats headphones,

1:27:56they don't look like Apple products. They look like beats products.

1:27:59Right. And they have, and beats has like a name image and licensing program with college athletes

1:28:05now where they're like given paying. Cause you can do that. Now you can pay college athletes to wear

1:28:10your headphones in this case. And like that's, and, and I would put that in the category of Apple

1:28:15would never write like Apple would never well beats is owned by Apple and beats is paying college

1:28:20athletes to wear their headphones. And that's the thing. Like, so, so I would argue whatever five,

1:28:25seven years ago, if I said, Oh, a couple of Sony executives, Jamie Ehrlich and Zach van Amburg. Oh,

1:28:33yeah. Like they're going to get hired by Apple and have their own offices in LA, but it's still Apple

1:28:37and they're going to report to Eddie Q and they're going to make movies and TV shows and win awards.

1:28:41Oh, Apple would never do that. That sounds ridiculous. Right. Except that's literally what

1:28:45happened. And, and I think, again, I'm not, I'm not trying to make the case that Apple should buy

1:28:52Disney here. I'm saying that I feel like a lot of people, I went on a rant about this in my podcast

1:28:57with my curly upgrade of like, I fear that a lot of people have a vision of Apple in their head.

1:29:03That is a little bit out of date because the Apple of today is so huge and they are, they,

1:29:08their tendrils are expanding into so many different areas. And it's very easy to say,

1:29:12Oh, that that's beyond like, Apple would never do that. Apple would never own a theme park. It's

1:29:17like, well, but like theme parks are very profitable and are very technological. And

1:29:24there's a lot of ways to fuss over the consumer experience and take and make a lot of money from

1:29:29people. Right. It's like, what part of that is not Apple, right? Like the theme park part,

1:29:33but not the other parts. And, and they have shown the ability to change in ways that are surprising,

1:29:40like having an entire entertainment wing that's run by intent entertainment executives. And yeah,

1:29:45they report to Eddie, but like Eddie's not ordering the shows, right? Zach and Jamie are

1:29:50ordering the shows. Eddie's like working with them at a high level and setting their budget or

1:29:55whatever. That's the part of it. That's like, I know, I know it's weird, but just like beats

1:30:01is doing its own thing in some areas, a Disney brand and an ESPN brand and anything that they

1:30:06would want to want to keep, they can set some rules. It's too easy and too facile, I think,

1:30:13to say, Oh no, but Apple would never be involved with gambling or it doesn't make any sense. Like

1:30:18in the context of ESPN, maybe it does make sense, but that doesn't necessarily mean that it makes

1:30:23sense that to put a casino at Disneyland, right? Like probably not, probably not that.

1:30:29Jason Tucker Right. Disney's not going to do that, but,

1:30:32and Apple is not going to make, and speaking of physical infrastructure and building out real

1:30:38world places in the year 2000, people thought it was crazy that Apple was building out its own

1:30:42retail stores. Why would a computer maker do that? Like Gateway, even their closing stores. So why

1:30:47would Apple, who has no idea what they're doing with retail do this? That doesn't make any sense.

1:30:51Well, today we have an entire generation of adults, my college-age son, I don't think could

1:30:58believe that you couldn't just go to the Apple store to get your iPhone fixed.

1:31:03Dave Korsuns I don't know if you've noticed this,

1:31:05but I've noticed this, that there are, there are certain people who listen to our shows and read

1:31:09what we write and all of that, who are vociferous defenders of Apple. And we'll say like, Apple,

1:31:15Apple has to have a reason for this. Apple can essentially like they're, they're, they're fans

1:31:21and that's fine, but they're like, Apple could do anything. And yet then you say something about

1:31:25like, well, why didn't Apple do this? And the response is, Oh, Apple could never do that. That's

1:31:31too hard. And it's like, well, wait a second, which is, are they brilliant and everything they

1:31:34do is right. Or are they incapable of solving a user interface problem in one of their platforms?

1:31:40Right. And I, I am a believer that Apple is incredibly capable of, of solving hard problems

1:31:47if they matter. And if they want to do them, this is one of those things where it's like,

1:31:52I just don't believe Apple would never, because I've seen it right. Retail is such a great example.

1:31:57It's like Apple would never Apple. Why would they do an MP3 player? Right. Like again,

1:32:02Apple would never until they do it. And then you, you say, Oh, of course. And so I'm not saying

1:32:08they will. I'm just saying maybe think for, instead of being negative about it,

1:32:14stop for a second and consider what if Apple owned Marvel and Pixar, Pixar and Star Wars and

1:32:22Disney plus and Hulu, and what would they do? And what would that mean? You could view it as like,

1:32:28is it a good deal or a bad deal? Is it worth the money? But just think for a moment about like,

1:32:32isn't that would be interesting. And it's not so far afield to take us all the way back to

1:32:37that Hollywood reporter story. It used to be ludicrous. Now I look at it and I'm like, maybe,

1:32:43maybe there it's maybe the biggest financial one in history is well, blah, blah, blah. You know,

1:32:50cell phones are computers. Apple makes good computers and Apple makes good minutes, but

1:32:54blah, blah, blah. They're never going to do it because they have to go through the carriers.

1:32:57Right. That was the thing. The argument pre-iPhone ended with, well, Apple's never going to do this

1:33:03because can you even imagine Steve jobs working with cell phone carriers and let alone in America,

1:33:08let alone all around the world. Well, guess what worked out. They did it. And they had, and, and,

1:33:15and there's this moment again, it's that idea that like Apple is amazing, but they, they, they,

1:33:19they certainly can't do that. It's like, they certainly can't work with. Dozens of carriers

1:33:23across the world and all sorts of different markets. And it's like, well, they, they do,

1:33:27they, they do. I remember even when the IMAX were coming out, the new IMAX, the M1 IMAX,

1:33:33I remember somebody sort of saying, Oh, you know, they can't do like all those different colors.

1:33:38Cause think of how many skews there would be. And it's like, they did, they did seven, six colors

1:33:44and silver, seven colors and color match cables and color match keyboards and color match track

1:33:50pads and color match mice, every one, a different skew. And they put it in their channel and it's

1:33:55all over the world online. And a lot of them in stores and they did that and they do the colors

1:34:00for the like, yes, I know that it's really hard and it seems like, well, why would you do that?

1:34:06And the answer is if Apple thinks it's important, they will make it happen. They will find a way.

1:34:10Let me take a break here and thank our good friends at Memberful. Oh, Memberful, Memberful.

1:34:16If you're a creator, this is where you go and you can set up a membership system for your audience.

1:34:23And they have a whole team that is ready to simplify the, maybe you've already got something

1:34:27in place. You just want to take it to the next level. Maybe you're just starting out.

1:34:31They've got everything you need to grow your revenue with Memberships. The most important

1:34:36thing I can say about Memberful as a customer of many, many Memberful creators and sites is that

1:34:43Memberful stays in the background. You don't know Memberful is there any more than you know

1:34:47who their web host provider is or what brand of pants they wear. Practically you, the owner of

1:34:53the creative site or whatever it is, maintain full creative control over everything you present. You

1:35:02own the membership list so that if you ever decide to go elsewhere, you just take your membership

1:35:08list with you. They pay you directly to your Stripe account. Everything is right there in your

1:35:14control. They're just there to supply all the stuff you need to make it easy. And they make money when

1:35:20you make money. That's it. And they're there to help you with ideas or strategies for how to grow.

1:35:26They have experience, obviously, with all the sites that are already using Memberful.

1:35:32Everything you need. Check out. Easy to use customer member portal so members can go in

1:35:37and change their email address if they need to change their email address, update their

1:35:40credit card, all of that sort of stuff. The transactional emails, the receipts,

1:35:45a membership dashboard where you can go to see everybody who's your member. They've got analytics

1:35:51that give you easy, up-to-date, in-depth view of what's working, what's not, where you should put

1:35:57your emphasis, where you should steer your future example. They let you create things like members

1:36:03only podcasts near and dear to probably everybody who's listening to this hard. I don't know if

1:36:08there's anybody listening to this who's not listening to some members only podcasts. And

1:36:12there are some people who are on today's episode who have members only podcasts. It's a big deal.

1:36:17So where do you go? Diversify your revenue stream with membership at Memberful. Six Colors is one

1:36:25of the places. Is the incomparable Memberful too? Yep. I have two different Memberful things and we

1:36:31use them for both and they both do a great job. This is pure serendipity. This is not why Jason's

1:36:37on the show, but I'm a member of Six Colors happily paying. I think, I don't know, maybe you sent me a

1:36:44freebie, but I would happily pay so you should cancel my freebie if it's free. Anyway, anything

1:36:49you need. Newsletters, podcasts, gift subscriptions, Apple Pay support, it's all there. Get started for

1:36:55free with no credit card required. Go to memberful.com. Memberful.com/talkshow.

1:37:04Memberful.com/talkshow. Oh, what a great service. I like it when it's serendipity with the

1:37:13guests in a service like that. No, they've served me well. What else did we coincide with this week?

1:37:20The iMac turned 25 and we both wrote about that. You wrote a terrific piece for

1:37:26The Verge of all places. Yeah. Caught me by surprise with that one. I ran into those guys at WWDC

1:37:33and they said, "Hey, it's the 25th anniversary of the iMac this summer. Would you like to write

1:37:40something for us about it?" And I said, "Sure." I've written for them like three or four times,

1:37:45I think, since I left IDG back in the day. So I said, "Sure, that was great." And they said,

1:37:50"Don't write about design because I'm going to do a separate piece about design." And then that piece

1:37:55fell through right at the moment where I was feeling short of my word count. And I got the

1:38:00go ahead to write about the George Foreman grill. So then I threw that in there and then I was in

1:38:04pretty good shape. But it was fun to revisit that. I wrote about it a little bit for my 20

1:38:10Macs for 2020 project three years ago, but it was nice to try to sit there and rub my chin and think

1:38:19about the big picture, about explaining to people who weren't around then maybe why it mattered so

1:38:25much. And the idea that in some ways, the places where the iMac made the biggest difference were

1:38:32not what you might think because that original iMac, the G3 iMac was the only one that used a

1:38:39CRT display. All the rest of them were flat panels. Desktops aren't as important as laptops are now,

1:38:46but it saved Apple. It literally saved Apple. It gave it the money to complete the OS X transition,

1:38:53which they needed. And then they had the money to do the iPod. All of those things had to get money

1:39:03from the iMac first and it really revived the Mac in general. And then I think the one that gets

1:39:09very little credit these days is USB, which was in existence before the G3 iMac.

1:39:16But it was just sort of kicking around in PC makers. They're like, well, we'll put it on there

1:39:21maybe as an option, but like really everybody's gonna use parallel and serial and that's what

1:39:25it's gonna be. And Steve Jobs was like, all things that we used to have, Mac serial, SCSI,

1:39:32ADB for keyboards and mice, and the floppy drive. I want them out. He kicked them out.

1:39:39And it's like, that's heresy. And that's one of those things that I think is a real legacy of the

1:39:44iMac is that it was a transgressive computer that broke compatibility in a bunch of different ways,

1:39:51benefited from the fact that it was the opening days of the internet and a Mac

1:39:55could survive on the internet. You would read your email and look at the web on the Mac,

1:39:58just as well as a PC. And that I think it's really striking that 25 years later,

1:40:03if you take that keyboard or that stupid round mouse, like I'm sitting here in a Mac studio

1:40:09right now. I could literally take that stupid round mouse and plug it into my Mac studio

1:40:14without an adapter. And it works 25 years later. That's bizarre. That's crazy. But USB,

1:40:21right? That was the thing. And I think USB would not have made it as fast and been as popular,

1:40:27were it not for the kick in the pants that the iMac gave because they announced it in the spring. And

1:40:32then, and then they shipped it in August. Every vendor of peripherals was like, oh, we'll have

1:40:38one. We're going to do a USB one. It was like, that was the moment where they realized they had

1:40:42to promise a USB product, even though they didn't have it yet and had to deliver it because they

1:40:46knew the iMac was going to be big. It's key that they got rid of the legacy ports and for Apple,

1:40:52it was ADB, which I still use an ADB keyboard, but with an adapter. But the fact that they got

1:40:59rid of that, that's the difference, right? The PC way of doing it. It really was true that even

1:41:06though USB had been out for a while, there were a lot of PCs that didn't even include it because

1:41:10they're like, well, we'd only be able to add it because of course we would just add it so that

1:41:15they could still use their serial keyboard and serial mouse. So if we're just going to add it,

1:41:20why bother? It's just another way of connecting a mouse. We've already got it. And if Apple had

1:41:25thought the same way, they would have included ADB. Of course, I'm sure the Apple way, if they

1:41:31had done that, would have been to make the new mouse and new keyboard USB use this new connector.

1:41:37But then the third parties wouldn't have jumped on it because they would have already said the

1:41:42Logitech and whoever else were making ADB mice at the time would say, well, just buy our ADB mouse.

1:41:48If you don't like this hockey puck mouse, just buy it. Whereas the fact that you either had to buy

1:41:53the one adapter, the Griffin iMate, which I'm not even sure when that came out, but of course it was

1:41:59blue translucent plastic, but it wasn't cheap even at the time. So it just forced, all of a

1:42:07sudden the whole industry was like, well, we better make USB mice. And a lot of people don't

1:42:11like this mouse, so there's a market for it. I mean, I don't think that was deliberate,

1:42:15but, and I always bring it up, my wife loved the mouse, used it for years afterwards,

1:42:19even when she no longer was using her purple iMac. It was not universally hated, but of course was

1:42:26mostly, mostly hated. James Thompson says that during OS X demos in the development of OS X,

1:42:37when Steve would come in to try something out, before he came in the room, they would take the

1:42:44round mouse and they would rotate it. Just so when the first time Steve tried to use the mouse,

1:42:50he would just grab it and push up and it would go to the side and he'd get frustrated. And that was

1:42:55their way to just remind him, you got to get rid of this mouse. It's really bad. And they just would

1:43:00do it every time. And they did right, like in 2000. So two years later, two years later at

1:43:06Macworld Expo, they're like, we're sorry. Just weird. Like here's, we got an oval mouse for you.

1:43:12JS Yeah. Wasn't they, when they, when they went from one color, the, I always pronounce it wrong,

1:43:17Bondi blue, Bondi blue. James It is Bondi.

1:43:21JS Bondi. James Even though that sounds like Bandai and the

1:43:24Power Rangers, it is Bondi, not Bondi. It's Bondi beach, Australia.

1:43:31JS When they went to the five colors, didn't they add like a dimple on the mouse button? I think the

1:43:37original Bondi blue one had no dimple. So it was much, it was even easier to misorient because it

1:43:43was a circle. But anyway, yeah, the USB thing was super interesting. One thing that noted,

1:43:47I noticed last week, looking back on it was forget if it was your piece or somebody else's or

1:43:53multiple of them. But talking about that, they showed like a, there was a close up photograph

1:43:59of the ports panel on the iMac. And it just struck me how low the industrial design was. Like there

1:44:08were gaps around everything. It was just sort of a piece of plastic with a hole in it. And then

1:44:13behind it, you could see, they just put like a generic ethernet card. And there was like a gap

1:44:19around the ethernet port and a gap around the USB port. Like nothing was as seamless as it is

1:44:26it quickly. It didn't take very long under the new jobs regime to start closing those little air gaps

1:44:33around things like that. It was very crude in some ways looking just at the details of how the USB

1:44:41port melded with the plastic around it. I remember at the time I started writing Daring Fireball in

1:44:482002. But I was equally obsessive about all of this stuff at the time. If anything, more worried,

1:44:55more obsessive because Apple seemed to be in trouble. And I really, it seemed pretty clear

1:45:01that if Apple didn't make it, I'd either have to switch to using Windows for everything or,

1:45:07I don't know, become a carpenter or something. But I remember being focused so much more on the OS

1:45:16story, right? And that's the whole reason they bought NeXT. The whole idea was we need a new

1:45:20next generation operating system. Our efforts internally had failed. We need something. We're

1:45:26either going to buy B or we're going to buy NeXT. We went with NeXT. And now here's the plan. And it

1:45:33kept changing. And it was all, it had to be, I mean, it's not a mistake, but it was like they

1:45:39bought them at Christmas, 1996. And so effectively beginning 1997, and they were like, we'll have

1:45:46this new operating system out in 1998. No. And then it was like, oh no, we'll have it out in

1:45:5299, no, 2001. I don't know. It's hard. OS X, Mac OS X was a very, very, very hard project to get to,

1:46:00but that's what I was focused on. And the up and downs of, well, so there was the Rhapsody and the

1:46:08Blue Box, the Yellow Box, the Yellow Box. Yeah. They were trying to figure out a way to navigate

1:46:13that thing where they could use most of the technology brought over by NeXT, but make it just

1:46:19compatible enough with the Mac that Mac users would be able to move to it and not have everything

1:46:25break. And that sort of became, in the end, it became Cocoa and Carbon. But there was originally,

1:46:31it was going to be like an emulator for Mac OS. And they're like, no, no, no, no, no, we can't do

1:46:36that. And they, and they, but it was, again, talk about things that don't get enough credit.

1:46:41The OS X development cycle that, because everything Apple makes is based on OS X,

1:46:47right? To this day, everything is, is, and that's a legacy from NeXT and some decisions they made

1:46:52in 98, 99, 2000, 2001. Any misstep there, the jig is up.

1:46:58Yep. There was a strategy. I think the Yellow Box was the name of it. That was because NeXT step or

1:47:05OpenStep ran on Intel hardware and there was, there was an idea that what we now call Cocoa

1:47:12would run on Windows. And so like Carbon apps would only run on Mac OS X or Rapsody or whatever

1:47:18the name was, and Cocoa apps would run there too, and would be best there. But if you wrote for these

1:47:23NeXT frameworks, you could also run your apps on Windows because they were going to ship the,

1:47:28and they did all, but the software, software, software, OS strategy frameworks was all what

1:47:33I was thinking. And I, my, it's very vivid. I just remember when the news broke that Apple shipped

1:47:39this new computer and it was like, Whoa, look at that. That is not just like a new beige box. This

1:47:45is a state, a hardware statement. I just, that's the, it was like a thunderclap moment. I didn't

1:47:52get to watch it live. I wasn't covering them. I wasn't at the Flint center or wherever it was held.

1:47:58They, there was no tech. It wasn't even possible to, to live stream the event. You had to read

1:48:03about it somewhere, but it made news, right? I mean, and it's, I linked to Steven Levy's

1:48:10cover story for, I think it was a cover story for Newsweek. Certainly should have been if it

1:48:14wasn't. And there was lots of coverage in Fortune where Brent, he wrote the, co-wrote the book,

1:48:20Being, Becoming Steve Jobs, had, had a bunch of access to Steve Jobs and he was on the cover there,

1:48:26but it just, cause it looked, it, it, it, it was meant for a magazine cover cause it was a very

1:48:31attractive device and it didn't look like other computers. Right. And it was like a statement.

1:48:36And the whole idea of an all in one Macintosh, it just sort of, it was like a statement that said,

1:48:44this is still the Macintosh from 1984 in some ways, right? There's, there was a,

1:48:50we're back to making things that are of the same DNA that, that made the Mac, what the Mac,

1:48:58the, the, the good parts that were worth saving. I said this in the Verge piece,

1:49:02essentially when he came back to Apple, he's like, what do we have here? I actually likened it to the

1:49:08princess bride where it's like, can we get a list of assets? Why didn't you mention a wheelbarrow

1:49:12and a Holocaust cloak? Now we've got something. It was like that. And it's like, what do we have?

1:49:16Well, we got Johnny Ive. He's playing around with all this plastic stuff. Like, all right,

1:49:19well, we got this diskless workstation thing called Columbus. We could probably adapt that

1:49:23into something. It's like, all right. Okay. Okay. What else do we have? And then Steve Jobs supplied.

1:49:27We have the original vision of the Mac, which is a computer for the rest of us and all in one

1:49:31that is not maybe the most ergonomic kind of thing, but you can move it around. It's got a

1:49:37handle, it's got a carrying thing. And, and that was a huge advantage. And keep in mind,

1:49:42it was, it was not that long after, right? It was, it was 25 years since the iMac came out.

1:49:48The iMac came out, what, 14 years after the original Mac. So Steve came back to the company

1:49:54and he was like, we still haven't nailed that. Let's nail that. Let's go back to the idea of

1:49:59creating an appliance that is friendly, that you can put on the desk, that people will be able to

1:50:05use. And so he, he was playing the hits in a way. He was saying we didn't nail it with the original

1:50:09Mac because the computer industry didn't, computers didn't end up looking quite like the

1:50:15original Mac. The GUI sort of happened with Windows 95, but everything's a beige CRT with a bunch of

1:50:22cables and a beige modem and a beige computer tower and all of that. So like, let's do that.

1:50:27And we'll use the translucent plastic from that kid in the design team. And we'll use this

1:50:31diskless workstation concept and we'll throw out a bunch of old stuff and we'll make it happen.

1:50:36I was struck thinking about it, struck by how much it was really Jobs going back to his old

1:50:41playbook and say, look, what was the original idea for the Mac? Let's do that again. And it is that,

1:50:48I mean, it really is what he envisioned. It's that same all in one thing that he was thinking

1:50:53of with the Mac. I, I probably, as you're listening to me talk right now, the album art

1:51:00for this chapter, but there's a, it was from the second generation when they went to five colors,

1:51:05but the, the Yum poster and I, I tweeted it on, well, whatever you call it, posted about it on

1:51:13Mastodon and Threads yesterday or the day before. And so many people responding to my post about

1:51:19what a great poster it was and just sort of, cause I, I consider those five colored iMacs,

1:51:25the original iMac too. It's just, it's not really a new generation. It was just sort of the second.

1:51:29Yeah. They're all G3 iMacs. And this, oh, this idea of, of translucent plastic is a hit. Well,

1:51:36yeah, let's do it in all the colors. I can't tell you how many people responded to it and said,

1:51:40yeah, either I still have that poster or I did. And I wish I still had it. Walt Mossberg replied

1:51:46to me on Threads that it was hanging in his office at the Wall Street Journal for years.

1:51:50Just a, just a statement. Just yes, computers are fun. They're super fun. So let's make them look

1:51:58like they're fun. Right. And the whole idea that let's just put everything you need in the box.

1:52:04That's it. And cause every other computer, like it wasn't just that they were boring and beige.

1:52:08It was that everything you needed for them, did you need another hard drive or an external drive

1:52:13or this or that? It was either a tower that you took apart and God bless you with some of them

1:52:20getting to the components, but putting them into drive bays and hooking things up inside and then

1:52:26resealing the case. Or they were these external things that you stacked up on your desk and plugged

1:52:32in and just including the modem as an internal component. It, it, it sounded, again, I think a

1:52:39lot of the, the John Dvoraks of the world thought that was stupid. Why if people want a modem,

1:52:44just buy the modem. It's not really safe, but it gave them, there's that poster that I love that

1:52:50Yum visual poster of the five IMAX and the TV commercial that everyone remembers is the Jeff

1:52:57Goldblum one. Right. No step three. And that is, that is, that is so jobs, right? And that is the

1:53:04idea that you plug it in and then you plug your phone line in basically into the iMac or the iMac

1:53:09into the phone line of the wall and you're on the internet. And the internet is the, is the also an

1:53:14unsung hero of this transition because like I said earlier, this was at a time where windows is sort

1:53:20of one, right? Like when the windows 95, they had kind of closed the gap as much as mattered to most

1:53:25people in terms of the user interface, but the internet people wanted to just get on the internet.

1:53:30They wanted an email. They wanted to see the web. They wanted online services and stuff like that.

1:53:35And the iMac could be sold and that's why it had the I in the name, right? The iMac could be sold

1:53:40as an internet appliance. It wasn't even like, does it run the program I run at my job or

1:53:44something? It's like, yeah, you don't worry about that. You buy it, you plug it in these two things

1:53:49and you're on the internet to do whatever things you can do to explore the internet. And that was

1:53:55a moment where suddenly being the Mac, being a Mac and not a PC didn't matter. And that was,

1:54:02I mean, how do you close the sale otherwise? If you're like, well, no, no, you can't buy an iMac

1:54:06because it doesn't get you on the internet game over. But instead it was like, yeah, this is a

1:54:12stylish little blob that you can put on a table in your house and plug in these two things and

1:54:17you're on the internet. And that was super important to uptake of this product that it was not,

1:54:22Oh, it's not compatible. It's scary. Cause max that's why people didn't buy max. Right? Number

1:54:28one reason is that they weren't compatible with the rest of the world and they weren't compatible

1:54:32with the internet. And for a lot of people in 1998, that is all that, Matt, they literally

1:54:36weren't compatible with floppy disks. They took the same disks, but if you put a Mac

1:54:40floppy disk in a PC, it would be unrecognized. Do you want to format or you want to format this disk

1:54:46right? Exactly. And the Mac eventually grew to buy by necessity, grew to have the built-in ability to

1:54:53read dos formatted fat 32 or fat 16, whatever the hell the format was floppy disks, but vice versa,

1:55:01if it didn't go both ways, it w it wasn't compatible. So you couldn't even share a word

1:55:07doc, even though I have word on my Mac and you have word on your PC and they could read the same

1:55:13doc files or Excel files. If you, I couldn't put a floppy disk in your computer and have you read it.

1:55:18So it was like, why am I even bothering with this? Right? Exactly. And I think that's one of the

1:55:22reasons that goes to why the iMac doesn't even bother with writable storage is part of the

1:55:26philosophy is like, look, you're not going to put things on a floppy disk. We're not going to do that

1:55:30anymore. And they, they knew the writable disks were coming. Writable CD-ROMs are coming. You can

1:55:35buy a USB floppy if you really wanted it, but they're like, no, no, no, no, no. Here's what

1:55:38you're going to do. It's got built-in ethernet. So if you're in a network, you just do it that way

1:55:43by file sharing. And otherwise it's got the modem. You're going to email that file. You're not going

1:55:48to walk it somewhere on a floppy. You're going to either use ethernet or you're going to email it

1:55:54because the internet is now what connects all of us. Right. Or if it was a story. Yeah. And,

1:55:59and to go back to our graphic design print world work of the nineties, it had all moved to zip

1:56:07drives at the time, which were just by, by those standards. I think they were like a hundred

1:56:12megabytes. So they were like, yeah, it's like a, yeah. An order of magnitude better than a

1:56:16floppy disk. Two, two orders of magnitude. It was like a hundred times bigger than, Oh, I guess

1:56:20you're right. Yeah. Yeah. It just it's yeah. Roughly this amazing, right? Roughly the same

1:56:24size as a floppy disk, but faster. Why do we still have the floppy? Why do we still have in

1:56:29the answer was because you might have to boot from it. It's like, forget it. Right. Like you

1:56:33boo from the CD rom drive and you'll like it. Right. It's like, okay, let's do this. Yeah. So

1:56:37just brilliant. And that TV commercial, that was it. And people had this idea and it was true. It

1:56:42was new, but how do I get on the internet? Well, Jeff Goldblum told you, you plug the

1:56:48iMac into the wall for power and you plug the Mo the phone into the phone socket and,

1:56:53Oh, that's it. There is no step three. That's it. No step. It was fantastic. And it really is true

1:56:59that for all the different weird names where Apple does not like to explain what they mean,

1:57:04what does the R in iPhone 10 R stand for? Well, you and I both, Oh, I always ask. And then they

1:57:11never tell you. They're like, whatever they told us what the I stood for. The I stood for internet

1:57:16it all of the products since the iPod, which is crazy because the iPod didn't have networking,

1:57:21but it eventually silently without explanation stood to mean cool Apple product. I would ever

1:57:30meant it was the cool thing from Apple, but with the iMac, the I stood for internet. And it

1:57:35absolutely was part of the reason a huge part of the reason that Apple still exists to this day,

1:57:41because in the early to mid nineties, all of the software Mojo was on the windows side.

1:57:48All the Mac had left was the graphic design, print production stuff, and a dough to go back to Adobe

1:57:54circle back two hours ago, all the whole Adobe suite moved to windows and stayed in parallel.

1:58:00We could go off on a tangent about this, but like when Microsoft word six infamously shipped on the

1:58:06Mac with a very windows style interface compared to word five, which was a beloved Mac app.

1:58:12Mac users rejected it. And it took until office 98, speaking of 98 for the Mac to have, or Microsoft

1:58:21to build the Mac business unit, the Mac BU that was dedicated to building Mac style versions of

1:58:27the Microsoft apps. Windows users don't have tastes like that. So Adobe making Mac style

1:58:34versions of Photoshop illustrator, whatever else was in the suite, windows users were like,

1:58:41whatever it was good. It was, well, it was like a ice water in hell. It was a better style,

1:58:46but if you were a Mac user used to Mac Photoshop and you had to use sit down in front of Photoshop

1:58:51and windows, it was the one part of windows. You were like, Oh, everything's the same. All the

1:58:55windows, all the menus are the same. The pallets are the same. The file formats are compatible.

1:59:00So the best the Mac could do at the time was, Oh, well like the Adobe suite is available on both

1:59:06and it's identical. But by the late nineties, all of the companies, you don't think of them as

1:59:13software companies, but what was amazon.com? It's a website is software, right? I mean,

1:59:19there's a hardware component to have the servers, but all the companies you had heard about these

1:59:23companies like Yahoo and Amazon, some Stanford research project called Google that's coming out.

1:59:29All of that stuff was on the web. And Bill Gates famously penned a memo where he kind of turned

1:59:35the company around where Microsoft was in denial about the fact that the windows had Germany,

1:59:41whatever, have you pronounced that word was kind of over the, the web was becoming the new universal

1:59:48platform, even more universal than windows. Cause if when they tried to undermine it right with like

1:59:54things that were plugins that only ran on windows and things like that, but it didn't,

1:59:57it didn't work. It didn't take in the end. The, I came to represent Apple to the point where for

2:00:03a while there, I think you could argue that the eye was the most important brand at Apple, not the

2:00:07Apple logo, which is not what they wanted, but that's where they needed to. To start is like

2:00:12iPod is named the way it is because they wanted to say the iMac that's cool. Well, this is too.

2:00:17And they went and that's why we have the iPhone in the, and the iPad and the, I, today it's Apple

2:00:23watch and Apple vision pro and all of that. But like, there was a time when Apple something was

2:00:28not as impactful as I something, everything, even stuff that was all Mac that remained Mac only like

2:00:35the eyesight camera, which is a brand they should I Cal it's just, it, it just was a prefix for Apple

2:00:42that, you know, it clearly was something that Steve jobs believed in that seemingly the rest

2:00:51of the company did not. I mean, I don't know who else, Johnny. But as soon as Steve jobs

2:00:58died, they stopped shipping. I named products and, and while he was alive, everything, I mean,

2:01:03famously when he introduced the iPhone, what are we going to call it? Yeah, that's right. iPhone.

2:01:07Cause there was like in the speculation up to the release of the iPhone, somebody figured out Cisco

2:01:12own a trademark, bizarrely for a product named iPhone and they worked it out. They paid them

2:01:18off or whatever, but iPhone iPad, everything up until 2011 was I whatever. And then everything

2:01:26afterwards I forget is I can't remember if there's literally cloud was, was jobs as last event. And

2:01:34that was the introduction of iCloud. So I think, and I think the iCloud is the last product name

2:01:39with the eye in front of it. I mean, and whether it's because the people left after he died,

2:01:44didn't like it anymore, or I don't think it was quite like Phil Schiller was in there saying the

2:01:50stupid I names got to go. This is dumb, Steve. And then he waited until they died or Johnny

2:01:54or whatever, but maybe it might've been more that Steve was the one who didn't want to put Apple in

2:02:01front of everything. I mean, famously there's a famous story about the original Mac before they

2:02:06come up with the Cloverleaf logo for the command key. They were all apples, right? Cause from the

2:02:12Apple two, there were two Apple keys. Yeah. Open Apple and closed Apple. Open Apple and closed

2:02:17Apple. They're two different, two different Apple keys that were different modifiers,

2:02:23early versions of the original system. One had it was Apple P for print and Apple S for save.

2:02:30And Steve was like, there's too many Apple logos. We're abusing it. This is supposed to be the Apple

2:02:35logo is precious, which is kind of right. So there'll be one, just one up in the upper left

2:02:40corner of the Apple menu. That's it. And no more apples. So they had to invent Susan care came up

2:02:46with the Cloverleaf from a, what was it like a park sign and yeah. In Scandinavia, somewhere in

2:02:52Scandinavia, it was, but you know, maybe that mindset of, you know, we want to be precious

2:02:59with using Apple was sort of what kept him on the eye names, but whatever it certainly worked out

2:03:04for them to the point where people call the Apple watch the eye watch. Exactly. They, they it's true.

2:03:11It's true. And, and yet now to go back to our, our Disney conversation, right? Apple today is not,

2:03:18is, is back to being an iconic brand in a way that maybe it lost its way for a while. And now

2:03:24they have, they made a dedicated choice to put Apple as the brand name up in the front that like,

2:03:30literally, what is the watch that Apple makes? It's the Apple watch. Like you don't need another

2:03:36name for it. It's just Apple watch. That's. And, and that's where they are now. And that,

2:03:42that is they're, they're on top again. It's hard to imagine from the perspective of today,

2:03:47how broken the Apple brand was in the nineties, but like, it was real broken to the point where

2:03:54the iMac was became like more valuable as the iMac than it did as a thing from Apple. And so the iPod

2:04:01logically was called iPod. And that's how they got people to try the Mac again was to love an

2:04:10iPod so much that they thought, Hey, I love this Apple product. Maybe that computer they make,

2:04:16maybe I should try that. I've never had one, but maybe I should try it. And they sold so many Macs

2:04:21to people who fell in love with the Apple brand because they love their iPod so much. It's just

2:04:25like that in the Apple store being making it easy to try a Mac and see it and see what you could

2:04:31get out of it. That's how the rehab of that brand happened. It's hard to imagine now, but really

2:04:36they had, they spent a good decade rehabbing the Apple brand, but now it's on top again.

2:04:42I remember in 2000, 2001, I was living in suburban Boston when I worked at barebone software and

2:04:49we used to go, my wife and I would go to the Rockingham mall where there was the closest Apple

2:04:54store. And repeatedly I would hear people say in the mall, let's go to the iPod store.

2:04:59Yeah, sure.

2:05:02It was, well, obviously not 2000. That would be 2001, but 2001, 2002, I think 2002. Yeah. I lived

2:05:09there until 2002.

2:05:10But that, that all just, yeah, that, that happened, that happened and the iMac. Yeah. So in the end,

2:05:15the iMac is funny because what the iMac represents is not maybe what you think,

2:05:21like, cause it didn't lead to a, a huge cavalcade of standalone desktops that were what everybody

2:05:28wanted. And it wasn't like brightly colored computers. Cause after the G3 iMac, they didn't

2:05:31really do bright colored computers anymore until the M1, essentially they didn't do that. It didn't

2:05:38even lead to, it didn't lead to brightly colored pro max. They did the one blue one and then they're

2:05:41like, Nope, people don't like it. We're going to make them boring and gray. Like none of those

2:05:45things are the, are the things that in the long run affected it. It's more like rehabbing the

2:05:50Apple brand, giving them a cashflow so that they could do OS 10 and ultimately the iPad and then

2:05:55continue on. And like, and the USB, like it's those weird kind of like choices that they made

2:06:02that actually like are the demarcation line between like before and after those are the places

2:06:08where it made its biggest impact. Yeah. And it exemplified that Steve jobs slash now just

2:06:14institutional Apple mindset of we're not going to ask our users what they want and build based on

2:06:19the polling. We're going to figure out what they want and, and build that. And nobody was saying,

2:06:25get rid of all of my AD, all the ADB ports on your exciting new Mac so that none of my existing mice

2:06:30and keyboards work without a peripheral and replace it with this thing. That's brand new. Nobody was

2:06:36saying that, but it was the right decision. I got a note from somebody who used to work at Adobe

2:06:41speaking, just calling back to an earlier part of the show and who got to know John Warnock as a

2:06:46young, young intern at Adobe, who just had the gumption to, to ask, to have lunch with John

2:06:53Warnock. And he said, sure. And, and gave him advice and it said, it said, what do you, what's

2:06:59your top advice? And he said, here's my top advice. Don't ask people what they want, watch what they do

2:07:04and then build something based on that. And again, that's the, that the I Mac exemplifies that,

2:07:11right? Nobody was asking for pretty translucent blue plastic, but you know, people like things

2:07:18that look fun. People like things. And USB has stood the test of time, right? I mean, the fact

2:07:24is it's like, well, how are we ever, ever, ever going to get out from under Scuzzy and max serial

2:07:30and ADB and the floppy drive? How are we ever going to do that? And the answer was the only

2:07:36way we're going to do it is if we make people adopt the new standard. And so we're going to

2:07:41just cut them off and Apple does that to this day. Right. I know it frustrates people, but like,

2:07:45I, I understand the frustration, but I also almost always understand why Apple does it where they're

2:07:51like, look, look, we could, we could stretch this out, but that doesn't make anybody happy. It just

2:07:56stretches out the pain. So we're just going to make like, it's a, it's the dock connectors

2:07:59going away and now it's lightning and that, and then we're about to enter probably the,

2:08:03Oh, your iPhone doesn't use lightning anymore. It uses USB-C. It's like, okay. And the Mac don't

2:08:09go into USB-C. It's like, Oh yeah, I know there's pain there, but like at some point trying to

2:08:14create a long transition, just, just stretches out the pain and, and instead of just like,

2:08:20let's do it, let's make the change. And you'll all thank us later. When you can't imagine going back

2:08:25to the way it was. And the iMac was the most extreme example because 90s Apple was so

2:08:29dysfunctional that they had done nothing to get rid of any of those three different peripheral

2:08:35standards that had to be on every Mac. It's like, let's get it out of here. USB. That's it.

2:08:39>> Let me thank our third and final sponsor of the show. It's our good friends at Squarespace. I can

2:08:45just tell you right now at the beginning, go to squarespace.com/talk show. You'll save 10% off

2:08:51your first purchase of a website or a domain name using that code talk show, just know the, just

2:08:57talk show. What else do you need to know about Squarespace? My God, everything that you need to

2:09:03have your own website online, your own brand, your own presence in your control. Squarespace

2:09:11offers it. I even said right there, domain name registration, the beginning, picking a template,

2:09:17picking the features that you want on your website. You do it all by drag and drop. They've

2:09:22got the new fluid engine. That's their next generation website design system from Squarespace.

2:09:29It's always been easy and always been WYSIWYG to use that term again, drag and drop where your

2:09:36interface as the owner of a Squarespace website, you're building the website, you're dragging

2:09:41features in, you're taking them out. It's exactly what you see is what the people who visit your

2:09:45website are going to see, except they're just not going to have the ability to tweak the design.

2:09:50The fluid engine takes everything Squarespace is known for and what they're good at and just makes

2:09:57it way, way better. It's just all reimagined drag and drop technology for desktop. You can do it on

2:10:03mobile too, which is a big change and a big addition. So you can actually design your

2:10:08Squarespace website, tweak it, adjust it, modify it right on your phone. It is terrific. It is a

2:10:14huge success. It's just Squarespace getting better at what they were already great at.

2:10:20Online store, all of that, anything you want to sell from products that you want to sell

2:10:25to selling your time, if you're a consultant or something like that,

2:10:28and you want to book people to sell your time to people and take the money and

2:10:35organize your schedule, all of that stuff right there. The payments, flexible templates that you

2:10:42can either choose from the existing template, start with a template and tweak it or do your

2:10:47own design from the ground up if you have the expertise or the desire to do it. Analytics built

2:10:53right in with an absolutely terrific, easily understood analytics interface. And if you've

2:10:59looked at 98% of analytics dashboards out there, they look like airplane cockpits, not Squarespaces.

2:11:06But that doesn't mean they don't give you all the information you need. It's just actually

2:11:10organized in a sensible, readable, logical, "Oh, I see where my traffic's coming from. I see which

2:11:16parts of the website people are actually going to." Or if you're placing ads on Instagram or

2:11:22something like that, which of the ads, where are people landing on your website, all of that built

2:11:27in with their analytics. Just a terrific service. So once again, go to squarespace.com/talkshow,

2:11:33get a free trial, 30 days, no limits, no watermarks on the site you build during the free

2:11:38trial. And by using that code, squarespace.com/talkshow, you save 10% off your first

2:11:45purchase of a website or domain. My thanks to Squarespace for their continuing support of the

2:11:51talk show. Last but not least, man, and this is, man, we could go for another three hours talking

2:11:57about the iPad. You wrote about your using the iPad as a travel computer. You just were down.

2:12:04Your mom lives in Arizona, I believe, right? Yeah. Yeah. Outside of Phoenix. And I went through a

2:12:11period of time when I tried really hard to not travel with a laptop and just travel with an

2:12:17iPad. I love using my iPad. I'm not going to not travel without the iPad. I'm going to bring the

2:12:22iPad. But I was like, do I really want to bring an iPad and a laptop on this? So I tried very hard

2:12:27for, and wrote about it a lot and talked about it for many years to do the, when I go somewhere,

2:12:31I'm just going to bring the iPad and the magic keyboard case, and I'm going to be able to do

2:12:36my podcasts and write my articles and I'm going to make it happen. I'm going to figure out a way

2:12:39to make it work. And ever since I got an Apple Silicon MacBook Air, basically, I don't do that

2:12:44anymore. I travel with both again. I'm back to that. And I was down on a Friday morning at my

2:12:49mom's house thinking I need to write something. And I, it was taken, literally I was in the shower

2:12:54and I was like, oh, that's what I could write. I could write about the fact that I'm doing this now

2:12:58is that's what happens. Sometimes you're like, oh, that's a piece. I'm going to write that up.

2:13:03And, and I, it was really just sort of like trying to close the loop on like, well,

2:13:08I tried this so, so hard for so long. Why did I stop trying? And, and it has been interpreted

2:13:14was at the top of hacker news. People were sending me messages. I mastered on you write about any of

2:13:19this and you're going to get the people who are like, how dare you, sir. And you're going to get

2:13:22the people who are like, why did you even try to use an iPad? Because it's silly. And the truth is

2:13:28I, I liked the idea of only traveling with one of those devices. I tried very hard and I have come

2:13:34to the con the Apple Silicon MacBook Air is so good and it's so small and it, and it's so flexible.

2:13:40And I decided as many of our colleagues have done David Sparks, I think is a really good example of

2:13:47this. I've decided I'm done trying to push the iPad where Apple doesn't seem to want it to go.

2:13:56I was pushing it before. And now I think I've just decided I will accept the iPad for what it is. I

2:14:03still write articles on my iPad in that keyboard case or in a stand with an external keyboard

2:14:09at my, in my kitchen. Like I like it as a change of pace. I like traveling with it, but I'm going

2:14:16to stop doing things like, like if I want to use a, like the stream deck doesn't work with it. And

2:14:22I use that for a lot of automation stuff and it's got shortcuts, which is great, but it doesn't do

2:14:27like global keyboard shortcuts for automation. So that's a frustration. And then the podcasting

2:14:32thing while I know esoteric, cause most people aren't podcasters is emblematic in a way of like,

2:14:36there is a fundamental thing that I need that the Mac does and the iPad just can't do it. And I can

2:14:43work around it or I can just give up and say, am I recording a podcast on this trip? I went to

2:14:47Colorado with my family for a family, for an event with like all of Lauren's family being there. And

2:14:54I had one podcast to do, and you know what I did? I brought the MacBook Air and a microphone. I opened

2:14:59the MacBook Air one time, recorded the podcast, posted it, closed the MacBook Air and that was it.

2:15:03But I like, I just decided that was easier. It was just easier to do it that way. So I did it that

2:15:08way. So I, I, for me, it's more like I, I, I tried to make the iPad more than it was. And then I

2:15:16realized I should stop, right? I should just stop and accept it for what it is. And I love it for

2:15:21what it is, but like, if I want flexibility, if I want to be able to do sort of like anything I want

2:15:27to do, I should just have a Mac for that because that's what the Mac is great at.

2:15:32- It's the most confounding platform in the history of computers. It really is. And I used to,

2:15:39I used to roll, I rolled my eyes for years and even talked to people in iPad product marketing.

2:15:46And I mean, I'm not, I'm not a, never, it's always collegial having briefings with, with Apple folks,

2:15:52but renaming iPad OS instead of just saying that it runs iOS. Cause it really it's, they're

2:15:59obviously siblings in a very tight way, but I'm, I'm down with it. I, I, I agree that it it's,

2:16:06it's worth its own name. It is different. It is, it is not a big iPhone, even though it's kind of

2:16:12a big iPhone, right? It makes it so hard to pin. The Mac is, is a PC. It is a full blown computer,

2:16:22a Unix workstation, and you can compile software on it and you can still do things, even with the

2:16:30things people worried wouldn't make the transition to Apple Silicon, like turning off system

2:16:35integrity protection, if you really want to, so that you can go and inspect and tweak and replace

2:16:41pieces of the system software, you can still do stuff like that. Like stuff that nobody in

2:16:46their wildest dreams imagines Apple's ever going to do with the iPad, right? There is no system

2:16:50integrity protection toggle for, for the iPad. And I don't think there should be, you know what it is

2:16:58and you know what the iPhone is. It's a phone and yes, people are frustrated and we'll see what

2:17:02happens with EU seemingly forcing Apple's regulatory hand with sideloading. We'll see where that goes.

2:17:10I know people have been frustrated that you can't, if you choose toggle a switch so that you can just

2:17:16install apps from the web if you want with a, you know, hopefully appropriate warning, but you know

2:17:25what the iPhone is. It still is very well defined where it fits in people's lives and people can

2:17:31quibble with the design decisions Apple have made on where to draw those limits. But the iPad

2:17:36straddles all of it. It's, it is, you can look at it and say that it's so close to being Mac like

2:17:43that it should just be more Mac like, and you can also see that what so many zillions, zillions,

2:17:50uncountable number of iPad thriving users who love it just love that it for them really is like a,

2:17:58just a big, big, big, maybe even 12.9 inch iPhone. And that's what they love about it.

2:18:06Eric Michael Rhodes I think, I think there's so much mixed up here too, because I strongly suspect,

2:18:12and I do not have a lot of detail about this, but I strongly suspect that Apple at one point assumed

2:18:21that they were putting the Mac out to pasture and they were going to do minimal effort on the Mac.

2:18:25It was going to be a legacy platform and they were going to build the new Mac like platform

2:18:32on the iPad. That was what they were going to do. And I think they changed direction and they said,

2:18:38you know what, we're not going to do that. I suspect even it might've been the moment where

2:18:41they decided they were actually going to do Apple Silicon for the Mac, right? Because they would've

2:18:45been very easy for them to put the Mac out to pasture and just kind of take Intel chips and

2:18:49let it kind of fade away. And I think at some point, and I, one day, I hope somebody will tell

2:18:54me this for true, but it feels like Apple went from thinking that the iPad was the future of

2:19:00computing and that this would be the next generation computing platform, general purpose,

2:19:05to saying, no, it'll be the Mac. We're going to stick with the Mac and we're going to make,

2:19:11we're going to import and they did stuff, right? It's like, we're going to do catalyst and we're

2:19:15going to let Apple Silicon Macs run iPad apps and we're going to do all this stuff. So like

2:19:20it can pick up the iPad and pieces of the iPad. What we're not going to do is sort of like put it

2:19:26on an island and make the iPad do Mac things. It's more like we're going to let the Mac be more

2:19:31iPad-y at times, which is why when there's rumors like that rumor that Mark Gurman had at one point

2:19:37about like a touchscreen iMac, I started to think if now I believe that if Apple ever does something

2:19:42that looks like an iPad, but, but does Mac like things, it will literally be a Mac that has a

2:19:49compatibility mode, not an iPad that has been tricked out with a terminal, right? I just don't,

2:19:57it feels like that was a place they weren't going. And at some point they said, we're not going to go

2:20:02there. We're going to keep the iMac or the iPad a little bit purer and more iPhone-like with more

2:20:09capability, but like purer and the Mac is where anything can happen. And like they, I don't know

2:20:16when 2017, 16, I don't know when, but like the rhetoric changed about the iPad. I'm sure the Mac

2:20:25round table, you know? Yeah. And then there was a moment that I'm sure they actually regret now in

2:20:302018, where they pointed out that the iPad pro is faster than 90% of all PC laptops that sold in the

2:20:35last year. Like that. I think they, I think they regret that because they were like calling it out,

2:20:40like look at, look at the computing prowess of the iPad and like, but that's actually not where

2:20:46they're, where they're going. Cause now that's the Apple Silicon argument, but it's not the iPad

2:20:50argument anymore. Right. And I remember for years, I was never obsessed with benchmarks.

2:20:55I'm glad that other reviewers are, but it's just not my vein. I'm not good at it. And I'm just not

2:21:01as obsessed with it. But there were a series of years where I remember not just with iPads,

2:21:06but even iPhones where I was just vaccinated watching geek bench, single core scores, approach

2:21:14high-end MacBook pros. And it was very clear they were going to pass it. It was, it was clear. And

2:21:21I remember writing about it and people would be like, you're crazy. There's no way a phone is

2:21:24ever going to get a better single. And I'm like, look at the, look at the, the, the slope of these

2:21:29graphs. It is absolutely going to happen. And then it did happen. And yet the back still didn't move.

2:21:35I think you're right. I remember you talking about this on this show and I've come more around to

2:21:41your argument. You know, you're obviously more iPad power usery than I am. I mean, it's, it's

2:21:47obvious from all of your, our combined writing. I, there's something almost broken in my brain

2:21:57in the way that my brain is melded with the Mac way of doing certain things. And it would have,

2:22:03I think, and I think I was in denial about it, to be honest, I think because I would have found it,

2:22:09if that's the way things had turned out, it would have been much more difficult for me to adjust.

2:22:14But I think in hindsight, I think it is true. And I don't think it was ever

2:22:18a spelled out plan. Like this is there's a cohesive roadmap for where, what year

2:22:26vaguely the Mac will go away and the iPad will grow to replace it. And there will be

2:22:32iMac style 27 inch things running iPad OS or whatever, whatever else it would take for the iPad

2:22:38platform to have fully obviated the Mac. I think it was more vague and it was just sort of it like,

2:22:48like one of those gnomes stealing underpants plans, right? Where it's like, the Mac is old,

2:22:54right? It dates back to 1984 on the Mac, the Apple side and 1988 or 89 on the next side.

2:23:02And Mac, even Mac OS X, by the time the iPad came out was a decade old. And it's, it's,

2:23:10it just, I think just sort of a gut feeling of something this old should be replaced by

2:23:17something new. And this iPad clearly had so much potential, right? Just the first one you're looking

2:23:22at and you're like, and as much as that first one really was just a big iPhone, it's like,

2:23:27this is so rich with potential. I just, I always say, I just remember that first

2:23:33hands-on for the very first original iPad, me and Dan Morin were the last two media people who

2:23:41really got, we practically literally got kicked out of the hands-on area. Because, and we were

2:23:47over by the one that had the keyboard. Remember the original keyboard? It was a weird-

2:23:51Yeah, keyboard dock.

2:23:52Yeah.

2:23:53And vertical keyboard dock.

2:23:54Yeah. A vertical keyboard dock. And it's the fact they had the keyboard dock obviously arranged and

2:23:59it was a late, famously, there were plans until very late in the game that they were going to have

2:24:05two ports on the iPad, one the long way and one the skinny way. And there'd be two 30 pin connectors

2:24:10so that you could connect it to the keyboard dock either way. But we were just sitting there in

2:24:16front of this iPad, which, you know, seemingly we were, I remember talking with Dan about it. Like,

2:24:22it seems like you ought to be able to put it the other way. You know, like we were just like,

2:24:27this is amazing. Right? They have, they always have like a dummy Johnny Appleseed, 1963 at

2:24:32mac.com. If you could send emails and try everything out, it's like, this is a real

2:24:37computer. This is not a phone. And you hook it up to this keyboard. And they didn't have trackpad

2:24:42support for almost 10 years. Right. Or it was 10 years. But even without it, just reaching out and

2:24:47touching the screen, it was like the, the potential is so rich. And I just feel like it was just like

2:24:53a gut feeling. Like, of course, this is going to grow to make the Mac seem so old and antiquated

2:25:01that this will be the bright future. And just like I said, like a gnomes eating underpants,

2:25:06this is new, the Mac is old, dot, dot, dot, profit. And then when it really came time in the middle of

2:25:14the teens for that to prove true, and it had to be a cohesive roadmap, I kind of feel like they

2:25:22looked at it and are like, there is no, there's no path to get there. Right. Like to keep the iPad,

2:25:26the iPad, we're not going to have a Unix subsystem under the hood that's exposed to users,

2:25:33but without this Unix subsystem exposed to users under the hood, how in the world is Xcode ever

2:25:38going to work? How are we going to build their operating systems? Yeah. I don't even want to say

2:25:42they took their foot off the gas, but it does feel like they recalibrated. Cause I do think that like

2:25:47the change that they made to files and adding external display support last year and stage

2:25:53manager, but also like the magic keyboard and the trackpad support, like they did a lot of this

2:25:57stuff to make it more Mac-like. And I think the question is, was that part of a more cohesive

2:26:03strategy to advance the platform or not? I think, I think in the end, what you say is right, which

2:26:10is the Mac going to Apple Silicon, it gains a lot of benefit. It also gains the software platform,

2:26:17right? It, the Mac Apple Silicon Mac can run if allowed. And that's an issue where a lot of people

2:26:22don't allow it, but like it will run iPad apps. It just runs them. Right. And it's fine. Like I,

2:26:27the MLB app just runs on my Mac. Right. And there is not a Mac app for MLB. It just runs on my Mac

2:26:33and that's great. Right. And, and that seems to be what they've decided is we're going to unify

2:26:38instead of unifying, like on iOS, we're going to keep Mac OS around, but they did the, they did

2:26:43the work to take all the low level stuff and get it to be aligned across all the platforms. Cause

2:26:48they had both, they had drifted apart and that allowed them to do catalyst, but it also allows

2:26:53them with Apple Silicon to just run those apps on there. And you can see you're sort of like

2:26:57building up this whole layer, which is why I said earlier at this point, if I'm Apple and I'm like

2:27:02intrigued by the idea of something that's more like a convertible laptop, something that could

2:27:07be touch and maybe thinner. I don't think you would build, like, I don't think there's a facility

2:27:14to build all that stuff into the iPad. Like the iPad is the iPad. The Mac is the superset. Right.

2:27:21So you would take the iPad and say, Oh, when you fold the keyboard back, it becomes an iPad.

2:27:27That's what you'd say. You wouldn't say, right. Enter Mac mode on your iPad. You'd say your Mac

2:27:32can be an iPad sometimes, but it's still a Mac and it runs the same apps on either side. That's

2:27:39how you would, that's how you would have to do it. And I'm not saying they will do that. I'm just

2:27:43saying that it's another indicator of my progression of sort of like how I view where Apple

2:27:49is taking these platforms that I just don't think that Apple is, is looking at the iPad and saying,

2:27:54one day the iPad will do everything that people look to the Mac to do. And then the Mac won't be

2:28:00relevant anymore. I just don't think, I don't think they believe that. No, I don't think so either.

2:28:04I mean, and one of the tests is for a real computer is can you use the computer to make

2:28:11software for the computer? Right. And we go back to the original Mac in 1984, you couldn't write

2:28:17Mac software on an original Mac. You had to have a Lisa. And when the Lisa was, I don't know,

2:28:23everybody complained that the Mac was too expensive and the Lisa was, I don't know,

2:28:26like $10,000. And that did not last long. Macintosh programmers workshop came out pretty

2:28:32quickly thereafter. And I never used the Lisa. I don't know about you, but I don't know, speaking

2:28:36of computers, I never saw. It didn't take long for the Mac to bootstrap itself to be able to

2:28:42write Mac software on a Mac. And Playgrounds feels like it might eventually be essentially

2:28:48an iOS app only Xcode. Right. It could be right there. And there's, you can take like a Playgrounds

2:28:54project from iPad and import it into Xcode now. And it gets to some of those things with the

2:29:01pro AV apps, the logic and Final Cut. Right. Where now they finally, and I think it was

2:29:07a justifiable finally, have real professional versions of Final Cut and logic for the iPad.

2:29:14And you can, which one, one's more of a, the Final Cut is more of a subset of on the Mac,

2:29:21but you can still go from the iPad to the Mac, even if you can't always go from the

2:29:25Mac back to the iPad. And Playgrounds is sort of like that, but even then it's only for making iPad

2:29:31style apps. Right? Like you can't imagine writing Mac apps and Apple doesn't just write apps on the

2:29:38Mac. They write the operating systems, they write the firmware for them. What, what computers do

2:29:42you think write the firmware that runs the AirPod Pro 2 noise cancellation? They do that on the Mac,

2:29:48right? You'd have to be able to write all that software. It's it just, I do. I think I,

2:29:55I kind of feel like in the early PC era, platforms came and went every couple of years. Nothing,

2:30:04if you were lucky, if you got a full generation, like the Commodore 64, which had, I don't know,

2:30:10six or seven years of prime time life and things like the Apple 2 platform had a

2:30:17over a decade long run of relevance, but then went away and it was just understood that

2:30:23platforms died after a decade or so replaced by something new. And the Mac and Windows were these

2:30:32two things that came out of that era and seemingly had instead of a decade, decades. But I still think

2:30:40a lot of people of our generations just sort of had an assumption, but they're going to come to

2:30:43an end eventually, right? Then we're not going to be using Macs forever, but I kind of feel now

2:30:48we are. I don't, I don't foresee in, I think 25 years from now, there's still going to be a Mac.

2:30:55I really do at this point. I wouldn't have said that 10 or 15 years ago.

2:30:59The, when I talked to Phil Schiller, maybe the last time I did a one-on-one with Phil Schiller

2:31:11was for the 25th anniversary of the Mac, I think. And it was Phil and Jaws and I forget who else was

2:31:20in, was there, but it was a time where I basically said, do you foresee the Mac kind of fading away

2:31:29with these other products there? And he could have done the PR thing, right? And what he said was the

2:31:36Mac goes on forever. That's what he said. The Mac goes on forever. Not you never know. It was the

2:31:44Mac goes on forever. And I think about that from time to time, because there was a moment where I,

2:31:48like I said, I was like, I'm not sure the Mac goes on forever. And now I think maybe the Mac goes on

2:31:53forever. I think maybe that is essentially that, that either that or the iPad and Apple's platforms

2:32:00and the vision pro and all of that will evolve and keep evolving at this pace where at some point,

2:32:08then there will be that more natural death where you'll realize that actually everything I use my

2:32:15Mac for now, I can do on those systems. And they've evolved to the point where it's irrelevant

2:32:21that the Mac, right? Cause like, it's very rare that a thing that you love, you're talking about

2:32:25when Apple was maybe going out of business and we're all horrified by it. It's very rare that

2:32:29a thing that is used and loved is just the plug is pulled while everybody's using it and they scream.

2:32:34Right. What happens is what happens is it becomes irrelevant. So when it finally dies, nobody cares

2:32:40anymore except collectors and some aficionados, but like everybody else has sort of moved on. So

2:32:46it's like, I can't imagine like when I stopped using a TiVo, it was like, Oh, I love TiVo. I

2:32:50did. But by the time I dumped my TiVo, it was irrelevant because everything was streaming at

2:32:56that point. I had given, I wasn't using it anymore. That's the more likely tech irrelevance for the

2:33:01Mac would be that all these other Apple platforms have reached the point where you don't need the

2:33:05Mac. Oh, they all do all those things. It turns out that I'm not using the Mac for those things

2:33:09anymore. And that's when it ends. I still use a TiVo, but that's really, we'd have to get my

2:33:13wife on to explain why I could, I could switch to doing everything through the Apple TV box, but

2:33:19iPod would be a perfect example of that. Right? There were no riots when Apple sold the last iPod.

2:33:25I mean, again, because it had become irrelevant by that deep, deep, deep affinity for some of the

2:33:30models, people collect them and people love them. And, and there's a part I know. And I know the,

2:33:35the oddest one was the hard drive based ones that had the biggest storage, right? Because they were

2:33:40like professional DJs who were like, I need to store like 80 gigabytes of music on a thing. And I

2:33:46used to show up at a wedding with this pack of cards. And now what am I supposed to do again?

2:33:50I got to take a whole laptop, but yeah, it, I think people sort of had that idea. And I think,

2:33:55I think the Mac is, is I really do. I think it's here forever. I think it has a longer future than

2:34:00the iPad ahead of it. I really do. You mentioned vision pro last thing I want. I'm so glad you did.

2:34:06Cause the one thing I wanted to mention was talking about this for travel and framing it in

2:34:10the perspective of, well, what do you put in your backpack or your briefcase to go on a trip? Right?

2:34:16Do you take the iPad and the Mac book to me? That's the thing that the, the elephant in the room is

2:34:23the vision headsets. And I'd say just vision headsets because there's clearly the $3,500

2:34:31vision pro that comes out early next year is not the only one that's going to exist.

2:34:36Let's blast fast forward three or four years. And there's a vision non-pro that's only $1,500

2:34:42or whatever it, and it is, it turns out that as I think is going to be true, it's going to be a

2:34:48phenomenal device to use while you're sitting on an airplane or a train and a phenomenal device

2:34:55to sit at a hotel room at a desk and sort of catch up on stuff on a virtual big screen.

2:35:01One thing about if you're taking a Mac book, especially a Mac book air, but you know,

2:35:08even if it's a Mac book pro and an iPad with you, they both pack flat. And yes, it is. I, I,

2:35:15I don't know why I obsess over the extra weight of my 11 inch iPad, but I do. And I think I should

2:35:22leave it at home, save my shoulders a little bit of wear and tear the vision pro I think is

2:35:26something or vision headsets is something I'm going to want to take with me on most

2:35:31trips. If it's like overnight length, maybe not like a day trip to New York, but overnight type

2:35:37trips is inherently going to be a pain in the ass to travel with packing wise, right? Because

2:35:44no matter you saw it in person, and even if for everybody out there listening, who still hasn't

2:35:48seen one in person, let alone tried one, it's, you know, you can just look at it. It doesn't pack

2:35:55flat. So where do you put it? It's, it's like taking a big over the ear head headphones instead

2:36:01of just earbuds it's takes some strategy. There's no way I feel like that's a breaking point for the,

2:36:10Hey, do I take my iPad and Mac book? If you're also going to take a vision pro all of a sudden

2:36:16now it's like, what am I taking a whole Apple store with me?

2:36:18Yeah. And, and what it sounds like, basically you'd be able to run anything you'd run on your

2:36:25iPad on a vision pro, but vision pro at least this initial version, the way it does,

2:36:31it's Mac compatibility is it is doing screen sharing. So you would, what basically you'd

2:36:37bring up, you'd have to bring a Mac with you. I do wonder in the long run, and this goes back

2:36:41to the iPad as well. Like I do wonder at some point if Apple says, you know what?

2:36:45Mac, the ultimate solution to the Mac OS is that is emulation is a virtual machine or virtualization.

2:36:53And that, that first off M M2 iPad pro, like it could run Mac iOS in a virtual machine if it

2:37:02wanted to. And that would be the answer to my iPad is not as functional as the Mac would be.

2:37:06We'll just run Mac iOS on it when you want to. And then you got it and it's not a Mac,

2:37:11but it'll, it'll virtualize it. I don't know if Apple will ever do that. But when I look at the

2:37:16vision pro, I think surely they're not going to say you always must bring a Mac with you

2:37:23in order to use Mac software. I surely the long game there is that it can be a Mac too,

2:37:31right? Just running again in virtualization, Apple Silicon, it's all the same. And that would be

2:37:37really interesting if I didn't have to bring a MacBook air with me, literally just so that I

2:37:43could open it up and then have it pop up into the vision pro. And with 10 more years, just to pick

2:37:49an even number of increases in performance in Apple Silicon, CPU, single core, multi-core,

2:37:5710 more years of the natural expansion of levels of Ram and memory and what's available, what a,

2:38:05what the computer in a, in one of these devices can do in its spare cycles. It, I like you said,

2:38:12if an iPad could already clearly, if Apple technically allowed it run a virtualized Mac OS,

2:38:19well, it's clearly vision pro probably could right now. And if not, it certainly will within

2:38:27a handful of years, let alone 10 years. So yeah, I could see that I could see a future where the

2:38:33forever Mac is purely software. I really, it's a virtual, it's a virtual machine that can run

2:38:40sort of wherever you want. And, and, and that, yeah, I, I, I have that thought too, that, that

2:38:47in the end, like every now and then I see people like version writers really like to write about

2:38:51that Samsung decks thing where you plug a Samsung phone into a monitor and it's sort of a weird

2:38:55desktop computer. And it's like in the grand scheme of things, like use a 10 years out, or

2:39:00is it unreasonable that every Apple product can be any Apple product? If you, if you put it in the

2:39:07right context, maybe, and vision pro seems to be especially the product that could do that right.

2:39:12Where it's sort of like, it is a virtual reality product. So if you say, I want a Mac right here

2:39:19on this empty desk in the long run, shouldn't vision pro be able to put a Mac on that empty

2:39:25desk? I think it should right in the, in the end. And it'll, if it's, if it's all virtualized inside

2:39:30Apple Silicon, I don't see why not other than wanting to sell a vision pro user an additional

2:39:37Mac, but you know, I don't know in the end, if that's the right thing for the product to do,

2:39:41I think Apple will let it do. Yeah, I do too. And I think, and I think it gets around a lot of the,

2:39:46I don't know how to describe them, but the objections that Apple has internally to allowing

2:39:55Mac like things on iPhones and iPads and whatever, that they're not going to give you

2:40:00Unix subsystem access to the actual file system on an iPad or iPhone. But if it's all virtualized,

2:40:06it's just in an app. It's not, you'd still have Unix. You'd still have all the command line stuff

2:40:10you want, but you'd only be diddling with the virtual internals of the virtual Mac with no

2:40:17access or connection to the actual literal physical computer that this is running on.

2:40:23And that satisfies Apple's design goals for keeping these generations of devices

2:40:31newer than the Mac completely sealed off from the user being able to touch them for, for good

2:40:39reasons, but with bad trade-offs it's there are reasons both ways, but virtualizing it solves

2:40:45those problems. It really does. So I kind of feel like that's the ultimate solution.

2:40:49Yeah. And I certainly would love, I mean, that would solve my travel problem. If I could just

2:40:54a virtual machine of Mac iOS on an iPad when I need it and then shut it back down again,

2:40:58I'm not saying they will do that, but that would solve a lot of my problems. If my product,

2:41:02if I'm bringing a keyboard and trackpad case along with me, anyway, I could, I could fake it in a Mac

2:41:08app for a while and then just get rid of it and go back to using my iPad. But there are all those

2:41:13arguments are like, why don't, but they they'll sell me both. So they make more money. It's like,

2:41:17yeah, I know in the short term, but in the long term, I think it's worth thinking about that

2:41:20moment where like all these Apple platforms are all capable of running virtually on all,

2:41:25it's all the same hardware essentially, right? Like a MacBook air and an iPad pro that are

2:41:29running them too. They are not that different. Those two computers are not very different.

2:41:34And so at that point you can almost mix and match and just say like run, run whatever, wherever.

2:41:39And, and the vision pro of all of them is like every, I think everything will be virtualizable

2:41:45inside the vision pro eventually. Cause that's the whole point of it is just create a, it's not

2:41:50hardware, it's virtual hardware on demand. I would think that it would definitely get there in the

2:41:54next 10 years. Right. And actually turns the portable Mac experience into something superior

2:42:00because right even right now, I mean, again, we did not get to try the Mac, Mac virtual display

2:42:07in the demos they gave out at WWDC, but talking to people at Apple who've used it, it is by their

2:42:14accounts, not like marketing people, but engineering type people. It's really good and usable and

2:42:20credible on this first generation one, three quarters of a year before it actually ships

2:42:26future ones, it's going to be great, but you'll have not just a 4k display like this one's

2:42:31promising, but you know, six or eight K displays eventually no problem. Right. I mean, there's no

2:42:37doubt in my mind that like a five year from now vision pro is going to be able to simulate like

2:42:41a giant 8k display in front of you that if it, and if it's the only thing you take in your backpack,

2:42:48wow, now you're traveling lighter, I guess, except for the battery packs, you'll need to take me out.

2:42:54But you know, still you'll probably save, it's probably going to weigh less than a MacBook pro,

2:42:59but you'll have a giant virtual display. So the future is bright, but I do think that it will

2:43:05in the near term next year and the year after it's, it's definitely going to change people's

2:43:11hey, what do I take with me when I go on this trip? I think you're right. I, and I don't know

2:43:17what my answer to that is. No, I don't want, I don't know what mine will be either. I,

2:43:21it's just one of those things where I'm like, well, I need to, I need to actually have one

2:43:25and live with it. I can't just go by marketing materials or a pack can 30 minute demo. I love

2:43:30that I got to have it. I love to talk about it. I still think about it. It kind of haunts me that I

2:43:35only got those sweet, sweet 30 minutes with it. Yeah. But I don't draw any conclusions from it.

2:43:40It's everything is different when you use it for real. Anyway, Jason, it's always good to have you

2:43:46on, even if it's a brief show like this one. Yeah. They can all be marathon. Sometimes we've got to

2:43:51cut it short, certain sweet Titan bright. We got, we, we it's like Bob Barker got to 99. Didn't go

2:43:58over. We got to buy my count here two 52, but we didn't go over the three minute mark. So we win.

2:44:03Yeah. This isn't like, this is Marco Arment or a star Wars talk here. We don't go over three hours.

2:44:09That's the forget that we're staying right under there. Titan bright.

2:44:12Did you remember as a kid, you go back to the prices, right? With the, in the, in the showcase

2:44:17showdown, when you got to be the fourth person and you you'd have the lucky option. If you thought

2:44:22everybody else overbid, you could go $1. And remember when you knew that that was obviously

2:44:27the right strategy and then somebody wouldn't do it screaming at the television. I mean,

2:44:34I have that when nobody knows the answer in final jeopardy and I know it's exactly the same feeling.

2:44:38Right. It was just like, come on guys, come on. How is it that I know this and you don't? Right.

2:44:42I would have zero chance of winning on jeopardy or qualifying on jeopardy. I'm way, I think way

2:44:47too slowly. And I don't even know enough trivia, but whatever trivia I know, I'm not fast. Like

2:44:53our friend Glenn, who actually is jeopardy player champion champion winner. But when I know the

2:45:00answer, I know it's bad. If they don't know it, it doesn't make me angry. Anyway. Thank you, Jason.

2:45:06Everybody of course can follow you at six colors.com and you always, even when you do write at

2:45:12unusual places like the verge or your weekly regular Mac world column, it's always linked to

2:45:17from six colors, right? The upgrade with Mike Hurley, fantastic podcasts, always, always worn

2:45:25out episodes on my podcast player. Thank you. And the incomparable network chock full of pop culture

2:45:32goodness. What else do, what else do you have? Those are the, I think biggest highlights. I'm

2:45:37believe it or not. I'm actually on Mac break weekly with Leo Laporte every Tuesday with Andy

2:45:42and Iko, who I have been working with for like 30 years now. So how do you do it? I don't understand

2:45:47how you do it. I don't understand. I don't know either. I just don't think about it. It's like

2:45:53violet coyote. You just run off the edge of the cliff and don't look down.

2:45:57Me I'm a looker downer. Thank you, Jason. Thanks, John.