0:00:00Gabe, this is a little weird because
0:00:02part of my checklist before I start recording an episode of this show because I usually disappear for
0:00:09anywhere from two hours to two hours plus while recording the show is before I start I check tech meme
0:00:16to make sure
0:00:18no news has broken
0:00:20Yeah
0:00:22And I feel like I don't have to do it. I can just ask you Gabe
0:00:26Is there any breaking news on tech meme that we should talk about keeping track of it?
0:00:31Today was a big day for Microsoft, but I don't remember anything too big in the past. Yeah few minutes. I
0:00:37Presume because I mentioned it on Darren fireball frequently
0:00:42I tell anybody who would ask but you know what a pillar
0:00:46Tech meme is of my media diet at least but can you talk about I mean just for anybody who doesn't know you're here to
0:00:53Talk about it. When did you start tech meme?
0:00:55What is tech meme? How does it work?
0:00:57Those are some big questions
0:01:01Okay, so well, thanks for thanks for calling it a pillar
0:01:06when we do what we do to keep it going every day we keep
0:01:11people like you in mind like writers who are like in the know and need to
0:01:16Have a high-level view of the industry and like tech execs and people like that
0:01:21So as long as we're relevant to you guys, we're doing our job
0:01:24How did it get started? So let's see. I've always been like
0:01:30Messing with news aggregators and like little things to get news from websites because I've always been interested in news
0:01:37So back in the early aughts I'd seen the the rise of blogging the bloggers
0:01:43Have a good grasp of what's interesting and what's trending and if you just follow a bunch of blogs and see what they're looking to
0:01:51You could see what's important. So I just I started writing like a little aggregator
0:01:57They would see what are the news stories that are linked to?
0:01:59most by basically political bloggers called it meme or random and
0:02:05The way I worked is
0:02:08There would be like mainstream media news sites and then underneath of
0:02:14Those headlines it would be the bloggers
0:02:17So the bloggers were always like the peanut gallery and the mainstream sites were always the the top so
0:02:23Having seen
0:02:26And I by the way, I launched that site a few bloggers had picked it up, but it wasn't like a big deal
0:02:30Then I thought okay now it's time to do a vision where the bloggers can be the top headline. There is no
0:02:37built-in hierarchy anyone can be the top headline and when I
0:02:42When I built that I decided to do a tech vertical
0:02:46keep the political vertical and so I launched those at the same time and the tech one is the one that took off and
0:02:52and then I renamed it tech meme a few months later and
0:02:55Ever since then the idea is be a good industry news aggregator
0:03:01That has taken a lot of twists and turns over the years, but I think in many ways we've been very consistent
0:03:08And what is it? It's like the best the moat like the essential
0:03:11tech industry
0:03:13news headlines and
0:03:16And
0:03:17float posts that you need to see
0:03:19at the moment to update your knowledge on what's happening so that you can be informed and make decisions and
0:03:25All that stuff that important people need to do
0:03:28Tech meme is great for several reasons. I use it every day
0:03:33It's usually something I do in the morning just to see what happened overnight
0:03:37Did anything happen usually because I'm on the East Coast even though I kind of sleep on West Coast hours
0:03:43It's usually nothing really broke overnight, but sometimes sometimes stuff happens
0:03:48early Eastern time because of a
0:03:52embargo or something like that, but it's just part of my
0:03:56Well, is anything going on?
0:03:58Recognize recognize I know about that. Okay. Oh, that's interesting. Hmm open up a couple tabs. All right
0:04:05Pour another cup of coffee move on
0:04:07but
0:04:09the other part is like if I'm
0:04:12traveling if I'm on vacation if it's
0:04:15You know like an Apple event day where I'm in Cupertino
0:04:20Because I don't know new iPhone 15 is being launched and I'm heads down all day
0:04:26In that environment and I just want to say what else is going on in the rest of the world
0:04:32it offers like mental closure to to go to tech me and
0:04:37Scan the list and say is there anything else? Of course, I got an iPhone 15 day iPhone 15 is on tech name
0:04:44Okay, here's but did I miss anything? Is there anything that I missed? Nope. Okay, scroll down scroll down
0:04:50Okay caught up and then I know that I'm caught up on like the tech sphere
0:04:55I know yeah caught up and it's a good feeling. I guess there there are two things I can say that number one
0:05:02What helps in that what makes it a little easier for tech meme to be that is we rewrite almost all the headlines that they're very
0:05:08Descriptive so you'll need to do a lot of clicking
0:05:11And another thing that gives you that peace of mind is we don't have a page to we don't have an infinite tool
0:05:16It just you get to the bottom and and you're caught up. Of course, there's more to read in the world
0:05:21But if you want that kind of view you are caught up
0:05:24The other thing though that I find very interesting is the way that tech meme batches
0:05:30Stories together. I'm looking at it right now
0:05:33Microsoft announces the Maya 100 chip for Azure clients blah blah blah
0:05:38And it doesn't really matter what the story is right now as you and I record by the time this episodes out
0:05:43That'll have scrolled off the bottom
0:05:44but then it says more and
0:05:46the lead article links to Bloomberg's coverage of this and then you've got coverage from Microsoft itself the verge venture beat and
0:05:54on at Tom's Hardware CNBC at least two dozen other sources all
0:06:00linking to the same story that's
0:06:02Human aggregated it correct. So yeah, yes and no we we've all like when tech meme launched
0:06:12It was like it was all
0:06:14Algorithmic there's this news crawling and an analysis engine
0:06:19I built to surface trending news and when there's trending news
0:06:24There's usually like other blogs and news outlets covering it so often linking to that
0:06:30So the algorithm could help tie it all up and then sometimes group related coverage, but over time
0:06:36For a number of reasons algorithms don't really cut it in all situations
0:06:41Sometimes the story is suddenly suddenly expires because some new event happened and then sometimes just there's the algorithm that groups things
0:06:49Groups things that shouldn't be grouped together and we still kind of fight against that the human editors will sometimes break things up
0:06:58so a lot of the grouping you see is
0:07:00When it comes to news headlines, it's mostly automated when it comes to social posts. There's
0:07:06There's like an approval process, but a lot of the recommendations are also automated. So it's it's a dance involving
0:07:14algorithms and our editors
0:07:17One thing though and again, I'm not just saying this to
0:07:21Compliment you but I think it stands out and I think anybody who's been reading tech meme for a long time would agree
0:07:28tech meme has never lost sight of
0:07:31the fact that you were
0:07:33targeting
0:07:35the reader first that it is a reader first presentation of news of
0:07:40Let's be respectful of our readers our visitors whatever you want to call them their attention
0:07:47When you do rewrite headlines it is only for
0:07:52Clarification it's not to take the piss and vinegar out of a punchy headline it is to
0:07:58Take the click baiting us out of a head. It really is and I think that's human done, right?
0:08:05You guys don't use AI or anything algorithmically to to do the headline rewriting
0:08:11I know art artifact has started doing that and I'd like to talk about artifact in a moment
0:08:16But I find the way they do it to be irritating
0:08:19Not that I haven't noticed when you've done it with daring fireball posts, but I've never once objected to it. You know, that's good
0:08:25Occasionally we get objections like once in a while. We'll make an error, but we try to be basically
0:08:32Descriptive and yeah, definitely respecting the reader like that goes through everything we do
0:08:37But yeah
0:08:38We want to give like little summaries where if you just want the most high-level
0:08:43View if you just want to know what it's about you can get that from the headline
0:08:48but but of course because it's just a headline if you have any kind of
0:08:53Curiosity that goes deeper you'll need to click and and get get that deeper look. What's the name?
0:09:00I've given myself five minutes here to think of it and I can't so I'm gonna ask you I think you'll remember
0:09:05what was the name of the I
0:09:08Would say it was a competitor to tech meme in the early days in the early aughts
0:09:13It was green and it was mostly focused on blogs and a sort of
0:09:19Ranking they had the ranking of the top hundred blogs at any given time
0:09:23Yeah, I think they're thinking of technorati technorati. Yeah, exactly it right and I can't I can't say they were they proceeded well
0:09:32But yeah, they had I think everyone went through iterations where they competed with us in the in that era
0:09:38Where they provided some kind of blog summary, but they were originally a blog search engine, but the rankings were sort of
0:09:44Competitive in a way that it's not a direct competition
0:09:49But obliquely so to me a pure feed reader like a net news wire is just as a user
0:09:56Here's the feeds. I want to subscribe to
0:10:00put them in a list and then give me all the posts from those feeds and let me sort by
0:10:04chronological order and read and that's it whether it's a
0:10:08Web based thing or an app like net news wire. It has no opinion or tries to do any kind of ranking. It's just
0:10:16More like an email client right?
0:10:18Email your email client most people's I know superhuman is a little weird like that, but
0:10:24For the most part you just want your email in order, right? Here's the new messages read them
0:10:30reply to them you're done and feed readers are sort of like that and techno Roddy was trying to do a little more some kind of
0:10:37ranking type thing like so many
0:10:41Success stories it was fleeting, right?
0:10:45it was like it burst onto the scene it became a phenomenon and then it blamed out and
0:10:52To the point where I've completely forgot the name of it here 15 years later, right?
0:10:57Whereas tech meme to me is as relevant as ever and has sort of been in it for the long haul
0:11:04Yeah, techno Roddy. I think they were
0:11:07they they had their big moment because they had a
0:11:11like when everyone realized real time search could do wonderful things because there were blogs and
0:11:19I guess I
0:11:22Forget what people search blog posts there just search links and see
0:11:27I even forget what they did
0:11:29but all I know is they index really quickly and
0:11:31Google was not indexing really quickly at the time. And so the reason why
0:11:36Technorati interests dissipated is Google eventually
0:11:40started indexing everything faster that and
0:11:44There was a lot of everyone sort of realized blogging would actually not continue growing
0:11:50Exponentially forever, especially when Twitter came along a lot of the like short post bloggers just moved to Twitter
0:11:56So technorati had both better technical competition and didn't have as much a reason to exist
0:12:02Why do you think tech meme of the properties which are all sort of based on the same platform, right?
0:12:09Yeah, and there's also media gazer, right which is sort of focused on
0:12:13inside baseball in the media industry
0:12:17They're clearly I mean to correct me if I'm wrong, but I mean
0:12:21I've just assumed by the way they look in the way they work that they're sort of built on the same
0:12:24Technical back end, right? It's just different
0:12:28Verticals as you said right obvious verticals that have preceded even the internet, right?
0:12:34Going back to the paper era. There was a section of the bookstore magazine rack for
0:12:40Computer magazines and there was me maybe not at the bookstore
0:12:45But there's always been a collection of inside the media publications, you know, that sort of thing. Why do you think tech meme is the one?
0:12:52that
0:12:55Reverberated the most or just is the most popular
0:12:58That's a good question because there's plenty of interest in politics
0:13:04I think maybe the the audience for tech news was just more receptive to
0:13:10This kind of nerdier presentation of news like hierarchy and grouping
0:13:16And maybe also they had more of a need to know because it's a little more
0:13:22For a business audience, you're more willing to like compare coverage and you know, look through the related
0:13:28But I'm not entirely sure now for sure we've invested more in tech me because it was the early breakout
0:13:35So it's not a fair comparison if we invested the same amount like me Miranda
0:13:40I'm the political one does still does not even have editor. So it's like it's like a demo of the algorithms
0:13:46So it's it's a little bit of a mystery but since tech mean pulled ahead that's been our biggest focus
0:13:53my spitball theory is
0:13:55Maybe technically minded nerds are willing to look for something different
0:14:02It's like by definition because they're technical nerds
0:14:06they're willing to look for something like this and then be I think that is
0:14:12Polarizing as some things in technology can be Mac versus Windows Android versus iOS, etc, etc
0:14:20and none of that compares to
0:14:23The polarization we've seen in politics and real politics worldwide
0:14:29Not really just in the US and that therefore political
0:14:33minded
0:14:35Enthusiasts people who are like, yes
0:14:37I am so interested in politics that I want to check on a more than once a day basis what's going on in the world of
0:14:44this
0:14:45But they're more I want to hear it from people on my side
0:14:48Tech meme has none of that right? I like if I were teaching a course on
0:14:54journalism, I would hold up tech meme as a great definition of objectivity right where it's
0:15:01Just here's a list of all this stuff and there's an editorial voice declaring importance
0:15:07but it really isn't imposing a
0:15:11view of the world of tech and I
0:15:15Think that in politics as we've become more polarized people say they want objective journalism
0:15:23But I don't think they do I think their behavior shows I think the continuing
0:15:27Success of Fox News is proof that large numbers of people don't really want that right?
0:15:34I well, I'd love to throw Fox News under the bus, but I don't even mean to throw them under the bus in particular here
0:15:40I think it works on both sides
0:15:42yeah, we when we
0:15:44Highlight a story where there are different like sharply different interpretations
0:15:52We will actively seek out
0:15:54Multiple views for the social post as long as they're out there
0:15:58Sometimes everyone basically has one view on social media. That's just part of doing our job because
0:16:05People who need to know what is going on here need to know that both those views exist and who's you know?
0:16:12Voicing them and so on it. Yeah, it goes with our kind of role is sort of like a dashboard
0:16:18Just like a place where you can get all the information rather than a place that you
0:16:23Go to because it makes you feel good about your team
0:16:25Right. All right. Let me take a break here and thank our first sponsor of the episode new sponsor for the show adblock Pro
0:16:33So let's start off with some accolades adblock Pro has earned itself a spotlight by Apple
0:16:40On the App Store not once not twice but three times in this Safari
0:16:45Extensions category and it is well-deserved adblock Pro
0:16:49Available right through at the App Store is now supported on all platforms where it could apply
0:16:55iOS iPad OS and Mac OS and it uses cloud kit for sync between platforms and has a
0:17:03Recently updated user interface that really really it just is so simple on all three platforms
0:17:10I know it can be very very confusing to choose a content blocker
0:17:14No matter which platform you're using or what browser there's so many and you wonder which one's the best or whatever
0:17:20Adblock Pro is undeniably one of the best. There's a reason why Apple is highlighted in the Apple Store at least three times
0:17:28What does it do? What does it offer you? You know those?
0:17:31Infuriating and to me and this is their word infuriating, but let me underline it italicize it boldface it auto play videos
0:17:39deceptive little tiny X buttons to make things go away
0:17:43Relentless scrolling batters sketchy redirects wave them. Goodbye and welcome a decluttered and much more delightful
0:17:50faster browsing experience dive into a web realm that can be up to two to three times faster
0:17:57Slashes your data usage by up to 60% and a bonus
0:18:01Using less data having less stuff like stupid
0:18:05Auto play videos that you never asked for that go in the sidebar and you don't even look at it
0:18:11Slashes your data usage and that it reduces your battery life because your device whether it's your phone your iPad your laptop
0:18:18Whatever isn't even downloading it and playing it and waiting for you to ignore it or click the stupid little X never even starts
0:18:25Therefore the battery life never even gets wasted. It really does
0:18:29affect your battery life say no to sly trackers they do anti trackers
0:18:35maintains the privacy of your online habits and for all the parents out there adblock Pro ensures a safer browsing environment
0:18:42Devoid of inappropriate content for young kids. Are you bombarded? It just a stupid annoying thing
0:18:49Annoyances like allow cookie notifications you can easily dismiss them and for days days after that when you want peace and quiet
0:18:56You've got the option to mute
0:18:58comment sections on popular websites really that's a useful feature to
0:19:03experience basic ad blocking through adblock Pro
0:19:06Absolutely free and for the cost of about two coffees annually
0:19:11You can unearth a treasure trove of premium features that will transform your browsing journey across the iPhone iPad and Mac all three
0:19:19For a very low price for adblock Pro for an annual subscription and the cherry on top with family sharing
0:19:25One subscription covers up to six accounts in your iCloud family account
0:19:30So you could share it with your whole family unless you're like the Brady Bunch or something like that
0:19:34So my thanks to adblock Pro for sponsoring the show jump to the App Store and just search for adblock Pro to transform your Safari
0:19:42Experience today, that's it. No, no custom URL. Just go to the App Store search for adblock Pro. It'll be the top link
0:19:48so let's parlay off a sponsor break there and talk about
0:19:52The ad model at tech me as different as daring fireball is from tech meme
0:19:59I have always felt that you and I right from when I first started monetizing during fireball with
0:20:05Little banner ads on the side
0:20:07I've always felt you and I were aligned on that and I vaguely recall when you and I first met which I think was it
0:20:13Like an O'Reilly food camp back around like 2007 or something like that, huh?
0:20:19In print, I don't know remember but I remember talking to you about it. How does tech me make money? So
0:20:25For most of the time we've made money indeed from ads and right there like sponsorships from people who?
0:20:32Like when they actually buy it, they know our audience thing
0:20:35They know our site and they're making the buy because they want to reach that specific audience
0:20:42And that's what I think we have in common. They're not using
0:20:44Some platform and the impressions just go out on onto the internet. So
0:20:52We have a few different ad formats, but the main one is this sponsor post format
0:20:57It's sort of like a native format where you know how we have news headlines, but we have sponsor headlines
0:21:01but they're marked sponsors and they've been there they've been there the whole time and
0:21:07Yeah, they've always been hopefully classy. They've never even been consumer ads for them. I don't think we've really had anything consumer
0:21:14It's usually like enterprise or something reached something trying to reach like developers or people in tech
0:21:21it's something that I'm proud of because
0:21:24Like we've never had
0:21:26mouseovers autoplay
0:21:29pop-ups anything like that, but it is still getting tougher like
0:21:33the platforms are just getting smarter and smarter and getting better at selling and
0:21:39Our sponsors have to do a little work. They have to write some copy specifically for tech meme it there's some friction there. So
0:21:46Well that will will continue to have ads and we're always encouraging sponsors to reach out to us
0:21:52Like we've we've had to build other businesses as well
0:21:55And we were probably the biggest new business is in the the media monitor monitoring space. Hmm
0:22:02It's nothing we've really announced because right now we have a product that's really excels just for the biggest companies
0:22:09So we just sell that directly. I feel like one way to that. I have an affinity for you is
0:22:17Would say I have three types of sponsors at Daring Fire
0:22:20the the biggest group by far thankfully is returning sponsors and
0:22:25Because they're returning it's they know what to do
0:22:29They're like, oh that was great or whether it was three months ago or six months ago
0:22:33Or sometimes people come back after a year-long break, but they're like
0:22:36What do you have available in the fourth quarter? We'd love to come back
0:22:41We have a new thing coming out blah blah blah, but they don't need anything explained to them
0:22:45Then I have new sponsors who told usually it's like indie developers or something like that and they know it
0:22:51They've they're like, I'm a longtime Daring Fireball reader. I've always wanted to sponsor
0:22:54We've got a new app that does blank and we'd love to book an ad and again, I can just send them the specs
0:23:02They know exactly what to do and then the third group
0:23:05Is when I get an email from like the marketing person at a company and the I and whether they say it
0:23:13Explicitly or not. I know I can read between the lines
0:23:16But sometimes they just say it explicitly that somebody in the company said we should sponsor Daring Fireball
0:23:22yeah, and
0:23:24They ask me questions that are all answered on my daring fireball dotnet
0:23:30sponsors page but they and I know that's how they got to me but they still have questions because they don't understand because these ads
0:23:38are not like any other ads out there and
0:23:43my
0:23:44Little snippet that I have saved up in text expander to paste into an email with the details on the exact specs
0:23:52What dimensions exactly the in pixels the ads are how many words you should try to limit yourself to?
0:23:58They're nothing like the specs for other ads. They're not complicated
0:24:03If anything, I think the simplicity of it should make it easier, but the fact that it's so different is
0:24:09Sometimes hard for them to wrap their heads around
0:24:13Do you run into the same thing? Yeah, it's the exact same all three categories are very familiar to me
0:24:19I think the funny thing about the the third type is often they speak like a different language. Yeah
0:24:24Sometimes they've used terms. I'm like, what does that mean? I go. Yeah. Oh, yeah. Okay, and then
0:24:30They'll send over the creative or the copy which is almost a little bit of industry term there
0:24:36But uh, like the text it'll be inside of a spreadsheet for some reason
0:24:40It's like some some other marketing thing. Yeah, I don't get it but
0:24:44And then we copy it from the spreadsheet and put it on the website like whatever works for them
0:24:50It's in a Google Doc a lot of times from that group and I find that to be so
0:24:55Complicated we compared to just having it in the email to copy and paste from instead
0:25:01I have to click the Google Docs link make sure I'm logged into the right Google account and then copying out of Google Docs
0:25:10It's not complicated, but it's nowhere near as easy as copying out of an email it is
0:25:16I'm happy to have them as sponsors and I'm happy to walk them through it and I'm also happy that they often become
0:25:24Repeat sponsors and I always I often say in my little thank-you messages to sponsors that repeat sponsors
0:25:31To me are my proof that that my sponsorships work. Why else would so many sponsors come back?
0:25:37If not for the fact that they thought their original buy was worth it. It's it's a nice little
0:25:44Reassurance, it's a virtuous circle
0:25:47if you were you know that I I make money because they paid the bills and they they are happy with the
0:25:53number of people who came and
0:25:56Whatever bought their service looked at their app
0:25:59Whatever it is that they're after and they come back and hopefully the readers of my site
0:26:05appreciate that this is what keeps my site completely free of charge to read and is not annoying and doesn't tempt you to
0:26:12block the ads or whatever
0:26:15But it is weird and I feel like my business is doing okay
0:26:20It's not growing like it was ten years ago
0:26:22But I just worry though that as it becomes weirder and weirder compared to the state-of-the-art
0:26:30That eventually that's going to become a problem for me and I do you worry about that that it's the whole
0:26:36advertising world has become so dominated by the sort of
0:26:40Google Facebook duopoly of
0:26:44algorithmic buying
0:26:46based on
0:26:48Completely different criteria than us instead of targeting a publication
0:26:52They're targeting buckets of users based on whatever Facebook and Google's
0:26:58Descriptions are that it really is like you said when you when you get email from these people it is like they're speaking a different
0:27:05Language and they use terms. I'm not familiar with do you do you worry about that?
0:27:08Or do you feel like the fact that it stands out is actually a strength?
0:27:12I do worry about it because it's a real factor. I've noticed like there's there's certain segments of
0:27:19Advertisers that only go to the platforms now, but I do think the thing that's unique
0:27:26About sites like ours is they will always
0:27:29Hopefully for a long time get that first and second type of sponsor people who know our audience
0:27:36But you know, I gotta keep keep these changes in mind
0:27:39That's why we have this like media monitoring business and you for the longest time
0:27:44You've had a podcast and while that's still a sponsor model keeping that going that just adds a whole other dimension
0:27:50To it and makes the blog makes the podcast stronger and the podcast makes the blog stronger. Yeah, I hope so and
0:27:58Kind of walked into the podcast business that wasn't something I set out to do but I do think you're right that it
0:28:06both strengthen each other and I can't quite explain why but I know that that they do and
0:28:12part of the reassurance is that
0:28:16Is just the emails I get from people who are like I listen to your show and I love your website blah blah blah or the
0:28:22sponsors who overlap and and sponsor both or something like that or that want to
0:28:27sponsor both to me is a good sign and that they I don't know that there are siblings that support the same overall
0:28:35Two two pillars in the same tent for lack of a better. Mm-hmm
0:28:39I don't know if that's a good analogy or not because I don't think I don't think a tent actually stands up with only two pillars
0:28:45A two-legged stool is not a great stool, but that's what I've got
0:28:49Before we move on I want to I still want to talk a little more about the back end at tech meme
0:28:55Like how is the sort order?
0:28:59Like what's at the top what second what's third how is that determined and how often does it update?
0:29:06And if it's secret sauce say it's secret sauce
0:29:10I'm not looking for you to spill the beans on anything you consider proprietary
0:29:14But I don't think you have to worry about
0:29:16Yeah, don't I don't have to worry about that
0:29:19nowadays and no one seems like nobody wants to
0:29:22Build this kind of aggregator anymore and that was different 15 years ago. Yeah, so the biggest factor all along
0:29:31since the beginning has been
0:29:33basically citations links there is a
0:29:37relationship there with like page rank like
0:29:41The new stories that are getting the most links are the ones that will shoot to the top and
0:29:49There's a time decay that'll bring them down again. But what you're saying is
0:29:54Roughly the the more linked things in the past few hours now, there are a lot of caveats now
0:30:02suppose everyone's talking about some Microsoft story and they're linking to
0:30:08The Microsoft announcement maybe a press release maybe a Microsoft blog and then maybe some
0:30:14developer blog and now suppose
0:30:17We decide to just post the verge or tech crunch or some kind of blog to be the like the stand-in for all that news
0:30:25Then that the way our back end works now that blog posts will
0:30:30still
0:30:32kind of get
0:30:33Get the lift that all the other blog posts are getting it'll be like transferred to that as far as how high it goes onto
0:30:40the page and
0:30:42and there are some other factors too because sometimes the stories break and
0:30:47five
0:30:49New sites will cover it and none of them are the ones getting
0:30:52you know, they don't link to each other that generally doesn't happen anymore and
0:30:57so we have to like
0:31:00you know the between the algorithms and the editors we have to pick one and then
0:31:04the hell hi goes on the page has to sort of take into account the fact that
0:31:09multiple sites are covering it even when
0:31:13They're not linking to it's there's not like one article or blog posts that everyone's linking to
0:31:19so I guess in the big picture, it's sort of like related to this original idea of
0:31:26What's linked to the most but then with a lot of ways that's been extended so indeed but in some sense it
0:31:33and I've always thought this and and I know it's you know, you've talked about it or written about it before but it is
0:31:39Vaguely like the original concept for page rank at Google where it's other
0:31:47publications that you're you're monitoring through the RSS feed or other beans which
0:31:55Hope put it put attack and that will come back to RSS in a second
0:31:58But if you see that the verge is article is linking to a Bloomberg
0:32:04original and
0:32:07It's a couple other
0:32:09Sites that you're monitoring are also linking to this Bloomberg article that
0:32:13Automatically promotes the Bloomberg version of it in some way because it's hey
0:32:19we're monitoring these
0:32:22hundreds of
0:32:24Sources and a couple of them are all linking to the same original therefore that original get some implicit
0:32:30Credibility or importance because of that and I know that even in the early days of Google like 1998 it
0:32:38It wasn't quite so simplistic
0:32:41but at a high level it was the breakthrough that made Google search better than other search engines and
0:32:47It's sort of like that attack me. Yeah, it's the that's that's like a core idea
0:32:53But like with a million qualifications
0:32:55With all those little things to account for
0:32:58artifacts of the real world and then
0:33:01changes in media since
0:33:03Everyone's reticent to link to each other
0:33:05But still do it drives me nuts
0:33:08The one thing I see less and less these days. It does seem like at some point in the last
0:33:14Ten years the damn burst but it would drive me nuts in the first decade
0:33:21Let's say the aughts like 2000 to 2010
0:33:24When you could see that the New York Times had a house style not to link to other
0:33:30competitors and even if they credited as as first reported by the Washington Post comma
0:33:36Blank blank blank and it wouldn't be a link
0:33:39It would just be text in the article like it was copy and pasted out of the CMS
0:33:44They were using only for their newspaper, right?
0:33:47Like it was like the CMS and I know that it wasn't true
0:33:51Their website was way too good to just be a copy and paste job from the print version and they would have links to other
0:33:57things but not to the other publication that they were crediting with as
0:34:02first reported by right as first reported by is
0:34:05Always in the news industry so clearly begrudging, right? It is like nobody types that phrase
0:34:13except through gritted teeth
0:34:16And therefore it makes their links so stingy
0:34:19Yeah that well, obviously we didn't like that either because there's not the metadata to read in and inform our algorithm
0:34:26Yeah
0:34:27I don't know what broke that damn what was it was it the community of journalists and pressure peer pressure among among
0:34:33Those people or was or just readers demanded it because hey we're on the internet. Of course
0:34:37He fully I think it's sort of an age thing and that as the balance between
0:34:45people of the
0:34:47Well, right roughly my my age
0:34:49generation X people who grew up
0:34:52Creating the web it became
0:34:55Natural for them to think of their publication as web first and so therefore, of course
0:35:03This is gonna have to be a link if we're gonna mention the fact that so-and-so reported this or broke the story
0:35:09It should be a link to the actual thing that they reported
0:35:13Whereas the tail end of the boomer generation that's older than me. I think clearly
0:35:18Never it's a making a sweeping generalization about an entire generation of
0:35:25Professionals, but I think that they clearly to me never ever gave the web the respect it was due
0:35:33they always felt that they were writing for a whether it was if it's a New York Times for a printed newspaper or a
0:35:41Printed magazine or whatever and that the web was a a weird
0:35:47stepchild
0:35:49Medium that to them didn't deserve the respect it was due and I you know, I tried to guard against that myself personally, right?
0:35:56I'm not active on tick-tock to name one for example
0:36:00but I respect it right and when I read that 18 to
0:36:0429 year olds report that they get the majority of their news or like world affairs news from tick-tock
0:36:11It does make me roll my eyes
0:36:13But I feel like well
0:36:15It's a big pill to swallow but swallow it and deal with it because I think it's obviously true
0:36:20And so what's the point of me being a come up to curmudgeonly about it?
0:36:25Yeah, I think I think generational is a good explanation that maybe that was the biggest part of it. It's kind of funny
0:36:32How though now on Twitter? It's like we're moving backwards because of the algorithm people
0:36:38Will refer to something on a news site and they would just won't link to it
0:36:42They'll put a screenshot because the algorithm will ding link maybe ten minutes later though. Oh, and by the way, here's the link
0:36:48All right, I mentioned putting of attack in RSS I think the general consensus
0:36:57amongst people who care and
0:37:00Who really know what RSS means is?
0:37:05that RSS
0:37:07exploded onto the scene in the early aughts and
0:37:10Was awesome for news junkies and
0:37:16then Google Reader came on to the scene and a
0:37:22Added I
0:37:25would think fair to say millions of users who before that hadn't been using RSS at all be
0:37:32got millions of others to switch from whatever they were using before to Google Reader and then see I
0:37:40Forget how official their API was and how much was they didn't care that it was backwards engineered
0:37:48I think I think it was sort of that they just look the other way and they didn't care but
0:37:54Effectively allowed third-party aggregators
0:37:59Like net newswire at the time to use Google Reader as a sync engine
0:38:04So that you could subscribe to all your feeds in Google Reader and even if you didn't like their interface through the web
0:38:10You could use net newswire or a bunch of other feed readers on more than one device like your MacBook and your iPhone
0:38:17or your work desktop and your home Macintosh and
0:38:21sync the red and unread status of all your feeds and
0:38:26Then when Google pulled the plug on Google Reader unceremoniously and just say dab this Google Reader thing
0:38:32We're just gonna drop it and very quickly. They just pulled the plug and it went away
0:38:36that it effectively pulled the plug on RSS for users and that was that and I mean and that was like
0:38:4315 years ago. I mean that's a long time ago
0:38:46Do I think that's true?
0:38:49I think everything I said there is true
0:38:51But I kind of also think that even if Google it stuck with Google Reader something like that was gonna happen
0:38:57Anyway, I don't think RSS as a thriving
0:39:00This is the first primary way people are going to follow the news was long for the world
0:39:06Anyway, I think it was a utopian ideal, but it wasn't gonna work
0:39:10Because of the way shithead media executives think about protecting their content
0:39:17It has to be frustrating for you because when RSS was more thriving it had to make tech memes job easier on the back end
0:39:24Because you had good content to pull through RSS, which was already
0:39:29Prestructured data. Yeah, it was definitely great when a lot of sites actually put all their text in the RSS feed
0:39:36It's simplified the crawling but even when they didn't do that
0:39:40It still helped because if they have a snippet we would at least by checking the RSS feed know that new posts have appeared
0:39:48And then send a bot to fill in the rest and now a lot of sites don't even include that kind of feed
0:39:57That's been tougher. We have to make a
0:39:59Scraper basically for home pages to find like what are the new links that have appeared there?
0:40:05so the decline is cause all kinds of
0:40:09Problems, but the nice thing is I think there's still enough pressure
0:40:13That like most of the sites well a lot of say still have it
0:40:18I guess there's just enough users who complain and maybe new sites some of the bigger ones begrudgingly add
0:40:26Feeds with little snippets just to keep the most news addicted readers happy
0:40:32A lot of whom are probably bloggers and reporters at other sites who are more likely to link as well
0:40:38so the nice thing between that and also
0:40:42Companies like automatic just
0:40:45continuing to
0:40:47include feeds by default in WordPress blogs, I think it's going to
0:40:52Continue in a form that will be helpful
0:40:56But will a fall short of the dream that everyone had for RSS. Yeah
0:41:02yeah, I think tumblr has full feeds by default to which is owned by automatic and
0:41:08defaults really matter a lot and and I know that
0:41:11WordPress
0:41:13continues to have
0:41:15ridiculous stats for what percentage of
0:41:18the entire web if you just go by domain is powered by WordPress behind the scenes and
0:41:25The fact that they do include RSS by default and you have to take some kind of action to disable it. Yeah, that's great
0:41:32makes a difference but
0:41:35It's almost obvious I almost feel silly asking but yes, yeah in other words much much of what tech mean does is
0:41:42webpades crawling and
0:41:45Scraping of the HTML of
0:41:50Websites to sort of parse out the actual content of articles. Yeah
0:41:55Yeah, we've had to do that for the longest time and it gets it gets trickier too because thanks to AI and AI models
0:42:05a lot more and more sites are just let's just block all the bots is their approach and let's hire cloudflare to
0:42:12Force captions and it's just it's getting tougher and tougher
0:42:16Fortunately, like if you're if you're a big news site you start blocking tech memes car
0:42:21the good news is sometimes
0:42:23You're big enough to have a team where when I email and say hey, you're blocking us. We want to link to you more
0:42:31Can you please let her crawler in they'll say oh, yeah. Yeah
0:42:35Sometimes it takes three weeks to make that decision. Sometimes it takes a day, but we sometimes get that result
0:42:41but not always and then
0:42:43Sometimes we have to find other ways to crawl
0:42:45It's a mess and I don't like the trend but we're hanging in there. It's been true since the web was
0:42:53Obscure when it was still hey, have you heard of this thing called mosaic? Oh, yeah. Yeah. Yeah, that looks
0:43:01It's kind of cool or no. No, what's that? And it's like oh, it's a way to get on the internet other than through a terminal window
0:43:08And it's like what but ever, you know from the the beginning onward
0:43:13scraping HTML programmatically has always been a problem and
0:43:18there was a sort of
0:43:20Delightful heyday in the very early aughts where the sort of web standards
0:43:29Jeffrey Zeldman spearheaded I think sort of hey let's as professionals
0:43:34Be proud of the fact that our websites are actually written through
0:43:38Proper HTML that you can run through a syntax checker and we'll say yes. This is actually
0:43:45syntactically correct HTML
0:43:49Even at the heyday of that movement which coincides with like the early years of daring fireball
0:43:54I think the early years of tech meme it was still a
0:43:58Very few number of websites that could possibly run through
0:44:02Like the w3c syntax checker and actually come out a green check mark
0:44:07Famously difficult famously, you know
0:44:11There be dragons when you start to parse
0:44:14HTML programmatically and you know, I love everybody who not everybody but people who know my own
0:44:23Programming skills know that I have a weird knack for writing regular expressions
0:44:29It's just I I'm like a savant at it and famously
0:44:33People are tempted to use regular expressions to parse HTML and they're like a don't parse HTML on your own B
0:44:40Don't do not do it with regular expressions C
0:44:43Repeat a and B just don't do it one thing I have found I don't need to scrape but I wrote a couple of
0:44:53shortcuts for iOS and one of them is a way that I make little notes to myself with the title of a put like here's
0:45:00A post I might want to link to from daring fireball, but only when I'm back on my Mac
0:45:05I want to send it to my notes app with just the title of the page in the URL and save it in this same note
0:45:12put the new one at the top so I when I go to it the newest things are at the top and
0:45:16Just getting the title of the web page from shortcuts is actually very easy
0:45:22if web pages actually had a title tag, but it is
0:45:28remarkable how many web pages and of CMS's
0:45:33have like
0:45:36Dozens or like titles for every article and that's it
0:45:39HTML like simple simple
0:45:42HTML is not complicated lay people can easily be taught the basics of
0:45:50HTML tags and the title is it's by definition. There's one per page
0:45:55it is a thing that goes in the header of the HTML, but
0:45:59at this point because my little shortcut when it says get the title if there's more than one it presents them in a list and
0:46:06It's surprise. It's it's like the majority of websites have more than one title, which is
0:46:12So semantically incorrect that I don't even know where to start. I cannot believe that anybody
0:46:18Would do this and yet and I think it's I just bring it up as one example among probably
0:46:24Thousands that that your scraper must have to handle. Yeah
0:46:30Seen a lot of stuff over the years like even from the beginning even in the odds
0:46:34We need to handle some JavaScript some dynamic code like maybe to put the date
0:46:39But now nowadays there are some like some new sites. I'll go to it. They're not serving
0:46:46HTML they're serving like JSON and some JavaScript is assembling the page
0:46:51Right, and so you can't call that with something that reads
0:46:54HTML for a while I was over time slowly building like kind of like a
0:46:58Browser that I just kept adding stuff to it
0:47:02Okay
0:47:02like I
0:47:03Like I'll interpret this new CSS tag because I need to know when something's bold because those titles are bold
0:47:09I kept adding to it and adding to it and
0:47:12So I had my little shadow browser running inside the tech me back in over time
0:47:17but at some point I just gave up and
0:47:20For some sites just have to use a browser because of all the dynamic stuff. Yeah, I think
0:47:25Guessing Google does that too? Yeah, you have to use it
0:47:29To get the test so in other words the back end has to have an actual real web browser
0:47:35involved at a certain point to run things through the browser first and then
0:47:41parse the
0:47:43Computed rendered page that the browser is presenting
0:47:48Right Chrome is nice about that Chrome has a an option
0:47:52You can run from the command line and dump the DOM and then parse that using your HTML parser. That's Andy
0:47:59I hope chromium keeps getting those updates
0:48:01Yeah
0:48:02I hope so, too
0:48:02And I feel like it probably will because I feel like you said Google itself probably uses it and it's not the sort of thing
0:48:09That they have to worry about. Oh
0:48:11But what if the whole world starts using Chrome from the command line is no the whole world normal people are did
0:48:17It would never even occur to them to do it. It's not any kind of threat to the traffic
0:48:21They're getting to their actual consumer properties. Their special sauce is way it goes way beyond their crawler
0:48:28I mean they're crawling is I'm sure some top-notch technology there, but there's so much to Google
0:48:34They're they're fine
0:48:35And also they get access
0:48:37No one blocks Google if you want Google to if you want to appear in Google
0:48:41You're gonna make sure Google can crawl you and you can just as well block every other
0:48:45type of crawler out there and and and it won't hurt you and then that'll hurt me and
0:48:51That's when I'll send that email
0:48:54All right, let me take another break here and thank our next sponsor and it's our good friends at memberful
0:49:02memberful is a way that if you have your own online property or brand or
0:49:07Whatever you have an audience and you would like to offer a membership system to your audience
0:49:15Memberful is the way to go and you're crazy if you don't start by at least looking at it
0:49:21Memberful you always a have full control and ownership of your audience and your brand
0:49:27So if you ever do want to move on to something else something custom-made
0:49:30You take your audience with you you get the full list of subscribers
0:49:33The payments always go through your stripe account so you could just move as they couldn't make it easier
0:49:41To move if you wanted to but you won't want to I don't even know anybody who started with memberful has moved on
0:49:48They make it easy because they're so confident in their service that you won't want to they make it easy
0:49:53But it gives you that peace of mind that you're building your brand and you're still in control of it
0:49:59They fade in the background memberful so that your business is front and center
0:50:03Your your members probably won't even know that memberful is in between that's how seamless it is
0:50:08And they integrate with all of the tools you already use including services like MailChimp
0:50:14WordPress which Gabe and I mentioned stripe discord and more
0:50:19These are all your accounts you plug into your accounts and they they just connect to your accounts at those services
0:50:26But so for things like discord
0:50:28They make it so that you can run a members only discord through their system
0:50:34Which is if that's what you want to do. You don't have to set it up yourself. They handle the integration on their own
0:50:40It's really great. Everything you need to run a membership program goes through memberful. They've got analytics and they've got
0:50:47absolutely great tech support and
0:50:49almost
0:50:51Consulting advice where they know what works for other successful membership systems and they can help
0:50:57Steer you and answer your questions for how you should set up yours to be successful because they know what works and what doesn't
0:51:03Absolutely. Terrific. I subscribe to at least half a dozen memberful sites things like six colors
0:51:10Relay.fm a bunch of them and I just love it. I'm happy happy happy subscriber to so many memberful sites
0:51:17It's great as a user. It would be great as a creator
0:51:20So get started for free at memberful if you want to know credit card required
0:51:26Just go to memberful.com
0:51:28Slash talk show that's memberful.com
0:51:32Slash talk show and monetize your passion with member memberful
0:51:38All right RSS we kind of touched on there and the decline of it
0:51:44Has been it's irritating to me
0:51:47But to me the biggest bane of my existence at daring fireball and it must be for you, too
0:51:54Is the rise of paywalls? I mean, do you agree?
0:51:58Yeah, and I and I totally get it. This is not a complaint
0:52:02About the decision. It's just a complaint about the experience in a lot of reading scenarios
0:52:10And of course in a web crawling scenario once again, a lot of big publishers have been
0:52:17Kind enough to approve our crawler so that helps and another nice thing even when they haven't
0:52:24Like we haven't talked to them because so many
0:52:26publishers have like a trial
0:52:30Option, like, you know like a meter paywall that won't put the wall up until you've visited so many times
0:52:37It turns out those are easy to crawl
0:52:40You in most in most cases, right? So if you've already got a programmatic scraper
0:52:45It's kind of easy to tell it to delete the cache
0:52:51Of cookies for the New York Times every 20 visits or whatever. I mean, I would hold the tile
0:52:58I mentioned the times because they're obviously a major source of news across all fields and I also feel that
0:53:05That the way they've implemented their paywall is about as good and friendly
0:53:11to everybody as it could be where they have a generous allotment of
0:53:17Free page views a month for people who don't pay they've got enough content and you know
0:53:23And they publicly held company and they announced their numbers. They are pretty successfully
0:53:28Navigating the shift from print to web right? I mean print the writings been on
0:53:35I mean, I've known it since the web was created instantly. I knew print was going to be killed off
0:53:41I just didn't know how long it would take but a lot of other sites
0:53:44Are not so friendly
0:53:48I would say Bloomberg is a good example of a site that is to me kind of hostile
0:53:54Even as and I pay for a Bloomberg subscription
0:53:56This is one good measurement of how hostile a paywall is is how annoying it is to be an honest paying subscriber
0:54:03In a if you're still frequently logged out which I am at Bloomberg very frequently. That's a paddling
0:54:09You should go to the principal's office and get spanked. Yeah, Bloomberg is tough for
0:54:16Subscribers the experience could be much better. I'm a subscriber, too
0:54:20I think the last time I logged in I needed to complete a capture if I recall correctly
0:54:25Yeah, I think but one nice thing about Bloomberg is they to have I think it's very limited
0:54:30But still some kind of metered situation where you can see a page like one article maybe
0:54:37You guys have and going back to Technorati and the concept of leaderboards you guys do publish
0:54:46leaderboards in various rankings
0:54:48Bloomberg to me is an outlier at least amongst people who know who I am and listen to this podcast know that I have a
0:54:57particular
0:54:58obsession with with their big hack story from
0:55:012020 and their refusal
0:55:04Absolute steadfast refusal to acknowledge that they botched it on it
0:55:09And so I love to bring it up as frequently as I can with a footnote when they're reporting on unrelated things
0:55:15but
0:55:17sometimes people ask me right they know that I love to bring that up and
0:55:21They're like why even link to them in the first place instead of linking to them with this footnote that brings up this
0:55:28Story that you're highly critical of why not just not link to them and my answer is they're too good not to
0:55:35Right. They're a bizarre to me
0:55:38News culture, but they are a scoop machine by design
0:55:45Yeah, it's it's there they're so far ahead of other
0:55:49business publications and in publishing stuff that like you where you need to
0:55:55Link to them if you want to if you want to know to report it first
0:56:00It's definitely like more in the long tail
0:56:03I don't think they show up so much in the links that like mass audiences are linking to on social media to complain about
0:56:11Politicians they hate or whatever. It's just more like in all these nice industries. They they're
0:56:18reporting
0:56:20Lots of little things first and it adds up to so many so many links
0:56:26So yeah there at the top of our leaderboard
0:56:28I'm starting to build this little community on discord where we share a number of like feeds useful for
0:56:35People in different scenarios and one of the one type of feed we have is if you're a publisher
0:56:40you can see when other tech sites are linking to your work and
0:56:43The volume of Bloomberg there is just so it's so high compared to all the other publishers
0:56:50It's an outlier, right? I think part of it is and I've mentioned this and I do
0:56:55I I guess I am critical of it. I because I think it's a worrisome practice and no one's ever denied it
0:57:02So I'm about as sure that it's true as could possibly be and I've spoken to people who've confirmed it off the record
0:57:09but that they have a
0:57:11bonus structure within the company that as a reporter at Bloomberg your
0:57:16Bonus is tied to the the number of times throughout the year
0:57:22I don't know if it's an annual bonus or quarterly or how often they pay it but that you get a financial bonus
0:57:27For quote-unquote market moving news
0:57:30so if you're writing again, obviously my sphere of interest is off obviously often Apple Center and if you post something about Apple and
0:57:38Immediately after posting it their stock goes down
0:57:422.37 percent or something like that you get paid a bonus for that whether it goes up or down and the well
0:57:50Why do they pay that way?
0:57:51It's obvious because they're the main way they make money is by selling Bloomberg terminal access and
0:57:58Bloomberg terminals are insanely expensive there. I forget I think it's like 20,000 a year
0:58:04Per seat to start and that you can't even get one you can't even if you want to pay the money
0:58:10You can't just say here. Here's $20,000. Give me a Bloomberg terminal for the next year. You still have to get approved
0:58:17Which is bizarre, but the idea and I think it's actually true
0:58:22Is that Bloomberg publishes their own original reporting through the terminal?
0:58:27First with I think about a 15-minute window and so if you subscribe to the Bloomberg terminal
0:58:33You have the opportunity to read Bloomberg's original reporting 15 minutes before the rest of the world sees it on
0:58:40Bloomberg calm and if you think this news is very good or very bad for the company being reported on
0:58:48You have this window of opportunity to trade their stock accordingly that others don't have and that's what they're selling
0:58:56Bloomberg terminal subscriptions and therefore the they need
0:59:01original reporting that is market moving news and
0:59:04therefore there's this
0:59:06motivation for their reporters to
0:59:09Contextualize what they're reporting in market moving ways, which I think is often to me sensational
0:59:17Yeah, it's something I've looked at with that lens
0:59:21So that all I I can't give an informed view on this, but I can see how that way of
0:59:29motivating their reporters leads to both producing good work that needs to be cited and
0:59:34Also tempting them to distort things. I guess with all you know
0:59:39In management who said it like you start measuring one thing you have to like come up with a measure for the opposite thing because it's
0:59:46Gonna be abused. Yeah, or be careful what you measure, you know, I guess is good advice. I
0:59:51Do know and for example and again just the intersection of?
0:59:57Daring fireball Bloomberg and tech meme
1:00:00Mark Gurman who like I forget how many years now he's been on the Apple beat at Bloomberg
1:00:08But came to Bloomberg from 9 to 5 Mac where he was writing as a teenager and college student. I mean
1:00:15To say that he was precocious is it's hard to imagine how he could have been much younger
1:00:20When he first started writing for 9 to 5 Mac and getting these scores
1:00:24But on the tech meme leaderboard
1:00:27Gurman was off the charts near the top for like the Apple related sphere and
1:00:35I I think that tech memes actual ranking of it
1:00:40I think people even if tech meme didn't exist or tech meme didn't publish that leaderboard. I think it was pretty obvious
1:00:46Gurman's
1:00:48unique stature
1:00:50Covering Apple and he might have likely been made an offer from Bloomberg anyway
1:00:55but I've heard that that was part of what led them to say we've got to hire this kid because look at how
1:01:02influential he is in this world about this company that is a humongous and B
1:01:07people care about
1:01:09And he's still there, right? He's
1:01:11Incred you know Bloomberg itself overall is very influential at tech memes leaderboards
1:01:16But Gurman in particular as a reporter in the tech sphere is way near the top deservedly. So
1:01:22Yeah, I haven't heard that but I I know he's been he's always been very tech meme aware and sometimes we talk about it
1:01:29I was referenced as tech meme would spill into Twitter and he wasn't shy about that and and I you know, by the way
1:01:36I know mark not super well, but I I see him at events and stuff
1:01:40I remember meeting him once when he was he was that teenager. Yeah, he's uh, he's probably he's probably still the top of our
1:01:46author leaderboard
1:01:48Yes, our leaderboards are like well, there's a whole history with of them and it's part it's probably like can get a little boring but
1:01:57one way we can be helpful to a lot of companies and comms people in particular in companies is to provide lists of
1:02:05the reporters who basically
1:02:07dominate that area or are prominent in certain spaces like AI or
1:02:14Security or Apple or whatever. So we used to have this general leaderboard
1:02:19but we like who's on tech meme the most but
1:02:22Ultimately that wasn't too too helpful because there are just a lot of reasons posts end up on tech meme that aren't necessarily
1:02:30Aligned with having scoops or being like thought leaders exactly if you're fast to important stories that also helps you get on tech me
1:02:39but anyway, once we introduce all these leaderboards on different topics that you know, that's actually a helpful product for a lot of people and
1:02:46When you look at any of these reports, it's not the exact order that matters like, you know
1:02:52Number one versus number three usually isn't too meaningful. It's just like if you look at the top
1:02:5720
1:02:58You'll probably have some good ideas of people to reach out to if you want to pitch some
1:03:04Whatever new social network or something
1:03:07Let me just take a break out and and then we'll we'll hit the finish line
1:03:10but let me take a break right there and I'll thank our third and final sponsor of the episode and it's our
1:03:15Long-term sponsor are very good friends at Squarespace. You guys know Squarespace. It is the all-in-one
1:03:22platform for publishing on the web
1:03:26Lord only knows how many Squarespace sites are out there that I have linked to over the years
1:03:31It is just a wonderful wonderful platform that handles
1:03:35Literally everything you need to create your own presence online everything from domain name registration
1:03:41to picking a template from
1:03:44Hundreds of templates you can choose from that are all professionally designed
1:03:49look great on everything from a phone to a giant studio display and
1:03:54everything in between and that you can customize out as
1:03:58little or as much as you want through a
1:04:03totally visual drag-and-drop interface or
1:04:06through HTML CSS JavaScript if you want to and you know how to
1:04:11Actually write code and want to do it on your own you could do it that way or you could do it visually their new
1:04:17Fluid engine which is their name for the new WYSIWYG editor that most people use
1:04:22Is the their best way of doing it that they've ever had and the big big difference between what they call the fluid engine and?
1:04:30This the engine they had before is that the fluid engine works?
1:04:34Absolutely great even on the phone our touchscreen little tiny touchscreen display
1:04:40You can actually drag and drop to design a website right there
1:04:44Which is let's face it the phone is the primary computer for a growing growing number of people and as I always
1:04:51Always love to reiterate when Squarespace sponsors the show
1:04:54It's not just for you the nerd is listening to the talk show with John Gruber who might want to build a website with
1:05:02Squarespace, but it's the people who come to you and say hey
1:05:05nerd I
1:05:07Need a website or I have an old website that I want to update where should I go to do it?
1:05:12Tell them Squarespace first give them the URL from here and they'll even if they don't listen to the show
1:05:18They'll still get credit for it. Which is all I want go to squarespace.com
1:05:23Slash talk show squarespace.com
1:05:25Slash talk show and by going to that website first
1:05:30They get or you if you sign up get 10% off your first purchase of a domain
1:05:36Or a website using that code so why even care about giving my custom version of their thing well
1:05:43They save 10% so I get credit for it. They save 10%
1:05:46squarespace.com
1:05:48slash talk show
1:05:51All right, I feel like there's a big topic which is why I wanted to get the third sponsor spot out of the way
1:05:57But to me the other factor in RSS is demise
1:06:02Other than Google Reader having the plug sort of unceremoniously pulled out of it
1:06:08It could be you can't prove it without somehow having an alternate
1:06:12multiverse where
1:06:15Google Reader is still with existed but
1:06:18Looking back on it the decline of RSS and the decline of plain old-fashioned blogging
1:06:26coincides with the rise of Twitter and
1:06:28to me it's
1:06:31It would be a very hard argument to make that they're not
1:06:34Related. I mean we could get into the we have a lot to talk about with Twitter
1:06:38but I'm curious whether at first whether you saw the rise of Twitter and tweeting as
1:06:44helpful to
1:06:46Tech memes purpose or a hindrance. Yeah, there's a lot to look at there
1:06:52I mean, it's both it's always both
1:06:55Twitter definitely
1:06:57I'm convinced it was it was the biggest factor in
1:07:00Blogging's decline you can just look at the people who their posts went down as their tweets went up
1:07:05there's so many bloggers and
1:07:08Apparently not all of them probably not you but maybe I don't know maybe some of your quick posts became tweets
1:07:13I guess we didn't really do much about Twitter for the first year
1:07:16or two well very early on we were posting the Twitter because I got that people wanted to see tech meme headlines
1:07:23So we were doing that one in March
1:07:252007 but at some point
1:07:28The next thing to do is to see what people are linking to on Twitter
1:07:33Because when people are linking to less on blogs and linking to more on Twitter
1:07:38Then you got to get those links from Twitter to feed into our algorithm
1:07:41And so we found some ways to do that
1:07:44Fortunately when it comes to like informing a news algorithm for an industry niche like tech meme does
1:07:51You don't actually need like the fire hose. You don't need this massive access to what's going on in Twitter
1:07:58You just need a smart place of Twitter
1:08:00So we did that fairly early on and it helped us but you know, it would have been better like in some
1:08:06hypothetical world where
1:08:09Everyone just kept blogging and it just got a little more real time
1:08:12Like, you know, maybe RSS aggregators found a way to just get the post instantly and apps made it super easy
1:08:19So that Twitter never had a wedge. I mean that would be a superior world for tech meme and I guess mastodon and
1:08:26federated open source approaches now are
1:08:30reviving that promise
1:08:32but a lot more a lot of more things need to fall in place before we begin to see that reach even like
1:08:395% of where it could go. It's like in some ways Twitter as originally conceived is one of the
1:08:48To me great accomplishments of the entire world wide web. Hey, and I still think the basic idea is because it was
1:08:55Democratizing to
1:08:59posting your own
1:09:01Stuff on the web which I think was central to the concept of the world wide web. Yes discovered
1:09:08Yeah, it was a natural natural thing waiting to be discovered. I've often
1:09:12revisited this idea of
1:09:15user interfaces
1:09:17friction and that reducing friction is
1:09:21Vastly overlooked as something that should be
1:09:27Strived for in design to make things as frictionless as possible because it's just good a it's just better like an
1:09:35Interface that feels like you don't have to fight it that is actually helping you accomplish that whatever it is is
1:09:40Good for you the user and so therefore
1:09:43a sort of design priority that makes users happy is
1:09:48In and of itself a good thing
1:09:51But it also makes it more popular and makes it useful people stick with things with less friction, but I do think
1:09:58Twitter is so friction free
1:10:02that
1:10:05Blogging almost couldn't compete with it right like however easy
1:10:08WordPress made it to
1:10:11Post a new blog post once you've set up your blog in WordPress
1:10:19Making a new post it's
1:10:21There's a little bit more inherent friction
1:10:24Even if you only have two fields in your CMS title and then content that's versus Twitter where it's just one field
1:10:31it's just a box what's happening and you just type in the box and
1:10:35On the one hand that's worse because titles are useful semantic content
1:10:42But it's better in terms of friction and the less friction
1:10:48It just people end up going that way
1:10:51I do think I think you're right that I even me who has a website that has supported
1:10:57short-form link posts where the primary purpose is here's the primary link from what I'm linking to is to this article at the
1:11:06verge or
1:11:08six colors or
1:11:09Wherever else and here's a quote from the article and here's my two cents or my thoughts about why I'm linking to it
1:11:16I think I've done it less there were times it like the peak of my Twitter usage maybe midway through the teens
1:11:24Where it kind of occurred to me like hey
1:11:27I should be posting this on my website first and just if it's gonna be on Twitter
1:11:31Let it go through the ad during fireball account. I should not be tweeting so much from ad Gruber. I
1:11:37Should be putting it on my website and but it's like even me who has a website that supported it. I
1:11:45Was doing it less because it was easier and the pressure was lower right I think my tweets are mostly
1:11:51Grammatically correct and well punctuated and whatever just because I'm old-fashioned that way
1:11:58But it still feels like less it always felt like less pressure
1:12:02it let alone the fact that most publications don't have a
1:12:09Format for their reporters to post the equivalent of a link post. So therefore if they couldn't you can't go through
1:12:16Bloomberg or the New York Times or the Wall Street Journal if you work there full-time, there's no equivalent of my link post
1:12:22So if you're a reporter for them and you have something you want to link out
1:12:26You could do it on Twitter or not at all. And so they did it on Twitter
1:12:30Yeah, and I think we're really worked and I think the way that tech meme for a while
1:12:37I forget when you started doing it, but it's I don't remember when you didn't but let's just say there's a
1:12:43Top story of the day is some report from the verge about topic X
1:12:49And then there's a bunch of links from a bunch of other sites that are linking about the same thing
1:12:55And then there's a section underneath that'll say Twitter or I guess now I get it's X
1:13:00Colon and then there might be dozens sometimes several dozen
1:13:06tweets that are all linked under the same article in tech me and
1:13:11You don't even have to open them all in little tabs because they're tweets
1:13:14You could just hover if you're on a desktop computer
1:13:17you can just hover the mouse over them and the hover text will show you the whole tweet because tweets are little and
1:13:23in that sense tweets haven't competed with blogging per se but but they
1:13:29completely
1:13:31usurped the
1:13:33Comments that used to be per post and were per CMS and therefore were off in their own universe
1:13:39It's like a universal commenting platform, which in theory is great. And I think was good for tech meme. Is that how you see?
1:13:47Tweets overall in the tech meme context as sort of the universal comment platform
1:13:54they usually have a
1:13:57comment type function when they're on tech meme and they aren't comments that we
1:14:02You know own
1:14:03So if you see a good tweet on tech meme
1:14:06You don't share the tech meme link once in a while a tweet will also be the news headline doesn't happen too often
1:14:11You know
1:14:12usually if we wait five minutes will get a post from a blog that just adds more contacts and that'll be preferable but
1:14:19Sometimes sometimes sweet to the news as well. Yeah. Yeah, you see it with like in my sphere like Ming Chi Khloa
1:14:26Or somebody like that will sometimes tweet something that is big news
1:14:29But then it sooner rather than later somebody like Mac rumors or somebody is going to have an actual article
1:14:35That's more of a canonical source for the news
1:14:38Yeah explains where it fits in a little bit of history a little bit of context and even for an industry audience
1:14:45That's preferable to link to as our top headline in most cases
1:14:49How do you see the arc of?
1:14:54Twitter over the years. I know that's sort of an open-ended question
1:14:59but I'm curious because I feel like your perspective on it is
1:15:04if not representative of the Twitter user base overall, it's representative of
1:15:10My audience's view of Twitter as a sort of aggregator of news and a state of source
1:15:17so
1:15:20even before
1:15:21Elon Musk took over people referred to it as the hell site
1:15:25so there are all these dynamics that were corrosive and it made people feel bad to go there and so on but I
1:15:31Didn't think of it that way and I I didn't experience that for me
1:15:36It really was that hive brain that attracted a lot of people who?
1:15:41Had smart things to say about the news often in a fun funny way. It was really powerful and
1:15:47we needed tweets to complete the picture and
1:15:53For on tech meme and so it was important to include those tweets and crawl them
1:15:57If there's a headline on tech meme we were using the API to like find
1:16:01Tweets that link to it so that we could recommend them to our editors to add to the site
1:16:07And that's how a bunch of tweets would appear over the year
1:16:11So it it just seemed to get more and more important
1:16:13But that has crested because of something that happened last year and it's not just because we stopped using their API
1:16:20I guess we could use their API again if we paid a lot of money and rebuild it
1:16:25But it just doesn't seem worth it to us people with good contacts added to news really are
1:16:31Starting to leave Twitter and it's still got maybe more than half of what it had
1:16:35But it's missing a lot and it's and it's dispersing. It's not unfortunately. It's not in one. Well, maybe fortunately
1:16:42It's not in just some one new social network. You gotta you gotta
1:16:47Go to threads for for some of this you got to go to Mastodon for some of it LinkedIn
1:16:52We'll have some of it and that's that also is reflected on tech meme. It's kind of ridiculous now
1:16:56You'll look under some of the the bigger
1:16:58News headlines and there'll be sections for LinkedIn blue sky threads Mastodon
1:17:04yeah, I just
1:17:07Looked I computed something right before I got on with on this podcast and I guess in October
1:17:152022 we had seven thousand thirty one tweets on
1:17:19Tech me throughout the month and now in October 2023
1:17:235036 so, you know, it's it's down 30%
1:17:27It's down but not out but a lot more threads a lot more LinkedIn a lot more Mastodon
1:17:33Well, it's got to be all new threads because threads didn't exist in October 22, right? Yeah and and blue sky
1:17:41My basic theory and I think it's true is that Twitter suffered under
1:17:47the way that
1:17:51the market for publicly held companies works where
1:17:55being profitable
1:17:58Alone and sustainable isn't isn't enough that you it's viewed as a failure to be anything less than
1:18:05the leader or
1:18:09Peer amongst the leaders and
1:18:11In the Apple context and I think it's I think it's a useful analogy
1:18:17but like in then especially the late 90s like when the
1:18:20When Apple acquired next and the Steve Jobs regime from next came in and took over
1:18:26Apple, you know had I don't know five percent market share or something like that or depending on where you measured it or at least in
1:18:34The US they did and it was a good five percent market share because they all even back then sold more expensive computers than other companies
1:18:41but they were
1:18:43essentially considered in the business press a complete failure because Microsoft and Intel were so much bigger and that the drumbeat was they
1:18:51Apple should just do what Microsoft does and when that was
1:18:54Microsoft makes billions where Apple makes millions because Microsoft licenses their OS to PC makers
1:19:02Therefore Apple should license their operating system and then eventually Apple is like fine
1:19:08We'll do it and they license these clone makers and I know it is like that of all the things Apple has ever done
1:19:14Since the two Steve's were in a garage
1:19:17The weirdest period of Apple was the period where there were Macintosh clones
1:19:22I think I think for people younger people who didn't live through it
1:19:26I really think it's people would think that it was a prank and that you've photoshopped the articles about these companies
1:19:32That did it and one of the first things Steve Jobs did when he came back and became the I CEO was just canceled
1:19:38Unser just said you know what? This is terrible. It's killing us
1:19:41We're gonna get rid of it, but the basic idea was just look this company is so much bigger than you
1:19:46That's what they're doing. You should do it too. And then in the Twitter context, it's the comparison to Facebook, right? Facebook is
1:19:54so much bigger than Twitter ever could have been and
1:20:01The basic and the idea is well, they're both social networks where you go and post things
1:20:07so therefore Twitter's measuring stick was always against Facebook and
1:20:12It wasn't enough for Twitter to just let it be what it was going to be it
1:20:18Because they were being measured against Facebook. They tried things that I think were contrary
1:20:26To what Twitter should have been and it was to the detriment of the site and then it only
1:20:31well
1:20:33Once Musk took over a year ago that was out the door because now all of a sudden instead of answering to shareholders
1:20:39They're they're answering to one shareholder, right?
1:20:42So everything changed when he took over but up until that point
1:20:46I think the reason Twitter was even available to be taken over was the fact that they sort of flailed in that
1:20:54comparison I was thinking about it today in my post about this
1:20:57coyote versus Acme movie that time Warner had commissioned a
1:21:04complete major motion picture with a 90 million dollar budget a major star John Cena a
1:21:10Fantastic premise where the idea is the wily coyote from the Bugs Bunny cartoons is suing the Acme
1:21:16Corporation who sold them all of these gadgets he used through the years to try to catch the Roadrunner and
1:21:22It's sort of a Roger Rabbit sort of live-action slash animation thing and that they
1:21:28Decided for tax purposes to just never release this finished movie
1:21:33because
1:21:35David Zaslav the CEO just somehow this somebody did the math and said it would actually be better for us
1:21:40financially to just shelve this movie and never release it and
1:21:44It made me think of this quote from Walt Disney
1:21:48Probably close to 100 years ago at this point, but at least like 80 years ago, but the quote is we don't we Disney
1:21:55don't make
1:21:57Movies to make money we make money so we can make more movies, right?
1:22:01Disney was in the content business and first as a priority and they wanted to be profitable doing so so they could keep doing it
1:22:10whereas
1:22:11Obviously anybody who's the CEO of a movie studio who would be willing to do what they've done with this
1:22:18Coyote vs. Acme movie has their priorities the other way around and I kind of feel like you and I are
1:22:24Some pot to go in in this regard like I don't run daring fireball to be the most profitable thing imaginable
1:22:31I'm glad it is profitable glad I make a living at it
1:22:34I'm very gratified but my goal has always been I want to this is what I want to write
1:22:39I want to write these weird long
1:22:415,000 word articles reviewing a new
1:22:44iPhone that would never be able to run at that length anywhere else and also post weird little
1:22:5150 word links and
1:22:53If I make a good living then that's good enough and I feel like tech meme has always been like that too
1:23:00Like you have a vision for what tech means serves and the point isn't how do you make the most money?
1:23:05The point is how do you make money at all to keep it afloat while you're doing it? Would you agree with that?
1:23:10It's just thing to solve except I always would like to make more money as it turns out but well
1:23:16I mean, I'm with you there, but for sure there were hills
1:23:22we could have attempted to climb which would have been the wrong hills to climb and
1:23:27Part of that reason is because it would make tech meme crappier for its readers in ways that you're talking about here
1:23:35I think we did see the same with Twitter like they wanted to get impressions and maybe they should
1:23:40Come up with some API access scheme. I mean, I don't know exactly what what would have been optimal for them
1:23:47But it's too late for that now
1:23:49yeah, I like
1:23:52quality of experiences
1:23:54And maintaining it in the face of so much change is important for us
1:24:00I'm also hoping that that'll unlock new business opportunities. That'll make things more lucrative so I can
1:24:08Pay all our editors more money
1:24:10Well, let me just put it this way as an admitted daily reader of tech me for as long as I can remember tech mean
1:24:18Existing so at this point 20 years give or take I can't remember tech meme
1:24:24Ever once getting worse. It's evolved over the years and it has changed
1:24:30But I can't remember any time where it's oh this changed at tech meme
1:24:35Want one that's kind of I see why they did it is to make more money but blank
1:24:39Oh now you can only see three times a day and then it cuts you off and asks for you to subscribe
1:24:45Like you can only - there's no now there's a paywall just to read tech me or something like that
1:24:51And it's never once happened. And I think it's because you're prioritized
1:24:55First yes, you it is a very important priority for the company to be profitable and sustainable
1:25:03Going forward in the face of all this change in the media world, but never more important than well
1:25:09Let's just make sure it stays great for our readers
1:25:11yeah, happy to hear that and I I
1:25:15Hope it's true for everyone and it's something we work to uphold. I
1:25:20Putting myself on the back now. Yeah. Well, let me pat you on it. I'll do the back padding for you
1:25:26It is a great resource, but the Twitter format to me
1:25:31It's genius in its simplicity
1:25:33right that you just pick people to follow and everybody can just pull at the top for a decade or two is
1:25:40140 characters, but you've got this severely limited character count per quote post and
1:25:46Out of that limit necessity is the mother
1:25:50invention it made people creative and there are a
1:25:54lot of people who
1:25:58Aren't you know, you see it when you get emails from them, right? Most emails would be so much better off
1:26:04if they had the same character constraints as Twitter and
1:26:07everybody out there knows the people who you're either your colleagues or people at other companies that you deal with who
1:26:14send
1:26:17emails that you have to scroll to read the whole thing and that should have been tweet length and so
1:26:22Mandating that length on everybody a was a great benefit, but B it just gave people a platform
1:26:29That they wouldn't have and yes in a way that it's this massive trade-off where it didn't kill blogging
1:26:35But it greatly reduced blogging still exists and blogging is still great
1:26:39It's obviously far less common as a practice than it was at its peak which was pre Twitter
1:26:45But on the whole more people are posting more of their thoughts
1:26:50post 2006 because of Twitter and now Twitter like things but
1:26:55I've seen this frustration in my personal usage, right? I use all of them
1:27:01I have I'm on still on Twitter X whatever you want to call it. I'm on threads and really like it
1:27:07I've been on Mastodon for years
1:27:09But really got active on it once musk took over Twitter last year and I've been on blue sky
1:27:15Since I got in the invitation system at some point
1:27:19It is though as a just as a user
1:27:22mentally
1:27:25Exhausting to keep up with more than one of these services
1:27:29it was so much easier when the only Twitter like thing that I cared about was Twitter itself and
1:27:36Now that there are multiple Twitter like things that I do care about and want to keep up keep up with in some regard
1:27:45each additional one
1:27:48Like multiplies the mental
1:27:50Exhaustion I feel of having to keep up with them and I'm curious for you because you
1:27:57You guys keep track of all of them as a source for commentary on your articles. Do you do you think it's
1:28:05is it better for tech meme and or the world at large that there's sort of
1:28:14Fragmentation in this card and we're not we're not dependent on just one
1:28:18Source Twitter or is it worse overall because now there's fragmentation
1:28:23Sorry, I'm one of these people who will say it's both but it's it's definitely from a user perspective
1:28:29It's usually if you're going for completeness. It's it's harder and it's more annoying
1:28:35You have to check multiple things
1:28:38Fortunately, it's if it's a story on tech meme you can look under tech meme and see our roundup and hopefully that's good
1:28:44But you know in general for keeping up all this happening on social networks
1:28:48Like there are a bunch you have to use and I do do that
1:28:52like I I still go to Twitter for like my war news and
1:28:55AI tweeters and then I go to
1:28:58threads for kind of like the tech
1:29:01pundits for a lot of tech pundits now and then a little bit of
1:29:05Mastodon and blue sky on the tech. What is as far as what it means for tech meme?
1:29:10It's maybe it's like a little bit of a moat I guess but it's not like we have
1:29:14competitors in what we do
1:29:16This past year the amount of stuff we needed to build has been daunting
1:29:21like we're using all we're using blue sky API is we're using Mastodon API's and
1:29:27I'm really hoping
1:29:30To tie all this together is there's this promise of Federation if the Reds actually hooks up to activity pub then
1:29:37Threads and Mastodon will in some ways be one thing and you'll be able to get your threads
1:29:43posts on Mastodon and tech meme will be able to
1:29:46Crawl threads posts in an automatic way through Mastodon API's and it'll go both ways and it'll be great
1:29:53I just hope Facebook doesn't find a reason to say actually nevermind
1:29:57Right right now threads has no API at all, which is
1:30:03Not surprising at all as a Facebook property because I think Facebook has had some sort of API in the past
1:30:12but in general over the length of the company, they just have not been API driven and therefore as
1:30:18opposed to Twitter which
1:30:21Part of you know, the Musk era the first major controversy under his ownership was him
1:30:28cutting off the API that third-party apps could use like tweet bot and Twitter if ik and those things were instead of using Twitter as
1:30:37your app as a user you could use these third-party things and they
1:30:42Long before Musk took over for the early years
1:30:45They loved those third parties and they got you know talking to Craig Hockenberry at the icon factory
1:30:51He was a personal friend of mine and Twitter if ik was the first major
1:30:56third-party client for Twitter and gave them think
1:30:59The word tweet was invented by the icon factory not Twitter and the idea that the logo would be a bird
1:31:06Came from the Twitter if ik bird not Twitter itself Twitter itself had it just a lowercase T is their logo
1:31:13Before that's how you know and it wasn't that I don't think the icon factory feels ripped off
1:31:19I feel like they thought you know, they were
1:31:21Sort of partners in it and took it as a badge of honor that they influenced the course of the company so much
1:31:28But then long before Musk took over Twitter more or less just came out and said hey don't make a new third-party client for us
1:31:36We're sort of and they put like user caps on the ones that existed
1:31:39because of
1:31:42Effectively business reasons, you know that they thought we we want to do ads in a way that we don't want to or our vision
1:31:49For how to deliver ads doesn't work with an API
1:31:52Therefore we need people to use our client and if they have to use our client, we don't want third-party clients
1:31:57wobble
1:31:59that's
1:32:00totally different with mastadon which is
1:32:04Truly built in the spirit of the open web right where and they actually even in the good ways to have things like documentation
1:32:11So you yeah, it's not just that their API is stable and that you don't have to piss off a central authority to use it
1:32:19But they actually document it and the documentation is correct
1:32:22And it works and there are you could get get the posts from a mastadon user via RSS and the RSS is actually valid
1:32:30RSS it's so great. I was like
1:32:34I literally excited and I liked
1:32:36tweeted about it and intruded about it when when I just saw how easy these
1:32:42API's were and how and how open they are you can just take any
1:32:46Mastadon post URL and you you like tweak the URL that'll you put something before the number and then it stays on
1:32:53Yeah, that's the the data right there that you don't need to be authenticated. There's other stuff you can do without
1:33:00authentication and
1:33:02The like the limits are generous. It's maybe if if mastadon becomes really big maybe they'll have to find ways to
1:33:08To cut back in some ways just to make just so these servers can function or maybe to cut off forms of abuse
1:33:16But it's reassuring that underneath it all there's like a philosophy
1:33:21They're like an open source not-for-profit philosophy behind all this because you know, they're not going to go in
1:33:28In the kinds of directions that led to all these great Twitter experiences being destroyed. Yeah, I know I've I
1:33:35couldn't click the heart icon under your posts often enough on threads, but I
1:33:41Forget his title, but the the the head of threads at Instagram is Adam. Moser. Yeah
1:33:47Who's also comes from Instagram where he's also the lead and they even say and they've said since threads launched that it's an Instagram
1:33:56not a meta app and it looks it shares visual DNA with Instagram and
1:34:03They Adam and
1:34:07Zuckerberg himself are active
1:34:10participants on threads and I know that there are cynical people who think that because they are major
1:34:16Executives at this company that they actually don't that it's not them
1:34:19It's some kind of social media team at meta who does all these posts, but it's not I mean
1:34:24maybe there's somebody in comms at meta who can post as
1:34:29Zuck, but I'm not sure there is I'm not sure that anything that's ever been posted by at Zuck on threads isn't actually from
1:34:38Mark Zuckerberg's thumbs and I know Adam is
1:34:41Personally very very active on threads personally, but he asked hey, we're moving as fast as we can
1:34:48We've gotten a lot of low-hanging fruit. We're moving fast
1:34:52What are the most important things that we can do and as next steps to keep moving forward and you posted the API API API
1:35:00Yeah, I talked about API so much that I changed my bio at some point to say on the guy who complains about API's
1:35:07Yeah, their API situation is is I mean, there's you can talk about API's
1:35:13Endpoints that would be nice to have on Twitter
1:35:18You can talk about the ones that Twitter used to have and then lost but you could you can still post to Twitter
1:35:23You can't even post right now. That's right. There's no API even for posting and that is
1:35:29Crazy, right in some ways. Yeah, and
1:35:32Yeah, it seems crazy to me that any kind of microblogging
1:35:37Anything that had an aspiration to be a microblogging service would would even for a while talk about
1:35:45Not having that API I get like launching without it fine
1:35:48But you should at least say that you plan to add an API for posting and yeah, I get it
1:35:54They they're not like super excited about having you know news content all over threads, but so many kinds of Twitter like posts and
1:36:03memes and
1:36:05Pieces of content that start conversations on Twitter
1:36:08Originate through at least a posting API
1:36:12You don't have to give it like I don't actually I don't mind that they're not building
1:36:16an API that will enable a kind of tweet deck or right alternate reading type app because
1:36:25as long as they do this activity pub hookup will get that eventually but right now I
1:36:31would like
1:36:34API for posting and it was very
1:36:36Good to see them change what they were saying on that
1:36:39I could it's kind of like there are a few people who work for threads and
1:36:42They talk pretty openly they post pretty openly about stuff. That doesn't look like it's approved by
1:36:48By cons, I noticed ahead of their announcement
1:36:51There are a few more likes from some of those people on my post about API's and like that's interesting
1:36:57But I'm not gonna like call them out. I just wonder what's going on here. And then yeah a few days later
1:37:02I got these people were like at Nate had mentioning. Hey, they just announced that posting API is coming
1:37:08I do the same thing with Apple folks. Sometimes where somebody who I know works at Apple
1:37:13will favorite something I posted on one of these services or jump into the thread with a reply and
1:37:20Yeah, you know it's public and you've posted it, but I will often not
1:37:26Even if it is sometimes I would just say yeah, you know
1:37:29I'm not gonna link to their tweet on daring fireball
1:37:33Because I don't want to bring the eye of Sauron upon them inside Cupertino for jumping into this. It's there
1:37:39People can find it and I'm so glad they're jumping into this
1:37:42But I don't want to bring undue attention to it and I could I think you're saying the same sort of thing with these API
1:37:48advocates within meta
1:37:51I think the other thing and I mentioned this earlier my basic theory that Twitter was corrupted by its
1:37:58Investors forcing them
1:38:02Expecting them to be Facebook size
1:38:04With a concept for a site that never was going to be Facebook sized, right?
1:38:10Facebook is a trillion dollar idea and
1:38:13Twitter is a billion dollar idea and there's nothing wrong with having a billion dollar idea unless your
1:38:20expectation is hey, you need to be a thousand times bigger the advantage threads has is
1:38:25if they're never as big as
1:38:29Instagram or as the blue app that Facebook is which I think is true
1:38:35I think threads could thrive over the next ten years and
1:38:39will probably never be close to as popular or as
1:38:44lucrative as Instagram and probably not the blue app
1:38:48But that's fine because they own it and they don't need it to be right in a sense. There is free
1:38:55Not free of charge, but as free as in freedom
1:38:59as
1:39:01Mastodon even though threads is not open source or a community project, but there it's free
1:39:05It must be freeing for them that Zuckerberg has said. Okay, let's do this
1:39:10Instagram Moserri you're in charge of it. Let's get this built quickly
1:39:15but simply with the goal of
1:39:19Being a in Zuckerberg's words. Let's get to a billion users and then we'll figure out how to monetize it
1:39:26But let's just effectively let's just kill Twitter if we can and that's all they need to do and it's incredibly freeing that they don't
1:39:33There's no expectation Zuckerberg's mission isn't you have to build something that's going to be bigger and more profitable than Instagram
1:39:39It's just I want you to build something that's bigger and more popular than X
1:39:44Yeah, I hope they have a reason to sustain it if it's only a small fraction of Instagram revenue
1:39:52There are business they're good at making money and finding new ways of making money and
1:39:56there I think there are ways to make money out of
1:39:59threads type app that we just haven't imagined yet, but
1:40:04Like
1:40:08It's I'm optimistic, but I I'm ready. I'm prepared for every anything
1:40:14I'm ready for them saying we're not even doing
1:40:17Activity pub I hope it doesn't get to that but like a lot of people just roll their eyes at the idea that they're gonna federate
1:40:24I've seen that since the day they launched where there are people
1:40:28Who are so cynical about meta that they're like this. There's no way this is ever gonna happen, but I have
1:40:36Come around and have a much more
1:40:39Open mind towards a meta and their products than I had
1:40:43before last year and I part of it is
1:40:48Just changing my mind about things in the past
1:40:50That they've done and part of it too is that I think they've changed, you know
1:40:55And I think that's one of those things that is very hard for anything but a founder led company to do is to grow
1:41:03to a humongous size and yet remain nimble enough to
1:41:08Keep adapting to the world as the world evolves and I I think meta is a better company
1:41:16Ethically speaking than they were five years ago and there just seemed to me to be a lot of people
1:41:22Who I don't know what the word is, but they lack
1:41:27the grace
1:41:30to even think about
1:41:32Forgiving a company or even if you're not asking for forgiveness
1:41:36But just to accept that hey, they used to do blank which was morally questionable and now they don't do it anymore
1:41:44Can you ever move past that or are you always going to hold against them?
1:41:48Whatever it is that you think they did wrong during the 2020 election or whatever it was
1:41:52Yeah, I mean I perceive some of those changes and it's evident like you alluded to in
1:42:01posts from
1:42:03executives and
1:42:05lower level
1:42:06Product people on threads itself. Yeah, I think they will do the activity pub thing and I get why it might be
1:42:14Complicated for them, but the idea I think the way that it would work would be
1:42:19That you can be a mastodon user on
1:42:23Mastodon dot social or whatever of the thousands of mastodon servers are out there and if you would like to follow Gabe Rivera
1:42:30as a thread user
1:42:32Without you being on threads but follow from your mastodon account. You'll just follow at
1:42:40Gabe at threads dotnet or well, I don't know what is your username at threads? I forget it is gay
1:42:47Bravara gay Bravara
1:42:48So follow at gay Bravara at threads dotnet and all of a sudden your threads posts come in the way they would if
1:42:56threads were a mastodon server and you can just follow along from your mastodon account and get Gabe's or at
1:43:03Gruber at mastodon dot socials or at Gruber at threads dotnet
1:43:08It'll be a question for people like me and you who use both
1:43:12Where do I stop posting on threads and just post on mastodon and assume people will follow it
1:43:17There's questions about that, but I don't think to me. There's no question that them implementing it in that way
1:43:23Will not hurt the overall number of people who go to threads dotnet and use the official threads app. I
1:43:31Really don't I don't think it'll decrease that I think it only
1:43:35Strengthened would will and would only strengthen their position as a sort of canonical source for people's short-form
1:43:43posting on the web I think so because already they're much bigger than
1:43:47mastodon and
1:43:50People
1:43:52It's a reason to post more on threads knowing that mastodon
1:43:55Users can also see you like, you know mastodon is really strong in
1:44:01Like areas like security a lot of security people because they're if you're a security person you're not posting on
1:44:07mastodon or threads yet
1:44:10You you'll know that you can
1:44:12Just by posting on threads if you start doing so
1:44:17After Federation those security people on mastodon will be able to get your posts
1:44:23I think it helps threads and meta in in numerous ways. I hope they continue to be convinced by that
1:44:31Where where do you see X go and where what do you think of the the year one under Elon's?
1:44:38leadership
1:44:40It's it's pretty bad in the areas that I care about a lot of people just aren't
1:44:46posting as much or gone entirely and that's not good and the reasons are kind of
1:44:51There are simple reasons and more complicated reasons for that, but I just sense like Elon Musk
1:44:58There are certain aspects of Twitter that he just doesn't get and he doesn't realize he's destroying a lot of it
1:45:05You know, there are parts that are I'm sure
1:45:07Are being bolstered by his approach, but they're not I don't think they're great parts
1:45:14And I don't think they have a great chance of sustaining themselves forever. I
1:45:19Think it's hurt him tremendously that he's almost
1:45:26universally is regarded as an executive who does not want to be told no by his employees and
1:45:32therefore has seemingly surrounded himself by yes men and
1:45:36His other companies are you know, Tesla is obviously very successful and growing
1:45:41SpaceX is a remarkably successful company. I mean they've they've truly pushed
1:45:47rocket science actually, you know the the go-to
1:45:51metaphor for big-brained smart people has been pushed forward by SpaceX and
1:45:57and they're therefore their success has masked that I think over the years because
1:46:03He can maybe push through something like I think of questionable design for the Cybertruck
1:46:09Oh, I think let's say that's an open question
1:46:11But the gull wing design for the the model what I think it was the model Y or the model
1:46:17I forget which one of the models it was but that had the stupid doors that open up from the top
1:46:21It was pushed forward by him and people said that's a bad design boss and they got fired or just blown past
1:46:28But overall Tesla continues to grow and Tesla owners are overall pretty happy, but I think with Twitter
1:46:35He's wrong about so many things
1:46:38And like you said just tech mean which is not
1:46:41Truly I think has no pro or or anti bias against Twitter
1:46:46But you can measure it and before he took over there were 7,000 links and now there's 5,000 for the same month a year later
1:46:52And that's a pretty significant decline not a collapse
1:46:56But that's a sign of fading influence and there's just so many people I follow
1:47:02who have
1:47:05Officially announced. Hey, I'm done posting over here on X
1:47:08I'm over on threads or on Mastodon or I'm on both but the hell with this place and then I think there's a lot more
1:47:15People who are more like me where I've never said I'm done posting on Twitter
1:47:19I I just do it less because it's just lower in my ranking of which apps I check and sometimes I don't get to it
1:47:26Yeah, yeah, it's definitely lower for me. It's I
1:47:30mainly tweet like
1:47:33self-promotion and
1:47:36Just a few occasional housekeeping things
1:47:39And I don't think he understands the role Twitter plays right and I can't think of a better example and it looks like they've
1:47:46Reverted it literally like in the last this week
1:47:49but that they changed the link format like when you post a link to not contain the
1:47:56Headline of the article so I could say here's a link at the verge comm slash
1:48:02Here's the URL and
1:48:04Then the link will contain the verges headline so that people can read it and I can write my commentary in the tweet with
1:48:11Snark or just a summary or hey, I think this is real. I did not expect this whatever
1:48:15I paste the URL and then the link is formatted with the title and he took the titles away
1:48:21He admits it was his decision and then it just says the verge comm and has no context for the headline
1:48:28and I guess his thinking was I
1:48:33Want people to stay on Twitter and not leave to bounce to read articles elsewhere
1:48:39so I'm going to penalize the format of
1:48:42URLs to encourage publications to
1:48:46become
1:48:48$10 a month or whatever it costs to post more than that but pay to become a Twitter pro user and
1:48:53Post your entire article on Twitter, which no sane
1:48:58Publication was ever going to do like the verge you're not gonna get neil I Patel to have verge writers post the entire article on
1:49:05Twitter that would be
1:49:07Stupid but I guess that's what musk wanted. I I feel like he doesn't understand that and that's one thing again tech meme
1:49:14Is like daring fireball in a way where we we've always
1:49:19linked tech meme
1:49:22By design, you know the whole point of it is you come to tech meme and then you immediately go elsewhere
1:49:27To read the actual articles. It is come here find out what's happening
1:49:31and then yes go go to Bloomberg go to New York Times go to the verge go to daring fireball and read the article there and
1:49:37Because you found good stuff through tech meme you'll come back and that's how Twitter worked and the idea that you would take that away
1:49:45And just try to keep people on Twitter is not to me
1:49:49It's as nuts as if you change tech meme to try to keep people on tech me, right?
1:49:55It doesn't I don't know you it doesn't even make any sense
1:49:57Yeah, and you can see how it's going by seeing what actually is promoted by
1:50:02These new the Twitter algorithm changes and the new subscriber formats and all that. It's pretty
1:50:10It's pretty crappy stuff
1:50:11I I get I still actually get a lot of value out of Twitter and it's by meticulously crafting lists
1:50:19and reading those lists in a reverse chronological order
1:50:24But anywhere that actual algorithm intrudes it's like get this out of my face
1:50:29And I'm not anti algorithm right like threads is is generally algorithmically driven and you can you could switch to a
1:50:38Chronological feed if you want, but I actually prefer their algorithm
1:50:42because their algorithm
1:50:45seems optimized only to surface stuff that's of interest to me and I've sort of feel the same way about
1:50:51Instagram to and Instagram has the same similar
1:50:54It's sort of hidden you have to tap on the logo in the app the actual Instagram logo
1:50:59And then you can switch to a for you feed that shows the people you follow a chronological order
1:51:05But in general the algorithm
1:51:08Just seems driven to show you things of interest because that keeps you coming back in that that's good for meta if you come back
1:51:16I found there are them very good. I helped it very early by
1:51:21Following a bunch of accounts and being generous with my likes and things that I found interesting. I found it. Excellent
1:51:28Some people I know
1:51:30have complained about
1:51:32Like too many influencers and so on but I think just tending to your follow graph and doing a little liking can get you past
1:51:39That yeah. Yeah, and I've seen a lot of people
1:51:42Who their first impression of threads is I okay. I'll try it
1:51:47Let's see and it's like yeah, this is I'm not liking this feed at all. And that complaint you had about too much influencer content
1:51:55Why do what why am I getting shown all these posts from youtubers? I don't want to see that and then a week later
1:51:59I see the same person. I've seen this so many times. I've lost count of it of hey
1:52:03I've stuck with threads for a week and all and my feed is actually a lot better
1:52:06Yeah, you know it that they are
1:52:09Scarily smart I think at meta and in a very good way where and and
1:52:17It is such an interesting contrast with Twitter where they're
1:52:20And I know Facebook slogan used to be move fast and break things but it it seems as the company has matured
1:52:27they've kept the move fast and dropped the break things and
1:52:31Twitter is so under musk is sort of the opposite. It's moved slow and break things
1:52:36And I I just think it shows I think it's and I think for the most part the behavior
1:52:42Isn't people protesting even though there are a lot of high-profile people who are actually protesting the political
1:52:50Climate on Twitter and which posts get promoted and the whole thing where the
1:52:57$10 a month pro blue check accounts get
1:53:01algorithmically promoted just because they're paying accounts and
1:53:06the people it's such a bad
1:53:11Form of rewards because the people who were most likely to pay still are
1:53:16most likely to willingly pay $10 a month for Twitter are Elon Musk fans and they're
1:53:22How do I say it gently not the sort of people whose thoughts I really care to hear and yet their algorithm?
1:53:28Became optimized to show them first which it
1:53:32Makes me a bottom line makes me less interested in going to X
1:53:38And let's just say it the name change is stupid I
1:53:42Again, I'm a curmudgeon probably a little resistant to change more than most people but X is just a stupid name
1:53:50It is I believe so always felt that way and I I think people are pointing to App Store trends
1:53:57Demonstrating that with clarity. Oh, it's it's devastating to their App Store ranking
1:54:03I mean it has been it dropped when they change the name and
1:54:05Has stayed low and when you go through the list of free downloaded apps the number of apps that are listed above them
1:54:13It's almost it's almost comical. What's what's got higher recognition above? I guess that about covers it
1:54:19I guess if there's one last bonus question, it's AI and I don't know what to say about it
1:54:26Do you see it as a threat to what you do to what tech mean does that AI?
1:54:32Could do a better tech meme than tech meme itself. I
1:54:36think it's something we gotta stay on top of and find places to
1:54:42Apply it where it can be applied successfully. I do think there are reasons
1:54:49why
1:54:52why it's not it's
1:54:54AI
1:54:57Driven alternatives are not gonna be a part of a complete solution right now LLM's are are
1:55:04trained on the past and news has the word new in it and a lot of what makes us interested in
1:55:11news is how it's
1:55:14certain
1:55:16present things are recombined as something entirely new and
1:55:19The way LLM's work now. I don't think there are they're ready to like rank
1:55:27those new things as well as successfully and
1:55:30Another thing like a lot of the value of tech meme is people will go there just to see they'll just look at headlines and
1:55:38No, oh, I know that this thing happened. I'm not even gonna click
1:55:44I'm just gonna glance or like people not many people click on our fundraising headlines
1:55:49But you can go to tech meme and three companies in this category were funded today
1:55:54And oh, this is something a lot of a lot is being invested in this is something on the way
1:55:59where I can expect some products in the future along these lines and
1:56:03any kind of
1:56:06AI-driven news algorithm has to it's not possible, but it's got to get that
1:56:10It's got to have that data on what you glanced at and process it and and do something meaningful with it
1:56:17So I think there are there are certainly obstacles for AI
1:56:22Approaches to be awesome in news aggregation, but but boy
1:56:27LLM's are
1:56:30nevertheless despite other flaws are miracles and
1:56:34there are a number of ways we need to
1:56:39Introduce like either LLM's for summarizing or like machine learning approaches to better detect
1:56:47when certain features when it comes to text and links signal
1:56:53Something that may possibly be news
1:56:55We use a lot of old automated approaches already
1:56:57But we haven't trained neural networks yet to be like this a trending story that you the edge or want to consider for tech me
1:57:05It's still kind of your algorithm
1:57:08heuristics
1:57:10Alright, my biggest concern in the near term is
1:57:13the use of AI and LLM's and especially the image generation
1:57:20capabilities to
1:57:22Purposefully create false context. I mean and obviously in the context of a major US presidential election is sort of what I'm thinking
1:57:30I think it's a concern but I sort of feel
1:57:35Confident that we'll get past it in the same way that we've gotten past
1:57:41Outright attempts to mislead people disinformation not just oh, I honestly believe
1:57:48That Bill Gates put nanobots in the vaccine
1:57:51Well, if you honestly believe it, I mean what you're probably not an authoritative source of information on Twitter anyway, but people who?
1:57:58purposefully are trying to
1:58:01Mislead people I mean the best one of the best examples of that and it's it's a trick that predates the web
1:58:07But trying to convince people of the wrong voting day
1:58:11Hey
1:58:11Even in your state voting day is Wednesday not Tuesday for this anymore
1:58:16And and of course everybody's voting day in the u.s. Is Tuesday, but that's a dirty trick and using AI to commit dirty tricks
1:58:22I feel like the way that LLM's can create
1:58:26extremely realistic looking photographs of fake things at you know Photoshop's have been around for 30 years, but
1:58:34They AI can do it so fast that it's almost a machine we as human beings have
1:58:42Guards against that and the guard against it is trusting certain sources over time
1:58:46Right, and I feel like that's what tech meme is
1:58:49I hope that's what daring fireball is at an individual voice level
1:58:54But like I'd because I'd as far as I know you and I think your your employees would agree
1:59:00You have no plans to completely automate tech meme and replace the staff with AI
1:59:04And that part of what makes tech meme tech meme is that you and your editors know?
1:59:12Who can be trusted just by name alone?
1:59:14and and then that trust
1:59:17Goes to the users the users can trust what they see on tech meme and tech meme knows who they can trust going forward
1:59:24So I sort of feel like it's it'll be okay
1:59:27Yeah, I think so. I think we would have seen a lot more mayhem from deep fakes if these
1:59:35trust networks weren't
1:59:37robust and
1:59:39trusted by by ordinary people and yeah, the the AI techniques are getting smarter, but
1:59:45For sure, the level of mischief will increase but I too am optimistic on that. I
1:59:50almost feel like the bigger danger is
1:59:53Using AI and the existence of good deep fake technology
2:00:00to say real things are fake rather than vice versa and I'll just go to the 2016 election and when the
2:00:08Grab her by the pussy tape leaked of the Trump which really hurt his poll numbers
2:00:14I mean like in the aftermath of that tape coming out that what was it access Hollywood was the TV show
2:00:19his poll numbers dropped so precipitously after that that there was a
2:00:23serious movement in the Republican Party to get him to drop out of the race, which is just
2:00:28Absurd in September of an election year and I know everybody out there's a yeah, but he won the election anyway
2:00:34But it's that really really hurt him and I feel like if a similar tape dropped now
2:00:38Him and his cohorts now. I think they would just say app fake. That was fake fake fake fake
2:00:44Yeah, well, hopefully those those same trust networks can help there
2:00:49but I
2:00:51Think trust will be eroded a bit
2:00:53But will hopefully hang in there
2:00:56Well, thank you Gabe for your time
2:01:00This was you've been somebody who I wanted to get on this show for a long time and it was just as much fun talking
2:01:05To you as I expected at sea. That's what can we promote?
2:01:09We've talked about tech meme a lot tech meme if you don't go there my god
2:01:13You should go there but your other two sites in the network are
2:01:16Yeah, this is gonna I have to say it carefully me Miranda, which is meme me me o
2:01:22R-a-n-d-u-m. That's the political news aggregator, right? But but that that's a that's a weird that that's
2:01:30only for like hardcore political
2:01:32Hobbyist who also can deal with the chaos that the algorithm unleashes in in help
2:01:40Presents this news summary the other news vertical we we have editors carefully
2:01:44Carefully curating is media gazer and if you're in content industries or you're into what's happening in journalism or especially
2:01:53Digital journalism. I I don't think there's any real substitute for it. It's like a
2:01:59It should be it should be what you're checking every day and and I'm Gabe Rivera on all the social networks
2:02:05Yeah, so just search for Gabe Rivera and you'll find so thank you for your time
2:02:09I'll also thank our sponsors of the day
2:02:11They were Squarespace where you can build your own website
2:02:13Memberful where you can monetize your passion with membership and ad block Pro, which is an outstanding
2:02:21content blocker for
2:02:24Safari Mac iOS iPad OS just go to the App Store search for ad block Pro
2:02:29Thanks Gabe.