Podcast Search

The Talk Show

390: ‘The Blurry Edge of Acceptable’, With Nilay Patel

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00Somehow Apple Notes, which has been rock solid for me for years, is not syncing from my Mac to

0:00:06anything else. That's why I had to disappear. And so I actually printed it out. I had a weird one the

0:00:14other day where I realized I'm hopelessly dependent on being able to copy something from my computer

0:00:20and paste it on my phone or copy something on my phone and paste it to my computer. And it stopped

0:00:25working. I realized I had no idea how to do anything anymore. I've had that exact same thing,

0:00:34the continuity feature, which also to me has gotten way more rock solid in the years since

0:00:40they introduced it. But because it's gotten more rock solid, whenever it does break, I'm the same

0:00:46way. I'm lost. I'm like, "Wait, how do I do this?" Yeah. And then I started doing incantations.

0:00:53I found a terminal command on a forum from five years ago. Maybe that worked. Or maybe it was

0:00:58just the fact that I restarted my computer. It's one or the other. But it's back. I think I need

0:01:03like a functional human being. I think I need to restart my computer. What else was what was my

0:01:07other reason? I had a Oh, I know what my other reason problem is. It might be good fodder for

0:01:11the show. I took a ton of photos at Thanksgiving, and just family, nephews, nieces and nephews and

0:01:20my parents and typical family stuff. And I took a bunch of them with a third party camera, my Rico

0:01:29GR3, which I love and has me taking more photos like my number one tip. This is my number one tip

0:01:35is having gone a couple years shooting almost all my personal photos with my iPhone instead of a

0:01:41camera. The biggest change since I bought this Rico GR3, I think in March of this year, is I

0:01:49take way more photos than I do when I use my phone, like at a family event. Like really? Yeah, it's

0:01:55like some combination of battery anxiety with my phone and not wanting to have my phone out and

0:02:05having just a dedicated I don't know, maybe it's just me. I don't know if it applies to other

0:02:13people. But literally just having an actual little point and shoot camera. I take just way more. I

0:02:21mean, like I took hundreds of photos at Thanksgiving, and I never would never ever would have

0:02:26taken hundreds if I was only using my phone. I don't know why that is. But I feel like it's it's

0:02:31the opposite for most people, you give them a phone, they start just firing off shots and

0:02:34assuming that Google Photos or Apple Photos or whatever, we'll just figure it out for them.

0:02:40It could be me. I don't know. But anyway, what happened is over the weekend, then I was like,

0:02:45don't do that. I don't want to do the stupid thing. And just have all these hundreds of

0:02:48photos sitting in my photo library and never go through them and share them with my family. I was

0:02:53like, I'm going to take a couple hours Friday, Saturday, triage all these photos, get all the

0:02:58good pics, share them with my family, blah, blah, blah. And I also had hadn't used Apple Photos

0:03:08de duplicate feature. I don't even know when it came out. But I was like, you know what,

0:03:12I should do this. And it found for some reason, a different assortment of duplicates on different

0:03:17devices. Like my iPad had a couple but my Mac had a bunch of them 80 of them or something and I'm

0:03:23like eyeballing them and they all I scrolled through the whole list. They all looked good.

0:03:28Yes, if I hit do this, this is going to get rid of the duplicates and do good things.

0:03:36And the other problem I had, I don't know which one caused this and which one didn't. The other

0:03:42thing was I wanted to move a bunch of photos to an album. And it wouldn't let me move them to an

0:03:46album. Because a bunch of them it said were unsaved. And I don't know, I didn't know what

0:03:52that meant. What what do you mean save a photo and Apple Photos like the whole thing and photos.

0:03:57But what it meant was they were ones from like messages that, you know what I mean? And it's

0:04:04a weren't in your library. They weren't in my library there. Yeah. But I said, yes, save them.

0:04:09And I think that's the main problem. I said, Yeah, sure, save them all. And then I went to my

0:04:16recents and my recent album in Apple Photos only had three, the three most recent photos I had

0:04:25taken. And then it was just random photos from the last 15 years in a random order. And I thought,

0:04:33Oh, my God, something I did here. And I was using dark room, which I love, because it's sort of like

0:04:40Lightroom. But in it uses your Apple Photos library as your library. I was like, something I did here,

0:04:46jumbled all 50,000 of my photos into a random order. And there was nothing I could do to fix

0:04:56it. And I was like, Oh, but what it was, was those photos I saved from messages are deemed recent,

0:05:07because it recent doesn't go by the date on the photos, it goes by when you added them to your

0:05:13library. And so once I scrolled, like 388 photos down into my library, boom, there's the other

0:05:2150,000 all in chronological order. But 380 photos or so was enough that I scrolled, scrolled,

0:05:29scrolled, scrolled, scrolled and decided my entire library was a, oh, my God, entirely out of

0:05:34chronological order. And I was like, I'm going back to film and I'm just going to start putting

0:05:39print photos into a book. And that's,

0:05:43my theory is that the Apple library is untouchable, right? Because it's, that's the most photos, it's

0:05:49all the, I mean, I, I can't say that I have a good photo management technique. I just have a very

0:05:54strong opinion about it. So there's the Apple library, which is untouchable, just leave it

0:05:57alone. Don't touch it. It's the most brittle of all of them. I find the Google library is everything

0:06:02goes into it. All the, all the photos from everywhere we're going to it. And then I have

0:06:06Lightroom, which is where all my full resolution DSLR and mirrorless photos go. And that is just

0:06:13going to be a cost that I carry forever. Right? The thing about Lightroom, I think I saw you

0:06:18posting with us on threads the other day. The AI denoise in Lightroom is it has re jiggered my

0:06:25relationship with my cameras, right? Because it is so good. It is. And I'm like the world's leading

0:06:32practitioner of what is a photo hand-wringing and I'm just like, whatever, denoise it, just have at

0:06:38it, just invent some pixels, make it look good. My ancient D 7,500, my Nikon D 7,500, which I love,

0:06:45which is, I want to say it's 2014. It's old. This camera is ancient. I just took it to Disney world,

0:06:51you know, with a big, fun lens on it, but it Lightroom just remade this camera. I'm using

0:06:57it in places that it was not usable before in ISOs that frankly, I didn't even know why they enabled

0:07:03them on this. Like they were unusable. And now I'm just like firing away with this thing. And I

0:07:07realized that the thing about iPhone photography is that you get so used to how much noise reduction

0:07:14it does and how good at it it is that when your other cameras can't do it because the processing

0:07:21isn't there, you're like, oh, this camera isn't good. When really it's, you're just used to the

0:07:26amount of processing that's happening. And so I added Lightroom to the mix and it's like my old

0:07:32cameras are just back in the game, old lenses, old cameras. The camera that I've outgunned,

0:07:40I think it's time to upgrade. When my daughter was born, I bought it Sony RX100 Mark IV.

0:07:46Yeah. And now this thing is like the screen on the back is chipped. It's like,

0:07:51this thing has been everywhere. It's lived in my pocket for five years. And I think that one,

0:07:56I'm past the range of its capabilities. Like I run into its limitations more than I'm happy with the

0:08:02photos it takes. So I think that one it's time to upgrade, but my old Nikon plus Lightroom,

0:08:08it would be hard to convince me to buy a new camera at this point, at least in that size.

0:08:13Darrell Bock We have too much other stuff to talk about,

0:08:15but I used and loved Lightroom for years and never really abandoned it. What I did was I packed up

0:08:24an iMac that was on my desk when I was getting my office completely renovated and then never unpacked

0:08:32it because I switched full time to a MacBook Pro. And so I still have Lightroom and I've got like

0:08:40these... Jared Ranerel Lightroom Classic or Lightroom?

0:08:43Darrell Bock Lightroom Classic. This is from before the Adobe Cloud era. And one of the things

0:08:48that gives you peace of mind about Lightroom is at least Lightroom Classic, it organizes your photos

0:08:53in the file system. So like worst case scenario, as long as you can read the disk that it's on,

0:09:00and there's no version of Lightroom in the future that runs on whatever computer hardware you have,

0:09:05you've still just got all the original images there and you lose like your Lightroom edits if

0:09:10you haven't exported them or something like that. But that's not a bad worst case scenario where

0:09:15your original images off the camera are all safe and sound, chronologically organized into year,

0:09:22month, day, full folders in a library, which is awesome. But that thing about the de-noising,

0:09:27I was like somebody else, I forget who posted it. I'll see if I can find it and put it in the

0:09:30show notes. But somebody on threads was just more or less saying that the new AI powered de-noise in

0:09:37Lightroom turned this and it was like, I don't know, he was shooting it like ISO 25,000 or

0:09:43something in that range. And it was like a picture of some animal at nighttime in the dark, and it

0:09:48turned it into this. And it's, it looks like the cover of Natural Geographic. It is like, absolutely

0:09:54insane. It's insane. I will say I think that's a good example. And I know you're right that you are

0:10:01sort of the leader of what is a photo philosophical debate. I would say that falls clearly on the side

0:10:09of not, it's still a photo, right? Color grading and...

0:10:15No, if you look at it, I have some photos from this trip to Disney. They're just in the dark,

0:10:20where someone's hair is, it's just a mess of pixels. And your brain is, okay, there should

0:10:25be some hair. And then Lightroom is like, here it is. And you're like, that is not contained.

0:10:30Right. Right.

0:10:31Right. You just have enough information in Adobe Firefly to be like, okay, here's what some fringes

0:10:38of hair looks like. We can do it. And it's the same as the Google best take feature where it's

0:10:45like, am I really lying? Like the hair wasn't in place, like whatever. Like the camera doesn't have

0:10:51enough data for me to conclusively say that my hair was frizzy. But Lightroom is like, you know

0:10:57what, let's put it there. Maybe that's on the blurry edge of acceptable. And I think most people

0:11:02with family photographs, they don't care. But it's still kind of like, every time I hit the button,

0:11:07and I don't even, I don't even hit that button one by one anymore. I hit, I select all in batch

0:11:13process, all of the photos off this camera before I begin editing. And it's like the GPU in my M1 Pro

0:11:20is pegged for an hour. And then I come back and I finish the edits. And I'm like, first of all,

0:11:25it's like awesome to peg your GPU. It's like the most, if you're a computer nerd, you're like,

0:11:30I'm working now, but you're not doing it. You're just like waiting. But then you come back,

0:11:35these photos are incredible. Well, I guess my, my breaking point on that philosophical

0:11:41devolved question, what is a photo is, is it still attempting to present to you

0:11:50a moment of reality from the perspective of the lens of the camera at a certain moment in time?

0:12:01And if the answer is yes, then I think you're on the, this is still a photo side of it. And yes,

0:12:10filling in fine details like hair, like strands of hair are so small that the individual

0:12:18pixels of noise would interfere with what they were. And therefore it has to be filled in and

0:12:25it's literally filling some content in that the image didn't originally contain it, but it still

0:12:34is capturing a moment of time from that perspective. Whereas the Google, what do they

0:12:40call it? The best take, which is a cool feature. Like I wrote on daring fireball about it. Like

0:12:47I find this feature highly questionable and I know that I would use it. Right. Yeah. And this

0:12:54is how I feel about Lightroom. It's I think it's on the safer side of the line, but you know,

0:12:59there was a time in the culture where Turner movies, colorizing, black classic films caused

0:13:06a great deal of hand wringing about the sanctity of art. And we are just, just imagine trying to

0:13:13tell a teenager, we used to worry about colorizing black and white that was gone. Right? Like we are

0:13:18fully past it. My line is like, did this happen? If you cannot confidently say about a photograph

0:13:27that that thing happened, we're probably a little too far and we should recalibrate. And I know a

0:13:33lot of people are trying to recalibrate in various different ways. It does seem the best take is a

0:13:37great example of this. I have received for many people, the argument, well, something like it

0:13:43happened and that's good enough. And it's I think you should move that one back. Yeah.

0:13:49And it's, it's only going to move forward from here. Right? It's like we're nowhere near

0:13:56at the end point of these features. Xiaomi has the Xiaomi 14. Let me see it. Let me make sure

0:14:04I'm correct. Make sure it's the 14. Yep. Okay. So the Xiaomi 14 just came out and it's a launch

0:14:13event, which is very much like an Apple keynote. They demoed a feature in the camera where you just

0:14:17feed it some photos and then you say, make a photo of me standing on a mountain and it just does it.

0:14:23And that's the camera. And it's not, this is not like the science fiction hypothetical. This is

0:14:29a thing they demoed on stage while launching the phone.

0:14:32Well, that's it is something and it is cool, but it's not photography. Right? I mean, there's also

0:14:42things, features like that, which I, I, I know that there were probably people, I was too young

0:14:51and therefore too, Oh, this is nothing but cool. And I refuse to, to even read anybody's down saying

0:14:59or downplaying of it. Like when Photoshop first became a thing, you could do all sorts of things

0:15:05in Photoshop that previously you couldn't practically do. Right. There were ways to

0:15:10manipulate photos in the analog film era, right? There's the famous pictures from the

0:15:16Stalin era in the Soviet union, where they would erase people who had been erased from the, the,

0:15:22the poet Bureau from photos, you know, and the Dodge and burn feature in Photoshop is named after

0:15:31an actual physical technique that you would use in the dark room when you were developing film.

0:15:38It's all cool, but it does. I don't know. I, and, and, and, and you come from you, you, you lead

0:15:46a publication that has actual photos that your staff takes and that therefore you guys need rules

0:15:54for what counts as a photo, right? Most publications have some sort of house rules for

0:16:00that same way you have rules. Most places have rules about datelines. You can't claim to be

0:16:05reporting from Israel if you're not actually on the ground in Israel.

0:16:09Jared Yeah. There's a very internetty

0:16:11nature to the conversation on what is a photo because people bring it up as a known as ever

0:16:18considered the problem before when in reality, right. People have been considering the problem

0:16:22for hundreds of years since the dawn of photography. And so big news organizations,

0:16:27especially the big photography organizations like Getty or AFP or what have you, they have very

0:16:32restrictive rules about editing. The best example I can give you is if you look at the New York

0:16:37Times, New York Times basically can't do any editing. And that the house style for the New

0:16:42York Times whenever they want to get arty is they just vignette the hell out of their photos.

0:16:46And once you see it, you cannot unsee it. And you're like, oh, this is the only knob you have.

0:16:51Let's go for it. Just, just turn it up like vignetting. You can go read the guidelines.

0:16:56They're all basically the same. And then remove dust and scratches and all this other stuff.

0:17:00But you can't actually edit the photo. Right. And you can crop, which shows you the fact that

0:17:06they even mentioned cropping as an issue shows you just how conservative they are.

0:17:11Right. And for some of them, you can't crop in a way that changes the image of the photo.

0:17:17Or that is even if you're a license, if you're a licensee, so like the Verge has a Getty license,

0:17:23and our Getty license has restrictions in it. They do not want us to use their photos in a way that

0:17:28would convey some other meaning. Okay. Like all of that, I think is fair. But it,

0:17:32as this stuff goes to consumers, and it's Google has best take, you can't drop. There's 200 years of

0:17:41AFP photo licensing restrictions under the camera app of your Pixel 8. Like, that's, that's just not

0:17:49realistic, right? You can't expect anybody to learn that stuff or even understand why that

0:17:52stuff is being imposed. So you got to come up with something else. And I think that's the moment

0:17:57we're in where the companies have to decide what restrictions are they're going to place on the

0:18:03tools, the platforms that distribute the stuff like Instagram, YouTube, or decide what restrictions

0:18:08or labels are gonna put on the stuff. And then we have to decide what is acceptable as a culture.

0:18:13And all of that stuff is in, I wouldn't even say tension. It's like that they're not close enough

0:18:18to each other to be in tension yet. The table's just flipped and we're all just looking at all

0:18:21the shit in the air. And it's like, I know what the Verge is going to write about for the next 10

0:18:25years. But like everything else is pretty unsettled. Yeah. All right, let me take a

0:18:31break here and thank our first sponsor and it's our good friends at nuts.com. Oh, man,

0:18:35your grocery stores. I'm sure they've got stuff like pecans. But what if you want bourbon pecans

0:18:41or sweet and spicy pecans, pecan brittle, or butter toffee pecans, all sorts of exotic stuff.

0:18:47If you want to try stuff like that head to nuts.com. They have hundreds of different

0:18:52varieties of nuts and snacks that they offer. nuts.com is your one stop shop for freshly

0:18:59roasted nuts, dried fruits, sweets, pantry staples like specialty flowers stuff you wouldn't think

0:19:05nuts.com might sell and more. Their wide selection means there is something for everyone at nuts.com.

0:19:12Quality is a top priority. They roast their nuts and pop their corn the same day it ships so they

0:19:18reach you deliciously fresh satisfaction is guaranteed. This is this is the time of the

0:19:24year where I started having sponsors who are suggesting gift ideas for you to buy for others

0:19:29nuts.com is a great idea. You can buy someone like a whole platter of stuff, wrap it up for

0:19:35the Christmas tree, you could probably get them some kind of subscription. If that's the sort of

0:19:39thing you want to buy for someone in your family. You can shop all a cart anytime or you can opt

0:19:45into automatic deliveries so you never run out of your favorite items. I they sent me a whole bunch

0:19:51of stuff at the beginning of their sponsorship and I love it all. My favorite I told you last time is

0:19:57their half popped popcorn, which is just unbelievably addictive. I go through it as soon

0:20:04as it shows up in the house. It just disappears that night when I'm watching TV. So so good. So

0:20:10many other things that they have that are so good. I just regular nuts are so good. They're snack mix

0:20:15type things. The trail mix type things, all that stuff. I got it all. It's all very, very good.

0:20:22I don't usually eat lunch or make breakfast. I just sit I love stuff like that to just sort of

0:20:27fill me up until late afternoon when I decided to spoil my dinner by eating a late lunch way too

0:20:33late. But they've got all sorts of great, great snacks like that. And it's just I really love it.

0:20:40Right now is nuts.com is offering new customers a free gift with purchase and free shipping on

0:20:46orders of $29 or more at nuts.com slash the talk show. So go check out all of their delicious

0:20:54options and nuts.com slash the talk show, you will receive a free gift and free shipping when you

0:21:02spend $29 or more. And it is easy to run up $29 or more not because their stuff's expensive,

0:21:08but because they have so much good stuff. That's nuts.com slash the talk show. We have a lot to

0:21:16talk about maybe we should get the iPhone 15 talk out of the way. This is sort of our annual

0:21:20tradition. It is we're very late. We're late. We're really late. It's been out for a while.

0:21:26I'm curious. What's your takeaway? I mean, we could I don't know if we should breeze through

0:21:31this or if we have a lot to say. I am now in a dual USB-C lightning household. So my takeaway

0:21:41is I got to upgrade my wife and daughter to USB-C iOS devices posthaste because it is very annoying

0:21:48right now. And I think that's probably what Apple is worried about. Yeah. But once you do it,

0:21:53it is incredible that I just have one cable for my laptop and my iPad and my phone and my earbuds.

0:22:00And I don't know why they resisted it for this long. Because from a user experience point of view,

0:22:05vastly superior to having multiple cables and chargers. Like I don't I don't I understand why

0:22:12they held off. And I understand that they felt pushed into it. And there's a bit of resistance

0:22:17there. But it is actually like a sparse superior user experience to just have one cable for all

0:22:23stuff. I do think in hindsight now that we've waited, I do think that the USB-C transition

0:22:29story is both a the sort of most obvious angle for this year's iPhones. And oftentimes the most

0:22:36obvious angle is sort of a dumb angle that I don't find interesting our audience doesn't find

0:22:41interesting. But this year, I feel like it actually is. And it's for exactly the reasons you said,

0:22:46like, why did it take them so long. And I know that the cynical take has always been that it

0:22:54was about money and that the lightning port somehow made them gazinga dollars every year

0:23:02with licensing for the made for iPhone program and selling lightning cables and stuff like that.

0:23:07And I mean, I don't have their balance sheets. I mean, I can't prove it. But talking to people

0:23:14at Apple off the record. That wasn't it. It's Apple almost never and you know, this Apple

0:23:22executives almost never explain themselves, right? It's it's I always think of that scene from there

0:23:29will be blood where Daniel Day Lewis is character says I hate to explain myself. Apple is like that.

0:23:35If it's not in the keynote, or in the marketing materials on apple.com, they don't want to explain

0:23:41why they did x, right? They just don't want to talk. They just it's just part of their culture.

0:23:47But sometimes they'll say no, right? I won't say why. But they all categorically I was told

0:23:56that the money they made from licensing, made for iPhone stuff for the lightning port, or selling

0:24:03their own lightning cables was negligible by Apple standards. And that in the past,

0:24:09that used to be a big deal. But it really was an iPod era thing. Like in the iPod era, it was a

0:24:17significant amount of money and everybody still to this day. In fact, more and more like when you

0:24:23check into a hotel and they still have a 30 pin adapter on the alarm clock. It's Oh my God, how

0:24:29old is this alarm clock? Back then that that stuff was a big deal. That's not the reason I really

0:24:36think it best my best theory is that they were reluctant to change because they the iPhone is so

0:24:44popular with literally like a billion users around the world that they just didn't want to risk

0:24:50pissing people off and that however frustrating it was for people who just wanted to go USB C for

0:24:57everything. It's not infuriating when they didn't switch for the iPhone 12 or 13 or 14. It's just

0:25:06frustrating. Whereas switching could risk infuriating people. And I feel like they just

0:25:12sort of were gun shy about it. That's, yeah, I think that's it. I think that's real. I don't

0:25:20think that's not real. Right. You don't want to piss off your customers. I think that the money

0:25:24piece is negligible by Apple standards is still a huge amount of money. Right. So if you want to run

0:25:32around funding, like negligible by Apple standards is enough to fund one movie on Apple TV plus,

0:25:39right? Like they're not bad at this. And I think that like turning off any money,

0:25:45especially when your sales are kind of sideways and it's like a weird time. I think that no,

0:25:50Tim Cook is many things. He's excellent at making money, right? Like he's an amazing business person

0:25:57and there's no reason that he's going to incur cost to switch to USB C while turning off the

0:26:03revenue associated with the old port, unless he has to. And I think with the iPad, they had to,

0:26:10in order to make the iPad a credible laptop replacement, which is where they needed it to go.

0:26:16And you can debate whether they got there, but they needed to make that claim.

0:26:20They had to enable faster USB speeds, faster charging and ecosystem of device, all this stuff.

0:26:27So they did it because the product demanded it. The product for the lightning cable

0:26:33is like it charges your phone. Maybe it connects to your car. So they didn't need it for the longest

0:26:38time until they were made to do it. So I don't want to say it was the money. They needed all

0:26:42the money and they're being greedy. I think it's a much more raw, instinctual business decision.

0:26:47Why would I turn off some money for any reason? And it's like, it's hard to fault any business

0:26:54for looking at it that way. Yeah, it does seem now here we are on the cusp of December and it

0:27:02does seem like they switched without really pissing people off. Right. It doesn't seem

0:27:08there's nowhere near as much consternation or, hey, this is a money grab play. There was when

0:27:16they switched the iPhone from the 30 pin connector to lightning with the iPhone 5, I believe was the

0:27:24first one with lightning, which even people in my family, my extended family at least thought was

0:27:30a money grab like, oh, and it's don't you see how much better this port is? I mean, well,

0:27:35because you don't have to buy Apple's cable with lightning. You go buy Apple's cable with USB-C.

0:27:39You're like anywhere. Right. And there's one of these cables floating around. Right. Well,

0:27:43and the other thing though, about the money is I really don't think made for iPhone with lightning

0:27:48has been a moneymaker. Even I just don't think I don't even know what products it would be. What

0:27:53products shipped with lightning ports anymore. Very, very few. Every single third party cable.

0:27:59I yeah, but I got even I've talked to people who make from companies that sell their own

0:28:06lightning cables. And they said like the licensing fee really was even by the standards of the

0:28:13company selling the cables negligible. It really was just sort of a quality control

0:28:18surcharge. I think where Apple makes money is selling their own cables in the store.

0:28:24And they sell their own USB-C cables for $29. Right. Which are ridiculous. Right. Yeah. So

0:28:29they still have that going on. I just think that they were a little conservative about it. But

0:28:34I will say it with just two people in the house at the moment, because my son's in college,

0:28:39my wife's iPhone 15 Pro, because I didn't wake up at the crack of dawn to order it for

0:28:48didn't show up until I think early November, it was a long time. And so there was like a six week

0:28:55period where I had an iPhone with a USB-C port and she did not and it really, we don't have that many

0:29:02cables around the house. I mean, if it was up to me, we'd have all sorts of cables all over the

0:29:07place. She's more in charge of where we're allowed to have permanent standing cables. And it did it

0:29:13did interfere with it. And now now that she's got one, the one device we have left between us that

0:29:20still is lightning is her, I guess, first gen AirPods Pro or maybe they're second, I don't even

0:29:26know which gen they are. But because they're not brand new, they have a lightning thing on the case.

0:29:32And it's where is she going to charge these. And so now it's my job to just sort of babysit her

0:29:38AirPods and every once in a while, take them to my office or somewhere and charge them or do they

0:29:43not? That's the one before the wireless charging or there were there is wireless charging, but

0:29:48we don't have a magsafe puck. Again, I don't have permission to have a permanent magsafe

0:29:54puck in the kitchen. Just for it because it would be there just for her AirPods because otherwise,

0:29:59why would you use my god, I get dude, you got to get on Amazon, you got to start looking at the

0:30:03alphabet soup brands. There's a thing out there that can hold all this stuff. Like I walk in the

0:30:08door, I like throw my keys in the thing, I put my AirPods in the thing, it all looks nice. But it's

0:30:13it's I couldn't even tell you the name of the company I bought this thing from. Yeah.

0:30:18Right. That's what's it? Amazon alphabet soup. But anyway, I think that's been successful. I think

0:30:24that the I still do I at this point, I still appreciate how much lighter the phone is than

0:30:31the stainless steel ones that they've been selling for years. And I as someone who prefers to go

0:30:36caseless, I know it seems so superficial. But I so much prefer the way that it feels in my hand

0:30:43to that shiny stainless steel with not sharp corners, but sort of harsh corners.

0:30:50The matte finish of the titanium and the rounded, chamfered edges, whatever you want to call them,

0:30:56are so much more pleasant in hand. It's it's now just in my case to make sure you're not

0:31:01lying to me. No, you're right. I'm a case person. I dropped this thing left and right.

0:31:05To me, I think it's fascinating that they're marketing this thing as titanium. It is the

0:31:11point of the marketing. Right. It is it is the first word out of all the celebrities lips when

0:31:16they like iPhone 15 Pro titanium. And it's like, most people have in a case, what you're going to

0:31:21notice is that it's lighter. Yeah, which is great. I agree with you. But it's interesting that you

0:31:27and a few people who are, frankly, insane, who don't have cases, are the only people that will

0:31:33ever actually touch the phone. Well, I think that's always I think that's, it's long been

0:31:39fascinating to me. I did a poll on Mastodon. And my audience, of course, is out landishly unlike

0:31:45the general population. But I did a poll, I don't know, sometime over the summer, people who follow

0:31:51me on Mastodon, do you put your iPhone in a case? And I think I put it in the show notes, but off

0:31:56the top of my head. My questions were, do you use an Apple branded case, a third party case or no

0:32:02case at all? And it was like, I think roughly one third, one third, one third, which blew me away. I

0:32:10didn't even think amongst my audience that one third of people don't use a case. Because in

0:32:15reality, it's got to be like, I don't know, 95% of people at least keep their phones in a case.

0:32:22But I've always thought that part of the reason why is because the phones are so nice uncased.

0:32:29It's like, even though people like take it out of the most people, unbox their brand new iPhone,

0:32:38look at it, appreciate how nice it looks. They care about what color they bought,

0:32:43and then put it in a case that covers up the nice sides, covers up the back color,

0:32:50and they never see it again, until they take it out of the case to trade it in for a new phone

0:32:55in two or three years. Yeah, but it's the fact that they know that inside the case is this

0:33:01beautiful pristine, shiny iPhone that makes them want to put it in a case whereas if,

0:33:07if in some alternate universe iPhones were sort of G shock, Casio G shock style devices that are

0:33:18sort of a rugged plasticy shell, that's what the device actually is. I don't think people would

0:33:25care about putting them in cases they wouldn't care if they get scratched up. It's and their

0:33:29ads for years during the stainless steel era, always way over emphasized how shiny the stainless

0:33:37steel is. Right? I mean, yes, they were they were it was like jewelry photography, not consumer

0:33:43electronics photography to sort of emphasize the difference between the iPhone Pro models and the

0:33:49iPhone non pro models. Yeah, I mean, I the again, this one, I think it's really interesting that

0:33:55we're leaning into the material and not the camera or the action button or any of the features of the

0:34:00phone. And I think it's still a little bit of a remnant of the sort of Johnny Ive fashion era.

0:34:08Like it still permeates Apple a little bit when they do the big mass consumer marketing. These

0:34:14are fashion items or cultural objects, all this stuff. I mean, right next to that is they're

0:34:18showing the Olivia Rodrigo commercials where they're shooting it right like they are emphasizing

0:34:23the technical capabilities there. But even that is about a cultural product, right? It's not the

0:34:28music video. It's not really about the phone. Like you wouldn't walk away from that ad. Being like,

0:34:35I know a lot about the phone, what you know is this phone was used to make this really awesome

0:34:38music video. And that there's much more of a cultural piece to that, which I think,

0:34:44emphasizing the material is, it's of the same category. Right? Here's a here's a very luxury

0:34:51item. At this point, we're we're, we are in the middle of covering gigantic trials. It seems like

0:34:57the entire tech world is literally on trial all the time right now. And we have this window

0:35:03because of DOJ versus Google, which is all about Apple's deal with Google to have Google as default

0:35:09search, and then Epic versus Google, which is all about Google's contractual relationships with

0:35:14various parties who make the phones make the apps. We have this window into how all these deals are

0:35:19made. And you're like, Oh, the iPhone really is dominant. The world warps around this product.

0:35:24And Apple just has to make you think it's constantly cool in the marketing.

0:35:28Yeah, because it's not that you won't go buy a new iPhone, you won't forget about it.

0:35:33But the brand halo of looking at how cool the thing I own is, is like important to maintain.

0:35:40It's fascinating to watch Apple market a new phone, which is, I mean, I think it's very similar

0:35:46to the outgoing phone minus USB-C, even the camera, like, they're right on top of each other.

0:35:50Like the longer zoom, obviously performs a little better in low light. There's there's the

0:35:54incremental stuff. But pound for pound, they're like very similar. And there's, in my opinion,

0:36:01there's really no way for a 15 year old product for that not to be true. Right. And every once in

0:36:08a while, there will be some sort of breakthrough. I mean, the best example I can possibly think of,

0:36:15because it's almost a canonical example would be the Mac in 2020. At age, let me think here 36.

0:36:25Yeah, 36 year old platform, moving to Apple Silicon was a holy shit, this is like years

0:36:34of difference. If you bought like a late or in the middle of 2020, bought the last generation

0:36:42of an Intel MacBook of any model, compared to what you would get in the end of November,

0:36:49when Apple Silicon and the first M1 chips debuted, it was like, wow, these are, it's a chasm chasm

0:36:58between these two products. That's very rare for an established product. And the iPhone at 15. It's

0:37:04just you can't, you just can't reasonably expect anything like that on a regular basis, right?

0:37:11There really isn't a practical difference between the iPhone 14 and 15. In almost any regard,

0:37:19other than the USB C and the difference between the titanium and steel. And yeah, and for the

0:37:26people who put them in a kit that I put it in my review. It's like the nice thing about the

0:37:30titanium versus steel thing is even if you are in the vast majority of people who keep your phone in

0:37:35a case all the time, you still enjoy the benefits of the weight reduction. Yeah, which is which is

0:37:40not nothing. No, it's very meaningful. Here's the thing they could do. They could steal from

0:37:44car world. So there are these long running car models in the world. And every now and again,

0:37:50they're like, we're bringing it back. Here's a Mustang from the sixties again, here's a new

0:37:55beetle. And you're like, will they ever just do the iPhone four again? Like if they put, if the

0:38:00iPhone 16 was just the iPhone four design, but bigger for our time of bigger screens, I feel like

0:38:07yeah, I'm definitely buying that. Zero questions asked. I would buy an iPhone four. I would buy an

0:38:13iPhone 16 sized iPhone four. Man, that was a pretty cool design too. It was easily the best one.

0:38:20I like the iPhone five and five s best, but for similar reasons, right and and but for

0:38:30retro nostalgic value, I'd give I'd give it to the iPhone four four s style because it was a little

0:38:36bit more iconic or stood out a little bit it was a little bit it was it wasn't like the iPhones that

0:38:43came before it. And there hasn't been, there haven't been iPhones since that look even

0:38:46introduced. I think he said it looks like a beautiful old Leica camera. Like it was introduced

0:38:51with a bit of retro to it. But I just want to be look at other things. Yeah. Other things that run

0:38:57for this amount of time. There's always at some point, a callback to the past is a reset. And you

0:39:03build from there. Cars are I think are probably the best example of this. But it happens in

0:39:08watches. It happens in fashion. It has not yet happened in technology design, which seems to be

0:39:14ever pushing forwards towards canonical examples of what a laptop is or a phone. But you could just

0:39:22you could totally see how you would rewind it. You could get somewhere if they put out a

0:39:26titanium power rook g4. Like I'd buy tomorrow zero questions asked. I would buy that thing.

0:39:36Yeah, something that really looked like the old one, but just had modern bezels around the screen

0:39:40and stuff like that. But tomorrow, if you're listening, tomorrow. I also do think it does

0:39:48seem like broadly across industries. Design has gotten homogenized in the last decade, or decade

0:40:00and a half, right? Like you really it is it is extremely difficult to identify a cell phone at a

0:40:07glance. These days. They all look like iPhones, right? I mean, they all have retful screens,

0:40:14round corners, same dimensions. It's, it's very hard. Cars, I think, I think have never ever in

0:40:22the entire 120 years of the auto industry have never looked more all the same. Yeah. And I don't

0:40:32like it. And the more I see details about it, the less I like it. But I do have to give Tesla credit

0:40:38for the Cybertruck being wholly unlike anything else that's ever been made, right? The only thing

0:40:45I can think of that that has any DNA to would be like, well, what if the DeLorean Motor Company had

0:40:51been a had been a success? And then they expanded to the point where instead of just making a

0:40:58sports car, they'd made a pickup truck? Well, I guess that's what it would look like, right?

0:41:03Yeah. And there does seem to be concern. I don't know how well it's going to sell. But it certainly

0:41:08seems like just in the broad market of people who might buy a pickup truck or an electric truck,

0:41:15people at least are interested in the Cybertruck. And there's certainly no mistaking which car it

0:41:21is that when that drives by no one is going to go, Hey, what is that? Was that a Ford? No.

0:41:25Yeah, it's true. I mean, look, most cars, cars have like a packaging problem. Phones all look

0:41:32the same. And they work the same, because the manufacturers are desperate to get you to switch.

0:41:36And so they they reduce the switching costs. This is something that has come out,

0:41:41again, in these interminable trials, which are very fun to cover, by the way, there's just a

0:41:45lot of them at once. And the Google like the DOJ one went for 11 weeks. So it's like trial overload,

0:41:50but you learn a lot. We're learning a lot. And you learn that the you think switching costs is

0:41:57some like esoteric tech nerd term. And in reality, all these companies are thinking about all the

0:42:03time. They want to prevent churn, they want to acquire customers, they're like trying to get

0:42:06market share. And so phones have collapsed. Particularly the central innovation of the iPhone

0:42:12at the beginning, with Steve Jobs saying all these buttons, you could get them out the way,

0:42:16let the app define the interface. So the phone like the hardware design of the phone,

0:42:22really, we've now reached a point where it is fully taken a backseat to the software design.

0:42:28And then the software design because they want to reduce switching costs is all just sort of

0:42:31converging on some some iOS Android middle point, right? iOS steal some stuff from Android every

0:42:38year and Android steal some stuff from iOS. And that's the way it goes. But there is that

0:42:42convergence. So it is homogenous. Cars is like a is a packaging problem. Particularly as you move

0:42:49to EVs, and you basically have a big battery and some motors at the wheels. Everyone's what shape

0:42:54should this be? And those are the cars that are interesting, right? The new Hyundai's and new Kia's,

0:42:59they're just like out there. Those are some of the most interestingly designed cars that there are.

0:43:04And then the Cybertruck is like, what if it was a triangle? Why not? I am very curious about two

0:43:12things with the Cybertruck. One is what you said, will anybody buy it? Right? There's lots of

0:43:16reservations. We'll see how it goes. I think pickup truck owners notoriously brand loyal.

0:43:22If there's one thing about the Cybertruck that makes them happy, they're just going to flip back.

0:43:28If there's one thing about the Cybertruck that makes them unhappy, they're just going to flip

0:43:31back. That's how that's going to go. And then the second thing, which I will now bring to your

0:43:36audience, the Verticast audience knows I'm obsessed with this. I have been told that the

0:43:41wiper is actually two wiper blades in a row. And I have been begging for, well, I guess we'll find

0:43:48out on Thursday because the launch event's on Thursday. But I have been begging for someone to

0:43:52just lift this thing up because they're all over the place now and just tell me if it's two wiper

0:43:56blades in a row. I'm pretty sure they figured it out now and they're just making one gigantic

0:44:03custom wiper. But I have definitely seen somewhere it's two wipers in a row. And I'm like, of all of

0:44:10the design problems to resolve in the world, the windshield wiper was like high on Tesla's list

0:44:18with this truck. I do think that even certainly even more so than your dominance atop what is

0:44:25a photo. I think how many rubber blades are on the cyber truck wiper has got to be where you

0:44:33absolutely undeniably are the king of social media. I mean, there's no doubt about it,

0:44:38Neil. Every now and again, you're like, oh, this is my brand. And my brand is being obsessed with

0:44:41this wiper because it is, I mean, one, it's hilarious. Like, it's just deeply funny. And

0:44:45the stakes are so low, like who cares? But two, it's so emblematic of this entire vehicle and

0:44:52Elon Musk's entire moment where he is so convinced that he's smarter than every other person in the

0:44:59world that he had to reinvent the wiper blade. And it's, no, you didn't. You really did not.

0:45:05You could have put two wipers in the front of your truck. Well, it would have been fine.

0:45:09I think a better example, well, maybe not a better example, but another very similar example is the

0:45:15goofy yoke steering wheel on some of the Tesla models, which is terrible. I'm sorry. I mean,

0:45:21I don't, I've never driven one with it, but I've, I just know it's terrible. And I've never seen

0:45:26anybody who really has opinions about cars who thinks that that's a good design for a steering

0:45:31wheel, but it does look cooler. That's why Knight Rider had a yoke instead of a steering wheel,

0:45:36right? Yeah. I mean, it definitely looks cooler. That's the only thing it has going for it,

0:45:42but ergonomically, it is a terrible design for a steering device for a car. A wheel is what you

0:45:48want. Then they put that there. I mean, they're not shy about this because they thought that you

0:45:53wouldn't be driving. Right. So like, why not make it look cool? And that doesn't work well enough.

0:45:58Right. Or maybe never will. Maybe never will. Right. I can't tell you how many emails I've

0:46:03gotten from people. I, you probably have too, but people who've worked on the problem in my case,

0:46:08for a company that isn't yet selling cars who, who genuinely believe, and it's not speaking for the,

0:46:16for the company, but as a personal engineering level, don't believe full self-driving will ever

0:46:22be a thing within our lifetimes that it's that difficult, especially given the realistic

0:46:28constraint that they have to be introduced alongside 99% of cars being driven by humans.

0:46:36If you could magically say, we're going to make human driven cars illegal, starting in two years,

0:46:45and the only cars allowed on the road will be self-driving cars, then it's theoretically

0:46:51possible. I think everybody would agree to have some sort of way that cars would communicate with

0:46:56each other and it would all be safe and would probably work. But even then there are problems

0:47:03that are just extremely difficult to, to solve. Yeah. But it was a weird thing for them to bank on

0:47:11with the industrial design of the steering wheel, the goal wings on the, was it the model Y or

0:47:17the access Falcon wing doors. Yeah. The Falcon people love them, but they break and they leak

0:47:23and it's fun. They're terrible in a parking lot because they require space that a door that opens

0:47:28from the side doesn't necessarily need to get in certain parking lots where, where the spots are

0:47:34too close to each other. The wings are just a terrible design for a door. Yeah. Well,

0:47:40they look cool. They do look cool. I mean, look, some people love their Teslas and I know people

0:47:48who are horrified by Elon Musk and they would like to switch from a Tesla and they're like,

0:47:53I can't, the tech in this car is too good. I know other people who are like, I can't believe I fell

0:47:58for full self-driving. I paid $15,000 this feature and it's never going to work. Right. Remember,

0:48:03Elon promised everybody that your Tesla would just be out there driving at night,

0:48:07doing robotaxis for you. Yeah. Making money. People believed him. Yeah. In a way that I think

0:48:13people are starting to get wise. We'll see how the Cybertruck event goes. They're only supposed

0:48:18to give away 10 of them. I'm assuming they're going to be like heavily NDA. But the reality is

0:48:23he's now competing in the fiercest part of the American car market. The one with the most brand

0:48:30loyalty to most of them, the most opinions. Right. With a very expensive product that is

0:48:35basically a low poly render of a real car. And we'll just, we'll just see. I think this on top

0:48:41of the Twitter stuff, which is a disaster, I won't post there anymore. And I know a lot of my

0:48:46journalist friends won't post there anymore. And like brands are quitting and you, you couple the

0:48:50like, is this product that you sort of bet a chunk of the company's future on any good with also

0:48:57people are repulsed by the CEO who is just posting openly racist memes now. Yeah. I want, well, can

0:49:04they continue to attract talent? Right? Like, maybe this is how Apple actually does ship that car.

0:49:09Because all the good people at Tesla are like, we just need a new place to go work. Right.

0:49:13I wonder, I have to say as a somebody married to a woman who's not at all tech obsessed, but is

0:49:24technically proficient, given the general population, but just didn't have strong

0:49:31opinions about Elon Musk until the Twitter thing happened. She'd heard of him. And she,

0:49:35I think she had a vague idea that he was sort of a jackass, or like an attention whore, but really

0:49:42didn't have strong opinions. There is 0% chance that I could convince my wife for us to get a

0:49:47Tesla. There's no way I might as well ask her to buy a car with swastikas painted on it at this

0:49:52point. Oh, but he gets, you know, it's really the best driving car. It's like, there's no way she's,

0:49:58I mean, to her, that's practically that's on the spectrum of what the Tesla brand stands for at

0:50:03this point. And so they could be giving them away. And I couldn't get her to take one.

0:50:07Yeah, I have friends who are like, I need to get rid of mine. It's the whole spectrum.

0:50:11And sometimes like the product is just good enough that it wins over the brand. But that

0:50:15is not forever. Right. By the way, one thing I'll point out a totally different car related subject.

0:50:21It's November 28th when we're recording this. Apple has what 32 days, 33 days to ship carplay,

0:50:30the full carplay that they announced the WWDC last year, this year. It's never going to happen.

0:50:34It's never, I've talked to so many car CEOs on decoder. I've talked to people who make other car

0:50:41entertainment systems. I asked them this question, would you ever hand over your car to Apple in this

0:50:46way? And it's just deafening silence. Right? I learned a lot about this. And you you'll remember

0:50:52this because actually, I think you are the one of the first people to reach out to me with some

0:50:56corrections where there was a story a couple months ago where Porsche came out with a new

0:51:03second sort of like a screen in front of the passenger seat in some of their cars. Yeah. And

0:51:10I mistakenly thought it might be and they were like, it wasn't like, hey, we're shipping this.

0:51:15It was like Porsche pre announcing. This is coming. And so I thought, oh, because it's coming

0:51:21like next year, early next year. This must be the first and I knew that that the whole Porsche group

0:51:28has been pretty pro carplay, right? The whole Volkswagen company or whatever, I guess. Who is

0:51:35it? Is it Volkswagen or Porsche who really owns it? I guess it's Porsche who owns the whole group,

0:51:39but that they've been pretty carplay friendly all along. I thought, oh, this is the first

0:51:44carplay to announcement. And you're like, no, that's not carplay too. And and then I looked

0:51:48and of course, I should have known better. There's tons of verge coverage about it. It's just an

0:51:53extra screen. And then a couple people who own Porsches are like that, that second screen isn't

0:51:57even new. And it's totally stupid. And every single person, every single No, every single

0:52:04person who reached out to me who owns a Porsche who has the screen said, I paid extra for it. And

0:52:10I it's the only thing I regret about my purchase. Because and they're like, hey, this and when you

0:52:15pay extra for something from Porsche, it's a lot. I don't know what the add on is. But you know,

0:52:21yeah, I mean, you there's you can get it in black or you can get it in the good black. And it's Oh,

0:52:26I want the good black paint. And they're like, well, that's an extra $10,000. Ah, geez.

0:52:32No, I don't think it's coming. Yeah, it was so it was last WWDC. Right. So it was June

0:52:4022, when the Apple announced it and the gist of it. I got too distracted by the idea that it was

0:52:48more adaptive to irregular shaped displays, which sounds super useful in the design of a dashboard.

0:52:59But I think what you can hit on there and what I missed and I see why it might be a non starter

0:53:06is in addition to that technical detail, which is very cool. And I'm sure car makers would embrace

0:53:13it. The whole point of carplay to really is to put the whole computer experience for the whole car

0:53:18in carplace hands, right? It's it's no longer just show me some media stuff from my iPhone,

0:53:26or let me use my iPhone to show maps from whichever map app I want, which is a great feature,

0:53:31right? That's one of the great benefits of the carplay Android auto present of cars where you

0:53:40get a choice in your mapping. And you don't even have to pay if you're using Apple Maps or Google

0:53:45Maps, as opposed to you have to use your car makers brand of maps and pay your car maker

0:53:54$45 a month for the privilege. And it's shittier compared to what you would get on your phone

0:54:00anyway. That's great. But the idea that they're going to put their brand and their control over

0:54:06the whole thing in anybody else's hands, and I think they're right, honestly, it almost seems

0:54:11foolish, especially and it gets to the heart of the whole question of Apple's dual position of,

0:54:20okay, they make one of the two major platforms for getting your phone to drive your on screen

0:54:26content, right? There's Android and there's iPhone, and that's it. But also, it's the biggest open

0:54:33secret in the entire history of Apple, I'd say even more so than the headset was until they

0:54:39announced it a couple months ago, that Apple has an incredibly large division working on making

0:54:47an Apple branded car, right? So there, I mean, I don't know that they would do it even if if Apple

0:54:55totally announced if Tim Cook just they just said, we had this whole project Titan, and we're

0:55:03shutting it down. And then it's just all in the open. And all of these people with expertise in

0:55:08the area are all on the market and can go to work at Tesla or Ford or whoever else wants to hire

0:55:15them. Even then, I don't know that car makers would want to put that much control into another

0:55:21company's hands. But given that Apple is still seemingly working on making competing products,

0:55:28I don't know, I don't get it. Why would you hand it and you need your phone, right? This is like,

0:55:34the problem for every car maker is one they know their future, especially as things go electric,

0:55:40is they're not going to be able to differentiate on engines anymore performance, the cars are going

0:55:45to be fast and quiet, right? They might be able to differentiate on range, differentiate on the

0:55:50experience inside the car. And you are already seeing that in huge ways. I love Doug DeMuro

0:55:55videos, Doug's a good guy, you should go watch them. They're all just about the buttons you can

0:56:00push inside the car. That's how the cars are being differentiated. Now is look at all the

0:56:04cup holders and buttons and weird like quirks and features, right? And then he you watch every

0:56:09single one of these videos, and I've talked to Doug about this a number of times, Doug and every

0:56:13other car viewer on YouTube, they wave at the screen, and they say it runs carplay and Android

0:56:17Auto. Yeah, and they just move on. They're done with that. And that is if you are a car maker,

0:56:24that is death. What is happening is Doug DeMuro is casting a spell on you, that you will die soon,

0:56:31because you are no longer in control of where all the most interesting features of the future of

0:56:36cars will happen. And so GM dropping carplay, probably a huge short term mistake for GM.

0:56:40If you're GM, you're like, we need people to start using our shit. We need people,

0:56:46we need to escalate buyers to think that our software is good. Is that going to happen?

0:56:52I have no idea. But it is an amount of self esteem that the car industry has not had about making

0:56:59software save Tesla in forever. Right. And Rivian, right? And Rivian is brand new. Right.

0:57:06And it's cool. And you know, Rivian, like they make the whole stack. They've licensed,

0:57:10I think it's Unreal in their cars, the Unreal Engine, the graphics are really cool.

0:57:14You can see the newer car makers have figured this out. The older car makers are not going to just

0:57:21hand this over to Apple and die, which is I think what would happen. We started this whole

0:57:26conversation by saying all cars kind of look the same and design is dead. If you're driving around

0:57:30in a bunch of bubbly crossover SUVs that are all running carplay, like how are you going to

0:57:36advertise these cars? But how are you going to market any differentiation? So there's some huge

0:57:42tension there that's going to get resolved. I don't know in which way. And I think some car

0:57:48makers are running towards Apple basically. And most of them are running towards Google.

0:57:56And they're saying, we're going to let Android Automotive, which is Google's OS for cars,

0:58:01not Android Auto, the phone, the Android Automotive, who's actually the OS for cars

0:58:06and run in the car. We're going to bet on this because we think the power of Google's overall

0:58:11ecosystem and cars will bring us an app platform and all the other stuff that we need. And that's

0:58:19GM, that's Ford, that's Volvo. It's like down the line, they're all running Android.

0:58:24Right. But with carplay support, most of the cars that have carplay support are running on Android.

0:58:30Yeah. It's utterly crazy. Right. But at some point they're going to, I think they're all inevitably

0:58:38going to do the GM thing, except for Volvo. I just had CEO of Volvo on decoder.

0:58:44Yeah. And he was like, no, we're never doing that.

0:58:46I don't know about that. I think keeping it so that you can at least get the content from your

0:58:50phone, like media content and maps content onto your screen just makes people happy. I thought

0:58:56it was so funny because it's so seldom happens. But Joanna Stern, our mutual dear friend had

0:59:03the CEO of Ford on stage at one of the Wall Street Journal's events over the summer. And when she

0:59:09asked him about the GM decision to drop carplay, he laughed. And you really just don't see CEOs

0:59:17laughing at their competitors very often. And maybe long-term even they'll move in that direction,

0:59:23but in the near term, it seems, man, that is a disaster. And the backstory on that is just how

0:59:29many people when they go into a dealer to buy a car have carplay and it's a stat Apple has bragged

0:59:36about. And it was so eye popping. I think you and I might've even been together when they first

0:59:42popped like at that first WWDC, the one we're talking about where they announced carplay too.

0:59:47And when they announced how many US new car buyers demand have carplay as a non-negotiable feature

0:59:54they want. I forget what the number was, but it's, I don't know, it's 80% or I don't know,

0:59:59some ridiculous number. And we were like, that can't be true. And they were like, well, it's

1:00:04a new car buyers, not car buyers, right? And so new car buyers by definition are more affluent.

1:00:11It's because they're more, way more expensive than used cars. And you listen to them and it's,

1:00:17huh, that does make sense. And then you look into it. And it's like other people say the same thing.

1:00:21And people people wrote into me and they're like, yeah, I work at a car dealer. And yes,

1:00:26that's the how many people come in and say I need, they won't look at a car without carplay.

1:00:31Trenton Larkin And I, I believe it. Honda and Toyota were

1:00:34holdouts for a long time. And they actually they had to cave right the market just demanded carplay

1:00:38from them. I'm just saying if you are, if you are a carmaker, if you are any kind of device maker,

1:00:45turning over the core user interface of your product to another company is not a good idea.

1:00:51No. Well, it's just think about it just from the maps perspective, right? And I agree with you. I

1:00:56love I, I'm, I have like Tom Tom map, we have a new gene, and has whatever maps Tom Tom or whatever.

1:01:02And it's this is horrible. But if you are selling an EV to people, and you needed to be able to plan

1:01:09a route or do charging, or self driving, you actually need control of the map, you need

1:01:17control of the navigation interface of the car, right? And you've got to wait for Apple to give

1:01:23it to you. That's you can't hand your future off like that. And I, I really do think this is the

1:01:28central tension. Apple had a great idea with carplay to although I think we talked about this

1:01:32last year, maybe the design of it, like just what they were showing on the screens was asinine.

1:01:39It was like four clocks. But they had the right idea, right? This big adaptive thing,

1:01:43all this, all the apps will take over the speedometer, all this stuff. They're better

1:01:46designers, obviously. But you there's no wonder no one's taken it up. You cannot hand over

1:01:52everything the future of your business to a company, like you said, that might be building

1:01:57a car of its own. Well, and the other factor too, that I've wondered about, and really,

1:02:02sort of a year later, when I re re looked at it this summer with that Porsche thing,

1:02:07is well, wait a second, even if a car maker totally bought in to Apple's spiel and said,

1:02:17Okay, we're going to embrace carplay to as soon as we can, we're going to put our engineering team

1:02:23onto it and say this is a high priority, we would like to ship these in the first possible model

1:02:28year. It only works if the customer has an iPhone, right? That's the only way that you get carplay

1:02:35to so the car needs to do all of that stuff in its built in interface anyway, right? Because it's

1:02:41like stuff like like how much how much energy is left in the battery if it's an electric vehicle,

1:02:47right? That's obviously that's essential information. If it's presented through carplay to

1:02:53when you you're using carplay to there still needs to be a way when for people who don't own

1:02:58an iPhone or if you just even if you do own an iPhone, but you get in the car without your phone

1:03:03with you. Yeah, it needs to still be there. So it effectively doubles the work. It's like you need

1:03:11to have a built in interface for everything. And then you need to redesign everything to work with

1:03:16carplay to that makes no sense. Honestly, it just and the other thing that it's just sort of ironic,

1:03:22almost it's Horace Deju coined it as the the cook doctrine. But it was one of the maybe the first

1:03:30time that Tim or maybe the second time that he was acting CEO while Steve Jobs was out on medical

1:03:35leave, but it was in hindsight, obviously sort of laying the groundwork for Tim Cook, who up until

1:03:42that point had sort of been a behind the scenes figure at Apple, and mainly known for his presence

1:03:49on the quarterly analyst calls not at keynotes or product wise, but he sort of had to in his

1:03:57prepared statement like a effectively a doctrine and read it and it was part of it was I'll put

1:04:05the link to the show notes where where Horace transcribed it but the part that sticks out is

1:04:11we believe that we need to own and control the primary technologies behind the products we make

1:04:16and participate only in markets where we can make a significant contribution.

1:04:20That is essentially just that it that explains why they pursued Apple silicon when they could have

1:04:29easily stayed on Intel forever. Because then they you know, while the Mac platform was on Intel,

1:04:37they it was at worst, technically under the hood, architecturally the same as every other

1:04:44PC out there. And so they could compete solely on the design of the cases, the quality of the

1:04:50displays, and of course, the software versus Windows, but so essential that they deemed it

1:04:57worthwhile to pursue their own architecture, right? That if you apply that doctrine as a car

1:05:05maker, controlling the interface to the car on the screen to be deemed a primary technology behind

1:05:14the products that you make. Right? Yeah. No, without question. It is that I'm glad you brought

1:05:20this up because it's the thing that's always been on my mind when I hear about the future of cars is

1:05:24if you seed control of the software, you've lost the product, right? Especially with EVs like it

1:05:31is like a traditional carmaker is really good at building gasoline engines, controlling explosions,

1:05:40moving fuel, right? An engine is a big air pump. It's that is a very complicated mechanical

1:05:45engineering problem. And I'm not saying EVs are not, but they're different in a meaningful way.

1:05:52And the consumer experience of them is meaningfully different, right? So now you're

1:05:59just left with the experiences you can have in the car. And boy, if you don't have control of

1:06:05the screen, are you limited in what you can do? Like you're down to cup holders. You're down to

1:06:09basically coupled. Well, you say cup holders when we took Jonas, we took my son, we drove him up to

1:06:15Boston for his sophomore year of college at the end of August. And I rented a Jeep Wagoneer, which

1:06:22is their big ass, but DNA via blood and truly one of the ugliest cars ever. Oh, it is it was

1:06:28hideously ugly. And it's ridiculous. It's so big. It is so big that as we were driving, I noticed

1:06:34that I could as an of course, I passed a lot of cars because I drive fast. But as we would pass

1:06:40minivans, I could see their sunroof. I'm so high up that I'm looking that's really down on a

1:06:48minivan. But there was some question I had about the Wagoneer and I thought I know that the best

1:06:54way to find an answer to this is Oh, I know what it was. I couldn't find the the USB C port that

1:07:02I would want to use to plug my phone into CarPlay. So I didn't have to use Bluetooth. And it was it.

1:07:08I just couldn't find it. And so I looked at a YouTube video and the YouTube video was about

1:07:14the fact that the Wagoneer has 18 USB ports. And they were celebrating. This is so awesome.

1:07:21Look at this. It doesn't matter where you're sitting. You've got you can charge to every

1:07:25single seat in this car can have two devices charging backseat, middle seat, middle seat,

1:07:32even the middle seat. There's like here is a USB port just for somebody sitting in the middle seat

1:07:36in the second row. And it's exactly but that's that's cupholders right 18 USB ports.

1:07:42Why not? So my Jeep does also has a second screen in the front passenger. And I have all these

1:07:49dreams that my wife will drive and I'll plug my phone in over HDMI and stream and it's not just

1:07:55gonna hold my phone. Like I did it once. And I was like, Wait, why am I not just holding my phone?

1:08:00And the only other thing you can do is put the map up on it. But it's only the built in map.

1:08:05So we have the screen that we never use. And that is I'm telling you, this is existential for car

1:08:10makers. Yeah, no doubt about it faces. And the sooner they recognize that, I mean, and it to me,

1:08:18it's the broad trend. And I think it's underappreciated. You get it because I think it

1:08:22almost exemplifies the verge. What is it that the verge covers is the fact that everything is

1:08:32becoming a computer, everything's a computer, and it's only going to accelerate right. I mean,

1:08:37my favorite example is that our headphones are computers now, right? Little our airport,

1:08:42our air air pods and every other wireless headphones from competing companies that are

1:08:47the same thing. They're just little independent computers that fit in your ear. That's all

1:08:52everything is a computer. And car makers who don't recognize that they're just big multi ton,

1:08:58fast moving computers. They're out there. They're missing the point. That's all they are. They're

1:09:04just big people transporting computers. Yeah, they fail. There's an infinite car makers love

1:09:11car CEOs love being on decoder. They like talking about it. They want to talk to a tech audience

1:09:17about how they know they are rolling computers now. And there's a big split. There's the car part

1:09:23where they're basically integrating hundreds, if not thousands of little custom microcontrollers

1:09:30from different suppliers that control the windshield wipers and the body control module.

1:09:34All of that stuff is now moving to unified platforms. And that was initially the big Tesla

1:09:41innovation. It is the Rivian innovation, right? That they've, they've unified the compute

1:09:46architecture of the entire car so that your brake lights are running on the same compute stack as

1:09:52whatever else. That is not true in most cars today yet in a way that it's true. That's why Tesla can

1:09:58do over there updates. And then there's the infotainment experience, which is what most

1:10:03people think when the car is a computer. So these things are happening in parallel. The car makers

1:10:09have very quickly moved on the unify all of the architecture of the car piece because they all

1:10:17have the same problem. So the suppliers are getting ahead of it, right? Cause they're just responding

1:10:22to like market demand basically from all these car makers. So they're figuring it out over there,

1:10:28make good touch screen computers continues to allude virtually every company that is not Apple

1:10:35or Samsung's mobile division. Google, right? There's a handful of companies that are like,

1:10:40we're good at touch screen, mobile computers and car makers as of yet save Tesla are not among them.

1:10:46Right. Rivian may be close, but even there. I keep not talking about like,

1:10:51keep bringing up Rivian's a teeny tiny company. Right. That's exactly why Lucid is potentially

1:10:56good at this too. Right. But like, right there, they are just different. Well, and it's yeah,

1:11:02cause there's currently there. So you just, you don't buy a Rivian. You get on a years long list

1:11:07to buy a Rivian. You can at least one now. Do you have to get on a list? I don't know. And they will

1:11:13allow you to lease a Rivian. So they're really nice vehicles that you're on a list. It's just

1:11:18a list of people who make 95,000 dollars that are currently, they're currently made in such small

1:11:24quantities that there's just no way to extrapolate what it means to the industry. Like you had

1:11:29mentioned earlier that pickup truck buyers are infamously brand loyal and Rivian can sell their

1:11:37pickup trucks as fast as they can make them. But there's such a small quantity that it doesn't,

1:11:43it doesn't give us any clue as to whether the majority of pickup truck buyers are willing to

1:11:52switch to brands like Rivian or Tesla or something like that. It's just, it's just too much of a

1:11:57rounding error at this point as much as I, and I wish them luck because I love their design and,

1:12:02and I hope they succeed and thrive, but it's just too hard to, to draw any conclusions from their

1:12:09small quantity. Yeah. The first job that chat GPT is going to take in the auto industry is the

1:12:13person who writes the press release at Ford every year saying the F-150 is the best selling vehicle.

1:12:17They have written that press release for 40 years. Just let the robot do it, man. It's going to be

1:12:23fine. It just sounds it's to me hearing that phrase makes me think of NFL football because

1:12:32I don't remember, I don't remember watching football on TV without hearing that in a

1:12:39commercial, the best selling pickup truck in America. Oh, sorry. This is totally inside

1:12:45baseball. I think your audience will appreciate it. So, you know, the built Ford tough plate.

1:12:50Yeah. A friend of the ad industry, that plate was real. That was a real thing that they dropped

1:12:55to get that sound and that effect. And there, apparently there had been discussions about

1:13:00redoing it, updated, make sure, then they got to make another place. And then there was like,

1:13:06I don't know. I don't know where they landed. I just know that there was some conversation

1:13:08I'm doing in CGI and like people had very strong feelings about not actually dropping

1:13:13a giant metal plate again. Page Todd Visserie here for debate.

1:13:19Yeah. I would just say it's the cyber truck wiper. And did they drop a giant metal plate in the Ford

1:13:24ad? These are the car stories that I am chasing at the verge.com. All right, let me take a break

1:13:29here and thank our next sponsor. It's our good friends at trade coffee. Trade coffee is just a

1:13:35remarkable, remarkable service. You sign up for trade coffee and they deliver freshly roasted

1:13:41coffee beans to you on in the quantity and the schedule that you want. Now they are not a coffee

1:13:48roaster. You don't when you sign up with trade, you don't get trade branded coffee. What trade does

1:13:54is they have partnerships with over I forget how many hundreds but they have over 450 different

1:14:01coffees from over 55 top independent roasters. Here it is in my notes, 55 independent roasters

1:14:09around the country, 450 coffee varieties. And you might think, well, that's overwhelming. I don't

1:14:14know where to start. They if you don't know where to start, you go to drink trade.com slash the talk

1:14:19show drink trade.com slash the talk show. They'll walk you through getting started with a couple of

1:14:25questions about what kind of coffees you like. coffee starts showing up to your house and then

1:14:30they'll send you an email a couple days later. How do you like you know, and they know exactly

1:14:34which coffee you got? How do you like it? Thumbs up, thumbs down. And then you just do a couple

1:14:38of tweaks like that. It's like the Netflix algorithm sort of, you say I like that, that

1:14:44one I didn't like so much. And then they just dial in to your tastes. And it is uncanny. I mean,

1:14:51algorithms are good at lots of things at this point. But trade coffee has an algorithm that

1:14:55gets me coffee that I love every time. And it's really, really fun. You don't have to go

1:15:01shopping or make any choices. It just happens automatically that you get new coffee from new

1:15:07roasters you've never experienced before delivered right to your house. Again, what a great gift idea

1:15:13for the hard to shop for coffee lover in your life. Get him a subscription to trade coffee

1:15:17could be absolutely the best gift you give anybody all holiday season. It's really, really good.

1:15:22All sorts of everything you want. Things like Oh, you're going on vacation, you could skip

1:15:27a delivery or Oh, I'm getting I'm it's I'm, I'm running out of coffee before new stuff comes,

1:15:32you can adjust the delivery to get it more frequently, you can dial it back to get it more

1:15:37slowly, whatever you want. It is so easy to set up so easy to keep going. And all coffee that they

1:15:44deliver to you is freshly roasted. It's always shipped within 48 hours of being roasted takes

1:15:50a day or two to get to you. So you've got coffee delivered to your house that is days old from being

1:15:56roasted. You cannot get coffee beans like that at a grocery store. There's just no, it's just

1:16:01impractical. And coffee is like a produce even once it's been roasted, it just starts going bad.

1:16:07As soon as it's been roasted. It is so much better to have fresh coffee. It is more than what

1:16:13coffee maker you use or what technique you use. The number one way to get better coffee when you

1:16:19make it at home is to have freshly roasted coffee. And that's what trade delivers to you.

1:16:24So upgrade your morning routine. With better coffee right now trade is offering listeners

1:16:29of the talk show a free bag of coffee with any subscription. Again, the URL is drink trade.com/the

1:16:36talk show. That's drink trade.com/the talk show for a free bag of coffee with any subscription

1:16:42purchase. Drink trade.com/the talk show. It's funny what podcasts I don't do you do the reads

1:16:52for decoder or no, usually the decoder ones are often they're pre recorded, but they we are we

1:16:58are precious journalists, my friend. The well, I'm a one man show. So I don't have the opportunity.

1:17:05But I was listening to Bill Simmons podcast this week. And you can tell what they require where

1:17:11they're like, you have to say this this many times or this paragraph must be read verbatim.

1:17:16He had a spot from McDonald's. And at the end, he had to say copyright 2023 McDonald's Corporation.

1:17:24And it's like, no way. I swear to God, somebody at McDonald's, some lawyer at McDonald's needs

1:17:32to be fired. Because you don't need you don't need to state a copyright in a radio ad or a

1:17:41podcast ad. It's like, what are you doing? We might as well parlay this into talking about decoder you.

1:17:48I mean, it makes me sick. To be honest, the guests you've had and let's just start with the big one.

1:17:54You had fucking Obama. Yeah, on the show. My wife thought it was really cool. That was the coolest

1:18:00she's ever thought I've been. That's great. How did that come about? I highly recommend it. And

1:18:05it was for it was the topic and it was good that you had a topic because I mean, again, I mean,

1:18:10you know me, I'm I'll keep you here for three hours. I keep Obama Yeah, I mean, you could go

1:18:15for three weeks talking to that guy. But it was about the AI regulations that the Biden

1:18:19administration had passed and what he thinks about it. But how did it come about?

1:18:22I don't want to sound like I'm bragging at this point. There is more incoming to decoder than

1:18:28outgoing, which is really fascinating. See, I took over the show from Kara Swisher. This was recode

1:18:35decode. It was our old feed and she went to the Times and, and I'm a confident man. I think people

1:18:42acknowledge I have no lack of self confidence. But you know, it's like a daunting thing to take over

1:18:47Kara Swisher. So in the beginning, there's like lots of like, what are we gonna do? How do we not

1:18:51turn the audience and we've just gotten the show to the point where I think it's understandable

1:18:58enough what's going to happen and what we're going to talk about and how it's going to work

1:19:01that I think a lot of people want to be on it. I always describe it as it's a game that CEOs

1:19:07can plausibly win. Most of the episodes should be a tie. That's how I feel about it. But most CEOs,

1:19:14most executives, most ex presidents are pretty type A. They would like to be challenged and they

1:19:19would like to, they would like to win. I feel the same way. So decoder is set up that way.

1:19:23It's not over, it's not contentious. Sometimes it can be, but it's set up to be challenging.

1:19:30And so there's just, we do get a lot of incoming. And I think with Obama in particular,

1:19:36the one that we did was actually our second attempt at it. The first one had been just a

1:19:41couple of weeks prior. He had been set to open a big social media department at Harvard. There

1:19:47was a big fancy launch event. He was going to be on stage and we were going to do decoder right after

1:19:51and talk about content moderation. He's really big on it. He thinks that we should rethink how social

1:19:57networks impact democracy. This is a big point of it. It's in that interview because I was obviously

1:20:02very well prepped for that interview. And then he had what they called COVID like symptoms, so he

1:20:06had to cancel. So I was like, "Oh, this is never going to happen." I left and everyone was riding

1:20:12high and my team was all around me. They were all dressed up and they all looked sad. And then the

1:20:17AI thing was happening and his team called back and said, "He really wants to talk to you about

1:20:21this stuff." And I think, again, I just come back to that first piece of it. I'm good at whatever

1:20:27the things I'm going to talk about are. There are very few places where you can sit in the weeds of

1:20:32content moderation and get into it and be challenged and have it still be accessible to

1:20:37the audience. I want decoder to be that show where I always joke that the tagline of the entire

1:20:42verge is, "It's fun to be smart." And it's fun. So he came back and we talked about AI a little bit,

1:20:47but really what I wanted to talk to him about was how are we going to regulate social networks when

1:20:53there's just cannons of AI hallucinations pointed at every input box in the internet?

1:20:59Because you have a First Amendment in this country that makes it very difficult

1:21:03to even think about doing it. And if we were talking about Lightroom earlier,

1:21:09I can open Lightroom or Photoshop and confidently, with a lot of effort, make an image that looks

1:21:16convincing that is a lie. And the government really can't regulate me out of doing that.

1:21:20And they can't regulate Photoshop out of doing that. If I push a button that says, "Generate

1:21:26an image of me at the Eiffel Tower," the government right now is thinking about how to

1:21:30regulate Adobe when you push that button and not the other button. That's, to me, it's just like a

1:21:36wild point in history. There's only two other places where I can think of where that happens.

1:21:43One, you cannot Photoshop a dollar bill. You can't do it. You can try to scan into Photoshop. Maybe

1:21:49you can edit it. You try to print it. At some point, it's like, "No, we just don't allow this

1:21:54to happen. Stop it." And then the second is obviously child pornography. It's like speech that

1:21:59most platforms, we accept some amount of automated content recognition and integration with the

1:22:03police and everybody understands why. That's it. But now with AI, because the volume of deception

1:22:09can be so high, there is a real conversation about, "Okay, should we regulate the tools or

1:22:15the distributors?" And I think Obama, he's a big nerd and he just wanted to talk about it

1:22:21with somebody who was already in the weeds. And I'm a huge nerd and I was excited to do that.

1:22:27I don't know why people come to us, but that's my belief is that the show is challenging and

1:22:33people are drawn to it. It was a great interview. And I'm about as pro-Joe Biden as anybody I know.

1:22:44I really like him and I actually, I think he's doing a great job as president. But yet at the

1:22:49same time, I watched your interview with Obama and I'm like, "Christ, I miss that guy."

1:22:54I do.

1:22:55It's an overwhelming reaction to this interview.

1:22:58Both of those things can be true, right? I can totally think Joe Biden is doing a very good job

1:23:05as president and I'm very proud of a lot of the decisions or most of the decisions he made.

1:23:11In fact, I might even politically align more with Joe Biden personally than Barack Obama on certain

1:23:18issues, right? Like I'm very, my politics very much aligned with Joe Biden's. But yet at the

1:23:22same time, even me as a very pro-Biden person, he's not Barack Obama, right? He's not. He just isn't.

1:23:32The guy is just, he is a once in a lifetime combination of so many things, charisma,

1:23:43intellect, open-mindedness, knowledge, humility, right? Like he has an enormous amount of humility

1:23:50for somebody who's, well, a two-time…

1:23:53Well, let me offer you one tiny… I'll give you actually two tiny counterpoints to this.

1:23:59At Decoder, we interview a whole lot of people from a wide variety of backgrounds. Everyone needs

1:24:04to know how to pronounce my name. So the way that I have learned to get around telling people how to

1:24:10pronounce my name is I ask them how to pronounce their name. And then that has evolved into,

1:24:15and tell me what title you'd like to use. And I'll tell you this after two years now we've been doing

1:24:20this, academics really give a shit about what title. Like you ask that question, you get like

1:24:25a 10-minute response, all the endowments say whatever. CEOs are like, "Whatever." Barack

1:24:30Obama looked at me and said, "Everyone knows who I am." Just flatly that's what he said. It was an

1:24:35incredible… I was like, "All right, my shtick is not working here, whatever, but at least I said

1:24:39my name to him." And then as he was leaving, and this just blew my mind, we had been talking about

1:24:48the First Amendment and writing some laws. And there's this very famous Supreme Court case

1:24:53called Red Lion that says the government can regulate broadcasters because they use public

1:24:57airwaves. This is why the FCC could find CBS for the Janet Jackson thing, but they can't

1:25:03regulate what happens on the internet. CBS uses the public airwaves. So it's like, you got to

1:25:07find something. How are you going to regulate the internet without somebody like this? And he just

1:25:12looked at me and he's like, "Yeah, you just got to figure it out. You'll figure it out." And he

1:25:16just left. And I was like, "Oh, you used to be the most powerful person in the world." Your brain is

1:25:21like, "Why are you bothering me with this problem? Come up with four solutions and I'll pick one."

1:25:26Yes, there's humility, there's intellectual humility. But then every now and again,

1:25:30you're reminded, he's very aware that he's one of the most famous people in world history,

1:25:36and certainly used to be the most powerful person in the world.

1:25:39Pete: Right. So I say that relative to who he is and what he's accomplished, right?

1:25:45Joe: That's true.

1:25:45Pete; Not just a two-time president of the United States, but a overwhelmingly popular

1:25:50two-time president of the United States.

1:25:52Joe; And left and right, the feedback was, "Boy, we miss that guy." There are Trump voters who

1:25:57listen to Decoder, they often write me emails telling me how stupid I am. That's all fine.

1:26:01But the overwhelming feedback was, "I wish we had a politician who could sit in the problem,"

1:26:07right? Who was obviously engaged in the problem, had done their research. I'm not saying, I don't

1:26:12know if Joe Biden has. I know that when Kamala Harris talks about it, it doesn't sound like it.

1:26:17And I know that when Trump talks about it, he sounds like he's from another planet.

1:26:20Pete; Right. It's all make-believe to him. It's all pro-wrestling. I've thought that since before

1:26:26he was even elected in 2016, and I think it's only gotten exacerbated as he's gotten older,

1:26:32gotten more crazy, is clearly losing his marbles in some way. He just thinks the whole world is

1:26:41pro-wrestling and that there's, you just, whoever yells the loudest wins, and it's no different on

1:26:46technical issues, even when there's very, very firm technical evidence. It doesn't matter at all.

1:26:53You just know, though, there's no way Joe Biden can talk like Obama does about this issue. He

1:26:59just isn't. And I don't, he is who he is, and I think he might be the first to admit it. Maybe

1:27:03not, because, dude, I miss that guy. Also, you dressed better than Obama, and he called you out

1:27:10on it at the beginning of the interview. So, again, this is like two rounds. So, the first

1:27:14time I didn't wear a tie. And then I watched, we did an emergency interview with Larry Lessig as a

1:27:21villain. Thank you, Professor Lessig. That was a great conversation. I encourage you to go listen

1:27:24to it. And I was watching the clips of that. I was like, I can't be looking like that. And I

1:27:30was dressed nicely. And so, the second time I wore a tie, and he walked in, he was like, what are you

1:27:34doing? All right.

1:27:34Pete Lausen>> You didn't need to wear a tie. That's what he said. Oh, man. It was a really

1:27:40good interview, though. And the other thing, too, and again, it is weird. I don't want to turn this

1:27:45into a whole thing about the next year's presidential election, but it is, and people are

1:27:50coming around to this, where because of Fox News, there's this whole narrative that Joe Biden at 81

1:27:57is too old, as though Trump isn't 77, right? Which is, you know, same ballpark, right? It's the same

1:28:05four-year window. And quite frankly, there's always on the right wing, too. There's this,

1:28:11especially driven by Trump, there's this whole thing of projection, right? Just, and it's, it's

1:28:17almost cartoonish in the way that it's like introductory psychology 101 for college sophomores.

1:28:25What is projection? The examples from Trump are like, couldn't be more almost laughable, right?

1:28:32So what do they accuse Joe Biden of? Corruption. This is the guy who owned a hotel three blocks

1:28:38from the White House while he was president of the United States. So the age thing is totally

1:28:47projection. They're both too old, right? I think everybody can admit it. I mean,

1:28:51I'm a big Joe Biden supporter. I'm going to be voting for him next year, no matter what,

1:28:55at this point. I mean, there's, what else? That's what the choice is. But I will happily admit,

1:29:01I think 81 years old is way too old to be president of the United States. I think it's

1:29:06too demanding. I think 77 is too old. But the idea that one of them is too old and not the other

1:29:14is ridiculous. But the other thing is, man, at 62, Obama seems younger than us, right?

1:29:22Yeah, he's doing all right. He's living his best life. There was a moment in that interview where

1:29:27I was like, you're an author. What do you think about Chatzavu and copyright? And he just goes,

1:29:30Michelle and I have done very well. And it's like, all right, you're doing great. We had our first

1:29:35sort of election planning meeting, the Verge team. How are we going to do this this year? And it was

1:29:41the first, eventually it's exciting. Election year is always exciting for journalists. You get to go

1:29:45out and there's lots of stuff happening. But you start from the perspective of these two guys are

1:29:51kind of the least important thing about the election, right? You're kind of voting for

1:29:56administrations or platforms or fundamental beliefs about America. Vibes. Vibes. And one of

1:30:04them is evil. It's autocratic in a way that scares me. The Verge is like, we don't have to pretend to

1:30:13be a newspaper. We just say it. And once you start from that premise, we can just say it out loud.

1:30:18It's weird that Trump is talking about doing the things that he's talking about doing, which are

1:30:24very autocratic. It's weird that Republicans seem to love speech regulations lately. For all Elon

1:30:30Musk talks about being a free speech absolutist, he's the one suing his critics right now.

1:30:34That's weird. And so you just start from this place of what is this election? It's not about

1:30:42these men who are old and what they say about their policies is rarely perfectly accurate.

1:30:51With Trump, it's not even related to reality. With Biden, he says stuff,

1:30:55and then the Biden administration clarifies what he says. It's just because he's off the cuff or

1:31:04whatever. But you're kind of voting for the operation of government. That's what this

1:31:09election is about. Do you want one that operates, that is respectful of its citizens? Or do you want

1:31:14one that's crazy? And if you're a tech publication, what are we going to ask them what their

1:31:19differences on TikTok are? This is almost like a nonsensical place to begin. And we kept going. We

1:31:26got excited about it because there's actually real differences. The service we do to the audience is

1:31:31motivating and all this stuff. But I was thinking about this coming out of the Obama interview,

1:31:37because that election was about him as a person. He was the captivating political leader. He

1:31:44represented all of the things. And this election in particular is the opposite of that. These are

1:31:51just stand-ins, they're cardboard cutouts of Democrats and Republicans, and they're both

1:31:57very old. And if they ever debate, I think it will just go down as the moment millions of young

1:32:04Americans decided to run for office. I think everyone's reaction to it has to be, we cannot

1:32:12hand over the operation to the country to an ever-increasing number of older people. We young

1:32:18people have to go do it. It's bizarre. It's just some sort of fluke of who won primaries and who

1:32:30ran out of terms to run for with the limit of two terms. I mean, if there weren't a term limit,

1:32:37Bill Clinton, obviously, in my opinion, would have easily won reelection in 2000. I mean,

1:32:41if Al Gore came within 500 votes in Florida, beating George W. Bush—

1:32:46Trevor Burrus Do you ever wonder about the timeline that

1:32:48Al Gore won? Like this, to me, I was a sophomore in college in 2000.

1:32:54Ben

1:33:11Leibovitz I always think when I think about what had happened, what would have been different if

1:33:32Gore had won in 2000? To me, it all comes down to whether they would have headed off 9/11. And I

1:33:41sort of think they would not have. And I know that people on the liberal left-leaning side love to

1:33:49over-index on the fact that—and this is a fact—that when the Bush people were coming in,

1:33:58and the foreign policy people or the national security people talked to the

1:34:03outgoing Clinton administration, the outgoing Clinton administration said,

1:34:07"We think the number one priority is Al Qaeda." And the Bush people were like, "Vat! Nope,

1:34:14it's Saddam." And that—it proved very prescient that in the year 2000, the last year, the Clinton

1:34:21administration, their national security people really thought that Al Qaeda was going to be a

1:34:26problem. And Al Qaeda had already tried to bomb the World Trade Center, right? They set off like

1:34:30a truck bomb that just wasn't explosive enough to bring the buildings down. And so there's some

1:34:36chance that a Gore administration would have been more focused on Al Qaeda in the first half of 2001

1:34:43and maybe would have covered it. But it was such a sneak attack and so deviously played the policies

1:34:55of airlines in the case of a hijacking against them. Such a pure jujitsu move. And it's funny,

1:35:01too, because I was watching like documentaries, like, I forget, there were a couple of them. But

1:35:05like in the 60s and 70s, like, airline hijackings were like super commonplace. And I know if you're

1:35:12young enough, you're like, "What? What are you talking about?" And it was like, "No!"

1:35:15Like dozens of times a year around the world, airlines, commercial airlines would be

1:35:19quote unquote hijacked by like activists. And they never crashed the planes. They'd say,

1:35:26"We want you to land and we want you to free political prisoners from such and such country

1:35:30or whatever." And it was just sort of like a hassle. People didn't get killed. The planes

1:35:35didn't explode. And the idea was that they institutionalize. The airlines said, "Okay,

1:35:40if you ever get hijacked, here's what you do. Just listen to the guys, do what they tell you to do.

1:35:44If they tell you to land, call air traffic control, say we're being hijacked, we're going to land

1:35:49at the nearest airport or wherever they want you to land. Just do what they say, because then

1:35:54nobody gets hurt." And, you know, playing that against us, that was the whole key to their plan

1:35:59was like, "They're just going to let us do what we want. We'll take the cockpit and then we'll fly

1:36:03the planes into the..." I think it would have happened. I think that what the Republicans would

1:36:08have done to Gore would have led us to today's level of partisanship. Partisanship doesn't even

1:36:15do justice. And Trump himself, like you said, where his rhetoric has gone, he's literally

1:36:21saying things, calling his political enemies within the United States vermin, right? It's

1:36:26like this coded Nazi language, explicitly saying over and over in his new stump speech that

1:36:33our enemies outside the country aren't an issue. It's the enemies within the country are the issue.

1:36:39I think that if Gore had been in the White House when 9/11 happened, which I think is more likely

1:36:45than not to have happened probably on the same day, I think instead of getting behind him as

1:36:51a country like the Democrats did behind Bush at first, I think they would have gone thermonuclear

1:36:57and blamed it on Gore. And it's very hard to predict what would have happened after that.

1:37:03But one thing that wouldn't have happened after that is going to war with Iraq.

1:37:06Right? So it's so likely. The what ifs are like, "Oh, it's really hard to predict."

1:37:15Trevor Burrus Yeah. Like I said, every now and again, I wonder what's happening on that timeline.

1:37:22Is that dude okay? It seems like he'll be fine.

1:37:23John Green I met him once at an Apple event. And just,

1:37:27it was, I don't know, like a 10-second interaction. I mean, I had no idea who I was. I never know at an

1:37:33Apple event whether somebody will know me. And I thought, as I shook his hand, "Well, he is an

1:37:39Apple board member, and I'm pretty well known as an Apple media person." So there's a chance he'd

1:37:45be like, "Ah, John, I've always wanted to meet you." You know, which is what happened the first

1:37:50time I met Steve Jobs. You know, it was like, he knew who I was. And I was blown away. And I'm like,

1:37:54"Ah, well." Or Schiller, same thing for, I met Schiller before I met any other higher level

1:37:58executive. And he obviously read my website. And I was like, "Ah." So I thought there was a chance,

1:38:03he obviously didn't. The man's head is enormous. I mean, like, I take a seven and a half hat size.

1:38:12Al Gore must take like a size nine. I mean, it's like the size of a basketball. But you really,

1:38:19you don't hear much about Gore anymore. It's kind of...

1:38:21Steven: Well, he did the Inconvenient Truth, right? I mean, he had his moment. He's older.

1:38:25Yeah.

1:38:26Steven, off camera Well, but you say that, but I don't,

1:38:28I'm not, let's see how old he is. He might be younger than either, he's certainly younger than

1:38:33Biden, right?

1:38:34Steven He's 75.

1:38:35Steven He's 75.

1:38:36Steven So he's younger than both.

1:38:37He's younger than both. Yeah.

1:38:39Steven And that's, that's, again, it just gets to

1:38:43how weird it is that we've got these two really old candidates. Bill Clinton, I think, is younger

1:38:47than both of them.

1:38:48Steven I think, John, the only logical conclusion

1:38:50of the show is Al Gore gets drafted to rerun for the presidency.

1:38:53Steven Ah, man, I would get behind that.

1:38:55Steven Apple board member Al Gore is gonna,

1:38:58he's gonna save the country.

1:38:59Steven It would free up a spot on the board, that's

1:39:01for sure. Although I guess if he does, if he does it like Trump, he could just keep the seat on the

1:39:05board, right? I don't know. Let me take a break here and thank our third and final sponsor of the

1:39:09show. And it is our good friends at Squarespace. Squarespace, you guys know what Squarespace is.

1:39:14It's the all in one platform where you can build your brand on the web, the real web, the open web,

1:39:21where you own and control your own website. And you can do everything at Squarespace from

1:39:28registering your domain name to picking from any of hundreds of templates to choose from.

1:39:35You can use their new fluid engine, which is the name of the WYSIWYG editor. You just do it all

1:39:41in the browser itself. And you drag and drop the pieces, the logos, the components, the features.

1:39:47If you want to add a podcast to your website, Squarespace has that built in. You do it all in

1:39:53the fluid engine. And it is their new layout system. It works great even on phones. You can

1:39:59just do drag and drop layout of your own website right on your phone. Couldn't be easier. I always

1:40:06say it is the easiest way. And because it's free, there's a 30-day free trial to get started.

1:40:13So there's no cost to just try Squarespace first, whether it's you who needs a new website or

1:40:19somebody you know who comes to you because you're their nerdy friend or nerdy family member.

1:40:23Send them to Squarespace, give them this URL, and then they'll know I'll get credit for the

1:40:29signup. And just give it a try. You get 30 days, no watermarks while you're in the free demo period.

1:40:36It's full featured. And when the 30 days are up, just use the same code, talk show, and you save

1:40:4210% off your first order. It's that easy. So what do you do? Go to squarespace.com. You get a free

1:40:49trial. The URL that gives me the credit is squarespace.com/talkshow. Just remember that URL.

1:40:57Sign up 30 days in when you need to decide whether you're going to pay or not. Just remember that

1:41:02same code, talk show, and you save 10% off a full year if you want to buy for a year. Whatever you

1:41:10do when you first pay, you get 10% off just by using that coupon code, talk show. So my thanks

1:41:16to Squarespace for their continuing support of the show. You've had a bunch of other guests. You

1:41:22had Zuckerberg on recently. You had friend of the show, Matthew Panzareno.

1:41:27Steven: Zuck was with Alex Heath. I gotta give Alex credit for that one.

1:41:31Steven: Oh, that's right. That's right. But it was the same show, Decoder.

1:41:35Steven; It is our show. Yep.

1:41:36Steven; I thought the Panzareno interview was really interesting because it was sort of like

1:41:41peers, right? Like you as the editor-in-chief of The Verge, Panzareno is the decade-long

1:41:46editor at TechCrunch. I know both of you. I'm in between you. You're both regular guests on my show

1:41:53here. We're pals at events. It's sort of like the way that it's not a zero-sum game, right? Like

1:41:59TechCrunch and The Verge could both do good work and it's better for the web as opposed to a sort

1:42:06of old-timey, you know, the two editors of newspapers in the same town hate each other,

1:42:11right?

1:42:11Yeah. But they need each other. You need an ecosystem of friends and competitors.

1:42:17We've got to keep each other honest. The competition makes you sharp. All that stuff

1:42:20is really important to me. I keep joking that The Verge is the last website that exists. We

1:42:26care about it. We talk about it. We're trying to build it all the time. Everyone else in publishing

1:42:31is kind of like they're decided to be content suppliers to a big platform one way or the other

1:42:37for pennies. I just think that sucks. Matt and I, our careers are in a similar arc. That conversation

1:42:45is really fun because we've just faced so many of the same pressures and so many of the same ways.

1:42:52And in particular, I quit the corporate owners that he worked for for a long time at AOL.

1:42:56It was just like sometimes only a handful of people know what the hell you're talking about.

1:43:03Matt was one of those people for me.

1:43:05Yeah. Well, the other similarity too, though, is that both of you never stop producing or just

1:43:11writing your own stuff, right? Or you host a show now. You're not just the editor at The Verge.

1:43:17You're one of the leading writers and your drive to continue writing and doing your own podcast is

1:43:26unabated.

1:43:28Yeah. Not to be too cheesy, but there's a... This is the right show to be. This

1:43:34particular kind of cheesy on. There's a Steve Jobs clip where he talks about hiring managers

1:43:40and how they were all bozos because they didn't know how to do anything.

1:43:43It's a great clip. I watch it once a month. And he's like, literally, it's Steve Jobs using the

1:43:50word bozos, which is like all you want in life. And he's like, we tried to hire a bunch of

1:43:54professional managers and they were horrible. They didn't know how to do anything. And if you're a

1:43:59great person, why do you want to work for somebody you can't learn anything from? And I

1:44:04have just interned... And he's like the best managers are the individual contributors

1:44:08who know that nothing will be as good unless they go manage the people.

1:44:11That is as internalized in me as it can be. If I can't do it at the high level,

1:44:17I have no credibility. And maybe there's a lot of other editors who are great, who don't do it

1:44:23every day and they retain the credibility with their SaaS. There are lots of different ways to

1:44:27do everything. For me, I'm always afraid that if I let up for one day, everyone will know that I

1:44:34have no idea what I'm talking about. I need the proof. And I also think the verge is small. It's

1:44:39a big fish in a little pond, but you hold us up next to our competitors, like the times or the

1:44:45poster, the other things that we have to go up against. And we need to punch way above our weight.

1:44:51To me, part of it is if I don't do the work, then I am in no position to push the staff as hard

1:44:58as we need to push in order to compete the way that we should compete.

1:45:03When did the redesign of the verge happen? Were you on my show afterwards or did it happen

1:45:11between last year's and this? I think it was fresh last year.

1:45:16When Yeah, once we're about a year, we're about a year into it. Yeah,

1:45:20we launched it in late November and now we're about the same place. So yeah,

1:45:24it exemplifies, you know, literally practicing what you're preaching though.

1:45:30And I know people, of course, anytime you change the fonts for anything,

1:45:34you can complain about fonts. And that was like the first thing it was like this

1:45:37huge, significant redesign of a very popular website. And all anybody could bitch about

1:45:42were the fonts for certain of the page elements. And you guys tweaked them. And it's I think it's

1:45:47very, very readable. But the biggest thing, it's not the specifics of the design or the branding

1:45:54of it. It's just the basic philosophy that it's a website, right? That you go there.

1:46:01And so you're so right. It's just, every now and again, I have to say it out loud, right?

1:46:08But you make a website, you should go to it, right? And if I do something like post link on

1:46:15threads or mastodon with a link to the verge, or me personally, my weird thing where I run a website

1:46:21where I spend a lot of time linking to articles at other websites, I know when I link to the verge,

1:46:27that everybody can read it. And yeah, okay, you guys have a couple of paid newsletters now. But

1:46:32for like news coverage, you just go there. And you can read the article and there's no paywall.

1:46:39And when you scroll down, it doesn't cover the article up with a pitch to subscribe to a

1:46:45newsletter or podcast or something like that. It's that the average website from most publishers

1:46:53is so bad and getting worse, that to have a website that did a major redesign and went in

1:47:02the other direction to make it more bloggy, you know, and you guys have like these short

1:47:08form link posts now that you put on the homepage. And it's been I think, as a reader of the verge,

1:47:15a grand success. As you know, fun. Yeah, again, it's it was super duper. I thought the verge

1:47:22killed it during the whole open AI drama pre Thanksgiving. And because there was like,

1:47:29oh, three hours later, everything you knew about the saga is old.

1:47:33But you if all you guys learned was one nugget of new information, then you've got a format now

1:47:41where you could post an update with just that nugget of information. And you didn't have to

1:47:45write 700 word article about it. If it was 50 words worth of news on this ongoing saga,

1:47:54then there's a 50 word link on the front page. So I when I say most publishers have turned

1:47:59themselves into suppliers to other people's software. It's the same thing as cars. The

1:48:04reason most publisher websites are bad is because most media companies have just given up on making

1:48:10software. So they just buy other people's software. Right. And I'll just the stereotypical examples,

1:48:18you have a WordPress template that you let some design firm make five years ago,

1:48:24that they're gone. No one remembers anything about it. And that's where you're publishing into.

1:48:28And then you bought a bunch of ad tech from some other people. And then you've got a newsletter

1:48:32vendor. And they're like, you can increase suppliers, you can increase signups,

1:48:37if you do this pop up. And then you kind of just get to the screenshots that people share

1:48:42bad websites. And you're like, if you just take one step back, you're like, yep, that's a bad user

1:48:46experience. He takes one step back to why it's Oh, there's 45 different pieces of software designed

1:48:53to optimize 45 different business goals here. And no one is in charge of this. Right. And that is

1:48:59that is just to be clear. This is not like a hot take. And this is just reality. Most people know

1:49:04this. But because everyone's given up on making their own software, no one has any ability to fix

1:49:09it. There's no one to talk to. And nobody can really explain how the page is ultimately rendered.

1:49:15Really? It's like crazy. Right. And so I but so what I look at is when I say suppliers, right,

1:49:22they've done that they've got them on the web. And then the only meaningful source of traffic to most

1:49:28websites anymore at scale is Google. So everything is like this festival of SEO optimization,

1:49:35which is weird and bad for the web. And I'm going to say this, and some Google executive is going

1:49:40to jump out of a bush the next time I walk outside my house and say, that's not what the guidelines

1:49:44say, which is literally all they can say while pointing to their 10,000 pages of SEO guidelines.

1:49:49It's a very confusing and you're like, Oh, this is why everything got long and padded out. And

1:49:55you can't just post an update. Because people believe in their heart, that sending 50 words

1:50:01of new information onto a web page is bad for your Google ranking. And so we have to build this

1:50:07article page. And the SEO consultants will do all this and it's this sucks. It should not be easier

1:50:14to tweet than it is to post to the website that I run that pays me money. And so that's where all

1:50:19that came from. And we are just baby stepping our way. We have the live streams now, which like when

1:50:24we do Apple live logging, they're like basically in real time, we have a very special tool that we

1:50:29use called Norcon live center for that. And then we have this, you know, then there's articles. And

1:50:32then in the middle, we're doing these story streams, which are like slow life logs. Like

1:50:37they're just a middle speed of updates that happened throughout the day. We're doing all

1:50:40the trial coverage in there. Cause it's about right. No one wants to read a real time transcription

1:50:44of a trial. Well, no, it does not seem like that's what anybody wants. No. So we have a middle speed

1:50:50and it's because we control our product. Despite I mean, you know this cause you're an actual lawyer,

1:50:56but despite what TV and movie dramas would have you believe courtrooms are very boring places

1:51:02that person that proceed at very slow pace. And everybody who's ever served jury duty knows this.

1:51:10You say you don't even have to be a lawyer. All you have to do is actually get, Oh, actually me,

1:51:14I've never been picked for a jury because I have a wife who's a criminal defense attorney.

1:51:21And you just, all you have to do, usually all you have to do is say that. And then,

1:51:24and this has been my go-to. I thought that all you had to do was say you're, you're a lawyer.

1:51:29And then the last time I got picked, I was like cruising to the end and the case settled right

1:51:32before the impairment was. So we are, we're doing great. My wife is a criminal defense attorney is

1:51:37a good way to get out. And then if that doesn't do it, and the last time I got had jury duty,

1:51:42they asked me, would you be, or there's a questionnaire and I, and one of the questions is,

1:51:48are you less likely to believe the testimony of a police officer? And I checked yes. And then they

1:51:55called me out. They said, juror number 37. And I said, yes. And they said, you answered that you

1:51:59would be less likely to believe the testimony of a police officer. Why? And I said, well, I, I believe

1:52:06that police officers, once they've arrested somebody will say whatever it takes to convict

1:52:10that person. And then they say, juror number 37, you are dismissed. And I left. And I, I look

1:52:18forward to living a long, healthy life. And I, at some point when I'm retired, I look forward to

1:52:25hang out on the jury. I look forward to making up for lost time as, and serving my civic duty

1:52:32proudly as a member of juries. And then I might perhaps answer that question in a way that is

1:52:38actually, it would actually be less, but that's actually honest for me. I actually, you can hook

1:52:43me up to a polygraph and assuming you believe polygraphs actually produce actual results that

1:52:49are accurate, I actually do believe police officers say whatever it takes to convict whoever it is

1:52:54they arrested for a crime. I actually believe that. But it's a good way to, good way to get

1:53:00out of jury duty if it's a criminal case. What else do we have on the agenda for the show?

1:53:05**Matt Stauffer** Okay. I'll just, I'll add this. The thing that we're going to do with the redesign

1:53:10where we're going to, we're going to get there is we are somehow, some way going to federate

1:53:16the site with ActivityPub. It seems very obvious that that's what we should do with Quickposts.

1:53:20So we started with this, you should be able to post the website as quickly as any social

1:53:24platform. We added, we should be able to line up all those posts in order so we can do slow

1:53:29live logs. And we're going to get to those posts should natively go to other platforms so you can

1:53:35follow one of our writers while they are working for us, for ourselves. And somehow your likes and

1:53:42comments on other platforms should come back to us and add value back to us. I don't know how any

1:53:48of that's going to work. I just know that that is a newer and more interesting set of problems to

1:53:52solve in media than whatever the hell has been going on for the last five years.

1:53:57**Scott Benner** But it's so, I want to come back to that and it's a perfect segue into something

1:54:01else I want to talk about, which is where social media is going with Threads and Mastodon and Blue

1:54:06Sky and the husk of remains of Twitter. But before we move on, I just think that the core point of

1:54:14that though is still just what a tremendous, who would have thought it's a competitive advantage

1:54:20for sites like The Verge and mine that people can just go to them and read, right? It's a huge

1:54:28competitive advantage at this point. And because so much is locked away, like more stuff, a higher

1:54:36percentage of professional content that's published on the web today is inaccessible to most people

1:54:42than ever before. The web, the open web where you can just go to trust that anybody can go to the

1:54:47URL and without any kind of shenanigans about deleting your cookies or your site history or

1:54:52whatever, or opening a private window so that it doesn't read your cookies so you can reset the

1:54:57counter of the paywall or whatever. It that it's actually like it was supposed to be where if you

1:55:05tell the browser open this URL, it shows you the contents of the URL. It's become a competitive

1:55:09advantage at this point. It has I worry that advertising and scale on the web is in a

1:55:18competition no one wants to acknowledge. Well, I and I think at scale on TikTok, I desperately worry

1:55:23about it because at the moment, it's more or less my entire income. Yeah, and that stuff waxes and

1:55:29wanes. And I don't think the advertising products on the web like you run a very bespoke advertising

1:55:35product for a set of marketers that no one trusts you and that you can do that for us, which we need

1:55:41big brand advertisers, right? And that's not my side of the house at all. That's someone else's

1:55:46problem. I just see the stress on their faces. And so I think we got to invent some new products.

1:55:52Otherwise, we're going to lose all of this. All of the dollars are going to go to TikTok and Instagram,

1:55:56right? And you can feel how that way you can feel about that however you want. But those dollars

1:56:03are not been going back into making journalism. Right. And so when you're saying there's this

1:56:07explosion of paywalls, what you're really noticing is a bunch of journalists have,

1:56:13for the first time in a long time, asked to be paid what their work is worth, which is a thing

1:56:20that in no other industry is controversial, but is always controversial when you're like,

1:56:24you have to pay to read this article. Right. As though it's like an accessibility problem,

1:56:29right? Like, we're like, I literally the other day, I linked to something that was a paywall.

1:56:33And someone said, Can you put a warning on this? And I was like, No, you're fine. You're you're

1:56:38going to be fine. You saw paywall, you didn't get to read the thing. Fine, right? Some people are

1:56:43going to pay. And that for us, we have big free homepage that actually sends out a meaningful

1:56:49amount of traffic, our role in the ecosystem, I come back to the ecosystem, our role is to curate

1:56:54the stuff that we think is worth looking at some which includes stuff worth paying for. Could I get

1:56:59to a place where we send out enough traffic, that we can strike some business arrangements and let

1:57:05people read the stuff? I would love to get that we didn't we I don't I can't walk into a meeting at

1:57:10the New York Times, right? Like let my links through. May we work hard enough, like maybe

1:57:14we can get there. But I there's just something about paying for journalism that has gone so far

1:57:22out of the mainstream culture, that I think this response is actually healthy. Maybe the pendulum

1:57:29has swung too far. Right? entirely possible. But it can't be that all of journalism is the New York

1:57:37Times. And then tick talkers yelling at the New York Times. That's a dangerous place for us to

1:57:43land. Yeah. And so I'm excited for a bunch of these, the worker owned models that are popping

1:57:47up for a four media is the best new tech site in years. Yep, that's great. There. There shouldn't

1:57:52be an argument of whether defector they should give all their stuff away for free. You should

1:57:56obviously pay them if you want to read their stuff. And it's just weird that journalism,

1:58:01right? Because at the end of the day, it's about facts and the facts are not copyrightable. You

1:58:05just end up in this weird knot where no one thinks the response to Spotify existing is saying it's

1:58:13immoral to have a paywall on Spotify. We just don't think about anything else that way.

1:58:17Yeah. You mentioned publishing bird stuff through activity pub. And it's occurred to me that it's

1:58:23the right way because I've been looking at this and it's ever since the Twitter hegemony over

1:58:30short form text. Social media died when Musk bought the site a year ago and it and Mastodon

1:58:38at least for my audience and probably the verge audience to it became relevant. I know Mastodon

1:58:44has been around since I don't know 2017 or something like that. I know I signed up somehow

1:58:48for some reason due to some Twitter fiasco in 2018 for my account. But now threads is a thing. Blue

1:58:58Sky is I don't know. I wouldn't want to bet on Blue Sky lasting at this point. But it seems like

1:59:04there's a culture there. And my homemade I'm, you know, again, one person show, but I'm responsible

1:59:11for the auto Twitter posting bot that used to post to the daring fireball articles to Twitter.

1:59:16And I know I could fix it in an afternoon. And I haven't made like a protest decision. Like I'm out,

1:59:23I'm off Twitter. I'm not going to use it anymore. But it's like my sort of on the fenced ness

1:59:30about the state of Twitter keeps me from ever spending the afternoon to fix that bot.

1:59:37Oh, we're in the same place. Right? People ask us why we are still auto posting Twitter. I'm like,

1:59:41look, it's an RSS feed. Yeah, just doing its thing. And it breaks. We won't fix it.

1:59:46I, I think I'm going to fix it for me because part of me, I just bothers me that I, but

1:59:53but looking at it, and I've been mucking about with that script because I added mastodon. So

2:00:00there's there's a mastodon daring fireball at mastodon that social account that auto gets the

2:00:06same content that used to go to the Twitter during fireball account. And I'm thinking there is no

2:00:11threads API yet. But I had Gabe Rivera from tech meme on on the show the previous episode, and

2:00:17he's leading the charge for really, really hoping that threads ads posting API, yeah, for tech memes

2:00:23purposes. And if it did, I would immediately if the day that they open it up, I would spend the

2:00:28time to add to to get during fireball content on the threads. But it doesn't make sense to be

2:00:36to have, oh, here's this path that goes to post to Twitter. And then here's this path that goes

2:00:43to post to mastodon. And here's a path to go to the post to threads. And I'm getting enough requests

2:00:48for blue sky. Here's a fourth pad now now that the every time there's a new article, there's these

2:00:54four paths for 40. What you're describing, like abstractly, I'm sure you think this is bananas.

2:00:59And I'm sure your listeners think this has been as the entire publishing industry did this for

2:01:05the weird proprietary formats like Google AMP and Facebook and star articles, right and snapshot

2:01:10discovery did this already. And they did it more manually with video, right all over the place.

2:01:18They're like, we're gonna make a video and then we're gonna do a square and we're gonna cut it

2:01:20rectangle, then we're gonna manually upload it to all these fucking platform, the media industry is

2:01:25and I am a member of it. And I like my job a lot. The media industry is stupid, just fully stupid.

2:01:33And it will always choose what I describe as unscalable media shit over smart tech shit,

2:01:39right. And you can see the tech industry is like really good at sustainable high margin businesses.

2:01:44And the media industry is not and all activity pub represents for me is an opportunity to just

2:01:52rest some control back over how we distribute our content. Like it's if you want to follow me,

2:02:00you should follow me on my server that I that pays me money to work at right. And that's fine.

2:02:06And maybe it'll show up in threads. And if you want to hit like there, maybe it'll show up on

2:02:10my platform. And I should be able to follow john Gruber on my platform. It seems very obvious how

2:02:15this should work. Right. And I think everyone wants threads to be this like one for one drop

2:02:20in replacement for Twitter. And maybe it will be and maybe it won't be like who knows it's going

2:02:25to take time. But what it also represents is a huge tech company, loudly saying they're going

2:02:32to support Federation and activity pub over and over again. They're not they keep talking about

2:02:36it. They're gonna do it. They have to do it to open up in Europe, it seems. Yeah, you just have

2:02:41this moment where there's a nascent technology standard. There's a groundswell of support.

2:02:45There's identifiable consumer benefits from it in business benefits in a way that crypto did not

2:02:53have any of those things. We'll just put those things next to each other. Like, of course,

2:02:58we should try to build some stuff. This is the time to build some stuff. A lot of it will crash

2:03:01and burn, right? But at least it will be like interesting and new, rather than All right, I

2:03:09we're gonna watch 500 Mr. Beast videos reverse engineer them into optimizing the YouTube

2:03:14algorithm. And then that is the future of that stupid. We got to all stop doing that. Yeah,

2:03:18you don't do that. But I know but my commercial media world does that right. instinctively and

2:03:24I would rather spend I spent time with our product team today at the verge, just talking about,

2:03:31okay, here are the 9000 problems we're gonna have to solve if we federate the site.

2:03:35And that's so much more interesting, right? Because it's a product conversation. So

2:03:40it's a conversation about what is the user experience of journalism going to be in the

2:03:44future? I mean, that's the sweet spot for the during firewall audience. But like, that's it,

2:03:49like, that's what we got to do. It's competition is generally good, and almost some having some

2:03:56competition almost always makes any market better. And it's unfortunate, though, that most things

2:04:03tend to dwindle to very few competitors, right? In the long ago history of TV, there were three

2:04:10major networks in the United States, ABC, NBC, CBS, and it's sure as shit was better than if

2:04:15there was only one. But it wasn't enough, right? But it was better. Twitter being the only relevant

2:04:23short form text first social network was a bad idea. It's just always it before Elon Musk,

2:04:32right? It's better that we have choices now like Mastodon, which is truly open, and you can

2:04:38federate with truly micro sized. I mean, I know people who run their own personal server,

2:04:45and they're the only user at their domain. That seems like too much work to me. But, you know,

2:04:51some people find that fun, especially in my audience. But it's, I think overall,

2:04:57things are better. And this drives some of my friends nuts that I overall, I think the effect

2:05:04of Elon Musk buying Twitter has been good for this form of social media. I think it has been terrible

2:05:11for Twitter itself. Yeah. And potentially democracy. And well, I don't hit maybe because

2:05:18Twitter continues to be the number one instance of this sort of thing. But if it weren't for the fact

2:05:26that Musk bought and steered Twitter into a demented direction, there's no way threads

2:05:34would exist. I'm first in line as a critic of meta as a company overall and continue to be in other

2:05:41ways. But the world is a better place with threads than it was before threads existed. I mean, I

2:05:49really firmly believe it. It's a really good product. And it's opened it up. And Mastodon,

2:05:54which did exist for five or six years beforehand, exploded in popularity by Mastodon's previous,

2:06:03I mean, Mastodon usage remains tiny compared to threads or Twitter, but it's a thousand fold

2:06:09increase over where Mastodon was before Elon Musk bought Twitter. And the world is a better place

2:06:14with Mastodon much more popular than it was before. And it's Mastodon's popularity that

2:06:21makes this whole discussion about activity pub even relevant, right? It wouldn't...

2:06:26I just wish there was one more year before the election. That's all I'm saying. Like,

2:06:29yeah, I wish this would global along a little with a little more distance.

2:06:32I do too, right? It would be worse, I guess, if this had happened a year later, if now is when

2:06:38Elon had bought Twitter, but it would have been better if he'd bought it a year earlier. Yeah,

2:06:42it would have been better to happen just after Joe Biden was inaugurated, right?

2:06:47Yeah. We're doing a big package on just the thing that was Twitter. It's dead now, right?

2:06:55It is. They changed the name. I feel very comfortable saying Twitter is dead now. Whatever

2:06:58it is, is called X. My contribution to it, which I'd have to finish writing this evening,

2:07:03is just talking about how for a decade, the default answer for every question in the media

2:07:09was a tweet. Literally any problem. Their site went down, tweet about it. The reporters will

2:07:14tweet the news instead of posting to the website. A candidate makes a gaffe on the campaign trail,

2:07:19we'll tweet an apology. It breaks on a tweet, right?

2:07:21Everything. It was just the default answer. Like, how do we communicate? And it was like a

2:07:26weird answer. It was a weird answer for a weird audience. And Twitter is always the smallest,

2:07:31but it had the most elite audience. It was just a weird platform. And I am also the same way as you.

2:07:36I think it's net good that everyone is reconsidering whether something like that

2:07:41should be important. What I would put next to it is, I think the flood of AI content that is

2:07:47coming for the web is sending Google into a tailspin. The web, first of all, because

2:07:54the incentives of SEO are so crazy, the web itself, there's just not a lot of innovation

2:08:01and content on the web. There's a lot of application level innovation on the web.

2:08:06There's a lot of cool toys on the web, but the make content and publish it on the internet has

2:08:12all moved somewhere else. It's all moved to some platform or the other. Mostly in video.

2:08:16If you were starting today, you were starting Darren Fireball, or I was starting The Verge,

2:08:21today as young people, not as Chris. But as young, if we were starting, we would almost certainly

2:08:27start on TikTok. We would almost certainly start on YouTube. That's wild. I'm a writer at heart.

2:08:33I like doing those other things. I love podcasting, but I am a writer at heart.

2:08:37There's not a set of incentives that would make me start a blog today. That's bad. That is a

2:08:44doom loop for the web. It is a doom loop for Google. Especially as the web gets polluted

2:08:49with more and more AI content and Google starts generating more and more AI answers.

2:08:53I'm just looking at this and saying, "Oh, this is a reset moment for the internet."

2:08:58The thing at the center of every media answer is gone. The biggest referral traffic on the web is

2:09:04something is going to happen to it. We should build some new shit to our specifications

2:09:10and come up with some new habits. Maybe it'll be Activity Club. Maybe it'll be Threats. I don't

2:09:15know. But chasing the old goals, I think, is doomed. I think we're going to watch a lot of

2:09:22media companies literally kill themselves because they fail to see that this is not just challenge,

2:09:28but also opportunity. Just yesterday, Sports Illustrated got caught publishing AI-generated

2:09:36content. I was going to bring that up. It's hilarious. But if you dig in the story,

2:09:41they didn't even do it themselves. No. This is what I mean about other people's software.

2:09:45They contracted an affiliate marketing company that uses ML to generate spam affiliate bullshit.

2:09:52Against Sports Illustrated's Google rank, Google Site Authority, and then hopefully,

2:09:59we'll collect some pennies along the way when you buy a hat.

2:10:02[Music ends]

2:10:02This was uncovered by Maggie Harrison at Futurism. But she wrote, "This is my favorite paragraph I

2:10:08block quoted of these AI." Well, the part that's scandalous about it, too, is that they were

2:10:17passing these as off as real people. And they used AI-generated headshots. So, they made up names

2:10:23and bought AI-generated headshots of these fictional people who don't even exist. But

2:10:29the one of them, this guy—it wasn't a guy, but this fictional construct, Drew Ortiz,

2:10:35said, "The AI author's writing often sounds like it was written by an alien." One Ortiz article,

2:10:41for instance, warns that volleyball, quote, "can be a little tricky to get into, especially without

2:10:48an actual ball to practice with." It doesn't make any sense. What do you mean, "volleyball's

2:10:54tricky to get into without a ball"? Right? It's a nonsense sentence. It's like you wouldn't even—a

2:11:01human being wouldn't—it's not poorly written. It's just nonsense. And there is—

2:11:06I'll give you another one. So, that's really bad, right? That's as bad as it gets. A major American

2:11:12cultural institution, Sports Illustrated, contracted an outside SEO chum vendor, which then

2:11:19did something that looks like AI fraud. And Sports Illustrated published this without a second

2:11:25thought. And look, the business goals here are not opaque. They wanted some traffic because they

2:11:31thought they might sell some volleyballs and make some pennies. This is not a complicated thing.

2:11:37Okay, you can go and look for coupon codes. I just bought a Solo Stove, so I was Googling for

2:11:45Solo Stove coupon codes. I'm not going to call them out. It's a lot of our competitors have entire

2:11:51coupon websites embedded in their websites to search for coupon codes, because they get

2:11:56fractions of a penny. CNET, which is a storied brand, right? Literally—I mean, we have reported

2:12:04on this several times—has an entire underlying automated mortgage rate content division,

2:12:10where it just publishes today's mortgage rates. Why is CNET publishing mortgage rates today?

2:12:16What are you? What have you become? Have you lost your soul?

2:12:21It started, I don't know, 10 years ago with the rash of what time is the Super Bowl articles,

2:12:27right? It was like all these sites that had nothing to do with sports or with television

2:12:32would have an article somebody wrote about telling you what channel and which Sunday and what time

2:12:39the Super Bowl starts. And it's all just SEO nonsense. But you're right. I think Google is

2:12:46at a crisis point. And with their core product search, they've always had—to me, it's obvious

2:12:54that you don't need inside information. Google has done better as the web got bigger, because

2:13:01they can deal with the scale of it better than any of their competitors could, right? It was a

2:13:07natural moat that as the web got bigger and more content got posted to the web, and it's

2:13:16you know, and as more audio gets posted to the web with podcasts and with videos, all of that stuff

2:13:21is harder to index or spider. And the bigger it got, the better it was for Google. A bigger web

2:13:27is good for Google. But now the web can literally grow to infinite size. Like we have that—AI

2:13:36is the infinite monkeys and infinite typewriters.

2:13:39But it's not infinite information. This is the doom loop.

2:13:41Right. Right.

2:13:43It's not infinite new information. The LLM chatbot AIs that we have today

2:13:48are not generating new ideas. Like almost definitionally not generating new ideas.

2:13:54You can prompt them into smashing two other ideas together.

2:13:58Right.

2:13:59But you can't reliably get new information out of them in any way, really. So the web

2:14:06might grow to infinite size, but it will just be a reflection of the past.

2:14:11Right.

2:14:11And so Google's first big problem is just identifying what is old and what is new,

2:14:16and I don't think that they can. Like as far as I can tell, OpenAI had one tool for a minute

2:14:23that was supposed to detect AI-generated text, and they pulled it because it was so inaccurate.

2:14:28That's where—and I don't think—I think the arms race between chatbot technology

2:14:35and chatbot detection technology is already lost.

2:14:38Yeah.

2:14:39Wasn't it CNET where a couple months ago there was a thing where they were deleting

2:14:44old articles, like just turning them into 404s, and not because they were expensive to host,

2:14:51but that they somehow were under the impression that it was good SEO strategy

2:14:55to cull little visited articles from their archive, which is insane from—I'm not a librarian, but—

2:15:05You've got to be careful, man. A Google search executive is going to jump

2:15:08into your house. You're going to leap through a window and tell you that's not what the guidelines

2:15:12say. The gap between the received wisdom about SEO and what Google thinks people should do

2:15:20is vast. It is growing. It makes people furiously angry when you point it out,

2:15:27angrier than anyone has ever been at us for some of our coverage. We just did the big article about

2:15:33the culture of SEO professionals, and just the fury directed at us. And you really unpack it.

2:15:40I was very sympathetic to it. It was a bunch of people staring at the asteroid, freaking out.

2:15:48Don't make fun of us. We know we're doomed. It's basically the gestalt of that fury.

2:15:51Yeah. That was a great, great piece, by the way. I'm blanking on the writer, but—

2:15:57Amanda Chicago Lewis. She's wonderful.

2:15:59It was just wonderful in terms of getting to know the personalities of the industry and sort of

2:16:04how we got here. But I really am with you. I just don't see how—I don't think Google is set up to

2:16:10do what we would want our leading search engine to do, which is to separate actual quality content.

2:16:21And again, it doesn't have to be. I'm not religious about it. I mean, if AI can generate

2:16:26actual good content, okay. It's like the bartender in the cantina in Star Wars. We don't serve their

2:16:32kind here. I always thought that was such a throwaway line in the movie, but I always

2:16:35thought it spoke to some sort of myth building that there's a resentment in the working class

2:16:43in that universe towards droids, right? Which, you know, we're seeing now with AI, right? There's

2:16:49resentment towards AI taking people's jobs. And I get it, you know? I mean, I don't know if it's

2:16:54going to take my job. It could. I don't know. But at some level, beyond the concerns about people

2:17:04having their livelihoods disrupted, what we really just want as users is I type a query in a search

2:17:13engine and I get high-quality results that are true, right? That are actually giving me what I

2:17:19wanted and I can trust these results are actually accurate and truthful. I don't think Google is set

2:17:26up to deal with it. I almost feel like the way that these AI language models work is specifically

2:17:34meant to, not purposefully just for SEO optimization, but the nature of it is exactly

2:17:40the sort of thing that Google's spidering doesn't detect or notice. It just sails right through. And

2:17:47there's just going to be, however big the web is, there's literally, it's effectively infinite how

2:17:52much AI can write. They're never going to tire. They write a thousand times faster than a human

2:17:59does. So I just bought a new refrigerator. So I just did a search just to test what's better,

2:18:04LG or GE refrigerators. And I'm sure people listening to this have furious opinions about

2:18:09this. This is where I learned people have very strong opinions about not this question,

2:18:13but just appliance brands in general. So here's what Google said. LG refrigerators are generally

2:18:18considered to be more energy efficient and have better smart features. GE refrigerators are

2:18:21generally considered to be more liable, have a better selection and more affordable. And then

2:18:25you click the little dropdown. All of its sources are from upsee.com, which is just an SEO spam

2:18:34website. You can see how in the next turn upsee.com, which appears to sell warranties,

2:18:42like it's an extended warranty company. They did this as content marketing because people Google

2:18:47this and then you might buy a warranty from upsee. You can see how they're going to, the person who

2:18:52wrote this, their job is gone. Right. Chat GPT will write the next version of this article and

2:18:57Google won't know. Right. So then Chat GPT is going to write an article based on what it has

2:19:02already scraped from the web, feed it back into Google, whose AI is going to re summarize that

2:19:06and turn that into a Google result. And it's like, Oh, this is a disaster.

2:19:10The other thing is that it's almost like there's some sort of irony in that Google is famous for

2:19:17conducting AB tests, like the infamous one where they tested 29 shades of blue for a thing, and

2:19:22then just pick the shade of blue that, that seemingly led to the most clicks or something

2:19:27like that. But AI can run these, forget about AB tests. They can run like A to Z 1000 tests and just

2:19:37publish a thousand articles about refrigerators and let Google figure out which one it wants to

2:19:42send people to in a way that human labor would never be able to scale to that level cost

2:19:48effectively. Right. If you're only going to make pennies for the thing, you can't afford to pay

2:19:54even low paid human workers to generate as much content as AI can churn out.

2:20:00Trenton Larkin Yeah, again, I I'm with you. I think there are uses for AI, I will tell you that

2:20:07of all the people at the verge, I'm the only person who is confidently published AI generated

2:20:11SEO spam onto the website. In the best printer article, I just wanted to see what would happen.

2:20:16Trenton Larkin Yeah, that's what happens. Wait, for people who don't know what was the

2:20:22gist of the gimmick?

2:20:23Trenton Larkin It was best printer 2023, just buy this brother printer,

2:20:27laser printer. And it was like, literally the genesis of this article was I was on a zoom call,

2:20:31and everyone was at home and everyone had the same printer. And I was like, what are we doing?

2:20:34Let's just see what happens. And is a joke as like, you know, needs to hit the SEO page limit,

2:20:41or the SEO word count, which, again, a Google executive is about to leap out of a bush and tell

2:20:45me that it's not like I don't say but whatever. So I just like to hear some chat GBT garbage to put

2:20:50on the page. By the way, this page ranked it was like number one for best printer for a while.

2:20:55We sold a number of printers, I'm told by the affiliate commerce team, whatever. The point is,

2:21:00I did it as a joke. And it was like very transparent that I did it and no one got mad

2:21:05at me. I certainly did not get a viral outrage cycle, which would have driven even more printer

2:21:09sales. Right. But it's if you're just honest, we just don't lie to people, we had to come up with

2:21:14editorial guidelines or an AI usage for our various editorial teams of the company. And

2:21:19they asked me for my advice. I was like, the only guideline is don't lie. Right? If you're

2:21:25just honest with people about the tools you're using, they will very often go along for the ride

2:21:29with you. Right. Right. If you lie to them, and you tell them that volleyball is hard without a

2:21:34ball, and because you're a robot thing, so of course people are going to be outraged,

2:21:39or that this person exists. Yeah. A baseline lie. Yeah. Right. And I look, I don't I don't know if

2:21:46it has been good or bad. I think personally, it, it generates c plus content at best to my eyes.

2:21:53Some people feel very differently about that. It's going to get better, whatever.

2:21:57It can't have new ideas. This is our competitive advantage. We're just, I'm just going to keep

2:22:01having new ideas until I stop. And then I'll, I promise to disappear. But for the web at large,

2:22:07the number of people that want to spam the web with content in order to get some clicks from

2:22:11Google search in order to convert into some clicks onto affiliate links, that number is infinite.

2:22:18Right. They are going to keep running that game forever. And Google has to figure it out.

2:22:21Right. Or they have to pivot search in some huge and meaningful way to only trusted sources,

2:22:28which I don't think they can do. Yeah. And it's turning, it's turning the web against itself,

2:22:33where there's no cost of goods or effectively none, right? Serving another page view. So in

2:22:39the paper era, paper is prohibitively expensive. It really, even newsprint, the pulpiest, cheapest

2:22:47paper that you can possibly print things on, which is why newspapers were printed on it.

2:22:52It's extremely expensive. Like the printing operations of a major newspaper or even a local

2:22:57newspaper, which are largely closing, it's incredibly expensive. All that junk that get

2:23:03put through my mailbox every day, all of these paper catalogs is incredibly expensive for those

2:23:08companies to produce. And it's thankfully that it is because otherwise if it was like the web,

2:23:15it would be like a infinite pile, like a fire hose of junk mail coming in.

2:23:19Yeah. TV, there's only so many channels on cable. And prior to cable, there were only 13

2:23:27wavelengths for over the air transmission that could be picked up. It was limited. And the fact

2:23:33that there is no limit like that on the web means that it can really be an infinite fire hose. It's

2:23:38an enormous problem. You know, where there's also no limit is YouTube, where I just searched LG

2:23:44versus GE refrigerator. And I will tell you this thumbnail is incredible. The title is what's the

2:23:50best fridge to brought to buy the truth will surprise you. The word surprises in all caps.

2:23:54This video is 24 minutes long and has 3 million views. And it's like, is that better than a web

2:24:02page? I don't even get the same person provides the same information. I hate how much of how to

2:24:09blank how to fix blank is now a YouTube video. And it's convenient when it really does have a

2:24:14visual component of you want to look for a thing under your sink that looks like this. And that's

2:24:20the thing that you need to twist or whatever. But it's that it may it makes me so mad when

2:24:26how to video of three steps is a seven minute YouTube video. Yeah, it's in fear. Now a YouTube

2:24:32executive is going to leap out of the way to tell me that that's not what the guidelines say.

2:24:35Right. And they don't only give you an ad break if your video is eight minutes long.

2:24:38I know right where I didn't know the limit. But I you can backwards engineer what it is by looking

2:24:46at the length of all those how to videos and you often get a second ad break if you hit 10 or more

2:24:50minutes, which explains a lot of things. By the way, I really encourage everyone to just Google

2:24:54LG versus GE refrigerator and look just look at the thumbnails. It is. Do it on YouTube. Yeah,

2:25:01it's it's it's real good. It's, it's a it's I would call it a design playground.

2:25:08Just trying to convey the information that you should watch this video.

2:25:10All right, well, I will leave it at that. Thank you,

2:25:15Nilay for coming back on the show. And thank you for your time and your continuing good work.

2:25:19See you next year. I'm sure at some event or another and I look forward to having you back

2:25:23on the show. I will thank our three sponsors of the day. We had Squarespace where you could build

2:25:28your own website, Trade Coffee where you can subscribe to freshly roasted coffee beans delivered

2:25:35to your house and nuts.com where you can get all sorts of delicious snacks, not just nuts, but

2:25:42really good nuts if you want nuts delivered fresh to your house and I love having them as a sponsor

2:25:47because I get to say nuts over and over and over again each time they sponsor the show.