0:00:00I'm glad hand is perfect doesn't even take premium fuel yes it was about to
0:00:10bring the iPhones into the crescent moon problem and the various experiences
0:00:14people had and what the Apple Jesus asked them to do their phone and what
0:00:18happened to the phone when it was taken into the back room and all sorts of
0:00:21stuff like that so one theme was some people are super angry that we don't
0:00:27know the stuff I hear you talk about genius stuff that you don't know about
0:00:32it like yeah we we don't know and then people you know plenty of people tell us
0:00:36like without that kind of the show works like we've had wonder what does happen
0:00:39in the back room and then a bunch of algae is anonymous the email us back to
0:00:44those one team and by the way I can relate to that like when you when you
0:00:47hear people talking about stuff on the podcast and you know the answer but no
0:00:52one on the show knows the answer you know because you're an apple juice and a
0:00:55former Apple Genius and you have to be able to get this wonderful like we all
0:00:59of us offered at various ideas of what it could be a whatever so I can be
0:01:04frustrating that's also part of the fun of getting the second team that I saw
0:01:08emerged from the very large volume of feedback we got from Apple Genius is
0:01:11accessible geniuses are people who are Apple Genius adjacent like a caged about
0:01:17what they're you know jobs are known to be anonymous for the most part was that
0:01:22things are actually slightly different from Apple Store Doublestar regard you
0:01:27know email from geniuses in different countries in different states in the
0:01:31United States and they all describe what their store does and there is a
0:01:36commonality like we'll get to that we get the answers there is an answer to
0:01:38all of our questions last time but some stories we like our store tends to do
0:01:42this
0:01:43except there occasionally we do that our star always does this and doesn't like
0:01:46subtle differences in policy that I assume there are like may be at the
0:01:50discretion of the
0:01:51the store manager or just kind of like what they tend to do other people
0:01:55delving into details of how the geniuses are rated by their managers based on
0:02:01certain metrics that have to do with how they choose to discretionary things
0:02:04anyway I was surprised at the variety and how much things can vary from store
0:02:08to store and these are not things that the people writing in presented as
0:02:12things that might vary the only way we discovered that they've areas by the
0:02:15sheer volume of feedback and you know like these five people said they always
0:02:18do this and these four people so they always do something slightly different
0:02:21and all those people are not presenting as a thing that they think berries I
0:02:24think like Apple stores do this but they actually do very surprising about that
0:02:29kind of matches up with you know the experience even just you two had in
0:02:33terms of every night at the end of the day in the stores gonna close maybe
0:02:37they'll give me a replacement phone instead of trying to repair or just have
0:02:40me come out the next day or you know or if you you know if you have a high with
0:02:44nine or be done at the machine can replace his alleged that like lots of
0:02:48lots of variations from
0:02:51we're not really interesting images and variations find it interesting that
0:02:56there is apparently so much discretion from one side or the other but the
0:03:00common stuff is what we're doing and try to get to the feedback so you can try
0:03:04summarizing the answers to all of our questions you might let me take a stab
0:03:08at this very quickly so the general theme seems to be that the reason that a
0:03:13genius we'll ask you to turn off Find My iPhone there's a couple of reasons
0:03:16actual number one it's to prove that that is your regular phone and you
0:03:21haven't stolen the phone and you know claimed that something is broken or
0:03:26perhaps something is broken and you're trying to get a perfectly functional
0:03:30phone out of the deal so the most obvious answer was we want you to prove
0:03:35that it's indeed yours subsequent to that if they comes that they need to
0:03:39replace the phone according to the geniuses if i understood him correctly
0:03:44they
0:03:46the activation lock is tied in some way shape or form to Find My iPhone and so
0:03:51if they screw something up or something is just fundamentally broken and they
0:03:56need to give you a new phone they're going to want to recycle or
0:04:00remanufactured the word I heard use the lottery manufacture
0:04:04the the phone that you've just given up and they can't do that unless my phone
0:04:09is off because they have no back door to this I think that that summer is
0:04:13accurate
0:04:14most common reason we are inside it was provided ship for a reason because
0:04:18apparently people bring in stolen phones in going through this whole thing like
0:04:21intentionally breaking part of like opening it up and and disconnecting the
0:04:24home button and bringing in single the home button doesn't work like with
0:04:27stolen phones is apparently very common thing so that is the the primary reason
0:04:33is you're proving you're on the phone and then the other reasons I'm still a
0:04:35little bit fuzzy on but we got a lot of what you summarizes the common answer
0:04:39think right so that's the fun my from portion now the passcode was interesting
0:04:46I didn't realize the the the order of operations that happens once my phone
0:04:52disappeared to get crescent moon unlocked repaired so apparently what
0:04:57happens is they go to the back room and they use this little thing that has
0:05:04suction cups on it to heal apart the phone once they removed the couple of
0:05:08screws that are on the bottom of it then they replace the screen with the screen
0:05:13is the touch I D sensor and a bunch of other things I don't remember the list
0:05:16off the top of my head but the key is then they put it into this big black
0:05:20calibration machine and they are not allowed or told anyway not to give you
0:05:25your phone back unless you pass calibration and apparently the way you
0:05:29pass calibration is among other things they put in app on your phone
0:05:32temporarily that interacts with calibration machine in order to
0:05:36calibrate the screen and make sure the screen is working now this is important
0:05:39because they can't put this app on your phone or do any of those other things
0:05:42without you having either given them your passcode or just taken off the
0:05:46passcode so they run this thing through they run your phone service coverage
0:05:50machine just make sure everything's functional and if it passes calibration
0:05:53you get your phone back that has a new screen you touch idea etcetera if it
0:05:56doesn't pass calibration then they'll just hand you a new phone and say be on
0:06:01your way
0:06:01one person said that we also provide customers to decline giving us the best
0:06:06go with the expectation that will perform this functionality check with
0:06:09the customer
0:06:10some of the geniuses who said they said that they contrasted the machine more
0:06:13than like check
0:06:14functionality with the people I would trust the machine like to especially
0:06:18first screen calibration type stuff on that is not clear to me whether that can
0:06:21work with the passcode to offer not I think there's any way you would think
0:06:25that we've been on this now but there are subtle differences between all the
0:06:29feedback that we got and you can tell the subtle differences are significant
0:06:32differences in phrasing or whatever but bottom line and the passcode is they
0:06:38want to make sure that if they change something that phone that all the stuff
0:06:42that supposed to work still works and the other than just wanted to clarify
0:06:45little bit is when I said an appt with the calibration machine I mean I may
0:06:49have the details little wrong about that I think we've heard talk of a custom ROM
0:06:54firmware we've heard talks a talk from the feedback that it was a nap the point
0:06:59just being that something happens on your phone that interacts with this
0:07:02machine in order to make sure everything works right there anything else on the
0:07:07repair things I don't have anything else I feel like all we've done is initiated
0:07:12another torrent of geniuses which is fine but this one we can say right now
0:07:17we're not going to talk about this anymore so please you don't have to even
0:07:20email us about it we're done with this topic please for the love of God well I
0:07:23mean I don't think there's anything more productive to get out of it because we
0:07:26wandered like why they why they want you to have my phone that I think we got a
0:07:29solid answer and that you know it to prove you own it and then the passcode
0:07:34stuff and the other things and when you get a new phone and when you get a
0:07:37replacement although the stuff I've got another meeting to understand what
0:07:40they're doing
0:07:42I don't think we implied it was anything sinister going i think im just wondering
0:07:45and I don't think there's anything sinister going on so I think we're all
0:07:49satisfied that front Marco still wants the ability to you know there is one
0:07:54person said they had basically the ability to test everything without
0:07:57anyone like you or your thing with basket but anyway that's a clarification
0:08:05that I think I probably won't be able to help you I totally withdraw my argument
0:08:10just because i dont wanna get an email about it I'm so done with this topic
0:08:13just one just wanted to say thank you to the geniuses did write it as much as
0:08:18we're joking I I for one and I think I speak for at least John
0:08:24appreciated hearing all of this and i knows a lot of you and I'm not trying to
0:08:30be funny I know a lot of you probably felt like that was a risky thing to
0:08:32write into it to us and share any sort of information so I speak for all of us
0:08:37even those who are those of us who are grumbling in saying thank you for what
0:08:41you've already written but I agree I think we've got the just now so thank
0:08:45you
0:08:46alright mocha what would you like to talk about anything else so quickly
0:08:51very fast for this is how you to follow guys very fast follow-up last episode we
0:08:57talked about the lifeboat mode in the 60 S III said that it was most likely
0:09:02dumping the entire sensor at 12 megapixels in a very fast bursts make
0:09:07those videos you can see in John Gruber's review you should read it that
0:09:12the resolution is substantially lower than that is not dumping at 12
0:09:15megapixels for the video it's basically taking a lower resolution video at like
0:09:191440 buy something and it's it's one of those things like it looks fine on the
0:09:24phone I wouldn't even say it looks good on the phone looks fine the phone on any
0:09:28more inspections and that any larger viewing or any clothes you and it does
0:09:34not look very good but it looks good enough on the phone doesn't look good it
0:09:39is very weird creature i I think it's cool I think it's it's an interesting
0:09:44idea but the quality is is you know not amazing and you know it's it's not going
0:09:52to be for preserving things in in high-def it's gonna be for like a haha
0:09:57funny look at this moment surrounding surrounding kind of things if you want
0:10:01to actually have video of something just shoot video it'll looks way better when
0:10:06it's in video mode one way or another I am really really excited and amped see
0:10:11this because I really think this could be extremely cool a lot of times when
0:10:17I'm taking pictures with either by phone or my big camera I really wish I had
0:10:23either context or even just a crappy still from a half second before I
0:10:29actually hit the shutter
0:10:31and I'm really really excited to see this I think it should be really cool
0:10:35now I may end up that I get my iPhone success which by the way is in
0:10:38Louisville not that I've been looking I will get my iPhone success try and think
0:10:45it's crap but I know I'm really excited for it and I am in it just occurred to
0:10:48me I'm not saying that just because I want to sound enthusiastic about
0:10:52something i genuinely am enthusiastic and excited about this
0:10:56yeah I'm most excited reading on this your views on everything I'm most
0:10:59excited about 3d touch honestly and also the the performance increase was WAY
0:11:04bigger than I expected
0:11:05get my goodness I think they talked about it when you see it in the keynoter
0:11:09special event every year they say now it's even know it's
0:11:13percent faster eighty percent of the usually eat a lot of times they they
0:11:17carry pick that metric to be like the maximum than in reality it's me only 30%
0:11:21faster rates are still great for one year of some advancement compared to the
0:11:26world of PCs and Macs but this is this is one of those years are you know some
0:11:30years it makes a bigger jump than others and this is one of those years where
0:11:34it's a it's a bit know where the big jump her sponsor this week is
0:11:39Squarespace squares base is the online platform that makes it fast and easy to
0:11:43create your own professional website portfolio online store free free trial
0:11:48and 10% off visits where space.com enter offer code ATP at checkout
0:11:53where space is simple and powerful with easy to use intuitive drag-and-drop
0:11:57tools you have beautiful designs to choose from you can customize them
0:12:01however you want and your site looks professionally designed regardless of
0:12:05your skill level with no coding required and if you want to jump in there and
0:12:09codes of custom you can inject arbitrary code so it covers the whole base from
0:12:14from you know super basic use if you don't want to go to the thing is gonna
0:12:17get something up there quick we wanted to use the GUI to configure it all you
0:12:20can do that or you can jump in there and inject your javascript css or whatever
0:12:24and really customize the crap out of this thing it is really really it spent
0:12:28the whole grains they're all these designs are fully responsive to your
0:12:32website scales to look great and to look like your website on any device of any
0:12:37size every website also includes commerce functionality if you want to
0:12:41use it
0:12:41you can build on a free online store for physical or digital goods and there's no
0:12:48additional charges that included with every Squarespace plan if you need any
0:12:51help if 24 7 support available via live chat or email all this is powered by
0:12:57state of the art technology to ensure your site security and stability you
0:13:02don't have to worry about a better install this update before I got hacked
0:13:05know they take care of all that for you if somebody big least your site won't go
0:13:09down it is backed by incredible technology that is trusted by millions
0:13:14of people and some of the most respected brands in the world all of this starts
0:13:18at only $8 a month and let me tell you I've used as base we use for our site
0:13:23here I use it for a couple of the side projects I've given it to people for
0:13:27other projects that I was involved in or to relatives and friends even my kids
0:13:31preschool uses Squarespace because they asked me to make a way to help them make
0:13:35a website and I said here this is basically done for you in an hour and I
0:13:39don't support it highly recommend using Squarespace for purposes like this or
0:13:43your own side project or anything else like that
0:13:46start your free trial site today with no credit card required at Squarespace dot
0:13:51com we decide to sign up for space make sure to use the offer code ATP to get
0:13:5510% off your first purchase Squarespace noted beautiful so big we mark oh yeah
0:14:03you know what we might as well go right to the main controversy of the week the
0:14:09colored activity rings I don't get why that's such a big freakin deal like I
0:14:14don't I don't like that its color but I seriously I'm like whatever but man the
0:14:20internets upset is it only color on a much lower face No
0:14:24is it simpler the other one that its color has its own utility where its
0:14:30color that's the one that's what everyone's mad babies utility values and
0:14:34I have activity ring on it
0:14:36utility is it was previously a very kind of extreme design it really you could
0:14:43have called it simple like it is a very simple design wrap it up with a bunch of
0:14:47stuff it is a very good design and many people are very upset about the activity
0:14:53rings now being these bright colors that match the colors in the inactivity app
0:14:58rather than the previous monochrome version it was a great experience so
0:15:04it's best to write very confused by his first I tried to do it work and I didn't
0:15:10work because it wants to be connected the charger and of course I don't watch
0:15:13hard work so fine when I get home and do it and I did like the phone part of it
0:15:17then or download the OS right I get home and I put my watch on charger and it led
0:15:22to the update and it goes along and then come back later
0:15:25looks like it's all done and I pick up my phone in the watch app and I'm not
0:15:30sure if it's done so I go back into like the updates thing or whatever and it's
0:15:33everything is up to date one point zero point one you got one point your part 1
0:15:38all good and Mike one point zero point one as it says there's no update them up
0:15:43to date in mind at one point zero plan one is is that talking about the version
0:15:48of the Apple app on the iPhone I was super confused anyway all I did was pick
0:15:53about watching turned it down to time travel go and basically say they go it's
0:15:57installed so I do have a choice to but I was confused about what is that if you
0:16:02did it too did you discover what the 1.0 part 1 is referring to what was the
0:16:06previous version just a bug in the washout books it wouldn't be the first
0:16:10one I i guess i dont like the colors on the activity rings on the wood which one
0:16:19did you say it was you don't utility I keep on just a simple I mean I looked at
0:16:22it too and I was like a utility and I thought you know this this really is now
0:16:28much less elegant looking face than it was before however I also do use the
0:16:35activity rings pretty heavily it's it's one of the most common reason they look
0:16:39at my watch face and so when I first saw it I thought what a terrible mistake
0:16:43there so garish and they are but then I went for a dog walk and on the dog walk
0:16:49usually
0:16:50I would open the watch or I would look at the washer wake up and usually I
0:16:54would tap the activity brings in the corner to launch the full activity app
0:16:58to check how I was doing in that out because of the Rings in the watch face
0:17:01either wouldn't have updated yet or or you know it would be kinda hard to see
0:17:05you when I was in motion in the space walk and rings and now with the colors
0:17:10it is easier to see how I'm doing what I'm doing a walk or something
0:17:15one of the Rings can get ahead of the others and sometimes you can't quite
0:17:19tell whether it's like the orange one of the green one you know and and so you
0:17:22got to look more closely to really know and now with these new colors it makes
0:17:27it very clear so when I find that was I don't have to launch the activity at the
0:17:31gym or I can just glanced at it with the colors and I can see how you doing with
0:17:35the with the green room so it actually works for me and I really don't like the
0:17:42way it looks but it does work better for me anything else going on this week for
0:17:47anyone
0:17:47Marco I don't think so I mean I'm working on some overcast upgrades and we
0:17:52really don't talk about this because I don't care either way but now we can
0:17:55talk about it we can talk about it now ok it will happen so peace your content
0:18:02locker that we talked about last episode it became extremely popular you had a
0:18:07change of heart you pulled it and the internet got really really upset about
0:18:12it I will start by saying I think it's kind of ridiculous how upset the
0:18:17internet got about it it bothered me quite a lot and I really have nothing to
0:18:22do with this really at all but I got bothered by it because I feel like the
0:18:28Internet
0:18:29wholly and entirely over-reacted over a decision that was not easy for you to
0:18:36make and quite literally cost you a ton of money
0:18:40cost them any money in the end right time obviously spent less time making
0:18:45this app and then you know it was all for nothing I get let me maybe cost is a
0:18:50poor choice of words what I need to say is on the icon and the SSL cert the
0:18:55domain name right so here's something I didn't know until this all went around
0:18:59that clarified for me ask questions about it with my previous understanding
0:19:04about how refunds worked was that if someone bought an application for a
0:19:10dollar and Apple issued a refund they would still want thirty cents from the
0:19:16person who made the appt in other words if every single person who bought your
0:19:19application asked for a refund you would start to pay Apple 30% of the total
0:19:23revenue for your application
0:19:26pally that change some point in the recent past market you know an exact
0:19:29date so people have said that over the years the thing is with with a mean it
0:19:34from a different on the Mac App Store where the prices are usually lot higher
0:19:37on iOS though the number of refunds that that happened to polly and I S is
0:19:43usually solo me most most days I get you know from over cast on GATT like you
0:19:48know whatever you know 2400 are tens of of byes and you have like 10 or 20
0:19:55refunds like it'll be a massive difference and so it's it's the kind of
0:20:00thing almost all iOS developers never have to think about
0:20:03therefore I never looked into it and therefore I don't know if that was ever
0:20:05true anyway the new system as Marco can confirm is happily refund Marco doesn't
0:20:14know Apple any money for that particular purchase all the money goes back to the
0:20:17person who paid for the application and that's that so in theory and we'll find
0:20:22out in practice if for example every single copy of an application that was
0:20:26purchased was refunded the developer get zero dollars and ever
0:20:30one who bought it gets the exact amount they paid back so it's a clean slate
0:20:34ignoring Marco paying for the development the application in SLC
0:20:37tonight continent let us know so that is the current situation I'm happy to hear
0:20:41that because I remember hearing back in the old days about refinancing oh that's
0:20:45you know that's pretty pretty harsh that Apple still demands that 30% of whether
0:20:50it was a intentional policy or a side effect of the system that they had never
0:20:54used a big deal because refunds are infrequent but in a strange situation
0:21:00like we had here where many applications were purchased and all refunded that
0:21:04could have ended up being even more costly but it's it's nice that that
0:21:08wasn't the case if it becomes the case believe me I will notice and I'll let
0:21:12you know I said the other thing most people don't understand about you can't
0:21:19really blame them
0:21:20developers know this nerds to know developers know this but regular
0:21:24customers why would they even have any need to know this
0:21:27developers can issue refunds can't they just cant like it you sound application
0:21:31on the App Store and someone asked if your refund you literally cannot give it
0:21:34to him there's nothing you can do this no button you can press say here's your
0:21:37money back
0:21:38only Apple can issue refunds that stupid and it has been the case
0:21:42forever and you know everytime stuff like this comes up we all reflect once
0:21:47again about how Apple owns the customer in the developer doesn't we don't know
0:21:51the customers names were not accustomed to the people who sell applications can
0:21:54respond to customers comments don't know who they are in some respects it's good
0:21:57it's like Apple's isolating you keeping your privacy but on the other hand
0:22:00developers cannot issue refunds so a lot of the people who are angry justifiably
0:22:06is like I bought an application for all three dollars and really mad about it
0:22:09anyway and it's obviously not supporting it was pulled and the developer won't
0:22:13give me a refund which is true but he can't give you literally cannot I'm sure
0:22:18Marcos first question for Marco if there was a big button that you could have
0:22:23pressed to refund everybody when you decide to pull the app would you have
0:22:26press that maybe I would have I would have definitely considered it i mean one
0:22:31of the weird things about the way this was done so I get into why Apple the app
0:22:36you know this topic I will actually give people what they're looking for
0:22:40but unfortunately already did and it's it's it's a really boring story the
0:22:44story as its whatever you want but no refunds for a second you are right so
0:22:53far the way you said it we don't mean I wouldn't even gotten them assuming that
0:22:57the sales had gone through it had not been refunded I wouldn't even have the
0:23:01money until like a month and a half from now if there was a way in Apple system
0:23:05to basically say oh give all that money back like customers gave the money to
0:23:09Apple and you can push a button the main applicant the money back to them like it
0:23:12would never appear in any year statements are pluses and minuses
0:23:16mountain in your statement about half an hour be like $0 right right I mean if if
0:23:20they gave me the control then I would have really consider doing that it does
0:23:26really suck on that i are actually now losing money on this on this project
0:23:31rather than making some money but I also it was it was a weird dilemma of light
0:23:37do I keep all or any of this money that I you know whoever doesn't claim a
0:23:42refund do I keep an event an apple made the statement made this decision for me
0:23:46they sent me an email I can email from iTunes Connect whenever it was yesterday
0:23:52afternoon but whatever day wasn't lost track of the meaning of days but
0:23:56whatever it was saying because you pulled your app we are refunding all the
0:24:01customers and it almost like a form email you could tell that it was you
0:24:07know somebody killed in like three words and it but they they decided to do that
0:24:13most likely because I was directing over 10,000 people to their refund for think
0:24:19that's like I was seeing over the last couple days there there were i think i
0:24:22think i last kind of something like thirteen or fifteen thousand people who
0:24:27had been issued refunds through the regular process and the process is
0:24:32involves doing some kind of like live chat agent thing with somebody so this
0:24:40was I Apple money to write I mean I can't imagine the load that put on the
0:24:46man and I was not very happy about that either
0:24:48and you know but I didn't have much of a choice you know I mean my my my original
0:24:53choice would have been don't like this app but you know I messed up and i got
0:24:58to lie but I messed up simple as that
0:25:01so I decided given the situation I mean we're already done that mistake how do I
0:25:05resolve this mistaken the best way possible and had been given the option
0:25:10to issue everybody book refunds I probably would have done it I can't say
0:25:14definitely yes I would have because i dont
0:25:18it was such a rush I don't even know I also don't know but I i considered and I
0:25:23had asked some some friends at a some friends like is this possible to like
0:25:27both canceled all these all these things in bulk refund them and everyone I asked
0:25:31by a simple people and they all said I don't think that's possible because most
0:25:35of the time the way the iTunes Store works is this total black box and it's
0:25:40all it's all hit accused him in any Q's team has enough to do if there if
0:25:46there's one department within apple that has way too much on their plate it said
0:25:50accused apartment and so I thought especially in regard to the iTunes Store
0:25:54this is you know this this whole infrastructure that is often does not
0:25:59work incredibly well with things like iTunes Connect error that's the idea of
0:26:04asking them to make an exception for you sound so ridiculous to almost anybody
0:26:09who's involved in this because they know that you know asking them to just make
0:26:13the basic functionality work every day is enough work for them that's that's
0:26:17hard enough anyway so I i didnt i I was not given the option to book refund
0:26:23everybody but I am kind of glad it happened because it it resolved a lot of
0:26:29problems it even though it was it was weird that they didn't ask first but I'm
0:26:36not surprised and it is kind of nice that I didn't have a choice in the
0:26:41matter because then I didn't have to make that choice but related to that
0:26:45part of the reason why someone who purchase the application will be annoyed
0:26:48I mean if you purchase it since Marco can issue your refund and since he had
0:26:54no way to do about refund but what you were doing was directing people please
0:26:59go request a refund is the only way you're going to get one you have to ask
0:27:02Apple and that process is annoying and it's like you know by now busy just
0:27:06happen but on your phone
0:27:07getting your refund seems like a hassle I don't know how to do it now I gotta
0:27:10look at Apple's site how do i do refunds market link you to the form that the
0:27:13palace added champing at the hassle so that they can give you $3 bacteria but
0:27:18why would you want your $3 back over people basically doing is like the APIs
0:27:22pulled obviously know for the development of the Apple the question
0:27:25isn't a lot of people have this question will the application continue to work on
0:27:30you know why I bought it I installed it on my phone market pulled from the
0:27:34storage means no people can buy it what does it mean about the copy of peace
0:27:37that is on my phone right now will continue to work if I get a refund will
0:27:42continue to work will be deleted from my phone if i dont answer refund how long
0:27:46will peace work before it just breaks entirely right so the answer is as far
0:27:52as I know it doesn't affect the light logical mark on your account the says
0:27:58you bought it so you are still able to have it run it I think you're able to
0:28:04restore it the way I deleted it was I didn't actually delete the entry of
0:28:09iTunes Connect I just set the availability date to be as far into the
0:28:13future as it would let me I don't know that fine details of how that work and
0:28:16so how it works and so I'm not going to promise anything there but I think it
0:28:20should allow restores everything anyway as for it functioning once you have
0:28:26installed it will continue to function until something and iOS makes it stopped
0:28:32working it will though stop getting updates from good story sometime in the
0:28:38future right now it is still a bit updates these are going to be somewhat
0:28:41costly for me to run if a lot of people keep the app installed so I might stop
0:28:44that I'm going to something eventually because now that everybody has gotten a
0:28:49refund on it that also makes it easier for me to say well you know what
0:28:54in in a few months I decide to shut down the updater and stop paying for all that
0:28:58began with the hosting for for that operation then you know I feel ok doing
0:29:03that so I'm gonna shut down some point but I haven't yet
0:29:06and when that happens the app background updates to get new definitions from from
0:29:11my server so eventually it'll become less effective over time as new ad
0:29:18servers in New trackers start existing on the web that it doesn't know about so
0:29:23that's how it will eventually break or some iOS update comes out and says well
0:29:28now you have to be on our new 128 bit processor by this day and if you're not
0:29:33running to the store as far as I know I don't think they've done any permanent
0:29:37breaking changes that would say rule out and iOS four Apple still running today I
0:29:42don't think that's the case let's be all that is a very long way of saying if you
0:29:48want to keep peace installed and if for whatever reason Apple does not remove it
0:29:52off your phone and any kind of like budget restore operation are weird thing
0:29:56like that as far as I know it's going to continue to work for a long time I think
0:30:01John I both have some more questions about this but let's talk about
0:30:04something that's awesome
0:30:05our second sponsored this week is igloo igloo software dot com slash ATP igloo
0:30:11is an internet you will actually like now
0:30:14anyone that's worked in the corporate environment knows how painful internets
0:30:18usually are content to be stale the interface is usually very tedious and
0:30:23very hard to use and usually can access on your phone or the lab breaks in your
0:30:28phone's he can't really do much short span about to use a glue fixes all that
0:30:32includes an internet you'll actually like because it is designed with modern
0:30:36technology for modern devices for the user in mind now gives you flexibility
0:30:42to get your work done how you want where you want and whatever device you want it
0:30:47is truly built for 2015 not 1997 like unfortunately too many internets with a
0:30:54glue internets you can share news you can organize files coordinate counters
0:30:58and manage projects all in one place everything can be social with comments
0:31:02like buttons lots of modern conveniences like that anybody can add content based
0:31:07on their permissions with drag-and-drop widget and what you see is what you get
0:31:11editor and it makes use of fully responsive web design this looks
0:31:14fantastic on all of your devices they have so many events feature things like
0:31:19document
0:31:19editing anti-russian you don't read management tracking who's read what it
0:31:24is really advanced stuff check it out and one of the great things about it is
0:31:28free for up to 10 people and is also there's a free trial for even more than
0:31:3310 if you have more than 10 if you have 10 or fewer people it's free forever so
0:31:36really give this a shot if you have more than 10 people start with a free trial
0:31:40and the two very reasonably priced after that check it out
0:31:43igloo software dot com slash ATP for your free trial get started today things
0:31:48like to include the internet you'll actually like John any other questions
0:31:52immediately about he's yeah we get to the good stuff we just covered let me
0:31:57let me get into the white and let me tell you the story of how this came to
0:32:01be as it does that is that good will can we just cover a couple of something
0:32:05right off the bat can we just admit that it was just a a complete glorified
0:32:12well-executed money grab that that's absolutely what happened right now the
0:32:16most unsuccessful MoneyGram in history
0:32:18yeah I'm really bad at MoneyGram yes so anyway
0:32:24know what actually happened was Apple paid the other was my best I heard was
0:32:31the Apple paid me off 22 now Apple who made this content blocking API who
0:32:38clearly wanted people to use it for Adam tracking bloody just wanted you to block
0:32:42pictures of cats Marco who I was also making them a lot of money thirty
0:32:49percent 30% a lot you know that that I think by far my favorite theory that yes
0:32:56of course yet they Apple paid me off to take this down for what exactly to to
0:33:01make them lose money and go against all their strategy goals that that makes
0:33:04sense no I mean the fact is no one paid me anything I'm now losing money on this
0:33:08because all the refunds got issued so i'm gona I'm gonna lose a few thousand
0:33:11dollars on it but oh well it took so what happened was over the summer so so
0:33:19we we had the iOS we had the content blocker announcement the BBC and in fact
0:33:24John and I are actually in the session video this there's one of the one of the
0:33:29shots and pans over
0:33:30to the audience and there's a there's a clip of me and John I think were
0:33:34clapping and one of the things that was said whatever so that's how I know
0:33:37you're making content Marcos in this session go to make any content bunker
0:33:43and I hadn't I hadn't decided right then whether I was going to do it or not but
0:33:47I knew right then it was going to be a big deal in a big market and I wanted to
0:33:52use one and that is usually a pretty good recipe from you want to make an
0:33:56appt and you know that the reality is I also want to keep doing overcast as my
0:34:04primary a pipe and so I wasn't going to tackle a new app that I thought was
0:34:08going to be a massive time sink and so content blockers are are so easy to me I
0:34:15mean really it the one the one I made that briefly did very very well and then
0:34:22the ones that are there now this is probably like the most money for the
0:34:26least effort that is ahead ever been possible in the App Store in San Marino
0:34:30soon enough it'll be diluted by tons and tons but I thought on day one there
0:34:36would be way more in the market then there were yeah I I could make one
0:34:40that's how we did it because it's like the one if you go to the session he like
0:34:44this is how it works and it is down to the data and and so the data is the code
0:34:51part of it is ridiculous that people asking me to open source it you to
0:34:55understand how little code there is here it is an incredibly special you like the
0:34:59the the extensions I added all they do is bring Safari ViewController
0:35:03I don't even read them any browser like it there is so little code in the at
0:35:08anybody can make these the only limitation is what the heck he used for
0:35:12the data for the rules of what to block that is the only hard part and the fact
0:35:17is there's tons of public of publicly available lists and databases that you
0:35:22can use and you can even like that I expected to see more
0:35:26looked into cutting bloggers that deeply but you could have couldn't you have it
0:35:31so that someone enter the URL from which to pull data in a format that you
0:35:34specify like it could be like the app could come with no didn't say well this
0:35:39is a content blocker and it works like this and expect stated to be in this
0:35:43format so type the URL here a file that I can pull that will be in that format
0:35:50and I will parse it and I will be your content blogger and maybe you don't like
0:35:53a defaulting on that pole like a block or two blocks like to be in that
0:35:58something you could do as well yeah I mean all the data you have to give them
0:36:02is just a it's a list of rules expressed in JSON and so you can you can get that
0:36:07Jason from anywhere you could included in the app you can build it on demand
0:36:11way I was doing it you get a dynamic rules it doesn't matter if it doesn't
0:36:16matter so you can make up your own format this is like a bunch of hostnames
0:36:19if you want to be like a super simple 1 I'm actually surprised more people to do
0:36:22that because that is really the least amount of work he can do you make like a
0:36:25trivial application that uses one epi and maybe even you go the extra mile
0:36:28marker didn't do the little extensions to bring up the separate you controller
0:36:32and I see nice I said there's not a lot of code in here a lot of people said the
0:36:38right thing to do is to open source it a I disagree that's I'm not obligated open
0:36:42source it would be my arrangement with ghost story is that I'm just giving it
0:36:47to them and they can do whatever they want it so it's it's no longer mine and
0:36:51that's fine
0:36:52the fact is if you want to reproduce this it is not a lot of work to do to
0:36:56make another appt like this it really is very very easy
0:37:00the only hard part of the data and that is that is very hard and make the icons
0:37:05are you could copy markers I can I don't mind could go to him and what the what
0:37:11the what the million ripoff applications that science and a few occasions that
0:37:15but like pictures of Mario into their games and stuff like they'll just copied
0:37:19exactly yeah if you want to get icon made good apparently it's great because
0:37:24they're awesome to do great work
0:37:26copy my designer don't have my design anyway
0:37:31so the thing is all summer I was I was thinking you know I should do this
0:37:38because I have like a it seems like there will be a market now again I was
0:37:43assuming from the beginning that it would be a very crowded market right
0:37:47from day one and that somebody like Adblock Plus like some well-known brand
0:37:52in an ad blocking that had to wait more exposure and visibility and user base
0:37:58than I could ever muster that they would be there in day one and would just own
0:38:02the whole market I want to think they don't they just not paying attention to
0:38:05WWDC like just not like you know cuz we all knew bloggers are going to be a big
0:38:11thing is we were but like maybe they get lost in the W ABC news like you would
0:38:15think I don't know I agree with you I totally thought that on day one of the
0:38:19store there would be a million content like this because they are so easy to
0:38:23make and there are so many places where you can get list from you can do the
0:38:27things like I said in nineteen clueless and I am when I found out you are making
0:38:32a Michael that's pretty good because in the sort of even if there are tons of
0:38:36them coming out because they're easy to make
0:38:38how do you get yourself heard above the noise and people who are against all I
0:38:42was nine on day one like you know and who are into who know that their content
0:38:47blockers and who gonna be looking for one day one you have better access to
0:38:52them than a lot of other things maybe you better access to those people then a
0:38:55big company like the thing to make that bike plus because you travel and Mac
0:38:59nerd circles and macaroons read your blog and podcast or whatever so if your
0:39:04goal is to try to sell a lot of content blockers being there on day one with the
0:39:10content blogger with a name that people recognize was a good play and you know
0:39:15it was it turns out that you know there was a good play a lot of people thought
0:39:19you meant to being number one paid app in the App Store and there weren't a lot
0:39:23of other ones too and I don't quite understand why either
0:39:26maybe they were just everyone else is asleep at the switch yeah I mean like
0:39:29like at the loop they tried to they were published in this list that was that was
0:39:32being updated and even at low on launch day they were only something like six
0:39:37entries on it and and only a half only like two or three of them were really
0:39:41getting any traction with charts I mean I was really surprised by how few there
0:39:44were any way and and by the way going back I think one of the reasons why the
0:39:48big companies like a block plus didn't go there or or haven't been there yet is
0:39:52because I was kinda blockers are very very limited didn't have access to
0:39:57what's being browsed all you do is you provide a list of rules and regular
0:40:02expressions the same block things that match this but you are not being your
0:40:06code is not being called on every page load or is it not being notified on
0:40:11what's being loaded and you can't do things like inject your own script to
0:40:15your own tracking from your site like you have no access to the way things are
0:40:20and these big companies like Adblock Plus like ghosts hurry they have you
0:40:25know the business arm of those companies usually need some kind of access or
0:40:30analytics or or track he humorously of what you are what your browsing and what
0:40:36things are being included on this page what ads are being shown what trackers
0:40:39are being loaded almost all these big companies have arrangements like that in
0:40:43some way shape or form some of them are kind of questionable I think those trees
0:40:48is pretty safe the way it works I explained in the post you know I don't
0:40:51their business model I don't think it's something to be concerned about the
0:40:54whole a couple as they are now blocked pluses I think more here doesn't matter
0:41:00fact is that i think is why these big companies weren't there on day one of a
0:41:07kind of makes sense because like I understand that their business model
0:41:11doesn't work on to be like oh by the way when they just do exactly what you did
0:41:14in selling out for three dollars and make a whole bunch of money and I think
0:41:17the answer is probably that even though it's a lot of money for a one-person due
0:41:22for a big company they're like well paid apps they can make a little money in a
0:41:28burst in and that's it there's no recurring revenue
0:41:31and we can support I mean business models so they say they're passing up
0:41:35what they consider to be chump change what is significant to one person I
0:41:38don't know how many people work for companies but a lot more than one person
0:41:42like that it just didn't seem worth it so that it might explain why the really
0:41:47big companies that do it they do you know they want huge numbers they don't
0:41:51like something that would be significant to an individual and especially but not
0:41:55recurring but then it's like why didn't someone else's another single person
0:42:01developer just give it a shot like it there were so few of them that many
0:42:06people are making a list I with my lunch they like here although I was nine
0:42:10content bloggers
0:42:11two things on a list of yours wasn't even included because of the five hour
0:42:14delay getting on the stars like crystal purity purify one blogger blog blogger
0:42:21within our yeah I saw this and trickling in but to be able to have them in a list
0:42:25if it's on a single screen and not a lot of people make content placards right so
0:42:29that's that was surprised number one was that there were so few surprise number
0:42:34two is that mine top the chart anticipate chart crystal was free on day
0:42:39one and got I think the guy said it was a hundred thousand situations and then
0:42:42he he made it paid on day two and I think now its number one but anyway
0:42:47doesn't matter and you're right I mean the kind of money that's coming in it's
0:42:51great for individual if you have a big staff it's questionable you know if it's
0:42:57worth going against your business interests and then you have to support
0:43:00that like say so you're a big well-known companies like I make my little bursts
0:43:04of money from it and maybe a little bit trickle-down effect but it's not
0:43:06significant bottom-line and then I have to continue to pay some contractor to
0:43:11make sure the app continues to work and make sure whatever servers serving data
0:43:15file that gets up to like it just might seem like a hassle of the big companies
0:43:18exactly so anyway
0:43:20going for the summer as a as I'm thinking about building this and I i
0:43:23really didn't spend a lot of time on it mostly summer was spent thinking about
0:43:27how to do it and I had my form the idea of the structure of the app at these
0:43:32extensions it would have
0:43:33have you know how that would work everything on that be great I wasn't me
0:43:36writing a lot of code until the middle of summer when I started playing with
0:43:40the various blocklist third that exists out there and in various hosts files I
0:43:45started emailing the people who maintain them asking if I could license them for
0:43:48use in a in a paid app is most of them are for non-commercial use only so you
0:43:52have to get a separate license so I started that that kind of negotiation
0:43:56and discussions but the original version of a tiny made when I was running for
0:44:02for at least a few weeks over the summer
0:44:04my own phone it was much simpler all it did was a block all third-party
0:44:10JavaScript that actually works surprisingly like one rule just block
0:44:17all third-party JavaScript
0:44:19I'm not entirely sure and recommended people do this but if your main goal if
0:44:24you're really tolerate a lot of things being broken and you're willing to go
0:44:29through the process of making the exception or whitelisting or opening up
0:44:32you know without condom bloggers like if you're going to go through that process
0:44:34a lot that gets you most of the way there I would say just blocking all
0:44:40third-party JavaScript gets you eighty percent of the way there and that's
0:44:45really it's kind of it's kind of sad how much I get you there and all these other
0:44:50databases and everything they their their strengths are mainly in getting it
0:44:55getting to the point where blocks the ad without making anything break or making
0:44:59very few things break but if you want to block all the ads and and you know
0:45:03occasionally have to open something up in in the undershirt of you just call
0:45:07germs that works fine and so awesome as do that and you know towards the reason
0:45:12this this problem attractive in the first place again was because I know
0:45:16there's going to be a market for it I wanted to use it and I had the idea of
0:45:20how to do it my way I i thought i I did think at a time you know I wonder if if
0:45:27I'm gonna get in trouble for making a block I wonder if people get people are
0:45:30you get mad at me if I make it a blocker I did think about that but in the
0:45:34excitement of solving this problem in a way that I thought was very good luck I
0:45:39was very proud of this work and so in the process of like ramping up and see
0:45:44how it turned out see how good it was
0:45:46my phone even with just that but just that Jobs corporal I kinda got lost in
0:45:51the the the the the idea of I wonder what people are going to think and if
0:45:55anyone is gonna be mad about this that got pushed back of my head because I was
0:46:00so driven by and happy about how nicely the APIs turning out and like so I was I
0:46:06was focused on totally the wrong things I was focused on I'm very proud of this
0:46:11of this nice app I made that is that is very it's making me very happy on my
0:46:15phone and I sent it to some friends later on and they they is making them
0:46:19very happies like I was so caught up in that that I i didnt go back in and
0:46:25rethink issues and then then what happened was you know I in an effort to
0:46:31try to make it better because at first you know again I said like running it
0:46:34for me with just the note thereby JavaScript ruled that worked ok but I
0:46:39wasn't necessarily sure that that was going to be a good enough product to
0:46:42text my name too because it's like you know this is really great if you're a
0:46:45nerd and you don't care about reloading lot of things
0:46:48couple times to make them work properly so that's when I started looking at
0:46:55licensing one is a daily basis and I couldn't find a good one until I tried
0:47:00groceries and then I tried that it was amazing so I contacted them I didn't
0:47:04think they would even say yes and they did say as it turns out they're actually
0:47:08really nice easy to work with and really fast to get things together I wasn't
0:47:11expecting any of these things from from a company as big as them but they they
0:47:15were really really easy and nice to work with so I work with them and and and we
0:47:20you know met their offices right here in new york city met in person we we
0:47:24arranged and we did the whole database contract everything else so then my mind
0:47:29from his last few weeks before the launch as this is all you know getting
0:47:33in place my mind is all about that and about looking now at were on this street
0:47:38this has a shower going this is gonna happen once I sign that contract I'm
0:47:42like this is going to happen and I never went back to re-evaluate should I do
0:47:46this do I want to do I want to be the person who owns the app Locker do I want
0:47:52to be in charge of an ad blocker that I stopped evaluating that
0:47:57once I got on this train of like you know this app is really good and now I
0:48:02have someone else's data in a deal with them to keep going with it and even
0:48:05better with their data I was so excited about how good the app was I never went
0:48:10back and and rethought that initial decision to even make it in the first
0:48:13place
0:48:13also I made the same mistake with the magazine that's that was an interesting
0:48:19story but you know when a when I made the magazine I was so tied up with the
0:48:23idea of making the school magazine app looks really nice and worked well and we
0:48:27better not either newsstand apps that I I forgot her really truly evaluate like
0:48:33what it would be like to have to publish an issue of the magazine every two weeks
0:48:37indefinitely and that's a lot of work and it's really hard to make the
0:48:41economics work and I kinda brushes aside I wanting to school at and so I made the
0:48:46same mistake here with different consequences different downsides where I
0:48:51was so enthralled with the app with with the technical side of it that I didn't
0:48:57adequately think about you know so what so I didn't think ahead in six months
0:49:04do I want to be spending half or more of my time being the guy who runs the big
0:49:08ad blocker Casey this very jumping with address bar code that you have off the
0:49:13top of your head I do it in about seven seconds he that he spared no expense no
0:49:23thats can go right movie I've got nothing got it market so preoccupied
0:49:31about whether or not he could make an app that didn't stop to think we should
0:49:34write exactly and or rather I stopped really early on to think and I was like
0:49:38let me try it so when you when you thought about it but before you got into
0:49:41like the whole time in making deals with those tree I'm happy with the applicable
0:49:45you thought about before that before before all that you said I'm gonna make
0:49:48what did you what was your thinking like you you you got to give yourself the
0:49:54green light you thought about it before you decide you do this and you said you
0:49:58know what I am going to do with it
0:50:00based mostly on the fact that you wanted to run one just before anyone had run
0:50:05when you had made one
0:50:06didn't exist I want to run one that why you're making you know like take us back
0:50:11to that thinking before you got caught up in some of the momentum of making the
0:50:15right I mean I absolutely want to run one as soon as I they had the very early
0:50:20prototype of the app on my phone with me just know they're pretty jobs for parole
0:50:23as soon as I had that on my phone and saw the massive difference it made in
0:50:27browsing speed and also I really do objected to tons of web advertising and
0:50:34tracking I think what the web publishing rule has done and and I blame the
0:50:39publishers a lot of people you know that I don't go too far in this case if you
0:50:43want to hear more about the you know why this debate is so complicated this
0:50:47week's epicenter back to work is really good on a topic and then talked at
0:50:50length about this whole thing it covered a lot of angles because it really is a
0:50:55very complex problem that is not a simple yes-no kind of thing they covered
0:51:00a lot of it but just you know briefly I do want to make clear I'm gonna still
0:51:04use an ad blocker and I'm still going to advocate that people block things that
0:51:10they don't think are acceptable
0:51:12what changed in my in my mind and what really should I bother you that I don't
0:51:17want to be the person in charge of making this decision for everybody I
0:51:23don't want to be the enabler necessarily I don't want to be the arbiter of what
0:51:26is good and what is the problem is you know you say block first of all I want
0:51:33to clear up right up front the idea of what I just want to block tracking but
0:51:38not adds that's BS because you because ads are tracking like you you can't
0:51:44while this is why they are very very few ads like the deck recently published
0:51:50their new privacy policy where they they explicitly say we we will not do any
0:51:54tracking from the decker disturbingly static images or whatever but that is
0:51:58really there's there are almost no advertising networks that will that will
0:52:02claim that will guarantee that and actually do that so the fact is if you
0:52:07are saying I want to block tracking but not adds that is not that's not really
0:52:12an enforceable thing you have to in order to block almost any tracking
0:52:17you have to block almost all ads that that simple it's simple as that you have
0:52:22to block at supply tracking furthermore if you really want to block more
0:52:27tracking you also have to block things like social and beds because Facebook
0:52:31and Twitter and Google+ all these things Amazon all these links these things that
0:52:35are embedded in people's site +1 this on Facebook thumbs up this on Twitter
0:52:39whatever I know this because I don't care all those things are also tracking
0:52:42because the social companies are some of the biggest tracking companies in the
0:52:46world so you also have to block social and pets and what about embedded YouTube
0:52:52videos
0:52:53Google's tracking those like there's a lot you if you really want to block
0:52:56tracking there's a lot you have to block so the fact is this is very very
0:53:00complicated it's it's a very much a gray area but you can't have it both ways if
0:53:07you say you object to being tracked or you say you check too bad ads or you
0:53:13know you try to dance a well I want to block ads but not yours yours are good
0:53:19you know it becomes very very hard to actually do that to actually manage that
0:53:23because it's usually usually are asking for something that isn't possible are
0:53:27you asking for for distinction doesn't really exist and you thought about this
0:53:30angle at all before embarking on creating the application as in like when
0:53:37I make this application when I use it you know I'll set it up so I like how it
0:53:42works but then I will sort of de facto be even if it's just buy a pitiful that
0:53:48included the application be deciding what everyone who uses my application
0:53:52fees on the web and therefore I am sort of like be the linchpin of some subset
0:53:58of the number of iOS users like Marco controls whether
0:54:01this these this group of users sees this kind of ad on this site because he's out
0:54:06to the defaulters application that happens to be thought about that at all
0:54:09or not measured reminder if you did think about it that was going to shake
0:54:13out I really didn't think that much about these distinctions CEO the only
0:54:20thing I thought of when I was making the appt was good stories data is tagged
0:54:25with like this one of the reasons why go through to be so good as you can see
0:54:29this when you stop liking each of the entries is taxable sales block this page
0:54:33you can see how it brought you know Google Page century never ends comma to
0:54:38add comment tracker it brought the deck ends a plot to do the amateur tracker
0:54:43and it'll get tags each entry with whether it's in a detractor social
0:54:47widget find commenting on whatever the categories attends so I could have very
0:54:51easily made an option right in the app that said you know check mark block ads
0:54:57check mark block trackers and had you target the separately from each other
0:55:01but again I think that's a false distinction because the fact is if you
0:55:05say you don't be tracked you have to look at
0:55:07simple as that so anyway so I really hadn't thought about the reality of me
0:55:14because I thought you know up until a few weeks before the thing launched I
0:55:19was doing my javascript thing and didn't have any distinction whatsoever and
0:55:23that's i think almost more defensible if if you say third-party javaScript is a
0:55:29problem because the reality is most of the problems with web tracking and
0:55:35creepiness and bad ads if you block third-party JavaScript that is a very
0:55:41defensible practical thing that you should consider doing because that is
0:55:46kind of why these trackers on the web can be so powerful because you can embed
0:55:51a script tag on millions of different publisher sites and your your server is
0:55:57called from the use the browser and you're able to run code arbitrary code
0:56:01on the user's browser and have access to the top of the browser the hardware
0:56:05access it's now the exposed API's all this crazy stuff you have access to
0:56:10freeze their party in beds you as the creepy had company or whatever and you
0:56:13can track everything and
0:56:14offended if people saw what is possible if if if you're on the fence about
0:56:20whether you want to block tracking you see like the kind of just it is so
0:56:27creepy what publishers are able to see the they're basically watch they can
0:56:32watch an individual's every move they can see when you throw the consumer your
0:56:36mouse cursor they can see what you have heard how long you have and how long you
0:56:39look at something they can see everything if you block cookies or if
0:56:43you block their party you know whenever there's almost nothing you can do
0:56:47including a tractor there's almost nothing you can do to prevent them from
0:56:53identifying you uniquely because even if you disable cookies and everything else
0:56:57they can identify what your phone's battery capacity is to the new battery
0:57:02level API's they can set different kinds of cookies through flash or through
0:57:06databases web TV kinda stuff there's so many they can't they can just analyze
0:57:12your browser request headers and just just combining that with your IP address
0:57:17and you can they can generally get pretty unique with that it is so easy to
0:57:23track you and to uniquely identify you
0:57:27between multiple sites between the only thing you can really do is block their
0:57:32party and beds now and so let me get to it but Garba said in the chat so you
0:57:38know what a publisher's then just proxy the JavaScript do their servers good
0:57:42question the main area so first of all and this is a whole topic we can get to
0:57:47it like you know what happens if others have blocking does it become so big that
0:57:51publishers have to change what they do things and you know the things they
0:57:55changed you might be worse and in some ways they will be but that major thing
0:57:59holding us back right now is ease and trust publishers usually don't have big
0:58:07tech teams and whatever tech teams they're doing are busy busy doing the
0:58:11crazy CMS stuff trying to accommodate some crazy stuff the salespeople sold an
0:58:16advertiser for like a one off thing that's the tech teams are busy doing it
0:58:19at big publishers and they're usually not very big teams so to have those
0:58:24texts teams do any custom work that involves running more things through
0:58:28their software and through their servers through their domain names that's
0:58:32unlikely to happen a lot of publishers secondly the issue of trust and the
0:58:38effect is the advertisers and publishers and the Vienna visitors we all hate each
0:58:44other like this
0:58:46the advertisers and publishers either get published writer at them off and so
0:58:50the advertisers don't usually trust the publishers to say how many people viewed
0:58:55something if you prosecute everything through the publisher server then the
0:59:00advertiser whatever the network has no way to verify that those were real hits
0:59:05that came from real unique people
0:59:07the publisher could fake that dated back to the advertiser and enough people
0:59:11would that you know you might get the big sites could agree to do that
0:59:15like you know New York Times could do that but you wouldn't see something like
0:59:19Google Adsense her like this common things on tons of sites you would see
0:59:22some like that kind of model because they just couldn't be trustworthy back
0:59:26to advertisers so that's not gonna happen anyway going back before I before
0:59:30i came to part of it to be like the post-release thing services thing not be
0:59:36a problem and then as the success rolled in and as I started as a hit number one
0:59:42and as money started rolling in big money starts rolling in I started
0:59:48getting a lot of attention that I really was not prepared to get and I didn't
0:59:55want to be the face of this war you know I felt and I used a war metaphors and I
1:00:00am i pulling post and I do want to recognize that I'm using these metaphors
1:00:03extremely lightly because this is all very much first world problems and this
1:00:09is nothing like what real war is so I really want to do these metaphors
1:00:13extremely loosely in with that John disclaimer had a bit but I I almost feel
1:00:18like I was an arms dealer you know there's a war going on and these two
1:00:22sides you know really don't like each other and attorney whatever they can to
1:00:25disagree a lot of casualties happening and I was the arms dealer that was
1:00:30enabling them
1:00:31and yet if I start if I pull my appt somebody else will step in they are did
1:00:37i mean you know somebody can step in and can become the arms dealer so it's gonna
1:00:40happen anyway let them be Dr regular I didn't want to do that I didn't want to
1:00:44be in a position and I i just i didnt expect the scale of it I didn't
1:00:50adequately question how I would feel about it you know
1:00:55late enough in the process I was so I was so taken by how great the app turned
1:00:59out and how great the good news was working that I I didn't put enough
1:01:03thought into do I really want to be doing this and then all the requests are
1:01:08rolling in a well you know this is really terrible for everybody but if he
1:01:11could make these changes and everybody had different changes and they were all
1:01:15very complex and it was going to be that peace was going to take it was it was
1:01:21going to have to replace overcast completely it was I was no are going to
1:01:25be a podcast at maker I would have had to be a full-time ad blocking at maker
1:01:31dealing with the full-time realities of being in a position of being an arms
1:01:37dealer being that arbiter of what is what is acceptable and what's not and
1:01:42the fact is I don't know anything about that business at all I've only even used
1:01:48an ad blocker for like three or four months and barely even use them for that
1:01:52long I was totally unprepared to to be in this role and one slice once I was
1:01:58faced with the reality of what this role is like I realized oh I really don't
1:02:03like this this is really uncomfortable I was I was having trouble sleeping for
1:02:07those few minutes only few nights that people before it pulled it but you know
1:02:11I was having trouble sleeping I was I was really kind of upset all day all
1:02:14night it was I really did not know what to do I I just realized that I I had
1:02:21gotten in way too deep
1:02:22i'd was way over my head I had not thought through enough and I have found
1:02:27myself in a very powerful position that I really didn't want that power
1:02:35in an industry that I really didn't want to be in being the face of a war that
1:02:42are really did not want to face up that's what happened though it was just
1:02:48ask the question that a lot of people have asked on Twitter in a ceremony with
1:02:51the answers
1:02:52was the fact that piece blocked ads on Marco dot org factor in any of your
1:02:58decisions no I don't make that much money from that is fine it's not at all
1:03:02and it does block them right piece on the market of your website it blocks the
1:03:08ads on it and you know that and it did not affect any of your decisions I
1:03:11thought it would be a massive dick move I didn't i mean that's maybe it's
1:03:15because of you know like that all the different things that you do you make
1:03:20overcast got the podcast you got a website and they all kind of contribute
1:03:24to the stuff that you do but it seems to me in recent years that your website
1:03:30although it used to be much more important is now less important so maybe
1:03:34people who only know you're a public space from me didn't you stop selling
1:03:39sponsorships to the website recently like a year ago or more anyway I think
1:03:45people have the wrong impression and think think of you think of black market
1:03:49targets are saying things like there is in like that Martin target the main
1:03:54thing and then you do these podcasts on the side you make software on the side
1:03:56or whatever but at various times the balance between the things you do it
1:04:00right away I barely even write on my site anymore
1:04:03tell me about it yeah yeah you winning you are no but I mean the fact is like
1:04:11if the deck cancel my membership over this that would like threatening to do
1:04:17that wouldn't have been if they didn't but threatening to do that would not
1:04:20have been enough for me to make this is it I made this decision with almost no
1:04:25input I asked almost nobody I did actually run a lot of a lot of theories
1:04:29are the John Gruber somehow like sodomy to force me to do this the only person
1:04:34who knew before I pulled the app that I was going to pull the ad besides history
1:04:38and my wife the only the person that I told was John Gruber and he's he's here
1:04:43he's he's a smart guy and and so I ran up by him as kind of a sanity check
1:04:49like my totally insane here and I don't want to ask a lot of people but I did
1:04:54ask him is he has thoughts on this issue and he said I should keep it up he told
1:05:02me to leave like he said don't do it he said wait you know this is your being
1:05:07rash is think this through you really want to do this so the theory that he
1:05:11somehow got to me I don't know that in the bed the theory that he got to me is
1:05:17completely wrong that the fact is I made the decision before talked to him about
1:05:21it I ran by him he told me don't do and then I did it anyway so that's what
1:05:27happened and you know once and goes there was great and I thought that was a
1:05:32problem going to them and be like hey nevermind but they made their employment
1:05:39before them but we we were on the same page it was fun and they were they were
1:05:43like they were again so incredibly easy to work with
1:05:46ok if that's what happened you know before and during and so I don't know
1:05:56how much time I talked about you know what I think about ads today a Merry
1:05:59ranted about how a detractors are the same thing as they are I will say that I
1:06:05think the biggest problem that web publishing faces is that things they're
1:06:10doing it is nicely I would say journalists are kind of like I've had
1:06:18this problem with academics as well and probably cuz I was a terrible student
1:06:22had generally terrible experiences with school incurring up but academia put
1:06:28itself in in a really pious position and some of those deserved but a lot of it
1:06:34isn't in a lot of ways they're just people with the same flaws as everyone
1:06:38else
1:06:39the role they serve is in some part special necessary in some parts just a
1:06:43business and so journalism I think you can see all the same things about it is
1:06:49it does serve a critical role in society
1:06:53sometimes most of the journalism taking place today is not providing value
1:06:59really or not providing enough value
1:07:01it's really hard business because if you're in the business like I thought it
1:07:07was kind of ironic premium
1:07:10misusing that word the ironically these but it was kind of ironic that my my
1:07:17post in which I said that I was pulling the app somebody's preacher and take me
1:07:23that it was you know they were like you know a hundred other posts from new
1:07:28sites that were basically gives rewrites of it just valueless bad rewrites of it
1:07:34that didn't even get the right point out of it of course my experience with
1:07:39journalists personally has been mostly mediocre to negative I have said many
1:07:43times in the past that talking to journalists is like talking to the
1:07:47police
1:07:48ideally don't they they have different goals the new and they have lots of
1:07:53incentives that might be misaligned incentives and you in my experience I've
1:07:58been very frequently misrepresented and I've had my quote very frequently used
1:08:03out of context and against me or again or as weapons to fight a cause that I
1:08:07wasn't representing so I had a lot of mediocre experiences or negative
1:08:11experience of the journalists because there's this this attitude in the
1:08:15business that they are untouchable that that they are that they they must they
1:08:21must be automatically supported by society somehow that what they're doing
1:08:25has has infinite value and the fact is that you have read this post I see like
1:08:28the hundred useless rewrites that that most site publisher some sites had
1:08:34original content that was interesting an interesting perspective most didn't
1:08:38there's a massive oversupply of journalism publishing on the web ad
1:08:45blockers have existed for a long time people from blocking ads for a long time
1:08:50ad rates have been going down for a long time especially display ads on websites
1:08:56design decisions have been being made by data for a long time there's this this
1:09:02infectious culture of data people to drive me nuts
1:09:05the analytics and data and read all those things are euphemisms for tracking
1:09:10and so this culture drives major decisions
1:09:14at publishers including what analysts going to have in their site what
1:09:18trackers are going to embed how to attract you what they're going to track
1:09:21who they're going to cellular data to this culture of we're gonna track
1:09:26everything that's ok we're gonna make all of our design decisions based on
1:09:29data and he be testing everything that has infected the industry so so badly
1:09:35and by the way all the supplies to apps as well but whereas can do is different
1:09:39and then we'll get to that of the time but the combination of the the the data
1:09:43people plus publishing just being so hyper competitive so oversupplied and
1:09:51adverts being so bad leads to an environment where publishers are just
1:09:57desperate because as an economic so hard they're really hard if you have a staff
1:10:03of more than zero here if you're just yourself working a lot of people can
1:10:09make can make money themselves enough to survive but once you're supporting staff
1:10:13like if you if you're big enough to like having a chart apartment I think that's
1:10:18that's a good barrier like if you're so be like that and you're trying to make
1:10:21it in publishing it's really hard to do this environment this atmosphere of
1:10:26difficult economics decreasing ad rates it screams environment where bad
1:10:31behavior like him getting tons of trackers and doing creepy things to your
1:10:34data is only going to increase it is it is prevalent now it only going to
1:10:39increase and the fact that or the idea that journalism needs to be supported by
1:10:45society no matter what despite all this garbage I don't think is a valid
1:10:50argument and and I think that there's really fault on both sides here the
1:10:54attitude from publisher seems to be that they are helpless in this fight that
1:10:58well it's not our problem but advertisers do we have to use them then
1:11:02that's your problem you know it then that's your fault you you are choosing
1:11:06to do this you are selling me to them so this is this is a hard problem it is not
1:11:13going to be solved anytime soon
1:11:16it is not you know it's as much a blogger's fault as the decline of the
1:11:21music sales were Napster his fault you know that gets you know that's
1:11:24contributing factor but it's not only the root problem
1:11:27and I think any discussion of of a bloggers that comes over the next months
1:11:33and years as the economics of these friend and will continue to crumble a
1:11:39lot of people in a blockers but the reality is it's much more complicated
1:11:42than that and i really think journalists and publishing companies are looking at
1:11:47complete their own way they're looking at it it really in a way to bury their
1:11:50head in the sand they're saying well it's your fault you're blocking our ads
1:11:53whatever the real problem is that the real problem is that they are adding
1:11:59things to their sites and tracking things and and shoving in an arbitrary
1:12:02could they are allowing themselves and advertisers to do really creepy things
1:12:07in the name of money and data that's problem number one problem number two is
1:12:13that many of them are doing work that they assume has value that might have
1:12:20less value than they think like taking my blog post and rewriting it for your
1:12:25audience how much value that have really liked are you adding much there should
1:12:30people be paying you for that I don't know if I think there I think they're in
1:12:35trouble I i think they're looking at it the wrong way and I don't want to seem
1:12:40like to enter publisher here because a lot of them they're really good but
1:12:43there's also a lot of having a really hard next few years and I think they're
1:12:49gonna blame ad blockers but the reality is this was happening with or without a
1:12:54blogger's anywhere finals but really it's about time for that much of this
1:13:01week is a mail route mail route that net / ATP to learn more
1:13:06just makin first second and world that's spam without viruses about don t know
1:13:10that is why they can bring that to you today here's what you do you put mail
1:13:15route in front of your mail server they filter the mail and a forward the clean
1:13:20mail to your mail servers that's it you can configure if you want you can set
1:13:23times a great option they can they can establish you know they can administer
1:13:27groups and individuals and all sorts of corporate buzzwords that they support
1:13:32they they support everything LDAP now back after director et al Sabban really
1:13:35all this crazy stuff but that's it that's all there call option but if you
1:13:39want to learn how to do
1:13:40is this point your MX records of them have them point to you and then you just
1:13:44stop it expand
1:13:45that's it i mean i view this now for six months a year some have used for a while
1:13:50and it is really good I mean they they cannot pay me to say that is really good
1:13:55I'm telling you myself off script I've been using it and it's a really good I
1:14:00hardly ever C span it is it is a rare occasion that spend it through the
1:14:05school thing where they send to Quarantine email if they think something
1:14:08might be spam
1:14:09but they're not that confident about it because the quarantine it sends you an
1:14:14email digest
1:14:15like one email I think it's one today I have mine set to come in the morning for
1:14:19this through this time period and then there's just a list of subject lines and
1:14:23there's links in there you can just tap a link to say what was this one send it
1:14:26through and the rest is ignore and India that adds to your database overtime and
1:14:30they learn from that so I'm not worried about things getting falsely trapped in
1:14:34my spam filter because I'm being sent anything that was questionable and
1:14:38occasionally I want this one to send it through and you get there is no longer
1:14:42news click link it's it's all you know has everything you need to login it's
1:14:45great it's such a great system
1:14:47economic phone you know my brother doesn't matter it is great and so all
1:14:51you do you set this up and then you just dont C span anymore that alone until you
1:14:56it works I'm telling you this makes any email hosts have better spam filtering
1:15:01than gmail from Gmail friends told me from hurting other people have said that
1:15:05on the previous ad reads and hurting people who say the same thing but this
1:15:09is better than Gmail spam filter the combination of mail route in front of
1:15:14any other I'm outposts gives you standards-based email with world-class
1:15:18painful during a mean the best I've ever seen on any host you want and it's great
1:15:23so check it out now right that net / ATP for a free trial and if you use that
1:15:28link you get 10% off for the lifetime of your entire account there it is used by
1:15:33all sorts of people individuals like me all the way up to large corporations
1:15:36large universities can reduce load in your email service your self can really
1:15:41dramatically improved just been filtering on a host service that you use
1:15:44like what I do they have API is everything it's amazing
1:15:47check it out and tell you it works now read that net / ATP thanks a lot for
1:15:51sponsor show
1:15:53what did you learn from all this from the peace thing and and I mean this not
1:15:56to be you up but clearly this did not go the way you thought it was going to go
1:16:00and clearly it was a disaster right and and i think what a lot of people lost
1:16:06sight over when you pulled piece was was that that it was going to be a long-term
1:16:13fix but it was a short-term increased disaster like you are not making things
1:16:21easier on yourself by at least for the first few days by pulling peace and I'm
1:16:28curious you know what did you learn from this experience and and maybe even from
1:16:32the magazine you've made a few parallels with that experience what have you
1:16:35learned I'd like to say that I learned not to tackle after thinking them
1:16:40through but the reality is I'm probably gonna make that mistake again the future
1:16:45a pic better ones I say I like making stuff and I got carried away in both in
1:16:52both cases they carried away with like you know first of all underestimate how
1:16:56much work they would be in second of all not taking forward enough like do I
1:17:00really want to be this thing full time because that can and probably will
1:17:06happen a lot of these things you know I thought he was going to be a really
1:17:10simple thing that especially since I outsource the data to go story I thought
1:17:15it would be effectively no upkeep I did not think it was going to do that well I
1:17:22didn't think I'd become the face of a blocking and I didn't think through what
1:17:26it meant what it would mean for it to be widely used and what it what it would
1:17:32mean to put myself in that position and whether I want to be in a position and
1:17:36the reality is I'm not made for that I'm not made for this business I i made for
1:17:41occasionally talking about it on podcasts but I'm not made for for
1:17:46actually being in it for being involved her for being a major decision maker for
1:17:52the politics for the pressure for possibly being sued I mean we don't know
1:17:56anything about cricket suit you know that there's all these things could
1:17:58happen
1:18:00and I didn't want to be in that business that deeply I just wanted to make a cool
1:18:05app and then get back to my podcast and the fact is it isn't that simple and
1:18:10success makes it especially not that simple but you could have done that like
1:18:15physically speaking it could have been no upkeep if you had to deal with those
1:18:18trees could have made the appt you could have never modify the application again
1:18:21except to keep it running and you know just continue to serve the country like
1:18:24that was that was a possibility it's not as if there was something specifically
1:18:28about this application that required a tremendous amount of upkeep right yeah
1:18:33it's it's more that I thought the problem was with simple it really was
1:18:36you know i i really thought that just having this master on off switch and a
1:18:42handful options below would be enough to solve the problem and the reality is
1:18:46that's not enough you know like any app I mean when I made buckshot whenever was
1:18:51two years ago yet two years ago when I meet buckshot I thought the same thing
1:18:54that this is going to be a simple little thing I know I'm gonna spin like a week
1:18:57on it and then you know if I'll use my friends we use it maybe also a couple
1:19:01thousand copies right then and buckshot case that's exactly what happened but
1:19:06it's even on day one it was like well gotta fix this bug this feature requests
1:19:12coming in a lot I really should address that it wouldn't be that much work and
1:19:14so it starts eating more and more time eating more and more of your attention
1:19:18the idea of just releasing an app out there and and that's the end of it is
1:19:24something that I keep falling into that that is one of the things I have to
1:19:27learn here is like when I had his idol ideas for little side apps it's very
1:19:33hard to to make those stay a little side apps to really make them not take that
1:19:40long
1:19:40not take away a lot of time for my primary APICS right now is overcast and
1:19:44I i said to be there for a long time I I keep thinking I can do more than I
1:19:50really can in in in a day or at a time that is the main problem here I have a
1:19:55lot of things I want to do have a lot of ideas I want to work on but I really
1:20:00need to first question a how much time they were actually take probably way
1:20:06more than I think of ongoing time
1:20:09and then be do I really want to be there what if it succeeds then I then I'm that
1:20:15person that I mean that business to everyone to be there I think but I see
1:20:20at the center of this is like getting hit by the idea that you could have made
1:20:22peace the way it was a major continued to work as I was updated but never had
1:20:27another feature to it never changes thing on it never update the icon never
1:20:30liked that's it you do the app you make it you leave it on the story this for
1:20:34sale
1:20:35you never make any other changes to it that is thing you could do but I think
1:20:38the problem is that the application requires up to that they don't require
1:20:43the appeal the only required because you feel bad about having an application
1:20:48that you know could be better in the million ways that everyone is it just
1:20:50you and so you feel compelled to you like with buckshot like you know those
1:20:54people have a point it would be better at this feature that beer and this
1:20:57actually would be a good idea and it just you can't you can't you can't abide
1:21:01by having an application on the story that you made the debt is in some ways a
1:21:05representation of you like this is my work is it everything I made and they
1:21:08just never touch it again like that sounds like it would be torture for you
1:21:11to be forced to put out an application is that the only thing to do is
1:21:14application from now on you know I do any work on it except that it breaks
1:21:18because of an OS update and you do the minimum to get it working in that he
1:21:21can't be Jersey can't change behavior you can tap the icon you can't make it
1:21:26more efficient you can't do anything with it right and it seems like you are
1:21:30constitutionally incapable and you know I think most developers are customers of
1:21:34cable doing them because they would just eat it to you to be like but it's not
1:21:37but is not good is not as good as it could be it could be better or I think I
1:21:42made a mistake with this or it should or should be different or even just your
1:21:46own purposes even like you know what a distinct set up its not even working for
1:21:50me anymore I can use my own out because of the changes of that that i think is
1:21:53at the core here because I know there are a lot of developers like who you
1:21:57know these these these places they just turn up thousands and thousands and
1:22:01thousands of applications but you know fleets are developers their fire and
1:22:04forget it's like how goes out into the world makes whatever money is going to
1:22:07make it will never be revisited right but that is not how you you don't feel
1:22:12good working that way so you never will work that way and so that's why it's
1:22:15basically impossible for you to
1:22:17up like that you to say just make this app to sit on the store making money on
1:22:23never look at it again
1:22:25yeah I think you're right I mean that I can't do that I am NOT able even eat
1:22:31whatever I think will will happen before it happens when the time comes I am NOT
1:22:36able in the morning and that that I decided to pull it decided to pull you
1:22:43know mid-morning before that I was sitting down to start work overnight
1:22:48peace there I was starting to work on the on the 1.1 update that would add all
1:22:51these you know granular settings and all this crap people wanted unlike you know
1:22:54that's when I start thinking like I really don't want to do this like this
1:22:58is really I'm not happy making this app I am i cant handle the heat I would like
1:23:05to go to the kitchen please like I i cant get and why am I like I wanna be
1:23:10shipping overcast to point out what what the heck am i doing doing this app that
1:23:14is that is making me hate myself and one of the problems is it was bringing good
1:23:22money it's really hard to turn that down a lot of people wouldn't be able to turn
1:23:27that down I was fortunate that I have other sources of income I had made money
1:23:31in the past so I i I could you know I'd ask my wife of course like you know like
1:23:35crazy but I you know the fact is it was really hard to turn that away once it
1:23:44was working but that should give you some idea of how bad I felt about it
1:23:49like that I really really did not want to be in at once I was in it once I was
1:23:57in 2010 this is this is not for me I can't I can't handle it I mean being in
1:24:05the AM blocking business feels like being the piracy business you know men
1:24:09please don't wanna hear from people about this comment but because it isn't
1:24:14it isn't the same it isn't it isn't a direct perfect metaphor but there are
1:24:19there's a lot of that that you know being an ambush you know piracy and
1:24:24blocking these are things that lots of people want lots of people or admit they
1:24:29wanted
1:24:30the one anyway lots of people do it and don't talk about it it's no big deal
1:24:34there are some legitimate reasons to do things that are unjust you want things
1:24:39for free like this actually get reason for people power thing sometimes and
1:24:43there's I think very many legitimate reason to block ads but the fact is they
1:24:46they can all live in the same world of like things that are either illegal or
1:24:50kind of clothes you know kind of in a gray area it's it's a it's a tricky area
1:24:56to to define like morals and standards around and so making a living from a
1:25:02blocker it kind of feels like a kind of music profiting off of piracy or I
1:25:11wonder if like people who work for porn sites field feel weird about it like any
1:25:16season is over I don't know I don't like either but I suspect it might have some
1:25:21similar issues of like some people just don't want to be associated with that
1:25:26kind of industry you know and so i think i block it one of those things where it
1:25:30is questionable
1:25:31it is potentially risky your people getting hurt somewhere along the way
1:25:36like it's kind of tricky to stomach and I think there's a reason why most people
1:25:44who make a blocking software are not like prominent indeed personalities in
1:25:51public like I don't know the people in either a blogger's at all I've never
1:25:56heard of them its fine they probably would not be exposed to as much crap as
1:26:02well I was getting because I I put myself out there in the public eye I
1:26:06have a very public persona in this industry and and and among the press
1:26:11which sometimes I really regret and this is one of those times but where it's
1:26:17really hard to handle but this this is the business made for anonymous
1:26:22companies and people who don't mind the heat that's made for them and I'm
1:26:27neither of those things from people who are angry like my anger about this thing
1:26:32I if I could speak to those people are moment of this show and didn't rage quit
1:26:37figures now
1:26:37stabilize banks at first I think it's reasonable for people to be angry his
1:26:46Marco did it convenes a lot of people who had to go get a refund before the
1:26:51big thing happen and and also like you know it's a sort of feeling of betrayal
1:26:55like I'm buying the thing because I trust the things that Marco makes and
1:26:58now the address is being betrayed so there is a fundamental screw up on
1:27:03Marcus part underlying all this and understand why people are angry about it
1:27:07and you know Marco knew that I would be coming and I think you accept that ya
1:27:11know like that the short-term pain for long-term gain it's best to just rip off
1:27:14the bandaid now people are going to be angry at you and that's just something
1:27:18you have to deal with right obviously goes online people get really like
1:27:23there's that aspect of it and I don't think that's that's that's that's part
1:27:29of your decision-making as I think although you made any way to get to the
1:27:33second thing is that people are angry about that you know they're angry spend
1:27:36down all sorts of directions and it's like how did you make an ad blocker and
1:27:42not understand that you didn't want to be a person who makes a netbook I think
1:27:45you've got done a good job explaining that now but I think your blog post
1:27:49about it explains even better particularly in the title and that they
1:27:52like how dumb is going to be he spent the whole summer making an ad blocker he
1:27:56put that out there and then one day later he goes you know what I don't want
1:27:59to make an ad blocking a block ads right like that it somehow you didn't
1:28:02understand how ad blockers work and my take on the base on your blog post
1:28:07everything you said is that you understood that you were going to make
1:28:10an ad blocker you wanted to use that bloggers you still do want to use in
1:28:13that bunker and you may 21 you like to adjust it a serious like you said you're
1:28:17overdoing things an application that you think is gonna be popular that you
1:28:20yourself want to use that you can develop that the formula for making it
1:28:23an outbreak yeah and so you you made the thing and when it came out that thing
1:28:29you didn't anticipate was the fact that not that I couldn't block dad but it was
1:28:32you know making an ad blocker and having a block as all that work the way you
1:28:36hope that it's great but you didn't anticipate was how you would feel about
1:28:39beating how you feel about being the person who made a net locker and people
1:28:45who think that you should be able to predict how you feel about something
1:28:49that has now
1:28:49happened are asking too much I think of you know like I really want to be I
1:28:57don't know like the manager of the store that I work out I really want to be
1:29:02married I really want to you know get a tattoo I really want to learn to fly a
1:29:09plan to be an account until you actually do all those things you can have
1:29:13predictions about how much you're gonna like it are you really gonna like being
1:29:15manager
1:29:16are you actually gonna like learning to fly a plane you know all those things
1:29:21you say you want to get married once this person a lot of people change their
1:29:25mind about that about half of them you know like you may think you know like
1:29:31didn't you understand what it would be like to be managed to see the manager
1:29:34every day you know what managers do it's not like the mystery and then you're
1:29:37saying you're the man now you're not happy sometimes you just don't know how
1:29:41you gonna feel about doing anything until you actually do it and that's a
1:29:45mistake we all make that mistake in various sizes hopefully most of us don't
1:29:50make those mistakes in the public eye but sometimes you do right and so my the
1:29:54way i frame what margaret is done here is that he didn't correctly picked
1:30:00predict how he would feel about something that's not an intellectual
1:30:02thing where he didn't understand the consequences or that you know all the
1:30:07grand conspiracy theories Iran to get into is that like you said you think it
1:30:10didn't feel good to you to be doing everything else was working exactly as
1:30:13you predicted like you thought it would could potentially sought because you you
1:30:18know you're prominent and something that people want and it was working more or
1:30:21less the way you wanted and your friends that you tried out working well and it
1:30:24worked well for you all working exactly but other things made you feel bad about
1:30:29having you there and so what you did was make decisions I feel bad if I want out
1:30:34of this feeling make feeling stop now please and the consequence of doing that
1:30:39was making a bunch of people angry and they're just by an angry cuz you screwed
1:30:43up and but you fix it as fast as he could and you know like ripping off a
1:30:47bandaid the worst thing you could have done is Hemant on feel bad about this
1:30:50for weeks and weeks and then that would've been terrible get an even more
1:30:54money even more people pissed and we were in the same situation but you still
1:30:58had no way to both refund them and they would have to even more people going
1:31:01through there
1:31:01you know it was just you made the decision you made the best of many
1:31:06possible bad decisions at the time you had to make it and that bad decision
1:31:09doesn't absolve you of everything but like I think people are who are who you
1:31:15don't forget who are very angry and I like you know that's like I have to say
1:31:20like that's too high of standards like what you're basically saying is my
1:31:23public figures can never make a mistake you know no that's not you can't hold
1:31:27people that america's you can you can just say about this mistake this one
1:31:31mistake too far and now I'm never gonna like I'm never gonna leave a mark was
1:31:34again I will never trust him again I mean it is a minor betrayal of trust you
1:31:39can decide that night but like I think it's unrealistic to think that anybody
1:31:43is ever going to fulfill you know they're never gonna do a market in which
1:31:49is basically not correctly predicted they would feel about something I don't
1:31:53just like I'm not going to say that people should or shouldn't be angry or
1:31:56whatever it just from my perspective in the grand scheme of things it's so
1:32:03understandable as a thing that happens to all of us and it just happened that
1:32:06happened to Marco on a grand scale and public which is ready for Marco and
1:32:10credit for everyone else involved and you know to be clear I really messed up
1:32:16like I made a huge mistake but a huge mistake was launching the app it was not
1:32:20pulling it pulling it was my solution to the mistake the mistake was watching it
1:32:26that I should have I should have seen some warning signs ahead of time that
1:32:30you know I don't wanna sleep in this business or I won't be able to handle
1:32:33the heat I should have seen those warning signs and I didn't feel I was
1:32:36blinded by the idea of this cool app that I just made that I thought was
1:32:39working really well and that was very proud of so I did make that mistake but
1:32:46the mistake was launching it once the idea got my head I was feeling miserable
1:32:50for like to know that the two and a half days earlier and then once the idea got
1:32:54my head that you don't wait a minute I can just end this I can just pull down
1:32:59and get myself out of this and I knew it was going to be really messy I knew that
1:33:03it was a problem with apple juice into a problem with all the customers you know
1:33:08part of the reason why the Apple launched so well and and grow so quickly
1:33:14is because
1:33:15was I've been building a reputation for years and my audience for years and I
1:33:21knew they were gonna be a major cost to do that that I have died have lost a lot
1:33:28of people the next time I do anything even when overcast two ships hopefully
1:33:32sometime soon
1:33:33the next time I release anything or ask people to buy or look at anything I lost
1:33:40a lot of the reputation over the years now that a lot of those people will no
1:33:44longer buy it they won't look at it I'm gonna be hearing about this in emails
1:33:49and comments and tweets for years and people are still making butter coffee
1:33:53jokes I'm going to hear about this this for years the other aspect of the
1:33:58polymer all the bad things about it like the people who who applauded your
1:34:01decision like a lot of people like you know my respect for your Marcos increase
1:34:06are you doing this thing I'd ever subset of them are happy about it because they
1:34:10think a block is unethical and guess what guys market input because he's
1:34:15against that blocking right and so they're like oh well you know like so
1:34:21then maybe you lose those people to their there's still hope that majority
1:34:25of the people I didn't understand like this the person who made a mistake in
1:34:29public and fixed it decisively as fast as quickly as possible and like you know
1:34:36and again once you've made the mistake you can't unring that Bell you did ship
1:34:39the app but like the worst thing you could do is just like I don't know leave
1:34:43it out there for a week two weeks and then just like you would like two days
1:34:48right I don't I think that is it was one night wonderful day and then one morning
1:34:53so it was a total of about 48 hours there is a resume and and and and like
1:34:58so as soon as I decided that morning I decided well having my morning coffee
1:35:01and talking to my wife we were talking about like I really want to go to this
1:35:05i'd I wanna be done with this it was it was down within an hour and a half of
1:35:10that decision because I the only thing I want the only thing I had to do was I
1:35:15had to look at my contract with those three make sure you could do this and I
1:35:19want to call and ask them and the CEO of ghost tree super nice guy was on a plane
1:35:24coming back from Germany
1:35:26time
1:35:27but he has wifi so every email on his in-flight wifi was bothering him on a
1:35:33plane trip like we don't talk right now I'm that I got this business
1:35:37the app was was pulled within an hour and a half of me deciding that this is
1:35:42what I wanted to do and I would have done it sooner I was gonna be sued by
1:35:46anybody but it believe me I did not take the decision lightly and it would have
1:35:53been way more profitable
1:35:55you know if I got to keep the money it would've been way more profitable to
1:35:58just sit on it for a while and I and II know that's the thing is what a lot of
1:36:05people don't understand you know when I said that you know I didn't make Yahoo
1:36:12helicopter money which is true but that I now have i I have enough of a cushion
1:36:17now from from the timber sale that I don't need to take every opportunity I
1:36:23get to make money if it's something that I don't feel good doing I don't feel
1:36:26comfortable doing are they don't we want to working on I can pick and choose now
1:36:30and when I was writing that when I was actually talking about was making a
1:36:36podcast app because the time
1:36:38podcast apps for way smaller there today targeting was waste more than it is
1:36:42today and I really wanted to work on a podcast app but I knew it probably
1:36:47wouldn't make as much money as Instapaper was making or anything else
1:36:49that I could do more generally would make but the fact is I am I'm able now
1:36:58I'm fortunate enough that I can I can make a decision that is against my best
1:37:02financial interests but that is for my own mental health and for long-term
1:37:08habitation and for you know of avoiding problems in my life avoiding burnout
1:37:14times my family etcetera I can make decisions like this and I had to make
1:37:21one of those decisions for this to preserve myself I'm a programmer I'ma
1:37:27keep working hard technical problems and a blocking is not a particular problem
1:37:31is actually a very very very easy technical problem
1:37:33combined with a really really
1:37:37messy tricky political guilt-ridden problem of classifying sites and dealing
1:37:46with what is right and what is wrong and what is good and what is bad and all
1:37:50these impossible to solve decisions that's the a blocking business and
1:37:56dealing with really really angry people all the time that that is what this
1:38:01businesses it's really gross to me and I didn't think that through my mistake was
1:38:09launching it not canceling it so that the subset of people who made the people
1:38:14who are applauding you because they thought you had a change of heart about
1:38:16at blocking which you have not know I just don't want to be the one doing it
1:38:20right so the remaining people who applaud your decision basically you know
1:38:25basically showing sticking to your principles doing the decision that is
1:38:29bad for you and but doing it again ripping off a bandaid quickly instead of
1:38:34doing it slowly right I am trying to think of what distinguishes those people
1:38:38from the people who like will never forgive you I think what it comes down
1:38:41to as it very often doesn't things is empathy because the people who applaud
1:38:48your difficult decision to to have that feeling where you have to do is
1:38:51empathize with the personally imagine yourself in that situation imagine that
1:38:55you had made a mistake he would launch an application that you realized you
1:38:59don't want to be the person who make the application and it
1:39:02and and it's too late now and you know that any course of action is going to
1:39:06make a bunch of people unhappy and you know it's going to cost you money is
1:39:11gonna cause irritation or whatever if you can empathize with that if you can
1:39:15put yourself in my shoes and say boy that must have really sucked because you
1:39:19know I remember when I made a mistake and miscalculated how much I would like
1:39:24doing X&Y and after that I got myself stuck in it and then you're stuck with
1:39:27like well do I have to just you know well on it now I just gotta get through
1:39:31it or can i just imagine for example you took a new job and first weekend you go
1:39:37I made a terrible mistake this I am NOT happy this job I will never be happy
1:39:41this job do you quit after working there for a week there to be like that guy we
1:39:44hired they kinda quit in the first week don't hire him he's fighting he doesn't
1:39:48know what he was like that's a mistake you should not have taken that job i met
1:39:50that's a mistake that people can relate to read anyway
1:39:53empathy is what separates people people who are able to empathize with your
1:39:57situation said boy I feel bad I've been in a similar situation to understand
1:40:01what it's like and what I know the decision had to make this hard and all
1:40:05his decisions are crappy and it feels bad language you for justifiable reasons
1:40:10and therefore they say now Marco my esteem for you has risen because I
1:40:16understand what you like and the thing you just mentioned about you know Tumblr
1:40:20and being able to make podcast applications and and not having to do
1:40:24Instapaper past where you want to and stuff like that that really hurts
1:40:28empathy because people don't have empathy for people who are financially
1:40:33more well off than they do in general like that that is a theme that you know
1:40:37people but it is sometimes difficult to put yourself in the shoes of somebody
1:40:42who you think doesn't have what you think is one of your main sources of you
1:40:47no problem if you worry about money a lot you can and and you think I am a
1:40:53good smart hardworking person and this guy does not to worry about money at all
1:40:59and how how is he any better than me it's harder to add them to the is like
1:41:03how can you you know like all your problems whatever your problems in your
1:41:06life you Marco you like this well Marco may have stubbed his toe but about his
1:41:11money I wouldn't care about stood toe stepping right you know me like it it's
1:41:15very popular to turn down the embassy dial when somebody is more successful
1:41:21than you or has something that you want as if that why why does everything
1:41:24famous people like he's a celebrity well like I have no empathy for you know I'm
1:41:32a celebrity ever I was gonna say tempers of that salt and scientology I wanna go
1:41:35down that way and I'll jump in the rebel you know and Julia Roberts like you can
1:41:43say mean things about her while she's rich and famous if I was rich and famous
1:41:46nothing anyone could ever say would bother me or like I i don't have any
1:41:49sympathy for her she is the most you know she's beautiful she's rich she's
1:41:54famous like it's very easy to not have empathy when you feel that about people
1:41:58and so that i think is a factor in the exactly how angry people are about what
1:42:04you did because they they feel like you you know they can't put themselves in
1:42:09your shoes they can't they think that you know that they have to think that
1:42:13everything you do is sort of machiavellian and and it made to
1:42:17maximize your profit or there is a conspiracy theory or you are taking
1:42:22advantage of your position of privilege to screw other people like it had no
1:42:26thought the people who bought your application or you all you care about
1:42:28your feelings and so on and so forth like I get that I see I see that play
1:42:33out in this is a perfect a perfect little crucible for that to play out
1:42:38because it is legitimate mistake but it's a small mistake in terms of like
1:42:43impact on an individual right it's $3 like I don't get involved like you know
1:42:47they are you people are angry feel free to being a minor way but some people
1:42:52just so angry that it is and you would like for closed on their house in
1:42:56Clifton hey guys I got some guy threatened to sue me that was
1:43:03interesting to see how much lawyers charge that's more than three hours it
1:43:07thank ya know but like seriously I one of the lessons i'm taking away from this
1:43:11besides the
1:43:12previously expressed lessons about reconsidering what the heck I'm doing
1:43:16before I do it whether I want to be in the business of trying to be in it like
1:43:21it's a great concern like what if this succeeds like that's that's obviously
1:43:25the number one lesson that I have learned from this but down the list
1:43:29somewhere one of the additional lessons I learned from this do I really want to
1:43:34be allowing people to hold me hostage over $3 because that's the attitude is
1:43:43that there's a there's a psychological thing I probably heard about it from
1:43:46Merlin Merlin my psychology news but there's some kind of thing really people
1:43:50are are way way more reactive and feel way worse about about a loss of feeling
1:43:58like they they had taken from them then a missed games so if you said like you
1:44:05know i neva $3 oh no not you know that they don't feel as bad about that as if
1:44:09you take $3 from them something something like that of a premium if they
1:44:15had lost a version that you can just go to 200 studies trying to put you on
1:44:23Compal situations and saying hi to people felt really bad about the
1:44:26negative thing but not so bad about be lack of the positive thing to be
1:44:31homemakers you right there you go
1:44:32so everybody wants to read the correct version of the things about you but
1:44:37right now i i give people opportunities like that we're like by putting this out
1:44:41there I said please give me three dollars and in Sheen's you will get this
1:44:48app and of course than most people
1:44:49implicitly assume that you will therefore have this at be free and
1:44:53updated river as you give me that $3 an end so that's why they they got so angry
1:44:57when I pulled it two days later they don't perceive that I had stolen at
1:45:03three dollars from them the things that were said to me by so many people on
1:45:08Twitter you couldn't pay that person $3 to go tell a stranger that if somebody
1:45:16on the street and was like hey I'll give you $3 if you go over there and tell
1:45:20that person just how I just this horrible thing about themselves I just
1:45:23tell you that you've never gonna love you again like would you do that for $3
1:45:29but people get so into this thing that like they they really it's like they're
1:45:33holding you hostage but their expectations and they they feel they
1:45:37really have this over you that that you know I'm you owe me this massive thing
1:45:42for my three dollars and the fact is I don't think I want to give people access
1:45:47to mice to me that way anymore I don't think I want to give you the chance to
1:45:51hold me hostage for that $3 anymore because you know what I don't want your
1:45:55$3 badly enough it's not worth it so I i'm gonna reconsider things I'm doing
1:46:01with that with that in mind I don't have a plan yet but that that was another bit
1:46:07of perspective I can from this that you know what if that's how you're going to
1:46:12treat your money then I don't want it
1:46:16the amount of just unbelievable bitterness over this $3 I i remained
1:46:23stunned and I find it kind of comical because I think to myself I go to the in
1:46:29this is just an example but I go to football games at my wife alma mater the
1:46:34University of Virginia know what you mean soccer or football no football like
1:46:38the one that is actually fun to watch
1:46:42finally you're taking a position now don't email me I know that american
1:46:48football is much lower it was just a joke everybody calm down anyway the
1:46:51point of driving it is I go to these football games and a soda at these
1:46:57football games as I believe three or four dollars a bottle of water I'm
1:47:02pretty sure see the 250 or $3 that's a bottle of water but it doesn't matter
1:47:07it's a whole different context whole different context it's just ridiculous
1:47:10to me like it but it is and you're right but it's $3 for a bottle of water that
1:47:16I'm literally away in an hour literally and these people like some of these
1:47:21replies that you got just unbelievably disproportionately and I think that's
1:47:27the real crux of it here
1:47:29disproportionately angry over the money not all of them in John went over a lot
1:47:33of this before and he's right but some of them are disproportionately angry
1:47:37about $3 and so
1:47:38my first thought was ok was there was a time when I had no freakin money just
1:47:42non we're going to McDonalds in getting myself like a Big Mac was a special
1:47:47treat and yes I know that's terrible for me but I don't need to hear about it at
1:47:51the time going McDonalds and getting myself a Big Mac was a special treat and
1:47:54I only allowed myself that once a month or once a week at most and i genuinely
1:47:59had to think about whether that's seven dollars whatever was was worth spending
1:48:02and even then I don't think I would have gotten this upset over $3 loss which
1:48:08ends up as it turns out not being lost and I think John really hit the nail on
1:48:12the head
1:48:13earlier when he said people just don't have enough empathy and these people
1:48:19seem to think that you mark over this infallible person that never makes a
1:48:23mistake in its bowl if you if that's just completely wrong that you might
1:48:28have made a mistake and clearly I mean you are infallible so this must be a
1:48:31money grab this is this is insane
1:48:34there's no other explanation and just people need to relax understand that
1:48:38people make mistakes and $3 probably isn't going to be the end of the earth
1:48:45on your $800 iPhone but they have the wider context the people who most me
1:48:49know the context they know a lot of copies of assault they know that the
1:48:53total amount is much more than their $3 and what they're really angry about is
1:48:56this guy who doesn't need my is much as them is getting a bunch of extra money
1:48:59and that makes them have less empathy for Marcos not as if they do write him
1:49:02off slow because I had everybody was richer than me know i'm saying is it for
1:49:06the people who are angry it lessens their ability to empathize because they
1:49:09feel like this very good thing is happening tomorrow go and just minor bad
1:49:16things happening to me but to smile about things like Steve Jobs like one
1:49:19second off the boot time this computer
1:49:22millions of people uses computer you're saving millions of seconds every time
1:49:25people booed up like it's it's you know at scale and they do the scale like him
1:49:28i three dollars in a big deal but he still three dollars from thousands and
1:49:32thousands of people he's basically a thief and this guy doesn't even need the
1:49:36money and it makes me even more angry and to some degree that's how I like
1:49:39people feel that all businesses everyone has seen the person is angry at the
1:49:43person serving them coffee at a coffee shop
1:49:45you know or at a store or whatever and they're out like a dollar fifty or
1:49:50whatever because they wouldn't accept that return because he was like all
1:49:52sales final like a stick of gum or something like you know what I'm never
1:49:56coming to this coffee shop again and whether that's true or not like they're
1:49:59willing to say you know this entire business you know you this is not
1:50:04ethical business you should have let me return the sticking gum like it's the
1:50:08principle it's not the dollar 50 at the principle that UN on ethical business
1:50:11and I'm never going to you know that's that's the power of the heavy the
1:50:14consumer in the hole you know customers always right thing we've all seen people
1:50:17get angry about that and in that case it's like the poor cashier is like you
1:50:21know just trying to do the job that owned the place or whatever someone who
1:50:26looks like they don't control the policies of the store they're just
1:50:30trying to do their job they get yelled at for the most part those businesses
1:50:33are like faces entities that people can be indignant angry about you know I'm
1:50:38just thinking like airlines where there's no more legitimate reasons to be
1:50:41angry like I've been delayed today for my destination and you know like I got a
1:50:46ticket on this flight but now you know oversold it and I have to check my back
1:50:50like whatever being mad businesses just on the murder case that he is the
1:50:55business it's a one-man business is the public face and it's not just like he's
1:50:59not wrong mcdonnell he is the actual he's not just a figurehead he actually
1:51:03does all the pushing buttons and key parts two and so it it's a bummer for
1:51:09Barco but like that that attitude is not unique to Marco it but it's exactly the
1:51:14same thing in the way that would people are really angry at the place wouldn't
1:51:17accept a return to the starting gun they're not thinking about the stores
1:51:21feelings because the store is the man and you know it's like the big faceless
1:51:25entity and may as well be the government Marco is the man in the bad way
1:51:30bad and so they like the man is sticking to me the man is taken three dollars and
1:51:35thousands of people and the man is you know screw us all over and so it's easy
1:51:40to get a self-righteous and indignant and angry at the man
1:51:43you don't spend a lot of time empathizing with the man and saying how
1:51:47does a man feel man said the demanding a mistake and now he has to do the you
1:51:55know something that he knows gonna make people even more angry at me like I'm
1:51:58sorry that's the divide some people are able to empathize and understand some
1:52:03people mistakenly thought the marcos now again that blocking and some people were
1:52:07more or less able to empathize and we're super angry about it and I think this
1:52:11all this will pass we covered all the positive negative income from it we all
1:52:17make mistakes it's a bummer we do it we can hopefully we'll all learn from this
1:52:23we can learn by proxy by Mark for Marcus mistakes marker can learn from his
1:52:27mistakes and we can all move forward together and finally get overcast 2.0
1:52:31out with you ever stop loving pockets microphones this is a really good
1:52:36actually tonight they said her three sponsors this week Squarespace igloo and
1:52:39Mallory out and we will see you next week
1:52:45now the show they didn't even mean to begin was accidental
1:52:52accidental
1:52:55it was accidental
1:53:02shown to be a team are cool
1:53:43got the most important question are you going to make a peace fracture know yet
1:53:50a lot of people have asked this no I don't think I'm a planning to wear now I
1:53:56mean maybe in the future once it hurts less but right now it's it's too painful
1:53:59I can't do it what you should do is order the fracture suffered and throw it
1:54:03away