0:00:00Here's the most disappointing part of the show. I'm so appreciative of you taking time in the
0:00:05holiday season to do the show that I was going to get you a gift but the gift I was going to get you
0:00:12was a new series 9 apple watch. Someone just said today in a slack they went to the apple store and
0:00:19bought one. I guess you can get them in the brick and mortar retail stores. So that
0:00:29I do want to talk about it because I think there is some poetic justice here right with the
0:00:35and it's a perennial topic with you guys on ATP about your unanimous dislike of the US patent
0:00:45system and long whatever the situation here is between apple and Massimo. I don't know how do
0:00:52you think it's pronounced Massimo Massimo. Ultimately it comes down to patents right. It's
0:01:00that Massimo has patents apples filed counter patents they both claim each other's products
0:01:05are violating each other's patents and the international trade commission I forget what
0:01:11ITC stands for has this whole injunction against apple selling apple watches in the US is about
0:01:19a ruling that says yes you're violating Massimo's patent or patents and therefore the apple watch is
0:01:27off the market and you can't I sympathize with anybody who still wants to buy an apple watch and
0:01:37isn't going to be able to if this holds through Christmas and I wrote on my website today.
0:01:43Overall it seems like well it's okay because they got the warning out so people could
0:01:48people who were going to do a last minute watch gift that wasn't a joke like the one I was going
0:01:53to buy for you had time to get one you could still go into the retail store and get one
0:01:59but the after Christmas thing is real right like people who got silver but wanted midnight or
0:02:06I guess you could even exchange sizes right if you pay the difference or I you know depending on the
0:02:11size you might get money back if you got gifted a 44 millimeter and you wanted 41 you could do that
0:02:19none of that's going to be possible and the big one to me is the gift money right and gift
0:02:23certificates right everybody so anybody who is like just give me a gift certificate and I'll go
0:02:29to the apple store after Christmas and buy myself an apple watch well you may not yeah plus all the
0:02:36repairs like all the models that have the blood oxygenation uh sets around them that people
0:02:41already have if they break them they don't repair apple watches they give you a new one but they
0:02:45can't give you a new one if they don't have a new one to give you and you're like well it's I've got
0:02:48apple care and it's under warranty you're supposed to replace it yeah we don't have it yeah and that's
0:02:53another thing that's sort of coming back to bite apple like the basically unrepairability of apple
0:03:01watches yeah and I maybe I don't who knows what they do with them but basically as far as I know
0:03:07if you have any sort of physical problem with an apple watch they just take it in the back and then
0:03:13come out with a different watch and give it to you and I guess it's supposed to match but I think
0:03:19if you have an a still under warranty series eight and it breaks in a way that's covered by the
0:03:27warranty or apple care and you take it in the store they just give you a series nine now I think
0:03:32yeah yeah that's that but these are doing with max back in the day if you had a really old mac
0:03:36and it was something was wrong with it and they couldn't repair it or they tried to repair it and
0:03:40messed it up they'd give you a new one I think that happens to some people in my family a couple
0:03:42times that's always an exciting surprise you're sad that your computer's broken you're excited
0:03:46to get a better computer yeah so in some ways for a customer that's great as a ecological thing I
0:03:55mean I don't know I don't know what they do with those watches I presume if possible they ship them
0:04:00somewhere and if they can be repaired they do that's what refurb apple watches are is ones that
0:04:07were taken in the store and they can't fix them in the store they ship them off to someone yeah it's
0:04:14not can't it's how much would you have to pay someone of what level of skill for how much amount
0:04:19of time to fix it and then how much money you're going to make selling the refurb you know what I
0:04:22mean because I don't doubt that someone very skilled could make repairs on these things but
0:04:27they're so small and so delicate you have to be so careful and it's just it's a skilled job and you
0:04:31have to pay that person for the 15-20 minutes one hour two hours they spend and maybe you've just
0:04:37burned all your profitability on that so I think giving it to the recycling robot that yanks all
0:04:40the metals and everything might be better I guess I don't know and I also think it's a function of
0:04:46how they're put together I and I know that over the years there have been iFixit I guess is the
0:04:53premier gadfly publicly badgering apple over the repairability of iPhones but there are the iPhones
0:05:04are fundamentally held together by screws that you can unscrew and take it apart and there is
0:05:09glue involved and whenever there's glue it it gets messy I guess a huge issue with repaired iPhones
0:05:16is to restore them to the same level of water and dust resistance not just oh it looks like
0:05:22it's repaired but it actually yes you can still dunk it in a pool or whatever and it's safe but
0:05:27the watch is there's no screws it's all glued together I mean yeah it's the same problem and
0:05:33everything is smaller on the watch of course every little bit and piece in there is smaller the watch
0:05:37itself is smaller there's not a lot of margin for error yeah so how do you how what was your guess
0:05:43as this do you I mean and who knows we're recording this on December 22nd it'll be out
0:05:49before Christmas so it'll be out but the show will be out before the deadline who knows by the time
0:05:54the show's out there might be some resolution to this it feels like something that could be resolved
0:05:58at any second right like it I mean it could have been resolved at any point in the past it's just
0:06:03there was not a meeting of the minds in terms of how much money is going to exchange hands here and
0:06:08they're playing a game of chicken and I feel like apple has sort of lost this round but it it's I've
0:06:15always said I want to talk about atp I can't imagine that apple is going to allow themselves
0:06:20not to be able to sell this watch for a long period of time so at a certain point in the semi
0:06:25near future apple will make something happen that makes this go away yeah the other thing too is
0:06:33german has reported and this seems like an obvious solution it's whether it would actually comply
0:06:41legally I don't know but the idea of a software update that would disable the blood oximeter
0:06:49sensors I guess only in the us I mean it wouldn't make sense I mean as usual masimo doesn't think
0:06:56it's possible to do that apple thinks we can make a software update and we won't violate your
0:06:59patents and masimo's no you'll totally still violate them and how will they settle that
0:07:03disagreement courts lawyers blah it's just it could go on for a while especially if they
0:07:09continue to have a disagreement about remedies and the only way to settle those is with further
0:07:13court cases so I'm not quite sure how a software update would take time though because it's well
0:07:19they have to figure out a way to do it do we have a way to change the software such that our lawyers
0:07:24here at apple think that we technically are not violating the patent anymore well but you know
0:07:29that all of the sensors or at least all the new ones as they get added are gated by country
0:07:36because whenever they say hey this year's new apple watch has this new sensor like three years
0:07:41ago when it was the blood oxygen readings it'll and then there's then you get to the part of the
0:07:46keynote where it's like available in the us and canada and more countries to come later because
0:07:51there's surely a nightmare of country by country bureaucracy to get these things legally allowed
0:07:59even if they're not deemed medical class devices or whatever all of those sensors always seem to
0:08:04roll out country by country I would think I guess it's not as simple as just saying take the us off
0:08:11the list and now if you're in the us you don't get blood oxygen readings oh no I was well the software
0:08:17update I'm thinking that I think apple wants to do is we still take blood oxygen readings we just
0:08:22do it in a way that isn't exactly like that it says in the past that's the whole point that
0:08:27masamo says no you have to make hardware changes like it's just it's part of the stupidity of
0:08:32patents right they didn't patent the idea of a watch that gets your blood oxygen level they
0:08:37patented some specific aspects of it and if they can accomplish that if apple can find a way to
0:08:42accomplish that task to give you a reading but doing it differently enough that it doesn't
0:08:46violate their patent then they're in the clear but masamo's like actually there's no way you can
0:08:50do that with you can't just make a software app to do that we think you have to actually make
0:08:54hardware changes but you're never going to do so please pay us some money and we'll figure it out
0:08:59right because and I don't and I don't really feel like wading into the details and I can't I have
0:09:04you ever I mean I'm sure you have because I know you're a critic of them but patent filings are
0:09:08like the most obtuse purposely so I don't I'm not sure I've ever read a patent filing that was
0:09:14cogent to a lay person maybe amazon's one click patent or maybe I'm just misremembering that there
0:09:22was always sort of a lay person's explanation with it and the actual patent filing is just as obtuse
0:09:29as everybody else it's got to be like this is a perfect job for chat gpt you feed in patentees
0:09:34and it translates it to english and some embodiments the blah blah blah and it's just
0:09:37find these phrases and translate them to the lay person's understanding and then at least you can
0:09:42read it without your eyes glazing over yeah overall I am surprised that apple did not resolve this
0:09:48beforehand it must be a mountain of money that masamo is asking for part of it is we've all noted
0:09:56the fairly favorable to apple timing of all this where it's like the sales shut off just as
0:10:01christmas arrives so you still get your haul your holiday sales and maybe they were just like look
0:10:05let's play this game of chicken let's run it out if we have to pull them we'll pull them and then
0:10:09in january we'll come back to the table and dump a dump truck of money onto masamo and make this go
0:10:14yeah apple rolled this out in an unusual way too seemingly only with once with a a statement given
0:10:23only to one outlet chance miller at nine to five mac which you know kudos to chance who i just met
0:10:32uh i think the iphone event for the video i mean so first of all the content of it was just a
0:10:37let's play the refs right it was a playing the refs letter right and the fact that it was sent to
0:10:42by media standards an obscure outlet we don't it's not obscure to us but in the rest of the world
0:10:47they have no idea what it is is a way of playing the refs while also not you don't give it to new
0:10:52york times or wall street journal right and so it's just kind of like one of their essentially
0:10:57their last move that they have hey biden maybe give us a break here but only released to nine
0:11:02to five mac and so we'll all talk about it in the apple technosphere and new york times wall street
0:11:06journal are all they're all on vacation right all right well and i guess the calculus is not just
0:11:12it's it's some kind of mix of wanting to get word out so that last minute shoppers stop waiting right
0:11:19and if you wanted to order online you had a couple days to do it before they cut you off now you know
0:11:24you can do this uh one of the odd things and again lawyers right who knows but german reported that
0:11:31apple store retail and store employees have been told that they can't tell customers that they can
0:11:38go buy them at target and best buy and everywhere else that'll still have them in well if you're in
0:11:43charge of apple stores especially if you're not an apple person but you're just a retail like i'm i
0:11:49run retail stores of course you're going to tell your employees that yeah i wonder if that's the
0:11:54lawyers or the people who run the stores and they're like no we i don't care it's not actually
0:11:59like we're legally bound not yeah you don't tell the same reason they don't i mean we talked about
0:12:05this in atp recently that the price match thing that apple stores do that they will essentially
0:12:09match the price of any other authorized app dealer but they don't advertise that because that would
0:12:13be admitting there are other places you can buy apple products or every single time you buy
0:12:16anything major at an apple store if they told you hey just go over there look there's a macbook air
0:12:22that's available see if you can hunt for a discount on this device that you're buying
0:12:26and then come back here we'll give you the money and then we'll come back here no they don't they
0:12:31don't encourage that yeah i don't know it's such a weird story and it's just i i have the most
0:12:38sympathy for anybody who's going to get caught up at this after christmas who wants to exchange or
0:12:44use a gift card or something like that i wonder how many people who otherwise were going to get
0:12:50a series 9 watch are now going to get stuck with a se which isn't the worst it's a fine apple watch
0:12:57but it's obviously the worst one i don't know it what a fun time to be a top level executive at
0:13:05apple during the christmas week ruin your holidays i mean i do wonder how much of this is they have
0:13:10they had a plan that was sketched out by the beginning of this and said here's the steps
0:13:13we're going to go through and they're just running the plan right and part of the plan is we make our
0:13:18last ditch uh plea to biden if it doesn't work we go on vacation we come back we finally settle this
0:13:24again who knows biden could settle it i don't think that's going to happen
0:13:27apple could tim cook could obviously like you always say there's just keep adding zeros to the
0:13:32check and eventually masamo is going to be okay i don't know if there might be a number that is
0:13:37so high that even just at a bean counting level they're like this isn't actually worth it this is
0:13:42a major product of ours yeah we'll just pull the feature right apple always has that option of say
0:13:47you know what we we tried to roll out this feature in our apple watches but the the people who
0:13:52apparently control the only way to do this in the same manner will not accept a reasonable amount
0:13:56of money so now apple watches cannot tell you your blood oxygenation anymore which is crappy
0:14:01but it's who's more stubborn right who is more who feels more righteous and who can afford to be more
0:14:06righteous and stubborn is masamo a public company that's another question yeah i don't know does it
0:14:10matter anyway if they're a public company they will have similar pressures to apple and okay
0:14:15well you can feel aggrieved and ask for a really big number but a certain point take the number
0:14:19apple is offering you yeah so we shall see all right i'm going to take a break here while we have
0:14:24a good segue and i'm going to thank our first sponsor it's our good friends at trade coffee
0:14:30now look this is a possible last minute gift now this is going to be a last minute episode before
0:14:36the christmas holiday but if you're listening to this and you still need a gift let's say you're
0:14:41driving to somebody's house christmas morning and you're entertaining your family in the car
0:14:45with the dulcet tones of the two johns and family fun for everybody but there's somebody in your
0:14:52family who you haven't bought a gift for yet or maybe you feel like you you've under gifted them
0:14:56so far you can get them a trade coffee subscription right now just as casey always says when they're
0:15:02ordering atp stuff just pull your car over on the way to the family get together and sign up for a
0:15:08trade coffee subscription for that coffee lover on your list it's a pretty good gift what trade is is
0:15:15a subscription service that sources the best coffee around the country and they deliver it
0:15:20right to your doorstep they've got relationships with over 55 local roasters so it's not like trade
0:15:28is some big factory that's roasting all this coffee and sitting out trade sort of a middleman
0:15:33a service that sits above truly local really boutique local coffee roasters all around the
0:15:39country with all sorts of varieties i mean 55 roasters hundreds of varieties of coffee but they
0:15:45make it really easy and convenient to discover and find the sort of coffee that you like couple
0:15:50of questions to start then your subscription starts coming in you say maybe you want it every
0:15:55week every two weeks however often you want it you can configure that and then after you get the
0:16:00coffee you give it like a thumbs up or a thumbs down on the website and then they use that to
0:16:05steer the coffee that they send you in the future does not take long in my experience for them to
0:16:11dial in on the sort of coffee that i like i've been subscribed now over a year it is terrific
0:16:16coffee uh our mutual friend marco arment says and i've been to his house he has trade coffee i can
0:16:23verify that he likes it he used to roast his own coffee he was such a nut and now he doesn't
0:16:28it is a great service super convenient super good coffee and you're helping local roasters all around
0:16:34the country it's just great it's a great gift it's a great thing for you if you're a coffee lover and
0:16:39you just get it right in your house give the gift a better coffee at home from now through december
0:16:4425th trade is offering 15 off all gift subscriptions at drinktrade.com the talk show
0:16:52get it now if you want it as a gift drinktrade.com the talk show shop now through christmas day to
0:16:59save that's drinktrade.com the talk show for 15 off all gift subscriptions through christmas day
0:17:07drinktrade.com the talk show and if it's after christmas day get it for yourself
0:17:13not to ruin your segue but before i moved on from the uh patent thing i think i've never really heard
0:17:18your opinion on patents what do you think about patents as a concept i guess i've lived my whole
0:17:24life so i i've never worked at a big company and so it's never really entered into it i think the
0:17:31idea when the country was founded in the 18th century was probably pretty good and when you
0:17:40read like the history of patents and the way they used to work i think it was a pretty good idea
0:17:46and 250 years later i think it's a mess i i think that they only benefit the biggest companies well
0:17:57setting aside how it's implemented like the patent system the the concept that if you come up with an
0:18:01idea there should be some period of times that you legally have the exclusive rights to that idea i
0:18:07think that's okay but i think that computers in i i think in general going back to the late 1700s
0:18:14or the 19th century when things were mechanical devices if it was clever then i think a period
0:18:20of exclusivity i i'm not offended by that it's hard because i i fundamentally believe in the
0:18:26basic idea i think it was derek sivers i'll put a link to it many people have espoused the same idea
0:18:31but that ideas are only a multiplier on execution right it's the idea is worth nothing by itself
0:18:40a good idea multiplied by zero execution anything times zero is still zero right but if you came up
0:18:45with the idea suddenly now you have the ability to stop anyone else from doing it unless they pay you
0:18:50so kind of it all of a sudden the idea now has value because the government says it has value
0:18:55so you don't even need to execute the idea yourself at all you just need to have the idea and then
0:19:00find somebody else who's executing that idea and make them pay you because you have the exclusive
0:19:04rights to that idea because you filed a patent before they did yeah i think on the whole it's
0:19:09been a net negative because it's supposed to promote innovation and i think it only hinders it
0:19:14and i think that's it sounds like a great system but in practice it is it's hard to defend it i i
0:19:21think it's a disaster but it's also hard to see a way out of it yeah i mean we used to back in the
0:19:25day when we used to talk about this there was a big deal i guess in the 90s on the internet where
0:19:29people were real angry about software patents right because we were talking about how can you
0:19:33patent software and what is software or whatever but that conversation was so focused on software
0:19:38and the patent system and this new thing and never really no one ever wanted to revisit the idea yeah
0:19:43but what about patents in general right right because we have this idea in our head of you're
0:19:47going to invent the cotton gin right and you're going you're a genius inventor it's like it's part
0:19:50of our ethos the american dream of come up with an idea you build a better mousetrap you patent it
0:19:55and that's how you become rich and it seems just and fair because you came up with a good idea
0:20:00therefore you should be rich and but that idealized version of patents people seem to be on
0:20:06board with mostly because they haven't really thought about the consequences of it setting aside
0:20:09does that ever happen in real life because of the patent system i mean as i've said many times and
0:20:13i'm on the extreme end of this which is i don't think anything should be patentable ever for any
0:20:17reason and that there is no way that this should work and i don't think you should for all the
0:20:21reasons you just said like the idea is worth nothing it should not be there should not be a law
0:20:25that something makes the idea more valuable than it actually is what you get out of having an idea
0:20:29before somebody else is you get to make your product before somebody else you get to bring
0:20:32it to market before somebody else you do get advantages but you don't get a 20-year monopoly
0:20:36on that idea and that's before you start considering okay but what about the really bad
0:20:41patents what about software patents i'm talking about baseline level patents but you know yeah
0:20:45that's the type of thing that is so against the the popular notion of patents that it will probably
0:20:51never get any traction right and the entrenched incumbents have so much at stake that it's hard
0:20:59to see any sort of let's abolish the patent system getting any traction at all i don't i mean i don't
0:21:06think that's what would stop it i think the big established companies are so weary of this because
0:21:10it is essentially a tax on all of their operations right and like they build these patent portfolios
0:21:16as a defensive mechanism it's mutually assured destruction i have a bunch of patents you have
0:21:19a bunch of patents let's do patent cross licensing don't you sue me because i'll sue you because i
0:21:23have patents on the most ridiculous things you can imagine but in the end i think if you get them all
0:21:28the biggest companies in the in the world together and said what do you think abolish patents there'd
0:21:32be one or two annoying people who say no but a lot of them would be like boy that would just make all
0:21:36of our lives so much easier i mean maybe i'm being naive in that way but it just seems like everybody
0:21:40is weary of it maybe i mean it it's but we can't even get rid of the penny john i know i'm saying
0:21:48like yes america so yeah i'll send you some links for the show notes for this in case people want to
0:21:52dig into this further my past couple of podcasts about this or my remember i did a couple hyper
0:21:58three hypercritical podcasts about patents i do i do it was way back in the day and that that was
0:22:03linking to a document by uh david k levine and michelle boldren it was called against intellectual
0:22:09monopoly that tries to make the case that i've just alluded to which is that you should have
0:22:13government mandated 20-year exclusive rights to an idea what do you think i guess one of the areas
0:22:20where these things often come up is pharmaceuticals right and the idea is that merc or name your
0:22:28favorite merc's local here in philly or at least part of the conglomerates local here but big giant
0:22:34pharmaceuticals spends billions of dollars to create test authorize a new drug and then they
0:22:43hold a patent for it for 20 years and until then they're the only ones who can make this drug on
0:22:50the one hand i can see the argument in favor of the patent system there that they need to recoup
0:22:57these enormous costs and there's no no other way to bring a major drug to market than to spend this
0:23:05money and if there were no patent protection for the drug then there'd be no reason to spend the
0:23:11billions of dollars to create the drugs you know that i i there's seemingly some truth to that
0:23:17right but then on the other hand you're talking about things that save people's lives right and
0:23:24what you're getting at is obvious people do worry about that because they can't see past the system
0:23:27that we have but what you're getting at is well but should health care be a thing that is a profit
0:23:32center and are there any negative consequences to health care being a for-profit industry and that's
0:23:37even setting aside okay but how does it really work how it really works is these pharmaceutical
0:23:41companies get billions of dollars for the u.s government to develop a like let's say a covid
0:23:45vaccine and they develop it and then they get to sell it and make all the money and they jack up
0:23:50the price to insane levels and that just brings you right back around to the idea of should health
0:23:54care be a profit center i mean this against intellectual monopoly does talk about these
0:23:58things and as i talked about in the past i fully believe that it is entirely possible for human
0:24:02beings to come up with medicines without the patent system but it can't just be everything
0:24:07exactly the same as it is now but then remove patents because obviously that wouldn't work
0:24:11right but i am also against the idea of of health care being a for-profit enterprise because we see
0:24:17how that works in this country we see how you know when someone has a monopoly on something how they
0:24:22price gouge and how they don't care that they got billions of dollars for the government so they
0:24:25don't act out of the goodness of their heart to distribute a few small people do like the person
0:24:29who like gave away the patents for insulin and stuff like that but fast forward 2050 years and
0:24:34a less scrupulous people come in and it's just bad for everybody i think the motivation to find life
0:24:39saving drugs is that we're all human beings and we want them to exist and we should form a society
0:24:44and government that allows that to happen in a way that doesn't just enrich a small number of people
0:24:48but you know we are far from that as well right and the whole to me that the pharmaceutical
0:24:54industry's sort of argument in favor of the patent system the hey should this be a profitable a
0:25:02business that's for profit is above that right it's a higher level than that and there's no
0:25:07better there's no better example than insulin which is no longer covered by patents or maybe
0:25:11never was i don't know if that actually the person gave it away like the person came up with it said
0:25:15i'm giving this patent away for everybody because it's you know i don't want i don't want this to be
0:25:19a thing that somebody makes money from well then it's a perfect example because we're still fighting
0:25:23over grossly inflated prices for insulin today right i mean that's what because when someone
0:25:29needs something to live it turns out you can charge them as much money as they have for it
0:25:32and if they're not giving you the money you can get the money from the insurance companies and
0:25:36then you make sure the government can't negotiate drug prices for those insurance companies either
0:25:39and it's just it's not a great system i don't know if you know that no it is it's heartbreaking
0:25:44it is absolutely heartbreaking that there that there's a really serious disease diabetes that
0:25:50has a medicine that really works well and lets people people need to live yeah and they can live
0:25:57really normal great lives with it and that and it's incredibly inexpensive to manufacture
0:26:03incredibly inexpensive right and yet somehow there are families who are have to worry are we
0:26:08going to pay for the food we want or pay for yeah because because the industry is tuned to extract
0:26:14as much money as it can to keep you alive but how much money do you have in your bank account just
0:26:20give us all that can you eat a little less food this month can you move to a smaller apartment
0:26:24because we know you need this to live sorry kids no more netflix yeah people want apple watch
0:26:31series 9 so people need insulin to live yeah it is very different so i overall i'm not as adamant
0:26:38as far out on it as you but i also don't think i've given it as much thought as you and yeah
0:26:43that's the problem with these things people accept the status quo is that's just the way it's always
0:26:46been and it seems reasonable and i've seen a couple tv movies about it and and you know
0:26:50the more you learn about anything like this uh the more complicated it seems but you know if you
0:26:54take small steps in the right direction uh it's the best we can do yeah you brought it up on either
0:27:00the most recent atp or the second most recent because it was also in the context of this
0:27:04masa mo apple watch fiasco and ben and i brought it up on dithering but like you brought up like
0:27:12the sort of eli whitney who invented the cotton gin yeah yeah or edison or any of these prototypical
0:27:20storybook inventors who like with the view of hindsight we know that even the stories that we
0:27:26hear about them are obviously not going to be completely accurate right but the edison of our
0:27:31times steve jobs obviously was very pro patent and it was part of his nature i mean he wore it
0:27:39on his shirt sleeve that when his companies had a breakthrough and he knew it was a breakthrough like
0:27:49he just knew it it's like darth vader looking at the screen when they were showing the base on hoth
0:27:53that's it you know that i know it that's it don't give me any shit take the whole fleet of star
0:27:58destroyers there that's where they are when they had the iphone he knew it he knew they had magic
0:28:05in a bottle and he like literally said in the keynote and something to the effect of boy we
0:28:10patented boy did we patented and the audience laughed because they were you know everybody's
0:28:15it was like going into conniptions because of this thing that we couldn't believe was possible
0:28:20was being unveiled to us and i think his whole career was sort of based on that and that whole
0:28:26it's almost sad to think of how many how much time of the last few years of his life he spent
0:28:32burned up over google stealing what he thought were patentable ideas from the iphone you know
0:28:40it's very very very kind of like childlike notion of things like that yes you go to xerox park learn
0:28:46about the gooey come back to apple make a gooey and think now this is my idea and anyone else who
0:28:49makes a gooey they're stealing from us and it's like well what about you what you did xerox but
0:28:53there's who was bad and ours is good and they're copying the good one and they invited us in right
0:28:59anything like that like where did multi-touch come from yes he was not shy about saying when we make
0:29:04something it's almost here's the thing i think in his mind it's rude for people to try to make
0:29:09another phone that works like the iphone it's just not quite it's rude like no you shouldn't do that
0:29:13and once you do that you're downgraded his book is bad manners right and it's just a very naive
0:29:18view of the world but he just really like this we deserve this he was he would be very gung-ho and
0:29:23he loves the patents and was like we came up with this idea it's ours no one can copy it and
0:29:27the sad fact is they totally can copy it and they can find a way to copy it without technically
0:29:31violating your patents and if you try to fight them out it'll just burn up time and money it's
0:29:34a waste of everyone's time like the look and feel lawsuit that no one remembers anymore it's just
0:29:38it's a it's a tar pit for everybody involved but his sense of justice is once i've done something
0:29:43and i do the good one no one should have the nerve to copy us and that's not way the market works nor
0:29:49should it be it is some sort of innate sense of justice that i think is at least in in jobs was
0:29:56misguided yeah it's like a toddler's innate sense of justice little kids have the same sense of
0:30:00justice that is just they think that things should be the way they are and it's not really a real
0:30:04sense of justice yeah but i wonder how many people you know i don't think it's most people people who
0:30:09work at apple i know many people who work at apple and i guess it's the nature of your and my
0:30:14both our personalities and our work what we're known for what's gotten us introduced to people
0:30:21at apple i don't know anybody at apple who would brag about patents and i know people who have
0:30:26either are still at apple or were at apple who have their name on patents but they're never they
0:30:32never like brag about it but then i'm sure they exist there are some people i mean well and the
0:30:36thing is it's not like you should be ashamed of having a patent you should be proud for the work
0:30:41that is represented by that patent because you did a thing and figured out a thing that's an
0:30:45accomplishment and having a patent as much as i think they shouldn't exist if it's a reasonable
0:30:50good patent and not something really stupid it is like an artifact of the work that you did and so
0:30:56i can imagine being proud of that but i think the more contact people have with the patent system
0:31:01the less proud they'll be of that particular artifact they still like we came up with this
0:31:05clever idea we did this good thing and we think we're smart and we're proud of our work but the
0:31:09patent i think the more you learn about it you're like and yeah i also have a bunch of patents but
0:31:13a they belong to apple not you really and b you're just like it's kind of like starting to
0:31:18be ashamed that you want to test the car didn't change it's the same car it always was but ancillary
0:31:22factors that you now know make you feel differently about it i think as you learn about the patent
0:31:26system the pride and the patent specifically reduces even if you are still proud of the work
0:31:31it embodies yeah well on that is i i send a link in the our chat there i'll put i will put it in
0:31:38the show notes but it's one of my favorite personal home pages i've ever seen in my life
0:31:42imron chaudhry yeah famously humble yeah very humble he's the co-founder of humane the makers
0:31:50of the now available for pre-order coming in march supposedly ai pin imron chaudhry.com and his entire
0:32:00home page it is very attractive very minimal it's a white page with black low contrast light gray
0:32:06text on a white background very apple medium gray helvetica very small text on a background and it
0:32:12just says selected patented works volume one 1995 to 2017 and it is a list of i would estimate i
0:32:21don't want to sit here and count uh i would guess this is about 500 patents yeah more than that i
0:32:27would say maybe more than 500 patents and it's just the numbers that's all it is on the page
0:32:32it's just a grid one two three four five six seven i don't know 15 rows a bunch of rows it's like a
0:32:39huge spreadsheet but very pretty of just the patent numbers with a link to the google patent for that
0:32:46patent at least 500 patents that he has his name on and then here's here's the part that makes it
0:32:51my favorite personal home page it's not just that his home page is just a list of patents
0:32:57it's the footnote at the bottom randomly selected us patents only so in other words he's got more
0:33:04he's got more patents and maybe there's other ones in other countries who knows because this is us
0:33:08patents yeah like for a certain kind of person it becomes a way to keep score you know i mean if you
0:33:13decide your value is based on how many patents you file because you think each patent is a beautiful
0:33:17wonderful idea and again we're talking about good patents and bad patents i think all patents are
0:33:21bad but they're still with it within each one you can characterize it for example is this an idea
0:33:25that works you can patent things that don't work right right is this is this a patent for something
0:33:31that is a blindingly obvious and would be invalidated if any company wanted to spend 300
0:33:36grand to invalidate it because apple for example invalidated a bunch of masumos patents because
0:33:40there are tons of patents that are just stupid that could be invalidated but to do so costs
0:33:45money and some companies to be motivated to do that so of all the patents here i wonder what
0:33:50the ratio is of patents that are reasonable ideas patents that are remotely original patents that
0:33:54weren't done years before by other people patents that actually work right it really narrows it down
0:33:59if you have to do it to that filter but to make a home page like this makes you think every one of
0:34:03these is gold i i highly doubt it all right what else is in the news oh the beeper mini the ongoing
0:34:11saga of beeper mini which i think finally i can record a podcast and not be worried
0:34:18that by the time the podcast airs the story will be different i mean i think you're mostly right
0:34:23that the beeper part of it but i think it's gone to phase two now because now phase two is silly
0:34:28government hearings that i think isn't going to last but and i well i don't know because you never
0:34:36know with politicians yeah exactly it's not it's harder to harder to judge that one we could we
0:34:40kind of know how it was going to work out between beeper and apple because that's a fight that we
0:34:43understand but the government thing it's hard to even understand why it is exists other than
0:34:49people want to showboat in front of a committee for a while so they can hopefully help their
0:34:52reelection chances uh so the news is that beeper mini has they think they're the number one they've
0:35:00said we're gonna stop playing cat and mouse after this so we'll see what they said in the statement
0:35:05was paraphrasing we can't play cat and mouse with the biggest company in the world and as i just
0:35:09said on the atp we just recorded yeah everybody knows that so sody it's presumably they knew it
0:35:15too but you did it and pretended it was the thing you were gonna do and you're like you know what
0:35:18we just can't play cat and mouse with a trillion dollar company we know of course you can't i
0:35:24appreciate their fervor even though they are a real company i i mean and i think that eric
0:35:30midget kofsky i hope i'm pronouncing his surname right he's the ceo of beeper he's best known or
0:35:37previously best known as the ceo founder of the pebble smartwatch which was sort of the first
0:35:45it certainly didn't break through to the mainstream but certainly broke through
0:35:49to our audience probably everybody listening remembers the pebble smartwatches that you can
0:35:53get so caught up in the fact that it does work and thinking it does work and it is extraordinarily
0:36:01clever this kid the 16 year old i guess isn't pseudonymous anymore he goes by jj tech on github
0:36:07but he was on cbs news i forget his name but i see clearly this 16 year old kid is super talented and
0:36:14has a bright future ahead of him it's tremendous work to backwards engineer this but what they've
0:36:20been doing is using let me see if i can paraphrase this right basically to be an i message client you
0:36:31need an a registration key that's part of the cryptographic exchange and part of that is
0:36:37verifying that you the client software are running on an actual legit apple device and for the last
0:36:47week or two they've been using a bunch of max servers that beeper owns and runs for their
0:36:53cloud-based messaging service and because there's only so many actual max that they can have and
0:37:00share with hundreds or thousands of beeper users apple's been whack-a-mole them one by one because
0:37:09it looks suspicious if a hundred different iMessage users all are using this the same
0:37:15mac right like maybe you and your your spouse and your kids all have accounts on the same the family
0:37:21iMac and all four or five of you send iMessages from a mac but there's very few families with a
0:37:28500 different iCloud accounts that's why a lot of the coverage of this unfortunately calling it like
0:37:32a hack or whatever makes it sound like they somehow broke the security and are like they're
0:37:36in the system and they're controlling everything when all they're essentially doing is finding
0:37:40various ways to masquerade as a legit device it's not like they have cracked the protocol and now
0:37:44can register any device they want and be totally unseen by apple it wasn't that kind of hack it was
0:37:49simply we've found various ways to masquerade as legit apple devices and those ways are slowly being
0:37:54shut down for the reason you said because once you get more than one or two people using the same
0:37:58device it starts to look hinky yeah so they've updated this now where the android client and i've
0:38:05went through it before we recorded i went through it today and actually ran it the most ludicrous way
0:38:11they have of still using beeper mini on an android device is to either have your own old iphone iphone
0:38:21six seven eight or ten or success right but those eras because i guess there's jail breaks that
0:38:28still work on those phones you need an old iphone iphone 10 or older you need to jailbreak it you
0:38:35need to install some sort of beep serve damon that runs on the iphone and can therefore you know
0:38:44because it's some kind of like server damon it obviously needs the that's why it needs the iphone
0:38:48to be broken and leave the iphone running and connected to wi-fi 24 hours time yeah all the time
0:38:56in other words you need to run a jailbroken iphone as a server in your home and then you get to go out
0:39:01of the house with your android phone and your reward is you get to use iMessage yeah so you
0:39:06could do it that way or if you are a beeper cloud user which is their older desktop thing that has
0:39:14a bunch of things other than iMessage i think it does whatsapp and signal and other things although
0:39:19some of those don't require reverse engineering i think they're open i think that you're sort of
0:39:24allowed to have clients for i'm not sure but if you're there's a wait list for it though because
0:39:29it has this tremendous overhead of them needing to partition an entire server or virtual server
0:39:36for each user or something like that so there's this overhead and so they have a wait list
0:39:40if you're already through the wait list you can run it on you run their other desktop app on your
0:39:47mac and that will generate a code that you can use on your phone and if it's only your phone and your
0:39:55mac using the same code that's not enough that's gonna hopefully probably not enough to for apple
0:40:02to notice i don't know and then the easier way i'm surprised they don't mention it more prominently
0:40:08they have a command line tool they wrote on github it's just a it looks like it's written in go
0:40:13you can download it on github and run it from the terminal on your mac that's what i did and it just
0:40:19generates a code that you can copy and paste into beeper on android and then share this and use it
0:40:25but they also say with that route which you might think well then why would anybody possibly
0:40:30run the jailbroken iphone as a server connected to wi-fi and powered 24 hours a day this other way
0:40:37doesn't let you register a phone number with iMessage so people would have to address you
0:40:43by your iCloud email address and therefore it also requires you to have an iCloud account
0:40:50and you will need to regenerate the key and re-enter it every week every month they don't
0:40:58know it's obviously it as soon as they said that we're not quite sure if you'll have to do it every
0:41:03week or month i thought well this seems like something apple could turn a dial on and make
0:41:08it like every day every 10 minutes and needless to say it's also kind of hard to copy and paste
0:41:13a 16-digit code from mac to android because they don't have continuity it's all forget it i mean at
0:41:20this point i'm not sure how much apple is going to care anymore because i can't imagine how many
0:41:24beeper users there are going to be but they still might continue to turn the screws up on it
0:41:33i that the other aspect you said the legislature so elizabeth warren from your fine state of
0:41:38massachusetts started it with a tweet and then a bipartisan group of senators what's her name from
0:41:44minnesota amy clobichar and mike lee from utah strange bedfellows just i don't know i'm writing
0:41:54about it i don't know if it'll be out tomorrow i have a half-written piece for daring fireball
0:41:59about other stuff but we're all related to beeper but their letter is hey this is anti-competitive
0:42:07and apple's being mean and being anti-competitive and bullying a company and this is why we need
0:42:12to crack down on big tech and to me it just has there's no grounding and it just belies
0:42:18like a complete ignorance on their part of what i message is yeah i mean it's so hard to tell
0:42:23politicians are they it's always the question the cynics dilemma are they ignorant or are they
0:42:27malicious slash devious right because so here's the question right so we talked about we were
0:42:32talking about this whole issue as it's been going on it's so clear that if the idea for your company
0:42:36is to use apple service for free without their permission it's probably not a great business plan
0:42:41there's this black and white that like what they're doing is not the right thing to do probably not
0:42:46legal not a viable business so on and so forth right but the other angle on it that so far i
0:42:51haven't seen anyone actually argue is okay but in certain circumstances when one company has
0:42:57such dominance in a particular area we have decided they are monopoly and in those cases we
0:43:03might decide that this thing is so big and so important and so dominant that they have to allow
0:43:10other people to use it an example might be windows operating system for pcs in the 90s is that the
0:43:16dominant operating system for pcs in fact so dominant that the rules for them should be
0:43:21different and they should not be able to do certain things that that keep competition off
0:43:26of pcs yes like that's the textbook case i remember that when they did the thing in the
0:43:30hearing of like how many people in this room use windows on their pc and they all raise their hands
0:43:33remember that one it was like yeah if you're going to argue in the 90s that the windows is not the
0:43:37dominant operating system to a massive degree not like 60 40 right or 70 30 like it was just
0:43:44they're massively dominant suddenly different rules apply right so in the case of apple like
0:43:50the beeper thing is okay what they're doing is obviously illegal and wrong or whatever but what
0:43:54if iMessage is so dominant that it's we that new rules apply and it's like apple you have to let
0:44:02third parties put their clients on your network because you're so big and so dominant that's what
0:44:08you have government hearings about but i don't hear anybody trying to make the argument that
0:44:13iMessage has been is dominant in the way that windows was as pcs the operating system what
0:44:19planet are you on iMessage is big but it is not 95% worldwide market share for messaging systems
0:44:27about any planet china alone invalidates that idea even within the us they're not that big
0:44:32so if you're going to come from this you can't come at it from saying they're being mean to
0:44:35beeper you have to start from iMessage is a monopoly and it is dangerous for any one company
0:44:41to have that control therefore apple must allow third parties to interface with its instant message
0:44:48network that it runs and if they can successfully make that argument legally within our current
0:44:53monopoly laws then it becomes an entirely different conversation but trying to say they're
0:44:58being mean to a small company you can't start from that first convince me that apple is legally
0:45:03obligated to open iMessage to third parties and then we don't have to talk about beeper because
0:45:09then anybody can make a client for it because now legally they have to let them but that is a
0:45:13difficult case to win and that case is not going to be won by a bunch of senators who either don't
0:45:18understand or pretended not to understand this issue grandstanding while they grill apple employees
0:45:23about stuff yeah you john are way too sensible to be a senator you you have no chance of taking
0:45:30elizabeth warren's seat because i like elizabeth warren usually so i can't my guess is that she
0:45:35actually doesn't understand i don't think so either i think the problem i think what you're
0:45:39describing is based on a fundamental understanding of basically what iMessage is which is a very large
0:45:47maybe not by apple standards but by your my standards or beeper standards extremely expensive
0:45:54hard to run proprietary instant messaging service it's not just a protocol it's not just oh we have
0:46:03a secret or like a file format right people think like when they send a message it goes directly to
0:46:08other people's phone through magic tubes and there's nothing in between they don't see the
0:46:12giant fleet of servers doing a billion requests a second all day every day in giant cooled buildings
0:46:17that apple pays for right i think it's a testimony to how seamless iMessage is right and part of what
0:46:23beeper backwards engineered is the fact that you don't even need an iCloud account to use it when
0:46:30you're on an iPhone right that's the one difference between an iPhone and iPads and Macs that are
0:46:36which are the other devices that can run iMessage i don't think apple watch counts because i don't
0:46:40think you can do it with apple watch without going through the phone i think your watch well i don't
0:46:45know i guess the watches do have their own phone numbers as far as like Verizon is concerned but
0:46:49they they use your phone's number to call them it's right right they don't register as a you
0:46:54can't address my watch's secret you don't even learn your secret phone i think it's just like
0:46:58the account number and Verizon's account system or whatever right but it's so seamless to use
0:47:03iMessage especially when you're using your phone number as your identifier i mean and it's how they
0:47:09bootstrap this network off SMS in 2011 or whenever it was that it launched which always surprises me
0:47:16when i look or did surprise me when i look back on it i thought iMessage came sooner i didn't
0:47:21know because the messages app was part of the iPhone yeah one but it was an SMS app right and
0:47:27it's just hey the messages app will now every time it goes to send an SMS or use it not an SMS
0:47:36message to 212-123-5555 or whatever your phone number is right before it sends it as SMS it'll
0:47:45check with a server say is this phone number registered for iMessage oh it is oh okay i'll
0:47:51render the phone number in blue and i will send it over this other network that apple made not SMS
0:47:58and you getting your number registered on the iPhone as an iMessage user it just happens
0:48:05automatically so you have no password to remember there is no password you don't sign in you just
0:48:09have an iPhone with a phone number which comes from your cellular carrier and you just get
0:48:16iMessage and it will send iMessages to any other phone number that is also registered with iMessage
0:48:23and beeper backwards engineered that it's so seamless though it's so invisible that i really
0:48:29do think most people including Elizabeth Warren including Amy Klobuchar and Mike Lee that they
0:48:36just see it as like you said it just this magic phone-to-phone thing so that when i text you
0:48:42it just bits go off my phone and they go to your phone and they don't imagine that there's this
0:48:49whole complicated infrastructure in between oh actually i mean to give them to be a slightly
0:48:54more charitable the idea is that it is a yet another walled garden that people have it is
0:49:01and then they should all they should all be able to talk to each other and and it seems unfair that
0:49:05there is this one network that is just iPhones talking to each other and whenever they talk to
0:49:10other people it is it is lesser and it's a setting aside obviously you can talk to other people using
0:49:16other you can get whatsapp on your iPhone i swear you can and i Android people can get it on their
0:49:21thing and you can talk to them so it's not even much of a wall it's just like choosing which little
0:49:25playgrounds people are going to be in but the whole idea of technology is i don't care about
0:49:29the technical deals i'm just a senator i think all phones should be able to talk to each other
0:49:34and everything should be interoperable based on standards and it seems like there's something
0:49:38preventing that because it's apple not wanting to play ball and it is it is not much to hang
0:49:43anything on but my most charitable read is they just kind of wish everyone would all get along
0:49:49and they don't want to hear about the technical details and i just it doesn't really make sense
0:49:53to me it's like of all the problems of all technology big technology doing things the
0:49:57inability of android users and iphone users to communicate to each other with their phones is
0:50:02not a problem there is competition in this section in fact apple is losing across most of the world
0:50:06because their message app isn't that great and isn't that popular right and china has one that
0:50:11is essentially government mandated and they have a lot of people and it does a lot of things right
0:50:15europe runs on whatsapp right and then all of europe and then sms is out there that everyone
0:50:21is still using is sort of the lowest common denominator for this type of stuff and that's
0:50:24being heard at rcs which still isn't even as i message which isn't as good as whatsapp which
0:50:29doesn't do half the things that wechat does and then japan's online kids this is not an area where
0:50:34there is the lack of competition is causing innovation to be stifled right it's just but
0:50:39i think they're getting on that bandwagon it's like can we latch on to this as an opportunity
0:50:43to grandstand about big tech not interoperating because there are problems of technology not
0:50:48interoperating for competitive reasons that is worse for consumers but i don't think this is
0:50:52one of them and that's why i think any hearings they have on this are going to be silly and mostly
0:50:56ridiculous and hopefully not go anywhere yeah i will just well and it's you so i'm risking along
0:51:04the side but i would argue against the notion that i message is worse than whatsapp it's better in
0:51:11different ways right there's different priorities and you i hope you'll agree ben and i have always
0:51:16just been it ben thinks i message is trash and whatsapp is well so here i'll say with that i
0:51:22think we can all agree that whatsapp has more features yes right so it's so but that but apple
0:51:26often does that the competitors have more features but apple's things better and i will say uh and on
0:51:30the sort of simplicity and ease of use front the thing that hurts i message is the bugs uh we don't
0:51:36kind of get into a bigger side about software quality but like you mentioned typing in a phone
0:51:39number and having it turn blue how many times have you sent someone an iMessage and for whatever
0:51:46reason it comes out as a green bubble i've been talking to this person at their apple id for six
0:51:50months and you're sending them a green bubble how the hell does that happen i don't know either but
0:51:55it that happens to me less and less but it has happened yeah and that's the thing where if you're
0:51:59going to make a product that's simple and easy to use it should work 100 of the time and bs like that
0:52:03and never setting aside the whole like oh and now you want to try to have a group conversation with
0:52:07some people on sms and some people iMessage and half the messages don't appear and on your mac
0:52:10the conversation is missing some of the messages that's where i'm going to ding apple it's okay
0:52:14it's fine not to have as many features as whatsapp because you have different priorities but make the
0:52:18features you have work i will say like where i think iMessage particularly shines is the the way
0:52:24that it works on non-phone devices iPads and Macs especially for me the Mac because i care more
0:52:30about it or the Mac is a first-class iMessage client and it's a catalyst app well but i think
0:52:36it's a i think it's a better catalyst app i think it's a better mac app than the the the previous
0:52:40mac yeah i just wish all the messages show up there in a timely manner in the correct order
0:52:44all the time well and i wish i wish that it would well i have a lot of complaints i mean it does
0:52:51have a sync button it had the sync button years before the ios version had it that sync button
0:52:55doesn't always do something but i do feel better when i press it well my favorite part about the
0:53:00sync button is once you press it it gets disabled oh yeah it didn't used to do that the old in
0:53:05Sonoma gets disabled in Ventura it wouldn't get disabled you can hit it again it was like that
0:53:09like the closed door button on the elevator to make you feel good it doesn't tell you what it's
0:53:12doing no progress bar no progress bar no spinner not even in the indeterminate there is there is
0:53:18some some very low contrast text at the bottom of the sidebar that says syncing messages from iCloud
0:53:23all right if you can find that and if you can see it with your old eyes it's there but my problem
0:53:28with whatsapp and signal which are the two i'm most familiar with i don't use line or some of
0:53:32the other ones but they're so phone centric that you're always and the way you registered
0:53:38their other clients is always your phone is your main account for signal or whatsapp and then brutal
0:53:43i know signal is rolling out usernames and i know both of us probably use signal for the same reason
0:53:48but i never want to give oh let someone communicate with you on signal that's such i have to give them
0:53:52my real phone number because i use my real phone number with signal see that's why i use a google
0:53:56voice number for signal and i have it i should have done that but it's too late it's too late
0:54:01and it yeah you don't want to give out your phone but they are supposedly rolling out if that if
0:54:04signal continues to exist now that all this government funding has been pulled from them
0:54:08i can't wait until they roll out usernames because i will leap on that in a second right and i don't
0:54:13want to complain about and i know signal takes the sort of privacy part more serious than anybody else
0:54:19including like iMessage especially in terms of being a target like if you're a political dissident
0:54:27or a journalist who takes really sensitive anonymous tips from like government employees
0:54:34or whistleblowers or something and you want the utmost secrecy and privacy of these things that
0:54:42therefore they they don't really have like online backups of like your message history like so for
0:54:47the most part and i know they're working on that but for the most part like give it with whatsapp
0:54:51and signal if you lose your phone you kind of lose your message history and your mac and your ipad are
0:54:56always these sort of satellites to your phone that you register by shining a qr code from your phone
0:55:03to this they don't even they don't even try to say oh we're going to keep all these in sync all
0:55:06the time because doing that would be a security violation because like you're only allowed
0:55:10it's like you get a message in both places if they're both registered at the time the message
0:55:14arrives and i understand like that's a totally different focus right the way iMessage is
0:55:20architected where and again i'm probably like right up there with like an apple employee who
0:55:27tests a bunch of devices because i keep all these old iphones and i have review unit macbooks and
0:55:33stuff so at any given time i'm like logged into iMessage on 10 different devices maybe at least
0:55:40and so every time somebody sends me an iMessage it actually goes to 10 and and each device has
0:55:45its own key pair and there's a lot of work going on there to make it look as seamless as possible
0:55:52that my iMessages just show up everywhere all the time right at the same time and the other
0:55:58platforms don't do that well at all and of course it makes sense that apple the company that sells
0:56:03things like expensive five thousand dollar macbook pros would make it a more of a priority but it's
0:56:08neither here nor there here's what i want to run by and i hope you like it because i've actually
0:56:13spent most of my friday working on it but here's my analogy is that if you are an amex platinum
0:56:21card holder and they run american express runs centurion lounges at a couple of dozen airports
0:56:29around the world and so when i go to philadelphia i now go way early this is the best part about the
0:56:35centurion lounge is it gets me to go to the airport early and so i'm never last minute for
0:56:41a flight anymore i go early and all i have to do is i go to the centurion lounge show them my
0:56:48platinum amex show them my boarding pass they make you have the boarding pass because it's
0:56:52i guess they're worried that people will just go to the airport to get free food i don't know it
0:56:58seems weird it always seems weird to me that they make you show a boarding pass but they do
0:57:02but if you have a platinum amex and a boarding pass they say welcome mr grouper do you need the
0:57:08wi-fi password and i don't because i've been there before but they have very good wi-fi very
0:57:14comfortable chairs they have desks they have food that is actually really pretty good for free a
0:57:21full service bar and you could just get alcoholic beverages for free they just give them to you
0:57:26they've got really nice bathrooms they've even got like showers so that if you're on some kind
0:57:32of extended trip or have a really long layover or something you can get a shower it's all quote
0:57:38unquote free but it's not free it's something you get as a perk for paying i think i don't know i
0:57:45don't know what my annual fee is it's i think three or five hundred dollars or something like that
0:57:50i don't know you pay like three or four hundred dollars a year to have an atnam amex platinum card
0:57:55and one of the perks is you get access to these centurion lounges i message is sort of like that
0:58:02for apple device users it is free they just give it to you if you pay for an iphone an ipad or a mac
0:58:11and you just get a very nice end-to-end encrypted high speed very reliable messaging service for all
0:58:20of your devices it doesn't compress your images it lets you send video you can send big video
0:58:25attachments doesn't recompress those but if you don't have an amex card you can't get in a lounge
0:58:31you can just wait in the terminal right and pay for your food and that's like sms and beeper is
0:58:39sort of like a way that you can come into the centurion lounge and show like a fake platinum
0:58:44card and get in and get all the free food i i think the analogy kind of holds i mean but i think
0:58:50a very a very john grubber analogy for sure and a long way to go to get to the idea that apple runs
0:58:55servers you know how to use them without apple's permission i think the government case and this is
0:58:59you know what everyone should have access to that centurion lounge if that came to pass like
0:59:03centurion round is so important that you should not deny anyone access but the solution would be
0:59:07very much you've talked about so many past shows all the degrees that say apple has to allow third
0:59:11party processing if apple was ever forced to open the iMessage network they would say fine anyone
0:59:15can go in the iMessage network you just pay us this license fee and show us the source code to
0:59:19your app and the license fees would be so high we're like oh i'm not going to pay that to get on
0:59:23that's not fair and it's well the government just said you need to have access and they didn't say
0:59:26you needed to be able to build a profitable business by selling a client for giving i'm
0:59:31going to give away the paper client for free i'm going to charge you two dollars a month
0:59:34but wait apple wants how much money they want how much money per message because there's no
0:59:38rules in the sort of you let me to allow access dictating the exact economics of how apple allows
0:59:43you access so yeah you can use a third-party payment processor but you just pay apple
0:59:4627 instead of 30 well and that holds with the analogy because i could take a if i'm traveling
0:59:53with a companion who is not a platinum card holder i could take them into the centurion lounge by
1:00:01paying 50 per adult it's 30 bucks for a kid and 50 bucks for an adult and you have to pay with
1:00:08a platinum card nice apple doesn't have that option with iMessage but like you said if forced
1:00:16to then they could say okay anybody can join iMessage it's 50 a year and try telling somebody
1:00:21that they have to pay for a messaging service yeah or whatever it would cost and this is the
1:00:25other factor that's why i mentioned them showing the source code is apple doesn't want clients that
1:00:30it doesn't know about using its network even if they said iMessage is going to be open to
1:00:33third-party clients they would have to be some sort of validation maybe a test suite they have
1:00:37to pass maybe they have to see the source code because every new client you have on the network
1:00:41is a potential security risk because you end and encrypt doesn't mean everything is safe forever
1:00:47you have to trust the app you're using because the app in the end decrypts your messages to show them
1:00:50on your phone screen so the app has access to all your messages in going and outgoing in plain text
1:00:56and you hope the app isn't secretly sending them off somewhere right and storing them for later
1:01:02but the only we trust apple not to do that but do you trust this third-party client or that one and
1:01:06if there's any third-party client on the network that's essentially exfiltrating conversations in
1:01:10plain text apple would want to know that because that changes the security like people say oh it's
1:01:15the apple has no argument about security they have a great argument would you want a an unknown
1:01:20third-party client that's able to exfiltrate messages in plain text on your network you can
1:01:24no longer say the iMessage network is secure end to end because you don't control the ends anymore
1:01:29so if they were forced to open the network they would have to have some system whereby they
1:01:33validate okay this client app this binary say something like app review but actually sane and
1:01:38working is not doing something nasty with the messages that it is receiving yeah i don't know
1:01:46what they would in a hypothetical world where regulators do force them to quote unquote open
1:01:51it up i don't know if that would mean that they would be forced to just have you know would they
1:01:55comply by apple releasing its own iMessage app for android and say that that's not opening i mean
1:02:02this will never happen because again i don't think if you want to pick something that apple needs to
1:02:05open up let's start with the app store maybe and not the thing that actually has competition there
1:02:09aren't a whole bunch of competing app stores and apples is not the most popular there are a bunch
1:02:13of competing messaging clients and apples is right it's the most popular in the us but not worldwide
1:02:18right and it the point i've made this too the other one of the other security points that
1:02:22beeper keeps brushing past is and as they keep reimplementing the register your phone number
1:02:29without an iCloud account to use it is as beeper mini first existed and as they keep trying to come
1:02:37back to apple has lost control over user account creation on their own network yeah and that is a
1:02:43security problem and beeper might have the best i i do actually believe that beeper has the best
1:02:48of intentions and are and trustworthy intention yeah we don't think they are exfiltrating it but
1:02:54how do you know and what about they're not exfiltrating now what if someone buys beeper
1:02:58what if their client gets hacked what if their company gets hacked right how does apple know
1:03:02that they're actually storing the messages on device like the cache or whatever's there in a
1:03:06trustworthy way that other apps on the phone can't read them they don't know and they're like well
1:03:11we'll show you our source code apple did they didn't want to do this you can't just say they
1:03:15don't want they don't want to audit your source code it's hard enough for apple to keep its own
1:03:18clients secure they're constantly bugs in apple's own clients they don't want to multiply that out
1:03:23and so it's just right particularly iMessage right i it's a the number one source of zero days or it
1:03:29had been in the past because people receive messages so it's taking years and years for
1:03:34apple to to work on security problems to wall off the parts of the message app so they're less
1:03:39exploitable and that's just that's the richest company in the world working on the one and only
1:03:44ios message app over the course of a decade and a half right we want to open the door to to a
1:03:49company of the size of beeper yeah sure you can write a client throw in the network it'll be fine
1:03:52right with a lot of it being operating level operating system level security things like the
1:03:58whole blast door thing is in the operating system not iMessage for security so that whenever
1:04:03i long story short or layperson's explanation when an image comes in on iMessage it gets put in
1:04:11behind a quote-unquote blast door and the image is rendered or read the bits the decoding part of it
1:04:19is the dangerous part all right this series of bytes claims to be a jpeg let's decode it but
1:04:28do it in a sandboxed process so that if it's a maliciously formed jpeg it's the code is running
1:04:35in a process that has access to nothing else including the rest of imus did you hear about
1:04:39the bios speaking of decoding images you're at the bios bug is uh yeah you don't remember this well
1:04:44anymore because we have all these apples with a max remember uefi that like the firmware that was
1:04:49on like efi firmware that was on intel max it was basically like the tiny bit of stuff that gets the
1:04:53machine running in the beginning that kind of firmware you can put firmware passwords in anyway
1:04:57there's a bios in the days of pcs some bios are uefi firmware on pcs and it had a feature where
1:05:05pc makers could have it so it shows their logo when you turn it on oh yeah and the and of course
1:05:10this tiny little firmware code and it's very simple and it's just it's not a full operating
1:05:14it's just the firmware and the thing that decodes the vendor image to display on the screen had a
1:05:20security exploit so you could basically route a machine by giving it a malicious vendor image
1:05:25to the uefi bios and what can you do you can't like you can't patching the operating system's
1:05:30gotta help the operating system hasn't come yet you just turn the machine on right the operating
1:05:34system hasn't even been woken up yet yeah it's too late it's just that yeah so image decoding and why
1:05:39didn't they make it a little an isolated thing and blast like it's firmware there's not even like a
1:05:44full operating system running in there yet it's just you're just turning yeah anyway and it was
1:05:49tricky and again most programmers even really clever ones aren't thinking like an asshole
1:05:58right they're not thinking like a jerk they're just like oh wouldn't it be cool if instead of
1:06:03showing all of this stupid terminal garbage you know auto exec bat it probably still shows that
1:06:08but it shows the logo first yeah well wouldn't it be cool if it showed our logo first and they would
1:06:13say yes anybody's logo because we're gonna sell this we're gonna sell this bios to lots of pc
1:06:17makers so just put your logo file right there and you'll be fine right and it's yes that would be
1:06:22a much cooler way a much cooler thing to see upon first booting your pc so yes let's ship it
1:06:29and like you said there is no operating system it's just literally just the firmware that's
1:06:35bootstrapping the computer so it can load an operating system so obviously it's probably very
1:06:41tightly written possibly assembly code in a memory unsafe language like c probably
1:06:46uh anyway i do not expect i i expect that this iMessage beeper thing will now settle down and go
1:06:53away i don't know it's fascinating to me though i guess that to me the most fascinating thing is
1:06:58the fact that people just people who should know better including i think even the people at beeper
1:07:03just overlook what iMessage is it is a tremendously large proprietary messaging platform that it just
1:07:12is sort of seen as invisible it's it must be frustrating to the people who work on like the
1:07:18iMessage infrastructure because it's like hey what about us i'm busy all the time you know how hard
1:07:25i work you're just a cost center all right let me take a break here and thank our next sponsor it is
1:07:29our good friends at nuts.com oh man nuts.com they sell so many snacks it's crazy it is like they say
1:07:39it's like willy wonka's candy factory yeah they got a lot of candy too they call it nuts.com
1:07:44but they've got all the nuts all the amazing selection of nuts any kind of nuts you want
1:07:49but they've also got all sorts of classic candies butterscotch fudge and licorice that type of stuff
1:07:55they also have i have a friend who's heard me do these reads for nuts.com who said you should
1:08:00mention that they sell uh dark chocolate m&ms which are very hard to find retail i didn't even
1:08:06know they existed turns out they are delicious they are way better i'm actually i'm a dark
1:08:11chocolate fan i and but i actually find m&ms like american style milk chocolate like hershey's and
1:08:17mars to be like just it's like eating i don't know tar or wax or something dark chocolate much
1:08:24tastier they've got dark chocolate m&ms so they've got like some name brand candy that type of stuff
1:08:29really great it's just unbelievable i mention it every time they're half popped popcorn it's sort
1:08:35of halfway between popcorn and like a corn nut it is my favorite snack every time i open a bag it
1:08:42i eat the whole thing at once i can't stop myself it is that good regular popcorn half pop popcorn
1:08:49cashews almonds pecans pistachios i mean you did i'm not gonna i'm gonna stop listing them but
1:08:54they've got everything nuts.com is your one-stop shop for freshly roasted nuts dried fruit sweets
1:09:02pantry staples like specialty flowers stuff like that like kitchen stuff and more their wide
1:09:08selection means there is something for everyone and nuts.com quality is a top priority they roast
1:09:14their nuts and pop their corn the same day it ships so that stuff reaches you deliciously fresh
1:09:20satisfaction is guaranteed they've also got like gluten-free options organic choices other diet
1:09:27friendly products i mean it is if you think hey all you sell is nuts i'm telling you you better
1:09:32have a big variety they've got it they've got everything it is really great you can shop a la
1:09:37carte anytime or opt into a hassle-free auto delivery type thing so you never run out of
1:09:42your favorite staples right now nuts.com is offering new customers a free gift with purchase
1:09:48and free shipping on orders of 29 or more by going to nuts.com slash the talk show so go check out
1:09:58all of their delicious options at nuts.com slash the talk show you'll receive a free gift and free
1:10:04shipping when you spend 29 or more that's nuts.com slash the talk show easy to run up 29 not because
1:10:13it's expensive but because they have so much good stuff go check them out do you do the sponsor
1:10:18reads on any of your podcasts i do not do you think you could would you like to uh i would not
1:10:23like to i could but i would do a terrible job i used to do a terrible job you know that because
1:10:29i know you listen to my show no yeah you did a terrible job but you got better i think the same
1:10:32thing would happen to me i would do a terrible job for a few years eventually i would get better but
1:10:36it is not a thing i relish doing i will tell you that's one thing you cannot you can't practice it
1:10:41or at least i couldn't i tried talking to myself without a microphone on tried doing it can't do it
1:10:47you got to actually do it i don't know how did marco end up as the sponsored guy seems like casey
1:10:53because casey's sort of like to do all the work yeah but marco does an amazing job on them he's
1:10:57really good he was not as good at the beginning but he started off better than you and he got
1:11:02better real fast and i think casey does a great job too casey is you're right casey is more
1:11:06naturally inclined to do it he's casey's only done a few ads and i think he started off even better
1:11:09than marco but he just hasn't done as many so he doesn't have the experience yeah it seemed it was
1:11:14casey's job seems to be to do all the pre-show work he told he said on the last episode hey
1:11:20what planet do you want to do all the pre-show work he he said the other day that on the days
1:11:25you guys record he said yeah he sits down in the morning what he said was he sits down in the
1:11:30morning and he goes over all the notes and all the links how do you think all those notes and
1:11:33links get there that he's looking at in that morning who put them there that was me he sits
1:11:38down in the morning of the show and looks at now what am i going to do today because i've already
1:11:42put it all there don't get this wrong okay we all do our own we all pitch in and we all do our own
1:11:49things but there are they're somewhat distinct and when marco does the post he does all the editing
1:11:55and yes exactly actual publishing it's i don't know you should try it on one of your podcasts
1:12:00too late for atp but no thanks what else do i have on the agenda here oh there's the ios passcode
1:12:07story which is ongoing i don't have a lot more to add about this i know that you guys talked about
1:12:12it but the are you gonna are you gonna turn your you're gonna turn on the stolen device protection
1:12:18i am i'm gonna try it i i have mixed feelings about whether i want to or not because i kind
1:12:23of feel like what happens am i going to be annoyed if i ever do but then i thought like i don't think
1:12:28i've learned enough about it to think that i'm actually not going to be annoyed assuming there's
1:12:31no bugs that are catastrophic and screw me over right i think it really won't impact my life at
1:12:38all i think so too because i realized i never change i never change passwords right like the
1:12:44idea that you don't tell people that on a podcast you change passwords constantly they're all very
1:12:49unique and random and they're always changing i think it's i think a lot of my passwords including
1:12:54i think my iCloud password are easily 10 years old like the idea that you're supposed to regularly
1:13:00change your passwords as good password hygiene i think is not just nonsense but you shouldn't
1:13:07change it every 90 days but you can change it once every few decades i mean your security practices
1:13:12may not be the best yeah they're probably not but but then i think but if i don't change my iCloud
1:13:17password and or if i do only change it once a decade why do i care if i have to wait an hour
1:13:22and i guess i i don't have to wait an hour if i do it at home i know you changed your apple id
1:13:27password at least once because you told me your apple id password remember when you reset your
1:13:30apple id password to something so i could use it do you remember that it was ages ago before our
1:13:36apple ids were email addresses and you wanted me to do something with your apple id so you changed
1:13:40your password to some simple phrase that i could use and then i logged into your apple id and did
1:13:45something and then you changed it back i don't i have no recollection of that whatsoever i i you
1:13:49know why i know that because i was recently cleaning out my keychain and i found that iCloud
1:13:53password for your old non-email apple id do you remember what the password was nope but i remember
1:13:59the apple id was john space grouper yep and the the password was the other john ah there you go
1:14:06the other john now that rings a bell yeah yeah remember that oh you changed your apple id password
1:14:11at least once i'm hoping it's not still the other john you know what though that's a different apple
1:14:18id yeah i know it's nice again we've all so much has changed since then no that's but the main
1:14:24thing my takeaway about this whole saga since joanna and nicole when first started reporting on
1:14:29it is you're okay as long as your device passcode is a secret and as long as you treat it as a holy
1:14:37i saw you when you say that the pines like i'm just gonna be real careful and not let people see
1:14:43my passcode who do you think you are i just hold it real close to my chest you don't you go to
1:14:48casinos everyone can see everything i don't i but i i almost never need to enter my device
1:14:55passcode all the time i don't think you're as as james bond as you think you are and hiding your
1:15:01i wouldn't i if i were in a casino i wouldn't enter my device passcode on my phone i really
1:15:07have three three drinks in you just want your phone unlocked face id fails for some reason you
1:15:11get frustrated you type in no i wouldn't because i and i'd be super i would actually be extra
1:15:15suspicious in a casino because there's shifty people about well i mean if you're in a casino
1:15:21you got another problem because you got the what is it rubber hose encryption you know about that
1:15:24one where they just put you in a chair and beat you with rubber hose until you right on the passcode
1:15:28they don't even have to do that they're just going to grab your phone from you hold your arms behind
1:15:31your back hold up to your face all right so i don't know maybe i should turn it on and and i
1:15:36thought that uh talking to joanna like when apple announced the stolen device protection last week
1:15:42she wouldn't tell me she didn't she did not spoil it she's a good wall street journal employee and
1:15:47would not say what it was but she said i'm so annoyed because i've spent a ton of effort on
1:15:53something coming next week and i'm worried that this spoils it and i was like oh i'll look forward
1:15:58to it and then the the thing was she traveled all the way to minnesota to visit a guy in prison who
1:16:06was part of a crime ring who had stolen police say at least 300 000 not just of phones but then
1:16:13using this technique of get the passcode then go in the phone and change the icloud password and
1:16:20turn off find my so the victim is can't do anything with the phone and is locked out of their icloud
1:16:27and now you can get into their keychain and look for bank accounts look for paypal look for venmo
1:16:34and start clearing the cash out of that and then start going to retail places and uh using apple
1:16:41paid to buy what you can and he told her that while the police said that they stole 300 000
1:16:48worth of stuff he thinks it was more like a million which i'm not quite sure it whether to believe him
1:16:53and give him credit for honesty he had a ridiculous accounting i'm sure of everything he stole in a
1:16:59notebook like in the style of the wire i also i do i i do think he was being honest at the end
1:17:06where his regret was getting too greedy not that he had been living a life of crime there's a lesson
1:17:12for the silicon valley people that he just had a lifestyle criminal business but no we have to try
1:17:16to be as big as facebook but my my my favorite takeaway from the video and again and i i'll spoil
1:17:23the detail she did not make public but she she actually went there to interview him on her
1:17:28birthday so it was ruined the family fun of joanna stern's birthday but i thought one of the best
1:17:34parts they actually got at the last minute some security footage from like some minneapolis bars
1:17:41it where this guy she interviewed with him showing him like with his victims and it was way more
1:17:50social engineering than even i was thinking and as soon as i saw it i was like you know what i should
1:17:55you should all never underestimate how much of any of these hacks is social engineering like it
1:18:00wasn't like surreptitious it wasn't oh we'll set up a guy with a camera to look at this thing it
1:18:06was like he everybody had a couple of drinks and he's got his arm around the one guy they're like
1:18:11friends and he would say it's like hey you should like join my snapchat account follow me on
1:18:17instagram or something here give me your phone i'll give you my account and people would just
1:18:21hand their phone over to this stranger and then he would squeeze the two buttons and say hey it's
1:18:25locked oh and then they'd say and some of them he said would just give him the number it's one two
1:18:31three four and he'd say one two three four and then he'd put them on his snapchat give him the
1:18:35phone back and then later on steal their phone and now he knows their number and the game is over but
1:18:41it's the willy-nillyness with that people were willing to share their device passcodes with a
1:18:47stranger it surprised me and then i thought about it and i thought i don't think people have any
1:18:52idea how i think that's the fundamental problem it's one of those things that you're never going
1:18:57to think about until it happens to you and then the dawning real the series of cascading dawning
1:19:02realizations of how much power someone has if they have your access to your phone yeah i mean
1:19:07and then any in any security system humans are always the weakest link so it makes perfect sense
1:19:11to go after them first don't try to crack the encryption just get the guy to get a few drinks
1:19:15and tell you the number i think that most people think that it's just sort of that the passcode is
1:19:21on your phone just to keep people from like nosing through your pictures or something you know right
1:19:27going through all of your pictures reading all of your emails and and they think if i'm only going
1:19:33to hand my phone to this guy for a minute while he pops types right i got the phone right back
1:19:37i'm fine i got the phone right back i know that he wasn't going through my pictures or whatever
1:19:42they think what's the difference they don't care it's almost like the sharing the bathroom code
1:19:48with somebody right right oh what's the code to go to the bathroom oh it's four three two one
1:19:52oh okay and then they go in there they don't think of it that way whereas they would never give a
1:19:58stranger their atm pin code exactly but their device and the atm is way better protected because
1:20:05you can't take out more than 200 or whatever and there's a camera right there in front of the thing
1:20:10and your phone probably has access to the same bank account that your thing so your phone passcode
1:20:16is like a superset of your atm pin code but nobody would just give their pin code to a stranger so i
1:20:22think basically treating your device passcode as a secret at least as valuable as your atm code
1:20:28gets you most of the way to not having to worry about this but like you said on the other hand
1:20:33i don't even know what the downsides are to turning on the stolen device protection for me
1:20:37you should turn it on and see if you even notice the downside because if you said share location
1:20:40to your house that you never leave and given how often you change your passwords this will not
1:20:45come up in your life i don't think you'll notice that it is there but and in fact i would suggest
1:20:49as we talked about an atp they're like maybe have all the your family members turn it on as well
1:20:54and see if it annoys them because you can always disable it after but like why not try it and see
1:20:59if you turn it on and they don't even know get their consent obviously but if you say i'm going
1:21:03to turn this on and if it ever annoys you in any way let me know and we can turn it off but i just
1:21:07want to try it yeah i i kind of think that's probably true i've kind of coming around to that
1:21:12because the worst case scenario oh okay i don't like having this on then the worst case scenario
1:21:18is you have to when you decide i don't like having this you have to wait an hour before you turn it
1:21:23don't have to wait an hour for you to trust the location right and i guess you don't i i'm still
1:21:27not confused about that because i was but i i think part of the reason that my test device
1:21:34didn't recognize my home is my home is that it's a test device using a spare apple id not my apple
1:21:41id i just don't want to turn this on on a beta operating yeah yeah yeah i mean that's why is it
1:21:45usually using your test apple id too but also i think the trust the location thing is going to be
1:21:49configurable so it's not like it's just your home and your work i think you can set locations but
1:21:53we'll i i definitely wouldn't use this in beta if you don't have to and don't use it on your real
1:21:57apple id in beta but once it comes out we'll see yeah uh also in the news apple's journal app
1:22:03shipped have you used it have you looked at it i launched it for the first time while you were
1:22:07doing an ad read literally the first time ever launched it i have no interest in an app like this
1:22:12but i do know that this type of app is popular and i think it is i think it has reached a level
1:22:17popularity that it is reasonable for apple to ship a rudimentary one of these with their phone plus
1:22:23the whole thing what they're doing with api so that third parties can contribute items that might
1:22:27appear in the journal it's kind of one way it's not quite the way you'd want it to be kind of like a
1:22:32calendar where third parties can make full-fledged calendar apps for example or photos apps where you
1:22:37know but this is like the other direction where like well third-party apps can contribute stuff
1:22:41that you might want to put into your apple journal in your apple journal app which is not
1:22:44completely open but like i said i think it is a reasonable thing for there to be a default one
1:22:50of these on every iphone i can't pass any judgment on the feature set of this app because i do not
1:22:55use journaling apps but presumably it's a 1.0 and it will get better i have never kept a journal or
1:23:01a diary really regularly but i've been playing with this app and so i am but i don't think i'm
1:23:09going to keep it up but i'm doing it mostly just because i keep i'm really interested in the app
1:23:14and at first i was so confused why this thing that they announced at wwdc in june
1:23:21didn't ship until 17.2 in december and it's iphone only for the moment there's no ipad or mac app
1:23:31and it is a really simple app it is just a list of entries there's a plus button at the bottom
1:23:38to make a new entry and you make entries and then there's a list of them it doesn't have a search
1:23:44feature yet so you can't search it again doesn't have ipad or mac clients i was like how could this
1:23:50have not shipped on time and then the light bulb went off and i realized the app is very simple
1:23:57and thin and iphone only but the work was all of these apis because the apis work two ways there's
1:24:05the suggestions that the system gives to the app so like when you hit the plus button it'll say
1:24:11oh you went on a walk yesterday do you want to use that as a journal entry for yesterday and there's
1:24:17a map a little map insert that'll show you the course or wherever it was that you went or it'll
1:24:24show you recent photos or something like that and those are apis that third-party journaling apps
1:24:30can use so like day one to name the i guess the most popular long-standing ios journaling app can
1:24:38and i guess is using those apis to get suggestions or prompts for entries and i guess it works
1:24:44the other way too where those third-party apps can offer their own suggestions to the system
1:24:52so that any journaling app that that subscribes to this can do it that's where all the work was
1:24:57to do this to add these features and to cross every i or cross every t dot every i to make
1:25:06sure that it's private because obviously journaling personal journaling information
1:25:10is inherently needs to be private that's where all the work was and why it didn't ship till 17.2
1:25:17but i find the app itself fascinating because i think most journaling apps i've looked at day one
1:25:23over the years it never again i don't want to keep a journal so i'm not really in the target market
1:25:28but it seems like most of them it gets to the design idea of what's like the atomic element of
1:25:34your app and i think for most journaling apps they're sort of like calendars where the atomic
1:25:40unit is a day where it's like okay here's a new day what happened today and the day is the unit
1:25:48which i think kind of is like going from the skeuomorphic era of where you kept a diary in
1:25:56an actual book right and if you can keep a diary in just a plain notebook but they sell diaries
1:26:02that have like dates at the top already right so you just already it's like a page is a day
1:26:07like it's like a combination calendar type thing apple has obviously a notes app that's been on the
1:26:16iphone since the first version you could i'm sure there are probably with a billion plus users
1:26:23there's probably millions of people who keep a journal or a diary in apple notes right you could
1:26:28just say here's a new note or here's a folder in my notes that's my journal they have hashtags in
1:26:36notes now so you could use a hashtag to keep your journal entries or something like that and notes
1:26:41has a lock so that you can put like an extra layer of layer of security on certain notes or
1:26:47like a whole folder at a time but the journal app used and this is where i was like i wonder what
1:26:53apple's going to do why they're not making this part of the notes app and what fascinates me about
1:27:00it is that the metaphor for the journal app to me is clearly inspired not by like a notes app
1:27:07but instead by like social networking it's like your own personal one person social twitter just
1:27:13for you and so instead you don't have days you just have entries so you could do three entries
1:27:19on one day you could do none for a while and you don't need a title you just hit plus start typing
1:27:26you can add pictures or a map or something and then you're done and then you just have this
1:27:31one timeline of entries ordered chronologically i it's deceptively simple but i feel like
1:27:38i've never seen that idea put forth in a personal app rather than a public social networking app
1:27:44in my first 30 seconds with the app i just said i launched it for literally the first time ever
1:27:49earlier and i also just tried to like hit the plus button to to make an entry and in the first run
1:27:56experience it says as it has a sheet that explains what it's going to do and it says do you want to
1:28:00allow me to do suggestions like the thing you just described so the other apps can suggest things to
1:28:04it or whatever and i said yes allow suggestions and then it popped up an os dialog for allow
1:28:09notifications just the regular notification dialog i said okay and then i'm when i hit okay i was
1:28:14back to the same screen that i had seen previously but the one big button on the bottom that said
1:28:18allow suggestions was grayed out because i had already hit it and i was like so what do i do now
1:28:23and i wiggled the sheet a little bit and it wiggled up and down i'm like is this a bug is there
1:28:28some button i should be able to hit do i swipe the sheet away no is there anything animating on the
1:28:34screen can i get the thing behind it i tapped on the thing behind the sheet nothing happened and
1:28:40then eventually the sheet slid down and what it revealed to me is that i had been working hard to
1:28:45build up that big giant grid of memories and images and prompts and everything behind the scenes
1:28:50right i know this isn't specifically about the journal app but i'm gonna say that it's another
1:28:55one of those pieces of basic information about human interaction design that has somehow departed
1:29:00the company of apple when your computer is doing anything that takes a little bit longer than
1:29:06expected put up something on the screen so people know that the computer is busy and it will be done
1:29:11in a little bit it could be a watch cursor it could be a progress bar it could be an
1:29:15indeterminate spinner and i know you think it's not going to take a long time but i have 175,000
1:29:20pictures on my phone and when it does take more than two seconds pop up a spinner very frustrated
1:29:26i think it's another piece of the same mentality at apple that has gotten them away from showing
1:29:34error messages when things go wrong yeah and i kind of understand that one as well but it's
1:29:39this is fundamentals it's like fundamentals in basketball dribbling passing there there used to
1:29:45be in the old days in the prehistoric days in the dinosaur era error messages from any software were
1:29:52always just cryptic codes right error 128 or something like sometimes it was a negative number
1:29:58yeah sometimes it was a negative number there i used to know what that meant what the hell did
1:30:01that mean in classic mac negative meant something i think it was like i don't know but you'd get an
1:30:08error number and there was no google there was no internet or are there but negative 37 with a bomb
1:30:15icon would become your friend right and then you could duly report well if you had a way because
1:30:21you remember a lot of the you know if you go back far enough and you and i both do where you didn't
1:30:26even have emails reporting a bug to the developer might have meant writing a letter and putting it
1:30:31into postal mail but you could tell them you've got error 37 and somebody somewhere has a list
1:30:38of what the error codes are and what they actually mean and we all learned as user interface designers
1:30:44or critics whichever side or both that we could be that's a bad way of doing errors and that your
1:30:49error messages should be descriptive and give as much helpful information to the user describing
1:30:54what went wrong and what what action you might take what actions you might take and i remember
1:31:00it might even still be there somewhere in the remnants of the human interface guidelines of
1:31:05what they are but when the human when the hig was really a book there was like a whole chapter i
1:31:10think about like writing good error messages yeah exactly i mean and that one their heart's the
1:31:15right place with that one but with the thing that i'm talking about is one of those things where
1:31:19i think that's probably still in the hick which is look if you have an operation it's going to take
1:31:22over a certain amount of time put something up so the user knows that they're waiting on the computer
1:31:26but you know the people who made this program it's like when they hit that button we're going to be
1:31:30so fast at composing the screen that sheet's going to slide down in a fraction of a second
1:31:35there's no way this is ever going to take more than a fraction of a second and they don't test
1:31:39with the photo library the size of mine and now i'm waiting long enough to be struggling to figure
1:31:43out what the hell i'm supposed to press on the screen trying to tell if the app is frozen yeah
1:31:47do you need to force quit no where i was going to with the error message to me in modern it like
1:31:51apple took error messages in the right way long ago where they made them more descriptive and
1:31:56tried to get third-party developers to get more descriptive but modern apple has said error
1:32:01messages are bad and rather taking that to mean let's write even more reliable software that
1:32:07doesn't generate errors they just don't show errors they errors occur and to me far worse
1:32:15than just saying error negative 37 is not showing anything at all and not having anything because
1:32:22what it does is it adds doubt to everyone's mind and when anything is happening they're like
1:32:27is our errors silently occurring or is this normal operation because at least when you're
1:32:31when you expect if anything goes wrong i'm going to see some stupid error message at least you know
1:32:35if i don't see one of those nothing has gone wrong yet but you can't make that assumption once
1:32:39they've trained you that hey something could be going wrong we're not going to tell you about it
1:32:42right and so i think they're doing the same thing now with progress indicators where they're like
1:32:46that's a bad experience and so instead of writing that in the next version instead of writing taking
1:32:51that to heart and writing software that never takes more than a fraction of a second to do
1:32:57anything they just don't show a progress i mean but that's not possible i know things scale like
1:33:02they in the common case yes it's not going to take a while the app wasn't hung like i said i could
1:33:06still move the sheet up and down like it's not it wasn't a hang right it was just simply they just
1:33:10never expected this take a long period of time so there was no sort of they didn't think start a
1:33:15timer and if the timer reaches three seconds throw show a spinner there's no place to show a spinner
1:33:19they're never going to show a spinner no matter how long it takes and they just it's not a big
1:33:22deal but and by the way speaking of error messages from from the gaming world your son may know this
1:33:27but the gaming world has to tackle a similar problem because modern video games are fiendishly
1:33:31complex the the one a popular game that i play destiny the way they handle this is not unique
1:33:36to destiny many games do this but i'm very familiar with it in destiny is anytime there's an
1:33:40error for the application for whatever the reason they will they essentially have that same
1:33:46dictionary of numbers negative 9 57 whatever right but they don't put like an error code up on the
1:33:51screen to make you report that error they map them all to words so you get weasel errors beaver
1:33:56errors like they're all like animal like memorable names like that because gamers will all talk to
1:34:02each other and say oh i got a weasel error it's memorable they remember it it's not like they have
1:34:06to write it down when it happens or whatever how many beaver errors are happening to and on the
1:34:10back end that means something to them but that mapping is such great social engineering because
1:34:16it's not like people know it remember it and report it without having to write it down when
1:34:21it happens error one h p q 974 that's actually pretty clever i like that i'm not familiar with
1:34:28that but i will check anyway i just i i admire the design of the journal app as a social feed
1:34:34that is anti-social because it's just for you i think it's a super clever design and i really do
1:34:40i don't i mean i'm not the developer of day one so maybe they're not happy about it but i think
1:34:47in terms of not sure locking the existent entrance in the market doing this ultra minimal version of
1:34:57a journal that i find very appealing i find this to be that this is the closest i started using it
1:35:03only to test and explore the app but it's the most inspired i've ever been to actually use it as a
1:35:09journal because the metaphor is so simple and clicks for me and is so to me original it's just
1:35:18so not overkill i really like it um i do and i agree i think like this type of thing where apple
1:35:24when there's a common use case like this where a certain genre of app is popular apple should make
1:35:29one and include it with the phone it makes the phone more valuable and i don't think if done
1:35:33well that really hurts the market for third-party ones because what they're doing is introducing
1:35:37people to the idea of journaling and if they want a better journaling app third-party apps are
1:35:40available and especially if they take the approach again using calendars as an example there's a
1:35:45thriving ecosystem for third-party calendar apps because the operating system calendar is accessible
1:35:51to third-party apps you can make a calendar app that can do essentially everything that apple's
1:35:56calendar app can do uh if they can do that with journaling as well they haven't quite gone that
1:36:01far with journaling but if they can do it with journaling as well what it does is make a healthier
1:36:05more thriving ecosystem for journaling apps instead of saying oh you've sherlocked me and now
1:36:09i can't uh ship a commercial uh journaling app because you give everyone for free right the
1:36:14other thing that journal app does that i think is a first for apple is the floating plus button at
1:36:18the bottom that's a very google yeah yeah that's a androidy googly off the top of my head i can't
1:36:26think i uh doesn't tweet bot or not tweet bot yeah a lot of a lot of third-party uh twitter
1:36:30clients and uh and mastodon clients do have the flame i hate it i hate the floating button but
1:36:34yeah it's there it covers up the content it does it does but it just emphasizes to me the fact that
1:36:43it is like a personal social network feed right it's yeah yeah the plus button is sort of like
1:36:47that so hats off to apple for doing that uh i there must be i actually did speak to somebody
1:36:54at apple pr before journal came out they wanted to i had a 10-minute webex call before 17.2 shipped
1:37:01because they wanted to sort of build the hype for it and build the awareness for it and of course
1:37:08i all my none of my questions ever get answered for the most part like i asked is there going to
1:37:13be an ipad or mac client and of course the answer was we we don't talk about our future products
1:37:19yeah right but as it stands journal already does sync to icloud by i guess you could turn it off
1:37:27the way that you can turn off any apps access to icloud but out of the box if you were signed into
1:37:32icloud it does sync to icloud so if you lose your phone you won't lose your journal and if you have
1:37:39two iphones yeah which of course you do which of course i do you can see that they stay in
1:37:45sync with each other so they have built a sync system that would seemingly already work if if
1:37:51and when there come ipad and mac clients oh yeah speaking of losing your stuff that's the other
1:37:56thing that it gives me a little bit of pause about journal and why it would be better if it was well
1:38:01i don't know if it was like calendar would be the same deal i suppose if you're going to spend weeks
1:38:07months years of your life journaling in there putting your precious memories building up years
1:38:11worth of content what you hope is that apple respects that and if apple decides that they
1:38:15don't want to make the journaling app anymore they'll have some way for you to export that in
1:38:19a reasonable format but even if that happens it's still disappointing oh man i use this app for my
1:38:23kids childhood years and we put so many memories in it and now the app just is gone and can i get
1:38:28an export or did i miss the thing and what i'm thinking of is something that i did with my kids
1:38:32we had iwebsites remember iweb yes of course we had pictures of our kids and a blog about them
1:38:38we would show to family members and a password-protected iwebsite and iweb was not a
1:38:43great program it was kind of unwieldy but we filled it with years and years of stuff and iweb
1:38:47of course is no longer a thing at apple and i have these giant iweb archive like the data file for
1:38:53iweb but it's just sitting in my backups and i don't really have a good way to view it i did
1:38:58do a bunch of html exports and stuff so you can kind of see it and i believe i still have it
1:39:01online somewhere but iweb the application no longer exists or runs except for really old
1:39:06versions of mac stuff and i always worried when apple does something like this is can they be
1:39:10trusted with my memories when it comes to calendar and photos i think they probably can be trusted
1:39:15but the journaling thing i'm not entirely sure they're so dedicated that this is worth putting
1:39:19decades of your time into yeah there is no export feature no import feature i mean it's a 1.0 it is
1:39:26a 1.0 like i said there's no search even yeah which is seems like there has to be a search
1:39:31eventually but you would i would imagine you just pull down and a search box will come from the top
1:39:37yeah search is missing as a day-to-day usability feature now and export is missing but also raises
1:39:44questions about the privacy security again i think and there there ought to be eventually a way to
1:39:52export i mean it seems criminal i mean as far as i can tell now if you really wanted to export you'd
1:39:56have to go through one by one select all copy and paste yeah i mean this is another area where apple
1:40:03could have a little bit more religion about this because the other example that i hear complaints
1:40:08about a lot is iMessage believe it or not right people people think of iMessage as i mean maybe
1:40:14this is like some people have it in their mind some people have in their mind that iMessage is
1:40:18forever and so the conversation they had when they first met their wife five years ago before
1:40:23they went on their first date and they iMessaged back and forth and they had cute flirting and
1:40:26stuff they a apparently they think they can somehow get back to that by scrolling which
1:40:31i don't know how they do that but b if that ever disappears they consider it like data loss you
1:40:36remove pictures pictures from my wife and i just met if apple accidentally deleted them or they
1:40:40scroll off the end or if they didn't think people would be furious but some people not all people
1:40:44but some people view iMessage the same way and apple either doesn't view iMessages that way or
1:40:50is not able to implement iMessage in a way that makes looking back at that old conversation
1:40:55possible yeah that's one of my big complaints about iMessage just that it is really hard to go
1:41:01back in time and search is better than it was but still better right uh that's a that that's
1:41:09a perfect description yes better than it was but not great you ever try to scroll back on the mac
1:41:14version it was awful before and it's still bad but it's just so weird like they really need to do like
1:41:18a month years like they do in photos like where you can go in granular chunks but i just think
1:41:23the sync system for messages and the way the service is designed is not meant to be a permanent
1:41:28archive for of decades long conversations forever and ever which means that if you want that out of
1:41:33it apple should implement an export feature of some kind to make some kind of offline archiver
1:41:38i don't know or maybe they just have to be more clear that's not what iMessage is and
1:41:41if you really care about messages i don't know take screenshots of them or something
1:41:45yeah uh i got one more sponsor do you want to guess is the squarespace it's squarespace i
1:41:51wouldn't have put you on the spot if it was anybody else it is it's our good friends at
1:41:56squarespace good friends of uh atp as well what do you need to know about squarespace it is the
1:42:02all-in-one platform where you can build your own website with your own domain name your own control
1:42:10over how it looks what features it has everything soup to nuts you can do it in squarespace what a
1:42:17great project maybe over the holidays you got time off over the holidays you've been thinking you want
1:42:21to upgrade your own personal space on the web or maybe start one or maybe you know someone who
1:42:27needs a website and you've got time you want to build it try it in squarespace it is absolutely
1:42:32my favorite way to recommend to anybody to get started doing their own website because it is
1:42:40really easy to use completely visual you can do it right in your own browser and their new layout
1:42:46engine works great on phones even so you can do the actual design your own website right there on
1:42:53your phone or make tweaks on your phone i mean you know i don't know how much work you want to do on
1:42:57your phone but it's there you can do it it's that good what kind of features do they have i mean
1:43:02they've got everything i told you about the fluid engine that's their next generation design system
1:43:07that works on all any system including a phone online stores you can sell stuff including
1:43:13flexible payments their checkout system accepts credit cards paypal apple pay anything like that
1:43:19you want it's all right there they can even integrate with the new stuff like afterpay and
1:43:23clear pay those sort of things if that's what you want to do for your store they've got flexible
1:43:29templates hundreds and hundreds of professionally designed templates that you can choose from
1:43:34and you can use them as is or tweak them to your heart's content analytics built in really a
1:43:41fantastic analytics interface that instead of confusing you and just looking like a bunch of
1:43:47dials and numbers that don't make any sense is presented in a super cogent really really clever
1:43:54data information way to just show you what parts of your website are people going to where are they
1:44:00coming from to get to your website the actual information you want to know is presented in a
1:44:05way that you'll just understand and you don't have to learn how to use their analytics it just is
1:44:10self-explanatory it's one of their best features so what do you do to find out more go to squarespace.com
1:44:17and you get a free trial 30 days no credit card required no watermarks on your site for the 30
1:44:23day free trial just it's a real deal you get 30 days you got all the features you get everything
1:44:29you want no marks and then when the 30 days up you can just go to squarespace.com/talk show
1:44:35that's squarespace.com/talk show use that code talk show and you save 10% off your first purchase
1:44:42of a website or domain it's fantastic you could buy a whole year at once save 10% by using that
1:44:47code so my thanks to Squarespace for their continuing support of this podcast and my
1:44:54favorite podcast ATP over on the other side of this conversation so I guess it's getting close
1:45:00to wrap it up but other things in the news infinite loop company store to close that's
1:45:06that just happened this week or they're going to close it next month have you were you ever at the
1:45:10infinite loop company store yeah I think I've been there a couple times I was only there once that I
1:45:16can remember and it was recently because it was in the era when it looked like it didn't look it
1:45:21it looks a little different than most apple stores but it looked mostly like yeah I was never there
1:45:26back before apple retail because I heard it looked very different then did you see I I linked on on
1:45:32daring fireball to a reddit thread that had some photos of what it looked like circa 1993-94
1:45:40and then I later today I found scrolling down the same thread I guess it's the same user there was
1:45:48apple made a quicktime vr of the store back in the day when that was a thing and so this industrious
1:45:55and helpful reddit user made a screen recording of the quicktime vr which because the quicktime
1:46:02vr doesn't really play anymore so he found I don't know if he was emulating or had an old mac
1:46:08and used the quicktime vr and made a video and so you could kind of see what it was like to walk
1:46:13through it is so apple 1993 and if you were an apple user back then or a mac user it can't help
1:46:22but bring nostalgia but it also emphasized just how far apples come because it really just sort
1:46:29of looked like a nice it was a nice egghead yeah yeah like a nice egghead exactly like if your
1:46:35neighborhood mac reseller was really nice and had new shelves that's because that's what computer
1:46:41stores look like they had box software right lined up on a bunch of shelves you have computers on a
1:46:46little like a little table kitty corner to the end cap on some display and you had a bunch of it was
1:46:51like that combined with the merch store at your kid's college right to have the sweatshirts you
1:46:55could buy yeah it was just very like the the floor plan the layout of how all the racks are arranged
1:47:02it was like a software retail store combined with the college store in 1990 yeah i have in fact have
1:47:09been at my son's merch store at his university and it yes it's exactly laid out like the apple
1:47:15company store was in 1994 drop ceilings apple has leveled up in production values in so many ways
1:47:24but none more so than architecture yeah the current retail stores and they've always been are so much
1:47:31more beautiful and elegant but also a little bit more kind of spare and impersonal and i still wish
1:47:38they had checkout lines i've given up on that but i do i do still wish that they did and i still
1:47:45i guess the reason i've i complain less is for the most part when i go to my local apple store
1:47:52it's to buy something that you couldn't order online or that's the it's a little thing like
1:47:59a battery pack or i did i actually did when they discontinued the apple iphone battery pack i went
1:48:07and bought one while they still had them because i thought that's it's a really good battery pack
1:48:12and i thought that's it's a good way to sort of have a iphone that could be charged either by
1:48:20usb-c or lightning because then if you have usb-c you could plug it in the phone i don't know if that
1:48:26was a smart move or not but like i wrote on the site the other day money runs through my hands
1:48:30like water so i bought one i went last week i popped in and bought 12 south a third-party
1:48:37peripheral maker has a new 130. it's they say it's meant for travel but it's it's uh
1:48:46it's a little aluminum thing i'll put it i swear to god i will put it in the show notes but they
1:48:52only are selling it it's made by 12 south but they're only selling it through apple stores
1:48:56and i couldn't buy it online or if i went to buy it online it wouldn't ship till january but i could
1:49:02go to my local apple store and pick it up right now so i went to the local apple store and picked
1:49:06it up but i could just walk in pick it up the shelf and then just check myself out yeah check
1:49:11out thing i still haven't done that yet i've gotten to the point now where i'm comfortable
1:49:15with it i've i every time i've done it and in the philadelphia store they have actual police
1:49:21officers at the front door every single time i did it for years i would think i'm gonna get stopped
1:49:27i'm gonna get stopped and then i'm gonna have to talk show them my phone and nope i could just walk
1:49:32right out i mean it's it breaks some part of my brain that says that i need to check out right
1:49:39before walking out just wait until they implement that amazon technology where you just walk in and
1:49:43pull it off the shelf and walk out and they figure out how much to charge you later the 12th south
1:49:48thing is a little circular thing it's a little bit bigger than a pair of airpods pro case and it's
1:49:55two parts and it breaks apart and on the one side it takes usb-c in and it's a charger so you can
1:50:01put your phone on the one side and then on the other side is an apple watch charger that pops up
1:50:07so that you could use the watch as a whatever they call it nightstand mode and the recent airpods
1:50:14cases also charge on that same thing so for traveling it's super small super lightweight
1:50:20charges your iphone at the high speed for magsafe charges your watch at the new high speed which is
1:50:26a lot faster than the old speed and you could charge your airpods case on either side of it
1:50:32and so apple used to make the same thing i forget what apple called theirs but it's you know it folds
1:50:37yeah i remember that the apple one was like 150 bucks and the problem with the apple one well hey
1:50:41now the problem is it was like lightning in and lightning is no longer something we talk about
1:50:47but the other thing was that the size of it the iphones got so big that they kind of got too big
1:50:53to fit comfortably on it the camera bump the camera bump pushed it off that's a problem with
1:50:57a lot of the inductive charging things right so this one made by 12 south has a pleather
1:51:04connector between the two circular halves and they made the pleather thing far enough apart that
1:51:12i think iphones could get significantly bigger and you'd still have no problem fitting it side by
1:51:17side so 130 bucks not cheap but it seems like a very good product there's my review just put it
1:51:22on your christmas list why are you buying this stuff for yourself see that's i'm the worst you
1:51:26talk to my wife i am the worst you know you're getting this here and i i had nothing charcoal
1:51:33that's what you're getting because you're almost out i am i should get charcoal no i'm the worst
1:51:38person to buy gifts for because even in december when the idea pops into my head you just demonstrated
1:51:46it that i would like x i just i am meat and i i don't just go get it i get it the way that is the
1:51:53fastest so whatever the fastest way for me to get whatever it is that just popped into my head that
1:51:59i should buy i just do it as you're walking out the door your wife should have said where are you
1:52:03going i'm going to the apple store to buy something she said what are you buying tell them tell it to
1:52:07me i'll get it to you for christmas i want it now well and i bought it i don't know it's probably
1:52:11four or five days ago i still i'm podcasting about it now but i keep thinking i'll at least link to
1:52:16it and write some form of minimal review on daring fireball i'm obviously running out of time before
1:52:21christmas so whatever i would have told you four days ago well i will definitely have written about
1:52:26it before christmas so i couldn't wait until christmas to do this obviously at this point i'm
1:52:31i easily could have gotten it as a stocking stuffer but i didn't are you are you like that
1:52:37do you or are you more diligent and if you have stuff you want you'll suggest to your family it
1:52:42would be nice if they bought you blank i mean i have the discipline now that around november
1:52:47things that i would normally just buy for myself instead of buying them put them on a list see i
1:52:51don't do it i have no discipline i am the absolute worst but you're going to keep that passcode secret
1:52:57no one will ever see it nope nobody will ever see the person with no discipline is going to make
1:53:02that happen you know what this feature would have been great for this feature would have been great
1:53:05during covid when we had masks and the so at the time everybody was wearing masks everywhere
1:53:11face id didn't yet even have the option to work with a mask and so yeah we were and i wanted to
1:53:20at the time when we were worried that you know you could die if you touched covid germs contactless
1:53:26payment seemed more important than ever so i was trying to use apple pay even more than i usually
1:53:31do but i had to i always have to type my contactless payment even when it works well you still have to
1:53:37press the button that says no thanks that you don't want to give them your telephone number and
1:53:40all this other crap before you get to do the contactless payment part so yeah yeah it turns
1:53:45a quote-unquote contactless but what else anything else on the main agenda oh i know what i wanted to
1:53:50tell you i wanted to tell you we have a new we have a new pc in the house did i said if you look
1:53:55at the shared note i sent you you could see a picture of it is this a christmas present it is
1:54:01but we decided that because he's only got a limited amount of time before he has to head back
1:54:08to college that he could set it up early it came it arrived yesterday and it is it was nice because
1:54:15if we have we have an ero household and i got the alert when he set it up it is a curious company
1:54:21name and i don't know how you'd pronounce it i don't know if they pronounce it n-z-x-t but it
1:54:25reminds me of course of next right one letter off it is a big black rectangle but my son's gaming pc
1:54:35i think we've bought him the i think it was 20 christmas 2017 or maybe 2018 but five years is
1:54:41pretty long in pc gaming so that was that's jonas's big gift for the year you could have told them
1:54:47your college tuition is your gaming pc now yeah that i would like many gaming pcs i would like to
1:54:55when he got his first gaming pc i'm gonna say i'm gonna i'll say 2018 i don't know maybe but it was
1:55:02five or six years ago but it was also a christmas gift and i wanted him to because i don't know shit
1:55:09about pcs i really don't i mean i guess i i know them in terms of the way i just know how computers
1:55:14work but i mean i haven't used windows since i don't know i think the last version of windows
1:55:21i ever actually used was windows 2000 i don't know it's been a long time i just have no interest in
1:55:28that universe so i wanted him to do all the research i was like we'll get you a good gaming pc
1:55:34but you have to give me you know you do the research tell me all the comp everything you want
1:55:39and why and justify it and he how much of that do you think he did yeah he's your kid so not a lot
1:55:46not a lot and so i got involved and i steered him toward a small smaller case from the company
1:55:57his msi which makes a bunch of components for pcs but i steered him towards a smaller one
1:56:03a smaller you thought the small one might be quieter you didn't know about pcs yet no i didn't
1:56:09i thought maybe it would be louder actually because i realized space makes cooling better but
1:56:14it probably was a bad decision because i remember i think i actually got help from you about this
1:56:20remember his video card went bad did you paint yourself into a thermal corner i we painted
1:56:24ourselves into a thermal corner so his first video card went bad it was probably a 3080 i guess would
1:56:32that be right from 2017 or 18. no uh was it maybe it was a maybe i don't know it was a good video
1:56:40card but it was a variant of it that was meant to fit in a smaller case and i think that was the
1:56:47problem anyway the he ended up the pc worked when the video card went bad but it wasn't it was
1:56:54only using like the built-in video but it was very just typical pc experience it wouldn't just show
1:57:01an error it says your video card is toast it was it seemed like something we could troubleshoot
1:57:07and we wasted a lot of time on it and we just had to replace it and the replacement we got was the
1:57:13exact same nvidia number whatever the number is 40 whatever or 30 whatever but it was a different
1:57:20you could because we had to take the old one out and look at the new one and you could see the
1:57:24differences and specifically there were a lot of a lot of differences with the heat sink this time
1:57:30he actually did do the work though he did configure everything he configured what brand to buy what
1:57:37video card he personally wanted amd not intel for the cpu which i think is probably a fine decision
1:57:44i think seems like a lot of gamers sort of feel that way there's the current state of the art so
1:57:50he did everything that i wanted him to do the first time but this time he did it but and i told him you
1:57:57probably shouldn't get it shouldn't get a small case but i said this is going to be a lot bigger
1:58:02and he was like all right all right he's astonished by how big it is he can't believe it i and i'm
1:58:09i can't believe that he can't believe it but i guess he just hasn't seen a lot of gaming pcs
1:58:15because most of the people you just play online you don't see the other people's pcs this is a
1:58:20pc that he he literally thinks he can't fit on his dorm desk oh yeah that's right if he's going to
1:58:26take this back to school with him that's you should have more mac pros now so let them know
1:58:30how big real computers are but actually this form factor of a case it's a tower style case it looks
1:58:34like i mean i would say like it's an at tower but people don't or xt whatever actually those aren't
1:58:38the right terms for towers never mind but it's almost as big as a what we used to call a full
1:58:42height tower back in the day do you remember you ever see a full height tower pc back in like the
1:58:46windows 95 windows 3.1 days they were so tall so huge they had spaces for five and a quarter inch
1:58:53hard drives in them they were just monstrous but these days there is a form factor that i've seen
1:58:58of gaming pcs that is like this tower but take two of these and put them side by side it's like
1:59:03a more of a cube shape it is like the least efficient most space hogging designed for a
1:59:08computer either so it's like as big and tall as a tower but twice as wide it's just a giant
1:59:14sometimes they're made of like transparent materials like a giant cube like a huge cube
1:59:18and you're like who has room for that literally anywhere you can't even put it under your desk
1:59:22by your feet because it doesn't leave room for your feet it's so big in a dorm room i don't know
1:59:26what they're gonna do with this but i mean it'll keep them warm in the boston winters i guess well
1:59:30so he did not come home he did not come home with his gaming pc so last year he took his freshman
1:59:36year he took his playstation 5 this year he left the playstation 5 here and took his gaming pc to
1:59:44college so and he didn't bring it home for christmas because he only took a carry-on for the flight so
1:59:50his current plan is to stop worrying about shipping this to college and just leave it at home for a
1:59:57semester and then worry about next year yeah you'll drive it up in the rental van right i'll have to
2:00:02i may have to get a u-haul for this thing it is very big i mean it's not bigger than mac pro sizes
2:00:07it looks about no i guess not no i think it's probably about that size hopefully it's lighter
2:00:11than a mac pro i've i have only owned one big desktop computer in my entire life i i had fresh
2:00:20out of college so it was probably the summer of 1996 i bought a power mac 9600 350 which i used
2:00:31the hell out of for oh man probably six seven years a long time never got to at the time they
2:00:41were talking i think maybe it was 97 when i bought it because maybe they were already promises maybe
2:00:47the next thing had already happened but they said it would run mac os 10 before it was called mac
2:00:53os 10. is that around rhapsody yeah yeah rhapsody would run but it never did i was well g3 i think
2:00:59you had to have a g3 to run mac os 10 and the power mac 9600 was 604 or something yeah i believe
2:01:08i love that computer though man that was that was a good computer but man you get that computer what
2:01:14job did you have that gave you enough money to buy that thing it was expensive i i got it after
2:01:20i think i got it after it was discontinued or after maybe after the g3s had come out
2:01:26and so i didn't buy it when it was the top of the line and it just come out but i knew enough to
2:01:32know that it was better than like i i got it and i think it was like mac connection one of those one
2:01:38of the catalogs and they just they had like a fire sale on it and i was like holy shit this is an
2:01:43amazing deal right so i whatever i paid for it was far less than the original retail yet it was still
2:01:50utterly relevant performance wise and lasted me without uh any complaint for years because it was
2:01:58such a beast of a machine but i never again bought a desktop that's where you and i share so many so
2:02:07much that you like that i like and i like that you like but our preference for computers could not be
2:02:12more you don't even have a mac studio in the house somewhere nope well unless i have a review unit i
2:02:17forgot to send back which is possible but i don't have one that i use i should that's what i should
2:02:22do for my podcast setup instead of this yeah i mean yes the laptop is silly although actually
2:02:27though i don't studio would be overkill though for my podcast setup a mac mini would be fine
2:02:32i mean there are many yeah either way i was just like desktops that are less obtrusive now
2:02:36i got my wife on a studio i think she likes it yeah no and i think i i have owned a mac mini
2:02:42i forget what i bought one years ago so i i say desktop meaning yeah yeah case but boy this pc is
2:02:50a beast do you have any piece you you don't what's the gaming situation with your kids no no pc is in
2:02:56this household i've never i came real close years and years ago came really close to getting a
2:03:00shuttle pc you know that company no i don't think so they make very small form factor pcs i think
2:03:07sff was the small form factor they're they're kind of like shoe boxes right the idea is you get a pc
2:03:13into it i mean it was it was also the days before video cards were so massive and took so much power
2:03:19but back when you could actually fit a gaming video card in a slim shoebox size case without exotic
2:03:24cooling because they were neat looking it was oh it's like a mac mini kind of like you you cram all
2:03:29these components there you just pick the ones that you want it doesn't take up too much room in your
2:03:32desk i'm like you know what i can get a gaming pc shove it off to the corner and use my same desk
2:03:35and have a kvm these are all things that were possible when briefly there was an overlap between
2:03:41pc hardware and mac hardware like they were both using vga connectors and they were both using
2:03:46similar buses or you could you could get a kvkvm they could switch between them right but that
2:03:51fever passed i never did actually buy it and then the world's diverged again and so no no gaming pcs
2:03:57so i've got my playstation 5 which is what i do most of my gaming on on a gaming monitor
2:04:01and i do play games on my mac it is still an intel mac i do have a big apple ridiculously expensive
2:04:07apple video card in there i do have windows 10 on an ssd that i boot from and i can play windows
2:04:13games and if any mac games gets it i could play them as well yeah how much of a factor is that
2:04:19in your i mean and longtime listeners of atp know you held on to your previous mac pro for a
2:04:25ridiculously long time absurdly long time comically long time while waiting for them to come out with
2:04:31the next generation mac pro and then bought a very nice one for yourself but how much of your
2:04:37still using the intel mac pro is based on the fact that you can game on it i mean it is kind of like
2:04:42i kind of like i'm feeling like i'm saying goodbye you know what i mean because i know this is not
2:04:46going to be the case for the next one so might as well write that and also i don't really feel
2:04:50pressure to make this decision because apple's going to make it for me when they stop supporting
2:04:54intel with mac os like that'll happen and whatever that happens i'll get an m4 mac studio or something
2:05:00like unless they do something very different with the mac pro i'm no longer interested in that
2:05:04machine because it doesn't give me any of the things that i want out of a machine that size
2:05:07and price and i do like the mac studio i just hope you know who knows what the game situation
2:05:13will be like by then but yeah i'm kind of enjoying this one while i have it because i know this will
2:05:17be this is the end of an era there could be a new era someday i'm always rooting for this there's
2:05:22not a lot of signs that it's happening we're always rooting for you know what microsoft and windows
2:05:26should also come over to arm so that max could once again natively boot windows on i know windows
2:05:30and arm exists but it's the the hegemony of x86 is still such that it's all it's got a long way to go
2:05:37before like quote-unquote pc games are binaries that run natively in arm windows right do you
2:05:45think i'm optimistic i know that and i don't want to rehash deep speculation about the future of
2:05:52apple silicon but the idea is that the current mac pro with apple silicon just is not all that pro
2:06:01really i mean compared to the mac studio right it kind of is a mac studio in a bigger case much
2:06:06bigger case and because it's apple silicon there's not as much stuff that you can put in a case that
2:06:13you could do on the intel like you said you've got some kind of monster what kind of gpu do you have
2:06:19what i have the the pro vega 2 mpx module that apple sells that's one of the one of the great
2:06:24things about this computer is the horrendously expensive video cards that apple sells are giant
2:06:29and cost way too much money no fans on them right no fans just the biggest heat sink you've ever
2:06:34seen in your life but no fans so by i at one point i had multiple gpu's in there at various points
2:06:40none of those gpu's had fans in them adding another gpu would not increase the fan noise
2:06:45unless heated them up so i love this machine for that but that is yeah yeah i feel like it
2:06:50even though it's the the smallest selling by quantity mac that apple makes by definition of
2:06:57it being super expensive and really only optimized for pros it also really was sort of exemplified
2:07:03apple's design ideals versus the rest of the x86 makers if you wanted to see what would a pc look
2:07:10like if apple made one like this machine this i don't know if you've seen i mean you have probably
2:07:14one that oh yeah see whatever like the inside of this machine is immaculate yeah there are no wires
2:07:20no it's not like the no visible wires like they hid them behind things there are no wires it's
2:07:25like a work of art in there it really is and they're even the cards are even pretty they're
2:07:30blue not green no yeah everything is beautiful and color matched and that's why you buy the apple
2:07:35video card for 20 times the real price and it's like it has no fans it comes in this huge module
2:07:40and it snaps in and it's got this proprietary connector the mpx module that gives you the
2:07:44extra power so you don't have to have the extra power leads yeah i love that stuff i just it
2:07:49pushes all my buttons i'm going to be sad when i get this replaced with a max studio which is
2:07:55its own in its own right a cute little machine but not the cathedral to personal computers that this
2:08:00thing is now when that when your intel mac pro shipped and fulfilling the promise of okay we've
2:08:06completely rethought our approach to the pro market where we're coming back with pro max
2:08:12we'll have a pro imac for you by the end of this year and then the next year they came out with
2:08:17this they went no pulled no stops to show off to we in the media the internals they were they're
2:08:24super proud of it but it's it exemplifies apple's design ideals way better than their laptops do
2:08:30because a an intel macbook looks so much like an hp laptop because all the other companies that
2:08:39make these aluminum laptops just copy what macbook airs look like and you don't see the inside of the
2:08:44inside no apple and the inside of the apple laptops are in general better looking than the insides of
2:08:49pc laptops but they're still kind of ugly because you got to cram everything in there it's like the
2:08:53inside of an iphone you can't afford to make it pretty but when you've got as much space as in a
2:08:57tower computer like it's gaming pc's obviously do this those are like little cathedrals to rgb
2:09:01lights with their hard cooling tubes carefully arranged and everything but that's a whole
2:09:06different aesthetic this is the apple aesthetic for a tower personal computer and it's just so
2:09:12expensive and so low volume and so needless quote unquote needless like it doesn't make the computer
2:09:18any faster but it makes it nicer it makes it more beautiful it makes it like a work of art this is i
2:09:22do love this machine i'll miss it it and it's probably one of the last johnny i-visms i mean
2:09:30because it's certainly the tail end of his time but the way that they hollowed out those circles
2:09:37around the case and trust me they spent a lot of time talking to us in the media about how much
2:09:42how much time it takes to to make one of those cases and now they've that it's apple silicon
2:09:47it's just like a mac studio running inside this beautiful with a bunch of card slots it's just
2:09:52just a desert in there right and i get it i know it's it for people with tremendous i/o needs it is
2:10:01more pro than a mac studio so for there's video certainly like video production type people who
2:10:06are pushing around 4k or even 8k video footage in which is enormous and you want lots of storage
2:10:13inside it so if i/o is your problem the mac pro actually is a legit upgrade but only because the
2:10:20next best thing has zero slots right because like the pci the pc a number of pci lanes and the
2:10:26bandwidth available in the current mac pro is actually less than it was i mean it's not less
2:10:31because it's a newer version of pci but it's not decked out oh you'll just a huge amount of
2:10:36bandwidth it's better than zero cards so you take what you can get and you can put big honking things
2:10:42inside there that you couldn't connect to a thunderbolt connector for example but it's not
2:10:46even like they said okay well it's just the mac studio but we really went overboard with the with
2:10:51the pci they didn't they just did sort of the minimum possible to get pci slots plus an m2 ultra
2:10:58and it's kind of disappointing so i do think though my my takeaway from the introduction of
2:11:04the m3 a couple months ago and the way that they've clearly rethought what the pro and the max are
2:11:14compared to the regular where the pro is not just half of a max anymore right the max is sort of a
2:11:22totally different thing the pro used to not be half of max the per used to be a max with some gpu cores
2:11:27chopped off and that was right right that was and now it is it's a totally different system on a chip
2:11:32much much different than something simplistic like that and i know that sounds simplistic but it
2:11:37really was it was just the max with some gpu cores bend out but then that chopped off like physically
2:11:44physically yeah is that because like if you believe apple's die shots you could overlay the
2:11:49pro onto the max and you would see you would cover up all of the max except for the bottom part where
2:11:53there was more gpu cores there was a project so what the ultimate is right now is the m2 ultra
2:12:02and what there was a rumor that there would be like an ultra plus i don't know who they're
2:12:08running out of adjectives but something that would be like two ultras together well that was the
2:12:13original rumor with the m1 that you would get the you get the m1 and then you would get the m1 max
2:12:17and you get the m1 ultra and then you get something that was essentially two m1 ultras or four m1 maxes
2:12:23together what do you what would the adjective be what's more than ultra i think the that was the
2:12:28jade 4c die i think that thing was canned before marketing got a chance to name any of these so
2:12:34marketing was probably never faced with the problem of what are you going to call all these
2:12:39with the quad one in there i think maybe that would have been ultra right yeah or extreme or
2:12:45who knows yeah extreme apple's names are terrible well they're terrible but they're also funny and
2:12:51what comes around goes around right i mean who knows they might still make now that they've gone
2:12:56back to just apple books there might be an iBook again who knows yeah seemingly done keep waiting
2:13:01they're seemingly done with the i prefix but who knows if they'll bring it back so they've made
2:13:06extreme products before i they could do it again but it is funny because the one that makes me
2:13:11laugh is max because max means max it's the maximum well and it also rhymes with max it also
2:13:18rhymes with max so it's actually like i've all as soon as they named it i've said all the time it is
2:13:23the worst product name ever for podcasting it works perfectly fine when you're in print and it
2:13:30is the worst the max with the max chip is really just horrible to speak but the way that they've
2:13:38clearly rethought the relationship of the different tiers at least in the macbook pros gives me more
2:13:45optimism that they're not giving up on your professed goal which i agree with to just
2:13:51it's it's a worthy goal even if the market is tiny to just make the fastest computer that anybody can
2:13:59buy on the market or at least try to the way i always characterize it is right now in apple
2:14:04silicon apple has given up trying to even compete in that high end if you think of the highest npc
2:14:11cpu the highest npc gpu apple has nothing that is even trying to compete with it which is a shame
2:14:18because it's not like they don't have the technology to do it but they're just not interested
2:14:21in that market and they always used to at least try to compete at any time in the past you look
2:14:26at apple's lines of computers they're fielding and you would say if you get the most expensive one it
2:14:30is in the conversation with the most expensive pc with the most expensive graphics card or whatever
2:14:36is it always the fastest that's obviously usually not the the best bang for the buck or whatever but
2:14:40they were in the conversation and now it's like the ultra compared to a single top end nvidia
2:14:46video card it's not really in the conversation well my son's goofy gaming pc upstairs probably
2:14:52right yeah for sure you get a 40 90 versus the ultra it's not a contest i mean and i say goofy
2:14:58it was like four thousand dollars so it's so almost as much as a good mac laptop yeah
2:15:05almost as much as mine right but i do i have optimism that they haven't given up on that goal
2:15:12and we just it just sucks for us being on the outside without ever hearing of their plans because
2:15:20it there's something going on there where they're not just phoning it in on the above or on the
2:15:29pattern of what is an m3 compared to an m2 they clearly rethought that so whether the m3
2:15:36generation will be the one where the whatever the maximum that they can stick in the mac pro chassis
2:15:42is i don't i i wouldn't be surprised if this isn't the year but maybe the m4 series will be i don't
2:15:47know it seems we're talking about this on atp if you look at the m3 max chip like the dive shots
2:15:53that apple gives you it looks very much like the m2 max and the m1 max in terms of where the crap
2:15:59is arranged and we know with the m1 max and the m2 max the stuff was arranged so you could stick
2:16:03another one to it end to end and make an ultra out of it because that's where they connect with
2:16:07the silicon interposer and if you look at how the m2 max is laid out it's laid out so that you could
2:16:13take another m2 max stick at the end and make an ultra and what we know about the the the previous
2:16:18ones the m1 and the m2 is that they didn't have a way to connect four of them right and i think the
2:16:24m3 max being end to end with another m3 max to make an m3 ultra is going to happen it will be
2:16:30available in the max studio uh and they have no way to connect four of them and so if there is
2:16:35going to be there if they're going to take a run at this i think it's going to have to wait at least
2:16:40until the m4 and some of the vague rumors that i heard from my vague sources was like forget about
2:16:45anything that's four of these things connected until past the m7 because that's how long these
2:16:50roadmaps are and they kind of gave up on it right and i kind of understand that because it's look
2:16:54why do we need to do that for every application realm that we care about you get acceptable
2:16:59performance from an ultra and who cares if it's not in the conversation with the fastest nva
2:17:03gaming card we don't care about that market anyway and we the frame rates you get are acceptable
2:17:09and we're not used to we're never on a computer same thing with the gpu's you can buy that amd
2:17:13i think the reason your son was interested in amd well probably not for gaming but amd offers
2:17:17cpu's that have huge numbers of cores so does intel for that matter more than you more cores
2:17:21than you can get an ultra that have higher multi-core scores than the ultra but apple
2:17:27sample we don't need that none of the applications we care about would take enough advantage of that
2:17:31for it to be worth the cost it's the bargain apple got for itself now that they make their own socs
2:17:35now they make their own chips they can make just the chips they want until it comes time to make
2:17:40the one for their top of the line products and they're like how much is it going to cost us to
2:17:44make that and how many of those do we sell oh and it was kind of easier when intel could sell their
2:17:48xeons to every like server farm in the world and apple could benefit from that and yeah they would
2:17:53pay through the teeth for the profit margins on those intel xeons but they didn't have to pay for
2:17:57the r and d for those xeons and intel paid for the rnd for those xeons so they could sell a million
2:18:02of them to data centers and also by the way sell them to apple with a huge margin on them and it's
2:18:06not like okay well now that we don't have to do that we don't have to pay intel's margins we can
2:18:10make our own xeons oh that costs way too much money that costs way too much money for the
2:18:14number of mac pros that we sell so i don't know how they square this i think they should do it
2:18:17and just suck it up as the r and d center for like pushing the envelope and mac performance but i'm
2:18:23not optimistic about re-engaging with the high end for many more years if they've even decided they
2:18:28want to do it but of course we don't know if they've even decided they want to do it it's just
2:18:32what we're hearing and what we're seeing externally is don't hold your breath for a long time yeah i
2:18:36often trot out the analogy that and i think you have too that it's like consumer car brands making
2:18:43race cars honda has a race car team yeah mercedes is just a giant money pit it is a money pit but
2:18:49the other thing that the race cars at least have is at least they can justify it on marketing
2:18:54grounds where people actually there are millions of races see the millions and millions of yeah
2:18:58millions and millions of people around the world love to watch f1 racing and and it's a you know
2:19:03it's sensation on netflix and so there's some you know you could justify it marketing wise nobody
2:19:08no there are no thousands of fans waiting to watch john syracuse with the the m4 extreme yeah although
2:19:17i mean there is an equivalent version of that kind of there's esports right and people know about
2:19:22nvidia and they know about famous gamers and they know about streamers and there is a place to put
2:19:26your name out in front of people as a high performance brand it's not the same as formula one
2:19:31but that like the marketing and the image behind nvidia because of their dominance in gaming and
2:19:36because of how popular gaming is in the mainstream media that is a thing unfortunately nvidia is not
2:19:41really a consumer company that's also trying to sell you like iphones or whatever but right
2:19:44yeah i could definitely make the case for apple to try to do this but it would be a
2:19:49a apple style argument which is like long-term big picture don't think about short-term roi
2:19:57like all the sort of touchy feely things the same reason they do all the environmental stuff and all
2:20:00the other things they do but you can't make the argument for it as in do this now and at the end
2:20:05of the year you'll make x amount of dollars because you won't all right and even with the
2:20:09environmental stuff i kind of feel like you can say this actually is good for business because
2:20:16it's long term yeah right well i and i definitely long term and i think the younger people are the
2:20:22more they actually make their buying decisions based on stuff like that so i don't really i
2:20:28don't i didn't look at the emissions of my macbook pro when i bought it but younger people do and
2:20:34they care about it and knowing apple's trustworthy and saying what's their promise 2030 they're going
2:20:38to be carbon neutral across the board uh yeah and yet still they haven't cancelled the car project
2:20:44somehow i don't i don't understand that i mean i think you guys again i think you guys mentioned
2:20:49that on atp that it seemed that it seems like impossible i don't i it could be the most most
2:20:55energy efficient cars ever made but i don't see how you build and ship cars in a carbon neutral
2:21:00way i but i guess that's neither here nor there the other thing i'm hopeful i do think i think
2:21:07apple is in the way that all companies take on the personality of their founders and in for better or
2:21:14for worse apple is and always will be in some ways steve jobs's company and he's a very spiteful man
2:21:21i do think the fact that apple everybody knows does not like nvidia it can only help right it's
2:21:31man it must bother them in some ways that a company they do not get along with kicks their
2:21:38ass on gpu and happened there there was the whole thermal corner with the trash can but the whole
2:21:45thing it's the way that apple 10 years ago with the trash can mac pro underestimated the next
2:21:53decade of the importance in size of gpu's physical size it the whole ai thing and gpu as the more
2:22:02important processor processing unit of all your pus in your computer the way that the gpu is
2:22:10preeminent over the cpu now i would have never guessed it 20 years ago you'd think apple should
2:22:18have been a position to guess it but they're so they're in their own little world where they didn't
2:22:23but it must bother them now right so here they are today and i think it's clear and i know you
2:22:28called me out i know i misspoke on certain details when the m3 came out about like the single highest
2:22:36single threaded performance that you can pay you can throw enough money at intel or amd and maybe
2:22:41beat the m3 not maybe yes definitely well you can and and like you said with the multi-core you can
2:22:49get things from them with so many cores that of course the multi-core performance is going to win
2:22:54because it's it's ginormous it's closer than you would think it is that's the frustrating thing
2:22:58same thing with the gpu that that if you look at what apple does even with the ai stuff like
2:23:02that recently they have those new recompiling libraries to take advantage of apple silicon
2:23:06and neural engine they yeah their performance first of all their performance for a while is
2:23:09amazing second of all the overall performance they're punching way above their weight class
2:23:13the problem is there's this hulking monster that is seven times as big and it's oh apple if you
2:23:18just made one that was twice as big as you have now you could compete because what you're doing
2:23:23with what you got is amazing but nvidia is like this takes 500 watts and fills it's bigger than
2:23:28an entire max studio and costs 1500 and we're they're winning by brute force right it's like
2:23:35they're an nvidia is asking you how close do you live to your power station right like it's we're
2:23:39not you know you don't have to do things the nvidia way like and that must be frustrating
2:23:43to people involved because they're like we have the technology we have if we just doubled the
2:23:48number of gpu cores extrapolate linearly from our performance now but but no we don't have a way to
2:23:54package that and in an soc right i i do think it's fair to say again i misspoke on certain technical
2:24:00details and you were you as usual were correct on those details but i think apple can rightly say
2:24:06can rightly hold itself up and say we are the preeminent cpu designers in the world today our
2:24:12cpu's maybe our top single threaded score isn't the best it's not and maybe we can get beat on
2:24:19multi-core for whatever but we're good on cpu's we feel they're good at it i don't know if they
2:24:24could say the preeminent they're very good at it but based on their priorities they are the
2:24:28best yeah whereas they even by their own priorities they cannot possibly say that they're the best gpu
2:24:34makers well you have to ask what their priorities are because they're like well everything we need
2:24:37to do with our gpu's we find that the m3 ultra will it was acceptable and everything is okay
2:24:43but what if you want to play a high-end game with the maximum frame rate so we don't want to do that
2:24:47we or they could be like rolls royce we think 60 frames per second is adequate
2:24:51and gamers are like i need 240 frames per second now right it it's it's just you just know that
2:24:58they're they're wrong they're behind on this when you're saying well it's the apple thing and the
2:25:04most frames per second the frame rate doesn't matter we don't even sell displays that have
2:25:08that refresh rate anyway that's that is not the apple way saying that frame rate doesn't matter
2:25:12right the company that first went to retina for resolution the company that had the smooth still
2:25:19has by far the smoothest scrolling on phones i don't know i'm sitting in front of a very
2:25:23expensive apple monitor that refreshes 60 hertz so well it's you should just do all your computing
2:25:31on a phone or a laptop screen only 120 like 240 hertz exists right well anyway they've and again
2:25:40it's good for apple to be behind somewhere i think i mean i think one of the as a fan of the company
2:25:47and a fan of their ideals and the priorities that they have it's been good to see them succeed but
2:25:54when there's when the second place competitor in factor x that you care about is so far behind
2:26:01it's easy to get lazy and it's so it's good to see them behind on gpu's but it is an open question
2:26:08whether they care because the market for the number of people who who want to pay thousands
2:26:14and thousands of dollars for the gpu to put in their mac pro is so small i don't know but i'm
2:26:22at least talking to one of them right yeah no i mean so the thing is with the end of the intel
2:26:28era the question is if you had an arm mac with an nvda class gpu what would you play on it what kind
2:26:34of games would you play where would you get the games from that you play on that because if you're
2:26:38thinking you're going to play windows games those don't run natively on arm right and so are you
2:26:43going to play the the plethora of mac native games it's not really a lot of those out there either so
2:26:48it's a difficult situation and that's i and that just it's a self-fulfilling prophecy if apple
2:26:53doesn't serve this market it doesn't make computers to do it people won't make games
2:26:56for it and it's a spiral that goes downward and that's kind of what we're caught in right now
2:26:59do you i do think as a final point i do think apple is at a very high level more interested in
2:27:09the fixing this question of mac gaming than they have been i think ever really now i don't know
2:27:16that not ever don't you remember game sprockets and input sprockets oh yeah that was way they
2:27:21were making libraries and quick draw 3d not sprite kit quickdraw 3d input sprockets like that whole
2:27:29thing they had all these libraries where they're going to make it easier to make mac native games
2:27:32and a whole department doing it it was also equally misguided and terrible but that showed
2:27:37them that was the most interest i think they ever had i mean they made the pippin game console for
2:27:40crying out loud also completely misguided but that was their peak of interest you're right that
2:27:47currently they are more interested than they have been have been in the past i don't know decade or
2:27:52so but they're not at input sprockets and quickdraw 3d level yet the argument i've heard from people
2:28:00at apple which i can't quote but probably i'm not even supposed to paraphrase but in an off the
2:28:06record briefings but the argument from them and i do find part of this true now whether this will
2:28:10actually lead to anything or not but my question this was when the m3s came out a couple months
2:28:18ago in the macbooks and they had stuff to talk they didn't spend a lot of time talking about
2:28:22games but they mentioned it but i my question was framed along the lines of you guys are talking
2:28:29about games and the game the future of this is better but isn't it counterintuitive that you're
2:28:34saying gaming is better on apple silicon than when the mac was on x86 which is the platform
2:28:41that all the games are written for and their answer was that they thought basically the one of
2:28:49one of if not the single biggest problem mac gaming has faced is the size of the addressable
2:28:54market and that when the mac was on intel that whole era the addressable market for serious
2:29:02gaming on mac was just a tiny subset of the mac market because so many macs were running were
2:29:11laptops running on the shitty intel integrated graphics which are just terrible and so that the
2:29:18addressable market for max that might be reasonable to run a game at a pretty good resolution at a
2:29:26really good frame rate is way bigger in the apple silicon era than it ever was going to be on the
2:29:31intel era and that they think that will get the attention of game makers i mean they're right up
2:29:36to the point where they have the conclusion and therefore we will now succeed where we've really
2:29:40failed it is true that they have raised the bar but like gaming very much like we mentioned the
2:29:44formula one gaming is very much a market where even if most people don't have the high-end card
2:29:49because it's expensive and you can't even get them it is aspirational and so you have to have
2:29:54you have to have the high-end card available even though most gamers are going to have the two steps
2:29:58down last year's model in their gaming pcs and there's just so many other problems they need to
2:30:03address like it is they have we've talked about this in atp the floor for gaming performance on
2:30:07max is higher than it has ever been because even the cheapest crappiest exact you get has better
2:30:13but that is that is just one tiny thing you need to address but there's so much more just so much
2:30:18more i mean think of it this way if you could make 100 of the current mac installed base any cpu
2:30:25intel max arm any mac that anyone is using anywhere on the planet suddenly those things
2:30:30have adequate performance to play games still a that might not be enough people to make a dent
2:30:36and b do the people who have those computers even think of the idea of playing a game on them
2:30:44and then see if they had that thought where would they find that game because all their friends are
2:30:47playing in certain name of game x would it occur to them to get it oh go you can play that on your
2:30:53mac how do i get it on my mac where do i buy it from is it available for a mac and the answer is
2:30:56no you can't it's not available for the mac for use from apple will show a keynote where you can
2:31:01play a game that all your friends played four years ago running at reasonable frame rates on
2:31:05your mac but that's not they're so far from success in this market and it's going to take
2:31:10so much for them to get there i what they're doing is they're not wrong that they did a good thing
2:31:14it is better than it was but this is such a huge mountain for them to climb and they're just really
2:31:21taking baby steps up the foothills of it right and apple arcade is really a sort of iphone first yeah
2:31:29that's a whole different thing for what it is apple arcade i think is doing what it has to do
2:31:33and serving its purpose but that is very different than the quote-unquote pc gaming market right we're
2:31:37not out here trying to convince apple they need to be interested in the pc gaming market they have
2:31:41apparently convinced themselves that they're interested in the quote-unquote pc gaming market
2:31:45they just have absolutely no idea how to get from where they are to be competitive in the pc gaming
2:31:51market and so they're doing some things that are moves in the right direction but what a hill to
2:31:56climb for them and a cultural more than technical really i mean ultimately yeah you can't you can't
2:32:03really have i mean i always use microsoft as the example of this like surely there are people in
2:32:07apple there that really are for this right just like it at microsoft there was a small group of
2:32:12people who said we should totally make a game console and i'm sure there were tons of people
2:32:17microsoft has said no we should not make a game console but the people who wanted to make xbox
2:32:22eventually made a go of it and even if there are still naysayers inside the organization there is
2:32:28no doubt within the xbox organization that those people who are working on the xbox are like this
2:32:33is a thing we want to do and they microsoft spent billions of dollars in many years and worked so
2:32:39hard to essentially be the second place or possibly third place in in that market but you can't no one
2:32:45denies that microsoft is a player in the game console market right and that is a thing that
2:32:50they made happen a small group of people happen despite an organization that was somewhat hostile
2:32:54to them within apple i feel like the group of people who want to do this is smaller and so much
2:32:59more of the organization is hostile either unknowingly hostile because they have bad ideas
2:33:03about how to achieve it or knowingly hostile and they say we should not be doing this at all it's
2:33:07stupid right and they're not going to it doesn't almost it's the person who maybe should be if they
2:33:13wanted to most involved wouldn't be like suruji or turnis or somebody or even fedorigi don't say
2:33:20any q i was gonna say eddie q i know you're gonna to to do for games what he did for video content
2:33:28for shows i mean i get what you're getting at what you need is someone who knows how to make deals and
2:33:32do business stuff and how to throw money around right yeah you need but you also need someone
2:33:36who knows the gaming industry if you look at the people who made the xbox happen in microsoft they
2:33:40all you have to have game industry inside kind of like when apple made tv shows they didn't hire
2:33:44people who like they hired people who knew how to make tv shows they found hey who's who's good at
2:33:48producing television and movie content right but they didn't say they report to eddie q so it
2:33:53wouldn't be eddie you know it'd be eddie as in a way for content eddie q is sort of like a ceo
2:34:00within apple right he's like ceo of the content services and i think he's very good at it and i
2:34:06think in a very humble way i think in a very humble way they went out and they hired people
2:34:12x hbo people to run to to have that expertise and he said it's like people never go back i do the
2:34:20claim chowder bit but there were all this stuff before apple tv came out and their first two shows
2:34:27like literally carpool karaoke and then there was the one that was planet of the apps planet of the
2:34:32apps right it was like what's that shark shark tank yeah not an auspicious start right it was
2:34:37well it was worse than carpool karaoke but those didn't exemplify what apple tv plus is all about
2:34:45right and before tv plus came out there were a couple of stories that like hey apple is meddling
2:34:50with these people they're telling them tim cook's telling them to take out the dirty words and they
2:34:55didn't like the gang violence into one show and they want everything to be nice and they're
2:35:00sending these awful notes and that people in hollywood hate it and this is going to be a
2:35:05disaster and then it turned out not to be true their shows are great i mean i think pound for
2:35:11pound arguably the highest quality of any streaming service and without question one of the highest
2:35:18average qualities of original content and you don't see those stories anymore you actually i've
2:35:24seen well you got the john stewart story right yeah but i had you heard you i talked about this
2:35:30i guess with ben but yeah i mean so here's the thing i meddling with the content is not the thing
2:35:35that we're worried about because think of nintendo nintendo famously it was like no no blood on our
2:35:40consoles we don't want this type right it doesn't matter as long as you make good games right it
2:35:44doesn't matter as long as you make good shows it's fine to have an ethos and enforce it and say this
2:35:49is the kind of movies you want these are the kind of movies we don't there is room for you to be a
2:35:52pixar pixar doesn't make every kind of movie in the world they make a certain kind of movie that
2:35:57fits with their studio that's fine the problem is are you going to find the people who know how to
2:36:02make a good movie period you can set the boundaries we want our movies to be this kind of movie for
2:36:06these audiences with this kind of subject matter we don't want to anger china like whatever you
2:36:10want to do fine there's plenty of people making entertainment you don't have to be all things to
2:36:13all people but you do have to do and i guess you're right that eddie q did have the wisdom
2:36:17to say hey you know who we should hire to make movies and tv shows people who know how to make
2:36:21movies and tv shows yeah but they have thus far not done not said you know what we should do to
2:36:26make the mac into a gaming platform and i this is an atp i think the big barrier is probably
2:36:31that in order to make the mac into a good gaming platform not only do you need to hire people who
2:36:37know the game industry to do all like the schmoozing and the deals and finding which
2:36:40studio you're gonna buy which exclusives you're gonna get but unfortunately to make the mac a
2:36:45good gaming platform you also have to talk to the people who run the mac and get them to do things
2:36:52for you so you're going to come to c-fed or whoever else is controlling this internist or whatever and
2:36:56say oh and by the way as part of this initiative way over here at eddie q's organization we need
2:37:01you to do this to the hardware and this to the software and it's a top priority they're going
2:37:04to be like whoa whoa whoa you don't control what goes into the mac you're over there in eddie's
2:37:09org we decide what goes into the mac you're like but you don't understand for me to pull off my job
2:37:13to do it with apple tv you don't have to have a lot of influence on the apple tv team you're just
2:37:17gonna be able to show freaking video right right right but to do it on the mac suddenly now you're
2:37:21interfacing with organizations in apple that are massively entrenched they do not want you telling
2:37:26them what they need to do the silicon organization the mac the mac operating system and none of those
2:37:32organizations want this fledgling gaming is apple tv came and told the mac team they had to change
2:37:38everything about what they were doing to help the apple tv effort we don't even know if your thing
2:37:42is to succeed i'm not changing the silicon we're planning seven years from now for this i'm not
2:37:46changing i'm not putting open gl back into my operating system you don't make those decisions
2:37:50and that is one of the many institutional barriers that's keeping apple away from being decent at
2:37:55games yeah it's a good point that basically they could go all in with tv plus and needed no buy-in
2:38:04from the software or hardware didn't have to tell them what to do just give us a streaming box it's
2:38:09not too complicated can you play video it truly was a pure content play and doing that with gaming
2:38:15would not be gaming it would require hardware and software and only apple but maybe that's the way
2:38:22you sell it to convince tim cook that only apple could do it or tim apple as some people call him
2:38:28anyway that's got to be about it it's getting close to christmas
2:38:32john i do not have you on the show often enough because i work myself up and i think when
2:38:39syracuse is on the show it's got it i got to bring i got to bring my a-game and then i get
2:38:43too worked up about it and then all of a sudden years go by and you're not here well you should
2:38:47bring your a-game well i need to you're you're because you know you're doing 15 minutes with
2:38:52ben all the time you just gotta think of me like that i'm just like it's just like ben it's like
2:38:56anytime you could just stop it and chat but yeah i do have my own tech podcast so you gotta fit me
2:39:01into the schedule that way i do you've also got what else you have you want to pimp you've got
2:39:05reconcilable differences with uh merlin you haven't had merlin on ages see that's another
2:39:11one i gotta gear up i gotta gear up that's a different kind of show yeah it's a different
2:39:15kind of show and it's a different kind of gearing up but i should have him on i mean you put in a
2:39:19good word for me and see if you can get him to agree to it what else anything else robot or not
2:39:24on the incomparable have you ever listened to robot or not you probably haven't i actually i
2:39:28honestly have never listened to an episode of it's it's very it was very much like dithering before
2:39:32dithering well it's not 15 minutes will you do like five minute two minute episodes three minute
2:39:36episodes these little bite-sized thingies if you start from the beginning you'll get the idea of
2:39:41the show but like super short like tiny nuggets and me being me occasionally we'd have a little
2:39:45bit longer one that goes for 10 minutes or whatever but it's fun i know the problem i
2:39:49know the problem yeah do that with jason snell over on the incomparable yeah and speaking of
2:39:54jason snell you you subbed in for uh mr mike hurley and either the most recent or the most
2:40:00recent episode that i listened to of upgrade which was a real treat yeah he's being he's becoming
2:40:04like uh who is it um terry gross on fresh air that she's not there half the time mike yeah appears he
2:40:10had a whole bunch of subguests coming in to to take up the mike slot he's backing up well that
2:40:15was like uh carson at the end of his career on the yeah it doesn't come in on thursdays yeah you know
2:40:20carson by the end was doing like three shows he was like doing like tuesday wednesday thursday
2:40:24he had a guest host on monday and a rerun on fridays yeah i remember they were like inducting
2:40:29him into the tv hall of fame or something and letterman gave the speech and he said
2:40:33the backbreaking three day a week schedule and literally it was like people just died because
2:40:39carson was like right next to him on the ds and nobody laughed harder than him but yeah that's
2:40:44sort of snow that was really funny well you said there was something i wanted to say about that
2:40:48upgrade but they made me do video that they're ruining the dream of podcasting just like you are
2:40:54yeah maybe all i wrote down is consistency is key oh that's it that's it consistency is key you and
2:41:02jason were talking and giving advice to like up and coming podcasters and about the importance of
2:41:08a consistent publishing schedule and talking about the really staggering run atps had of one episode
2:41:17a week every week for i i don't for over 10 years we do 52 shows a year for over 10 years haven't
2:41:23missed one yet right they never haven't missed one yet and your bastards are sneaking in members only
2:41:29episodes in addition that's right which is which i literally do consider to be a backbreaking schedule
2:41:35which is it's not that bad whereas the talk show schedule is not quite as regimented no well that's
2:41:42what i'm saying who knows how successful hey when you said you were gonna do dithering you do three
2:41:47shows a week i'm like there's no way he's gonna be able to do that like how many talk shows but
2:41:49you've been doing it i guess ben is a well we did switch to two episodes a week oh that's right
2:41:54even so you're doing i'm proud i'm proud of you for and you can't pre-tape the dithering really
2:42:00because they're like about current events and stuff so you're actually doing them like two
2:42:04times a week it's not like you're banking seven of the episodes and then going off to vegas
2:42:07nope and ben travels more than i do and when ben travels he has to travel literally around the
2:42:12globe exactly he's going to work like a taiwan to wisconsin right so there are times where the
2:42:18dithering schedule and again and ben is a very nice friend and gracious partner but you know he's
2:42:25like can you do the morning on thursday and i'm like well where are you going to be and he's like
2:42:29i'm going to be coming off a 17-hour flight from and i'm like oh yeah i'll wake up for this i'll do
2:42:34it really guilt tripping you into waking up before noon right but he's recording from a hotel after a
2:42:4017-hour flight he's recording from his like his is a covid lock there aren't even covid lockdown
2:42:45and like oh yeah they're pushing his food under the door or whatever he's doing those are my
2:42:50favorite episodes yeah he was in some kind of taiwanese prison for me exactly i came back into
2:42:55the that's the show i want to be on i know dithering doesn't have guests but i'll be like
2:42:58every email in your inbox and say you should have me as a guest on dithering even though it's a
2:43:02podcast that doesn't have any guests because i just want to argue with ben about things you'd
2:43:05be at the top of my list for a suggested substitute we don't even have to tell anybody really i don't
2:43:10know that anybody would notice oh they would notice he could he'd just address you as john
2:43:15and there'd be a lot more arguing anyway i will also i thank you for your time i thank you for
2:43:21the excellent podcast you do that i do listen to and i will thank the sponsors of this episode
2:43:26are good friends at squarespace nuts.com and trade coffee thank you john thank you