Podcast Search

The Talk Show

396: ‘The Essence of Stealing’, With David Barnard

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00David Bernard, welcome to the talk show. I'm a terrible podcast host because I've wanted to have

0:00:05you on the show for years. And here we are in 2024, first time on the show. Nice to finally be on.

0:00:15You first covered my apps, and I gotta say thank you, back in the fall of 2008. So we have been

0:00:25corresponding off and on, and you've covered my apps and writings I've done for decades now.

0:00:32So yeah, thanks. What would that app have been? What would 2008 have been for you?

0:00:39I think the very first thing you wrote about was TripCubby, a mileage logging app,

0:00:45because you had lambasted this really poorly designed mileage logging app.

0:00:50It was the only mileage logging app available when the app store first launched. Mine was ready,

0:00:55but Apple hadn't approved my app store account, which to this day, it still kills me.

0:01:01I actually, a funny story. I mean, I thought about going to WWC 2008 because I'd started my company,

0:01:09I was building apps, but it was so much money and I borrowed money from my family to start

0:01:14the company. It was like ultimate bootstrapping. It felt like an insurmountable cost trying to get

0:01:23this business off the ground to go to Cupertino, or I guess back then it was San Francisco still

0:01:29for a week. But had I gone, they were signing up people on the spot and I would have had the app

0:01:36on the app store day one, and you could have been writing about that day one as an alternate to the

0:01:41other one. But I think you wrote back in like August or September of 2008.

0:01:47Yeah, I remember when I mean, it's still expensive, but I mean, I remember when it was a

0:01:53sit down and really talk about it at the table with the CFO of the company, you know, my wife

0:02:00and figure out what the budget is and pulling shenanigans like I don't 2008 I might have

0:02:10already been paying for a badge. But yeah, and I was getting press press badges by then but the

0:02:17press badges were only good for the morning keynote, not even like the afternoon State of

0:02:21the Union. So and I wanted to stay all week and go to sessions. And so eventually for several years

0:02:28in a row, I bought myself a full price ticket, even into the like the lottery years when it was

0:02:35like when it got to the which was very soon after 2008. Like 2008 was the first year first year with

0:02:44iOS apps, because 2007 was the year the iPhone came out. And the only thing they said it WWDC,

0:02:49ironically, was that you could do web apps. Right, which put a put a put a pin in that one. We'll

0:02:58come back to that later in the show. And then 2008, the App Store had been announced like in

0:03:06March. I think that was like the first time JAWS hosted an event. It was like a special

0:03:13Greg JAWS react hosted event. I think that was it. But then did the App Store open before WWDC? Or

0:03:19did it open at W like they announced the SDKs and everything in March, but then they didn't open the

0:03:24App Store till 2000 July 11. So it was like one month after WWDC. So WWDC 2008 was like,

0:03:32on the cusp of the App Store opening. Exactly. Right. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, all those dates are

0:03:39kind of seared in my mind, because I had heard rumors in the fall of 2007. I think it was Steve

0:03:46Jobs even said explicitly, yeah, we're gonna do an SDK at some point. I know it's like a huge

0:03:53Mac nerd at the time. I worked in a recording studio. And so I had, I mean, I was using Macs

0:03:59back in the 90s in the Texas State sound recording technology program where I where I studied and

0:04:05finally bought my own Mac in like 2003. And then as a recording engineer, that's that was a primary

0:04:12tool. And so I had a 17 inch power power Mac, power book, power book, power book, the lunch.

0:04:21Yep. So I was super into all that and started in the fall of 2007, brainstorming, like what

0:04:29possible businesses could I build? And my memory, and maybe we should pause and Google this,

0:04:36but my memory is that it was Steve Jobs who made that full SDK announcement that I watched. And

0:04:43this was back before live streaming. So I believe I watched it the night of, they posted the video

0:04:49the night after whatever small group of press got to see it live. And I started my company

0:04:56like days later. And so I was super inundated and all that stuff starting from March, early March,

0:05:02when the announcement was made. I, as I recall, it was, we don't have to be, it's better to speculate.

0:05:08No, but as I recall, it was in, in WWDC 2007, they announced that the greats, the sweet solution,

0:05:17as they said, for third-party developers for the iPhone was developing web apps,

0:05:22which I called a shit sandwich. And that was, I've told this story before, but in 2007 would have

0:05:29been a year. I was there for the keynote with a press badge and still, I think it was my first

0:05:36WWDC with a press badge and I, it was still, this is the greatest keynote of all time, right? So,

0:05:43and I still think, man, if I had been like one year behind in terms of my popularity, whatever

0:05:51it is that got me, that got somebody writing for a personal blog elevated to the level of the

0:05:59attention of Apple PR, where you could qualify for a press badge. If I'd been like a year behind

0:06:03and missed that one, I'd, I'd, I'd every day at some point, I'd think, God damn it. I missed the

0:06:08best keynote of all time. But that was definitely, that might've been the last year where I didn't

0:06:13pay for a badge for the full conference and a friend who worked at Apple supplied me with an

0:06:21Apple engineer badge. And so for Apple engineers who were like in and out, there were a bunch of

0:06:29badges that didn't have name, personal names on them. They just were like a different color badge.

0:06:34And it just said Apple engineer. And the idea is they only printed so many of them. And people who

0:06:40work at Apple would be like, I think I'm going to swing by on Tuesday, check it out. Somebody else

0:06:44is coming on Thursday, might take that same badge. Well, I, I spent the week with a badge like that.

0:06:50And I would just turn it around. It was only printed on one side. So I would keep it turned

0:06:54around so that anybody who met me and knew me, I did, I just didn't want to talk about the fact

0:06:59that that was my badge. I remember those early days of badge surfing. They've gotten a lot more

0:07:05strict about it, but I I've definitely surfed a few badges and loaned my badge out over the years.

0:07:10Ah, it's sorta like the way I, when I was in college, I pirated a lot of software

0:07:16cause I couldn't afford it. But then once I became a professional and could afford it,

0:07:19I pay for all my software now. I kind of felt that way about that badge. But the funny story

0:07:24was the day after the keynote, it was Tuesday. That was the first time I ever met Phil Schiller

0:07:30personally. And it was on the third floor of Moscone West. Were you ever at Moscone later

0:07:35for WWDC? I was at every WWDC after that until, yeah, I missed a few in 2015, 16 era, but I was

0:07:43there 2009, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14. It's kind of a neat, it really was. I miss it. It's the Moscone

0:07:50West. Moscone West was, is a beautiful building and, and it was perfectly suited for WWDC in my

0:07:56opinion. And I was at the third floor. And so anybody doesn't know it's a three floor thing.

0:08:01The first floor is just sort of a lobby. And I guess the cafeteria is down there. And the

0:08:06cafeteria is sort of also where they'd have a whole bunch of high-speed ethernet set up.

0:08:11So that develop, if you want to download the new X code, the new betas and everything,

0:08:14you can go in there with your MacBook and connect to ethernet and get all that. But the first floor

0:08:20isn't conferency. It's get your badge. There's a place to eat. There's the big room where you can

0:08:24sit. Second and third floors where all the, where all the conference halls are. But you oftentimes,

0:08:30when you're on the third floor, which was where the keynote hall was, and then what they call it,

0:08:35Presidio, they'd smallen it up from the keynote, but it was still like the biggest room. So like

0:08:42at any given time, there's often, at least back then, there was like, what's the main session

0:08:49at 10 o'clock in the morning on Wednesday? Like the one that the most, like what's new in UI kit

0:08:55or something like that, right? Oh man, everybody wants to go to that one. Well, they put it up on

0:08:59the third floor in the big, big hall. So a lot of times when you're leaving, you'd have kind of a

0:09:04zigzag escalator ride, third floor to second, walk around second floor to first. And I was at third

0:09:11floor and right behind me was Phil Schiller with Ron Okamoto, who I think has since left Apple,

0:09:16but was like head of developer relations. And I thought to myself, "Oh, I got to introduce myself."

0:09:22But you know, and at the time I always still had the, "Oh God, what if he has no idea who I am?"

0:09:28Well, whatever, people probably come to Phil Schiller all the time. So I turned around and

0:09:33said, "Hey, Phil, I'm John Gruber." And he definitely knew who I was, obviously red daring

0:09:39fireball instantly. He said, "Hey, great to meet you." And then the next word, really, really nice,

0:09:43really friendly. And he said, next words out of his mouth were, "Hey, I read your piece on

0:09:47the keynote yesterday. I got to disagree with the shit sandwich." Right away. And then I'm thinking,

0:09:56I'm thinking instantly, "Oh, now I'm wrong-footed." Now he wants to talk about the fact that I call

0:10:02the web absolution as "shit sandwich." Whereas I'd been coming from, "Does he even know who I am?"

0:10:10too instantly. Now he hates me. No, but he was totally Phil. He was very, he said it with a smile

0:10:17on his face, but he obviously meant that he disagreed with it. And instantly I thought,

0:10:21"Which way is my badge turned right now? And how weird would it be if I looked down?" And I did,

0:10:31I sort of like looked down as little as I could and saw that it was turned to the white side. So

0:10:36that was, I was in the clear at explaining that. And then we had like a little, it lasted long

0:10:43enough that when we got down to the lobby, we stopped and kept talking. And I remember too,

0:10:48after talking about the web app thing, we talked about the big announcement in 2008 was enterprise

0:10:55support in iOS, right? So that you could get first-class Microsoft Exchange support in the

0:11:02settings app, which obviously surprised me. And then he explained why it wasn't,

0:11:07shouldn't be surprising. And that they really saw already first year that iPhone was going to be

0:11:13way bigger than the Mac was in traditional enterprise, quote unquote, "enterprise

0:11:19companies." And it was just a really interesting conversation, but yeah.

0:11:23How was your relationship with Apple back in those early days? Cause I thought you were going to say

0:11:28something about your scoops cause you back then were a bit more of a Apple spoiler with spoiling

0:11:36all the things that were coming. When was that? Maybe around 20, 12, 13,

0:11:41you started drifting away from kind of spoiling. It was never contentious at all. And my impression

0:11:50is that while Apple, and I've talked about it with Phil and I've definitely brought it up with

0:11:58Jaws and Federighi in the years since just sort of on stage when I've been interviewing them in

0:12:05the live show about leaks and the thing that angers them and it's the way that Jaws and Phil,

0:12:13you can just see how Jaws worked as Phil's right-hand man for so long before taking over

0:12:19the role. They're so aligned. They're not alike. Well, they each have their own very distinctive

0:12:25personalities, but in terms of the way they think about their work and Apple's role,

0:12:30they're so aligned and the thing that infuriates them aren't the people who publish the leaks.

0:12:37It's the people inside the company who do the leaking that that's the betrayal. And it's the

0:12:44only thing they're angry about. So nobody was ever angry with me. I talked to, I had a really

0:12:48interesting, I went to lunch with Bertrand after he left Apple. It was like the first year

0:12:54after Craig took over as the head of software engineering and Bertrand Cerlet was, I guess,

0:13:03retired, semi-retired. He sort of became an investor, but he was at WWDC and we went to lunch

0:13:09and he asked me about how I knew certain of the things that I had leaked. And he was really just

0:13:15curious because he thought when his perspective, and I guess it reflected a bunch of other people

0:13:20at his level, was that the things I leaked or spoiled were often very different than what

0:13:26most of the leaks and spoils are before and after. What did I get? I think I got this,

0:13:33the Windows version of Safari, you know, and the way I would do it was I wouldn't say Apple's going

0:13:39to announce a Windows version of Safari. I would just say, here's my spitball ideas for what I'd

0:13:44like to see this year at WWDC the night before. And then I listed a Windows version of Safari.

0:13:51And then I remember that WWDC, the WebKit Safari team, you used to have an annual party,

0:13:58wasn't it Chevy's, but it was somewhere, was that something Bear? It was like a beer place with

0:14:06Bear in the name, sort of across from the W down there on the same, whatever that street is that

0:14:12Moscone's on. Yeah, I've been there, but I can't remember the name either. Thirsty Bear, was that,

0:14:16I think it was Thirsty Bear. And they would just have like an open, you know, hey, if you're WWDC,

0:14:22come meet the WebKit team. And I went there and chatted them up and somebody,

0:14:27their theory was that they blew it because the night before WWDC was when they flipped the switch

0:14:37in the build for the Windows version of Safari to actually use the real user agent string they

0:14:44were going to use. That said, it was Safari from Windows. And up until that point, they'd just,

0:14:50I guess, been using the regular Safari Mac user agent string for all the builds. And when they've

0:14:57made the build that they were going to ship to developers the next day with the actual user

0:15:02agent string, they quick tested a couple sites and they tested Daring Fireball. And they thought

0:15:08that's how they blew it. They were like, is that what happened? And then you saw it in your logs.

0:15:14And I said, it wasn't. And I said, no. And I said, and think about it, what kind of a maniac would

0:15:20I be if every night at midnight, I start looking at my server logs and they're like, yeah, actually,

0:15:26that doesn't make sense. And then they're like, well, how did you know? And I'm like, I can't say.

0:15:29I looked it up. Me.com. I think I got me mobile, me and me.com. I got the name the night before.

0:15:40I don't know. I gave up on that because it just stopped. It wasn't fun. And as I did it,

0:15:48I was growing in popularity and knew more people and knew more things. It almost felt like I was

0:15:55cheating. Yeah. Shooting fish in the barrel. Yeah. Well, I looked up the announcement of the iPhone

0:16:02SDK with Scott forest all believe you. And I both forgot that it was got forest all March 6. He did

0:16:08the, I think Schiller opened it forest all did the meat and then jobs closed it and jobs talk more

0:16:17about the, like the app store itself and the business opportunity and all that kind of stuff.

0:16:22So, so March SDK announcement, is that video still available? I'll put it in show notes if it is.

0:16:28All right. But let's go back to that. What was your developer experience before the iPhone?

0:16:32None, none. So you were, you were a Mac enthusiast and a computer enthusiast,

0:16:41but then the iPhone comes out and it was, I remember the original announcement was just one

0:16:46of those great Steve jobs, open letters, right? Like thoughts on music and the thoughts, thoughts

0:16:52on flash. There are the two big ones. And then I think it was just sort of a, okay, okay, shut up

0:16:58about the SDK. We'll do it. Right. That was, it was like in the fall, right? And there was all of

0:17:05this jailbreaking action going on, which is still amazing to me, like the pre app store development,

0:17:11like Hockenberry had a version of Twitterrific going before there was an SDK. And I remember

0:17:18Lucas Newman. I forget who worked with him on it, but he, Lucas Newman used to work.

0:17:22Was he Steve Troughton Smith? I forget if he was out.

0:17:26Well, Steven has it now, like in the version of lights app, that's currently in the app store

0:17:32is his. I'm not sure if he helped with that original, I mean, obviously Steven Troughton Smith

0:17:37is exactly the sort of developer who could do this sort of black magic of without an SDK,

0:17:44somehow Jerry rigging the tools so that developers could produce Xcode apps using nothing but private

0:17:53API. It was amazing. But there was the first app I remember using was lights out. But I know Lucas

0:18:01Newman was sort of, he was a delicious monster with Will Shipley at the time. But there were

0:18:06developers making apps without any SDK at all, which just seems impossible to me.

0:18:11And then Jobs said, okay, fine, we'll do it. Give us a couple months. We're going to make this super

0:18:17secure. We got to tighten things up and we'll get back to you early next year with this thing.

0:18:22But you're instantly thinking you're you, it just struck you.

0:18:26It struck me as a, as a huge business opportunity. I, and actually I remember specifically

0:18:33listening to Leo LaPorte's This Week in Tech. He had Amber McArthur on the show and they were

0:18:39talking about Facebook apps and how, how many people kind of rode the wave of Facebook apps

0:18:47from the early days. And so I was listening to that. That was maybe like December of 2007.

0:18:53And I thought this iPhone SDK is going to be like that. Like this is, this is a tech wave.

0:19:01It's a, and it's going to be a huge business opportunity. And I, I gotta,

0:19:04I gotta find a way to ride this wave. And, and so at that point I had never, yeah,

0:19:10never developed, never written software. I mean, I had like tinkered in HTML and CSS, like, you know,

0:19:16most nerds at some point build your own website and stuff like that. But in March, I had, I had

0:19:23already started, I had already kind of like done a business plan. I'd already like started like

0:19:27floating the idea to my folks who'd always said, if you want to start a business, we'll, we'll figure

0:19:32out a way to support you. And so within like hours of watching the SDK announcement, I was kicking

0:19:40off a corporation and borrowed 20K from my family to start the company. My parents and my aunt and

0:19:48uncle both pitched in because there's a lot of money. And that that's where the, you know, not

0:19:52going to WWDC. It's like, am I going to take this, this limited, you know, 20K that family put in

0:20:00that they weren't like rich or anything. It was, it was a lot of money to them to put it in the

0:20:03company and, and fly out to WWDC in 2009 and, and decided not to. But yeah, so I just, I hit the

0:20:12ground running as soon as the SDK was announced. And originally my plan was to learn to code.

0:20:19And so I got a big nerd ranch Objective-C book, and I got two or three weeks into it and realized

0:20:29that it was going to take more than three months to learn to code, much less learn to code and

0:20:35build an app. And I didn't have that much runway. My wife was working, but not making much money at

0:20:41the time. That 20K investment from my family was going to run out fairly quick. And so,

0:20:47so I actually ended up hiring a developer, Jonathan Johnson. He's still in tech somewhere.

0:20:52And he had been a long time coca developer, but even he struggled. Anybody writing these days,

0:21:00people just have no idea unless you were there in 2008, just how hard it was because

0:21:05there was an NDA in place. So you couldn't talk in forums. You couldn't write blog posts. There

0:21:12were no books on iOS development. It was, you read the docs and you figured it out. And if you had

0:21:20some prior knowledge of cocoa, all the better, but it was brutal. Those first few years of writing

0:21:27iPhone apps. I mean, not as brutal as Craig Hockenberry figuring out how to write his apps

0:21:31without even an SDK, but it was, it was rough going in those early days. And so I actually

0:21:37never ended up learning to code because after that my business started taking off. And so I've worked

0:21:43both with partners and with, and just paying contract developers to build the apps with me.

0:21:50Yeah. I'm sort of in the same boat where I'm, I mean, I have a degree in computer science

0:21:56and program quite a bit. I mean, I wrote the reference version of markdown and I write lots,

0:22:05you know, you, if you read my website, you know, I write little scripts from time to time,

0:22:08but writing full apps is just beyond my can. I can't explain it. Maybe sort of along the lines

0:22:18of my writing too. I've never written a book and I've never really had an idea for a book. I mean,

0:22:24and I could in theory do a collection of the best of daring fireball, which does it to me, doesn't,

0:22:29I mean, it would be a book, but that's not writing a 300 page thing that stands on its own with the

0:22:37narrative flow, right? Like my writing, my ability to write is sort of article length. That's, it

0:22:43just, that's just, and my programming, my programming ability is like script length,

0:22:50right? And so if the division between a full app and a script is sort of scope scripts, I can do

0:22:56and enjoy doing and feel like I can do pretty well and programs just, I think I could, but I think

0:23:02it would take me forever, right? That's the problem. And when you find, when you know a

0:23:07really good app developer, it's like they can move fast, right? And they can get something off the

0:23:12ground fast. And that's a good thing. It's a good thing to recognize, right? And it's sort of,

0:23:17probably it was a hard thing for you to admit, right? You think, cause you could probably could

0:23:20have done it, but it's like getting a sense that I'm never going to do it well enough.

0:23:25Yeah. Well, and it was like every six months I'd be like, oh, I should learn to code and I could

0:23:30just do this. Anytime I'd get frustrated, like we're moving too slow. I'm spending too much

0:23:34money. I mean, I had two separate projects where I got $50,000 into each of these projects with

0:23:40contract developers and I didn't see the light at the end of the tunnel. And so I just, I

0:23:45shit canned them and just took a hundred thousand dollar loss on those two projects. And so in

0:23:56moments like that, I'm like, damn it, I should learn how to code. But what I think has ended up working out

0:23:59for me in the long run is that by not coding, I spent my time thinking about things in different

0:24:08ways and focused on different things. So I studied the app store hours and I would go look at the top

0:24:16downloaded apps. I'd look at the trending, I'd look hours and hours unpacking all the different

0:24:21apps and trying to understand the business models and reading you and a bunch of other folks. And

0:24:27it just gave me such a different perspective, thinking more about the business and design and

0:24:35marketing and that side of things versus being head down in code. And so I'm probably one of the

0:24:41few people who's been around since the early days, who's just been like completely obsessed with the

0:24:46app store, but not a developer. Well, but I think it's, oh man, how's my pal Merlin put it? I guess

0:24:57it was a South by Southwest talk that Merlin and I, or panel just joint discussion around that time,

0:25:042006, 2007. But the way he put it was obsession times voice, meaning, and that it equals success

0:25:14as an independent creator. And you need, the voice is sort of your own taste and your perspective,

0:25:22like the sort of things you'd want to build and the way you'd want to build them. And also the

0:25:28way the problems you see with the existing things in that category, whether it's other for me,

0:25:33like with Daring Fireball, with other sites that wrote about Apple, what do I, what would I do

0:25:38differently? What would I, what would be different about my site? And then, but the obsession part

0:25:44is just something ineffable. Like you either have it or you don't. And lots of people are

0:25:51successful in fields. I mean, everybody knows people like this, people who spend their whole

0:25:55careers with a job that they really don't like. I mean, my dad was like that. My dad

0:26:01was a train dispatcher for Conrail, which is like the train equivalent of an air traffic controller,

0:26:07somebody who just spends eight hours at a time making sure trains get where they're

0:26:13going without hitting other trains. And he didn't hate his job, but he had a long commute.

0:26:19Cause, and it, and really for me and my sister, because he just, when we were really young,

0:26:26decided he had to move or where he worked moved and it was either move the whole family and put

0:26:32the kids in a new school or just have an hour plus commute five days a week, each way. And part of

0:26:39he made that work cause there were other, he carpooled with other colleagues. So he didn't

0:26:44have to do the driving all the time, but he didn't love his job. He really, you know, and it was high

0:26:48pressure. I mean, you know, every single day he was responsible for making sure trains don't

0:26:54collide. And every time there's a train derailment, it's national news. I mean,

0:26:58whether it's a passenger car or not, or look at the thing in Ohio a couple of years ago, I mean,

0:27:05terrible, terrible things happen. He didn't like the pressure. He didn't love the work. It wasn't

0:27:10like a passion, but it was a good job, good career, good union. And so he did it for 40

0:27:17years. I mean, it's a long time. I, and you know, it, it helped him promote the idea for me and my

0:27:24sister to, to encourage us to follow, you know, try to find something you want, you want to do or

0:27:28love to do. And I think for you, it's very clear that you just saw something ever since I've known

0:27:35you in a way that you've always shared your knowledge about it. Like you saw the opportunity

0:27:39with apps for the phone and you just had to do it. Right. I mean, yeah. So I started a business. I

0:27:47probably would have figured out a way to do it on the side. So yeah. Yeah. Like something always

0:27:51happens once an industry gets big, then it attracts the people who are interested in the money first.

0:27:58So like when I was a teenager in the eighties, it was going to work on wall street, right? Example,

0:28:06can't even be exemplified better than the fact that one of the most popular movies of the decade

0:28:10was Oliver Stone's wall street. Right. But like that whole mindset I think American psycho with

0:28:18Brett Easton Ellis's novel, and then the movie with Christian Bale, those sort of guys, it wasn't

0:28:24cause they loved the work. It was just in the eighties. It was like, well, if you want to make

0:28:28a lot of money, you go work on wall street. And then at a certain point after when the 2010s,

0:28:34when mobile was clearly on a path to, Oh, this is going to be bigger than way bigger than PCs

0:28:41ever were. Oh, it all of a sudden attracted all sorts of people who are just in it for the money

0:28:48and the passion for making great apps was second. Right. But the people who I'm interested in are

0:28:54the ones who are passionate about making great apps and then thinking, can I make a business out

0:29:01of this app? Right. And that priority, that difference in priority makes is it, you know,

0:29:08which one's first and which one's second, making the most money and then making a good app out of

0:29:12that, or having this vision for a great app and then finding, figuring out a way to make it a

0:29:19successful business. It makes a tremendous difference. And you can, you could go through

0:29:23your app, your iPhone, and just go ABAB with each app and decide, you'll know, you, you know, which

0:29:31apps were from our today from the obsessives who are after perfectionism and which ones are just

0:29:38there for the money first. Yeah. And not to jump too far ahead in the conversation, cause I wanted

0:29:43to bring this up later when we talk about the DMA and Apple and other things, but you kind of get the

0:29:51sense that used to be Apple too, you know, Phil Schiller saying, Hey, what if we just cap app store

0:29:57profit at whatever it was? It was a billion. Yeah. Like a 1 billion. Yeah. Just like a

0:30:03spit ball idea. He put out an email, what if we cap it at a billion run rate? And then once it

0:30:08gets there, just start, you know, go from 30, 30% to 25%. I mean, that was because that was before

0:30:15the 30, 15 offering. It was all 30. And it was, I don't think there were subscriptions yet.

0:30:20Yeah. But yeah, why don't we go to 25 and then when 25 hits a billion, maybe we'll go to 20.

0:30:26That more than anything was like that ethos of Apple of we're not building the app store to make

0:30:34money on the app store. We're building the app store to empower our platform, to empower

0:30:38developers, to create opportunity, to have cool apps. Like there were so many other reasons behind

0:30:46the app store and then somewhere in all of this, it'd be started to become a lot of money. And now

0:30:52Apple's a little bit more about the money than the passion. It feels like externally anyway.

0:30:57Yeah. So it was funny as you were talking about that. I wasn't thinking how many people inside

0:31:03Apple is that true of that, you know, now it's, it's such a huge driver of their stock price that

0:31:09the kind of passion that it feels like there's still so much passion inside Apple for apps and

0:31:14the platform and everything else. But it feels like we've lost a little bit of that because of

0:31:19how important it is to them financially. And the fact that the business, is it more so ahead of the

0:31:26passion these days? Yeah. Well, and like I said, it, the order of your priorities matter. It's not

0:31:33if there's three or four things you really care about. These are the three or four reasons why

0:31:37Apple has the app store. They want to empower developers to make new creative things that,

0:31:46that corner of liberal liberal arts and technology, the art part of it to let people

0:31:52make the things of their imagination and put them out there. They want the users to be able to find

0:32:00great apps that they love just because they want to make them happy. That's part of why people go

0:32:05to work to Apple to make the users happy. And they know that just like the Mac where, yes, there's a

0:32:11Mac app store now, but it's nowhere near as big a deal on the Mac as it is on the iPhone. And the

0:32:18Mac itself is so much smaller, a user base that even if the Mac app store grew to be as important

0:32:24on the Mac as it is on iOS, it still is dwarfed by iOS, but it's great for the Mac. Even in pre

0:32:32app store days, it's great for Apple to say our platform has all of these great apps. And a lot

0:32:38of these great apps are only available on the Mac because they're taking advantage in such deep

0:32:45integrated ways with our system frameworks that that's great for us too, right? That's the win,

0:32:52win, win circle. Apple does Apple's platform succeed when there are lots of great third-party

0:32:58apps available. The developers succeed when they're able to make great apps and find a market

0:33:05for them. And the users are happy when their device has all sorts of great apps games available

0:33:12for their interests, right? That's that win, win, win scenario. And with iOS, with the app store,

0:33:20like you said, it's very clear. I mean, there's, I don't, I think the only people who had disputed

0:33:26are people within Apple who I think because they know the way their priorities used to be ordered

0:33:32and never officially changed them. There was no, I don't think there was ever any kind of meeting

0:33:38where they're like the new most important thing about the app store is increasing our rake.

0:33:43Nobody ever said that it just happened and nobody wanted to turn the fire hose off, right? And so I

0:33:52think in inside Apple, they still see the reasons why they joined the company. So many people at

0:33:58Apple in higher positions have been there their whole careers or most of their careers with a

0:34:04brief stint a couple of years away. And then they come back lots and lots and lots of Apple people

0:34:10leave and then come back. That's one reason why, and everybody at Apple knows it. And it's one

0:34:15reason why Apple employees often keep up their silence about their work after they leave because

0:34:20they think I might want to come back because they know how many people come back. But yeah,

0:34:24somewhere along there, it seems pretty clear that whether they admit it or not, or it's written on

0:34:29the whiteboard in the CFO's office or Tim Cook's office, number one, make lots of money from the

0:34:36app store. And I don't want to let Apple completely off the hook in those early days either though,

0:34:41because there was a very strong commoditized or compliments vibe to the early app store was that

0:34:46they were making a ton of profit on the iPhone as a hardware device and saw that as the primary

0:34:55profit motive was to sell more iPhones. And the more apps we have, the more iPhones we sell.

0:35:00And the cheaper iPhone apps are, the more value is accrued to the device itself. So

0:35:08if you pay $400 and get your subsidized plan or whatever in 2009 to get an iPhone 3G and it costs

0:35:18$500 to load it up with apps, well, now you're competing for consumer pocket book. But if it's

0:35:27free and 20 bucks to load it up with apps, you spend that $400 on the device and it feels like

0:35:34a great deal. And I mean, Steve Jobs, even when he was announcing iAd, he said, "We created iAd

0:35:41to help developers make free, to monetize their apps so they can keep them cheap, free and cheap."

0:35:47Something along those lines. I actually have it screenshotted because I've used it. I've tweeted

0:35:52that one out many times, but there was definitely a vibe of that commoditized the compliments.

0:35:58And so it wasn't fully altruistic motives. It wasn't fully passion for apps. I think there was

0:36:05definitely a profit motive. It was just a different profit motive back then.

0:36:09Pete: Yeah, definitely. And I know Jobs, I think, totally bought into it, but I know that iAd was

0:36:17Scott Forstall's baby. That Forstall personally thought this... And really, really, really,

0:36:23because I actually talked to Scott after that keynote, off the record, in the press mingling

0:36:30area. And it was a really, really interesting conversation, but it was really, really clear.

0:36:35He was super enthusiastic about it, but really specifically from the perspective of indie

0:36:40developers, that he really thought that this was going to solve a problem that they saw was there

0:36:47on the... Even that early in the app store era, that developers trying to make a go of it

0:36:55professionally were having a hard time, in a way. And those of us...

0:37:00Geoff - It's funny, all these years later, I have been wishing for iAd 2.0. And the history of all

0:37:09that is that once they launched it, I used it day one, and CPMs were ridiculous. I made great money

0:37:16on iAd. I think David Smith, our mutual friend, he made a ton of money on iAd in the early days.

0:37:23And then all these other AdMob and a bunch of other stuff started popping up, and more and more

0:37:27developers were able to use that. And it just deprioritized from Apple at some point. But today

0:37:34in 2024, freemium subscription apps, which is what I publish generally and work with at my day job at

0:37:42Revenue Cat, there's still a lack of good ways to monetize free apps. So my weather app, I actually

0:37:49pulled ads from the app and ended up using a hard paywall because we were running Google AdMob as

0:37:56our ad aggregator. And I would get tons of complaints about gambling ads that were distracting

0:38:03and animated. And then I'd get gun ads, and I'd go into Google and I'd take every little box to try

0:38:09and like, and every box you tick makes you less money because it limits the pool of ads that can

0:38:15be served. And I would do all of that and still get crappy ads and still have no idea what all

0:38:22these ad SDKs closed source are doing in my app. And so finally, I was like, enough is enough. And

0:38:26I pulled all the ad SDKs from my app. And so even in 2024, I think Scott Forestall was right that it

0:38:35is an important thing that Apple or somebody still needs to solve. And it's never, even once Apple

0:38:41moved on from it and all these other platforms came in and there was Mopub, that Twitterbot,

0:38:47Facebook had their audience network for a while. Like there's been tons of solutions over the years,

0:38:52but it's all been like a privacy mess. The ad quality has been terrible. Like there's never

0:38:57been another iAd. It really was genuinely a good thing, but to this day, sad that Apple abandoned

0:39:04it. And then they haven't come around and built 2.0. Let's do this thing that is all the existing

0:39:12ones are crappy for various ways. And the fact that they're all crappy, this is not just for ads,

0:39:20but this happens in a lot of fields. If everybody's in a race to the bottom and using bad

0:39:26patterns and practices and the frameworks are getting bloated, it just makes everybody else

0:39:32follow the same thing. Well, everybody else is doing it too. So why don't we do that?

0:39:36And then you have this opportunity to say, no, let's just do something totally opposite,

0:39:41make it small, fast, lightweight in terms of the resources it consumes.

0:39:46The original iAd announcement emphasized that they were going after mainstream big brands,

0:39:52the Procter & Gamble's, that sort of thing, Crest toothpaste, not gun shops.

0:40:01Right. And especially back then, casino ads where it's like sketchy because it wasn't as legal

0:40:06or it wasn't legal in as many places. Let's make ads we can be proud of, right? I mean,

0:40:12that's my career too, right? That spoke to me even though I didn't have an app,

0:40:16but that's literally how I've tried to or have built so far and hopefully to come.

0:40:21My entire business is sort of based on high quality ads that are lightweight,

0:40:29good for the advertiser, lightweight, not annoying. Basically, I want ads that people don't want to

0:40:35block, which I think is a pretty good baseline. Yeah. And I think, while we're going down memory

0:40:43lane, I think younger people just cannot fathom how expensive apps were in the box software era,

0:40:52that everything was hundreds of dollars. The early versions of Photoshop, as I recall,

0:40:58were like $700 or $800 if you wanted to get Photoshop 2.0. And then when Photoshop 3 came out,

0:41:06you could get the upgrade for $299 or something like that. Apple used to charge $129 for new

0:41:15versions of Mac OS X, or Mac OS 9 and Mac OS 8. It wasn't like they started it with Mac OS X.

0:41:22But you'd buy a Mac, and obviously it came with the latest version of Mac OS included,

0:41:27and then a year and a half later, when the next major version came out, it was $129 just to upgrade

0:41:33your Mac. And people, we'd line up. And people like me and you would line up.

0:41:38I lined up for Tiger and Jaguar both, I think. Yeah. We'd line up to pay $130 to upgrade our

0:41:48operating system. They were shorter lines than the iPhone era. They didn't go out in the parking lot.

0:41:55The Apple employees didn't have to come out with trays full of water bottles to give to people who

0:42:01were waiting for hours. But you'd go to the Apple store and line up in the morning, and you'd meet

0:42:07fellow Mac nerds who wanted to get the update on day one. And in addition to the nerdiness of just

0:42:14wanting it right away, there was the camaraderie of meeting people who had the same sort of

0:42:21obsession that would lead them to line up to pay $130 to upgrade their operating system. But stuff

0:42:28was expensive. And there was a boom in, you know, there were a lot of indie developers in the '90s,

0:42:36but that was sort of the era when we often called it shareware. And I know there were a lot of

0:42:41developers, even if they were, the original idea with shareware was, it really goes back to the

0:42:49era before the internet, when apps were distributed on floppy disks, and you'd go to like your local

0:42:56Mac user group, like at Drexel, when I was at Drexel, there was a great Drexel Mac user group.

0:43:01And it was like a, you know, in the building with all the student organizations, and you could go in

0:43:07and if you, with empty floppy disks and get all of these apps, we didn't even call them apps then,

0:43:13really, but get all these applications and games, of course, and just fill up as many floppy disks

0:43:18as you could put in your backpack with all of these apps from a machine that they had set up,

0:43:24just to have them all on a hard disk and save them. And the idea with shareware is that was

0:43:28encouraged. Now you could share, I could, if I had a cool Tetris clone, I could share it to my

0:43:34friend David, just give you a floppy disk or you give me a blank floppy disk and I'll give it to

0:43:39you. And then the about box would say, if you enjoy this, you can send me $15 and there'd be

0:43:43like a mailing address. Really? Right. You'd mail a check. Believe it or not, those developers,

0:43:51most of them didn't make a lot of money that way. But the idea was, right. But most of those apps

0:43:58that were truly shareware didn't have a lock screen. It wasn't like, oh, you can use it for

0:44:0230 days and unless you mail me a check and then I mail you back a code to type in, you could use it.

0:44:09You could just use it forever and voluntarily pay if you wanted to. But the developers who made a

0:44:15go of it professionally, you know, and had box software or even when it got to the download,

0:44:19you know, the download era really opened it up to a lot more developers because the whole box thing

0:44:25was such a pain in the ass. I mean, I was at bare bones software from 2000 to 2002 where we were

0:44:33very much transitioning from selling box copies to, and we still did, we sold lots of box copies

0:44:40to lots of developers or customers, but there were a lot of customers who were just downloading it

0:44:45directly and paying not through checks sent through the mail, but through credit card

0:44:49processing over the internet. But doing a box software release was a huge deal. I mean, we had

0:44:55to print CDs or DVDs at some point. I guess CBB had it fitted on a CD. We printed copies of the user

0:45:04manual and shipped them in the box. It's a real book. I have a couple of copies because I wrote

0:45:08so much of it or contributed so much to it for the years that I was there. But that's all-

0:45:15And then you got to figure out demand and forecast. Do we eat 10,000 copies? It's cheaper,

0:45:20but are we going to sell 10,000? If we do 100,000 copies, it's even cheaper. But man, now we're

0:45:25sitting on a giant pile and you got to warehouse them. You got to do it in a different world.

0:45:30Right. And when your box of BB Edit 6.0.0 came, and then we had a 6.0.1 bug fix, you didn't have

0:45:38to get a new box. You could download it. It used to be, I think it was Stuffit who made the

0:45:43technology, but you could make an upgrader and the upgrader would just be effectively doing a binary

0:45:50diff and just applying to the application and all the other components that were installed.

0:45:56What's different between 6.0 and 6.0.1 because the download size mattered so much, right? Like

0:46:04you really had to keep a download to the smallest possible size because people at home had very slow

0:46:11connections. A lot of them were still on dial-up modems and the bandwidth cost for the company was

0:46:17humongous. I mean, you used to pay... Even Daring Fireball, originally, I had to watch my bandwidth

0:46:25just from a site with very few images and mostly text. When my site started getting popular,

0:46:33I started getting notices from my then web host that I needed to upgrade my account to something

0:46:38that was enough that I felt the strain, especially before I had Azure.

0:46:43You just got in the habit of never posting photos and it just became part of your MO, right?

0:46:48Right. But posting like a 50 megabyte app would have been ruinous for thousands of customers.

0:46:55But anyway, it was a huge deal. But in that early Mac OS X era where two things I think happened,

0:47:06first was the ability for independent developers to make download only. No, we don't have to do

0:47:13any disks ever. We're never going to print a manual. Everything will be over the internet.

0:47:18And so that made it so much easier for small developers who really just wanted to work on

0:47:23the software to do it. And you didn't have to deal with the middlemen, the micro, whatever that damn

0:47:28company was. One of the reasons its app was so expensive back then, such and such app or

0:47:37word processor was $300. It was like micro somebody, I forget, but they were the middleman

0:47:44who you give all your box copies to. And they were the ones who distributed to CompUSA and to Best Buy

0:47:52and to whatever other mom and pop shops carried the box software. They took like 80% of the money.

0:47:58It was like the opposite of the app store. And one of those reasons why Apple originally,

0:48:04and they still make the argument, right? Even in recent years, like JAWS has made the argument

0:48:08that like a 70/30 split where the developer keeps 70% is complete opposite of the box software era

0:48:16when the developer only got like 20% of the money. So that was great. You could switch to direct

0:48:25sales, cut out the middle person, no boxes, no printed manuals. And all you'd have to do is pay

0:48:31for your credit card processing fee and et cetera. And then the second thing was CoCo and that the

0:48:37CoCo frameworks and Objective-C really were and are a better way to write applications,

0:48:46to structure them, to take advantage of built-in functionality in the frameworks and let one person

0:48:54shows or three person teams make apps that in the '90s would have taken a hundred person companies

0:49:02to make. Gus Mueller at Flying Meat can make Acorn, which is a legit image editor. It doesn't

0:49:11have as many features as Photoshop, but it does compete with Photoshop. And it's him and his wife,

0:49:17his wife handling the business and Gus doing all the development. That just wasn't possible before

0:49:22CoCo. There were image editors, but I don't think that they could... I don't think Brent Simmons

0:49:27could have made NetNewswire as nice as it was when it came out as a one person developer as he could

0:49:32have in Mac OS 9 or would have taken him a lot more work. So there was that. And they could sell

0:49:38the apps for real prices like 50 bucks or $40, $80 for this or 120 for a serious app, productivity

0:49:47app. And I think everybody sort of had that idea when the App Store opened that it would follow

0:49:52that Mac model of prices that were, I don't know, $10 and up at least, $10, $15, $20. There was this

0:50:02sort of a sense like, well, the phone is smaller than the Mac, so they probably shouldn't be like

0:50:0650, 60, $70. They should be like 10, 15, $20. And then we'd get thousands of more customers because

0:50:15there'd be more iPhone... Everybody knew there were going to be more iPhones sold than Macs,

0:50:19and this would be great. And then it turned out that people thought 99 cents was way too

0:50:24expensive. Yeah. And this is something, it's still a pet peeve of mine, the folks who

0:50:33don't give Apple enough credit for helping to make that happen. Because early in the App Store,

0:50:41there were those $10 and $20 apps. And what started happening pretty quickly was that folks

0:50:47noticed that if you put your app on sale, you would get a bunch of downloads. That would push

0:50:52you into the top charts because the top charts were based solely on downloads, not revenue.

0:50:58They didn't introduce the top grossing chart until 2011, I think. And so you started having this race

0:51:06to the bottom on pricing, incentivized very directly by the structure of the App Store,

0:51:12not necessarily even by consumer demand or anything else. It was that if I drop my price,

0:51:18I'm going to get more downloads. Therefore, I'm going to get higher in the charts. And if I get

0:51:23higher in the charts, I get more attention and get more downloads. And so it was like a marketing

0:51:27thing to drop your price. And then it really was early in the App Store, just this devolution of

0:51:34prices from those $10 and $20 price points down to the floor of $0.99 in part because of the

0:51:41incentives that the App Store created. And that happened so quick. I mean, it happened over months

0:51:47since the App Store launched July 11, 2008. And by the fall, people were putting their apps on sale.

0:51:56And there were enough people that for the mass market apps, $0.99 could work. And you had the

0:52:01iBeers of the world at the end of the news, "Oh, they made a million bucks." But it still didn't

0:52:07work, right? Like my gas cubby app and other apps, I played the pricing games and I tried $2 and $3

0:52:15and $5. And you didn't have upgrades, much less subscription. And it was a mess. But to your point,

0:52:23it was like we went from this era of software being expensive to now all of a sudden software

0:52:28being super cheap. And I think that benefited Apple tremendously in the kind of accrued value

0:52:35to their platform that users were paying for their hardware and perceiving their platform as a place

0:52:41that you can get free and cheap apps versus having this platform where things were more expensive.

0:52:47Pete: Yeah. Just sort of ballpark mapping it. It's like you could get to with a $50 app, you get 20,000

0:52:58customers and now you've got a million dollars in revenue. And it depends how many employees you

0:53:03have, but that's real money. But if you have three or four people working on a thing and not that

0:53:11much overhead because you're not doing the printed stuff and you're not selling through a middle

0:53:16person, a million dollars divided by four is pretty good. And you only need 20,000 customers

0:53:22to get there. And I say you only getting to 20,000 customers for a new app can be really hard, but

0:53:28it's manageable, right? It's not boiling the ocean. It's like you're boiling a swimming pool.

0:53:34You could do it. You can heat up a hot tub. But if you're selling it for a dollar and you get 20,000

0:53:41customers, it's not much money, right? It's really not. It's well, I guess we can go to WWDC. That's

0:53:50it. You don't have to pay any bills. I saw somebody tweeting earlier this week. It was

0:53:56something about back in 2008, the app store was so easy. A beer app made millions. And I was like,

0:54:02"No." Yes, a beer app made it because it went viral. But that was the exception, not the rule.

0:54:09It wasn't easy in 2008 because you still had all those factors that are today still in place is

0:54:15that I was making more productivity and utility apps. So how many people need a mileage logging

0:54:21app? Two to 5% of the population? And then you start doing that, "Well, 2% of a million people

0:54:30is a lot of people." But then you have to get the attention of that 2%. And so if you get the

0:54:38attention of 0.01% and then half of those do end up buying your app, the numbers ended up being so

0:54:45much smaller. And the apps that that really did work for were just the mass market apps. It was

0:54:51very much centered around, and the stories that made it sound so easy were all centered around

0:54:56those mass market apps. And all the niche apps really suffered because of it. I mean, I did all

0:55:02right, and I made it. Until I joined RevenueCat in 2019, I was full-time working on apps as a

0:55:10non-programmer, probably one of the few people who could say that. So for whatever that was, like

0:55:1513 years, 100% of the money I made that provided for my family came from selling apps on the app

0:55:23store. So I did all right, but it was a struggle. And the pricing was a part of that.

0:55:30What you really want, what we want is effectively like a meritocracy. And

0:55:36of course there are exceptions, but I think sports often works like that for the most part. If you

0:55:45are a talented basketball player and you're a teenager, you're going to get noticed. If you're

0:55:52good, clearly good enough to go on to Division I college. I think there's very few high school

0:56:00kids, athletes who have that remarkable amount of talent who don't get it. And sometimes you're

0:56:07overlooked. Like Steph Curry, I forget where he went to college, I watched that recent documentary,

0:56:13but didn't go to a Tier I school. But he did play Division I college basketball. It was just

0:56:18at a smaller school because he was like, "I don't know, that kid looks short and scrawny." So he was

0:56:25overlooked, underrated, but he still eventually got to where he is today, a sure thing, all time great

0:56:32hall of famer. There's very few people who probably out there in the world who deserve to be in the

0:56:38NBA or the WNBA who aren't, right? You just sort of get there. And you want that with everything

0:56:44in the world. You want the people who deserve to succeed to succeed. And I think the web really

0:56:50worked like that. It's like when I started Daring Fireball, I hoped it would succeed.

0:56:57And it maybe took a little longer to succeed than I had hoped, but I think I eventually wound up with

0:57:04the success that I deserve. And then years later, when someone like Federico started Max Stories,

0:57:10it's with as good as Federico's writing is and as interesting and good as Max Stories is,

0:57:16I think it was effectively a sure thing that as long as the quality of the work kept up,

0:57:22it was going to become a top tier Apple news media site. It was going to happen.

0:57:28And I think that's what the App Store really has always been missing, right? You can make a great

0:57:35app that in theory ought to be able to find whatever niche there is of users that could

0:57:42and should make it a financial success, but it doesn't work, right? There's good apps that don't

0:57:48make it. And I'm not just talking about my own Vesper, but it is, I think it's a self-serving

0:57:55aspect of it aside. It's a pretty good example, right? And I've told this to, why didn't it work?

0:58:01I mean, we never got past only having an iPhone version and an iPad version. We should have had

0:58:05a Mac version, but we missed, we were too early for the subscription era and subscription pricing

0:58:11might've been the thing that saved us, but selling a four or $5 notes app, it was very clear when I

0:58:18did the analysis that what was happening, you can't prove it because you can't really prove

0:58:22what the people are doing in the App Store. But it was very clear that when people were looking

0:58:29for notes apps in the App Store, they would get a list of results and they would try the free ones

0:58:35first and eventually found one that was like, well, it's good enough and it's free. And they

0:58:42never get to the ones that you had to pay even just like four bucks. But if we were paid upfront

0:58:47and the only way to try it was to spend four bucks and they, it's not that they were, I don't think

0:58:53it was that people thought I'm never going to spend four bucks on a notes app, but they think

0:58:59I'm going to try the free ones first, find one that's, ah, it's good enough. And then they never

0:59:03get to the paid ones. And I think that's what killed. And I think that happened to a lot of apps

0:59:08and I think it still happens. I think it's very, there's a luck aspect to it that is unfortunate.

0:59:14And like the beer app that made a million dollars was a perfect example. There were all sorts of,

0:59:19some of the fart apps made a lot of money and most of the fart apps made no money at all. And

0:59:24it wasn't because some of them were good, it's really because some of them got lucky, right?

0:59:29Yeah. Yeah. And the, the, the paid upfront thing really, again, it's like in 2024,

0:59:36the app store just looks so different that I think for folks who weren't actually running an

0:59:43app business back then, including a ton of people inside Apple, it's like, there's, there's like

0:59:47kind of a history of the app store and app store monetization. That's just completely lost on folks

0:59:53who weren't, who didn't try to make a go of selling three bucks a pop upfront download apps

1:00:01back, back in the day. And, and for all the stories of success, like you were talking about,

1:00:06it was, it was challenging because it, in people's mentality around it, because things were kind of

1:00:13free and cheap of, Oh, I'd never pay for an app. I never spend that kind of money. And so you've

1:00:17got this great notes app that's four bucks or five bucks or whatever you price it at. And yeah. And

1:00:22yeah, it just, it, it, the hurdle to overcome, to spend anything was, was huge. And then especially

1:00:29when there were tons of free apps, like Evernote that eventually started monetizing, but we're

1:00:35able to just kind of ride that VC money and build a huge audience that they did. But yeah, it's,

1:00:42it's, it's a, the, the, the way that it, the fact that you couldn't do paid updates, the fact that

1:00:48for a long time, you couldn't be paid within that purchase. Like there were all sorts of rules,

1:00:54the, the way the charts work. Like I wrote several posts over the years about how Apple has and

1:01:01continues to shape the app store. And people often pretend that it's a, it's a free market. Oh,

1:01:09you didn't succeed, but it's a, it's a free marketplace. But I think you drawing the parallel

1:01:14to the web, the web really is free and open, and you have the opportunity to surface and build

1:01:22businesses in whatever way you feel like. On the app store, there are so many different boxes you

1:01:30have to tick and, and you have to fit yourself into the way the app store works and try to find

1:01:37success in within the limitations of the structure of the app store as it actually exists. I mean,

1:01:44I've likened it to economies where the app store is like a government and everything they do or

1:01:51don't do is a tax policy is law enforcement is all these different things that shape a traditional

1:01:57economy. And Apple is shaping that through the app review guidelines is shaping it through giving you

1:02:04a fifth 15% on the second year renewal of subscription. That's an incentive. That's like a

1:02:10tax break for subscription apps that you get a discount. If people say subscribe not allowing

1:02:16paid updates like that, there's, there's no way to prove the counterfactual, but had they allowed

1:02:21paid updates at some point early in the app store, I think the economics would have looked very

1:02:25different. There's so many different ways, like errors of commission and errors of omission that

1:02:31the app store would be a completely different place today were it not for, and the opportunities

1:02:36and the developers who succeeded and didn't succeed. I mean, I definitely won't say that my

1:02:42own choices didn't limit my success in some ways more than Apple did. I made my own choices about

1:02:48what I built and didn't build and how I marketed and how I didn't market. And I think any and I've

1:02:54done really well. So I'm not saying I like failed or anything, but any kind of potential additional

1:02:59success I could have, should have, would have had, or other things. I think there's, there is some

1:03:05essence of Apple's shape of the app store creating and defining the opportunities that would work and

1:03:13wouldn't work. And I think it's easy to underestimate just how much that played into

1:03:18what apps did succeed and what apps didn't succeed. And then don't even get me started

1:03:24on App Store search and App Store search is a disaster to this day in 2024. Surfacing apps that

1:03:32are like buying reviews and manipulating search. I mean, actually I, as part of my day job at

1:03:37Revenue Cat, I run this podcast called Sub Club. I actually had a guy on Steve Young last year

1:03:43in the summer talking about App Store black hat tactics. And I had him on as like an education

1:03:51thing. And we talked about it on the show and I was very upfront. I don't think some of the things

1:03:56he was suggesting are moral. Some of them are clearly against the rules, but like developers

1:04:01are still succeeding to this day using those black hat tactics and then search and other ways that

1:04:08the apps will work actually incentivizes you to play those games. Yeah. In a way when there's

1:04:14always been SEO with search on the web, but to me, it's, there's something fundamentally different

1:04:23about like you can make a website that doesn't play SEO trickery and succeed, right? You'll,

1:04:32like I said, you, it might take longer, but you'll eventually get the success you deserve

1:04:36on the web because you'll get linked to from other websites. There's other ways to do it, but the

1:04:41gamification of the app store is sort of central to it. There's no, there is cause it's cause it

1:04:47is the only game in town. If you could only get two websites through Google, if, if the entire web

1:04:54had been invented by Google and was a proprietary platform and Chrome is the only browser. And the

1:05:02only way to get anywhere is with a search box that you can't type direct URLs. You just type a query

1:05:09and only get to places through the results in one search engine, Google's results. The web would be

1:05:18a very different thing today and probably more the app store, right? Where

1:05:22it's not loose boundaries that kind of shape the flow of how the economy works to go to your

1:05:31economy allergy, but rigid rules and barriers and deliberate design from the owner of the platform

1:05:40that steers how the economy flows. And then like your analogy with SEO, I mean, Google

1:05:46spends a ton of time and is constantly updating the search algorithm to punish those techniques

1:05:53that are trying to manipulate SEO. And I mean, there's whole, I mean, I looked into this for,

1:05:58for some of the stuff I write for revenue cat there's whole like industries around like

1:06:03following Apple Google's changes and trying to figure out what they've changed and how they

1:06:08changed it and how you can like leverage a new system and Apple kind of tweaks on the app store

1:06:14search algorithm. And we see some shifts here and there, but it's yeah. And, and, and they have made

1:06:22progress on it over the years. I don't want to act like they haven't done anything, but so many of

1:06:27those dark patterns still work to this day. For example, one of them is that you can pay people

1:06:34to search a specific keyword, scroll to your app and download your app after having searched that

1:06:39specific keyword. And this is a technique. And again, Steve shared this on the podcast.

1:06:44He actively uses this in or did in 2023. And yeah, it's hard for Apple to like guard against

1:06:52that kind of thing. And maybe they guard against it in, in mass, but it's like a technique that

1:06:56still works. So you want to rank for notes app in your example with Vesper over back in the day,

1:07:02like you pay people to go search notes app and then download your app and it improves your

1:07:08ranking for that keyword. And like those kinds of dark patterns are still working to this day.

1:07:13And, and I mean, to be fair, I mean, SEO, like there's all sorts of dark patterns in SEO and

1:07:17black hat SEO and all that kind of stuff. But, but yeah, the fact that everything does go through the

1:07:23app store in that way means that Apple's search algorithm is incredibly important to the platform

1:07:30and who succeeds and who doesn't succeed. And I don't think Apple has effectively managed it

1:07:37as what it is being so dramatically important to the platform.

1:07:42Yeah. Let me take a break here and thank our first sponsor. I have a,

1:07:46I know exactly where I want to go after this, but it's a good reason to take a break. Hey,

1:07:51you ever wish you could go to Willy Wonka's candy factory? Well, you can't do that in real life,

1:07:56but there is an online version of something akin to that. And it's called nuts.com. In addition

1:08:03to an amazing selection of nuts, surprise, surprise at nuts.com. They have tons of classic candies,

1:08:12like butterscotch fudge, licorice, you name it. Everything from stuff that they make in house,

1:08:17that's sort of custom to nuts.com to name brand stuff. One of my very, very favorite things to

1:08:23get at nuts.com are dark chocolate M&M's. In my opinion, very hard to find in actual stores.

1:08:29I like dark chocolate way better than milk chocolate typically. And especially in M&M's,

1:08:35it's surprisingly good dark chocolate. So they've got that. They've got all sorts of things like

1:08:39that, that you might not see in stores. All of it's at nuts.com. It is your one stop shop for

1:08:46freshly roasted nuts, dried fruit, sweets, pantry staples, stuff like specialty flowers and more.

1:08:53Their wide selection means there is something for everyone at nuts.com. Quality is the top priority.

1:09:00They roast their nuts and pop their corn the same day it ships. So everything reaches you

1:09:06deliciously fresh. Satisfaction is guaranteed. They've also got lots of stuff like gluten-free

1:09:12options, organic choices, other specific diet-friendly products. So whether you're

1:09:17looking for something sweet, savory, or just need to stock up on everyday cooking essentials,

1:09:22you're bound to find something to try. Shop a cart at any time or opt into hassle-free auto

1:09:28delivery so you never run out of your favorite items. And if you're already stocked up at home,

1:09:32they also sell directly to businesses. I love nuts.com. Ever since they've been sponsoring,

1:09:37I've been buying some staples regularly. I always mention their half pop popcorn, which is,

1:09:43I don't know why this isn't like a universal treat that you can buy everywhere. It is so good.

1:09:47Just exactly what you think it is. It's just sort of like a corn nut, but sort of like popcorn,

1:09:53halfway in between. Really salty, really simple, like three ingredients. It's just popcorn, oil,

1:09:59and salt. I don't know how the hell they pop every kernel halfway, but they do it and it's

1:10:03really good. It's some kind of trade secret. That might be why they're the only ones that sell it.

1:10:09Anyway, right now, nuts.com is offering new customers a free gift with purchase

1:10:13and free shipping on orders of $29 or more at nuts.com/thetalkshow. It is so easy to run up

1:10:24$29 or more at nuts.com. Not because their stuff's expensive, but because they have so

1:10:28much good stuff. So go check out all of their delicious options at nuts.com/thetalkshow. You'll

1:10:34receive free gift and free shipping when you spend 29 bucks or more. That's nuts.com/thetalkshow.

1:10:42One of my all time favorite sponsors, because I get to say the word nuts so often.

1:10:47Well, you sold me, man, dark chocolate M&Ms. I didn't even know those existed.

1:10:54Half pop popcorn is like my absolute favorite. When you're digging through the popcorn and you

1:11:00get those like half pop kernels, they're like my favorite part of the popcorn.

1:11:04I'm telling you, they sell bags of it. That's all it is. It is so good.

1:11:08We wrap up. I'm going to nuts.com.

1:11:10Let me ask you this before we move on to current events. But I think one of the other critical,

1:11:17fundamental errors at the App Store is that they have user reviews at all. I don't think

1:11:23they should. I think it was a mistake to have them. And I don't think it's ever helped the store.

1:11:28Do you think with your much more in-depth study of the App Store that they're,

1:11:34do you think they're as problematic and gamed as they used to be still?

1:11:37Yeah. Yeah, unfortunately.

1:11:40Sometimes it's so obvious. It's been a while since I saw one that was super obvious. But every once

1:11:45in a while, they'd surface on Twitter, and you'd go read the reviews. And it's so obvious that

1:11:49somebody just paid one of those services where you can hire, like you said, to hire people to do a

1:11:55search for a term, hire people to download and review. Because the reviews either A, make no

1:12:02sense at all. Let's say it's a weather app, right? And it's a great notes app. Love it. And it's like,

1:12:07it's not a notes app. What are you talking about? It's the best calculator I've ever used. And it's

1:12:14a traffic app or something like that. It's like, or just nonsensical grammar, or just a bunch of

1:12:19comments that are just obviously the exact same words. Yeah, I mean, the ratings and reviews are

1:12:26gamed in a lot of different ways. And still to this day, I mean, Apple, it's like Amazon. I mean,

1:12:33Amazon struggles with fake reviews. And I don't think I've ever personally

1:12:42thought that they should completely remove ratings and reviews altogether.

1:12:47But I have, and I've tweeted this. I had to hold tweet storms on this about how

1:12:52I don't think Apple and Amazon are taking it seriously enough. I'm sure they have teams. I'm

1:13:00sure they work really hard. I'm sure they spend a lot of money. I'm sure they have sophisticated

1:13:04algorithms and everything. But when you can get a third-party tool like FakeSpot, which these days,

1:13:09I mean, I almost don't like shopping at Amazon anymore because everything is just knockoffs.

1:13:14And speaking of search not being good, you search there and it's 50 knockoffs before you find the

1:13:20thing you're actually looking for from a reputable retailer. But pretty much everything I buy of

1:13:25consequence on Amazon, if it's not a name brand that I know and trust, I'm running it through

1:13:30FakeSpot. And if FakeSpot can figure that out, Amazon should be doing more to find those quality

1:13:35signals. And then similarly, I think Apple should be doing more. However much they're doing, they

1:13:40should be doing more. The App Store is making tens of billions of dollars a year in profit for them.

1:13:45They can do more to police this rather than just completely getting rid of it. Because I think

1:13:50it is helpful to get signal from real humans as to the quality. But then that goes back to the

1:13:56search thing too, though, is that one of the things that impact search ranking significantly,

1:14:02Ariel from AppFigures is somebody who studies a search algorithm and has built search tools to

1:14:08help developers figure out how to improve their search rankings. And one of the things he shares

1:14:13is that the velocity of ratings has a huge impact on your search placement. Well, what do you do?

1:14:21You game that. And so you asked for a rating earlier. It's explicitly against Apple's rules,

1:14:29but people filter before showing the review prompts. So you say, are you enjoying this app?

1:14:35Yes or no? If they say no, you send them to support. If yes, you send them to rate the app.

1:14:40And I mean, huge apps. I think I saw realtor.com app doing that. Tons of apps do that, even though

1:14:46it's explicitly against the rules. And that's just, you're clearly getting a bias. And then

1:14:52the most frustrating thing for me personally is that I've seen all these games be played on the

1:14:57app store for years. And I know that if I don't do those things, I'm fighting with one hand tied

1:15:03behind my back. And I do, I don't morally think it's right to fake reviews and do all these kinds

1:15:10of things. And so I don't do it, but then I'm bringing a knife to a gunfight. Like it's

1:15:16It's like trying to compete in a sport that's riddled with PEDs without taking the PEDs,

1:15:24right? Really? I don't know if cycling is still like that. But at least when I followed it in the

1:15:29Christ, what was his name? Armstrong, right? In that era. And it turned out that he was on PEDs.

1:15:35And it's, it was, but everyone was and yeah, but if you weren't, you really, you couldn't win,

1:15:41you probably couldn't even qualify for the Tour de France. And baseball was a little different.

1:15:46Baseball had a terrible, well, I will say terrible, a bad PED era when all these home runs were getting

1:15:53set. And you couldn't use there was no chance you weren't going to win the home run. You weren't

1:15:59going to be the home run leader without taking them when Barry Bonds and Alex Rodriguez are

1:16:04hitting 50 6065 to 70 home runs a year that you weren't going to do it. But you could be an all

1:16:11star, you could be Derek Jeter and never take the PEDs, but you're not going to hit the home runs.

1:16:15But there was room in baseball for other players who had different skills and could just hit for

1:16:19average, but like a sport like cycling, or like when the East Germans and the Russians were

1:16:24cheating at swimming, right? You just, you weren't, you had no way you could beat them.

1:16:29I mean, it was impossible. And this is what I talk about all the time on the App Store. Like,

1:16:33I talk to a ton of developers, I do office hours weekly with with Revenue Cat, where any customer

1:16:39or prospect or just anybody can book time with me. And we chat about how to make your app successful.

1:16:43And one of the things I say is like, if you're not aware of what's going on, and you think you're

1:16:48doing competitive analysis, you're looking at all these other apps, you're like, Oh, man, there's

1:16:52this wallpaper app, it's making $500,000 a month, I should make a wallpaper app. Well, when you

1:16:58actually like download the app and understand all the dark patterns, and then when you realize that

1:17:03they're that successful, in part because they got high in search, well, how did they get high in

1:17:07search, they probably manipulated the search rankings with buying reviews and filtering

1:17:12reviews. And like, why are they still a 4.8 star app when they have like 1099 a week subscriptions

1:17:21for wallpapers, that there's still just so much of that going on in the App Store. And and so

1:17:27if you're going to play by the rules, you just have to at least understand what handicaps you

1:17:34have in trying to play by the rules versus so many apps are still pulling all sorts of crap.

1:17:41Right. It's like we talk about dark patterns, but there's different shades of darkness, right?

1:17:46There's gray patterns, and then there's like black patterns, right? And the black one of the black

1:17:50patterns is trying to create an app that like you said, like a wallpaper app, which is a legitimate

1:17:56thing. A lot of people are into our friends at the icon factory have a what's it called wallaby,

1:18:01I think, which is a really cool wallpaper app for the iPhone. But trying to, you know,

1:18:07something like that, no matter how good your wallpaper app is, I don't know what the maximum

1:18:11fare price is. So let's just say ballpark for really good, really custom art, maybe 50 bucks

1:18:20a year. And you can find a niche of people who love maybe and maybe it's using certain trademark

1:18:26characters or an intellectual property, you know, 50 bucks a year for a wallpaper app. That sounds

1:18:34premium, right? And if but tricking somebody into a three day trial that turns into a $10 a week

1:18:41subscription, well, now you're talking $520 a year, which is ridiculous for a while, but that's a scam.

1:18:48And the whole idea of those apps, as I understand it is they realize people are going to notice

1:18:54eventually somebody at some point, you're going to look at your credit card bill or you're using

1:18:58some kind of app like copilot or something that gives you you know, hey, you know, you're spending

1:19:02a lot a lot of money on blank. And it's like, that's crazy. I didn't know that I thought the

1:19:06wallpapers were free. But somehow, the presentation of the subscription screen was good enough to get

1:19:15past app review, but somehow tricky enough that people who really would never agree in plain

1:19:22language to a $10 a week recurring automatic subscription, somehow tap that button that gave

1:19:29them a $10. That's an out that's theft. That's not, ooh, that's a little skeevy. I mean,

1:19:36that's just stealing people's money. There's patterns, there's designs that get people there,

1:19:41really. And on the one hand, I appreciate that Apple is not trying to set prices. So

1:19:46I mean, they're in a tough spot. Like, I do want to give them some credit where credit is due,

1:19:52because I mean, yeah, we could, you and I could go on for 10 hours on this podcast. I don't know

1:19:58when you're going to cut me off. But philosophically, I still like the App Store

1:20:02model in that for all the complaints that we have now and complaining about search and complaining

1:20:08about these $10 a week subscriptions and things like that, I do still think that the App Store

1:20:15has been a great thing in the history of software that you have Apple curating. Are they the perfect

1:20:21curator? No. But they are curating software and getting rid of the worst of the scams when news

1:20:28pops up. Oh, this app is stealing your credentials. And those are going to pop up. Nobody's going to

1:20:33be perfect at stopping those kinds of things. But guess what? It's off the App Store in seconds,

1:20:38versus if that were on the web, people would be falling for that for years. And so I think

1:20:43there's a ton of value in the App Store. But Apple, I mean, with all the regulation, with

1:20:50everything going on around the world, and people complaining about this, that and the other,

1:20:55it's a hard job running a platform like this. It's like balanced on a knife edge. Do you let

1:21:00developers set their own prices so that if people are willing and able to pay $10 a week for

1:21:06wallpapers, let them pay it? Right.

1:21:10And I think that the Apple has had to, to a certain extent, not say that a wallpaper app

1:21:18can't be worth $520 a year. Now we can sit here and say you're ripping people off. But for Apple

1:21:26to say, "Okay, developer, you cannot charge $10 a week for your subscription." I think that's,

1:21:31I appreciate that Apple hasn't drawn some of those lines, because I think that would be

1:21:37limiting business. But I will say, I do think that there are more ways that Apple could continue to

1:21:44shape the App Store to make those kinds of things less effective, which then makes it less attractive

1:21:49as a business model. For example, and again, I want to chase so many different rabbits here,

1:21:56but Apple's payments, while they do get taken advantage of by apps like those charging $10

1:22:02a week or whatever, they are incredibly consumer friendly. And they send you the email every time

1:22:08you're going to get a renewal. They do a lot, but I think there's more that they could do.

1:22:12There should be a badge on the App Store for apps that you haven't opened in a month and they're

1:22:17still charging you a subscription. Just check in. Legitimate apps that people are using and getting

1:22:22value out of, they're not going to cancel those subscriptions. But those $10 a week, there's ways

1:22:27that Apple could bring more attention to the apps where people use them once, forget that they're

1:22:33subscribed. And again, full transparency, I work at RevenueCat. We benefit in some ways indirectly

1:22:39from that, but I think our philosophy and my philosophy personally is that subscriptions

1:22:45are an incredible win-win for consumers and developers. Is it when you can deliver value

1:22:52over time and that value is paid over time as a subscription, you can continue to add more and

1:23:00more value and build great software. And ultimately, like we were saying, compared to the box software

1:23:06days of paying $130 to update your operating system, we're getting a ton of value for a

1:23:11relatively inexpensive fee. But for that to be successful over the long haul, all of these dark

1:23:18patterns and people forgetting that they're subscribed and things like that, it's better for

1:23:24the subscription and software industry over the long haul for those kinds of things to go away,

1:23:30even if in the short term subscription app developers and then platforms like ours that make

1:23:35money from subscription app developers make less money in the short term. The fewer people who get

1:23:40scammed into those subscriptions, the more people who are comfortable paying over time, the better

1:23:46it is for everyone in the long haul. And so I do think there's still more Apple can do in so many

1:23:52fronts to make it a better place for consumers and for developers. Yeah. And I'm looking at my

1:23:58subscription list right now, and I pay for quite a lot of subscriptions through Apple. And a lot of

1:24:03them, I last year broke down and subscribed to Bloomberg because I read enough Bloomberg articles

1:24:10where it's like I should be paying to get past the pain wall. It's a professional thing, but it's a

1:24:16super expensive publication. I'm looking, it's $35 a month. So, you know, $10 a week wouldn't be that

1:24:23different really. I have Apple one is $32, 30, no, $38 a month. I keep raising the price on that. I

1:24:32can't even keep track. For my family account. So, I mean, I subscribe, you know, clearly there are

1:24:36things that $10 a week, I don't, I'd rather not because whatever was $10 a week, probably I'd save

1:24:43money on a monthly or annual. And I think I would save money on my Bloomberg if I switched to annual,

1:24:49but I have enough. I feel I want to be able to cancel that one at a moment's notice.

1:24:58Well, let's, you mentioned Revenue Cat a couple of times. So, tell me what is Revenue Cat?

1:25:05We are a subscription app platform. So, we provide SDK that goes in the app that manages every,

1:25:14that's how I actually came to Revenue Cat was I was switching my apps to the subscription model.

1:25:20And it's so much code inside the app. And then you really need to have server infrastructure to

1:25:27manage all this, validate receipts, to track the subscribers over time, to understand that they've

1:25:33turned on or off auto renew and those kinds of things. And so, we provide that drop-in SDK.

1:25:39It's in tens of thousands of apps now. So, if there's going to be a bug, we found it and

1:25:44solve for it immediately. So, you don't have to pay attention to that kind of stuff. And then on

1:25:50the server, we provide infrastructure where you can pass data to CRM tools to do win back campaigns.

1:25:58So, it's just end to end. And we have a dashboard where you can look at your subscription revenue

1:26:03and filter it by cohorts and things like that. So, it's kind of an end to end solution to help

1:26:10subscription apps monetize. All right. That sounds good. So, in other words, though,

1:26:14your customers are developers who are making apps that use subscriptions. And the idea is to give

1:26:20the developers a lot of tools that just aren't there and what you get from Apple, really.

1:26:26Exactly. And Apple has made it somewhat easier with StoreKit 2. But even with StoreKit 2,

1:26:30you need a server, you need to write a ton of code to process the payments and validate receipts and

1:26:36all that kind of stuff. And so, we just make it way easier. And then you have some people who,

1:26:41and I was this way. I was like, I don't want to put some third-party code between me and making

1:26:45money. And what I've realized after being at RevenueCat for a while now is I want RevenueCat

1:26:52code between me and making money. I don't want the one-off implementation that any developer I work

1:26:59with wrote to manage this. And so, the fact that we manage, I think we've crossed $3 billion a year

1:27:07in management of transactions across iOS, Android, and the web. And so, whose code do you want in

1:27:15your app managing those subscriptions and whose server do you want running that? The one that's

1:27:20processing $3 billion worth of payments every year or the one-off implementation that you're

1:27:25going to write and have to maintain over time. So yeah, it's a lot of fun working there too. I run

1:27:30a podcast called Sub Club, where I talk to industry experts about running subscription app businesses,

1:27:37attend conferences, and do that sort of thing. My official title is Growth Advocate. And I get

1:27:43a lot of leeway to come on, talk to industry folks, and talk to developers, and run the

1:27:49podcast and things like that. So it's a lot of fun. All right. And so that leads us to your app

1:27:56WeatherUp, which just had... What version is it now? 3.0 is what just launched recently.

1:28:05So it's more of a traditional... A lot of people are screwing around with version numbers lately,

1:28:09but I'm not a fan of it. I don't like it. It's funny because I was just talking on my podcast,

1:28:16the Sub Club podcast, I had our CEO and a colleague interview me about WeatherUp on the

1:28:22podcast. And we just did that a few days ago. And it dawned on me while discussing it that 3.0 is a

1:28:29very box software era way to do updates. And we talked about how I took a very box software era

1:28:37approach to doing the update, where we worked on it for a long time. We put all these features into

1:28:44it and then rolled out this big 3.0. And so I'm actually leaning more these days, especially in

1:28:50the era of subscriptions where you should just be pushing updates whenever anything's ready.

1:28:56Instead of holding it all for these big updates, I'm going to contradict what I think you were

1:29:00about to say, and say that I actually think that this whole 3.0 and 3.1 and big releases,

1:29:08it's kind of a bygone era. It's our era. So I think you and I both have a fondness for it,

1:29:14but it is kind of that bygone era. I kind of get the other way. I think Marco

1:29:20has switched overcast to... I know he switched to something different, but I think he does the sort

1:29:25of dated releases. And so the one thing you want, no matter what your version numbers are,

1:29:31no matter how you structure them and where you put the dots, they need to go up over time.

1:29:38Right. And some people play goofy games. I forget what app it is, but there's some app that just

1:29:44keeps making it, adding digits to pie. It's like 3.14, 3.141, 3.1415, 3. You know, which is funny

1:29:56and clever, but it does, no matter what, you're always adding a digit. It keeps going up. And I

1:30:00get it. And I think it ties into exactly what we were talking about in the first half of the show

1:30:05with the box software, where one of the advantages, I think it's a huge advantage to subscription

1:30:13pricing in general versus the big upfront payment, $500. And then for 2.0, that's when you got on

1:30:24board. And then 3.0 comes out and you pay $250 for the upgrade or stick with 2.0 and not upgrade

1:30:32and wait for 4.0 and see if they offer upgrade pricing, even if you only bought it at 2.0,

1:30:38and maybe it's somewhere in between. But then from the developer...

1:30:41I held on to that student edition of Photoshop, whatever it was, like 5.0 for a decade.

1:30:46But it leads users to make those decisions, right? It's an added decision for users of,

1:30:55do I want to stick with what I have or upgrade and get new features? And in that era,

1:31:02there wasn't so much... So many apps were sort of independent little islands as a user,

1:31:09where you just get the app and you make your own files in that app's file format, and you'd save

1:31:15them to your disk, and you could keep using an old version for a long time. And you could even

1:31:20interchange files with people with a newer version. And maybe you'd have to coordinate

1:31:25and have somebody who's on 3.0, but you're stuck on 2.0. They need to export in the older file

1:31:32format, right? If they wanted to send you the file, or maybe the file format, if it's a text

1:31:36editor, like BB Edit, well, it's a text file, it's a text file. You can always stay on the old

1:31:40version. But you still had to make that decision as a user. Do I want to upgrade or do I want to

1:31:45stay? And then I think worse from the development standpoint, it just led to... The only way to make

1:31:52it work financially was to save up new features to combine all together in a big new 4.0 release

1:32:02and batch them up. And it meant that in the interim between 3.0 and 4.0, you were really

1:32:09mostly doing bug fixes and minor feature tweaks and saving all these features for one big dump

1:32:16in 4.0, which it's better. It's a better thing for users if you just keep dripping new features

1:32:24every couple months when they're ready. And it also is better as a developer of coordination-wise,

1:32:30right? Everybody who was around in that era has war stories of a major upgrade that went wrong,

1:32:39because, "Okay, we got to get to 6.0. Here's the features we're going to put in 6.0." And maybe two

1:32:45of the features took way longer than it was expected, or one of them just didn't work out,

1:32:52happened all the time, or didn't ship at all, right? There were a lot of companies that went

1:32:57under because they planned for a big Datto release and ran out of money before they got it done.

1:33:03And subscription pricing definitely helps with that a lot. It kind of solves the problem,

1:33:08but I get it. The big problem with subscription pricing is the number of users out there who just

1:33:14hate it, right? Either just refuse to buy any subscription software period because they're

1:33:21that adamant about it, or they're at least going to complain about it, right? And I get it. I get

1:33:29it. But there's pros and cons. And I think, like any issue, if you're a zealot on the issue,

1:33:36you refuse to acknowledge the pros of the other side. All you want to do is hammer away at the

1:33:43cons. I have a theory or an explanation for subscription fatigue. And this is the way I think

1:33:53about it. Subscription fatigue is actually value fatigue. It's not that people hate the business

1:34:00model. It's that they don't feel like they're getting the value they deserve from what they're

1:34:05paying. But I think that's good. I think that's good for the industry, right? If you don't want

1:34:12to subscribe to my weather app, if you don't want to subscribe to whatever, don't. But if you're

1:34:19getting value, then you subscribe. I'm currently subscribed to like six different streaming

1:34:23services. Do I love paying whatever it is, $80 a month? But you know what? I was thinking about

1:34:30this the other day. I mean, that's so much cheaper than I used to pay in cable. I'm not watching any

1:34:36ads. I'm getting unlimited, amazing content, like the golden age of TV. It might be over now,

1:34:42now that ZURP is over and studios are pulling back and things like that. But it's like,

1:34:48we're in this golden age of content. We're not watching ads. And we're paying,

1:34:52especially inflation-adjusted, way less than we were paying for cable TV just a decade ago.

1:34:58And we're complaining about it. And so more broadly though, I do think that there's a

1:35:06mentality that's kind of a legacy mentality of software should be free. And I like that we've

1:35:14kind of gone the full span from like shareware to like really expensive software. Then the app store

1:35:20kind of did reset things that software should be free and cheap. And I should just be able to pay

1:35:2499 cents upfront and use it forever. But there's a reason why shareware was shareware because it was

1:35:30like people just doing it for fun, side projects and things like that. And then there's a reason

1:35:35it got really expensive because it's very expensive to create great software. And then

1:35:39the reason it got cheap was because it did get easier to build stuff. But now the things that are

1:35:47more expensive again are often things that are that smaller niche or trauma. It's got

1:35:54massive team, hundreds and hundreds of people building this app to better track your fitness.

1:36:00And so I think as people kind of come around, which people are... And people complain about

1:36:08spending money no matter what, right? So if it weren't subscriptions and it was still five bucks

1:36:12upfront, people would complain about five bucks upfront. And so I think like people complaining

1:36:16about spending money is just the nature of things. But the whole subscription fatigue is that...

1:36:22- It's very true.

1:36:23- Is that if you weren't getting... If you weren't anticipating getting some value out of it,

1:36:29you wouldn't be complaining that you have to pay for it. Like, why would somebody even complain

1:36:35about paying for my weather app? Because they want to use my weather app. Well, if you want to use my

1:36:40weather app, it's because you see that there's value there. And then how do you fairly compensate

1:36:45somebody for that value that they've created? And then especially how do you compensate them in a

1:36:50way that incentivizes them to keep working on it and make it a viable business versus being this

1:36:57like shareware, we're going to throw it out there in the world for free and just let it be what it

1:37:01is. Well, you probably don't want me to do that to my weather app because guess what? It costs a lot

1:37:07of money to provide the weather data in my weather app. If you find value in the app, you want me to

1:37:13be successful over the long haul. If you're finding value, you want that value to increase over time,

1:37:19not to just go away and sit on a shelf. See, I'm a bit of a subscription app zealot as a developer

1:37:27and working at RevenueCat, but I do think more and more people are coming around to it being

1:37:33a viable way to pay. And then if you're not finding value, cancel your subscription. It's

1:37:36super easy. Apple makes it so easy. Just go cancel your subscription.

1:37:39Jay Famiglietti Yeah, I mean, and again, I get it that there are pros and cons to both. And it's

1:37:45just the way it is. And with the App Store, as you discussed earlier, there is no upgrade pricing

1:37:51allowed in the App Store. And apps that have tried to figure out ways to effectively get upgrade

1:37:58pricing, it's such a pain. The Tapbot guys, the Tapbot guys who are just wonderfully user-focused

1:38:07developers, Mark Jardine and Paul Haddad, with Tweetbot in particular, I forget which version

1:38:14of what doesn't really matter. But going from like, tweetbot two to tweetbot three was a paid

1:38:19upgrade, five bucks or something like that. And what they did was make a bundle that included

1:38:27tweetbot two and tweetbot three, like so one of the things you'd have to do is make an all new,

1:38:33effectively SKU, right? It's like a new app. And so to have a paid upgrade that would let

1:38:39people who didn't want to pay to upgrade keep using tweetbot two on their phones. You could

1:38:46buy a bundle and the bundle included both and effectively gave you tweetbot three at a cheaper

1:38:53price if you already own tweetbot two, but it makes no sense. It's a it's obvious.

1:38:59Tons of people still complained. They got so many complaints. I remember when they did that,

1:39:03like a real so many complaints. The real point of a bundle is so you could, I know Apple doesn't

1:39:09charge for them anymore. But if you make a suite of a word processor and a spreadsheet and a

1:39:15presentation app, and you want to sell all three at less than the price of each one individually,

1:39:22like Microsoft Office or iWork or whatever, then you can make a bundle and include all of them at

1:39:26a lower price. It wasn't meant for two versions of the same app. But it was what I'm laughing,

1:39:32but it was all because they were trying to make their users happy. The users who wanted to get

1:39:38the upgrade but wanted to pay an upgrade price because they'd already paid for tweetbot two.

1:39:42And it just is so I hope and I know tweetbot is no longer a thing because the Twitter API

1:39:48isn't a thing. But, you know, ivory, their Mastodon successor to tweetbot is subscription

1:39:54only. And I think it's just the only way to go with the App Store. So whatever you think about

1:39:59what developers should do, if it weren't for the App Store, it's just unrealistic not to take the

1:40:05App Store for what it is. So what's the pricing for WeatherUp? Well, the pricing is currently $40

1:40:15a year or $4 a month. I actually took advantage of Apple's new, there's a new thing with App Store

1:40:21Connect that instead of doing $39.99, you can actually just make it $40. Yeah, right, right.

1:40:28I just wanted to make it simple. So how so four times 1240. So 48 or 40, right? Yeah. If you pay

1:40:37monthly, you're paying 48 dithering is current, we're going to raise the prices soon. That's a

1:40:42spoiler. But it's currently five a month or 58 year. So 10 times the monthly price. So you get

1:40:49two months free if you subscribe annually instead of whatever. Yeah, that's pretty much exactly what

1:40:54it is with WeatherUp. Two months free. So what do you think I've my whole life, even as a kid,

1:40:59I remember being annoyed by the dot 99 trick, because it just seems it's I mean, I even people

1:41:06who don't obsess over things like design and pricing and stuff. Everybody knows it's a trick,

1:41:12right? And I mean, the most famous trick of all is the way and I don't even know how again, I'm not a

1:41:17big fan of government regulation in general, but I kind of feel like it should be. Even as a kid,

1:41:23I thought how is that legal the way that gasoline is sold with nine tenths of a penny at the end,

1:41:29not even a penny they sell to the 10th of a penny, just to make it look that much cheaper and get

1:41:35actually make it that much that much closer to the whole price of a gallon. But you're really going to

1:41:40do that you're going to take off one 10th of a penny, I mean, which you can't even actually

1:41:45charge. So what do you think having shipped it at the nice even $4 or $40? Do you think it matters?

1:41:52Or do you think that's one of those things that everybody does it because everybody does it?

1:41:55Well, I'm actually doing an AB test right now. I haven't had enough traffic to reach statistical

1:42:02significance. And so my result I just started the test recently. So if you're listening to this and

1:42:07download the app, you may half of you will see $40 and a half of you will see $39.99. And I will

1:42:13report back on Twitter at least as to whether it still works. But my hypothesis in launching at

1:42:21that just simple $40 price point is that it doesn't work anymore. But we'll we'll see in the data. I

1:42:28mean, that's a nice thing. The App Store does make it super easy. And then using RevenueCat actually

1:42:32makes it super easy to run these kind of experiments. And so we'll find out I don't

1:42:36care yet. I'm I am super keenly interested in the results. So I can't wait to find them. But

1:42:42well, hopefully this drives some more traffic so we can get to statistical significance. And I'll

1:42:47share the result. But I am biased. I'm definitely rooting for even numbers to be close to close

1:42:53enough. And I can't help but think that maybe they work better. I don't know. Because I feel

1:42:58like it. It definitely makes the math easier, because the only way to really do it is to first

1:43:05go through mentally a rounding up, right? So if the prices are $39.95 and $3.99, what you do in

1:43:14your head is call it $4 and call it $48 and or $40. And then do four times 12 is 48. Okay, 48

1:43:25versus four. So in your head, you're already doing it, right? So why not just remove that step from

1:43:30the mental process of the user's evaluation of value? That's what I think. So can we and we'll

1:43:37see if that one logical jump does actually make that big of an impact. So and what's what's the

1:43:44story for free use of weather app? Whether we because it was we talked about this, like, what,

1:43:52an hour ago, hour and a half ago, I removed ads from the app, because I was just so fed up with

1:43:59the ad networks. And with a weather app, I've actually been losing money. So I actually removed

1:44:05the ads before we launched this 3.0. And so I've been losing money for over a year now, because

1:44:11every time somebody opens the app, it costs me money. And so to support a free user base,

1:44:18you have to have some kind of monetization of that for user base. Well, if I hate ads and don't want

1:44:23the the the ad SDKs in my app, the closed source doing who knows what inside my app. So with this

1:44:293.0 update, I decided to do a hard paywall. And there was other reasoning behind that as well is

1:44:35that the big exciting new feature for the for the 3.0, or actually the two big exciting new features

1:44:41for the 3.0 update, or the Apple Watch app, including complications, and the win widgets,

1:44:48which are interactive, and we can talk a little bit more about it. But guess what's super expensive

1:44:56to provide as a weather app, complications and widgets, because every 15 minutes or so in the

1:45:02background at Apple get Apple is actually pretty smart about this, that if it's on a home screen

1:45:08that you don't access frequently, it will actually update those every 15 minutes. But the one that's

1:45:13on your home screen, it tries to anticipate when you're going to open your open up your iPhone and

1:45:18look at your home screen so that the data is fresh. So every 15 minutes to 30 minutes a day,

1:45:25and then of course, it's not going to do that overnight when your phone's plugged in and

1:45:29standby and everything. But it's it's costing me money every time the system updates.

1:45:35Do you think that you've sort of lucked into the fact that they don't just update all the time?

1:45:42Or in so far as Apple's thinking is we want to conserve battery life and energy use, because

1:45:49weather apps are an exception, I think, to most apps in terms of cost. There's much more of a cost

1:45:58per API call. Whereas, I don't know, I've got sports apps on the mind from Apple Sports, but

1:46:08other things aren't the developer isn't thinking so much about every single time this thing updates.

1:46:15And if it's updating on the watch, and it's updating on their widget, there's two different

1:46:21same user, but those count as different API calls. And you want you made the watch complications for

1:46:27people to use them, you want people to use them. But do you think that they were thinking in terms

1:46:33of that or is weather app weather up? I keep saying weather app. And I knew this before we started is

1:46:38that let me ask you that as an aside, was that part of the naming of the app that it sounds like

1:46:42weather app? No, it was we were originally called it weather Atlas, because as you've told me in as

1:46:50you've beta tested the app, you really love how when you launch the app, the maps are prominent,

1:46:55which again, is actually something very expensive. There's a reason a lot of weather apps hide the

1:46:59maps, because that's one of the more expensive data calls is for the maps. And so every time

1:47:04you launch the app, the maps loading costs us a lot of money. Anyway, so that the app was originally

1:47:09weather Atlas. And then I went through a whole rebranding exercise, it's just tough finding a

1:47:15name that for ASO, I don't want to name it some random thing that doesn't say weather. And then

1:47:20just so people understand what it is, it needs to have weather in the title. And so then there's a

1:47:25million different words you can combine with weather. The one thing I did do, and part of

1:47:31me regrets up because people do say weather app and weather up. And when you're telling somebody

1:47:38the name, people hear weather app instead of weather up. So part of me regrets it. But the

1:47:43other thing too, is that it gives you more characters on the app store for your title.

1:47:48And it gives me some flexibility. And I don't know, I like it as a brand name, even if it has

1:47:54some downsides on saying it out loud, but it's like, what's the weather, like, weather up?

1:47:59Like, what's the weather up to?

1:48:00No, I like it overall. And I think most of the time you see it rather than say it. And I think

1:48:04I think that the saying it and having it come out of my mouth, at least weather app,

1:48:10isn't that bad, actually, because it's sort of, you know,

1:48:12That I don't want you telling all your friends to go download weather app,

1:48:16because you go search weather on the app store, you're not going to find weather.

1:48:19Speaking of that, the search algorithm being really hard.

1:48:23So if you just search weather, you're not that high?

1:48:26No, no, no, I mean, it'll probably like hundreds down the weather. Yeah, I don't recommend anybody

1:48:32build a weather app. It's a fun, it's fun. It's a fun playground.

1:48:37Let me stop you there, though. I have a lot of developer friends. And I'm not sure that I know

1:48:42a single one of them who wouldn't say that for their niche that they would say, Oh, no, don't

1:48:49get into it. I think Rich Segal would tell people don't build a text editor. Don't do it.

1:48:53Well, that's a good would say, Oh, my God, do not build audio apps, you have no idea

1:48:59what working with core audio for 20 years will do to your gray hairs, you know.

1:49:05So I think that any developer who's successful and builds a great app,

1:49:11and I think weather up is a great app, you become intimately familiar with all the

1:49:15reasons not to do it. But it is a competitive field, right? It is super competitive, right?

1:49:20Yeah. You're asking if I lucked into Apple not updating as frequently. And I would actually say

1:49:28that the opposite in some way. I mean, I, we definitely benefit from Apple being careful

1:49:37and how frequently it updates the widgets and complications. But Brock, my cousin, who's a

1:49:43developer working on it, he spent a ton of time, months and months working around Apple's

1:49:52limitations for widgets and complications to make it as fresh as humanly possible.

1:49:57And so I challenge anyone to compare our frequency of update compared to other apps. And I think

1:50:04you'll find it to be, if not the fastest updating close to equivalent to the fastest

1:50:10updating weather app, because we invested so much time and we put the user experience ahead of our

1:50:15costs. And that's part of why the app is more expensive than a lot of the weather apps is that

1:50:20we do a lot of things in the, to create a better experience for users that costs us a lot more

1:50:26money to deliver it in that way. And for example, one of the features I love about the app is that

1:50:31you can actually set a widgets data source individually. I have a screen on my home screen.

1:50:39That's my current location and it's Apple weather at the top,

1:50:43Aris weather in the middle and Accuweather on the bottom. And so I swipe over to that one screen and

1:50:48in an instant, I see the three different forecasts, see which one's forecasting rain, which one's not.

1:50:53They all have the short term dark sky style next hour precipitation forecast. All three of those

1:50:59come out different every time one says drizzle and in 10 minutes, one says it'll end in 25 minutes.

1:51:05Right. Right before, right before you released, when I was beta testing,

1:51:08you sent me a screenshot of your three widgets and they were where you're in Austin, right? Or near

1:51:14just south of Austin. Yeah. And it was profoundly different. I mean, it was, I think, I think you

1:51:22probably even thought, cause especially you from your perspective as a developer, you're like,

1:51:25do we have a bug? Cause I was, how is this possible that it's so different, but so yeah,

1:51:31you've got three weather sources. I know other weather apps do too, but for people out there,

1:51:35I don't think they realize this, that whether the weather providers out there, it's very expensive

1:51:42data overall. And they're very proprietary about it. You know, Accuweather famously,

1:51:46you know, loves to Sue people and stuff like that. What's even Apple weather though,

1:51:52does that cost money, right? Apple weather is actually the least expensive of, of the three

1:51:58primary of the three that we use and of, of there are cheaper weather data providers out there than

1:52:04Apple, but they're generally ones you don't want to use. And, and you can, and some apps just scrape

1:52:10the national weather service data which you can get for free, but it's, it's not as good as the

1:52:16proprietary models. Isn't that the act that's the Accuweather scam is that the Accuweather

1:52:21Accuweather is such a big company that they sort of lobby to keep the free data source from the

1:52:27national weather service, from sort of competing with them. At least I've read that, that they've

1:52:31sort of, maybe that was true historically, but I don't, I don't think that's true anymore because

1:52:37we've looked into it and we can, it's just not as good. My apologies to Accuweather if I've

1:52:44besmirched you and I do like your forecast. All right. So the first thing people need to know is

1:52:49if you're going to make a weather app, you are, you have to pay for the data and even, and I think

1:52:54one of the nice things about Apple weather is that they've got, it's sort of like the DMA thing with

1:53:01the, the, the service charge for apps where you get a certain number of calls for free.

1:53:06Right. And then you start paying. So. It's not very many though.

1:53:09Right. It's. Not enough to like actually run a weather app and have any level of success,

1:53:14but it's pretty quick. Right. If you're successful, you'll be in the paying range

1:53:18quickly, but it's at least you can, if you, if you have an idea to add weather on the side to

1:53:23something, you can experiment with it without and wait to see if it's, if it's popular. Why do you

1:53:29think Apple got into weather? I mean, they bought dark sky famously and sort of use that as the

1:53:35foundation, but why do you think Apple got into providing their own weather source?

1:53:40I have theories. It's funny you asked me this because I don't, I don't know if I ever

1:53:47DMed you and told you, you should write something about this, but I definitely DMed other folks in

1:53:51the press when this was announced ages ago. You might've, I don't remember specifically.

1:53:56Yeah. So it's funny you bring this up. I, I genuinely think Apple took a hard look

1:54:05at what was being done with weather data with the data of users who use weather apps

1:54:15and decided that they wanted to provide a good enough experience that people weren't

1:54:21essentially forced to use third-party apps because weather apps have notoriously, and there's been

1:54:27all sorts of news stories, more so back in like the 2018, 2017 timeframe. But there were some

1:54:34huge stories about weather companies and it's still happening. There's just not stories about

1:54:40it. And then AT and ATT kind of lessen the impact of it, but most third part, not it's hard to say

1:54:47most, but a lot of third-party weather apps sell user location data. And then even the weather

1:54:53channel got bought by IBM and IBM was aggregating data acquired through the weather channel app and

1:55:05selling to hedge funds and other businesses through their proprietary big data warehouse

1:55:11kind of stuff. And so what was happening for a long time and ATT has minimized the impact because

1:55:18it's can't be as directly tied to individual users, but it can still be tied to an IP address,

1:55:24which your home address doesn't change. When you're out and about, you may maintain the

1:55:29same IP address for a certain amount of time or whatever. And so there's a lot of shady stuff

1:55:35still going on to this day, but I think Apple, at least in part, made that decision because of that.

1:55:42And so one of the things we do in Weather Up, even though I don't think it's as necessary today as it

1:55:48has been in the past, but there's actually two layers that we implemented to protect user data

1:55:56even more so. So in the Weather app itself, we don't pass the full significant weather location,

1:56:06latitude and longitude to the server. We actually lop off quite a few significant digits so that

1:56:12it's essentially giving you the weather of your block, not giving you the weather of your actual

1:56:18house. And we do that because that latitude and longitude does need to get passed to a

1:56:25third-party service. And we don't know what those third-party services do or don't do with data. So

1:56:31at least we're passing them your immediate block or two area. And realistically, your forecast is

1:56:39not going to vary. People like to think that weather forecasting is that sophisticated,

1:56:44that they're going to forecast for your house and not a block away. But we looked at the level

1:56:49of precision and lop off enough significant digits where you're close enough where you're getting the

1:56:56data you need and it's accurate enough, but then it's not pinpointing your house.

1:57:00John Greenewald Right, which is a lot more

1:57:02fingerprintable to identify somebody.

1:57:05Ben Lee Right, exactly. Yeah. And that's

1:57:08where the IP address still matters when a weather app is... If a weather app is selling your data,

1:57:13even if they're not selling it associated with a tracking ID like the IDFA,

1:57:19which they would do before app tracking transparency, they can still sell it with

1:57:24your IP address. And so now all sorts of data brokers have your IP address associated with the

1:57:30exact like you sitting in your home office or whatever level of precision of your location.

1:57:38So then the second step we take to kind of anonymize the data is that we actually pass

1:57:45all of the queries through our own server so that the IP address that is sent, even with that

1:57:52latitude and longitude that's not identifying your house, we still send that from our server

1:57:58to the third party servers instead of sending it directly. So yeah, we created... And funny enough,

1:58:04I mean, we were working on this stuff. We've been doing this in the app for four or five years now.

1:58:09So even when ATT wasn't in effect and when there was more shady stuff going on, we'd already started

1:58:15doing this. But I think that's ultimately why Apple did it. I mean, there's probably other reasons.

1:58:21They are building out. I've been surprised we have not yet seen Apple Weather Plus where they

1:58:27start charging for additional features. We've seen them coming out with more and more. Apple Fitness

1:58:33is a subscription, Apple Arcade. They're going more and more in these directions. And so I kind

1:58:38of expected it to be that, to be something that they put in the Apple One bundle or charge for

1:58:43independently. So I'm kind of surprised they didn't do that. But when you look at the privacy

1:58:50angle, I think it makes a lot of sense. Because not only are they able to provide the default

1:58:56weather app, which is genuinely quite good these days, to enough users who aren't going to go seek

1:59:03out these third-party weather apps, but they're also now able to provide data to developers like

1:59:09me so that I'm not sending latitude, longitude, and IP address to these third-party services.

1:59:16And so from a privacy angle, I think it makes a ton of sense. And I don't know that they ever

1:59:21wanted to say that out loud or would ever acknowledge that that was at least a part of

1:59:26the motivation. But I can't help personally think that that was part of the motivation for them

1:59:32doing it. I think so too, that the privacy angle was a big part of it. Because the one thing,

1:59:38it's as a user, when you think of a weather app, you're very obviously thinking about weather,

1:59:44right? And you might have different reasons. That's why there's, I love talking about Twitter

1:59:50clients and Twitter-like clients like Mastodon threads and everything as a playground for user

1:59:56interface experimentation. And we're definitely seeing it all over again with the explosion,

2:00:01with the transfer of nerds from Twitter to Mastodon, and the way that Mastodon is totally

2:00:07open. There are just a slew of really interesting, really great clients for it that are all different

2:00:15from each other, right? There's reasons to one for another. And weather apps, I think are even

2:00:20more of a playground in terms of just how different they look when you first open them.

2:00:27I mean, you know this better than me even, but it's funny because I'm looking at the top charts

2:00:31for the weather category and it shows how popular weather is that there's an entire category just

2:00:36for it. And it's hilarious how many of them for me, instead of a get button, it's the cloud with

2:00:42a download arrow because I've already tried so many of them. But I do think, I thought so too,

2:00:49because what is the, you're thinking as a user, I want weather and maybe I want precipitation.

2:00:55That was Dark Sky's claim to fame originally. I want to get alerts depending on where you live

2:01:00and how suddenly rain might pop up. It could be literally not life changing, but daily habit

2:01:07changing to be able to plan it. Or maybe you live somewhere like the desert and you hardly ever get

2:01:12precipitation. So who cares? Maybe you travel a lot. And so being able to check the weather

2:01:17in multiple locations is your big thing and you don't want to do a lot of taps, blah, blah, blah.

2:01:22The one thing all weather haps have in common is they all get location access because it's,

2:01:29however many people there are who are so privacy sensitive that they don't even let their weather

2:01:36app know their location. I mean, it's got to be like 1%. I mean, because it's the whole point is

2:01:42you want the weather where you are, wherever else you might be interested in, you're probably

2:01:46interested in where it is. Very few apps get location access because most apps it would make

2:01:52no sense, right? And games try it like games that have scammy monetization on the back end. But if

2:01:59you download a game and the game says, and it's not like a Pokemon hunt game where you know that

2:02:04you want it to have your location. If you're just playing a game where you tap things on the screen

2:02:08and it says this app would like your location, you're like, what the fuck? What? It seems like

2:02:13a scam. With a weather app, it's the most natural thing in the world. The only thing that's more

2:02:18likely to get location access is a mapping app. And maps, I think, I mean, although there are lots

2:02:25and lots of specialty map apps, I know, I think it was ATP was talking about the couple months ago

2:02:32when Marco had to rent a truck, there's like a specialty app for truck drivers. It takes roots.

2:02:38- Yeah, no, no, no. A friend of mine has a RV app and he explained to me in detail just how

2:02:45valuable it is because you plug in how tall your RV app is. You plug in what voltage you need when

2:02:52you arrive at a place and it guides you to not take the top off of your RV. - Right. Either take

2:02:59the top off on a low underpass or like in New York state in particular just has a lot of, I think

2:03:06they're usually the throughways and it's all that weird naming where there's highways and throughways,

2:03:12but like a lot of throughways in New York are just no trucks allowed, right? You don't want to get a

2:03:16ticket for driving. Even if it has nothing to do with fitting on an underpass, you want directions

2:03:22for that. So I know there are specialty map apps, but for the most consumers, they really are just

2:03:28using like the big name apps, right? Apple maps, Google maps, Waze, and whatever else. But weather,

2:03:33there's a lot more diversity, but they all have location data and there's a lot of scammy ways to

2:03:39monetize location data. - Yeah. And then not only is it that they get your location access,

2:03:49they actually get it frequently. So if you're going to do a weather widget, it's going to update

2:03:56every 15 minutes. So they're going to get your IP address and your exact location every 15 minutes.

2:04:02Or if you have it set up for notification, so yeah, you want to get the dark sky rain

2:04:07notification, so you give it notification access. Well, guess what? In the background,

2:04:11it is pinging their servers maybe even more than every 15 minutes with your exact location and IP

2:04:18address. So yeah, it's a perfect playground for privacy violation. - And I think, well,

2:04:25like you mentioned ATT before, App Tracking Transparency, I think it was definitely played

2:04:30a big way into the pre-App Tracking Transparency world, which it still happens, still happens today.

2:04:36But I do think ATT stopped this to some degree, the spookiness of getting an ad in some other app,

2:04:44I don't know, a game. You're playing a game that shows apps or ads and the ad is for a restaurant

2:04:49two blocks away for you. That's weird. You're like, what? That's crazy. I never gave this app

2:04:54my location data. And yet it knows something like to send you to a local Philadelphia area store or

2:05:00restaurant or whatever it would be for wherever you live. I definitely think that's why Apple

2:05:04got into it for one reason. And I think the other obvious reason is to control their own destiny

2:05:09with their own weather app, which they clearly had a, I'm sure, and again, you know it better

2:05:15than I do, a sort of, hey, let's get serious about the built-in weather app, which went from

2:05:22almost like a widget originally, right? I think like the very early years of iPhone,

2:05:28like the skeuomorphic years before iOS 7, the weather app was really more of a widget. It was

2:05:34sort of a one-page panel of the day's highlights, like a full-screen widget. And now it's much

2:05:41richer. But that brings up the, it's sort of like Sherlocking, but the Sherlock was there from the

2:05:49beginning, right? But how, and Notes apps have to face that, right? But weather is, calculator apps

2:05:56have to face it. But anybody who wants to get in a weather game, and there's obviously, I'm looking

2:06:01at the top charts here, there are an awful lot of weather apps, but they all have to compete with

2:06:05what I think is undeniably a pretty good built-in weather app. So how do you see that?

2:06:10Well, so weather up and then weather outlets before it weren't even my first weather apps.

2:06:17So my first weather app was Perfect Weather. I think I launched that in 2011. So I've been

2:06:22building weather apps for 13 years now. And when it keeps coming back, like the reason I keep

2:06:27working on it is just that as good as the Apple weather app is, everybody makes very specific

2:06:35choices on how they design their app and what features they expose, what features they don't.

2:06:40And living here in the Austin, Texas area, radar is super important for most of the year,

2:06:49like rain showers will just sprout up over out of nowhere. And so from the beginning,

2:06:54even with Perfect Weather, one of the kind of key design features was that radar and the map

2:07:00was going to be a primary component of the app. And still to this day, and again, like you and

2:07:06I've discussed, like when launching the app and immediately seeing the map is more expensive for

2:07:13us to provide as a weather app. And that's why so many apps, unless it's a radar specific app,

2:07:19most regular weather apps in Apple's weather app specifically, they're not doing it on a cost

2:07:25basis. They're from California where the radar doesn't matter. That's a whole nother tangent

2:07:31about Apple building a weather app when they don't have weather in Cupertino for the most part.

2:07:36Last couple of months, notwithstanding. But yeah, so I mean, it's just, it's been a playground for

2:07:42me to build the weather app that I want essentially, and that I think enough people out there

2:07:47want. And then that's where like the new widgets came in is that when Apple announced the widgets

2:07:53and they shipped their widget for their weather app, it's fine, but it's not very information

2:08:03dense. It doesn't tell you a lot of what's going on. You launch the app and you got to dig through

2:08:07the app to get to the maps. And so we thought we could build something interesting in the space

2:08:15that aligned more with what I wanted to see of the weather in an instant. And I will credit to

2:08:23Ben Baharin. I forget the name of his creative strategy, something like that. You've known him

2:08:27from the Apple press core. He's not press, but he's an analyst and goes to all the events and

2:08:33stuff. He's been a weather app user for a long time. And when we were starting to explore building

2:08:40an Apple watch app, I asked him like, what would you want in an Apple watch app? And he said,

2:08:45I want to, I want a weatherman on my wrist. And after he said that, it struck me as rather

2:08:52profound. And then we spent months thinking about that. What does a weather man on your wrist

2:08:56actually mean? And what we kind of came to was this idea that most weather apps display the

2:09:03weather as, as a table. It's Monday at 10 AM, it's going to be 89 degrees. Monday at 11 AM,

2:09:10it's going to be 90 degrees. Monday at noon, it's going to be whatever. And to get to what

2:09:15you're looking for requires a lot of scanning, a lot of like deciphering of the information.

2:09:20And what does a weatherman do, weather person do on a newscast? They tell you what matters.

2:09:26And so what we tried to do initially within the bounds of a complication, but then got to really

2:09:33spread our wings with widgets once iOS, what was that? 15 shipped is to as succinctly as possible,

2:09:44show as much as possible, but show what's most important. And so it's kind of hard to describe

2:09:50in a podcast, but the display is a temperature line that goes up and down and you see three to

2:10:00four days of forecast. And what do you see? Most times you're seeing the high and the low, which

2:10:05is what you care more about. The temperature line is actually color coded. So if it's green,

2:10:10it's comfortable. If it's blue, it's cold. If it's red, it's hot. And then all the kind of

2:10:15gradient in between. So at a glance, you see what the general temperatures are going to be,

2:10:20what the high and low is going to be. Then if it's going to rain, we have the rain precipitation

2:10:26forecast behind that line as blue bars. So I turn my wrist up and or open my home screen. And in an

2:10:32instant I see whether it's going to rain in the next three days or not. There's no like thinking

2:10:37and looking at percentage numbers and everything else like that. It's just like more blue

2:10:41means more potential rain, less, no blue means it's not forecasted to rain at all in the next

2:10:46three days. And you just are able to understand that in an instant by looking at it. And then

2:10:51if it's currently raining, what do you want to know about? You want to know about the current

2:10:54rain. And so we don't take up extra space in the widget having this like blank space saying it's

2:11:01not raining, but when it is raining, we'll do that next hour, short term, like dark sky style

2:11:07forecast of what the precipitation is going to look like over the next hour. And we kind of push

2:11:12in time. The first hour kind of expands out to show that that next hour of rain. And so,

2:11:21yeah, I mean, I'm rather partial to it myself having created it, but I love that I can just

2:11:27flip my wrist over or look at my home screen and kind of instantly know what's going on,

2:11:31whether it's raining now or going to rain, what the temperatures are like, what the highs and

2:11:35lows are going to be over the next few days. Yeah, I'll try to get this in as the album art for this

2:11:40chapter. But I realized that this discussion, this particular one would work better on YouTube,

2:11:46or we could show a couple of slides, but hopefully right now, as we're talking, the chapter art is the

2:11:52widget for weather up. And then the problem with showing it even as a chapter is that with iOS 17,

2:11:59we were able to do interactive widgets, and that's been a ton of fun to experiment with. And so the

2:12:04real thing is a YouTube video because it's super interactive now. It's fundamental to the design.

2:12:12And the one I use is the sort of full width, I forget what you call it, probably medium size.

2:12:18It's not a square. It's like half height, full width. And it's broken in four. So the

2:12:26going across left to right. First quarter is the next hour. So it's like-

2:12:33If it's going to rain because it-

2:12:35Well, and I've got drizzle. I've got drizzle in Philadelphia. And in fact, it's funny

2:12:39because when I came down here to my podcast cave, when we started, it was actually a nice,

2:12:43looked like a nice day outside. And so when I opened weather up as we're talking here,

2:12:47and I saw that the map had a big green thing over the city, I was like, what the hell? And then so

2:12:52it turns out I didn't know it was raining. Didn't look like rain earlier. But yeah, because it's

2:12:57drizzling for the next hour here. It starts with next hour, and it's a quadrant. Then it says

2:13:04Wednesday the 28th, Thursday the 29th, Friday the 1st. And I get a three-day forecast ahead. And I

2:13:09can see- Yeah, I might as well take a screenshot because mine's actually a pretty good example of

2:13:14everything you're talking about. But I've got drizzle for the next hour in Philadelphia. Lots

2:13:19of rain tomorrow. It's like a 93% chance of rain. And I can see the bars of where it's going to

2:13:25happen, right? Each bar is an hour. It's going to- Looks like it's going to be a miserable- Well,

2:13:3062, which is warm for February. And then it's going to get cold but dry on Thursday and Friday.

2:13:36Well, that's great. But with big swings. And I can see the colors. It's going down to 29 degrees

2:13:41overnight Thursday, but then it's going to go up to 51 midday on Friday. And I see all of this

2:13:47in one panel. And it's very information-dense, but also very clear and very easy to parse and scan.

2:13:57It's really, really a great design. And the interactive part, which is super cool,

2:14:04is I can tap right here on the widget. I can tap next hour. And it expands the whole widget to show

2:14:12the next hour in detail. And then just tap again to go back to the overview. And I could tap on

2:14:18Wednesday. And it just shows me Wednesday. And it just expands the whole widget to show the whole

2:14:24day's forecast on Wednesday. Right in the widget. I didn't open the app. I didn't leave my lock

2:14:30screen or the whatever you call the first home screen, the zero home screen where you can stack

2:14:35your widgets. Really, really. And then just tap to go back. And if I do want to launch the app,

2:14:41I can just tap at the bottom and it launches the app, which is- And the app is a very- It doesn't

2:14:47look like it's not the same brand, but it's a totally different presentation. And I get it

2:14:53because what's the point if the app just shows the same thing as the widget? I would say it's

2:15:00very fair to describe it as a widget first design overall. Yeah. And we want to make the widget

2:15:08experience an option in the app. We just decided to prioritize making a great widget first.

2:15:14So for those who use the app and want that widget experience in the app, we will make

2:15:20that an option eventually. But like you said, it's like if you already looked at the widget,

2:15:25you're probably not wanting to just see the same thing. And so in the app, the way the weather is

2:15:31displayed is that kind of more standard weather app where it's just like a line of numbers,

2:15:36which has its place. I mean, in some ways I do actually sometimes like seeing it a different way.

2:15:42So when I'm looking at the widget and then I open the app and I see essentially the same

2:15:46information, but presented differently, you process it differently. And so in some ways

2:15:52it is nice to have both, but we'll probably make it an option in the future to make the

2:15:56app itself look more like the widget. Well, it's good as it is. And then also on the widget,

2:16:01at the bottom right, there's a right arrow that if I can want more days, I can just get more days.

2:16:06And it really is. I mean, I get why Apple debuted widgets as display only. I mean,

2:16:15I forget how many releases it was where there were widgets, but they, all you could do is you

2:16:21tap the widget, it opens the app and there's no interactivity at all. And it's a battery saving,

2:16:25right? And they don't want effectively to have these apps running all the time because it would

2:16:32drain the battery. And so they've, however, however much hair developers have pulled out

2:16:40with Swift UI. It's the intention of making it so that interactivity would be possible

2:16:49without an app running constantly in the background is a worthy and obvious goal.

2:16:57And it's complicated enough that you can understand why it took them a couple of years to get there.

2:17:03But this, these widgets are so fundamentally different than they would be as static widgets.

2:17:08It's not that it would be a useless view, but it effectively is like having a widget,

2:17:13a whole weather app right there in the widget. A simplistic one that fits in a very small area,

2:17:19but with the information density gives you everything you need to know. And from, to me,

2:17:25the big ones are precipitation, very obvious presentation, temperatures, which are on a graph

2:17:30and have numbers marking the highs and lows. And then the little icons to show you the,

2:17:35is it going to be sunny? Is it going to be cloudy? What's what's the cloud cover going to be like?

2:17:40Yeah, it was a ton of fun. I mean, in, in some ways it's, it's, it's the same old,

2:17:45same old story of, I think at this point, it looks very refined and obvious, but we,

2:17:51we spent years and thousands of iterations of refining, refining, refining to get to this

2:17:58exact presentation that I think is a really nice refined view that's information dense,

2:18:06but still visually appealing and not cluttered. And I I'm really proud of the work we did on this.

2:18:12Yeah. Well, I have good news and bad news.

2:18:15What's that?

2:18:17Well, it's both at once is that I think you need to be prepared for your widget to be ripped off.

2:18:24Yeah. Because the good news of that is that it's clever and original and incredibly useful.

2:18:31And that's very flattering to your design work and the, like you said, the iterations it takes

2:18:36to get there. Just the grind of doing thousands of iterations to wind up with this thing that seems

2:18:42totally obvious. But the bad news is it's, I think that's, it's going to be a copy because it is.

2:18:49And then whenever people go, it's not, I just good ideas are out there to be shared. Right. And they,

2:18:55and, and they, they flow, but the, it, you, the best designs in anything end up seeming so obvious

2:19:05that people think, well, of course that's how it is because how else would it be? Right. Of course,

2:19:11all phones today are just slabs of glass with a touchscreen because anything else would be stupid.

2:19:16So they all of course look like iPhones, but the iPhone didn't look like any phone before it.

2:19:21Yeah. And if you're, if you haven't ever been a, if you haven't ever done that, where you've done

2:19:28the iteration and iteration and grunt work to, to build something like that, I think the weight of

2:19:38things getting ripped off hits different than when you've actually experienced that. Cause I've, I've

2:19:44had that with other apps that we spent months and years of building this thing and then, oh,

2:19:50it's so obvious. And then people just rip it off and, and it feels like theft, IP theft in, in,

2:19:59in, in a way that's why copyrights exist. That's why patents exist because you want to have like

2:20:05some incentive to go through all of that work to refine and build something useful. And you

2:20:12want to have some level of protection at a societal level to protect that. But some things just aren't

2:20:19really copyrightable and aren't really patentable and I'm not going to go file a patent on it,

2:20:24but if somebody does rip it off and then especially if they rip it off and then are

2:20:29more successful for whatever reason, they're more scammy. They like buy reviews. They,

2:20:35they really get it. Let's hope. Yeah. I don't want to, I didn't want to turn this into a downer.

2:20:41It's supposed to be. No, no, no. I mean, it's a fascinating topic though about, yeah, about what,

2:20:46what is ripping off? And I've actually written about this and, and you know, one of the, one of

2:20:50the things I, I wrote about was when Steve Jobs said and used the quote about stealing and great

2:20:57artists and it's actually, I'm totally botching it, but it was, it was actually like a English

2:21:03poet or something who said great artists steal. And in the essence of that though, in my mind,

2:21:11good artists copy great artists. There you go. Thank you. And the essence of that in my mind is

2:21:17that the steal part connotates that you make it your own, not that you like rip something off.

2:21:27It's that the people who, who borrow and have the good taste to make it something better,

2:21:33make it something unique to add to it. That's fair. If somebody takes some of the ideas

2:21:39and some of the design work that I spent hundreds of hours and, and years of my life on, if they

2:21:46take aspects of that and, and do their own thing, more power to you. If you take 90% of what I did

2:21:54and just tweak a couple of things and call it your own, that's, that's bullshit. That is, that is,

2:22:00that's just stealing from me. And that's where I kind of draw the line intellectually was like,

2:22:05okay, yeah. Borrow from things of the past, Kirby Ferguson, everything's a remix,

2:22:09but have the good taste to actually remix it. Don't just do the same thing. For example, I mean,

2:22:16and we backed into it looking somewhat like weather line in that, you know, Ryan Jones,

2:22:22he's actually a friend. He lives here in Austin. We hang out and I've known him for years.

2:22:26It was an original concept as far as I can tell when he launched originally to put the

2:22:34weather icon on a line and that's why he called it weather line. And it was a great app eventually

2:22:39got bought and closed down. And so you could say we quote unquote borrowed from weather line

2:22:46in putting those on the line. Now the true story of it all was that we, we were the original mocks

2:22:51up was had it not on the line. And then because the Apple watch complication was so small and

2:22:57that's what we were designing for. We put it on the line and it was only after that, that I was

2:23:02like, Oh crap, we just like replicated weather line. And it is different from weather line.

2:23:07Cause he had the high temperature on one line and the low temperature on the other line. And

2:23:11that always kind of broke my brain because it's actually one continuous line. And that's what we

2:23:15ended up doing is that the high goes up and then the low goes down and the high goes up because it

2:23:21is actually one line in a chart for the temperature going up and down. But anyways, you can look at

2:23:27weather line and look at weather up and see some vague similarities in that we put the icon on the

2:23:33line, but it does not look in any way like weather line. Like we did a lot of. Interesting and

2:23:38innovative stuff again, whether or not that that could be viewed as borrowing from him or not.

2:23:43But yeah, I mean, I think it's a, it's an interesting topic, especially for the

2:23:46developer community where I think sometimes people kind of steal with a little too much

2:23:53of a blase attitude when like real people put a lot of work into something.

2:23:59But then on the flip side, like I totally agree. Like the world is a better place

2:24:02for. Inspiration being taken from one thing and building something completely new.

2:24:09But I think that's, again, I think that's best done when you take inspiration, but then actually

2:24:15add a ton of value yourself versus like mostly just ripping somebody else off. And that's what

2:24:20I would be. If I do get ripped off, that's what I'd be most pissed off about is not if somebody

2:24:25kind of has a good taste to make it their own is that if, if it just pretty much ripped off

2:24:31everything I worked so hard on. I think it's a confounding quote on the surface. I think that's

2:24:36what makes it so interesting that good artists copy great artists steal because steel sounds

2:24:42like a worse crime than copy. Right? Like steel sounds like that's the real crime, but the meaning

2:24:48of it. Well, why would that be the great artists? Right. And it's exactly, you expressed it very

2:24:53well. Like a shallow copy is just shameless. Right. And you're just, and, and the best

2:25:00examples of that are like an app that literally tries to be a clone. When, and take a name that

2:25:07sounds similar, spell it weather up with two P's. I don't know, weather down, call it weather down.

2:25:14And, and it just looks like the app it's at a glance it's side by side, right? It's it famously,

2:25:22if you squint and it looks like the same app, you've probably just ripped them off. Right.

2:25:26If you can't tell if you have to squint to see the difference. Yeah, it's probably too much.

2:25:30So it's, and it's interesting that I can think of a couple of examples. Like I remember

2:25:37in the nineties, there was a big controversy that erupted that Quentin Tarantino's Reservoir Dogs

2:25:44was supposedly just a blatant copy of a Hong Kong action movie called City on Fire. And it

2:25:52instantly, I loved Reservoir Dogs. It was like one, it was like a bolt of lightning was like,

2:25:57I'd never seen a movie like this, or it was so seemed so original in so many ways. And then to

2:26:02see that there's this controversy that it was just a blatant ripoff of a Hong Kong movie.

2:26:07Made me and my roommate at the time, we instantly rented it. And I think we had,

2:26:11we had like a hard time getting the tape at the video store because other people were doing the

2:26:16same. And then we rented it and it was a great movie. And I'd seen other Hong Kong action movies,

2:26:22Hong Kong action movies had a fantastic run in the eighties and nineties. And yeah,

2:26:28there were gangsters who all wore black suits and there were like a couple of things like that,

2:26:33but they weren't, it wasn't the same. It was a totally different movie. It's a great movie.

2:26:37Anybody out there who's looking for a subtitled Hong Kong gangster action movie, go rent City on

2:26:43Fire. It's fricking great, but it's not Reservoir Dogs, right? That's a steal. He stole, oh man,

2:26:51those guys in the dark suits were so cool. I'll just copy that. And Tarantino was, his reaction

2:26:56to it too is like telling people like, oh man, I've told everybody in the world to watch City

2:27:00on Fire. It's one of my favorite movies of all time. Like he wasn't trying to hide it.

2:27:04It was like the accusation was that because it was a Hong Kong movie with subtitles that Quentin

2:27:09Tarantino thought no one in America had seen it, but it's exactly the sort of film that Quentin

2:27:13Tarantino has spent like before he made Reservoir Dogs when he worked in a video store, was telling

2:27:19people rent this movie. He, you know, that's stealing, not copying, right? And same thing

2:27:25with Star Wars and the Kurosawa's Hidden Fortress, right? Where it's, I don't know, there's a princess

2:27:32and a couple of young guys with weapons and they've got to get into a fortress and it's the

2:27:38Death Star. And it's, but you watch, it's not like Kurosawa is an obscure filmmaker. He's revered as

2:27:45one of the great filmmakers of all time. George Lucas, again, like Tarantino would tell people,

2:27:50yeah, you should go, if you should go find every single Kurosawa movie that's ever been made and

2:27:55watch them every night for the next two weeks, go watch them. That's not a rip off. And then

2:28:00on conversely, the biggest, to me, perhaps the biggest mistake Apple ever made ever, and it not

2:28:08so much that the lawsuit and losing it sunk them, but it just exemplified how the company's

2:28:15leadership went wrong was when under John Sculley, they sued Microsoft in the famous look and feel

2:28:23lawsuit. I forget what year they filed it, but like the early nineties,

2:28:26and they spent years litigating, trying to sue Microsoft for copying the Mac with windows.

2:28:33And effectively they were trying to say that they, Apple should own the concept of the WIMP

2:28:43interface, windows, icons, a mouse pointer, and that you move a little arrow around the screen

2:28:49and you have rectangular windows and menus and buttons. And it's like, which way are you going

2:28:56to have it though? Like the problem with that lawsuit is, was the Mac better designed and way

2:29:01more, way more elegant than windows or were they the same thing? Right. And Apple on the one hand

2:29:07was saying the Mac is way better than windows and windows is kind of gross. And especially windows

2:29:14two and three before windows 95, but even with windows 95, the whole point should have been

2:29:20we're better, right? We're the whole point of Apple is to make the best computers and to waste

2:29:25years of the executive's attention on this lawsuit with the goal being to, if they had won somehow

2:29:34keep Microsoft from shipping a graphical user interface into what stick with DOS forever. And

2:29:41that's the way it should be. I mean, obviously that was goofy. It just showed that they had the

2:29:45wrong idea and they were worried that Microsoft had stolen their ideas and gone in their own way.

2:29:51Right. There was no confusion over whether you were using windows or a Mac, right? If they had

2:29:56made windows such that you looked at it and it looked just like the Mac and use similar fonts and

2:30:02put the menu bar at the top where it should be instead of stuck into every window,

2:30:06you know, it just exemplified that Apple had lost the way we, and the way is to just keep moving

2:30:13forward and making awesome products that are better than the competition. Right. Yeah. But

2:30:18as a maker, I empathize with the desire to protect all the work that went into that. And then folks

2:30:26will, will be shouting into their, into the abyss, listening to this podcast saying, well, Apple

2:30:32ripped off wimp from Xerox park. And, and, and that's a whole nother thing where, and that actually

2:30:38is to my point one, Xerox park was not commercialized, but then two is that Apple

2:30:44stole it in, in that stealing sense that like they had the time and good taste to make it something

2:30:53way more, way better, way different than what Steve jobs saw at Xerox park. They did not

2:31:00copy. They stole, they really made it their own elegant, commercially successful way.

2:31:06They also licensed it on partners. So they actually got like a life that's true. They were

2:31:13given a tour and told, yeah, take all the, you know, we're here to make ideas, take all the

2:31:17ideas you want. So even if you do think it was a blatant rip off that they should be ashamed of,

2:31:21they did license it. But be right. It is always the knee jerk reaction to those accusations about

2:31:27Apple that Apple ripped off the Mac from park. But if you've ever tried to use that, and I know you

2:31:31can't actually get, I don't know, a PDP 11 or whatever the hell machine you needed to run their

2:31:36software, but those, whatever those machines were, you can't get the hardware. But if you've ever

2:31:40watched, go to YouTube and watch the park system in action, it's inscrutable. It is, it is graphical

2:31:48and there is a mouse that you move around, but it's got like four buttons and it's not clear at

2:31:53all, which, you know, it's not like, Oh, main button and then contextual menu button, like two

2:31:58button mice today. It was like, I don't know, the select button, like you needed to use a select

2:32:04button to select text and very, very confusing in a way it, anybody familiar with the Mac

2:32:10would never be able to sit down in front of the park system and use it way different. Not,

2:32:14not at least with windows, you could say a Mac user could sit down in front of windows

2:32:18and they might be like, Oh, this is weird. This is weird. That looks ugly. These icons are terrible.

2:32:23The whole thing is kind of ugly in the windows three era, but you you'd find your way around

2:32:27the park system. You wouldn't even find your way around. You really needed to read the manual,

2:32:31but, and one more point on that, this crazy tangent we've gone on is that I think your kind

2:32:37of comments about windows exemplifies as well, that they did copy. They didn't steal in that it

2:32:45looks so familiar, but the, but to me, the essence of, of stealing, since we're, we're going really

2:32:52deep on this, this quote and this analogy, but the essence of stealing is that you,

2:32:58you spend the time to really understand what's going on because if you're going to make it your

2:33:04own, if you're going to add value, you have to, if you're just going to copy, you copy.

2:33:09And then windows three, one, I mean, windows three and then three, one, and like windows for a long

2:33:14time sucked. So they copied it, but they didn't, they didn't understand. Well, no, I would say they

2:33:18stole it. I'd say they stole it, but they stole it poorly. No, I mean it because a copy to me is

2:33:28a clone. A copy is, Oh, it's exactly like the Mac. There's a trash somewhere on the spectrum.

2:33:33Yeah. There's a bad between copying and stealing. Yeah. It was somewhere on the,

2:33:44on that spectrum of copying enough that they didn't under really understand like the fact

2:33:50that Apple pioneered the graphical user interface and the way they did you, and this is where like,

2:33:58I understand the design choices and all the different iterations that we tried that didn't

2:34:05work that led us to this current design of weather up in the, the person who just copies that doesn't

2:34:12have that experience. And they won't have the taste moving forward to, to, to have that depth

2:34:19of what does work and doesn't work and why it works because they didn't do those thousands

2:34:23of iterations. And so for however much windows did in some ways steal and make it their own,

2:34:28I think they fall further toward the copying side of the spectrum because they didn't have that

2:34:36depth. And it showed, I guess you could say they just didn't have the taste period. I said that

2:34:43many times, but they didn't have the good taste both in evolving it into the place where it was.

2:34:49And they didn't have the context of why the Mac was what it was. Right. And then the other,

2:34:53just while we're on this, I think I put this out there before, but to me, the other damning thing

2:34:58about the Apple leadership from 90 to 95, and it's, it's tied right in with the look and feel

2:35:03lawsuit where they decided to use lawyers to try to keep the Mac as the preeminent GUI, as opposed

2:35:10to using designers and engineers to make the Mac even better. Right. And it sounds a little

2:35:16superficial, but it mattered at the time. It was a very big deal. If you were into computers that

2:35:22in the nineties and you know, in the Mac went from black and white to color and color just became

2:35:27even on PCs, like one of the reasons windows three was so ugly, it was, it was designed to work on

2:35:32computers that could only show 16 colors at a time. And then as it became 256 was actually kind of

2:35:39magic, but once you got to like 256 colors on screen at a time, let alone, if you could get to

2:35:45thousands, you could make things that looked 3d and you could make, you know, use little shading

2:35:50tricks to make the windows look like they had depth and make the buttons actually look like they

2:35:55pressed and went in. And that was really, it just seemed cool. And it seemed like the way things

2:36:00ought to be. And it informed two decades of user interface design of making things look 3d and

2:36:07textured and depth and cool. And meanwhile, Mac system seven was, even though the screens were

2:36:12color and it could show color content, the UI was just flat black and white and the buttons were

2:36:17still flat. And the most damning thing about windows 95 was that they ripped off next, not

2:36:27Apple, right? No, it's true. Look, look, look at next step from when they started in 1989 and they

2:36:35were had grid, they had gray scale screens instead of black and white screens. And that doesn't sound

2:36:39like a huge difference, but it let them have depth from the beginning shading. And then they

2:36:43got color and look at screenshots from next step in the early nineties. And it looks, it then look

2:36:51at windows 95 and it's, Oh, windows 95, windows 95 to me is more of a ripoff look and feel wise

2:36:57of next step than windows three was of the Mac. It was way more of a ripoff the windows 95 windows

2:37:06style, which admittedly looked a lot cooler than before and kind of look cooler. I don't think

2:37:10better than the Mac. And it was an organized as well. And they're weird ideas about what the

2:37:17buttons and the title bars of the windows do. I never was into, but it just overall just kind of

2:37:22looked cooler because it was 3d and gray scale and not flat black and white, but it really looked

2:37:28like next. And part of the job of Apple is to be the company that makes the things that all the

2:37:34other companies rip off, right? That's it is, that's how Apple, the fact that Samsung is now

2:37:40making phones with titanium on the sides, that's just proof that Apple still has it. And that's

2:37:46what I meant when I complimented you on the fact that I'm predicting you're about to get ripped

2:37:49off because it means you're onto something. All right, I'm going to take a break here and thank

2:37:53our next sponsor. Everybody knows Squarespace. They are the all in one platform for creating

2:38:00your own website online. And they have everything you need to make a website templates to start with

2:38:09hundreds of professionally designed templates of all kinds that scale from phones to tablets to

2:38:16big, big displays, big 5k displays that are the size of your wall that you're looking with in Mac

2:38:22display mode in your vision pro headset online store, drag and drop it in and add a store to your

2:38:29website, flexible payments. You can make checkout completely seamless for your customers with very

2:38:35simple and powerful payment tools. You can accept credit cards, you can accept PayPal. It works with

2:38:40Apple pay, of course, and offer customers the option to buy now or pay later with things like

2:38:45after paying clear pay, big, big part of modern e commerce. Squarespace builds them right in

2:38:50analytics, they've got all the analytics you can want built in what parts of your website

2:38:56are people using? Where are people coming from to get to your website, all that sort of information

2:39:01you'd want to need is there and it's presented beautifully, just absolutely beautiful information

2:39:08design and the analytics that you get from Squarespace. And of course, the big new thing

2:39:13recently at Squarespace is what they're calling the fluid engine. That's their next generation

2:39:18website design system. It's always been easy to design your website on Squarespace. And you've

2:39:23always done it right in your browser. And it's sort of what you see is what you get like you're

2:39:28the website owner. And you you have editing control to drag and drop the elements on screen

2:39:34and place them and size them and color them and do stuff like that. And the only difference between

2:39:40what the visitors to your website see and what you see is that they don't get the edit mode,

2:39:45they're in read only mode and just visiting and using your website. But what you do in the browser

2:39:50is what they get when they visit your website. And their new next generation fluid engine

2:39:55makes all of that better than ever at Squarespace, including the fact that it works great right from

2:40:01your phone, you can just design, tweak, adjust, add stuff to your website, right on your phone,

2:40:09using Squarespace. So go check them out at squarespace.com/talk show that squarespace.com/talk

2:40:19show, you get a 30 day free trial, no limits, no watermarks, just build your website for a whole

2:40:25month, have it live. And then when that month free trial is up, just remember that same code,

2:40:30go to the same URL. If you remember it squarespace.com/talk show you save 10%

2:40:35off your first purchase squarespace.com/talk show. All right, that brings us to the DMA

2:40:43and the App Store. I don't know how much of the previous three hours is going to get cut,

2:40:51but we're three hours. And we could easily talk three hours on this. So you you and I commiserate

2:40:58is when I first started thinking I should have you on the show. But we commiserated quite a bit when

2:41:02Apple announced their DMA compliance plan three weeks ago, four weeks ago, well, sometime last

2:41:07month. The the date is forever seared into my mind because I launched my 3.0 update. And I had the PR,

2:41:19I had the press embargo set for the exact moment that Apple set the embargo for the DMA news.

2:41:27And it kind of ruined my day to be honest. What was the date? This date that will live in infamy?

2:41:32January 25th at 10am Pacific time. Literally the same time. That was a Thursday, right?

2:41:41So Thursday, and I thought I had even asked you ahead of time. I was like, Hey, John,

2:41:45you know of any like press embargoes coming? I'm trying to like pick a nice quiet day. And then

2:41:52boom, people people tend to pick Mondays and Tuesdays for good news, and happy announcements,

2:41:59and they tend to, of course, infamously put bad news or unpleasant news and announcements

2:42:07at the end of the afternoon on Fridays, right? That's a telltale sign that a company whatever

2:42:13they're announcing was begrudging. And so Thursdays and Wednesdays are sort of in the

2:42:19no person's land, right? So you don't expect something like that on a Thursday at 10am.

2:42:24If I had just launched on Wednesday, it would have gone totally different.

2:42:29Here's why I think Apple chose Thursday. I think Apple chose a Thursday because it gets them closer

2:42:37to the end of the week, because it is something that they did begrudgingly, right? So it's bad

2:42:42news. So they didn't do it on a Monday or Tuesday. But they wanted a day or two to talk about it,

2:42:50right? I was in multiple WebEx briefings that I was invited to by Apple to talk to people,

2:42:57you know, on Thursday. And then on Friday, there was a follow up because there were so many

2:43:02questions about it. And I think they I don't know that they anticipated that they do a second day of

2:43:08media briefings. But I think they at least plan to make room for it. And so announcing it on Friday

2:43:13would have kind of wrecked that because it would add away till Monday. So backwards, you know,

2:43:18if you knew what was coming, you could kind of see why they picked Thursday. But that's kind of

2:43:23amazing. I knew you. I knew you collided with it because we were texting about it. I didn't realize

2:43:28it actually was the exact same moment. 10am exact same moment. Yeah, we ended up TechCrunch in nine

2:43:34to five. No, TechCrunch and MacRumors ended up publishing an hour early because they were like,

2:43:39"Hey, some big news is incoming. You probably want us to post it now." So I was like, "All right,

2:43:44go ahead." So yeah. And it's not just that you ran into some big news that just happened to

2:43:55maybe overshadow WeatherUp's launch. But it's also news that is of keen interest to you

2:44:03anyway, personally. And all the press who would otherwise maybe have considered even writing about

2:44:10it. Anybody in the kind of spheres I run in, any press that would write about apps was immediately

2:44:19just heads down digesting the DMA stuff. And then I didn't even get to finish my launch plan. I didn't

2:44:25even tweet from my company account. I didn't get to have a celebratory dinner. Instead, the moment

2:44:32the launch is done, the moment it's like out there in the world, I'm reading European regulation and

2:44:39fine print from Apple and staying up till 2am reading all this stuff to do a webinar

2:44:43with RevenueCat the next day. So it was not a fun way to launch an app for sure.

2:44:48Your story trumps mine because you had release. No, it does. So I'm not trying to out bad timing

2:44:57you. But it did fall during the review period, the six days I had exclusive with the Vision Pro

2:45:04before the embargo for the Vision Pro. So all of the time I spent figuring it out and then writing

2:45:10about it the next day was all time taken away from my Vision Pro review. And I joked about this

2:45:19somewhere else. I think on another podcast, maybe I tweeted or something. But you got to think

2:45:26that the timing is maybe a little too coincidental. Here's this vision. And I didn't know the exact

2:45:34because you were under embargo. So nobody told me when exactly they got the review units and then

2:45:39when in the middle of that the DMA news dropped. But my joke was that Apple scheduled it then

2:45:46because it was like, here's the DMA news. Oh, and by the way, here's your Vision Pro to go review.

2:45:51I do think that they looked at the calendar and some aspects of it were outside their control,

2:45:58like the DMAs, whatever you want to call it. March 1st. Or March 6th, I thought was the come

2:46:02into effect date. I think. Somewhere, yeah. I don't think it comes in. Yeah, I think it comes in.

2:46:07And I guess that means iOS 17.4 is coming out in the next few days, I guess. Yeah, it has to.

2:46:15Well, I don't know. I don't know how much trouble they're in if it comes out a week after the DMA

2:46:20comes into effect. But I don't know. I don't know. Their rules for how they find companies are rather

2:46:26inscrutable. But that's the March 6th or 7th, whatever the day is when the DMA comes into effect

2:46:32was set in stone. So they kind of needed to announce it before that. But I think they did.

2:46:36They looked at the calendar. And obviously, the date they decided to release the Vision Pro was

2:46:41entirely in their control. But I think in hindsight, and looking at how ready Vision Pro is,

2:46:48I mean, 1.0 is a little rough, but I think they were I think they were set even back at WWDC. I

2:46:54think they were pretty sure they could launch and wanted to launch in January. And I think that they

2:46:59probably, if not for the holidays, probably could have launched earlier like November or December.

2:47:06But I think that there's no way that they wanted to launch this distracting niche product that

2:47:14it was only they knew whether it was what they could produce or how much interest there was.

2:47:19Some kind of thing that's going to sell in hundreds of merely from Apple's perspective,

2:47:25merely hundreds of thousands of units, they did not want to distract from the iPhone 15 models,

2:47:32which, you know, and MacBook M3 models, which they knew were coming out. And the new Apple Watch,

2:47:38which came out alongside the iPhones, these things that people do buy in the tens of hundreds of

2:47:43millions as holiday gifts, they didn't want to distract from. So I think that they knew,

2:47:49or at least hoped to launch just after, quote unquote, just after the holidays,

2:47:54ever since June. And then I think they kind of looked at the calendar with the DMA and kind of,

2:48:00yeah, I mean, let's put this, to borrow the term, let's put this shit sandwich

2:48:05right before the Vision Pro so that however much shit eating of sandwiches there's going to be,

2:48:14people are going to be talking about this new thing a week later.

2:48:16Yeah. No question.

2:48:18You can't help but think that. I mean, I'm sure people in Apple have their reasons and they're

2:48:23going to think we're just making stuff up, but you can't help but think that from the outside. And

2:48:29then, then especially it being in the, in the review window, I didn't realize you even already

2:48:33had the Vision Pro on your person when you got this news. They could have done it a week earlier,

2:48:39they could have done it two weeks after, like the timing's a little.

2:48:43It was, I did a lot of typing in a very few days, but there you go. There's proof that

2:48:49Jon Gruber does not break NDAs. Didn't tell my pal David that I had the headset.

2:48:54So where, now that it's, the dust has settled on kind of analyzing their compliance plans.

2:49:01I don't know about dust having settled.

2:49:04Well, but I think we at least, I think, I think we understand it now, right? I think that, that was

2:49:09really the hard part, really. It took me like a full day of kind of organizing my thoughts before

2:49:14I could structure them into, oh, I see that here's the outline of what the options are for developers.

2:49:20Yeah, it is very complex.

2:49:23It is. I think it kind of has to be. I don't, did they purposefully make it a little more complex

2:49:28out of spite than it needed to be? I don't think so. I actually, I don't think so. I think the DMA

2:49:37itself is so complex and has conflicting, I mean, it's anybody who reads my stuff and listens to the

2:49:44show knows I'm not a fan of the DMA at all, to say the least. But even just trying to put aside my

2:49:50feelings about whether it's a good idea or not, I think it's undeniable that some of the edicts in

2:49:57it are conflicting. And it's not that the people who think it's all about opening, just opening up

2:50:04the app store and open, open, opening payments and opening this and opening that haven't read the DMA,

2:50:10because the DMA also includes a lot of stuff that it's like in the law, it's not just, oh,

2:50:15and you can hopefully make it as secure as possible. It's in the law that things need

2:50:19to be as secure and private as they possibly could be and were before. And those two things

2:50:26are sort of sideloading and keeping things private and secure are sort of at odds by definition,

2:50:33unless you create complex rules and APIs to keep things sandboxed no matter what.

2:50:40And I kind of think overall that other than the third-party app stores, which Apple,

2:50:50and Apple to their, in my opinion, to their credit, remains critical of. They're flat out saying in

2:50:56their documentation for it that we think this is a bad idea and we don't think this is in the user's

2:51:01interest or in the platform, anybody's interest really. But that's the law and we'll comply with

2:51:07it. But I think other than the third-party app stores, a lot of it is sort of an honest

2:51:13rethinking on Apple's part of what would we do differently if we had it to do all over again.

2:51:20Yeah, it's funny you say that because that was a point I was going to make

2:51:23in this conversation as it kind of, I made some notes before we started our chat today.

2:51:29And I agree, but I think the way to look at it though is not Apple blank slate,

2:51:40what would we do different today had we to start all over again? It was a little bit more,

2:51:49and this is where it rubbed most people the wrong way and people called it malicious

2:51:53compliance. And otherwise, I think it was a little bit of a, how do we rethink the app store

2:52:00for an allow new business model? And to their credit, there are all sorts of new opportunities

2:52:07created by the way they chose to do the compliance, but they rethought it in a way that still

2:52:18takes care of Apple, that they're still getting their pound of flesh.

2:52:21Well, that's what I mean though. I think that that's one of the conclusions that came from,

2:52:26that if we had it to do all over again, we'd still want our pound of flesh, but how would we do it?

2:52:32Yeah. And I already regret saying pound of flesh because I think you and I agree,

2:52:39and I think a lot of people listening to this will have a different perspective. And I can respect

2:52:44that perspective. Somebody like David Hennemeyer-Hanson, he and Jason Fried built an

2:52:51incredible web business. They didn't have to ask permission from anybody. They wrote their own

2:52:57framework, Ruby on Rails, to build the business. They built out their own credit card payment

2:53:03infrastructure to help settle accounts and all that kind of stuff. They built a great

2:53:08business that they run and love to talk about what a great business it is and other stuff.

2:53:14But when you come from that world and your customers want access to your product

2:53:22on another platform, and now all of a sudden after decades of running the business the way you want

2:53:29to, not having any form of gatekeeper, not having to pay anybody other than credit card fees or what

2:53:36you choose to pay to come to a platform like iOS, and all of a sudden you're having to jump through

2:53:42all these different hoops. You're having to pay a commission. You're having to do all these things.

2:53:45I can respect his view of the world that he should be allowed to publish apps to this platform

2:53:55without having to follow any rules or do anything else. I can disagree with it because I do,

2:54:03but I can respect that as a worldview. But I think you and I and a lot of folks do see

2:54:09Apple's work on the platform and the intellectual property that they've created, which we had a long

2:54:16talk about IP just now and whether or not that should be defensible and what you should get paid

2:54:21for or whatever. But I do think at a fundamental level, it's Apple's platform and they have some

2:54:29right to charge developers to be on that platform. And so then what it comes down to is how much,

2:54:39like what's fair, but even the fair statement, it's their platform. So what's fair is what they

2:54:48determine. And this is where regulation gets really tricky because even the judge in the

2:54:54epic case, and it appears that the EU is not telling Apple that they can't charge developers.

2:55:00So then now what do they charge developers? And so I think the DMA though, and the way Apple complied

2:55:08in a way, especially the core technology fee is designed in a way for Apple to make similar

2:55:18amounts of money and capitalize on the platform at the levels they've currently been capitalizing on

2:55:25the platform. But then ultimately for developers, that then creates similar problems as with the

2:55:31current 30%. Because for a lot of developers, 30% is, and especially 15% for the small developers,

2:55:37is actually quite reasonable. The increased conversion you get, not having to deal with taxes,

2:55:44getting the payment processing, especially with subscription apps, getting Dunning,

2:55:48Apple supports hundreds of different payment methods around the world. If you're in Africa

2:55:53and you're paying in M-Pesa or whatever different, I forget what country that even is, but there's

2:55:58all these different payment things that they handle out of the box, that even Stripe, the

2:56:03stripes of the world don't fully support and don't collect and remit your taxes. And there's so many

2:56:08things that Apple does that are actually quite valuable to developers. But how valuable?

2:56:16And then the thing is you fall in a spectrum, right? Where Spotify that is very margin

2:56:22challenged, that 30% is a huge burden on a business that pays such a significant portion

2:56:30of their revenue out in royalties compared to me, somewhere in the middle as a weather app that pays

2:56:36out so much of my potential profit to the weather data providers to Fortnite on the way other end,

2:56:44that is essentially selling infinitely reproducible skins and has almost no

2:56:48literally near zero marginal costs on goods. And so the 30%, and then you get different benefits

2:56:56of the app store, you get different benefits of the APIs. It's a complex equation. And even in

2:57:02the 30% and 15%, you have winners and losers on a spectrum. And then the problem with the DMA is

2:57:11that because of the core technology fee, it just distributes that same spectrum, but in a different

2:57:16way. For some apps, the core technology fee can actually potentially be a very good deal.

2:57:21For a lot of apps, probably most apps, it's just not a viable option because they use some form of

2:57:29freemium model where having to pay per user just completely breaks the model. So yeah, I still,

2:57:36and I've tweeted about this, you and I have talked about this. I still long for a day when Apple

2:57:42rethinks the app store from a more kind of first principles, like blank slate, where how much

2:57:49should we make? How much value are we providing to developers in this opportunity of the app store?

2:57:58And then how do we more equitably distribute that, charging those developers in a way that

2:58:07maintains business opportunity in a way that still does compensate Apple to a certain amount?

2:58:13I think that originally that what Steve Jobs said when he announced the app store,

2:58:21and now I remember that event and I remember the Jobs portion, and it was when he explained the

2:58:2630-70 split and said, "Free apps, we're not going to charge you anything, and we'll do the

2:58:33distribution. We'll handle all of that, and we'll cover our costs by taking 30% of the apps that are

2:58:42paid." And he said, I think he even said like, "Break even." I think he more or less said,

2:58:48"I think we'll run this at break even." And I think that they meant it at the time. And I think

2:58:53the reason they meant it is that they were so intimately familiar with the iTunes Music Store,

2:58:58which famously the app store was built on. And still, maybe even today exhibits a little bit of

2:59:05that. But for a long time, really, they were sort of selling apps the way they sold songs.

2:59:10And I think they knew that the music store was not a huge moneymaker for Apple. And they took

2:59:19every 99-cent song, they got 30 cents. And I think they thought that's how the app store might work

2:59:25out and that would be fine. And it just turns out that 30% of app sales was way more lucrative than

2:59:3330% of 99-cent songs and $10 albums. And with the commissions they had to pay to the music labels.

2:59:45The other thing I think a ton of people forget is that it genuinely was a good deal at the time.

2:59:49And Apple still talks about, "Oh, before the app store, it wasn't all box software." But even those

2:59:58companies you were talking about three hours ago, headphones and others, even if you were setting up

3:00:03downloads, you were paying exorbitant fees on the bandwidth. People today, it's hard to even

3:00:10comprehend unless you were doing business in that time, that just the bandwidth of having a 200-megabyte

3:00:17app that people are downloading was very expensive. Doing credit card payments back before the app

3:00:24store was way more expensive and way more work. You had to pretty much build out your own payment

3:00:30system. And then you had to collect and remit the taxes yourself and deal with compliance around the

3:00:35globe if you're selling a different... Or take the risk of not complying and not collecting taxes.

3:00:41And so it was genuinely... In my business plan in 2008 that I submitted to my dad and uncle and mom

3:00:48and aunt, I explicitly talked about what an incredible deal it was to pay 30% to get

3:00:55distribution on the app store, not have to ever worry about credit card fees, not have to worry

3:01:00about taxes, compliance, and all those other things. It was genuinely a fantastic deal in 2008.

3:01:08Yeah. And the comparisons to box software, one of the reasons I have to roll my eyes at that

3:01:13in general is 'cause we're not talking about computers, we're talking about phones. And the

3:01:17way that software worked on phones at the time was entirely through the carriers. And the way they

3:01:23solved the things like the credit card processing problem and stuff like that was that they didn't

3:01:30charge the user by the credit card, they would charge you on your Verizon bill. And if you wanted

3:01:37to get the new snake game or whatever the hell was available for your whatever phone you got from

3:01:42Verizon or AT&T that could play games, you paid AT&T and it showed up on your phone bill. And the

3:01:48way you got the game, you had to go through the carriers. And it wasn't like the app store where

3:01:54you signed up for a $99 account and downloaded an SDK and just sort of submitted your app and then

3:02:00it would show up. There weren't, never were thousands of apps, let alone hundreds of thousands,

3:02:06let alone millions or however many apps there are, there were like dozens. And each one of them had,

3:02:12you didn't go through developer relations at Verizon, you went through business development,

3:02:17right? And so there's a reason why nobody remembers getting apps even on their smartphones

3:02:22of the time, which weren't all that popular, right? But there wasn't like, oh, get it,

3:02:26you know, lots of people had Blackberries and lots of people loved them, but it wasn't because they

3:02:30could get apps for that. It was because of the built-in app for the messaging and the email.

3:02:35And didn't developers pay like 50%?

3:02:38Oh, more, more. Yeah. I don't know. Who knows? Yeah. But you know, and nobody got the same deal.

3:02:42It was your custom negotiation, right? And if there, if some of the games were made by

3:02:47Electronic Arts, surely Electronic Arts was better at negotiating with AT&T than a startup

3:02:54with 20 people or something like that. But it all went through them and they approved it and

3:02:59it was limited and it was just nothing like this. And it's just the way that the app store is just

3:03:04one of numerous ways that Apple broke the control of the carriers, right? And forget about global

3:03:09distribution because if you went through Verizon, you were in the US, you weren't even, couldn't

3:03:13even get to Canada because, you know, yet I go through Canadian carriers. So yeah, but, but again,

3:03:18on the other hand, that's 17 years ago, right? And you, all right, you successfully changed the world.

3:03:26But I think to go back to my point of thinking that at least the core technology fee to me is

3:03:33the component of their compliance with the DMA that to me is the, hmm, what would we do all over

3:03:40again? Because the loophole, and I don't mean it in a bad way, it's some loopholes are good things,

3:03:46but the loophole that I think Apple never foresaw in 2007, 2008 when they launched the app store

3:03:52was the rise of freely distributed apps that could be, I was going to say billion,

3:04:01but like literally trillion dollar ideas, right? Meta, Facebook slash now Meta built a,

3:04:10what's now a trillion, $2 trillion company entirely based on apps that you never pay for.

3:04:18There's no pro mode for Instagram. I mean, I know there's some paid things in there for getting,

3:04:23but you don't, it's not a paid app, right? And the whole idea, like if you told people that they

3:04:29needed to pay $5 to download the Facebook app, they'd be like, what the hell are you talking

3:04:33about? It doesn't make any sense to them. But that I think Apple sort of knew there'd be lots

3:04:38of free apps, but that they'd be sort of hobbyist things or teasers for the paid app. And that I

3:04:43really do think coming from the fresh 2007, they were still at that time when they launched the app

3:04:49store, they still were selling upgrade copies of Mac OS X. They were lowering the price by then.

3:04:55It was no longer $129. It was like, there was one version that was like $70. And then it was $29.

3:05:02And then it was a big deal in 2013 or 2012 or whenever it was like, Oh, you know what,

3:05:06we're going to make them free. But yeah, I think you had to pay $5 for an iOS update one time.

3:05:11I was going to bring that up. It was the iPod touch. They were accounting for the revenue

3:05:17of touch differently than the iPhone. And so they charged, I think it was more like

3:05:2310 bucks. Yeah. Like $999. Yeah. Yeah. Because they were, they were accounting for the phone

3:05:29amortized over quarters. So if you spot a $600 iPhone 3G that they were accounting for it over

3:05:37the lifetime of your two year mandatory contract with AT&T. And so because they were amortizing

3:05:44the cost a year and a half in, they were still hadn't fully booked the money you'd already give

3:05:49them. And therefore under their interpretation of the accounting laws, whether those interpretations

3:05:54are right, I don't know, I'm not an accountant or a lawyer, but they thought that was okay

3:05:58to give free updates. But that because they booked the whole revenue from the iPod touch on sale,

3:06:03like they'd done with all other iPods, which never really got major OS updates. They felt like

3:06:10legally they had to charge. I mean, and people today, I mean, that's, try telling people when

3:06:15iOS 18 comes out next year, that they have to pay $10. I mean, it's, but coming from that world,

3:06:21I think that's what they thought. They thought the money that will be made on this app store will

3:06:25come from games and apps like the Mac, where people pay one time 10, 20, $40, $5, whatever

3:06:34the price is, they'll pay and then they'll get the app. And they never foresaw things like Facebook,

3:06:38or all the zillions of other bigger companies that have followed where that's sort of now

3:06:44the default model, where it's the App Store is sort of more like the web from their perspective.

3:06:50And it's not the total freedom of the web in the 37 signals David Heyermeyer Hanson fashion,

3:06:55where you can do whatever you want. But it's like the web, where to get to facebook.com,

3:07:02you go to a browser and type facebook.com. And now you're there. And to get Facebook on your phone,

3:07:08you go to the App Store, or Play Store on your phone, and you type Facebook and then tap the

3:07:14download button. And now Facebook is on your phone. Right? It's sort of like that. And that

3:07:19data, they don't pay, there's no platform owner, they pay anything to but I think Apple saw that

3:07:25there's these companies that have worth many of them worth billions of dollars, a handful that

3:07:31are worth trillions that they didn't, they don't collect a cent from. And, you know,

3:07:36a hundred dollars a year. I use this analogy recently that I have personally paid Apple

3:07:42well over a million dollars in commissions and Uber has paid Apple precisely $1,400.

3:07:49Actually a little less, right? It'd be like $1,386 or something.

3:07:54Yeah, because it's $9999.

3:07:58All right. All right. No, I'm not doing the math right with the pennies, but yeah,

3:08:02yeah, yeah. Yeah. $1,399.86 or something like that. Yeah, exactly.

3:08:07And I think this is a kind of new paradigm where apps that choose to use this new, who choose the

3:08:16new model will pay whether they would, no matter how they monetize. And so that, that part of it is

3:08:22interesting. Right. I, you know, I think part of it, if, are they going to do that part worldwide?

3:08:30Maybe. I think maybe they might see how this works out and maybe offer developers a option to get a

3:08:37lower commission rate on in-app sales or more flexibility on in-app sales in terms of how you

3:08:44process them on your own or whatever, in exchange for agreeing to a new deal where you send Apple

3:08:5150 cents for every download over a million. And again, it's like a loophole. And again, I'm not,

3:08:56I'm not, if you think Apple is greedy with the app store, then what I'm describing isn't absolving

3:09:03Apple. It's Apple trying to get, how do we get money from the, from Facebook and Google? Right?

3:09:10Yeah. And, and, and my personal contention, I mean, I know you and I, again, probably fall well

3:09:17closer to what a lot of people, maybe not your audience specifically, but I think a lot of people

3:09:21more broadly would think are Apple shills or Apple fanboys and defending Apple and everything else.

3:09:27I don't think Apple is greedy in the app store in the sense of like, they have created hundreds of

3:09:34trillions of dollars of value over the last 17 years, not only in the iOS platform, but in

3:09:41Android being able to copy them and create the, I mean, they, they created the modern smartphone

3:09:47era. They deserve to be compensated and have been compensated very well for that.

3:09:53And so I don't as much in my mind, think about them being greedy. And what I personally care

3:10:00more about is the, is the business opportunity of the app store and how much them not evolving those

3:10:09business opportunities over time is limiting what developers build, which then ultimately limits

3:10:16what consumers have access to, which limits their ultimate upside of, I mean, even things like the,

3:10:23the fee at some price, all the big players like Netflix would come back to the app store and they

3:10:31they'd make money where they weren't currently making money. And so, and then the problem with

3:10:37the core technology fee is that it is similarly very limiting on what kind of business models

3:10:46will work and be able to pay that 50 cent technology fee. So it's fine. Apple make your

3:10:51money, but the problem with both models and that's why in some ways I do like that we now have a

3:11:00whole new model. I mean, I was even thinking a few weeks ago, as I was digging into all this stuff,

3:11:04I should go raise some money and, and build, cause I've always loved pushing the boundaries of iOS.

3:11:09I've gotten my apps rejected so many times for stupid stuff. That's so frustrating to talk about

3:11:14now, but things like using notifications to launch apps, Apple rejected my app and said,

3:11:20you're misappropriating the API. That's not what we designed it for. You can't launch this app.

3:11:25And, and I didn't, and like, I had to remove that feature completely from the app. And so I've had

3:11:31so many cases like that, where I try to do something and get rejected for, for innovating.

3:11:38And then I spent a decade like scared to innovate the, the shortcuts guys workflow, which Apple

3:11:44bought and turned into shortcuts. They pushed the boundaries a lot more than I did in part because

3:11:52they hadn't gotten burned. And they were, I had like kids to feed and I was, I was genuinely

3:11:57scared at times that my whole business was going to go down. And so with this new opportunity in

3:12:03the EU, there is some like excitement inside of me that we're going to see new apps, new business

3:12:09models, new opportunities that were, that are just never possible on the app store. And the most

3:12:14obvious of which unfortunately is porn. I think that's probably, I mean, if somebody's not already

3:12:19building it, the like OnlyFans store or something like that is, is going to happen. But, but the,

3:12:25the point being that I do think there's a ton of opportunity. The problem is that, is that, is that

3:12:34the, the 50% core technology fee will be an incredible deal for apps that monetize

3:12:40really well and can get, and can do innovative things and kind of get out from under the

3:12:44commission, but it's going to be a really bad deal for others. And, and I don't think it's

3:12:51an exact mirror of the current commission. I think there's a lot of overlap of businesses that still

3:12:58just can't make it work. And I think Spotify is a good example. They, they're kind of the canonical

3:13:04example of an app that just gets screwed either way because they have a huge freemium base that

3:13:10they monetize via advertising and don't pay Apple a penny and Apple can argue, well, hey, look at

3:13:15all the revenue they're making and not paying Apple a penny, but at 50 cents a download and

3:13:2050 cents an update every year, that that's not, it's very unlikely to be economically viable for

3:13:26them. And then on the flip side, when they're paying so much of their revenue out in royalties

3:13:31and have such a low margin business, it's really hard for them to operate under the existing rules

3:13:38paying Apple 30 or 15%. And so there is still this squeeze in the middle of neither of these

3:13:45are actually good opportunities. Yeah. I think Spotify though is, I mean, they're obviously

3:13:52because they're in the EU and they're famously it's on, on the record that they've been a bug

3:13:58in the European commission's ear for years asking for regulatory help to, to force Apple to help

3:14:07them. And I would compare it to Apple in the early nineties when Apple was hoping to beat windows

3:14:14with a look and feel copyright lawsuit in court, rather than out innovating them.

3:14:19I think Spotify is just bad at business. I mean, and Apple in their last week issued a statement

3:14:26and the numbers are eyeopening in the EU. Spotify has 56% market share and second place is Amazon

3:14:33and third place is YouTube music and Apple's in fourth place with 8% market share. And I guess

3:14:39that's EU overall, not EU iPhone only, but Apple has Apple music on Android, right? They compete

3:14:47in music across cross-platform. And so Spotify is dominant. I mean, it's a majority market share

3:14:54by some definitions. Spotify has a monopoly that Apple doesn't have. If anybody's a monopolist

3:15:00and they're just bad at monetizing, they have so many users and they're really bad at monetizing.

3:15:05I mean, there's no reason their ad business shouldn't be better. They have so many users,

3:15:09they're, it's their fault that they're bad at making money, but their solution isn't to get

3:15:14better at making money. Their solution seemingly is getting the European union to protect them

3:15:20legally, in my opinion. I mean, cause I think, I think you have a point. And I think that Spotify

3:15:26is not the perfect example in this, but, but I think like my point, and I probably shouldn't have

3:15:32brought up Spotify cause they have made a lot of comments and they're like kind of aggrandizing.

3:15:37They've helped shape the DMA. It's impossible that if we didn't bring up Spotify, even briefly,

3:15:42we'd be doing just justice to the conversation. It's, it's there. They are front and center in

3:15:47this. They really are. But it's so aside from like them having the EU's ear, aside from a lot of the

3:15:53kind of self-serving comments and disingenuous, seemingly disingenuous comments that they've made

3:15:58about all of this, I bring them up as an example of an, of the spectrum of business opportunity on

3:16:06the app store is that you have on the far side, I mean, Kindle, let's take as a different example,

3:16:14Kindle is a low margin business. They pay such a high percentage of revenue on the books to the

3:16:22publishers that they, they are a margin challenged business. It's hard to build. And there's,

3:16:28there's not as much economic incentive to build these margin challenged businesses,

3:16:35especially when your distribution channels then eat up more than you actually make a margin.

3:16:42And so maybe the Kindle is a better example of this, but my, my point in bringing up Spotify

3:16:46was just that both deals, the, the, the, the new rule, the new regulations under the,

3:16:53what do you even call it? The new opportunity, the new paradigm, the new whatever under the DMA

3:16:58regulation in Europe is a flip side of the same coin in that it's a, it's generally going to be

3:17:06a bad deal for margin challenged businesses and or freemium businesses. And so there's the,

3:17:12and I think that's an important way to look at this is that for, and I think Apple maybe to a

3:17:20fault internally leans too heavily on, we'll look at all the look at it. I mean, they say this in

3:17:26like the press, well, look at all the developers who are only paying 15%. It's like, yeah, great,

3:17:30but like, that doesn't absolve you of like all the others who are paying way more than 30%. And then,

3:17:36well, Hey, you get a million downloads for free. Well, okay. That's great. But most people aspire

3:17:42to build a bigger business and are going to hit that at some point the regulation or the

3:17:47compliance, the way it stands in the existing app store in my mind does not account for the disparity

3:17:56in, and this is why so many companies do custom deals, right? Like if, if, if Apple had the

3:18:02bandwidth to just custom negotiate and say, Hey, Spotify, like we're competing with you.

3:18:08We have their default music player. We have, we understand your margins. Like you're going to get

3:18:13to pay 5% instead of 15% or 30% that would solve it. But then how does Apple negotiate a million

3:18:20different custom deals for all the different people? And again, maybe Kindle is a better

3:18:24example and it does seem like Apple's made some back room deals with Amazon and some

3:18:29to a limited extent. But the point being like the opportunity, the business opportunity discourages

3:18:36any kind of margin challenge business on either side with the DMA or with the existing commission.

3:18:43Right. There's certain types of business models that wouldn't work under the old,

3:18:46the existing app store rules. And then with the new rules, there's a different section of

3:18:51business models that just won't work. But the one thing, and I've mentioned this on,

3:18:55I forget if it's only on dithering or on this show too, but the one thing I had to rethink was when

3:18:59these rules first came out and Ben and I did the math in our heads on dithering and we're like,

3:19:05well, let's just say Facebook has a billion users of all their apps combined in the EU,

3:19:10which seems like a fair, you know, across WhatsApp, Instagram, and Facebook, a fair round number.

3:19:16Well, then they'd have to pay Apple $500 million a year. And well, who do that? Because that's a

3:19:22huge number. And then you think about, but then rethinking it, thinking about meta's actual

3:19:27finances, $500 million a year is not that much for them. And the best example is Google who famously,

3:19:36and now, you know, this came out in lawsuits recently. Everybody's been speculating about

3:19:40it for years, but the Google pays Apple roughly best estimates $20 billion a year to be the

3:19:47default search in Safari. Like for some of these companies paying for access to the users of Apple's

3:19:55products is worth $20 billion a year for Google for search for the iPhone. So 500 million is 40th

3:20:03of that. It's smaller. I'm not saying, and I know Zuckerberg's come out and said, he doesn't think

3:20:08this looks good. Doesn't think that Facebook's going to do it and whatever, but it's not

3:20:12ridiculous to think that they would or that other, some other companies would, even if they do have a

3:20:18billion users and wind up paying Apple $500 million a year, if your monthly income from the average

3:20:24user of your app is way more than 50 cents a year, it might be a great deal. And I thought it was

3:20:30really interesting recently that Epic, that Apple is going to let them have a subsidiary in Europe,

3:20:36get a developer account back and there's Epic has announced it. They're going to make an Epic game

3:20:41store. And I think that's super interesting. And you know, and like I wrote on Daring Fireball,

3:20:48I, Apple can hold a grudge and they definitely play hardball, no doubt about it, no argument,

3:20:53but I don't think they're a spiteful company. I don't think they're cut off their nose,

3:20:57despite their face. And while they might dislike Epic because of that whole lawsuit. And,

3:21:03but I think if they could think strategically that, Hey, if Epic can take advantage of these

3:21:09rules and build and be happy, that's the sort of thing that would make any regulator at the EU

3:21:14think, well, we won, right? We forced Apple to open up a store that lets their enemy Epic open

3:21:20a store and have a game store. And now there's another place where iPhone users can get games in

3:21:27the EU. And that would be a win. I think Epic said they're doing it. So like the argument,

3:21:32there was a knee jerk reaction when the rules first came out that quote unquote,

3:21:36nobody's going to use these rules. And so it's ridiculous. And I thought that at first too,

3:21:42right? Just doing that back to the envelope math and thinking, well, my God, $500 million is a

3:21:46lot of money, but it's not a lot of money to meta. So I think, you know, if Epic's doing this,

3:21:52somebody else will, you mentioned porn and we can laugh because porn is funny in a way, but porn,

3:21:57porn also is very popular. And if you think like, if you think like, I think that software tends to

3:22:07comp complex software tends to be better in a native app than in a web app, then like the

3:22:14argument now for the fact that the Apple did won't allow porn in the app store is that, well, you

3:22:19know, the good news is safaris out there and there's zillions of porn sites that you can access

3:22:25all you want on the web. But I think you can get ready or right, right, right. You can,

3:22:31or HBO Max, right? But if all if all you want is porn, you're you're you're not lacking on the

3:22:36iPhone. But could you get a better porn experience through a native app, right? And for something

3:22:42like a two way camera where you see them and they see you might work a lot should, in theory,

3:22:48work a lot better in an app. And maybe, you know, processing payments through their custom processor

3:22:53through an app might be better than doing it through the web. So I think you're right. I

3:22:57think there will be a porn store or store full of porn stars. And I it's also very true. It's an

3:23:05America society wise has a it's our pure our puritanical roots from the founding of the

3:23:12country. We have a more puritanical view of porn than other countries in Europe, especially and

3:23:19Europe and Europeans see that as a source of pride, like in a way that Americans are, in my opinion,

3:23:27rightfully proud of our freedom of the press and freedom free speech. Europeans are proud of the

3:23:34fact that porn is more acceptable there and that Amsterdam has had a red light district since

3:23:41forever and prostitution is not as frowned upon morally or ethically. And so I think the European

3:23:48Union, if there is a successful or multiple successful porn app stores for the iPhone,

3:23:54again, we'd see that as a win, right? That Apple was never going to allow it. Apple still doesn't

3:24:00allow it outside the EU. But thanks to us and our wonderful DMA law, now all the proud citizens of

3:24:06the EU have a better porn experience on their iPhones than people outside the EU. It is funny.

3:24:13It's I agree. It is funny. But I also think it's true. I don't think it's the case that no one's

3:24:18going to use it. I think there's going to be an epic game store. I hope it's successful. I think

3:24:23that would be interesting and neat. Yeah. Will there be others? I don't know.

3:24:27I think there will be and I'll give you my list of five opportunities that I do think exist under

3:24:35the new DMA rules. But let me step back just to further make that one point I was making about

3:24:42the spectrum of business attractiveness and margin challenge of operating on the app source.

3:24:50I should know these exact numbers because I've read them 100 times and I'm trying to channel

3:24:55my best Eric Seufert. But I believe it was in one of his updates or one of Ben Thompson's updates

3:25:00talking about the revenue per user in Europe is actually significantly lower than the revenue per

3:25:07user in the US. And then you combine that with the fact that WhatsApp either monetizes very little,

3:25:15then Instagram monetizes, I think the best of all of them. And then the Facebook blue app monetizes

3:25:21less than that. So let's say in Europe, I think it's closer to the single digit, low single digit

3:25:29euros per user per year in the EU compared to the US. And so let's just, I mean, I don't know the

3:25:37exact numbers I should, but let's say it's $4 for euros a year per user. Paying 50 cents out of $4

3:25:45is a lot, that's 12.5%. So that's actually on a margin basis, a pretty big hit and actually

3:25:55fairly close to your 15 and 30% if it were, let's say a subscription and at the second year they

3:26:02start paying 15%. And so that again, to my point is that even though it is a new opportunity,

3:26:14the amount apps are actually going to pay as a percentage of the revenue can still be actually

3:26:21crazy high. But the opportunities I see, so to flip this around is that there's, like you were

3:26:26saying, kind of hacks and loopholes around this, right? So you could start an app store that was

3:26:32all paid up front. And these are some of the ideas I was kicking around. Like maybe I should go raise

3:26:37money and go build my own European app store where I can flaunt the app store rules and do whatever

3:26:42I want with innovative utility apps and other apps. And so the way to get around some of this

3:26:48is that you charge. And there's actually a ton of apps starting to do this on the web. It can be a

3:26:54dark pattern where they charge a dollar to start your free trial, but then they get your credit

3:26:59card on file and then they can charge you whatever they want and the subscription fee is really high.

3:27:03I've seen, and that's actually another argument for Apple's payments being very friendly,

3:27:07comparatively. But if you have a strong value prop and you just say it's a dollar,

3:27:13enough people will likely do that if your value prop is strong enough. And then you have things

3:27:20like AAA games or more well-known apps and other stuff where you can get around that with charging

3:27:30some kind of fee upfront. And then, I mean, you do have tons of high average revenue per user apps.

3:27:37Yeah. I think Fortnite will qualify for that. There might be a zillion users who never pay anything,

3:27:43but Epic knows what the average user pays and they know how the whales who love to buy the outfits

3:27:50and the dances and whatever else there is for sale, they know the average they make per user.

3:27:55Right. But I mean, Fortnite's actually probably an example where it's actually quite low. Like,

3:28:00they're the canonical ultra freemium where the whales are paying $10,000, but on average,

3:28:07it's like 25 cents per user per year monetization because they have this massive freemium.

3:28:11Oh, you think it's that low? I think it's higher than that. I don't think they'd be making it.

3:28:15It may be higher than that, but my point is just that it's on the lower side. It's not like,

3:28:20the apps I'm talking about more of like high average revenue per user, like the pro-sumer apps,

3:28:26I mean, Microsoft would be a good example. Like they could open a store selling Microsoft Word

3:28:31and Excel and other apps like that where their average revenue per user is going to be quite high

3:28:37where the 50 cents is like nothing. It really is just like 2% or 3% or whatever.

3:28:42So I do think there's opportunities for that. I think to my earlier point about getting rejected

3:28:48so many times, like there's opportunities to do innovative things that Apple doesn't currently

3:28:52allow on the app store, even within the current APIs that I think would be attractive enough to

3:28:58get attention and find a way, again, around the core technology fee. And then B2B and pro-sumer

3:29:06apps. Yeah, I think there's a ton of opportunity here. There is some risk though. And one of the

3:29:14things I'm hoping Apple will do at some point, whether forced to or not, is allow for some kind

3:29:22of cap on the core technology fee that if an app goes viral, because that's one of the big risks.

3:29:30I talked to a lot of developers about it. Well, yeah, probably 99.999% of developers are never

3:29:37going to get a million downloads in the EU, but there's going to be that one developer who does.

3:29:42Well, David Smith and Widget Smith is the perfect example. And I mean, he's been upfront because he

3:29:47exploded in popularity when Widget Smith went literally viral, like with TikTokers saying,

3:29:53"Got to get this app, Widget Smith, because look what you can do. A, B, and C." And some other

3:29:57TikTokers all followed each other and made their own things that they could do with Widget Smith.

3:30:01And all of a sudden, Widget Smith went from, "Hey, pretty popular by the standards of David Smith's

3:30:06other apps, which are all great," to millions of users very quickly. So for him, if it had

3:30:13been a 50 cent per user over a million, I think he tweeted it or I don't think it was only private,

3:30:20but it's very obvious. It would have bankrupt him if they had tried to collect the money instantly.

3:30:24And paying more than 100% of revenue to Apple.

3:30:26Right, because there was no nice scale. Like if you're imagining that, "Oh, you're getting to

3:30:32800, 900,000 users and now you can prepare to hit that limit and you think you're going to get to a

3:30:38million and then you get to a million point one and you're only paying $50,000 on the 100,000

3:30:45over a million and you can adjust the way you're monetized. If you feel like, "Ooh, if we keep

3:30:50growing, this might be tight, we can make adjustments." But if you suddenly go from

3:30:55500,000 users to 10 million users because you went viral on TikTok, you've got a $4.5 million bill.

3:31:03And so that's where taking advantage of these opportunities either needs to be a big company

3:31:11that knows the risk and has the financial backing and tolerance for that level of risk or Apple

3:31:20needs to find some way to cap the risk for smaller developers. Because right now I wouldn't recommend

3:31:26it for small developers. If you run a freemium app, it's not a good idea to accept the new

3:31:31terms generally because will you likely hit the million downloads? No, but if you do and Apple

3:31:37doesn't give any provision for getting out of it, you're screwed. Right. And that makes me wonder

3:31:41back to my point of Apple. I do think genuinely designing this to be used. And again, the fact

3:31:48that it does not address all the complaints and perhaps none of the complaints of their

3:31:53most vehement critics, but that the DMA wasn't written to satisfy those critics either. It

3:31:58doesn't satisfy everyone, but it does. It might be interesting for some, and that doesn't mean

3:32:03it's uncompliant with the DMA. But I do think that in terms of what would we do if we had to

3:32:09do this all over again, seeing how that mobile world evolved, I think on the forefront of Apple's

3:32:16mind or meta and Google and Microsoft and Amazon who've built these apps that get used all the time

3:32:23and that they don't see any money from. Well, that's not true of Microsoft. Microsoft has

3:32:28all the office apps in the store. Yeah, they do. They make hundreds of millions and we don't know

3:32:32what backdoor deal is. Microsoft did. And then same with Amazon. Amazon has some things on the app

3:32:38store, but you're making a point. There are tons of Uber and Facebook and Uber. Uber is a good

3:32:43example. Apple almost nothing. Uber's entire business would not exist without the iPhone,

3:32:48in my opinion. And I've had this argument where I just don't think that if the mobile world had

3:32:53evolved in the BlackBerry sort of way, that there would have been enough people to make it useful.

3:33:00Uber's whole premise was that effectively everyone would have a device that could show maps and GPS

3:33:07and do credit cards and stuff, not just the 5% of people who own smartphones pre-iPhone.

3:33:14Because I saw a pitch deck recently and the original thing was like, you would just text,

3:33:19pick me up at work in five minutes. And it's a great pitch deck thing, but it's now looking back,

3:33:26you can see a million reasons why that doesn't work. Like how do you know they're actually going

3:33:29to be there in five minutes? And it's so obvious that having that pinpointed location of the driver

3:33:35and the always on GPS where they can find you and like all the things that made Uber were the

3:33:40smartphone, but they did start. Didn't they launch right before? Was it the 3G that got a GPS? Because

3:33:49the original iPhone didn't have full GPS. No, the original iPhone only triangulated between

3:33:55cell towers. Right. So it was like a 3G, which was released. I guess that was released in 2008

3:34:01and they didn't launch in 2009. But it was, yeah, it's interesting. But to your point, the Uber has

3:34:08made a ton of money and built an entire business on these technologies, whether they could have

3:34:12built very unlikely that they could have built what they have today, whether or not they started

3:34:18before GPS or whatnot. Yeah. And I remember when Uber came out, even with GPS, it was inaccurate

3:34:24enough that there were often problems where the car would show up on the wrong side of the block,

3:34:27like in New York City, like you're on 42nd Street, and they think you're on 43rd Street around the

3:34:33corner or something like that. But I do I just I don't know, I could be wrong. But I do think that

3:34:38these rules were designed basically with all these billion dollar companies aren't paying us anything,

3:34:43how could we get money from them and left over, unthought of are the the long tail of smaller

3:34:51developers who have hundreds of thousands of dollars or maybe low millions of dollars of

3:34:57revenue, where and and a much lower revenue per user that this these rules are just unpalable to

3:35:06that's okay, because for 99% of those small developers, the current situation with the small

3:35:12developer programs actually pretty good deal generally, like you get all the billing

3:35:17infrastructure and the access to the platform and everything else from 15%. It's not that bad.

3:35:22It's really not. All right. I said at the front, I should have had you on the show years ago. And

3:35:27I think the runtime the runtime we've gotten to is proof that I was right. I was correct. I made

3:35:33a grievous error by waiting until now to have you on the show, David, but we've got to wrap it up at

3:35:38some point. I want to thank our sponsors at squarespace.com/talkshow and our good friends one more

3:35:47time I get to say the word nuts nuts.com/the talk show. David's great, great weather app that you

3:35:55all should immediately if you didn't pause the podcast halfway through to go download it is

3:36:00weather up. Just search for weather up in the App Store and you'll get it. Is that the best URL or

3:36:05is there a better URL than just search search in the app for weather app does actually find it

3:36:11thankfully. So do you know we're not paying you to search for weather up bird we're just encouraging

3:36:16you strongly and telling you it is absolutely worth your time. And absolutely do not miss the

3:36:23widgets in weather up it is if if you look at the app, you're like, I don't know if this is the

3:36:29weather app for me and the app itself, which I think is great. I love the map first presentation.

3:36:34Don't skip the widgets before you make your decision. It is that key. David is active on

3:36:40Twitter at Dr. Barnard, Dr. Barnard. My middle name is Richard. That's where that came from.

3:36:49But it's your doctor. Yeah, but I've known that I've known that you must have I didn't know your

3:36:54middle name exactly. But I figured it was your middle name issue. But I've always and I knew

3:36:58you weren't a medical doctor, or you don't seem like the type with a PhD either just but not in

3:37:05my mind. In my mind, your Twitter handle has always been Dr. Bernard and in the other guy,

3:37:10he was on my show a couple years ago. But I don't know if you're familiar with the political

3:37:13economic columnist Matt Iglesias. He's he's on substack. Now he was a founder of Vox, but he's

3:37:21his name is Matt. Y-G-L-E-S-I-S. I'm not quite sure what the ethnicity of his surname is, but

3:37:30it's Matt Iglesias with a Y. But his Twitter name is just all mushed together. And even though I

3:37:36know his name is Matt and he got more Matthew, but he goes by Matt. I've always read his Twitter

3:37:41handle is Matty. Even Matty Iglesias. So Dr. Bernard. A decade ago, Rene Ritchie, I think it

3:37:49was on his podcast or something. I've just always thought of you as a doctor of apps.

3:37:53Yeah, you're a doctor of apps. Yeah, you should be. You're officially a student of the App Store.

3:37:58You're an unofficial doctor. So thank you for your time. And I will I will have you back on soon.

3:38:03We'll have to have to have you back on once the dust settles on on how much of this DMA stuff is

3:38:09compliant and what gets adjusted and what doesn't. Thanks and good luck with weather up. Everybody

3:38:14remember that weather up. Thanks.