0:00:00Federico. Hello. Good to hear your voice. 15 years of max stories. Thanks for having me.
0:00:09Just for this anniversary! I guess. I saw you tweet that, and I'm sure you had the same.
0:00:15Because I've been there. I'm at 22 years at DarrenFirable. But at this point, 15 to 22
0:00:24is like not that big a difference. But I'll bet, because I still think of max stories
0:00:32as newer, like a different generation, and I'll bet you probably think of DarrenFirable
0:00:38as sort of, oh, much older, right? But it's like, no, we're like in the same age group
0:00:44now. Yeah, yeah, we are. And I don't know, it feels like, and this is, I'm sure it's
0:00:49a pandemic related thing. It just, it literally to me, it feels like yesterday that we celebrated
0:00:54the 10th anniversary. And so when it was coming up, John Voorhees was telling me, hey, the
0:01:0015th anniversary is coming up. And I'm like, really? Because we literally just celebrated
0:01:06the 10th just a couple of years ago. And it was not a couple of years ago, it's five years
0:01:09ago. And it's the whole pandemic thing in the middle, of course. And that's stretching
0:01:14out time in a strange way. It really is, isn't it? It really is. It just, and not to delve
0:01:22into politics, but it really feels like Joe Biden's fourth year. It's like, how is this
0:01:29possible that we're at the election again? It feels like Trump's four years, or it's
0:01:3420 years. It felt like it was two decades. And I feel like Joe Biden just got into office
0:01:39and telling me we've got an election again. And yeah, it is the way that the last four
0:01:45or five years have been screwed up time-wise. Parts of it seems so long, parts of it seems
0:01:50so short. Yeah, I do think of Mac stories as still like the young website. And I realized
0:01:59that that's wrong because for a lot of people looking from the outside, looking at Mac stories,
0:02:04they're like, well, those guys have been doing this for 15 years. They've been around forever.
0:02:08They must know all the tricks of the business. And personally, I don't think I do. I don't
0:02:14think we do at all. And I still look up, I mean, I look at Daring Fireball, I look at
0:02:18Mac rumors, like Mac rumors has been around longer than Daring Fireball, I think. Somewhere
0:02:25around the same age, I think. But then of course, I look at YouTubers and especially
0:02:32I look at TikTokers and folks on Instagram and I realize, yeah, I am part of an older
0:02:38generation. That's sort of what keeps me grounded is looking at all these new creators, doing
0:02:44things that I don't know how to do and don't want to do. And I realize, yeah, 15 years,
0:02:51I see the age now. It is weird to, for me, like I don't see Daring Fireball or me personally
0:03:03as that different from when it was undeniably new and young. Let's say if I started in 2002,
0:03:14let's say the years between 2002 when I started Daring Fireball and when the iPhone came out
0:03:21in 2007, I would say like that five-year period would be the early days, pre-iPhone, which
0:03:26is clearly a seminal moment covering Apple, covering the industry, covering just technology,
0:03:32right? I mean, no hyperbole truly changed the world. I don't view it that differently.
0:03:40It's like there's a part of me, a little part of me, like 20% of me in the back of my mind
0:03:45that knows that I carry a certain gravity, a stature. The best example I can think of
0:03:55is that I used to regularly post jackass of the week being jackasses. And at a certain
0:04:07point somebody pointed out to me that somebody's name, when you just type their name, not like
0:04:14Federico Viticci jackass, and then it comes up with the Daring Fireball post, just like
0:04:20Federico Viticci. And then the first hit is my website calling you a jackass. And I thought,
0:04:27oh, that's not that they, you know, and I remember looking back at them and I was like,
0:04:32are there any of these that I really regret? And it was like, nope, nope, jackass, jackass,
0:04:36jackass. But I thought it that's just the one example I can think of where I definitely
0:04:45adjusted my personal editorial stance, because I thought, you know what, it is something,
0:04:51something that Peter Parker with great power comes great responsibility. Okay, I, you know,
0:04:58and just a couple weeks ago, I called somebody a jackass. But I was like, you to me, the
0:05:02bar is way higher now, it has to be somebody who, who is writing at a publication of similar
0:05:09stature like CNBC or something like that. And it has to be truly egregious. But, but
0:05:16for the most part, I tried to stay in the same headspace that I was when I was much,
0:05:24much lower on the totem pole of Apple tech related media. And I think that served me
0:05:31well because I feel like the site still has the same flavor. And I see that at Mac stories
0:05:36too. I don't think Mac stories is very different at 15 than it was at no five, right? No, right.
0:05:44Yeah, no, it's true. This is something that I think about a lot like the idea of, of staying
0:05:49true to yourself in terms of what you publish, what you write, what you're interested in,
0:05:54but also being aware and conscious of the responsibility that you carry. And so something
0:05:59that I noticed for example, is that I used to blog a lot more. Like I used to publish
0:06:04all sorts of things in the early days. Like, Oh, there's a rumor. I'm going to publish
0:06:08a rumor. There's this new app. I'm going to write it up in, in, in a couple of hours and
0:06:13publish. And I obviously like, I still love to write about apps and I still love to publish
0:06:18frequently, but there's always that thought in the back of my mind that makes me go, okay,
0:06:25you do need to think about this more carefully maybe. And I'm sure that's something that
0:06:29also happens with age. Like you tend to be more, you tend to think about stuff for longer.
0:06:35At least that's something that I've noticed in myself. I tend to, I don't want to say
0:06:40second guess, but I try to understand, okay, how could the audience take this article?
0:06:46What impact could it have where, and maybe that's something that I was not necessarily
0:06:51considering when I was getting started because I was hungry to publish all sorts of content
0:06:56and to be found by as many people as possible. And so I think it's an interesting problem
0:07:02from a creative perspective. How do you balance? Because I still have that hunger inside of
0:07:07me. I still have that, that's, that spark isn't gone, but I need to be careful. I think
0:07:14I need to, I need to remember, look, there's, there's thankfully a lot of people opening
0:07:20the site and so could, could, could this do any sort of harm to somebody? Like if you
0:07:28write about an app and the app is terrible and like this is also, this also goes with
0:07:32the, it reminded me of this topic, the, the, the latest controversy, quote unquote controversy
0:07:38with MKBHD and the power of reviews. It's something similar, right? Like obviously I
0:07:44still want to review products and obviously just like Marques and you want to review Apple
0:07:49stuff in this case, but there's that little thought that's there and you need to remember
0:07:56there's a big audience out there. And so as time has gone on over the past 15 years, that
0:08:01is something that has changed, like thinking more deeply about the possible impact of something
0:08:07that I publish.
0:08:08Yeah. Yeah. And it's, I think what you're saying gets to the point I was trying to make
0:08:14earlier where you kind of part of the trick of hopefully, I mean, I hope it applies to
0:08:21me. I can say from my perspective as a reader of Mac stories, it definitely applies to you
0:08:25that it, in the whole site and John and anybody else who contributes that you guys still have
0:08:32the right spirit. I hope I do too, but there is a trick in terms of realizing you have
0:08:40more influence while still being true to your readers, which is your first priority. And
0:08:50that means not holding your punches when it's deserved. And to me with the MKBHD thing with
0:08:55the humane AI pin, part of the reason that is just so eye-rolly to criticize him for
0:09:04any aspect of that review, which I think, and again, it does the part of it. The only
0:09:10part that maybe has a little credence is the, was the title of the video deserved. Right.
0:09:15And that gets to a point I've tried to make a daring fireball for a decade or more that
0:09:21headlines. You cannot, you cannot over over estimate how important headlines are right
0:09:29in terms of like, and it's like why tech meme years ago started rewriting headlines where
0:09:37they see fit to be adjusted because so many people only see headlines and with the notifications
0:09:45on the phone, it's even more, it's always been true that headlines are overly influential
0:09:52compared to the body of the article, but with notifications it's even more so because I
0:09:59mean, I have to admit, I do it. There are times where I'll look, I let Apple news send
0:10:03me notifications. They're pretty good. And a lot of times they come in and I don't read
0:10:08the story. I'm like, Oh, something, something Trump in New York. I just take the headline
0:10:12for what it is and flick it away. So there's a point about that. But I actually think though
0:10:16that he and he in, in his followup video, it's very clear that he thought long and hard
0:10:23about that headline or the title, whatever you want to call it. And the other point is
0:10:29humane raised $270 million in venture capital. They have a petty. They're the first ones
0:10:35to S to let everybody, just like people who go to Harvard or the first ones to, how do
0:10:40you know somebody went to Harvard? Just let them talk. They're the first ones to tell
0:10:44you that they, their founders worked on major products at Apple and, and take a lot of credit
0:10:50for the, their roles in those products. He's not punching down, right? That's, that's punching
0:10:56up. I mean, Marquez is in my opinion, the preeminent tech gadget reviewer of, of our
0:11:06generation right now, no doubt. He he's, he's taken the mantle from Walt Mossberg as the
0:11:13top reviewer across the industry. And it makes sense that it's a YouTuber. I'm not, you know,
0:11:20you're not a YouTuber, but you know, I, my eyes are wide open. I realized that it's probably
0:11:26true that if I were getting started today, if I were in my twenties and getting started,
0:11:31there's a good chance I'd be a YouTuber instead of a writer or the other way around. And I,
0:11:36I don't know. I mean, maybe not because I don't know that I'm very good at it, but,
0:11:42but it's maybe I would be because I'd practice at it. I don't know. It's just clearly video
0:11:47first is, is and it happened in the 20th century going from earlier in the 20th century, being
0:11:56a newspaper columnist would be much was, was by far and away the most influential somebody
0:12:01could be. And then television took over and it's not that newspapers and newspaper columnists
0:12:06disappeared, but TV became preeminent and the same thing has happened to the internet.
0:12:11Just much faster because that's the nature of computers and being a writer on the internet
0:12:18very quickly in the grand scheme of things became eclipsed by being a video personality
0:12:24on the internet. But there's no doubt that as influential as Marquez is, it's still punching
0:12:30up to criticize a company that raised a quarter of a billion dollars to make their product
0:12:36is charging customers a serious amount of money. It's an $800 product with a mandatory
0:12:42$24 a month cellular connection. So it's at least a thousand dollars for a year to use
0:12:48the thing. That's fair. I don't know. Yeah. Yeah. And yeah, I saw, I really think that
0:12:54that that all controversy was kind of silly. And so many of these people that I think criticized
0:13:00Marquez on Twitter or X, whatever, I do think that some of them did it for some sort of
0:13:05clout like to get to publish the controversial opinion and to be noticed. And so there's
0:13:13also that dynamic at play in this circumstance, which I think is kind of silly. But your point
0:13:20about sort of that natural transition from newspapers to television sort of mirroring
0:13:27what we saw with blogs and the written content to video, I think is a really interesting
0:13:32one. And personally, I feel like, like if I were getting started today, maybe I would
0:13:39consider video obviously, but I look at where I am now and I could not imagine doing any
0:13:49other thing about writing. So it's not like I'm looking at these new creators and I'm
0:13:54like, man, I'm jealous. I should, I picked the wrong career. No, I don't feel like that
0:13:59at all. And I think there is, in fact, I do think there is room for all kinds of different
0:14:07types of editorial content, whether it's words on screen or footage on screen. And in fact,
0:14:15I do think it's also interesting to keep an eye on thinking about the next 15 years, maybe.
0:14:20I think it's interesting that this resurgence of the indie web of sorts with this talking
0:14:25about activity pub, but in general, I see all these new cool web projects pop up now
0:14:32compared to a few years ago when it was just Twitter and Facebook and YouTube and that
0:14:36was it. And so this new approach to the indie decentralized web, it makes me hopeful that
0:14:44we are not going to be the last of our species, so to speak. I don't know.
0:14:51Yeah, well, I was thinking that's sort of a topic I wanted to ask you about, though,
0:14:56because I think it's almost undeniable. I don't think it's just because I'm older and I'm
0:15:00missing the upstarts, but that there are, to me, a slightly disappointing dearth of
0:15:10newer sites in our sphere who would be, let's say, let's say hitting their five year anniversary
0:15:16right now. Like, hey, congratulations to so and so for five years of something. Oh, yes,
0:15:21and I looked up to Mac stories when I founded my site. There's very few. But I wonder, though,
0:15:27if we're not, and I think you might be seeing the same thing, that maybe we're all having
0:15:35a moment where that might happen over the next five years.
0:15:38Exactly. Yeah, that's the feeling that I have.
0:15:43I'm thinking of, in particular, like one example I can think of is Molly White, who writes,
0:15:49she's probably best known for web. Web three is going great.
0:15:55Oh, yes.
0:15:56But she's and she just started like a new microblogging site. I mean, she's obviously
0:16:01also in addition to being a very, very astute pundit and observer and critic of crypto,
0:16:09the whole crypto world. She's also obviously a very good programmer and she's putting,
0:16:14which I appreciate putting together her own site and has like a new just sort of a pure
0:16:19old school blog blog, right? And it's for posts that she and she has a newsletter too
0:16:25and things that she thinks like the newsletters are sort of more one big 750,000 word sort
0:16:33of essay. And for things, this is what blogs are perfect for things that are way too big
0:16:39to put into a Mastodon post entirely, but wouldn't make a full newsletter. And it's
0:16:47like, yeah, that, and that is sort of the beauty of the internet is that you, you can
0:16:52carve out post sizes, whatever the medium, whether it's video or audio or text of the
0:17:02appropriate size. And in the pre internet era, the scarcity of being able to reach people
0:17:10print is so expensive and so just labor intensive. It's just the, when you really think about
0:17:20like even today, I mean, people's, there are still people who read print newspapers, but
0:17:24like the hay day of newspapers where, where like major cities around the world, you know,
0:17:30had million plus circulation printing an entire newspaper and a million million plus copies
0:17:37a day. It's just an enormous amount of paper and just truck after truck after truck loaded
0:17:48with printed copies of the newspaper. And when you see the printing presses, how fast
0:17:53they would go with these huge sheets of broadsheet, it's almost mind boggling. I've told this
0:18:02story on the talk show before. Let me, I, but years ago, it must be probably like 10,
0:18:0715 years ago, I was at Starbucks and it was a Sunday, I think. And there was two young
0:18:14women like college age, maybe like early twenties and there was a copy of the New York times
0:18:19and I swear to God, I'm not making this up. The one was like, like the one that had clearly
0:18:25just never really thought about newspapers and they were, the one was saying to the other,
0:18:30like, well, there's, there's the business and there's the sports and there's look, there's
0:18:33different sections and, and, and then she said, and they print, they do this every day.
0:18:40And the other girl said, why would they do that? When you can just go to the website,
0:18:46right? Like why would you print this much paper every single day? But that's how you
0:18:51got it. But, but it was the nature when, when you had to spend all that money to print a
0:18:55magazine or a newspaper, you couldn't just publish a 50 word article. There just was
0:19:02no, no form for it.
0:19:04Yeah. So I really do feel like there's a few things that have happened over the past, over
0:19:10the past decade for sure, that have led to that sort of scarcity of, of sites, of blogs.
0:19:17I definitely think that the whole Twitter, Facebook era over the past 10 years, that
0:19:23saw a lot of, a lot of folks realize, well, why can I, why do I need to start a website
0:19:29if I can just publish my own opinions on Twitter? And then it used to be Facebook video for
0:19:35a while and then it became Instagram, but mostly on Twitter. And I have seen like, there's
0:19:40a ton of folks from, from people who are you know, pundits or observers to this new generation
0:19:48of leakers of Apple rumors specifically just on Twitter. And then I've started seeing a
0:19:55lot of people who they should have just started blogs in my opinion, but folks who publish
0:20:04opinions, like little blog posts essentially on places like Reddit.
0:20:10And then came the newsletters, right? So there was that consolidation of sub stack and all
0:20:15the newsletters and, and so many folks realizing, well, this is an easier way for me to publish
0:20:22long form content that I used to split up in multiple tweets on Twitter. Now I get to
0:20:27send it to an audience and I don't have to think about setting up a web server. I don't
0:20:31have to think about RSS integration. I can just open a sub stack account and I can just
0:20:36serve this small audience that I have there. And people still do it. Like I've seen, for
0:20:40example, in the video game press with all the layoffs that have been happening in the
0:20:45video game industry over the past few years, a lot of folks from, from websites like the
0:20:50older Kotaku website from that was sold to Geo media. I think Geo media has also been
0:20:56in the news today because they sold the onion again. Yeah. So a lot of those folks coming
0:21:02out of those websites, they started sub stacks instead of starting websites. But over the
0:21:08past year or so, I've seen the opposite started happening. There are some new video game websites,
0:21:15for example, and there are folks realizing, well, maybe I can just open up a little blog
0:21:22with all these tools that exist today to set up a little blog like we did 15 years ago.
0:21:29And I think that the sort of implosion of Twitter and the arrival of threads combined
0:21:36with the arrival of Mastodon and Activity Pub is making a lot of people rethink their
0:21:41approach to owning your opinions. And maybe this is an optimistic view that I have, but
0:21:47I do think that what we didn't see, what we haven't seen over the past 10 years, the situation
0:21:54may improve over the next five because I think people are, creators are a lot more aware
0:22:00of the importance of owning your opinions, owning your content and not trusting again
0:22:10this silos and these platforms that promise you maximum reach, minimal effort, and then
0:22:17they shut down after a couple of years and you're left with nothing.
0:22:20Or they fundamentally change after a couple of years, which is, could be just as bad or
0:22:26even worse than, and maybe Twitter falls under that category where it's maybe worse than
0:22:31if it had shut down in some ways. Yeah. And Mac stories launched, so 15 years would mean
0:22:37you launched in 2009 and that means Twitter, Twitter already existed and was sort of, I
0:22:44would say it was sort of entering its heyday, right? I would peg Twitter's best years as
0:22:50maybe right around then, 2009, 10, 11. And personally, I think the world is a better
0:22:58place right now for Twitter-like media split across multiple platforms. Twitter itself
0:23:08or Twitter X, whatever you want to call it, is not dead and maybe not dying and it sort
0:23:14of seems to be stabilizing. I kind of feel like it's, personally, what I see on Twitter
0:23:25is better now. I would say this year, like the calendar year 2024, like something happened
0:23:33at Twitter where I'm not seeing stuff I don't want to see in my timeline. And it's not,
0:23:41I'm not a delicate flower. It's not like stuff that offends me. It's just stuff that annoys
0:23:47me or irritates me. Just like, why are you showing me this? This is nonsense. And I know
0:23:53that there's, if you go looking for it, you're going to find people with political opinions
0:23:59that are unpleasant no matter which side you are on Twitter. But it feels to me like they're
0:24:03no longer shoving it down your throat like they were when Elon Musk first took over.
0:24:10But there's no doubt. I saw somebody, I forget which publication, and I'm always the first
0:24:16one to say if it's a third party saying how much traffic a site is getting or how many
0:24:24downloads an app is getting, take it with a huge grain of salt because they don't know.
0:24:29They're estimating and they might be right, but look into their methodology and see how
0:24:34they know how many downloads an app has. But somebody suggested this week that threads
0:24:40has passed Twitter for monthly active users or daily active users. I don't know about
0:24:46that. And it's so hard to tell because I think Twitter is home to so many more bots and whether
0:24:53they're not even scam bots, right? I mean, just like national weather service programs,
0:25:01you know, a bot that everybody would agree is a great Twitter account, right? Like if
0:25:04you have some kind of weather service that just on the hour, every hour tells you. I
0:25:09subscribe to one on Mastodon that I really like that just tells me the sunset and sunrise
0:25:14times for Philadelphia every day. So every day in the evening, I have a little Mastodon
0:25:18post from a, it's obviously automated, but there's so much more of that on Twitter that
0:25:23it's hard to compare. But I find personally, I like the current state of things where there's
0:25:30no one true Twitter like service, which was Twitter for over a decade. And now I've got
0:25:38my feet in three or four different of them. I check Mastodon, I check threads. I do still
0:25:45I'm and more and more, I'm a little bit more back on Twitter. I keep my eye on blue sky,
0:25:50blue sky. I really like and I wish in some ways I kind of see it as the best idea, the
0:25:56best balance between all of the things and it, but the content just isn't there for me.
0:26:03But I also find that with three or four of these Twitter like things to keep tabs on,
0:26:09I spend less time overall than I did when it was just one Twitter.
0:26:14Yeah. Yeah. I do think that there's obviously a few communities that never left Twitter.
0:26:20I see this with video games. I see this with, there's a lot of like startup, young developers
0:26:27type creators that continuously post stuff to Twitter. I don't use Twitter, but occasionally
0:26:33I do log in and like you say, I have noticed things getting better just in the, in the
0:26:38for you recommendation timeline. There's one specific type of community. There's a, I,
0:26:45for many years, I cultivated this list on Twitter just about Pokemon news and specifically
0:26:51competitive Pokemon players. And those people never left and Nintendo is still actively
0:26:59posting on Twitter. So there are those pockets of communities that never left, but then you
0:27:05go to threads and you find this new, like there's a ton of journalists, a lot of tech
0:27:11coverage happening there. And then of course there's Mastodon where the core of the tech
0:27:17early adopters, tons of folks are into the open web, indie web, all those modern web
0:27:24projects being active on Mastodon. And then there's like the artistic community on Blue
0:27:29Sky. I do follow a bunch of really cool like artists and animators on Blue Sky. And so
0:27:36I think it's fascinating that we are entering this era where there's no single and clear
0:27:42winner of them all. There's different places for different communities. I don't know how
0:27:48this will shake out over time, but like you, I don't mind the splitting apart of these
0:27:56segments of online culture, if you will, like following different people in different places
0:28:03where it makes the most sense for them to be in. But I think there's also a lesson here
0:28:09for websites like ours, but for creators in general, I think, to like obviously Twitter
0:28:17was incredible for me in 2009. I owe so much to Twitter. It was the golden era of Twitter
0:28:26and that old era of Twitter clients. Like it was wild. And the amount of traffic that
0:28:31Twitter drove to Mac stories in the early days, I owe so much to them. But now I wouldn't
0:28:41trust Mac stories to say, well, we're going all in on threads and we're just going to
0:28:49publish. Like I don't want to do that the same way I did in 2009, even though it worked.
0:28:56And it works really well, but I wouldn't do it today.
0:29:00I think it would almost I'd almost want to like, hey, Federico, you OK? Not because I'm
0:29:05down on threads. I'm almost to the point of controversy from people who find metas past
0:29:13transgressions unforgivable. I'd been going back and forth with people trying to explain
0:29:19how I see it as consistent. My staunch criticism of Metta from three, four, five, six years
0:29:26ago to less critical and an enthusiastic user of threads today. But I would say you're crazy
0:29:35to go all in on one of the platforms. Right. Any of them. Right. And I think that's actually
0:29:40a really good sign. And I always go back to video game consoles. I don't know what happened
0:29:45there, but we've always been fortunate that there have been two or three. And it's really
0:29:51been at this point, Xbox came out in 1999. So for twenty five years, we've had three.
0:29:59And I think that's about as lucky as you're going to get. I wish, you know, we're lucky
0:30:05in so many ways. We could get to this later in the show. And it's sometimes one of those
0:30:11things that can keep me up at night is how much of what I love about computers is only
0:30:17represented by one company, Apple, and how how that's one thread. You know, I wish that
0:30:26like desktop computing and mobile phone computing was a three way race instead of a two way
0:30:33race. It would have been so especially if it had been Palm's Web OS that had carved
0:30:39out like like 15 percent market share or something like that, like something maybe more akin
0:30:45to where the Mac was 20 years ago, strong enough to be a business like or like Nintendo.
0:30:52Right. I don't know. It would have been great. But it's always lucky when you have at least
0:30:58three competitors. And I think that it really shows for social media. I think it's better
0:31:04now. And personally, it's just so much less of a gravitational black hole that when Twitter
0:31:11was in its heyday, I really would get it. I wouldn't call it an addiction. It's just
0:31:16that it was there was so much and everything was concentrated there that you'd go check
0:31:21Twitter and then three hours goes by and it's like, oh, yes. Oh, yeah. Twitter on Apple event
0:31:27days was impossible to use. And we still did. And that's the thing we still did. We still
0:31:33did it because it was the only place and everybody was there. And so I do think we are much better
0:31:38off today with options with with like like the idea of like you said, I think that the
0:31:46video game console analogy is a really good one because we've had options for twenty five
0:31:51for twenty five years at this point. And there's always also been like PC gaming also always
0:31:57right. Right. So never, never went away. Yeah. I would say that's call it for I would say
0:32:03that I often think of it as three. But I think PC gaming should count as the fourth pillar
0:32:08of of the video, the serious video game industry. Yeah. Especially not especially now that the
0:32:14PC manufacturers figured out, I guess, starting with the steam deck, but they figured out,
0:32:19hey, we can actually make these things portable. And so we've been fine as as as as people
0:32:25with with different consoles and platforms and picking your preferences and maybe owning
0:32:32multiple consoles like I do. And it's fine. And so I think using different social networks
0:32:39and something that I do, for example, I post different types of content or maybe the same
0:32:44content but presented in a slightly different format on Mastodon and Threads, because I
0:32:50know that folks on Threads, I think, like certain types of of posts and folks on Mastodon
0:32:58like other types of content. And so I think these are these can only serve me well, especially
0:33:05when you have different audiences coming from different places. It can only be good for
0:33:11an independent publication like Mac Stories instead of I was I was really scared when
0:33:17that whole Twitter saga was unfolding a couple of years ago. I thought, well, now we're done,
0:33:23like in terms of social media, because we never started using Facebook, we never did
0:33:28YouTube. And so I really thought, well, unless there's a better hope that those RSS subscribers,
0:33:35they stay subscribed, because otherwise, like, we're gone from social media. And then, of
0:33:40course, Mastodon started taking off and then Threads came around. So multiple options is
0:33:46not a bad deal, I would say.
0:33:50To me, at its best, what these social media platforms, the Twitter like ones are, is it
0:33:58really is a great way to have a back and forth with the readers. And one of the differences
0:34:09between when I started Daring Fireball and Mac Stories, like earlier in the show, I said,
0:34:15we're the same, we're roughly the same generation now website wise, but there's one difference
0:34:20from the 2000s that you more or less started at the end of was when I started, it was universal
0:34:29for a blog to have comments on each post. And I've never had comments. And it used to
0:34:35be it was almost a gag, where over and over again, people would say, you know, and again,
0:34:42circa 2004 2005, there was no Twitter yet. So it wasn't even on Twitter, it would be
0:34:46like email, but people I would get email over and over and over again, I swear, where they
0:34:52would they'd be like, Hey, this was a good article, blah, blah, blah. But then they would
0:34:55say, they'd be irritated that they were emailing me rather than leaving a comment. And the
0:35:00way they'd over and over again, they would say, it's not Daring Fireball can't really
0:35:04be called a blog, if it doesn't have comments. And then I would write back to them, I say,
0:35:09thank you, you know, and I'd respond to their comments. And then I'd quote that part. And
0:35:13I'd say, Okay, then it's not a blog. I don't care. We use a different word for it. But
0:35:17fine, but I'm not going to put comments on this site. I don't I, I've always thought
0:35:22they were the cons outweighed the pros. There are pros, right? And and an astute comment
0:35:31is an astute comment. But I always thought once Twitter became a thing, I was like, Ah,
0:35:35here's the solution. And I think it's better that it's on neutral territory, rather than
0:35:41being on my site under my post with me, with the admins ability to delete the ones I don't
0:35:49want or whatever. And the responsibility of deleting the spam ones and whatever, not just
0:35:55like, Oh, I don't like you or you're being I think you're being a jerk. But oh, this
0:35:58is obviously I don't this is spam, I need to delete this. Take that off my hands. I
0:36:04thought Twitter was and still is. And I think that's where all of these platforms still
0:36:10are, like, and that's why I love to engage in them in have a public back and forth. And
0:36:16especially, especially if people disagree with me on something, I'm happy to debate
0:36:20it. I know that it's just one of those things where people have been more drawn to like
0:36:27minded content, like, I only want to read things I agree with, I think is a little more
0:36:34of a common mindset now. And I don't understand that I feel like I want to read things I disagree
0:36:39with not vehemently or jackassery. But teach me if I'm wrong about something, I'm only
0:36:45going to learn that I'm wrong about it by reading somebody who has a different view
0:36:49back and forth on the social media is still great. And I think it's better now that it's
0:36:53not all on one Twitter.
0:36:55Yeah. And we used to have comments for the first couple of years on Mac stories, and
0:37:00then we removed them. And I remember a lot of people were upset when we did and we got
0:37:06a lot of the same comment, sort of emails from people saying it's not a blog anymore,
0:37:11if I can leave a comment. And we stuck with that decision, because ultimately, I think
0:37:17it's better to use social media to engage with readers, to be social, to be social.
0:37:23Exactly. It's already there in the name, like, and the way I see it, you read Mac stories,
0:37:27or you read during fireball, what you see on the screen is my opinion or John's opinion,
0:37:33that is the content. The comments, especially for, there was a time a few years ago when
0:37:41it was almost, the argument was, well, but the comments are part of the content. And
0:37:48I strongly disagree with that. The comments are somebody else's comments. Whereas the
0:37:54article that I publish, the review that I publish is my content. And that's why you
0:37:59open the site or why you subscribe. And if you don't like it, you know, there's other
0:38:03websites. But if you want to comment, that's not part of the original story that you're
0:38:09reading. And I think it was the right decision. And it doesn't seem like anybody cares that
0:38:17much about comments on blogs anymore. The one maybe asterisk here is comments on YouTube.
0:38:29That is still very much part of the YouTube. I say way of doing things. Everybody, like
0:38:34everybody says, let me know down in the comments below, for example, you're watching a video
0:38:38and everybody's just asking people to leave a comment. So YouTube is maybe the one outlier
0:38:43here. I don't, I never read the comments. Occasionally there is the useful correction.
0:38:52And I think, I think part of the reason why they are occasionally useful is the fact that
0:38:57you can timestamp a video and point to like, if you want to issue a correction or something,
0:39:03you can just have a little link that points to that point in the video and say, hey, here,
0:39:07by the way, it's such and such. So maybe that's why. But by and large, they are filled by
0:39:14you go see a comment on a MKBHD video and there's always the people commenting first.
0:39:21That's the comment. Occasionally there is the useful comment here and there. And the
0:39:26other place of course is Reddit. I think a lot of, a lot of actually sometimes useful,
0:39:33some often interesting conversations surrounding an article can happen on Reddit. And that's,
0:39:40I guess the place for it, right? You have tons, it's like a forum basically, but it's
0:39:44open to everybody. So yeah.
0:39:48It's another one too, where almost admitting that they're copying Twitter with the, okay,
0:39:53we're going to, we're going to third party APIs and try to for the stated purpose of
0:40:02controlling the first party interface, making sure everybody goes through the first party
0:40:06interface to the site for better or for worse. And you understand business wise, why they
0:40:10want to do that. But as somebody who enjoys nice native software, you know, it's not as,
0:40:19it's not as nice, but you know, it has stabilized, right? There was the, they did this, there
0:40:24was an uproar. There was sort of a revolt. There were protests on very popular subreddits
0:40:33and it's sort of stabilized and it is sort of an indispensable part of the internet.
0:40:37My wife is a much more dedicated Reddit user than me or reader and it is, it is a great
0:40:42source of local news among other things. But yeah. All right, let me take a break here
0:40:48and thank our first sponsor. It is our good friends. I love, I love this sponsor cause
0:40:52I get to say the word nuts so many times. nuts.com nuts.com is your one stop shop for
0:40:59freshly roasted. Guess what? Nuts of course, but also dried fruit, sweets, candy, pantry
0:41:07staples like specialty flowers, things for baking and cooking, stuff like that and more.
0:41:13Their wide selection means there is something for everyone. And I mean that if you go to
0:41:17nuts.com and surf around for just a couple of minutes and you don't find a couple of
0:41:22things that you're like, Oh, I would like that in, I don't even know if you eat really,
0:41:27really a great one stop place to buy all sorts of stuff. And number one, their top priority
0:41:33is quality for the nuts. They roast their nuts on their own. They pop their own corn
0:41:39and they do it all the same day at ships. So if you buy nuts, they roast the nuts, seal
0:41:44them up, put them in a box and it's on their way to you the same day they were roasted
0:41:48or popped. And so everything reaches you as fresh as possible. Satisfaction is guaranteed.
0:41:54They offer plenty of things like gluten free options, organic choices, all sorts of other
0:41:59diet friendly products. Whether you're looking for something sweet or savory or need to stock
0:42:04up on everyday cooking essentials, you are bound to find something to try. You can shop
0:42:10a cart at any time. Just go there, order the things you want, get one order or you can
0:42:16opt into a hassle free automatic delivery of the things you want on a regular basis
0:42:21so that you never run out of your favorite items. And if you're already stocked up at
0:42:25home, they also sell directly to businesses and they have a bunch of great gift options
0:42:30too. Right now, I should say some of my personal favorites, I've mentioned this and here's
0:42:36one, I always mention the half pop popcorn. For me, that's the one thing from them that
0:42:40I haven't run, ever since they've started sponsoring the podcast, have not run out of
0:42:43at home because I love it so much. It's exactly what you think. I don't know why this isn't
0:42:49like a universal snack item that you can buy everywhere because it is so good, but it's
0:42:54half pop popcorn is like halfway between like roasted corn nuts and popcorn. It is so good.
0:43:01The other thing they have, and again, it's not just their own nuts.com branded stuff.
0:43:05They've got dark chocolate M&Ms, which I'm telling you are like 10 times better than
0:43:11milk chocolate M&Ms. I find milk chocolate M&Ms to have like no chocolate taste at all.
0:43:16It's like just like sugar. Whereas dark chocolate M&Ms are like really, really good chocolatey
0:43:23flavor. It's really good. And it's really hard to find dark chocolate M&Ms. I didn't
0:43:27even know they existed until I found them in nuts.com. And ever since I've been calling
0:43:31out the dark chocolate M&Ms, I get emails from people who's, you know, go to nuts.com
0:43:36because of the sponsorship and they're like, you were right about the dark chocolate M&Ms.
0:43:39So if you're on the fence about that, get them. So anyway, right now, nuts.com is offering
0:43:44new customers a free gift with purchase and free shipping on orders of $29 or more. And
0:43:51it is so easy to put $29 of stuff in your cart at nuts.com because they have so much
0:43:56good stuff. Just go to nuts.com/thetalkshow to get that special deal. So go check out
0:44:03all their delicious options at nuts.com/thetalkshow and you'll receive a free gift and free shipping
0:44:10when you spend $29 or more. So one last time nuts.com/thetalkshow.
0:44:20It's the busy time of the year for the Mac media. WWDC is coming up, but unusual for
0:44:27Apple on the schedule and I don't want to run out of time. So I feel like we should
0:44:31get to it. Are you familiar with the iPad Federico?
0:44:34Yes, I would say, Hey, there is an online event that they, it unusually they've announced
0:44:45two weeks in advance. It's going to be Tuesday, May 7th. And I would say more than any event
0:44:52in maybe in history, they're making it clear what it's about because the announcement
0:44:58shows a human hand with an Apple pencil in it.
0:45:03And Tim Cook tweeted pencil us in May 7th.
0:45:09I would say that's even more of a clear than what did Jaws tweet about WWDC. It was something
0:45:15with AI.
0:45:16It's going to be absolutely incredible with the AI capitalized.
0:45:21Which is a hint, but it's only a hint of a topic rather than a product. And we kind
0:45:28of know what, you know, WWDC is it's annual, but we know they're going to talk about
0:45:34every one of the platforms. And we don't know what, they're just telling us a bunch
0:45:37of it's going to be AI related. Whereas this May 7th event, what's the event title?
0:45:42Let Loose.
0:45:43Let Loose. I don't get that. Do you get that?
0:45:45No, I have no idea. What are we letting loose? I don't know.
0:45:50Yeah, but I feel like they should have just titled it. It's the iPad.
0:45:57It's the iPad again, parentheses.
0:45:59Right. And it's exciting because I feel like it's quite possibly going to be the biggest
0:46:09iPad. I mean this with no hyperbole. The biggest iPad event since the first one in 2010.
0:46:15Yeah. I'm starting to have that feeling too. I don't know why. I was pretty down
0:46:21on these iPads going into these events. And I don't know, I'm just picking up a few
0:46:28signals here and there that it's not just going to be, they obviously wanted to do more
0:46:34than just a press release. So that's a good first sign. Now it's not a keynote with
0:46:41an event in person. There used to be like they would announce these products. If you
0:46:46recall when they did the events at the Yerba Buena Center in San Francisco, they used to
0:46:51do these product events there. Now they obviously do them at Apple Park. So it's not that
0:46:55type of event, but still it's not just a press release. And the iPad Pro has been effectively
0:47:04unchanged for the past, I want to say six years at this point.
0:47:08Yeah, 2018.
0:47:102018. And the iPad Air is a couple of years old now. And so I do feel like both in terms
0:47:17of hardware, but really also in terms of software, there is a lot to be done still. And I feel
0:47:25like this is the sort of conversation that we've always had about the iPad. I'm sure
0:47:29last time I was a guest on the talk show, we talked about like, oh, the iPad has so
0:47:33much potential, but they don't pay attention to it. And so we continue having this conversation,
0:47:40but now it's been six years since the 2018 iPad Pro. And so it does feel like something's
0:47:47got to change at this point for it to make sense.
0:47:52And I feel like, you know, you and I talk about it every time I have you on the show.
0:47:57It's hard not to say that Apple loves all of its platform children, but they love the
0:48:03iPhone most. I mean, and the Mac is different enough that I think the Mac comes second and
0:48:11the iPad just falls in third place in terms of interest. And that it's sort of, it always
0:48:19comes back to that, well, it's just a big iPhone, right? And the way that when they,
0:48:28which is more of a marketing decision than a technical decision to call the iOS, iPad
0:48:36OS, instead of saying that iOS is the operating system for iPod touches at the time, iPhones
0:48:44and all iPads, part of it to me was about setting it up so that the iPhone could get
0:48:52features a year ahead of the iPad, right? Like the widget stuff, the lock screen customization,
0:48:58just in the last couple of years, the iPhone has been a year ahead of the iPad. And I sort
0:49:04of thought that's partly why they for the name, but there are features, right? There's
0:49:09major, major new features. I know you and I talked about it at length a year ago with
0:49:14stage manager, which is a huge attempt to address a lot of the long-term complaints
0:49:20about, Hey, what if you really want to be a power user on this platform? And of course
0:49:25stage manager doesn't make any sense on the iPhone. It's screens too small, I think. But
0:49:32there's just also at a, not that the software level with what features are in the operating
0:49:39system, I also feel like the hardware has sort of fallen in third place. Right. And
0:49:45there's, you know, like, can you even explain the pencil compatibility story? I get so confused.
0:49:55It doesn't really make a lot of sense. Like honestly, like the confusion that they have
0:49:59created over the years and the pencil compatibility is one of them. The keyboard story is also
0:50:06not like so all over the map, especially when you look at the base model iPad, the base
0:50:11model iPad, arguably for a lot of people would make for a better laptop like iPad than the
0:50:22iPad pro you have the more flexible keyboard with the kickstand that can be detached. And
0:50:28you have the, the, you have the front facing camera on the landscape side. Right. And I
0:50:33think it's so funny that that iPad, which is the very base model for a lot of people
0:50:40would actually make, will actually allow for more flexibility than the expensive iPad pro.
0:50:46And so it's clear you're, you're talking about the 10th generation one. I know you, I know
0:50:52you are, they still sell the ninth generation, which has the, the touch ID button at the
0:50:59bottom, you know, and, but you, you know, you, you mentioned putting the front facing camera
0:51:04on the landscape side. Yeah. It's, you can kind of see how it happened, but it's always
0:51:11been true. I think that the, as a, as an entire lineup, it's always felt like the iPad lineup,
0:51:21the family is always sort of out of sync in some way. Right. Like maybe in 2018 when the
0:51:29current industrial design for the iPad pros debuted. Right. And part of that I'm still
0:51:34using, I've got it right here in my hand for the show notes is my 2018 11 inch iPad pro,
0:51:39which is still a great device. But form factor wise, it fits into the exact same keyboard
0:51:47cases as a brand new, well, two years old at this point, but the, the latest generation
0:51:5311 inch iPad pro you could say in 2018, when they refresh the iPad pros, okay, now the
0:52:01iPad pros make sense, but the iPad errors didn't make sense. And now they've sort of
0:52:06made the iPad errors better, but now the iPad pros seem dated. It seems like six years is
0:52:12too long to go between this. And now it's almost like right now, as we're recording,
0:52:18they've kind of fixed it by making all of the iPads out of date. Yeah. Right. I mean,
0:52:25I'm not being sarcastic. I mean, a little sarcastic and I kind of feel like on May 7th,
0:52:30it's like the, the godfather reference. They're going to settle all family business and get
0:52:34the whole, get the whole platform from top to bottom into a logical sense. I, the reason
0:52:42why I'm excited for these events more than I thought until a few weeks ago is I wonder
0:52:50if maybe this is an opportunity for Apple to start telling a new story for the iPad
0:52:56pro at the very top of the line, because if it does feel like, especially if the iPad
0:53:01air is going to come in two versions, the 11 inch one and the 13 inch one with that
0:53:07iPad air, which is compatible with the pencil, with the magic keyboard as USB-C, it does
0:53:13feel like that is the iPad and has been for a while, but even more so with a bigger model
0:53:18can be the iPad for most people who want an iPad as based on the way they think of an
0:53:26iPad, which is this device in the middle. That's familiar. It's looks like an iPhone,
0:53:31but it's bigger and it's got a keyboard, but what does that mean for an iPad pro? And
0:53:37I'm going to say something that maybe you're not going to like, Jon. I created my own hybrid.
0:53:43I want to talk about it. So yeah, I created my own hybrid Mac iPad device. I've been using
0:53:52it for two months. Like it is my main computer. And I do wonder if maybe the opportunity that
0:53:59Apple has to start telling a new story for the iPad pro is we have this device that can
0:54:08be an iPad, but when you dock it into a keyboard, it can also be a Mac. And now I know that
0:54:16it sounds like heresy for a lot of people, but if you think about it the other way, I
0:54:24would say that there's literally no other company on earth right now that can sell a
0:54:32tablet that can be great in equal measure as a tablet and as a laptop. And I speak from
0:54:41experience. Last year I used for six months without telling anybody a Microsoft Surface
0:54:47because I felt like I was going crazy with the limitations of iPadOS and I thought, well,
0:54:52maybe I need to clear my head. I need to take a look at what it's like on the other side.
0:54:57Let me tell you, the Surface is not a good tablet. It's a semi-decent laptop, but boy
0:55:03does Windows suck on a tablet. It's horrible. And you look at the iPad and you realize,
0:55:12well, here's this one company, literally the only company in the world right now that can
0:55:18potentially make a hybrid laptop/tablet that makes sense and is actually nice to use. And
0:55:26I know that Jason Snell also talks about this idea a lot. It doesn't have to be a convertible
0:55:32all the time. It doesn't have to exclusively run MacOS when you dock it. But as an option,
0:55:39I don't think there's anybody out there, except for Apple, that can say we can do this. Not
0:55:44Microsoft, not Microsoft, third-party Windows manufacturers, not Google with the Pixel tablet,
0:55:53and then we're out of tablet companies at this point.
0:55:56I think Microsoft tried it. And it's interesting. I just saw, speaking of Twitter, he's a great
0:56:02follow on Twitter because he kind of uses it as a blog with longer posts, which I sort
0:56:09of wish he had just had a blog. But Steven Sinofsky, who used to be in charge of Windows
0:56:14for a long time at Microsoft and spearheaded the Surface tablet thing in 2012, was it RT?
0:56:22I forget what they called it. But the ones that they had that ran on ARM, what they tried
0:56:26to do was create a new version of Windows that got rid of all of the legacy APIs and
0:56:33only had a modern API set of APIs and only bring those forward to ARM. And for whatever
0:56:42reason it didn't stick, and they abandoned it. And now they've just sort of said, "Okay,
0:56:47Windows is Windows and we're going forward." And his recent post, I'll put it in the show
0:56:51notes I swear, but his post either yesterday or the day before was talking about that old
0:56:55effort. And he's not throwing his former colleagues under the bus, but like he said, this is with
0:57:01the upcoming Snapdragon chips that Microsoft is... And Qualcomm has been saying for two
0:57:08years that they think they're going to achieve parity with at least the non-pro, max and
0:57:14ultra M series chips, that they're going to have chips that stand toe-to-toe with the
0:57:20M3 or the M2 or something like that. We'll see. But Sinofsky's point was that, okay,
0:57:26and I have no doubt at a technical level, this is the sort of thing Microsoft engineers
0:57:29are great at, as great as Rosetta is, right? And Rosetta was great a generation ago going
0:57:36from PowerPC to Intel. It was absolutely seamless from a consumer's perspective, and it's been
0:57:42great going from Intel to Apple Silicon. And if anything, Apple Silicon is so good and
0:57:48Rosetta is such a good emulator, translator, whatever you want to call it, that almost
0:57:54everybody, even when they're running Intel compiled Mac apps, is getting faster performance
0:57:59on Apple Silicon than they are on the last generation of Intel Macs. There's extreme
0:58:05examples for Intel-based Mac Pros with parallel computing, where you really want as many cores
0:58:10as possible, where you can say no, but still better to run it on Intel. But for the most
0:58:14part it's like that. But the difference that Microsoft faces trying to move Windows to
0:58:19ARM is that the nature of Windows is that Windows still runs like DOS compatible software
0:58:27from like 1989. And all of that has to be emulated. And they might be able to pull it
0:58:33off, but it is Apple that's a very big philosophical difference between what Mac OS is and, you
0:58:41know, and Apple's been even more aggressive about keeping iOS culling old APIs and keeping
0:58:50as the years go by, keeping it modern and just saying old APIs are no longer supported
0:58:57even more so than Mac. Whereas Windows, that's the nature of it. For some people, that's
0:59:02the appeal of Windows is that compatibility is something Microsoft takes seriously, but
0:59:06now they've got to emulate all of that. So we'll see. Tell people about the hybrid device
0:59:13you made. I will put this in the show notes, but you have to describe it to...
0:59:17Okay. Okay. So it all started because of Sage manager. It all goes back to that. I've always
0:59:25loved working on the iPad, but I was reaching a point where I kept running into these limitations.
0:59:32Right? We've spoken about this before with multitasking, just the fact that, for example,
0:59:38I couldn't record my own podcasts on an iPad because it doesn't have the audio APIs that
0:59:45I need to use for software like Audio Hijack and just why am I using two computers? So
0:59:52I started thinking about this and having conversations privately with Jason about this. Hey, wouldn't
0:59:58it be cool if Apple made a hybrid laptop? But then, oddly enough, the final push was
1:00:06given to me by the Vision Pro. I wanted to have the best keyboard for the Vision Pro,
1:00:13the best input system for the Vision Pro. And almost as a joke, I said a few months
1:00:19ago, "Hey, maybe the best keyboard for the Vision Pro is a headless Mac laptop." The best
1:00:28input system for the Vision Pro is something that you put on your lap. It doesn't have
1:00:31a screen, but it's still a Mac. It's got a large trackpad with palm rejection built-in.
1:00:38It lets you virtualize macOS in Vision OS, and it lets you type and control Vision OS
1:00:45thanks to universal control. And so I went ahead and I did it. I removed the screen from
1:00:52my MacBook Air, from the M2 MacBook Air that I have. I decapitated the MacBook Air. And
1:01:01it was working perfectly. And then I was done with the experiment and I looked at it and
1:01:05I was like, "Well, now I have this thing that doesn't have a display anymore." And then
1:01:11I don't know how it happened, but I thought, "Well, but wouldn't it be nice if for those
1:01:18times when I don't want to use a Vision Pro with virtual Mac desktop, wouldn't it be nice
1:01:25if I could use an iPad as a display for this headless MacBook Air?" And that's when all
1:01:31the pieces started coming together. So the setup that I have, and I'm using it on a daily
1:01:36basis, I carry it with me all the time. It's always with me. It's the computer. I'm using
1:01:41it right now. It's a MacBook Air. I attached three magnetic kickstands to the keyboard,
1:01:49essentially, of the MacBook Air. Three magnets to the back of an iPad cover. And I'm using
1:01:56the iPad as a display for this computer. And the funny thing is I'm not using any weird
1:02:01third-party hack or anything. I'm just using Sidecar, the built-in Apple-provided technology
1:02:09to turn an iPad into a Mac display. Usually it's used to turn an iPad into a secondary
1:02:15display. In this case, it's the primary display for the Mac. And the beautiful part of all
1:02:21of this is that at any point I can just grab the iPad. So I grab the display and it's an
1:02:29iPad with iPadOS. And then when I need to get work done again, I dock it down, press
1:02:35a button, and it's MacOS.
1:02:38And the magnets connect to the natural spots on the iPad where there are magnetic connectors?
1:02:44No, they don't.
1:02:45No, they don't. You had to put things on the back of the iPad?
1:02:48Yes. Not the back of the iPad, on the back of the cover that attaches to the iPad.
1:02:53Oh, okay. Gotcha.
1:02:54Nobody should do this. I want to say nobody should do this. And I saw a bunch of people
1:02:59when I did it. I saw a bunch of people when I did it. They're like, "Oh, he's trolling
1:03:04us or he's looking for attention." And I mean, it turned out to be a really fun, really popular
1:03:12story also. But this is actually my computer now. It was not like a joke thing. It is what
1:03:21I'm using. And if anything, I think it's been a useful experiment to try to inform this
1:03:30idea of, would it be so terrible if an iPad could optionally become a Mac? And so far,
1:03:40I've been using it with an 11-inch iPad Pro, so it's even like a small display. It has
1:03:46been a dream for me. I would pay serious money for Apple to make this an official, much better
1:03:52looking product than mine.
1:03:57It comes back to modularity. And modularity is a powerful concept. I remember, I mean,
1:04:06again, I'll date myself here, but in the late '90s or early 2000s, there was a two-year
1:04:12stretch where I worked at Barebones Software, the BB Edit maker. But at the time, the second
1:04:17product that Barebones had was an email client called MailSmith, which was based on the text
1:04:23engine of BB Edit and didn't make it and never... It didn't support IMAP, and that's sort of
1:04:29why it died off. It was POP only. But at the time, coming out of the '90s, POP was how
1:04:35most people used email on the Mac anyway. That's how Eudora worked. And POP, for people
1:04:40who don't remember if you're too young, instead of the server being the truth and you just
1:04:46have client software that talks to your mail being stored on the server, with POP, the
1:04:53mail server just sort of holds your new mail temporarily, and then your POP client would
1:04:59download your mail. And I would have it delete it from the server once I downloaded it locally.
1:05:06And we had really, really strict... No matter who gave you your email in the '90s, your
1:05:12mail storage on the server was measured in megabytes, not gigabytes at the time. But
1:05:18then it raised the question, if once you downloaded it to a Mac, how would you access your email
1:05:22from multiple machines? And what I did, and you could configure MailSmith very easily,
1:05:27I would store my mail on an external FireWire drive. And when I would go to work, I would
1:05:36just unmount, quit MailSmith, unmount the drive and just take the FireWire drive with
1:05:41me and then plug that into my machine at Barebone's office, and then there's my email. And I would
1:05:47have it just... I had other things that I would tote back and forth on that same portable
1:05:51drive, but just porting a drive instead of using a laptop. And it's that same sort of
1:05:58mentality. I mean, that's an old example where it's just data, but there is sort of like,
1:06:02"Hey, if you could just sort of plug things apart and have this be that and that be this,
1:06:08like, hey, the Mac lives in just this bottom case with a keyboard and a trackpad, and it
1:06:13has no display, and you could..." And to me, the fascinating part of your little Frankenstein
1:06:20project is that you can still use that Mac with your Vision Pro. It's the same Mac, right?
1:06:25And that means all the stuff you've configured, the apps you've installed, whatever else you
1:06:29have on that Mac that makes it Federico's and has your stuff on it is all there. But
1:06:35it's really kind of clever. But it's always been a dream of this, right? And of having
1:06:43like, "Oh, if you could only just have one device and then it would be everything, everywhere."
1:06:48And Samsung has this thing, what do they call it? Dex, D-E-X. And the idea is, okay, what
1:06:53if your whole life was on your phone? And if you want to use like a desktop computer,
1:06:58you just plug your phone in and you'd get a keyboard and a mouse and you could plug
1:07:03into a big display. I don't know if Dex supports multiple displays. I wouldn't be surprised.
1:07:08Modern high-end phones are so powerful. Maybe there's enough video power to drive two displays,
1:07:14but just plug it in. And people have been saying that about the iPad forever, probably
1:07:22since 2010 when it first came out. Like, wouldn't it be great if you could just, instead of
1:07:26booting into iPad OS, boot into Mac OS? And I think that's fundamentally, it sounds good
1:07:35as just like an elevator pitch, but when you really get into the nitty gritty details,
1:07:40it doesn't really make sense for an iPad to boot into Mac OS.
1:07:44No, no.
1:07:45Because it just behaves differently. And there's things like, yes, you could fix it by just
1:07:50adding APIs to Mac OS to say, "Hey, apps, you should be ready for the display to rotate
1:07:57at any moment from vertical to horizontal." Because right now Mac apps don't expect that.
1:08:03Touch is obviously, that's the big one, right? You should be ready for touch input. You should
1:08:09possibly consider spacing your, sizing your controls for touch as opposed to the precision
1:08:15of a mouse pointer, et cetera. But the big thing is just an iPad is expected to be used
1:08:21in the context that a Mac is not. And if it's booted into Mac OS X, it's just very different.
1:08:28But running Mac OS as a remote display works in a way that booting the iPad doesn't.
1:08:37Yeah, yeah. And I think it's that idea of you can only do it when the iPad is nearby
1:08:45or when the iPad is connected over with a USB cable from the base computer to the iPad.
1:08:54It's that, and obviously it only makes sense if you're using a keyboard and a trackpad,
1:08:59right? And it's that sort of idea that fascinates me in a potential future iPad Pro. If Apple
1:09:05ever does it, I don't think they will do it in two weeks. But this idea of, well, we can,
1:09:12I agree with you, it doesn't make sense for an iPad to boot into Mac OS for all those
1:09:17reasons. It wouldn't be a pleasant experience. But what if you limit that possibility to
1:09:23just, well, if you have the Pro Magic Keyboard or whatever it's called, and so the iPad is
1:09:30physically attached to that keyboard, you can use Mac OS in that circumstance. I've
1:09:38seen folks say, "Oh no, they should let me dual boot iPad OS and Mac OS and let me use
1:09:45Mac OS with touch." No, speaking from the Surface experience, but even just trying to
1:09:56with Sidecar on an iPad Pro, you can have some basic touch gestures that work in Sidecar
1:10:04mode. For example, you can scroll with two fingers in Sidecar and you're scrolling a
1:10:10Mac OS window. And it's not nice because your fingers are covering tiny, even just the basic
1:10:18act of scrolling isn't nice because you're covering tiny scroll bars, you're covering
1:10:24tiny buttons. Even just that doesn't make sense. So imagine actually controlling the
1:10:30whole UI. It wouldn't be nice. But what if it were possible just when you're using an
1:10:36accessory? Now that's something that, I don't know, intrigues me. And I mean, worst case
1:10:42scenario, Apple is never going to do this. I'm going to get an OLED iPad Pro and I'm
1:10:46going to have my own OLED MacBook years before an OLED MacBook because I'm just switching
1:10:53up the display at this point.
1:10:56I think one of the most interesting, very interesting things about Vision Pro is the,
1:11:03what do they call it? It's called the Mac display mode?
1:11:07Mac virtual, Mac virtual display.
1:11:10Yeah, I forget what it's called. But the fact that it's there right in the 1.0 product is
1:11:19to me super duper interesting. And I don't want to fork this podcast on a tangent about
1:11:27the Vision Pro, but it works incredibly well. And really would be, especially for tasks,
1:11:41there are certain, the nature of my work on the Mac is I don't really need a big display.
1:11:47When we were doing renovations in my house, again, I was going to say recently, but it
1:11:54was 2019 into 2020. And I know this because they finished up just by happenstance right
1:12:01before the COVID lockdowns. We just lucked into. And I had some eye problems at the time
1:12:09too, where I kind of needed to be close to the screen. But there was over a year, maybe
1:12:14close to two years, where because my office was being renovated, I put my iMac in a box
1:12:18and I just lived on a 13-inch MacBook Pro. It was my only display. And it was fine. Because
1:12:24I write most of the time, it felt a little cramped, but for the most part, just using
1:12:29the 13-inch MacBook Pro display was fine. And I did it full time for over a year. And
1:12:35I'm happy now. I'm happier now with one studio display on my desk. I like having a big display,
1:12:40but it worked all right. But if I wanted, like if I did video editing or something like
1:12:46that, I can see for some people who, or photos, you know, something where you just want a
1:12:51big display. And if you do work portably, I think it's just phenomenal that you can
1:12:57use a Vision Pro, even if it's like your primary reason to have the Vision Pro, to have a big
1:13:04virtual Mac display for Mac software to do Mac work, but being able to make it big wherever
1:13:12you go just by, and you can take a 13-inch instead of a 16-inch MacBook Pro or a MacBook
1:13:18Air even and be even lighter weight and have this big display. But it's so, it's a, to
1:13:25me, it's a really interesting decision that Apple would embrace because it's sort of,
1:13:32is a tacit admission that Vision OS isn't going to, doesn't do everything a Mac can
1:13:38do. And it was a long time before the iPad had sidecar and sort of embraced a similar
1:13:46sort of, "Hey, we can work alongside the Mac." Right? It was for a number of years, the iPad
1:13:51was just its own thing and there was no way to use it as like a Mac display or something
1:13:56like that. But what it really opens up for me is the idea going forward, like not just
1:14:03a, not two weeks from now what they're going to announce, but long-term, where does the
1:14:09Mac go? I could kind of see the Mac becoming software only, ultimately. This would be like
1:14:1710 years, 20 years down the road, but I don't know that I'd lose anything, right? I can
1:14:24imagine a world where it's not really a Mac hardware, but I just use devices. But when
1:14:29I want to do Mac type things, I can just bring it up in an app and it's just completely virtualized.
1:14:35Yeah. I mean, I can tell you, I'm basically using like my Mac is a, my Mac is a keyboard
1:14:42at this point. Like my Mac is a keyboard case with a track pad. And the way I use Mac OS
1:14:51is a projection of Mac OS to other displays. Like for example, now the base keyboard is
1:14:57plugged into an external monitor and I'm at my desk and Thunderbolt cable, and I'm looking
1:15:01at Mac OS on a monitor, but then I touch my iPad and I'm looking at Mac OS on an iPad.
1:15:09And then I use the vision pro and I look at Mac OS inside the vision pro. So yeah, I totally
1:15:15agree with that theory.
1:15:16I mean, wouldn't it be great if instead of taking a Mac with your vision pro, if you
1:15:20could just take a keyboard and a track pad.
1:15:22And yeah, and it's got Mac OS inside.
1:15:25Right. And this is why I just, in the last week or so, I've been writing a little bit
1:15:29of Daring Fireball about RAM. And it's just an idea, you know, it's the iPad event just
1:15:35sort of put it in my head that CPU wise, performance wise, if the device had the RAM, it would
1:15:43be trivial for Apple Silicon to run Mac at a totally respectable speed that yes, at the
1:15:51highest end of performance. If you're really like, if you have a big complex Xcode project
1:15:56or a big 4k video, 20 minute 4k video project that you want to export, it would be slower,
1:16:06of course, to do it through a virtualized Mac OS running in another operating system.
1:16:11But for 98% of computing, the only really limiting factor is RAM. That if your iPad,
1:16:19for an iPad to theoretically run Mac OS as an app, the iPad itself already is not RAM
1:16:26constrained, but you know, the most RAM you can get in any iPad is what, eight gigabytes,
1:16:30right?
1:16:31I think the higher end model maybe has more.
1:16:34But it's nowhere near the upper limits of Macs, which go up to what, 192 at this point.
1:16:42And like even my M1 MacBook Pro has 64 gigs of memory and I think that now the M3 ones
1:16:49go up to like 96. There's a lot more headroom for RAM in high end Mac Pro hardware than
1:16:56iPad and you'd want to have at least, I don't know, 1632 something more. But if they did,
1:17:03it would already work. It would work today. There's no other technical limitation. The
1:17:07CPU is, the performance would be fine. It just suddenly gets you into the uncomfortable
1:17:14Tim Cook era or side of Apple of, hey, do they really want to discourage people from
1:17:20owning a Mac and a Vision Pro and an iPad and a phone, right? I mean, I don't think
1:17:27Apple prioritizes that at the utmost, but they prioritize it to some degree, right?
1:17:35A world where you could just buy one Apple device and it does everything is...
1:17:39I mean, beautiful in theory, right? Beautiful as a concept, but maybe not so beautiful from
1:17:44a financial perspective.
1:17:46Right, from Luca's perspective, right?
1:17:48Yeah, but I mean, it is technically, I think, totally doable. Like I said, here I am looking
1:17:56at a keyboard. It's effectively like a keyboard with an M2 inside and it doesn't have a fan.
1:18:02It doesn't, it's got a, it's just a keyboard base that I had to do it myself. And it's
1:18:07a, by and large, it's an ugly sort of way of doing things, you know, detaching the display,
1:18:12causing it backup. But it put that idea in my brain of like, well, wouldn't it be nice
1:18:18to have this as an actual product? And I think it would, but...
1:18:23And with the Vision Pro too, right now, the Mac virtual display feature in the Vision
1:18:29Pro as it stands is one of my favorite things about the product. And I'm glad they did it.
1:18:32I wouldn't, you know, it seems a little out of character. It seemed just an unusually
1:18:36sort of nerdy slash modular feature, especially for 1.0, but I'm so glad they did it. I think
1:18:42it's so super useful, but it also instantly made me think, wouldn't it be great if I could
1:18:48just have a keyboard and a trackpad and not a Mac and just launch Vision?
1:18:52And it's a $3,500 to $4,000 product. So it's not like, oh, I'm cheating Apple out of some
1:18:58money. Like I think for $4,000, it's not that unreasonable to think that it could run macOS
1:19:04virtualized right there within Vision. And I think that would be, you know, I think that's
1:19:10super compelling. And I think it might be the way of the future.
1:19:14Maybe just not in two weeks though.
1:19:16Yeah, maybe not. All right, let me take another break here and then we'll go on to what we
1:19:19sort of think we're going to see in two weeks and talk to you about my good friends right
1:19:24now. I'm enjoying some of their fine product as we speak. Trade Coffee. Trade Coffee is
1:19:31changing the way you experience coffee at home. They continuously curate a wide variety
1:19:36of coffees from best small batch specialty roasters in the US, and then they make personalized
1:19:42recommendations based on what you like or what you may like to try. Every bag is roasted
1:19:49to order and shipped fresh to you by one of their 50 plus partners that are small independent
1:19:55roasters. Trade believes that anyone can make great coffee at home. All you need is access
1:19:59to the best fresh beans, roasted to order and curated for your personal taste. That's
1:20:05exactly what Trade does. And thanks to their in-house team of coffee experts, their over
1:20:1050 small batch specialty coffee partners who do the roasting, they have over 450 roasts
1:20:17in the rotation, different coffee varieties. You might think, well, that's overwhelming.
1:20:20Getting started is easy. You answer a few questions about what type of coffee you think
1:20:24you like. They start shipping it and after you get it and try it, then you just go back
1:20:30to their website. They'll send you an email to prompt you like, hey, thumbs up, thumbs
1:20:33down. What'd you think? I've been subscribed for a couple of years now, but it was just
1:20:39a couple. A, I've never gotten what I would consider an unpleasant batch of coffee from
1:20:44them. But once I gave them a couple of thumbs ups and thumbs downs, like more like this,
1:20:48more like that, they are dialed into my taste in coffee. And it's really, now I don't do
1:20:53anything. I never even rate them anymore. I just let them send me the coffee on my schedule.
1:20:59And it's just banger after banger. It's just really good. But it's also left to my own
1:21:04devices. I would just order the same bag of coffee over and over and over again. Like
1:21:08good enough. This one I like. I'll just get the same one. But with Trade, I get variety
1:21:13automatically. It's just built into the subscription, but it's all of a variety that's sort of to
1:21:18my liking. It's really kind of amazing. And it just shows up at my house every two weeks.
1:21:23It's so great. So that's the key. It's a subscription service. You get started. It just comes on
1:21:30the schedule you want. And they've got everything you might want from dark roast to decafs,
1:21:36espressos to cold brew and ice coffee varieties that are optimized for that sort of coffee.
1:21:42You can discover the best coffee suited to your taste. And it's a great gift. Mother's
1:21:47Day is coming up. Father's Day graduation gifts. It's a great gift for coffee lovers
1:21:52in that season. I recommend it wholeheartedly. I'd recommend them even if they weren't a
1:21:56sponsor. So if you want to get started for a limited time, you can enjoy a free bag and
1:22:02up to 15 bucks off selected plans when you visit this URL, DrinkTrade.com/TheTalkShow.
1:22:12That's DrinkTrade.com/TheTalkShow. And going to that URL, you get a free bag of coffee
1:22:20and up to 15 bucks off selected plans at DrinkTrade.com/TheTalkShow.
1:22:28So I feel like the one thing we've been dancing around is with the iPad and what I really
1:22:34do think that I hope or at least and I sort of expect Apple to clarify this is to make
1:22:43more clear the difference between an iPad Air and an iPad Pro.
1:22:49Yes.
1:22:50Right? Because I feel like what's happened over the years because they've, like I said,
1:22:53they've always been out of sync. It's like, oh, 2018 the iPad Pros took this great leap
1:22:58forward and there was clarity for a while. Like the iPad Pros really stood head and shoulders
1:23:04above the medium and lower tier iPads. But now I feel like there's, it's really blurry
1:23:12between the iPad Air and the iPad Pro. I personally think Face ID is a single, is a $200 feature.
1:23:23But what else? You know, what else is worth 200 bucks?
1:23:27Probably not the four speaker audio system. I mean, it's nice, but is that enough to say,
1:23:33oh, I really want to get an iPad Pro because I really want to have two more speakers.
1:23:37And I have to say from my personal iPad use, I don't use the speakers that much. It's a
1:23:42lot more AirPods than speakers. Just and maybe somebody else's scenario is different and
1:23:47they are playing music through their iPad speakers. So there are differences like that,
1:23:53but overall...
1:23:54Is it Thunderbolt speeds because maybe you want to connect multiple external monitors
1:24:00to an iPad, but then you go back to that idea of, have you tried connecting multiple displays
1:24:05to an iPad and using stage manager on multiple external displays? It's not nice. So are there
1:24:12actually people who are taking advantage of those? And I guess maybe video makers with
1:24:17the faster transfer speeds of Thunderbolt compared to vanilla USB-C on the iPad Air.
1:24:24But I don't know, it feels like a stretch.
1:24:27Yeah. It just feels like there's more, way more clarity in the non-pro iPhones and more
1:24:34clarity on between MacBook Airs and MacBook Pros on the Mac side. I feel like with desktops,
1:24:42it's almost self-defining. The new 24-inch Apple Silicon iMacs are clearly consumer products.
1:24:50They don't come with M series Pro chips. The Mac Pro and Mac Studio are clearly pro products.
1:24:59If you need a Mac Studio, you know you're a pro. But the laptops, which are the bread
1:25:04and butter of the Mac lineup, there's just so much more, "Oh yeah, this is why the 16-inch
1:25:10MacBook Pro starts at $2,500," which is way out of the budget for most people for a laptop.
1:25:17And it's so nice now that if what you really want in a laptop is a bigger than 13-inch
1:25:26screen that you can get one without spending $2,500. I mean, the biggest missing Mac for
1:25:36almost the dawn of calling them MacBooks was a big MacBook Air, and now we have one. And
1:25:43it's great. And what's missing on the iPad? For everybody who would like a 13-inch iPad
1:25:51but doesn't want to spend iPad Pro money, the rumor that a 13-inch iPad Air is coming
1:25:59is exactly, to me, of the same mindset as making a 15-inch MacBook Air.
1:26:05Yeah, yeah. The thing about the rumors is that the details we've heard so far, I feel
1:26:13like they make the most sense on the iPad Air side. Right, it makes total sense to have
1:26:20a bigger iPad Air and to offer more space for people who don't want to spend a fortune
1:26:27on an iPad Pro but still want to use an iPad. Where the rumors give me pause is the idea
1:26:33of, well, on the iPad Pro side, you're going to have an OLED display. And that's it, at
1:26:40least so far, and maybe a new keyboard. And I mean, I love OLED. If I can get an OLED
1:26:47version of a TV or a video game console, I'm going to get the OLED version. But would I
1:26:54say that OLED in itself would justify calling an iPad Pro a Pro machine? Probably not. And
1:27:03so I kind of feel like there must be, and maybe this is the wishful thinking right now,
1:27:08like there must be something else, right, besides a display. And maybe that's where
1:27:14the keyboard comes in or maybe where the new Apple Pencil comes in.
1:27:19Don't you kind of think, though, that I expect a new Magic Keyboard case, but I would expect
1:27:24that it's going to work with all of the new iPads, or at least the iPad Airs and the iPad
1:27:28Pro. One Magic Keyboard for all of the iPads. One that's 11-inch, one that's 13-inch. And
1:27:35one pencil that will work with all the new iPads.
1:27:40Yeah, so I am more convinced that the pencil is going to be cross-platform, if you will,
1:27:48than the keyboard. There's something about this idea of Apple making a Pro version of
1:27:55the Magic Keyboard that almost makes me wonder, are they going to keep the Magic Keyboard,
1:28:01the current one, around? And they're going to make an additional version. Call it Magic
1:28:06Keyboard Plus or Magic Keyboard Pro. It's just for the iPad Pro. That is the thought
1:28:13that I'm having lately.
1:28:15I would rather see them just make one that works with all the new iPads. One for 11,
1:28:20one for 13-inch. And it doesn't matter if it's an iPad Air or iPad Pro. But then I realize,
1:28:26though, that me saying that takes off the table a possible distinguishing feature for
1:28:32why would you buy the iPad Pro other than the OLED display and the speaker.
1:28:36Exactly. Exactly. I've been thinking about this. All right, so how can they differentiate
1:28:43this product from the iPad Air? Because an iPad Air, you get it with decent storage size,
1:28:50and you get an accessory, and you get an Apple Pencil 2. It is, by and large, the same experience
1:28:56of an iPad Pro right now, more or less.
1:29:00Face ID versus Touch ID.
1:29:02It comes down to that. It comes down to Face ID versus Touch ID. And sure, you do have
1:29:08the mini LED on the iPad Pro. But the screen of the iPad Air, it's a pretty good display.
1:29:15Yeah, it is. It really is. It's not as bad as the iPad Mini one, for sure.
1:29:22Right. And which still isn't that bad, right? Compared to the industry as a whole, it's
1:29:31the worst iPad screen, but it still isn't that bad.
1:29:36There are some terrible tablets out there running Android or versions of Windows.
1:29:41But part of the corner Apple's painted itself in, and we're complaining, we mentioned it
1:29:45before that all the, except for the low end, just plain no adjective iPad, the front-facing
1:29:52camera is still on the hold it in portrait side, which just seems wrong at this point.
1:29:59And again, it comes back to the, "Hey, I can't believe it's 2024 already." But 2020
1:30:05was the big lockdown year where everybody was working from home and Zoom became a big
1:30:10brand and a household name. And Apple has a variety of these, use your iPad in a laptop
1:30:17sort of configuration with a keyboard. And it just looks terrible to have the camera
1:30:24on the side. It's a bad, it's too low. It's even lower. Everybody knows laptop
1:30:30cameras are unflattering when they're at desk height, they're low. Well, here they've
1:30:35lowered it even three inches. It's off to the side. So if you are looking at the center
1:30:40of your display to make eye contact with the people you're having the Zoom call with, you
1:30:45actually look like you're off looking off to the side, like you're distracted because
1:30:49the camera's coming from there. It's just...
1:30:51And they're looking at your chin most of the time.
1:30:53But, but here's the big but. The but is where the camera would naturally go to put it at
1:31:02the top and laptop configuration is where the magnets and charging go for the Apple
1:31:06Pencil, right? It's that Apple Pencil 2 is such a clever upgrade over the original Pencil,
1:31:12right? The original Pencil was a great product. It made Apple break through this sort of...
1:31:20They hadn't had anything with the stylus since the Newton and there was the whole, "Hey,
1:31:25if you see a stylus, they blew it," which is misquoted because what Jobs meant by that
1:31:30is if you need a stylus, they blew it, not if there's a stylus as an option. But Apple
1:31:37Pencil 2 was so much better. It didn't have a cap. It charged magnetically instead of
1:31:42charging by plugging something in, but it took up, it takes up the long side of the
1:31:47screen that goes at the top. And so I'm curious, I don't know, what do you think they're going
1:31:52to do with the Pencil 3?
1:31:54So I mean, obviously there's the optimistic scenario in which Apple almost magically figured
1:32:00out how to put both the camera and the charging on the same side. I don't know how, I don't
1:32:06know why, but hey, if there's a company that can figure this out, it's them, right? I guess.
1:32:11There's the idea of maybe you put it on the shorter side. Now that would potentially look
1:32:18a little odd, I guess.
1:32:21It would be too long for the Mini if the Mini eventually gets updated to get it and it would
1:32:25block the speakers.
1:32:27Yeah, it would block the speakers. That's the other thing. There's option number three
1:32:32would be, well, it just charges via USB-C. So you just, we go back to the idea of it's
1:32:38not magnets anymore, now you need to plug in a USB-C adapter.
1:32:41I don't see it going that way.
1:32:44Me neither. Another option that I've seen a few people mention, maybe you place the
1:32:50Pencil on the keyboard and the keyboard as a slot to carry the Pencil and charge the
1:32:56Pencil. I've seen some third-party cases that do that. They don't do the charging, but they
1:33:00do the open slot to carry the Pencil. It's nice, but it's still not as seamless as...
1:33:09And then the implication is that you "need to buy a $330 keyboard."
1:33:15Exactly.
1:33:16And there's surely, surely, especially for people who are illustrators, there's a lot
1:33:21of people who don't want a $330 keyboard. All they want is the Pencil because they want
1:33:25to do drawing on their iPad. So why in the world would you make them carry a $330 keyboard?
1:33:30My idea, my guess, and I have no inside info, I have no idea. It seems like Apple's... Part
1:33:36of the excitement about this is it seems like a lot of this is really kept under wraps,
1:33:41right? I mean, the OLED stuff has just leaked through the supply chain, right? And it's
1:33:46the sort of, I don't know, for whatever reason, the whole display industry seems to be the
1:33:53leakiest of leaky supply chain industries. Everything related to Apple's displays seems
1:34:02to leak and the leaks seem to be pretty accurate. My guess would be that the Pencil 3 will be
1:34:12a lot like the Pencil 2 as a user, that it'll magnetically snap into place on the long side,
1:34:19but that instead of making the magic spot the middle where the camera is, maybe put
1:34:25it at the end or maybe put it at... Yeah. And so it could do whatever components need
1:34:32to be in there to charge the Pencil and to pair it, put them off center. And so the Pencil
1:34:39still takes the center of the spot, but the magic spot where it connects isn't in the
1:34:43middle anymore. And it's just move it to move the magnet to the side, down towards the bottom
1:34:48or up towards the top or something like that. And so super familiar to users who already
1:34:53know Pencil 2, but then it lets them put the camera in the correct position.
1:34:58Yeah, maybe that's the simplest answer is you just move it a little to the side and
1:35:03you have a way to have all components on the same side of the device without sacrificing
1:35:11the... I mean, let's face it, even from an accessibility perspective, from a user experience
1:35:17perspective, it's such a win, right? The Apple Pencil 2, it charges, it pairs, it serves
1:35:24as a carrying mechanism. It's such elegant and beautiful design at the expense of the
1:35:31webcam. That's the problem.
1:35:33Yeah. Apple tries to do such a good job with pairing in general and they tend to... It's
1:35:39pretty easy to pair a magic keyboard with a Vision Pro or with a Mac, but nothing is
1:35:45as easy as the Pencil. And if I want to hand my Pencil to my wife, all she has to do is
1:35:52take the Pencil, connect it to her iPad and now it's her Pencil. It's hard to imagine
1:35:59it being more seamless or more easy to understand. Just snap it into place on the side of the
1:36:04iPad. That's where it charges. That's where it pairs. Easy. So I'd love to see them do
1:36:11that.
1:36:12Otherwise, we're looking at OLED, new Pencil, possibly Pencil with some kind of gesture
1:36:18built in for additional functions.
1:36:20There's a rumor that it'll have a button.
1:36:22A button. There was the other rumor that mentioned the squeeze gesture, sort of like you squeeze
1:36:27your AirPods.
1:36:28Yeah. I wouldn't be surprised if that's the same rumor too, right? The way that it's like
1:36:34the proverbial five blind people touching different parts of an elephant. Like, "Oh,
1:36:39I think it's a tree. I think it's a rope because one guy's got his hand on the tail." It's
1:36:44like maybe the button is like a capacitive squeeze thing, like the stem on AirPods. And
1:36:51one person thinks it's a button because they know the feature and one person thinks it's
1:36:55a squeeze because they know the components.
1:36:57Exactly. Yeah.
1:36:58All right. You were talking about the keyboard.
1:37:01The keyboard, I think that's the interesting story in terms of my own usage of the iPad
1:37:06Pro. There are so many things that they could do compared to the original version of the
1:37:10Magic Keyboard, which is now four years old. It came out in 2020 with a fancy floating
1:37:16design. Obviously, the rumor is pointing to a more laptop-like, sort of made of aluminum,
1:37:23maybe more premium, more pro accessory. The two big obvious things I think would be a
1:37:32larger trackpad and the function row. That is, I would be very surprised if this new
1:37:39keyboard still doesn't have a function row on iPadOS or on these iPad Pros. And I think
1:37:47judging from what it seems that Apple is doing, they are going to potentially drop that floating
1:37:54design and they're maybe going to use a different hinge mechanism or a different attachment
1:38:00mechanism compared to the current Magic Keyboard.
1:38:03But delightfully so. We don't, I mean, we've heard this rumor that it'll be aluminum instead
1:38:09of, I don't know what you would call, I've got my Magic Keyboard, my four-year-old Magic
1:38:14Keyboard here. It's rubbery.
1:38:16It's not silicon. Yeah, I don't know.
1:38:18But I've posted to Mastodon, and I don't take mine out of the house very often. I don't
1:38:23travel with it. But it hasn't worn very well.
1:38:28Oh, no.
1:38:29It's like in between the keys. And I'm sure, and when I've posted my pictures of mine,
1:38:34it's always great because people who follow me will post theirs. And so many other people's
1:38:39are so much more worn. And the truth is, a well-worn MacBook Air just doesn't wear like,
1:38:47aluminum just doesn't wear like rubber. It doesn't fall apart. And it's like, a well-used
1:38:55five-year-old MacBook just looks good, right? Like in the way the kit-bashed props from Star
1:39:03Wars just look cool because they're old and gritty and used. Whereas a well-worn Magic
1:39:09Keyboard looks like it is poorly constructed.
1:39:12Yeah, and it looks kind of gross. Especially if you get the white version.
1:39:17Yes, yes.
1:39:18That thing is, I had one of those. And for all the care that I put into, you know, every
1:39:24once in a while cleaning the case, cleaning the keyboard, it still gets stained and it
1:39:29gets dirty and it starts turning this yellowish sort of color. It's not good. It doesn't look
1:39:37good.
1:39:38My son has a 12-inch or 13-inch iPad, an old and a 13-inch MacBook Air. He's got both,
1:39:45uses both. But he got the white Keep Magic Keyboard for his iPad. And he takes really
1:39:50good care. He's a sophomore in college. He takes really good care of his products. It's
1:39:55like a trait he probably inherited from me. Well, my wife takes good care of her stuff
1:39:59too. But he's always, even as a young kid, always took good care of his stuff. And we
1:40:04trusted him with expensive devices maybe earlier than some parents would with kids who are
1:40:11reckless with their stuff. But man, oh man, I know how much care he takes of his stuff.
1:40:16And his white Magic Keyboard looks like, I don't know, like it was picked out of the
1:40:22garbage or something like that.
1:40:24Yeah. And this happens to everybody. There's no way around it. That material that maybe
1:40:29wasn't the best choice for a product that, you know, most people hold onto their iPads
1:40:35for many years because they're so durable. And I mean, you're still using the 2018 iPad
1:40:41Pro.
1:40:42Yeah.
1:40:43And the Magic Keyboard was not meant to, especially in the white color, was not meant to last
1:40:48four years.
1:40:49Yeah. But you know, so here's what's really curious though. So my, I have a 2018, it's
1:40:53right here in my hand as we speak, 2018 11 inch iPad Air or iPad Pro, the iPad, and a
1:41:012020 Magic Keyboard. My Magic Keyboard looks worn to hell in between my most used keys.
1:41:07My iPad is like near mint. I mean, there are, there are a couple of dings on the edges of
1:41:14the aluminum, but they're not, you know, you could just see where, I don't know, I must've
1:41:18dropped it or something here or there. There's, you know, you could tell that it's been used,
1:41:23but overall it's in very good condition. Like if I sold it, I, you know, I wouldn't call
1:41:28it mint or near mint, but it's in good condition and it's six years old and it's obviously
1:41:34been used more than my Magic Keyboard, right? Because every, every moment I've used the
1:41:40Magic Keyboard has been with this iPad. Aluminum just is, surprise, surprise, way more durable
1:41:46than a rubber coating. So here, let me, let me throw this idea at you. And it, when the
1:41:52M3 iMac came out in November, one of the minor disappointments, minor surprises was that
1:42:02they still are shipping a keyboard and trackpad and mouse that use lightning instead of USB-C.
1:42:11Surely eventually they're going to, all of those lightning peripherals are going to go
1:42:15to USB-C. And one explanation would be, well, the, they just, the iMac is just not that
1:42:21important a product anymore. And so they weren't going to sync up the USB-C update to the keyboard
1:42:30and trackpad for that device. But Vision Pro came out too. Vision Pro pairs with a keyboard
1:42:38and trackpad. And for whatever reason, I don't know. I mean, do you have a theory as a side
1:42:43note? Do you have a theory? Like you can pair any Bluetooth 5 keyboard with a Vision Pro,
1:42:49but for a mouse pointer, you can only pair a Magic trackpad. You can't pair a third,
1:42:55no third party mice or even a Magic mouse for some reason, even Apple's own mouse.
1:43:01Just a trackpad and I have no idea why.
1:43:03Yeah. But what if the new Magic keyboard, in addition to being something you use with
1:43:13the new iPad Air and iPad Pros, is also an all in one keyboard and trackpad that you
1:43:20can pair with a Vision Pro?
1:43:21Oh yeah. Oh yeah. This is, this is one of the things that I would love to see. And,
1:43:27and, and, and I'll also add that I think it's, it's, it's long due for Apple to figure out
1:43:36for a better story for their accessories in terms of, because this is a company that cares
1:43:42so much about, about their, about the environment and about e-waste. This idea of having to
1:43:49buy multiple sets of keyboards for the different Apple computers that you have. And I think,
1:43:56imagine if the same were true with your AirPods, right? Imagine if you had to buy AirPods for
1:44:01your Mac, AirPods for your iPhone, AirPods for your iPad.
1:44:04Yeah.
1:44:05No, it's not the case because they so cleverly figured out a system to so seamlessly pair
1:44:13the AirPods to multiple devices. And it is what like, we take it for granted now, but
1:44:19when you look, when you look, when you take a peek in Bluetooth land with standard Bluetooth
1:44:24earbuds land, it's still not the case. Bluetooth multi-point, not only does it, by and large,
1:44:30does it suck compared to what Apple does, but it's still not even so widespread. And
1:44:35it's been, the AirPods are what, eight years old at this point? I think it's time for Apple
1:44:40to figure out a similar system for their accessories, where just like AirPods, you buy the one keyboard
1:44:46and the one trackpad and your Mac computer, your iPad, and maybe your Vision Pro, they
1:44:52recognize the accessory and they switch to the accessory. I think it's time for them
1:44:58to do this sort of technology that they did with the AirPods for their input accessories.
1:45:05I think it's a bug in Mac OS 14.4, because if not, it's something's weird with my personal
1:45:14MacBook Pro. But in, I'd say for like the last month, maybe six weeks, I've had an intermittent
1:45:20problem where my AirPods always want to pair with my MacBook. Even my home office is on
1:45:27the ground floor of our house and our living area is on the second floor. And so it's like,
1:45:34I'll be like on my way out to walk around, run errands or something like that. And I'm
1:45:38using, I'm listening to podcasts or music on my phone. And as I leave the house, I have
1:45:44to walk by my office and then the audio just stops on my, in my ears because it's jumped
1:45:51over to my MacBook and restarting the Mac fixes it. But I, and I think it's a recent
1:45:58problem and once I restart, then it's fine for like a week and then it starts happening
1:46:02again. But it's all it's done is emphasized to me how awesome the automatic pairing with
1:46:09AirPods is when it, when it's working as intended. Right. And it's exactly what you said. It's
1:46:13great. And it would be crazy if it would seem crazy now that we're used to, Hey, I just
1:46:17have one pair of AirPods Pro and they work with all my devices and they kind of do the
1:46:22right thing. They do what I mean when I switch devices, which feels magical. It does. It
1:46:28would be great to have that with a keyboard and it would really be a sign to me that Apple
1:46:33has getting its overall cross device story together. If they made an aluminum base, sort
1:46:45of like your hybrid thing, right? It would just be like a keyboard with a nice big Mac
1:46:50size track pad F keys would be great above the numbers. And if it could just pair with
1:46:58both a vision pro and any iPad, and I don't know what the connectors for the iPad would
1:47:04look like. I don't know if there's a slot that you'd slotted into. I don't know. I leave
1:47:09that to their Clyde never in a million years would have imagined the weird cantilever.
1:47:15How weird. It's very clever, but the way that, like you said, like the magic keyboard that
1:47:21we have for the last four years, the way that it sort of lets the bottom third of the iPad
1:47:26hover over the keyboard. I leave that to Apple's designers to come up with the clever connecting
1:47:31mechanism, but man, would that be great. And if it's in the same price range, 350 ish,
1:47:37300 to $350. That seems like a much better value. It seems like, yeah, that's worth
1:47:45$350. If it's aluminum, more durable, and it pairs with both the vision pro and an iPad,
1:47:52and presumably you could also pair with like a Mac mini or a Mac studio. Right? Yeah. Now
1:47:58that would be a much better deal. I mean, it would also be a way for people to buy that
1:48:01accessory even if they're not iPad users. Right. Even if you don't want to buy an iPad,
1:48:06you get the new Apple keyboard and it still works with your vision poem with your Mac
1:48:11mini or whatever. And yeah, I do think that some of Apple's most fascinating work lately,
1:48:17I mean, besides obviously vision-wise, I think it is coming from those teams that have been
1:48:21working on like those cross-platform integrations, like the folks behind, I mean, obviously Sidecar,
1:48:29but even Universal Control. I think it's such, once you get used to it, the magic of Universal
1:48:36Control, when you can just move the cursor off to the side and it pops up on your iPad
1:48:42or even with VisionOS, like you're using the Mac virtual display mode, and then you look
1:48:47at a VisionOS window and the pointer is there, the work that Apple has been doing there.
1:48:54And then of course the AirPods. I would love to see Apple apply their knowledge actually
1:49:01to two products in this case, the keyboard that we just mentioned, but boy, would I also
1:49:07love to see Apple try and make a game controller with the same features.
1:49:14That would be, I mean, it would be cool, but...
1:49:17They're never going to do it, but it would be cool.
1:49:19Yeah. I kind of feel like the best we can hope for is what we've got where they've thoroughly
1:49:24embraced third-party controllers. Right.
1:49:27Yeah. And it's fine.
1:49:29And they try to be very agnostic about the Xbox PlayStation Divide.
1:49:34Exactly.
1:49:35Because I don't know, like when you get review units, do they send you game controllers sometimes?
1:49:38No, no, no, no, no, no.
1:49:40Oh, they've sent, I've been sent a couple of game controllers with various things to...
1:49:45Like PlayStation ones?
1:49:47Yeah. Yeah. They've sent, but they mix it up. Like I've got like at least three game
1:49:53controllers I need to send back. I have a whole bunch of queued up review units to send
1:49:57back, but they'll send me like a PlayStation one one time. And then I think with the M3
1:50:03MacBook Pro, they sent me an Xbox controller, but it works great with both. And I think
1:50:08that's the best we can hope for.
1:50:09Yeah. Yeah. I'm fine with third-party controllers. I am not fine with third-party keyboards.
1:50:13I just want to use the Apple one.
1:50:16All right.
1:50:17Yeah.
1:50:18But boy, that would be such a great story. And it would give them a reason to talk about
1:50:22Vision Pro in this event on May 7th. And I just noticed today that they've put a thing
1:50:29in the app store like, "Hey, why don't you buy a Vision Pro?" Like, I think they recognize
1:50:35that the enthusiasm around Vision Pro's launch has dissipated. I was going to say it's not
1:50:42just decreased, but it's sort of disappeared. And I think leading up to WWDC where surely
1:50:50they're going to have a lot of Vision OS 2.0 features that they are going to want to tell
1:50:54us about. But up to that, any kind of... If they could just work the Vision Pro into this
1:51:00iPad event on May 7th with the keyboard, it would be great. And personally, at my desk,
1:51:07I use a keyboard and a mouse. I'm a mouse person, not a trackpad person. But when I
1:51:13do use a trackpad, it's very natural for me to do it in a laptop way with the trackpad
1:51:21for my thumb underneath the space bar as opposed to a magic trackpad off to the side. I doubt
1:51:29that me, that I would abandon my beloved 30-year-old Apple Extended Keyboard 2 for a new peripheral.
1:51:38But if an integrated device that put the trackpad under the keyboard, under the space bar, would
1:51:46be more tempting than anything Apple's made peripheral-wise for a while, for me, for the
1:51:51Mac, I think it would be really interesting.
1:51:54It sure would be nice to have that keyboard maybe compatible with Vision Pro and maybe
1:51:59some European Vision Pro launches before WWDC. I mean, I can see...
1:52:04Yeah, that would be another point of... Yeah, that would definitely be a thing to announce
1:52:09on May 7th, yeah. Where is Vision Pro? It's still officially only in North America? Yeah,
1:52:16US and Canada?
1:52:17Is it in Canada?
1:52:18I don't even know if it's in Canada.
1:52:20Yeah, yeah. I had to get mine from the US, so yeah, still only there.
1:52:28So yeah, that would be nice if they expanded that. And why not, right? I mean, it's not
1:52:32setting the world on fire sales-wise. And I know Ming-Chi Kuo just came out with a story
1:52:38this week that they've cut the estimates, which seems ridiculous. I mean, I'll put a
1:52:44link in the show notes, but Neil Seibart called him out, Ming-Chi Kuo, for like two months
1:52:49ago. The same guy said they expect to sell 150,000 in the US, and now he's like, "They've
1:52:56cut the orders from 450,000." And it's like, "Well, wait, which is it?" Yeah, that would
1:53:01be good. Anything else that you are hoping for at May 7th?
1:53:06I would still love to see a software story. I know that we talked about the hardware,
1:53:13and realistically we are going to get hardware. And software is... WWDC is usually the place
1:53:19for software, right? And it's literally like a month after. But my concern is that just
1:53:27hardware would still not fix that story of the iPad Pro, right? And so maybe there will
1:53:35need to be an addendum of sorts at WWDC for iPadOS. But then again, I'm skeptical given
1:53:43that maybe the focus of WWDC is going to be AI and iOS 18. So I would love to see not
1:53:51just here's an accessory, here's OLED, here's new hardware for you. I would love to see
1:53:59actual changes in iPadOS, but I know that it's not the time.
1:54:04I wonder if... OS changes surely are going to wait for WWDC. And there's a reason why
1:54:12Apple, to my memory, has never done a hardware launch in May. And presumably it's just because
1:54:19they wanted these iPads to be out earlier, and for whatever reason one part or another
1:54:25were delayed. And because we're expecting them to change so much. iPad Air's new iPad
1:54:33Air model that's bigger, all new iPad Pros, new pencil, new keyboard and trackpad, magic
1:54:39keyboard thing, who knows what other keyboard case things they might have. All of that,
1:54:45any one of them might have been delayed and held up the whole thing, we don't know. But
1:54:50maybe software-wise they'll have an app or apps, like an upgrade to Final Cut and Logic
1:54:56for iPad that they could talk on, or a new app, something new that is decidedly pro.
1:55:03I mean Final Cut and Logic are very, very pro apps. Maybe a major update to them or
1:55:10something, something they could show off and say, "Look, when you run Final Cut on these
1:55:15new iPad Pros, you can export at MacBook Pro speeds." And it's totally suitable for a truly
1:55:22professional workflow for these things, I don't know. But I agree that doing this in
1:55:28May makes me wonder what in the world they are going to show off software-wise. Because
1:55:35you have to show software. As much as it's about selling new hardware, there's no demo
1:55:40without software, right? It is very strange. All right, let me take a break here and thank
1:55:46our third and final sponsor of the episode, our very good friends at Squarespace. Squarespace
1:55:51is the all-in-one platform for creating your presence online. Federico and I were just
1:55:58talking about having a home base on the internet that you own, your blog, your podcast if you
1:56:05have a podcast, a place to sell your own stuff if that's what you want to do, or just a home
1:56:10page, right? Just a home page where you can just centralize your personal space online
1:56:15and link to your stuff on other platforms across the web. Everybody should have a home
1:56:21base on the internet, and one of the, if not the easiest way to do it is Squarespace. And
1:56:27certainly one of the most powerful ways to do it is at Squarespace. They have everything
1:56:31from domain name registration to templates for how your thing looks like to a complete
1:56:38WYSIWYG in-browser editing interface for styling, adjusting, adding features to your website.
1:56:46They call it the Fluid Engine. That's their new latest generation of the engine that's
1:56:52used to design your Squarespace site. And the new version of the Fluid Engine works
1:56:57great all the way down to phone-sized devices. You can design your entire website right from
1:57:02your phone. It is absolutely tremendous for whatever you want to do on the web. If you
1:57:09are selling stuff, they have flexible payments that you can make checkout as seamless as
1:57:15anything you've ever encountered on the web with very simple but very powerful payment
1:57:20tools. You can accept credit cards, PayPal, Apple Pay. And in eligible countries, you
1:57:25can offer customers the option to buy now and pay later with Afterpay and ClearPay,
1:57:31that sort of stuff. Just you name it. If you want to do it on the web, you can do it at
1:57:36Squarespace. And they've even got AI features now, Squarespace AI. You can help it to do
1:57:42your writing, to fix your content, to get editing suggestions for the content you've
1:57:47written all baked in right on Squarespace's platform. It just keeps evolving. I was just
1:57:54rewatching just to think about how long Squarespace has been around and how long they've been
1:57:59sponsoring this podcast. My wife and I just rewatched The Jinx the first season because
1:58:04the new season's coming out on max. And there's a scene where somebody's in a taxi cab and
1:58:09another cab pulls up and there's a Squarespace ad on the cab. And it just made me laugh because
1:58:14the first season of The Jinx was from 2015. And they've been around a long time, but
1:58:20they keep evolving and moving forward. It's just the best place I can recommend for you
1:58:24to start a new website or to create a website to replace an old one. So where do you go?
1:58:30Go to squarespace.com. You get a free trial, 30 days, no limits, no watermarks on the site
1:58:35as you develop it at squarespace.com/talkshow. Squarespace.com/talkshow. And using that URL
1:58:44and that code talk show saves you 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain.
1:58:50You can subscribe for a whole year at once, save 10% on the whole year. Squarespace.com/talkshow.
1:58:55Federico, you're in Italy. That's the EU. And now you're living in a different world
1:59:05than I am on iOS.
1:59:08That is correct. I'm using people manager on my phone. Yes.
1:59:13Well, I've got the same one because I've got a build from Riley. So I've got clips
1:59:21on my phone, clip singular, but there's not a lot yet. Right now, we've only got one.
1:59:28It's still, I think, and there's still just Alt Store is the only.
1:59:31Alt Store, yeah.
1:59:32Alt Store, PAL, which is such a great name. I love it. But like I wrote and I've been
1:59:39very, I am, I still largely against the DMA. I think it's poorly considered legislation
1:59:46overall, but in a way that two opposing things can be true. I also am jealous because as
1:59:54a nerd/power user, there's no better place to be an iOS user than the EU right now. And
2:00:01it's only going to get cooler going forward.
2:00:04Yeah, yeah. That's sort of my take. And obviously we've been writing about the DMA at Max
2:00:07stories. John has been as a former lawyer by trade, has been writing about the DMA.
2:00:17Trust me, as somebody married to somebody who used to, there's no such thing as a former
2:00:21lawyer. You're always a lawyer. You're just no longer practicing lawyer. Trust me. I guess
2:00:29what, guess what my record is in spousal arguments? Oh, for whatever.
2:00:38So I think there are so many parts of the DMA that either don't make sense or are poorly
2:00:47written, poorly explained, more idealistic than anything. But at the same time, I got
2:00:56to say that as a user, looking at this from the outside, if you don't have an opinion
2:01:03on like what it means for Apple as a company, you're just a user and you're like, well,
2:01:07now I get to choose which other browser I want to use. Now I get to install a bunch
2:01:12of apps, at least in theory, we've only got the one for now. A bunch of apps that were
2:01:18not allowed before. That's great. I still feel like I can't help but think that it's
2:01:25unfortunate that we've ended up in this situation where regulation had to happen for certain
2:01:34changes to occur on iOS and only in a part of the world. I can't help but wonder if
2:01:41maybe all of this could have been avoided from Apple's side, of course. Look, I'm
2:01:48not a fan of regulation. I'm not one of those people who are like, regulation can
2:01:56do no wrong. And in fact, in most circumstances, it does harm, especially when it's created
2:02:03by people who maybe are not so technically knowledgeable. And at the same time, I wonder
2:02:15like maybe in an alternate timeline, Apple could have avoided this if they wanted to.
2:02:23It's undeniable. Right now, globally, this is a change that Apple has instituted in the
2:02:29App Store outside the EU is now they've relented on the longstanding ban on emulators,
2:02:37classic game emulators famously. And not only, I'm sure this isn't news to anybody who's
2:02:42listening to us because Riley tested Delta is, I don't know if it's still number one,
2:02:48but I think it is. I'm going to look, but it's literally the most popular app in the
2:02:53App Store, which emulates a bunch of classic Nintendo platforms only. I don't know if
2:03:00that's what it's limited to, but it's still number one. But there's no question that
2:03:09it wouldn't have happened without regulatory pressure. And I've always said like, piracy
2:03:17is a form of negotiation. And go back 20 years before the iTunes Music Store, when the iTunes
2:03:27Music Store was sort of an answer to, "Hey, everybody wants to just download MP3s, and
2:03:33right now the only way to really do it easily is to pirate them. Here, we're going to make
2:03:38it even easier, and we're going to do it by selling the songs for 99 cents. But you
2:03:44don't have to worry about quality, we're going to make sure everything's encoded right,
2:03:47we're going to pre-fill all the metadata." And you can feel good about the fact that
2:03:51you're not pirating it, that you're paying a reasonable price for the music. But the
2:03:55piracy was a form of collective negotiation with the music industry. It's like, "Oh,
2:04:02you guys only want to sell us music on complete album CDs, and you're going to up the price
2:04:07to like 20 bucks a CD, and I really only want one song from the CD. Well, I'll just kind
2:04:14of download the song." Right? It's a form of negotiation. And regulatory pressure works
2:04:19that way too, where it's like, sometimes the best regulation isn't regulation that's
2:04:25put into law, it's the threat of regulation, and it is enough to create changes in the
2:04:32company or the product or whatever it is that you're attempting to regulate. And in some
2:04:37ways, the emulation restriction in the App Store rules, I think, is an example of that.
2:04:44There's been no law passed around the world or in the United States or elsewhere that
2:04:49says that Apple has to allow 20-year-old Nintendo platforms to be emulated on the phone, but
2:04:55it's thanks to the regulatory pressure that that's now true, that everybody around the
2:04:59world can download Delta from the App Store. It works, and sometimes that's the best
2:05:05way, right? And my criticisms, and I think you probably agree with it, I think almost
2:05:10everybody who's technically literate, even people who overall think the DMA overall is
2:05:17a good idea, will acknowledge that yes, there's some technical clunkers in here, aspects of
2:05:23it that are written by people who just don't understand, shouldn't be passing mandates
2:05:29because they don't understand the things that they're mandating. But it's, I'm really, really
2:05:34interested to see what the next couple of marketplaces that open in the EU. And I think
2:05:40it's so cool that the first one is Riley's. I really do. It's such a great little independent
2:05:47story. I mean, it's just two guys who made the first third-party App Store for iOS.
2:05:58I kind of feel like, obviously, having lived in Italy my entire life, and we've been part
2:06:04of the European Union for what, the past almost 30 years?
2:06:09Yeah, right.
2:06:11If the way the European Union operates historically is of any indication, it seems to me that
2:06:19with all kinds of regulations that they have passed over the past decades, usually they
2:06:24are interested in sort of setting a baseline for how they think things should be done.
2:06:32And this applies to currencies, to foreign travel, to healthcare mandates. It applies,
2:06:41of course, during the lockdown and the pandemic. It applies to immigration. It applies to funds
2:06:48that they give to different governments to redo their infrastructures, for example. That's
2:06:53one of the things that we've been doing in Italy for the past couple of years. We've
2:06:56been using European funds to redo very basic things like our streets and bike lanes, that
2:07:04sort of stuff. Usually, the European Union seems to be interested in setting a baseline.
2:07:09And this is such a European thing, but most things are always up for debate. And there's
2:07:18always a lot of concessions happening behind the scenes. And sort of like the European
2:07:26Union coming in and saying, "We want you to do this," and setting these vague sort of
2:07:33mandates, just like in the DMA, so many aspects are sort of vague. It's not clear exactly
2:07:39what you want with this regulation. But it seems that I've seen this story before with
2:07:45other types of EU mandate regulations, and it always comes down to, "Okay, let's get
2:07:51these people behind closed doors to figure things out in a way that makes sense in the
2:07:57end." And I think this initial moment is the most awkward one. And that is my interpretation
2:08:05of things, that there are some good aspects, I think, in theory, that can be salvaged in
2:08:15the DMA. It's like, on paper, the idea of, "Hey, should users have options when it comes
2:08:22to installing software on their phones?" And Apple saying, "Okay, but maybe we'll let them
2:08:28do it in a secure way that we still control." That sort of back and forth, I think, this
2:08:35is just my personal theory, is what we will continue to see. And it's why now the European
2:08:41Union needs to get back to Apple in terms of how they've implemented the core technology
2:08:46fee, and how they've implemented installing software via a web browser. There's going
2:08:50to be a lot of this. And I think I've seen a similar narrative unfold before with all
2:09:01kinds of regulations that, coming from Brussels to the individual governments, and it starts
2:09:08this conversation between them that eventually ends up with, "Okay, the original regulation
2:09:15was interpreted and revised to be applied in this specific way for, say, Italy, or in
2:09:22this case, maybe in the future, Apple and iOS." So this is sort of where I stand. I
2:09:28think, and I hope, it goes like other regulations before, where it was mostly about setting
2:09:37a baseline, but the details were intentionally kept vague because they needed to be figured
2:09:42out between the parties involved.
2:09:44And it's just the EU way of doing it, really. I mean, it's different to not delineate things
2:09:50very specifically, but sort of leave it up to interpretation in the future. And that's
2:09:54really where we are, is what are they going to choose to enforce? I think, for example,
2:10:00I think the mandatory browser choice screen is a bad idea. I don't think it's horrible,
2:10:06and the people who are fans of it are like, "Why are you objecting to it?" I just think
2:10:11it's the sort of thing that I just think most typical users don't understand. And I've shown
2:10:18the screenshots of the browser choice screen to my mom and my mother-in-law, who are very
2:10:24typical iPhone users, non-technical. Neither of them, they're both bright. They're bright
2:10:31women, but they're not technical at all. And I was like, "Would you understand what to
2:10:36do with this screen?" And they say, "No, I don't know what it is." And I think my mom knew
2:10:41that her browser is Safari, but my mother-in-law didn't even know Safari is named Safari. But
2:10:49it's just one thing, and I do recognize that from the European Commission's perspective,
2:10:54I think that they naturally see the web as their platform, that what the web, the World
2:11:01Wide Web of browsers is, is sort of the computing equivalent of the European Union, right? The
2:11:13European Union is not a federal single entity. There's no European Union army, right? It's
2:11:20not like the United States. Yeah, you even laugh because you're intimately familiar with
2:11:23it, and you know how ludicrous that is. But it is. It's like the web, and the web doesn't
2:11:29have an owner, right? The European Union doesn't really have an owner, right? Germany doesn't
2:11:33own the European Union, even though it's the biggest economy in the union. It's sort
2:11:39of like the web, and so they have an affinity for the web, and they've given special attention
2:11:46to it with this browser choice screen. I think that the sort of murmuring that maybe they
2:11:51would do the same thing with photos would be a disaster. I don't...
2:11:55That would just be so silly. Like, why even consider that?
2:11:58It is not... So I think stopping with the browser is one thing. I think if they continued
2:12:05to push and ended at what? You're going to have an email client choice screen, a calendar
2:12:09choice screen, a photo storage choice screen, and the photo choice screen in particular
2:12:15really just does not work with the central role that the photo role stores in iOS in
2:12:23terms of the photo picker and stuff like that. I mean, it's all typing. Anything could happen.
2:12:28Apple could comply with anything. Software is flexible, but that's just... To me, it's
2:12:37pointless and detrimental and doesn't deserve to be mandated. And maybe that's just something
2:12:42that they said. It just depends on how they interpret it.
2:12:45Yeah, they say many things. I think they could have probably just mandated that users should
2:12:53be able to install different browsers without the screen. If anything, because like Google,
2:13:00for example, they have been so aggressive lately in Italy. I don't know if it's the
2:13:06same elsewhere in Europe, and I have to believe that it was in preparation of this, but they
2:13:11have been running TV commercials so aggressively for Google Chrome on iPhone over the past
2:13:17few months that I can see how the regular person now sees that screen and it's like,
2:13:23"Oh yeah, I've seen Google Chrome on TV." They say that it's more secure than other
2:13:27browsers. Let me tap on the Google Chrome because this is exactly what they have been
2:13:31arguing in their commercials, that you don't have to worry about passwords because Google
2:13:36Chrome has your back. Now, you don't see those Safari commercials on Italian TV. You
2:13:41see the Google ones, and when you get that screen and you see Google Chrome, maybe some
2:13:46people would say, "Yeah, I hear that's secure," even though they have a perfectly fine and
2:13:52maybe even more secure browser already on their phone. So I would have personally preferred
2:13:58like, "Yes, open it up. Let me install different browsers," but maybe the screen
2:14:03was a little unnecessary. For sure, I wouldn't like to get more screens. Even if it's a
2:14:11screen and you can dismiss it, and somebody like me, I'm fine. It's not going to kill
2:14:17me or anything, but like you mentioned, my mom would see that screen and I am convinced
2:14:22my mom, not because she's stupid or whatever, she just is a regular person who doesn't
2:14:28read Daring Fireball or Mac stories, and she makes the connection of, "Yeah, I've seen
2:14:33Google on TV. I want to choose that because it seems to be better." And so I am a little
2:14:39concerned about what that screen could do for people who don't know all the details.
2:14:48And they don't recognize things, and I don't think the DMA acknowledges. I think that the
2:14:52DMA is written from a perspective—and again, it's biased towards the web, and I think
2:14:58the US Department of Justice lawsuit that, or brief, whatever it's called, the opening
2:15:04salvo launched against Apple, is from the exact same perspective, where it's from
2:15:09technocrats who see computing devices as sort of blank slates, and that the ideal is cross-platform
2:15:21software, and that it doesn't matter which brand phone you have, and that write-once-run-everywhere
2:15:27web apps for everything would be all pros, no cons, and just not only doesn't acknowledge,
2:15:36but is actually completely ignoring the advantages of integration and how that's actually the
2:15:42appeal of Apple, right? The appeal of Apple is, "Okay, especially for typical consumers,
2:15:49you can trust us," and there's just this integrated experience of, "Okay, you've
2:15:55got an iPhone and you like the iPhone, and so maybe now your next laptop you'll buy
2:16:01a MacBook, and you've never owned a Mac before, and by default you're using Safari
2:16:07and you've signed into your iCloud account, and you've got shared history. Your history
2:16:12of what you browsed on your iPhone is there in the history menu in Safari on your Mac,
2:16:17and it just works." And I know that if you go all in on the Google ecosystem, you
2:16:21get the same thing with Chrome or with Brave, that if you use the same browser on your phone,
2:16:27your iPhone, and your Mac, you can get shared history and shared bookmarks and stuff like
2:16:31that. But the people like my mom and my mother-in-law, it's not just because of me, because I'm
2:16:38my mom's son and my mother-in-law's son-in-law, that they've bought Apple products, that
2:16:42they don't badger me for advice and what to do and get lost. They just sort of have
2:16:48a trust that, "Oh, if I just do the Apple thing, it'll all work and it'll be both
2:16:53useful and safe. It won't be installing unwanted toolbars in my browser and junking
2:17:01up the interface with stuff that I don't want," or something like that. And I do think,
2:17:06it's just funny watching, of course, the downloads of third-party browsers went up
2:17:12once this browser choice screen went into place in iOS 17.4 in the EU, because of course
2:17:20more people are downloading these third-party browsers than before. But are they all doing
2:17:26it because they're making a knowledgeable choice? That just gets glossed over by this.
2:17:32In the same way that there surely are some people who've discovered a browser that
2:17:36they like, like, "Oh, I didn't realize Chrome was available on an iPhone. I don't
2:17:40know who those people are," because like you said, Google's advertised it heavily.
2:17:47But there's just as surely people who've made a mistake, who didn't know what they
2:17:52were choosing and picked something and now they've got a default browser that is unfamiliar
2:17:58and they don't know how they got there.
2:18:00Yeah, and I do think that there are aspects that I appreciate. There are installing software
2:18:14from third-party marketplace while still knowing that it's being notarized by Apple. And
2:18:21so I can rest assured that I'm not installing some scammy malware coming from who knows
2:18:27where and it's still under some sort of control from Apple. I think that's a great
2:18:35thing and I think it's showing how my concluding thought would be that it's a shame that
2:18:47it had to come down to this, to what's happening now. But I do think that a little bit of pressure
2:18:57on Apple to change things up, whether, you know, you look at emulators, for example.
2:19:08Now they didn't have to, but they felt like maybe they had to show that they're listening
2:19:14and opening things up. I do believe that in this case, competition and a healthy dose
2:19:23of regulation can push things in the right direction. If anything, from the perspective
2:19:28of it creates new opportunities for people who maybe wouldn't have gotten to realize
2:19:37those opportunities before. Like, for example, Riley and Delta, if it were not for what's
2:19:46happening now, not only is now Delta providing a hopefully sustainable business for the two
2:19:56young developers involved, but it's also having this sort of cascading effect for,
2:20:01like, sales of third party game controllers are up, way up, because of what's happening
2:20:08now. Millions and millions of people want to play those Nintendo games and therefore
2:20:12they're spending their money elsewhere. So I think it's important to consider not just,
2:20:16you know, the individual example of, yeah, there's a Nintendo emulator now in the App
2:20:21Store, but it's important to consider how competition and regulation, sometimes they
2:20:26have an effect on the economy and what's possible now that wasn't possible until a week ago.
2:20:35And now it's moving a bunch of aspects of people spending money in different places
2:20:42that they wouldn't have otherwise, and I think that's a nice thing.
2:20:48I think some of Apple's mentality and their obstinance at changing and adapting and opening
2:20:54up is, I mean, let's face it. I mean, the most staunch critics of Apple would say it's
2:21:02just pure greed and that it's all about the 30 to 15% cut from the App Store and everything
2:21:10is about the App Store cut. And there's no doubt about it that Apple cares about the
2:21:14revenue from the App Store. I mean, it's a lot of money, it's the services has been their
2:21:20growth engine and the growth is an important, it's from an investor standpoint, traditionally,
2:21:28the thing that any investor looks at at any company, it doesn't matter what they make
2:21:32is are they growing or not? And if they're not, then it's bad for the stock. And so of
2:21:37course that's an A factor, but I do think that Apple without Steve Jobs has lost a little
2:21:45bit of the, okay, fuck it, let's just do a new thing, right? Like there's the whole story
2:21:50about like that Jobs was opposed to putting iTunes on Windows, that the original idea
2:21:57of the iPod as a Mac peripheral to help bolster the Mac and keep the software Mac only. And
2:22:05Schiller, we know from books that have come out and a couple other executives, like, I
2:22:10think we should put this on Windows and sell. Not only will we make a lot of money selling
2:22:15iPods to Windows users, it's a way to give people who've never tasted the Apple experience
2:22:21their first taste of the Apple experience. And Steve Jobs was resistant and they made
2:22:25their case a couple of times and then he was like, okay, screw it, but it's your problem.
2:22:28You know, go do it. But I feel like they've lost a little bit of that sort of, I think
2:22:35there's, it's not just greed for the app store revenue. There's a bit of, if it ain't broke,
2:22:41don't fix it. Let's not screw anything up. And I know that the critics of Apple's compliance
2:22:49with DMA call it malicious compliance and I could not disagree more. I actually think
2:22:54that, okay, they fought against it. They did not want the DMA to be passed at all. They
2:22:59did not want sideloading. Craig Federighi went to, it wasn't Barcelona, was it Portugal?
2:23:05There was some conference in Europe. I mean, somebody, Apple executive flying all the way
2:23:09from California to Europe to speak at a conference, it shows you how important they took it. And
2:23:15the whole point of his keynote two or three years ago was to make the case against sideloading
2:23:20as a mandated feature. They clearly, but they, they, they lost the argument. The mandate
2:23:26was passed. And I feel like they said what Apple has done is said, okay, it is what it
2:23:32is. This is the law. How do we do the best job of complying with this? To me, malicious
2:23:38compliance with sideloading would have been what a lot of nerds think they want Apple
2:23:45to do, which is anything goes okay. Anybody who compiles a native app for iPhone, just
2:23:52put it on the web and download it and it installs on your home screen and there it is. And if
2:23:57it uses private APIs and runs in the background or tries to install stuff outside the sandbox
2:24:02or whatever, anything goes, just let it happen. That's malicious compliance where, and surely
2:24:10that would lead to malware and just poorly coded software that drains the battery. And
2:24:17then Apple could point to the EU and say, look at all these people complaining about
2:24:20the battery life being hours shorter on their phone than before. I think they've right.
2:24:26The complexity of their, their compliance is, isn't about being confusing. It's about
2:24:32trying to comply with all these things in ways that maintain the experience. And I really
2:24:37do think that Apple's looking at it as, okay, we're, we have to do this. What can we do
2:24:45that might be what we would do if we were starting all over today? And I think like,
2:24:50that's why I think the core technology fee is a way of Apple saying we, we will still
2:24:56want to monetize third party software development on this platform. That's the nature of this.
2:25:03This is not an open platform where developers can just freely install whatever they want.
2:25:10What if instead of taking a cut of sales, we just took a cut, a 50 cent or 50 Euro cent,
2:25:17whatever you, what do you call them? Euro cents? What are they? 50 Euro cent download
2:25:22fee over a million. Cause it fills in. I've, I've mentioned this, but you know, I don't
2:25:26think in 2008 when they launched the app store, they foresaw things like TikTok and Facebook
2:25:33and Instagram and these apps that are free to download only free to download and form
2:25:40billion dollar companies that Apple's mindset was surely the successful companies that build
2:25:48apps will be selling their apps. Right. And it's turns out that's not true. So what would
2:25:53they do to adjust? I honestly see a lot of almost almost everything in their compliance
2:25:59plan is something that if it works out well and is a good experience for users in the
2:26:04EU that they might open up worldwide without any kind of mandate by the law. I really do
2:26:10think so. Yeah. And I think that's, you know, and that's why I think the things like people
2:26:15are complaining about, Hey, you have to agree. You know, it's not just tap a link on the
2:26:20website and you get an app on your home screen. It's you have to go into settings and say,
2:26:24I permit some, this developer to give me an app. I think that it's, it's all, it's not
2:26:31to discourage people. It's to strike the right balance between making sure the experience
2:26:36stays good. Yeah. And honestly it's fine. Like clicking through a couple of dialogues.
2:26:43I think it's, it's, it's, it takes 30 seconds. It's not a big deal really. Yeah. Anyway.
2:26:53That's about it for me. It's good to talk to you.
2:26:55Watch you again. Lots to look forward to in the coming weeks. Are you coming? Do you know,
2:27:00are you coming to WWDC? Oh yeah. Yeah. All right. Well then I can, I can gladly say I
2:27:05will see you there. Awesome. See you soon. Everybody where else, where, where, where
2:27:10should we tell people to go? Of course, max stories.net net. I'm a mastodon at BTT dot
2:27:17max stories.net because we're using our domain. You've got your own domain. How's that working
2:27:22out for you? Are you glad you did that? I don't know. I don't know. The mastodon gets
2:27:28expensive fast. So to give you a quick sense of things, we're spending $80 a month just
2:27:36to run the mastodon instance. So yeah, it's not really well optimized. I hope they're
2:27:43working on it. I'm mostly just happy that it's under my own domain, but I don't know.
2:27:49Anyway, also on threads, also on threads, the same user.
2:27:55Great to talk to you Federico. See you soon. See you soon.
2:27:58Thank you.