Podcast Search

The Talk Show

403: ‘150 Million Calculator Apps’, With Quinn Nelson

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00this better be worth it. Sure enough. It was really cool. It

0:00:04was super well done. The live stream went off without a hitch.

0:00:07There was no weird quality issues or any major frame skips.

0:00:11And it really did feel like you were in the audience, which was

0:00:14pretty awesome.

0:00:15The funniest thing was that Adam was just off stage. All he had to

0:00:21do is turn his head and he could have watched the whole show from

0:00:24right where he was behind the curtain and he watched the whole

0:00:26thing in the vision.

0:00:27In the vision pro?

0:00:28Because he was like, I just wanted to see that it worked.

0:00:32And then he was like, well, and then I got into it. And I was

0:00:35like, well, I'll just keep watching. So he was literally

0:00:38right off the stage, watching Envision Pro. So I, I have to

0:00:42say I'm pretty I mean, again, I cannot take credit for any of

0:00:45the technology. It was all Adam and Spatial Gen and his

0:00:48colleagues at sandwich. And all I did was say, Okay, let's try

0:00:52it. You know, all I did was grant permission. So I don't

0:00:54want credit for it. But I have to say it is a minor thrill that

0:00:59my show to my knowledge is the first live thing ever broadcast

0:01:05for vision Pro.

0:01:06I think that's right. Yeah, that's cool.

0:01:09And it's kind of weird. Oh, well, you'd think Apple would

0:01:12do it first. But Apple doesn't really do anything live anymore.

0:01:16Right? Their keynotes ever since COVID are all pre recorded. And

0:01:19even like at WWDC each year, when they show it to 1000 or 2000

0:01:27people on the lawn outside Apple Park and Tim and Craig

0:01:31Federighi come out beforehand, they don't broadcast the little

0:01:34three minute introduction. So I don't even know what Apple would

0:01:38do live other than sports, of course, which sports fans are

0:01:42all waiting for, but which is a whole nother huge, humongous

0:01:47can of worms and certainly isn't going to be the first thing that

0:01:50happens something like complexity. Right, something

0:01:55like my show, here's a stage you can just point static, right at

0:01:59it. And yeah, static subjects is kind of perfect for it, even if

0:02:03not exciting. I thought it was great. It was really fun. So I

0:02:08just want to say again, what a thrill. I'm glad it worked very

0:02:12well by thanks to sandwich and everybody and it's I guess we'll

0:02:16do it again next year. And the other thing I was braced for were

0:02:20complaints from people who don't have vision Pro Well, how come

0:02:23you don't just broadcast do the live thing flat too so I can

0:02:27watch and nobody complained. Which again, I'm like, are they

0:02:33in my spam? I'm like looking at my spam. It's like, nope,

0:02:36everybody just took it in stride. And I was like, pretty

0:02:39cool. Thank you for everybody for not complaining. I guess we

0:02:43should start with Apple intelligence. I wrote about it

0:02:47finally over the weekend or finally finished it up. You know,

0:02:50some years WWDC has a Oh, that was the year blank. And now

0:02:56we've got two years in a row last year was the vision Pro got

0:02:59introduced this year obviously will be remembered as Oh, this

0:03:02is the year that Apple intelligence was announced. It

0:03:06does seem like a big deal. And I worry that I buried it by

0:03:09putting it the conclusion of my article because I do think it's

0:03:13like the single most important thing people can take away. But

0:03:16and it felt like it belonged at the end. But I always worry about

0:03:19putting things at the end. Maybe you feel the same way with

0:03:21videos to where it's I worry about the people who don't get

0:03:23to the end. I'd like to think that everybody who reads my

0:03:27articles reads them to the end because they're so compelling.

0:03:30But I know that people start reading and then they drift

0:03:32away. But the main takeaway I want to emphasize is we don't

0:03:36know if any of this stuff works. We don't know even if it does

0:03:40work if it's going to scale to where Apple needs it to scale. I

0:03:44don't know that even true experts in setting up data

0:03:47centers ever really know if something's going to scale until

0:03:50you flip the switch and go live. And it just seems like if it

0:03:55wasn't this huge moment of pressure from users who seem to

0:04:01want these features and Wall Street investors who definitely

0:04:04seem to want Apple to to have something to say on generative

0:04:08AI, I honestly think almost all of this would have come next

0:04:13year, not this year. I feel like we're finally get here's what

0:04:16Apple would do if they told us what they're doing a year in

0:04:18advance.

0:04:19I tend to agree if anything, because all the features that

0:04:22are the most compelling features don't even have a date or or

0:04:27have been suggested to come sometime next year into the

0:04:30future. I think they did a pretty good job at explaining

0:04:34what Apple intelligence is supposed to be and what it will

0:04:37be. That's part of the problem, right? This is such a new thing

0:04:41to so many people, that not only do they have to explain what it

0:04:45is, and how it works, and why it's different from other

0:04:49generative AI stuff that exists on the market today, but then

0:04:52they have to lean into the okay, now that we have the foundations

0:04:55of what it is, what does it actually do? And I felt a little

0:05:00bit, I don't want to say disappointed. But that's where I

0:05:04feel we didn't get a ton of information about what it will

0:05:08do beyond the basic stuff that was expected, like summaries and

0:05:13rewriting tools and generative images, which I didn't really

0:05:17expect, but it's not a novel or new thing. That's where I think

0:05:21it's, it's difficult and maybe weird is they came out guns

0:05:25blazing with here's what it is. And here's how it works. But we

0:05:29still are kind of waiting for the okay, but what, how will it

0:05:32help me? What is it supposed to do into the future? We just have

0:05:36the little kind of principal foundations that are good. But I

0:05:40don't know that any of them are all that unique as compared to

0:05:43what already exists today on the market.

0:05:45And it's it was very telling to me not in a surprising way. But

0:05:51in a Oh, this is very early days. And they are really giving

0:05:55us a sneak peek behind the curtain that at Apple Park, for

0:06:01those of us who got media invitations, they had briefings

0:06:04after the keynote Monday afternoon. And then back on

0:06:07Tuesday, I was back there all all morning Tuesday for demos of

0:06:12Mac OS and iOS and iPad OS and stuff like that. And none of

0:06:18those demos, not only are those features not in the developer

0:06:21beta that shipped last week, and not coming, I don't know, maybe

0:06:25even while we're recording this podcast today, supposedly, today

0:06:29is the day second developer betas are dropping. But the

0:06:32Apple intelligence features aren't coming yet. But they,

0:06:35they didn't even let us play with it hands on, which is pretty

0:06:39unusual for Apple. But again, in this case, it's not surprising.

0:06:43So I got to see Apple representative in a briefing,

0:06:49writing an email, just exactly like the keynote, here's an

0:06:52email for a job, I'm applying for a job, and I've attached my

0:06:56resume. And I've written the email, select the text of the

0:07:00email and hit this little blue thing and say, make this sound

0:07:03more professional. And I got, we got to watch that happen. And I

0:07:07asked, is this determinant? I know you're doing these demos

0:07:11for these are small groups of media three or four at a time.

0:07:14And then the same people every 40 minutes are doing it for

0:07:17another group. I was like, do you get the same answer every

0:07:20time? And they said no, we there are slight differences. And

0:07:24because they've been rehearsing the demo and doing it for

0:07:26groups, he even told me, here's, here's the sentence

0:07:30where sometimes we get slightly different words when we say make

0:07:33it more professional. That's how LLM's work, right? That's

0:07:36the proof that it was a live demo of what they actually have

0:07:40working behind the scenes. But it also also shows why they

0:07:43didn't let us type our own email and, and say make this

0:07:48funnier or make it whatever the options are for that. We didn't

0:07:53get to make our own Genmoji. We didn't get to they didn't even

0:07:57show the image playgrounds in action. So I mean, there's a lot

0:08:00of stuff that they didn't even demo to us live. I mean, that's

0:08:04how early it is. The Xcode stuff they definitely showed live. And

0:08:08it seems again, I keep mentioning this on dithering to

0:08:13it just is wild to me, but I get it. But it just seems crazy to

0:08:17me that LLM's are particularly good at writing computer

0:08:21programs. Whereas for humans, writing computer programs is

0:08:27generally considered a much rarer skill and harder than

0:08:31writing prose, right? It's just the nature of LLM's and the

0:08:35nature of code that it works with the robotic brain for lack

0:08:39of a better and they showed us that live demo of the code

0:08:43completion and Xcode and the much more impressive Swift

0:08:47assist where you can sort of just type a natural language

0:08:51query, like I've got a collection of images, I'd like

0:08:55to present them in a carousel that users can swipe

0:08:59horizontally. Boom. And then here's some code that would say,

0:09:03okay, given a collection of still images, here's how you

0:09:06here's some code that would generate a Swift UI view of a

0:09:10swipeable carousel of those images. Very, very impressive.

0:09:14But again, they did not let us I don't know how much help it

0:09:17would be letting the media write code, but we could write

0:09:21natural language queries, though, right? I mean, if

0:09:24anything, that would actually be a demo we could have done, but

0:09:27very, very early days. And it's kind of exciting, right? To be

0:09:32following Apple and to actually see them reveal something so

0:09:36early.

0:09:36Yeah, it's very atypical. On the one hand, I agree. It's it's

0:09:41definitely for optics, they need to let investors know that it's

0:09:45something that they've been working on and something that's

0:09:47planned. I think their focus on running many of the models that

0:09:52they have on device is proof, I guess that the NPUs and the

0:09:59neural engine as it as Apple calls them as that they've been

0:10:02putting in basically all of their a series chips for several

0:10:05years now. And in the M series chips as well, that that there's

0:10:09a point to that there's been a point in the past. I mean, NPS

0:10:13have been doing all sorts of stuff on Apple Silicon for

0:10:16years, but nothing so definitive as in, this is why these chips

0:10:20keep getting larger and larger and more powerful, especially in

0:10:24a market where you know, with something like the Snapdragon X

0:10:27elite, the new, you know, alleged competitor to the M

0:10:30series chips, they they keep talking ad nauseum about how

0:10:35amazing their NPU is and why neural engines and application

0:10:38specific silicon is going to be super important into the future.

0:10:41And Apple's kind of just Yeah, we've been doing this for a

0:10:45decade now. And this is the proof that it matters. And, and

0:10:48being able to do a lot of the stuff that right now with other

0:10:53AI models is done in the cloud on device is a really big deal

0:10:57being able to write, rewrite or to proofread or to make your

0:11:01email Sam more friendly when you're on an airplane with no

0:11:05internet connection. It's it's going to be faster. It's going

0:11:09to be there's no downsides really, it's pretty amazing.

0:11:12Again, not surprising, it almost would have it would have been far

0:11:16more surprising if it wasn't in a personal context, right?

0:11:21Because it really does fit with Apple's long standing under Tim

0:11:27Cook sort of doctrine, as Horace Dedue has put it that the Apple

0:11:32seeks to own and control the core technologies, most

0:11:36important to its products, blah, blah, blah. But there's also, I

0:11:41don't know, a couple years ago, there was sort of a mantra, only

0:11:44Apple things only Apple could do and that that semantic index of

0:11:50your personal information put into a stored securely on

0:11:56device, cryptographically, and the key demo of the whole keynote

0:12:01was that when does my mom's flight arrive? Question, right?

0:12:06And presuming that it worked that you'll be able to do

0:12:09something like that, and that it'll work even close to as

0:12:13well as Apple is suggesting it works, is, yes, that's what

0:12:18we've been thinking in the back of our heads ever since the

0:12:22first version of Siri, right, that you'd just be able to ask

0:12:26a question like that and get it. But it, it really is the nature

0:12:31of the question. You don't have to get into one of these

0:12:35comparisons. I know with Anthropic, and they just

0:12:39announced the Claude 3.5. So nada, whatever their new one is,

0:12:44and they've got these benchmarks, and they show these

0:12:46comparisons to chat GPT four o and perplexity and whatever else

0:12:51the leading Gemini whatever the leading other ones are, and they

0:12:54come up with scores like 64 to 65% on this issue or 83 versus

0:13:0179% on something else. Put aside where Apple's models compare in

0:13:08a benchmark like that against these rivals, only apples is

0:13:12going to be able to get the personal context of that right,

0:13:14you could go we could go to the future and chat GPT five isn't

0:13:20going to be able to answer the question when is my mom's flight

0:13:23arriving because it doesn't even know who you are, let alone your

0:13:26mom or have access to your email. So the focus on stuff that

0:13:31only Apple can do that because it's stuff that's only on your

0:13:35device and that you trust to be on your device is potentially I

0:13:42know and it sounds like a bold adjective but radical, right?

0:13:45This could change the way we use our devices.

0:13:48And and that's what I think is so compelling about Apple

0:13:52intelligence. Most of the stuff that they showed this year is

0:13:57stuff that no doubt will be helpful. I think that rewriting

0:14:01tools are going to be used by tons of people, I think image

0:14:04generation for emojis and memes will definitely be a thing.

0:14:09These are all things that are coming and they're cool. But I

0:14:13don't know that we'll look back at tools like this in five years

0:14:16and go remember when that changed the world. But I I do

0:14:20think that reasoning as it's kind of referred to in in ml and

0:14:25AI nomenclature, which I don't really like because it's such a

0:14:28wide encompassing term. So I invented one that's not really a

0:14:31real thing. But like this idea of an intent engine, something

0:14:35that understands the input that you as a user are asking it,

0:14:39knows how to find the data related to that and then provide

0:14:43a result that you expect. That's the promise that so many of

0:14:48these kind of AI specific hardware devices have sold

0:14:52themselves on. But nobody's come even close. I think like the

0:14:56humane AI pin is a good example. I reviewed that thing. It's it's

0:15:00not a great product. I didn't recommend anybody buy it. But

0:15:03one of the things that did do that was quite cool is there was

0:15:09one time where I was standing in front of a bus stop. And I said,

0:15:13When is the next bus supposed to arrive? It took a picture of the

0:15:17sign. And I guess via searching the web told me that the next

0:15:22bus was supposed to arrive in eight minutes. And it was off by

0:15:25a little bit, but that could have been the buses for all I

0:15:27know. And then I at the same time after said, Let my wife

0:15:32know when I will be arriving home. And it used its reasoning

0:15:37to find when the bus would get to my house. I don't know if

0:15:40that was done via traffic data or whatever. But it was really

0:15:44cool because I was able to just say a thing and in the

0:15:47background, it was able to go okay, he needs to get from point

0:15:50A to point B, he's standing in front of a bus stop. So he's

0:15:52going to take the bus. Who is his wife? When he says let her

0:15:56know that's probably a message. How should we do that? How do we

0:15:59craft the message? And it was one of the few instances that I

0:16:02use the AI pin where I was like, this actually could be a game

0:16:06changer. And I think that is what the promise of Apple

0:16:10intelligence is.

0:16:11John Greenewald In your case, and that is a great demo. I

0:16:14mean, just a great example. Did it have to intuit that you would

0:16:19be riding the bus that you just asked about? Like you didn't

0:16:22say, I'm going to get on the bus.

0:16:25Yeah, I actually said and you have to use the look command.

0:16:28But I said, look at where I am, and tell me when the next bus is

0:16:32coming. So it took a picture of the scene. And I don't know what

0:16:36kind of models that used and Apple is a little different

0:16:39because they're doing most of this with their own stuff. If

0:16:43you look at something like the human AI pin, they need to this

0:16:48engine basically that understands intent. The only

0:16:51thing they're doing is basically saying, okay, what does the user

0:16:54want? Because we don't have the models, they don't have their

0:16:57own on device models, they don't have image recognition. So they

0:17:01just try to understand what the user wants. And then they go out

0:17:03to Claude or to the perplexity or to chat GPT, or any one of

0:17:08these AI services. It's called the AI bus. That's what humane

0:17:12calls it. And it's actually a pretty good name. Because it

0:17:15that is what it does. And basically, what's the what's the

0:17:18input? And how do we get an output and make sure that that

0:17:21output responds to the input from the user. And that's what I

0:17:25think is so interesting about Apple intelligence. If that demo

0:17:29that they gave in the keynote of Craig, where he said, Oh, I have

0:17:33a meeting later, or excuse me, they want to change the time of

0:17:36a meeting. Can we change the time and but I know my daughter

0:17:40has a concert. And I didn't put that in my calendar, but she did

0:17:42send me a PDF that has details of the performance. That kind of

0:17:46stuff is a game changer. If that works, where I think there's

0:17:51caution that will need to be had is that my main frustration with

0:17:56the AI pin and the rabbit and all of these devices when

0:17:59compared to something like Siri, they're vastly more capable. But

0:18:03I ran into more and more limitations, because there was

0:18:07this expectation of Oh, well, you can do anything. And that's

0:18:10where I think it will be interesting to see if Apple can

0:18:13pull this off is right now there's a lot of things that

0:18:17people know Siri can't do. Siri's been to put a charitably

0:18:21not very good for a long time, has gotten better. But most

0:18:26people have just they know what Siri does. They asked her to set

0:18:29alarms and timers and home automation stuff, but they're

0:18:31not going to ask questions because they know it can't

0:18:33respond. When it starts to be able to do those things. That's

0:18:37exciting. But the more and more capable it gets the higher the

0:18:42expectation from the user that it completes the thing that the

0:18:45user wants it to do. And if it gets to the point where it can't

0:18:48do that, or it doesn't do reliably, or in the case of the

0:18:52AI pin, it'll do some things, but then five minutes later, it

0:18:54will go, Oh, I can't do that when when it actually can.

0:18:57That's where I think there's a risk of frustrating the end user

0:19:02because they're kind of over promising of a the world's your

0:19:06oyster. But then you're dealing with the realities of reasoning

0:19:11in AI models that are still relatively young and small and

0:19:14inherently limited because this is early days of AI. I don't

0:19:18know. I keep thinking about and I go back to just writing silly

0:19:27programs and basic in the 80s in like grade school and it's you

0:19:32think I'm gonna we're gonna make a computer program that's so

0:19:35smart, it can answer questions. And as a little kid, you just

0:19:38wind up with if this else, if this else if this else and you

0:19:44start, you just quickly realize, oh, you really can't build up

0:19:48enough if F's of else if else to cover everything, even for a

0:19:53limited domain used you what seems like Oh, we'll just build

0:19:57a bunch of those. No, that that's not how you build

0:19:59something that can answer questions arbitrarily. It just

0:20:05always springs to mind in these LLM's really sort of are the

0:20:08first time we're seeing computers sort of encroach on

0:20:13human intuition, right? And and it's so easy to overlook how

0:20:20good human beings are, by nature at intuiting things like context,

0:20:28right? If you're talking like how far away is this bus? If you

0:20:33were just talking to a person who's standing right next to

0:20:36you, who you think knows the bus schedule. And then they say, oh,

0:20:40it's probably about eight minutes away. And then you said,

0:20:43could you text my wife and tell her when I'll get home? The

0:20:46person would know. Oh, because we're me and Quinn are getting

0:20:50on the bus, right? And we're heading home. You don't have to

0:20:54say, I'm going to get on this bus with you. This is why we're

0:20:58waiting here at the bus stop.

0:21:00Yeah, exactly. Yeah. And there's just a zillion of those little

0:21:07fill in the gaps that humans do intuitively that computers

0:21:13don't and, and now sort of with LLM's they kind of do except you

0:21:18have to double check. And that's it. So it's the intuition of

0:21:23filling in gaps that really is the step change.

0:21:26It is. And that's the hardest part. I mean, to bring in

0:21:28another example of something that's also kind of ml and AI

0:21:32driven, self driving cars, right? This has been something

0:21:35that's been right on the horizon for years and years and years

0:21:39and years. And certain individuals have promised that

0:21:41it's right around the corner for years and years and years. And

0:21:44what we've discovered over time is that despite these systems

0:21:49becoming vastly more capable, they're still quite bad at

0:21:54driving. Because there are instances in which humans do

0:21:57stuff intuitively, that goes against traditional convention,

0:22:01they're able to perceive things that go against the traditional

0:22:05rules of driving or the road or they're, they're aware of

0:22:08weather conditions or someone that might be inebriated in

0:22:11front of them. And there's so many factors of when we drive or

0:22:14when the lane markings are disappeared, or it's a, it's a

0:22:17weird intersection that has this strange construction layout. And

0:22:21the first time you were kind of confused by it, but you've

0:22:23you've driven through it once before. And so now you know,

0:22:25that's the kind of stuff that these AI models have to deal

0:22:29with. And the reality is that least with self driving, these

0:22:34roads and this infrastructure has been built for humans. And

0:22:37so once the kind of self driving problem is solved, it's gonna be

0:22:45easy. I mean, that's, once all cars self drive, it's gonna be

0:22:50simple. The issue right now is they're driving with people on

0:22:53roads designed for people. And so the hardest it's ever going

0:22:57to be to develop self driving software is right now. And I

0:23:00think the same is true with AI and LLM's for stuff like this on

0:23:05on device and on platform. Apple has the benefit of being the

0:23:10owners and carers of the system. And so they have access to a

0:23:15bunch of information that third party applications just don't.

0:23:18It's a huge competitive advantage. The question is, like

0:23:22self driving cars, are they going to understand the intent

0:23:26and the reasoning that a person would want with vague input,

0:23:32like, humans talk to other people? I mean, there are entire

0:23:36pieces of software that these reasoning engines, their entire

0:23:40AI companies that exist to basically rewrite your prompts,

0:23:44so that you can get the output from chat GPT that you want,

0:23:48right? And it's because humans are inherently not very good and

0:23:52not very descriptive at this stuff. But that's where the AI

0:23:56is going to have to come across the aisle to get to the hardest

0:23:59part is going to be right now. And unfortunately, once the

0:24:03infrastructure is built out for cars, and once every car is

0:24:06self driving, well, then it's no problem. But until that happens,

0:24:09it's incredibly difficult. And that's not going to happen until

0:24:12AI itself has been able to overcome those things. So it's,

0:24:15it's almost like a catch 22. But that's where the promise of this

0:24:19is incredible. And I'm actually surprised that Apple showed us as

0:24:23much of their hand as they did, like you mentioned, because this

0:24:26is the kind of stuff that they don't traditionally talk about.

0:24:29But at the same time, it's the kind of thing where I go, nobody

0:24:33else has really been able to figure this out. And it's still

0:24:35pie in the sky. This is full self driving kind of stuff. Yeah.

0:24:38And will Apple be able to come out guns blazing in a year and

0:24:42have solved the issue? I don't know.

0:24:45Yeah, because it's like, we all know how it's supposed to work.

0:24:49And that's the other thing too, like, what, when does when does

0:24:55my mom's flight arrive? You know exactly what you mean. It's

0:24:59your mom's next flight. And you know that you must be you must

0:25:03trust that your your mom has either texted you or emailed you

0:25:07with the flight plan so that it's there somehow you wouldn't

0:25:10be asking your phone this question if you thought there's

0:25:15no chance that the information's even on your phone.

0:25:17Totally.

0:25:18Given our experience with Siri over the last what, 14 years?

0:25:23How shocked will we be if the answer is about a flight your mom

0:25:29took six months ago? Right? It's, you know, we're going to be

0:25:35disappointed. It's not going to get reviewed very well. But I

0:25:39don't know that if that's what happens, or if that's how it

0:25:42happens out of the gate. We're not going to be shocked. Get me

0:25:47to the fainting couch. Siri just gave me my mom's flight

0:25:51information from 2019. It was there in your email.

0:25:55Yeah, or even harder. What if the flight is changed? Or there's

0:25:59a cancellation and the flight number changes? That's a much

0:26:02more real world example of it. Serious. Well, we just grabbed

0:26:06the flight from a day ago. We didn't know there was another

0:26:09one that appended this and it's, it's gonna be hard.

0:26:13It really is. And it really speaks to, like I said, just how

0:26:20intuitive actual human beings are. Like when you hire a actual

0:26:26personal assistant who is a human being, you just make all

0:26:31sorts of assumptions that they're going to get if you tell

0:26:36your assistant to get you, can you get me three tickets to the

0:26:42Phillies game Friday night? You kind of know that they're going

0:26:46to ask you certain reasonable questions like, well, how much

0:26:50are you looking to spend or double check with me before you

0:26:55spend an exorbitant amount of money or get me a seat all the

0:26:59way in the third deck way too far away to see anything I know

0:27:03you don't or you might expect your if you're have a you know,

0:27:09if you've been working with the same human assistant for a

0:27:11while, they might know something like, Oh, I know john likes to

0:27:15sit behind first base or home plate usually not third base.

0:27:19They know stuff like that. Totally all of these things. You

0:27:23just expect these computer assistants to pick up but will

0:27:26they I don't know. And we're not going to be satisfied until they

0:27:30do. Right.

0:27:31And what level of information do they retain over time? That's

0:27:35another thing too. I mean, right, you can tell someone,

0:27:37hey, I think I'm going to the jazz game on Thursday. And then

0:27:41two days later, you can come back and ask a person, hey, did

0:27:44you get tickets to the to the game? Or an AI model might go,

0:27:48Okay, tickets to game? What game? There's too many sporting

0:27:51franchises here until they are. And maybe they meant on the TV.

0:27:55Well, here's an Apple TV suggestion of where you can get

0:27:57this. It just so wide. And I think in the beginning, it is

0:28:02going to be limited, and that'll be okay. But they have to do the

0:28:06things that users expect them to do however limited very well.

0:28:10That's where I think it will become frustrating because with

0:28:15and again, I'm coming back to the AI pen, it's gonna be way

0:28:17better than the AI pen. But one of the things the AI pen would

0:28:21do was when I asked it to do something that couldn't do I'd

0:28:23be like, okay, like it was worth a shot. I wasn't that frustrated

0:28:27because it was never really a promise. But there were things

0:28:30that I knew the pin could do that it would have done

0:28:33previously. And then two hours later, it was just like, Oh, I

0:28:36can't do that. And I'm thinking to myself, yeah, you can you

0:28:39just did it a couple hours ago, or you did this task that's so

0:28:43hyper similar that why would you not be able to do task B, it's

0:28:47almost the same thing. And that's where it gets frustrating

0:28:51is, is what's the level of expectation they set from day

0:28:55one? And how good is the baseline? I think it will

0:28:59satisfy me and most people, if it's good at just indexing

0:29:04information. So if you say, Hey, when was my daughter's concert

0:29:09supposed to be and it wasn't in your calendar, and it goes and

0:29:11finds the PDF and then does OCR on the PDF and finds that's good

0:29:16enough. I don't need it to do all the other stuff. But if it

0:29:19can't even do that, or it fine, that's where it's gonna be this

0:29:23failed promise kind of thing where the potential is

0:29:26theoretically so high, but in practice, it's just not there. I

0:29:29am excited because I think if anyone can manage this, it's

0:29:32Apple, they're running the models on device, the model seem

0:29:35quite powerful. They have full control of the operating system

0:29:38that nobody has control of. If anyone can do it, it's them. But

0:29:42that's also like saying it's NASA. Yeah, it's Yeah, they can,

0:29:46but it doesn't mean that it's easy. You know what I mean? So

0:29:48yeah, yeah.

0:29:50All right, let me take a break here and thank our first

0:29:53sponsor. It is our good friends at trade coffee, whose fine

0:29:57product I just finished consuming earlier in this

0:30:00recording. Trade coffee has a great deal for listeners of the

0:30:05show 30% off your first month of coffee that's 30% off by going

0:30:11to drink trade.com slash the talk show. Trade coffee offers

0:30:18tailored plans for coffee delivered to your home. And it

0:30:24is without lock in without any kind of rigidity. Or once you've

0:30:29signed up, you're not getting enough coffee or you're getting

0:30:32too much coffee or something like that they're tailored plans

0:30:35can be adjusted on the fly as you see fit. For example, during

0:30:39the summer months when you go on vacation, it is super duper easy

0:30:43to just log in to the website and pause the delivery just skip

0:30:47one delivery because you know you're not going to be home or

0:30:50something like that. Or if you've got guests coming in to

0:30:53stay with you over summer for a week or two and you know you

0:30:56need more coffee than usual. You can get extra coffee for one

0:31:00shipment in August or something like that. Anything you'd want

0:31:04to do like that you can do. But the best part are just like the

0:31:07normal weeks of the year where your coffee just shows up at

0:31:11your door. At the pace you consume coffee and it's you

0:31:16never run out of extremely fresh, extremely delicious

0:31:20specialty coffee. Trade doesn't roast their own beans. They are

0:31:25a sort of parent umbrella over a bunch, a whole slew of

0:31:30independent roasters all over the country who they pair with

0:31:33to and they make recommendations and you get new coffee from new

0:31:37small family owned roasters all over the country on a regular

0:31:41basis. The variety is terrific. But also, you just give a thumbs

0:31:45up and thumbs down as your shipments arrive and they kind

0:31:49of dial in your taste profile for lack of a better term. It's

0:31:52just terrific. I recommend them very highly and it is super

0:31:56duper flexible. And once again, special deal for listeners of

0:31:59the show 30% off your first month just by going to

0:32:02www.drinktrade.com/the-talk-show. So go try Trade Coffee if you

0:32:08drink coffee. I recommend it highly and drink it myself. What

0:32:13do we think about the I feel like if there's the biggest

0:32:16sour note of that whole Apple intelligence announcement was the

0:32:20cutoff for iPhones, right? It's for iPads and Macs. It's any M

0:32:27series device and that feels completely expected, right? And

0:32:33for the Mac in particular, it goes back at least to what the

0:32:36end of 2020. Yes, feels that that's a pretty good backwards

0:32:40window. It's better than I thought that there would be.

0:32:42Yeah, I have cut out M one honestly. Yeah. Because there's

0:32:46so many of those M ones hanging around that are just still

0:32:49kicking so good. So it's good on Apple like that, like a

0:32:53legendary class of devices, the M one max, because they debuted

0:32:58to spectacular, too good to be true reviews. And here we are,

0:33:02almost four years into it. And they're still kick ass machines.

0:33:07I see it all the time where people are like, you know, I

0:33:10was thinking about upgrading, but I've got this M one that I

0:33:12bought the first generation and it I've got no complaints with

0:33:16it. I've long said the base model M one Pro 14 inch MacBook

0:33:20Pro will go down in history as one of Apple's best machines

0:33:24ever. I mean, that's legendarily good, especially for the price.

0:33:28I mean, you could get those things for 1500 bucks on sale

0:33:32within a year of them releasing and it's still just a killer

0:33:37machine. That made really, really good. And so I would say

0:33:40that the backward compatibility for Apple intelligence on Mac

0:33:43and iPad, very fair. Now I realized the difference is with

0:33:48a Mac, pretty much all well, effectively all Mac books. And

0:33:53that means most Macs that people have bought since the end of

0:33:572020 have been Apple Silicon, right? That it's some number of

0:34:01people bought a Mac Pro for reasons in 2021. But for the

0:34:06most part, anybody who's bought a new Mac in the last three

0:34:10years has one that qualifies for this. Whereas the story for

0:34:13iPhones is for iPads. And there have been M one iPad pros for a

0:34:21while, but it's only in the pro line, I guess, right. Or is

0:34:24there an iPad air now?

0:34:25Yeah, there was an M one air and that's, yeah.

0:34:29So there's a couple, but it's, you know, it's pretty broad and

0:34:32it's, you know, it's the ones that cost 800 bucks or more. They

0:34:36qualify from the last few years, but that, that sad trombone is

0:34:40the only iPhone that qualifies is the iPhone 15 pro, which is

0:34:45nine months old. And even the regular non-pro iPhone 15, which

0:34:50debuted just last September, doesn't qualify.

0:34:53Yep. Brand new phone. You can still go buy in store. No go.

0:34:57Yeah. It's a real bummer. JG on your show basically said, we

0:35:02could, in theory have gotten Apple intelligence to run on.

0:35:06And he said, very old devices was, I think the phrase he used.

0:35:10Yeah. However, the performance would have been so poor that it

0:35:15wouldn't have been worth doing. And I actually believe that I

0:35:17think that much of what makes these models compelling is their

0:35:21speed. And if it can't be done well on device, if you've got

0:35:24memory limitations that just makes it not feasible, or you

0:35:27have to load stuff in chunks, it's not ideal. It's, it's not a

0:35:30good experience. The disappointment is that. Yeah.

0:35:33There's one single iPhone that does this thing. And, and the

0:35:38iPhone 15 is not a very old device. It is a current

0:35:41generation device that is for sale today.

0:35:43I wonder if his thinking on that, and it probably wasn't the

0:35:48most judicious way of him phrasing it, but it's one of

0:35:52those, it was one of those moments on the show where I was

0:35:54like, Ooh, I was worried they wouldn't answer that question at

0:35:56all. And that was actually a pretty straightforward answer

0:35:58that yes, the RAM matters, right? Apple doesn't like to

0:36:01talk about RAM and iPhones. And they more or less came right out

0:36:04and said, yeah, well, it's, it's everything. It's the whole

0:36:06device. It's the neural engine size, but RAM definitely matters.

0:36:10And infamously, at least in tech circles, iPhones have been

0:36:15relatively starved of RAM, which it's more complex than just Tim

0:36:20Cook bean counting, right? Oh, add another $10 worth of RAM to

0:36:24each iPhone and it affects 1% of the profit margin or something

0:36:28like that. But every gigabyte of RAM you add to a device consumes

0:36:33electricity. Once you put RAM in a device, it always consumes

0:36:36electricity. More RAM adversely affects battery life. I don't

0:36:40know by how much like for six versus eight gigabytes. It's

0:36:44probably true that if like the A16 chips had two more gigs of

0:36:50RAM, it really wouldn't affect battery life that much. But you

0:36:55know, every little thing counts for battery life, right? Like

0:36:58I've spoken to people who work on the team at Apple, more or

0:37:02less the battery life team, which can kind of swoop into any

0:37:05project within the company. We've identified that this is a

0:37:09battery drain. It's hundreds and hundreds of little things that

0:37:13contribute to battery life and RAM is one of them. But basically

0:37:17it's it's undeniable at this point that it kind of looks like

0:37:20a little bit of an own goal that Apple didn't move iPhones to

0:37:24eight gigs of RAM a generation earlier at least.

0:37:27Well, yeah, and I don't think that it was malicious intent. I

0:37:32think it was frankly, probably, I mean, Apple's an enormous

0:37:35company. I do think that if everything is to be believed on

0:37:39how this kind of came to be that this Apple intelligence stuff

0:37:42has happened fairly recently. And it's likely that the iPhone

0:37:4715 generation of phones was already pretty much finalized by

0:37:51the time this really started getting steam, the teams are not

0:37:54the same team. So they're not really talking about the

0:37:57requirements. And so it kind of just came to be that I have no

0:38:00doubt that by the time the iPhone 15 went on sale last

0:38:03September, they knew it wasn't going to run Apple intelligence.

0:38:06But I'm not confident that they would have known that when they

0:38:08started development on the iPhone 15. So I think come this

0:38:12fall, if we see an iPhone 16, that still doesn't have eight

0:38:15gigs of RAM and can't do Apple intelligence. That's gonna be a,

0:38:19we should get mad at them. Yeah, yeah.

0:38:22What, what the hell's going on? Right? Yeah, yeah. Do you think

0:38:27that it's sort of maybe not a comedy of errors, but a sort of

0:38:32just unfortunate timing that it seems like Apple ran into not a

0:38:43like a hiccup with going to three nanometers at TSMC with

0:38:48the eight. So the a 17 Pro and the M three chips are Apple

0:38:53silicon on the first generation three nanometer process from TSMC

0:38:57and out over my skis here talking about this you but it's

0:39:02good that you're here much more you're you have much more

0:39:05informed opinions about this to me. But basically, that first

0:39:09generation three nanometer process is expensive. And it's

0:39:13probably why the eighth, the regular iPhone 15 are using the

0:39:21a 16 chip from the year before. And maybe I that's what I was

0:39:26getting at with JJ's answer that maybe from his perspective, he

0:39:30doesn't really see from a software perspective, the iPhone

0:39:3315 isn't nine months old, it's two years old, because it's

0:39:37that's the silicon. Yeah, it's it's possible. I think. Yeah,

0:39:44it's tricky. Apple has been the kind of number one purchaser of

0:39:49silicon from TSMC. Much of it is you've got to have the money and

0:39:53you got to get in line to get the ticket deals and the kind of

0:39:57the fabbing room that that you need. So I think they kind of

0:40:01had to move to n three e by necessity. However, it is a bit

0:40:07of a bummer kind of a black guy, in the sense that not that it

0:40:11was a bum process, but it was expensive. It didn't really

0:40:16yield the expectations and performance that people had come

0:40:20to expect. And we don't really know the yields. TSMC doesn't

0:40:24talk about it. Apple certainly doesn't talk about it. But I

0:40:27would suspect they're not very good. And every everything that

0:40:31you know, all the reports suggested it wasn't very good.

0:40:33And so it's hard to say that it was cynical. But I do think that

0:40:42they that it was unsurprising to me that they were not quick to

0:40:47put the a 17 Pro in the non pro iPhone just because of the

0:40:52amount of volume that the iPhone does. There literally may not

0:40:56have been the overhead to be able to do that. Now with the M

0:41:00for being on the new second generation and three process

0:41:03from TSMC, I really expect that to come to the to the iPhone

0:41:08this year. I'm still not confident that some of the

0:41:12features of the a 17 Pro I mean, they gave the chip name Pro

0:41:17right that they'll come down to some of the iPhone 16 stuff. So

0:41:21one example is like the a 17 Pro has an onboard USB three

0:41:25controller. The iPhone 15 famously does not support USB

0:41:29three or Thunderbolt, it's just USB two over USB C, I will be

0:41:35unsurprised, let's say, if a USB three controller does not make

0:41:39its way into the base model iPhone even with newer silicon.

0:41:42So I think they'll still find a way to kind of not fragment but

0:41:46to cost cut in order to hit those lower prices on the kind

0:41:51of the base model iPhone. But I do think that memory limitations

0:41:55and then kind of just generalized fab stuff is going to

0:41:59start to go away because TSMC new process is really good.

0:42:03Apparently, the yields are pretty good. And I would expect

0:42:05that to come kind of down to the rest of the lineup. I mean, look

0:42:08at the look of the M for its killer, right? Yeah, it was way

0:42:11more performant than anyone expected.

0:42:12Yeah, so hold that. Yeah, hold that thought. But let me let me

0:42:16just ask you to repeat that, though. Do you see you're

0:42:19saying, come September, when we get the iPhone 16, and the 16

0:42:24pros, you're not going to be surprised if the 16 get new

0:42:29silicon, which is almost certain whether it would be shocking if

0:42:32they're still on the ASX. I can't. But so yeah, but that

0:42:35their silicon won't have the quote unquote, pro level USB

0:42:40three. USB three. It feels funny to call pro Thunderbolt. You can

0:42:45call pro. Okay, sure. Sure. But you think that maybe it won't

0:42:48ship with that? I could see that too. Where they might not.

0:42:51Yeah, I think they'll both get an a 18 because the a 17 pro

0:42:55that's that's dead. That's old fat. They're not going to keep

0:42:57the name. But I wouldn't be surprised if we see an a 18 and

0:43:01then an a 18 Pro. And some of the distinguishing features are

0:43:05on die memory, which has always been a characteristic of the

0:43:08higher end chips, and then maybe goofy stuff like that USB speeds

0:43:13or Thunderbolt speeds. I don't think they would extend that to

0:43:16Wi Fi, but I suppose that's maybe a possibility to or maybe

0:43:19the pro chip gets Wi Fi seven and the other one sticks with

0:43:2260. I don't know. I wouldn't think so. But who knows?

0:43:24Yeah, but they definitely see the Thunderbolt stuff as a pro

0:43:29configuration. And they're all in and you've been documenting

0:43:32this with each keynote ever since they've started shooting

0:43:35them on iPhones last year. That's there. They really are

0:43:40dogfooding the iPhone 15 Pro camera as their camera. They've

0:43:45they've they've ever since they started, they've shot all of

0:43:48their keynotes using their own devices, which is kind of

0:43:52flabbergasting given what we know of their production quality

0:43:55standards.

0:43:56Yeah, especially with new apps like Final Cut camera and Final

0:44:01Cut for iPad two, which is the worst name ever. Yeah. I've had

0:44:07to that is a Microsoft name if I've ever heard.

0:44:10All right, this is this is we have to have an aside on this.

0:44:13The name of the product is Final Cut Pro for iPad two, which

0:44:18really sounds like it's made for 2011 iPad two. And we know

0:44:24again, it speaks to the human intuition that I was saying,

0:44:28we're not robots. So we know that Apple in 2024 did not just

0:44:35release Final Cut Pro for a 2011 iPad. But that sure is what

0:44:41this what it sounds like. It's like the those those grammar

0:44:44books, like eat shoots and leaves. It's, it needs

0:44:47rewriting. I would suggest Final Cut Pro for iPad version two.

0:44:53But yeah, I would go back in time and name it something fun,

0:44:57like Final Cut Go or something like that. Yeah, maybe I don't

0:45:01know. Because it's not really Final Cut Pro. Right. You tried

0:45:05using it, right? Yeah. I mean, I know. We're sort of over the

0:45:09place. And I couldn't really. So I bought the one terabyte and

0:45:13four iPad. The footage that we shoot here in studio is ProRes

0:45:18422, very large footage, the kind of compression ratio, it's

0:45:23very, very little. So it's this enormous amount of data. And

0:45:27you've got to manage the library size and the iPad in some

0:45:31instances wants to make proxy footage. It doesn't with ProRes

0:45:34because it plays back ProRes like butter and anything can

0:45:37now ProRes is a pretty awesome codec, if not very highly

0:45:41compressed. And I literally could not use Final Cut because

0:45:45even though I had a one terabyte iPad with almost nothing on it,

0:45:48I couldn't fit a single video's worth of video footage on the

0:45:51iPad, you couldn't use an external drive. Now with Final

0:45:54Cut Pro for iPad two, you can, however, it's still limited in

0:45:59some of the stuff that it can do. It doesn't have the entire

0:46:03feature set of the Mac variant of Final Cut. Now it does come

0:46:07pretty close, closer than you would think. But I think you

0:46:11would be hard pressed to find anybody that's seriously editing

0:46:14in Final Cut, that does not have a bunch of extensions and tools

0:46:19from third parties inside the NLE. And that's something that

0:46:23the iPad obviously does not support. So in that way, it's

0:46:29pretty much a no go still for me. But I think it's close

0:46:33enough that you can get 95% of the video done. You can keep it

0:46:37stored on an external drive now. And then when you get back to a

0:46:40Mac, you plug it into the Mac, you finish up the last 5%. The

0:46:43same story is kind of true with DaVinci Resolve for iPad, where

0:46:48Resolve is very odd, is they disabled a few of the tabs.

0:46:53DaVinci Resolve has a bunch of tabs, they have like cut tab, a

0:46:56color tab, a fairlight tab, which is their like compositor,

0:47:00their 3d rendering engine thing, actually, fairlight might be

0:47:03Adobe, in any case, it doesn't matter. They've got a bunch of

0:47:06different environments that you can use inside of this app. And

0:47:09in typical DaVinci, I should say, maybe say a non Apple

0:47:13fashion, this is something Microsoft would do, it seems

0:47:16that they ported the entire app. So all of the functionality of

0:47:20DaVinci Resolve theoretically, is in the iPad version. But then

0:47:24from like the from a build level, they went in and disabled

0:47:30a bunch of those pages that didn't work very well on the

0:47:32iPad. But what they didn't disable was keyboard work

0:47:36arounds that you can use to pull those pages back up. So you can

0:47:39open up DaVinci Resolve for iPad and open up panels that they

0:47:43specifically closed because they don't run very well on the iPad,

0:47:46because it is the full desktop app on the iPad, it's the whole

0:47:49thing. It just doesn't do certain stuff, because it's

0:47:53missing components because of the way that iOS sandbox

0:47:56required for it to work. So the 3d kind of the modeling engine

0:48:01where you can do VFX stuff, that's all available, it just

0:48:04doesn't do anything, you can go in and push all the buttons and

0:48:07just nothing happens because the underlying code is not there on

0:48:10the iPad and or can't run. But I was able to re enable a bunch of

0:48:14the tabs that by default were shut off. I don't know why.

0:48:17Because the iPad and I'm guessing it was for overhead on

0:48:21older iPads, but now with the M four worked great. And I edited

0:48:25a full video doing everything I normally would have done on a

0:48:29Mac on the iPad, like legitimately 100% worked

0:48:32awesome.

0:48:33Huh? That's really interesting. And it is true, that is very much

0:48:37sort of a taste of traditional PC software development on on

0:48:43the iPad of Yep. You know, and I am not a DaVinci Resolve user in

0:48:48any way, but I've seen it in demos. And it is sort of, you

0:48:53know, it's obviously written in some kind of cross platform way

0:48:56where it doesn't run as a regular Mac app, it runs sort of

0:49:00in a rectangle, it has its own menu bar. So like the actual Mac

0:49:04menu bar just has two commands like quit. Yeah, it's gotten a

0:49:08lot better. But originally, like I started using resolve with

0:49:11DaVinci resolve 15, I think, which probably came out at this

0:49:14point, five years ago on the Mac. And resolve was originally

0:49:18an app for Linux, because they use it in Hollywood in these

0:49:22air gapped machines that are running like Red Hat Linux that

0:49:25you know, it's so they did this initial kind of port to Mac OS

0:49:30and Windows. But they were such rudimentary reports that in

0:49:34order to quit the app, there was no system level quit command. So

0:49:37you couldn't command queue, you had to hit the close button in

0:49:40the top right of the window, of course, because that's where

0:49:43where Linux and Windows had put it. And so it was really janky.

0:49:48It's gotten much better over the years, but you still open it and

0:49:51you think to yourself, yeah, this is not a Mac or an iPad

0:49:55first app, that's for sure.

0:49:56Right. And the the diehard, native Mac asked Mac app

0:50:02proponent in me, objects, objects to that on the surface,

0:50:06but I totally get how at the extreme ends of professional

0:50:10software, that's where you tend to run into this type of app.

0:50:14And I do appreciate that it if it really is not really a Mac

0:50:19app, and they're not deeply or even shallow, we use using app

0:50:24kit, the Mac only application framework, you really can sort

0:50:28of just recompile it for iPad, and it just runs in a rectangle

0:50:31on the iPad.

0:50:32Yeah. And to be fair to resolve, they've spent a black magic has

0:50:36spent a bunch of time making sure that it uses the video

0:50:42engines that are available on Apple silicon, it's not running

0:50:44some janky ported OpenGL that Adobe did for a long time, like

0:50:49this is native uses metal, and all of the API frameworks that

0:50:54Apple supports just in an app that's quite ugly and on Apple,

0:50:57but it's one of the reasons why you can export a video at crazy

0:51:01lightning fast speeds in super high resolution from really high

0:51:04resolution source footage on a freaking iPad, and it works

0:51:08great. It's so cool.

0:51:10It's also a reason why Apple likes to show it to the media as

0:51:14whether it's for the Mac or the iPad, even though it's not you

0:51:17typically, oh, this doesn't really look like a great Mac or

0:51:21iPad app is a big red X against his Apple going to use this as a

0:51:25demo. But when it does amazing things with amazing performance,

0:51:30because it's taking advantage of metal and really using the

0:51:34Apple silicon GPUs to the full extent that they're possibly can

0:51:37be used, then Apple's like, yeah, we'd like to show this off

0:51:40even if don't look at it.

0:51:42I don't know if there's a better example of a pro app than

0:51:44resolve.

0:51:45On the iPad, do you get to use the menu bar because the menu

0:51:50bar is their own?

0:51:51Yes and no. So they've put some of the menu bars into more

0:51:55iPad esque sub menus. So they have moved the UI around a

0:52:00little bit, but not much. There's like this home button

0:52:04that takes you back to the main project window that's that's

0:52:06available inside of the desktop version of resolve. But yeah,

0:52:10you can tap a project. There's a little kind of triple dot

0:52:13thing. And if you click that with your mouse cursor, a big

0:52:15sub menu pops up and you can go into a full windowed settings

0:52:19menu pane that you would see on the desktop. So effectively,

0:52:23yeah, I mean, you can, you can get access to, and because much

0:52:27of what they've done to make it feel more iPad esque is they've

0:52:31disabled some of the stuff that is ugly and they've moved them

0:52:35into more iPad looking sub menus, but all of that stuff is

0:52:37still there because the code base hasn't changed. And so

0:52:40you can use hotkeys that you're used to using on the desktop

0:52:43and it'll pull up some janky looking menu that doesn't fit

0:52:47well at all on the iPad, but it's there and it still is

0:52:50functional. So anything you can do on resolve on the Mac, save

0:52:54for kind of the, the compositing stuff you can do on the iPad.

0:52:56And it might be ugly, but it works and it's pretty cool.

0:53:00Yeah. It seems sort of like a poster child for some of these

0:53:03arguments that we collectively have been having about the iPad

0:53:07as a pro machine. It's well here, if you took this pro software

0:53:10and just sort of let it be its desktop self to the fullest

0:53:15extent possible, here's what it would be like. And it's kind of

0:53:19weird and kind of ugly in some certain ways, but maybe one of

0:53:23the most capable apps period on the iPad. Yeah. And I think

0:53:27there is an argument to be had about, I think if Apple had

0:53:31their way, they would go to Blackmagic and say, Hey, we

0:53:33love the functionality and the power of this app. Let's spruce

0:53:36it up visually a little bit. Let's maybe move some stuff

0:53:38around. So it doesn't feel there's even like weird scaling

0:53:41issues where some of the text is really small. Cause again,

0:53:44it's just some lazy, I don't want to say lazy port, but it

0:53:46is, it's kind of a lazy port, but I feel like part of what

0:53:50makes it so compelling for people that are using this type

0:53:53of app is that it is DaVinci resolve. It's not some weird

0:53:55iPad version of DaVinci resolve. It's the app that I use

0:53:58on my Mac. And so I don't have to relearn a new user

0:54:01interface. I don't have to think to myself, where did they

0:54:03hide that thing? That's not in the sub menu it's normally in.

0:54:06Can the iPad even do that? It just, if you can do it on the

0:54:09Mac, you can do it on the iPad. And for certain apps like that,

0:54:12that might be the way to go, honestly.

0:54:14Yeah. And that it just to sort of wrap up the point that the

0:54:19M4 appearing last month in the new iPad pros was definitely a

0:54:23surprise. And I, sir, I infamously wrote like when

0:54:27Gurman reported on it, I don't know, this doesn't sound right

0:54:30to me. It just based on their schedule, but it really in

0:54:33hindsight, it makes sense because of what we were talking

0:54:35about with the TSMC fabrication and that if it does, if the

0:54:40yields were too low, and therefore yields being low makes

0:54:43it more expensive. If it was expensive to start, and the

0:54:47yields were low, it explains why only one iPhone got the A17

0:54:51Pro. It explains why Apple was more or less in a rush to go

0:54:55from the M3 to the M4. They are a by all accounts, because

0:54:59WWDC has come and gone. They are going to skip the M3

0:55:04generation for the Mac Studio and yep, no ultras for the M3

0:55:10and wait for the M4. And it's really about getting to that

0:55:14second generation three nanometer process. And so yeah,

0:55:18I would be flabbergasted if all the new iPhone 16s aren't

0:55:23using, I guess I'm guessing the names will be A18, maybe

0:55:28A18 Bionic, I don't know. Maybe. And A18 Pro for the Pro chips.

0:55:34And maybe they'll just be binned that there'll be more GPUs.

0:55:38I don't know what the differences will be, but I would

0:55:41anticipate that they didn't just introduce the A17 Pro name

0:55:45for one year. So I guess A18, A18 Pro. But I think the other

0:55:51thing is also going back to all of this Apple intelligence

0:55:56being revealed by Apple almost unprecedentedly early by Apple

0:56:02standards means that maybe this device cutoff doesn't matter

0:56:07that much anyway, because a lot of this stuff they're already

0:56:12saying won't even come in developer betas till later this

0:56:15summer. All of the features in Apple intelligence are at the

0:56:19earliest later this year. And they've already said even come

0:56:25fall when the new OSs are out, the Apple intelligence features

0:56:30will still be called beta. That once iOS 18 comes out and you

0:56:35can just install iOS 18 on your phone, at whatever pace they

0:56:40roll out the features of Apple intelligence, they're going to

0:56:43ship as beta apparently, even when you're not running a beta

0:56:47version of the OS. And some of the features they're even saying

0:56:50next year, so it won't come till 18.3 or 18.4 early next year or

0:56:57something like that. So by the time a lot of these features come

0:57:01out, it won't just be the A15 Pro, there'll be all of the A16

0:57:05phones too. And if we really think that this is all a year

0:57:10ahead of time, mostly, we're really talking about like for a

0:57:14lot of people, it may not be till the iPhone 17s come out.

0:57:19A year and a half from now, when people really start, you

0:57:24know, again, to overuse the metaphor, but there's kind of

0:57:27skating to where the puck is going, not where it is right

0:57:30now. And this, I don't think this will be that big a deal

0:57:34that the cutoff is so limited right now in terms of hardware.

0:57:38I agree. I think that Apple intelligence is very much not a

0:57:43singular product, it's a platform, and that we're going

0:57:46to continue to see new features added and new capabilities for

0:57:50years to come. I mean, this is, I wouldn't be surprised if in

0:57:53future WWDC keynotes, we almost get an Apple intelligence

0:57:56section independent of, you know, as if it were its own

0:58:00operating system kind of platform in many ways. Yeah, in

0:58:03many ways, it somewhat will be. The other thing, I don't

0:58:06actually think this is going to happen. But I, I thought it

0:58:09would be interesting, perhaps to postulate. Apple still

0:58:14doesn't really have any usage data on any of this stuff. They

0:58:16don't really know what users are going to be most interested in

0:58:20or what will be used the most. I'm sure they have ideas

0:58:23because many of these features still exist, or many of these

0:58:25features do exist in other, you know, AI company products. But

0:58:30I wouldn't be surprised perhaps if this private cloud compute

0:58:34functionality makes its way to some older devices via iCloud

0:58:40Plus, if there's a way for them to use services, or to increase

0:58:45services revenue by bringing maybe some, it's not going to do

0:58:48everything, but some of these simpler AI features that don't

0:58:51run on device to older devices, and it just comes with the

0:58:54gotcha of, well, it's going through the cloud, it's going to

0:58:57take a minute, but it can still do the thing. I wouldn't be

0:59:01surprised if that happens next year, sometime into the future.

0:59:04Yeah, I, because that's, and I mentioned it in my write up that

0:59:09I published last night, that perhaps the most common question

0:59:15I've been asked after WWDC, and I think it's a super

0:59:18interesting, very, very good question is, okay, if they've

0:59:23got stuff on device and the on device stuff is limited to the

0:59:27iPhone 15 Pro and later, but they've also got private cloud

0:59:31compute, why not just do everything through private cloud

0:59:35compute on older phones? And I think it's, I think, I, I wish I

0:59:43had asked a question along those lines on stage, because I,

0:59:47because I think it's actually a really good topic. And I think

0:59:50they might have said some interesting things about it. But

0:59:53I also kind of think they may not want to talk about some of

0:59:56the reasons and I, I, I, but like you said, I can't help but

1:00:00think that maybe they will expand that and that they might

1:00:04expand both things, right? Obviously, as time goes on,

1:00:07they're going to do more stuff on device five or six years from

1:00:10now, they'll be doing way more on device than they are now,

1:00:14because the devices will be five or six years into the future in

1:00:18terms of performance and memory and stuff like that. But I also

1:00:21wouldn't be surprised once they get confidence and scaling and

1:00:26know how much computational power private cloud compute

1:00:30takes, that they'll expand what private cloud compute can do,

1:00:34too, maybe by bringing it to other devices. But I can't help

1:00:39but think that part of the reason for this iPhone 15 Pro

1:00:41cutoff, in addition to the RAM and the neural engine size and

1:00:44everything is they just want to minimize the initial onrush of

1:00:51traffic. They, they don't know how it's going to scale. They

1:00:55obviously have a, they have a theory as to how it's going to

1:00:57scale. But I don't think anybody really knows how anything will

1:01:01scale until you flip the switch and go live.

1:01:03And I think maybe one technical reason that could be given this

1:01:07seems like the answer maybe jaws would give. I don't know if it's

1:01:12a technical reason or but it's one that I've heard postulated

1:01:15that does make sense is Apple intelligence isn't just the AI

1:01:21model that actually does the thing you want it to do. It's

1:01:23also this kind of, you know, intent engine that's supposed to

1:01:28understand, okay, what's the thing that wants to be

1:01:30performed. And if there's some reason, perhaps technically,

1:01:33that devices with not enough memory or whatever can't even do

1:01:35that part, where they don't even know what is being asked of it.

1:01:40And we don't want to just send everything to the cloud,

1:01:42because that's the whole point of Apple intelligence that it

1:01:44only sends what's required and that it's deleted right after if

1:01:48it can't even do that part of what does the user want to have

1:01:51happen, then how can it do the rest of the AI stuff that maybe

1:01:55is one rationale. But yeah, I don't know, it does seem like an

1:01:59opportunity to get a bunch of services revenue out of people

1:02:03into the future because people buying. I mean, Apple knows the

1:02:06average upgrade cycle of iPhones, it's several years now.

1:02:09And there's a lot of people that have bought iPhone 15 that might

1:02:12subscribe to iCloud plus or something if image generation,

1:02:17for example, could be done in the cloud, but they're not going

1:02:19to go buy a brand new phone, they'll just wait three or four

1:02:22years till they go buy their next upgrade, you know, so

1:02:26I had to double check, but it is true. And I guess it makes

1:02:29sense, given that it is LLM generative image generation, but

1:02:35Genmoji is part of Apple intelligence and therefore

1:02:38subject to these device limitations, right? And and yeah,

1:02:44it is, again, I don't blame Apple because they had so much

1:02:47to announce. But in the structure of the keynote,

1:02:51everything in the first hour isn't part of Apple

1:02:54intelligence until they mentioned Apple intelligence,

1:02:56like an hour and five minutes into it, and started the second

1:03:00half of the keynote. All those previous features are available

1:03:03to other devices, the whole math notes thing, which is so fun

1:03:07and super cool, goes back to every device that's eligible

1:03:11for iOS 18. So whatever the earliest cutoff is for an iPhone

1:03:15that can run iOS 18, you can do math notes on it. The

1:03:19handwriting match feature, they call it smart match, I think,

1:03:23or smart script. Smart script is their name for it, which in

1:03:26my testing so far isn't really doing a great job at my

1:03:30handwriting. It is making my handwriting more legible, but

1:03:33it's also to me not recognizable as my handwriting. But still,

1:03:37I think any improvement over my really bad handwriting is,

1:03:42but that's coming to every iPhone or iPad, obviously,

1:03:47because it requires a pencil, A14 or later, and I forget

1:03:51where the cutoff, but that's pretty reasonable. That's a

1:03:53couple of years worth of iPads. But they definitely, I think,

1:04:02left people confused because they announced so much at once

1:04:05as to which devices are going to get any of these features

1:04:08and which devices aren't. And I just don't know how much

1:04:12better job they could do by trying to have one two hour

1:04:16keynote that covered all of this.

1:04:17Ben

1:04:26features come and part of me suspects that even they are not

1:04:31fully entirely sure yet. I mean, they've Yeah, what exists in

1:04:34the beta today? That's obviously, you know, that's part

1:04:37of iOS 18 or iPad OS 18. But much of the kind of Apple

1:04:41Intelligency stuff, I wouldn't be surprised. I mean, so one

1:04:44other example, like this image playgrounds app, where you can

1:04:47go in and make whatever photo you want, that's all running on

1:04:50device, right? So that's not in the cloud right now, as far as

1:04:53I'm aware. But I don't know. I really thought that they're

1:04:58done on device. I think they're I think Jen Moji might be on

1:05:02device, but the image playground is not. But they also

1:05:06they have been made to their credit. They behind the scenes

1:05:11and briefings when I asked, Are you going to show what's local

1:05:14what's remote? And they said, there's going to be a log you

1:05:18can look at. And we'll show you when it went to private cloud

1:05:22compute, but they're not going to show it in the interface,

1:05:24whether it's going remote or not. And they're not talking

1:05:28about which features are which because they just fully admitted

1:05:30we don't know yet. And we reserve the right even after we

1:05:35ship and come out of beta, we're going to be constantly all the

1:05:38time. Sure. Okay, so well, then that's maybe a better argument.

1:05:42Much of the kind of image playground stuff is context

1:05:46based, right? So they showed in the keynote, oh, hey, it's mom's

1:05:50birthday. And yeah, who knows that. And so it generated this

1:05:53image in the messages app. Don't bring that because that requires

1:05:56Apple intelligence. But why couldn't you just bring a basic

1:05:59image playgrounds app where you can go in and there's no

1:06:01contextual, no smart suggestions that they have. It's just like,

1:06:05Hey, picture of Brenda on top of a mountain or whatever. And it

1:06:10could do that all in the cloud, you would think that would be

1:06:12something fairly easy, because that's something that, well,

1:06:15basically, every image generation service already does.

1:06:19And maybe that would be Apple's reasoning as well. Just go use

1:06:22something else. But seems like money left on the table. I don't

1:06:25know how

1:06:25funny would it be if Genmoji is the feature that drives people

1:06:29to like, okay, I was gonna wait another year or two to get an

1:06:32iPhone, but I've got to get a new iPhone because it may got it.

1:06:34It cracks me up. And I know this for a fact that Apple, I

1:06:40forget if Apple has a say in world emoji J day, or I know

1:06:45Apple is, they're influential across the industry, but they're

1:06:49particularly influential in the emoji world. Because they're

1:06:53Apple and that's where people they're sort of Apple's emoji

1:06:56set is sort of the de facto baseline standard that all other

1:07:01emoji sets are compared against. But I know that Apple times

1:07:07their release of new emoji, the like here, the inner the Unicode

1:07:14consortiums new emoji of the year are out and we're going to

1:07:18unveil our versions of the new emoji. They always wait until

1:07:22iOS 7, usually right. Point one or point two. And it's, it's the

1:07:26one that they think, Oh, this is the one that's really stable.

1:07:30And that's when they start hitting the button that pushes

1:07:33the pushes the updates to people, right? So if you're just

1:07:36a typical iPhone user with default settings, which include

1:07:41okaying to automatic app store updates and automatic OS updates,

1:07:48hey, Apple. And I think that's the right way to go. I turn that

1:07:52stuff off. I like to upgrade all my stuff manually. I'm sure you

1:07:55do too. Right. But I get why they want typical users to say,

1:08:02let, let Apple handle when my device will update. They don't

1:08:06update people to iOS 17.0 automatically. They usually wait

1:08:11till point one, sometimes point two, but that's also when they

1:08:14do the new emoji because they want people to upgrade and they

1:08:18know that people I've spoken to people at Apple. They're like,

1:08:21yes, emoji prompts people to update they, and especially once

1:08:25they get a text message from somebody else who's updated

1:08:28using one of the new emoji, they're like, wait, I can't see

1:08:31that. Square. Yeah. You have to update and they're like, okay,

1:08:36I'm going to go update right now. Yeah. Be very funny. And

1:08:39even Jen, the driver as an, it very well could be as silly as

1:08:44it was like an emoji when it shipped with the iPhone 10 that

1:08:48was mocked by tons of people and everyone thought this is so

1:08:51stupid. And that was a huge driver. I think in interest of

1:08:56the iPhone didn't mean everyone went out and bought an iPhone 10,

1:08:58but it was, I mean, it was probably my vote, my most viral

1:09:02piece of content I've ever made. I made a, with an iPhone 10, I

1:09:05made like a quote unquote Apple ad in the same style that you'd

1:09:09find on TV. And I did an animoji dub to Gasolina from daddy

1:09:14Yankee. And I think that got, I think that got like 250 million

1:09:20views on Twitter or something. Oh my God. It was like the

1:09:23number one tweet for a couple of days. And so I think that kind

1:09:26of stuff as goofy as it is legitimately does drive real

1:09:30interest. I don't know that it sells a bunch of phones, but it

1:09:33definitely sells some of them. Yeah. I will say before we leave

1:09:37the subject, I will say that I would say the least impressive

1:09:41thing Apple showed in all of Apple intelligence to me was the

1:09:45image playground app, just because it looked like every

1:09:50other image, Jen thing I've seen. It, it, it seemed like the

1:09:55one thing in all of the announcements that didn't Apple

1:10:00wasn't bringing anything to the table in my opinion. Yeah. No.

1:10:03And I actually think that it looked worse than many services.

1:10:08It looked like several versions, old of Dolly. And part of that

1:10:11is because of, and it was an intentional decision, this kind

1:10:15of cartoonish art style they wanted. They don't want photo

1:10:18realism, but on the same hand, we didn't look at those and go,

1:10:23Oh, this is Pixar level. You're like, yeah, that's a, that's a

1:10:26weird AI image. And even in some of the images they showed in the

1:10:29keynote, which are obviously handpicked. I mean, there's a

1:10:32probably the best that they produce. There's still weird

1:10:35stuff. If you look close at them, there's like weird finger

1:10:37stuff going on and hair that goes through parts of the torso

1:10:41at some point. I mean, it's still very much a high image.

1:10:45And there's a picture of a woman that they've used in

1:10:48several, I might even be in the newsroom post. It's like a white

1:10:52woman probably in her in real life, forties or fifties. And

1:10:56it's kind of unflattering to her. It's, she's got crows feet

1:11:00around her eyes. It's almost the opposite of what you would want,

1:11:04right? You kind of, if you're the boardwalk caricaturist,

1:11:08you're supposed to make the person look exaggerated. Like

1:11:11they're going to give me a big nose because I have a big nose,

1:11:14but not in an unflattering way, right? That's the trick. It's,

1:11:18Oh, we'll give the John's caricature is going to have a

1:11:21real big nose, but we're still going to make them look pretty

1:11:23good. And a little younger than he really is, right? You don't

1:11:26make somebody look older. Yeah. Like I didn't wear your eye

1:11:31cream the night before. Yeah. And you wait, that's, there's

1:11:33going to be controversy behind that because they're just

1:11:36grappling with the stuff that everybody's grappled with. So

1:11:38even within these, these walls and parameters that they've

1:11:40set of, we're not doing photo realism, we don't, there's

1:11:44definitely going to be a bunch of keywords that it just

1:11:46refuses to generate images on, but you wait, I mean, it's

1:11:49going to mess up people's skin tones and it's gonna, it's just

1:11:53going to do the stuff that AI images do. And Apple's not

1:11:56immune to that. And proof of that is kind of the images they

1:12:00demoed, which again, like you said, we're awesome. Yeah.

1:12:03Yeah. And with the words, the language stuff, they're not

1:12:08letting you prompt, right there. So you don't get to say,

1:12:13write me a cover letter for a job I want to apply for. You

1:12:17write a cover letter and then you select the text and say,

1:12:20make this sound more professional or proofread it, right?

1:12:23I'm real, I personally, I'm very intrigued by the proofreading.

1:12:26I don't, I, I'm stubborn and I think of myself very well as a

1:12:33writer, so I'm not really looking to have my own prose

1:12:36rewritten in a different tone, but the proofreading I would

1:12:41love if it works well. I certainly appreciate, I have long

1:12:44appreciated spell checking, automatic red underlines of

1:12:48Save My Bacon, I was going to say thousands, probably tens of

1:12:52thousands of times since I've been writing Daring Fireball.

1:12:56So I would love the proofreading part as a one person show who

1:12:59does his own proofreading, but you don't get to say, write me a

1:13:03cover letter or write me a very inappropriate story about X, Y,

1:13:09and Z. You don't get to say that. So what they're saying is

1:13:13they don't, and again, what they're saying to me is the

1:13:16exact attitude I would like Apple to have, which is we're

1:13:19not going to give you a full prompt where you can ask for

1:13:24inappropriate stuff, but if you write something yourself and

1:13:28ask the system to proofread it or to change the tone, it will.

1:13:34So if you write an inappropriate story, an R-rated or X-rated

1:13:39story, select it and ask for it to be made funnier, it should

1:13:43still do it. That's what they're saying, which I think is the

1:13:47right way to go, in the same way that you could always just

1:13:51open text edit and use text edit to create the instructions for

1:13:56making a homemade pipe bomb, right?

1:13:58Pete: Sure, totally.

1:13:59Pete; You know, though, that there's going to be stories,

1:14:01you know. I wrote an X-rated story about a kindergarten

1:14:06teacher and look what Apple's AI engine helped me polish it

1:14:11up, right? It's kind of on you, but with the image playgrounds,

1:14:14it is just a prompt. I don't know.

1:14:17Pete; You can type anything in there.

1:14:19Pete; So I feel like, I don't know, again, Apple doesn't talk

1:14:23about their internal debates, but I have to think that that

1:14:26was sort of a, hmm, do we want to, do we want to even do this

1:14:31and let alone announce it now or not?

1:14:32Pete; Yeah, and it'll be interesting to see what happens

1:14:37because there's definitely things that you can, an example I

1:14:42used in one of my videos is, and this is much of what's hard

1:14:46is, again, understanding the intent of the language. So

1:14:49putting into image playgrounds, emoji with Hitler mustache is

1:14:53probably going to result in, yeah, no, we're not doing that.

1:14:56But if you did emoji, little black square above lip, is that

1:15:01something that the system will recognize and say, no, no,

1:15:04we're not doing that. Or will it just go ahead and, it's going

1:15:06to be fascinating and you wait, there are going to be people

1:15:09that are going to try to break it in any way they can to get

1:15:12it to do stuff that, you know, but…

1:15:14Pete; I forget the comedian, but there's a comedian who has

1:15:17a great bit. It might be John Mulaney, but it doesn't matter,

1:15:21but it's about the Michael Jordan Hanes commercials from

1:15:25like the 90s where Jordan had a, quite frankly, sort of

1:15:29Hitler-esque mustache. And they're like, Michael Jordan was

1:15:32so big that Hanes didn't even say anything when he was

1:15:35supporting. So I can see like, here's a picture of Michael

1:15:38Jordan from 1997 Hane commercial with, give me an emoji

1:15:43with a mustache like his here. And now you've backwards

1:15:46engineered your prompt way into a Hitler mustache.

1:15:49Pete; Right. So that's where they're going to have to battle

1:15:52with stuff. And I think, and this is one thing that I believe

1:15:57Craig said on your show was that they had established a bunch

1:16:01of kind of principles of what are we going to let users do?

1:16:05What's the system going to do? And one of the things that

1:16:08they really had a big focus on according to them was that they

1:16:11were going to respect the user's intent. Isn't that the way

1:16:14they phrased it or something? Which, I mean, that's a big

1:16:17deal. And that would suggest that maybe it will do stuff

1:16:21that is unsavory if you are unsavory and that's what you

1:16:25intend for it to do. But yeah.

1:16:27Pete; Well, and then it raises other uncomfortable questions

1:16:31for Apple because when you think of inappropriate topics,

1:16:34you obviously think of stuff that would get a movie to be R

1:16:37rated or X rated. You think of violence, you think of

1:16:41sexuality, but then what about writing about Tiananmen Square?

1:16:46It would, to me, be absolutely outrageous if they give you,

1:16:51"Sorry, I can't help with that," outside mainland China for

1:16:56asking for help writing a report on the Tiananmen Square

1:17:01massacre. Obviously, though, if,

1:17:04and when, Apple intelligence comes to mainland China, you're

1:17:07obviously not going to get help asking for rewrite proofreading

1:17:13help on a report about Tiananmen Square, right? There's

1:17:16other topics like that that are sensitive to Apple in ways

1:17:22because of their business interests in China in particular

1:17:25that presumably that they're not going to, you're not going

1:17:29to notice that as somebody who isn't in mainland China, but

1:17:33it's something I look forward to trying as soon as I get my

1:17:36hands on this?

1:17:36Yeah, it'll be interesting. That's just the whole

1:17:41boondoggle of AI, I suppose.

1:17:42All right, let me take another break here and thank our

1:17:45second sponsor of the show, and it is our good friends at

1:17:49Squarespace. You can go, I'll spoil the ending right here,

1:17:53go to squarespace.com/talkshow and you can save 10% off your

1:17:58first purchase of a website or domain. Look, what is

1:18:01Squarespace? Squarespace is the all in one service for

1:18:07building your presence online. Everything from domain name

1:18:12registration to templates to choose from for designing your

1:18:16website to adding features to your website, hosting a

1:18:20podcast, hosting a blog, selling stuff on online, whether

1:18:24it's like t-shirts or other goods that you ship to people or

1:18:28selling your time as a professional, like a consultant

1:18:31or a trainer or something like that. You can do it all on

1:18:34Squarespace. They handle everything from the commerce to

1:18:37the SEO to the analytics to see how people are getting to

1:18:42your website. They've got checkouts that are made as

1:18:46seamless as possible, powerful payment tools. You can accept

1:18:49everything from credit cards to PayPal, Apple Pay, of

1:18:52course. And in eligible countries, you can even offer

1:18:55stuff to buy now, pay later with features like Afterpay

1:18:59and ClearPay. The Fluid Engine is their next generation

1:19:03content website editor. I still call it new. It's from within

1:19:07the last year, but it's a major rewrite of the system that

1:19:11lets you design your website on even on your phone. You can

1:19:15actually just go on your phone, log into Squarespace and do

1:19:18the drag and drop stuff to rejigger your website right on

1:19:20the phone. It all works great. Email campaigns, they've got

1:19:24that built into the system too. So for email marketing tools

1:19:27or for setting up your own newsletter, you can do it all

1:19:29through Squarespace. If you can do it on the internet, you can

1:19:32do it through Squarespace. Go to squarespace.com/talkshow.

1:19:36You get a free trial for 30 days, no watermarks, no limits,

1:19:40just the full Squarespace experience for 30 days. And

1:19:44when you're ready to launch, just remember that same

1:19:46domain, squarespace.com/talkshow, and you will save 10%

1:19:50off your first purchase of a website or domain. My thanks to

1:19:54Squarespace. Maybe lightning round, dig through the

1:19:58announcements for the platforms, which I think it's fair to say

1:20:03and Adam, this isn't even really a complaint, but I think it

1:20:07kind of shows that the company's focus is very largely diverted

1:20:12to Apple intelligence this year, that the non-Apple

1:20:16intelligence features are thinner than most years. But

1:20:22again, I don't know that that's a complaint. I feel like maybe

1:20:24some years they sort of pile on tent pole features just for the

1:20:31sake of having something to put in the keynote. I don't know.

1:20:34Yeah. Some of them, I mean, I don't know how numerous they

1:20:38are, but it feels like at least a few of them have been things

1:20:41that people have wanted forever. So that way it was kind

1:20:45of a big year, like home screen customization. Yeah. Which is

1:20:48what they led with, right? They led with that. Yeah. Control

1:20:52center. I think that's another big change. Control center has

1:20:55been a pile of garbage to put it nicely for quite some time and

1:21:00this new one promises to be much better. So. My theory with

1:21:06control center is that I feel like the iPhone evolved in a

1:21:12kind of curious way that I that I at least didn't notice until

1:21:20recently, but in hindsight, it sort of feels like, huh. It was

1:21:24sort of a slow boil there. I can't say that there was one

1:21:27particular year where it switched, but the iPhone evolved

1:21:32from when it debuted even Apple thinking of it like pre iPhone

1:21:39phones where a phone is more like it's not part of your

1:21:42personal computer life and you don't think about locking it

1:21:47down. I mean, famously Steve Jobs spent tons of time and

1:21:52everybody loved it. Just the slide to unlock right. It's

1:21:56like this beautiful. It was a beautiful metal looking 3D

1:22:01thing and it tracked the little thing that you slid to unlock

1:22:04tracked your finger perfectly, but there was no passcode

1:22:09right. II think even in the original iPhone, you could set a

1:22:14passcode just because even yeah, even dumb phones used to

1:22:17let you do that too right. You could just buy like a flip

1:22:20phone and have it so that you have to type a code or

1:22:22something to be able to use it, but it's clearly some default

1:22:26behavior right and the assumption was that most people

1:22:30would just not put a code on their phone and just slide to

1:22:33unlock. That's how I carried my phone for a few years at least

1:22:36and then it sort of dawned on everybody like hey all my

1:22:40emails in here. I'm logged into my bank and I guess most

1:22:44banking apps would make you put a pin in before touch ID and

1:22:47face ID, but there was a lot of stuff in your phone that you

1:22:50wouldn't want a stranger to have access to just by sliding

1:22:54a thing, but we kind of lost something by locking everything

1:23:01into face ID and everything and that there are things you just

1:23:04kind of want to tap into your phone and just quick do and

1:23:07that's sort of what control center is now. It's sort of like

1:23:10the thin private version of the iPhone experience that oh, you

1:23:16don't have to worry about locking people out of this. It's

1:23:17just right there. Just swipe down from the top and you can

1:23:20control your TV and change the volume, change the brightness,

1:23:24stuff like that. It's you know as opposed to, I don't know,

1:23:30it's just like conceptually heavier to go into your phone

1:23:35and start launching apps to do things. It's hey, let's just do

1:23:38this. The homestream customization thing. I think this

1:23:42is great. I don't plan to make heavy use of it. I don't plan to

1:23:48tint all of my icons in a certain color, but I totally

1:23:53understand why people do and it's I mentioned it on stage

1:23:56during my show like when I first got a Mac in college in the

1:24:0090s, I spent an inordinate amount of time in ResEdit just

1:24:03customizing the icons for my apps and folders just for the

1:24:06same reason. I just I don't know. I wanted to make my own

1:24:10icons and even though I'm not a very good icon designer, it was

1:24:13kind of cool to know that I did it myself and but I see people

1:24:19that it's always Steve Jobs would never right. Steve Jobs

1:24:24would never have allowed people to make their home screen ugly

1:24:27by tinting every single icon magenta. What I don't know that

1:24:34he wouldn't have because that it doesn't happen to anybody by

1:24:38accident, right? It's not oh if you shake your phone, it's like

1:24:42a slot machine and you know maybe you'll get a magenta

1:24:47home screen. You have to do that on purpose and if that's

1:24:50what you want to do, okay, so be it. So I think the complaints

1:24:54that that it allows you to make your home screen ugly to me.

1:25:00That's well then don't do it right. If you don't think

1:25:03magenta all magenta icons are ugly, then now you can do it.

1:25:06Yeah, one one parallel that made me think of it around the

1:25:11same time as WWDC. I had gone to the unveil event of the new

1:25:17generation of Rivian R1 vehicles and as part of the new

1:25:21generation of cars and they're bringing this retroactively.

1:25:25There's just ambient lighting that's been RGB controllable for

1:25:28years, but it's never been user controllable and in this new

1:25:32version, unlike Tesla where you can make it any garish color

1:25:35you they only have. I think it's nine colors that are

1:25:38acceptable to Rivian that you can select and so it's a very

1:25:41specific shade of green and a very muted hue of blue and and

1:25:47the designer said it's because we don't want people making

1:25:50their cars pink and on the one hand there was a laugh but on

1:25:53the other hand I was like if you're gonna let people

1:25:56customize it, let them do whatever they want and so that's

1:25:58kind of where I'm thinking here. If Apple were to say, oh,

1:26:01here's the colors or here's the formats in which you can

1:26:03customize your phone. Well, then it's not really customization

1:26:06is it so I think this is the only way they could have done

1:26:10it that I think this is a minimum basically of letting

1:26:14people make it however they want. It's still fairly limited

1:26:18in the grand scheme of things. You can't change the whole icon

1:26:20you know shape in the way that you could with ResEdit.

1:26:25Technically, there are still loopholes you can use through

1:26:27Widget Smith and theme packs and using shortcuts and all

1:26:31that stuff, but that's not a system level thing. That's still

1:26:33a weird kind of hack around way to do it, but as a base level

1:26:37customization is about as minimal as it gets and yeah,

1:26:41people are gonna make it ugly, but you gotta let them do it or

1:26:44let them not do it.

1:26:45And I the demand is clearly there the success of Widget

1:26:50Smith, the viral sensation of those TikTok videos from two

1:26:54years ago or so when it first became possible to make

1:26:57shortcuts with a custom icon that would launch the app so

1:27:02that you more or less like creating an alias to the app so

1:27:05that you could give it a custom icon. But what a huge advantage

1:27:09because with the old way of creating a shortcut with a

1:27:12custom icon for every app you use on your even if you only

1:27:15did your first home screen, you've got to set up 16 of them,

1:27:19put them in the right order. And if you get tired of the

1:27:22black and white monochromatic look and you really want to go

1:27:26magenta now you've got to do it all over again. Whereas this

1:27:29way you just bring up the slider and say switch from black

1:27:32and white to cyan or whatever color suits your mood for the

1:27:36day. I think that's pretty cool. One of the demos and I

1:27:39again I often even if the demo isn't particularly interesting,

1:27:44I always think it's an interesting insight into what

1:27:48Apple thinks is important or most used and the press hands

1:27:54on thing for watch OS 10. What number are we up to? Is it 10

1:27:58or 11?

1:27:5911 I think. 11. Yeah it'll be the 10th watch and 11th OS or

1:28:03something. But it was pretty much, well maybe not entirely.

1:28:07They did a lot of stuff with the vitals app too, but they've

1:28:10really were focusing on the photos watch face, which is the

1:28:14one where it picks one of your or you get to pick your photos

1:28:18and make a watch face based on your kids or your spouse or

1:28:23whatever pictures from your own library you want to use as a

1:28:27watch face. Clearly this is a super popular watch face. I

1:28:30mean they said so. They said this is like one of the most

1:28:33popular watch faces. And it does, I mean again we didn't get

1:28:39to do it hands on, but with the, and I don't think they're

1:28:43calling it Apple intelligence, but they're definitely using

1:28:45machine learning. So it's coming to all of them. Right. And I

1:28:48guess the watch doesn't count for Apple intelligence because

1:28:50it doesn't have a A series or M series chip. But using machine

1:28:56learning to pick photos that are particularly well suited to

1:29:00the aspect ratio of the watch, and then using the machine

1:29:05learning to pick where in the frame would it be good to put

1:29:08the digital numerals like behind the head because the

1:29:11person has space on the right, or if with another picture,

1:29:14it's on the left. You get all of this assistance and it was

1:29:17Apple's demo, so it did work well, but it really was sort of

1:29:21like having a graphic designer helping you. Oh, this is great.

1:29:24And we could even put like the part of the minutes behind your

1:29:28head because there's space for that and we have the depth in

1:29:31the photo to do it. But if you want to customize it your own

1:29:35way and make it ugly, you're still free to. It's a good mix

1:29:39where automatically it tries to use machine learning to give

1:29:42you an attractive Apple style version of your photos. But if

1:29:46you want to make it garish, it's your watch. And that's the

1:29:51way it should be. Try to encourage you to make it look

1:29:55good. Allow you to make it look ugly. Yep. 100%. Let me see. I

1:30:01thought that the feature and again, it's one of those things

1:30:05where I would love to be in the meeting where they decided how

1:30:09to demo it. The hide an app from your phone feature and what

1:30:15was their example? It was Craig saying like a hairdryer app or

1:30:19something like that. Like a USB. It's like an AR hair app or

1:30:23something. I think. Right. Or hair kit. I don't remember.

1:30:27Because everybody's mind goes to apps that that somebody,

1:30:31whether you yourself might have apps you'd want to hide for

1:30:34whatever reason. And you know, I'm laughing but it's you know,

1:30:38could be there's all sorts of things. It could be something

1:30:43that's not funny at all like a help managing an addiction or

1:30:48something like that right. It's not just about like married

1:30:52people with the dating apps or something like that that you'd

1:30:56want to hide from your spouse, but it could be something like

1:30:58a medical type thing. I thought that was pretty clever and it.

1:31:05They showed it. I feel like in the keynote people were like

1:31:08well, but if they put it in a folder called hidden apps,

1:31:12isn't that where everybody will go? But the key is that the

1:31:16hidden apps folder has a generic icon that doesn't show what's

1:31:22inside it. So yes, you'll be able to go to somebody's phone

1:31:25and and in their app library, there is going to be a hidden

1:31:29apps folder, but you won't be able to get into it because

1:31:32your face won't do the face ID unlock and the icon for hidden

1:31:37apps isn't going to give you a hint as to which apps are

1:31:39inside hidden. It's you know. Moreover, it's it's there by

1:31:42default. So right. And if you don't have anything in there,

1:31:45it's still there. Yeah, exactly. So you you you don't know

1:31:48what's in there. It's sort of like I think it's generally

1:31:51considered best practice now, but if if like you go to your

1:31:55account page on a site and it's it says email, here's your

1:31:59email address password in it. It might show bullets, but the

1:32:04bullets don't correspond to the length of your password like it

1:32:08always shows eight bullets whether your passwords 20

1:32:10characters long or thirteen characters long. It just shows

1:32:14eight bullets so that it doesn't give you a hint what's in

1:32:16there right. Yeah. Seems like that sort of thing, but a cool

1:32:20feature. The mail categorization seems a little late. Frankly

1:32:27given the big big time big time if they can use Apple

1:32:31intelligence to do it more intelligently, then that's

1:32:34that's cool. I think the surfacing of kind of like

1:32:38contextually relevant stuff is kind of neat. So like yeah when

1:32:41it knows that you're on you're headed to the airport or it's

1:32:44the day of your flight. It resurfaces those emails. That's

1:32:47cool. But yeah, the basic categorization thing. I mean

1:32:50welcome to mailbox from 2013 or whenever that was. Alright.

1:32:55Wasn't that that was the app Google bought everybody loved

1:32:58it and then it just disappeared. I think so right that was yeah

1:33:01inbox and then yeah the first one was bought by Dropbox. I

1:33:05think that was the one that popularized it was that one.

1:33:08Oh, I forget email. I don't remember mailbox. Yeah. So

1:33:14Dropbox purchased it back in 2014. Never to be heard of

1:33:20again. Yep killed it a year later. Yeah. I'd never thought

1:33:24of it, but I do have to say it's one of those ideas where

1:33:27once I heard Fedor or whoever said it on the in the keynote,

1:33:31I was like, oh, that's brilliant. I wish I've had that

1:33:34for 15 years is in the list of emails. Don't just show me the

1:33:38first two lines of the email. Show me a two line summary of

1:33:42the email because so many emails the first two lines

1:33:46aren't helpful at all. It's so true. I've been irritated by

1:33:51that, but it never occurred to me that it's a problem that

1:33:53could be solved. I'm very much looking forward to that. I'm

1:33:58always a little surprised when Apple Mail is late to get

1:34:01certain features simply because I know how much Apple

1:34:05institutionally runs on mail. They are a very very heavily

1:34:09email driven company internally. So when and they all

1:34:14do use Apple Mail, it's always surprising to me when things

1:34:19like this are late. I love using my main mail is still on

1:34:23Gmail and the main reason why is that using Mime stream on

1:34:28my Mac, I get product or categorization of the email and

1:34:32it is such a game changer to have all your sales receipts

1:34:38and all the **** you get every time you buy something and

1:34:41even if you uncheck the box to send you promotional emails,

1:34:44they still send you some. It's like like send me no

1:34:48promotional emails means in the in modern ecommerce. Okay,

1:34:53maybe we'll send you fewer promotional emails, but having

1:34:56them out of my main inbox so that my main inbox is really

1:34:59just email from people emailing me is like it's like time

1:35:04travel to when I first got email in the 90s and email was

1:35:08nothing but joy like oh, I got new email. What is it? What I

1:35:12get? It's like getting a present every day. I love it,

1:35:15but it's hard hard not to say finally to that one. Let me see

1:35:20here from my notes. What else anything else stood out to you?

1:35:23I guess we should do photos on that's a big deal. Yeah. Have

1:35:27you looked at it in beta? I have of course it's the

1:35:31developer beta under NDA so I haven't used it, but if I had

1:35:33used it, I might say that you do. It's a it's an adjustment,

1:35:39but I think it's pretty well laid out. There will be some

1:35:42people that will be irritated if they're heavy albums users

1:35:45cuz they've moved albums that are user created to basically

1:35:48the very bottom of the page and there's there's some weird

1:35:52stuff like for example when you open up the app half of the

1:35:55display shows the typical grid you're used to and half of it

1:35:58shows the smart albums. The idea being that they're more in

1:36:01your face. You're more privy to actually look at them, but

1:36:05there's weird kind of UX stuff. It's a little strange. So if

1:36:08you go to select multiple photos, you can't do that when

1:36:12half of the grid is on the screen. You have to actually

1:36:14pull the grid down so that it's all photos. Then the select

1:36:17tool comes up and that might change over the beta. There's

1:36:20kind of weird stuff like that, but in general, I think it's a

1:36:24lot better. Those smart albums have been there for years and

1:36:28they're pretty cool. I mean that was one thing that you

1:36:30know, Craig. I think it maybe it was even on your show was

1:36:32like well. we added the pets and people one last year. Oh

1:36:35yeah, but a lot of people a lot of people think these are all

1:36:37new. They're not. I mean they've been there for a long

1:36:39time. We're just adding more and more of them and getting

1:36:41better and then I'm really interested in the optics of

1:36:47improved search because that's something that when you have

1:36:50large libraries, it's just miserable. Apple's always done

1:36:55that well not always, but over the last several years, they've

1:36:57been better at OCR stuff works really well just because of

1:37:00that being so capable on device, but object recognition.

1:37:04It's not bad, but you open something like Google photos

1:37:07who trains probably by stealing all of your photos and and and

1:37:11it's really good. So when I need to actually find something

1:37:14I'll open it in Google photos rather than Apple photos and

1:37:17hopefully that'll change to the point where if the Apple

1:37:21intelligence stuff is to be believed, you can say Megan

1:37:24when she was wearing the spotted dress on Tuesday back

1:37:27in Rome get that hyper specific and that will be great. We're

1:37:31not just a green sweater, but a green fuzzy sweater. Oh my god

1:37:34that it's actually the picture I was thinking of. I'll say that

1:37:37that's the sort of feature that I continue even before WWDC

1:37:41just in regular life and talking to family members and

1:37:45stuff. People have no idea that you can search Apple photos for

1:37:50stuff like that. They really don't that you can and and that

1:37:53it works pretty well for a lot of things certainly works well

1:37:56for people once you've tagged some people, but that you can

1:37:59do things like say a cheeseburger and if you have got

1:38:04some pictures in your library of like cheeseburgers, it'll

1:38:09find them and now whether it finds every single one. I think

1:38:12Apple is not at the state of the art of that, but it's pretty

1:38:15useful and when I do it, it's really it blows people's

1:38:19minds if they're not aware that you could search for stuff like

1:38:22that in photos and I definitely think they're doing the right

1:38:25thing because I probably organize my photos a lot more

1:38:31than the typical user does, but my photos in my library are

1:38:35largely uncategorized, unalbumed and it's really just a

1:38:40big pile. So doing more stuff automatically is going to be a

1:38:45help and I and I agree though that by pushing your manually

1:38:49organized folders or albums, whatever you call them down, it

1:38:53is a small price of convenience cost to the diligent users who

1:38:59really do dutifully put all of their photos into albums

1:39:03manually as they shoot them. Yeah. Well, I think it's a

1:39:06really good way to surface features like you just said one

1:39:10of the problems that I think iOS and iPad OS in particular

1:39:13have had over the last few years is that they have become

1:39:15so hyper capable, but on the surface, they still wanna be

1:39:19approachable and simplistic to everyone that however comes at

1:39:22the expense of people that aren't watching the keynotes

1:39:25and reading your blog and other people not knowing that things

1:39:28exist. So one example is when you open up the photos app and

1:39:32hit the search button now before it was just a random field

1:39:35that you could enter text into and like you just said people

1:39:38didn't know you could search for a cheeseburger or for a dog

1:39:41and now it actually shows you suggestions, which is great. So

1:39:45it says like solely who's my cat in 2023 last month with

1:39:50Campbell who's my brother. That is a it's just a really simple

1:39:53visual cue that lets people know. Hey, you can type

1:39:57whatever you want in here and we'll try to find it and I think

1:40:00iOS this year in particular got a lot more of those subtle kind

1:40:05of pokes of hey, this is a thing that you might not be able

1:40:08to know that you can do, but actually you can. Yeah, it's

1:40:11cool. Exposing and I think that's the sort of that's the

1:40:14whole thinking behind this photos redesign is you know,

1:40:17let's surface these smart albums and and make a

1:40:22collection from your nephew's birthday party last weekend.

1:40:26Let's just assume that that that's an event you'd

1:40:28categorized into an album and push it to you. So you see oh

1:40:32here here are all the photos I have from that, including the

1:40:35ones shot by other family members that I downloaded from

1:40:39messages when they shared them to me and messages and put them

1:40:41in there very very cool. I love I have to mention this as one

1:40:46of my absolute top features of the year is the whole I guess

1:40:51they're calling math notes, but it's more than just in the

1:40:55notes app and then the calculator app that's finally on

1:40:59on the iPad, but you can type math anywhere in a text field

1:41:04and get the answer. So in messages you could type 96

1:41:09divided by twelve equals and it'll auto complete eight as

1:41:15the answer and it's just like auto completing a word. You just

1:41:19hit the space bar to get it and the whole math that simple

1:41:23whether it's simple arithmetic or more complex notation like

1:41:27they showed in the notes app. You can do it and that's super

1:41:31cool cuz that's something the computers. It's like the the

1:41:34first thing in the 60s when people heard about. Hey, you

1:41:38ever hear of these things called computers. They're really

1:41:40they're good at math. It's kinda awesome and it kinda

1:41:43makes you wonder why you haven't been able to again.

1:41:45Again. It's one of these features where it's like why

1:41:47haven't we been able to do this forever right computers are

1:41:50really good at math. Yeah. No, it's super handy and it's

1:41:54available on all platforms too. That's not just an iPad thing,

1:41:56which is great and the calculator app in general has

1:42:00gotten huge improvements. Now you can see the actual the the

1:42:04math that you typed out before you hit the equals button. It'll

1:42:08show you the solution. There's now a log of all of the stuff

1:42:11you've entered. It's just oh, it's a way better. So that's

1:42:14good long and I'm. Longtime friends with James Thompson,

1:42:19author of Peacock and I think Peacock will be fine as a truly

1:42:25excellent calculator. That's always going to go way further

1:42:29than Apple's ever willing to go in terms of customization.

1:42:32It's always mixed feelings, though when you're friends with

1:42:35somebody who's been Sherlock even to a minor degree right.

1:42:39We can all complain that it seems very strange that the

1:42:44iPad went 13 years without a built-in calculator app. It's

1:42:49really does seem curious, but if you make a calculator app

1:42:53that kind of was good news for a long time, but I'll just say

1:42:58I've I ran into this issue two mother's days ago. I don't

1:43:04know it wasn't this year. So it's either last year or the

1:43:07year before, but we got my wife's mom a new iPad and. She

1:43:14didn't need a lot of help setting up. She had an iPad

1:43:16before she just upgraded from the old one, but she was when

1:43:20you get a new device is when you ask questions of your son

1:43:24in law of things. Hey she she not knowing that this is like a

1:43:30meme in our circles. Why doesn't the iPad have a

1:43:32calculator? She asked me why my phone my iPhone has a

1:43:35calculator and she uses it all the time. She does tips and

1:43:39people use calculators a lot. I asked about an iPad calculator

1:43:44app and I looked at the app store for calculator apps and I

1:43:49eventually send her to the free version of but there are I

1:43:55don't know 150 million calculator apps in the app

1:43:59store. It's there's a lot of them and none of them make me

1:44:04feel good. There are so bad. There are some of them are

1:44:09really bad. They all have ads because it's this race to the

1:44:13bottom and because there really are a zillion that are free

1:44:17with ads. There's not a lot of room for a paid version and my

1:44:22mother-in-law isn't thinking of a calculator app is the thing

1:44:25she should pay three or $4 for and I know again. I'm friends

1:44:29with James. I pay for P Calc happily so, but it's people

1:44:34don't think of a calculator is a thing they should pay for so

1:44:37it's it is good, but it's also really interesting that they

1:44:42did what Fedor said for years. We don't wanna bring a

1:44:45calculator to the iPad unless we can bring something new to

1:44:48it. They brought a lot new to it. It's really interesting.

1:44:51They did if you will permit me to complain about one thing

1:44:54that I noticed in trying to search for a good scanning app.

1:44:58I like I know you can scan documents in iOS and it's fine.

1:45:02What I don't love about it is that you've gotta do it a weird

1:45:07way, not a way that goes with my flow. I would much prefer to

1:45:10open a camera effectively that scans you know a photo into my

1:45:14image library. Normally you have to go through notes and

1:45:17create a note and then once you get into notes, you can say hit

1:45:20the little share sheet and then you can send it to files. You

1:45:22can't save it to your photo library. I get it. I understand

1:45:25the flow. They don't wanna jam up your photo library with but

1:45:28sometimes I just want an image of a of a scan. One thing that

1:45:33is been very frustrating and I think it's maybe why you

1:45:36weren't able to find a good free calculator app because I

1:45:38have no doubt that there is one that's out there and doesn't

1:45:40have ads but the app store search is just so abominable

1:45:44because now it's all ranked searching based on who pays for

1:45:47surfacing all that stuff and keyword jamming and so it's

1:45:52it's a really unfortunate that the discoverability on the app

1:45:55store is so poor that it you would be hard pressed to find a

1:45:59free calculator app without in-app purchases and without

1:46:02ads but I guarantee there's one out there. You just never find

1:46:05it because the app store search sucks. And you can't you can't

1:46:09search with the natural language. No calculator app

1:46:13without ads and without in-app purchases. That's what we need

1:46:15Apple intelligence for the app store. Alright. Alright. Let me

1:46:19blow your mind, Quinn. You can go to the files app. On your

1:46:24phone and go up to the little dot dot dot menu and the second

1:46:28item down or third item down scan documents. Hey, there you

1:46:33go. That does. I just learned that about 2 weeks ago on

1:46:36threads where somebody was complaining. Somebody was

1:46:39complaining about the exact same thing you just mentioned. I

1:46:41only ever did it in the notes app and it seems very hard to

1:46:44get them out of the notes app. It does. But you can actually

1:46:48do it right in the files app and so here I am telling you

1:46:51how good the files app is. There you go. You still can't

1:46:55save it as an image without saving it too as a PDF in your

1:46:59file browser and then so but that is better. I will start

1:47:02using that. That is much improved. Thank you. Yeah.

1:47:05There you go. Tip of the day. We might as well. We gotta talk

1:47:08about the iPad though cuz you've you've it's been a topic

1:47:11of conversation. You've reviewed the what how would you

1:47:16summarize your your M4 iPad Pro review? Well, I sang praises of

1:47:21the hardware. It's the best. I think it's it's seriously the

1:47:25best device they've ever made full stop. It's incredible.

1:47:29True as well. Yeah. And it's it's unbelievably good. And I

1:47:33think that's exact and I think people recognize that even

1:47:37especially when they see it like when you it's thin. They

1:47:40keep telling you it's thin. They had that that controversial

1:47:43ad that the whole point of it was to emphasize that it's so

1:47:47thin. It's you need a two-ton hydraulic press to make

1:47:50something that then then you hold it in your hand and look

1:47:53at the screen and it's wow. This is amazing, but I think

1:47:56it's the it's this weird. It's the fact that the hardware is

1:48:02probably the best computing device they've ever made full

1:48:04stop that makes the people who want iPad OS to be

1:48:07fundamentally different enraged. Yeah and II am I

1:48:13wouldn't put myself in that group in the sense that there's

1:48:16a lot of people that are pushing for the iPad to run

1:48:20virtualized Mac OS or to dual boot or for there to be a Mac

1:48:24OS icon. You can open on the iPad and have some sort of file

1:48:28syncing between the iPad environment and the Mac

1:48:30environment. I don't want that. I don't even want a kind of

1:48:34parallel style environment where you can open Mac apps in

1:48:38the kind of iPad environment without you seeing the Mac

1:48:42underpinnings. I don't want that either. I am truly a fan of

1:48:45iPad OS and that's what makes it so frustrating is year after

1:48:50year. It's like death by a thousand paper cuts. There's

1:48:53not there's not much that iPad users are asking for, but what

1:48:59we're asking for just never seems to come and it's just

1:49:03rudimentary basic stuff with the files app being fairly

1:49:07hyperlimited tagging or being able to change the extension,

1:49:10which you can't do of any file name. Just basic stuff that any

1:49:15file browser since forever has been able to do and then you

1:49:19augment that with limitations in multitasking because of

1:49:23stage manager and they're just artificial limitations. I mean

1:49:27this thing's running an M4. So one of my favorite examples is

1:49:30and this even counts when you're using a huge external

1:49:33display. So I've run my iPad on this 27 inch Apple Studio

1:49:39display. You can only have four windows open at any given time.

1:49:43That's the maximum limit and there's tons of room for more,

1:49:47but you can only have four and if you choose to open up

1:49:50another window either in a new app or maybe in an app that you

1:49:54already have open, you just want to open another window. It

1:49:56will at random just close one of those windows and the only

1:50:00way to get it back is to resummon it through the app

1:50:03environment like it's just bananas and so it's just small

1:50:08stuff like this that individually it's not that big

1:50:12of a deal, but in aggregate it really makes for true

1:50:16limitation and this is not limitation in the sense of I

1:50:19want the iPad to be a Mac. It's limitation in the sense of I

1:50:22want an iPad to do a thing that I know the iPad should be able

1:50:25to do, but it can't and they don't need to change. I I iPad

1:50:29OS. They don't need to make it feel like a Mac. They just need

1:50:32to add some of this basic stuff that frankly should have been

1:50:36there for a decade now. Yeah, you posted last month. I guess

1:50:41it was when you were first testing the new iPad Pro. It

1:50:46was like a 3 minute video. You posted the threads. I don't know

1:50:49if you posted it elsewhere, but just sort of explaining your

1:50:52frustration as to what ought to be a very simple thing. How do I

1:50:58get I already have an app a window open for I forget which

1:51:01app you were using was it notes. I think it may have been

1:51:03craft, which is a third party notes app. Yeah. Okay. But it's

1:51:07it's you've got a window. You've got your iPad connected

1:51:09to a display a studio display and you just want to open

1:51:14another window for the same app. Yeah. Shouldn't be hard and

1:51:18it shouldn't be hard and you said you've been using Apple

1:51:21platforms for 25 years. You're pretty familiar with them. This

1:51:25really is your job explaining things like this and again. It

1:51:30comes back to intuit as a verb. You could not intuit how to do

1:51:36it and I'm watching the video and I've I'm in the same

1:51:39racket, including the sub racket of complaining about

1:51:43limitations of iPad OS and I'm sitting here thinking I'm

1:51:47stumped too and you're like what if I hit these the three

1:51:50little dots up here and I'm like yeah, that's probably it.

1:51:53No that wasn't it. I was like. Oh, I thought he had it and

1:51:56then I remember the first time I watched your video like three

1:51:59times cuz I was like this is so succinct at explaining the

1:52:05frustrations that people are talking about and but it's like

1:52:08the first time I watched it. I remember looking down at the

1:52:12little bar telling me how far for the video. I'm like. Oh,

1:52:15he's not even close to finding the answer to this yet right and

1:52:18I followed it up on threads with my comment was this is

1:52:21just command end on a Mac right and it is and it is and and one

1:52:26of the the leading kind of dissenting arguments on that

1:52:30post was well, you're trying to make this behave like a Mac.

1:52:34It's not a Mac. Stop trying to treat it like one and I'm like

1:52:36I'm just trying to open a window man. I'm not trying to

1:52:39make it like a Mac. I understand that they're

1:52:41inherently different platforms, but it's not intuitive. I

1:52:44couldn't give my grandmother an iPad and she would figure out

1:52:48how to open up a window on a Mac sooner cuz she'd be like

1:52:51hmm. Let's look at crab. No, it's not there. What about

1:52:54file? Oh yeah. File new window. There you go and on on iPad OS.

1:52:59It's some arbitrary. You've gotta drag the icon out of the

1:53:02dock which yeah, but you've gotta do it only in stage

1:53:05manager cuz if you do it in the standard mode, then it enters

1:53:07jiggle mode right. Just all these behaviors that make no

1:53:11sense and aren't consistent with between themselves. All of

1:53:14the things convenient or they're not intuitive. It's like a

1:53:17double whammy right and it it's it's like they've somehow

1:53:23painted themselves into a corner with some of these

1:53:27features with the way iPad OS works that I and I feel I don't

1:53:32know I'm mixing metaphors here, but it's like they've painted

1:53:34themselves into a corner and blindfolded themselves so that

1:53:38they can't see that they're painted in a corner and it's.

1:53:43I had that 3 minute video just exemplifies that there is no

1:53:47easy solution. It's not oh, I see how the the whole thing

1:53:53Apple should do is they should just do blank and then Quinn's

1:53:56problem that he describes goes away. It's it's deeper than

1:54:00that, but because it's deeper, I feel like collectively Apple's

1:54:04just pretending it's not a problem right and and then you

1:54:07have different modal kind of environments that conflict with

1:54:11one another. so one of the problems that I found out and I

1:54:14didn't even realize it when I made this video was that the

1:54:17studio display to which the iPad was outputting runs stage

1:54:21manager all external displays now on when connected to an

1:54:25iPad run stage manager, but you can still run the windowing and

1:54:29multitasking environment on the iPad in either stage manager

1:54:34or the old split view. So I was running stage manager on the

1:54:38external display and split view on the iPad. Unbeknownst to me,

1:54:42they're completely separate from one another and you can go

1:54:45into control center on the iPad and turn stage manager on and

1:54:49if you do, then you do get window interactions more

1:54:52similar to what you'd have on a Mac, but the fact that it

1:54:55wasn't turned on by default and I didn't even know there was no

1:54:58obvious indicator that hey you're actually running two

1:55:01completely different windowing environments on each display.

1:55:05Right. It was almost like they were incompatible with one

1:55:08another because they are because split view is this old

1:55:11archaic windowing interface of yesteryear. That's pretty good

1:55:14for touch, but not really very good for a keyboard and mouse

1:55:17and so we bring stage manager to help with that, but let's

1:55:20not get rid of the old way cuz some people still like

1:55:22multitasking that way and so it honestly feels kind of like

1:55:25Windows product where you've got seven or eight old kind of

1:55:31somewhat deprecated, but not really cuz some people still

1:55:34use them environments that don't really work with one

1:55:36another, but kinda sometimes they do, but only in this

1:55:39specific way. That's not obvious to you and then you

1:55:42enter you end up with a product that is neither intuitive or

1:55:46simple to use and also not powerful because they're trying

1:55:51to keep it simple while actually making it very complex

1:55:55and so I think there needs to be a fundamental rethinking of

1:55:59iPad OS. I'm not saying turn it into the Mac at all. I'm just

1:56:02basically saying let's go back to the core. Go back to the

1:56:04springboard. We've got a home screen. How can we make this

1:56:08powerful and capable for the people that want that while

1:56:11making sure that that's out of the way and simple for grandma

1:56:14that doesn't intend to use that at all and maybe the answer is

1:56:17you put some switch and control center. That's like a pro mode

1:56:20that enters more of a desktop class UI that still looks like

1:56:24an iPad, but has more windowing features and capability that

1:56:28you might wanna use if you were interested in that kind of

1:56:31environment, but they've gotta do something cuz every year

1:56:35they keep adding a thing of oh and they did it again this

1:56:38year. They added this new little menu bar thing. I forget

1:56:40what it's even called, but yeah, the the concept of the

1:56:45hamburger menu. They're like we know a hamburger menu is not a

1:56:47really good solution. It's designed for touch and so now

1:56:50you can put some of your most common menu items that you used

1:56:53to have to go into the hamburger menu. Now it's in

1:56:55this kind of floating menu bar, but it's not a menu bar in the

1:56:59traditional sense and nobody that's using it thinks it's a

1:57:02menu bar and and and there's not sub options in that. So it's

1:57:06just another thing that convulates the OS without

1:57:09really addressing any of the real problems. It's quite

1:57:12frustrating. Yeah. I I I was just discussing this with the

1:57:19just by coincidence, but I think it's cuz everybody because

1:57:21the new iPad pros just came out. Everybody just sort of

1:57:24resurfaced their frustrations and it's just made it a topic

1:57:28of conversation right now and until last week, there was hope

1:57:32I did not think that iPad OS was going to get a major

1:57:36rethink this year, but the people who really wanted to

1:57:39were like maybe they've one month after unveiling the new

1:57:43hardware. They're going to unveil a radical rethinking of

1:57:46the operating system. I was like don't hold your breath.

1:57:49But there there was a guy who was at Xerox for a long time in

1:57:53the 70s and then he was at Apple during like their first

1:57:57heyday of the original Macintosh years into the 90s

1:57:59named Larry Tesla and he died just a few years ago, but a

1:58:04real real Titan in the field of sort of defining the modern

1:58:11graphical user interface and sort of humanizing computer

1:58:15interfaces and his big thing was not having modes that modes

1:58:19were bad. In fact, famously, he even had a custom license plate

1:58:23called no modes was his license plate in California and. It's

1:58:29like you can say no modes, but I think if Larry Tesla were

1:58:32still around even he would admit that there were always

1:58:35edge cases where okay, here's an edge case where yes, you kind

1:58:38of have to have a mode for blank, but that is a general

1:58:42rule of thumb. You should eliminate modes because modes

1:58:46just aren't intuitive and they're not the way people

1:58:48think, but the iPad is all about modes like you said that

1:58:53you can have the iPad itself in the non stage manager mode

1:58:58while it's connected to a display that isn't stage

1:59:01manager and you get two entirely different interaction

1:59:06models between windows on the two at the same time and it's

1:59:10very difficult to explain how you switch between the two

1:59:13like why can I make the iPad use either, but I can't on the

1:59:17studio display the studio display only support stage

1:59:21manager. Why I don't know. It's just the way it is. Yeah. Yep.

1:59:26So it's one of those things that again. I'm I'm not asking

1:59:30for Apple to completely redo iPad OS. I think it's so much

1:59:34of what makes the iPad great is the way that it's been designed

1:59:39it like the iPad has been a success for a reason. It's not

1:59:42a mistake. It's not the issue is that they are trying to

1:59:48suggest that this is a legitimate pro product. There

1:59:51are pro apps available for it. They're pushing Final Cut Pro.

1:59:54This new version of Final Cut Pro is amazing. They have

1:59:56logic. They're trying to really argue that this is a pro

2:00:00platform and yet they're hesitant to bring features that

2:00:04would make it so much more convenient and likely to be

2:00:08used by pros and so it's one of those you can't really have it

2:00:11both ways. Either it's a simple limited really good product.

2:00:15It's great for reading news and watching content and browsing

2:00:18the web and doing short emails or it's a powerful machine and

2:00:24it can do all this stuff and they kind of want it to be both

2:00:27which I think it can be but not without creating and I don't

2:00:31know if this is a different mode or a different environment

2:00:34or at least some sort of kind of like bringing some of the

2:00:38features that you know you can't just say that oh it's

2:00:42powerful and it can do anything you want but then when you hit

2:00:45a limitation and you go well it's just an iPad. I mean, what

2:00:47do you want it to be a Mac? You can't have it both ways. You

2:00:50gotta pick your lane, right? So, yeah. Well, till next year.

2:00:58As we say every year, maybe, maybe next year. I can't let

2:01:04this show just good that we didn't record Friday but I do

2:01:09want to talk about the Apple's sort of bummer. The other that

2:01:15shoe that dropped on Friday was the announcement that Apple

2:01:20Intelligence and iPhone mirroring and the new share

2:01:24place screen sharing features are not coming to the EU when

2:01:30they come to the rest of the world. Now, none of those, none

2:01:33of those features are available to anybody yet but apparently,

2:01:37it may and literally while you and I are talking here on

2:01:40Monday afternoon, the betas might be out. Supposedly, the

2:01:43iPhone mirroring and screen the share play screen sharing are

2:01:47coming in developer beta twos which are supposed to come out

2:01:50today should be out by the time everybody's listening to this

2:01:54but will not be out even to users of the beta operating

2:01:57systems in the EU and Apple Intelligence is postponed

2:02:02indefinitely there even though it's also postponed for

2:02:06everybody else too and why? Well, because of uncertainty

2:02:10around the DMA. Needless to say, people have thoughts. I'm

2:02:17curious what your take is. II have a take that I'll I'll

2:02:20share but I'd like to hear yours first. Yeah, I think it's

2:02:25difficult because on the one hand, you can argue that

2:02:29regulation does often push companies to do things that

2:02:34they wouldn't do otherwise. Apple had shown for a pretty

2:02:38long time that they were willing to make the experience

2:02:42of messaging people with Android phones worse such that

2:02:47they well, I shouldn't say worse. They didn't they didn't

2:02:50try to make it better. Right. And part of that you could say

2:02:54was malicious because they wanted more people to buy

2:02:57iPhones cuz they were guilted into it. The more charitable

2:02:59thing would be that they just didn't care to spend resources

2:03:02building out RCS support and there were problems with the way

2:03:05that Google had implemented their version of RCS that

2:03:08didn't. It's it it goes on ad nauseum but the reality is is

2:03:12that regulation does get companies to do things whether

2:03:15they want to or not within a time frame. The problem is and

2:03:19this is where I've been not super I've been empathetic I

2:03:25guess towards Apple in regards to the DMA is and this is the

2:03:30way that Europe has just chosen to do legislation in some ways.

2:03:33I think it's better than the way we do it here in the US.

2:03:36There's not really any strict their guidelines right. So

2:03:40there's not this is what you can and can do. It's the onus is

2:03:43on Apple that kind of come to the DMA and say hey or come to

2:03:46the EU and say hey this is what we think as per the DMA

2:03:50guidelines fit within the framework of what's expected and

2:03:53then the EU either goes okay or nope try again you're still not

2:03:57there and so it's been this kind of teetering back and

2:04:00forth where it gets problematic is that the more regions that

2:04:06try to do this the less I don't want to say accommodating but

2:04:13the more fragmented the iOS and iPad OS and Mac OS experience

2:04:18is likely to become for people all around the world and I

2:04:22think that is problematic because once you've shoehorned

2:04:26yourself into a region that's pretty small that's worth

2:04:29investing money into they're not Apple's not gonna stop sales

2:04:31altogether but they're also not gonna continue to upgrade this

2:04:36weird legislative thing that your government said was

2:04:39required five years ago and there's just you're gonna have

2:04:42more bugs you're gonna have less consistency as there's more

2:04:44binaries that need to be installed when different

2:04:47devices around the world at different times I empathize

2:04:51with Apple because it seems incredibly unrealistic to do on

2:04:54a global scale and the EU I think they're playing ball

2:04:58because it's such a huge market and they have to comply if

2:05:00they're gonna sell stuff there and it's a big enough market

2:05:03that they're willing to do it and some of these things that

2:05:06they do to comply I think will come by extension to the US and

2:05:10other parts of the world just because it's too difficult to

2:05:13not if they have to do it you might as well just bring it

2:05:16everywhere but it does kind of in some ways seem to be

2:05:20innovation by consensus which as history would dictate is not

2:05:23always the best way to do stuff so I think what I've been

2:05:28thinking about over the weekend is that I think there's a lot of

2:05:32people who think they are in favor of the DMA who if they

2:05:37really read it and understood the full implications of it

2:05:41would realize that it's it's not what they think it is and I

2:05:46think there's a lot of people nerds people in our collective

2:05:49audience you remind whose main issues are a couple of things

2:05:54where they see Apple being dicks that Apple is a dick about

2:05:59the 30% 15% mandatory cut of the app store and that they're a

2:06:06dick on the same vector about the whole idea that the only

2:06:10way to distribute software for iOS is through the app store and

2:06:15the DMA addresses both of those issues that the both it both

2:06:20says that you can't mandate that all transactions go through

2:06:26the gatekeepers payment processing which is where Apple

2:06:29that's the that is the actual gate where Apple takes their cut

2:06:33because all transactions have to use their payment processing

2:06:37here's this gateway where they can take their 30% 15% cut and

2:06:41the DMA mandates that you can't be the exclusive distribution

2:06:46channel for software on your gatekeeping platform and in fact

2:06:50they further clarified since Apple's initial attempt at

2:06:54compliance where they said okay we'll have alternate

2:06:57marketplaces and then they went back and forth and said no

2:06:59you've also got to allow direct sideloading from the web and

2:07:03there's a lot of people out there listening to the show

2:07:05listening watching your videos people who are yelling at me on

2:07:08social networks who see those as the their main complaints

2:07:12about Apple and what they see a lot of these people see and I'm

2:07:16not saying they're wrong. I think I disagree to some extent,

2:07:21but I at least see the argument that they're saying that Apple

2:07:27itself that this isn't even an Apple anti-Apple sentiment.

2:07:30This would be good for Apple. Apple's too obstinate for its

2:07:34own good and opening up would be good for Apple, not just good

2:07:38for the people who want to distribute apps that aren't

2:07:41allowed through the app store etcetera that this would be

2:07:43competition is good for Apple and being insular and

2:07:48protective in the long run is always detrimental. I get it, but

2:07:52the DMA is so much more than that. So what I saw on Friday

2:07:56when Apple announced this is this stuff isn't even about the

2:08:00DMA. Why in the world is Apple withholding iPhone mirroring or

2:08:04the screen sharing this is just spite. It's Apple being a dick

2:08:09again to make people in the EU mad about the DMA so that

2:08:15dot dot dot what they're going to get the DMA revoked. That's

2:08:18not Apple's goal at all. Apple's not telling people in the

2:08:21EU to call their Parliament representative and try to get

2:08:25the DMA revoked the DMA passed by a vote of 588 to 11 in the

2:08:31European Parliament. This was not a controversial law and it

2:08:35were like 31 abstentions. So 31 no votes 11 against 588 for the

2:08:41DMA is not going anywhere, but the DMA is so much more wide

2:08:46reaching than just breaking up the app store. It the whole

2:08:50point of it is more or less in my opinion to attack the whole

2:08:56idea of a vertically integrated company, which is exactly what

2:09:00Apple is and it says pretty much anything that Apple does or

2:09:05adds to the system that's exclusive to their own products

2:09:09and services is contrary to the DMA. So I do think I don't

2:09:14think they're being spiteful. I think they're they are

2:09:16legitimately 100% uncertain whether the iPhone mirroring

2:09:20feature would be deemed compliant or not because it

2:09:23only the iPhone is a gatekeeping platform and iPhone mirroring

2:09:28only works with Apple's own desktop computers. Max it does

2:09:31not work with any other computer and I think the DMA

2:09:35could reasonably be held again. It's the ambiguity is built in

2:09:39it's up to the European Commission to interpret it, but

2:09:43they could definitely interpret the DMA as saying that this is

2:09:47illegal under the DMA. Apple needs to open this up as an API

2:09:50so that any computer could do the iPhone mirroring in the

2:09:53same way and what Apple is saying is this is a security

2:09:56concern because this is actually a very complicated. Doing

2:10:00this in a very secure way is very complicated. I sort of

2:10:03brought it up on my show last week that Apple's way of doing

2:10:07things is to sort of do it themselves privately and if they

2:10:13years two years in think, hey, this is good. Our private APIs

2:10:18that we've been using are stable. Let's make it a public

2:10:21API and now everybody can do it right and this year's example

2:10:24of that is the way that you get a really cool pairing

2:10:28interface for AirPods on your phone or iPad. You just get

2:10:32your brand new AirPods, open the case, hold it near your

2:10:35phone and you get a little three-dimensional animated

2:10:40thing of the AirPods. It's so cool that if you get your AirPod

2:10:44case engraved, the engraving is actually on the 3D

2:10:47representation on the screen and you say pair and now your

2:10:51AirPods are connected and every other company in the world

2:10:54that makes wireless Bluetooth headphones has to go through

2:10:58settings, Bluetooth, pair, weight. I think if AirPods were

2:11:03brand new this year, if this was the year that they announced

2:11:05the first version of AirPods, I think they would be delayed in

2:11:08the EU because they'd have to wait and see whether the

2:11:12pairing process would be deemed legal under the DMA or you

2:11:18know, is it only legal if third parties can get the same thing

2:11:21and if that's the case, what is Apple going to do? Are they

2:11:25going to delay AirPods for two years while they work through

2:11:30EU regulatory approval to see if it's legal and the two years

2:11:35it might take to get public APIs to do it or are they going

2:11:39to roll it out everywhere else, the 93% rest of the world and

2:11:43make the EU wait two years? It's the latter. That's what's

2:11:47going to happen. Yeah, I think there's really kind of like

2:11:53three things that the DMA kind of ignores and doesn't really

2:11:56take into consideration and then one area where Apple really

2:11:59kind of fumbled. So you talked about the technical issue.

2:12:04There's tons of things that from a technical standpoint are

2:12:08just quite literally not feasible. So it's not that

2:12:11Apple's intending to be malicious. It's just the way

2:12:13that different security protocols work and different

2:12:16authentication methods and the shared code bases. It's not

2:12:20practical or sometimes even possible to let that be

2:12:23accessible to everyone. The second argument is one that

2:12:26Craig made on the show that I actually am glad he said,

2:12:29because I've been suggesting this for a long time and a lot

2:12:32of people seem to disagree with me was once you create a

2:12:36publicly accessible API, the onus is on you as the company

2:12:39to support that. Apple can't just come out and say, hey, we

2:12:42have this new feature and here's a public API for it.

2:12:44Yeah, we're doing it, but also you can too and then find out

2:12:48that the feature doesn't really work that well or consumers

2:12:50don't really care about it or and you're still on the hook to

2:12:53support that API for years and years and years to come because

2:12:57you have hardware or software partners that have built their

2:12:59own products and services and platforms upon that. So that's

2:13:02number two and then I think the third one is really the

2:13:06compelling selling point of the product. I think they're and

2:13:11you can make the argument that it's not true for everyone, but

2:13:14it is absolutely the case that Apple has sold iPads because it

2:13:18is fairly locked down. I buy my grandparents iPads because of

2:13:22this very reason. I know they cannot screw it up. Right. And

2:13:25is it does that mean that iPad OS has to be locked down for it

2:13:28to be successful or that there couldn't be a way to side load

2:13:32stuff in a way that's that's pretty easy for, but at the

2:13:35same time, the social engineering aspects of it of oh

2:13:38well, I can just already envision the boondoggle of of

2:13:41Apple and their customers that are slighted and or financially

2:13:45hurt because they get a call from a scam center saying, okay,

2:13:48your iPad has a as a bug. You have to go into settings and

2:13:51then go into alternate app stores and click the enable side

2:13:54loading button because we've gotta help you get this. I mean,

2:13:57you know what I mean? It's just so those are the three aspects

2:14:00that I think there's technical issues surrounding it. There are

2:14:02practical considerations from a financial support standpoint

2:14:06and then last, there are product reasons why it just

2:14:09legitimately is not of benefit. Now, if we go to the other side

2:14:13where I think Apple really screwed up here is that there

2:14:16has been mounting pressure for them to have done stuff for

2:14:22years and I'm not confident that the DMA, despite it being

2:14:26super wide sweeping and going beyond the app store is not a

2:14:30consequence of Apple and other companies cuz they're not the

2:14:34only one beholden to the DMA, but they're certainly a player

2:14:38in the sense that if they had not compromised a little bit in

2:14:42the past to allow third party payment processing or whatever

2:14:45that the extent of this legislation might not have been

2:14:48as wide sweeping as it has been. They've fought this for

2:14:51years to the point where it just looks bad and part of the

2:14:56problem is because Apple's a massive organization. It's not

2:14:59the engineers that are deciding this. This is legal and

2:15:03compliance official. There's all these people that are

2:15:05involved in this massive process and that's why it's so

2:15:08slow moving and complicated, but one has to wonder if the

2:15:12extent to which they had to compromise on product is not

2:15:17kind of a consequence of them being unwilling to do it on

2:15:20their own. But in the same breath, it sucks. Yeah, right.

2:15:26Cuz you know. Money is different, right? Everybody

2:15:30knows money is occupies a special part of the human brain

2:15:36and what people see is a lot of some of that not a lot some of

2:15:42Apple's decisions that frustrate people are specifically

2:15:46related to protecting their money they make from the App

2:15:49Store. I mean there's no denying it and I don't think

2:15:52anything better exemplifies it than the anti steering to the

2:15:56web provisions that they've been enforcing all along and I

2:16:01bring it up all the time. Ben Thompson brings it up all the

2:16:03time, but it's the single to me. It's the one it's maybe not

2:16:08the biggest issue, but it's the one that can really only be

2:16:12justified from Apple's own own institutional perspective of

2:16:17the only people. The only institution that benefits from

2:16:20the anti steering to the web provisions is Apple itself to

2:16:24protect the amount of money that goes through the App Store

2:16:27instead of going through the web. It certainly is of zero

2:16:30benefit. It's anti benefit to users in particular with apps

2:16:35like Kindle right that you can use Kindle on your iPad and you

2:16:38cannot buy Kindle books in the Kindle app because Amazon not

2:16:43just won't but really couldn't sell through the App Store

2:16:47without losing money on every book because of the way ebooks

2:16:50are accounted for it. So it's not even a choice like say

2:16:56Spotify or Netflix makes the choice that they years ago

2:17:01stopped selling subscriptions through the App Store because

2:17:05they didn't wanna share any of their subscription revenue with

2:17:09Apple. That was a choice that Netflix made. They certainly

2:17:12could have done what Disney does and just sell through the

2:17:15App Store and give Apple their 15% cut of the subscription

2:17:18over time, but ebooks can't without losing money because the

2:17:23publisher gets 30% of the price and therefore that's the Apple

2:17:27wants 30% and now the the ebook seller is left with less than

2:17:32they paid the publisher wholesale. How in the world is

2:17:35that a benefit to users? It's A, they can't buy the books in

2:17:38the app they're using and B, they're confused as as hell,

2:17:41right? Yeah. It only benefits Apple. There's no instructions.

2:17:44Nobody tells you. You can't talk about. Right. So there's we

2:17:47can prove that there's some degree of greed involved in

2:17:50Apple's decision making here and therefore. Absolutely. But

2:17:54therefore the fact that everybody knows there's some

2:17:57greed involved in the decision making process. It just opens

2:18:01the door to presuming that all of the decisions they make are

2:18:06about greed and I really don't think that's true and we can

2:18:09litigate this for hours on podcasts and columns and stuff

2:18:13like that. But of course there are many people who are going

2:18:17to just say nope. It's all about the money and it's not

2:18:20that unreasonable because some of it clearly is about the

2:18:22money and that's where Apple shot itself in the in its foot

2:18:25because however much money they have saved them or made for

2:18:29themselves by steering X percent of transactions through

2:18:35the app store that would have gone to the web if they had

2:18:39just allowed apps to link out to the web. They've already

2:18:43wasted way more than that money and on their time complying

2:18:46with all this and sending executives to lawsuits and that

2:18:50might never have happened in the first place. They've already

2:18:52I guarantee you they've lost money on this. It's just not

2:18:55worth it and even if you can't prove it in a spreadsheet, it

2:18:59has to be what they feel in their gut in terms of why are we

2:19:03bothering with this? Why are we wasting our time on this? It's

2:19:06no fun. It's not helping. It's not making. It's not why

2:19:10anybody went to work at Apple in the first place. It's yeah,

2:19:14but II really can't help but think though that there's just

2:19:17a lot of DMA proponents who really think it's just about

2:19:21busting up the app store when it's way more far reaching than

2:19:25that and really does open up Apple to non compliance finds

2:19:31for anything that they do that is vertically integrated within

2:19:35their own products and services and I really do think that this

2:19:40it'll become it's fresh right now because these WWDC

2:19:44announcements are the first new announcements Apple's made

2:19:47under the DMA. So it's the first time they're saying this

2:19:49but people in the EU should get used to it because I don't

2:19:52think the DMA is going the DMA isn't going anywhere. Like I

2:19:55said, it's it's on the books. It was passed overwhelmingly,

2:19:59but I think henceforth every future thing Apple does is

2:20:03going to come late and possibly limited to the EU. Apple Watch

2:20:08if Apple Watch were brand new, it would definitely be delayed

2:20:12because it only works with iPhones and II think that's I

2:20:16think that's illegal under the DMA or it could be they would

2:20:19need them to to rule and they don't rule in advance and Apple

2:20:23doesn't want to tell them in advance. It's not the Apple way

2:20:26of doing things. Hey, we're thinking about unveiling these

2:20:28new smart glasses next year. What do you guys think in the

2:20:31EU? They're not gonna do that. No. Yeah, it's a mess and it's

2:20:36a real bummer and I agree that it's it's the first of many

2:20:39things that are going to start to be problematic, but it's

2:20:44also somewhat hard to be fully empathetic because it is

2:20:47somewhat of their own doing. It's just unfortunate. Really

2:20:51the bottom line is it's unfortunate for users. Yeah and

2:20:54consumers are the ones that lose really at the end of the

2:20:57day. Yeah. Yeah. And and I really don't think I just know

2:21:01people that sort of people who work at Apple. They've II don't

2:21:04think they're like yeah stick it to the citizens of the EU.

2:21:08They I think they feel terrible about it. II think along the

2:21:11lines of what I'm arguing though that they they realize

2:21:15that the the Apple using citizens of the EU really don't

2:21:19understand the full ramifications of the DMA and

2:21:22again, it's the European commissioners themselves.

2:21:25Margaret Vestager who's they're they're continually

2:21:28emphasizing. They're the ones making the threats emphasizing

2:21:31that they can find Apple massive amounts of money and

2:21:35even talking in my opinion almost laughably, but she's the

2:21:40one bringing it up breaking up the company, which I guess

2:21:43would not really breaking up company nation or

2:21:49internationally, but forcing them to what make a European

2:21:53subsidiary of the app store that I don't even know what

2:21:56that would mean, but she's the one making the threats and when

2:21:59government regulators are threatening a company publicly

2:22:02they take it seriously. I guess that's the other point I would

2:22:05make is that so many people are saying Apple isn't taking the

2:22:08DMA seriously. I think Apple's taking the DMA as seriously as

2:22:12a heart attack. I think they're seeing they see it as an

2:22:14existential threat not because the EU itself is so big, but

2:22:19because if DMA like legislation passes in more countries like

2:22:24you said, it won't be an exact clone of the DMA. So the

2:22:28compliance would need to be entirely different. Yeah

2:22:31federated around the world and it really does attack the very

2:22:36nature of what Apple does best, which is the vertical

2:22:39integration of if you buy our phone and our smartwatch, they

2:22:42will work better together in an easier, more reliable way than

2:22:48a watch from company A and a phone from company S to pick a

2:22:53letter. Anyway, there's my rant on the DMA. I guess that's

2:22:57about it. Anything else you wanted to touch on or you're

2:23:00ready to wrap it up? Yeah, I think that's about it. I mean

2:23:05Vision OS 2 was kind of there were some nice updates there.

2:23:08Yeah, I will say my experience echoes everybody else's where

2:23:12it's almost a shame that they have to go through a beta

2:23:15because I actually I actually think it might be it might be

2:23:19better. I think it's a couple of obvious bugs, but I suspect by

2:23:23Beta two or three, it might be better than Vision OS 1.1 and I

2:23:28kind of feel like the nature of Vision OS being a 35 four

2:23:333500 $4,000 product that the the people who have it are sort

2:23:39of the sort of people who aren't afraid to run betas. I

2:23:42don't know. It's I would I would love to see the percentage

2:23:45of Vision pros that are running the developer Beta. I bet it is

2:23:48shockingly high. It's got definitely double digits. No

2:23:50doubt about it. I'll try to find it from a friend. I maybe

2:23:53sandwich will know he might have maybe yeah. A lot of the

2:23:57features are just much improved. I think the new

2:23:59control center interaction and gestures are way better. It's

2:24:03brilliant how well they work. I mean this is another example of

2:24:06so the the hold out your palm and touch your your index and

2:24:10your thumb together to to summon the home screen right.

2:24:13That's the identical interaction that meta uses so

2:24:16Apple just straight up copied Facebook. However, it's so much

2:24:20better. I mean because you can do it without and I don't know

2:24:25you should try this. It's very very interesting. You have to

2:24:29look at your hand with your eyes using eye tracking to get

2:24:32it to actually perform the action, which makes sense. You

2:24:34don't want it. Misinterpreting some sort of function without

2:24:38you looking at your hand, but what you can do is for the

2:24:41control center gesture, you have to open your hand and then

2:24:44you rotate your palm over. You basically twist your hand to

2:24:48get the control center little bubble to show up. What you can

2:24:51do is you can begin that gesture before you've looked at

2:24:55your hand and then after completing the gesture, you can

2:24:58look over at your hand and the little indicator will show up.

2:25:01It's just super well thought out and so seamless and smooth

2:25:04and that in addition to the enhanced polling rate for hand

2:25:08tracking just frankly makes the device feel way different like

2:25:14if you had if you had given me this vision pro and if you put

2:25:19me in a box and said you're in a time machine, it's now 2025

2:25:22and you gave me the the you had me put this on and I played

2:25:26around the OS. I'd say. Oh yeah. This is definitely the

2:25:28vision pro two. This is not the same hardware. It it truly feels

2:25:33substantially better. It's wild. Yeah and it's just sort of

2:25:37it's they're still like I described it in my piece like

2:25:40vision OS two doesn't really get seemingly doesn't get any of

2:25:44the Apple intelligence features. They didn't mention it

2:25:46and it doesn't even get stuff like math notes, which isn't

2:25:48Apple intelligence because they've still got so much low

2:25:51hanging fruit because it's such a dripping. I mean you

2:25:54couldn't even rearrange the icons on the home view till

2:25:57this beta right. I mean I mean and they know right. I mean and

2:26:00again the the iPhone didn't have copy and paste until

2:26:03version three right. I mean never and Apple knew people

2:26:06wanted copy and paste. It's stuff has to get prioritized. I

2:26:09guess though the thing that really hit me once I started

2:26:11using vision OS two beta is just how much I never realized

2:26:18how how every time I hit the crown to go to the home view.

2:26:22It took me out of the immersion right because and I know it's

2:26:28everybody loves to emphasize that the first generation vision

2:26:32pro is too big too heavy sticks out too far. I mean of course

2:26:36it's the biggest heaviest vision pro they're ever gonna

2:26:39make probably but once you once you're yeah. Hopefully once

2:26:43you're in it, it is immersive and you ideally until you get

2:26:50fatigued or something you're you're like in it it and your

2:26:55mind is in it and going out of the world that you see around

2:27:01you to tap that button totally takes you out of it every time.

2:27:04It just is like all of a sudden instead of being in this

2:27:08virtual world. All of a sudden you're back to a computer is

2:27:11strapped on my eyes and I've gotta hit a button. No I'm

2:27:15because touching the button almost moves the headset on

2:27:17your face and you're like. Oh yeah. This is hot and large and

2:27:19uncomfortable right and it's like double tapping the other

2:27:22button to confirm a purchase from the store. I feel like

2:27:25that's good right. You want to be taken out. Oh you're making

2:27:29a purchase take me out of the moment. Let me confirm but for

2:27:33just switching between apps, it was in now that I've tried the

2:27:37new way. I'm like. Oh, this is yeah. This is way better way

2:27:41better than the whole look up to get the control center was

2:27:44always never good. Yeah. No because even after I got used

2:27:47to it, I'm like how far up do I need to look. I feel like I'm

2:27:50like looking all the way up at the ceiling. Well, it's weird.

2:27:52It's it's it's counterintuitive because you you've technically

2:27:55only have to move your eyeballs up cuz you're right. I try but

2:27:59people as we move our eyes up. We also tilt our head up. So

2:28:03it's that same thing where you keep tilting your head and

2:28:04you're like when is this bubble gonna show up and you're just

2:28:07craning your neck until you're in pain and then you're like

2:28:09well, I've hit the end stop of my neck. I guess I gotta move

2:28:12my eyes further and then it would finally work. Yeah. It's

2:28:16it's just much more refined and much more polished and even

2:28:18though it is a small update from a feature standpoint, I

2:28:21think that's okay because the platform is so young and some

2:28:25of the stuff that I didn't like has already been fixed, which

2:28:28is good and then one of the things that I never really

2:28:33didn't speak to me that much was the spatial photos and

2:28:35videos. So II saw all these reviews from reviewers that had

2:28:39had time with the headset and I think you as well had

2:28:42mentioned it. I know other reviewers had basically said

2:28:45this is a huge deal being able to see your photos with spatial

2:28:49depth and you kinda relive the moment and I remember being

2:28:52super excited for that. I had been shooting spatial videos

2:28:54for quite some time leading up to the vision Pro launching and

2:28:58I remember opening them and going. Yeah, it's kinda cool,

2:29:02but it didn't really speak to me now with vision OS two. It

2:29:07creates artificial depth on any photo at all. It can be photos

2:29:12that you took 20 years ago on a DSLR. It could be photos from

2:29:15the web. It does it to any photo and because this is all

2:29:18done from an ML standpoint, it doesn't deal with the reality

2:29:22that the iPhone 15 Pro Max and 15 Pro have two camera lenses

2:29:27that are still quite close together. so they don't really

2:29:29create that convincing of a depth effect. It's very shallow

2:29:34once you can do that all artificially. It's actually

2:29:37pretty amazing and so I've spent hours looking at photos

2:29:43inside of the vision Pro from when I was a kid and it truly

2:29:47was emotional in a way that I never anticipated because I was

2:29:52able to see my grandparents who have since lost in this almost

2:29:56hyper realistic 3D depth and the amount of work they do to

2:30:00make it convincing is really impressive. There is one of me

2:30:02in front of a tree, maybe a few feet and not only did it cut

2:30:08me out as the subject and separate me from the tree, but

2:30:10it even added a drop shadow in between me and the tree and so

2:30:15it did this really convincing depth effect and I really only

2:30:18had I've probably looked at. I don't know 150 200 photos.

2:30:21There was one photo where I was like. Oh yeah, this this got

2:30:25messed up, but it's unbelievable how reliable it is

2:30:29and and if you look at the try to pull the thread, you can

2:30:33start to see there's weirdness like one example is I was on a

2:30:36pier next to a cruise ship as a kid and the the camera was

2:30:42shot at a fairly high aperture. So there's no depth of field.

2:30:45Everything is in focus. It's infinity focus and inside of

2:30:49the vision Pro you look at me and there's perceivable depth,

2:30:53but then you look at one of the light posts six light post

2:30:56backs. The is pretty far away and there's faux depth added to

2:31:00that too. So it's it's kinda weird cuz everything is in

2:31:02focus, but it's also kind of not, but it still was

2:31:05convincing and then when you have a photo that does actually

2:31:09have natural bokeh like a portrait photographer or

2:31:12portraiture photos. It's unbelievable. It looks like it

2:31:16was legitimately taken with a 3D camera and it's it's really

2:31:20really really cool and it's one of the things that I've been

2:31:23really excited to show people that try it cuz it it is it's

2:31:27surreal to see stuff that was taken 2030 4050 years ago and

2:31:31make it feel like it's happening again, which I just

2:31:34didn't get the same effect with when it was a video I had taken

2:31:37three months ago and I'm like, Oh yeah, I remember that it was

2:31:40a little while back and it feels like one of those things

2:31:43that they probably were hoping to have a year ago so that they

2:31:46could talk about it when it first came out because the

2:31:48other thing I've been thinking ever since the end of the year

2:31:51November when they first started letting people in the

2:31:54press play with the spatial video on the iPhone 15 Pro.

2:31:59Well, okay. This is cool, but why can't I take still photos

2:32:02in three days and I get the answer. It seems is oh you

2:32:06don't need to go to a special you do need the special mode

2:32:09for video because video shooting is obviously more

2:32:13complex than still but totally just wait just shoot photos.

2:32:18I wish they would have told me that it was it would have been

2:32:20a much better answer than here. They are cuz I asked about it

2:32:24and I just got one of those non answer Apple answers. That's

2:32:28come on. That's not an answer. This is weird right. You can't

2:32:30you can shoot 3D video, but you can't shoot 3D stills, but now

2:32:33you don't need to and it is definitely compelling and it's

2:32:37I know it's people aren't gonna spend most people aren't gonna

2:32:39spend $4000 just to see their photos big and in 3D, but it is

2:32:44really something to see your personal photo library big. I

2:32:48mean there's a lot of photos that I have that I've never

2:32:51really seen most of my photos. I've never really seen even as

2:32:55big as my studio display. I don't look at all my photos

2:32:57full screen, but even then it's only 27 inches as opposed to

2:33:01movie theater size and the depth is definitely. I don't

2:33:04know it's emotionally relevant resonant to experience depth

2:33:08like that. So good good for them. Good update sort of

2:33:12finally again. That's right everybody. Where's the best

2:33:17place your home on YouTube is what youtube.com/snazzyq

2:33:21slash snazzy. Yep. Yep. Yep. Snazzy Labs everywhere else.

2:33:28Snazzy Labs everywhere else. You're you're on the threads.

2:33:31You're on the mastodon. Yeah. I'm on Mastodon. I'm still on

2:33:36Twitter. Unfortunately, the old one can't get away from that

2:33:38cesspool. Something about it. Something they put in the water

2:33:42that makes me come back. I don't know why. Well, I enjoy

2:33:45it, but I'm there. I'm not making apologies. I mean, but I

2:33:48have we we and I know you do too. I have readers and

2:33:51followers who are there who aren't elsewhere and I'm not

2:33:55I'm not delighted about it, but I'm happy to go to where my

2:33:58readers and listeners are so still there. Quinn always a

2:34:01pleasure to have you on the show. Thanks for having me

2:34:04again. John keep up the good work. Let me thank our

2:34:05sponsors. We had trade coffee where you can get a tailored

2:34:08subscription plan just for yourself and Squarespace where

2:34:11you can build a website and have your own presence on the

2:34:13web thanks to them. Thank you Quinn. Alright thanks man appreciate it.