Podcast Search

The Talk Show

406: ‘Hock TUAW’, With Christina Warren

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00The breaking news, if we want to get right into it, yesterday, iOS 18.1 and MacOS 15.1 Sequoia betas shipped with some Apple intelligence features.

0:00:15Yeah, which I'm glad they did that. But this dual beta process, that's fun.

0:00:21I got the night before. Yeah, Sunday night, I got invited to a WebEx briefing from Apple PR. And

0:00:29they never did. I don't think this is breaking the omerta, the NDA of, do you agree that this is on

0:00:37background? But their usual technique is not to tell you what the briefing is about, even.

0:00:43I don't care. And oftentimes, based on who from Apple PR is reaching out to me, I have a very good

0:00:51guess sometimes, but sometimes not. And this is one where it's not because it is sort of general,

0:00:58right? It's not like there are people at Apple PR who are in charge of developer betas, you know,

0:01:03just sort of like iOS people or Mac people or something. But I am so, I'm so mad once I found

0:01:11out what it was, I was, I'm still fuming that I didn't guess weeks ago that they might do that

0:01:18this summer with the Apple intelligence. Because I realize this is very strange to have two forks

0:01:26of the next year's. But if ever there was a reason to do that, I think Apple intelligence would be it.

0:01:33StephanieH: No, I mean, it makes sense on a lot of levels. I mean, one, I think,

0:01:37just to really be able to hone in on testing and getting feedback on those specific features,

0:01:42right? So that's one part of it. And then the secondary part is, as Apple's product catalog

0:01:47becomes more varied, it does become difficult and has more architectures, right? You do start to have

0:01:53this increasing kind of dichotomy between like what features are supported on what platforms.

0:01:58And that's hard to ship even in a normal OS update. But I think in a beta, that could be a

0:02:02really difficult thing to like, okay, how can we zone in on what are show-stopping bugs and what

0:02:08are specific things maybe that are specific to this architecture that whatever version of the

0:02:14binary we wind up shipping to these devices is going to be different. So having different,

0:02:19you know, I guess like branches does make some sense.

0:02:23Yeah, and I feel and it's funny, because I just from the previous episode of this show,

0:02:31where just a couple days ago, Hunter Hillegas was on, he's the developer of an app called Vegas

0:02:36Mate, and I had him on, we talked about a couple of things. But at one point, we got talking about,

0:02:41I forget what led us there now. But we were talking about the legendary purple button in the

0:02:48pre Mac OS 10.0 betas that would put the Mac into single window mode. I mean, I know that this is,

0:02:57you were very young at the time. But I'm sure you've seen the stories that it,

0:03:01yes, for Mac OS 10 came out there. In addition to the red, yellow, green buttons, there was going

0:03:06to be a purple one in the other corner. And then your Mac would only have one window at a time.

0:03:11And when you switched to another window, they would automatically, whichever one was open,

0:03:18would genie into the dock, and whichever one you were switching to would genie out of the dock.

0:03:23And it did look cool.

0:03:24So it was Stage Manager.

0:03:26Yeah, I think that that's one of the things that Stage Manager put it back, put this idea back

0:03:33into the air, right? You know, like what comes around goes around, right? And when Stage Manager

0:03:38was new, those of us old timers who were there for the early days of Mac OS 10, were like,

0:03:44we've seen ideas like this before. But yes, very sort of similar, except Stage Manager is more than

0:03:50one window. But right. But well, you know,

0:03:53it depends on what iPad you're on.

0:03:56Yes, yes, exactly. But I always say, and I've stuck with it. And it's generally good advice is

0:04:04a lot of the times, as a user, or even as a colleague, when you're working, I bet you have

0:04:10this experience to even as a colleague, working with engineers, software engineers, a lot of the

0:04:18times, the best way to make a feature request isn't to describe what you think you want.

0:04:26But just describe your problem. And then, if you have an idea, maybe tack it on. But start by

0:04:33describing the problem. And oftentimes, that's just a better way to frame it for the engineers. And

0:04:39Stage Manager today, and the purple button single window mode, 24 years ago, did try to solve the

0:04:48same problem, which was, hey, if you've got a lot of windows open, because you're using either a lot

0:04:54of documents in the same app, or many apps, each with a window, it can get visually cluttered on

0:05:01screen, which might just annoy you aesthetically, but also make it hard to switch between the few

0:05:07that you want to switch between, right? It solves the same problem, managing the visual complexity

0:05:13of multitasking. But what struck me was in the show notes, I put, I think Hunter actually sent

0:05:19me the link, but it was a great link. It's like a seven or eight, nine minute link. I guess now I'm

0:05:24stuck putting it in the show notes again for this episode, but I will. But it's Steve Jobs at, I

0:05:31think probably Macworld. I didn't even look. 2000, maybe it was WWDC 2000. But he's demoing to the

0:05:39audience, this beta version of Mac OS X. It might have been the first public demonstration of the

0:05:46Aqua user interface. And what made it seem relevant in addition to the whole Stage Manager

0:05:53thing and whatever Hunter and I were talking about was just that one of the things that's come around

0:06:00and Apple seems to have come back around to is not being afraid to show software well in advance of

0:06:09when it ships, right? They're still totally as secretive as they can possibly be about hardware,

0:06:16right? You could not get Jaws right now. If it was me and you and Jaws on this podcast,

0:06:22instead of just me and you, we could not get him to tell us that there will be new iPhones

0:06:28in September, right? Right. Well, you have to wait and see. We're like, bro, we know.

0:06:33We're aware. We know everything about it. We've seen the leaks of the colors. Come on.

0:06:38Not even getting him to tell us whether there's an extra button this year for the camera,

0:06:47what the colors will be, what the materials will be. No, no, no. He wouldn't even acknowledge that

0:06:51he could exist. He's like, I don't know. We always have a lot of things going on. I think you'll be

0:06:54excited, but like, don't know. But with software, there, you know, to me, it's just one of the

0:07:02differences between hardware and software. There's just not, and here's Steve Jobs in the year 2000,

0:07:09over a year before Mac OS X actually shipped, a couple of years before Mac OS X certainly became

0:07:16the mainstream OS for Mac users. Yeah. Or good. Well, I mean, I mean, honestly,

0:07:21being, just being candid here, it was immediate. It was obviously the best desktop operating system

0:07:27ever, but it was, what do you think? I think it was, I think it was 10.2 before it got good.

0:07:34Yeah. That's, yeah, that's probably where, 10.2, yeah, there was like a blurring of some,

0:07:42for some people it was 10.2, some say 10.3, 10.4, which I think was Tiger,

0:07:47I think was the one that was sort of universal. Or almost everybody could agree that the combination

0:07:56of Mac OS X getting faster and supporting more old stuff that people were waiting for, combined with

0:08:02classic getting longer and longer in the tooth because they weren't.

0:08:07Right. And you also had the Intel transition that happened with Tiger as well, right?

0:08:11So you had finally, you had like that. Yeah. So you had like good hardware, right? So you had like,

0:08:16you had spotlight, you had all kinds of stuff. Yeah.

0:08:18Yeah. They needed the hardware to get faster just to be fast enough to run the software.

0:08:24But I mean, genuinely, I mean, unless you were running in like one of the towers, in which case

0:08:28you're like, great. Okay. As long as you need to like heat your house, it's great. But yeah.

0:08:33I just thought that was really cool. Serendipity of it's on my mind now this week, because Apple

0:08:39is already, you know, as two versions now of these operating systems in beta this summer,

0:08:44they've told us all the features, they do this now every year. And it's not just three months

0:08:50in advance from June to September. It's really sort of the roadmap for the next year, or at least

0:08:56yeah, pretty much until WWDC, right? Yeah. I mean, basically, I mean, I think that

0:09:02there was a time when you would basically have everything that was going to launch would launch

0:09:06in September, and then you would maybe have some point releases and whatnot. With macOS, that

0:09:10sometimes maybe that was a little bit different, but it was kind of finalized. But with iOS,

0:09:14especially, and we've seen it with macOS too, it has been interesting in the last probably,

0:09:18I'd say probably five, six years, where they've started to push out features throughout the course

0:09:24of the year. So you might see a preview of something in June, right? And then you might

0:09:29not have it until March, which to your point, and I hadn't even thought of this, is more similar to

0:09:34what it was like in before now, now, now times, right? When 25 years ago, it made sense to kind of,

0:09:43I think, pre-announce, especially for Apple, who was in a different position of, I guess,

0:09:49a different power position than they are now. They really needed to let developers know as quickly as

0:09:54possible what was happening, especially in the macOS 10 era, right? Because there had already

0:09:59been so many aborted attempts at getting the next generation OS. They'd already burned a lot of

0:10:04devs, which I know probably firsthand from either experience or from places you worked, where people

0:10:10are like, "Oh, we're going to be doing this Rhapsody thing." Oh no, nevermind, right? And then

0:10:13it made sense to, I think, kind of let people know as early as possible, this is what we're working

0:10:19on so that they could start planning accordingly. That hasn't really been the case in the iOS era.

0:10:24But again, like in the last five or six years, it has been interesting that they'll kind of

0:10:29announce and kind of show off a vision of a feature that might not be realized and finalized for

0:10:35several months after the initial OS release comes out. Yeah. I thought it was interesting at the old

0:10:41demo where Jobs was showing, and it was mostly about the dock, the whole nine-minute video is

0:10:47like about the dock, and single window mode was considered a dock feature because, like I said,

0:10:52as you switch between apps or windows... Right, it would just kind of...

0:10:56Go in and out of the dock. Yeah. And it included the, I don't know what the,

0:11:00he said there's a shortcut. He didn't say what it was, Jobs, while he's demoing it. But, you know,

0:11:05in modern day, it's the shift key, it has been for 20 years where if you hit, you know, I'm sure

0:11:11somebody out there listening to the podcast is about to have their mind blown. But if you hold

0:11:15down the shift key, when you hit the yellow button on a Mac window, it goes into the dock in slow

0:11:24motion, which is really cool. And it was there in 2000, just so he could show how cool it was.

0:11:32And he even showed, it was, this is how old it was, it was a trailer for Mission Impossible 2.

0:11:38Oh my God. That's so funny.

0:11:41But in terms of some things changed, some don't, there are still Tom Cruise starring

0:11:49Mission Impossible movies coming out. So... Yes. Well, I mean, forever, right? I mean,

0:11:54well, what's funny, that reminds me, I don't know if you've ever read Gil Amelio's book, which,

0:11:59if you haven't, it's so good because it's so bad, but it's genuinely one of my favorite,

0:12:04completely tone deaf memoirs ever. It's called 500 Days on the Firing Line or something like that.

0:12:07Which is a great title, you know, he didn't come up with, you know, that his publisher was like,

0:12:13this is not going to sell many copies. And this is a self-own in every respect, but man,

0:12:19we're going to give it the correct title. But, you know, the entire book is just kind of an

0:12:23apology for, and it wasn't my fault, it was basically the thesis of the book. And then

0:12:28when you read it, you're like, it kind of was your fault, Gil, it kind of was. But one of my

0:12:33favorite anecdotes in it is he talks about how he spent, he's bragging about himself, how he spent

0:12:38all this time getting Whoopi Goldberg's Nephew, one of the power books that was in Mission

0:12:43Impossible, because she wanted one and he was like, very proud of himself for this. Keep in

0:12:48mind, this was like one of the famous power books that like overheated that they had to like recall

0:12:53because of the battery issues. So,

0:12:57Dave Asprey Oh, man, like the what was it the 5400 or something?

0:13:01Jessica Vinas-Nelson Yeah, I think I think it was that one. And it

0:13:03was in and he was very frustrated because they had this massive media moment with that MacBook

0:13:08and that power book rather in that huge movie. And then it was it was a recall, they had to recall it

0:13:13like it was it was one that they really couldn't ship and it was just not a good product.

0:13:18And so I'm happy that they were able to at least I guess keep that Paramount relationship

0:13:23intact so that they could get the product placement for Mission Impossible too.

0:13:27But yeah, it is crazy that we're however many years later and Ethan Hunt is still is still

0:13:33Ethan hunting. And we're like, yeah, you're gonna be 70 years old and hanging off the side of a

0:13:38helicopter and we're, we're gonna be like, yeah, because you're Tom Cruise. Makes sense. That's

0:13:44just what you do. Dave

0:13:46I am going to tell you I don't think I've told this story yet. I have such terrible podcast

0:13:51amnesia, but I don't think I have. I think you're going to enjoy this. And I've, I've been thinking

0:13:56about telling this story now for seven, eight weeks. So backstage at my live show this year

0:14:04at WWDC.

0:14:05Jessica Vinas-Nelson Which was great. By the way, I was there. It was awesome.

0:14:08Dave Oh, yes, you were there. Thank you. Thank you for coming. Thank you for the good words.

0:14:12I am drawing a blank on his name. And maybe it's best that I am. All I remember now, I have it

0:14:18written down somewhere in a notebook, but it's, it was one of those names like Sean, but it wasn't

0:14:25Sean, but where it could be spelled two different ways. I had to figure out how to spell it. But

0:14:29anyway, he's sort of an old, I would say a gentleman in his late 60s, sort of a hippie,

0:14:35long hair, kind of seemed to have enjoyed some, some marijuana before. He's the sound one of the

0:14:43sound guys for the California theater. And he was probably kidding. He was putting my lapel mic on

0:14:51and my battery pack. And we went out and did a sound check with me on stage. And you know,

0:14:59this year was a little different because we had the 3d cameras for the sandwich vision broadcast.

0:15:05The spot where I was going to stand had to be adjusted, you know, so that I'm in camera,

0:15:10blah, blah, blah. And, you know, we're doing the sound check and he's, I've never met this guy,

0:15:15been at that theater before, but I don't know how, you know, if it's like a day gig type thing. I

0:15:21mean, he's, but anyway, he's been doing sound for shows in Silicon Valley for decades. And I,

0:15:32lovely gentleman and I'd somehow, I think he asked me if I'd ever met Steve Jobs.

0:15:37And I told him I had twice, really told him briefly about it. And he said that he did,

0:15:45I think three times, three or four times where he had miked him for events. And he said,

0:15:53I'll tell you one story. And he didn't remember the year, but it was the year where Gil Amelio and

0:15:59Steve Jobs, I think it was the infamous horrible Gil Amelio never ending keynote, which I think was

0:16:07like Macworld. Oh yeah, where he had the terrible shirt, which he also wrote about in the book and

0:16:11he complained about the shirt. Yes. The keynote where I think Muhammad Ali was there and also

0:16:17Waz was there, which Steve Jobs was not happy about, but that had been an

0:16:22Amelio idea to have them together. Sorry, go on. Yeah.

0:16:24It was just after, so it was probably like Macworld 1997 in January and the deal to reunify

0:16:32and acquire next was in December of 1996. So it's January, they're going to announce this. They're

0:16:39going to announce that Steve Jobs is going to be a special advisor while Gil Amelio remains the,

0:16:45and he said that he'd miked them both and they went into the nicest green room, just the two of

0:16:51them. But unbeknownst to them, they were still miked and he could hear everything they were

0:16:57saying. Oh my God. And he said that Steve got going about something and I, it's something about,

0:17:06and I think it was because of, I forget if Muhammad Ali was there too, he didn't say, but

0:17:11you know, they had some special guests and Steve said, what we should do for these things is start

0:17:17having great musical bands come in as the special guests and let them play. And he said, you know

0:17:24who we should get? We should get the Grateful Dead. That's it. They're a great American band

0:17:29with a great history and they really kind of stand for a lot of the stuff that Apple stands for. And

0:17:34he said he went on and on and he said there was just silence from Gil Amelio. And then he said,

0:17:43Steve said to him, you've never dropped acid and gone to a concert, have you? And Gil Amelio said,

0:17:48no. And I said, that was the end of the conversation. And they just sat in silence

0:17:54afterwards. And I said to him, I said, you might've heard the moment when it clicked in

0:18:00Steve Jobs, the moment when it clicked in his head, I got to get rid of this bozo.

0:18:05Yeah. No, I think you nailed it. That's fantastic. I think he was there for it. He like,

0:18:10it probably been, you know, in Steve's mind, he's like, I don't know, I'm selling the company.

0:18:14Maybe I'll just focus on Pixar, whatever. Who knows? Then he talks to this guy and goes,

0:18:18oh no, oh no, no, no, no. We're getting rid of this guy. I'm coming back in. I'm saving this.

0:18:23We're taking this back. We're not letting the guy who's never been high at a concert. We're

0:18:29not letting him run Apple, right? No. He said from his perspective, he honestly wondered if

0:18:38Gil Amelio had ever heard of the Grateful Dead. And you know what I mean? This isn't like,

0:18:42it was like the year 1997. It's pretty well known.

0:18:47They were, I mean, you know what? I would bet that Gil Amelio is probably like my parents

0:18:51and that they knew of the dead. My parents have been dead heads, but because my parents are just

0:18:56not the types of people. My mom is definitely into the Beatles. She liked the Stones too. My dad

0:19:01is a little bit older than her. And so he doesn't even like that as much, but they have like

0:19:04different types of things. My parents are too straight edge for that sort of thing. So I bet

0:19:08that's Gil Amelio where he's like, no, because I think he came from a semiconductor company or

0:19:13something. Yeah. National semiconductor. That's right. That's right. Yeah.

0:19:18I mean, I don't want to go off on a Gil Amelio tangent more than we already have, but I do

0:19:26remember thinking as an outsider, God, I wish I had been writing Daring Fireball just five, six,

0:19:32seven years earlier. So there'd be an archive of it. But I remember having being mostly queasy

0:19:39because even then I thought that an outsider could never properly run Apple. I still think that's

0:19:47true, but Apple had been in such trouble that who knows? I mean, I don't know. It just seemed so,

0:19:58the situation seemed so dire. And then some of the things he said seemed to make sense.

0:20:03Totally.

0:20:03He often made the connection that he wanted Apple. He saw Apple to computers, what Maglite

0:20:09is to flashlights and that anybody can go into any store and buy those plastic ever-ready flashlights

0:20:17for $3 and they work. And probably 95% of the dashboards in cars in America have one of them

0:20:25in there. But if you really care, you're willing to spend 10 times that or more than 10 times that

0:20:31and get a Maglite flashlight that's made of actual steel and it's made in America and the buttons

0:20:38are really nice and it's brighter. Everything about it is better. And it costs a lot more.

0:20:43And he said, "That's what I think Apple is to computers." And I thought, "Oh, that's pretty

0:20:47good." And then the guy shows up for keynotes wearing a suit and it's, "That's not Apple."

0:20:52No. And then in addition to be like, "Oh, we want to be the definitive thing. You pay more for us.

0:20:57Oh, but we're also going to license the... We're going to let people do clones." Right?

0:21:01So I think that... I don't know. He's one of my favorite kind of exec stories because he's just

0:21:06the wrong hire. A lot of his ideas for turnaround would have worked at a different company.

0:21:11And they weren't even bad things. And you can credit him for Johnny Ive a little bit because

0:21:19he was the one who really kind of elevated some of that and Johnny Ive's predecessor a little bit,

0:21:24at least keeping them in the flow of things there. But he's just the wrong guy for the company. I

0:21:31mean, look, Apple did not hit the problems that it hit because of him. He came in after Michael

0:21:36Spindler, right? There was already so much turmoil, but he was just... I think that his techniques

0:21:43would have worked at a different type of company, just not Apple. And we are fortunate that he was

0:21:48at least smart enough to buy the right macOS spinoff to get next instead of B. And...

0:21:55Yeah. Yeah. He made the one... The most important decision he made wound up being the one that was

0:22:03ultimately the best decision in the history of the company for sure. And the industry probably.

0:22:10Like when it came down to one single decision, you'd have to go back... The only things you could

0:22:16compare it to would be like Gates talking IBM into licensing DOS from Microsoft. There's a couple of

0:22:23singular moments where you can easily see how whoever made the decision could have decided

0:22:29something else. Some other engineer at IBM could have said, "Come on, we can write our own DOS."

0:22:34Yeah. The guy from... I can't remember what company it was, but the guy made a digital research,

0:22:39I guess that's what it was. Like could have not been on the airplane and could have taken

0:22:43the call from IBM or whatever. I think that's apocryphal. I don't think that's quite true.

0:22:48People have disputed that, but I think there's enough truth in it to be like there was some of

0:22:53it there. But yeah, you can see how, yeah, if that hadn't happened, things would be different. And

0:22:57the same thing with Apple. And so, yeah, I mean, to all the shit that I like to talk about Gil

0:23:01Emilio, admittedly, again, to your point, when it matters, he made probably one of the most important

0:23:06business decisions in modern history. And that was a really good thing. Just put that on your

0:23:13epithet, dude. That's what made, I think, the book so funny is that it's just this whole tome about

0:23:18him basically rationalizing all this bad decision. It's like all you really had to do is be like,

0:23:23"I brought back Steve Jobs." That's all you had to do. That's it. That's it. Don't focus on any of

0:23:29the other stuff. That's it. And then just like sell yourself on the speaking circuit on that alone.

0:23:33"Oh yeah, I had the foresight to see this and then get out of the way." Like just do that.

0:23:37That would have been a better title for his book. "I brought back Steve Jobs."

0:23:41Yeah, absolutely. Not just to Apple, but from the wilderness,

0:23:46really. Right? I mean, everybody, you know, it's weird how young Jobs was at the time to say he was

0:23:52sort of in the wilderness, but he was. Next was sort of languishing. It certainly wasn't super

0:23:57relevant at any point in the Next's company history. People, pundits like me at the time,

0:24:04always talked about Steve Jobs in the past tense. It was kind of weird.

0:24:10And then he had this beautiful kind of one-two thing with the success finally of Pixar after

0:24:14years of struggling the breakthrough with Toy Story and that becoming like a real thing.

0:24:19I know.

0:24:19And then basically the same time, like a year later, Apple is, "We want you back."

0:24:25Or, "We want to buy your company. We don't necessarily want you back." And he's like, "Okay,

0:24:29well, there we go." Suddenly like the relevancy thing is just off the chart.

0:24:34Yeah. It's just crazy how stuff works out sometimes. It really is. What a digression

0:24:39from talking about iOS 18.1. You mentioned in the show notes, and I am the same way, there is

0:24:45no way I've got a couple of trips for August coming up. There's no way I'm putting any beta,

0:24:53let alone the next beta on my carry phone. So I will wait until after my vacation time. I'll wait

0:25:02till the end of August to put it on my regular phone. And because my regular phone is my only

0:25:0715 Pro and therefore the only phone I have that's eligible for Apple intelligence,

0:25:11seemingly no point really to trying these new betas, the 0.1 betas on Mac or iOS if you don't

0:25:21have an Apple intelligence compatible machine. Right. Yeah. I might put it on my personal M3

0:25:31Macs MacBook, but I'm either on a separate partition or something, or container, whatever the

0:25:38term is. But yeah, I'm not putting it on my phone. I would love to play around with it,

0:25:44but I'm like, I don't have two iPhone 15 Pro Maxes. I just, I don't. So I will just have to

0:25:50wait until yeah, probably end of August, like you, once it's basically about to kind of be released.

0:25:56And then I'm like, all right, now I'll play around with some stuff. I do think Apple under Craig

0:26:02Federighi, and it almost pains me to admit it because now that I see Federighi every year at

0:26:10my show, it's like, I'd rather be able to kid him about it. But I feel like their engineering

0:26:18discipline is just at an unprecedented level year over year that they, the way that they've,

0:26:26without ever announcing it officially, but clearly by evidence have switched to a, from a,

0:26:35let's try to get everything we announced at June out in the big release in September or October,

0:26:42depending on whether it's iOS or Mac to let's figure out how we can slot these features into

0:26:49dot updates a couple of weeks after September, we'll get one out in November, December, then

0:26:56we'll have one in January, February, and then we'll have a last one in the early spring.

0:27:01It's been a really good, I think the last, I forget the numbers, but I think it might've been

0:27:08iOS 13, four or five years ago was a really, really rocky September version. It was the one where

0:27:16the iPhones came out with it and they came out with, I think it was 13.

0:27:22I think it was 13, right? Yeah. They had to do the point release basically in the boxes before

0:27:26they developed the technology to do it. But it was one of those where like, you had to run an update

0:27:30before you could even set up your new phone because it was like that rocky. Yeah.

0:27:34Yeah. It was, it was pretty bad. And I feel like that might've been their, Hey, let's not let this

0:27:39happen again moment. And I feel like the way they've managed it since has been really

0:27:44It's improved a lot. I fully agree. I will say though, like just as an end user who I do usually

0:27:50have a separate phone that I can use for testing, although not in years like this for some of the

0:27:56Apple intelligence features. But before I transitioned careers, like Apple would usually

0:28:02kindly supply me with a, a, a loaner phone to, to use that I could run betas on. And, and I would

0:28:08put it on my, my main phone too, but it was just kind of like part of the job now that that doesn't

0:28:12have to be part of my job. I will say that. I think it was iOS 13. That whole beta process was

0:28:19so Rocky and so bad that that kind of dispelled me of the notion of being like, yeah, I'm not,

0:28:24I'm not putting this on my main carry until I get kind of a heads up from people I trust online,

0:28:31that it's not going to be a disaster. And I know they've improved the processes since then.

0:28:34But it, that was kind of one of those moments for me where I'm kind of like, I know they,

0:28:38and I agree with you, I think it's really impressive what they've done, but I'm still

0:28:41skittish. I'm like, nah, I'm out of weight. I remember that one. And it was public. I mean,

0:28:47people, you know, we were talking about it on podcasts and blogging about it, but it was like,

0:28:51I don't know, like August 21st or somewhere around not quite the very end of August,

0:28:57but like last week of August. And it was an awful beta, just awful. I don't know what exactly the

0:29:03problem is. There were some crashes. Maybe it was like, you'd start at 100% battery life and

0:29:08two and a half hours later, it was like dead, dead, just right up and just be dead. Yeah,

0:29:12that was, that's what I remember the battery life just being atrocious, crashing too. But I really

0:29:16remember the battery life. Right. And if you hadn't been paying attention to it, you're like,

0:29:19I didn't even get like an alert, like a low power alert. It's my phone's right dead. And it's warm

0:29:25and it's plug it in, wait. And yeah. But what I remember was everybody doing the math. Well,

0:29:30wait a minute. We were, they always hold these iPhone events in September, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12,

0:29:37somewhere in those early days of September, the new iPhones have to have the new OS. That's the

0:29:43only OS with the hardware support. And so like doing the math of like, when did these factories

0:29:49start churning out a million of these things a day or millions of these things a day?

0:29:55It's gotta be around now. Right. I even, and we're all like, well, but then that would mean

0:30:00they're going to ship all these phones with a really buggy OS. And we're like, I guess.

0:30:05And then turned out they did. They did. They did. They had to like get out at the point update

0:30:11literally like the day before, day after. Yeah. Which is, yeah. I think that I do, I do appreciate

0:30:17kind of this approach. And I have to say, even though I'm like, I'm not a windows user,

0:30:20this is something Microsoft does a little bit too with, with the, I guess their current kind of

0:30:24like windows thing where they basically have either one or two big kind of releases each year.

0:30:29And I think that splitting things up that way, like I like Apple's approach of announcing it all

0:30:33at WWDC and then kind of slowly rolling things out over the year. I think that's a much,

0:30:38I have to imagine that for the engineers, it's a better process for them. They don't feel as

0:30:42constrained by crunch. And I think for end users too, there is something to be said about the fact

0:30:47that because of the longer beta process and the fact that people can get used to things like

0:30:53you're aware of features and you're, there's like more of a education aspect where people can kind

0:30:57of, you know, through kind of the ethos of social media or friends or whatever, kind of become aware

0:31:02and be like, Oh, okay, this is what's going to come. And this is, this is what this is. So it's,

0:31:06it's not as, as much of a day one dump that it was before where sometimes people, a new feature will

0:31:13come out and there were so many of them that people don't even know what something is, right? Like

0:31:16they don't even know, might not even discover it for years until somebody points it out. And so

0:31:22I think that's kind of one of the benefits too, is slow rolling it a little bit, give some of those

0:31:26new things, a chance for people to really discover, especially when it comes to UI changes.

0:31:30Trenton Larkin Yeah, I think so too. I think that's sort of

0:31:33underappreciated, but I find myself even as an obsessive who professionally covers new features

0:31:39and stuff like that, I actually do find that I, turning them out over a couple of releases over

0:31:46the year does bring attention to features that if they all came out at once, maybe one of them would

0:31:51have been, I didn't even know I've had that since October. I didn't even realize that it's less

0:31:56likely to happen. I do think, so I think good for Apple that they've got these two forks of the OSs

0:32:04right now. I suspect, and I'm hearing from a couple of friends, this is not great for third

0:32:10party developers, really. And especially I think on the iOS side, which let's face it is A, the

0:32:17highest priority one, and it's certainly the one with the most users. But the problem is now what

0:32:23do you do if you're a developer and you've got a testing phone? Do you run 18.0 betas because that's

0:32:30the one that's coming first? Or do you put 18.1 beta on because you would like to start integrating

0:32:39Apple intelligence features or test the ones that are built into the system, right? Like the,

0:32:45and we'll get to this in a second, the writing tools feature is one of the features that's

0:32:51already in the first beta where you, any system-wide text field, you can select some

0:32:56text, bring up the writing tools and say, make the sound more professional or make it funnier

0:33:03or something like that. And if you want to make sure, 'cause you're thinking, well, our text field

0:33:08we're subclassing UI text field or whatever, but we've done enough customizations for whatever

0:33:15reason. I've been a little worried ever since WWDC that ours isn't going to work, but now what do you

0:33:21do? Like how many iPhone 15 pros are you supposed to have for testing? Well, that's, I mean, this

0:33:28is the frustrating thing, right? Is that these are, it was easier a decade ago when the median

0:33:34price of the phone was like $700, but now it's more than that. And you already have the struggle

0:33:41of having to test on a number of different screen sizes and device types and whatnot. But yeah,

0:33:45to your point, like how many pros are you supposed to have? And it's okay, well, maybe I have a whole

0:33:49collection of pros at that catalog. But only this one. Exactly. These are $1,100 phones. You're

0:33:55like, okay. And it's also, it's one of those things, 'cause it's okay. And I know they would

0:34:00never do this. I know they wouldn't, even for developers, I know they wouldn't, but it does make

0:34:04you think you're like, man, why can't they just let you dual boot like two different OS versions

0:34:09if you're one of the very special jail mode, right? That would be just for developers, like

0:34:13not even like you can even disable certain telephony or other types. Well, I guess you'd

0:34:17have to have telephony, but you could even disable certain like user focused features, but just be

0:34:22able to do that just for testing would be really nice. It also kind of, again, kind of opens up,

0:34:26I think what people have wanted for a long time and Apple's even sued some people over this. This

0:34:30is why people try to create virtualized versions of iOS that they can run on their Mac so that they

0:34:36can at least experiment with things. It might not be the same as the, although at this point it would

0:34:40be the same as the normal hardware, but basically, but that would be a good way to be able to test to

0:34:44see, okay, is this going to work or is it not without having to buy multiple $1,100 phones

0:34:49that are going to be obsolete. This is a bad thing, right? They're literally going to be obsolete in

0:34:54six weeks and you're going to have to buy multiple of the next iPhone 15. You're going to have to get

0:35:01like a bunch of, or 16, you're going to have to get a bunch of those, the pro versions of those,

0:35:06right? So there are very few, very few things that I would feel confident saying that every single

0:35:13person listening to this podcast would agree upon. But I think here's one where I think we could ask

0:35:20every single one of the tens of thousands of people who are listening to this episode,

0:35:24what month of the year is the worst month of the year to buy a new iPhone?

0:35:28Yep. August. Yep. August. August.

0:35:31Always. Always. Well, it's so funny because I have friends who their phones will break and like,

0:35:34if your phone breaks, your phone breaks, but I'm always like, okay, do we have a used one? Do I

0:35:38have an old one I can send you? Can you get a good trade in thing? Like, what's the best deal

0:35:43you can do? I have two. I have two. I've done that multiple times for friends because it is just one

0:35:47of those. Yeah, it's the worst time. Like the only way I would ever suggest it would be like,

0:35:52you don't have any other choice and they're giving you one hell of a trade in for your old broken

0:35:58phone and without a shadow of a doubt that you have no interest or budget to be able to buy

0:36:03the next year's model. Like that's the only way because otherwise, yeah, like,

0:36:08yeah. If you were already going to buy like the iPhone 14 or whatever, or 13, which I think they

0:36:15still sell. Sure. Why not? It doesn't matter. You could wait a month and get then for the same price

0:36:20the iPhone 14 would drop down, but you don't care. So just buy the phone. But otherwise, yeah. And

0:36:25the other thing too, I know this, I have enough friends, you know, who work, you know, I have

0:36:30friends who are totally indie like me, like one person companies. I know people who work at mid-size

0:36:36companies and I have friends who work at very large companies and even at like very large

0:36:42companies, it is often hard to requisition hardware. You can't just because you work at,

0:36:49I'll just say Netflix, right? A very successful company. You can't just raise your hand and say,

0:36:54yeah, we need a bunch of iPhone 15 pros because now we've got to install this. That may not work.

0:37:00No. Well, especially when they know they're like, okay, but we're going to be getting a requisition

0:37:03in literally six weeks for a bunch of iPhone 16 pros, right? Because that's the ones we're really

0:37:09going to want to focus on because we know that that'll have even more RAM and that's going to

0:37:12have even more neural imp users and other other things that we know that no matter what Greg

0:37:18Jazwiak would never tell us that they're going to be releasing, they're going to be really

0:37:22optimized for this software, right? Which honestly, maybe, I don't know, which honestly kind of is one

0:37:30of the reasons why I haven't been as focused, at least on the phone side about even testing

0:37:34anything because I have such a strong feeling. I'm like, okay, if they're gatekeeping it so much,

0:37:39just for the current pro devices and select Apple Silicon machines, if they're gatekeeping it to that

0:37:46degree, that really says to me, okay, well then the 16 is going to be the one that's really going

0:37:51to be able to show this stuff off. So in my mind, I'm kind of like, I'm not building apps, right?

0:37:55Like I'm an enthusiast, but I'm not building apps. I'm not having to write about all these features.

0:37:58So I'm in a little bit of a different position where I'm just like, yeah, I can wait until the

0:38:02new phone comes out to really play with this stuff because that's going to be the better experience

0:38:08anyway. And also I'm only going to have this phone for like six more weeks.

0:38:12Right. And again, this is pure speculation. I literally, nobody would tell me this anyway.

0:38:18And nobody who knows would tell me, but I wouldn't be surprised too, if both for legitimate silicon

0:38:28reasons, because the iPhone 16 chip is designed for this, that in addition to doing a better job

0:38:36running all of the Apple intelligence features that Apple already showed us in June,

0:38:40wouldn't be surprised if there's X, Y, and Z Apple intelligence features that only run on the iPhone

0:38:4716 Pro. Absolutely. No, I have the same and even fewer people would, no one would tell me,

0:38:53people wouldn't tell you, they would certainly never tell me. So yeah, again, just pure

0:38:57speculation, but that's been kind of my thought too, because they do that a lot, right? Where

0:39:00there will be some things that we only learn about at the launch event. And this, it struck

0:39:05me actually watching the keynote last month, actually, where I was like there now close to

0:39:11two months ago, where I was thinking, I was like, okay, they're so light on so many of the details

0:39:16on this. We don't know when this is hitting beta, the real extra wow features and some of the other

0:39:21stuff is only going to be available probably again, like for hardware design, all kinds of

0:39:25reasons on the next phone, right? Like we're getting a real preview of this now kind of at

0:39:31a high level. That's how I viewed the keynote at WWDC was this is setting out our vision, no pun

0:39:38intended, of how we see the AI landscape, not this is a well trotted out narrative of everything we

0:39:46expect to accomplish, more like this is our high level goal. And we'll sprinkle in the details as

0:39:51things become more available and as we learn more and as we get more feedback and as hardware is

0:39:55better, but it was very much kind of much more aspirational, I think, rather than prescriptive,

0:40:01which has not been the case for a lot of years and is not a typically very Apple thing to do.

0:40:06But I think in this case makes a lot of sense, especially just given how much the tech,

0:40:10not just raffle, but for everyone is changing so quickly.

0:40:13Trenton Larkin Yeah. Yeah. If I had to guess and it's just because

0:40:17the camera is so important and somebody did a poll is like, what do people who think they might buy

0:40:25a phone? Anybody just general public, not nerds. What are the biggest priorities for the next phone

0:40:30you buy? And it's I might get the order wrong price, battery life camera. I think that's the

0:40:38order though. And of course, everything everybody buys in life price matters. So price is always

0:40:43first. It's almost like you could take it off the list. Right. Battery life for features is above

0:40:49everything else. And it's true. I mean, we all bitch about it, but it's true. And for all of

0:40:55the fancy portrait mode and slow motion mode and cinematic mode in the camera and all the Apple

0:41:00intelligence stuff coming out this year, and whatever new apps that come out, blah, blah, blah,

0:41:04battery, battery, battery, battery, battery. But the camera is third. And there's a reason

0:41:09that Apple has been running. I forget how many years now. As far as I know, it's the only

0:41:16permanent ad campaign in tech history. Maybe the shot on my phone campaign. Is that what you're

0:41:22talking about? Yeah. Shot on iPhone. Yeah. It goes back easily over 10 years. And with absolutely no

0:41:30abatement, billboards all over the place. I live near a billboard here that Apple has had

0:41:37continuously for years. There's a couple of them, I think in center city, Philadelphia, but I know

0:41:41of one. And new iPhones come out. It's always for the new iPhones. And there's other things.

0:41:47I think right now it's a Safari, the actually private browser right now. In the summertime

0:41:56when there's no new actual products, that's when they'll do something like a privacy ad,

0:42:01but at least a few months of the year shot on iPhone. It's super important. I could definitely

0:42:08see how there would be. And they didn't really talk too much about Apple intelligence in the

0:42:12camera. They talked about it with photos, the photos app. Apple intelligence will categorize.

0:42:18Exactly. Because I think they want to be really careful there. Like A, they don't want to be like

0:42:24Samsung and create the moon out of thin air. And I think even more to the point, because Apple has

0:42:31been one of the pioneers of this, we've been using AI to make photography better for a decade now.

0:42:38And that was a different type of AI than the AI we're talking about now. But that's,

0:42:40it's been a consistent thing. Google has done a great job with that too. A lot of upscaling

0:42:45things. There's a lot of things that go into that. But when we talk about this new era of AI and

0:42:51generative AI, I think Apple wants to be really careful not to conflate things because they still

0:42:56want people to feel like the photos you take are your photos. And this isn't something that is

0:43:01changing reality for you. And it's not using, it's not training on your photos, which is an

0:43:07important thing, but it's also not retrospectively, again, to use the Samsung analogy, yeah, great,

0:43:11that moon looks awesome. That's not the moon. You don't want it to change what actually happens. And

0:43:16so I think you have to be careful how you thread that needle. But I do expect to see some things on

0:43:22the hardware level, like improvements, right? I anticipate that how it will be with the narrative

0:43:28around that will be, will again, to my point, it won't be about anything is changing, but just

0:43:32look at how much better we're going to make this so that you can take the perfect shot.

0:43:36We're going to do an even better job at automatically selecting the right frame.

0:43:40They're not going to take the gray out of my hair and my beard, right? They're not going to make me

0:43:44look 10 years younger as much as I wish they could. But I mean, I would love that if they could,

0:43:49but yeah, yeah, they might do a better job of making sure everybody's eyes are open.

0:43:53I don't know color balance and all sorts of stuff they could do along that spectrum. And then they

0:43:57could say this is powered by Apple intelligence only because of the whatever chip the A exactly

0:44:03will be the A 18 pro blah, blah, blah. Before we move on, you sent me a tweet. Somebody's already.

0:44:10Yes. I've loved this so much. This is so good.

0:44:13How do we, how do we put this on podcast terms though? It's not really an explicit podcast.

0:44:18Yeah. Okay. So we'll just use the word F I guess.

0:44:24Yeah. Yeah. This is great.

0:44:27You want to read it or should I maybe I should.

0:44:30Yeah, you go ahead. You read it. I will put this into show notes. Hold on. Let me,

0:44:34let me do this right now. But somebody on Twitter was like, no, Apple intelligence. No. And what

0:44:40they did is they typed in. Let's F daddy selected it. And with the actual F word spelled out

0:44:49and then use the writing tools. Yeah. Let's F daddy select all writing tools.

0:44:55Professional professional, make it professional.

0:45:00And then it changed it to let us engage in sexual intercourse with our father.

0:45:05And they added, they added the period, which is more professional.

0:45:10It is, it is more special and then submissive. Okay. It's not wrong though. And then they added

0:45:15in a comma. But I think I don't think no Apple no is I think that's the wrong take. I think that

0:45:24Apple intelligence should do this because I agree. It's Oh no, no, no, no, no. I think no was was

0:45:31saying this is not the correct interpretation of what I was writing. I don't think it was. I don't

0:45:38think it was St. Apple should do this. Cause I agree with you. I was actually thrilled to see,

0:45:41I see what you mean. I see. I see. I see. You're there. They're dinging Apple intelligence,

0:45:48not for allowing them to say inappropriate things, but for not getting what the original slang intent

0:45:56was. Exactly. Which, which is, which is, which is, which is why when they added in a comma,

0:46:01which is great, the comma is better. It's it says, let's F comma daddy. It becomes when you

0:46:06use professional, it becomes let us engage in sexual intercourse, comma father. Much better,

0:46:15much better. I get it now. So I'm glad we talked about this. I get it. I misinterpreted what,

0:46:20what their objection was, but now they're on team team us that you should be, it shouldn't,

0:46:25shouldn't bring up topics like this unprompted, but if you input something like this,

0:46:31that's your artwork and, or, or your communication. And, and we talked about it on at my show and they

0:46:38were like, yeah, if you, you get to be you and Apple intelligence will help you, but Apple

0:46:43intelligence shouldn't be bringing this topic up out of nowhere. No, it definitely shouldn't,

0:46:48right? It shouldn't be suggesting that, especially in a professional context, probably any context,

0:46:52it shouldn't be suggesting that. However, if you're trying to yeah, professionalize your,

0:46:57your, your sex or whatever, that should be, yeah, your flirtation. Absolutely. I mean, look,

0:47:03I'm hoping that I, I, I'm really into emoji pastas, which are like the ridiculous, like

0:47:08chain texts that people send with that are very, very, very profane with those emoji things. And,

0:47:13and I've used various like generator things for years and I'm a big fan of those,

0:47:17my friends and I, but I would love for Apple intelligence to help me create those. Right?

0:47:22Like that would be in, in, in a peak world, something that could look at things, help me,

0:47:25help me do this. And I don't know if that'll ever be a thing that they would embrace, but to me,

0:47:29that is kind of the right balance, which is we're not going to suggest those things. But if people,

0:47:35look, people are adults, these are our computers. If you want to use profane language with these

0:47:39tools, if you're told no, that's just to me, that'd be like, okay, well, I'm never using this

0:47:43feature, then what's the point in the same way that it just dumb? No, no AI at all. If you want

0:47:51to write some sort of offensive manifesto in text edit, yeah, or send it to send a very rude or

0:48:00threatening email in mail. You just, you're the one type, you're the one typing these things and

0:48:06it's the computer's just a tool. Apple intelligence is a tool and I think Apple is very clear about

0:48:13that. And I think that's one of the things that's very clarifying about their approach so far to,

0:48:19to LLM AIs. Yeah, no, I totally agree. And I think it's a good thing. And, and I don't know about

0:48:24you. I remember one of the first things doing with the McAnnel entry school was you could make them

0:48:29say things and yeah, typing, trying to see what profanities and what profane things we could get

0:48:34the computer to say, but to just, to reel out, right? This is just the thing that kids are going

0:48:38to do and the people are going to use these tools for and any attempts to prevent that from happening

0:48:45is, is just going to make people even more committed to the bid. And, and it's, I don't

0:48:50think it's the place of, if you're really wanting to be in the background, especially the way that

0:48:54Apple is by making it so clear through their messaging that they want this to be on device

0:48:57as much as possible and that it is private and whatnot. I'm like, okay, well then don't judge

0:49:02me because of what you want to proofread, right? What I want you to proofread.

0:49:06Trenton Larkin All right, let me take a break here and thank

0:49:08our sponsor. It's our good friends at Squarespace. Go to squarespace.com/talkshow. Know the,

0:49:15just slash talk show. You get a 30 day free trial. You get 10% off your first order, everything you

0:49:22would want. That's the URL. Look, they've got a new feature speaking of AI right on, right on

0:49:26subject. They call it Blueprint AI. You can start a completely personalized website with Squarespace's

0:49:33new guided design system, Squarespace Blueprint. You start with professionally curated layouts and

0:49:40styling options, just like which direction do you want to go and asks you some questions and you

0:49:46steer it with just language, which way, how you want it to go. And you can build a unique online

0:49:51presence from the ground up tailored to your brand or your personal personality. Optimize for every

0:49:58device. Of course, easily launch your website and get discovered fast with optimized SEO tools too.

0:50:04That's part of Blueprint. So you can show up more often to more people and grow the way you want to

0:50:10grow. Another great feature at Squarespace, flexible payments. They want me to emphasize

0:50:15this and they really do have all the payment options you could possibly want. For whatever

0:50:21you might be selling, which could be products, could be t-shirts, could be stuff, could be your

0:50:26time if you're a consultant or a trainer or something like that. But if you want to sell

0:50:31stuff through your own website and you build it with Squarespace using their built-in payments,

0:50:36you get credit cards, of course, PayPal, Apple Pay, and in eligible countries, they even offer

0:50:44the buy now pay later stuff like Afterpay and ClearPay, which I actually pronounced correctly

0:50:50for once. I usually say ClearPlay, but ClearPay is the name of the product. They've got all of that

0:50:55you could possibly want and they take care of all the hassles of online commerce that you don't want

0:50:59to deal with, all the stuff that it's just all wrapped around their stuff. You just get the money.

0:51:05Fluid Engine is their new layout tool. Blueprint works with it. But Fluid Engine is the thing that

0:51:14lets you, in addition to the old way where you can, of course, use a desktop computer to do

0:51:19tweaks to your layout or adjustments or something like that. You can do it right from your phone now,

0:51:24right down to your phone or your iPad or something like that. Everything works great. They've

0:51:28optimized it with knowing just how many people their phone is their primary computer these days,

0:51:35and their new Fluid Engine is built with that in mind. And the great thing about building phone

0:51:40first is for anything really is if it works great on the phone, of course, it still works great on

0:51:46the desktop computer. It's really vice versa often doesn't work. Build desktop first often doesn't

0:51:51work, doesn't fit, something like that on the phone. But the other way around works great.

0:51:55Email campaigns, they've got great, great automatic email marketing tools that engage with

0:52:01your community, can help drive sales and simplify audience management. So if you want to run like a

0:52:07newsletter or something like that, you could do all of that through Squarespace too. All of that's

0:52:11available so much more. Just go to squarespace.com/talkshow. You get a free trial 30 days,

0:52:18and you save 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain by using that domain,

0:52:23squarespace.com/talkshow. Well, the other the other reason I've been meaning to have you on

0:52:32the show, Christina was you. I had my identity stolen. And I'm the one who told you. You're the

0:52:41one who figured it out. I was gonna say because of you, I found this out. It's an incredible story.

0:52:45Ridiculous. So what happened? I'll start is, yeah, you start because you're the one who figured this

0:52:52out. So at this point, I guess it's about two or three weeks ago. I keep meaning to write about it,

0:52:58but I'll just talk about it now. But I've been having a strange problem on my Mac with the auto

0:53:04complete feature. And in certain apps, I'm not getting a full list of words. But this is the

0:53:09feature where if you start typing H O S P, and then you hit F5, it should complete with words

0:53:18like hospital. It's been there. I think it might even go back to speaking of next, might go back

0:53:23to next step, certainly has been part of Mac OS X since for 24 years. And for me in certain apps,

0:53:29in some apps, I get the full list of dictionary words. And then in a few apps, it must be some

0:53:35kind of preferences. I don't know, I still haven't figured it out. But it's the main reason I want to

0:53:39write about your story here. So I can get this off my chest. And maybe a reader will help me debug

0:53:43this problem. But anyway, I started searching the web for this, about this feature. And it doesn't

0:53:50really have a name. So it was kind of hard to Google for. And then I found a daring fireball

0:53:57article, or just a brief link, like one of those links where I linked to something and I only wrote

0:54:03one sentence and I didn't even block quote it. And it but it was a link. And I hovered over the link,

0:54:09and it went to Tua, the unofficial Apple web blog for those of you who don't remember, but it was a

0:54:14long standing, very popular group blog run by web blogs, Inc. Right? Yeah, that's right.

0:54:21You know, the early years of daring fireball work coincident with Tua. And I happened to I forget

0:54:29the number. But I because of this story, I've looked up how many times I've linked to Tua over

0:54:34the years. And it's dozens and dozens of times really good site. Lots of great writers started

0:54:39there, including I don't know if you started there, but it was it was my first tech writing. Yes.

0:54:44It's the first time I remember your byline. Yeah, I mean, I was still in college. I did a thing for

0:54:51USA Today about American Idol of all things. That was my first thing that I shocked shocker Christina's

0:54:57shocking, absolutely shocking, Christina. Well, what's shocking is that I got that gig because I

0:55:02was a commenter on the music editors blog. He had a music blog, and then he had an American Idol blog

0:55:08and thought that my comments were smart enough to reach out to me and was like,

0:55:12we're looking for a contributor to the print an online edition about the show. So it was like me

0:55:17and a couple people who actually knew what they were talking about giving the contestants advice

0:55:20each week. So fake it till you make it works. But no, but yeah, Tua was my very first paid for tech

0:55:26writing gig. Yeah. So you say Tua? I always say to most people say to most people say to I think

0:55:33I've always been the aberration there. But yeah, although I guess that brings up the the hawk to a

0:55:38girl it does which people made some really good puns about that actually, which was really,

0:55:43really good. I think I think that 404 media when they wrote about this incident, which will be

0:55:46they wrote they hawked Tua which yes, very good. Well done.

0:55:55So anyway, I found an old Daring Fireball link and I thought I don't remember what I linked to,

0:56:01but it was clear from the little brief thing that I had written that it was a story at Tua

0:56:08about this feature. And I thought, well, if I link to it, it must be good. And I don't mean that to

0:56:14be self serving to me. I just mean that's probably why I linked to it. Oh, and I know that the

0:56:19unofficial Apple web blog got shut down like a decade ago. And unfortunately, whoever still owned

0:56:25it hadn't kept the archive up. And I thought, this isn't the links not going to work. But what

0:56:31I thought was, well, I'll click it anyway, it probably won't resolve. But then I'll copy the

0:56:37link and go to the Internet Archive, paste the link. But when I do I just thought, well, I'll

0:56:44try it first. And before I do the copy and paste with no, I don't even know why I did it that way.

0:56:49It occurred to me to just it actually seemed lazier to do it that way to just click rather

0:56:55than control click, copy and go. It was like, I'll just click it and then I'll copy. But lo and

0:57:01behold, it worked. It loaded. And then I thought to myself, my first thought was, oh, maybe I'm

0:57:08wrong that they took down. Yeah, I don't know. And then I saw that the article's byline was

0:57:16Christina Warren. And I do not have a really great memory of 2006 links at Daring Firewall.

0:57:27Jessica Vinas-Nelson Right.

0:57:27Jared I did think at first,

0:57:29Jessica Vinas-Nelson You're like, that seems odd.

0:57:31Jared Because it doesn't seem like your type of topic,

0:57:34right? Like I said, this is where I first became aware of you. And I remember you writing for TUOP,

0:57:41but I don't remember you writing things like the Esoterica of a nerdy text autocomplete

0:57:49in F5 feature. But I thought maybe. And then I start reading and I'm like, this doesn't sound

0:57:56like what? It's just this, it didn't sound wrong. It just didn't sound like you. And I know your

0:58:04voice, not just your literal voice here. I know. Jessica Vinas-Nelson No, you know my writing

0:58:07voice. Absolutely. Yeah. Jared Absolutely. And I just, spidey sense started going off. And then I

0:58:12got, this is where it gets funny. I get to the bottom and there's the author bio and it says,

0:58:19"Christina Warren is a dedicated writer with a deep love of technology, Christine blah, blah,

0:58:24blah." And there's a photo. And the photo is not you. Jessica Vinas-Nelson It is not me. It is not

0:58:31me. It is not even a real human. Jared Nope. Well, it's got that generic, it is a young

0:58:38white woman with long brown hair. But it's clearly in hindsight AI generated. It doesn't have

0:58:48telltale signs of being AI generated, but you know. Jessica Vinas-Nelson No, but it's just,

0:58:52if you've seen enough of these things, like I do anyway, like I look at them like, "Oh, okay,

0:58:55yeah, this just has a slightly uncanny valley." It was not a bad AI generated photo. And

0:59:01I made this photo in my profile picture for a few days. So I had to stare at it a lot. And I also

0:59:06did it at work, which was very funny. But when you sent me the link, at first I was like, "So go on."

0:59:12Jared Well, that's it. But literally, then I thought this is screwed up. Either something's

0:59:18gone on with Too Odd that I missed, or something has just happened. And I stumbled across it. And

0:59:24so I took a screenshot of it. I forget which I sent to you first, the screenshot of the bio with

0:59:30the picture or just the link. Jessica Vinas-Nelson I think it was just the link. Yeah, it used to be

0:59:34both. I think it was just the link. And I was like, "What in the hell?" And at first, my first

0:59:37thing, because I think it was just the link that came in first, going back, I'm trying to scroll

0:59:41through and find it. I was like, "Okay, what is this?" Because at first I was like, "Oh, yeah,

0:59:46you found like an old link. Yeah, this doesn't resolve anymore. This hasn't resolved in years."

0:59:49And then I clicked on it. And I realized it did resolve. And then I saw the photo and I went,

0:59:54"What the f," but I didn't censor myself. And then I linked you to the author's page. And I said,

1:00:01"LMAO, they stole all of us. This is insane." And they basically just, what we realized they did is

1:00:07they bought the domain from Yahoo, Apollo Global, who were the, I guess, current owners of the

1:00:13domain and whatnot. They sold the domain, but they did not sell the content. It turns out the content

1:00:18actually, they couldn't have sold it. Even if they'd wanted to, it belonged to us. And it was

1:00:23very clear, even in this company's about page, they only bought the content. And then what they

1:00:28did is they scraped the internet archive, ran the archives that they could find through an AI

1:00:34rewriting thing, and then just randomly assigned different authors to different stories. So

1:00:40that link resolved and it was probably similar, but still uncanny valley compared to what an

1:00:47original author wrote back in 2006. But they just randomly assigned author IDs to things.

1:00:53But I had no idea. You were the one who just, you're, and I think you caught it. I think that

1:00:59when people did some research, it looked like it had maybe launched a week earlier. So it was a

1:01:03really, really recent thing. So it was like, I'm so grateful that you happened to be lazy and not

1:01:10go immediately to the internet archive to click on that link, because I don't know when I would

1:01:15have found out that my identity and name was being stolen and reused on stuff. At first,

1:01:22I thought I was like, okay, well, they just, because this has happened before where a domain

1:01:26expires, somebody buys it, and then they create kind of a splog, like a spam blog using archives

1:01:32they can find. And I've seen that for years. That happened to the Hairpin a couple years ago,

1:01:36which was a really great website. But what was, what incensed me where I kind of frankly, like,

1:01:43lost my mind a little bit was that I realized that they were publishing new articles.

1:01:49Yeah. And still using the old author names on those new articles. And that's when I flipped

1:01:57my stuff. Well, the whole thing is so scummy and scammy. I mean, I don't know, we need some kind of

1:02:05combination word for scummy and scammy. But yes, there have been, and I know this firsthand from

1:02:12all of the various domains that have gone defunct that I've linked to 10, 15, 20 years ago, that

1:02:21like the best case scenario is when the domain is just, nothing is there. And it's like, okay,

1:02:26all the URLs are 404s, but you can go to the Internet Archive or whatever. But a lot of them,

1:02:32whatever the scam of the day is, it used to be like links to casino sites or something like that.

1:02:40In recent years, it's more, a lot of times it'll be like a Bitcoin or cryptocurrency type thing.

1:02:47Imagine if they did it with Tuod. Here's a site that used to be the unofficial Apple web blog,

1:02:51and it was a bunch of Mac and iPhone nerd stories. And now it's trying to convince you to give your

1:02:57money to cryptocurrency or something like that. That's the old way. This is sort of,

1:03:04and it could only happen with AI. That's this, I think. I mean, in theory, you could do it

1:03:11another way. But it's so bizarre that this guy, and apparently his name, I have tried to reach

1:03:20out to him, but his name is Haider Ali Khan, and he's bought a bunch of other domains. I forget

1:03:27some of them. What's his name? Ernie? Yeah, Ernie Smith from TDM figured a lot of this out.

1:03:33Ernie Smith from TDM, who anybody who's like, "Ah, where'd I hear of him recently?" He's the guy

1:03:39who figured out the UTM 14 trick to get pure web search results out of Google.

1:03:47You had to get the good Google results. Yeah.

1:03:48So I had linked to him recently and his UTM 14 or whatever the hell it's called site,

1:03:55which I am just jotted down, duly noted to put in the show notes. But he figured out that it's

1:04:00this guy Haider Ali Khan. And I forget what other sites he's bought. iLounge, I think.

1:04:06iLounge, yeah.

1:04:07Yep. And anybody who remembers 2UP, I remember iLounge.

1:04:11Yeah. I remember when it was iPod Lounge. iLounge was probably... That and ThinkSecret

1:04:16were probably two of the earliest in the blog era Apple sites that I remember.

1:04:21Yeah. I still think of it as iPod Lounge too.

1:04:24Yeah. Yeah. I remember when it changed and I was like, "Aw, end of an era." But yeah.

1:04:30But think about that. It is clever. I often think about this. Whenever new technology comes,

1:04:37most people are good people and they are honest people and they don't think of novel ways to rip

1:04:47off, screw and defraud people. They just don't. And the whole history of computing is like things

1:04:57that had never occurred to anybody. And they're like, "Oh yeah, I guess that is insecure."

1:05:01I mean, it used to be. I mean, as late as the '90s for sending email, you would just telnet

1:05:09into email server, an SMTP server on, I forget, it was like port 20 or something like that.

1:05:16And you didn't have to log in. You could just start typing email commands. And so you could

1:05:20send email from any address on that domain to anybody you want to forge an email from somebody

1:05:28because the SMTP protocol was written thinking like, "Well, what's the easiest protocol we could

1:05:35have for sending email?" And it would be like, "Oh, you would just write a program to telnet in

1:05:41on port 20 and start typing commands." Right? And the whole idea of spam, which is a forever problem

1:05:49for email, but the idea that anybody can send email to anybody else, it sounded wonderful

1:05:55originally. And then somebody figured out, "Well, hell, I could send a million of these to every

1:06:00single email address on the internet." All sorts of problems like that. But people just don't think

1:06:07of these things, right? And so I never would have thought of this scam. This never even occurred to

1:06:11me. But what he did, I just, you described it, but I just want to reiterate. So he bought the domain

1:06:17legally from Verizon or whoever, whatever the…

1:06:21Yeah, it's Verizon, yeah, Apollo Global, one of them, yeah.

1:06:26So he bought the domain but did not buy the content rights to everything Tua had written.

1:06:32So all he had was a domain. But he knows somehow, I guess, through the Internet Archive,

1:06:40he scraped the Internet Archive to get all the URLs from old Tua articles and then got the

1:06:48content from them from the Internet Archive. Knew somehow he had the moral compass not to just

1:06:57steal the content, which he didn't have a right to, and paste it in,

1:07:01but instead fed it into AI and said, "Rewrite every one of these articles."

1:07:07Yep.

1:07:09And so the articles are about the same subjects. If you go to the Internet Archive and look at the

1:07:16original, it is about the F5 autocomplete feature. I think it was Dave Campo or somebody had actually

1:07:24written the original article at Tua. And I could see once I read the original on the Internet

1:07:29Archive, I was like, "Oh, yeah, I could see why I linked to this. It was a good article."

1:07:32But what he did is he had every single one of those articles rewritten, put them at the same URL

1:07:37they used to be, and yet for whatever reason decided or maybe by happenstance, just randomly

1:07:45assigned bylines from the list of actual people who had previously written to Tua to each article.

1:07:52So each article, whoever wrote the original one, like there were—here you got assigned to an

1:07:57article you didn't write, and then there were other articles you did write that got us—

1:08:01That you did write and other people's names were on it. Yes.

1:08:03Yeah, like Scott McNulty wrote this article.

1:08:05No, he did not write an article about American Idol or whatever it was that you wrote. They're

1:08:11all mixed up and jumbled. Every single one of these authors, he decided, "I'll use their real

1:08:18names, but I'm going to make AI-generated headshots for each of them. Good to go."

1:08:26Yeah, this is fine. And then had the temerity to write in the about page that, you know,

1:08:35they had meticulously rewritten the articles to match modern standards. And that was when,

1:08:43when I talked to The Verge, they had a really nice poll quote for me that I can't repeat on this

1:08:47show, but it was great. That's when I said that poll quote, because that was when I was like,

1:08:52"Okay, genuinely, you can go believe yourself," because it's bad enough to do all this, but then

1:08:57to write, "Oh, meticulously rewritten to adhere to modern standards." Are you actually out of your

1:09:04mind? Right? And like you, this scam had never occurred to me. Of course, I've seen people rebuy

1:09:09dead domains and revive the URLs and whatnot, but I never thought that somebody would try to

1:09:16revive a brand using the names of the former writers with fake photos, and then do what they

1:09:25did, which is like, "Okay, we want to keep the past links because we want to have good Google

1:09:29juice, but we're not even going, we're going to rewrite them in a mishmash way because we think

1:09:34that'll get us around the copyright infringement. It won't, but we think that'll do it. And we'll

1:09:38just assign different author names because that'll be fine. The actual people who wrote that content,

1:09:43they won't be mad about this at all. Spoiler alert, I was mad. I was very mad.

1:09:48Our good friend, the hater Ali Khan, had originally given himself much credit on the

1:09:58about page as a visionary media mogul and investor. And then surprisingly,

1:10:07once you went public with this on social media and it got picked up by The Verge, it got picked up by

1:10:13404 Media. What's it, Jason? Yeah, Jason Keebler.

1:10:18Keebler? Is that how you pronounce it? I'm not sure, actually. So I probably

1:10:21said it wrong. I apologize, Jason, but he wrote a great post. InGadget wrote about it.

1:10:25Yeah, Jason Snell was really kind enough to link to it early on because he saw my post on Macedon.

1:10:30Because what happened is you told me about this and I was incensed and I was actually sick that

1:10:35day. I was incensed. That's why I saw it a couple hours late. You sent it to me earlier in the day.

1:10:40I woke up because I hadn't been feeling well. I'm incensed. And so I immediately do the only

1:10:46thing that I feel like I can do in that situation, which was like, "Okay, well, I'm going to throw a

1:10:50temper tantrum and hope that people care enough online." And so I posted about it on Twitter and

1:10:54on Threads and other places and people saw this and were understandably, they're like,

1:10:59"Are you kidding me?" Because just everyone else's response was the same response that you and I had,

1:11:03which was I didn't even think that somebody could do something like this, right? I obviously,

1:11:09this is a human problem, not a technology problem, but the way they were able to do this in such a

1:11:13quick way obviously only happens because the AI would allow them to automate the way that they

1:11:18did. But I was incensed and I was like, "Okay." I also sent an email almost immediately to the

1:11:25one contact thing on the site and I was like, "Remove my name from your website immediately.

1:11:30I don't want to be contacting my attorney." And I meant that. I was like, I didn't want to,

1:11:35before I knew anything about the guy, I was like, "There probably isn't even any jurisdiction where

1:11:39I could get these people and I don't really have the time. It's not even a money thing. I don't

1:11:43have the time to fight this, but I just really wanted my name off the website." And so I sent

1:11:48kind of a threatening email and then I had an inkling that it might get some attention because

1:11:54some friends of mine who work at The Verge told me that they were posting about it in their Slack.

1:11:59I was like, "Okay, well maybe they'll do a story," but I wasn't expecting anything.

1:12:02And then my friend Karissa at Engadget was kind enough to write a story. She was assigned,

1:12:06she didn't even like the pitches and they just said, "Hey, can you do this?" She was like,

1:12:09"Can I talk to you about this thing?" And I was like, "Yes, absolutely." And 404 Media was also

1:12:13working on something at the same time. And so I was able to basically within the first day,

1:12:20what they did was, and this was even funnier. So first, after my email came in and after the

1:12:26story started going up, clearly the heat was on. And so first my byline was changed just from

1:12:33Christina Warren to Christina. And I was like, "That's still not good enough." Because unfortunately,

1:12:39and not unfortunately, for better or worse, even though the site's been gone for a really long time

1:12:42and I haven't written for them since 2009, a lot of people will associate me with TUAW. And I was

1:12:48like, "No, there's one Christina that's associated with that domain, with that brand and you can't

1:12:53use my name in any way." Then it quickly shifted from that to Mary Brown. And they did change the

1:13:00names of all the authors, which was my primary concern was not even for myself, because I'm

1:13:05fortunate enough that I have a big platform other ways that even though I wouldn't want people to

1:13:10mistake new AI generated slop with my byline and a different photo from me, I wasn't overly concerned.

1:13:17But there are other people who have other careers and done other things who don't have the same

1:13:22profile I do, who their names are being reused and are being again, like published actively on a site

1:13:28that is in Google News, has been indexed, they know how to play this game that has a lot of backlinks

1:13:33and Google doesn't care about that stuff, no matter what they say, they'll let these sorts of

1:13:37scams go on. I there's, there's no way that a search engine would pick up that anything

1:13:43suspicious. No, not at all. Not at all. It would just be like the search engine would be like,

1:13:47"Oh, this URL is active again. Here's an article, let me index it." Exactly. Exactly. And so my main

1:13:54concern was I was just like, I don't want some of my former colleagues to have their SEO and other

1:13:59things caught up in this because that could hurt them professionally and whatnot. And then

1:14:03selfishly too, I was like, I don't want my name on this stuff. I'm pretty protective over that.

1:14:07So they changed the names and all the bylines. By the time the 404 media story was up, they started

1:14:14to go through that process of changing it. But what was funny is that the backlash kept building

1:14:19and it became bigger and bigger. It was a slow news week. So lucky for me, and also thank you

1:14:23very much again for sending me the first heads up. I didn't expect it to have legs, but I'm

1:14:28sort of person I've never met like a crisis that I won't turn into a publicity stunt. And so I was

1:14:33like, I will milk this for everything that's worth, right? Because I think we need to talk about this.

1:14:37And also this is insane that this happened and there'll be a great story for years to come. But

1:14:43what was funny is that as this sort of be uncovered about this guy, he started removing

1:14:49his own information from the internet, which was very, very funny because-

1:14:53I was about to say, I don't know, because I don't know about you. Did you get an answer to any of

1:14:59your emails? I did not. I just double checked right now just to make sure-

1:15:05I got nothing. There was no correspondence with me at all. All I know is that within about a couple

1:15:11hours of me sending that initial emissive and they started changing the bylines and stuff. And I know

1:15:16that that wouldn't have happened if there hadn't been the media attention. And also if I hadn't

1:15:20sent the vaguely threatening email.

1:15:23And there's still some fishy stuff. I'm looking at the homepage of tuah.com right now, and I don't

1:15:28recommend anybody subscribe to the feed. But it's still up to date. There's July 30, July 30,

1:15:36I don't know, three or four articles a day. But it's like the byline for the first four stories,

1:15:42five stories, six stories, seven stories is Paul Terpstra, T-E-R-P-S-T-R-A. Now there's-

1:15:50Brett Terpstra.

1:15:52Brett Terpstra, a good friend of mine. And I told Brett to do this-

1:15:54Who was an author at Tuah and is best known-

1:15:58He was. He's something I met.

1:15:59He's written a bunch of markdown related utilities. People listening to this have

1:16:03probably heard his name. And it's quite frankly a somewhat distinctive surname.

1:16:07It is. It is.

1:16:08I don't know any other Terpstas.

1:16:10Yeah, no, I told him because he and I do a podcast together called Over Tired,

1:16:14please subscribe. I told him, I was like, you should contact them and be like,

1:16:20change the name. Because to me, that one, like everybody else's names were sufficiently

1:16:25different enough. That one wasn't. And I don't know who just laziness, what the situation was,

1:16:31but I don't know if they would listen or anything, but since they were responsive the first time,

1:16:36you'd like send an email and see what you can do. Because yeah, that's still there.

1:16:41I still don't love that hyperlinks, the two things that I wrote now go to something that is not what

1:16:48I wrote and whatnot. I can't really do anything about that because again, the domain was sold and

1:16:53I don't think you can copyright URLs, nor would I want people to. And yes, there is, I'm sure,

1:16:58copyright infringement case brought up, but this guy, even finding out what country he's in would

1:17:04be difficult. I'm not pursuing that. I have too many other things to do.

1:17:07I've just never, but it never occurred to me and it is devilish and it sucks that it's still up.

1:17:13Because like you said, as somebody else who didn't have my unique position of having been

1:17:23doing the thing I do while Tua was an act of concern and knowing you personally,

1:17:29it wasn't just a random- No, it's amazing that we caught it the way that we did. And I hadn't been

1:17:35aware of how you described it to me, but I hadn't quite understood until you explained it on the

1:17:41podcast how you'd come across it that you'd actually click the link. I had thought that maybe

1:17:45you had Googled something and then it came up in the Google results.

1:17:48Well, but it was my article that came up in the search results.

1:17:52Okay, okay. Got it, got it, got it.

1:17:54And I thought, I will admit, there's a lot of times where I'm searching for something

1:18:01and if a Daring Fireball link comes up, I think, "Oh, maybe I already knew the answer and I've

1:18:07forgotten it." Oh, totally. No, I think we've all gone through that.

1:18:10I've definitely done that. I found my own articles or own documentation to solve a problem that

1:18:15currently has. I'm like, "Oh, right. I did figure that out however many years ago. Got it." Yeah.

1:18:20As I accelerate through middle age, it happens more and more and I'm like, "Oh, younger John

1:18:28solved this problem. Thank you, younger self."

1:18:31Yeah.

1:18:32No, it is so—no, and I will say though, it only took a couple minutes to really sort of figure out

1:18:38the scope of the basic gist of what this guy had done. But every click along the way, my first

1:18:45thought was, "Oh, they just—somebody resuscitate—" Obviously, I knew the site had been

1:18:51defunct for a while and it had been—the best case scenario is somebody bought it and resuscitated it

1:18:56and I was actually kind of happy for a moment. I was like, "Oh, this is fantastic." Some—whether

1:19:02it was Verizon or whoever—somebody took the care of rejuvenating a site that I wish had never gone

1:19:10away. I mean, I get closing it, but I wish that like the way that old copies of magazines that

1:19:17don't exist anymore, you could still go to the library and read them on microfilm or if you have

1:19:22a copy of the magazine in your box in your garage, it's still there for you to read. I wish Tua were

1:19:29still there as it was on the day it shut down forever. I wish everything I've ever linked to

1:19:35was still there. And I am so, so happy that the Internet Archive exists and I'm so worried because

1:19:44it occupies a singular position on the entire Internet. There is—if something were to happen

1:19:53to the Internet Archive, what's plan B for finding the original version? Unfortunately, not everything

1:20:01that you wish you could find from 2006 on the web is in the Internet Archive, whether it was because

1:20:06the site had a robots.txt file that said, "Don't even use the Internet Archive. We don't want to

1:20:12be archived." Why in the world anybody would do that? It's bizarre and beyond me, but people have

1:20:17done it or it was an obscure site that they didn't index. I've run into that problem where I can just

1:20:25tell this is not a very popular—this was not a popular website and the Internet Archive, "Sorry,

1:20:32no, we don't have any indexes of that. Darn." But here's one that did. But every step of the way,

1:20:38I thought, "Oh, somebody resuscitated this and they mixed up the images. They made a—maybe it's

1:20:43a coding error." And like I said, you were a 20-something white woman with long dark hair,

1:20:55and this is a 20-something woman with long dark hair. So I could see how somebody might have

1:21:00made the mistake. But the more I looked at it, the more I'm like, "No, no, no, no, no." And then I

1:21:07started clicking around the site and I sort of got—I was like, "Oh, oh!" And it's like, "Oh!"

1:21:15And the key, of course, was when I went to the authors page where they had all of the authors.

1:21:22And I know at least half of them personally, maybe more than half.

1:21:26Stephanie: Yes, exactly. And you were like, you're just like, "Wow, okay, this is great. This is not

1:21:31at all who you are."

1:21:32Geoff; None of these are the actual people. And then you—

1:21:37Stephanie; I do have to say, the nice part about this was that Jason at 404 Media reached out to

1:21:40Mike Schramm, who had been an early and frequent contributor to the blog, and he'd sent an email

1:21:45to a number of us. And so some of—I've kept in touch with a number of people from that era,

1:21:50but a bunch of people I haven't talked to in years and years and years. And so it was kind of nice

1:21:54that there was kind of a mini email reunion amongst some old writers that came out about this,

1:21:59which was good. But no, it was just such a bizarre and utterly weird thing to happen.

1:22:05And I am—I'm angry at a lot of people about it, obviously, primarily the guy who did this.

1:22:10I'm also a little bit annoyed, I'm not going to lie, with Yahoo, Apollo Global, whatever, for

1:22:15selling the domain, making it clear that it's just that. And then I'm like, "Okay, you had the

1:22:20perpetual license to this content too, but it's like, what are you doing? Do you do any due

1:22:24diligence about this or not? Because the amount of money that you sold this for, which was probably

1:22:29five or 10 grand, it couldn't have been a lot of money, especially for their bottom line. It's

1:22:33completely inconsequential. What are you doing? Like, what's the point?"

1:22:37It is frustrating. And it's only slightly tangentially related. But just a week or so

1:22:45ago, the news came out that Google is shutting out—or years ago, it said they're deprecating

1:22:50their link shortener, which was like a Bitly type thing. There was a brief period of time—

1:22:57Everybody had a short URL, yeah.

1:22:59Driven by Twitter's then 140 character length, which counted the entire URL as part of the

1:23:07character count. And I had my own custom—

1:23:10Yep, same.

1:23:11—Daring Fireball link shortener, which—but guess what? Mine still works. I don't use it anymore.

1:23:16I don't need it anymore. But as long as my internet presence is active, those links will

1:23:24keep redirecting. And Google announced that, I don't know, in a couple months, they're all

1:23:28just going to die.

1:23:29They're all going to die, which is—look, on the one hand, they shut the service down

1:23:33six years ago. And I get that there is a very real cost to maintaining an older service

1:23:39and whatnot. Having said that, at GitHub, we went through a similar situation where

1:23:44we had a URL shortener that only worked for GitHub URLs. And so it wasn't widely used,

1:23:49and we were going to sunset it. And the initial plan was to just get rid of all the URLs.

1:23:54And then we heard back from people who said, "Well, no, we've used these things in academic

1:23:59papers and in other research stuff." And so we got that feedback, and we went, "Okay,

1:24:03well, we will scan." And in our situation, it was a little bit better because it wasn't

1:24:08a general URL shortener like what Google's was, which could go to any number of resources.

1:24:13Right.

1:24:13It's just going to go to GitHub repositories. But we were able to say, "Okay, well, what

1:24:17we'll do is we will scan these URLs that have been created. And any ones that go to something

1:24:22that 404 is out, we're not going to maintain. And anything that goes to something that we

1:24:27have viewed as spam or malicious or anything else, we're not going to maintain." But we

1:24:32will go ahead and we kind of created a static service that somebody is maintaining to continue

1:24:37to make the redirects work, which I think is the right thing to do. We got that feedback

1:24:41from our users. And yeah, it's not as if it wasn't a ton of work that went into it, but

1:24:47it required some. But that's the right thing to do.

1:24:49Like one of the core tenets-

1:24:50Especially when you're a somewhat big-ish company or GitHub, right? I mean, GitHub-

1:24:54Well, GitHub, absolutely. No, it was the right thing to do, right? One of the tenets of the

1:24:58web, this doesn't really hold true anymore, I guess, which is really sad. Again, to your

1:25:05point why it's so important the Internet Archive exists, but you're not supposed to

1:25:08break links. That's just one of those things. And-

1:25:11And you think Google would know that more than anyone.

1:25:14Exactly. Exactly. And again, I'm not saying that they should have to maintain this service

1:25:19forever, because I'm sure that has a real cost and they're probably running older servers

1:25:23and older software and I get all that, but they could do something similar to what we

1:25:27did, which is, okay, scan the links, find the stuff that goes to 404, find the stuff

1:25:32that goes to malware, extricate that. Even if you can't save all of them, look at the

1:25:36top ones, but okay, has it received at least one click in the last X number of months?

1:25:40Then statically maintain this. It's not like your DNS file is that is going to be even

1:25:46more complicated. Your Google, again, you can handle the redirects.

1:25:49This would be a fantastic project for interns. I mean, it's almost like the definition.

1:25:55Yes. 1000-

1:25:56And I suspect Google has a few interns. I don't know. And I get it that it's not quite

1:26:04as simple as like my URL shortener, which only points to daring fireball articles. So I know

1:26:12there are no DF4.us. That was my, but that still is my shortened URL or domain name. None of those

1:26:23direct anywhere except to daring fireball. And then it's at daring fireball where there's an

1:26:29article that links elsewhere. And so I get it that Google's could go anywhere. And so it's not,

1:26:34but the basic mechanics of taking a short URL and redirecting to a long one is, I mean, like trivial.

1:26:43It's so simple.

1:26:43Yeah. That would be like, not for an intern. That would be like day one of learn to code.

1:26:48Oh no, totally. I was going to say, I've literally written tutorials using Azure

1:26:53functions and things like that on how to create like a short, a URL shortener. I mean, it's an

1:26:57incredibly simple thing. And again, it's not like they don't have a ton of redirects and they own

1:27:02the domain. They're not, they're never going to get rid of that domain. So it's like,

1:27:05They're not going to get rid of the domain.

1:27:07So, so again, you don't want to maintain a database. What I think we did for that reason

1:27:10is that we have a static kind of, we figure out the kind of a static way to kind of, you know,

1:27:14serve like the URLs we were doing.

1:27:15Super easy. Right. You could just do it with a cache of text files.

1:27:19Yeah, absolutely. Look, I'm not claiming it would take no effort, but it wouldn't be,

1:27:23to your point, I think it'd be a great intern project. And then you would not be breaking the

1:27:27web, which is a thing that you penalize people for all the time. If, if, if, cause like people

1:27:33like your blog, like if you are sending, if you have a bunch of links that don't resolve,

1:27:36like they will combat against you when they do their scanning and whatnot. So what are you doing

1:27:41here? The funniest part about that to me too, is that Google's suggestion about six years ago,

1:27:47they're like, okay, well, everybody should move, move to this Firebase service for, for short URLs.

1:27:52Well, that Firebase service has now been deprecated as well. And, and, and, and so, and when people

1:27:57are like, well, what should we do for this? The, the basic response is kind of like shrug.

1:28:02Yeah. And it is very Googley. I mean, it's like when they shut down, I mean,

1:28:07one that everybody still laments is Google Reader.

1:28:09Of course.

1:28:10Which again, if you, if they wanted, you know, and it is slightly different. I see the argument of,

1:28:15well, we've decided to abandon this, so we're not going to keep it going. But what people wanted,

1:28:20and I don't think it was unreasonable was okay, stop adding new features, but just let it go

1:28:24for a couple of years. It's not broken, right? Just let it just, just keep it up. How much could it

1:28:29cost? Can't cost anything that would matter to them. It just can't. And I do, I get it that

1:28:35something, whoever bought old domains, like two hours or whoever shut down the hairpin or whatever

1:28:41other site, it, it is more expensive to keep them running in perpetuity just to always have it up,

1:28:48but it is not that expensive. And now one, everybody knows that once a site stops publishing

1:28:56new stuff, traffic plummets. You, you, you just, all you have left is the long tail,

1:29:03but that long tail matters for archival purposes, right?

1:29:08It does. It does.

1:29:09You know, so keeping sites, okay, we're all of the things that suck. Oh, I loved the hairpin,

1:29:17or I love to, or I love my favorite site is shutting down. I can't believe it. And everybody

1:29:23feels bad when staff gets laid off. And especially because it tends to come in waves as the economy

1:29:30goes up and down. And so it really sucks when a site lays off their staff at a time when other

1:29:36sites are laying off their staff. So the job market is tight. It sucks. Everybody who's ever

1:29:42been in this business knows that it sucks and knows that it's, it's a hard business to want to

1:29:49be in. But man, it is like insult to injury to say, Oh, and by the way, on your way out,

1:29:55all the work that you've put into the site for the last years, many years, in some cases,

1:30:00Oh, yeah, it's all just gonna go away and won't even resolve anymore.

1:30:04No, that's really, that is just kicking dirt on somebody when they're down.

1:30:10No, it totally is. And then, and it's, it's bad too, because I'm a big, strong proponent of kind

1:30:16of preserving the web because this is the stuff matters. Like MTV news, this was one that,

1:30:19that really hurt. Like they, that's how they existed for more than more than 20 years. And

1:30:24they just completely nuked the whole thing. And again, I'm sure that it was expensive. They'd

1:30:29been on WordPress and they moved to another CMS. I was trying to get in contact with people there

1:30:34to see if there was a way that maybe we could crowdfund some money to save it. Matt Mullenweg

1:30:39from Automattic has, like they offer a thing where WordPress, where basically you pay like,

1:30:43I think it's 25 grand or something, and they'll host your content for life, which would be a

1:30:49reasonable amount of money for Viacom to pay, but Viacom is undergoing ownership changes and, and

1:30:54all that stuff. And so we were like, well, maybe we could crowdfund that. I wasn't able to get in

1:30:59contact with anybody who had access to kind of IT stuff there to see if they even still had the

1:31:04archives available. But I was trying to kind of help a week before all this stuff with the AI,

1:31:09stealing my identity thing happened. The MTV news shutdown happened and writers lost decades worth

1:31:15of work in some cases. The messenger, when that site, which lasted less than a year, like they

1:31:20shut that down basically the day that I guess they filed bankruptcy or chapter seven or whatever.

1:31:25And it was just like removed off of Amazon like instantly. So people's work is just gone and,

1:31:31and it's a shame. What's, what's super interesting about the, the, the, the two-aw situation though,

1:31:36is that they didn't redirect the URLs. However, to their credit, like when they got rid of the site in

1:31:432015, they did archive all the contents on Engadget. And so, so the content has been archived

1:31:49that the URLs don't resolve, but like the content has been archived. And I was very appreciative of

1:31:54them at the time, even when they did that, I was like, okay, well, I'm glad that even though the,

1:31:58the images won't work and the formatting is different and whatnot, like at least this

1:32:01preservation of this thing that, that I, that I did in college is still out there somewhere. And

1:32:05I appreciated that, but that then made it almost that much more jarring. And it's okay. You did

1:32:10the right thing. And, and to be clear, they didn't do that for all of their sites. Like when I worked

1:32:14also for a site called download squad, which was great. And when that died, I think in 2010,

1:32:18they, they didn't archive any of that. And and so those archives literally only exist in the

1:32:24internet archive and it wasn't a popular enough site for it to probably have, you know, as many

1:32:28iterations as two-aw did, but yeah. I don't know what the backstory on that is. I don't know,

1:32:35maybe you do, but it is great. I am glad that Engadget.com is hosting all of the old original

1:32:43two articles so that the only it's not the internet archive is not the only place to find them.

1:32:49It's that's great, but I can't help but imagine that internally there was like one person who

1:32:55wanted to do the right thing. And somehow somebody was like, all we have to do, it'll cost us like

1:33:0320 bucks a year to keep the domain name registration for two-aw.com. And they're like,

1:33:08Nope, Nope. And it's, what can I do? Well, that was the thing. They kept the registration. They,

1:33:14I think they just didn't want to migrate the site over and whatnot. So, so, so I think they just,

1:33:19they migrated the archives. Why they didn't do redirect, I couldn't tell you. I didn't work there

1:33:23then, but at least they kept the archives, but then that was the thing, right? They kept paying

1:33:27the $20 a year renewal. And then I guess they are approaching like the 10 year mark and they're like,

1:33:32okay, well, we'll see if we can sell this. I saw it is the four character.com. It's a good one.

1:33:40It's a good one. And a dot com, right? Like it's a four character one. Like it's, it's a good one.

1:33:44And it's one of those things you could see in like a perfect world where like, if somebody wanted to

1:33:49revive the brand, even if I didn't agree with it, I would be like, good luck to you. Even if,

1:33:53even if they didn't in a kind of scammy way, fine. All power to you. Where I got angry was just,

1:34:00okay, you can't take my words and you can't take, you can't bastardize my words and you certainly

1:34:06can't take my name, right? That's the best word. I honestly think what he did is worse than just

1:34:13stealing the original content from the internet archive and copy and pasting it onto his new

1:34:19rebranded to all.com. I think having AI rewrite each article is worse because it,

1:34:29the articles are worse. They're all, they're all ever so slightly one generation of slop reduced

1:34:36from the original pros of these writers who were all, it was a really good site with a bunch of

1:34:42really good writers. And it was like that, like I said, the first, before I got to the picture,

1:34:49that was not you, it was the pros. And again, it's not quite, it's, it's so hard to put your finger

1:34:55on what makes AI slop pros tingle my spidey sets. Cause it's not as bad as the old game of, oh,

1:35:07start with an English sentence, tell Google translate to translate it to Hungarian and then

1:35:15translate it back to English or go like English to French, to German, to Mandarin, back to English.

1:35:23Now what does it say? Ha ha. It's really nonsensical.

1:35:27There's a great news radio episode about that.

1:35:29Let's have sexual intercourse with your father.

1:35:33Exactly. No, totally, totally. No, exactly. Like it's, it's better than that. Right? Like that,

1:35:37that's the thing, but it's just uncanny enough, especially for blogs where there was this

1:35:41conversational method. Yeah.

1:35:44Jason and I, when we were, we were on the phone together and when he was interviewing me about a

1:35:48story, we were both at the same time clicking through links. Cause I still had a kind of an

1:35:52archive of some links that I'd written for the site ironically backed up on my, on my tumbler.

1:35:56And so I still had what the original URLs were. And so we were able to, we were, both of us were

1:36:00kind of comparing what was originally there and what was there now. And it was very funny just to

1:36:06see kind of the subtle differences and, and the verge even did like comparison between that too,

1:36:11for some stories, because it was, it was just subtle enough, but yeah, there was an uncanny

1:36:15quality and yeah, but, but again, I wouldn't expect somebody who didn't know me, right?

1:36:20This is why we got so lucky, right? Somebody who didn't know me from anything, or maybe they knew

1:36:25of me, but like certainly didn't know like my, my, my, my writing voice, my style wouldn't have

1:36:29been able to look at that. They might've thought as you did initially, and I would have thought

1:36:32this too, Oh, they just got the byline photo wrong or whatever, but they wouldn't have understood,

1:36:36Oh, that's not how Christina writes, right? Like many people would just be like, no, that's,

1:36:40that seems appropriate, especially if it were from this past date, right? That's, that's how you

1:36:45wrote. And I will, I will defend or not defend, but I will, I will own up to the bad writing that

1:36:50I wrote as a college student. That's fine. I'll take my lumps on things that I wrote that I'm

1:36:54sure some of them were good. Some of them were not good, but I, I won't take responsibility for stuff

1:36:59I didn't write, right? Or if you're going to make it worse like that, that's when I get insulted.

1:37:03Okay. I will own my bad work, but I will be damned if you're going to make it something that I didn't

1:37:08actually write. Yeah. And it's just, I was just the right, right person to stumble across it.

1:37:15I knew it. But the other thing that also makes it a little insidious is, and now the link doesn't

1:37:22go there anymore. I don't know my original one, but I'm pretty sure he either removed the dates

1:37:27or changed the dates ostensibly because they'd been refreshed. Like you said, refreshed from

1:37:32modern standards or whatever. That's bullshit was, but any, anything that would have alerted

1:37:39somebody to, Hey, this is a 20 year old article or 17 year old article or something.

1:37:44No, they didn't do that. Right. Yeah, exactly. Yeah. All the dates were set up kind of on these

1:37:48modern kind of things. It's like the slug. Yeah. Wouldn't be clear. Like you could go through the

1:37:53archives and you could find things where like on, at least at the time when I looked at it,

1:37:57if I went to an author page, I could go all the way kind of through the history

1:38:02and I could be like, okay, which, which now I think they've changed. But at the time when

1:38:06it was live, like my, my author page was like hundreds of pages long and I could go back and

1:38:11I could see things going back to 2004, which was before I ever wrote for the site. I think they've

1:38:16kind of gotten rid of that now. And, and so, and I was like, I didn't write any of this. Um, now it

1:38:21seems like they've, I don't know if they've culled some of the archives or if they've just hidden it

1:38:24or what the process has been, but yeah, you're right. They, that, that was the insidious thing

1:38:29is that like you might know from one view that the article was this age, but then you click on it and

1:38:33all of a sudden the date is been modernized, which is a scam that a lot of companies have done for a

1:38:38lot of time, for a long time news organizations, especially because it'll bring them higher in

1:38:42Google results where they'll just make some small update and then all of a sudden it'll be like

1:38:47originally published this, but if they even have that there, but it'll have a more current date up

1:38:53top. So yeah, very insidious, as you said, I mean, very much trying to get people to think that this

1:38:58was the site that they used to know. And if people hadn't been following those things and who would

1:39:03right. Like it's just small again, like I just, the, the luck that, that, that it had in this,

1:39:09and I'm, I'm so grateful for you for pointing this out to me because we were able to get it taken

1:39:13care of. And also I think it's a good, I hope, look, these things will happen again. I hope that

1:39:19people can maybe be more prepared for them. And that the, because it was a slow news day, which

1:39:25thank God, because literally a couple of days later it was not. And so being able to, I think,

1:39:31have kind of the outrage from a community perspective is good. I hope that obviously if

1:39:37there's money, you meet people will do it, but I hope that it will make it harder for people to try

1:39:41to pull off scams like this in the future. Yeah. And I don't want a lot of credit. It was just

1:39:47serendipity that I found it early. And I think the baffling thing, and it wasn't genius that

1:39:51uncovered the scheme. It was pretty obvious. Oh yeah. It was very obvious once you could see it.

1:39:55It was just the awareness. We just didn't know the URL resolved. And the just pure dumb good luck

1:40:01that I decided to go on this search into this problem like a week after the scam had started,

1:40:07because the crazy part is it was inevitably going to come out. I mean, I think by now, right? I mean,

1:40:13there's no way it would have gone a month before somebody stumbled across it and been like, "Hey,

1:40:20that's not Scott McNulty. I mean, come on. It doesn't look anything like him. What the hell is

1:40:26going on here?" Like how this guy thought he was going to get away with it is crazy. But that is

1:40:30often the case with scams of all sorts when they're uncovered. You're like, "How did they

1:40:35think they were going to get away with it?" I don't know. There's no point trying to

1:40:38debug the mind of a scammer. I don't know. Exactly.

1:40:45All right. Well, I told you an hour. We only overshot by 50 minutes, but

1:40:52too much good stuff to talk about. I thank you, Christina. It's always good to talk to you. And

1:40:57it's good to talk to the real you. Yes. Thank you. Thank you for having the real me. Thanks again.

1:41:02Like, I'm just such a weird, a couple of events, but thank you for helping bring that attention.

1:41:06And I'm going to be dining out on the AI still mind-numbing story for like years.

1:41:11Like it's—

1:41:11Though the funny part, the other—we have to mention this—the other part is when you were—after

1:41:16this got taken care of to some extent, you started joking by using the AI-created avatar as your

1:41:23avatar. But then you ran into the limit on certain—which social networks that don't let you

1:41:30change them back right away? Was it Twitter?

1:41:33It was Twitter. It was Twitter because I have enough—they gave me a blue check. I can't do it.

1:41:37I got mine back too. I did not ask for it. But—

1:41:40I didn't ask for it, but, you know—

1:41:41Yeah, but the downside—

1:41:44Then I was stuck. I was like stuck with this photo. And I was like, "Can you change this?" I was like,

1:41:49"No, I can't." I was like, "I'm in hell." It was very funny.

1:41:52So for like—you wanted for like one day as a guy—

1:41:55Exactly.

1:41:56While everybody was talking about this to use your fake—

1:41:59Exactly.

1:42:00Fake Christina as real Christina and you ran into the "you can only change your avatar once a week"

1:42:05or whatever the rule is.

1:42:06Exactly. Yeah, right. I had to wait for like Twitter's AI or whatever to verify that my photo

1:42:14was not breaking any guidelines so I could actually change it back to my real photo. It was a very

1:42:18funny circumstance. And then I was like, "Well, I did it to myself." But I also—

1:42:23But it was the perfect coda though to the story.

1:42:25No, it really was. It was the perfect thing. I will say though, what made it—and now obviously

1:42:30it doesn't work this way—but at the time what was funny was that when the Verge story came out,

1:42:35their embeds all had the fake profile photo, which the commenters enjoyed. And I did too. I was like,

1:42:43"This is even funnier now." Because you've got to find it funny. I initially only did it on

1:42:48on Slack at work. And some of my colleagues who followed out what happened thought it was funny.

1:42:53And then one of my colleagues kind of dared me. He was like, "You know, you've got to do this on

1:42:57all your social networks." I was like, "Okay, why not?"

1:43:02Things that sound good but have unforeseen—

1:43:05Well, especially since I had a whole situation with my Twitter account getting—I lost access to it for

1:43:10a couple of months. And so I really was like attempting fate there. I will probably never

1:43:17change my avatar or anything in my profile ever again on Twitter anyway. But yeah, that was a very

1:43:22funny thing. I was like, "Well, I'm stuck with the fake me." And people were like, "You have to

1:43:25change your profile photo. It's freaking me out." I'm like, "It's freaking me out too. I can't do

1:43:30anything about it."