Podcast Search

Upgrade

525: Best of U3

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00[Music]

0:00:09From Relay, this is Upgrade, episode 525 for August 19th, 2024. Today's show is brought to you by Fitbod, DeleteMe and KRCS.

0:00:19My name is Mike Hurley, I'm joined by Jason Snow. Hi, Jason.

0:00:22Hi, Mike. By my calculations, if you do 52 episodes a year, after 10 years of Relay, you should have 520 episodes.

0:00:30This is episode 525. We're not at our 10th anniversary yet. I just want to point out again how much extra work we do.

0:00:36How much extra work... No calendar can hold us down.

0:00:39No, we burst right through. There's like a week and it's like, "Hey, one episode of Upgrade," and we just kind of jam ourselves in there and like, "Nuh-uh! Two this time! Boom! We did it!"

0:00:47How about that? How about that?

0:00:48And we high-five and we did that like nine times in 10 years, apparently, so great.

0:00:53I have a Snow Talk question for you. It comes from Anthony, who wants to know.

0:00:56Jason, you said on the last episode that you were a long-time U2 fan. I'm curious, what is your favorite album or song from the band U2?

0:01:05Originally this question said "Lifelong," and I just want to point out I'm not a lifelong U2 fan because they didn't exist until like 1980.

0:01:12Well, the long lifetime of the band.

0:01:14And in fact, the... and I was not a fan for the lifetime of the band. In fact, my sophomore year in high school, we had to do like reports about a thing we liked.

0:01:24I don't even remember what extended project of some sort, and there was a guy in our class who did a thing about U2 and we thought it was dumb.

0:01:32And then in 1987, "The Joshua Tree" came out and it's a great album and it's my favorite U2 album and I became a U2 fan.

0:01:38So that's the answer, "The Joshua Tree." And favorite song, I don't know. I had a hard time picking. I don't have one clear favorite.

0:01:44Maybe one, which is from "Ockton Baby," or "With or Without You," which is from "Joshua Tree." But like, it's great.

0:01:49I have a playlist called "Best of U2." It's got like 50 songs in it. It's great.

0:01:53And then there was that time that Apple Music, iCloud, Sync, Thing, whatever, had a little burp.

0:01:59And I got an additional playlist called "Best of U3."

0:02:03Oh my God. I was so ready for that.

0:02:06I nearly just smashed my wall into my microphone. That's going to affect me for the rest of the episode now.

0:02:12It incremented helpfully when it got a sync failure of some sort and it thought, "Oh no, I don't know which one of these playlists."

0:02:19There aren't two playlists. It made a mistake, but it does that thing where it's like, "Well, okay, I'm going to add a number onto the end."

0:02:26But then they've obviously got code that says, "But if there's already a number at the end, just increment it."

0:02:32And therefore, I got a playlist I have not yet deleted because it's hilarious.

0:02:37Also, by the way, does not contain the entire contents of the "Best of U2" playlist.

0:02:41They messed that up too. But the "Best of U3," a great classic playlist that I've never listened to because why would I do that?

0:02:52Incredible. That's so good.

0:02:55Some good Apple Music bugs there.

0:02:57You have to keep it, right? Like, it's too good to get rid of.

0:03:00I do. "Best of U3." It's "Best of U3," there are only 34 songs. "Best of U2," there's 55 songs.

0:03:08So who, what? Don't ask. It's U3.

0:03:13But let me ask you, Jason. Is the "Best of U3" playlist better? Is the curation better? Is it good at it, do you think?

0:03:19I don't think so.

0:03:21Okay.

0:03:25I don't know. It's not just cut off at the end. It's like there's some very weird sync problem. I don't know. Don't ask at Apple Music.

0:03:34If you'd like to send in a question of your own to help us open a future episode of the show, just go to upgradefeedback.com and send in a snail talk.

0:03:42We have some follow-up from last week's episode, Jason. We'll start with some stuff on macOS screen sharing.

0:03:49So I'm seeing from 9 to 5 Mac here, starting in beta 6, the screen sharing prompt now allows you to approve for a month rather than a week.

0:03:57And the popup says, "App name is requesting to bypass the system private window picker and directly access your screen and audio.

0:04:05This will allow app name to record your screen and system audio, including personal sensitive information that may be visible or audible."

0:04:12And you can approve, you can deny, or you can approve for one month. Is this better?

0:04:16No. Well, yes. It's better but doesn't solve the underlying issue, is what I would say.

0:04:23Which is asking once a month is better than asking once a week. But not having apparently a way to say, "No, really, I approve this app. Stop asking me," I think is user hostile.

0:04:37And then I also think the way that this is written, and again it's a beta, but assuming that it ships like this, it's written in a way that shames the developer.

0:04:48And provides a level of technical detail that no regular user is going to understand.

0:04:55Bypass the system private window picker and directly access your screen and audio.

0:04:59I don't actually know what private window picker means. What is that? What are they talking about?

0:05:04So it's a system thing that they did where there's a more constrained way to grab information off the screen, where you as an app ask the system to have the user pick a window.

0:05:17It's that thing. And the user picks and it gets shared back to the app so that there's an intermediary.

0:05:23This is one of the ways that Apple has tried to make things more private and secure, is that there's an intermediary that asks.

0:05:29Like in iOS, it's the idea that when you select a photo, instead of the app reading your photo library, the app asks Apple to ask the user to select a photo.

0:05:39And the user selects a photo and Apple hands the photo that was selected back to the app.

0:05:44Because that's more secure and private that way. The app can't see all the photos.

0:05:50The problem is, one, that's a very technical API kind of thing going on here.

0:05:55And two, it doesn't actually solve the larger problem of apps that actually do need to read your screen and are not just screen sharing a window, which is what this seems to be suggesting.

0:06:06Yeah, so apps that want to see everything, do they get the one month still? Or is it just one week for those?

0:06:13No, I think they get the one month.

0:06:15Okay.

0:06:16I think that's the change here.

0:06:17This is just an example of the text, one of the prompts.

0:06:21Yeah, I mean, a month is better than a week, but it's still worse than forever.

0:06:26Right?

0:06:28Like, I mean, that's what we're arguing here.

0:06:30And here's what I say. We got some good feedback from a couple of listeners who wrote in.

0:06:34And these are things that I hadn't considered. I'm sure you had, but we didn't talk about them on the show specifically.

0:06:39So first one comes from Adam, who says, "This change that Apple wants to make is going to be a miserable mess for IT professionals.

0:06:46Services like LogMeIn and Splashtop must have screen recording permissions to allow remote IT support to take control and support remote computers.

0:06:54Having to accept the permission often would be a disaster for IT departments.

0:06:58Confused users might disable the software and create more work and frustration."

0:07:03And Stephen wrote in and said, "I have a Mac mini home server like many people do.

0:07:07I also work at a church where people are remote every day, but Sunday and remote inter-production machines are set up the weekend.

0:07:14If you never or rarely see the screen of the machine, how would you re-authenticate so you can continue to have remote access?"

0:07:21Yeah, I saw a Mastodon post by Luke Van Dahl who does the screens app that was similar, which is,

0:07:26how do you connect to a remote Mac in order to control its screen so that you can administer it when it's in a data center or something like that,

0:07:35if the act of connecting to it pops up a dialogue?

0:07:38Like, you can't use what happens.

0:07:41At least the second example in that example is like, it's something you're doing to your own computer, right?

0:07:46So like, you know, maybe you can work it out.

0:07:48But that first one about IT departments, that feels like a nightmare.

0:07:53The second one, maybe you can work it out.

0:07:55If there's a way to do it that doesn't do that prompt, that's fine.

0:07:59But if I'm on vacation and I need to connect to my server back at my house and it throws up a prompt,

0:08:03or honestly, if I'm sitting at my desk and I need to connect to my server in the back of the house and it throws up a prompt like that,

0:08:09and I don't have access to the interface, it's actually an enormous problem because I can't access that computer, if that's the case.

0:08:15It's a very, very, very bad use case.

0:08:17That computer doesn't have a monitor attached to it.

0:08:19And you can't dictate when it's going to show you that prompt either, can you?

0:08:22And there's that.

0:08:23Now, I'm not saying that there aren't APIs for a lot of this stuff and there are ways through and all that.

0:08:28I'm just saying that there are lots of complexities here.

0:08:30Both of these examples are good.

0:08:32And we'll come back to what we said last week, which is, I think I'll appreciate Apple trying to protect users.

0:08:38The issue is protecting the users haphazardly, stumbling around and throwing a bunch of things, a bunch of permission dialogue boxes up there inartfully,

0:08:48and without thinking through all the use cases is going to break people's workflows and make more work for people.

0:08:55And they need to consider the whole before doing this.

0:08:59And that is, see, that's at the root of my criticism of stuff like this is it just doesn't feel very well thought through.

0:09:06Like the security people, their job is to think things through carefully.

0:09:10And the reasons that they're choosing, I think, are careful.

0:09:14And the APIs that they're building to create more secure ways of accessing private information, I think are carefully planned.

0:09:21And then you get to the point where it meets the user and it does not feel carefully planned.

0:09:26It feels haphazard. It feels last minute.

0:09:29It feels like people who are really under the gun to force an interface onto users because this API has been built and the security stuff has been built.

0:09:39And the last people to meet it where the rubber meets the road are the people doing the interface.

0:09:44And they're just kind of like tossing things out there.

0:09:47And as I've read this week from a bunch of people, it also is very piecemeal.

0:09:52Like that's the other problem is there's no holistic answer here.

0:09:55There's no, you know, oh, there's three screen recorders that you use.

0:10:01I'm going to put up a dialogue at an unknown time to you in six or seven days where I say, hey, there are three apps looking at your screen.

0:10:10Do you care? Let us know.

0:10:12Instead, you'll just get three popups at three different times, presumably.

0:10:17And it's just, again, it's just haphazard and frustrating.

0:10:20And I've discovered in the last week listening to podcasts that I have become the permissions guy, apparently.

0:10:28And I don't want to be that guy.

0:10:30But somebody has to say, you can't just go, oh, yes, Apple, thank you.

0:10:34Thank you for protecting us.

0:10:36Thank you.

0:10:37When you get smothered by popups and partly the people who just click yes to get it out of their face, they're not even going to complain.

0:10:47That's a huge security problem. Right.

0:10:49And who's going to say, right, who is there to say so if I have to be the one to say this is bad, do better.

0:10:55I do think that's kind of part of my job.

0:10:57And unfortunately, the reason I keep coming back to these permissions requests is not because I'm against security and privacy.

0:11:02It's because this is a place where Apple is failing.

0:11:06Right. Like they are not doing a good enough job.

0:11:08So that's that's the reason.

0:11:10Like, I would rather not.

0:11:12But that's the reason is my Mac belongs to me.

0:11:15I need to have a certain level of control over it.

0:11:18You can get in my way to a certain extent, but then you need to get out of my way when I tell you to.

0:11:22And that's not happening.

0:11:24And it's just it's unacceptable.

0:11:26They need to change how they approach this.

0:11:28Why can't they just I mean, there already exists a like that little screen sharing thing that pops up in the menu bar that goes purple.

0:11:35Right. Like, why isn't that enough?

0:11:37Like, I don't I don't feel like I'm having to reauthenticate my camera usage for applications.

0:11:43And like my camera, the access to my webcam for an app is as audio is like that's as dangerous, in my opinion, as screen sharing just in different ways.

0:11:54I got my little orange microphone in my menu bar.

0:11:56And like there is the purple one, right? Because I remember you had to change some stuff for bartender to get it to work.

0:12:00So like what? Yeah.

0:12:02What is not good enough about that system that it can't be adapted?

0:12:05And like, I don't if if what it takes for me to never see these things is to have another one of those colored icons in my menu bar.

0:12:13I'll take it fine.

0:12:14I'm a big boy.

0:12:16Like I can handle that.

0:12:17It's not going to upset me that much if I get to do the things on the Mac that I want to do.

0:12:21And maybe it protects other people.

0:12:22But like, why does it have to be this this pop up every month?

0:12:26Like, just give me give me the little purple icon on the menu bar or whatever.

0:12:30I hope that the sign that they push this to a month is a sign that there has been some understanding inside Apple that this is maybe not the best approach and that hopefully they will continue to make changes here.

0:12:44Honestly, you know, having to give permission again later is fine for me because it does solve a lot of issues where instead of it,

0:12:55somebody has access to your system and you give permission in the moment and then they never ask again is not a great situation to be in.

0:13:02But the next time they ask, or if you go immediately to a particular setting, at some point, you need to be able to say stop asking or notify only.

0:13:13Right.

0:13:14Where like that's the other way to go.

0:13:15Right. Which is instead of having a permission, have a notification, have a thing on the menu bar.

0:13:19There are other things you could do.

0:13:21And that's my big point here is I feel like a bunch of smart people at Apple who are experts in user experience could get together and come up with kind of a holistic approach that serves the needs of privacy without getting in the user's faces quite as badly and giving users power to control their Macs when they want to.

0:13:41It doesn't feel like that has happened and instead it's just another permission thing comes off the conveyor belt and they slap another permission style box into the OS and we're showering in them now and it's just it's too much.

0:13:53They need to they need to do better.

0:13:55And that's just and I'm aware of the fact that there are internal Apple issues here.

0:14:00Right. Like I'm aware of the fact that there are certainly people at Apple who feel exactly the way I do.

0:14:07They're just not being heard.

0:14:08And so I don't want to say Apple doesn't get it.

0:14:11I think there are parts of Apple that do get it and I think even the parts that maybe don't get it kind of get it but they're like they just don't care and they don't think it's important enough and and so all I can do is complain.

0:14:22I guess so they're sorry I did it again.

0:14:25Well, you know, we're doing the best we can out here, you know.

0:14:29I wanted to just do some follow out Jason to a wonderful movie that was put together by a friend of the show Ian Anderson.

0:14:40Ian was with us at the Relay 10 event and he was going to be making a video and he ended up making this beautiful thing which is kind of like honestly it feels like like a love letter to Relay.

0:14:53And he spoke to all of the hosts that were there including you and everybody including you had some very lovely, incredible, heartwarming things to say about what we've built together over the last 10 years because Relay is now 10 years old as of yesterday when we're recording.

0:15:10And it's a 15 minute video.

0:15:12I've watched it three times.

0:15:14I cried all the way through all three times.

0:15:17It's very special to me and I hope that people check it out.

0:15:21And also if you subscribe to Ian's channel on Friday, I think this coming Friday, he's going to be putting up a two hour interview that he did with me and Steven.

0:15:30So we both sat down with Ian and spoke to him like an hour about Relay and he's putting that together too.

0:15:36But he ended up making something I think wholly more heartwarming.

0:15:40And yeah, everyone that I've seen that's watched it in our Discord and on social media is just like, it was incredible.

0:15:47So I hope that people will give it a time and again, I would like to thank you in person because I have waited until now to say that it meant so much to me the stuff that you said and I loved it very much.

0:15:57That's great.

0:15:59Ian literally just said, "Jason, here's a microphone.

0:16:02I'm going to ask you a bunch of questions."

0:16:03And I had to speak extemporaneously.

0:16:06It was a little before we went on for the show.

0:16:10So it was a lot.

0:16:11You got to get those raw emotions baby.

0:16:12Let's go.

0:16:13And I remember nothing about anything there.

0:16:15So yeah, I'm glad.

0:16:17Very sweet.

0:16:18It was just super nice to me that so many people said such similar things unprompted from each other.

0:16:25Which just made me feel real good about this thing that we've all built together over the last 10 years.

0:16:30And I'm very thankful, feeling very thankful this past weekend.

0:16:34So I hope people check it out because I think it's worth the 15 minutes.

0:16:37This episode is brought to you by Fitbod.

0:16:42If you're looking to change your fitness level, it can be hard to know where to get started.

0:16:45Which is why you should check out Fitbod.

0:16:47It is both an easy and affordable way to build a fitness plan that is made just for you.

0:16:51This is super important because everybody has their own path, their own journey with personal fitness.

0:16:56So Fitbod makes sure that they take all the information that they can to customise everything to suit you perfectly.

0:17:02It will adapt with you as you're improving, making sure that every workout remains challenging and interesting.

0:17:06But also pushing you to make the progress that you're looking to achieve.

0:17:09Because you will see the results you're looking for when a workout program is tailored to your unique body, experience, environment and goals.

0:17:17Fitbod stores everything, all of this information in your Fitbod gym profile.

0:17:21And they use this to track your muscle recovery as you're doing your exercises and doing your workouts.

0:17:26And they also then will adjust the workouts that you're doing.

0:17:29So you're avoiding burnout and keeping up your momentum.

0:17:32Fitbod has analysed billions of data points that have been fine-tuned by certified personal trainers to make sure that you're doing the best work you can when you're looking to get fit.

0:17:43You can also make sure that you're going to be learning new movements the right way.

0:17:47Thanks to their more than 1000 demonstration videos, which is one of my favourite things in the app.

0:17:52Because whenever they show me a new exercise, I want to feel confident and comfortable with it.

0:17:56So they have instructions that are written but then also videos that are shot from multiple angles.

0:18:00So I can watch these and I know what's going on.

0:18:02But then once I've learned them, I don't need to look at that stuff.

0:18:05And I can be using my Apple Watch and it tells me what exercise I'm doing.

0:18:08I'm like, great, I know how to do that one.

0:18:09And I can just do it and continue.

0:18:11But then whenever I need to pick up my phone again and watch the videos to learn something new.

0:18:15Your muscles improve when they work in concert with your entire musculoskeletal system.

0:18:19Overworking some muscles while underworking others can negatively impact your results.

0:18:23Which is why Fitbod tracks all of your muscle fatigue and recovery to design that well-balanced workout routine.

0:18:29The app is great to use. As well as those videos, you can stay informed with their progress tracking charts,

0:18:34their weekly reports and sharing cards to let you keep track of your achievements and personal bests and share them with your friends and family.

0:18:40Personalised training of this quality can be expensive, but Fitbod is just $12.99 a month or $79.99 a year.

0:18:46But you can get yourself 25% off your membership by signing up today at fitbod.me/upgrade.

0:18:53So go now and get your customised fitness plan at fitbod.me/upgrade. One last time, notice fitbod.me/upgrade for 25% off.

0:19:02Our thanks to Fitbod for their support of this show and Relay FM.

0:19:06It's time to lawyer up Jason Snow.

0:19:10Clunk, clunk.

0:19:11Fortnite is back on iPhone.

0:19:14Via the Epic Games Store and Alt Store Pal.

0:19:18So we knew this was coming. It has now happened. The Epic Games Store has launched. Fortnite is on there and a couple of other games as well.

0:19:24Epic has said that they're going to expand this out as time goes on.

0:19:28And they're going to be expanding and extending the deals and arrangements they have on the Epic Games Store and other platforms to this.

0:19:36Namely, Epic's cut is 12% of transaction fees.

0:19:41So that's one of the things that they'll be extending for other games that want to join.

0:19:45But there's been loads of interviews with Tim Sweeney talking about how things like the core technology fee makes him think it's probably not going to be a lot of games that want to join.

0:19:53But nevertheless, Alt Store has also announced that they have received a grant from Epic which they're going to be using to pay the core technology fee for their users.

0:20:03Alt Store say that this basically no longer means that at the moment you have to give them a fee and it covers development and also covers the CTF.

0:20:12And it's an annual fee that you pay just for access in Alt Store.

0:20:15So now no users will have to pay this going forward. This is new customers and no renewals will occur for previous customers.

0:20:22These two things are epic new business because they're also putting Fortnite on other stores as well.

0:20:28There's like more stores than just Alt Store. Other stores are going to launch. They're going to put Fortnite there.

0:20:32Basically, it seems like they're doing everything they can to undermine Apple and increase the desire for sideloading worldwide.

0:20:39Because all of the headlines that I've seen, which I understand why the headline is this way, the one on the verge, Fortnite is back on the iPhone.

0:20:47Mhm. Just not your iPhone.

0:20:50Exactly. Unless you're in the European Union, that's not your iPhone.

0:20:54But people will want Fortnite back on their iPhone. Especially they have timed this so well, Jason. I don't know how familiar you are with this.

0:21:01It's their Marvel season just started. It was all timed.

0:21:04So they know what they're doing. They mean business.

0:21:07They know what they're doing. I don't particularly like Tim Sweeney and the way he goes about things.

0:21:13And I think that some of the stunts that they pulled with Apple were counterproductive.

0:21:19But I appreciate their sticking with this. And this is the great experiment. We'll see where it leads.

0:21:27But I honestly don't know where it will lead. I think that they're just trying to continue putting pressure on them.

0:21:33And again, is it self-serving? Of course it is. But I do also think that they are, like they have turned their back on other revenue around the world on iPhone in order to make this point.

0:21:45And maybe they're playing a long game here, but I think they're also standing up for something that they believe. So good for them.

0:21:52I can make a catty remark about that there's taking a percentage for games that are in their store because isn't it supposed to be about gatekeeping, et cetera, et cetera.

0:22:00But if you don't like it, you don't have to go on their store. You can go to a different store because, again, there's different marketplaces in the EU.

0:22:07The Epic Games Store is quite complicated. There's a lot more to get into, but they are a better partner to their partners.

0:22:16They frequently fund games and then take a cut. So there's a different scenario going on there.

0:22:24But I mean, this is the thing. I don't think they said they don't believe Apple should take nothing. But I think what they said. Anyway.

0:22:33You were talking about putting pressure and it making changes. Starting in iOS 18.1, Apple is going to be allowing developers access to the NFC chip and the benefits of the secure element.

0:22:46I don't know when this was changed from enclave to element, but Apple refers to it as the secure element.

0:22:51So what is this going to mean? I'm going to tell you right now, this is quite complicated. I read three articles four times today.

0:22:58So there's a few things going on here. Financial institutions will be able to offer their own contactless payment options as well as other contactless payments in stores.

0:23:06Like a supermarket could have its own. I think Walmart, for example, you can pay with a QR code or something and they would be able to basically have their own.

0:23:15But this will also be for keys, car keys, house keys, that kind of stuff. Hotel keys, transit cards. Like the Oyster card in London is just like an NFC card.

0:23:25But you can't have it in Apple Pay. But maybe they would do that. Corporate badges, student IDs, loyalty cards, event tickets.

0:23:32Apple say to incorporate this new solution in iPhone apps, developers will need to enter into a commercial agreement with Apple, request the NFC and SE entitlement and pay the associated fees.

0:23:44Of course there are fees. But I do like that there is like, not anyone can just like do this. Like you have to like go to them and arrange it because you're really kind of going deep into the system for access to this.

0:23:56This is going to be available in iOS 18.1 in Australia, Brazil, Canada, Japan, New Zealand, the UK and the US.

0:24:03Now, I want to read from Apple's developer document the very high level of how this works. Because there is a bunch of things that developers will be able to have access to.

0:24:14So, first, NFC transactions. Users of eligible iOS apps can initiate NFC transactions from within the app with compatible NFC terminals.

0:24:24So you can open up an app, go to a terminal, you can hold your phone on it and you can double click and pay.

0:24:29Default app settings. Users can choose any eligible app as their default contactless app which will enable the app to support field detect and double click features.

0:24:40These are, field detect is, the default contactless app automatically launches when a user presents their iPhone to a compatible NFC terminal and after user authentication.

0:24:50So, for example, in transit here in the UK, if you put your iPhone on an oyster card thing, it pops up. It automatically brings up Apple Pay and then you can double click.

0:25:00And then also double click. The default contactless app automatically launches when the user double clicks on the side button or the home button and does the authentication.

0:25:08So, a user can choose for any app that is in the kind of NFC, given the NFC entitlement, to just replace Apple Pay if they want to do that.

0:25:18Replace, I guess, Wallet, right, is what it's replacing.

0:25:21Yeah, what is the wallet. Good point, good point, good point.

0:25:24There's also support for non-default apps. Eligible apps running in the foreground can prevent the system default contactless app from launching and interfering with the NFC transaction.

0:25:33So this is, I guess, if you were in your supermarket and your supermarket had its own thing and you were in the supermarket's app and you held it up, it wouldn't bring up Apple Pay.

0:25:43Then it could bring up the NFC thing but you don't have to make it as the default.

0:25:46This is really interesting, really weird, really complicated. I will be intrigued to see what actually this looks like when it launches.

0:25:54And I desperately hope it does not mean we're going to start seeing banks pulling out of Apple Pay because they want you to use theirs instead.

0:26:01That is what I worry about in seeing this. Every bank is going to be like, "Great, now we're just going to do this."

0:26:09So my hope is, and what I think Apple's probably going to do, they're going to price these fees in such a way that it just means that you might as well do both.

0:26:17But I really hope this isn't the case, man.

0:26:20So this is what I assume. I assume, and this is just because this is how Apple's been behaving,

0:26:26I assume that the associated commercial agreement and fees will be the equivalent of what Apple has done with other stuff where they say, "Oh, you want to be outside of our Aegis as the wallet app?

0:26:41Okay, as long as the reason you want to be outside is not to get around paying us because you're still going to have to pay us, but you can build a separate thing and not be an Apple Wallet."

0:26:56Which is competition in a sense, right? Which is a developer who wants to build something that doesn't make sense in Apple Wallet or is not supported by Apple Wallet could build it in their app and not worry about Apple Wallet.

0:27:10But Apple still has to approve that app. Apple still has to sign a commercial agreement with them. So is it really that different? I don't know.

0:27:22And it does, I agree with you, I am a little concerned as well. I mean, the advantage of having everything be in the Wallet app is everything's in the Wallet app and I don't have to worry about it.

0:27:30And if this is not the case, then that's less good.

0:27:36But at the same time, I like the idea that I could open up an app and just do a bunch of NFC stuff in that app. You know, like tickets or hotel keys or even like a badge to get into a building or something.

0:27:51Like that kind of stuff is good, but I worry about the financial institutions part of it and what might happen to Apple.

0:27:59Yeah, I don't know.

0:28:00So all of this, the reason I brought this up is like pushing, all of this is similar to what Apple already announced they were doing for the EU with opening.

0:28:08But like they have way less information about that, so I'm not sure how exactly they overlap, but I think they overlap pretty close.

0:28:15But I think there are going to be some separate things that are going on, which is why they're kind of being very restrictive about the countries that this is going to act in.

0:28:24But this is like, again, the EU made them do something, so now Apple is doing it worldwide and maybe it will bring some good, maybe it will bring some bad.

0:28:32Yeah, we'll see.

0:28:33Spotify is now able to show the prices of the various plans that they have available in their iOS app in the European Union as a result of Apple's legal battle with the European Commission, in which the $2 billion fine was proposed against them in March.

0:28:47As a result of this, something called the Music Streaming Services Entitlement was created. This appears to be able to provide a developer of a music streaming app who opts into this, the ability to add one link out to the developer's website to explain how to purchase these plans.

0:29:03You cannot do any purchasing in the app itself without also opting into the new developer terms and paying the CTF.

0:29:08From Spotify's, what they're talking about, it doesn't look like they're actually putting this link in or talking about the link, but you can now go and see how much a Spotify plan costs, which is awesome.

0:29:22Great.

0:29:23This is, just think about this.

0:29:27Spotify has spent years in a legal battle with Apple for the right to list their prices and link to their website.

0:29:36Kind of.

0:29:37They can't even link to the normal website.

0:29:39They can't link to the purchase plan.

0:29:40They can link to a place which explains how someone could potentially buy something.

0:29:45Imagine, the money.

0:29:46The money that has gone into this for years.

0:29:48Yeah, just for something that, and this is the thing, and I know, I mean, we've talked about it.

0:29:53I know Jon Gruber's talked about it a lot.

0:29:55This is one of the most nettlesome things that Apple does because this is like the biggest bit of rent-seeking behavior.

0:30:01And I just, just to say it again, making people aware of things that happen outside of an app and outside of Apple's control is not a big deal.

0:30:13And yet Apple treats it like, oh, every link to the internet is a scary thing that you must be warned away from and information needs to not be shared.

0:30:21And it's the difference between saying, look, buying it in the app using Apple system is super convenient.

0:30:26And so you should do that.

0:30:28But if you don't want to, you can also just go to the web because we all do it.

0:30:34It's fine.

0:30:35And Apple doesn't want to do that.

0:30:38And they can say lots of reasons why, but the bottom line is they want all the money.

0:30:43That's it.

0:30:44That's the only reason.

0:30:45I just, I can't believe that Spotify spent all this time and money for something as basic as telling their customers what the prices of their services are and linking to their website.

0:30:55Like, come on, what are we doing here?

0:30:57And speaking of wanting all the money, I wanted to get your take on the Apple Patreon thing.

0:31:02And we mentioned this very briefly.

0:31:04Money, money, money, who wants all the money?

0:31:06It's Apple.

0:31:08It's not a jingle.

0:31:10No.

0:31:11That was us singing on a podcast.

0:31:12It's just us singing.

0:31:13That's a different thing.

0:31:14That's a single.

0:31:15Yeah.

0:31:16So just a quick disclosure about the thing.

0:31:18We both work with memberful.

0:31:19Memberful is owned by Patreon.

0:31:21I just think that's worth mentioning.

0:31:22Yeah.

0:31:23Real AFM, Incomparable, Six Colors are all memberful plans.

0:31:25Yeah.

0:31:26And they've also been sponsored on these shows before.

0:31:28We've had memberful as a sponsor.

0:31:30So we mentioned this very briefly on the show last week because it happened, it broke last Monday.

0:31:35But it was too big a thing for us to really think about and digest.

0:31:39And I've actually, I gave a lot of my own thoughts about SunConnected last week.

0:31:44But I wanted to know your take.

0:31:45So essentially, Apple is requiring Patreon to give them a cut of all memberships that are started in the Patreon iOS app from November.

0:31:55This does not count any existing payments or memberships.

0:31:59So like if somebody signed up in the iOS app today, Apple's not going to get any money from that person.

0:32:04It is 30% of all iOS only signups from November of this year onwards.

0:32:09What do you think about this?

0:32:11It's also, they changed, they used to have a thing where if you didn't post a thing during a span, you didn't get charged.

0:32:17And that is not possible with this scenario either.

0:32:19Yes.

0:32:21I mean, I don't like this.

0:32:25I think that there are a couple of ways to look at this.

0:32:27And one is, what is Apple doing?

0:32:31Because I've heard, there have definitely been threads about this.

0:32:34What is Apple's policy about having to offer in-app purchases?

0:32:40Because I've also heard from people who've developed apps where Apple said, "No, this is based on buying something outside.

0:32:46And even if you don't tell anybody it exists, it doesn't matter, you need to also make it available for an app purchase."

0:32:51Apple's rules for the App Store is if you offer a purchase, you must also offer in-app purchase.

0:33:01So like if someone could buy your thing on the web and it's like a digital good, they want you to offer it also in your app and also offer an in-app purchase for it.

0:33:11Yeah. It's just, and that's, I think that's ridiculous.

0:33:15So it doesn't, there's a bunch of things going on here.

0:33:18First off, I don't actually do any Patreon in the in-app purchase.

0:33:21It makes me think, was it John Gruber who said this?

0:33:23Somebody said they should just shut off their iOS app and use the web.

0:33:28I use the web for Patreon and it's fine.

0:33:31Clearly it's important to their business, right?

0:33:33Yeah, I get it.

0:33:34The iOS app must be important to Patreon or they would have just gotten rid of it.

0:33:38It lets creators push notifications into iPhones.

0:33:40I get it.

0:33:42There are actually like community stuff in it. Like people can have like group chats instead of like a Discord.

0:33:48I don't, so things I don't like.

0:33:51I don't like Apple saying, "If you have an app, you have to offer in-app purchases."

0:33:57Especially since you have to offer in-app purchases and pretend that you don't know where else people can buy this thing because it's against the rules.

0:34:04That I think is just fundamentally not great.

0:34:07But I also think that this is Apple trying to insert itself in a product that already has a middleman.

0:34:15So it's trying to invalidate Patreon's business model like it made it impossible for Amazon to, or ComiXology for that matter, right, to sell in-app.

0:34:25Because that means two middlemen, they're both taking their cut.

0:34:29It can't pencil out. It doesn't work that way and so they can't do it.

0:34:33Not great.

0:34:35And the whole idea of the creators being taxed for this, like one of the problems is because Patreon rolls everything together into a single account and then pays creators,

0:34:47they have, they're not eligible for the small business plan even though almost all their creators are.

0:34:52So it's a 30% cut instead of 15.

0:34:55So that's the top of it.

0:34:57It seems to be misguided in the sense that people creating art is not something that Apple should actually take a cut of, I think.

0:35:06I think it makes, I mean the optics, it makes Apple look bad, but I think also it doesn't really make a lot of sense for them to do it this way.

0:35:12It doesn't pass the sniff test for logic.

0:35:14Like in a bunch of ways.

0:35:16Yeah.

0:35:17And I think also this is a great example.

0:35:22I mean, first off, it's Apple's one size fits all approach here, which is Apple doesn't think about the creators at Patreon.

0:35:29Apple thinks about Patreon.

0:35:30Apple is focused on taking its cut from this company called Patreon that's making a lot of money.

0:35:36Apple wants its cut.

0:35:38Not thinking about the fact, at least not aggressively thinking about the fact that it, Patreon is actually a middleman, a facilitator for a bunch of individual independent creators.

0:35:47Yeah, but you're just, you're just brainless if, you know what I mean?

0:35:50I know what you're saying, but that is like such, and I agree with you.

0:35:54Oh yeah.

0:35:55But it's a brainless thought.

0:35:56This is what I'm saying is, is you're looking at it in this certain way because you've decided that that's how you're going to look at the world, even though there's very clearly isn't that kind of thing.

0:36:05But they've decided, it's like, I'm sorry.

0:36:07And it's that same thing, right?

0:36:08Which is, I'm sorry, our hands are tied.

0:36:09These are the rules.

0:36:10It's like, you made the rules.

0:36:11You make the rules.

0:36:12Your hands are not tied.

0:36:13You made the rules.

0:36:15So what are you doing here?

0:36:16And in the end, just stepping back, what does it look like?

0:36:21It is Apple muscling into a whole bunch of independent creators who make a small amount of money on the internet and saying, "Hey, we want our money."

0:36:29And it's like, why do you want the money?

0:36:30Patreon's doing all the work.

0:36:32Patreon built our app for us.

0:36:34Patreon's doing the backend.

0:36:35We're cutting in Patreon.

0:36:36What has Apple given us?

0:36:37And Apple's response is, "Well, we built the platform that the Patreon app runs on."

0:36:44And it's like, well, okay.

0:36:47So why aren't you entitled to a portion of what Patreon takes from us?

0:36:51Why are you entitled to 30% of what people are giving to me as an independent creator?

0:36:57It just looks bad.

0:36:58It doesn't pass the sniff test.

0:37:00You're absolutely right.

0:37:02And again, this is actually an easy one.

0:37:09This is a great example of Apple playing by a playbook from when they were down on their luck and desperate for money, and now they're rich and they're still playing by that playbook.

0:37:25And it makes them look bad.

0:37:27I would say it's probably as bad a look as the hydraulic press ad was, but it's actually actual harm being done to people.

0:37:43They're actually doing the thing that people were upset about that time.

0:37:45They're actually doing it with us.

0:37:46It is Patreon creators in the hydraulic press now.

0:37:48Yeah, exactly.

0:37:50Well, that was just an interpretation before.

0:37:52I had a thought about this and looking through Patreon's rules, and it clarified something to me, which I feel like I'm going to keep talking about now as people end up going to hit us a lot.

0:38:02Apple are perfectly happy with their customers paying more for digital goods than everybody else, because they have zero problem with you putting the 30% on top.

0:38:15And the argument is, if it's so easy to do an in-app purchase, then you pay extra for it, if it makes it super easy.

0:38:26Like, okay.

0:38:27Like, all right.

0:38:28I mean, I think that there's my frustration with Apple's in-app purchase thing is they don't want to compete.

0:38:33They want to hide and have this 30% and not compete and maybe have to lower their take in order to make it.

0:38:38But as a platform owner who has built-in payment systems that are just right there in their APIs and everything like that, should Apple offer that and take a cut and say, look, we made it really easy for you.

0:38:48Just give us our cut, and it's all built in, and it's using their existing credit card, and you don't have to worry about it.

0:38:53That's not an unreasonable proposition.

0:38:55It's all the other stuff that's been built around it, which is you can't tell people about the other things.

0:38:59You can't link to the other things.

0:39:00There are no other alternatives if you're in our store unless you're in the EU.

0:39:04This is your only choice.

0:39:05It's 30%.

0:39:06That's the total number.

0:39:07We have very specific rules about it, and you're covered under it, so everybody is going to be covered under it.

0:39:12That's where it all goes from being not an unreasonable argument about Apple's convenience, the convenience of in-app purchases, to being more like a racket.

0:39:22It just bums me out, man.

0:39:24Yep.

0:39:25It's just bums me out.

0:39:26This is the feelings part of the podcast where we say we're kind of tired of talking about all this stuff.

0:39:32Yeah.

0:39:33Because the bottom line is I didn't get into this, and you didn't get into this, to talk about legal policies and who gets cut of what in big business.

0:39:42We got into this for enthusiasm about the products and about what people can do with the products and how we use them and how other people use them to make their lives better and have fun and all of those things.

0:39:54None of this is that.

0:39:55I think there's value in understanding Apple's business, but it's the summer of fun.

0:40:03Summer of fun.

0:40:04This year has reminded me of 2020.

0:40:06It's just rough.

0:40:08Just in that, in summer of 2020, there was no break in the news.

0:40:14It's kept going for the whole summer.

0:40:15Yes.

0:40:16This year, there has been no break in the news.

0:40:18The news has just kept happening.

0:40:21The thing about this is it's kind of in between a rock and a hard place.

0:40:27This is, I think, interesting stuff that is happening to Apple.

0:40:33We cover Apple.

0:40:34We talk about Apple.

0:40:35But it's also depressing.

0:40:40But I wouldn't want to just pretend it didn't exist.

0:40:44And we just carry on like it didn't exist.

0:40:47But I don't want to get lost in it either.

0:40:49So basically, what I've been thinking of, I think once we get through this period,

0:40:56like getting up to the iPhone, right?

0:40:58A couple of weeks for that.

0:40:59Potentially after the iPhone, I might readjust a little bit how much I'm putting in.

0:41:05Yeah.

0:41:07But I'm not going to ignore it.

0:41:09So like this Patreon thing, would have spoke about it, right?

0:41:12But maybe not the Spotify thing, maybe not the Fortnite thing if I was editing this down.

0:41:18But I want to complete the threads of the stuff we started talking about.

0:41:21Yeah, I think we need to talk about it.

0:41:23And lawyer up, you know, the artwork is beautiful and all that.

0:41:27I think we're going to continue talking about it.

0:41:29But I do think that there's a point at which we have to say as the kind of curators of the content of the show,

0:41:33that it's too much.

0:41:35And we don't want to do it.

0:41:36And I can say from personal experience, Stephen Hackett and I did a podcast called "Download."

0:41:41And the year plus that we did it was the year where every single week was a terrible Facebook story

0:41:48about how Facebook had done another thing to ruin people's privacy and change election results

0:41:56and lead to potential genocides.

0:41:59And just it was one terrible story after another to the point where we added a segment called

0:42:04"The Fuzzy Puppy Update" because we were so depressed at the end of the segment.

0:42:07Well, we have "Rumor Roundup" kind of next and that's a lot of fun.

0:42:10And the number one reason we stopped doing "Download" is because it was dispiriting to cover that terrible stuff all the time.

0:42:16It's not what we got into this to do.

0:42:18And we didn't want to do it anymore.

0:42:19And we have had the luxury of just saying, "Let's just stop this."

0:42:24And we're not going to stop covering the stuff on "Upgrade," but I do feel like at some point,

0:42:29we're going to need to recalibrate a little bit because it's a lot.

0:42:33There's a lot going on.

0:42:34And we can't not talk about stuff that Apple's doing that we don't agree with or we think is bad.

0:42:39And we have to talk about it.

0:42:42But there's so much of it right now and there's a limit to what we can do.

0:42:47Well, it's like I said last week, right?

0:42:49And I've been thinking about it a lot.

0:42:51I think I said it on this show.

0:42:52I don't remember if I said it on the show.

0:42:53I'm going to say it again now anyway.

0:42:54Okay.

0:42:55Do it.

0:42:56And Federico had a version of this himself too where he said the two Apples.

0:43:00But for me, it's just that I'm so happy the products are good.

0:43:04Yeah, because I was talking about the Mac Molaise time, right?

0:43:07I'm so happy the products are good right now.

0:43:10Imagine if the butterfly keyboard was out there now.

0:43:12Yes, imagine that, right?

0:43:13Then it would be like, I don't know what I would do.

0:43:16The products are good right now and the software is good right now by and large.

0:43:23But the products are good at least.

0:43:24And they're doing interesting stuff.

0:43:26So it at least gives some balance.

0:43:29And basically, just going forward, we're still going to talk about the stuff.

0:43:34But I think I'm going to start tapering some of these bits off a little bit.

0:43:38And just try and cover the biggest things.

0:43:41I don't want to do this every week.

0:43:43But I don't want to let them off, right?

0:43:47This Patreon thing, we would have spoke about this no matter what.

0:43:51It's so unnecessary.

0:43:54It's so unnecessary.

0:43:55And I'm going to tell you, having spent decades now understanding Apple's mindset,

0:44:00I'm sure the mindset here is essentially, "Oh, Patreon hides behind their creators."

0:44:09But they're the one that's built a big business taking money from the creators.

0:44:13And we've let them sort of slide and not taken our cut.

0:44:16But they're taking advantage of us now.

0:44:20Patreon the corporation.

0:44:21And we're not going to let them, we're going to put the screws to them.

0:44:24I guarantee you that's what they're thinking internally.

0:44:27And let me say, Patreon is not without fault here.

0:44:31Patreon has chosen a path that they want to go with their business that makes it more than maybe the initial plans of Patreon.

0:44:38Patreon made changes to the terms that creators are unhappy with.

0:44:45Patreon is not without fault here at all.

0:44:48And I do think that part of the reason Apple does this is that Apple perceives Patreon as being a business

0:44:56that is trying to make a lot of money from creators while skating by Apple and giving Apple its cut.

0:45:03That said, this is an own goal on Apple's part.

0:45:08Because in the end, you make your policies and you can adjust them.

0:45:13And so the argument of like, "Well, but Apple had to do this because if they let Patreon slide, then somebody else is going to slide."

0:45:19The answer is no.

0:45:20Apple can make a new entitlement, a new system, a new business term.

0:45:24They can say, "Oh, if you're passing on something to an independent creator and you have a certain..."

0:45:31Like, they could build a whole little program around it.

0:45:33They did it for a different type of creator, the big Hollywood creators.

0:45:36They created reader apps for them.

0:45:38Yeah. So they could do it if they wanted.

0:45:41And maybe they will. Maybe this is phase one.

0:45:45But the fact is, they should not have done this just unilaterally like this.

0:45:48It makes them look really bad.

0:45:50And the fact that it's... I think the most galling thing to me is that it's the 30%.

0:45:54So they don't even get the discount. They don't even get the half off.

0:45:58Even though each individual creator probably deserves it, because Patreon doesn't as a whole.

0:46:05And so they're going to put the screws to Patreon there.

0:46:07I do think in the end, that's probably what's going on here.

0:46:10Apple views Patreon as a competitor or as a business partner that is not giving Apple its fair share.

0:46:17I don't think they're thinking about the creators at all.

0:46:20Which is obvious, because if you thought about it, you wouldn't do this.

0:46:24So, anyway.

0:46:26This episode is brought to you by DeleteMe.

0:46:29Have you ever wondered how much of your personal data exists on the internet?

0:46:33Stuff that you don't know about, but stuff that you don't want people knowing about?

0:46:36It's uncomfortable to think about your information being out there.

0:46:39Especially since there are a whole industry of data brokers who make their business selling people's data.

0:46:46But, the good part is, we have the right to stay private and protect our privacy.

0:46:51But how would you know who the data brokers are to go and ask them to remove your information from them?

0:46:57This is where DeleteMe comes in.

0:46:59DeleteMe is a subscription service that removes your personal information from the largest people search databases on the web.

0:47:04They know who they are, and they chase them down.

0:47:07In the process, help preventing potential ID theft, doxxing and phishing scams.

0:47:11You can sign up and provide DeleteMe with exactly what information you want deleted, and their experts take it from there.

0:47:17DeleteMe sends you regular, personalised privacy reports showing what information they found, where they found it, and what they removed.

0:47:23And this isn't just a one-time service.

0:47:25DeleteMe is always working for you, constantly monitoring and removing the personal information you don't want on the internet.

0:47:31I was talking with someone a couple of days ago, and I was actually basically giving them the ad for DeleteMe.

0:47:36Because I love this service.

0:47:38I love the reports that I get, which tell me exactly what information has been removed from where,

0:47:44what process they are, and removing my information from the brokers that I want.

0:47:47But my favourite thing is that they have so many fields of data that you can provide them,

0:47:52but you only need to give them what you want removed.

0:47:55Maybe you have a corporate email address that you want to be available online,

0:48:00because you want people to find you so they can contact you for work.

0:48:03Just don't give them that email address as the information that you want removed.

0:48:07But maybe your personal information is out there, your personal email address.

0:48:10You give that to DeleteMe, and they'll make sure that it's taken away from all these data brokers.

0:48:14It's an amazing service. I could not recommend it higher.

0:48:17Take control of your data and keep your private life private by signing up for DeleteMe.

0:48:21Now, with a special discount for listeners of this show, you can get 20% off your DeleteMe plan.

0:48:26You go to joindeleteme.com/upgrade20 and use the promo code upgrade20 at checkout.

0:48:32The only way to get that 20% off is to go to this URL that is joindeleteme.com/upgrade20

0:48:40and use the promo code upgrade20 at checkout.

0:48:42I'm going to give you that one last time.

0:48:44joindeleteme.com/upgrade20, promo code upgrade20.

0:48:48A thanks to DeleteMe for their support of this show and Real AFM.

0:48:52Room around up time, partner.

0:48:55Yeehaw.

0:48:57Your favourite topic. Mark Gurman has published another robot.

0:49:01Another robot. Another report about his tabletop robot.

0:49:04Robot or not.

0:49:06Robot or not.

0:49:08You can check out Robot or Not on the incomparable if you have no idea what that is.

0:49:13Yeah, that's right. All those theme songs we sang by Lex Friedman, maker of Upgrade Jingles.

0:49:17Indeed. That's what he's best known for.

0:49:20Oh, man. Jingles.

0:49:22I'll put a link in the show notes for Robot or Not.

0:49:24So, Mark Gurman has posted a quite lengthy report about Apple's robotics plans.

0:49:30So, the first thing is a product that essentially combines the look of an iPad on a robotic limb.

0:49:38Yes, it's going to look like the iMac G4.

0:49:41So, I'm going to stop you here.

0:49:44Why?

0:49:45I'm going to stop you here because I'm going to say it again.

0:49:52A kitchen speaker with a base and an arm and a screen that rotates or goes up and down or whatever is not a robot.

0:50:06It's not a robot.

0:50:08Are you allowed to give that distinction?

0:50:10Yes. I allow it.

0:50:12On this show, you say what the robots are.

0:50:15Well, I can cite. We had this question for John Saracusa and he said if it just sits on a counter and moves around within itself and it's not skittering around and doing stuff on the counter, it is not a robot.

0:50:29It is moving automatically, but it is not a robot.

0:50:32And look, we love Mark Gurman. He gets good scoops. He's very good at scooping.

0:50:39His insistence on calling this thing a robot is killing me.

0:50:44It's like a HomePod version of the Amazon show, Echo Show, right?

0:50:54It's a kitchen speaker that does FaceTime and apparently it will move the screen around, which some other things also do.

0:51:02I think the Facebook one does it.

0:51:04Also not a robot. It's just not a robot.

0:51:06But he's packed it in this narrative of Apple has a lot of robotic things going on.

0:51:10And there are other robotics things that he talks about in here.

0:51:13Maybe more robots.

0:51:14Which make me roll my eyes because I don't think that there are going to be anything we see anytime soon, if ever, probably never.

0:51:19Sure, sure.

0:51:20Whereas this seems like it's a real product.

0:51:22But to call it an iPad on a robotic limb, it feels like this is the very definition of the parable of the blind men and the elephant.

0:51:32Where it's like you're describing a product that we can all pretty much guess and I would never describe it as an iPad on a robotic limb.

0:51:40I would call it a kitchen speaker on an arm.

0:51:42It's more intriguing to call it a robot though, right?

0:51:46Well, that's why it's narrative building anyway.

0:51:48It's not a robot.

0:51:49It's a home pod with a screen that can move around, that can pivot or something.

0:51:57It's not, like I'll just say, unless it can move around on my countertop, it is not a robot.

0:52:03That's it.

0:52:04Quote, "The device is envisioned as a smart home command center, video conferencing machine and remote controlled home security tool."

0:52:12Gorman says that Apple now has several hundred employees working on the project.

0:52:17It is expected that there could be a debut of it in 2026 or 2027 at around $1000.

0:52:23And there has been internal concern about the price of such a device and if it would attract a market.

0:52:28But Tim Cook and John Turness are in favor of this project, which has now become, quote, "The sole responsibility of Kevin Lynch."

0:52:37Okay.

0:52:38Here's a longer quote.

0:52:40"The idea is for the tabletop product" -- doesn't call it a robot there --

0:52:43"the tabletop product to be primarily controlled using the Siri digital assistant and upcoming features in Apple intelligence.

0:52:49The device could respond to commands such as 'look at me' by repositioning the screen to focus on the person saying the words,

0:52:56say, during a video call. It could also understand different voices and adjust its focus accordingly.

0:53:01Current models in testing run a customized version of iPadOS."

0:53:05Okay, first off, that's describing center stage, except you have to tell it to do it.

0:53:09And I get the idea that center stage has limitations and if you can actually move the camera around, it's better.

0:53:15Although, again, what a weird example to say, "Look at me" when, like, during a video call, right?

0:53:23Like, well, during a video call, it should just look at you.

0:53:26I mean, I'm now the only commandant of my robot.

0:53:29Just for video calls, though, right?

0:53:31Like, you know, me and you are in the kitchen and I want the weather and the robot's pointing at you and I'm like,

0:53:36"Hey, give me the weather."

0:53:37It's not a robot, but yes, you say, "Look at me" because I want to see the weather.

0:53:40I get it. I get it.

0:53:42Robo. HomePod Robo.

0:53:44Again, this feels very much like somebody is describing it and it's being obfuscated and simplified and it sounds much more complicated than it actually is.

0:53:54We know all the parts that Apple has for this thing.

0:53:56A thousand dollars is a lot of money for a device like this, which doesn't mean that Apple won't do it at that price.

0:54:07But I would say one of my concerns about modern Apple is that they build, they over-engineer their products.

0:54:14Not that they're expensive because Apple products are always expensive, but that they overshoot and over-engineer their products.

0:54:21And that if the only way to build a combination smart home command center video conferencing machine and remote controlled home security tool

0:54:30that moves around in response to your voice commands is by building this amazing thing that costs a thousand dollars.

0:54:36You know, maybe not.

0:54:39Let's just not do the arm. How about that?

0:54:41Just get rid of the arm and it's 500 dollars.

0:54:44Have a little base that turns.

0:54:46Don't even do that. Don't even have it move. It doesn't need to move.

0:54:49It doesn't need to move.

0:54:50That's really not a robot then.

0:54:52It doesn't, right?

0:54:54Just because you can, it doesn't. In fact, you could put very clever sensors on it.

0:54:58If you wanted to have a 360 view, you could put a camera on the front and a camera on the back.

0:55:02And then it could see everywhere.

0:55:03But it doesn't have to move.

0:55:05It doesn't have to move.

0:55:07It doesn't have to move.

0:55:08And that's, sometimes I wonder of what Apple is doing with some of these products.

0:55:11They're saying, well, there's already those products in the market.

0:55:13So we can't come in at that level.

0:55:15We have to make it better.

0:55:16We got to make it better.

0:55:17But then they make it a thousand dollars.

0:55:18It's like, well, no, no.

0:55:20Make it good and not full of ads and slow and bad like what Amazon and Google have.

0:55:26And then bring it in at 500 or 750.

0:55:30But also, yeah, look.

0:55:31Make a HomePod, put a screen on it, and it can move on a base.

0:55:35Right?

0:55:36Yeah.

0:55:37And that could be 600, say.

0:55:39But it's not a thousand.

0:55:40Yeah.

0:55:41It feels very Vision Pro to me where it's overdone, just over egged.

0:55:46There's too much in here.

0:55:47This product is a product I want.

0:55:49Right?

0:55:50I do want this.

0:55:51Yes.

0:55:52This is that enthusiasm we were talking about in the last segment.

0:55:54I'm very excited about Apple using all of the tech that it's already got that we all know

0:55:58to build a product that is like a home speaker that could go in the kitchen that's got a screen

0:56:03that I can control and that ties into Apple's ecosystem.

0:56:06It's got all my apps on it.

0:56:07Sold.

0:56:08It's got my calendar on it.

0:56:09Sold.

0:56:10When I ask for my calendar, it shows me my calendar.

0:56:11Yeah, I want it.

0:56:12But they're going to have to tell a real good story, which I think they could, but they

0:56:16have to tell a real good story for why this needs to be on a robotic arm and cost a thousand

0:56:20dollars.

0:56:21Right?

0:56:22Maybe they can do it and maybe, hey, just maybe it's so beautiful that you're happy

0:56:29to put it in your kitchen.

0:56:30Sure.

0:56:31You're happy to put it in your living room.

0:56:32Right?

0:56:33Because, and it's a thousand dollars because this thing is like beautiful.

0:56:36Maybe it's too beautiful.

0:56:37You're like, no, no, it can't be in my kitchen.

0:56:39It's too beautiful.

0:56:40I can't even bear to look at it.

0:56:41It's so beautiful.

0:56:42Because my Amazon Echo show is an ugly duck.

0:56:46It's, yeah.

0:56:47Right?

0:56:48My Google Home is, uh, it's, it's, it's, yeah.

0:56:51It's not great.

0:56:52And so maybe this would be really nice.

0:56:54And so like that, you know, that helps to the thing, but a thousand dollars on a robotic

0:56:58arm is a lot.

0:57:00It's a lot.

0:57:01It's a lot.

0:57:02It's a lot.

0:57:03It's a lot.

0:57:04And again, look, this is what we always say with these things.

0:57:05We have so many details we don't have, but it's on the face of it as a lot.

0:57:10And do you remember the HomePod?

0:57:12How much does the HomePod?

0:57:13Does that have 500 when it came around the first time?

0:57:15Something like that.

0:57:16Yeah.

0:57:17That was too much.

0:57:18Right?

0:57:19But I bought two of those and I prefer one of these.

0:57:20So maybe I'm the problem.

0:57:21You know what I'm saying?

0:57:22Yeah.

0:57:23Yeah.

0:57:24Yeah.

0:57:25It just, and maybe a thousand.

0:57:26$349 apparently, but still two of those $349.

0:57:28It seemed like a thousand dollars, but it was $349.

0:57:32But this is the thing.

0:57:33This is the thing at a thousand dollars.

0:57:35I, I, I look at it and I say, whatever we're doing here, it's too much.

0:57:40But like, and that's the problem I've got is like, what's going on inside Apple that

0:57:45you make these decisions and you're like, oh no, $3,500 headset.

0:57:49That's a good idea.

0:57:50And a thousand dollar kitchen speaker thing.

0:57:52And it's like, well, yeah, but it'll be so amazing.

0:57:54It's like, yeah, what would the $700 one look like?

0:57:57Yeah.

0:57:58We'd have to take off the legs and the wheels that make it roll around on your countertop.

0:58:01Oh, well do that.

0:58:03Cause then it's not a robot.

0:58:05I think you made a very good point about the, they start with the, we want to do this thing.

0:58:11How do we make it different?

0:58:13That's a problem when, when, when you do that.

0:58:15We got to blow away what Amazon and Google have done by taking it.

0:58:20Like it'll be next level in so many different ways.

0:58:23Cause I do think that there's a pride thing where even though again, Apple, they're bad.

0:58:29The Amazon product, the Google product, they're bad.

0:58:32They're not up to your standards.

0:58:34It's the equivalent of Apple TV versus the stuff that's on a TV or, or a Roku or whatever.

0:58:41Yours is better.

0:58:42I mean asterisk, but, but it is better.

0:58:45And the hardware is really nice and you charge a lot for it.

0:58:49And like it's found an audience.

0:58:50The remote is great.

0:58:52The TV app is great.

0:58:53Like it's all good.

0:58:54I think so.

0:58:55Joe Rosensteels in the chat room.

0:58:59Don't anger him.

0:59:00No, no, but I'm willing to die on this cross.

0:59:02Like I think, I think Apple TV is awesome.

0:59:04I love it.

0:59:05Having used other, other set top box things.

0:59:08It's the best.

0:59:09It's the best.

0:59:10It's not, it's, it's got lots of issues, but it's still the best.

0:59:13Okay.

0:59:14Google and Amazon stuff for this category are awful.

0:59:17They're awful.

0:59:18They're not close to Apple standards, but Apple seems to want to well, but we got to

0:59:22blow them away.

0:59:24They don't want the glory of entering a category with a product.

0:59:27That's kind of like what the ones that are already there, but more expensive and better.

0:59:31And instead it's like, they want to dunk on them and like dunking on them is not a bad

0:59:38thing, but dunking on them for five times the price of them where nobody's going to

0:59:45buy it is a bad thing.

0:59:46So that's the restraint I would like to see if you want to make Apple tabletop home robot

0:59:51pro and Apple tabletop home, not a robot and sell them both.

0:59:57That's great.

0:59:58But you get, you end up in a home pod situation where you do the home pod and it goes over

1:00:02like a lead balloon.

1:00:03And then they're like, Oh, home pod mini.

1:00:04And it's like, Oh yeah, people kind of like that.

1:00:07Right.

1:00:08That should have been your first product.

1:00:10That's what I'm saying here is I'm getting real home pod vibes, real vision pro vibes

1:00:15where it's like, you're making some decisions to, to blow away the competition when your

1:00:20basic thing would blow away the competition.

1:00:24So maybe make that apparently Apple also has a team now that are exploring other robotic

1:00:30devices, including a humanoid robot.

1:00:32The actual robot, actual robots.

1:00:36This team is being run by a robotic expert by the names of Hans Warfum Tapayna.

1:00:43I will say this person sounds like a robotics expert.

1:00:46That is the name of someone who knows robots.

1:00:50Hans Warfum Tapayna.

1:00:52That person, I don't know anything about them, but I know they're a robots expert and I believe

1:00:56it.

1:00:57Tapayna's team consists of a hundred engineers who departed the car project.

1:01:02They're going from one to the other, you know?

1:01:07Look I, I think that here's what I think about this.

1:01:12I like the idea that Apple has people who are experts at this stuff who are just messing

1:01:15around trying to figure stuff out.

1:01:17That's fine.

1:01:18It doesn't need to be a product.

1:01:20It could lead to a product.

1:01:21It could accidentally lead to a product.

1:01:23You will, we'll see.

1:01:24I'm not sure if this is in Apple's wheelhouse, but, uh, sure.

1:01:28Why not?

1:01:29Why not investigate that and experience it?

1:01:31And if yes, if Apple eventually comes up with a little robot that can vacuum and mop and

1:01:36sweep and, and I don't know what fold your laundry or whatever, like, great, that'll

1:01:41be amazing.

1:01:42But it seems unlikely to me that any of that will actually happen.

1:01:47Mark Gurman, standby everybody.

1:01:50Mark is also reporting that Apple continues to explore a larger iMac.

1:01:54Oh, I hope they find it.

1:01:58What's what's out there?

1:01:59What's across the horizon?

1:02:00Could there be a larger iMac somewhere out there?

1:02:02They're out there.

1:02:03They're still developing the idea.

1:02:04It's like a bigfoot though.

1:02:06It's like there are pictures that suggest there might be a larger iMac, but you can't

1:02:09verify them.

1:02:10I don't want it anymore.

1:02:11All right.

1:02:12You told me I couldn't have it.

1:02:14Now I don't want it.

1:02:15Don't bring it.

1:02:16Don't do it.

1:02:17Honestly, I want them to do a larger display.

1:02:21Yes.

1:02:22Give me a big display.

1:02:23That a Mac studio, a laptop, a Mac mini could be attached to.

1:02:27I want a big display that is ProMotion.

1:02:31That's what I want because I have my 14 inch MacBook Pro that I record on here hooked up

1:02:36to an OG display because like whatever.

1:02:39But like even if I hooked up to a studio display, it's not getting everything that computer

1:02:43can do.

1:02:44That computer can do promotion and I want that.

1:02:47Give me that in a display, please.

1:02:50That's fair.

1:02:51As well as this, Mark is reporting that the next generation of AirPods could get active

1:02:55noise cancellation.

1:02:57So currently you can buy two sets of products called AirPods.

1:03:05AirPods 2, which was the long stem ones and AirPods 3, which was redesigned to be closer

1:03:11to AirPods Pro in packaging and like its format, but they don't go in your ears, right?

1:03:17They just don't go directly in, you know, the rubber tips.

1:03:21So this year Apple is looking to redesign, like repackage these, right?

1:03:29So there'll be two new sets of AirPods called the AirPods.

1:03:33They'd be like AirPods 4 basically.

1:03:35And maybe like they may name them slightly different.

1:03:38So but what they will do is create a new entry level product that retains the features of

1:03:43the current AirPods 3.

1:03:45Yeah, and AirPods 2.

1:03:47So it like retains those features and then add in a new mid tier AirPods product that

1:03:53gets noise cancellation, but not all the other features of the AirPods Pro.

1:03:58Both would get USB-C cases.

1:04:01I wonder what these will actually look like.

1:04:05Like are they going to redesign AirPods 2 to be like shorter stem maybe?

1:04:10And then also is the AirPods 3, I guess it has to have in-ear silicon tips.

1:04:17Right?

1:04:18Like how else can you do noise cancellation?

1:04:20You have to have a seal, don't you?

1:04:23I don't know.

1:04:24I mean to do a good one, yeah, because otherwise the sound gets in.

1:04:27Because then what's the point?

1:04:29So it looks like what they're going to do is create a regular AirPods set.

1:04:34And I, you know, I feel bad for the people who AirPods 3 don't fit in their ears because

1:04:38maybe there won't be any more AirPods that will fit in their ears.

1:04:41Then create an active noise cancellation cheaper version and then AirPods Pro, I don't know

1:04:49what it will get.

1:04:50Like I wonder, I assume that these…

1:04:52Get that infrared camera.

1:04:53I guess, but that's not this year.

1:04:56Like there won't be a new AirPods Pro this year.

1:04:57That would be next year at the earliest, Mark says.

1:04:59So I mean I would assume that as well as noise cancellation, it will also get transparency

1:05:04mode.

1:05:05I mean it doesn't say that, but I would assume that you would get that.

1:05:09Intriguing.

1:05:10I mean, this is the iPad and iPad Pro of it all, right?

1:05:14Like this is what they do.

1:05:16The features roll down the line.

1:05:17Yeah, I think they've got…

1:05:20One question is, it's like is it a mid-tier or is it essentially an extension of what

1:05:24we have now where we essentially have a low-end AirPod and a mid-tier AirPod?

1:05:29And that will these be like…

1:05:32In other words, is AirPods 2 replaced by something that is also at a similar price, right?

1:05:38That is very limited in features, but just revised to be a little more modern.

1:05:41And that AirPods 3 gets replaced with something that is really just kind of in the middle

1:05:46there so that they've got a good, better, best kind of scenario with the AirPods Pro

1:05:50on top.

1:05:51You know, AirPods Air.

1:05:52No, don't call it that.

1:05:54It's a bad idea.

1:05:56AirPods…

1:05:57And so they put the Air in AirPods in all caps, you know?

1:06:01Just to let you know that it's the…

1:06:03Okay.

1:06:04So yeah, interesting.

1:06:05I will be intrigued to see where this goes and I know it's going to upset some people

1:06:09because people get like very…

1:06:10They're like very specific.

1:06:11Like some people, AirPods 3 don't fit in their ears and some people don't want in-ear

1:06:17silicon.

1:06:18I will just say, you know, people that have…

1:06:21I didn't want to do in-ear silicon.

1:06:22I've never liked that before, but I like AirPods.

1:06:25They work for me.

1:06:28The next iPhone Pro, we've been talking about a bronze color.

1:06:32Is it actually going to be brown though?

1:06:35So there is an image that has come out of potentially what the next iPhone lineup is

1:06:41going to look like from Sonny Dixon, who has had a pretty good track record with this stuff

1:06:46in the past.

1:06:48And the bronze color iPhone Pro, it looks very Microsoft Zuni.

1:06:54It's very brown looking in this image.

1:06:57Yeah, I would caution people because based on lighting and cameras, colors can really

1:07:05be different than reality.

1:07:09It does look really brown in here, although there is that one thing that suggested it's

1:07:13like desert titanium or something.

1:07:16One of the names is suggested is desert titanium, which I think is a translation error, but

1:07:21nevertheless, that's…

1:07:22Yeah, well, look, it's iPhone math, okay?

1:07:25Forget about it.

1:07:26iPhone math, that's a reference.

1:07:28What I would say is worst case scenario, Zun phone.

1:07:36Best case scenario, tan phone?

1:07:40It's not a great best case scenario.

1:07:43Yeah, I'm not sure.

1:07:46So I was intrigued about bronze, but like now I'm like, "I don't know, like was this worth

1:07:51replacing blue?"

1:07:53No, as the owner of a blue titanium phone, no.

1:07:58But the black one looks nice though, you know, in this image.

1:08:00Of course it does.

1:08:01The black one looks good.

1:08:02Something that I've forgotten about, but I saw in another article about this, which was

1:08:08the rumor that they were going to move from matte rails back to polished again.

1:08:13And it definitely looks like that in this image.

1:08:16And I don't know how I feel about that because I actually quite like the matte texture on

1:08:20the side of the current titanium one.

1:08:21I don't know if I want to go back to shiny again.

1:08:23I think that's too soon to go straight back.

1:08:27I understand the idea of you change things up.

1:08:29So they're like, you know, you're just setting your own trends and stuff.

1:08:32But I think one year of the matte rails may not have been long enough to go straight back

1:08:38to shiny again.

1:08:39But yeah, I mean, looking at this lineup, I'm probably going to stick with natural titanium.

1:08:45I bought blue and then at the podcastathon last year, I saw you guys had your natural

1:08:50titanium models.

1:08:52And I thought about returning the blue and in the end, I decided the blue is fine.

1:08:57I like the blue and I don't want to go through the trouble of returning my phone and getting

1:09:00a new phone.

1:09:01That said, natural titanium looks real good.

1:09:05And I might go with that next time.

1:09:08We'll see.

1:09:09I'll probably stick with it like that.

1:09:10I don't think I'm going to change it because I actually do kind of like it.

1:09:14I want to just say while we're talking about the iPhone real quick.

1:09:17These things are made of really strong glass.

1:09:20I've dropped, you've been in my house.

1:09:22I have concrete floors downstairs.

1:09:24I dropped my phone twice in the last week because I had like shorts that had, I was

1:09:28wearing some shorts that I didn't have very deep pockets so it kept falling out my pocket.

1:09:32I've dropped my phone twice hard onto the concrete.

1:09:35Perfectly fine.

1:09:36These phones are strong now.

1:09:37I know that they break.

1:09:38I know that they break.

1:09:39But like in years, you know, going back into the past, I don't know how long, my phone

1:09:43would have been absolutely done.

1:09:45Like a couple of little drops here and there where I thought, oh, and it's not going to

1:09:50work.

1:09:51Nothing is happening.

1:09:52It has hit hard.

1:09:53I had one that hit directly onto the front and then one that hit onto the side and then

1:09:56the front and they made bad noises.

1:09:58It was the kind of noise where Adina was like, oh no, when she heard it, right?

1:10:01Because she knew what it was.

1:10:02Yeah.

1:10:03Absolutely fine.

1:10:04Not a mark on it.

1:10:05So beautiful.

1:10:06These phones are strong.

1:10:07The investments that they've made in glass, like I know that they have that deal with

1:10:11Corning, right?

1:10:13To make strong glass, stronger, stronger glass.

1:10:16It's doing the business.

1:10:18I got to say, I'm happy with it.

1:10:20I've got a statement that I want you to think about here, which is you've got to have deep

1:10:24pockets if you'll use an iPhone without a case.

1:10:28Bravo.

1:10:29No, I'm really, Adina is incredible.

1:10:34And figuratively.

1:10:35You should be proud of that one.

1:10:36Genuinely.

1:10:37Thank you.

1:10:38I'm putting it on the hall of fame.

1:10:39Put it on the board.

1:10:40Yes.

1:10:41Congratulations to me, everybody.

1:10:42Let's raise your jersey.

1:10:43He's going to retire now.

1:10:44We're done.

1:10:45Stand up for the champions.

1:10:46Yes.

1:10:47Wow.

1:10:48That's so good, Jason.

1:10:50You can tell you're a writer, you know?

1:10:52You have the shallow pockets.

1:10:53That was your problem.

1:10:54That was my problem.

1:10:55Because then, you know, you got to, because you have to shell out for it.

1:10:57Anyway, I'm not going to explain.

1:10:58Don't keep doing it because we're going to ruin it.

1:11:01Yep.

1:11:02This episode is brought to you by KRCS, one of the oldest around of the Apple premium

1:11:07resellers and your one-stop shop for all things Apple in the UK.

1:11:12For our UK listeners right now at KRCS, you can get 0% interest on any Mac over a thousand

1:11:18pounds for 12 months.

1:11:20This means you can buy the latest MacBook Air M3 for just £76 per month.

1:11:25You can make your Mac truly yours and have the exact specification you want with pricing

1:11:30that you're not going to find anywhere else.

1:11:32Or choose from popular models in stock as long as it's over £1,000 and it will qualify

1:11:36for 12 months interest-free credit with free next working day delivery on in-stock items

1:11:42ordered before 3pm.

1:11:43There's never been a better time to get a Mac at KRCS, your local Apple experts.

1:11:48You can get more information at krcs.co.uk/podcast or click the link in the show notes.

1:11:5418+ only, subject to approval, terms and conditions apply.

1:11:57Please spend responsibly.

1:11:58Borrowing, growing your means could seriously affect your financial status.

1:12:02Ensure you can afford to make your payments on time by the due date.

1:12:05Once again, go now to krcs.co.uk/podcast and get free next working day delivery on in-stock

1:12:12items ordered before 3pm.

1:12:15Our thanks to KRCS for their support of this show and all of Relay.

1:12:19And it's time for some Ask Upgrade Questions.

1:12:28First question comes in from Steven, not that one, who asks, "Jason, what was better in

1:12:33the 90s, Mac user or Macworld?"

1:12:35Oh, Mac user.

1:12:39I was a Mac user reader and that's why I wanted to work there and then I worked there.

1:12:45And we were the upstart, we were a little less formal, we had more fun.

1:12:51And then they merged us together with Macworld and you know, most of the Macworld people

1:12:57left and most of the Mac user people stayed and most of the people you see out there writing

1:13:03about tech or working at Apple or whatever now are almost entirely people who worked

1:13:10at Macuser and not who worked at Macworld.

1:13:12And that was the big surprise I had was that Macworld was much, again, I don't wanna say

1:13:19that everybody was like this, but sort of generalizing is bad, but I felt like most

1:13:24of the people on the Macworld staff were happy to be in the magazine business and most of

1:13:28the people on the Macuser staff were excited to write about Macs.

1:13:34And I think it showed, I think Macworld was very serious and professional and Macuser

1:13:38was wackier and had more fun and had Chris Breen and Andy Anico and Bob Levitas and I

1:13:45was a fan, that was the one that I read.

1:13:48And so, we tried, when we went to Macworld, we tried to kinda make it more like we wanted

1:13:54to be and that just the effect of everybody for Mac was leaving and most of the Macuser

1:14:00people who went over there staying and then, you know, turnover and eventually me being

1:14:05put in charge like Macworld ended up in a very different place in the 2000s than it

1:14:08was in the 90s, but in the 90s, yeah, Macuser was my thing.

1:14:12- Peter wrote in to ask, I'm just wondering if the bigger icons on iOS and iPadOS removed

1:14:18the silly blue dots after you updated an app.

1:14:21I think Peter is very anti blue dot.

1:14:23I tried this out today to check for Peter and currently, I would say yes it does.

1:14:27So I was on my iPad and I updated some apps and I switched the icons to big and the dots

1:14:33weren't there because the names aren't there so there's nowhere to put the dot.

1:14:36However, when I then switched my icons back from big to small, the dots were gone even

1:14:41from my test flight apps.

1:14:42So, who could tell, you know?

1:14:45Who could tell 'cause that's not supposed to happen.

1:14:47But currently, yeah, it does get rid of them.

1:14:50And I would put a bet on it will actually get rid of them.

1:14:54So, there you go.

1:14:57I don't know if I need to know that my apps have been updated, you know?

1:15:00Like, I don't think I need to know that.

1:15:02But there you go.

1:15:04James asked a question.

1:15:08Jason, you're not gonna like the frame of this question, I can tell you that.

1:15:10'Cause I don't like the frame of this question either, but it's an interesting question.

1:15:15James asks, why does Craig Federighi seem to get a pass from Apple commentators?

1:15:19See, this is the frame, man.

1:15:21I don't like everyone being lumped in together.

1:15:23Like, it's one-

1:15:24- I called him out on a podcast recently, by the way.

1:15:26So, I, but continue.

1:15:29- People are quick to directly excoriate,

1:15:32that's an interesting word.

1:15:34Tim Cook for issues with regulation services revenue

1:15:37in the China supply chain or Phil Schiller for app store rules.

1:15:40But for all of the complaints about Apple software, paternalism, quality, release cadence,

1:15:46no one seems to bring up the SVP of software engineering

1:15:49who's actually in charge of these things.

1:15:51Can it really be the hair?

1:15:52- Well, first off, you mentioned Tim Cook and Phil Schiller.

1:15:56Like, Tim Cook's the boss, stops with him.

1:15:59And Phil Schiller, he's been there longer than anybody.

1:16:02And he's kind of the boss when it comes to some of the stuff

1:16:04that is in his purview.

1:16:06So, that's why they get brought up.

1:16:08Even then, we don't know the true dynamics of it.

1:16:11We don't.

1:16:11That's the thing about making anything personal at Apple

1:16:14is you don't actually know the real dynamics going on.

1:16:16That said, I don't know whether it was on this podcast

1:16:20or Mac break weekly.

1:16:21I mean, I do lots of podcasts people,

1:16:23but I have absolutely in the last week or two

1:16:26mentioned Craig Federighi.

1:16:29I think about the permissions thing,

1:16:31but I think the reason to answer this question directly,

1:16:36Craig seems to get a light touch from Apple commentators

1:16:40in part because he feels like he's one of us.

1:16:43- He's possible.

1:16:44- He's a friendly guy.

1:16:46He's nerdy.

1:16:47He understands about software development.

1:16:50There's so many things as a character

1:16:53in interviews and in Apple events and it's lighthearted.

1:16:59And we remember when he did his first demo

1:17:01and he was shaking 'cause he was so nervous

1:17:04and he feels like one of us.

1:17:07So, that's my answer.

1:17:09But I will say this.

1:17:11Absolutely a lot of these issues about Apple software system

1:17:16and the missteps they make

1:17:20in terms of their software development

1:17:22can be laid at the foot of Craig Federighi,

1:17:26CFED, CFED himself, our buddy, the guy with the hair.

1:17:31Craig, the buck doesn't stop with Craig.

1:17:34There are a lot of SVPs at Apple,

1:17:35but like he's in charge of the software.

1:17:37If we think that Apple software quality is bad

1:17:39or that they have misguided priorities

1:17:41or that the security and privacy people

1:17:44are bullying the user experience people

1:17:45and the user experience failed,

1:17:47ultimately while we can't know who's responsible

1:17:51and that's why you should never make it personal,

1:17:54I do know that ultimately Craig is responsible.

1:17:59And I think a lot of people think, well, he's so likable

1:18:04and he's gotta be fighting for what's right on the inside.

1:18:07And he seems like a nice guy.

1:18:09I think that's all true.

1:18:11I think it would be fair to say,

1:18:13is he a good leader of a giant software group or not?

1:18:18I don't know.

1:18:19I don't know.

1:18:20I haven't heard from anybody at Apple about it.

1:18:22I don't know if he's like,

1:18:23just because he's a nice guy and we like him

1:18:25and he seems like one of us,

1:18:26does that make him flawless?

1:18:29It does not.

1:18:30Is it the case that Craig Federighi

1:18:32is fighting the good fight every day,

1:18:33but that there's some stuff that he just can't win on?

1:18:36Sure.

1:18:38Could it also be true that Craig Federighi

1:18:40is letting things go that he shouldn't

1:18:43and not standing up for things.

1:18:44And as a result, the processes are not as clean

1:18:49and good as they should be.

1:18:50Could also be true.

1:18:52This I don't know.

1:18:53But I will agree with James

1:18:55that Craig doesn't deserve a pass

1:19:00even though we like him.

1:19:02That ultimately we can't know,

1:19:04unless somebody wants to tell us,

1:19:05the details of the inner workings of Apple.

1:19:08You can never say, oh, this thing happened

1:19:10that I don't like, who is at fault?

1:19:12Very hard to say, right?

1:19:13There's huge organizational dynamics at play here.

1:19:16But ultimately, yeah, he's the guy in charge of software.

1:19:18And if software is messing things up,

1:19:20he's the guy we gotta question.

1:19:23I mean, not that we can talk to him

1:19:25other than maybe at the talk show,

1:19:27John Gruber can ask him a question

1:19:28that Greg Joswiak reaches out and bats out of the air

1:19:31before we can reach him.

1:19:33But other than that, I mean, yeah, I think that's true.

1:19:36It's just a lot.

1:19:37He's one of many SVPs

1:19:39and so it's harder to make that statement

1:19:43than it is for something like Tim Cook, who's the boss,

1:19:45or Phil Schiller, who's been there for a million years

1:19:47and very clearly has had stuff

1:19:49just sort of delegated to him

1:19:51that he rules over and that's it.

1:19:54So that's kind of my answer.

1:19:56I don't think it's the hair though.

1:19:57If I had to do armchair psychology,

1:19:59I would say it's because he's the most like us.

1:20:01He's like our wish fulfillment character

1:20:03at Apple a little bit.

1:20:04And as a result, it's very hard to criticize Craig.

1:20:07He seems so nice.

1:20:08And like one of us, I seem to understand him.

1:20:10And we know that they send people over to his house

1:20:13when there are bugs, right?

1:20:14Like that's all sweet, but at the end of the day,

1:20:17if Apple's messing up at software, he's the boss.

1:20:19- I don't know if I do a good job of this.

1:20:23I know how I feel.

1:20:24And so maybe, I know how it makes me feel,

1:20:27so I hope I do.

1:20:28I try my best to never try and ascribe anything

1:20:32to an individual 'cause I don't know.

1:20:33- Don't get personal.

1:20:34- And there's no point, right?

1:20:36'Cause I don't know who's making the decision.

1:20:38Like just because you're the boss,

1:20:40sometimes you have to make a decision

1:20:42even though you don't agree with it

1:20:43because everybody in your organization is asking for it,

1:20:45but it doesn't mean you agree with it.

1:20:46- Yeah, but at a certain level, you gotta wear it though.

1:20:49I'm like, if Tim Cook makes a decision,

1:20:50he can say that he doesn't like it,

1:20:52but he made it and he's the CEO.

1:20:54So he has to take it.

1:20:55- But you also can't say that he doesn't like it.

1:20:57Like you can't say that 'cause-

1:20:58- 'Cause you don't know.

1:20:59It's true, that's why you should never get personal.

1:21:00- I mean, like even if he doesn't like a decision

1:21:02that he makes, he can't say he doesn't like it,

1:21:04but he has to just take it, just do it

1:21:06because like what else you can do?

1:21:06- But he's still the CEO.

1:21:08So in the end, he's still the CEO.

1:21:11- But anyway, for me, I would never try

1:21:14and ascribe blame to someone for something.

1:21:17Like I don't, I mean, Apple is what Apple is.

1:21:22Do I think that like the services stuff

1:21:24is like Tim Cook's fault?

1:21:25I don't know that.

1:21:27I don't know that.

1:21:28- Or Eddy Cue's fault for that matter, right?

1:21:30- Or anybody's, but they just are where they are.

1:21:33- This is why I always say the extreme example of this

1:21:38that I really don't like, but it's a spectrum

1:21:42is people say this person should be fired, right?

1:21:46First off, talking about somebody's livelihood

1:21:49is really, it makes me very uncomfortable.

1:21:53- It's gross.

1:21:53- It's yes.

1:21:54Second, you don't know.

1:21:56You don't know.

1:21:57Like you, unless you literally have been working

1:22:00with these people inside Apple for years

1:22:02and they can say to me, oh yeah,

1:22:03he should have been fired years ago, whoever it was.

1:22:06Yeah, she should get out of there 'cause it's a bad fit.

1:22:09She got promoted above her level.

1:22:10Whoever it is, one of these people inside Apple,

1:22:13unless you're inside there, you don't get to say,

1:22:15oh, well, you know, the thing is about Craig

1:22:16is they should fire him because I had a bug in the beta.

1:22:19And people say that kind of stuff.

1:22:20And it's like, you don't know.

1:22:22Like I imagine the pressure on Craig Vetterighi

1:22:24to run that organization is enormous.

1:22:26And I imagine that there are very difficult decisions

1:22:29he has to make.

1:22:29I'm reminded of something Obama said,

1:22:33which was like, what is it like being president

1:22:36that surprised you?

1:22:36And he said, you know, they don't come to me

1:22:39with the 98% decisions or the 70, 30 decisions.

1:22:44They come to me with 49, 51.

1:22:47Really, they come to me with 50, 50.

1:22:48Like if it's a decision that's easy,

1:22:51it never even gets to the president.

1:22:53Only the very, very hard decisions

1:22:55where there's no good answer

1:22:56get to the president's desk, right?

1:22:58That's sort of the truth of being a leader in general.

1:23:01But I always remember him saying that

1:23:02'cause like Craig Vetterighi,

1:23:03I'm sure that he has all sorts of forces pushing him

1:23:07left and right.

1:23:08And there's the politics

1:23:09and there's people at his level

1:23:11who are like, we need this thing.

1:23:12'Cause he's got John G and Andrea who's in charge of AI.

1:23:15That's software, but it's also his own fiefdom

1:23:18and not Craig's group and how do they interact?

1:23:20Like it's very hard to say,

1:23:22oh, this thing happened and it's Craig.

1:23:25'Cause like, we don't know.

1:23:26We don't know.

1:23:27Maybe he navigated it better

1:23:29than anyone else could possibly have done

1:23:32in difficult circumstances.

1:23:34Or alternately, maybe he totally messed it up.

1:23:38But we don't know.

1:23:39We just don't know.

1:23:39And that's why you should never make it personal.

1:23:43And while I can say, like I said,

1:23:45I do believe that I can say something's going on in software.

1:23:48Craig Vetterighi is in charge of software.

1:23:50What's going on, Craig?

1:23:51I'm not gonna say Craig Vetterighi should be fired, right?

1:23:53Craig, go fire him because like you can't.

1:23:57'Cause you don't know.

1:23:58It's way more complicated than that.

1:24:00And like, again, I do believe the buck stops here.

1:24:02We talk about Tim Cook and the Tim Cook era.

1:24:05It represents he's been presiding over it for a decade.

1:24:07This is the direction Apple's going in.

1:24:09We could, there is a nuanced debate to have in there,

1:24:12but also as the CEO, I would argue like, he's a big boy.

1:24:15He's the man in charge.

1:24:16He has to own it regardless.

1:24:19But even then I wouldn't make it personal

1:24:21because you are right that like,

1:24:24there are lots of things I think Tim Cook does

1:24:26as the CEO of Apple that he's uneasy about,

1:24:29but he feels that he has to because that's the job.

1:24:33He gets his wins where he can get them.

1:24:35- Like when he stood next to Donald Trump

1:24:38in a Mac Pro factory sometime and just said,

1:24:40"Oh, he did this."

1:24:42- Yeah, no, I mean, he gets the wins where he can

1:24:44and he does the other things.

1:24:46Yes, I'm pretty sure Tim Cook didn't want to go

1:24:49to the Mac Pro factory with Donald Trump,

1:24:51but he was the president of the United States

1:24:53and he wanted to do it.

1:24:54And they're like, "Okay, we are gonna do this.

1:24:57"It makes sense for Apple."

1:24:58I'm sure he was uneasy about it sitting next to him

1:25:00at that thing.

1:25:01But again, he's the CEO of Apple.

1:25:03He's got to do a whole bunch of stuff

1:25:05that makes himself uneasy.

1:25:06And then he's got the places where he says,

1:25:07"Oh, look at our environmental record.

1:25:08"We're gonna take the win over here."

1:25:10And that's just, it's a hard job.

1:25:12It's easy to throw stones from the outside.

1:25:14And we can be critical of Apple as a company

1:25:16because they make bad decisions.

1:25:18We've talked about them in this episode,

1:25:19but very hard to say it's that person there

1:25:23because it's just not that easy.

1:25:26Even though it would be so,

1:25:28it would feel so good if it was that easy,

1:25:30but it's just not that easy.

1:25:31- And Noah asks, "Now that we're in the summer of fun,

1:25:35"what is your go-to music, album, or playlist

1:25:37"for the summer while testing out the betas?"

1:25:40Noah specifically asks,

1:25:41"Mike, I remember a few years ago your album of choice

1:25:43"was Maggie Rogers' 'Surrender'.

1:25:45"Are you enjoying her album this year?

1:25:47"Don't forget me."

1:25:48Now let me tell you real quick,

1:25:50we'll take a quick Maggie Rogers aside, Jason.

1:25:51- Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

1:25:52- If you have a different thing.

1:25:54I was really apprehensive of Maggie Rogers' third album,

1:25:57Don't Forget Me, because I just didn't think

1:25:59it was possible she could do it again

1:26:01because her first two albums

1:26:02are just absolutely perfect albums.

1:26:07- They're great.

1:26:08- And she did it again.

1:26:09Don't Forget Me isn't just incredible.

1:26:12As a body of work across three albums,

1:26:16it is hard to find,

1:26:17I find it, I struggle to find a comparable artist

1:26:21where of all the artists that I love

1:26:23that I consider of my favorites,

1:26:25to have three albums in a row

1:26:27and they're all absolutely fantastic.

1:26:30I mean, she is operating at a different level.

1:26:34I love that album.

1:26:35- That new album has grown on me.

1:26:37First time I heard it, it left me kind of cold,

1:26:39but it has grown on me over time

1:26:40and I like it a lot better.

1:26:41Now, by the way, if you're wondering

1:26:44where an artist of the caliber of Maggie Rogers might play

1:26:48when she's in London,

1:26:50she's got two dates, September 4th and 5th.

1:26:52You can go see her at London's storied Hackney empire.

1:26:57- We're all the best perform.

1:26:59- Only the best and also every Taskmaster contestant,

1:27:02but also Maggie Rogers.

1:27:04- It's wild, it's wild.

1:27:05Yeah, she's doing that.

1:27:07They were like, I think it was one of those ones

1:27:09where if you buy a pre-sell album,

1:27:11you could get a code and they're intimate dates.

1:27:14Anyway, but yeah, I would say on that album,

1:27:20So Sick of Dreaming, The Kill and Don't Forget Me,

1:27:23they're just, those songs are just so good.

1:27:26So good.

1:27:27- The summer album that people should listen to

1:27:29to give them the vibe of the Summer of Fun

1:27:31is of course exotic themes for the silver screen

1:27:34by Michael Giacchino.

1:27:35We mentioned it on a previous episode.

1:27:36That's where Michael Giacchino, the composer,

1:27:40took a bunch of his famous movie themes

1:27:42and turned them all into essentially Summer of Fun music.

1:27:45It's pretty great.

1:27:46I also recommend The Best of You Three.

1:27:48It is an amazing playlist that Album Music made for me.

1:27:51- It's in the show notes, it's in the show notes.

1:27:53- Man, just get on that.

1:27:55Woo, yeah, yeah.

1:27:57I don't have one thing that I listen to for betas

1:28:01or anything in the summer.

1:28:02My music is just, I've got a bunch of different playlists

1:28:04and Apple Music playlists.

1:28:05- Do you have anything new this year though

1:28:06that you've really been enjoying?

1:28:07- I don't know.

1:28:11Been listening to a lot of Caroline Polachek,

1:28:18who's really great.

1:28:20And a couple of her recent albums.

1:28:24And then she has an album on a soundtrack.

1:28:28I forget, I saw the TV light maybe,

1:28:29that's really great that I've really been into.

1:28:32Yeah, Maggie Rogers.

1:28:34I don't know.

1:28:36It's, let me look, I've got a best of,

1:28:38see, have they made a best of 2025 playlist

1:28:42out of my best of 2024?

1:28:44They haven't.

1:28:45Or would it be a best of 20, 2042?

1:28:48Would Apple Music do that?

1:28:50I don't know.

1:28:51It's yeah, my best of 2024 is mostly Maggie Rogers,

1:28:56Beboduby, Caroline Polachek and Holly Humberstone.

1:28:59So yeah, just the usuals.

1:29:01- What was that last one, Holly?

1:29:04- Holly Humberstone.

1:29:05She's a Brit, she's great.

1:29:06- Oh, well come on.

1:29:07- Really, really great.

1:29:08Yeah, oh, I love her stuff.

1:29:10She's great.

1:29:11I did an EP with Maddie from the 1975

1:29:15'cause every artist I like apparently has a collaboration

1:29:19with Maddie from the 1975 at some point in their catalog.

1:29:22He's out there hunting them,

1:29:23but Holly Humberstone is great.

1:29:26Fantastic.

1:29:27- All right, if you would like to ask us a question

1:29:30for a future episode of the show,

1:29:31if you have any feedback or follow up about today's episode,

1:29:34just go to upgradefeedback.com and you can send that in.

1:29:37You can check out Jason's work at sixcolors.com

1:29:40and you can hear him on Relay and at the incomparable.com.

1:29:43You can also listen to me on Relay too

1:29:45and check out my work at cortexbrand.com.

1:29:47You can find us online.

1:29:48Jason is at Jason L, J-S-N-E-L-L.

1:29:51I am at i-Mike, I-M-Y-K-E.

1:29:54You can watch clips of this show on TikTok, Instagram

1:29:57and YouTube where we are @upgraderelay.

1:29:59Thank you to our members who support us with Upgrade Plus.

1:30:02Thank you to our sponsors, KRCS, Delete Me and Fitbud.

1:30:05But most of all, thank you for listening.

1:30:07We'll be back next time.

1:30:09Until then, say goodbye, Jason Stapp.

1:30:11- Goodbye, everybody.

1:30:13(upbeat music)

1:30:16(upbeat music)

1:30:19(upbeat music)

1:30:21(upbeat music)

1:30:24(upbeat music)

1:30:27[BLANK_AUDIO]