0:00:00[Music]
0:00:10From Relay, welcome to the 11th Annual Upgradies Awards. This evening's proceedings are brought to
0:00:17you by our broadcast partners, ShareShot, FitBod, and Data Citizens Dialogues. Simulcasts from London,
0:00:25England, and Mill Valley, California. I am one of your hosts, Mike Hurley, and joining me is my
0:00:30illustrious co-host, Mr. Jason Snell. Hi, Jason. - Hello, Mike Hurley, how are you? - Oh, I'm so excited.
0:00:37It's the Upgradies. It's the 11th Annual Upgradies, which also means it's the 10th anniversary of the
0:00:42Upgradies. - It is. 10th anniversary of the Upgradies. That first Upgradies, I know I mentioned this last
0:00:46year. Ten years ago, I was in my in-laws' upper, like, one of their guest bedrooms at a really
0:00:53uncomfortable desk and a really uncomfortable chair, but I remember it so well because it was
0:00:58like, yeah, I've got this podcast now, I've got my new job where I'm doing all this podcast, and we're
0:01:02doing these things, and I got to go up there, and everybody, my whole family and Lauren's whole
0:01:05family are all downstairs, and I'm up in a stuffy room doing what turned out to be the
0:01:12very important milestone of the first Upgradies, which at the time I thought, well,
0:01:20remember at the time I thought this is a little bit silly because I had been coming out of, like, the
0:01:23Eddie Awards and all of that, and this was, it was like, this is just you and me, and you were like,
0:01:27no, no, man, this is gonna be amazing. - And that's why I called it the first annual, even though you hated that.
0:01:33- I did hate that because nothing is the first annual. Anyway, I guess what I'm saying is, thank you for your vision.
0:01:39- Anytime. I'm always happy for a lot of my vision. - It's what makes Upgrade everybody's second favorite podcast, so
0:01:48congratulations to us. - Well, we'll find that out later on in the show when we get to the podcast category.
0:01:54I would like to mention, for the spoiler adverse out there, something we're going to do this year
0:01:59is we're going to try and get into the show notes every nominee that we mention, so if there is
0:02:06something that you want to go back and find, maybe it's a podcast or a book that we talk about, we're
0:02:10going to do our best to add everything to the show notes. Usually all I do is add a link to the
0:02:15wonderful Upgradies.com, which has the winners and the two runners up, if there are two runners up in
0:02:22each category, but I'm going to try this year to get everything in there, but the first link in the
0:02:26show notes is Upgradies.com if you want to see the winners later on, but all of the nominees will be,
0:02:32that we mentioned today, will be in the show notes for today's episode. Yeah. Now I would like to, as
0:02:39all good awards do, as awards grow, Jason, there has to be a pre-show or something like that,
0:02:46to try and get all the other awards in. We have a red carpet? Yeah. Are we on the red carpet? Oh,
0:02:51I see. This is like the Technical Award Academy Award Banquet where they send the nerds to get
0:02:56their awards. So we're going to be doing our technical awards because, as we say,
0:03:00around this time of year, it's nice to look back and think about and appreciate the people who help
0:03:07make Upgrade possible because, as time has gone on over these 10 years, it has become quite a large
0:03:12team effort to put this show together every single week. So I would like to thank for Web Designer
0:03:18Upgradies.com and also all of our scorecards, the wonderful Zach Knox, for the artwork and art
0:03:25direction is J.D. Davis. And J.D. did an incredible job with the Upgradies artwork this year in the
0:03:32obvious only way that it could have gone to, which is all the way to 11. All the way to 11. All the
0:03:39way to 11. For our music, for our special theme, and for all of our themes, the wonderful Chris
0:03:43Breen. Jim Mattson-Dorf for achievements in audio editing, of which they are needed sometimes of us.
0:03:51Similarly, for achievements in video editing, we'd like to thank the wonderful Chips.Earth
0:03:56for Chip's work and putting the video clips and video version of the show together every week.
0:04:01And then for making us cool with the kids, thank you to Jamie Snell for social media assistance.
0:04:07Jim Mattson- Yep, that's right.
0:04:08Chris Breen- We're doing the memes over on TikTok.
0:04:10Jim Mattson- She was posting things on social media from my couch last week.
0:04:16Chris Breen- That's gotta be fun to see. Like to see that in action, you know? It's just like
0:04:20things are happening. Should we get on to the first award category?
0:04:24Jim Mattson- I guess so. We're just going right in.
0:04:26Chris Breen- I mean, is there anything more?
0:04:28Jim Mattson- This is like when they do best supporting actress before the first commercial
0:04:32break to keep everybody tied in. It's like, I'm sure I've said that before. Anyway, let's do it.
0:04:36Chris Breen- So let's start off with the best overall iOS app for 2024. I'll mention that our
0:04:44lifetime achievement award winner in this category is Overcast, in case you are new to the Upgradies.
0:04:51If something wins three times in the same category, we kind of raise it up into the rafters
0:04:58and it will always be mentioned in every Upgradies because this is it. They deserve that, right?
0:05:03Jim Mattson- Right. But we have to stop giving them awards.
0:05:06Chris Breen- Because there are some podcasts and/or apps that we may have awarded at 10 out of 11
0:05:11times. We don't talk about that one year if we hadn't otherwise created this. They know what
0:05:16they did. Now, we also put out a nomination form to the Upgradients, to you, our listeners. And we
0:05:23got hundreds and hundreds, I think it was over a thousand submissions that came in. I would like to
0:05:28give an additional technical award at this point to Jason for writing a script to help me get through
0:05:34those really quickly. It used to take- Jim Mattson- You're welcome.
0:05:37Chris Breen- This year, I think I put together the Upgradients picks. It took me the same amount of
0:05:45time to do one category in the way I used to do it, as it took me to do the entire thing this time.
0:05:52It used to take me so much work. And so I'm very happy that I don't have to do that anymore. So,
0:05:56we're going to go in from bottom to top. I don't know if you'd say- it's ascending order, right?
0:06:03Jim Mattson- Okay.
0:06:04Chris Breen- So that's with 6% of the Upgradients votes is ivory. Actually, for this category,
0:06:10it doesn't matter because for- Jim Mattson- Yeah, I was going to say ascending from six to six.
0:06:14Chris Breen- Six to six to six. All of the other ones, it goes from lowest to highest, but there
0:06:20were so many, so many individual apps nominated here that no one really got a large share of the
0:06:27vote. 6% is Flighty and 6% is Carrot Weather. So that's where the Upgradients are. Ivory,
0:06:35Flighty, and Carrot Weather. Jason, what are you thinking? Jason Tucker- Well, I want to do a
0:06:41shout out to the new version of Overcast because it can't win in this category. But after some
0:06:46initial pain, I think in general, I am very happy with where it has gone. And I like that Marco has
0:06:52made some changes to it that I like and added the, you know, what you've listened to over the year,
0:07:01where I've gotten to see how everybody listens to Upgrade, the second or third most of all their
0:07:06podcasts. Very exciting. And so I'll shout out Overcast, even though it is not eligible and
0:07:11cannot win. And, you know, I just, in a span of 10 days, I took five flights. And so Flighty has been
0:07:22on my mind, because there were a bunch of big additions to Flighty. Plus, I find it so useful
0:07:27in general, but they added a bunch of stuff where they're looking at like delays at the incoming
0:07:32airport and the outgoing airport and giving you more detail of why your plane might be delayed.
0:07:39And it's just really good. And at this point, I don't think I would fly without it. I can track
0:07:45my kids' flights as well. So I know when like, are their flights going to be delayed? And I knew when
0:07:50Jamie landed back home last night. Like it's so, so I struggle in this category because I'm using
0:07:59the same old apps most of the time. But Flighty is the one that keeps coming up. And I know that
0:08:04if it wins, it's going to be a lifetime achievement winner, but I'm kind of headed in that direction.
0:08:08What are you thinking, Mike? Oh, it was undoubtedly Flighty for me.
0:08:11In the same way that it has won in the last two years. Like the app has been around for quite an
0:08:19amount of time now, you know, longer than those two years, but over time, it just got consistently
0:08:23and consistently better. I mean, last year, they added the Apple Watch app, which I was very pleased
0:08:27about. But then this year, its overall polish has continued. But then the connection assistant and
0:08:33the delay predictions thing, that is just, those are features that to me, especially the delay
0:08:38predictions is like a dream feature that I just didn't ever really think that they'd be able to
0:08:43add because the amount of data that you would need to do that. But I guess at this point,
0:08:47they have gotten to the point where they have enough people using the app that they're able to
0:08:52use the information that they get, along with the information that they get historically from the
0:08:56data providers to build this system to say like, hey, your plane hasn't left yet. That means you're
0:09:03probably going to be delayed. Like it's a thing where I can look at it and maybe I can think
0:09:07that's the case, but I don't know, you know, like how long does it take these things to turn around
0:09:12over? But yeah, Flighty is just an excellent application. And I do actually really want it to
0:09:20become a lifetime achievement award winner because I think the app is that good. Like I, it's one
0:09:25thing I want it to be there. I agree. And I've heard, and one of the things I want to mention,
0:09:29because I know it comes up when we talk about Flighty is that it's a fairly expensive subscription.
0:09:34I agree. Although I think that you don't have to travel a lot for Flighty's subscription to be
0:09:41worth it. Also they do, like you can buy the little passes and stuff. Yeah, this is where I was going.
0:09:46What I love about it is if you are below the level where it's reasonable that it, you know,
0:09:51it's worth it because you fly so much, you can just buy a pass for a trip, basically. And so
0:10:00they've got a way to, you know, if you don't travel very much, but you're going to be going on a long
0:10:06trip and you want it for this, you know, for this week or this month, you can do that. I love it.
0:10:11That's really, it's really smart and it makes it accessible to more people. But yeah, it's a winner.
0:10:16So let's put it in the Hall of Fame with a lifetime achievement or whatever it is. Let's just put it
0:10:21in there. Well, that's the Hall of Fame because the lifetime achievement award was the thing we did.
0:10:25I guess we do every 10 upgrade-ies because we did that last year. I thought that was the other way
0:10:29around though. Isn't that, isn't that the Hall of Fame we did last year? Yeah. This is the lifetime
0:10:34achievement award. They just got a lifetime achievement award. Hall of Fame's a different
0:10:37thing. Flighty, you're banned. You're too good. You're banned from the category now. Indeed. Well,
0:10:41this may actually now open up for either Carrot Weather or Ivory. Hilariously, it's the exact
0:10:46same winners and runner up last year. Yeah, I know. And so, you know, but look, really good though.
0:10:52No, but this is like Carrot Weather, for example, has won a bunch of times and I expect, yeah,
0:10:59I could imagine Carrot Weather winning next year and also becoming a lifetime achievement award
0:11:04winner. And to me, these are apps that have been around for long enough and are good enough that
0:11:09they deserve that. They should. Right? I agree. And so it makes sense to me that Flighty would
0:11:14keep winning because it is also probably the best designed iOS app that I use. And that makes a big
0:11:25difference. I agree. Even down to like the way they do their kind of year in review thing,
0:11:30their passport thing, which is actually a really fun feature. The fact that it looks like a
0:11:34passport page. You don't need to do that, but they do. And it's all these little touches
0:11:40make it overall like just really a very strong example of what it takes to have a good iOS app.
0:11:49Like that's why it's there. Yeah, agreed. I agree. But it's not about just apps that have existed for
0:11:56a long time. There are also new apps. So we're going to now move into the best newcomer iOS app
0:12:02category of which this year, lots of really good options. So the Upgradians voted thusly.
0:12:10With 6% of the vote for Quasant, 7% of the vote for Bellatro. I think that might give a hint for
0:12:17later on that it made it into the app category. It broke out of games. And 10% goes to Delta,
0:12:24which is the emulator app, which every time I read this, I cannot fathom that that was this year.
0:12:32That Delta came out. And yeah, I believe Delta has been available by other means,
0:12:40but this year it was available in the app store in Europe. Or everywhere. No, everywhere, right?
0:12:45Because the Apple relented and was like, "Fine, have your emulator everywhere, whatever." Right.
0:12:50So it made it in. It's true, right? Yep, yep, yep, yep. Where are you sitting?
0:12:57I struggle with this category. Delta isn't really new, but I like the kind of political statement
0:13:05about it. Bellatro is a game, but I have played it a lot on iPad especially. Quasant is a fun idea
0:13:11for a cross-posting tool. There are others. And I think it shows that it's trying to get
0:13:16off the ground. Some of the account management stuff especially is pretty finicky. And some of
0:13:22the error handling is, I mean, they're working on it really hard. And I like what they're doing
0:13:26with it, but it still, I feel like, has room to grow and improve. So the other one I'm gonna throw
0:13:35in the ring from my side, honestly, is passwords. We asked for a long time for a passwords app
0:13:42instead of having it be a setting in iOS. And it is. And it's pretty good. And I am using it.
0:13:50You know, my biggest complaint about passwords is actually, I think maybe it was a bug in the beta.
0:13:56But it's too late now, which is that when I imported it from 1Password, it seems to have
0:14:01imported my original passwords on all of my accounts and not the most recent one that is
0:14:07the current. So I have to keep 1Password open every now and then too, because it'll say, "Oh,
0:14:13this is the wrong password." And I'll go into 1Password and get the right password and put it in
0:14:17and then update the passwords. It's not ideal. But I think maybe that was a beta bug and I just,
0:14:24I haven't gone back and wiped it out. It's too late now. I'm just gonna kind of live with it.
0:14:28But I really have liked that integration. And I think they did a pretty good job with the passwords
0:14:31app, even though, you know, anyway, so I'll throw that out there as a possibility. What do you think?
0:14:35So I have three. One of them I'm gonna mention now, which was on my list, which is ShareShot.
0:14:42But they're a sponsor of today's episode now, so that would be peculiar.
0:14:46Oh yeah, no, that's a good app. Good app, good app.
0:14:48Yeah, but so I will talk about my love of ShareShot when I'm actually doing the ad for ShareShot,
0:14:54you know, which is, I feel like it's probably the best place for that.
0:14:58Then for me, it was Croissant and Delta. So like Croissant for me is emblematic of kind of a point
0:15:08in time, which is now, right, of there are many social networks now that I'm posting to. And it
0:15:14is an app that has been really, really helpful for me this year. It was indispensable during the
0:15:19podcast-a-thon. I was using a very early beta of it then and was able to post very quickly and
0:15:24easily. And since, you know, there are things for me, which is the promotion of something,
0:15:30which I do want to post everywhere. Like that's just the world that we're in. And this is an app
0:15:37that I really like that is a native app, which is fairly priced that I appreciate. And I really like
0:15:46it. And I think for me, it would be my, the one that I would really push on as like, this is a,
0:15:55an example of a really good, like just iOS app that solves a good need very well.
0:16:04But I keep coming back to Delta as a thought of if Delta had come out two months ago,
0:16:12this would be no question. And that would not be a 10%. That would be significantly more. This app
0:16:20took over the world, but it happened really early in the year. So I think the wave has come down.
0:16:26And I think that is an app which, I mean, because it had been in development and in, you know,
0:16:32forms of release for years was basically perfect at a 1.0. And when it shipped, like on the app
0:16:41store and now they're doing things like they're able to add things to the app now, and they're
0:16:46working on things that they're adding to the app now, which are wild, like the ability to,
0:16:50I think this is coming very soon, the ability to be able to play say Nintendo DS games
0:16:57in multiplayer with multiple phones, like stuff like that is really incredible. And so, you know,
0:17:03it's just, this was an app that exploded and it was number one and they were just, the iPad app
0:17:09was just number one again over Christmas in the US. I saw Riley posting, but it had like a big
0:17:15crescendo because now for a lot of people, including me, it's an app that I have on my phone
0:17:19and sometimes I can jump into a game if I want to. I feel like if we're looking at the year,
0:17:25this is the app, right? Like this is why I think Mac stories gave it their app of the year. And
0:17:31it's like for similar reasons, like this Delta was honestly, it's historic as an application
0:17:39to have released on the app store. Like it is a game emulator. I think we never thought was
0:17:45going to happen. And not only was it like, cause there were lots of them. This one was really good.
0:17:51And so I think I would lean towards that as the app that we should give.
0:17:58- Okay. I am going to say that we should make Croissant and ShareShot,
0:18:03even though it's a sponsor because I love that app, runners up with the, you know, again,
0:18:09asterisk. Yes, it's a sponsor, but seriously, I just forgotten about that. And I have used that
0:18:13a lot on my iPad to do screenshots and then Delta should be the winner. I think you're right. I
0:18:19think it says something about this year and although it's not new, why is it a newcomer?
0:18:23It's because Apple refused to let it in the app store until now. I think.
0:18:26- No, I'm just going to head this off, right? Like if an app is in beta for two years,
0:18:33does it mean that it can't be a newcomer? No, like it wasn't on the app store. It's now on the app.
0:18:38- We decide what a newcomer is. We've had all sorts of weird things as newcomers.
0:18:43- We've had one app win best newcomer twice. - Yeah, indeed we have.
0:18:47- You know, you can't stop us. - So there it is. For all of that,
0:18:51that it says about Riley's persistence and Apple's policies and how fun it is to have
0:18:57classic game emulators, Delta is the winner. - Yep, it really is fantastic and well, well deserved.
0:19:05This episode of Upgrade, The Upgradies, the 11th annual is brought to you by ShareShot.
0:19:14We all take screenshots and we often use them to create content or use them to explain something
0:19:19to someone. Showing a screenshot in context on the device that it was taken on looks just so much
0:19:26better. And ShareShot is an app that puts your screenshots into device frames and places them
0:19:30over pretty backgrounds. It adds perfect fitting device frames to screenshots for most modern Apple
0:19:36devices, including the Apple watch, Macs, Apple Macs, the Apple Macs, Jason, you ever heard of
0:19:42those, the Apple Macs? - Yeah, is that the M4 Macs, Apple Macs, MacBook Macs?
0:19:46- Apple Macs, Apple watch, Macs, iPad, iPhone in many color variants, as well as devices like the
0:19:52Nintendo switch, the play date and also custom frames that you can make yourself. No matter where
0:19:58you're using screenshots in blog posts or documentation, presentation slides, website
0:20:03marketing images, social media to promote apps or your latest home screen, ShareShot gives you
0:20:08beautiful results in seconds. It's designed to be fast and fun. It offers over 40 background styles
0:20:15with thousands of variations, gives you control over the light direction for the shadows, which is
0:20:20wild, includes several actions for shortcuts to automate batch framing, integrates system features
0:20:26like keyboard shortcuts, drag and drop, a control center widget and more. And it won this year's
0:20:30Mac story select best design award. So I take and share screenshots of my devices often for the
0:20:38shows that I do, like for example, say the apps, which is on Cortex. And I used ShareShot this year
0:20:44and I was very pleased. So like it makes my screenshots look better. I think screenshots
0:20:50look better when they do have a device, when they're sitting in a device, right? Federico has
0:20:54had his Apple frames that he's done over the years too. What I like about ShareShot is an app that I
0:21:00can go in and tweak really easily and visually. And I love that, you know, I can say I want the device
0:21:05to look like this, you know, like I want it to be my specific iPhone color, you know, and then I want
0:21:11the background to be this color. I want the background to be that color. But one of the ways
0:21:15that I also use it is via their fantastic shortcut support. So I was able to integrate ShareShot into
0:21:22some screenshots that I was using previously. So now I can take say four home screens, and I can
0:21:29run a shortcut on those images that I've taken, and it will frame them all and then lay them in
0:21:35one horizontal image. So I'm able to grab the screenshots, I'm able to make some customization
0:21:40to how they look and frame them all together. It makes my job so much easier and it makes the
0:21:44screenshots that I shared just look so much better. ShareShot is available for iPhone with a desktop
0:21:51class UI available for iPad, and there is a Mac version that is currently in public beta testing
0:21:56and coming soon. To take your screenshots up a notch, you can install the app for free.
0:22:01Go to shareshot.app/upgrade for a download link and an introductory offer for 50%
0:22:07of your first year of a pro subscription. That is shareshot.app/upgrade for the 50% offer link.
0:22:15Our thanks to ShareShot for their support of this show and all of Relay.
0:22:19Now, Mike, Yes.
0:22:21Upgrade Plus subscribers will have not heard your ad for ShareShot, but I as an independent observer
0:22:29will just point out that ShareShot was a runner up because it is an excellent
0:22:33screenshot utility that frames your screenshots with the devices, whether it's a Mac or an iPhone
0:22:38or an iPad. I find it very useful for six colors. It won a Mac Stories award. They obviously find
0:22:44it useful too. And so outside of the realm of the ad, which is tricky, right? Like we had it last
0:22:50week, we had a thank you to Lex.games. That was technically an ad, but it was really a thank you.
0:22:55And we had a whole debate about like, do we put that in the upgrade plus are they going to be
0:22:59offended because it's an ad? So I'm just saying here outside of the ad that ShareShot is neat and
0:23:06congratulations for being a runner up to its developer, Mark ShareShot. Oh, is this like Neil
0:23:13Mime stream and Tom Marie Jones? Yeah, this is the new convention for upgrade is its first name.
0:23:17Name of app is the person who created it. They named it after themselves. This is the story and
0:23:21I'm sticking with it. So Mark ShareShot, well done, sir. Congratulations. This is like, I guess this
0:23:27is like, I don't know, I'm just gonna say ancient times, medieval times or whatever, where you'd be
0:23:32named for the thing you did, you know, like you're a blacksmith. So your name is Smith.
0:23:36Schwarzenegger.
0:23:38Yes, for all the, I don't even know what to say. We're going to move into best overall Mac app now
0:23:46and we have a lifetime achievement award winner for Audio Hijack. Yeah. So thank you to Audio
0:23:54Hijack. I want to shout out Audio Hijack because they had a big milestone this year, but we can't
0:23:58award them anything for it, which is they finally after and Paul Kvass has told the story on the
0:24:04Rogue Amoeba blog. They finally, after years of working with Apple and explaining why Audio
0:24:12Hijack and other audio utilities are important on the Mac. This year, they finally got a version of
0:24:18macOS that has the entitlements and authorizations required so that you don't have to reboot like
0:24:25eight times and set all of your security settings weird in order to get Audio Hijack installed. Now
0:24:29you can install it without a reboot. And I believe Audio Hijack without even putting in your password,
0:24:33you can install it. So big steps forward for Audio Hijack and getting out of sort of Apple getting
0:24:39out of its way. But it's a lifetime achievement winner, so it can't win. Sorry, Audio Hijack,
0:24:44sorry. But you know, I like what we're doing this year actually of shouting out things about those
0:24:48apps, which would that would make them in the contention anyway, right? And that is it like
0:24:54specifically for this year. I mean, it seems like a small thing, but I think for a lot of people that
0:25:00use Audio Hijack professionally, they're changing equipment. They're installing new versions of
0:25:05operating systems, right? Like they're that kind of user, i.e. me and you, right? And you know,
0:25:11like we're getting review units, we're getting new hardware to test, etc, etc. And the honestly chaos
0:25:20of installing the app before now, through the security restrictions, made it really difficult.
0:25:29And I think it is great that they've been able to work to get that fixed. And it has actually taken
0:25:34the work to get that fixed. Yes. So the Upgradients voted thusly for best overall Mac app at 3% of the
0:25:44vote for MimeStream, 4% for Raycast, and 4% for Pixelmator Pro. Oh, an Apple product.
0:25:52I don't know what to do with this category. I have four names that I'm going to throw out,
0:26:03so I guess these are my kind of honorable mentions, and then we'll figure out what to do here.
0:26:07So I love MimeStream. I still think it's great. It got some updates this year. It's my mail client.
0:26:13I think it's really good. I'm looking forward to that iOS version maybe at some point here.
0:26:18I want to shout out Swiftbar again. I wrote some new Swiftbar things for my like home solar power
0:26:28system this year. It's just really great. I can see right now I'm looking at it. I can see the
0:26:33temperature outside. I know how much power my solar panels are generating, and I know how many
0:26:37people are listening live to upgrade. And that's all because of Swiftbar. Really, really great
0:26:43utility app for that sort of thing, putting things in your menu bar. I want to shout out RetroBatch
0:26:48from Flying Meat. This is a tool that I use. Talk about processing images like Wish Areshot.
0:26:56Especially when I'm doing my book, Take Control of Photos,
0:27:00photos have to be in formats. For that book, they need to have a border, and they need to be below
0:27:08a certain file size and in a certain format, and I have this a lot. RetroBatch lets you create
0:27:14basically a -- it's like shortcuts, kind of. It's like a branching logic tree for your images.
0:27:19So you can literally save out a droplet onto your desktop and drag and drop images onto it,
0:27:24and it processes them and outputs them in exactly where you want. Super clever app from the people
0:27:30who brought you Acorn from Gus RetroBatch. Or really, he's Gus Acorn, but he also makes
0:27:37RetroBatch. And -- - Better than Gus Flying Meat. - Yeah, yeah, no. Please, Gus Flying Meat's his
0:27:44father. Downy is the other one I wanted to shout out. The venerable Download app. You know, I
0:27:53actually subscribe to, among other things, what is it, Flop TV, which is the flophouses, like a
0:27:59live show that they do live on a weekend, and then they put up an archive that you can watch for a
0:28:05week or something like that. And I want to watch it in Plex at my leisure. I don't want to watch it
0:28:10like on whatever their thing is that's playing on a computer and stuff like that. And so that's one
0:28:16of the many great legitimate uses for Downy, because you can point it at a URL and it will
0:28:21pull down the video file, get it in the right format, and then I can put it on my Plex. And
0:28:25watch it at leisure. Really great little app. So those are ones that came to mind
0:28:29beyond the usual suspects and the Hall of Famers. What do you think, Mike? - I'm very conflicted
0:28:36this year. This is always the category I struggle with the most. And honestly, the app that has been
0:28:43jumping to mind recently is Pixelmator Pro. But that feels weird now. - I know, right? - That feels
0:28:49weird now. But I've been using it to create some graphics for a stream that I'm going to do this
0:28:56week, kind of showing off some journaling stuff. And Pixelmator Pro for me is what I want Photoshop
0:29:06to be 95% of the time, which is significantly more simple and just the tools that I want.
0:29:17I don't want all of the photo editing features that Photoshop has. Neither do I want the generative
0:29:26AI stuff that they do, which is very impressive. And I understand why people like it, but it's not
0:29:31what I'm looking for. And I feel that Pixelmator has the power that I want and the tools that I
0:29:38want in a UI that I can really easily understand. Genuinely, we said it at the time, but it is
0:29:45abundantly clear why Apple considers this an app that they would want in their arsenal.
0:29:50Like, it is if Apple wanted to make a Photoshop competitor, they would make Pixelmator. That's
0:29:56what they would do. - Yeah, and maybe why they bought it. I have two other kind of creative
0:30:03tools that I will throw in, as usual. I mean, if you ask me in my heart of hearts what the best
0:30:10overall Mac app is, I will say BB Edit every time. I write in it, I use it as a text utility.
0:30:20I use it for all sorts of text processing, including things like our compilation of awards
0:30:30and things. That's where it all started. I love it, and I could give it this award every year.
0:30:38But, so there it is. And I know I mentioned it once before, but Affinity Designer from
0:30:42Serif, Affinity Designer 2 now, I bought it mostly because I had two things that I did in Adobe
0:30:49Illustrator that I didn't want to do anymore because I had an old version of Adobe Illustrator
0:30:53and didn't want to pay for the Creative Cloud version or run Illustrator in a virtual machine.
0:30:59And it has since ended up being a tool I use a lot instead of things that I used to do in
0:31:07Photoshop that I thought this is not really appropriate for Photoshop, but I know how to
0:31:11use Photoshop. And now I build that stuff in Affinity Designer instead. It's very, very good
0:31:17at what it does, which is building graphics. It's got vector tools. It's really good. So
0:31:24I'll throw that in there too. I don't know what we do now. Now, this category is a problem. So I will
0:31:32say BB Edit has won before, I believe, or no, it's been nominated. It's been nominated. It's just
0:31:42been nominated. It has never won. Affinity Designer has won in the past and so have a
0:31:48selection of Apple apps. So I mean, and it's not, my funny thing about Pixelmator is not like,
0:31:54I don't want to not award it because it's an Apple app, but it is just like a funny thing that
0:31:58it's not has not actually happened yet, but it's obviously going to happen. Yeah, I don't know. I
0:32:04feel strongly for Pixelmator, so do the Upgradients, but this is a category like
0:32:10books where I'm never going to push you to award something of a Mac app, you know, how many mice
0:32:18it would have or something. I don't know how many mice would it have. I hope enough. I wouldn't want
0:32:23anybody to get angry if they didn't get enough mice. Like I would say MimeStream, I understand
0:32:27why people love it and I have loved it in the past, but to me, an email app that just does Gmail
0:32:36is not really an email app for me. Like it's a Gmail app and so like it's missing a significant
0:32:43feature that I would need, which is to also have support for other types of email and it's one of
0:32:49these things where it's like kind of like the iOS version of like, oh, it's coming. It's like, yeah,
0:32:53I know, but we've been saying that for years now and I understand that it takes time, but we can't
0:32:58keep, for me at least, I can't keep using that as a like a thing for MimeStream, right? Where it's
0:33:04like, yeah, but it's coming. So yeah, I know it is. I'm sure. It also is completely irrelevant for
0:33:10the Mac app category. Yeah, but the email part though, I'm talking about like using other email
0:33:16services in that application and also as well, like I actually, I just think the new iPhone mail
0:33:23app is really good. Apple, what are you doing? Just put it on other platforms. Like I think
0:33:28they've done a pretty good job with the category stuff, but yeah. On that, we disagree. Yeah,
0:33:34I mean, it works for me though. Like it's simple. I'll leave it to, people can read what Joe Steele
0:33:38thinks about it on sixscholars.com. I pretty much agree with him. I think it's a disaster, but okay.
0:33:45Everybody uses email differently. Like for me, my email is in Gmail. So MimeStream, personally,
0:33:52MimeStream supporting other email services doesn't matter, but I understand that not everybody uses
0:33:59Gmail, right? So it makes sense. It makes sense. I'm going to accede to the wishes of Mike and the
0:34:04Upgradients, both of whom are against me. And we're going to name Pixelmator Pro the winner.
0:34:09I wouldn't say that people are, nobody is against you here. I wouldn't really classify.
0:34:15It's all a conspiracy. I see what's happening here. You and the Upgradients. Did you open,
0:34:21audit the lists? Maybe you cooked the books for Pixelmator. It is possible. It's actually
0:34:26something else. It is possible. Pixelmator Pro, I think, as we send it off on its journey into
0:34:33side Apple, who knows what will happen to it. Let's give it an award and recognize its great
0:34:38service as an indie Mac app. It is actually wild that it has never won.
0:34:45Considering how long it's been around and how good it has been for that whole time.
0:34:48Right. Like that, that is, it's surprising to me that this is an app, this is not, this is an app
0:34:53that we have not awarded in this category before, which is a category you will struggle with. And
0:34:57this is like a great app that's just been sitting there that we never awarded. Right. So I think.
0:35:02Speaking of which, BB Edit is the runner up. Yeah. Always, always the bridesmaid.
0:35:06One of these days there won't be any other apps left. It'll have to still be BB Edit because it's
0:35:11not going anywhere. A grade is 20, you know. Double X. Let's say, let's put, let's say MimeStream.
0:35:23Yeah, I'm good with that. As the other runner up. Maybe one day MimeStream, what I really want is
0:35:28for MimeStream to somehow win best newcomer again. Get that three times, be lifetime achievement.
0:35:36If they do that iOS version, they could be a best newcomer in a different category.
0:35:39Yeah, but that won't give it lifetime. Like I don't know what would have to happen.
0:35:43Lifetime newcomer. Yeah. Well, Neil MimeStream is going to just have to come up with like
0:35:47some way that it can be new again and then we'll throw it in there.
0:35:51So now let's do the best newcomer Mac app. Yep. Gradients voted 5% for the Apple passwords app,
0:35:5913% for the iPhone mirroring app and 17% for chat GPT.
0:36:08Interesting. What do you think about this category, Mike?
0:36:10I think this is, here's what I say. In previous years, this category is complicated because
0:36:18there aren't a lot of new Mac apps. And so things like features find their way into it. However,
0:36:24what I will say is passwords and iPhone mirroring, I think no matter how strong the year is,
0:36:30these could have made its way in, especially iPhone mirroring. Like that is just a fantastic feature,
0:36:35which is it is actually an app as well. It's not just a feature. For me, chat GPT for Mac is
0:36:43my winner. And my reasoning for this is, isn't it great that they actually made a Mac app?
0:36:52Yeah. And it's a real Mac app and it's pretty good. It's got stuff that I think needs to be
0:36:57improved. They actually made an app. They made an app. And they didn't just say use the web,
0:37:03right? They made it before they made their windows app. It uses some accessibility features to look
0:37:09on the screen of windows and process them for you. So you don't have to paste it in. You can say,
0:37:14look at my terminal and do this thing. Again, I want some basic automation. I'd really like
0:37:21to be able to bundle up a query and send it to them via a shortcut or a URL scheme or something
0:37:26like that. I don't think that's in there yet, but I'd love it. They've got it. Yeah, they made an
0:37:31app. It's got a keyboard shortcut so you can use it like you could use Spotlight or Launch Bar or
0:37:36anything else, Raycast, whatever. Really interesting direction. I agree, actually.
0:37:43This is not a wholesale endorsement for chat GPT because, wow, it still really gets some stuff
0:37:49wrong or reluctantly right. I actually had this yesterday. We were talking, Jamie asked, how many
0:37:55NFL head coaches are former NFL players? And I thought, this is a very straightforward question.
0:38:01Let's see what chat GPT does with it. And the answer was, it did not give me a wrong answer
0:38:07per se, but I said, how many current NFL head coaches are former NFL players? And it said,
0:38:16there are several, here are five. And I said, that's not what I asked, list them all.
0:38:24And then it listed seven, I think it was, or eight. And I was like, okay, I think that's probably
0:38:29right. Scanning my knowledge of the NFL, I think that's probably a right answer. It got there. But
0:38:33again, there are issues, but there are also places where this stuff can be really useful
0:38:37and interactive. And again, it's not great for everything, but it has its moments. And I also
0:38:45like the fact that this tech giant that could very easily just say, look, desktop apps are the worst,
0:38:52just type things in a web browser, like you said, didn't do that. And actually is building
0:38:58and developing apps for platforms. I think that's a good thing. So I agree. I think we should give
0:39:06it to chat GPT for Mac, runners up, let's say iPhone mirroring. And do you have any others?
0:39:16I don't. So we could do passwords. Yeah. Let's just do passwords. They are good features.
0:39:23Passwords I don't have so much experience with because I'm just stuck in 1Password at this point.
0:39:29And I'm actually to a point happy to continue to be in it. I'm in like three different teams.
0:39:36I'm just not going to move at this point. And I am mostly fine with it. But I'm happy that the
0:39:43passwords app exists. Because I do also use Apple's password stuff. And so I like that it's easier to
0:39:50get to than digging through settings. And you can't have shared groups, but if anybody is using
0:39:57a non-Apple platform, it's no good. It's not the same. They have a feature which sounds the same.
0:40:03It's not the same. But it's not. I agree. I'm happy you said that because every time I say this,
0:40:09people contact me and it's like, trust me, if you think it's the same, you're just not using it the
0:40:14way I am. You're not doing that. But that's why I phrase it the way I did, which is they have it,
0:40:20it's not good. It's just not. It's just it's there, but it's not. It's a different thing.
0:40:25It's a different thing. We now move into, this is a new category last year, best feature. And it
0:40:32would rotate, right? Yes. So this year it is best feature in VisionOS, which was a funny one to
0:40:40pick really. Like I'm happy we picked it because I think it's important. And I think we're going
0:40:44to be talking more about it later on in the episode. Shipped version one and version two
0:40:47this year. They sure did. Very, very busy with that one. But I think that it is an important
0:40:55thing to exist. And I'm happy that we're talking about it. So the Upgradients voted lastly.
0:41:02Environments, so immersive environments is 6.5%. Immersive video, so it's kind of spatial video,
0:41:10immersive video, I guess the things that we've seen, the things that we've watched, 10%. And 36%
0:41:17for Mac virtual display. I'm not surprised. When it got introduced at WWDC last year, 2023,
0:41:28everybody said that that looked like it was going to be the best feature, right? I really do think
0:41:35people were blown away by it from the beginning. And they've updated it so that it's gotten better
0:41:40in the latest VisionOS update. So I'm not surprised that that is a top feature for VisionOS.
0:41:47Got significantly better with the ultra wide. Here's the thing I'm going to say.
0:41:52This might be a strange take. Because to me, I can see what you're going to suggest in the document.
0:42:06I'm suggesting the same. So I'm going to spoil your pick because I need to kind of spoil your
0:42:10pick to make my point, which is spatial personas is easily the best feature of VisionOS.
0:42:16I would wonder if many people in our audience who have used VisionOS know other people that have a
0:42:24vision pro. I know. I know. Because I think if you have used spatial personas, it is obviously
0:42:35the best feature. But I think you have to have somebody in your life that you could have that
0:42:41call with. And the amount of people that you probably know in your life that have a vision pro
0:42:48is a big fat zero. Where we're in the position where a lot of our friends have these things,
0:42:57because we're technology vision professionals, so we have had these calls. It is an absolutely
0:43:05transformative. And for me, specifically, it's interesting because you can go back to, I don't
0:43:10know, all the way back to our first use of this in WWDC 2023, where I thought personas, as they
0:43:19were then, were the bomb feature. They were going to be the equivalent of digital touch. And this
0:43:25is for two reasons. One, it wasn't very good in the initial version. And two, in my initial demo,
0:43:30it failed spectacularly. Where the person's eyes were facing the wrong direction and for a moment
0:43:36they had no hair. So it went real bad and I was like, no one's going to use this, it's silly.
0:43:41But then they upgraded it very quickly. I think it wasn't even with a software update, it was like
0:43:47an over the air update that Apple did somehow with Vision OS 1. When then the personas could break
0:43:56out of their boxes and they would exist in space and you could sit and have calls with people and
0:44:01you could look at each other and you could look at things together. And it really is,
0:44:06for me, and I've said this on a couple of shows, I think on this one too,
0:44:09spatial personas are as close as you can get to meeting someone in person without meeting
0:44:14them in person. And how close that is, is very close. That me and you can have these
0:44:21calls and we've done them a bunch of times and it just feels like we hung out together.
0:44:24It really is. There are many very, very impressive things about Vision OS. It is
0:44:33like it is worth remembering that because the story of Vision OS has been odd and the Vision
0:44:39Pro has been odd throughout the year. But all of these things, the immersive environments are the
0:44:44best 3D environments I've ever been in. The immersive video is the best 3D video I've ever
0:44:48seen. And the Mac virtual display, especially in its Vision OS 2 version is honestly a triumph
0:44:54to have this ultra wide massive display. But spatial personas are unbelievably good.
0:45:02That's my pitch for spatial personas. I wonder if there are things they could do to make it more
0:45:11widely applicable. And my thought about this, and I wonder if this might even actually happen
0:45:18in next year's OS updates, but I wonder if there are things Apple could do in FaceTime
0:45:25to make this better. I don't know if they want to prioritize this or not, but one of the things
0:45:30that Zoom can do and that other apps can do is they, and Apple can do it, right, which is detect
0:45:36your background, lay out a virtual background, right? That's built into the software now.
0:45:40And then Zoom also has this thing where it basically puts you in an environment. So you're
0:45:47meeting instead of happening in little boxes, it's like a table with the cutout, no background
0:45:52of all the people. It's a little weird, but I get what they're going for there. And I wonder
0:45:57if they might do something like that with FaceTime, where if I'm doing a FaceTime with
0:46:02somebody and some people are in Vision Pro and some people aren't, could we do it where the
0:46:06person who's not gets cut out and floats and looks like they're a spatial persona, even though they're
0:46:13not? And from their perspective, could they have a view where they could choose to, instead of having
0:46:18that person in a box, have an environment that all the people are in together? You could do either of
0:46:26those or both of those and have them on or off separately. I think there's some stuff they could
0:46:33do to make this more broadly applicable that would be nice, because I do think it's a great
0:46:41feature, like you said, that nobody can use because they don't, I mean, there just aren't
0:46:49enough Vision Pro users out there. But we have created a sort of, it comes off sometimes, it
0:46:54doesn't sometimes, sort of standing chat with people we know who have Vision Pros and we try
0:47:03to do it every couple of weeks, it doesn't always come off. But I love those conversations. And one
0:47:09of the reasons I love them and treasure them is that I am talking to my friends about things that
0:47:16aren't technology, about just catching up about their lives, and doing it in a way that feels like
0:47:25I'm spending time with them and not being in a Zoom call with them or a phone call, but like
0:47:35being in the room with them as wild an idea as that is. It feels like it. It's the closest that
0:47:40I have felt to actually spending time with somebody. The quality difference compared to a
0:47:49FaceTime call or a Zoom call is massive. Really is a very, very good feature. So obviously this
0:47:57is the winner because we feel so strongly about it. Mac Virtual Display, good runner up. What do
0:48:04you think about as a second runner up? We've got immersive video and environments there as options.
0:48:12Yeah, I would say...
0:48:15I think environments are a better kind of VisionOS thing than really good 3D
0:48:27video as good as it is. The environments make a huge difference.
0:48:33This episode is brought to you by Fitbod. If you're looking to change your fitness level,
0:48:38and this is a time of year where a lot of people think about it, it can be hard to know where to
0:48:42get started. That's why I want to let you know that Fitbod is an easy and affordable way to build
0:48:47a fitness plan that is just for you. Everybody has their own path through personal fitness.
0:48:52That is why Fitbod uses data to make sure they customize things to suit you perfectly.
0:48:56Fitbod adapts as you're improving to make sure that every workout remains challenging.
0:49:00This pushes you to make the progress that you want and it also makes every workout fun.
0:49:06Your workouts aren't getting boring because you're doing the same six exercises every single day.
0:49:12They're making sure to balance your workout routine. They're going to get new exercises,
0:49:16new rep schemes, supersets and circuits for you to make sure that you're really getting something
0:49:22that is benefiting you and keeping you engaged. You're going to see better results when a workout
0:49:27program is tailored to your body, your experience, your environment and goals. Fitbod stores this
0:49:32information in your gym profile and tracks your muscle recovery to make sure that you're avoiding
0:49:36burnout and keeping up your momentum. It's great whenever you get a new exercise, you're going to
0:49:41learn it the right way thanks to their demonstration videos. There are more than a thousand of them in
0:49:45the Fitbod app which is really lovely and easy to use. They have great instructions for you but also
0:49:50videos shot from multiple angles so you can make sure that you're learning these exercises correctly.
0:49:55The Fitbod app also has progress tracking charts, weekly reports, sharing cards so you can share
0:50:01your personal bests and keep track of your achievements. It also integrates with your
0:50:05Apple Watch, Wearr, Smartwatch and other apps like Strava, Fitbit and Apple Health.
0:50:10Personalised training of this quality can be expensive. Fitbod is just $12.99 a month or
0:50:14$79.99 a year but you can get 25% of your membership by signing up today at fitbod.me/upgrade
0:50:21that is F I T B O D dot me slash upgrade. Go now and get your customised fitness plan at fitbod.me/upgrade
0:50:29and that is one last time fitbod.me/upgrade for 25% of your membership.
0:50:33Our thanks to Fitbod for their continued support of this show and all of Relay.
0:50:37So we now move into game of the year at the Upgradies. Gamers rise up! Rise up gamers it's
0:50:46gamers time. The Upgradians voted with 3% for The Legend of Zelda Echoes of Wisdom,
0:50:535% for Astro Bot and 28% for Bellatra.
0:50:59I go to my game expert now. Upgrade game expert Mike Hurley for his choice for game of the year.
0:51:09Or choices.
0:51:10Yeah I have been oscillating back and forth wildly between Astro Bot and Bellatra.
0:51:19Now we did a remaster episode and it was a similar thing and we decided on Astro Bot there.
0:51:29And the reason that we decided on Astro Bot there is Astro Bot is a better overall game than Bellatra.
0:51:40For what you think of as a video game. It is very joyful, it is a very engaging experience,
0:51:49it is a wonderful 3D platformer. It is the best example of a 3D platformer outside of what
0:51:56Nintendo makes which is quite an achievement on its own. Especially for the team that made this.
0:52:03Astro Bot has existed in different games before. This is like their first real attempt at something
0:52:08like this.
0:52:08Right. I have great fondness for Astro Bot as a concept because I played the Astro Bot game
0:52:15on the PSVR. So good.
0:52:19They had a pack-in game called Rescue Mission which is kind of like a very simple, small,
0:52:26free platformer game for PlayStation 5. But this was their first real big shot at it.
0:52:33And they did just an incredible job. Bellatra though is the game I have played without a doubt
0:52:42the most this year. I probably play an hour of Bellatra a day. It is just a game that I play
0:52:49on my commute and it is a game that I play to kind of wind down in the evenings. I'll listen
0:52:56to a podcast, play a bit as a kind of wind down. I have played thousands of rounds of Bellatra
0:53:03I win all the time. I'm really good at the game now. I did a thing where I was scaling
0:53:08through the difficulty levels to unlock things. Now I've kind of gotten to a point where I have
0:53:13a starting deck that I like and I'm not playing for anything other than just to play the game.
0:53:18I'm not trying to get better and better. I just like playing through the game and winning.
0:53:23And it's just a glorious video game.
0:53:27So now we go to Julian, my game consultant. I told him about Bellatro. He now has basically,
0:53:36he says he's got like, I forget what completion percentage. It's ridiculous.
0:53:41Because he is a true gamer. He has blasted through Bellatro. Very impressive. But it allows me to
0:53:47talk to him about it. And I have played it a lot. I think my probably most played hours this year
0:53:55is still Marvel Snap, but I've not played that in months. It's all Bellatro now. Not like you,
0:54:01though. I'm just not a gamer like that. I have limited time for games. I read books instead,
0:54:07but I do play Bellatro. It is great. I also want to share for people who don't get it,
0:54:12a few things that I have some interesting Mastodon exchanges about Bellatro.
0:54:15First off, a good friend of the show, Lex Friedman, he did a Mastodon post four days ago that was,
0:54:24"I encourage my son to play Bellatro. He loves it. Now he wants me to play it. My friends,
0:54:29I truly hate it. I hate it so much. I don't understand why anyone likes it." Now,
0:54:34a lot of people responded to Lex. Yesterday, he posted, "My son begged me to try it more,
0:54:43to play 10 games with him watching and advising. I did. My friends, I now unironically love Bellatro."
0:54:50Yes. I have one more social media post I want to quote, which is a friend of the show,
0:54:56Ben Rice McCarthy, and they wrote, "First time playing Bellatro. I don't know what the fuss is
0:55:00about. Second time, okay, I see why people like it, but I'm not sure it's for me. Third time,
0:55:05I would remortgage my house to get that raised fist joker again." If you know, you know. Go
0:55:11ahead, Mike. Explain. All right. I want to give kind of a quick crash course in Bellatro. Like,
0:55:17if you've played the game and you don't understand it and you're failing out,
0:55:20I want to give some tips for how to play this game. So one, don't worry about the fact that
0:55:26you don't know poker hands. The game does a decent job in teaching you them and you also can get by.
0:55:33You can win games. I've won many games just only playing two pairs. Two pairs. Yep. Right? I've won
0:55:40many games with just two pairs. That's it. The main thing comes down to what are the joker cards
0:55:47that you get. The joker cards adapt your score. Your score is you get a count, which is like the
0:55:53total number of the cards that you've played, right? So if you played, you know, two pairs of
0:55:59sevens, right? So that would be what, 28 plus any modifiers that you can add in. Don't worry about
0:56:05the modifiers now. It's not important. Two pairs of sevens is four of a kind, so it would be
0:56:09different. But like if you had two sevens and two twos, right? Yeah. You'd get 14 for the sevens and
0:56:14four for the twos. So you'd have 18 chips. And then the jokers are doing things like giving you
0:56:20more chips or giving you multipliers that increase the total number of chips that you win and you
0:56:25have a total you need to hit before you run out of hands to play in a round. To win a game, you're
0:56:31looking to try and get more chips and you're looking to try and get a higher multiplier.
0:56:34Now, as well as the multipliers, you also have jokers that can multiply your multiplier.
0:56:44Exactly. So you have some that will add to your multiplier and some that will multiply your
0:56:49multiplier. Those are really good. The key thing to remember is joker cards are scored left to
0:56:55right in order once the hand has been played. So if you have any multipliers of a multiplier,
0:57:02they go at the far right end of your joker line. So then any other consecutive score
0:57:09will be added in and then multiplied at the end. Good tips. Knowing that is quite... knowing...
0:57:16Basically, my big term of Bellatro was understanding that the jokers, the kind of
0:57:21conditions to the jokers are added left to right. Once you've done that and you can reorder them,
0:57:27then you'll start to win. So yeah, it is. The other thing, the other resistance that I see to Bellatro
0:57:34is that people describe it as a deck builder. It's not a deck builder. And a lot of people
0:57:40are resistant to that and it is absolutely not a deck builder. I called it a roguelike. People
0:57:45said, well, technically a roguelike is just about adventures with procedurally generated maps. I'm
0:57:49like, okay, you can call it a roguelite if you want to. I think... let's not argue about the terms.
0:57:53The reason I brought it up is I also get turned off with the idea that every time you go through,
0:57:59you pick up items and you grind and you end up building something through grinding, which is the
0:58:04thing I hate the most about games is grinding. I just want to pick it up and play. This isn't like
0:58:11that. You start at zero in the beginning of every round. When you die at Bellatro, when you lose a
0:58:18hand, you go back to the beginning and start again. You lose all your jokers, you lose all
0:58:23the modifications you've done. Everything has changed. You're back to zero. What progresses is,
0:58:29as you successfully pass certain tests on certain levels, you unlock more items to be put in the
0:58:38random selection that you get. So there is progression because more items appear that
0:58:45have different functionality, but they're still sent to you randomly and you still have to start
0:58:51from nothing. And as a result, it's a game you can pick up and play from zero and then put it down
0:58:58when you get to your destination or whatever and not have to keep in your head the entire multitude
0:59:06or spend hours grinding in order to build a deck that makes it fun. It doesn't do any of that.
0:59:11Also, as you win games, you unlock new decks that have different starting types.
0:59:19Yeah, so like, again, it's more game variants happen as you progress, but they're not
0:59:26changing the fundamental that you're at the start. When you start, you have to start from nothing.
0:59:32Bellatro is the winner, Astrobot is a runner-up.
0:59:37We'll put Zelda in.
0:59:40Sure, fine. Great. Done.
0:59:42Favorite movie.
0:59:44The Upgradients voted to 10% for Inside Out 2,
0:59:4816% for Deadpool and Wolverine, and 22% for Dune Part 2.
0:59:56Okay. Pretty strong.
0:59:58Yeah. My favorites of the year were Deadpool and Wolverine and Inside Out 2 for very different
1:00:06reasons. But I loved both of these movies. I am a Marvel guy through and through, and this was a
1:00:13great Marvel movie. And Inside Out 2, it surprised me with how good it was, to be honest. I was quite
1:00:21blown away by that, personally.
1:00:22So, listeners of The Incomparable will know that we did an Inside Out 2 episode and I wasn't on it.
1:00:28I was going to be on it. And then I saw Inside Out 2 and said, "You know what?
1:00:34Lex, can you host this one? You love this movie, right?"
1:00:38You didn't like it?
1:00:39I did not like it. No, I didn't like it. I didn't like it at all. But that's fine. People like it.
1:00:45But I'm, no, I don't like it. I like, oh, the three movies that I like the most that I saw
1:00:51this year were, that were new to me, were Godzilla minus one, which is a masterpiece. It really is.
1:00:59It is an adult movie with a Godzilla in it. It's so well done. I just, I can't say enough good
1:01:07things about Godzilla minus one. It is a very good movie with a Godzilla in it, with the Godzilla in
1:01:16it. Past Lives, which was an Oscar nominee, which is very much like a two friends, and then they're
1:01:30apart, and then they meet as adults, and they think about their lives. I mean, it's really,
1:01:34that's just kind of it. But it's great. Great movie. And American Fiction, which also was an
1:01:40Oscar nominee, which is really good, which is very meta about a, it's a writer who is literally,
1:01:48literarily successful, but not commercially successful, who decides to create a persona,
1:01:53who plays into all of the worst stereotypes, and it becomes a wild success. It's a little
1:01:59producers-esque in that way, right? He's just sort of like, he's not quite selling out. He is
1:02:04selling out, but he's also sort of selling out to mock the culture, but then it's a success.
1:02:12And there's a real human story there, but it's also, and that's Jeffrey Wright, I think,
1:02:17is the star of that. It's really great. So that's a great movie. I like Deadpool and Wolverine quite
1:02:23a bit. That is the only Marvel movie of the year, but it is a good Marvel movie. I also,
1:02:29this year, Mike, I watched all the Deadpool movies for the first time, because I hadn't seen any of
1:02:34them. And I liked them. I like the first one a lot. I think it was really fun and worked for me.
1:02:40The second one I enjoyed, but I was disappointed by, because it felt like it was more of the same
1:02:47instead of doing something extra. And also I didn't like the fact that they sidelined
1:02:51his girlfriend immediately. It's like, no, no, you're boring. Love of his life, you're boring.
1:02:58We'll get rid of you and then continue with the story. And I was like, that made me mad.
1:03:02It's not like Alien 3 levels of invalidating the emotional stakes of the previous movie so that
1:03:10you can, so that your movie can have fun stuff happening in it. But it was there. Those vibes
1:03:15were there. And then Deadpool and Wolverine did a whole incomparable about all three of these
1:03:22movies, individual episodes about all three of these movies. Good movie, funny, surprisingly
1:03:29heartfelt. And I think that in general, that's the thing that surprised me about the Deadpool movies
1:03:33is they are not just, they're not cynical joke machines. They are funny.
1:03:42They like to make you believe they're going to be, which I think is the truth.
1:03:45Yes, they do. They are funny and violent, but there is an emotional core in all of them. That's
1:03:52very important. And Godzilla minus one. Yeah. Also true, actually. Deadpool and Wolverine
1:03:59has emotional content. It's very funny and it is very violent, but violent in a silly way. It's
1:04:07the kind of movie where something terrible happens that's violent and I laugh at how ludicrous the
1:04:12violence is. Whereas I don't like as much movies where the violence is very realistic and
1:04:19emotionally stressful. That's not this kind of movie. And yeah, surprisingly,
1:04:25emotionally resonant and surprisingly really honoring Logan, which was a wonderful
1:04:35final movie about Wolverine. Again, an adult movie, but with Logan in it, just like Godzilla minus one
1:04:42is an adult movie with Godzilla in it. You could argue this movie desecrates the grave of that
1:04:48movie because it literally does. And yet that's not the case. It actually honors it. And I think
1:04:56that was a neat trick. So that's my two minutes on Deadpool and Wolverine. It's a good movie.
1:05:00I think I would push for Deadpool and Wolverine because while we make the rules ourselves,
1:05:06you would pick the rule from last year. Well, I don't care about that because I saw that.
1:05:15So if you would not have just spoke for two minutes about how much you enjoyed Deadpool
1:05:21and Wolverine, then maybe we'd take a look at that list and see if we could... Is there something...
1:05:26But I really liked Deadpool and Wolverine. You did and so did the audience, which would make
1:05:31you feel like we could do that rather than... So Doom Part 2, also really great. I had a
1:05:37great experience seeing that movie. Big screen, beautiful. And so I'm going to say, let's give
1:05:44it to Deadpool and Wolverine, but I want Doom Part 2, which was the Upgradients choice and I also
1:05:48really endorse it. And I want to put Godzilla minus one in there because it was great. Yeah,
1:05:55I've been meaning to watch that movie, but I haven't gone around. Gotta see it. It's so good.
1:05:59I wanted to watch it last year and then kind of couldn't get it for a long time because it was
1:06:04like... It was unavailable for contractual reasons because there was an American Godzilla movie that
1:06:10came out and there was some rule about how they can't release the... They couldn't release the
1:06:16video version of Godzilla minus one because they were in the blackout period because of the American
1:06:20movie. It's super dumb. Yeah, it was a really self-defeating for everybody involved. All right,
1:06:26great. Moving now to the easiest category. This is just the slam dunk, open and closed category.
1:06:34I agree. Other than that we have to have runners-up. Yeah. But other than that, yeah.
1:06:42Easy peasy. This is favorite TV show. The Upgrading is at 7% for Shrinking,
1:06:479% for Slow Horses and 11% for Shogun. It's easy. Shogun is not just the best TV show I've seen this
1:06:57year. It's one of the best TV shows I've ever seen. Like unbelievable television show. Easy peasy.
1:07:04I agree. I think Shogun is the show of the year. It's so good. I love that it's...
1:07:14Among other people, it's Justin Marks who did Counterpart which is one of the criminally
1:07:25missed fantastic best shows of the last decade. He was brought in by his wife when they went into
1:07:33rewrites with it and I love that he was involved with this because this got all the acclaim that
1:07:37Counterpart deserved and didn't get. I think it's our winner. We do need to pick some runners-up.
1:07:44Sure. I had Tim Goodman on Downstream for Christmas Special. Great.
1:07:54And I did my sort of like short list of, which wasn't that short, of my favorite shows of the
1:08:02year. So I'm going to quickly run them down here and then we'll pick some runners-up.
1:08:08So Silo on Apple TV Plus Season 2 is excellent. A little slower than Season 1 for some good reasons
1:08:20but that's a really good show. Very impressed. Did not think that would be much of anything
1:08:25and it's actually very good. Bad Monkey on Apple TV Plus based on a Carl Hiaasen novel. Vince Vaughn.
1:08:32It's so good. Like it's just it's so good. Funny. The perfect Vince Vaughn TV show. It is so good.
1:08:42It is perfect. It's like all of his good. You know like all of his good. I know it's like Will Ferrell.
1:08:48I know some people don't like Vince Vaughn. This is the, like Will Ferrell and Elf. This is the perfect
1:08:53use of the skills of Vince Vaughn. He is great in it. Really good. He is the main character but he's
1:08:59surrounded by it's, you know, it's a mystery and it's sort of sleazy because it's the Florida Keys
1:09:07and there's intrigue but also it's laid back. It's so good. I cannot recommend Bad Monkey
1:09:14highly enough. It's probably the second best show I watched other than Shogun last year.
1:09:20I really love Dark Matter on Apple TV Plus. Again, I was reluctant to watch it for a while
1:09:29and then we started watching it and we burned through those like an episode a night because
1:09:34the elevator pitch is what if your life was stolen from you by yourself?
1:09:43And as you might expect, I just praised Counterpart, parallel universes come into play here.
1:09:49In the first episode, right? It's not really a mystery. In the first episode, parallel
1:09:54universes come into play here. What I love about Dark Matter is that it fully commits to the
1:09:59premise instead of saying sort of like, "Well, yeah, there's science fictional parallel universes in it
1:10:06but really this is about, this is a character drama." And so we're gonna not talk about the
1:10:12implications of the parallel universe machine. We're gonna just focus on the characters. And look,
1:10:18you should focus on the characters. That's the most important thing. But you could also not
1:10:22ignore the implications of the parallel universe machine as well. And Dark Matter, and I admire it
1:10:30greatly, does not ignore the implications of the parallel universe machine at all. I thought it was
1:10:37really good. It's based on a novel. The showrunner of the show was the guy who wrote the novel.
1:10:42And much to my-- it adapts the novel and much to my surprise, they renewed it for a second season.
1:10:48So like Shogun, a show based on a novel that adapts the entire novel in one season and it's
1:10:55so good that they're like, "Yeah, make something up for season two!" So it's gonna come back.
1:10:59Love that. And some others I want to mention, Hacks on Max, very funny, just great show about
1:11:10women in comedy. I love it. I couldn't love it more. So mad about this, Jason. I'm so mad about
1:11:15this. So Hacks was on Amazon Prime in the UK. They have not picked up season three. And nobody has.
1:11:27So season three is just completely unavailable. You can't even buy it here. So I loved Hacks season
1:11:33one and two, but you can't watch the new season. Because they want to have launch a max version or
1:11:40have a partner that's doing a max version in the UK. Well, they do already. Sky. But Sky
1:11:45pick up specific things. I don't understand why they do this, but no one's got Hacks,
1:11:51so I just can't watch it. Well, VPNs are available. Anyway--
1:11:55Yeah, but I have to have an account, right? No, that's true. That's true.
1:11:59I can't sign up for Max, so a VPN doesn't help me.
1:12:03Gene Smart, Hannah Einbinder are great in that. And then that is part of the greater Mike Schur
1:12:10universe, because it's some people who work with Mike Schur on The Good Place and other places that
1:12:15are doing that show. It's great. Yeah, third season was awesome. Shout out to Slow Horses,
1:12:21which continues to be fantastic every season. My other Apple TV+ thing I'll shout out,
1:12:28I really liked Masters of the Air. I didn't think I would. I was like, oh,
1:12:31boy, it's a World War II drama again, just like Band of Brothers and The Pacific,
1:12:35from the same producers. It was really good. It was really well done. You could see Apple's
1:12:39money on the screen with that one. I was very impressed. That's a miniseries. It was really
1:12:43good. I have two Netflix picks. The Diplomat came back for season two. A little short,
1:12:48but I like it. I really like that show. They're already shooting season three. Carrie Russell,
1:12:52as an American. If you haven't seen the show, there's also season one. You can start there.
1:12:58You should start there. As an unlikely choice to be the US ambassador to the UK, because she's
1:13:03usually from conflict-filled regions of the world. There are reasons why she's gotten this job.
1:13:10I also just delight in the fact that she feels ill-suited for it and seeing her be confronted
1:13:15with the things she's supposed to wear to various formal events when she's used to being like,
1:13:19running around in blue jeans in some, you know, far-off region of the world. It's delightful.
1:13:27I also really liked A Man on the Inside on Netflix, which is Mike Schur. As mentioned before,
1:13:32this is with Ted Danson. It's a very sweet comedy. It's about a mystery at a retirement home,
1:13:42but also it's about old people and finding ways to live their lives after traumatic events. I think
1:13:51it's very sweet. It's not sad as much as it is just sweet. Really good. Great use of San Francisco
1:13:56locations. And finally, much to my surprise, season two of Sure-See, the Letterkenny spin-off
1:14:03on Hulu in the US at least. I was kind of left cold by season one of Sure-See. Why would you
1:14:10do a spin-off about a one-joke character in Letterkenny, which was, I think, finished this
1:14:16year and is an all-timer. I love Letterkenny so much. Sure-See season two, I really got into it.
1:14:21I kind of got what they were selling. It's a sports movie as a TV show. It's about a bunch of
1:14:29adult minor league hockey players trying to win a tournament. It's just very silly and there are
1:14:37many jokes and I love it. So Sure-See. And if you haven't seen Letterkenny, go watch Letterkenny.
1:14:43It's great. That's my list. You mentioned about being sweet, right? Like a thing that is sweet.
1:14:49You said that for what? Man on the Inside? Man on the Inside. For me, Shrinking is that. Shrinking
1:14:56season two is really, really, really, really good. I was very surprised actually of how good it is.
1:15:02That cast is just like so good. This may be a beautiful cast. People may disagree with me here,
1:15:09but this is my opinion. This is my favorite thing I've ever seen Harrison Ford in.
1:15:15I think this is him perfectly. Kind of the mixing of the actor and the man. Like it feels like he
1:15:23fits so well in this role. It lets him use muscles that I think most movie people just don't aren't
1:15:29gonna bother asking him for. Yeah. It's like, oh yeah, what if Harrison Ford, treasure of an actor,
1:15:36was a supporting character on a sitcom? And you're like, well, why would he do that? Well,
1:15:42we don't know why. Apple Money just wanted, I think, for the challenge of doing something
1:15:46different. And guess what? He nails it because he is actually a great actor. And it isn't just,
1:15:52and it's actually him in Shrinking, which is great. I didn't like season two as much as season
1:15:57one, but I do love it. It's a great show. I think it's a great example of how actors are misused
1:16:05by creative people in Hollywood. How once you're an actor who's known for a certain kind of role,
1:16:13you never get the opportunity, or rarely get the opportunity, to do something different.
1:16:17And it can be like it's a bejeweled prison, right? Like Harrison Ford not hurting for money
1:16:24and parts and all of that. And yet I'm sure the professional actor part of him always feels a
1:16:31little bit disappointed when he's asked to do your Han Solo and Indiana Jones thing again and again
1:16:40and again. And in Shrinking, he gets to be a little bit different. And so creatively, he must
1:16:46absolutely love it. And that's great because he's great in it. My favorite thing about season two
1:16:51was how much Ted McGinley is used in it. I really, really enjoyed him in, so he plays Derek. I
1:16:59really enjoyed him in the first season. He's very funny. And then in this season, we got more of
1:17:03his funny, but also a lot more hot. So you said about using Harrison Ford, I actually saw a thing
1:17:08with Jason Segel yesterday. And he was talking about Harrison Ford being in Shrinking. He says,
1:17:14you know, like whenever you work on a project, you start with, if we could cast this person,
1:17:20how amazing would it be? And you always reach out to that person. And they always say no.
1:17:26So then, which is fine, because then you at least for two days get to say, you know,
1:17:30we asked Harrison Ford and he said no. But he said, Harrison Ford said yes. And then they had
1:17:35to rewrite the show because Paul was not in the show very much. And like, well, now we have
1:17:39Harrison Ford. So then it became a co-lead. It's essentially the way that he says, like, you know,
1:17:44now it's the two of them, right? That they are both doing leading roles where Paul was just much
1:17:48more of a mentor figure. You saw him sometimes. So I thought that was really interesting. Just
1:17:54like what that was like. Yeah. So Shrinking I loved. And I also just wanted to throw out
1:17:59the Penguin too. It's a great show. - Again, I have not seen it. My son loves it.
1:18:05- I will say, I've said this to a lot of people, if you like kind of mob gangster stuff,
1:18:11but think I don't want superheroes, then you're fine. Because there are no superheroes in the
1:18:16show. It's just people. - Yeah. Okay. Let's give it to Shogun. We already
1:18:24tabulated that. We mentioned a bunch of other things. I think I'm going to suggest
1:18:27we go with, well, let's do, okay. Why don't we do Shrinking and Bad Monkey?
1:18:39- Yeah, that's a good one. I enjoyed that. I think it's something new. So the winner of the favorite
1:18:44TV show of the year is Shogun and Shrinking and Bad Monkey are the runners-up. - Yeah. Good stuff.
1:18:52- It's time for favorite book. - Your favorite category.
1:18:56- Yeah. - Did you read a book this year, Mike?
1:18:58- Yeah. I actually have a recommendation, but it's like, it's called How to Be a Dad,
1:19:04which is a book that I've been really enjoying. It's by a British doctor, Dr. Oscar Duke.
1:19:12And it's just a, it's a book that I've enjoyed a lot. It is written in a way that I really enjoy,
1:19:19that he is a doctor and he also became a dad for the first time. And so the book is written from
1:19:26both perspectives. So you have like a chapter about a certain element of pregnancy or newborn
1:19:33life, and he writes it as a dad and he writes it as a doctor. And so you kind of get both sides of
1:19:38it. And it's just a very relatable, very easy book. And I enjoyed it a lot and it doesn't
1:19:45fall into too many of the tropes that I have found this kind of stuff to be,
1:19:50which is just kind of like, don't call your wife fat. And it's like, this is not,
1:19:53I don't need that information, you know, which is like a lot of what like dad like focused stuff is.
1:20:01And I actually have, I found out a lot of really helpful, interesting things from this book. And so
1:20:08I recommend it to people that are in my particular set of circumstances, but this was a book
1:20:13published in 2019. So, you know. Okay, that's fine. It does. You read it this year. Sure.
1:20:19That's all that matters. The Upgradients. I forgot to do the Upgradients because I got so excited.
1:20:25Yeah, no, no, I derailed you. It's fine. With 4% Service Model by Adrian Tchaikovsky,
1:20:336% Wind and Truth by Brandon Sanderson and 8% The Armageddon Protocol by Dan Moran.
1:20:42Dan Moran's annual appearance. You love some, I enjoy the ballot boxes being stuffed personally.
1:20:49Yes, I'm really thrilled because my favorite book that I read this year
1:20:53made the Upgradients list. That is rare. That usually does not happen.
1:20:59No, no. Service Model by Adrian Tchaikovsky. First off, Adrian Tchaikovsky is probably
1:21:04the best science fiction writer going right now. Science fiction, fantasy, he does a whole bunch
1:21:09of stuff. I've read a lot of his stuff the last couple years. He's very prolific and he's so good.
1:21:14And Service Model, I went into it not knowing what it was at all and then about a chapter in,
1:21:20I thought, well, this is funny because he's taking us from the perspective of a robot
1:21:26and why robot logic and computer logic could lead to ridiculous outcomes. It really is the idea of
1:21:34like, okay, so yeah, robot apocalypse, got it, got it, but how would that happen? And he takes you
1:21:41through the mind of the robot who's helping kind of with the apocalypse. And it's ludicrous. And
1:21:49I thought, well, he can't keep this up for the whole book and he keeps it up for the whole book.
1:21:53It's great. It's funny. It is about the end of the world. So there's a lot of like, you got to laugh
1:21:59at the absurdity to keep from crying from the tragedy of everybody dying basically. But like,
1:22:05takes you really deep inside the robot apocalypse. When there are almost no humans left,
1:22:09what do the robots do? And the answer is, wow, they do a lot of stupid things because they're
1:22:13robots. It's very funny. And it's sort of a series of adventures that this robot has where he goes
1:22:21from place to place to place to seek out the source of the robot apocalypse, sort of. I don't
1:22:30know. It's great. I love it. It should be the winner. I'll shout out a couple other books I
1:22:34really love this year that didn't, that one of which at least was not printed this year, but I
1:22:38don't care. I read it this year. I read "Titanium Noir" by Nick Harkaway, who is John le Carré's
1:22:46son and actually had a new book in that universe that he wrote that came out this year that got all
1:22:51the press. But he's also apparently writing a sequel to "Titanium Noir" which I really loved.
1:22:56Great book. It's very funny. I just went to like, put in the show notes and on Amazon,
1:23:00it's "Titanium Noir", a titanium noir novel. It's like, okay. Yes. Well, it's now "Titanium
1:23:05Noir" number one because it's going to be a number two. It is just very funny. It's like,
1:23:10no, you're kidding. No way. It's great. It's like, it's the future and income
1:23:15inequality means that although there's a cure for death now, only the richest people can get it.
1:23:20And it makes them taller every time they get a round of their treatment. So you end up with these
1:23:25these like Titans that walk the earth that are like 10 feet tall and rich and immortal.
1:23:32One of them dies and our schlubby noir detective has to figure out who and why.
1:23:37That's a really good premise. I like the sound of this book. That, that would make a good TV show.
1:23:42It's great. It's so good. And Nick Harkaway is such a good writer.
1:23:45All these stories about, about like, Oh, John look, Le Carre died, but his son is going to
1:23:51write a novel. Speaking of Dune, right? Cause that's what happened with Dune is Brian Herbert
1:23:55came in. Here's the thing about Nick Harkaway. He's such a brilliant writer. He is a brilliant
1:24:00writer. It has nothing to do with him being related to his dad. I think it's kind of amazing
1:24:04that he decided to write a book in his dad's world because he is, he's really great on his own. I
1:24:10mean, he really is a, a, a treasure of a writer, great writer. Book I just finished this week that
1:24:16I turns out sliding right in under the wire as one of my favorite books of the year is called the
1:24:21book of love by Kelly Link. It is a dark, it's, it's an urban, it's kind of like a suburban
1:24:29fantasy. It's a, it reminded me of Neil Gaiman or the, the more fantastical and less horror of
1:24:37Stephen King might be a good comp as well about some teenagers in a seaside town in new England.
1:24:44I know it feels like Stephen King, doesn't it? Who, who apparently, apparently died, but have
1:24:49now come back to life and are trying to figure out why and how and what happens next. And I thought
1:24:56it was really great. So it was my, the book of love by Kelly Link. That's a fun title. Kelly
1:25:02Link Pulitzer prize winner and winner of a MacArthur genius grant. So not exactly a, an
1:25:07unknown quantity, but the book, I think this might've been her first novel or her first
1:25:10intentional novel. It's great. Good, good book. Good book. So a service model is obviously the
1:25:15winner, right? Yeah. Yeah. And then let's put in how to be a dad. No, we don't need to do that.
1:25:21We really don't need to do that. Let's put in the actual books. We'll look back later. And okay,
1:25:26then let's say, um, we'll put in Armageddon protocol by Dan Moran, of course. And let's put
1:25:33in one of Dan Warren's favorite authors, titanium noir by Nick Harkaway as our runners up, then I'll
1:25:38get a kick out of that being alongside that book. Favorite podcast. Sometimes this is hard because
1:25:48our lifetime achievement winners are ATP and the flop house, which means that, uh, two of the
1:25:52podcasts I listen to regularly are out of contention. The rebound came in at 8% of the
1:26:00vote. I'm just going to say it. The ballot boxes have been stuffed this year in this category.
1:26:0412% is this very show upgrade and at 19% is connected. I was, I was present for some of the,
1:26:11the ballot box stuffing, uh, on connected, but unfortunately this is, this is another open and
1:26:18closed. I'm sorry to say because, oh boy, I have been mainlining the rest of this history. Like,
1:26:25love to hear it. I started listening to this show, uh, on my vacation kind of around Thanksgiving.
1:26:32It is essentially the only podcast that I've listened to. So to give you, and just to let
1:26:39you know, right, because I can do the overcast stats thing, right? So this has been since
1:26:46like, this has been what's five weeks, right? In five weeks I have listened to
1:26:5557 hours of the rest of this history.
1:27:01So it's a little more than 10 hours a week. I love it. Yeah. Yeah. It's the only podcast I'm
1:27:07listening to right now. My backlog right now is horrific. Uh, because I am just, I am just,
1:27:14I cannot even describe how much I love this show. And this funny thing for me is I have,
1:27:18this was already going to be a difficult category for me. I have five podcasts that I wanted to call
1:27:25out in this list, which I would do in a minute, but the rest of this history is just perfect.
1:27:31I love that show so much. Thank you for introducing into me. It is now particularly
1:27:37funny now I've listened to so much when I go back and think about the holiday special from last year,
1:27:41which was in the style of that show, right? The Colorzars, because now I kind of, I get it.
1:27:47There's like so many jokes that I didn't get, which is very funny. But yeah, I am loving this
1:27:55show. There's like so many good seasons. What I have noticed though, Jason, I don't know if you've
1:27:58noticed this. There was obviously a shift in the style of the show kind of late 2023, because I've
1:28:07gone back kind of to early 2023 and the episodes like, hey, we're just going to talk about this.
1:28:12Like the two of them are just having a conversation about something where now the show
1:28:18is more, we're going to tell you the story of this thing that happened. So like, there's a,
1:28:24there's, they did, they did two, even two series about the Nazis. They did like, how did it,
1:28:29how did it, how did we get to the Nazis and then what happened? And they were like a year apart
1:28:33from each other. And so I went back to the episodes early 2023, which were like, how did we
1:28:40get to the Nazis essentially? And in those, it's like the two of them are having a kind of a
1:28:45conversation about it. And like, well, what did you think? What did you think? And then the, the,
1:28:50like, what happens in the Nazis takeover? It is, they're kind of taking it in turns to tell the
1:28:55other one the history of the thing that happened. And I much prefer that style.
1:28:59- They've changed their form. I think it's great. Yeah. I haven't listened to too many of those past
1:29:03episodes, but it's fine. The personalities are great. I mean, it's got all the things a great
1:29:07podcast has. - That's, that's what's, what I love about The Rest is History is it is the type of
1:29:13show that I like, which is a couple of people who have very good chemistry talking to each other
1:29:18about something that they care a lot about. And it's about a thing that I don't have too much
1:29:24knowledge about a lot of the things that I've listened to. Like, you know, stuff like World War
1:29:29Two, I know, and you know, like some of the Cold War stuff I know, JFK I knew about, but I knew
1:29:34nothing about the Aztecs. - Yeah, let me tell you about Carthage. They're like, what? - Yeah,
1:29:40there's so many things. I mean, so I will say there is stuff that I've realized that like,
1:29:44oh yeah, no, like for example, that a lot of like the Roman stuff is like, I just can't attach to
1:29:49that. It's too far gone. Like I started listening to an episode about like the Romans invading
1:29:56Britain and it's like, they're talking about countries that don't exist. And it's like,
1:30:01I can't keep this information in my head. So I kind of, I like, yeah, but anyway, this show is
1:30:07just fantastic. But I had other shows that I wanted to mention. - Okay. - Similarly from
1:30:13The Goal Hanger, The Rest is Politics. This was going to be my pick because I started listening
1:30:18to this show at the beginning of the year when we had the election in the UK, because I wanted like
1:30:22some more information, kind of what is going on. And I found the show and it's the same idea,
1:30:28right? It's two people who are very knowledgeable because they have both been in British politics.
1:30:34And I really liked that they come from two, they're both kind of like center, well, one,
1:30:39they like center left and center right as kind of figures. And I like that because they come at it
1:30:45from different points and they can actually have a debate, which is helpful, I think for politics,
1:30:50but also that neither of them are too far in one direction that it becomes like a fight. So I
1:30:57really appreciate that show for that. I wanted to share our NPC, Next Portable Console, which is
1:31:02a Federico, John and Brendan show about portable gaming systems, which I love. My very first
1:31:09podcast has come back, Dignation. Dignation is back, which is like amazing. Like just for this
1:31:16show to just reappear after all this time is fantastic. That's been a lot of fun for me,
1:31:21because it's incredible that it feels like the show hasn't changed, even though they've not
1:31:25done it for like, I don't know, maybe 10 years or something. And then I just got a shout out
1:31:30of town as well, which is always there. Always there. Great year for podcast for me.
1:31:37Yeah. So what are our runners up here?
1:31:39I would like to suggest the rest is politics, because that was going to be my other vote,
1:31:52and then the other one, whatever you want it to be.
1:31:54All right. Well, if I look at my top four podcasts of the year in Overcast, two of them are Lifetime
1:32:04Achievement Award winners. One of them is the rest is history. And so congratulations to Connected
1:32:11for being a runner up. So the funny thing about this and why Steven has been like,
1:32:16really putting this out there is I think Connected is one win away from Lifetime Achievement.
1:32:24I think that's the situation. But yeah, it ain't happening this time. I'm afraid.
1:32:31This episode is brought to you by Data Citizen Dialogues, which is a podcast, which is great
1:32:37for the starts we've spoken about a bunch of podcasts. Data and how we use it is an
1:32:42ever shifting landscape. But you know that because you're a listener of this show.
1:32:45If you like this show, you're probably going to like Data Citizen Dialogues. It's brought to you
1:32:49by Collibra, the leader in data intelligence. They are the one stop shop in the latest hot topics in
1:32:55data. In every episode of Data Citizen Dialogues, industry leaders unpack data's impact on the world
1:33:01from big picture questions like AI governance and data sharing to more nuanced questions like how
1:33:06do we balance offense and defense in data management. You'll hear first hand insights
1:33:11about the data conversations affecting all kinds of industries with guests sharing unique stories
1:33:16from some of the world's largest companies. Like in their episode, the secret sauce behind
1:33:20McDonald's data strategy, which digs into how AI driven tools can be used to support crew efficiency
1:33:26and customer interactions. I listened to an episode about how data is being used to improve
1:33:31healthcare at Memorial Care. And I really enjoyed how the episode was featuring the people that are
1:33:36actually kind of doing the work so they could talk about the things that they have experienced of how
1:33:40they have to think about data security and privacy and all of the important things that will be
1:33:45needed to when you're working in healthcare, but then also how they're using the data they get to
1:33:50improve the care of their patients. Be a part of the data conversation and start listening to the
1:33:55Data Citizens Dialogues podcast now. Follow Data Citizens Dialogues on Apple, Spotify, YouTube,
1:34:01or wherever you listen to your podcasts. Our thanks to Data Citizens Dialogues for their
1:34:05support of this show and all of Relay. We now move into favourite Apple product of the year.
1:34:13The Upgradients voted 10% for the M4 MacBook Pro, 16% for the M4 iPad Pro, and 33%
1:34:25for the M4 Mac Mini. Well, I don't know about you, Mike. I mean, a good year for Apple products.
1:34:30I got an angry bit of feedback from a listener because we were listing our favourites over at
1:34:40Six Colors. We were all listing sort of our favourite hardware of the year. And none of us
1:34:44chose to write up the super thin all-time winner M4 iPad Pro, which is cool. You know, I love how
1:34:52thin it is and I love how bright that beautiful new screen is. It's all good, but I chose to
1:34:59write up the Magic Keyboard instead. And my reasoning was, if somebody told me I had to
1:35:08give up my M4 iPad Pro, what would be the one thing about it that I would miss the most? And it
1:35:15wasn't the iPad, it was the keyboard that goes with it, because I think that keyboard is so
1:35:21much better. But look, the iPad Pro M4 is great. There are a lot of things to be said for it.
1:35:31I do love how thin it is. It's really good. I use my iPad all the time. I bought an M4 MacBook Pro.
1:35:40Coming to you, we'll talk about this I'm sure in future episodes, but I am docked with a MacBook
1:35:47Pro at my desk now. This is my life now, Mike. So do I like that product? Yes, I do. I think the M4
1:35:54Max is really good. But who are we kidding? I feel like the Apple product of the year
1:36:01is the Mac Mini. I feel like it has to be the Mac Mini. It is so remarkable. Not only do the
1:36:09Upgradients say that, but to finally make a new Mac Mini and have it be so tiny and yet so powerful
1:36:14with the M4 Max or M4 Pro version of it. It's way more power than anybody needs for a regular life.
1:36:24You can max out that Mac Mini and it's this incredibly powerful little tiny thing.
1:36:29So cool and so useful. And I know a lot of people who don't have any use for a Mac Mini who still
1:36:36want one. So I feel like that is good. Also, my understanding is that you also have ordered a Mac
1:36:43Mini. Is that true? Yes, we will talk about this in Upgrade Plus today. But yeah, I have actually
1:36:51made the order that I've been threatening to make for months now and I have actually ordered the
1:36:56M4 Mac Mini. Which is why I would very happily give it to that product. It's not my choice
1:37:02because I've not used it, but I do really appreciate that product. So I think it's fantastic.
1:37:06For me, my favorite Apple product of the year is the M4 iPad Pro. Oh, there you go. It's my first
1:37:13iPad Pro with a very good screen like that. I didn't have an OLED iPad Pro. I didn't have the
1:37:21Mini LED iPad Pro before now. So the 11 inch specifically, I adore that iPad. How thin it is,
1:37:29how light it is, and how powerful it is, and how good it looks. But yeah, the Mac Mini is
1:37:38clearly a very special product. And so I'm very happy to give that the Apple product of the year.
1:37:44But I would like to put the iPad Pro in as a runner up. Absolutely. And the MacBook Pro I would like
1:37:51to put in as a runner up. I'll talk about my Mac Mini purchase on Upgrade Plus today.
1:37:56Okay. Favorite non-Apple product of the year. This is a tricky one. This is a tricky one. This
1:38:05is always a tricky one, but it's a fun one too. So the Upgradients voted with 4% for the OLED
1:38:10Steam Deck, 4% for the Google Pixel 9 family, and 6% for the Meta Raybans. I was surprised to see
1:38:17the Meta Raybans take the spot here, but I was pleased about that. Was there any ballot stuffing
1:38:22from Connected in that? Maybe. Well, I mean, the ballot stuffing that I'm talking about is where
1:38:27specifically people are asking for votes, not just that they've been influenced by listeners
1:38:32of the show. I'm not shilling for Meta. Okay. What do you think here? So I could make a case
1:38:43for the Meta Raybans. I think they're a very interesting product. I like mine a lot. Federico
1:38:50loves his and wears them every day. I use mine just as sunglasses, so my options are limited.
1:38:56But being able to take photos and listen to music and like when I was on vacation, I was listening
1:39:01to the rest of history by the pool via my sunglasses, which was just a great experience
1:39:08like that, that it is a very, very good product. Take the AI out of it. It's still a good product.
1:39:15Add the AI in and it can do more stuff, but you know, whatever. I'm going to pick, and my favorite
1:39:21product of the year though is something completely different. It's called the Oslo Sleepbuds.
1:39:30And that's Oslo with a Z, of course. I mean, why would it not be? Bose used to make a product
1:39:37that I've forgotten what it was called, but it was a, they were sleeping headphones
1:39:43and they essentially just played white noise. They stopped making this product. So the entire
1:39:50team that made it went and made their own company called Oslo to make the new version of what that
1:39:56would be. So by the way, they were called the Bose Sleepbuds. There you go. So, you know,
1:40:01I'm expecting that there was an agreement made between all these. Like, I don't just think that
1:40:09they just went and did it. This product feels like a startup's product. It is not by any means
1:40:19a kind of very complete feeling product, but they are very comfortable to wear when sleeping.
1:40:26They're like very, very thin and they've got, they're very comfortable. They don't go in your
1:40:31ears. They sit on your ear and they have those kinds of wing tips to hold them in.
1:40:35And they have an app and the app comes with a selection of white noise that you can play or
1:40:42like different sounds. Like I listen to the sound of an ocean and I find them to be really
1:40:50comfortable that you can also, you can use them as Bluetooth headphones. So you could be listening
1:40:55to something else. You could be watching something else. They have a feature that I've not used,
1:40:59but I like that it's there and I've seen mixed results, but some people say it works and some
1:41:03people say it don't. That it detects that you've fallen asleep and pauses what you're listening to
1:41:08and it activates the white noise. There are things about it that are not ideal. Like for example,
1:41:14you have to open the app and then like open the case and then they connect and then it will work.
1:41:20And also, I set it to just to play for an hour because I don't need it doing it all night.
1:41:28But then if I wake up and want to put the white noise back on again, I have to do that repairing
1:41:32process. So that's what I mean. There are things about it where it's like, oh, this could be a bit
1:41:36slicker, but as a product for, I want some headphones that I can wear comfortably while
1:41:43sleeping on my side that don't dig into me, that don't fall out of my ears and get lost
1:41:49and that provide me with a white noise experience. These are it. So I really love this product. It's
1:41:55a fun little tech product that I've used this year, the Oslo Seat Buds. Wow. That's fun. Yeah.
1:42:01It's nice to find something like that. Like here is a tech solution to a problem that I want solved
1:42:06made by people who care so much about it that they want to start their own company to do it.
1:42:11All right. I thought of four things. I'm sure there's something that I've forgotten.
1:42:18I'm sure of it, but I thought of four things. The Miu Mini Plus, which we talked about in
1:42:25Upgrade Plus last week. This is a little tiny handheld game emulating thing that
1:42:31is like super cheap on AliExpress and was on sale. So it was super duper cheap when I bought one.
1:42:38Gave that to my son for Christmas. I think he's into it. Really good. Just a good build. The
1:42:44buttons are good. My son, again, the gamer was like, these buttons are really good. I'm like,
1:42:48yeah, they are. It's really well built piece of hardware. And then amazing that you, you know,
1:42:53what OSs are out there to run on top of it. This thing called Onion OS. And that is a third party
1:43:02thing that's not even from Miu, but they know that people install it and it's really good. And then
1:43:08it's got a whole bunch of different emulators on it. Just I'm very impressed with that product.
1:43:12There are a lot of, I don't have a lot of nostalgia for handhelds, which is part of my
1:43:17problem with all of these products is that they're like, oh, it looks just like a Game Boy, or it
1:43:21looks just like a, what's the full dope and what, anyway, it doesn't matter. I don't have nostalgia
1:43:31for those little handhelds. So I'm more into it for having it be a handheld that is fun, that runs
1:43:39a bunch of games, especially old arcade games and old console games, less than I am running,
1:43:47you know, Game Boy games, because I have no nostalgia for Game Boy games. But that hardware
1:43:52is really good and I love this category. So I wanted to mention it. Very impressive. There are
1:43:56other styles. There's ones that are shaped more, you know, horizontal, more like a Steam Deck that
1:44:01do, you know, PSP emulation and all sorts of other emulation. But like the two things that I ended up
1:44:07playing the most on the Miu Mini+ when I had it were Joust, classic arcade console game, and
1:44:13NFL Blitz 2000, which was my favorite game for the PS1. So that's the kind of stuff I gravitated
1:44:21toward. I tried to play Pac-Man on it and realized like Game Boy Pac-Man, you like, they pan around
1:44:26the screen, you can't see the whole screen because they couldn't do that. I was like, oh yeah, a
1:44:30little handhelds can't do that stuff, can they? We can do better. I mentioned my EverLights
1:44:38experience where I put lights on my house. That was a fun tech product this year that
1:44:43I used that put lights on my house. Permanent lights, holiday lights, I program them.
1:44:49It's currently Hanukkah. I have built my own Hanukkah pattern that shows like how many
1:44:54candles there are. It's really cool. I love it. I will shout out my Christmas present, which is the
1:45:03Traeger Ironwood Grill, which is a pellet grill. Smokes some meat on it. But the thing that
1:45:09impresses me the most about it as a tech product is that it's basically got a little computer in
1:45:13it. The hardware of this thing, other than the grill hardware, is it's got an auger that
1:45:18basically feeds the pellets into the combustion chamber and it's got a fan so it can control the
1:45:25combustion. It's all done by this little computer that has Wi-Fi and it'll talk to your phone and
1:45:30they have an app and the app is surprisingly not terrible because most of these apps are terrible.
1:45:38I used it over the holidays. It worked really well, but I was delighted by the fact that not
1:45:43only was this little computer, you know, that the buttons on the grill itself are very clear,
1:45:49but that the app is good and you can control other than the initial ignition, you can control it all
1:45:55from the app and it does a pretty good job. So that was a fun gadget. And then finally,
1:45:59I threw it in here because it delights me. That Belkin Vision Pro case and sure that head strap
1:46:07thing too. The two products that got released that are literally "Apple says you should make this"
1:46:12and that clearly should have been what Apple shipped when they shipped the Vision Pro,
1:46:17but instead they shipped the big puffy marshmallow case and a really kind of weird misguided set of
1:46:24head straps instead of just using that knit strap with an over-the-top strap simultaneously.
1:46:30I thought that was it makes me laugh that those products have to exist, but they're also pretty
1:46:34good. What do you think? So from your list, I really like the Belkin products. I think they
1:46:49should be in the conversation. Yeah. Well, my suggestion was going to be that we give it to the
1:46:55Metaray bands. Cause that sounds like a product that actually people like and that you like and
1:47:00that is doing something interesting. Yeah. And then we can make your sleep buds and the Belkin stuff
1:47:06the runners up. Love it. That's fun. What a fun category. Yeah. I mean, Apple, you got to do
1:47:13something and these smart glasses, like what are you doing? I know, right? No, the AirPods that you
1:47:19wear as glasses that tie into Siri on your phone and Apple intelligence and all of that. And that
1:47:26can they're, they're AirPods that you wear as glasses. They don't even need a display, right?
1:47:31That'll come, but they don't even need a display like Apple. Yes. I don't say this that often,
1:47:37but I think I said it a few weeks ago and I'll say it again here, which is if I were at Apple
1:47:42in a position of authority, I would say we'll draw on the inspiration of the iPod
1:47:50by the end of 2025, we need by the holidays of 2025, we should be shipping AirPods glasses.
1:47:57Yeah. Period. Make it happen. I don't care. Like take the innards of AirPods and like, and honestly,
1:48:04if you're working on a new version of AirPods, stop, put it on hold and do this instead. Cause
1:48:09AirPods are great. The existing shipping AirPods are fine. Stop it. You can build a product and
1:48:16get it going and ship it by the end of the year. Let's use all the power within Apple to make that
1:48:22product happen. Simplify and miniaturize the work that you did to get the speakers in a vision pro,
1:48:25right? So you like, you know how to do that. It doesn't need to be that good, right? Like,
1:48:30you know how to make a speaker that fires into the ear, right? Or use, or, or you did a bunch
1:48:35of research about bone conduction and decided not to go for it. Maybe that works for these and you
1:48:39could use that instead, but the guts of it are going to be AirPods. That's all. And, and ship it,
1:48:45like do it now. I don't understand. This is one of my frustrations. I know that Apple
1:48:49is a big company and things are complex. I get it. But one of my frustrations about Apple is that,
1:48:56and it may be to their overall harm in the long run is they seem incapable of doing something
1:49:04with speed. They seem incapable of making things happen that are obviously weaknesses,
1:49:12addressing them quickly. They didn't address the butterfly keyboard, for example, that's a classic
1:49:16example, but I would argue the smart home stuff. Like they're talking about this display. How long
1:49:21has it been since the echo show came out? Like this was an obvious place for them to go years
1:49:26ago. And they, I guess decided not to, or they just decided to put their toe in it, but like
1:49:30they could have made that product happen. And, and this is another case where like, look, meta figured
1:49:34it out AirPods, but glasses. And, and I don't know whether it's like, well, no, we, we thought about
1:49:41that and decided not to do it. And so now that net is doing it, we're really never going to do it.
1:49:44Well, that's stupid. That's stupid. And it's not the vision pro it's a totally different approach
1:49:49to putting something on your face, but it, you know, for people who don't want to wear the AirPods,
1:49:55they could wear this instead and they get an AirPods experience. It really is. That's why
1:49:59I described it as AirPods glasses. Cause think of it like that. I don't, I just went and then Mark
1:50:05Gurman comes out and says, yeah, they're looking at that. It'll be out in two or three years. I'm
1:50:09like, what are you doing? What are you doing too slow? Worst gadget or most disappointing
1:50:16technology. The upgrade is voted of 11% for the vision pro 12% for artificial intelligence as a
1:50:25whole and 15% for the humane AI pin. The humane AI pin, which was introduced in 2023, but shipped
1:50:39in 2024. The humane AI pin won this category in 2023. Amazing. Yeah. Which honestly makes this
1:50:48really tantalizing as a possibility to give it the award twice, but I want to make a pitch.
1:50:54Okay. Image playgrounds. Oh, wow. Image playgrounds is the most disappointed that I've been in
1:51:04technology this year. Like I said, this is the show of how many say it many times, so I'm not
1:51:10going to go into it in a lot of detail, but I just think that I don't think Apple, a lot of people
1:51:16write in Apple intelligence, but not enough to get into the thing, but like, I don't think Apple
1:51:19intelligence on the whole has been bad, but I think image playgrounds is bad. I think it is not
1:51:24a good, uh, um, it is not a good use of this kind of technology. It's not good enough. Um, and it
1:51:32undermines in my opinion, some of the good work that Apple have done, like with genmoji, which is
1:51:37a fantastic thing. I think it is really great. Uh, I think that image playgrounds is just
1:51:43not worth it. And so they shouldn't have shipped it. And so I, I'm disappointed in that feature.
1:51:49Yeah. I mean, I, I don't think it's very good either. It's absolutely true.
1:51:59Um, I, I don't, I mean, I guess if you got your hopes up, the vision pro is disappointing,
1:52:06but I think it is exactly what we thought it was initially, which is a developer kit.
1:52:10That's I actually think it's kind of great, but nobody should buy it. Right. Which is how do you,
1:52:15am I disappointed by that? No, is exactly what it should have been. The things that have been
1:52:19disappointed is what came after that wasn't at, well, some of it's Apple, but not the hardware.
1:52:24It wasn't enough content. It wasn't enough apps. Like they can, they can to a point,
1:52:29uh, do better in these areas, but like the vision pro specifically, it is exactly what was promised
1:52:39and maybe a better than like, it's just like hardware software, how it works, but it is the,
1:52:43the content that was the, the thing that was a failure to it. I think. Yeah. Yeah, I agree.
1:52:52Um, well I'm, I'm okay with image playground being the winner in this category because I agree. I,
1:53:01I am, I am disappointed in Apple for it and I find it using it eternally disappointing.
1:53:09I've only ever shared things to laugh at them. Yep. I've only ever used things to share them
1:53:16and laugh at them because it, I am unhappy with all of the output and I'm especially unhappy that
1:53:23they centered caricatures of people in your photos library instead of centering generic people,
1:53:30which are in there, which I totally even missed that it was in there. I mentioned this a couple
1:53:36of weeks ago that it had to be pointed out to me by friend of me of the show Griffin, that, um,
1:53:42that there is this appearance thing, but like, think about that. Apple wants you to make
1:53:49caricatures of your friends using its ML models like, and they're not good. Yeah. I just don't
1:53:56like it. I don't like anything about it. No. When again, Genmoji is really good, works good,
1:54:04and I laugh with it, not at it because I can make funny things with it. Yeah, it's funny. Yeah.
1:54:10Yeah. Have you seen the ad? There's a great Genmoji ad. I haven't seen it. No. It's great.
1:54:15There's a great ad. You have this great technology. Why even bother with image playgrounds? Like why?
1:54:22It's very strange to me because they're trying to look, look, I think in the end, in a couple
1:54:27of years, what we're going to look at Apple intelligence and say, Apple panicked because
1:54:32they were behind. They threw out everything that everybody else was doing, but we're behind on it.
1:54:37And then if they're lucky, what we'll say is, and then we realize the stuff that actually mattered
1:54:42and the stuff that didn't matter. And they kind of like faded away the stuff that didn't matter
1:54:47and focused on the stuff that mattered. But right now they don't have that.
1:54:51Yeah. I'm happy with that. Cause I thought humane AI pin would be fun.
1:54:58Great runner up. But the thing is, was the humane AI pin, it wasn't a disappointment.
1:55:06We knew it was a worse gadget though. It was a worse gadget. It shipped and it wasn't,
1:55:10it wasn't any good. And all the reviews were brutal. And so I think it's, I think it's
1:55:15literally worst gadget is the humane AI pin. And then do you have another runner up?
1:55:20I don't agree with the vision pro and I kind of gang. I love you all so much, but like,
1:55:29we can't keep calling AI as a whole, the most disappointed. We're going to do this forever.
1:55:34Like we get this, like at a certain point, like I think finding specific things to be mad about or
1:55:40upset about, I think is better than just like all of artificial intelligence. I think I was,
1:55:45I was trying to figure out a way to say like using like using AI for search, but even then it's too
1:55:59complex. I keep thinking about how I do Google searches now and they put up these AI things.
1:56:05I would be happy to say that the Google AI summary like Google AI summary is, is the worst.
1:56:12I will say a few words about it. They sit, they send their stupid AI summary at the top.
1:56:17It's it must be disregarded or checked. So essentially it's just more garbage at the
1:56:22top of a Google page before you get to real results. And this would be different if the
1:56:28search was the solution, but it isn't because some percentage of the time what you get back is
1:56:35completely wrong or useless. And again, I'm a, I think that AI in certain contexts is great,
1:56:46but boy, it is getting applied to contexts where it does not belong. Where it actually serves to
1:56:54make the product worse. Well, like I think search and chat GPT, like web search abilities in chat
1:57:00GPT has made chat GPT better, right? Like it, cause it's still wrong. You know, it's going to
1:57:06be wrong, but like putting AI in Google made Google worse, right? Like where you can still
1:57:13say, and I get it like how you were saying earlier, chat GPT was getting things wrong,
1:57:16but chat GPT was getting things wrong before, like giving it search functionality made it better,
1:57:23but it's still unreliable. I expect Google to be reliable and now it isn't.
1:57:29Right? Like the answer that Google gives me is an unreliable thing. I don't know if you saw this,
1:57:35but Jason Schreier at Bloomberg is a game reporter. He kind of went viral a little bit on
1:57:40Blue Sky over the weekend because he said his children watched Encanto and loved it.
1:57:46And he wanted to find out if there was a sequel. So he typed in Encanto 2 and it gave a full plot
1:57:51breakdown and a release date of 2024, which all came from a fandom Wiki where people kind of
1:57:59fan fiction movie development, like even down to the fact of saying that Gloria Estefan was
1:58:06actually the lead in this movie. Like they did like a whole thing who wrote the music when they
1:58:10did it and Google just used that. Now, like that's not a good source to be training your AI on
1:58:16because it's not real in the first place. And of course, once that breaks, they turn that off and
1:58:21they're like, oh no, no, that's not there anymore. But you can't, this is not how we can live our
1:58:24lives. And that, that, yes, I saw that example. It is a great example. How, and this is my
1:58:30overarching thought. Cause I think this, this goes for a lot of that, the stuff that Apple has done
1:58:34too this year, which is maybe we need to be a little less generous about AI results because
1:58:46that Google result, like being so wrong, I feel like it's very easy to say, well, it's,
1:58:52it's an AI result. What do you expect? Sometimes they're wrong. And in fact, I think what we should
1:58:58say is Google released a defective product that misinforms its users, even though they're in the
1:59:08business of information and they've done it because they feel they have some sort of external business
1:59:15pressure to do it, but clearly they've released it before they can stand by its results because
1:59:23they've just decided to inflict it on the world, even though it's not very good because they feel
1:59:28they need to. And everything I said also applies to Apple intelligence. Yeah.
1:59:32Yeah. Cause it's like, again, like, you know, cause I do, I am, I've, I do like using chat
1:59:40GPT for some element of searching, but it's always like, get me to somewhere, get me to somewhere.
1:59:46And I like the way that it gets me to places. AI is great when it is assisting people who know it
1:59:52is assisting them and providing information to, as a tool, as a part of a bigger nutritious breakfast.
2:00:00So we go to Google for answers. And, and, and the people who are using it don't know
2:00:07that it's an assistive tool and it's being presented to them as a fait accompli as a,
2:00:11this is your answer. And that's, that is, I think the worst thing about AI right now
2:00:16is that it's being presented by companies as the answer. Yeah. When in fact it's best used
2:00:23as an assistant. Yes. Who is going to bring you things that you scrutinize, but that's,
2:00:29that's a complex message. And a lot of people don't want to scrutinize anything. They just want
2:00:33the answer. Okay. Fair enough. But if you're giving them the wrong answer, you're not solving
2:00:38their problem. You're making their problems worse. And that's where we are with a lot of AI stuff
2:00:43right now. So, so that's why I think, I think there are specific, very good complaints,
2:00:47but I just think like all of AI, I don't believe is like a, just like a good, like it's just an
2:00:53easy thing to say, but we all have our different opinions on this and that's great that we have
2:00:56our different opinions. Okay. So image playground is the winner. Winner. Uh, we'll put the humane
2:01:03AI pin as a runner up. And how did you describe the Google? You had the right of Google AI summaries.
2:01:09Summaries. Yeah. Let's do that as a runner up. So we go to most life-changing hardware. The
2:01:16upgradients voted 3% for the AirPods Pro 2's hearing aid features. Pretty strong. 4% for the
2:01:23Apple vision pro and 12% for the Apple watch. The Apple watch is always up the top of the lists here,
2:01:30which makes sense because if you've just got an Apple watch for the first time,
2:01:33your life just got changed. Right. Like it will save your life. Yeah. Yes.
2:01:36Uh, I'll throw the M4 MacBook pro onto the pot because it changed my life because I'm working
2:01:46in a completely different way now with one computer instead of having two. I'm going to
2:01:50make a case for the vision pro. Okay. Because this is where it should have been, right? This is where
2:01:57this, when you know, before this year began, if you think about what product, what category could
2:02:04the vision pro sit in most life-changing hardware could have been it. So for me, the vision pro has
2:02:10been a huge part of my year, right? Like it's been a dominant thing that has occurred throughout the
2:02:16year. Uh, I traveled to America and had a great trip. I got to meet Tim Cook and Greg Joswiak.
2:02:23Uh, that was pretty fun. Um, and I would say then the product has helped me stay better connected
2:02:30with friends and colleagues, right? Like we spoke about earlier. Um, it's been something which has
2:02:36been very interesting to track. It's been a good story that has been like worth tracking the whole
2:02:41way through the year. Um, it didn't change everything the way that I thought it would,
2:02:47but I think has made a big impact. Um, this is not, I'm not really pushing for this,
2:02:53but this is my kind of like, how I could say that it has been a life-changing piece of hardware this
2:02:59year. Okay. I can go with that. I don't think that the vision pro has changed my life in any way.
2:03:07I think it's got a lot of interesting potential. I like it. I am, I, I, I think it is a great
2:03:14cutting edge piece of Apple hardware that just is basically an experimental piece of hardware now.
2:03:19Um, and fine. That is what it is. Um,
2:03:24I'm, I'm happy to have it in the mix. I'd like to put the MacBook pro in the mix.
2:03:31And I think the AirPods pro two with hearing aid is actually really resonates with me. Like that is
2:03:38kind of what this category is about. Yeah. I'd say these three, I think we could give it to the
2:03:43AirPods pro two. Yeah. Um, I agree. And then have the, the MacBook pro and the vision pro in the
2:03:49mix as the runners up. Yeah. I agree. Because that is, again, it's like, it's not a thing that I need,
2:03:55but I did the hearing test and was really impressed by that. And I hear about how it could
2:04:01be used for people. And I think that is an amazing thing. And, uh, if I ever get to that point, I feel
2:04:08confident and comfortable in knowing that there is, there is already a solution that I have in
2:04:11my pocket that can help me. And she's similar to how I feel about a lot of that health stuff
2:04:16that Apple does is like, I'm just very happy that the products that I already choose to wear and use
2:04:21have these features in them. And so this is just another great example of that. I agree.
2:04:27Uh, favorite tech story. Yeah. Upgradients, uh, 5% of leaving Twitter for Mastodon or blue sky,
2:04:377% Apple ended DMA and 9% Apple vision pro. So I would just say copy and paste what I said
2:04:45about the vision pro into this one too. Cause that is my favorite text story of the year.
2:04:49All right. My favorite tech story of the year is actually the surprise reveal of the M four.
2:04:57Okay. In iPads. When we thought that the M fours would go in computers, you know, like Mac,
2:05:05Macintosh computers. And instead they did this M four reveal with the, yeah, the thin iPad with
2:05:12the great screen, but the fact that they had the M four in there, I think that that was it. It's,
2:05:17I know Mark Gurman kinda kinda broke it slightly early, but like it was still in doubt. Like it
2:05:23seems so unlikely. We didn't think that it was going, even though that Mark was saying,
2:05:27it was like, is this one of the places where he's misunderstood? Right. Cause it didn't seem
2:05:33likely that that was happening. So that was, I think that was my favorite story of the year,
2:05:41although yeah, for some, for some definitions of favorite Apple adapting to the DMA this year was
2:05:50interesting. We talked about that when we talked about Delta. Um, it's not just the DMA, but,
2:05:55you know, reacting to it by doing things like making it emulators allowed and, and all the
2:06:00changes that they've had to make at marketplaces and all of that stuff has been interesting to
2:06:06track and continues. Sure. I don't know if I'd call it favorite though. I know. I'm not sure I
2:06:12would either, to be honest. I think, what do you think? Well, I mean, for me, I think the vision
2:06:20pro it would, would take it here for me. This is the year. This is the year where, I mean,
2:06:24the vision pro was just an announcement last year and this year it was real and we've got the good
2:06:28and the bad about that. So I'm fine with vision pro being the winner. I would like to put the M4
2:06:33reveal as a runner up and what should our other runner up be? We can put the DMA one in, uh, as a
2:06:40runner up because it has been a big story that's gone throughout the year. And I can understand
2:06:45some of the things that have come out of it have been either interesting or good, but also there's
2:06:50just like a lot of, uh, press releases from, uh, institutions that are just upset at each other,
2:06:58which can get, which can drag you down a bit. Yeah. Favorite is, is an interesting word here
2:07:03because the one other one I was going to nominate was, uh, the fall of Intel, but I, I don't
2:07:09consider that a favorite. Right. I think it was a really interesting story. Yeah. Well, I mean,
2:07:14that could go in the next category. Oh boy. I mean, tech screw up over the course of a decade,
2:07:20I guess. Uh, let's, let's put in Apple adapting to the DMA as the runner up. All right. And so we
2:07:30come to our final category in the 11th annual upgrade ease. Favorite tech screw up the upgrade
2:07:38Ian's X at 5%, which is sure. I'm just going to say on that, like, I know what you're saying,
2:07:45but also he got what he wanted. Like, I don't, I don't think he screwed up. Like people left,
2:07:52but I don't think he cares. Uh, I think he's going to lose a lot of money and I don't,
2:07:56I'm not sure he cares about that either because it's doing exactly what he wanted to do, which is
2:08:00feed his ego. Like for me, the, the screw up, I mean, if you want to just say the name of it,
2:08:05yeah, I would agree with that. But like that all of the screw ups had already happened before this
2:08:09year. And this year we saw like he got something out of it. Uh, 13% CrowdStrike update failure that
2:08:17took out the entire world for at least a day. And then at 15% is the humane AI pin. It's back again.
2:08:26It's back again. Okay. Let me, let me contribute to this because I also think the CrowdStrike
2:08:33situation is my favorite screw up of the year. I was on a plane when CrowdStrike happened,
2:08:41landed and got all these texts about, Oh no, are people going to have trouble getting
2:08:48where they need to go for the relay event in the UK? Oh my gosh. Yeah. It's happening then. Yeah.
2:08:53And I was thinking, yeah, no, I was flying to the UK and, and I got to Heathrow and they're like,
2:08:59Oh, you know, w will you even be able to get your continuing flight? Which we did. We had
2:09:03literally no impact on us. But here's the, here's the thing. One of my favorite things in the world
2:09:08is how basic computer technology can completely fail us in ways we don't expect and in ways that
2:09:19we see in the real world. And I'll give you a concrete example, which was, was we were in,
2:09:24I think it was when we were in Denver visiting my brother-in-law this summer,
2:09:32cause they have a new baby. We're driving down the highway. I'm driving and Lauren's looking out the
2:09:39window and she laughs and says, check it out. And I look and it's a giant digital billboard
2:09:45with a DOS boot up error. And first off, she made the absolutely dead right comment, which is
2:09:54if this was the Bay area, I would think this was an ad. Right. Like it's, it's it's and, and,
2:10:01and by the way, if you're somebody who makes digital billboard ads for a tech company,
2:10:06you're an agency, a fake crash of the billboard, that's actually about your company. Brilliant.
2:10:13Do that. Okay. Do that. But this wasn't, this was literally like, I can't read this external device,
2:10:18press F1. I was like, Oh man. And then I was just in an airport, five flights in 10 days. I don't
2:10:22know which airport. And when we were walking, there was a big, I think it was an ad terminal
2:10:27and it was all, um, it was the DOS startup pro. I love it when just a cheap crappy PC thing happens
2:10:35and you see it in the world where you shouldn't, I don't love it necessarily when a dumb software
2:10:41update breaks the entire like world in a way that causes havoc among, especially travelers.
2:10:52And that requires it people to individually manually update their PCs to get them to work.
2:10:59Right. Yep. Um, plus just the, just the fact that it, it's a problem with windows PCs.
2:11:07I mean, okay. Am I as a Mac, a long time Mac user, do I still have enough feeling in my heart that I
2:11:16can delight at the utter failure of a windows PC that's being used in a vital situation because
2:11:23somebody was asleep at the switch when they pulled the software update out there and now nothing can
2:11:26be done. I'm not too small or I'm not too big for that. I am that small. It, it, it actually kind of
2:11:33delights me. It's why, why those DOS prompts delight me when I see them. It's the same thing.
2:11:36It's like, Oh, your PC broke. Oh, that's too bad. Uh, so yeah, I love the CrowdStrike story. That
2:11:42is my, that is a hundred percent my favorite tech screw up of the year. Yeah. It was pretty
2:11:49monumental as a thing. Just like you said, one of those things of like, Oh, this is what Y2K would
2:11:55have been like, like, yeah, this is what people will worry about. This sort of thing. Yeah. Yeah.
2:12:01I saw, there was a story over the weekend that NPR did that made a lot of people on Mastodon very
2:12:05angry for good reasons, which was like, you know, basically it's just overheat or re reheated content
2:12:14for the end of the year where everybody's got time off. And it was like, Hey, remember Y2K?
2:12:19Uh, that obviously written by somebody who does not remember Y2K. Oh, well that amounted to nothing.
2:12:25And everybody was like, it amounted to nothing because we spent tens of thousands of hours
2:12:31fixing all the software in the world so that it would get dates right outside of the 20th century.
2:12:37That's why it amounted to nothing. And yet in people use it as a punchline, like, Oh, Y2K,
2:12:42that turned out to be nothing. It's like, it only turned out to be nothing because everybody fixed
2:12:46all the stupid stuff and CrowdStrike. It would have been like 10 CrowdStrikes if it had actually
2:12:53been left to happen. Yep. So, you know, like it would have been, it would have been much worse
2:13:00than this, but, uh, yeah. Do you have any other nominees here? Apple and the DMA. Apple and the
2:13:06DMA. They screwed up. They're going to keep screwing up and it's going to keep getting worse
2:13:14and it's going to get worse and worse and worse because they screwed up and then they could have
2:13:19taken that time to try and meet these people where they wanted to be met and they've decided not to
2:13:24and instead decided to dig their heels in. And so it's just going to keep getting worse.
2:13:30We've been doing our special episodes, so we haven't had a chance to talk about it yet,
2:13:34but I would fold into this favorite again, not a, not a strong word, but I do appreciate that
2:13:40Apple has tended to have a very aggressive reaction to the DMA and then has had to come and
2:13:45actually do the things that they want anyway. And that I do kind of really enjoy. But,
2:13:50what I will say is one thing that seems to have happened in the last few weeks,
2:13:55that's very interesting, is Apple has once again used the supposedly neutral notarization system
2:14:03for iOS in the EU to issue a blanket rejection of an app submission, which is not supposed to
2:14:13happen. They talked about it a lot on ATP a couple of weeks ago. It's the idea that they say on,
2:14:18I think it's Mini VMac, Mac emulator, on trademark grounds because they own the trademark, they're
2:14:24going to refuse to notarize the app. And I think this is one of those things that first off, like
2:14:30legally, I don't think they can do it. I think that the DMA or that the European commission is
2:14:34going to say, you can't use it this way, but it makes me so angry that they're using their neutral
2:14:41approval system that's supposed to be neutral. All they have to do is sue the Mini VMac developer and
2:14:50say, you're using our trademarks incorrectly. They send an immediate cease and desist,
2:14:53like cease and desist. That's the way you do this. But the fact that they pulled that lever that
2:14:58should never be pulled, that turns the entire supposedly innocent, unbiased, for user safety
2:15:09notarization system and turns it into a de facto approval system, it's the worst. And I would be
2:15:16more angry about it if I didn't think that Apple is going to get smacked down for it, that this is
2:15:22going to be one of those cases where somebody said, let's just use this mechanism to disapprove
2:15:28of this app. And that hopefully somebody at the European commission is going to go, no, that is
2:15:33not what that mechanism is for. Use another mechanism and stop it because really the jig is
2:15:40up. If Apple can use notarization to ban apps in the EU and elsewhere, then what are we even doing
2:15:49here? It's totally counter to the point of it where notarization is the app store approval
2:15:54process and that's not allowed. So anyway, I'm going to file that under Apple's reaction to the
2:15:59DMA here, because I think it's an example of Apple behaving incredibly stupidly and badly
2:16:06when they were better and ruining a thing that they built because they didn't want to do the
2:16:13more logical recourse. And I'm baffled by it, but there it is. Which is my, this is like emblematic.
2:16:20My kind of like favorite text grew up at the year or like it is what I consider to be the biggest,
2:16:26because it is not just one story. It has been an entire year's worth of things that they have
2:16:34over and over and over again, made it worse and like continue to make it worse. And
2:16:42something's going to happen. I don't know what it is. Yeah. Like I have no idea. I have no idea
2:16:50anymore. Either they, you know, get fined into oblivion and will go to court and I don't know
2:16:58what will happen there. Or it's Apple is basically going to strong arm the EU enough that this all
2:17:06falls apart. Like at this point, like I don't know what the result is, but it's not going to be pretty.
2:17:12No, I actually, I'm going to go with you. I think that that should be our winner.
2:17:20Because we are specifically saying that Apple's reaction to what's happening in Europe
2:17:26is a screw up. They're not doing it right. They're not doing it well. And I know there's an argument
2:17:30of like, there's a legal argument. I'm like, well, yeah, but if there's a legal issue,
2:17:35they need to fight it out. Right. And like, I get that, but this goes way beyond that.
2:17:40Some of this behavior goes way beyond that. And we'll put the AI pin as number three.
2:17:45And CrowdStrike of course. CrowdStrike is a jiffy. Yeah. Loses by a hair.
2:17:52So that's it. That is the 11th annual upgrade. We hope that you have enjoyed this episode.
2:17:58Thank you so much for listening to us for yet another year.
2:18:03Happy new year to you all as we get ready to go into 2025.
2:18:07Very excited about what the year will bring for personal reasons and professional reasons.
2:18:13Yes, sure. Happy new year to all upgrade-ians. Thank you so much for listening.
2:18:19If you would like to send us in any questions or follow up to talk about next week's show,
2:18:23please go to upgradefeedback.com and you can do that. You can check out Jason at sixcolors.com,
2:18:28the incomparable.com and here on Relay, where you hear me too. And you can find my work at
2:18:33cortexbrand.com. You can follow us online. We are on Mastodon threads and Blue Sky,
2:18:38and you can find video clips of the show on TikTok, Instagram, and YouTube. We are at Upgrade
2:18:43Relay. Thank you to our members who support us of Upgrade Plus. This week, we're going to talk about
2:18:47my Mac mini. And I think maybe we'll talk about the holidays a little bit. You can go to getupgradeplus.com
2:18:54and sign up. Thank you to Fitbaud, ShareShot, and Data Citizen's Dialogues for their support
2:19:00of this week's episode. But most of all, thank you for listening. Until next time,
2:19:05say goodbye, Jason Snow. Goodbye, Mike Hurley.
2:19:16[ Silence ]