Podcast Search

The Talk Show

418: ‘Putting a Stink on the Letter X’, With Craig Hockenberry

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00I think we should switch over to Skype, for old time's sake.

0:00:03We'd have the distinction of being the last podcast recorded on Skype.

0:00:10Somebody's got to be the last.

0:00:13I thought I was going to be the last.

0:00:15I used it longer than most people, because I'm a creature of habit, and because, I don't

0:00:20know, it just worked, you know what I mean?

0:00:22And it was-

0:00:23Yeah, well, we were the same way.

0:00:24In fact, you talked about it on the website, about how they kind of kick-started the whole

0:00:31podcast industry, but it also, for creative types like us, we used to have our weekly status

0:00:37meetings and stuff on a phone call, and when Skype came around, we just latched onto that,

0:00:42and it was great.

0:00:43And eventually, we moved over to Slack and came up with more modern ways of doing things,

0:00:48but yeah, it was pretty transformative technology.

0:00:52Yeah, I talked about it on Dithering a little, but if anything, I think what I wrote on Daring

0:00:57Fireball, I undersold how much Skype and Skype alone pushed podcasting years ahead of when

0:01:06it would have happened.

0:01:07Like, I don't know how the whole first run or two runs of the talk show, when I was doing

0:01:16it with Dan Benjamin, I really don't know that we could have done it without Skype.

0:01:20I really don't.

0:01:21Certainly not 2006, 2007.

0:01:24Whatever option B was, was terrible.

0:01:27In theory, we could have done something that sounded terrible, and just by relying on our

0:01:34local recordings for double-enders, the show would have sounded all right.

0:01:37But it was something about the fact that the actual Skype quality was so high fidelity and

0:01:43low latency that it made conversation natural.

0:01:47It didn't feel like talking over the internet.

0:01:49That's why we switched from being on phone calls.

0:01:51I had this nice polycom speaker phone.

0:01:54It was like top of the line thing.

0:01:55And once we started using Skype, that thing just sort of sat there and gathered dust because

0:02:01the quality was good enough that you felt like you were in the room with the person having

0:02:05a conversation.

0:02:06Yeah.

0:02:07That's kind of the baseline functionality.

0:02:09Yeah.

0:02:10I remember getting feedback in the early days.

0:02:12Like the very first run of this show was like one of the first podcasts and people were

0:02:19listening and they would be like, I can't believe you guys don't aren't recording together in

0:02:24the same room because that's what it sounds like.

0:02:26And no, we don't even live in the same state.

0:02:28And, you know, it has that feel and everybody takes it for granted now.

0:02:34But the weird thing now, too, is I still hear podcasts occasionally where like one of the

0:02:39guests is obviously not a regular podcaster and they're calling in from a phone or I don't

0:02:47know, like using a really old laptop mic or something and they just sound so tinny.

0:02:53And it's like, yeah, remember when the callers on the radio always sounded like that because

0:02:58they were always on a phone?

0:02:59It has a different vibe.

0:03:01It does not sound like a conversation.

0:03:03It sounds like it sounds like you're talking to somebody on the phone, right?

0:03:06It's a different thing.

0:03:08Your your mental image is that they're out and about, you know, at the shopping mall, having

0:03:13a chat with you while you're doing your podcast or whatever.

0:03:16Right.

0:03:16So anyway, it's a big week.

0:03:18Yeah, we could go in chronological order.

0:03:22I don't have much to say about the new iPads.

0:03:24Do you?

0:03:25I mean, it's no, no, it's the revs.

0:03:30Yeah.

0:03:30And hopefully came across.

0:03:32But, you know, and I know everybody, it's like Apple can't win.

0:03:36Nobody can win because everybody wants everything to be super exciting.

0:03:39And it's I guess what everybody really wants is a fantasy world where every 12 months there

0:03:45is a revolutionary new upgrade to every product.

0:03:49People want to be blown away every 12 months or every 11 months.

0:03:54Blowing away is hard.

0:03:55It's not going to happen in 12 months.

0:03:57Sorry.

0:03:58But in practice, you know, that's just not going to happen.

0:04:02And the truth is, it's not just that it can't happen.

0:04:05I honestly think if you think about it objectively, if you could just had a magic genie and could

0:04:11make it happen, you wouldn't really want it to happen.

0:04:13You don't want unfamiliar new products replacing familiar ones every 12 months.

0:04:18Right.

0:04:18There's right.

0:04:20It's look at the look at the problem.

0:04:23People are having adjusting to Apple intelligence now.

0:04:26Yeah.

0:04:26A lot of things have changed because of that.

0:04:28And some of the things are good.

0:04:29Some of the things are bad.

0:04:30But everybody's having to deal with the change, right?

0:04:33If you did that every 12 months, it would get old pretty quick.

0:04:37So, you know, and so what are the practical alternatives?

0:04:41The practical alternatives are regular speed bumps with occasional major revisions or irregular updates

0:04:50and years-long gaps between updates at all where, because Apple's company-wide longstanding policy

0:04:59is not to comment about future products, everybody's left to wonder,

0:05:03hey, is Apple, like, abandoning the iPad mini or the whatever has?

0:05:08Like keyboards.

0:05:10Yeah, exactly.

0:05:11It's like, well, what's going to happen here?

0:05:14Well, they did try updating those.

0:05:16Remember, they had a couple, like...

0:05:18Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

0:05:19That was, you know...

0:05:20And, yeah, Apple's damned if they do and damned if they don't.

0:05:23And they know that, right?

0:05:25Right.

0:05:26They just roll how they're going to roll.

0:05:28I'm not asking anybody to be super-duper excited about the new M3 iPad Airs.

0:05:36I keep getting mixed up because some of the new products,

0:05:39as we'll get to in a much more interesting topic, M3s mixed with M4s, I keep thinking new, so bigger.

0:05:47And I've had to correct the typo on Daring Fireball at least twice this week,

0:05:51calling the new iPad Airs the M4 iPad Airs, which aren't true.

0:05:55They are new, but they're new with the M3 because they're only the Air, which starts at $600.

0:06:03Yeah, honestly, I only pay attention to that stuff when I need one, right?

0:06:08And if you're one of those people, yeah, you want to hear about this new product announcement

0:06:15and you make your product buy decision and all of that.

0:06:18But if you don't, it's just like, my iPad Air, I'm not even sure which generation it is.

0:06:26It's fine, right?

0:06:27I don't need anything.

0:06:29I'm still using, as my personal iPad, a 2018 iPad Pro 11-inch.

0:06:38And at this point, it is long in the tooth.

0:06:41I'm actually wondering, but I also have sort of found myself, the less I use an iPad, the

0:06:49more productive I am, that I should either be somewhere out and about, and if I need to

0:06:55do anything, use my phone, or I should sit my ass down at my desk at my Mac and work.

0:07:00And for me, trying to quote-unquote work, even if it's like, I think, well, you know what I

0:07:06need to do?

0:07:07I just need to catch up on email.

0:07:08I haven't gone through my inbox in days.

0:07:11I should just do that.

0:07:12I could do that on my iPad.

0:07:13But then it's like somebody sends me a link, and the link I open in a browser.

0:07:17And then I'm thinking, maybe I should link to that from Daring Fireball.

0:07:21And now I'm trying to post something to Daring Fireball from my iPad, which I can do, but

0:07:27none of it is like, click, click, click, all my shortcuts.

0:07:31Yeah, you don't have all your macros and automations.

0:07:34Right.

0:07:34You're just not set up to...

0:07:38Right.

0:07:38And next thing I know, instead of being 10 in the morning, it's 1.30 in the afternoon,

0:07:45and I still haven't posted the thing.

0:07:46And it's, what am I doing?

0:07:47Why am I not at my desk?

0:07:49But at this point, a 2018 iPad, it's like noticeably slow.

0:07:53I don't know.

0:07:54I'm curious if I just do the factory reset and restore from backup, if that clears it up.

0:07:59Because I don't know that I've ever used...

0:08:01Probably not.

0:08:02I don't think so.

0:08:03But I don't think so.

0:08:04But it's curious to me how slow it feels.

0:08:07Like, it feels like maybe I have run into the...

0:08:11I think Apple's done such a better job with this over the years.

0:08:14But I think at this point, they're not really testing iPadOS 18 on 2018-era hardware.

0:08:21Oh, yeah.

0:08:22No.

0:08:23Yeah.

0:08:23And...

0:08:24You see, well, it's kind of across the board, right?

0:08:28The older versions of Mac...

0:08:29Or older Macs with new versions of Mac OS is where you tend to see the problems.

0:08:35Yeah.

0:08:35And I can...

0:08:36I'm not trying to diagnose engineering problems just by using it.

0:08:41But you can kind of smell or just use the force that this 2018 iPad Pro doesn't have enough RAM.

0:08:49It's just RAM.

0:08:50Because I notice I'll just be using Safari and not even switching apps.

0:08:55And all of a sudden, tabs will reload.

0:08:57And it's like...

0:08:58Or you do something in Safari, you go back to the other app, and it's launching from...

0:09:04Back to a blank screen.

0:09:06Right.

0:09:06Yeah.

0:09:07So...

0:09:08So, yeah.

0:09:09But, you know...

0:09:10I guess the other thing I'll just say about the speed bumps, though, is it is interesting...

0:09:14A little interesting to me...

0:09:15Because I think what Apple naturally wants is a 12-month cadence to everything.

0:09:20The human beings run on an annual cycle.

0:09:24The planet does.

0:09:26It's very natural.

0:09:28The iPhone has always been very predictably annual.

0:09:33At this point, I think...

0:09:37Again, I'm not going to speak for Tim Cook, but I honestly think that if they weren't planning to release iPhone 17s in September, they would need to actually, like, somehow warn the world.

0:09:50Issues, you know, do some kind of...

0:09:52They'd have to warn their suppliers.

0:09:54Right.

0:09:55The whole machine is just set up to just crank these things out every 12 months.

0:10:01Right.

0:10:01And they've done it.

0:10:03Even remarkably so, kept it pretty much on schedule during 2020 and even 2021 with COVID.

0:10:12And then the year after COVID, yeah, the whole supply chain had lurched and the world had sort of stopped for months.

0:10:19And some of the phones came out in October or something, but they were able to announce everything in September.

0:10:24But, like, the Mac in the Intel era would go through years-long gaps.

0:10:30And everybody's like, what the hell?

0:10:31Remember the long, long wait for a Retina MacBook Air?

0:10:35Yeah.

0:10:36To the point...

0:10:38Well, again, there was another company calling the shots there.

0:10:40Yeah.

0:10:41Yeah.

0:10:41Exactly.

0:10:42They couldn't build the Retina MacBook Air that they wanted to with the chips that were available from Intel.

0:10:49The Mac Pro, famously, with the trash can design, they had to do the weird, call a couple of us in, me and Panzerino and...

0:11:00Yeah, yeah.

0:11:01I remember that round table thing.

0:11:03Diener Fried, and I forget who else was there, and do a, okay, we sort of screwed up the Pro hardware, but we mean it.

0:11:09We're going to come out with a...

0:11:12We're not going to say it's a new Mac Pro here, but we're going to come out with new Mac Pro hardware.

0:11:17And we're even going to come out with a Pro iMac.

0:11:21And I remember asking, is it going to be called the iMac Pro?

0:11:26And Federighi looked at Schiller, and Schiller just gave him a look, and they're like, it's going to be a Pro-targeted iMac.

0:11:33It was like, no, we're not going to tell you the name.

0:11:36Was it the iMac Pro at that point, or were they thinking about the studio that early?

0:11:41No, no, it was the iMac Pro, because they weren't going to hint at Apple Silicon.

0:11:45It was like 2017 when they had that?

0:11:48Oh, that's right, right, right, right.

0:11:51Because, yeah, and then the new Mac Pro came out with all the Xenon.

0:11:55Right.

0:11:56In 2019, right.

0:11:57But they'd go through those gaps.

0:11:59And then even when they did come out with the first Retina MacBook Pro in that era, and it was Retina, but then it was stuck where it was for years, because they didn't have any new chips from Intel to move it forward.

0:12:13So I think getting to an annual cycle is what they want for almost everything.

0:12:19And it seems like now, in addition to the phones, the MacBooks are very, very predictable.

0:12:25It's down to like the same time of October, right around Halloween, right?

0:12:29And they had a Halloween-themed virtual event two years ago for the M3 Pro and Macs, MacBook Pros.

0:12:38And then this year's, they didn't have a Halloween theme, but it was October 30th where they announced them.

0:12:43It seems like they want the MacBook Airs to come out around now, which they did this week.

0:12:50We'll get to them next.

0:12:51The iPad still is the one, it's like the middle child of the family, right?

0:12:56It's like the iPhone is the star, and the iPhone gets September, hell or high water.

0:13:01If we have to drop other products, we're coming out with an iPhone in September.

0:13:04The Mac seems to be the second favorite, and it's like especially MacBook Pros and especially MacBook Airs.

0:13:11MacBooks are the main Macs, and they're very, very predictable at this point, or have been for two or three generations.

0:13:18And iPads are still sort of like, well, not every year.

0:13:24Well, I think it goes to show, at least in Apple's mind, the relative importance of those platforms, right?

0:13:31The mobile, super important.

0:13:33Right.

0:13:34The desktop, super important.

0:13:36I mean, everybody doing development at Apple or any other kind of work has got a Mac, right?

0:13:44You need them.

0:13:45Yeah, but I think the difference, though, is that the Mac market really needs new Macs.

0:13:51So many people need, if they can make a buying decision based on something that's vaguely predictable, they might hold off because they know.

0:14:00You know, like somebody in January, just two months ago, who kind of needed a new MacBook Air, probably if you did any kind of research, you'd probably figure out you should wait.

0:14:11And that's good.

0:14:11Right.

0:14:12It's kind of good that people have a sense.

0:14:13And if you're like, I don't care.

0:14:15I really don't care.

0:14:16If you read the Mac rumors page and it said it's expected that it's going to be just like the M3 MacBook Air, except with an M4, which is the truth.

0:14:25That's what they just announced two days ago.

0:14:27And if you're like, what do I care?

0:14:29Who buys a phone in August?

0:14:32Right.

0:14:33I know.

0:14:33I do wonder.

0:14:34And there are got to be people out there, and they're probably the people that are like, they're going to be happy with the 16e, right?

0:14:42Yeah.

0:14:42It's just like, okay, I just need a phone.

0:14:44My old one broke.

0:14:45I need a new phone.

0:14:46Yeah.

0:14:48I do think, but what I think is a little interesting about these new iPad Airs that just came out this week with the M3 is that the M2 ones only came out in May last year, which is now it's under a year where they've gone from the M2 to the M3.

0:15:02I think once Apple's under a year, that's like when they're really rolling.

0:15:07That's a sign that all gears are turning internally, and chip yields are high, and margins are good.

0:15:16And sure, let's just...

0:15:18That's a huge part of the equation right there, right?

0:15:21Yeah.

0:15:21The fact that they have all the chips kind of aligned, and they can bin some and throw them in these products, and they've got that whole machine just cranking components out.

0:15:34And then they can distribute the components as they need.

0:15:38Yeah, and there's obviously some binning involved because with the M3 MacBooks, it's like there were eight core models at the entry level, but most of the configurations were 10 core GPUs.

0:15:53And now these iPads all have nine core GPUs.

0:15:57And I guess that's just how binning works, that some percentage of hopefully 10 core GPUs only have nine that are good, and so they put them in a pile and save them for iPads.

0:16:12I do have to wonder, and I feel like this is the sort of thing we'll never find out because it's like the people who know at Apple are like in a sanctum.

0:16:23But if it is binning, not purposeful making nine core GPUs to save some amount of money, does that mean there are iPads out there that could have functional 10 core GPUs where one is just disabled?

0:16:39Right.

0:16:41Yeah, exactly.

0:16:43Is this a software disable, right?

0:16:46I think it would have to be...

0:16:48I don't even know how they disable them.

0:16:51I don't know either.

0:16:51Say you have a chip that has 10 supposed core slots in it.

0:16:56How do you pick which of the nine to use?

0:17:01Is there like somebody in there with a tiny little soldering iron going, no, this one's no good anymore.

0:17:07I don't know.

0:17:08And I've tried to see if anybody, like there are some good, like Tom's hardware, it's just sort of a layperson's what is binning.

0:17:16And basically it's just the high level.

0:17:19Conceptually, it's a very easy thing, but I bet in practice it's a lot more complicated than it appears.

0:17:25Right.

0:17:25And how clear is it that all 10 cores are up to snuff?

0:17:29And is that really why if you take two identical, it doesn't matter which product, but you take two brand new iPad Airs this week, just go to the hour next week, I guess, when they come out.

0:17:43Same configuration, 128 gigs of storage, same price, open them up at the same time, turn them on at the same time, put them on the same Wi-Fi network right there in the Apple store and run Geekbench at the same time.

0:17:57You'll get like a slightly different score.

0:18:00You'll get like 3,257 and 3,248.

0:18:07I don't, you know, it's like, there's like a margin of error there.

0:18:09Why?

0:18:11Right?

0:18:12Is that because the chips aren't?

0:18:14You've got a new conspiracy theory.

0:18:15No, it's not a conspiracy, but it's, you know, and it's like, it could be that.

0:18:22It's physics, John.

0:18:23It's just the electrons are moving around a little bit differently.

0:18:26Yeah, I guess.

0:18:27But is that sort of how it goes and they're running something like that and one of the CPU cores is coming up low or is it like totally bum?

0:18:36I don't know.

0:18:37Nobody, there's no, it seems.

0:18:38Yeah.

0:18:39Again, it goes back to how do you determine that one of those things is bad, right?

0:18:43You've got to run some sort of test, right?

0:18:45Right.

0:18:45And what is that, right?

0:18:47And you've got to do that test pretty quickly because you've got a lot of these chips to go through, right?

0:18:52Right.

0:18:52They make a new iPhone every second, let's say.

0:18:56Yeah.

0:18:57Right?

0:18:57Something like that.

0:18:58You've got to test that new CPU in under a second.

0:19:00Yeah.

0:19:01Well, I don't know.

0:19:03If anybody out there really knows the answer and has the nitty gritty answer, somebody out there definitely knows it.

0:19:07If somebody out there is listening and knows a really good answer and wants to give it to me in confidence, I'm all ears.

0:19:13Hit me up on Signal.

0:19:14I don't know if Apple is an expert on this.

0:19:16Yeah.

0:19:16I would love to know the nitty gritty details of how Apple or anybody determines, okay, this M3 is only nine GPU cores.

0:19:25It is curious to me that the CPU cores aren't binned.

0:19:29They're all exactly the same.

0:19:30I forget what the number is, but it seems like GPU cores are more, I don't know, delicate, finicky, precise.

0:19:37Easier to do without?

0:19:38Maybe.

0:19:39I don't know.

0:19:40But I think one of the things that the CPU can't be binned is because you've got the performance and the efficiency cores.

0:19:49So you're basically splitting your odds.

0:19:50Yeah.

0:19:51Yeah.

0:19:51Right.

0:19:52Right.

0:19:52You got four and four.

0:19:54You can't go with, okay, you got three performance cores, not four, right?

0:19:57That would be weird.

0:19:59Yeah.

0:19:59So, whereas GPU, you've got 20 of them.

0:20:03No, no, you only got 18.

0:20:04In my mind, especially just talking it out with you here, Craig, I've got in mind that CPU cores are like what we think computers are like.

0:20:16It is binary, right?

0:20:17It's like here's the CPU, here's the test, pass or fail.

0:20:21And it's like an exact, it's just like a one or a zero.

0:20:26It comes out, yes, all 10 cores are good, good to go.

0:20:29Or no, one of the CPU cores is not good, thumbs down, absolutely out.

0:20:34I feel like with GPU cores, it's more like picking produce, right?

0:20:38You're at the store.

0:20:39Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

0:20:42Oh, that tomato's a little green.

0:20:43No, no problem with that one.

0:20:45Well, that apple's got a little blemish on it.

0:20:47Yeah, or picking avocados, right?

0:20:50And it's like, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, you got to squeeze it.

0:20:52Yeah, yeah, you want a little bit of give because if it's like a baseball, if it's hard as a baseball, it needs a couple more days.

0:21:02And if you're planning to make guacamole for company tonight, I got good at this.

0:21:09One of the worst feelings is you go to get the avocado out of the place where you've been letting it right.

0:21:14You grab it and your fingers just kind of sink into it.

0:21:17Oh, right.

0:21:20So I learned if avocados come to mind because I have learned we're a big avocado house here that you kind of want them good to go right now.

0:21:30You know, if Amy says we need four avocados to make guacamole for the family, I want four that have a little give but aren't soft so that she could use them right now.

0:21:40Because if I buy really hard ones thinking, hey, we'll use these in the next couple of days, right?

0:21:46We'll figure out something to do with them.

0:21:48Like you said, all of a sudden you're like, hey, I wonder how those avocados are doing.

0:21:52Yeah.

0:21:53And it's great disappointment.

0:21:55It's just like, oh.

0:21:57And I'm like making tacos or something, right?

0:22:00You're thinking, oh, that avocado is going to be great on the taco.

0:22:03You're going to grab it and say, no, it's going to be an oily brown mess.

0:22:08Yeah, a mess.

0:22:09You know what I mean?

0:22:11Unlike bananas, which you can truly just eyeball as they age.

0:22:17And I actually like bananas that are a little bit past their due date.

0:22:20But you can really just eyeball it from across.

0:22:24It's like I can tell how it's going to feel and how it's going to taste just by looking at the peel.

0:22:29But avocados, you've got to pick up.

0:22:31I feel like GPU cores are like that.

0:22:34And they're like, yeah, this one core is no good.

0:22:37This expert at Apple is going to get in contact and go, yeah, they're exactly like avocados.

0:22:44The other interesting bit of iPad news is that the regular iPad, the one with no adjective and the $350 starting price,

0:22:53it gets the A16 chip, which doesn't support Apple intelligence.

0:22:58So I don't think that's surprising given the low price.

0:23:02Our friend Mark Gurman said it was going to have the A17 Pro so that it would have Apple intelligence.

0:23:08And that wasn't right.

0:23:09I don't really think this is a big deal.

0:23:13But I bet it almost certainly is the last device Apple's ever going to make that doesn't have Apple intelligence, right?

0:23:20Because if the iPhone 16e did, then they're not going to make another iPhone that's under the 16e performance-wise ever.

0:23:30Basically, all the Macs are now, too.

0:23:33So it's just, yeah.

0:23:35Right.

0:23:35They've remarkably qualified the Macs all the way back to the original M1s, some of which only have 8 gigs of RAM.

0:23:44Like, I honestly, I don't hear people complaining.

0:23:46It's that memory that's the key, right?

0:23:49These models need a big chunk of memory to do their work.

0:23:53Right.

0:23:53And there's been a side benefit for everybody, isn't it?

0:23:56You're getting more memory in your devices now.

0:24:00Because you may not be using Apple intelligence, but you still have a benefit from it.

0:24:04Yeah.

0:24:05Yeah.

0:24:05And we've talked about it, and other podcasts have talked about it at length, that you can chart Apple's base RAM over time.

0:24:15And it actually, the slope of the curve, or whatever, the line, changes dramatically when Tim Cook becomes CEO.

0:24:23I mean, and, you know, the buck stops there.

0:24:25And it is a Tim Cook-type thing.

0:24:27It's a margin thing.

0:24:28But you can definitely see that even before jobs came back, even if you go through the early 90s, there was, like, a sort of slope to the curve.

0:24:40It was a steady increase.

0:24:40Yeah, yeah.

0:24:41There was just kind of a year over year, maybe not, but over a decade, you could see a trend.

0:24:48Yeah.

0:24:49My 1991 Mac LC had four megabytes of RAM.

0:24:54Megabytes.

0:24:55I held out for the fat Mac.

0:25:00I didn't want the one with 256 kilobytes of memory.

0:25:04I was the one with 512.

0:25:06Man, that was sweet.

0:25:09I think it was, I think the first one was 128.

0:25:11I don't think, I don't think they had a 256.

0:25:13Oh, yeah, we're right.

0:25:14Yeah, it was, it was, yeah, it was, it was four times as much, man.

0:25:17Yeah, yeah.

0:25:18That was awesome.

0:25:19Kilobytes.

0:25:21And it's a credit to those original developers that they got the thing to work in 128 kilobytes of memory.

0:25:27It's really amazing if you think about it, that they had a GUI with multiple windows and all the things, as limited as the original Mac was by any reasonable today's standards, it's absolutely amazing that all of that worked with 128 kilobytes.

0:25:46I still remember, I know it's a site, but one of my, the whole thing is remarkable, but Andy Hertzfeld's folklore.org website, here, I'll put a note in the show notes, and then the book version, what was it called?

0:25:59Revolution in the Valley.

0:26:00Can't believe I remember that.

0:26:02Yeah, both are great, yeah.

0:26:04So many great stories, and again, it's sort of sad that it doesn't seem like that sort of thing is going to come out for the iPhone or anything after, the sort of code of silence is deeper now.

0:26:17Yeah, I think Ken Koshinda's book is part of the way we're going to get.

0:26:21But one of my favorite stories from Hertzfeld's folklore.org website and Revolution in the Valley book was when they first showed Bill Gates a prototype Mac.

0:26:32Do you remember this story?

0:26:34I know you've read it, but they showed, and I think Andy Hertzfeld was the guy who showed it to him, and Jobs had told him, don't tell him any secrets.

0:26:42Show him the Mac, because we want Microsoft to build some apps for it, but don't tell him anything.

0:26:50Press him, but don't give anything away.

0:26:52Right, and it's like, imagine pleasing, especially young, more irascible Steve Jobs at the time.

0:27:00And Bill Gates as well, right?

0:27:03Yeah, the thing Gates was obsessed about was the mouse cursor on screen, that it didn't leave trails, and that, because he knew, because Gates was super, Gates, Bill Gates was a really good programmer by all accounts, like really, really super talented as a programmer, and really knew.

0:27:20Good architect.

0:27:20Yeah, and knew how computers worked, and knew, especially in that era, the things that should be possible and impossible, and the things that should be slow or fast.

0:27:31And one of the things that seemed like it should be impossible was a mouse pointer moving on screen without leaving trails behind it, or stuttering.

0:27:45Like, the refresh rate seemed too high.

0:27:47And it was just that they were that clever.

0:27:49And I think he, like, accused Hertzfeld of that, you guys have a hardware, like a whole hardware card just for the mouse, right?

0:27:56And he was like, no.

0:27:57And Hertzfeld wanted to do it.

0:27:59No, we just have Bill Atkinson, that's all.

0:28:01I hope I'm not misremembering this story too bad, but it's really fantastic.

0:28:07He really wanted to explain how they did it, but he knew Jobs had told him, don't tell him how we did anything.

0:28:12And if you remember, the early versions of Windows, the mouse pointer moved like shit.

0:28:16I mean, it was horrible.

0:28:18It was a really hard thing.

0:28:20Somehow they did it in 128 kilobytes of memory.

0:28:24Well, now we have more memory, but not enough for the iPad.

0:28:27I had to think back.

0:28:29Was it kilobytes or megabytes, right?

0:28:31Yeah, kilobytes.

0:28:32It was kilobytes, yeah.

0:28:33Yeah, and you start to question yourself.

0:28:35You're like, well, that's impossible.

0:28:36How could you write a whole graphical user interface?

0:28:39That's less than the thumb drive I've got sitting on my desk.

0:28:42Right.

0:28:43Like, how does that work?

0:28:44Right.

0:28:46But then you start to realize things like why into the 90s there was still, like, a default text editing field in the Mac toolbox that only supported...

0:28:5732 kilobytes of text, I think was the limit, right, of the...

0:29:01Yeah, yeah, something like that.

0:29:03But there were all sorts of apps and text fields in apps that if you pasted more than 32 kilobytes of text and the text was eight, each character was just one byte because that's how text was encoded back then.

0:29:1832,000 characters.

0:29:20If you get to 32,000 and then one...

0:29:25You know, if we're going to go back in time and reminisce about this stuff, remember having to set the memory limits on apps as well?

0:29:31Oh, yeah, of course.

0:29:31It's like, oh, yeah, yeah.

0:29:32This app can't use more than 50 kilobytes of memory.

0:29:37It doesn't make sense now, and it doesn't make sense to people today, but at the time when you had a machine that only had four megabytes of memory, which, again, in 1991, four megabytes seemed pretty generous from the eyes of somebody thinking with a 1989 computer.

0:29:58And then by 1993, it seemed way too little.

0:30:01But if you only had a very limited amount of RAM and you wanted to run three apps at the same time, being able to specify, well, this app is limited to 1.5 megabytes of RAM.

0:30:13That's it.

0:30:13You don't get any more.

0:30:15And then you just get the app would test, is there a memory available for me to do this?

0:30:21Yes or no?

0:30:22Yes.

0:30:23Okay, I'll do it.

0:30:24And if the answer was no, then show the user the error out of memory.

0:30:28Right, or crash.

0:30:30Yeah, or crash.

0:30:31Because a lot of apps didn't do the test.

0:30:34Yeah, exactly.

0:30:34It was extra work.

0:30:36And this will never break.

0:30:39Right.

0:30:39Oh.

0:30:41Yeah, I mean, that was one of the reasons why, you know, preemptive multitasking and memory managing virtual memory and stuff like that were so important with apps.

0:30:51What comes around goes around, you know.

0:30:53And there was this sweet decade for Tim Cook where he could be really miserly with the default RAM configs.

0:31:01And every one of those devices with 8 megabytes of RAM for Macs or whatever the 4 megabytes or 2 or 3 or whatever older iPhones had, they could make…

0:31:11Well, I think, look at the iPhone.

0:31:13You don't know how much memory is in an iPhone.

0:31:14You can figure it out.

0:31:16Right.

0:31:17You don't know.

0:31:18Right.

0:31:19There's no thing on Apple's website that says, oh, the iPhone 16 Pro has X gigabytes.

0:31:26Right.

0:31:26It just doesn't exist.

0:31:28And they got away with…

0:31:30It doesn't need to either.

0:31:31Really.

0:31:31People are interested more in what can it do.

0:31:34Yeah.

0:31:34But it came to bite them with this Apple intelligence.

0:31:38Yeah.

0:31:39And again, I know people out there, users are like, ah, it's not that big a deal.

0:31:44I don't like it.

0:31:45It's not good.

0:31:46The image generation playground thing doesn't make good images.

0:31:50You can get better ones from elsewhere.

0:31:51But Apple obviously thinks it's important.

0:31:53They're the ones who are touting it in advertisements.

0:31:57They seem to think, and they'd be the ones to know that if actual customers are coming into

0:32:01stores and saying, I'm curious about this Apple intelligence thing I keep hearing about.

0:32:05I want to buy a new device that does it.

0:32:08They might know.

0:32:09But they're the ones who are paying the price with all these zillions of iPads out there and now older iPhones that people spend a lot of money on, like iPhone 14s or an iPhone 15 not Pro, which is not old.

0:32:25That came out a year and a half ago.

0:32:27It doesn't run Apple intelligence because of the RAM and it doesn't have more RAM because margins.

0:32:33That's Apple.

0:32:34That's on Apple.

0:32:35They've made the break, right?

0:32:37They're moving forward.

0:32:38Right.

0:32:39And I think that's all you can ask of them, right?

0:32:41Yeah.

0:32:42And we're at a point now, I think, where we're early days with this whole AI stuff, right?

0:32:51A lot of it, like image playgrounds, is a solution in looking for a problem, right?

0:32:55I don't feel the need to go in and use image playgrounds.

0:33:00But at the same time, there are stuff emerging like summarization, like better Siri recognition is hopefully down the line.

0:33:10That kind of thing is going to be really important to people.

0:33:14Yeah.

0:33:14And you've got to take it back to the old how Apple rolls thing that you wrote however many years ago, right?

0:33:20Yeah.

0:33:20They've started the role with Apple intelligence.

0:33:24Yeah.

0:33:25And we're going to see where that goes, and it's going to not be the next 12 months that it happens.

0:33:31It's going to be the next decade that happens.

0:33:33Yeah.

0:33:33Yeah.

0:33:34And think about Maps, right?

0:33:36It's the first version of Maps came out, and they kind of had to launch it when they did for reasons with licensing.

0:33:42It was rough.

0:33:42But it clearly wasn't ready, and it was what it was, and it got a bad rap, and then like a year later, people would be like,

0:33:51it still stinks, and with very, very concrete side-by-side, here's if I ask for directions from this point A to this point B in Google Maps,

0:33:59and I do the same thing in Apple Maps, here's how much better Google Maps is than Apple Maps.

0:34:06And it was like, yeah, that's night and day.

0:34:07Or here's places where the drive-by real terrain view from Apple Maps still shows bridges that look like they melted in half and other glitches.

0:34:19But everything was perfect in San Francisco.

0:34:22Right, right.

0:34:23Everything looked great in San Francisco.

0:34:25It really did.

0:34:26If you just didn't go any further than like two or three dollars of gas.

0:34:31If you want a great Apple experience, move to San Francisco.

0:34:34Like two or three gallons of gas drive around that range, it was really good.

0:34:40But here we are.

0:34:41And so those impressions matter.

0:34:43And I think it's going to happen with Apple Intelligence, where people are forming this negative impression of Apple Intelligence based on where it stands right now.

0:34:53And it is going to get significantly better.

0:34:57And people will still think they'll have Apple Intelligence filed away in their head as, oh, that's a thing that stinks, even after it gets good.

0:35:05Apple Maps is definitely a prime example of that.

0:35:08Oh, it's what we use now, right?

0:35:09It's not going anywhere.

0:35:10It's the default.

0:35:11Yeah.

0:35:12It's better, in my opinion.

0:35:13It used to be that Google Maps was the default.

0:35:15And then, God, the UI, they just started throwing shit here and there.

0:35:18And it's like it just became hard to deal with.

0:35:22You had to navigate the navigation.

0:35:24Yeah.

0:35:25Which is, that's not a good state to be in.

0:35:27I find the app itself to be confusing user interface wise and the actual results to be cluttered with ads.

0:35:34And I've read rumors, you know, there's rumors that Apple is going to start selling ads or more ads for locations in Apple Maps.

0:35:42So, I'm not saying it's always going to be the way it is now.

0:35:45But the clutter, both UI-wise and content-wise in Google Maps, to me, it's actually flipped.

0:35:52But it's amazing to me how those impressions stick, where so many people just sort of form an impression.

0:35:59Google Maps better, Apple Maps worse.

0:36:02And 10 years later, it could be very, very different, but they still have those impressions.

0:36:05But I do think it's true, though, that Apple, and it is, it's the way Apple markets with, I don't know what the word is, integrity?

0:36:14Like when they say you have Apple Intelligence, they're going to keep supporting Apple Intelligence on that device going forward as Apple Intelligence improves, right?

0:36:22That's part of why they cut off so many iPhones, you know, like the iPhone 15 or all iPhone 14s, including the iPhone 14 Pro.

0:36:31Like, you just don't get it.

0:36:33Because it's not just that those phones aren't going to give a good experience this year with a limited subset of the Apple Intelligence features available now.

0:36:44It's about the fact that they don't want to be building, targeting that low RAM constraint next year, the next year, 2027, 2028.

0:36:52You might see some segmentation in the future there, right?

0:36:57Yeah, I could see a case where, you know, you're able to run some models in older devices and newer models and newer devices, just because of, again, purely because of the RAM requirements.

0:37:13Yeah.

0:37:13All right, let me.

0:37:14Yeah.

0:37:15Like I said, we're in early days there, and we'll see what happens.

0:37:20Yeah.

0:37:20All right, I'm going to take a break here for a very unusual sponsored message.

0:37:24Okay, this episode of the talk show is exclusively sponsored by Google Gemini, Google's AI assistant app that's available for download on iOS and Android.

0:37:34Their ask for this read was simply for me to record some actual conversations about actual questions I had, my interaction, my actual conversations with Gemini, and play them for you.

0:37:45So this is me talking to Gemini, the free version that's available to everyone, and our actual conversation response times aren't shortened.

0:37:53Hey, Gemini, what's your best recipe for a grilled cheese sandwich?

0:37:58All right, since you asked so nicely, here's my take on the perfect grilled cheese.

0:38:04First, the bread sourdough is my favorite for grilled cheese.

0:38:07It has a nice tang that plays well with the melted cheese.

0:38:11Next, the cheese, you can't go wrong with a classic sharp cheddar, but if you want to get fancy, try adding some Gruyere or Havarti.

0:38:17And finally, the cook.

0:38:19Use a little mayo instead of butter on the outside of the bread.

0:38:22It helps the bread get crispy and adds a little tang.

0:38:26All right, I'm going to stop you right there.

0:38:28My wife hates mayonnaise.

0:38:32Here's another way to get that perfect grilled cheese.

0:38:34You could try using a little olive oil instead.

0:38:36It adds a nice richness and helps the bread get crispy.

0:38:39Or, if you want to keep it simple, just use a little extra butter.

0:38:43You could also try grilling the sandwich in a panini press.

0:38:46If you've got one, it gets that perfect golden crust with the melted cheese on the inside.

0:38:49All right, let's wade into something controversial.

0:38:55What is your recipe for a martini?

0:38:58All right, let's get fancy.

0:39:01Now, a classic martini is a pretty simple drink, but there's a whole world of debate about what goes in it.

0:39:06Some purists say it's just gin and vermouth, with maybe a twist of lemon.

0:39:10Others like to get creative with olives, dirty or extra dirty, or even a splash of orange bitters.

0:39:16So, I'm curious, what's your take on the perfect martini?

0:39:18Well, I got to tell you, I'm a Vesper man.

0:39:22Do you know a recipe for a Vesper?

0:39:25Of course, the Vesper is a classic.

0:39:27It's a little different from your standard martini.

0:39:29You'll need gin, vodka, and Lilet Blanc.

0:39:32Shake it all together with some ice and strain it into a chilled glass.

0:39:36And for a finishing touch, add a lemon peel.

0:39:39Well, what are the portions of gin to vodka to the Lilet Blanc?

0:39:45The classic Vesper calls for three measures of gin, one measure of vodka, and half a measure of Lilet Blanc.

0:39:52That's straight from Ian Fleming's book, Casino Royale.

0:39:55You could adjust it a little to your taste, but that's the original recipe.

0:39:59And you shake it, not stir.

0:40:01Correct.

0:40:03Shaken.

0:40:04Not stirred.

0:40:05Though, if you want to get technical, James Bond actually asks for it shaken and strained.

0:40:09That extra step removes any ice chips that might sneak into your drink.

0:40:14Okay, there we go.

0:40:15End of discussion with Gemini.

0:40:17That was fun.

0:40:18Really natural.

0:40:19My thanks again to Gemini.

0:40:20It's really impressive.

0:40:21The way you can just interrupt it, break it off, take it in a new direction.

0:40:25Just, you know, it's just natural conversation style.

0:40:29Gemini is a free download, free to use for both iOS and Android.

0:40:33And all they want you to do is download it and give it a try.

0:40:35My thanks to Gemini.

0:40:37All right, well, that was fun.

0:40:38It really was fun, I have to say.

0:40:42Yeah.

0:40:42Yeah.

0:40:43Interesting.

0:40:43I never really thought I'd be talking to robots on my podcast, but I suspect in the future I'll be doing more.

0:40:52How do you know that I'm not a robot, John?

0:40:55You know, I've had my doubts for years.

0:40:59I'm a highly intelligent being.

0:41:00The other news was the MacBook Air this week came out.

0:41:07Again, a pure speed bump.

0:41:09Went from the M2 to the M3.

0:41:11They added a new color, sky blue, which seems nice, but I haven't seen in person because they didn't.

0:41:19Well, it replaced the space gray one.

0:41:21Yeah, yeah.

0:41:22Which I think is actually, you know.

0:41:25That's the right move.

0:41:26Yeah.

0:41:27You don't need two black ones, right?

0:41:29You got the midnight one.

0:41:30Yeah.

0:41:30Well, and the space gray was never really dark enough, right?

0:41:36It was, I think, for a couple of years there.

0:41:39Just the dark silver.

0:41:39Yeah.

0:41:40It really was sort of like, my son even said it at one point a couple years ago.

0:41:46Like, he'd forgotten whether his was silver or space gray because it was just sort of like this medium gray.

0:41:52And then you'd see an actual silver one and be like, oh, that is a lot lighter.

0:41:55I don't know.

0:41:56As a general rule of thumb, designing anything, it's always better to go to one extreme or almost always better to go to one extreme or the other.

0:42:05If you're going to go dark, go really dark.

0:42:07If you're going to go light, go really light.

0:42:10And maybe, you know, there are obviously there's a whole middle range in between, and maybe that's wrong, but at least as a starting point, that's good to go.

0:42:16And if you're only going to offer two grays, having silver gray and slightly darker silver gray is, I don't know.

0:42:26Yeah, commit to it.

0:42:27Commit to it.

0:42:28The midnight one, they committed to it, right?

0:42:31Yeah.

0:42:31So, like, it's dark enough to get fingerprints on it.

0:42:33Yeah.

0:42:33That's a good thing, right?

0:42:35Yeah, yeah.

0:42:35If you want a dark MacBook, there you go.

0:42:38Yeah.

0:42:39And now they've got this sky blue, which seems like a nice idea.

0:42:43I like the idea of a blue laptop.

0:42:44Yeah.

0:42:45They've been hesitant for reasons they will not explain to just do colors, right?

0:42:51Oh, man.

0:42:52Yeah.

0:42:53I know.

0:42:54And people complain.

0:42:55Especially with the Air.

0:42:56Especially with the Air.

0:42:57The Air is like the iMac, right?

0:42:58It's like the everybody device.

0:43:01Yeah.

0:43:02Just give me a, I'd love, like, an orange MacBook Air.

0:43:06Yeah.

0:43:06You'd think so?

0:43:07I'd probably, I'd go replace the one I've got with, just to get the orange MacBook Air, right?

0:43:12And I'm looking at a MacBook Air right now, as I'm talking to you, this is what I'm using

0:43:18to record the show, and it's the screen, you don't really see the color.

0:43:21So, if it was, like, your sweater that I see you wearing, which is sort of a brick orange,

0:43:28right?

0:43:28I wouldn't really see brick orange around my display, right?

0:43:32Right.

0:43:33You'd see the black bezel.

0:43:35It would be on my palm rest, and that's the device.

0:43:38I'd know that it, yes, that's a vibrant orange color on my palm rest here and the track pad

0:43:44in front of me, but that's what I chose.

0:43:45Like, I'm not, like, I don't know why they, I don't know, but, like, I've been in briefings

0:43:51with them.

0:43:52I think, I think the most interesting was when they, yeah, because it was WWDC a couple

0:43:59years ago when the M2 MacBook Air first came out, with the design that they've stuck with

0:44:06since, right?

0:44:06Instead of, because the M1 MacBook Airs looked like the Intel.

0:44:10The awesome Mac, right?

0:44:11The best Mac that's ever been made in my opinion.

0:44:15The M1 MacBook Airs looked like the Intel ones, the teardrop classic shape.

0:44:21Yeah.

0:44:22The wedge.

0:44:22And then with the M2s, they came out at WWDC two and a half years ago, I think, or something.

0:44:28Whatever, we could look it up.

0:44:29But whatever that was.

0:44:31And I guess that's when they first debuted Midnight, but it would seem interesting, and

0:44:37at least it's dark.

0:44:38But everybody, they had, like, a briefing I was in after the keynote and after some time

0:44:45in the hands-on area at Steve Jobs Theater.

0:44:47And then they had one of these briefings, and I'm in there with, like, I don't know, they

0:44:51always break us up for things like that into, like, groups of, like, six, sometimes as many

0:44:56as eight, depending.

0:44:58You know, and you get a spiel with product marketing people, you get to see stuff with

0:45:02less of a scrum around you in a smaller, more like a little meeting room, and then they'll

0:45:07take questions.

0:45:08And somebody in my group asked, just sort of just asked, like, why don't you just make,

0:45:12like, vibrant colors?

0:45:13And it's frustrating because they don't give you a straight answer.

0:45:17But they do try to answer, but they answer in this opaque, Apple-speak way.

0:45:23And it's like, we like the colors we are offering, or something like that.

0:45:28Right, right.

0:45:28And it's what I'm trying to glean.

0:45:30Are you worried that people think they want colorful laptops, but you've tried it, and

0:45:36it doesn't look good?

0:45:37Like, they won't, they'll never even say that, which would be an interesting answer.

0:45:41Yeah, remember the iPhone 5C?

0:45:42You know, everybody's like, oh, yeah.

0:45:43I've got iPhones in all sorts of cool colors, and then they did that, and it was just kind

0:45:48of like, eh.

0:45:48Yeah, and nobody bought them.

0:45:49There's probably some market research there that we don't know about.

0:45:54Yeah.

0:45:55Right?

0:45:55I mean, Apple's not dumb.

0:45:56They're going to do some investigation.

0:45:59They do sell gobs and gobs of MacBooks, so they know what they're doing, and they probably

0:46:05know better than us.

0:46:06But there's a part of me that just wants them to make, like, a cool orange laptop, or a cool

0:46:11red one.

0:46:11Make, or make the blue one instead of sky blue, which is really close to silver.

0:46:16Make it that blue titanium one that they had that year.

0:46:20I forget what the name of the ocean blue or something like that, but it was just a, that

0:46:25was a really good blue.

0:46:27Yeah.

0:46:27I got some pre-release, under-embargo images of the MacBook Air the night before, and I'll

0:46:39just say, I shared them with Syracuse, and his first reaction was the color tint on these,

0:46:46because they were pings, not JPEGs, which is a little weird.

0:46:49You don't really think of photographs as being pings, and his thought was that the color

0:46:53temperature on these images is so weird that it looks blue, not silver.

0:46:57And I was like, no, no, I forgot to tell you, that actually is sky blue.

0:47:00But that's how slight the sky blue color is.

0:47:04It could almost be mistaken for silver, yeah.

0:47:06Yeah.

0:47:07Silver under a tungsten lamp or something like that.

0:47:10Yeah, like it's just the color grading, to use movie terms, of the imagery.

0:47:15And Midnight, the one that they've been using for a couple of years, is so dark that you could

0:47:21almost mistake it for super dark gray or black, really.

0:47:25In certain light, you can tell it's definitely blue, but in other light, it just looks black.

0:47:31They don't really have one that's Crayola blue, right?

0:47:33They just blue, like Cookie Monster blue.

0:47:36They just don't.

0:47:37And I can't help but think some people would really like that, and it would be fun, but

0:47:42they don't do it.

0:47:43And I guess I also do notice that PC makers don't do it either.

0:47:48Like, you can't just go buy a Dell in a fun orange color.

0:47:52But I don't know how much of that...

0:47:53Would they do it if Apple started doing it?

0:47:55Right.

0:47:56Has Apple become so influential that nobody does anything without following Apple's lead,

0:48:03right?

0:48:04Yeah, it's like there were no notches on phones until somebody did notches on phones.

0:48:08There were no islands on phones until somebody did islands on phones.

0:48:11And I think Google's pure Android, like when you get a Pixel phone, looks really clearly

0:48:19derived from the iOS 7 look, right?

0:48:23iOS 7 was like this statement redesign of software that, you know, here we are 11 revisions

0:48:32later at iOS 18, and it's been a very much this is how Apple rolls scenario year to year.

0:48:39From iOS 7 to iOS 18, the look of iOS has definitely changed every year in subtle ways, but you can't

0:48:49look at one of those years and say, oh, yeah, that was the one year where they really

0:48:53changed things up.

0:48:54You know, remember when they went from iOS 13 to 14, and they really added some depth and

0:48:59made the buttons look different and stuff?

0:49:01No, there hasn't been a single year like that.

0:49:03And I think even pure Android looks pretty shamelessly like a copy of the flatness and the

0:49:12overall look that Apple started with iOS 7.

0:49:15But then I'll watch an MKBHD video about some Android brand that I don't follow closely, and

0:49:23I'll look at their custom skin, and it's like ridiculous how much it looks like an iOS ripoff.

0:49:28I mean, it's like at this point, it's like you can't even comment on it.

0:49:31It's like, do these people have no shame at all?

0:49:33I mean, it's...

0:49:34They don't.

0:49:36Right.

0:49:36And it's like you expect it from Samsung, but it's...

0:49:39I don't know.

0:49:40I just expect some of these Android brands to sort of...

0:49:43I don't know.

0:49:44Just make...

0:49:45I think people would be glass of ice water in hell if somebody came out with a phone where

0:49:51everything had depth and texture.

0:49:52Like...

0:49:54Yeah.

0:49:55I'm not saying make it look...

0:49:56Back to iOS 6.

0:49:58I'm not even saying like fake leather and fake ripped pages in the Notes app and that form

0:50:05of...

0:50:06Yeah, that was over the top, but you could...

0:50:10The comment back on the...

0:50:12When the change happened was you could tell a button was a button.

0:50:16Yeah.

0:50:16Right?

0:50:17Yeah.

0:50:17A button was very clearly a button.

0:50:19And for a while it wasn't, and it's starting to come back.

0:50:23Yeah.

0:50:24Every time somebody posts screenshots from like Snow Leopard, if they post them on Mastodon

0:50:30or Blue Sky or something, there will immediately be comments saying, oh man, remember when software

0:50:37looked like that.

0:50:37When you see screenshots of the first versions of Mac OS X from 2002, it's over the top, right?

0:50:44It is like nobody...

0:50:46People...

0:50:47You might say, oh...

0:50:47Yeah, the stripes.

0:50:48The stripes in the menu.

0:50:50That was a bad idea.

0:50:51Right.

0:50:52The stripes that...

0:50:54Too many things.

0:50:55If you think there's a problem with the level of translucency now, we had transparency then

0:51:01where they didn't even blur behind it.

0:51:02You just...

0:51:03Yeah.

0:51:03It's like...

0:51:05It was like trying to read something printed on onion paper.

0:51:0850% wide over everything, right?

0:51:11You're done.

0:51:11There's a reason that they don't print books.

0:51:15Like if you go to buy a novel, they don't print it on see-through paper.

0:51:18But you know, like around where Mac OS X's look settled in around 10.6 or so with Snow Leopard,

0:51:25it just was like a nice look.

0:51:27And it's like there was depth and more shadows and buttons look like buttons.

0:51:32And when you pressed buttons, they clicked and went in.

0:51:34And I think somebody can make a phone like that today, the whole phone that looks like

0:51:38that, and people would kind of go nuts, like in a modern way, not like retro 2006 phone

0:51:45look.

0:51:45But I think there's like a modern 2025 look where buttons have depth that somebody could

0:51:52do.

0:51:53And it's nobody's going to do it till Apple does it first.

0:51:55And then if Apple does it...

0:51:56Yeah.

0:51:56Mac OS Platinum on a phone.

0:51:58Right.

0:51:59That would be pretty cool.

0:52:00It would be.

0:52:01Like a modern take on that look would be...

0:52:04Yeah, yeah.

0:52:04And that's how style is...

0:52:05Flat, but with bevels.

0:52:07That was it, right?

0:52:08It's like you can do a lot with the highlight edge and the shadow edge of the bevel.

0:52:13And instead, we're sitting here trying to get excited about Sky Blue.

0:52:22Which is really kind of silver.

0:52:25I get these review units every year for the phones and they usually send me...

0:52:30I get so many phones in September.

0:52:31I get...

0:52:31I mean, who knows?

0:52:32This year I might get six or five or something.

0:52:35I don't know.

0:52:36But I guess just four because they're saying the plus is going away.

0:52:39But like the last few years, I've had review units for the regular 16, the 16 plus, the 16

0:52:46Pro and the Pro Max.

0:52:47And I'll have four of them for one person to review in a week.

0:52:51And it's like, I just pick one and use it.

0:52:54But they won't give me two of the same color, right?

0:52:56So they'll give me like a Pro and a Pro Max in two different colors.

0:53:00They usually pick the colors they want to show off.

0:53:03But...

0:53:04And I always show them to Amy or Jonas when he was home and now he's at college.

0:53:08But...

0:53:08And they're always like, what shade of gray are they all this year?

0:53:11That's every year.

0:53:14I can totally see Amy saying that.

0:53:16Yeah.

0:53:16She wants...

0:53:18What's the gray look like now?

0:53:19Tell me, John.

0:53:20And again, she's not...

0:53:22You know her.

0:53:23She's not unsophisticated technically.

0:53:26Oh, she's got a great sense of color.

0:53:27Yeah.

0:53:28Yeah.

0:53:28But she would honestly be more interested in upgrading her phone if it was like, oh, cool

0:53:34looking.

0:53:34Not...

0:53:35She really thinks it's insane that they're always same looking.

0:53:39And I'm like, well, this one, they're calling it graphite.

0:53:42And she's like, that's the same color.

0:53:44She goes, it's the same color.

0:53:45You just hold it in different light and you can't tell the difference from last year.

0:53:50And I'm like, yeah, I guess you're right.

0:53:52And there's probably some materials engineered at Apple right now going, well, what do you expect?

0:53:57It's metal.

0:53:58I can only do so much with the process, right?

0:54:02And I think some of that is purely process.

0:54:06Yeah, maybe.

0:54:07And with titanium, I don't know.

0:54:09You know, and I come home and I am, and it's not, I'm not hepped up on Apple propaganda coming home from California after getting these review units or something.

0:54:20But I'm more excited.

0:54:22I've seen them and examined them in different lighting.

0:54:24Like with the iPhones, they've got like white with a silver, you know, like a pure titanium.

0:54:29And then there's natural titanium.

0:54:31And Amy will just be like, they're the same.

0:54:34They're the frigging same.

0:54:36There's no difference.

0:54:38And they're not the same.

0:54:40They are different.

0:54:41But in the grand scheme of possible colors, they are the same, right?

0:54:46There's this narrow, very narrow sliver of the spectrum that Apple picks colors from.

0:54:53And sky blue is in that very narrow sliver.

0:54:57They haven't expanded it.

0:54:59The bigger news, the most exciting and weirdest news, I guess it's only proper that on this show we saved it for an hour in, is the Mac Studio.

0:55:08The Mac Studio came out this week, was not expected.

0:55:13There were no, for as much as the M4 or M3, there I go again, M3 iPad Airs, the M4 revision of the MacBook Airs was definitely expected around now.

0:55:28It's become like sort of an annualized schedule that around March or so is when they come out.

0:55:33Nobody was saying, I bet they'll come out with Mac Studios.

0:55:36Nobody.

0:55:37I mean, total surprise, kind of fun.

0:55:40And then it turns out, not only is the Mac Studio here, but it's the M4 Max, which is the exact same M4 Max from the MacBook Pros that came out at the end of October.

0:55:53There's no difference in like the core options or the RAM options.

0:55:59It's do you want an M4 Max system in a chip in a laptop or do you want it in a cute little box called the Mac Studio?

0:56:11Do you want a desktop?

0:56:12And the M3, not 4, Ultra chip, which was sort of like a record scratch when they told us in a product briefing the night before.

0:56:24Not, oh, that's horrible.

0:56:26Oh, my God.

0:56:27The M3 generation.

0:56:28But it just seems weird, right?

0:56:32At first.

0:56:33No, there's got to be some part of the story there that we're not hearing.

0:56:38And it probably has something to do with production lines and what they can get their hands on chip-wise and all that, right?

0:56:49You know, these Ultra chips, you know, where they have that, what do they call it?

0:56:53The fusion interconnect or something like that.

0:56:57So it's the name of the thing that ties the two dyes together.

0:57:02Yeah, yeah.

0:57:03That cannot be a simple thing.

0:57:05We were talking about bending earlier, right?

0:57:07When you're talking about three nanometer things or actually four nanometer, whatever it is now, whatever the process size is.

0:57:15It's like everything at that scale gets more difficult.

0:57:18Yeah.

0:57:19I mentioned this on Daring Fireball.

0:57:22Snell mentioned it in his write-up.

0:57:25Jason was in my little virtual WebEx briefing group.

0:57:29Somebody was there from ours.

0:57:31I don't think it was Andrew.

0:57:33It wasn't Andrew Cunningham who wrote their story.

0:57:35But I forget who else was in my group.

0:57:39Oh, Ina Fried was there and asked the question.

0:57:43It was like they did their spiel with the demos and telling us and stuff.

0:57:48And then it was like, okay, now we'll open it up to questions.

0:57:50And Ina asked the obvious one right off the bat.

0:57:53Thank God, because it was on everybody's mind.

0:57:56Why is it the M3 Ultra and not the M4 Ultra if everything else is on the M4?

0:58:01And the Apple representative from product marketing, it's an off-the-record briefing.

0:58:06We're allowed to say we had a briefing.

0:58:08I'm not supposed to quote them directly.

0:58:11But he answered as straightforwardly as he could and said something to the effect of,

0:58:16our Ultra chips do have our longest development cycle.

0:58:22And then he said, and ours picked up on this, and Jason did too in his writing, and I can confirm I wrote it down,

0:58:29that he said, I forget if it was we're not going to have an Ultra.

0:58:35I think he said we may not have an Ultra in every generation because of the development time it takes to make them.

0:58:45Which is super interesting, because Apple doesn't say anything like that.

0:58:49And again, it serves them well overall, but they've taken the policy of not talking about the future to such an extreme

0:58:56that it leads to unpleasant surprises like this, right?

0:59:01Like they didn't really, they never set the stage for as good, and you and I were just talking about it for the last hour, how...

0:59:08I was just going to say, that predictability works for you and against you.

0:59:12Right, where all these other products are so predictable, but the Ultras have been at the highest end.

0:59:20I'm sure it's both factors, a little bit of column A and column B, where it is the hardest engineering challenge chip design-wise.

0:59:28And it is, by quantity, the smallest selling product, right?

0:59:34It's the Mac Pros are a super niche.

0:59:37The Mac Studios surely are the lowest selling Macs next to the Mac Pros by quantity.

0:59:44And they are expensive, so it's not like they're giving them away.

0:59:48But, of course, they could probably come out with Ultra Series chips faster if there was some reason to think we'll sell a zillion of them, right?

1:00:00We'll sell as many of them as we sell iPad Airs.

1:00:04Right, if they were putting them in phones, it would take on a whole different priority.

1:00:09Right, if there was some kind of reason to make M5 Ultra chips for the iPhone or M6, however many years they would need to build up to that.

1:00:20But at some point, then I'm sure they could throw more resources at it.

1:00:24But, like, the proper allocation of engineering resources to Ultra chips is in balance, I think, with the amount that they sell.

1:00:33And I think that 2017 meeting where they said they are committed to the pro hardware market, it's proven out over the last eight years.

1:00:41And, yes, the current Mac Pro is really just a Mac Studio in a bigger box.

1:00:48And it has better I.O. capability.

1:00:49It's not just hiding in the box.

1:00:51There's I.O. capabilities.

1:00:52It's got an SD card on the front, too.

1:00:54There are things.

1:00:55In fact, I just ordered one.

1:00:57A Mac Pro?

1:00:58I've been dying.

1:00:59Yeah, the Mac Studio.

1:01:02Oh, not the Mac Pro.

1:01:03The Mac Studio.

1:01:04No, no, no, no.

1:01:05Just the Mac Studio.

1:01:06For me, the whole upgrade thing.

1:01:08Which one did you get?

1:01:09What did you order?

1:01:10The M4 Mac.

1:01:13M4 Mac.

1:01:14With the, I think it was 48 gigabytes of memory.

1:01:18I don't remember.

1:01:19And a terabyte storage.

1:01:21And I'm replacing an M1 iMac with 16 gigabytes of unified memory.

1:01:34I'm not looking at the M1 CPU-wise is kind of okay.

1:01:40I mean, Xcode builds fine.

1:01:42Everything else is just dandy.

1:01:44But, yeah, having 16 gigabytes of unified memory is just not cutting it these days.

1:01:51So that, for me, was the big thing.

1:01:54But, yeah, I'm looking forward to getting that.

1:01:57And probably getting a couple of studio displays as well.

1:02:00Yeah.

1:02:01I still haven't written it.

1:02:03I can talk about it.

1:02:04And it's just the way some things fall through the cracks for me as a one-person show.

1:02:10But I got a 16-inch M4i MacBook Pro for review back in November when they came out.

1:02:20And I switched to it full-time for, I think, at least four weeks.

1:02:24And I switched back sometime around.

1:02:27I still haven't written a review of it.

1:02:29But I do mean to.

1:02:30And maybe I'll tie it in with a review of this new stuff if I get any of the new stuff.

1:02:34But the most interesting thing about it is that I got, A, they sent me the review unit had the nanotexture display, which is, I really love matte displays.

1:02:46I thought, yeah, when I say I'm going to get a couple of studio displays, I've got, I mean, can you go to the Apple store and check it out?

1:02:56I mean, that's one of those things I'd really love to see in person before I pull the trigger on.

1:03:00You definitely can.

1:03:01I don't know if every store has one.

1:03:03And I think our store here in Philadelphia only had, last time I was there, they only had one in person.

1:03:10They're not, most of the configs for display are the glossy ones.

1:03:13And most people just prefer glossy.

1:03:16They don't.

1:03:17Most people aren't annoyed by the glare and reflections of glossy displays.

1:03:22Apple has, over the years, done yeoman's work to make shiny displays as anti-reflective as they can.

1:03:32And I know they're better than they used to be, but I see them.

1:03:35And some people, I know there are super picky people.

1:03:39You've worked with designers your whole life.

1:03:41There's no accounting for taste.

1:03:43And some people who are super, super picky like the way colors look on a glossy display more than any matte display, that they think matte takes away certain pop from colors.

1:03:56Others, you know, I remember when the studio display first came out, the Apple studio display came out with the nanotexture.

1:04:03And the Verge got, like, pinged the opinion of one of their staff photographers, or maybe a couple of their staff photographers.

1:04:10And they all raved about it.

1:04:12Now, these are photographers who are specifically thinking about wanting to get accurate color on screen.

1:04:18Right.

1:04:18And they love the nanotexture.

1:04:20I'm sure there are other photographers and video people out there who are like, no, no, I don't want matte.

1:04:26So it's good that they offer both.

1:04:28But I really like it.

1:04:29The way that I'm looking at it and the major consideration, yes, there's the color correctness, which is, that's, Apple's always been good at that.

1:04:38Their color profiles are spot on.

1:04:41Right.

1:04:41But there's also the eye strain aspect, right?

1:04:44Yep.

1:04:45I'm 65.

1:04:46My eyes are not as good as they used to be.

1:04:48I don't.

1:04:49And anything I can do to make it easier to look at my screen, it's kind of money well spent, right?

1:04:55So that's the other thing that I've heard.

1:04:56And I'm a little behind you in years, but my eyes might be effectively older than yours.

1:05:04Right.

1:05:04Yeah, yeah, the eye problems you've had.

1:05:06The downside of, even with nanotexture, which I think is the best, you know, I think Apple's justified in calling it nanotexture instead of matte, giving it a fancy Apple name.

1:05:16But I know that people with really good eyesight say that they think they can see that it makes things a little blurrier.

1:05:24Because it has to, right?

1:05:25Like, that the actual pixels...

1:05:28Yes, diffracting light.

1:05:28Right.

1:05:29And so if your eyes are so good that you can really see the difference in crispness of text on a regular Apple display versus a nanotexture one, A, your eyesight is excellent, enjoy it.

1:05:45And B, then buy the one that you think looks better, right?

1:05:48And I remember when I was younger, my eye, I could definitely, I'd run every display I got at the highest, most pixels per inch resolution it could possibly support.

1:05:58And the smallest, tiniest text to pack the most stuff on screen.

1:06:03And maybe that's why my eyes went bad.

1:06:05I spent years looking at tiny text on a...

1:06:10Paying for past mistakes.

1:06:11On blurry CRT monitors.

1:06:14But I, the advantage of being a little older and not having the super sharp vision is I don't see any difference in crispness from a nanotexture versus non-nanotexture Apple display.

1:06:27I see that.

1:06:27That's actually one of the reasons why I want to see it in person, right?

1:06:30Right.

1:06:30Because there's no product shot that's going to convince you one way or the other.

1:06:34You've got to just be there and look at it.

1:06:36But anyway, I used it for a month, loved it.

1:06:40And because I was testing it, instead of using it at my desk, what I, my usual rig for 98% of my work, other than podcasting, where I go down here and use this other machine, is I use an, I have an M1 Max MacBook Pro.

1:06:56And it's maxed out with the highest specs from that M1 MacBook Pro generation with 64 gigs of RAM.

1:07:02And I don't forget how, I don't know, maybe it's not maxed out on the SSD.

1:07:06I think I only have, because I don't have a lot of storage needs, but I maxed it out on RAM.

1:07:10But I run it with the lid closed hooked up to a studio display with the nanotexture finish.

1:07:17Right.

1:07:18And I don't really use the laptop as a laptop all that often.

1:07:21I just like having a laptop.

1:07:23Yeah, I don't travel as much as I used to, and I don't have to work in other rooms of the house or whatever.

1:07:28Like, one reason I used to move around the house was for sunlight hitting my display in my office and making it unreadable.

1:07:36And now it's not a problem, because nanotexture actually takes care of it.

1:07:40But to test the MacBook Pro in November, December, I was using it as a laptop, because that should be part of the review, is testing the nanotexture display.

1:07:49It was amazing.

1:07:50I just loved it.

1:07:51And I could work in direct sunlight hitting the screen, and it's like, yeah, it's totally usable.

1:07:56And I thought, I need to buy one of these.

1:07:58That's kind of amazing.

1:07:59Right.

1:07:59It's like the dream.

1:08:02And I like...

1:08:04Not having to find shade when you're out and about.

1:08:06I like dark things.

1:08:09I always buy my iPhones black, or the closest to black they sell them.

1:08:13I love the new space black look on the MacBook Pros more than the space gray of mine.

1:08:20Now, that's totally just spending money to buy a thing that looks like a cooler shade of aluminum.

1:08:25But I thought, well, I've waited a couple of years.

1:08:28I should just upgrade.

1:08:29This is a work tool.

1:08:30I wouldn't just throw my M1 generation MacBook Pro in the garbage.

1:08:35I'd find some either use for it.

1:08:37Maybe I'd make that my new podcast station, or sell it, or something.

1:08:41It's very usable.

1:08:43But then I switched back to my...

1:08:46From this thinking, I should buy myself an M4 MacBook Pro with the nanotexture.

1:08:51And then I switched back to my M1 MacBook Pro, my personal one.

1:08:57And I didn't notice anything get slower.

1:08:59Nothing.

1:09:00Yeah.

1:09:01Nothing I do.

1:09:01And I really thought, and how much do I use the laptop as a laptop where I'm looking at the laptop display?

1:09:09Very little.

1:09:10Like, it doesn't...

1:09:12Even if I sold this older machine or found a good use for it, I just really...

1:09:16There was no argument to be made for...

1:09:20You couldn't convince yourself that you needed to go spend the money.

1:09:23All these years that I've been doing product reviews of Apple products, and now that I'm in the circle I'm in where I get review units to try, I don't have to buy them myself to try them.

1:09:35Every time a new thing comes out, a lot of times...

1:09:37I write about this often in my reviews, right?

1:09:40Where I'll get the new one, and I don't notice, hey, this feels faster, right?

1:09:44Because my personal kit usually isn't out of date.

1:09:48But I get the new thing, and it feels fast, but I don't think it feels faster.

1:09:53It doesn't matter.

1:09:54Phones, iPads, certainly Macs over the years.

1:09:57And so, eh, this is pretty nice.

1:09:59And then I go back to my thing from two years ago or three years ago.

1:10:03And I think, ah, shit.

1:10:05This feels slow.

1:10:07I'm ruined now.

1:10:08What?

1:10:09And I think, like, I would think sometimes, what happened?

1:10:11I know I wasn't using this Mac for a couple of weeks because I was using a review unit.

1:10:17What did it?

1:10:18Did it get cold?

1:10:19Did it get hot?

1:10:20Did something happen?

1:10:21Why is it slow?

1:10:22And I'm like, no.

1:10:23It's going backwards that makes you notice the speed improvements of going forwards.

1:10:29I don't know why.

1:10:30But when I went back to my personal M1 MacBook Pro from an M4, I didn't notice anything get slower.

1:10:39Nothing.

1:10:40I mean, like, literally no difference.

1:10:41Well, if you spent your day encoding video or training AI models or doing other things.

1:10:47Swift.

1:10:47If I used Xcode.

1:10:49Yeah.

1:10:49Right?

1:10:50Exactly.

1:10:50And even Xcode, even Xcode is not too bad going back in time as long as you've got enough

1:10:57memory.

1:10:57It's a memory hog these days.

1:10:59And there's a good reason for that.

1:11:02You and I have mutual friends who work at Adobe on the Photoshop team.

1:11:08And Photoshop, believe it or not, takes a long time to compile.

1:11:14Well, yeah.

1:11:16It takes a long time.

1:11:16Yeah.

1:11:17The room gets a little warm.

1:11:20Yeah.

1:11:20Even with Apple Silicon, it gets a little warm.

1:11:24There is a totally justified case for engineers who work on something like Photoshop at Adobe

1:11:32to buy a new MacBook every time they come out or a new Mac Studio or whatever comes out.

1:11:39If you get 10% improvements in compile times on a massive project, it really adds up.

1:11:46And if you go back in time, 20, 30 years, every project that went through, like, a C compiler

1:11:53or a C++ compiler was a get up, take a break, crack your knuckles, go get a cup of coffee, right?

1:12:00I mean, that's just the way things work.

1:12:03You know, compiling tapestry right now is that for me, right?

1:12:07It's like, I know it's going to take five minutes.

1:12:09Yeah.

1:12:09Thereabouts.

1:12:10All right.

1:12:10Right?

1:12:10And it's a release build, right?

1:12:13If I'm doing debug builds, it's not an issue.

1:12:15But, you know, we're going to send out our weekly release.

1:12:18I did it once or twice a week, maybe three times.

1:12:21I know I've got to go take a five-minute break, right?

1:12:23I'm going to go make some lunch, use the toilet, whatever.

1:12:26There are lots of tasks in the world that still remain bound by performance like that,

1:12:33like minutes long or half hour long.

1:12:35I know from my annual talk show live at WWDC,

1:12:39how long a final render takes of an hour and a half or hour and a half plus 4K recording.

1:12:47Well, you've been exporting this podcast, right?

1:12:50Yeah.

1:12:50Well, I don't do that, though.

1:12:52Yeah, but, you know, somebody like Caleb is going to be interested in a new processor,

1:12:57more cores and all that stuff.

1:12:58But I do know, like, when we do, like, hey, it's final, and if I give it a listen or something,

1:13:04some random thing comes up and it's like, oh, crap, we needed to edit something out or I wanted

1:13:10to insert something.

1:13:11I know what the turnaround time is like, and I know that getting faster hardware can make that work.

1:13:16I don't do anything like that.

1:13:19And so I really...

1:13:21You want top performance with BBEdit, though.

1:13:23Got to have that.

1:13:24I remember when I used to do things with BBEdit that would take time.

1:13:28I don't do it.

1:13:29Nothing I do takes time.

1:13:31All I need is gobs of RAM.

1:13:3364 gigs is still, for me, enough.

1:13:36So I'm actually...

1:13:37Yeah, I would suspect your main use of memory is Safari tabs.

1:13:41Yes.

1:13:42Oh, you know it.

1:13:43It's...

1:13:44Yeah.

1:13:44It's my problem.

1:13:46For a lot of developers, it's the same thing.

1:13:48Yeah.

1:13:48I'm researching a problem.

1:13:50Yeah.

1:13:50I got...

1:13:52In fact, I love that moment where I've finished some sort of part of a project where I can go close

1:13:58all the browser tabs, close all the windows.

1:14:00There's something really satisfying about just, okay, I don't need this anymore.

1:14:05I've learned what I need to learn.

1:14:07I've researched what I need to research, and I'm done.

1:14:11That's kind of like shipping a product to my house.

1:14:15If I were...

1:14:17My problem is I do too...

1:14:20My problem is, A, I'm a mess.

1:14:22My physical desk has always been a mess anyway.

1:14:26If you remember Andy Rooney on 60 Minutes, I've got books, I've got papers.

1:14:32And if I'm doing a research for one post on Daring Fireball, I've opened up one new window

1:14:37and have all the tabs for that there.

1:14:38And in theory, a lot of the times, I will then close that window and all the tabs.

1:14:43And I do get that sense of satisfaction of there.

1:14:45That's done.

1:14:46I posted about that.

1:14:48But more often than not, what happens is I've already moved on to the next thing,

1:14:52or I started working on the next thing while I was working on the previous post.

1:14:55And those tabs...

1:14:56Yeah, I'll finish that later.

1:14:57Yeah.

1:14:58And then that tab with those eight tabs...

1:15:00Three months later.

1:15:01That window...

1:15:01Three months later, that post shows up on Daring Fireball.

1:15:04I meant to do this in November when this thing happened.

1:15:07But the tabs are still open.

1:15:09Anyway, no, I couldn't do it.

1:15:12But it's a fantastic hardware.

1:15:14I mean, but it speaks to...

1:15:17If you have enough RAM, any M-series silicon is good enough for most tasks.

1:15:22It's amazing.

1:15:23What's a real eye-opener, and I've had to do this a couple times for testing stuff,

1:15:28is to go back to Intel.

1:15:30It's just like my MacBook Pro, whatever year it was, the last year that they made the 16-inch

1:15:39with the Intel chip.

1:15:40My God.

1:15:43And the thing's got plenty of memory.

1:15:45I was testing something with Sequoia a while back, and it's just like, God, this thing is

1:15:50just not...

1:15:51No snap to it, right?

1:15:52But that brings us to the M3 Ultra, and why we...

1:15:56Before we digress there, we were talking about the fact that Apple just admitted that

1:16:00it takes us longer to make an Ultra.

1:16:01It's not...

1:16:02It sounds like it's easy, and they're describing it as two M3 Max chips fused together with their

1:16:08Fusion technology, and that sounds like it should be super easy, right, as a layperson.

1:16:14Yeah, just take two of them, solder some connections.

1:16:18And we know that things are not as easy as they sound, right?

1:16:23You've got to think about it, they're going to flip it, too, right?

1:16:28So it's like, it's not just like a mirror image, it's rotated 180 degrees.

1:16:32So how do you interconnect all this stuff?

1:16:35There's got to be some magic going on there, too.

1:16:38It is obviously much more involved, and it would be great if they would talk more about it,

1:16:45maybe.

1:16:45And I do think that they should, and who knows, it's not with me, I can say, that I don't

1:16:51have any briefings with their Silicon team, but it would be interesting to me if now that

1:16:56they've made this announcement, if they do pick some media people who can write about this

1:17:02intelligently.

1:17:02I mean, it's who, though?

1:17:03It's like, in the old days, it would have been like a non-tech or somebody like that.

1:17:08But non-tech, it's just no more.

1:17:10But it would be great if Apple would take somebody behind the scenes and show them just how complicated

1:17:16it is to go from a Max to an Ultra and set people's expectations.

1:17:22Is it something that deserves some special branding, right?

1:17:25You've got the A-series chips for mobile, right?

1:17:28M is more the Mac Pro iPad.

1:17:34Is there like a P3, Pro 3, and just Pro 3 Max, Pro 3 Ultra, whatever.

1:17:42But just another way of identifying.

1:17:45And maybe everybody has the expectations of this happens every two years instead of every

1:17:50year.

1:17:51I could see that something like that happening.

1:17:54Yeah.

1:17:55That's exactly what I've been thinking.

1:17:58So, you know, famous last words, who knows what will come out first, this podcast or me

1:18:01writing about it.

1:18:02But there's a chance that by the time this podcast comes out tomorrow that I will have

1:18:07written about it.

1:18:08But what you said is exactly what I'm thinking.

1:18:09And in the same way, by all accounts, certainly looking at TSMC's processes, there's the new

1:18:17three nanometer process.

1:18:19And the A-17 Pro is on the first chip on the A-7 is on this process.

1:18:25And then the M3 is on the same process as the A-17 Pro.

1:18:30But because it's the first three nanometer process, it's got lower yields and it's more

1:18:35expensive.

1:18:36And there's blah, blah, blah.

1:18:38And that's why, for example, it seems to be why the iPhone 15, not Pro, didn't get an A-17

1:18:51chip, it stuck with the A-16 from the year before.

1:18:55And only the A-15 Pro got the A-17 Pro because this new process was finicky, blah, blah, blah.

1:19:02And oh, now that they've gone to the second gen three nanometer process, it's better, it's

1:19:08higher yields, it's more predictable, it's faster, something, something.

1:19:12So they want to move everybody, A-18 for everybody on the iPhone side and M4s, let's get rid of

1:19:19these M3s.

1:19:20Well, I don't know.

1:19:21Maybe it's like they built out all of that first gen three nanometer process and it's as

1:19:28finicky and first gen as it is.

1:19:30They're still coming out with new devices.

1:19:32The iPads are M3s.

1:19:34Now we've got Mac Studios that are M3 Ultras.

1:19:37But I do wonder, in that same way that you can say, and it seems to be true, that the A-17

1:19:45Pro and the M3 are sort of in the same family, that they're the same process, and that in some

1:19:53sense, the M3 is an A-17 that's bigger, or just very broad layperson's terms, right?

1:20:00But they got a different brand, because it's on a different schedule and it's meant for different

1:20:05things.

1:20:05I'm thinking the same thing is true for these Ultras.

1:20:08And if they wanted to make something beyond Ultra, an extreme, that it would be, call it

1:20:14P, call it X, because X is the coolest letter of the alphabet, right?

1:20:18This is the new X one.

1:20:19Not totally, in some cases.

1:20:21Well.

1:20:23Like social networks.

1:20:24But that's why he freaking named it that, right?

1:20:28I'd get my dig in there.

1:20:28Right?

1:20:29He names everything X, because he thinks X is the coolest.

1:20:31He thinks he's cool, right?

1:20:34He's putting a stink on the letter X.

1:20:36It really does.

1:20:37Somebody's got to fight back, though, for the letter X, which should be the coolest letter,

1:20:41right?

1:20:41Mac OS X with the X, XServe.

1:20:45It is a cool letter.

1:20:47iPhone X.

1:20:48Right.

1:20:48So whatever they wanted to call the chip.

1:20:52I do think, though, that there's something to that.

1:20:54If it had, instead of calling it the M number Ultra, if it was instead the P and give it its

1:21:03own number.

1:21:03It would eliminate the raised eyebrows, right?

1:21:06And then, like, that is the processor chip that has the fusion technology, too, right?

1:21:12Right.

1:21:12It's like it's the one that's doubled up, right?

1:21:15It's like twice as good.

1:21:17Right.

1:21:17And it would also signal, I think, more of a difference in terms of the name alone signifying

1:21:25to users how to start their conceptual framework of what they need.

1:21:31It is more of a break, right?

1:21:35And then I actually...

1:21:37Yeah.

1:21:37It's like with the iPads, right?

1:21:39It's like, do you need an iPad with an A processor or an M processor?

1:21:42Well, do you need a Mac with an M processor or a PX processor?

1:21:46And then for the M series, you'd effectively have three tiers.

1:21:50Good, better, best.

1:21:51The classic Steve Jobs, good, better, best.

1:21:54There's the M4.

1:21:56The M4 Pro, better.

1:22:00M4 Max, best.

1:22:03For a standard Mac user scenario, you got good, better, best.

1:22:09And it's better in ways that correspond to what people just understand.

1:22:15More cores, faster performance, each tier up going from regular to pro and then from pro

1:22:21to max supports, has more base memory if you just get the base of that chip name, and it

1:22:27has a much higher range at the maximum end, especially the M Max.

1:22:32Yeah, there are totally going to be price expectations for this stuff as well, right?

1:22:36You're not going to get a P processor for under $5,000, right?

1:22:41In fact, Sebastian DeWitt the other day showed an order for the new M3 Ultra maxed out.

1:22:49It's $11,000, not including taxes, right?

1:22:53That's a chunk of change.

1:22:55But if you need it, you need it.

1:22:59If you're charging a customer $10,000 to encode some video for them, that's dropping a bucket.

1:23:08If you need the Ultra, if you really know you need the Ultra or would make good use of it,

1:23:13like your life, your day-to-day life, working life would be better with an Ultra chip than

1:23:18a Max chip, your needs are so outside the bounds that the regular spectrum of Mac user needs that

1:23:27you kind of need, I think it would actually be more, the marketing would be more conveying

1:23:33the sense of that than just picking a new adjective, pro, max, ultra, extreme, ultra extreme, right?

1:23:43Just adding an adjective is good for good, better, best, but let's just say they called

1:23:49them the M5 good, the M5 better, the M5 best.

1:23:54Ultra is like trying to say bestest, bestester, right?

1:23:59More better.

1:24:00Right.

1:24:01M5 more better.

1:24:03Right?

1:24:04If you went to somebody 20 years ago or somebody who doesn't work in our industry but is a very

1:24:12fluent English speaker and said, what do you think is better, the pro, the max, or the ultra?

1:24:18I think you could probably guess that the max and ultra are both better than the pro just

1:24:28linguistically, but max is the max, right?

1:24:33It should be, right?

1:24:34Like, they've already run into, like, it's, max obviously doesn't stand for maximum because

1:24:41it's not the maximum.

1:24:43The ultra is the maximum.

1:24:44Yeah.

1:24:44Right?

1:24:45And if they're going to come out with a chip.

1:24:48When are we going to get some AirPods ultras, right?

1:24:51Right.

1:24:51Maybe that's the plan.

1:24:54Maybe, I honestly have no, and again, marketing names are the holiest of holies at Apple.

1:25:00The 16e barely leaked.

1:25:03I guess some people are saying that there were some leaks beforehand.

1:25:05But for the most part, everybody was referring to the iPhone 16e as the iPhone SE, the new

1:25:12SE until it came out.

1:25:13And they don't print the names on the boxes often.

1:25:16If you buy an iPhone 16e, it just says iPhone on the box.

1:25:20Yeah.

1:25:20And it's got a picture of the device.

1:25:22Yeah.

1:25:22They can keep stuff like that.

1:25:24And then it's a sticker that they put on that says iPhone 16 with whatever color and whatever

1:25:30cellular config for your region.

1:25:32Well, and you know how much memory it's got and all the other stuff, right?

1:25:36Right.

1:25:36It's the basic box.

1:25:37They want to print up one basic box and then just...

1:25:40But I do think that's...

1:25:43I really do think that's the way to think about.

1:25:45And I'm not making excuses for Apple.

1:25:47But I think that anybody who's thinking, oh, Apple, it's a sad trombone sound that they've

1:25:56introduced this embarrassing M3 generation chip in 2025 isn't understanding how complicated

1:26:05these ultra chips are engineering-wise, how long it really does take them.

1:26:10Even if there are no mistakes or hiccups in the development process, it really does seem

1:26:15to take a lot longer, like more than a year.

1:26:19Do you think they expected this kind of pushback, this kind of confusion with the M3 Ultra introduction?

1:26:29Yeah, I think so.

1:26:30I mean, was there any indications from product marketing that they kind of, they knew this

1:26:34was going to happen?

1:26:34Yeah, I think so.

1:26:36It's very hard to tell because on, you know, these calls, and that's one of the reasons...

1:26:42I'm glad they didn't, you know, and I often say to people that Apple is very properly

1:26:48respectful of people's time and so media people's time.

1:26:54So they don't have us flying to Cupertino needlessly or even going to New York when they

1:27:02hold regional things on the East Coast, which for me is easy breezy to take a train from Philly

1:27:07to New York.

1:27:07You know, I bet this one was a borderline call for them.

1:27:11Would they have had, should they have had something in New York and Cupertino for the West Coast

1:27:16people?

1:27:17But what are you going to see?

1:27:18You know, they demonstrate stuff and it's like, what, a video export takes less time.

1:27:24And the case looks the same.

1:27:26Here's a photo of the die, right?

1:27:28You know, it's like, look, it's got two cores on it or two chips.

1:27:32I do find it easier to suss out things that aren't in the transcript of the conversation,

1:27:42but the body language or the look on somebody's face in person.

1:27:45That's what I was asking.

1:27:46Yeah.

1:27:47If they felt like they had a problem there, that's a lot more incentive for them to come

1:27:53up with new branding for this thing.

1:27:55And it does seem to both of us like it's a different thing.

1:27:59It's something unique.

1:28:01Yeah.

1:28:01And they were ready for it.

1:28:02And I think it's like, what do they want to do?

1:28:05They want to keep big announcements secret.

1:28:07And they did, but because they kept it secret, it landed like a lead balloon because it sounds

1:28:15like they've introduced this $4,000 going up to 15, 16, $17,000 configs with 512 gigs of

1:28:25RAM and 16 terabytes of SSD.

1:28:28Very expensive, super workstations that sound from a lay person's perspective, like it's

1:28:35using year and a half old silicon generation.

1:28:38Right.

1:28:39It's last year's model.

1:28:40Yeah.

1:28:41Here.

1:28:41I looked this up.

1:28:42So the original M1s came out in November of 2020.

1:28:47The MacBook Air, the low end MacBook Pro 13 and a Mac mini.

1:28:52And then they didn't come out with the Mac M1 Pro until a year later in October of 2021.

1:28:58They came out with the MacBook Pro and the MacBook Pro 16 with the M1 Pro and the M1 Max came out

1:29:06at the same time in October, 2021, a year later.

1:29:10The M1 Ultra, which was only in the studio, came out in March of 2022.

1:29:16So that's what, a year plus, a year and a half, almost a year and a half after or no?

1:29:25No, no, no, no, no.

1:29:26It's like six months.

1:29:28No, I'm saying from the M1 though.

1:29:31Oh, from the M1, yes, yes.

1:29:33And then six months after the M1 Pro.

1:29:36But that is, you know, then the M2s, I think, is the generation that threw us all off expectation-wise.

1:29:44The original M2s came out in the MacBook Air in June of 2022.

1:29:48That's the WWDC I was talking to about earlier.

1:29:52The M2 Pros came out in January of 2023.

1:29:57And I think those were late, and the schedule works out this way.

1:30:02I think that that was while they were still trying to get to the annualized schedule where

1:30:06they want those MacBook Pros to come out around the end of October.

1:30:10I think they were, for whatever reason, a little late, came out in January the next year.

1:30:14M2 Max came out at the same time, January 2023.

1:30:19And then the M2 Ultra came out at WWDC in June that year.

1:30:26So just five or six months after the M2 Pro and the M2 Max, the M2 Ultra came out.

1:30:35And that's still the only Apple Silicon Mac Pro.

1:30:38They updated the Mac Studio, and the Mac Pro came out five or six months later.

1:30:43And I think that's thrown us off expectation-wise, where we think, okay, five or six months after

1:30:49the Pro and the Max, we get an Ultra.

1:30:52But now here we are.

1:30:54The M3 Pros came out in October 2023.

1:30:58A year goes by, they come out with M4s, and everybody thinks, I guess they're skipping the

1:31:04Ultra for the M3 generation?

1:31:06Yeah.

1:31:06But now here we are another six months later, and now we finally get the M3 Ultra.

1:31:11Now, maybe there was an engineering fiasco behind the scenes, and it really was supposed to come out

1:31:19last year sometime, WWDC last year.

1:31:22There could have been constraints on the supply line.

1:31:31There could have been regulatory things.

1:31:35Talk about stuff like that.

1:31:36Something comes up to works.

1:31:37The rumor mill, the Germans and Ming-Chi Kuo's and Wayne Ma, the Informations of the World, aren't focused on Mac Pro components and Mac Studio components the way they are, the iPhone and iPads.

1:31:52So they could keep a lid on an engineering setback.

1:31:56This is going to be like, this is going to set us back nine months or a year longer than we were planning.

1:32:03What do we do?

1:32:05Do we cancel it?

1:32:06Or are we still far enough along that we might as well push through because it's going to come out before we would have an...

1:32:12I don't know.

1:32:13Those are tough decisions.

1:32:14These chips are not getting any simpler, architecture-wise, right?

1:32:19You're doubling the die.

1:32:23Maybe you're not just doubling the amount of work to get those to fix together.

1:32:30And they get double the memory bandwidth.

1:32:32So if you're doing something that is super constrained on the memory bandwidth, writing back and forth to it, that it's...

1:32:39It really...

1:32:40And again, if it was so easy to just double it, well, then they'd quadruple it and tuple it too, right?

1:32:47If you can just keep gluing them together, well, then there'd be an extreme and an...

1:32:51Back them up.

1:32:52Yeah.

1:32:52It obviously doesn't work like that.

1:32:55So who knows?

1:32:56But I thought that the two interesting things they did say...

1:32:59Again, I can't quote it, but other people heard the same thing in the same briefings.

1:33:04The Ultra does take a lot...

1:33:06It's their longest development time.

1:33:08And they said they may not have Ultras every generation.

1:33:12Well, they had one for the M2, and they had one for...

1:33:17Now they have one for the M3.

1:33:18If they don't have one every generation, does that mean we shouldn't wait for an M4?

1:33:26Ultra?

1:33:26And they're going to, you know...

1:33:28Or, yeah.

1:33:28Is it going to be in the M5 timeframe?

1:33:30Yeah.

1:33:30Who knows?

1:33:31Right.

1:33:31That the timeline is sort of, hey, maybe it's like odd number generations will get Ultras going forward.

1:33:39I don't know why they said that, but that was actually more of a hint that it...

1:33:46I always say...

1:33:46Yeah, there's a lot to read between the lines there.

1:33:49Being in the Apple media business is reading a lot into tiny little crumbs of clues, but that was a definite crumb.

1:33:57I mean, and it was definitely a canned response to the question.

1:34:01Like, he was ready to say that.

1:34:03It wasn't something that slipped.

1:34:04I think that's really interesting.

1:34:06But if not, if there is an M4 Ultra coming, well, then what the hell is he talking about?

1:34:12What?

1:34:12That they already know there's not an M5?

1:34:14That's...

1:34:15I don't know.

1:34:15I kind of feel like that...

1:34:17I take it to mean no M4 Ultra?

1:34:20Like, I know some people are thinking maybe this means the M4 Ultra will come out in a couple months at WWDC and it'll only be in the Mac Pro, and then there's an argument for why the Mac Pro and the Mac Studio are different products.

1:34:33But that doesn't make sense.

1:34:35I don't think that makes sense at all.

1:34:37I just don't.

1:34:38I mean, it's kind of weird.

1:34:40But I think that if they just called it the P chip or the X chip or whatever, then it could come out on a different 18-month or 24-month cycle, and people would get used to that, and they wouldn't be waiting for it, and it wouldn't seem weird.

1:34:55Well, the people that are going to be spending 15 to 20K on a Mac, right, they're going to budget it, right?

1:35:02They're going to have their own constraints for this thing.

1:35:06And, you know, if somebody like Adam Lizagor, you know, Sandwich, you've got this many clients, you know, you're going to have this many jobs, you're going to need this kind of hardware, let's budget out 20K per person for this hardware that we know is going to happen sometime mid-2027, let's say.

1:35:24So you just deal with it that way.

1:35:27Yeah, exactly.

1:35:29And it really is where it's left us is we still, I don't know, I mean, nobody seems to know what to guess the future of the Mac Pro is, right?

1:35:37I think a perfectly reasonable, defendable guess for what the future of the Mac Pro could range from Apple's going to cancel it and just say, you know what, the Mac Studio is our highest-end Mac, to, oh, they're planning something really good for the future of the Mac Pro, and it's going to make the Mac Studio look slow and cheap.

1:35:59The full range of options seems plausible, given what we know, but that just shows you how little planning anybody could make.

1:36:08Like you said, like somebody who has a budget for $40,000 or $50,000 worth of high-end, professional-grade workstations for video production work and wants to spend it soon, but you don't need it right now today, what should you do?

1:36:25I don't think there's a good answer.

1:36:28See, that's the thing, too, is that the Mac Pro exists so that you can put cards and stuff in it, right?

1:36:33And I suspect that these machines that people are buying, the cards probably cost as much as the machine itself.

1:36:40Yeah, often do, yeah.

1:36:41Right?

1:36:42So we're not talking about a $20,000 machine.

1:36:44We're probably talking about a $40,000 or $50,000 machine.

1:36:46Right.

1:36:47And these people, a little bit of predictability, yeah, Apple doesn't want to give away anything.

1:36:53They never do.

1:36:54But a little bit of predictability could go a long way.

1:36:58Right.

1:36:58Oh, yeah, this new Mac Pro is coming.

1:37:00It's going to have a P-chip in it.

1:37:02It's going to be super wonderful.

1:37:04Wow.

1:37:05And I can put my old cards in it if I need to, or I can upgrade, budget new cards, whatever.

1:37:10All right.

1:37:12Moving on.

1:37:13You mentioned it already, Tapestry, the Icon Factory's new app.

1:37:16I know it.

1:37:19I've been beta testing it for months.

1:37:21When did I start beta testing it?

1:37:23Yeah, it's something that's been in the works for a couple years, actually.

1:37:29Right.

1:37:29Yeah, start from the beginning.

1:37:31Where'd the idea, I guess it starts with Twitterific, really.

1:37:35Yeah.

1:37:36I like to say it's the scariest app we've ever made, right?

1:37:42There were so many things that were unknowns about this thing.

1:37:48And this is for everybody, right?

1:37:50This was a hard product to build.

1:37:53And yeah, it all started off when, in January of 2023, I guess it was, when they cut off our API access.

1:38:04Was it only 2023?

1:38:06Yeah, I guess it was 2023.

1:38:07Yeah, it's like two years ago.

1:38:10A little over two years ago.

1:38:11We lost a third of our revenue there, right?

1:38:14And we had the whole refund situation with Apple.

1:38:17Yeah, yeah, I remember.

1:38:19We took a financial hit there, right?

1:38:20It was, that's the first part that was scary, right?

1:38:23Right.

1:38:23It's like, oh, shit.

1:38:24We're a company that's been around for 30 years next year.

1:38:28Yeah.

1:38:28We've been around a while.

1:38:30And we were all like, is this the end?

1:38:32Right?

1:38:33It was a dire situation.

1:38:38It's one of the great stories of our developer community that you're friends with the guys at TapBots, makers of TweetBot.

1:38:44Yeah, yeah.

1:38:45And there was sort of a camaraderie.

1:38:47And it was two different Twitter clients with very different takes on it that appealed to different audiences.

1:38:53But both companies were in the same situation where you had sold your annual subscriptions to the app.

1:39:02And now the app stops.

1:39:05And in some jurisdictions, you have to give them back.

1:39:07Yeah.

1:39:07Right.

1:39:07And the app stopped working.

1:39:09You're pre-selling.

1:39:09Right.

1:39:10And it's like, huh.

1:39:12And it's, again, you wrote about it at the time.

1:39:15To Apple's credit, they went out of their way to make it so that people could say, no, I don't want a refund.

1:39:20Right.

1:39:21Right?

1:39:21I like these guys.

1:39:23They've given me an app that I enjoy, and I don't need a refund.

1:39:27Right.

1:39:27I mean, that is not something that Apple has done ever.

1:39:31And will they do it again?

1:39:33Who knows?

1:39:34But it was definitely a situation where Paul and Mark and us were just in the same boat.

1:39:42That's Paul Haddad and Mark Jardine.

1:39:44Yeah, Paul Haddad and Mark Jardine at TapBots.

1:39:47All right.

1:39:47So, yeah, we were just kind of looking at it as like, are we going to make it?

1:39:52And I wasn't going to let that shithead get the better of me.

1:39:57It really came down to that.

1:40:00I started prototyping and thinking about things we could do.

1:40:05And this whole notion of a universal timeline is something that had been kind of rattling around in my brain for a while.

1:40:13A couple of interesting things is that when Twitter shut down, there was this bot that posted every day, the Nancy comic at GoComics.

1:40:23And I love that.

1:40:24Right?

1:40:24Yeah.

1:40:25And all of a sudden, I didn't have it.

1:40:26I also noticed that there were some websites that I kept tabs open that I would refresh periodically.

1:40:32Your site, Kotki.

1:40:34I follow Michael Sy's blog for tech news and developer news.

1:40:39And it was right after that time that we'd been working with Brent Simmons and Matt and Reese on the JSON feed stuff.

1:40:49So it's like kind of all of these things where it's like there was some sort of commonality there.

1:40:55JSON feed was Manton and Brent, I think, are the two.

1:40:59Yeah.

1:41:00Maybe it's the lead author.

1:41:01But basically, it was a way to do a spec to do something like RSS, but instead of with XML as the underlying tech format, use JSON instead.

1:41:14Do RSS type things encoded as JSON.

1:41:18How should you do it?

1:41:19And how can we make a spec that people could follow that would be, hey, let's not assume it's a blog.

1:41:25Let's not assume it's something like Twitter.

1:41:27It could be anything that fits in a feed.

1:41:29Yeah, exactly.

1:41:30Manton wanted to use it for the feeds for users at microblog, right?

1:41:35Brent's obviously looking at it.

1:41:37How's it going to work in a newsreader?

1:41:39Right.

1:41:39That kind of thing.

1:41:40To me, it was like, okay, feeds are starting to become relevant again, right?

1:41:46And this, you know, missing Nancy, right?

1:41:48This bot was essentially a feed, right?

1:41:52Your website has RSS feed.

1:41:55So does Kotki, right?

1:41:56Why am I looking at it in Safari?

1:41:58Right.

1:41:58Especially when some sites, I'm not going to name names, don't look great in a browser on a mobile device.

1:42:07Right.

1:42:07I hear you.

1:42:08That's my tapestry ad.

1:42:14Yeah, well, you know, and you've told me before, right?

1:42:16You look at it and be, be at it.

1:42:18You read Daring Fireball in a different environment than everybody else.

1:42:20Well, but that's not why it's not updated.

1:42:23It's more lethargy and inertia.

1:42:26Having better things to do, right.

1:42:28Well, or, yeah.

1:42:30I wouldn't put it that way because I think it's at a certain point.

1:42:35I think it's letting the urgent override the important for too long.

1:42:41Like, I should have a perfect looking mobile look on the iPhone on Daring Fireball by now.

1:42:48But I don't, and who knows when I will.

1:42:50But I should, and I don't have a good excuse.

1:42:53I don't want to make it sound like I think there's a good excuse for it.

1:42:55And it's not just persnickety holding on to an old way of the way it looks, although that's the way it feels at this point.

1:43:03But anyway, keep going.

1:43:04Well, it's also a harder problem than people realize, right?

1:43:07What's the markdown spec going to look like on a mobile device where it needs some width?

1:43:13And I've actually looked at your site and looked at your markup and thought, how would this be?

1:43:18Oh, it's possible.

1:43:20I mean, there's solutions to it.

1:43:23But because I want to, and the other thing is because I want to do it myself, I would want, or I want to be involved at least, it would need me to divert attention.

1:43:32I could spend writing stuff today, tomorrow, doing a podcast with you today to doing that, right?

1:43:39But anyway, keep going, because I feel like talking about my site.

1:43:43So there were all of these motivations for a universal timeline, right?

1:43:48I wanted all these things to be in one place, in one app.

1:43:52And one day, I stumbled across this article at NSHipster, which is a developer blog, talking about this thing called JavaScript Core, which is something that's on all Apple platforms.

1:44:02It's basically Apple's JavaScript engine that they use in Safari.

1:44:07And having done several versions of a Twitter app, one of the hard problems is mapping the data that comes over the wire in an API request.

1:44:19It's a big blob of data, and you don't need all of it.

1:44:22You need to pick parts of it, and you need a username, you need to get the date, that kind of thing.

1:44:28That's kind of a pain in the butt.

1:44:29But since all this data is arriving in a JSON format, doing it in JavaScript is really easy, right?

1:44:38It's JSON.

1:44:39Right.

1:44:40It already is JavaScript.

1:44:42The native format for JavaScript.

1:44:43Right.

1:44:44So that's kind of where this idea of, okay, I could build these things called connectors.

1:44:49I called them plugins at that point.

1:44:51But it was basically that these things could exist to map data from whatever happens over the network to what the app needs.

1:45:00Pull out a standard title.

1:45:02Pull out a standard date.

1:45:03Pull out a standard body.

1:45:04And I started working this idea, and that's when this Muxer prototype kind of came down.

1:45:13Muxer was a terrible name.

1:45:16How did you spell it?

1:45:17M-U-X-E-R.

1:45:20M-U-X-E-R, right?

1:45:20Everybody who heard it was like, ugh.

1:45:22But it was one of those things.

1:45:24It's like, I know the name's going to change.

1:45:26You know what's funny?

1:45:27It's a multiplexer.

1:45:27It's a cool name, but it's not a pleasant name, right?

1:45:32Exactly.

1:45:33It's not a product name, right?

1:45:35It's like I told the designers the name of it, and they're going, ugh.

1:45:38But basically what you were thinking is how do you send, how do you filter various streams of input into one timeline?

1:45:50Yeah.

1:45:51That was the idea, and it worked, right?

1:45:58You know, I had this prototype, but at the same time, it was like people get excited about products.

1:46:04They don't get excited about protocols.

1:46:06And this was very much a protocol kind of thing, right?

1:46:08I had built this thing to map data from one point to another point, and it's like I wasn't even sure it was a good demo, right?

1:46:14This whole thing is a part of it being scary, right?

1:46:18It's like if I had this thing, it worked, but was it a product?

1:46:23And I got some encouragement from some people.

1:46:25I mean, I remember Cable Sasser heard about it and got all excited about it, and there were definitely some signs that this could be a thing.

1:46:33But, yeah, it took us about a year to work this concept through to get to the point where we could actually talk about it on a Kickstarter pitch.

1:46:41And by that time, the money situation was even more scary.

1:46:45Right.

1:46:46So, you know, we're making this pitch and kind of flying by the seat of our pants, right?

1:46:52We had this idea.

1:46:52We had this notion, and it wasn't fully formed.

1:46:58We had some imposter syndrome because of that, right?

1:47:01Everything else we'd done in the past, we'd been very confident about.

1:47:05We knew what we were going to build, and this was kind of a lot of question marks.

1:47:09Yeah.

1:47:10The best you could say is that we knew what we didn't know.

1:47:14Right.

1:47:15You guys have, like you said, Twitterific was like 30% of the companies.

1:47:22Revenue, about a third.

1:47:23Some of your other big products are, I'm not sure which ones are bigger hits than others.

1:47:28I know which ones I use.

1:47:31I use Xscope, but maybe that's not big.

1:47:34Xscope is one of our mid-range products.

1:47:38You've got some games.

1:47:39Linnea right now is the big one.

1:47:41Which one?

1:47:41Linnea, the sketching app.

1:47:44Well, as I say it, Linnea.

1:47:45A lot of artists love it and use it, including our own.

1:47:48Yeah.

1:47:49You talked about it last time you were on the show.

1:47:50Linnea is a good one.

1:47:51Tot is another one that a lot of people love.

1:47:56I use Tot every day, every single day.

1:47:59And, again, just to revisit just really quickly, your whole thing with me and me being sort of a mess, the you only get eight Tots in Tot, is it's a forcing function to keep me from piling up and turning it into a full-fledged notes app, right?

1:48:18That I've got eight scraps of paper in notes, in Tot, and that's it.

1:48:23And that's actually a feature, not a limit, you know, for me.

1:48:27But, anyway, yeah.

1:48:27So, you've got other apps, but you're looking to fill the void that Twitterific left.

1:48:33Yeah.

1:48:34So, and we'd gotten to the point where we felt pretty comfortable with the concept and how we could pitch it.

1:48:43Yeah.

1:48:43So, when was that?

1:48:45When the project got funded, it was a blessing, right?

1:48:48It's just, in fact, we are still so grateful to the backers, right?

1:48:51They really kind of saved our ass there.

1:48:53In fact, we got all sorts of little goodies in the app for the people that backed us.

1:48:58Kickstarter's sort of gotten, it's been around long enough, and you guys have done several of them.

1:49:03And it's, there have been some high-profile Kickstarters over the years that never shipped.

1:49:10And that is part of, it's been a part of the premise from the beginning, right?

1:49:14That it is sort of speculative, and it's sort of like user-funded venture capital, right?

1:49:20Not venture capital, V.C., and it's the official, go meet somebody on Sand Hill Road and have a pitch deck or whatever.

1:49:27This is a venture.

1:49:28It is like an ad venture.

1:49:32Well, yeah, when you press the button on Kickstarter, it says there are no guarantees, you know?

1:49:42This is not, this may not result in anything.

1:49:45You're flying with a promise here.

1:49:50And it is, it is, tapestry is exactly the sort of project, I mean, you could, the angel investors, you can always find a rich person who, if you knew, you know, somebody who was interested in this, somebody who's got silly amounts of money could fund it, right?

1:50:10So, and again, that's how the Medicis commissioned all the art back in the Renaissance.

1:50:16You know, rich people can always pay to have things made, which I'm not putting down.

1:50:20Right, I mean, but the benefit to us, at least, with having a group of people, you've got an immediate community, right?

1:50:29Right, and you don't have to answer to one person.

1:50:30You're not beholding to one person.

1:50:32Right.

1:50:33You're not beholding to some guy with deep pockets.

1:50:35You're talking about a bunch of people that want the same thing.

1:50:39As beneficial and as nice as your rich uncle moneybags, who might have single-handedly funded the development of tapestry, could be, unless it's literally like your grandfather or somebody who's like, here, I'll just give you the money.

1:50:56I don't even know what you're talking about.

1:50:57I don't even want to see it.

1:50:58But if they're giving you the money because they do want to see it, you're kind of building it for them, right?

1:51:03Right.

1:51:03They're going to say, I want the icon to be purple.

1:51:05Yeah.

1:51:06You're going to make the icon purple, even if you don't want it.

1:51:09You'll try once to talk them out of purple, but then it's like, if they say purple again, you're like, okay, I guess it's going to be purple.

1:51:16Yeah, yeah.

1:51:17So when was that?

1:51:18When was the Kickstarter?

1:51:18About 14 months ago.

1:51:20And we got funded and super happy, but also kind of scary because we had the idea, we had the concept, but we also knew there was going to be a ton of work.

1:51:33It seems to me as a casual, a friend of yours and a beta tester, but from what I remember, the plan, it seems like it took about as long as you thought it would.

1:51:43Yeah.

1:51:44No, we said during the Kickstarter, it would take nine to 12 months.

1:51:47Which kind of never happens.

1:51:49When does that ever happen?

1:51:51Yeah.

1:51:51No.

1:51:52Well, this is not the first app we've ever built.

1:51:55I know.

1:51:55Not the first kind of social timeline thing.

1:51:57We knew what we were in for.

1:51:59And that, again, is part of the scary part, right?

1:52:01It's like, this is a totally different thing.

1:52:03It could.

1:52:06We're trying to take all these different various sources on the internet, which are just like, it's like a whole smorgasbord of stuff and present it all in a nice, beautiful way.

1:52:16Right.

1:52:17Get and Anthony and Talos and the developer.

1:52:21It is beautiful.

1:52:22They did a great job of cleaning the thing up.

1:52:25Yep.

1:52:26Right.

1:52:27It simultaneously looks new and different than anything before it does not.

1:52:33Nobody's going to open it up and think, oh, it's Twitter-rific.

1:52:36But it also does look Icon Factory-ish, right?

1:52:40Yeah.

1:52:40It's us.

1:52:42Yeah.

1:52:42Right.

1:52:42And it's got our personality in it as well, which I think is very important.

1:52:48You know, we could have gone with some sort of least common denominator bullshit, right?

1:52:52That is not us, right?

1:52:54You're right.

1:52:57In a way, it's like Twitter-rific on steroids, right?

1:53:00Super Twitter-rific.

1:53:02So anybody out here who's listening and hasn't tried it yet, what is the intended experience?

1:53:08Okay.

1:53:08Joe and Jane, listener of the talk show, are hearing us.

1:53:12They're like, this sounds interesting, but what's the basic idea?

1:53:14I go to the App Store.

1:53:16I get Tapestry.

1:53:17I open it.

1:53:18And then what?

1:53:18You are in control of what is in your feed.

1:53:24It's one feed that looks like a Twitter-type feed.

1:53:27It can be multiple feeds.

1:53:28You can slice and dice the feed.

1:53:30But there's one continuous chronological flow of information that comes from blogs.

1:53:36It comes from Blue Sky.

1:53:38It can come from Mastodon, Tumblr, all these different services, different parts of these services.

1:53:45There's a connector for Go Comics, so I get my Nancy comic.

1:53:49Right.

1:53:50One of the first ones I wrote.

1:53:52And Calvin and Hobbes, right?

1:53:55Yeah.

1:53:55Yeah.

1:53:56Yeah.

1:53:56Yeah.

1:53:56Calvin and Hobbes.

1:53:58There are some comics that I just love to see every day.

1:54:02And those just appear in my timeline, and it's kind of a happy moment when I scroll across them.

1:54:07And the comics are an interesting one, and it's one of my favorite parts of Tapestry, because I see them now regularly in a way that I never used to with Twitter before.

1:54:17Even though, like you said, you could follow those things on Twitter before, and I'm sure they're posting to Blue Sky and other places.

1:54:23But I see them every day in my Tapestry feed, because my Tapestry feed is not overwhelming getting Twitter in the last 10 years.

1:54:35Mastodon isn't like that for me, and that's why I spend more time on Mastodon.

1:54:41But Blue Sky has already shot up in popularity to the point where it's like getting the phone book delivered every day.

1:54:47And I can open it.

1:54:48You know, I can scroll for a couple minutes and find interesting stuff and find links and find some commentary I like.

1:54:53But the idea of seeing everything from the people I follow, it's untenable.

1:54:58I mean, I'd go from waking up in the morning to midnight, and still, having done nothing else all day, I still wouldn't complete it.

1:55:07It's a fire hose, right?

1:55:10Whereas my Tapestry feed is not.

1:55:12My Tapestry feed is like a nice little personal newsletter.

1:55:16Yeah, that's a really good way to look at it.

1:55:19It's your best of.

1:55:21It's like one of the first things I added in the Muxer was Daring Firewall.

1:55:26The next thing was Kotki, right?

1:55:28And I had my Go Comics Nancy there.

1:55:31But is it all of your Blue Sky?

1:55:33Like, you just turn on your Blue Sky feed, just shows up, melded into Tapestry?

1:55:38Yeah, you can do that if you want.

1:55:40There's some people that want to do that.

1:55:41I personally do not.

1:55:42I just want to, you know, I don't want to see the replies from people on Blue Sky and Tapestry.

1:55:47I just want to see what individuals say.

1:55:50And in the next release, we're going to have the ability to actually follow a single account.

1:55:55So, like, if you just want to see the Brimley Cocoon line account.

1:55:58Which I, if I could give you any, you know, and I probably should have because I was beta testing and I'm your friend, so forgive me.

1:56:06That would have been my one feedback, is that for two reasons.

1:56:10A, I think you did the hard thing first, which is digesting more, right?

1:56:16So, in some sense, maybe that was the right way to tackle it.

1:56:20Engineering-wise, it's better to do the hard thing first than the easy thing, because maybe the hard thing is so hard you won't get it done.

1:56:28Well, yeah, we had to go figure out what kind of stuff is in these different feeds.

1:56:34Right.

1:56:34The feed that you get from Macedon is very different than the feed you get from Blue Sky.

1:56:39But it's not what I want in Tapestry.

1:56:42And so, just selfishly as a user who has this app now on my first home screen and really likes having it there, not just because you're my friend and not just because I wanted you on my show,

1:56:52this app is satisfying itch or a desire or satiating me in a way that there is no other app quite like it.

1:57:03But I don't want to use it as a client for Blue Sky and Threads or Mastodon, because I have clients for those things.

1:57:11And the fact that those things are so overwhelming, even though I try to, I don't willy-nilly follow people on Blue Sky, but already my Blue Sky feed is too much.

1:57:23I don't want that.

1:57:23You know, like if it's a weather service that once every three hours posts to Blue Sky, that's more like an RSS feed, right?

1:57:33And I want that.

1:57:35And it doesn't, the fact that it's a Blue Sky feed doesn't make any more difference to me than if it's an RSS feed or an Atom-formatted XML feed.

1:57:44That's just an implementation detail.

1:57:46That's, you know.

1:57:48Right.

1:57:48It's good to hear that you're using it this way, because that's kind of the way that it was designed.

1:57:53We've had people, you know, start using the app, and the first thing they do is they load 300 of their RSS feeds from an OPML file.

1:58:02And it's like, yeah, then we hear a little bit later, it's like, oh, I've gone and trimmed stuff back, right?

1:58:07It's using, it's like your personal newsletter, right?

1:58:10It's like the things that generally interest you and you want to stay on top of.

1:58:16And it's better to build it up than to have a fire hose and trim it down, I think.

1:58:21Right, right, right.

1:58:22One of the things that was really core to the design is that we were putting the user in control of this stuff, right?

1:58:30Number one, it's chronological, and it's stuff that you pick, right?

1:58:35It's not, there's no kind of algorithm out there saying, hey, here you go.

1:58:39We think this might interest you.

1:58:41No, you've got to be active about it.

1:58:44Did you see that video, the technology connections video last week where the guy was talking about,

1:58:51you've got to mind your feeds and how your life on the internet is better when you do that?

1:58:56That just totally resonated with us.

1:58:59But that was maybe more than a week ago.

1:59:00Yeah, it's a half-hour video.

1:59:02It's well worth watching, and it's kind of, the guy could have written it as our manifesto.

1:59:09The other important part is we don't know who you are, right?

1:59:13The app is very private.

1:59:15All of the work is done on device, so there's no servers out there tracking what you're doing.

1:59:21If you hadn't told me, I couldn't tell you what you're looking at in tapestry.

1:59:26Honestly, I don't care.

1:59:28Right, you don't want to know, right?

1:59:30No, you don't.

1:59:30I don't want to know, right, exactly.

1:59:32Right, it would be great if the FBI shows up and says, hey, Icon Factory, there's somebody,

1:59:38we're looking at this person and they're using your app.

1:59:41Tell us what they're reading in your app.

1:59:43You get to say, I don't know.

1:59:46We don't know.

1:59:47We can't know.

1:59:48Sorry.

1:59:49Here's the disk on our server.

1:59:50Go knock yourself out.

1:59:52There's literally nothing there.

1:59:54Yeah, and it feels good on an app privacy label to say, no data collected.

1:59:59Yeah.

2:00:00That's a totally honest thing.

2:00:02But it's a hard thing to describe, though, right?

2:00:07And Ben Thompson, my dithering colleague, he's done a good job over the years, and especially

2:00:15even recently talking about how the feed, the idea of feeds from a user's perspective, not

2:00:21a technical format, but that users open a thing and they have a scrolling feed that they

2:00:26can go through, has become the predominant form of media consumption.

2:00:31And it kind of snuck up on everybody, right?

2:00:36And there is the whole Google Reader shutdown reset of RSS feeds, which is now closer to

2:00:4920 years ago than, I think it was like 2006 or 2007 or so when Google Reader shut down.

2:00:54It started that whole idea.

2:00:56RSS is dead.

2:00:57It died with Google Reader.

2:00:59And it's not dead, dead, but it's never going to come up or never going to resurge or anything.

2:01:05And it didn't ever resurge in the way that it was surging from 2002 to 2006 or so.

2:01:15But also, the overall design of the feed readers of that era, it was sort of a dead end anyway,

2:01:25right?

2:01:25I think I certainly, Google Reader was hugely disruptive to my business because so many people

2:01:33were using it, but then I ended up, that's where I came up with the whole RSS feed sponsorships

2:01:39that I've built.

2:01:40By adapting to it, I actually built the financial model that let me go full-time with Daring Fireball.

2:01:48Right.

2:01:49But at the time...

2:01:49Didn't you have some authorization or something at some point, didn't you?

2:01:52It's like you had to, your members had a special code or URL or something.

2:01:56You got a special, I didn't want to make people log in, so I just gave everybody their own

2:02:00custom URL.

2:02:01So you got a mat, it was ugly, no, not ugly, I tried to make it as, but like a random string,

2:02:06each user had their own and you weren't supposed to share it because you were paying me for it.

2:02:12But Google Reader would share URL.

2:02:15So if you'd search for Daring Fireball, you would get, in Google Reader, you'd get A, the

2:02:22one that I was making free for everybody, which didn't have the full content of the site, which

2:02:28is what you, if you weren't a paying member, you were supposed to get.

2:02:31But then all of the members' feeds that were supposed to be one for each user were showing

2:02:38up, and if you didn't know that, this isn't people trying to pirate or bootleg my content.

2:02:43Yeah, it's automatic piracy, right?

2:02:45No, it was innocent people who were like, well, here's this feed that's the first one, but it

2:02:50has limited articles, it doesn't show the full article content, and here's these other ones

2:02:55with the full article content, I'll subscribe to them.

2:02:57And so every day there'd be like just a random user's feed from Daring Fireball, it was supposed

2:03:02to be just for them, that like 100 people were subscribed to.

2:03:06Right, but in the end, it led to a better business model for you, too.

2:03:10Yeah, it did, and it led to a better experience where the whole feed is free for everybody with

2:03:14full article content, but I had to adapt to it.

2:03:16But I think the whole idea that the Google Readers, and then when Google Readers shut down, people

2:03:20using RSS dropped off spectacularly.

2:03:22But I think the whole thing was a dead end, because it was all pre-iPhone.

2:03:27And post-iPhone, the single-column, Twitter-style, infinite feed is the model.

2:03:37That's the thing that Twitter stumbled onto almost by accident with the original concept for Twitter,

2:03:42that just one feed that you just scroll.

2:03:46And it could be everything, if I'm interested in politics and Apple and the New York Yankees.

2:03:53I had the first scrolling list of Twitter on a phone, and it was pretty freaking awesome.

2:04:00And it was obvious at that point that this is the way things...

2:04:03And, you know, Lauren Brichter came along and improved on that idea with pull-to-refresh,

2:04:08which is, again, another thing that's just totally natural.

2:04:11Right, but Twitter came out in 2006 before the iPhone was even announced.

2:04:17But it turned out that what they came out with was not the look of Twitter.com in 2006,

2:04:24but the idea of these little 140-character nuggets with URLs and eventually images that you could show

2:04:30that you just put in one timeline and just scroll was the model for the future.

2:04:36And it really is a great model.

2:04:38And that was, in developing tapestry, that was the easy part, right?

2:04:42We knew what a timeline should be and how it should act.

2:04:48How does it look?

2:04:49How do we pour all of these various sources of information into that timeline?

2:04:55That was a really hard design problem.

2:04:57It was also a really hard technical problem.

2:04:59Right.

2:04:59The other thing...

2:05:01But here's where I think...

2:05:02I just want to revisit my thing about where I think maybe it was the wrong order

2:05:06to put following your whole Blue Sky feed and pouring it into tapestry before...

2:05:13Just let me pick these two people on Blue Sky and put those two accounts in my tapestry

2:05:19is I think it sets the wrong idea in people's heads that tapestry is a multi-social network

2:05:26social network client.

2:05:27Yeah.

2:05:28Yeah.

2:05:29And because I wrote about...

2:05:31I can see that.

2:05:32That's a totally valid perception, right?

2:05:35I got so...

2:05:38I mean, I just say it because you're here and I didn't mean it.

2:05:41But like back in January, I wrote about...

2:05:44I'm already forgetting the name of the app.

2:05:46I tried some app that was supposed to be an open vibe, a multi-social network app for Blue

2:05:53Sky, Mastodon, Threads, and supposedly Noster.

2:05:56It's like a Twitter-rific, tweet-bot, ivory-style app for your phone that lets you subscribe to

2:06:06Blue Sky and Mastodon and Threads all in one app.

2:06:09And some people think they want it.

2:06:11And I wish them good luck.

2:06:12I gave it a try.

2:06:13And I thought it was so...

2:06:15Sort of like...

2:06:16I don't want to waste my time writing bad reviews.

2:06:19Right.

2:06:20The thing you have to be careful of is the overload, right?

2:06:24Even back in the days when we were using Twitter, right?

2:06:27You had to unfollow accounts.

2:06:29Some accounts were just too noisy, right?

2:06:31They're too noisy.

2:06:32And I...

2:06:33I love Glenn Fleischman, but I could never follow him on Twitter.

2:06:36I just couldn't.

2:06:37You know what?

2:06:38Glenn's the first one to admit.

2:06:39He's like, I don't know.

2:06:40I couldn't follow him on Twitter.

2:06:41I've talked to him in person about it.

2:06:43He's like, yeah, that's just the way it is.

2:06:45Fine.

2:06:48But I wrote about OpenVibe and tried not being mean, but saying, here's why I don't think

2:06:53it's a good idea.

2:06:54The other thing, I have Ivory, which is a great Mastodon client by the TapBots.

2:07:00And the BlueSky native, you know, the official client isn't too bad and there's a couple of other third-party BlueSky clients.

2:07:09And Threads makes...

2:07:10Meta makes a pretty good Threads client.

2:07:13Threads doesn't have an API, so you cannot make a third-party client.

2:07:18They have a posting API.

2:07:20They don't have a reading API.

2:07:22Which is very different, right?

2:07:23And people ask us all the time, oh, can you support Threads?

2:07:27Yeah, no.

2:07:27No more than what you support.

2:07:29But I don't know.

2:07:30OpenVibe is trying to somehow be a Threads client.

2:07:33That's why I wrote supposedly in my headline.

2:07:35They're trying to shim, cram their way into acting as a Threads client by being a Mastodon client.

2:07:43But even if you could make it work perfectly, there are semantic differences between how BlueSky and Mastodon and Threads work.

2:07:52Character limits are the most obvious one, right?

2:07:54Yeah, the kind of media you can post, the size of the images, the size of the videos.

2:07:59People just kind of look at it on the surface and it's, yeah, these all look the same, right?

2:08:04They're all scrolling lists.

2:08:06But each of these platforms.

2:08:07But there's subtle things.

2:08:08It's like on Mastodon you call them boosts and on BlueSky you call them repos.

2:08:12Yeah.

2:08:12Which name do you pick?

2:08:15Those things add up and if you try to make a multi-platform client that addresses them all, it becomes bad at all of those things or mediocre at best at all of those things.

2:08:27That's what I was saying earlier.

2:08:29We didn't want to become a least common denominator, right?

2:08:31Right.

2:08:31It's let's just make the crappy social client, right?

2:08:35But I know, let's make the great feed reader.

2:08:37I published that article on January 28th and I haven't been writing about it on Daring Fireball, but I've been testing.

2:08:46I guess I linked to your Kickstarter a year ago, but I don't expect readers to remember that I definitely mentioned Tapestry over a year, 14 months ago or something.

2:08:56But I got a bunch of email, a surprising amount of email from people after I wrote about OpenVibe and gave a thumbs down both to OpenVibe in particular and sort of made the case against a multi-network client in general.

2:09:11I got email from people saying, oh, my God, I know you're friends with the guys at the Icon Factory, but, you know, they just came out with one, Tapestry.

2:09:19I'm not saying I got like hundreds of emails like that, but I got dozens of people saying, oh, Tapestry, maybe you'll like Tapestry.

2:09:26Tapestry is a better looking version of that.

2:09:29That is part of the scary part, right?

2:09:31People not knowing what you're building, right?

2:09:35Right, that's not it.

2:09:36That was one of the things.

2:09:37That's not what we were aiming for.

2:09:39And it shouldn't be, right?

2:09:42It's not what you're aiming for and it shouldn't be, but it's hard to set people's expectations, though, because the best way to understand a new thing is to say it's like this or like Jack meets Jill.

2:09:56Oh, I get it.

2:09:58But it's a little bit, I don't know, that's famously how movies are pitched.

2:10:02It's like Star Wars meets Die Hard, right?

2:10:05It's in a spaceship.

2:10:07Our last Kickstarter was Twitterific for Mac, right?

2:10:09People knew what Twitterific was.

2:10:11They know what a Mac is.

2:10:12They know what you're making.

2:10:13Right.

2:10:14That was an easy pitch.

2:10:16So the idea of a scrolling feed with new content coming from multiple sources is like Twitter.

2:10:24It is like Mastodon.

2:10:26In a way, it's like TikTok.

2:10:28It's a different type of scrolling, but it's like a feed and you go up and down to get more.

2:10:33But where the sources come from and the fact that it's not algorithmic is totally different.

2:10:41So it is, I guess, the closest is to being like an RSS reader.

2:10:46But it's not just RSS.

2:10:47Right.

2:10:48That's this whole thing with the connectors, right?

2:10:51It's like they can load.

2:10:53Basically, if there's anything out there that's readable on the internet, you can get it into Tapestry.

2:10:58Right.

2:10:59And because you can add these things to the app, we don't necessarily – like in the past month that the product has been out, there's been connectors for Glass, Lemmy, PixelFed.

2:11:16Well, somebody wrote one for Gmail, right?

2:11:18You know, it's like you chose your Gmail inbox.

2:11:21If that's what you want.

2:11:22If somebody wants that, great.

2:11:24I personally don't.

2:11:26That's a really good sign.

2:11:27So where do third-party connectors – where are they hosted?

2:11:32So it's not just about getting a feed.

2:11:34We're just getting ready to put up on our website a page that shows the most popular ones that we've heard about.

2:11:41It's probably going to grow beyond that at some point, and we'll have to have some sort of repository, you know, maybe something like how you can browse through WordPress plugins, maybe something like that.

2:11:53I don't know.

2:11:53We'll cross that bridge when we get to it.

2:11:56Plugins as a concept never disappeared, but they peaked.

2:12:02They peaked at a certain point, right?

2:12:04Just in very broad strokes, like in the 80s.

2:12:08In the 90s, yeah, with Photoshop plugins and WorkExpress plugins.

2:12:11In the 80s, there weren't really plugins or extensions.

2:12:14You got apps – because our computers really could only do one thing at a time, and they ran off floppy disks for a lot of that era.

2:12:21So the idea of an extension for an app – or we didn't even call them apps for programs.

2:12:26It didn't really make sense.

2:12:28And then in the 90s, things got richer, and you could do more things.

2:12:32And the idea – it was almost at that point where I wouldn't really consider using an app that didn't have an extension mechanism, right?

2:12:39And not out of principle, but out of, oh, that's just a sign that this isn't going – this isn't worth it.

2:12:48Because all of the apps I do use have extensions, right?

2:12:50BBEdit had extensions and scripts.

2:12:52Photoshop.

2:12:54When an app supported plugins or extensions, it meant that you could customize it to the way that you needed it to be.

2:13:00Right.

2:13:01Or you could build a weird thing that had a niche audience, and you couldn't – it wouldn't make sense to expound the engineering effort to do everything Photoshop already did just to serve Kai's power tools, right?

2:13:17Or it's a talking moose extension, right?

2:13:20You could customize your OS, right?

2:13:22Not everybody needed a talking moose, but the people who needed it, they wanted it.

2:13:26But nobody was going to build a whole OS just to have a talking moose up in the corner.

2:13:30No, no.

2:13:31Exactly.

2:13:31Right.

2:13:32Exactly.

2:13:32And that's kind of – tapestry's kind of got an old-school approach there, right?

2:13:37You can customize this thing.

2:13:39Right.

2:13:39You can make it what you want it to be.

2:13:41I made it what I wanted it to be, but I also made it in a way that other people can take that work and riff on it, right?

2:13:50All the connectors are open source, right?

2:13:53If you want to go look at our repository and figure out how we're reading data off of Mastodon or Blue Sky or whatever, it's all there, right?

2:14:00And it's JavaScript.

2:14:01Anybody can figure it out.

2:14:03It's not that hard.

2:14:05All of the great plug-in extensions, connectors, whatever you want to – I think connectors is a great name because it is sort of – for you, but for tapestry.

2:14:16But this sort of – it's the same sort of thing, right?

2:14:19At some level, it's just semantics, whether you call them plug-ins or what are connectors.

2:14:23They are plug-ins for tapestry.

2:14:25But all great plug-in systems usually have a story where the creator of the app or the platform that hosts them will say, then this one came along.

2:14:36We never imagined something like this, right?

2:14:40We had no idea.

2:14:41And Rich Siegel has told this story many times about BB Edit where BB Edit, he first started developing it in 1990 or 91.

2:14:50And it wasn't public, and then the first public version came out in 91 or 92.

2:14:55And it had, by version 2 or 3, the extension interface, and you could build, like, pallet in the extension.

2:15:03And there was one day around 1994 or so where a whole bunch of people started emailing bare-bones support about this HTML extension that somebody had built.

2:15:16And they had questions about it and wanted blah, blah, blah.

2:15:19And Rich and Patrick Woolsey, his longtime colleague, partner, bare-bones, were like, what's HTML?

2:15:25What is that?

2:15:26And then they looked it up, and they're like – it's like, oh, it's another new thing for the internet at the time.

2:15:37Oh, the web.

2:15:38It's like, yeah, I heard about that mosaic thing.

2:15:39Oh, I see.

2:15:40Okay.

2:15:40And then somebody like Rich or anybody who knows programming languages could look at – especially in 1994 or 1995 could look at ViewSource in a browser and say, oh, I get it.

2:15:51Why – and why you'd want to use a text editor.

2:15:53And why you'd want, like, a little extension that you could select text and then hit a button for a paragraph tag, and it would wrap it in a paragraph tag.

2:16:01Or hit a button for an image tag, and then it would prop a dialogue up that gave you all the fields for the image tag.

2:16:08Select some text.

2:16:10Make it bold.

2:16:10Right.

2:16:11And they wound up buying the HTML extension and building it in for a long time.

2:16:18Then by, like, 1996 or 7, there were a zillion people using BBEdit who didn't think of it as a text editor.

2:16:24They thought of it as an HTML editor because the web had exploded.

2:16:28BBEdit hadn't been designed – they didn't know what HTML was when it was created.

2:16:33They didn't know what it was when the extension first came out.

2:16:36And by 1996, there were a million users who thought it was an HTML editor.

2:16:41And the core of BBEdit never changed.

2:16:44So if you didn't use BBEdit for HTML, if you still used it to write C code or just text files or parse log files, it was not in your way because it was an extension.

2:16:56Right?

2:16:57You give people tools to do interesting things, and they'll do interesting things.

2:17:03Right?

2:17:04It's like the whole thing with shortcuts on iOS.

2:17:07Right.

2:17:08You give people what is a pretty simple interface, and they end up doing some really complex and unique things, things that you never could have guessed that would be done.

2:17:20What's going to happen with tapestry in the next five years?

2:17:25I have no idea.

2:17:26Right.

2:17:27And if it's successful, it'll be in ways that you didn't imagine.

2:17:31And it is the hardest thing in the world.

2:17:33That's exactly what I'm hoping.

2:17:35That's exactly what I'm hoping.

2:17:38So how do you build a connector interface that allows for the creation of things you didn't imagine?

2:17:43You don't know.

2:17:44Right?

2:17:44That's the uncertainty you're facing.

2:17:47But I think you've got it.

2:17:49Right?

2:17:49And it's like any kind of serialized thing that could be put into a feed that you could parse and read, a connector could be made to take that source, put it into tapestry, and then it just gets braided into your tapestry feed.

2:18:07And in chronological order.

2:18:08I've got a good connector story here.

2:18:12All right.

2:18:13Have you ever ridden on Mr. Toad's Wild Ride at Disneyland?

2:18:15No, I have not, because I've never been to Disneyland.

2:18:18Or Disney World.

2:18:20But you've been on Mr. Toad's Wild Ride.

2:18:22You know what?

2:18:22No, they got rid of Mr. Toad at Disney World.

2:18:25Oh, really?

2:18:25And replaced it with Winnie the Pooh's Wild Adventure.

2:18:27Oh, okay.

2:18:28But it's the same ride mechanism.

2:18:30Yes.

2:18:31Lots of twists and turns and things happening.

2:18:33So I am familiar.

2:18:35This story actually begins back to our friend, Toad.

2:18:39It got the name.

2:18:41It was a concept based on an app called Tyke, written by Andre Torres.

2:18:46Yes.

2:18:48And I spent three minutes coming up, okay, what's related to Tyke?

2:18:52Okay, we're going to call it Toad.

2:18:54And this became a great product, right?

2:18:57It's like Toad, just, it became the thing.

2:19:01And we launched it.

2:19:03I had some great branding behind it.

2:19:05Again, the designers I work with did some great things, taking the O and the letter Toad

2:19:11and making it look like the dot that you select.

2:19:15But we started getting emails from Germany.

2:19:17And they were all saying the same thing.

2:19:22Do you know what tot means in German?

2:19:25And it turns out, tot means dead.

2:19:28So when you're scrolling the app store in Germany and you come across our product, you see dead.

2:19:37Can you localize the name?

2:19:40It was way too late to change it.

2:19:42We'd had all the branding.

2:19:43We had the app URL, just all sorts of things.

2:19:47What do they call tater tots over there?

2:19:51It turns out, we were in the process of writing up this KB article, knowledge-based article,

2:19:57that taught being a short, succinct word also has a lot of other meanings in other languages.

2:20:04It's everything ranging from male genitalia to oral intercourse, right?

2:20:08It's like it's a name with a history.

2:20:11It's two.

2:20:13When you have three characters, it's bound to be used in every language.

2:20:18Exactly.

2:20:18And it's just like, it's onomopoeic.

2:20:22It's just like, tot, tot.

2:20:23You can see some German go, tot, right?

2:20:26It's dead.

2:20:28So we're still getting emails from Germany every once in a while, and we point them at that knowledge-based article.

2:20:34And I hope, you know, we say in the article, we didn't mean to offend anybody, and we didn't.

2:20:40And it was just, it's like one of those things that happened.

2:20:42But we started getting emails after the launch of Tapestry from Germany for something totally different.

2:20:49It turns out that there's this blog that's really popular there.

2:20:54I'm guessing it's a little bit like Daring Fireball.

2:20:57It's opinionated tech.

2:20:59It's called Fefe's blog, right?

2:21:02Everybody's talking about, we can't read Fefe's blog in Tapestry.

2:21:05And there have been, you know, RSS is a thing that's been around for, what, 26 years now, thereabouts?

2:21:12Yeah, something like that.

2:21:13And everybody has their own interpretation, and nobody's read the spec, right?

2:21:17I have.

2:21:18I know.

2:21:20You and I both have, right?

2:21:21We figured it out because, you know, we read the RFCs and all the other stuff.

2:21:26But I know exactly what you mean.

2:21:29I've said to the crew that we're speedrunning the work that Brent Simmons and Silvio Rizzi had done over the last however many years, right, of dealing with poorly formed.

2:21:40But let me guess.

2:21:41Fefe's blog has a very curious interpretation of the RSS spec.

2:21:45It's valid.

2:21:48It is a valid feed.

2:21:51But it only consists of a title, a description, a link, and a GUID.

2:21:58There's no date.

2:22:00Right?

2:22:01And we, as a timeline, need some time, right, need some period point to put it into the feed.

2:22:10So I'm thinking, oh, geez.

2:22:13And then I notice that all the links have a TS equal parameter, which I'm thinking, oh, that's a timestamp, right?

2:22:21I can write a connector to figure this out.

2:22:23So on a Friday afternoon, I sit down and I do a little poking.

2:22:28And yes, indeed, TS looks like it's a number.

2:22:32Oh, but it's in hexadecimal.

2:22:33That's kind of a weird way to put a Unix timestamp.

2:22:39So, you know, I started taking this number and changing it from hex into an integer value as a timestamp.

2:22:46And I was getting dates in 2053, right?

2:22:49It was clearly wrong.

2:22:50Right.

2:22:51Well, I'm thinking, who puts a timestamp in hex, right?

2:22:55So I just typed in FFA's blog timestamp.

2:23:00And he's got a gist on GitHub for his blog.

2:23:06It's one single C file that produces the output of this blog.

2:23:11And I'm like, oh, this is going to be easy.

2:23:14It's C code.

2:23:15I've been writing C code since the mid-'80s.

2:23:18Yeah, since Dennis Ritchie.

2:23:20Yeah.

2:23:21Well, actually, I actually referred to Kernighan and Ritchie's book at a point in this story.

2:23:29We're not quite there yet.

2:23:30Okay.

2:23:31So I see this thing.

2:23:34And, you know, it's like this one long C file.

2:23:37I'm searching through it.

2:23:39And I find that the TS is in the source code.

2:23:41But it uses the caret operator with a value called ZAL, Z-A-H-L.

2:23:48And I'm like, okay.

2:23:51Like, doesn't that – and, you know, it's been – I don't even want to think how long it's been since I've written C code day to day.

2:23:59Yeah.

2:24:00But it's been a while.

2:24:01So I, you know, pull out Kernighan and Ritchie with the caret.

2:24:04Oh, right.

2:24:05It's an exclusive OR operator.

2:24:07So he's exclusive ORing the timestamp with this thing called ZAL.

2:24:14Well, over to Google Translate.

2:24:18ZAL, what does it mean?

2:24:20Number.

2:24:21So he's XORing this timestamp with number.

2:24:26The string number.

2:24:28Yeah.

2:24:30All right.

2:24:32Oh, and after ZAL, in a lot of cases, there's this comment that's hee-hee.

2:24:36He's laughing.

2:24:38Right?

2:24:38He knows what – this guy knows what he's doing, right?

2:24:42He's written a blog in one C file.

2:24:44I mean, Befe is – he's the real deal.

2:24:47He's a developer.

2:24:50So I go searching through this C file for ZAL, and I find out it's zero.

2:24:54So the thing – the property of a Bitwise XOR operator when it's zero is there's no op.

2:25:03Nothing happens.

2:25:03So I knew that zero was not ZAL.

2:25:07Well, what is it?

2:25:10And the thing that – the important property with Bitwise exclusive OR, in fact, that Mac,

2:25:16the original Mac, used it when it was drawing selection outlines.

2:25:20Right?

2:25:20You can put a pattern, XOR it with a value, and it flips all the bits.

2:25:27Right.

2:25:27And then if you XOR it again, it flips it all back.

2:25:28Everything black turns white, everything white turns black.

2:25:30Right.

2:25:30Right.

2:25:31So it's a good way to do selection mechanisms, marching ants, that kind of thing.

2:25:36So he was obviously taking the timestamp, XORing it with this value, this special ZAL that

2:25:43he had, and you could transform it one way out and back in, and you could know what the

2:25:49real timestamp was.

2:25:51And without that value, I was just like, this is a 64-bit integer.

2:25:55I'm going to have to do an exhaustive search for ZAL using timestamps that I'm not really

2:26:01sure what they are.

2:26:02I was like, I'm giving up.

2:26:04And I wrote about this on Mastodon.

2:26:06A matter of minutes later, I got back this reply from this guy in Sweden, Forced, who says,

2:26:14oh, I just figured out what ZAL is.

2:26:16I was like, how the hell?

2:26:18Well, he had gone to the blog and gotten the timestamp from the last modified header in the

2:26:26HTML that came back.

2:26:27Took that, converted it into a hex number, and it turns out that ZAL was 0xfefec0de.

2:26:39So, Fefec0de, right?

2:26:41I plugged that into connector, and immediately I had timestamps, and it was like everybody

2:26:47was, it was golden.

2:26:48And I thought this was going to take me like 15 minutes.

2:26:53And once I knew what ZAL was, it took me about 15 minutes.

2:26:56But after that, it's like I got the connector going, I uploaded it to GitHub, and I've atoned

2:27:05for my sins and naming taught, I hope.

2:27:09I don't think that we should, I think you're setting very poor expectations for everybody

2:27:13listening to this, just how much work you're willing to do to get one feed into Tapestry.

2:27:20Well, it was, it's kind of like I felt bad about the name of Germany, and all these people

2:27:26in Germany are contacting us, and it's, I mean, I, you're in the world.

2:27:31I love Germany.

2:27:31I've been to Germany many times.

2:27:33It's like, I love Germans.

2:27:34It was a good thing for me to do on a Friday afternoon, and it turned out it was more entertaining

2:27:40than I thought it would be.

2:27:41It sounds like you're in like the new Dan Brown novel.

2:27:45Exactly.

2:27:47Trying to solve some kind of puzzle from the Middle Ages.

2:27:51Yeah, well, but there's a couple things that, you know, I step back after doing this, and

2:27:56it's like, you know, you can step back and look at, you know, a normal RSS feeder could

2:28:01not have done this, right?

2:28:02It didn't have that ability to perform bitwise operations on some value in a URL, right?

2:28:08So, okay, that's something in Tapestry's favor.

2:28:12You've heard of Molly White and her blog and this concept of posse, right?

2:28:20Post on on-site, syndicate everywhere.

2:28:22Right.

2:28:23Right.

2:28:24Fefe's doing that.

2:28:25He's posting on his own site, and his site is, you know, you go look at it.

2:28:29It's blog.fefe.de.

2:28:33It's, there's no CSS there.

2:28:36It's just, it's raw HTML.

2:28:38It's kind of what you'd expect to be produced by a single C file.

2:28:42Right.

2:28:43A gist, a GitHub gist.

2:28:45Right.

2:28:46And it's really more Tapestry's job to adapt than it is for the content creator to produce

2:28:54something that makes RSS feeds happy.

2:28:57Right.

2:28:57It's the epitome of, by allowing software as the integration level with these connectors,

2:29:05it's like epitomizing the adage, I forget who gets the credit for it, be liberal in what

2:29:12you accept, and conservative in what you emit.

2:29:14So in other words, if you're dealing with RSS in and out, you should try to emit totally

2:29:20correct RSS out.

2:29:22But whatever you're taking in, be liberal about accepting all sorts of common mistakes and things

2:29:29that are out of spec.

2:29:30And if Fefe had decided he wanted to post his blog in a CSV file, we could have parsed the

2:29:38CSS file and produced a reasonable feed from it.

2:29:42One thing I also said, you know, there were a lot of creators, yourself included, that

2:29:47wrote tweet bots that produced posts on Twitter, and that was a great thing.

2:29:55When there was one social network, right?

2:29:58Are you going to write something that posts to the social networks for Blue Sky, Mastodon,

2:30:04Threads, Noster, Pixel Fed, Glass?

2:30:09I want to say yes, but the answer is evident in what I'm emitting right now, which is no.

2:30:17Right.

2:30:18So again, it's up to the reader to kind of pull in what they can find.

2:30:22I mean, you produce a great RSS feed, right?

2:30:25Both in a JSON feed as well.

2:30:27Right.

2:30:27Actually, your JSON feed is better than your RSS feed.

2:30:30Right.

2:30:30We've talked about it, and we don't have to go into it here, but.

2:30:33Right.

2:30:34And there's reason for that, right?

2:30:36But again, it's up to us to pick the right one, and that's one of the reasons why I wanted

2:30:45to run an ad for Daring Fireball in the initial app, right?

2:30:48So it shows people, get this one from Daring Fireball.

2:30:52It's right there in your timeline.

2:30:53Tap it.

2:30:54The feed finder comes up.

2:30:56You say, verify it.

2:30:58And next thing you know, you've got Daring Fireball.

2:31:01It's in its best format.

2:31:02It is.

2:31:04I mean, that's just to wrap it up.

2:31:06It is.

2:31:06It's a.

2:31:07I love the story, but it is.

2:31:09It exemplifies what Tapestry can do.

2:31:13And so if there is some weird site out there that is publishing once a day a CSV file, you

2:31:19know, we, you know, and CSV isn't like just comma separated values.

2:31:23It's like any, you know what I mean?

2:31:25It does.

2:31:25It's not a.

2:31:26There's not one universal comma separated value file.

2:31:29The scientific community posts, you know, there are lots of feeds.

2:31:32You want to know what the earthquakes are or you want to know what the water temperatures

2:31:36are from NOAA, right?

2:31:37And there's one specific one that gets updated every day or every 12 hours or something like

2:31:42that.

2:31:42And you would like to just have those updates in your Tapestry feed.

2:31:45It's not hard or complicated.

2:31:48And you, what do you write connectors in?

2:31:50JavaScript, right?

2:31:51Because that's.

2:31:52Yeah, it's all JavaScript, right?

2:31:53And it's basic JavaScript, you know, you can use async await and all of the other nice

2:31:58features of it.

2:31:59But yeah, there's no DOM to get in the way.

2:32:01And these things are, they're really lightweight.

2:32:04They're super fast.

2:32:05Right.

2:32:06And they're, they run in a secure sandbox too.

2:32:09That's the other thing that we've had to be very careful about is that you don't leak

2:32:13information between the JavaScript context.

2:32:16And basically every feed has its own JavaScript context to work in.

2:32:21And there's nice separation there.

2:32:23Right.

2:32:24One of the ways that the idea of making apps that have a plug-in ecosystem faded away was

2:32:30with the rise of the phone and iOS and Android and sandboxing.

2:32:34And you can't just have an interpreter in your app.

2:32:37And it just sort of, here we are 15 years into the iPhone era and we sort of lost the whole

2:32:43mentality of building pluggable apps.

2:32:46And there are, we also got lost.

2:32:49And again, we could just keep going and going.

2:32:51But like with the whole idea that the feeds you consume on your phone when you've got five

2:32:56minutes to burn while you're waiting in line for something, that they're going to come from

2:33:01big companies like Meta or Twitter or X now or whatever, or TikTok, which was all in the

2:33:08news with the ban and everything.

2:33:09And not even getting adamant about indie publishers and indie mediums and open formats and stuff.

2:33:19It's just, even if you love those things, it's just obviously true that they have, again, not a

2:33:24nefarious agenda, which some people might think they do, but they have very different interests in

2:33:30the amount of control they have over it.

2:33:32And they have this obvious, they don't even try to hide it, this obvious motivation to keep you

2:33:39scrolling forever, right?

2:33:41They all give you what you want.

2:33:43And sometimes the best things for you are the things you don't want, right?

2:33:48No, and there's so much proof.

2:33:50It's good to hear from diverse viewpoints, people that don't agree with you.

2:33:55But the one thing, there's evidence that backs it.

2:33:59And again, we could go on a whole digression about it.

2:34:01But real evidence that backs it, that so many other things, trends come and go, and then they

2:34:07fade off and they don't work.

2:34:09But the one thing that people do not get tired of is outrage.

2:34:14And they don't, not that they seek it and nobody's raising their hand and saying, yes, I would

2:34:19like to be outraged several times a day.

2:34:22But it's like the nature of evolution, that if there is something that makes you angry, you're

2:34:27supposed to pay attention to it, right?

2:34:29Yeah.

2:34:29Because it's a fight or flight.

2:34:31It's enjoyable to get heated up about some things.

2:34:33Or not.

2:34:34It concentrates your mind.

2:34:38It's not that you enjoy it.

2:34:39People don't enjoy it.

2:34:40But our minds from an evolution, like a survival instinct is if it's alarming to you, your attention

2:34:48will go there to keep you alive.

2:34:51Because a thousand years ago, the outrage was, there's a fucking bear, right?

2:34:56And it's coming to a time.

2:34:57It's fight or flight, right?

2:34:58Right.

2:34:59What do I do here?

2:35:00Right.

2:35:01Do I keep scrolling or do I reply?

2:35:02Your spouse is outside yelling and you go to see what the ruckus is and it's a bear, right?

2:35:08And yes, but that part of your brain is what gets triggered when you're scrolling through

2:35:15TikTok or Instagram or whatever.

2:35:17When you see this video about what's going on in Washington, D.C. and it's outrage, it

2:35:23grabs your mind.

2:35:25And they know it and they know that that's what keeps people glued and they don't get tired

2:35:30of it.

2:35:30We're not hooked up to get tired of it.

2:35:32Back to one of Tapestry's features is the ability to muffle and mute.

2:35:36And this happens across all your feeds, right?

2:35:38So if you get triggered by Elon Musk or you get triggered by Donald Trump, it's really easy

2:35:46to say, just, I don't want to see it.

2:35:48And again, this is a personal control, right?

2:35:50Yeah.

2:35:51And it's easy to do in Tapestry, right?

2:35:53The advantage of those systems is you just sign in and they know stuff about you and they

2:35:59just start, it's like turning on your TV and stuff just starts coming.

2:36:03And there are default feeds that I think are very well chosen, especially the Daring Fireball

2:36:08one in Tapestry.

2:36:10But there, so you took, you, you, as a new user, you can load it.

2:36:15And I think people who listen to the talk show will find those default feeds enjoyable, but

2:36:20those, that's not, you're supposed to find a couple of things that are of interest to

2:36:25you, stick them in, into your feed and you'll build your own little personal, it's not social,

2:36:33but it is like a social network feed that's just of your interest.

2:36:37It's like an, instead of a social network feed, it's an interest network feed.

2:36:42Further down the line, one of the ideas that I've had is some way for people to share interesting

2:36:51things that they find, right?

2:36:53If you find a blog that's just, Sean did this during the most talented developer I know, who

2:37:00I have the luck of working with, pointed at me at Hackaday one day as an RSS feed.

2:37:07And it had some sort of little problem and I fixed the problem.

2:37:10And I've been following it since, it's just a great little blog about just weird little

2:37:16things people build with electronics.

2:37:18And I mean, that kind of recommendation that comes from a person, it's like, I go back to

2:37:26looking at, you know, whenever Roger Ebert recommended a movie, I knew that that was going to probably

2:37:31be a movie that I liked.

2:37:32And even if you didn't like it, it was worth your time to watch it.

2:37:36Exactly, exactly.

2:37:37His tastes aligned with mine, right?

2:37:40And your tastes aligned with mine as well.

2:37:42Well, that's because my taste is excellent.

2:37:44A lot of the things you recommend during Fireball, I'm like, oh, this is awesome, right?

2:37:48And I think that's part of your success, too, right?

2:37:52You've got good taste.

2:37:53Well, I have very good taste in guests for the talk show, in particular.

2:38:00I literally just did a spit take there.

2:38:02Here's the bottom line.

2:38:05I want to thank Google Gemini for sponsoring the show, our exclusive sponsor for the show.

2:38:11And you should go check out Google Gemini, too.

2:38:13It really is worth your time to check out.

2:38:15It's a very good app and very much worth trying.

2:38:18But I really do want to leave people with this parting message.

2:38:21Go check out Tapestry.

2:38:23You can run it on the Mac, too.

2:38:25I know you won't get into it.

2:38:26Yeah, it runs in the Apple Silicon emulation thing.

2:38:30But it's, in my opinion, fundamentally meant for the phone.

2:38:35Yeah, and one of the things that we have stated, and there's going to be a Mac app, right?

2:38:41We will do a Mac app at some point.

2:38:43And we're at that point where the dust is settling on our 1.0 release.

2:38:49We're working on a 1.1 release that's got a lot of new stuff.

2:38:53And then we're going to go head down on it.

2:38:56And I think that'll be great.

2:38:58And I'm going to be using the Mac app.

2:38:59And it'll be great when it happens.

2:39:01But I think starting phone first and building up from there is the way to go.

2:39:05Because that's where the whole rise of scrollable feeds comes from, right?

2:39:09And the whole –

2:39:10I knew that the first time I was at the supermarket waiting in line, I was probably the only one

2:39:19that had Twitter on a phone.

2:39:20And it's like I knew, this is great, right?

2:39:23It's kind of little bites of entertainment that show up while I'm waiting to do something else.

2:39:31And I really do think that building your own little interest feed as opposed to getting

2:39:36into a social feed, even on a nice social network like Mastodon or Blue Sky and not talking about

2:39:42any of the pernicious outrage and stuff on other platforms, I just think it's a better way to

2:39:50spend your time.

2:39:51It is more nourishing.

2:39:53And I know that – I used to roll my eyes at the term media diet.

2:39:57But the more I think about it, the more I realize that it's a really useful analogy and that

2:40:02you feed your mind with what you pay attention to.

2:40:06And so much of the stuff from the metas, the Instagrams, the – certainly X, in my opinion,

2:40:15TikTok is junk food for your mind.

2:40:19It is.

2:40:20And I eat junk food.

2:40:21I like junk food.

2:40:21Cable Sasser, I follow his recommendations.

2:40:24I like candy.

2:40:25I do.

2:40:26I like weird potato chips.

2:40:28I'm so right he's still alive, honestly.

2:40:32I am too, but I like weird potato chips and weird Japanese candy, and I do.

2:40:38I like junk food.

2:40:39But I'm very cognizant of when I'm eating potato chips and when I'm eating candy or drinking a beer

2:40:46that, hey, this isn't something that I should be doing all the time and basing my entire caloric

2:40:53intake on.

2:40:54And yet, in terms of what we consume when we have time to blow on our phones or iPads,

2:40:59that's sort of where we trapped ourselves.

2:41:02And tapestry is a way to build yourself a nice, little, tasty, healthy lunch every day for your mind.

2:41:08It's a happy place.

2:41:09Yeah.

2:41:09It's my – and going back to the original thing, right, there were a handful of blogs.

2:41:15There were some comics.

2:41:17There were some people that I wanted to follow.

2:41:19And that was my happy place, right?

2:41:23And I'm really happy that it has become a happy place for a lot of people and will continue

2:41:30to be, and it will continue to evolve.

2:41:31But in addition to being happier and not being outrage-inducing, it's also nourishing.

2:41:38And it's a little bit more work and requires a little less mindlessness, but I think that's

2:41:43what people want.

2:41:44And if that's what you want and something to dick around for 10 minutes here and there

2:41:48on, it's perfect for it.

2:41:50So go check it out.

2:41:50Just go to the App Store and search for Tapestry, and you should find it, right?

2:41:54Yeah.

2:41:54Who knew that Elon Musk did us a favor?

2:41:57In a way, right?

2:41:59Yeah.

2:41:59Yeah.

2:41:59Silver linings, right?