0:00:00From Relay, this is Upgrade, episode 557, recorded March 28th, 2025, released March 31st.
0:00:18We're recording this a little bit early.
0:00:19I am one of your regular hosts, of course, Jason Snell.
0:00:23Mike Hurley continues to be on assignment.
0:00:25His assignment is paternity leave this time.
0:00:28And with me this week, oh, on a show brought to you by Google Gemini and Ecamm, by the way.
0:00:35Haha, see, got it in there.
0:00:36I'm going to totally get this nailed by the time Mike comes back.
0:00:39It is my compatriot at Six Colors, as well as the host of Clockwise here on Relay,
0:00:46The Rebound, off on its own, on The Rebound, and many other podcasts over at The Incomparable.
0:00:53It's Dan Morin.
0:00:55Hi, Dan.
0:00:56Hi, Jason.
0:00:57And I'd say it's so nice to talk to you unusually, but we talk pretty frequently.
0:01:01Yeah, this is, for those who do not know, we are weekly on, actually on Fridays when we're
0:01:06recording this, we do the Six Colors podcast, which is for Six Colors members only.
0:01:11And people seem to like it, actually.
0:01:14I get great feedback and praise for that podcast.
0:01:18Every once in a while we break some news.
0:01:19You know how it goes.
0:01:20Oh, I mean, every now and then somebody quotes us on a site and it's weird.
0:01:24But this time we are, we are talking on what will be a regular episode of Upgrade.
0:01:31They're all a little bit different with Mike Gunn, but that's fine.
0:01:34We'd like to start though with a Snell Talk question.
0:01:36I know you love, you love it.
0:01:39You can, I'm going to ask you to chip in here after I answer this question.
0:01:46I'm prepared.
0:01:46Javier, there was a time in my life when this would have been the most embarrassing
0:02:04question possible because having grown up loving Star Trek, you get to that point when you're
0:02:11sort of like, I would say a high school student and you start to realize that everybody thinks
0:02:16you're a gigantic nerd because you're a gigantic nerd.
0:02:18And you're like, oh no, deny, just deny it.
0:02:22Deny that you're a gigantic nerd.
0:02:23Throw away all your stuff and pretend that you're not a gigantic nerd.
0:02:27Here's a pro tip kids.
0:02:29It doesn't help.
0:02:30It doesn't hide anything.
0:02:33It does not hide anything at all.
0:02:35Anyway, during this period, I think when I graduated from high school, maybe, or thereabouts,
0:02:40my parents gave me what I still have.
0:02:42And I'm now for the watchers on YouTube, I'm holding in my hand.
0:02:46Which is a Franklin Mint Pewter USS Enterprise.
0:02:51It probably cost a lot of money.
0:02:54It's beautiful.
0:02:55And I was super embarrassed when they gave it to me, which is funny because I still have it.
0:03:01And now I think it's really beautiful.
0:03:02And the problem is that it came, because the USS Enterprise is meant to only fly in space and
0:03:07not be in Earth's atmosphere, even though it is in Earth's atmosphere and a few things.
0:03:12It had a stand.
0:03:13It was a little stand, sort of shaped like the Starfleet symbol.
0:03:17And that broke off.
0:03:18And the problem now is that I love this thing and would like to kind of have it on a stand.
0:03:22And I can't because it broke off.
0:03:25It's actually, the part of the stand is still stuck in there.
0:03:27I might be able to get that out.
0:03:29But yeah, recruit our pal John Maltz and his 3D printer and print yourself a new stand.
0:03:34Like John Maltz might be up for this because he is a Star Trek fan.
0:03:39But I'm going to throw it out to the wider upgrade community.
0:03:43If somebody would like to work with me to figure out how to build maybe a 3D printed stand or
0:03:49a partially 3D printed stand, maybe the piece that's coming out of the ship needs to be 3D
0:03:53printed because it's a specific shape.
0:03:55But then it could be on something heavier so it doesn't tip over.
0:03:58Anyway, upgradefeedback.com because it is beautiful and I'm no longer embarrassed by it.
0:04:04And in fact, it's a very sweet thing my parents did for their nerdy son.
0:04:06So that all said, it's not my favorite Star Trek related memorabilia.
0:04:10In the year 2000, I went to a wedding.
0:04:13It's actually our friends, Philip Michaels and Lisa Schmeiser's wedding in Las Vegas.
0:04:16And the Star Trek experience was still in Las Vegas then where you could go and there was
0:04:22like a bar.
0:04:23You could have like Romulan ale or Klingon blood ale, which were just beer with food coloring.
0:04:30I had the Klingon blood ale.
0:04:33And there was a little experience you had where you're on the bridge of the next generation
0:04:37enterprise.
0:04:37And in the gift shop, because there's always a gift shop.
0:04:39Of course.
0:04:40There was a very simple product that yet it, I just loved it at the time and I still love
0:04:47it to this day.
0:04:48It's just a teddy bear.
0:04:50But it's a teddy bear wearing Captain Kirk's uniform from the original series.
0:04:55I love him.
0:04:57He's the best.
0:04:58I always have him on a shelf somewhere nearby because he's just adorable.
0:05:03And so the Captain Kirk bear is my favorite Star Trek memorabilia.
0:05:08Now, Dan, I have to ask you, you're a big Star Wars fan.
0:05:11I know you're also a Star Trek fan because nerds, what's your favorite piece of memorabilia
0:05:16or collectible?
0:05:17Well, let me throw this out for you.
0:05:18A couple of things.
0:05:18One, I do remember when I was a kid, there was an exhibit at the Science Museum that was
0:05:23a Star Trek TNG exhibit here in Boston.
0:05:26And my parents took me.
0:05:27And the only thing I remember about it really is I bought a, it was like a lanyard with a
0:05:33badge, like an ID badge on it.
0:05:35And I bought a Geordi one.
0:05:36So I had a Geordi little ID badge on a lanyard that I loved.
0:05:40No idea where that is now.
0:05:42I also had a little like toy phaser and a toy tricorder from TNG, both of which I like.
0:05:48I still have the tricorder.
0:05:49I don't really know where the phaser is.
0:05:50And recently I've also acquired a communicator, old school TOS communicator and a badge, Strange
0:05:59New World style, you know, or non-com badge, but insignia because that's been my Halloween
0:06:04costume the last couple of years.
0:06:06I bought a shirt and I have the badge.
0:06:07But my favorite piece of Star Trek memorabilia is I got given probably circa 1993 a mug that
0:06:16has the, it's from the NCC-171A.
0:06:19It's part of like the, it's the official China, you know, a sort of style, but it's like a
0:06:23mug with the Starfleet insignia on it.
0:06:26On the back it says USS Enterprise NCC-171A.
0:06:28And it's a false graph mug.
0:06:32I still have it.
0:06:33I still drink from it on the regular.
0:06:34And then I was amazed to discover that our pal John Maltz has one as well and his broke
0:06:39and he found another one on eBay.
0:06:41So I worry about the day when that goes and I won't be able to find it because John has
0:06:46already bought the replacement.
0:06:47He bought your replacement money.
0:06:48He bought my replacement.
0:06:49On the Star Wars side, people who are watching the video can see behind me, I have a bookcase
0:06:54here which has a bunch of stuff on it, Legos and some toys and stuff.
0:06:58I do have a nice Chewbacca sock monkey up there somewhere, which you can't quite see.
0:07:03So recently, about a year and a half ago, my wife and I went to Disney World and I got
0:07:09to go to Galaxy's Edge for the first time and I built my own custom lightsaber.
0:07:15Now, I built a couple.
0:07:16I built one in the past.
0:07:17It's like the plastic pieces that you screw together and they're in a big bin when you go
0:07:21there.
0:07:21But this time we splashed out for the experience.
0:07:24You go and like have within a room with like 20 other people and there's a whole like show
0:07:31as you pick your pieces and they're like metal.
0:07:34So you can also see behind me right here on my bookcase.
0:07:37That is my lightsaber, my custom lightsaber that I built.
0:07:41It is quite heavy.
0:07:42It weighs several pounds because it is made of solid metal and it has in it, it's got a
0:07:49little switch and you can flick the switch and it has a blade that's not currently screwed
0:07:53in because otherwise it would be really hard to store.
0:07:55It lights up and inside of it, there are crystals that you pick during this whole experience that
0:08:02dictate what color it is.
0:08:04But you can get different crystals, swap them in and it makes different color.
0:08:09It changes the color and it changes the sounds.
0:08:11I was very disturbed at this event when I looked around and realized of the 20 or so people in
0:08:17there, the vast majority chose either purple or red lightsabers.
0:08:23Throw inside, all of you choosing red lightsabers.
0:08:26Then I had green and there was like one person had purple.
0:08:29Everybody else had red and purple, red, 1% blue, blue, one blue, one blue.
0:08:34One green, mostly purple and red.
0:08:36And I was like, I don't know, what's wrong with it?
0:08:38I don't know.
0:08:38Seems like, uh, seems like in the zeitgeist.
0:08:41Seems about right, actually.
0:08:42Yeah, I don't, I'm not happy about it.
0:08:45I'm not happy about it.
0:08:46Mine's green, by the way.
0:08:47Mine's green because green is my favorite color and also because it's very similar to Luke's
0:08:51Return of the Jedi lightsaber.
0:08:52All right.
0:08:52Okay.
0:08:53That's, uh, the nerdiest Snell talk ever, but it's, it's okay.
0:08:56You asked for Javier and you got it.
0:08:58Mike's not here for us to get mad at us being nerdy.
0:09:02So we're doing it.
0:09:02Exactly right.
0:09:03And yes, you can go to, uh, search for Upgrade Podcast on YouTube.
0:09:06If you want to see us pointing at things behind us or holding things, uh, not really great
0:09:11audio podcasting, but, um, you know, that's, that's, it's a, it's a rare moment where I feel
0:09:16like we, we, uh, we had some show and tell there.
0:09:20Um, maybe I'll, maybe I'll find a clip, a frame grab and stick it in there somewhere.
0:09:25All right, moving on to the fatherly advice segment where I asked one of our parade of father co-host
0:09:32fill-ins if they have any words of wisdom or observations to impart to Mike early enough in the
0:09:37episode where he's still listening or he skipped that previous chapter and has moved on to this
0:09:41chapter.
0:09:42Straight, straight to the fatherly advice, right in the veins.
0:09:44What's your advice for Mike?
0:09:45You know, it's interesting.
0:09:46I am probably of all your guests.
0:09:48I assume I'm the one with the most recent experience with a very young child.
0:09:52You are a kid.
0:09:53Yeah.
0:09:53My kid's only a two and a half.
0:09:55Um, so I've been through this in the not too distant past and I will, so we got a lot of good
0:10:01advice when we were expecting our first kid.
0:10:04Like we had a lot of friends that we asked and one of my friends I will call out specifically,
0:10:07um, this woman named Angel sent us a really wonderful email that she's like, this is my like,
0:10:12like standard email I sent to people who asked me about this.
0:10:15And it's just really thoughtful and really well-reasoned, all this great advice.
0:10:18And one of the things that stuck in my mind from this is the nothing lasts longer than two
0:10:24weeks, which is a way of saying anything bad that's happening.
0:10:28Your baby's not sleeping.
0:10:30They're not like, you know, oh, they don't like this food or they're crying about this thing.
0:10:35Like it's, it's frustrating when you're in that moment and you feel like, oh my God, is this
0:10:40my life?
0:10:40Is my life forever?
0:10:42This baby not sleeping or this baby being upset or not liking this thing or that thing
0:10:47to which I say, deep breath.
0:10:49Nothing lasts longer than two weeks.
0:10:51Now the flip side of that is nothing good lasts longer than two weeks or good or bad.
0:10:55Nothing lasts longer than two weeks.
0:10:57There will be something else.
0:10:58Something else will happen.
0:10:59Something else will change.
0:11:00But it also is a good reason and sort of reminder to slow down and enjoy those things.
0:11:06Because, you know, your kid doing something really amazing and cute, write it down like
0:11:11you will forget.
0:11:13You don't think you'll ever forget how cute that one thing they did was where they, I don't
0:11:17know, said a word the specific way or crawled over something.
0:11:21And you're like, oh my God, that's so amazing.
0:11:23I'll never forget that.
0:11:24There is a lot going on in your brain right now.
0:11:26Trust me.
0:11:27Write it down.
0:11:28Write yourself a little note.
0:11:29My wife and I have a little file of things where we write down cute stuff that our kid
0:11:33has done.
0:11:33So we can refer back to, oh yeah, remember when he was doing that?
0:11:36And then my second corollary I'll put in there is the pick your battles thing, which I think
0:11:41somebody else mentioned as well.
0:11:42But I think is an important one to stress.
0:11:44And this probably is more of a long-term, you know, less a case when your kid is an infant.
0:11:51But as you hit toddlerhood and realize that there are some very particular, your toddler
0:11:57will be very particular and specific about things that they want to do.
0:12:01And you will be trying to put a jacket on them and get out the door.
0:12:05You will be trying to get them to put their shoes on.
0:12:07You will be trying to get them to eat their vegetables.
0:12:10And just, you know, again, deep breath, relax, think to yourself, this is the hill I want
0:12:17to die on.
0:12:17And the answer is, if it's not, that's fine.
0:12:20If they're throwing around their food and it's like, you know, I can't get them to eat
0:12:24that, it's fine.
0:12:25It's going to be okay if they miss their vegetables for a day or two.
0:12:27It's totally reasonable.
0:12:29Just decide which of the things that you actually need to get done and do those.
0:12:34Don't worry about everything else.
0:12:35And I think I want to refer back also to, I think John Syracuse had a really good one
0:12:40too, about like the, you know, feeling like, having feelings about it and like questioning
0:12:46things and like beating yourself up sometimes.
0:12:49And like having, you're like, oh my God, I can't believe I'm having these thoughts or whatever.
0:12:52Forgive yourself really, I think is another big part of it.
0:12:56Like go easy on yourself.
0:12:57Like I definitely had a breakdown like just a couple weeks into having a kid where I was
0:13:02convinced I was the world's worst dad and I was really bad at this.
0:13:05I didn't know what I was doing.
0:13:06I couldn't have, like the kid wasn't doing it.
0:13:08Like anything I felt like I tried didn't work.
0:13:11It's going to be okay.
0:13:13It's going to be fine.
0:13:14It's going to be fine.
0:13:15Everybody feels that way.
0:13:17I like emailed a bunch of my friends who are dads and they are all super great.
0:13:20And like, don't worry.
0:13:22Everybody knows your syndrome.
0:13:23You're fine.
0:13:24Yeah.
0:13:24It's very, statistically, it's very unlikely that you're the worst dad.
0:13:27Exactly.
0:13:28That is, that helps.
0:13:29You know, you're like, oh, I'm probably about average, you know, maybe a little above average.
0:13:33I like to flatter myself.
0:13:35I'll work for it.
0:13:36Yeah.
0:13:36Yeah.
0:13:36That's it.
0:13:37So go easy on yourself.
0:13:39It's going to be okay.
0:13:40All right.
0:13:41Very good.
0:13:42Thank you.
0:13:42Happy to help.
0:13:44Hi to Mike.
0:13:46And let's move on to some follow-up.
0:13:48I got some good follow-up in the last few days since we recorded Monday's episode, since
0:13:53we're recording this a little early.
0:13:54And here it is.
0:13:58First, an anonymous writer wrote in and said, I was listening to Upgrade and Stephen Hackett
0:14:03posited that adding cameras to the Apple Watch or AirPods would pose a problem for people who
0:14:07work in sensitive areas.
0:14:08I work in the defense industry.
0:14:10Apple Watches and AirPods are already banned from secure spaces.
0:14:13So adding a camera wouldn't change anything.
0:14:15The rules disallow any electronic device with a transmitter, camera, or storage.
0:14:20But I do agree with Stephen's general point about introducing cameras unexpectedly into
0:14:24private spaces.
0:14:25See?
0:14:26It's not a problem.
0:14:28Put them in there because they can't use them already.
0:14:30Although, I don't, Dan, I don't know.
0:14:33Aren't defense rules meant to be broken anyway?
0:14:38Oh, topical.
0:14:40Let's move on to.
0:14:42Yeah.
0:14:42Before we start delving too deep into that one.
0:14:45I mean, what is a rule?
0:14:46Really?
0:14:47What is, I mean, sometimes you just want AirPods.
0:14:50One of those people has brought a camera into some place they shouldn't have.
0:14:53I guarantee you.
0:14:54100%.
0:14:54Boyd wrote in and said, in that same episode, Jason suggested that ideally tvOS's primary
0:15:01landing page should be a TV app-centric one.
0:15:04As a non-US Apple TV user, I hope the screen full of app icons remains.
0:15:07Apple does not have a great track record when it comes to integrating non-US or really non-English
0:15:11content.
0:15:12I'm worried it would turn the TV experience into a wasteland for us abroad.
0:15:15Because without the local streaming apps and live TV, is that not just the current TV app
0:15:20but then as the primary interface?
0:15:21No thanks.
0:15:22I got several people wrote in or posted on Blue Sky or Mastodon and said, Jason, you're
0:15:28completely wrong.
0:15:29The all-app grid is the way to go.
0:15:32And I appreciate their perspective.
0:15:35A lot of them, the argument was the TV app is bad.
0:15:39I guess embedded in my argument that Apple needs to embrace the TV app as the main interface
0:15:43of tvOS is that it wouldn't be the current TV app.
0:15:49It would be an improved TV app with more access to your apps.
0:15:53And yes, they should do a better job with content across the system and floating it up.
0:15:58I think I mentioned that the current TV app is, even on the main screen, is too TV Plus-centric
0:16:04and it needs to be focused on broader content.
0:16:06But if you look at what Google and Amazon do, one of the top rows, maybe on Amazon, it's
0:16:11like right below that ad for Mancini's Sleep World, is a row of apps that are your apps.
0:16:19So the app launcher is in the home screen.
0:16:21And although Apple is, if you scroll down, there are apps in the home screen and the TV app as
0:16:27well.
0:16:27I do think the TV app, if it's going to bear the load of the entire interface, would need
0:16:30to be better.
0:16:31I'm not saying that.
0:16:33But I do think that when you use these other interfaces, it's just very clear that it's
0:16:39deeply confusing that Apple has that, but it also has this kind of blank screen, which feels
0:16:45old-fashioned.
0:16:45I did hear from some people who don't use most services and just use third-party apps that
0:16:51they completely control.
0:16:52And they don't want to have this experience either because they don't use their Apple TV
0:16:56that way.
0:16:56I would argue that there's no TV box that really is geared toward that use and that if
0:17:01Apple went away from that direction, I feel for those people, but I think it would be perfectly
0:17:05reasonable.
0:17:05Also, honestly, if Apple wanted to make it that if you really didn't want to use the TV app
0:17:13and you could go back to the app, the launch screen experience, they could maybe make that
0:17:18a setting.
0:17:18But I think the default should be a very functional TV app that actually integrates with third-party
0:17:25apps.
0:17:25That's what I was trying to say.
0:17:26I would also argue maybe there's another middle ground there in some ways, which is, wouldn't
0:17:31it be nice if there was a configurable app, kind of like the TVO app, almost widgetized,
0:17:36where you could drop in, like, well, I watch these apps.
0:17:39Let me just drop in a widget for that here, a widget for that.
0:17:41I mean, the other alternative, obviously, is to make it much more of an open API so those
0:17:46local apps could integrate in some way, but you'd still need some degree of user choice
0:17:51to allow the user to say, these are the things I want to watch.
0:17:54I think there is something to that.
0:17:56I think there's something to the idea of making it more customizable.
0:17:58I would love, I was thinking about this because I watch a bunch of stuff on Plex.
0:18:02I watch a bunch of stuff on YouTube.
0:18:03I would love apps to be able to contribute whole rows to the TV home screen.
0:18:11Again, configurable, so I could maybe put up next on Plex if I really cared about it, or
0:18:16up next on YouTube in my, or what's on my YouTube TV, TVR, or whatever it is, and have
0:18:22it be even more that's feeding out of those apps.
0:18:24And that's, again, I think that's one of my complaints about the current TV app is that
0:18:28Apple's not, among the things that Apple's kind of not moving forward with, with tvOS,
0:18:34better integrating the apps that do want to share data with the system.
0:18:38And that's, you know, I know it's via APIs and all that, but I'm telling you, I think
0:18:42if Apple did an API that allowed Plex to put shows in your face on the home screen, the new
0:18:49home screen, I think, you know, Plex would jump to the challenge on a lot of apps, maybe not
0:18:54Netflix, right?
0:18:54But a lot of apps would jump to that challenge.
0:18:56And then customizability, so it feels more like it's your device.
0:18:59I got a whole wish list.
0:19:01Yeah.
0:19:01And that's what I want to say to Boyd is I've got a whole wish list about ways the TV app
0:19:05should be better.
0:19:06Yeah.
0:19:06That I think it is incumbent on Apple to make the TV app better if they go away from the
0:19:10home screen approach.
0:19:12But, but my larger point is that it's very hard to look at the state of affairs out there
0:19:15and think the right way to do a TV box is a blank screen full of icons.
0:19:21And then you launch individual silos.
0:19:23I think that that's just not the way it works or should work.
0:19:28Literally just over the last week, I was at my parents' house and my mother asked something
0:19:32about like the Apple TV that I set up for them.
0:19:35And it was like, oh, I can see my photos on here.
0:19:37I'm like, yeah, there is a photos app on the Apple TV.
0:19:39And I like showed her where it was.
0:19:40And she's like trying to remember which she's like, oh, it's that orange icon.
0:19:43It's like, no, it's the one that looks like the photos app on your phone.
0:19:46And she's like, oh, yeah, I guess that makes sense.
0:19:49And it's like, I understand why you never would have bothered looking for that, though.
0:19:53I mean, it's just a sea of icons.
0:19:55And there was a time where that was very accessible and easy when we were all learning
0:19:59how to use our smartphones.
0:20:00But it's been almost 20 years.
0:20:02I think we can expect a little bit more and maybe push the envelope a bit and make things
0:20:09a little friendlier and more customizable.
0:20:10This is a classic Apple, like, we know best.
0:20:13We're going to provide the one way of doing it kind of situation.
0:20:16Yeah.
0:20:18Somebody did actually write in.
0:20:19You mentioned widgets.
0:20:20Somebody wrote in and suggested, I wonder if the widget kit framework could be applied
0:20:24somehow to tvOS.
0:20:25And I think it's a great point.
0:20:26Like, could you drop a widget from one of your streaming apps on the home screen somewhere?
0:20:30I think it'd be great.
0:20:31Yeah.
0:20:32Really interesting idea, too.
0:20:33Linus wrote in and he said, regarding the Snell Talk discussion about how exactly to disclose
0:20:39where you live on the internet.
0:20:40This was Casey writing in after he was already on the show about me talking about living in
0:20:46Mill Valley.
0:20:47Linus says, in Germany, you're legally obliged to state your place of residence in the imprint
0:20:52of your own website, unless you have a company with a different address, I guess.
0:20:55I don't want to judge this one way or the other, but it's a strange feeling at first.
0:20:59And I just wanted to say, I pay a surprising amount of money for a post office box at my
0:21:05local post office, specifically because legally, if you send out mass emails, you must include
0:21:11a mailing address at the bottom of it.
0:21:13And even though, as I said last week, I bought my house in 1999, it's very easy to find where
0:21:19I live.
0:21:19Don't be creepy.
0:21:21I don't want to put my home address on every email I send, so I pay for a PO box at my
0:21:27local post office instead.
0:21:30So I think there are various rules about this where it's like, you can't hide on the internet.
0:21:35You have to show where you really are.
0:21:36And if you've got especially a small business, it's like, but privacy?
0:21:40I'm just a guy in a house.
0:21:42I had the same thing where I don't remember what if it was for GDPR compliance or something,
0:21:46but there was a point at which I had to put on my website, like my contact info.
0:21:50And I just made like a hidden page on the website, but it's like, and I think I even tried to avoid
0:21:55having it crawled by robots.
0:21:56I don't know how well that worked, but it's technically there just so I could link to it
0:22:01and put it in as the, you know, okay, I've fulfilled your requirements.
0:22:06But it is weird after all these years to feel like, all right, I'm just going to put
0:22:11up my name and my address in plain text on my website.
0:22:15Very weird.
0:22:17I mean, and this is the right thing to do is to go to your local PO or a mailbox store.
0:22:24And I thought about it, but as you pointed out, it's expensive.
0:22:27And I looked at it and I was like, it's just, I don't know if it's worth it for me.
0:22:31The U.S. Postal Service is just, it's jacked up that rate, like 40% every year.
0:22:35I was surprised how much, because I investigated this a couple of times, like maybe that would
0:22:39be worthwhile.
0:22:39And I was like, that is more than I pay for many of my services.
0:22:43Honestly, if my business got enough mail, sure, it would be worth it.
0:22:48But the fact is we get so little mail that every now, every like month or so, Lauren says,
0:22:53she takes the key chain that's got the key on it.
0:22:55And it's right here.
0:22:57It's right by our Whole Foods.
0:22:58It's very, we can walk to the post office, but we'll check it.
0:23:02And there's like two things in it and they're junk mail and they go in the recycling bin.
0:23:06It's a great ecosystem where the paper comes in, it gets put in a box, people take it out
0:23:10of the box, put it in the recycle bin, and then leave the post office.
0:23:13Because you can see all the same inserts from everybody else.
0:23:17Because they just get put in everybody's box behind the scene there.
0:23:19But anyway, it is, and I think Linus's point here is also very interesting because
0:23:23it's meant to protect consumers, but it's also a privacy violation.
0:23:29So they've said like, I'm going to tip toward the consumers, but you could argue, especially
0:23:35for certain individuals, that it's also a privacy violation the other way.
0:23:40It feels like there should be a carve out for if you are a business with fewer than like
0:23:44X employees, or if you have a customer base smaller than Y, maybe you could get an exemption
0:23:50or something, but yeah.
0:23:54This episode of Upgrade is brought to you by Google Gemini.
0:23:57I used Gemini for the first time the other day, and the most impressive thing to me was
0:24:01just talking to it.
0:24:02You go live with it, and then it's just like you're having a conversation.
0:24:05You can just talk about your day, or have it explain something to you, or start brainstorming
0:24:10ideas.
0:24:11I'll give you an example.
0:24:12I pretended I had a job interview coming up, and I asked for it to help me prep for the interview.
0:24:17It immediately started suggesting common questions I might get asked.
0:24:21Then, I started talking through my answers out loud, and it would give me feedback, and
0:24:26it's all happening in real time, like I'm talking to a career coach.
0:24:29That's just what I tried first, but you can talk to it about anything, and that's the magic
0:24:34of it, how you can have this back and forth, and it's all seamless.
0:24:37If you haven't tried it yet, it's definitely worth checking out.
0:24:40You'll see what I mean.
0:24:41Our thanks to Google Gemini for the support of this show and all of Relay.
0:24:46Let's turn to Upstream.
0:24:49I have one Upstream item.
0:24:51Mike is going to be so sad to not be here for an Upstream segment because he likes it so
0:24:56much, but I didn't know where else to put this, so I'm going to put it in a segment that we
0:25:01have.
0:25:02It's an interview with Seth Rogen in Variety about his new Apple TV Plus show, The Studio,
0:25:08which is getting great reviews.
0:25:10I haven't seen it yet.
0:25:11I haven't seen either, but it's on my list.
0:25:12Everybody I've seen seems to really like it and think it's very funny.
0:25:16I love Hollywood satires.
0:25:18I really do.
0:25:18They're one of my favorite genres.
0:25:20Yeah, and apparently there's a character in this who is literally the Tim Robbins character
0:25:24from The Player, but it's not played by Tim Robbins.
0:25:28It's played by Bryan Cranston, which is weird.
0:25:29Like, was Tim Robbins not available?
0:25:31He's on another Apple TV show.
0:25:32He's on another show.
0:25:33That's right.
0:25:34Anyway, people really like it, and that's great.
0:25:36This is an interesting tidbit.
0:25:38Oh, by the way, this show, The Studio, every episode has a oner, which is the industry talk
0:25:45for a long single take shot that is often, they're often spectacular, but they're also
0:25:52showing off.
0:25:53And apparently in The Studio, they put a, it's meta.
0:25:58They are discussing oners as well as doing them, sometimes while doing them, apparently,
0:26:04which is hilarious.
0:26:05I feel bad for them because the show Adolescence on Netflix, it's four episodes and they're
0:26:11all oners the whole episode.
0:26:13So they kind of stole their concept there.
0:26:17We were talking about that on The Rebound and Lex talking about how stressful it is when
0:26:21you get to like, okay, you're like 90% done.
0:26:24Don't flub a line now.
0:26:25Yeah.
0:26:26Oh boy.
0:26:26There's a, there's a, before and afters has a thing about the CGI in the VFX in Adolescence.
0:26:35Because, and this is actually kind of brilliant, right?
0:26:37It's messy to do a oner.
0:26:39Yeah.
0:26:40And so there are, they are erasing things that are bad in the background and taking the
0:26:45shadow of the camera off of the chest of somebody who's in the oner and things like that.
0:26:50And I thought, I'd never really thought about that, but that's really cool.
0:26:53So you keep the concept of the oner, but you use VFX to clean it up so that you don't
0:27:00have to be as precise as you would otherwise have to be.
0:27:03Right.
0:27:03Like nobody wants to see, oh God, the, the boom's in the shot there.
0:27:07Right.
0:27:07You know, that's really takes me out of this moment.
0:27:09You're, you're making this very immersive, very, you know, a shot designed to make you
0:27:13feel like you are in the thing, in the show, in with the, like, it's, it's just real and
0:27:18happening.
0:27:19And all of a sudden you're like, oh, I can see the guy holding the microphone over there.
0:27:23Although, uh, tangent, but, um, it's the 20th anniversary of the office, the American office,
0:27:28and there was a great oral history about the office that I will try to find.
0:27:32Uh, but, uh, they were talking about how they had to hire, they hired documentary filmmakers
0:27:40to shoot the show.
0:27:41And they had to explain to them and the writers had to figure out, like, you can't say, you
0:27:48know, we want you to cut to this or that you, you, they would set the scene and they would
0:27:54tell the documentary filmmakers and the camera people.
0:27:57They're like, you know, who were, they hired from making documentaries, like shoot it like
0:28:01a documentary.
0:28:02And, and if the boom gets in the shot, it's fine because the boom is in the office.
0:28:09It's a documentary and that they had to, now it's incredibly common to do that.
0:28:14But at the time it was not, it was actually really hard.
0:28:19So that is a piece on, uh, the Hollywood reporter.
0:28:22I'll put in the show notes by Rick Porter.
0:28:24Never, never watched a full episode of that show, Jason.
0:28:27It's a great show.
0:28:28It's a great show.
0:28:28Went to high school with two of those guys.
0:28:29Never, never watched the episode of that show.
0:28:31Yeah.
0:28:32Uh, it's true.
0:28:33You did.
0:28:34Well, maybe that's why.
0:28:35I don't know.
0:28:35Did John Krasinski wrong you in some way?
0:28:37Um, only one, no, never.
0:28:40Anyway.
0:28:41He was always, my, my minor interactions with him were always very pleasant.
0:28:44Anyway, Seth Rogen, uh, uh, BJ Novak is the other person you went to high school with.
0:28:48Uh, Seth Rogen said to Variety, because of the way we shot it, essentially nothing could
0:28:54be done after the episode.
0:28:56Apple would give us notes, but the answer was always, we can't do that.
0:28:59Can you take out this line?
0:29:00Nope.
0:29:01Can you go from this line to this line?
0:29:02Nope.
0:29:02We can't do any of that because it's a one-er.
0:29:05Brilliant.
0:29:06That is brilliant.
0:29:07Genius.
0:29:08That's great.
0:29:11I, I really love that.
0:29:12And also, I mean, I also feel like at the same time, you got to have a pretty good relationship
0:29:16of course, with the studio to be able to do that.
0:29:19And especially in this case where you're doing something that is a satire about this industry,
0:29:24like you need them to be realized, like, you know what?
0:29:27We're going to make fun of stuff.
0:29:28It might hit a little close home, close to home for you, but like, this is the show you
0:29:32hired us to make, right?
0:29:34This is the show you bought.
0:29:34That's right.
0:29:35That's right.
0:29:36And, and they probably said, we're going to have some one-ers.
0:29:38So you, you need to give us notes about that at script stage and not when we shoot it,
0:29:41you know, not after we shoot it.
0:29:43And they're like, yeah, yeah, yeah.
0:29:44And then they give them notes and they're like, well, it's too late now.
0:29:46Sorry.
0:29:47But anyway, brilliant.
0:29:47Brilliant move, Seth Rogen.
0:29:48Okay.
0:29:50Rumor roundup time.
0:29:51Yeehaw!
0:29:52Oh man.
0:29:53The best yeehaw yet.
0:29:55Well done.
0:29:56Thank you.
0:29:57Spoken, spoken by a Massachusetts guy.
0:30:00You know, we're a little, we're a little cowboy out here.
0:30:02Okay.
0:30:02We're going to start with the iPhone fold.
0:30:04The folding phone due apparently next year.
0:30:07Apparently this is actually going to happen in 2026.
0:30:09We're, we're very much in a, uh, where there's smoke stage.
0:30:13Cause the rumors about this have started to come much faster.
0:30:16I've seen half a dozen over the last couple of weeks.
0:30:18Yeah.
0:30:19Yeah.
0:30:19And it's, it's, um, between this and the thin phone, the iPhone air, Mike and I did a podcast
0:30:25at some point last year where these things were starting to be talked about, where I did
0:30:28one of those connect the dots.
0:30:30And I was like, wait a second, they make the thin phone next year and they use all of that
0:30:34thinning technology that they're, that they're working on for a whole cycle the following
0:30:39year to make the two thin planes of a folding phone.
0:30:42And that seems to be what is happening here.
0:30:45My understanding is, it's just one of those pasta things where you put the phone through
0:30:49and you crank it and it just spits out a nice thin, a very large thin phone out the other
0:30:53side.
0:30:53And then you throw it in hot water.
0:30:54You're done.
0:30:55Yep.
0:30:56Um, so the, the detail here is about the aspect ratio of the unfolded display.
0:31:04Now this is a, this comes from a, uh, Weibo based account called digital chat station.
0:31:10So sounds super legit, but I, you know, again, it is, it is a China based source for something
0:31:16that's probably in the supply chain.
0:31:17I actually think that's not unreasonable that they, it, what, here's what it's going to be.
0:31:23The, it's going to fold out to a four by three aspect ratio screen.
0:31:27That is 7.8 inches diagonally.
0:31:29Now the reason this is interesting is a four by three, in addition to being the classic
0:31:35television ratio, we're back.
0:31:38Everything comes around.
0:31:39Jason is the, it's one of my favorite things.
0:31:41Speaking of Star Trek, watching those classic Star Trek episodes on an iPad, it fills the
0:31:47screen because iPads are also four by three.
0:31:50So the, the iPad mini is 8.3 inches diagonal.
0:31:54So this would be an iPhone that folds open to almost an iPad mini, including being the
0:32:00right aspect ratio.
0:32:02And, um, as our friend Federico Vittici commented on Mastodon, if this is true, it's kind of ironic.
0:32:08Apple will embrace the iPad's most common criticism.
0:32:10It is just a giant iPhone, but Dan, I got to say as a big fan of the, of the iPad and somebody
0:32:19who uses his iPhone, but like not a lot, lot, I love this idea.
0:32:24I really love this idea that I could just have a phone that was an iPad or in my case, an
0:32:29iPad that was also a phone.
0:32:30I mean, yeah, I think this is always kind of where I envisioned them going.
0:32:35I mean, unlike a lot of the, this is where their advantage is, right?
0:32:38Unlike a lot of the other companies making foldable phones, almost all of those companies
0:32:43with maybe the exception of Samsung just make phones, right?
0:32:47They don't generally make tablets.
0:32:50And moreover, even if they do, they're not good, right?
0:32:53Like, because Android is not a great tablet, you know, system.
0:32:57So Apple has a huge advantage here in that they have a successful tablet system and a successful
0:33:02phone system.
0:33:03And if they can make the, you know, the utility of it is once you get that open into a, you
0:33:09know, a four, three ratio, you can probably run iPad apps, like just like their iPad apps.
0:33:14I mean, yeah, there'll be some scaling and whatever, but like it's fairly, it's the same ratio.
0:33:19So it shouldn't matter that much.
0:33:20It's a huge advantage that Apple has a good, and we can, there's a lot of iPad criticism
0:33:26out there and there's a lot of issues with Apple's developer relations and all that.
0:33:29But that all said, the iPad is the definitive tablet.
0:33:33It's got a great library of software, even if we have a lot, again, not saying that there
0:33:38are, it's perfect.
0:33:38I'm just saying that in terms of being a competitive advantage over Android phones, in terms of
0:33:44making a, an iPhone that opens up and you go into iPad mode, it's a big advantage for them.
0:33:50I think it really is.
0:33:51It can make this product very, very good because they've spent 15 years on the iPad and they
0:33:57just get to use that when this phone is unfolded.
0:34:01Really interesting.
0:34:02And I know, I saw some criticism there, like, well, all the videos in 16.9, so is it really,
0:34:07what's the point?
0:34:08And it's like, well, to your point, A, there is a lot of older content in 4.3.
0:34:12There is, I mean, if you're dealing with an iPad, you already have this problem.
0:34:16Like letterboxing is a thing, you know, we, it's fine.
0:34:20We've been dealing with this for years.
0:34:22So I don't think it's necessarily bad.
0:34:24And I think the idea of having a larger screen that's available to you, because like, look,
0:34:28I like having a phone with a decent size screen, but if I could flip that open and have a much
0:34:33larger screen for the cases where I need that, that's pretty compelling to me.
0:34:37So I don't know if it would be good enough to, like, I don't feel like it would make me get
0:34:40rid of my iPad necessarily.
0:34:41Cause I use my iPad for a lot of things that I think this may not be suited for, but I'm
0:34:46super intrigued by it.
0:34:47And I think, I think there's something here.
0:34:50And plus like, this is the first version, so it's going to continue to evolve.
0:34:54I also think one of the points that's been interesting that we, you know, you've been
0:34:58making elsewhere.
0:34:59And I think people have been talking about is Apple is kind of feels like it's at the top
0:35:04of its hardware game.
0:35:05And the hardware is a big question here, even more so than software, as we just discussed,
0:35:09like the software could just be like it's iPadOS on the inside and it's iOS on the outside.
0:35:13Fine.
0:35:14But the hardware is the question because this is the issue we've seen with all the foldable
0:35:19phones.
0:35:19They are more fragile.
0:35:20They have creases.
0:35:22The screens can break, right?
0:35:23Like these are a lot of risks that you're taking here, but Apple does seem to have really
0:35:28high quality hardware engineers and they are really firing on all cylinders.
0:35:31So I'm sure there will be some shortcoming of this device.
0:35:36There has to be like, let's go.
0:35:38So that's the first version, right?
0:35:39Doesn't do face ID.
0:35:40It's going to be touch ID.
0:35:42It's going to be the camera is not going to be that great, but we'll see.
0:35:46Maybe the screen won't work quite the way they want it to.
0:35:48And maybe there'll be more of a crease than they want.
0:35:50But like, again, this is starting point, right?
0:35:53Like, yeah.
0:35:54Yeah.
0:35:54And it feels very much like the point where Apple feels like the screen technology is
0:35:59good enough for an iPhone to have it.
0:36:01Whereas I think many of their competitors don't mind being out early with something that doesn't
0:36:05quite work right.
0:36:06Apple tends not to do that and kind of just hangs there for a while, especially with something
0:36:11like the iPhone, which is the crown jewel.
0:36:13I'm just not sure I'm ready to spend $2,000 on a phone.
0:36:15I know.
0:36:16I mean, but I will say this.
0:36:18If you're somebody who frequently buys an iPhone and an iPad, it starts to get interesting.
0:36:23Although even then, you could buy a regular iPhone and an iPad Air and have two products.
0:36:28Anyway, yeah, it's a place for them to get their revenue up, but also a place to experiment.
0:36:34I'm hoping this is all real.
0:36:36The other rumor item is the iOS 19 interface, which has been chatted about a lot.
0:36:42FrontPage Tech has a video showing mock-ups of it.
0:36:47I find it fascinating that one of the things that John Prosser says in his video is that
0:36:52when we last showed you, because remember, they did a thing with a mock-up of a camera app
0:36:55and said, see, it kind of looks like the sports app, kind of looks like the invites app.
0:36:59This is what they're doing with their design language.
0:37:01And he says in this video, the camera app was all we were allowed to share at the time,
0:37:06which is fascinating because what that suggests to me is that they got a lot of information
0:37:11from somebody on the inside and they said, you can't leak this all, which is interesting
0:37:15because that's a very weird condition to put on something as a leaker.
0:37:20Obviously, they must have been afraid.
0:37:21It's a leaker.
0:37:22Yeah.
0:37:22Yeah, right?
0:37:23Like it is, it just strikes me.
0:37:27It's like, here's all this information, but you can't print most of it yet.
0:37:30Just wait and we'll get to it later.
0:37:32And I mean, we've worked with people who've had great sources who haven't been able to print
0:37:35stuff like that.
0:37:36I understand it, but I think it's funny where the control of what gets leaked out of the
0:37:41dump of information is the source's control, but the source gives them everything, but then
0:37:48says, but you can't do all of it yet.
0:37:50It just is weird to me.
0:37:51Don't worry, Jason.
0:37:53They are clean on OPSEC.
0:37:54I'm sure it was all on signal.
0:37:56It's fine.
0:37:57Anyway, this design is more rounded, has translucent glass elements.
0:38:00It's the things we've been thinking about.
0:38:02You can get some suggestions of it from Vision OS.
0:38:04Although again, I will say my feeling is they were working on this design language and Vision
0:38:08OS got it because they needed to ship Vision OS and they didn't want to ship it with an old
0:38:13design language that was about to be replaced.
0:38:15So they shipped it with what they were working on and used it as a trial.
0:38:18But I don't think it's like they built Vision OS and everybody said, that's it.
0:38:22Let's do that for everything.
0:38:24I don't think that's the case here.
0:38:25I do think that those apps that came out, sports and invites, were influenced heavily by this
0:38:32design language.
0:38:32I do think that that's true.
0:38:34Interesting outline floating effect for the keyboard in some of the mock apps.
0:38:38Yeah, it was, I mean, again, you can watch the front page tech video.
0:38:43It is like essentially if it was a web article that would have three screenshots, but instead
0:38:47there's this long video with jokes and false starts and filler and I don't love them, but
0:38:53I also understand it's the YouTube game.
0:38:55Yeah.
0:38:56Yeah.
0:38:56It's a YouTube game.
0:38:58It's a YouTube game.
0:38:59I, yeah, I'm curious to know just how accurate these are.
0:39:03I mean, obviously we see some pushback on this as you, yeah.
0:39:08So Mark Gurman weighed in and he said the iOS 19 images floating around aren't representative
0:39:12of what we'll see at WWDC.
0:39:14They look to be based on either very old builds or vague descriptions, missing key features.
0:39:19Expect more from Apple in June.
0:39:21Regardless, mock-ups, real or not, are always exciting for Apple Watchers.
0:39:24So he's literally like saying, don't listen to John Prosser, but pats him on the head and
0:39:28says, but it's fun.
0:39:29Everybody's having fun, aren't they?
0:39:31And I, what I think here is fascinating too, because this either means Mark Gurman knows
0:39:37what it looks like, can't report more about it and is knocking this down.
0:39:41Or I think more likely one of Mark Gurman's sources reached out to him and said, this is
0:39:46not representative.
0:39:47Yeah.
0:39:48Yeah.
0:39:48And I can, I can believe that.
0:39:49I mean, even if it's not inaccurate in the sense that it was correct at some point, Apple
0:39:57always has a vested interest in trying to downplay these kinds of things, right?
0:40:01Because it wants to make a big splash when it unveils this.
0:40:04And so it is, you know, within their interest to be like, no, no, no, no, you think you've
0:40:09seen it all, but that's not, that's not really what it looks like.
0:40:11Either that or Mark Gurman was also given all that information with a condition not to leak.
0:40:15This has got one guy is going around telling everybody, oh, here's all the iOS 19 screenshots,
0:40:20but you can't, you can't publish them anywhere except for this one.
0:40:23And maybe these three.
0:40:25I mean, I'm intrigued in the idea of a, of a big new design overhaul.
0:40:29Uh, we talked about this a little bit on clockwise this week, uh, uh, Micah and I, especially
0:40:33in our post show, um, you know, there, there's a lot to be said about this.
0:40:38The iOS seven design language has lasted a long time, right?
0:40:41I mean, 12 years that's, it's gotten refined obviously over that time.
0:40:46Uh, we don't have exactly the same interface that we had when iOS seven debuted, but it is
0:40:51still fundamentally kind of the same look and feel broadly speaking.
0:40:56But in that time, we've had a lot of changes like Johnny Ive was instrumental in the iOS
0:41:01seven redesign and he's not there anymore.
0:41:03So, and he, and you know, not only is he not there, but a lot of the people who worked for
0:41:07him are not there.
0:41:08So the people who are coming up now probably have, you know, uh, maybe this is all they've
0:41:12seen.
0:41:13They've only lived with the iOS seven one.
0:41:14So they get a chance to really push the envelope and do something different.
0:41:17Um, and you know, I know there's a lot of people who get trepidatious because of the
0:41:21idea of like, Hey, well, no, we don't want to change for just for changes sake.
0:41:25Right.
0:41:26Like, well, people get frustrated.
0:41:27The photos redesigned this year is a good example.
0:41:29Like I know people who still get frustrated with it.
0:41:31I think it's a nice redesign.
0:41:32I think it is thoughtful, but I can understand why people who are, especially are very emotionally
0:41:37attached to their photos and are frustrated when they can't find the thing that they used
0:41:40to know how to get to are like, why is this all different?
0:41:43Um, but I think it's one thing that we don't think about enough is sort of the flip side.
0:41:47Like you shouldn't leave things the way they are just for the sake of leaving things the
0:41:52way they are either.
0:41:53Like that's the corollary to this is you can't just keep things the same forever because
0:41:59especially in, in something like technology where the field is moving forward faster and
0:42:04faster and there's different stuff.
0:42:05Like you can't just expect that last year's interface or 12 years ago interface is going
0:42:10to accommodate the stuff you're doing now.
0:42:11I've heard from a lot of people who say, say I'm worried about this because I don't really
0:42:16like the direction that Apple's interfaces have been going lately.
0:42:19And I totally get that.
0:42:20That is a reason to have trepidation.
0:42:22At the same time though, I often see these arguments that are like, well, I don't like what Apple
0:42:27has done with this interface.
0:42:28So they, so I'm, they, they shouldn't change it essentially.
0:42:31So they shouldn't do something new because I don't like what they have now.
0:42:34And, and that's, I get the fear, but it also doesn't make any sense.
0:42:39Like I can make the argument.
0:42:41I don't know if they're going to succeed at this.
0:42:42I really don't like, I do agree.
0:42:44There are lots of reasons to be worried.
0:42:46And the truth is you mentioned iOS seven.
0:42:50The truth is every redesign, this happened with a Mac world web redesign and the macro print
0:42:55redesign that I did and all that, like every redesign goes too far and then spends time
0:43:01reeling it back.
0:43:02But you do end up getting to a new base place that was not possible when you spent a decade
0:43:08just shoving new things into an existing design.
0:43:10That's why designs get old and weird.
0:43:12So my counter argument, my hope, my reason for hope and optimism, I'll say it again for
0:43:18Mac users is yes.
0:43:21It's been annoying to have iOS things shoved into Mac OS over the last decade, but what
0:43:26if that's because they were using iOS design language to shove things into Mac OS because
0:43:33the iOS design language and the Mac OS design language never really synced up.
0:43:39And what if with this, if they did it right, they should be thinking about a design language
0:43:45that can scale across all their devices and what's unique about each of their devices.
0:43:50I'm not saying they will do this, but I'm saying that that's a reason for optimism because I think
0:43:56that Mac stuff will get a better design in a design system that thinks about the Mac and I'm not sure the stuff they brought to the Mac over the last 10 years from iOS has been anything but stuff that they, you know, they slap into Mac OS and it doesn't feel like Mac OS.
0:44:14So there's, I think there's reason for hope here.
0:44:16I totally get the argument that their track record recently is, uh, is worrisome and that
0:44:21this may be bad.
0:44:22Also when it comes out and people have a million criticisms of it, that doesn't mean it's a
0:44:27failure for a few reasons.
0:44:28One is, as I discovered when people complained about the box box during the Superbowl, anything
0:44:34new will be, will be attacked because it's new and people are used to what is there before.
0:44:38And as I said before, every redesign goes too far and needs to get reeled back in to the nature of the beast.
0:44:43In fact, a redesign that doesn't go too far is not an effective redesign.
0:44:46I would argue because it's too timid and you need to try a bunch of stuff.
0:44:50And then, and then you find out over the summer and over the success of years of OS release, you, you, you sand off all the rough, rough edges and hopefully get to a good place.
0:45:00That's where this is going to go, but that's not going to stop any of the discourse about this.
0:45:05No, absolutely not.
0:45:06Because people feel, I mean, again, phones are things that we carry with us every day and many of us use them constantly.
0:45:13And so it is something you are exposed to much more than even in many cases, people who sit down at a computer at some point.
0:45:20And so I think people just get emotionally attached and yeah, I get it.
0:45:25It's, it can be frustrating if you pull out this device that you're so used to having your entire life in and all of a sudden you're like, ah, yeah, everything's different.
0:45:34Where do I, where's my stuff?
0:45:35That's what happened with iOS 7.
0:45:37iOS 7 convinced a lot of people just to not trust any software updates because it completely changed their, and Apple has changed their approach since then.
0:45:45But yeah.
0:45:45Between that and it came on the heels of Apple Maps too, right?
0:45:49Like that was a bad, like one, two punch over those two years.
0:45:52That's rough time.
0:45:53When people talk about dark time now for Apple with the AI stuff and all that, this came up in Mac Break Weekly last week where it was like, yeah, you remember the butterfly keyboard and all the ports going off the laptops?
0:46:04Or yeah, you remember Apple Maps and the iOS 7 redesign?
0:46:09Like Apple has rough patches.
0:46:11And the question is, you know, do they course correct or not?
0:46:14That's the, that's the catch.
0:46:16And how quickly do they, do they course correct?
0:46:17Also a good, good point being made in our member discord, David Schaub saying, you know, I'm concerned Apple will break the accessibility features I use to mitigate Apple's old or wrong choices.
0:46:27And it's like, I get it, but this is one of those things like a movie is announced and people start listing all the reasons it's going to be bad.
0:46:34And the fact is any project can be good or bad.
0:46:37And until you see it, you don't know.
0:46:40And so, yes, David is absolutely a hundred percent right to be concerned that Apple is going to blow it and break things and mess everything up and not make accessibility features to allow you to un-mess it up.
0:46:52It is a legitimate concern, but I would also argue maybe this is an opportunity for Apple to fix those issues so that it isn't a concern anymore.
0:47:01And until we see how they execute, we don't know.
0:47:04I'm going to take it even a step further, Jason.
0:47:06Every update, like every movie, can be good and bad.
0:47:10There may be things about it that are good.
0:47:12And there may be things about it that are bad.
0:47:14Also true.
0:47:14Probably will be.
0:47:15In fact, odds are.
0:47:17Unlike a movie, well, I mean, some movies, they do the special edition and the director's cut and all that.
0:47:21But like, unlike most movies, software evolves, right?
0:47:24And redesigns evolve.
0:47:26So you throw it out there and then you, I mean, it always happens.
0:47:29We did a Macworld website redesign that was so vastly better than the previous one.
0:47:34And a lot of the feedback was, I can't believe you did this.
0:47:37You've ruined the website because it doesn't do X.
0:47:40And our response to that was not, oh, let's revert to the old website.
0:47:43Our response was, oh, we got X a little bit wrong.
0:47:47Let's fix it.
0:47:48Right?
0:47:49And that's not the same as this whole design is useless.
0:47:52Throw it all out.
0:47:52It's like, no, I mean, we thought this would be something that you would like.
0:47:57And it turns out it doesn't really work.
0:47:59And let's talk about it and let's get more feedback and let's make changes if we need to.
0:48:02And that's just, it's part of the process.
0:48:04So we'll be talking, I, Dan, I think this is a preview of our summer.
0:48:08Yeah.
0:48:10There's going to be a lot of, a lot of design change talk.
0:48:13I am sure.
0:48:13I think maybe this will, I mean, you know, people doing the conspiracy theory that this
0:48:18will take the pressure off a Apple intelligence, which I think is not, certainly not why they
0:48:23did it, but sure.
0:48:23It probably will.
0:48:24We'll have a new thing to talk about.
0:48:27Yeah, it's not a design smoke screen, but it might be a smoke screen regardless.
0:48:31To paraphrase the old, you won't have Apple intelligence to kick around anymore.
0:48:36Yeah.
0:48:37All right.
0:48:38Really quick dive into the B-tails.
0:48:41Woo-hoo.
0:48:42Woo-hoo.
0:48:43Oh, yeah, you got it.
0:48:44You're the right age.
0:48:45Oh, I love DuckTales.
0:48:47Please.
0:48:47For the B-tails.
0:48:47I'm right here.
0:48:48I can do the whole song.
0:48:49This is like an almost all segment episode.
0:48:52I don't know why.
0:48:53We've got segments.
0:48:53I might as well tag things as being in a segment if we've got a segment to do.
0:48:57Mac OS 15.4 and iOS.
0:48:5818.4 should be out imminently.
0:49:00Last week, they put out a bunch of release candidates, including Mac OS twice.
0:49:07Something was in there that wasn't quite right.
0:49:10So that should be out this week, maybe even momentarily.
0:49:14Of course, what does it contain?
0:49:16Well, not any of those promised AI features.
0:49:18Zing.
0:49:19Boom.
0:49:19Oh, we already have been talking about that for weeks.
0:49:21But Apple Intelligence actually picks up support officially for French, German, Italian, Brazilian, Portuguese, Spanish, Japanese, Korean, Chinese, simplified, and English in India and Singapore.
0:49:34So that's nice.
0:49:35The priority inbox features that were strangely only on the iPhone now appear on the Mac and the iPad in this update.
0:49:41Sure.
0:49:42The easy device setup with Quick Start, where just like with a phone and an iPad, you can now set up a Mac by holding your old Mac.
0:49:49If it's running this or your phone near your Mac and having it basically say, yeah, this is who this person is.
0:49:55This is their Apple ID and get that thing started quickly, which is really nice.
0:50:00Great feature.
0:50:00I remember it was like eight, nine years ago.
0:50:04It was a long time ago where Mike and I did that episode where we complained the whole episode about how Apple's iPhone setup was a disaster.
0:50:12And that your happiest day as an iPhone buyer became a nightmare because you couldn't get things transferred and all of that.
0:50:18And I'm happy to report, I'm not taking credit for it, but I'm happy to report that since we've done that, it really has been on a trajectory where they are so much better at this aspect of device setup than they used to be.
0:50:30So this is bringing it to the Mac.
0:50:31It's great.
0:50:32It gets better every year.
0:50:33I mean, I honestly think that the transfer and speaking as someone who gets a new phone every year and has to do that dance every time.
0:50:41I mean, I think that that process is vastly improved year over year over year.
0:50:45And I think it's good that they're adding that to the Mac side as well, because you don't do it probably as much as you do with the phone.
0:50:51But it's still, if you've got the benefits, you might as well leverage them.
0:50:55Yeah, for sure.
0:50:56Also, visual intelligence improvements.
0:51:01Yeah, it's coming to the iPhone 15 Pro will be able to use it in the Pro Max because it will, remember, it relied on the camera control button, which those didn't have.
0:51:10Right.
0:51:11Even though those can run Apple intelligence.
0:51:14On the 16e, they do.
0:51:16And so now they'll be able to do that on the 15 Pro.
0:51:19Yeah, either via the action button.
0:51:21And there's also a control in control center.
0:51:23What's the ambient music change?
0:51:24So there's now ambient music available in the control center as well.
0:51:29Apple added these four different sound categories, sleep, chill, productivity, and well-being.
0:51:35And it just plays music in the background.
0:51:36It just plays ambient music.
0:51:37So if you're like, I mean, you know, speaking of someone who does put his headphones in sometimes and doesn't put anything on, like I'm at the coffee shop or something, and I'm just like, sometimes I'll have music on, but then I'll pause it and I'll forget to put it on again.
0:51:49Like, I don't know, the idea of just having ambient background noise available.
0:51:52Sure.
0:51:52It's fun.
0:51:53It's a fun idea.
0:51:53And in a really interesting feature that I have not used a lot, but the priority notifications are there on iOS.
0:52:02So you get these notifications that it is analyzing with its ML models and saying, this seems important.
0:52:09And so they get floated to the top and they are outlined and they glow.
0:52:13And it's like, this seems to be an important notification for you.
0:52:16I've used this in the beta.
0:52:19It is mixed, as you might expect from these types of features.
0:52:24Sometimes it works fine.
0:52:25But just this morning, I definitely got one that was for one of those, you haven't paid your toll, your car toll scams.
0:52:32So it's like, okay, well, that's not important.
0:52:34So never mind.
0:52:35And then there's one other thing I noticed, actually, as I was scrolling through, I forgot.
0:52:39This is, you know, was in the beta when 18.4 came out, is the Apple News food section will be available.
0:52:46Ah, yes.
0:52:47Plus subscribers, the recipes and all that stuff, which I think is interesting.
0:52:50It does feel a little bit like with its integration with sports stuff and then the puzzles that it's added.
0:52:56In some ways, I think Apple is trying to recreate the newspaper a bit more in its Apple News thing, which I think is clever.
0:53:02It's a content bundle.
0:53:03I wonder sometimes, the food thing is the thing that made me wonder about it.
0:53:08But I also now am thinking about the puzzles and stuff, too, is I appreciate the all-in-one approach,
0:53:15which is, like, it's all-in Apple News app for News Plus subscribers.
0:53:18They're trying to create a content bundle.
0:53:20Yep.
0:53:21I do wonder if, and this is going to make anybody who uses, like, a third-party app wins,
0:53:27but, like, I do wonder if they should maybe just make a recipes app that contains all that content.
0:53:32Maybe.
0:53:34And maybe a games app.
0:53:37Oh.
0:53:38Lex.
0:53:39Lex, cover your ears.
0:53:40Apple.games.
0:53:42I don't know.
0:53:43It's because, I mean, the challenge is that some people use news all the time.
0:53:49Other people don't even think about it.
0:53:51And if you, so the argument is this will get people to use the news app.
0:53:54And then once we got them, the counterargument is people who don't go in the news app because
0:53:59they don't find it valuable are never going to find this content, even if they might like
0:54:02to do the crossword puzzle, even if they might like to look up recipes.
0:54:07Like, I think about this, and I'm like, oh, recipes in the news app.
0:54:10Yeah.
0:54:10I mean, the Times does this with its setup, right?
0:54:13Yeah.
0:54:13The New York Times app is news, but then it has a cooking app, and then it has a puzzles
0:54:17app, and they're separate.
0:54:18It does.
0:54:18And you can subscribe to them separately in some cases, too.
0:54:20Indeed.
0:54:21So I do wonder, I'm not saying that Apple should make a full-fledged recipes app that you could
0:54:27add your recipes to, although they might do that, but it would be interesting if they
0:54:32could put their news plus.
0:54:34What I'd really like, this will not happen, but wouldn't it be nice if Apple thought this
0:54:39way, is Apple's put a bunch of recipes in news plus.
0:54:43What if Apple offered a recipes API that allowed recipe apps to include Apple news plus recipes
0:54:50in their search?
0:54:52That'd be interesting.
0:54:54So like cremela or paprika or whatever could pull from that.
0:54:58I don't know.
0:54:59Yeah.
0:55:00I was wondering briefly if there was a thing in the alternative, too, where it could pull
0:55:03stuff from your recipe apps into Apple news plus or pull games that you want to play.
0:55:08And I was like, I don't know if that's a good solution or not, but it would be cool if there
0:55:12was integrations with like, hey, you like these games in Apple news plus.
0:55:15Why don't you try out Lex's games or the New York times games or what have you?
0:55:19Yeah.
0:55:20That'd be interesting, too.
0:55:21All right.
0:55:23This episode of Upgrade is brought to you by Ecamm.
0:55:27Ecamm Live is the leading video production and live streaming studio built for the Mac.
0:55:33And it doesn't stop there because Ecamm is great at simplifying your workflow, too.
0:55:36You can do it all with the Ecamm app.
0:55:38Get started quickly and have everything on hand to create whatever you need with video.
0:55:42I am an Ecamm Live subscriber.
0:55:45I love it.
0:55:46The reason I love it is because first and foremost, it's a Mac app.
0:55:50It's made for the Mac.
0:55:51If you've used other video streaming apps, they are great.
0:55:55They're often free.
0:55:57They're open source.
0:55:58They feel like open source apps.
0:56:00Sometimes they feel a little bit janky.
0:56:02Their interfaces are weird.
0:56:03Sometimes they're slow.
0:56:04Ecamm Live is none of those things because it's built for the Mac on Mac frameworks.
0:56:09Everything in it is super Mac-like.
0:56:11I use it for all our Six Colors live streams, for all of the Total Party Kill live streams
0:56:18that I stream.
0:56:19What I love about it most these days is its integration with Zoom because we use Zoom for
0:56:26our podcasting.
0:56:27So I can pop with Zoom integration.
0:56:30Okay, I got to step back.
0:56:32I used to capture the Zoom screen and then carve it up into little squares and put those
0:56:37squares in places for the people who are on the podcast.
0:56:39With the Zoom integration, I just make boxes where the people should go and assign the
0:56:43people to boxes.
0:56:44And it just happens automatically from session to session.
0:56:47It makes it so much easier.
0:56:49The quality is really great.
0:56:51It lets me stream at a very high quality because the individual people are coming in at 720p, but
0:56:59they're actually scaled down and a little bit smaller.
0:57:01So they're actually of higher quality.
0:57:03It's really great.
0:57:04easy to set up my YouTube streams so that I can press a couple of buttons in the interface,
0:57:10add a new stream, schedule it for the future, press a button and go live, press a button and
0:57:15we're done.
0:57:15It auto records in the background.
0:57:16So it generates a super high quality file on my disc.
0:57:19It's got a great set of canvases so you can do different layouts you can set up.
0:57:23So I have a Total Party Kill layout with everybody's faces in little boxes, but I've got a different
0:57:28one where the faces are in different shape boxes.
0:57:30And there's a map that's a screen capture.
0:57:33They have a new version that just added some great new screen capture features that allow
0:57:39the screen capture aspect ratio to be more dynamically controlled.
0:57:43Like it's, it's all there.
0:57:45It's all full speed.
0:57:47It's fast.
0:57:47It's responsive.
0:57:48And it works the way a Mac app should work.
0:57:52So it's great for streaming, recording, podcasting, and presenting.
0:57:55If you want to stand out from the crowd, you need high quality video.
0:57:59You can screen share, you can use multiple cameras.
0:58:01I bought a second Insta360 webcam because Ecamm Live will let me use it as a second input,
0:58:08including giving me complete pan, tilt, zoom control over it inside Ecamm Live without even
0:58:13using the Insta360 app.
0:58:15And I direct these shows in real time.
0:58:17I use their Stream Deck plugin to do switching and toggling on and off using my Stream Deck.
0:58:25You can add in logos, titles, lower thirds, graphics, drop in video clips, bring on interview
0:58:30guests, use a green screen.
0:58:31I use my green screen with it when I'm doing the D&D stuff.
0:58:34You can bring in comments from YouTube or elsewhere and put them on the screen and react to them,
0:58:40which we do with the Six Colors live streams that we do.
0:58:42It does it all.
0:58:43Ecamm's members are entrepreneurs, marketing professionals, podcasters, educators, musicians,
0:58:47church leaders, bloggers, and content creators of all kinds.
0:58:51If you're on the pro level plan like I am, you get Ecamm for Zoom, automatically send
0:58:55Ecamm Live's audio and video outputs into a Zoom meeting.
0:58:58How about that?
0:58:59So that you can actually produce your output and send it to a Zoom meeting or a Zoom webinar
0:59:05or event.
0:59:06You can add up to eight Zoom participants as cameras in your broadcaster recording, automatically
0:59:12create individual participant audio and video recordings for later that are separate.
0:59:17really good.
0:59:18You can get one month free today.
0:59:20Go to ecamm.com slash upgradefm and use the code upgradefm.
0:59:24That's a whole month free of Ecamm Live.
0:59:26E-C-A-M-M dot com slash upgradefm and code upgradefm.
0:59:32Go there now.
0:59:33Check it out.
0:59:34We like those people over at Ecamm.
0:59:36Thank you for supporting Upgrade.
0:59:38Dan, WWDC 2025.
0:59:43It's here.
0:59:45It's now.
0:59:45I got to go.
0:59:46I'm not surprised they're doing it.
0:59:47Right now.
0:59:48No.
0:59:48Not right.
0:59:49Not a surprise that they're doing it.
0:59:52We're all shocked.
0:59:52Not a surprise the way they're doing it.
0:59:54Not a surprise that it's the week of June 9th, but at least now we know and can therefore
0:59:59make our hotel reservations.
1:00:01The most important of all, make your travel plans.
1:00:06Yeah.
1:00:07Yeah.
1:00:07Nothing, as you said, nothing surprising about this from the format, which sounds like it's
1:00:12going to be exactly what we've seen the last several years.
1:00:14Yep.
1:00:15I mean, we've talked a lot about this.
1:00:16I know you've talked a lot about this.
1:00:18There's no reason for them to change.
1:00:20This is kind of a piece with their, like, you know, when you're on top, why change, right?
1:00:25Like, it's working for them.
1:00:26Works for them.
1:00:26Yes.
1:00:26Yeah.
1:00:27Like, would there be elements of doing a live show that could have advantages?
1:00:33Sure.
1:00:33Would those advantages outweigh them being able to do a heavily produced, you know, pre-recorded
1:00:38video?
1:00:38Not necessarily.
1:00:39I don't think so.
1:00:40I don't think so.
1:00:41It gives them complete control.
1:00:43I wonder about some of the ancillary stuff.
1:00:46Like, last year, for example, we got that post-keynote session where I, Justine, interviewed
1:00:53John, John, Andrea, and Tim, and everybody.
1:00:57And, like, I, again, a lot of that felt like damage control, right?
1:01:01Like, we're behind on AI and we need to talk about it.
1:01:04So, let's, yeah, let's promote our, what we're doing.
1:01:06I don't know that I expect them to repeat that this year.
1:01:10I think this will look more like the pre-ones where it's like, okay, it's a recorded thing,
1:01:14then there's the State of the Union, and then you'll have some other stuff.
1:01:17I mean, they may experiment.
1:01:19The Apple PR has shown, like, if they have a new thing, like, if they do the big redesign,
1:01:23I could see them doing a post-keynote availability, press availability at the Steve Jobs Theater
1:01:32with the design team talking about the new design.
1:01:37And the idea there is that it's a controlled environment that allows the press to write
1:01:42more about their, you know, what they want to say about why they did the design the way
1:01:47they did.
1:01:47I could see it, but it would really take that where they feel that that's necessary.
1:01:51And I could also see them say, no, it's not necessary.
1:01:53We'll do a, we'll do an exclusive with Wired or something and, and we'll put it there or the
1:01:59Wall Street Journal or whatever it is.
1:02:00We'll do some exclusive interviews and we'll have somebody go on the talk show and that'll
1:02:04be that.
1:02:05But it's going to be the same game plan.
1:02:07We also got a lot of, um, of briefings.
1:02:11Like I was, like there was an Xcode briefing and there was a private cloud compute briefing
1:02:15and they, more than they've done in the past.
1:02:18And again, it depends on what they want to explain to the press.
1:02:21They could do.
1:02:21It's controlled narrative, right?
1:02:22It's, it's, it's not only what they want to talk about is what they don't want to talk
1:02:25about, right?
1:02:26So if you're like, you know, if they're, if they're promoting something where it's like,
1:02:30here, we're going to talk about the new redesign or whatever, it's because they may not want
1:02:34to talk about Apple intelligence, for example, this year.
1:02:36Uh, and so if they can, again, spin, if they can shunt you into talking about, these are the
1:02:41topics we're really excited to talk about and those other things, that's fine.
1:02:44We'll answer your questions, but we're not as excited to talk about those.
1:02:46So let's, let's focus on this stuff.
1:02:47It's a, I mean, it's a, it's a press event and it's also a PR event because they'll invite
1:02:52developers there.
1:02:53Um, and, and I mean, that's going to be an interesting dynamic because there's a lot of
1:02:59uncertainty right now about us based events.
1:03:01The fact is there are a lot of people who are going to be reluctant to travel to the U S
1:03:04given what's going on with immigration enforcement.
1:03:06Fortunately, most of the event is online, but, and the, and the group of developers who gets
1:03:11invited is incredibly small, but I have also heard from a lot of people in our community
1:03:15who don't come as an invited developer, but come because this is the one event all year
1:03:20where all the people in the community, high profile developers and media people are, and,
1:03:26and people we know at Apple are all in the same place.
1:03:28And that will also get hit by this, where there are people we know who feel like they aren't
1:03:34comfortable coming through U S immigration for various reasons, you know?
1:03:38And, uh, I think that will be the case where all those, this is a, everybody gets together.
1:03:44I suspect that it will not be as much as it's been in the past for those reasons.
1:03:49It does feel between that.
1:03:51And also some of the flack Apple has taken for its political and other stances or lack thereof,
1:03:58uh, you know, there is a, a feeling, I think a slightly more subdued feeling around it this
1:04:04year.
1:04:04Uh, so there's a lot of challenges, but that said, however many, uh, developers they invite,
1:04:09they will get a bunch of gleeful developers who will cheer, uh, that will be in the seats
1:04:13at Apple park and they will go ahead with it.
1:04:16But you know, that, that is a thing that's kind of hanging over it and we'll see.
1:04:18It's not going to be the, the audience of a last place baseball team on a cold day, right?
1:04:23It's not going to be like, Oh, all those open seats, right?
1:04:25They'll fill all the seats.
1:04:26What's going to happen though, is that we're going to, we're going to be at a, at a dinner
1:04:30at a restaurant somewhere and be like, or even at the event and say, well, where is so
1:04:34and so?
1:04:34And, and, and the answer is going to be, well, they didn't come.
1:04:36Yeah.
1:04:37And, uh, in fact, what I would love, this is a thing that they haven't announced, but I
1:04:41would love if they would consider doing this and they might do this.
1:04:44It's possible is to offer some alternate venues.
1:04:48I know they did that in London last year where they did an event at Battersea.
1:04:54So it's possible that there could be some other things, but it's not going to be the same because
1:04:59it's not going to be the one place that everybody is.
1:05:01That's not going to happen.
1:05:03Yeah.
1:05:03I do think that would be smart.
1:05:04And they've done a lot of their little like, uh, tech talks and stuff, right?
1:05:08In various places.
1:05:09They have a lot of offices around the world.
1:05:12They have retail stores around the world.
1:05:14Like I've always thought like, you know, if, if you're going to call it the worldwide developers
1:05:18conference, like, I don't know, embrace that first part a little bit more, realize that
1:05:22you have lots of people.
1:05:23Yeah.
1:05:23Granted, it's great that everybody's online, but if you can also sort of have opportunities
1:05:26for people to gather locally to like, Hey, we're going to watch the keynote at the Apple
1:05:30store or we're going to invite several developers who live in this country to come to the campus
1:05:34and I don't know, Bangalore or something like, you know, that's great.
1:05:37You should do that.
1:05:38You should take advantage of the fact that you're a global company.
1:05:41So you and I both spent our, uh, most recent Macworld columns talking about what this event
1:05:46is going to be and what they're going to do.
1:05:47I, I argued in mine this week that I think this is the most intriguing, um, WWDC maybe
1:05:55ever since I've been covering it.
1:05:57And you know, the early days of OS 10, there was a lot of interest in like what they were
1:06:01doing, but here it's more, it's not really about what they're doing as much as like, what
1:06:07is the strategy and how do they communicate it?
1:06:10Because they created the Apple intelligence brand.
1:06:14That was kind of the goal of last June and they did do that.
1:06:17So maybe they back off a little bit.
1:06:19My theory in my Macworld column was that they enter a cleanup and consolidation phase, right?
1:06:25They, it was a big mess last year.
1:06:28Maybe they, this year they can afford to say, we're improving our models.
1:06:32Here's a few details.
1:06:33Here's some changes that we're making to how it's implemented that, that make it nicer.
1:06:37Um, we'll ship the stuff that we promised that we didn't ship the last time.
1:06:41Maybe there's a few new features.
1:06:43Wouldn't it be nice if part of the story was developer focused this time?
1:06:47Because as we noted last June, but I just want to put it out there again, most of what
1:06:51they announced last June at the worldwide developer conference was not things that developers
1:06:56could do anything with, like the most developer integration is like, you could make a button
1:07:02to do image playgrounds, or you could use the, the, the writing tools in your app, but there
1:07:08wasn't like access to Apple's models or anything like that.
1:07:11And I understand it on one level, which is, it was brand new and it was rushed to market.
1:07:14But another level, you, it, as a platform play and Ben Thompson wrote about this on
1:07:20Stratechery a couple of weeks ago, handing a lot of these tools to developers could actually
1:07:24make your platform much stronger.
1:07:26So I do wonder if they will have a developer story that's more fully featured this time.
1:07:31That would be nice.
1:07:31Yeah, I agree.
1:07:33I mean, you know, obviously the big thing that everybody was kind of looking to for the developer
1:07:37story was app intents, right?
1:07:39Like that is a place where there was integration.
1:07:41It's like the, pretty much the only place that developers could have their apps touch Apple
1:07:47intelligence at all.
1:07:48And of course that's now been delayed.
1:07:50So there's a question as to whether or not that will be something they want to talk about
1:07:54this year.
1:07:55Right.
1:07:55Like, yeah.
1:07:56Is that still happening?
1:07:58Well, do they put that in the beta?
1:07:59Right.
1:08:00I mean, they might say.
1:08:01That's a big question.
1:08:01Guess what?
1:08:02We are shipping that.
1:08:03And here it's in the developer betas and you've got all summer to help us make this stuff
1:08:09better.
1:08:09Let's get going.
1:08:11And in fact, I would argue that that change is so huge that giving developers lots of runway
1:08:17instead of dropping it on a 0.4 would be really good.
1:08:21Like that would be a much.
1:08:22Yeah.
1:08:23Especially if you've taken it a step further.
1:08:25Like if you're doing more.
1:08:26Yeah.
1:08:26If that's the case, I do wonder if that's actually one of the reasons they delayed those features
1:08:30is they're like, you know, there's so much here.
1:08:32Let's get the long rollout starting at WWDC instead of dropping this in a point release
1:08:38with a very narrow beta cycle.
1:08:40Maybe.
1:08:41I don't know.
1:08:42So maybe I want to see what they learned.
1:08:45Right?
1:08:46Yeah.
1:08:46I want to see what they learned from last year.
1:08:48Did they learn anything?
1:08:48Right?
1:08:49Did they learn their lessons?
1:08:50That's the question.
1:08:50Did they learn things about AI that they can say, oh yeah, we've realized that this is
1:08:55the right thing to do?
1:08:56Or did they not?
1:08:57And then did they learn about over-promising and under-delivering?
1:08:59Because they just put a bunch of new executives in charge of Siri.
1:09:03And I know there's a lot of pressure to ship something that's better Siri and ship it soon.
1:09:08Sooner rather than later.
1:09:10And I agree.
1:09:12I want to see new Siri sooner rather than later.
1:09:15My fear is that they could get tricked into over-promising and under-delivering for Siri
1:09:23like they did with Apple Intelligence.
1:09:25Right?
1:09:26Sure.
1:09:26Yeah.
1:09:26There's a lot of questions about how they're going to respond to what they did last year.
1:09:30Right?
1:09:30Like this was kind of the thrust of my article is like, you've got a couple different
1:09:33options into how you handle this.
1:09:36Right?
1:09:36First option is to cop to it.
1:09:39Be like, you know what?
1:09:40We announced these really exciting features last year.
1:09:42We realized that we're going to take a little more time than we needed, but we're excited
1:09:45to announce they're coming in iOS 19.
1:09:47And maybe even here's some tweaks we've made or things that like more details, et cetera.
1:09:51That's one option.
1:09:52Option two is to just not talk about it, which sounds ridiculous, but I can easily imagine
1:10:01a world where Apple maybe like says like, yep, and we've obviously we've got Apple Intelligence.
1:10:04Moving on.
1:10:06Let's talk about iOS 19 redesign.
1:10:07Oh, yeah.
1:10:07Right?
1:10:08Like, and we'll all look at each other and they'll just keep going.
1:10:12Right?
1:10:12They just don't want to talk about it.
1:10:13Yeah.
1:10:14Because that was your column is like, feels like they might want to apologize here or at
1:10:17least do a apologetic statement of some sort.
1:10:21Right?
1:10:21Maybe not a full on apology, but just an acknowledgement.
1:10:24Yeah.
1:10:25Maybe.
1:10:26Or maybe not.
1:10:27And then the other question is, you know, like you said, is this just a consolidate
1:10:32and clean up?
1:10:33Or is this them saying, look, look, you know, AI is still big.
1:10:37We're going hard on it.
1:10:38And here's our next generation of Apple Intelligence features.
1:10:41Or here's what we're doing to improve the stuff we put out last year.
1:10:44Like, and especially in the case of the former, if you're talking about new features that you're
1:10:50adding under this umbrella of Apple Intelligence, how do you deal with the fact that you didn't
1:10:53ship everything that you promised the first time?
1:10:55Because on the one hand, it's like, well, what, like, can you build on it?
1:11:01Like, technologically speaking, like, it's not like you can take something like App Intents
1:11:05or, you know, personalized Siri and soup it up when you never shipped it in the first place.
1:11:11And then the other side of that, as you and I discussed elsewhere recently, is like,
1:11:15realize that you're talking, as we said, to a press event, you're talking to developers,
1:11:19you're talking to press.
1:11:21Both of these people are going to be a heck of a lot more skeptical about anything you
1:11:24announced in this area.
1:11:25A lot, right?
1:11:26Because you did not ship it.
1:11:28And in the past, you have a lot of credibility built up where we all, you know, kind of accepted
1:11:33that if you talked about a thing like, okay, some stuff might ship in the fall, some stuff
1:11:37might ship in the spring.
1:11:38That had started slipping more and more lately.
1:11:40But it would get shipped in that version, especially with something that is that big a deal that you
1:11:47spent that much time on.
1:11:49But instead, what we got to is a point of realizing, maybe not only are you not going
1:11:54to ship that, but it didn't work when you had it, right?
1:11:56Like, it was never a thing.
1:11:56Nobody saw it.
1:11:57Nobody saw it demoed.
1:11:58So a lot of press are going to be a lot like harder on like big claims that Apple makes.
1:12:02They're going to ask to see demos.
1:12:04They're going to ask to see like, okay, does that work?
1:12:07Can you show that to me?
1:12:08Can I try it?
1:12:09Like, what state is this in?
1:12:11And so I think you have to realize if you're Apple going into this, that you are going
1:12:14to be subjected to a lot more scrutiny than in the past.
1:12:16And you have to be prepared to deal with that because you're going to get a lot of questions
1:12:20out.
1:12:20And Apple PR, they're very good at what they do.
1:12:23They're very good at talking about the things they want to talk about and not talking about
1:12:25the things they don't want to talk about.
1:12:27But I think a lot of those of us who are there are going to be asking a lot of questions.
1:12:31And more to the point, we are going to be noting when they talk about things and don't
1:12:36want to show them to us.
1:12:37So you got to be very careful about how you're doing that.
1:12:40And that's the lesson I want to see if they learned this time.
1:12:42Yeah.
1:12:42They made it harder on themselves.
1:12:44And I think they, I think they are, I think they are aware of that.
1:12:47I, that if, if I'm certain about anything, it's that one that I think they know because
1:12:54of what happened last time that they need to be more specific about timeframes.
1:13:00If they can be also more warning flags about this is going to ship next year, which they
1:13:06did some.
1:13:06I mean, I will say that, that, um, like John Gruber was on here a few weeks ago and he said
1:13:13he felt bamboozled by WWDC announcements because they couldn't, they didn't ship them.
1:13:16And I dug up my piece from afterward.
1:13:20And one of the things that I pointed out is the Siri section of that keynote is aggressively
1:13:27in the future tense.
1:13:28Yeah.
1:13:29You know, so much of what they do is like, look at this image playgrounds does this image
1:13:33playgrounds does this.
1:13:34Genmoji does this.
1:13:35And then they're like, let's talk about what Siri will be able to do.
1:13:38Siri will be able to do this.
1:13:40Will, and it's all suddenly we're like in the future, we will do Siri as opposed to it
1:13:45does it now.
1:13:45I don't know.
1:13:47That was 20, 20, 30, 20, 37 flag, big red flag right there.
1:13:51So, uh, we'll see.
1:13:53A lot of things I'll do in the future, Jason.
1:13:55Oh yeah.
1:13:55I mean, it's amazing stuff in the future.
1:13:57I'm going to be in great shape.
1:13:58I'm going to go, I'm going to run a four minute mile in the future.
1:14:02I will run a four minute mile.
1:14:04I mean, you could, if you put your mind to it, it's all possible.
1:14:06So yeah, I, I, how they, how they frame it, what they show, how they choose to show it.
1:14:11Um, I'm sure it goes into the, they're going to have conversations about it based on last
1:14:15year, but that's, again, that comes back to my thing that I find most fascinating is last
1:14:20year was an aberration.
1:14:22Last year really was Apple kind of panicked, rushing and behaving very on Apple-like in
1:14:30some ways because they felt like they had to get the stuff out.
1:14:33It's been a year.
1:14:34Do they feel less panicked?
1:14:36I would argue yes, at least in some areas, maybe not so much in others.
1:14:40I mean, I really would argue that I don't think Apple feels the abject panic, existential panic
1:14:46of being completely flat-footed on AI.
1:14:49They've had, you know, a year plus to be on this path now.
1:14:53And I still believe that if you look at what's out there with AI, uh, catching up is not going
1:14:59to be hard because it seems.
1:15:02I was listening to a podcast the other day where they're like, they're so far behind and they're
1:15:06still behind.
1:15:07It's going to take them forever to catch up.
1:15:08It's like, I don't know.
1:15:09I look out at AI and it feels like everybody is just continuing to advance the ball.
1:15:14And that, that, uh, deep seek suggested that it's really easy to just kind of like do a
1:15:19fast follow of the people who are out there and that there's not much of a moat.
1:15:23And if that's true, then Apple doesn't have a lot to worry about.
1:15:26They need to press forward.
1:15:27They are still behind, but they, it gives me more confidence that they can be good enough
1:15:32and catch up.
1:15:33So I feel like the panic is not quite as strong, although the Siri panic may be real.
1:15:37The features they didn't ship may be real.
1:15:40Uh, but so what do they learn and how is their demeanor different and how does that impact
1:15:45how they communicate this stuff?
1:15:47Is, is it less panicky than last time?
1:15:51Is it not panicky?
1:15:52Yeah.
1:15:53I don't know.
1:15:53I mean, I think, you know, Apple say what you will for Apple.
1:15:58I think they work hard to try and cultivate obviously a demeanor of being very,
1:16:02calm and rational, right?
1:16:05Like they don't, they don't like to look like they're sweating.
1:16:08It's not a, not in their, in their, in their image.
1:16:11So everything you're going to see out of them is going to feel very, I think the, you know,
1:16:17they will project an image of being very much on top of things and very decisive and very,
1:16:23yeah, this is how things are doing that.
1:16:24We're very excited about this, all of this.
1:16:26Um, but yeah, our job as people who have watched this company for a long time is to read
1:16:31between the lines and see why are they doing these things?
1:16:34And what does that tell us about what they learned or did not learn from last year?
1:16:38I think in the post keynote episode that Mike and I did last year, I said, they feel very
1:16:43much like the proverbial duck where they really want to be completely serene above the water
1:16:49waterline, but in this case, everybody knows they are paddling furiously below the waterline
1:16:56because they just don't want to be seen as breaking a sweat.
1:16:59And you could argue that that's why those features went in there and that, and that people feel
1:17:06like they blew it is because they, if they're going to announce a feature, they're going to
1:17:10do so with confidence.
1:17:11So much confidence.
1:17:12In fact, that then their marketing team put out ads showing the feature in action.
1:17:16And, you know, that's why I think maybe the greatest failure in that whole process was a
1:17:22failure to communicate properly how hard it was going to be to implement those features.
1:17:28When lots of us sat there and thought that's a heavy lift, that's going to take them a lot
1:17:33of time.
1:17:33That's clearly a, a next spring kind of thing.
1:17:36Cause that's a big, big, hard feature to implement.
1:17:40Yeah.
1:17:41Yeah.
1:17:41And, and they were like, no, but we're never going to, we're never going to let them see
1:17:44a sweat.
1:17:45What I'm hearing Jason is you're saying what we have here is a failure to communicate.
1:17:51I'm just saying, be a duck, be a duck, be a duck or don't be a duck, be a goldfish,
1:17:57be a goldfish.
1:17:58Thank you.
1:17:59Um, we're going to go to ask upgrade in a moment.
1:18:03I just wanted to mention if you love upgrade and want to get more of it, please consider
1:18:07subscribing to upgrade plus longer ad free episodes every week, access to the relay members,
1:18:12discord, tons of bonus content, including two members, only relay shows and more bonus content.
1:18:17You support Mike and his new baby by signing up for upgrade.
1:18:21Plus, uh, people in memberful tell us we have incredibly low churn, which basically means
1:18:25our members want to say, say, subscribe once they've signed up.
1:18:28That's a good sign.
1:18:30Uh, so please consider upgrade plus, and now we move on.
1:18:34It's time for ask upgrade.
1:18:37I expected nothing less from the author of the galactic cold war series.
1:18:44Full of lasers.
1:18:45Full of, I'm just full of lasers.
1:18:47You are a laser machine.
1:18:49Uh, first question comes from Rio who asks, what do you do when you fall behind on your podcast
1:18:54listening?
1:18:55I'm on a Disney family vacation combined with additional, uh, hockey episodes.
1:18:59I fell behind close to a hundred hours on my podcast.
1:19:02So far, I've bumped speed to two X on some episodes and not listening to time irrelevant
1:19:08episodes.
1:19:09What do you think?
1:19:09What do you, what do you do when, uh, you're behind on podcasts?
1:19:14I have the dirty secret of a podcaster.
1:19:16Jason, I don't listen to that many podcasts.
1:19:19I mean, how could you, you work at home and I, and I make podcasts.
1:19:23I'm usually podcasting or writing.
1:19:24I have limited time to listen to podcasts.
1:19:27I do try to catch up on the few shows that I listened to regularly of which I should say
1:19:33upgrade is one.
1:19:33I don't always, I think I triage some stuff, right?
1:19:36Like there's times where I'll be like, I've got to be backlog.
1:19:38Usually if I have a backlog, it's because I was traveling.
1:19:41Um, and a lot of times if I really have a backlog, it's because I was traveling and I
1:19:45want to listen to the shows that I am normally on, but I was not on like my shows.
1:19:50So it's like, oh, I was not in the rebound on the rebound this week.
1:19:53So let me listen to John and Lex and what they talked about, or I wasn't on clockwise.
1:19:56Let me listen to what Micah did in my absence so I can know kind of have continuity or what
1:20:01have you.
1:20:01Sure.
1:20:01Um, a lot of times I have the benefit there of like, I've traveled, so maybe I'm on a
1:20:05plane or something and I have some time or I'm at the airport and I need to kill some
1:20:09time listening to a podcast.
1:20:10So that's fine.
1:20:11But I, you know, in the past when I have, you know, listened to more podcasts, more consistently,
1:20:16I literally, I just, I just declare bankruptcy.
1:20:19I think that's what it is.
1:20:20Yep.
1:20:21That's the answer.
1:20:22If it's new stuff, especially.
1:20:24Oh yeah.
1:20:24Like if it's timely, no, I'm not going to listen to that.
1:20:27Declare bankruptcy is the answer.
1:20:28If you, if you can't get to it, if it's narrative or whatever, it's like, okay, then I, I will
1:20:33spool it out, but no new stuff.
1:20:35Don't worry about it.
1:20:36I have podcasts where I'm largely not on the current.
1:20:39I'm just going through the archive.
1:20:40Rest is history is kind of like that for me.
1:20:42And that's easy.
1:20:43Cause I can just hold, I can just hold those there.
1:20:45It's history.
1:20:46Exactly.
1:20:47All that's happened.
1:20:47It's fine.
1:20:48But I mean, I just, I, I was in Hawaii and I had a huge backlog and I just recently,
1:20:53I deleted a bunch of like two ATPs and a couple of connecteds and like, I just, yes, this is,
1:21:01this is the truth is bankruptcy is a thing.
1:21:03If you are behind, first off the timely stuff, listen to the timely episodes.
1:21:07Don't listen to the past episodes.
1:21:09You can go back to the past episodes if you need to.
1:21:11If there are segments in the past episodes that sound interesting, maybe you jump to those
1:21:16and listen to those and then delete those episodes, but you can't, you can't be a completist in
1:21:22these scenarios.
1:21:22Cause I, I absolutely have dealt with the same thing, especially on vacations.
1:21:26And I think the answer is it's okay.
1:21:28If let's say, I know you're going to feel like you missed out, but like if you went on vacation
1:21:34and came back and you had that really long John Grouper episode of Upgrade and the really long
1:21:38John Syracuse episode of Upgrade, and then you're looking at Stephen Hackett and Dan Morin,
1:21:43you're like, oh boy, well, you know, maybe you don't listen to the Grouper and Syracuse episodes,
1:21:49or maybe you look at the chapter markers and say, well, I really want to hear the Upgrade
1:21:53Plus segment where Jason and John talked about James Bond for 40 minutes, or maybe the reverse.
1:21:58And you say, definitely not that, whatever it is, take control of your life and it's okay to,
1:22:03to skip.
1:22:04And if you know what, if it becomes a part of podcast lore, it's still there.
1:22:08You go back and listen, download it again and listen to it again.
1:22:10And that's fine.
1:22:11Think about it this way.
1:22:12You were on vacation, having amazing experiences.
1:22:15Those podcast hosts didn't get to have those experiences.
1:22:18They missed out on you.
1:22:19I was watching, um, on YouTube, I was watching a segment of Conan O'Brien's podcast where he
1:22:25was talking about hosting the Oscars.
1:22:28It was really interesting.
1:22:29The whole time I'm watching it though, I'm thinking, meanwhile, while the Oscars were going
1:22:33on, I was literally sitting on a beach in Hawaii.
1:22:37And it's just like, I win.
1:22:42Conan O'Brien loses.
1:22:43I win.
1:22:44I was sitting on a beach in Hawaii.
1:22:45He had to host the Oscars.
1:22:46He had to host the Oscars.
1:22:47Exactly.
1:22:47Nobody wants that job.
1:22:48Nobody wants, uh, he's coming back.
1:22:51He's doing it again.
1:22:51I know.
1:22:52Good for him.
1:22:52Good for him.
1:22:53All right.
1:22:53Logan wrote in and said, seeing as Apple is rumored to be running behind, do you think
1:22:56the company will purchase their way to a better Siri?
1:22:58If so, what would they pick?
1:22:59Maybe perplexity or anthropic?
1:23:02I mean, they could.
1:23:03The problem is the AI companies tend to have really overflated valuations.
1:23:07And like I said, I feel like one of the lessons of DeepSeek is maybe there's not much of a
1:23:11moat here and then unless you really want the people and an influx of people and the risk
1:23:16there is they're not going to want to come work for Apple and, you know, I aqua hire, I could
1:23:21maybe see, um, or if something really ends up in trouble, but I think not.
1:23:28But I think, I think you need to state your commitment to AI and keep hiring people to do
1:23:33the job and catch up because I don't get the sense that, you know, Google, what Google
1:23:39does can't be replicated by perplexity.
1:23:41What anthropic does can't be replicated by open AI and vice versa.
1:23:45I just don't get that sense.
1:23:46If that becomes true, then yeah, they're going to have to buy somebody, but I just don't think
1:23:50it's true.
1:23:50Yeah.
1:23:51I think the, if you look at Apple's history, it's far more likely that if they want to
1:23:56purchase something, they'd purchase a small company doing something with AI that's specific
1:24:01to something they want to do.
1:24:02I mean, they've done this a bunch with mapping and different kinds of software over the years.
1:24:07It's very rare for them to do a really big purchase.
1:24:10I mean, you know, we've talked about this.
1:24:11Beats, right, is still, I think, the biggest purchase.
1:24:143.2 million or was it next?
1:24:16I don't remember.
1:24:17Either way, it's very rare.
1:24:19We're talking decades between acquisitions that large.
1:24:22And I don't think, as Jason said, there's not enough for them to get in terms of
1:24:26secret sauce that makes it worthwhile for them to go out and spend however many hundreds
1:24:31of millions of dollars, if not billions of dollars, it's going to cost them to buy a
1:24:34company that is that big and that prominent.
1:24:36And they have talent.
1:24:39I mean, you look at the stuff they've done, look at their machine learning blog, like they
1:24:42have people doing this.
1:24:43I don't think that the AI is necessarily the problem.
1:24:46I think the bigger question is, what are you going to do with it?
1:24:49And that's the part where the rubber meets the road and you got to figure that out.
1:24:53And that's, you know, not a problem that you can necessarily just throw people at.
1:24:56I agree.
1:24:57Anthony writes, Jason has spoken before that he primarily uses his Mac at home and doesn't
1:25:04use his phone as much unless he's away from the house.
1:25:06With the new iPhone mirroring, does he ever pick up his phone at home anymore?
1:25:09First off, I actually probably use my iPad as much as I use my Mac at home because I use
1:25:15my Mac for work and everything else I use my iPad at home.
1:25:19My Mac is a laptop now.
1:25:21I still don't generally don't leave it anywhere but docked.
1:25:24It's a very rare day that the MacBook Pro comes out into another place in my house.
1:25:31I did work on it in the backyard the other day where we had a really beautiful day.
1:25:35We had like an 80 degree day.
1:25:36Sunny, warm sat in the backyard for the first time this year.
1:25:39That was really sweet.
1:25:40And I use my laptop because I got that now.
1:25:42I bring my whole computer with me out there.
1:25:44It works pretty well.
1:25:46So that's the case.
1:25:47But I don't use my iPhone as much.
1:25:48Although I will say, Anthony, I use my iPhone more than I used to in part because I have
1:25:54so many devices now that have iPhone apps to control them.
1:25:59And even if I can put them on my iPad or even on my Mac, there's this whole issue of like,
1:26:04you know, is the iPad authenticated?
1:26:07So I use that more than I used to.
1:26:10iPhone mirroring.
1:26:12Here's the truth.
1:26:13I don't use iPhone mirroring as much as I would like to for two reasons.
1:26:17The first is my iPhone lives on in a charger in standby mode and the charger is in my kitchen.
1:26:26It's actually it's coming out of my kitchen.
1:26:29There's the there's a counter that runs sort of to the hallway door and that's where it is.
1:26:34It is the two places that I work are in my garage and in the back bedroom, neither of
1:26:40which is within range of that to do iPhone mirroring.
1:26:43So that's not great.
1:26:45It means I have to pick up the iPhone and and mindfully bring it with me, at which point
1:26:48I kind of can just open the iPhone.
1:26:51And my other problem with the iPhone mirroring is authentication.
1:26:54And I don't know.
1:26:55I'm sure Apple is doing things properly from a security standpoint.
1:27:00But let's be honest here.
1:27:01Every time I use the iPhone mirroring, one of two things happens.
1:27:06Either it says you need to go open your iPhone and put in your password for me to use this
1:27:12feature, which is so frustrating.
1:27:14It's like I'm right here.
1:27:17Or the other thing that sometimes happens is I've got my iPhone open and I think, you know
1:27:21what, I can just do this on the Mac.
1:27:22And then I click iPhone mirroring and it says, I'm sorry, iPhone mirroring won't work
1:27:26because your iPhone is being used.
1:27:29And then, you know what I do?
1:27:32Then I lock it so that I can do that.
1:27:34And it says, now you need to authenticate on your iPhone because it's locked.
1:27:38What is happening?
1:27:40I don't know if this is intentional or not, but I think it reset the permissions every
1:27:47time there was a software update.
1:27:48And we're in the beta phase now.
1:27:50So I'm frequently updating the software on my iPhone every couple of weeks.
1:27:53And so I think every time I did that, it's like, oh, you got to re-authenticate.
1:27:58And it's so few and far between that I forget.
1:28:00And I did notice the other day I used it and it did not prompt me.
1:28:04And I was like, oh, did I enter the password or maybe they fixed that?
1:28:07So I'm not sure.
1:28:08Maybe they'll make some changes about that.
1:28:09But I agree, the barrier to entry on it is just high enough that a lot of times it's
1:28:13like, look, I've got Face ID.
1:28:13I can literally just pick this up, open it, and I'll be doing the thing I want to be doing.
1:28:17I might as well just open it up.
1:28:19I like it.
1:28:19It's a cool feature.
1:28:20And I like it for specific tasks that I want to do where it's like, you know what would
1:28:24be great?
1:28:24Having a keyboard that I can use with my iPhone right now or accessing this app that I
1:28:29like only can get on my phone.
1:28:31So this is one of my, maybe I'll put this on my macOS wish list.
1:28:35In addition to having the lock behavior be better, what I would really like is I would
1:28:40like to be able to add iPhone apps like I can add web apps.
1:28:48So they go in the dock or they go in users, you know, my user folder applications so that
1:28:53I could just have a shortcut that opens iPhone mirroring and opens that app.
1:28:57So it feels like that app is running.
1:28:59But I don't think that feature exists.
1:29:00I don't think, I think it's just like all or nothing.
1:29:03And I would love that because there are specific apps.
1:29:05You can launch, you can launch from notifications.
1:29:07So if you can do that, it feels like you could have a shortcut to open a app.
1:29:10Feels like, right?
1:29:11And you can do widgets on your desktop.
1:29:13So anyway, yeah, I also, I know why they're doing it because they're using continuity.
1:29:18But like if my iPhone is in my house on my Wi-Fi and I want to view it, I should just be
1:29:24able to view it.
1:29:25I shouldn't, I should not have to, even if it's a setting I have to set, like saying if
1:29:29you're on my home Wi-Fi, just let me do it.
1:29:32Because that's the thing that really kills me is I have this great iPhone mirroring feature,
1:29:37but it doesn't matter.
1:29:37I have to get up and walk down the hallway and get the iPhone and then do the thing I
1:29:42wanted to do without getting up and walking down the hallway and getting the iPhone.
1:29:45So I hope they make it better.
1:29:46It's a cool feature, but I don't use it.
1:29:48The answer to Anthony is I actually don't use my iPhone as much with mirroring because
1:29:53of all the roadblocks.
1:29:54So I hope it gets better is all I can say.
1:29:57I agree.
1:29:59Darren wrote in and he says, do you listen to any podcasts where you can't tell the hosts
1:30:04apart?
1:30:05I don't have that issue with upgrade, but on Jason's recommendation, I started listening
1:30:08to the rest is history.
1:30:09And for the life of me, I can't separate the identities of the two hosts.
1:30:11I used to have the same problem with reply, reply all as well.
1:30:14Does this ever happen to you?
1:30:16And if so, any tips on how to fix it?
1:30:17Now I'm fascinated by this because I can tell Tom and Dominic apart easily, but I think
1:30:24some of it is you have to have an ear for it.
1:30:26I was always really good.
1:30:27I have always been really good at hearing voices, even of like voiceover artists and being able
1:30:32to pick out who it is.
1:30:33Um, so some of it is just how our brains process information.
1:30:36I'd say for me, it's time is the other thing is just the more time you spend.
1:30:41Uh, also if that podcast has a video rest is history posts, you has a YouTube channel.
1:30:45They post clips and they sometimes post extended segments.
1:30:48You watch that a little bit and then you'll get pictures of them in their, in your mind
1:30:52and you'll see who's speaking.
1:30:53And that might help your brain kind of lock on to who is who.
1:30:57I would like to ask now my, my cohost, John Syracusa, what he thinks.
1:31:01Oh, I mean, Dan Morin, lots of people can't tell you guys apart, which I don't understand,
1:31:06but apparently it's a thing.
1:31:08We're clearly very different.
1:31:09Jason.
1:31:10Oh, what?
1:31:10I know.
1:31:12People tell me that too.
1:31:15And I am, I don't get it.
1:31:17Cause I don't hear, I don't John.
1:31:19I, to my, my mind has a very distinctive voice and I does, I do not confuse him with anybody.
1:31:24No, um, I don't, I don't really.
1:31:26Yeah.
1:31:26I do get that a lot though.
1:31:27Um, I don't have this problem either.
1:31:29I think like you, I just have a brain that's wired for it.
1:31:32And again, I don't listen to so many podcasts.
1:31:34Oh, my other piece of advice, in addition to give it time and maybe watch videos to kind
1:31:39of maybe trick your brain into, into learning who these people are.
1:31:42My other, you're not going to like it people, but I'm going to put it out there.
1:31:45Maybe for that podcast, slow it down.
1:31:49I was going to say, maybe they sound very different at one X and it's because you're listening at
1:31:54two X that you can't differentiate between them.
1:31:56Just a guess.
1:31:57I wouldn't advocate going to 0.5.
1:31:59No.
1:32:00Unless, unless you enjoy podcasts where people sound drunk.
1:32:04Uh, and it's very funny for about the two seconds I let it say.
1:32:11Uh, but yeah, I agree.
1:32:13I mean, slow it down to one is what I'm saying.
1:32:15Yeah.
1:32:15Yeah.
1:32:15Or, or just slow it down a notch or two until you can pick it up and then maybe you can crank
1:32:21it back up.
1:32:21But that would be another suggestion.
1:32:22I think there are ways to trick your brain to do this or to educate your brain.
1:32:26And then it starts to map everything and then it will start to work.
1:32:29That's my guess.
1:32:29Um, I know it's hard.
1:32:31Brains are weird.
1:32:33Brains are weird.
1:32:34Brains are weird.
1:32:34Anyway, thanks, John.
1:32:35I mean, Dan, sorry.
1:32:37I got you confused again.
1:32:38Ah, Jason, I'm done with this show.
1:32:40It happened a lot in the beginning with the incomparable.
1:32:42I was like, it's, I never, ever in a million years would have guessed weird.
1:32:46You know, the funny thing is, as I joke, John lives like five minutes from the house where
1:32:51I grew up.
1:32:51I know.
1:32:52He lives in the same town where I grew up.
1:32:53He lives very close to my parents, but he grew up in New York.
1:32:56So it's not like our accents are even the same.
1:32:58I read a whole piece today about the, uh, California accent, which was really, uh, funny
1:33:05because it's, the whole idea is California say they don't have an accent, but they do have
1:33:10an accent.
1:33:10Uh, great story, very fun.
1:33:13And, and they, they said that the biggest, the thing that, the one thing that everybody
1:33:16already knew about people in the West is that the, is the caught, caught merger where
1:33:21the C-O-T and C-A-U-G-H-T in California are identical.
1:33:25Whereas in, in the East, you get a lot of people who say caught and caught.
1:33:29Caught.
1:33:30Caught.
1:33:30Yeah.
1:33:31It is, my, uh, in-laws are both from Queens, so I have lots of New York.
1:33:35That's, that's very strong.
1:33:36Every now and then I, I just like to rip out a Florida because it's fun.
1:33:40I do, I do highly recommend, by the way, it's several years old now, but the, um, the old
1:33:45New York times quiz where it would ask you, it would try to nail down where your, your dialect
1:33:50is from.
1:33:51Oh yeah.
1:33:51Yeah.
1:33:51That thing was incredible.
1:33:52It was so good.
1:33:53This piece points out that it's two things, right?
1:33:55It's the, it's your word use and it's your, it's, it's your vowels and things like that.
1:34:00Yeah.
1:34:00Exactly.
1:34:01And that they can move at different rates and that usually word use is fast and that the,
1:34:06the phonetics are slow.
1:34:07But in the case of California, that's actually not the case.
1:34:10So really interesting.
1:34:11And, and yeah, that New York times thing, um, said you're probably from Modesto for me.
1:34:18And it's like, Modesto was the largest city to where I grew up.
1:34:22So yeah.
1:34:22Yeah.
1:34:23Nailed it.
1:34:23The one that got me on that one was, it told me like, all right, so I got Boston, which I
1:34:27did not think was terribly hard, but then it does like secondary places.
1:34:30And the secondary place for me was Rochester, New York, where my mom's family is from.
1:34:34And I was like, I don't even understand how you figured that out.
1:34:37Amazing.
1:34:37Amazing.
1:34:38Um, one last question.
1:34:40This is from Chris, who said the perfect segue.
1:34:43I'm thinking about getting upgrade plus, but I'm in hesitance since the bonus content isn't
1:34:46in its own feed.
1:34:47How do you recommend going back and listening to all the past episodes or should I just start
1:34:51listening going forward?
1:34:52It's sort of a bookend podcast question.
1:34:54Chris, thanks for thinking about getting upgrade plus, uh, the way upgrade plus works is generally
1:35:01just, we do an upgrade plus segment at the end of the show.
1:35:04So there aren't standalone episodes.
1:35:06It's true.
1:35:07I would say it's all just, I would go forward, but if you do want to go back and dip into
1:35:14the archive, uh, just be a little more active, make sure your podcast player has a chapter
1:35:19skip function and skipped upgrade plus.
1:35:21Cause there's a chapter for the plus version always at the very end that just plays plus
1:35:27and depending on your podcast player, some of them will even let you like say only play
1:35:31this chapter with this name and you could do it that way too.
1:35:34I think Castro does that.
1:35:35So I, yeah, I was going to say the, the, I am always amazed when people tell me they've
1:35:40gone back and listened to some of our older, like there's shows where that's fine.
1:35:43Like people will listen to like total party kill.
1:35:45Cause it's like, okay, it's a story.
1:35:46Fine.
1:35:47You want to start at the beginning.
1:35:48That's great.
1:35:49But like, I love, I love all of you out there, but please don't start at like clockwise
1:35:54one and listen to almost 600 episodes.
1:35:58But you don't need to, you know, the only person who would do that, it's John Syracuse.
1:36:02I started at the beginning, Jason.
1:36:05Always start at the beginning.
1:36:06A Syracuse of Muppet.
1:36:08It's a little too Muppet, I think.
1:36:09Yeah.
1:36:09A little too Muppety there.
1:36:11John is a little Muppety, but not that Muppety.
1:36:12Yeah.
1:36:12Turn it down a little bit.
1:36:14Thank you for this episode.
1:36:16We have reached the end.
1:36:17You can send us your feedback, follow-up and questions at upgradefeedback.com.
1:36:21I am still in charge of that.
1:36:22So be nice.
1:36:23I also wrote an awesome shortcut that automatically puts them on the clipboard formatted, right?
1:36:27So I can paste them in the show doc because I'm not willing to live like Mike lives.
1:36:31Thank you to our members who support us, as mentioned earlier with Upgrade Plus.
1:36:35We are going to take a couple of extra kind of home tech questions from listeners in Upgrade
1:36:42Plus this time.
1:36:42And of course, support Mike and his baby.
1:36:44I'm going to keep holding that baby up by being an Upgrade Plus subscriber.
1:36:49To be fair, the notes say, Mike Hurley, colon, if you want to buy a gift for Mike's baby,
1:36:55get yourself an Upgrade Plus membership.
1:36:56So it's Mike saying this.
1:36:58Mike's holding his baby up.
1:36:59I got some pictures, baby pictures the other day from Mike.
1:37:01Adorable, adorable baby.
1:37:03And Mike has a very nice striped robe.
1:37:06A little comment.
1:37:07I've never really seen Mike's robe before, but when you're getting a baby.
1:37:11Oh yeah, you spend a lot of time in that robe.
1:37:12You let it all hang out.
1:37:13You can find us on YouTube and see our things that we like from Star Wars and Star Trek by searching for Upgrade Podcast.
1:37:23Thank you to our sponsors, Google, Gemini, and Ecamm Live for supporting this episode.
1:37:28And thank you all for listening.
1:37:30And of course, thank you, Dan Morin, for taking some time away from your many other podcasts,
1:37:35including the one we do at Six Colors, to be here this week.
1:37:37I really appreciate it.
1:37:39It is distinctly my pleasure.
1:37:41I love Upgrade.
1:37:41It really is one of the few shows I listen to every week.
1:37:44So it's always nice to be on because...
1:37:47It's one podcast you don't have to listen to this week.
1:37:49I don't have to listen to it this week.
1:37:50Yeah.
1:37:51All right.
1:37:51Thank you for that.
1:37:52Thanks, everybody.
1:37:53We'll be back next time with yet another in the cavalcade of guest stars.
1:37:56Who will it be?
1:37:57I don't know.
1:37:58I actually do know, but I'm not going to tell you.
1:38:00And we will see you next time.