Podcast Search

The Talk Show

422: ‘A Monkey on a Rock’, With Stephen Hackett

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00Hey, here's something new, an upfront sponsor read.

0:00:02This episode of the talk show is brought to you in part by WorkOS.

0:00:05If you're building a B2B software as a service app, at some point, your customers are going

0:00:11to start asking for enterprise features like SAML authentication, SKIM provisioning, role-based

0:00:16access control, audit trails, et cetera.

0:00:19WorkOS provides easy to use and flexible APIs that help you ship enterprise features on day

0:00:24one without slowing down your core product development.

0:00:27It's used by some of the hardest startups in the world today, such as Perplexity, Vercel,

0:00:32Plaid, and Webflow.

0:00:34WorkOS also provides a very generous free tier of up to 1 million monthly active users for

0:00:41its user management solution.

0:00:42It comes standard with rich features like bot protection, MFA, roles and permissions, and

0:00:48more.

0:00:48You don't pay a cent until you hit a million customers.

0:00:51If you are currently building your SSO for your first enterprise customer, you should consider

0:00:57using WorkOS.

0:00:58You can integrate in minutes and start shipping enterprise plans today.

0:01:02Go to WorkOS.com.

0:01:04WorkOS.com.

0:01:07No special slug, just WorkOS.com.

0:01:09And now, the show.

0:01:11I don't know how it's possible.

0:01:14There's only one person to blame, and it's me, that you have never been on this podcast before.

0:01:20Oh, well, thanks for having me.

0:01:21I'm glad to be here.

0:01:22Fun way to wind down the week.

0:01:24Yeah.

0:01:25Let me ask you this question, and I think you're going to know the answer.

0:01:28I'm sure everybody listening is familiar with your various work, but especially your home

0:01:33base of 512pixels.net.

0:01:36Where does the name 512pixels come from?

0:01:39Yeah, so it's part of the resolution of the original Macintosh.

0:01:43That compact Mac line was 512 by 384, and wanted to honor that.

0:01:48I was about to ask you this as a trivia question.

0:01:51Isn't it not 512 by 384?

0:01:53512 by 384 is the magic 4 to 3 aspect ratio.

0:01:57But I was going to say, this is like one of the trivia items that I would think I would

0:02:03know, and I think everybody would think John Gruber would know, and that I've often gotten

0:02:08wrong over the years.

0:02:09Yeah, I mean, it's actually, I think, 342, now that I'm quite in the background.

0:02:16And I don't know the reason why.

0:02:18I thought you would have remembered this.

0:02:20But I always think, but the mistake that I make all the time, I always say 512 by 384,

0:02:26because I had so many 512 by 384 computers, and I just happened to know that's 4 to 3.

0:02:32And for some odd reason, the original Macintosh was slightly more widescreen than 4 to 3.

0:02:39I mean, that original Mac in particular was basically held together with, like, tape and

0:02:44luck.

0:02:44I mean, they really were squeezing every ounce they could out of the hardware.

0:02:48And so, I don't know, somewhere Syracuse is rolling over in his grave, but you can have

0:02:53him follow up.

0:02:53I thought you'd have it.

0:02:55You probably got one there behind you, right?

0:02:56I do.

0:02:57I do have one.

0:02:58It's on the shelf behind me.

0:02:59It was a Christmas present from a family member who didn't know what to get me one year.

0:03:03I don't know.

0:03:04I found this old computer, and I was like, oh, this is an original.

0:03:06Thank you.

0:03:07Yeah, they're cool, man.

0:03:09All computers should have handles.

0:03:11Yeah, they really showed up to a, well, hmm.

0:03:14You never go wrong.

0:03:17Nobody ever complains when a computer has a handle.

0:03:19That's right.

0:03:20I mean, they did it with the iBook once.

0:03:22You beat me to linking to Dr. Drang's little back and forth that he and I have going on where

0:03:30he, I mentioned talking about old school Apple retail and how it's like the claim chowder of

0:03:37all claim chowder.

0:03:38The prediction that Apple's initial foray into their own brand of retail stores would prove

0:03:43disastrous because they need their small independent resellers, which was the downside to them getting

0:03:52into the business, although some of them are still around.

0:03:54But more that if Gateway couldn't do it, what makes Apple think they could?

0:03:59And that they're going to piss off their good partners at Best Buy and Sears Robeck and Company.

0:04:05Yeah.

0:04:06Yeah.

0:04:07Where's Sears now?

0:04:07Yeah, it's funny.

0:04:08Growing up, there was a Gateway store actually kind of around the corner from my parents' house.

0:04:13And I've got memories of like going in there.

0:04:16If you can look at pictures online, some of them, the early ones were kind of themed like farms

0:04:21inside because their whole thing was like the cow print design on the boxes.

0:04:25And yeah, now Apple retails, it's usually in the top, I don't know, two or three, like

0:04:30most valuable per square foot or something.

0:04:32It's unbelievable.

0:04:32Oh, I think it's number one, or at least the last time I looked at the numbers.

0:04:35And the only distant, like a somewhat distant second place was Tiffany, the jeweler.

0:04:40I don't know how that quite gets computed.

0:04:44That feels like one of those numbers that there's, it's sort of like the bill of materials.

0:04:49And which I don't, it doesn't seem like that's as big of a thing anymore, but it would always

0:04:53be a new iPhone would come out and some analyst with analyst in his title, which makes the whole

0:04:59thing credible, of course, would come out and say that the entire bill of materials for the

0:05:03$700 iPhone seven is $30.

0:05:07Yeah.

0:05:08Oh gosh.

0:05:08There was that whole cycle we all lived through for so many years.

0:05:11That would come out and then people would be like, well, no, there's R&D and development

0:05:15and that's all built in.

0:05:17Yeah.

0:05:17It's okay.

0:05:17Yeah.

0:05:18That's all kind of died out.

0:05:19I think people got tired of that ride each year.

0:05:22I don't know how they would compute the average retails.

0:05:25I mean, cause Apple, I don't think breaks out their own internal stores, retail sales.

0:05:30At least I don't recall Snell reporting that as a breakout number.

0:05:33That's right.

0:05:34I don't think it's a chart.

0:05:34And I also don't think Apple would publishes what they pay for leasing, right?

0:05:39They're a secretive company, very good at negotiating and real estate, especially very high end realist retail.

0:05:48Real estate is like a cutthroat secretive business.

0:05:51So I don't see how anybody could figure that out, but you know, they're doing pretty well.

0:05:56But anyway, I remember we had a chain.

0:06:00I think it was somewhat regional to the Northeast.

0:06:04It was sort of like a proto Best Buy where you would go and buy like any TVs, stereos, any kind of electronics.

0:06:13And it was called Silo.

0:06:14I think, I think everybody had like a regional version of it.

0:06:18You can think back, you, you probably could to like something that's like a Best Buy, but was smaller than the cavernous size of a Best Buy.

0:06:26But Silo was weird because they had sort of a dark nightclub-y vibe inside.

0:06:34And I think when I was a kid, I remember a lot of TV stores were very dark, like in the same way that our coin-op arcades were dark.

0:06:42And it's like, ah, let the screens really glow.

0:06:44And I remember they sold Macs for a few years at the absolute nadir of Apple's confusing product lines, right?

0:06:56The, when there was like a, I'm going to get the numbers wrong.

0:06:59Cause I mean, nobody at even, nobody at the time could remember them, but there was like a Performa 7300 and a PowerPC 7310.

0:07:09And they were the same thing, except that the Performa didn't have a CD tray and it's what, and it's, so they had a bunch of the performance and I'd go in and, and I wasn't one of those types of Mac fanatics who would go in and fix the computers for free.

0:07:25There were, there were like community members who were so worried about Apple making it out of the nineties that they would like go into stores and they'd go on Usenet and say, I was at the such and such store.

0:07:36And I went in and I updated the software, cleaned up the desktop, but I would just go in and the Macs, they would be in such a sad state.

0:07:43I mean, they just, they, they look like, like when a school cleans out the computers at the end of the year and they're like, here's the ones that don't even work anymore.

0:07:53We'll just put them out back and see if some kids take them.

0:07:55And instead they were the ones on sale in the store.

0:07:59In Memphis, we had a couple of really good Apple authorized like resellers back in the day.

0:08:06And we had an early Apple store.

0:08:08Our Apple store was number 20.

0:08:10And so it was early on in the run, but I remember going into those resellers and it's like, they knew what they were talking about.

0:08:17There was lots of software.

0:08:20I'm sure in reality, it was like all the software that, that, that there was, I mean, when the Mac was small, but those guys really knew what they were doing.

0:08:27And then Apple retail just ate them all for lunch.

0:08:29We still have one right here in center city, Philly, and it's only three blocks from the Apple store called Bundy typewriter, which tells you how long they've been in business.

0:08:43I guess they've officially, I've just looked it up, but they've officially changed their name to Bundy computer.

0:08:48They've made it.

0:08:49They're not what they used to be.

0:08:51But like when I was in college, if you needed something for the Mac locally, you'd go downtown, cross the river from Drexel, go to Bundy.

0:08:59And they were super knowledgeable.

0:09:01They really were.

0:09:02They were nerds.

0:09:03And now I think they stay in business because they're really good for repairs and you can, and they're still officially authorized.

0:09:09So when you book a repair with Apple, you can, at times I had a, like an old, really old Mac book air and it, the battery swelled up and you can, you'll appreciate this.

0:09:20I didn't want to just throw it out.

0:09:21I wanted to get it fixed.

0:09:23I do appreciate that.

0:09:24And even though I don't use it anymore, I haven't booted it since I got it fixed at Bundy, but I made the appointment and it was like, you could go to the Apple store and we'll fit you in, I don't know, three, four days from now.

0:09:37Or you could just go 30 minutes from now, you'd stop in at Bundy.

0:09:41And I went there and they do a good job and stuff like that.

0:09:43Anyway, Drang told a good story.

0:09:44Tell Drang's story.

0:09:46Yeah, so y'all were going back and forth about this and he has, he has a story on lean crew about going to a comp USA and he wanted to see if the G4 cube, which famously didn't have a fan, the heat just sort of came out of the top of it.

0:10:00If it was actually hot and he put his hand over it and the machine immediately overheated and shut itself down.

0:10:07And he says he didn't touch it, that his hand was just, I guess, just hovering over it.

0:10:13But then every time he went in there afterwards, he, he would go in there and cause it to crash like a little, a little game of cat and mouse with a, with a G4 cube.

0:10:21I believe him because he's, he seems like one of the most believable human beings walking the face of the planet.

0:10:27I, and I never owned a G4 cube, but I had seen them and I don't recall them being that finicky.

0:10:34I always thought, I mean, so, but it makes me think that the ones in the store were already running hot because they were configured poorly and had stuff running in the background.

0:10:43And like, I, I think Drang's post leaves the impression that if you bought a G4 cube and used it like a sensible Mac user, that if you put your hand over it, it would, it would crash, which is not true.

0:10:57It's like using the force.

0:10:59Like you wave your hand over it and the computer turns off.

0:11:02All right.

0:11:05One last subject before like a pre, pre-show subject is I, one of those weird things about this whole career that, that I have is I thought, man, this would be great if I can make this work.

0:11:17Cause then I will always be caught up on all of the tech news at all times.

0:11:22Cause that would be my job.

0:11:23And that is very appealing to me.

0:11:26And somehow there's so much going on.

0:11:29I know almost nothing about what was announced at Google IO this year.

0:11:33Did, did you pay attention?

0:11:35Yeah.

0:11:36I watched most of it and, and like most years is a lot of stuff that will probably never see the light of day or, or be killed off the, the vaporware to actual shipping product ratio is a little funny at IO.

0:11:49But it was interesting a few days before IO, they did a stream that was all their Android stuff.

0:11:54Like they, they cleared out the Android announcements before IO.

0:11:59And obviously that was cause IO was going to all be AI stuff, the whole thing.

0:12:05And so they've got new image and video generation stuff.

0:12:09Ars Technica had a piece today about, remember like the horrifying Will Smith spaghetti video from a few years ago.

0:12:14Yeah.

0:12:15Yeah.

0:12:15Which, I mean, if I close my eyes, I can see it.

0:12:18Like it really is horrifying.

0:12:20They remade it and Google's new tools and a bunch of AI stuff, some for developers.

0:12:25And I mean, they're all in, right?

0:12:27And they've got a new, I think potentially one of the most interesting things is they've got basically two tiers of paid service to use kind of bigger and better versions of Gemini and notebook LM and stuff.

0:12:39Including a really serious paid level.

0:12:42They've got one now that's, it's like ChatGPT Pro.

0:12:45Yeah.

0:12:46I don't know.

0:12:46I pay for, I pay 20 bucks a month for ChatGPT.

0:12:49Same.

0:12:50I know.

0:12:51And the other one, whatever the name of the other tier is, $200 a month.

0:12:55And I like, I can imagine where if I start hitting limits, I would be like, well, maybe I have to pay more.

0:13:03But I don't, I never run into anything where I think, oh, you cut me off or something.

0:13:09I don't know.

0:13:09Yeah, same.

0:13:10But now Google, Google has a $250 a month tier.

0:13:13Man, we're in the wrong business.

0:13:16We should just be making AI services.

0:13:19It's, well, that's, but it's kind of weird for Google, right?

0:13:23Because Google's whole thing from day one has been everything they make is free if you're a consumer.

0:13:28Free with ads, eventually.

0:13:30Although for years it was just free.

0:13:32I think there's two components to that for Google in particular.

0:13:35One, their ad business could be on the verge of being broken up, depending on how their various court cases go in the U.S.

0:13:43And so maybe they're looking at a post ad business or at least a business that's not so centered on ads.

0:13:51But also I think it speaks to how expensive this stuff is to run.

0:13:54I've been writing a lot about our local impact of that with XAI because XAI is in my hometown.

0:14:00And it's a huge investment.

0:14:03And so maybe it's also to help offset that.

0:14:05For Google, I think it's probably a little bit of both.

0:14:08Yeah.

0:14:09Because, and again, I know I'm mixing up the companies here, but it all kind of meshes together.

0:14:14But one of the numbers that was thrown out when we talk about the other IO of the week, which will be a bigger topic, but that chat GPT or open AI, I guess, overall is expected has themselves have set the expectation that they're going to lose $44 billion between now and 2029 or something like that.

0:14:35I mean, I love, I've made the joke so many times over the years, billion here, a billionaire, and suddenly you're talking about real money.

0:14:43But that's just real money right off the, $44 billion is a lot of money for anybody, right?

0:14:50It's bananas.

0:14:51And I mean, Sam Altman and that team, they can raise money, right?

0:14:55Sometimes they're standing in the White House to do it, which is a different thing.

0:15:00But clearly they feel like they've got the runway to do that sort of thing.

0:15:03And I guess that's the other thing about Google, like modern Google.

0:15:09One is the threat to the ad business overall.

0:15:12And will it be spun out?

0:15:14Will it be broken off?

0:15:15Is that part of the thinking?

0:15:16And then the other thing is that with all of the Google Cloud stuff from, I don't know, probably going on a decade at this point,

0:15:25they've built a big chunk of their business where they're selling software to corporations effectively, right?

0:15:33And so signing up for a $250 Gemini account isn't exactly cloud computing at the corporate IT level,

0:15:41but it's more the same mindset where you're exchanging cash for access to the thing, right?

0:15:49Yeah.

0:15:49You don't get to touch the thing.

0:15:51When they're not selling you a computer that runs Gemini, you just log in and use it.

0:15:57But yeah, they've gotten comfortable with charging money for stuff.

0:16:01Yeah.

0:16:01I wonder sometimes if you roll back the clock at Google and they saw that this was the way things were going to go.

0:16:07Because I mean, for so long, I mean, I've used a free Gmail account for 20 something years.

0:16:12Same here.

0:16:14I have never paid for it.

0:16:15And I've, I don't get tons of attachments, so it just keeps piling up and they, every once in a while, I guess they up how much.

0:16:23Note to Apple, every once in a while you can up the storage tier for free users.

0:16:29Five gigabytes is plenty, John.

0:16:32It's plenty.

0:16:33You think that'll come?

0:16:35Before I forget about it, do you think that'll come at WWDC this year?

0:16:38It feels like if I were just wandering around inside of Apple, I would be looking for low-hanging fruit to make people happy.

0:16:46Yeah.

0:16:47It's like, that fruit is scraping the ground.

0:16:50Yeah, yeah.

0:16:51So who knows?

0:16:53What was the storage tier that they were stuck at for so long with iPhones as the minimum?

0:16:59Was it eight or 16?

0:17:00I think 16 was a big deal, like in the four 4S days.

0:17:05It's been a long time, but.

0:17:06And I think it was still at 16, yeah, for a long time.

0:17:11Like one of the years where I had Phil Schiller as the guest on my live show at WWDC.

0:17:16And I brought it up and he had a good answer.

0:17:19Not like a satisfying answer, but a, ah, damn, you really talked your way out of that.

0:17:23Son of a bitch, you really are at Phil Schiller.

0:17:25That's why he's been promoted to the roof or whatever.

0:17:29But it was, give me the cheapest possible new iPhone, was it 16?

0:17:33I'm pretty sure it was 16 for so long that we really did.

0:17:37A lot of us, I think, were like, I don't know, maybe they're never going to, maybe it's always going to be 16.

0:17:41And then, of course, it moved up.

0:17:43But the iCloud storage is a totally different, I mean, it's been five gigabytes from day one, which was, I don't know, what, 15 years ago?

0:17:51Yeah, 2011, I think.

0:17:54So, yeah, it's been a long time.

0:17:56Yeah, it's just never moved, which is kind of bananas.

0:17:58Like, it has to be.

0:17:59I mean, I know they have more users.

0:18:01And I know that services is a long, complicated story financially.

0:18:05And they want high margins for it.

0:18:07And it's very strange.

0:18:09I just looked in my iCloud Plus family group.

0:18:13So it's my wife and I and two of our three kids.

0:18:16And we are at 1.9 terabytes.

0:18:18It's like.

0:18:19That's about where me, my wife and son are.

0:18:24Like, we're hovering.

0:18:25We're not dangerously close to two.

0:18:27But something.

0:18:29And I've got that whole.

0:18:30I don't want to sidetrack this discussion.

0:18:32But I've got that whole situation with two Apple accounts.

0:18:36Oh, yeah.

0:18:37One that's my real Apple ID.

0:18:38One that's my iTunes ID that does the payment.

0:18:41And I know they announced the thing where you can merge them a couple months ago.

0:18:44And that was another one that was like, hey, are they ever going to do this?

0:18:48And they finally did it.

0:18:50But I stared down the barrel of all of that and looked at.

0:18:54And it seems like it went well for most people who tried it.

0:18:57But I seriously got a dose of very mature, middle-aged, if it ain't broke, don't fix it, groups.

0:19:05Like, when I was younger, I would have waited 48 hours to see if anybody had, like, a disaster.

0:19:12And then I would have whacked the button and thought, ah, I'm sure it'll work out.

0:19:16And it probably would have worked out.

0:19:17But the current situation is, it really is fine.

0:19:22But I think it is going to be somewhat complicated when I have to go past two terabytes to add another two terabyte.

0:19:29Or maybe, and it might be that I get the two terabytes for free because I pay for Apple One.

0:19:34Okay, I'm going to go one step further down the rabbit hole, then we can back out.

0:19:40I went through it because of the storage issue.

0:19:42And it was, I couldn't merge them.

0:19:45And so I ended up basically making my purchase ID part of my iCloud family.

0:19:50So I named him Legacy Steven and his picture is in grayscale.

0:19:53And he's just in my iCloud family with all of his purchases.

0:19:56And it's like the ghost of my past Apple account.

0:19:58Ah, that's pretty clever.

0:20:00I wonder if I could do that.

0:20:02Anyway.

0:20:03Because you can do the purchase sharing stuff, which is pretty cool.

0:20:05It does seem, yeah.

0:20:07And that's why we have the family account.

0:20:09And I do have spots because at this point, with a 21-year-old heading into his senior year of college, I'm pretty sure my wife and I are done having children.

0:20:17So it's going to be an amazing surprise if we don't.

0:20:22But all right, let me take a break here and thank our first sponsor.

0:20:26And it is, this episode is sponsored by BetterHelp.

0:20:30Look, BetterHelp, let's face it, this audience for this show, there's a lot of you out there who are men.

0:20:37And there's sort of, I guess, stigma around men's mental health and getting help, getting therapy, stuff like that.

0:20:46That's a bunch of nonsense.

0:20:47Man, it's crazy.

0:20:49Men in today's world, they have lots of pressure.

0:20:52They always have.

0:20:53But it's a different world.

0:20:54But it's a different world.

0:20:55And you can, like, talk about your problems, and it actually helps.

0:20:58Trust me.

0:20:59It is okay to struggle.

0:21:01Real strength comes from opening up about what you're carrying, what's going on in your life, what's going on in the back of your mind.

0:21:07If you're a man and you're feeling the weight of the world, talk to someone, a friend, a loved one, or a therapist.

0:21:13With over 35,000 therapists, BetterHelp is the world's largest online therapy platform.

0:21:22And they have served over 5 million people globally.

0:21:26And it works.

0:21:27They've got an App Store rating of 4.9 out of 5 with over 1.7 million client reviews.

0:21:33And it is convenient.

0:21:36You can join a session with a therapist at the click of a button, and it can help fit therapy into your busy life.

0:21:43No commute.

0:21:44No travel.

0:21:46No trying to figure out how to get to the office or something like that.

0:21:49Do it online.

0:21:51But the other advantage of doing it online is it's really like no friction to switch.

0:21:57I don't know if the vibes are off with your first therapist or second therapist or something like that.

0:22:02You just feel like switching it up.

0:22:04It is easy to switch at any time.

0:22:07It's sort of a platform that is built for switching like that.

0:22:10Or not if you're really happy with the therapist that you're paired with.

0:22:14As the largest online therapy provider in the world, BetterHelp can provide access to mental health professionals with a diverse variety of experience.

0:22:23If you've got a specific problem, they can match you with a professional who specializes in it.

0:22:28Talk it out with BetterHelp.

0:22:30Listeners of the talk show get 10% off their first month at BetterHelp.com slash talk show.

0:22:39That's BetterHelp, H-E-L-P, dot com slash talk show.

0:22:45My thanks to BetterHelp for sponsoring the show.

0:22:48I guess let's just move right on to the other I.O., right?

0:22:52I mean, how can we not?

0:22:54It's a big week for companies with two letters in their name.

0:22:57Yeah.

0:22:59I know there's sort of a weird, fun, cold war between OpenAI and Google that last year, or maybe for two or three years in a row, they've scheduled big announcements during Google's I.O. conference.

0:23:14And I saw some people speculating that the name for this new company that's acquired and now within OpenAI was a tweak over Google's previous quote-unquote ownership of I.O. from their developer conference.

0:23:31I think that's just purely coincidence.

0:23:33I think the timing definitely may not be coincidence, but I think the fact that Johnny Ive and his team at Love From named the company I.O. was purely coincidence.

0:23:44It's a good name.

0:23:45I like the name.

0:23:46I.O. for AI.

0:23:50It is a good name, and I think it's – I mean, they – if you watch the video, right, they're looking at new ways for us to interface with our computers away from legacy products like laptops.

0:24:01And so, yeah, if they're looking to see how we could reintegrate technology into our lives, it's a pretty good name from that angle.

0:24:10Yeah.

0:24:13It's both – the AI is currently – and I guess it is sort of – I mean, I don't know, maybe something can come after it, but it is ultimately the highest level of abstraction of computing, right?

0:24:24Like famously, even the experts in the field admit that they don't fully understand how LLMs work, right?

0:24:34They just know that they do.

0:24:35You start with these algorithms, and you've trained them on massive, massive ocean-sized corpuses of data, and then out comes a thing that you can – that'll start predicting natural language or start predicting pixels in an image based on the patterns that it gleaned from the thing.

0:24:57But how exactly it works, nobody really knows.

0:24:59It's very abstract.

0:25:01But input-output is sort of the further end of the spectrum.

0:25:05It's like the very beginning of computing, right?

0:25:08It's like looking at, like, logic boards, right?

0:25:11Input-output, signal, XOR gates, AND gates.

0:25:16You're talking about the very basic levels of it.

0:25:18And I think it gets to what Johnny Ive recently talked about on his delightful and intriguing onstage interview with Patrick Collison from Stripe, where I thought Johnny Ive very deftly danced around his feelings about Apple today, five-plus years after his departure.

0:25:41But I think part of it is his discomfort with the time that people spend on their phones.

0:25:47Yeah, it's fascinating to me that that was one of the driving things behind the Humane pen, too.

0:25:56And I get the sense that maybe those two guys don't like each other very much, but –

0:25:59Oh, I can say for sure.

0:26:02Or at least I know one of them doesn't like the other.

0:26:05Yeah, one direction.

0:26:06But that was part of their pitch, too, right?

0:26:09We spend too much time on our screens.

0:26:11We want something that's more ambient, that you just – it's part of your life.

0:26:14It blends into the background more.

0:26:17And I think at the root of it, that's a compelling idea, whether something you wear or something that you have with you that talks from an LLM.

0:26:27If that's the solution or not, I don't know.

0:26:29But it's above my pay grade.

0:26:30But I do resonate with that.

0:26:33Like, I see it in my own life.

0:26:34I see it in my kids.

0:26:35I see it in other people's kids, right?

0:26:36Like, we are addicted to these things.

0:26:39And I do wonder if these folks who were there in the early days, if they were trying to kind of reconcile their feelings of responsibility over that.

0:26:49Maybe that's reading too much into it, but –

0:26:51I don't think it is with Johnny Ive in particular.

0:26:53I think he's – I don't think I'm putting words in his mouth even.

0:26:56I think if you look at the transcript of his interview with Collison, he kind of comes out and says it to some degree, that he's maybe not guilty or feels complicit in doing something bad, but that at least he questions the role he played in getting to where we are.

0:27:18And I think the problematic nature of our society-wide addiction, let's call it what it is, to phones, the problematic side is when it's very one-way.

0:27:34It's not I.O.

0:27:35It's not – the problem isn't like when you and I are texting each other like, hey, we're going to be late to start the recording of the show, and you're like, oh, okay.

0:27:44But that sort of two-way communication, I don't – I think that's just been purely additive to the world.

0:27:51It's really – texting in particular, Ben Thompson and I have been talking a lot about how to really take a step back.

0:27:58Chat is – it's just a fantastic interface.

0:28:00It really is.

0:28:02It's not just fantastic for communicating one-on-one or in a small group.

0:28:07It's fantastic for – it's literally the only interface we have so far really for interacting with all of these AI systems.

0:28:14And it's also great for large groups, Slack.

0:28:18The whole Slack phenomenon is sort of based on the same fundamental interface.

0:28:24But I think that the problematic nature is more – I'm not just to throw TikTok singularly.

0:28:30But TikTok, Instagram, but the sort of swipe, swipe, swipe, swipe, swipe, sort of stone-faced, and there goes two hours.

0:28:40And what's in your head?

0:28:42Did you get any nourishment at all?

0:28:45Or have you been radicalized in some way that's bad for the world?

0:28:49Right, right.

0:28:50Which happens on these platforms, right?

0:28:52Or – I mean there's – I've been reading a lot about this as someone who's got a high school daughter.

0:28:57Like the – truly the epidemic of body image and other issues that come from social media.

0:29:04I think the question – and clearly I think we know Johnny Ives' answer.

0:29:08But if that stuff is all bad and they're trying to right the ship, steer the world back in a better direction, a lot of people would look at AI and LLMs and say, well, that's not the direction we should be steering.

0:29:24That comes with its own issues.

0:29:27Now, they're very different issues, right?

0:29:29There's where the data comes from, the power, the water, all of those things.

0:29:34And so it feels – I was thinking about this a lot this week actually.

0:29:38In all the years I've paid attention to this stuff, this feels like the most complicated thing to cover or talk about that I've ever had to do because everyone has feelings about it.

0:29:53You can't not almost in modern life.

0:29:56And it's only been things like ChatGPT or Gemini, AI tools on phones where I see like the normal people in my life or like family and friends who maybe they only ask me about tech when it's time to buy a new iPhone.

0:30:12Like they're talking about these things because they're using them or they feel really bad about them.

0:30:18It just – it feels like such a big, complicated topic and God bless him, but Johnny Ive like dove into the deep end this week.

0:30:26Yeah.

0:30:26It is true.

0:30:28I mean it's almost hard not to get a little philosophical about it, right?

0:30:32I mean what else is big money investment going into these days, right?

0:30:37Go back to my youth and like the era portrayed on Halt and Catch Fire of the early PC and it was like anybody with real money was like, what are you nerds talking about with these computers?

0:30:52Like I mean here's $50,000 if you really want to go make a computer.

0:30:56I mean it's nobody really – nobody except the real – the nerds who really were living it got the potential, right?

0:31:05And fast forward to the last few decades and look at like the top companies in the world by market cap and they're all computer companies or Berkshire Hathaway who's bought and sold tons of shares of Apple and other computer companies in recent years, right?

0:31:26Right, and the Saudi oil company.

0:31:28There's one oil company left.

0:31:29So in some ways it's good for the world that like the market cap monsters of the 90s, those ExxonMobiles and a bunch of other dig up fossilized dinosaur remains and burn it and pump the carbon in the air profit.

0:31:47That this is better but we've just come around to that all of this excitement is about these endeavors that involve massive amounts of energy.

0:32:00And there are – I think that the knee jerk, hey, all of AI is bad because the energy consumption is too high and it's going to kill the planet is kind of silly because it's – I don't know.

0:32:10Somebody's done some of the math where it's using chat GPT all day for one day is like – you know, like taking – or like if you take one fewer airplane flight in your life, like you could use chat GPT all day every day for the rest of your life and come out ahead carbon-wise.

0:32:27Something like that.

0:32:28Yeah.

0:32:28I've heard a lot of that from my readers and listeners because I've been writing about XAIs.

0:32:33They have a giant site here in Memphis.

0:32:36They're building a second one.

0:32:37And I've been writing a lot about it because the utility company here is not ready for that yet.

0:32:45The amount of power they need, TVA and our local utility company, they don't have the juice yet for that.

0:32:52And so they're using these big gas turbines, which are like the size of 18 wheelers, right?

0:32:57And that's caused a lot of concern in the community.

0:32:59So I've been writing about it on a really local level.

0:33:03And I mean it's just different when it's in your backyard, right?

0:33:05And problematic when you're pumping a bunch of gas into like the poor zip codes in Southwest Tennessee.

0:33:14We have to reconcile all that stuff, right?

0:33:16And I can on one hand use chat GPT for some things in my life or in my work, but also be concerned about the pollution and all those things.

0:33:26And I feel like there's a lot of kind of one side or the other right now on this topic because it's such a big topic, because it's so important.

0:33:34But the reality is it's just it's really complicated and people are going to have feelings that sometimes even like conflict within themselves over it.

0:33:42And that's that's OK.

0:33:43Yeah.

0:33:44And there's something something going on.

0:33:46And like Amazon.

0:33:47Amazon is a tricky company and it's hard to and like any of these giant companies, they're all unique in their own ways.

0:33:57They're as unique as people and largely because they're so they're each so obviously informed by their founders, right?

0:34:06That Apple is so Steve Jobsy still and Microsoft is so Bill Gatesy still and Amazon is still so Jeff Bezosy.

0:34:16But there was something weird about the way Amazon got off the ground or unprecedented where they weren't turning a profit.

0:34:24But every few quarters when investors would get antsy about that, they'd turn a little bit of a profit just to show that they could do it if they would.

0:34:33And they kept telling them the reason we're not turning a profit, even though we could, is we think we should be pumping all of the money that we could book as profit into continuing to build out our infrastructure.

0:34:45And now it's been a while since Apple or since Amazon wasn't profitable.

0:34:51Now they are very profitable.

0:34:53And what they told investors was right.

0:34:55Stick with us.

0:34:57We will be profitable.

0:34:58But we'll but we're going to build out an infrastructure that will give us a dominant position.

0:35:03And all of that was true, including the fact that they've built out a dominant position that nobody can catch up on because nobody else can afford to do that.

0:35:13I mean, Walmart a little, but like when you kind of dwarf Walmart's ability to spend with you on building out infrastructure, you've reached a really dominant position because that was Walmart was like, hey, that's our game, squeezing out the little retailers.

0:35:33Don't take that from us.

0:35:34Don't take that from us.

0:35:34Yeah.

0:35:35And the Amazon story, I mean, it's so brilliant, right?

0:35:38They built the tools they needed and then built the tools like relay stuff like we run on AWS.

0:35:45They took their technology and productized it in a way that is so fascinating.

0:35:53And I think that's the term we're starting to see with these AI companies a little bit, right?

0:35:58Where they've they built tools to build the tools and they built tools for nerdy people.

0:36:04But now like the chat GBT app, it's just on your phone, right?

0:36:07It's it's there's still lots of rough edges when it comes to it being a product, right?

0:36:12Like my word, if all Johnny Ive does is fix their naming of their models and like he's worth the six billion or whatever it is.

0:36:18But we're seeing that turn now, right?

0:36:22From, yeah, they're still bleeding money.

0:36:25A bunch of these companies are, but they are starting to make the turn into we're making products for regular people.

0:36:30And that's when it gets interesting.

0:36:32Well, and that's that's where I feel like the lesson.

0:36:35It's a yada, yada, yada.

0:36:37Amazon proved you could lose money for a long time and build a dominant position and then make lots of money forever.

0:36:42And I feel like that's where the mania is coming from.

0:36:48Like, how can it even be that it's even plausible that a company could say, oh, yeah, we expect to lose 44 billion.

0:36:55Over the next five years, right?

0:36:56I mean, try going back 40 years and explaining to somebody back then that that and even take the inflation out of it.

0:37:04Right.

0:37:05Deflate the numbers to 1985 numbers or something.

0:37:09It's still they would be like, well, what kind of a nut?

0:37:12Nobody who anybody who would invest in this is a lunatic and they don't have money because they're lunatics.

0:37:17So where is this going to come from?

0:37:19This doesn't even make sense.

0:37:21And instead, it's actually the way everybody thinks.

0:37:24And eventually.

0:37:26The bills come due, right?

0:37:29Eventually, you have to turn a profit.

0:37:31And the question is, who's left when when that happens?

0:37:35I don't know.

0:37:35It won't be all of them, I don't think.

0:37:37I mean, as I think OpenAI is in many ways the dominant player.

0:37:43But there are lots of other interesting companies, right?

0:37:45Like I know Federico has talked a lot about what Anthropics is up to.

0:37:48He's paid closer attention to them than I have.

0:37:51But it is it is a race.

0:37:54And at some point they'll have to kind of mature into what we think of as a sustainable business.

0:38:01But man, part of me feels so allergic to it.

0:38:04Like thinking about when we started our company is like we didn't lose money at all.

0:38:08It's like we were going to make money or we're going to have to go back to our jobs, right?

0:38:12It wasn't an option.

0:38:13It's not an option for normal people.

0:38:14Right.

0:38:15There is, to me, a sort of ick factor to a business strategy that's lose a ton of money for a long while.

0:38:22And something, something will happen.

0:38:25And it's like I see it.

0:38:26I think that the path to that, though, is by somehow it causes a lot of destruction along the way.

0:38:36And that's what carves the path out for profitability.

0:38:39And it was with Amazon and retail, it was that Amazon got effectively de facto permission from investors, the people who owned its publicly held stock after they went public, that we don't expect you to turn a profit for quite a few years.

0:38:59We're with you on this.

0:39:01And no other company had that kind of permission from their ownership, whether they were private or public.

0:39:06And it gave them, it's a very subtle thing that Bezos pulled off there, but it was genius.

0:39:14It led to less competition, right?

0:39:18I don't think it was, in the pre-internet world, the position that Amazon holds in retail is, it's almost unfathomable.

0:39:28I mean, there were Kmart's and Walmart, of course, has been around since I think the 50s or 60s.

0:39:34Go back to earlier in the show, Sears Roebuck, right?

0:39:38Big company, big part of people's lives.

0:39:40And I guess was sort of the proto-Amazon with their catalog, which was the way that people could buy stuff from a major retailer, even when they lived in the middle of nowhere, somewhere in the middle of the United States.

0:39:55Because you'd get the Sears catalog once or twice a year, and you could buy everything that was in a Sears, even though you lived 500 miles away from Chicago or something like that.

0:40:04I mean, they did mail-order homes.

0:40:06Like, you could, I need a house.

0:40:08Can you ship me all the parts for a house?

0:40:09I mean, in the 30s or 40s, it's wild.

0:40:13Yeah, and everybody knew them.

0:40:15I mean, even when I was a little kid, it was still a cool store to go to, you know, and it was kind of cool because they sold, like, everything.

0:40:21They had a whole hardware store within the store, like a real hardware store.

0:40:25Yeah.

0:40:26It was a Craftsman Tools.

0:40:27And they sold appliances, TVs, lots of clothes.

0:40:31I mean, I used to get lots of my back-to-school clothes at Sears, no doubt about it.

0:40:35A shoe store, a whole shoe store.

0:40:36It was a real department store.

0:40:38But sort of never, it just never would have possibly, there was no imaginable way that, everybody knew it, but there's no way that it would be as ubiquitous as Amazon is, right?

0:40:52I mean, you could, I mean, my wife and I try not to buy stuff at Amazon a little.

0:40:56Like, we both think, sort of just fuck Jeff Bezos and with the whole Washington Post thing.

0:41:01But, you know, if you can think of a way to buy something somewhere else first, we do.

0:41:05We're not protesting.

0:41:07We don't.

0:41:08But we still, we still get Amazon stuff all the time, even trying to go elsewhere.

0:41:12Same.

0:41:13We get Amazon stuff all the time because there's so much stuff that you just can't get anywhere else.

0:41:18Or I can't figure out an easy way to get it somewhere else.

0:41:21Right.

0:41:22Yeah, no, it's huge.

0:41:23I mean, they saw that opportunity.

0:41:25To your point, they were given permission to chase it.

0:41:28And I had not really linked in my mind, like, Amazon's route to where they are now to what OpenAI could be doing.

0:41:36But it is interesting to consider, like, if there's a next Amazon, who is it?

0:41:42OpenAI would be on my list in terms of importance and value down the road.

0:41:47Yeah.

0:41:48And building out an infrastructure that it turns out nobody else can catch, maybe.

0:41:52So what do you think?

0:41:54Well, number one, before we go to what they're building, I don't, I'm going to say it.

0:41:59I said it on dithering.

0:42:00I'll say it again here.

0:42:01I don't like the lowercase IO.

0:42:03I really don't.

0:42:06At least they're consistent.

0:42:08Something I think you and I both pointed out that on Humane's website, when they launched, it was, like, capitalized in different ways on different pages.

0:42:16Oh, yeah, yeah.

0:42:16Sloppy.

0:42:17So at least it's consistent.

0:42:19So I'll give them a point for that.

0:42:21But, yeah, I really think Google's, I think they've stylized it differently now.

0:42:25But I think for a long time it was capital I, then a slash, and a capital O.

0:42:29And that was cool because, to your point earlier, it felt old school.

0:42:32Like, it felt like I'm doing toggle switches on some old computer.

0:42:36But, you know, Johnny Ive, he can't escape the lowercase vowels.

0:42:40He just, the man loves them.

0:42:42But, you know what, they did walk away from, they know, when they first launched Love From, they were trying to get people to spell it.

0:42:50You know how Yahoo always tried to spell their name with the bang at the end?

0:42:54Yep.

0:42:54Love From was trying to do that with a comma.

0:42:58That's terrible.

0:42:59Remember that?

0:42:59Right.

0:43:00Which makes no sense.

0:43:02But they've walked away from that.

0:43:03They've come to their senses.

0:43:04You can't just pretend that your name has a comma at the end because it's going to interrupt the flow of every single sentence your name appears in.

0:43:12Yeah, it looks like it's still the title of their webpage, but once you dig in, they've dropped it.

0:43:18Yeah, someone tapped them on the shoulder and be like, you're impossible to write about.

0:43:21Please, please change this.

0:43:23Right.

0:43:24I'm trying to think what would be more annoying.

0:43:27If you could legally insist and force everybody to include a punctuation character in your name, what would be worse than a comma at the end?

0:43:38I mean, the comma's pretty bad.

0:43:41I could see, I mean, they're close, right?

0:43:45But a semicolon, I think, would also be complicated, mostly because most people don't know how to use them.

0:43:49But, yeah, the comma may be the worst one.

0:43:52It's pretty bad.

0:43:55What if you tried to start your name with an open parentheses, but you don't have a closed parentheses in your name?

0:44:05How about that?

0:44:06You'd break every webpage in existence.

0:44:08Yeah, or like an open angle bracket.

0:44:11Why doesn't this HTML render, oh, you wrote about that company again?

0:44:16So, all right, let's give them a pass.

0:44:20And I'm going to style it capital I, capital O on Daring Fireball.

0:44:24Because that's the other thing, when I don't go with a company styling of their name spelling, then there's the, well, then what do I do, right?

0:44:33So famously, or at least famously in our circles, like I spell Mac OS with a capital M.

0:44:40Yeah.

0:44:40And my rule, but I spell iOS with a lowercase i.

0:44:44And my rule is if you say the letters out loud, you're allowed to have a lowercase one at the beginning.

0:44:50So, you pronounce, you don't say M-A-C-O-S, you say Mac OS.

0:44:55So, that's a real name.

0:44:56You have to capitalize the first letter.

0:44:58iOS, though, you just say it.

0:45:00So, lowercase i.

0:45:02T-V-O-S, you say them.

0:45:05So, fine, lowercase T, lowercase V, capital O, capital S.

0:45:09But if that's my rule, then I guess I should be spelling I-O lowercase?

0:45:16It's like, but I feel like I want to add, I have to add to the rule, which now it suddenly feels like I'm like a Trump judge, right?

0:45:24Like, right, a Trump justice on the Supreme Court trying to backwards engineer a way to sign a thing that says, yes, I think the president of the United States has legal immunity from all crimes he may commit while in office.

0:45:38Now I want to add a rule that you can start with some lowercase letters if they're pronounced letter by letter, but you've still got to have some uppercase letters in there.

0:45:48Yeah.

0:45:48And they can't spell it lowercase I, capital O, because then it would look like iOS.

0:45:54Yeah.

0:45:55Do you have a, just like, do you have a document somewhere of your style guide?

0:46:00Yeah, yeah.

0:46:01Yeah.

0:46:01It's online.

0:46:02Yeah.

0:46:03Okay.

0:46:03So, I've got one.

0:46:04It's just in Apple Notes, because sometimes I forget how I stylize things, and I wrote one for our friend Underscore, because he was just, like, capitalizing stuff all over the place.

0:46:12I was like, okay, buddy, you've got to have some rules here.

0:46:14But, yeah, you've got to pick a style and stick with it.

0:46:18It can be different from iOS.

0:46:19I'm texting you now.

0:46:20It's a text document.

0:46:21You'll enjoy it.

0:46:23I link to it every once in a while.

0:46:24Yeah, it's not secret.

0:46:26It is public.

0:46:26It is not HTML.

0:46:28It's just a text file in a sort of self-

0:46:31Yeah.

0:46:32EGS is the second entry.

0:46:33Yes.

0:46:35There's quite a few.

0:46:37If you read the whole, don't start reading it now.

0:46:39No, I'm not.

0:46:40It's a bunch of rabbit holes.

0:46:41But a lot of the entries are very dated.

0:46:44And sometimes when I'm adding a new one and I look above and it's something that really I haven't written about since 2006, I'm like, should I take that out?

0:46:52And then I'm like, nah, why should I take it out?

0:46:54It's kind of fun that it's there.

0:46:55It's not hurting anybody.

0:46:56It's not hurting my search ability.

0:46:58You mentioned it.

0:46:59The humane thing is, to me, the knee-jerk refutation of, hey, why is everybody excited about this IO thing with Love From and OpenAI?

0:47:10Isn't this just humane and maybe with a little bit more money?

0:47:12What are they possibly building?

0:47:15And isn't it the same folly of thinking that people even want to move past their phones?

0:47:22Yeah.

0:47:24I'm super conflicted on that because people really do like their phones, right?

0:47:29Including both of us.

0:47:31But, yeah.

0:47:33I mean, humane, I think, failed for a bunch of reasons.

0:47:36I mean, the second someone was like, yes, laser projectors are the future, then they probably lost, right?

0:47:42Like, that was the moment maybe.

0:47:44But it is hard, I think, just because we're so used to interacting with things with screens.

0:47:50Because once you got past, like, the Altair, right?

0:47:53Once we had even a DOS prompt, screens have been the way computers talk to us.

0:47:59Generally, mostly for most people.

0:48:01And even before that, the teletype was sort of a screen that just was printed on paper.

0:48:07Yeah.

0:48:07Right?

0:48:07And just sort of kept scrolling.

0:48:09Right.

0:48:10It's a lot of history to break away from.

0:48:13And maybe these are the guys to do it.

0:48:14Maybe not.

0:48:15Maybe AI is what we needed to move past that.

0:48:19Maybe it's not.

0:48:19I don't know.

0:48:20But I do share your enthusiasm about just seeing what it is.

0:48:24Like, because, I mean, Johnny Ive did make some of the most incredible products that the world has ever seen.

0:48:31Also made some weird ones that maybe shouldn't have left the lab, but very clearly the most important product designer of our time.

0:48:40What do you think is one of the weird ones that shouldn't have left the lab?

0:48:43The iPod shuffle with no buttons is pretty high on my list.

0:48:48I've been talking recently for, I forget why, but it's come up on a couple of podcasts I've been on.

0:48:53The Fat Nano.

0:48:54The Fat, Fat iPad Nano.

0:48:56Which, to me, is a really interesting one.

0:48:59And I'll put a link.

0:49:00Where's my notebook here?

0:49:01Put a link in the show notes.

0:49:03People probably forget this one, but they had the iPad Nano, or iPod Nano, right?

0:49:09Or they had the iPod Mini, which was a big hit because it was so much smaller, seemed so much smaller, than the bigger hard drive, traditional, original iPod size.

0:49:20And the iPod Mini was really taken off, and its sales are going up all the time.

0:49:25And then they threw it away and said, nope, we're getting rid of the most popular iPod, and we're coming out with the iPod Nano, which is going to switch from tiny little hard drives to Flash.

0:49:35And so there was a cut in price per storage.

0:49:40But I think they rightfully figured, and probably with data, that, hey, people don't have, like, one gigabyte is fine.

0:49:47They don't need five gigabytes.

0:49:48Like, for most, almost everybody out there, like, a one gigabyte or two gigabyte of MP3 files.

0:49:53And compression had gotten better in the intervening years, because everybody was listening to compressed AAC files and MP3 files.

0:50:01And so they had this original Nano, super, even a bigger hit.

0:50:05Everybody was like, this is perfect.

0:50:06And it was sort of a, what would you call it, like a stick.

0:50:10Yeah, like, it was amazing.

0:50:11I mean, it was mind-blowing at the time.

0:50:13And then one year, it was like 2011 or 2009, I forget, they came out with the Fat Nano, which was more like a square.

0:50:20So we had a weird moment.

0:50:24But directionally, the idea behind the Fat Nano, so they only did it for a year.

0:50:29It wasn't a hit.

0:50:30They went back to the other size.

0:50:31But directionally, they were spot on exactly right, which was, hey, people want to watch video on a little thing in their hands.

0:50:40Yeah.

0:50:40Right?

0:50:41And it sort of gets to what Johnny Ive maybe has some guilt and regret over, right?

0:50:45That they've maybe underestimated just how badly people and how much time they would spend watching video.

0:50:52And so they made a device that was optimized for video, widescreen rather than horizontal.

0:50:58I think what they got wrong with that design, clearly, if you just watch the way people use their phones, is not just thinking, hey, just hold the device sideways.

0:51:08Yeah.

0:51:08I mean, to the point that my iPhone is almost always rotation locked, right?

0:51:13Because if I'm watching video, it's in YouTube, and they have a player that will go horizontal.

0:51:19And then, but the rest of the world has moved on to vertical video, because that's how we hold our phones.

0:51:23The idea of turning my phone over 90 degrees, no, no, thank you.

0:51:27I can't be bothered to do that.

0:51:29The no-button shuffle that you mentioned, that's an interesting one, because I wonder how much that informs what they're building at I.O., right?

0:51:39Yeah.

0:51:40I mean, vastly more complicated than something that only played audio through a wired headphone connection.

0:51:47But I could see that sort of being the thing.

0:51:51But then again, then why do they hire all these UI designers and stuff?

0:51:57I don't know.

0:51:58Yeah, who knows?

0:51:59I mean, it is, I think, the biggest mystery in Silicon Valley now is, like, what are they doing?

0:52:05And whether or not it's successful or not, it'll be very, very interesting to see what it is and their explanation behind the decisions they made.

0:52:18Because you know they're going to do that, right?

0:52:20There's going to be a whole thing about every little detail about it, because it's Johnny Ive, and that's what he loves.

0:52:26And so that'll be, it'll be a fun day when that ships.

0:52:29Now, will it be a fun day for them six months later?

0:52:32Are they selling a bunch of them?

0:52:33Man, I just don't know.

0:52:37I think one of the ways that Humane went wrong was, I think, fundamentally, it was hubris at a very almost profound level.

0:52:46And part of that hubris was that their original marketing, like, a year in advance of shipping, or maybe even more, I forget, when they first started putting out the bizarre teaser video.

0:52:58You know, like the one where the lady was staring into the eclipse, which is, it's like, everybody except, like, the current president of the United States knows that you don't stare into an eclipse.

0:53:08Oh, I've forgotten about that and then saw a gif of it the other day where he's, like, pointing at the sun and just, oh, my gosh.

0:53:15What are we doing?

0:53:17I know, but they, Humane made a video about some woman in a, she was, like, in a sea of people staring at their phones, and she noticed there's a solar eclipse going on, and so she stares at it.

0:53:28Wait, what?

0:53:30There go your retinas.

0:53:31I don't know.

0:53:32But I think that they somehow had the hubris of thinking that they were building a replacement for the phone, which wasn't going to happen.

0:53:42And Sam Altman has spoken, and I forget where, because they made the video, and he did some interviews, and there was some reporting on what he told the team.

0:53:51But either in one place or in multiple places, Sam Altman has said this week, now that they've decloaked with I.O., that they see what they're building as, you know, in the same way that the phone didn't replace laptops, and that we all still have laptops, but we also still have phones.

0:54:07This will be, like, this will be to the phone what the phone was to the laptop, which sounds plausible to me.

0:54:14Like, I still don't know what that device is, but that sounds reasonable to me.

0:54:19Like, the phone isn't going anywhere, right?

0:54:21Like, but it maybe, eventually, it has to, at some point, become less important, right, that something is going to do to the phone what the phone did to the laptop.

0:54:32So I think there's an advantage.

0:54:35But I think, and I only really thought, I didn't really think, all the snark that I've written at Humane's expense over the years, the one thing that never really hit me until this week, thinking about this partnership, is that their A.I. sucked anyway, right?

0:54:55They didn't, it wasn't their A.I.

0:54:57I mean, what were they using, Open.A.I.?

0:54:58I don't know even who their partner was.

0:55:00They were, and I think if my timeline is right in my head, Humane came out of the shadows before the chat GPT moment.

0:55:10And I think some people, including me, like, we had that question in our minds of, like, how far along were you before you settled on Open.A.I. helping you power this?

0:55:20Like, was your plan to do it all in-house, or did you just, like, bolt A.I. onto this product that was going to do something else?

0:55:26I do not know the answer to that, but it wasn't their own technology.

0:55:30They definitely didn't own it.

0:55:31Yeah, I, and so I think that the profound difference here is obviously this new endeavor is truly a partnership by all accounts, right?

0:55:41And so it's going to be, like, the full power of Open.A.I. doing the A.I. for the device, not just, oh, here's what you can pay and get through an API bill or just a regular account.

0:55:58And so I think, if I had to guess, that it is putting aside speculation on what shape the device will be, and will it be, like, a pendant you wear around your neck, or is it, I really doubt it's going to be a pin, but is it a watch?

0:56:17Is it a little rectangle?

0:56:19Is it something that you carry around or something you wear?

0:56:22Put aside those questions.

0:56:24I think what they, Johnny Ive and Sam Altman seem to be hinting at, but don't want to come out and say, is that it is a much grander ambition for the actual A.I. itself than going from ChatGPT3 to ChatGPT4 and going from ChatGPT4 to 4.1.

0:56:46I don't think it's ChatGPT.

0:56:48And the closest I think Altman came to dropping a hint about that this week was talking about current A.I. being in the equivalent of the terminal era.

0:56:58Yeah.

0:57:00And that they want to build the GUI for the A.I. age.

0:57:04And that this will be, like, the Macintosh, what the Macintosh was to the terminal command line character-based computers that came before it.

0:57:12And saying that when your partner is Johnny Ive, he knows what he's saying.

0:57:16Right.

0:57:17Not that Ive was there at the original Macintosh, but he was, he's, he's the person people think of when they think of Apple hardware.

0:57:23And it's a huge claim, right?

0:57:26And, but he's not wrong in that, yeah, if I'm going to use ChatGPT, I'm opening the Mac app or I'm opening the app on my phone or maybe I'm using a web browser, right?

0:57:35And even with the Mac, where there's a lot of integration with different applications now, which I think is actually pretty cool in some situations, even that, like, feels like new technology kind of living within the frame of old technology in a way.

0:57:53And at some point it's going to potentially break free of that.

0:57:58And I think that's what they're trying to do.

0:58:01And I, the other thing in their shared history, I keep thinking about Johnny Ive's role.

0:58:06I mean, who knows how, how much effort he put into it, but that he supposedly informed or hinted or suggested aspects of Eve, the robot and Wally.

0:58:18And that's sort of, it's, Eve certainly feels a very, looks and feels very Johnny Ivey, right?

0:58:27It's from the, even to the color, right?

0:58:30This white and black, shiny, clean, perfect thing.

0:58:35And the beeps and boops she communicates with and the way she moves and the fact that I'm calling her she and not it.

0:58:43I could see him aspiring to build a gadget that you become attached to in the same way that you would imagine.

0:58:50If you owned a real working Wally, if Wally could be made real and put Roomba out of business, that you would feel affection to Wally.

0:58:59Well, it's why it's one of my favorite movies, not just Pixar movies, but one of my favorite movies, period, ever made.

0:59:07I think it's just an astonishing cinematic achievement.

0:59:10But one of them is just, just how much of a character that robot is and how much emotion it, it carries.

0:59:19Wait, my kids named our Roomba, right?

0:59:21Like people have that with their technology, right?

0:59:24His name is Charlie and he goes around the house.

0:59:26Yeah, people have that, right?

0:59:29Like the Roomba is like, and I've got a pretty decent one, but it's still basically just like bouncing around my house and will like run over a thing of ribbon that my daughter left out and try to choke itself, right?

0:59:38Like it's not an intelligent thing.

0:59:40So take those feelings that we have towards technology now, and then you pair them with something that knows you and you communicate with.

0:59:48And that is extremely powerful, kind of scary in some ways for some people, I think.

0:59:54But you could see people like Sam Altman and Johnny Ive being attracted to that idea.

1:00:01We're going to make something that is more of a companion than anything we've had in technology so far.

1:00:08Yeah.

1:00:09I think companion was the word I used on Dithering's episode that aired this morning.

1:00:15But yeah, I'm glad you said it because that's my guess.

1:00:18I don't know.

1:00:19Nobody's told me that.

1:00:20But something that's more of a companion.

1:00:22And then it's sort of a sick way of looking at it, but the better the thing is, the more risky and uncertain the eventual outcomes of it will be, right?

1:00:36It's the fact that the iPhone was so spectacularly amazing that here we are 18 years later talking about how it's too addictive, right?

1:00:47And so you can certainly imagine if they pull it off and make something that's more of a companion that you talk to throughout the day, that it gives you companionship, that it could maybe not be so good for a lot of people.

1:01:02Yeah.

1:01:02Right?

1:01:03I mean, there's definitely people who have unhealthy relationships with the chat, GPT, et cetera, as they are today.

1:01:11There was the guy at Google who a couple years ago, before these things became public, who was working with an early version of what I guess became Gemini, who, remember, there was a story that the guy became convinced that it was sentient and that he felt like it's not a human right.

1:01:26It's like, I don't know, an intelligence right activist, that it was immoral for the company to have created this thing and trapped it within the system.

1:01:37And he's wrong.

1:01:39It's really, really just like sort of a complicated regular expression system that just predicts patterns that come out.

1:01:48But it's already, even years ago, created the very convincing illusion of being real.

1:01:55And imagine what something really good along those lines that you talk to and that beeps and boops at you in truly appealing ways, you know, how, I was going to say corrupting, but how, I don't know what the word is, but I don't know.

1:02:12I think it's confusing to some people, right?

1:02:16And you can see the outcome of that.

1:02:21There was a story a few days ago about users have like uploaded pictures of people to Grok and asked Grok to undress them, right?

1:02:29It's like that is wholly inappropriate at every single level I can think of.

1:02:35But people are doing it out of lots of terrible reasons.

1:02:38And so like there is a danger to that sort of technology, I think, for a lot of people.

1:02:42But then I also think about something I read recently about hearing loss.

1:02:46Maybe it was in conjunction with some Apple hearing aid stuff.

1:02:49I don't remember.

1:02:50But there's evidence that people with hearing loss are more prone to things like dementia because they don't hear words clearly.

1:02:58And so you could also see that technology like this could be helpful to people who live alone or who are elderly.

1:03:09There's upsides and downsides to all of it, right?

1:03:13And it's up to product people like John Hive and Sam Altman and this team they've put together to navigate those things and to take, I think, the rough edges off of them.

1:03:23And then we'll see what the people do with it.

1:03:27We'll see what humans do with it once it's out.

1:03:29But I watched that video and read a bunch of the same stuff you did, I'm sure.

1:03:33And what I walked away from it all is like, these guys, they're doing something really weighty in a way that we haven't seen out of Silicon Valley or San Francisco.

1:03:43Boy, those guys really love San Francisco.

1:03:45It was like a whole section of the video, which is not how I feel about San Francisco personally.

1:03:49But it's just this is my taste.

1:03:51But their San Francisco, as pictured in the video, does not smell like the San Francisco that I have experienced.

1:03:57Although I do love the city of San Francisco and consider it one of my favorite places in the world.

1:04:02Maybe over the years at WWCs and stuff, I was like seeing some things I can't unsee.

1:04:08But I'm also living in my hometown.

1:04:10So take that for what it's worth.

1:04:11But they're doing something really weighty.

1:04:14And obviously they think it's important.

1:04:16And I think to the world it's important probably.

1:04:18But it's weighty in a sense that we haven't seen from Silicon Valley or from these companies maybe since the iPhone.

1:04:27Yeah, I don't think so.

1:04:29Meta's made some glasses.

1:04:31But they're glasses so far.

1:04:32They're not real.

1:04:33I mean, I'm not saying they're not real or that people don't enjoy taking pictures with them.

1:04:37But they're not a real attempt to make a computer, right?

1:04:41I mean, Vision Pro maybe.

1:04:43I know people think it's this historic flop.

1:04:46And I think the jury will – I think we need to see the next few generations before you can make that judgment.

1:04:53But Vision Pro might be something as ambitious as what they're doing, but maybe in the wrong way in terms of actually being something that really makes people just die to use it.

1:05:05And the computer history is littered with the corpses of products and companies that didn't make it but were on the right track, right?

1:05:13Humane joins the list of companies.

1:05:15I know y'all spoke about this on Tethering.

1:05:17General Magic, right?

1:05:18Yeah.

1:05:19Or even going back to the Halt and Catch fire days, right?

1:05:23For every one company whose name people remember, like Commodore, there were a whole bunch of companies that you will never come across on the modern internet because they live and died in such a short period of time.

1:05:36Like, they made no impression on the modern world.

1:05:39And so these guys, they're entering that level of intensity, I think.

1:05:46And I don't – my money is on them not being the next humane AI pen if they have anything to say about it.

1:05:56I think they're taking it super seriously and hopefully taking all those, like, safety and societal concerns at the same level as what's the finish like on the clip.

1:06:08Like, those things deserve equal weight if not one more than the other in these conversations.

1:06:14I – you know, the last thing is it really is an amazing lineup of talent.

1:06:18Just the names that are already publicly known, let alone some of the ones that I know aren't publicly known.

1:06:23But Evans Hankey and Tang Tan and Mike Mattis, who I don't know is at IO, but he's at Love From.

1:06:30A whole bunch of people who helped build the iPhone and iPad and great stuff from the last 20 years are now working on this.

1:06:41And I'm not saying there's not tons of talent still at Apple right now, including younger talent and stuff.

1:06:48But I can't think of names like theirs, right?

1:06:51And it's part of – part of Apple's continuing – what's the word?

1:07:00Anonymity within the ranks.

1:07:02Sure.

1:07:02That the only people – as the years go on after Steve Jobs has died, we know fewer and fewer of the people making things at Apple who aren't the executives on the senior leadership page.

1:07:15Yeah, I mean, I think in some areas that's true.

1:07:19I'm thinking about like keynotes in recent years.

1:07:22We're seeing more people like, oh, this person's involved with health or with Apple Pay or something.

1:07:26And that's great.

1:07:26Like they should have more faces, more diverse keynotes.

1:07:29That's excellent.

1:07:30I think where the difference is, though, is that we know the name of Johnny Ives and his lieutenants because at the time Apple had design at a higher level both, I think, organizationally but also sort of in the way they talk about things than they do now, right?

1:07:51Think about like in 2008, 2008, they did the unibody MacBook Pro.

1:07:57And Johnny Ives is on stage at town hall talking about, oh, like we used to make this with a bunch of little parts we screw together and now we're carving it off aluminum, right?

1:08:05It's a fascinating video.

1:08:06People can go find it on YouTube.

1:08:07It was a whole keynote about this is how we build our laptops.

1:08:11And that sort of highlighting or spotlighting the design process, we still see it from Apple sometimes, right?

1:08:19The Vision Pro announcement a couple years ago had quite a bit of that, but it's in line with all these other things where it used to be more on a pedestal, I think.

1:08:29And that's an interesting change that I think has taken place over time.

1:08:32And maybe not just design either.

1:08:34I think back to some of the Phil Schiller-led iPhone keynotes where he'd really sort of nerd out on subpixels in a very, hey, it's not going to take more than 90 seconds, maybe two minutes tops.

1:08:47But here's Phil Schiller who really knows his shit about photography, giving you the lowdown on a legit breakdown in sensor technology that allows this tiny little iPhone camera to shoot a lot better photos than last year.

1:09:02Or maybe another, like the unibody example is so great because you're right.

1:09:06The whole video was really just, here's how we make laptops now.

1:09:10Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1:09:12It's wild.

1:09:13I think also those laptops-

1:09:14Steve Jobs did some of that.

1:09:16I'm trying to think of some Steve Jobs examples, but there were times where Steve Jobs would just want to nerd out on something.

1:09:21Like, hey, by the way, we got this, his little, I just linked to it, his little mini lecture on what a retina display was, was great.

1:09:28That's maybe not the best example, but yeah, sometimes they would just nerd out.

1:09:31They would just nerd out on this.

1:09:32Yeah.

1:09:33And I don't know who those people are anymore.

1:09:35Yeah.

1:09:36Who's the Mike Mattis who makes the slider, the slide to unlock slider, look so good that you just want a slide to unlock just to actually just watch it go across the screen?

1:09:45Who, it's someone in our friend group.

1:09:46Was it Guy who had a phone and that's all he could do with it?

1:09:49All he could do was that slider?

1:09:50Yeah, I think so.

1:09:50It might have been.

1:09:51I think it was Guy who was talking about that.

1:09:53Yeah, because he was from Canada and couldn't get his SIM card to work in it because it was U.S. only.

1:09:57He had an iPhone that had no cell service and he would just slide to unlock and sort of figure out, try to figure out how the animation algorithm was working, that it was tracking his fingers so perfectly.

1:10:10And there are people, you know, the folks who think it's time for change at Apple and the high ranks, they would look at that part of our conversation or that change over time and be like, well, it's because Tim Cook's not a product guy.

1:10:23He's not a design guy.

1:10:24I don't know exactly where you come down on that debate, but it is clearly a difference from the jobs era to now, that those things aren't given the time, at least in public, that they once were.

1:10:36I have a draft that I should, maybe by mentioning it here on the show with you, it'll force me to finish it up and get it out over the weekend.

1:10:47But basically where I fall on that is, I don't think, I don't really think it's worth spending that much time arguing about whether it's time for Tim Cook to retire or step upstairs to chairman of the board or something, because it's not going to happen anytime soon.

1:11:05It's fan fiction, you know, and I know that's, I'm not accusing Syracuse of having done that because he didn't really call for Cook to be asked to retire.

1:11:17By the board, he's what I think fairly encompassing, encapsulating his argument is just, I think Apple really needs to do X, Y, and Z.

1:11:29And we're kind of needed to already, but the sooner they've changed their mind on X, Y, and Z, the better.

1:11:36And they're not going to do X, Y, or Z so long as Tim Cook is still the CEO.

1:11:41And I think that's why his essay hit very well, because it wasn't a polemic.

1:11:47It wasn't saying this guy should be canned, he's a bozo, get rid of him.

1:11:51So I don't disagree with him.

1:11:52I just don't think it's worth thinking about that much.

1:11:55What I think is, I think Tim Cook is a man who has shown that he can change his mind on very profound topics.

1:12:06And I think he needs to, on a few of those, at least X, Y, or Z at this point.

1:12:12So what I would like to see from Tim Cook, and again, I've been down a nostalgia streak of late at Daring Fireball, but I reread Steve Jobs' Thoughts on Flash, which was so much longer than I read.

1:12:24I've read it like 10 times.

1:12:26But every time I read it, I'm like, wow, this is a lot longer than I remember.

1:12:29And I think because Thoughts on Music was so much shorter.

1:12:34Thoughts on Music really wasn't a very long essay, because it wasn't that complicated.

1:12:38But Thoughts on Flash, it's like six points.

1:12:42He's like point and sixth.

1:12:43And it all, it doesn't get too, but it doesn't get too complicated.

1:12:47He was such a great writer.

1:12:49And when he had figured something out, he was terrific at explaining it.

1:12:52I would like to see Tim Cook write Thoughts on the App Store.

1:12:56That's right.

1:12:58It would be, it would be really good for him to do that.

1:13:03And I agree with you.

1:13:04He's not going to go anywhere.

1:13:05I think if the election had gone differently, maybe he'd be looking at retiring sooner.

1:13:11But I think as long as Trump's in office, Cook feels like a personal obligation to be there because he can't somewhat manage the chaos.

1:13:23Do you ever do this?

1:13:24I do this.

1:13:25It happens to me all the time where I'll start.

1:13:27I started linking to Syracuse's essay and then I started my own commentary and it kept growing and growing.

1:13:34And I thought, what am I doing here?

1:13:35I really should just link.

1:13:36I want to, I really wanted to just link to it and blurb a little, quote a little bit of it and just encourage everybody to go read it and let it speak for itself.

1:13:45And so I cut all of the stuff I had written and have it in a different draft now.

1:13:49Do you do that?

1:13:50Oh, yeah.

1:13:51Do your link posts ever start spiraling?

1:13:53You're like, what am I doing?

1:13:54Is it a link post or is it a full article?

1:13:56Oh, I know.

1:13:56Yeah.

1:13:56Sometimes I just stare at Mars at it and the little field that has the link list item is like, is that, which one of these is this?

1:14:04Yes, you know, sometimes I'll even end up switching it after the fact because I'm like, that was too long to be a link list item.

1:14:09But I think I cut this part, too, because I think I was like, you know what?

1:14:12I should take all these points out.

1:14:13But I even included that part in the folly of thinking that Tim Cook might go anytime soon.

1:14:18That I also think it's not just that what Tim Cook thinks about his obligations to Apple politically in the world right now with with Trump in America, Xi Jinping in China and the threat to TSMC in all of Taiwan.

1:14:34I also think it literally is the biggest problem that faces Apple right now.

1:14:40We'll actually come to that after the break, after I thank the next sponsor.

1:14:44But that as much as developer relations in general is, I think, problematic for Apple and growing and getting worse because they seem to be not seeing it.

1:14:57And my response to that is, even if they're right, this is my response to anybody at Apple who thinks that they have an overall correct stance on developer relations.

1:15:07Even if Apple is right about that, it's almost undeniable.

1:15:13I don't see how anybody could deny that the developers in the outside world do not see it that way.

1:15:17So even if Apple's right, they're wrong because developers think they're wrong.

1:15:22And they're not poor, right?

1:15:25They're not losing money.

1:15:26They're in a position where they can be magnanimous.

1:15:29And even if they're like, well, we don't think we should have to do this.

1:15:32We actually think 70-30 is extremely fair for what everybody's getting.

1:15:37Just to name one particular issue, right?

1:15:39Right.

1:15:39The most obvious thing they could just change at the snap of a finger is the commission rate.

1:15:44Even if they really do feel in their bones that this is just and fair, and if a omnipotent Solomon-like deity could come, whose judgment everybody would say, oh, this deity is always correct.

1:15:59And the deity looked at the situation and said, 70-30 is exactly fair.

1:16:06And all of us would be like, son of a bitch.

1:16:08And then by tomorrow, all developers would be like, nah, that's not right.

1:16:13Right?

1:16:13There's no way to, even if it is the correct fair commission, there's no way to convince everybody outside the company that it is.

1:16:23So that would be my message there.

1:16:25All right.

1:16:26Let me take this break and thank, before we spiral out of control, our good friends at Squarespace.

1:16:31This podcast is sponsored, as episodes of this show often are, by our good friends at Squarespace.

1:16:37Squarespace is the all-in-one platform for making your own website.

1:16:43And they have been around for a while at this point.

1:16:45And they've been sponsoring this show for a long time.

1:16:47And they keep evolving their platform in new ways.

1:16:52And one of the big new ways that they've got in the last year or so is design intelligence.

1:16:59Design intelligence from Squarespace combines two decades of their industry-leading design expertise and design tools with cutting-edge AI technology to unlock your strongest creative potential.

1:17:11Design intelligence empowers anyone to build a beautiful, more personalized website tailored to their unique needs and craft a bespoke digital identity to use across one's entire online presence.

1:17:23Their design tools have always been approachable to non-professional designers.

1:17:27And they have always been what you see is what you get.

1:17:30And you're looking at it in the browser.

1:17:31But it's really by using AI for this.

1:17:35And if you're using AI to do lots of other things, making images and writing text and just coming up with ideas, and you can actually use AI to help design your almost part sum, a new section of your Squarespace website.

1:17:51And their users are really, the more they try it, the more they really like it.

1:17:56Another thing, Squarespace payments.

1:17:59Squarespace payments is the easiest way to manage payments in one place with Squarespace.

1:18:02Onboarding is fast and simple.

1:18:05You can get started in a few clicks and start receiving payments right away and give your customers more ways to pay with popular payment methods like Klarna, ACH, direct deposit in the U.S., Apple Pay, Afterpay in the U.S. and Canada, and ClearPay, which is sort of like that, but over in the U.K.

1:18:24So many different things.

1:18:26It's such a great system.

1:18:27They've got invoicing built in.

1:18:29So if you run a sort of service where you have to send out invoices to clients or customers on a regular basis, you could do it all through Squarespace.

1:18:36And your clients will thank you because you just send them a link and they go to the Squarespace site and there's the invoice right there.

1:18:42Easy peasy.

1:18:43And it could tie it in with the Squarespace payments.

1:18:45So where do you go to find out more?

1:18:47Go to squarespace.com.

1:18:49You get a free trial.

1:18:50And when you're ready to launch, go to squarespace.com slash talkshow and you will save 10% off your first order of a website or domain.

1:18:59Squarespace.com slash talkshow.

1:19:02And just remember that code talkshow to save 10%.

1:19:05So you ready for a USA-made iPhone, Stephen?

1:19:09I'm saving up now because it's going to be – oh, man.

1:19:17Letterman used to have this phrase – or he still has it, I'm sure, but he just – I don't even know what the hell it means, but I know Snell loves it too.

1:19:23But I wouldn't trade Tim Cook's Trump problems to a monkey on a rock.

1:19:28Mm-mm.

1:19:29No.

1:19:30We were talking earlier about if you wind the clock back.

1:19:32Imagine, like, Tim Cook – a young Tim Cook gets a call from Steve Jobs.

1:19:38He's at – Tim Cook was at Compaq, I think?

1:19:40Yeah, Compaq.

1:19:41Hey, come fix our inventory problems.

1:19:43And now he's, like, holding the world economy in his hands.

1:19:46What – how did I get here?

1:19:47Like, how did this happen?

1:19:48But, yeah, I know a few days ago – because one thing Apple's been doing is they've been trying to move some of their supply chain stuff out of China and diversify, right?

1:19:59India has been kind of at the top of the list, I feel like, in the last couple years at least of moving some production stuff there.

1:20:05Trump said a couple of days ago he didn't like that.

1:20:09And then this morning said that a 25% tariff must be paid by Apple to the U.S. unless the phone is made in America.

1:20:19Right.

1:20:22Which, again, he just tweeted it on his blog.

1:20:25I keep calling his Truth Social his blog, which I actually – I have a side rant on that.

1:20:30I'll just talk about it here.

1:20:31But I think if you really think about it, that's what Truth Social is.

1:20:34Like, one of the little mini-mysteries of the whole Trump-Elon Musk partnership that I've been curious about for a year, like before the election, but even just when Musk threw himself in as all-in on trying to get Trump elected.

1:20:49Is the conflict between Trump owning his bespoke Twitter-like Truth Social social network and Musk famously was talking about $44 billion or $42 billion, having purchased Twitter and renamed it X, and Trump having been previously one of the most famous users of Twitter.

1:21:12And how does that work?

1:21:14Like, has Elon ever – has he ever said to him, like, hey, why don't you just shut that thing down and come back to Twitter?

1:21:20Yeah.

1:21:21Or does he not say it?

1:21:23Does nobody talk about it?

1:21:24But for all of the lickspittle – really, I think, already humiliating.

1:21:32But I think when this whole thing is over is going to make all these people look so bad.

1:21:37The lickspittleism of everybody that Trump has selected for the Trump 2.0 administration in every position and how he's a genius and it's all about him.

1:21:48And they have these cabinet meetings where they just go around the table and say what a great job he's doing.

1:21:53And he sits there and nods his head and all of that.

1:21:55None of those lickspittles are on True Social.

1:21:59You know, Kristi Noem isn't on True Social.

1:22:01She's on X.

1:22:02Pam Bondi, when she tweets, or the Justice Department or whoever, they do it on Twitter or X, whatever you want to call it.

1:22:10But not Trump.

1:22:10No.

1:22:11And I think if you think of it – and it doesn't seem to bother him.

1:22:14It does – I don't know.

1:22:15Maybe somebody – if somebody mentions it to him, maybe he'll get on everybody's case and get little Marco Rubio to start posting on True Social.

1:22:22J.D. Vance, he doesn't post on True Social.

1:22:24The biggest lickspittle of them all.

1:22:26None of them do.

1:22:28But if you think of it –

1:22:29It's wild.

1:22:29If you think of it as his blog, it kind of all makes sense.

1:22:34It's really Trump Social.

1:22:36It's just his blog.

1:22:38The only – the one and only person who posts there who matters is him.

1:22:42I don't even know who second place is.

1:22:44I have never once seen a news story.

1:22:46And I'm back to reading more political news than I was hoping to be by this point in his administration.

1:22:52I read political news all the time.

1:22:54And I see links to posts that so-and-so or the Justice Department or Doge or somebody posts to Twitter over and over and over again.

1:23:03It happens all the time.

1:23:04I see links to things people post to Blue Sky now all the time.

1:23:08I see links to things people post on Threads, maybe a little less frequently.

1:23:12But, you know, it's being used.

1:23:14And I see in news stories, oh, here's somebody posted this to Threads or Blue Sky.

1:23:20I've never once seen anybody post anything to True Social other than one person, which sort of makes it a blog.

1:23:26And if you go there – and I'm not recommending anybody go there.

1:23:30But, you know, when the president of the United States makes an announcement like, hey, I'm going to impose a 25% tariff on India-made iPhones, I link to the original source.

1:23:41If you go there and just scroll down and look at the replies, they're blog replies.

1:23:46Like, they're so much worse and so much more illiterate than Twitter replies, which is saying something.

1:23:53It's his blog.

1:23:55That's really interesting.

1:23:58I've not thought about it that way, but you're right.

1:24:00I've never seen another person sourced there.

1:24:05I also – I have it open now because I was reading that thing.

1:24:08And just every four seconds, a little pop-up comes up in Chrome saying, I'm not authenticated to do that action.

1:24:13I'm not doing any actions.

1:24:14I'm looking at the page.

1:24:16So it's got the same level of technical competence that X does now, I guess.

1:24:20Tim Cook's – I mean, I don't know what happens here.

1:24:24If Trump can't – if doesn't get distracted by something else or forget about it or Cook can't do whatever he whispers into his ear to talk him down from these ledges.

1:24:38Because this isn't going to happen.

1:24:39There is no possible – I've tried to explain it, and I don't even think it's that complicated a story.

1:24:46You have to think about it a little bit deeper than the typical person on the street.

1:24:50The typical person on the street thinks – not crazily so, because I think for many common everyday objects, this is the explanation.

1:25:00Like, why are most T-shirts not made in the United States?

1:25:04Because it's cheaper to make them outside the United States, because labor is cheaper, and it's cheaper to just make them in Vietnam or China or South America somewhere and ship them all to the United States than it would be to pay U.S. wages here.

1:25:22Now, you can buy USA-made T-shirts.

1:25:24Some companies make them, but they are a little bit more expensive.

1:25:27So you can do it.

1:25:29They're just a little bit more expensive because labor is expensive.

1:25:31And people think, well, that must be the situation with the iPhone, too, that it would just – it would make the iPhone more expensive.

1:25:39Right.

1:25:39Because they'd have to pay people $20 an hour to put the screws in the iPhone instead of paying them $4 an hour over in China.

1:25:47The problem is the screws are on the other side of the world, right?

1:25:50The strength of what Apple has built is that it's not just the production, although that is obviously a huge part of it, but it's all the little parts.

1:26:01I mean, have you ever opened an iPhone?

1:26:02There's a zillion things in there, and Apple's really the only thing in recent time product-wise that I'm aware of that they've assembled in the U.S. has been the Mac Pro.

1:26:12Famously, the last – in Trump 1, Tim Cook went and showed it to him, and the guys on Connected were like, you think that's your Mac Pro?

1:26:19Because I had a 2019 Mac Pro for a while.

1:26:22I was like, God, I hope not.

1:26:23But even that, right, an extremely low-volume, very expensive product.

1:26:29But there were reports even then that they had trouble getting some of the components they needed to Texas for the final assembly.

1:26:38Yeah, including stuff like screws, which sounds so simple.

1:26:42But it's not.

1:26:44It's not.

1:26:45At their scale, it's not.

1:26:46And, I mean, for every one of Mac Pro they make, how many millions of iPhones do they make, right?

1:26:52That ratio has to be totally bonkers.

1:26:54It's just impossible.

1:26:56It's just impossible.

1:26:58I think that the thing – and even when Steve Jobs was alive, I remember there was a story.

1:27:04It was sadly towards the end of Jobs' life.

1:27:07It must have – I guess, based on when he died, it must have been the first Obama administration.

1:27:12But that he and Obama were at some kind of fundraising dinner or something.

1:27:16And Obama had asked him, why aren't you making more things here?

1:27:22And Jobs' explanation was – and Tim Cook has spoken about this too, about what we used to call in the U.S.

1:27:29vo-tech training.

1:27:30Like when I was in high school, there were kids who took vo-tech.

1:27:34And they had to take, like, regular history in English and a math class in the morning.

1:27:38And then they would go to vo-tech and they would learn trade skills, fixing cars or becoming a plumber in high school.

1:27:45And that in China, for decades, they've had vocational, technical training like that for something that's more akin to engineering-level talent.

1:27:56Sort of like – I don't know.

1:27:59What's the – oh, man.

1:28:01What's the two – there's different levels of nursing, right?

1:28:05Yeah, you could be, like, a nurse practitioner or a registered nurse, like that sort of thing.

1:28:10Right, like a registered nurse.

1:28:11Yeah, that's what my mom was and is sort of – I couldn't believe I couldn't – yeah, like an RN is a higher level of education and is not quite the same as, like, a bachelor's degree.

1:28:20But it's sort of the equivalent of a bachelor's degree.

1:28:22And being, like, a nurse practitioner is still – you're very, very skilled.

1:28:26And you go to real school and you're doing real medical things, but it's a little less aspirational.

1:28:33I don't know what the word is, but that China has tens of millions of people with this skill set, like sort of an engineer but not quite an engineer.

1:28:42And then they go and do this incredibly intricate technical work that you really can't do.

1:28:49I don't even know what some of these things are, but you can't really do them without a very high level of skill.

1:28:54But that's true, too.

1:28:56I know in, like, the retro Mac community, there's a big movement right now.

1:29:01People are recreating parts that you can't get anymore.

1:29:05And so you can go out and buy, like, a remade – like, a brand-new rebuilt SE30 board.

1:29:11I just linked to one the other day.

1:29:13Someone's rebuilding the Macintosh Plus board.

1:29:15And part of that is a response to, like, these parts are hard to come by, that everything's old.

1:29:20But within those conversations, like, if you read through those forum posts, every single time the person with the project idea runs into this problem.

1:29:29Like, oh, I want to get these boards made and sell them on my side or give them to my friends.

1:29:34It's like – you run into the problem of there's basically one company in the United States that does that kind of work.

1:29:40And they have a ceiling to what they can do.

1:29:43And if you go past that ceiling, you've got to go overseas.

1:29:47And, again, think about a retro hobbyist trying to rebuild the SE30.

1:29:51Like, that's a small project made with love, and they may not ever make their money back.

1:29:56The iPhone is such a different universe than that.

1:30:00Like, I mean, I think about, like, projects I've done over the years and, like, the sort of logistics that go into them.

1:30:07I can't even imagine what it takes to build an iPhone, let alone hundreds of millions of them.

1:30:12And they're out on time basically every year.

1:30:15Like, that machinery and those muscles have been built over decades, and you can't just pick it up and move it because the guy in charge at the White House wants you to.

1:30:25It was fun, and I think the bigger thing isn't even the skill set, right?

1:30:31But that is a huge factor.

1:30:32And to have that skill set and want to take a job for a relatively low wage, right?

1:30:40I don't know.

1:30:41The wages in China aren't as low as people think they are anymore.

1:30:45But the people putting iPhones together at Foxconn in China are still making wages that wouldn't give you a living here.

1:30:51And so you can say, well, you know, $20 an hour, $30 an hour, something like that, and then the iPhone price would go up a little.

1:30:59But you can't find people that skilled here in the U.S. who would want to spend eight hours a day putting tiny screws into an iPhone.

1:31:08And the last time I mentioned that, Ben Thompson called me out on it and laughed and said, eight hours a day?

1:31:14Because if you get the job in China, you're working 12 hours a day.

1:31:18And obviously, you know, in the United States, we have different labor laws, but to run a factory 24 hours a day would take three shifts, not two, which would also increase the cost.

1:31:27And, you know, it's not just 1.5 as many employees to go from two shifts to three.

1:31:33But then there's the whole tradeoff inefficiency of having, well, at eight in the morning every day, everybody leaves and a new crew comes in and it's downtime.

1:31:42Yeah.

1:31:42But I think the biggest thing to me is just the fundamental scale of the whole thing.

1:31:47And that exercise I did a month or so ago with Ryan Jones, when they first came out with the story that Apple was trying to hurry up and fly as many iPhones out of India as possible ahead of the worldwide tariffs.

1:32:02And, well, how many iPhones fit on a plane?

1:32:05And we did the math based on the weight of the plane or Ryan Jones did really originally.

1:32:10And then I just stole it.

1:32:11But it's really, really eye opening.

1:32:14I think it's big, big numbers, like hundreds of millions of phones or 100,000, 150,000 phones a day.

1:32:21They're very hard to imagine.

1:32:22But when you think of filling six jumbo jets, the biggest jets Boeing makes that are entirely used for shipping freight, and fill them from the entire cargo capacity with brand new iPhones and give the benefit of the doubt to how small the packaging is for the iPhones, that's 12 days of inventory in the United States.

1:32:45It's 100 – on a typical April, May, this quarter, Apple sells around 150,000 iPhones per day in the U.S.

1:32:53Gosh.

1:32:54So if they were making them all here – and, again, that's not even accounting for the rush in September when they do preorders for new ones.

1:33:01It's not an even demand year-round.

1:33:05Right.

1:33:05150,000 a day.

1:33:07That's 6,250 per hour.

1:33:11Gosh.

1:33:13So that's 104 iPhones a minute they need to produce.

1:33:17And now they're doing that somewhere right now, mostly in China.

1:33:21104 iPhones a minute are being assembled just to meet the demand in the United States.

1:33:28That's not to meet the demand everywhere else in China and Japan and Europe and everywhere else they sell them, right?

1:33:33So I don't know how many – you could do the math on how many more they're making elsewhere.

1:33:36But to meet Trump's demands of U.S. sold iPhones being made in America, they'd have to figure out a way to produce 104 of them every minute, 24 hours a day, 365 days a year.

1:33:49So if they only run the plant for two shifts instead of three, it goes up even more.

1:33:54It would have to be, you know, like 150 of them an hour.

1:33:57Yeah.

1:33:57The scale of the operation is – it's just unfathomably.

1:34:02I mean, so even if you could just concede for the sake of argument that Apple could hire enough Americans who would want to do the work and have the skills or could be taught the skills to do the work,

1:34:16the infrastructure build out to build out that sort of capability, in a best-case scenario, would take years.

1:34:24I mean, what kind of a maniac would start laying out that investment now knowing how erratic Trump's tariff policies have been just for the last, what, six weeks, five weeks?

1:34:38I don't know.

1:34:39Yeah, it's been the longest month.

1:34:40Like, I cannot believe it's still May.

1:34:42That was one thing that was so interesting with the CHIPS Act and companies like TSMC coming to Arizona, right, where they're going to build products there.

1:34:52And there was reporting, I think earlier this year or late last year, about sort of the conflict within TSMC between what they're used to overseas and what American workers are used to, right?

1:35:05And you can say things about both sides of, yes, the conditions and working hours should be better overseas and maybe some Americans, we've got it too soft here, whatever.

1:35:14But there's that conflict there, right?

1:35:17And that's TSMC.

1:35:19They're building legacy products in Arizona, I think is what the reporting has been, and probably not the scale of the iPhone, right?

1:35:26And TSMC also, like, they control so much of it, right?

1:35:30So much of that is in-house, where Apple is extremely dependent on a bunch of different vendors, right?

1:35:36And it's not as simple as, say, it comes in one end and, like, A15s come out the other, right?

1:35:43They've got vendors and everything too.

1:35:45But the iPhone has all of these different components from all of these different companies.

1:35:49It's just the scale.

1:35:51It's just so different.

1:35:52I think I remember that story.

1:35:54It was a good story.

1:35:55I'll have to see if I can find that for the show notes.

1:35:57But the anecdote, which I'll butcher a little from memory, was basically that, like, in Taiwan, if an engineer who's responsible for a certain critical machine gets a call at 1 in the morning that the machine is down,

1:36:11he or she just gets out of bed and puts their pants on and goes in to fix it immediately.

1:36:19And in the U.S., it would be like, oh, I'll come in early tomorrow morning, which I think most people would say, well, that's a healthy life.

1:36:28That's pretty reasonable.

1:36:29Instead of coming in at 9, come in at 7 in the morning because the critical machine is down.

1:36:34But in Taiwan, it's not like somebody's barking at them.

1:36:37It's just the expectation.

1:36:39Like, oh, that machine's down, all right, I'll be right in at 1, 2, whatever time of day.

1:36:44So I don't know.

1:36:45And I guess the other factor with this, too, is Trump is so dumb.

1:36:49He's so ignorant on this issue.

1:36:51He really is.

1:36:52I don't know.

1:36:52Anybody listening who's a Trump fan who still listens to my show, I mean, thank you, number one, for having an open mind.

1:36:58But two, on this tariff issue, he's just plainly wrong and dumb.

1:37:03And he knows he kind of knows it, too, because and I've called it out at least a week ago where his whole rhetoric throughout the whole election is this nonsense that tariffs are paid by the countries that you impose them on.

1:37:17So that a tariff imposed on Indian-made iPhones would be paid by India to the United States and that China pays tariffs on Chinese-made goods.

1:37:27But here's Trump last week telling Walmart that they should eat the tariffs before they raise prices on everything in their stores.

1:37:36And now here today, he's saying – he even said in his stupid little post that this is a 25% tariff that Apple will have to pay.

1:37:45I mean, which is it?

1:37:46You can't have it both ways.

1:37:48No, you can't.

1:37:48I was talking to a friend of mine a couple of weeks ago who – he owns a product company and some of their metal fixtures for their product are made overseas.

1:37:58Like, he told me literally no one in the United States could make this part that we needed.

1:38:02Now, their product is assembled in America.

1:38:05A lot of the other parts come from U.S. companies.

1:38:07But this specific metal piece has to come from China.

1:38:11And this was back when it was, like, whatever it was, 100-something percent tariffs.

1:38:16And he was like, we're going to go out of business because this is their main product.

1:38:20They can't make it another way.

1:38:21He's like, we're going to have to scale down because this decision destroys my business.

1:38:27It's like a guy with a small business.

1:38:28He, like, operates out of his house, right?

1:38:30Like, he's doing what you and I do but with real kind of products and not just words.

1:38:34It's like you're hurting so many people, a lot of people who voted for him.

1:38:39But so many people, because it's not China.

1:38:42It's not India.

1:38:42It's not even Walmart, right?

1:38:44Walmart got yelled at by Trump because they were going to pass it along to their consumers.

1:38:48And they are going to pass it along.

1:38:50And that's the truth, too.

1:38:51It's not Apple who's going to pay these tariffs.

1:38:54I mean, some part of it, yeah.

1:38:56But ultimately, it's going to cause prices to go up.

1:38:59That's, I mean, there's no other way about it.

1:39:03And it really is just simple arithmetic.

1:39:06There was that story that the iPhone costs are going to go up and Apple was going to, like, do some ninja PR work and be like, oh, try not to blame the tariffs.

1:39:17Right.

1:39:17Because they don't want to get that phone call, right?

1:39:20And in a way, Apple's position with the tariffs and the whole global anxiety in the system right now is much more precarious than somebody like Walmart or Target or Home Depot or big box stores.

1:39:35Like, their margins are a lot lower than Apple's.

1:39:38But as long as the products show up to their warehouses, they can still sell them, right?

1:39:44They're going to pass the cost on to the consumer.

1:39:46But if Apple's in a situation where they can't bring their phones in, it's why they were rushing them out of India, to your point, a second ago, right?

1:39:53It's why today I saw a thing at lunch of Apple has a short-term, like, increase on trade-in values on phones.

1:40:03Yeah, yeah.

1:40:05You can't tell me those two stories aren't at least a little bit linked.

1:40:08I saw that.

1:40:10Somebody else sent that to me and said that there's speculation that it's sort of a play to get even just recycled material and stuff ahead of the tariffs.

1:40:17Yeah, I'm sure you've seen this.

1:40:18I definitely have seen this in my email, but also just in friends.

1:40:21People, like, consumer spending has been pushed forward.

1:40:26I think you and Ben have talked about this, too.

1:40:28Like, the Apple stores are really busy right now.

1:40:31Like, people are buying phones who would – they wouldn't wait for the fall because there's going to be –

1:40:35a new one.

1:40:36Those people are going to buy a new phone unless the price doubles.

1:40:39But people who are like, I'm not really due for an upgrade yet, maybe next year, right?

1:40:45People like my wife, Mary, she basically upgrades her phone when she feels like the camera is no good.

1:40:50And usually that's every four years, sometimes a little bit longer.

1:40:52It's that sort of consumer that have been pushed forward by this stuff.

1:40:56And it's because of that anxiety in the system.

1:40:59Yeah, the anxiety is totally rational, right?

1:41:02Where you can guarantee yourself today that if you walk into an Apple store, you can buy today's iPhone 16 whatever model at today's price.

1:41:12And you know how good that camera is.

1:41:14And you don't know how much better the iPhone 17 model is going to be.

1:41:17But the other thing is in the last few years, we kind of – even casual users like both of our wives kind of have the sense of how incremental one-year difference would make camera quality-wise, right?

1:41:30You're not going to get screwed.

1:41:31You're not going to be like, oh, my God, I really made the dumbest mistake of my life buying an iPhone 16 in 2025, right?

1:41:38Because look at the iPhone 17.

1:41:39But do you want to gamble that the price of the phone won't go from $1,200 to $1,400 or $1,500?

1:41:48And knowing that that incremental increase in the quality of the device is to most consumers not worth $200, $300, $400 in price.

1:41:59It's not to them.

1:42:01That's how price and demand works, right?

1:42:05I mean, it's very simple concepts.

1:42:07But people who are like, so why take the chance?

1:42:10Maybe the iPhones will stay at the same price this year.

1:42:12Maybe they'll only go up $100 per tier.

1:42:16But maybe more.

1:42:17Who knows?

1:42:18And Trump certainly isn't calming anybody's anxieties that the tariffs are going to get more predictable.

1:42:25It's bananas.

1:42:26Like I said, I wouldn't trade Tim Cook's problems to a monkey on a rock.

1:42:30Or JAWS, really, because JAWS is the one who might be stuck trying to figure out the narrative to explain, oh, these prices are higher, but look at how much more you get.

1:42:41It's worth it.

1:42:42The last several years, there's this very funny trope in Apple's iPhone keynotes to me.

1:42:47There's the regular iPhone is announced and it's someplace like beautiful and well lit.

1:42:52And then JAWS is staying there at nighttime to introduce the pro phone.

1:42:56It's just very, every year is like, I have a little bet with myself.

1:42:59Are they going to still do it?

1:43:00And they always do.

1:43:01Oh, I bet they do again.

1:43:02Cayenne rants in the daytime for the non-pro phones.

1:43:05But you know it's going to be bad like when she's also in the dark, right?

1:43:10Like the whole iPhone keynotes starts and it's all at night and it's like gloomy looking.

1:43:14Hey, guys.

1:43:15Okay.

1:43:15They've set the mood early.

1:43:18Yeah, that might be what gets JAWS out of nighttime mode.

1:43:20He's just in a pitch black room.

1:43:22Hey, the phone's really expensive.

1:43:24Sorry.

1:43:25I forget if we talked about this on stage in one of the recent years or not because of the on stage shows, the WWDC, not iPhone.

1:43:33But JAWS is a morning person.

1:43:35He likes to wake up very early in the morning and he, I guess, runs on like Tim Cook's schedule.

1:43:40So he hates shooting at night, but he likes the look of it, so they do it.

1:43:47But they actually do shoot those things at night.

1:43:48Pro is nighttime and non-pro is daytime.

1:43:52All right.

1:43:53The bonus round question.

1:43:55Fortnite back in the App Store.

1:43:57Yeah.

1:43:58Man.

1:43:59What's your take?

1:44:00I cannot believe it's been five years since that started.

1:44:04I think I was reading the Verges coverage of it when they're like, oh, it's back.

1:44:08It was like, it's been gone since 2020.

1:44:10But that has to be a typo.

1:44:12Not a typo.

1:44:13It's true.

1:44:13It's been five years.

1:44:14There was a lot of conversation about how the injunction that has opened the door to web payment processing on the App Store.

1:44:20That doesn't really address can Fortnite come back because they did break their developer agreement, right?

1:44:27They did break the contract.

1:44:28That's effectively the contract between Apple and a third party developer.

1:44:32And they submitted it and then Apple sat on it and they had to resubmit it for some technical reasons.

1:44:39It seemed like, but then the judge is like, you guys got to deal with this or you have to come see me next week.

1:44:45And that seemed to get it over the edge.

1:44:47I think ultimately it's good that it's back on the store.

1:44:51I think it makes the iPhone a better platform to have one of the world's most popular games available for it, right?

1:44:57And I think they said this on ATP.

1:44:59It's not original to me, but Apple was making no money from Fortnite for the last five years.

1:45:05And now at least they're going to make some of it.

1:45:07There will be some people who click the in-app purchase, right?

1:45:11If anything, I was thinking about this in context of my own family, because I've got two teenagers, they have iPhones.

1:45:16They, we have the thing set up where they have to ask permission to download an app, right?

1:45:22Even if it's just that mechanism being a requirement in some family setups, Apple's going to make something from Fortnite.

1:45:30And you have the most popular thing back on your phone.

1:45:32And it takes a little bit of the edge off you looking like a jerk.

1:45:36And so I think it's good that it's back.

1:45:38Who knows what the future brings with this stuff.

1:45:40But I do wish Apple had just approved it.

1:45:42I don't like that it took them whatever it was, close to a week.

1:45:47And a judge telling them, figure this out amongst yourselves.

1:45:50It should not have to come to that, I don't think.

1:45:52This is where Apple's willingness to keep its mouth shut pays off, right?

1:45:57They never said anything about Fortnite.

1:45:59The only comment we've seen from Apple about it during the whole, will they, won't they, how's this going to work out, was the letter Apple's lawyers sent to Epic's lawyers that Epic put on Twitter.

1:46:11But I'm sure Apple thought, knowing that Epic has done that in the past, wrote the letter, expecting it to be posted publicly.

1:46:18But without making any public statements, no comments, I often don't ask for comment, but I did right from the first day when Tim Sweeney said that Fortnite would be coming back.

1:46:29Which was bullshit, right?

1:46:31He didn't know.

1:46:31Got a, you know, no comment at this time.

1:46:34If anything changes, we'll let you know.

1:46:36But they didn't really let me know when anything changed.

1:46:38I'm not a lawyer, but I followed this closely up.

1:46:42I'm pretty sure Apple was on perfectly firm legal ground to not reinstate Epic's U.S. developer account.

1:46:48And it was adjudicated in the first trial in 2021 with Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers, where the fact that they had revoked it.

1:46:57And there was a brief time period where, and, you know, they're a big company.

1:47:02I'm not even saying that it's shady.

1:47:03But Epic has multiple developer accounts.

1:47:05Like, there's the one that Fortnite is, the game is published through, was different than the developer account for their game toolkit.

1:47:14Is it Unreal or the other one that Epic does?

1:47:17Yeah, so let's say it's Unreal, but that's a different developer account.

1:47:21And Apple pulled all of them, revoked all of them.

1:47:24So for at least a brief time, it was going to seem as though nobody who's making a game with Unreal Engine for the Mac would even be able to get an updated version of Unreal Engine.

1:47:32And briefly, what she had ruled is it was perfectly fine that because of the blatant violation of the App Store guidelines that the Fortnite developer account was revoked.

1:47:42But Apple, she forced them to reinstate the other ones.

1:47:46And then ultimately, when that trial was over, it just stood.

1:47:50It stood as, yes, this was perfectly legit for Apple to kick Fortnite out of the App Store.

1:47:55And if only Apple had ever conceded on the most blatant anti-steering policy they have, the link outs and the just telling, being able to tell users what to do, right, which is just bananas.

1:48:11It's not just that the Kindle app couldn't put get book buttons next to the book in the iOS Kindle app.

1:48:18They couldn't even put text that says, due to App Store policies, we're not permitted to sell books within this app.

1:48:27To get a Kindle book, visit Amazon.com slash Kindle in any browser, including on this phone, buy them, and they will sync here.

1:48:37They couldn't even tell users that.

1:48:38That was one of the rules, which is bananas.

1:48:41I mean, it's just, it's indefensible.

1:48:44And if they had just conceded on that point, there wouldn't have been anything left for Epic to appeal.

1:48:49It was Epic appealing on link outs and informing users of outside the app deals that this whole thing was on.

1:48:57So if they had conceded that point a few years ago, they would have already had a clean win.

1:49:02And instead, with this one remaining issue, and which her original injunction, clearly what they claim was complying, did not comply with her injunction.

1:49:14I mean, that was one part where I really questioned my, well, I'm not a lawyer, you know, and maybe if I were, I would get it.

1:49:22Because I just remember thinking at the time when Apple came out with all of the crazy scare sheets, and especially the whole scheme of taking 27% of the transit.

1:49:34All right, you can link to the web, but you've got to use a screen that looks exactly like this, that is really scary looking and full of warnings.

1:49:41And then when they do it, you have to track the user for seven days.

1:49:45And anything they purchase, whether it's on their iPhone or any other device, after they've gone from the iPhone, your iPhone app to the website, for seven days, you'll owe us a 27% commission on.

1:49:57And to make sure that you're paying it, you're going to have to open your company's books to our auditors at our request.

1:50:03I mean, the idea that that complied with the plain language of her injunction, which was basically what Apple's now doing.

1:50:10Like, you have to let people put links and buttons that link out to the web and tell people about offers.

1:50:15It really made me question.

1:50:19I really thought, well, Apple's smart and they've got good lawyers.

1:50:21They must know something I don't, because I don't see the plain, I don't see it in this injunction.

1:50:26And one, I think, really, really great part of U.S. law is that if it's not written down, like, in the injunction or the order, it's not real.

1:50:36Like, there shouldn't and couldn't, and it turns out there weren't.

1:50:40It's not like, okay, her injunction makes it seem like they have to put link out buttons and allow apps to inform users of deals outside the web.

1:50:49But maybe, like, in her chambers, she told Apple's lawyers, like, yeah, sure, you know, if you want to make it really hard and impossible, sure, you could do that.

1:50:59I just kind of had to put that there.

1:51:00That's not how U.S. law works.

1:51:01If it's not in the injunction, it's not real.

1:51:04And the injunction made it seem like they have to permit link outs.

1:51:08And it turns out they did.

1:51:10And if they had just conceded that, they would have won on every point.

1:51:12But again, was it worth it anyway?

1:51:15Like, you said, what's, at this point, five years later, what's the point of keeping this incredibly popular game with ongoing enthusiasm out of the store?

1:51:24Yeah.

1:51:25It makes the product worse that that game's not there, right?

1:51:28I mean, so much of the scare sheet stuff, I mean, it all felt so petty.

1:51:34Like, I remember when the design of that was announced.

1:51:37I think it was announced, like, in developer documentation, probably on a Friday.

1:51:41And I remember scrolling through it and being like, this can't actually be what they're doing.

1:51:46Like, this, I mean, it looked ridiculous.

1:51:48And the state, the tracking and the auditing, all of it was so over the top.

1:51:53And to her credit, the judge saw through it, right?

1:51:56It's like, this is not what we, what I told you to do.

1:51:59And if Apple had done the right thing then, they could have, from their perspective, limited the damage to a degree.

1:52:08But now, because they did that, because they tried to hold on to the control, they've lost even more of it.

1:52:14And it's so frustrating as an observer and as someone who likes their products.

1:52:19Y'all are fighting over this.

1:52:20In the grand scheme of things, it's not that big of a deal.

1:52:24Because when you open it up to the web, like, there's been a lot of evidence from companies like Revenue Cat and Superwall.

1:52:30People still are going through the App Store.

1:52:32Like, you actually lose some conversion rate going to the web because people maybe aren't familiar with it.

1:52:38Or they go to the web and they get distracted and they go somewhere else.

1:52:41Or their credit card fails and they just kind of give up.

1:52:43Or it doesn't get autofilled right or it autofills the wrong card.

1:52:47Because, right, so much autofill works in so many places where now if you have to look it up and,

1:52:52Oh, what is the expiration date or the magic CVV numbers on this card?

1:52:56I forget.

1:52:56And you're like, ah, forget it.

1:52:58And so, like you said, you know, you lose, I don't know, some percentage of sales that you otherwise would have gotten in the App Store.

1:53:04Right.

1:53:04It's not all App Store money is going to go away.

1:53:09I think most will.

1:53:10I really don't.

1:53:11I know Marco said, I wish I had the exact quote, but on the last ATP, that, all right, now this is the law in the U.S.

1:53:18And let's say it stands and Apple's emergency injunction to get this revoked so they can take the rule back doesn't happen.

1:53:26And that these link outs continue exactly as they are in the U.S.

1:53:30Three months from now, six months from now, when Apple reports their services revenue, is there any?

1:53:35You're going to be able to see a little downward tick?

1:53:38I don't think so.

1:53:39Or if it is, it'll be like, I don't know, like one pixel in one of Snell's charts.

1:53:43That's right.

1:53:45We'll have to overlay Snell's charts exactly in Photoshop and see what the height difference is.

1:53:49They're going to continue making money.

1:53:52The idea that everybody's going to abandon in-app purchase when it's offered alongside for a 20% discount or whatever they're offering is just as wrong-headedly zealotous as Apple's obstinacy and even permitting it in the first place.

1:54:09The idea that the whole world is looking to get away of consumers or looking to get away from in-app purchase is bananas.

1:54:15They're not.

1:54:16They love in-app purchase.

1:54:17And it's one of the strongest legs Apple has to stand on is it is a very consumer-friendly purchasing system.

1:54:23I actually think, did you see the dual purchase thing Fortnite offered?

1:54:27I did.

1:54:28Yeah, super interesting.

1:54:30Because, you know, Riley with Delta like buried it in a support screen, which is just very funny to me.

1:54:36But yeah, it's on equal footing.

1:54:37Now, they are leveraging the fact that they have other games and other platforms and they have a V-Bucks system, which I'm too old to really understand.

1:54:45But like the beauty of that screenshot is like it's competition, right?

1:54:48Right.

1:54:48It's you have the consumer.

1:54:50I have two choices.

1:54:51There's various pros and cons to each one.

1:54:55Apple could, if they chose to engage in competition here, they could strengthen their position with some developers by making in-app purchase even better, right?

1:55:06They could do something with the commission.

1:55:08They already do offer a lot of flexibility when it comes to subscription and one-time payments and different trial links.

1:55:17There's a lot of tools there in App Store Connect for developers to use.

1:55:20If they were forced to contend with the open web and companies like Stripe and RevenueCat and others building tools, it would make their own payment system better.

1:55:30That's how competition generally works.

1:55:32And because they've never had that on the App Store, like they've never had to.

1:55:40Yeah.

1:55:41And so I don't – you know, who knows?

1:55:43Maybe I'm wrong.

1:55:43Maybe Apple knows something I don't and services revenue will drop noticeably because of this.

1:55:49I don't think so, and I certainly don't think so after Apple adjusts its strategies and commission rates and ideas.

1:55:57If I were in charge of the service revenue at Apple, I would be much more worried about the government versus Google and that $30 billion or whatever it is potentially going away.

1:56:06Well, but I don't think that's – that's not going to vanish, though.

1:56:10Even if it's the most adverse judgment against Google and they're not allowed to pay for not just default placement but any search engine integration, then Apple will switch to something that has some ads that make some number of tens of billions of dollars.

1:56:25I mean, it's not all going to go away.

1:56:28I think the most interesting thing about the – I'm going to try to make it the album art for this chapter in the show so people can just look and see it.

1:56:34But this screenshot that Epic has of what their payment flow looks like, it's, you know, to purchase $2,800 V-Bucks for $23.

1:56:43And you could – there's two buttons.

1:56:45They're the same size.

1:56:46It says choose how to pay.

1:56:48Epic Store.

1:56:49It has their brand name and their logo.

1:56:51And in a small print it says earn 20%, $4.60 back in Epic Rewards.

1:56:57So you get Epic Rewards back.

1:56:59And the other button in all – back to I.O.

1:57:03In all lowercase letters, in-app purchase.

1:57:07And then there's a cancel button underneath.

1:57:10Now, spelling in-app purchase in all lowercase letters and not putting an Apple logo there to show that you're using the Apple system, Epic clearly thinks they're steering people towards the Epic Storm.

1:57:21And maybe it is a little.

1:57:22I think – and it's not – it really just – it's like my cynical mind.

1:57:27I don't know.

1:57:28I don't want Epic Rewards.

1:57:30That seems like a scam and a hassle.

1:57:31But I'm not a gamer.

1:57:32So maybe people who do play do – they know what Epic Rewards are and they want them.

1:57:37But I want cash back, not points, right?

1:57:40Points suck.

1:57:41Like, that's a trap.

1:57:42So I'm kind of thinking, even if I'm a casual user, I'd be very tempted to just hit in-app purchase here.

1:57:49Or at least try it and see what pops up.

1:57:51And then it's the familiar double-click side button and then I've got it.

1:57:54And I'm like, I don't know what the other thing is.

1:57:56I think what's funny about this is that Epic's screen for this is way more generous to in-app purchase than Apple's ScareSheet link-out screens from their original design were to link-outs.

1:58:10Yeah.

1:58:10It's on equal footing, right?

1:58:13Right.

1:58:13You're not going through a screen that's like, hey, you're – I mean, basically, like, your identity may get stolen.

1:58:18They did the thing – the grossest thing to me about it is they used the developer's name instead of the app name.

1:58:26In quotes.

1:58:27In quotes.

1:58:27Right.

1:58:28Yeah.

1:58:28And there's lots of companies that have – like, when I made Vesper, we were Q-Branch LLC, which is a funny little in-joke for the James Bond fans of the world.

1:58:37But there are surely many, many, many Vesper users who had no idea that the company behind Vesper was named Q-Branch.

1:58:45So all of a sudden, if we had had in-app purchase at the time and it says the company Q-Branch LLC wants to charge your credit card on their own, people would be like, what the fuck is that?

1:58:54I'm trying to buy, you know, whatever, upgrade storage for Vesper.

1:58:58And that was a company name.

1:58:59What if you had done it as John Gruber, right?

1:59:01Right.

1:59:01Then does it say John Gruber is going to know what you do after this?

1:59:04And that was one of the embarrassing things that came out in the latest injunction that required this, you know, some of the evidence that Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers included, included the Slack transcripts from Apple employees saying, oh, you know,

1:59:20somebody came up with the idea of putting it as the developer's name and somebody else was like, oh, yeah, the execs are going to love that.

1:59:27That's scary.

1:59:28And it's like, gross.

1:59:29Super gross.

1:59:30Also, Slack is like one of the worst things that's ever happened to big companies.

1:59:36Because it encourages, it encourages, it's like we said before about chat, it encourages a level of flippancy that I don't think email encourages or more formal systems.

1:59:47I don't know that that would have been put into writing using another system of tickets or in-person conversation.

1:59:57And I think people don't think about Slack being like, like Slack logs are stored if you pay for it, right?

2:00:04Oh, this is going to show up in court.

2:00:05Like email, you know not to put the crimes in the email.

2:00:08But I mean.

2:00:09Or even just the embarrassments, right?

2:00:11Even if you don't think it's illegal.

2:00:12It's not illegal to make them put the developer's name in scare quotes, but it sure does look bad.

2:00:18I mean, even at Relay, like between Mike Hurley and myself, like we run Relay on Slack.

2:00:22We got like 50 people in there.

2:00:24But like if it's like decision-making time, we're on the phone, right?

2:00:28Because it's like, we're going to talk through this.

2:00:30We're going to hear how we actually feel about it.

2:00:32A way that text doesn't come across.

2:00:34Yeah.

2:00:35And it's not that you and Mike Hurley are criming, right?

2:00:38No crimes.

2:00:39I promise.

2:00:39I really believe that, Stephen.

2:00:42I truly believe it.

2:00:44But even so, there are times where it's just more natural to spitball ideas without a permanent record of it.

2:00:50It's why Signal and WhatsApp, the disappearing messages are so popular.

2:00:54And it's not just about talking about sex or talking about crimes or talking about sex crimes.

2:01:00There are just certain things that people are more comfortable knowing that this is not permanent.

2:01:06Yeah.

2:01:07The thing, I mean, the Slack messages were definitely gross.

2:01:11The angle to it that keeps rattling around in my head is like that bit about, oh, they're going to love it, right?

2:01:16That someone's boss is going to be pleased with them because of this is like what that says about the culture, at least in that corner of the company.

2:01:23Apple's a huge place.

2:01:25We both know a lot of great people there who I've talked to employees of Apple who don't like how this is going down.

2:01:32But look, seeing the part of the culture that liked this or that was pursuing this or at least doing it because someone above them wanted them to, that's not good.

2:01:44Like it's not, it doesn't jive with the apple that resides in my head all the time.

2:01:49And it ties in, and I don't think he was talking about the App Store.

2:01:53I don't even think he mentioned the App Store, but I linked to a Benedict Evans Threads post of all things.

2:01:58Like I said, sometimes things on Threads come in the news.

2:02:00But Benedict Evans had a great little Threads thread, which is awkward to say, that I linked to.

2:02:07But I, that, you know, that Apple has great customer service and tries to make customers happy.

2:02:16And the same company is famous for squeezing their suppliers every step of the way.

2:02:23Like we were talking about just obtaining enough screws or metal parts to put the computers together.

2:02:28And that somehow they lost sight of the fact that third-party software developers are both customers and suppliers, depending on how you look at them.

2:02:36And not really either, they're just different.

2:02:39But that it's a different sort of relationship, but that they've wound up treating them just like suppliers.

2:02:44And here we are.

2:02:46And I got some pushback from some people at Apple that, oh, no, we don't.

2:02:51And again, it comes back to what I said to you earlier, where it doesn't matter if you're at Apple and you really think it's true that, no, we treat our third-party developers great.

2:03:03Wait till you see what we have to announce next month at WWDC.

2:03:05We've got all this blah, blah, blah.

2:03:07But the truth is that's what developers feel right now.

2:03:11The developer sentiment towards Apple has never been worse.

2:03:15And I've been following this.

2:03:18I've been part of the community for decades at this point.

2:03:22And it's never been worse.

2:03:24And that's a real problem for Apple.

2:03:26Whether they're actually wronging developers or not, the perception is more important than the actual reality.

2:03:34That they should be bending over backwards to repair those relationships and that there is – and again, maybe it's the perfect end of the episode.

2:03:45But another thing, Johnny, I've said in that interview with Patrick Collison, and I have to believe it was something of a very subtle jibe at where Apple has gone in the last 15 years,

2:04:00is the belief that trying to assign a number to everything that actually has value so that you can say six is greater than four, so go with the one that's six.

2:04:12But that there are many parts of design and relationships that you cannot assign a number to, right?

2:04:20How much is the Apple logo worth?

2:04:22You can't put a dollar sign on it.

2:04:25There's no price that anybody could pay to buy the Apple logo from Apple, right?

2:04:32It has tremendous value, but you cannot put a dollar of value on it.

2:04:36And developer relationships are like that.

2:04:40And Apple has squandered so much goodwill that – and you cannot put a dollar amount on it.

2:04:47There's no way to say it's $4.3 billion worth of developer goodwill has been squandered over the last five years because of the App Store policies and commissions or something.

2:04:57You can't do it.

2:04:58But it is valuable.

2:04:59And I do think – I really do.

2:05:02I feel it in my bones.

2:05:03I mean, but you have to go with a bones feeling that they've squandered more developer goodwill from companies big and small down to individuals and up to their biggest peers in the industry.

2:05:17They've squandered more developer goodwill and enthusiasm for creating unique and exclusive software for Apple's platforms than they have squeezed out of the App Store by being – to borrow Princess Leia's – I'll probably butcher this quote too.

2:05:36But the tighter you squeeze, the more systems will slip through your fingers.

2:05:39I mean, look at Vision OS, right?

2:05:43There's lots of complicated reasons that has not taken off as a development platform.

2:05:47But when you talk especially about the big companies, right, it's why would we build for another Apple platform if the deal is just the same?

2:05:58And look at what you did when your last thing really took off.

2:06:01Look at how you've wielded that power over the rest of us.

2:06:06So why would we help you gain another foothold like that in a new field?

2:06:10I mean, it's very – I mean, Zuckerberg talks about it flatly in such terms.

2:06:14And you could say, well, that's competition, not anti-competition.

2:06:19But at a certain level, they blur into each other.

2:06:25And you really can squeeze something so hard that it breaks.

2:06:28Yeah, absolutely.

2:06:30And I think parts of these various concerns we have about Apple currently, parts of them are closer to breaking than others.

2:06:36Some will be easier to fix than others.

2:06:38But the development sentiment has been declining for so long.

2:06:44It's more than just – say a few days before WBC, Phil Schiller just sits down with somebody like, hey, look, we're doing 90-10 across the board.

2:06:51Starting today, you're going to make 20% more money.

2:06:54That would go a long way to a lot of developers.

2:06:56So for a lot of developers, it is about the money.

2:06:58But it's also about respect and the tooling and all these other things.

2:07:04It's very complicated.

2:07:05They've got to unwind a bunch of things to fix it.

2:07:08Yeah, all of a sudden, it would just feel like it's pointing in a different direction.

2:07:12It would make an instantaneous difference to switch to 85-15 or 90-10 or some combination or something like that.

2:07:19And it would take a while for those financial differences to add up.

2:07:24But instantly, it would change the direction that everybody sees Apple pointing in.

2:07:29Yeah.

2:07:29So anyway, that's my ultimate – I mean, I'm not holding my breath for thoughts on the App Store before or after WWDC.

2:07:37But that would be my hope.

2:07:38Yeah.

2:07:39And it's the time, right?

2:07:40It's the time where you have developer attention.

2:07:42Several times over the last few years, they've taken the week before DubDub to announce something, right?

2:07:47Yeah, yeah.

2:07:48Actually, the App Store small business program was an exception to that.

2:07:51That was announced in the fall.

2:07:52I had to look that up the other day.

2:07:53But there have been several times where they've used that sort of – like what, going back to I.O., they did it with Android.

2:07:59They were going to do Android the week before.

2:08:00Yeah, yeah.

2:08:01They have an opportunity when people are paying attention.

2:08:04And if you want developers to be excited about, say, embracing your redesign of your OSs or embracing new technology or a new platform and the foundation is bad, you're never going to get the traction you want.

2:08:18And so they have an opportunity to address some of these things, but I'm not holding my breath either.

2:08:24I just –

2:08:25Right.

2:08:25And it's the sort of thing, too, that would, in my opinion, probably play better as a pre-WWDC announcement just because then they don't have to put it in the keynote.

2:08:35And it's like, yeah, the keynote's supposed to be all celebratory and it's all sunshine and good vibes.

2:08:42And there's no way to talk about reducing the commission in the App Store without it feeling like a concession.

2:08:49I mean, there's – Apple's really good at messaging and they'd be really good at Phil or Joswiak or whoever would get the job to do the sit-down about it.

2:08:59There's a way to do it where it doesn't seem like you're conceding.

2:09:03It's the famous Apple way where it drives people who don't like the company's products nuts where – and Jobs was the best at it is everybody else is doing X.

2:09:12Apple says we're not going to do X and then the next year Apple does X but they say – but they act like they invented it, right?

2:09:19Like somehow come up with a way to make a 90-10 split feel like a grand innovation in online payments.

2:09:26Apple could – if anybody could do it, it's Apple and it will drive the haters crazy, right?

2:09:31It will, but it would make them competitive, right?

2:09:34It would make them competitive with the web and they would, I think, retain more business than they will otherwise.

2:09:40So many of these things are just – they seem so obvious to those of us on the outside, right?

2:09:46All of us for years have been beating the drum about some of these issues.

2:09:50And that can be frustrating over time of like, okay, it's right there.

2:09:56Yeah, it's like they've stuck to principles that there's no advantage to sticking to, whether they're right or wrong about them, right?

2:10:02And it's like the buying books from the Kindle app instead of in the Kindle app or whatever.

2:10:07But the fact that you weren't able to do any of it or even know how to do it, how did they not see that as – this is the example that should have made them say, you know what?

2:10:16We need to rethink a lot of these policies.

2:10:18The fact that there is – under the current policies, there's no way to do this.

2:10:22It's just confusing as hell to a normal user.

2:10:25Normal users, when they can't do something that they think they're supposed to be able to do.

2:10:30And I think a normal user who figures out that they can read Kindle e-books in an app called Kindle on their iPhone and iPad probably thinks there's probably a way that I can buy books here too, right?

2:10:44Because they sell books and that's where I get the books that I am reading somewhere on Kindle.

2:10:47And when they can't figure out how to do it, they blame – a lot of them blame themselves and think, ah, I'm not good at computers.

2:10:55I can't figure it out.

2:10:55I don't know what the hell is going on here.

2:10:57Or maybe they blame Amazon unfairly and think Amazon is just bad at design.

2:11:02Boy, Amazon should just do what the Apple Books app does.

2:11:05Right.

2:11:05Yeah, come on, Amazon.

2:11:06Get with it.

2:11:07Get some buttons in there.

2:11:07Right?

2:11:08They really like losing money.

2:11:09They can't sell books.

2:11:10That obvious fact that casual users, millions of them – I mean, Kindle is so popular.

2:11:16Surely it's tens of millions – I guarantee it.

2:11:19Tens of millions of joint customers of Apple and Amazon who are trying to use the Kindle on the iOS platform have surely blamed themselves for not being able to figure out how to buy books.

2:11:32And that's the exact sort of, ah, I can't figure out how to do X.

2:11:36That's the whole reason Apple Computer exists, is solving that problem for people.

2:11:41I can't figure out how to print.

2:11:42Well, get a Macintosh.

2:11:44It's easy to print.

2:11:45You just connect a cable.

2:11:47I can't figure out how to get on the web on my phone.

2:11:50Get an iPhone.

2:11:50Here, it's Safari.

2:11:52It looks just like the Safari on your computer if you use a Mac.

2:11:56Solving those problems.

2:11:58I can't figure out the secret codes to make text italic.

2:12:01No, it's WYSIWYG.

2:12:02Just select the text and go up to the menu and choose italic.

2:12:06And you'll see it italic right on your screen.

2:12:08All of those problems, that's Apple's real DNA.

2:12:12I mean, I know it sounds corny, but that's what's driven their success.

2:12:15And the idea that they set up a system where tens of millions of Kindle users probably blame themselves for the fact that there weren't get book items or buttons for 15 friggin' years, 16 years in the app, it fundamentally shows it's broken.

2:12:31Whatever they're thinking inside Apple for all those years where they hung on to it, thinking, well, the hell with Amazon.

2:12:36They're a big company.

2:12:37They don't let our app onto their Kindle devices.

2:12:39All true, right?

2:12:41But so what?

2:12:43It's for the user.

2:12:44If it was user first, there would have been get book buttons in 2010 or 2011 or whenever.

2:12:49Or something as simple as if you want a refund from a purchase in the app store and you find the developer's email or you hit the button in their app to contact them.

2:13:00And the developers can't do that.

2:13:02That is on the Apple side of things.

2:13:04And instead of blaming themselves, they're going to blame the developers.

2:13:09No, you just, you rip me off, right?

2:13:10And you end up with a one-star review in the app store because maybe the refund request was completely valid.

2:13:16Maybe they misunderstood or they didn't mean to purchase and they did or the trial ran out and they didn't realize it.

2:13:21There's lots of legitimate reasons for refunds, but Apple's kept that on their side of the deal.

2:13:27You and I know developers, indie developers who are just like regular crafts people or people who run a cafe or something, you know?

2:13:33And it's like if you go into your corner cafe and all they have, you know, and somehow you've prepaid, but all they have is caffeinated coffee, but you can't drink caffeinated coffee.

2:13:44Any normal place run by a small business owner would be like, oh, let me give you your money back.

2:13:48You know, I'm not taking your money.

2:13:49I know developers who people think the app is going to print PDFs upside down, and it turns out the app doesn't do that.

2:13:57Well, then they'll just give the, oh, I'm sorry you thought that it did that.

2:13:59Here, take your money back.

2:14:00Sorry for the confusion.

2:14:01Whatever the future is.

2:14:02That's how the rest of the world works, and the rest of the world is fine, it turns out, in this regard.

2:14:06Yeah.

2:14:08You know, it's, again, they've got tariffs to worry about, but it's not on the App Store, so.

2:14:13Yeah.

2:14:13All right.

2:14:14Oh, man.

2:14:14Let's not go there.

2:14:16Yeah.

2:14:17That's not putting any ideas.

2:14:18Stephen Hackett, thank you for your time.

2:14:21Thank you for joining the show.

2:14:22We covered a lot.

2:14:23Again, 512pixels.net, your website, but also, I mean, you're like the co-founder.

2:14:29What's your title at Relay?

2:14:30Yeah, co-founder at Relay.

2:14:32I host connected and Mac Power users over there each and every week.

2:14:36It would be kind of bizarre if there's anybody out there listening to this show who's not

2:14:40familiar with your podcasting work, but it's, you know, you got to give a shout out.

2:14:44Thanks, Stephen.