0:00:00Patrick McGee, author of Apple in China, you've been doing the rounds lately, you've been
0:00:05on The Daily Show with Jon Stewart, you've been on a bunch of other shows, but now you've
0:00:08hit the big time, you're on the talk show.
0:00:09Hit the big time, yep, this is all culminating here.
0:00:12I was just joking to you pre-show that my show notes for this is a stack of index card
0:00:20bookmarks in the actual book.
0:00:22We'll see how this goes.
0:00:24There's so much to talk about.
0:00:25Is this your first book?
0:00:27Let's talk some authorial stuff.
0:00:30My first book, and based on the sort of strain it took, it might be my last book as well.
0:00:35So your day job, or whatever you want to call it, what's the beat for the Financial Times?
0:00:42It really is the Apple beat, but it includes other hardware, so I would have to cover robo-taxis
0:00:47to some extent, gaming consoles, drones, and so forth.
0:00:50But in a way, if I just described that, it still wouldn't really tell you the story of
0:00:54how I got involved in this topic.
0:00:55And the short version is that I've been at the FT for 12 years, and it was in Hong Kong,
0:00:59where I basically got to understand China, Germany, where I was covering the auto industry,
0:01:03so I was in and out of factories and understanding supply chain, and then Apple, right?
0:01:06And the book is sort of the culmination of those three beats.
0:01:08Yeah.
0:01:09And so you have been reporting on Apple and its supply chain and financial stuff.
0:01:16I mean, you write for the Financial Times, so obviously, and we'll get to some of the issues
0:01:20like the, what was it, the five alarm fire in 2018, the financial issues for how long?
0:01:29I covered Apple for four years before I took off two years to write the book.
0:01:32All right.
0:01:33And then you took two years off to write the book.
0:01:36Like, at what point did you think this is a book-length thing?
0:01:40It was when I reported the two-part series for the FT, the first of which was called How Apple
0:01:45Tied Its Fortunes to China.
0:01:46And Chris Miller, author of Trip War, essentially said, have you thought of turning this into
0:01:51a book?
0:01:52And I guess the sort of disconnect that I was excited by is that I knew that I was only
0:01:57scratching the surface in those articles.
0:01:59I mean, that was 6,000 words.
0:02:00It was the longest thing I'd ever written for one package, as it were.
0:02:03And yet some of the best stories couldn't be included because I didn't have the sourcing
0:02:08on them yet.
0:02:08And I also just knew that I'd just begun to really get involved with what are called manufacturing
0:02:13design engineers, who in my mind had really never been written about.
0:02:16You could argue they're as important as industrial design, which we know kind of everything
0:02:20about, and yet there'd just been no ink spilled on these guys.
0:02:23And so I was just really intrigued by them and their mission.
0:02:26And sorry if I'm getting ahead of myself here, but like they're the people who sort of take
0:02:29Johnny Ives' ideas, let's say, and then go to Asia to work with the factories, hand in
0:02:33gloves, dozens at first, later hundreds, to really audit, train, supervise, and install
0:02:38hundreds of millions of dollars worth of machinery into other people's facilities to really actually
0:02:42build what the design studio had come up with.
0:02:45I mean, if you just think of the topography of Aperol, if you were not including MD,
0:02:50you're just not getting the full picture.
0:02:51And I realized we just ignored them.
0:02:53And so there was a book there.
0:02:54Yeah.
0:02:55And I am to understand that you wrote the book in Apple Notes.
0:02:59I did.
0:03:00Yeah.
0:03:00I don't know if I told you that directly, but I don't know if it's the first book written
0:03:04in Apple Notes.
0:03:04I think it's an underrated app.
0:03:06And the key thing is that it's end-to-end encrypted.
0:03:08I'm always a little fascinated because I've never written a book.
0:03:13I don't know that I ever will, but I certainly write a lot of words and it's been on my mind
0:03:19for a long time.
0:03:21And I think Apple Notes is vastly underrated from people who formed their impression of
0:03:30it in the very early iPhone years when it was like an iPhone app that sort of kind of synced.
0:03:36It was like in the early years, it's it's synced via IMAP, the email protocol, which was really
0:03:42weird.
0:03:42And it was sort of a shortcut to getting a sync engine.
0:03:45But like, I don't want to get too sidetracked on this, but because it was syncing over IMAP,
0:03:52if you used a Mac.com address, and this was before iCloud was sort of your magic keys to
0:03:58the Apple sync kingdom, it worked really well for sync because Apple knew to get their IMAP
0:04:04email servers ready for notes.
0:04:07But the difference between a note and an email is a note you update, right?
0:04:11Like you start a note.
0:04:12Yeah.
0:04:13And then you come back to it and add some more.
0:04:15And most of the time with email, you don't.
0:04:19And I guess by 2025, a lot more email systems have the concept of live drafts where you don't
0:04:25really have to save a draft.
0:04:26But back in like 2009, if you were using like a Gmail account through Apple Notes to sync your
0:04:32notes, every time you made a change, you'd get a new note.
0:04:35Right.
0:04:36So if you just wrote a note and wrote the word one, close it, come back later, hit return,
0:04:43add the word two.
0:04:45Well, now you've got two notes, one that just says one and the one that says one, two.
0:04:49And people were like, and I think a lot of people just sort of walked away.
0:04:53In the modern iCloud sync world, Apple Notes, to me, I live a lot of my life through it.
0:04:59I really do.
0:05:00So I think it's fascinating that you wrote the book in it.
0:05:03It's a fantastic app.
0:05:04But the security of the app, I think, is probably the drawing point today.
0:05:07Obviously, I used multiple devices.
0:05:09And so the idea that you could do a voice note or something into the app and then pick it up
0:05:13where you left off next time you were in the office, that was kind of ideal.
0:05:15Right.
0:05:16And, you know, not that you're writing a spy thriller, but it's quite obvious that a lot
0:05:21of your sources needed to, especially in China, maybe it is sort of like a spy thriller.
0:05:27You mean in terms of confidentiality?
0:05:29Confidentiality.
0:05:30Yeah.
0:05:30Yeah.
0:05:31That's why N10 Encrypted was so important.
0:05:34Yeah.
0:05:34I've read, and you obviously have too, because you cite a bunch of them.
0:05:38There's a bunch of us old timers in the Mac media who've read a lot of books about Apple.
0:05:43And I seldom regret having read a book about Apple.
0:05:49There's good ones and bad ones.
0:05:51But I would say one of the telltale problems I have with most of the books I read about Apple
0:06:00is they feel padded out.
0:06:01If it's a 300-page book, it feels like a 100-page book with about 200 pages to make it thick enough
0:06:09to sell in an airport.
0:06:10Books.
0:06:11Yeah.
0:06:12I do think that's true of most books.
0:06:15But I feel like with my domain expertise with Apple, I can really smell it.
0:06:21And this book is as dense as all of your reporting.
0:06:25And I'm not just saying that because you're kind enough to come on the show.
0:06:28I really mean that.
0:06:29This book is intensely packed.
0:06:33Yeah.
0:06:33No, I mean, it is.
0:06:34And I had someone like you in mind when I was writing, which is that I wanted an Apple nerd
0:06:40to be in a Barnes & Noble, open a book, and say, do we really need a book about Apple?
0:06:44I just decided to glance at the table of contents.
0:06:46And I wanted them to be like, what the hell is the sewing machine repair shop?
0:06:51What's the yellow cows in the gray market?
0:06:53What does five alarm fire refer to?
0:06:55I mean, I didn't want it to be so opaque as to be intimidating.
0:06:58But I was hoping that if you flip to a random page, you would be like, I don't even know the
0:07:02characters that are here.
0:07:04Yeah.
0:07:04So I would strenuously avoid any supply chain story, let's say, or even any Apple story
0:07:09that had been told before the idea of Tim Cook telling Sabi Khan, why are you still here?
0:07:15I mean, that's in four different books and any number of profiles.
0:07:17So it's a good anecdote, but it's been used so many times.
0:07:20I don't want to use it.
0:07:21The only thing I had to do is like some handholding.
0:07:24Like, of course, I need to introduce what the iPod was, what the iPhone is.
0:07:27But I'm trying to do that in an original way before I get to all the new stuff.
0:07:32Yeah, and the historical stuff is there and it's good.
0:07:35And I feel like it's all, ah, but how did Apple get where they're going, right?
0:07:43It's all sort of concentrated historically on, OK, in this time period, how was Apple, how
0:07:51and where was Apple assembling its computers and why?
0:07:54And was there even a why?
0:07:57Or they were just like, I don't know.
0:07:59That's just where we've always done them.
0:08:00We've done them in Fremont, California.
0:08:02Or whatever the story was going far enough back in time.
0:08:05And it's necessary stage setting for where Apple got to, in my opinion.
0:08:12And I know, and this is something I'm very sensitive to now that I've been writing Daring Fireball
0:08:17over 20 years, that a lot of the stuff that I still think of is kind of new isn't new to
0:08:24a lot of readers, right?
0:08:26The whole iPod is sort of a flash, right?
0:08:30It was like it came out in 2001.
0:08:32And by 2007, when the iPhone debuted, they didn't stop selling them then, but it's sort
0:08:38of clearly obviated it, right?
0:08:40So it really only had six years in the sun.
0:08:42I think its biggest year for volume is actually 2010.
0:08:45So, I mean, obviously it begins to be cannibalized.
0:08:47And yet the growth is still pretty stunning really through that whole decade.
0:08:51But yeah, like my biggest fear, I think it's something you just alluded to, is that when
0:08:54I submitted the book, I mean, I didn't have a whole lot of contact with my publisher.
0:08:57They sort of sort of let me be for this initial 12 months off in which I wrote the whole thing.
0:09:01And when I submitted it, my biggest fear was they were going to be like, Apple doesn't really
0:09:06go to China in a big way until 2003.
0:09:08So let's get rid of your first two parts, your first seven or eight chapters, because
0:09:13here you are talking about Korea, Czech Republic, Mexicali, all these places that are making
0:09:18Apple products.
0:09:19But this isn't China.
0:09:20Let's just get to the China stuff.
0:09:21And I think probably some readers are encountering that as well, that they get this book called
0:09:26Apple in China.
0:09:26And like China doesn't really emerge until page 90.
0:09:28But the reason why is that you had to understand just how unique and helpful China was with
0:09:37its billion plus people of laborers, its tailor-made policies.
0:09:40You had to understand that Apple really experimented in about eight or nine countries with contract
0:09:45manufacturers.
0:09:46And it's not maybe not that they failed.
0:09:49That's a little bit harsh, but they hadn't wildly succeeded.
0:09:52And like that sort of archetypal example is the iMac G4, the one that looks like a sunflower
0:09:56or a Pixar lamp, right?
0:09:58That's built out of Taiwan, but with help from Southeast Asia, China, and Japan.
0:10:02And it really is like a disaster.
0:10:04And just the historical record is that they don't have them on time.
0:10:08Steve Jobs has to announce that the price on all three models is being bumped up by $100.
0:10:12I mean, that was a bit of a catastrophe.
0:10:15And then you think about the problems with the G4 Cube.
0:10:17They didn't have a great maintenance record either.
0:10:19My wife owned one, and then it's like the sunflower started drooping after a while.
0:10:25And it wasn't like my wife abused it, but, you know.
0:10:28Yeah, well, I mean, exactly.
0:10:30So once you understand how problematic every other region is, then it sort of gives you
0:10:35the sense of why China is so important.
0:10:37The other thing, of course, is that, you know, journalism, you say show, don't tell.
0:10:42And so I have multiple chapters where I'm just showing you how obsessive they are over the
0:10:48details and how insane the designs are and that nobody has the skills to actually build
0:10:53these without Apple hand-holding them.
0:10:55And even Apple doesn't know how to build them.
0:10:56They've got engineers that are like, like, I was told the ideal engineer responding to
0:11:00ID is saying, I have no fucking idea how to build that, but I'm going to do my best to
0:11:05try.
0:11:05Right?
0:11:06And then they would go over to Asia to go do that.
0:11:08So some people have taken it as a knock on China that I'm saying China offered nothing
0:11:12and Apple built China or something.
0:11:14And that's obviously a caricature of my argument.
0:11:16My point is that China offered things no other country had and was in best position to sort
0:11:21of work with Apple to get this done.
0:11:23But unless you understand the failures of every other region before then, you don't
0:11:28understand the significance of that partnership.
0:11:29All right.
0:11:30Let me take a break here and thank our first sponsor of the show.
0:11:32It's a brand new sponsor.
0:11:33And I am, oh my God, I love this company.
0:11:36I just had lunch from their product.
0:11:37Factor.
0:11:38Make this your best season yet with nutritious two-minute meals from Factor.
0:11:43Eating well has never been this easy.
0:11:45You just heat them up and enjoy and it gives you more time to do what you want.
0:11:48These are like prepackaged meals.
0:11:50It's not like ingredients and then you go cook them.
0:11:53These are meals.
0:11:54They're sealed up.
0:11:54You pick them.
0:11:56You heat them up.
0:11:57Honestly, just put them in a microwave like two, three minutes.
0:12:00That's all you do.
0:12:01The instructions are right there.
0:12:02Each week, they have 45 weekly menu options.
0:12:06You can pick gourmet meals that fit your goals.
0:12:08They have everything from categories like calorie smart, protein plus, lots of keto and more.
0:12:14And they've got great breakfast.
0:12:16They've got on-the-go lunches.
0:12:18I just had a meatball mashed potatoes, sun-dried tomatoes thing.
0:12:23Ah, so good.
0:12:24Just the right portion size, too.
0:12:26Really good.
0:12:26They also have guilt-free snacks and desserts.
0:12:29It is easy to savor more this spring.
0:12:31Factor meals pack in the flavor with none of the fuss.
0:12:36Really good food.
0:12:38My wife is loving them, too.
0:12:39Already running low from what they send us for the sponsorship.
0:12:42And I've got to order more.
0:12:44I mean it.
0:12:45I'm eating them, and I really like them.
0:12:47Go get started at factormeals.com slash talkshow50off.
0:12:55That's 5-0 for the 50.
0:12:57Use that code, talkshow50off.
0:13:01Talkshow50off.
0:13:02And that code means you get 50% off just for listening to the show.
0:13:08Plus free shipping on your first box.
0:13:10So use that code, talkshow50off at factormeals.com slash talkshow50off for 50% off, plus free shipping.
0:13:19Reading URLs on a podcast is always a bit of a challenge.
0:13:26I've been doing it a long time, though.
0:13:27One of the little anecdotes that I've been writing about this, and I guess that this is the other thing.
0:13:34So you spent a full year writing the book, then another year, I guess, editing, working on it, figuring out, et cetera, et cetera.
0:13:42Then the book is ready, or I forget when you first told me that it was coming out, like December, something like that.
0:13:49There's like this frustrating months-long waste in the book publishing world, which would drive me crazy.
0:13:57Because when I'm ready to publish, I mean, I don't know about you at the FT, but me as the one-man show at Daring Fireball, I hit publish, and then it's on my website like three seconds later.
0:14:08And I'm sort of used to that.
0:14:10Like when in my gut, I've done my last proofread, I'm like, this is good to go.
0:14:14I should publish this.
0:14:15Boom, it's up there.
0:14:16Meanwhile, you've got this book done, and then you've got to wait till May for it to come out?
0:14:21Yeah, the first draft was submitted in September, and then the edits came back.
0:14:26And then I added two chapters.
0:14:28I cut 20,000 words, and then Trump was elected.
0:14:31So that, of course, sort of caused me to upend the conclusion a little bit.
0:14:34And other things happened, like Morris Chong was interviewed, the founder of TSMC, I think by the Acquired podcast, and he had some great insights into the TSMC relationship with Apple.
0:14:42So I updated it with various things, but I actually came to really value the sort of eight months that I had because I got to create real distance.
0:14:51I'm not thinking about Apple for three weeks and then read the whole manuscript from front to back and just catch little errors or you would solidify your understanding of something.
0:14:59I mean, I actually felt like I got new forcing after the manuscript and sort of solved certain riddles that I didn't know the answers to that I ended up thinking.
0:15:08Like the big one being why China attacks Apple on consumer day.
0:15:11I hadn't linked that with the whole narrative of the yellow cows.
0:15:14I'm sort of jumping ahead of myself here, so I won't go into it.
0:15:17But I sort of solved that, as it were, after the first manuscript was submitted.
0:15:21So I really came to respect and value the time that I had to get away from it and then be able to read it with fresh eyes.
0:15:28And there's this serendipity and without getting into the, well, who'd you vote for, politics of it.
0:15:35But Trump did win the election.
0:15:37I'm not sure if you've heard.
0:15:39And he's pursued in some ways and as promised for years campaign of instituting tariffs, especially higher ones against China.
0:15:55And I think there's a general consensus that the broader, let's say, investor world had sort of chalked that up to, well, Trump's been yapping about tariffs and trade deficits his entire adult life.
0:16:12He was already the president for four years from 2016 to 2020 and didn't do anything nutty with tariffs.
0:16:21He's not going to do anything nutty with tariffs again, but Trump 2.0 is running very differently than Trump 1.0.
0:16:29And within, I don't know, a month or two of coming into office, he instituted what most people would consider some pretty nutty tariffs, including against China.
0:16:40And affecting very significantly with lots of news coverage, a company called Apple, who makes a lot of products in China.
0:16:49And meanwhile, you've got this book you've already been working on two years that is ready to come out and explain a lot of this.
0:16:55I mean, it's kind of amazing.
0:16:57I mean, what were you?
0:16:58Spectacular.
0:16:59And like the timing wasn't even just that.
0:17:02I mean, that was by far the biggest one.
0:17:03So I won't be your own summary there.
0:17:06But the other thing was that the entire time I was off, of course, you're terrified that someone of the Wall Street Journal or whatever decides, hey, I'm going to write my own 6,000 word feature on Apple's China problem.
0:17:15But instead, ChatGPT and AI was just such a story that I feel like every enterprising reporter in tech just covered AI the entire time I was off.
0:17:24And the China issue just got ignored.
0:17:26I mean, there were three major interviews of Tim Cook while I was on Bookly with Wired, the Wall Street Journal, and I think Vanity Fair.
0:17:34And I mean, honestly, China doesn't come up with any of them, certainly not China as an entity that's a threat to Apple.
0:17:39Maybe you've got Xiaomi or something coming up.
0:17:41But the degree to which the topic was just ignored the entire time I was laser focused on it was a real boom.
0:17:47Yeah, it must have been.
0:17:49And I would have that same anxiety, too.
0:17:51And especially, I feel it when I'm writing a long article, which is the longest thing I've ever written.
0:17:59But if I'm spending a couple of weeks on an article and I come upon an angle that I feel like, hey, this is a good angle.
0:18:09I've got something here.
0:18:10I just become obsessed that it's so obvious that somebody's going to beat me to the punch.
0:18:15Yeah, I'll just point out a couple of months ago, I wrote a piece that something's rotten in the state of Cupertino.
0:18:21Yeah, great article.
0:18:22Thank you.
0:18:22The linchpin of it was the clarity in hindsight that all of the Siri features that Apple wound up postponing for another year in March, just a few months ago, none of those were actually demoed to us in the media at WWDC last year.
0:18:40And all the features they did demo to us for Siri and Apple Intelligence were all the stuff that has shipped over the last eight, nine months.
0:18:48And I was like, well, this is bananas.
0:18:50Like, why in the world?
0:18:52And I was so mad at myself.
0:18:53But then I thought, well, surely there must have been like a dozen articles pointing out that these features weren't demoed at WWDC last year.
0:19:01And I've searched and nobody wrote.
0:19:03I was like, huh, I got something.
0:19:06So your book is filled with stuff like that, where I'm sure you were thinking, this is such a good story.
0:19:12And then you're sourcing it and you're like, oh, there's a bunch of people who know about this, right?
0:19:17Raising an example of that is the chapter you recently alluded to called Five Alarmed Fire, which is, I think it's chapter 36.
0:19:24I mean, this is late in the book, but basically, Apple is sued in 2019 and settles just last September.
0:19:32They pay $500 million.
0:19:33And the allegations that they lied to investors about the state of Chinese demand, in particular for the iPhone XR.
0:19:38Well, as part of this court case, there's all sorts of discovery.
0:19:43More than 1,000 pages are just made public.
0:19:46And I discovered them last February, like 16 months ago.
0:19:49And I spent some 60 hours going through all these documents.
0:19:52We're talking internal emails between Tim Cook and his deputies.
0:19:55Media strategy, once the Nikkei had sort of scooped that the iPhone XR was doing poorly.
0:20:01Depositions of Tim Cook and Luca Mastri, the CFO, among four or five other VPs of finance and sales.
0:20:06I mean, just all kinds of stuff.
0:20:08Competitive analysis of Huawei as a rival.
0:20:11And to have this so early and realize, am I going to be able to write this, submit it, have it be going through edits for eight or nine months and then be published and still be first?
0:20:20Is that even possible?
0:20:22And that is what happened.
0:20:23But, I mean, I couldn't bank on that.
0:20:25I didn't know that.
0:20:25I was terrified.
0:20:26Yeah, it's kind of crazy in hindsight.
0:20:31And your reporting makes it very clear that it really was incredibly worrisome.
0:20:36And we can talk about it now.
0:20:37I mean, there's no point not panicking for weeks.
0:20:40I mean, we're talking about the two biggest telecom giants in China are literally telling Apple, stop sending us these phones.
0:20:46We're not selling them.
0:20:47We don't want the inventory.
0:20:48You've already sent us too many of them.
0:20:51Yeah.
0:20:51The thing is revenue for Apple to ship the phones.
0:20:53That's all they need to sort of get it off their books.
0:20:55And so the telecoms are saying, I don't want any more of these.
0:20:57And like, they're threatening to withhold payment.
0:20:59And so it's the reason it's called Five Alarm Fire, which is when more than 100 firefighters are called to a scene, is this is how a VP describes it in an email to another colleague.
0:21:07And when Tim Cook gets a new estimate, a full five, maybe six days before going to earnings, going to the earnings call and essentially telling investors everything is fine.
0:21:15He says, this is a disaster.
0:21:16We need all hands on deck now.
0:21:19And there are all sorts of emails like this.
0:21:21I mean, loads of people are just completely understanding that this is a disaster.
0:21:24And one day after earnings is when the operations team literally slashes iPhone XR production for the next five months.
0:21:32So it's like they understand that this product is a dud.
0:21:36And it's happening within 24 hours of Tim Cook basically telling the board that things are fine, which is interesting.
0:21:41I've been emailed from Tim Cook to the board of directors and telling investors that things are fine.
0:21:45And in case I'm just not getting ahead of myself with the reader here, eight weeks later, Tim Cook issues the first revenue warning in 16 years.
0:21:51Yeah.
0:21:51So the historical context was 2017, 10 years after the original iPhone, Apple came out with the iPhone X.
0:22:00Yeah.
0:22:00But alongside the iPhone X, they had the iPhone 8 and 8 Plus, which were like sort of hedging their bets, you know, and they had the same whatever the A13 or A10 chip or whatever it was at the time.
0:22:15But the iPhone X was the one that introduced what we now think of as the modern iPhone design.
0:22:22Face ID, no home button on the front, no touch ID, all screen design.
0:22:28And the iPhone 8 looked like an iPhone 7, which looked like the iPhone 6, which sort of looked like the iPhone 6S, which looked like the iPhone 5, except going back to the original iPhone.
0:22:40Then the next year, but it was weird timing, and I'd forgotten this until recently too, is that the year 2017, when the iPhone 8 and the X came out, they introduced them at the same time in September.
0:22:55But the iPhone X didn't actually ship until November.
0:22:59It was very, must have been that aggressive an engineering challenge just to get it out in that year.
0:23:06And so I didn't even publish my review of the iPhone X until December because I was like, well, if it didn't ship until November, I might as well take my time reviewing it.
0:23:15Very strange year.
0:23:16It's just not the usual pattern of, hey, Apple announces these things in the second Tuesday of September, and those of us who get review units get one in the next day or two, and we review them in the next week, and then they go on sale that Friday or something like that.
0:23:34Well, you're inadvertently describing sort of the significance of China's speed because you're saying it took you until December to write a comprehensive review.
0:23:40And for the Chinese rivals to iPhone, it only takes them to November, so five months after the thing is actually shipping, to basically come out with their own versions of an infinity pool style design.
0:23:50And Apple executives in China are, like, flummoxed, like, how quickly these four big Chinese rivals are able to come up with it.
0:23:59And so they're sending notes back to Cupertino, and a VP of finance at the time says something like, I think Q3 is going to be really difficult for us.
0:24:06So even though the fire alarm fire narrative is just three weeks, like, it actually extends another six months beyond that.
0:24:11Before that, I should say, where Apple executives are realizing, like, oh, like, we've come full circle.
0:24:16Like, we've trained up these suppliers, and now they're coming up with rival phones, like, at a time when we thought we'd be basking in the halo of the iPhone X, they're already replicating it.
0:24:24I'll bet, and I forget if your book addresses this, I'll bet part of that isn't just the time from September 10th when Apple publicly unveils it till November.
0:24:36It's the fact that so much leaks out of the supply chain and the whole industry of everyone from case makers to rival phone makers in China is so insanely, intensely interested in what is Apple going to do with the phone next year and the year after and stuff like that.
0:24:56I mean, like, the rampant, rampant rumors for the last, I don't know, at least two years that this year coming in September, that Apple is going to introduce a radically thin iPhone, right?
0:25:08Samsung already came out with their radically thin phone a month or two ago because the rumors have been out for a while.
0:25:14Can I just ask, though, as a person who loves Apple products, has the thinness of the phone ever been a problem for you?
0:25:20Like, never have I said, God, I wish this was half the size.
0:25:22That's a good question and a very good digression.
0:25:26And people have been asking that of Apple devices every step of the way since that Steve Jobs came back to the company in 1997.
0:25:37I guess it was a couple of years because the, and I want to talk about the first iMac, which was notable and famous and it's in design museums, but wasn't because it was thin or light.
0:25:49And in fact, the fact that it weighed 40 pounds and had a handle was, makes for a fascinating chapter in your book.
0:25:55But when Apple did start making products thinner, people would, people always say that.
0:26:02What's the advantage, you know?
0:26:04And so many people have said over the years with iPhones, I think it was the iPhone 6, not the 6S.
0:26:11I think it was the 6S, that had the, quote, bend the gate, where people who would put the phone, particularly if they were prone to putting it in, like, their rear pants pocket.
0:26:20And if they sat on it, it didn't really have as much tension, strength, whatever you want to flick.
0:26:27It was prone to bending with, with, with, you can bend it with your hands.
0:26:31And there were YouTubers who would just buy one, open it up and on YouTube, just bend it.
0:26:37And it was a bit of a scandal.
0:26:39So why make it that thin?
0:26:41Why, why go so thin that it could bend?
0:26:43Why not just make it thicker?
0:26:45And then if you could make the phone that thin, why not just keep it as thick as it was and just fill the extra space with more battery?
0:26:52And now you could go two days.
0:26:53Better battery life for thinnest any day of the week.
0:26:55So that would be sort of one point as a consumer.
0:26:58But as a reporter, I just think this sort of gets into my argument, like, sort of implicit to the book, that we're covering this company wrong.
0:27:04I mean, it's one thing to have product reviewers, and that's what they do, and I get that.
0:27:08But there's way too much sort of intellectual resources, media resources devoted to, like, Apple scoops that are basically just pressing fast forward on Apple's own press releases, right?
0:27:16In other words, things that we're going to find out.
0:27:18Let's reward them as stuff that they don't want to tell us.
0:27:21Yeah.
0:27:21Well, I think with the thinness, though, what it is is inside Apple, and it definitely comes from Steve Jobs' DNA, that he wanted stuff to be thinner and lighter than it could possibly be.
0:27:33And if you don't just have the urge to make things by the standards of what's already on the market a new thing that seems ridiculously thin, then no one's ever going to make them thinner, right?
0:27:46If it wasn't for Apple driving the whole industry towards thinness for, I would say, 25 years at this point, I think all of our consumer electronics would actually be quite a bit thicker and heavier and chunkier.
0:28:00And the difference, I would say, is that under – and part of it, it's a counterfactual, you just can't imagine.
0:28:09What would have happened if Steve Jobs hadn't gotten cancer or if he had stayed ahead of the cancer for another five or ten years while Apple became so much bigger of a company?
0:28:22Like, it's just absurd how tiny Apple was in terms of how many products they sold when Steve Jobs died, 2010, 2011, compared to now.
0:28:32And so I think some of the proliferation of products – people often complain about Tim Cook that he used to brag, hey, every single product we make, we could put on one table in an Apple store.
0:28:46And I could explain this to you.
0:28:47And they've kind of gotten past that point.
0:28:50It would be a very crowded table if they put one of everything on a table.
0:28:54And people are like, they should go back to that.
0:28:55But it's really kind of hard to be a $3 trillion company that only sells that many products.
0:29:01So I think even if Jobs had been around for longer or were still around, I think Apple would do this.
0:29:08But in the Jobs era, he would just get rid of the old thing and say, here's the new iPhone, and the only new iPhone is this super crazy thin one.
0:29:16And people would be like, wow, that is crazy thin.
0:29:22And then you'd go home and use it for a couple of days, and you'd be like, I have to charge it at 730 at night or whatever the problem is.
0:29:28You know, my one counterfactual to this is that's not what he did with iPods.
0:29:31Sometimes it was.
0:29:34They did it with the iPod Mini going to the iPod Nano, where they were just like, we're just going to get rid of these, and you're going to lose space.
0:29:40So instead of five or six gigabytes, you're only going to get one gigabyte because we're going to flash memory.
0:29:45But at some point, I forget the stat, but I think someone said there was a from $50 to $550, there was an iPod available at every $50 increment, right?
0:29:54So you're going from the Shuffle to the Classic to the Mini, or I guess to the Mini to the Classic, to the iPod Photo to the iPod Video, and maybe to the iPod Video with 40 gigabytes or something.
0:30:04So to some extent, you would say like the iPhone proliferation actually hasn't even gotten to that complexity.
0:30:09And that was, of course, under Jobs.
0:30:10Yeah.
0:30:11So I think it started under him.
0:30:14And I think, assuming that the pervasive rumors are true, that it's going to be a regular iPhone 17, but no plus size anymore.
0:30:22An iPhone 17 Pro and an iPhone 17 Pro Max.
0:30:27So, so far, just like the last five, six years.
0:30:29But then the fourth new iPhone will be this iPhone 17 Air that is ridiculously thin and perhaps only has one camera on the rear.
0:30:40At a sort of premium price, probably.
0:30:42It's interesting.
0:30:44And again, maybe it'll turn out like the iPhone Minis, right?
0:30:49Which they only made for two years and turned out not to be that popular.
0:30:52And then they were just moved away.
0:30:54But I wouldn't buy them.
0:30:55I think that's how a lot of people feel about them.
0:30:58Yeah, and I know other people who bought the 13 Mini, the last one.
0:31:03And I don't know how many are still holding on to it now, but I know some are.
0:31:07And I'm sure I'll hear from them as they listen to the podcast where they so desperately don't want to give it up.
0:31:14But I think that's the thinking, though, is that there will still be, if you don't care, if you're like, I don't care how thin it is.
0:31:20I just want the battery life.
0:31:21They're like, go ahead and buy the brand new 17 Pro and Pro Max.
0:31:24That's what I think.
0:31:25Right.
0:31:26Back to the book.
0:31:28I thought this was really interesting from the prologue, where back in 2012, the value of Apple-owned machinery in the country, which is China, had soared to $7.3 billion, more than Apple's U.S. buildings and retail stores put together.
0:31:45Apple had essentially cracked the code on how to manufacture the world's best products without doing any of the manufacturing itself.
0:31:52It wasn't really outsourcing in the normal sense, that it would be sending blueprints to companies capable of taking the orders and executing.
0:31:58Instead, Apple was routinely sending its top engineers, designers, procurement specialists, and lawyers from the United States into hundreds of factories across China, where they would import machinery, train armies of workers, coordinate the delivery of intermediate goods, and scrutinize suppliers to ensure compliance.
0:32:15Apple's influence was enormous, but no senior executives lived in China or understood the politics.
0:32:21As far back as 2012, Apple owned more equipment in China than all of their real estate holdings in the United States, which in the stores were already getting pretty popular at that point, yet it still doesn't really own.
0:32:39They owned equipment, and they owned operations.
0:32:43I don't even know what you'd call it, but they didn't really own the factories, right?
0:32:46And I've known some of this, but to really have it spelled out like that, that they own $7.3 billion in equipment, but didn't own the factories or the plants or the real estate, is kind of bananas.
0:32:58Well, I guess the significance of the narrative is that China didn't really know that either, the political leadership in China, I mean.
0:33:05And so they just see this company that's really operating under the radar, and they know that the Chinese youngsters, the next generation in particular, really buying the iPhone.
0:33:13I mean, they're absolutely clamoring to buy this thing.
0:33:15And this is part four of the book.
0:33:16It's my favorite part of the whole narrative, intake, people demand in China.
0:33:19The hardliners in Beijing are against this.
0:33:21It's like the iPhone represents individualism, materialism, and the West, all the things that they're happy to crush.
0:33:27So that's sort of one element.
0:33:29But the other element is that because Apple is orchestrating events from afar, but just having people fly in and then visit these factories that don't have Apple logos on them, like local cadres, Beijing, they don't really understand what Apple's doing.
0:33:41So they're basing their view that Apple's an exploitative company on public data, because if you look at something like Foxconn margins, this kind of blew me away.
0:33:48In the first four years of the Apple-Foxconn partnership, in absolute dollars, Foxconn is the one making more profit.
0:33:54And their margins begin in double digits, and then they sort of collapse to around 2% the more they work with Apple.
0:34:01And Apple's margins at the same time start at around 1%, and they go to 25%.
0:34:05This is net margins.
0:34:07So it makes sense that if you're China, you're like, wait a minute, this is a company that's just exploiting our companies, exploiting our workers, paying minimum wage and whatnot, and they're getting everything out of it.
0:34:16And the sort of thesis of the narrative is the degree to which Apple, these eight executives called the Gang of Eight, sort of appointed to beat the senior people living in China, they flipped the narrative on its head to explain to Beijing, you don't understand, we're giving tuition-free training of the Ivy League equivalent of hardware engineering, just hundreds of factories.
0:34:35And we're playing this instrumental role, bringing up Chinese suppliers, who in turn are bringing up Huawei, Oppo, Xiaomi, Vivo, etc.
0:34:43Such that if I fast forward to today, the Chinese brands just mentioned, collectively have 55% market share globally for the smartphone.
0:34:49So that's like just a stunning narrative that I just think hadn't really been told.
0:34:55There's also in the grand scheme of things, and certainly you're in my lifetimes, but when I was young, Chinese made was roughly a synonym for very low cost and junk, probably poorly assembled, whatever it was, whether it was a piece of consumer electronics, a piece of clothing.
0:35:22It wouldn't be stitched well, the t-shirt would fray, if it was a radio or an alarm clock, it probably wouldn't last longer.
0:35:29It really was synonymous with low cost and low quality.
0:35:33And that's not true anymore.
0:35:36The low cost thing is still there, but it's really more like scale, right?
0:35:42Like these companies, like the fast fashion companies like Timu and the other companies like that, where you can just buy, I don't know, you buy like whole outfits for $7.
0:35:52The first time I ordered something from Timu, which I'm not really a fan of, but I was just curious when they rocketed to the top of the app store in their number one.
0:36:00And I was like, this is crazy.
0:36:02I'm buying like a fake pair of AirPods, a fake Apple watch, a couple of knockoff Apple watch bands.
0:36:08And I forget what else.
0:36:11It was something that, that it was labeled ThinkPad, but I knew it wasn't actually made by Lenovo.
0:36:17It wasn't a laptop.
0:36:17It was like another pair of headphones or something.
0:36:19And the whole bill came to $21 with free shipping.
0:36:23And I was like, this is not, I'm not going to get all this stuff.
0:36:26I know it's going to be junk, but it, and then lo and behold, eight days later, it all came in a weird hand packaged envelope.
0:36:33And it was all kind of told it was about the quality.
0:36:37I guess it was slightly higher quality than I would think for a grand total of $21.
0:36:42But I mean, so China still has that rep, but it's almost like China's reputation for assembly spans the entire gamut now from totally low cost.
0:36:53Fast forward, you could get like a man suit for $40 and all the way to making $2,000 iPhone 16 Pro Max to the highest engineering standards of any company in the world.
0:37:08And I think that's, I've always thought it was primarily driven by Apple, but I feel like that's one of the main themes of your book is, oh, it's entirely driven by Apple.
0:37:20Like, I don't know where China would be if Apple had never started assembling stuff there.
0:37:25Yeah, I'm not sure I would say entirely, but like the line that I use here is that Apple's late to going to China.
0:37:30I mean, they're late to outsourcing in general, right?
0:37:32Solid 15 years.
0:37:33And they're late to outsourcing to China in particular, but what they see in China is really quite different.
0:37:40So like, I joke with people like, what's your favorite Dell computer from the early 2000s?
0:37:44There is nothing.
0:37:46I mean, they don't have any equivalent of Johnny Ive.
0:37:48They're not pushing the limits of design.
0:37:49If you're not pushing the limits of design, then you're not having to train anybody.
0:37:53Because if you're just building a beige box computer, they already know how to do that.
0:37:57And what happens is the component suppliers come up with lighter materials, more durable materials or whatever.
0:38:02And that just gets incorporated into the next design.
0:38:05You don't have to really do anything to update that.
0:38:07Apple isn't playing that game.
0:38:09They're building computers where there is no precedent.
0:38:11And so when I say China didn't have the tech competence to fulfill their designs, I'm not trying to build a knock against China.
0:38:17Nobody had the competence to carry out what Johnny Ive was thinking.
0:38:20I mean, who had built a computer that was like anthropomorphic, looked like a sunflower, and had metal tubing going towards the base?
0:38:26Nobody.
0:38:26And so they had to work with all these suppliers, hand in glove, to train them all.
0:38:31And just the degree of minutiae and obsessiveness, or to quote Steve Jobs, giving a shit, is something that they had to teach all of these people to do.
0:38:41So, you know, I think what I say is like, Dell looks at China and basically sees like scale and margin, and maybe not even margin so much as cost savings that he can pass on to consumers.
0:38:53But Apple sees something different, which is that they see unconstrained design potential.
0:38:59Because if Johnny Ive comes up with a crazy idea, and you've got literal armies of workers in football field-sized factories carrying out the designs on a conveyor belt system, you can create anything at scale, at crazy quality levels, great yield, etc.
0:39:14So nobody's really doing what Apple's doing.
0:39:16I mean, they really are unique in that sense.
0:39:18So I know I get sort of accused on social media of like over-exemplifying Apple's example, but like Apple is in a league of its own in terms of the care that they put into their products, and then later, the quality and quantity that they're building the products at.
0:39:30Right.
0:39:31And in those go-go years, like the first 10 years of the Johnny Ive-Steve Jobs partnership, like Steve Jobs and Next are reunified with Apple.
0:39:44Steve Jobs discovers Johnny Ive and his colleagues, who are extremely talented in the design lab.
0:39:52Jobs is expected to walk in there and fire them all because he was like, whoever designed all of these products needs to go, goes in there and finds that they didn't really, that's not, the products Apple was selling were not the products that the design team wanted to make or be selling.
0:40:08And then the other funny part, of course, is Johnny Ive has his own resignation letter in his pocket.
0:40:12Like, he also expects the meeting to go poorly.
0:40:14So I call this their first meeting of the minds.
0:40:16Yeah.
0:40:17Probably also largely fueled by the legend of Steve Jobs.
0:40:21There were legends that if you happened to stumble into an elevator with him at Apple's campus and he said, hey, what do you do?
0:40:28And you didn't give him a good answer.
0:40:29He'd fire you before the elevator doors open.
0:40:31Well, the funny anecdote that I have is he was firing so many people that this French woman from HR was literally following Steve Jobs around with a briefcase full of non, what am I trying to say, non-filled-in exit contracts, essentially.
0:40:44And then when he fired someone, he'd be like, okay, what's your name, sir?
0:40:46How do I spell your name?
0:40:47And then just like, yeah, okay, here you go.
0:40:49Bye.
0:40:50Yeah.
0:40:50What was your starting date?
0:40:51Okay.
0:40:51Fill that in here.
0:40:52Signature here.
0:40:53The thing is, Apple needed that.
0:40:57I mean, they're really bloated as a corporation at the time.
0:41:00So you needed Steve Jobs.
0:41:02Steve Jobs doesn't come back.
0:41:03Apple never makes it.
0:41:03I mean, never mind the iPod or anything else.
0:41:05I mean, he's instrumental to that comeback.
0:41:06Right.
0:41:07And I don't think Steve Jobs ever makes it, right?
0:41:10Pixar would have.
0:41:10So he'd be remembered for that.
0:41:12But he was out of the computer racket.
0:41:14Next was dwindling, right?
0:41:16Next wasn't going to make it.
0:41:17riddles I told you that I feel like I solved was, it's not clear if you read any number
0:41:22of biographies, Walter Isaacson on down, like, why doesn't Steve Jobs take the role of CEO
0:41:28when Gil Emilio was ousted in July 1997?
0:41:31Like, he's offered the role.
0:41:32I mean, again, he's never held this role before.
0:41:34We always talk about him returning to being CEO, but he's just returning to the company.
0:41:38He's never been CEO before.
0:41:39My answer is that, well, he was so scarred by his earlier departure from the company that
0:41:45to oversee its demise once again was like, who likes reliving trauma?
0:41:49You wouldn't want to do that.
0:41:51And really what changes is the meeting with Johnny Ive, where they come to a realization
0:41:54that, like, we can redefine the aesthetics of a computer.
0:41:57And what was allowing me to have confidence about this narrative is I got these Steve Jobs
0:42:01meeting notes from the summer of 1997.
0:42:02Yes, yes.
0:42:03That explain in great detail, maybe not great detail, but some detail, how Steve Jobs, sort
0:42:08of his thinking of evolves over the course of a few months where he's saying we are in real
0:42:12danger.
0:42:12And he believes like five years out from now, I can see us being successful, but I don't
0:42:17know how we get through the next 12 months.
0:42:19Like, we don't have a product.
0:42:20So they come out with the Think Different campaign.
0:42:22But famously, like, there's no product for the Think Different campaign.
0:42:25You get all inspired by seeing Muhammad Ali, black and white photograph or whatever.
0:42:29Great.
0:42:29But there's no products to go buy that puts you in this league of mavericks and geniuses
0:42:33and stuff.
0:42:34And so really what changes is that he meets Johnny Ives.
0:42:37They come up with the idea of the iMac.
0:42:39He still thinks of it at the time as a network computer, which we don't need to go into.
0:42:42And that's what gets him inspired.
0:42:44And that's why he accepts the CEO role.
0:42:46Yeah.
0:42:47I started during Fireball in August 2002.
0:42:51So that's about five years after that, about four years after the iMac announcement.
0:42:57And from 2025, that feels like, well, soon thereafter, right?
0:43:02Four years.
0:43:03But in my head, the original iMac was way before I was writing Daring Fireball.
0:43:11Like, way before.
0:43:12I don't feel like I barely missed it.
0:43:14I feel like so much happened in those years when I didn't have a site like Daring Fireball.
0:43:21I was keenly reading the sites that did exist, the Apple blogs of the day.
0:43:26I wish that I had the idea or the gumption or whatever that get off my ass and just do it to start Daring Fireball earlier so that my archives would go back that far.
0:43:36In hindsight, it seems like the blink of an eye between, okay, they buy next.
0:43:41There's a couple of months of turmoil.
0:43:43Jobs kind of forces Gil Emilio out.
0:43:46He kind of, him and Larry Ellison kind of make the determination, like, this guy's a bozo.
0:43:50We got to get out of him.
0:43:52And then it feels like, and then Jobs came back into the job.
0:43:56And sure, he called himself the iCEO for a little bit, but then he was there.
0:43:59But no, it was like a year where he was sort of ostensibly searching for Apple's CEO.
0:44:05And as an outsider who really wanted, who thought, hey, this might be the path back for Apple.
0:44:12This sounds like an actual, real, modern operating system plan that could work.
0:44:18Like, the next step operating system can't just be put on Macs, but it is real.
0:44:24It has real credibility.
0:44:26It looks cool, right?
0:44:28And Apple has the hardware chops.
0:44:30They were making some decent computers at the time.
0:44:33Something, something, this could work.
0:44:35But it's like, man, I want Steve Jobs to take that job.
0:44:38I think what he did was brilliant.
0:44:40And I don't know to what degree it was orchestrated in advance.
0:44:43It probably wasn't.
0:44:44So it's one of those connecting the dots, looking back type thing that he used to talk about.
0:44:47But, you know, he essentially is appointed some sort of advisor in December 1996.
0:44:51That's when Next is acquired.
0:44:53But by being Steve Jobs, by being the founder, by having the control that he does without actually
0:44:58taking on a role, he's not really the person to blame as things are still in a tailspin.
0:45:03And yet, because he has no day-to-day responsibilities, he's able to just wander around the organization
0:45:09and talk to people and figure out what's going on.
0:45:11I mean, that's actually what Gil Emilia wanted to do.
0:45:14If you remember, he said, like, give me 100 days to explore the organization and come up with any ideas.
0:45:18But he just wasn't the guy.
0:45:19He was just like an operational efficiency guy.
0:45:21He was more like Tim Cook than he was like Steve Jobs, at least in terms of what he thought his competence was.
0:45:26So by not having responsibilities, but having the control because he was a founder really allowed him to sort of diagnose the company and then come up with a solution.
0:45:35And contrary to maybe his reputation, that he made up his mind that he was going to fire all the designers because the computers sucked and he was just going to come in and before Johnny Ive could even make his case, just be like, you're a bozo, you're fired.
0:45:51And he'd be like, sure thing.
0:45:53Here's my resume or here's my resignation letter.
0:45:55But instead, he really had an open mind.
0:45:58And Jobs, there's several interviews in the books you get into it, but that he came back.
0:46:02It wasn't just Johnny Ive and his team, but that he realized when he went through the company, hey, there's some pockets of really strong engineering talent here.
0:46:09Software engineering, hardware engineering.
0:46:11They've just all been suffering under terrible management for years and years.
0:46:16But there is a lot of talent here, so we don't need to fire everybody and replace them all.
0:46:21We just need to identify the pockets of talent and then set them free with a good plan.
0:46:26A surprising number of people in product development that were there from the original Macintosh days, and they'd survived three CEOs.
0:46:32So he would have been seeing familiar faces as he went through the organization.
0:46:35Right.
0:46:36And again, that was only 12 years, right?
0:46:38It seems like for me as somebody who was only in my early 20s at the time, it was like, felt like an epoch difference.
0:46:48But, you know, the idea that someone would still be there from 12 or 13 years prior, well, that's called having a career.
0:46:54And I just know, because I've gotten to meet some of those people in the intervening years now that I do what I do, that they really also believed in the cause.
0:47:04They were artists in a way, and they saw their life's work not just as drawing a salary for writing code, but for making computers or computer software or the integration of computers and computer software that really did sit at the intersection of the liberal arts and technology.
0:47:24I'm going to ask you a question, because you're such a, I mean, you're Apple blog for a living, right?
0:47:28So you've been doing this for 25 years.
0:47:30And I would love to know, like, the first, I don't know, six chapters of the book, is it just like history that you already know and that you just think, yeah, well, for the layperson, Patrick needs to get the reader up to speed?
0:47:41Yeah.
0:47:42Or do you think there was a lot new and that you were learning from?
0:47:44I would love to know just, like, what value you derived from the early chapters.
0:47:48I'm not sure which chapter the iMac assembly one was.
0:47:51Chapter five on manufacturing.
0:47:53Yeah, so that's one where I definitely learned a lot, and I want to talk about it.
0:47:57But let's take a break first, and then we come back, and I'll pick it up from that spot.
0:48:02And I'm going to thank our next sponsor, our good friends at Notion.
0:48:07Notion is a note-taking, knowledge-based building platform, and it's everywhere you want to be.
0:48:17It's got apps for the Mac, for the iPad, for iPhone, for Android.
0:48:20They've got Notion AI now, which is built into the system, and it's really, really good stuff.
0:48:28But one of the really cool things about Notion is it's built into the system.
0:48:33It's not an afterthought, but you can publish a page on the web.
0:48:37So it's sort of a website editor, too.
0:48:40And so I just started, I can't mention what app it is because it's a secret beta, but I just started beta testing a new app, and the user manual is currently a Notion website.
0:48:51And I was like, damn, for a beta app with an obviously draft user manual just for early beta testers, this looks like a polished final user manual.
0:49:03That's one of the things that I love most about Notion is it's not just that it does work and lets you do things from anywhere for anything, but that everything looks so polished and final when it's just a draft.
0:49:18It's really, really just a great platform that you should look into.
0:49:22Notion AI is their all-in-one AI.
0:49:25It is powered by your work.
0:49:26It's all in one place, and it automatically does things like capture meeting notes and instantly finds the exact content you need, and it drafts detailed docs for you and lets you chat with the best AI models.
0:49:39It's really just a fantastic service for just a feature, one feature among many, for capturing meetings every time.
0:49:47Every idea, every decision, every next step, you can capture in Notion just by recording it while you're in the meeting, and they can be put to work right away.
0:49:54And instead of just getting, like, dashed-off notes of the meeting, you get, like, this entire summary with everything you could want, and then you can query it with AI, like, three weeks later, ask about that meeting you had three weeks ago, and get answers out of it.
0:50:10There's no meeting bots, and it works on any meeting platform, so you could do it on Zoom, Google Meet, or just with your computer system audio if you want to.
0:50:19Transcription and summaries are automatically saved in Notion, so your notes are searchable, both by you through traditional search or with Notion AI.
0:50:28Find any past idea, insight, or decision alongside all of your information.
0:50:32Just type slash meet, M-E-E-T, not M-E-A-T, slash meet on any Notion page on desktop or mobile, and you get started immediately.
0:50:44Just slash meet, and you can just start recording a meeting right there.
0:50:47Notion is used by over half of Fortune 500 companies.
0:50:51Teams that use Notion send less email, cancel more meetings, right?
0:50:55That's sort of counterintuitive, but it's actually a useful selling point.
0:50:59They cancel meetings, and they save time searching for their work.
0:51:02You can choose inside Notion from the best AI models.
0:51:05They've got GPT 4.1, Claude 3.7 Sonnet.
0:51:09You choose.
0:51:10No separate subscription or tab is needed.
0:51:13Go check them out.
0:51:14Go to Notion.com slash talk show.
0:51:17All lowercase letters.
0:51:19It really is important that you use all lowercase letters.
0:51:23Notion.com slash talk show.
0:51:25That's how they'll know you came from the show.
0:51:28Go check them out, especially if you need a better meeting notes tool.
0:51:31Not just a recording, not just a transcription, but something that really is AI first for meeting notes.
0:51:37Notion.com slash talk show.
0:51:40Yeah, go back to the original iMac.
0:51:43We all remember it fondly.
0:51:45And it is funny, though, because it's sort of a flash in the pan design-wise.
0:51:50Apple didn't really make translucent plastic things for very long.
0:51:54CRT monitors were not around for the world very long.
0:51:59Obviously, everything went to flat panels just a handful of years.
0:52:03But as sort of the tail end of heavy CRT monitors and to herald the new design, everybody remembers that the first iMac and maybe the second generation when they went to five colors with extreme fondness.
0:52:18But what I learned from your book was how it's sort of – you tell me if this is a good summary – but it's sort of the first time Johnny Ive and his team were really empowered to be set free and to lead the way on what this should be like.
0:52:37I mean, Apple is banking, Steve Jobs is banking on this one-hit product, and it's going to set a design language for the rest of the company.
0:52:46And you'll remember that the Tower PowerMax adopted the translucent plastic with the white and Bondi blue colors and so forth.
0:52:51So, yeah, I mean, everything is banking on this.
0:52:54And the narrative that's really just untold is that, like, Johnny Ive's first design is just not possible to build.
0:53:00I mean, I talk to the product design engineers who are tasked with building it, and they say, we couldn't build one in the lab, let alone mass manufacture it.
0:53:08And it gets to the point where it's really to the brink of failure.
0:53:11And I don't know if you want me to tell this story, but, like, Steve Jobs enters a meeting that's supposed to be a tooling review and becomes a whole product review.
0:53:18And he tells them, like, you guys have screwed the pooch.
0:53:21I'm going to sell my one fucking remaining share of Apple stock.
0:53:25I talked to multiple people that were in this meeting, and, I mean, he's just absolutely furious.
0:53:29And he says 9,500 jobs are going to be lost, and it's because of you.
0:53:32And it's an extraordinary story.
0:53:36And, I mean, I was able to source it from so many people that worked on that product, including multiple people that led the product, but also Acorn, which is his favorite design consultancy, who are really interesting.
0:53:48So the two guys from Acorn are who developed the NextCube computer, right, which is a magnesium.
0:53:53Great thing to see at the Palo Alto Computer History Museum, but nobody ever bought the damn thing.
0:53:58I think it cost $10,000.
0:54:00Yeah.
0:54:01But through Steve Jobs, his, like, single-mindedness, they had to actually build this thing, and then they design their own, or they come up with their own design studio.
0:54:09So when his own PD team, right, remember, this is a team that Steve Jobs has inherited, basically says, we can't do this.
0:54:14And we've been trying for months.
0:54:15Like, this can't be built.
0:54:16He sends the blueprints and a team of engineers over to Acorn and says, can this be done?
0:54:21And the idea is that if Acorn says, this can be done, like, you guys are all off the project and maybe even all fired.
0:54:28Right.
0:54:28But it's like his test case as to whether or not he's inherited a good team or not.
0:54:32And they say, like, you don't have a quality product.
0:54:34And so Johnny Ive has to go back to the drawing board and make a number of changes to the product, and that's what ends up being in stores.
0:54:40And I'd never really heard that before, I guess.
0:54:44And maybe it's out there to some degree, but you tell the story with sources and with the Acorn involvement and the jobs threat.
0:54:51If these guys say it can be built, then you guys are obviously a bunch of bozos because you should be at least as good as them, and you're out.
0:54:57And it turned out everybody agreed it couldn't be built.
0:55:01And I guess what I had never really thought of, I love the design.
0:55:06I never bought one, for me personally, because I had just purchased a very expensive Power Mac 9600 350, I don't know, in 1996 or something, 97, that lasted me for quite a few years.
0:55:20But my wife got one.
0:55:21She got the grape one the next year.
0:55:23We got my mother-in-law the original Bondi blue one, and she used that for years and just loved it.
0:55:29It really, for the first time, was like, oh, and she didn't mind having a computer in her house anymore.
0:55:34She was always like, why would I want this big industrial-looking thing in my house?
0:55:38And then she had this cute little blue thing in her house.
0:55:40I loved the design, but I think even I had a superficial understanding of how much engineering it was to build it, right?
0:55:53What I thought was, well, they're already making laptops.
0:55:57Power books had been out for a while, and the whole industry, you know, the 90s was sort of a large part of the PC history of the 90s, was the rise of laptops and power books.
0:56:07So the idea of a Mac with reasonable performance that could run in a laptop, it was like they took a CRT and stuck a laptop inside.
0:56:16The trick was they picked these translucent or semi-translucent plastics that no one had ever thought to use that the sort of nerds would laugh at and say, that looks like a child's computer.
0:56:29And consumers were like, yes, I would like a computer that is not a beige square.
0:56:35But that was it.
0:56:36And what your chapter really describes was, oh, well, they kind of designed that, you know, and they had this idea of a handle.
0:56:43And Johnny Ive has spoken about that even recently.
0:56:46I think he even mentioned the handle of the iMac in his Patrick Collison interview recently.
0:56:50I know Johnny Ive has talked about it before, that a handle sort of gives you an emotional connection to a device, that he really, you know, he has a thing for handles.
0:56:59The original Mac...
0:57:00Well, it sounds like approach me, basically.
0:57:01Yeah.
0:57:01Pick me up, cuddle me, yeah.
0:57:02The original 1984 classic Macs, the first three, four, five models, all had handles on top so that you could carry them, even though they weren't really meant to be portable.
0:57:12Yeah, on the iBook, you remember that?
0:57:13Yeah.
0:57:13Yes, the iBook, yeah, it was like a handle, like a, so you could walk around with your iBook, like a briefcase.
0:57:19Yeah.
0:57:20Right.
0:57:20The iMac to go, it was called.
0:57:21Turns out that's not how people wanted to carry their laptops, but it wasn't a bad idea.
0:57:27And if you know that Johnny Ive has a thing for handles, you could see why they tried it.
0:57:32Yeah, exactly.
0:57:32But I just didn't really think about the fact that it weighed 40 pounds, was made of plastic.
0:57:40And so how exactly, when you pick it up by the handle, does a 40 pound, I mean, like you said, Jobs was secretly walking around campus with a bowling ball bag with an iMac inside.
0:57:51Yeah.
0:57:52So it went to be heavy.
0:57:53Yeah.
0:57:54But a real iMac was way heavier than a bowling ball, right?
0:57:58A bowling ball is 10 or 11 pounds.
0:57:59This is like four bowling balls, right?
0:58:01So, you know.
0:58:02I had the Tangerine iMac, and I would basically pick it up by the handle.
0:58:07I think I'd put my arms or arm around it for sport.
0:58:09And I'd walk it down two floors to my brother's room.
0:58:12I took it off to college and stuff.
0:58:13I mean, it's not like you'd set it up in a coffee shop, but you could pick it up and wander around.
0:58:17Yeah.
0:58:17Or do the equivalent of a LAN party or something like that.
0:58:21Or if you were a consultant or freelancer who, I don't know, it wasn't like you'd never moved a desktop computer around.
0:58:27And the iMac was a heck of a lot easier to move around than one with a separate monitor and cables and power supplies and stuff like that.
0:58:35But, yeah, just how do you make it so that you could just pick it up and it wouldn't fall apart?
0:58:39And the answer was, oh, they couldn't.
0:58:42And they had to try to have this design where it really was translucent.
0:58:46But the problem was it was quite ugly inside because of how much they were trying to cram in.
0:58:50And so it's only on the second generation that they really do make it translucent.
0:58:53But they deliberately made the first version foggy because they didn't want you to have a full view inside because they hadn't designed it very well.
0:58:59This was under such pressure.
0:59:01The company was going to go bankrupt if it didn't happen, right?
0:59:03I mean, if the iMac failed, nothing else comes after.
0:59:06The company was done.
0:59:07Yeah.
0:59:08So effectively, they designed it twice.
0:59:10They designed a prototype that looked right but actually couldn't be built.
0:59:15And then they went back to the drawing board and made one that could be built and then had to make certain compromises.
0:59:21Internal structure being added for support.
0:59:25Changed the plastic so that, well, if we add all the stuff we need to add, you don't really want to see it so clearly.
0:59:31So let's make it a little foggier.
0:59:32And they did it all in the same year.
0:59:35Like it was supposed to come out in early 1998, but they still did announce it in August 1998.
0:59:41So the company was moving very fast, right?
0:59:44That's a very compressed time frame.
0:59:46Nothing comes out of that sort of scale.
0:59:47I mean, I've heard you and Ben Thompson talking about the iPod development, really from like product conception to being in people's hands being nine months.
0:59:53I mean, nothing happens like that.
0:59:55Yeah.
0:59:55It's just kind of bananas, right?
0:59:56One day, what's his name?
0:59:58Rubenstein, I think, was the guy who went to Japan and said, hey, Toshiba has all these 1.8-inch hard drives.
1:00:05And the standard was like 2.4-inch hard drives.
1:00:07I don't know what, but something like that.
1:00:09And he's like, Toshiba shrunk their hard drives from 2.4 to 1.8, but no one wants to buy them because all of the laptops have plenty of room for a 2.4-inch drive.
1:00:20Yeah.
1:00:20So why spend more on a 1.8-inch?
1:00:23But maybe we could buy them and do something with them?
1:00:26Just to give the listener a sense of just how precarious Apple's position is back then.
1:00:30So when John Rubenstein figures out, oh, we could actually build a music player with this, and they corner the market, it's he and Jeff Williams, they corner the market by buying everything Toshiba can produce.
1:00:39They have to call Fred Anderson, the CFO, to make sure the check doesn't bounce.
1:00:43It's not clear that Apple's going to be able to even corner the market on these disk drives.
1:00:48And doesn't that sort of feel like what you and I were talking about earlier?
1:00:53Like, you're worried about getting scooped on something of your book.
1:00:56I'm worried about an article in draft that I'm going to get scooped on an observation or something.
1:01:01It's like it became so clear to Apple that they should corner to the market on these tiny hard drives that they were like...
1:01:08They were panicking that the iPod was going to be cannibalized by Motorola or someone with a phone that had an iPod embedded in it.
1:01:16So that's why they had to accelerate the iPhone development.
1:01:18And it's like, nothing like that ever emerged.
1:01:21Well, but it's like the Andy Grove adage, only the paranoid survive, right?
1:01:26And I honestly think that today's...
1:01:29And I'll have to go off on a digression, but I think if there's a problem right now with Apple's senior leadership is that they're not nowhere near paranoid enough.
1:01:37Not about AI, not about the centrality of the devices they currently make to the future of people's computing lives.
1:01:47I think that there's sort of a, hey, we're Apple.
1:01:50We'll figure it out no matter what.
1:01:52We don't have to worry too much.
1:01:53Whereas that paranoid mindset of...
1:01:57Again, we were both laughing.
1:01:59People listening to the show were probably laughing that they were worried about Motorola coming out with a phone that would put the iPod out of business.
1:02:09But that's the sort of thinking that makes things happen fast.
1:02:13In terms of AI, the last five years, it probably would be a different company.
1:02:18Probably.
1:02:19But the other thing that that original iMac saga, the end result of that was sort of a, okay, that's the first time we've done this and we've done a design first process for a new thing.
1:02:34We totally screwed up by not having, I forget what Apple calls the type of engineers, mechanical engineers involved, not at the end where they're handed CAD files, go build this.
1:02:49But at the, oh, it's just a sketch on a piece of paper right now.
1:02:53But this is sort of what we're thinking.
1:02:55Could we build this?
1:02:56What would it cost?
1:02:57Where could we build it?
1:02:58What materials?
1:02:59Having people like that intimately part of the development process from idea forward started right then.
1:03:08Because it seemed to me like they instantly recognized where we screwed up here wasn't in the ambition of the iMac.
1:03:14Where we screwed up is we brought engineers in way too late.
1:03:18Yeah.
1:03:19So the chapter ends with Johnny Ive apologizing to one of the product designers because he effectively understands I gave you something that couldn't be built.
1:03:26And it's my fault for not knowing it couldn't be built.
1:03:29And I'm going to make damn sure that never happens again.
1:03:31And so the ending anecdote is that years later, the same product designer, Ben and Chris Novak is in Japan.
1:03:36I think he's working with Toyo and he says, hey, Johnny, like, I don't think what you're looking for can be built here.
1:03:42And Johnny says, well, we know because we've already done the research.
1:03:44We've been to Toyo.
1:03:45We've worked out.
1:03:46And so what I'm trying to give you is a sense that Johnny Ive isn't just like the Johnny Ive that we know from the get-go.
1:03:53He evolves.
1:03:54He learns.
1:03:55And I'm not trying to point out mistakes or something.
1:03:57I'm trying to point out his evolution to become who he is.
1:04:00And so I've read biographies of Johnny Ive where it's just like from the earliest days of junior high school, he likes minimalist designs.
1:04:06And it's come on.
1:04:07This is just kind of balanced.
1:04:08It's like people grow.
1:04:09And so even within Apple, this is him growing.
1:04:11All right.
1:04:14Let me take one final break here and thank our third and final sponsor of this episode of the show.
1:04:20It's our good friends at Squarespace.
1:04:22Squarespace is the all-in-one platform for making your own website.
1:04:27And they have been around for a while at this point.
1:04:30And they've been sponsoring the show for a long time.
1:04:32And they keep evolving their platform in new ways.
1:04:37And one of the big new ways that they've got in the last year or so is design intelligence.
1:04:43Design intelligence from Squarespace combines two decades of their industry-leading design expertise and design tools with cutting-edge AI technology to unlock your strongest creative potential.
1:04:56Design intelligence empowers anyone to build a beautiful, more personalized website tailored to their unique needs and craft a bespoke digital identity to use across one's entire online presence.
1:05:07Their design tools have always been approachable to non-professional designers.
1:05:12And they have always been what you see is what you get.
1:05:15And you're looking at it in the browser.
1:05:16But it's really by using AI for this.
1:05:20And if you're using AI to do lots of other things, making images and writing text and just coming up with ideas, and you can actually use AI to help design your almost part sum, a new section of your Squarespace website.
1:05:36It's really powerful and their users are really, the more they try it, the more they really like it.
1:05:41Another thing, Squarespace payments.
1:05:43Squarespace payments is the easiest way to manage payments in one place with Squarespace.
1:05:47Onboarding is fast and simple.
1:05:50You can get started in a few clicks and start receiving payments right away and give your customers more ways to pay with popular payment methods like Klarna, ACH, direct deposit in the U.S.,
1:06:02Apple Pay, Afterpay in the U.S. and Canada, and ClearPay, which is sort of like that, but over in the U.K.
1:06:09So many different things.
1:06:11It's such a great system.
1:06:12They've got invoicing built in.
1:06:14So if you run a sort of service where you have to send out invoices to clients or customers on a regular basis, you can do it all through Squarespace.
1:06:21And your clients will thank you because you just send them a link and they go to the Squarespace site and there's the invoice right there.
1:06:27Easy peasy.
1:06:28And it can tie it in with the Squarespace payments.
1:06:30So where do you go to find out more?
1:06:32Go to squarespace.com.
1:06:34You get a free trial.
1:06:35And when you're ready to launch, go to squarespace.com slash talk show and you will save 10% off your first order of a website or domain.
1:06:44My thanks to Squarespace for sponsoring the show.
1:06:47Just remember that code talk show and save 10%.
1:06:50Your book covers this era, the iPhone era.
1:06:55And I've been writing about this recently because of the tariffs and I sort of became obsessed and still am with this idea of how many iPhones can fit on one airplane being shipped over from India or China.
1:07:08But that whole mental exercise on the cusp of the tariffs of, hey, if Apple is rushing six full Boeing 747 freight planes from India, how many iPhones is that?
1:07:23And it's like, oh, it's like 350,000 or something like that.
1:07:28And I forget how many it was, but it turns out it's 12 days of supply in the United States.
1:07:34Like the scale, that's what I keep coming back to.
1:07:37It's like I've always known it, but when you actually get down to working out some of the numbers, it really shows how other than this one path through China, the iPhone as we know it could not exist.
1:07:55I think it's like 200 million.
1:07:57They sell 200 million iPhones a year, give or take.
1:08:00And that works out to let me get my calculator again.
1:08:06I thought I had them on top of my head.
1:08:07Well, while you do the calculator, let me give you sort of two of the crazy numbers that I think about.
1:08:10One of them is that when Apple became worth $3 trillion the first time, I did the math on how much value Tim Cook had added to the company.
1:08:18And it was $700 million per weekday.
1:08:21I mean, sorry, per day.
1:08:22I'm counting weekends.
1:08:22I mean, that's just mind boggling.
1:08:24I mean, it sounds like I'm off by a couple of orders of magnitude.
1:08:26I thought it had to be an error.
1:08:28I really did.
1:08:29There's a great Brian Kernighan book.
1:08:31I'll make a note, put it in the show notes.
1:08:33Millions, billions, and zillions.
1:08:35And it's just about doing ballpark math in your head.
1:08:38And hey, every time you see a figure in a news story, just do a little ballpark head.
1:08:43Brian Kernighan, of course, is a titan of computer science.
1:08:46But it's really a great, fun book.
1:08:47I'm going to make a note here.
1:08:48Well, anytime you use an Apple figure, you have to draw some sort of analogy because the numbers are so large, they just
1:08:54go over our heads entirely.
1:08:55Right.
1:08:56It's really just such a fun, fun book.
1:08:59But I saw that number in your book, and I thought, that's got to be a mistake.
1:09:03And I was like, this is going to be uncomfortable because I'm going to uncover this mistake.
1:09:06Well, I've already published it.
1:09:08It was almost three years ago.
1:09:10But it's true.
1:09:11It's like $500 million every day of the week or $700 million every day of the week.
1:09:15$700 million a day.
1:09:16I mean, I could even say $1 billion per weekday.
1:09:18That would be maybe a rounder number.
1:09:20It's wild.
1:09:22But then you can work it out in your head where it's like you get to, what, $1,000 of those is a trillion.
1:09:31So every 1,000 days, it's three quarters of a trillion every 1,000 days.
1:09:39And so that's 1,000 days is roughly three years.
1:09:43So every three years, sort of a trillion.
1:09:46And all that tells you, of course, is that your ballpark, correct?
1:09:51And then you have to work out the math.
1:09:52Right.
1:09:52Yeah, absolutely.
1:09:53Yeah, but it's totally, totally bananas.
1:09:56So anyway, iPhones, 550,000 every day around the world.
1:10:01So to make that many every day by 24 hours, you get to about 23,000 iPhones an hour, every hour.
1:10:10And there's 60 minutes in an hour.
1:10:13So 380 brand new factory-sealed iPhones every minute.
1:10:17So you remember I said I had these internal documents, and one of them describes what a Foxconn big line is.
1:10:25And so they're capable of making, I'm just citing my own book here, page 337, a big line at Foxconn is capable of making 590 units per hour.
1:10:33And they had 60 lines, 62 production lines, making the iPhone XR at Foxconn.
1:10:39So that, I mean, that's a proprietary number from one of the internal documents.
1:10:44They don't, you know, they're a proprietary company that doesn't like talking about how Tim Cook ties his shoes, let alone what they consider competitive information like that.
1:10:55Which is so frustrating as a reporter, but I have to say, taking a year off and doing nothing but research into it means that every time you talk to somebody, you're basically getting new details.
1:11:04Because if they haven't talked to a reporter before, but they have moved on from Apple, they're happy to tell you their story.
1:11:09The brilliant thing about it is just that you're just getting nothing but novel information all the time.
1:11:14Right.
1:11:14It's banana.
1:11:15But I guess where I've landed on this is just sort of, I guess I've always kind of known it, but now I see how almost certainly true it is.
1:11:25That there's really by no other path does the iPhone as we know it, could it possibly exist.
1:11:32By which I mean a couple of billion people own one, right?
1:11:40And I think certainly in my audience, certainly probably in your social circle, most of the people you know own, not just own a iPhone-like phone, but probably own an iPhone.
1:11:51They were all purchased for $700 to $1,000 lately, maybe $1,100, $1,200, $500, $600, up to $1,100, $1,200, $1,300.
1:12:02And people replace them every two or three years.
1:12:06There's no other way that that product could exist than making them in China because you have to reach that level of pricing to create that kind of demand.
1:12:17If they all cost $3,000 or $4,000, and I think it would be just as a little thought exercise, if you went back in time to go back to when Steve Jobs debuted the iMac, August 1998, and me and you get in a time machine and we take an iPhone or a couple of iPhones with us and start showing even people from Apple like Steve Jobs,
1:12:43Hey, here's the type of thing you're going to be making in 2025.
1:12:46And by the way, you know, and let's pretend we can, or it was Wi-Fi out at the time?
1:12:52Maybe it was.
1:12:53But we'd say this is also a cell phone, so you get really high speed, better than today, you know, 1998 Wi-Fi.
1:13:00Everywhere you go, just out in the sidewalk, almost coast to coast, right?
1:13:04You get really good bandwidth just everywhere for like $70 a month from Verizon.
1:13:10Look at the screen, look at the size, here's a CPU benchmark, here's how fast the chip is.
1:13:17It's way faster than any computer in the world in 1998.
1:13:21How much do you think this device costs in 2025?
1:13:27John Gruber question ever.
1:13:29Right?
1:13:31Steve Jobs' scenario.
1:13:32Well, I guess.
1:13:33Or Tim Cook.
1:13:34Or Bill Gates.
1:13:38Or somebody from outside.
1:13:39All of this happened, yeah.
1:13:40Right.
1:13:41Just, you know, PC magazine columnists at the time.
1:13:45I think a reasonable person in 1998 would think, even factoring just a little bit in your head of inflation
1:13:52and thinking about how much computers cost in 1998, they would think this is at least a $5,000 or $6,000, $7,000 device.
1:13:59Yeah.
1:13:59First of all, they would think it was complete science fiction.
1:14:01But I would actually flip that on its head a little bit, which is to say that the significant thing about iPhone pricing over the last 10, 15 years, isn't that it?
1:14:09Is that it's gone up?
1:14:11Is that it right now that it's gone down?
1:14:13If you look at PC prices from, let's say, 1985 to 2005, it's just a steady downfall.
1:14:19And then you look at iPhone prices for its first two decades, and it starts at $500.
1:14:23That's the price that Steve Ballmer laughs at.
1:14:25I think the iPhone I have cost $1,600 because I get, like, the one gigabyte memory.
1:14:30I mean, so it's amazing that this ubiquitous device has gone up over the time period.
1:14:35And how they do that is pretty amazing.
1:14:36I mean, it basically is a violation of both technology and economics.
1:14:43Yeah, well, I think that's best exemplified by the MacBook Airs, which have started at $9.99 forever.
1:14:49Right.
1:14:50And again, in an industry where if the computer doesn't change, if the way it looks and the basic specs of the screen don't change, then every couple years it gets a little cheaper.
1:15:00Right?
1:15:00That's just how Moore's Law affects consumer pricing for computers.
1:15:05But with Apple, they kind of hold, they pick the price as part of the brand and try to keep putting more value into it to let it hold that price.
1:15:14But it's kind of remarkable how long MacBooks have started at $9.99.
1:15:19It's really wild.
1:15:21And again, with the iPhone, like you've said, the average selling price of an iPhone has gone up, not down.
1:15:27At a time.
1:15:28Basically doubled, yeah.
1:15:29And not only at a time, it's not like smartphones in general are doing that.
1:15:32Android prices, maybe they haven't collapsed, but they collapsed early a decade ago.
1:15:37And then they sort of held steady.
1:15:39But the average Android device is around $300, basically one-third of an iPhone selling price.
1:15:43And in my counterfactual world where Apple had never gone to China and therefore never grew the capability to build out the scale of building this many iPhones every year, year after year,
1:16:02at these prices that regular everyday consumers will buy, $700, $800.
1:16:10And instead, they're making iPhones for $2,500 or $3,000.
1:16:16And people like me would still buy one.
1:16:18But then they'd be competing.
1:16:21I think that that world ends up looking a lot more like the old PC market where it's not that Apple would be in trouble or the iPhone would go away,
1:16:29but it would be relegated to a 4% or 5% niche in the United States and other wealthy countries.
1:16:37And because the other phone makers would be making $700, $800 phones of some sort.
1:16:45They may pale in comparison to the $4,000 or $5,000 Apple iPhone, but they'd be making some kind of phone that copied the touchscreen interface as best they could for those prices.
1:16:57And they'd be making them at scale.
1:16:59It's part of the iPhone success story is they do compete.
1:17:03They are more expensive than their flagship brethren on the Android side, but not by much.
1:17:10Yeah, I agree.
1:17:11Yeah, counterfactuals are tough.
1:17:12So I don't know exactly where to take this.
1:17:14My sort of counterfactual fantasy is whether it is if they invested everything into Mexico, sort of NAFTA on steroids.
1:17:21And the significance of that, the reason why I go there with a thought experiment is that when you have goods being made in Mexico, you tend to have a lot of intermediary trade across the border with America.
1:17:30And so we don't sort of have a following of our industry if 25% of everything built in Mexico has some sort of American origin.
1:17:36When you go to China, China consolidates next door manufacturing into everything.
1:17:41So you just really just lose.
1:17:43So like within the political dynamic of America, if a factory closes in Ohio, it doesn't really matter if it goes to Mexico or it goes to China.
1:17:51For all intents and purposes, the jobs are lost or whatever.
1:17:53But actually, I think it really makes a difference.
1:17:55And I'd rather have it going to Mexico than China.
1:17:58When do you think Apple realized, oh, we're tied to China now?
1:18:03That's a great question.
1:18:05And I think it's the prologue of the book, which is when Xi Jinping enters office and within 36 hours, CTTP, let's just think of that as state-sponsored CNN in China, really attacks Apple.
1:18:15And Apple is really confused as to what's going on.
1:18:18I mean, I've talked to multiple people on the ground and they just didn't understand why they were being attacked, why they were being seen as this exploitative power.
1:18:25And so they sort of issue this sort of banal press release that more or less says, oh, there seems to be this conclusion here.
1:18:31Like, actually, our product warranties are the same everywhere.
1:18:34By the way, we make incomparably good products.
1:18:37This is a little sign off.
1:18:38And then they're attacked by what's called the state-sponsored New York Times of China, the People's Daily, who sort of riffs on that line and complains about their incomparable arrogance.
1:18:46And this leads to Tim Cook having to issue a letter in Mandarin, basically apologizing, I mean, effectively kowtowing, if not actively kowtowing.
1:18:54I have an anecdote from one person, so it's in parentheses, just to say that Tim Cook didn't just issue the letter.
1:18:59He flew to China to meet with the Chinese officials.
1:19:01And the person said, if you know anything about China, you don't just issue apologies, they make you bow.
1:19:06So that is the moment when they realized, oh, we are not like the person with the power in this relationship, right?
1:19:13There's a bit of a show trial, in a sense, of Apple and Tim Cook, where Beijing is going, we hold the cards, if I'm quoting Trump versus Zelensky.
1:19:21And that, to me, really is the time that instead of putting out a massive share buyback program, Apple could have said, story to shareholders, we're investing in the resiliency of our supply chain.
1:19:31But to be sympathetic to why they didn't make that decision, you have to understand just how difficult it was to keep up with the pace of building all of these products at immense scale.
1:19:40And their own realization that nobody else had the capability outside of China to do this.
1:19:44And they were just scaling, scaling, scaling.
1:19:47And they're an engineering-led organization, particularly under Tim Cook.
1:19:50And so they weren't pontificating matters of state.
1:19:53They didn't really understand the Chinese threat.
1:19:54They thought they'd sort of solved it with this apology.
1:19:57And they had to make the next great product.
1:19:58And they had to do it in bigger volumes than they ever had before.
1:20:01So that's why I don't have any bad characters in the book, right?
1:20:04I mean, you'll know, having read the book, I don't think, aside from the conclusion where I questioned Tim Cook's legacy,
1:20:09I don't portray him as a bad actor or anything like that.
1:20:12I think they sleepwalked into this crisis.
1:20:13I think they were outplayed by a belligerent regime in China, famous for its long-term thinking.
1:20:18But I don't really hold anyone deeply accountable.
1:20:24I think this just sort of happened.
1:20:26And it's journalist 2020 hindsight to point it out.
1:20:28But I don't have sort of unethical characters who are just after greed or something like that.
1:20:33So that was 2012 where Xi took power?
1:20:38So Xi Jinping comes – it's sort of like the American system where there's an election in November and then the president actually takes power in January.
1:20:44So technically he is appointed head of the CCP in late 2012.
1:20:48But he doesn't get like full presidential powers until March 14, 2013.
1:20:53And the following day is when Apple gets attacked.
1:20:56There are so many anecdotes in the book.
1:20:59One thing I didn't worry about, like when I said up front, that the book is so thoroughly jam-packed with original reporting and content.
1:21:08It's spoiler-proof, even on a long podcast like mine.
1:21:11There is no way.
1:21:12If you think that we've talked about any – all the good stuff in this book, we haven't even touched some of it.
1:21:17But what – how – can you describe the anecdote, the yellow card, yellow cow?
1:21:23Yellow cows?
1:21:24Yellow cows.
1:21:24Yeah.
1:21:26So this is my favorite part in the book and basically what happens.
1:21:29And by the way, so if you've read the book, I had John Ford on stage with me last night.
1:21:32We had actually never met in person.
1:21:34And we did an event together at the Commonwealth Club.
1:21:36So John Ford in the book, he's known as the missionary, beginning of part four.
1:21:40And he's this, like, 275-pound guy who goes to Portland State on a football scholarship.
1:21:45But he's also a Taiwanese – sorry, a Mormon missionary to Taiwan after high school.
1:21:50So he learns to speak Mandarin fluently.
1:21:52And he's an Apple head.
1:21:54And to make a long story short, he becomes, like, head of the Denver, Colorado Apple store circa 2006, 2007, working for Apple for several years.
1:22:02Real self-starter.
1:22:03But this is after when he's already been sort of in social auditing compliance, living in China, running his own business as the CEO.
1:22:09Just a fascinating character.
1:22:10And he just puts up his hand in a meeting where he's told that they're going to build a store in China.
1:22:15And he just puts up his hand and says, I speak Mandarin fluently.
1:22:19Like, can I go there?
1:22:20And he's just picturing himself being, like, a Mandarin version of a Walmart reader.
1:22:25But they begin to realize through talking to him that, oh, this guy could actually go out there and lead the Apple store.
1:22:32And so his story is just nuts, right?
1:22:34I mean, I have a chapter called The Sewing Machine Repair Shop.
1:22:36And it's because Apple's $70 billion retail business in China goes back to him experiencing a catch-22 in early 2008, where to build the Apple store, you need a license.
1:22:48To get a license, you need to have a store.
1:22:50And so it's not clear what he's supposed to do other than stuff a red envelope full of cash to some Chinese cadre.
1:22:55And so instead, he gets the idea of why do we buy an existing electronics store?
1:22:59And so he finds this five-foot-by-five-foot sewing machine repair shop.
1:23:04And that's literally the legal basis for the biggest, most successful business in China today.
1:23:08So just fast forward a little bit.
1:23:10What happens is the Apple store is successful almost immediately.
1:23:14And by 2010, they have four stores in the country.
1:23:172010 is the iPhone 4.
1:23:19Most of your listeners didn't have an iPhone.
1:23:21They didn't have an iPhone 3.
1:23:23They didn't have an iPhone 3G.
1:23:24But they might have had an iPhone 4.
1:23:25That's really the first year it's built in great volumes.
1:23:27And it's a breakthrough design.
1:23:29Dickie Howarth is the main guy that was designing it.
1:23:31He said he wanted it to be so smooth like it was licked by a thousand kittens.
1:23:35And the Chinese just go totally gaga over it.
1:23:38And so these yellow cows are these quasi-gangsters, just scalpers, you could say.
1:23:43But they're tied up with organized crime.
1:23:45And they recognize inefficiencies in the market.
1:23:47It doesn't matter if it's iPhones or anything else.
1:23:48This is what they do.
1:23:50But they recognize the mother of all opportunities here because it just becomes, the iPhone, the most conspicuous product that you can buy.
1:23:56I mean, to the degree that there's a case of someone selling their kidney through black market surgery just so they can buy an iPhone and an iPad.
1:24:04I mean, people are just doing anything they can to buy these things.
1:24:07They're being smuggled into the country.
1:24:09And you can only buy two.
1:24:11And so if you are a yellow cow and you want to go to a city like Chongqing, population 32 million, and sell iPhones by the thousands, you can't just buy as many as you want.
1:24:19So they begin busting in migrants by the thousands so that each of them can buy two.
1:24:24So, I mean, I've got scenes described by people working at Apple, by people working at the American Embassy in Beijing, where you've got 6,000, 7,000 people snake lining outside this store.
1:24:33And nobody in the store looks like they can afford an iPhone, right?
1:24:36It'd be like seeing like a bunch of riffraff lining outside the Tiffany's.
1:24:40And you're like, you guys are buying necklaces?
1:24:42Like, this doesn't make any sense.
1:24:43And it's because they've all been bussed in.
1:24:45So the yellow cows play this like instrumental role, essentially playing like a gig economy distributor role to get the iPhone to like every nook and cranny of China.
1:24:54And it's an absolutely wild narrative.
1:24:57The problem is they get greedy.
1:24:59And so they start doing illegal, nefarious things like going over to America using fake IDs, buying an iPhone at the T-Mobile store where they only pay one month of a 24-month contract.
1:25:11So they get an iPhone for less than $100.
1:25:13They go back to China.
1:25:15And then the problem with there is that, yes, you've got a new iPhone.
1:25:18No, it won't work in China.
1:25:19So with factory connections, they zap the processor.
1:25:22So they're rendering it inoperable.
1:25:25But at the same time, they're masking its retail market country of origin.
1:25:29So the genius bars don't know what's going on.
1:25:31They're looking at this phone and saying, well, this is a new phone.
1:25:34I don't know why it doesn't work.
1:25:35We must have a supply chain issue.
1:25:36And so they would give them a brand new phone with a receipt with the Apple seal and everything.
1:25:41And then the yellow cows basically are able to make more money per iPhone than Apple, right?
1:25:46They're acquiring them for less than $100.
1:25:47They're selling them for $800, $900, $1,000.
1:25:50So this is absolutely wild narratives.
1:25:52But the illegality of it is causing all kinds of problems for Apple.
1:25:56And this is really the instrumental narrative that drives home the point that Apple doesn't understand what it's doing in China.
1:26:01It's so successful as a producer.
1:26:03It's so successful as a retail division.
1:26:05But there's all sorts of distribution issues, cultural issues, political issues that they're not familiar with.
1:26:10I think I saw some of the tail end of that scam because I used to go to a conference or a festival, XOXO, in Portland, Oregon.
1:26:20And it was for a couple of years around 2012, 2013.
1:26:24The conference was the weekend where the new iPhones came out.
1:26:29And I know one year I was out in California to have the iPhone premiere, show and dance.
1:26:36And instead of flying back to Philadelphia and then flying to Portland, I just flew from San Francisco to Portland and met my wife there.
1:26:42But long story short, there would be a line around the Apple store in Portland, like thousands of people.
1:26:49And again, like people who did not look like they had the money to buy new iPhones and many of them Asian.
1:26:56And it I guess and everybody was like, what the hell is going on?
1:27:01And somebody was like, yeah, I think it's some kind of thing where they buy them and send them back to China or something.
1:27:07I'm sure you're right, because first of all, this happened at all kinds of stores.
1:27:10But Portland was like the epicenter because there's no sales tax.
1:27:13Yeah, I didn't even think of that.
1:27:16Or maybe that did come up at the time.
1:27:17But it was so clearly not like the 2007, 2008, 2009 lines to buy a new iPhone, where it was people like me with Apple T-shirts and high-fiving each other.
1:27:30And the other thing I should point out, just because this is really interesting, is am I right that you're on the right to repair side?
1:27:36You don't like that Apple serializes everything in the film?
1:27:39I feel like Apple, I'm not adamant on either side.
1:27:43And I feel like Apple is coming around to the correct perspective, perhaps.
1:27:48And I feel like this is an area where legislation is actually on the right path.
1:27:54What's being legislated is what should be legislated.
1:27:58I'm bringing it up just because the reason everything is serialized to the motherboard goes back to the yellow cows.
1:28:03Because again, you have to remember they're connected to the triads.
1:28:06And so not only are they buying the phone at less than $100 in fake IDs, they're hollowing out the components within the phone and replacing them with replica components.
1:28:13And so that's why you had to serialize it, because it's a defensive gesture against this massive scam that's worth billions and billions of dollars.
1:28:21I mean, iPhone sales in China go from something like a couple hundred thousand in 2009 to more than 20 million in 2012.
1:28:27And so many of these phones are being purchased by the yellow cows that it's just this massive problem for Apple.
1:28:34So how are they defending against that today while supporting the right to repair?
1:28:39I think it's more or less because they're selling authorized components that can still be serialized.
1:28:45And that's what, like, when you go to a third-party repair shop, you're still getting a display that can be verified somehow.
1:28:54Yeah.
1:28:54I mean, they've just taken total control of this.
1:28:56But, like, it got to the point where the replica models with the hollowed-up components were so good that the Genius Bar would have a real iPhone and a tampered-with iPhone in China and not know which was which.
1:29:07So Apple had to introduce, like, X-ray-style microscopic machinery to be able to look at the phone nearly at the atomic level.
1:29:14And that's how they could determine what was going on.
1:29:16Because even the IMEI, which back in those days is like a sort of number that's on the phone and the SIM card,
1:29:21they were, the yellow cows, using the factory connections, were typing in, were retyping in, scam IMEI numbers.
1:29:28And so what would happen is that they would have access to these systems that could determine, like, this IMEI claims to be on this phone,
1:29:36and yet I can see that it's in operation in New York on the other side of the world.
1:29:40So that would be enough proof.
1:29:41This has been tampered with.
1:29:42We're not giving this person a phone.
1:29:44But just going back to the CCTV narrative, and this is, like, the big riddle that I thought I solved,
1:29:48is that the reason CCTV attacks Apple over warranty differences is because Apple, in reaction to this scam,
1:29:55begins refurbishing the phones rather than giving them new ones.
1:29:59So when they were getting new ones, someone described to me as this was like cocaine to the yellow cows.
1:30:04But Apple, as Apple is losing money on this and they're taking countermeasures against it,
1:30:08the yellow cows are able to basically convince their political, off the political echelons in China,
1:30:14like, we are being disserviced here.
1:30:16The Chinese are being treated in an inferior way.
1:30:19And so CCTV, which runs this Consumer Day program, literally sends out Chinese consumers to places like America,
1:30:25to places like Europe, and asks people on record with hidden cameras, like, what is the warranty policy?
1:30:31If I come back with this, what happens?
1:30:32And they're able to establish that there is a difference of what happens in China.
1:30:36But it's all related to this scam that's going on.
1:30:38And so this is why Apple is so flummoxed when the CCTV goes after them,
1:30:41because now everyone's up to date with what's going on with these yellow cows.
1:30:44And it's, wait, do we have different warranty policies?
1:30:47Why do we have different warranty policies?
1:30:48And they're totally flummoxed.
1:30:49And that was an issue that was covered by the Atlantic, the Associated Press, Reuters, New York Times, everybody.
1:30:54And I don't think we've ever understood what the hell happened.
1:30:57And this is what happened.
1:30:58Yeah, it's fantastic.
1:30:59You really did piece all the strings together.
1:31:04And it makes, in hindsight now, a lot that never really made sense now makes sense,
1:31:09where there's sort of a kernel of truth to everything.
1:31:12Like, it wasn't wrong for whoever made the decision at Apple to start using refurbished parts,
1:31:18because, hey, something fishy is going on here, so let's cut our losses.
1:31:22Oh, and I think everybody would be like, yeah, that's fair.
1:31:24But then it was a totally different side of the company that got broadsided by the political campaign
1:31:33and the Chinese news media, where they're like, we don't have a different policy over there, do we?
1:31:37And it turns out they did.
1:31:38But they did for good reason, not because Apple thought poorly of China.
1:31:42It was in response to an actual scam that was going on.
1:31:45Here's my final question for you.
1:31:47Where's the best place for people to go for the book?
1:31:50That's their own decision.
1:31:52I would say bookshop.org, which sort of works like Amazon, but it goes through your independent bookseller.
1:31:57I mean, that's the best thing to do.
1:31:58Obviously, you could just go to your independent bookseller if you don't mind taking a walk,
1:32:01driving to the mall, whatever the case is.
1:32:03But look, if you buy it on Barnes & Noble, if you buy it on Amazon, I mean,
1:32:05for me, the key thing is that you start reading that doesn't exactly matter where you buy it.
1:32:09It is a fantastic book.
1:32:11It really is.
1:32:11We literally only scratched the surface of the great anecdotes and stories that are in here
1:32:16and the sort of tying together of the threads, which really is impressive in the book, Patrick.
1:32:22I really mean it.
1:32:23It's not just, oh, here's a whole bunch of facts and they're stacked and shuffled.
1:32:27It's like, no, this is a story.
1:32:29Yeah.
1:32:30Well, thank you.
1:32:31And I know you're really close to Apple people, and I'm dying to know what's happening within the glass walls
1:32:35of Cupertino, so we'll have to have another conversation where I can figure that out,
1:32:38because I'm sure you're hearing buzz.
1:32:40Absolutely.
1:32:41All right.