Podcast Search

The Talk Show

424: ‘Live From WWDC 2025’, With Joanna Stern and Nilay Patel

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00Hello and welcome to the magnificent California Theater in bustling downtown San Jose.

0:00:10We are delighted to bring you another edition of the talk show live with special guests.

0:00:18And now, here's your host, John Gruber.

0:00:30Hello. Hello, thank you for coming.

0:00:40I am your host, John Gruber.

0:00:44I have some business to take care of up front, as usual.

0:00:49Theaters like this do not rent themselves.

0:00:52And we have three excellent sponsors, and I want to thank them all.

0:00:58If you guys remember last year, you'll remember our primary sponsor was iMazing.

0:01:03They are back again last year.

0:01:05They were here to talk about iMazing 3.

0:01:08They are back this year to talk about the best experience for managing local iOS backups, device backups, including snapshots like Time Machine.

0:01:22That's what iMazing does.

0:01:25It is a beautiful native app.

0:01:27It is also a robust app management tool for maintaining a local library of iOS apps like iTunes used to offer and doesn't anymore.

0:01:37And a lot of people want.

0:01:38iMazing does it.

0:01:40And it probably does it better than iTunes ever did, really.

0:01:43Helpful, iMazing and WhatsApp chat extraction to PDF and other formats, including RSMF for legal and business apps.

0:01:54I don't know what that means, but if you do, it sounds like it's important for people to do, and iMazing does it great.

0:02:02They have a device file browser, data access, and data transfer capabilities that can be especially helpful for, well, let's say nerds, but developers, pros, system administrators.

0:02:15So, for that last group, system administrators, this year, they've got iMazing profile editor, too.

0:02:20It's the best way to work with Apple configuration files.

0:02:24It includes total app setup.

0:02:26It scans macOS app binaries and streamlines, setting up all required configurations and permissions.

0:02:33It is designed to save time, reduce errors, and complex deployment.

0:02:39There's also iMazing configurator.

0:02:41It adds powerful capabilities for provisioning, supervising, and automating Apple iOS device setup at scale beyond what Apple configurator offers.

0:02:51It streamlines MDM enrollment and migration processes.

0:02:55They've got a brand new, it's unique to iMazing, an enroll in MDM feature that allows devices to be migrated between MDM platforms while preserving the data on the device.

0:03:08This is apparently a big deal for people who need to migrate MDM stuff.

0:03:13I will just say, a lot of that sounded a little boring and nerdy, but if it's like your work, it's really important.

0:03:20But the thing about iMazing, it is like amazing to look at.

0:03:23It is not like, oh, look at it, this is like a nerd app.

0:03:26It's like a beautiful, like, you know, maybe nominated for an ADA type app that does all this nerdy stuff.

0:03:33It is perfect, honestly, perfect sponsor for this show.

0:03:37Check out iMazing 3 today.

0:03:39Save 20%.

0:03:40This isn't just for you guys in the audience.

0:03:42Everybody out there watching in theater, everybody watching later in the future on YouTube.

0:03:46Save 20% by visiting iMazing.com slash the talk show.

0:03:53That's iMazing.com slash the talk show.

0:03:57Next, Details Pro.

0:03:59They're actually sponsoring Daring Fireball this week, too.

0:04:02You might have seen them already.

0:04:05It is an app that lets you design SwiftUI things.

0:04:09Apps, widgets, anything you can do with SwiftUI.

0:04:13That's sort of the whole point of SwiftUI is if it has a user interface, you can design it with SwiftUI.

0:04:18Details Pro can do it for you.

0:04:21It runs.

0:04:22It's an app.

0:04:23You can use it on your iPhone.

0:04:25It runs on your iPad.

0:04:27It runs on Mac.

0:04:27They also have a great Vision Pro app with full features on all of those platforms.

0:04:33There are great templates built in that you can use so you can get started without starting from scratch like an empty template or an empty canvas.

0:04:42Templates for everything.

0:04:44It is really a fast and easy way to get new designs ready for iOS 26 and Liquid Glass.

0:04:51It's ready for this.

0:04:53It's the perfect time for them to sponsor.

0:04:54You can use the Basic Tools and Details Pro for free.

0:04:59The Basic Tools, a lot of the templates, free forever.

0:05:03Just download it, check it out, try it.

0:05:05There's a whole bunch of stuff you can do free forever.

0:05:06And then there's a subscription or a one-time purchase to unlock all the tools and all the templates.

0:05:13Details Pro has been around for five years and has a really big thriving community of UI designers and developers.

0:05:20And again, SwiftUI that just goes right into Xcode.

0:05:23This is real stuff that you can design it and then right into production in Xcode.

0:05:28Really great stuff.

0:05:29Go to detailspro.app.

0:05:32One of those .app domains.

0:05:34Detailspro.app.

0:05:36Third, our third and final sponsor.

0:05:39Another great company.

0:05:41Not really developer-oriented, but I'll bet a real crowd-pleaser here.

0:05:45Ooni.

0:05:45O-O-N-I.

0:05:47Ooni created a new category of pizza ovens about a dozen years ago.

0:05:55And they're going from strength to strength with their industry-defining products.

0:05:59Their range starts at just $299.

0:06:02But with Father's Day coming up, you should definitely check out the Koda 2 and Koda 2 Pro pizza ovens.

0:06:13Beyond pizza ovens, they're continuing to innovate.

0:06:15They've got a brand-new Halo Pro spiral mixer, which is huge for people who need, you know, they're sort of bringing smart stuff into the sort of, I'm not going to name names, but there's, you know, a couple big names in the mixer category.

0:06:30And they're shaking things up.

0:06:31Or mixing things up, maybe I'll say.

0:06:33Finally, Ooni.

0:06:36They even got, there is sort of a developer connection here.

0:06:39They got a little mention in yesterday's keynote.

0:06:41I don't know if you noticed.

0:06:42I did because I'm talking to them for sponsorships.

0:06:45But that was pretty cool.

0:06:47Christian, the founder of Ooni.

0:06:49He's somewhere out here.

0:06:50He's a long-time Daring Fireball reader.

0:06:53He's in the audience tonight.

0:06:54He's, like, I think still on cloud nine because they got into the keynote yesterday.

0:06:58Which, if anybody's ever gotten anything in the keynote, it's a big deal.

0:07:02So my thanks to them.

0:07:04Go to Ooni, O-O-N-I dot com slash the talk show.

0:07:11O-O-N-I dot com slash the talk show.

0:07:16And that's good for a 10% off.

0:07:19That code, the talk show, 10% off.

0:07:23So my thanks to all three of those sponsors.

0:07:24Wouldn't be here without them.

0:07:26Speaking of not being here.

0:07:30I actually forget the first year I did a live from WWDC talk show.

0:07:47It's probably like 2009, 2010.

0:07:49And the first few years were, you know, sort of pals from my regular weekly or couple times

0:07:58a month, whatever my schedule is, podcast.

0:08:00Cable Sasser from Panic was the first guest the first year.

0:08:04Guy English was here one year.

0:08:11I think the 2014 I had my friends, all three of them, from the Accidental Tech Podcast were here.

0:08:18And then in 2015 I came out.

0:08:25We were still in San Francisco at Mezzanine, a sort of nightclub that we retrofitted to do stuff like this.

0:08:33And I've always played this game where I've tried to keep my guests secret before I call them out on stage.

0:08:39I think that's fun.

0:08:40You know, it works better than usually it seems to stay under wraps.

0:08:452015 definitely stayed under wraps.

0:08:50And I came out here, and I still remember the introduction.

0:08:54I thought, I didn't run it past him, but I said, ladies and gentlemen, I shit you not.

0:08:59Phil Schiller.

0:09:02And the crowd was like, what?

0:09:06You know.

0:09:08And it was kind of raucous.

0:09:10And the curtain was right behind me.

0:09:14And nobody came out.

0:09:15And it is sort of my sense of humor, maybe, to say, nah, it's Maltz.

0:09:23And I did not know Phil was going to do that.

0:09:28But then Phil Schiller came out, perfectly timed to make everybody in the audience think,

0:09:34it's Gruber, shit me.

0:09:36And it was amazing.

0:09:39It was a lot of fun, and Phil was great.

0:09:42And it's, you know, I didn't know.

0:09:44It was at one time.

0:09:45Next thing I knew, 10 consecutive years, I had guests of that sort of level from Apple's

0:09:54senior leadership on this show, either the day.

0:09:58I think one year we did it on Wednesday.

0:09:59I don't know why.

0:10:00But usually the day after the keynote.

0:10:02You know, and this year, I thought, well, when I found out, it wasn't going to happen.

0:10:12I thought, well, I need to announce that.

0:10:16Like, you know, I don't want people buying tickets.

0:10:18I don't want sponsors sponsoring the show, expecting that if that's not what's going to happen.

0:10:23And then I kind of realized, man, it's really 10 years of this, and it really did sort of bake

0:10:28in the expectation of that.

0:10:32I did extend an invitation to Apple.

0:10:34They declined.

0:10:36And their declining was more than a simple no.

0:10:39There were reasons given.

0:10:44There was a discussion.

0:10:46It's not acrimonious.

0:10:48I mean, you know, and I've been told many times over the last 24 hours since I've been out here

0:10:52that they still love me.

0:10:56Funny way of showing it, but they do.

0:10:58But I'll leave it at that.

0:11:05But I always said, I've come out here and joked before, that one of these years, you know,

0:11:11I never, ever took it for granted.

0:11:14I'm, in hindsight, kind of surprised they did it 10 years in a row.

0:11:17But I always said, one of these years, it's going to be Maltz.

0:11:22So I called John Maltz.

0:11:24And I said, you know, I gave him the story, and he said, well, I just wouldn't be comfortable

0:11:35doing your show.

0:11:36I think a lot of your writing about Apple of late has been unfair.

0:11:46You had that piece that you titled, Something is Rotten in the State of Cupertino, and I just

0:11:54wouldn't be comfortable, after you wrote that, I wouldn't be comfortable coming out on your

0:11:57show.

0:11:57I don't think that was fair or accurate.

0:11:59And I said, John, you know, what parts of it do you not agree with?

0:12:05And he couldn't really put his finger on anything in particular that wasn't accurate, but he just

0:12:10said he wouldn't be comfortable.

0:12:11And I said, well, I've got other friends.

0:12:15And I do.

0:12:18I have two of my best friends, and I think you're going to be very, very happy.

0:12:24I think we're going to have a very good conversation.

0:12:26So without any further ado, Joanna Stern and Neelai Patel.

0:12:34Neelai's playing the role of Craig, and I'm doing Jaws.

0:12:59No, no, Jaws sits far further to just sort of jump in and...

0:13:05So I have to interrupt you before you might answer a question.

0:13:07Yes.

0:13:08That's my word.

0:13:08I should have let the gray hair grow out.

0:13:11The Verge does a great thing with tech keynotes.

0:13:21They'll take, for example, Google I.O. in 29 minutes, right?

0:13:26I think that was what it came down to.

0:13:27You'll take a long thing and sort of cut it down to the bones.

0:13:33From yesterday's keynote, Apple did Apple Intelligence in four minutes.

0:13:43So I feel like they did the editing job for the Verge.

0:13:47Yeah.

0:13:47A lot of the big tech companies have just stolen our moves.

0:13:50Like, they do their own live vlogs now.

0:13:52They do their own supercuts.

0:13:54They try to tell their own jokes.

0:13:57You know, like you do.

0:14:00And in particular, that we made a supercut of our own show has always struck me as being like,

0:14:06you know it could have just been shorter then, right?

0:14:08Well, I don't think the Apple Intelligence segment yesterday could have been much shorter.

0:14:15Well, it was diffused throughout the entire...

0:14:18All of Apple is Apple Intelligence now.

0:14:20What did you think about that, about them leading with Apple Intelligence

0:14:24and Craig Federighi just sort of recapping last year's announcement?

0:14:29You know, I think it's somewhat straight on.

0:14:34You know, some of the stuff we did, we announced recently was going to ship in the coming year.

0:14:40And we look forward to talking about it later.

0:14:42And then just rip the Band-Aid off and be done with it.

0:14:45Well, actually, can I just answer this question like a politician?

0:14:49Hi, everybody.

0:14:49I'm Yala Patel.

0:14:50He's running for Congress.

0:14:52Yes.

0:14:53Please vote Patel.

0:14:54I promise all the phones will have USB-C soon.

0:14:57We will take the fight to Europe and win.

0:15:00I just want to say, John and Joanna and I all came up in the same sort of era of web publishing.

0:15:06And we had no access when we started.

0:15:08Joanna's access was like getting netbook scoops.

0:15:11And this is like a thing that Joanna and I talked about all the time.

0:15:14Like, MSI doesn't know what's going to hit them.

0:15:15We're going to leak the new wind.

0:15:16We built our careers on this.

0:15:21And the fact that any of us have any access now, and all of us have varying levels of lots of access, is cool.

0:15:25It is not the point.

0:15:27And John has built an entire career on not getting access and not needing the access.

0:15:31And the less you need, the more you get.

0:15:33And everyone is going to learn that lesson throughout the next year.

0:15:36I am confident in it.

0:15:37So I just want to say that to you, John.

0:15:38Thank you, Nei.

0:15:39Well, they are talking to some press.

0:15:52And in fact, Joanna, you had Craig and Jaws on.

0:15:56You see, there are varying levels of access on the stage.

0:16:00When they asked me, I was like, this is going to be awkward.

0:16:03I was like, yeah, I'm going to have to tell John.

0:16:07And I, yeah.

0:16:08But the back story of this interview that you did with Jaws and Federighi is kind of weird, right?

0:16:20It's definitely weird.

0:16:21It came together very last minute.

0:16:22They asked me to do this yesterday, which is not a lot of time to prepare for an interview.

0:16:28You've been preparing for this interview for, like, probably a year now.

0:16:32Forty years.

0:16:33Forty years.

0:16:34Yeah.

0:16:35Yeah, that's right.

0:16:36That's when I was, we were born.

0:16:37And so, yes, it came together very last minute.

0:16:42But, of course, I knew, you know, really what I wanted to focus on was just the fallout of Apple intelligence

0:16:47and exactly how you sort of kicked this off, which was yesterday.

0:16:50This wasn't a big focus.

0:16:51A year ago, you know, the kind of crazy thing is that maybe one of the biggest products of this WWDC

0:16:58has been the fact that last year's products didn't ship.

0:17:01Right.

0:17:01There is a clip from Joanna's, and you're, at least, there might be a longer version of this that comes out.

0:17:12Yes, today we, I shot this this morning at 8 a.m.

0:17:15It's been a very long day.

0:17:17We were at Apple Park at 6 a.m., so we cut quickly what the Apple intelligence part of this was

0:17:24and a lot of talk about Siri, and then we will publish a longer bit about iPads and liquid glass and all the things.

0:17:31All right, but before we play the clip, just, but, like, how far in advance do you usually set up

0:17:37or get noticed that you'll get an interview like this?

0:17:40Maybe a week or so.

0:17:44I mean, it depends.

0:17:44I mean, it depends if it's breaking news and there's, you know, something Apple's responding to.

0:17:49You know, years ago there was the CSAM response, right?

0:17:53And they put out the product and then they pulled it back, and so that was an interview I did probably within 48 hours.

0:18:00Right.

0:18:00But, um, last time I spoke, probably a week or so.

0:18:04Yeah.

0:18:05And, like...

0:18:06But, I mean, in this case, like, I guess how...

0:18:08I didn't know what the news was until yesterday, right?

0:18:11Maybe they could have gotten up on stage and said, actually, we were shipping all the new Siri stuff and brand new Siri's here.

0:18:17I mean, we had a hunch that wasn't going to happen.

0:18:18So I'm not sure if all the extra time would have helped.

0:18:22And, you know, AI's doing all the question writing now, so I don't need...

0:18:27All right.

0:18:28I don't need much time.

0:18:29But we do have about a 90-second clip from the interview that I really want to talk about.

0:18:34So can we play the clip?

0:18:36So many people associate Apple and AI with Siri since about 10 years ago now.

0:18:43Sure.

0:18:44And so there is a real expectation that Siri should be as good, if not better, than the non-vision.

0:18:51Okay, well, we...

0:18:52That's certainly our mission.

0:18:55Yeah.

0:18:55That's our mission.

0:18:57You know, we set out to tell people last year where we were going.

0:19:01I think people were very excited about Apple's values there, an experience that's integrated into everything you do,

0:19:09not a bolt-on chatbot on the side, something that is personal, something that is private.

0:19:14We started building some of those and delivering some of those capabilities.

0:19:18I, in a way, appreciate the fact that people really wanted the next version of Siri.

0:19:25And we really want to deliver it for them.

0:19:27But we want to do it the right way.

0:19:29When's the right way going to come up?

0:19:30Well, we really want to make sure that we have it very much in hand before we start talking about dates for obvious reasons.

0:19:37And will that include these features that you had previously announced and more?

0:19:42I mean, is this the effort to make Siri this more interactive AI companion?

0:19:47Well, I mean, on one hand, I would love to dish about my enthusiasm for our future plans, but that's exactly what we don't want to do right now, right?

0:19:56We set expectations.

0:19:59We want to deliver something great that you and all of our customers really appreciate.

0:20:03You know, the best thing to do when you make a mistake is to address the mistake and not do it again.

0:20:27And, but it's, it's almost striking how, and I thought, you know, it's not, you know, Craig is Craig and he's very smooth.

0:20:39But it's, I love that for obvious reasons.

0:20:44We don't, we don't want to promise a date until we're really sure we're going to do it.

0:20:50But you would have thought those reasons were just as obvious a year ago.

0:20:54Well, so they, they, they've done a few interviews, um, and they have, they have an explanation now that they're going with in the way that like you could take all of the answers from all the interviews, put them into an LLM and then interview the LLM and like have a substantive conversation.

0:21:09Um, and so the answer is they, it's not offensive.

0:21:13It's not offensive.

0:21:14You are not the problem.

0:21:16You're also writing a book about letting AI take over your life.

0:21:18It's true.

0:21:19It's true.

0:21:19Okay.

0:21:19Please buy it next year.

0:21:23Uh, so the, the, the framework of the answer is they, they set off down one path and that was, they are very mad at John for suggesting that they did not show real code.

0:21:32Uh, and that is in John setting an area, which we should talk about this narrative that is taken hold, but they set off down one path and that was what they demoed last year.

0:21:40And they somehow realized that wasn't going to have the quality bar and they set off on a new path and you can listen to Craig and Jaws say this in various interviews.

0:21:48Um, I think the thing that is really interesting is the whole rest of the industry has identified the path that they want to be on for an assistant that can take actions across various apps and services on your behalf.

0:22:01And the word Apple won't use is agent.

0:22:03Like they just never talk about Siri as an agent that will go do stuff for you.

0:22:08But then you go watch that demo from last year and it's just doing agent stuff.

0:22:11Right.

0:22:12You're like, what's in my email?

0:22:12And it's like, here, I'm going to go do your email.

0:22:14I'm going to go book you a car.

0:22:15Whatever you see in all of these demos, the whole rest of the industry is like, these are agents and here's how we're going to build them.

0:22:21Here are the standards we're going to use.

0:22:23And like all these like technical words, it's a room full of developers.

0:22:25MCP, they're going to, they're going to do all this stuff.

0:22:28And then we're going to have to reorganize the business models of the web to make this happen.

0:22:31Apple is like, we're going to do Siri app intents.

0:22:34And it's basically the same stuff, but we can't use all the same words because people get confused.

0:22:38And the question that I have is when did they realize that the architecture was wrong?

0:22:45Because I think the whole industry picked the other architecture already and they're building it in public.

0:22:52And they're, no one has done this well, right?

0:22:54Alexa, they claim that a million people have Alexa plus.

0:22:57Does one person in this room have Alexa plus?

0:22:59We can't see.

0:23:01No, the wheezing side does not count.

0:23:03You have to actually say yes.

0:23:06You have to say it and shout it.

0:23:07You do?

0:23:07Really?

0:23:08Is it any good?

0:23:09Get that person up on stage.

0:23:17He's the one person with Alexa.

0:23:19Better than Alexa is a low bar.

0:23:23Is that Panos Panay?

0:23:24Do you work for Amazon?

0:23:26Okay.

0:23:29Thank you, Mr. Bezos.

0:23:30So there's like a million people out there having whatever experience that is with Alexa.

0:23:38By the way, Bezos wanted a free ticket.

0:23:43Google announced a whole bunch of stuff that Gemini can do in Project Mariner, which is going to run Chrome in the cloud and click around on TaskRabbit for you.

0:23:49Microsoft has all these ideas about MCB.

0:23:51They're all doing it.

0:23:52You can go use computer use on OpenAI and it's slow and broken.

0:23:55But they're like, here's the mechanism by which we're going to do this.

0:23:58Apple hasn't demonstrated any of that.

0:24:01And the thing that they're saying is, we got it wrong.

0:24:03The first cut was wrong.

0:24:05It was never going to be good enough and we had to invest in the second cut.

0:24:07But they won't say what they got wrong or what the new approach is.

0:24:11And I think that's going to lead to a lot of confusion down the road.

0:24:14If it turns out every app and service has to not use what the rest of the industry is using and they have to use weird Apple stuff.

0:24:21And it's not that Apple can't get people to use weird Apple stuff.

0:24:24Objective C, right?

0:24:25They're very good at getting people to use weird Apple stuff.

0:24:29Weird in a cool way.

0:24:30Yeah, not weird like Sony memory card formats.

0:24:35Weird like Apple is like our standard is better and we have the install base so you've got to deal with it.

0:24:40But I really mean it with Objective C.

0:24:43I never got into coding it myself, but I have many, many dear friends who absolutely love it.

0:24:49Some who still love it.

0:24:50I know Gus is out there somewhere.

0:24:52Who also got in the keynote, by the way, Acorn.

0:24:56But that's a perfect example though, right?

0:25:00I mean, let's just face it.

0:25:02Nobody else ever used Objective C other than Next and then Apple.

0:25:05Anyway, but the place you would point out, like here's our new architecture and here's what you have to do to let your app or service

0:25:13be addressed by our agent is at the Worldwide Developers Conference and that it still, I think, remains as opaque as ever.

0:25:19And that's the disconnect for me in all of the messaging about why we got it wrong.

0:25:24Because you would correct it by saying, and here's how we're going to make sure it works when it actually hits, is that all of these apps and services will connect to it.

0:25:33What did you think during the interview?

0:25:34Did you think they wanted to talk about that or did they, did you think they knew you were going to ask them?

0:25:38I think they knew.

0:25:40I mean, they're, and what Neal is mapping out is, he's right.

0:25:43A lot, they answered this very similarly across the interviews where they talked about the one of this architecture.

0:25:47They actually had it.

0:25:49We, I asked very clearly in, in one of the questions, you know, was this actually code?

0:25:54Was this at, or was this vaporware?

0:25:55Jaws said very clearly, this was not just demo where it was actually running.

0:26:00But that we, we started using it.

0:26:02We had a lot of errors.

0:26:03We went down a path.

0:26:04And Craig also says in the interview, especially when Siri, you know, you go off path with it.

0:26:10Right.

0:26:10And so if you were asking things that weren't directly, you know, Siri speak, it sounds like things were kind of going off path.

0:26:16And so now they moved to a V2, as Neal is explaining really well.

0:26:20And I think they're right in not wanting to talk about this right now.

0:26:26I do too.

0:26:26Right.

0:26:27They've learned some lessons of the last year.

0:26:30They learned it.

0:26:30They, they learned it.

0:26:32I think they were going to learn it.

0:26:33But I think especially your piece was extremely impactful, which is why did this happen?

0:26:38How does this happen at this type of company?

0:26:40Why is the marketing happening?

0:26:41And I think then you sort of look ahead and you can look at what happened to Amazon.

0:26:45They had a very similar issue.

0:26:47I mean, they announced, it wasn't even Alexa Plus at that time.

0:26:50It was this generative AI Alexa two years ago.

0:26:54They realized it's hard and that's nothing.

0:26:56And then they just do another launch event in February.

0:26:59Was that February?

0:27:00And only this guy has it.

0:27:02And I, I do think that.

0:27:08I mean, that guy, we must speak to you.

0:27:15I've been on social media asking people all the time, do you have this?

0:27:18And no one has it.

0:27:19I, I actually have an Echo 95, whatever the big screen is in my kitchen waiting for it.

0:27:27I'm like every day.

0:27:28I'm like, are you there, Alexa Plus?

0:27:29Anyway, this is not about Alexa.

0:27:33I do think it's really telling though, that last year's keynote had like 40 minutes of Apple intelligence.

0:27:41And it, you know, they needed to introduce it.

0:27:43They wanted the brand name.

0:27:44And I, I, it had to be a certain length, but that's an extraordinary length for something that is not one of their platforms.

0:27:54You know, their platforms are, correspond to their devices.

0:27:57That is what Apple does.

0:27:59They sell phones.

0:28:00They sell iPads.

0:28:01They sell Macs.

0:28:02They sell, uh, Vision Pro.

0:28:05They sell Apple TV.

0:28:06Those are the, are watches.

0:28:08They sell platforms and last year they spent 40 minutes on Apple intelligence.

0:28:15And then like the parts that were the most memorable, you know, that's, that's the other thing that I find in these interviews is, and what I tried to put my finger on writing about it is it's not just like, oh, they announced 10 things and four of the 10 things didn't ship and are going to be postponed.

0:28:36They correspond directly to how impressive they are and how uniquely positioned Apple is to do them, right?

0:28:43Like nobody else is going to get a semantic index on everybody's iPhone that can be queried running locally on device.

0:28:52They, and yet this year with only four minutes up front for the whole dedicated Apple intelligence segment, I thought the keynote as a whole was way stronger on AI and LLM than last year's.

0:29:07And because it was done in the context of Apple's own platforms, apps, and features.

0:29:14Oh, I totally agree.

0:29:15There is more AI stuff in this keynote.

0:29:18I actually think the Apple intelligence branding has set them back in a way, right?

0:29:24When, when people think about AI right now, they think about Sam Altman, OpenAI, and Chachi Petit trying to marry Kevin Roos on the front page in the New York Times.

0:29:33I'm never going to stop making this joke.

0:29:35And Kevin knows it, and I thank him for letting me do it.

0:29:37And, like, people are having real relationships with this technology, for good or bad.

0:29:45I think for mostly bad.

0:29:46Joanna's writing a book.

0:29:47We're going to see how it goes.

0:29:50Like, that is the thing.

0:29:52Like, you talk to the computer, and the computer talks to you.

0:29:54That's the thing that everyone thinks is the new user interface paradigm.

0:29:58They think that will lead to the platform shift.

0:30:00That's the re-architecture of the very concept of an API.

0:30:03And, like, all this stuff is down to, oh, we have natural language computers now.

0:30:07This is the thing that's going to change everything.

0:30:09It might replace the phone.

0:30:10Johnny Abb is going to build you a necklace that sees God.

0:30:12Sure.

0:30:13Right?

0:30:14He might.

0:30:17He might.

0:30:20And Apple is, like, Apple intelligence is, like, you can take a picture of a sloth and

0:30:24a light bulb, and, like, you're, you're, the thing.

0:30:31Is that a feature?

0:30:31That's a feature.

0:30:32You missed it?

0:30:32No, the emoji.

0:30:33Yeah.

0:30:34Yeah.

0:30:34I did not miss that.

0:30:36You make it look like the sloth is having a great idea.

0:30:38Yeah, yeah, yeah.

0:30:39Okay, yeah.

0:30:39No, it's that you are slow to get the joke.

0:30:41This is what I mean, like, this is not a good way to communicate.

0:30:44Like, genius sloth or kind of stupid is, like, all in the same picture, man.

0:30:50So, Apple intelligence, the reason I think they had to announce, like, a Siri, because

0:30:54that's what people want.

0:30:55They want to just talk to their phone and have the phone do stuff.

0:30:58And that was the promise of the original Siri.

0:31:01That was the promise of Google Assistant.

0:31:02That was the promise of Dear Sweet Bixby.

0:31:05Yeah.

0:31:06And Cortana.

0:31:07And Cortana.

0:31:08That is the promise of Gemini and Samsung phones today.

0:31:11You can be, like, turn off the Bluetooth.

0:31:12And it's, like, maybe.

0:31:13And, like, you know?

0:31:15And, like, all that is the thing.

0:31:19Like, that's where you've got to point it.

0:31:21And all of this other stuff that they're branding as Apple intelligence, I think, ultimately does

0:31:25that stuff a disservice.

0:31:27Because it makes it small.

0:31:28And some of it is actually, like, huge.

0:31:31Right?

0:31:32The idea that there's an LLM in shortcuts that you can just access is, like, kind of huge.

0:31:37For this crowd.

0:31:38The idea that Spotlight is now basically a Raycast clone.

0:31:43But it can also, which it is.

0:31:46The Raycast people said to David Pierce today, like, we welcome Apple to validate our idea.

0:31:52And it's, like, oh, no.

0:31:52You're in danger.

0:31:55But, like, that new Spotlight that has some natural language capabilities is kind of cool.

0:32:05It's, like, that is the future of a whole interaction paradigm.

0:32:08And I just think Apple intelligence makes the things that are easy or the things that Apple's capable of doing

0:32:14seem so small compared to the thing that it can't.

0:32:16And that branding, I think, is going to have to change.

0:32:18Yeah.

0:32:18I'm going to pivot off that because you were mentioning the time, right?

0:32:22And, actually, Craig specifically responded to that.

0:32:25And I'm sure it's in part because of some of what you wrote.

0:32:27But he said today, back with last year's keynote, we spent 40 minutes on Apple intelligence

0:32:33and the 100-minute show.

0:32:35Siri was building on Apple intelligence.

0:32:36We spent, oh, no, Siri's triggering.

0:32:38We spent eight minutes on Siri there, right?

0:32:43And four of those minutes we weren't able to ship.

0:32:45And I tried to push back on this, but I think it's exactly what Neelai's saying, which is,

0:32:50and you heard it in that question I asked.

0:32:53For Apple, AI and Siri are linked together since the beginning of time or whenever Siri was announced, right?

0:33:01And so that is the expectation.

0:33:03We want a great Siri because we know that Siri is not great now, as you also heard me say in that question.

0:33:09Yeah, and I think the other thing that's really come into focus for me, and your interview, you really emphasized the point,

0:33:15is Apple often says, and I think it is the correct philosophy for Apple, that they don't aim to be first, they aim to be best.

0:33:23And famously, you know, the iPhone didn't, the first iPhone didn't even support 3G, right?

0:33:30It was on the Edge network, and it was like the sort of people who were deeply informed about the state of the art of smartphones in 2006, 2007,

0:33:41were like, this is ridiculous, it doesn't even support 3G, and, you know, and they were late to LTE, 4G, whatever you want to call it, right?

0:33:49They were still shipping 3G phones when, you know, that's just not what Apple does.

0:33:54But then when they do come out with a 4G phone or the 5G or the, you know, they do it in a battery efficient manner.

0:34:02That was Apple's big contribution to 5G, not robot surgery.

0:34:06Right.

0:34:06Well, and also having that introduction where they had the guy from Verizon come out and say, 5G, 5G, have you heard about 5G, 5G?

0:34:14That was great, yeah.

0:34:15But with Siri, or just with talking to your computer and getting intelligent answers, they kind of were first, right?

0:34:24This is sort of a weird thing, and it is going back 15 years.

0:34:29But when Siri came out, I think on the iPhone 4S, it was sort of a sensation.

0:34:35It was, and in reporting that has come out since, you know, Steve Jobs was personally super, super invested.

0:34:44There was a story, I forget who wrote it recently, where, I forget his last name, but Dag somebody, he was one of the founders of Siri before they got acquired.

0:34:52And Steve Jobs, you know, had him over for dinner and said, you know, I think we want to buy your company.

0:34:58He's like, ah, I think we want to stay independent.

0:35:00And then Steve Jobs called him 37 days in a row.

0:35:03Yeah.

0:35:04Yeah.

0:35:05And it's like, there was, like, very few people on the planet who could call any other person on the planet 36 days in a row.

0:35:14And then on the 37th, you see the caller ID, and you're like, oh, I'm still going to answer, right?

0:35:18Steve Jobs is one of them, right?

0:35:20You know, like, and then you're like, all right, I'll sell this.

0:35:23I should take the money.

0:35:24Right.

0:35:24But it's, you know, it was the last phone that was introduced while Steve Jobs was alive.

0:35:32It was very near the end.

0:35:33But he spent, like, the last year of his life apparently very, very keenly thinking, this is the future of our interfaces.

0:35:41Like, really sort of had zoned in, like, in a way that he turned his attention from the Mac and the iPod to the iPhone.

0:35:47It was like, this is it.

0:35:49This touch is it.

0:35:50And this is the next few years.

0:35:51And then at the very end, it was like, this is it.

0:35:54And it was a sensation for consumers.

0:35:56They were first.

0:35:57So people do expect that, you know, and people do use Siri all the time.

0:36:02And that's where I really, and I regret not having time to ask this question, but where you look at the incumbents and the fact that they have to rebuild, right?

0:36:13They don't have this fresh start.

0:36:14They don't have, you know, a field in front of them with nothing in it.

0:36:17They've got to take what has been there.

0:36:19And that's what you're seeing with Alexa.

0:36:20That's what you're seeing with Google in some ways with Google Assistant and meshing these.

0:36:24And, you know, open AIs can just start brand new.

0:36:27And you can have this assistant that, yeah, sure, doesn't always tell the truth.

0:36:30And it doesn't control anything in your house.

0:36:32And it doesn't do all these other things, which is they don't also have the billion-plus user baggage.

0:36:37Well, they have a lot of users now.

0:36:39I mean, the problem with the original Siri and, like, you know, the knock on it for the past decade is that, like, it's not very good, right?

0:36:47And what they mean by it's not very good, and this is true of every statistic I think of every voice assistant we've ever covered, people use them to set timers.

0:36:54And to play music.

0:36:55And then everything else is brittle.

0:36:56Right?

0:36:57And open the garage.

0:36:58And Joanne and I, in particular, open and close each other's garages at will.

0:37:01Shout out to Miros, official sponsor of Milai and Joanne.

0:37:11And it's that brittleness that I think has kept adoption low.

0:37:14No one's been able to solve it.

0:37:15And LLMs might solve it, except that LLMs aren't reliable.

0:37:17And then you see, oh, it actually doesn't matter if they're reliable because everyone will just talk to ChatGPT all day long.

0:37:23And that's the thing that has everyone excited.

0:37:25And I think these big platform companies are realizing, well, if the assistant doesn't get it right, or if the assistant lies to you but an action is taken, that's even more brittle.

0:37:34Right?

0:37:35And in some cases, dangerous.

0:37:36And I think that's the wall that they've hit over and over again.

0:37:39Yes, Apple said they were going to ship a thing that they didn't ship.

0:37:42But, like, all the other companies have all promised they're going to ship a thing that they haven't been able to ship.

0:37:46Right?

0:37:47And the only difference is that you can play with the broken ones from the other companies.

0:37:51And that's not Apple.

0:37:53And I think that's what got them in trouble.

0:37:55They're like, oh, everyone else is doing, like, this, like, quasi-vapor stuff.

0:37:57Like, we'll do it, too.

0:37:58And then they're shipping in public, and Apple isn't.

0:38:02And that has put them at a disadvantage.

0:38:03I think it's also, like, the fact that the other Apple intelligence features.

0:38:08I mean, I think if we could see anyone's hands, like, a show of hands of how many people are actually using Apple intelligence features.

0:38:13Probably not that many.

0:38:15Any show of hands out there?

0:38:17Oh, we got the lights on this time.

0:38:18All right.

0:38:19We've got some.

0:38:19Vastly more than the Alexa people.

0:38:21I have to say.

0:38:22We've got some.

0:38:24But I think that that was a big criticism as well.

0:38:27Yeah.

0:38:27Right?

0:38:28Like, maybe you're not using writing tools or Genmo.

0:38:31I mean, I'd love to have a deep focus group with these people about if you're using Genmoji every day.

0:38:37But, you know, I think that was also the criticism.

0:38:40Right.

0:38:41And Image Playground is another perfect example.

0:38:44I mean, and you guys are in this.

0:38:45You know, we do the same thing.

0:38:46And throughout the last 12 months, when they'd be introducing new products, maybe it's the MacBook Air or the MacBook Pros or it's new iPads came out.

0:38:56And there's always a briefing and there's a prepared demo.

0:39:01Look what you can do.

0:39:01And every single one of them for every product had some part where it's like, and now, you know, I'm making an invitation for my daughter's 12th birthday party.

0:39:10Why don't I go to Image Playground and make a picture of her doing something?

0:39:14And it's like, I don't know anybody in the real world who used Image Playground to do anything.

0:39:19And it's just not – if you were going to use AI to generate a picture like that, Image Playground over the last 12 months was not only not best of breed, it really wasn't even competitive.

0:39:34Yeah, but, you know, there are tens of millions of people doing that in ChatGPT.

0:39:37Right.

0:39:37Right, and that's the – I think that's just the problem is OpenAI is just able to fail in a very different way, right, because they're perceived as new.

0:39:46But also, like, they're releasing new features in public constantly.

0:39:50Right.

0:39:51Right, they're like, here's another thing they can do now.

0:39:53And whether or not that thing is good, like, they're just moving forward in a way that doesn't require their product to be complete.

0:40:00And I – you know, and just to stick with it, with Image Playground, one of the – the thing that really stuck out to me yesterday in the keynote was that they said, like, the big new change for Image Playground this year is that one of the options is, like, you know, you could do, like, Pixar style, but they have a new name for it, you know, illustration style.

0:40:19And then there's, like, just have ChatGPT do it.

0:40:22And that's what they demoed.

0:40:25And so you could have, like, an oil painting of, you know, one of your friends.

0:40:29And it looks really like an oil painting, and it's really good.

0:40:31And I saw some other demos over the last two days in briefings, and the pictures you get when you choose the ChatGPT image going through Image Playground are much higher quality.

0:40:41And it's like, yeah, Apple, you don't have to do it all, you know?

0:40:45If there's something better out there, just use the better thing.

0:40:48And that was missing last year.

0:40:51There was sort of a very, very decided, we can do this all ourselves, like, a not invented here thing that didn't make sense, and that now it seems like they're pretending they never did.

0:41:05Well, I think, like, also last year, no one knew what people were going to use any of this stuff for, and there's at least a year of that.

0:41:14You know, I'll just compare it to Google I.O., which was a couple weeks ago.

0:41:17I was out here for that.

0:41:18Google announced 50 million AI features.

0:41:20And they have a lot of the same advantages as Apple.

0:41:23In particular, I think one of the ways you can think about who will win the personal assistant race is who has your email.

0:41:31Because your email is becoming this, like, place for incoming signal about the world in a really interesting place.

0:41:37Right?

0:41:38The AI is like, I figured out what time you're going to land, and I've booked you a car, and I made here's the directions to your hotel, whatever else it's going to do.

0:41:44All of that is information that arrives in your email inbox in a way that makes your email inbox just a weird messaging center for a robot.

0:41:52Weird.

0:41:53I don't know how this is going to play out.

0:41:55Google has that, too.

0:41:57Like, a lot of what Google announced was, like, oh, we can read your fucking Gmail.

0:42:00And they can.

0:42:03They're really good at it, it turns out.

0:42:06And they have a lot of people's Gmail, and they also have Google Maps.

0:42:09And they have all these other web services, and they can just, like, build the thing in the cloud.

0:42:12And they're like, here it is, we just, like, connected the dots.

0:42:14And, like, I saw people at I.O. being like, oh, this is everything Apple announced at Apple Intelligence last year,

0:42:21and Google's going to actually ship it because they can just connect the dots in the cloud and, like, give it to everyone.

0:42:25Google has to actually ship it.

0:42:27They seem very confident that they will.

0:42:29But that is the platform shift, right?

0:42:31The danger for Apple a long time ago was the iPhone become a vessel for Google services, and they fought back against that in various ways.

0:42:37I think the danger for them now is, well, there's another provider that has a lot of people's emails.

0:42:42And that personal data store is really, really important as we think about where the information about your world comes and goes.

0:42:49Apple has other advantages, right?

0:42:51They've got email, they've got iMessage, they've got all this other stuff.

0:42:53But you can just see, like, oh, the other company is ahead because they've built their entire platform in the cloud,

0:42:57and they can just rev it really fast.

0:43:02I do think that the way they broke it down this year, by not having, here's Apple Intelligence, here's 40 minutes of features,

0:43:10and instead sprinkling the features throughout the rest of the keynote.

0:43:14There is a lot of good stuff.

0:43:16Some of the stuff that, you know, I think I missed some stuff on this card, but the call screening and hold assist stuff in the phone.

0:43:24Now, that is catch up.

0:43:25I love that.

0:43:26That is catch up to Google, like the call screening.

0:43:28But I was not expecting that from Apple this year, I have to say, even though I really think it's a cool feature.

0:43:36Have you used it?

0:43:37I didn't use it.

0:43:38Not with the Apple stuff, but like the...

0:43:39Oh, I've used the Google versions.

0:43:41Yeah, I was very excited to see that.

0:43:42I was also excited, the live translation.

0:43:44I mean, those are things we also have had across other platforms, Google, Microsoft.

0:43:48But, yeah, I'm very excited about calls.

0:43:51I love making phone calls.

0:43:52Yeah.

0:43:56This is what I mean, by the way.

0:43:57That stuff seems small in comparison to the thing that they didn't ship.

0:44:00Right.

0:44:01But those things are genuinely useful quality of life features.

0:44:03Right.

0:44:03They rely on a whole bunch of ML algorithms and AI and all this other stuff that you need.

0:44:07Right.

0:44:07And I think that's always been Apple's bread and butter is like, oh, you know, just lots and lots of really little nice touches everywhere.

0:44:17And it's like you can't pinpoint one of them and say, well, this is a big colossal changes the industry feature.

0:44:22But it's like when you have them all across the platform, that's what makes using Apple stuff using Apple stuff.

0:44:28I think the visual intelligence stuff, too, was huge, even though that is tapping into various other apps and mostly ChatGPT or Google.

0:44:36I think that was a great example, too, of Apple controls the camera, right?

0:44:40This is the camera you use.

0:44:42And so they're going to provide that platform right there for you.

0:44:45And I find myself using either ChatGPT or Google Lens all the time.

0:44:50And so, I mean, they've had some of this in visual intelligence, but bringing that more forward, I think, was another big Apple intelligence feature that wasn't labeled as such.

0:45:00Yeah.

0:45:00And that's one of the next items on my list here is the addition of screenshots to visual intelligence this year, which I think is a great feature.

0:45:10It is, if you're old enough, you know, I remember, it wasn't that long ago where it seemed like only the nerds really knew how to take screenshots and knew what screenshots were.

0:45:22No matter what platform you're talking about, it's like normal people, I don't know, it's like, why would I take a, why would I snap a frame from my screen?

0:45:31Why would I do that?

0:45:32Whereas nerds, we've always been doing it for a zillion reasons.

0:45:36But now it's like, I don't know anybody who doesn't know how to take a screenshot on their phone because people take screenshots on their phone.

0:45:41Also because if you squeeze the phone too tightly, it just happens.

0:45:43But it is sort of the, it's like the escape hatch for sharing, right?

0:45:51Where it's like, you don't have to learn the path to share, you know, cause some apps just use the system share sheet, but a lot of apps, especially like meta apps and X, you know, the, want you to use their share thing.

0:46:08And then in their share thing is a share button that then brings up the system share.

0:46:13People just take a screenshot and then they share because it's here.

0:46:17This is on my screen.

0:46:18I want to send it to Neelai and Joanna screenshot text, Neelai and Joanna.

0:46:24Look at this, you know.

0:46:25Yeah.

0:46:26I think it's like fascinating that Apple is training a bunch of people already to screenshot, to extract text.

0:46:33Right.

0:46:33I do that.

0:46:35I do that all the time.

0:46:36A TikTok interaction that I could write a PhD thesis about that I saw recently was like one of those like, here's a product I like.

0:46:42And someone was like, where did you buy it?

0:46:44And they pasted an Amazon link.

0:46:45And someone was like, I can't click that.

0:46:47And the reply was, take a screenshot and select the text and paste it.

0:46:50This is bad.

0:46:53Make the links work, TikTok.

0:46:56But like they're training a lot of people to do that.

0:47:00And that means when they add more capabilities to the screenshot feature, more people will use them.

0:47:04And this is a very rich environment.

0:47:06In fairness, I will say that Google has had variations on this feature for so long that I think Dieter wrote the first story about it for us in hieroglyphics.

0:47:15Like, straightforwardly, this is a hundred-year-old feature on the Android side.

0:47:18It has had 5,000 different names and has convinced approximately zero people to switch from the iPhone to Android over the years.

0:47:25But they're pulling from like a rich body of like use cases and attempts to make this really good that I think will let them just like make it obvious to people or intuitive to people in a very Apple way.

0:47:37But they're also with visual intelligence.

0:47:39The screenshots is a big deal, but they're also allowing other apps to tap into that, right?

0:47:43That's where I was talking about the camera.

0:47:44So if you snap a photo, I think the one example is Etsy, maybe?

0:47:49Yeah, yeah.

0:47:49Yeah.

0:47:50Okay.

0:47:50Like any no search demo can end without a transaction.

0:47:54It's like the iron law of commerce on the internet.

0:47:57Like, what do you want to search for?

0:47:58Shit to buy.

0:47:59Yeah.

0:47:59And like, nothing else.

0:48:00Right.

0:48:0130% straight to my pockets.

0:48:03Right.

0:48:03But like, I buy crap for my kids all the time that way.

0:48:07Yeah.

0:48:08I love that toy.

0:48:09In my role as Greg Joswiak, I thank you for your 30%.

0:48:11But one of the other little interesting things, and I think it is a, seems subtle, but to me is not subtle, but is, ah, yeah, we should just let them do it.

0:48:25This is a serious course correction over 12 months is, um, when you do the screenshot for visual intelligence at the bottom, in the middle is where, if it looks like if you're screenshotting, ah, like a Instagram post with a concert and a date and a time, there'll be like, add to calendar in the middle.

0:48:45But over on the bottom left, there's always a button that says ask, and ask is like where you get to type a natural language query.

0:48:53The ask button for screenshots always goes to chat GPT.

0:48:58And so it's your choice as the user, whether you want to be signed into an account or not.

0:49:05And if you're not, then you're anonymous and Apple proxies your query through a redirect.

0:49:10So they don't even know your IP address.

0:49:13Apple vouches that it's completely private.

0:49:15And if you listen to the story behind it, it sure sounds totally private to me.

0:49:19And if you want to be signed in and maybe you pay 20 bucks a month for chat GPT, it'll use your account.

0:49:25You'll get the extra tokens or the better model that you have access to, and it'll be in your chat GPT app's history.

0:49:32But there, there's none of that.

0:49:35Well, we'll take a look at the screen and figure out if we could do it with one of our local models,

0:49:40or maybe we'll send it to our private cloud compute.

0:49:43And if it seems really complex, then we'll send it to chat GPT.

0:49:47It's just, no, it just goes to chat GPT.

0:49:50This is something chat GPT nails.

0:49:52And why are we even trying?

0:49:55We're not going to beat them.

0:49:56So why don't we just send them all to chat GPT?

0:49:58And they didn't have that kind of story last year.

0:50:00Everything was always, well, you know, we don't want to say because we're going to adjust the weights of it, you know,

0:50:06but maybe some of it will be local and some of it we'll do to our private cloud compute and complex stuff will go to chat GPT.

0:50:12No, that ask button is just chat GPT.

0:50:15Simple.

0:50:15And that way, even as a user, you just know what you're going to get.

0:50:18Yeah.

0:50:19So, you know, one of the, that stuff is really hard.

0:50:22You know, Google's good at it, too.

0:50:23They've had visual search forever.

0:50:24Last year they announced, and they basically all but confirmed,

0:50:28that, like, Gemini would be right there as a model alongside chat GPT.

0:50:33It hasn't happened yet.

0:50:34They seem to be leaning more and more into the relationship with OpenAI, which famously has hired Johnny Ive to compete with them.

0:50:42And there's just, like, some swirl of drama there that I think they prefer talking about not shipping Siri than any of that.

0:50:49They're like, just don't ask us about that.

0:50:52Like, yeah, we fucked it up real bad.

0:50:54Don't ask us about that.

0:50:55And I, that's going to be a weird one.

0:50:58Like, I do think they need to add more models to the mix to get away from this dependency.

0:51:03Yeah, I am a little surprised that here we are 12 months later and there is no Gemini because I thought it was a big tell last year where Federighi, like, right on day one, you know, was saying in interviews, like, even before my show, you know, was saying in interviews that, you know, it's an open architecture.

0:51:21We're talking to other people.

0:51:23We could have other partners in the future.

0:51:25And name drop Gemini in particular, which is a very unusual move for Apple.

0:51:30Like, and you know it wasn't an accident.

0:51:32And Mark Gurman and somebody else at Bloomberg recently in their sort of what went wrong with Siri piece reported that John Gianandrea wanted to go with Gemini all along and thought, I guess for the reason that he thought OpenAI, you know, maybe wasn't here for the long haul or something.

0:51:53But, you know, that there were voices in the company that were like, oh, no, if we're only going to do one, we should partner with Google.

0:51:58So I'm very surprised 12 months later, it's still just ChatGPT.

0:52:02But they're still talking about the fact that it is like they ask button in the few, you know, six months from now.

0:52:08Maybe there will be two options, you know.

0:52:11Really, when I think of Apple design, I think of those model pickers.

0:52:14And you just put those all through the operating system.

0:52:17Let's see.

0:52:23Oh, Workout Buddy.

0:52:24I'm into Workout Buddy.

0:52:27Yeah?

0:52:27Yeah.

0:52:28Yeah.

0:52:28Let's hear it for Workout Buddy.

0:52:30Now, see, I'm really playing the crack role.

0:52:32It's just that it's only one side of the room, I have to say.

0:52:35Those are the workout people.

0:52:36There's like a bunch of Peloton instructors over here.

0:52:39They're very fit.

0:52:40We can't see you at all.

0:52:41I think this is a great example of where they can go.

0:52:45And I wanted to ask about this today, too.

0:52:48This is a whole recap of things I didn't ask.

0:52:50But I think that intersection of Apple has this personal health and fitness data, combined with some sort of assistant, is a huge opportunity for them.

0:53:04Yeah.

0:53:04It's not an assistant.

0:53:05This is like the...

0:53:07It's a buddy.

0:53:08Yeah.

0:53:12Look, work is a family, Joanna.

0:53:16You can't talk to it.

0:53:20Yeah, you can't talk to it, but we will one day.

0:53:22Yes, as Craig Federini, one day you will be able to talk to it.

0:53:26No.

0:53:26But I think it's a step in that direction.

0:53:29What I don't like, and did you see it in one of the briefings?

0:53:32It's very nice.

0:53:35And if you don't...

0:53:38It won't tell you you haven't done as well as your last time.

0:53:43It's so Apple.

0:53:44It's like, we want to be nice.

0:53:45We want to be gentle with this.

0:53:46It's like, no, you did not fucking run as fast as you did yesterday.

0:53:50Speed it up.

0:53:52They said in my briefing that they said it as a selling point that it's always upbeat and

0:54:00it's always cheerful.

0:54:00That is not upbeat for me.

0:54:01And always encouraging.

0:54:02And I said, well, I raised my hand and, you know, it was like four or five of us.

0:54:06And I said, well, that's not a feature for me.

0:54:09I would rather have like, and they're like a drill sergeant.

0:54:12I'm like, no, not a drill sergeant.

0:54:13And I'm thinking like 1980s gym teacher, you know?

0:54:17I think Workout Buddy cuts the power to the PS5 and is like, get down there.

0:54:22Get to work.

0:54:23Like, I'm thinking back to like when I played high school basketball and the way my coach,

0:54:27you know, like beginning of the season when we were running wind sprints to get into shape.

0:54:31It wasn't like, hey, John, come on.

0:54:35You know?

0:54:36You want AI John Gruden just screaming at you.

0:54:39Gruber, come on.

0:54:40That's what got me running, you know?

0:54:45I just, like, this one to me is another one where it's basically just notifications, right?

0:54:50It's like keeping a timer about your pace and then telling you you did a good job.

0:54:54And there's a text-to-speech model that makes that happen.

0:54:56Sure.

0:54:57It's looking at data from your previous run or whatever Workout, but previous runs.

0:55:03This is a spreadsheet that can talk.

0:55:04Okay.

0:55:05That's a good first step.

0:55:07Maybe.

0:55:09I think people think that they can talk to the buddy and be like, am I on pace?

0:55:14And they might answer the question.

0:55:15And instead, it just, like, pops up in a chipper voice to be like, you're awesome.

0:55:19Right?

0:55:20It's like, all right.

0:55:22But I think I'm on Joanna's side.

0:55:24But where?

0:55:26I think there's just, I mean, in reporting's book, I think there's so much potential for this personalized health data.

0:55:32And it's been the promise of the Apple Watch for so long.

0:55:35I wear this thing.

0:55:36It knows so much about me.

0:55:38It's never given me that proactive information.

0:55:41And maybe combined with their models, someone else's models, that has the potential in the future.

0:55:46Well, I mean, let me ask you point blank.

0:55:49Do you think they should have shipped it this year or not?

0:55:51I think that a one-way workout buddy that you can't talk to interactively but gives you live, like, hey, you just, you know, you just crossed the 5K barrier, you know, for the sixth time this week.

0:56:04You know, as you cross the 5K barrier.

0:56:08I think that's something.

0:56:09I know people are falling in love with their laptops, right?

0:56:11Like, this is, we've crossed the line.

0:56:14Like, people have girlfriends that are robots now.

0:56:18If you say something's a buddy, I think the expectation for consumers is you can talk to it and it can talk to you.

0:56:24Like, there are entire companies that just can do this.

0:56:27And I, that's the, I just think that for, especially for the younger consumer that talks to chat GPT all day long, like, that's the expectation.

0:56:37So, like, whether or not they should have shipped it or whether it's useful, I think you call it a buddy or you, like, have a button in the app that's, like, start your buddy.

0:56:43I think the expectation is, like, a two-way street, not just, like, a chipper spreadsheet.

0:56:50But, like, maybe, like, all the other fitness apps are doing it, right?

0:56:53The Runkeepers have done something like this for a long time.

0:56:55But, like, I just, you all know that people think they're in love with their phones.

0:56:59Like, they, they're like, my friend is here and I love it.

0:57:02I'm married to it.

0:57:03Gary Vaynerchuk is out there being like, we're going to marry the robots.

0:57:05Like, it's over.

0:57:07Like, put your mind in the right spot.

0:57:10Infinite TikTok clips of him saying this.

0:57:14He knows what that algorithm wants.

0:57:15But the last thing I want to talk about with AI is the developer-oriented news.

0:57:20And I think there's two parts that I want to talk about.

0:57:24The one is that they have these APIs to the local foundation models so that apps can run things locally.

0:57:32This is what I've been waiting for.

0:57:34I wanted to hear the reaction.

0:57:35Yeah.

0:57:35And soon they will be in love with your apps as well.

0:57:38Right.

0:57:38This is a customer support nightmare.

0:57:41Right.

0:57:42This, you know, these are small models.

0:57:44They run locally.

0:57:45They are not, you are not going to be able to make a competitor to chat GPT in an app that uses this.

0:57:52But, like, for little targeted things, I think there are going to be, like, a thousand different little things that little, that each app can do.

0:58:02And from what I've been able to glean in, like, a developer-oriented briefing today, you know, it's, it really integrates very well with Swift where you can sort of, like, do things like, and I know this is a big deal, because it's one of those things that blew my mind away.

0:58:19It's one of those things like, you know, it's one of those things like, you know, it's one of those things like that.

0:58:37And they'll hallucinate where the parentheses go and some of the curly brackets.

0:58:41And so you don't, you have to, like, validate it before you actually trust it.

0:58:46And the APIs for this are, like, no, no, if you set up a struct in Swift and you say, this is what I want it to be, it's guaranteed to give it to you in that format.

0:58:56Now, maybe you won't like the answer intelligence-wise, but you won't have to, like, validate the data.

0:59:00Developers are super excited about this.

0:59:02But it almost feels like one of those things that's, like, last year's announcement seemed a year ahead of time, right?

0:59:12Like, why were they announcing any of this?

0:59:14Why were they announcing Apple Intelligence when they didn't have a story for developers to put in their own apps?

0:59:20Now they have that story, at least to, and it sounds like really, I mean, I've been very interested.

0:59:26about what people will build with this.

0:59:27I think it's hard for us to imagine yet, and I think for, especially around, you know, when you ask Apple what the benefit of this is to developers, there's two.

0:59:37One, it's free, and two, it's local, and there's more privacy, right?

0:59:42And low latency.

0:59:43And low latency.

0:59:44And so are those benefits better than going out to the cloud for whatever the task is?

0:59:55And so I'm just very interested in what people will build with this.

0:59:58Yeah.

0:59:59I mean, I've heard a lot of excitement about it.

1:00:01The latency piece is really interesting.

1:00:03Like, fast but worse is like a, there's some value to that, right?

1:00:09But not all the value.

1:00:11So you get the feeling people will have a hybrid approach.

1:00:14And then the, you know, the cloud services, they're getting cheaper over time.

1:00:18And a developer last night, he was like, I'm paying 200 bucks a month for all of my Gemini uses.

1:00:21Like, why do we need this?

1:00:22Like, so I think there's going to be some push and pull there.

1:00:25But certainly it will push the cost of cloud compute down in a way that it's already actually

1:00:29going down.

1:00:30And I actually think that in this case, the privacy thing, if developers do it right and

1:00:35market that right and explain it right, is a huge benefit.

1:00:38I will tell my story.

1:00:40Neil, I know it's about this.

1:00:40But I wore this recording device, this AI recording device a few months ago.

1:00:45I should really start wearing it again.

1:00:47And it recorded everything in my life.

1:00:49It was a, it's called the B.

1:00:51Limitless makes one, two, but the B.

1:00:53And it recorded everything 24-7.

1:00:56And the way it would work, it was Bluetooth runs to the iPhone and then they use a cloud

1:01:01model.

1:01:01And I was freaked out about the fact that this is a cloud model.

1:01:04That I have all of my life's recordings, everything going to the cloud of this company.

1:01:09And I think that this is a situation where they could, if they had this type of capability

1:01:14from Apple and access to these foundation models, I would have been like, okay, I'll keep wearing

1:01:19that bracelet.

1:01:19Yeah.

1:01:21It makes a big difference.

1:01:22But not around me.

1:01:23No.

1:01:24Not around my family.

1:01:25No one really wanted me.

1:01:26I, yeah, no one wanted me to wear the bracelet.

1:01:29The other thing that I thought was super impressive, it really feels like they have a really good

1:01:37story for Xcode and developer tools.

1:01:41And like a chatbot that you can open on the left and do the sort of things you would command

1:01:47tab to a chatbot app, but it's right there in Xcode.

1:01:50But with all of the knowledge of your Xcode project, because it's right there in your project

1:01:56window.

1:01:57And so it knows, you don't have to tell it, here's my project, or here's the path to it.

1:02:01It just knows it.

1:02:02Really, really, you know, they're not calling it Swift Assist.

1:02:09The whole Swift Assist thing they announced last year.

1:02:12And again, it just felt like so much of last year's announcements were, we have to say something

1:02:18big about AI right now, this year in 2024, ready or not.

1:02:24And it feels like what they're talking about now, developer tool-wise, is like, oh yeah,

1:02:29we spent a whole nother year and figured out what was working and what wasn't.

1:02:33And one thing that we, that Apple seemed to realize is we should just farm out to chat GPT.

1:02:40And in Xcode's case, they already have it.

1:02:43I think you have to be running macOS Tahoe and Xcode 26.

1:02:47But they already have it where you can use your own developer key and use another one, not

1:02:53chat GPT.

1:02:54You can, you know, they have integration with Claude.

1:02:56And that's what people expect, right?

1:03:00They expect like, you know, with every two months, somebody leaps ahead of the other in terms of

1:03:05what is the best coding agent and, or you just hear that, oh, you know, the new Claude

1:03:104 is so much better at this.

1:03:13And you're a developer and you're like, well, I'll try that.

1:03:15Xcode is set up for that sort of race.

1:03:18Like this Xcode that just shipped is set up for like, oh, two months from now, there's going

1:03:23to be a new King of the Hill.

1:03:24And two months after that, it's going to be a different one.

1:03:27It's set up for the fast, incredibly fast world of this.

1:03:31Yeah.

1:03:31Do people here, are you using Xcode and Cursor or Copilot or any other ones?

1:03:36Is there a mix?

1:03:36You're right.

1:03:37There's one boo.

1:03:40I think it was a woo.

1:03:42Somebody from Xcode.

1:03:43Is that a woo or a boo?

1:03:44I think it was a woo.

1:03:45Confusing, but we're going to go with it.

1:03:48You know, the race isn't just in the models.

1:03:50That's kind of why I asked, right?

1:03:51The models are leapfrogging each other, but they're kind of hitting a steady state.

1:03:54The incremental gains of the individual models are whatever.

1:03:58Especially, I think, in the coding domain where Claude is very good at it.

1:04:02But I know big companies that have shifted from Copilot to Cursor, and the engineers are

1:04:09happier at the big companies.

1:04:10And this was a big shift, right?

1:04:11Like a cost model shift for a company that already has a big Microsoft contract or whatever.

1:04:15I think this is where Apple can plug in the new models, but Cursor has invented a new way

1:04:21of doing things.

1:04:21And that's what they're going to have to compete with.

1:04:23And I'm sort of interested to see how that race plays out, because this is the most mature

1:04:27AI field so far.

1:04:29Right.

1:04:29And it kind of makes sense.

1:04:30It's a bunch of engineers being like, what can I do engineer stuff with?

1:04:32And it's a closed loop, you know, in that way.

1:04:35And that's kind of how all tech works in the beginning.

1:04:38But it's interesting that Cursor, you know, they just raise a bunch of money.

1:04:42Like, they're the leader.

1:04:43Yeah.

1:04:44And I don't know if Apple perceives them as the leader yet.

1:04:46Yeah, I don't know either.

1:04:48And I do think it's a serious threat.

1:04:50And I know, I mean, this is WWDC.

1:04:53And it used to be so really like the people who came and everybody who even knew the letters,

1:04:58WWDC really were developers.

1:05:00And now it really is Apple's sort of, here's our software plans for the next year.

1:05:08And it is, you know, the keynote itself is very, very consumer oriented.

1:05:12And they even like sort of made an exception, you know, like, we'll even talk a little bit

1:05:16about developer tools in the keynote.

1:05:18But, you know, mostly, you know, go get lunch and come back for the State of the Union, you

1:05:23know, where they effectively have a second keynote, which really is for developers.

1:05:29But I think in this case, it is important because part of Apple's developer story wasn't just

1:05:37we have these cool platforms that have lots of users.

1:05:40It was, this is a, you're going to love writing software for our platform, right?

1:05:46That was what I heard over and over again from all of my developer friends when they fell

1:05:51in love with Coco in the early 2000s.

1:05:54Even when like, you know, it was like 50-50 split between the people still using classic

1:06:00Mac and Mac OS X, my developer friends were like, I can't wait for everybody to get on Mac

1:06:05OS X because Coco is the future.

1:06:09And this is the, I don't want to go back to writing software the other way.

1:06:12This is so great.

1:06:14And then it was all there poised when the iPhone came and boom, there was this whole market of

1:06:23developers who already loved writing Mac apps, who already knew how to write iPhone apps

1:06:28and they loved doing it.

1:06:29They're like, this is amazing.

1:06:30I just wrote an app and it's on my phone.

1:06:32That sort of enthusiasm, like I'm having more fun programming than I've had in a while.

1:06:39I only hear that now from people using Cursor and Replit and other tools like that.

1:06:44And it sounds weird if you're one of the, you know, two billion people out there who just

1:06:50uses an iPhone and an iPad or something like that.

1:06:53But it really matters if developers really want to be using the tools and writing those

1:06:58platforms, writing for your platform.

1:07:00I'm going to sound like a total AI booster.

1:07:02So some caveats.

1:07:03One, I don't know if this industry is built on technology that will last, right?

1:07:07Like LM's have some sort of finishing point and I don't know where it is.

1:07:10I think there's like a fatal copyright flaw in all this.

1:07:13I'm only laying this out.

1:07:14Like it might just kill the whole industry.

1:07:15Who knows?

1:07:16I'm only saying this because I'm going to sound like a just naked AI booster for one

1:07:20second.

1:07:20So just like that's the copy.

1:07:21If you look at the rest of the industry, if you look at Google IO, Sundar Pichai told me

1:07:26on Decoder, the future of web results are we're going to just like one shot code custom web

1:07:31apps for you that are the search results page, right?

1:07:34We're going to, you're going to ask about some Yankee stats and we're going to build you a

1:07:37data viz on the fly real time using a vibe coding tool like in the backend that the robot

1:07:42we'll use.

1:07:43We will enable millions of more people to divide code and write one shot apps and deploy

1:07:48them to mobile.

1:07:49Like they, this is what they think the platform shift is at scale is millions and millions of

1:07:54more people generating millions and millions of more applications.

1:07:57He also told me that he thinks the web is a series of databases that agents can go and build

1:08:01applications out of by remixing.

1:08:02If you care about the web, you're like, stop.

1:08:08Hold on, your scientists were so obsessed with what they, right?

1:08:12Like, um, but that's the rest of the industry and they are racing towards it, like absolutely

1:08:20racing towards it.

1:08:21It's not just developers who are excited about building this stuff.

1:08:24It's like a bunch of kids on TikTok are using AI agent automation platforms like N8N and building

1:08:31little logic agent things.

1:08:33And most of them are toys and a vast majority of them are like, what's pirate Instagram reels

1:08:38to make money on TikTok?

1:08:39Stop.

1:08:41Like, but there you see, like, here's like thousands of people who are just excited about building

1:08:49loops and having the loops do stuff in new ways with new tools.

1:08:52And you, I just think back to like the web two days.

1:08:54Like, oh, that's, that's the thing.

1:08:56That's what's going to happen.

1:08:57Right.

1:08:57Remember there's a site called Mashable.

1:08:59Do you remember what Mashable started?

1:09:00Mashable is like APIs are a revolution.

1:09:02And then Facebook was like, no, they're not.

1:09:04Just ended that.

1:09:07Um, and like, I see that this is why I'm saying it's sound like a booster.

1:09:12I don't know if it's going to play.

1:09:13I don't know how it's going to play.

1:09:14I don't know how it's going to be successful.

1:09:15That energy is very familiar to me.

1:09:18That's what's making me take it all seriously is once you have all these people building new

1:09:23kinds of experiences in a new way with new paradigms of building applications, something

1:09:29will change.

1:09:30They're not going to go back to the old way.

1:09:31It might peter out the way that, you know, that sort of like web two, Oh, we're going

1:09:35to make everything out of APIs on the web sort of petered itself out, but it will lead to

1:09:40a next class of applications.

1:09:41And I think that is fundamentally fascinating.

1:09:42I want to go back about two minutes there.

1:09:46You're, you're telling me that after Google IO, a senior Google executive sat for an interview

1:09:53with you and answered your questions.

1:09:57Well, some of them, it was there.

1:10:00Yes.

1:10:00And all of them are like, what are you doing to the web dude?

1:10:03Um, yeah, I, I, I think sometimes look, all these executives are super type a, and I think

1:10:10they like the fight.

1:10:10And I think sometimes they choose the fight and they want to show their companies they're

1:10:14in the fight.

1:10:14Sometimes they don't.

1:10:16There's just been a timeout.

1:10:18You've been put in a little timeout.

1:10:20I do this to my kids all the time.

1:10:22You're going to come out of timeout.

1:10:23Apple's going to take you out.

1:10:28You just, yeah.

1:10:29This is one of the weirdest breakups I've ever been a part of.

1:10:32Yeah, I feel like we're in the middle of a break.

1:10:33Like we are like.

1:10:34Yeah, we're like, yeah.

1:10:35It's like, they're on a break.

1:10:36And we're not on a break.

1:10:38The only.

1:10:41Because we're going to come back and we're going to be here, right?

1:10:44Yeah.

1:10:45Yeah.

1:10:46We picked John.

1:10:48Let's be honest.

1:10:49Yeah.

1:10:49I've, I've never been good at staying out of trouble or staying in anyone's good graces.

1:10:56It's, it's, uh, not my forte.

1:10:59Um, let's move on.

1:11:01There was a, you know, the, the Apple's emphasis for the keynote, obviously.

1:11:06Is the liquid glass redesign, um, which was, you know, there were some rumors about it.

1:11:15Um, but, um, that was, you know, that's the theme.

1:11:22Let me ask you this.

1:11:23If they didn't have liquid glass, this redesign ready to go this year, how would the keynote

1:11:29yesterday have played to you?

1:11:30I don't think they would have had enough to fill the keynote.

1:11:37They spent like four minutes having a woman run while a voice was like, good job.

1:11:40But liquid glass, I mean, you probably have the breakdown, but like, that was a chunk.

1:11:46That liquid glass chunk.

1:11:47I mean, showing it across operating systems was a good five minutes, I want to say.

1:11:51And then each time they came to a new, other than Vision OS, which sort of already had it,

1:11:56um, um, it was a big part of it.

1:12:00I, I obviously, if it wasn't ready, if they had, you know, I don't know, whenever they

1:12:03make these keynotes, you know, eight, nine, 10 weeks ago, if they were like, this isn't

1:12:08ready to go this year, we're going to have to wait another year.

1:12:09I'm sure they would have had other things to fill.

1:12:12You know, there's always those bento box slides, you know?

1:12:15Yeah, they would have taken from that slide, and they would have picked like five more things

1:12:18on that.

1:12:18And the TVOS team would have been like, we got to come up with something.

1:12:21Yeah.

1:12:21Like, anything.

1:12:23Privacy.

1:12:24I don't know.

1:12:25Um, and I'm not slagging them for it, you know, I, but I think they thought, well, we

1:12:31could do this this year, um, and it'll make for a theme and, you know, it's a splash and

1:12:37it's sort of, oh yeah, 2025, that was the year they came out with the liquid glass interface.

1:12:42Um, but without it, you know, they would have filled it, but it would have been even more

1:12:48so like just a quote, regular WWDC, right?

1:12:53They've had, I forget how many, uh, they're up to like 40 or something.

1:12:57I don't know, but it's, it's a very long time that they've been having annual worldwide developer

1:13:02conferences.

1:13:03And most of them, if you went back like through all of them are just like, yeah, here's some

1:13:10updates to our platforms and there's new APIs and, you know, we've added some new features

1:13:15here and that's what they are.

1:13:17And that's maybe, you know, inevitable that some years that's what they're going to be.

1:13:21But I kind of feel like Apple's been king of the tech company hill and, you know, more

1:13:29often than not over the last so many years, the single most valued company in the world.

1:13:35And two years ago, they had the big vision pro it's an all new platform and it's, you know,

1:13:42an all new way of, of computing.

1:13:44And then last year's open Apple intelligence where they've sort of set themselves up where

1:13:48we need something big.

1:13:49We need like a big central theme.

1:13:51Well, and the reporting from German and others has been that this is the precursor to set up

1:13:57for some really new hardware products.

1:13:59And I did try to ask them about that today and they didn't budge, but I think that that's

1:14:03exciting.

1:14:04And I think if that's what developers and their diehard fans are thinking about, which

1:14:10is, okay, this is a beautiful new software or there's a lot of potential here.

1:14:13What is that going to look like on a thinner iPhone or eventually a foldable iPhone?

1:14:18That's exciting.

1:14:19Or, you know, glasses that, you know, have some kind of heads up display that projects through

1:14:26the real world.

1:14:28And they've been really clear about that vision OS was the real precursor here, that

1:14:33that this is what, what prompted them to go through this design change.

1:14:36What are your thoughts on liquid glass overall in the life?

1:14:40I talked to a lot of people over the past couple of days, like, oh yeah, it reminds me of iOS

1:14:467.

1:14:46And I am interpreting that as a trauma response.

1:14:49Just that's like a good memory.

1:14:54It took them two years to, to get out of the corner they backed into.

1:14:57They talked about kind of like a lot of shit about iOS 7 in the liquid glass presentation.

1:15:02They're like, this was a time of relics, like dinosaurs roamed the earth.

1:15:06And we were like, get rid of all the, it's like, okay, like this has lasted a pretty long

1:15:10time.

1:15:10Yeah.

1:15:10It was sort of pitched as like, uh, retina screens were new.

1:15:14And so we needed a reaction that was retina screen first.

1:15:18And then they, I forget the exact words, but they were like, and there was some interesting

1:15:22color choices.

1:15:23Yeah.

1:15:24And it's, I can't help but think that there is, it is like the coldest and subtlest of

1:15:31a cold war between Johnny Ive and IO and Apple.

1:15:37Like I, and I kind of feel like if Johnny Ive was only helping Ferrari do their first electric

1:15:47car, maybe that dig about the color choices in IO7 wouldn't have been there.

1:15:52Maybe.

1:15:53You kind of, um, I don't, I, I don't want to report you to back this up.

1:15:57I just know that I've spent a lot of time on the new Airbnb redesign and Airbnb redesign

1:16:03has lots of, like basically like skeuomorphism is back.

1:16:05It's like, they all but set it.

1:16:06You see, there's lots of animations, lots of texture, lots of rotating 3D elements.

1:16:10And like, that's where his head's at.

1:16:12And liquid glass is not that.

1:16:15Right.

1:16:16And that it, maybe they're doing it for glasses.

1:16:19Maybe, you know, they were inspired by the famously successful vision pro, but like you

1:16:26can't see through a phone.

1:16:27And so like everything being this transparent to me, I, they're going to have to back off

1:16:34of it that, and I think it might look really cool and they back off of it, but they're going

1:16:38to have to back off of it.

1:16:38Yeah.

1:16:39I, every time transparency comes out, every time transparency becomes a thing in an OS, the

1:16:45first version is too transparent and it's no matter what it always is.

1:16:50It's, it's, I don't know.

1:16:52It's some kind of immutable law of the universe.

1:16:54Also in my briefing, I was like, can we turn this off?

1:16:58And there are settings to basically turn this off.

1:17:01Yeah.

1:17:01I'm sure.

1:17:02Cause the accessibility stuff is, you know, for accessibility reasons alone, but I kind of,

1:17:07what I kind of hope for, and I haven't hunted around for it is something less than a full

1:17:11fledged, full accessibility, just make it totally non-transparent and flat, you know, something

1:17:20in between.

1:17:20Like, I want a glass slider.

1:17:22Yeah.

1:17:22I want a glass slider.

1:17:23I want to like turn down the glass.

1:17:25Yeah.

1:17:26Well, did you see what, see in the video, uh, there was a part of this video, it's very

1:17:29brief, but they would have you believe that Apple's designers like printed out full scale

1:17:35mock-ups of the interface and Lucite.

1:17:36They played it on stage.

1:17:38Yeah.

1:17:38I was going to say, like, it was like the briefest of like panning shots and like, you know, it's

1:17:42a designer, like holding a full scale Lucite icon.

1:17:45It's like, that's the opposite of skeuomorphism.

1:17:49Like the most not real thing you can do is be like, we're going to, we're going to print

1:17:53an icon in glass and look at it together.

1:17:56You know, there's something about that where I like, you've, you've gone too far.

1:18:02Like you, you, you just dial it back a little bit, it'll be fine.

1:18:05Uh, and then the other thing that really got me, you know, like, I'm actually curious for

1:18:08your take on this.

1:18:09There's a lot of contextual and dynamic user interface elements all through it, right?

1:18:15We're going to put the menu here where the object is and you'll click on it.

1:18:18You'll expand the menu right in place.

1:18:19And every time like an operating system heads in that direction, they, they always go too

1:18:25far.

1:18:25Like we're going to get all the shit off the screen.

1:18:27And then the pendulum has to swing back because you need some consistency and predictability.

1:18:32And Apple has usually been pretty good about predictability versus contextual UI.

1:18:37And this seems like they've gone all the way in that direction.

1:18:39I think I know what you mean.

1:18:44And, you know, I'll always go back to the Mac menu bar, which I think is considered so boring

1:18:50and Apple kind of got away from it and they're still like making it invisible now.

1:18:54And it's like, come on.

1:18:55Yeah, that's what I mean.

1:18:56I think, you know, it used to be like the, if you needed to make a thumbnail of a Mac desktop,

1:19:03how you knew it was a Mac desktop is there would be a couple of rectangles for windows.

1:19:08And then at the top of the whole rectangle would be the white bar across, which was the menu

1:19:13bar, right?

1:19:13The menu bar at the top of the Mac screen was sort of the definition of the Mac.

1:19:18And it's still there, but it's, it's out of your way, right?

1:19:22It's the opposite of contextual.

1:19:24It's just throw your mouse to the top of the screen and go to the view menu.

1:19:28And, you know, they can go too far.

1:19:32One thing I noticed is that some of the stuff that is, some of the stuff that I've seen so

1:19:38far playing around with iOS 26, which is a weird number, it's disconnected from what you see.

1:19:46They did an interview with Esquire about the version numbers in case you're wondering where

1:19:49the hard hitting.

1:19:50What did they say?

1:19:51They're like, it was time for a change.

1:19:54This was a TikTok.

1:19:55Oh.

1:19:56There's, there's a thing that I, um, I was looking for.

1:20:00I installed iOS 26 and I wanted to play with the ask button for a screenshot.

1:20:05I took a screenshot, but at the bottom of my screen were all of the drawing tools, the pencil

1:20:10and the highlighter and all that stuff.

1:20:12And I'm like, why, where's, how do I get this?

1:20:15And it turned out that in the screenshot interface, I had the markup button highlighted and you just

1:20:21have to turn it off.

1:20:22but the markup buttons up top and those tools show up at the bottom and that it, it took

1:20:28me surprisingly long to figure that out because I would expect that the toggle for the palette

1:20:34of tools is next to the palette of tools, not all the way at the top.

1:20:37So I think there's a fine line there.

1:20:40I think sometimes you want stuff to show up right next to the thing and other times you

1:20:44just want to know where it is.

1:20:46And that's the secret of the Mac menu bar is when in doubt, just go to the top of the screen

1:20:50and it's up there somewhere.

1:20:51Yeah.

1:20:51I can't, I mean, I like that sort of like you're in modes.

1:20:56Like the iPhone doesn't have modes in that way, except in these like weird corners of the

1:20:59operating system, but it, you just see, I haven't like played with it very deeply, but

1:21:04lots of the liquid glass philosophy is like things will pop up as lenses over the thing

1:21:10and that, and that's how you will experience different, not modes, but like different capabilities

1:21:14of the operating system.

1:21:15And I, I, I just like wonder if the pendulum has gone too far and it will naturally swing

1:21:21back the way it kind of always does.

1:21:22The, the Esquire, it was, I think it was on TikTok.

1:21:25You sent the link around, but it's like a 30 second interview with Alan, 30 seconds, good.

1:21:31Lots of, lots of time with top Apple executives, but Alan Dye talking about the version numbers,

1:21:37but Alan Dye introduced this in the keynote.

1:21:40And it's like, he just went on and on with this highfalutin talk about it.

1:21:47I wish I had the quotes, but you know, did everybody watch Alan Dye introduce liquid glass?

1:21:53And it's, you know, that it, it speaks to our users and it invigorates the spirit of Apple

1:21:59and, you know, and it, and it, it brings out the, the best in our Apple Silicon.

1:22:05And it's like, I don't know, bring back like when Steve Jobs showed Aqua, he didn't talk

1:22:12like that about, he wasn't like, this really shows off the power of our GPUs.

1:22:15He was like, look at this.

1:22:16This looks fucking cool.

1:22:18Right.

1:22:18Famously.

1:22:20He was like, you can lick it.

1:22:21Yeah.

1:22:22You can lick it.

1:22:23Right.

1:22:23Yeah.

1:22:25He literally said that.

1:22:26And I do think that they've sort of blanded themselves away from just saying, you know what?

1:22:35We made this and it looks really cool.

1:22:37Yeah.

1:22:38And we think people have, we think we have more fun at Apple using computers where the interface

1:22:44looks cool.

1:22:46And every couple of years, it needs to look new to keep looking cool.

1:22:50It can't look the same.

1:22:51And that's enough.

1:22:53That's reason enough to do a redesign.

1:22:55I feel like they wanted to talk themselves into some sort of logic, you know, let's explain

1:23:00to the business world why it makes logical sense for us to spend all this time.

1:23:04And it's like, no, just looking cool is reason enough.

1:23:07It really is.

1:23:08It's a great reason to do a redesign.

1:23:10Yeah.

1:23:10Again, Steve, it's true.

1:23:12I was going to say, like, famously, like, we can, like, relive, like, the Slashdot arguments

1:23:21about burning CPU cycles and, like, rendering the interface.

1:23:24You can tell how I'm poisoned.

1:23:27This is how I grew up in the computer lab on Slashdot.

1:23:29But no, actually, like, software design as a whole is, like, everything is too serious.

1:23:35Like, there's a lot of self-seriousness.

1:23:37And I think maybe some of the only designers left that are just, like, yeah, it looks rad

1:23:41are, like, car designers.

1:23:42Yeah.

1:23:42Like, we made it look like a jet.

1:23:43Like, okay.

1:23:44Like, every Toyota is now an angry robot.

1:23:47Like, okay.

1:23:47Like, there's no reason for this at all.

1:23:49Like, and I would actually like to see some of that whimsy come back to Apple.

1:23:53But Apple's so big.

1:23:54And, like, I don't, they need to have more fun with some of the things that they're able

1:24:00to have fun with.

1:24:01And I agree with you.

1:24:01And I think they should just say we're doing it for fun.

1:24:04Yeah.

1:24:04You know, I think that's reasonable.

1:24:05You know, I also remember in the original iPhone announcement at Macworld in 2007 that Steve

1:24:13Jobs did the slide to unlock, like, more than once.

1:24:17Like, he was like, here, let me lock it again and show this to you.

1:24:20And then it tracked his finger perfectly.

1:24:23And it was this cool-looking metal-looking button that was in a cool-looking channel in the

1:24:28back of the channel that the button slid across said slide to unlock.

1:24:32Wait, do you think this is just sort of the, like, accidental legacy of Johnny Ives' British

1:24:37accent?

1:24:39It's like, everything just felt very serious.

1:24:42Yeah, yeah.

1:24:42Right?

1:24:42He was like, he says aluminum.

1:24:44Like, we gotta, what's our new aluminum?

1:24:46Like, he's like, it's inevitable.

1:24:49And I'm like, oh, shit, we, this is like, we gotta do, it has to sound like a museum.

1:24:53Right.

1:24:53Yeah, maybe.

1:24:55You know, it wasn't that Johnny Ives was bringing the pretension, but the way he spoke.

1:25:00Yeah, it's like literally the pretension of being British.

1:25:02But they could, right, you see what I'm saying?

1:25:07They could just get a new voiceover artist.

1:25:09That's true, they could just have an AI.

1:25:10They could just have AI do the voiceover.

1:25:12It fucking rules.

1:25:13Yeah, yeah.

1:25:14Getting into the individual platforms, I'll start with the one that didn't really get the

1:25:20new refresh because it didn't need to, is Vision OS.

1:25:23But, you know, say what you will about the popularity of Vision Pro and the, you know, here we are two

1:25:31years after it was announced and, what, a year and a half after it started shipping.

1:25:37They are full steam ahead on Vision OS.

1:25:39The Vision OS 26 is super impressive.

1:25:42I did the, I had a briefing where I got to do the new, you know, much improved persona.

1:25:49Yeah, I'm very excited to see this.

1:25:51It's real.

1:25:52I mean, it is like really freaky, like, because then it, part of the demo, I don't know, maybe

1:25:58it should have been somebody else, but it was like me looking at me.

1:26:03Oh, I love that they did that to you.

1:26:04Yeah.

1:26:04Like, you think about what you've done, John.

1:26:07What?

1:26:07They scan, re-scan your face?

1:26:17Yeah, yeah.

1:26:17Okay.

1:26:17I sat down and did the demo and held it out and went through the thing and then they

1:26:21were like, here, here it is.

1:26:23And, you know, let me record like, you know, like when you go on vacation and you stick your

1:26:29head through a donkey or something.

1:26:31Yeah.

1:26:32You know, like there's a picture of a donkey without a head and, come on, Eli, you know

1:26:37what I'm talking about.

1:26:38I stuck my head through a donkey on a last vacation.

1:26:40The classic American vacation, locating a donkey.

1:26:45No, but it was like a way to, like, I got like a souvenir video of my persona at Apple Park

1:26:53in front of the big inflatable rainbow inside the room.

1:26:56They sent you that?

1:26:58Well, they airdropped it to me after I made it.

1:26:59What are you going to do with that?

1:27:00I'll show it to you after this.

1:27:02Okay, yeah, I can't wait.

1:27:03The stuff with the widget stuck on the wall, super impressive.

1:27:09Yeah.

1:27:09And they're really stable and they look really cool.

1:27:12And you can get up real close to them when you're walking around and like the clock has

1:27:18like, in watch terminology, applied numerals.

1:27:22So you get real close to the clock and it's not a flat clock face that prints the digit

1:27:27six and nine and 12.

1:27:30They're like a plastic pieces applied to the clock that have a little bit of three dimensional

1:27:36depth.

1:27:36And when you turn around, it is in the exact same place.

1:27:39Like, and they had like a demo room for the sake of brevity in the briefing already set

1:27:45up.

1:27:45And I could tell that the stuff like there was a poster for the Apple music widget for Lady

1:27:51Gaga and it was above a chair and it was perfectly aligned with the chair.

1:27:55And so I could tell that whoever set it up, I'm seeing it like to the inch where they

1:27:59put it.

1:27:59Oh, that's cool.

1:28:00Yeah.

1:28:01It's really cool.

1:28:01This is like the most AR-y vision OS has gotten.

1:28:04And it's like a clock.

1:28:06But like, this is the, like a very impressive clock.

1:28:12But like the promise of this thing was that it was, you know, it was going to lead Apple

1:28:16towards the AR future they were trying to build.

1:28:18And most of the experiences were VR or like pass through mixed reality with some of you.

1:28:23Like they're like, there's a clock in your room that's always there when you put on the

1:28:26headset.

1:28:26Cause they, they've solved that problem too.

1:28:28Like stuff stays in place between sessions.

1:28:30I think that's like the first little indication that they, they can actually do some of the

1:28:34stuff they were promising to do.

1:28:35Yeah.

1:28:36I thought that I think it was 2018 when Mike Rockwell was my guest on the show and you

1:28:42know, there was five years before vision pro was announced.

1:28:46Um, and, but they had a whole bunch of VR stuff in WWDC.

1:28:50And if you like read between the lines, they must be making a headset, right?

1:28:53I mean, there's no other reason.

1:28:55And, um, I kind of feel like this year's vision OS is sort of like, oh, they're definitely

1:29:01making glasses.

1:29:01Like, cause yes, they've added immersive stuff.

1:29:04Like if you have the three 60 GoPro and they'll work with the camera company so you can get

1:29:09an immersive experience out of your own footage, super impressive.

1:29:12I got to demo that, but most of it was AR not VR.

1:29:16And most of it would make way more sense with see-through glasses than, uh, goggles with screens

1:29:22in front of your eyes.

1:29:23Yeah.

1:29:23I actually, I thought that was an interesting gap in the first vision pro because like how

1:29:29many years of Apple keynotes do we watch people like play chess on an iPad that wasn't

1:29:33there and they'd be like, this is amazing.

1:29:35And you'd be like, I'm not looking at your iPad with you.

1:29:37This is-

1:29:38See a giant dragon.

1:29:39Yeah.

1:29:40This is like, this is just you being impressed by an iPad.

1:29:42Um, they're very impressive.

1:29:45Uh, and then the vision pro watch, it didn't have any of that stuff.

1:29:48Right.

1:29:48No dragons appeared.

1:29:49No chess was played.

1:29:50Uh, and now you're like, oh, they're getting there.

1:29:53Yeah.

1:29:53Right.

1:29:54They, they're connecting the dots between all the spatial location and stuff they have

1:29:56to do to build the glasses.

1:29:59I think someone has to build a display that, like there's a whole laundry list of technology

1:30:03you have to solve that maybe Apple will solve before everyone else.

1:30:05Right.

1:30:06Uh, but like they will have a software lead because they're, they have this simulator for

1:30:11it.

1:30:11The other thing that, uh, I think is the most important update to vision OS of all is that

1:30:16it can save your user to your phone.

1:30:18Yes.

1:30:18And so the headsets are interchangeable, which massive oversight in the first generation.

1:30:23Yeah.

1:30:23Yeah.

1:30:24But they, you still can't have multiple users on an iPad.

1:30:27Well, Greg is in my role as Greg.

1:30:32Yes.

1:30:32I will tell you that it's because we want you to buy more iPads.

1:30:35And actually they did say that in my interviews.

1:30:40Really?

1:30:42Well, I'm sure we're going to get to this, but the Mac, Mac and iPad distinction.

1:30:47I was very, I was, I, you know, you know, my thoughts on this.

1:30:50Both of you do.

1:30:51I would like to see either a touchscreen Mac or the Mac OS come to iPad.

1:30:54And, uh, they repeatedly told me no today, uh, many times no.

1:31:00And, um, but then they said, we would think you should have both.

1:31:03Yeah.

1:31:04It's fun.

1:31:05It is fun doing this show where I can bring up, it's a repeated question over the years.

1:31:09Why can't you have multiple users on an iPad?

1:31:11It's really refreshing to get an honest answer.

1:31:13I do what I can.

1:31:16Transparency is really part of everything we do here at Apple.

1:31:18But also the iPad isn't $3,500.

1:31:20Right.

1:31:22I mean, the Vision Pro is still $3,500 and your iPad is, that you're trying to sell me is $100.

1:31:29Yeah.

1:31:29Yeah.

1:31:30$200.

1:31:31Let's do iPhone first.

1:31:32$279.

1:31:33Um, the camera app has a total redesign.

1:31:38And I have to wonder if they, after the reaction last year to redesigning the Photos app, if it gave them pause about redesigning camera.

1:31:48Um, I, I, you know, I haven't used it.

1:31:52I have it on a spare phone, but I, you know, I kind of like the idea where there's, for most users, there's just video photo.

1:31:59And you have to like long press to get into which type of photo or video, but this is one of those handful of apps that like, I don't know what, what percentage of iPhone users do you think just sticks with the built-in camera app?

1:32:1496%, it's 97.

1:32:1899.9.

1:32:19Yeah.

1:32:19So it is a super, super.

1:32:22No offense to the other iPhone camera app makers.

1:32:25But I thought I, when I watched this, I was like, oh, good.

1:32:28I'll still have a job.

1:32:29Um, cause I will have to teach people how to find this.

1:32:32Right.

1:32:32I think that it is going to be, and I was excited about the fact that just these two things, I find it very overwhelming.

1:32:38And, you know, if you don't know right now, you like, you know, if you swipe up and sometimes you end up in the swipe up menu and you're like, how did I, what, I don't need all this.

1:32:45I just want to get back to this.

1:32:46I think it's good to hide a lot of that stuff and then focus on the camera photo, but, and the camera video.

1:32:52But I think, I wonder, was this, do they have a way to go back to the classic?

1:32:58Which was the one, what was the one that you can go back to the classic?

1:33:01Uh, the phone app.

1:33:02The phone app you can go back to the classic.

1:33:04And I remember thinking they should have this in a couple of different apps.

1:33:08Right.

1:33:08Yeah.

1:33:09Apple's in a weird spot with the, uh, the camera.

1:33:11Uh, we wrote a piece years ago about why all the Chinese phone makers copy the Apple

1:33:16camera app so closely.

1:33:17And it's because they want to lower the switching cost.

1:33:20Because if you pick up another phone and you can't use the camera, you're never going to buy that phone.

1:33:24Like, you're immediately frustrated, you're done.

1:33:25So they all just ruthlessly copy the iPhone camera app.

1:33:29And it, Apple's in the same spot where like, if you pick up your iPhone and you can't use the camera app, you will be frustrated because it is such a core part of the phone.

1:33:38So the changes they made are pretty minor, right?

1:33:40They've just made it simpler.

1:33:41Right.

1:33:42And you kind of wonder, like, do they feel constrained for making a bigger change here?

1:33:46Because if people are frustrated with their new camera, like, that's the end of the world.

1:33:50Yeah.

1:33:52I'm really curious to see how it hits when it drops.

1:33:55And I feel like it could be one of those things.

1:33:57You know, like, I was kind of wrong about USB-C.

1:34:00I thought because of how many people in my family when they switched from the old 30-pin to Lightning, how I, everybody in my family called me and they're like, why do I have to get a new plug?

1:34:09Like, why doesn't, why don't me and my husband get to use the same plugs anymore?

1:34:14And when they switched to USB-C, it was like nothing.

1:34:19It's like, I think because the whole world went USB-C and everybody already had a bunch of cables or something like that.

1:34:24And so it's very hard to predict.

1:34:26But I wouldn't be surprised if, like, we go through the summer and all the nerds who will install the iOS 26 beta are just playing with the camera and are, like, used to it.

1:34:34And then, like, come September 20, whatever, when it ships, everybody is like, what happened to my camera?

1:34:40No, I mean, you picked up on the, you said the Photos app.

1:34:44That was a huge thing.

1:34:45And I have a lot of old elderly readers at the Wall Street Journal.

1:34:50How do I say this in a polite way?

1:34:52They're old.

1:34:53And I hear from them.

1:34:56Yeah.

1:34:56And when you move something, they are very upset.

1:35:00And that's always, I always, when I look at these redesigns, think about that juggling act that Apple has to deal with, right?

1:35:06They have so many people who just want the phone as is.

1:35:11But then they have a lot of us that, exactly as you said, it's cool.

1:35:14It's awesome to get a new kind of phone.

1:35:16I mean, my favorite part of the year is covering iOS every year because you get to tell people about, oh, look at this free new phone you get, right?

1:35:23I mean, you don't pay for it.

1:35:26Yeah, and did Rupert Murdoch call you for tech support?

1:35:28Do you have, like, a weird personal episode of Succession once a year when they update the interface?

1:35:33I don't have that specific, but I may be thinking about him when I'm talking about these types of changes.

1:35:39But, I mean, but also, like, it's not just an age.

1:35:42Like, you know, my wife is not much older than me.

1:35:46I mean, she's also, like, she, and I can't believe that, like, I married her, but she will not update.

1:35:51Like, she will not update.

1:35:54And I will be, like, you must update.

1:35:56I mean, there have been things, like, group text messages, you know, different things.

1:35:59Like, I'm, like, you haven't updated in two years.

1:36:02I'm married to this person.

1:36:06Well, I mean, for a lot of people, phones are appliances.

1:36:10And if, like, you showed up in your kitchen and your microwave was fucked, you'd be, like, what?

1:36:14Why did you do this to me?

1:36:15Right?

1:36:16Like, and the answer is because it's better or more efficient or because it just looks cool.

1:36:21Yeah.

1:36:22There's, that's a weirdness here where Apple is at such a scale where they are constrained and maybe they just have to make the big changes all at once.

1:36:29Right.

1:36:29Because it can't make the iterative changes.

1:36:31I will say that the phone app, or not the phone app, the camera app in particular is another, like, hidden UI, like, wonderland.

1:36:38Yeah.

1:36:38Where all, it's all still there.

1:36:39You just have to know it's there.

1:36:41Right.

1:36:42But it's all still there in approximately the same places.

1:36:45I thought it was super telling.

1:36:48You mentioned the phone app, and so that's another thing that they've changed.

1:36:51And that's an app where the look of it changed with iOS 7, but the layout didn't change from, like, iOS OG, right?

1:36:59But, you know.

1:37:00But actually, now that I think, I think they did this for the older people.

1:37:03The classic mode.

1:37:05Right.

1:37:05Because they need to make phone calls.

1:37:07What?

1:37:07Right?

1:37:08Like, they're like, you, that's one step too far that you've changed.

1:37:13Right, and they figured out the old layout.

1:37:15Yeah.

1:37:15And that voicemails are over there.

1:37:17Right.

1:37:17And the recents are over here.

1:37:19I was almost shocked when they showed it, and I was like, oh, that's like an admission that you, like, this is.

1:37:24And I think the big tell that they are willing to, it's like new Apple that is getting used to accommodating, like, a billion plus user base.

1:37:33As opposed to old Apple, which had, like, four or five percent of the market.

1:37:37But the four or five percent were like, yeah, we love you, and we want, just tell me where to learn about this stuff.

1:37:42But you'd think, like, with a camera app, you would have a pro mode or a creator mode or, like, right?

1:37:47There's lots of things you could do to solve that problem in that app in particular that they seem resistant to.

1:37:52But that's also an area, and again, and not just because I have friends, and I know some of them are here, but who make the pro camera app.

1:37:58It really is well served by the pro camera apps.

1:38:01It really is.

1:38:02Absolutely.

1:38:02And when I said 99 percent, I don't even mean that as a knock.

1:38:04I just mean that that's how big the install base is.

1:38:06Right, and one percent of all users.

1:38:08Right.

1:38:08I mean.

1:38:09Like, what's the percentage of iPhone users who never take pictures, right?

1:38:13My dad is one.

1:38:15My dad has an iPhone, and I don't think he's ever taken a photograph.

1:38:18Wild.

1:38:19Yeah, but he's 87, you know.

1:38:22You know, they're out there, but it's, you know, very small, right?

1:38:27It's just one of those apps that, you know, everybody uses.

1:38:30But I thought the big tell with the phone interface wasn't just that they're going to have, here, we have a new unified view, which sounds good to me.

1:38:37Like, I kind of hate when I've got the red badge, and it's the same person who counts as a recent and a voicemail.

1:38:43And it's like, I've got to click through both to get rid of the badge.

1:38:46Yeah, I like this.

1:38:47I like the sounds of this.

1:38:48But I think the real tell is that to get to the classic interface, you don't have to, like, go back to settings.

1:38:53Right.

1:38:54Go down to apps.

1:38:55It's right up in the right.

1:38:55It's up there in the corner.

1:38:56You just hit the dot, dot, dot.

1:38:58And then right at the top of the menu that opens is, do you want the classic layout or the new layout?

1:39:03Oh, I'm going to be so popular the week that comes out.

1:39:06I mean, seriously, that would be the most popular story on the Wall Street Journal.

1:39:10It would be great.

1:39:11Yeah.

1:39:12And they did.

1:39:12It's like, Tariff's rock of the world.

1:39:15I'm not joking.

1:39:17We can revisit this.

1:39:18Let's talk in the beginning of September.

1:39:19I will be queen.

1:39:21Photos.

1:39:23Photos have it.

1:39:25How to make calls with your iPhone.

1:39:27Photos, they.

1:39:33Thank you, Apple.

1:39:34Thank you, Apple.

1:39:34Somehow, I've interpreted that as a threat against the Wall Street Journal.

1:39:39Right.

1:39:39Oh, yeah.

1:39:40Come at me.

1:39:41Come at me.

1:39:42Top this this week.

1:39:45Yeah.

1:39:46The Photos app has a new tab now where they kind of kept the idea of, we have these collections.

1:39:54We think it would be really useful if you took a look at them.

1:39:56We think you'd find it useful.

1:39:57But okay, we'll just make it a tab at the bottom, and we'll just show you your library in the Photos app.

1:40:04And they kind of acknowledged, I forget how they said it.

1:40:07They said, many of you enjoyed using tabs.

1:40:08No, but they said, like, we heard from some of you about the Photos app or something like that, you know.

1:40:15Just to keep harping on this, this is just the pendulum swung towards contextual dynamic UI, and then everyone was like, what?

1:40:24I just want the buttons that tell me what mode I'm in, and they put the button back.

1:40:28And I just see that pendulum swing back and forth in iOS like crazy right now.

1:40:31Right.

1:40:33I thought you were going to say that you saw this on TikTok.

1:40:35I see everything out of this.

1:40:37I know.

1:40:38It's just me, like, Zoomers doing piracy on TikTok is, like, my entire...

1:40:42Well, people complaining about the photo app on TikTok was a whole thing.

1:40:45Hmm.

1:40:45Yeah, oh, yeah, definitely.

1:40:47You have older people on your TikTok.

1:40:49Yeah, they're my older people.

1:40:50I honestly feel...

1:40:51Rupert Murdoch being like, what the fuck is that?

1:40:53I kind of...

1:40:54I kind of get the complaints about the Photos app.

1:40:59I see what people didn't like, but I kind of feel like it took off to a point where,

1:41:03for young people, it's like, you weren't cool if you didn't hate on the iOS 18 Photos app.

1:41:08Like, you kind of had to, you know...

1:41:10Yeah.

1:41:10I didn't hate it, honestly.

1:41:13Do you think your dad would take a virtual picture of your head through a donkey?

1:41:21Let's ask ChatGPT.

1:41:22Like, do you think that would initiate him?

1:41:25One of those prompts that really you're trying to make the ChatGPT give a nonsense.

1:41:31What about a sloth with a light bulb?

1:41:35Can I just note that this podcast has almost been going for two hours, and we have not gotten

1:41:39to iPad and Mac?

1:41:40And I know that we are going...

1:41:43iPad windowing is my next part.

1:41:44That's another 40 minutes.

1:41:45These people are trapped.

1:41:46You guys know that's 40 minutes, right?

1:41:49That's another 40 minutes.

1:41:50No.

1:41:51They saved it for last...

1:41:52I think it was the last platform they talked about.

1:41:54iPad.

1:41:55But they went through Mac quickly.

1:41:56And tvOS.

1:41:57Yeah.

1:41:57Well, tvOS, they're like, yeah, it's clear now.

1:42:00Also, look at our shows.

1:42:01And it's like, so you have no ideas.

1:42:02No further ideas for the TV.

1:42:05Posters look cooler.

1:42:06Yeah, exactly.

1:42:06No, iPad windowing.

1:42:08I mean, let's do it while we still have gas in the tank here, because how much do you want

1:42:13to talk about it?

1:42:1440 minutes.

1:42:18I mean, yeah.

1:42:19That's the downside of doing this on stage.

1:42:21Scattered applause.

1:42:22I can't take...

1:42:25Whenever I do one of Gruber's podcasts, I always take like a 15-minute break in the middle.

1:42:28I go get food.

1:42:29I get my coffee.

1:42:30Walk the dog.

1:42:32This is the downside of the live show.

1:42:35I feel like this is finally, right?

1:42:40Like, finally, they've just sort of given in on the idea that, yeah, we kind of know how

1:42:46overlapping windows should work.

1:42:48We got it right in 1984, right?

1:42:52Yeah.

1:42:53Close button in the top left.

1:42:56You can...

1:42:57There's a little thing in the bottom right where you can drag it to resize it, and you can move

1:43:01them wherever you want, and we think you'll like it.

1:43:04Yeah.

1:43:05And even when you have a second monitor?

1:43:07Yeah, yeah.

1:43:10Yeah, I saw that demo today, and it's...

1:43:12Yeah, it's...

1:43:13It is...

1:43:14I guess...

1:43:15I mean, you know, I don't know what they've been thinking for the years since they first

1:43:19invented split screen on iPad, where they've been resisting just doing Mac-style Windows.

1:43:26And I guess, maybe.

1:43:27I mean, and it's the sort of thing...

1:43:29I'd love to hear the explanation.

1:43:30But I...

1:43:33My spitball theory is that they thought if it looks too much like a Mac, it'll make it even

1:43:38more hard to answer the question of why are there two different operating systems, Mac and

1:43:43iPad OS.

1:43:44And so if we make it totally different, it'll make people not...

1:43:48And I think they sort of thought themselves into knots by just not doing the obvious thing.

1:43:54Like, yes, we have two systems that are based on Windows that overlap, and you can drag around.

1:43:59And so they share a similar design language and placement of controls.

1:44:03So I heard a variation of an answer, just like walking around yesterday.

1:44:08I don't know if they talked to you about this.

1:44:11And I don't know if I believe it, but they, from what I understand, they were worried

1:44:18that anything that increased the latency of the touch screen would wreck the iPad.

1:44:23So, like, they're like, we needed the full processing power of the...

1:44:27So that we can have multiple windows, and if you touch the iPad, it's always alive.

1:44:31And on a Mac, you can...

1:44:33As long as the mouse is moving, you're not too worried that the computer has crashed.

1:44:37But you have that.

1:44:39That's always happening.

1:44:40And you can preserve the mouse is moving, even if the apps are still in the background.

1:44:43But there's no feedback.

1:44:44There's nothing to...

1:44:46Feedback that the computer is anything but crashed on an iPad.

1:44:48I don't know if I believe this.

1:44:50Like, the computers have been very powerful for a long time.

1:44:53But they've tried every other idea of multitasking on a Mac.

1:44:57Like, every other possible variation of multitasking on an iPad.

1:45:01And I think they...

1:45:02People just want Windows.

1:45:04And especially now you have multiple monitors for all this stuff.

1:45:07Do you think the application platforms are going to converge more than they have now?

1:45:10That's my biggest question.

1:45:12I don't know.

1:45:14I mean, they've had the...

1:45:16What's it called where you make a...

1:45:20Catalyst.

1:45:21Catalyst, right.

1:45:21And...

1:45:23I don't know.

1:45:26I feel like Catalyst hasn't really shaken up the...

1:45:30You know, it doesn't seem like we see lots of new blockbuster Mac apps all the time anymore.

1:45:36But there still are new Mac apps that come out that are really asked Mac apps to use that parlance.

1:45:42So, I don't think they're going to converge.

1:45:44But I do think that with, like, Swift UI and stuff that there will be so many...

1:45:48It'll be a lot easier.

1:45:49And it's not just by using Catalyst to say,

1:45:51Ah, just spit this out and run it on a Mac.

1:45:53But to have a Mac app that does Mac-like things...

1:45:58And I just think it is hard to explain to a normal person the things that make a Mac a Mac that wouldn't be right on iPad.

1:46:09You know, and it's the new export feature, right?

1:46:12And this was kind of weird that they made Final Cut Pro for iPad a couple years ago.

1:46:17And you had to leave it in the foreground while it exported, which could take minutes because it takes a long time.

1:46:25Or maybe more than minutes, right?

1:46:26For a long enough project.

1:46:28And now, in addition to the windowing system, there's a new thing.

1:46:33There's an API where an app that does a long export process can...

1:46:39It just becomes a live activity.

1:46:41And it could take, you know, 30 minutes.

1:46:43And you could just go about your day and go to email and dick around on messages or whatever you want to do.

1:46:49And it live updates in the background.

1:46:52And then when you're driving your car, the live activity dynamically shows up in CarPlay.

1:46:57This is the power of the Apple ecosystem.

1:46:59My theory on this now, and I am very excited about these iPad changes.

1:47:04But I think having complained about this for so many years, 10, how many years now?

1:47:10That we've, since the, what is a computer ad, I feel like.

1:47:14We will, I personally, and maybe others feel this way, will continue to complain about the iPad not being a Mac until it is a Mac with a touchscreen.

1:47:26Because even though what they gave us yesterday, which was great windowing, more desktop, more monitor support, and preview, which is actually a really big deal for me.

1:47:34I, like, live in preview with a lot of the work I do.

1:47:36I'm still like, oh, yeah, now what about the apps?

1:47:40What about the Mac apps that I would want?

1:47:42What about the file system?

1:47:44What about this?

1:47:44And it's like, I'm going to just keep, for the end of time, want that, those Mac things to be on an iPad with a touchscreen that I can take off and then go use somewhere else.

1:47:55Which is your argument you've always made to me, which is like, do you really just want a Mac with a touchscreen?

1:48:01Yeah.

1:48:02Or do you want an iPad with Mac OS?

1:48:05I think you should buy a Macintosh.

1:48:09Have you heard of it?

1:48:11As Greg Joswiak can believe that?

1:48:13Yeah, I'm saying, have you thought about buying both products?

1:48:14No, he told, they told me today that I should buy both products.

1:48:17They're hoping to buy both products.

1:48:19Yeah.

1:48:20Not to just, like, harp on, like, the future of application platforms, but, like, in what other room would you do that?

1:48:26The weird thing about the Mac right now, and the weird thing about, like, where the action is, is, like, it's all web apps, right?

1:48:35Like, I, in the airport on the way here, I met a developer who was not coming to WWC.

1:48:39He was headed elsewhere, and he was like, look, the nature of our app is that the market share is on Android, so we care a lot about Android, and most of our action, our growth, is on the web.

1:48:49Like, that's how we're distributing the app to people.

1:48:51And that's just making a comeback.

1:48:52Like, the example I always use is Figma.

1:48:54Figma is a miracle of a web app, right?

1:48:57And it has overtaken the design world in all the ways that it has, and it's a web app.

1:49:02And you look at the Mac, and it's, like, over, the Mac app store.

1:49:05How many of you are making a killing in a Mac app store?

1:49:08Not even the Amazon guy, I was like, right?

1:49:10Oh, remember the Amazon guy?

1:49:13Oh, we're going to find him.

1:49:14Oh, I'm good.

1:49:14This is going long, so it's higher now, so you can't run fast.

1:49:17We have his workout buddy.

1:49:19Oh, no.

1:49:20It's like, you're going pretty slow.

1:49:23Like, Electron is, like, it has taken over the Mac in a real way.

1:49:30Like, I use Notion Calendar.

1:49:30That's, like, a beautiful Mac-asked Mac app.

1:49:33It is an Electron app, and that is the thing that I, they cannot allow that to break the

1:49:38iPad, and I think that's, there's going to be a hard wall there until the government or

1:49:42a judge or someone, John personally, breaks the wall down.

1:49:45That's going to be the difference.

1:49:48They called that, did you watch the State of the Union yesterday, or are you off?

1:49:51They called it out in the State of the Union.

1:49:53I might be paraphrasing slightly, but it was a line like, please stop making Electron apps.

1:49:59Wait, really?

1:49:59Yes.

1:50:00Did everybody else?

1:50:01I'm not imagining this, right?

1:50:02There was, it actually, yeah.

1:50:04That's crazy.

1:50:04Yeah.

1:50:05You know, along the lines of, you know, we've got these great tools that will, you know,

1:50:10that do so much more and give such a better experience, which I think is true, but I do think

1:50:17that does factor into it, you know, that the iPad is this protected space where they

1:50:21know it's only going, and you know, this.

1:50:24Do they pair that up with like, and we're lowering the take rate in the app store?

1:50:28They didn't.

1:50:30Right?

1:50:31Like, this is the problem.

1:50:32Like, you can deploy an Electron app for free and get a lot of distribution for free.

1:50:36Right.

1:50:36And what Apple should be saying is, we will give you a lot of distribution for free if

1:50:40you play by our rules, use our platform, and that will be economically viable forever.

1:50:43And they, I didn't hear any of that here at the State of the State.

1:50:46Well, and so many developers who might want to make native iPad and Mac apps for their

1:50:54company, you know, it's just the nature of how companies work, where you've got to sell

1:50:59it to somebody who's above you, who's not a developer.

1:51:02And when one of the alternate plans is, well, we'll just make a web app, and then you spit

1:51:08out an Electron app, and it runs everywhere, and there's only one code base and one team,

1:51:13and we can hire people who know how to write React JavaScript apps anywhere, and it costs

1:51:19more to get people who are experts in Swift UI, and they're like, well, I'll go that way.

1:51:23Yeah.

1:51:24Have you heard of React?

1:51:24Like, you just see it happen all over the place.

1:51:27And I think, like, they can make the iPad.

1:51:29They can finally give in.

1:51:31They can give you what you want.

1:51:33It cannot allow that to happen to the iPad, because that's what will break the app model,

1:51:37it will break the store model, and it will just collapse it into being a Mac, because the

1:51:41applications will actually end up being the same as Mac.

1:51:43And one of the little details I learned today, and it makes sense, is that this new export

1:51:48API, so like when a video app exports a very long process, it runs in the background on iPad,

1:51:56it can run as long as it takes until it finishes.

1:51:59But to access that API, you have to do two things.

1:52:03It has to be a task that has a completion.

1:52:06You can't just have an open-ended task that is, like, continuously polling forever.

1:52:12You can't just run something in the background forever.

1:52:14It has to be a task that has a, or in user interface parlance, it has to have a progress bar with

1:52:21an end, not one of those spinners that's like, oh, you know, maybe forever.

1:52:24And the other thing is it has to be user-initiated.

1:52:29So it has to be something where the user says, take this, export, go, and then it'll go.

1:52:35So the app can't just on its own while you're doing this say, ah, I'll run a background task

1:52:39and update, you know, blah, blah, blah in the background.

1:52:43And it doesn't work like that.

1:52:45But part of that reason why is that you can run into a situation on the Mac, because the

1:52:50Mac's the Mac, where you've installed stuff, all sorts of stuff is going on in the background

1:52:54that you don't know is going on, because most people out there don't run activity monitor

1:52:59and look for, you know, CPU usage.

1:53:02You don't, it's impossible on iPad, and it's part of the selling point, and I think that's

1:53:06why you're going to be forever unhappy.

1:53:08Thank you.

1:53:13They also, in the other half of the, finally, you know, and they got this right in 1984,

1:53:19really, I've been playing around in that classic Mac emulator on the web, Infinite Mac, I think

1:53:26it's called.

1:53:27And it's like, yeah, they really did nail the finder in 1984.

1:53:32By the way, it did not take like a global regulatory crackdown to ship a Mac emulator on the web.

1:53:38No.

1:53:39Right, this is, like, this is what I mean.

1:53:41Like, the web is this huge escape hatch of applications that breaks the App Store model.

1:53:45Right.

1:53:46And that is what, it's what, it's why the Mac thrives, and I think it's also what's holding

1:53:52the iPad back in just the realist of ways.

1:53:54But the Files app is actually, seems like, actually useful now.

1:54:02And, you know, like, they even said, and it was, you know, there was some good humor in

1:54:07it, like, in my iPad briefing of, like, spoken with humor, not like, hey, we invented this

1:54:13new breakthrough of a list view with more than two columns, name and date.

1:54:19Yeah.

1:54:19Yes.

1:54:19They're like, and there's a nice picker over there, and you can have as many columns as

1:54:23you want.

1:54:23And it was, you know, not the frustrating, hey, we invented multiple columns in list view,

1:54:29and you can sort by them.

1:54:30It was, yeah, you know, you know, we probably could have done this earlier.

1:54:36But, as I said, they're going to keep giving us more things, but.

1:54:39So that every year, you can be like, should I get an iPad?

1:54:42Yeah.

1:54:42And then I will sell you one additional iPad.

1:54:44I was, I made the joke, and I'm not sure, you know, it's at the, I'm at the point now

1:54:49where I'm older than a lot of the people briefing me, and I made the joke when they were talking

1:54:54about being able to pick folder colors.

1:54:56Oh, yeah.

1:54:57And I said, oh, did you, did you get that from System 7?

1:55:01That's rough.

1:55:05A couple people at the table laughed, and a couple people were like, who's this guy?

1:55:09Can I interest you in classic mode?

1:55:14They were like, does he use, does he know how to use the iPhone camera?

1:55:19Yeah.

1:55:21Yeah.

1:55:22I don't know.

1:55:22Right.

1:55:23What was that in the, remember OS 8 had that totally horrible theming engine?

1:55:28Oh, yeah.

1:55:29And they never shipped it, but there was one.

1:55:30Well, no, it was a great theming engine that the other themes were horrible.

1:55:35Right, but there was one that was just like, total 90s design, we're like.

1:55:38Gizmo.

1:55:38Gizmo.

1:55:39And it's like, oh, with liquid glass, finally you can enable gizmo on your own.

1:55:44Yeah, there was gizmo, and I think techno, I think was the dark one, you know.

1:55:51You know, actually, one thing on the iPad, I think you have written about this more than

1:55:56anyone over the years.

1:55:56It's maybe you and Jason Snell.

1:55:58Apple never has really known what the other two buttons in the stoplight menu, window control

1:56:04should do.

1:56:05Like, they've absolutely known what red is the whole time.

1:56:08Right.

1:56:09Nailed red.

1:56:10Right.

1:56:11And they're like, go?

1:56:13Yeah.

1:56:14It's like, go.

1:56:18Do you know what they do on the iPad?

1:56:21Uh, no.

1:56:24I don't know what they do on the iPad.

1:56:26Like, it's been one of these, like, puzzles for the long time.

1:56:29Like, one is minimize, and one is close, and that sort of makes sense on the, but what is

1:56:33the difference between close and minimize on an iPad?

1:56:36I think you can also long press on that.

1:56:38Oh, good.

1:56:38Yeah.

1:56:39I think you can use that to resize your reach out.

1:56:43So, I think close, I don't know.

1:56:46I haven't played with it.

1:56:47I've only seen it.

1:56:48But I think close would sort of close it, and then if you command tab, it won't still be

1:56:54there.

1:56:54And if you minimize it, it vanishes from your view, but it's still there.

1:56:59Like, you can command.

1:56:59This is, like, the one thing about, because they're iconic.

1:57:02As iconic as the menu.

1:57:03Yeah.

1:57:04But the fact that, like, no one at Apple has ever been like, okay, go.

1:57:07I would have been happy for years if they only had the red button.

1:57:11And again, go back to, like, 1984.

1:57:14That's all the Mac had up there.

1:57:16It was just a close button.

1:57:17I don't know.

1:57:17You don't need minimize or tiling options and stuff.

1:57:21I just wanted to know how to close a window on iPad.

1:57:24No, I'm, like, 100% convinced that, like, when they were doing Aqua, they were like, we'll

1:57:31have these stoplights.

1:57:32And they're like, we'll figure it out later.

1:57:33And Steve Jobs is like, it looks cool.

1:57:35And, like, we're, like, 40 years into it now.

1:57:37And it's like, green means go.

1:57:39Like, someone figure it out.

1:57:40All right.

1:57:41Ask ChatGPT.

1:57:42Last of the major platforms, the Mac, I think Liquid, I keep wanting to call it Liquid Metal.

1:57:49And my wife told me before the show, she goes, you keep calling it Liquid Metal.

1:57:53It's Liquid Glass.

1:57:54And thank you, Amy, for knowing the name better than I do after two days of this.

1:58:00But Liquid Metal is kind of funny because Apple was involved with a thing called Liquid Metal.

1:58:04Yeah.

1:58:04The most famous thing, they bought the company.

1:58:09Yeah.

1:58:10And the most famous thing was a SIM removal tool that I think is still ships to the phones.

1:58:13It's, like, in the frame or whatever.

1:58:15But it's, like, a good name that they should have brought back Brush Metal and rebranded that as Liquid Metal, I think.

1:58:23I think Liquid Glass looks the roughest right now on Mac.

1:58:29I think that it's kind of weird the way toolbar buttons float over the window instead of looking like they're part of it.

1:58:35But, you know, it's cool.

1:58:39It's cool.

1:58:41I thought that the big nerd audience thing was the additions to Spotlight.

1:58:46You mentioned it earlier.

1:58:47Do you guys use anything?

1:58:50Do you guys use Spotlight or do you use Raycast or LaunchBar or Alfredo?

1:58:53I'm a Spotlight person.

1:58:55David Pierce, who's the first guest with me, is a huge Raycast person.

1:58:59Like, super into it.

1:59:00Loves all those tools.

1:59:01I think what they do with Spotlight, one, it does look a lot like Raycast, right?

1:59:06But the sort of, like, you have a bunch of app intents on your computer.

1:59:11Like, the apps register their capabilities.

1:59:12You start typing a word.

1:59:14It's, like, do you want to send a message?

1:59:16And it sort of auto-completes that.

1:59:17That's Raycast's plug-in.

1:59:18It's like, that is that only it's, you know, the operating system has registered the capabilities

1:59:23of the apps.

1:59:24You just draw that line.

1:59:26You're like, oh, this is the thing you want Siri to do.

1:59:28You just want to say, send a message to so-and-so and have the app do it.

1:59:32And now you're just typing that in the Spotlight.

1:59:34Why can't I just talk to this?

1:59:36And I, you know, you're like, why haven't you drawn this connection?

1:59:39And they're like, no further comment.

1:59:41Like, that's the end of that conversation.

1:59:43But you can see, like, this is the beginnings of that.

1:59:46That's how you would build the thing, is you would have the operating system know what all

1:59:50the apps on it can do.

1:59:51And then you'd be able to pass data back and forth.

1:59:52And I just think, to bring all the way back to the beginning, that has to be part of the

1:59:57architecture shift that they're talking about.

1:59:59Yeah.

1:59:59What about you?

2:00:00Do you use...

2:00:01I just use Spotlight.

2:00:02I used to use Alfred, but I moved back to just regular old Spotlight.

2:00:06But I'm very excited about these changes, because I think this is another one where it's like,

2:00:10if you know where to find it and know how to use these things, it's going to be...

2:00:14And that opens that up to a much bigger audience.

2:00:17It does imply that all the apps are on your computer.

2:00:21Yeah.

2:00:22And the reality for many, many, many people is that all the apps are on the web.

2:00:26Are on the web.

2:00:27Right.

2:00:27And so Apple has to bridge this gap.

2:00:29And that, like, again, just to go to the Google approach, the Microsoft approach, they're like,

2:00:34oh, the web is now a giant, worldwide, interlinked series of application logic and databases.

2:00:39And that is the future of the platform shift.

2:00:42And you will just talk to the cloud and, you know, pennies will rain down from you and from

2:00:46heaven or whatever will happen.

2:00:47That might work only because they have the massive distribution advantage of the web browser.

2:00:54Right.

2:00:55Like, this is why Google does not want to get rid of Chrome.

2:00:57It's lawsuits.

2:00:58Apple is trying to get all the applications onto its platforms, natively registering in

2:01:02the operating system.

2:01:03And I wonder if that's just a harder fight given the direction everyone else has gone.

2:01:08And I would say, I actually think, like, reflecting on the last year, I'm probably downloading more

2:01:13apps, either from the Mac apps or from Mac apps.

2:01:15Like, the AI, like, ChatGPT makes a great, OpenAid makes a great Mac app.

2:01:21Yep.

2:01:21Claude makes a great Mac app.

2:01:25Superhuman.

2:01:26There's a number that I just feel like over the last year, like, I've been building up

2:01:30more native Mac apps.

2:01:32Yeah.

2:01:32I, you know, I mean, you famously, I mean, I love the Mac and I've always done.

2:01:37But I've noticed, I think it, I kind of feel, you know, like finger in the wind that the

2:01:42pendulum is swinging back towards more Mac apps.

2:01:46I, I, I do.

2:01:47And I, I mean, I think for the AI companies, they know.

2:01:51Raycast is a perfect example.

2:01:52Raycast is relatively new, right?

2:01:54I mean, I'm a LaunchBar guy.

2:01:56Hear it up for LaunchBar.

2:01:57Yeah, there's, uh, LaunchBar, Alfred's been around for a while.

2:02:03Raycast was sort of a new entry into the field of, we can do command space a lot better in

2:02:09Spotlight or we can do a lot more.

2:02:10Um, and it's a perfect example of like sort of reinvigorating Mac development and just sort

2:02:16of, you know, it, in an inherently nerdy sort of space.

2:02:20But I think it's really exciting that Apple is like, Hey, we haven't touched Spotlight

2:02:24in a long time.

2:02:25How about we make it awesome?

2:02:26And I do think it's Sherlocking Raycast.

2:02:28Right.

2:02:29Well, that's the way it goes.

2:02:31Right.

2:02:32And it's like if Raycast and LaunchBar and Alfred can't still stay ahead of it by doing more,

2:02:37uh, you know, that's the nature of the game.

2:02:39But I sort of suspect all three will keep doing more in certain ways.

2:02:43You know, Alfred, by the way, the original Sherlock victim, right?

2:02:46Wasn't that?

2:02:47No, no, that was Watson.

2:02:49Watson.

2:02:49Sorry.

2:02:50Right.

2:02:50They're all butlers.

2:02:51Yeah.

2:02:51The, the, the story was Apple made a thing called Sherlock and it wasn't that great.

2:02:55And then the third party company, Carolea made Watson.

2:02:58I'm aware that Watson wasn't Sherlock.

2:03:00We've been doing this for like six hours.

2:03:02I told you it was going to be 40 minutes.

2:03:05I knew it.

2:03:07Um, that's about it for me.

2:03:10I don't, do you guys have any other questions?

2:03:12We ended.

2:03:12Really?

2:03:13Oh.

2:03:14Can anyone else name any famous butlers?

2:03:19Jeeves was the answer for, if the mics didn't pick up.

2:03:24Good answer.

2:03:24No.

2:03:25Uh, thank you guys.

2:03:28Please respect the Amazon guy

2:03:30when you're leaving

2:03:31Do not trample him, we will

2:03:34Let me just thank a bunch of people

2:03:37I want to thank everybody once again

2:03:38here at the California Theater

2:03:40Everybody here is extremely nice

2:03:43I've been backstage

2:03:46but I hear from everybody every year

2:03:48that everybody out front is always very nice

2:03:51The ushers, the bartenders

2:03:52Everybody, thank you, thank you

2:03:54I want to thank my good friend Caleb Sexton

2:03:57the audio editor of the talk show

2:03:59every week, but he does so much

2:04:01at this show

2:04:02Indispensable

2:04:04Adam Lissagore and Sandwich

2:04:07and Theater

2:04:08for filming this

2:04:12and taking care of

2:04:13I have nothing to do with this

2:04:16except letting Adam

2:04:17run wild and do his thing

2:04:19and I think it is so cool

2:04:21I also think

2:04:24Theater in particular

2:04:26I think it is so cool

2:04:27that we're doing this live

2:04:29on Vision Pro

2:04:30and Spatial

2:04:31and I really thought

2:04:33after we did this show

2:04:34this way the last year

2:04:35I was like, well

2:04:36by next year

2:04:37there will be a whole bunch of them

2:04:38and it doesn't seem like that happened

2:04:40for some reason

2:04:41and I would like to thank everybody out there

2:04:45watching on theater

2:04:46hello

2:04:46here at 3D

2:04:48hello

2:04:49he looks way better in his persona

2:04:53this is the line

2:04:55they told me not to cross

2:04:56but my thanks to them

2:04:59my thanks to

2:05:00my wife and my son

2:05:03are both here

2:05:04Amy and Jonas

2:05:05and they both do

2:05:06a ton of stuff

2:05:07behind the scenes

2:05:08we had to send Jonas

2:05:10back to the hotel room

2:05:1215 minutes

2:05:12before the doors open

2:05:14to get an adapter

2:05:16USB to audio out

2:05:19forget it, Jonah

2:05:20it's Dongle Town

2:05:20yeah

2:05:21well, having a 21 year old

2:05:23back there to work

2:05:23and you can get to the hotel

2:05:25and back in 10 minutes

2:05:26easy, no problem

2:05:27I want to thank our sponsors

2:05:29iMazing, Details Pro

2:05:31and Uni

2:05:32I want to thank everybody

2:05:35I already thanked everybody

2:05:36watching on theater

2:05:37but I want to thank everybody

2:05:38who came to the show

2:05:39thank you

2:05:40very much

2:05:41in the audience

2:05:43and last but not least

2:05:44Joanna Stern

2:05:46and Nilay Patel

2:05:47thank you

2:05:48I wanted to thank Apple

2:05:50this opportunity

2:05:53And thank you to Apple for the opportunity to have me live.

2:05:57Thank you, Apple, for this opportunity to be here.