0:00:00Jason, sometimes, well, I'm always happy to have you on the show, but then it's like, who should I have on the show? I want to do a show. There's a lot to talk about. And I think, ah, and then I look and it's like, man, Jason hasn't been on since September. That's a long time. And then I'm doing the show notes where, you know, my little outline here. I'm looking at the topics and I've got it in my head now. I could not have anybody on the show this week but you.
0:00:22Yeah, I mean, we've got late night TV. We've got old computers.
0:00:26We've got Apple Sue and Apple Media.
0:00:30Yeah, we could talk about baseball and keyboards. Everybody loves that. There's so much for us to talk about.
0:00:37I know, I know. Let's get the baseball out of the way right now. I got a question for you.
0:00:42What do you think about the home run swing off in the All-Star game?
0:00:46I think nobody wants to see the third tier of All-Stars grind through extra innings.
0:00:52And if you get through nine and it's tied, having a swing off is a perfectly reasonable way to handle an exhibition game.
0:01:00But the people who are like, oh, they should end all the baseball games with one of those.
0:01:04It's like, folks, there will never be a more dramatic.
0:01:07That was the we literally saw the best possible outcome.
0:01:11Those three home runs by Schwarber, well, you'll never, I mean, that was a lot of fun, but you'll never get that again.
0:01:19That was the best.
0:01:20It reminds me of, and again, this is sort of like, to me, I wouldn't trade it for anything in the world.
0:01:28I think it was magic.
0:01:29But when I was growing up, and again, it sounds so old-timey now in the year 2025, but I didn't grow up in the middle of nowhere.
0:01:36It was right next to the city of Reading, Pennsylvania.
0:01:39It's a suburb.
0:01:40But it really was like, me and my pals went out to play.
0:01:45And sometimes, usually by the seasons of the pro sports, we'd be playing touch football or tackle football on the grass.
0:01:52We'd play a lot of baseball.
0:01:54Just kids on a baseball field, playing baseball, no adults.
0:01:57And it was totally stereotypical.
0:02:02My mom had said, just come home when the streetlights come on.
0:02:06I mean, that really was like the rule.
0:02:08And we didn't have watches.
0:02:09Nobody wore a watch.
0:02:10And it might be a tie.
0:02:13That's the sort of thing we would make up.
0:02:14Okay, we've all got to go, but the game is tied.
0:02:17Let's see who can hit one out of here first.
0:02:21Yeah, having a good, I think what it points out is that sports should have a pretty good, like, if you want to be, Americans are very much like this, a sport that does not have ties.
0:02:33I actually think ties are fine.
0:02:34I would say in baseball, like, I'd say after 12 innings, you should just call it a tie and walk away or 11.
0:02:40But if you're going to have to break the tie, break it in a way that is fun and doesn't take too long.
0:02:47So I do, Lauren and I do curling here, the Olympic, the ice, shuffleboard on ice.
0:02:53Yeah, yes.
0:02:54Anyway, if we're in our rec league, if you're done at the end, I mean, you can just call it a tie.
0:02:58Otherwise, both sides throw one stone.
0:03:01Whoever's closest to the target wins at the end, right?
0:03:03And I really like that because that's like your touch football on the grass.
0:03:07It's like, how do we settle this, but we got to go, so let's finish it off.
0:03:11And baseball, the problem with baseball and the problem with when you do soccer and you do a full extra period is it just goes on.
0:03:19Baseball could go on infinitely.
0:03:21There's that meme of we're in the 19th inning.
0:03:23The sun begins to rise.
0:03:24The sun swells.
0:03:25The sun consumes the earth.
0:03:26Like, you could go on forever.
0:03:28So I really like the idea of having a quick, fun thing that is not the sport, but we got to leave.
0:03:34We're done here.
0:03:35Let's settle this and be done.
0:03:37I don't go to see that.
0:03:39I like to see a handful of in-person games a year.
0:03:42And maybe when I get older and have more time, I'll go to see more.
0:03:47But I've had over the last 20 years, I think, given that I only go to see maybe on average two and a half in-person major league games a year,
0:03:57I've been to a surprising number of extra inning games and two that were really long.
0:04:01One was the first game I ever brought Jonas to when he was, I think, two and a half.
0:04:07Yeah, I think he was two and a half.
0:04:09And it got to, and we had seats.
0:04:12I remember the seats for this game.
0:04:13We were here in Philly, and we were a seat I really like.
0:04:17Sort of near the field between first base and right field, down the right field line.
0:04:23But close enough to see plays at first base, which I always like to see.
0:04:27I just love how, when you're in person, what looks on TV like, oh, my God, that was close.
0:04:32It's like, no, it wasn't even that close.
0:04:33That guy was out.
0:04:34I love it when you're in person that you can see that.
0:04:36But we're down there, and I forget how long the game went.
0:04:39Somebody could look it up.
0:04:40Some Phillies game in July of, it would be 2006, went to extra innings.
0:04:46And my wife was there, and Jonas was up, and he was good.
0:04:50And it was like, I don't know, the 13th or 14th inning, and it's still tied.
0:04:53And we're like, oh, we better go.
0:04:55I mean, this is crazy.
0:04:56This kid's only two and a half years old.
0:04:58It's, I don't know, midnight, past midnight.
0:05:01And we left with him.
0:05:03And I hated leaving.
0:05:03I've never, first, I think, the only baseball game I've ever left in my life before it was
0:05:08officially over.
0:05:09But I was like, I don't know what else to do.
0:05:11We leave.
0:05:12He's good.
0:05:12I'm holding him.
0:05:13And there's all these other dads holding, like, 11-year-olds, 12-year-olds, which is a
0:05:17really hard carry.
0:05:18But these 11-year-olds are asleep.
0:05:22They need to be carried home.
0:05:25And then one time we were there, it was probably about 10 years ago, we were at Yankee Stadium.
0:05:28And it was, might have been Yankees, Red Sox.
0:05:31Our friend Paul Kafasis was there, too.
0:05:33And this game just would not end.
0:05:35I mean, it was like, it was like 18 innings, something like that.
0:05:39And they were long innings.
0:05:42Like, there were men on base all the time, and nobody's scoring.
0:05:45And you could hear individual fans who were left, and it's, I love baseball, but my God,
0:05:50end this.
0:05:51Yeah.
0:05:53It is.
0:05:53After a while, like, there becomes a kind of perverse joy in watching, like, pitchers have
0:05:59to field and stuff, because they don't know what they're doing or position players pitching.
0:06:03But yeah, there comes, I'm a big believer in the idea that a penalty shootout is not the
0:06:09best way to solve a soccer match, because that's not the sport.
0:06:12That's like an add-on to the sport and a swing-off in baseball.
0:06:14It's not quite the sport.
0:06:16But at some point, either you need to call it a tie, or you need to say, let's end this
0:06:21now.
0:06:21And that's that.
0:06:23Actually, as a college football fan, I prefer the way they handle college, because they basically
0:06:29give you the ball really close and say, try to score.
0:06:31You got one shot.
0:06:32And then the other team, it's like, try to match them.
0:06:34And if you can match them, they keep doing it.
0:06:36But like, it's increasingly hard.
0:06:38And those games do not.
0:06:39I went to like a five-overtime game once, and it literally, the guy who was the head coach
0:06:43on the other team, or maybe it was four overtimes, it was Dick Tomey, who was the coach at Arizona
0:06:47at the time, and they lost.
0:06:48And he got to the fourth overtime, and he just went for two at the end, because he didn't
0:06:52care.
0:06:53He just wanted it to be over.
0:06:54And they didn't.
0:06:54And they didn't get it, and they lost by one.
0:06:56And in the offseason, he was on the rules committee, and he said, this must stop.
0:07:00And they changed the rules, so it's literally after you do it once, you got to go for two.
0:07:05And then after four, it's just a two-point conversion, because end this.
0:07:09The goal is, I don't mind ties, but if you're not going to have a tie.
0:07:13You just, it's got to end.
0:07:14Make, let it be exciting.
0:07:17It can be a crescendo.
0:07:18It's the climate.
0:07:19And then leave.
0:07:20Everybody get out.
0:07:21We got to clean up the stadium.
0:07:22Yeah.
0:07:23How are you feeling about the Manfred man?
0:07:25Now, for those of you out there who aren't baseball fans, this is what baseball's been
0:07:29playing with since COVID.
0:07:30It was like introduced.
0:07:32Yeah.
0:07:32Yada.
0:07:33There was like some explanation, like yada, yada, yada, COVID restrictions.
0:07:37Yeah.
0:07:37Yeah.
0:07:38It's basically, they didn't want the games.
0:07:39They didn't, they, I think they felt like the pitching staffs were really overtaxed and
0:07:43in COVID time, they were, they were having issues with that.
0:07:45And so they, they introduced what I, I don't know who, who invented it, if it was Craig Calcaterra
0:07:51or not.
0:07:52I don't know, but I love it because it's the joke about the Manfred man's earth band,
0:07:56the old sixties band.
0:07:58And so the Manfred man is Rob Manfred, the commissioner of baseball saying in extra innings
0:08:01that we just put a guy out on second base.
0:08:03He's like a ghost runner.
0:08:04How'd he get there?
0:08:04Nobody knows.
0:08:05Don't ask.
0:08:06I like it.
0:08:07I like it because it ends the game faster.
0:08:09I mean, bottom line, I like it because, because baseball is a low scoring game and you could
0:08:13go four or five innings where nobody does anything.
0:08:16And with the Manfred man out there, it's again, it's likely to be over in 10 or 11 and,
0:08:21and we can all go home.
0:08:22Let's just, I wish I've had a good day.
0:08:24Let's go home now.
0:08:25If I got to be baseball commissioner, I would have the Manfred man start in the like 12th
0:08:31inning.
0:08:31I would give, I'd give the teams two innings of real baseball.
0:08:35You're like, tell me with the, with the overtimes, you're like, you can have a little bit, but
0:08:39after that it's over.
0:08:41Stop.
0:08:41Yeah.
0:08:41Yeah.
0:08:42So, but otherwise, I don't know, but how would you, I just make it a tie after 12, maybe
0:08:49you get the Manfred man in the 11th inning and the 12th inning.
0:08:51And then it's over.
0:08:52Just, you both lose.
0:08:53I do think.
0:08:54And I do think too, it is a oddly American mindset to be, to have this aversion to, to
0:09:01ties or draw, whatever you want to call them.
0:09:03Absolutely.
0:09:04It really is.
0:09:05And I don't get it.
0:09:06And I know in the NFL, it's like if the overtime period ends up with no scores, it becomes a
0:09:12tie, but that almost never happens.
0:09:14Well, yeah, but they changed the rules.
0:09:16Sorry, non-sports fans, but you know, even nerds have to like rule structures and stuff
0:09:20like that.
0:09:20And they changed the rules in the NFL to make the overtime shorter and that there's this
0:09:25ability to match if somebody scores a field goal.
0:09:27And so now you do see a lot more ties and you see a lot more games that end with like 30
0:09:32seconds left or two seconds left because even that Superbowl, the 49ers and the, and the
0:09:37chiefs in the Superbowl a couple of years ago, that overtime was almost over.
0:09:41I believe when that, when the chiefs won because, and they would have just played another overtime,
0:09:46right?
0:09:46Because it's the Superbowl.
0:09:47But like when the games aren't advancing somebody in a tournament, I, I, I root for the tie in
0:09:52the NFL.
0:09:53Honestly, I love it.
0:09:54I love it when the teams are just, they're flopping around.
0:09:56They can't score.
0:09:57It's at some point, if you, if nobody's going to win this game, we need to stop.
0:10:01I just, just neither of you deserves a win now.
0:10:04Let's just leave.
0:10:05Yeah.
0:10:06I, it still bothers me game theory wise that if you win the toss in NFL and you, you say
0:10:13when everybody wants the ball because of this rule.
0:10:15So you get the kickoff and if you score a touchdown, you win and that's it.
0:10:19And the other team doesn't playoffs, but yeah, but it, yeah, except in that, that alone bothers
0:10:23me, right?
0:10:24The playoffs should be the same game you play in a regular season, which is also what bothers
0:10:29me about the Manford man that they take it out for post-season baseball.
0:10:32I think college is onto a better track.
0:10:35I agree.
0:10:35I think that the regular football where you play four quarters and there's a clock and
0:10:40the clock is very, very important strategically to the game.
0:10:42Then that's over.
0:10:44And I think you should have a coin toss for who decides they want the ball first and then
0:10:50do something like college where you get the ball on the 40 yard line and then the other
0:10:54team is guaranteed to get it too.
0:10:55And you've got to decide, see who matches.
0:10:57Yeah.
0:10:58And you've got to decide, do you kick an extra point or do you go for two if you score a
0:11:01touchdown?
0:11:01That's right.
0:11:02Up to you.
0:11:02Yeah.
0:11:03I like that a lot.
0:11:04If I was the NFL commissioner for a day, I'm going to share with you my weird thing
0:11:08that I would do.
0:11:08I think the listeners will really appreciate this, boy, more than anything.
0:11:11But it's a preview of this fall because the NFL, for those who do not know, the NFL is
0:11:16going to do this asinine thing this fall where they're going to use lasers and cameras to
0:11:22spot the football on the field.
0:11:23Oh, I heard about this.
0:11:25And it's the most fake technological solution because what's going to happen is the play
0:11:30will be over.
0:11:30A referee will eyeball where the ball was and then they'll use lasers.
0:11:35It's like, why are you using lasers?
0:11:37If you can't measure where it was and somebody's like, about here.
0:11:42And then the lasers clamp down and they're like, okay, that's where it is then.
0:11:45Exactly.
0:11:46It's like you're refining something that isn't refined.
0:11:49It doesn't make any sense.
0:11:50It's significant figures kind of thing.
0:11:52It doesn't make any sense.
0:11:53So if I was the commissioner for a day, you know, the rule is like you break the plane
0:11:57of the goal line to score a touchdown.
0:11:58If I were commissioner for a day, I'd make the rule in football that everything snaps.
0:12:02It's like snapping in Photoshop.
0:12:03Everything snaps to the yard line.
0:12:05And if you don't break the plane of the next yard line, the ball gets put back on the previous
0:12:09yard line.
0:12:10And there's no like halfway, one inch, quarter of an inch, third of an inch, because I don't
0:12:13think human beings on that field can measure like that.
0:12:16So it would literally be if you're at the two yard line and you gain six in,
0:12:20inches, you're back at the two yard line because you got to break the plane of the one yard
0:12:24line to get to the one.
0:12:25If I was, if I ran the zoo, that's what I do because they don't seem to have the technology
0:12:30to measure like where the ball is when the clock is stopped.
0:12:35And I get it because there's a big pile of guys on it and they can't see it.
0:12:38And that's how all the other sports use cameras to do that.
0:12:40I don't think it will be hard for technology to solve this problem.
0:12:44Yeah.
0:12:44But instead, the NFL says, yeah, we'll just slap a laser in there and that'll impress people.
0:12:50Do you think this is entirely because of the one game, the playoff game this year with Buffalo
0:12:54and the Chiefs are playing and it's at the end of the game and Josh Allen is running and
0:12:59they really gave Buffalo a very bad spot.
0:13:02Oh, yeah.
0:13:03I think it's that one play and there's an overhead camera that CBS had that showed it and it's
0:13:09like, I don't know exactly, you know, if you're talking about inches, who knows exactly where
0:13:14he got, but when they put the ball like most of a yard behind where he clearly got to, it's
0:13:18like, what the hell is going on?
0:13:20That's, that's not right.
0:13:21And then one bad, one bad play in a big game and all of a sudden they change the rules for
0:13:26every game.
0:13:26That's what I was going to say is a lot of times rules change.
0:13:30Why is it, and this is apparently just changing right now, but why is it that people take
0:13:34off their shoes to go to the airport to go through the security?
0:13:37It's because one guy, because Richard Reed in like 2004 tried to have like flammable stuff
0:13:43in his shoes that he was going to ignite and it didn't work.
0:13:46And since then everybody has to take their shoes off until maybe this year for like two
0:13:50decades, everybody had, and it's because there was a single high profile incident.
0:13:54And so people are like, okay, we have to be seen as doing something.
0:13:57And I think that's right.
0:13:59I have a guy who was not really even a serious terrorist.
0:14:02He was very bad at his job.
0:14:03He was a real kook and his shoe bombs were just, I don't know, a bunch of stuff glued to
0:14:10his goopy shoes just leaking out of them.
0:14:12And it could have done damage, I think, but like the idea is that just a huge overreaction.
0:14:17So yes, I think you're right.
0:14:18I think that some high profile thing happens.
0:14:20This is what, that's why there's the weird overtime rule in the NFL now is because weird,
0:14:25a weird thing happened.
0:14:26Somebody won the coin toss, went down, kicked a field goal and won a playoff game.
0:14:30And they're like, no, we can't allow that anymore.
0:14:32I think it was also a Bills Chiefs game where, where it was the crazy high scoring game.
0:14:36And then Josh Allen didn't even get to touch the ball.
0:14:38And they scored, I don't know.
0:14:39It was like three touchdowns were scored in the last 20 seconds of the game goes to overtime.
0:14:44And then the Chiefs score another one and the Bills don't even get to touch the ball or something
0:14:48like that.
0:14:48I don't, I can't believe we haven't even talked about keyboards yet.
0:14:51Which sport?
0:14:52Here's the sport.
0:14:53The sport that overtime is the most natural for is basketball.
0:14:57Nobody ever talks about it because it is a, because it is a, unlike other sports, you score
0:15:04a hundred points a game, right?
0:15:05Especially if it goes to overtime.
0:15:07So you just, all right, we'll play five more minutes and it's, it just works out.
0:15:13Nobody ever thinks, and every once in a while there's double overtime and like once a year
0:15:17there might be a triple overtime, but even then it's 15 minutes of basketball.
0:15:20Yeah, it's, it's, it's fine.
0:15:22I mean, the problem is the basketball has the best solution to this, which is the Elam ending
0:15:26where they basically, when you, when you reach a threshold, like when the clock's got five
0:15:31minutes to go, the Elam ending is like you add a number of points to whoever has the most
0:15:36point.
0:15:36So it's, let's say it's 88 to 80 and they're like, oh, five minutes to go.
0:15:41That high score is 88, add 10 to that first team to 98 wins.
0:15:46And then the clock gets turned off.
0:15:48And, and, and apparently they did this in an all-star game one year.
0:15:51Apparently it can lead to some very exciting outcomes because everybody knows that you have
0:15:56to get to 98.
0:15:57Right.
0:15:58And, and do you take three pointers?
0:15:59Do you take two pointers?
0:16:00What do you do?
0:16:02And it gets, it gets to be very dramatic.
0:16:04And I kind of love it because I, sometimes I think maybe this is me as a baseball fan.
0:16:07Sometimes I feel like the clock is the worst thing.
0:16:10Like watching a clock instead of watching people play sports, but bugs the heck out of me.
0:16:15That's the problem.
0:16:16So the problem with basketball that you, you touched on it.
0:16:18It's not the overtime.
0:16:19Overtime is natural for basketball.
0:16:21It's the time, it's the time killing at the end of the game.
0:16:24The game that it becomes strategic to play the clock rather than to play basketball.
0:16:27So imagine if there was no clock, then they could just play.
0:16:30And then, and then, and also then there would always be a winner.
0:16:33Yeah.
0:16:34I like it.
0:16:34Yeah.
0:16:35And then it gets, it also gets a little more playground deep where playground basketball is
0:16:39always first to 11 or 21 or something.
0:16:42Maybe the playground knows what, see, I think that's the answer here is what we've said is
0:16:45you guys out on the, on the grass playing tackle football on a, on a fall day in Pennsylvania,
0:16:51you, you knew what, what was up.
0:16:53You, you guys had the right answer.
0:16:55Yeah.
0:16:56All right.
0:16:57I do actually have keyboard news.
0:16:58Okay.
0:17:00I bought, I bought my first new, I bought my first new mechanical keyboard in several years.
0:17:05I, several years ago I gave up.
0:17:07I was like, what am I doing?
0:17:09I keep buying.
0:17:09I thought you weren't going to do this anymore.
0:17:11I, I, I figured out that I, every couple of years and then you come on and I talk about
0:17:16it and then I've, I've spent, I don't know, a hundred, usually a hundred, 200, sometimes
0:17:21a little more, never too much.
0:17:23And I buy a new mechanical keyboard and I kind of know what I like and, and I get it
0:17:28and it's, this is okay.
0:17:31And then, and there's a couple of days where I'm like, this is novel and it's fun to have
0:17:35a new keyboard.
0:17:36And then I go back to my Apple extended keyboard too on my desk and that's it.
0:17:40And I get it.
0:17:42And now I don't have a crazy high stack of keyboards, but it does, if you looked at all
0:17:47of them, because I never throw them out, it's starting to look a little crazy, even though
0:17:51it's because it's over 10 years, but I actually like this keyboard.
0:17:55It is the new fee or maybe new fi.
0:17:58I'm not.
0:17:59I think it's new fee.
0:17:59All right.
0:18:00They spell their name.
0:18:02And you can't camel case P H Y.
0:18:06And they make, and I have another one from them from a couple of years ago.
0:18:10I think they sent it to me actually out of the blue as like a, like a review unit.
0:18:15I think I have one or two from them that they sent me, but I bought what they call the kick
0:18:2075 and the kick 75 is, you can't, it doesn't come as a kit that you can change, but it is
0:18:29some kind of breakthrough that they are, they're claiming it as a breakthrough where the same
0:18:34keyboard can take either low profile or high profile switches in the same keyboard.
0:18:40So you could buy both sets and then do all the work of taking out the switches and, and
0:18:47apparently that the difference between low profile and high profile, and for anybody who's not
0:18:52a keyboard nerd at all, it just means exactly what you think.
0:18:54High profile is exactly what you think most mechanical keyboards are and low profile are
0:19:00more like laptop keys.
0:19:03They're, they're, they're, the actual plastic key caps are smaller and you press them less
0:19:08to go in.
0:19:09So they're sort of like the laptop keys from, and we'll get to this topic in a bit, like
0:19:14old, like late 1980s, early 1990s PC laptops when they actually were still mechanical keyboards
0:19:21on laptops.
0:19:22I don't like low profile.
0:19:24That's one thing I've tried.
0:19:25Yeah.
0:19:26I agree.
0:19:27I don't see the point.
0:19:27If I want something like that, I'd probably just use an Apple keyboard.
0:19:31It's not even mechanical.
0:19:32So I like high profile.
0:19:33So I ignored that aspect of the Newfie 75.
0:19:37I just went high profile, brown, and other things I like about this keyboard.
0:19:42A, I like their fun colors.
0:19:43Anybody, I'll put this in the show notes.
0:19:45You could see it.
0:19:46It's got like a fun yellow space bar.
0:19:48It's got a blue.
0:19:48It's sort of a, sort of like Google colors or I guess we, and it would be a little
0:19:52which, and Google colors are sort of primary colors, right?
0:19:55It's like crayon green, crayola yellow, a blue return key.
0:20:00I like that even though it's sort of a smaller layout, it's not an extended layout.
0:20:07The arrow keys have a little bit of separation, not like a laptop where they're Tetris totally
0:20:13into the other keys.
0:20:14There's a little bit of space there for the arrow upside down T arrow keys, and it has page
0:20:20page up, page down, and, but not both home and end, which is, I don't get, I don't get why,
0:20:29and it looks like there's room for it, right?
0:20:31It just has, I forget which one, home, but page up and page down are the ones that are the ones that are the one.
0:20:36This is a very similar layout to the keyboard that I've been using the last few years, which
0:20:40is the Keychron Q1.
0:20:41It's fairly compact.
0:20:44It's a 75%.
0:20:45So it's got a function row, and it's got arrow keys that are separate, and it's got page up,
0:20:50page down, home, basically.
0:20:51Yeah, I guess home is somehow deemed more important than end, but I guess so.
0:20:56I guess I want to pop to the top.
0:20:58And I don't even know, is that for us Mac users, or is it for the PC users?
0:21:03And you can assign it anything, so you can do whatever you want.
0:21:06Yeah.
0:21:06You know what home and end do for PC users?
0:21:08Do they not go to the top and the bottom?
0:21:11No, they move the insertion point to the beginning and end of line.
0:21:15Or at least they did.
0:21:16Yeah.
0:21:17And again, you can configure this, but like a standard, I think, bog standard PC setup,
0:21:23if your keyboard has home and end and you're typing, home and end move to the beginning and end of line,
0:21:28like command left arrow and command right arrow as God intended.
0:21:33Anyway, I like this keyboard.
0:21:35It has, the keys have a sort of chalky, I mean, I'm not going to try to ASMR it here on the podcast,
0:21:42but you can go to their website and listen to it.
0:21:44But sort of a chalky feel instead of a clicky sound.
0:21:49And I did use it at my desk for three or four days before I went back to my Apple extended keyboard too.
0:21:55But now this is my kitchen keyboard.
0:21:57I have a drawer where I'm allowed to keep stuff in the kitchen.
0:22:00And when I want to type on my phone or sometimes my iPad, instead of using that little cramped 11-inch magic keyboard,
0:22:10I use this.
0:22:12And so it is my second favorite keyboard.
0:22:15Yeah, that's good.
0:22:16It's, I mean, I, given your familiarity, I don't think you will ever find literally,
0:22:21I don't think anyone could make a keyboard that you would like better than the Apple extended too.
0:22:27Because you, because you know it so well that even if somebody could distill exactly what you like about it
0:22:32and then make something that was just even more of that, I don't, I think you'd be like, that's too much.
0:22:37Because I think you just have, have settled on this.
0:22:40The good news is, I know you've got spares, but, and, and by the way, just some follow-up from your,
0:22:46I think, interview with Mike Hurley that you did on Cortex.
0:22:51Yes, you totally could get, I mean, he said it, you could totally get your old keyboard fixed.
0:22:55You could fix that one key and you could, you could move ahead with that.
0:22:59But I was never quite as fond.
0:23:00I have here, in fact, I showed it to you the other week.
0:23:03It's the smaller, it's still huge, but it's the smaller version of your keyboard.
0:23:07It's the keyboard I got with my Mac SE.
0:23:09And I like it.
0:23:10And I, I definitely wrote on that, wrote hundreds of thousands of words on that over the years in the, in the like 90s.
0:23:16But, oh, wait, that keyboard you showed me was yours from way back when?
0:23:21No, it's an eBay replacement because I, I got rid of that.
0:23:23But it's the same, it's the exact same model.
0:23:25It's the model that you did use, right?
0:23:26That I, that I did use.
0:23:28Yeah, exactly.
0:23:28With a Tinker Boy USB-C to 80B adapter, which is great, which has probably got more electronics brains in it than the Mac SE had in it.
0:23:36But it's, this is the world we live in.
0:23:38We're in the 2020s now.
0:23:39But I, I did, I'm somebody who came back to mechanical keyboards and was like, this is the feeling I like.
0:23:45But I didn't have, I had broken that.
0:23:48I had been using just generic Apple keyboards for so long that I can, I have managed to find like brown switches and, and the high profile keys.
0:23:56And, and Mike Hurley made me this Q1 with these Kiwi switches in it.
0:24:01And they're really good.
0:24:02They're like, they come hand, they're like pre-lubricated and everything.
0:24:06And it's, it's a good setup.
0:24:08I have two now in two different rooms, but if I had, if I had kept that using that keyboard throughout my career, there is no way you could get me to stop because once you're used to something like that.
0:24:19And, and I was just talking to Andy and I co about this, which is don't feel bad about it because this is what we do.
0:24:25These are like the tools of our trade.
0:24:26This is your, this is your ax.
0:24:28This is your electric guitar.
0:24:29This is your screwdriver.
0:24:30This is your, your, your, your Ram truck, whatever it is as a writer, the keyboards as silly as it seems, it totally matters because that's, that's our tool of our, our, our trade is, is the keyboard.
0:24:41Yeah.
0:24:42And the microphones, I guess, I guess the microphones are part of our trade now too, but they're less exciting to me than the keyboards.
0:24:49Yeah.
0:24:50Because I mean, I guess some people have the ear of Marco, I think obviously has this.
0:24:56Sure.
0:24:57And Mike has opinions.
0:24:58Yeah.
0:24:59I don't hear it.
0:25:01I don't hear my difference when I use a dip.
0:25:03I had a professional, there was a Thanksgiving.
0:25:07And if I'm being honest now at Thanksgiving where I'd had, I'd had a few because it was Thanksgiving.
0:25:12And then I get on Twitter and there's a guy saying, Jason, you sound terrible on your podcast.
0:25:17You're using the wrong microphone.
0:25:18And I'm like, who the hell are you?
0:25:19He says, well, I'm a professional audio engineer.
0:25:21And I'm like, oh crap.
0:25:23And he said, get a guess, get a sure SM seven B it's the right microphone for your voice.
0:25:28And I bought one and this, the, the one I'm talking to you on.
0:25:31And my travel mic is now in a sure as MV seven, which is basically the USB version of the same
0:25:36microphone.
0:25:37And it's okay.
0:25:37All right.
0:25:38I'm, I, I'm big enough to admit that I was wrong 12 years ago on Thanksgiving.
0:25:43I think the difference with keyboards though, is, and it's that you feel right.
0:25:51And so I guess if I really cared about exactly how I sound, then, you know, that's a feeling
0:25:57too.
0:25:58But I think I sound good on all the, you know, I don't have that many mics.
0:26:01I have this one, a USB travel mic.
0:26:03Sure.
0:26:03And you don't get that kind of feedback when you're talking.
0:26:06I mean, you do get some feedback when you're talking, but it's just not the same as, and
0:26:09again, for, I talk to people, I mean, my wife is like this.
0:26:13She's like, stop talking about keyboards.
0:26:15I don't care.
0:26:15And, and, and she shouldn't care, but like some of us do, and we don't care.
0:26:20Look, there are people who care about keyboards or other stuff for purely kind of like academic
0:26:25just, or just fun reasons.
0:26:26It's a hobby, but like, seriously, I care about it mostly because I sit here writing a lot
0:26:31of words on my keyboard and I like it.
0:26:33I like it when it sounds good and feels good and I get into a flow and I can type 120 words
0:26:38a minute and that matters to me.
0:26:39So it's a professional tool.
0:26:41It can be boring to other people.
0:26:42That's fine.
0:26:43Yeah.
0:26:43And like, it's always good advice to, to don't cheap out on the chair that you buy for your
0:26:49desk.
0:26:49If you have a, if you can afford it, if you find a chair that you think is perfect and it costs,
0:26:54I don't know, 1500, 2000, I don't even know.
0:26:56I have a chair.
0:26:56I bought mine for, I think somewhere between 1500 and 2000, like 10, 15 years ago, but it's
0:27:03money well spent because it's, it's actually your health.
0:27:06I think your keyboard probably isn't your health so much.
0:27:09You can get into RSI things, but, but that's more posture.
0:27:12But, but if you just like the way it feels when you click the buttons on the keyboard and
0:27:18your job is either writing or programming or anything where you're actually just
0:27:24fingers on a keyboard and you actually find it pleasant how it sounds and feels, you do
0:27:30it thousands, tens of thousands of times a day, you know, you click these buttons.
0:27:35Positive reinforcement.
0:27:35It really matters.
0:27:36And yeah, I, I, I came in.
0:27:38So I've been on my own for almost 11 years now out here in the garage.
0:27:42And when I started, this was a work from home space.
0:27:45I set up before I left my, my job at Macworld and I, I was, I kind of cheaped out on some
0:27:51stuff and I've gradually come to the realization that I've been in here for a decade.
0:27:56And if, if it's something that matters, that is part of my workspace, I should probably spend
0:28:02money on it because it's part of my workspace.
0:28:05So it took me a decade to go from the curtains that I bought on Amazon for $50 and hung so that
0:28:12I didn't have to stare at our storage area to buy.
0:28:15I just, this happened like a couple of months ago.
0:28:17I bought like a corporate room divider that is eight feet tall that makes this feel like
0:28:22an office and it was, it was like two grand.
0:28:24It was not cheap, but it's my job and it's my workplace.
0:28:28And there is, so, so it's one of those things that like, look, if you can't afford it, that's
0:28:31fine.
0:28:31It's totally understandable.
0:28:32But I think a lot of people end up suffering with crappy things to do their jobs because
0:28:39they're like, no, no, it's fine.
0:28:41And, and, and sometimes the, the trick is realizing when it's actually not fine and this is your
0:28:47profession.
0:28:48And as when I set up my own business, that was one of the first things I learned is,
0:28:52Oh, it's not, it's a business expense, meaning it's free, but it's a business expense means
0:28:56this is a tool I used to do my job.
0:28:58I should probably pay for it.
0:28:59And that's okay.
0:29:00I know that I talked about it with Glenn Fleischman, who's now contributed to six colors, which is
0:29:06some of the, some of the best meet Mac media news that possibly of the year, but that's a
0:29:12great addition to six colors.
0:29:14But I think literally on this show many years ago, I think Glenn was on and we talked about
0:29:19when Glenn was an early Amazon employee and one of the edicts from Bezos was because like
0:29:26when he started it in a like literal garage with two other guys, they made desks out of
0:29:30doors and saw horses.
0:29:33They just took a couple of carpenters or construction, saw horses and abandoned doors, put them
0:29:39on top and then called them desks.
0:29:40And then it became like, well, that's how we started Amazon.
0:29:43So that's what everyone gets.
0:29:44And it's like, that's the, the idea behind it of we're not going to waste a lot of money
0:29:50on needless things.
0:29:52And we're going to be a lean, mean operation, even as we go through extraordinary growth and
0:29:57seeming success.
0:29:58I get that, but you're going to have a desk that is incredibly uncomfortable and is unsuited
0:30:05to be a desk is an ergonomic nightmare and is counterproductive to productivity.
0:30:12It's a nice idea, but a bad in practice.
0:30:16When I was in grad school, I got offered a job at Intel, which, wow, that would have been
0:30:22weird.
0:30:23It would be like writing for the internal Intel communication.
0:30:25I dodged a bullet there.
0:30:28It did.
0:30:28It did get me a bigger, a better job offer for Mac user.
0:30:31They put some more money in.
0:30:32So that was, that was good.
0:30:33But I interviewed there and they were talking about their corporate culture.
0:30:36And I want people know Intel of circa 1994, 93, 94, but they were riding high.
0:30:43They were riding really high.
0:30:44This was Pentium era.
0:30:45They were riding high.
0:30:46And they were like very proud of the fact that they had a really cubicle egalitarian culture.
0:30:52Everybody had a cubicle and they bragged.
0:30:54They're like, everybody has a cubicle.
0:30:56Even Andy Grove has a cubicle.
0:30:57And I walked by Andy Grove's cubicle.
0:31:00So Andy Grove was the CEO of Intel, one of the most powerful people in the tech industry
0:31:06in the nineties.
0:31:07And, and, and they were like so proud.
0:31:09Even Andy Grove has a cubicle.
0:31:11John, Andy Grove's cubicle was a fortress.
0:31:16It was the size of 15 cubicles that led to a cubicle that was the size of eight cubicles.
0:31:22That was the outer waiting room reception area that presumably led to something the size of
0:31:2915 or 20 cubicles.
0:31:30That was Andy Grove's cubicle.
0:31:33So I, and, and that moment I had one of those, oh, these are the lies that corporations tell
0:31:37themselves.
0:31:38I see.
0:31:38Right.
0:31:38I see how this is.
0:31:39As a 23 year old who was trying to get my first job, I realized that, and I had a power
0:31:46book with me and I was like, did the lasers come out of the ceiling and blast the power book?
0:31:49Because it's not an Intel computer, but yeah, that's the, those are the same things.
0:31:53They're the lies that a lot of corporations have those, have those tenets that don't make sense
0:31:58anymore, but they still do them because it's a totem.
0:32:00They think it matters somehow.
0:32:01That the myth is part of the company's ID.
0:32:03Yeah.
0:32:04Yeah.
0:32:04Oh, I love the idea, the egalitarianism of it, but trust me, Andy Grove is not using
0:32:09your cubicle.
0:32:10All right.
0:32:11Let me take a break here and thank our first sponsor.
0:32:12It's a first time sponsor.
0:32:14Very happy to welcome them to the show.
0:32:16Sentry, like the word that means like a guard, S-E-N-T-R-Y, Sentry.
0:32:23It's a real time error monitoring and tracing platform that helps developer teams and tech
0:32:28companies build better and more reliable products.
0:32:30Look, spending hours debugging is nobody's idea of a good day.
0:32:35Sentry provides the deep context and insights you need to quickly identify, debug, and
0:32:40fix errors in your code.
0:32:42Their new AI debugging agent, SEER, S-E-E-R, is like having an engineer help you who knows
0:32:51your entire code base on call, ready to go when you get like a 1 a.m. red alert bug panic
0:33:00call.
0:33:00SEER can leverage your Sentry data to work smarter and identify correct root causes 94% of the time
0:33:08and optionally provide merge-ready PRs ready based on that analysis.
0:33:13SEER uses Sentry's context, issue details, tracing data, profiles, et cetera, your code base
0:33:20integrated through GitHub and its interactions with you to identify and reason through problems
0:33:26in your code.
0:33:27Other new stuff, they've got AI agent monitoring.
0:33:30If you ever shipped an LLM agent that works flawlessly, it often does until it doesn't.
0:33:35Well, one minute it's summarizing and the next it's hallucinating legal advice, calling the
0:33:40wrong tool.
0:33:41Go to Sentry has a monitoring service that makes that less bad.
0:33:46It traces your agent's whole run.
0:33:48It monitors latency, token usage, prompt inputs, tool errors, all in one timeline and can identify
0:33:55when things go off the rails and need to be reset.
0:33:57What's special is that it's built into the same Sentry you're already using.
0:34:02No extra dashboards, no context switching, not a totally different tool built it on, no existential
0:34:09dread.
0:34:09So go to Sentry, S-E-N-T-R-Y, Sentry.io, and tell them you heard about them from this show,
0:34:19the talk show, and you can actually start understanding what your agents are doing or at least pretend
0:34:24like they do.
0:34:25Once again, go to Sentry, S-E-N-T-R-Y.io, and tell them you came from the talk show.
0:34:33My thanks to Sentry.
0:34:34All right.
0:34:35The keyboard talk parlays right into another topic I wanted to get to.
0:34:39And which is retro 80s, early 80s computing.
0:34:42And I don't know if it's a coincidence or not, or if it's one of those things, I forget
0:34:47what the term is, but it's like recent, it's sort of like recency bias, but something else.
0:34:52But like when you start shopping for something and you're comparison shopping, all of a sudden
0:34:57you see those things everywhere.
0:34:58My wife and I noticed this, I remember 20 some years ago when we needed to shop for baby
0:35:03strollers.
0:35:04And we're like, oh my God, look at them all.
0:35:06And there's different kinds and different brands.
0:35:09And there's, and then while we're thinking about this at like month, I don't know, seven
0:35:14or whatever of the pregnancy, we've got time, but we want to get this stuff done.
0:35:18I'm walking around the city and I see people pushing baby strollers everywhere.
0:35:23I'm like, where did all these babies come from?
0:35:24And I'm like, oh, that's a McLaren.
0:35:26That's this brand.
0:35:27That's that brand.
0:35:28And it's, and I'm like, should I ask that person what they think of this stroller?
0:35:31Do they look, and I'm like, I'm not going to be a weirdo, but I'm like, do they look happy
0:35:34with the stroller?
0:35:35But I saw them everywhere.
0:35:36And you know what's funny, Jason?
0:35:38I haven't seen a baby stroller in, in months right now.
0:35:42Huh?
0:35:43So I don't know if it's like that with this retro computing, but it seems like I, you, me
0:35:49and you off, I think before the Commodore thing even came out, we were talking about
0:35:54it based on your Apple keyboard.
0:35:56That's actually the name of the keyboard, by the way.
0:35:58Right.
0:35:59It's called like the way mine, there was an Apple extended keyboard and mine, which is only
0:36:05made for a few years, like 1988 and 89.
0:36:08And then it was replaced by the Apple extended keyboard too.
0:36:12Yours was the smaller, unextended version of that just called Apple keyboard, which is
0:36:19classic, the Apple keyboard.
0:36:20Yeah.
0:36:21Because we were going back and forth about some of the weird layout decisions that happened
0:36:24back then, like the arrow keys are all in a row.
0:36:26And some of that was picked up from the Apple II and the Apple IIc that I've got behind me
0:36:32is like that too.
0:36:33And there's just like weird, because keyboard layouts have sort of settled down now, but
0:36:37back in the day it was, it was a bit of the wild West.
0:36:39And so we were talking about weird things on keyboards and how I was talking about how I
0:36:45learned, I had this conversation with my wife, actually.
0:36:48She, she looked at me like I was crazy because her keyboard at work has the number pad.
0:36:53And I said, I hate the number pad.
0:36:54I don't want a number pad.
0:36:55And she's like, why?
0:36:56And I realized it's because my Commodore pet that I had as a kid.
0:37:00And then the Apple II didn't have a number pad.
0:37:02And I learned to type in programs in basic, which had lots of numbers, entirely using the
0:37:07one, one to nine, zero at the top row of the keyboard to the point that I can, I can type
0:37:12numbers in completely without looking into the keyboard.
0:37:15And it, and it feels perfectly comfortable for me.
0:37:18I don't need, and that led us onto a whole thing about how the number pads numbers are
0:37:22inverted from the touchstone on a phone.
0:37:24And what's that about?
0:37:25And like, it was this whole, like things that seemed fine at the time.
0:37:29And I mentioned the Commodore pet and I said, and I think that was when we had that moment
0:37:33of the, the two, the quote mark is shift two, which I have since come to find because we've
0:37:40been talking about retro computing in public is actually quite common on European keyboards
0:37:45where they need extra keys for accented characters.
0:37:49The quote mark ends up at shift two.
0:37:51And my first computer keyboard was the Commodore pet, not the little teeny tiny metal one, but
0:37:57the one that was like a real keyboard, but it, it didn't, it was shift two for quote.
0:38:01And, and there's an emulator that you linked me to a C64 emulator.
0:38:05And I typed in your Kmart sucks thing.
0:38:08And I had a moment where I pressed shift two and it all came back to me, John.
0:38:12It was like, it was 1982 again, where I was like, Oh, shift two to quote.
0:38:16That is, that is what it is.
0:38:18And it's just, it's fascinating.
0:38:20We talk about keyboards, but like in those early days, they were, there were distinct
0:38:24subcultures, but also like the rules were just all over the place.
0:38:28Like depending on what device you had, if you had an Atari or a C64 or an Apple or a TRS-80,
0:38:36like anything goes.
0:38:37And so it was a great time.
0:38:39The reason why I think it's so fun to hear from people, even if they're very angry with
0:38:42us about that period is because it's been so long that it was just two of something, Mac
0:38:49or PC, Android or iPhone.
0:38:52And back then it was before the IBM PC crushed everybody.
0:38:57Basically, it was Apple, Commodore, Atari, Sinclair, and the, and the variants of that TRS-80.
0:39:06There were so many, there were so many different computers that, that were all different and
0:39:12weird.
0:39:12And there wasn't a, a, a, an us versus them.
0:39:15Like, in fact, that was the thing that came up over the last couple of weeks is it turns
0:39:20out, and I didn't, you and I didn't know this because we were Apple II people, right?
0:39:23It turns out that yes, the Commodore people hated Apple II people and the Atari people hated
0:39:29Apple II people.
0:39:30But what I did not know is that the Commodore people and the Atari people really, really hated
0:39:36each other.
0:39:37Because they were fighting over that, that, uh, the ground of being the underdog.
0:39:42And they're like, no, we, it's us, no, it's us.
0:39:45And I had no idea because again, I was not even paying attention because I had an Apple
0:39:49II.
0:39:49So I, I just, and also the other thing I'll throw in before I stopped talking is I was
0:39:56amazed because I, I love my Apple IIe, but I had an Apple IIe as a home computer.
0:40:01And it turns out that the brilliant thing that Apple did, because like in California, Apple
0:40:07gave a computer to every school in California, in California, everybody got an Apple II.
0:40:11You hear the, the Commodore and Atari people talk and they hated the Apple II because it
0:40:17was the computer they had to use at school.
0:40:19And I thought, oh yeah, if it's the computer, that's your homework, then using an Apple II
0:40:24starts to be like, you're taking your medicine.
0:40:26And, and then the computer that you mess around with and play games on at home is the fun thing.
0:40:32And I totally see that.
0:40:33I wasted so much time playing games on my Apple II that I don't feel that way at all.
0:40:37But I get why you would think that if all you were ever able to do was like program in
0:40:42Pascal or play Oregon Trail.
0:40:44Yeah.
0:40:47And I think, I do think that was part of it too.
0:40:50And there's, there's all sorts of technical things people are talking about where the Commodore
0:40:5364 had some kind of built-in sprite engine.
0:40:56It had sprites very early.
0:40:58And it made game programming easier or made certain type of games look better than the
0:41:04Apple II.
0:41:04And I think it plays into that.
0:41:06And I think it's sort of, but that the Apple II, I think almost everybody's fighting over
0:41:15all this stuff.
0:41:15Yeah.
0:41:16But I think, I think for things other than games.
0:41:21And I don't, I think the Apple II was the heyday of Apple gaming, right?
0:41:24It's not like the Apple II, it's not, it's not like the Mac at all, like the Mac is to PC
0:41:29gaming for the last 30 years.
0:41:31I don't know.
0:41:32Or maybe forever.
0:41:33Right.
0:41:34But the Apple II platform was so much better for everything else, for actual quote unquote
0:41:41work, right?
0:41:42VisiCalc was, I think, invented on the Apple II, right?
0:41:45Like it was like the first spreadsheet.
0:41:46I think so.
0:41:48And it was, it was expensive and it was powerful.
0:41:50And I mean, and then, and like Apple II was good for games, but I think you could also say
0:41:56that the Apple II was like kind of overpowered for games because that wasn't really what it
0:42:01was made for, even though I played a lot of games.
0:42:04I also wrote all my papers in high school and my freshman year in college on it.
0:42:08So, and, and whereas the C64, you know, it was probably on your TV at home and very conducive
0:42:14to playing games.
0:42:15And it totally makes sense.
0:42:17What was the, the, it was like a three in one, like a suite that for the Apple II with a word
0:42:23processor, a spreadsheet.
0:42:24That was Apple works.
0:42:26Apple works.
0:42:27Like it was called, I thought it was called that.
0:42:28Before it was on the Mac.
0:42:29I've got it on this Apple IIc that is behind me right now.
0:42:32I, I, you can do it.
0:42:34I did a fantasy baseball league when I was a senior in high school or maybe when, maybe
0:42:39summer after high school.
0:42:40Anyway.
0:42:41And that was, we bought the USA today, which had the stats every week on Wednesday.
0:42:45And I had a spreadsheet on my Apple II that was in, it was Apple works.
0:42:50And that's how we compiled all the scoring for the fantasy baseball league was using.
0:42:55And I think about it now and I can't even picture what that spreadsheet looked like because it
0:42:58must've been so primitive.
0:43:00But yeah, it was a, it was a whole thing and you could do that.
0:43:03Yeah.
0:43:03But I think that specific point of the keyboard layouts really amplifies the sort of anything
0:43:11goes nature of the era.
0:43:13And even on the Mac into the very early nineties, the first keyboard I owned with my Mac LC that
0:43:22I got in 1991.
0:43:22I forget the name of that one because I hated the keyboard, but it had the escape key.
0:43:28A, I had the four at the, instead of an upside down T, the arrow keys were four in a row up,
0:43:34then down, then left and right.
0:43:36So left and right made sense to each other, but up and down had no spatial relationship to
0:43:41up and down this.
0:43:42And, but to the, they were to the right of the space bar, but then in between them in the
0:43:47space bar was the escape key or, or maybe it was back to, but some of the keyboards had the back
0:43:53tick there and some had escape there because they didn't, it was a smaller compact keyboard.
0:43:58So they didn't have a row above the numbers.
0:44:01So the one, two, three, four is a zero was up there above QWERTY.
0:44:05And then to the left of it might've been back tick, but then the way that escape goes above that
0:44:10where there was no row above that.
0:44:11So they just put it next to the space bar.
0:44:13Yes.
0:44:13And it's, this is 1990.
0:44:15I had the back tick next to the space bar on my Apple keyboard.
0:44:18On the left though.
0:44:19Yeah.
0:44:20On the left.
0:44:20And then the escape key is, is up.
0:44:21Yeah.
0:44:22No, it's anything goes well.
0:44:23You were, you were saying, I think this was a bit of inadvertent genius on your part.
0:44:28You said that the Commodore felt vaguely Soviet to you.
0:44:33Yes.
0:44:34Yeah.
0:44:34And, and I, I was doing at the same time I was reading up on the history of Commodore.
0:44:39Cause again, my first computer was a Commodore, but it was the pet.
0:44:41Which was an all in one and didn't have graphics mode, which made it really kind of unsuitable
0:44:47for, for most games.
0:44:49It had a weird shifted character set that you could use to make graphics, but they were not
0:44:54graphics in, in, in a normal sense.
0:44:56But it was like box drawing characters.
0:44:58Yeah, yeah, yeah, exactly.
0:44:59Exactly.
0:45:00And, and playing card suits and things like that.
0:45:02You could draw lines and stuff, but it wasn't the same.
0:45:05Exactly.
0:45:06So Jack Tramiel, who was the founder of Commodore, he started Commodore as an importer to Toronto
0:45:15because, because, because he was in Toronto importer of Czechoslovakian typewriters.
0:45:23And they had unusual type key layouts, as you might expect.
0:45:27And it seems to me that as Commodore became a computer company, Jack Tramiel had a comfort
0:45:36level with those kinds of keyboard layouts.
0:45:39And then hearing from the Europeans about how that actually is a shift for shift to, for a
0:45:46quote mark, makes sense to them, I think Jack Tramiel, with his whole company founded on Eastern
0:45:52European keyboards, just sort of was okay with it.
0:45:55And, and it also speaks to the fact that Commodore, one of the reasons, like somebody got really
0:45:59upset when I joked about the Vic 20, when, cause I said they sold a million of them.
0:46:03And he was like, how dare you?
0:46:04They sold two and a half million.
0:46:05I'm like, dude, I was, I was, I was being nice and, and, and sort of light, lightly making
0:46:11a joke about it.
0:46:11Point is it was so affordable.
0:46:13One of the reasons I think those Commodores were so affordable is they didn't do stuff
0:46:18like make a different version for a different country with a different keyboard layout.
0:46:22They just, there was one.
0:46:23So like in the U S that shift to quote shift two was so bizarre, but I think Jack Tramiel
0:46:30was like, I'm only doing one and I'm going to go with the Czechoslovakian keyboards that
0:46:35brought me here.
0:46:36Yeah.
0:46:36Because I think they had in, you had to type shift two to get a double quote mark.
0:46:40I forget where a single quote was.
0:46:42It was on, it was like shift shift seven or something.
0:46:44I don't know, but there are six, I don't know.
0:46:46It was on another key.
0:46:48So the double and single quotes were on totally different keys on the number row, but there
0:46:52was a standalone key for the British pound.
0:46:54Yep.
0:46:56Yep.
0:46:56I mean, again, and that, that's, that's what it's funny if you're an American, right?
0:47:01It's not funny if you live in the UK.
0:47:03It's well, of course, our keyboards have always had a sterling.
0:47:07And again, if you are using a keyboard with a language that has all of those extra characters,
0:47:11like somebody from Germany sent me a picture and it's, they've got the S at, which is the
0:47:14double S and they've got a bunch of louded characters.
0:47:16It's like, it totally makes sense that you would do that instead of what we have to do,
0:47:20which is option E, option U E to get an E with an loud over it or whatever.
0:47:25But, but for an American, it was like nothing else that existed.
0:47:31It was a very different kind of keyboard.
0:47:33And I think it goes to the Commodore ethos, not just at the Czechoslovakian keyboards imported
0:47:37to Toronto, but to the idea that they weren't going to make a bunch of variants of this thing.
0:47:42They're going to sell a VIC-20 for 300 bucks.
0:47:44It's going to, they're going to make one and they're going to sell it everywhere in the world.
0:47:48And that's just how it's going to be.
0:47:49Maybe the variant is, does the composite output do NTSC or PAL or CCAM or whatever,
0:47:55but literally the keyboard was not on the radar because they're saving money everywhere they can.
0:48:00And, and then that's the truth of it is Apple stuff was way more expensive.
0:48:04Even back then, Apple stuff was more expensive.
0:48:07Apple had a bigger profit margin.
0:48:08And that is a part of Apple that's been there since the very beginning.
0:48:11Yep.
0:48:12And it is interesting too, to, to, to take it out of nostalgia and tie it back into
0:48:17the current computing.
0:48:20It, it's kind of interesting.
0:48:22I think it's almost like inflation adjusted.
0:48:24It's almost exactly the relationship, the relationship between the Commodore 64 and the Apple 2e is almost exactly the relationship between Meta's Quest headsets and the Vision Pro.
0:48:39And, and Drang, Drang was the smart one who figured out that yes, when the Commodore 64 debuted in 1982,
0:48:46it retailed for $600.
0:48:47And I just, you know, I'm used to, I'm so used to when I look up, what did that cost when it came out?
0:48:54And because I write about Apple, and I've written about Apple professionally for 22 years, in the era I've been writing about Apple, when a computer comes out and it costs $999, and it doesn't get updated for three years, like the Retina MacBook Pro a couple years ago, guess how much it costs three years later when everything's cheaper?
0:49:12Yeah.
0:49:13$999.
0:49:14And I've, that's, that's not the way the rest of the industry works.
0:49:17And I just thought, huh, I don't remember this Commodore 64 being that expensive.
0:49:22I wonder why they sold it at Kmart.
0:49:23But I was like, well, I double checked, chat GPT.
0:49:26I double checked.
0:49:26It was $600 a night when it debuted.
0:49:28$600 it is.
0:49:30And Dr. Drang pointed out on Mastodon that it quickly got reduced in price, and it was like $200 by like 1983 and into 84 when he bought one.
0:49:40They cleared the VIC-20 out, and it kept going down.
0:49:43Yeah, it's like the VIC-20 was like Commodore's version of Apple selling a two-year-old iPhone at a lower price.
0:49:49And then within a year or two, they were like, ah, get rid of that.
0:49:52This 64 is a hit.
0:49:53Let's get everybody to buy one.
0:49:55They're making the same one everywhere in the world, like you said.
0:49:59They don't even have a different keyboard anywhere else.
0:50:01So they've got some economies of scale.
0:50:04And $200-ish without a monitor, but you can hook it up to your TV, so you didn't need a monitor, sounds exactly like about what I remember probably pitching my parents on.
0:50:15Because as much as, and I've told this story before, but I'll repeat it here, I didn't have a computer in my house at the time.
0:50:20I had an Atari 2600 for games, but my parents would not buy me a computer because, and I have to say, in hindsight, possibly not wrong out of the fear that if they did, that I would never leave the house.
0:50:33Even though my other friends were arguing to their parents, I want to get a $1,000 computer, and they're like, all you're going to do is play games.
0:50:41You're not going to do anything on it.
0:50:42I'm not spending all that money on it.
0:50:43You're never going to use it.
0:50:44It's going to gather dust.
0:50:45And my parents were like, we are not buying you a computer, John.
0:50:48You're never going to leave the house.
0:50:50Go outside.
0:50:51Meet your friends.
0:50:52And like I told you earlier, play touch football or pick up baseball and stuff like that.
0:50:56I don't know that I never would have left the house, but I certainly would have left the house less.
0:51:00Yeah, I definitely did leave the house, but not as much as I would have if I didn't have a computer at home.
0:51:07So while if I had somehow, at the age of 10, become independently wealthy and could have bought myself a computer, I 100% would have bought an Apple IIe.
0:51:14Sure.
0:51:15If my parents said, fine, we'll buy you a Commodore 64, I would have said, yes, let's go get it right now.
0:51:20Yeah, of course.
0:51:21Of course.
0:51:21And that is, I mean, leaving aside the, I mean, I think that the thing that we aren't talking about as much, and as a kid, you're maybe less aware of, is there definitely is a means story here.
0:51:34Which is, the kids, the kids with Apple IIs, like my dad was an orthodontist, like he got, I had, I had, I had a computer and then I had a different computer.
0:51:42And the 64 and the VIC-20, more people could afford, they were more affordable and they use your TV instead of having to also buy a monitor on top of that.
0:51:52So like, there are so many reasons that that's why I tried to say nice things about the VIC-20 is like the VIC-20 was, was accessible in a way that the Apples weren't.
0:52:01And that's, and that's really great.
0:52:03So that's all, I mean, that's all good.
0:52:05They were all amazing and good and fun and I would have taken any of them and I'm interested in hindsight in all of them.
0:52:11It's a great, it's a great era.
0:52:13It was a magical era because it was all new and there were no rules and there was no dominant force.
0:52:17Yes.
0:52:18And then IBM PC came in and just ground everybody into dust.
0:52:21Even though one of the things I find curious about this sort of trip down memory lane and everybody fighting or very, very, it's a very fun argument of everybody arguing for the one that they like the most.
0:52:33Not one person in the whole thread has chimed in and said, what was the best was the IBM PC.
0:52:39Nobody, not one person because it really didn't, for as dominant as it became, it had absolutely no mind share anywhere amongst kids.
0:52:51Yeah.
0:52:51I didn't see, John, I don't think I saw Windows until my freshman year in college.
0:52:59Yeah.
0:52:59Same here.
0:53:00There was a woman in my dorm who had a, a, a, a Radio Shack, a Tandy computer.
0:53:06It was Tandy at that point, but it was running like Windows one or something.
0:53:09And I was like, what is that?
0:53:11Cause it was like the weird tie.
0:53:12It was before three, one even.
0:53:13Yeah.
0:53:14And I just, it was not on the, and I went to, I went to college with an Apple two.
0:53:19I got a Mac by the end of my sophomore year in college.
0:53:22I was all in on the Mac, but I didn't even see them.
0:53:26I mean, I'm sure we had them.
0:53:27Our computer lab was Apple twos.
0:53:29Like I, in high school, like I just, I, I just, they were not, they were, I think they
0:53:36were in offices and I think that Microsoft's plan was to get clones out there and then to
0:53:40sell them into homes.
0:53:41But there was a, there was a lull in there where that was not a, a device for the, for, for the
0:53:47home.
0:53:47Yeah.
0:53:47I remember because I didn't, I might've remembered the same thing even if I had a computer, but
0:53:52because I didn't, I remember which of my friends owned which computers.
0:53:57I remember my friend Ethan had a Commodore 64.
0:53:59My friend Joey had the Apple two E and so I liked going to Joey's house and Joey was
0:54:05the one, cause our computer lab at school was full of Apple two E's and Apple two C's.
0:54:10He was the one who smuggled in all the games.
0:54:12Sure.
0:54:13Yeah.
0:54:14We're going to play Choplifter over here in the corner.
0:54:16We're going to play Ultima, Ultima three over here.
0:54:18Oh, Karate, Karateka.
0:54:19Karateka.
0:54:20Yeah.
0:54:20Oh man.
0:54:21Yeah.
0:54:21Yeah.
0:54:22My, my, um, Dr. J versus Larry Bird.
0:54:24One-on-one.
0:54:25Yeah.
0:54:26That was a great one.
0:54:26One-on-one.
0:54:27That was a great one.
0:54:27Yeah.
0:54:28My friend, it's funny.
0:54:29You're absolutely right.
0:54:30My friend, my friend Crispin had an Apple two plus my friend Thor.
0:54:33These are real names, by the way.
0:54:35My friend Thor had a TRS 80.
0:54:37So he had stuff, he had games.
0:54:39They were, TRS 80 was felt, it was really primitive, but he had these weird games that I'd never
0:54:43seen before.
0:54:44And it was just kind of amazing.
0:54:45And then I remember he did get an Apple two at some point and we went over there and we're
0:54:48playing Karateka, but like you could remember, yeah, you go, go to a different house.
0:54:52There's different software.
0:54:53You could, there's different games you can play over there.
0:54:56I remember the only kid I knew had a PC in the house was my friend Mark and he, Mark had
0:55:01lived in England.
0:55:02He'd, he'd been in first grade with us and then he went away for a few years cause his dad's
0:55:06job put him in England for a couple of years.
0:55:09He came back and all of a sudden he's saying the word bloody all the time.
0:55:12But he, his dad was like a, some kind of mechanical engineer or civil engineer of some sort.
0:55:18Like he worked on, I don't know, like dams or something like structural integrity of things.
0:55:22Probably something Drang would, would be familiar with and had a PC in the house for work purposes.
0:55:28And I remember one time Mark and me were writing something like a story, like a, I don't know,
0:55:35some kind of the type of story teenage boys would write.
0:55:38Not dirty, but, but juvenile.
0:55:40And even Mark didn't like it.
0:55:43He was like, yeah, this sucks, but it was better than writing it by hand or using a typewriter.
0:55:48So we used it.
0:55:49But even Mark thought the computer in his house sucked.
0:55:51It was the only computer anybody I knew thought sucked.
0:55:55It was no fun.
0:55:56It wasn't made to be fun.
0:55:57It was, it was for word processing and other sensible office things.
0:56:00Yeah.
0:56:01That was an era really, if these platforms weren't established and as a kid, if you didn't know
0:56:07somebody like I, there was a guy I knew who wasn't a close friend, but he was kind of a
0:56:11friend.
0:56:12And he lived across the street from my elementary school.
0:56:14And I remember at lunch one time we went over to his house because he was literally across
0:56:19the street.
0:56:19And I don't think we were supposed to leave the campus, but we did it because he was across
0:56:22the street.
0:56:23And, and it was like entering a parallel universe because he had a Mattel and television.
0:56:28Ah, and I had an Atari 2600 and some of my friends had the 2600 and this was the, the competing
0:56:36console of the era.
0:56:37And it, I mean, it really was like, I, I couldn't understand what I was seeing because it was like
0:56:44the Atari, but totally different.
0:56:47What a, and you feel like you just fell through a, through the rabbit hole.
0:56:51Just like it's a, and that is a thing now we really are the old man talking about the
0:56:56past, but that was one of the really genuinely delightful things of being about being on the
0:57:00very beginning of something like that is that it was just a mess.
0:57:03It was chaotic.
0:57:03You'd stumble, you'd step into somewhere and be like, Whoa, what is that?
0:57:07And have no idea.
0:57:08And it couldn't last forever.
0:57:10And it did get, by the time, again, by the time I got out of college, like there were only
0:57:14two computers, but in those early days, any, you would turn around and be like, what?
0:57:19Huh?
0:57:20I remember they got a, a Timex Sinclair, which was like a little, I want to say $50 computer.
0:57:25It was, it was nothing.
0:57:27It had no memory.
0:57:28It had no power or anything.
0:57:29A membrane keyboard.
0:57:31But I remember somebody brought one into the school and everybody was just like, what is
0:57:37that?
0:57:37Cause we didn't understand it.
0:57:38It was like not a computer we had seen before.
0:57:41Yeah.
0:57:41And the other thing is if you're young enough and you're still bearing with this episode,
0:57:45but hopefully you're fascinated.
0:57:47But the other thing I cannot emphasize enough, it was, it wasn't just that they were different
0:57:52platforms, but there was no way to get one to talk to the other.
0:57:57None.
0:57:57Really?
0:57:57None.
0:57:58Like there was no way to, to take something on a floppy disk from one computer and get it
0:58:04onto another.
0:58:05You could, you could use a modem or like a serial cable to send text or something.
0:58:11Yeah.
0:58:12But, but that was it.
0:58:13And, and, and basically you couldn't.
0:58:16Any kind of file you had saved was impossible to get read on another computer.
0:58:22Cause you just couldn't get it to read the disc or in some of the cases with those early
0:58:26PCs, the tape, cause some of them, because floppy disk drives were so expensive that they'd
0:58:31use a cassette tape using the same tapes that you'd listen to music on would be just have
0:58:38ones and zeros stored on them.
0:58:39I think they used to sell more expensive tapes.
0:58:41They were like data integrity tapes or something.
0:58:43And maybe they were slightly higher quality tapes, but yeah, not the most, but you, there
0:58:49was no way to take a tape from one computer and play it on another.
0:58:52So you couldn't exchange files.
0:58:53The programs were, if the same game was available on both platforms, it's because an entirely
0:59:01different programming team had implemented the game from scratch.
0:59:04There was no possible way to recompile a game or to use some kind of library to port a game
0:59:11because there was, you had to be so close.
0:59:13We're talking, Commodore 64 was a 64 cause it had 64 kilobytes of RAM.
0:59:18And it was not a lot of space in there.
0:59:22So it was, everything.
0:59:23Shahid Ahmad, he used to do a podcast, I think with Mike Hurley about games.
0:59:28He worked at PlayStation for a long time, but like when he got into the business, that
0:59:33was his, that was one of his jobs is he was a whiz kid and they would give him games from
0:59:38one platform and say, make this game for the other platform.
0:59:42And literally that was it.
0:59:44And he just had to remake the game and ideally it would behave exactly the same, but it didn't
0:59:51not quite.
0:59:52No.
0:59:52Yeah.
0:59:53The only thing that was in common was like basic and even basic wasn't quite the same,
0:59:56but you could, you know, learning a basic program, you could get away with it more or less across
1:00:01all the different platforms.
1:00:02For the most part.
1:00:02And sometimes if you bought like a magazine that would give you the basic program to type
1:00:06in by hand, which is probably how you became such a good typist.
1:00:09They might have like a note that would say, you know, on the Commodore, you have to do this.
1:00:14There might be like some kind of remark, like on an Apple, here's the difference in the program.
1:00:20But yeah, it was, it was crazy times of completely different and just dozens of them.
1:00:25Ultimately, I heard of one this week.
1:00:28Somebody sent me, I swear to God, I put it in the show notes.
1:00:30I'd never heard of this computer before ever.
1:00:32Oh, the Tomy Tudor.
1:00:33Yeah.
1:00:34The Tomy, Tomy Tudor.
1:00:35I remember Tomy cause they made little handheld electronic games, toys.
1:00:39The Tomy Tudor was a low cost PC.
1:00:42Good times.
1:00:44I mean, literally a toy company and just say like, yeah, we're going to, we'll, we'll all
1:00:50to make a computer.
1:00:51Okay.
1:00:52Sure.
1:00:53Yep.
1:00:53Why not?
1:00:54All right.
1:00:57Let me take a break here and thank our second sponsor.
1:01:00It is our good friends at factor factor powers your day.
1:01:05Sun up to sundown with nutritious breakfasts on the go lunches, premium dinners and guilt-free
1:01:11snacks and desserts.
1:01:12Factor has your whole day covered.
1:01:14Enjoy more this summer.
1:01:15Get factor.
1:01:16If you want all the flavor and none of the fuss.
1:01:20I have been ordering factor.
1:01:22They started sponsoring the show a couple episodes ago and I love it.
1:01:28It is super great.
1:01:29This is sort of like the meal kits you may have heard of from previous sponsors on the
1:01:34show.
1:01:34So, but instead of sending you like a box of ingredients and you make a full meal, these
1:01:38are pre-made meals that come sealed.
1:01:42That's like a little bit of plastic and a, uh, uh, airtight seal and the whole meal is already
1:01:47made.
1:01:48So you just heat it up in a microwave and done.
1:01:50It's more of a lunch thing for me than like a dinner thing.
1:01:53Not, they're not family size portions.
1:01:55They're sort of individual portions and they're not frozen.
1:01:59They're like fresh sort of stuff.
1:02:02You pick up a lot of like higher end grocery stores, like pre-made meals that are fresh.
1:02:07They need to be heated up.
1:02:09Super convenient.
1:02:09They have tons of options to pick from every week.
1:02:13So like every week that you do it, you want to place an order.
1:02:16You go there, they have an updated menu.
1:02:18You just go through and pick and they have 45 weekly menu options.
1:02:25You pick gourmet meals that fit your summer gains and goals.
1:02:28They've got all sorts of subcategories within those 45 options.
1:02:32They call them things like calorie smart, protein plus keto and more.
1:02:37Those things are self-descriptive.
1:02:39If that's what you're interested in, you can account for allergens.
1:02:42If you have ingredients you want to avoid or something like that.
1:02:46I have found that the ones I've ordered, I don't think I've gotten a one I didn't like
1:02:51in a bunch and they, if you think it's going to taste like something, that's what it tastes
1:02:56like.
1:02:56It's really, really good.
1:02:57I really enjoy it.
1:02:59It's super easy.
1:03:00And for me, frankly, as a lazy person who does not want to spend time preparing my lunch,
1:03:05it's really great.
1:03:07Get started at factor meals, F-A-C-T-O-R factor meals.com slash talk show 50 off.
1:03:18And the 50 is spelled with digits.
1:03:20So talk show five zero O F F and use that code talk show 50 off to get you guessed it 50% off
1:03:30plus free shipping on your first box of food.
1:03:34That's code talk show 50 off at factor meals dot com slash talk show 50 off for 50% off plus
1:03:44free shipping factor meals dot com slash talk show 50 off.
1:03:48Really, really good food.
1:03:50I seriously recommend it and eat it until it's out of the fridge.
1:03:54All right, I think we're up to the current events or are we okay back in the present
1:03:59day, John, I got a new iPhone here with some software on it.
1:04:04How much you want to pay me to show it to you?
1:04:06What a sordid when is that I've been asking around and nobody's giving me the answer.
1:04:14When is the previous time that Apple has sued or made a legal fuss out of somebody in the
1:04:19media?
1:04:20So what happened for anybody who's not paying attention is Apple filed a lawsuit a week ago
1:04:24or a week plus against somebody who I'd never heard of who's not really well known and doesn't
1:04:30seem to have a big footprint.
1:04:31Michael Racka, Miati, Ramassati and John Prosser of Front Page Tech, a YouTuber who's I've linked
1:04:42to him before and he had a series of three videos showing recreations of what he what was then called
1:04:50iOS 19 now iOS 26 what we now call liquid glass including one video that showed the not just the
1:04:58liquid glass but like the updated camera UI which putting the liquid glass aside is a major overhaul
1:05:06right just sort of blueprint wise of how is the camera app organized where instead of all these
1:05:11options at the bottom of modes to script switch through iOS 26 camera app just has photo and video
1:05:18and you just start from there regular video regular photo and then once you're in photo then this sort
1:05:24of sub modes it's sort of a hierarchy of modes and I think it's I think that's pretty clever but he
1:05:30showed that in a recreation and like two weeks ago Apple filed a lawsuit yeah when's the last time you
1:05:38can remember somebody getting sued I mean the the two events that come to mind are Gizmodo finding
1:05:47iPhone 4 in a bar and think secret yeah so do you remember so think secret was a website that was an
1:06:00Apple rumor website and Apple sued it in what 2005 I think yeah and said that it was violating trade
1:06:11secrets and that was actually there was a settlement a couple years later think secret basically agreed
1:06:17to cease publication it was a it was one guy it was a guy Nicholas Nicholas Ciarelli yes but he went
1:06:23by Nick Diplume on the internet which is always hilarious so basically they just sued him out of existence
1:06:29essentially yeah and and what they're trying to do with I mean with Prosser is basically say we want
1:06:36you to be barred from ever reporting about things about Apple secrets ever again now Prosser to be
1:06:42fair seems to have pivoted away from being a rumor guy and trying to do other stuff with his channel he
1:06:48sort of used the rumors to get some notice and he's trying to kind of paddle away from that possibly
1:06:54in part because he doesn't have very good sources most of the time if this is what he has to do
1:06:59allegedly to get sources then it would be a good time to pivot or it would have been a good time to
1:07:05pivot before this happened it sounds like this sort of maybe fell in his lap a little bit but I don't
1:07:10know I mean when I was in grad school they made us take a journalism law class because they didn't want
1:07:17to create journalists who would who would break the law and be sued and for us to know our rights and one of the
1:07:22things that they hammered home about was along with libel and things like that right one of them was
1:07:27about inducing somebody to commit a crime in order to get you information that was the the bright line
1:07:35that was drawn is like if somebody comes to you and says I got the Pentagon papers here you say thank
1:07:39you very much but if you call a call you go to somebody's house and knock on the door and say hey
1:07:44I got I got I got ten thousand dollars if you bring me the Pentagon papers out of the Pentagon
1:07:48you can't do that that that you're you're you're you're asking you're paying them to commit a crime
1:07:55and that's not that's a bright line so what is alleged in this lawsuit is that John Prosser
1:08:03said I'll pay you to break into your friend's phone and show me what's there now John Prosser
1:08:09says that that isn't quite right and we don't really know and there are a lot of hazy things
1:08:14here about just how involved was this guy who left his phone behind did he did he really leave it
1:08:19behind did did he know what was going on or was he I mean he got fired by Apple I would argue that
1:08:25means that something happened that Apple was like we don't there is zero you weren't just a victim here
1:08:29you're part of the problem even if they're not suing him but but regardless
1:08:34the bottom line is that there is somebody who is a content creator about Apple content who is being
1:08:40sued by Apple for revealing secrets and I think I keep coming back to that bright line I keep coming back
1:08:47to the the allegation that he said he would compensate this guy for unlocking his friend's phone and showing
1:08:54him what iOS 26 looks like yeah it's really it's it's and I've dug into it I've I've become somewhat
1:09:03obsessed you have nearly Nancy Drew in this thing yeah very much so and it is I mean there's while
1:09:10this whole Epstein thing has reignited in national affairs me calling this sorted is is a sort of
1:09:19small print lowercase s sorted compared to Helvetica black thousand point type sorted of the Epstein mess
1:09:30this there's no physical harm or sex trafficking involved in this this is really just pure Apple
1:09:37rumor ugliness and somebody losing a job at Apple but it is sort of sorted where especially that the
1:09:46the story Apple outlines which I believe is I haven't seen anything that contradicts it and I've learned
1:09:53other stuff it's basically true though that this guy I keep I even have a text type typenators shortcut
1:09:59for his name Ram Ramachadi Ramasadi yeah Ramasadi was a friend of this guy Ethan Lipnick who is the
1:10:08engineer at Apple who had a work phone with iOS 19 now iOS 26 on it and was close enough friends with him
1:10:16that he'd stayed at his house and Apple alleges that he and Prosser conspired to wait for him to be
1:10:23Lipnick to be out of the house and he'd somehow gleaned his passcode to the phone this is the part where I'm
1:10:29like how do you do that if you're an Apple employee with a work phone that you know has a secret OS not just
1:10:38like an app but like the whole OS and that the app it's not like going from iOS 17 to 18 where
1:10:44it kind of looks the same like you could walk around using it and people wouldn't see it but when it has
1:10:50like a very visually you know like it right down to entering your passcode right and who knows if the
1:10:56beta in January had the liquid glass on the passcode entry screen who knows I don't know but you know like
1:11:03right now today with like the beta it's like you could see on the lock screen whoa that doesn't look
1:11:08like iOS or the iOS I know right so how do you get the passcode you know like somebody could stay at my
1:11:16house and I do not believe that staying at my house would help them glean the passcode to my iPhone
1:11:21so I put that aside you know but somehow he the story according to Apple is that he had gotten this
1:11:27Lipnick's passcode waited till he was out of the house but had left this phone behind unlocked the phone
1:11:32and then over FaceTime showed iOS 19 to Prosser and Prosser recorded the FaceTime
1:11:38and then used that recording of the demo of the software to commission
1:11:44UI artists and there's this whole subculture in the
1:11:49Apple rumors world of mostly young
1:11:52men boys teenage boys who get into making these things being able to you know here's what it looks like make let's not
1:12:00we can't show this video because we won't want to get this guy in trouble
1:12:03ironically since ironically but but let's recreate
1:12:07recreate it and the recreations were spot on in hindsight right a lot of people after the WWDC keynote in June had to give Prosser credit whoa that stuff you showed was I mean you'd have to really like pixel peep to find things that were wrong it was like yeah he kind of showed it and conversely you could see why maybe Apple was pissed yeah right and if not for Prosser this one leak there were
1:12:12A lot of people after the WWDC keynote in June had to give Prosser credit. Whoa, that stuff you showed was, I mean, you'd have to really like pixel peep to find things that were wrong. It was like, yeah, he kind of showed it. And conversely, you could see why maybe Apple was pissed.
1:12:28Yeah. And if not for Prosser, this one leak, there were like, for example, the, what do you call them? The apex predator of the Apple rumors game, Mark Gurman had reported verbally on in Bloomberg on there is a new UI theme and it is based on the look of vision OS.
1:12:54It's called solarium and light through glass. Yeah. Yeah. Light through glass. And Gurman's, those descriptions of it also check out in hindsight, but didn't, don't, don't have anywhere near the punch of here. Look at this. This is what it is going to look at. Screenshots in this game matter way more than a description.
1:13:17So you could see why Apple pursued it, but that leads me to me. The thing that has me looking into it is that in Apple's legal filing, which Mac rumors first reported, I think last Friday night, something like that late at night. And apparently by all accounts, John Prosser found out about it when Mac rumors published the story.
1:13:39Wow. Like, I do believe, I think he's since gotten in touch or Apple has gotten in touch with him. But the first that Prosser found out about it was when Mac rumors published the story. But in the legal filing, Apple included a screenshot. Like, how did Apple find out about this whole thing going on?
1:13:58And according to Apple, an anonymous email came to Apple. Who had Apple? I don't know. And they included a screenshot of the email. The from is blacked out, even though it was anonymous. So I presume it was somebody using ProtonMail or something. I don't, I don't know what some anonymous email service.
1:14:17I used to know there were more of them. I haven't heard of one in a while, but I'm sure there's a bunch out there. An anonymous email to Apple subject iOS 19 leaker information dash Ethan Lipnick. And then it says, I am not sure who to contact, but as a courtesy to the iOS team at Apple, I wanted to share information that I have about an employee who leaked pre-release design details.
1:14:41The iOS 19 information shared by John Prosser is sourced from Ethan Lipnick. Two URLs to the first two of the three videos Prosser put. There was a FaceTime call between Prosser and Lipnick or a friend of Lipnick's, which we now know is Ramakadi, where the iOS 19 interface was dead, blah, blah, blah. He has details on the lock screen, home screen, app animations. The call was a few months ago. Prosser has video from it and shows, and that shows the iOS 19 interface.
1:15:09Then it names a bunch of other people in the Mac media, some of them like 9to5Mac and somebody from Mac Rumors. I figured out who all the names are. If anybody wants to, you can look at my Mastodon account.
1:15:22Just because, literally because of the kerning in the font that they used.
1:15:26That they included this screenshot and they just blacked out the names, but I knew that it was Ariel. I know, I mean, I'm cursed, like it's, I know Ariel. So I just sized type to match the Ariel in the screenshot and then typed surrounding words in the commas and then tried various names.
1:15:43And it wasn't just me guessing. It's also me asking around to various people in the Mac media who were like, oh, well, I heard the one name is so-and-so and it's, that doesn't fit. And then somebody else says it's so-and-so. And ooh, and I was like, oh, that seems like it's too long for the box. And then I type it in and ooh, that fits exactly.
1:16:02So there's a couple other names thrown under the bus in the Mac media, which is a little weird.
1:16:07Yeah, it makes me wonder. So it says Prosser has been sharing clips from the recorded FaceTime call with Apple leakers. And it makes me wonder, like, that's really interesting, right? Because this is sort of, that video clip is damning evidence.
1:16:22I wonder if what Prosser was doing is like trying to prime the pump with these websites to show, basically to show his work, to say, look, this is legit. I have video from a, from an, an internal Apple phone about this. I'll show it to you. And you'll see that this, you don't have to speculate about how I know what I know. I'm not lying here. I have video. And because on one level, it seems very weird to show it to your competition.
1:16:47But on another level, if you're trying to convince them that you're legitimate. And, but this is, it seems to me, this is also the pathway that tipped off whoever this tip, this tipster is about the same video, because, because that this email does not get sent. If somebody doesn't say, and this is what the filing says is somebody watched this video and said, hey, that's Lipnick's apartment.
1:17:11Yeah, somebody recognized it, because it was just this Ramacotti holding the phone up to like a MacBook camera or something to show the interface, you know, his iPhone or whatever.
1:17:23Yeah, whatever. But from one device to another, and it showed and somebody recognized his apartment. So says Apple. And the other thing I've found out is that somebody else who was saw the video, saw while he, this Ramacotti was scrolling through the phone, saw Lipnick's name.
1:17:41saw his name, saw his name, in the phone. Oh, no. And knew Lipnick and thought this doesn't seem like something he would condone. Right. And it's an end started spread. Anyway, the op sex surrounding this original FaceTime recording was not good. Not, not good. It really, I keep saying to other people that had to, it really makes the whole signal gate thing with the Trump national security people look like it was on the up and up and well organized and thought through.
1:18:11Oh, so what? We invited a guy from the Atlantic into the chat. Well, this, the way this video is circulated within the little subsphere of the Apple media that deals with anonymous leaks of upcoming features from within Apple was really bad.
1:18:28I mean, this is, this is not, not my, not my direct part of the business, but why do you, why do you share that video? I mean, I'm trying to theorize you shared, established that it's real, but like that, that's like, that's like a dead secret from a, a, a key source. Like, why would you, why would you reveal it? And this is why you wouldn't is because they, they figured out who it was from. And then the part that's also really fascinating is somebody called them on it, right? Somebody named names and said, this is the, I'm going to,
1:18:58I'm going to let you know that, that who this dude is, who is behind this, or, or as Apple's investigation clearly saw these dudes who are behind this. It's not just Lipnick. It's, it's his friend Ramasadi. Who's, who's, who's maybe doing this. And then if Ramasadi says, John Prosser offered me money, then they're like, oh, great. That that's inducement. Then we can sue him too. And what a, what a, I mean, look, why does Apple do this? One reason is just to remind everybody what the, what the law is and what the rules are.
1:19:28I've definitely, I mean, you know, more people inside Apple than I do, but I've heard from people inside Apple who are like, this is routine. Like you have devices, you have multiple devices and some of your devices are on shipping and some of your devices are on way out.
1:19:41And that it's not unreasonable for Lipnick to have an iPhone running unannounced software at his house. That's not unreasonable at all. However, I do think that a lot of Apple employees are having that moment of, okay, do I trust my friends? Do they know my passcode? Do I want my passcode on these secret devices to be different? Do I want to put them in a drawer or lock them away?
1:20:04Somebody said to me, was it Mike Hurley? Maybe he said on upgrade. He said, selling a lot of safes in Cupertino this week. I think that part of the reason Apple does stuff like this is to say there are severe consequences. Like when they fired that guy and it came out in public, like last year, severe consequences.
1:20:20If you don't take care of your stuff, it doesn't mean you can't take the stuff home. It means you need to know that like your friends, if they know your passcode, you can't trust them. You need to be much more diligent about this. And I do think it's also a reminder to people in the media about, about that bright line, about the difference between what somebody was asking me, like Mark Gurman, does he pay for sources? I can guarantee you he doesn't because Bloomberg would not allow it.
1:20:48That's just, it wouldn't be allowed. Somebody, the Pentagon papers walk into your office, you take it, you say yes, and you publish them. But this is a reminder that anything goes is not legal.
1:21:00Yeah. And I would even say further with just your point on Gurman, which is that even if somebody wanted to push back and say, well, sure, even maybe, maybe Bloomberg's rules forbid it, but how do you know he's not doing it behind the organization's back?
1:21:15And my counter that you can't disprove a negative. Sure. You can't, I can't prove that he doesn't. But Gurman's remarkable, truly remarkable longevity in the Apple rumors game, I would say is the best proof that he's not paying for sources. Because if he was one, you just can't keep a stack of, of lies like that.
1:21:40Yeah. Also, also, he, he's got really good security. Like he's not showing people videos of his leakers. He's got it buttoned up tight. And also now he's got such a reputation that people are coming to him and sending things to his signal account, presumably, and stuff like that as well.
1:21:55But like, what I think number one is he, he, they Bloomberg would fire his ass if they found out, like he'd be out on his ear because that would be against all of their policies. And they have lots of them.
1:22:06Yeah. I would, I would wager enormous sum of money that Mark Gurman has never paid for any information.
1:22:12And some people will argue, oh, well, it doesn't matter. He's releasing secrets. But it does, how it happens matters. If, if, if information comes across the transom and especially if you can verify it and publish it, like it's not a game that I'm in, but like it's a legitimate game.
1:22:26There is a line that you can cross though, where you're, you're actively approaching people. And in this case, it's not even actively approaching an Apple employee and trying to offer them money to reveal secrets. It's, it's actively, if this allegation is true, to be clear, he actively approached somebody who's not an Apple employee and offered to pay them to break into a friend's phone to reveal secrets that the friend had.
1:22:51Right. That's, that is inducement, not just to commit a leak from Apple secrets, but to commit a crime because you're breaking into somebody else's phone, phone security.
1:23:01Right. Even if it's not paying for it, I think, and again, I didn't take the college course in journalistic ethics, but there is a difference too, between somebody coming up to you, say, I have the Pentagon papers. Would you like to see them versus I know how to get the, I know how to get the Pentagon papers.
1:23:17I could get in, I know the combination to the locked door where they're stored.
1:23:21Right.
1:23:21Do you think I should go steal them?
1:23:24It's a, it's a less bright line, but it's still an issue is if you, is that inducement. That was the thing that we were always told is, are you in, are you causing this to happen?
1:23:32Right.
1:23:33Are you trying to convince people to do this thing, to break the, to break the law or break the rules of their employment versus did they decide to do this and are passing it to you and you're the conduit?
1:23:44And it may seem like a, like a, an arbitrary difference, but at least the way I was taught that that's kind of the difference is if it ends up in my lap and it's newsworthy, I will print it.
1:23:55But if it, but, you know, that's not the same as trying to bribe somebody to give you secrets.
1:24:01Yeah.
1:24:01It's just my, my self taught and self learned gleaned code of journalistic ethics would be way.
1:24:08I'm not really, I don't want rumors of Apple stuff anyway, but, but you know, something like that.
1:24:14But if it was something maybe so big that I would want interest in it and somebody said, I know how to get it.
1:24:20I would say, if you had it, I would be interested, but I'm not going to tell you what to do.
1:24:25I mean, I would literally say words like that.
1:24:27And I mean that too.
1:24:29Like I, it's not just me like worrying that I'm being taped or that our chat or whatever it is, is being recorded or screenshotted.
1:24:37That's literally also my feeling.
1:24:39Like I'm not going to tell you to do it.
1:24:41And if somebody told me I could steal it from my roommate, I think I would, honest to God, I would say, I don't, I don't think you should do that.
1:24:50Yeah, no, that's, that's, that's, you're, you're basically saying I can commit a crime and get this stuff for you.
1:24:55And it's no, no, do not, do not do that for me.
1:24:57I don't need that.
1:24:58No, it's, it's a, it's a very weird story that, that pushes a lot of buttons.
1:25:02I mean, I was thinking about this.
1:25:04What is the, the other thing that would stop me is what is the public interest here?
1:25:08And the truth is, I think for all of this stuff, there's not a lot of public interest.
1:25:13I think that that would be one of Apple's arguments is, is, I mean, you mentioned Epstein earlier.
1:25:19And I've seen people say, well, we want to know.
1:25:22It's like the public having an interest is not the public interest, right?
1:25:27Like they are not the same.
1:25:29And people want, of course, we want to know what hardware Apple's going to do for the next year.
1:25:34And Mark Gurman provides a lot of that, right?
1:25:35And that's entertaining and interesting and gives us stuff to talk about on podcasts and all of that.
1:25:40But is there a actual clear public interest in it?
1:25:45And I think, no, I think it's all, I think it's mostly about entertainment more than anything else.
1:25:49Because we all want to know the end of the story.
1:25:51We peek at the back of the book.
1:25:52We want to know what happens next.
1:25:53And Apple wants to control that.
1:25:56And sometimes they can, but mostly they can't.
1:25:58And we get it from on Sunday morning from Mark Gurman instead.
1:26:01Fair enough.
1:26:02But this goes back a long way.
1:26:03I remember I used to work at the same company that did Mac Week, which was back in the day,
1:26:08called Mac Leak by a lot of people.
1:26:10And everything leaked from Cupertino into Mac Week.
1:26:13And when you talk to Mac Week people about why they leaked this stuff, they had an answer.
1:26:17They had patter.
1:26:18They would say, well, our audience is volume buyers of Apple products.
1:26:22And they need to do their planning for the future.
1:26:24And when they know what's coming, they can plan their budgets and all of that.
1:26:28And even at the time, as a 24-year-old just out of grad school, I thought that was BS.
1:26:34I mean, it is the thinnest of tissue paper over the fact that people want to know what Apple's
1:26:40going to do in the future and Apple won't tell them.
1:26:41So I want to find, it's gossip.
1:26:43And it's fun.
1:26:44And don't get me wrong, I am very grateful to have Mark Gurman Talking Points to talk about
1:26:49on my podcast every week.
1:26:51I really am.
1:26:51And it's fun to think about a folding phone in a year and a thin phone this fall.
1:26:57And it would be more fun maybe if it was a surprise.
1:27:00But that's just not how it is.
1:27:02But I do keep coming back to the fact that I don't think there's a legitimate argument
1:27:08that it's in the public interest to know.
1:27:11I think it's just that we're curious.
1:27:13Right.
1:27:13As opposed to, oh, something totally uncontroversial.
1:27:19Let's just say like ICE detention centers.
1:27:22Like I just linked yesterday to a Human Rights Watch report on the absolutely deplorable, I
1:27:30mean, cruel and unusual, in my opinion, conditions within an ICE detention center.
1:27:35And if some of the sourcing for that, it seems like Human Rights Watch talked to a lot of
1:27:40actual people who were detained in the centers.
1:27:43But if somebody who worked for ICE broke a nondisclosure agreement they signed to be a guard in the detention
1:27:51center and broke it to talk to them.
1:27:54Well, that is, by definition, to me, in the public interest.
1:27:58I agree.
1:27:58This is whichever side.
1:28:00Even if you're like if you're of the political mindset that if you're in the country undocumented, you deserve what you get.
1:28:07I mean, it still is without to me, without question of of at the core of journalism to report on what is going on.
1:28:16And this this is what the country your government is doing right now.
1:28:19Well, I'll give you an even better example that is Apple related, which is it's illegal for the people in the UK to talk about what that secret snooping provision is.
1:28:29And yet it came out.
1:28:31And it's very clear.
1:28:32It's very clear that there are people in the UK, probably in the UK government, who saw that there was this thing that they were trying to do where they were going to get Apple.
1:28:41They were going to force Apple to backdoor everything everywhere in the world if the UK wanted it.
1:28:46And and because it's all secret, they're not supposed to ever even talk about it existing.
1:28:50And somebody talked to the Guardian and a few other places and it got out and then it became a whole thing.
1:28:57And that is a great example of something that is in the public interest because your government is doing something and they don't want you to know about it.
1:29:04But a but, you know, it's technically illegal for the people who spoke off the record to the journalists to break the story, not just breaking the gag agreement or whatever it is.
1:29:15The Secrets Act, not just breaking your employment agreement, but actually breaking the law to do it.
1:29:20Speaking of UK, we should also say we are both Americans.
1:29:23So this is this is for the shift to crowd up there in the United States.
1:29:28We have the First Amendment.
1:29:29We don't have an official Secrets Act or anything like that.
1:29:31The the part of this here is it's very, very difficult so far for the government to say you can't talk about that thing.
1:29:40And so it's a much higher standard here than it is in other places.
1:29:44So some of what we talked about with journalistic rules and what is inducement and all of that may seem very different in other countries.
1:29:50But here in the US, like when we see stories about trials in Australia or Canada or the UK where they can't report on who was the accused or they can't report on what's going on in court.
1:30:02Like that, it's completely foreign to us because it's just not the government can't say you can't report on that.
1:30:08It's not allowed.
1:30:09And so, yeah, it is.
1:30:11I just I'm not saying that I that I wish there weren't Apple rumors because I do kind of love them.
1:30:17But I just I want to say that when we're talking about like this, this stuff.
1:30:20I don't think there's a public interest for it.
1:30:24I think it really is all in all in fun and curiosity.
1:30:28And and I mean, and case manufacturers need to know the shape of the iPhone.
1:30:33All right.
1:30:33That's fair.
1:30:33They need to know that so that they can do their maybe they can make their cases.
1:30:36But like somebody violating an agreement, somebody breaking into their friend's phone.
1:30:41What are we doing here?
1:30:42I agree.
1:30:44And German certainly spans the divide.
1:30:47I guess Prosser has, too.
1:30:48I think Prosser has in the past had videos about hardware, but hardware and software are different.
1:30:54And the leaks come from and I think this is why, for example, we know, I mean, quote unquote, no.
1:31:01But I mean, I would I would bet really good money that there is going to be a remarkably thin iPhone added to the lineup this year.
1:31:09And it's already now in July of 2025, seemingly very clear that it's probably going to be a foldable phone that that it builds on this super thin ability because a foldable when unfolded is super thin.
1:31:25Otherwise, when folded would be super thick.
1:31:28Obviously, whatever technology is allowing and engineering advances are allowing Apple to build the super thin phone this year is similar to minus the hinge.
1:31:37What's going to let them build a foldable next year?
1:31:39It's a really smart two step planning process on their part.
1:31:43But that, you know, a large parts of that just leak from this.
1:31:46Clearly, we know leak from the supply chain.
1:31:49I mean, that's Ming-Chi Kuo's whole domain.
1:31:51Exactly.
1:31:52Software is different.
1:31:54Yeah, it's closer to home.
1:31:56It leaks from Cupertino.
1:31:57And that's why they hate it.
1:31:59That's why they hate it more than more than the hardware.
1:32:01The hardware.
1:32:02Look, they would like the hardware not to leak.
1:32:04But the Asian supply chain is so huge and there are so many parts.
1:32:09And I mean, I made a joke a moment ago about the case manufacturers, but it's not a joke.
1:32:13Like part of doing business in that environment is things like saying, I need to know the shape of the iPhone so I can make my cases.
1:32:20And like there's it's transactional and it's all happening in China far away from Cupertino and there's cultural differences.
1:32:28And like there's no way to plug those leaks.
1:32:31But a leak about software is it is a much more tightly controlled circle.
1:32:37Everybody's an Apple employee.
1:32:39Most of them are in Cupertino.
1:32:42I feel like it's the true betrayal.
1:32:44I think that that's what Apple feels about a software leak from inside.
1:32:48It is the truest of betrayals that I think they're almost over the fact that everything is going to leak from the supply chain.
1:32:54But the software stuff is what they can keep close to the chest.
1:32:57They can surprise people with it.
1:32:58And then this happens.
1:33:00And I think that's why one of the reasons they react the way they do is this is like the ultimate betrayal to have the software leak.
1:33:08And I think it happens extremely rarely, right?
1:33:13They're just literally literally there were, to my knowledge, two leaks of what we now call liquid glass.
1:33:23Prosser had the visual goods and showed them, recreated them to show them.
1:33:28And German described them verbally.
1:33:30So German, I suspect, again, I don't want to get in the weeds on it, but I suspect German never saw it.
1:33:38I think German spoke to someone who saw it and the person described it to German.
1:33:42Described it to him, yeah.
1:33:42Right.
1:33:43But the nature of the blue.
1:33:43You can read, you can tell in German's writing when he's sort of trying to grasp what he was told in a way that doesn't reveal his source.
1:33:52But he didn't see it himself.
1:33:54And he tries.
1:33:55I mean, he's really good at what he does, but that is a very difficult task to try and re-describe something described to you.
1:34:03Right.
1:34:04Very much so.
1:34:05But, you know, in hindsight, if you look back at his reporting from the six months prior to WWDC, did a good job.
1:34:11He got it.
1:34:11But that's it.
1:34:12And then it's possible that German had multiple sources describing it to him.
1:34:16Maybe it's more than one.
1:34:17But only went to one person who reports the rumors.
1:34:20And I suspect it wasn't many people.
1:34:22I just.
1:34:23I think he has confirmers, too.
1:34:24I suspect he's got confirmers.
1:34:26Yeah.
1:34:27Who.
1:34:27Yes.
1:34:27Yeah.
1:34:28He'll be like, I heard this.
1:34:29Is this right?
1:34:29And they'll be like, yeah, that's right.
1:34:30And then he'll go with it.
1:34:32But but it's not a leak as much as it is like, is this person accurate?
1:34:36And yeah, that person knows what they're talking about.
1:34:38But, you know, when you talk about like multiple nines, if if ninety nine point nine nine go to two nines of Apple engineers don't leak details.
1:34:49Apple has enough software engineers.
1:34:51Maybe that's too many nines.
1:34:53Maybe, you know, just say one nine ninety nine.
1:34:55One in a one in a thousand leak.
1:34:58Yeah, that's probably more of one in a thousand leaks.
1:35:00I don't know, but maybe there weren't a thousand engineers who had access to iOS 26 before it came out.
1:35:06But it's very small percentage.
1:35:08Right.
1:35:08You and I know a lot of people who work at Apple.
1:35:11And they and that means conversely, there are people at Apple who know people in the press, who talk to people in the media.
1:35:22And it would seem really scary, except you know what?
1:35:27The people I know who work at Apple are super diligent about this stuff.
1:35:31They take great pride in it.
1:35:32And I don't want to mess things up for them because I'm not trying to get things out of them.
1:35:37I they will.
1:35:38The people I talk to at Apple are often really great at providing understanding of what's going on.
1:35:44That's what I really love.
1:35:46And it's stuff that Apple PR would never approve, but it benefits Apple because it benefits my understanding of what's going on.
1:35:54It's a really nice kind of relationship that I can have with some of these people.
1:35:57But they they care a lot about following the rules and not revealing secrets.
1:36:03And I get lots of texts after products are announced, not before, after they're announced.
1:36:08Same here.
1:36:09And that's and that's all good.
1:36:11So so when you say it's important to say when it's ninety nine point nine, like it really is.
1:36:16These people are really diligent.
1:36:17And and and some people are are maybe bad.
1:36:21And I think there are also some people who are sloppy.
1:36:24And I don't know whether Lipnick was bad or just super lazy and sloppy about it and chose bad friends or whatever.
1:36:31But it is it is a shame either way.
1:36:33Yeah.
1:36:33Well, that's the other thing is the the closing paragraph of the anonymous tipster email is I am sure that Apple has the resources to further investigate.
1:36:45Lipnick has leaked iOS information to so and so and so and others in the past.
1:36:51And so and so is one of the writers, one of the publications everybody's heard about in the Mac media.
1:36:57Yeah.
1:36:58Yeah.
1:36:59And that's my good feeling about him getting fired.
1:37:02It was like, yeah, he got fired for reasons other than that.
1:37:04His friend unlocked his phone, folks.
1:37:06Yes.
1:37:06And I've I have confirmed that to some degree that he that he had.
1:37:13But but and I think it's sort of and the other thing is my understanding is that young Mr.
1:37:19Lipnick is literally like, I think, like 23 years old, maybe only 22.
1:37:23He's very young and early in his career and comes out of this little pocket subculture of younger men who are obsessed with cleaning the software secrets of upcoming Apple products.
1:37:37And so I think he got the job and was already in the sort of social circle.
1:37:43And it's like, finally, I can be a leaker.
1:37:44Yeah.
1:37:45It's like a bank robber.
1:37:46It's like a bank robber who gets a job at the bank.
1:37:49Fellas, I'm in.
1:37:54I got it.
1:37:55I got you.
1:37:55You're not going to believe it.
1:37:56But they gave me a job.
1:37:57But, you know, I don't think, though, but apparently and I think it's true that did not involve showing for recording an entire video of it.
1:38:06I think it was.
1:38:07Yeah.
1:38:07I think the usual style.
1:38:09And if you think about the way these things usually come out, it's usually dribs and drabs and not screenshots.
1:38:16And it's, hey, I heard they're going.
1:38:18Somebody will report at Mac rumors that, according to a source familiar with the situation, a messages app is going to add text effects this coming year or something like that.
1:38:29That's the way things come out.
1:38:31Not here's here's a recreation of how the text effects are going to look.
1:38:35That's the way things tend to leak.
1:38:37I'm not saying that that's a leak from this guy.
1:38:40I'm just saying that's how it happens.
1:38:42And then I think somehow it got out of control.
1:38:45Yeah, that's that's always the story.
1:38:48Right.
1:38:48I do think one last thing I want to ask you about, though.
1:38:51But here's the other thing is I have I can't help but wonder if the nature of John Prosser being a sort of independent creator on YouTube, more like what me and you do in terms of not in terms of content, but in terms of.
1:39:10The nature of the organization around it that Apple decided to name him in the lawsuit when they didn't with one of the last public things with a guy named is I wrote about this back in February.
1:39:25A guy named Andrew.
1:39:26Yeah.
1:39:27Journal or wherever.
1:39:28Yeah.
1:39:28Yeah, he leaked to Aaron Tilly, who was then at the Wall Street Journal, but then Tilly was in the round of layoffs.
1:39:35The Journal did, which I don't believe it was related to this.
1:39:39It was because the Journal laid off its per company beat reporters like Aaron Tilly was the Apple beat reporter for the Journal.
1:39:49And at some point in the last year, they decided we don't need one a reporter for Apple and one for Tesla and one for Microsoft.
1:39:55And anyway, Tilly's at the information where he was before he was at the Journal.
1:40:02But Apple, and there's this guy, Andrew Aud, who's named in Aud, A-U-D-E, and he issued a public apology on X, which I think he had some help with from Apple to write the apology.
1:40:15I spent nearly eight years as a software engineer at Apple.
1:40:18During that time, I was given access to sensitive internal Apple information, including what were then unreleased products and features.
1:40:24But instead of keeping this information secret, I made the mistake of sharing this information with journalists who covered the company.
1:40:30I did not realize it at the time, but this turned out to be a profound and expensive mistake.
1:40:34Hundreds of professional relationships I had spent years building were ruined, and my otherwise successful career as a software engineer was derailed, and it will likely be very difficult to rebuild it.
1:40:45Leaking was not worth it.
1:40:46I sincerely apologize to my former colleagues who not only worked tirelessly on projects for Apple, but worked hard to keep them secret.
1:40:52They deserved better.
1:40:53That's a good statement.
1:40:55I think he probably means certainly the part about it not being worth it and having derailed his career.
1:41:03But it's very curious, though, that him issuing that apology resulted in Apple saying, let's just dismiss the lawsuit and the lawsuit was over.
1:41:13They did not name Aaron Tilly or the Wall Street Journal.
1:41:16And, you know, and maybe the difference is just that Tilly, of course, as a journalist at the Wall Street Journal, much like Bloomberg, never paid the guy, never offered to pay him or induced him.
1:41:28And maybe that's the difference.
1:41:30And it quite possibly may be.
1:41:32And Prosser did, and that's the difference.
1:41:34But I can't help but also somewhat suspect that it's allowed.
1:41:38Why don't you pick on somebody your own size?
1:41:39The Wall Street Journal isn't Apple's size.
1:41:42They're not a $3 trillion company.
1:41:43But at a certain level, a company has the same quality legal representation.
1:41:48Yes, lawyers will be immediately involved if something like that happens.
1:41:53Right.
1:41:53And John Prosser is some guy on the Internet somewhere, according to this, in like upstate Pennsylvania near the New York border out in the middle of nowhere on a wide spot on the road, apparently, that he lives in.
1:42:04Yeah.
1:42:04East Bumblefuck, Pennsylvania.
1:42:06I mean, it is.
1:42:07You're from Pennsylvania.
1:42:08My mom grew up in Pennsylvania.
1:42:09I've had lots of relatives in Pennsylvania.
1:42:12I had to look up where this is, and it's not near anywhere.
1:42:14And I don't know if that's where he lives or not.
1:42:16But seriously, like, it's just a guy on the Internet.
1:42:20And yeah, of course, it's easier to sue a random guy on the Internet.
1:42:24Of course, it was easier to sue Nick Diplume and think secret than it would be to sue the Wall Street Journal.
1:42:30Who, it turns out, was a college student at the time.
1:42:32Who exactly was a college kid.
1:42:34Also, though, yeah, I think also allegations of offers of compensation, this was an easy call for them to make in that case.
1:42:44And I do wonder what the result is going to be, because John Prosser could fight this.
1:42:49He could say, that is absolutely not true.
1:42:52Ramisadi is making it up.
1:42:54He offered it to me.
1:42:55He intimated that maybe this would be something that would be successful for him over time, but I didn't offer him any money.
1:43:00And I'm perfectly within my rights to receive this stuff.
1:43:04He offered, I accepted, that's it.
1:43:06But to do that, he's going to have to get lawyers and take it to court.
1:43:09And that's the sad truth of something like this, is you've got Apple and a guy at the wide spot in the road in Pennsylvania.
1:43:16Right.
1:43:17And that is like being steamrolled.
1:43:19I don't see any scenario here.
1:43:22I feel like John Prosser will be lucky to apologize and say he won't cover Apple leaks anymore and keep his channel.
1:43:32That's the lucky scenario.
1:43:33The unlucky scenario is that John Prosser disappears from the internet.
1:43:36Yeah, maybe.
1:43:37I don't know.
1:43:38I don't know.
1:43:40It's a tough one.
1:43:41And again, leaving aside...
1:43:43I score it like you do.
1:43:44Leaving aside his, again, his shtick, which I don't like, but like whatever, if it works for some people, it does.
1:43:51One of the biggest corporations in the world versus just a random guy in a field in Pennsylvania, that's brutal.
1:43:57Like in law, in law, in lawfare, that is a real mismatch.
1:44:02And I feel for him.
1:44:03And if any of us screwed up like that, if the allegations are true, I mean, it would be easy for Apple.
1:44:12I mean, that's the sad truth about our system is like any of us, if somebody really wanted to make our lives miserable, they could do it.
1:44:20And that's scary.
1:44:22But this is what we do.
1:44:24And so that's just how it is.
1:44:25But Elon Musk has made a sort of side career out of it.
1:44:28Yeah.
1:44:29Of just suing people.
1:44:30Yeah.
1:44:31Suing people.
1:44:32Who are not his, don't have easy access to grade A white shoe law firms.
1:44:38Yeah.
1:44:38The other thing, I will admit, I'm not going to say I'm friends with Jon Prosser.
1:44:43I've communicated with him and chatted with him.
1:44:45I know him.
1:44:46And I'm not saying this to defend him.
1:44:48I'm just saying that all we know now is Apple's side of the story, which comes from their investigation into their employee, which I suspect gave them a lot because it was a work phone.
1:44:58So probably there's not much in there in terms of what was revealed that they don't know.
1:45:03But also that Rama Cotty had already cooperated with Apple.
1:45:11Well, there's criminal charges here.
1:45:15And I wonder if that is like, you need to cooperate with us because you could be in trouble like criminally.
1:45:20This guy who I've never heard of and everything I've heard since only makes him look even worse with regard to unrelated incidents in the past.
1:45:33But it's the good version of his story.
1:45:36The one that he got to tell Apple involves him betraying a friend whose house he was at.
1:45:41So looking at using fine my to find out when his friend was far away so he could be betrayed.
1:45:46Yeah.
1:45:46So I'm just saying in Prosser's favor in terms of Prosser saying, oh, this is not true there.
1:45:51I forget exactly what he tweeted publicly about it.
1:45:54But I'm willing to give some credence to Prosser on this in so far as that the other person involved is not reliable or trustworthy.
1:46:03Doesn't seem super trustworthy at all.
1:46:04Yeah, because he betrayed a friend and that's his best framing of it.
1:46:07Yeah.
1:46:08Oh, and by the way, before I go to a commercial break, what's the passcode on your phone again, Jason?
1:46:14It's a 1-2-3-4.
1:46:16What was Kanye's?
1:46:18Remember when Kanye unlocked his phone back into Trump 1.0?
1:46:22I think it was like 4 zeros.
1:46:23Oh, yeah, in the White House.
1:46:23Yeah, it was like 1-1-1-1 or 0-0-0-0-0.
1:46:27Yeah, yeah, yeah.
1:46:27It wasn't even six of them.
1:46:29It wasn't even six of them.
1:46:30It was four of them.
1:46:31No, no.
1:46:31Well, I mean, why?
1:46:32At that point, look, seriously, is there somebody who uses 0-0-0-0-8-2 as their passcode?
1:46:41I don't know.
1:46:42I don't know, but that was pretty funny.
1:46:45And in the Oval Office, we're the finest photographers in the world, still photographers in the world.
1:46:52Anyway, quite the segue to our third and final sponsor break, our good friends at Squarespace.
1:46:59Oh, once again, our good friends at Squarespace are sponsoring the talk show.
1:47:02It's the all-in-one platform where you can build your own website, move a website you already have,
1:47:11redesign it, put it in Squarespace, start a new website.
1:47:14And every single aspect of having a website on the internet, Squarespace can handle for you.
1:47:22Starting with domain name registration, they run their own registrar that's a great registrar for domain names.
1:47:29Picking from templates to get a basic look of your website.
1:47:33Features that you can add, things like, oh, I want to host a podcast on my website.
1:47:37Squarespace has that.
1:47:39I want to run a store on my website.
1:47:41I want to sell merchandise.
1:47:42If you want to sell your time or services, they have that.
1:47:54They can help you do that.
1:47:55And they've added recently, somewhat recently, Squarespace invoicing so that you can do your invoicing through Squarespace, send invoices, know when invoices have gotten paid, that sort of thing.
1:48:11They've got AI features that they've added somewhat recently.
1:48:14They call it design intelligence where they combine.
1:48:18They've already had great visual design tools for tweaking, either starting your own design from scratch and building it within Squarespace or taking one of their templates and tweaking it and modifying it.
1:48:27And you can do that now with AI help to help just sort of describe the features or changes or stylistic changes, the mood that you want to tweak or change on your site.
1:48:37That's all built in there.
1:48:38The invoicing, the payments, the AI for changing the design, all of that's there.
1:48:44And like I said, it goes all the way down to the lowest level of just registering a domain.
1:48:48You can do that at Squarespace too.
1:48:50People who listen to the talk show keep signing up or, I suspect, keep sending people they know who need a website or something like that to Squarespace using the code from the show so that they know that people are coming from here.
1:49:03Go to squarespace.com for a free trial, 30 days, all the features, everything Squarespace does unlocked for 30 days.
1:49:11And when you're ready to launch after the trial period's up, just go back to squarespace.com slash talk show and using that URL and that code, just talk show, you save 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain.
1:49:25Squarespace.com slash talk show.
1:49:27We are recording on Tuesday, the 22nd.
1:49:32The show should be out again a day or two.
1:49:35It's probably a race against time.
1:49:37I was guessing that the public beta would come out tomorrow, but maybe later in the week.
1:49:44Yeah, it feels like this is probably the week, though, unless there's a showstopper.
1:49:48Because as we recorded it, it's six hours after the developer beta 4 came out.
1:49:53And it feels if this is, if they have their way, it'll be out by the end of the week.
1:49:57Yeah.
1:49:58Yeah, again, I think it would require an heretofore unknown showstopping bug.
1:50:03And six, seven hours after it came out, it doesn't seem like that's happened yet.
1:50:07Those showstoppers are often like, oh, if you've got an iPhone 13 mini, it locks up when you install it.
1:50:15And it's, oh, nobody at Apple was still using an iPhone 13 mini or whatever the configuration is.
1:50:20Right.
1:50:20My son has, he got it, he wanted it for Christmas two years ago.
1:50:25He's got the Hermes Apple Watch Series 9.
1:50:29And he's an idiot who's been running the developer betas on his phone, iPad, and watch since the day of the keynote.
1:50:41And I think it was beta 2, watchOS 26 beta 2 crippled certain Apple Watches.
1:50:48And there might be other ones, but the Hermes models were the, and you can kind of understand why that's sort of a niche that maybe wouldn't get caught before the beta was released.
1:50:58This is actually kind of a funny story.
1:51:00He, the, the, the bug manifests itself as the watch getting overheated and wouldn't charge because it got too hot.
1:51:10But you, after beta 3 came out, he couldn't get beta 3 to install because the phone would be dead with no battery.
1:51:18And when he'd put it on a charger, even just charging it, it would overheat and stop charging.
1:51:22And you can't install a watchOS release unless you have 50% charge.
1:51:28So what do you do?
1:51:30He was, he's recently, he's 21, but hadn't learned to drive because he was under the impression as a 16, 17 year old that by the time he was out of college,
1:51:39robot cars would be driving us everywhere.
1:51:41And he's now learned that that didn't happen on the timeframe he was anticipating.
1:51:47I think that's much like Stanley Kubrick anticipating truly intelligent computers by the year 2001.
1:51:54So he's learned to drive.
1:51:57He's an excellent driver.
1:51:58I think, I think waiting until you're 21 to 20, or I forget, I guess he started learning at 20 and got his license at 21 is much more soothing as a parent
1:52:08than teaching a 16 year old.
1:52:10I recommend it if you could discourage your kid.
1:52:13My parents loved that I learned to drive at college and they didn't have to deal with it at all.
1:52:18I was, I, I personally am the worst.
1:52:21I learned, I got, I went to get my test the day I turned 16 and the day I turned 16.
1:52:28And I of course thought I was so smart.
1:52:30I didn't even look.
1:52:31I was like, there's no, I'm so, I'm so good at taking tests.
1:52:34I'm not studying for this.
1:52:35I went, I got my dad to drive me over there and I took the written test to get the permit, failed it terribly.
1:52:41I'm like, who the hell knows how many 25 feet or 30 feet from a hydrant?
1:52:45Who knows?
1:52:46Yeah.
1:52:47Drivers.
1:52:47Yeah.
1:52:48So I did, I had to take that test twice, but I got my license.
1:52:52But as a 16 year old with my license, instantly I was like, the day I got the license, I passed the test.
1:52:59I was like, can I take the car by myself?
1:53:01And I forget if it was my dad or my mom, or maybe both.
1:53:04I forget.
1:53:05We're like, okay, be careful.
1:53:06And I immediately took it down to farm country, a couple miles away from where I was on a little two lane road and just put the pedal to the metal to see how fast the car could actually go.
1:53:18And it was a Plymouth horizon from the eighties or late eighties.
1:53:24And the speedometer only went to 85, but the needle got way past 85.
1:53:28But I literally had just gotten my license that day.
1:53:31What an idiot.
1:53:32I mean, if my son did that, I'd strangle him.
1:53:34But anyway, what my son was doing, he realized that the air conditioning in the car, if he mounted the watch in front of it, would cool it down and keep it and it would get a charge.
1:53:45But he couldn't get the, he didn't have Wi-Fi and then he'd come in.
1:53:47And I was like, what are you doing?
1:53:49You're not going to do this in the car.
1:53:52Just put it in the freezer and we'll snake a USB cable into the freezer in the refrigerator.
1:53:58And he said, oh, I don't think that would work.
1:54:00I was like, sure it'll work.
1:54:01And it did.
1:54:02Except it turns out, I don't know what temperature a freezer is typically at, but obviously it's under 32 degrees.
1:54:08Watches don't like to charge at those temperatures.
1:54:11Oh, no.
1:54:13So we switched to the refrigerator and we just kept it.
1:54:15We kept it in the refrigerator, not the freezer.
1:54:17And it all was just perfect.
1:54:19It just charged fully.
1:54:20And the wife, it turns out we get a pretty good Wi-Fi, a good enough signal of Wi-Fi in our fridge, in our refrigerator.
1:54:27The overheating gets to fight it out with the fridge and you end up at a pretty good temperature.
1:54:31Yeah.
1:54:31And then Beta 3 fixed this terrible overheating bug in Beta 2.
1:54:35That's amazing.
1:54:36Pretty good story.
1:54:37I like that.
1:54:38I can't believe he didn't come to me.
1:54:39I'm worried that I'm too distant to a father or something.
1:54:44But you know what it really is?
1:54:45It's that he is like me and he wanted to solve it himself.
1:54:48Yeah.
1:54:48Yeah.
1:54:48Yeah.
1:54:49My son does that same thing.
1:54:50I don't want to bother you.
1:54:51I just thought I could figure it out myself.
1:54:53Yeah.
1:54:53Hilarious mistakes.
1:54:54Yeah.
1:54:56I like the independence, but it's like, ah, come on.
1:54:59I know this one.
1:54:59I had that answer in one second and you're like, spend a month worrying about it.
1:55:04It seems I don't think it's going to abate.
1:55:08It seems like I almost dug into writing about it at length after Beta 3.
1:55:13Maybe I'll do it this week now that Beta 4 is out.
1:55:16But with Beta 3, the debate was, hey, how come Apple is zigzagging all over the place
1:55:22from Beta 1 to Beta 2 to Beta 3 over how liquid glass looks?
1:55:26Is it clear?
1:55:27Is it frosted?
1:55:28Can you read through it or can you not read through it?
1:55:31But if you can read through it, which seems to aim the legibility of the UI elements,
1:55:35the coolness of the effect is downplayed.
1:55:37And if you make it look cooler, all of a sudden you can't read anything.
1:55:41So what are they going to do?
1:55:42And there's a...
1:55:45German wrote this.
1:55:46And again, this is one of those little things where I just don't think German gets it.
1:55:49Where German is...
1:55:50I think it's kind of sad that Apple is reacting to people on Twitter and toning this down after
1:55:55Beta 3.
1:55:55I really...
1:55:56I think Apple is aware.
1:55:58One thing you and I know, people within Apple, while they don't comment on it, all the way up
1:56:02to the very highest levels of the company, the type of people who previous years might have
1:56:09been on my WWDC talk show, are very well aware of what people on blogs and social media are
1:56:15saying about Apple products.
1:56:16They just don't talk about it.
1:56:18Yeah.
1:56:19They read everything.
1:56:19That's what we always said at Macworld is they read everything.
1:56:22They may not acknowledge that they read anything, but they read everything.
1:56:25Because if you take one step too far, you will hear about it immediately.
1:56:29Yes.
1:56:30I believe Phil Schiller has used those words to me exactly.
1:56:33That we read everything.
1:56:35Or I read everything.
1:56:36Yeah.
1:56:37Oh, yeah.
1:56:37And I mean, the PR people I know who have since left Apple, they would say that that
1:56:40was like first thing you do when you wake up in the morning before you even take your shower
1:56:43and go into the office is you read everything that was written about Apple.
1:56:47Right.
1:56:47First thing.
1:56:48Right.
1:56:48Because you can't...
1:56:49You get into...
1:56:49The moment you show up in the office, they figure that you will know.
1:56:53Right.
1:56:53And they will start asking you questions about...
1:56:55I imagine that probably was Phil.
1:56:57Right.
1:56:57Right.
1:56:58Immediately, you see what Gruber wrote.
1:57:00Yeah, yeah.
1:57:00And you're like, I don't even know.
1:57:01So now it's like I wake up early, read what Gruber wrote.
1:57:04Right.
1:57:06I don't...
1:57:07I think it's like an Occam's Razor situation.
1:57:09You don't...
1:57:10Before you get to, oh, Apple's reacting to what the commentary on Twitter or Threads or Blue
1:57:17Sky are saying about Liquid Glass, it's inside the company.
1:57:21They're just looking at their own betas and they're using it.
1:57:25Now everybody within Apple is using it.
1:57:27And they're the ones who see, oh, well, I can't read this.
1:57:30I can't read what's playing in music on my Mac right now.
1:57:34That's a problem.
1:57:35When you can't read the name of the song that's playing in the music app, that's a bug.
1:57:41Yeah, it needs to be fixed one way or another.
1:57:44And I don't...
1:57:46I mean, I'm sure somebody has done very close analysis, but I have been looking at it and
1:57:50it feels to me like every beta, they are tweaking a bunch of stuff involving opacity
1:57:57and blur and blur and not what...
1:58:00Because some people are like, the glass does this.
1:58:03Yes.
1:58:04It's super not true.
1:58:05The glass doesn't do a thing.
1:58:07It is dynamically changing the contents of the background and how they move through.
1:58:17It is dynamically changing the foreground elements.
1:58:21It will change...
1:58:23Dan Morin found this out.
1:58:25It's like literally when you...
1:58:26In beta 3, when you scroll under something under something else, if you keep on going, it
1:58:32doesn't react.
1:58:33And if you...
1:58:34But if you slow it down below a certain point, it does react.
1:58:37Yeah.
1:58:38Because it's trying...
1:58:39So there...
1:58:40And I think this points to a level of brittleness in this design, that they are trying to do some
1:58:45incredibly complicated things to get this design to work, that maybe that means the design
1:58:51doesn't work.
1:58:52I'm not opposed to this.
1:58:54I think it looks really cool.
1:58:55But like the legibility thing, I can see them sweating it.
1:58:59Like in the Mac menu bar, I feel like they're doing some things where dynamically, if the
1:59:04contrast isn't good enough, the stuff on the desktop gets a little bit darker.
1:59:09They're like trying to use the dodge and burn tools like dynamically to get the...
1:59:14And implement it, that actually could be brilliant.
1:59:16Because what you really want is it to look as cool as possible, but always be legible.
1:59:19But they haven't figured it out yet.
1:59:22Yeah.
1:59:23It's...
1:59:23If there's one thing I knew, and I think it always has to be this way, and we know, I keep
1:59:29bringing it up, but it's a lot like iOS 7.
1:59:33And with iOS 7, they...
1:59:36I forget exactly what month it was where the...
1:59:38All right, we're going to get rid of Scott Forstall.
1:59:41We're going to put design of software under Johnny Ive 2.
1:59:44I think it was like November, December of that year.
1:59:48It might have been even December.
1:59:49And Johnny Ive took over software like at the end of the iOS 6 year in like December and
1:59:59was like, we're going to ship an all new design by next September.
2:00:03But we're going to end it with the goal.
2:00:04I mean, obviously, if it had not come together, they weren't going to announce it.
2:00:08But it got...
2:00:09It was announced at WWDC.
2:00:10And that summer, all sorts of things, yin and yang, back and forth.
2:00:16The thinness...
2:00:17Some of the fonts were incredibly super...
2:00:20The super thinnest weight of Helvetica, Noia, like male for some reason in beta 1 from WWDC.
2:00:26Somebody had decided male is going to use this incredibly thin variant of the font.
2:00:34And they changed all sorts of things, like each beta to beta.
2:00:37It wasn't just like, oh, they're tuning it in.
2:00:39It's like, oh, we'll try this.
2:00:40We'll try that.
2:00:41This is a lot like that.
2:00:42It's obviously, you know, and that's because they only had six months before WWDC to even
2:00:48start the project.
2:00:49Because before that, before they pulled...
2:00:51Tim Cook pulled the trigger on, okay, we get it.
2:00:55Nobody likes working with Scott Forstall.
2:00:57I'll make a decision.
2:00:58If he hadn't, Forstall was forging ahead with an iOS 7 that was going to be like iOS 5 and
2:01:056 with the 3D texture and that sort of look.
2:01:08This wasn't triggered.
2:01:11Liquid glass wasn't triggered by something, a personnel change like that.
2:01:15So who knows how long they've been working on it.
2:01:17But at a certain point, there's aspects of this that feel like, boy, this could use a whole
2:01:22nother year to bake.
2:01:24But it's the forcing function of we need to announce it and say it's going to ship in September
2:01:30that makes you get it together.
2:01:32But I kind of feel, and you mentioned this, the thing about liquid glass, and I keep seeing
2:01:36people suggest, why don't they just give people a slider in settings that would go less to more
2:01:45in terms of how clear everything is.
2:01:47Like at the left edge would be more frosted and therefore less transparent and more legible
2:01:54for anything printed on top of the glass in the UI and go all the way to the right and everything
2:01:59is super clear and looks cooler and more liquidy.
2:02:03But that is totally misunderstanding how complex this is.
2:02:08It's not one slider or one access and it's not two.
2:02:12It is so many variants that to me, that's the problem is that it's like a Jenga game.
2:02:20And you want to, oh, I see it in music.
2:02:23Yeah, you can't read the album and the title is because the albums are underneath.
2:02:26So we'll pull out that Jenga piece and then everything falls apart.
2:02:30Yeah.
2:02:30And I think I actually just, I've been, as we've been talking, I've been playing around
2:02:34with iPadOS, the dev beta four.
2:02:37And it feels to me like there's still bugs, right?
2:02:40It's a dev beta and the public beta is going to have them too.
2:02:42So one of the things that happened in this cycle is people are like, oh, well, that's it.
2:02:46That's the final.
2:02:46That's what Apple wants us to be.
2:02:48And it's, you know what, there's what you design and then there's the implementation
2:02:52and they can really vary.
2:02:53And they're working toward a ship date that is September, not toward a ship date that was
2:02:59June or that is July.
2:03:01But when I scroll now, like weird, like stuff gets, as I'm scrolling up in music, like stuff
2:03:08comes in almost grayed out and then it fades into color, which means that the player is
2:03:16readable and then it fades into illegibility.
2:03:19And that can't be right.
2:03:20Like that, that can't be what it's supposed to do.
2:03:23That's a mistake.
2:03:24And, and yes, it is frustrating because you would want all of these mistakes ideally to
2:03:29have already been dealt with before the end of July.
2:03:32But I appreciate that they're working.
2:03:34Again, this is that thing is they're trying to make this so that it's always legible because
2:03:38we have powerful computers that are compositing all this stuff and they should be able to
2:03:44calculate, actually calculate legibility and vary the UI elements.
2:03:48The problem is that the content behind them is random.
2:03:51The content in front is random and things can move.
2:03:55And so how do you, like what Dan Morin found was in Safari, you'd scroll.
2:04:00And I think you saw this too.
2:04:01A bunch of us saw it.
2:04:02You'd scroll.
2:04:03And as you're scrolling through a webpage, all the text in your toolbar turns white and then
2:04:09it turns black and then it turns white again.
2:04:11And it's all half a second after the content is scrolled by that it's adjusting to.
2:04:15And that was in beta one.
2:04:16It's okay.
2:04:17They're trying to make it that smart.
2:04:19I think the challenge is, like you said, it is a Jenga kind of thing where you might
2:04:24build this up to be so complicated that it's kind of a mess.
2:04:27And what you really need is to come up with some more upfront rules about this stuff instead
2:04:34of it being, because legibility should not be an option.
2:04:37If you can't make it legible, you've got to try something different.
2:04:40And like music right now, the sidebar is frosted and the player is not.
2:04:45And the player is not legible and the sidebar is perfectly legible.
2:04:49And I think it all looks cool, but at the end of the day, it has to be cool and usable.
2:04:56And they're still struggling with it.
2:04:58What I see here is that they're not willing to give it up yet.
2:05:01They're still trying to solve the problem.
2:05:02And I suspect that if they can't solve the problem by the end of the summer, everything's
2:05:06going to get frosted.
2:05:06Yeah, that's a good way to put it, where liquid glass itself is so many variables.
2:05:12And I know from talking to a couple of developers that some of the stuff that they talked about
2:05:15at WWDC in their sessions about it, I think involving shaders in particular, aren't, or maybe
2:05:21in beta four, they're out because that's today.
2:05:23But as of beta three, weren't even available to third party developers.
2:05:27And that the shaders is a big part of both the coolness and the control over legibility,
2:05:35usability, whether it's text or icons or whatever.
2:05:38But that they weren't even in, not that they don't exist.
2:05:41I think Apple software has access to them, but that the APIs aren't available to third
2:05:45party.
2:05:45And again, beta, it's all, this is why developers, this is why so many developers who have podcasts
2:05:51all said the same thing at WWDC.
2:05:53I am super excited about this.
2:05:55It looks really cool.
2:05:55And I'm really, really angry.
2:05:57And my summer is ruined.
2:05:58My summer is ruined.
2:06:00Because I'm going to be working nonstop in a month, the month or the season of the year
2:06:06when maybe ideally people would most like to take vacations and not be working.
2:06:11Yeah.
2:06:11You really should be a developer in Australia, I think.
2:06:14Yeah.
2:06:15Because then this is your, in New Zealand, this is your winter and you can, you can do
2:06:19it down there.
2:06:19Yeah.
2:06:19I see the frustration, but I also share your belief that it's like what we say about
2:06:25the Vision Pro in a way too, which is at some point you got to ship.
2:06:28And I know I've seen that with all redesigns and things like that.
2:06:32I mean, at some point, maybe they could have held this for a year, but I do feel like even
2:06:36in a year from now, there would be all of these issues where you've got to put it out there
2:06:40and then everybody can see it.
2:06:42And then that is going to force a whole bunch of acceptance and change.
2:06:46You could argue it internally forever and never get an answer.
2:06:49And then you ship it.
2:06:50And the answer often can become fairly clear, like, oh, that person's argument was right.
2:06:55And I was wrong because we've now seen it in reality.
2:06:58And so that's what the beta period is for.
2:07:00Maybe Apple's too aggressive with it.
2:07:01Maybe we could make all those arguments.
2:07:04But I think anything like this, you got to get it out there and then start making changes
2:07:09because there's no, it's a fallacy to believe that you could ship something perfect without
2:07:13any, without it meeting reality.
2:07:15And then the moment it ships, it's perfect and nobody ever needs to see it again.
2:07:18That's just not, I'm not trying to excuse some of the issues with liquid glass.
2:07:21I'm just saying that I kind of feel like you need to put it out there and then work through
2:07:24it.
2:07:25Yeah.
2:07:25It is exciting.
2:07:26It does make for an exciting summer, especially for us as observers and commentators and not
2:07:31developers.
2:07:31Don't get me wrong.
2:07:34I still have to take screenshots and then they put out a new beta that changes the whole interface
2:07:38and I have to take a new set of screenshots because all the, all the interface changed.
2:07:42Yeah.
2:07:43I think a really good app to play with is Apple news because the news articles have all sorts
2:07:50of photos in them.
2:07:52And that you see these things like you're talking about, like the way that like the toolbar at
2:07:57the top will turn dark because it's on top, like a dark mode look because it's on top of
2:08:02a photograph and it needs to kind of reverse, but it doesn't happen as you scroll past it.
2:08:07It, unless you slow down, it's a really good example of that because you have this wide
2:08:13variety of content that scrolls through and they're not, it's sort of a top and bottom thing that
2:08:18Safari doesn't have.
2:08:20And the thing slides, it's just an interesting app to play with, with this.
2:08:24And I can definitely see that beta four, I could just see it right here.
2:08:27It's very different from beta three, but they're all different and it's not related to public
2:08:32commentary.
2:08:33Although that's just another chit on the pile of reasons.
2:08:37It is just a lot to do between June and September.
2:08:42And as much as Apple can play with everybody who's going to just use iOS 26 and all the
2:08:50other 26 is on their existing devices when they upgrade and they hold those, Hey, we, your
2:08:57badge turned red.
2:08:59You have a software update or we're going to install it tonight while you sleep.
2:09:02They hold that usually till November and like the dot one releases.
2:09:06So it's probably 26.1 or two, two even in November, December, where people's devices are set to
2:09:14automatic will upgrade.
2:09:16But it, September is a very important deadline because of the iPhone and the iPhones are going
2:09:22to come in September.
2:09:23And when you buy a new iPhone in September, it's going to come with this.
2:09:26Yeah, exactly.
2:09:28It, you won't have the choice.
2:09:30Everybody else, I think this is a function of iOS seven being so dramatically different
2:09:34is that a lot of people are really afraid of doing software updates now.
2:09:36And Apple, now we know Apple actually has a switch where when they roll out iOS in the
2:09:43fall for updates, the first wave is people who manually update.
2:09:48It won't actually push an update to everybody.
2:09:50And then Apple can push a switch, flip a switch later that then will notify people and say, Hey,
2:09:55there's been an update.
2:09:56Would you like it?
2:09:58And so then they get another wave.
2:09:59So they have this kind of a thing, but you're right.
2:10:02If you buy a new phone, that's it.
2:10:03You, you get it and it needs to be, and it's going to ship on those devices and it needs
2:10:08to be, even if it's going to progress and get better and they're going to fix things and
2:10:12all that, it's got to be presentable because the last thing you want is some sort of narrative.
2:10:16Like you shouldn't buy a new iPhone yet because the new OS isn't any good.
2:10:19Yeah.
2:10:19Yeah.
2:10:20And I also like your guess that if push comes to serve and whatever the deadline in late
2:10:26August is for, this is the version that is going to go on the first batch of iPhones out
2:10:32of the factory, dialing up frosting or whatever you want to call it for, okay.
2:10:38But that doesn't mean that that's not going to go back to getting tweaked in developer beta
2:10:42one of iOS 26.1 point one.
2:10:46Yeah.
2:10:46I, I, I would not be surprised at all if that's how it goes, if that there's a late beta where
2:10:51they, and there's all these stories that are like, Oh, Apple's gotten rid of the clear glass
2:10:54and they've all gone to frosted glass and all that.
2:10:56But that's really just to tie it because they couldn't solve the problem in 26.0.
2:11:01And then the first beta it ships and the first beta of the next cycle ships and it's all turned
2:11:06back on and people are like, what, what is happening?
2:11:08And the answer is because they're not, unless they give up, but, but they could very
2:11:12easily do a safe call.
2:11:14Right.
2:11:14If you, if you're still working the problem, but you don't have a solution yet, the safe
2:11:18call is frost it all over and kick the can down the road and then keep working on it.
2:11:23I think, I don't think that's unreasonable unless, unless they decide that it, that it's
2:11:28a bridge too far and they just can't do it.
2:11:29It doesn't sound very, I mean, Apple is doing Apple right now, which is no, no, we can solve
2:11:33this.
2:11:33We can, we, there's a way for us to get things as cool as they need to be, but also be legible.
2:11:38And we just haven't gotten it not nailed down yet.
2:11:41And I wish them luck.
2:11:42I hope they're right.
2:11:43Cause I would like my devices to be as cool as possible while remaining usable.
2:11:48But what I don't want is them to be so cool that I can't use them.
2:11:51So that's the trick.
2:11:53And as much as liquid glass has way more than two variables and certainly not one slider,
2:11:58trust me, as much as at a superficial level, you might think ultimately it really is a two
2:12:04access access decision, coolness and usability.
2:12:09Yeah.
2:12:09And right in the middle is the calculus, the maximum of both.
2:12:15You don't want to maximize one over the other.
2:12:17And you could argue, some people are going to argue for one extreme over the other, that
2:12:22it should be purely functional and coolness shouldn't even enter into it.
2:12:25And everything should look like Mac OS nine from 1998.
2:12:30Well, I mean, accessibility settings are not a, are not a failure.
2:12:34Like I think that there will always be accessibility settings you can turn on that will drop a lot
2:12:40of the animation and drop a lot of the opacity issues.
2:12:43And you'll end up with something that is not nearly as cool, but as super functional.
2:12:47And the fact that they put those in a few, a few check boxes, I think it's great.
2:12:51I may turn some of those on myself, but like out of the box, it should be usable.
2:12:56That's the, that's the thing is if everybody goes to the accessibility settings, you didn't
2:13:02do it right.
2:13:02Like you want out of the box it to be cool, but most people to be like, I like this and
2:13:07I want to use it like that.
2:13:08And the people, I think it's very important to people who are bugged, have a place to go
2:13:13and say, just, I don't just turn that off.
2:13:15I don't want to see it.
2:13:16That's fine.
2:13:16Do you remember Ray gun magazine?
2:13:19Yes.
2:13:21David Carson was the, the unreadable magazine.
2:13:24Yes.
2:13:25I will put a link in the show notes and I've sure I will hunt down a link that includes
2:13:31like PDFs of Ray gun magazine.
2:13:33David Carson was the graphic designer behind it.
2:13:36And it, it clearly was a magazine.
2:13:40It had good writing and they paid really good writers to write for it.
2:13:44But if you can imagine a magazine that was spearheaded and run ultimately by,
2:13:51an avant-garde nineties grungy or a graphic designer, Ray gun was it literally unreadable
2:13:57at times, all at the best, hard to read.
2:14:03And I was a budding graphic designer and me and my best friend at the time, it was a graphic
2:14:10design and major and an illustrator.
2:14:12We bought every issue and we poured over it.
2:14:14And the difference was he simply adored it and thought it was the best magazine that existed.
2:14:21And it was, and I admired it for what they were doing.
2:14:26And it was cool to look at, but as a also simultaneously budding writer, I remember thinking,
2:14:32I don't care.
2:14:33I'm a college student.
2:14:34I don't have a lot of money.
2:14:35I would not write for this magazine because it would bother me for my writing to be unreadable.
2:14:42And it was at times unreadable.
2:14:44Yeah.
2:14:45There are people who, you know, but the same sort of people like my former roommate and
2:14:50friend who loved Ray gun exactly as it was and wouldn't have changed a goddamn thing who
2:14:55want liquid glass to be like that.
2:14:58Just, just go all in on looking cool and legibility be damned.
2:15:04I know that's the back button.
2:15:05That's not right for Apple with the market that it has.
2:15:10There's a reason the, the, the wall street journal didn't, didn't hire David Carson to
2:15:13redesign the, the newspaper.
2:15:16You gotta be, you, and that's a tough balance to walk that they want to be, they want to be
2:15:20cool, but they're also have so many users that they have to, and our smartphones are so important
2:15:26to our lives that you've got to, you've got to have the ability for it to be functional
2:15:30again, without resorting to having literally everybody.
2:15:33You don't want all the tick tocks on day one to be, here's how you fix it.
2:15:37So you can use your iPhone.
2:15:38Here's an amazing thing.
2:15:40You go to accessibility and turn on reduce transparency.
2:15:43And then this amazing thing happens.
2:15:45Like that is you lost.
2:15:46If you, if you do that.
2:15:47I think I'll, I'll tweak that slightly.
2:15:50I think it's inevitable that that tick tock's going to be inundated with those videos, no matter
2:15:54what Apple does, but what you don't want is for most people or tens of millions of people
2:16:00to be like, give me those tick tocks.
2:16:02The tick tocks are going to be there, but you don't want them to be so viral because people
2:16:07think, Oh my God, I just bought this goddamn new iPhone air and I can't read.
2:16:11I guess I'm throwing myself on the algorithm here.
2:16:14If you see all those tick tocks, it's because everybody wants to learn that.
2:16:19Right.
2:16:20If people will do those tick tocks, but if nobody cares, then Apple will have done okay.
2:16:24But if everybody is the cool thing to do is to turn off all the liquid glass features in
2:16:30accessibility, then they will have done a bad job.
2:16:32They've still got time to do it.
2:16:33I think, look, I, I think it does look cool.
2:16:36I think they need to deal with some of this stuff.
2:16:38If they back it off because of legibility, that's the right thing to do.
2:16:41But I, I, I mean, I like the impulse, honestly, as a grumpy Mac user, my big issue is I think
2:16:48there's a great cycle for the Mac in terms of functionality, but it's so clear that the
2:16:52Mac is an afterthought when it comes to this design.
2:16:55If you look at Mac toolbars, they're so bad.
2:16:59They're like, they're like, they're just like gray on gray with little drop shadows.
2:17:06Like they, they, they don't have texture that it just looks so bad and that's a shame, but
2:17:11it's usable.
2:17:12I mean, I, I've been using it and loving it and the new functional features of the Mac of
2:17:16the Tahoe stuff with a spotlight and the, and the clipboard history and the changes to shortcuts
2:17:23and automations and the stuff that's going on in the menu bar.
2:17:26I think there's some really exciting things in Tahoe.
2:17:28I just, I am a little bummed out that I was hoping that this would be a, maybe they have
2:17:34better ideas about how the Mac should be that haven't been implemented yet, but I fear that
2:17:39they just, I mean that they did the whole liquid glass and they're like, yeah, yeah, yeah, liquid
2:17:43glass, iPhone, we got it.
2:17:45iPad, we'll make some changes here.
2:17:46And then like on the sketch pad, they had the Mac and they had like a question mark and
2:17:50maybe one thing down and they're like, we'll get to it.
2:17:52We'll get to it.
2:17:52And that's where we are because as good as it feels on the iPhone and as okay as it feels
2:17:57on the iPad, it just on the Mac, it's just a, I don't even, I mean, other than the unification
2:18:02of it, it's just, it's not unusable.
2:18:05It's just not good.
2:18:07It's just, it's just there.
2:18:08I mean, there's so many Mac toolbars.
2:18:11The Mac toolbar is the most other than the menu bar on the dock, which they did things too,
2:18:15but like every Mac app has toolbars almost.
2:18:18Right.
2:18:19And the toolbars in Tahoe are just awful and I don't understand it, but that's where
2:18:25we are.
2:18:25It's hard not to think that the, and again, there's people's opinions on Alan Dye and his
2:18:32whole team are span a very wide gamut.
2:18:36And without delving into that, I think it's almost undeniable.
2:18:41I think it's beyond argument that they're not really Mac diehards at heart.
2:18:49That it, you know, and it's, and if they were, they wouldn't have done lots of the stuff
2:18:55we see in these for, even in betas, even if you're like, oh, it's just the first beta.
2:18:59It's no, it's like whoever decided this clearly isn't, isn't immersed in the Mac the way that
2:19:06I am and they're not spending time in it the way that some of us are.
2:19:09The toolbar is not in vogue in Apple, in Apple apps, especially ones that came over from iOS.
2:19:17It's not in vogue.
2:19:18However, it's everywhere.
2:19:20It's in Safari and finder.
2:19:22It's in like third party apps everywhere.
2:19:24And I look at it, even in beta four, I look at it and think, is the person in charge of
2:19:32the toolbar on Mac OS Tahoe still working on it and hasn't passed it on to be implemented
2:19:38because it just, it feels completely untouched, not considered.
2:19:44It is like literally there's no contrast between the buttons and the background except for they
2:19:51put in this.
2:19:52I mean, forgive me, John, but I try to be really open about design because I'm like, I'm not a
2:19:58super design focus person.
2:20:00I care about it, but this is like the kind of drop shadow that I would put on it in college
2:20:06in Photoshop or in page maker.
2:20:08It's just, well, how do we deal with the fact that our buttons and our toolbar are exactly
2:20:13the same?
2:20:13The answer is I know.
2:20:14I'll just stick a drop shadow on it and it'll be fine.
2:20:17And it is not fine.
2:20:19It is really crappy.
2:20:20And I think it's partially because they didn't understand how important the toolbar is.
2:20:25In fact, now I'm ranting here, but I'll just say, have you ever recently gone to edit toolbar
2:20:31in the Finder?
2:20:33Because over the last few years, Apple has added a whole bunch of really interesting
2:20:37things to the Finder, like quick actions, which let you run shortcuts and all of these
2:20:41things.
2:20:41Can you put a shortcut or even a quick action button on the Finder toolbar?
2:20:47The answer is no.
2:20:48However, can you put a burn button on so that you can burn a CD-ROM from the Finder?
2:20:53The answer is yes.
2:20:55It feels very much like their whole portions of the Finder, which again, to your point, these
2:21:00are not people who are thinking like a Mac user.
2:21:02The Finder is super important to the Mac.
2:21:04And yet, parts of the Finder feel like they have not been thought about in a decade.
2:21:11And that's what I mean when I say the Mac, like they're adding cool new stuff to the Mac.
2:21:17But like this design, I don't think they're thinking of how Mac users use the Mac.
2:21:21I just don't think they are.
2:21:22And the other thing that to me belies a, I don't even know what you're thinking.
2:21:26And again, and it's not a question of taste.
2:21:29I just don't think you get it, is the way that the toolbar buttons look like they float
2:21:33and another layer in front or on top of the window, which doesn't make any sense.
2:21:39It's not logical.
2:21:40No.
2:21:40And the drop shadow makes it worse.
2:21:42Right.
2:21:43Exactly.
2:21:43Because the drop shadow only serves to emphasize that it's a layer in front.
2:21:47Right.
2:21:48The sidebar was really bad in the first beta and the second beta, but in the third and fourth
2:21:54beta is actually, the sidebar is floating.
2:21:56It's a pane of glass that's floating.
2:21:57Right.
2:21:58And it, it, it, it, somebody did some work there to make it better.
2:22:01And it is better.
2:22:02Right.
2:22:02But the toolbar is, I, what's the metaphor there?
2:22:06I mean, we're, we're turning into, both turning into John Syracuse now, but like, I ask you
2:22:10from a design standpoint, this is supposed to represent something.
2:22:13Is this, are these glass buttons sitting on a, because there's no texture, there's no indication
2:22:19that this is glass.
2:22:20It's literally like a flat piece of paper cut out and the drop shadow implies slightly
2:22:27suspended above another flat piece of paper.
2:22:29I don't know what the metaphor is.
2:22:31I don't know what they're getting at.
2:22:32It doesn't show off the graphical prowess of liquid glass as a concept.
2:22:36It's just not designed basically.
2:22:38And that's my frustration with it is that the Mac is so clearly just not a priority.
2:22:42And so they've slapped something in there that they can call liquid glass, but like whole
2:22:45portions of it seem to be not just badly considered, but not considered.
2:22:50There's a sort of, whatever the design is, and the style could be anything.
2:22:55You could, in theory, you could just go back to the platinum theme from Mac OS 9, or you could
2:23:01go back to Aqua from the first versions of Mac OS 10, or pick any of the themes from the intervening
2:23:07eras, or invent a new theme, or whatever.
2:23:11But whatever the theme is, and we can quibble about the appeal of the theme, but the theme should
2:23:19reinforce the concepts of the design.
2:23:22And like at a basic level on the Mac, which is unique, it's different from the other platforms.
2:23:27Yes.
2:23:28Certainly iOS is like just one nature.
2:23:31The menu bar represents the app has one menu bar.
2:23:37And there's an app, whatever the active app is, the app that gets the menu bar.
2:23:42So the menu bar is the app, the toolbar, which Apple has largely shifted to over, I would
2:23:49say close to 20 years, maybe 15 years.
2:23:53I sort of de-emphasize the menu bar and doing things by going to the menu bar for menu commands
2:23:58and putting more things in the toolbar on the Mac.
2:24:02But it represents what's in this window from the app.
2:24:06And so you could have two documents and just two.
2:24:11And there's a toolbar for both of them.
2:24:14And the toolbar for this document is that window.
2:24:17And the toolbar for the other one is that window.
2:24:19And it means this toolbar has commands that affect this window.
2:24:24So clicking something in the toolbar isn't going to affect the contents of the other window.
2:24:28Whereas a command in the menu bar might affect both, like show...
2:24:35Compare documents in BVEdit is a great example of that, right?
2:24:38It's going to sweep up all the documents and put them together in a diff.
2:24:41Right.
2:24:41Or something in the view menu might affect all windows or something like that.
2:24:45All windows, because it's a global...
2:24:47Yeah, exactly.
2:24:48And it sounds like such a picky thing.
2:24:51But if the toolbar buttons look like they're in a layer above and apart from the window,
2:24:57they're still there.
2:24:59They move around with the window as you move the window around.
2:25:02But it doesn't reinforce the concept.
2:25:05And so it doesn't help you learn it.
2:25:08It doesn't help you understand it.
2:25:09And if you do understand it, it just looks and feels weird.
2:25:12And I don't think it's ever not going to look and feel weird.
2:25:14No, you mentioned Aqua.
2:25:16And it's something that I thought about a lot.
2:25:18And I'm not quite sure what I think about it.
2:25:19But I was asking myself, what did I expect Liquid Glass as envisioned?
2:25:25What would the Mac version of Liquid Glass be?
2:25:28Because I think a lot of the problems here are they had a vision for Liquid Glass for these
2:25:32glass devices and the Mac isn't quite that.
2:25:34And so they're trying to adapt it.
2:25:36And I would argue they don't seem to be trying too hard, honestly.
2:25:39They're just like, let's just get it to be good enough.
2:25:43And I keep coming back to Aqua because I think about Aqua was that it was kind of like they were
2:25:48glass, raised glass buttons on the window.
2:25:52And I thought, I think that's kind of what I expected it to be.
2:25:57It's almost like out of the window would come these kind of bumps of glass with the toolbar
2:26:03under them.
2:26:04And instead, they're non-textured with the drop shadow.
2:26:07I'm like, I don't even know what I'm looking at here.
2:26:09And it's weird because maybe they don't want to go back in that direction.
2:26:15But I actually think that the closest we've gotten to Liquid Glass on the Mac is Aqua.
2:26:19Yeah.
2:26:20And of course, me and you feel like the Mac should be treated separately or differently
2:26:30or whatever.
2:26:30And it's not that I don't think it needed to be updated at all, but I almost feel like
2:26:34Liquid Glass on the Mac should be complementary to Liquid Glass on iOS and maybe the other platforms
2:26:42that can sort of share a one-thing-at-a-time aesthetic.
2:26:46But on the Mac, it's not that it would look out of place or be different, but it would
2:26:50just be not the same, but complementary.
2:26:52And your idea of, what if it was a lot more like Aqua, but with styling along the lines,
2:26:58use, of course, use San Francisco as the font.
2:27:01And instead of the all sorts of blue, no pin, get rid of the pinstripes.
2:27:05Yeah, it's just clear glass, not blue.
2:27:07Yeah.
2:27:07But it's still like you've got some reflective aspect of it and you're looking at a window
2:27:12that's made of glass.
2:27:13But because of the way that Mac windows are constructed in most cases, especially like
2:27:16something like the Finder, you can't see.
2:27:19Yeah, it's weird because on one level, it's like, I know that the Mac is not going to get
2:27:24special treatment.
2:27:25I know that the priority, absolutely the priority should be the iPhone.
2:27:28But if you were going to do this, this is, think of it this way.
2:27:32This is the first time Apple has ever attempted a global redesign across all of its operating
2:27:39systems.
2:27:40The iOS 7 didn't redesign the Mac to look like iOS 7.
2:27:44And over time, I think some of the issues that they've had with importing things from
2:27:48iPad and iPhone to Mac have been they're importing stuff from a completely different design sensibility.
2:27:54And it can be a problem.
2:27:56Some of it is that they're different devices, but some of it is just it's coming from a different
2:27:59design.
2:28:00And so what a great opportunity this is, the 2026 OS updates with redesign for the first
2:28:07time for Apple to say, yes, this is what Apple products look like.
2:28:11And if you're going to do that and you're going to half-ass the Mac, you've missed an opportunity.
2:28:18I mean, that's the bottom line.
2:28:19I know the iPhone is more important, but this is your opportunity to get the Mac to define
2:28:26what a Mac looks like in the context of your product line.
2:28:30And if you let it go, it's going to be this kind of mishmash of old design and undesigned.
2:28:36And I do feel like that's it's really weird, too.
2:28:38I am.
2:28:39This is the most ambivalent about an OS design or an OS release.
2:28:42I've been in a while, but it's not ambivalence.
2:28:44It's I think they totally have fumbled the design.
2:28:48And I think that it's the best set of productivity features they put in Mac OS in 10 years.
2:28:52Yeah.
2:28:53I think both of those things are true.
2:28:54And so it's very frustrating because it's like, we got clipboard history and also the toolbar
2:28:58windows look like crap.
2:28:59And it's like, that's Tahoe.
2:29:01I agree.
2:29:05Well, here we are, two hours, 30 plus minutes.
2:29:08Short show.
2:29:08And we covered everything, though.
2:29:10It's shorter if you don't talk about sports and keyboards, though.
2:29:12Oh, but we covered the whole agenda.
2:29:14I know.
2:29:15We got to do it.
2:29:17You know, I really did.
2:29:17Whether they want it or not.
2:29:18Yeah.
2:29:19I had a lot of fun talking to your pal, Mike Hurley, on his Cortex show.
2:29:25That was a great interview.
2:29:27It really was.
2:29:28I found it inspirational.
2:29:29I told Mike, you got to do that to me sometime.
2:29:31That would be like, you got to do that because he did a great job.
2:29:34And I thought he really led you in some interesting places.
2:29:36It was really fun to listen to.
2:29:37I totally did.
2:29:38I've done a lot more of other people's podcasts in the last six months than I've done in a
2:29:41long time.
2:29:42And no offense to anybody else.
2:29:44I've enjoyed it all.
2:29:45But boy, that was my favorite because that was the one I listened to.
2:29:48And I told Mike, I was like, I never listened to a complete podcast I'm on because I just
2:29:52don't like listening to myself.
2:29:53I really don't.
2:29:55And I listened to that whole thing.
2:29:56I was like, hey, that was pretty good.
2:29:58Yeah.
2:29:59Yeah, it was good.
2:30:00I mean, it's fun to hear about other people's processes, too.
2:30:04And I don't know.
2:30:05I mean, I have known some things about your process between our talking and me doing things
2:30:11and you sending me screenshots of your movable type interface and sharing some stuff.
2:30:15Some of the some of the things I mentioned that I've never released publicly, I have shared
2:30:18with you.
2:30:18Yes, it's true.
2:30:19It's true.
2:30:20I have seen some of that stuff.
2:30:21So anyway, I thought I'd get some of that out before Mike's interview.
2:30:25But it's like somebody on Mastodon said, don't ever bet against Mike getting something out
2:30:29before you.
2:30:30And I was like, yeah, and that goes like triple for me.
2:30:32I will thank my sponsors for the episode.
2:30:35Let's see if I can remember them.
2:30:36I can't.
2:30:37I'll go backwards.
2:30:38Squarespace.
2:30:39And before that, Factor, where you can get some food to eat.
2:30:43And then the new one, Sentry.
2:30:44So go check them out.
2:30:46And Jason, of course, is at SixColors.com and The Incomparable and Upgrade on Relay with
2:30:54the aforementioned Mike Hurley, which I did not listen to the latest yet because I knew
2:30:59you were going to talk about the same stuff I wanted to talk to you about.
2:31:01But now I'm going to go listen.
2:31:02Yeah, exactly.
2:31:02Exactly.
2:31:03Thank you, Jason.
2:31:04Just know that I referred to that guy, Ramisati, as a what a bad friend.
2:31:09That's the title of that episode.
2:31:11I think that says it all.
2:31:12With friends like these.
2:31:14Anyway, thank you, John.
2:31:16Thanks for having me.