0:00:00Louie Mantia.
0:00:00Am I saying it right?
0:00:02Am I saying it right?
0:00:03People are going to be in like a John Syracuse thing.
0:00:08He's going to be mad at me just for the way I said that.
0:00:10It's Mantia, but yeah, Louie Mantia, sure.
0:00:16Yeah, the way I think of it is I know you're of Italian heritage, where Mantia comes from.
0:00:21So just sort of guido it up a little.
0:00:24Mantia.
0:00:25There you go.
0:00:26Then it sounds fine.
0:00:27Yeah.
0:00:28We were talking recently because you're doing something Philadelphia-related or something,
0:00:33and we got talking about hoagies and sandwiches and Italian sandwiches.
0:00:37And then you got mad at me about hoagies, like within a few minutes.
0:00:41I do think as a Philadelphian, I do think, and I know Philadelphia is I think best known for
0:00:50the cheesesteak, and I do like a good cheesesteak, but I feel like I told you privately, I'll say
0:00:56the same thing here.
0:00:57What's the guy's name?
0:00:58Thanos, the guy from the Avengers?
0:00:59Yeah, that's right.
0:01:01Yes.
0:01:01Yeah, yeah.
0:01:02If a Philly sandwich were to be Thanos-ed out of existence with the snap of a finger, I
0:01:10think the world would be a better place if the cheesesteak were vanished and the Philadelphia
0:01:14hoagie, Italian hoagie remained.
0:01:17I think it's the better day-to-day sandwich.
0:01:20If I could only eat one for the rest of my life.
0:01:21I mean, you're right about a day-to-day sandwich.
0:01:24If we're talking about like a once-a-month sandwich, then maybe the cheesesteak.
0:01:28It's a really different situation then.
0:01:29In the same way that when Thanos snapped his fingers, a lot of people, heroes and people
0:01:35that everybody loved, you missed some of the people who went away, but it's not that the
0:01:40cheesesteak wouldn't be missed, but I do feel it's a better overall sandwich.
0:01:44It does make me wonder.
0:01:45It doesn't make me wonder.
0:01:46That could have been the whole plot to the movie instead, that we could have just had just
0:01:50half of the food, half of the cuisine went away instead.
0:01:53That would be like the Mel Brooks sort of Spaceballs take on the Avengers.
0:01:57Right, right, right.
0:01:58Would be to have some kind of guy who's got really strong opinions about sandwiches.
0:02:02That just eliminates half of sandwiches in the world?
0:02:05Sure.
0:02:06Why not?
0:02:06Yeah.
0:02:06We were also talking about the terminology of it.
0:02:11This is where I think we were arguing as to whether hoagie is a Philadelphia regionalism.
0:02:17Yeah.
0:02:18Or, and you were saying, I believe in St. Louis that they call them hoagies or no?
0:02:23Well, I don't know.
0:02:24I just like, I just remember hearing that word all my life.
0:02:27So I don't know if, I don't know if that ever, yeah, that was always a word I knew.
0:02:34Yeah.
0:02:35In America, people call it, this is a long Italian roll, hopefully Italian, with Italian lunch meats
0:02:42and I like it with the Italian, like sharp provolone cheese, onions, lettuce, tomatoes, oil.
0:02:49Another one, we didn't even get into this, is the issue of mayonnaise on an Italian hoagie.
0:02:54Oh, interesting.
0:02:56I guess I've never felt like that was a necessary component of it.
0:03:00I would say it's anti-Italian hoagie.
0:03:02Yeah.
0:03:03You need some moisture on an Italian hoagie, but that comes from the oil and vinegar.
0:03:07Yeah.
0:03:08Oil and vinegar, a million percent.
0:03:09Yes.
0:03:10Yeah.
0:03:10I don't, yeah, I think mayonnaise, I don't think mayonnaise ruins it.
0:03:14I just don't think it's what that sandwich is for.
0:03:16Right.
0:03:17It's in the same way that putting American cheese on it wouldn't ruin it.
0:03:21It would, it would just be a different sandwich at that point.
0:03:23Yeah.
0:03:23It's just slightly, slightly off the taste profile.
0:03:26But if you, I think a lot of the places that call them subs or submarine sandwiches default
0:03:31to mayonnaise because it's not really.
0:03:33And I think you got to it in chat, which is the basic thing is it's not a Philadelphia thing.
0:03:38It's an Italian thing.
0:03:40And that's true.
0:03:42I just think you guys call them hoagies.
0:03:44Right.
0:03:45Like everywhere else might have this sandwich, but you guys are the ones that call it a hoagie.
0:03:51Yeah.
0:03:51Yeah.
0:03:52So the term might be a little more Philadelphia-ish, but the Italian sandwich, which I've also,
0:03:58and in Philly, a lot of people just call them instead of calling them a hoagie.
0:04:00A lot of people, even here in Philly, will just call it an Italian sandwich.
0:04:04And what they mean is an Italian hoagie.
0:04:06What I don't understand is like what New York had, what was the, they called it like an Italian
0:04:11grinder sandwich.
0:04:13I don't know where that word came from.
0:04:14Where did that word come from?
0:04:16I don't understand that at all.
0:04:17I don't understand it either.
0:04:19And I've never really gotten a good sandwich, Italian sandwich in New York.
0:04:23But whereas, and this is one of those, I'm sure, you know, New York is huge.
0:04:28I'm sure somebody can do it.
0:04:30You're sure it exists.
0:04:31You just didn't have it.
0:04:32But I'll tell you where I know you can get an excellent Italian sandwich is in Boston.
0:04:38Boston has a big Italian community.
0:04:39I think it's South Boston.
0:04:41A friend of the show, Paul Kafasis at Rogue Amoeba.
0:04:44My son goes to college in Boston.
0:04:46So we're visiting more than we used to.
0:04:49And he knows a neighborhood place, but it's totally, it's like a weird little store that's
0:04:55been there forever that bought the store.
0:04:57It seems, this seems like the layout of the place.
0:05:00It's sort of like half a deli where they make sandwiches and half sort of a bodega corner
0:05:06store where you could just buy, you know, it's a corner.
0:05:08That sounds great.
0:05:10But it seems like what they did is they got so big and popular that they bought the store
0:05:14next to them and knocked, not really a door, but just sort of an archway into the next.
0:05:20So it's like, yeah, it feels like, wait, am I in the same, am I in the right store?
0:05:24It's, it wasn't, it wasn't designed that way.
0:05:26It was not intentionally this way.
0:05:28But they make absolutely excellent Italian sandwiches, but I don't believe they call
0:05:32them hoagies.
0:05:33They just, why are we starting out with this?
0:05:35I feel like, I don't know.
0:05:39I'm, I'm already hungry.
0:05:40It's only like 6am right now.
0:05:43Okay.
0:05:43All right.
0:05:45All right.
0:05:46Before we go any further, let me already take a break here and thank our first sponsor.
0:05:50Just get it out of the way and we'll keep going.
0:05:52Cause I feel like we get on a roll.
0:05:53We're not going to, we're not going to have breaks.
0:05:55I want to thank our first sponsor.
0:05:57It's Notion AI.
0:05:58Notion AI is the all in one AI powered by your work and it puts everything you need all in
0:06:05one place.
0:06:05It automatically captures meeting notes, instantly finds the exact content you need, drafts detailed
0:06:12docs for you and lets you chat with the best AI models.
0:06:16Notion AI just became twice as powerful for teams, making it the best AI tool for work.
0:06:24AI meeting notes is a huge, huge area of focus for Notion.
0:06:27Imagine perfect meeting memory every time, every idea, every decision, every next step
0:06:33is captured in Notion where they can be put to work right away.
0:06:37And it even follows up with suggested action items immediately after the meeting.
0:06:42But the best part is because it's for teams, the whole team can share the exact same summary
0:06:47of the meeting and the meeting notes.
0:06:48So it's not just your copy of the meeting notes is in Notion and it's better because you
0:06:52did it in Notion, but because it's collaborative, everybody gets to share it and take advantage
0:06:55of it.
0:06:56You can capture anything in the meeting and turn it into organized searchable notes.
0:07:00Regular meetings with a bunch of people, one-to-one conversations, lectures.
0:07:05You can even throw podcast episodes into it.
0:07:07No meeting bots in the platform.
0:07:10You don't need bots.
0:07:11It just works on any meeting platform, Zoom, Google Meet, et cetera.
0:07:15It works just with your computer's system audio.
0:07:19You just let it pipe into the audio.
0:07:21It listens to the meeting.
0:07:22Boom.
0:07:23Summarizes the whole thing.
0:07:24Transcription summaries automatically and summaries are automatically saved in Notion.
0:07:30So your notes are searchable with the Notion AI.
0:07:33So you can search for words from the transcript or from the summary.
0:07:36Find any past idea, insight, or decision alongside all of your other information.
0:07:43All sorts of other stuff.
0:07:45PDFs you can embed right into Notion.
0:07:48You can do PDF search.
0:07:49All sorts of great stuff like that.
0:07:51And it has all the top AI models built right in.
0:07:54It lets you choose.
0:07:55ChatGPT 4.1 or Claude 3.7 Sonnet.
0:07:59Chat with them right in Notion to ask questions about the content in your Notion database or
0:08:05to generate more content for your Notion note system.
0:08:08Notion is used by over half of Fortune 500 companies and teams that use Notion.
0:08:13Send less email, cancel more meetings, and save time searching for the work.
0:08:20And they reduce spending on tools to keep everyone on the same page.
0:08:23The fastest growing companies like OpenAI, Ramp, and Vercel all use Notion AI
0:08:28to make processes faster and help their team stay ahead.
0:08:32So check out Notion, the best AI tool for work, right now at Notion.com slash talk show.
0:08:39That's all lowercase letters.
0:08:40Notion.com slash talk show.
0:08:43They want me to emphasize, use lowercase letters for the slash talk show.
0:08:47And try the powerful all-in-one Notion AI today.
0:08:51And when you use that link, you're supporting our show.
0:08:54Notion.com slash talk show.
0:08:58All right, before the main topic, I have another one.
0:09:00Another, so we're easing into it.
0:09:02I ask this periodically, and the results fascinate me.
0:09:06I asked on Mastodon and Threads, this identical poll question yesterday.
0:09:13I haven't publicized it yet, so it's not sometime before the show is recorded.
0:09:20And when it comes out, I've already linked to it on Daring Fireball.
0:09:23But here's the question.
0:09:25On your phone, do you use, it's a poll, light mode, dark mode, switch by time of day, or switch willy-nilly?
0:09:39I think it's switch by time of day.
0:09:41I think that's the way that it works for me.
0:09:43That's what you do personally?
0:09:45I'm checking.
0:09:46I'm checking right now, because I don't even know, I don't even think about it anymore.
0:09:49What is this?
0:09:50Yeah.
0:09:52Yeah.
0:09:53It's light until sunset.
0:09:55Yeah, that's how it goes.
0:09:56I mean, the icons don't change.
0:09:59That's the big deal for me, though.
0:10:01Right?
0:10:01I don't switch to the dark mode icons, right?
0:10:05I switch to dark mode for the UI, right?
0:10:07Because I'm not trying to blind myself.
0:10:09Personally, I just, I'm permanently light mode.
0:10:13I use light mode 100% of the time.
0:10:15Okay, I'm not trying to make any value a statement here, but is it an eyesight thing, or is it just like a classic thing?
0:10:22So that's a super interesting question.
0:10:25So I think I've talked, I know I've talked about this long ago, but I'm only 52, but in my 40s, which is a ridiculously young age, I had cataracts in both eyes.
0:10:36So I've had cataract surgery in both eyes before I was out of my 40s.
0:10:39And it is very unusual to have cataracts in your 40s.
0:10:44But the other thing I learned with the first one, which was my left eye, is the younger you are when you develop a cataract, the faster it gets worse.
0:10:53It gets worse very quickly the younger you are.
0:10:56And 40 is preposterously young.
0:10:58So I went from not really noticing I had anything wrong to my left eye was just blurry all the time, seemingly in a matter of months.
0:11:07And it was so young that at first, my eye doctor was like, they didn't think about cataract and didn't like, you know, if they think cataract and they just sort of shine a light, they're like, oh, you've got a cataract.
0:11:16Because it's just a cloudy lens.
0:11:18The lens in your eye is cloudy.
0:11:20But they weren't thinking that.
0:11:22And so they were just sort of, you know how when you go to the eye doctor for glasses and they put the things that are like, click, and it's, is this better or worse?
0:11:28And it's, it's a little better.
0:11:29So then they go one more.
0:11:31He just kept going more, more.
0:11:33And it was like not getting any better, right?
0:11:35No, I was like, I guess it's a little.
0:11:37And he's, and then they were like, do you have diabetes?
0:11:39And I'm like, I don't think so.
0:11:41But it turned out I had a cataract, but it went very quickly.
0:11:44And so I've had the surgery for both eyes.
0:11:46But anyway, at one point when my second eye had the cataract, my first eye, I swear to God, this sounds terrible, but it's all better now.
0:11:54Develop what's called a secondary cataract, which is.
0:11:58Oh, fine.
0:11:59So the cataract is cloudiness in the lens in your eye, but the lens sits in a sack that's sort of like a Ziploc sandwich bag.
0:12:08This is how it's.
0:12:09Right.
0:12:10It's just like that.
0:12:11Right.
0:12:11It's, it's, so the lens is the more important part, but it sits in a sack in front of your eye.
0:12:17The secondary cataract is that sometimes or often when you get the, the cataract is the, this is gross.
0:12:24I've had it happen, but they take out the natural lens in your eye and put in an artificial lens in place.
0:12:32And that's perfectly clear.
0:12:33But a secondary cataract is when the sack develops a little bit of yellowing.
0:12:38Right.
0:12:39And that's, you don't need surgery for that.
0:12:41They take care of that with a laser.
0:12:43You just sit there.
0:12:44It doesn't hurt.
0:12:44They don't numb you.
0:12:45You just sit there, keep your head still.
0:12:47And it looks like a green light is flashing in your eyes and they go click, click, click, click, click, click.
0:12:52And it's all better.
0:12:53And then you, they're like, beforehand, they gave me a magazine to read with my other eye closed.
0:12:58Said, can you read it?
0:12:59And I was like, yeah, not really.
0:13:00And then, then click, click, click, click, click.
0:13:02And can you read it?
0:13:03And I could read it clear as a bell.
0:13:05It was, you know.
0:13:06Wait, can you walk out, can you walk out of the surgery like fine?
0:13:09No big deal.
0:13:10There's cataract surgery.
0:13:11I mean, there was recovery time.
0:13:12No.
0:13:12When you get the actual cataract surgery and they replace your lens, they put you under because it's, they actually cut your eye open and put a lens in there.
0:13:20And you're kind of woozy coming out.
0:13:21When they do the secondary cataract though, I swear to God, it's, it is five minutes in and out.
0:13:26You just stare at a machine, green light flashes in your eye and it's all better.
0:13:30But at one point I had a cataract in my right eye and a secondary cataract in my left eye.
0:13:36And my, so for a bit of a stretch there, my combined vision was very bad.
0:13:41And I had to get.
0:13:42That sounds awful.
0:13:43It was awful for a brief while.
0:13:45It was really pretty bad.
0:13:46Well, it's interesting.
0:13:47It's interesting that you say all this because, so I had like my, my corneas like were deformed, I guess.
0:13:54There's a weird, dumb thing, a reason that that happens and it's not important, but I also had surgery in both of my eyes, but it was like corneal crosslinking and they have to like open your cornea and stick some like steroids in there for it to chill out and get back to a normal side.
0:14:08And I'm like, yeah, I mean, I'm like 37 now.
0:14:11I'm like, could we, can we wait until later to do this sort of stuff?
0:14:15Like, this is my job.
0:14:16I actually need these more than anything.
0:14:18And it just, yeah.
0:14:19So trust me, I know.
0:14:21And I get nervous about it because the other, it's a total side issue and it's far more significant and risky, but I've also had retinal detachments in both of my eyes.
0:14:30This is fun.
0:14:30You're just having eye problems all over the place.
0:14:33Oh, all over the place, but not in recent years.
0:14:35And currently with, with my glasses on, I see with both my eyes open 2020 with the glasses.
0:14:41It's really great.
0:14:42But when I had the cataract in the right eye and the secondary cataract in the left eye and I was waiting and it was like, I forget which one I had to get taken care of first.
0:14:50And it was, I think right after COVID.
0:14:53And so some of it was postponed.
0:14:55Like I might've had it, the one procedure earlier, except it was like, ah, we're not doing these procedures for a couple months because of coming out of COVID.
0:15:04And I think it was the first, I'm pretty sure it was like, I might be getting the year wrong, but I think it was the first year back at WWDC.
0:15:14So this would be like 2022 or else it was 2019, the last year before WWDC.
0:15:21I don't know which year it was, but I'm in the hotel lobby.
0:15:24And at the time with both of these eye problems, I kind of had to get really close to a screen to read it.
0:15:29And I was working on something for daring fireball.
0:15:32And I don't know, I was like six inches away from my laptop screen typing.
0:15:37And my friend, Matt and Reese saw me in the lobby and he thought I was like working super diligently because I was hunched over this computer.
0:15:46Yeah, yeah.
0:15:46And he's, ah, and I was like, hey, why did you say hi to me?
0:15:49Because, ah, you looked like you were like super focused.
0:15:51In the zone.
0:15:52And I was like, oh, no, I can't, I can't read my screen unless I'm six inches away.
0:15:56But here's where I'm going with all of this.
0:15:58At that time, the cataract, it, because it's like cloudiness in the lens and the effect that you see is just sort of a general haziness.
0:16:09Like in a sitcom, like a classic 80s, 90s sitcom when a character would have a dream sequence.
0:16:16Yeah, yeah.
0:16:16It's just very, yeah, yeah, yeah.
0:16:18Yeah, it's like a haziness.
0:16:20Well, that's what the whole world looks like.
0:16:22And you can start to notice it, like people really start to notice it when you're driving at night because a light source, like a stop sign or opposing headlights.
0:16:32Right, just blurs the entire vision.
0:16:34Yeah, they, any kind of light source really gets like these wild specular highlights.
0:16:40But in the daytime, anything bright like that.
0:16:43So looking at a light screen, a white background with black text, the white overwhelms the black and all you really see is white.
0:16:51Right.
0:16:51So at that time, dark mode was an enormous savior for me.
0:16:58It meant the difference, not just that I preferred it.
0:17:01It meant the difference of, oh, if I get close to the screen in dark mode, I can read.
0:17:05It's just fine.
0:17:06I didn't have to make text bigger.
0:17:08But light mode, I literally couldn't read.
0:17:11There was nothing I could do.
0:17:12I could bump the font size up, up, up.
0:17:14If I made it truly, truly ginormous on the phone, I guess I could kind of read it.
0:17:20Wait, wait, wait.
0:17:21So are you telling me that dark mode for you was like an accessibility feature only and that now that you've got like your 2020 vision, okay, you're like light mode only now?
0:17:31I went back to white mode.
0:17:32Incredible.
0:17:32Because I just, and it's probably that I'm used to it.
0:17:37But it's why, and I would have been okay if this had happened to me before dark mode became a system-wide thing on iOS and macOS because for that accessibility reason, both platforms had supported something.
0:17:54It was like called reverse mode or something.
0:17:57If you fire up like an iPhone from 2007 or a Mac from 15, 20 years ago, there's a feature in accessibility that reverses the screen.
0:18:06But it makes everything look weird.
0:18:08Like photographs look like x-rays.
0:18:10Because everything.
0:18:11Yeah, there's an invert mode at the time.
0:18:15And now they call it classic invert.
0:18:17In the modern version of invert, they intentionally don't invert content like photos, but they invert everything else, which is like better, but still like dark mode is like really what you're after in this situation.
0:18:34Yeah.
0:18:34So I would have been okay with invert before, but when this happened to me, dark mode was a thing.
0:18:40So I didn't even feel like I was missing anything.
0:18:43Like I was like, oh, there's a mode that just suits me.
0:18:45And so it was great.
0:18:46And there are a couple apps that I use in dark mode.
0:18:49I have BBEdit for years and years now.
0:18:52I used to go back and forth, but my text editor of choice, I have in dark mode.
0:18:56And I just kind of like looking at code as light text on a black background.
0:19:03And it just sort of feels worky to me to be.
0:19:08That's a good point.
0:19:09I feel like a bunch of pro apps were like actually doing dark mode way before like system stuff was right.
0:19:14I mean, of course, final cut, just because you're working with with movie stuff was always like and stuff like aperture was like with that.
0:19:22It was like a graphite like sort of appearance for a light room.
0:19:25Kind of like a mid-tone.
0:19:25And so, yeah, I mean, I can't even actually imagine.
0:19:29Does GarageBand have a light made?
0:19:31I don't think so.
0:19:32Or is it permanently in dark mode?
0:19:34I think it's permanently in dark mode.
0:19:35Yeah.
0:19:35So I don't know why, but the watch app has always been dark mode only.
0:19:41Oh, that's right.
0:19:42Yeah.
0:19:42But the other thing I like about BB edit being, it's not quite black, like my color scheme, but it's almost black.
0:19:49Any normal person would look at you.
0:19:51You would look at it and instantly know that's just dark gray, but it's very dark gray.
0:19:55But I like that the BB edit windows stick out with a bunch of windows tiled on top of it.
0:20:00I can, I go, there's my BB edit back to work.
0:20:03So it's not that I hate dark mode, but I just like it very selectively for certain apps.
0:20:08Right.
0:20:08Well, I mean, that's a, well, that's a good point because it's like there used to be, I get, we're getting an interesting thing here and I don't want to get there.
0:20:17But like when 10, 15 years ago, I feel like apps were more visually distinct in not just like the background color, but just like the style overall.
0:20:25So you could identify like what app was over on this side of the screen versus this side of the screen very easily based on what it looked like.
0:20:34Right.
0:20:34Whereas I think it's getting, it is increasingly getting harder to figure that out.
0:20:39Yeah, I totally agree.
0:20:41Just, and again, putting aside, we'll get back to this issue for the, a lot of this on the show.
0:20:46I'm trying to save it off for some reason.
0:20:48I don't know why.
0:20:49But for example, and I made fun of it, the, the rich Corinthian leather of Apple calendar for a while, right?
0:20:57That it, it had these leather accents, like it was a leather desk mat on an executive's desk.
0:21:03And we can make fun of that particular style or, or the over the top.
0:21:09I know everybody calls it skeuomorphism, but it's the skeuomorphic use of leather as a photorealistic leather or almost not even photorealistic,
0:21:19but like hyper realistic leather.
0:21:21Yeah.
0:21:22It's an illustrative, like idealized version of this.
0:21:26Yeah.
0:21:26Right.
0:21:27But it, say what you want about the, oh, I like the way that looks or I, I like the gimmick of the way it looks.
0:21:33It undeniably made the calendar window instantly recognizable.
0:21:38It was super distinct.
0:21:39Yeah.
0:21:40Right.
0:21:40Yeah.
0:21:40So for me, it's light mode all the time on the phone.
0:21:44I, I would probably rather switch to dark mode 24 hours a day than do the switching at sundown because I find to me, and I think it's probably related to the fact that I'm older and, and I grew up at a time when all the, all there was, was light mode.
0:22:02It was light mode.
0:22:02Right.
0:22:03Okay.
0:22:03Well, here's like, I don't, I don't.
0:22:04I have a question for you.
0:22:05You, if you're, okay.
0:22:08Sometimes you go to Walt Disney World, right?
0:22:10It's a thing you do sometimes.
0:22:12Like it, here's, this is where I always struggle.
0:22:15This is where I end up being willy nilly because I have to switch between light and dark mode at a place like Disneyland because you're in darker environments.
0:22:23If you're in the queue, I don't want to be the guy with a bright white phone.
0:22:26Right.
0:22:27So like, I got to go into dark mode.
0:22:28First, you tell me you don't.
0:22:31You're just like, you're the guy with the bright white phone.
0:22:34I try to keep my phone in my pocket as much as I can while I'm there, but there's, you're in a long enough queue.
0:22:41And you're there for an hour.
0:22:43Yeah.
0:22:44And if, if Amy and Jonas both have their phones out, then I'm like, well, now it's a free, it's free for all.
0:22:49Right.
0:22:50But no, I don't switch to dark mode.
0:22:51I would just turn the brightness down.
0:22:53Brightness down.
0:22:54But I find that, I just find that when it switches automatically, I don't recognize the app anymore.
0:22:59To me, Apple Mail doesn't look like Apple Mail.
0:23:03Apple Mail is this white background app that has these, the white background to me is part of Apple Mail's visual identity.
0:23:10So I don't.
0:23:11Well, do they allow you, I know that some, some third party apps have settings that are like, do you want to follow the system or do you want to use light or dark?
0:23:21But like none of Apple's own apps have that capability, right?
0:23:25I mean, they're all technically capable of providing this, but none of them seem to do that.
0:23:29I mean, I wonder if you would, I'm curious if you would intentionally select dark mode for any app that you use just for that app.
0:23:39Well, like I said, I do it for BB edit, but for Apple's apps, would I change?
0:23:44Probably not because I, let's see, the Apple apps I use the most are messages, I'm not necessarily in order, but messages, Safari, and Mail for sure.
0:23:57And I wouldn't want to switch any of those.
0:24:00I find it confusing with Safari.
0:24:02There used to be a time where dark meant you're in private window mode.
0:24:09That's, oh God, yeah, right.
0:24:10And now it's like.
0:24:12Now it's like the kind of the URL bar maybe changes its appearance a little bit or something you don't really know.
0:24:18Yeah.
0:24:18Yeah.
0:24:19Okay, well, here's the thing.
0:24:21So being in dark mode, because mine happens like automatically, it doesn't change if you're actively looking at it, right?
0:24:29Even if it technically hits the time, it doesn't do it until like you turn off your phone or look away from it for a second and then it changes.
0:24:35When, like, when it changes into dark mode, like for the rest of the evening or whatever, the thing that always killed me is in Safari, when a page loads, it loads white first before everything else.
0:24:49So before a page even loads, I get like this really hot flash of like white right in my face before it decides, oh, like the website will maybe respect dark mode and have a dark mode appearance.
0:25:00So it's just bright, like what is awful.
0:25:03Yeah, and that brings me to the other, hey, how can you have to mention this, or I have to mention this, is that effectively, Daring Fireball has been a form of dark mode from its inception.
0:25:18Yeah, okay.
0:25:19So I wanted to actually talk to you about this, so I'm glad you brought it up.
0:25:22Because, so, you've straddled this light mode, dark mode thing for a really long time by being medium mode the entire time, right?
0:25:31You, like, by having the medium grayish sort of blue color that you have, like, you work both, like, you work well in both modes and no one cares.
0:25:40No, no dark mode person is going to complain, no light mode person is going to complain, right?
0:25:44But if you have a white website and you don't work in dark mode, you're like an asshole, right?
0:25:48So, like, I mean, this is the same thing I do, like, with a bunch of my websites where it's like, I have, like, medium blue as my background for, like, Parakeet and Junior and whatever else.
0:25:58And, like, my own personal website, I guess I have, is it's dark mode, for real.
0:26:02But I guess light mode people, I don't know, often complain about the dark mode, whereas dark mode people often complain when, like, it's not supported for them.
0:26:12Yes, they do.
0:26:13It does seem like that's what they complain about.
0:26:16And the web is another area where, again, I have my own personal opinion on the color of my site, which is I've been pretty consistent with those colors all along.
0:26:29But I like that going to your blog is a very dark background with white text.
0:26:34I like that when I go to Ars Technica, it's the same way.
0:26:38I like that I wouldn't want your site to switch to light mode just because my system's in light mode.
0:26:45Yeah.
0:26:45And I would find that very strange if I went to your site, which I've been reading a lot lately because you've been writing about things I care a lot about and why I've invited you onto the show.
0:26:56And I do a lot of reading after sundown.
0:26:59I would find it very strange if your site reversed color just because it was after 8 o'clock at night.
0:27:04Are you choosing when to read my blog based on time of day?
0:27:07Are you always?
0:27:08But I might.
0:27:10It's a dark remote website, so I only read it after 9.
0:27:13All right.
0:27:14I want you to – do you want to guess the poll results?
0:27:18I had 3,300 people on Mastodon respond and on threads 2,838, so about the same, but Mastodon was a little more popular.
0:27:30The results were very close, not quite the same, but very close.
0:27:33I have to imagine there's actually a fair amount of automatic people, but maybe that's just because I lean that way.
0:27:38I feel like it's got to be half are those people, and I actually bet a bunch of people are like explicitly dark mode all the time.
0:27:44Many light mode people?
0:27:46Oh, God.
0:27:47I'm scared to know this.
0:27:48Nope.
0:27:49I'm going to give you full credit here, Louis.
0:27:51I think you guessed it.
0:27:52Number one, switch by – switch willy-nilly only got 3% on both.
0:27:56Yeah, no one does that.
0:27:57Switch by time of day, which implied automatically – I forget if I was running short on characters that I didn't include the word automatically, but people know what I meant.
0:28:05It was 51% on Mastodon, 49 on threads, so 50%.
0:28:11Call it even, 50%.
0:28:13Dark mode, 30%.
0:28:15Right.
0:28:16Light, 36 on threads, so call it 33% average, about one-third, and 12% and 16% on light mode only.
0:28:25So I'm in a – all right.
0:28:27So about half do the automatic thing, which I do think is the default now.
0:28:33Yeah, that might be why that's – yeah.
0:28:35About a third do dark mode all the time, and the remaining, you know, what, a sixth or so – a sixth or seventh.
0:28:49So you're in – it's not nobody, but you are in the lowest or the smallest group, besides the weirdos that are just, like, apparently switching willy-nilly, which I don't know who those people are.
0:28:59I mean, I knew that sometimes, but not all the time.
0:29:02That's crazy.
0:29:03I just thought it was interesting, and it does seem dark mode is more than a passing fad.
0:29:09Well, that's definitely true, yeah.
0:29:11All right.
0:29:13Let's keep going on this topic, though.
0:29:16You mentioned this before we segue into talking about the iOS 26 and liquid glass and everything, but I guess that this is changing this year for the first time.
0:29:26Or did it change before where apps got dark mode icons in dark mode?
0:29:31Did there?
0:29:33I don't think – that didn't happen on Mac OS ever.
0:29:37We didn't even have dark mode iPhones yet.
0:29:38So dark mode app icons changing – I think that was in the previous version where they did that.
0:29:44No.
0:29:44I'm looking right now because I've got two phones here in front of me.
0:29:47So my main phone on iOS 18, I just put it in dark mode, and none of the icons changed.
0:29:53But I think it's a – I think it's a – oh, God.
0:29:55I want to say it's a setting.
0:29:57Like, in that weird, like, customized thing on the home screen.
0:30:01I don't think it does.
0:30:05I find that to be off – I find the app icon switching around to be very off-putting, and that's something, like, to me, it would be like – I don't know.
0:30:17So that's, to me, the thing that you were talking about before, where it's, like, you don't recognize male if it's dark mode.
0:30:24Like, I don't recognize icons the same way if they're inverted in color.
0:30:28I just don't.
0:30:28Like, they're just completely different apps at that point because the color composition of an app icon is, like, its entire identity.
0:30:35And, like, yeah, I will probably, like, understand certain things, like, mail and messages maybe.
0:30:41But it's – like, there is some cognitive dissonance that happens.
0:30:44Like, when you see a mail envelope that's white on blue, and then you go to it being blue on black, like, both of these attributes changed.
0:30:54And my brain isn't – oh, the background color is now the foreground object.
0:30:57That makes sense in my head.
0:30:59It doesn't.
0:30:59So, like, I don't even really recognize these – like, these apps I use every day.
0:31:04I just don't recognize them when they're in dark mode.
0:31:06I really don't either.
0:31:08So, for example, like, the Notes app.
0:31:10Notes is – I should have mentioned Notes as one of the main Apple apps that I use all the time.
0:31:16And the – in iOS 26, the icon changes what used to be – the icon represents a notepad of white-lined paper with a yellow – I don't know what you call that at the top – binding at the top.
0:31:31Yeah, some binding, yeah.
0:31:31And when you go to dark mode now, it becomes a black piece of paper.
0:31:36Yeah.
0:31:36Well, this has always been, like, the weird part about, like, notes in dark mode.
0:31:40I mean, I remember when that happened, and then it was like, oh, what – that – is this black paper that we're writing on?
0:31:45It suddenly stops making sense, right?
0:31:48I mean, this is – it's funny because I think in that whole, like, era where everyone was, like, questioning, like, rich visual design and skeuomorphism, we were always making questions.
0:31:57Like, we're like, hey, does this really make sense for it to be rich Corinthian leather?
0:32:00It's – I don't know.
0:32:01And it's like, no one – I don't want to say nobody.
0:32:04But, like, when the black notes paper happened, I don't think anyone was like, hmm, yeah, that doesn't make any sense.
0:32:10They were just like, well, that's what the icon has to be, so it is now, right?
0:32:12I don't know.
0:32:13It's like selective criticism, you know?
0:32:15It's just like, we're going to complain about, like, the rich visual design, but not about this.
0:32:20It's weird.
0:32:20It's weird to have the black paper.
0:32:22I think it's weird that the phone app changes from a green icon with a white phone, which is the main light mode icon, to a black icon with a green phone.
0:32:33Yeah, that's what I was saying about mail.
0:32:35It's the same thing.
0:32:36I like –
0:32:37Right.
0:32:37It's not – like, if it kept a black – okay, here's – really what I think they should have done with, like, dark mode the whole time was make the background part of the icon darker, but retain some vibrancy of the original color of the thing.
0:32:52If it was a dark green with, like, still, like, maybe, like, even a light green phone, right?
0:32:57Like, reduce the contrast, reduce the white point on the whole thing, right?
0:33:00But keep the vibrancy.
0:33:01That would have made more sense because it would have kept all of this, like, information in your head.
0:33:05It would have looked like you're just looking at a dimmer screen, right?
0:33:08But no, here's my question.
0:33:10Do dark mode people, like, when they have all these dark mode icons, or God forbid the people that do, like, tinted icons or whatever, are – like, do they fully just have some capability?
0:33:21I don't – where they just instantly recognize this stuff?
0:33:23Are they just, like, spatially organizing everything?
0:33:25Yeah.
0:33:25So they don't care?
0:33:26Are they searching for all their apps?
0:33:28Like, there's no way.
0:33:30You can't tell me that they're just, like, instantly just, like, identifying all of these things.
0:33:34I don't know.
0:33:34I just feel – yeah, I feel like I'm particularly logo sensitive or logo – I – the way that people – humans naturally – every – almost everybody.
0:33:46I know there's a condition that some people have where they can't.
0:33:50But the way that almost all humans recognize others instantaneously by their face.
0:33:56And that you can – and if you run into somebody who you haven't seen in 10 years and they've aged, you still –
0:34:03Yeah, it's true.
0:34:03You recognize them instantly.
0:34:05You're like, wow.
0:34:05And that's how I feel about logos.
0:34:08And to me, icons for apps are logos.
0:34:11That's one of the purposes that they serve.
0:34:13And you do this, and to me, it doesn't look wholly unrelated.
0:34:18But the first time I saw the dark mode app for phone, I thought it was, like – I thought it was, like, Google Voice or WhatsApp or something.
0:34:29And I'm like, how did this get on my first home – get on my first home screen?
0:34:33It starts conflating some of these things, right?
0:34:36Because, like, okay, there are a bunch of apps that, like, just for better or worse, are just green backgrounds with white, like, chat bubbles on them.
0:34:44Okay?
0:34:44This exists, right?
0:34:45There's a whole suite of these.
0:34:46Yes, WhatsApp.
0:34:47Yes, messages.
0:34:48Yes, like, Line in Japan.
0:34:50They're all like this, right?
0:34:51And so – but when they get inverted, it's not that they – they're actually less different because they're all black, right?
0:34:59And there's no difference in shade of green.
0:35:01And then the foreground object all being green, you're just, like, looking at – they look like third-party apps now.
0:35:06Like, all of them, including messages.
0:35:08Like, it puts messages in with the others instead of being its own separate thing.
0:35:14Yeah, I don't get it.
0:35:16I don't get the thinking.
0:35:17And I – like I said, I just don't recognize it instantly.
0:35:23To me, a perfect example of this would be a can of Coca-Cola versus a can of Coke Zero.
0:35:31Right, yeah.
0:35:33And to me, what Apple is doing in iOS 26 is saying, oh, you're in dark mode?
0:35:38Well, now regular – cans of regular Coke now are black cans.
0:35:42Right.
0:35:43They look like Coke Zero, right?
0:35:45Right.
0:35:45It's – well, actually, no, it's a good point.
0:35:47Like, they're saying that that kind of difference now, right, is actually, like, something that we have to accept is an alternate version of this rather than being, like – like, actually, there was tons of apps, right, that were, like, black – like, even Apple's apps have a black background, right, before dark mode existed.
0:36:07And those – those are weirdly, like, still safe, right?
0:36:11Like, like, the watch app doesn't have a light mode icon, right?
0:36:14Right.
0:36:15So, there's, like, there's, like, voice memos doesn't have a light mode icon, right?
0:36:20There's – wallet doesn't have a light mode icon.
0:36:23Stocks doesn't have a light mode.
0:36:24They're all dark mode, like, permanently, right?
0:36:27So, yeah, I didn't know.
0:36:30Yeah, you're right about the Coke Zero thing.
0:36:32Like, they're saying it's now a black can of Coke.
0:36:34Yeah.
0:36:35Like, that's different.
0:36:36And you're supposed to know that that's different than Coke Zero.
0:36:39And you're like, how are you supposed to know?
0:36:40Yeah.
0:36:41And, again, you took my point that I was going to make, which is that in this scheme, it's not like the Coke Zero can changes either.
0:36:50The Coke Zero can changes.
0:36:52It stays the same.
0:36:53Yeah, it stays the same.
0:36:54So, now you have two icons that are more similar, even though they were totally different in the other mode.
0:36:58Right.
0:36:59Absolutely.
0:37:00And so, you can see the polling.
0:37:02And, again, I always – I guess I should always preface a poll that I do that I don't pretend that the people who follow me on social media are representative of the world at large.
0:37:14But I bet –
0:37:15But they're representative of Apple nerds.
0:37:17And I'll bet it's representative – I'll bet the basic takeaway that dark mode is overall more popular than light mode.
0:37:25Right.
0:37:25You know, that lots of people use the automatic switching, so they use both.
0:37:29And more people prefer dark mode all the time than prefer light mode all the time.
0:37:35I'll bet it's true.
0:37:36Maybe the percentages are different in the general population.
0:37:38But I'll bet that's true.
0:37:40But I do think then, therefore – and you just made the point that Apple – looking at Apple for examples of leadership, which I don't know if we should be doing for UI anymore.
0:37:53Yeah.
0:37:54But that they have some apps like Wallet and Watch, both – coincidentally, both on the same second home screen for me.
0:38:03They both start with WA, but they have dark icons that don't – in light mode, too.
0:38:12So when you switch to dark mode, their icons don't change.
0:38:14So in some sense, from Apple's perspective, dark mode is more canonical now than light mode, that it's the one where if an app – like Watch is – Watch is the perfect example.
0:38:26The interface doesn't get light no matter what you do.
0:38:29Yeah, that one, that one, they were fully – actually, the icon and the app are both dark mode permanently.
0:38:35Right.
0:38:35Right.
0:38:36But the icon for wallet doesn't change no matter what.
0:38:39But when they show iOS 26 at WWDC, they show light mode either all the time or almost all the time.
0:38:50I think if you go to Apple.com, that that's what they show you.
0:38:56But it's certainly in the keynote, they make it seem like light mode is still the canonical one true lie.
0:39:03Well, I think it is for icons.
0:39:05I think light mode is the canonical icon color system.
0:39:09Actually, they changed it, right?
0:39:10Because last year it was light, and this year it's called default.
0:39:13Do you see this?
0:39:15Like, in the customized – in the customized, like, whole thing on, like, the – on the home screen, they renamed it from light to default.
0:39:22Huh.
0:39:23Which is interesting.
0:39:25Like, they are saying that the light mode icons are the canonical versions.
0:39:29But I think they want to believe that everyone's using light mode maybe because it – does it photograph better?
0:39:36Does it just look better against, like, backgrounds?
0:39:39Do you see, like, windows more easily?
0:39:41Does dark mode just blend in with everything?
0:39:43I don't know.
0:39:44They show – they show tinted icons a lot.
0:39:48They advertise tinted, like, stuff, clear icons a lot.
0:39:52It's right at the top of the iOS 26.
0:39:55They really love that.
0:39:56They really want everyone to start using that for some reason.
0:39:59It's like they got the memo that we all wanted to customize, and they were like, is this good?
0:40:05And we're like –
0:40:06I find that very strange, though, that Apple seems to be steering, pushing people towards using dark mode.
0:40:15But yet, when they present their own interfaces, like in commercials and stuff, it's light mode by default.
0:40:22And I don't know why that is.
0:40:23There might be something more than just tradition that I'm not thinking of, but I was hoping maybe you could think of it.
0:40:29I don't know.
0:40:31I mean, if you're shooting an ad, I imagine that you want, like, bright things on the screen rather than dark things.
0:40:36Those dark things are just going to catch all your reflections, right?
0:40:39So, that's my only dumb guess.
0:40:42So, I'm on apple.com slash iOS or OS slash iOS.
0:40:50That's the URL to the iOS 26 preview page right now.
0:40:54And I get at the top there's a tab bar where you could switch to macOS or iPadOS.
0:40:59Here, I'll switch to iPad.
0:41:01And as I scroll down the page, it's light mode.
0:41:03I'm looking at every screenshot.
0:41:05Light mode.
0:41:05Then it's clear.
0:41:07Then it looks like control center in light mode.
0:41:13Icons that are clear.
0:41:14Light mode.
0:41:15Light mode.
0:41:16They don't even show dark mode.
0:41:19It's just all light mode.
0:41:21And I've gone ahead and changed because I thought, I just thought right now as we're talking, wouldn't it be clever if Apple dynamically changed the web page depending on your mode?
0:41:32On the time of day.
0:41:32Yeah.
0:41:33They could do it based on your mode.
0:41:34They could also do it on time of day.
0:41:35They could have that be a second.
0:41:36Wait, wait.
0:41:37Now I'm wondering, like, okay, John, what's the time on the clock on all of the screenshots?
0:41:42It's still 941, right?
0:41:45So if it's 941 AM, then automatic, it would show light mode, right?
0:41:50Yeah.
0:41:50Oh, yes.
0:41:51So maybe, maybe.
0:41:53They never say it's 941.
0:41:54Maybe that's what they're saying.
0:41:55Maybe they're saying technically auto is what's on.
0:41:58It's not that they're against dark mode, but they want to keep 941.
0:42:01Therefore, it has to be light mode.
0:42:03Right.
0:42:03Oh, no, they do say AM.
0:42:05You're right, because I'm looking at the iPad when they show the AM, PM.
0:42:09Yeah.
0:42:10So maybe you're right that I guess there is.
0:42:12It's technically auto.
0:42:13They're, like, skirting by on a technicality.
0:42:16Right.
0:42:17And they are being consistent in the way that I'm going to argue for the most part.
0:42:21They're no longer even pretending to be consistent in any way overall.
0:42:27I don't know.
0:42:28I thought it was a curiosity.
0:42:29All right.
0:42:31Let me take another break here and thank our next sponsor.
0:42:35First time sponsor on the show.
0:42:37And it's a new app.
0:42:38I think it just came out last month.
0:42:39I've been using it now for a couple days knowing the sponsorship is coming up.
0:42:43It is called Quip.
0:42:44Q-U-I-P.
0:42:46Quip is a beautifully designed clipboard manager and text expander that feels like something Apple might have built.
0:42:54It looks and feels very Apple-y.
0:42:56It is a native app for Mac OS, iOS, and iPad OS with fast, seamless iCloud sync.
0:43:04Most clipboard managers become a dumping ground.
0:43:06They save everything you copy, whether you want them to or not.
0:43:09Quip solves this with two very powerful features.
0:43:13One of them is that if you want, you can only copy on a specific shortcut.
0:43:18So in other words, if you want, if you only want to copy to your Quip sometimes, you could set it to a custom shortcut like Shift-Command-C instead of Command-C.
0:43:29And only when you use that does it go to Quip.
0:43:32And your regular Command-C copies don't.
0:43:35I think that's a pretty cool feature for people who don't want to copy everything to their clipboard manager.
0:43:40But I do.
0:43:41To me, that's the whole point of a clipboard manager is everything I've copied, I would like to have access to.
0:43:48And they have that as a feature, too.
0:43:50It's like a toggle.
0:43:51So I have it set to always copy everything on my Mac.
0:43:54Command-C, it goes right to Quip.
0:43:56The other thing that it does, and I think it's the first one.
0:43:59I've used a bunch of clipboard managers, a bunch over the years.
0:44:02And one of the things that annoys me about a lot of them is that they limit how far back the clipboard history goes.
0:44:09And I think that just sort of stems from 20, 25, 30 years ago or longer when memory was tighter, storage was tighter.
0:44:17And people thought it was weird to have a utility that remembered everything you put on your clipboard.
0:44:23And it said, I better only be like 100 or something like that.
0:44:25Quip, you can set it to like only remember a week.
0:44:29A month or forever.
0:44:31And now the apps only come out for a month.
0:44:33But that's what I would set it to is forever.
0:44:35Because I would love to remember everything I copied from a year ago and just have it available in search.
0:44:40And it doesn't get in any way to have that massive history because what you see when you invoke Quip is just your most recent copies in order, top to bottom.
0:44:50It also includes something they call super shortcuts.
0:44:52It's a lightweight but powerful text expansion engine that works anywhere.
0:44:57You don't need extra cloud accounts or scripting or anything like that to do it.
0:45:02You can just set up custom shortcuts that you want to remember and have them expand anywhere you type.
0:45:07Quip intelligence is their feature to use secure on-device AI to keep your clipboard clean and useful.
0:45:15It automatically filters out junk.
0:45:16So if you have tracking links or if you copy something like a password, it uses AI to identify it and not keep that in your memory.
0:45:23And you can turn on a feature to intelligently categorize your copies.
0:45:28So you could have an intelligent feature that recognizes code snippets.
0:45:32So when you copy programming code or HTML or CSS code, it'll automatically recognize that.
0:45:39And then in the Quip interface, you could quick filter.
0:45:41Just show me the code examples that I've copied recently, and it'll just filter to them.
0:45:45It really works great.
0:45:47It's a very, very clever feature for filtering the whole history.
0:45:50Quip is private by design.
0:45:52It does sync between devices, but everything, including AI, runs locally on your device.
0:45:58And the sync only works via iCloud.
0:46:01So the security and privacy of iCloud protects the syncing between your devices.
0:46:06You don't need to...
0:46:07There are no accounts to sign up for.
0:46:08There are no ads, no data tracking.
0:46:10It's all as secure as iCloud itself.
0:46:13You can try Quip completely free for 14 days.
0:46:16After that, you can buy it once or subscribe for an annual fee.
0:46:20It is up to you.
0:46:21I've been using it all week.
0:46:23It is great, and it syncs over to the iPhone and iPad.
0:46:28It uses a keyboard extension, so you have a custom keyboard for Quip in those apps.
0:46:32So you can copy stuff on the Mac, go over to your iPhone, switch to the Quip keyboard, and paste any of the items that you've recently copied on your Mac right there on your phone.
0:46:41Where do you go to find out more?
0:46:43Go to BZGapps.com.
0:46:49That's the developer.
0:46:50BZGapps.com slash Quip.
0:46:53BZGapps slash Quip.
0:46:56Go check it out.
0:46:57Great new app for the Mac, iPhone, and iPad.
0:47:01All right, I guess that brings us to the meat of the show, Louis, which is the OS.
0:47:06I wish there was a better name for them.
0:47:08I have been calling them the OS 26 apps.
0:47:11OS 26.
0:47:11Yeah, there's no word for collectively calling this release.
0:47:15I've been calling it the 26 release of Apple.
0:47:20I don't know what to do with everything.
0:47:21That's weird.
0:47:22I will say this.
0:47:25And I just did an episode last week with Jason Snell, and we talked about the transparency and legibility of liquid glass specifically, not the UI of these systems overall or the liquid glass scheme overall, but just sort of the legibility and the sort of tweaking that we've obviously seen Apple do through the first four betas as we record.
0:47:54And that tweaking was inevitable.
0:47:57No matter how good a job Apple did or how polished it was come June, once they let it out in the world, this sort of change always needs a lot of tweaking in the beta period between June and September when these things ship.
0:48:11Hold on.
0:48:15Wait.
0:48:15I want to question that premise for a second because I'm curious.
0:48:18I'm curious.
0:48:18I don't know how good your memory is about some of this stuff.
0:48:23But if you go back to, I'm not questioning it.
0:48:26I'm just curious.
0:48:27Could the betas, some of that, some of what happens during the betas just kind of becomes nothing because it's not relevant after the release.
0:48:35But if you think back to like Tiger era, did the UI change a lot during developer betas?
0:48:42Yeah, no, not really.
0:48:44I think I was.
0:48:45There was.
0:48:46Don't get me wrong.
0:48:47Don't get me wrong.
0:48:47When they initially announced Tiger, I don't know if you remember this, but I do vividly.
0:48:51But they had like end caps on the menu bar, like the left side of the Apple logo and the right side with spotlight were like the full height, full like blue aqua caps.
0:49:03Oh, yeah, yeah.
0:49:04And it was like that.
0:49:04It was so iconic.
0:49:06And then that didn't ship.
0:49:07They were like parentheses almost.
0:49:10Right.
0:49:10Yes, yes, yes.
0:49:11Yeah.
0:49:11Yeah.
0:49:11And so it's so interestingly, like that sort of thing didn't happen.
0:49:15And so that did happen during the beta phase.
0:49:18But I don't know how much like beta like software Apple releases changed that much, like the UI changing much as it does today.
0:49:28You're right, though, that now like it always seems to change a lot.
0:49:31There's a lot of tweaking.
0:49:32There's a lot of updating that could just because be because of the scale that Apple's at right now.
0:49:37They have more people looking at it and more people scrutinizing about it.
0:49:40I don't know.
0:49:41Tiger.
0:49:42I just for those who don't remember, I have pulled up my little note with it.
0:49:47because I remember a lot of the older names better.
0:49:49Yeah.
0:49:50You asked how my memory is.
0:49:51And I don't know.
0:49:51I don't think it's just aging.
0:49:53I think it's because when there's only been five versions of Mac OS X, it's easier to tell them apart.
0:50:01And then when you get up to around 2015 and it's which one was El Capitan.
0:50:04Yeah, if you're like Puma, Jaguar, Panther, Tiger, you're like, yeah, I know all of these.
0:50:08I know the year they came out.
0:50:10Right.
0:50:10Yeah.
0:50:10So Tiger was 10.4.
0:50:12April came out in April 2005.
0:50:15So about two years before the iPhone and four years after 10.0 came out.
0:50:22And that's about five years after Aqua, which was unveiled with the Mac OS X public beta in 2000.
0:50:31So it's like five years.
0:50:33I'm going to count that for Aqua, even though it was a full year as a public beta.
0:50:38Yeah, about five years in.
0:50:39And it felt like Tiger was really where it got dialed in.
0:50:43I think so, too.
0:50:44You know, and probably peaked.
0:50:47I have to, you know, agree with the masses.
0:50:49I know it's the most popular release, I think, ever for multiple reasons.
0:50:55Stability, the whole, hey, we're not adding features, even though they did actually add a bunch of features.
0:51:01But Snow Leopard, 10.6, which came out in 2009.
0:51:04But those years from 2005 to 2009 were very good years for the Mac.
0:51:10You're totally, absolutely right.
0:51:13That is exactly the time period where you said it right.
0:51:16They dialed it in.
0:51:17They were refining things.
0:51:19They were really trying to.
0:51:20And I think that's like, you're talking about, like, refining, like, the UI through the beta phase.
0:51:25They were refining, like, the UI over years, right?
0:51:29And that really was, like, fairly significant because it was, like, they were identifying all of the things where it was, like, was this too much?
0:51:36Was this too little?
0:51:36And they were, like, making those changes in yearly releases.
0:51:40I would even stretch that heyday all the way to 2011, which is when Lion came out and maybe things started going haywire again.
0:51:48But that's because Snow Leopard was the version from August 2009 until July 2011.
0:51:55So there were two.
0:51:56And those years are not a coincidence, right?
0:51:58That those years when Apple and Steve Jobs and Apple's top talent, Scott Forstall, and the key designers and engineers who they picked to work on the iPhone and then the iPad.
0:52:16Their collective attention was sort of off the Mac, right?
0:52:19I mean, there's no question about it.
0:52:21I mean, I don't even think it's really up for debate.
0:52:23They were shifting off of the Mac into other things.
0:52:25But in an odd, counterintuitive way, that was very good for the Mac platform because it was like, I would have to guess that's because some of those designers that were, like, they were the Mac designers stayed with that.
0:52:40And you have other people that were worrying about, like, the phone and stuff.
0:52:43Like, it broke off.
0:52:44Like, some of those designers that were working only on, like, platform Mac stuff moved to iOS and moved to, like, that's the touch interface stuff.
0:52:52But you have some of these people that were sticking around for this Mac stuff.
0:52:54And those are the people who they had to care about the Mac because these other people weren't, right?
0:52:59They were worried about iOS.
0:53:00And so almost, like, in the separation of these two teams, right, you have, like, more clarity on both of these as distinct operating systems.
0:53:09Whereas, like, now, like, ever since they've started to merge these, I don't want to say that they're trying to merge the actual operating systems, but merging the styles of these operating systems, I think that's when we end up with, like, holes in there where it's, like, what was good for one system is not necessarily good for another.
0:53:25Yeah.
0:53:25Right?
0:53:26I mean, like, yeah.
0:53:28And they've been very consistent.
0:53:30I keep bringing it up.
0:53:32What other people do, too, is sort of a very memorable moment.
0:53:36I forget exactly which year, but around 2017, I think it was largely fueled.
0:53:45I think people had the idea.
0:53:46I think casual thinkers about these platforms often think, well, wait a minute.
0:53:51If the iPad can go to an 11-inch screen and it has these apps like Safari and Mail and Notes and the Mac has 11-inch screens and has apps like Mail and Safari and Notes, shouldn't they just be one operating system, you know?
0:54:05I mean, because we have so many real-life conspiracy theory nuts who are literally running the United States government at the moment.
0:54:15But it's sort of the Apple nerd conspiracy nut thinking of, oh, Apple's going to get rid of the Mac and replace it with the iPad.
0:54:24And they had that one commercial that was like, hey, what is a computer about showing a teenage girl who's just using her iPad for everything?
0:54:33And the idea is that the iPad is something other than a computer.
0:54:37That commercial always bothered me.
0:54:40It is a computer.
0:54:41It is a very different type of computer in a lot of ways, and I can totally see why some people like it better and why it might be forward-thinking in a lot of ways.
0:54:49But it's still a computer, right?
0:54:51It's like trying to say a microwave oven is not an oven.
0:54:55Yeah, maybe those – I don't know.
0:54:57Is the implication there – was the implication that, like, kids just aren't familiar with that word anymore, even though the iPad is technically a computer, that they just don't use that word anymore?
0:55:07Yeah, that it's not cool.
0:55:09Yeah, maybe.
0:55:09What's a computer?
0:55:10Like, I don't know.
0:55:11I don't know.
0:55:12And then Tim Cook had an interview somewhere, or maybe it wasn't even an interview, but he just – at some point, Tim Cook said in public that the iPad is our best expression of the future of computing.
0:55:26People took that too literally as, oh, if Tim Cook says it's Apple's vision of the best expression of the future of computing, it means they're going to make all their computers work like the iPad.
0:55:38And that's not how Tim Cook talks, right?
0:55:40Like, if you had taken Tim Cook when he said that and five minutes later asked him a question about the Mac, he would say the Mac has never been stronger and it's never been – because that's – he's just so – he's a cheerleader.
0:55:52Even though his demeanor is sort of taciturn, he's an endless cheerleader for whatever Apple product he's talking about.
0:56:01And so you get him talking about the iPad, he's going to say, yes, it's the future of all computing.
0:56:06Well, I mean, well, I would say that they're in a little bit of a tough spot regarding that sort of, like, projection of, like, how they see all these products because they will say that – they will say the nicest thing they can about any one of these products, right?
0:56:20They're going to be like, well, the Mac is absolutely the best computer that you can buy.
0:56:24They're going to say that the iPad is the best expression of computing that we see.
0:56:27They're going to say, oh, well, the Vision OS is, like, how we see computing in the future, right?
0:56:31They're going to say the truism, like, about whatever it is.
0:56:36God bless him because Jaws is the one guy who will say – and he always says it like it's half a joke, but you kind of know he means it, and it plays into people's cynical thinking about Apple.
0:56:46But I think when Joanna Stern was interviewing him and Craig at WWDC, I know he said it on my show in years past, but you get him talking about the differences between these platforms, and he'll say, you know, there's an easy solution to that.
0:56:58Just buy a Mac and an iPad.
0:57:01In some sense, yeah, duh, Apple wants you to buy a Mac and an iPad, but it doesn't necessarily mean they're conspiring to hold back elements.
0:57:09I know that's what so many people think explains why Macs don't have touchscreens yet.
0:57:15Look, I think everyone would be crazy if they really think that Apple has tried out touchscreen Macs.
0:57:21Come on.
0:57:22Let's see for a second.
0:57:23This definitely happened, right?
0:57:25They already know.
0:57:28They tried this out.
0:57:29They're looking into it.
0:57:30They're always thinking about it.
0:57:32And I don't think people who think that are really thinking through, well, who then is that fooling?
0:57:38Do you really think there exists anybody who says, I think my computing needs would be fully met by a MacBook, fully, except I really want at least one bigger than a phone computer that I can touch?
0:57:52Yeah, yeah, I don't know.
0:57:53Well, I think I said this before, and I don't know.
0:57:57Feel free to disagree with me.
0:57:59But my thinking is people have room for two primary devices, right?
0:58:03You can have your Mac and your phone, right?
0:58:06And then you can sometimes use an iPad, right?
0:58:09Or you can sometimes use a Vision Pro or whatever, right?
0:58:12But you're not using three things in equal measure.
0:58:15Nobody is doing that, right?
0:58:18Or if you do, it's sort of like having two families.
0:58:22You know what I mean?
0:58:23I don't know.
0:58:24You're like, don't get me wrong.
0:58:27I think there's people that use their iPad a lot more when they're, like, relaxing versus, like, when they're working, right?
0:58:33Like, they're working, so I'm on their Mac.
0:58:35But if they're, like, on vacation, they're using their iPad, right?
0:58:38I totally get that, like, that kind of person.
0:58:40I get that, but I just don't think that, like, more devices – I don't know how many people are using a Mac in equal measure to their iPad.
0:58:49I don't know who those people are.
0:58:50Like, do you use your iPad a lot?
0:58:52No.
0:58:53And I'm not trying to throw it under the bus because I do like it for what it is, but I kind of –
0:59:01And part of it, too, is my personal iPad.
0:59:05I've got it right here.
0:59:06I do read – I love it for when I'm on the podcast so that I can keep looking at you on the Mac and I don't overlap it.
0:59:12But I use it for, like, the show notes and things so I can look off screen here.
0:59:16But it is totally secondary to me.
0:59:19And once I totally gave up on that, that it is only secondary, I felt like my productivity resurged.
0:59:27I felt like the more I tried to do some of my work, like, maybe I'll work on my iPad until noon, and then afternoon is when I'll go downstairs to my office and work on my Mac.
0:59:37I felt – I said this.
0:59:40I was on Mike Hurley's Cortex show talking.
0:59:43He interviewed me about how I work and how I do what I do.
0:59:46And I'm a procrastinator by nature, and I felt the more I tried to use my iPad for work part of the day, the more it made my procrastination worse because there were so many things where I'd get to that.
1:00:01Oh, I should post that to Daring Fireball, but I'd really like to do that.
1:00:04It would be so much easier on my Mac than to do it here because I'd like to add a lot of links to this article.
1:00:11I want to link a bunch of things, and switching back and forth from an editing view to the browser to copy the links and put them in is so much easier on a Mac.
1:00:18I could arrange them side by side on my big display.
1:00:21And so I found myself, like, instead of doing the thing on my iPad, I'd be, like, putting it into the Things app or some other to-do system.
1:00:31You're preparing to do the thing for later.
1:00:34Right, yeah, you're like, why are we always preparing all the time?
1:00:37Just go, right?
1:00:38I've said that on the interview with Mike, and it's been clarifying for me as a way to be more productive.
1:00:44And the iPad, for me, and the tools I use, and the way I work, and the level of unthinking, I don't have to think about it, proficiency I have on the Mac, command tabbing between apps, command tilde-ing between two windows in the same app.
1:01:03Wait, wait, wait, command tilde goes through apps?
1:01:07I did not know that.
1:01:08Yeah, yeah, yeah.
1:01:09Open up multiple windows.
1:01:10Are you fucking with me right now?
1:01:11Are you totally serious?
1:01:12No, it's been there for, like, 25 years.
1:01:16Jesus Christ.
1:01:17Although I think they got rid of the keyboard shortcut.
1:01:23I think they don't have the menu item anymore.
1:01:24It used to be a standard item in the window menu.
1:01:26I see.
1:01:27Oh, I see.
1:01:28But you're saying it still works, but maybe it doesn't.
1:01:30And shift, command tilde will go the opposite direction.
1:01:33So if you have multiple windows open.
1:01:35All right, I'm going to give this a try.
1:01:36You command tilde through them, although it doesn't seem to work in Chrome.
1:01:42Shocker.
1:01:43So maybe they have something mapped up to that instead.
1:01:46Yeah.
1:01:47I don't know.
1:01:48But I don't know.
1:01:50But I just have things.
1:01:52Well, it's second nature to you, right?
1:01:54Like, using the Mac, you fully, like, understand and comprehend it, right?
1:01:58Whereas, like, iPad, even though you're familiar with it, it's a little foreign to you because
1:02:03it's not the way that you grew up.
1:02:04But that's the thing.
1:02:05I think some of this stuff is generational.
1:02:07I think maybe that's why that, like, that ad about what is a computer, like, makes sense
1:02:11for younger generations because younger generations who maybe never really used computers in the
1:02:16way that we did, right?
1:02:18They're using, like, iPads growing up and iPhones growing up, right?
1:02:22And so that's their, like, thing that they're most proficient in.
1:02:25Maybe they feel more comfortable in that.
1:02:27But, I mean, almost every task, every task I can do way better on my Mac.
1:02:32The only thing I can't do is, like, sketch.
1:02:33If I'm trying to, like, draw something, I'm like, well, that's where I guess I need my Apple
1:02:37Pencil, right?
1:02:38So I'm not out here being, like, I need my Apple Pencil on my Mac.
1:02:42I understand that's an iPad feature, right?
1:02:44And I know, I'm glad you mentioned that because that would be the one thing I don't think anybody
1:02:49would, I really don't think there's anybody who would say, I could do everything I want
1:02:52to do on my Mac, but I really want a second device that I can touch the screen.
1:02:56They might say that.
1:02:58They might say that about Pencil, right?
1:03:00That if you really do use the Pencil for illustration, they might say that.
1:03:03But the form factor of every existing Mac would be terrible for the Pencil.
1:03:07Yeah, right.
1:03:07Don't even, yeah, foldable bullshit.
1:03:12Do you remember, like, that era of, like, early tablet PCs, like, where it's, like, it
1:03:20was a laptop, but it swiveled around and then folded down so the backside of the display
1:03:24was against the keyboard?
1:03:25And so you have this really chunky, like, computer that you were using a pen really
1:03:30horribly with?
1:03:31I mean.
1:03:31And there were some that just folded all the way backwards.
1:03:34Yes, right.
1:03:35That's right.
1:03:36The bottom of the tablet was an actual functional keyboard.
1:03:39Although I think when you folded it that way, they turned the keyboard off so that you wouldn't
1:03:43get key presses.
1:03:44So you wouldn't get spurious inputs.
1:03:45Right.
1:03:45But imagine.
1:03:48I'm not super fussy about keeping my devices clean, but I'm not going to lay my keyboard
1:03:52upside down on a table.
1:03:53Right, right, right.
1:03:55Yes.
1:03:55And we have what form factor would those people want?
1:03:57And maybe they just don't.
1:03:58I mean, I think, like, I don't think anyone's really asking for Apple Pencil on the Mac,
1:04:03right?
1:04:04Well, look, people think they are.
1:04:05If someone at Apple figured out a decent way to do Apple Pencil on my Mac trackpad just
1:04:16in that case, I might be intrigued, but I don't know how they're going to do it on my screen.
1:04:21I don't need direct input, which is maybe why they won't do it.
1:04:24That's what I feel like there is, like, tablet companies, their whole business model anyway.
1:04:28Right.
1:04:29I feel like a lot of those complaints are from people who haven't thought things through.
1:04:38And it's fine.
1:04:39Oh, yeah, sure, sure.
1:04:40For people not to think things through.
1:04:41But that's Apple's job to think things through.
1:04:44Well, it's the same reason that every time you look at, like, oh, here's a concept version
1:04:48of the iPhone or the concept version of a new MacBook, it's like, yeah, you just, you
1:04:53drew something without consideration to, like, its actual use.
1:04:56It's like, good job.
1:04:57Like, I guess you made a pretty image, but it doesn't look like it actually would work in
1:05:02practice.
1:05:02It's easy to think about that stuff.
1:05:04I will also say before we move on, but that part of my frustration trying to use the iPad
1:05:11for work significantly was that the multitasking interface was so bad.
1:05:17And so if I ever tried it again, I'd probably be happier with iPadOS 26 and forward going
1:05:24forward.
1:05:24Well, isn't that the one thing they keep changing every release?
1:05:27They're like, okay, but this time really figured out multitasking.
1:05:30No, no, no, no.
1:05:31But really this time.
1:05:32And, like, they even introduced, what was that feature that they added even to the Mac
1:05:37where it, like, floats your window on the left?
1:05:39Yeah, what was that?
1:05:41I don't even know what that's called.
1:05:43It's still there.
1:05:44I try it out every once in a while.
1:05:46I'm like, no, not really.
1:05:50Actually, the dock is really good.
1:05:52Well, this gets us, though, to, and I feel like the long journey that the iPad has been
1:05:58on to get to the point of them doing the most obvious thing possible, which is where they've
1:06:04landed with iOS 26.
1:06:05And I think it's the single best, and I would say almost unambiguously good UI thing to come
1:06:13out of the OS 26 endeavor.
1:06:16And I will say, as another side note, now that we're six weeks after WWDC, I kind of
1:06:23thought this when it was just a rumor before WWDC that they were going to renumber all the
1:06:27OSs to next year, to 26.
1:06:29And I thought, I think that's going to work.
1:06:32I think once we get used to it, it's going to work.
1:06:35And I do think so.
1:06:36Six weeks in, as somebody whose job is to write about and talk about these things, it does make
1:06:43it so much easier.
1:06:44Talk about remembering, like, what the release was.
1:06:46I mean, we were just talking about how you don't know what years it is.
1:06:49And so it actually is really, it's a good touch point to actually know what year.
1:06:53But okay, so are they going to do with phones too?
1:06:56Is it going to be like iPhone 26?
1:06:58No, I don't think so.
1:06:59Really?
1:06:59I'd be shocked if they did.
1:07:01Because they don't want to emphasize, here's the thing, if you think about it, think this
1:07:07through.
1:07:07They don't want to emphasize the age of older hardware devices, right?
1:07:14That they sell.
1:07:15I don't.
1:07:16Right, right.
1:07:16They don't.
1:07:17And that's one reason they don't number any of the other devices before iPhone.
1:07:21It is.
1:07:22I don't know.
1:07:22Maybe they do have a plan to stop numbering iPhones.
1:07:26Right.
1:07:27Maybe in general, and start doing like the Mac thing or the mid-2026 in parentheses off
1:07:31Yes, but they're not going to call it iPhone 26.
1:07:34Because then next year when they're still selling, like the way that you can go in the store and
1:07:39buy an iPhone 15 right now, they don't want to have you buying one that looks like the year
1:07:45is old.
1:07:45It's just the number that's old.
1:07:46It doesn't work.
1:07:48Whereas the software, they correctly expect people to keep updating automatically when the
1:07:55automatic software updates.
1:07:56So you're not left behind.
1:07:59Like next year when iOS 27 comes out, your current iPhone won't be left behind.
1:08:03You'll get iOS 27 too.
1:08:05It's different.
1:08:06It's one of those things that's different about software than hardware.
1:08:09I do think it's weird that we're up to like iPhone 17 and they're just going to keep numbering
1:08:14At some point, this numbering is going to start feeling really stupid.
1:08:18I mean, like at some point, we're going to be like, all right, you know what?
1:08:21Call it in.
1:08:22We don't need this anymore.
1:08:23And the other thing that I get confused about now, I always have, is that the numbers of
1:08:30the iPhones don't correspond to the numbers of the Apple Silicon chips, right?
1:08:35They're up to the A18 now or something.
1:08:39I don't even know.
1:08:40I don't know what those numbers are.
1:08:42Right.
1:08:42But they're so, but it's worse because they're so close.
1:08:45Yeah.
1:08:46Right.
1:08:46Right.
1:08:47Yeah.
1:08:47I don't know.
1:08:48I mean, they have been a little willy nilly with numbering phones before.
1:08:52I mean, iPhone 3G to 3GS was like a very odd thing for them to do.
1:08:58And then they went 4, 4S.
1:08:59And they were doing like every other year, they had like the whole S scheme.
1:09:02And I feel like, yeah, at some point, they're going to have to realize that like this entire
1:09:07scheme is like not going to work well for the future.
1:09:10And maybe that means that they put things in parentheticals, but I don't know.
1:09:13But here's my question.
1:09:14When you go to the Apple store and you see like 10 iPhones in front of you, and if they're all
1:09:17just called iPhone, that's not very helpful either.
1:09:20So like they need some distinguishing factor to be able to sell them as different products.
1:09:25Yeah.
1:09:26So I, because the iPhone is just weird and different.
1:09:29They did have a system for those early years, the system, which they've never officially,
1:09:35but you could just see that they followed it was if the iPhone looks the same as the one
1:09:43the year before, no matter how significantly upgraded the internals might be, the name was
1:09:49just add S.
1:09:50So the iPhone 3GS looked exactly like a 3G.
1:09:54And how do you do that though?
1:09:56In a system where the last four releases almost looked the same.
1:09:59Like most people's eyes, it would.
1:10:01I mean, yeah.
1:10:02How do you do it now though?
1:10:03And you can't.
1:10:03But that was because they also knew the roadmap.
1:10:06Yeah.
1:10:07Well, that's true.
1:10:08That's true.
1:10:08By the time they were deciding, okay, let's just call this third iPhone, the 3GS.
1:10:13They knew that the next year was going to be the iPhone 4, which was like, whoa, this is
1:10:19radical.
1:10:20It's got a retina screen.
1:10:21It's glass sandwich on front and back.
1:10:24It's got the steel sides.
1:10:25And by the time they named the 4S, they knew that the next year was the 5.
1:10:30They knew that they were like, oh, we've got radical, easily, like totally distinctive,
1:10:37looks not like a little new, but totally new hardware every two years.
1:10:42And then that sort of broke down after the iPhone 6S.
1:10:47Because the iPhone 7 looked, it really should have been like the 6S S.
1:10:51Right, right, right.
1:10:52Well, this is, yeah, this is where it became a problem.
1:10:54And then we get to like where, like where they were like, hmm, 8, 9, 10 was like a really
1:10:59difficult, weird situation.
1:11:00Then like iPhone 9 just never existed.
1:11:02No, never existed.
1:11:03iPhone 10, like their justification for it was like, oh, it just jumped ahead in the future.
1:11:08It's like, oh, okay, all right, sure.
1:11:11It's very funny.
1:11:13It really is that they just skipped 9 and the iPhone 8 looked like the 7, which looked like
1:11:19the 6S, which looked like the 6, right?
1:11:21Like the 6, 6S, 7, and 8.
1:11:23There was a system, you're right, for a very short period of time where things, you could
1:11:29logically understand like how that worked.
1:11:32And it worked, you're right, because they had the roadmap.
1:11:34But I think as soon as, maybe they just settled on what it's supposed to be.
1:11:39I mean, like after we had the whole rounded phones, then they went back to basically, I
1:11:44mean, what we have now is basically like with the iPhone 4 design, right?
1:11:48That's, you can look back at this and see a direct line from that.
1:11:51Yeah, yeah.
1:11:52Glass sandwich front and back, steel or metal side, right?
1:11:57And it used to be steel, and then it was aluminum, and now it's titanium, but, or aluminum
1:12:01on the non-pro models.
1:12:02But it's basically the back to the iPhone 4, 4S.
1:12:07And we're getting distracted.
1:12:10I feel like we're obviously avoiding talking about this.
1:12:13I'm trying to hit the three-hour mark with you, John.
1:12:15No, I want to, this is summertime.
1:12:18We've got to take it easy.
1:12:19Two hours are bust.
1:12:21What did I joke with you the other day?
1:12:23Oh, I asked you, I invited you to be on the show, and you said, your three-hour podcast.
1:12:27And I pointed you to a Todd Vaziri tweet where he periodically updates the average length of
1:12:34episodes of this podcast.
1:12:35And I pointed out correctly, very few episodes have gone over three hours.
1:12:39Yeah, it's, I don't know, 10 or something total.
1:12:41Yeah, it's not that bad.
1:12:43David Hanemeyer Hanson was on, there's a guy named Lex Fridman, not to be confused with
1:12:47Lex Fridman, who's in the podcast circles of this, was on his podcast, and they talked
1:12:54for over six hours.
1:12:55Jesus.
1:12:56All right, well, let's not do that.
1:12:58No, I physically couldn't.
1:13:00All right, you have been blogging about Liquid Glass and these OS26 OS updates, and you have
1:13:07a lot of thoughts.
1:13:08First, let's just, let's say this.
1:13:10Here we are over, well over an hour into the show.
1:13:13Let's talk about your personal background in this.
1:13:15I assume a lot of people listening are familiar with your work, but they may not be, it's the
1:13:20first time you've been on the show with me.
1:13:21And I hate this line of thinking that people criticize the UI of Liquid Glass, and then the
1:13:30people who want to defend it will say, well, who are you to criticize this interface?
1:13:36What interfaces have you ever designed?
1:13:39And I think this idea that to criticize a practice, you have to be a practitioner is
1:13:44nonsense.
1:13:44It can certainly help, but Roger Ebert himself was not a filmmaker.
1:13:49He's, in my opinion, the most accomplished film critic of the 20th century into the 21st.
1:13:56And if you wanted to argue as Pauline Kael or whoever else you think might have been one
1:14:00of the top film critics, almost none of them were filmmakers themselves.
1:14:04Now, Quentin Tarantino is a very good film critic and has very interesting taste in movies
1:14:10and is himself a very renowned and accomplished filmmaker.
1:14:13You can be, but you don't need to be.
1:14:16But for anybody who feels that way, you are an accomplished both UI designer and icon artist.
1:14:23I don't know what else.
1:14:25You'd think, but I guess then I wonder, like, does that mean that people qualify me like in
1:14:30that way?
1:14:30They're like, oh, okay, well, this guy knows what he's talking about.
1:14:33Now we'll definitely, no, they're going to like discredit it for some other reason.
1:14:36But speak about your history in this field, like where you've worked and the things you've
1:14:40worked on.
1:14:41Yeah, so I mean, I guess I was just, I mean, when I was a kid, I was just doing a bunch
1:14:45of like Mac customization things.
1:14:49So I was starting to make icons on my own.
1:14:51And I started making iPhone apps like in 2007 before 2008, before the App Store existed, right?
1:14:58Before we had an SDK.
1:15:00I mean, when jailbreak was the only option, right?
1:15:03So like I was making iPhone icons then.
1:15:07And I don't think there's many people who are still doing it from that time.
1:15:11And I don't think there were many people at the time that were doing it anyway.
1:15:14Kind of ever since I've been making iPhone apps.
1:15:17I worked at Apple for only a year and a half, but I worked on iTunes, which I feel like is
1:15:24a big deal at Apple.
1:15:25But I don't know.
1:15:26Like I was working on the shoulders of giants there.
1:15:29I mean, iTunes was an established product.
1:15:32I mean, what time I got to, what year was that?
1:15:34Yeah, that was 2010 to 2011.
1:15:37I mean, that was the timeframe we were talking about, about like that, that time period where
1:15:43it was culminating, right?
1:15:45And I mean, and I say this, I say this only because maybe people remember that period of
1:15:51time.
1:15:52But in 2011 there, that's when Steve died.
1:15:54And so there was like, everything that kind of led up to that moment was fully Steve's control.
1:16:00And then after that, it wasn't, right?
1:16:03I'm not saying that everything went to shit immediately after he died.
1:16:06I'm not making a comment about that.
1:16:07But that's the period of time I was there was before that happened.
1:16:11And you, for better or for worse, I would say most people probably agree it was largely
1:16:16for better, lesser, for worse.
1:16:18And we can disagree over where that line is.
1:16:21But everything Apple produced was Steve approved.
1:16:23Right.
1:16:25I mean, at that time, yeah, either, either it was, either it was Steve approved or like
1:16:30he had a lieutenant that was basically doing all of that kind of approval.
1:16:34I mean, don't get me wrong.
1:16:34Like Steve wasn't approving literally everything.
1:16:37There was like, there were certain products and certain facets of features that like he wouldn't
1:16:42necessarily bother to do.
1:16:44I think he entirely entrusted like the GarageBand team to just build GarageBand without like
1:16:48his intervention.
1:16:49But, but there were certain products like Mail, iTunes, where he had like a ton of opinions
1:16:55and insight and like vision for.
1:16:57And I think he knew what those products, what he wanted them to be.
1:17:01And so I think he was way more hands-on and yeah, was approving like, like visual design
1:17:06for that product at that time.
1:17:09Yeah.
1:17:09And he's, he's a complex, he was a very complex person.
1:17:14I met him twice.
1:17:15I can't say I knew him well, but just studying his career, reading all the books and, and it's,
1:17:21it's very obvious, but he's misunderstood in some ways where if your viewpoint of him is
1:17:26only superficial, you, you think of him as a singular genius control freak who micromanaged
1:17:34everything and then they're like every single icon, every toolbar icon inside every app went
1:17:40before him and he scrutinized.
1:17:41And that's a, it wasn't how it worked.
1:17:43B was impossible.
1:17:45There's, it was too much, even, even 15 years ago, the scope of Apple's work was too much
1:17:51for any one person who, you know, from, he couldn't, he literally could not QA everything.
1:17:57That's insane.
1:17:58Right.
1:17:58Right.
1:17:59Like it was already too big, but I'm going to make a note and try to find it, but he spoke
1:18:03about this and a lot of the things he spoke about, he said multiple times in slightly different
1:18:07ways, but he was consistent about it.
1:18:09But he said at one point that the reason you hire smart people isn't to tell them what to
1:18:15do.
1:18:15You hire smart people because they're smart and they will figure out what to do.
1:18:19And so the idea wasn't that the people designing the apps he cared about most had to might, he
1:18:25had to micromanage every single design decision they make.
1:18:27The idea was he put you in charge of, put somebody in charge of iTunes or the iTunes interface.
1:18:35And it's, it's the terminology inside Apple is directly responsible individual, the DRI.
1:18:41And somebody is the DRI for this.
1:18:43And whether Steve Jobs was personally like week to week looking at the changes or not, the DRI
1:18:51knew Steve might at some point come and look at it and they would have to answer to his
1:18:55questions and opinions on how it was.
1:18:57And so whether he was looking at it, oh, we're going to do a major new version of GarageBand
1:19:01or something like that.
1:19:02And maybe he wasn't looking at it every week, but whoever was in charge of it and was looking
1:19:06at it every week knew at any week, Steve might come in and look at it.
1:19:10And so it needed to meet his standards.
1:19:12So it was Steve approved, even if Steve not micromanaged, right?
1:19:16Right.
1:19:16Yeah, I think that's true.
1:19:17Yeah.
1:19:18And iTunes was certainly.
1:19:19I mean, he's still putting, he's still putting it on stage.
1:19:21He's still going up in front of it, talking about it.
1:19:23So he's got to feel like confident about it.
1:19:25I mean, I have to assume that's the case, but yeah.
1:19:27But iTunes, I mean, definitely.
1:19:28So including at iTunes, so you did what you did like an iTunes app icon, right?
1:19:33Yeah.
1:19:34Yeah.
1:19:34I mean, actually, so my responsibility is in the group at the time.
1:19:37So when I was hired, it was called consumer apps and I was working on a bunch of things.
1:19:42There was like half the org was like iTunes, remote, trailers, Apple TV, that sort of stuff.
1:19:48And the other half of the org was like, I like stuff.
1:19:53So iPhoto, iMovie, GarageBand, DVD, like that sort of stuff.
1:19:58And I was working on almost all of those things.
1:20:01And iBooks kind of became part of the whole trailers, iTunes thing.
1:20:04Like, if you think about like, it's just like the iTunes store kind of bubble.
1:20:09And then there was like everything, the creation tools, right?
1:20:12And so I was working on iPhoto visual design.
1:20:15I was working on iMovie visual design.
1:20:16That was for like Mac and iPad.
1:20:18I was working on, yeah, the iTunes stuff.
1:20:20And yeah, the iTunes app icon also.
1:20:23Yeah.
1:20:24But the one that everyone loves, right?
1:20:26Yes, it is.
1:20:27The one that everyone thought was the best.
1:20:28Yeah.
1:20:31I'm not just saying it because you're on the show, but I kind of think that's true.
1:20:35That if anybody's been using iTunes for 20 some years, and you've got one icon with a blue glow.
1:20:43I mean, if I'm the one giving the opinion, I think the one that was the best was the green music notes on the CD.
1:20:49But I mean, you can't do that forever, right?
1:20:52I mean, like, at some point, I mean, Steve was right.
1:20:55You can't have the CD be there anymore.
1:20:56It doesn't make any sense.
1:20:58Right.
1:20:58Yeah.
1:20:59All right.
1:21:01But that gets to it, right?
1:21:02That was part of the motivation for changing the icon is, hey, we're not selling CD.
1:21:08We're not ripping CDs anymore.
1:21:09And you could if you had, you know, but they were moving away from putting the CD drives, the DVD drives in the computers.
1:21:17CDs were not an important part of the music story, I think is like the way to put it.
1:21:23Or the computing story.
1:21:25Computing story.
1:21:26It wasn't a part of Apple anymore.
1:21:27I mean, they were just not doing that.
1:21:29So, yeah, I mean, at the time, I guess that, yeah, we don't need that.
1:21:33They managed that transition aggressively, which is what they do when they smell that the puck is going a different way.
1:21:41They go there aggressively.
1:21:42Compare and contrast with the game consoles that are still selling discs with games.
1:21:49And I know that there are the same reason that there, in theory, would be reasons to still put a DVD drive in a MacBook.
1:22:00Yeah.
1:22:01You could play an old thing.
1:22:02You could have everything.
1:22:03Well, it's like, you know, I think they, Apple thought that they were like, what if we just don't have SD card slots in our MacBooks?
1:22:09And then people were like, well, and then they were like, okay, all right, you guys are going to have those back.
1:22:12It's just, I mean, like CDs, I don't think anyone was, like, demanding that.
1:22:16And I don't think anyone who needs a CD or DVD drive cares that much about the fact that they have to have an external one.
1:22:23Fine.
1:22:23Who cares?
1:22:24That's not a problem.
1:22:25So.
1:22:26I remember, it's been a while at this point, but I remember long, long after MacBooks got much thinner than would support it, that there were so many standard PC laptops that still had the VGA port, which was just super old.
1:22:43Thick.
1:22:43Yeah.
1:22:43Super thick.
1:22:45It literally is one of those ports so old that it came with the two screws on the side.
1:22:48The screws on the side.
1:22:49I know.
1:22:49To hold it in place.
1:22:51Right.
1:22:52I would make fun of it occasionally when somebody would publish, some company would come out with a new laptop trying to be thin, but it was so thin that the VGA port looked ungodly weird because it was, like, almost somehow thicker than the laptop, which I know is impossible.
1:23:07Right.
1:23:07Yeah, yeah.
1:23:07They're going to, yeah, if there's feet on the bottom of the laptop, then they're going to eat up some of that space with the VGA port.
1:23:13They're going to, yeah, yeah, a million percent.
1:23:15And then I would get email from people saying, oh, but I work at a big, large university and all of our projectors are still VGA input only, and you won't believe how often, like, a lecture's about to start and nobody has a working dongle.
1:23:28But it's, like, the reason that some of that stuff goes away is because the product itself that you're using doesn't support it anymore.
1:23:35Right.
1:23:36If you don't have the VGA port on the laptop, suddenly you are going to have to upgrade the systems at the university, wherever you're like, but if you never have to.
1:23:43But there was a logical consistency there where we see the whole world is moving away from CDs and DVDs and discs in general, and we're not going to put these drives on our laptops anymore.
1:23:54And so why in the world would the iTunes icon be represented by musical notes in front of a disc?
1:24:01It's a logical consistency.
1:24:03It doesn't mean that the icon has to be realistic.
1:24:07Like, I was never a fan of the next icons, which went to me, like, too photorealistic.
1:24:15Like, they looked cool in a way because they were so, I don't know, 16-bit color or something.
1:24:22Yeah, we're talking about, like, next workstation, right?
1:24:24We're talking about those icons?
1:24:25We're like, yeah.
1:24:26Yeah, I mean, so I've been having a recent appreciation for those, though.
1:24:29I'm not going to say I, like, strongly disagree with you on this, but they were interesting because you're right.
1:24:35Like, they were so much more detailed than the stuff that kind of came before.
1:24:38They were bigger.
1:24:40I mean, the home icon had, like, bushes on it.
1:24:42It was, like, weird, right?
1:24:44And the folders were not just, like, a simple folder.
1:24:47They were, like, these brown-bounded folders with a strap around it.
1:24:51I mean, they were gratuitous.
1:24:53They, like, they were gratuitous.
1:24:54Million percent they were.
1:24:55But I don't know, there's something really charming about it.
1:24:57But I mean, at the time, like, when your computer, like, doesn't have so much visually going on.
1:25:04I mean, I do think that icons carry the weight of, like, visual identity.
1:25:08I mean, you mentioned that, like, icons are a kind of logo thing.
1:25:12And I think that when you have a system where, like, most of what you're doing is, like, text-based stuff, icons basically define what the system looks like.
1:25:21And I think Next, at the time, needed a different, like, approach to, like, how things would be so that people saw it and were, like, this is not what we were used to.
1:25:29There needs to be, like, if I think, and I think that's what we see, like, when Aqua came out, like, after that.
1:25:34I mean, we saw, like, Windows XP be very different from, like, Windows Classic in, like, 95, 98.
1:25:39Like, they were intentionally designing, like, icon systems and Y that looked distinct so that you could tell the difference.
1:25:45And that's the reason why that stuff happens, right?
1:25:47Yeah.
1:25:48Yeah, absolutely.
1:25:49Yeah, I'm not going to say I didn't have a brief period where I was – I never owned a Next computer, but there was a time where I – I know that there was a time where I installed some series of system extensions on my Mac to give me Next-style Windows and Next-style icons.
1:26:05And the Next-style Windows, I thought, looked cool longer than the Next-style icons.
1:26:11Those – it's not that –
1:26:12The black style bars?
1:26:13I saw them as cool.
1:26:14Yeah, it was not.
1:26:14Yeah, with the 3D buttons and stuff.
1:26:17Yeah.
1:26:17But it was very Steve Jobs-ian.
1:26:20It was, like, let's take these – the realism of these icons and the detail, like you said.
1:26:25The folders were not, like – they were, like, super – they were more like those – I don't know what you call those.
1:26:32They're, like, almost like a briefcase folder.
1:26:34Yeah, I know what you're talking about.
1:26:36Yeah, or, yeah, it's, like, either it had a strap or it had one of those kind of, like, strings that you, like, wrap around, like a legal binder sort of thing.
1:26:43Yeah, like, to tie the folder together.
1:26:46So that nothing could fall out the top of it.
1:26:48Because that was important for computers to not drop files, right?
1:26:51Right, and meanwhile, like, Windows and the standard classic macOS just had these super simple –
1:26:57They were file folders.
1:26:58They existed – exactly, yeah.
1:27:00It's like a rectangle with a tab in the folder.
1:27:02That all changed, right?
1:27:03Like, with Aqua and Windows XP, I mean, then they had – they were starting to be more metaphorical with folders.
1:27:10I mean, they were more literal before.
1:27:11They were, like – they were literal file folders before.
1:27:14And then they kind of became – I don't want to say abstract, but, yeah, metaphorical.
1:27:18They were, like, this is a folder.
1:27:19But no real folder exists with, like, pinstripes in, like, a translucent blue – I mean, now they're – I mean, we got clear files all the time now.
1:27:26It started a little, though, with classic macOS, and I'm not quite sure if that – I think sort of happened after Jobs came back to the company, and I don't know how much influence he had on it.
1:27:37But the way that once macOS 8 went all platinum, which was, like, the theme revolution in classic macOS, the icons were still blue, bluish-purple.
1:27:49I mean –
1:27:50Yeah, that bluish-purple, that indigo color.
1:27:52That very Mac –
1:27:54It is distinctively that color.
1:27:56Right.
1:27:57Yeah, that Mac is distinctively that color.
1:27:59That's – well, you posted about the Finder icon that I made, and that was exactly what I was getting at.
1:28:04Because, to me, the Finder icon should always be that, like, purplish-tinted blue, because that's what Mac is.
1:28:11But, like, even the platinum, like, quantum foam wallpaper that existed at the time was that tinted color, right?
1:28:18It was, like – it was that purple and that gray, that light gray.
1:28:22That's what made Mac Mac at the time.
1:28:24And so there was, like, on the classic macOS 9, macOS 8.5 era, the icons looked different than – and they looked more 3D than they did before.
1:28:35But they were still that classic Mac blue-purple, which real-world folders typically aren't.
1:28:41Yeah, you could go to a stationary store and find purple folders.
1:28:44But, and at the same time, Windows, like, even Windows 95, which, you know, supposedly was, like, the big, oh, now the UI is good on Windows, too, had manila folders.
1:28:54The most boring folder.
1:28:56Yeah, the most typical ones.
1:28:58Yes, yes.
1:28:59You're right.
1:28:59Like, so the macOS ones were a little bit metaphorical, but they were, like, what if they were normal but we made them?
1:29:05Which is actually a very Apple way of approaching something, right?
1:29:08Like, whereas I just think Windows is not like that, which is fine.
1:29:12It's just a totally different – yeah.
1:29:13Yeah, maybe this is a bad example.
1:29:16But, like, during COVID, remember when Apple came out with their own face mask design?
1:29:20Oh, that's right.
1:29:21Of course.
1:29:22Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, right.
1:29:23It didn't look like anybody else's.
1:29:25It was theirs.
1:29:25Right.
1:29:26Actually, another classic example is the fucking pizza box at Cafe Max, right?
1:29:31Oh, yeah.
1:29:31It's like a circle, right?
1:29:32It's like they could not tolerate having a normal fucking pizza box.
1:29:36They had to go invent one for themselves, right?
1:29:39Right, because somebody – it's a very Apple employee.
1:29:42It doesn't matter where you are in Apple, but it's the sort of people who've always been drawn to work at Apple and I think sort of draws someone like me to write about and talk about Apple or for you to work on Apple platforms and design for them is you see something and it annoys you and then all of a sudden it becomes an obsession.
1:30:01And somebody at Apple became annoyed by the way that pizza boxes have this fundamental problem where the middle of the pizza touches the top of the box and it kind of ruins the middle of the pizza.
1:30:13And it's like nobody wants to eat a pizza where the whole middle part is sort of smooshed and stuck to the top of the box.
1:30:19And even though we've all just generally accepted this, it was not tolerable for them, so they had to make it.
1:30:25And somebody like Domino's put a pizza, like a little plastic table in the middle and it sort of solves it.
1:30:33But somebody at Apple was like, no, no, we're going to design a box where this can't happen.
1:30:38And it's only for them.
1:30:40It's only – it's like you never see it outside of Apple.
1:30:43It's the only time you see it.
1:30:43Well, they don't run a chain of people.
1:30:45Yeah, I mean, I'm not – yeah, well, like, I love they fucking – I love they fucking patented it.
1:30:50Even if someone took that idea, is that just not better for the common good of the world?
1:30:56Like, why do you have to own that?
1:30:57You can let everyone have that.
1:30:59This is a long shot, but do you watch – happen to watch The Bear on Hulu?
1:31:03I do.
1:31:03Yeah, I do.
1:31:04I like that show.
1:31:05Yes.
1:31:05All right.
1:31:05So the premise of The Bear, for anybody who doesn't watch, is there was a family-owned – again, back to sandwiches, a Chicago sandwich shop called – what's it called?
1:31:16The Original Beef.
1:31:17Yeah, The Original Beef.
1:31:19And honestly, I've had Midwest beef sandwiches, and they're excellent.
1:31:23They are amazing, amazing sandwiches in general.
1:31:26And the ones that they made on the show looked really good, but it was like a lunch counter, hectic sandwich shop, family-owned.
1:31:34And long story short, it's the whole saga of Four Seasons is that one of the – the prodigal son of the family became, like, a renowned chef who had worked, like, in the French laundry in New York for several years.
1:31:48And he turns it into an ought-to-be-Michigan-starred fine-dining restaurant.
1:31:54Did you say Michigan-starred?
1:31:55Is that what you just said?
1:31:56Just Michigan-star?
1:31:57Michelin.
1:31:58Michelin-starred.
1:31:59That's right.
1:32:00Michelin-starred.
1:32:00Yeah, yeah.
1:32:01Sorry.
1:32:02Thank you, Louis.
1:32:03I like the idea of a Michigan-starred restaurant, though.
1:32:06I thought I didn't need that to be a thing.
1:32:08Well, I started thinking about Chicago, and it's close to –
1:32:12Yeah, go on, go on, go on.
1:32:13Go on with your story, yes.
1:32:14But in the premise of the show, it's fine dining, and they're struggling financially because it's so expensive, and the guy is trying to – I'm not spoiling anything, but he's trying to do this thing where instead of having a set menu every day, every day they come up with a new menu, or they have a series of 30 different menu items.
1:32:33And every day they pick eight of them, and it's making the place.
1:32:36But meanwhile, they're still running the sandwich operation out of the back of the restaurant.
1:32:40That's right.
1:32:40And it's killing it.
1:32:41And in fact, it's more profitable than ever because they got rid of the eat-in dining, and it's takeout only.
1:32:48They super optimized that part of the business, and it's running out of just the window.
1:32:52Yeah, it's running out of a window with four guys, and they're doing killer business.
1:32:58So wouldn't it be funny, although Apple stores –
1:33:01Oh, yeah.
1:33:01I hear where you're going with this.
1:33:02I love this so much.
1:33:03This is such a good idea, John.
1:33:05Who in Cupertino fucking needs this?
1:33:07They should be selling pizzas out of the back of Apple stores.
1:33:10Yeah.
1:33:11And they would never do that.
1:33:13No, but wouldn't that be amazing?
1:33:15Why wouldn't they do that on some location?
1:33:17That would just be a fun thing.
1:33:18Well, it is interesting because this is the dumbest thing.
1:33:21I can't believe we're talking about this.
1:33:23Well, they have the Welcome Center, right?
1:33:25And the Welcome Center has a cafe, right?
1:33:26And people can go there, right?
1:33:28So, like, technically, they're not – and they do have Cafe Max locations all over, right?
1:33:33Like, all over their campuses around the world, they have a Cafe Max.
1:33:36They are not – they are not not well-versed in running, like, this sort of operation.
1:33:41They could do this if they wanted to.
1:33:43Yep.
1:33:43Takeout only.
1:33:44I'm just going to say this.
1:33:47Cafe Max pizzas, they're actually really good.
1:33:49So that's one thing.
1:33:50I really miss those.
1:33:51I really miss them.
1:33:52The first time I got to eat – I haven't eaten at Cafe Max many times, but the first time I had the opportunity to – and I forget who I was there with, but – and they were like, you can have anything you want.
1:34:00We got to do this.
1:34:01We got to do that.
1:34:01I'm getting a pizza.
1:34:02I've heard about it.
1:34:03Right.
1:34:03Every time.
1:34:04I got the pizza, and it was excellent.
1:34:05And it's – I'm a pizza – open-minded about pizza, right?
1:34:10It's not an East Coast Italian-style pizza.
1:34:12It is a very West Coast California-style pizza.
1:34:15I also – I like Chicago deep dish-style pizza.
1:34:20Yeah, but do you like St. Louis-style pizza?
1:34:22This is where – yes.
1:34:23I'm open-minded about pizza, yeah.
1:34:25Okay, shut up, John.
1:34:26I'll bet – but I'll bet that the best places in St. Louis – I'll bet the best places I would love, right?
1:34:32Anything where you have some dough and tomato sauce and good cheese.
1:34:37And some kind of cheese.
1:34:38And made with care by somebody who's a real pain in the ass.
1:34:43Right, right.
1:34:44It's going to be tasty.
1:34:45But the Cafe Max pizzas are a very good version of the California pizza.
1:34:50And it is the kind of – and it's also, I think, very, very good, not coincidentally, for lunch.
1:34:56Whereas, you know, like a Chicago deep dish pizza, if you eat that for lunch, you're taking a nap.
1:35:02But you're in a food coma, yeah, a million percent.
1:35:04Yeah.
1:35:04I mean, that's the thing.
1:35:05I mean, so many of the lunch things – I mean, you know, why are we talking about Cafe Max?
1:35:09Because we want Apple to start selling pizzas out of the back of Apple stores.
1:35:13Yeah, I will say this.
1:35:14None of the other things – at the time, and admittedly, this was like 12 or 13 years ago.
1:35:19But, like, none of the other things at Cafe Max would I think they could sell outside of Apple.
1:35:23I don't think they're good enough for that.
1:35:25But, like, that, absolutely.
1:35:26I think they could do it.
1:35:28Here's my proposal.
1:35:31Here's who I think maybe should run it.
1:35:33Alan Dye.
1:35:35Move.
1:35:37God damn it, John.
1:35:40He has the experience.
1:35:43They call him – Tim calls him in, and he says, Alan, we've got a great opportunity for you.
1:35:50We're expanding.
1:35:52Yep.
1:35:55And you can lead the operations for this entirely.
1:35:58Yeah, exactly.
1:35:59All right.
1:36:00Let me take one last break here and thank our third and final sponsor of the episode.
1:36:06It is unsurprisingly, perhaps, but delighted to have him here.
1:36:10As always, our very good friends at Squarespace.
1:36:14Squarespace is the longest-running sponsor on this podcast.
1:36:17I hope they continue to be.
1:36:19People – they keep sponsoring the show because people who listen to the show keep signing up or sending friends and family who need a website to sign up to Squarespace with the code from the show.
1:36:32People keep signing up for it.
1:36:33They keep sponsoring, and I'm happy to have them.
1:36:36Squarespace, if you don't know, or if you do, I'll just tell you once again, is the all-in-one platform for building your brand online with your own website.
1:36:47And every single aspect of having your website, if you're like, I don't know how to have a website, I don't know what to do, just go sign up at Squarespace, and they will guide you through every single step.
1:37:00If you're like, I don't know how to connect to a server, I don't know how to register a domain name, I don't know how to keep paying for a domain name, I don't know how to design a website, I don't know how to add features to a website.
1:37:15All of that stuff, Squarespace makes easy, point-and-click, just look at it, they guide you through it, and they keep moving the platform forward.
1:37:26About two years ago, they put forth – it's always been easy to do from a desktop computer, and it still is.
1:37:31But now, all of the features and the way that you as the owner of a Squarespace website can manipulate it, control it, change it, add features, do stuff like that, all of it is just as easy to do from your phone as it is from a desktop computer, which for a lot of people is a big deal, because you're managing a business where maybe you're not at a computer all day, you're on your phone all day.
1:37:52Squarespace lets you keep your website up to date or make changes or anything like that that you want to do.
1:37:57They have all sorts of features for people who need their website for a business.
1:38:01Things like payments, they do payment processing.
1:38:04You're like, I don't know anything about this stuff.
1:38:05Squarespace takes care of it.
1:38:07You just sign up.
1:38:08But all the features, the modern stuff that you would want in a modern payment system like Apple Pay support, AfterPay, ClearPay, which is like the AfterPay for the UK, being able to take anything from credit cards to debit cards, stuff like that, all of that stuff they handle.
1:38:23Invoicing.
1:38:24If you run a sort of consulting business or anything where you need to send invoices, you can do all the invoicing through Squarespace.
1:38:32Send your clients a link, they come and they go to your website to see the invoice, and when they pay the invoice, you get it all through the Squarespace system interface.
1:38:41It is really, really easy, and of course, integrates with the payments for when people pay the invoices that you send to them.
1:38:48All sorts of, they call it Blueprint AI, which is their AI-backed system for doing website building, where instead of the drag-and-drop traditional interface, which is all still there,
1:38:59If you would rather do it in the modern AI chat style, where you just sort of give directions in a verbally chat interface to AI, you can do that, too.
1:39:08They've built that out.
1:39:09It's obviously one of the new things that they've done in their last few years.
1:39:13Analytics built into the Squarespace platform, one of the best, probably the single best analytics user interface I've ever seen from the perspective of,
1:39:23Oh, here's actual useful information, as opposed to looking like when you're exiting a plane, and you can look into the cockpit and see what the pilots see, and you're like, how the hell did they know what any of that shit does?
1:39:34That's what most analytics interfaces look like to me.
1:39:36Squarespace analytics is, oh, here's your traffic.
1:39:40Here's where it's coming from.
1:39:41It's super, super easy.
1:39:43It's like the difference between looking at a Honda dashboard versus a Boeing 747 cockpit.
1:39:48Really, really great.
1:39:49Where do you go to find out more?
1:39:52Go to squarespace.com slash talkshow.
1:39:55Squarespace.com slash talkshow.
1:39:57And remember that code.
1:39:58You can either start by going to that URL or just remember that code, talkshow, and you save 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain.
1:40:07Go to squarespace.com slash talkshow.
1:40:09All right, I'm going to read to you from one of your recent blog posts.
1:40:15This is July 18th.
1:40:16A responsibility to the industry.
1:40:18This is the opening.
1:40:21Firstly, I maintain that it makes absolutely no sense that Alan Dye has the power that he has, because he simply has no taste.
1:40:29But what's worse is that he wields that power so clumsily, so carelessly.
1:40:33And because it goes unchallenged, unchecked by someone higher than him, the entire industry suffers the consequences.
1:40:39If that sounds too dramatic, maybe the rest of this post won't be for you.
1:40:44What do you really think, Louis?
1:40:47Yeah, well, that.
1:40:49Yeah, that's basically it, John.
1:40:52I think, and you do go into the details, but I think as a bracing first paragraph, and I know that there's a tendency that some people like to shock and awe and clickbait, that's not what you're doing here.
1:41:07You're saying what you really think.
1:41:08Yes.
1:41:10It's no secret, Alan Dye's background is not in UI design.
1:41:14He's a graphic designer.
1:41:15He came from managing brands like Levi's, and I forget who.
1:41:20I always remember Levi's, because I used to wear Levi's jeans.
1:41:22Yeah, Kate Spade, I think is in there, too.
1:41:24Yeah, Kate Spade.
1:41:24But like sort of a fashion clothing industry background, not designing the clothes, but designing the branding for those companies.
1:41:34Yeah, I think.
1:41:35I don't know.
1:41:35Actually, weirdly, there is like very little information about him that you can find out of what happened.
1:41:43Like I am desperately trying to find like portfolio pieces.
1:41:46I want to see things that he's actually designed by himself without other people.
1:41:51I want to know what like his actual, because all I have to go on right now is what is the org that he's in charge of, the things that they are shipping, right?
1:42:00Like that's the only insight I have into what his taste is, because I don't know what it is other than this.
1:42:05And I think that's where the whole discussion over liquid glass, quote unquote, is losing the forest for one semi-transparent tree.
1:42:18Everybody's focusing on this see-through tree and, oh, the tree was very clear in the keynote.
1:42:24And then in beta 3, the tree got frosted.
1:42:28And now in beta 4, it's back to being clear.
1:42:31It's not frosted.
1:42:31But nobody's really looking at the forest.
1:42:35You said earlier on the podcast, did other previous UI changes go through these sort of visible yin and yangs, back and forth, tweaking during the betas?
1:42:47And like Mac OS Tiger in 2005, you said.
1:42:49No, but those were minor revisions.
1:42:52Like we talked about that being a sort of dialing in the look.
1:42:55Aqua did, right?
1:42:56Aqua went through dramatic changes from when Steve Jobs first unveiled it publicly.
1:43:02I think at a Mac world, I think Mac world, San Francisco in 2000, until the year or 14 months or whatever it was of public beta until Mac OS 10.0, it went through a lot of changes.
1:43:16And then it went through a lot of changes from 10.0 to 10.1, which only came out six or seven months later because 10.0 had a lot of problems.
1:43:25That when you do something that's really, wow, everybody, even casual users notice, oh, this looks new.
1:43:34You cannot miss it.
1:43:35Yeah, absolutely true.
1:43:37Yes.
1:43:37I think that you inevitably get this sort of visible back and forth once it goes from something they were trying to keep secret until they unveiled it.
1:43:45And then, okay, now we've unveiled it, but we need some time to get it ready to ship for the public.
1:43:51It happened with iOS 7 and it's happening with liquid glass.
1:43:56I think, though, that arguing about the transparency and the visual effects is losing.
1:44:02It's important.
1:44:03And I think it's emblematic of some of the things that Alan Dye personally and his team just don't get.
1:44:11They clearly don't get or they wouldn't do it.
1:44:13But I also think a lot of the stuff that we're seeing in iOS 26, they've been moving in this direction, but now they've taken a big step change.
1:44:21But it has nothing to do with the style or how transparency or how frosted the thing is, but rather just a philosophical, complete lack of understanding of what UI design actually is.
1:44:33I think this is the part that frustrates me about it.
1:44:36It's like there was a period of time, I think, after I left Apple and I started my own company, and now I'm on version two of that.
1:44:44I did Pacific Home and we had that weird phase where we had to go through.
1:44:47Everyone was hiring us for iOS 6 style design that everyone now had to do iOS 7 design.
1:44:52And that was a big deal too, right?
1:44:53I mean, we had to do all that stuff.
1:44:55But I think ever since I left Apple, I've always been a visual designer, right?
1:45:00Like, I'm not just, I am capable of being a UI designer, but I would consider myself a visual designer.
1:45:06I make the UI design look good.
1:45:09I make it look like it makes sense.
1:45:11Even if it, like, actually makes sense, I make sure it looks like it makes sense, right?
1:45:15So I need to make sure that, like, the different parts of it are differentiated.
1:45:18That, like, the title bar is distinct.
1:45:20Like, visually, that needs to make sense.
1:45:23So the parts of this modern liquid glass stuff that gets me, actually, yeah, isn't the material stuff.
1:45:28For the most part, I have to say, like, I don't like the glass, like, appearance for, like, the dock.
1:45:34I think that looks really good.
1:45:36I think the command tab stuff looks really good.
1:45:38I think glass notifications are totally fine.
1:45:41But it's, like, this other stuff, like, this deeper stuff that has been true forever, right?
1:45:48It's just, like, title bars, sidebars, status bars, like, toolbar items, right?
1:45:54Like, these quintessential attributes of both iOS and macOS just getting this complete overhaul without, guess, yeah, that full comprehension of what these things are and what they're supposed to be.
1:46:07I don't know if it comes from, like, a lack of understanding or just, like, a disregard for that understanding.
1:46:14I don't know which one it is.
1:46:16I think it's a lack of caring that stems from a disregard or a disregard that stems from not caring.
1:46:24Yeah.
1:46:24And not being fascinated by it.
1:46:26And so let me tell you this.
1:46:28A couple, some point after WWDC, so last five weeks or so, in talking about the unveil, I think it was right after WWDC.
1:46:37I think it was in my week after Thoughts and Observations on WWDC.
1:46:42I quoted from Alan Dye's keynote introduction of Liquid Glass and just a transcript of it.
1:46:51And then I quoted from and linked to Steve Jobs' 2000 introduction of Aqua.
1:46:57And it's like a night and day difference in the way they're speaking.
1:47:04The thing I've been trying to figure out with regards to this is, like, there was a tonal shift between the old Apple and, like, new Apple.
1:47:11Go ahead.
1:47:11Go ahead.
1:47:12Well, I couldn't find it because I was looking for something started Thoughts and Observations.
1:47:16But it started – I titled it One Week Out, Some Brief Thoughts and Observations on WWDC.
1:47:21And let's see here.
1:47:23Let's see if I can quote a little bit from Alan Dye.
1:47:26Software is at the heart and soul of our products.
1:47:28It brings them to life, shapes their personality, and defines their purpose.
1:47:32At Apple, we've always believed it's the deep integration of hardware and software that makes interacting with technology intuitive, beautiful, and a joy to use.
1:47:39Blah, blah, blah.
1:47:40Right?
1:47:41What is he talking about there?
1:47:42There is nothing.
1:47:44It's nothing is what it is.
1:47:46Like, it's the part that kind of – that really rubbed me the wrong way because it's like – I don't like the term corporate speak, but it is this sort of – it's gutless.
1:47:54There's nothing in there.
1:47:55You're just saying what sounds nice.
1:47:57You're saying something that sounds like it's true, and you can do – you can show anything after saying that, and then you're like, oh, yeah, that totally makes sense.
1:48:05And it doesn't, right?
1:48:06Yeah.
1:48:07All right.
1:48:07Here's what else he said.
1:48:08Blah, blah, blah.
1:48:09Today, we're excited to announce our broadest design update ever.
1:48:13Our goal – here's what their goal – he says their goal.
1:48:15Our goal is a beautiful new design that brings joy and delight to every user experience, one that's more personal, puts greater focus on your content, all while still feeling instantly familiar.
1:48:27And now here's what Steve Jobs said in 2000 about Aqua.
1:48:30The one more thing is we have been secretly for the last 18 months designing a completely new user interface, and that user interface builds on Apple's legacy.
1:48:39And carries it into the next century.
1:48:41And we call the new user interface Aqua because it's liquid.
1:48:45One of the design goals was when you saw it, you wanted to lick it.
1:48:49There's the goal.
1:48:51Yeah.
1:48:52So good, you wanted to lick it.
1:48:53Yeah, yeah.
1:48:53It's just – the whole point was the appearance of it.
1:48:57It was so fun that you just – yeah.
1:48:59You wanted to interact with it in some way.
1:49:01And then he starts – not by showing like a whole screenshot or something.
1:49:05It just starts showing –
1:49:06It was just a pill, right?
1:49:06It's just individual elements.
1:49:08Yeah, right, right, right.
1:49:10And he just says, what does a button look like?
1:49:11This is quoting.
1:49:12Right.
1:49:12And you spend months working on a button.
1:49:14That's a button in Aqua.
1:49:16That's him showing a slide button of just a regular oval capsule push button in Aqua.
1:49:21This is what radio buttons look like.
1:49:24Simple things.
1:49:25This is what checkboxes look like.
1:49:27This is what pop-up lists look like.
1:49:29Again, you're starting to get the feel of this.
1:49:31A little different.
1:49:32This is what sliders can look like.
1:49:34Now let me show you windows.
1:49:36This is what the top of windows look like.
1:49:38These three buttons look like a traffic signal, don't they?
1:49:41Red means close the window.
1:49:43Yellow means minimize the window.
1:49:44And green means maximize the window.
1:49:47Pretty simple.
1:49:48And a tremendous fit and finish in this operating system.
1:49:51As you roll over these things, you get those.
1:49:53Remember, you used to roll over the red and you'd get a little X that would say, hey, here's
1:49:58just to double emphasize, hey, when you click this one, it's going to close the window.
1:50:02When you rolled over the green one, you got a plus because it was going to make it bigger.
1:50:06Right?
1:50:06It was.
1:50:07And he explained it.
1:50:09Yep.
1:50:10And that was the goal.
1:50:12Skipping ahead of Jobs' thing, which is all worth listening to.
1:50:15I'll link to the video, I promise, in the show notes.
1:50:17But if you haven't watched, even if you watched it five weeks ago,
1:50:20when I wrote it, you should watch it.
1:50:21It's always good for a rewatch.
1:50:23Yeah.
1:50:23And that was the goal of this user interface.
1:50:26So here he's getting to it.
1:50:28First goal to make it look like you wanted to lick it.
1:50:30And then when he wraps this introduction up, he says, this is another goal.
1:50:34This was the goal of this user interface.
1:50:36To make it span the range so that people turning on their iMac for the first time were enchanted
1:50:41with it.
1:50:42And it was super easy to use.
1:50:44And yet, our pro users also felt, my God, this takes me to places I never thought I could
1:50:49get to.
1:50:50And that's what we tried to do.
1:50:51There it is.
1:50:53We want to make something that makes new people who have never owned a computer and just bought
1:50:57an iMac and it's their first computer feel like, hey, this is cool and I understand how
1:51:01to use this.
1:51:01And they wanted to make pro users feel like, wow, this is the best part.
1:51:05Right.
1:51:05Yeah.
1:51:06Yeah.
1:51:07I had a friend who recently ish, ex-Apple, he had been there doing design work for 15 plus
1:51:1820 years.
1:51:18I don't know.
1:51:19But he left somewhat recently and he watched that.
1:51:23And I guess he got to a part that I didn't quote because jobs keeps going on.
1:51:28But he said, I knew this because he had been there, started at Apple while Steve Jobs was
1:51:33still there.
1:51:34I don't know if he ever, I honestly don't even know if he ever interacted with Steve Jobs
1:51:37personally, but was there at the time.
1:51:39And he knew this about Steve Jobs, that he could really get nerdy about UI.
1:51:43But in that keynote introduction, Steve Jobs was talking at one point about the key window
1:51:49and that this, here's how you can tell which window is the key window because it has input
1:51:54focus because the red, yellow, and green were red, yellow, and green.
1:51:57And a window in the background, which wasn't the key window because it was in the background,
1:52:01they were grayed out.
1:52:02And that it gave you this instant obvious, oh, the key window is glowy and colorful.
1:52:08And at a glance, out of the corner of your eye, you could see which window is the one.
1:52:14And he said, I forgot that Steve talked like that about using UI design lingo, like key
1:52:21window and input focus and things like that.
1:52:24And he said to me that he had meetings with Alan Dye's team in recent-ish years, and that
1:52:32he'd used terms like that.
1:52:35And he said, I never got like cut off, but there was always an underlying tone of shut up with
1:52:40the UI nerd stuff.
1:52:41That they didn't use terms like that.
1:52:44And that when he would, when describing an idea, that their eyes would roll back in their head.
1:52:50Here goes another one of these key window input focus guys again.
1:52:53Meanwhile, though, they're the fucking team that shipped an iPad multi-window interface for
1:52:59seven years where you couldn't tell which half of the screen.
1:53:02You and I have talked about this before, this exact thing that like, I said it like years
1:53:08ago, but it's like, we solved that problem like over a decade ago.
1:53:13Why are we doing this right now where we are like backtracking on the things that we already
1:53:18know to be true?
1:53:19I mean, it doesn't really make any sense to me why it's hard to distinguish the inactive
1:53:23window.
1:53:24But this goes to exactly what we were talking about earlier too, where it's like even different
1:53:28apps are distinguished from each other and the focus was determined.
1:53:32Like we could identify all of these things.
1:53:34The original Macintosh team had one bit color to work with black pixels and white pixels.
1:53:40That's what we were talking about.
1:53:42Yeah.
1:53:42Wasn't even a grayscale screen.
1:53:44Yep.
1:53:44And they did things like they put pinstripes in horizontal pinstripes in the active windows
1:53:52title bar and the background windows were just a white rectangle.
1:53:56White, right.
1:53:57And that I'm sure they've tinkered with all sorts of things.
1:54:01You know, there's all sorts of ways Mac paint had paint bucket full of them where the paint
1:54:06bucket didn't have colors because it was a one bit screen, but it had patterns and the patterns
1:54:11could create different indications of grayness or something.
1:54:14They could have made the active window title bar black with white text.
1:54:19There's all sorts of ways they could have done.
1:54:20They've done tons of different patterns, but that was the one that they did.
1:54:23Yeah.
1:54:23They settled on these stripes and it worked in a way where even with just black, you could
1:54:29just do it.
1:54:29But then as devices got things like color, it was like you could see it in the history
1:54:36as the Mac OS interface evolved where user interface designers, it wasn't just we could
1:54:41make, we can do cool things with color, which was part of it.
1:54:45People love to make things look cool, but you could see that the user interface thinkers were
1:54:52thinking, oh, we can solve a certain problem in a way we could never solve before.
1:54:58Right.
1:54:58Due to the display technology that we now have, we have more tools at our disposal to distinguish
1:55:05like inactive windows and stuff like that.
1:55:07So another one, a one that was really kind of ugly, it's undeniably ugly, but I don't
1:55:13know what else they could have done is when the Mac interface was only black and white.
1:55:16Let's say that a window or a dialog box is in a state where one of the buttons, you have
1:55:24to fill in a certain text field.
1:55:26It can't be empty or you can't go onward.
1:55:28So the button, the OK button has to be disabled.
1:55:33Well, how do you indicate a disabled button in black and white?
1:55:37Well, they would use a 50% the sort of checkerboard pattern pixel by pixel to gray it out.
1:55:43But when you only have one bit, that meant that by XORing every other pixel to make a
1:55:5050% checkerboard pattern at the pixel level, the word OK or the word next or whatever it
1:55:56was, you could kind of not read it because it was a font.
1:55:59You couldn't pick gray.
1:56:01Yep.
1:56:01Yep.
1:56:02And so having color, even just 256 colors or even 16 colors, which some Macs could run in
1:56:10as a resolution, they could just render the button in gray instead of black and white,
1:56:15make it gray and white to show, oh, this button is currently disabled.
1:56:19They were solving a problem.
1:56:21And you could, as a user, as the Mac interface evolved, I could see the joy.
1:56:26I could experience it.
1:56:28I really could of the user interface designers discovering how to solve these problems with
1:56:35technology.
1:56:35Yeah.
1:56:36You were suddenly getting like a certain level of clarity that was always intended.
1:56:40It was always understood that this was needed.
1:56:42But then with the greater like technological capacity, you were seeing like the clarity
1:56:47of that object, the way that it should be, the way that it could have been, right?
1:56:52But the way that it is now, and now it's fully distinguished from other objects, right?
1:56:57That makes this, that goes for buttons, that goes for checkboxes, that goes for like inactive
1:57:01windows and active windows, that goes for everything.
1:57:03I mean, like even what you said with like aqua, like aqua windows, the active ones have
1:57:08the red, yellow, green as like fully opaque colors.
1:57:12And then the inactive ones are like gray, you know, that they're a little translucent to white
1:57:16sort of thing.
1:57:17But, but it was also like the title bar got a little translucent, like in the inactive
1:57:22window on the original light.
1:57:24And that was like, by having these individual different tools, right?
1:57:27It made it so that whatever the active window was, if there were buttons, if there were
1:57:31checkboxes, they were blue.
1:57:32But if the window became inactive, they all became a grayish tone so that you saw this entire
1:57:40window is not the active window, not just by the title bar, but by all of the controls
1:57:45within it.
1:57:45And it's not that some macOS stuff still doesn't operate like this.
1:57:49It does.
1:57:49Like there are still things that like have that fundamental principle, but there's like these,
1:57:54like, if we, if we consider like modern liquid glass things, they have like kind of a couple
1:57:59appearances, right?
1:58:00They have like the fully transparent, refracted, like fun version that they have the frosted
1:58:05version when things are out of focus, but they use that frosted version sometime in other
1:58:11contexts.
1:58:11And they use the like super refracted one in other contexts so that in a way that difference
1:58:17doesn't mean anything to the user.
1:58:19They can't use it as an identifier of, oh, this is what that means inherently because
1:58:25of its appearance.
1:58:26They have to guess, oh, it's because they didn't want to put glass on glass.
1:58:30So the under one has to be frosted.
1:58:31The user isn't thinking about that, right?
1:58:34I understand that that's like how the developer should be thinking about that, but that doesn't
1:58:37make sense to the user to help them understand the user interface.
1:58:41And that's the thing that always struck me as soon as I got engaged with the Mac and
1:58:47the consistency and uniformity of this, of good Mac interfaces.
1:58:52That's where it really, I was like, oh, this is something that fascinates me endlessly is
1:58:57that a good UI designer to me is also a teacher where they are teaching the user how to understand
1:59:06the system and that once you understand just something that sounds as simple as if the buttons
1:59:11are gray, that means they're in a window or otherwise not active for a reason because the
1:59:17window is not front most and you need to click on the window to make it front most.
1:59:20And now they'll light up as color and the window you were in, the controls will go gray.
1:59:26But the other thing that that, just that simple example gets to is it was the windows controls
1:59:34or the, and the apps controls and buttons and toolbar buttons in the scroll bar within the
1:59:39window that would gray out when the window became inactive, but the content of the window didn't
1:59:45change at all.
1:59:46So if you had two Photoshop documents open overlapping either side by side, the content, the picture
1:59:53wouldn't go grayed out or, or dim or have a filter put over it.
1:59:59The content stayed the same.
2:00:00The apps interface would gray out because it was the app that was inactive.
2:00:05The content hadn't changed, but that way you wouldn't want that because what if you have
2:00:09in Photoshop, you have.
2:00:12Yeah.
2:00:12If you're comparing two things that you're trying to color pick from the other object, you need
2:00:15to have them both in focus.
2:00:16Not in focus.
2:00:17Yeah.
2:00:18Yeah.
2:00:18Yeah.
2:00:18Yeah.
2:00:18Somebody says to you, an icon designer, here's the icon for go left and we need you to make
2:00:28an icon for go in it, but it needs to match this.
2:00:30So you, you're not changing the left one there.
2:00:32Everybody's like, yeah, this icon's done.
2:00:34And you've got this other way.
2:00:35You certainly wouldn't want the content of the window to dim out because it's in the background.
2:00:39It would make no sense.
2:00:40You'd, you'd, you'd throw your computer against the wall.
2:00:42Right.
2:00:43And so the separation between the app interface and the content is essential to understanding
2:00:50how to use the app.
2:00:52Yeah.
2:00:52And so this whole philosophy, which you have written about, but this whole philosophy of
2:00:58we're going to make the app interface fade away to put your content forward is doing the
2:01:05opposite.
2:01:05It's the opposite.
2:01:07It's not putting the content forward.
2:01:09That's exactly what I said.
2:01:10It's, it's this very funny thing where they've just, they're, they're saying this thing.
2:01:14And I, and I think they really believe it.
2:01:16I just want to say that.
2:01:17I think when they say we're trying to put like content forward, I think that's what they
2:01:22think they're doing.
2:01:22And that's the problem.
2:01:23Right.
2:01:24And that is the problem.
2:01:25There's like this fundamental misunderstanding of what this is supposed to be.
2:01:28And I, and I, and I said this, that you need the distinct difference between the
2:01:33UI and the content so that you don't mistake one for another, that like you see which, which
2:01:38clarity, which things are tools and which things are not.
2:01:41I mean, like, this is a stupid example, but if I'm designing UI, then I need the UI of the
2:01:46actual app to look different from the content.
2:01:49If I, if that starts to look the same, right.
2:01:50And this is where Safari really gets me, John.
2:01:52If the, in the new Safari on iOS specifically, but also on like macOS, but iOS specifically,
2:01:58like when you scroll and it's got like that tiny, like little URL thing, it is like touch
2:02:03fuzz.
2:02:04It has this slight like glass appearance, but like on some websites that have their own buttons
2:02:11in UI, which is not crazy to think about is unclear whether the buttons belong to the app
2:02:17or belong to the website.
2:02:18And this is so screwed up, John.
2:02:21Like this should never be in question.
2:02:24Like no one should be looking at the app, wondering whether the controls will do something
2:02:28to the page or to the app or whatever.
2:02:30Like they need to know what those things are.
2:02:33Like you're right.
2:02:34Like UI designers are teaching users how to use the interface and how to understand how to
2:02:39understand it.
2:02:40Yes.
2:02:40And the clarity of an individual object in the separation of UI and content is critical to
2:02:46that.
2:02:46There used to be a term in, I don't think they use it anymore, but in the human interface
2:02:50guidelines, not that Apple cares about that stuff.
2:02:52That's for third-party developers, but like, but there used to be a term called perceived
2:02:55stability.
2:02:56And it's like by every app adhering to certain guidelines, right?
2:03:02By every app having the same distinct UI elements, you have this perceived stability on the platform
2:03:09that people understanding one app meant they understood another app, that they could understand
2:03:15the entire system as a whole, right?
2:03:17If everyone plays by this sort of thing, then everyone gets it.
2:03:20The issue now is that like, we see like a new UI paradigm that throws out all of the things
2:03:26that people were stabilized from, right?
2:03:28Like I knew that the stoplight controls were in the title bar.
2:03:32Now they're in the sidebar.
2:03:33What does that mean?
2:03:34Does that difference actually communicate like a fundamental difference on the way the window
2:03:40works?
2:03:40No, it doesn't, right?
2:03:42So it is only a style decision.
2:03:44And so the part that like, I guess frustrates me is that the visual designer that I am, like
2:03:52those things were so critical.
2:03:54And we scrutinized the trivial part of it, like in the iOS 6 era, being like, we didn't want
2:04:01the rich Corinthian letter that was silly.
2:04:03And now we're using visuals only for visual like reasons, like not to communicate the UI when
2:04:09that was the entire purpose of like visually designing anything.
2:04:13Right.
2:04:14So, yeah.
2:04:15I further think that in addition to being disrespectful to the content by blurring the distinction
2:04:23between the UI 2.
2:04:23Oh, that kills me.
2:04:24Yes.
2:04:25But I think it's profoundly disrespectful to the apps themselves because an empty app is
2:04:33still a thing.
2:04:33When you go to Photoshop or any app, right?
2:04:36Photoshop or text edit or, and you hit command N and you have a brand new document that's empty
2:04:46because you haven't made anything in it yet.
2:04:47It is a thing.
2:04:49It is an app.
2:04:50It is somebody, some team of engineers and designers and managers have created this thing.
2:04:56And the more powerful a tool it is, the more it is a thing that you should be able to identify
2:05:04by looking at it.
2:05:06And that it should explain to you what, if you're new to it, how and what you should start using
2:05:14it and fill it in.
2:05:15And this idea that all of these apps should, should sort of look the same and that a web
2:05:21browser, like an empty Safari window should clearly look like a web browser because it should have
2:05:26visible UI Chrome for the app that looks web browser-y like a field for typing URLs and search
2:05:32terms and back and forward buttons.
2:05:35It should obviously be a web browser before it's filled in.
2:05:39You should definitely, everybody knows what a web browser does.
2:05:41So when you look at an empty web browser, you should clearly know it's a web browser.
2:05:45You should be able to know that each app is what it does because it should have that.
2:05:52And it's, you talked about it multiple times.
2:05:54And I know that the Corinthian leather as a specific one apps only theme was sort of over
2:06:00the top, but it was better to, it was a better mistake to make or a better way to take things
2:06:05to an extreme than this, where everything just looks like glass and it all goes away and the
2:06:13buttons are shrink and, and go away as you scroll the content.
2:06:18I think in hindsight, I know I was never happy about it, but in hindsight, I think it's a worse
2:06:24and worse mistake and it probably does predate Alan Dye joining Apple, I think.
2:06:29But I think that the getting rid of scroll bars is the canary.
2:06:36I said, I said that exact thing.
2:06:38I said like, it is a moment in time where they were just like, yeah, we don't need that anymore.
2:06:43And it's, but, but, but, but, but, but that does communicate things.
2:06:46It communicates three different things and without them, you don't have that.
2:06:50Like it helps you, like, it actually has the interactive like element.
2:06:54It shows you how much is left of the page and it shows you like your position in the page.
2:07:00These are three distinct things that it does and not showing it requiring your input to just
2:07:06to see that status.
2:07:07It's like, so that's one of the things that I talked that I was trying to reference before,
2:07:13like where the addition of color gave UI designers a new set of tools to use to convey understanding.
2:07:21And some of it isn't just adding color or something technical like that, but just,
2:07:25just the ideas from other companies.
2:07:28So the original Mac scroll bars, the, the little thing in the middle of the scroll bar that shows
2:07:34you your position is called the thumb.
2:07:36That's the thumb and the scroll bar.
2:07:37And for the original Mac in 1984 through somewhere in the nineties, I think in the Mac OS eight
2:07:46era, the thumb on Mac OS was just a perfect square.
2:07:50Right.
2:07:51No matter what.
2:07:51And it, so it didn't scale.
2:07:53So if you opened a one page word processing or one page, well, one page didn't used to fit
2:08:02on screen at the time.
2:08:03Yeah.
2:08:03Yeah.
2:08:03Right.
2:08:03So it's a one page word processing document, but you can only see about a half a page at
2:08:08a time on your screen.
2:08:09You still got a perfectly square thumb in the scroll bar.
2:08:13Yeah.
2:08:13And if the document was 250 pages, because it was, there was no visual difference.
2:08:18It was still a square and the, I, I don't know if they were first, but I know the first platform
2:08:25I remember with a dynamically sized thumb that was dynamically sized to represent the scale
2:08:34of what's in the current viewport in the window proportional to the overall scrollable area
2:08:40was next step next had that first, or at least the first one I remember, maybe some other
2:08:45Unix E platform had that. And I remember when I saw a screenshot of it, it was like instantly,
2:08:51it was like a light bulb went off. Oh, that's a bunch of, that's a brilliant idea because now
2:08:55you've added an extra layer of information to the scroll bar. It tells you.
2:09:01Without taking away anything. It didn't take, it didn't really, it didn't like you already
2:09:05had that space reserved.
2:09:06Right.
2:09:06So it didn't really take away anything. It was totally fine.
2:09:09And so, and, and for shorter documents, which are more common, it actually gave you a bigger
2:09:15grabbable area to drag it up and down. So in some ways it was more usable. And in the worst
2:09:21case of a, like, again, a 200 page thesis document, it also wouldn't shrink below a minimum size.
2:09:28Right, right. There was always some, yeah, right. What's the point of it? It's like, at that point,
2:09:33you're like, I already understand this is big. It's not really helping me to have it be like
2:09:37actually representative.
2:09:38Right. But so we'll keep it at the size that it, on the Mac, it always was. And then eventually
2:09:43at some point in the Mac OS eight era, the Apple updated the standard scroll bars to have that
2:09:48feature. And it was like, it was like a glass of ice water in hell. Well, maybe not hell,
2:09:53but it was like a delicious treat to Mac users who didn't have that. And it was like, yeah,
2:09:59like the state of the art for scroll bar design has moved forward because now it's added this
2:10:05new dimension of showing by the size of the thumb, the scale of the document.
2:10:10And it didn't matter. It's not about the look and feel of the UI system and the next step look and feel
2:10:18their style of making things look grayscale in 3d or the Mac OS 8.5 or Mac OS nine platinum theme. And it
2:10:26had blue thumbs by default, but if you changed your system color to orange, then the thumb would be orange
2:10:32to match the same color as the menu bar selection or the tech selection. That's cool. But it didn't have to it.
2:10:39The idea that the scroll bar would be proportional was separate from the look and feel. And that's a different
2:10:48type of UI design. And you could be there are I know people who are extremely talented UI designers in that area who
2:10:56never, ever, ever would admit, I'm not a good illustrator. I'm not good at Photoshop. They would
2:11:01hand it off to somebody with the skills like you have to say, make this look good.
2:11:05Yeah. I mean, and then that's why we've got the fun Haku ones, which had like the non moving pinstripes that
2:11:11were masked inside. That was so, there was, there was no reason for that. Other than that, it was fucking
2:11:16fun. And I think that's, that's, that's like the thing that like job said. It was like, it's like,
2:11:19it makes you want to look at it. It's that, that's like a cute way of just saying you want to play with
2:11:25it. It's just like, you want, and how many of us did that? I mean, we, to be fair, like, I'm doing
2:11:30that with liquid glass. I know a lot of other people are too. Like for the visual component of this,
2:11:34there is some like fun attributes like that, where you just like, you're just dragging around. You're
2:11:38like, oh, that's so interesting. It's the same as like the genie effect. Yes. Technically, we need to
2:11:43move the window to here. How do we do that in a fun, interesting, cute way? We can do that.
2:11:47That's the visual interactive like thing on top of the good UI design that needs to exist from the
2:11:53start. If you don't have that and you're only doing the visual part. One of my favorite purchases I've
2:11:59ever made was, I was either a senior in college. I think it might've been right after I was a senior
2:12:04in college, but it's like, I finally, I guess it was after I graduated and I was making some money
2:12:08because I got a job and I got to buy like a home theater and I bought the biggest Sony TV that I
2:12:15forget what size it was, but it was this Trinitron TV with, it was like a 36 inch Trinitron, but it was
2:12:21huge. And oh my God, I lived on, at one point I moved to the fourth floor with Amy. It was the first
2:12:28apartment. Amy and I got together and we had to move. It was like 10,000 pounds to move it up to the
2:12:34fourth floor. But I got, I bought a Sony receiver and the receiver, I, I, you know, it wasn't the
2:12:41highest end stuff, but I always loved Sony stuff, but I just love turning the volume dial. And it was
2:12:46like this anodized aluminum that they had made concentric circles around the front face of it. And
2:12:52you, it was kind of nice to rub your thumb across it. And it, even without turning the dial and the dial
2:12:58had a nice feel to it when you turned the dial, but it felt good even just to touch the dial. That's the
2:13:04sort of thing that Sony had. That's the sort of thing that Steve jobs admired about Sony as a
2:13:08corporation. Like ultimately, yes, it was about how good the receiver made the audio sound and what specs
2:13:13it had to drive speakers that were connected to it. But you know what, if you're going to make the thing
2:13:18and you're going to sell it for a Sony level of pricing, the dials and the buttons should feel good
2:13:24too. And so, yeah, if we have the capability to make the scroll bar thumb, do a weird animation
2:13:31behind it as you drag it up and down. Yeah. We should do that. Yeah. Right. Yeah. Well, I think
2:13:36there's, so like you said, how like you good UI design is there to like teach users, like how to
2:13:42understand like the UI of the app. I think that like there's like that level of visual design on top of
2:13:48the good DUI design. The purpose of that is to make this stuff like approachable computers are a little
2:13:55scary for a lot of people who are using this stuff for the first time. Anyone that's like using an
2:14:00iPhone for the first time, there is like an intention or has to be an intention to make it fun and
2:14:05approachable. It was like that. You were saying like that original, like aqua presentation, like he's
2:14:10like, this is what a checkbox looks like. This is what a dropdown looks like. Like the first interaction
2:14:15we had with iPhone was like slide to unlock and he did it twice because everyone was so into it.
2:14:20There is like an important part of making things make sense, make them joyful. There's like delightful
2:14:25thing because if you don't have that, then the entire system looks like something you don't want
2:14:31to touch. Like, I don't want to touch that button. I don't want to interact with that because I don't
2:14:35know what that's going to do. Right. The whole point of slide to unlock was just to make sure that if the
2:14:41phone got activated in your pocket or when you're otherwise looking at it, that you didn't do anything
2:14:44accidentally. That you weren't going to call someone or like do a destructive action.
2:14:48It had nothing to do with any feature. If you listed every single feature the original iPhone
2:14:54did, it wasn't even number 120. It was like an anti-feature just to make sure you didn't engage
2:15:02any features accidentally. But they made it look so good and so fun and like you would want to. And
2:15:09everybody I know who got an iPhone, the first night it was like we're all waiting for AT&T to
2:15:15activate our phones anyway. We just sit there and like slide to unlock, slide to unlock. It was so
2:15:21good. I will genuinely joyful. Yeah, I like it. It was nice. I will toss this out there because I
2:15:27haven't mentioned it or written about it in a long time. But on macOS, one of the top tips I would advise
2:15:32everybody to do if you haven't done it is in the appearance settings under show scroll bars. There's
2:15:39an option to it. I think it defaults to when scrolling. So you only just like iOS, you only see scroll bars
2:15:47when you scroll. Turn on always show scroll bars always scroll. But even when you do show scroll bars
2:15:54always like for the last 10 years of macOS, they look so boring. They're so they do. They're so unhelpful and so
2:16:01unfun. Nobody's sliding them for fun at all. Right. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, there was like,
2:16:08yeah, I mean, like when there's an interaction, like it's like there is a little bit of it that's
2:16:12like wasting time. But I mean, there is like some element that like through repeated action, you also
2:16:17you do understand what the thing does, right? Like by making the scroll bar like a little fun, you do
2:16:24understand it a little bit better because you're using it a lot more. Right. And there was I remember
2:16:28hearing this, like, I don't remember when I heard this, who I heard it from or whatever, but like
2:16:31that things like solitaire, like on windows, which is like this quintessential, like original windows
2:16:39app. Right. The purpose of it is like to get people comfortable with clicking and dragging.
2:16:43Yeah. It's just, and I'm like, oh, that's so brilliant. That's so smart. Get something that
2:16:48like just hooks people a little bit, but that, that teaches them how to drag and drop like an item,
2:16:53because that is what they're going to be using a computer for. It's so smart. Yep. And I just think
2:16:59it's, it's ultimately very sad. And I think fundamentally, that's what it really boils down
2:17:03to is that Alan Dye and his team are full of designers who, even if you like the style of the
2:17:09work they're producing and the way it looks and whether you think it looks cool, only think about
2:17:15it that way. They do not think about user interface from that perspective of it doesn't really matter
2:17:21exactly what it looks like. It's about the functionality and solving these problems.
2:17:25Well, there should be a very clear indication of which tab is, is the active tab in a, yeah,
2:17:30like that is the entire goal of tabs. Right. I mean, I think if you look at, I think, yeah. What
2:17:36other purpose does it have? Like there's, there's so many of these elements like scattered around like
2:17:41Mac OS and iOS now with liquid glass, where you're just like, this defeats the purpose of the actual
2:17:47like object that this represents. Why would it, why would it look like this? Why would it behave like
2:17:52this? There's no real reason. No, I like John. Okay. So I wanted to say this, but I don't, I don't know
2:17:57how to say it, but I, in preparation for talking with you today, I installed like OS 26, iOS 26 on my
2:18:05personal phone, like just like last night. And I was like, let's fucking go, man. Let's like,
2:18:11let's give this a go because I've been living with it on my Mac since like beta one. Right. And it's
2:18:15and, and I have to say almost, this is so weird. Almost all of my complaints are actually about
2:18:23Mac OS and less about iOS. Oh, definitely. I think, I think that shows so much. I mean, I, and I'm the
2:18:30opposite where I've been using it, not on my main iPhone, but my iPhone 15 from last year, which I'm
2:18:36trying to use all the time in the house because it doesn't have a cell service, but I don't, if I
2:18:42had, I just don't feel good enough about it. And there's a couple of apps that kind of crap out.
2:18:45Oh yeah. I mean, million percent, like it's a bad idea to have your main phone, but I'm like,
2:18:49what am I going to do? But when I look at it, it's so much more polished on iOS 26. It is. It's more
2:18:56polished and it makes it like, I don't want to say it necessarily makes more sense, but it's definitely
2:19:00more fluid. We get none of the liquid part of liquid glass on the Mac yet. No, ever. I don't
2:19:06know where that is. They do things and I don't even know how it's possible, right? Because in a way it,
2:19:12but it baffles me. For example, it always has. I understand that there are a hundred times more
2:19:17iOS developers than Mac developers, probably more than a hundred times. And you know that when somebody
2:19:23who's developed iOS apps for years makes their first Mac app, they're going to make what I consider
2:19:29to be beginner mistakes. Yes. Oh God. Yes. It's just because they make, because they're not
2:19:36familiar with the system. But the thing that gets me is they make certain mistakes where I don't
2:19:42understand how it's possible because I know they at least use a Mac to make the iOS apps because the
2:19:47only way to make an iOS app is to use a Mac and X code. And I know that X code gets blank, right?
2:19:53Like X code. I don't know what the example, you know, there's a hundred of them, but whatever it is,
2:19:59X code is a pretty good example of standard, good Apple Mac UI design. And I know that you've been
2:20:05using it for years because you've been making iOS apps for years, but somehow you've been using X code
2:20:10and not paying any attention whatsoever to the interface. Okay. So hear me out. I'm not saying
2:20:16this is the cause, but I do wonder like over the years with the iOS application of a bunch of things
2:20:22and with iOS becoming like a more dominant platform in everyone's hands, like there also have been
2:20:29simultaneously like a decrease in Mac OS, like native apps that were good at solving like a particular
2:20:35problem, like a really good tool. There still are great ones, but a lot of people use Safari as like
2:20:42an interface for web apps that they use a lot more. I mean, some people's docs look like Finder Safari
2:20:49trash and you're like, what to leave? I can't even imagine it, but that is how some people live.
2:20:54Right. And cause they're, even their email is in a tab in Safari.
2:20:57Yeah. I'm like over here, like using mail and some people are like, wait, what you can, there's a mail
2:21:01app on iPhone. I'm like, Jesus. And it does make me wonder, I guess where I'm going with this is to
2:21:05people just like that are making these apps, like for iOS that did come out of nowhere to make iOS
2:21:10apps that never made Mac apps before. Are they the Safari web app people? And they're just not familiar
2:21:16with like platform as a whole that they just like that for them. It's Finder Safari X code trash. Is
2:21:23that the issue? I don't know, but it certainly seems like the people on Alan Dye's team who've defined
2:21:30the Mac OS 26 interface are amongst those people. Like they must be using, they must be using Macs for
2:21:37some of their job, but they're not paying attention to the why. For example, I know Snell and I talked
2:21:45about this, but I'll mention it again, like the way that in Mac OS 26, that toolbar icons look like
2:21:51they float above the windows and it makes no conceptual sense. It's not, oh, is it too clear? Can you read
2:21:59it? Is it, do I like the glassy or whatever? It's the toolbar buttons by definition, by functionality
2:22:06applied to the contents of the window. So they ought to, no matter what the application is of how you make
2:22:15them look, it has to look like they're part of the window for it to make any sense. And if it looks like
2:22:21they're above the windows, it makes no sense. There's no conceptual sense.
2:22:25And I would say that, yeah, if you're going to have toolbar items that levitate like that
2:22:29without even just a clear, without just a line, like it is unclear whether it's there, like a line
2:22:35would add a lot that would make it so clear where the window was. But if the content area is blurring
2:22:42with the navigation of the app, yeah, I don't know. How do you get to that point? How do you get to the
2:22:50point where you disregard that stuff, where you think that stuff isn't important? I mean,
2:22:54one of the things that I think any good designer, whatever kind of designer you are,
2:22:59like the fundamental thing you have to do is like live life. You have to go out, you have to look
2:23:06at things. This goes for artists too. You have to like see real life. You have to experience this stuff
2:23:11to understand it, to then develop an opinion on it. Right? So if there exists designers who do not
2:23:19use macOS, who do not live with it, who do not, they will never understand it. Right? And they will
2:23:24consistently misinterpret it. And that goes for independent developers. That goes for like
2:23:29developers that work at like big companies. That goes for the execs, Apple's big companies that they
2:23:32themselves don't use like these products. That goes for like the people at Apple who maybe just don't
2:23:37really use it that much other than to design apps. Right? And I'm like, how do you like the only way
2:23:44that we get to this point, I think, is that those people just don't experience it anymore.
2:23:48I, I guess it's like, you have to buy a pizza in a bad pizza box that's ruined, but in the middle,
2:23:56you have to actually buy the pizza and have the bad pizza to want to be inspired to design a better
2:24:03pizza box. And so there's a part of me, I mean, I think I said this, but like, okay, so I know that
2:24:08I'm picking on Alan Dalawa. Like I know I am doing that, but he is the person that's the VP in charge of
2:24:13this whole thing. And took it on as he introduced it. He's the face of it. Like whether or not like
2:24:18he's directly responsible for everything is like, just, it doesn't matter. But like, but like, I want
2:24:23to see him do basic things on Mac OS. I want to see him execute certain tasks that are like, that should
2:24:31be easy. I want to see him do it. I want to see him like do it on, on iOS. I want to see him close a
2:24:36Safari tab. Why is it more difficult now than it's ever been? Like, I want to see the process of like him
2:24:43using it and like, then go back to older iOS or older Mac OS. And I don't know, I wanted to like
2:24:49experience that stuff. So maybe he understands it or someone on that team. I don't know.
2:24:53I had a briefing with Alan Dye with a couple other members of the media, like second or third year of
2:24:59Apple watch. And I, he was talking about how great it was five of us and him. And I remember where it was,
2:25:10it was in a, like a yoga studio in the fitness center at Apple park. So I guess it might've been
2:25:15later than the second or third year because the Apple park was open. And I, I had a question cause
2:25:21I think they tweaked it in that version of the new version of watch OS, but about the way that they
2:25:26were rendering. When you look at an analog face with the hour hand and minute hand in the second hand
2:25:32on Apple watch that they, there's a Z axis, even though watch OS has always been largely flat it and
2:25:41all watch. I've never seen any watch, even like a $7 discount quartz watch that you'd buy in a discount
2:25:48store. Every physical watch with analog hands, the hands are stacked in the same order where the hour
2:25:55hand is on the bottom. The minute hand is on top of the hour hand. And if there's a second hand,
2:26:00it's on top of the minute hand so that the hours, minutes, seconds going forward and Apple watch
2:26:08renders, the hands always has in the same Z axis ordered. It's not perfectly flat. And they render a
2:26:14sort of shadow around things so that you could see like when the minute hand is slightly overhanded,
2:26:21like it's not quite the time where the minute hand perfectly overlaps the hour hand. It's like a minute
2:26:28beforehand. There's a little bit of a shadow so you can tell them apart. And I had a question about the light
2:26:33source for the shadow. And I was like, oh, finally, I get to ask Alan Dye about this. And he was like, oh, we render a
2:26:39shadow. And I was like, oh, you never even looked. I was like, oh, I just instantly realized you'd never really even
2:26:45looked at it that closely. Like somebody at Apple has, but Alan Dye didn't. And I was like, oh, that's your job is what
2:26:53you do. I just remember thinking at that very moment, it just suddenly came to me, oh, he doesn't do what I thought he did.
2:27:00And so this is like this thing, I think maybe this must have happened after Steve died. And all the
2:27:08execs like took on new responsibilities of what Steve used to do, right? Steve did used to approve
2:27:13like all these individual things. We were talking about that earlier, right? Who does that now? I
2:27:18don't know. It's not Tim. And it's not Federighi either. I don't know. Is it Alan Dye? I don't know.
2:27:23Does Alan Dye look at some of this stuff? Sure. But who is it? And where is this coming from?
2:27:28I don't know. And like, where does the direction come from? I don't know. Like the fact that we
2:27:33actually don't know who that person is when it was very obviously Steve before, right? I mean,
2:27:39like, why, why don't we know? I don't know either, but it touches upon, it was a talk I gave a couple
2:27:45times, at least twice. I gave it at Macworld Expo, I think once. And it's, I think, Deconstruct down in
2:27:53New Zealand, but maybe it was, I don't know, but over in Ireland, but I think it was Deconstruct in
2:27:59New Zealand, like around 2010, that I called the auteur theory of design, which was using the French
2:28:06use this term auteur, the author of a film to say that the director of a movie is the author of the
2:28:15film. And that there is sort of traditionally, like the author of a novel is very clear. It's one person
2:28:20who sits down and types out a novel. And sure, there's editors at the publisher who help polish
2:28:25the manuscript. But nobody disputes that the author of Huckleberry Finn is Mark Twain, right? But there
2:28:33wasn't this clear idea that the director of a movie is the one who gets a film by Steven Spielberg until
2:28:42later, you know, because, well, there is a screenplay that somebody wrote like a novel, and that they did the
2:28:49author of the screenplay, or authors, if it's a collaboration, wrote that. And every inch of the
2:28:56footage of film was shot by a cinematographer with their hands on the camera. There are some directors
2:29:02like Stanley Kubrick, who did most or a lot of the photography themselves. There's a lot of film
2:29:06directors who've never touched the camera, right? And there's a film editor who takes the footage and
2:29:12is responsible for cutting it into mise en scene. But that what and the actors are the ones who were there
2:29:18speaking the lines and doing the action. And so what is the director? The director is the person who whose taste
2:29:25the film rises to the performances of the actors, the look of the cinematography, the story and the dialogue
2:29:32told in the screenplay, the way that it feels when it's edited together and the use of music and all of that.
2:29:40The director, that is a breakthrough. And that software is like that, too. And that my thesis, and I think it's I still think it's
2:29:47true, I should really want to read. I don't know if I'm gonna do a talk because I don't talk at conferences
2:29:51anymore. But maybe it'll be a blog post or something. But to revisit that and look at the intervening years. But that my
2:29:57conclusion was that the level of quality of the work of a company, whether it's hardware or software or something in
2:30:04between eventually rises or falls to the level of taste of the person who's ultimately in charge of it and gets to say yes or no.
2:30:14And I think we're seeing Apple's UI design, not the styling, which is a separate issue, but the quality of the semantic design of the user
2:30:27interface sort of fall apart. Because like you said, I don't know that there is person, it's like trying to make a
2:30:34movie without a director, right, right, that there is a screenplay, and there might be a very good person
2:30:39writing the screenplay. And it's the most talented cinematographer is behind the camera. And there's a good film
2:30:44editor, but there's no person whose role is director.
2:30:48And so this, this is exactly right. Like this, I do believe this is all the same with software, I think there's a
2:30:57bunch of people working on this that like, I think all of these people can collectively say,
2:31:02this is their app, or this is their OS that they worked on that day that they are the author. I think
2:31:07everyone isn't everyone who works on this stuff is entitled to say that they that they made it like
2:31:11unequivocally. But there has to be right, like there's this person that like everyone's meeting
2:31:16that vision. And I've used the word vision to describe this thing like directorial stuff,
2:31:20there is someone's vision that they have. And like, when it meets that, that's when we're shipping.
2:31:24And I think it was so clearly Steve, while Steve was there, like that was the person who that was,
2:31:31because he would go on stage and talk about things in a way that like had a level of familiarity with
2:31:36like, I don't just know this, because I like my team worked on it. I know it because I use it every
2:31:42day. There was this whole thing where it was very clear, but like, I'm not knocking on Tim,
2:31:47like Tim Cook is like a good CEO. But like, but like, I don't think that he's the person that like making
2:31:53these decisions. It's not him that's like that he's not the tastemaker at the company. And so and I think
2:31:59maybe like hardware wise, like the tastemaker was like Johnny I for a long time. And I think in the
2:32:05collaboration with Steve, he defined what that was. I think that the installation of Alan Dye as the, you know,
2:32:12UI person at the time made him basically the tastemaker. Like you said, we don't know who it
2:32:17really is. But he's the person that's on the face of it. He's the person with the title, like, for all
2:32:21intents and purposes, he's he's the guy. Right. But I guess my question that I've had is, why does he have
2:32:29this job? Why is he the person that does it? Because I think you and I like, even if you don't think like
2:32:35Wes Anderson makes the best movies, I think we have to agree, like, he is the definition of that
2:32:39author, like he is million percent that kind of person, right? So like, you have this clear vision,
2:32:45everyone is in service of that. And you see it in the people that like are the cinematographers,
2:32:50you see it in the people that are the actors that he chooses, everyone there is like fully committed to
2:32:55the vision. And I think that was true. When Steve was there that like everyone and I've talked with
2:33:00like friends at Apple, like that have been there that used to work there people I used to work with,
2:33:05everyone agrees about this. Everyone was happy to let go of like their own personal like idea of how
2:33:14things should be in service of the vision that Steve generally had. Yes, we were still making all
2:33:19these individual decisions. Yes, we were still deciding how but we were all like in the back of our
2:33:24minds is like, what is the thing that we are guiding towards? And it was always like toward the vision
2:33:28that Steve had. So like the thing? Yeah, go ahead. Well, there's the type of clothing you like to
2:33:34wear. And I, you know, I like very boring clothes and lots of grays and basic colors and navy blue is
2:33:40flashy for me. But if I were picking the clothes for a character in a Wes Anderson movie, I know what I'm
2:33:46supposed to be. You know what that's supposed to be. You wouldn't necessarily be the best person to
2:33:51fit the wardrobe. But like, but like you under but you but the person who does do wardrobe for Wes
2:33:56know that probably doesn't themselves dress like a when Wes Anderson, Wes Anderson, right, but they pick
2:34:02clothes for a Wes Anderson character, right? And they're happy to do it. Yeah, because they're happy to do it
2:34:07because yes, we we've just got like very few like real auteurs like who have like vision in the world in a
2:34:15bunch of them exist in film, a bunch of them exist in other mediums, where it is a collaborative thing that they
2:34:20work on. I mean, a lot of artists are like painting and they're the only people they don't have to have other people
2:34:25working to that vision, right? But software is the thing where it's like, we do need someone to have
2:34:32good taste, good vision that everyone collectively trusts. It can't just be for Apple, because because
2:34:40that team develops for the entire platform. They're developing for every developer that like is going
2:34:46to be designing things. They're designing it to the standards that this team develops. So everyone that is
2:34:52like making apps, they're like making like liquid glass UI, they're all doing this stuff. And it's
2:34:56like, everyone collectively is placing an immense amount of trust in that person, whoever that is,
2:35:03that team to develop the best things. And I just think like, some of these people who are developing
2:35:07apps have been developing like macOS and iOS apps for longer than those people have, and maybe have a
2:35:13idea for what their app is supposed to look like. I'm not saying abandon liquid glass. I'm not saying
2:35:18not put it in there. But like, maybe you have a good idea about what it's supposed to be.
2:35:25I really think it's fascinating that literally aqua and Steve Jobs's introduction of it was we're
2:35:31calling it aqua because it's liquid, that there is a sort of full circle to this. And going with the
2:35:39Wes Anderson art director, right? What colors are you going to suggest for the interior of an apartment
2:35:45that the scene is set in? Well, there's a lot of colors Wes Anderson uses in his movies,
2:35:51but they're within a very narrow palette of colors. You're not going to pick most colors.
2:35:55And when you're designing the shot, you're making sure it's symmetrical. There's a bunch of like
2:36:00very quintessential characteristics, right? Yeah. And maybe you don't, maybe you as a cinematographer
2:36:05like weird Dutch angles and stuff too. You like a different situation. But you know what you're
2:36:10doing for this system. And aqua was an extraordinarily opinionated UI system. And it wasn't really to my
2:36:19taste personally. Right. It was a little too childish or maybe childish isn't right, but
2:36:25Windows XP was childish. But then yes, yeah, right. And I turned my-
2:36:28But it was opinionated. It had an idea.
2:36:30In those early years, I used the graphite option instead of the red, yellow, green button and blues.
2:36:35You're like, I don't want this for children. I'm trying to be a professional.
2:36:39I did. I liked the graphite though. And I also think that the graphite was not spitefully designed.
2:36:46I think that they took it, they made it look as good as they could.
2:36:50No, I think so too. John, I am unsurprised and I think everyone else would be unsurprised to know
2:36:53that you prefer graphite because your website is also that color because the Yankees color is
2:36:57similar to that. You like this color gray, John. Like you just do.
2:37:02At some point though, in the flattening era, I switched to the full color, red, yellow, green.
2:37:08Uh-huh, uh-huh.
2:37:09Because, because the graphite option in Mac OS X at some point in the last 10 plus years, 10-ish years,
2:37:15became to me spitefully designed. Like, okay, sure, you lose red, yellow.
2:37:19They had it because they feel like they had to have it.
2:37:21Yeah. And it made everything look disabled instead of when you lose, you know.
2:37:25Well, that goes, like when we were talking about like the tools available on the system to design
2:37:29like different elements to communicate what those things are supposed to be. Like that thing you said
2:37:34about going from like black and white checkerboard pixels to being gray. Like when we had more tool
2:37:39to design buttons, you could design a button that looked active, disabled. You could design one that
2:37:43looked inactive. It was an inactive, inactive, disabled. You could have this entire matrix of all of the
2:37:49different states of a button and it was all super clear. When we reduce it down to just color,
2:37:55it's like, it's just a rounded shape and it's got like a color or not a color, then it's, man,
2:38:01that is so much harder to distinguish. And it does make it so that graphite, like as a, as a design
2:38:06choice, then, well, then what's the difference between this and this button? It's, I don't know.
2:38:09Yeah. Do we, Apple willfully took away things like depth from the toolkit of visual language that
2:38:17could be used. But the thing is with Aqua in hindsight, I have a much, I feel much more affinity
2:38:23for it in hindsight than I did extemporaneously at the time because I took for granted that it would
2:38:28be a cohesive system overall. I, that was just table stakes for me. So of course it was a very cohesive
2:38:36system of design. And now that, that Apple's UI design language is unsystematic in so many ways.
2:38:45Yeah. Yeah. I look back at that and I think, well, at least Aqua was a wholly consistent within itself
2:38:52system. Yeah. And even if you were the developer, let's say like Omnigroup who makes
2:38:58pro apps like productivity apps for people who've outgrown things like text edit and that you need
2:39:07something a little more serious. I think Aqua was a little too playful for Omni's brand, but Omni did
2:39:13the right thing by saying, okay, but if this is the system design, we're going to embrace it
2:39:19wholeheartedly and go all in on it, even if it's not really the right fit for our brand. And I think
2:39:24that's why starting with tiger and into the lion and or leopard and snow leopard era, that 2004 to 2011
2:39:34era, why it was such a golden age was that the playful consumer apps like iTunes could still be
2:39:42playful and consumery, but the design language had evolved into a slightly more serious way where
2:39:50serious pro apps could look even more serious and proie, right? Like I think that's final, the early
2:39:57versions of final cut pro are some of the best looking pure UI design I've ever seen. And those
2:40:04early versions of iMovie looked less pro, but they also looked sort of like, Hey, this is not like a
2:40:13super casual app. Even if you're using iMovie to make your home movies, you're doing something kind of
2:40:19serious, right? You're hooking up a firewire camera and you're importing all this video and you're
2:40:23editing video. You're taking, you're, you're becoming a video editor. So it looked a little
2:40:28more serious than, I don't know, the calculator app or something. I don't know, but the language of that
2:40:34era of Apple design encompassed that range that Steve Jobs set out to cover from novice.
2:40:42I think, yep, yep. I think that the style, the style of Aqua though was so adaptable and now it's
2:40:48what made it work. And like those other products that you're talking about, those like productivity
2:40:52tools or pro apps, they didn't ignore Aqua. They acknowledged Aqua. They understood what it was
2:40:58trying to do. They adapted it to their product. Aperture was like entirely graphite. The UI was
2:41:05graphite. The buttons were graphite. The window was graphite, right? I mean, there's some of those
2:41:11things where it's like these, these kinds of apps, like even GarageBand was super playful, right? Now
2:41:16like in comparison to like these other apps, GarageBand had like wood on the side of the, but it was just,
2:41:22but it was like, but it like took away almost no screen real estate. Nobody cares. Like it's no big
2:41:27deal, but it's, but it puts you in, it puts you in a mood. It puts, it puts a visual clarity on what
2:41:31this app is versus what this other app is. But at no point that it looked like it was not part of the
2:41:36same system. And I think it's because there was like a, there was a visual richness to Aqua that
2:41:43was like, okay, so the system looks like this. So we, even if we have buttons that are rich Corinthian
2:41:49leather, even if we have buttons that are wood, right? Even if we have these other materials,
2:41:53they need to match this level of quality, right? Of this visual quality that this has. And it's like
2:41:59this thing that everyone is working on this movie, right? Everyone sees what the direction is and
2:42:04everyone's like, okay, so in the Aqua cinematic universe, there's actually more room for than
2:42:08just Aqua, right? And that was true on iOS too, right? I mean, like early iOS stuff, like when it
2:42:15was iPhone OS, right? iPhone OS had all of these different kinds of material qualities to it where
2:42:21like any app could do whatever it wanted, especially because it was taking up the full screen at the
2:42:26time, right? I mean, like you could do anything and it was not incongruous with the system, but
2:42:30like as long as you acknowledged like what the system was trying to do, then you could play with
2:42:34it a little bit. Can you do that with liquid glass? Because it feels to me that if it doesn't look
2:42:41like liquid glass, then it looks wrong on the platform, right? There's no alternative quality.
2:42:46There's no alternative material to use. It's not like you can suddenly use paper, but make it looks
2:42:51like it belongs in the liquid glass cinematic universe. And that's why I'm so disappointed overall
2:42:56with the big new UI. Like when it was, we didn't even know what it was supposed to look like, but
2:43:00there were rumors for the last year that Apple's doing a big platforms spanning UI redesign and that
2:43:08it's going to add some kind of texture and glass and something. And I was so hopeful that it would bring
2:43:15back some of that era. Yeah. Some of that tactical quality, some of that richness. Yeah. And just the
2:43:23fucking fun, right? Like the first voice recorder app that looked like an exquisitely rendered reel
2:43:30to reel tape machine. Because what are you doing when you're recording a voice memo or a memo? Well,
2:43:37the app, the phone just sits on a fucking table while you talk. You hit a record button and you're like,
2:43:44I'm going to record this conversation, this meeting, and it's just sitting there on the table. And so
2:43:49what's shown on screen? Well, at that point, at that point, because you know that you don't need
2:43:55that screen in that moment, that's like the open door to like ornamentation and fun and silly.
2:44:00Right. Yeah. That old voice recorded, the original voice recorder interface made me want to make voice
2:44:06memos. It just made me want to use it to hit. You're talking, you're talking about the podcast app,
2:44:11but the voice, the voice recorder had the VU meter, right? Oh, that's right. It was like,
2:44:15I have the yellow screen with all the VU interface. Yes. But it made me want to listen to podcasts.
2:44:20Right. Right. And it's, and it was so silly because it's like, you could swipe away the album art of the
2:44:24whole thing and see the reel to reel actually working. And it was like, yeah, it's super cool. And it's
2:44:29super fun. And it's, you know, what I think is a great example of this stuff is like,
2:44:33is like iBooks, like the original iBooks on iPad was like, it was like trying to be a physical book,
2:44:40which like is a little silly. Like when you think about it, but like, but like the page actually
2:44:45moving with your finger, the UI existing on the page, you understood it. Like the skeuomorphism of
2:44:52this made it fun. In addition to being like helpful thing for you to understand what it is that you're
2:44:57looking at. Right. And when it was cool looking to turn pages, it made you want to read the book
2:45:02and turn the pages. Right. Yeah. I really, I really think so. Yeah. And I do think I do. I've always
2:45:07thought one of the worst. So most canards and idioms are, there's a lot of truth to them. I think one of
2:45:15the worst is that you can't judge a book by the cover because I judge all books by the cover.
2:45:19Yeah. That's what we're all doing. Yeah. And I'm not saying that there are, can't be a great book
2:45:24with a bad cover and there can't be, there aren't books with very good covers that are bad books,
2:45:29but there is a correlation between the quality of cover design and the quality of books.
2:45:33It's like the chair that you put into it overall. It's not just the content of it. If you know that
2:45:40the content is good, you better bet like you want that cover to be representative of the quality that
2:45:46you put inside the book. And the most important thing in a book is the quality of the prose and the
2:45:51meaning of it itself, of course, but a good book on printed on good paper with good typesetting in a
2:45:59good typeface makes me want to read it even more. Yeah. And a book in a bad typeface printed on cheap
2:46:06paper makes me want to read it less. So here's, so here's my, my, and the same is true for user
2:46:13interfaces. Right. And so here's my question with that is if everyone skates toward this liquid glass
2:46:17puck and everyone's app starts to look like this, we're all deciding that we're okay with our apps
2:46:24looking like they're what Apple says they should look like. And it kind of removes a bunch of the
2:46:30freedom, the capability that we once had to design apps. We're like relinquishing this control,
2:46:36right. Of how this is supposed to look. And in doing so, all, every app like now looks the same,
2:46:42right. Like they all look like they have the same like fundamental controls. If you're a third
2:46:47party developer, do you do that? I've heard people talk about not implementing liquid glass,
2:46:52which also seems like a bad idea. I don't know the right solution here because we're kind of in like
2:46:56between two really tough situations. Like you can play it fun and different and not liquid glass,
2:47:03but you really just like making it more difficult for yourself. But then again,
2:47:07all the old apps that were not using Aqua that were using custom interfaces, we were all doing
2:47:12the same thing then. We were like, well, by not using a real button, that means we have to make
2:47:16our own states. We have to make all of the states and we have to design our own buttons. And it was
2:47:20more difficult to do than just using stock UI. Right. Because you, there's all sorts of edge,
2:47:26edge cases, edge cases that the stock UI handles that are hard to get right.
2:47:32Yeah. And this is the thing, this is, I mean, of course, I mean, we, we, we, we could talk about
2:47:36this part forever, but non-native apps on Mac OS that don't actually behave like they're native
2:47:42apps. Even though you understand the thing, it's like for ages, like discord, like just kind of an
2:47:48awful app all around. It's just like, I would use discord. And it's like, if you hover over the
2:47:52window control, they didn't have that X minus like plus thing. And you're like, but that's what it's
2:47:58supposed to be. So don't you notice that? How do you make the app without noticing?
2:48:03That's what I was like. Yeah. And so when making apps, I feel like using what the system provides
2:48:08for free is always, always quote, quote, a sound idea because you get inherited all of these decisions.
2:48:15Right. But when you no longer trust that the decisions are being made in good taste, in good
2:48:21conscience, like in, if you don't believe in it anymore, what do you do? And I think the lack of
2:48:28material quality is like a real bummer. Like the fact that no one can make a button look like anything
2:48:33else other than glass. Like what if your app just doesn't like jive with that? What if it's just not
2:48:39what that app is supposed to look like? I keep wondering what does Final Cut Pro look like in this
2:48:44world? I like, cause we talked about how that would acknowledge like the system and then design
2:48:49something differently. I don't know. We haven't even talked about app icons, John.
2:48:53We are running out of time though.
2:48:56I just like the material stuff. It's like, how are we going to communicate everything with glass?
2:49:02Why is like, why is it an eyedropper rubber part? Why is it glass? Why is it now glass? That
2:49:09doesn't make any sense. Even, even though the other part of the eyedropper is supposed to be glass.
2:49:15Yeah. It doesn't even look like glass in that context anymore. It doesn't look like it's supposed
2:49:20to. Like developers are giving up this sort of control to Apple to decide what their apps are
2:49:25supposed to look like. And I wonder on a brand level, so many companies are doing the same thing.
2:49:30They're going to have to start looking at their apps being like, do we want to pivot our brand to
2:49:35looking like this now? If you're black and Decker, do you want your app to look like it's
2:49:40this fragile? You know, like that sort of element? I don't know. That doesn't make any sense to me.
2:49:44You know, we were talking about like the tone of how Apple's talking about this stuff. And I think
2:49:48it's an interesting difference because Steve used to be like, this is done just because it's cool.
2:49:52Whereas like now it's, this is glass and yeah, maybe it is cool. But if every app starts using it as
2:49:59their like app icons as their, as their like primary branding element, like they're, Apple's making
2:50:05that decision for people. You know how they do this with like app icons? They're like, we're, this, this
2:50:11developer did not update for the liquid glass aesthetic. However, we did it for you. Yeah. And it's actually
2:50:17what ego does that have? Like it is implicated. Suddenly you're making decisions for these other
2:50:22companies of what their logo should look like. What can you imagine other companies doing this for
2:50:28Apple? No, no, no. We're going to make the Apple logo like this appearance. What? So I kind of feel
2:50:36that way about the option to make clear icons, right? Yes. That same. Exactly. It's like the developer
2:50:42didn't choose that. The designer didn't design. I mean, like we can design for it in hopes of it,
2:50:46I totally get the light mode, dark mode and okay. Now we're going to have and recommend dark mode
2:50:52icons, but the clear mode, like if the color is essential to your brand, it's right. It's suddenly
2:51:00it just is, it's not like they're saying everyone should have an identifiable glitch. And I think
2:51:06that's what I do all day, John. I draw iPhones for a living, right? I don't know how to, I don't think
2:51:12every app can fit that model, right? It works for Apple's own apps. They can make the phone app,
2:51:17just the fucking telephone glyph. Okay. But not everyone can make just the telephone glyph for
2:51:21their own VoIP app. You have to make it distinct from Apple's. So you're going to have to decide not
2:51:27just a different glyph, but a different metaphor or a different visual style. And it's, if you're also
2:51:31limited by material, it's like the thing we were talking about. It's like, we have all these tools now
2:51:36with the visual interface. We don't have to do just the black and white checkerboard anymore,
2:51:40but now we're like, but now you have to do glass. And it's like, for app icons, I just don't see how
2:51:45that makes sense. I don't either. And I, as a proprietor of a company like Parakeet that makes
2:51:52app icons all the time, I'm just like, will all of our app icons just look like glass now?
2:51:56I don't know. When someone comes to my entire portfolio just looks like glass now.
2:52:00Do you think there's going to, when this ships in the fall and the updates come out and everybody's
2:52:06whatever version 26.1 that Apple decides, okay, this is good to push to everybody. And remember,
2:52:1226.0 in mid-September will go to everybody who gets an iPhone 17 on day one, right? You don't have an
2:52:19option. So there will be millions of people who get this in September. Do you think there's going to be
2:52:25a backlash? Is it going to be...
2:52:28Well, they already put out public betas to the people who are at least...
2:52:31Yeah, but there's...
2:52:32No, I'm not saying it's the same. I'm saying like, it's another level, right, to get there. And it's
2:52:36like, I do... I think some people won't notice. I'm going to be honest.
2:52:40Of course, some people won't.
2:52:42Some people don't notice.
2:52:42There's going to be tons of people that won't notice a difference or that will, but they won't
2:52:45be able to put their fingers on it. Like, I get that. There's people that don't use their
2:52:49phone that much or that use it a lot, but don't look at that stuff. I get it.
2:52:53I think there will be people who will are using the music app and won't understand why
2:52:58they made the decisions that they did, right? I think they will be like, wait, where did
2:53:01this go? We saw this happen with Photos. When they launched Photos last year, everyone
2:53:05was so confused about it. Like, you got rid of the tab bar so you could put all this long
2:53:10list of collections. I think there will be backlash, but I don't think anyone's going
2:53:14to know. It's like this thing. I think, you know, like you brought up Todd Vaziri before.
2:53:19Like he says this about, you know, when people say it's bad CGI, is it really that it's bad
2:53:24CGI or is it just that like something else in the movie like was bad and you're directing
2:53:29all of your attention on the visual thing you can see, right? If that same thing applies,
2:53:34people might feel uncomfortable with this new version of the OS. They might look at it and
2:53:38be like, it's the visual material. God damn it. That glass, it looks bad. And it's like,
2:53:42maybe it's not that. Maybe it's the UI underlying the thing, but they just don't have the vocabulary
2:53:47to know that that's what that is. They'll focus on the fact that in music,
2:53:51I can't read the song that's playing. Right. And I think a lot of people already have been
2:53:55doing that. And so I think that's indicative of how it will go publicly. But like, I think
2:53:59like we've been talking about, I think the real issue is UI stuff. And I think especially UI stuff
2:54:05on Mac OS. I don't know if Mac OS users, the diehard Mac OS users will really care. They will find
2:54:11this like deeply upsetting, but like the people who casually use any of this stuff, they probably
2:54:15won't even notice. Yeah. That's why it makes it so hard to predict whether there's going to be a
2:54:20backlash. I'm surprised. I was very surprised. Personally, I use the photos app a lot. I mean,
2:54:24photos is my main photo store and I take a lot of pictures and I don't love all the changes from last
2:54:29year's photos, but I didn't feel, and I'm just literally, literally my job is to complain about
2:54:34Apple UI and I didn't find photos app that bad. But I kind of grew over the year. I started trying to
2:54:42listen to what people were saying. And like TikTok videos were very poor form. One minute of vertical
2:54:47video was a very poor, but I eventually got it is that people did use the tab bar and they did want
2:54:54the main tab to just show their photos. And now it didn't. And that they had all the stuff at the
2:54:59bottom that they didn't want when they just wanted their photos. And I'd say, Oh yeah, that is kind of
2:55:04a big change. And it was more of a backlash. So I, I, I kind of hope, I mean, I kind of hope that
2:55:11there's like photos last year's photos times 10 knee jerk reaction to this and that it leads to change.
2:55:20Am I saying, I think Alan Dye should be fired. I don't know. I don't know, but maybe, or maybe,
2:55:27you know, again, like maybe, I don't know who's in charge. Maybe, I don't know. But maybe instead
2:55:32of firing him, they start selling pizzas out of the back of Apple stores and Alan Dye can run that
2:55:39and do the graphic design on the boxes. Do the menus. I think Alan Dye could kill that with his Levi's
2:55:49experience, right? I think it's the Kate Spade that'll really seal the deal. Like John, if there
2:55:56is all of this, if there is a theoretical backlash, you know how Apple's doing this thing now where
2:56:01like actually on iOS now, they're doing it with mail. They're doing it with photos, I think. And on
2:56:07phone, they definitely did. They were like, here, try out this alternate UI. I don't know if you've
2:56:12noticed this, but you open the phone app and it's like, we have this new unified UI. We put voicemails
2:56:16and memos and whatever. And they do with mail. They're doing, they basically did that with all
2:56:21of photos. And that's what, like, it was just forcibly, right? But they're doing this thing
2:56:24where they're like, hey, you can try this other thing or go back to the old way or whatever.
2:56:28And I, I think this is a very odd place for them to be in where they're going to start offering like
2:56:33alternate UI for like basically every app. And you don't have to go to settings to do it into the app and
2:56:40then scroll down and find it. It's right there in the upper right corner of the phone app in,
2:56:44in what I'm guessing is called the filter button. It's like an upside down three line. Yeah. Yeah.
2:56:50But you tap it and right at the top permanently, it doesn't go away is a big toggle between unified
2:56:55and classic. Right. And it's like, how long are they going to put this up? And it's just like,
2:56:59how long are they going to have that as an option? How long are they going to put it there? I don't
2:57:03know, but they've been doing this with more and more apps. And it's like, maybe that allows people to
2:57:07have the app that they want. I mean, I'm all for like general app customization. I feel like I got
2:57:12to say that, but, but, but the original iPhone had the more tab and you could put whatever tab you
2:57:18wanted in the tab bar. For some reason, we let go of this perfect solution for all of these problems.
2:57:25If you had to make your own tab bar for literally every app, then no one would have been complaining
2:57:29about the photos app because you could put whatever you wanted there. The issue wasn't that,
2:57:33I can have pinned collections. The issue was like, Hey, actually I use the max view a lot.
2:57:37Why can't that be a tab bar item? I just want quick access to it. That's all I'm asking. And I think
2:57:43Apple's like fake solution to this is, Hey, have you considered making a shortcut for that? You can make
2:57:48a shortcut to do anything. I'm like, yeah, technically I know, but that's a weird backdoor thing that requires
2:57:53like a significant knowledge of like how to do this. You actually have to build UI for people
2:57:58to like just quickly access this stuff. You could, it's one of my favorite features in app kit. It is
2:58:04still there. It's still there in all good Mac apps, but you go to usually in the view menu, edit toolbar or
2:58:11edit. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. It's in the view menu, customized toolbar and it's a standard feature of
2:58:19app kit. And it opens up a standard menu where you have a bunch of toolbar buttons and you can create a
2:58:26minimal interface by taking out standard toolbar buttons. You can reorder them to put the ones
2:58:32that it's sort of like the difference. I often use this analogy. It's the difference between designing
2:58:37plastic toys through injection molding, where you're creating metal dyes and pouring hot plastic into a
2:58:44metal dye to create your own custom toy or snapping together Lego bricks and building your own toys. And yes,
2:58:51your Lego creations are not as refined as a custom toy that Hasbro is selling shrink wrapped in and bubble
2:58:59packaged in a toy store, but it's yours, right? And you get to do it the way you want. And the toolbar in
2:59:07app kit is like that. It's like a little bit of design your own interface for the, for these apps and the
2:59:13original first few versions of iOS or iPhone OS, as you said, it was called at the time kind of had that
2:59:19thinking with tab bars at the bottom with that more button, right? Yes. Where it's like, oh, if you use
2:59:25different features in music, you can put them in the toolbar and put the hide the ones you use less
2:59:31seldomly in the more button. Yeah. And Apple's just moved away from that. And you know, it's still there in
2:59:36app kit, but Apple's making apps for the Mac that aren't app kit that don't have toolbars and don't
2:59:41have any toolbar. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And it's all moving away from that. And it's, well, I think you
2:59:46can, you can have that feature that customized toolbar if you have a good menu bar system, right? You still
2:59:51need to be able to access all of the features of the app. And so maybe that part of the issue is that
2:59:56like, if you no longer have the actual item represented anywhere else, then you can't just tuck it away
3:00:02somewhere, right? You need to be able to make sure that you have it. So it's, it's kind of lazy when
3:00:06an app doesn't have that customized toolbar feature, right? I think like, yeah, the thinking was, I think
3:00:13very clearly that the people who add Apple and next before them who kind of came up with the customized
3:00:18toolbar thing, I think, but that the professional UI designers at the company that tries to hold itself
3:00:25as the best company for UI design overall since the dawn of graphical user interface computing want to
3:00:34spread the enthusiasm for UI design that they have to users to let users customize their design within
3:00:43constraints in a sensible way. Because when you understand how the system works and you know what
3:00:48you want from the tools that you're using, you might want to change them. And we're going to give you
3:00:55the power to do it in a easily understood, easily accessible, consistent way across applications.
3:01:00Go to the view menu, go down to customize. That's why they gave you the tinted icons, John.
3:01:05Right. You can personalize your own experience. I think they're taking the wrong, the wrong lesson.
3:01:10I think they're taking the wrong lessons where they're letting you, they're kind of taking the
3:01:13wrong lesson from that Steve Jobs quote that's off-cited and is a very good one that people make the
3:01:19mistake of thinking design is only how it looks, but it's not only what design is. Design is how it
3:01:25works. And it's really putting into the hands of users only the power to tweak how it looks,
3:01:30which is cool. And if people really want clear icons on their home screen, more power to them.
3:01:35And, but it's only giving them the customization for how it looks and not how it works. And the only
3:01:42place where I see that spirit in Apple in recent years, and I do love it and think it shows that
3:01:48it's alive and well at one place is the lock screen for iPhone and iPad.
3:01:53Yeah. Yeah. They really let you put like widgets and like buttons and they're like, Hey, you know
3:01:57what? We know that you want quick access to these things.
3:02:00And the widgets have grown in the ability to be interactive in with new APIs. And so that's what
3:02:06gives me hope. I don't think all hope is lost. I think that the flame is still burning there and
3:02:11the lock screen and, and in iOS 26, it only gets better. I think it's, it both looks cool the way
3:02:18that the time stretches. I think that just looks cool for the sake of being cool. I also think it's
3:02:23more legible at a distance. It's one of the things I really miss from iOS 26. When I go back to my
3:02:28daily phone on iOS 18, I'm like, Oh, the time looks stupid, all short and squat like that. But also it's
3:02:34more functional where you were able to put the widget buttons in more places with more flexibility
3:02:38and they can do more things. And that's the spirit of the toolbar and app kit, but it's only on the
3:02:44lock screen, which to kind of take this full circle was the thing that was pointless in the original
3:02:49iPhone. Yeah. It was like, it was like, actually don't interact with this, right? It's like, this is
3:02:54the non-interactable. You can modify as a user, tweak the functionality of the lock screen more than
3:03:00you can tweak the functionality of the actual system. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Well, I have good news
3:03:06for you, Louie. Yeah. We hit, we hit three hours. Yes. You did it. Oh, that's all I ever wanted,
3:03:12John. I just love being among the group of what? The dozen people. I don't know. I'll make a list
3:03:17of how many it is, but that's, that is, that is, this is the limits of, of, of time and space. We're
3:03:23going to run out of recording space. Yeah. This was a lot of fun. Well, the reel-to-reel is running out.
3:03:28Yes. The reel-to-reel is running out in my interface here. Louie Mantia, people can find,
3:03:33oh, we didn't even mention Parakeet, right? Where you do consulting work designed by hire.
3:03:38Make like funds and have like funds. Yeah.
3:03:40And what's the URL for Parakeet? That's basically all I do.
3:03:43Is Parakeet.co. That's it.
3:03:46.co. They can, people can go there.
3:03:49Yeah.
3:03:49Your blog is at MN, wait.
3:03:53Oh, you're so close. I love it. You got a bookmark, so you don't need to know the name
3:03:56anymore. It's L-M-N-T dot me.
3:03:58I know. I do. L-M-N-T.
3:03:59Yeah. It's Louie Mantia, but without the vowels, because my name is full of vowels.
3:04:04And in addition to your blog, you've got all sorts of fun stuff there, wallpapers, people,
3:04:10I can't tell you how many times, because probably my, I switch wallpapers all the time, but you
3:04:15know which one's my favorite.
3:04:16I know it's the shining. That's why I had to redo it.
3:04:19It's the shining carpet.
3:04:20Yeah.
3:04:20And I cannot tell you, not just how many times I'm somewhere and somebody sees my lock screen
3:04:26and I'm on, I have your shining carpet wallpaper. And they don't just say, hey, is that your
3:04:31shining wallpaper? They say, is that Louie's shining wallpaper?
3:04:34And I say, oh yeah.
3:04:36Yeah. Well, I'm glad that people can identify my version of it. That's great.
3:04:43Yeah. So I've got a bunch of wallpapers and icons and I don't know, I guess that's the
3:04:47customization at the moment that I can do. So that's the customization I love the most.
3:04:52Well, I thank you for your three hours of time. And this was every-
3:04:57Thank you for giving me three hours of time.
3:04:59It's somehow fun to talk about a thing that you and I have both been frustrated about for
3:05:05a long time.
3:05:06Yeah. Well, it's fun. It's fun to talk about things that you're frustrated about, but I'm glad
3:05:10that we value like these kind of same things from, it's not just nostalgia, is it?
3:05:15No.
3:05:16It's something else.
3:05:18Yeah. It's something lasting, right? It's something that is going to be a craft and an art after
3:05:25you and I are done.
3:05:26And I feel like there's a certain wave that needs to crest here and that I hopefully is sort
3:05:34of cresting with the OS 26s. Anyway, thank you, Louie.
3:05:38Yep. Thank you so much.