0:00:00Matthew, it's been a while.
0:00:01It has.
0:00:01It's been a minute.
0:00:02Yeah, I think we saw each other at WWDC.
0:00:06Yeah, but what year?
0:00:09I don't know.
0:00:12What year is it now?
0:00:13I don't know, but I was just there.
0:00:14Oh, yeah.
0:00:16The talk show, after the talk show, maybe your last appearance there, which was quite good,
0:00:21by the way.
0:00:21Yeah, we chatted a bit.
0:00:23But yeah, other than that, it's been a minute.
0:00:25I've been out of the Apple orbit.
0:00:26Oh, that's right.
0:00:28That's right.
0:00:28I did see you at the talk show.
0:00:30Yeah, yeah.
0:00:31See, the problem is that I saw you at my show, and my show, I'm in a tube of concentration.
0:00:40I completely forgot that I saw you.
0:00:41And after.
0:00:43Yeah, exactly.
0:00:44While you're in the lead-up, it's all the adrenaline and focus of the show, and in the aftermath,
0:00:50it's all the endorphin release, so you forget it.
0:00:52It was good to see you, but it's been a long time since you've been on the show.
0:00:57On the show.
0:00:58It has.
0:00:58Yes, it has.
0:00:59At the show.
0:00:59You've been at the show more recently than on the show, which is very unusual.
0:01:03Yeah, it's probably a rare occurrence.
0:01:07Well, anyway, the idea popped in my head to have you back.
0:01:10There's lots that we can talk about.
0:01:12I have not gone through every single email I've gotten over the last 10 days yet, but I believe you're the only person to point out the technical corrections from my post, which is so very much appreciated.
0:01:38Oh, yeah.
0:01:39That's like my itch I get to scratch, because I'm not blogging on a daily basis anymore.
0:01:43Well, I am on my personal blog, but I'm not blogging for most of the public.
0:01:48And so, like, I'm the dairy fireball comment section.
0:01:50I'm just going to text Josh.
0:01:52That's how I get my jollies.
0:01:54So, somehow, despite being a – everybody knows.
0:01:59I mean, this is – I mean, if you're really new here to the podcast, if you're not aware, I'm a James Bond fan.
0:02:06I obsess over logos and design.
0:02:10So, the designer of the James Bond 007 logo is an intersection of my interest that is very rare.
0:02:19And the guy died one day before his 104th birthday.
0:02:24And he seemed to have a really great long life, this documentary that was made about him at the end.
0:02:34It was – I'm looking at my post.
0:02:36By design, the Joe Kareff story, which is streaming on the Max.
0:02:40I still haven't watched it, because I've been so busy this week.
0:02:42But it is at the top of my queue.
0:02:46Apparently, it's only a couple years old.
0:02:48He was interviewed – he's in it at age 101, and people who have watched it have said he's sharp as a tack.
0:02:53So, I mean, that's about as good as it gets, right?
0:02:56Yeah, exactly.
0:02:57It's sort of unheralded.
0:02:59Like, that was sort of some of the commentary in his obituaries is that – and it's not just, oh, he did one thing of renown, the 007 gun logo.
0:03:08He did all of these amazing posters.
0:03:10He did a whole bunch of posters from the heyday of Woody Allen's career, like the fantastic poster.
0:03:15Yeah, I think he did Manhattan.
0:03:16Yeah, which is a really good poster.
0:03:19It's really, really good.
0:03:20And West Side Story.
0:03:21I mean, you can't get much more iconic.
0:03:23Right.
0:03:24Yeah, the West Side Story poster is sort of poster as logo.
0:03:31It's almost like the poster is the logo for that movie, and it's so literally iconic that it just feels like it was always there, right?
0:03:42Because that's a movie from before we were born, and it just feels like one of those movies that – I'm not a huge musical fan, to say the least, but it's a super well-done, famous, renowned movie.
0:03:54And the logo itself with the fire escape and the dancing figures and the name attached, West Side Story, that is – it's literally a logo and has been used for the musical on Broadway and many other cases, you know?
0:04:05You know, he had this renowned career, but he wasn't really – you know, he was sort of a –
0:04:11Saul Bass, I guess, would be the number one person to compare him to from the era as somebody who designed posters and worked with great filmmakers over the years and just really didn't get the acclaim, but didn't really look for the acclaim either, you know?
0:04:26I like his philosophy about it.
0:04:27He's like, hey, it got me a lot of work.
0:04:29Yeah, yeah.
0:04:29Which is like a very – I think these days people are, ah, I did that.
0:04:33I need credit.
0:04:34And he's like, hey, I got work.
0:04:36I lived.
0:04:36Yeah.
0:04:37Yeah, and he started – he was doing pretty well because the thing is that it is a curiosity that he only got $300 one-time fee for the 007 logo and no other royalties or anything like that.
0:04:51But I saw in one of his obituaries by, like, you know, that was Dr. No was 1961 or 62.
0:04:58And by the end of the 60s, he had started his own design firm in New York and had 22 people on staff.
0:05:04So, you know, he's –
0:05:05Yeah, he was doing okay.
0:05:07Yeah, I mean, I think one of his 70s posters that stood out to me was the Cabaret poster.
0:05:11Oh, that was good.
0:05:12And so, like, that was – yeah, I think that was 1972.
0:05:14So – but you definitely continued to have a career and make an iconic stuff.
0:05:18And it's just unbelievable.
0:05:20The spaghetti westerns that Sergio Leone made, the Good, the Bad, and – I don't know if he did the Good, the Bad, and Ugly, but he did A Fistful of Dollars and a Few Dollars More, which are some of the – my favorite westerns ever – or movies ever made.
0:05:34Just fantastic.
0:05:35Just fantastic.
0:05:35And just really, really cool posters.
0:05:37But just all – across all genres of movies, great work.
0:05:41Just really cool.
0:05:42But that 007 logo, man, what a great logo.
0:05:46Talk about a logo, too, that from my perception as a kid born in 1973, already into the – as a baby, the Roger Moore era, that logo just felt like it was already part of the universe.
0:06:04It's –
0:06:05Right.
0:06:05Like, it had always been.
0:06:07Like, the best design tends to feel inevitable.
0:06:09And it was like, of course, that's the – of course.
0:06:12You know, it feels embedded in the fabric of the universe.
0:06:14Yeah.
0:06:15It's like, what does a dollar – a U.S. dollar bill look like?
0:06:18Well, everybody knows.
0:06:19It's about six inches long, and it's got green on the back.
0:06:23And then, you know, you look at, like, what money looked like in 1850, and you're like, what the fuck is that?
0:06:28Right?
0:06:30Right.
0:06:30Yeah.
0:06:30You're like, this is not right.
0:06:32Yeah.
0:06:33Lie.
0:06:34This is a lie.
0:06:35It's like they've got, like, pre-Civil War dollars that are – I don't know.
0:06:38They're like a whole sheet of paper, like a diploma.
0:06:41And it's like, what is that?
0:06:43How in the world are you walking around with that?
0:06:44But that's what the 007 logo was to me.
0:06:48And I mentioned, you know, it was just one of those things where I thought, oh, you know, I at least got a link to this guy's post.
0:06:54And all of a sudden, I spent all day writing about it.
0:06:56And I was like, why am I regretting this?
0:06:58This is why I have a site like Daring Fireball, so I can spend a whole day writing about this.
0:07:04Yeah.
0:07:04And I got to scratch an itch that I have literally had to some degree as long as I can remember knowing who and what James Bond are.
0:07:18I mean, so this is going back to some point in the late 70s as me being six, seven, eight years old.
0:07:26I don't know if I had seen a James Bond movie in a theater yet, but I know that I had seen them on TV.
0:07:34And part of my bizarro gift that I sometimes mention on the show that I have an unbelievable ability to tell you what network a TV show was on for most of my life.
0:07:52Surely this will come in handy at some point.
0:07:54And I didn't study it.
0:07:57It wasn't like I sat there with the TV guide and memorized it.
0:08:00It just comes to me naturally.
0:08:02It has something to do with my brain being a sponge for branding.
0:08:07Name a TV show from, like, the 80s.
0:08:10Name a couple.
0:08:11The 18.
0:08:13NBC, Tuesdays, 8 p.m.
0:08:16That's fantastic.
0:08:18Maybe not.
0:08:18But I can often tell you what day.
0:08:21But I know 100% NBC.
0:08:23Okay, got it.
0:08:24Yeah.
0:08:25And then what about Dukes of Hazzard?
0:08:27CBS.
0:08:28Okay.
0:08:30Forget what day of the week, though.
0:08:32Yeah, I don't know.
0:08:33This is.
0:08:34Yeah, days of the week, let's forget.
0:08:36But definitely CBS.
0:08:37Yeah.
0:08:38Or one more.
0:08:39One more.
0:08:39Airwolf.
0:08:40Ooh.
0:08:43That's a good one.
0:08:44That's a late 80s one.
0:08:46Airwolf.
0:08:47Who?
0:08:48Was that Jan Michael Vincent?
0:08:50It was.
0:08:51Ooh, it's either CBS or NBC.
0:08:53But I'm going to go CBS.
0:08:54Look it up.
0:08:56It was CBS.
0:08:57Yep.
0:08:58The tricky parts is when you get to the shows that were ripoffs of the others.
0:09:03Right.
0:09:04So Blue Thunder?
0:09:05Wasn't Blue Thunder, like, one of the other helicopter ones?
0:09:08Yeah, somebody else had a helicopter one.
0:09:10And it was all because of the Clint Eastwood movie with the, I forget what the Clint Eastwood
0:09:16movie, maybe with Ernest Ford.
0:09:17Foxfire?
0:09:17Yeah, Foxfire.
0:09:19So they ripped off that, right?
0:09:21And then it was like, Clint Eastwood's movies inspired a lot of TV shows.
0:09:25We're going on a digression here.
0:09:26But remember that there's-
0:09:28What?
0:09:28What else is very fireball than an enormous digression?
0:09:31Especially in August.
0:09:32But remember, Eastwood made Every Which Way But Loose, where he played sort of a rowdy tractor-trailer
0:09:41driver.
0:09:41With the monkey.
0:09:42Whose companion was an orangutan.
0:09:44Yes.
0:09:46And then there was a show, oh Christ, I can't even remember what the show was called, but
0:09:52I know it was on NBC, about a guy who drove a truck, but it wasn't a total ripoff, because
0:09:59it wasn't an orangutan, it was a chimpanzee.
0:10:01Oh, okay.
0:10:03That's how they avoided the infringement case.
0:10:05Yeah, but I know it was on NBC.
0:10:06About BJ and the Bear.
0:10:07BJ and the Bear.
0:10:08That, and I guarantee you it was on NBC.
0:10:10That's how sick and twisted my ability to tell you what network it is.
0:10:14I couldn't remember the name of the show, but I could tell you what network it was.
0:10:18So, part of that, it's not just the shows, I can tell you that when I was a kid, you know
0:10:24how like family vacations are often usually the same week of the year, and it was-
0:10:30Yeah, within the variance, but they're normally kind of like-
0:10:33Yeah, it was like my dad would, I think we'd go like at the end of July or the beginning
0:10:38of August, either last week of July or beginning of August, we would go to Wildwood, New Jersey,
0:10:43the shore, five or six days, and I think we always left on a Monday, and there were a
0:10:50couple of years, I don't know if they were in a row, but on the Sunday night before we
0:10:55left for the shore, ABC's million dollar movie of the week was an old James Bond movie.
0:11:00Okay.
0:11:01And usually, because they were the old ones that ABC could afford to put on commercial
0:11:06TV, they were the ones with Sean Connery.
0:11:08Right.
0:11:08And I remember watching them with my dad, and you know, I'm a kid.
0:11:13And I'm like, I don't know, six, seven, eight years old.
0:11:15So it wasn't like I was responsible for packing.
0:11:17Right.
0:11:18Yeah.
0:11:19So long for the ride.
0:11:20And I loved them.
0:11:22But it's so crazy.
0:11:25It's the way kids are so in tune to what's truly new, that in like, as like a six-year-old in
0:11:351979, I thought like Goldfinger from 1964 looked 100 years old.
0:11:43And I remember thinking, this is good.
0:11:46I like watching it.
0:11:47But this is nowhere near as cool as the new ones with Roger Moore.
0:11:51And my dad telling me, this is such a great, iconic dad moment where he didn't yell at me.
0:11:58He didn't scream at me.
0:11:59Right.
0:12:00He just said, John, those new ones are good.
0:12:04But he's not a better James Bond than Sean Connery.
0:12:07There's no comparison.
0:12:08Yeah.
0:12:08Yeah.
0:12:09And I was like, you got to be kidding me.
0:12:11And I was like, my God.
0:12:12It's just this.
0:12:12And I remember thinking, this is my dad is so old.
0:12:15He thinks that Sean Connery is a better James Bond.
0:12:17And my dad just said it to me.
0:12:19Well, the new one has a Lotus in it.
0:12:21How could you say that?
0:12:22Right.
0:12:22Exactly.
0:12:23The Sean Connery is just driving around in that dumb old gray car, whatever that is.
0:12:28No, not even any pop-up headlights on that thing.
0:12:33Yeah.
0:12:34Although that Lotus is pretty cool.
0:12:36But it was on ABC.
0:12:37And it was like every year in the summer, ABC, to fill a Sunday night, would have an old James Bond movie.
0:12:43I loved them.
0:12:44But one of the things that I noticed, because I've always had this aptitude to notice logos,
0:12:51which is how I associate the commercial breaks, because there'd be an ABC logo while you're watching an ABC show.
0:12:58And it just sticks in my head.
0:13:00And I just remember thinking, ever since I can remember, that the way that they make 007 into a gun is cool.
0:13:08That's cool.
0:13:10Guns are cool.
0:13:11I mean, that's how kids think, or at least thought back then.
0:13:15Oh, yeah.
0:13:15Guns are cool.
0:13:16And what could better represent James Bond than a gun?
0:13:19But I remember thinking, but the gun in the logo doesn't look like a gun that James Bond uses.
0:13:25It's not like that little Walter PPK that he sticks in the holster and fits under his suit.
0:13:30It's this long-nosed, Luger-looking gun that wouldn't really comfortably fit in a little side holster under your suit jacket.
0:13:40And anyway, we're getting to your excellent, excellent reader feedback.
0:13:46Turns out it's not—there are pictures of Sean Connery with a Luger-looking gun, but it's not a Luger.
0:13:54Right.
0:13:55Right?
0:13:56What is it?
0:13:57It's actually an air pistol, so it's not even a real gun.
0:14:01I think the story was that there were some photo shoots being done for promo, and they gave him a Walther LM53, which is like an—it's an air pistol, airsoft gun, I guess you'd call it these days.
0:14:15But it resembles a Luger a lot.
0:14:18It's got the sight at the end of a very long barrel, definitely has an iconic look, and that was, I would guess, the inspiration.
0:14:30It's hard to, obviously, this far in hindsight, look into, like, exactly when those promo shots were taken and whether Karoff would have had them as a reference, but it seems pretty clear that this was the reference for the logo.
0:14:42Yeah, and I have seen—because those pictures, I'll put them in the show notes.
0:14:48I've already built up a bunch of these show notes, I swear.
0:14:50But that picture of Sean Connery or pictures of him holding that gun up by his face are—it's like, oh, yeah, I have seen that.
0:14:59They're not from the movies, and it's not a prop from any of the movies, but it's like, oh, well, here's a vaguely European-looking gun, right?
0:15:08Like an exotic-looking handgun.
0:15:10Those promo shots, by the way, are like a relic that they no longer really do.
0:15:16I think they did it mostly through the 90s.
0:15:18These days, now and then, you'll see it, but it used to be every movie that came out, there was always, like, a promotional shoot that went along with it.
0:15:27There were almost always, like, actors isolated on some sort of background, you know, one or more of the principal actors.
0:15:33And then, of course, they would use them for a variety of promotional purposes, including graphic design, like putting them on posters or other things.
0:15:40But it seems like you're seeing that a little—it's more rare now.
0:15:44They'll still do shoots, but they're usually more highly produced and less—almost these head-shoddy-looking things.
0:15:50But that photo of him with that gun is extremely iconic.
0:15:54It's one of those ones where when you see it, you almost—assuredly, almost everybody would be like, oh, yeah, I think I've seen this, you know?
0:16:00Yeah.
0:16:01Yeah, and so maybe that didn't come out of nowhere for Karaf.
0:16:05Maybe he's looking at that gun, and he doesn't know it's not the one from the movie, and so he puts it in.
0:16:10And it is, like I said, it's like a European debonair handgun.
0:16:15Right.
0:16:16And if anything, the air gun looks even more like that, because it's not dainty.
0:16:21It is a gun, but it's also not like a big American gun, like a .44 Magnum.
0:16:27Right.
0:16:27It's not bulky.
0:16:28It's elegant.
0:16:29Right.
0:16:29Right.
0:16:30It's like the tuxedo of firearms.
0:16:33It looks like—even if it wouldn't fit in a—under the armpit holster or whatever, it just looks like something a guy wearing a tuxedo driving a fancy European car might have.
0:16:45So what do you think it's shot, like BBs or pellets or something, if it's an air gun?
0:16:48I think so.
0:16:49Yeah, I didn't really look into it that deeply.
0:16:51I don't know, but it was basically the idea was that the prop master who was there for that shoot that day gave him this, because I think they were like, ah, he won't know the difference.
0:17:04He doesn't give him this.
0:17:05Right, just make him look cool.
0:17:07Yeah, exactly.
0:17:08Yeah, that leads me to another—something I haven't brought up with you, but that the other thing that the Luger gun always reminded me of is that—because the handle was like round at the bottom of a Luger, and it always reminded me of whatever the name of the gun is that they based the Han Solo blaster off, like a Mauser or something.
0:17:33I know—see, the way that I know guns is I know like the fake guns.
0:17:40Yeah, what was the base for the prop?
0:17:42In the Star—no, I know it was some kind of German World War II-era gun, but in the Star Wars universe, it's a DL-44.
0:17:51That's right.
0:17:52Blaster.
0:17:52The DL-44, yeah.
0:17:53What the prop is, I don't know, but it's vaguely Luger-like in terms of having that rounded pistol.
0:18:02And I just remember as a kid thinking—I loved Han Solo, he's my favorite guy in the movie, and I just remember thinking, god damn, that laser gun is the coolest looking prop I've ever seen.
0:18:13Yeah, I know.
0:18:14It is in like the sight, like the seemingly unnecessary sight and like everything about it.
0:18:21Right, because he's never like—
0:18:22And he never uses it, never once.
0:18:24Right.
0:18:26It's always from the hip, which is very Han Solo, you know.
0:18:29Right, which was part of what made him cool was that the action figure, even—he was the only one.
0:18:33All the other Kenner action figures had no articulated elbows or knees at the time.
0:18:37They just had rotating shoulders and hip sockets.
0:18:41But the Han Solo figure had a bent arm.
0:18:45Nice.
0:18:47Like in an L-shirt.
0:18:48Like, here's where we are, buddy.
0:18:50This is where this shot is coming from.
0:18:52Right.
0:18:52It's coming from low and quick.
0:18:54It's a blow the belt.
0:18:55Yeah, the Mouser broom handle, C-96, that was the basis for the DL-44.
0:19:01See, I even got that right, Mouser.
0:19:03But little things like that always bothered me as a kid, like with Star Wars.
0:19:08And like Star Wars, and I'm—I'm the perfect age for the Star Wars.
0:19:18Like guys like me in Syracusa are like just the perfect age because I was like four when Star Wars came out.
0:19:25So it's—I was like too young to really understand it, except that it was fucking awesome.
0:19:30And then they'd put it back in theaters the next summer.
0:19:32They're like, ah, you can't watch it anywhere else.
0:19:34And so I got to watch it like three times in the theaters.
0:19:38And there was no other movies I'd ever seen more than once because you could only—and I'd know it more and more.
0:19:43And I like just memorized everything in it.
0:19:46And then I'd go look at the toys and see how they were wrong.
0:19:49Right.
0:19:50Because in a lot of cases, I mean, especially in those days, there was not really any super picky attention to accuracy.
0:19:56They were like, I don't know, give him like a gun.
0:19:58There was not like these days where they're like, oh, take a mold of the actor's face, laser spin the actor's face.
0:20:03But make sure that the action figure has his exact nose.
0:20:06Right.
0:20:07It was like, I don't know.
0:20:08He's kind of a white dude with some brown hair and he's got a gun.
0:20:11Well, for example, I think one of the most famous parts of that is that in the—I'll put this in the show notes, I swear.
0:20:18But if the Luke Skywalker action figure—in the first round of Kenner figures, the lightsabers for the lightsaber, the three lightsaber-wielding characters, Luke, Obi-Wan, and Darth Vader, had the lightsabers embedded in their arms.
0:20:36With a little slider, right?
0:20:38Yeah, with a little slider.
0:20:39And Darth Vader's was red and Obi-Wan's was blue, but Luke's was yellow.
0:20:45Oh, right.
0:20:47So—and that really bothered me.
0:20:50Right.
0:20:50You know, it wasn't like I—and I was a good kid.
0:20:53I was amenable.
0:20:54It wasn't like I cried and threw a fit.
0:20:56I just—and I knew my parents didn't care, so it's not like I sat there and chewed their ear off.
0:21:02I held it inside for 45 years until I could spew here.
0:21:08That you were so disappointed that it was yellow.
0:21:10Well, and I was just like, who—I'm a little kid and I know this is wrong.
0:21:15How can the adults who made these things—clearly it was adults who made these toys.
0:21:20How could they get this wrong?
0:21:22It's—this is insane.
0:21:24So little things like that would bother me.
0:21:26The Han Solo figure did have a DL-44 gun.
0:21:30I think Luke came with a gun, too, and it was a DL-44, but that was wrong.
0:21:36I forget.
0:21:37Because there was only one DL-44 in the original movie.
0:21:42And Luke—because Luke didn't really have a gun until they killed a couple stormtroopers and stole one of his.
0:21:47So maybe Luke came with the correct gun, which would be a stormtrooper gun.
0:21:50But anyway, but the lightsaber being the wrong color, terrible.
0:21:55Oh, yeah.
0:21:56And similarly, the James Bond logo having a gun that he didn't really use seemed wrong to me.
0:22:02Except that didn't bother me.
0:22:04It just stuck out to me.
0:22:05And I remember—I really do.
0:22:07I know this sounds like something like, come on, you're 52 now.
0:22:10How in the world do you remember this?
0:22:12But I just remember thinking at, like, age seven or eight, that's not the right gun, but that gun looks so cool.
0:22:19So that's probably why they did it.
0:22:21Yeah.
0:22:22It totally seemed to me like that's the sort of discussion that the people in charge of James Bond would have.
0:22:28They're like, should we make the gun and logo look like the gun he actually carries?
0:22:34Or does this one just look cooler?
0:22:36Let's just use it.
0:22:37Yeah.
0:22:37I mean, it certainly has a better shape for the logo.
0:22:40Right.
0:22:42Than the stubby PPK.
0:22:43And then I never researched it before, but while writing that post last week, I went and it was like—and I started looking at the posters.
0:22:52I wrote this in the article, but it really does seem like the Eon Productions people—the posters, like you said, there was—the movie world in the 60s was just a different place where they just shot weird promotional photos that weren't on set.
0:23:07They were just on, like, the equivalent of a blue screen, but like a white screen.
0:23:11I don't know.
0:23:12Star Wars had those, right?
0:23:15Everybody knows that picture of Harrison Ford where his hair's not quite right.
0:23:20He's, like, in the costume.
0:23:21It's almost like it was, like, his tryout for the role.
0:23:25I just remember the thing—and so I looked it up, and I'm looking at all these old posters from the 60s, and it's so hard because it's not like there was one golden eye or gold finger poster or one poster for Thunderball.
0:23:39So they're all over the place.
0:23:41And, like, the ones in foreign countries look like they hired entirely different designers for some countries.
0:23:47Other ones, they just translate to different languages.
0:23:50Sometimes they'd redraw them.
0:23:52But it looked like, in the Connery era, they didn't really use the 007 logo that Karif designed religiously.
0:24:01It's there in Goldfinger, at least in the poster I found.
0:24:03But then it's not in Thunderball.
0:24:06It's not there in You Only Live Twice.
0:24:08And then it's bigger and more prominent on Her Majesty's Secret Service, the first one without Sean Connery with George Lazenby taking the role.
0:24:19And it totally makes sense to me.
0:24:22Like, I wrote, it's like, oh, before that, they just used Connery's face to say, this is James Bond, right?
0:24:28And now it's like, oh, we've got to start building a brand that's not—
0:24:32Gellion to the brand.
0:24:33Right.
0:24:33Right.
0:24:33The brand over the person.
0:24:35And then I believe every single official poster for every movie from On Her Majesty's Secret Service in 1969 until now has had the Karif 007 gun logo.
0:24:49Except I noticed, like the newest ones, it doesn't look like a Luger anymore.
0:24:55It does look like a Walter PPK.
0:24:58And so I started going back, and they changed it with Timothy Dalton's first role of two, The Living Daylights.
0:25:07You know, it makes sense.
0:25:08It's like they recast the role.
0:25:10Roger Moore had aged out of the role probably a couple movies before.
0:25:14But he looks really old in A View to a Kill.
0:25:17Yeah, I know.
0:25:19There are those inflection points where you're like, wow.
0:25:22Wait, oh, wow.
0:25:23And then I think, you know, it's weird, too, because at least me, and I know you probably watched some of them, I didn't watch most of them until much later.
0:25:31And so I—you'll reach those moments where you're like, wow.
0:25:36And then you realize there was like six years between the movies.
0:25:39You're like, whoa, what happened here?
0:25:40You realize, oh, was it like today where you're like, oh, this was successful?
0:25:44Let's film another one, please.
0:25:45Oh, let's film the next two back-to-back, where the actors actually look roughly the same.
0:25:49I don't know who directed A View to a Kill.
0:25:53And it's interesting because 1983 was maybe—
0:25:57That was John Glenn.
0:25:58Huh.
0:25:59It was a weird—83 was a weird Bond year because that's the year that Connery went with the rival producers and made Never Say Never Again in the summer.
0:26:12And then in the fall, Octopussy came out with Roger Moore.
0:26:17They both did well, but the Roger Moore one outgrossed Never Say Never Again.
0:26:23And I think that Eon people took that as, oh, we got to keep this guy.
0:26:28You know, he even outgrossed Sean Connery, even though he was, I don't know, like 50-something at the point.
0:26:33So they made A View to a Kill two years later.
0:26:35And I don't know if he aged in two years or if they just shot him poorly for his age.
0:26:42And there's a scene where it takes place.
0:26:45It's like an action chase scene on the Eiffel Tower.
0:26:48And he looks—even at a movie, it's not like, hey, this is like not just a bunch of kids with a camcorder.
0:26:54You got to get the shots while you can't.
0:26:56He looks winded.
0:26:57Yeah, this is not a run-and-gun production.
0:26:59Like, give the guy a minute, right?
0:27:01Yeah.
0:27:01Tom Cruise, famously.
0:27:03Tom Cruise is at 8—can you believe it?
0:27:0587 years old, I believe, Tom Cruise.
0:27:07Something like that.
0:27:0886.
0:27:0996.
0:27:10Yeah.
0:27:11Tom Cruise is in his 80s, but is still making Mission Impossible movies.
0:27:15But Tom Cruise obviously really works out, right?
0:27:20Brad Pitt starred in the—as a race car driver, F1 race car driver.
0:27:25Now, he's supposed to—he was aging.
0:27:26He was an aging, retired F1 driver.
0:27:29But he's—in real life, he's too old to be an F1 driver.
0:27:33Oh, yeah.
0:27:34By far.
0:27:35I mean, the F1 is incredibly punishing, yeah.
0:27:37But doesn't look it, right?
0:27:38I mean, sure, there's all the—Brad Pitt and Tom Cruise money can buy a lot of skincare products.
0:27:47I do—I will say, like, Tom Cruise, I mean, 63, doing these scenes, and there's—you can defeat a lot of things.
0:27:56And he is, obviously, in incredible physical shape.
0:27:59I mean, far better shape than I will—because all the millions that, you know, can buy, that sort of thing.
0:28:04Plus, his indisputably uncommon will.
0:28:09He has a lot of willpower.
0:28:11Like, whatever you think about the man individually or personally or whatever, incredible amount of willpower, clearly.
0:28:16But I will say, on the most recent movies with him, you can see that the one thing that is undefeated is, like, you cannot defeat, like, the body getting bulkier and boxier.
0:28:28Like, it just—it happens, right?
0:28:29Right.
0:28:30And it's, like, he's incredibly fit and lean, but he's 63.
0:28:33I mean, look at him.
0:28:34It's, like, it is what it is.
0:28:35I have not watched the latest one, the final Reckoning, the last Reckoning, whatever it's called, yet.
0:28:41But I just re-watched Dead Reckoning Part 7 from two years ago that leads into it.
0:28:47Just re-watched it in prep for the new one coming to home video.
0:28:52And it's, like, it doesn't look bad.
0:28:55It's not awkward.
0:28:57But, yeah, it's, like, he's puffier in the face, and you know it's not because he's eating poorly, right?
0:29:02But he's in incredible shape.
0:29:05It's very clear that in 1985, Roger Moore was not in incredible shape.
0:29:10I mean, he wasn't fat.
0:29:11He was slim.
0:29:13He looked good in a suit.
0:29:14But he looked closer to 60 than 50 and did not—was not ready to run.
0:29:21But anyway.
0:29:22And even when you're a kid, like, there's a switch of disbelief.
0:29:24It just hits you a little bit.
0:29:25You're like, really?
0:29:26Well, but then the other thing, I just—I know that I saw that, like, first run, first opening weekend in the theater.
0:29:35And it was just—it was a James Bond movie.
0:29:38And it's—I wasn't—I would criticize—I'd think of things like, hey, the gun's not right in the logo.
0:29:45But I wasn't a critical thinker at age 12 about cinema, right?
0:29:50Like, I knew which movies—you know, it's, like, kind of a just pure Ebert and Siskel thumbs up, thumbs down.
0:29:57And it's like, ah, it's a James Bond movie.
0:29:59Thumbs up.
0:30:00You know?
0:30:00And sort of a thought, like, well, of course it's Roger Moore.
0:30:04It's always been Roger Moore.
0:30:05Because it had been Roger Moore since I was born.
0:30:08And it felt like, well, I don't know.
0:30:10This will last forever.
0:30:11But that was it.
0:30:12But anyway, they recast it, redrew the logo to look like his actual gun.
0:30:17And I have to say, it doesn't look as cool.
0:30:19And it hasn't looked as cool since.
0:30:21Mm-hmm.
0:30:22Yeah.
0:30:23The stubbier version is not quite as elegant and doesn't make as much of a statement.
0:30:27I like the sight on the end, too.
0:30:28Yeah, I do, too.
0:30:29If I—if somebody from Amazon was like, hey, you seem to blog about James Bond a lot.
0:30:35Would you like to be hired as a consultant for our reboot of the franchise?
0:30:40I, of course, would jump at the chance.
0:30:42One of my suggestions would be, let's bring back a sort of a 60s-style logo.
0:30:48I think that would be a hands-down.
0:30:52I mean, why not, right?
0:30:53If you're going to put your wife in it, you might as well bring back the old logo.
0:30:57Because Bezos is apparently angling to have his wife have a role there.
0:31:03I saw the story.
0:31:05I think it was in one of the UK tabloids.
0:31:07So maybe it's of questionable certainty.
0:31:11Yeah, exactly.
0:31:12I haven't sourced that one.
0:31:13So sorry if my journalistic integrity is failing there.
0:31:16But I found the rumor to be amusing.
0:31:19Yeah.
0:31:20And I'd find it to be believable.
0:31:22Yeah, exactly.
0:31:24It's not too shocking if it's fair.
0:31:26All right.
0:31:27Let's take a break.
0:31:28And I will thank our first sponsor.
0:31:32And it is our good friends at Sentry.
0:31:37If you're listening to this podcast, the chances are you've built an app or there's a good chance you've worked on a team that's built an app or maybe a website, a mobile app, the back end.
0:31:48And whatever it is you're building that software, you don't want to have bugs.
0:31:52Sentry, S-E-N-T-R-Y, helps you fix bugs faster so you can deliver that five-star experience your users expect and that you want to deliver.
0:32:03It works with just about any language and framework you'd want.
0:32:07Swift, Python, Node, your whole stack is covered.
0:32:11It also supports every Apple platform from watchOS to visionOS and everything in between.
0:32:18Some of the platforms are more popular than visionOS.
0:32:21I'm not sure any or less.
0:32:23But Sentry supports them all.
0:32:25It goes way beyond what you get from the app store with real-time crash reporting and performance monitoring, hang detection, and session replay to see exactly what your users are experiencing.
0:32:38It's used already by millions of developers, including some of the biggest apps like Claude, Disney+, and Duolingo.
0:32:45And Sentry recently launched a new AI agent, Seer, S-E-E-R, which can automatically generate fixes with over 90% accuracy.
0:32:57Try it free at Sentry.io, that's S-E-N-T-R-Y.io, and tell them that this show sent you.
0:33:11They have a free dev plan, and listeners of the show can use the code TALKSHOW for three months and 150,000 errors for free.
0:33:21Go to Sentry.io slash TALKSHOW.
0:33:24That gets you three free months of the team plan and a free 150,000 errors.
0:33:30What else do I have?
0:33:32I guess we should move on.
0:33:33Is there anything else on Joe Kareff and Bond?
0:33:35No, I don't think so.
0:33:37I mean, I think it's a cool logo.
0:33:39It's really iconic and enduring.
0:33:41And I think if there's any takeaways, if you want, from that, I think it's sometimes adherence is not always the right call in design.
0:33:51When you're like this, we talked about like the yellow lightsaber.
0:33:55That's probably a bad case.
0:33:57But the gun is a good case where you're like, I could have made this extremely accurate.
0:34:01But we all agree now that we've seen them do that, it wasn't the right call.
0:34:05The right call was to make something that felt like punchy and iconic.
0:34:09And he made the right call at that moment.
0:34:12So it's not always the right call to be like as accurate as possible.
0:34:15So it's just what's the intent and work from there.
0:34:18Yeah, yeah, absolutely.
0:34:20And it's again, the books had been a smash hit for Ian Fleming for a decade before the movies started.
0:34:26But the logo came from the movies and it's impossible.
0:34:30It's like, how could they not think that the seven in 007 would make a gun?
0:34:34It's but it's like you don't think a thing when you come up with the perfect thing.
0:34:37The thing that's not actually obvious becomes obvious once you've seen it.
0:34:42It's like, yeah, I can't see it.
0:34:43Like you can't believe that the books didn't have that logo all over the country.
0:34:46Right.
0:34:47It's you could easily Mandela affect me into thinking that they were always it was always on the cover.
0:34:53Let's see what else.
0:34:54I don't want to spend a lot of time on it.
0:34:56Did you see the the made by pixel made by Google pixel event?
0:35:00Yeah, I did.
0:35:02I did.
0:35:02I think I saw somebody which I agree with say it felt like being sucked into an episode of WandaVision.
0:35:08Yeah, yeah.
0:35:09That was the verges.
0:35:11Okay.
0:35:12Yeah, that's a good take.
0:35:14I think Victoria Song, I'm going to guess.
0:35:17I'm loading it as we speak.
0:35:18Yes, Victoria Song from The Verge.
0:35:20Nice.
0:35:20Yeah, good turn of phrase, Victoria, because it did feel like that.
0:35:23It felt very much like a through a mirror, darkly version of a product announcement, but where everybody was supposed to be in on a joke, but the joke wasn't evidently obvious.
0:35:35It was just an awkward one.
0:35:36And I think summary was it was not what they hoped it might be, I would guess.
0:35:42It's funny because it's funny because a lot of us.
0:35:44I know Ben Thompson, my pal on Dithering is really, really adamant about he really misses live events.
0:35:51It doesn't not that Apple.
0:35:53He doesn't think Apple does a poor job with their pre filmed ones, but that he just misses the energy of live events.
0:35:59Even just watching over video and me personally, I miss them because I get to go see the Apple ones and I do think they're more enjoyable to watch in person or I think there's trade offs.
0:36:11But I also, you know, in the same way that I could see why they used a cooler looking gun for the 007 logo, I can see why Apple prefers sticking with the pre recorded thing.
0:36:23But there's other companies have had live events.
0:36:26Microsoft and OpenAI has had some that have been cool.
0:36:30And it's it it does make for interesting differences.
0:36:35Right.
0:36:36And so everybody's not competing with Apple on this.
0:36:39It doesn't I don't know that I don't think anybody else has the stomach to to put the effort in that Apple does for those pre recorded ones.
0:36:49Right.
0:36:49That it's because they're they don't make them like, you know, like old, really old TV shows.
0:36:57When you watch like the honeymooners shows or I Love Lucy from like the 50s, it's they're like stage plays with a camera in front of them.
0:37:06Like a two dimensional like you you could feel like you were in an audience sitting in a chair in a theater, which is the only other major form of like entertainment.
0:37:16Right.
0:37:17That most people had a reference frame for for TV.
0:37:20Right.
0:37:20Besides movies.
0:37:21It was like, OK, we can't do the whole movie thing every week.
0:37:24That's too much.
0:37:25We're not there yet.
0:37:27So what do we do?
0:37:28We film a play.
0:37:29Right.
0:37:30And so Apple didn't go that route right from covid onward, right from the first one.
0:37:35They sort of I believe I'm pretty sure I don't just believe but kind of know, even though he doesn't personally take credit, that is largely driven by Phil Schiller, who still runs events at Apple in addition to running the App Store.
0:37:49But let's not just have presenters come on and come into an empty Steve Jobs theater and we'll film it from the or not even empty.
0:37:57Right.
0:37:58Well, I guess during covid half fill the theater with employees to cheer and clap and just film it like it's an Apple event.
0:38:06Let's do something if it's going to be different because it's prerecorded, let's do something different and make it more like a TV show or a movie or a documentary or something about these products.
0:38:17They go every, you know, every I was going to say episode, every event, but it is like episodes.
0:38:26They go to new locations for the ones outside Apple Park.
0:38:30It's like here's Cayenne Drance introducing the non-pro iPhones here.
0:38:36It's an outdoor opera house in Sydney, Australia or something.
0:38:40Right.
0:38:41And I don't think other companies have the will to do that.
0:38:44I think it's so much work.
0:38:46I think it's like, oh, you know, whatever urge companies have to, oh, we should do what Apple does.
0:38:50And then they start plotting like, wait a minute.
0:38:52How much time are we going to ask our executives to spend traveling around California or the world to shoot these things?
0:39:01And so the fact that so many companies have gone back to live ones makes for an interesting contrast.
0:39:07Right.
0:39:07And NVIDIA is a great example.
0:39:10Right.
0:39:11Because NVIDIA is filling arenas once or twice a year.
0:39:14Like it's CES, 7,000 seat arenas, you know, like Apple used to at Mac World Expo or at WWDC.
0:39:23It's an interesting contrast.
0:39:25And so I want to say kudos to Google for trying something new.
0:39:31But I don't know why they thought this would work.
0:39:35Yeah.
0:39:36Yeah.
0:39:37I don't know either.
0:39:38I don't know what the impetus was.
0:39:40I know Google has definitely leaned more into the celebrity angle over the past couple of decades worth of their events.
0:39:47They certainly have had more celebrity guests.
0:39:49It's not that Apple has not, especially musicians, right?
0:39:52And every once in a while, partners, which are like high profile CEOs.
0:39:56And then now and then a celebrity or two, especially like Apple TV events and things like that.
0:40:00They definitely have had it.
0:40:02So I'm not saying that they haven't.
0:40:03But it just seems like Google has leaned into that more.
0:40:06And I'm not sure exactly what's driving it internally.
0:40:09I know a little bit more about the decision making process that Apple went through and like the iterations that they went through in their event process.
0:40:17Obviously, the pandemic was why the 2020 event was the way it was, but then why they didn't go back.
0:40:23And some of the impetus there was like to get more people involved, to like get more people on stage than they would be able to like get on and off a stage during the event cycle.
0:40:33So they could get more visibility to different teams that were actually working on things.
0:40:37But the on the Google side of things, if you look back at their history of events, they've gone through a ton of different formats, like whether it's like more talk show style formats or variety show or music centric or whatever.
0:40:52They've definitely mixed it up.
0:40:53And I like that they're trying new things.
0:40:56I just think that in this case, they tried this thing and it didn't work out.
0:40:59And I think that a large part of it is just it came down to the wrong host.
0:41:04I could actually see this working with the right host.
0:41:08And I have some experience in this because we we hosted this award show called The Crunchies and we did it for a few years.
0:41:14And our first host for that for the first couple of years was John Oliver.
0:41:19And this is pre John Oliver being John Oliver, right?
0:41:22Like he was it was early, very early in his career or much earlier.
0:41:26And we didn't have quite as wide a recognition.
0:41:28And he was amazing at that because he deeply understood tech, like not from a I'm a techie or I'm a tech person, but from like he got the dynamic, right?
0:41:40He understood that, hey, yes, these people are building things that are difficult to build.
0:41:44But at the same time, there's a certain amount of hubris and a lot of money involved.
0:41:48And he got like the line to walk where you could host an event like that and have it still be an award show where we're like giving awards to rich people.
0:41:58You got to everyone has to acknowledge this or about to be rich founders, etc.
0:42:02But it's still you could poke fun.
0:42:05But, you know, it's leavened.
0:42:06And like I think the Jimmy Fallon type who just isn't really technically savvy or at least did not display it on this stage and did not or did not have the time, energy or remit to dive deeper and really understand the topics.
0:42:23Because you could see him making many of those jokes that landed poorly, like saying tensor and clapping, you know, like a seal.
0:42:30But if he had just made a different joke about it that was more in the know, like it would have worked fine.
0:42:37Like it wouldn't have been to my personal taste probably still, but it absolutely would not have landed with a thud like it did.
0:42:43So I think it's like wrong host, not really well prepared.
0:42:47And then like the format secondarily didn't help the matter.
0:42:50Yeah, I think Victoria Song mentioned it in her write up at The Verge and I heard from somebody else who was there.
0:42:57I wish I had gone because it was in New York and I've been to Google events before.
0:43:01I'm obviously not like on their A list of people who write about Pixel phones.
0:43:07But I'm pretty sure if I had asked, I could have gotten in because I've gotten in before.
0:43:11And I wish I had, especially knowing it was only in New York and I regret it because I really wish I could have seen it first person.
0:43:18But they literally had an applause sign and they had a warm up just like a real talk show, like a real TV talk show.
0:43:27They had a warm up comic who came out 10 minutes before the actual show started to warm the crowd up.
0:43:32But you know what the press is like at these events, like an applause sign.
0:43:39What do you I mean?
0:43:41And I mean this.
0:43:42I know this sounds like a joke.
0:43:43But what do you think would go over more poorly in the press at a tech keynote event?
0:43:54A sign that lights up and says applaud or a sign that lights up and says fuck you?
0:44:01The fuck you would probably would have gotten a more hilarious response.
0:44:07It probably would have been hilarious.
0:44:09Hey, we delivered.
0:44:11You thought we would.
0:44:13The fuck you side only comes on.
0:44:15Right.
0:44:16I honestly think that would go.
0:44:18The club side is definitely not going to go over well.
0:44:20Right.
0:44:20Because the press is so cynical and so down, you know, concentrating on this and, you know, and thinking.
0:44:28I'm not on your team.
0:44:29I'm here to write about this and try to detect if you're full of shit about any of this.
0:44:33And I'm here to serve.
0:44:36You know, hopefully this is how most people in the press think.
0:44:39They're thinking like how I'm here to serve my readers and give them this and they're concentrating.
0:44:43And it's like the last thing they want to do is applaud.
0:44:46And it's and it's just I'm not religious about it.
0:44:50But a lot of people in the press are that they like it's almost like a religious thing where they feel like it's inappropriate in the press to applaud that you're here to represent.
0:44:59You're not.
0:45:00So you're not going to cheer for anything.
0:45:03And, you know, you and I have sat next to each other and dozens of these things.
0:45:07It's like, you know, especially for things like if somebody says that the new AirPods have twice the range away from the device that they had before and all the Apple employees who are in the crowd start clapping.
0:45:21Right.
0:45:22Especially the people from the AirPods team.
0:45:24Right.
0:45:25Right.
0:45:25I'm not going to clap for that.
0:45:28You're not going to clap for that.
0:45:29No one.
0:45:29No one in the press is going to clap for that.
0:45:31But like in the opening part where they talk about somebody whose car went over a cliff and their Apple watch saved their life because it said like it seems like you're in a car accident.
0:45:42And we're going to call emergency services.
0:45:45People start clapping.
0:45:47I'll clap for that.
0:45:47The guy's life was saved.
0:45:49Right.
0:45:49You know, like the tearjerker stuff.
0:45:51I'll clap for.
0:45:52I'm not religious about it, but I'm not there to clap.
0:45:55I am there to work.
0:45:56Right.
0:45:56So it just is.
0:45:58It's it's it's tone deaf.
0:46:00Right.
0:46:00But it might also sort of be.
0:46:04And I know you and I.
0:46:05I don't know if we talked about it on like a podcast, but I know we've talked about it privately.
0:46:09But like the media is very bifurcated and it's tilting.
0:46:16It's still continuing to tilt between what I traditionally think of as the media, which is journalists or columnists or people who are serious about it.
0:46:29And it it used to seem like the distinctions were only which medium you worked for.
0:46:35Were you from TV were you from print like the New York Times or Time magazine or Wired magazine or the web or, you know, and then the web.
0:46:45Which generally, by the way, was a scale of detail.
0:46:47Like you were all working with the same general journalistic principles.
0:46:50It was just on TV.
0:46:52You're building a two and a half minute segment.
0:46:54So you're trying to pick your 30 seconds at a time.
0:46:56And then in print, you're trying to pick your soundbites to go around an exclusive interview or glossy.
0:47:02And then in the blogs, you're like trying to get everything right.
0:47:05Like you're trying to like almost transcribe, but then add your take.
0:47:09Right.
0:47:09That's that was like the rough scale.
0:47:11But yeah, the underlying principles were all the same.
0:47:14You're there to fact find you're there.
0:47:16And maybe that also changes in scalar detail.
0:47:19But that's the same job was being done.
0:47:22Yeah.
0:47:22Different levels.
0:47:23And yeah.
0:47:25And so the distinctions were artificial.
0:47:28Right.
0:47:28And it's not just me as having been the up and comer and I have no background in print and no face for television.
0:47:38And so I was web only from my own publication.
0:47:43Like my publication didn't have a hundred year history of the print before it existed.
0:47:48And so with some of the people in the media, I never got like a stink eye or like a sharp elbow, but I could sense coldness.
0:47:58And I've told this story before, but the opposite.
0:48:00And it was the first time I don't remember if it was a WWDC or a Mac world, but it was definitely at Moscone West.
0:48:08And the first time that I got that didn't just get a press invitation to watch the keynote, but also got a, hey, we'd like to schedule a briefing with somebody to talk about the keynote after the keynote be like an hour afterwards or something.
0:48:24And there's a green room off to the side of where the keynote was up on the fourth floor of Moscone.
0:48:31And the first time I went in there and I felt a little weird and Walt Mossberg said, hey, I really like what you're doing.
0:48:38It's good to see you here.
0:48:40It just was super welcome.
0:48:41And I got to say, you're Walt Mossberg.
0:48:45I think that's what I said.
0:48:47I'm existing in the same place as you.
0:48:49That's awesome.
0:48:49Yeah, I think I was like, you're Walt Mossberg.
0:48:51I don't know.
0:48:52I think I handled myself okay.
0:48:53But it was like, oh, I was like, that was pretty neat.
0:48:56He said hello to me and was very, very gracious and then immediately got taken away to go talk to Steve Jobs or something.
0:49:02And I got to wait.
0:49:03But I was like, that was cool.
0:49:04But those distinctions were artificial.
0:49:06And I think your articulation of it is it's really about depth.
0:49:09TV, very shallow.
0:49:11Print, traditional.
0:49:12The web was where I could write 4,000 words about the keynote.
0:49:16Yeah.
0:49:17Or you could go ham on a button and people would either read it or ignore it.
0:49:21It would win on its merits.
0:49:22Right.
0:49:23And there were always people like Pogue who did both, right?
0:49:26Pogue is good on TV.
0:49:28I mean, he's still on the CBS morning show.
0:49:30But part of what made him good about it is he knew, here, I can write 800 words for The New York Times.
0:49:36But I could also write 90 seconds for CBS Sunday News.
0:49:40Now, though, it's the influencers.
0:49:42And it is different.
0:49:46And I keep thinking, you know, and it's just like when you're a kid and you think, hey, when I become a parent, I'm not going to do blank.
0:49:54I'm not going to make my kid go to bed early on a school night.
0:49:56I'm going to let him stay up until 10 o'clock or whatever.
0:49:59And I do think, in a lot of ways, I don't want to be the grumpy old man who's like, get off my lawn, right?
0:50:07There's enough of that that's inevitable, right?
0:50:09You can concentrate.
0:50:10You can wake up every morning and think, I am not going to tell the kids to get off my lawn.
0:50:14I'm not going to tell the kids to get off my lawn.
0:50:16And then three times every day, you're going to tell the kids to get off your lawn.
0:50:19But that's why.
0:50:20Can't help it.
0:50:22That's why.
0:50:22It's like the Roger Rabbit bit, right?
0:50:24Where it's two bits.
0:50:25He can't help but say two bits.
0:50:26It just bursts out of you at some age.
0:50:28Get off my lawn.
0:50:29Two bits.
0:50:31I remember being the younger person in the media pool who'd come up only through the web, only through my own stuff.
0:50:41I had no background at any other publication.
0:50:44And I remember feeling this sort of get off my lawn vibes.
0:50:50Nobody said anything, but I could feel it.
0:50:52And I don't want to be that way to the younger people now.
0:50:54I remember how Walt was to me.
0:50:57I try to be like that to younger people who I see, whose work I recognize.
0:51:01I come up to them to say hello.
0:51:03I like doing that.
0:51:05But the influencers, like the pure YouTubers, you know, there's like the MKBHDs of the world, who's totally just rock solid aces, maybe the best overall tech reviewer working today.
0:51:21I'm talking like the TikTok type people, like people who I don't even know.
0:51:26It's like YouTube doesn't even recommend their stuff to me, right?
0:51:30Yeah.
0:51:32And those people have a very different approach to being in the media at an Apple event, right?
0:51:39It is like, yeah, it's, it's a complex topic, too, because you have certainly people and I think people are young people are smart.
0:51:49All people are smart to some degree in their own ways.
0:51:51But young people are especially media savvy because they've been, they've grown up like kind of surrounded with this.
0:51:59What's the word I'm looking for?
0:52:00Not a panorama.
0:52:01Panopticon.
0:52:02Panopticon.
0:52:03Of information, right?
0:52:04They have all of these ways to consume information.
0:52:08And in fact, they couldn't stop it if they wanted to.
0:52:12It's almost like Clockwork Orange style.
0:52:14Like their eyeballs have been pinned back and it's being fed to them from at a very early age.
0:52:20And I mean this in terms of all kinds of media from a TikTok to an Instagram reel to a Twitter feed or, or whatever they're consuming, their phones are always with them.
0:52:30We did not have that.
0:52:31We had you and I speak in we, but I'm sure some members of your audience are following the same bucket.
0:52:36We had time for our brains to absorb information and understand what that was like at a relatively slow pace.
0:52:45And we had relationships with people that these days, I guess you'd classify them under what we would call parasocial, right?
0:52:52Like parasocial relationships are relationships with people that you don't personally know, but you build a relationship with them based on exposure to them.
0:53:00And we've had some of that where in our day it was called being a fan, right?
0:53:04Oh, I'm a fan of this actor.
0:53:05I'm a fan of this musician or this writer.
0:53:07But you never really expected to have a personal relationship with them.
0:53:11But influencers and people that make content on TikTok or on YouTube, they have these deep parasocial relationships with the chat or with their fans or followers, where those fans or followers feel very, very personally attached to them.
0:53:26And so like you or I, even Daring Fireball is a layer between you and a fan.
0:53:30And they know it's John, right?
0:53:32But you have a brand.
0:53:33For a lot of these people, their brand is their body, right?
0:53:36Their brand is themselves, their soul or whatever.
0:53:38And so people develop these really deep, really like tight attachments to them.
0:53:43And so when you put somebody like that in a context of an Apple event where there are journalists there, there are people with these strong bodies of fans or group of people that they have these parasocial relationships with.
0:53:56It's just a completely different vibe.
0:53:58And in some cases, that can manifest itself as, hey, that parasocial relationship is stronger than their expectation of access.
0:54:07So like an MKBHD or somebody else who is out there doing journalism level journalism, they just happen to be operating in this space where they have like deep relationships with their viewers that go beyond a brand.
0:54:22Like, okay, I wrote for TechCrunch and some people know me, but like more, they knew a brand a lot better, right?
0:54:26And so, oh, how did TechCrunch cover this thing?
0:54:29Or how did TechCrunch write about this thing?
0:54:30Whereas with an influencer, it's like, no, no, what is so-and-so saying about this thing?
0:54:35Period.
0:54:35That it's a one-to-one relationship.
0:54:37And so you'll find influencers that have that ability to go, you know what?
0:54:41This relationship is more important to me between me and these people who have chosen to follow me and therefore enrich me or allow me to keep doing this thing.
0:54:51And then there are other people where the access is more important because they are churning out old audience.
0:54:57They don't really care about the audience that would deeply care about this sort of thing.
0:55:00They only care about the new audience and growing their followership and all that stuff.
0:55:04And they're constantly in seek of new.
0:55:05And so in order to be in seek of new and growth and all of that things that the platforms emphasize, they have to have access.
0:55:13And so to them, access to an Apple event and to the hardware and to the people so that they can make these soundbitey things, they can make this content that gets new followers or that captures new audience is more important than actually telling the truth.
0:55:26When you come up against something where you're like, I'm not really so sure these are good colors.
0:55:29They're kind of blah.
0:55:30It's okay.
0:55:31Well, then you don't get access to the next event and therefore you don't get any new followers.
0:55:34Right.
0:55:35And so I think it's just like journalism where there is a nuance and subtlety to it as well.
0:55:40There are layers to it.
0:55:41And so I don't think of it in the buckets of like influencers versus journalists.
0:55:45It's just now it's like, what if instead of five major outlets, there were 5,000, right?
0:55:52And now you have to think of it in those terms.
0:55:54It's weird.
0:55:54It's different.
0:55:55Yeah, it's not.
0:55:56And so one thing I'll say that it's very clarifying from what you just said is it's not the medium, although maybe video, right?
0:56:06TikTok, I think, is geared towards influencing.
0:56:09I don't know that there's anybody whose primary outlet is TikTok who I would consider a journalist.
0:56:15I mean, maybe TikTok is so big that there are exceptions that I'm not aware of.
0:56:19I don't know.
0:56:20But in tech, I can't think of anybody.
0:56:23But for example, being a YouTuber, that's just a medium, right?
0:56:27And there are people like Marques Brownlee and Quinn Nelson.
0:56:32Justine is Eric, right?
0:56:34I, Justine, who they're more like bloggers whose medium is the show of YouTube, right?
0:56:44And influencing, it's just a different, totally different mindset.
0:56:49It's like everything you just said, like the access is the most important thing.
0:56:53And it ties into, if I'm going to make it all about me, you know, the whole kerfuffle this year with the Apple executives not doing my show after WWDC because they're a little prickly about what I wrote about the Apple intelligence stuff, which was always, I never felt it hanging over my head.
0:57:16And I said this on stage with Neely and Joanna, and I'll get to Neely's, to me, my favorite point of that whole show.
0:57:23But I always set things up for me that I don't need access, right?
0:57:28And it was nice when I started getting those invitations to attend the press events.
0:57:33And it was nice when they, without me asking, invited me to have the briefings after the events.
0:57:39And it is, you've, I've been in, not just been in the keynotes, but been in the briefings with you many times.
0:57:46And it is actually helpful to get to ask people like Jaws questions.
0:57:51And yes, you know, we often don't get the answer you really want to get, but, you know, without a tape recorder running and with an agreement that it's off the, on background, you get a better answer to certain questions.
0:58:05And it's like, oh, that's really interesting.
0:58:07So it is definitely helpful.
0:58:08It's not just the way that they answer, right?
0:58:10It's like, they're like, have full confidence in it.
0:58:13They were well-prepared.
0:58:14Even the fact that they were well-prepared for that question tells you something.
0:58:17Yeah.
0:58:18It can tell you like, oh, they saw this coming.
0:58:20And so they clearly thought about this problem a lot, which means, et cetera, right?
0:58:23You school it out.
0:58:24Yeah.
0:58:25You just, the way they answer, it's helpful, but I don't need it.
0:58:28And Neelai's great summation of that on stage was the less you need their access to them, the more they need you, you know, that they need the verge and that they need, the verge is very prickly about all of these things, right?
0:58:46Like they're, they've, for a couple of years now, they're very prickly even about the, they won't say Apple said, or Apple spokesperson said, they're going to give the name of the Apple spokesperson, even though the spokespeople do.
0:58:58They do not want their name.
0:58:59They want it to say an Apple spokesperson said.
0:59:02The verge is very prickly about that, but because they're prickly and they're good at what they do and they don't need, you know, they're like, we just won't run it if we can't put your name on it.
0:59:12And they're willing to do that.
0:59:14Then because the verge is the verge, Apple's like, okay, we'll give you a spokesperson whose name you can use to say what we, what the company wants to say.
0:59:23And that's a good defining line between what side of this is journalism and what's influencing is do, you know, oh man, whose line is it?
0:59:33I think it's George Orwell who said journalism is printing something that somebody doesn't want printed.
0:59:41Everything else is public relations.
0:59:45That sort of mindset is journalism and influencing is something different and it absolutely needs the access, right?
0:59:55Getting cut off from getting invited to the iPhone event in early September is, I mean, it may not be death of your channel, but it's death of your channel when it comes to talking about iPhones.
1:00:06Yeah, it's so like the way it works for Apple is they get sort of an opportunity to get an end run around critique and just have the products be shown off on their merits.
1:00:16The way it works for influencers, I guess at the most, at their most craven, which they're just people.
1:00:22So some of these people are cool people and conscientious people and some of them are not so good.
1:00:27And like at its most craven, it is very much a, hey, we're just like saying this product exists and we're showing it and we have access to it.
1:00:35And the fact that we have access to it means we get a view out of you and maybe a follow.
1:00:37But then at the upper scale, at the most conscientious and most, even if you don't, even if you don't cross the line from like an influencer into a tech columnist that just happens to use YouTube as a medium,
1:00:50even if you stay below that line, there are influences that are really, they're not covering the products, nor are they even claiming to review them, right?
1:00:57They're just sort of like in the presence of them and their fans are like interested in seeing them in the presence of those things.
1:01:05So it's honestly more about them than it is the product.
1:01:08It's just the marriage of the two gives them the lift.
1:01:10There are shades of it and it's just so much more nuanced than it used to be.
1:01:15It is just a very different mindset.
1:01:19And again, the best of them are very honest and upfront about it, right?
1:01:23That's the thing is it's not dishonest.
1:01:25They're just like, oh, yeah, they gave me this thing to have in my house for a month.
1:01:30And, you know, I just think it's cool.
1:01:32Look at it.
1:01:32That's awesome.
1:01:33And they're, theoretically, their viewers trust them, you know, to some degree.
1:01:38Now, they are not claiming to run it through lab testing and lying about it, right?
1:01:42They're just saying it's existing in the same space as I am for a while.
1:01:45And isn't that cool?
1:01:46Yeah.
1:01:46But the exclusivity of the access is part of what makes them influencers, right?
1:01:53And that's the part that's just a different game.
1:01:56And I remember, I don't remember exactly which device it was.
1:02:00I think it was iPhones.
1:02:01It would make sense if it was iPhones, but it could have been anything.
1:02:05But I'm sure you remember the vague details of this.
1:02:07But it was maybe like five, six years ago.
1:02:09It was pre-COVID, I think.
1:02:11And whatever the new thing was, like, me and you and everybody, The Verge and everybody had
1:02:19been to the event.
1:02:20And people with review units, you get them under NDA.
1:02:24Everybody knows that there's an NDA or an embargo until next Tuesday at 9 a.m.
1:02:30Eastern, and like a day or two before the embargo, there were like all of these YouTubes that came
1:02:36up from YouTubers with these phones.
1:02:41I don't know if they were iPhones, but let's just say they were iPhones.
1:02:43Showing these iPhones, like, two days before the embargo, saying, hey, this is really cool.
1:02:49I got the pink one.
1:02:50This is really beautiful.
1:02:51And we were all like, what the hell is going on here?
1:02:55Why am I operating under this embargo that's 48 hours away?
1:02:58And these people got to show these phones off.
1:03:02And I forget if I complained.
1:03:06I don't know.
1:03:06But a bunch of people in the press did complain.
1:03:09Like, hey, what the hell is going on?
1:03:11And I think Apple was taken aback because they're like, oh, these people aren't like you.
1:03:14Right.
1:03:16I don't know that they called them influencers, but they're like, we just had them to our place
1:03:22in New York, that big secret mansion.
1:03:24And they didn't get phones, like, to review and leave the premises with.
1:03:31They got to be there and have a hands-on.
1:03:33But that's a big, huge, spacious, five, six, seven-story townhouse in New York.
1:03:39In New York.
1:03:41And they all got to go off into different rooms in their own corner and find the light
1:03:45they want.
1:03:45And, of course, they made it look like they weren't in a press scrum with 25 or 30 of their
1:03:54peers.
1:03:54They made it look like it was all about them.
1:03:57And I got a blue, brand-new iPhone a week before they come out.
1:04:02And here it is.
1:04:03And I can show it to you.
1:04:04And whoever else was there, 20 feet away from them, shooting a similar video with a pink
1:04:11one, looked like they were in a totally different place.
1:04:14But then once I knew that's what happened, and I'm familiar enough with what most of the
1:04:18interior of that whole townhouse looks like.
1:04:21Oh, I see.
1:04:22And it is like every room looks a little different, and each floor has different lighting and
1:04:28is sort of a different thing.
1:04:29And they all just sort of spread out as – because it's their instinct, is how do I make my video
1:04:36look as distinctive as possible?
1:04:37Yeah, it's got to be unique, right?
1:04:38Right.
1:04:38If it looks the same as everybody else's, why would they watch mine over somebody else's?
1:04:41Right, and that's why they're the ones who got invited, because they're obviously good
1:04:45enough to have hit Apple's radar for popularity.
1:04:48And so their natural abilities at being an influencer and creating content for the influencer audience
1:04:55kicked in, and they made these videos.
1:04:57But then their videos, for us on the outside, triggered us of, hey, how did this group of
1:05:02people, most of whom I've never heard of, get these review units without the embargo?
1:05:07Which wasn't what happened at all, right?
1:05:09Yeah.
1:05:09But it started this whole – and anyway, to bring this all back full circle, I feel like
1:05:16the whole PR industry is adapting to this new world.
1:05:22And it's – even at Apple, which is obviously the tech company PR I'm most familiar with,
1:05:28I'm not saying it feels like I'm talking to an entire PR organization that's optimized for
1:05:34influencers.
1:05:35I don't, because I think my contacts there aren't meant for that.
1:05:39But I can kind of sense, though, that overall they are adapting to it.
1:05:43And I don't blame them, right?
1:05:45Because that's where the attention is, right?
1:05:47Like, I just was listening to a podcast today where somebody mentioned that in terms of like
1:05:53media strategy – not saying this tilted the election or whatever, but Kamala Harris' big,
1:05:59okay, I'm going to do this interview, I'm going to do this 60 minutes.
1:06:02And it was like a week before the election, Kamala Harris on 60 minutes, and there were
1:06:074 million people who watched.
1:06:08And Donald Trump's big, I'm going to do this, I'm going to do this show, I'm going to do
1:06:14an interview, was appearing on Joe Rogan's podcast.
1:06:18And 60 million people watched.
1:06:20Right.
1:06:22And it's say what you want about Joe Rogan, say what you want about the quality of the
1:06:27interviews of Harris on 60 Minutes versus Trump talking for three hours nonstop with Joe Rogan
1:06:33or however crazy long it was.
1:06:34It's the modern media world, right?
1:06:38Like, the Joe Rogan show is a huge deal, right?
1:06:41And these – the influencers who hit Apple's radar and make the cut to get invited for this
1:06:47obviously have huge audiences, right?
1:06:49And that's ultimately – and I don't blame them.
1:06:52This is what Apple wants is they want to get their message to a huge audience of people,
1:06:58young people who might buy iPhones.
1:07:00And I don't blame them, but it does corrupt the process in a weird way because what I detect – and
1:07:11again, I'm not throwing anybody at Apple under the bus.
1:07:13I detect it from other companies even more, but I just detect it where – you know this,
1:07:19like, from being the editor-in-chief at TechCrunch for a long time and writing about this stuff,
1:07:23is you knew you weren't going to bend to Apple's, oh, we really don't want you to mention that, right?
1:07:30You're like, well, I got to mention it if it's important.
1:07:32But you could feel that they want you to, right?
1:07:35They kind of like, oh, you know, we'd rather have you not talk about the bend gate with the iPhone 6
1:07:40or, you know, it's, hey, it's okay, just don't put it in your back pocket.
1:07:43Whereas the influencers, they're like, hey, we'd rather not have you talk about this thing
1:07:48where the one guy made a video where he put it in his back pocket and the iPhone bent.
1:07:51And they're like, okay, sure, I won't mention it.
1:07:53And the PR people, that's just crack to them.
1:07:56They're like, oh, finally.
1:07:58You know, like, they're like braced for an argument.
1:08:02And instead, they bring it up and the person is like, oh, yeah, sure.
1:08:04Why would I mention that?
1:08:06It's not really that important to them either, unless controversy is their brand, right?
1:08:10Right.
1:08:10Because they have a personal brand.
1:08:11And if their brand is controversy, which there are some out there that are,
1:08:14then they're all over that.
1:08:16And they don't really even expect to get invited, right?
1:08:18Right.
1:08:19So they have what they would like you to talk about.
1:08:21And if you're just like, sure, I'll just stick to your talking points, they're like, oh, this is great.
1:08:26Why are we dealing with these other people with smaller audiences?
1:08:29And so I definitely felt implicit stuff over the years, because how could they not be like, oh, please don't.
1:08:36Right.
1:08:36Please don't mention this terrible foible or whatever.
1:08:38But I was never explicitly asked because they knew.
1:08:41Right.
1:08:42Right.
1:08:42They're not going to ask me not to say anything, you know.
1:08:44Right.
1:08:45Whereas I feel like the way it works now is that the influencers will ask for it.
1:08:50They'll be like, what do you want me to say about this?
1:08:52I really do think it because it and it's the nature of their work in their medium.
1:08:57And it is more popular in terms of just how many eyeballs are watching it.
1:09:02You know, it's a quantity versus quality thing, I hope.
1:09:05I mean, that's what the remainder of my career is hopefully staked on.
1:09:08But it's a very different it's such a different thing for the same PR organization to be dealing with.
1:09:19Whereas I don't think dealing with TV, print and web meant that the PR people 15 years ago had to have different mentalities.
1:09:29Whereas now it's a bifurcation and I kind of feel PR needs a very different approach to it.
1:09:36And to bring this all to where I was going is I can't help but think that the nature of this made by Google event was sort of put together by influencer first people at Google that.
1:09:51Oh, my God.
1:09:52We'll have Jimmy Fallon.
1:09:53We'll have Steph Curry.
1:09:54We'll have all of these.
1:09:56The Jonas brother, whoever else was there.
1:09:58I forget.
1:09:59I mean, not just a celebrity at the end.
1:10:01It was like a dozen famous people from TV and from music and from sports and stuff.
1:10:07Some famous people for everybody.
1:10:09And you could, you know, be there when they come out.
1:10:12Here's Cody from Peloton, the most famous Peloton trainer.
1:10:17And the applause sign, I don't think that some of the people in the audience thought twice about it, right?
1:10:23Right.
1:10:23No, honestly, as an influencer, you're used to running your own talk show every day, right?
1:10:27Even if it's YouTube, you're in the comments.
1:10:29If it's Twitch or another streaming service, you're talking to chat and you need that, right?
1:10:35That's how you build relationship with your audience.
1:10:36That's how you build engagement.
1:10:37That's how you get either money directly from them in terms of like subscriptions or gifts or long term brand deals based on more followers, right?
1:10:46Like there's sort of that they're a nerd to that concept.
1:10:50Whereas a journalist, you're not, you're very much allergic to that concept of, oh, I'm in the audience of a talk show.
1:10:59I don't want to be here.
1:11:00I want to be in a place where I can get information that is closer to the truth than this highly produced scenario.
1:11:07Yeah.
1:11:07So I have something weird going on and I can't help but think that that weird Google event is a sort of, I don't think it's a sign of the future.
1:11:16Cause I don't think they're going to do it again, but maybe like you said, maybe they'll make another stab at it.
1:11:20It won't be exactly the same, but they're definitely not going back.
1:11:23I think Google has definitely organically integrated creators in their, into their marketing for a while.
1:11:29Like Apple's basic timeline was, as you mentioned, like 2019, right?
1:11:33The iPhone 11 release was, and I have some information about this that is non-public, but like the, the nature of it was like, that was basically the year they decided to go at it.
1:11:44Right.
1:11:44Let's influencers are out there.
1:11:46They're going to cover our stuff.
1:11:47Anyway, we need to like loop them in so that we can control the environment at least.
1:11:52So it's not just some guy getting in, in the mail and throwing it on the ground.
1:11:55Right.
1:11:56It's okay.
1:11:56Let's, let's embrace them.
1:11:58You, well, you know, that's what they do.
1:11:59I was doing, I drew it from a building and it broke.
1:12:01I can't believe it.
1:12:02You know, at least that was the mentality of some folks, but they embraced them.
1:12:06That was the first year they did it.
1:12:08They gave them this, their early access, as you mentioned, a few hours early, 12 hours, whatever it was.
1:12:13Like the day before they were allowed to post very lightweight, Hey, look at this thing videos, but that was the first year they do it.
1:12:19And they, they managed like parallel outreach pipelines, journalists and influencers, and they've only gotten more aggressive about it since.
1:12:27And it's more fleshed out.
1:12:28Now they have a full pipeline, influencer pipeline.
1:12:30And you, you, like the last iPhone event, there were hundreds of people there that were not journalists.
1:12:36They were very much more on the influencer spectrum.
1:12:40Google has done it organically for a long time as well.
1:12:43I don't, I know they have an influencer outreach department, like in their comms department, but I'm not sure if it's, I'm not sure how fleshed out it is.
1:12:53I'm not intimately familiar with it, but they certainly from external externalities, they clearly do have embraced influencers.
1:12:59They're not going back.
1:13:00Nobody is because you can't afford to.
1:13:02You're giving up so much earned media.
1:13:05Like you can't even say paid media.
1:13:08They're not paying them, right?
1:13:10It is earned media, but it basically is as easy as paid media.
1:13:14So like for the un-journalists or un-media savvy out there, there's basically tiers of media coverage that you can get.
1:13:20As a comms person, you, they have certain rough values too.
1:13:25So earned media, organic media is basically media that happens without you saying you want it to explicitly happen or paying for it.
1:13:32Then you have paid media, which is like ads, right?
1:13:35Or sponsorships or things like that, where you're paying, get your message out.
1:13:38And then there are other various shades of it, but like those are the main ones that are important to talk about right now.
1:13:43And so like with an influencer, you're technically getting the ease of paid media, which paid media, anybody will say anything you want as long as you're paying them.
1:13:50Like Facebook will put all over their site, iPhone's the best in all of their ads.
1:13:53You're on the hook for the legal aspect, not Facebook, right?
1:13:56So if you say iPhone will cure cancer, they'll put it all over, right?
1:14:00And then they're like, iPhone cures cancer all over.
1:14:01Like 10,000 people will see it in the next 30 seconds, right?
1:14:04That's paid media.
1:14:05And like with influencers, you can get access to millions of people, millions of viewers with relatively the same kind of level of attention to it.
1:14:15Is this actually true or not as paid media?
1:14:18And you could do it like at the top of a hat.
1:14:20And all you got to do is invite them to your event.
1:14:22Yeah.
1:14:23They bring their camera equipment.
1:14:24They bring their brain.
1:14:25They bring their creative, which is in many cases, amazing creative juices.
1:14:29Like these people wouldn't be big if they didn't build creative content.
1:14:34They're amazing editors, they're amazing videographers, all of that.
1:14:37And yet they are not really hypercritical because that's not their job.
1:14:41That's not their job to their audience.
1:14:43That's not their job to themselves, the vast majority of them.
1:14:45And so like they view this as like an opportunity to just get new content.
1:14:48It's the same for them as doing that versus going to the beach.
1:14:51It's like, oh, look at this amazing sunset.
1:14:53I'm here in my bikini.
1:14:54Let's film this content.
1:14:56Or let's like, let me go ride an ATV in the woods with my buddies.
1:15:00And now we can think whatever they're doing that's keeping people interested
1:15:03and viewing, that's just another drumbeat for them.
1:15:07And for Apple, it's very easy too.
1:15:08It's very low stakes.
1:15:10It's very easy to get all these views.
1:15:12So why wouldn't they, right?
1:15:13And I think Google thinks the same way.
1:15:15Yeah.
1:15:15Something's going on and I can't help but feel like the show exemplifies it.
1:15:19Yeah.
1:15:20And I do think that the fundamental mistake was Fallon as host.
1:15:24There's some disconnect there.
1:15:27Not that I don't like his show really, but I don't hate it.
1:15:30I get why it's been on the air for a long time.
1:15:33I'm drawing a blank on who they could have got, who else they could have gotten.
1:15:37Right.
1:15:37I don't feel any of the other late night hosts would have been right.
1:15:43Right.
1:15:43I don't.
1:15:44Kimmel.
1:15:45No.
1:15:45Stephen Colbert.
1:15:47Definitely not.
1:15:48Right.
1:15:48And I think Colbert, I just, I don't know.
1:15:52Maybe Colbert would have been better at it, but I don't know that they could get him.
1:15:55And I don't think if they could have, maybe Seth Meyers would have been better.
1:16:00Seth Meyers did some Verizon commercials a year or two back and it was pretty good.
1:16:06I can't help but feel that Seth Meyers could have bridged the, look, this is a bunch of geeks
1:16:13and we're trying to talk to normal people and I'm going to bridge that gap, right?
1:16:18That there is that fundamental disconnect.
1:16:20And Apple has less of it because Apple is a company with cooler people.
1:16:26It really is.
1:16:28It just, you know, I know some people out there roll their eyes like, but it is, it's
1:16:32sort of what makes Apple, Apple, where Apple knows how to speak to normal people better than
1:16:37most tech companies do.
1:16:38They just do.
1:16:40See, the thing is though, they could have nailed this.
1:16:43They like, the format is not actually that bad.
1:16:47I know people were joking about the QVC aspect of some of it.
1:16:50I get it.
1:16:51But if it's the right host, it doesn't matter, right?
1:16:53Because there are celebrities that are generally like very tech savvy and actually care.
1:16:58And are nerds.
1:16:58And are probably watching the event.
1:16:59Yeah.
1:17:00Like, go find those.
1:17:01Joseph Ford and Levitt has a tech company, right?
1:17:05Go, go get it.
1:17:05Like, you know, we've had him.
1:17:06He's amazing.
1:17:07He's like very intelligent about this stuff.
1:17:09I mean, you could go broader.
1:17:10Even Will.i.
1:17:11Him, he's founded several tech companies.
1:17:13They haven't been extremely successful.
1:17:15Right.
1:17:15And they've been kind of weird, but he loves tech and like certainly has a viewpoint.
1:17:19There are versions of this that I think could have worked.
1:17:23You know, I just think, I think it did not have the right host.
1:17:26Yeah.
1:17:27All right.
1:17:28Let me take a break here to thank our next sponsor.
1:17:30It is our good friends at Factor.
1:17:33Factor Meals.
1:17:34Hey, between busy schedules and summer plans, sometimes all you've got are a couple minutes.
1:17:39Factor helps you eat smarter with tasty chef prepared meals that are dietician approved and delivered right to your door.
1:17:48Right now they have more than 65 weekly meals to choose from made for how you live and how you like to eat.
1:17:57And they've got all sorts of things.
1:17:59And they've got all sorts of ways to fit in with whatever other meals you're going to eat throughout the day.
1:18:03And there are, of course, and this show has had previous sponsors who do it where you get these meal kits, where you get ingredients that are all pre-prepared.
1:18:11That's not what Factor is.
1:18:13Factor, the whole meal is all cooked, prepared, ready to go, sealed up.
1:18:19And it comes refrigerated with dry ice in the box.
1:18:23So it's refrigerated when you get it.
1:18:24You put it in.
1:18:25It's very fresh food, much like the sort of pre-made meals that are all made together that you get at like a premium supermarket.
1:18:3265 a week to choose from.
1:18:35You pick the ones you want, how many you want.
1:18:37They come.
1:18:38You put them in the microwave for just a couple minutes.
1:18:40And you've got a whole meal in not like 30 minutes of like you putting the stuff together and putting it in the oven.
1:18:49But you just taking a package out and opening it up, put it in a microwave for a couple minutes, and boom, you've got like lunch or dinner in three minutes.
1:18:57And it is really, really good stuff.
1:19:00I've been eating it for months now ever since they started sponsoring.
1:19:02I really like it.
1:19:04And again, 65 choices a week, give or take, lots to choose from.
1:19:09They've got all sorts of things that support your wellness goals.
1:19:12They've got GLP-1 friendly meals.
1:19:15They've got new Mediterranean diet options packed with protein and good-for-you fats.
1:19:20They've got all sorts of flavors from around the world.
1:19:23For the first time, you can try Asian-inspired meals with bold flavors influenced by China, Thailand, and more.
1:19:30They've got all sorts of other choices related to nutrition.
1:19:34They handle allergies.
1:19:35They've got kid-friendly options.
1:19:38You name it if there's like, oh, well, Aikido.
1:19:40They've got that.
1:19:41They've got you covered.
1:19:43It's why 97% of their customers say that Factor helped them live a healthier life.
1:19:48Feel the difference no matter what your routine is.
1:19:50I use Factor.
1:19:51I think you should try it too.
1:19:53I really do mean it.
1:19:54I like it.
1:19:55You can eat smart at factormeals.com slash talkshow50off.
1:20:04That's talkshow50off is the code at the end of the URL.
1:20:10And use that same code, talkshow50off, to get, guess what, based on the code, 50% off.
1:20:18Plus free shipping on your first box of food.
1:20:21That's code talkshow50off at factormeals.com for 50% off plus free shipping.
1:20:29Get delicious, ready-to-eat meals delivered with Factor.
1:20:33I'm trying to think what else.
1:20:35Rapid-fire stuff.
1:20:37Did you see that the UK has withdrawn their demand for the iCloud backdoor?
1:20:44Yeah, I did see that.
1:20:45That is interesting.
1:20:46I kind of felt like that was inevitable, but it's ultimately, it's, it's, everybody has their
1:20:54limit on what they understand about, well, almost everybody, I guess.
1:20:57Somewhere there's somebody who understands all the math in the world, but somewhere, you know,
1:21:01you run into the limits of your ability to understand math and encryption is math.
1:21:06And the, hey, okay, end-to-end encryption.
1:21:11Sure, sure, we support it, but we would just like to let the good guys in the middle.
1:21:15And it's like, you don't understand saying you want to get in, even, you know, you pinky swear,
1:21:22it's only for the good guys.
1:21:24And even if we take off the table of debate right now, that good guys only could lead to
1:21:30bad guys getting in through social engineering or through a bug or through an election, take
1:21:37that off the table.
1:21:38It just isn't possible, right?
1:21:40Like with end-to-end encryption, there is no way to put a thing in the middle.
1:21:44So if you say you're going to pass a law that you have to have a spot in the middle,
1:21:48that means you're banning end-to-end encryption because it's impossible.
1:21:54And they're like nodding their heads and they're like, yeah, but we're not banning end-to-end
1:21:58encryption.
1:21:58We're just saying we have to be in the middle.
1:22:00And it's like, that's like saying you want two plus two to equal five.
1:22:04Right.
1:22:05Yeah.
1:22:07It was clearly like, it is one of those topics that is clearly a non-starter from anybody
1:22:14who's technically savvy enough to understand it and like theologically like world-breaking.
1:22:18Okay.
1:22:19Well then encryption might as well not exist.
1:22:21If you're going to build any sort of backdoor or middleman, it might as well not do it at
1:22:24all.
1:22:25And I think the UK was definitely being used as a test case to see, hey, how are liberal
1:22:33democracies going to treat anti-encryption legislation?
1:22:36Because they have the Online Safety Act is what this is based on, which they passed in
1:22:40like 2023.
1:22:41And the argument was like, hey, this is about CSAM and about illegal material and drug deals
1:22:48and this kind of stuff.
1:22:48And Apple definitely was duck's feet about it.
1:22:51I mean, has negotiated furiously behind the scenes and then made some public statements as
1:22:56well about withdrawing iMessage entirely from the UK and all of that.
1:23:00And I definitely think there was a lot of negotiation, a lot of stuff that-
1:23:04And they did.
1:23:05They never pulled iMessage from the UK, but they did pull iCloud Extra Protection.
1:23:11That's not the name.
1:23:13I forget.
1:23:13It's not called Extra Protection.
1:23:14Yeah, I don't remember it either.
1:23:15Sorry.
1:23:15But it's the super extra, everything is end-to-end encrypted.
1:23:21And you can't go to the Apple Store and say, everything was on my iPhone and I just dropped
1:23:27it in a lake and I need a new iPhone.
1:23:30I don't remember my password.
1:23:31Is there a way that you can help me out?
1:23:33It's no.
1:23:34There is no way to help you out if you turn it on.
1:23:36Advanced Data Protection.
1:23:37Advanced Data Protection.
1:23:39Right.
1:23:39They did pull it.
1:23:40And it wasn't as a stunt.
1:23:43It was like there was no way to keep it and be- And I guess maybe they pulled it before
1:23:47they had to, to comply with the law, to send a message, but it's like, we have to pull this
1:23:52if you're going to make us go down this route.
1:23:54And the UK law, and again, the US is, you know, I don't want to just, obviously, there's
1:24:02politics going on in the United States, but, and it's polarizing, let's say.
1:24:07Yeah, it almost feels like the rafter in your own eye scenario when we're talking about anybody
1:24:11else's politics at the moment.
1:24:13Right.
1:24:13But there are aspects of US culture and the First Amendment and freedom of speech that
1:24:20are so permeate our approach to all of life, including politics, that there are things
1:24:29in other countries, even one as similar in so many aspects culturally to the US as the
1:24:36UK that you're like, wait, what?
1:24:38Which is this aspect of the snoopers law or whatever the real name of the law is that they
1:24:43pass where they can hand this request to a company like Apple, like we would like a backdoor
1:24:50and there are two aspects of this that are sort of breathtaking, where the one is that
1:24:55when you get one of these requests, it is illegal under punishment.
1:24:59It's like a, not like a civil fine.
1:25:01Oh, you got to pay us some money because you blabbed about it.
1:25:04It's a criminal law where like somebody at Apple would, would be liable to be locked up
1:25:10in the UK for a prison term by just saying that they got the request.
1:25:15It was illegal under UK law to even say that the UK was demanding backdoor access to iCloud
1:25:22encrypted communications.
1:25:24Right.
1:25:25That is just, it's just crazy bananas.
1:25:27Whether you're, whether you have a red MAGA hat that you like to wear or you're a diehard
1:25:34Democrat in the US.
1:25:36Either way, the idea of the government telling a company, you can't even say that we're making
1:25:42you do this, it really doesn't compute.
1:25:45And maybe there's some exception somewhere that you agreed, but it just isn't like that
1:25:50here.
1:25:50But then the other part about it that was the most breathtaking is what they were asking for
1:25:56was a worldwide backdoor, not just like for communication between UK citizens and their
1:26:04iCloud accounts, but it would have given the UK secret service, speaking of throwback earlier
1:26:11in the podcast, access to anybody's encrypted iCloud communication anywhere in the world, which
1:26:18is just sort of like crazy bananas.
1:26:20Yeah, it is a weird one because it's, it, we're kind of at this place and have been for
1:26:25a while now.
1:26:26It's just like now coming to loggerheads in a lot of ways where you're, you're having an
1:26:31argument about whether tech companies or governments can establish and set global policy on things
1:26:36like encryption.
1:26:37And there's an argument back and forth.
1:26:39And unfortunately the most popular, most potent argument for tech companies having the most influence
1:26:45here is that the governments truly don't understand it or don't have the people in place that
1:26:50can make decisions that understand it.
1:26:52Right.
1:26:52And the, either they're ignoring their advisors or ignoring their people, or they do understand
1:26:58it or have been explained it and they're being facetious and they're, they're pushing an
1:27:03agenda based on getting reelected or maintaining personal power instead of what is actually best
1:27:08for people.
1:27:09Right.
1:27:10Or maybe just deliberately setting up the tech companies as scapegoats for any future things.
1:27:17If a, some kind of widespread CSAM ring pops, you know, like a, the Epstein thing, but like
1:27:24a new one pops up and it turns out they were all communicating over iMessage or any WhatsApp
1:27:30or something else that's end to end encrypted.
1:27:33And they're like, yeah, it's their fault.
1:27:35We tried to get in the middle so we could interrupt these things.
1:27:37And they said, no, and it doesn't matter that the math does, doesn't work out.
1:27:42And that it having end to end encryption and knowing that the math works out, ultimately
1:27:47it, it is like everything else in life.
1:27:49A trade-off where yes, in theory, letting the good guys snoop, it could be helpful in
1:27:56some cases, but overall the trade-offs of having secure end to end encryption.
1:28:01And therefore, if law enforcement wants to get access to things, you got to do it some
1:28:06other way, which is more or less gumshoe work, right?
1:28:10It's show up with a warrant and go in their house and take their devices, right?
1:28:14And that's, it still happens, right?
1:28:16It's not like in this world where so much of our text communications is now end to end encrypted
1:28:22that the law enforcement around the world no longer gets evidence from people's communications.
1:28:29It still happens all the time.
1:28:30It's like, they just can't do it by clicking a button from Virginia to communicate.
1:28:36It's like, you got to go get the devices.
1:28:38And guess what?
1:28:39All the stuff is on people's devices.
1:28:41Right.
1:28:42And it's, it's a weird one because like on the face of it, if you look at it and examine
1:28:47it, it's like clearly folly.
1:28:48It is like to bring back the bond analogy, let's do it again.
1:28:52Let's keep doing it the whole show.
1:28:53But remember when, uh, uh, like tomorrow never dies.
1:28:56Okay.
1:28:56So Elliot Carver is like Jonathan price, the villain in that movie, the MacGuffin of that
1:29:01movie is a GPS encoder that can basically make ships believe that they are in a different
1:29:08place.
1:29:09Like tell any ship in the world basically, or any GPS enabled in that case, it was in those
1:29:15years, 97, it was like military, right?
1:29:18So like 97 GPS was just starting to appear in a lot of places, but it wasn't in everybody's
1:29:24phone like it is now.
1:29:25And so like, it was still like this thing that existed.
1:29:28And so it was like, Oh, what if you had a universal key and you could fool any GPS thing
1:29:33in the world?
1:29:34And what is so silly about it is not the premise that you could do that, which technologically
1:29:39is very feasible.
1:29:40It is that there, anybody would build a thing like, like they would intentionally build like,
1:29:46Oh, we're just going to steal this thing that has been built to, and has access to every
1:29:50GPS satellite to like fool anybody.
1:29:53Right.
1:29:54And it's like what these governments are saying is, Hey, build us that.
1:29:57And let's just, well, trust me, it'll be fine.
1:30:01We're going to put it in a bolt inside a glass case in a sky, sky rise, and nobody will ever
1:30:06parachute in and laser cut a window and reach it and take it.
1:30:10Nobody, it will never happen.
1:30:11Don't worry.
1:30:12It's all fine.
1:30:12It was like intentionally building a MacGuffin for like somebody to steal and misuse.
1:30:17And it's, it's just actually kind of wild when you think about it in those terms, but
1:30:21he's the state of the union.
1:30:23That's where we are.
1:30:24Right.
1:30:25And it seemed, and again, knock on wood, I mean, who knows what they actually got, but it's
1:30:30like certain things inevitably, if anything can be exploited and it, and it's valuable, eventually
1:30:37it will, right?
1:30:38And it's almost a certainty and the way that it turns out that Chinese spies have infiltrated
1:30:46the U S telecom system.
1:30:48This was big news last year, but that they've been able to intercept phone calls and unencrypted
1:30:55SMS text messages and that, that they've gotten into the not data centers, whatever you want
1:31:01to call like the, the centralized parts of the cell phone, the telephone network, there's
1:31:06a fact it's like, it's like, Oh geez, the Chinese got in here and they were spying on
1:31:10stuff.
1:31:10The fact that that none of that, anything that they did get wouldn't have been gettable if
1:31:16it was end to end encrypted, if it, instead of a telephone call, that's not encrypted.
1:31:20If you made a FaceTime audio call that is end to end encrypted, well then they'd get nothing.
1:31:26It sort of opened people's eyes to, Oh yeah, I guess we do want.
1:31:29And you know, even in law enforcement and government and politics are like, yeah, we, I guess we kind
1:31:33of do want end to end encryption. So I guess sometimes it works out. I don't know. It was
1:31:38like, but right before it's just by coincidence, but right before, did you see that the brief
1:31:42item I had on daring fireball last week where I was like, I don't know. I, I feel pretty
1:31:47pessimistic about the UK government ever getting encryption because they're, they're having a
1:31:52drought over there. I don't know if you've heard there's, there's the climate is sort of
1:31:55screwy. Yeah. A little wacky. Yeah. And the UK's national drought group issued advice to citizens
1:32:02of the UK to how, how the, how individuals in the UK can help with the drought. They can delete
1:32:08old emails.
1:32:13Wait, wait, I swear to God, see this. Why? What's the rationale there? Well, it, uh, we
1:32:22are, it really helps simple everyday choices such as turning off a tap or deleting old emails
1:32:28also really helps the collective effort to reduce. And then later on, they have a list of tips
1:32:34with a bunch of legit tips. Take shorter showers and turn off the tap while you're brushing your
1:32:40teeth. Right. Right. Yeah. Yeah. If you, you know, you should brush your teeth for like two
1:32:44minutes anyway. So why run the water the whole time? So turn it off. And then the, the, one
1:32:49of the bullet points was delete old emails and pictures as data centers require vast amounts
1:32:55of water to cool their systems. Wow. Wow. I love it. I mean, there is a twisted logic to
1:33:03it. Theoretically, I mean, if well, okay. Theoretically, this feels like another hour of the podcast.
1:33:09Right. I thought about the same thing too. And again, it's the way that my, it's the way that
1:33:13every post on daring fireball, every single one could in theory spiral to 4,000 words, every single
1:33:19one. Okay. Let's read the numbers. Like how much does steady state store storage need versus active
1:33:27memory and how often do people access their images and like, you know, like, yeah, let's, let's talk
1:33:33about this is why I brought it up. But, and I even thought too, all right, let's say you've
1:33:38got, uh, what, what takes more energy to just leave an old email that you're never going to look at
1:33:45just leave it in your account. And let's just assume it is stored in a data center in the UK
1:33:53to just leave it there untouched, never look at it. Or if you delete it, then the server has to do
1:34:01something. It has to delete it, right? It has to erase it from the storage. And does that consume
1:34:09more energy? The act of the server deleting and whatever file system actions have to happen,
1:34:16does that consume more energy than just leaving it there? Because if you just leave it there, the
1:34:23bits don't change. And then presumably if enough people in the UK deleted enough old email and old
1:34:31pictures from cloud storage, they could decommission some of the storage on the cloud. And then it's not
1:34:40even plugged in, right? That that would consume less energy. But just leaving it there versus the act of
1:34:48doing something with it, like deleting it, does that take more energy? It probably does, at least in the
1:34:53near term. Yeah. But either way... Let's turn to ChatGPT for a moment. Hold on. We're going to take a ChatGPT
1:34:59break. 4.0, good ChatGPT, not new ChatGPT. Oh, you're one of those. Really? Oh, yeah. Oh, I don't know.
1:35:06I like them both. I use them both. You just have to be more articulate. I like... 4.0 is a little
1:35:10better with lazy prompts. And my prompt was very lazy, right? Okay. Its answer is yes. Over the long
1:35:18term, deleting an old email can reduce energy consumption. And I think it follows the same
1:35:23logical thought process that you did, which was my process. Okay. Eventually you could decommission
1:35:28or stop using that. But it says in the short term, deleting an email uses more energy than just
1:35:33leaving it alone. You have to wake up storage. You have to modify indexes, so CPU cycles for the mail
1:35:38system. You have to update metadata and sync states. And then like queuing, deletion, journaling,
1:35:45like all of it, right? And then over time, basically they say the only like savings would be to actually
1:35:54decommission or lower the amount of storage in the facility. So like the storage is still going to have
1:36:02power to it. So it's not really going to be using any more or less. It would only be if there was suddenly
1:36:07so much less email that they didn't need to run as large of a data center.
1:36:11Or I guess, and I guess the way that would actually manifest itself, really thinking this through,
1:36:16which is really fun, is they'll need to add more storage later rather than sooner because there's
1:36:25free space available on the existing server storage because people deleted their pictures
1:36:32and emails, right? So that it in the payoff in the future isn't really that they're ever going to
1:36:38have less storage. That just doesn't seem like it's ever going to happen.
1:36:42Yeah, no.
1:36:43But if enough people were like, well, I'll just keep my 100 most recent photos and throw out the other
1:36:4950,000 that they'll need to add storage further in the future. It's just ridiculous. It makes no sense.
1:36:59You know what it is? I will say at its base level, at its base level, here's what it is. It's used paper
1:37:06straws, right? No, it's not about the straws, dude, right? It's about the corporations paying lobbyists
1:37:15to make it so they don't have to do all the stuff that they really should do because the scale is so
1:37:20off. You would have to have six billion people recycling their paper straws when you could really
1:37:28just make Exxon not do the stuff that they're doing. You know what I mean? Like it's really putting the
1:37:33onus on the individual, which is like the worst. It's the worst part of environmentalist thinking
1:37:38and like passing the buck that I hate about environmentalism. It is not about, yes,
1:37:44individual responsibility is great, especially from a personal perspective. I have individual
1:37:48responsibility. I hope you do too, and other people. However, every single amount of effort we put is like
1:37:55a drop in a literal ocean of effort that is being pushed in the opposite direction because big corporations
1:38:04have been lobbying for years to not have to do the due diligence and actually do things that are good
1:38:09for the environment. So it's like, come on now. Goodness gracious.
1:38:11Right. If you could split the earth into two multiverses where starting 10 years ago, every single straw,
1:38:21every single person used across the planet was a paper straw, and in the other one, nobody ever stopped
1:38:29using plastic straws or giving them out as freely as they did before this became an issue. And then you
1:38:35came to today, August 2025, and looked at the atmosphere. Would you see any difference whatsoever?
1:38:43No. I mean, like a couple of molecular, you know, like an omniscient deity could perhaps detect
1:38:52minor molecular differences, right? But I think most of it would be from the carbon dioxide emissions
1:39:01of people bitching about paper straws. Yeah, like maybe the straws is the wrong analogy. That was
1:39:08really like a weird turtle fake out. But you get the idea. It's just like the individual responsibility,
1:39:13it's so hard to measure. And I think COVID actually showed us how crazy it would have to be the change
1:39:20in our lifestyle, like an individual's lifestyle. Because we, everybody saw, oh, nature is healing
1:39:24and all of this stuff. Why? Because literally like every person on the planet stayed home for two
1:39:29weeks. I mean, that's like, you know, like that's not feasible. Sorry. Right. Like when the people
1:39:34went out and photographed like the freeways in Los Angeles at four o'clock on a Wednesday,
1:39:39and they're empty. And it looks like a post-apocalyptic movie where there's just an empty freeway on a sunny
1:39:46Sunday after weekday in California, Los Angeles. It's like, yeah, the environment got better. Right.
1:39:52If you could suddenly get rid of every internal combustion engine on the planet and either have
1:39:59people take mass transit or everybody switches to electric personal vehicles, you'd have a very
1:40:05measurable effect very quickly. Very quickly. The straws thing is like telling people to delete their old
1:40:12emails from the cloud server, except at least with the straw thing. It's like, I don't like them either.
1:40:20And I hate that Trump personally is annoyed by paper straws too. Like I hate, right? I really dislike
1:40:29this guy so frigging much that when he is, and again, the whole UK thing, I have to admit the Trump
1:40:36administration did a better job than the Biden administration. The Biden administration was on
1:40:40the wrong side of this. The Biden administration, I mean, I can put it in the show notes, I guess I'll
1:40:45make a note here, but the Biden administration, when they found out what the UK was up to,
1:40:50we're like, Hey, you do yours. Cause they knew the UK would share with them through the sharing
1:40:55agreement that the UK and Canada and Australia have for secret stuff. They're like, I don't know.
1:41:01It sounds good to us if we can kind of, yeah, well, we can't get it here. We'll just get the other end
1:41:05of the conversation. Right. And that there is like a law and that Biden administration officials were
1:41:10asked by Congress. God bless him. One of my favorite senators, Ron Wyden, I think he's from
1:41:15Washington or Oregon. I think he's Washington, but whatever. He's very, very good on tech issues and
1:41:20privacy and encryption and stuff like that. And it was on the committee where they asked them like,
1:41:25Hey, is there, you know, like they're under an obligation to say when they know that another
1:41:29country was asking for something that would infringe upon the privacy of the United States.
1:41:34And the Biden administration was like, yeah, we don't know. I don't think so. It's all good.
1:41:37Biden administration screwed that up. And the Trump administration was sticking it to the UK on this.
1:41:42And I kind of feel like, Hey, maybe not for the right reasons. And I know whenever I bring this up,
1:41:48people are already probably firing an email to me like, Oh my God, the Trump administration would
1:41:52love to be able to snoop on everybody's email. Don't be surprised if they do ask the same thing,
1:41:57they just don't want another country to have it. But it's like, I feel like the one factor of
1:42:01everybody involved from Trump himself to everybody he's surrounded himself now is they're all paranoid
1:42:07kooks. Right. And so they don't trust conspiracy all the way down. They don't trust each other,
1:42:14right? Trump doesn't trust anybody else in his administration. He doesn't want them to be able
1:42:18to snoop on his, his own communications. And none of them do either. Right. Right. That goofy
1:42:24cash Patel with his googly eyes. I mean, the last thing he wants is somebody reading his text
1:42:29messages. Anyway, it worked out. Yeah. Yeah, I know. I don't. But anyway, the thing about the
1:42:34straws, I hate, I hate that I'm on the same side as Trump. But the worst part is you get a shitty
1:42:39straw that falls apart by the end of your beverage. Yeah, I didn't mean it changes the taste of your
1:42:43beverage. Whereas if plastic straws, they don't change the taste of your beverage. Any poor sap in the UK
1:42:49who takes their, if this catches on in the way that, hey, we got to get rid of the straws,
1:42:55we got to save the dolphins, dolphins are choking on straws or whatever the explanation is, which is
1:42:59all nonsense. But if somehow this catches on, that you need to help with the drought and the climate
1:43:05situation by deleting your old cloud storage, then it's heartbreaking because anybody who follows the
1:43:12advice no longer has cloud storage of their personal photos. Right. Right. Like it does go back to
1:43:19COVID where billions of people around the planet were like, what do you want me to do? Do you want
1:43:24me to wear a mask? I'll wear a mask. You want me to stay inside? I'll stay inside. Whatever. I want to
1:43:28help. There's something, there's a crisis going on. And the same thing with the straws where the whole
1:43:33reason it took off is that people are like, okay, they say that the plastic straws are bad and there's
1:43:39obviously bad stuff going on with the climate. So, all right, I'll do what I can. Somebody who takes
1:43:44their advice on this is deleting their own photos. That's a minor tragedy that like a thousand paper
1:43:53straws don't amount to. Yeah. And I think they're targeting emails because it's an easy choice of like,
1:43:59oh, well, do you really read your old emails? No, you can delete those. But you know, you can see it. It's like,
1:44:04okay, so by that logic, if I use cloud storage, I hate the environment, right? Yes. It's like, okay,
1:44:11yeah, all right. But it's that personal guilt thing that is really like, I view it as even if people are
1:44:17well-wishing and it's not pragmatically happening, like actually happening, the framework for thinking
1:44:24about it is, this is just another way that corporations are able to get away with putting
1:44:29the onus off of themselves and onto people's guilt. And it's like, all right, oh, I should delete my
1:44:35old emails, not Google should find a way to make their data centers more efficient, you know? And
1:44:40which they do, which is fine because it saves them money. So if you can attach money to something,
1:44:45they'll make it more efficient. But yeah, that's the thing. Any individual deleting their emails
1:44:49is not going to do anything. Right. I don't think this one is going to take off. I think it's just goofy
1:44:53and it's not, there's not going to be a rash of people deleting their old photo libraries from
1:44:58cloud storage, but it does play into the general belief that tech companies are reckless and rather
1:45:06the tech data centers are overall a drain on the environment, which is true. They are enormous energy
1:45:15consumers and the energy is the fundamental source of the climate problem, right? Energy is the problem.
1:45:23that causes all of the carbon emissions and emissions and data centers are enormous,
1:45:30like the fundamental problem, like the whole reason the compute isn't the limit. It's the compute per
1:45:38watt is the limit. And that a lot of these places they they're using every watt that they can get into
1:45:43the data center. And that's what caps their compute. It's not the performance of the servers. It's the
1:45:50number of watts that are coming into the facility. And so that's true. And so people think, oh yeah,
1:45:58I guess it is like I'm part of it too. Cause I have a whole bunch of shit in my iCloud, but that's not it. You have no idea what it is that makes these data centers. So energy expensive, but it is not your personal library of 10,000 photos that you've shot over the last 20 years. Yeah. Oh man. All right. One last sponsor to thank. And it is our good friends at Squarespace and Squarespace.
1:46:27Squarespace is, as you probably know from me talking about it before the all in one, and I mean, all in one platform for putting a website online. It could be a personal website for you. It could be a professional website for you. It could be a professional website for a business like a restaurant or some other bigger concern, any sort of website that you need. Squarespace has plans to serve that scale of what you need.
1:46:54And when I say all in one, I mean, literally all in one, everything from registering a domain name to picking how it looks from a bunch of templates or adjusting how it looks with their built-in design tools, which they keep working on, which work great on the phone anymore.
1:47:11It's all there built in at Squarespace. Let's see some of the new stuff that they have design intelligence that's using AI to unlock your, your creative potential.
1:47:23So for tweaking the way your website looks, instead of using the WYSIWYG design tools, which are already very easy to use, you can just sort of chat with AI and tell the AI what type of look or what type of changes you're looking for works really well there.
1:47:38Of course, they're always on top of the new trends like that at Squarespace, Squarespace payments is easiest way to manage your payments in one place.
1:47:45They support everything you'd want. ACH direct deposit, Apple pay, after paying clear pay, those sort of things, everything you want.
1:47:54If you are a professional, like a consultant or a trainer or something like that, they've got invoicing now, so you can do all of your invoices, create your invoices, bill your clients, send it to them, and then they come back to your website and see the invoice there, pay it right there on your website.
1:48:14Very, very easy. Built-in analytics, all of that is there. Where do you go to find out more? Go to squarespace.com, get a free trial. 30 days, no limits, no watermarks on the website you build over that whole 30-day free trial.
1:48:30And then when you're ready to launch, go to squarespace.com slash talkshow. Just use that code talkshow. Either go there on the URL, squarespace.com slash talkshow, or just enter talkshow when you go to pay, and you will save 10% off your entire first purchase, which can be prepaid for a whole year.
1:48:49So you can save 10% on a whole year by going to squarespace.com slash talkshow.
1:48:55More on the legal front. The other thing I definitely wanted to talk about just happened this week was the, I have to laugh, the Massimo Apple Watch blood oxygen sensor dispute.
1:49:10It's still ongoing. It is not settled, but still we persist.
1:49:16So 18 months ago, I guess it came to a head. I guess Massimo had lodged their complaint months earlier, but it came to a public head right before Christmas 2023, when the Apple Watch Series 9 was new.
1:49:30And Massimo had won some sort of judgment from the U.S. It's such a confusing name, the International Trade Commission.
1:49:37Sounds like it's something like the United Nations, where it's like, right?
1:49:42Yeah, it does.
1:49:43But it's a U.S. organization that deals with international trade within the U.S.
1:49:52But I didn't, I had no idea. I never really knew this.
1:49:55But when the judgment first came, I'd heard of the International Trade Commission, but assumed it was, yeah, NATO or the U.N. or something.
1:50:02But it's not. It's a U.S. outfit.
1:50:03And they sided with Massimo that the Apple Watch blood oxygen sensor trampled on a couple of patents that Massimo held.
1:50:14And we're going to impose a trade block, an import ban.
1:50:20That's an import ban on Apple Watch.
1:50:22And Apple got it, at least got it postponed until after Christmas, which is obviously a huge deal for Apple Watch.
1:50:30You know, but it kicked in either at the end of December or very early January, then 2024.
1:50:36And from that point forward, the Apple Watches sold in the U.S. were, the hardware was the same, and they still had the blood oxygen sensors.
1:50:45But from the factory, out of the box, they were running a version of watchOS that in the U.S. disabled the blood oxygen sensors.
1:50:54And really unusual.
1:50:57I can't remember anything like this happening to Apple before.
1:51:01And I thought, and as far as I know, everybody else who follows this thought, well, this will last, what, a month?
1:51:06And then either Tim Cook writes a check or the judge says, ah, well, you know, this appeal is upheld.
1:51:14That's, this is not, I don't know, somehow this is going to go away in a couple of weeks.
1:51:18And it didn't.
1:51:20And then a whole new generation of Apple Watches came out last September, and the import ban was still on.
1:51:27Now, again, they're still imported, obviously, to the United States, but the blood oxygen sensor hasn't been available on an Apple Watch in the U.S.
1:51:36unless you bought it before, on or before December 2023.
1:51:40And the U.S. Customs Office issued a ruling last week based on an idea that Apple, and it's funny, I read it.
1:51:51It happened, Apple sent five units, five watches to Chicago from China with this workaround in place for a valuation by the Customs Department.
1:52:04And the way that it works now is it's still the Apple Watch Series 10 or the Ultra 2, but now when you go to the blood oxygen app on your watch and, say, take a reading, it says, okay, hold your arm still like it does everywhere else in the world or on any Apple Watch purchase before December 2023.
1:52:26And then it says, you can view the result on your iPhone.
1:52:29And what happens to work around the patent is the sensors are obviously on your wrist on the watch, but then the data goes to your iPhone for processing.
1:52:39And the result is only displayed in the health app on your iPhone or any other iPad or Mac with a health app.
1:52:49And the Customs Department sided with Apple that this gets around the Massimo patents because the patents, and I read the rule.
1:52:57I didn't read the patents.
1:52:58I scanned them.
1:52:59But the Customs Ruling picks out on page 15 of the Customs Department border ruling.
1:53:05And, well, I'll come back to what I was about to say.
1:53:09But they point out the patents, and the patents seem to say when you boil them down that the patent is for a device worn on the user that reads via two different lights, like infrared and whatever the other two ways of shining light through the skin.
1:53:29And non-invasive, doesn't puncture your skin, processes the data on the device worn on the body, and or displays the results on the device.
1:53:41And so by not processing the data on the device and not displaying the result on the device, it does seem that the patents that Massimo held applied.
1:53:53And I think Massimo's lawyers own gold themselves because it says in the Customs Ruling that the Massimo lawyers, when Apple first proposed this workaround, only said that we don't think that the patents are limiting that all of the stuff we describe in the preamble of the patent.
1:54:16Which is that it's a device on them, and it does this, and it processes it on the device, and displays the result on the device.
1:54:24We don't feel that's limiting, and this word limiting keeps coming up.
1:54:28And the Customs Office or whoever this hearing was for is, well, what if it's not limiting?
1:54:35And if the interpretation of the patent, and Massimo was like, we just don't think it's limiting.
1:54:40And that was their only argument.
1:54:41And the Customs Department went, or Customs and Borders Office, went to the International Trade Commission, the people who made the original decision.
1:54:50And they said, was your interpretation of these patents that they were limiting or not, based on the description in the preamble?
1:54:58And their answer was, oh, yeah, definitely.
1:54:59We did, definitely limiting.
1:55:01And so they sided with Apple.
1:55:04And I honestly think that based on the patents and Massimo's arguments about the patents, I really don't think, I know how silly this sounds, but I really think it was the right decision.
1:55:14And Apple found a workaround around it.
1:55:16There.
1:55:19I think it's a good summary, yeah.
1:55:20I mean, as far as I understand it, anyway, and obviously not a lawyer, but yeah, I mean, like the ITC order being, like, reversed, and so Massimo claims, like, ex parte.
1:55:31Like, basically, hey, you need to let us know that you were reversing this, and they didn't.
1:55:35I think that's, like, the next interesting legal wrangle.
1:55:39The workaround seems fairly straightforward.
1:55:41Okay, cool.
1:55:42Like, this SCT, like, this technology that Massimo basically claims at the center of their patent, it's basically their ability to, like, extract signal from confusing signals that can arrive from venous blood movement and arterial blood movement.
1:55:58And, like, that patent, which, and forgive me, my memory's a little fuzzy at this point, because I haven't really thought about this patent in a couple years, but I think that's basically what it was.
1:56:06It was, like, the technology to extract a proper signal from there and to do that on the device, and so Apple is basically saying, hey, we're doing that, but we're doing it off device, so that's where your limiting factor comes in.
1:56:17Like, is it all this stuff that matters together?
1:56:19Because if so, we've got a new thing.
1:56:21And they ruled in their favor.
1:56:22The ITC ruled in Apple's favor in this new.
1:56:25Well, no, Customs did.
1:56:26Sorry, sorry, Customs.
1:56:28Customs did, yes.
1:56:29I apologize.
1:56:29And then Massimo's saying, hey, the Customs ruling is, we don't think this is cool.
1:56:34And so that's the new legal back.
1:56:36No, they don't.
1:56:36They definitely don't think it's cool.
1:56:37They do not think it's cool at all.
1:56:39But I think they're suing over that, specifically now.
1:56:41Yeah, but it's interesting, because they're not suing Apple.
1:56:44They are suing the Customs and Border people.
1:56:47And I guess it does sound, I don't know what is typical or not.
1:56:52I guess this idea that Massimo found out about Apple's workaround solution being okayed when
1:57:00Apple announced it does seem like, I don't know about that.
1:57:04First of all, very Apple maneuver.
1:57:05Right.
1:57:06It's like, oh, yeah, we'd let you know, because we released a press release.
1:57:09Right.
1:57:10It was all very ready to go, right?
1:57:14Like, from my perception in the press, you know, and I got a email the night before.
1:57:23It's like the way you know this rigmarole where it's like, we'd like to send you something under NDA for nine o'clock tomorrow morning.
1:57:32Would you agree?
1:57:33And I was like, okay.
1:57:34And then they sent it.
1:57:34And I was like, oh, that sounds interesting.
1:57:36And then later today, there will be software updates for the iPhone and watch that do this.
1:57:41But it was all ready to go.
1:57:43And nobody had any, there were no leaks about this.
1:57:46No Mark Gurman reports that Apple's found a thing.
1:57:49This was all very, very tight lipped.
1:57:51But it's not, I feel like, I think, I don't know if there was any funny business with Massimo not getting a heads up that they got a word.
1:58:00But they obviously got to argue about it before customs.
1:58:03They're not as blindsided as they made it seem in the announcement of their lawsuit.
1:58:09Right.
1:58:09It's not like they didn't know anything was going on.
1:58:11They just didn't know that the ruling had been made.
1:58:13And it really does seem like they only argued, hey, these patents are not limiting to a combination of all these things.
1:58:20It's like any one of these things.
1:58:22So we're okay.
1:58:22And the ITC said, no, no.
1:58:24The whole basis of the import ban was that we read these patents as limiting and no watch does all these things on one device.
1:58:33I kind of, and I've been in an argument with various people about the meaning of the term patent troll.
1:58:39Because I describe Massimo as trolling over this.
1:58:41And it's colored by, I obviously have better sources at Apple than I do at Massimo.
1:58:47And Apple is biased.
1:58:49Right.
1:58:51But I have been told that these are not the reason that, you know, why hasn't this settled?
1:58:55Why haven't you just written a check?
1:58:56And they're like, because this is bogus.
1:58:59We are not going to settle this.
1:59:00And Apple tends to stick to its guns.
1:59:03There was a case.
1:59:04I forget the details.
1:59:05I forget who wrote about it.
1:59:06But there was some guy, like a blogger, who like 15 years ago took Apple to small claims court because his NVIDIA graphics card and his Mac went bad.
1:59:16And Apple sent two lawyers out to East Bumblefuck, Kentucky, a small claims court to fight this guy over this.
1:59:25And in the case, they're like, well, how much would it have cost for you to just replace this card?
1:59:30And their answer in the courtroom was, oh, nothing.
1:59:34When those cards go bad, NVIDIA pays, not us.
1:59:36Right?
1:59:40You did not want to get into a legal fight with a person like that.
1:59:43Right.
1:59:44Or an entity like that.
1:59:45They're just, it really wasn't about the money.
1:59:47And they were obviously spending more money to fight it than it would have been because literally they admitted, oh, no.
1:59:53They're like, we, you know, NVIDIA pays for those graphic cards that go bad, not us.
1:59:57Yeah, yeah.
1:59:57In the legal sense, like, they are fighting about precedent at that point.
2:00:03Okay.
2:00:03If this guy can get his replaced, okay, what if we have to replace millions or tens of millions?
2:00:09Right.
2:00:09Right.
2:00:09But on the individual basis, it's like just pure, like, nah.
2:00:14Right.
2:00:14And I know that Massimo is a real company with a bunch of real products, typically in the medical.
2:00:19Right.
2:00:19Which is why I wouldn't classify them as a troll, personally.
2:00:21Right.
2:00:22Right.
2:00:22Because a patent troll, almost like the prototypical patent troll, does not produce any products of their own, doesn't conduct research, you know, doesn't sell products.
2:00:32And Massimo does.
2:00:33So they are very aggressive, obviously.
2:00:36Right.
2:00:36But I wouldn't consider them a classic patent troll.
2:00:39And, you know, it's just like a term that I've learned, people.
2:00:43And my read on patent troll is more like cheating.
2:00:47This is the analogy I keep coming back to.
2:00:49And that the worst type of cheaters are people who only cheat.
2:00:52And if you cheat at card games, the worst cheaters are ones who run, like, a whole team full of cheaters.
2:00:58And it's like organized crime meant to cheat the slot machines in a casino or something like that.
2:01:04But it's also somebody who mostly plays honestly, but occasionally, like, takes a peek at a card in a home poker game or something like that.
2:01:13Or, like, one or two hands a night that tries to slip themselves an ace, that's still cheating, even if you play honestly 99% of the time.
2:01:22But I get it that some people are like, no, no, a patent troll is only like an outfit.
2:01:27Like, they're always registered in East Texas because then the court cases get adjudicated by the crazy Yosemite Sam lawyers in East Texas.
2:01:37And, you know, like a reporter goes to check out, here's the address of the patent holder, and it's like a closet.
2:01:44It's like room, you know, a suite.
2:01:47Rusty warehouse.
2:01:47Yeah, suite 200 at this address is literally just like a janitor's closet.
2:01:52The most famous, probably, that most people would know, or at least people involved in this world, is intellectual ventures, right?
2:01:58That's like a pre-load patent troll.
2:02:01Right.
2:02:01And they do nothing but collect patents and then sue people over them, basically.
2:02:06Right.
2:02:06Right.
2:02:07It's, you know, Nathan Mervhold, a Microsoft billionaire, who's like, I think, you know, I love the patent system.
2:02:14He kind of turned patent system to like a cleaned up version of an organized crime, right?
2:02:20Like, if most patent trolls are like pickpockets and swindlers on the corner, intellectual ventures was like the savings and loan scandal, right?
2:02:31It's like, oh, no, it's a real business, and it's, you know, it's got real money.
2:02:35I get it.
2:02:36And maybe that we need a different term, but it's like, I don't know what to call it, though, if a company like Massimo, who most of their stuff is real products, and they do have real breakthroughs in sensor technology over the decades or however long they've been in business.
2:02:51But on this particular case, they're trying to assert something that their patents really ought not to allow them to claim to hold exclusivity on.
2:03:02Right.
2:03:02It really does not seem to me like their patents mean nobody else in the world other than Massimo or Massimo paying licensee can read blood oxygen through the skin.
2:03:14What else do you call that but trolling?
2:03:16And I think it's also tech.
2:03:17I guess like uppercase T versus lowercase T, right?
2:03:20Like uppercase T, uppercase G-O-D versus lowercase G-O-D.
2:03:24Are they a troll or are they a troll?
2:03:26Like, they're definitely trolling for their recompense here, but are they a capital T troll like an IV?
2:03:32I don't know.
2:03:32And, you know, long story short, it's still the U.S. owners of new Apple watches and the people I feel really bad for are anybody who bought a watch before the import ban but got it replaced either under warranty or AppleCare, either because the watch was defective or it got smashed or something.
2:03:53Even though you bought it before the import ban or you just get, like, the battery replaced, they don't really replace the battery in your Apple watch.
2:04:01It's like you go in there and they take your watch and send it back and give you somebody else's refurbished Apple watch of the same kind with a brand new battery.
2:04:11Anything like that, you, after 18 months ago, you get one that doesn't do the blood oxygen reading, which kind of stinks.
2:04:17I mean, it says that the biggest deal, I mean, if they just said next month at the Apple event, if they just, it turns, again, they wouldn't announce it.
2:04:26But if after the keynote, everybody's looking at the tech specs in the series 11 Apple watch doesn't have a blood oxygen sensor.
2:04:35I mean, obviously, in this particular case, people think, well, does that have to do with this Massimo thing?
2:04:39But would you really think that would affect the sales of Apple watch, the blood oxygen?
2:04:44This is not a huge deal to why people have an Apple watch, but it's like any one of the sensors, as they go further down the chain of biometric sensing that they can do on your wrist, it all adds up to a better picture of your overall health, right?
2:05:01The blood oxygen, it's not nonsense, right?
2:05:04And if your blood oxygen drops below the low 90s percents, it's not good.
2:05:09And you might want an alert about it and go, it's one of those things that you might get alert about.
2:05:15And then you're the guy at the beginning of the Apple keynote who's like, yeah, my Apple watch told me I had this.
2:05:21And I went to the doctor and he said, hey, if your watch hadn't told you that, you'd be dead in a month.
2:05:24Right.
2:05:25Yeah, it's like you never know, like the confluence of those things gives you things like the dips in blood oxygen level can, along with other signals, not alone, but along with other signals, tell you things like, hey, you're getting sick, right?
2:05:38Or, you know, your capacity is lowered, which is one of the newer features that they introduced, which I've seen it happen to me.
2:05:45And it's been pretty accurate.
2:05:46Yeah.
2:05:47So it's like it adds up to a fuller picture and a fuller kind of x-ray vision into your health.
2:05:54And so I think any losses there are certainly ones that Apple does not want to just take on the chin.
2:05:59They would want to get more, not less capacity there for reading that information, for what they can do from the wrist, which is already quite limited.
2:06:08So I think they're going to I doubt they're going to give up the ghost on this at any point.
2:06:12I think they'll keep fighting it in some way.
2:06:14Yeah, I do, too, because I and I really do think that they're probably right that the patents should not be applied to the Apple Watch.
2:06:21But who knows?
2:06:22I did not expect Massimo's original import ban to last.
2:06:26So and I was wrong about that.
2:06:28And so I might be wrong about their suit against the Customs and Border Patrol.
2:06:33The one thing I want to add to that is and Massimo in their lawsuit did mention specifically that they found it curious that this ruling from Customs and Border Patrol came very shortly after a very high profile visit of Tim Cook at the White House where he gave Trump.
2:06:54They mentioned this in the law and I don't know if it's in the lawsuit or I guess it's in the lawsuit in comments where they announced that they had they're going to plan to spend.
2:07:03an extra hundred billion dollars in the US in the coming years on job creation and US manufacturing efforts or blah, blah, blah, and gave him a gold trophy.
2:07:15And then this happened.
2:07:17It is true that Tim Cook was in the Oval Office just like two weeks ago and did announce that they're spending more money on US manufacturing and job creation, which is in line with Trump's goals.
2:07:29And they definitely gave Trump a solid gold trophy.
2:07:33These things did occur.
2:07:34Can't dispute it.
2:07:36But I will say reading all the stuff I did on this that I did that all of this was in the works last year, a year ago, like while Biden was president, like the initial Apple, I think, came up with this workaround of doing the processing and not displaying the results on it on the watch a year ago, over a year ago, and and started the chain of events to get the Customs and Border Patrol to ask the ITC.
2:08:05Is this is your interpretation of these patents limiting?
2:08:08All of that was a year ago, and it was all set in motion and seemed inevitably coming to this conclusion from what I read.
2:08:16So I think it's a coincidence.
2:08:17But, you know, so on the one hand, if it was sparked by somebody else in the Trump administration calling the Customs Department and saying, hey, Tim Apple, he's our friend.
2:08:28What's going on here with this?
2:08:30Give him a good ruling.
2:08:31Right.
2:08:32Well, that's rotten, right?
2:08:33That's just that's that's oligarchy and corruption.
2:08:36And that's just a rotten and shameful way for the U.S.
2:08:39federal government to be run.
2:08:40But even if it's not, even this is a totally up and up, which I really do think is the case, having read the details of this report or the ruling from the CBP or whatever.
2:08:51Yeah, CBP.
2:08:52I really do think it's on the up and up and was entirely adjudicated by the sort of bureaucratic, fair minded, nonpartisan people who you think your whole life have been working at places like the Customs and Border Patrol Office of patent disputes on import bans.
2:09:12Right, right.
2:09:12I really do think that that's what happened.
2:09:15But that's the downside of Tim Cook going to the Oval Office and giving Trump his fucking gold trophy is then even when legitimate things work out in your favor, people look at him and say, that seems fishy to me.
2:09:31Right.
2:09:31Yeah.
2:09:31You've given up your benefit of the doubt.
2:09:34Right.
2:09:35Or your freeness of speech or whatever you want to call it.
2:09:37Like, you have created the, at the very least, the optics or planted the seed of that conversation to happen every time you, any one of these things comes down the pike.
2:09:50And so you can't get mad or upset about it when people assume that your payola is paying off.
2:09:57It's like, you gave him a gold trophy and then a government agency said, ah, cool, it's fine.
2:10:03Yeah.
2:10:04What are we supposed to think, right?
2:10:06And so, like, I agree with you.
2:10:07It's probably not the case in this case.
2:10:09But anything that happens from now on, you've poisoned the well, right?
2:10:13Right.
2:10:13Yeah.
2:10:14And effectively, even though you don't get to see the results of your blood oxygen test on your wrist, it's a very good workaround from Apple's perspective.
2:10:25You know, I'm sure they're going to continue petitioning to get the whole thing thrown out so they can just make the U.S.
2:10:30Apple watches have the same experience worldwide where you can see the fucking number on your wrist instead of having to go to your phone.
2:10:38But effectively, blood oxygen in particular is not something where people are ordinarily running a test.
2:10:44Like, hey, I'm going to check my blood oxygen.
2:10:46It's not like heart rate.
2:10:47Like, heart rate would be devastating, right?
2:10:49Just like, might as well not have an Apple watch, you know?
2:10:51Right.
2:10:52Because people do think, I want to test my heart rate right now and I want to see it while I'm exercising.
2:10:57Every workout, yeah, every workout, you're saying you're looking at it.
2:10:59I want to see what my heart rate's at as I'm on the bike or the spin machine or whatever you're doing.
2:11:04The blood oxygen thing is just a background reading while you sleep a lot, too, and it just shows up in your health report.
2:11:12And any kind of drop or a change in the weekly trends or something like that, you'll just get in a notification on your phone and it's fine, right?
2:11:22It really isn't a problem that you don't get to see.
2:11:25It's a little awkward when you actually run the test on your watch that it's like, we're not going to tell you why, but go check in the health app on your phone.
2:11:32Yeah, it's like one of those things when Siri tells you, oh, go look on your iPhone.
2:11:35No, just read it to me.
2:11:37Shad Zibig, he can read it to me.
2:11:39Just read it to me, you know?
2:11:41Yeah, exactly.
2:11:42I can't tell you that, but I could if you tried it on your phone.
2:11:45Yeah, yeah, exactly.
2:11:46I know that, but I'm not going to tell you.
2:11:48Go pick up your iPhone.
2:11:49Prove you have one, please.
2:11:50Thank you.
2:11:50Yeah.
2:11:51All right, Matthew.
2:11:52All right.
2:11:53It's good to have you back.
2:11:54You are blogging, and you're at theobsessor.com, which is, I told you the last time, such a great name.
2:12:02Very, very self-descriptive, because you do obsess.
2:12:05I do about all kinds of stuff.
2:12:08But yeah, I'm looking forward to continuing on there, just trying to do some essays, and then also doing some just recommendations, little things.
2:12:15And what else are you up to?
2:12:16What in the hell else are you doing?
2:12:18I work at a company now called GrowthX.ai.
2:12:20I'm pretty stoked.
2:12:22It's fun.
2:12:23We get to work with a lot of AI systems.
2:12:25We're basically a workflows company, so we're building workflows that could apply to all kinds of different ways that people work.
2:12:31And I'm stoked.
2:12:32I get to work with a lot of smart people, do new work.
2:12:35I mean, one of the reasons I exited journalism was that I wanted to build products and learn how that happened and work with people that did it on a close basis.
2:12:44So I spent a lot of my day in linear and Figma and messing around with code, doing a little bit of bytecoding myself or regular coding, mostly simplistic stuff.
2:12:53I'm not that good.
2:12:54But then I can sketch things out, and the engineers make it a reality.
2:12:57So that's me.
2:12:59That's why I kind of left the writing game, not so much because I didn't like it or it wasn't enjoyable to me.
2:13:06I just had spent a decade-plus covering people that built stuff and learning very deeply in how these processes worked, and I just really wanted to actually do that process.
2:13:15So that's what I'm doing.
2:13:16I'm happy.
2:13:16Very nice.
2:13:18Well, good to talk.
2:13:19And I want to thank our sponsors.
2:13:20We had, I guess I'll go and reverse order, Squarespace.
2:13:23You can get your all-in-one website.
2:13:26Factor Meals, where you can order delicious meals that are so easy to cook very quickly from a wide variety.
2:13:33And Sentry, a great developer system for just helping to find and fix bugs in your app or website or service.