Podcast Search

The Talk Show

430: ‘Ersatz PopSocket’, With Andru Edwards

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00Andrew Edwards, welcome to the talk show.

0:00:02Appreciate it. Thank you. Very happy to be here.

0:00:05I think you texted me personally last week before you tweeted about it, like on threads or wherever, but you were at Google's Made by Google event and said, this is so weird.

0:00:16Tell me about it.

0:00:18Yeah, it was weird. So basically, I mean, we've been to these press events before.

0:00:21I've been to press events from pretty much any company you can think of, and they're all, except for Apple post-pandemic,

0:00:29they're all pretty much the same thing, right?

0:00:30You go in, you sit down, and there's a bunch of media there, and there's some sort of presentation about these products that are meant and directed towards the media who are in the audience.

0:00:41That's pretty much how this works.

0:00:42If you go to an Apple event, they're going to make a video these days, and you're going to watch the video, which I guess, in a way, the videos almost feel equally meant for media as well as the general public.

0:00:58If you're interested in what Apple is doing, you can watch an Apple video and kind of be entertained, even if you're not media.

0:01:04What Google did here was almost put together a media event where they just ignored the audience, or the audience was expected to be a participant in what was going into the cameras.

0:01:19So they had these huge cameras like you'd see on at The Tonight Show or SNL or something like that, and they're just looking into these cameras.

0:01:26They're not really paying much attention to us.

0:01:28And when they sat us down, I want to say maybe 30 minutes before they started or something, they had a guy come up and do a warm-up, like some sort of comic, to warm up the crowd and be like, hey, when you see the applause sign up there, be loud.

0:01:43Let us know you're enjoying yourself.

0:01:45And I'm just sitting there like, I came here to learn about a product, not fawn over it to make it look good for anyone who's watching a live stream.

0:01:54So it felt very strange to me.

0:01:56And what was, I don't know, even more surprising to me, not to call anyone out, but it seemed like there were some others who thought I was being, like, too harsh.

0:02:04Other media who were sitting in there, it's like, hey, this is how live shows go.

0:02:09Haven't you ever been to a live show?

0:02:10I'm just like, what do you mean?

0:02:11That's what we're here for.

0:02:12Matthew Panzerino and I talked about it just a couple days ago on a previous episode of this show, but he wasn't there, which is why I want to talk to you about it.

0:02:20Yeah.

0:02:20But I do think, I mean, you tell me, I mean, is it sort of a generational divide where it's the younger, more pure influencer types who are like, hey, this is normal.

0:02:33You play to the camera and it's the older, let's face it, like us who are a little more, hey, we're here for work.

0:02:41This is my job to cover this thing.

0:02:43And it's not about being a dick, right?

0:02:45It's not like, right.

0:02:47You know, I'm more specifically Apple-focused, but I have been to Google events.

0:02:51I wish I went to this one.

0:02:52I really do.

0:02:53I've been to events from other companies, and I'm always, I try to be, just like when I see you and I bump into you in June at WWDC keynote.

0:03:02I'm friendly to other people in the press.

0:03:04I'm friendly to the PR people from the company that I'm there for.

0:03:08I'm friendly.

0:03:10That's how I go about life, but I'm also professional and clapping and applauding is sort of not professional.

0:03:17Yeah.

0:03:18Yeah.

0:03:18It's a little strange.

0:03:19And one thing I saw from, well, first going back to what you just asked, I think there is that generational divide.

0:03:24I feel like I'm kind of in the middle, almost like people say people who were born like in the, I saw I was born in 1980.

0:03:31So I think it's Xeniel, they call it, where like, as I became a teenager, the internet came into fruition.

0:03:38And so I remember, I clearly remember a time before and I clearly remember the time after, but I was of the age where you grabbed onto it very quickly.

0:03:47And it just became part of your life as opposed to if you were older and you're like, well, what is this internet thing?

0:03:52I think that it kind of felt like that.

0:03:55It was like, I'm here to have fun and just cover stuff and show this to my audience.

0:03:59And if I'm clapping and having a good time, what's wrong with that?

0:04:02Versus me feeling like if all of us said to ourselves, you know what?

0:04:07No, we're here for work and we're not going to clap.

0:04:08That would have been an incredibly awkward presentation.

0:04:11Right.

0:04:12Like Google counted on the audience to make the presentation what it was.

0:04:17Right.

0:04:18You know what I'm saying?

0:04:18Yeah.

0:04:19So in that respect, it was like.

0:04:21They're putting an onus on the person.

0:04:23Yes.

0:04:23That's right.

0:04:24I did not like that.

0:04:25One argument I saw from people was, well, you clap when you go to the Apple events.

0:04:29And it's like, no, at the Apple events, I'm frantically typing and taking pictures and shooting video and trying to post.

0:04:35The people you hear clapping are the people who work at Apple who probably worked on those products or services that they're announcing.

0:04:41It's certainly not the press because when I look around at my friends in the media, everybody's frantically trying to get their work done and get posts up as soon as possible.

0:04:48No one's taking time to clap.

0:04:49Yeah.

0:04:50It's like I said on the previous episode, I will clap for certain things like when they open with, you know, here's a guy whose life was saved because he drove his car off a mountain and his Apple watch saved his life.

0:05:02And everybody's, you know, it's like, yeah, yeah.

0:05:05I clap because also I don't really have notes to take.

0:05:07My notes say opening video guys life saved by Apple watch.

0:05:11Right.

0:05:12Right.

0:05:12So my notes are done.

0:05:13And, you know, who's not happy that some some guy who drove his car off a cliff and his cell phone couldn't reach his phone, got his life saved because his watch issued an SOS alert.

0:05:23Yeah.

0:05:23Yeah.

0:05:24Yeah.

0:05:24Yes.

0:05:24Or somebody with I remember very specifically, there was a really, really good one that Apple did about accessibility where blind people were using either the phones or like a combination of their iPhones and AirPods to like navigate the world.

0:05:40Like somebody, you know, found their hotel room, you know, a door that reads 2114, you know, it's like, oh, that's my hotel room.

0:05:47And it's like, how do you clap for that?

0:05:50But for the most part, like when they're saying the new M4 chip is 20 percent more power efficient or whatever.

0:05:56Let the Apple people clap, you know.

0:05:58Yeah.

0:05:58I mean, I'm glad.

0:05:59Unless it's unless it's an orange device.

0:06:01Last year, I clapped for the orange AirPods Max.

0:06:04Yeah.

0:06:05And this year, if there's an orange iPhone Pro, as rumored, I will clap.

0:06:08Well, besides that.

0:06:09Right.

0:06:10For the most part, you don't.

0:06:13Was there this is a question?

0:06:15Because I watched the whole video for the made by Google event.

0:06:18And I mean, it's not the worst.

0:06:21And I watched I hadn't watched the whole thing when I recorded the previous episode.

0:06:25Now I've watched the whole thing.

0:06:27It wasn't so bad that I don't know that they'll never do it again.

0:06:31But I feel like it needs a lot of tweaks.

0:06:33And I am glad they're trying something new.

0:06:36Right.

0:06:36And Google often tries something new.

0:06:38They seem to be trying to.

0:06:40They've always seemed to be trying to find their voice for how to do a press event.

0:06:46But were there Google employees?

0:06:49Was there a set?

0:06:50Was it all press in the audience?

0:06:51Or was there a contingent of homers from Google?

0:06:55Like Apple, I guess the audience.

0:06:57Yeah, I can't say or you can't.

0:06:59I know for sure.

0:07:00But what I can say is the audience seemed pretty small.

0:07:03So, I mean, this is just me gauging off of visuals.

0:07:07I want to say it was maybe two thirds the size of what would you see in a Steve Jobs theater.

0:07:13Yeah.

0:07:13So, there wasn't a lot of people there.

0:07:16So, if they did make room for Google people, then probably would have been a lot of them.

0:07:21You know, it does seem like it was a mix of a traditional in-person press event where, like you said, the reps from the company are addressing the media in the audience, even though it is being taped or filmed and broadcast on throughout the world.

0:07:40And thousands or perhaps even a big enough company, millions of people are watching on YouTube or wherever on video.

0:07:49And it's at most, even in a big room, a couple hundred media live.

0:07:55But the address from the stage is to the media and you can perceive that.

0:08:00But people know, like, if you go to see the real Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon or the Stephen Colbert show or something, you understand when you're in the audience that they are doing a TV show and that they are playing to the cameras and that the cameras are in the way sometimes.

0:08:18You know, and that the cameras are big and there are big camera people who are standing there and that they're, you're like, well, yeah, I mean, I'm here to watch the taping of a TV show, not a live audience stage show that just happens to be being taped subtly from cameras that are hidden.

0:08:38You get that.

0:08:39So, this is sort of a middle ground where they're playing to the camera, but it is live and there is an audience there, right?

0:08:45Right.

0:08:46And the weird thing was we weren't even told, I didn't find out it was like this until I stepped into the room.

0:08:51Yeah, yeah, I would never have guessed.

0:08:53Why are these cameras so big?

0:08:55If they would have at least told us in advance, hey, here's what we're doing.

0:08:57And because here's the thing, like Apple will never tell us in advance what they're going to show, right?

0:09:02I think there was one time where an Apple invite very clearly told us what it was going to be.

0:09:09It was the iPhone 5 event that had a number 5 in the invite.

0:09:14Besides that, they try to be subtle with it, right?

0:09:16For this one, alternatively, for Google's, Google's event started, I believe it was noon.

0:09:22No, I think their event started at 1 p.m.

0:09:24And the embargo for coverage was noon.

0:09:27So, I was able to put my video out showing what they were going to announce an hour before they started their event.

0:09:33Ah, yeah, yeah.

0:09:33Which, Apple would never do that, right?

0:09:35No.

0:09:35Hey, our Apple's going to go on stage at 10, but 9 a.m., all the hands-on of the iPhone is going to go on YouTube.

0:09:41That's just never going to happen.

0:09:42So, if they allowed us all that information in advance, you could have at least told me, like, hey, here's what we're going to be doing, and here's how it's going to go down.

0:09:51Just so you know what's going on, because it was so, I've never been to a media event like that ever from any company, where it was like, we were just kind of ignored, except for make sure you clap when the applause sign comes off.

0:10:02I always, it's harder now, and maybe, because they, I mean, they only have one event a year for the press in the Steve Jobs Theater, right?

0:10:11It's the iPhone.

0:10:11Yes, correct.

0:10:12Which we'll get to later on the show and talk about our thoughts about it, because it's coming up.

0:10:15What are we, like, a week and a half away or something like that?

0:10:19And WWDC has a live audience, and it's big, but WWDC has always, even in the old days when it was a real conference,

0:10:30we were at a keynote in the old WWDC days, like, at the San Jose Conference Center.

0:10:34I've only gone to them, no, I've only gone to them at Apple Park.

0:10:38At Apple Park.

0:10:39So the old way, when it was, like, either at Moscone or then a couple of years afterwards at San Jose,

0:10:46and I know that it, don't write me, in ancient days, like, in the late 90s, they were in San Jose, too.

0:10:53But the ones that I remember from Moscone and then the San Jose Convention Center, it's every developer who went to, who bought a ticket for WWDC got to go, too.

0:11:04And they'd have it in a cavernous, not quite arena, but there were 5,000 people in the room, five or more, right?

0:11:13It was always, and so the press was just a tiny contingent.

0:11:16And yes, there were all the Apple employees and executives in the front, but for the most part, it was filled with developers.

0:11:24And so there was lots of cheering and clapping and stuff because it was developers.

0:11:29So, of course, that was always a little weird.

0:11:31And Macworld, way back in the day, I only went to a couple of those as press, but that was the same, too.

0:11:37Even more so, where it's just fans of the company who went to Macworld Expo and waited in line to go to see the keynote.

0:11:44But with the traditional press events where you think everybody's either an Apple employee or in the media,

0:11:50you could always tell, A, the front row and the front few rows is always Apple executives and VIPs.

0:11:59Board members.

0:12:00Yeah, and VIPs like people from Pixar and stuff like that, right?

0:12:05Like I met Leon Critch at one, you know, and I'm sure he was sitting in like the third or fourth row or something.

0:12:10I didn't meet him in the third or fourth row.

0:12:12I was in the back with the other hacks.

0:12:14But then you could always tell where the team members were, right?

0:12:19If it was like the first version of AirPods with noise canceling and they talk about the noise canceling,

0:12:26you'd hear the applause from like off to the left.

0:12:30Oh, that's the team.

0:12:31They're here.

0:12:32They're like, woo.

0:12:34And I like that.

0:12:35Yeah, it was kind of fun.

0:12:38And it was one of those things that was neat about being there in person as the media,

0:12:43because I don't think I and for many, many years before I started getting invited to attend in person,

0:12:49I'd watch them online and watch the video.

0:12:52And all you hear is applause on a video.

0:12:54You don't hear that it's like a section of people.

0:12:59Like it's only like 25 people, but they are super excited about P3 color gamut on the display.

0:13:06Right, right.

0:13:07And I feel like we kind of lose that because so since we get to go in person, we still get to hear the applause.

0:13:13And I remember for Apple Vision Pro, two WWDCs ago, I think that was the last time I said, hey, we have one more thing, right?

0:13:19And everybody went crazy.

0:13:20Yeah.

0:13:20And then I went home and watched it.

0:13:22It was like, it's just Tim Cook saying, and we have one more thing.

0:13:25Yeah.

0:13:25And it's just silence.

0:13:25Yeah.

0:13:26I'm like, oh, that's, it just doesn't hit the same when you can't hear at least mic up the crowd or something.

0:13:32Like, it makes it feel way more dry than what we experienced watching the exact same video in the crowd.

0:13:39Yeah.

0:13:40I would definitely say that the incongruity between the in-person experience and the watch at home experience has never been greater.

0:13:50And I don't think it could be greater than the last few years of WWDC in particular because they still do the thing where they invite, like, a thousand random developers just to attend the keynote and the State of the Union afterwards.

0:14:07And they're very enthusiastic, super excited to be there.

0:14:11And there's hundreds of Apple employees, some up close, some in the back, like, way in the back, like, really, really in the cheap seats.

0:14:20You know, like, when you're behind the media, you have a bad seat, but they're, like, back, right?

0:14:25Like, guys like me and you.

0:14:27They're in the cafeteria.

0:14:27Yeah.

0:14:28Like, we're, like, strategically at the edge of the sun and the shade.

0:14:32Yes.

0:14:33Right?

0:14:33And it's, oh, no, I don't want to go.

0:14:35They're like, do you want to move up a little?

0:14:36No, no, I don't want to get a sunburn.

0:14:37Absolutely not.

0:14:38I'm going to sit right here.

0:14:39But then there are, like, seats all the way back in the cafeteria, literally in the cafeteria that's, like, Apple employees.

0:14:43You're inside the building.

0:14:45Right, so you get this stereo effect of, yes, there's people up front cheering because they are the invited developers and Apple employees.

0:14:51And then there's people behind us cheering, and they're the Apple employees in the cafeteria.

0:14:56And then there's us miserable hacks typing away or writing in notebooks in the middle.

0:15:01But we do hear applause, right?

0:15:03And like you said, like, the one more thing for Vision Pro was a bananas moment on the lawn in Apple Park.

0:15:12And, you know, it was rumored.

0:15:13It wasn't like it came out of nowhere.

0:15:14Everybody sort of expected that Apple was going to announce their headset.

0:15:17But it was a real moment, right?

0:15:21It's like, oh, you hear this.

0:15:22And the people watching at home, or if, you know, me and you watch the video to take notes again at home, you hear nothing.

0:15:29Yeah.

0:15:30There's no...

0:15:31Yeah, it's so weird.

0:15:31Yeah, it's very different.

0:15:33Really weird.

0:15:34Anyway, I want to talk, too, not just about the event.

0:15:37I want to talk about what was announced at Google's event, really.

0:15:41But let me take a break here and thank our first sponsor.

0:15:45It is our good friends at Sentry.

0:15:49S-E-N-T-R-Y.

0:15:52They want me to emphasize the spelling for the very good reason that people hear it as Sentry, which isn't true.

0:16:00It's Sentry, like a guard.

0:16:01If you are listening to this podcast, there is a very good chance that you have either built an app or a website, like a mobile app, a desktop app, a web app, or you're building one, or you're going to be building one, or you're doing it all the time, or you've got like three or four of them up in the air, open projects right now.

0:16:17And one thing nobody wants in any of these projects are bugs.

0:16:22Sentry helps you fix bugs faster so that you can deliver the five-star experience that your users expect.

0:16:28Sentry supports just about any language and framework you'd want.

0:16:33Swift, Python, Node, you name it, they support it.

0:16:37Your whole stack is covered.

0:16:39And in particular, for my audience, they support every single Apple platform.

0:16:43Not just the big ones like iOS and macOS, but the smaller ones like watchOS, visionOS, and everything in between.

0:16:51But they've got great support for every single Apple developer platform.

0:16:54And Sentry goes way beyond what you get from the app store for, like, crash reporting and stuff like that.

0:17:00Sentry has real-time crash reporting and performance monitoring, hang detection, and session replay.

0:17:06So you can see exactly what your users are experiencing or the steps that they went through that led them to the bug or the freeze or whatever unpleasantness happened.

0:17:13Sentry is used by millions of developers, including some of the biggest apps.

0:17:18Some of these I know everybody out there listening has used.

0:17:21Claude, Disney+, Duolingo.

0:17:24Sentry has recently launched a new AI agent, Seer, S-E-E-R, which can automatically generate fixes in your code repository with over 90% accuracy.

0:17:35Try it free at sentry.io slash talkshow.

0:17:40That's S-E-N-T-R-Y dot I-O slash talkshow.

0:17:45And tell them when you sign up that this is the podcast where you heard about them.

0:17:49They have a free developer plan.

0:17:50And listeners of the show who use that code talkshow get three months of free service and 150,000 errors for free.

0:18:00Sentry.io slash talkshow.

0:18:03You also texted me.

0:18:05I think you texted me before the applause sign.

0:18:09But basically, I think, at least for my audience, the headline feature is that Google with the Pixel 10 is shipping effectively the just tell the AI to do stuff.

0:18:22And it gets context from your app's experience that Apple promised.

0:18:26Not even.

0:18:26Not even.

0:18:27It's like one better than that.

0:18:29If you were to text me, hey, where were we meeting for dinner tomorrow?

0:18:34I don't have to ask.

0:18:35If you send me that text, it'll give me like a pre-written response where it already has included the information.

0:18:41And I just have to tap on it and it sends it to you.

0:18:44So I don't even have to say like, hey, when does mom's flight land again next week?

0:18:48It'll just offer it up, which I was very impressed by.

0:18:52What other things can it do?

0:18:55Tell me more.

0:18:56Apple has talked about this, has not delivered it, but it's the sort of what's on my screen right now stuff.

0:19:02Yeah, it can do what's on your screen.

0:19:03I mean, that's almost table stakes now for Google.

0:19:05Google, I mean, if you want an AI phone and you're not deeply embedded into the Apple ecosystem of products and services,

0:19:13Google has made the AI phone because, what was it?

0:19:16Apple, in the past few interviews, they used the term bolted on AI, right?

0:19:21We're not just bolting on AI on the side, which I think they were talking about like a chat bot separately.

0:19:26But now when you look at what Google did with Magic Q, that's the feature that can just offer things up.

0:19:31It almost feels like the Apple intelligence version is kind of a bolt on two because it's not proactive.

0:19:37It's still reactive to your request.

0:19:40Another example they gave was if someone said, hey, could you call the airline about our flight tomorrow?

0:19:46Instead of writing a response to that person, it will give you, here's the number to United Airlines.

0:19:51You tap the number to call.

0:19:53It'll take you into the phone app and start making the call, but it'll also surface.

0:19:56Here's your flight number.

0:19:57Here's your flight time.

0:19:58Here's the airport.

0:19:59You go, you leave from here.

0:20:00It just gives you everything right there.

0:20:01You don't have to look for it.

0:20:02It's just, it's smart.

0:20:04And so it's things like that where I'm feeling like if I want an AI device that feels helpful and feels like it doesn't get in my way, or I think a lot of people are also averse to AI just because they feel weird talking to an inanimate object still.

0:20:21If you can just surface things for me as they appear on my screen, or as you see people ask them of me, or you just see I'm kind of searching, looking for something.

0:20:31If you can just offer it up and surface it for me, that feels like AI that is actually helpful and still stays out of my way when it's unneeded.

0:20:40That, I think, is a huge deal, plus the fact that if you are comfortable or willing to use an AI chatbot, the fact that it can see your screen but can also see the world.

0:20:54So you can just say, hey, take a look through my camera, not a photo, but walk with me and look down, I don't know, look down the aisle of this supermarket.

0:21:02I'm looking for a can of food that has these types of ingredients, but it's low sodium.

0:21:06I don't know.

0:21:07It can scan for, oh, right there on the second shelf to your right.

0:21:10Like that is, I think, very cool and kind of shows a practical idea of the future of how AI can be used.

0:21:19Right.

0:21:21And I just used the word on dithering.

0:21:24It's not out yet, but I guess it'll be out before this episode.

0:21:27But AI, in some ways, on its own, is superhuman, right?

0:21:32And I know that word gets tossed around a lot in the context of watching DC and Marvel Universe movies.

0:21:41But if you just reduce it to the plain language, it just means something that humans can't do.

0:21:46And computers have always been superhuman in some ways, right?

0:21:50Like the whole, just the dawn of the PC industry where spreadsheets were the first killer app, so to say.

0:21:58And like accountants were like, oh, the tabular two-dimensional layout of numbers is already how they were filling out books, green paper books.

0:22:10But, oh, I could change a number in the middle and all the other numbers update instantaneously?

0:22:16Superhuman, right?

0:22:17Because you just, there's no way to do that with pen and paper or even with a calculator, right?

0:22:22It's, it was totally different.

0:22:24And AI is superhuman in so many different ways.

0:22:27But also it is sort of, again, it's just to lean on the superhero analogy.

0:22:33It is the superhero who it's most like is clearly Tony Stark in Iron Man, right?

0:22:39Where he's, he doesn't have any superhuman abilities, right?

0:22:43He's got this augmented suit.

0:22:46And it is kind of like that, right?

0:22:48Like if you can just sort of point your phone at the aisle and it's like, I'm so bad at finding Where's Waldo, right?

0:22:56Yeah.

0:22:57I derive, I'm so bad at it, I derive no pleasure from it.

0:23:00This is a nightmare for me.

0:23:02And I know what that's like, especially like if it's a supermarket you don't go to regularly or an item you don't buy regularly.

0:23:09Of course, the things you buy all the time, you know exactly where they are in the store.

0:23:12But it's like if you're making a recipe where it's like you need a certain kind of beans and I never even buy beans.

0:23:18I don't know.

0:23:19And it's like, oh my God, where the hell is this?

0:23:21If something could just say it's right there, third shelf, red can.

0:23:24Well, that's freaking great, right?

0:23:27And it totally can do that.

0:23:30It can already do it, right?

0:23:31And it's all now just sort of sorting out how are we going to make this more ubiquitous?

0:23:37Is it going to be glasses?

0:23:38Is it going to be a badge, a pendant?

0:23:41Is it, you know, all of the above or there'll be multiple form factors or is it going to settle on one?

0:23:47Who knows?

0:23:48But me personally, I'm personally, my personal computing life is shocker in the Apple ecosystem.

0:23:55And I'm sure a lot of my audience is too.

0:23:58But you're in denial if you don't see that that sort of, hey, some of this stuff is already real, is already out there.

0:24:07And you're missing out if that's all you use.

0:24:10You really are.

0:24:11And like Apple executives like at WWDC, it's, you know, it's their job.

0:24:16What are they going to say?

0:24:17Yeah, we really got caught with our pants down on this stuff.

0:24:20Right.

0:24:20Of course.

0:24:20They're not.

0:24:21They're going to downplay it.

0:24:23And I don't think it's too late, right?

0:24:25The truth is somewhere in the middle.

0:24:26They are not hopelessly behind.

0:24:28They're just behind.

0:24:31And they often are behind or they often are measuring twice, cutting once before they come out with their thing, right?

0:24:38There were smartphones for a decade before the iPhone, right?

0:24:41And nobody remembers them now.

0:24:43It was cool, right?

0:24:45And it was the same way that people who had a smartphone in 2005 or 2006 wouldn't shut up about them, right?

0:24:52I don't know if you did.

0:24:53I did not.

0:24:54It felt cool if I had a computer in my hand.

0:24:56Right.

0:24:57And being able to take, even though they were kind of shitty cameras, but it's like, I have a camera with me everywhere I go.

0:25:02And I can text you the picture from wherever I am.

0:25:05Yep.

0:25:06I don't need to go home and take out an SD card and put it in my computer and copy it over and then put it back on my phone so that, you know, or whatever you had to do.

0:25:16Or sync, plug it into sync.

0:25:17Right, sync.

0:25:17Yep, right.

0:25:18I could just send it to you right here from the supermarket.

0:25:21It's out there, right?

0:25:23And I think the Pixel phones are sort of leading the way.

0:25:26No, I think so too.

0:25:27But one thing that's not AI that I thought, you know, I've always loved, I don't know why, maybe it's the drama of it.

0:25:33This is my version of drama because I don't, as a tech nerd, I love when companies call out other companies on stage.

0:25:39I just like that.

0:25:40Like when Steve Jobs was like, hey, let me show you all these other sucky phones before I show you the iPhone.

0:25:44Here's the palm tree, right?

0:25:46He's just naming names.

0:25:47So I did enjoy when Google was like, hey, Apple, we think we have something that stands up to what you're offering in some areas, at least.

0:25:54And then they introduced PixelSnap.

0:25:56What was funny about that, though, was Apple created MagSafe and then like, I don't know how you want to put it.

0:26:04Like they, I don't know if they offered it up or teamed up with, like they allowed it to become a standard.

0:26:10So when you now incorporate the standard into your device, you can't call out Apple about how, well, we have this tune.

0:26:18The only reason you have it is because Apple allowed this technology to become ubiquitous for anyone who wants to incorporate it.

0:26:24That said, I do like the fact that I feel like that's the second biggest thing people talk about from the Pixel event.

0:26:30Number one is the AI features.

0:26:31Number two is PixelSnap.

0:26:32And the fact that on day one of buying a Pixel 10, anything that's ever been a MagSafe device now works with your phone.

0:26:40So you have this unbelievably large ecosystem of devices that work day one.

0:26:46And it's not Google's version that you have to look for on the box.

0:26:50It's just if it's MagSafe, it works.

0:26:51PixelSnap, it works.

0:26:52Yeah, it's a good, maybe canonical.

0:26:56Maybe it's like the best example of the sort of hybrid approach of a proprietary invention and novelty combined with some open source.

0:27:10Open standards and cooperation from the inventor, in this case, Apple sharing, you know, to make Qi or Qi 2 compatible.

0:27:20And I think some, even people who use Apple products often are the most critical of Apple's, hey, our way or the highway, use our stuff sort of proprietary mindset.

0:27:34But they are a very active participant in the standards that they really care about.

0:27:40They're super active with Bluetooth.

0:27:41They really did contribute tons to the design of USB-C and really drove the, hey, this is so stupid.

0:27:51Look at the fact that lightning came first, sort of lit a fire under everybody's ass in terms of how much nicer it is that you cannot plug it in upside down.

0:28:03And it's like at this point, and it's USB-C and lightning have been around so long that at this point there are like teenagers who don't remember that there used to be plugs that, like a piece of buttered toast, always falling buttered side down.

0:28:17Yep.

0:28:19Your first attempt to plug something in on the back of your computer where you can't see, always upside down, every time, guaranteed.

0:28:26Every time.

0:28:26I agree.

0:28:28Yep.

0:28:28And the Qi thing is a good example where making it proprietary really didn't give Apple any advantage, and it would make the life of iPhone users, including people who work at Apple who carry iPhones, better if, like, when you go to the airport,

0:28:44if you go to get a cup of coffee or a beer or something, and there's a charger right there that you could just put your iPhone on it, and it'll just start charging.

0:28:53Right.

0:28:54It'll just snap into place.

0:28:55And making it an open standard makes that possible in a way where if it were more like lightning itself and had to be licensed and, you know, you had to do this, they're not going to put them into airports.

0:29:06Right.

0:29:06And that other phones could use them, too, even if they didn't snap into place.

0:29:11You just have to hit the sweet spot and rest it there.

0:29:14So it's a total win, right?

0:29:16This is just – and it would never happen if it only came from standards bodies.

0:29:21There's no way that USB-C consortium or any other open consortium was going to come out with something as cool, simple, and elegant as MagSafe.

0:29:30Absolutely.

0:29:32I agree with that.

0:29:32I've been – I mean, Qi 2 has been a standard for at least a couple years now, and we've all been kind of confused.

0:29:37Like, why is no manufacturer on Android side putting this in their phone?

0:29:42Like, it's – we see a lot of MagSafe cases for Android devices so that you can snap things on the back of your Android devices.

0:29:49Google's really the first one to, like, embrace it wholeheartedly after a couple years, which is cool.

0:29:54But I wanted to ask you about this other thing that Google announced.

0:29:58I think the other main thing is the cameras.

0:30:01So the first thing is – this is just kind of a footnote.

0:30:06The main Pixel 10 now, the cheapest one, now gets the telephoto.

0:30:09So it's kind of been like the Apple iPhone where it had an ultrawide, it had a main, but no telephoto because that would be reserved for the pros.

0:30:16Google has now brought a telephoto down that goes up to 20x to the main Pixel, which when you look at it, it almost doesn't make sense for a lot of people to go to a pro now.

0:30:29When you look at everything that just the main Pixel can do.

0:30:33But that's not what I wanted to ask you about.

0:30:35What I wanted to ask you about was this.

0:30:36The Pro line goes up to 100x on their cameras, but when you shoot the photo at 100x, it takes a look at this mess of pixels and it uses AI to generate the actual photo that you end up with.

0:30:57So what Google said was anything in the photo, it's not looking at, like, what's in it.

0:31:03It's not like, oh, this is a tree and this is the tree trunk.

0:31:07It's just looking at the pixels to figure out how should these look from this far away.

0:31:12If it recognizes a person is in there, it will not enhance them because they don't want you to be able to, like, creep on someone from 100x and take stalker photos from people.

0:31:23Or to make somebody like a book.

0:31:27Or just remake them, yeah.

0:31:29Yeah, just remake them.

0:31:30And it's like, well, Christ, I know who that was.

0:31:32That was a picture of Andrew from 100x away.

0:31:36And now it doesn't look like Andrew at all.

0:31:38It doesn't look like him at all.

0:31:39Right.

0:31:39But a wildlife, it'll work on anything else but just not human beings.

0:31:43And I was just like, I don't know.

0:31:46I see the positive and I see the negative.

0:31:48Like, it goes back to the whole, what is even a photo anymore?

0:31:51Right.

0:31:52So what do you think about that?

0:31:53100x.

0:31:53Exactly.

0:31:55100x, it is allowing you to take something that looks good.

0:31:59Unlike the Samsung 100x, which really doesn't, it feels like a gimmick because it's not really usable.

0:32:04At least Google's giving you something.

0:32:05Unless you point it at the moon.

0:32:06Right.

0:32:07Exactly.

0:32:08Yeah, then we can superimpose something on there.

0:32:10When they cheat.

0:32:11Oh, that's the moon.

0:32:13Well, we know what the moon looks like.

0:32:15Right.

0:32:15We just stick it in there.

0:32:16So what do you think about that?

0:32:18I wish that there were more companies in this space, right?

0:32:24Like, I feel like we're lucky, and I was just thinking about this today on a different reason.

0:32:30Maybe we'll get to it to talk about on the show.

0:32:31But as frustrated as we can all get at the duopolies of mobile, of there's iPhones and iOS and Android, right?

0:32:43And at a fundamental level, that's really the only two options.

0:32:46And when you find other non-Google phones, guess what?

0:32:51They're all based on Android because Android is open source, so you can do that.

0:32:55You can make a totally un-Googled version of a phone, but it sucks.

0:33:00The best we've ever gotten is three with video game consoles, right, where there's Xbox, PlayStation, and Nintendo.

0:33:10And I always, my dream would have been, man, imagine if Palm could have made it and WebOS could sort of play the role that Nintendo did and make it a triumvirate.

0:33:23But there's reasons, you know, it's market forces of why it tends to get squeezed to fewer and fewer platforms.

0:33:32And I wish there were more so you could get more philosophical differences.

0:33:36And I don't think Google is doing this just to be different from Apple.

0:33:42I think it does.

0:33:43I think this feels Google-y.

0:33:45I think Google as a company is more, hey, let's do it with code.

0:33:51If we can do this, let's do it, right?

0:33:54I've seen the example pictures at 100x.

0:33:57They look pretty impressive.

0:33:58They don't look AIE.

0:34:00I mean, of course, these are example photos that are not going to pay.

0:34:03I don't know if the reviews are going to come out.

0:34:05And in real life, they're going to look more AI-generated.

0:34:07But I know Apple.

0:34:10Well, I don't know.

0:34:10I guess I don't know.

0:34:12But I strongly suspect Apple is not going to do that.

0:34:16Or even if they did, they would do it to a lesser degree, right?

0:34:20So, and it's a philosophical.

0:34:23It's not because they can't, right?

0:34:25Especially on photography.

0:34:26Apple has got the chops where they could definitely do it.

0:34:29You know, and they brought, what do they call it, magic eraser in photos where you can use Apple intelligence.

0:34:36If there's like a trash can in the picture behind your family, you can draw your finger around it.

0:34:41And then the trash can goes away.

0:34:43Even that's actually a philosophical difference, too.

0:34:46I know.

0:34:46It's the same thing, right?

0:34:47To see how on Samsung devices, you can circle and remove something from the foreground.

0:34:55Like, say, if I covered my face with my hand, I can remove my hand and it'll just draw in a great-looking face.

0:35:02Right.

0:35:02Whereas Apple will leave like a mangled mess of a face because Apple's not trying to remake the whole photo.

0:35:09They're really focusing on distractions in the background.

0:35:11Right.

0:35:12And so it's all levels of a gradient.

0:35:15It's not binary.

0:35:16Do you think that AI should be used to generate parts of photos or not at all?

0:35:21And if you say, yes, it should be allowed.

0:35:23It can do anything and everything.

0:35:26And if you say, no, it's not going to do anything at all.

0:35:29Everybody is doing it to some degree.

0:35:31And of course they are.

0:35:32But I think it's sort of like approaching the sweet spot from the, well, Google's going to approach it from the top side.

0:35:41And if they make an error, they're going to do a little too much.

0:35:44And Apple is going to approach it from the bottom side.

0:35:47And if they make them, if they air, they're not going to do enough.

0:35:51They're going to be a little too pure.

0:35:53You know, the photo is what photons hit the sensor.

0:35:56That's the photo.

0:35:58And so they're not going to fill in a face if you cover half your face, like you said.

0:36:03So I think it's interesting that they've taken a different approach.

0:36:07But I personally find myself more aligned with Apple's way of thinking that we should be cautious and that there's time.

0:36:17If the sweet spot is a little bit more manipulation through AI algorithms, there's time to do that in the years to come.

0:36:24And we can definitely go back, like you can do it, like look at all the things you can do with your old photos and Apple photos and Google photos, everybody's photos now, right?

0:36:33You've got all these photos that had no AI at all from 20 years ago.

0:36:38They're in your photo library and now you can turn them into little 3D things in Vision Pro or on iOS 26.

0:36:45So there's time to do that later anyway when AI gets better.

0:36:48So I kind of appreciate Apple's approach of being a little bit more true to let's mostly stick to the photons that hit the sensor, go through the lens, are focused on the sensor, and what hits the sensor is what we're going to show you, right?

0:37:05Okay.

0:37:06But, you know, I don't think Google's gone.

0:37:07I don't think they've gone too far.

0:37:09But it all boils down to Neela's repeated question.

0:37:12What is a photo?

0:37:13Right, right.

0:37:14So what was your take on Magic Take?

0:37:18Which one's that?

0:37:20That's where you have like you, your wife, and your two kids, and this kid looking at it.

0:37:24So it's taking things that have hit the sensor, but it's combining them so you get the good face on each person.

0:37:32Right.

0:37:32In other words, I can take a picture of my wife and son, and then my son can take the camera, and he can take a picture of me with my wife, and then we'll get a picture of the three of us together.

0:37:44Yeah, that's another one.

0:37:45Yeah, that's another one, yes.

0:37:46Right?

0:37:47I kind of, and again, this sounds arbitrary, and again, maybe the way this will become table stakes and five years from now, everybody, it'll seem silly that I'm arguing this in 2025.

0:38:01That I don't think it should be part of the built-in camera slash photos app.

0:38:07Because obviously, you could have done that 20 years ago in Photoshop, right?

0:38:12Right, right.

0:38:13You could have done this, you know, you couldn't do it with a click.

0:38:17You'd have to do the work of highlighting somebody, you know.

0:38:21Right, right.

0:38:21I was far from a Photoshop master, but I was pretty good at, I remember I was pretty good at knocking somebody out.

0:38:32In other words, when you take a picture of a person and there's a background, but what you want is just them on a white background, and you'd have to like cut around the person.

0:38:41And hair, of course, was always the hardest part.

0:38:44I got pretty good at that.

0:38:45But you, like, knocking out one person in one photo would be, like, something you would spend, like, an hour on.

0:38:51And now it's just a right click and it's a left.

0:38:53Yeah, yeah.

0:38:54It's like a totally useless skill, because it's not just that you don't need to do it anymore, but that the automated one-click ones are better than any human has ever been at it anyway.

0:39:07Correct, right.

0:39:09So I just sort of feel like it shouldn't be built in.

0:39:11I don't know why, because it's sort of pretending.

0:39:16It's more like an art project and less of a photograph.

0:39:17Right.

0:39:18It's less, and it's conveying to the user that it's fine to just pretend that this was a photo in the first place, as opposed to making a deliberate choice to create an event that never existed, right?

0:39:35That makes sense.

0:39:36It's a fine line, though, right?

0:39:38I mean, and everybody has to find their comfort level in it.

0:39:41I think, obviously, the comfort level of this will change over time and will expand in the direction of more and more.

0:39:49And it sounds old.

0:39:53I guess maybe it's because I am old relative to most of the population today.

0:39:58But I just sort of feel like it's okay to apply the brakes a little bit as we hurtle forward in the generative AI era, right?

0:40:07It's like it's all happening already.

0:40:09There are deep fakes of stills.

0:40:10There's tremendous deep fakes of videos, right?

0:40:13Absolutely.

0:40:14And even putting aside using them for malicious or deceptive purposes, which is a hell of a thing to put aside, it just raises questions of, hey, we all have to get more comfortable with accepting that just because you see a video of a thing doesn't mean that it happened.

0:40:34Yeah, you have to question or see a photo, right?

0:40:37And I feel like making it a built-in feature of the camera that you can shoot these photos that never existed is doing a disservice to the caution that we should all be developing around this.

0:40:51How's that for you?

0:40:53I see that.

0:40:53No, I see that.

0:40:54I see that argument very much so.

0:40:56All right.

0:40:57Let's take a break.

0:40:58I'm going to thank our next sponsor.

0:41:00It is our good friend at Notion.

0:41:02Notion AI is the all-in-one AI powered by your work, and it puts everything all in one place.

0:41:10It automatically captures meeting notes, instantly finds the exact content you need, drafts detailed docs for you, and lets you chat with the best AI models.

0:41:21Notion AI just became twice as powerful for teams, making it the best AI tool for work.

0:41:27One of the reasons I think Notion is in such a strong position as an AI tool is that if you take the AI out of it, Notion is a tremendous notes slash sort of everything you want to store in a thing app.

0:41:43And then with AI integrated into the system, the bones are already there that when you have the AI and Notion AI do things for you, it's already in a great app that is meant for things like notes.

0:42:13And so, for example, the meeting notes is a big thing.

0:42:16Imagine having perfect meeting memory every time.

0:42:19Every idea, every decision, every next step that was mentioned in the meeting, when you use Notion to capture the meeting, it all gets captured there.

0:42:27And it can be put together with suggested action items immediately after the meeting, but also those meeting notes that Notion AI will capture for you are in a great notes app that people have already been using for things like meeting notes before the AI.

0:42:45It's a great place to capture meeting notes.

0:42:47And with AI, you can do it automatically without work.

0:42:50You capture anything, turn it around into organized, shareable with your whole team, searchable notes, including meetings, one-to-one conversations, lectures, even podcast episodes.

0:43:02So you can throw a podcast episode into Notion and get it summarized into a note.

0:43:07And if you want, it can be just for you, or you can share it with your whole team if there's like a podcast episode that you think everybody should know about.

0:43:14Throw it into Notion, have Notion summarize it, and boom, there you have a structured note that everybody can share, read the summary, or go back to the original and listen to the actual podcast, which I recommend people do.

0:43:27Transcription and summaries are automatically saved in Notion.

0:43:30It's a really great feature, and it's so easy to get started.

0:43:33To use the meeting feature, you just type slash meet, M-E-E-T, not M-E-A-T, just slash meet on any Notion page on desktop or in the mobile app where you can just type those slash commands.

0:43:46On any page, you can just type slash meet, and it'll go into meeting capture mode right there.

0:43:51That's how easy it is.

0:43:53Some of the fastest-growing companies like OpenAI, Ramp, and Vercel are using Notion AI to make their processes faster.

0:44:00They have all the top AI models built in.

0:44:03They integrate with the best models from OpenAI.

0:44:06They've got Claude.

0:44:08You name it, if it's a good model, Notion has it integrated.

0:44:11Whichever one or one you're most comfortable with, you can use.

0:44:15They're used by over half of Fortune 500 companies.

0:44:17So go check out Notion, the best AI tool for work, right now at Notion.com slash talk show.

0:44:24That's all lowercase letters.

0:44:26They want me to emphasize this.

0:44:27Notion.com slash talk show.

0:44:31Lowercase letters to try the powerful all-in-one Notion AI today.

0:44:34And when you use that link, you're supporting the talk show.

0:44:37Notion.com slash talk show.

0:44:41Anything else about the Google?

0:44:43Do you have a review unit of the Pixel?

0:44:46I have them.

0:44:47I have them all right here.

0:44:48You have them all?

0:44:48I have them all.

0:44:49Except for the Pro Fold.

0:44:51The Fold comes a month later.

0:44:52Comes out in October.

0:44:53So that review unit hasn't hit yet.

0:44:55I think the only other thing that I think is very interesting and different and sets it apart

0:44:59is when you're taking a photo of someone, they're sitting in a chair or whatever.

0:45:05It'll quickly AI generate that person in different poses in that environment and guide you through

0:45:13different poses you may not have thought of.

0:45:15So, and it'll even like different angles too.

0:45:19So like, hey, if you went off to the side and had that plant by their shoulder, it might

0:45:24look like this.

0:45:24So it's like a camera coach in a way to help you just think of different ways to take a

0:45:29photo of someone while they're trying to pose.

0:45:31Just another cool and smart way of using AI that it's not making these photos after you

0:45:37take them.

0:45:38It's just guiding you towards, instead of just taking the standard person standing in the

0:45:42center of the frame, right?

0:45:44Try these other angles based on what's around them to make an interesting photo.

0:45:47I thought that was cool too.

0:45:48It makes me wonder though, because I haven't written about it yet because it's, I haven't

0:45:55used it a lot yet, even though I'm super fascinated by it, is Mark Lavoie used to be in charge

0:46:01of the cameras in the Pixel team.

0:46:03And now, a couple of years ago, he left Google for Adobe and Adobe came out with, remember,

0:46:11what's the name of their new camera app?

0:46:12Oh, Project Indigo.

0:46:14That's it.

0:46:15It's only on iOS.

0:46:17I will put the link in the show notes, I promise.

0:46:20But it's a new free camera app from Adobe and Mark Lavoie is one of the leads on it.

0:46:26And it really suits the Mark Lavoie approach to computational photography, which is a little

0:46:37more, or a lot less generative and a lot more using computation to do things that you just

0:46:43can't do without computation involved in the photo chain.

0:46:48But it's more, with Project Indigo, is more like capturing film-like images in terms of

0:46:58them looking natural.

0:47:01And the direction, and the Pixel phones used to go in this direction.

0:47:06It's just interesting when there are multiple companies with different philosophies.

0:47:10But the Pixel phones in the earlier eras, like five or plus years ago, would have features built

0:47:17in that you wouldn't see the effect in the viewfinder as you shot the photo.

0:47:24Or you'd hit the shutter button and it would capture, but you wouldn't see it right away.

0:47:30It would require even just a couple seconds of post-processing on device.

0:47:35You know, like let's say low-light photography, night mode, whatever you want to call it.

0:47:39But something where you don't want to turn the flash on and you want to capture an image where

0:47:45it's not enough light and it's going to take multiple images and sort of stitch them together

0:47:50and do whatever, just computation to get rid of the noise and magically capture a brighter,

0:47:56sharper image than would be possible without computation involved.

0:48:02But even if it takes more seconds, Apple's philosophy has been all along, it has to happen right away

0:48:10or they won't do it.

0:48:11And even with portrait mode, you see it live in the viewfinder.

0:48:16And if they can't do it live and maybe with a little bit of post-processing, but that you

0:48:22wouldn't perceive as a user.

0:48:23You hit the shutter button, it captures the image.

0:48:25And if you tap the little thumbnail of the image you just captured, you see it right there.

0:48:30That's an interesting philosophy too.

0:48:33It's, you know, that we're going to give you an instant photo and that's it.

0:48:37Not that it's cheating to take more time, but it's just a philosophical difference that

0:48:42we don't want to make you wait for it.

0:48:44And if you have to wait, we're not going to show it to you yet.

0:48:46And the Mark Lavoie perspective is, what if we do, why not take a couple seconds to actually

0:48:52do something if you can get an amazing result?

0:48:54And that's basically what Project Indigo brings to the iPhone is, what if it took three or four

0:49:01seconds to produce an image on your phone?

0:49:04And your phone gets warm, you can feel it getting warm, not shooting video, but just

0:49:08shooting stills with Project Indigo.

0:49:10Just getting to work.

0:49:10But you get these amazing images.

0:49:14I've only played with it a little, but you get these images that don't have that sort of

0:49:20over sharpened fake.

0:49:22You know, everybody's sort of tired of it.

0:49:24It's hard to put your finger on.

0:49:26The smartphone look.

0:49:27Yeah, exactly.

0:49:28That smartphone look, that's sort of hard to describe.

0:49:31It's often most easily visible on people's faces because so much of, you know, it's what

0:49:38we care about.

0:49:39It's, you know, of course, it's where the focus is, because what do people care about?

0:49:43Most people only care about the people who are in their photos, right?

0:49:46Right.

0:49:47It's the thing most people care about by far the most.

0:49:50And for some people, it's all they care about.

0:49:52And so it does things that aren't natural.

0:49:55It smooths wrinkles and smooth skin tones and over sharpens to some people's eyes.

0:50:02And you get a certain look right off the camera.

0:50:05Not just iPhone, not just Pixel, but all the major phones.

0:50:10And there's differences between them, right?

0:50:12Samsung loves its vibrant colors, and Apple loves its more natural palette of colors.

0:50:19But overall, you take all these photos right out of the factory camera app, and there's

0:50:25a certain shared aesthetic.

0:50:26And the Project Indigo, and where Pixel used to be more different, even though it involves

0:50:33way more computation because it takes time, it results in a more natural look.

0:50:38Can't help but feel if that's why Mark Lavoie is now at Adobe.

0:50:42This is all my way of saying, without knowing him or ever having met him in person, I kind

0:50:47of feel like that's why he left Google and went to Adobe, because Google wanted to go in

0:50:52this direction, and Lavoie is still peddled to the metal pursuing this other direction.

0:51:00Yeah, that's interesting, because I think Google had to achieve the results they wanted at the

0:51:07time, they had to rely on that because Silicon wasn't good enough to do what it can do today

0:51:13without requiring that wait, right?

0:51:16You can take a great portrait mode photo on a Pixel today without needing to wait two or three

0:51:20seconds for it to process.

0:51:21It'll just shoot it.

0:51:22So I can see them kind of deciding, like, this is what's necessary now, but it's not necessary

0:51:27anymore.

0:51:28It used to be, but not anymore.

0:51:30And Mark's saying, well, we can still wait and just have even better results.

0:51:34And Google's saying, well, that's not what we're going for.

0:51:37Right.

0:51:38And you know this, I know, Andrew, but I think most people listening know that if you use a

0:51:44lot of third-party apps, I don't know, Halide is one of my favorites, but you can take a raw

0:51:49image on the iPhone and really just look at what the sensor shows without any processing at all.

0:51:56And the raw files are huge, put that aside, and you're like, holy shit, this looks terrible.

0:52:00Vastly different.

0:52:01Yeah.

0:52:02It's crazy.

0:52:02Like, the no processing what is right off the sensor look, often it incredibly shows noise

0:52:12even in daylight, right?

0:52:14Yeah.

0:52:14It's like, well, how is that even possible, right?

0:52:16Right, right.

0:52:17Why is it noisy even in daylight?

0:52:20And it's like, yeah, man, I'm telling you, there's a lot of computation that goes into using

0:52:25these tiny little sensors.

0:52:26And the biggest of these sensors in our smartphones are so small compared to a frame of 35 millimeter

0:52:34film, which is this quote unquote full frame sensor in like a DSLR.

0:52:38They're so tiny.

0:52:39Even the biggest ones are so small.

0:52:43That's why everything is noisy.

0:52:45And it's funny because the arguments people have about smartphone cameras, it's almost

0:52:49as if they think it's the physical hardware that makes a good camera as opposed to Google's

0:52:57processing versus Apple's post processing versus Samsung.

0:53:00It's about who processes that image best because if you're just comparing the sensors from the,

0:53:07like, no one's going to have a good camera if that's what you mind off of.

0:53:10Well, or nobody could compete with a big dedicated camera.

0:53:13Exactly.

0:53:14That's right.

0:53:15They could compete with each other, but we wouldn't be having these arguments like, hey, do you

0:53:20even need a point and shoot camera anymore?

0:53:22And the truth is for 98, 99% of people in the world who, even if you take people who previously

0:53:31owned a dedicated point and shoot camera or bigger of some sort, I would say at least 95,

0:53:3796% of them don't own a camera anymore, right?

0:53:40There still is a camera industry and the people who really want a camera camera definitely still

0:53:45want one.

0:53:45But the consumer end of that is just gone because of cell phones and with good reason, right?

0:53:51Most people take better pictures with their tiny little sensor iPhones and Android phones than

0:53:58they ever took with a dedicated camera or Canon or Nikon point and shoot camera.

0:54:02You get better low light performance.

0:54:04You get better autofocus.

0:54:06I have, you know, I really love it and I don't use it all the time, but when I do, I get better

0:54:12images.

0:54:12I really love my, I have the Ricoh GR 3X, which is the, it like the, exactly like the Ricoh

0:54:19GR 3X, except the X has a 40 millimeter equivalent lens instead of 28.

0:54:24So it's a little more in iPhone terms, closer to the 2X.

0:54:29It's a great camera.

0:54:32I love the way the images look.

0:54:34It has very good autofocus for a little point and shoot camera, but the autofocus is so much

0:54:41worse than my phone.

0:54:42It is so much, at least in terms of just making sure somebody's face is in focus, right?

0:54:49Because an iPhone, if, as soon as you hold it up and there's any human being anywhere in

0:54:54the frame, it'll immediately focus on a face, no matter what else, like a tree or if there's

0:55:00any kind of foreground background confusion, like trying to capture somebody at a party where

0:55:05there's a crowd of people and shoulders of, of other people in front of you, it's going

0:55:11to latch onto a face in a way that dedicated cameras can't, because there's so much, the

0:55:15computation is so much better, right?

0:55:17The lens is tiny and inferior.

0:55:20The sensor is tiny and inferior to what's in the dedicated camera, but the computer is way

0:55:27better and way more powerful and the computer programmers at Apple are just way better than

0:55:33the ones at Canon or Nikon or Sony are ever going to be.

0:55:36Absolutely.

0:55:36So it's, it's a weird trade-off and it's interesting that Lavoie landed at Adobe of all places, which

0:55:43doesn't really have skin in the game, right?

0:55:45In terms of making phones or making dedicated cameras, right?

0:55:50They're just, they truly are a pure software company.

0:55:53It's an interesting third approach, but I kind of wish he's working on software.

0:55:58He's working on software to create pictures from your sensor as opposed to, but I kind

0:56:03of feel like the reason he'd, I think thrived for a few years at Google was that in the early

0:56:08years of the pixel program, I think Google's hardware was behind where if you looked at this

0:56:13is why I was talking about raw photos.

0:56:14If you just looked at a raw image off like a pixel two versus the probably like an iPhone

0:56:2110 or something at the time.

0:56:24I don't know what the, the, you know, exactly here years ago, but the Apple hardware was better.

0:56:29Take all the computation out of it.

0:56:31And Google needed more computational photography to sort of get even a word as so many people

0:56:39argued for so many years and still do to this day.

0:56:42A lot of people just like the aesthetic of the right off the camera pixel look, but they

0:56:47were doing it with, I think almost inarguably inferior camera hardware.

0:56:52Oh yeah, for sure.

0:56:54But it didn't matter.

0:56:54And I think that was the big thing is like the hardware matters so much less than what the

0:57:00software can do.

0:57:01Right.

0:57:01That if you have better software, you can actually get better photography with inferior

0:57:07hardware, which never used to be true in the old days, certainly in the film era where you

0:57:13really kind of, I mean, you, obviously if you don't know how to use the camera and don't

0:57:17know how to set manual exposure or focus, your photos are going to be poorly exposed and out

0:57:24of focus.

0:57:24But fundamentally better glass on a better camera was going to result in a better image.

0:57:31And there was nothing that you could do about it with an inferior lens shooting on an inferior

0:57:36camera.

0:57:37There's just nothing you could do.

0:57:39Right.

0:57:39What else?

0:57:41So what'd you think of the fold?

0:57:43What's it called?

0:57:44The pixel?

0:57:45The pixel 10 pro fold.

0:57:47It is a mouthful, but it's basically like, okay, you have the pixel 10 pro and now we have

0:57:52the folding version of the pixel 10 pro pixel 10 pro fold.

0:57:54I thought it was good.

0:57:55I mean, there's not much different other than the things we've already talked about that the

0:58:00pixel 10 pro does that the fold is basically the folding version of the 10 pro, but it's

0:58:05the first foldable that has the dust rating.

0:58:11Right.

0:58:12So it's like this hinge is new and this phone is more protected because that's really been

0:58:20the thing with foldables is you don't want to take your galaxy folds to the beach, for

0:58:24example.

0:58:24Right.

0:58:25You don't want sand getting behind that display and just destroying it.

0:58:28So you've kind of still had to be careful with, with folds in a way that you really, I mean,

0:58:33geez, the candy bar phones these days, they can go through so much.

0:58:37You can, you can put them in the washing machine by accident and it'll come out working fine.

0:58:41Right.

0:58:41So that was really the problem with the folds.

0:58:43I like, I like, I am a primarily iOS user.

0:58:47So having something, even the fold seven that from Samsung that came out last month, these

0:58:55things are really incredible these days.

0:58:57Like what they started as versus what they are today is really interesting.

0:59:02My only wish with these things is that they ran iOS, like going back to hardware versus

0:59:07software, beautiful hardware, great hardware.

0:59:09And then when I start using, it's like, and I, and I don't hate Android by any stretch

0:59:14of the imagination, but it's just not, it doesn't feel like home, I guess, to me when

0:59:17I'm using things.

0:59:18And when I want to get work done, I don't want to be trying to figure out how I, iOS just

0:59:22second nature to me for whatever I want to do.

0:59:24So not to jump ahead to topics, but if Apple does this, then I'll be like all in on just

0:59:31carrying a foldable with me.

0:59:32But I like that Google's still doing this.

0:59:35I like, because since they make Android, it means that other companies that use Android

0:59:41for their foldables don't have to kludge together their foldable experience on the phone.

0:59:47Instead, Google builds in, here's features for foldables too that anyone can use.

0:59:54Right.

0:59:54People don't talk about it and users don't think about it, but there is this truly essential

1:00:01role of the platform maker to sort of define, not just define the experience, but then provide

1:00:10the APIs to the apps to use them to define things like, well, what do you do?

1:00:15How, how, what do you expect to happen when you're using it on the front?

1:00:20You know, it's closed.

1:00:21The book is closed on the phone and you're using the front phone.

1:00:25So it looks like a regular candy bar, regular smartphone.

1:00:28And while you're using it, you just open it up.

1:00:31What happens?

1:00:32The, obviously you should still be using the app you were using on the front, but does it

1:00:37expand to the whole square or does it only take half and leave the other half for you?

1:00:42And what can you do with two phones?

1:00:44What happens if you snap a window to the slide it to the side?

1:00:48Does it go defining those gestures and actions and capabilities for like, oh, here's how you

1:00:55can take two thirds of it for one app and put a skinny little one third thing on the side.

1:01:01It really matters.

1:01:02And if anything, the iPad OS 26 that that's coming out in the fall and it has been available

1:01:09in beta really shows how important it is for the platform to define things like that, right?

1:01:16Where we've been in iPad users have been suffering for seven, eight, nine years of quote unquote

1:01:23multitasking.

1:01:24That's just frustrated everyone from power users to typical non the least powerful users alike

1:01:33where the typical users are like, how did I get into this mode?

1:01:37Why is there this weird window on the side of the screen?

1:01:39I can't get rid of.

1:01:40And the power users are like, why can't I just make windows that I can drag to any size that

1:01:45I want?

1:01:46And, you know, I think that's the sort of definition of a failed paradigm for a bigger screen is when

1:01:54you ideally you want to make a system that makes everybody happy from the least advanced technical

1:02:01user to the most advanced, but you should at least make one of them really happy.

1:02:06And so having it having Google sort of take the reins on how Android is going to handle

1:02:16at a system level by default and like everything in Android, the third party phone manufacturers

1:02:21can override it for sure.

1:02:22Yes.

1:02:23But say, here's the table stakes of the default Android way of handling this sort of phone,

1:02:28which it still is a niche.

1:02:31Somebody on threads and I had to, I don't know, I try to, I read threads and try to never respond

1:02:37because I feel.

1:02:38Why is that?

1:02:40Why is that?

1:02:41I can perceive I do get good links, right?

1:02:45And I find interesting stories like, oh, I hadn't heard about this.

1:02:48This is very interesting.

1:02:49I saw the most interesting stuff about the Cracker Barrel logo controversy.

1:02:54Oh, God.

1:02:55Yeah.

1:02:55I found on threads.

1:02:57I, in the, everything else I had read about it, hadn't mentioned this, that there's this

1:03:03guy, I forget his name.

1:03:04I blogged about it the other day, but he owns, he owns this holding company and they own the

1:03:08steak and shake.

1:03:09Oh, yes.

1:03:11And he's been trying, he, he owns steak and Cracker Barrel and he's been trying to get

1:03:16on the board for over 10 years.

1:03:18And obviously he wants to be the CEO of Cracker Barrel.

1:03:21And he's the one who got the steak and shake Twitter account to start saying fire this track

1:03:28Cracker Barrel CEO.

1:03:29It's just really weird.

1:03:30It's like, we live in this weird comic book universe where the steak and shake Twitter

1:03:35account is shitting, shitting on another chain restaurant brand's logo redesign.

1:03:41Like, that just doesn't happen.

1:03:43It wasn't supposed to happen.

1:03:44Like, that's not how brands interact.

1:03:46Why is this happening?

1:03:48And it's like, when you find out that it's this guy who's been an activist investor in Cracker

1:03:52Barrel who owns the other chain.

1:03:54Oh, that makes sense.

1:03:55And you find out that he's very pro-Trump and pro-MAGA.

1:04:00And that's why Fox News and the other Republican friendly US media jumped on this Cracker Barrel

1:04:09story, right?

1:04:10And it's like, oh, all of a sudden this thing that didn't make any sense to me.

1:04:14Like, anytime an app changes its icon or anytime a company changes their logo, everybody's going

1:04:21to chime in because logos and icons are the sort of thing that even non-designers can say, I like it

1:04:27or I don't like it.

1:04:28I don't like change or whatever.

1:04:30It's an easy thing for everybody to have an opinion on.

1:04:33But it usually doesn't lead to a company losing 20% of their stock in a day.

1:04:38Correct.

1:04:38Like what happened to Cracker Barrel, right?

1:04:39And in particular, the Cracker Barrel logo change, it wasn't that big a change, right?

1:04:46It wasn't like they changed the colors.

1:04:48It's like they took the old guy in the barrel off the logo.

1:04:52Right.

1:04:52They just modernized it with a modern, yeah.

1:04:53Yeah.

1:04:54And it clearly looks more modern, right?

1:04:56And you find out things like that the average age of a customer eating in a Cracker Barrel is

1:05:0265 years old, which I read in multiple stories this week.

1:05:05That's not good, right?

1:05:07If, Andrew, you and I buy a restaurant together and we own a restaurant, we're doing good,

1:05:14and then we're like, you know, let's have a state of the company meeting, somebody comes

1:05:17in and says, well, here's some bad news.

1:05:20We did a survey and the average age of our customer is 65.

1:05:22You start thinking, well, we're in trouble because the average age of our customer in 15

1:05:30years is dead, right?

1:05:31Exactly.

1:05:32Exactly.

1:05:34And it's always funny to me when people have, not to go on a tangent on this, but when

1:05:41a brand has seen multiple years of falling sales, which means people aren't going as much every

1:05:51single year, for people to then be upset that they're trying to do something to bring some

1:05:56life back.

1:05:56It's like, well, now I'm not going to go to Cracker Barrel anymore.

1:05:59You weren't going, though.

1:06:00That's the whole reason this problem's been happening.

1:06:02You were not going.

1:06:03So what's the difference if you're not going now because you weren't going then?

1:06:07Right.

1:06:08You know what I mean?

1:06:09It's not like Apple changed their logo and got rid of the apple with a bite out of it.

1:06:14It's like, well, why would you screw with that?

1:06:15You're on fire.

1:06:16You're more popular than you've ever been.

1:06:18Cracker Barrel is a chain that's in trouble, and the trouble is their clientele is old.

1:06:24And I think even if you say, I don't like the new logo, I think it's too simple, it's

1:06:29too minimal, whatever, you have to admit it is clearly younger looking.

1:06:34It is.

1:06:35Yes.

1:06:35It just looks modern.

1:06:36Exactly.

1:06:37Right.

1:06:37Exactly.

1:06:37So wild.

1:06:39I did see someone on thread say he's glad we weren't around to show Apple change from

1:06:44the Isaac Newton version of the logo to just the simple Apple with a bite out of it.

1:06:48What would have happened then?

1:06:49Yeah.

1:06:50Look at this new Apple logo.

1:06:51But on the other hand, the Apple logo, the old woodcut one with Isaac Newton under a tree,

1:06:57that was in use for like one year before the Apple II came out.

1:07:01So it's like there aren't many people who remember Apple before the Apple II, but point taken.

1:07:08But anyway, I try not to respond to people on threads because I can just see how good,

1:07:16say what you want about meta overall, and I've said a lot, but they are very, very good at

1:07:22their core business of keeping people using their platforms.

1:07:26Yep.

1:07:27And no other platform I've ever used before, I see it in my feed.

1:07:34It's like, oh, I need to respond to this asshole.

1:07:37And it's like, oh, no, they got me.

1:07:39Right?

1:07:41I can just see it.

1:07:42But I don't think it's because I've got a defense mechanism where I'm trying to avoid being

1:07:48manipulated.

1:07:49Yep.

1:07:50And I don't want to waste my time tweeting on the threads, but I can see it.

1:07:55It's like, oh, they've got me pegged.

1:07:57They know I'm upset about this.

1:07:59So it's more of trying not to reply to those kinds of things.

1:08:03But I assume you'll do like friendly replies.

1:08:06Yeah.

1:08:07Yeah.

1:08:07And sometimes, and what was I talking about?

1:08:09I chimed in on somebody.

1:08:10I forget where I went before the Cracker Barrel thing, but I chimed in on something.

1:08:15Oh, I know.

1:08:16It was about the, thank God.

1:08:18I'm going to bring this full circle.

1:08:20It's about foldable phones.

1:08:22Okay.

1:08:22And somebody who's, it was arguing, I think, I didn't think they called for Tim Cook to

1:08:28be fired, but sort of, if all the proof you need.

1:08:31It was about the very positive reaction that the Galaxy Fold 7 has gotten.

1:08:35Right?

1:08:36And it is clearly in today's state of the art for foldable phones, probably the most

1:08:41impressive overall.

1:08:42And I've seen a lot of, the reviews are very good and seemingly deservedly so.

1:08:47But the perspective was, this is the proof that Apple's lost the ball and they're out

1:08:51of touch and whatever.

1:08:52And so I did the research, you know, again, wasted time.

1:08:56Well, this is why I did it.

1:08:58I was like, ah, they got me.

1:08:59But I was like, ah, I actually do want to know.

1:09:02And I feel like it's useful for my work to know the market share of foldable phones right

1:09:06now.

1:09:07Right?

1:09:07I don't, because I don't want to be in the Apple, well, Apple doesn't make one so they

1:09:11don't matter.

1:09:12What if it is 5% of the market right now?

1:09:15It's like, hey, that's actually a pretty big deal.

1:09:17I looked it up.

1:09:17It's like 1.2% of the U.S. market is foldable phones.

1:09:21And I suspect that's high, to be honest.

1:09:24I think if you go to an airport or Disney World, I mean, I don't know.

1:09:32What's the best place to get like a cross-section of 100 random or 1,000 to avoid sampling?

1:09:38Subway.

1:09:39Subway in New York City.

1:09:40Yeah, it's Subway in New York City.

1:09:41If you take 1,000 people going through the Subway in New York City, are you going to get

1:09:461% of them using a foldable phone?

1:09:49Maybe.

1:09:49I don't know.

1:09:50I guess I do see them in New York.

1:09:51I've seen the last couple I've seen have been on Amtrak or like at the train station in New

1:09:56York.

1:09:56So I might be right.

1:09:58But I don't think it's far off.

1:09:59Right?

1:10:00It's either a little under 1% or a little over 1%.

1:10:03It's not that big a deal, right?

1:10:05It's something, right?

1:10:06These phones are something.

1:10:08And I know that there are people who already have them and have been using them for a few

1:10:12years who really swear by them in the same way that there were people using pre-iPhone

1:10:17smartphones who really swore by them.

1:10:19And they're like, this is really something.

1:10:21I'm telling you, you know, I'm doing my email just out of a thing in my pocket.

1:10:24They were right about that, but wrong about the nature of the form and the software that

1:10:31it's running.

1:10:31And I just had to respond to the guy and just say, this is 1.2% of the market or whatever.

1:10:37I think I saw that reply.

1:10:38And then I replied because one thing Samsung told us last year with the 6, the launch of

1:10:43the Fold 6, was that, now remember, there was a Fold 1 through 6.

1:10:47So the 6 is, you're half a decade in.

1:10:50And they said about 3% of the market had even touched a foldable before.

1:10:56So like your friend has one and you just, let me check that out.

1:10:59So 3% of the market after half a decade, and not a Samsung foldable, just any foldable.

1:11:05Right.

1:11:05Yeah, I believe that.

1:11:06Yeah, and I think it's, I don't think it's wrong to say that if and when Apple does a

1:11:12foldable, it's going to legitimize the market.

1:11:15Yeah.

1:11:15You're going to see a jump in percentage.

1:11:17And the fact that it legitimizes the market means not only is Apple going to sell foldables,

1:11:23but Apple is going to help Samsung and Google and others sell foldables too by way of legitimizing

1:11:29it.

1:11:29And that's just kind of the power that Apple holds.

1:11:31Right.

1:11:32No, nobody did more to help Android than the iPhone.

1:11:36Right.

1:11:37Exactly.

1:11:37Because the Android and in terms of, oh, who copied whom?

1:11:41And it's like, oh, you know, like slide down notifications.

1:11:44So yeah, Apple stole that from Google.

1:11:46It's like Google was first and it's a good idea.

1:11:47But B, web OS to go back to my, I wish Palm had somehow figured out a way to gain a Nintendo

1:11:55like foothold.

1:11:56Like foothold for people, you know, Palm had that first, but anyway, it, that, that's

1:12:03a detail.

1:12:03Like you look at the original Android phones from when they first Google bought, what was

1:12:09his name?

1:12:10Rubin, Andy Rubin, right?

1:12:11Yeah.

1:12:12Andy Rubin's company.

1:12:13They looked like BlackBerrys, right?

1:12:16They were little square screens with a hardware keyboard underneath and the green and yellow

1:12:21call buttons and the back and forward buttons.

1:12:23And they looked like, they looked like open source BlackBerrys.

1:12:28And if Apple had never made the iPhone, if they were just like, ah, we just, what if,

1:12:33what if AT&T had said they could never find a cellular partner for it?

1:12:37I don't know.

1:12:38There's some hypothetical world where Apple never built the iPhone and Android probably

1:12:44would have done.

1:12:44Okay.

1:12:45It looks like they were on their way to building something that was probably better than a BlackBerry

1:12:50or that I would have liked better.

1:12:51Cause I like it.

1:12:53They probably would have had a better web browser than BlackBerry ever would have had.

1:12:56But I think by giving Android a much better concept to copy, it let Android differentiate

1:13:04itself from everything else quicker than they would have.

1:13:07Right.

1:13:08Cause otherwise it would have been, well, now Google has a phone that looks like a BlackBerry,

1:13:12which also looks like the Samsung Blackjack, which I always laugh.

1:13:17That's actually the name that Samsung gave to their BlackBerry ripoff, the Blackjack.

1:13:23Motorola had one, right?

1:13:28It was like the Motorola Q, I think it was all those phones that it was all those phones that

1:13:33Jobs had on that slide, right?

1:13:34Yeah, exactly.

1:13:35To their embarrassment, Palm, it started making BlackBerry look alike phones rather than sticking

1:13:42to, you know, they had the concept with the Palm Pilot.

1:13:45The whole thing is a screen.

1:13:46They had it.

1:13:47Then they were like, well, I guess we'll build a keyboard.

1:13:50But they had the stylus though.

1:13:51They had the stylus.

1:13:52Yeah.

1:13:52They had the stylus.

1:13:53It was, and I agree.

1:13:56But imagine this.

1:13:57Imagine if there were no foldables yet.

1:14:02Yep.

1:14:02Right?

1:14:04At least not mass market.

1:14:05Not like Samsung with the fold or Google with this.

1:14:10And next year, if the rumors are true and Apple debuts its first foldable iPhone.

1:14:16And imagine if the price is comparable to these other ones, which is around $2,000.

1:14:21Yeah.

1:14:22I still think even in today's world, where all these other companies have been making $2,000

1:14:29foldables for five or six years now, that people, the press is still going to lose their shit

1:14:34if the Apple foldable phone is $2,000.

1:14:38Sure.

1:14:38As though those other ones.

1:14:40But imagine they didn't exist and Apple unveiled it at $2,000.

1:14:43Oh.

1:14:44Absurd.

1:14:45Right.

1:14:46Right.

1:14:46Here's the Apple.

1:14:47It's funny because Apple doesn't sell the most expensive phones anymore.

1:14:51If you compare it to Samsung, they're almost very comparable in price.

1:14:55You want a Galaxy Fold.

1:14:57Not the Fold.

1:14:59You want the Galaxy S25 Ultra.

1:15:02Right.

1:15:03It's going to be very comparable to an iPhone Pro Max.

1:15:05Like, there's really no price difference at all with these things.

1:15:08And still, the argument is that Apple products are so much more expensive.

1:15:14It's like, and it doesn't mean that was never the case.

1:15:17Like, Apple does charge a premium for a lot of things.

1:15:19But at least in the smartphone world and in the tablet world, like, it's very comparable.

1:15:24I do wonder, though.

1:15:26I mean, and I do think that is, it's just such an obvious price and demand are fixed economic factors that play into consumer demand, right?

1:15:36So, like, when they start around $2,000, demand is going to be lower than if they were $1,000, right?

1:15:44And most people, vast majority of people, think $1,000 is a lot of money to spend on a phone.

1:15:51They might do it, but they still think, oh, Christ, that's a lot of money.

1:15:55And they think this is how they get you, you know?

1:15:57And they've got, like, a five-year-old phone, whatever brand, and it's time for a new phone.

1:16:02And they're in the store, and it's like, they kind of can see, oh, look at, I kind of do want this one.

1:16:07And it's, oh, jeez, $900.

1:16:09Oh, man.

1:16:10And they think, man, this sucks.

1:16:12Because they don't want to spend $900.

1:16:14They don't want to spend $900 on anything because they're not like us who are tech geeks who are, like, already, we're already out the door with a phone and a bag unlocking it, right?

1:16:25Right, right.

1:16:25And most people have much more sense about their tech purchases than people like us or people who listen to shows like this do.

1:16:35That's why Apple sells so – that's why their lineup of iPhones is so much more complicated than their other products if you want to list them all because they know people are super price sensitive at all of these levels.

1:16:50Like, from the base model iPhone 16e up, they don't want to spend $500 on a phone, a lot of people, right?

1:17:00That's – people used to like – it was like the whole cell phone industry was like, hey, just sign up for a two-year plan.

1:17:05We'll give you a phone, right?

1:17:06That's what people like.

1:17:07They're like, yeah, that's the price I want.

1:17:09I want to pay nothing, and I don't care if it's a piece of junk.

1:17:12Yeah, yeah.

1:17:13I mean, people still do that.

1:17:13People still get the –

1:17:14I know.

1:17:15Those overtime deals.

1:17:17Yeah.

1:17:17They did a huge part of it, right?

1:17:20I don't think there's any consumer product in the world with more pay overtime options.

1:17:27Yeah, good point.

1:17:28You can pay the company who makes the phone over time.

1:17:31You can pay the company who provides your cell service over time.

1:17:34You can pay your credit card company over time.

1:17:38I mean, everybody wants the market from people who want to buy their phones over time.

1:17:44That is funny.

1:17:44Yeah.

1:17:45It's like it's your house, your car, and your phone.

1:17:47Your phone, right.

1:17:48Right.

1:17:48Exactly.

1:17:49Because they're relatively expensive.

1:17:51And now you're talking about a form factor that more than doubles the price most people pay, right?

1:17:59Of course that's going to keep – so however good and useful they are, and maybe this is the future of all phones,

1:18:06and five years from now everybody's going to be using a foldable.

1:18:10I really doubt that, but maybe that's how powerful or effective the form factor is.

1:18:16Until the price goes below – well below $2,000 and more like $1,000, it is not going to get that much of the market.

1:18:23Right.

1:18:24Well, it should also be said – oh, go ahead, go ahead.

1:18:26Well, I'm just saying people would lose their shit if Apple was the first one to unveil it at $2,000.

1:18:31I agree.

1:18:32It would be like the Vision Pro, right?

1:18:34It would be exactly like the Vision Pro in terms of the consumer reaction or the –

1:18:39If you look at the foldable –

1:18:41Yes.

1:18:42If you look at the foldable market, though, the most popular foldables are the ones that take the candy bar

1:18:47and fold it in half into a little square as opposed to the book style just based on price alone.

1:18:53But that's – so even going back to that 3%, that does include those, but those are the vast part of the market.

1:18:58And actually, believe it or not, Motorola is the leader in the U.S.

1:19:02Yeah, yeah.

1:19:02In foldable smartphones, not Samsung or Google based on that.

1:19:06I don't know anybody who owns one of those, though.

1:19:09I mean, do you?

1:19:10I see them around when I'm like – you know, I do a lot of – I'm in airports at least, I don't know, three or four times a month.

1:19:18I will probably see more of those flip style.

1:19:21Those are called the flip style folds as opposed to the book style folds.

1:19:25And the people who are younger.

1:19:26Like, for me, I don't really see the point.

1:19:28It feels like you're just trying to make space as opposed to – if you open a phone into the size of an iPad,

1:19:35you have – it's like you can do two different types of work, right?

1:19:39As opposed to just – I'm just folding my phone in half like the old school flip phones back in the day just to put it in my purse or pocket.

1:19:46Right.

1:19:46I don't really see much utility there personally for me, but I think it's more of – it's like a fashion accessory for some people.

1:19:56Yeah, yeah.

1:19:57It's an accessory as opposed to having something that's – it folds because it's usable.

1:20:02It just folds because it's cute and it's personality-based.

1:20:06Yeah, it's my favorite thing to do in airports.

1:20:09And as I go back and forth to pee on the airplane is looking at people's devices.

1:20:14I just love it.

1:20:16That's funny.

1:20:16I do the same thing.

1:20:17I'm just curious.

1:20:18What do people have on their wrist and in their hands?

1:20:19Yeah, on their wrist, in their hands, or on their lap, in the seat, in the tray.

1:20:24It's like, oh, that guy's got – that's a tablet, but it's – oh, it's a Surface tablet.

1:20:28Wow.

1:20:28Yep.

1:20:28You know?

1:20:29I love – it's the only daring fireball consumer research is conducted in the aisle of an airplane or the seating area around the gate at the airport.

1:20:41I would guess Apple's is going to be expensive.

1:20:44It seems like these foldable screens are the primary thing that drives up the cost, the durability, that none of that comes cheap.

1:20:51And Apple is entering late because they're – they want to do it Apple style.

1:20:59And supposedly, you know, Gurman keeps reporting.

1:21:01But of course they do.

1:21:02I mean, you don't need Gurman to know that Apple doesn't want to have a visible crease on the screen.

1:21:06They're Apple, right?

1:21:07And they're not going to ship a phone where it's like, yeah, don't get dust in it.

1:21:12Right?

1:21:14Yeah.

1:21:14I mean, I say that knowing that I just wrote yesterday about the rumor that they're going to – or more than a rumor.

1:21:20It seems like they already leaked.

1:21:21But they're going to have these tech-woven cases for the iPhone 17 lineup to replace the fine-woven.

1:21:28So it's like, you know, they are the company that shipped iPhone case – protective cases that themselves weren't durable.

1:21:37Right.

1:21:37But your iPhone still was protected.

1:21:39It's just the case on the outside.

1:21:41Right.

1:21:42The point of the case is to protect the phone, but the case needed a case.

1:21:48Yes, exactly.

1:21:49I remember looking at Joanna Stern's, like, after a month of use.

1:21:53It looked like it got, like, run over by a truck on a muddy road or something.

1:21:58And it was also weird because you would go to the Apple store to check out because they would, like, have them on display.

1:22:02Right.

1:22:02And they all look terrible because people would, like, pick them up and scratch at them and put them back.

1:22:08It's like, you just have a display of cases that look so worn.

1:22:11And remember – I remember years ago, it was, like, either the first iPod Nano or the second one, but there was, like, an iPod Nano that was bizarrely easily scratchable.

1:22:22Right?

1:22:23It was, like – it was, like, if you looked at it funny, you could put a scratch on the front face.

1:22:28Yeah, the whole front.

1:22:29Like, the Nanos were sort of shaped like the Apple TV remote, like a diving board.

1:22:35And there was one generation of them that was, like, the plastic part.

1:22:39It was, like, metal on the back, plastic on the front, and the plastic was super scratchable.

1:22:43It wasn't unusable, but it was, like, people don't want their $300 iPod to look scratched up.

1:22:50Not at all.

1:22:51Not at all.

1:22:52Jeez.

1:22:52So, I think whatever led them to the lazy solution of fine woven for iPhone cases, where they clearly only tested them by taking very careful care of them, they're not going to do with the phone itself, right?

1:23:07Like, they're going to debut with good dust and water resistance and a hinge that can take tens of thousands of foldings and unfoldings without breaking.

1:23:19All that's going to be expensive.

1:23:21And I'd really do – I'd almost look – the main reason I look forward to it is not that I want to use a foldable iPhone, because I don't think I do.

1:23:29But I'm certainly willing to give it a try in a year, but it's mostly to see the press give Apple shit for the price when they're entering a market where all the other phones are at the same price or more expensive.

1:23:42Yeah, yeah.

1:23:43My guess is that that is going to happen, but I think it's going to be similar arguments to what we see today, which is, for example, most Android phones, even at the base level, have been shipping with 120-hertz screens for years.

1:23:59Right, right.

1:24:00So people will say the foldables that are available from others have all these other features, and Apple's has – they're making a foldable with less.

1:24:07You're getting less for the same amount of money.

1:24:09And that is kind of my own personal worry as a user, not as a journalist.

1:24:16I get the phone.

1:24:18The reason I'm a Pro Max guy is because I want every single camera feature and every – I don't want to have a device that I just know in the back of my mind is missing.

1:24:28I have a 3X instead of a 5X camera or whatever it might be, right?

1:24:32And I highly suspect, just based on what other foldable manufacturers do, if you're not aware, the foldable is the most expensive in the lineup, but it's not the best in the lineup as it pertains to the specs of the device.

1:24:47If you were to get a Samsung Galaxy S25 Ultra and compare it to the Galaxy Fold 7, the Ultra, which is $1,000 less, is actually the better device from a camera perspective and things like that.

1:25:02And so I'm assuming even just based on purpose reporting.

1:25:05Exactly.

1:25:05Battery life.

1:25:06A lot of things.

1:25:07Durability.

1:25:07Apple – it sounds to me, and this is me pontificating on what I've been seeing, the foldable from Apple will be more akin to an iPhone non-pro than a Pro.

1:25:23It'll be the foldable iPhone, not the foldable iPhone Pro.

1:25:27And then maybe that leaves room in the future for a foldable Pro version.

1:25:32But when I hear, like, you know, it's going to have two cameras on the back, right?

1:25:36That's an entry-level iPhone thing.

1:25:38Right.

1:25:38That's not a Pro iPhone thing.

1:25:41So just things like that, where other phones have more cameras, other phones have these features, other phones have those features, and then Apple's giving us this for $2,000.

1:25:48How dare they?

1:25:50That's what I'm expecting to see.

1:25:51Definitely.

1:25:53All right.

1:25:53Let me take a break here.

1:25:54Thank our third and final sponsor of the episode, our very good friends, at Squarespace.

1:25:59This podcast is often sponsored by Squarespace.

1:26:03And that's because people like you, whoever you are listening to me tell you about Squarespace right now, keep signing up for Squarespace accounts.

1:26:12Or, which I think is really the key to the fit of Squarespace as a sponsor of the talk show, is people keep coming to you as a nerd to say,

1:26:23Hey, I need a new website for me, or for my consulting business, or somebody who owns a restaurant, if you have a friend.

1:26:30Or maybe you're the one who's going to intervene and say to your friend who bought a restaurant or owns a restaurant,

1:26:35you know, your website stinks.

1:26:36You ought to build a new one.

1:26:38And they're like, are you going to build it for me?

1:26:40And you're like, no.

1:26:41You know what you're going to do?

1:26:42You're going to go to Squarespace.

1:26:43And you're going to do it, and it's going to be easy.

1:26:46And they're going to say, I don't know how to build a website.

1:26:48And that's the whole point of Squarespace, is you don't know how to build a website.

1:26:53And Squarespace will let you build a website.

1:26:56And they'll say, I don't even know how to register a domain name.

1:26:59Squarespace has that too.

1:27:01Everything from the domain name to what the website looks like to what features or things are on it.

1:27:09If it's a restaurant, obviously you want hours, a page like that, and a menu and stuff like that.

1:27:14And if you are a consulting business, you want to have a thing where people can book your services.

1:27:21Squarespace has that built in.

1:27:23They've got Squarespace invoices now where you can invoice your customers through your Squarespace website.

1:27:31And they get a URL that goes to your website where they see the invoice,

1:27:35and then they pay the invoice through Squarespace payments on your website.

1:27:40All the secure stuff you need for payments, everything like that, built right in.

1:27:44Squarespace offers it.

1:27:45And then you get to see all of your paid invoices right there, all integrated on your own website.

1:27:51They've got AI features to help you manipulate the design.

1:27:56So instead of using their truly, really, really good, long-standing drag-and-drop visual WYSIWYG style of traditional dragging with your mouse or your finger,

1:28:08because all of their stuff works great from iPads and phones now,

1:28:13you can design your website, change the features and the layout the old way with drag-and-drop,

1:28:19which is probably what I would still do.

1:28:20But you can also just use AI and tell it, this is what I want.

1:28:23I want a sidebar that lists this, this, and this.

1:28:25And then you get it, and you can see it.

1:28:27And what you see as the owner, manager, whatever you want to call it, of your website on Squarespace

1:28:33is exactly what the visitors to your website will see, except without the editing features.

1:28:39Truly WYSIWYG for the modern age.

1:28:42What you see is what you get on Squarespace.

1:28:45So if you need a website, or someone you know needs a website, and all those features sound good to you,

1:28:49go check them out at squarespace.com slash talkshow.

1:28:53Squarespace.com slash talkshow.

1:28:56And that code, talkshow, gets you 10% off your first purchase, which can be up for a full year of service.

1:29:03So save 10% on a full year just by going to squarespace.com slash talkshow.

1:29:08I feel like the show is leading inexorably towards the Apple event coming in a week and a half.

1:29:14We've been talking about Apple's foldable phone, which is next year's, I guess, 53 and a half weeks away, probably.

1:29:21I keep wanting to say awe-inspiring, but it's awe-dropping.

1:29:27Awe-dropping.

1:29:28Like jaw-dropping, yes.

1:29:29Yeah, jaw-dropping.

1:29:30Of course, because awe-inspiring isn't a pun.

1:29:33It's just a phrase.

1:29:34I wonder, you know, Apple always comes up with these puns for their event names.

1:29:39I wonder how short the list is getting, or if they've got an infinite list of them.

1:29:43The logo is sort of an infrared Apple logo.

1:29:47I love the Kremlin, I always call it Kremlin-ology of trying to decipher the meaning of the logo theme.

1:29:54Do you have any guesses based on this one?

1:29:57Yeah, for me, it was just about the colors.

1:30:00You've got that dark blue in there, which, and you got the orange, which seems to be the two, I want to call them rumored, but it's, I don't know, it's almost leaked.

1:30:10A lot of times these things feel like they're confirmed before we get there.

1:30:13So the orange and the dark blue iPhone Pros, and then this lighter sky blue, which would be the, I assumed, like the hero color of the new iPhone Air.

1:30:22So I think that's kind of what this is telling us.

1:30:26I do too.

1:30:27I have bought a new iPhone every year since they come out.

1:30:32And at this point, it's like, what am I doing?

1:30:34This is, I mean, even me, I'm still using an M1 MacBook Pro.

1:30:38My iPad is from 2018.

1:30:40I tend not to buy a new thing every year.

1:30:42I like to buy a new maxed out thing and then use it for a few years.

1:30:46So with the iPhone, I keep buying a new one because it's like now, well, now it's a thing.

1:30:50And I want to keep doing it.

1:30:51And I do, I've started selling, I don't keep them all.

1:30:55I don't think I have every one.

1:30:56I have all the first couple ones, but I'm not running an iPhone museum in my office.

1:31:01They're just in a cabinet, higgly piggly.

1:31:04There's a couple that I really care about keeping.

1:31:07I really love the original.

1:31:08I love the iPhone 5.

1:31:12But one thing I've done every single year, I do buy a new iPhone and every year I buy

1:31:17it in black.

1:31:18Because every year, without exception, I've been tempted once or twice.

1:31:24There was the one year where there was sort of a very dark, near black, sort of a Boba Fett

1:31:31colored, bluish green.

1:31:33I forget, like maybe around the iPhone 12 or 13 or 11.

1:31:38It's like a Pacific blue, I think you're thinking of.

1:31:40There's a couple that have been tempting.

1:31:42You know, and I'm not saying I'm always going to buy black, and I'm not saying I'm always

1:31:45going to buy a new iPhone every year.

1:31:47But as a rule of thumb, when I buy anything, if it's offered in black, I buy black.

1:31:51And if it's not offered in black, I just buy the closest to black.

1:31:55And it's not, A, I am boring and basic.

1:32:00But B, that way, it is like Steve Jobs having 20 of the exact same black turtleneck.

1:32:07Or Albert Einstein having a whole closet full of the same blue sweater.

1:32:13Because then I don't have to think about it, right?

1:32:15Because if I sit there and think about it, I'll get torn up between the colors.

1:32:22But in recent years, I haven't even been tempted by the last few years.

1:32:26They're so boring, in my opinion.

1:32:28And I know every single Apple-related podcast says this every year.

1:32:32Why does Apple think Pro means boring colors?

1:32:35And they make these other devices, including iPhones now, in fun colors.

1:32:40Yes.

1:32:40And then the Pro ones, which cost more, come in white and then other shades of near black or black.

1:32:50And this year, the rumor is they're going to make, like, a really vibrant orange one.

1:32:55My wife and son, I bet, are both going to go gaga over it.

1:32:59Because they don't just buy black everything.

1:33:01They do like getting interesting colors of things.

1:33:04And want the Pro phone for the cameras, but don't want boring colors.

1:33:10I think this thing is going to be a hit.

1:33:12And I really hope it is.

1:33:13And if it's not, I think...

1:33:16Oh, man.

1:33:16Colors are doomed.

1:33:18It's like the iPhone mini from the 12 and 13 era, right?

1:33:21I wish that they'd been a hit.

1:33:24I really do.

1:33:24They obviously weren't.

1:33:26And it's like...

1:33:29And I know that...

1:33:30I know.

1:33:30I'm going to...

1:33:31I welcome your emails.

1:33:32I would love to hear from you if you're still using your iPhone 13 or 12 mini.

1:33:36I know people, personally, who are because they don't want to get a bigger phone.

1:33:41But don't be angry at Apple.

1:33:44Be angry at the people who didn't buy them.

1:33:46Because they clearly were not a hit product.

1:33:48I don't know.

1:33:49I kind of feel like this orange iPhone Pro, though, is going to be a hit.

1:33:52I do.

1:33:53I'm so excited.

1:33:54I love the color orange.

1:33:55It's my favorite color.

1:33:56I would get orange in everything if I could.

1:33:59And when I saw...

1:34:00I mean, I would ask the Apple for that for years.

1:34:04I remember when before the Apple Watch Ultra was announced upstairs in the theater, when

1:34:09one of the PR people on the watch team was like, what are you hoping to see today?

1:34:12And I was like, there's a rumor that you're going to have a Pro watch today.

1:34:15I would love to have some pops of orange on there.

1:34:17And that was the color of the action button.

1:34:19I was like, this is fantastic.

1:34:21And last year, I said to...

1:34:23Who was it?

1:34:24I said to Jaws.

1:34:25I was like, same thing.

1:34:26Why does Pro on the iPhone mean no colors?

1:34:30And all he said was, you know what?

1:34:31We hear you.

1:34:32So to me, I was like, okay, next...

1:34:35It's like without saying it, just look out for next year, right?

1:34:38And so you're going to get the black.

1:34:41You're going to get the white.

1:34:41You're going to get what looks to me like a nice dark blue, right?

1:34:44If you don't want black or white.

1:34:45But then you'll have something a little different for those people who want something a little

1:34:50more colorful.

1:34:51So the way I buy my phones is regardless of what the color is, I like to get the color

1:34:58that's different that year.

1:35:00It makes it easy for me to remember just by looking at it.

1:35:03Oh, that's an iPhone 12 because that's Sierra blue, right?

1:35:05Or whatever it might be.

1:35:06So I'll always go for just the new and different option of that year, at least on the pro phone.

1:35:14But I'm never really excited about it.

1:35:17And I never really get people's excitement about color until I saw, oh, now there's a color

1:35:23I really want.

1:35:24Now I get it.

1:35:25Now I see why.

1:35:26Or now I see why women, for example, like how come we never get...

1:35:30colors that are traditionally something that is aimed towards a female, like a nice pink

1:35:35or purple.

1:35:35How come it's always a utilitarian dark steel color?

1:35:38I get it.

1:35:39Rose gold is probably the closest they came to...

1:35:42Yes.

1:35:42I'd say it is sort of a traditionally feminine color.

1:35:46I know they've made pink, truly pink, like bubblegum pink, regular iPhones.

1:35:52Regular phones, yes.

1:35:52And that's bubblegum pink.

1:35:54It doesn't say pro to me, right?

1:35:56It's not about gender, right?

1:35:57In the same way that there's blue and blue in our culture is traditionally the boys color.

1:36:04There's shades of blue that don't say pro, but then there's shades of blue that do.

1:36:09And there's some of those shades are a lot more fun and have a lot more pop than, oh, unless

1:36:15you hold it just right, it kind of looks gray.

1:36:18Yeah.

1:36:18Right?

1:36:19Right, right.

1:36:20Even the MacBook, the sky blue, right?

1:36:24Like, when they showed it to us in the briefing, it was very obviously sky blue.

1:36:29And then when I got it at home, I was like, did they send me?

1:36:32Yeah.

1:36:32Like, I thought it was the silver one.

1:36:34I was like, this is not...

1:36:35And then I put it next to a silver one.

1:36:36I was like, oh, okay.

1:36:37You have to put it next to a silver one to really see it.

1:36:41And then it's like your eyes do the white balancing.

1:36:44They really do.

1:36:45I mean, human eyes, right?

1:36:46This is why somebody who buys the wrong light bulbs, right?

1:36:52And it drives me crazy.

1:36:53Somebody who doesn't even look at the color temperature of the light bulbs they purchase

1:36:58and they buy these terrible surgical room blue-white light.

1:37:05You don't want these in your house.

1:37:07But if you sit in a room long enough, your eyes will get used to it, right?

1:37:11Yes.

1:37:11And it's like that sky blue MacBook Air looks silver until you put it next to silver, right?

1:37:18Right.

1:37:19If you want people to know that you have the sky blue MacBook Air, you have to buy both models

1:37:23and then have the other one off to the side so people can see that you have the blue one.

1:37:27That's how ridiculous it is.

1:37:29Right.

1:37:29It's like the Dallas Cowboys pants wouldn't look blue or like slightly blue, except for the

1:37:35fact that their helmets are silver, right?

1:37:37But if their helmets match the pants, they would just look like they were silver.

1:37:40That's right.

1:37:41That's right.

1:37:41You need color.

1:37:42So I think that, and I know it's the most superficial thing possible, but I think it's going to

1:37:48be a big hit this year.

1:37:50I agree.

1:37:50Because, and the one thing, even though it leaked a while ago that there would be an

1:37:57orange pro iPhone 17 and there's leaked images and stuff like that.

1:38:02The one thing that never really comes out of those leaked images is what the colors really

1:38:07look like.

1:38:07Yeah.

1:38:08Because the exact tone.

1:38:10And it's not just, oh, Apple's product photography is better.

1:38:13I'm saying like me and you right out of the keynote when we're in the hands-on area and

1:38:18get to look at them in natural light.

1:38:19We're like, ooh, that's neat.

1:38:21And just based on the Apple Watch Ultra, Apple does a really good anodized arch.

1:38:28Like it's a really good.

1:38:29So I think that's going to be a big hit.

1:38:31The other big thing, obviously, is the much leaked, talked about iPhone Air.

1:38:38Do you think they're, A, do you think they're going to call it the Air?

1:38:41And B, what are your thoughts?

1:38:44Because I think it's exactly what you're talking about with the foldables, where I think it's

1:38:49going to be priced in between the regular and the pro.

1:38:53And if anything, if it's not exactly in between, closer to the pro, because it's Apple.

1:38:59But it's going to have specs like the regular one, I suspect.

1:39:02It's only going to have two cameras and the battery life is going to be less because it's

1:39:08thinner, right?

1:39:09Do you think they're going to call it Air?

1:39:10And what are your thoughts now that we're like a week and a half out from it?

1:39:14My expectation for this phone is a couple of things.

1:39:17So I think it's going to just take the place of the plus, including the price.

1:39:21But there are rumors of price increases due to the tariff situation.

1:39:28So if we see price increases, I don't think that it's going to increase in price because

1:39:32it's thin, but it's what the plus would have increased to anyway, if the plus stayed around.

1:39:37And I do think it's going to be, so I don't think it's going to have the same specs as the

1:39:43regular, where are we at?

1:39:4517, 17.

1:39:46I think it's going to have a pro chip with one less GPU core active.

1:39:54So it's in between as it pertains to GPU power of the 17 and the 17 pro.

1:39:59I don't know if it's, I bet, I'm going to bet the other way that it doesn't have the pro

1:40:04chip because I'm not quite sure what pro features it would need.

1:40:08I don't think it's going to do the high, the high speed Thunderbolt IO out of the USB port.

1:40:16What, what exactly would it need?

1:40:17The reason I thought that was not to jump ahead, but the rumor of how next year we're not going

1:40:24to get an 18, we're going to get the 18 air pro and fold.

1:40:29And then the regular 18 and 18 E will be the following spring.

1:40:33Right.

1:40:34So it just leads me to think that the pro, the higher end models come in September and

1:40:40then the lower end models would come in the spring.

1:40:42And the chip is one of the main differentiators there, which is kind of leads me there.

1:40:47But I, here's what I think, why I think otherwise though, I think if you think the chip is a thing

1:40:53to care about, you're not buying the thin one anyway.

1:40:55That is true.

1:40:56That is true.

1:40:57Which I do think it's going to be like that flip.

1:40:59I think this is going to be the cool thing to buy.

1:41:03This is going to be the, the accessory, the cool, different looking iPhone.

1:41:07And what's super interesting to me is that it seems like Samsung's edge, which came out

1:41:12a couple of months ago, just came and went.

1:41:14Yep.

1:41:15Like it came and it went.

1:41:17I have not seen them anywhere.

1:41:18It is an impressive thing to hold.

1:41:20I think it's 5.8 millimeters and the iPhone air is going to be 5.5.

1:41:25So three tenths of a millimeter, but it seemed like it just came and went.

1:41:30And Apple's going to be able to say, Hey, we have the thinnest phone.

1:41:32Actually, I think Motorola put out a 5.2 millimeter phone a few years ago.

1:41:39The one that had, you would slap the attachments on the back magnetically.

1:41:43I forget the name of that phone.

1:41:45But I do think this is going to be wildly popular just due to the fact that it's a different

1:41:50form factor.

1:41:51And what's something you alluded to earlier about people caring about color.

1:41:55I do a lot of videos right as like right after the keynote.

1:42:00Like I try to sit in the cheap seats so that as soon as it ends, I can just get up and run

1:42:04to the tables.

1:42:04Right.

1:42:05And start making some quick vertical TikTok or Instagram videos.

1:42:08And I can tell you right now, I can give you a spec rundown.

1:42:12I can tell you about all the new things about the camera or whatever it might be.

1:42:15The video that pops to like a million views almost instantly is here's the four colors of

1:42:20the new iPhone.

1:42:21Just showing the colors.

1:42:23I'm not even saying anything about the phone other than the colors.

1:42:26And those will blow up.

1:42:27So I think people really do get pent up for, I want something to look new and I want something

1:42:35to look unique in my hands when I'm out and about.

1:42:38And so the Air, I think it's going to be very impressive and people are going to love it.

1:42:42Just for me, it's something I wish I would want to carry around, but I know I'm, I mean,

1:42:49I don't want a phone with one camera.

1:42:50I don't want a phone that with bad battery life.

1:42:53And you know what I mean?

1:42:55Like the new thing isn't for me, which is a very rare thing for me to say.

1:43:00Yeah.

1:43:00I really was impressed with the 16E, which only has one camera.

1:43:09I just really, I just loved how it felt.

1:43:12And I think, as I recall, the theme of my review was basically, I think, or at least it was a

1:43:18point I tried to make in it, that there's an alternate universe where the iPhone never went

1:43:24high-end and pro, right?

1:43:26And that the 16E feels like, in some other way, the derivative of the original iPhone and

1:43:36the 3G and the 3GS.

1:43:37And I guess, you know, those first three, the original and the 3G and the 3GS.

1:43:43Yeah.

1:43:44Because it was with the iPhone 4 with the glass back and the steel sides where it kind

1:43:50of went more premium, just not even talking about what it does, just the way it looks and

1:43:56feels.

1:43:57And the 16E is so plain.

1:44:01It's got this matte aluminum finish, and it's got a couple colors and just one camera, but

1:44:06the camera hardly sticks out.

1:44:08Yeah.

1:44:08It sticks out so little that if you buy a case, the case doesn't have any kind of lip around

1:44:15the camera because it doesn't need one for the case to be protective of the camera if you

1:44:21put it flat down.

1:44:22Right.

1:44:23Which is amazing, right?

1:44:24So most people use a case.

1:44:26And so if you buy the 16E, you can lay your phone flat on a table like we did when we were

1:44:33young.

1:44:34And it doesn't wobble, which is really cool.

1:44:37And it is, for one camera lens, really useful, right?

1:44:42Oh, for sure.

1:44:43I'm not going to buy it.

1:44:44I take way too many photos with the 0.5 and the telephotos, but especially the 0.5, where

1:44:53I really want to be able to do that.

1:44:56But boy, it's tempting and it's close.

1:44:59And most importantly, I really do like that the 1X lens on the pro cameras is optically

1:45:07superior to everything else.

1:45:08And so, you know, I'm only going to have this phone for a year.

1:45:11I'm going to get the one with the best camera probably.

1:45:14But boy, it's tempting.

1:45:16And I can see it.

1:45:17I think for most-

1:45:18You're saying the Air is tempting?

1:45:20No, but the 16E even was somewhat tempting.

1:45:23And I wouldn't hesitate to recommend it to most of my family members, even if I know they

1:45:28take a lot of photos.

1:45:29And I think if I looked through their entire photo library, I would see, like my wife,

1:45:33for example, every photo she takes is 1X, every photo.

1:45:37It's because she doesn't think like that.

1:45:38She takes photos, but she takes out her iPhone, points it, frames it, hits the button.

1:45:42And when you do it-

1:45:44Walks to where she needs to be.

1:45:44Yeah.

1:45:45And when you do that, you get a 1X photo.

1:45:47Most people are fine with that.

1:45:49And I think it's going to take really good 1X photos, but I don't always want a 1X photo

1:45:55or 2X with the optical sensor crop.

1:45:57Yeah, I don't know.

1:45:58And I do think that the failure of the mini, which was the last time they really tried

1:46:03something radically different with the form factor.

1:46:06I think there's a lot of people who, if you gave them an iPhone mini and said, you have

1:46:12to use this for a month.

1:46:13I think there's a lot of people who, if you made them do it, they'd be like, you know,

1:46:17I really like this.

1:46:19I really like the size and how it fits in my pocket and I don't miss the bigger size and

1:46:24I don't really type a lot.

1:46:25So I don't care if the keyboard's smaller.

1:46:27I really like it.

1:46:28I just think though, people make the decision what to buy before they've actually used it.

1:46:33And I think that people think they want a bigger phone than they really need in real life.

1:46:39And the Air, if that's what they call it, I still want your answer on whether you think

1:46:43they're going to call it the Air.

1:46:44But it solves that because it's apparently going to have a screen size in between the

1:46:49regular size and the max size.

1:46:52So it won't be a small screen in terms of area.

1:46:54And I think that's a deal breaker for people, right?

1:46:58Like I think if this 17 Air were smaller in every way, not just thinner, but actually more

1:47:04like a mini, I think that would doom it because I don't think people want a small area screen

1:47:10size.

1:47:10And I might be wrong.

1:47:12It might be, it might just be that people really do want big screens on their phones

1:47:16because they do so much of their daily computing life on their phone.

1:47:20So they, of course they want a bigger phone.

1:47:22I think the battery life will be fine, especially the 16E isn't super thin, but it gets better

1:47:29battery life than the regular iPhone 16, right?

1:47:31That's C1, that's C1 modem though.

1:47:33Yeah, right.

1:47:34And it's, that's the shit, man.

1:47:37That is Apple like caring about a thing that other companies just don't care about, which

1:47:43is somebody at Apple or some team at Apple has been looking at the power draw and Qualcomm's

1:47:51talking about 5G and 87 different bands of 5G they support around the world.

1:47:56And there's this team at Apple that looks at the power draw of that antenna in every single

1:48:02phone out there.

1:48:03And they are sick.

1:48:04They're sick to their stomachs at the power that is going into this.

1:48:09And they built a modem that doesn't support all those bands, doesn't support the super fast

1:48:14ultra wide band that nobody really needs.

1:48:17It's nice to have if you really do need it.

1:48:19But for the most part, regular 5G is fine.

1:48:22But I'll say not yet.

1:48:23It doesn't have it yet.

1:48:25Right, right.

1:48:25It will.

1:48:26Yeah.

1:48:26And they know that too.

1:48:27Right.

1:48:27But what they do know is that it draws less power.

1:48:30Right.

1:48:30And that's the shit, man.

1:48:33So I think that the battery life is going to be fine on this thing, no matter how thin

1:48:37it is.

1:48:37You know, it's obviously not going to get the battery life that the pro ones that are thicker

1:48:41and certainly not what the Max has, which is thicker and taller and wider.

1:48:46But that's not what people need.

1:48:48Right.

1:48:48It's interesting because I believe it was German who reported that the battery life will be

1:48:54similar to an iPhone 12.

1:48:55I don't.

1:48:56I bet it's better.

1:48:58I do.

1:48:58But that also Apple will bring back the battery case for the Air in particular, which to me,

1:49:04aren't you definitively?

1:49:06If you're buying this because of the thinness, why are you going to put that battery case with

1:49:09the bulbous back on it?

1:49:10You know what I mean?

1:49:11Like, well, if it's a yeah, if it's the battery case, I don't know that.

1:49:15I think that's what it maybe it wasn't German.

1:49:17Maybe that was Wayne Ma at the information or maybe both of them.

1:49:20I don't know.

1:49:20German has so many reports that maybe he's chimed in on it, too.

1:49:24But I think it was Wayne Ma who said that my secret hope.

1:49:27And I wrote this at the time is that Apple doesn't bring a battery pack, but they bring

1:49:32back the magnetic battery thing.

1:49:35Right.

1:49:35The MagSafe battery.

1:49:37Right.

1:49:37Which I still have two of and I love.

1:49:42And I'm telling you, do you have one?

1:49:44I do.

1:49:44I have two of them.

1:49:45They're so much better than the third party battery packs from Anchor or whoever else makes

1:49:51them because it snaps on better.

1:49:53It doesn't come off in your pocket.

1:49:55And they do have their cheaty internal super secret software APIs that show you things that

1:50:02the other third parties can't do.

1:50:03But it's also just really smart.

1:50:06Like, it doesn't try to charge your phone too much past 70 percent because it knows that

1:50:12a magnetic battery, it's better to let the phone get to 70 and then fall back down and

1:50:18then charge it back to 70 than to push it to 90 because you'll get more, you'll get

1:50:22more actual battery life out of that.

1:50:23It's just such a great product.

1:50:25And the only problem with it is it has a lightning port instead of USB-C.

1:50:29So my secret hope is that report is slightly wrong and that they bring back that.

1:50:34And then it'll work on any iPhone, not just this year's new ones, but any of them that

1:50:39have MagSafe rather than make a battery case like the previous Apple battery cases that

1:50:45will only fit one model of phone for one year because next year's 18 Air is going to

1:50:51be like a millimeter thinner or whatever.

1:50:53That's my hope.

1:50:55And that would make me very happy.

1:50:56Did you know that you can charge that battery case by plugging your iPhone into lightning?

1:51:03Yes.

1:51:04Your phone will charge the case.

1:51:05No, plug your iPhone into USB-C.

1:51:08Yeah, yeah.

1:51:09Sorry.

1:51:09Plug your phone into USB-C and it'll charge your lightning MagSafe battery.

1:51:14Right.

1:51:15So that if, right, so you can, if you have one of those Apple MagSafe battery packs in

1:51:20a drawer and you've taken it out of your travel bag because you're like, ah, otherwise I could

1:51:25live the lightning.

1:51:26I could just have USB-C cables only.

1:51:29That's all I need.

1:51:30So I don't want to take this.

1:51:31You can live the USB-C only life with the battery pack.

1:51:36Plug your phone in at the bedside in the hotel to the USB-C, leave the battery pack on it and

1:51:42the phone will charge the battery pack.

1:51:44It'll charge.

1:51:44It's such a great product.

1:51:45It really, and it, I cannot emphasize how strongly the battery holds and doesn't rotate like a

1:51:52clock around the middle like every other battery pack does.

1:51:56It's such a great product.

1:51:57I love the size and shape of it.

1:51:59It actually sort of works better as like a AirSat pop socket for your finger.

1:52:04That would be my hope.

1:52:06And it leads me to another really interesting rumor, which probably is German.

1:52:11I don't know.

1:52:11Whoever.

1:52:13But did you see this, that Apple's rumored to bring back bumper cases for the Air?

1:52:18I did see that.

1:52:19I did see that.

1:52:20That is interesting because the thinness of it, I can't imagine like a super thin, flimsy

1:52:28almost seems to be the word for this.

1:52:29But I mean, it makes sense because you want to preserve the thinness of this thing and cases

1:52:34are bulky.

1:52:35That's why I never, I don't use cases on any of my phones because I like how they're

1:52:40designed and how they feel.

1:52:41I don't want to add any bulk to them.

1:52:43So that, I think that's a smart way to protect it from dropping and, but still keeping it thin.

1:52:48I haven't asked because it's one of the, I'm always so overwhelmed with questions, but, but

1:52:54I've been meaning to ask, like if a briefing with jaws or somebody, whatever happened to

1:52:59bumper cases.

1:53:00And I hope this year that they announced them and therefore I don't have to, I still, I guess

1:53:05guess it'll be a reminder to ask like, why did it take so long?

1:53:07But for anybody who doesn't remember, I think they only sold them for one year with the iPhone

1:53:12four.

1:53:13Maybe they still sold them with the four S I don't know, but it was certainly they went

1:53:17away with the iPhone five, but with the iPhone four, which would be 27, eight, 10, 2010.

1:53:25Their only branded quote unquote cases were bumpers.

1:53:29And so it was just around the rails of the iPhone and it had a completely open back.

1:53:34It was just like a picture frame for the phone and you'd put it in place and it would cover

1:53:39the rails.

1:53:40And they ended up giving them to everybody because of the antenna gate pseudo scandal, because

1:53:46the attenuation problem of having a finger that covered the antenna gap on the stainless

1:53:52steel frame really was to do with the electromagnetic conductive skin bridging a gap that wasn't meant

1:54:00to be bridged.

1:54:01And so if you did anything to avoid putting the skin of your finger or hand across those

1:54:07two pieces of the stainless steel antenna, it would alleviate, make the problem go away.

1:54:12So they just gave everybody these $19 bumper cases.

1:54:16If you have an iPhone four here, we'll just give you one.

1:54:18And they download the app.

1:54:20You have to download the iPhone four bumper app to redeem it.

1:54:24They made an app just to send these to you.

1:54:26But yeah, that was, they had a whole press conference.

1:54:28That was the funniest thing.

1:54:29They had a whole press briefing about it.

1:54:32Yep.

1:54:32That was like an emergency press briefing just for it.

1:54:36Jobs came back from vacation in Hawaii to do it.

1:54:38I have a small claim to fame in that press conference where it was in the Apple's town hall, which

1:54:44only sat, I don't know, 75 people, maybe a hundred.

1:54:47I think they rejiggered the seats at some point and added, it sucked because it was already tiny

1:54:53and cramped and they wanted to put more people in.

1:54:55So they made the seats even smaller, like movie theaters used to do before movie theaters came

1:55:01to their senses and made like big fat Barker loungers.

1:55:04Yep.

1:55:04Yeah.

1:55:04No, but they did quite.

1:55:06It was so long ago.

1:55:07They did questions and answers with the press.

1:55:10And I raised my hand and I think it was Jobs who actually called on me and I wanted to know

1:55:17if since they were giving away the cases, did the executives on stage themselves use a case

1:55:24with their iPhone 4s?

1:55:25And they all, it was Jobs, Big Bob Mansfeld, I think Phil Schiller and Tim Cook, I think were

1:55:33the four, but I know Mansfeld and Jobs and I'm pretty sure Schiller were on stage and instead

1:55:39of answering the question, they all laughed and they all reached in their pockets and took

1:55:43out their iPhone 4s and they all had no case.

1:55:45No cases.

1:55:46No cases.

1:55:47But if you're going to have a case, a bumper case is the way to go, right?

1:55:50It's like the least case and you can feel and see the back.

1:55:53You could see if you care about the color, right?

1:55:56So hopefully it's not just for the air.

1:55:59Why not make them for the Pro too, right?

1:56:01If you've got this cool orange iPhone 17 Pro, don't you want to show off the actual orange?

1:56:07Correct.

1:56:08But did you see the rumor today of the other accessory?

1:56:10No, I did not.

1:56:12All right.

1:56:12Majin Boo, who I think is hit or miss, but he has had some scoops in the past, is he showed

1:56:22photos of an alleged iPhone 17 crossbody strap.

1:56:25So it's like a magnetic strap that would almost hold your phone.

1:56:29I'm assuming in a bumper or the case would have a, what was the?

1:56:34Lanyard, right?

1:56:35It's a lanyard.

1:56:36Like you have at the bottom of the AirPod.

1:56:37Yeah.

1:56:38On the side of the AirPods Pro, have a lanyard hook so you could hook your phone in and just

1:56:42wear it like a crossbody, almost like that one iPod shuffle that had the wear around your

1:56:47neck.

1:56:47Yeah.

1:56:48And it's different colors that match the rumored colors of the phone.

1:56:52So there's an orange one, a blue one, a purple one, dark blue.

1:56:56Would you rock your phone that way?

1:56:58Would you get the crossbody?

1:57:00I don't think so.

1:57:01Put your black phone.

1:57:02Are you going black phone again this year, by the way?

1:57:04Well.

1:57:05Come on.

1:57:06Probably.

1:57:07No.

1:57:08Well, I don't, and I think, and I think I have a really good excuse, even if the orange

1:57:12is a banger.

1:57:13My wife has actually stopped a few years ago.

1:57:16She's like, I don't need a new phone every year.

1:57:18So she's due for a new phone.

1:57:20And orange is her favorite color.

1:57:23She actually didn't buy an orange iMac.

1:57:24In 1999, we went into the store to buy her an iMac, and she was going to buy orange, going

1:57:33to buy orange, going to buy orange.

1:57:34And we got into the store.

1:57:35It was a CompUSA, because there weren't Apple stores yet.

1:57:38And she saw the purple, and was like, oh, I need the purple.

1:57:41Oh, really?

1:57:41But in, yeah.

1:57:42And I think I just read somewhere that orange was, I think they called it tangerine.

1:57:48And maybe because it was called tangerine, it wasn't a great orange in person.

1:57:53I have to admit, I thought that the purple looked better than the orange.

1:57:58But orange in general, as a general rule of thumb, is probably her favorite color.

1:58:02So she's almost, unless there's something horribly wrong with the orange of the iPhone 17

1:58:07Pro, she's going to buy it.

1:58:08And it's as, and she's not a case person either.

1:58:12And as you probably know, having different looking phones is very important.

1:58:17Yeah.

1:58:17You can have the same color.

1:58:18You can have the same color.

1:58:19Okay.

1:58:19Listen, you asked me if I think it's going to be called the iPhone Air.

1:58:21Yep.

1:58:23I'm going to say like the original rumors like a year ago was like iPhone slim or it's

1:58:28like, I don't know.

1:58:29I feel like Apple is a company that they will reuse names appropriately, right?

1:58:34Like whether it's the max term or the like air, we've seen air across products.

1:58:38So I feel like there's no iPhone Air.

1:58:40Now we have an iPad Air.

1:58:40We have a MacBook Air.

1:58:41iPhone Air makes sense to me.

1:58:43So that, that would be my guess.

1:58:45But I think if they name it iPhone Air and I'm correct, then you should at least get the

1:58:49dark blue instead of the black.

1:58:51That's just what I think.

1:58:52That's just what I think.

1:58:55I'm probably, I'm not going to take to bed because I think I'm going to, if I can't get

1:58:59orange, I'm going to get black.

1:59:00Fair enough.

1:59:01Fair enough.

1:59:01Fair enough.

1:59:02I think that the confusing thing with Air is that Air means almost anything to Apple anymore,

1:59:10right?

1:59:10It used to, the original MacBook Air was named the Air because it was so much thinner and

1:59:15lighter.

1:59:15Thin and light.

1:59:15Then he could put it in a Manila inner office memo envelope and take it out on stage.

1:59:22And then eventually the, the MacBook Airs weren't the thinnest, right?

1:59:27They, for a year, a couple of years, they made the regular 12 inch MacBook that was thinner

1:59:31and lighter and smaller.

1:59:32The iPad Airs are not the smallest iPads.

1:59:37They're heavier for sure than the M4 Pro.

1:59:40It just sort of means mid, mid level, right?

1:59:43It's like there's iPad with no adjective.

1:59:45Then you upgrade to the Air and then you upgrade to the Pro.

1:59:48It just means mid.

1:59:49It's like iPad mid.

1:59:51Whereas this is meant to be impressive, but Apple does like to reuse names, right?

1:59:56So I, if I had to bet, I would bet it's the iPhone 17 Air.

2:00:01Okay.

2:00:02If it's not Air, I bet it's an all new name that Apple's never used before, but I can't

2:00:07imagine.

2:00:07I don't have a good one off the top of my head.

2:00:09So if it is, Jaws is going to earn his paycheck with, with clever naming, but I'm going to

2:00:16guess it's Air.

2:00:17Yeah.

2:00:17I would guess Air too.

2:00:18I think it makes too much sense.

2:00:19Yeah.

2:00:20And Apple haven't made a new i-product in so long.

2:00:23I think it was Steve Jobs was still, I think, I think it was a Steve Jobs thing, you know,

2:00:28and I think Johnny Ive didn't like it.

2:00:30And then by the time Johnny Ive was gone, they were already like, well, we just call everything

2:00:35Apple, whatever.

2:00:36Right.

2:00:36Apple watch, Apple this.

2:00:39But so they don't have the i-prefix anymore, but Air is an adjective.

2:00:44The other thing that Air has going for it is no other company calls their things Air.

2:00:49Yes.

2:00:49Everybody's got Pro, everybody's got Plus, everybody's got Max, HBO renamed themselves Max, for God's

2:00:57sake.

2:00:57There's so many of those adjectives that everybody uses and all these companies use them.

2:01:04But Air says Apple, so I kind of feel like they would do it.

2:01:07Let me ask you this.

2:01:08Another thing about the Air, though, the MacBook Air comes in that sky blue, and that seems

2:01:13to be the rumored color for this new phone.

2:01:14This thin phone has that also sky blue, which also leads me to Air.

2:01:17What do you think, going back to the foldable, do you think that gets called an iPhone, or

2:01:25do you think that gets a different name?

2:01:28Because it's almost like it has iPhone properties and it has iPad properties.

2:01:34That's a super interesting question.

2:01:37Probably, I guess, so we can close the show with it.

2:01:40And I was thinking about it earlier when we were talking about it.

2:01:42Whereas I do wonder, did Apple, in hindsight, however many years ago when they named iPadOS,

2:01:52iPadOS, as opposed to just calling it all iOS and some iOS features are for iPads and some

2:01:58iPhone features are for phones, I still think the main reason they did that was to permit

2:02:05themselves to ship some iPad features a year late, right?

2:02:10So, for example, widgets, right?

2:02:12Like widgets on the lock screen came for the iPhone and they didn't come for the iPad until

2:02:17a year later.

2:02:18And Apple has, to Craig Federighi's credit, really gotten their shit together in terms

2:02:23of shipping everything the same year to whether it's a good idea or bad, right, with the state

2:02:28of liquid glass on macOS in particular this year.

2:02:31But every platform is getting liquid glass this fall and they don't do that anymore.

2:02:37So, they don't kind of need that.

2:02:38But for a couple of years, it'd be like, oh, there's a brand new lock screen customization,

2:02:42right?

2:02:42iPad didn't get it until the next year.

2:02:45And it was because, oh, that's iPadOS, not iOS.

2:02:49Now, with this foldable, I wonder, how much have they shot themselves on this?

2:02:53Like, shouldn't, when you unfold it, shouldn't it be like an iPad?

2:02:56Like an iPad mini?

2:02:58How different inside is it going to be?

2:02:59I would almost argue no, actually.

2:03:01I would argue it should be not like an iPad or an iPhone.

2:03:06Should be something different altogether.

2:03:08Hmm.

2:03:09Yes.

2:03:10So, when they were showing us last year the new window management in macOS for, not last

2:03:17year, this past WWDC, rather.

2:03:19Yeah, yeah.

2:03:19Which felt like a year ago.

2:03:21Yes, exactly.

2:03:22The smoothness, how in macOS 26 Tahoe, Windows can resize.

2:03:28And I was looking at that and I was like, if you miniaturize this, this would be an amazing

2:03:35open foldable experience.

2:03:37The way these windows can just move around so fluidly.

2:03:40It's not the way it works on iPad and certainly not the way it works on iPhone.

2:03:44Because that's another thing Apple does.

2:03:46You'll see them use something in one product and all of a sudden they'll use it elsewhere.

2:03:50Like the digital crown on the Vision Pro or the way when Vision OS launched, you can grab

2:03:55the window and drag it to resize it.

2:03:57And now that's how you do it on the iPad.

2:03:59Same way.

2:04:00With that little handle grabber.

2:04:02I was looking at the window management and thinking, this makes perfect sense for, if Apple were

2:04:09doing a foldable, I could see it working exactly this way, the way macOS is doing this.

2:04:13And that's what made me back then come to the questions like, I don't know what you would

2:04:18call it, iPhone fold or whatever.

2:04:19But it seems like it's an opportunity to define a whole new category rather than this is an extension

2:04:25of the iPhone or this is a mini, you know, iPhone, iPad fold or whatever it might be.

2:04:30Would they actually come up with something new to call this thing?

2:04:36Maybe I haven't played around.

2:04:37I don't have an iPad mini in the house anymore.

2:04:40And I kind of wish I did to see how iPad OS 26 windows work on such a small screen and in

2:04:48a practical way, because no matter what, even if the effective screen real estate of this

2:04:54hypothetical next year, iPhone 18 fold is roughly around the same area of an iPad mini.

2:05:00I just cannot, there's no way they're going to add windows with red, yellow, green buttons

2:05:05to iOS on iPhone where you can drag them to any size you want.

2:05:09I just don't see them doing that.

2:05:12And so therefore, I think they probably are very in a good place with calling iPad OS and

2:05:20iOS different things and making them more different.

2:05:22But obviously they've got to come up with something then.

2:05:26This is the conundrum, right?

2:05:28iPad OS has ways now, new ways that are better than ever for putting multiple apps side by

2:05:35side on the screen.

2:05:36Windows, side by side, you could do tiling.

2:05:38They're going to have, if they're not going to bring that to the foldable phone, then what's

2:05:44the foldable phone going to do for side by side?

2:05:46Something new, right?

2:05:48Right.

2:05:48Exactly.

2:05:49Right.

2:05:50And the one that they had for iPad OS for the last six, seven years sucked.

2:05:58But I kind of feel like Apple is seeing this, right?

2:06:01I think like everybody at Apple is like, they're not going to say it, but I think they're going

2:06:05to say, yeah, it did kind of suck.

2:06:06And they're like, we don't want to bring that to the iPhone because the iPhone is the flagship

2:06:09product of the company.

2:06:10So they're like, all right, how about this?

2:06:12We'll give the iPad Mac style window management.

2:06:16And that's been, it is truly a success.

2:06:18It is definitely better than any kind of putting more one app on a screen thing that they've

2:06:23ever done before for iPad.

2:06:25I don't think it's perfect, but it's, they're on there.

2:06:27I think they're definitely on the right track with iPad OS 26.

2:06:30And it gives them free reign to do something else for split screen on iOS next year with

2:06:37the foldable.

2:06:37I think that this is what, you know, why was the iPad doing weird things in hindsight with

2:06:43side by side for years?

2:06:45I think it's because their HI designers were thinking there has to be something, you know,

2:06:51the tiled windows came out in the seventies at Xerox park and were popularized in the eighties.

2:06:56There's got to be something better, especially for touchscreens, right?

2:06:59This isn't a mouse pointer screen.

2:07:01It's a touchscreen back to the drawing board, right?

2:07:04That they, they got five, six, seven, eight years of trying something with iPads and it

2:07:10led to a dead end.

2:07:11And they were like, all right, let's throw that out.

2:07:13But if they had ideas from the last few years of, oh, I wish we had done it this way with iPad.

2:07:20Now they have a chance to do it with iOS.

2:07:22Yeah.

2:07:23I don't know what they would call it.

2:07:24I don't think they'll call it a new OS.

2:07:26I just think that iOS will have in the same way that back when iOS was running on iPhones

2:07:34and iPads, it had different capabilities on the two platforms.

2:07:37It'll just have different capabilities on the foldable one that the other ones don't have.

2:07:41Yeah, it'll have to.

2:07:42The other thing that foldables do that I would expect Apple does too, is it's not just the

2:07:47side by side or the full screen on the inside.

2:07:50There's also a mode where if you fold it halfway closed, now you have almost like a laptop form

2:07:55factor.

2:07:55Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah.

2:07:56Like an L.

2:07:57Right.

2:07:57Exactly.

2:07:57What will your apps do when they're in that way?

2:07:59Because there's a lot of apps that have the folded interface.

2:08:02So you open it all the way.

2:08:04They have one interface.

2:08:05You have it on the front screen closed.

2:08:06They have a different interface.

2:08:07And they have a third interface when you have it partially folded.

2:08:10You might set it up as a selfie camera that the bottom is your touchpad and the top is

2:08:14where you can see yourself, for example.

2:08:16So it is going to have to be different.

2:08:18Right.

2:08:19And you don't need a third party easel or whatever to prop it up on a counter while you eat lunch

2:08:26and watch a horizontal video.

2:08:28Right.

2:08:29Yeah.

2:08:29So you have your horizontal video and then your video controls at the bottom, for example.

2:08:32Right.

2:08:33So they don't cover the video.

2:08:35Right.

2:08:35Yep.

2:08:35So it's going to be very interesting.

2:08:37Man, that's probably the device I'm most excited to.

2:08:40Just Apple's take on a foldable.

2:08:42What are they going to do differently?

2:08:44I hate the thing, and I know we're doing it right here, and that's why I'm mentioning it.

2:08:48And I do think that all of the rumor specialists, from Gurman to Mai Jinbu to Ming-Chi Kuo,

2:08:58it's part of the, if rumors of Apple stuff are your main racket, every year it's like clockwork.

2:09:07But come the beginning of August, they stop talking about what's coming in September.

2:09:13Although Mai Jinbu, who's clearly juiced into the retail slash supply chain with these things,

2:09:20like I was just looking right here while you were talking at his website with this crossbody strap,

2:09:25he's obviously juiced into these products coming out of the factories, and he's got photos of these straps.

2:09:33But for the most part, the rumor guys start focusing on next year before this year happens.

2:09:40And it's every year.

2:09:42And so I guarantee you, like, if you think right now the most exciting thing coming on the horizon

2:09:48is the foldable iPhone 18 coming in September next year, I guarantee you, in August of next year,

2:09:54it'll all be about whatever's coming the next year, not the foldable that's coming.

2:09:59Well, Gurman started that this year, though.

2:10:02He's already talked about the 2027 one.

2:10:05It happens every year, and it's the nature of the game because the rumor game is effectively about,

2:10:15and I'm not trying to be judgmental here, but I am a little.

2:10:19The rumor game is mostly to go Don Draper Mad Men on it.

2:10:24It's about creating an itch you can never scratch.

2:10:28It's about describing things you cannot buy right now that are really cool.

2:10:33Yeah.

2:10:34And talking about what Apple's going to announce in 13 days or 12 days or whatever it is from when this episode comes out

2:10:42can't do that because that's all stuff that before this podcast episode is stale, you will be able to buy, right?

2:10:51The whole rumor game is about itches you can't scratch, and the iPhone 17 lineup and the iPhone Apple Watch Series 11

2:10:59and I hope the AirPods Pro 3 are itches that we're all going to be able to scratch by the end of next month.

2:11:07And the thing that I get a little judgy about is I feel like when you hyper-focus on the rumors of what's coming a year from now,

2:11:15always, or maybe it's like getting all Yoda, right?

2:11:19Eyes on the future you've always had, whatever the hell he said to Luke.

2:11:22But never your mind on the present, where you are, what you are doing.

2:11:27There's so much interesting stuff about the tech you can buy and use and that's in your pocket or whatever device you're using to listen to me and Andrew talk right now.

2:11:35There's so much.

2:11:36I learn stuff, new features that you can do all the time, right?

2:11:40It's so much more, to me, satisfying to focus on the present than the future.

2:11:47Even, you know, I mean, but come August, you kind of have to talk about what's coming in September a little.

2:11:51And the other thing, too, I think Gurman hyper-emphasizes, because it fits into the Bloomberg narrative of making the stock move,

2:11:59which is how Bloomberg reporters are rewarded financially.

2:12:03It's not about making a stock go up.

2:12:05It's not about making it go down.

2:12:07It just has to go up or down in the five minutes after it's published when the Bloomberg terminal users can,

2:12:13who pay $20,000 a year for the things, can make trades based on news before it hits the open wire for everybody else.

2:12:20I don't think it's only about that, but it's partially about that.

2:12:24And that's why they always emphasize, every single time, and they say, you know, like if a story comes out at 9.00 a.m. Eastern time,

2:12:35it'll be updated at 9.11 a.m. Eastern time with a paragraph, four paragraphs down,

2:12:42that say Apple stock is up 3% in early morning trading based on this news.

2:12:48Because it's telling people, hey, if you had had a Bloomberg terminal that cost $20,000 a year,

2:12:53you'd have known about this news that made Apple stock move 3% five minutes before everybody else.

2:12:59And it's, you know, so that the, hey, here's how Apple's going to reinvent the iPhone over the next three years.

2:13:09It seems true that there's going to be more changes and less, hey, this phone, these years, this year's phones look like last year's phones than ever before.

2:13:20But I think that's inevitable after a couple of years of them looking the same, right?

2:13:25I think there's a narrative he's trying to add to it that they need to reinvent it, which is really just the inevitability of change.

2:13:32I think it's interesting, and I think it's a more interesting series of three years than, say, the iPhone 12, 13, 14 years.

2:13:42Yeah, or really any three.

2:13:44Like, if you think of any three years in a row from Apple, they've never had three different form factors three years in a row.

2:13:52At the very least, they would hang on to one for two years back in the S days.

2:13:56Right.

2:13:58I think the foldable, though, is the first one that's a true reinvention, just because of the nature of the screen, if it's really true.

2:14:04Which would, and the only one to compare it to would be the iPhone 10, right, which got rid of the home button and added a whole new metaphor for how you manipulate the system from swiping up from the bottom.

2:14:15Got rid of the chin and the forehead on the front face and went to the round corners and more or less set the paradigm for how iOS works till this day.

2:14:25Right.

2:14:26That was a reinvention.

2:14:28The foldable, in a way, would have to be a reinvention, by definition, right?

2:14:31It's just the nature.

2:14:32Reinvention, but for a much, much smaller segment of the market than the iPhone 10 was.

2:14:37But then the year after that, the all-glass, quote-unquote, all-glass phone.

2:14:43But, you know, even if it's a hit, let's say the iPhone foldable is a smash hit.

2:14:48Okay.

2:14:48Next year's is not going to be a smash hit, right?

2:14:51The year after?

2:14:53Well, if it is-

2:14:54Oh, you mean the fold, the follow-up to the fold.

2:14:56Right, like maybe 5% of all iPhones sold next year are the foldable 18s.

2:15:01There's going to be some segment that's going to say this is a flop, right?

2:15:04And then the next year, it'll be 8%.

2:15:09And then next year, it's 14%.

2:15:11And then four years later, it's like one-third of all iPhones are the foldables, right?

2:15:16And they're the most expensive and the highest margin, and half the revenue for iPhones comes from the foldables.

2:15:24And nobody who called it a flop after the first year when it was 5% is going to go back and say, oh, I was wrong about that.

2:15:31Of course.

2:15:32Right.

2:15:33As it always goes.

2:15:34Right.

2:15:34My favorite example of that is Apple Pay, where a year after Apple Pay came out, there were so many articles saying, yeah, this stupid thing where you tap to pay with your iPhone.

2:15:42You can't do it anywhere.

2:15:44It's a dud.

2:15:45And it's, yeah, nobody's better than Apple at playing the long game.

2:15:50Yes.

2:15:50Like when they know they're on to the right track.

2:15:52So I kind of feel like as much as people are arguing now Apple's late to foldables, I think Apple will come out next year, and it's still kind of early.

2:16:00And it won't, even if it's a success and sells as many as Apple thinks it should sell, it won't be that many compared to total iPhones.

2:16:08Of course.

2:16:10But if it's a good idea, 10 years from now, we might all be using them.

2:16:13I agree.

2:16:14And we'll look back at that first iPhone 18-fold and say, oh, my God, look how thick it was.

2:16:19Right, right.

2:16:20The same way we do now with Samsung.

2:16:21Right.

2:16:22Yeah, exactly.

2:16:23Right.

2:16:23They're way thinner than they used to be.

2:16:25All right.

2:16:26I'm going to call that a wrap.

2:16:28Andrew, it was awesome to have you on the show.

2:16:30And I love this when I have somebody on the show and I can say this.

2:16:33I will see you soon.

2:16:34Yes.

2:16:35Yes.

2:16:36About a week and a half.

2:16:37Yep.

2:16:38Where can people find you online?

2:16:41Your YouTube channel is at Andrew, A-N-D-R-U.

2:16:46Yes.

2:16:46So it's really easy to find me, but also very difficult, because it's

2:16:50easy because it's at Andrew, A-N-D-R-U, but it's hard for people to remember that.

2:16:54So when they try to find me, they're putting in the typical spelling.

2:16:58So if you look up A-N-D-R-U on Instagram or Threads or YouTube, that's my main thing is

2:17:03just making videos about tech.

2:17:04You can find me there.

2:17:06Do you ever thank your parents for naming you in a way that it's way more likely you can

2:17:10get the username Andrew than if it had the E-W at the end?

2:17:13I have made that.

2:17:15I do like having a unique name.

2:17:18Anytime I call customer service, for example, and I have to spell my name, I would say maybe

2:17:2375% of the time, oh, I've never seen it like that.

2:17:25That's interesting and cool.

2:17:26It's just, I don't know.

2:17:27I like it.

2:17:28It's a really good unusual spelling, though, because it's five letters, A-N-D-R-U.

2:17:33So you don't, it's not like when your name is Stephanopoulos, you know, and it's like, ah, you know.

2:17:38Right, right.

2:17:39Or if it was like A-N-D-R-E-A-U-X or something, like, why did you do that?

2:17:43Yeah, exactly.

2:17:44Right.

2:17:45Or like Elon Musk's kid who's got, like, Roman numerals in the name or whatever.

2:17:49Yeah, so you've got at Andrew on threads.

2:17:54You also, you write a site, Circuit Breaker, at Beehive, Andrew, spelled A-N-D-R-U, dot Beehive, dot com, which is B-E-E-H-I-I-V.com.

2:18:05Yeah, that's a real crazy one.

2:18:06Yeah, nothing's spelled correctly in that URL.

2:18:08Yeah, but just search for Andrew Circuit Breaker and you'll find it.

2:18:12And, of course, your Geared Up podcast, where I had the pleasure of being a guest earlier this year.

2:18:17Geared Up, and that's on YouTube, just Geared Up at YouTube, right?

2:18:21Is that the best URL for Geared Up?

2:18:22Yep, just YouTube.com slash at Geared Up.

2:18:25At Geared Up.

2:18:26All right, thanks, Andrew, and I will see you soon.