0:00:00Dan Moore and welcome to the show. I'm sure you can hear it. I have a cold.
0:00:04You and Frank Sinatra.
0:00:06Yes. And I do not mean to complain. I have had, it's been quite a September and October for me
0:00:14personally, but the cold is the least of my problems. But when you're a podcaster, it really
0:00:19sucks.
0:00:19It's kind of a, you got to play while hurt.
0:00:21Yeah, exactly. Yeah, but when I'm writing, it's like one of the many things I prefer about writing.
0:00:26I mean, I always say, number one, you don't need to take a shower, right?
0:00:31Some people find it helps not to take a shower. You kind of marinate a little bit.
0:00:34Right. And I still do an audio only, no video podcast. So as you can tell, my hair is disheveled.
0:00:42It is, I have not had a shower yet today, but your voice, you can't help.
0:00:45Yeah. Can't do anything about that.
0:00:47The other thing I use underscores sleep plus plus app for sleep analysis. And I've been wearing
0:00:54Apple Watch to sleep. Not religiously. It's like, because I don't want to get obsessive
0:00:59about having a sleep score for every night. Yeah. But my last two nights have the sleep
0:01:08score from sleep plus plus has been absolutely abysmal. And I should look actually at Apple
0:01:13because Apple is giving a sleep score now too.
0:01:15Yeah. I actually have started doing this in the last month or so. I actually have a second
0:01:20Apple Watch because my main watch is a Series 7 and it does not last the day, much less overnight.
0:01:26But I happen to have another watch that's a Series 10 that's a loaner. And so I've been using that for
0:01:31sleep tracking. And I think what's fascinating, I've been using the Apple sleep tracking one. And I feel
0:01:37like the Apple sleep tracking one is more optimistic. The rates are almost always higher. And I feel good,
0:01:44like no matter what, maybe there's a placebo effect. It's like, I wake up, I feel kind of,
0:01:48oh man, I'm still kind of tired. I look at the sleep score. It's like, you got a 90. I was like,
0:01:51oh, great. And I sometimes look at sleep plus plus and it's, you got a 40. And I was like, jeez.
0:01:58Yeah. I'm seeing the same thing.
0:02:02I feel like underscore is like, I can't tell if he's just there to be like, let me bring you back down to
0:02:07earth or what the difference in their algorithms are. But they clearly have different approaches
0:02:12to that. So yeah. Apple gave me yesterday, a 79 high and today a 65. Okay. Okay. Sleep plus plus.
0:02:23And I, the cold really hit me Wednesday night. Sleep plus plus gave me a 20 out of a hundred yesterday
0:02:31and a 35 out of a hundred today. So yesterday was all the way in the red and today is 15 on sleep plus
0:02:38plus for last night. And I was like, I don't think I slept that badly. So I don't, I don't know what's
0:02:43happening there, but yeah. Well, anyway, I feel all right though. And it is funny though, to be able
0:02:48to measure it with a cold because I felt like, well, like my fear is that I'm going to be waking up all
0:02:54night, like stuffy waking up. And I'd kind of slept straight through and I think, well, that's good.
0:02:59And then I look at these numbers and I'm like, well, I, I think it, it, it sort of exemplifies
0:03:05the limits of a lot of these health tracking things, which is that does it, does it matter?
0:03:09Does it matter if your score isn't good? If you feel fine? I mean, I guess it's, it's reminding
0:03:15you you're inching ever closer to the abyss. So there's that, but I don't know that that actually
0:03:21helps anybody. Maybe, maybe some people. All right, let's take a break here and I'll thank our
0:03:27first sponsor. Get it out of the way, right? It all, I love this sponsor. This is really good
0:03:31factor. Look, fall always feels like a reset between back to school, busier routines and shorter days.
0:03:37Finding time to cook can be tough factor steps right in here. Their chef prepped dietitian approved
0:03:44meals, make it easy to stay on track and enjoy something comforting and delicious. No matter how
0:03:49hectic the season gets. So with factor, you just, you order the food you want. They have a huge
0:03:55variety. It comes, it's pre-cooked. This isn't like a meal kit where you get ingredients and then you spend
0:04:0120, 30 minutes making dinner from the ingredients, which those things are great too. These are like
0:04:07pre-packaged meals that you can get very similar to the ones you get at like really nice supermarkets
0:04:11where you just put it in a microwave for a couple of minutes and you've got a nice meal ready to go.
0:04:17I think of them, they have breakfast. For me, factor is a big lunch thing where it's like, oh, I just pop
0:04:22upstairs from my office, put a factor in a microwave. Two minutes later, I'm eating a complete lunch. It's
0:04:27really great. They've got all sorts of stuff to choose from. Types of diets and stuff like that. They deal
0:04:34with allergies. They've got new stuff that they've added. GLP-1 friendly meals. Like if you're on those GLP-1
0:04:41weight loss drugs, they've got meals that fit that sort of metabolism. They have a new
0:04:46Mediterranean diet option packed with protein and good for you fats. And they've added Asian inspired
0:04:52meals with bold flavors influenced by China, Thailand, and more. 97% of customers say that
0:04:58factor help them live a healthier life. Feel the difference no matter your routine. I use factor.
0:05:03I think it's great. I not just because they sent me some free. I've started ordering stuff out of my own
0:05:08pocket because I like it so much. It's really good. So eat smart at factor meals dot com slash
0:05:16talk show 50 off. That's factor meals dot com slash talk show five zero off talk show 50 off. And as you
0:05:32might guess with that code, you'll get 50% off your first box plus free breakfast for one year. Get
0:05:49delicious ready to eat meals delivered with factor offer only valid for new factor customers with code
0:05:54So what do you want to do? You want to do the M5 stuff, which is sort of the big
0:06:02month news? Or do you want to do current events first?
0:06:05Ooh. Are there are there current events that are not bad current events?
0:06:10No, no. Okay, then let's do current events. Let's knock it out. All right. ChatGPT has announced
0:06:17there. Is this good or bad? I don't know. ChatGPT has announced Atlas, their long rumored web
0:06:23browser. I've used it a little for two days. Have you tried it? I haven't been like I saw it going
0:06:30around and I don't use ChatGPT a lot. And so it was not something that immediately appealed to me.
0:06:37And I saw Microsoft, I think, came out with their AI browser, like almost like the next day or something.
0:06:42I just maybe it's because I feel old. But like the idea of replacing my browsing,
0:06:48like this thing I've done on the internet for 25 plus years and to sort of rejigger how that works,
0:06:58it feels difficult for me. And I'm also I wouldn't say I'm a total AI skeptic. I acknowledge it has
0:07:04utility for things, but it has so many flaws for the kind of things that this seems to be using it for
0:07:10that I'm very hesitant to make it front and center in my web browsing experience. I've lamented recently
0:07:16that like Google has gotten so much worse, partially by injecting a lot of its own AI stuff.
0:07:22Yeah, Google search. Like I have, I will be looking for things and unable to find them in a way that I
0:07:28feel like 10 years ago, this was not a problem. And part of that is the content, right? Like there's
0:07:33just so much crap out there. And there's so much stuff that especially was written with like SEO in mind.
0:07:38And some of that is a larger issue about society, journalism, etc. But certainly their AI overview
0:07:44thing has had its fair share of problems too. And so that frustrates me enough that I'm not sure that
0:07:51I want to like willfully turn over my browsing experience to a chatbot at this particular time.
0:07:57I'm open minded. If I can, if someone can tell me why I would want to do this.
0:08:02So I was open minded, kind of. And I don't think they answered my main question is why would I want to switch
0:08:09from this from Safari, which has been my go to browser from forever at this point. And the browsers, I would if
0:08:18somebody said I was at some kind of legal injunction, and I was prevented from using Safari, I would look
0:08:25for the most Safari like browser. I actually like Kagi's Orion, which puts the tabs on the side, and they
0:08:32use WebKit as the rendering engine. And even some of the Chromium browsers, I guess Chrome itself would be
0:08:39on the list. It is basically just a web browser. That's what I want. I want a web browser.
0:08:44Yeah, right. Right. I've been using the web since Mosaic in 1993, 94. I don't know, somewhere around
0:08:51there. I think I'm pretty good at it. And that's what I want. But so why would I want to switch to
0:08:57something else? And I remember I tried Edge, Microsoft Edge, like a year ago, sometime in 2024, like when
0:09:06Microsoft seemed like they were tied to the hip with OpenAI and ChatGPT. And they had built in
0:09:14Copilot features, they called it. I forget if it was powered by ChatGPT. I don't know. It just,
0:09:20but it still, it looked like Microsoft Edge. And it was confusing. And it had all sorts of it was just
0:09:26very, very Microsoftian where there were lots of toolbar buttons. And now there's an extra sidebar on the
0:09:32right for chat with lots of buttons. And none of it was stuff I wanted. So it didn't stick at all. And I
0:09:39couldn't see any use point to it or use case. Yeah. I don't get it. Whereas I actually, and do use, I don't
0:09:47think I use it as much as many people, but I use ChatGPT in my work quite a bit. It's always open on my Mac
0:09:53now. I love that it's a native Mac app. And it's typically pretty easy for me. If I know I'm looking for a page
0:10:02that I have in mind on the internet or some page that I know must be a page, then I just do a web
0:10:10search. And I've for over two years, I think now I've been using Kagi instead of Google. And I typically do
0:10:16that on my Mac through launch bar. I have a launch bar action. I command space K for Kagi, hit return or
0:10:24hit space, type my search. And then it opens in a new tab in Safari with Kagi search results. And usually the top
0:10:31hit or one of the top hits is either the thing I knew I was looking for, or, Oh, I hadn't seen this
0:10:37article, but that's a good one. I'll open that one. And then if I have a question, I go to ChatGPT,
0:10:43right? Like it's not that I'm looking for a webpage. It's just that I have a question and ChatGPT is great
0:10:49at that. And I really like having it in its own app. It makes total sense to me. Like I don't want
0:10:55everything in my browser. I don't want, I don't want my email in my browser. I like having an app
0:11:00for my email. I don't want my chat in my browser. I like having separate apps for my chat.
0:11:05And it's literally right there in the name, ChatGPT. It's, it's a chat interface with an AI bot and you
0:11:15chat questions and get chat answers. And it makes total sense to me that it's in its standalone app,
0:11:21just like Apple messages or WhatsApp or something like that. So why I would want this in my browser,
0:11:27I don't know. So I tried Atlas and I have to say, I still don't know. I will give them credit.
0:11:36It is a much cleaner implementation. It's like sort of the opposite of Microsoft edge, right? It's just a
0:11:43very clean browser with just a field in the middle and you type, but right off the bat, I already don't
0:11:49like it because it's, you're typing in the box and is it the location field where you're pasting URLs
0:11:55or is it a chat? And the answer is yes. Yeah. It's both. It's all those things. Yeah. Right. I,
0:12:01I think the other thing for me is that I feel like Safari is so deeply integrated in so much of my
0:12:06experience on my devices. And the reason, one of the reasons I like Safari is because since it is
0:12:11Apple's browser, it is well integrated with the rest of the apps and the rest of the system.
0:12:15It is also there wherever I go, right? If I'm using my phone, my iPad, my Macs, it's always there.
0:12:22I have my tab groups and stuff like that. I can always get to that. And sure, chat GPT, I'm sure
0:12:26opening, I would love to be the, the sort of abstraction layer there and say, well, but you
0:12:30open chat GPT everywhere and you have all your stuff, but it's a lot of rewiring. It's a lot of
0:12:36figuring out like, am I going to go log into all my account websites in my chat GPT browser?
0:12:42I don't know. It feels weird and I can see why they're doing it. It feels kind of like
0:12:47Google with Chrome where they kind of want to insert themselves into that and tie you to their
0:12:53ecosystem. That makes sense, but I don't know if that serves me.
0:12:58I kind of feel, and by the time this episode of the podcast is out, I'll have something on
0:13:03Daring Fireball. I've got like the, the outline for a post on this where I'm linking mostly to other
0:13:08people's commentary. Anil Dash, friend of the show, who's been on the show. Maybe I should have
0:13:12him back on the show. Talk about this soon. But he had a good blog post about it and he calls it the
0:13:17anti-web browser. And I think he has a good case. And from the demo that the OpenAI team did showing
0:13:26Atlas, here, I'll just quote from Anil's post. In the demo for Atlas, the OpenAI team shows a user
0:13:32trying to find a Google Doc from their browser history. A normal user would type keywords like
0:13:37Atlas design and see their browser show a list of recent pages. They would recognize the phrase
0:13:41Google Docs or the icon and click on it to get back to where they were. But in the OpenAI demo,
0:13:46the team member types out in the chat box, search web history for a doc about Atlas core design.
0:13:56And as Anil says, this is worse than every conceivable way. It's slower, more prone to error
0:14:00and redundant. That is not how I want to find stuff. And I don't like using Google Docs, but I do use
0:14:06them occasionally. People send me stuff, sponsors or something like that. That is not how I want to
0:14:12find them. Right?
0:14:14Yeah.
0:14:15I fundamentally so much of my problems do come back to the AI, the fundamental natures of AI. I was
0:14:22doing, I do sort of puzzles as a, as a collaborative thing on occasion with some friends. And we were
0:14:29trying to solve one the other day. And it required like looking up some details and you're trying to
0:14:33sort through things. And I did this search in Google about like, oh, hey, the clue is something about
0:14:39French city in this region that also could connect somehow with an instrument. And it totally was
0:14:46like, oh, yeah, there's this chateau. It's known as the instrument because the bridge spans this river.
0:14:52Here's a link to the Wikipedia page. And I clicked on that link and it was all crap. It was made up.
0:15:00There was nothing there. Those words did not appear on that page. And I think there is still a world
0:15:06where, where these AI chatbots are so eager to prove that they can answer any question that you
0:15:13have, which of course ties in with so much of the hallucination problem that I, I am very wary of
0:15:19being like, well, I trust, I never trust the Google AI overview. I always scroll down to links still.
0:15:23And sometimes the AI overview is right, but sometimes it's not reliable enough for me to be willing to
0:15:30trust it.
0:15:31Do you use the, uh, UDM 14 if you're using Google?
0:15:35I have it. I have, yeah, I do have something like that or something else where Dave defaults to
0:15:40searching the web, but I like my, my wife loves the AI overview thing. She's always, well, it says
0:15:45right here. And I was like, please show me some link to something that is not this.
0:15:50And Google, they're famously A, B testers, A, B, C, D, E, F, G testers. So I'm sure people do use it,
0:15:57right? Like AI overviews.
0:15:59I'm sure they do.
0:16:00And I know that there's lots of studies showing or results from news publishers saying that traffic is
0:16:06dropping off from places that depended on Google search as a traffic funnel to their site, which
0:16:14I sympathize with, but not that much because I've, I don't know, 15, 20 years, I've never thought that
0:16:22was a good mindset to have as the publisher of a website.
0:16:28Well, it's like you're depending on an external source to prop up your business model. Moreover,
0:16:33it leads to bad habits like SEO. If Google is the only thing that matters, you write all your content
0:16:38to suit Google, which isn't a good solution either.
0:16:41Right. And it seems, yeah, it seems, and it's always seemed to, A, I don't even know which one
0:16:46to list first, but A, incredibly risky, right? Because, and here's the risk, right? Now we're
0:16:51seeing it where Google is suddenly not sending people away to read the stuff. They're summarizing
0:16:59for them and putting it right in the answer. And they just look at it, read it and close the tab
0:17:03and never go anywhere. But the other one that I was tempted to list first is just that it's a
0:17:08shitty way to make a website, right? Yeah. The right way to make a website is to appeal to actual
0:17:14humans. And I would say the same way for writing, let's say, like in your experience, a novel,
0:17:20right? Like, yeah, it's, yeah, I don't want to write for, for Google to find my novel. That would
0:17:27be very weird. I don't even know how that would work. I mean, there's people, you can't write for,
0:17:30people try to write for markets, right? They're like, oh, this is hot right now. I'm going to write a
0:17:34book that's this. And it mostly does not work. No. Mostly. Sometimes. But I don't think that
0:17:43writing for the web is all that different at a fundamental level than writing a novel, or it
0:17:51shouldn't be, where you're writing for human readers to read. Yeah. And yes, I do welcome,
0:17:58I'm sure that when I write a particular banger of a post, it gets read by people who don't regularly
0:18:05read me. Or like the, this year, the something is rotten in the state of Cupertino went pretty viral.
0:18:12I'm sure there were people who never even heard of me who wound up reading that one. And that's great.
0:18:17And that's how you get new readers. And maybe they're like, hey, this is, I never heard of this
0:18:20guy. Maybe they'll stick around. But for the most part, I'm writing for my regular readers. That's,
0:18:26that's who I've got in mind. And it, a seems like a path to a more fulfilling career.
0:18:33Yeah. Like, this is why I enjoy my work, as opposed to wake up and dread it. And it seems
0:18:40sustainable. And it doesn't seem as risky, right? Because there's no, hopefully, there's no
0:18:48intermediation between me and my readers. The Google reader fiasco of 2006 was the closest it
0:18:54ever came to a disruption, right? When Google, the most popular RSS reader, just, they just said,
0:19:02we're, we're closing the doors, deleting it.
0:19:05Because so many people didn't understand that it was based on RSS and thought Google readers gone,
0:19:12they didn't replace it with anything, right? They just stopped using that, because they didn't,
0:19:16they didn't know. So yeah, yeah. And you're just sort of we, we as the collective whole of the web,
0:19:22who had people reading our stuff through RSS through Google reader, or one of the things that made Google
0:19:28reader so great, was they had API's, so that other like net newswire could hook up to Google reader,
0:19:35and it was just sort of the sync engine API. And then you could go to work where you don't have a
0:19:40Mac and couldn't have used net newswire. And you could just use the Google reader web interface while
0:19:46you're at work at a PC or something, and then go home and the articles you read were updated and
0:19:51marked as read and net newswire. It was really great. And it just sort of broke people's habits.
0:19:56That's the problem. And they were like, Oh, yeah, I still want to read the same sites. But
0:19:59nobody, a lot of people just didn't want to do the the work of taking half an hour to reproduce their
0:20:06Google reader subscription somewhere else. Yeah. Well, I mean, it's always a challenge to you. I mean,
0:20:12the the, the industry has always struggled with trying to figure out in the the pivot to digital,
0:20:17how to, how do you make those relationships stick writ large, right? Like in terms of media,
0:20:23large media companies, of which how there are fewer than there were before. And there are ones that
0:20:29are not doing so well these days, sometimes because billionaires buy them and seem to
0:20:33want to drive them directly into the ground. But yeah, it is it is tricky when you are beholden to
0:20:38other interests. And I don't know that, that open AI replacing Google changes that other than it,
0:20:44it switches one intermediary for another and one that seems to be even less interested in in sending
0:20:50people to the originals. Yeah, exactly. And I just see it as and I think that's what one of the
0:20:57things Anil was getting at with calling it anti web, yeah, is, as much as we can complain about or some
0:21:05of us can complain about the AI results at the top of Google search results, you just have to scroll
0:21:12down to get the Google search results, right, right, right, they are still there. And, and they are
0:21:18presented visually differently. There's no, you could still do that. And so Google still is sending lots of
0:21:25traffic to places like it always has. And I'm not sure Atlas is designed that way.
0:21:30Yeah, which is it feels short sighted, too, right? Because it depends on the content being generated
0:21:36from those other places, right? Literally, deals to either deals or no deals, right? Either you're
0:21:43scraping it and not like making a deal with the publisher, or you're making a deal with the publisher.
0:21:48But sooner or later, if you are eliminating so much of the direct attention on those publications,
0:21:54they will have fewer writers, they will produce less content, and you will have less stuff to scrape.
0:21:59All right, it's like challenge there. It's like cutting down the entire forest to make paper as opposed
0:22:05to only cutting down trees at the same rate that the new ones you plant are, there's no sustainability
0:22:11to it whatsoever. Yeah. And it, like many bubbles, I think this is the way bubbles tend to work. There's a,
0:22:20we'll figure out the future later. Don't worry about it. Now, now, now, now, now, right? Yeah,
0:22:25just now. All that matters is now. I do think it's interesting. I think, I think if there's a
0:22:31critique I have of Anil's post, it's that he's too comparing chat as to the command line interface of
0:22:39the past and that the world switched to graphical user interfaces in the 90s and never looked back.
0:22:44I think, I think part of what makes chat GPT and all of its knockoffs, and effectively,
0:22:52they're all knockoffs of chat GPT. So effective is that, and again, it gets into critiques of
0:22:59certainly Siri, I think Alexa, and you could go all the way back to something like AppleScript and the
0:23:06English-like nature, which was a great intention, but didn't really work, as I've written about at
0:23:12length on Daring Fireball, where when you get an AppleScript that works, and then you give it to
0:23:19someone who doesn't really know AppleScript at all, perhaps, but they can read it and they can read it
0:23:24like English and kind of understand what it does. And that's not nothing, but when you're writing Apple
0:23:30Script, you have to get the ofs exactly right. The syntax exactly right.
0:23:35Jason Snell is my AppleScript mule. I don't write AppleScript. I just use AppleScripts he gives me.
0:23:41And then read them. But you can read them.
0:23:43I can read them. That's true. But if I need to change something or fix something, that is,
0:23:47it starts to get out of hand pretty quick.
0:23:49Yeah. And it's just all sorts of crazy little things like you have to use of instead of an
0:23:54apostrophe or S or something. There's so many little edge points where it's really is like real
0:24:00programming where you have to get the syntax just right. It's just that when you do,
0:24:03it comes out looking like English. And we've all made fun of Siri for 15 years about the ways that
0:24:09would sound completely natural to a human being who speaks English. And one of them works and one
0:24:22of them doesn't.
0:24:22It's bananas. We have a scene, a home kit scene in my house that my wife made, which is to like,
0:24:29we're watching TV or a movie or something. And it turns off basically everything except one lamp
0:24:34downstairs. And she will tell the home pod to set it. And it will just say, "There's nothing to stop
0:24:41here." And then I will rephrase and be like, "Set scene, blah." And it will be like, "Oh, sure." And it's
0:24:48just baffling. And ChatGPT broke through that problem. You can ask the same thing in any natural
0:24:57idiomatic way in English or whatever other languages ChatGPT supports, and you get the same answer. And it's
0:25:05a real breakthrough. And Chat turns out to be a great interface that human beings really thrive on.
0:25:14Everybody I know texts. Everybody.
0:25:17Right. I was going to say, sure, it's not the command line. The command line was arcane and esoteric.
0:25:22You had to know, like the Apple script, "All right, I'm typing this command, and then I'm using this
0:25:27switch, and then I'm using the input file and the output file, but I don't get them in the wrong order."
0:25:31But when you text with a friend, you don't worry about it. People spell things all sorts of ways,
0:25:36right? There's a whole jargon that's come up, but it doesn't ultimately matter. It's not like you're
0:25:40writing a formal letter. And so the fact that Chat mimics that, and you sort of are just like,
0:25:45it's like another person you're texting with, is a very, very big success.
0:25:50People are very adept at it. It comes naturally to them. As much as I kind of miss the golden age
0:25:56of email, where me and my friends would send very thoughtful... It almost feels...
0:26:01Civil War, Ken Burns is doing a voiceover. Yeah, like the 18th or even 17th century,
0:26:07where we're communicating with these things that are... You wouldn't be embarrassed at the
0:26:11end of your life to be compiled into a book. Here's my course.
0:26:14Please don't compile my texts at the end of my life. That will not look good for anybody.
0:26:19But we actually wrote thoughtful emails to each other on a daily basis. They may not be long,
0:26:25but they might have been short, but they were thoughtfully written. But texting, chatting,
0:26:30whatever you want to call it, appeals to way more people than email did. Like most people just
0:26:36weren't going to... It's not that they don't understand it. It's just that they're not
0:26:40writerly enough to want to engage in it.
0:26:45I'm fascinated too by it's cutting across various ages and stuff. Like my mom texts, my family, a lot
0:26:51of my family texts, people who probably otherwise maybe didn't write email or would check their email
0:26:56like once a week or something like 20 years ago. But they all text, they all have phones.
0:27:02My now 87-year-old, my now 87-year-old dad texts me. Doesn't text a lot. His texts aren't
0:27:09ready to be put into book form. But he never emailed me, right? Almost never. The best he would ever do
0:27:18is if he got a real banger of a joke from somebody, he'd forward me the joke.
0:27:22I had a cousin who for a while there would write his texts as though they were letters. Like he would
0:27:30sign them. And I'm like, yes, I know. I know who you are.
0:27:33Yeah. And my dad definitely has... He's gotten away from it though. He's picked up on it.
0:27:37Yeah. No, they learn.
0:27:39Yeah. And so the chat interface to ChatGPT is actually really great. It really is an interesting
0:27:46way to interact with the technology that they've developed. I don't think chat is a good way to
0:27:52interact with a web browser. I just don't. I don't think you should be typing commands. And so there,
0:27:58I really think Anil is onto something where the breakthrough was with the web in the 90s from the
0:28:04origin was that most of the quote internet of that era, you went through a terminal interface,
0:28:10you logged into your account at university or your ISP and you type command line things to get onto
0:28:18Usenet or you type command line things to go for, or you do your email there. And all of a sudden,
0:28:28you could just see things and move your mouse around and click on them. And in the same way that
0:28:34seeing things and moving your mouse around to click on things was a much better interface for word
0:28:40processing and spreadsheets and other early PC era productivity apps. Turns out it was a much better
0:28:48way of getting on the internet and finding things to read and making things for other people to read,
0:28:55the graphical user interface. And I just don't think chat is a good way. So why did they make it? And I
0:29:02really do feel like it's for them, not for us. And it's like they're trying to convince you and I'm
0:29:09stealing again from Anil here, but that they're trying to convince you that Atlas is an agent for you,
0:29:14but really you're the agent for ChatGPT where it's, oh, please let us have full access to everything in
0:29:21your private internet. Like where all of a sudden you're using Atlas to log into Gmail and there it
0:29:28is. And because you've got the chat window open on the side, now they can see an index. It's not,
0:29:33I'm not even saying they're using it for nefarious purposes or privacy invasive purposes that you're
0:29:40not aware of, but now they've got access to this context about you that they ordinarily wouldn't have
0:29:45because it's not on the public internet. You have to be gated.
0:29:49It's a little bit like what Google did in the earliest days by having Gmail and Google Reader and
0:29:55all of that. Like they could synthesize information about you. They could create a profile of you.
0:29:59They could just learn about you, right? And then they would know this stuff.
0:30:02And I wonder with ChatGPT and using this browser, whether this is like sort of the command line
0:30:09or the dial up access of the era, if this is a way station for them on the way towards something
0:30:15else. Because you mentioned the chat isn't a great way to interact with the web, but part of me also
0:30:20thinks, well, chat's not a great way to interact with a computer either, as we've already discovered,
0:30:25but that they want to be there. They want to be intermediating your relationships with all the
0:30:30other apps on your system, too, if they could. They would like to, because again, they can learn
0:30:35all this stuff about you. They can do all this interesting stuff. And we've seen a little bit
0:30:38of this stuff with the MCP protocol, right, where you can sort of wire together things. And there's
0:30:44some very interesting stuff to be done there. But I don't imagine that open AI is content to stop
0:30:50at the web. I think they would like to be your OS, your platform, I think, ultimately.
0:30:58And for the people who live their life in the web browser, and there's a lot of people who use Macs,
0:31:05who use their Mac that way, where they really kind of spend all day in their web browser,
0:31:09and their email is a tab in the browser. They use Google Docs or some other web-based
0:31:15thing as their productivity tool. And for those people, using Atlas as their browser is a way to sort
0:31:23of give them that, right? Where now it's sort of like, oh, we're sort of the OS. We're an OS in an OS.
0:31:31But effectively, if you're living your digital life, mostly or almost entirely in a browser,
0:31:37and you're using our browser, we've got access to everything you're doing.
0:31:41Yeah, exactly. Yeah. So I mean, I'm sure they'd like to get there. And maybe this is the stepping
0:31:45stone for them. But yeah, again, I don't know that it's something I'm... It's not a step I want to take,
0:31:51I guess.
0:31:51There are just things that I would like robots to do for me in general, whether they are robots that
0:31:57just live in my computer, like ChatGPT, or physical robots like C-3PO, who I would love it while I'm
0:32:04watching TV if a robot could go get me a drink from the fridge and bring it to me. I really would look
0:32:11forward to more and more automated driving. I don't really enjoy... Sometimes I enjoy driving,
0:32:18but for the most part, and if I had daily commute, man, it would be great if my car could just take
0:32:24me to work and I could safely dick around on my phone or catch up on email or something like I'm
0:32:29in an Uber, like a personal Waymo. That would be great. There are times when I want to drive because
0:32:35it's fun. And there are lots of times where I would like to be driven. That's great. Surfing the web is
0:32:41not something I want somebody else to do for me. I still enjoy using the web.
0:32:46Well, I see this a lot with the talk about the agentic AI, right? And oh, you'll go make your
0:32:52vacation plans for you or whatever. And I, again, I imagine there are some people for whom that is
0:32:58attractive, but I know people like my wife is another one who she loves. She wants to look at
0:33:02all the hotels. She wants to figure out the flights. She loves doing that. And so I guess it's there for
0:33:07for the people who want it and the people who don't want it, don't need it. But it is things
0:33:12where I find the, the shopping by agentic AI thing, most puzzling because I don't, I don't want it to
0:33:19decide. Like I want to at least, even if I come to the same result that it does, I want to feel that I
0:33:26have done the research and looked at the options and figure it out and know all the trade-offs and stuff
0:33:31like that rather than just being told, Hey, I did all that for you. And here's the thing you want.
0:33:35I don't get it at all. I really don't like, what are you buying that you don't want to choose for
0:33:43yourself? And there are so many ways that, I mean, I think, I don't know how long web browsers have
0:33:50sort of reached. And I don't think this is a knock against traditional web browsers. And I'll hold up
0:33:56Safari in particular as like a sort of icon or exemplar of just a traditional web browser. That's just a
0:34:05web browser, right? And it's got tabs and it has scriptability so that you can do things with
0:34:12Apple script or JavaScript that should to manipulate it. It has extensions, but it's just there for
0:34:18surfing the web and some of the features and it's, they've sort of reached the end state. It's, I think
0:34:25that's natural that it's like after it's so used, such a much used app and the idea of, Oh, like I
0:34:31remember back in the day, everything, there were no tabs. Everything you opened was in a new window
0:34:35window. Yep. And instead of having like a hundred tabs in eight or nine windows, I'd have a hundred
0:34:42windows. It wasn't great for performance. No, it was definitely not good for performance and it wasn't
0:34:46good for finding them. But like when you're searching it's, Oh, here's three or four, I'm looking for new
0:34:52shirts and here's three or four that I like open and tab, open and tab, open and tab. Now I've got each
0:34:57of the shirts that I'm looking at in their own tab and I look at them and I can see their availability and
0:35:03either put them in my cart or close the tab and then I'm done. And I feel like I've gotten what
0:35:08I want. I don't want somebody else to do that for me. I don't know why, I don't know why this is
0:35:14presented as a use case. This is a, because for some people, I guess it feels like a chore as opposed to
0:35:21something they're doing for fun. But I mean, I guess if I were like, Oh, I need new jeans. Like
0:35:28you could look at my history of like where I bought my jeans or whatever and what my size is and all
0:35:34that and just go, go buy them. But I also don't think that's saved much time compared to go, I go
0:35:39to Amazon and like, Oh, I bought those jeans six months ago. I'll buy another pair like bang. So I don't
0:35:44know. Maybe that's the Steve Jobs in me. Just buy the same jeans, same shirts, just keep rolling.
0:35:49I guess there is a thing. Obviously, schoolwork comes to mind where it's like you have this assigned
0:35:54book to read or chapters to read. And back in the day, it would be get the CliffsNotes and just sort
0:36:00of cheat your way by reading the summary of the thing instead of reading the thing. And now you can
0:36:06just ask one of these AI things to summarize it for you.
0:36:10I despair. I despair of it. I was in a coffee shop not long ago. And it's in an area with both a high
0:36:16school and a college. And a younger person came in and sat down next to me. I happened to glance over
0:36:23at their screen. And I watched as they literally copied a document from like Google Docs and pasted it
0:36:29at GPT. I was just like, Oh, boy. This is this is Oh, soon you won't even have to do the copying and
0:36:37pasting. It'll even do that for you. I don't know. It's it feels a little worrying. I don't want to come
0:36:41across too much as like kids these days. But it is a little disconcerting how how quickly it became
0:36:47like I have friends who are teachers. And they struggle with this all the time. People get kids,
0:36:51students college all the way down to elementary school generating their homework in in AI and stuff
0:36:57like that. And it's hard to find. There's no good tools, really, because all the tools themselves
0:37:02rely on AI. Right. But it's AI all the way down. It really is. This is robots checking robots.
0:37:07Yeah, it's AI detectives trying to find AI. We're all looking for the person who did this.
0:37:12But to me, a lot of the web browsing that they're presenting as use cases for agentic web browsing
0:37:19are things I enjoy. I read books to enjoy them. I don't want to read an AI generated summary of the
0:37:24book. I want to read the book. Yeah. So I don't really get it. And even for some of the agentic
0:37:30use cases, if you have a personal assistant, a real human being, and you need to get from California to
0:37:37New York for a conference or a meeting or something, and you could say, here's the dates, can you please
0:37:43take care of this for me? And you trust your human assistant to get you on the flight that they know
0:37:50which times a day you like to fly. They know which airline you have status on. And they'll take care
0:37:56of this stuff for you. That's one of the things personal assistants do. And AI could maybe serve
0:38:03that role or is already serving that role for everybody. But I don't see why you need that baked
0:38:08into the browser, right? Why not just use chat GPT, the app? I don't get it. I don't know. So
0:38:14anyway, long story short, I don't get it. And I think it's more for them, not for us. And pretty
0:38:21much done with my experiment with Atlas. Also, current events new moving on. There's, I don't think we
0:38:27have, I have much to say about this, but Apple lost a ruling, a landmark UK lawsuit over app store
0:38:35commissions. Here I am quoting from Reuters. Apple abused its dominant position by charging app
0:38:40developers unfair commissions. A London tribunal ruled on Thursday a blow in a blow, which could
0:38:46leave the US tech company on the hook for hundreds of millions of pounds of damages. The competition
0:38:50appeal tribunal CAT ruled against Apple after a trial, blah, blah, blah. The cat ruled that Apple had
0:39:00abused its dominant position from October 2015 until the end of 2020 by shutting out competition in the
0:39:06app distribution market and by, quote, charging excessive and unfair prices as commissioned to
0:39:12developers. I think there's other reports about this have said that there, if Apple unsurprisingly
0:39:19is appealing, they always appeal, right? Yep. Of course. Yeah. Take it as far as you can go.
0:39:25If they lose the appeal, they're on the hook for $1.5 billion in damages. And as I sometimes joke,
0:39:33hey, a billion dollars isn't that much to Apple, which just sounds ridiculous to say about any
0:39:38entity. But a billion here and a billion there, and all of a sudden you're talking about real money
0:39:44for anybody. Yeah. It is interesting to see as more of these cases seem to come across various parts
0:39:52of the world in different ways, but all kind of, I think, getting to the same issue, which is the app
0:40:00store. And the app store, I think, has long been their largest vulnerability in terms of just exposure
0:40:09to regulation. Nobody really seems to care very much about your iPhone. Like, they've tried attempts
0:40:14to be like, oh, the iPhone and Android, that's a duopoly, etc. It doesn't seem to hold a lot of water
0:40:19because people, there is a choice and people like their various phones. The app store, and I mean,
0:40:24we in the Apple community, especially those of our friends in the developer community, have long
0:40:30had bones to pick with the app store. They are not shy about it. And I think a lot of their concerns
0:40:36have been well-founded, and sometimes Apple addresses those concerns. But fundamentally, at the end of the
0:40:40day, we still have this issue where the company controls all means of distribution on iOS, which is
0:40:47one of the largest platforms in the world. I think that's going to become more and more tenuous,
0:40:53it seems, between stuff like the DMA in Europe, other various countries like, I think, Japan and Korea,
0:41:00too, have taken shots at this. At what point does it become, like, cut your losses? I mean, like,
0:41:06Apple wants to hold on to this, and they want to make as much money. And right now, if they haven't
0:41:11seeded that, it's because they think, even with all the lawsuits, they will still do better controlling
0:41:16the app store every place they can than letting open the floodgates. But that'll change eventually.
0:41:22At a certain point, if this keeps, if this wave continues in this direction, if they lose this appeal,
0:41:27if they lose the stuff that they've challenged in the DMA and the European courts now as well,
0:41:31they're going to have to make some changes. And I think the smart move potentially would be to
0:41:36have more of a competitive angle about it. In the same way Steve Jobs got up years ago when they
0:41:42introduced the iTunes store and said, we can't eradicate piracy, but what we want to do is compete
0:41:47with it. And they made it so attractive to go and buy your songs for a dollar or your albums for 10
0:41:53bucks that I don't want to trawl Napster and LimeWire to try and find something that may not
0:41:58even be what I want. And it sounds bad, and it's broken and all that.
0:42:02Bad metadata attached to the files.
0:42:04Exactly. Dubious metadata.
0:42:06Yeah, I remember songs that were just like, not at all the song that you like.
0:42:10Right.
0:42:10Anyways, is there a point where they start competing by saying, well, okay, let's cut
0:42:15the commission. I mean, they've done this already sort of with the small business program,
0:42:19but I feel like increasingly they may be under pressure to bring it down to even lower levels,
0:42:25even for people not in it. Or conversely, finding ways to be like, look, what we really want is to be
0:42:32getting a cut of money from the big players, your Spotify's, your Netflix's, etc. We don't care about
0:42:39anybody making an app for 1,000 people or even maybe 10,000 people. We care about the people make
0:42:46apps for millions of people. And those are like, we strike partnerships with them, for example. Do we
0:42:50take that approach? I don't know. But this feels, again, I think the other challenge is Apple is a
0:42:57global company. And we've seen this with a lot of their media plays, right? When they make a movie or a TV
0:43:04show, they've got the rights to it. They can send anywhere in the world. If you've got Apple TV, you can
0:43:08watch Slow Horses in Japan or Korea or China or whatever. At what point does it become too complex for
0:43:15them to manage all of these different rubrics and systems for different places? Obviously, they built that
0:43:22whole system in Europe, which has gone back and forth a number of iterations. There's the possibility that
0:43:27you'll see more countries saying, well, we want what they have in Europe. And they're like, well,
0:43:31we've already built it. We can roll it out in Brazil or Japan or whatever. But at what point does it
0:43:37become too annoying to try to be like, in every country, we have to worry about what are the specific
0:43:42app store rules? What are the commissions? And then they have to pass that on to developers who are
0:43:46distributing stuff internationally. It becomes very complex. And might they be served by letting go a
0:43:52little bit and thus making their lives easier and still being able to hold on to some revenue?
0:43:57I think it's not that complex overall. But I do feel that there's an aspect, an important bit of it's
0:44:06not. There's an important bit of it that is overlooked, either deliberately, or even by not really thinking
0:44:16hard enough about it or looking back far enough about it by the most strident of Apple slash App Store
0:44:24slash App Store, Google Play duopoly critics, which is that it's a very different scenario than most
0:44:37monopoly or near monopoly abuse cases where it's not like they built a monopoly and then turned the
0:44:46ratchet up on the commissions. The Cory Doctorow term in shittification, it hasn't gotten in shittified.
0:44:54They haven't made the App Store worse. And I think that's where, in terms of what in the world is Apple
0:45:01thinking, and we in the Apple commentariat have been talking about this for at least five years, but in some
0:45:09ways longer, of why doesn't Apple, why can't, it seems so obvious to us that heavy-handed regulatory
0:45:16scrutiny, fines of some significant nature, right? This is 1.5 billion pounds. It converts to $2 billion.
0:45:25Again, it's not going to bankrupt Apple, but it adds up. It's a PR disaster, right? Every single one of
0:45:34these cases around the world, it's Apple's always on the losing end now. When's the last time that they
0:45:39won one of these regulatory scrutiny things, right? The whole EU, now the UK, Japan, Australia, I think,
0:45:48is looking into it for something similar. They're on the wrong end of it every time, and it adds up,
0:45:53right? The headlines, you keep getting it repeated. Apple's losing, Apple's losing,
0:45:58when the government, you know, democratic governments are holding them, finding them to be
0:46:04abusing their position. But they haven't changed anything. And that's to explain why has, what is
0:46:10Apple not seeing? And I think it's that they've got tunnel vision on the fact that they haven't
0:46:15changed it. It's always been 70-30. The only ways they've changed the 70-30 split are in the favor
0:46:22of developers, right? Where for subscription pricing, after the first year of 70-30, it goes
0:46:28to 85-15. They've added the small business program sometime in the last five years, where if you're
0:46:34a developer with under a million dollars in revenue through the App Store in a year, you can apply for
0:46:40this program and start with an 85-15 split. They've only moved it in that direction. But the world has
0:46:48changed, right? That's the clear thing. The App Store's centrality to... And the duopoly,
0:46:54the complete duopoly that the App Store and Google Play Store have over digital good purchases through
0:47:01mobile phones is as near a complete duopoly as you're going to get. There are... I mean,
0:47:08how many people does anybody listening to this podcast know who either don't use a phone or use
0:47:15a phone that doesn't use Apple's App Store or the Google Play Store for purchases? I don't know
0:47:21anybody. I know that they exist, that there are like Linux-based alternatives. Sure. Right? You can set
0:47:28up a Google-free Android phone. I don't know, personally, anybody who uses such a thing.
0:47:33Nobody. And it's... So basically, what I think government bureaucrats and politicians around
0:47:42the world are looking at is they just see it. And they are as technically inept and as bad as they
0:47:47are at product design, because they're politicians and bureaucrats, not product designers. They're
0:47:52correct about the fundamental issue that this centralized aggregation of power and taking a
0:48:0215% to 30% slice off all this commerce of everything going through everybody's phones isn't tenable
0:48:09as the way that our society should work. Right. And for Apple's part, I mean, there's a few challenges,
0:48:17right? I mean, Apple's argument in the earliest days was we want to be safe and secure and make
0:48:23sure apps are good citizens and make sure your phones work well. And I think that's all laudable.
0:48:28They've struggled with it. And some of that is just a matter of scale, right? There is so much stuff
0:48:34on the App Store. They miss stuff. We know they do frequently. It gets pulled sometimes. But like,
0:48:39you just had that article this past week about the T apps. Yeah, yeah.
0:48:42Pulled months after it was widely reported how bad these apps were. Right. But you flip side that
0:48:47with the control issues too, right? I mean, we've talked about all the ICE apps. They were in a
0:48:51position where there is no alternative to the App Store. And so if they remove something, it is
0:49:00functionally not there. It is not a thing that you can get, right? Because there is only one channel.
0:49:06And that makes them responsible in ways that maybe they could argue internally. They don't want to be,
0:49:13right? Like they maybe don't want to be in a position of removing those kinds of apps, but they
0:49:19have to because there is no alternative. That is a challenge as well. I think I hesitate to be too
0:49:26mercenary about this, but I've written about this a bunch. They are a corporation. They are a corporation
0:49:30that is designed to make money. And I think part of me wonders, yeah, maybe they have tunnel vision
0:49:37about feeling like they're doing a good job of regulating this system. But I also have to imagine
0:49:43that somebody is running the numbers and saying like, well, 2 billion here, a billion there. Yeah,
0:49:47it's real money. But like our revenue from services based on the App Store is still 4 billion. I mean,
0:49:53it's better. 2 billion of profit is better than nothing. I don't know. I mean,
0:49:56someone in there has got to be doing some calculations. Well, and I think that's the
0:50:00incongruity with Apple in particular, where Apple's never been that company. And they say it and they
0:50:06mean it in so many different ways that they don't mean to make the most money. They mean to make the
0:50:12best products and then make as much money from making the best products as they can. And if that means
0:50:17they make the most money, which they have with the iPhone, so be it. But the driving motivation is to
0:50:24make the best product they can and then make a profit from it. Not the other way around.
0:50:28The App Store has always been the one that felt like it didn't fit with that from the earliest
0:50:33days of them saying, remember when they first launch subscriptions and the like, taking a cut of
0:50:39subscriptions. There were many of us at the time who were like, really? You're going to take a cut of
0:50:44people's content that they're producing here? I think they've always struggled with this. If that is
0:50:50indeed their core identity, this part of it always is, as you said, incongruous. And I think
0:50:55maybe part of their, they've had a bit of an identity crisis in trying to deal with,
0:50:59well, we love this because it does make a lot of money. And a lot of that money is free,
0:51:04quote unquote. But does it fly in the face of their corporate culture? I mean, Steve Jobs was no stranger
0:51:11to saying, these people are making their money off the backs of our products and we want to cut
0:51:16it because we feel like we deserve it. The best time to walk away from the money train of the App
0:51:21Store was long ago. And I know that the adage is, it applies in so many aspects of life that the best
0:51:27time to do something was in the past. And the second best time is right now, right? The second best time
0:51:33to do it would be starting now. But the big, in this case, it's a real difference because to back away
0:51:39from this, they'd have to walk away from money they're already making. Right. And that's, that's
0:51:43a problem. And Apple isn't, none of these companies, all of the major companies have sort of learned
0:51:50their lesson from the Jack Welch GE era of the nineties of having these, the biggest corporations
0:52:00in the world truly treat their shareholders as the primary thing to run the company around and just
0:52:07thinking about the stock price and making shareholders happy. Yeah. None of these companies
0:52:11are, and the newer ones starting with Google have set themselves up with unique stock structures
0:52:19where the public shareholders don't even really control the company. And Apple is not pretty,
0:52:25Apple doesn't have that sort of stock structure where the two founders of the company or in Meta's
0:52:30case, Zuckerberg personally owns a controlling share of a class shares that can't be outvoted.
0:52:37Every single public shareholder of Meta can't outvote Mark Mark Zuckerberg on an issue, which is a,
0:52:43perhaps a dubious way to set up a publicly held corporation. But it, it, it, it still would be a
0:52:52problem though for Apple to say, we're going to purposefully make less money from the app store.
0:52:56Yes. But I, it still would be the right thing to do. And there's a way they don't have to come out
0:53:01and say that they could just say, we're doing these great things for customers and leave it as implicit
0:53:06that this might decrease the services revenue from the app store because it's going to happen one way
0:53:12or the other. And they can't keep hanging their hats on the fact. And I'll, I'll, I'll argue against you
0:53:20here where at the very inception of the app store, it really was completely pro developer and pro user
0:53:28where on mobile devices, everything went through the carriers, all the apps you got on any phone.
0:53:35If you had a Verizon Blackberry, you got apps from Verizon, not from Blackberry. And if you switch to
0:53:41AT&T, none of your apps worked anymore because now you're on a new carrier and your apps were all
0:53:46built through your Verizon account and the app sucked. Right. Yeah. And the ecosystem was bad. I mean, and
0:53:52they, they, they did as with the smartphone itself, they reinvented it and full credit where credit is due.
0:53:57And I think the problem is that that's a very different world from the world we live in now.
0:54:01And you, the developer get to keep 70% was incredibly generous. And again, I, I, Apple hasn't brought up
0:54:09the boxed software thing too recently, but even just sometime within the last five years,
0:54:15they've brought it up in some of these arguments and that's so antiquated. There's an entire generation
0:54:22of young adults who don't, who've grown up in this era. My son is 21. He's a senior in college. He was
0:54:28three when me and my wife got our first iPhones in 2007. So he doesn't really remember a pre iPhone
0:54:34world. He doesn't remember boxed software. It's certainly, and there never was box software for
0:54:40phones. There never was. And talking about like when you had to box up your software and print CDs and
0:54:45print paper manuals and go through Ingram micro as a middle, a wholesaler distributor, and that you'd be
0:54:53lucky if you got 10% of the retail price of the box software back. That's all true. And the 70 30 split
0:55:02was way better than the split. The carriers were giving the distributors of software for phones
0:55:06pre iPhone. But again, that's it. It's, it's that Steve jobs quote about, Hey, when you do something
0:55:13great, don't I'm paraphrasing, but you know, don't get too caught up thinking about it, move on to the
0:55:18next thing and make something else. Wonderful. It's time to give up on the fact that the 2007 or 2008
0:55:25original app store was a breakthrough and a, and a true win for developers and consumers and face the
0:55:35fact that things by, by 2015, which I don't know why the UK picked that as the starting date to look
0:55:41at, but certainly it's a good by 2015, the world was different in terms of the app stores take to what
0:55:47to, to, to credit to what, again, what they did, right? Like they are, they are a, in this case,
0:55:51a victim of their own success because they, they reinvented it and it did so well that it became
0:55:58the default, but it also, it also spotlighted all the problems with it because they got magnified,
0:56:06right? I mean, your point earlier about how Apple always seems like they're on the losing end
0:56:10of the PR when, when all these things come up. I mean, they're one of the most valuable companies
0:56:16in the entire world, or if not one of the most profitable companies in the entire world
0:56:20and their sympathy for them, much as people like their products, sympathy for them is not high in
0:56:27the court of public opinion. You're not going to find a lot of people shedding tears over a trillion
0:56:30dollar corporation. Definitely not. Even people who use a MacBook and iPad and an iPhone and have for
0:56:39the last 15 years and wear an Apple watch and, and like to just pop into their local Apple retail
0:56:47store just to walk around because they just kind of like it. Even those people like look at these
0:56:52fines and they're like, yeah, I don't have any sympathy for them. They can pay it.
0:56:55It's a tough thing too, just because I think what's difficult is, and I mean, you've written about this
0:57:00too, but like the relationship of the customers with Apple versus customers with developers,
0:57:06developers with Apple, like that whole triangular relationship is very tricky because you see a
0:57:11lot of customers. Customers don't feel the pain here necessarily, right? You're not sitting there
0:57:16buying your apps for two or $3 and thinking, my God, how could these prices be so bad that you don't,
0:57:23and you don't know, right? Most people don't know how much money goes to the developer, how much
0:57:27money goes to Apple. We know because we're in the, we're in this sphere, but like the average person
0:57:31on the street has no idea how that split breaks. No, so many people think developers work for Apple,
0:57:36right? Yes, exactly. I mean, I can't, I'm sure it's the same thing with you. I've lost track of the
0:57:41number of indie developer friends who, when they tell people, oh, I make apps for the iPhone and they
0:57:45say, oh, so you work for Apple. People used to say that about me when I worked at Macworld. Oh,
0:57:49you work for Apple. No, I don't work. Right. People don't understand, but yeah, it's a different,
0:57:56it's a different. And so like the customers aren't in a position necessarily to complain because they
0:58:00don't feel ill used. And most of them aren't even going to think about if they could go to another
0:58:04app store, right? They're like, no, let's just go to the app store and you install it. What do you
0:58:07mean? Because most people aren't downloading software from the web and they were in the way they were maybe
0:58:1215 years ago when you would, maybe more people using computers were comfortable downloading
0:58:18software to the web. But now everything is app stores, whether it's Apple or Steam or whatever,
0:58:23like you're used to downloading stuff through a storefront and it's associated with the platform
0:58:29in many cases. And I think that they just don't, they don't see the impact. Like it's the developers,
0:58:35unfortunately, are the ones who get squeezed. I'm talking out of my ass here a little, but
0:58:39just think back to like when automobiles were a new thing and it's like, there were no traffic laws
0:58:47based on automobiles because they would just been invented and it would be like some,
0:58:51some family in your neighborhood. You hear about Dan, Dan, the Morin's bought a car. They bought
0:58:55an automobile. Holy hell. Let's go see it and go over and there's Dan Morin cranking the thing on
0:59:03the front of the car to start it up. And it's a, yeah. And you'd be like, Hey John, you want to take
0:59:06a ride in my automobile? And I'd be like, sure. And then we'd go driving down the dirt road and passing
0:59:12the people on the horses and stuff. And they'd be honking your horn with the old timey honk.
0:59:17And there's no laws. There's no seatbelts. There's no headlights. There's nothing. Yeah.
0:59:22Yeah. Yeah. There's no regulations about the safety of the thing. There's no regulations for how you deal
0:59:28with the intersection. And then at some point between there where it was a novelty just to know somebody
0:59:34who bought an automobile in the way that it was a novelty to know someone in 2007 who had the original
0:59:40iPhone. And I remember going to Whole Foods and I have my shopping list in the, what was it? Ta-da list
0:59:45from, from 37 signals where my wife and I could, it was fucking great. We had a shared shopping list
0:59:52where we could both add items. And there I am checking these things off and people just random
0:59:57strangers would say, is that an iPhone? And I'd be like, this is the downside of having this.
1:00:03Right? You couldn't even put it in a fake case those days because there's nothing else.
1:00:08The upside is I felt like I was living in the future where I had this cloud synced shopping list
1:00:15that my wife and I had shared access to. And the downside was every other time I went, I'd have to
1:00:20talk to a stranger about the iPhone. To today's world where literally everybody has an iPhone or
1:00:27an iPhone-like phone, right? There's something changed in between 2007 and now. And something
1:00:32changed with the automobile between 1907 and at some point in the middle of the 20th century where
1:00:37everybody, every, the whole country had been, and big parts of the world, automobilized, right?
1:00:45And of course there were going to be things like traffic regulations and speed limits and
1:00:50safety regulations, right? It started, which, which were put off for way too many decades,
1:00:55right? Of course that was going to happen. And it's what, what would you, what was better for
1:01:01the car makers? Was it better for the government to specify all this stuff or should they have gotten
1:01:06ahead of the curve and done the safety stuff on their own? And I think for Apple, it's clearly,
1:01:12this is what we've been, it's not, Hey, the app store started as a crooked, bad deal. It started
1:01:17as a great deal and a breakthrough, but something it's clearly changed and the world is different.
1:01:22And the role that the app store, the Apple's app store plays in the world of digital commerce is so
1:01:28big that of course governments are going to look at it. And of course they're going to just look at it
1:01:34and say 30% seems like way too big a cut for something that there is no option not to use.
1:01:39And it's that simple. And it doesn't matter if it was a great cut 20 years ago or 15 years ago,
1:01:46or a fair cut 10 to 15 years ago. At this point, they look at it and say, this is not fair. And
1:01:55Apple can solve it themselves. And really not like a tweak, not like a little nudge, but do something
1:02:02fairly radical to open it up from Apple designed by Apple that is designed with the intention of
1:02:09assuaging these concerns from government regulators and politicians around the world and issuing it
1:02:16globally and saying here, this is our vision for the next few decades of the app store. And it has a lot
1:02:21of choice and it does it removes the centrality of our position to skim off the top financially of
1:02:29everything. Or the government regulators and politicians are going to design it and define it
1:02:36themselves, right? There is no other option because the starting point of the government regulators and
1:02:41politicians saying this current situation is untenable is not going to change. So either Apple can find a
1:02:49solution that's going to douse all these fires around the world, or we're going to get stuff
1:02:55like the DMA, which in my opinion is well-intentioned, right? That's the thing that when people get mad at
1:03:00me for my anti-DMA stance, I'm not arguing with the starting point intention of it. I'm arguing only
1:03:07against the actual implementation details of it, which are terrible, but it's inevitable. It's one or the
1:03:13other. Yeah, I think the real tipping point will be certainly, I mean, there's multiple cases in which
1:03:21it could arise, but the United States has so far not engaged on this. There's been the DOJ antitrust
1:03:28fail, but it didn't really touch the app store. It was about a whole bunch of other weird esoteric
1:03:33things. And this is not going to happen anytime soon. There's no appetite for this right now,
1:03:38certainly not in the administration where Tim Cook is, is buddy, buddy. He's funding a ballroom
1:03:43for our... But if it happens, it's not going to change. That DOJ case against Apple is still there.
1:03:53It's just dormant for the last post-Biden. I forget who's the president. But if there's a point where
1:03:57the US follows in the footsteps of the stuff that the UK and the EU and others have done and decides,
1:04:03hey, look, we looked at what all these other countries are doing. And even though Apple is
1:04:07an American company, and obviously we want to support American companies, we still think this
1:04:11is potentially unfair against developers who are also small businesses. At some point, that bill will
1:04:17come due. And the US is the biggest market for Apple. And so... Or I don't know if it's the biggest,
1:04:23but it's certainly the most significant market for Apple.
1:04:26They don't need this. And it's like going all the way back to the beginning of your and my
1:04:31conversation here about it. You pointed out that as much as they do make good money from this,
1:04:35it's not central to their finances. They can... And anything they come up with that I think would be a,
1:04:44hey, this makes the... It's not... You're never going to please everybody. But...
1:04:49You could assuage an awful lot of the concerns of the people whose biggest concern is simply the money
1:04:56and being able to use other payment methods or that Apple's own in-app purchase would take a
1:05:03significantly lower, like a 90 to 10 split or something like that. You could do... And the other
1:05:09people who are concerned about the choke point of distribution of software, which just came up most
1:05:14recently with the IceBlock app, which is a really interesting use case that I don't want to
1:05:19digress too far about. But it's really, really interesting because the nature of IceBlock,
1:05:26this iPhone iOS app that was meant for people to report ice activity in their local proximity,
1:05:33and then you could get alerts that ice activity was by having the app, by giving it access to your
1:05:40location. It... The lesson that so many people who didn't understand the technical details of it was,
1:05:47well, that's why it should have been a web app, because then it wouldn't be subject to Apple
1:05:51removing it from the app store. But the nature of IceBlock technically was that it couldn't be done
1:05:57as a web app with the same privacy control, because the author of the app didn't want to have a database
1:06:02of people's device IDs, didn't want to have a database of users' location. He outsourced all that
1:06:09to iCloud and trusted Apple to protect it. And so far, Apple hasn't been asked to, nor have they given
1:06:16over any of that private information. But it couldn't be done with the same degree of, oh,
1:06:22the author of the app does not know any of the users of the app, their device identifiers,
1:06:28their locations. He never had access to any of that. It had to be a native app. But if native apps can only
1:06:35go through Apple's app store, then when the government says, hey, Apple, we would like you
1:06:39to take this app that we're angry about out of your app store, and they're like, sir, yes, sir,
1:06:44whatever you say, Mr. Trump, take it out, then it's gone. And to assuage those people's doubts by having
1:06:51alternative distribution methods for native apps that could still use iCloud as storage, that don't go
1:06:59through the centralized app store. You could assuage those concerns about the distribution of software
1:07:05and the concerns of people who are most upset about the money with something that would still leave
1:07:13Apple with tons of money that they would make from the app store. That's part of it. I mean, yeah, I think
1:07:19just not all the money more and more. It seems like the stuff that we've done both on the Mac and in the DMA in terms
1:07:26of providing an alternative mechanism, perhaps something like notarization seems like a sensible solution.
1:07:33That said, Apple itself has misused the notarization in the EU. I never really blinked at that.
1:07:41So that doesn't 100% deal with this problem, but it feels closer to what you're probably looking for.
1:07:48It would be a better place. I agree. And I think they would have a harder time with some of the
1:07:52notarization stuff in the US. I think they've sort of skated by some of it on Europe. But yeah,
1:07:56it feels like that is the eventuality we are getting to. It's just Apple has not come to terms with
1:08:03accepting that yet.
1:08:06And at a very simple level, it actually works against Apple's arguments to argue, whether it's
1:08:12Apple or anybody who wants to defend Apple more strenuously than you or me certainly do, that opening
1:08:19it up more would be catastrophic to Apple financially in terms of how much money they could make through
1:08:25the app store. That argument implicitly says that Apple can't compete with third-party payment
1:08:31processing and services. And that to me is an argument Apple doesn't want to make. I think
1:08:38they obviously could. Everybody should be able to compete. That's one of the fundamental tenets
1:08:43of capitalism. And Apple has always been a very good competitor. They're good at competition.
1:08:49I've always wondered why they don't just do something like... You can use Apple Pay for digital goods.
1:08:57Also, it's like just credit card processing at that point. Hey, implement Apple Pay instead
1:09:02of the in-app purchase. I don't know. That seems like... I was surprised years ago that they didn't
1:09:06do that. It didn't have that weird thing between like, well, you can use it for stuff in the real
1:09:10life like Uber or physical goods that you're buying, but you can't use it for digital goods. You got to
1:09:16use in-app purchase. It's still credit cards no matter what. I don't know. It's always seemed a little
1:09:21arbitrary. They'll be fine. But I feel like they're headed towards a case where they're not
1:09:27as fine, right? There is a path they could chart that would be financially lucrative and get these
1:09:33regulations, regulators off their backs and get rid of the bad publicity of Apple being the target of
1:09:42negative outcomes in these lawsuits one after another after another all around the world.
1:09:47There is a path to chart to get there and they seem completely unwilling to even take steps in
1:09:54that direction. Yeah. Anyway, let me take a break here. Thank our other sponsor of the show are good
1:10:00friends at Squarespace. The show is brought to you by Squarespace as many, if not most episodes of the
1:10:06talk show are Squarespace. All in one website hosting. You have a website. You want a new one. You could
1:10:13build it on Squarespace. You don't have a website yet, but you need one. You could build it on
1:10:17Squarespace. You should definitely try it first before you try other things. They have everything
1:10:24you need from domain name registration to dozens and dozens of templates to choose from for what your
1:10:30website can look like. AI design tools for tweaking or creating original designs. Traditional
1:10:37WYSIWYG design tools if you don't want to use AI for something like that, where you just sort of drag and
1:10:44drop and select the interface. And because you do it in the browser, what you see is what visitors to
1:10:51your website get just without the editing controls. You make your website look just the way you want in
1:10:58the admin interface to Squarespace in your browser on any device, desktop, tablet, all the way down to a
1:11:06phone. They've updated their editing and interface tools to work great, even on phones. And what you
1:11:13see in the admin interface is what visitors to your website will see. Absolutely terrific stuff. Their
1:11:19design intelligence, that's the AI design stuff that I've mentioned. It empowers anyone, even somebody
1:11:25without graphic design skills, to just who wants you just describe what you want and get a more personal
1:11:31website tailored to your specific needs. Squarespace payments, speaking of payments, as our discussion
1:11:37was, it's the easiest way to manage your payments in one place with Squarespace. You can get started in
1:11:43just a few clicks, and you can start receiving payments for just about anything you would want
1:11:48to sell on your website. Could be that you sell products, like you make t-shirts or sell some kind of
1:11:53arts and crafts, or you could sell your time if you're a consultant. Anything you would need to do with
1:11:59payments, you can do through Squarespace payments, and they take everything you could possibly want.
1:12:04ACH, direct debit, Apple Pay, Afterpay, ClearPay, the pay later services in the US and the UK,
1:12:11all of that stuff is supported if you want it. Invoicing, if you do sell your time or your services
1:12:17or something like that, they've got a whole invoicing feature built into Squarespace now where you can send
1:12:23your clients or customers invoices through Squarespace. They get it. There's a web, they visit your
1:12:28website, see the invoice, pay the invoice, and it all takes place through your website. Really,
1:12:33really easy, very, very slick. What do you do to find out more? Well, you get a 30-day free trial.
1:12:38Everybody who goes to Squarespace, whether you come from this show or just go there on your own,
1:12:43everybody gets a 30-day trial. No limits, no watermarks on the website. Go there, spend a whole
1:12:48month making the website just the way you want at squarespace.com. You get a free trial. When you're ready
1:12:54to launch, go to squarespace.com slash talk show. And by going to squarespace.com slash talk show,
1:13:00you get 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain. And you could prepay for a whole year and
1:13:05get that 10% discount on a whole year of service. My thanks to Squarespace for their continuing support
1:13:12of the talk show. All right. So, M5 products. The M5 is out. We got the low-end entry model MacBook Pro,
1:13:21new iPads Pro, and a headset thing called the Vision Pro. I haven't heard much about it.
1:13:31It's hot. It's new. It's super popular. But not hot. It's warm. It's lukewarm. Yeah. Well,
1:13:39I mean, the M5 is, I mean, we've kind of, it's fascinating to watch the Apple Silicon evolution.
1:13:44We have seen, obviously, five generations of these chips now in about five years. It is,
1:13:50yeah, they're right on. They, the regularity. Well, six years, right? It's six years. I guess,
1:13:56yeah. 2020. 2020. Yeah, it was. Okay. Yeah. I can't count. It's an off by one error. It's fine.
1:14:01Yeah. But yeah, it was like November of 2020 when the first M1 Max shipped in November.
1:14:07So, we kind of know the deal, right? You know, you get some year-over-year improvements. They choose
1:14:14a little area they're going to work on this year. The GPUs with those neural accelerators kind of got
1:14:20beefed up. There's some increased memory bandwidth, stuff like that. But a lot of the stuff is very
1:14:24incremental. But that's, I mean, I would argue, and I think Stephen Hackett wrote a good piece
1:14:29over 512 pixels talking about, this is what we wanted. Yeah. We wanted the lack of, we didn't
1:14:34want the Intel world where it was like, I don't know, Intel makes some new chips and they'll come
1:14:37into Max eventually. Maybe you'll be waiting a couple of years between models getting, no,
1:14:41we get a new model pretty much every year to 18 months. And yeah, that means that they're not all
1:14:47going to be barn burners, right? It's not, if you go from the M4 to the M5, it's not going to be a
1:14:52huge change for you. But if you go from the M1 to the M5, it's probably a pretty significant change.
1:14:56I just, I just two months ago upgraded, I had an M1 Air, the MacBook Air that I had been using since
1:15:04the first generation. I bought it basically as soon as they got announced. And I just bought an M4
1:15:09MacBook Air to replace it. And it's great. If you go three generations, it's, it's pretty,
1:15:15pretty substantial improvement there. So I'm still on my M, so I'm still on my M1 Max MacBook Pro,
1:15:24which came a year later. It came in October of 2021. There was a whole year where there was just
1:15:31the M1 chips before we got the M1 Pro and Max. So it's about four years old. And the only thing after
1:15:40a month of testing the M4 MacBook Pro last year, the one thing I loved about it was the nano textured
1:15:47display versus mine where it only had the glossy display. Yeah. But, and I've always said this, I'm
1:15:55sure you agree because you review a lot of products too. Like the way to, the real test of whether
1:16:00something is faster, the new thing is faster, isn't when you start using the new thing. It's when you go
1:16:06back to your, your older thing. And then it's, Oh, I hadn't really noticed how much faster this was.
1:16:13And now I'm back on my old two-year-old iPhone or year old, whatever, or four-year-old MacBook.
1:16:19And I went back to my personal M1 Max with 64 gigs, which was the maximum amount of RAM you could get in
1:16:27at the time. My MacBook after a month, full month, full time using the M4 Max MacBook Pro. And I didn't
1:16:36notice any performance difference. I know it's faster, but I know it's faster at a couple of
1:16:41things, but nothing that I do regularly. I don't run out of RAM with 64 gigs. I, I, and I was like,
1:16:47ah, I was really going to buy one. I thought, cause that's, that's a good, that's from the M1 to the M4,
1:16:53that's a good period. That's, that seems reasonable to, to buy another very expensive
1:16:57cause I would max it out again. It's my main work tool. It's, it feels justified to spend
1:17:02five, six, $7,000 on something I'm going to use every single day for my work. But when I went back
1:17:08to my old one, I couldn't notice anything that felt slower, anything. I was like, ah, I guess I'll wait
1:17:13a year. Yeah. I, for me, honestly, the thing that tipped me over was I, I had skimped a bit on the
1:17:19storage on my air and even with nothing on it, just the base system and like my own data,
1:17:26et cetera, not even that much stuff. Like maybe my photo library, I was constantly hitting the like,
1:17:31Oh, you're running out. You're running out of space. You're running out of space. I was like,
1:17:35I got to the point where I couldn't, I, there's nothing else I can take off this. So I had to,
1:17:38I had to, and it was like, then Amazon sells these things at like huge discounts. Now it's a really
1:17:43nice one. I can get it for the same price I paid for my M one air five years ago. It was a hard
1:17:48move not to make it. It's great. But yeah, I think the, the testament to Apple's Silicon prowess is that
1:17:55it's only now, I think for a lot of people that like M one stuff is starting to feel a little bit long in
1:18:01the tooth. And Apple did finally start really comparing much more like in their press releases.
1:18:06Oh, it's this compared to the M one, as opposed to saying they've been talking about Intel for so long.
1:18:12Yes. Right. So they've now been like, all right, five years. That's a pretty reasonable time to start
1:18:16comparing against our new generation. And also to show that we have an, like good enough improvements
1:18:21in performance over that time, because M one to M two M two to M three, a lot of those cases,
1:18:27they were very minor improvements. But again, Apple has always had a good history of having
1:18:31devices that tend to last. And, and this is no exception. So the M five, I mean, it's the truest,
1:18:37it's the truest definition of speed bump. We're just going to pop a new chip in it. I mean,
1:18:41I remember when I first started covering Apple stuff or reading Apple news and people would talk about
1:18:44speed bumps and I thought they meant those things you put in the road that you drive over. I don't know
1:18:48why they call them that. That's pretty weird. But yeah, these are, these are very speed bump
1:18:52releases and it's not to say they're not good, but it's just, they just take up a
1:18:56little bit every time.
1:18:57Yeah. Yeah. And as Stephen Hackett's piece argued that there is no alternative universe
1:19:04where every come every October, Apple wows us with an all new MacBook pro design that it's
1:19:12not possible. It's not possible. It wouldn't make any sense. And it's why you and I do what we do.
1:19:18It's why people listen to shows like this one. We, we all have a bit of tech enthusiast in us where
1:19:23we do want to be amazed and wowed and have our minds blown by something new. And we, we're not
1:19:30the people we, we are in some aspects of our lives, early adopters of some things, right? Whereas
1:19:37normal human beings aren't early adopters of anything. That's the whole bridging the chasm
1:19:42metaphor of, of innovative product design. But it's, you have to have the maturity to realize you're not
1:19:49going to get it. You, you, you shouldn't want to get it or crave it every single product release,
1:19:54right? These are very stable products, right? You don't want revolutionary new MacBooks every year.
1:20:02You shouldn't feel always be waiting for the next thing. Oh, this is good. But next year it'll be a
1:20:07new one. And I mean, they, they get away with it sort of with the iPhone, but it's again, not as
1:20:11it's, it's a different world and it's not, it's still not a major redesign every time.
1:20:15Right. And that's, I was going to get to that. That's a great point though, that the iPhone is
1:20:21about as aggressive as you, as, as possible. And I think Apple is about as aggressive as possible with
1:20:27the iPhone where the camera system certainly changes every year and they change the sizes.
1:20:32they've, the iPhone pros have went to titanium for a few years and now they're back to aluminum
1:20:39where they haven't been aluminum for a very long time because before titanium, they were stainless
1:20:43steel, right? So now they're all the way back to aluminum, good old aluminum. So they, they change
1:20:49things with the iPhones, especially the iPhone pro. They introduce new phones every year or not every
1:20:55year, but every couple of years, like the iPhone mini and then the plus sized ones. And now the iPhone
1:21:01air, I guess we could talk about it at the end that the air seems to be a report, all report in the same
1:21:07way that all reports about Apple and regulatory stuff about the app store are negative. All reports
1:21:13about the iPhone air are negative in terms of sales. But, but to your point, like there's a, you're right.
1:21:20The iPhone is the most aggressive and I think it runs like a, like a spectrum, right? It goes all the
1:21:24way down to the Mac pro. Right. But even with the iPhone where they are the most aggressive about
1:21:30changing it year over year and the most single mindedly obsessive about sticking to an annual
1:21:38schedule, September, the only time they get knocked off that September schedule, like COVID in 2020
1:21:43knocked them off by a month, which is amazing. Yeah. Right. That it was like October instead of
1:21:48September with all of the disruption. They're single mindedly focused on an annual 12 month schedule.
1:21:54They change as much as they can. And even there, 95% of people who pay attention to iPhone announcements
1:22:01are like, ah, it's the same thing every year. Yeah. Even there. So it's a good place to be. And the
1:22:08alternative is not, wow, my, the M5 MacBook Pros are totally unlike the M4 MacBook Pros, which weren't
1:22:16at all like the M3 MacBook Pros. That's not tenable. The alternative is like the, the period where there
1:22:22was no retina MacBook air for four or five years after it seemed like it should have been possible.
1:22:28And sometimes the MacBook Pro would go to two and a half years without an update, even a speed bump.
1:22:35Whereas the closer we get the, the flip side of that, which has also been interesting is watching
1:22:38their strategies for rolling out each new chip generation, because I think it's kind of changed like
1:22:43every time in terms of when you get the base chip, the pro and the max variants, whether or not there's
1:22:49an ultra variant, like each time the schedule has been a little bit different in terms of which
1:22:54computers come out when. And it's, it's kind of fascinating because they're, you're watching them
1:22:59juggle in real time, especially as they now have processors that are shared so broadly across all of
1:23:05their devices. And they're working at such scales that they need to be kind of cagey about, all right,
1:23:11we can launch the MacBook Pro M5 and the iPad Pro M5, because neither of those are going to sell,
1:23:17particularly in the quantities that say an M5 MacBook air would sell in, which we would need
1:23:23a lot more. And so are we get a little more bang for our buck by saying we can put it in these devices
1:23:28now, and then put it in the air in the spring when we've had a chance to ramp up our production lines
1:23:32on a brand new processor. So they have to contend with these economics of scale,
1:23:37Apple and having these, these expansive product lines and the fact that they're all underpinned by
1:23:43this Apple Silicon. So that's, it's kind of fascinating to watch them. It's, it's turning a
1:23:47battleship, right? There are so many different factors that need to be considered in order to decide
1:23:52which, which like things we can release. I mean, I, I think as part of the reason that roadmap wise,
1:23:57we, we knew that at some point they would probably do an Apple vision pro with a better processor in
1:24:03it. And so, but we also know it's not like that's going to sell in huge quantities. It's probably not
1:24:09going to sell to most people who have M2 Apple vision pros because they can't trade them in.
1:24:13And it's the improvements are minor anyways. So they, they're very, they're very canny about how
1:24:20they do this and how they roll these out. Yeah. I've summarized this in a post, my post on the
1:24:25announcement, which I think is worth pointing out. They didn't even hold an event for not even in
1:24:30person. And they didn't put one of their prerecorded video keynotes out for this. All of these M5
1:24:37related announcements were just by press release in Apple newsroom posts. And they've had briefings
1:24:43for us in the media about some of these things, but I, Apple continues to the way they present news
1:24:51continues in my opinion, to be very humble and accurate about the importance of it, right? If they
1:25:01have, if they send out invitations to the media to come to Cupertino or go to New York or do something,
1:25:07have a big in-person thing, that's because they think it's important and it tends to be more
1:25:13important. And if they just do a show, one of these Apple shot on iPhone videos, that's an hour long
1:25:21keynote, or maybe even less than an hour, they think it's more important than just doing by press release.
1:25:26And if it's less important, it doesn't mean they shouldn't do it. It's, Oh, well then why even have
1:25:30a press release? No, these are good updates, but they don't, they don't abuse the, the attention
1:25:38that they know that they can garner at the snap of a finger by doing a keynote. It's they're,
1:25:43they're accurately reflecting. Yeah. It's a time and effort and energy like decision too, right? I mean,
1:25:48like last year we saw all those videos with it where they did three days in a row, right? With the new
1:25:54MacBook Pros and then the Mac mini and all that for the M4. And it was kind of interesting because
1:25:59it felt like, I felt so bad. I remember we, I mean, we talked about it on this show, like they had to
1:26:03keep talking about Apple intelligence, but like the same person was in every video talking about Apple
1:26:07does, but a little different each time. And it's again, this year, I think they decided that there
1:26:12wasn't even quite enough of a splash for them to do that. Could they have done an M5 MacBook Pro
1:26:18video and an M5 iPad Pro video and an M5 Apple vision Pro video? I think so. But I think people
1:26:23would have rolled their eyes at a lot of it because it would have been kind of, there's no meat.
1:26:28Yeah. And it gets to like a little boy who cried wolf problem. Right. And it's not so much like in
1:26:33the parable, it's about just outright lying. Oh, there's a wolf and there is no wolf. And then
1:26:38people stop believing it. But it's imagine he's got like a really good set of binoculars and he sees a
1:26:43wolf several mountains over and it's like, hey, there's a wolf. And they're like, where? And
1:26:48it's 11 miles away. And it's all right. It's true. There is a wolf, but it's 11 miles away. So maybe
1:26:55you didn't need to scream it. And then eventually people stop paying less attention. And I feel like
1:27:00they put out a press relief here that there's an M5 wolf. It's coming. It's coming. Anytime. It loves AI.
1:27:07It's great at AI. I really respect them for that. And I think it shows that Apple thinks
1:27:13still overall continues to think long-term. Whereas if it was all short-term and people who were just
1:27:19looking to put, I worked in Apple product marketing for two years, you'd squander all of that as much
1:27:25as you could. And as opposed to keeping the tank of attention full. Yeah.
1:27:33But it is different. I don't know how strategic it is. I think it's more that the one place where
1:27:37they're aggressive with the year to year M3 to M4, M4 to M5 is that they are very aggressive about
1:27:46moving to the latest and greatest fabrication processes at TSMC. And I think that because they're
1:27:55moving as fast as they can, the schedule is just not regular. Like the most regular is just the regular,
1:28:02no adjective, M number chip, right? M5. Here we are. It's October again. It's around Halloween.
1:28:08Here's a new... Right. There's nothing magically inherent to a year that makes chips advance on a
1:28:16year-by-year basis. That's not how it works, despite what Moore's law has always predicated. But it's not
1:28:22the year time frame is not beholden by the advance of the technology. It is a marketing thing to a certain
1:28:27extent. And it's also like a roadmap thing. And we have this much discipline, right? There's no reason
1:28:32that WWDC has to be annual. Sure.
1:28:35It could be every 15 months or it could be whenever Apple feels like it. And instead, I think the company
1:28:41really feels and believes across the whole company that running the whole company on a more or less
1:28:48annual schedule is good for the company and keeps them from complacency. And it does, I think, to some
1:28:58degree, too, speak to human nature. We are animals who are aware of the annual calendar, right? It's
1:29:06maybe less so in Cupertino, where it's sort of the same weather all around the year. But certainly
1:29:11in Philadelphia and Massachusetts, you have this internal sense. And there are, even in Cupertino,
1:29:17there are things like Christmas season and summer is somewhat different. The sunlight hours are
1:29:23certainly different in winter and summer. We run on an annual schedule. We feel years pass, but it's a
1:29:29good schedule. Yeah. So it's an interesting set of upgrades, even if there's not anything in here that
1:29:35really makes you sort of jump out of your chair and shout. It's intriguing to see what things they
1:29:40are focusing on. And I think the addition of those accelerators to the GPUs is, I was talking with
1:29:46this about, with Jason Snell about this. It is kind of Apple coming to terms with reality about,
1:29:51we built this great neural engine, but everybody wants to do AI on GPUs. So for sure, fine, we'll do it
1:29:59on the GPUs. Granted, what the utility of those, I know Federico Vitticci wrote a good piece over
1:30:04on Mac Stories about the M5 iPad Pro and trying to find ways to get similar results to what Apple did in
1:30:11terms of local AI processing and struggling in some ways because the tools are just not there yet.
1:30:17Like, they are not really designed for that platform, even though Apple does have some of them internally.
1:30:22They're not things that are actually being used everywhere. I find that in my experience so far,
1:30:27I mean, so the A19 Pro has those same accelerators because it's based on the same cores.
1:30:33I have found, like the one time I made a Genmoji in the last month on my iPhone Pro, it went speedy,
1:30:40I'll tell you that. It was faster than the last one, but I'm not sure that's enough of a use case for me
1:30:45to be like, run out and get these new chips with the AI accelerators in them.
1:30:50I also think the hardest thing to demo, the M5, even though it's the biggest upgrade,
1:30:56is the Vision Pro, which goes all the way from M2 to M5. So just in terms of pure benchmarking,
1:31:02it's going to show way more improvement than M4 to M5 because there was no M3 or M4 Vision Pro.
1:31:08But how do you show that? And it's such a hard... I always think back to when the first HomePod shipped.
1:31:14I think it was at WWDC, I'm pretty sure, because I remember it was in the big, big, big North Hall at Moscone West.
1:31:21And Phil Schiller was on stage and just talking about how it's inherently kind of impossible
1:31:27to show an audience of 4,000 people how good these HomePods sound when you're in an auditorium with 4,000 people,
1:31:35where you really need to hear them in a realistic scenario like a living room or a kitchen or an office.
1:31:41You can't really demo it. It was also true with retina displays.
1:31:45How do you show what a retina display looks like when everybody's viewing the website on a non-retina display?
1:31:51You can't really.
1:31:53It's like trying to show 3D on a 2D screen is exactly the problem.
1:31:56And even with the Vision Pro, even if you're comparing the M5, the M2, you can't A-B test it.
1:32:02You can't have one on one eye and one on the other eye.
1:32:04You got to swap back and forth.
1:32:06It's like, I can kind of tell.
1:32:07And you're still at the whims of people's eyesight and people, whatever lenses they're using and all that stuff.
1:32:13So it is very, very tricky for them to demo that.
1:32:16Right. So apparently, I don't have an M5.
1:32:20I'm on the fence about whether to take a review unit, but I might.
1:32:25But apparently, the resolution is higher for things like virtual Mac desktop.
1:32:29And you get higher frame rates more often.
1:32:33I think the old one was capped at 90.
1:32:3690. Yeah.
1:32:36You can go up to 120 in certain circumstances.
1:32:39Certain scenarios.
1:32:39Yeah.
1:32:39Which sounds great.
1:32:40But again, you can't really demo it without putting it on your head.
1:32:44Yeah.
1:32:45And to see the improvement, you'd have to have both.
1:32:47You'd have to have the old one.
1:32:49Swapping back and forth.
1:32:50Yeah.
1:32:50Right.
1:32:50It's hard to do that.
1:32:52I mean, I think the most impressive thing to me about that upgrade is the fact that they managed to eke out that extra performance and extend the battery life.
1:33:00That's a real testament to their engineering there because getting an extra half hour out of that battery life is not nothing.
1:33:07It also shows that the Vision Pro, I mean, Jason and I have talked to this a lot on Six Colors, but the Vision Pro is so far out there.
1:33:18It is such a cutting-edge piece of technology.
1:33:21It can literally take as much horsepower as you can give it.
1:33:25There is so much headroom there for them to keep improving performance.
1:33:30Yeah.
1:33:31Putting aside everything else they could do, weight, temperature, battery life.
1:33:35If they could just throw more processing power at it, it would be a better product.
1:33:39Right.
1:33:39And it's not that it's bad at what it does now, but, like, it shows you how much, like, how much more you can do because they're using these incredibly good displays and everything.
1:33:48And I'm always impressed.
1:33:50I have an M2 unit, and I'm always impressed with how good it is when I use it.
1:33:55And thinking, like, yeah, you can even think, okay, it could be improved, and there's all these, sure, more refresh rate, rendering more pixels.
1:34:01All this stuff would be better, but it's still an incredibly impressive piece of hardware for all of that.
1:34:07Yes, absolutely.
1:34:08They did send me, I do have a review unit of the Dual Knit Band.
1:34:13I have one as well.
1:34:14And, well, what's your impression of it?
1:34:16It is, so I only had the ones that came with the M2, the Solo Knit and the Dual Loop.
1:34:22And I had switched to the Dual Loop because I felt like the Solo just wasn't quite working for me enough.
1:34:30And I think that the Dual Knit is better in every way.
1:34:35I think that it's very Apple, right?
1:34:38It's designed very well.
1:34:39They really embraced that 3D Knit feeling.
1:34:43And I think that they did a really nice job with improving the fit dial that lets you tweak.
1:34:49I love that it's got that sort of – it's like I compared it in my review to the watch stem, right?
1:34:54It's like popping your watch stem out to set the time.
1:34:56Yeah, yeah.
1:34:57And you can kind of – it's got a nice satisfying click.
1:34:59It is fascinating to me that they put more weight in it because it feels counterintuitive.
1:35:04Yeah.
1:35:04You're like, oh, my God, it's so heavy.
1:35:06You're putting more weight in.
1:35:07But it really – the balance is, I think, the most important part.
1:35:10Like, it's never going to be a device you wear five or six hours a day, battery life notwithstanding.
1:35:15And I think you won't notice the additional weight so much from the band as you will notice the compensation in the balance.
1:35:22And I do think it improves the balance of it.
1:35:24It's not going to get rid of it totally.
1:35:26It's still a heavy device.
1:35:28But it does help it make it a little bit more comfortable for the sessions where you are using it.
1:35:32I was going to say to you, I've found with mine that I like the single loop band.
1:35:40I think that's what they call it.
1:35:41Or solo knit band.
1:35:43And I never had a comfort problem with it.
1:35:45And I tried the dual or the old – whatever the old over-the-head secondary strap was.
1:35:52Dual loop.
1:35:53And I was going to say to you, I don't even know where mine is because I never – it seemed –
1:35:57But then I realized it's right here.
1:35:58It's right there.
1:35:59It's right here at my podcast station, which is nowhere near my Vision Pro, which is upstairs.
1:36:03And I looked over to the left here and it's like, oh, there it is.
1:36:06And I think it was the last time I talked about it on a podcast.
1:36:09Yeah, you held it up.
1:36:10That's right.
1:36:10It's for demos.
1:36:11Never used it.
1:36:12I tried it and I was like, oh, I kind of see what people are talking about.
1:36:16But it's like the shape of my head, the size of my head, maybe my big nose.
1:36:22I don't know.
1:36:23But something left the – I found the solo knit band to be just fine.
1:36:28And with the new one, I have to say it is more comfortable.
1:36:31I like the solo one.
1:36:32That's all I've used for years whenever I used my Vision Pro.
1:36:35And instantly with the new dual knit band, I'm like, oh, this is more comfortable.
1:36:42And it does feel more balanced.
1:36:44It feels less front heavy, right?
1:36:48It's like there is a – even when I've gotten my Vision Pro to as comfortable as I feel like it's going to get, there is a front face heaviness that makes your chin want to go down.
1:36:58And the counterbalance on the back definitely helps.
1:37:02And it just feels – the downside, though, is I don't know what I'm going to do when I travel with it.
1:37:07Because I do taking it with me for any kind of long airplane flight.
1:37:10But I feel like now it's like extra – even more extra weight.
1:37:14More weight.
1:37:14That's right.
1:37:14So I kind of feel like at home, I'll use the dual knit band.
1:37:18But when I travel, I'll still take the solo because I'd rather – it already feels like I'm lugging this ridiculously heavy thing just to watch one movie on the airplane.
1:37:29Do I really need an extra, I don't know, half a pound or however much the weight is?
1:37:35I think I did it.
1:37:35I can't remember.
1:37:36I found a good website somewhere that gave you the weights.
1:37:38Like you put in how much a thing weighs and it tells you.
1:37:40I think it's – oh, yeah, the new band weighs like a hamster.
1:37:43Yeah.
1:37:44I don't know.
1:37:44It's insane.
1:37:45It's not nothing.
1:37:46You pick it up.
1:37:47You're like, oh, it is a little weight.
1:37:49Did you have any – like a briefing with anybody with Apple about it?
1:37:52Did.
1:37:53With FaceTime and Personas?
1:37:56Yeah.
1:37:57Yeah, I did too this week, earlier this week.
1:38:00What do you think?
1:38:00I thought it was amazing.
1:38:01I mean, I've used the Spatial Persona thing a bit here and there chatting with some – I chat with Jason, James Thompson too.
1:38:08I've had a couple like calls and like I am consistently blown away with it because it was the thing.
1:38:14I think I was so – I had such a negative reaction to it when they first announced it, right?
1:38:20You're like, oh, my God.
1:38:20This is Uncanny Valley.
1:38:22It's terrible.
1:38:23This is so distracting.
1:38:24And the first version – I never used the first version.
1:38:27I think I didn't – because I didn't get a review unit until this summer.
1:38:30So, I've only used the Vision OS 26 versions.
1:38:33And holy cow, they're good.
1:38:36Like, they're not perfect.
1:38:37Like, you can still tell.
1:38:39But like, your brain kind of just lets it go at a certain point.
1:38:43Like, I've had – like I said, I'm having calls with people I know and have spent quite a bit of time with in person.
1:38:49And in my brain, it's just like talking to them.
1:38:53Yeah.
1:38:53Like, it's kind of wild.
1:38:55I'm – this feels like famous last words.
1:38:59I'm probably going to be wrong because they're probably going to keep moving this to make it more and more realistic.
1:39:04But there's a part of me that wonders at this point with these personas.
1:39:08I don't know if they're calling them 2.0, but they might as well, right?
1:39:11There's like the original personas, which if you never tried it, it was – it wasn't unpleasant.
1:39:21But it was somewhere in the Uncanny Valley where you got like a window, like a square window floating in front of you.
1:39:28And the window was flat, but the persona of the person you're talking to was three-dimensionally behind in the window, right?
1:39:38And so there was a 3D effect to it, but it's –
1:39:41It's like the spatial photos that you can look at, sort of.
1:39:44Right, but it was like a real-world window, not a computer flat window where when you look at somebody through a window, like when you pull up to the drive-in at McDonald's or Dunkin' and it's your turn to get your food, you see the person – the window is two-dimensional.
1:40:04And you see the person and they hand you the bag and it's three-dimension that you see the person behind the window.
1:40:09It was like that, sort of.
1:40:12The new ones, it's really more like a hologram of a person.
1:40:15My briefing was three people from Apple product marketing and me.
1:40:19So it was four of us.
1:40:20But we were sitting like in a foursome and there was somebody on my left, somebody on my right, and somebody directly across from me.
1:40:29And the sound and the spatial awareness –
1:40:33The sound is really good.
1:40:34The sound is really good, just uncannily good.
1:40:37And I'm like, wow, this sound is really good.
1:40:39And then 30 seconds later, I'm like, oh, I completely forgot about the sound because it's so good.
1:40:43Yeah, that's right.
1:40:44And I'm like, I should be more amazed by the sound.
1:40:46Really good for screen sharing content from Vision Pro where it's, oh, all of a sudden now, instead of being in a circle, the four of us, we're seated like theater style in a row.
1:40:57And there's a screen in front of us where what somebody wants to show me, whether it's like a keynote deck or just demo the new photos app or something like that.
1:41:06Really good.
1:41:07And just way closer to an in-person briefing in terms of the emotional and the – that I don't feel like I have to deliberately pay attention to this.
1:41:19I feel like because I'm with these people and I'm here with them, my attention is naturally being pulled toward what they're telling me and presenting as opposed to a WebEx where it's, I have to pay attention, pay attention, pay attention.
1:41:32I'm staring at a little square of a person on a flat screen.
1:41:34They've been talking for 30 seconds and I've not been paying attention because I've been trying to pay attention.
1:41:41I did the – I was on a – my friend Micah Sargent has a program over on Twit that's Tech News Weekly.
1:41:46And I – on a whim, I joined the show in Zoom but with the persona because I had never tried that before.
1:41:53And it was very strange.
1:41:55It kind of works, but it kind of goes back to that same issue you're talking about where you're – but like for them, it looked like just a meme.
1:42:02Right.
1:42:02In a flat screen.
1:42:04But for me, I'm getting like a – I don't know.
1:42:06It's a bizarre accommodation, but it also is one of those ones where looking back at how else were they going to do it?
1:42:14Like that – you kind of look at this and be like, okay.
1:42:17Like there was all this – the rumors that it was going to be like, oh, you're all Memoji or something.
1:42:23And it's – and it feels like that's what – that's what you see on the Facebook, like on the meta and stuff like that.
1:42:29But that never seemed quite Apple-ish.
1:42:33Yeah.
1:42:33And I think that this seems like in retrospect entirely predictable.
1:42:38We just – I don't think anybody believed they could pull it off.
1:42:41And it's weird too because like right now, you and I, we're using this web-based thing, StreamYard, to record this show.
1:42:47And even though I don't record the video, I'm looking at you in your home office.
1:42:51You're looking at me in my basement.
1:42:53So I can look at you, but I also can see myself.
1:42:56I'm right here.
1:42:57And you could see yourself.
1:42:58So the difference with this is that you don't see yourself because it's truly a first-person perspective.
1:43:03But I did look at myself when I made my new persona, and I have to say it moved past a certain uncanny valley, right, where like the previous personas I'd made, maybe even earlier, like when I first installed Vision OS 26 beta back right after WWDC with the new stuff.
1:43:20I feel like they've improved it even since then.
1:43:23Yes, they have.
1:43:24Where I'm actually not weirded out, and before it was like, wow, that does look like me, but I'm really freaked out, and there's a part of my brain that is like, this is weird and wrong, that's you.
1:43:36And now it's like, oh, yeah, that looks like me.
1:43:38That did a really good job.
1:43:39Yeah, I mean, in the same way that you see like an artist rendition or something, you're like, oh, yeah, they captured something.
1:43:44I don't know what they did.
1:43:45Or at least it's now gotten to the point where I'm like, I hope that's what I look like because I think I look pretty good there, right?
1:43:50I hope that's actually what I look like.
1:43:53It's the aspirational Persona.
1:43:54Yeah, so I don't know what they're doing, but it's gotten from freaking me out.
1:43:58Like, I've always been amazed by it.
1:44:00Even the first version of Persona at the original WWDC debut of Vision Pro six months ahead of launching or seven months ahead of launching, where it was super early beta.
1:44:11Even there, I was technically impressed.
1:44:14As weird as this is and as kind of crazy as it is that the person is through a window, not just there, it still is impressive.
1:44:22But looking at myself was always this combination of I'm technically impressed by this, but totally freaked out.
1:44:29Yeah, right.
1:44:30And now it's just, oh, I'm just technically impressed and I kind of hope that's actually what I look like.
1:44:34And using FaceTime this way, it's really amazing.
1:44:38It really is.
1:44:39If I had to do meetings with a distributed team more regularly, I'd really want to do it this way.
1:44:44It would make me, it is so much more engaging and pleasant that it really would get me over that hump, which is the big thing for everything related to Vision Pro is do I really want to get it out, put it on, fire it up.
1:44:59Inevitably plug it in because the battery.
1:45:01Plug it in because the battery's dead.
1:45:03Because that's one thing they still haven't fixed is if you don't leave this thing plugged in, it will be dead.
1:45:07It goes.
1:45:08Yeah.
1:45:08Yeah.
1:45:08Yeah.
1:45:10I've been using it a lot since I got a review unit and I've been just trying because I got one late.
1:45:14So it was just sort of trying to chronicle some of the things I've been doing with it.
1:45:17And lately I've been trying to use it for gaming a bunch because I'm just super curious to see all the different sort of gaming experiences, whether it's the native stuff or the stuff you can play on from iPad games.
1:45:27And even there's some game streaming apps where you can like stream stuff from your PlayStation or Xbox.
1:45:32And it's been intriguing to use it there for something that's like, this is kind of a step further than just like immersive video or using it to watch a big movie or something like that into something a little more interactive.
1:45:45I think it has a lot of the same struggles there that Apple has with gaming everywhere, but they're trying, they're damnedest to try and we can do all these different things, right?
1:45:55We can do iPad games.
1:45:56We can do native games.
1:45:57We can do streaming with, you can use a controller, et cetera.
1:46:00You can use hand controllers, like all of these things are sort of them trying a lot of different things.
1:46:06I think the main thing that's laying them down at the moment is the user base being so small, there is little incentive for people to say, develop more native games for it.
1:46:16iPad games look fine, but they're limited by being iPad games, which are just, you don't get the full experience.
1:46:23And the iPad, as good as it is, isn't as good as a console.
1:46:26Streaming stuff is let down a little bit by, you got to stream it and there's always going to be some performance problems when you're streaming stuff, but it's, it's still impressive.
1:46:34And when you can get in there and like, I was playing like PS5 games streaming on a giant screen right in front of me and it's pretty cool.
1:46:41Right.
1:46:42I'm not sure I'd say go get one for that, but it's pretty cool.
1:46:45Yeah.
1:46:46And it still is the thing I forget.
1:46:49And again, you, it's almost like, it's not just that you have to use it to understand it.
1:46:52It's like, you have to use it to remember it.
1:46:55Even when you've done it before is how impressive it is to look at a really big screen, even though you're looking at these little tiny post stamp screens that are right in front of your eyes.
1:47:05But your brain is not 99% convinced.
1:47:09It's a hundred percent convinced that you're looking at a hundred foot screen in front of you.
1:47:13It's like, oh yeah, this is awe inspiring.
1:47:15Right.
1:47:16It's a, it's an incredible piece of technology.
1:47:18It is intriguing to see that.
1:47:20I'm glad that they, even though this was long planned, I'm sure to do this, this speed bump.
1:47:24I'm glad that it shows between this and they've, they've been doing some developer stuff in Cupertino the last couple of days, I think that's vision pro related.
1:47:31And they, even though there's the reports that they've dialed back on sort of what the next version of this might look like, they are clearly still full steam ahead on the platform.
1:47:39Yeah.
1:47:39I don't believe that.
1:47:40I, I, I, they might've changed plans, but I don't think they've dialed back.
1:47:44I think they're full steam ahead and it's inevitable that the plans are going to change, right?
1:47:50I mean, it would be kind of weird if their plans didn't change.
1:47:54over four years of seeing what works, seeing what doesn't work, learning, seeing what advances are made in the technology and stuff like that.
1:48:03It would be kind of weird if nothing from the roadmap changed in four years.
1:48:07It is interesting though, that, I mean, the biggest complaints, right?
1:48:10Obviously the weight and price.
1:48:11Right.
1:48:12I don't think anybody really thought they would change.
1:48:14Anybody who was following this thought that this version would change anything hardware wise.
1:48:18Right.
1:48:18I am a little surprised that they didn't, didn't change the price at all.
1:48:22I kind of felt like, but I, I get it.
1:48:25Like I, I get it from their perspective.
1:48:26They've staked out that price point.
1:48:28It's kind of the same, the same device.
1:48:31So I can see that they wouldn't be like, and now it's $3,000.
1:48:34Like you feel, have a lot of people with M2 being like, what?
1:48:36I spent $3,500.
1:48:38And now, so they, they like to keep price points as we've seen with iPhone line stuff.
1:48:43They like to put that flag in the sand.
1:48:44Or think about the Mac Pro, right?
1:48:46The trash can Mac Pro started at $5,000 even when it hadn't been updated in any way for, I don't know, six or seven years or something.
1:48:53Yeah.
1:48:53Because they, the people buy it.
1:48:55Yeah.
1:48:56Right.
1:48:56And they're holding the, they were holding the price for the next thing that would be worth $5,000.
1:49:01And I kind of feel that's part of what they're doing here.
1:49:05I don't know if they actually know like what a 2028 Vision Pro that more people think, oh man, it's still $3,500.
1:49:14But man, now I really want one.
1:49:16I don't know if that's what they're thinking or they just, they don't know.
1:49:19So they want to keep that price out there so that it doesn't go from, oh yes, it started at $3,500.
1:49:26Then it dropped to $2,500.
1:49:29And then it went to $2,000.
1:49:31But now we have something cool that's $3,500 again.
1:49:34And now all of a sudden they're adding $1,500 to the price of, that's just not how they think.
1:49:40Yeah.
1:49:40Anyway, good stuff.
1:49:42Not super whiz bang, but speed bumps across the board.
1:49:47All right.
1:49:48Last but not least, iPhone Air seems like not so good sales wise.
1:49:53Yeah.
1:49:54I'm intrigued.
1:49:54I mean, these reports are always a little like what you make of them.
1:49:58Yeah.
1:49:59And it's hard to tell sometimes.
1:50:00There's been enough here.
1:50:01There's enough smoke here to make me think that there is there.
1:50:04It was always tricky because this is cool.
1:50:07It's a cool device.
1:50:08I held one a few times.
1:50:09It is very impressive.
1:50:10I know people who bought them.
1:50:12But it's sort of a little sandwiched between the iPhone 17, which is a great phone, honestly.
1:50:18Like, I've been impressed with everything that the sort of the message of the iPhone event earlier this year was like those low-end products, whether it was the iPhone 17 or the Apple Watch SE, they keep getting better, right?
1:50:30They keep eliminating things that were missing from them and make them more compelling, right?
1:50:36Adding ProMotion to the iPhone 17 is a big deal.
1:50:39Adding some of these features to, like, the distinction stuff is like, hey, the Pro is always going to be nicer, but you don't feel like you're making as many sacrifices.
1:50:46So to sandwich the air right in between those two, especially price-wise, I think is challenging because the question is, who is the audience for it?
1:50:56Is it early adopters, but early adopters who don't want all the power or battery life of the Pro?
1:51:01Or is it people who just really want a really nice, really thin phone, but they don't have as many cameras as even the standard phone?
1:51:08So it's a tricky needle to thread there.
1:51:11I'm still daily driving my review unit, and I've been on the fence.
1:51:18Like, I've given – I still haven't ordered a personal new iPhone yet, but – and I've – only because I really am at least partially torn between spending a year using an iPhone Air as my daily phone
1:51:34or getting the more obvious choice, the 17 Pro.
1:51:38And I'm probably going to buy a 17 Pro.
1:51:40I think I told this to Molson the last episode of the show, and I still feel the same way, but I'm still torn enough that I haven't placed an order.
1:51:47But I'm not surprised – and again, I always say when I link to these reports from Ming-Chi Kuo or Counterpoint Research or anybody else who says sales of this iPhone product are bad or they are good,
1:52:01that you have to take them with enormous grains of salt because they're all guesstimates.
1:52:07And they can – and Apple doesn't – we have to wait for Apple to release their quarterly results at the end of the month.
1:52:14And even then, they don't break down by year.
1:52:16Right.
1:52:16They'll just give you a little color.
1:52:17But like this – it's the classic, like, touching part of the elephant problem, which is they don't – they may get some numbers.
1:52:25Like, those reports might have some numbers, but, you know, they can't speak to Apple's expectations.
1:52:30Right.
1:52:30And the fact that the iPhone Air is right in the middle price-wise means that the average selling price isn't going to tell us much.
1:52:37Yep.
1:52:37So, for example, if all the rumors are right and there's a foldable iPhone that comes out next year and all the foldables from every other company make non-foldable phones look cheap, right?
1:52:49They're all, like, $2,000 or more.
1:52:50So, let's just say the foldable iPhone is $2,500.
1:52:54If it's a hit, you might be able to see it in the average selling price, right?
1:52:59Sure.
1:52:59If the average selling price really goes up noticeably, you could say this is a really strong sign that the foldable iPhone is a hit.
1:53:06Having a $999 new iPhone is like the –
1:53:10It's because it is the average, basically.
1:53:11Right.
1:53:11It is the average.
1:53:12Yeah.
1:53:14But there's – I don't – they tried the mini for two years, and by all accounts, it wasn't that big a hit.
1:53:21But the people who loved it really loved it.
1:53:24And I'll hear from them now every time I mention it, in writing or on a podcast.
1:53:28Well, you had Moulton already.
1:53:29Yeah.
1:53:30But somebody will say, I'm hanging on to my 13 or even 12 mini as long as I can.
1:53:36You never hear that with the Plus, though.
1:53:37No, you don't.
1:53:39I don't hear anybody who says they love the Plus that much.
1:53:41I know people love the Pro Max, but people want that big screen.
1:53:45They go Pro Max.
1:53:45They didn't go Plus.
1:53:46Yeah.
1:53:47You're right, though, because I think if you really love big phones and you really are a phone enthusiast, you probably were just – maybe you don't use the extra camera lenses.
1:53:56Maybe you'd like it to be a little lighter weight.
1:53:58So you enjoyed the option of saving a few hundred dollars by buying an iPhone 15 Plus instead of a Pro Max.
1:54:06Nobody really has passion for saving $200 or whatever, $300, whereas people have passion for the mini form factor.
1:54:13Yes.
1:54:14And I think people have already and will continue to have, even if it's only a one experiment only, passion for the thinness and lightness of the iPhone Air.
1:54:25It is really, really fun to hold.
1:54:27It still is striking.
1:54:28I've been using it daily, driving it for most of the last six weeks, five or six weeks.
1:54:34It still – it fits in jean pocket so much nicer.
1:54:38The one camera lens on the back is really good.
1:54:41It's still not quite as good as the Pro, but I'm not entirely sure that I could Pepsi challenge the difference that if you just held it up.
1:54:49And I've taken a lot of side-by-side photos, and it's kind of hard, especially in good lighting.
1:54:54It's really kind of hard to tell.
1:54:56But I do kind of want the telephoto lens, and I do kind of want the ultra-wide lens.
1:55:00And I actually do – the longer I use it, the more annoyed I am by the area, the width of the iPhone Air.
1:55:09That I kind of – what I want is an iPhone Air Mini.
1:55:13Even if the Mini is only the screen size of the 17 Pro or the regular 17, like, I want one that's this thin and a little smaller side-to-side, top-to-bottom.
1:55:28Like, it does feel too big to make a little.
1:55:30I think your battery life is going to take a hit there.
1:55:32Yeah, but the battery life is good enough.
1:55:35And, again, it speaks to your point about, like, with the Vision Pro going to the M5, that they added all this stuff like higher refresh rates and higher resolution.
1:55:43And the battery life is better.
1:55:44And it's – the battery life story with this year's whole lineup of phones is amazing, right?
1:55:50That the iPhone Air gets the battery life of a Pro phone from just a year or two ago.
1:55:58Maybe not last year's, I forget, but at least two years ago.
1:56:01Yeah, it is nice.
1:56:03I've held one in the store mainly, and I was impressed.
1:56:06Even then, when I came in to pick up my Pro, they were like, oh, have you seen the Air?
1:56:10You want to check it out?
1:56:10And so they handed me one, and I was like, you – the experience of holding it, again, kind of like we were talking about the Vision Pro with using it or not.
1:56:17It is tactically very different.
1:56:19And it is impressive from a purely physical standpoint.
1:56:23And I think the camera tradeoff is so fascinating to me because it is a place where everything about it makes sense, right?
1:56:31You look at the size constraints, you look at what they do.
1:56:34But at the same time, the cameras are what we described earlier, the aggressive upgrade schedule.
1:56:40And the cameras are what push it forward.
1:56:42So that's always going to be a challenge, right?
1:56:46And when it comes to saying, look, there's only one camera.
1:56:48It's a good camera, but there's only one on the back.
1:56:50You're going to lose out on people.
1:56:51And it also remains an engineering challenge.
1:56:57Is there – if that is the future of the way the iPhones are going to look in the same way that we saw with the iPhone X or something like that, if this is the design direction, how do they overcome that?
1:57:07How are they going to engineer it so that you don't have three giant camera lenses on the back of a phone that need that much space?
1:57:15I think that's – it's a hard challenge for them.
1:57:17Right.
1:57:17Yeah.
1:57:18And it's just – so I think it all boils down to the obvious question we all had while it was a rumor even, but even immediately after the keynote where it was announced is, well, who is this for?
1:57:27And it's definitely for someone.
1:57:30I know there are people – I see them on social media.
1:57:33I hear from them as readers of Daring Fireball.
1:57:35There are people who bought it and love it.
1:57:37It's definitely for someone.
1:57:38But the mini phones were too.
1:57:40And I feel like while it's a very different type of mini by just being thinner than the 12 and 13 minis were, it's very similar though in that it appeals very much but to a – clearly a niche, a niche.
1:57:55And with the minis, we could – we saw from Apple dropping the form factor that they don't care.
1:58:03It wasn't nobody.
1:58:04I don't know.
1:58:065% to 10% of iPhones in those generations were the minis by accounts I've seen.
1:58:12And Apple seemingly, if it's only 5% to 10% of sales, they don't want to keep it in the lineup.
1:58:18And I don't see how this one – I think some of the estimates I've seen is that it's 8% of this year's new iPhones are the air.
1:58:25I don't know if that's accurate or not.
1:58:27Sounds right.
1:58:27Sounds truthy.
1:58:28And if they didn't care about the mini, why are they going to care about this?
1:58:32So I kind of feel like it's not long for this world.
1:58:35Yeah, it is interesting because they did the thing where they – it didn't have a number on it, right?
1:58:39It's just the iPhone air.
1:58:40It's not the iPhone 17 air.
1:58:41Obviously, there's rumors about the foldable.
1:58:44I think, to your point, you wrote about this, but I don't think it was intended not to be a standalone product.
1:58:49I think they felt it was a compelling enough thing to ship.
1:58:51I think it's also where the engineering challenge is, hey, we're building a foldable phone.
1:58:55We need to be able to do this.
1:58:57But along the way, they're like, well, we could also make a pretty cool thin phone.
1:59:01But I think when you add that foldable in next year, I mean, I certainly wonder whether or not the air gets an update every year.
1:59:08It doesn't feel like it.
1:59:10No, it doesn't feel like it.
1:59:12No.
1:59:12And I think that lack of a number really says it.
1:59:14And I pointed out this week that they don't seem to be advertising it.
1:59:19Maybe they will, and the big advertising campaign is coming.
1:59:22Holiday season, yeah.
1:59:23All of the ads I've seen are for the 17 – most of the ads are for the 17 Pro.
1:59:29And you could just tell at a glance because it's orange.
1:59:31And I think I've seen some ads for the regular iPhone 17, but I'm not even 100% sure.
1:59:38But I've seen no ads about the air, no TV commercials, no billboards, nothing.
1:59:43That is interesting.
1:59:44And I think that's weird.
1:59:46And I don't know.
1:59:46I guess that they're just – even Apple's not that into it.
1:59:51I don't know.
1:59:52Well, it's weird to kind of feel like every other year, the Pro is the flagship.
1:59:57It's undisputed.
1:59:59Whereas this year, you have two good models, two better models.
2:00:04Hero models, right.
2:00:05Yeah, exactly.
2:00:06And how do you balance that?
2:00:09How do you have to – it feels like they chose.
2:00:12They're like, all right, they're both great, but we're putting all our eggs in the Pro basket.
2:00:15And we're pushing that as hard as possible because it's still the more expensive phone.
2:00:20It's the – you got the Pro and Pro Max.
2:00:22And in hindsight, I don't remember Apple ever advertising the 12 or 13 minis.
2:00:27I don't remember them ever saying –
2:00:29Yeah, there were some, but it was – I think more than this, but it wasn't a lot.
2:00:32Yeah, certainly not a lot.
2:00:34And I don't know if that's because they were like, what's the point?
2:00:37We know this isn't going to be a huge hit.
2:00:40And I don't know.
2:00:41I've never – off the record, I've never been able to get anybody from Apple to really say – I'd love to, but I've never gotten anybody to say, yeah, we kind of knew the 12 and 13 minis weren't going to be a big hit.
2:00:52But we sold enough for them, it was worthwhile, we just wanted to put it out there, we thought it would be cool, and it was cool, but we kind of – we never really had plans for a 14 mini, even from the start.
2:01:01And if the 12 mini had been a bigger hit than we expected, sure, maybe we would have adjusted our future pipeline, but we didn't expect that.
2:01:10Nobody from Apple has ever told me anything like that, unfortunately.
2:01:13I'd love to know if that's the truth or not, but the lack of an ad campaign makes me think that it was, that they didn't really expect much.
2:01:23And the lack of an ad campaign so far – and again, the holiday season is really only starting – I feel like we really shouldn't be talking about the holiday season until after Halloween.
2:01:33I agree.
2:01:33Let's wait until November.
2:01:34Please, no Christmas decorations until at least November.
2:01:38If the calendar doesn't say November, don't do it.
2:01:41So let's see, and I would love to see them make commercials for it, but do they feel like then that's weird and their iPhones are fighting each other?
2:01:48Yeah.
2:01:48Where they're making this commercial bragging about how thin and light this one is?
2:01:52Or do you segment it?
2:01:53Are like the air advertisements showing up in like glossy fashion magazines or whatever, and the pro stuff is getting TV spots?
2:02:00Right, or sports.
2:02:01I don't know, men.
2:02:02Hey, men who watch football.
2:02:05You need five razors, you can shave with your iPhone pro.
2:02:07Three camera lenses.
2:02:08Fuck it, we're going – no.
2:02:10You like a heavier phone.
2:02:11You like it heavy.
2:02:12It's good to be – it's good to have a heavier phone.
2:02:14It's like a brick in your pocket.
2:02:15Right.
2:02:15It does sort of make an interesting trend line, though, which is that they've really struggled with that fourth spot.
2:02:21Every other phone seems like it's got its place kind of demarcated for you.
2:02:25You've got the iPhone, you've got the more expensive iPhone.
2:02:27You want the bigger version of the more expensive iPhone, great.
2:02:30We got you covered.
2:02:31But they have not cracked that fourth model.
2:02:34Maybe it's the foldable because it will be so far out there.
2:02:37It's so different.
2:02:38So different.
2:02:38And it's at the top, not at the middle.
2:02:41Exactly.
2:02:41It's like –
2:02:43Maybe there's some kind – and again, they clearly don't – in some alternate universe, and many other tech companies today, I think Samsung is a perfect example.
2:02:52Samsung makes tons of phones.
2:02:53Sure.
2:02:54We in the tech press tend to focus on the Galaxy line, but they make a zillion cheaper phones at all sorts of different price points.
2:03:01Look at how many laptops Dell makes.
2:03:04There are still tech companies that try to –
2:03:06Baffling at times.
2:03:07My wife uses a PC, and I tried to help her buy one.
2:03:11I was like, I literally cannot tell you the difference.
2:03:14It's really hard.
2:03:15So there is an alternate world where Apple comes out with maybe not six or seven new iPhones every year, but six or seven iPhones every two years, and that others are on different schedules.
2:03:25And I guess the 16e counts as a phone in the lineup, and it's really impressive, in my opinion.
2:03:31It does have a number.
2:03:32Yeah, it does have a number.
2:03:34At least it did last year.
2:03:35Yeah, we'll see if there's another one.
2:03:38Yeah, but again, not in the middle, right?
2:03:42Right.
2:03:42It's at the low end.
2:03:43It's got a clear demarcation.
2:03:44It's like there's room at the low end for a new phone, and if they're right about the – they certainly were right about the pro phones, that there was room at the high end above the regular –
2:03:55I think there's always room at the high end.
2:03:56I don't think they'd be able to vent a phone that's too expensive for someone to buy.
2:04:01That they could make a Vision Pro-priced iPhone, a $3,500 to $4,000 iPhone.
2:04:07I don't think it's out of the question that that mobile costs in that range.
2:04:10I think that's terrifying, but yeah.
2:04:13Yeah, and I know, and it would be very Apple-like, right?
2:04:16And everybody was like, oh my God, all the other ones are $2,000, and Apple, of course, comes in with a $4,000 iPhone.
2:04:22And then meanwhile, the day it launches, there'll be a line around the block outside the Fifth Avenue Apple Store of people trying to buy.
2:04:27Who's buying these things?
2:04:28But somebody might.
2:04:29I don't know.
2:04:29They will.
2:04:30But if you're going to tap into people's passion, if people have a passion for a really small iPhone,
2:04:37the mini, or a really thin iPhone, and they don't care.
2:04:41They only, they know, I only ever shoot 1x photos.
2:04:44That's fine for me.
2:04:45I don't care about the other lenses.
2:04:47Or I use the digital zoom because it doesn't matter to me.
2:04:50Yeah, I don't really notice.
2:04:51But I feel like if it was people being passionate, then it should be charged that way.
2:04:56Like, one of my, I'll just leave it at this, is that I've always wondered, what if instead of making a 12 and 13 mini, they'd made a 12 and 13 Pro mini?
2:05:08And okay, what they like to do with the Pro and Pro Max phones is have the exact same camera system on both.
2:05:17You just get a bigger screen and longer, bigger battery life with the Max.
2:05:22And some years they don't.
2:05:24There have been years where it's like, oh.
2:05:25The Max has its own little edition or whatever.
2:05:27Yeah.
2:05:28It's like it's got a slightly better telephoto lens than the non-Max one because there was space to put it in.
2:05:34But then the next year, the regular size one catches up.
2:05:38What if the Pro mini had lost a camera lens or only had the One X?
2:05:43It was like the other Pro phones but only had one lens because it was, people would understand, people who wanted it would understand.
2:05:50I guess the regular minis did have two lenses.
2:05:54So, you know, maybe two instead of three.
2:05:56People would understand because it's mini.
2:05:58Yeah.
2:05:59It makes, you don't even have to, stop, stop.
2:06:01Yeah.
2:06:02Jaws, you don't have to explain.
2:06:04It's smaller, so there wasn't room for three cameras.
2:06:07There's room.
2:06:07It's physics.
2:06:08Yeah, but you had me at smaller.
2:06:10Please take my money.
2:06:11But I kind of wonder if that, it would have sold in similar quantities and because it would have cost more because it had Pro on the name and had otherwise had Pro specs, that maybe it would have been, Apple would have caught Tim Cook's interest financially because same number of users almost, but more money because it was more expensive.
2:06:33There's something to that.
2:06:34I mean, you look at the Mac lineup, right?
2:06:36If the iPhone 17 is the MacBook Air, your MacBook Pro comes in three different flavors.
2:06:42You know, you've got your M5, your M5 Pro, your M5 Max.
2:06:46So there's an argument for it.
2:06:48Sure.
2:06:48I think so.
2:06:49Yeah.
2:06:50I'm game for them to try it.
2:06:51Maybe if this doesn't pan out, that's what we'll see next.
2:06:53So anyway, I hope it sticks around.
2:06:56Kind of not surprised because I do.
2:06:59I think that there is a similar size audience for the iPhone Air as the iPhone 12 and 13 minis.
2:07:05And we learned from those that that size is not of interest to Apple.
2:07:09So I don't know.
2:07:11I still think it's an impressive phone.
2:07:12And if people out there listening are on the fence about it, I would encourage you to eat.
2:07:16Go check it out and perhaps buy it.
2:07:18But I don't know.
2:07:21Something's not quite right about it.
2:07:24Yeah.
2:07:24Yeah.
2:07:24It's yeah.
2:07:26Well, we'll find out.
2:07:27Yeah.
2:07:28All right, Dan, everybody can read your most of your writing that pertains to the show is, of course, at Six Colors with your colleague, Jason Snell, also a friend of the show.
2:07:38And, of course, at your website, DanMorin.com is that's right.
2:07:42I got you.
2:07:44I think that works.
2:07:44I own them all at some point.
2:07:47I think DanMorin.com works.
2:07:48DMorin.com also goes there.
2:07:50But yeah, they both go there.
2:07:51I made sure I owned all of them.
2:07:53All right.
2:07:53We referenced all of your novels, your science fiction series, and short stories collections are all available there.
2:08:01Anything coming out soon?
2:08:03I got one in the works right now.
2:08:05I'm on deadline, actually, for my next manuscript.
2:08:08Oh, I'm so glad I asked you to be on my always too long.
2:08:12No, it's fine.
2:08:12It's fine.
2:08:13I needed to break.
2:08:13I got my, I sent it out to my early readers, and they came back with a bunch of feedback.
2:08:17So now I have to fix stuff, and I'm like just letting that marinate in the back of my head.
2:08:21I don't want to think about it right now.
2:08:23So it's a good distraction.
2:08:24All right.
2:08:25DMorin.com or DanMorin.com, you can find out more.
2:08:30Thanks.
2:08:31And thanks to our sponsors, Factor, where you can get meals ready to heat up and eat, and Squarespace, where you can get yourself a website.