0:00:00Brian Mueller, welcome to the show. I asked you just before we started whether your surname was pronounced like Robert Mueller of Mueller Report fame, and it turns out it's not. Is this something that people with your surname have to go through all of life?
0:00:13Yeah, especially after all the news with that. But yeah, it just rhymes with Ferris Bueller. I get that all the time instead.
0:00:23I have been meaning to have you on the show for so long, and I feel like, anyway, you are the developer, author, mastermind, owner, I don't know what your title is, behind Carrot Weather.
0:00:35And a whole suite of other applications, but I think it's safe to say Carrot Weather is the flagship. Is that correct?
0:00:43Yeah, it started with Carrot To Do, the to-do list, and basically made a new app every few months until I ended on Carrot Weather, and that ended up being the most popular by far, and just took up all my time.
0:00:59And so I basically have to spend all my time now on Carrot Weather, and I'm stuck, stuck on it. I can't do anything else anymore.
0:01:09It's the curse of success of the indie developer, right? And I've seen this pattern for decades. I was going to say years, but there are so many bare-bones software springs to mind where bare-bones used to have more.
0:01:22I mean, they still have Yojimbo a little bit, but it's sort of the BB Edit company. I could think of other examples.
0:01:27Tapbots has a suite of applications, but their social media apps, Tweetbot and Ivory sort of are the one that takes up all the time.
0:01:37So you did not set out for Carrot Weather to dominate your time like it did?
0:01:41No, when Weather came out, or when I was working on Weather, anyhow, I just thought that it was going to be another app, and then I'd keep doing more and more of them after that.
0:01:53I was honestly glad when it was that successful that I didn't have to keep making new apps because I was sick of—the thing that I hate most about working on apps is, like, the promotion part of it and, like, having to make videos and reach out to press and all that kind of stuff.
0:02:09And so I'd have to do that every single time I made a new app.
0:02:12And so Carrot Weather being so successful freed me from having to do that constant marketing cycle.
0:02:22Well, I have to apologize for the rest of the media.
0:02:26But it works to some extent, where you always send me emails with announcements of major new versions or new apps when you do have a new app.
0:02:37And, you know, as much as it can seem like it lands on deaf ears, it registers because here you are.
0:02:47Yeah, it's been—and it was really cool starting out because I knew nobody in the industry when I started.
0:02:55I was just doing cold emails to people when Carrot2Do launched, and I got 26 downloads on the first day.
0:03:02And with each update to that app and each successive app that I launched, I got, like, new press outlets covering it, and each one did better than the last.
0:03:15And it's just—it was cool having that growth and being able to feel like the apps were getting more and more successful as time went on.
0:03:24Fit was actually the one that had probably the biggest, like, carrot fit, that is.
0:03:30It was a weight tracker.
0:03:31That got the most attention, I think, of all the apps in terms of having more of a mainstream breakout.
0:03:38And when it first came out, there was an article that appeared on the Drudge Report.
0:03:43And then I got all of these, like, mainstream, like, producers from, like, Good Morning America and stuff calling or emailing me and calling me at the real job that I had at the time.
0:03:56And I had to have all these calls in, like, this meeting room at my job.
0:04:01And, yeah, it was surreal having camera people coming from Good Morning America to my house and filming in my kitchen and stuff.
0:04:09Ugh.
0:04:10I never had anything like that with weather.
0:04:12So, was that after weather?
0:04:14That was the year before weather launch.
0:04:17All right.
0:04:18So, the year before.
0:04:19So, for anybody who's not familiar, I presume carrot weather is a big enough hit that most people listening are at least vaguely familiar with the premise.
0:04:28But the whole suite of apps has, and from the get-go, has had a, what would you call it, a gimmick?
0:04:35Yeah, I don't mind calling it that.
0:04:39Yeah, this snarky AI robot personality to it.
0:04:43And, yeah, it started with the to-do list app, the very first app.
0:04:48Because I was just looking for some kind of personality to give the app.
0:04:54And all the apps at the time, like, tons of them had gamification in them.
0:04:58And it was always like this, if they had any kind of personality to it at all with the gamification,
0:05:04it was always just like this, like, annoyingly over-the-top positive feedback of,
0:05:10you did an amazing job, you got an achievement, or you went up a level, or that kind of stuff.
0:05:16And I just hated that, and it felt so fake.
0:05:19And I just really liked the idea of having this, like, snarky character in there that would, like, make fun of you
0:05:25and yell at you in the to-do list if you didn't get your tasks done.
0:05:29It is a very different attitude.
0:05:34I mean, one way to go is just sterile, right?
0:05:37And that's sort of, for better or for worse, let's hold up Apple's modern design aesthetic as the definition.
0:05:46That there's no real personality to, say, Apple reminders, right?
0:05:51It is the visual aesthetic is the Apple OS look.
0:05:57And the tone of any kind of alerts you get is just super straightforward.
0:06:04It's not overly saccharine either.
0:06:07It's not like, hey, you can do it.
0:06:10Check off some texts.
0:06:11Keep going.
0:06:11And Apple, I guess, leans into that a little bit with some of the fitness stuff, like on Apple Watch, right?
0:06:16I get things.
0:06:17I just got one today.
0:06:18It was like, hey, looks like you took it easy yesterday.
0:06:20I didn't wear my Apple Watch yesterday, right?
0:06:22That's, it's like I didn't have it on at all.
0:06:25And then I put it on.
0:06:26It's like, hey, looks like you didn't meet your goals yesterday.
0:06:28It's like, if I was wearing my Apple Watch yesterday, that means I slept all day, right?
0:06:33Because I didn't move.
0:06:34I have zero calories.
0:06:35That's not taking it easy.
0:06:37So there are places where Apple takes a little bit of an attitude and where they do, it's a little saccharine.
0:06:43I don't know how else to describe it.
0:06:44The carrot attitude is definitely different.
0:06:49And it is certainly not for everybody's taste, right?
0:06:52And I'm sure you hear that all the time.
0:06:54Yeah, that's definitely true.
0:06:56And I actually, the first four apps, they all had like the base carrot personality, but I definitely took some of that feedback to heart in weather.
0:07:08And there's actually five different personality levels in weather now so that people who don't care about the personality and don't like that aspect of the app at all, they can just turn that off and have the app in like professional mode.
0:07:22So it doesn't have any of that character to it at all.
0:07:26And then there's like a friendly personality and snarky.
0:07:29And then there's homicidal and overkill.
0:07:32Yeah, I've got mine.
0:07:34I'm checking.
0:07:35Mine is sent to homicidal.
0:07:36What is the default?
0:07:38The default is, I guess the default is technically professional.
0:07:44I think that's what it starts at.
0:07:46Oh, really?
0:07:47No, I guess I have it set to snarky.
0:07:51I think when you first went in the onboarding, I think it's in the middle and you can move it in either direction.
0:07:57So snarky is probably the deal.
0:07:59Yeah.
0:08:00I have it set to homicidal.
0:08:03I guess it speaks to how good of a weather app it is just for the weather that the option to take the personality out is there and desired by some users.
0:08:14But at the beginning, at the outset, it was the sort of defining characteristic of your whole suite of apps.
0:08:20Yeah.
0:08:21And when weather launched, that's all it was.
0:08:23It was just like a gimmick joke weather app that literally the idea behind it was just there's it would be great to have a weather app that told a bunch of jokes.
0:08:36And it was easy to imagine I could have a bunch of jokes about the different weather conditions, like whether it's sunny or rainy or whatever, and then the seasons and then the temperature.
0:08:47And so that it just gave me a ton of material that I could work off of.
0:08:52And the first version of the app was only a joke weather app and had some funny visuals and stuff.
0:08:59It was very, very basic.
0:09:01And it was actually the launch of the Apple Watch a month later that started me down the path of taking it from a joke app to a real professional, like weather app that people would actually want to use to check the weather.
0:09:20And I find it very funny that it was such a lark almost, really, as as an example right now.
0:09:27And you're one of the odd things you and I have never met in person, but we were local.
0:09:31I live in the center city, Philadelphia.
0:09:33You live somewhere very close to Philadelphia, right?
0:09:36Yeah, right outside.
0:09:37I'm in Bluebell.
0:09:38So it's sort of like near Plymouth meeting mall.
0:09:40Right, right.
0:09:41So we probably have the same weather right now.
0:09:43Right now it is 65 and it's been raining all day and carrot weather says, don't worry, the rain will wash away the evidence.
0:09:51And that is very, it's a perfectly typical carrot snark, at least for my personality setting for the weather every day.
0:10:02Here, let me take a break right now and thank our first sponsor and then we'll keep going.
0:10:07But I have a new sponsor.
0:10:08I'm very happy about this.
0:10:10It is Uncommon Goods.
0:10:12Spark something uncommon this holiday season with incredible handpicked gifts from Uncommon Goods.
0:10:19They make your holiday shopping stress-free by scouring the globe for original, handmade, and absolutely remarkable things for everyone on your list.
0:10:28Uncommon Goods gifts spark joy, wonder, delight, and it's exactly what I wanted feelings.
0:10:36It's funny because they're sponsoring the show.
0:10:39They gave me some promo codes to spend on goods and see what they've got.
0:10:43My wife and I, I let my wife pick because I'm not stupid, and she picked a lemon tree, just arrived earlier this week.
0:10:50It actually comes from the small producers.
0:10:52It actually comes from a lemon tree farm owned by Danny Trejo, the actor from movies like Heat.
0:10:59I don't think he's personally planting all the lemon trees, but still, it's kind of cool.
0:11:04And it is, it came in, it's a beautiful little indoor right now, lemon tree, Mike Meyer lemons.
0:11:10But it turns out my wife bought me a gift from Uncommon Goods a couple years ago, and they still have it.
0:11:16I'll put a link in the show notes.
0:11:18It is an absolutely delightful, it is an F-bomb.
0:11:22It is a little desk trinket, like a paperweight.
0:11:26Very heavy, actually.
0:11:27Looks like a classic bomb, like the old classic Mac OS system alert, like a sphere with a fuse sticking out of it.
0:11:37And just the letter F on the front of it.
0:11:39Perfect for a writer like me.
0:11:41That's the sort of gifts Uncommon Goods have.
0:11:45Like, where else are you going to find a literal F-bomb?
0:11:48All sorts of really cool, clever stuff like that.
0:11:51Really love this company, and you can really lose yourself on their website perusing the depths of their offerings.
0:11:57And when you shop at Uncommon Goods, you're supporting small artists and independent businesses.
0:12:02Many of their handcrafted products are made in small batches, so shop now before they sell out this holiday season.
0:12:08Get your holiday shopping in early.
0:12:10I know by the time this episode's out, it'll be like Halloween.
0:12:13As soon as Halloween's over, it's time to start the holiday shopping.
0:12:16Trust me, don't do what I do, which is wait until December 20-something.
0:12:20Here's what you do to find out more.
0:12:21Or to get 15% off your next gift, go to uncommongoods.com slash talkshow.
0:12:29That's uncommongoods.com slash talkshow.
0:12:33And you get 15% off just for coming from the show.
0:12:35Don't miss out on this limited-time offer.
0:12:37Uncommon Goods, they are out of the ordinary.
0:12:40F-bomb.
0:12:43So does Carrot ever swear?
0:12:44Is that with the homicidal or the...
0:12:46That's what the overkill personality setting opens up.
0:12:50So I should maybe turn that on.
0:12:51I should turn that on.
0:12:52All right.
0:12:56So when did Carrot2Do...
0:13:00Is that what the ToDo app is called?
0:13:02Carrot2Do?
0:13:03So when did you launch that?
0:13:05That launched in January of 2013.
0:13:102013.
0:13:11And that app is still out there, right?
0:13:14I mean, it's...
0:13:15Yeah, it hasn't gotten any updates in a long time.
0:13:18So it doesn't even work with the non...
0:13:21It doesn't resize to fit the screen like newer apps do.
0:13:27Like it should.
0:13:28Right.
0:13:28All right.
0:13:29Well, but again, it's the curse.
0:13:32And you work by yourself.
0:13:34You're the sole designer, developer, marketer of...
0:13:40Yeah, I do it all.
0:13:41Yeah.
0:13:42It's...
0:13:45So Carrot2Do 2013, then...
0:13:49What was the second one you said?
0:13:50Carrot fit?
0:13:50Well, Carrot Alarm was technically the second app.
0:13:54So that was an alarm clock.
0:13:55Right.
0:13:56And then it would fit.
0:13:58Wake you up and abuse you verbally.
0:14:01Right.
0:14:02Yeah, and if you snoozed the alarm, she would yell at you a bit.
0:14:06Where does the Carrot voice come from?
0:14:11It is a very robot-sounding female voice.
0:14:15And you do refer to Carrot as she.
0:14:17Mm-hmm.
0:14:18Yeah, the actual voice is just the Apple's speech synthesizer engine that's in the built-in
0:14:26to the iPhone SDK.
0:14:29I thought so.
0:14:30But do you pre-record them, or do you generate them live using the API calls?
0:14:35Yeah, it's all generated live via the API.
0:14:39And I think that that makes it so I'm able to have, like, literally thousands of lines of
0:14:48dialogue in the app so that it doesn't ever feel old.
0:14:51And one of the things that I like the best, I've been about, like, five or six years now,
0:14:56but I've made it so that I can update the app remotely around, like, current events.
0:15:01So if some big thing happens in pop culture or politics or stuff like that, I can have a
0:15:08Carrot joke for that.
0:15:09It's funny that, like, I get a lot of emails and tweets and stuff like that from people who
0:15:15say that they found out about a celebrity dying for the first time through Carrot.
0:15:21That's, it's definitely, I don't know if I've ever discovered that somebody died, but I've
0:15:26definitely seen references to when the news was still, hey, did you hear about so-and-so
0:15:32dying?
0:15:32And it's already in Carrot.
0:15:35One of the other preferences in there is a political slider where you can shift your political
0:15:40humor leaning or your personal feeling from liberal to conservative or, I don't know, is
0:15:47there a setting in the middle?
0:15:47Is anybody in the middle?
0:15:49Yeah, there's a centrist, and then there's apolitical if you don't want to hear any political stuff.
0:15:55Oh, I got it.
0:15:56Apolitical, centrist, liberal.
0:15:58That's where I have checked.
0:15:59Communist, anarchist, libertarian, conservative, far-right, alt-right.
0:16:06I don't even know, what's the difference?
0:16:08What is the difference between far-right and alt-right?
0:16:11And you have to write material to please all of these people?
0:16:15Well, I simplify it a little bit and have basically just dialogue for conservative and centrist and
0:16:25the more left-leaning group.
0:16:28But I have stuff for everybody.
0:16:30Do you find that difficult to write for both sides?
0:16:34I would.
0:16:36I personally would not be able to try to...
0:16:40I can't imagine having a version of Daring Fireball with its slider, like even just a two-way slider, left-right, and have a version that pleases everybody.
0:16:51Yeah, it's tough sometimes, especially when crazy stuff happens on one particular side of the spectrum.
0:17:01But, yeah, I think it's fun being able to figure out how to write in different voices and stuff like that.
0:17:08And I think that's one of the skills that I've tried to develop.
0:17:12I salute it, though.
0:17:14Do you think it makes a difference in terms of reaching a bigger audience?
0:17:21Do you have metrics on how many people set Carrot's personality certain ways?
0:17:27I don't keep metrics in the app.
0:17:31I don't do analytics for privacy reasons.
0:17:34That's one of the things that I pride myself on.
0:17:37And it's just the kind of thing...
0:17:41It works out well for me because I don't care about that kind of stuff.
0:17:44I'm not the kind of developer that sits around and tries to figure out the best way to tune each individual screen to get the most revenue out of people.
0:17:55And that just has never interested me.
0:17:57So I just don't collect any kind of analytics.
0:18:00But I do have tons of people from all the different political perspectives.
0:18:06One of...
0:18:07It's crazy.
0:18:09One of the biggest fans...
0:18:12One of the biggest names that I am aware of that used the app was Rush Limbaugh.
0:18:18He talked about the app all the time on his show.
0:18:22Really?
0:18:23So I know I have a lot of users just because of Rush Limbaugh.
0:18:27And he would actually email me all the time.
0:18:30It was kind of funny.
0:18:31And at first, I wasn't sure that it was actually him.
0:18:34Right, right.
0:18:35I would feel the same way.
0:18:37But one time, he sent me like a screen...
0:18:40Instead of like a screenshot of his monitor, he sent me like a photo that he took of his monitor.
0:18:45And I could see his reflection in the screen.
0:18:48And so that's how I knew that it was actually him.
0:18:51And he had like a golden microphone too.
0:18:54Very...
0:18:55I always knew...
0:18:57I mean, even predating...
0:19:00Predating Daring Fireball is going back a long time.
0:19:03But I mean, I started Daring Fireball in 2002.
0:19:05And even at that point, he was already...
0:19:08It was known that he was a big Mac user.
0:19:10And he was a big Mac advocate in the dark era of,
0:19:16Hey, I think Apple's going out of business.
0:19:18Now they're desperate.
0:19:19Can you even believe it?
0:19:20They rehired the founder, Steve Jobs.
0:19:22Yeah, how's that going to work?
0:19:24I don't know.
0:19:25Even in that era, it was known that he was like a celebrity Mac user who evangelized the platform to his enormous listener base.
0:19:34I don't know how much good it did, but it certainly didn't hurt.
0:19:37That's kind of hilarious.
0:19:39Yeah.
0:19:40And I kind of...
0:19:42We can keep going on that.
0:19:43I feel the same way.
0:19:45I haven't had any analytics installed on Daring Fireball in I think it's close to five years.
0:19:50I forget when I turned off Google Analytics, but I want to say it was around 2020, like around the beginning of COVID.
0:19:57And I turned it off for privacy.
0:19:59I was like, this does not seem tenable anymore to have an analytics package on every page.
0:20:06Did you use it much?
0:20:07Did you look at and do anything different because of it?
0:20:10No, not really.
0:20:12That was the other part.
0:20:13That was the other reason that from my perspective...
0:20:16And I barely checked it.
0:20:18I didn't check it very frequently, but every once in a while, I would check it if sometimes I'd...
0:20:24I still do.
0:20:25Sometimes I'll get sponsors who want to know some demographics, like even just like country by country.
0:20:32And Google Analytics is certainly good for that.
0:20:34But guess what?
0:20:35All of the answers from Google Analytics for my site were completely unsurprising.
0:20:40It's totally dominated by North American readership.
0:20:44And outside North America, it's like United Kingdom and then distant third, I think, is Germany.
0:20:51And it's exactly what you think.
0:20:54So there's no surprises there.
0:20:56So turning it off didn't really change anything.
0:20:59And I thought, oh, I'll just find something else that's private.
0:21:02And then five years have gone by and it's like, yeah, I don't really miss it.
0:21:05So I can look at Cloudflare stats for just general, hey, am I getting about the same amount of traffic as I usually do?
0:21:13And yeah, I am.
0:21:15But in terms of exactly where and who and what, I don't care.
0:21:19And I don't mean to be nonchalant about it.
0:21:22And sometimes when I'm dealing with sponsors, most of my sponsors know exactly what I do.
0:21:28And they know exactly what they're getting.
0:21:30But sometimes it's a bigger company and it's like somebody inside the company is like, we should sponsor this obscure website that's mostly about Apple that has a good tech base.
0:21:43And the marketing people completely have no idea who I am, what I do, have never heard of it.
0:21:49And they've never heard of ads that work like mine, that there is no tracking code.
0:21:55And I start telling them that I don't have demographic information.
0:22:00And I have a saved snippet, so I don't have to rewrite the same email all the time.
0:22:05But it's basically trying to not sound like I'm scamming them, which is what it sounds like.
0:22:11I don't know anything about the demographics of my audience, and I don't want to.
0:22:15But when it comes to weather apps in particular, it's sort of a, I was going to say goldmine, but goldmines are good, but like a goldmine for people who want to do nefarious things with personal information.
0:22:31Because the one thing that's true about almost everybody's weather apps is that they have location permissions turned on, right, amongst other things.
0:22:40But location is the big one.
0:22:42Because, of course, you want the most natural setting for where you want the weather for is wherever you're standing right now with your phone in your hand.
0:22:50Right. And having, like, precise tracking turned off isn't useful because that's, like, that could be anywhere from 1 to 20 kilometers from your actual location.
0:23:01So you actually need to have, and that wouldn't work for, like, weather alert, government weather alerts, or rain notifications.
0:23:08That becomes useful.
0:23:09Right.
0:23:10So you really need to have a precise location in your weather app.
0:23:14Right. And so it is the least private, but it is the most useful and is sort of inherent to using the app.
0:23:22And, again, I even sent you a text message a couple minutes before we were scheduled to start.
0:23:26We were scheduled to start here at 2.00 in the afternoon, and at 1.50, Carrot sent me an alert that the rain here is going to stop at 2.01.
0:23:35But Carrot has those sort of exact location-based precipitation alerts that I think fairly are described as initially an innovation from the late, great dark sky that Apple ended up acquiring and turning into Apple weather in some way.
0:23:52So do you get, do you have to field a lot, given the popularity of Carrot Weather, do you field a lot of inquiries from marketers who are looking either to acquire the app or partner with you, or would you put our SDK in your app, blah, blah, blah?
0:24:07Yeah, I mean, I get a lot of outreach in all those different buckets that you just mentioned.
0:24:13There are a lot of those location-tracking companies out there that are looking to harvest that data and then sell it on to other people, and they offer a lot of money that I don't want.
0:24:29Because I just think that's not the kind of thing that I would want in a weather app that I use, and so I'm not going to do that to any of my users.
0:24:36All of that location data can be used in such creepy ways beyond just like selling you stuff, and I don't want any part of that, especially as things get crazier and crazier in the world, and they find more and more ways to use that kind of stuff against people.
0:24:54I definitely don't think that's the kind of thing that you should have to be worrying about in the apps that you use on a daily basis.
0:25:02Yeah.
0:25:02The privacy report card for Carrot is very good.
0:25:06It's data that's not linked to you, so you don't have any indication of who I am or what it is, but purchases for in-app purchases, subscription, obviously that needs to be connected to the person, location, precise location, identifiers, and usage data for product integration.
0:25:24But it's not linked to me, so you can't say, oh, I know exactly which settings John Gruber is using or anything like that.
0:25:30Right, and the only stuff that I store on my servers is if you have notifications turned on, and then I have to save stuff like your location and your push notification ID and that kind of stuff.
0:25:43But it's not tied to an IP address or an email address or any of that kind of stuff.
0:25:49And all the requests to all the different weather data API providers that I have, those are anonymized to a degree so that Apple Weather, for example, doesn't know that, not that Apple is going to do anything with your location data,
0:26:05but to use them as an example, they're not going to know your exact apartment in your apartment building, and then that same person went to the grocery store down the street and then went to whatever.
0:26:20I have that all anonymized, and then it's all going through my own intermediary server so that your IP address isn't being sent.
0:26:29When did it occur to you that this, I guess there's two questions here.
0:26:35When did it occur to you that Carrot Weather was going to be a smash hit?
0:26:38And then when did it occur to you that, oh, this is a privacy minefield, a minefield that you can navigate, but that privacy is uniquely endemic to the weather app category?
0:26:52I think it was when Carrot Weather first launched, it had the biggest launch that I had had to that point.
0:27:03But like all apps, when Carrot Weather first launched, it was a paid up front only app.
0:27:10And so all my other apps, you get that big launch, and then it slowly tails off, and people forget about it because it's not being featured on the App Store, and people aren't talking about it in the press.
0:27:23But then a month later, the Apple Watch came out, and with the Apple Watch, I had to focus a lot less on making a really funny app because the screen is so small, I don't have room for funny visuals or lots of room for jokes.
0:27:39And especially on the watch face with the complications, you only have room for a data point for the temperature and an image of the weather condition.
0:27:48And so I had to focus much more on making a really good weather app, and then because the complications on the watch face update throughout the day, I had to, instead of having it be paid up front only, I had to introduce a subscription.
0:28:06Because each weather data update that I do costs like a small, a very small amount of money, like one thousandth of a penny or something like that.
0:28:16And so if it's updating constantly throughout the day, every day automatically, eventually it's going to get to the point where it's going to cost me more than you paid for the original app.
0:28:29And so I was basically forced to start a subscription for people using the watch face complications.
0:28:36And as a little bonus feature, I just thought it'd be fun to have an option, be able to like flip a switch in the iPhone app and have a different, instead of just the weather, just the temperature and the weather condition, you could have a second complication on your watch face that showed the wind speed.
0:28:56And Carrot was actually the first app that had any kind of customizable complications.
0:29:01And that customization, it led to like a flurry of requests from people asking for like different data points.
0:29:10And then for me to carry that into the iPhone app as well.
0:29:14And that was really just like the genesis of that becoming more than just like a joke weather app and, and having all the, these customization features that it now has.
0:29:26That's when that started to take off.
0:29:28And when, when I started to feel like this was more than just like a joke app, like I could focus on this full time and I'd never run out of stuff, new stuff to add.
0:29:39Yeah.
0:29:40And, you know, I'm sure you've noticed, I mentioned it all the time.
0:29:43I'm an aficionado of weather apps.
0:29:45I just, I, I, I'm a real slut and I have a bunch.
0:29:48Carrot is one of them that I rotate between regularly and oftentimes somebody else, some app major update.
0:29:55Then I'll switch to that one for a while.
0:29:57And I enjoy, I continue to, and it's just as a user interface critic slash practitioner at times throughout my life, I find it fascinating how many approaches to presenting weather info information there are like it's so many different ways.
0:30:19And yeah, it's really one of the most personal kinds of apps that you can have because I mean, everybody cares about the temperature, but tons of people care about the feels like temperature.
0:30:33And are you going to have that in the app, like front and center?
0:30:37Are you going to have it focus on like visuals, like the current weather conditions outside?
0:30:44Are you going to show it like when it's rainy and that kind of stuff?
0:30:46Are you going to show the wind speed?
0:30:48Tons of people that bike or do anything outside, they care a lot about the wind speed.
0:30:54But everybody else who doesn't do that doesn't.
0:30:57And so there's just so many different ways to do a weather app and so many different use personal use cases and other apps like like calendar apps or photo apps.
0:31:10They don't have that same kind of personal need to have a different interface.
0:31:17I mean, you know, I don't want to start naming good competitors, but but I think one of the things that separates carrot from the rest of its competition is that right out of the box.
0:31:29Like if somebody is listening to this episode and they're like, OK, I've heard a carrot over the time.
0:31:34Listening to Brian talk to John, I'm going to give it a try.
0:31:39Never tried it before.
0:31:40They download carrot weather to their iPhone right out of the box.
0:31:45You get a very carefully designed experience for the presentation of whether it looks.
0:31:51Oh, you know, even if it's not this isn't really for me.
0:31:56I think everybody would look at carrot right out of the box factory default experience and say this is a very carefully designed presentation of the weather.
0:32:06But it's also like a weather app construction kit, right, where you've got themes and theming options for customization where, like I said, it's like it's like getting a prebuilt Lego kit and it's already snapped together and it's in a certain way.
0:32:27But you could take the pieces apart and kind of make your own weather app out of it and or choose from other preset themes for the presentation of it.
0:32:36Like one of the things I was going for with that was there's Nintendo makes a version of Mario called Mario Maker.
0:32:44Yeah.
0:32:45Let's you build your own courses and everything.
0:32:48And so that was one of the the ideas that I had going into making this version of carrot that has this whole build your own layout thing.
0:32:57And it was this feeling that I got when I first launched the Apple Watch app was that there's just so many different ways to go.
0:33:04And this was like my holy grail of I would love to have an app where you can make your own weather app that is perfect for you.
0:33:13Yeah.
0:33:14And that is really what carrot is.
0:33:17And again, you don't have to if you don't want to spend that time.
0:33:20I'm sure, you know, like everything, you know, that appeals to power or any kind of app that scales from casual to power users.
0:33:31Most people are going to stick towards the casual user experience end of it.
0:33:36There's some kind of long tail graph of how far into the customization X percent of carrot users get.
0:33:44But I think it's so fun and cool that it's there.
0:33:50Right.
0:33:50And one app I just maybe it's top of mind because I just linked to an update.
0:33:54But James Thompson's P Calc, the calculator app, which is, again, you just if you just download it and launch it, you get a really cool looking calculator app for iPhone or for Mac.
0:34:07There's a bunch of themes to choose from.
0:34:09And if you want to make your own and customize like the layout of the buttons in your calculator, it's all there for you to play with.
0:34:16So you can make your own calculator.
0:34:18I that appeals to me.
0:34:20It's like why I write about this stuff is that sort of approach to making software where it's it's not just throwing the Lego pieces at the user and giving them an instruction.
0:34:35And now before you get anything useful, you have to build something yourself, which is a good way.
0:34:42There are things that are like that.
0:34:45I mean, arguably something even like Xcode is like that, right, like where you don't really get like there's default projects.
0:34:51But the whole point is to make your own thing.
0:34:54But I love the idea of an app that sort of has a good default presentation and usefulness, but that is customizable out the wazoo for the sort of user who has their own itch to scratch.
0:35:08But it was never going to sit down in Xcode and make their own weather app to do it.
0:35:13Right.
0:35:14And it's great now that it's done.
0:35:16But it was a nightmare to code.
0:35:18And especially when there's stuff like a big redesign, like with iOS 26, having to go through and and handle each of the different like sections and the different designs for each section and then making sure they all work together perfectly.
0:35:36And technically still, that was a lot of work that I was like picking myself for.
0:35:42So let's talk about the why you mentioned it.
0:35:49So if Carrot Weather is 10 years old, I presume then the original version was UIKit entirely.
0:35:55Because I don't think Swift UI came into being until 2019 or so.
0:36:03I want to say 2019 or 2019.
0:36:06What I remember year wise was that I think it was the last in-person year for WWDC.
0:36:15Because I presume it had to be UIKit entirely in Objective-C probably when it started.
0:36:25Where is the code base now in terms of nerdy stuff?
0:36:28Which language and which frameworks it's built using?
0:36:32I am ashamed to say that it's still almost entirely UIKit in Objective-C.
0:36:38I don't think that's anything to be ashamed about.
0:36:41But there might be something to the surname.
0:36:45Because I know my friend Gus Mueller of Flying Meat fame is still largely Acorn and RetroBatch, the image editing apps for Mac.
0:36:55I know Gus is still largely AppKit in Objective-C.
0:37:00Maybe entirely?
0:37:01So I don't know.
0:37:02Maybe there's something with the Mueller last name.
0:37:04But I don't think it's anything to be ashamed of.
0:37:08I mean, you build what you know.
0:37:09I mean, and I think.
0:37:10But have you looked at it?
0:37:12I know famously for podcast listeners, Marco Arment spent a lot of time rewriting Overcast in Swift and Swift UI over the last few years.
0:37:21It's difficult.
0:37:23Yeah, that's my thing is I have basically zero interest in rewriting something I've already done.
0:37:31I think for a lot of programmers that is fun, like refactoring stuff to make it more efficient and make it better.
0:37:38But I just like working on new stuff.
0:37:40So like the idea of porting my app to different platforms.
0:37:44Like I've tried that before with Android and I just get sick of it after a few weeks just because it's doing something that I've already done just isn't exciting to me.
0:37:56And so having to do that for Swift, I mean, there's there's definitely benefits to it, but it's just redoing stuff that I've already done.
0:38:05And that's not that isn't very motivating to me.
0:38:09And but I mean, I do have plenty of Swift code in places where I basically have to use it and Swift UI in places where I have to use it.
0:38:17Like the Apple Watch app is entirely Swift UI because it has to be now and widgets and live activities.
0:38:25Those all have to be in Swift UI.
0:38:26And so I'm comfortable enough with it now where I definitely if I was going to do a new app, I could do it in Swift and Swift UI.
0:38:35But in terms of the stuff that's already written until I have to do it, I think I'm probably going to keep it an objective say.
0:38:42Yeah, I can't blame you from an end user's perspective.
0:38:46There's no way to know, right?
0:38:47Like there are certain things that me as a persnickety user can tell.
0:38:53Like I can pretty much sniff out very quickly when an app isn't native at all, right?
0:38:59That it's I don't know what this is, but it's it's not it's not native.
0:39:03Whereas with Carrot, I had no idea.
0:39:05You could have told me I've starting around 2022, I rewrote the whole thing in Swift or no.
0:39:11Like you said, like the large parts of it that were written in UIKit and Objective-C are still UIKit and Objective-C.
0:39:18There's no way to tell as a user, right?
0:39:20Yeah, I mean, yeah, that's definitely true.
0:39:23Earlier versions of Carrot Weather that didn't look like really native iOS apps, they had more of like a game design to them.
0:39:32Those could have easily been written in something else entirely.
0:39:36But definitely the current version of Carrot Weather really looks like a native iOS app.
0:39:43Yeah, absolutely.
0:39:44So how did you find working with updating it for iOS 26 and Liquid Glass?
0:39:51It actually, I thought it came very naturally to Carrot Weather.
0:39:55All the new UI components slotted in very easily.
0:39:59And I didn't have any significant issues with legibility or anything like that in the app.
0:40:05I liked how it looked almost right away.
0:40:08So I was very happy with it.
0:40:10Yeah, I have to say, and it's not out of beta yet, and probably won't be by the time this episode drops.
0:40:20But iOS 26.1, the second-to-last developer beta, introduced a preference, not hidden in accessibility, but right in settings display, liquid glass, between clear and tinted.
0:40:37And it's funny, I find it funny because so many people clearly want that tinted preference.
0:40:45And I tried it for a full week, and now I'm back on clear, and I think I like the default clear better, even though I'm certainly not one to hold my tongue regarding disliking Apple design directions.
0:40:58I actually like the clear look, system-wide.
0:41:01Have you played with that setting, system-wide?
0:41:03Yeah, I played around with it, and I personally like the clear glass as well.
0:41:09I think it looks new and fun.
0:41:11And when I went back, like during development season, when I'd go back to my device that was still on iOS 18, it just felt dated by that point.
0:41:21Yeah.
0:41:22I mean, once you get used to something, I guess, that's new, going back feels old.
0:41:29Yeah.
0:41:29I kind of, I have complaints about liquid glass.
0:41:36And I know I had Louis Manchin on the show a couple weeks ago or mid-summer, and we, especially Louis, but we both kind of vented about what we didn't like about liquid glass overall, especially on the Mac.
0:41:50And there are things, I stand behind it all.
0:41:52It's not like I've changed my mind.
0:41:55It's just, there's a lot to like and a lot to dislike.
0:41:58And I feel like a lot of the stuff that there is to dislike is such low-hanging fruit and is sort of like, how can anybody at Apple not see this?
0:42:10But on the whole, overall, I do think it's better.
0:42:14And I think that the great flattening of iOS 7 11 years ago was way too flat and kept everything, kept the third dimension out of the UI too much for too long.
0:42:29And I think it's not just that this is new and iOS 18 is old and the old always kind of looks stale.
0:42:36I think this is overall better.
0:42:38It's a better look.
0:42:40And it does the flatness going back to iOS 18, which I still have on my last year's iPhone.
0:42:47I still, for comparison's sake, I've got new iPhones running iOS 26 and my year-old iPhone still running iOS 18.7, whatever.
0:42:58Going back, it's not just that it looks old.
0:43:01It just looks what I've always felt in my gut that they weren't trying hard enough, right?
0:43:07That this is, that they're just, that Apple is so full of talented UI designers and artists.
0:43:15And so, why are they seemingly making these user interfaces with one arm tied behind their back?
0:43:23Right.
0:43:24And I imagine that a lot of these low-hanging fruit are going to be worked on over the course of the year.
0:43:31And then we're going to see a lot of change 27, 28.
0:43:36And just like we did with iOS 7 to 8 to 9, 10.
0:43:40And we're going to look back at this as just like the beginning of a change in the iOS design line.
0:43:48And it's just going to take a little while to get there.
0:43:50And so, basically, though, you didn't think it was, you didn't find it too hard to update Carrot for iOS 26.
0:43:57It was more work than I thought it was going to be.
0:44:02I thought that it was just going to be like change the tab bar, change the nav bar in the code, and I was basically going to be done.
0:44:10But there was a lot of work just because of all the different customization that you can do in Carrot.
0:44:16And so, there were just so many different – I had to touch basically every single screen in the whole app and every single view.
0:44:24So, that part was a lot of work.
0:44:26But it all came naturally.
0:44:28There wasn't anything where I was like stuck on the design and like, how do I make this look good?
0:44:33I didn't have anything like that.
0:44:36Do you think that's part of the – how much of that is just the nature of Apple moving its own platforms forward versus the almost never-ending well of just weather apps in general?
0:44:52Even if Apple stopped moving their platforms forward, there's so much you can still do with the weather app as a genre.
0:44:58But how much does Apple moving the platforms forward just sort of – okay, you've got this hit app.
0:45:06It is the app, the subscriptions for which are running the business that is your career.
0:45:13And just keeping up with the way the platforms change and evolve takes you a year before it's next year and now there's a whole new setup of APIs or even platforms, right?
0:45:27Does Carrot have a vision app?
0:45:30Yeah, there's a vision app and a Mac app and a CarPlay app and – yeah, I'm on all the different Apple platforms.
0:45:37Right.
0:45:39And even that might be getting – stretching the limits of a one-person development shop, right?
0:45:45Let alone the – do you get requests on a regular basis for an Android version?
0:45:50Yeah, I get requests to do that and update what I have, but that's definitely outside of my ability to keep up with doing a completely separate platform and a different language and different design language and all that kind of stuff.
0:46:09All right.
0:46:09And how much do you think that by being – embracing the native APIs has set you up to be able to adopt Apple's new stuff on a regular basis, right?
0:46:24Because I think that's the thing that gets lost amongst non-developer laypeople when the discussion comes up about users preferring or like critical users and reviewers like me advocating for truly native apps for the Apple platform.
0:46:43It's not just for arbitrary reasons or some kind of – I don't know, religious purity.
0:46:50There's practical benefits to it on an ongoing basis where if you're a devoted Carrot user, you end up with things like a Vision OS app pretty early on or support for live activities or something like that early on.
0:47:08How much of it helps that you're kind of doing things the Apple recommended way?
0:47:14I think it helps a tremendous amount because if I had to – if I was using some other like intermediate platform, you'd have to just wait around for them to update all their stuff to work with the new stuff.
0:47:28And one of the things that I think has made Carrot so successful is that I do embrace the new stuff as soon as it comes out.
0:47:37Like every – like all my users can rely every year, launch day of the new operating system to have all of that stuff integrated into Carrot and have all the cool new features built into the app.
0:47:52And it's just a lot of fun for me to work on the new stuff over the summer and find fun and interesting ways to put it into the app.
0:48:01And users love it too.
0:48:06Right, and yet you don't have to appeal to everybody, right?
0:48:11That the overall user base, the slice of the user base of iPhone users who might consider a paid subscription to a weather app is relatively small compared to the billion-plus total iPhone users.
0:48:27But even just a few percent of a billion users is a potential audience of a lot of people, right?
0:48:33And in that group, you're hitting the sort of people who want things like – who are aware.
0:48:40I mean like in the general world, there's a lot of iPhone users who don't even know what a live activity is.
0:48:46Even if they have them on their phone because they have an app that supports it, they don't know what it is.
0:48:51They just know – I don't know.
0:48:52At some point, they started getting sports scores on their lock screen.
0:48:55I don't know.
0:48:56Who knows where it came from?
0:48:57But there it is.
0:48:58But then there's the sort of nerdy users who might be listening to this show who are like, yeah, as soon as Apple announced that at WWDC, I couldn't wait to have it on my iPhone.
0:49:08And it's perfect for a weather app because I live somewhere where we get – it's not Cupertino where it's 72 and sunny every day.
0:49:15The weather's all over the place where I live.
0:49:17Yeah, I think that there's definitely two big user bases there and finding ways to get those users who aren't in on all the latest marketing terms, finding ways to surface those features for them and explain them in a way that makes sense without using those marketing terms and expect them to know what they are.
0:49:44It's a tricky path to figure out, especially with the new releases and being there on day one and not having examples to like crib off of.
0:49:57That's always been one of the exciting things for me to go off on a tangent is like making the Vision OS app or the Apple Watch app back in 2015 and not having examples to go off of and basically having to figure it all out for myself.
0:50:12And not having anybody like in my company to talk to, to talk this stuff through with and say, is this a good idea or am I making a dumb decision?
0:50:21That's always been like a frustrating thing, but also like a fun thing at the same time for me.
0:50:29One of the other things that characterizes the weather app category is that there is a tremendous amount of competition.
0:50:36It is.
0:50:37There aren't many app categories.
0:50:42I mean, there's things like productivity, right?
0:50:44And there's all sorts of apps and productivity.
0:50:47Weather apps is a category unto itself.
0:50:50And it's guess what's in it?
0:50:52Weather apps.
0:50:53I mean, there are different types of weather apps.
0:50:55But for the most part, they're apps that tell you the weather, where you are or at a list of saved locations.
0:51:02And there are a lot of them.
0:51:04Do you how much of an advantage do you think it is, though, that a lot of the ones and I was just as we record this carrot is number 10 in the weather app category, which is pretty good, I think, for a paid app.
0:51:18And to be clear, I can't tell.
0:51:22It's one of the frustrations when you're already a user of an app.
0:51:25I presume you can download it for free now, right?
0:51:27Yeah, you can download it for free now.
0:51:29And you get some kind of free trial.
0:51:31The app's free to use.
0:51:33And then there's ads, but they are, in carrot fashion, they are fake ads.
0:51:40So they're not paid for by any company.
0:51:44And there's no tracking involved or anything like that.
0:51:47They're all in the voice of the app.
0:51:49I've never seen fake ads.
0:51:51That is totally the most carrot way to do a free version.
0:51:58And the idea is, if you want to make these fake ads go away, you subscribe.
0:52:03Yes.
0:52:05And so that's one of the features that you get.
0:52:07If you subscribe, you can get rid of the fake app.
0:52:10How much of a leg up do you think you have, though, that so much of the competition,
0:52:15so many of, even though there are a zillion weather apps for iPhone, that most of them
0:52:20are ugly and cross-platform and don't support, aren't quick to adopt new features for the
0:52:29platform, et cetera, et cetera.
0:52:32I think it definitely helps that carrot is a good-looking app somehow.
0:52:40I was able to figure out a way to make a decent-looking weather app and code it, and that it has all
0:52:47those nice features and everything, and that it is updated regularly.
0:52:52I think that that definitely helps.
0:52:54I'm surprised that such ugly apps can be so popular still, but I guess there's a lot of
0:53:03people with bad taste still out.
0:53:05Or no taste, right?
0:53:08Which, I guess, is sort of a different thing, right?
0:53:11Yeah, they just don't care.
0:53:12Right.
0:53:13Just slide the political slider here to the liberal side.
0:53:16But I would say Donald Trump objectively has bad taste, right?
0:53:20He likes gold, right?
0:53:21Look at what...
0:53:22Let's just put everything else aside and just look at what he's done with the Oval Office.
0:53:26He has bad taste.
0:53:28Very bad taste.
0:53:29Not no taste.
0:53:30Bad taste.
0:53:31There's a very certain aesthetic that he prefers, and it is kind of horrible.
0:53:37Whereas, I'll bet, again, just to go the other way, I don't think Joe Biden had a particular
0:53:41aesthetic, right?
0:53:42He just sort of, yeah, I want an Oval Office that looks like the Oval Office, you know what
0:53:47I mean?
0:53:47Right.
0:53:48Yeah.
0:53:49I mean, I was there.
0:53:50I got to visit the Oval Office in October of last year, and my sister has a...
0:54:00She worked in the Biden White House, and so we got to have a tour.
0:54:04Wow, that's amazing.
0:54:06I did not know this.
0:54:07I just happened to bring that up as an example.
0:54:09What did you think when you were there?
0:54:11I thought it was amazing getting to see it, and I'm so glad I got to see it before what
0:54:17has happened to it.
0:54:19But yeah, I mean, it's just amazing getting to see a building with such history.
0:54:24Right.
0:54:25And a room, right.
0:54:26It's a little icon.
0:54:28Does it feel when you're in it?
0:54:30Does it feel like it's oval-shaped?
0:54:32It does.
0:54:34When you see photographs, you can tell the room is round, but you can't tell that it's
0:54:39not a circle.
0:54:40There's no way to photograph an Oval from within the Oval.
0:54:46Yeah, that's true.
0:54:47Yeah, it is.
0:54:48It is a little strange being there, and it's just crazy and amazing how much history is
0:54:55in there and how cool it is to, like, it almost feels like you're stepping onto a movie set.
0:55:01It must, right.
0:55:04I've taken, when I was a kid, like, in junior, yeah, I guess junior high, we had a field
0:55:09trip, like a multi-day field trip to Washington, D.C., and we took a White House tour, but when
0:55:14the kids come through in the middle of a weekday, you don't typically get to see the Oval Office.
0:55:20I think we mostly were in the East Wing, R.I.P., and I think the good news about Trump's modifications
0:55:28to the Oval Office is that they're just held up on the wall with Elmer's glue, so I don't
0:55:33think it's going to take a lot of work to snap them off.
0:55:38Anyway, let me use that as a perfect segue to talk about our second sponsor of the show,
0:55:43our good friends at Squarespace.
0:55:44Squarespace is the all-in-one platform for building your presence on the web, and they offer everything,
0:55:54soup to nuts, that you need to get a website online, everything from registering a domain
0:55:59name and managing your domain name to picking the features you want on the website to editing
0:56:06the website to editing the content on the website to modifying the design of the website by picking
0:56:11from a bunch of pre-built themes or creating your own theme from scratch, using CSS and JavaScript
0:56:17to code your own website if you're an expert like that, or using AI with their new design
0:56:24intelligence feature to sort of modify one of the existing templates just by chatting with
0:56:30AI like you do with ChatGPT to modify the website or change it in the ways you want.
0:56:36They keep moving Squarespace forward in so many different ways.
0:56:40They've got Squarespace payments.
0:56:42It is the easiest way to manage your payments in one place.
0:56:45You can get started with a few clicks, and whether you are selling a product or like T-shirts or
0:56:51something like that, or if you're like a consultant or something like that or a trainer and you sell
0:56:57your time, you can do that through Squarespace payments.
0:57:01All of it is through there.
0:57:02They have invoicing now, their whole invoicing system, so you can, if you're doing something
0:57:07like that with training or consulting, some kind of client work, you can do all the invoicing
0:57:13through your Squarespace website.
0:57:15Your clients, your customers get an invoice.
0:57:18They go to your website to pay the invoice, and the payments go through Squarespace payments
0:57:22all in one, very easy to use.
0:57:24You do not need to be a technical user in any way, but if you are a technical user, it scales
0:57:30to your level of expertise at what level you want to jump in.
0:57:34Where do you go to find out more?
0:57:35Go to squarespace.com, and you get a free 30-day trial with no limits, no watermarks on the site
0:57:42that you build.
0:57:42Spend a whole month making the website you want to make just the way you want it, and
0:57:47when it's the free demo period's over, go to squarespace.com slash talkshow, squarespace.com
0:57:53slash talkshow, and with that code, you save 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain.
0:58:00My thanks to Squarespace.
0:58:03So we left off there talking, Brian, talking about third-party weather competitors in the
0:58:09app store, and Carrot seems to have eked out its own space.
0:58:14The other gorilla, the 800-pound gorilla in the room, though, is that you're competing against
0:58:20the first party, Apple weather.
0:58:21And I think at this point, I was thinking about it in preparation for interviewing you for the
0:58:26show, I'm trying to think of popular third-party apps that don't have a competitor from Apple,
0:58:36and it's a pretty short list, right?
0:58:38Like, the truth is that as time has gone on, you know, and I'm old enough, I remember like
0:58:45in the classic Mac era of the 90s, Apple hardly made any apps at all, and the default Mac system
0:58:52didn't come with apps from Apple.
0:58:55And that was a deliberate choice by Apple that, hey, we make the platform, third-party
0:59:01developers make the apps.
0:59:02But it left Apple in a position where effectively their pants were kind of down, where they didn't
0:59:07have their own web browser, so they needed to license somebody, and then they ended up
0:59:11being, after Jobs came back, Internet Explorer.
0:59:13They didn't have an email client, so they got Claris email.
0:59:18Now, and Claris is a subsidiary of Apple, but emailer didn't start as a Claris product.
0:59:24It was an acquisition, and then they just were like, we're just going to stick it on all new
0:59:28Macs.
0:59:28Because it got to the point where it was absurd to be selling a computer that didn't have an
0:59:33email client built in.
0:59:34Somehow, you fast forward from, oh my God, now there's an email client built into the Mac?
0:59:41That's weird.
0:59:42That's unfair to the other email clients, to today where there's a notes calendar, a
0:59:48contacts app, and guess what?
0:59:50I don't know if you've heard of it, but the iPhone comes with an app called Weather.
0:59:54Yes.
0:59:55And it's pretty good, right?
1:00:00Yeah.
1:00:01So how do you see that relationship between you as a third-party carrot app developer and
1:00:08the fact that there is a pretty good weather app built in?
1:00:10I think that the relationship has been great.
1:00:15I've talked to the developers at Apple who work on the weather app, and I do think that
1:00:21they've done a great job of making a good starter weather app that millions or billions of users
1:00:29can be perfectly happy with.
1:00:31And it has gotten better on successive releases of iOS.
1:00:37But when they first announced it, I was a little bit worried, but it hasn't ended up being a problem.
1:00:49So I think the competition is good.
1:00:52And I think that having stock Apple apps that are good enough for a lot of people, but then I think it drives people to find apps that are better or at least better for certain use cases to the app store to find something better that works for them.
1:01:12And the other thing that's sort of unique to Apple and weather is Apple's acquisition of dark sky.
1:01:20I forget how many years ago now at this point, but turning that acquisition into a built-in set of weather APIs, which carrot can optionally use.
1:01:31I mean, I'm not sure there is a third-party weather app that doesn't at least offer it.
1:01:38Let me ask you this.
1:01:41Which weather service that carrot offers is the default, and does it vary by region?
1:01:48It doesn't vary by region.
1:01:50The default is called Forica, and they are one of the leading weather APIs out there.
1:01:59They're very accurate worldwide on a different location.
1:02:03And then you can optionally upgrade to use – I've lost track of how many weather data providers I have in the app now, but there's –
1:02:13I'm looking at the preferences.
1:02:14Forica, Apple Weather, AccuWeather, Tomorrow.io, XWeather, which I've never heard of, and OpenWeather.
1:02:22That's – you may have heard of their – the previous name that they went under.
1:02:27They were ErisWeather.
1:02:28Oh, I did hear that.
1:02:30I do remember that.
1:02:31So that's XWeather.
1:02:32Mm-hmm.
1:02:33Yeah.
1:02:34Why do you think Apple added Apple Weather as a data source?
1:02:40That's a good question.
1:02:43I imagine it's because so many developers rely – they knew that so many developers relied on Dark Sky, and I think that they wanted to have – by buying a weather data API, they wanted to be able to offer that to developers of the platform.
1:03:01It's not free of charge for developers to use, but you can pay for it, and it has a bunch of great use cases for developers on the platform outside of just making a weather app.
1:03:15Right.
1:03:15And so I think it was a win-win for them.
1:03:19They get an API that they can build into their app that they can control, and they don't have to worry about another third-party weather data provider, just like they didn't have to worry about another Maps provider once they stood up on the map.
1:03:32And then they can also offer that same data to developers so that they can make great apps out of it.
1:03:40Yeah, I think it was first – my theory is that it was first for themselves.
1:03:45And again, my general theory of how Apple operates is that Apple's priorities are Apple first, users second, developers third.
1:03:54And they do care about all three, but that's the order, and that order isn't going to change.
1:03:59And I kind of feel like the dark sky acquisition and turning it into an Apple weather API service fits that perfectly, where it's Apple first, where they absolutely need a pretty good weather app built in to the system and didn't want to be beholden to anybody else anywhere in the world.
1:04:23The same reason with Maps, right?
1:04:25And Maps – weather never got to a problematic state like Maps did at the crisis point where Apple felt like they needed to launch Apple Maps in 2011, I think.
1:04:382011 or – yeah, it was – or maybe 2012 because Steve Jobs was dead, I guess.
1:04:44So that's why Scott Forstall got forced out, not just because of weather, but because of the personality clash behind all of that.
1:04:54But that Apple – Google had them by the short hairs, where the license that Apple had for Google Maps didn't involve vector map tiles.
1:05:05They were just bitmaps, so that scaling was a problem.
1:05:08And it didn't involve, crucially, turn-by-turn directions, which at this point, it seems ridiculous.
1:05:15It's like talking about the fact that the original iPhone in 2007, the camera didn't even shoot video.
1:05:20It wasn't like it shot bad video.
1:05:21It just did still photos.
1:05:23It didn't shoot video.
1:05:24And you think, is that real?
1:05:25And it's like, yeah, that was real.
1:05:26And it didn't have a front-facing camera.
1:05:28And you're like, it didn't have any selfie camera?
1:05:31Nope.
1:05:31It just had a camera on the back.
1:05:33That's how phones were at the time.
1:05:35And, yeah, the Maps app didn't do directions.
1:05:39Well, then it's like, what did you use the Maps app for?
1:05:42Like, all I use the Maps for are directions.
1:05:44And it's like, oh, you used it to see where things were.
1:05:47And so to get all that from Google, Google was asking for way more information about users' location.
1:05:54And they're having them sign into their Google account so they could track them that Apple was comfortable giving.
1:05:59And they knew that their own offering wasn't ready.
1:06:02And I kind of feel like they took that lesson to heart.
1:06:06And I think that before weather could ever become a crisis situation like that, they were like, we've got the money.
1:06:13We can own and operate our own weather service.
1:06:16But then from a user's perspective, I think it was the benefit of by offering it to developers, there would be.
1:06:25And I think there are a lot of – probably most, if we actually dissected them, most of the weather apps available for iOS, I think if you explained what they do privacy-wise for the user – and, yes, they agree to it.
1:06:41They agree to share their location because it's a weather app.
1:06:44But the way that those apps will sell or let – do sort of squishy, make you feel a little gross marketing things with the data from the user, I think would make people very surprised to find out that all these weather apps are like that.
1:07:03But at least with Apple Weather as a Service, there's an option for developers to make an app that doesn't impede upon users' privacy at all.
1:07:15So it's kind of good for users and developers.
1:07:17And like you said, it's there for – like if you have a calendar app or something like that, you could integrate with Apple Weather.
1:07:24It's not a weather app first, but you could show the daily weather with a couple of calls to the weather APIs.
1:07:30And it's right there, and you don't have to build in a third-party SDK that might be expensive and it might be privacy-invasive.
1:07:38Yeah, I don't know what the internal discussions were around it, but I've always just gotten the sense that if Apple is going to make something themselves and make it available on the platform,
1:07:52they're not going to just hold it back from developers just for fun and to keep it to themselves.
1:07:57And so I was always hopeful that if they were going to turn the Dark Sky API into an Apple API, that they would then offer that to developers as well.
1:08:10Do you – so I just checked.
1:08:13My carrot weather, I'm using the default weather provider, FORECA.
1:08:18I would have guessed it was FORECA, but I guess it's F-O-R-E-C-A.
1:08:23FORECA, I guess, makes more sense.
1:08:25It's probably a shortening of forecast, I assume.
1:08:28Yeah, but then maybe there's no middle syllable in there.
1:08:31I don't actually know the pronunciation.
1:08:35I don't know, but I'm always willing to bet that my guess is wrong.
1:08:39But one of the reasons I like using multiple weather apps is I like getting different forecasts if I'm flipping around, if there is weather going on.
1:08:48But do you get the Dark Sky-style precipitation alerts through all the services or are those you need to Apple?
1:08:56I actually do that myself now.
1:08:59So I am doing something similar to what Dark Sky did with taking multiple frames of radar data and then extrapolating out where the motion fields are.
1:09:13Right.
1:09:13And then using that to basically fast-forward the radar and get an idea of the next hour's rainfall for a particular location and then send that all out via notifications so you can get a notification when it's going to start or stop raining.
1:09:29And also, I have now the live activities that can auto-start and stay on your lock screen with a rain chart, which I think is much more useful than it.
1:09:38Yeah, I do too.
1:09:40And as you know, being local, it's been sort of a rainy, crappy week, and it's been spot on.
1:09:46And I've been paying, knowing that I wanted to have you on the show, I've been paying attention.
1:09:50They've been spot on.
1:09:51And last night, it was like, I remember I was in the living room with my wife, and it said, rain's going to start in 10 minutes.
1:09:56And I was like, ah, it didn't look like rain when I was out.
1:09:58And lo and behold, about 10 minutes later, it started to rain.
1:10:00Kind of a, it's one of those little things, like when Dark Sky first started doing it, it was like, holy shit, this is amazing, right?
1:10:10Like, yeah, it felt like the future.
1:10:11I remember it from the second Back to the Future movie.
1:10:15Yeah.
1:10:15Christopher Lloyd knowing when it was going to stop raining.
1:10:18Right, exactly.
1:10:20And people love to complain about, it's just sort of a trope, long lines at the post office.
1:10:28The weatherman's always wrong.
1:10:30But it's like, actually, weather forecasting has gotten remarkably good overall.
1:10:35And it's nowhere near as spotty as decades ago.
1:10:39And right down to the fact that these alerts that Dark Sky kind of pioneered for like, very, very local to your specific location, precipitation alerts, are, it's sort of like table stakes at this point.
1:10:55You expect to get them somehow.
1:10:56And they no longer blow my mind.
1:10:59They're like, I only really took notice of the one last night because I knew I was going to have you on the show today.
1:11:05And I was like, oh, I should remember this and tell them that it nailed it to the minute.
1:11:10But it's funny how once you get used to something, no matter how amazing it is.
1:11:14I mean, just the fact that we have these phones in our pockets with us all the time.
1:11:17Little pocket Unix computers with, yeah, well, of course we do, right?
1:11:22Right.
1:11:23But even just, if you just go back 10 years, 10 years was 2015.
1:11:28And looking at the phones that we have today and all the stuff that we have today, like ChatGPT and Apple Watch and the Vision headset, you wouldn't be able to imagine that back then.
1:11:40All the different little nice things that we have today that weren't there.
1:11:44Yeah.
1:11:44So you mentioned ChatGPT.
1:11:47One of the questions I have for you is one of the ways that I feel like Carrot, the whole idea, the gimmick, and again, I don't mean gimmick to be diminishing.
1:11:56I think you've carved out this very unique brand for Carrot Weather that is a huge part of its success.
1:12:06So I just don't know what other word to use, though.
1:12:10Because a gimmick can be a big part of the brand.
1:12:13But the idea of it being driven by a sentient AI 10 years ago was very far, seemed far-fetched.
1:12:26And while the voice, and again, I kind of always thought you were using Apple's default female robot-ish voice because it sounded familiar.
1:12:36And you hear it in gags on TV and in movies all the time.
1:12:40But the personality was clearly coming from you, the author of the app.
1:12:44That this was not a sentient AI that's calling me a meatbag.
1:12:49But here we are 10 years later, and there are things like ChatGPT.
1:12:53And it actually, I don't think you would get anything nearly as funny as the Carrot UI.
1:12:58But you could have a ChatGPT-driven actual AI personality, right?
1:13:05Like, you're kind of ahead of the curve on this.
1:13:07And have you considered having actual AI drive the personality?
1:13:13I mean, I've tried to get ChatGPT to write jokes for Carrot just to give me more breadth.
1:13:19And it kind of fails at that still.
1:13:23It's able to do some really basic stuff, but it's not amazing at the humor part.
1:13:29But if one thing that I've built into the app is the ability to chat with Carrot via ChatGPT.
1:13:37And every once in a while, when you're talking, and so I give it instructions to talk basically like a snarky weather robot.
1:13:47And every once in a while, when you're having a conversation with it, it will come up with something funny and actually feel really like the Carrot character.
1:14:00So I think in a few years, it would basically be able to write stuff that is indistinguishable from me and be able to do a lot of that work for me.
1:14:11Is this your retirement plan?
1:14:13Just work until the AI can write all the jokes for you?
1:14:18I don't know that the jokes are ever going to come from AI.
1:14:21I mean, famous last words.
1:14:24I think one of the ways that it has helped me with that is being able to give me ideas like every once in a while, I'll be like, like one of the things for writing comedy is like a rules of three and having a list of three funny thing or a list of three things.
1:14:42And then the third thing is like the funny option.
1:14:44And so I'll ask ChatDBT for like a bunch of funny options that would fit this.
1:14:49And sometimes that'll give me like a good idea.
1:14:52But for being able to actually write a brand new joke, it's not able to do that yet.
1:14:59Yeah, there was always a there was always a certain pattern to the Dave Letterman top 10 lists.
1:15:04For example, number one was never funny.
1:15:06And it wasn't supposed to be funny.
1:15:08It was sort of like because the band start as soon as he says number one, the band starts playing and they can't hear commercial.
1:15:15Yeah.
1:15:16And so it's supposed to be like really stupid.
1:15:19It's that was and then that it actually became funny that number one was never funny.
1:15:24But there is sort of a pace to to it and something like that.
1:15:29The third item in the list needs to be the funny one, because if you don't want to if you make it number one, then it's the rest of them.
1:15:35There's nobody's going to read them and it somehow doesn't work.
1:15:39It's do you worry that that the rise of actual A.I.
1:15:47I mean, it's all anybody can almost talk about in tech these days.
1:15:52Take some of the shine off the carrot gimmick.
1:15:56Or do you think that because you came at the right time and it's already established, it's actually sort of bolstering it?
1:16:04Do you mean in the sense that everybody's scared of A.I.
1:16:08Yeah, exactly.
1:16:10And people are going to want a joke version of an A.I.
1:16:13that's taking over when actual A.I.
1:16:15are taking over?
1:16:16Yeah.
1:16:18I'm not I don't think I'm to that or that they'll be confused or even that they won't get it.
1:16:23Right.
1:16:23That new users are going to be like they might rather than just assume that it's a joke, they might think it actually is A.I., which I guess doesn't matter if they actually think it is A.I.
1:16:34Yeah, I think it's obviously funny enough that it isn't and it's obviously over the top in terms of it being like she wants to like kill everybody and all that kind of stuff.
1:16:51It's not like an A.I.
1:16:53That's trying to masquerade as human and that kind of thing.
1:16:57So I think I'm a little bit safe there for now until until the A.I.
1:17:02actually is a bit more open with with its plan with ChatGPT being more open with its plans.
1:17:07Right.
1:17:08Actual ChatGPT personality, which to me has informed the personalities of all its competitors, is this obsequious deferential approach to humanity.
1:17:22It stops just short of addressing us as master.
1:17:26Right.
1:17:27Right.
1:17:27It's just like what I was talking about with when I first created Carrot back in 2013 with all the apps being so over the top deferential and and positive and all that kind of stuff.
1:17:39Yeah.
1:17:40You see the same thing with ChatGPT and all the other A.I.
1:17:43agents today just being so, so deferential to people.
1:17:48What a great question.
1:17:50That's a fantastic question, Brian.
1:17:56Yeah.
1:17:56And so instead having this personality that the core of the Carrot personality is I would define it as a very comfortable in its complete sense of superiority to the human race.
1:18:10Yeah.
1:18:12Yeah.
1:18:13I think that that still sets it apart.
1:18:15It's sort of its perspective is is sort of mild resentment at living a life of being forced to address these.
1:18:25Ant like intelligence meatbags who are holding these cell phones, asking for the weather and sort of looking forward to our demise, which all things considered, we're probably closer to than we were when Carrot started 10 years ago.
1:18:43To be honest, yes, it's been a good, good 10 years for carrots personality, which sadly doesn't actually exist.
1:18:54Well, you mentioned the phrase, last but not least, I want to mention this because it is you mentioned the phrase over the top.
1:19:00And I can't think of anything you've ever done with Carrot weather or Carrot anything that is more over the top than launching a musical.
1:19:14Which again, if you, I'm sure a lot of people out there are Carrot users who are listening and they know exactly what I'm talking about, but then there's a lot who either aren't or are irregular Carrot users.
1:19:25And I mean, and I mean it, you've commissioned an entire musical that is unlocked song by song as you use Carrot weather.
1:19:34Tell me more.
1:19:35Yeah, it was this crazy thing that I was just playing around with different ideas and it was actually an AI thing that I was playing around with.
1:19:46And you can input lyrics and it'll create a song for you.
1:19:50And I was just playing around with it thinking, oh, it'd be fun to have a song from Carrot in there.
1:19:57And just completely by accident, I put something in and it sounded like a Broadway musical.
1:20:03And I was like, oh my God, this would be amazing to do like an entire Broadway musical in the app with a bunch of songs written or done by Carrot, the character.
1:20:16And then I got the idea to have some songs that were sung by me, by quote unquote me.
1:20:23And then, so I ended up being the villain in the musical and Carrot's the hero.
1:20:29But it's not you singing.
1:20:31No, it, the, the actual, the lyrics and everything are written by me, but the, the actual singing is done by AI.
1:20:40It's very good.
1:20:42So all the voices are AI, including the main woman's voice.
1:20:47Yeah, that, that's AI as well.
1:20:50And just to, and just to let people know, like song one on the soundtrack is titled, what the F is this?
1:20:55That's the, the, the people finding out about a weather app that makes fun of you.
1:21:04Yes.
1:21:04And so it's just been a ton of fun and it's just, it's the kind of thing that I think AI is perfect for being able to do things that you would never, ever be able to do.
1:21:20Like I'm not a music person with any kind of musical talent, but I can write.
1:21:24And so it's just unlocks a cool thing for me to be able to do it.
1:21:30I would never be able to do hire a bunch of singers and musicians and that kind of stuff.
1:21:36It would cost like half a million dollars or cost half a billion dollars.
1:21:41I don't know about that, but maybe, but yeah, it's, so it's not like using AI to produce this musical 15 song musical for Carrot was taking money or business away from Broadway style musical performers and conductors and musicians.
1:22:04It never would have happened in the first place.
1:22:06Right.
1:22:06And meanwhile, now there's this incredibly fun and funny things in the middle of, of an already funny weather app.
1:22:16And I have to admit when it first prompted me with an alert for it, I guess a couple of weeks ago, it coincides, it seemed to have launched with the iOS 26 version.
1:22:26Am I right?
1:22:27Or is that just, I really thought, well, what is it really going to be when I tap this?
1:22:33You know, what is really going to happen?
1:22:37I'm going to tap this, but what's really going to happen?
1:22:40And then it was really a song.
1:22:42What the F is this?
1:22:43That is about clearly by and about carrot weather.
1:22:47And I was like, holy shit, he did it.
1:22:49Like how much more of this is there?
1:22:51And it's 15 songs.
1:22:53It's kind of crazy.
1:22:54Yeah.
1:22:56I wrote a few and then I just kept going.
1:22:59And I was like, this is the dumbest thing I've ever done, but that's when I knew that I should do it.
1:23:05All right.
1:23:05And the other thing I'm sad to report or perhaps unsurprisingly, so carrot has often as long had a series of quote unquote missions.
1:23:15I'm on mission one of 156, despite being a user of carrot for most of its lifetime.
1:23:24I don't do the missions.
1:23:25What are the missions?
1:23:27I don't get it.
1:23:28Those are basically like geographical.
1:23:31It's like a geographical quiz almost.
1:23:34So carrot will give like a clue.
1:23:36The first one's really easy to find the White House.
1:23:40I think it's a little bit more of a clue or a better phrased clue than that.
1:23:47But the first one is you have to find the White House.
1:23:49And so you have to go on Apple Maps and zoom in and find the White House.
1:23:55And then they just get progressively harder from there.
1:23:59And it has a bunch of, when you actually find the location, it has a mock encyclopedia entry written by Carrot that has like a bunch of like funny stuff in it.
1:24:11Speaking of being ahead of your time, now we have an entire encyclopedia written by an evil sentient AI construct.
1:24:23An actual evil AI.
1:24:25Right.
1:24:25I don't know which one's funnier.
1:24:28I suspect Carrot is actually funnier.
1:24:31I feel like Grokopedia is just sort of sad.
1:24:34Well, it is a lot for a weather app.
1:24:37So I don't feel that it is too surprising to find out that it is the sole focus of your career at this point.
1:24:49But it's fantastic that it's been going strong and still going as strong as ever 10 years in, which is great.
1:24:55It's truly, you and Carrot are truly, really, an indie development success story that I worry are getting fewer and far further between.
1:25:06But it's a great example of the last 10 years of a great indie success story.
1:25:11Anything else you want to say before we wrap up the show?
1:25:16Any other surprises, anything coming up that you want to mention?
1:25:19Or people just need to download Carrot and stay tuned.
1:25:22Yeah, I think people just need to stay tuned.
1:25:25I've got lots of fun ideas for where to take the app.
1:25:28And it just has been such a great experience.
1:25:32Like when I first came out with Carrot to Do, I thought I'd be able to work on this for a month or two or something like that.
1:25:40And I've just always been worried that the other shoe is going to drop and I'm going to have to go back to a real job.
1:25:46Right.
1:25:46But it's now been 12 years since that first app launched and 10 years of Carrot Weather.
1:25:55And still going strong.
1:25:56So it's been a really cool and crazy experience.
1:26:00Well, and it just seems, talking to you here on the show and just observing from afar, just from the release notes, it just seems like very fulfilling, fun work for you.
1:26:14And I can't ask for a better job.
1:26:16Right.
1:26:17I think it just shows.
1:26:19It just shows in the app.
1:26:21Your enthusiasm for it really shows.
1:26:24And it just makes me happy.
1:26:25I think that I've just always tried to make the app that I want to use and I don't chase trends and do stuff for users.
1:26:37I do stuff for myself.
1:26:38Right.
1:26:39And make the app that I want to use.
1:26:41And luckily for most people, that ends up working out for them.
1:26:45Right.
1:26:46And if you don't want a weather app infused with personality, guess what?
1:26:51You're in luck.
1:26:52There's one built into your phone and there's 5,000 of them in the app store.
1:26:56Or you can just turn off the personality and Carrot and use it as a regular weather app.
1:27:02Which I really, I do have, well, maybe it is, like I said, it's a Lego kit.
1:27:07I probably are some people who really love it that way, but I kind of feel like they're missing out.
1:27:12But it speaks to the breadth of Carrot's scope that it can even appeal to somebody who wants a very boring, unpersonalized weather app.
1:27:23There are a lot of people using just the professional side.
1:27:26Crazy.
1:27:27Well, I guess not crazy.
1:27:30Brian, thank you very much for your time.
1:27:32It's great to have you on the show finally.
1:27:34I really appreciate it and good luck going forward with Carrot Weather.
1:27:37Thank you so much for having me.
1:27:38It was great to be on.