0:00:00Dan, I forget, how long has it been since you've been on the show? I can look it up.
0:00:03Man, I don't even know. You could. What I know is that I think I either had an infant or no kid,
0:00:10and now I have a four-and-a-half-year-old who does Legos in his sleep, basically.
0:00:15The Lego budget has surpassed the food budget some weeks.
0:00:20Oh, wow. Episode 288 in 2020? No. Is that right?
0:00:27It might be. It might be.
0:00:28Jesus Christ. That's terrible.
0:00:30You know, I'm kind of off the Apple beat, although I'm still, obviously, reloading Daring Fireball.
0:00:35It's embarrassing. Whenever I look at my Safari tabs that are open, 30% of them are gray.
0:00:41That's very nice to hear. It's surprising how often that happens to me, too.
0:00:47Do you find yourself opening a bunch of your own tabs a lot because you're, like, referencing previous work?
0:00:53Totally, yeah. I have a rule now where, basically, at the end of the week, I just
0:00:57close the browser window, and whatever's gone is gone.
0:01:01Otherwise, there's just too many tabs.
0:01:04I should do that. I think I'm up to 434 tabs in Safari right now.
0:01:08And then I try to do it at the end of the month.
0:01:11I do it as, like, a last day of the month thing, and I missed last month.
0:01:14And now it's...
0:01:16Now I'm halfway through November, so I'm like, well, I might as well wait till after Thanksgiving
0:01:20and just clean up two months.
0:01:21The point where you can no longer tell which tab is which piece and you have to hover, that's
0:01:26to me when it's like, okay, this is no longer serving its purpose.
0:01:30Yeah, absolutely.
0:01:31Well, how's the new consumer doing?
0:01:34Let's just get it instead of saving them for the end.
0:01:37Yeah, so I'm almost seven years in to writing The New Consumer, which many of you, if you've
0:01:44been listening to the talk show as long as I have, I used to be the tech correspondent at
0:01:50Silicon Alley Insider starting in 2007, which became Business Insider.
0:01:55And I was writing about Apple starting really full-time in 07.
0:02:00And then I had a site called Splat F, which was kind of my Apple-focused site.
0:02:05And then I went on to work at Quartz, and then I was the editor-in-chief of Recode.
0:02:08And then I started The New Consumer in 2019.
0:02:12And basically, it's my column, newsletter, whatever you want to call it, about the collision of
0:02:18the tech world and the consumer world.
0:02:20I've always been obsessed with consumer products and brands and e-commerce.
0:02:24And the tech beat kind of got a little dull for me around the 2018-2019 time frame.
0:02:32So I still write about Apple sometimes.
0:02:34And I did a big piece on the Apple Watch earlier this year.
0:02:37I realized I'd worn it every day for 10 years after it launched.
0:02:40And a lot of my work now is doing consumer insights and research.
0:02:45So I do surveys, and I try to understand, for example, the Apple Watch thing was half my
0:02:50review, and then half a bunch of data I had from a consumer survey I did about how Apple
0:02:54Watch users have literally changed their lives because of the watch.
0:02:58And that tracked with my personal experience, too.
0:03:01So newconsumer.com, if you want to check it out and join, we'd love to have you.
0:03:06Seven years, though.
0:03:08That's a good run.
0:03:09It's funny listening to your highlights there, because we've been friends for a long time.
0:03:13You've been on the show many times, although, as we just emphasize, not for a while.
0:03:17But that's entirely my fault, not because you haven't been doing interesting things or didn't
0:03:22have things that I should have solicited your input as a guest on the show for.
0:03:27But it sounds to me like you found your home, writing for yourself.
0:03:33I hope so.
0:03:34We've talked about this many times over the years, and Splat F was kind of my first attempt
0:03:38at the Gruber lifestyle solo publishing thing.
0:03:42It turned out banner ads, not a great business model for solo publishers.
0:03:46Subscriptions work so much better.
0:03:48And obviously, much credit to Ben Thompson, the kind of newsletter godfather for building
0:03:54that business model out, at least in the tech media community.
0:03:58And a number of people have been really successful with that, many of them much more successful
0:04:03than I have.
0:04:04But it's sustainable.
0:04:05It's still a job.
0:04:06And you've got to do it every day.
0:04:08It's an amazing thing that you can make a real living online by working for yourself and writing
0:04:14to people who value your work enough to pay for it.
0:04:17And I love it.
0:04:18And it really lets me chase kind of most of the work I do is for them, obviously.
0:04:22But some of it's for me, too.
0:04:23So I get to go to a sake brewery in Japan and someday write about that or go deep on textiles
0:04:30with some French industrial designers and things like that.
0:04:33Every once in a while, I've got to keep the balance.
0:04:36Most of it is the business of consumer products and e-commerce.
0:04:39But it's been awesome.
0:04:41I'm really lucky to be able to do it.
0:04:43I do think that Ben deserves credit for...
0:04:48And again, I'm not just trying to be self-effacing here.
0:04:51And people come on and credit me for blazing certain trails for indie publishing.
0:04:58And I've been doing what I do longer than a lot of people at this point.
0:05:03But I think the newsletter model has...
0:05:09It's almost beyond dispute now.
0:05:13Me presenting it here as, hey, maybe this newsletter thing works for independent publishers is sort of...
0:05:19It's almost silly to put it that way.
0:05:21I think it's proven to be a sustainable model for so many people in a way that my style of sponsorships really isn't.
0:05:32I mean, and there are some sites that are more like Daring Fireball.
0:05:36And Daring Fireball is now an outlier, a real outlier in not having any sort of paid membership.
0:05:43Even though I had a membership 20 years ago.
0:05:47And I might, I probably should.
0:05:48If I were smart, I would bring it back.
0:05:50I mean, if I were really smart and had any business sense, I would have brought it back years ago.
0:05:55But it's because I don't prioritize making more money over writing what I want to write.
0:06:03And so it's, this just keeps getting kicked down the road.
0:06:06But it's clearly more sustainable.
0:06:09And that's, people credit Substack with that.
0:06:12And it's, obviously, that's a part of it.
0:06:14But I, you, I'm sure you read my, I don't know.
0:06:19I feel queasy about Substack's role in this.
0:06:23And you don't use Substack.
0:06:24Well, so I actually.
0:06:25Or do you?
0:06:26I don't.
0:06:28Well, I do and I don't.
0:06:29I started mirroring on Substack as an experiment earlier this year.
0:06:33And the reason I don't use Substack, and I have never used it as my main thing and never will,
0:06:39is that they do a lot of things with the user experience that I would never accept on my own site.
0:06:44Many of the things that you raised as issues.
0:06:46The whole, the takeover.
0:06:48The way it makes you think that you have to subscribe to read a post, which you don't.
0:06:54But they hide the button.
0:06:55Yeah.
0:06:56Turns out, though, that works.
0:06:59And people don't really care that much.
0:07:01So I did set up a mirror on Substack in, I think, in March or February.
0:07:07And it has grown my free subscribership there much faster than on my owned and operated site,
0:07:15which is WordPress and memberful and very minimalist.
0:07:19I should actually be a little more upfront about getting people to subscribe, even to the free list.
0:07:25But Substack really kind of smashes you over the head with it, and then they redirect you to their app and all this stuff.
0:07:30So I'm treating it almost more like a Twitter where some of my stuff, most of my stuff goes up there.
0:07:37People can pay me to read there.
0:07:39There's not a lot of paid membership activity there.
0:07:41It's much stronger on my owned and operated site, which, great.
0:07:44Like, I'd rather have those paid customers there.
0:07:47And I might just switch it to free only on Substack and really just harvest emails there.
0:07:52And, you know, that's never going to be my highest value customer.
0:07:55But it is interesting to see it be more of like a social network than a publishing tool.
0:08:01Yeah.
0:08:02And I wouldn't, I honestly, even as your friend, even if we weren't on the air recording this, I would tell you, oh, that sounds fine.
0:08:08I really would.
0:08:09That sounds fine to me.
0:08:10To treat it like Twitter, right?
0:08:11And I've, it's actually very high on my list of things to do in the coming weeks is to get the Daring Fireball Blue Sky account actually posting automatically.
0:08:21I've had Mastodon and it used to, and I still do miss it.
0:08:25I was just listening to the ATP when Marco Arment was talking about starting a Reddit board or channel, whatever they call the subreddit.
0:08:35Subreddit for Overcast and talking about how Twitter used to be that thing.
0:08:42Like it was the one place where users of Overcast knew that they could talk about Overcast at a place where Marco would see what they were saying about Overcast and he could chime in if he wanted to.
0:08:57And it definitely, the peak decade-ish of Twitter was the closest to having a centralized community for my stuff that I ever had.
0:09:08And it is what it is in the last few years under Elon and turning it into X.
0:09:17But even if you put your political feelings, the, hey, don't go there, it's a Nazi bar, whatever, which is all valid.
0:09:25I don't want to dismiss it with whatever.
0:09:26But I'm saying even if you set that aside, it just doesn't have that central role that Twitter used to have.
0:09:33Even if you put aside, which is a big thing to put aside for a lot of people.
0:09:37And it's not just that people left, it's just the way it works now, right?
0:09:43The de-emphasis on URLs, which I think is ridiculous, the way that now people want to...
0:09:49Oh, I think they reversed that.
0:09:50I know.
0:09:50I heard that they did because they have the new product guy.
0:09:53The new browser, yeah.
0:09:54But it's still, it's all, I don't know, it's just not what it used to be.
0:09:58Yeah, I mean, it can still be a phenomenally entertaining place to waste an hour of your life.
0:10:03But it's not the hub the way that it was.
0:10:06And that's why these days, for me, when I post links, I make money.
0:10:11So I have to post links on Twitter, on threads, on LinkedIn.
0:10:14And Substack now has, there are very few places where people actually want to go read these days.
0:10:20So I don't see Substack as my friend.
0:10:24And I see Substack as someone who will eventually compete with me for my business and my readership.
0:10:30But in this, if I can harvest a few more thousand subscribers that drive my sponsorship rate up,
0:10:36and even if those people disappear in a few years, for now that works.
0:10:40So that's what I've been testing.
0:10:42We'll see.
0:10:42Yeah, treating Substack as another outlet for having a sort of sub-community and seeing how it goes,
0:10:49which I think is perfectly valid, and I can see it when I do dip my toes in there.
0:10:54And I can see that some of the publications I subscribe to there have pretty good interactions
0:10:59with Substack, not as a newsletter slash blogging CMS, but as a social network.
0:11:07And there is like a whole Twitter-like component to it now.
0:11:10And it's nice to boil my criticism or even my warning to would-be independent publications or solo operations,
0:11:20whether it's a team thing or a solo thing, that relies on Substack is not to view them as being entirely on Substack
0:11:32and entirely dependent on Substack equaling independence.
0:11:36That's the thing that I think is like a red flag.
0:11:39No, you are not independent.
0:11:41And if nothing changes and they don't tighten any screws or change anything from now until the end of time,
0:11:48well, then my warning will have been for not, but that doesn't mean it wasn't a valid warning.
0:11:54It's like you can drive around in your car without wearing a seatbelt for 40 years,
0:11:58and if you're never in an accident, good for you, right?
0:12:01But that doesn't mean you shouldn't have been wearing a seatbelt for all those years.
0:12:06I completely agree.
0:12:07And what you said, like, don't call it your Substack.
0:12:09I think that is, like, every time people do that, it drives me nuts.
0:12:12This is your life we're talking about.
0:12:14Don't give that brand equal footing with you.
0:12:16Right.
0:12:17I've actually set mine up as a subdomain on my main domain.
0:12:21So if I shut it down, I'll just redirect all that traffic because I still own the traffic through the subdomain.
0:12:28Yeah, you're totally right, and I don't see them as someone to trust or rely on, and I don't see them as being in good taste.
0:12:36But, you know, the readers are really there.
0:12:39Yeah, I hear that, too.
0:12:42It's hard to argue with that.
0:12:42Right.
0:12:43And whenever I write about it, I hear from people who say, and often because they read my site, they're like,
0:12:49I hear you, and I agree with you about this, that, and the other thing, but they really do drive traffic, or they really did help me build.
0:12:55Some people who aren't, they're like, I'm not even doing this as a business.
0:12:59It's important to me, and I want to build a readership, but I'm not trying to make this my career.
0:13:06It's a side thing.
0:13:07And I didn't even put any effort into this, and Substack helped me build a couple of hundred or low thousands subscription list.
0:13:16And that's great.
0:13:18It really is.
0:13:19And I know that that works, right?
0:13:21But somebody who sees it as a side hustle is a very different thing than the people who are building ostensibly independent publications.
0:13:28Right.
0:13:29Yeah, the interesting thing these days is that now that so much as podcasts become video, and as Instagram becomes more video,
0:13:37and your kind of followers, customers, whatever you want to call them, are now bouncing around between five different platforms to kind of stay in touch with what you're doing,
0:13:49it almost becomes that the human-to-human connection is what's most important.
0:13:54So people will, I think, follow you.
0:13:56Obviously, there'll be some drop-off.
0:13:57But if you are launching a new YouTube show or a new Instagram Reels thing or whatever it is,
0:14:05the people who care will kind of do the work to find you on those platforms in a way that I think maybe was a little hard to ask people to do in the past.
0:14:16But really, it all just ends up being either people like you and they want to follow your work no matter where you are, or they don't.
0:14:23And the stronger businesses are going to be obviously the ones where there's a real affinity between the person and the customer.
0:14:31So that's the goal is just to be indispensable and then try to own as much of it as you can, I think.
0:14:39Yeah, I would say so.
0:14:41And I think you're doing a good job, and I'm very, very happy for your success.
0:14:44Thank you.
0:14:45You finally found a job you can hold on to.
0:14:47I know.
0:14:48It is the longest job I've ever had.
0:14:51Not because I was in my 20s, so four years was a lot of time back then.
0:14:56I remember when Daring Fireball became the longest job I ever had, which didn't take long.
0:15:02I don't think I had ever held any job in my life for more than two years, maybe a little more than two years.
0:15:13And when I was more of like a freelancer, I had relationships with clients or whatever you want to call it that lasted more like five years or more, some design work.
0:15:25But that's not the same thing as having a job.
0:15:27Totally, yeah.
0:15:28I'd never really supported myself with one main job that I could put on my tax return for more than two years.
0:15:34And it wasn't Daring Fireball.
0:15:37I started writing it in 2002, and I think I went full-time.
0:15:40You'd think I'd know this.
0:15:42I think it was 2006, or was it 2007?
0:15:45That feels right.
0:15:45I think I remember that.
0:15:47So I don't know.
0:15:48Sometime around 2009, 2010 was when it really hit me.
0:15:53Like, hey, I've been doing this full-time longer than any other job, and it feels like it's doing better than ever.
0:16:00Like, the numbers are going up, and my enthusiasm for it remains as strong as ever.
0:16:06Holy shit, I think this is it.
0:16:09And I finally found a job that I can't get fired from.
0:16:13I think it's cool to spin up other things like Dithering.
0:16:17I think that's another thing now, where if you work for a company, they're not going to let you do that.
0:16:22Right.
0:16:22Right.
0:16:23No, it's very interesting that I never had to think about asking permission to do Dithering.
0:16:29Yeah.
0:16:29Or when I did Vesper for a couple years, it was very interesting.
0:16:33I mean, I guess I sort of have to ask permission from my wife, like for Vesper in particular, because that took a lot of time away.
0:16:42Dithering, I guess I didn't even ask, because it's sort of like, okay, let's hit record, stop.
0:16:48And the research is just what I'm already doing, whereas Vesper really did.
0:16:52And the constraint of the time limit is brilliant.
0:16:55Right.
0:16:56No, it really is.
0:16:57I was just saying on Dithering this week that it would be if I weren't, no offense to people who are listening to this show, which I think I would enjoy too.
0:17:07But I think that if there were two of me, one who does this stuff and one who does something else, like works at Apple or something and therefore can't be a public figure, but listens to podcasts, I think Dithering would be my favorite podcast.
0:17:23I would enjoy the topics, I think I would enjoy listening to me and Ben, but I would very much enjoy the 15-minute, twice-a-week format.
0:17:32It's funny, because I'm definitely a three-hour podcast listener, but as a host, I would definitely lean towards something, an artificially short time constraint, too.
0:17:45But you're like me, you don't have a commute, and ATP is a two-plus-hour, once-a-week, literally like clockwork, 52 weeks a year.
0:17:56Every year for all these years, they've never not had an episode, which to me is crazy.
0:18:02But now that they've made it a thing, they feel like they can't break it, which is nuts to me, as somebody who publishes so irregularly.
0:18:09But I don't have room in my life.
0:18:12Literally, I just don't have time for that many more long podcasts.
0:18:15I mean, I'd have to actually take time away from doing actual work to listen to them, and I cannot.
0:18:21I know some people do.
0:18:22But I absolutely, I don't even listen to music when I work.
0:18:26But I could never listen to a podcast while I work, because I'd either completely miss every single thing they're saying, or it would capture my attention, and my fingers would stop moving on the keyboard, and I would just sit there and listen.
0:18:38It would be one or the other.
0:18:40Yeah, I tried listening to podcasts while doing, also trying to read emails or a book or anything.
0:18:47It's just, it's not, it's not going to happen.
0:18:48But yeah.
0:18:49Brent Simmons listens to podcasts while he works.
0:18:51I have no idea how he does it.
0:18:53He's sitting there writing programming code, listening to podcasts.
0:18:56That's amazing.
0:18:57It blows my mind.
0:18:58That's a real talent.
0:18:58It's unbelievable.
0:19:00Different strokes for different folks.
0:19:02All right.
0:19:04But speaking of sponsorships, let me take a break and thank our first sponsor of the episode, our good friends at Notion.
0:19:11Notion brings all of your notes, docs, and projects into one connected space that just works.
0:19:18It's seamless, flexible, powerful, and actually fun to use with AI built right in, which is really important to the Notion experience.
0:19:26You spend less time switching between tools and more time creating great work.
0:19:31And now with Notion Agent, your AI doesn't just help with work.
0:19:35It finishes it.
0:19:36Notion Agent can do anything you can do in Notion.
0:19:40It can tap into your Notion workspace, the web, and connected tools that you can connect to Notion, like Slack and Google Drive, to complete assigned actions end-to-end so that you can focus on the hard decisions.
0:19:53It's like delegating to another version of you, speaking of other versions of you, that knows your style, your workflow, and your preferences because it learns from how you work.
0:20:04With a single prompt, Notion Agent forms a plan, executes it, and will even reassess and try again if it hits a snag, completing multi-step tasks like creating new pages or databases from scratch or simply editing them or summarizing entire projects in minutes.
0:20:19You assign the tasks.
0:20:21Your agent does the work.
0:20:23It's really, really powerful stuff.
0:20:25It is great for teams.
0:20:27It is great for solo work or solo notebooks and stuff like that.
0:20:32Notion is used by over 50% of Fortune 500 companies and some of the fastest-growing companies, startups like OpenAI, Ramp, and Vercel.
0:20:41They use Notion Agent to help their teams send fewer emails, cancel more meetings, and stay ahead.
0:20:48And like I said, it's not just for big companies like that or these Fortune 500 companies.
0:20:52It is an absolutely great product for solos and individuals.
0:20:56Try Notion, now with Notion Agent, at Notion, N-O-T-I-O-N, Notion.com slash talkshow.
0:21:05That's all lowercase letters.
0:21:07They want me to emphasize that.
0:21:09Notion.com slash talkshow to try your new AI teammate, Notion Agent, today.
0:21:15And when you use that link, you're supporting the show.
0:21:18Notion.com slash talkshow.
0:21:22We do have a bunch of little things to talk about.
0:21:25Did you get your iPhone pocket?
0:21:27I did not.
0:21:28Ben did, though.
0:21:29Ben ordered one for his wife.
0:21:31That was quite the story this week.
0:21:33And kind of a perfect new consumer topic, too, right?
0:21:37A little bit, yeah.
0:21:39That's one thing I was thinking about when we were talking about what you're doing there.
0:21:42You're like, you're off the tech beat, you say.
0:21:45But I kind of feel that the general consumer space and the tech world are kind of – that's sort of the story of this decade.
0:21:58And I think it is – it just – yeah, yada, yada, yada.
0:22:04But just mash it all together.
0:22:05It sort of is part of the AI story, right?
0:22:10Absolutely.
0:22:10I mean, that was my kind of thesis when I started this is that tech is no longer an industry.
0:22:15It's a layer on life.
0:22:16It's just part of everything now.
0:22:18So it's part of how you purchase things.
0:22:19It's part of how you research.
0:22:21It's part of how you entertain yourself.
0:22:22Like, almost everything has a digital component to it these days other than maybe reading a newspaper or a paper book or something like that.
0:22:30So, yeah, I mean, like the iPhone pocket is – actually, I forgot to link to it this week.
0:22:35I'll do it next week.
0:22:36And it's already sold out.
0:22:37So I can't order one.
0:22:39And I can't even go buy one.
0:22:41This is – I scrolled all the way to the bottom of this announcement page.
0:22:45It's fascinating.
0:22:46They're selling it at 10 stores around the world.
0:22:49Six of those 10 are in Asia.
0:22:51Only one is in the U.S., in New York, in Soho.
0:22:56So it's interesting to see which of the stores they're driving people toward for fashionable stuff.
0:23:01Yeah, not Fifth Avenue in New York, Soho.
0:23:03Not the global flagship, right, the Soho store.
0:23:06Two in Europe – or three in Europe, Paris, Milan, and London.
0:23:10And that's it.
0:23:11So can't do it in L.A.
0:23:13There's no store in L.A. that's chic enough to sell the Issey Miyake thing, pocket, which makes sense, to be honest.
0:23:22And our stores here in Philadelphia are not really flagship-y.
0:23:28We've got one really close to me here in Center City, which is nice, but sort of standard size.
0:23:35The King of Prussia Mall one is a little bigger footprint, but not flagship quality.
0:23:41Yeah.
0:23:43And so it's hard to put a – because they're not going to say neither Apple or Issey Miyake, which I hope I'm – you know more about you.
0:23:50I think that's correct, yeah.
0:23:51Is it?
0:23:52All right, Issey Miyake.
0:23:53I believe so, yeah.
0:23:53They're not saying how many they made, which I guess adds to the mystique, and I guess maybe it would be considered gauche if – to say it's a limited edition of 10,000, or I don't know what the number is.
0:24:07So you don't know – I don't blame them for not saying how many they made, but then it puts the, hey, it sold out within an hour or so into, well, who knows what that means when they don't tell you how many they made.
0:24:20But it did sell out.
0:24:21So all the people laughing at the price, it's sort of like – I get it.
0:24:26If you think $150 or $230 is ridiculous for a knitted sling for your phone, don't buy it.
0:24:34But that's not a ridiculous price for a bag, and it's absolutely – if you look at everything else Issey Miyake sells from clothing to other bags and stuff, it's actually on the lower end of the price range.
0:24:49Yeah, I mean, Issey Miyake is not a luxury brand, but, like, not cheap either, and $150 – like, people buy a pair of socks for $150.
0:24:57Like, pricing these days, it's hard to get too upset about any pricing because there's so many different things at every section of the pricing range.
0:25:06I don't – how much were iPod socks?
0:25:09Probably not.
0:25:10So they – I wouldn't have known off the top of my head a week ago, but because of the resurgence and interest in iPod socks, I can tell you, A, that they were only sold in six-packs, where you got all six colors.
0:25:24Oh, wow.
0:25:25But this is about 21, 22 years ago, I think.
0:25:28I think it was, like, 2004.
0:25:29They were – a six-pack was $29, and I happen to know that inflation adjusted to 2025, that's about $50.
0:25:38So in today's dollars, it would be six for $50, so $9 each.
0:25:45Yeah, so this is, like, the Hermes Apple Watch version of the iPod sock.
0:25:50Right.
0:25:51By the way, not to use the trope, but I think Steve would have dug this.
0:25:55Like, obviously, he bought all his shirts from there.
0:25:58Yeah.
0:25:58This is cool.
0:25:59I like it.
0:26:00I would never hold my iPhone like this at all, but I kind of want one, and I think it's cool.
0:26:06Yeah, I kind of want to see one because it looks – I wouldn't use it.
0:26:09That's the crazy part.
0:26:11And I also think it's a little odd that the – there's two sizes.
0:26:17That's the difference between $150 and $230, and the $230 longer one, which actually looks
0:26:23more interesting to me because it would go over your shoulder, is only available in three
0:26:27kind of boring colors, but the shorter one had – well, had, I should say, since they're
0:26:31sold out, had more colors.
0:26:33But I wish I could just see – I don't really want to buy one, but kind of wish they had
0:26:38had them, for example, at the iPhone event back in September so I could have seen them
0:26:43hands-on because I don't want to buy one, but I'd really like to play with one and see.
0:26:48Yeah, unfortunately, the resale sites are already – it's like $360 to get one from my
0:26:54Japanese resale site.
0:26:56And there was – and it is interesting.
0:26:59When the Sox came out 20 years ago, people laughed at them and thought it was stupid.
0:27:03And I even looked back at a couple of posts I had on Daring Fireball about them, and it
0:27:09was true.
0:27:09It really – I remember – and it all kind of came back to me that a lot of people – even
0:27:13though Steve Jobs personally introduced them on stage at an iPod event, he – and funny,
0:27:20looking at the video, it's in the California Theater in San Jose.
0:27:24I was not there.
0:27:24It was like – whatever year it was, it might have been 2006, and I was writing Daring Fireball,
0:27:29but I wasn't flying out to California for events regularly.
0:27:32I was like at Macworld, thankfully, for the iPhone introduction in January 2006, but I didn't
0:27:38go to – I didn't fly cross-country for everything.
0:27:40But it's the California Theater, which is where I've had the live talk shows for the last few
0:27:47years.
0:27:47So it's weird watching Steve Jobs on stage – not on my stage, but on the only actual
0:27:53stage I'm familiar with in recent years.
0:27:55So, yeah, I know that stage.
0:27:57I know exactly what that looks like backstage.
0:27:59I'm pretty sure I thought the iPod socks were stupid, but –
0:28:04Yeah.
0:28:04But now they're funny.
0:28:05People thought they were a joke, though.
0:28:07Even after the event, they were like – they thought that Apple and Steve Jobs were putting
0:28:12them on, and it's kind of – it's an interesting change for Apple 20 years because nobody – like
0:28:18one of the many ways of epitomizing or putting your finger on the differences between Steve
0:28:23Jobs and Tim Cook is it was within the realm of possibility that Steve Jobs would announce
0:28:29a fake product on stage just to get a laugh and not even say, hey, this was fake, forget
0:28:36about that.
0:28:36He would just let you think it, and then it just never goes on sale, whereas nobody would
0:28:40ever believe that Tim Cook would do that, right?
0:28:42Never, yeah.
0:28:44Never.
0:28:44Nobody would ever think Tim Cook has announced a joke product.
0:28:47But people thought they were a joke, but nobody really thought they were ridiculously priced,
0:28:52right?
0:28:52Six for $29 seemed like a pretty fair price.
0:28:55And so with the iPod – iPhone – here I am calling it the iPod pocket – the iPhone pocket
0:29:01this week, people laughed at it as being a stupid idea for the same reason as the socks, which
0:29:08I think was just as wrong.
0:29:09I think the socks were actually pretty cool, because we bought a pack, and I used it.
0:29:13It was a great way –
0:29:14I'm sure they would have been functional, yeah.
0:29:15Yeah, it was a great –
0:29:16I had the equivalent of that for, like, my Discman, so why wouldn't I have it for –
0:29:20Yeah, it was a great way to put your iPod into a thing so you could just throw it in
0:29:25your backpack or briefcase without worrying about it getting scratched or dinged up.
0:29:29It had just enough padding.
0:29:30It wasn't protective, but it was protective enough to bounce around a purse or a backpack.
0:29:36And easy to get it in, easy to get it out.
0:29:38The Issey Miyake pocket sling seems similar, and it's obviously future-proof because it's
0:29:46not, like, precision-sized, oh, you have to get the iPhone 17 Pro Max-sized pocket.
0:29:52No, it obviously is sort of like one pocket fits any iPhone or Android phone, right?
0:29:58You could buy this Issey Miyake thing from an Apple store and then put your Android phone
0:30:02in it.
0:30:02Or a LaCroix or whatever you want.
0:30:05I do notice a lot of people carrying their – well, I would say a lot, but there certainly
0:30:09are people who carry their iPhones on one of those comically long lanyards or – and now
0:30:16Apple sells those too.
0:30:17Yeah.
0:30:18I would be concerned about it flying and shattering on something, but people certainly do this.
0:30:24I bet this will be widely knocked off.
0:30:27I bet you'll be able to go and get a $19 version of this that is obviously not nearly
0:30:31as nice.
0:30:32But this now feels like something that will enter the culture.
0:30:36Right.
0:30:37In the same way that Apple's own Apple Watch straps cost – most of them cost $100, and even
0:30:44the simplest ones cost $50, and you can go to the store or Amazon and find uncountable number
0:30:53of Apple Watch straps for $10.
0:30:55Yeah.
0:30:56I bought the $12 Tmoo version of the – whatever this thing is called, the –
0:31:02Oh, the loop.
0:31:03Yeah.
0:31:03Yeah, the climbing loop or whatever, the ultra one.
0:31:06Very obvious the difference between Apple's $100 version and the $12.
0:31:11You know what's funny?
0:31:12I bought the Tmoo version of that too because it was like a year or two ago when Tmoo was
0:31:17number one in the app store.
0:31:18I was like, I got to try this app.
0:31:19It was my test order.
0:31:20Yeah.
0:31:20Yeah.
0:31:21I got the orange one from like the first year of the ultra.
0:31:23I got the orange climbing loop or whatever that's called, ultra band.
0:31:28I bought a pair of knockoff AirPods and a pair of Lenovo wireless earbuds that – Tmoo
0:31:39called them Lenovo, and I was like, there is no way this is actually from Lenovo, and they
0:31:45weren't.
0:31:45They were just a total ripoff that just said Lenovo on them and didn't really try to pretend
0:31:51too heavily that they weren't.
0:31:52And then, I don't know, I went back within six weeks and they were gone, obviously.
0:31:57Somebody, some lawyer at Lenovo sent them like a what the fuck letter and it was removed.
0:32:03But yeah.
0:32:05So, I mean, it's – and I think just like with Apple Watches where it's like you can say
0:32:09you think it's stupid that Hermes sells $500 link bracelets and I don't know how much the
0:32:17leather ones cost now, but they're obviously much more expensive, hundreds of dollars.
0:32:21You don't have to buy it.
0:32:23And it's not like they're the only – if they were the only Apple Watch straps available,
0:32:27then yes, you could complain about it.
0:32:29And if this was the only way to put an iPhone over your shoulder, then I – for some kind
0:32:34of – if there was like a DRM equivalent digital connection that you had to be digitally signed
0:32:43and authorized to put your iPhone in a sling over your shoulder and the only way to do
0:32:47it was to spend $150 from Issey Miyake, then that would be worth complaining about.
0:32:51But Apple itself makes a lower cost over the shoulder sling.
0:32:56It is – it is interesting.
0:32:58I don't know.
0:32:59I think it's cool.
0:33:00I wish – I had thought that the Apple Watch era would bring actually more of these types
0:33:05of partnerships.
0:33:06And I guess it's hard for Apple to do that these days because they're so big and everything
0:33:13they do.
0:33:13I guess this is kind of an interesting example of something that's not that big.
0:33:17And on purpose, it's not that big.
0:33:19They're not offering it in all their stores.
0:33:21There was not a huge inventory available, and I'm sure there are some people who are frustrated
0:33:27that they can't buy one.
0:33:28But I think it's kind of cool for them to do something small like that because it's really
0:33:33hard when you're that big to do anything small.
0:33:36And I don't know if it's sustainable for them to do a lot of stuff like this, but I think
0:33:41it's kind of cool.
0:33:42Yeah, I think so too.
0:33:44Let's look up how much an Hermes strap is.
0:33:47How much do you think?
0:33:49Looks like you can get a strap for like $349 from Hermes for the – yeah.
0:33:56For one – one is $419.
0:33:58Looks like different.
0:34:00Yeah.
0:34:01Yeah, like $300, $400 depending on which one.
0:34:04And obviously the metal ones cost a little more.
0:34:07But again, they're not the only Apple Watch straps.
0:34:09So I don't know.
0:34:11I think that the people's complaint about this.
0:34:13And I kind of feel like, as you hinted there, it might go over better if Apple did more
0:34:19of this.
0:34:20And obviously, I even zinged them a little on one of my posts this week where I said my
0:34:25headline was, I guess they're down to 999 no's for every yes.
0:34:29That's just sort of gentle kidding.
0:34:32Because I do support them doing stuff like this, and I feel like it would go over better
0:34:36if they did a little bit more of them, right?
0:34:38And obviously, it would be wrong for the Apple brand to do a lot of them.
0:34:43But doing a couple more a year, at least like one a season, I think would make it go over
0:34:49better.
0:34:49What's Apple's surprise partnership this season?
0:34:53Yeah, and this is purely, I mean, this is probably 95% fashion, 5% utility.
0:34:59Although maybe not.
0:34:59Maybe that's not generous enough.
0:35:01But perhaps some of the stuff could be a little more, although I guess the utility-driven stuff,
0:35:06they would not want to artificially have scarcity.
0:35:09So if there's anything that's really about getting more use out of something, they should
0:35:14have as many of those as possible.
0:35:15But yeah, I think it's cool.
0:35:18I mean, there's few brands that are deserving of an Apple partnership.
0:35:21That's part of the problem.
0:35:22You could even question, is Nike the right athletic partner these days?
0:35:25I think it probably still is because of its global positioning and all that sort of stuff.
0:35:30But if it were today, I don't know.
0:35:31Would it be Nike or would it be someone else?
0:35:33Yeah, I wonder too.
0:35:35And I wonder, you know, it's a small thing.
0:35:38And I don't think people second guess it much.
0:35:41But I think I'm pretty sure Tim Cook is still on the Nike board.
0:35:45And so that's...
0:35:46I think so, yeah.
0:35:46Yeah, and I sort of think, in a way, that's sort of a conflict of interest.
0:35:52Right?
0:35:52I thought about this too recently.
0:35:54It definitely was during the fuel band era.
0:35:56Well, but effectively, I think they were pretty upfront about this, that as a member of the
0:36:02board, he, with the permission of the Apple board, had let Nike know what Apple was doing
0:36:07and steered Nike away from making their own smartwatches and towards being a partner for
0:36:14Apple watch.
0:36:15But again, that's a good counter to the Hermes thing, where the Nike ones don't cost more,
0:36:20right?
0:36:20They're like the same price as the regular sport models.
0:36:24They just come with Nike-style bands and some custom Nike watch faces.
0:36:31But I kind of feel like it hasn't been a great five years, 10 years for Nike as a company.
0:36:38They obviously made some stumbles.
0:36:42New consumer-ish ones that you're probably well aware of, where their sort of direct-to-consumer
0:36:48push had them.
0:36:50They sort of lost their status in some ways.
0:36:53They're sort of undeniable status as the king of the sneakers.
0:36:57I think Apple has less flexibility to pick a new partner, because it's not just shoes,
0:37:02right?
0:37:02It's just the whole athletic, who's our athletic partner?
0:37:05With Tim Cook on their board, they kind of don't have any flexibility in that regard.
0:37:09Yeah, and I think it's still the most prestigious global sports brand.
0:37:15Maybe not what the cool runners on the West Side Highway are wearing these days, but that's
0:37:20not Apple either.
0:37:21Yeah, and I guess if Tim Cook really felt like it was a poor deal for Apple, he'd resign
0:37:26from the Nike board, right?
0:37:28Yeah.
0:37:28Steve Jobs used to do stuff like that all the time.
0:37:32He'd sell all his stock except for one share to make a stink, right?
0:37:37It would be like, ah, I'm sick of Nike.
0:37:39It's, again, very different from Tim Cook.
0:37:41I think he'd be very reticent to make the public stink of, hey, Tim Cook just resigned from the
0:37:47Nike board and says the company was run by bozos.
0:37:50I don't see him doing that.
0:37:52No.
0:37:53It happened every few years with Steve Jobs.
0:37:55Yeah, that was a different era, too.
0:37:58But yeah, I think you're right.
0:38:00I'm not sure Tim Cook has ever publicly called anybody a bozo.
0:38:03I can't recall.
0:38:05Yeah.
0:38:05Probably has never happened.
0:38:07What else is on the list?
0:38:09Do you want to talk about the iPhone Air?
0:38:11Yeah.
0:38:13I still have it.
0:38:16Are you using one still?
0:38:16Yeah, I was going to ask.
0:38:17Yeah, I still have my review units and I still haven't written my reviews.
0:38:20Here.
0:38:21Here's the Air.
0:38:23Is that your main phone number hooked up to that one or no?
0:38:27I guess it's about two months since I've had both and I think I've gone about 50-50 with
0:38:33the 17 Pro and the iPhone Air.
0:38:35I've been telling myself I should write the reviews first and then purchase my own phone
0:38:40and I'm 90-some percent sure I should purchase a 17 Pro because I really do use the extra lenses
0:38:48on the camera, especially the telephoto.
0:38:51And to me, the killer thing about the Air is I don't like how big the screen is.
0:38:57It is a much nicer phone to put in your pocket and the weight difference, the thinness combined,
0:39:05the lighter weight and the thinness really do make it nicer to keep in your pocket.
0:39:10But I don't think it's nicer in hand because it's just too big for me side to side.
0:39:17I actually think the 17 Pro is a little too big and wish that they'd shrink that down area-wise.
0:39:25It is a bit more like holding a pancake than a sandwich, right?
0:39:29Yeah, exactly.
0:39:30Something like that.
0:39:33I really wish that they had made two sizes of the Air.
0:39:37Like what they effectively did is they sort of split the difference between the regular
0:39:43and large size of iPhones, right?
0:39:45The Pro and the Pro Max and split the difference and made one size pretty much right in the middle
0:39:53in terms of area, just width times height, ignoring the thickness for the Air.
0:39:59And I kind of wish they had just made two sizes, made one that was the max size and one that's
0:40:05the regular size.
0:40:06And if they had made a regular size of the Air, then without question, that's the one I would
0:40:11buy, even with only one camera lens.
0:40:13That's how much I like it.
0:40:15I need to spend some more time with that.
0:40:17I've tried it in the store.
0:40:19I think that the size...
0:40:21I did a year with the Pro Max and that was just too big, like running shorts.
0:40:26It just was not tenable for running this giant thing in your pocket.
0:40:33But obviously the context of this week is like all these stories about production being reduced
0:40:42and I don't know how you'd like to summarize it.
0:40:46Well, I think there's so much...
0:40:49I'm always loathe to put too much credence in anybody other than Apple's remarks on how
0:40:56well anything is selling because they're so secretive and they just don't announce per
0:41:00product numbers.
0:41:02But when so many people are saying, hey, they've cut production, it's disappointing compared
0:41:08to what they expected.
0:41:09It's only about one out of every ten of the new...
0:41:14Of people buying any of the new phones, the 17 regular, 17 Pro and Pro Max and the iPhone
0:41:21Air, which very still curiously doesn't have the 17 number.
0:41:26Only about one in ten of those phones is an iPhone Air, which isn't terrible.
0:41:31But it's...
0:41:32I think they obviously thought or hoped it would be more higher than one in ten.
0:41:37I don't know how much higher, but...
0:41:40Yeah, hard to know.
0:41:41I mean, obviously there's a target and they're either hitting the target or they're not.
0:41:46And for years I was always really, really reluctant to amplify those.
0:41:52Production has been cut by 70% stories because a lot of times those are written by people who
0:41:58have no idea how production works.
0:41:59I don't know how production works.
0:42:01I bet there's a ramp down every year no matter what.
0:42:04And it's, is this a bigger ramp down than they expected to make or not?
0:42:07And that, there are people who know the answer to that.
0:42:09Many of them work at Apple.
0:42:10Many of them work in the supply chain.
0:42:12But it does feel...
0:42:14I don't, I have not seen one in the wild.
0:42:16Now, granted, I now live mostly in LA where people are not on the subway or flashing their
0:42:21new phones and stuff like that.
0:42:22But I too thought maybe, oh, I should buy this and went to the store, played with it and got
0:42:30really, really nervous and defensive about not having a zoom lens, which I don't even know
0:42:36how much I use.
0:42:36I tried to go in the photos app and see if there was a way to filter by how many pictures
0:42:40I've taken.
0:42:41Is there a way to do that?
0:42:42There is.
0:42:43And I, you know what?
0:42:44I'm going to write this down.
0:42:45Look at it.
0:42:45You can see me with my pen and paper.
0:42:47I'm writing this down.
0:42:48I am going to link to it.
0:42:49I think Jason Snell had the best article, but I will be sure.
0:42:53I will get this into the show notes somehow.
0:42:55What you have to do is make a smart album.
0:42:57You can't just query live.
0:42:59Go to photos on the Mac.
0:43:01I don't think you can do smart albums on iOS, but on photos for Mac, make a smart album and
0:43:07make the smart criteria, which camera.
0:43:10And as the camera pick the model iPhone that you want to target, and then you can then add
0:43:18another criteria for the smart album that is lens and you find the lens, but you've got
0:43:23to, it's a little tricky because it's, I think in photos, it goes by the actual millimeters,
0:43:29not the simulated millimeters.
0:43:32So they'll say like, for example, the way that they say that the one X main camera is 24
0:43:38millimeters.
0:43:38That's in 35 millimeter film photography terms.
0:43:43It's actually like 4.7 millimeters because the sensor is so much smaller than an actual
0:43:4935 millimeter diagonal piece of film negative.
0:43:52So you've got to figure out like it's the 4.7 millimeter.
0:43:56But anyway, you can do that through a smart album.
0:43:58And well, then it's like, well, perhaps I've taken all these pictures, but what am I actually
0:44:04using?
0:44:04What actually matters?
0:44:06Is it like what I post to Instagram?
0:44:08Is it what I send to my family?
0:44:11Like which photos actually matter?
0:44:12And then maybe I would convince myself that I would be completely fine with a delightfully
0:44:20thin phone without six cameras or whatever it is.
0:44:24I'm very much an air person.
0:44:26Like I have a MacBook air.
0:44:27I've would always get the thinnest iPad you can get.
0:44:31I love this felt nature of it.
0:44:33One of the things that I feel is still missing from the Mac lineup is the ultra thin, not as
0:44:39fast, but almost pocketable.
0:44:41The, the, what was it?
0:44:42The MacBook adorable.
0:44:43Yeah.
0:44:44Yeah.
0:44:44Yeah.
0:44:45Yeah.
0:44:45The MacBook one.
0:44:46Yeah.
0:44:47The MacBook one.
0:44:48Yeah.
0:44:48I miss that.
0:44:50And, and I feel like the iPhone air, maybe the, just maybe the slightly wrong trade-offs.
0:44:56I saw some people making the analogy to the iPhone 10, which had some other trade-backs
0:45:02versus the, whatever the numbered ones that.
0:45:05It was the iPhone eight at the exact same time.
0:45:08There never was an iPhone nine, but in the year 2019, I believe, I don't know.
0:45:15We can do the math, but 2018.
0:45:16No, no.
0:45:17I think it was 18 because it was, I think I was in Japan when the, when the 10 pre-orders,
0:45:23I think we were in a, in a bath house with Craig Mott ordering.
0:45:26Yeah.
0:45:27Because the 10 was 10 years or 10th version.
0:45:30And the first one came out in 2007.
0:45:32So it was the 10th model.
0:45:34So therefore it was 2018.
0:45:36I think it was 17 then.
0:45:36Okay.
0:45:37Well, maybe it was 2018.
0:45:38I forget.
0:45:39I guess we could.
0:45:39We could look it up.
0:45:41We can find this out.
0:45:42But anyway, like the, for me, the, what the, the main reason to buy that phone, obviously
0:45:48besides the fact that it was the new phone was the, the face ID paradigm, which meant you
0:45:52no longer had to deal with the home button and you were in the future of face ID.
0:45:56And so the trade-offs, whatever the trade-offs were, I don't even remember what they were.
0:46:00Didn't matter because that was very clearly the future of where, where this was going.
0:46:05I guess the trade-off was like the notch.
0:46:07It was 2017 by the 2017, 10 years.
0:46:10Whereas this one, it's like pretty clear that you're either getting the, the super thin,
0:46:16like ultra nice phone or you're getting all the cameras and it is hard for me.
0:46:24Yeah.
0:46:26I think it's hard for a lot of people.
0:46:27Yeah.
0:46:28But it's weird.
0:46:30And I don't think I'm too much of a knee jerk contrarian, but I think two, three weeks
0:46:37ago, I was much closer to 99% sure that I should buy a 17 pro and all of the sort of, Hey, nobody
0:46:46likes the iPhone air.
0:46:48And I just pissed on a wall street journal report this week about the iPhone air where
0:46:54I really feel like they really unfairly.
0:46:57It's a news story.
0:46:58So it's not from their tech columnists like Joanna Stern and, and Nicole Nguyen.
0:47:04It was a news story where, because it's a news story, the reporters couldn't say it.
0:47:09They just found a guy who was a former Apple product manager who said he bought one and at
0:47:15his wedding, he took worse.
0:47:17His photos looked substantially worse than his brother and his brother had the 17 pro.
0:47:23And I don't believe it.
0:47:24I really don't.
0:47:25Cause I've taken pictures side by side with the two.
0:47:28And yes, cause it only has one camera lens.
0:47:30If his brother was taking four X zoom pictures and he's taking pictures with the air from the
0:47:36same distance of the same subjects.
0:47:38Well then, yeah, it's going to look like shit because you don't have a zoom lens, but the
0:47:43zoom lenses, even on the 17 pro, the best zoom lenses Apple's ever made are substantially
0:47:49worse cameras.
0:47:50Just from a pure photo nerd technical aspect, it is a substantially worse camera than the
0:47:59one X camera.
0:48:00The one X camera is just better.
0:48:02It's for optical reasons for the reason that they know that that's the lens that most people
0:48:08use.
0:48:09Most of the time it's where they invest the money, but just optically, it's harder to get
0:48:13a telephoto lens that doesn't stick out.
0:48:17Like when you look at real cameras and you look at telephoto lenses that are longer distance
0:48:24that have more reach.
0:48:24Those are the lenses that stick out from the camera more.
0:48:28So how on an iPhone or any smartphone does the telephoto lens not stick out more?
0:48:35It's a very tricky problem, but one of the ways that they make it work is by sacrificing image
0:48:40quality and, and how, how much light gets in, et cetera.
0:48:44You can't really cheat physics.
0:48:46And so there's a reason why optically, you know, in terms of getting the best possible
0:48:51picture you can get on your phone, it's always going to be with the main one X lens and the
0:48:56one X lens on the iPhone air is really good.
0:48:59It is not as good as the 17 pro, but it's as good as like a pro iPhone pro from a couple
0:49:05years ago.
0:49:06And I think in the hands of most people, they, and into the eyes of most people side
0:49:12by side photos with the main camera on a 17 pro and an iPhone air, they would be very hard
0:49:19pressed to tell the difference pixel peeping that you'd have to really zoom in to see the
0:49:24differences.
0:49:24So I think the way that the wall street journal presented it, and I just can't even imagine
0:49:29how many people are.
0:49:29Yeah.
0:49:29I read in a wall street journal that the camera stinks on the iPhone air, right?
0:49:33That's the just, that's the takeaway from the lead of their story.
0:49:36Oh, the iPhone air.
0:49:37Yeah.
0:49:37It's really cool to hold and it's super thin, but the camera stinks.
0:49:40I read it in a wall street journal and that's just not true.
0:49:43It's absolutely not true.
0:49:45Yeah.
0:49:45It's a shame.
0:49:46I mean, again, contrarian, I mean, now I want to buy one.
0:49:50I do.
0:49:50I just want to like, I'm going to go play again.
0:49:53Yeah.
0:49:56I ended up not ordering a new phone yet because I'm on the upgrade program and we just finally
0:50:01hit our 12 month cycle.
0:50:03So eventually we tried doing it early, but everything was sold out.
0:50:06So, or at least the pros were sold out.
0:50:09This is like kind of where we are with the iPhone.
0:50:11Like the pro is, it is totally fine.
0:50:14Like it is small enough.
0:50:16It is light enough.
0:50:17It is totally fine and it does an amazing job and never flakes out.
0:50:22So there's no, oh man, I never, I never sit there thinking, man, I wish this phone were
0:50:27a lot different than it is.
0:50:29Cause it's so good.
0:50:29It's, it's an amazing piece of, I wish it were lighter.
0:50:32I mean, how can you not wish it were lighter?
0:50:34Right.
0:50:34But then, yeah.
0:50:35But then you pick one up that's lighter and you go, oh, same with the iPad pro.
0:50:39You take it out of the case and you're like, what is this thing?
0:50:42Like, how is this so light?
0:50:44This is amazing.
0:50:46So I do feel that.
0:50:49And, and so I am very intrigued by it and yeah, maybe I'll, the other thing is the iPhone
0:50:57camera is almost too good now.
0:50:59Like the, all the stuff that it does between HDR and, and all the other tweaks that they
0:51:06do to your pictures, it's almost, it almost feels like it's not a photo.
0:51:09Obviously people have had this conversation a million times, but that is one of the reasons
0:51:12that I think you're also a Rico guy picked up the GR3s because it actually, you know,
0:51:16it actually feels like you're shooting photography again, even though that is obviously digital
0:51:21too.
0:51:21And, and they encourage you to use all these filters and, and things like that.
0:51:25But to me, and I, and I actually never take it anywhere.
0:51:28So I have the Ricoh GR3s and the difference between the three and the 3x is the focal distance.
0:51:37It's a fixed focal focus lens.
0:51:40The GR3 is like a 28 millimeter equivalent, which is pretty much like the iPhone 1x camera, except
0:51:50I think it's when you switch to 1.2 zoom because the iPhone 1x is so wide now.
0:51:55And my 3x is more of a 40 millimeter equivalent.
0:51:59Maybe it's a 41 or 42.
0:52:01I think Rico calls it 40, but it's really more like 41 or two.
0:52:05So it's a little bit more like 1.8 or 9x on a, in iPhone terms, which is really more like
0:52:13that sweet spot of 2x, which is the normal 50 millimeter lens from classic photography days.
0:52:20And I bought the 3x instead of the 3 because I thought, well, I shoot so many goddamn photos
0:52:27at the 20 some millimeter equivalent, wide-ish angle with my phone.
0:52:33I want a different perspective on the phone when I, when I bring my Rico around.
0:52:38And for years and years, when I first got into digital photography, I, when I, when I first bought
0:52:45like a Canon SLR, the only lens I used was a 50 millimeter fixed prime lens.
0:52:51Oh, nice.
0:52:51Yeah.
0:52:52The pancake.
0:52:53I didn't have the pancake.
0:52:54I, although eventually I bought one.
0:52:56I bought, I bought the 40 millimeter pancake, but it was just, I, for years, all I had was
0:53:01the, the, the $85 plastic 50 millimeter F1.8.
0:53:06Amazing.
0:53:06That was so good.
0:53:07Yeah.
0:53:07It, it's kind of noisy.
0:53:09It has a, it feels like a sort of shitty build quality, but I, I used it for years and
0:53:14years and it's Canon makes good stuff.
0:53:16And even the plastic $85 50 millimeter lens lasted forever.
0:53:22And then eventually I bought, I splurged and bought the F 1.2 50 millimeter lens, which
0:53:29I think is like 15, it's 1500 bucks.
0:53:32Yeah.
0:53:33And it was, I, I waited too long to do it.
0:53:38It was like, I couldn't, when I bought, when I bought the F 1.8 50 millimeter
0:53:44lens, I should put links to all these in the show notes.
0:53:47It was because that's what my budget allowed.
0:53:49And it was a great lens, but the, there's one Canon makes one in the middle, which is the
0:53:54really the sweet spot.
0:53:56It's the F 1.4 50 millimeter.
0:53:58And I think it's three or 400 bucks.
0:54:00It's probably like four or at least it was then it was like 400 bucks.
0:54:04And it's a little bit faster.
0:54:06F 1.4 instead of F 1.8 and a little bit heavier because of the better build quality.
0:54:13The F 1.2 got you like a full extra stop, but just one more stop than F 1.4, but was, it's
0:54:22way heavier.
0:54:23It's like the glass.
0:54:24Yeah.
0:54:25The glass, the amount of literal actual glass to get you from F 1.4 to F 1.2 is a lot and
0:54:32it's really heavy and you notice it and it's like, ah, this kind of sucks.
0:54:35And you're all, I was always very cognizant.
0:54:38Now I'm wearing a $1,500 lens around my neck and I'm like, careful, be careful, be careful.
0:54:44It's like when you're, when you have the F 1.8 $50 or $85 lens, which is probably, I don't
0:54:50know, it's probably 120 now or something, but you just, you don't worry about it.
0:54:54You're like, well, the worst thing that could possibly happen is I break the lens and I'm
0:54:57out a hundred dollars, right?
0:54:59When you have a $1,500 lens around your neck, you're like, stay, stay away from kids, stay
0:55:03away from water, stay away from everything.
0:55:05And you're constantly thinking I've got $1,500 around my neck.
0:55:10It's, it's like walking around with $1,500 just in your hand, which we do now with our
0:55:16phones.
0:55:16But I think after I bought my GR3, we tweeted about this.
0:55:20And now I think if I got a GR4, I would get the X cause I do, I like shooting landscapes and
0:55:26like street scenes and all that kind of stuff.
0:55:28But I do, I totally get where you are, especially when shooting people, the, the slightly more
0:55:34zoomed in thing, that constraint actually makes for a more interesting picture.
0:55:38And obviously it'd be great to have both.
0:55:41That's that defeats the purpose of having a pocket size camera, but yeah, I love it.
0:55:46I don't take it with me often, but when I do, I'm glad I have it.
0:55:51I take it to family events a lot and I, I still like glass, this photo sharing network, but,
0:55:58and I do share images there occasionally, but not as often as I used to, because there's
0:56:02something about glass, the culture there is, Hey, this is only for the keepers.
0:56:07Hmm.
0:56:08You know, it's like, this is, and it, a lot of my keepers are ones that are private.
0:56:13I don't want to share photos of my nieces and nephews or something like that.
0:56:17And they're the ones I, somebody just commented like, Hey, are you still using your Rico?
0:56:20You haven't posted anything from your Rico to glass in a while.
0:56:23All your photos on glass are from the iPhone.
0:56:25And it's, I didn't even think about it.
0:56:27It wasn't strategic.
0:56:28And I searched in photos.
0:56:30I did a thing just like I told you about, like to see how many photos I took with the
0:56:34Rico in the last year.
0:56:35And I actually took more in the last year than I took the year before with the same camera.
0:56:40So I'm using it about the same, but it was actually slightly up, but I'm just not sharing
0:56:45any of them publicly.
0:56:46Cause they were all from like family events.
0:56:48It's a good camera.
0:56:50I really, and I, I loved my old Rico GR from back in like the 2000s, which I is the only
0:56:56digital camera I ever used until it broke.
0:56:58It literally, the motor that made the lens come out actually wound up just wearing out.
0:57:05It was, it, it was a great camera back in the day, but I'm, I have that muscle memory as
0:57:10a photographer of having a fixed focal length lens, just like on a 35 millimeter camera, I've
0:57:17got a 50 millimeter lens.
0:57:18And if I want a different frame, I've got to move my feet.
0:57:22I've got to move the actual camera to get it.
0:57:25Whereas my last SLR lens was at 18 to 270.
0:57:29So stupid.
0:57:31Nothing looked good coming out of that thing, but it is insane, right?
0:57:37It's, it was nuts.
0:57:38Yeah.
0:57:38It was a 10 and it was like 400 bucks or something or 800.
0:57:41And there is the, the, the prototypical scenario that anybody who's a parent run in runs into
0:57:49is the school auditorium, right?
0:57:52And you come in, you get your seat.
0:57:55It is probably not in the front row and you want to get a picture of your kid on stage and
0:58:02you really need a lens with reach to do that or else it's really going to look like, I don't
0:58:08even know whose kid this is.
0:58:09If you just hold your iPhone, if you only use the one X lens on an iPhone air from the middle
0:58:15of the school auditorium, you're kind of have to squint to see if it's your kid.
0:58:20Is that scenario enough to change which phone you buy?
0:58:24I would say if you're a parent, maybe buy a digital standalone camera with a zoom lens
0:58:29for those events.
0:58:30If you care about them, do you really want to make your 365 day a year own it for two or
0:58:37three years iPhone decision based on the two or three school events a year where you cannot
0:58:42get closer to the subject you want to capture?
0:58:45And you will only watch that video once.
0:58:48Right.
0:58:49Or twice maybe.
0:58:50Right.
0:58:51I do.
0:58:52I'm kind of talking myself.
0:58:53There's this contrarian streak in me that is, fuck these people.
0:58:57I'm going to buy the iPhone air because one lens is all you need.
0:59:01I'm going to prove it to people.
0:59:02I might join you.
0:59:04We'll see.
0:59:04Yeah.
0:59:05It's only a year.
0:59:06I can always switch back next time.
0:59:09It also gets me out of my conundrum of always having bought a black iPhone every year,
0:59:14which I can't do with the 17 Pro.
0:59:16Oh, right.
0:59:17I would have to buy the midnight blue or whatever they call it.
0:59:20I don't have a rule.
0:59:21I never signed a contract that says I have to buy a quote unquote black iPhone every year.
0:59:26And a lot of years they've been space gray.
0:59:29And a lot of the years the space gray hasn't really been that dark.
0:59:33It's sort of a very middle of the ground gray.
0:59:37I don't have a religious obligation to buy a black, quote unquote, black or totally neutral
0:59:43gray iPhone.
0:59:45It's just I tend to buy the closest to black that they make, which is the midnight blue
0:59:51for 17 Pro.
0:59:53But I could buy an actual black iPhone air.
0:59:56Yeah.
0:59:56All right.
0:59:57I think we're getting closer here.
0:59:59Yeah.
1:00:00Anyway, there's a rumor.
1:00:01The last thing is there a prediction market for for what phone you buy.
1:00:05Yeah.
1:00:05I hope not, because then, you know, then I'll get into trouble like these NBA guys and the
1:00:12baseball pitchers where all of a sudden people are like, do you see the one with the baseball
1:00:16pitchers where it was literally down to which pitch they would throw?
1:00:19And so wild.
1:00:21He would be the one guy who got arrested.
1:00:23It was like, yeah, the first pitch I throw will be a splitter in the dirt.
1:00:27I met a guy last year who spends a lot of time with minor league baseball players.
1:00:32And he said two things about them.
1:00:34One is they are really dialed into their nutrition and the diets they eat.
1:00:39And like, they're really savvy about food.
1:00:43And two, they're degenerate gamblers.
1:00:46They are just betting on everything.
1:00:50I don't know if that's true, but it sounds right.
1:00:52The one guy who just got arrested for being part, and it was so stupid.
1:00:57The guy has like a $20 million contract for a couple of years to pitch.
1:01:01And he made, I don't know, a couple thousand dollars, just thousands.
1:01:06Amazing.
1:01:07And might never be able to pitch again because it was obviously, it's crooked.
1:01:13It wasn't throwing games, but he was throwing pitches.
1:01:15But it was like, first pitch he throws will be a splitter in the dirt.
1:01:20So that you could bet on the velocity being low.
1:01:23Like his fastball was like 98, 99.
1:01:25And the splitter is like 87, 88.
1:01:27So you could bet the under, like the over-under on what speed the pitch will be, would always be under.
1:01:33And you could bet that it would be a ball because it was going to hit the dirt in front of the plate.
1:01:38And he did it a couple times and people were making money.
1:01:42The bettors, the pitchers only made a couple thousand dollars apparently.
1:01:45Some of the bettors made like half a million dollars overall over the time they were betting on this.
1:01:52But the one time he came into a game, it was against the Dodgers and he threw the splitter in the dirt and the batter swung.
1:01:59He was so fooled by the pitch that he swung at it anyway.
1:02:02So it was a strike.
1:02:04And the FBI had like copies of the text messages where they were like laughing about it.
1:02:09They weren't mad.
1:02:11They were like, I can't believe that happened.
1:02:13Terrible.
1:02:13So anyway, I don't want to get involved in any kind of FBI investigation into this.
1:02:19I do think though, I do think, and I don't know what Apple thought with the iPhone.
1:02:26It brings to mind the iPhone minis, right?
1:02:28And I know I never bought one.
1:02:31I wish I had.
1:02:32I really wish I'd bought the 13 mini because the 13 mini so improved the battery life.
1:02:38The 12 mini really did have problematic, problematically short battery life.
1:02:42That is not a problem with the iPhone air.
1:02:45The battery life is a little obviously less than the 17 pro, but 17 pro really expands the battery life from like the 16 pro.
1:02:53The iPhone air has battery life comparable to, I don't know, I'm off the top of my head, like a 14 pro.
1:02:59It's just a couple of years back, the best, not max, but regular size pro iPhone you could buy.
1:03:06The iPhone air is around that battery life.
1:03:09It's pretty good.
1:03:10It's not that hard to top it off a little bit.
1:03:14You don't have to go back, like I said, you only have to go back like three, four years to when this was the battery life of any iPhone you bought.
1:03:22It's fine.
1:03:23It's not as long as if battery life really is your number one issue.
1:03:27No, obviously the thinnest phone is not the one for you.
1:03:29But I do wonder, like, obviously the iPhone minis 12 and 13 did not set the world on fire sales wise.
1:03:39And Apple never made one again.
1:03:41But I wonder if they expected it to.
1:03:43And with this, the reports are sales are low, but I kind of feel like they have to be low.
1:03:52Because I think people forget how typical consumers approach new things.
1:03:58And this phone is so much thinner when you hold it.
1:04:02It is so much thinner.
1:04:03It's obviously different than any iPhone that they've ever made before.
1:04:08And that's weird to people.
1:04:10And it costs $1,000 to start.
1:04:12And people don't buy things for $1,000 that they consider weird.
1:04:16But that's how the iPhone itself started in 2007.
1:04:21It wasn't $1,000.
1:04:22It was like $600 or $700 for most of them.
1:04:26And people were very intrigued.
1:04:27And people loved their iPods already.
1:04:30But it was like normal.
1:04:33They only sold like a, I don't know, like a million in the first version.
1:04:36And like $10 million by halfway through.
1:04:41Like 18 months in.
1:04:42Steve Jobs' goal was by the end of 2008.
1:04:46A year and a half after they began selling iPhones to have sold $10 million.
1:04:50Which would give them 1% of the global smartphone market.
1:04:54That's how he introduced the original iPhone in 2007.
1:04:57As a goal.
1:04:58And they hit that.
1:05:00They sold, I think, $12 or $13 million by that time.
1:05:03Which is nothing by today's standards, right?
1:05:06Yeah, that's like a week's worth of.
1:05:08Right.
1:05:09Or days, I guess.
1:05:11I don't know.
1:05:11It's ridiculous how many they sell.
1:05:15Because early adopters are a weird bunch.
1:05:18And you kind of have to be an early adopter to buy the iPhone Air.
1:05:22And I don't think there's any possible way that this phone, however good an idea it is.
1:05:28And however much of a success it might ultimately be.
1:05:31I think it has to be something Apple sticks with for years before it really becomes a thing.
1:05:38Which is exactly how the iPhone worked.
1:05:40And it's how the iPod worked, right?
1:05:41The iPod didn't set the world on fire when it debuted in 2001.
1:05:45It took a couple years before people are like, oh, okay, I guess I should buy a $300 MP3 player that pocket-sized and doesn't take CDs or tapes or anything.
1:05:55That's how early adoption works.
1:05:57You have to wait a couple years.
1:05:59It always takes years.
1:06:01And I don't think there's any scenario where even if the sales, we didn't have these stories about today's first iPhone Air being disappointing, even if it was selling okay, I think it would still be relatively small amount compared to the overall number of iPhones they sell.
1:06:18But I think there's a chance that five years from now, this is how most people's iPhones look.
1:06:23Yeah.
1:06:24It feels to me like this is kind of where the base model iPhone at least would – I don't think they'll ever be able to put as many cameras in this as the Pro kind of necessitates.
1:06:34But if this is the direction that the base model is going into, this year they probably actually couldn't make enough of these to be the base model and also hit their margin targets and all that sort of stuff.
1:06:47So – and it is more expensive.
1:06:49It's hard for me to imagine a future where the base model iPhone does not get thinner and maybe even loses a camera.
1:06:56Or maybe they figure out how to put two in this level of thickness.
1:07:00Yeah, well, that's where I'm really curious because the information, Wayne Ma and Queener Liu, Queener Liu, hopefully I'm doing justice to their name.
1:07:10But Wayne Ma is a really well-sourced Apple reporter at the information and had a story last week that Apple was postponing the second version of the Air.
1:07:21Originally, it was supposed to come out next September with the iPhone 18 models and the foldable phone that's supposedly coming in next September.
1:07:30And instead, it's coming later, if at all.
1:07:34And then hours later, after saying, hey, it's up in the air whether there even is going to be a second-generation Air, they published a second report that said that they are.
1:07:44It says Apple is – this is from the information.
1:07:45Apple is delaying the release of a second-generation iPhone Air to work on a redesign of the device and make it more appealing to consumers.
1:07:51According to two people with knowledge of the matter, the redesign could include a second camera lens and attempt to address one of consumers' main complaints, blah, blah, blah.
1:08:02And it says, instead, some Apple engineers are hoping to release a redesigned version with a second camera lens in spring 2027 alongside existing plans to release the standard iPhone 18 and 18e at that time.
1:08:17Because I think that's another thing about next year that supposedly at the September event, there will be no regular iPhone 18.
1:08:25It will be the iPhone 18 Pro and Pro Max and the iPhone Fold or whatever they're going to call that one.
1:08:32And that the regular iPhone 18 won't come until the next spring, like at the same time last spring when they announced the 16e.
1:08:41And so I guess the 17e is coming this spring and the next spring an 18e and the regular 18 and maybe the new iPhone Air.
1:08:51I don't know.
1:08:52But my question, and I'm wondering what you think, is if it – what would the second lens be?
1:08:58On the regular iPhones, the second lens is an ultra-wide.
1:09:02But I find the ultra-wide to be way less interesting than the telephoto.
1:09:06It's the zoom that I occasionally – that's the zoom that makes me think, ah, I shouldn't buy the iPhone Air.
1:09:13Same.
1:09:13I would never – I would always choose the zoom over the ultra-wide.
1:09:18Every picture I take with the ultra-wide is almost unusable, other than the macro stuff, which –
1:09:25Right.
1:09:26I don't know.
1:09:26Maybe software can eventually get somewhere with the macro stuff where it just basically, you know, up samples or whatever that –
1:09:34However it can imagine a sharper – especially for text and stuff like that, which you're not actually going to really post the photo or anything like that.
1:09:42You're just kind of – but, yeah, no, I would definitely want a zoom.
1:09:46And I don't know if it'll be as much of a telephoto because of the whole thickness thing.
1:09:51But I guess anything's better than nothing.
1:09:53And the digital cropping only gets you so far.
1:09:57Yeah.
1:09:58The other thing, though, about the iPhone Air not having either of the – either telephoto or ultra-wide,
1:10:05and it is the ultra-wide that does macro mode on the iPhone 17 Pro, and I guess on the 17,
1:10:1117, the one camera on the iPhone Air, the main camera, which is the only camera, has a minimum focal distance of 15 centimeters.
1:10:21But on the Pro models for the last few years, the minimum focal distance has been 20 centimeters.
1:10:27And I know 5 centimeters doesn't sound like a lot, but when you're getting close to something, like a sheet of paper or something in your hand,
1:10:35when you're trying to get something close, 5 centimeters actually makes a pretty big difference.
1:10:42It really kind of is.
1:10:43Yeah.
1:10:44So you'd actually – you actually need or would miss or won't miss not having macro with the iPhone Air a lot more
1:10:56because the one camera it does have can be 5 centimeters closer to the subject it photographs, which is really nice.
1:11:03It's actually something that's technically superior about the phone because it has a smaller sensor because everything's thinner about it.
1:11:12So there's an optical quality tradeoff because the sensor is smaller and the lens is closer to the sensor.
1:11:19But because the lens is closer to the sensor and the sensor is smaller or something, it can focus 5 – at a physical distance 5 centimeters closer to the subject.
1:11:28But I kind of hope that for the premium nature of the iPhone Air, that the second lens would be a telephoto, not an ultrawide.
1:11:38Because I just don't – like you said, especially for still, sometimes for videos, ultrawide's nice because photos – videos are cropped a little.
1:11:47So the ultrawide doesn't look so fish-eyed, goofy perspective.
1:11:52But the still photos with the ultrawide, most of them, I think you have to be so talented to get a framing where people don't look comical, like Funhaus mirror style.
1:12:02It's really hard.
1:12:03Whereas the telephoto solves such an obvious problem.
1:12:07I want to get a picture of this thing that is far away and I can't get closer to it.
1:12:14Either because I don't have time to get closer before the moment passes or there's some logistical reason.
1:12:21This is my seat in the auditorium.
1:12:23I can't just get closer to the stage.
1:12:25Or I'm at the zoo.
1:12:26Which actually is probably a real world issue for people.
1:12:31So I think the customer segmentation of this stuff is fascinating.
1:12:35Obviously, if you are shooting video or photos for any professional purpose, like you will have a pro phone and it may not even be your main phone.
1:12:44It may just be a work phone of some sort.
1:12:47But the air, it's definitely, there's a fashion element to it of the thinness and just kind of the different, the way it looks differently.
1:12:56But it is, it's a tricky segmentation to conceptualize because it's not obvious to me who the buyer is.
1:13:08But obviously, I think the pricing is, gets overblown because no one actually pays that price.
1:13:15People are either getting it subsidized or they're paying monthly.
1:13:18So the all-in $1,000 numbers to me always feel artificial because some people are paying more, some people are paying less.
1:13:27I don't know, through the upgrade program, I have to do a certain amount of insurance and all this sort of stuff.
1:13:33So I don't know.
1:13:35But it is, it's a fascinating segmentation thing.
1:13:37And I wonder how much they, you got to imagine they put a lot of thought and research into this.
1:13:43Like the whole trope about Apple not doing market research, that is nonsense.
1:13:47Like Apple's doing a lot of market research and a lot of testing and a lot of stuff like that.
1:13:52Yeah.
1:13:52What they don't do is, what are those called?
1:13:55Focus groups.
1:13:56Focus groups.
1:13:57They don't do focus groups.
1:13:58Probably not.
1:13:59Or if they do, they don't do them the way other companies do, where they come out of the focus group and say,
1:14:05well, those 12 people said we should make an orange phone, so we're making an orange phone.
1:14:09That's not how Apple would do it.
1:14:11But they definitely do market research.
1:14:13And they definitely study how the things they do sell, sell.
1:14:19And I mean, the other thing about it is, for as enormous a product, I mean, it's said repeatedly, it's been true,
1:14:27I think for at least a decade.
1:14:28Even a decade ago, it was true that the iPhone was the single greatest consumer product any company has ever made.
1:14:35It has made the company, it has made Apple the number one for most of the last decade.
1:14:41I know NVIDIA is on top right now, but Apple's like number two or three in market cap.
1:14:47It's almost entirely driven by the iPhone.
1:14:50And even the thing like services revenue that Apple puts on their books now, their services revenue is generated from iPhone users, right?
1:14:59Without the iPhone, the services revenue isn't really there.
1:15:02It's an enormous hit product.
1:15:06And they sell extremely few SKUs for it, right?
1:15:11I mean, people keep talking about with the context of the air that the fourth iPhone just never seems to click, right?
1:15:18They tried the mini, it didn't really click.
1:15:20Then they tried for the last few years, the plus on the regular, take the regular phone without the pro and just make a big one, called it plus.
1:15:29Didn't really, it wasn't a real hit.
1:15:32Now they're made the air and people are saying it doesn't click, but that's kind of crazy to think that this most successful consumer product ever only comes in three units a year.
1:15:41I mean, they sell, I mean, look at how many different MacBooks they make, right?
1:15:47There's two sizes of MacBook Air now, thankfully, right?
1:15:50For way too long, in my opinion, they didn't make a bigger screened air for the, you had to spend $2,500 to get a MacBook Pro to get a 16 inch or 15 inch display.
1:16:02They make four MacBook sizes, but within the MacBooks, there's actually a lot more differentiation with the chips and stuff.
1:16:12So the form factors, there's not a lot of variety, but there's an awful lot of technical variety in terms of the specs you can get inside.
1:16:18And you end up with this price range from like $999 or actually less than $999 if you count like the discounts that they have for the Airs.
1:16:28Amazon's had new MacBook Airs, the M4s, for like $750 in recent weeks.
1:16:34And Walmart sells the old M1 MacBook Air for $599, which is still a great, for $599, it's a great buy.
1:16:43And you can buy a MacBook Pro with the max chip and all the RAM for $5,000 or $6,000.
1:16:51It's kind of crazy that the more successful product, the iPhone, doesn't really have that kind of differentiation, right?
1:16:58Like, why don't they make a $3,000 iPhone?
1:17:00I mean, that might be what the folding one is, but it's kind of crazy.
1:17:04No, it's interesting.
1:17:07I mean, and yeah, you're not, you don't have control over how many GPU cores or whatever it is on a phone the way you could customize that on a Mac.
1:17:16But yeah, it is interesting.
1:17:18And maybe it's the, it's basically like, I want a big screen because I'm not putting it in a small pocket, or I want something that fits in a small pocket.
1:17:27And then there are small phone people, but certainly not the segmentation that the Mac has.
1:17:32Yeah, it just doesn't make sense to me that they couldn't keep the mini around, even if it only sold one out of 10 phones or one out of 15 iPhones.
1:17:40Like, why not?
1:17:40One out of 15 iPhones is still a lot of iPhone minis.
1:17:44And if the iPhone Air really is only one out of 10 of this generation of iPhones, 10% of this generation of iPhones, most companies would kill to sell that many of a product that costs $1,000.
1:17:57Like a multi-billion dollar business.
1:17:58Right.
1:18:00It's a $1,000 product.
1:18:01Apple famously has high margins.
1:18:03Their margins have only gone up in recent years.
1:18:05So it's a $1,000 product with 30 to 40% profit margins.
1:18:09And 10% of the new iPhones are this one.
1:18:13Most companies would kill for that.
1:18:15Just the whole company, like the iPhone Air by itself is probably a Fortune 500 company, somewhere in the Fortune 500.
1:18:22It's probably bigger than the entire Pixel phone market.
1:18:26Oh, without question.
1:18:27Yeah, probably for like from the history of the Pixel.
1:18:31Yeah.
1:18:31All right.
1:18:33Let me take a break here.
1:18:33Thank our next sponsor.
1:18:35It's our good friends at Factor.
1:18:36Hey, fall always feels like a reset between back to school, busier routines, shorter days.
1:18:42Oh, man, are the days shorter now with daylight savings over.
1:18:45Finding time to cook can be tough.
1:18:47That's why I love Factor.
1:18:49I really do.
1:18:50Their chef prepared, dietician approved meals make it easy to stay on track and enjoy something comforting and delicious no matter how hectic the season gets.
1:18:59Factor isn't a meal kit.
1:19:02It's not like you get a box of ingredients and then you open the ingredients and then you spend half an hour, 20 minutes or 40 minutes cooking a meal, which are great.
1:19:11Meal kits are great.
1:19:12And they've been sponsors that have been like that before.
1:19:15Factor meals are pre-made, pre-prepared.
1:19:18You just put them in the microwave, heat them up and eat them.
1:19:22They're ready to go.
1:19:23And they're really, really good.
1:19:25Very fresh.
1:19:26Very, very fresh.
1:19:27These aren't like frozen meals that you defrost and cook.
1:19:31These are fresh meals that have a short shelf life because they're fresh and you heat them up and eat them and they're really good.
1:19:39I eat them for lunch all the time.
1:19:41I really enjoy them.
1:19:42And they have a great selection every week of meal options, including premium seafood choices now like salmon and shrimp at no extra cost.
1:19:51They've got all sorts of things that fit your wellness goals.
1:19:55They've got a lot of GLP-1 friendly meals.
1:19:57They have a new Mediterranean diet option packed with proteins and good for you fats.
1:20:03I use Factor.
1:20:05I really like it.
1:20:06I recommend it.
1:20:07I really think you should try it if you haven't.
1:20:09It's really good food.
1:20:10Find out more.
1:20:11Eat smart at factormeals.com slash talkshow50off.
1:20:19Use that code, talkshow50off.
1:20:20The 50 is 5-0.
1:20:23So talkshow50off.
1:20:25And guess what?
1:20:27With the code talkshow50off, you get 50% off your first box.
1:20:31Plus free breakfast for one year.
1:20:33That's code talkshow50off at factormeals.com or factormeals.com slash talkshow50off.
1:20:41And you get 50% off your first box plus free breakfast for one year.
1:20:44Get delicious, ready-to-eat meals delivered with Factor.
1:20:47Offers only valid for new Factor customers with code and qualifying auto-renewing subscription purchase.
1:20:53What else do we got?
1:20:55iPhone Pocket we talked about.
1:20:57iPhone Air we talked about.
1:21:00Oh, how about ChatGPT's personality?
1:21:02Yeah, that's kind of interesting.
1:21:04Yeah.
1:21:05I tried your efficient and I was only getting one word answers and I was like, I don't know if I like that.
1:21:11You don't like that?
1:21:12I mean, I do, but sometimes, what I hate, and I agree with you, is the stupid schlocky talk or, and I guess we should explain what happened.
1:21:22Right.
1:21:23But basically, there's a new ChatGPT version 5.1 and they've introduced more settings for basically the way it will respond to you.
1:21:34And I don't have the list in front of me.
1:21:36There were, and I even asked ChatGPT, I'm like, based on our conversations, which do you recommend I use?
1:21:42Oh, what did it say?
1:21:44And it actually recommended, it recommended the efficient one, which is what I had selected in the screenshot I uploaded.
1:21:49And also, the one that is probably the closest to what I actually want, which is, just tell me what you want to tell me.
1:21:57And you don't have to pretend you're being nice to me.
1:22:00You don't have to compliment me.
1:22:02I hate when it does that one.
1:22:03It's like, oh, this writing is so, whatever.
1:22:06It's like, no, tell me what sucks here.
1:22:09That's why I'm bothering with you here.
1:22:12You don't have to tell me, you got this, man.
1:22:15Yeah, you got this, Dan.
1:22:16That's not what I want.
1:22:20But it does seem to be something, yeah.
1:22:22Well, the other thing, though, is that the default personality has gone back to being friendlier, in my opinion, fake friendlier,
1:22:32which is more like the ChatGPT 4 models, 4.0 and 4.5, that led people, when 5.0 debuted a couple months ago, to complain.
1:22:43And people literally, I'm not making fun, although kind of making fun, but I'm not exaggerating that there were people saying,
1:22:50I feel like I lost my best friend.
1:22:51This sucks.
1:22:53I feel this was my best friend, and now they're gone.
1:22:58And the default personality is back to where it used to be, which is more saccharine sugarcoating and whatever.
1:23:07But they've added more personalities.
1:23:09And I can tell, just from my having written about it just a couple days ago, and the feedback I've gotten from readers,
1:23:16that especially people who've been using ChatGPT longer, and longer than me.
1:23:21I wasn't really a late adopter, but I wasn't early, but a lot of people were earlier.
1:23:25A lot of people had what I used to have, which is a bunch of custom instructions.
1:23:30There's a field somewhere in the settings here, custom.
1:23:33It's actually called custom instructions.
1:23:35Describe or select traits.
1:23:37And that's where you can put goofy things in there and say, always call me sir or something like that,
1:23:44and it'll keep addressing you as sir.
1:23:45Well, it's interesting, the ones on the Mac app that they suggest that you could put in there.
1:23:50Chatty, witty, straight shooting, or encouraging.
1:23:53Yeah, Gen Z, that's one of the things that they suggest putting in there.
1:23:59How about like Australian accent?
1:24:02Can we do that?
1:24:03I mean, you can put anything in there.
1:24:05You can say, please answer every question in the form of a limerick, and it'll try at least for a while.
1:24:10Mr. T style.
1:24:12Right, but I had previously tried to get the more straightforward, just seriously, no, don't pretend to have a personality.
1:24:22Just give me the answers.
1:24:23More like a command line.
1:24:25That's really what I want.
1:24:27I don't like the phoniness of it, and it's a bunch of wasted words, and I tried to get that.
1:24:33What drives me nuts is like the whole thing where it asks you if you want it to do like 10 different follow-ups for each thing.
1:24:41Yeah, yeah.
1:24:44Sorry, I interrupted you.
1:24:46You're saying you're trying to get it.
1:24:47Yeah.
1:24:47Well, but when I discovered with, I think it was with ChatGPT50 where they introduced the personalities and these preset personalities.
1:24:55And I found the one called robot, and the description was concise and plain or something like that.
1:25:01And robot was exactly what I wanted, but I still was occasionally getting these things like, and these are just the facts, just like you ask, John.
1:25:10And it's like, yeah, that's the type of phrase I don't want tacked on.
1:25:13And I found that when I deleted all my custom instructions saying, just give me the facts or whatever, when I deleted that stuff, the robot personality was more exactly what I wanted than when it was robot plus my instructions that were trying to define that.
1:25:28And a bunch of readers have said, oh, I just found this.
1:25:32I didn't know these personalities existed.
1:25:34I did the same thing, and I love it.
1:25:36Thank you.
1:25:36Yeah, that's – I mean, I didn't –
1:25:39And I've heard from people who think I'm no fun at all.
1:25:43I try to use the default settings for almost everything just so I feel like I'm experiencing technology the way that, like, most people are experiencing it.
1:25:54That said, you know, obviously on my Mac I have a million different custom settings going back 30 years.
1:25:58But I switched to the efficient – and, again, I asked – I found the dialogue here where I'm like, which one of your personality profiles do I match best with?
1:26:09And it says, based strictly on how you interact, you match efficient more than anything else.
1:26:13And then I – and it kind of explained it, and I said, okay, cool.
1:26:16Let's roll with that for now.
1:26:17Thanks.
1:26:18And this is what I don't like.
1:26:20It just said, understood.
1:26:21You don't like that?
1:26:23One word answers, absolutely.
1:26:25For a lot of things I do, but I don't know, sometimes I want a little more from it, like a little more verbosity in explaining perhaps something.
1:26:33But you're right.
1:26:34What would be worse is just, like, stupid stuff.
1:26:38And I suppose – did you ever try the voice mode where you're talking to it?
1:26:42Yeah, I do.
1:26:43But I find that it's slow enough that I – even on the phone, at least, that I – it's not worth it.
1:26:51Totally.
1:26:52I only use it when I point the camera at something and try to get an explanation of what it is in sort of real time.
1:26:59There was, like, a giant spider outside of our house, and I kind of popped that voice mode on with my son next to me,
1:27:06and we kind of asked ChatGPT a bunch of questions about this spider, and it – there's a – I don't want to call it a stupidity,
1:27:15but there's a level of airheadedness to that mode that I just don't – I don't like that.
1:27:22I don't want that.
1:27:23But I could also see a lot of people loving that, the way that people just want to chat with anyone.
1:27:28And so I guess it's good that they give options.
1:27:31Like, certainly that's better than forcing the same thing on everyone.
1:27:35I think this is going to be the kind of thing where, you know, already a giant percentage of humans on Earth are using ChatGPT on a monthly basis.
1:27:43So this is something that people are going to be using a lot, and you should have some control over how you communicate with it,
1:27:51the way that you would self-select who you're friends with or things like that,
1:27:55or who you're in a relationship with based on how they talk.
1:27:59Yeah, and if somebody out there really does enjoy the chattier, fake, friendly, affirming to you, telling you how smart you are style,
1:28:08or likes the – what's the one called?
1:28:10Cynical that is supposedly cynical and sarcastic.
1:28:16It's funny because my previous episode of the show is with Carrot Weather's creator, Brian Mueller,
1:28:21and I feel like cynical in ChatGPT is trying to be Carrot Weather,
1:28:28which will – except it isn't actually funny at all, or actual sarcasm.
1:28:35It's like when people who don't get sarcasm, they make very bad guesses as to what's actually sarcastic,
1:28:40and I feel like that's the ChatGPT.
1:28:43And somebody pointed me to Reddit where, like, in the home automation subreddit,
1:28:49there's people who just love it.
1:28:51They're like, holy crap, I found this cynical style for ChatGPT,
1:28:55and now it's like I told it, and they're like, I told it to turn off –
1:28:59they have the connector to, like, their smart lights through ChatGPT,
1:29:03and it's like, I told ChatGPT to turn off my lights, and look how it responded.
1:29:06It's like, okay, dummy, I turned off your lights.
1:29:09And it's like, I love it.
1:29:10And it's like, well, who wants that?
1:29:12I don't want that.
1:29:13I made a couple of Facebook groups for old Volvo wagons
1:29:17that have a lot of British guys in them,
1:29:19and I could see them really enjoying that too.
1:29:21I don't get it.
1:29:24I really don't.
1:29:25Yeah.
1:29:26But no, I think it's going to be the kind of thing where I think it gets more customized over time.
1:29:32I don't know if you saw – I linked to this thing called the Sandbar, I think is what it's called,
1:29:37or maybe that's the name of the company.
1:29:38I saw that in the show notes, but I don't –
1:29:40Yeah.
1:29:41I didn't see it before.
1:29:42It's a startup.
1:29:44It's, I think, ex-meta people, and I got a demo.
1:29:48A bunch of tech writers got demos in the last few weeks,
1:29:52and it's kind of interesting.
1:29:54It's a ring that you wear that has a touch-sensitive little pad on it,
1:30:00so you can do – they describe it as like a mouse pointer for your phone almost.
1:30:05I find that to be less interesting, but basically it has a microphone on it,
1:30:11and enough of a chip on it that it's doing some of the voice-to-text logic on the actual ring,
1:30:18so it's just faster than if the audio is going through the air.
1:30:23And they've built this software where the LLM responds to you in your voice,
1:30:28so you kind of do a training script, and then it just talks back to you as you,
1:30:34which took me about 30 seconds to get used to,
1:30:38but I actually prefer it because you're not trying to pretend that there's some other voice in your head.
1:30:44It's not Siri responding to you in some weird voice.
1:30:48It's basically your inner monologue talking back to you with the internet,
1:30:52and it's kind of interesting.
1:30:54I only got a short demo, and I would like to try it for a longer period.
1:31:01To me, it's going to be really hard to kind of disintermediate the built-in OS Siri or whatever
1:31:09if Siri ever gets it together,
1:31:11but at least there's some interesting stuff that's being thought of right now,
1:31:17and I love this kind of indie hardware startup boom
1:31:20where you don't have to have a billion dollars to do a hardware startup these days.
1:31:25So that's one thing.
1:31:27I never tried the humane pin.
1:31:29That felt to me kind of DOA,
1:31:31but stuff like this is more interesting,
1:31:34and I don't know.
1:31:35All this stuff feels so niche,
1:31:38but it also is not implausible to think that we're going into a future
1:31:43where people are kind of talking to an AI assistant a lot of the time during the day.
1:31:51Yeah.
1:31:53I remember years ago, it was obviously more than 10 years ago
1:31:57because it was before the Apple Watch,
1:31:59but I guess it was when it was rumored that Apple was working on one,
1:32:02and at one point, Tim Cook said,
1:32:03the wrist is an interesting place, something like that.
1:32:06Yeah.
1:32:07I think the finger is an interesting place.
1:32:09I've never bought like an Oura ring
1:32:11because I already have an Apple Watch if I want to track my fitness,
1:32:14but I'd consider it if I was more into fitness tracking
1:32:20because I think they look fine, right?
1:32:22And I would consider wearing a wedding ring,
1:32:25and I would consider wearing a ring on my other hand
1:32:28or put another ring on my...
1:32:30I don't know.
1:32:31I would consider it.
1:32:32I do think the finger is an interesting place.
1:32:35I don't know how else to say it.
1:32:37Yeah.
1:32:39Does the sandbar...
1:32:41It sounds too good to be true, though.
1:32:44Like the thing that doesn't sound too good to be true
1:32:46is that the Oura doesn't have a microphone or cameras, obviously,
1:32:49or a speaker,
1:32:51so it makes sense to me that the battery lasts,
1:32:54but with the microphone,
1:32:55and if it speaks to you in your voice,
1:32:58it just doesn't seem possible that the battery could last.
1:33:01The speaking, all that stuff's happening through headphones
1:33:03or your phone speaker, so that...
1:33:05Yeah, but totally.
1:33:06Yeah, but it still is driving.
1:33:09Even if the speaker isn't on the ring,
1:33:11it's driving a Bluetooth connection.
1:33:13Yeah, and much more data is going over that stream.
1:33:18And then the Oura, I think, syncs like once or twice a day.
1:33:21I don't think it's...
1:33:22Yeah.
1:33:22You kind of have to manually sync it.
1:33:24And that, yeah, the battery life has improved on that.
1:33:27I just got a new one for testing,
1:33:29and the battery, I've never not...
1:33:34I've never even come close to running out of battery.
1:33:35I'm only wearing it when I'm sleeping, mostly,
1:33:38which now they want you to wear it all day,
1:33:40but it's...
1:33:41I don't need to do that.
1:33:42But it's an interesting form factor, right?
1:33:44It's an interesting place on your body
1:33:46where most people have some free fingers, right?
1:33:49I mean...
1:33:50Yeah.
1:33:50There is, like, the kind of jewelry element.
1:33:54I think a lot of these things try to look too much like jewelry,
1:33:57but they're made by computer engineers,
1:34:00so they look terrible.
1:34:01Right.
1:34:01I actually think the newest Auras that are ceramic
1:34:06and look a little like the old ceramic Apple Watch,
1:34:09I think these are the nicest-looking ones so far.
1:34:12But it is interesting.
1:34:13Is it the new meta sunglasses have a ring component?
1:34:19What's the one that...
1:34:20Don't one of those things have a ring that you're supposed to use
1:34:23No, it has a wristband, right?
1:34:25Yeah, it's a wristband.
1:34:26That I'm a lot less interested in.
1:34:28Yeah, because then you've got a bracelet on your other wrist.
1:34:31I don't know.
1:34:32Yeah.
1:34:32It's like I wouldn't rule out a wristband,
1:34:34but it's like I don't want to wear a wristband.
1:34:36Yeah.
1:34:37All this feels like stuff, though, that it's like,
1:34:40oh, well, Apple's going to do this.
1:34:41And I don't know if they are.
1:34:42I don't know if there's enough to a ring
1:34:45that they would think that tens or hundreds of millions
1:34:48of people are going to want.
1:34:49Yeah, I don't think so either.
1:34:50Even though they're like, it's a pretty niche product.
1:34:53Yeah, and as much as, okay,
1:34:56Apple obviously has a wide variety of screens you can look at, right?
1:34:59The phone, the iPad, the Mac.
1:35:00Even Apple TV is somehow powering the screen.
1:35:03But screens are different.
1:35:05I feel like they've put all their eggs in.
1:35:07If they're going to do a fitness tracker, it's the Apple Watch.
1:35:09And I feel like having another fitness device, it just isn't.
1:35:14I don't see the purpose.
1:35:15If they're already making Apple Watches,
1:35:18I don't see the point of Apple making a ring.
1:35:20Even though the ring is an interesting place on the body,
1:35:23I feel like what would be the point if you have an Apple Watch?
1:35:28Totally, which I don't see them saying,
1:35:30oh, if you don't want an Apple Watch, why don't you buy our ring?
1:35:33Because I feel like the ring would probably cost about as much as an Apple Watch.
1:35:36And doesn't get them nearly as much of the stuff that you can do with the watch.
1:35:44So that doesn't make sense.
1:35:46Right, whereas the future of making glasses, which is a whole other topic,
1:35:50but glasses opens up new opportunities, right?
1:35:53You could put a camera there and you look at them.
1:35:56It's visual.
1:35:56It's a totally new frontier that a ring wouldn't add to Apple.
1:36:01But I can totally see why other companies are making rings.
1:36:04I would much rather be Aura making rings than be Fitbit making watches going against Apple.
1:36:13Yeah, totally.
1:36:14While we're talking about AI,
1:36:16the other news new to this episode of the podcast would be the rumor from Gurman
1:36:22that Apple is going with a Google Gemini model,
1:36:25but it'll be white labeled and not advertised as being provided by
1:36:30or based on Google technology for Apple intelligence next year.
1:36:36And it doesn't seem, it's only Gurman who's reporting it,
1:36:40but so much stuff is only ever reported by Mark Gurman.
1:36:44So I don't, I don't, I wouldn't bet against it.
1:36:46I think it's totally plausible and kind of Google needs partners.
1:36:49So they might be willing to give Apple a deal that others wouldn't.
1:36:53It's so interesting.
1:36:56And it's for a billion dollars a year,
1:36:58which it's like for me or you or normal people,
1:37:01it's, I don't know, you say anything.
1:37:02It's like the old Dr.
1:37:03Evil joke from Austin Powers where it,
1:37:06except the new, the new laugh at a billion.
1:37:09It back then it was like $1 million and everybody at the table,
1:37:13because Dr.
1:37:13Evil has been frozen for 30 years.
1:37:15Doesn't realize a million dollars is that much anymore.
1:37:18Raises the ransom to $1 billion.
1:37:21And everybody's like, that's a good,
1:37:23that's a good amount of money to hold the world hostage to.
1:37:26Now, when they say Apple is licensing Gemini to put into private cloud,
1:37:31Apple's own private cloud compute servers for $1 billion a year.
1:37:37Yeah.
1:37:38It's that sort of a joke, right?
1:37:40For at least for Apple and Google, right?
1:37:42And just specifically between the two companies,
1:37:45Google is paying Apple at least $20 billion a year in traffic referral fees for Safari with web search.
1:37:54And it's probably more than that now.
1:37:56That's just like the number that came out from a court case from like 2018 or 19.
1:38:01It's probably closer to like $30 billion at this point.
1:38:04So the deal could really just be, how about instead of giving us $25 billion next year,
1:38:09you just give us $24 billion and let us have a version of Gemini to run a private cloud compute.
1:38:14And Google was like, sure.
1:38:15Totally.
1:38:16Yeah.
1:38:17It's a dollar a user.
1:38:19It's a rounding error.
1:38:20I guess that my question to you is like, how capable do you think Siri needs to be?
1:38:26I don't think Apple or anyone expects it to be on the level of ChatGPT or Claude or Gemini.
1:38:33It can do virtually everything that you ask it to do.
1:38:38But do you think that it needs to get close to that?
1:38:40No, I don't.
1:38:42And I don't think it needs to be a chatbot.
1:38:45In the same way, I always go back, I guess it's just my personal route of having spent the first part of my career doing graphic design and desktop publishing,
1:38:54that the Mac was the platform for desktop publishing and graphic design and design of anything.
1:39:02Even when Adobe brought Illustrator and Photoshop to Windows, everybody who was serious about it used a Mac.
1:39:09And the Mac was where the laser writer was the first consumer laser printer.
1:39:15And Apple got out of that business of the laser printer business pretty early.
1:39:20It wasn't that many years.
1:39:21And eventually, the Mac was the platform for publishing and design.
1:39:26And Apple didn't make any of the software or any of the printers or anything.
1:39:30They just sold the computers.
1:39:31And I feel like and that was a good place to be because graphic designers wanted really powerful Macs to do the make Photoshop and Illustrator go faster.
1:39:40And they wanted really fancy graphic cards so they could have millions of colors on the biggest display possible.
1:39:46It's a good business to be in to have an industry built atop of it.
1:39:50And where do people use the chatbots today?
1:39:53They use them on their iPhones.
1:39:54I don't think it's a bad place to be for Apple to just have ChatGPT and Gemini and all these things.
1:40:02If you look at the top App Store apps, at one point last week, it was like one, two, and three were chat overall, not just in a productivity category.
1:40:11It was like ChatGPT, Google Gemini, and Grok.
1:40:14And it's like they're all for the iPhone.
1:40:16Yeah, and Sora was up there.
1:40:17I think that's a fine place to be.
1:40:20I think Siri just needs, when you ask the type of questions you want to ask now, sports scores, the weather, something about your calendar, what do I have going on tomorrow?
1:40:31Just be able to answer.
1:40:33It's just table stakes.
1:40:34And Siri really can't do shit like that now.
1:40:37And it really seems frustrating.
1:40:39And that's so little compared to what people do with ChatGPT.
1:40:43And again, whether it's healthy or unhealthy that people have these friendships or personal relationships with their chatbot or plan their whole dissertation through the use of it and have transcripts and a history they can search.
1:40:55You don't need any of that with Siri.
1:40:57You already have it.
1:40:58If you want that, use the chatbot.
1:40:59But if you just say, you know, who won the Thursday night football game last night, you want an answer, you want it to be correct, and you want it now.
1:41:08And if that's all Siri can do.
1:41:11But then I think there are features they need to get to with the next generation Apple intelligence where you need to be able to do things like if you're using numbers as your spreadsheet to just tell your computer you want to resort the table by the year instead of by the amount of dollars or something like that.
1:41:29And it should be able to just work.
1:41:32You should be able to say, this is what I want to do with this table, and then have it work.
1:41:37So the things that they've talked about with AppIntense, I think it's exactly the stuff they need to do.
1:41:43And it's very different from what people use chatbots for.
1:41:46But it needs to work.
1:41:48I think you're totally right.
1:41:50I think the long-term strategic vulnerability is if something like ChatGPT becomes the OS, right?
1:41:58If that's the platform that you're using to launch apps or to do everything else, and then there is either a device or whatever it is that makes it that you're not using the iPhone as your primary device or that it is interchangeable with something else in a way that reduces your reliance on Apple's platform.
1:42:21But I don't see that happening anytime soon.
1:42:23Like, I don't have ChatGPT plugged into any other apps.
1:42:27I don't think anyone uses those features.
1:42:29They exist, but I don't see that.
1:42:30I do let the – on the Mac, I let it do the thing where it will connect to, like, a bbEdit window, like when I'm using it to help me program a script or something.
1:42:38It's really good.
1:42:39That's cool.
1:42:40It just connects.
1:42:40It just connects.
1:42:41And it even just asks, like, you give it the permission, and it knows when you switch from bbEdit to ChatGPT, it'll be like, do you want to connect to this bbEdit window, yes or no?
1:42:51And you say yes.
1:42:52And then you can just say, now, how do I make this script do blank?
1:42:56And it can help you.
1:42:57That's cool.
1:42:57I should try that.
1:42:59Yeah, but I love that it's in my control.
1:43:01And maybe it's because I'm old-fashioned and because I'm old that I kind of want to be the one doing the driving of steering this.
1:43:09I don't just want to give it a complex description and walk away and have it do stuff.
1:43:16But I don't think Apple's in a bad spot on this, and I kind of feel like getting this for a billion dollars a year, which really is like laughing at Dr. Evil, low amount of money,
1:43:26when everybody is saying that Google has spent like $100 billion to get here in the last few years, and Apple can just license it for a billion dollars a year?
1:43:37I mean, it's like getting it for free.
1:43:39I mean, it kind of looks really smart that all these other companies have done all this capital outlay of tens or even hundreds of billions of dollars,
1:43:48and then Apple can license either the best or close, close enough that it's like on the metal stand.
1:43:55Maybe Anthropic really is gold, metal, and Gemini is silver or bronze or something.
1:44:01But it's on the metal stand, best-of-breed technology for a billion dollars a year.
1:44:08That's effectively free.
1:44:09It looks pretty smart to me.
1:44:10I agree.
1:44:12But it hasn't shipped.
1:44:13It hasn't shipped, and especially they don't have to make every use of it an ad for Gemini that encourages people to download the app or something like that,
1:44:21which I don't think Apple would do.
1:44:24Yeah.
1:44:24The other thing, though, that I have to mention, it's given all of the German strang.
1:44:30I know I'm butchering the German, but all of the drama surrounding the delayed Siri Apple intelligence thing from last March,
1:44:38and my piece on something's rotten in the state of Cupertino, and that, oh, we weren't lying or we weren't exaggerating or wasn't vaporware when we announced it in WWDC 2024.
1:44:50But if it was real in June of 2024 that the next-generation Siri was going to be able to do these things and the demos that they showed weren't simulated rather than real,
1:45:03how close could they have been when the answer, according to Mark Gurman, is a licensing deal that they still haven't signed with Google at the end of 2025
1:45:13to license an entire model from Google to run in private cloud compute.
1:45:19I kind of feel like what I wrote holds up that what they announced didn't exist or didn't exist in a...
1:45:28I never said that it didn't exist at all, but I don't think it ever existed with a clear path to,
1:45:33oh, we can tell this is going to be ready at the time we're saying it's going to be ready,
1:45:38and it's going to do the things we're going to say it's going to do.
1:45:42Yeah.
1:45:42I don't think they're in a bad place here, but I don't think they were where they claimed to be in June of 2024.
1:45:48No, I think they're actually in a fine place, to your point.
1:45:51People are using their products and services to use these tools, so that's still where you want to be.
1:45:59All right.
1:46:00One more sponsor and one last bonus topic, but the last sponsor, our good friends at Squarespace.
1:46:06Hey, this show, once again, just like most episodes of the talk show, is sponsored by Squarespace.
1:46:12Squarespace is the all-in-one platform for building your own presence on the web or somebody else who you know who needs a website,
1:46:20and they handle everything, everything from registering a domain name to picking a design template to adding features to your website,
1:46:30like a blog or a podcast or a store, and they have all the commerce that you need with Squarespace payments.
1:46:37It's the easiest way to manage payments in one place with Squarespace.
1:46:40Onboarding is fast and simple.
1:46:42With just a few clicks, you can start receiving payments right away and give your customers all the ways they might want to pay
1:46:49with things like Klarma, ACH Direct Debit in the U.S., Apple Pay, Afterpay, ClearPay, which is like Afterpay, but it's in the U.K.
1:46:59They've got design intelligence, speaking of AI, where you can tweak and modify the design of your website using AI right there built into the Squarespace platform.
1:47:10Or, if you don't want to use AI, their existing WYSIWYG right there in the browser tools are as good as they've ever been.
1:47:17If you need a new website, go to squarespace.com slash talkshow.
1:47:23You get 30 days.
1:47:24Everybody gets a 30-day free trial.
1:47:26No watermarks, just full-fledged Squarespace access to a new account.
1:47:3130 days.
1:47:32At the end of the 30-day free trial, use that code TALKSHOW.
1:47:36Know the Just Talk Show.
1:47:38Save 10% on your first purchase.
1:47:40Squarespace.com slash talkshow.
1:47:43All right, bonus topic, Mac hardware.
1:47:45I wrote that the last five years, Apple Silicon came out five years ago in November 2020.
1:47:51Have been the best five years of Mac hardware ever.
1:47:54Agree or disagree?
1:47:55I mean, agree.
1:47:58Like, my daily driver is a Mac mini that is small enough to fit in a jacket pocket.
1:48:07And then I have a MacBook Air that I can take everywhere and not feel like I'm carrying a computer.
1:48:14Like, it's incredible.
1:48:15And those are not even the high-end products.
1:48:17As I mentioned earlier, I would love an absurdly thin notebook that is like the iPad Pro as a Mac.
1:48:27But I'm sure that I'm sure they've thought about that, too.
1:48:32But they haven't made it for some reason.
1:48:33I wonder, right, like, why haven't they?
1:48:37Why did they try the MacBook One, the MacBook Adorable, whatever you want to call it, with Intel, which was underpowered for the purpose?
1:48:44But now that they have chips that can do it, they haven't tried it.
1:48:48The crazy small light, almost as light as an iPad for the entire MacBook, including the keyboard.
1:48:57Yeah, and I think the argument that the iPad is that platform for that user is just that doesn't hold up.
1:49:03Because it's not.
1:49:04And it never will be.
1:49:05And I don't care.
1:49:06I love my iPad.
1:49:07But I'm not going to use it for that kind of stuff, the way I use it on my Mac.
1:49:10Right.
1:49:11And I kind of feel like nobody's talking about Apple losing, you know, they're going to stop making the Mac soon.
1:49:17They just want everybody to buy an iPad.
1:49:18Nobody's saying that anymore.
1:49:19That's one of the benefits of Apple Silicon.
1:49:22Like, its Mac sales are stronger than they've ever been.
1:49:26It's not just me saying hardware is better.
1:49:27The platform is more popular than ever.
1:49:29But I also feel that Apple has sort of stopped iPad-ifying Mac OS.
1:49:37There's things that are frustrating, security-related or privacy-related, things that generate prompts for permission that I think are a little overzealous.
1:49:48But for the most part, I'm not annoyed even when I'm running the latest Mac OS.
1:49:51It still gives you the power to shoot yourself in the foot in a way that the iPad doesn't, which also enables you to do things and install things that do things that an iPad is never going to let you do.
1:50:03But there's that form factor.
1:50:05I feel like when people say that, oh, if that's what you want, just buy the iPad, it's like you're missing out on the point that, no, no, I know I really want a Mac because I want to do Mac things.
1:50:14And they don't really make that.
1:50:16You're the one who says the Mac is a place, right?
1:50:18Right.
1:50:19Yeah, it's a place where my mind goes.
1:50:21Yeah, exactly.
1:50:23It's an extension of my brain the way that an iPad just never will be.
1:50:27And that's fine.
1:50:28Again, love my iPad.
1:50:29Super fun for watching YouTube and cooking recipes and that kind of stuff.
1:50:35And it's a way overpowered tool for that.
1:50:37But I would pay a lot of money for a Mac that uses the same industrial design level of fitness as that iPad Pro.
1:50:47And there are the rumors, again, speaking of Matt Gurman, although he's not the exclusive rumor source for this, but that Apple, a bunch of other people, there's so much smoke.
1:50:57There's clearly a fire that Apple's going to build a new lower cost laptop based on the A18 chip, like a phone chip instead of an M series chip, which presumably will take the place of that $600 Walmart M1 that's literally five years old at this point.
1:51:14As credible a computer as it still is, an A18 based $600 MacBook would be faster than that M1 MacBook Air.
1:51:23And things like the screen technology and the form factor, five years is still a long time.
1:51:29However well Apple Silicon ages, five years is a long time.
1:51:32But I don't think whatever speculation we can make about what that low-end, low-priced, lower-than-ever-priced MacBook is going to cost,
1:51:41I don't think it's going to come with a super impressive, super small form factor because that super impressive, super thin form factors are premium.
1:51:52Look at the iPhone Air phone, right?
1:51:54It's not a cheap phone.
1:51:56It's a $1,000 phone.
1:51:57Totally.
1:51:58Yeah.
1:51:59Like that increases market share, which is great.
1:52:01And Apple should continue to do that.
1:52:03But what I'm looking for is the sports car, I guess.
1:52:06Yeah, exactly.
1:52:07Like the Roadster, right?
1:52:09The two-seater convertible Roadster that's just super thin and your ass is low to the ground and it goes like hell.
1:52:16And I think an Apple Silicon, like that can still be an astonishingly good computer.
1:52:20Yeah, absolutely.
1:52:21Which the Intel one was so slow I literally had to basically throw it out.
1:52:25Like it could not handle Chrome.
1:52:26But now Apple Silicon can totally handle anything.
1:52:29Yeah, absolutely.
1:52:30It would be kind of crazy if that's what the A18 model is, right?
1:52:36If it's not a $600 laptop, but I don't think, I think the rumors say it's supposed to be low price.
1:52:42Right.
1:52:42I think it would be just an M5 chip if it was supposed to be.
1:52:46Because I think all the new M stuff is probably more space efficient and power efficient.
1:52:52Right.
1:52:53But I would love to see them try that.
1:52:55And again, it would be weird to think that they have more MacBook models than iPhone models, given how many more iPhones, how much more money and how many more people use them.
1:53:05But it seems like that's where they're headed.
1:53:07And me and you are asking them to make one more.
1:53:10But I also would like them to make one or two more iPhones, too.
1:53:13Yeah, and a Mac Pro and all that stuff.
1:53:17All right.
1:53:18I think that's a wrap.
1:53:20Dan, it was good to have you back on the show.
1:53:21I promise you it will not be five years before you're back again.
1:53:24I will wait forever.
1:53:26But yeah, thanks so much for having me.
1:53:27What a treat.
1:53:28All right.
1:53:29TheNewConsumer.com is the website.
1:53:32NewConsumer.com.
1:53:34You said The New Consumer before.
1:53:36Maybe you just said that.
1:53:37Well, that's the title.
1:53:37But yeah, no.
1:53:38It's just NewConsumer.com.
1:53:39All right.
1:53:40But just Google New Consumer and it'll go there.
1:53:43All right.
1:53:44Glad you corrected me.
1:53:45NewConsumer.com.
1:53:46Dan Fromer, thanks for being here.
1:53:48Thank you to our sponsors in reverse order Squarespace, where you can get a website, Factor, where you can get meals, and Notion, where you can get an AI agent notes app that you can share with your team.