0:00:00Steven Robles, welcome to the talk show, and please, please, please tell me how to pronounce
0:00:05your surname.
0:00:05I'm not even sure anymore.
0:00:07Thanks for having me.
0:00:08It's an honor to be here.
0:00:09I say Steven Robles.
0:00:11Robles.
0:00:12More like a Z.
0:00:13All right.
0:00:14All right.
0:00:15And because I'm going to admit to you something that is probably in the decades of your life
0:00:20completely expected, which is that in my head, I'd been pronouncing your surname Robles.
0:00:29Oh, in elementary school, I had all various.
0:00:31Until I was on your podcast, Primary Tech, with Brian Aiton back in May?
0:00:38Jason, Jason Aiton.
0:00:39Jason, Jason Aiton.
0:00:40Jason Aiton.
0:00:41We'll leave that in.
0:00:42I can mispronounce everybody's name.
0:00:44He told me to tell you he'd love to be on as well.
0:00:46He'll fill in whenever you need.
0:00:47All right.
0:00:48All right.
0:00:48It's good to know.
0:00:49My laptop bag made.
0:00:50That's right.
0:00:51We figured out at a recent Apple event that Jason and I have exactly the same briefcase.
0:00:56We could be part of a movie like Mishap, where one of us takes the wrong bag.
0:01:01It's the Thomas Crown affair style.
0:01:03Exactly.
0:01:04I realized when I was on your show, I believe you as the host introduced yourself and Jason,
0:01:10and that's suddenly when I realized how your surname was pronounced.
0:01:15Because, like, I watch your YouTubes all the time.
0:01:18You don't say it.
0:01:20You don't have to.
0:01:20You just jump right in.
0:01:21That's YouTube style, where there is no introduction.
0:01:24That's right.
0:01:25Yeah.
0:01:25It's pronounced Pixelmator.
0:01:27That's how you say your last name.
0:01:28Yes.
0:01:28Pixelmator.
0:01:29That's it.
0:01:30That's it.
0:01:31Steven Mator.
0:01:33Well, while we're talking about it, one of the reasons I wanted to have you on the show,
0:01:37A, because I thought we got along swimmingly when I was on your show, but B, just in the last,
0:01:43I was going to say month, but it's more like a fortnight.
0:01:46It's like two weeks.
0:01:47You've gone full time on your YouTube channel.
0:01:49You've joined the ranks of independent media.
0:01:52I have.
0:01:53It's something I've thought about for a while, but a variety of things have made it possible,
0:01:58like my shortcuts community, and people have really been responding to my videos, and the
0:02:04channel has grown, and so I decided to make the jump.
0:02:06I'm going to take issue right away with the title of your episode of your YouTube show where
0:02:14you announced it, which was, I don't have a job anymore thanks to you.
0:02:20Let me tell you, running your own independent media, I don't know if you've figured it out
0:02:25yet in the two weeks you've been doing it.
0:02:26It is definitely a fucking job, Steven.
0:02:28People who say YouTube is passive income don't do YouTube, at least not the YouTube that I
0:02:35do, but I also do A, B titles for all my stuff.
0:02:38That video was one of them, and so YouTube allows me to test out two or three titles at
0:02:43a time, including two or three thumbnails, and so that actually won out out of the few options
0:02:48I put.
0:02:50Did you try day job?
0:02:52I don't know right now.
0:02:54So the two titles I put was, I don't have a job anymore thanks to you.
0:03:00Which won out?
0:03:01I'm going to, well, you know what?
0:03:05YouTube thinks I put the same title for both.
0:03:07Oh, no, I'm sorry.
0:03:08I tested the thumbnail with the same title.
0:03:09One thumbnail said three years later, and one thumbnail said going solo, and going solo
0:03:16got 54%, while I was three years later, got 45%.
0:03:20Okay.
0:03:21Well, I think you should have called it a day job, because it is most definitely a job, but
0:03:25congratulations having gone through this transition myself at this point a long time ago.
0:03:31But it's, and I've never, I've spoken to so many other people who have done it.
0:03:34Nobody has ever been anything except terrified.
0:03:37Is it true for you?
0:03:39It is terrifying.
0:03:40But, you know, I have a wife and three kids.
0:03:42I've worked full-time jobs my entire life.
0:03:44I turn 40 next year, and so I thought, well, it seems like a time to try it.
0:03:50It's working out that way.
0:03:51Let's do it.
0:03:52Let's do it.
0:03:52All right.
0:03:53John Syracuse said he didn't quit his day job until what, like three years ago, four years
0:03:57ago?
0:03:57I forget how long it's been at this point, but it's, I don't know, four years at the most,
0:04:02which is ridiculous.
0:04:03But, well, it's good to have you.
0:04:04And I will just say, I counted them up in the preparation of you being on this show
0:04:10today, that you've done, in the last two weeks, you've published 11 videos on your channel.
0:04:15Which, I'm not sure that's sustainable, but it's a lot.
0:04:21I mean, not a lot like it's too much, but I mean, well, maybe you are a natural-born YouTuber.
0:04:26I have developed systems that allow me to turn them around pretty quick.
0:04:31I use some AI tools in the editing process, and a lot of my content, I'm just talking
0:04:39about what I'm doing.
0:04:40I'm showing features on iPhone and iPad.
0:04:42I'm showing you the shortcuts I've built.
0:04:44So, a lot of times, the work is before the video, and the video is just me explaining what
0:04:50I did, and then maybe covering news, maybe trying out an AI browser, whatever it may be.
0:04:55But my style of content and the systems I have in place, it allows me to turn it around pretty
0:04:58fast.
0:05:00I do think it's like a professional, not a midlife crisis, but like a midlife reflection,
0:05:08where it's very obvious that there...
0:05:12I mean, and I just...
0:05:14The previous episode of the show before you was with Dan Fromer, who's writing The New Consumer,
0:05:19which is a paid newsletter in the style of Ben Thompson's Stratechery, which sort of trailblazed
0:05:25is the whole genre that's AKA sub-stacking.
0:05:29So, it's in a whole...
0:05:31For all of my griping about sub-stack as a sort of a trap for independent writers, I'd give
0:05:38them credit for the resurgence in independent creators who are just writers.
0:05:45Overall, to date, sub-stack has been a net positive for the world, I mean, without any question.
0:05:53My concerns are about what will happen, and I think it's almost inevitable, because I've
0:05:59been doing this long enough where anytime something centralized gets put in the middle like that,
0:06:04it goes bad, or goes away, or something.
0:06:07I mean, Christ, even Blogspot, it went away, and Google's literally got all the money in
0:06:12the world.
0:06:12So, it's not like there aren't new writers, or older writers making the shift from working
0:06:20for a publication, like Philip Bump left the Washington Post and now is writing at sub-stack.
0:06:25Paul Krugman left the New York Times and now is writing on his own website that's at sub-stack.
0:06:31But for the most part, new, hey, I'm doing this full-time independent creators are on
0:06:37YouTube.
0:06:37I mean, that's just, and it's the way, it's like the whole 20th century has been crammed
0:06:45into 20 years of the 21st century, where the transition from print to radio, which would
0:06:53be podcasting in our era, to TV, and then TV becomes the dominant nature, and the TV of today
0:07:00is YouTube.
0:07:00But it's so much more competition.
0:07:02I mean, do you feel that?
0:07:04There's a lot of competition, trying to enter the tech space when I did, which really put
0:07:09concerted effort into my channel three years ago.
0:07:11So many already there, with millions of subscribers, obviously have huge ones like MKBHD, Snazzy Labs
0:07:17is out there, and there's tons of tech channels, and so no shortage there.
0:07:21But I did think I could bring something a little different, and I didn't know if it was going to
0:07:26work or not. But the one thing that I've done for years, and what I enjoy doing, is teaching.
0:07:31I enjoy teaching about things. I enjoy showing people how to use their devices, their technology,
0:07:37and people have said I can explain things pretty well. And so while there's also lots of explainer
0:07:41channels out there, I do think just there's lots of writers, there's lots of speakers, there's lots
0:07:47of podcasters. There's still room if you are unique or bring something slightly different to the
0:07:52table. And so that's what I've tried to do. And also the shortcuts area is a lot of creators doing
0:07:58shortcuts and automation. I just am so obsessed with them. I don't know what it is. The part of me is I love
0:08:03tinkering. I love troubleshooting. And so it kind of scratches all those itches at once. And the audience
0:08:08has just really responded to it. And I love making the videos. They enjoy watching them. And so yeah, I've just
0:08:13kind of be able to create a wedge for myself. That's great. You're very you are good. It's not
0:08:18just that people say you're good at explaining or teaching or however you want to call it. But it is
0:08:23your it does seem to come naturally to you. And it's definitely part of the appeal. But when I think about
0:08:28the changing indie media landscape, and I think about, hey, if I were 20 years younger, or more, I'd probably
0:08:36have to pursue this on YouTube, rather than in writing, or at least more, at least partly, maybe
0:08:43like the way that I have podcasting on the side of my writing, it would have to be YouTube or something.
0:08:48And I think, man, it would be so the thing that would get me is how slow it would be that you can
0:08:56only do so much. And then I see you publish 11 videos in two weeks. And I'm like, well, maybe,
0:09:00maybe if you're good at it, it's not.
0:09:03Well, it's funny, I try to write periodically. And if I could go back in time, I would have
0:09:09started writing way before and actually kept with it. But for some reason, for me, it takes me longer
0:09:15to write an article than it does to make a video. And any of the few things I've tried to write in the
0:09:20last couple years, just to do it, it just takes me so long. And it never feels right to me. I'll read
0:09:26it back to myself. I don't like how it sounds. Whereas when I make a video, and I'm speaking
0:09:32extemporaneously, I don't script anything, I'm just talking. It comes together faster for me for
0:09:37whatever reason. And it is a double edged sword, like you're saying the media, because as a writer,
0:09:41you can put it on your website, it's your content, no algorithm, you're not beholden to between you and
0:09:47the audience, which is kind of like podcasting as well. Whereas obviously, on YouTube, it's all about
0:09:53the algorithm. And so while that algorithm has allowed me to be discovered by 1000s of people,
0:09:58it can also turn. And so there is a part of the new media that if you want to make a go of this,
0:10:05you need to have other platforms. And that's why I've done communities with podcast,
0:10:09and anything else to kind of diversify how you're building a creator business today.
0:10:15Yeah, and that's the thing I keep going back to. And you've you've sort of made my point for me,
0:10:20which is that ultimately, when as new technology becomes available, new forms of media become
0:10:29available. And I forget who I was just talking about this with. But like, when I first started
0:10:35podcasting, when Dan Benjamin, I started the very first version of the talk show, which I think was in
0:10:422006. I was listening, just publishing hour long mp3 files with more compression than we use now. I
0:10:53think we used 64 megabits per second. And I think I don't even know what my show is it now. I don't
0:11:00think it really matters. But I think for voice at 128, it's hard to tell the difference. But just
0:11:05publishing the mp3s was a real technical challenge and a real concern cost wise. And there weren't any
0:11:12kind of hosting services. And I even forget what we did. I think we used S3 or something. But it was
0:11:19like, and we had no sponsors. There was the idea of I had already just started taking sponsorships on
0:11:27Daring Fireball. And that was considered new. And there were people, I swear, it was like a common
0:11:34thing that when I first started doing sponsorships on Daring Fireball, there were people who were upset
0:11:42about it, and would say it's not a blog anymore, because a blog doesn't have ads. And I would write
0:11:49back and say, Okay, thanks for your time. Yeah, well, okay, then it's not a blog. I never really liked
0:11:54that word anyway, whatever. And I get it that there's always like, we're still living in the golden age of
0:12:01the AI chatbots, right, where none of them have ads. And the free versions are just sort of like there's
0:12:06limits on like the free version of chat GPT, and etc. usage limits to kind of spur you to upgrade to the
0:12:12$15 a month or more plans. But you can use them for free get an enormous amount out of them. And you
0:12:19don't see or hear any ads ever. That's going to come to an end. Ben Thompson is all over all up
0:12:26open AI's case that they've got to look how long Netflix took before they had an ad based tier.
0:12:31But it's coming. And every it happens to everything. And hopefully it won't ruin the experience. But
0:12:38with podcasts in 2006, it was crazy to think about asking somebody to sponsor the episode. And so we
0:12:45just sort of ate the cost of the hosting. I mean, it was just crazy. So the idea of shipping video,
0:12:51it was ridiculous, it was hard enough to ship just mp3 audio, video is ridiculous. And that's
0:12:58sort of like when YouTube, even before Google bought them, it was just sort of like too good to be true.
0:13:03How can this be possible that they're saying you could just upload any video you want? And they'll
0:13:09process it a little and ship a pretty usable version. And that's it. And as many people can watch it as
0:13:16possible. And they're like, Yeah, that distribution is unmatched. Obviously, YouTube has become a
0:13:23behemoth. It's just that's where everybody is. And that's something where podcasting still doesn't have
0:13:29that. And, you know, writing, I don't know how a writer would be discovered today. I guess you have
0:13:36to have another avenue. You have to be Jay Klaus uses this analogy. He's a create, he's creator
0:13:42science podcast. And he says there's relationship platforms and discovery platforms, discovery being
0:13:47social media, things like YouTube, TikTok, Instagram, then our relationship platforms that don't have an
0:13:52algorithm. And it's like podcasting email newsletters, or having a personal website and blog. And you
0:13:59really want to get people to that relationship platform, because that's where you can either have paid
0:14:03communities or you sponsorships will pay even more for that kind of thing. But you can't just
0:14:08do that only because there's no discovery mechanism built in. And that's the thing that YouTube is the
0:14:16best at right now. And that's why I put my energy into it, because you get discovery, and you get
0:14:21monetization. And it's more discovery than relationship. But there's a little bit of relationship
0:14:27platform in there, because there is a comment section, there are subscribers, people do put on
0:14:30notifications for videos. And so it's been worth the energy.
0:14:33Yeah. Well, now it's trivial to publish video, right? As you're saying, you just shoot it and
0:14:39our phones shoot remarkably good video. So everybody's got a good enough to shoot a pretty
0:14:47good looking YouTube video in their pocket camera. And at that point, the people who are meant and have a
0:14:54natural inclination to that form of media, get drawn to it and do it right. And it's like, I've always said, it's as
0:15:03as much as I do enjoy this podcast and dithering, and as much as this podcast and dithering are definitely
0:15:11combined, probably a little over 50% of my income. I'll never ever not think of myself as anything but a writer
0:15:19who podcasts. It's just, it's not just because that's what I did first. It's just who I am and what I think I'm
0:15:25better at. And people find the media that they're meant for. And I think, again, 11 videos in two weeks, I think you've
0:15:33found your medium, Stephen.
0:15:34Well, thank you. And I don't know if you saw Casey Neistat's video about AI slop, but he has a
0:15:40I think so. Yeah.
0:15:41He has a good portion where he talks about the democratization of video and how the bar has just
0:15:46been lowered and lowered over the years as far as access to the tools to make the video. And now with
0:15:51AI generated video, the bar is on the floor, because you have to do is type text into an app, and it will
0:15:56generate the video. And there's concern there, there's going to be even more content going forward,
0:16:02most likely. There's lots of faceless YouTube channels where it's just AI voice and AI imagery,
0:16:07and we'll still get hundreds of thousands of views. And so that is the competition. But I am betting on
0:16:12that the audience, that human beings will still want and resonate with real people on the other side of
0:16:20the camera. That even as there's even more AI slop and more content out there, that people will seek
0:16:26out the trusted voices and stick with them even more into the future. And there's varying feelings
0:16:33about the creator economy. I hear Neil Patel on the Vergecast, and he'll say, it's like HSN, and it's
0:16:39going to collapse or whatever. And there is a part of that that maybe is true with influencers and
0:16:43affiliate stuff, which I do as well. But I'm still betting on it, if you provide something of value
0:16:49to the audience that they want to see that they learn from, they're inspired from,
0:16:54that in the future, they'll still go to the real flesh and blood people that are creating that content.
0:17:00Yeah, I just saw I just looked it up to double check that it was the right word, but the
0:17:05Cambridge Dictionary's word of the year for 2025 is parasocial, which is it's sort of the phenomenon
0:17:13phenomenon that people feel like they know these people they don't know. Meghan Markle and Prince
0:17:19Harry, celebrities embody it at the mass scale. And then you work your way down to totally not
0:17:28celebrity creators like me and you and Ben Thompson and Neelai and even Joanna Stern at the Wall Street
0:17:38Journal. And it's where we're, we're more known than most people, right? Like most people. How many
0:17:48followers are there on your YouTube channel? I think it was like 187k 183k, I think 183k. That's 183,000
0:17:57people who at least know who Steven is, right? I mean, a varying degrees of fandom, right? It's
0:18:04sure. Most people, there's only dozens of people who know who they are. That's just the nature of
0:18:09humanity since the dawn of time. So it's all a little bit unusual. But that it is a phenomenon
0:18:16that you get when you find your favorite podcasts or YouTube channels or blogs or newsletters to follow,
0:18:23and you follow them for a while. And there is a singular voice behind the writing or a voice on the
0:18:31podcast or a face on the videos. It's also part of human nature to feel like you're getting to know
0:18:38them, right? It is a real phenomenon. And I don't think I'm being naive and thinking that
0:18:47AI is definitely going to shake this up. It's already shaking this up, and it's going to continue
0:18:53to. But I do think that it's mostly, again, famous last words, we'll see. But I do think it's mostly
0:19:02taking away what was human slop work, for lack of a better term, right? There are these AI-generated
0:19:13blogs now, and you can kind of tell, right? There was that whole thing with the Tua, the unofficial Apple
0:19:19weblog where I forget the guy's name. But the ham-fisted mistake he made, I had Christina Warren
0:19:24on the show after it happened, where he had reused the actual names of the actual humans who used to
0:19:32write for the unofficial Apple weblog, like Christina, and was reusing their names and rewriting their old
0:19:39articles by AI with their bylines still attached, which really... And then it was a huge kerfuffle,
0:19:46rightly so. And then it went away because he just changed them to made-up names and made-up pictures.
0:19:52And it's still there. I don't know why. I don't know who would ever read it. But there have been
0:19:57blogs that are just... Where they just pay 15 bucks a post or some ridiculously paltry sum
0:20:03that were human-generated. And if that's where AI takes over, I mean, it's... I guess in some sense,
0:20:10it was better that people who wanted to write for a living could get their foot in the door with
0:20:15something like that. And if they had some talent, maybe use it as a stepping stone to move up. But
0:20:20I think for the most part, it's not hurting people who really have something worth following.
0:20:27Yeah. And I think that the parasocial was the word of the year this year, but I feel like I've been
0:20:31hearing that in podcasting for the last two decades. I've been listening to people like yourself and
0:20:37Merlin Mann and John Syracuse for over a decade. I followed Neelai and Joanna from...
0:20:42Well, 20 years for me, you're telling me.
0:20:43Yeah, exactly.
0:20:45Or 19, I don't know.
0:20:47I followed them from Engadget to This Is My Next to The Verge. And then when I met them at
0:20:52DubDub and met you there as well for the first time, that was surreal for me. And so I think the
0:20:58parasocial thing, for those of us in a little podcast sphere that listen to podcasts pre-serial,
0:21:03I think we kind of understood that dynamic and at least got it. And so now I think it's almost
0:21:09mainstream. Yeah, parasocial relationship with creators. And I think you see on Instagram and TikTok
0:21:15that there's accounts where there's a face, it's an AI-generated face. A lot of times it's like
0:21:20female imagery in these posts, and it has hundreds of thousands of followers and lots of views.
0:21:25But I think if someone has the option in the future to go to their news, to go to learn something,
0:21:33to go to be entertained, and they have the choice between someone who looks like a real human being,
0:21:40sounds like a real human being, but is not one, and another human being, but that's real, and will
0:21:46watch them, I think they're going to choose the real person. And that remains to be seen. It's not
0:21:52as good. It's not that good yet. It's not indistinguishable. But when it is, I'm betting on people choosing
0:21:57real people.
0:21:59Yeah. And I think the other difference, too, is that regular readership, regular following type
0:22:04thing, right? And TikTok exemplifies the opposite approach, right? Where people open TikTok and you
0:22:10don't really, it's not, oh, these are my favorite TikTokers every time. And here's the update. You just
0:22:16thumb your way through and you see whatever the algorithm thinks is for you today. And it's,
0:22:23it's obviously successful in that people spend a lot of number, an almost frightening number of
0:22:29aggregate hours every day thumbing their way through TikTok. But I don't think it makes people
0:22:36say, yeah, this is my favorite part of the day. My favorite media consumption today was the time I
0:22:41spent going through TikTok while I waited in line at the supermarket to check out. Like, they might do it,
0:22:47it might be something they like, but they don't say, they don't think about it the way they think,
0:22:51hey, that was a real banger of an episode of ATP today that I listened to. I really enjoyed that.
0:22:57I'll take a counterpoint to the TikTok thing just a little bit, though, because there are characters
0:23:02on TikTok. There's a couple of Mario and Bryn. They have millions of followers. And if you look at the
0:23:08comments, people are like, hey, mom and dad. And it's like in this joking way. But I do think there's
0:23:14that parasocial affinity to it. And I don't know if you're familiar with this TikTok account.
0:23:18This was a high schooler. His name is Davis Big Dog. His whole TikTok account is literally
0:23:25ranking and rating school lunches. And his videos, I kid you not, hundreds of thousands of views each.
0:23:33He just sits there, he'll talk about either the chicken nuggets or the burrito. And he got 700,000
0:23:40followers in a couple weeks. And it was this weird thing where you see famous people in the comments
0:23:46saying, hey, our show is on. That's a joke line that people say our show is on.
0:23:49Yeah, I shouldn't be too dismissive of TikTok celebrity. But it's not the nature of the medium.
0:23:56Will that audience move somewhere else is the question. If somehow TikTok shut down tomorrow,
0:24:01would someone look for Davis Big Dog on his website?
0:24:04Davis Big Dog.
0:24:05And as much as I tend to be knee-jerk dismissive towards TikTok, I salute it in terms of... I mean,
0:24:14because how old would you say that kid is? Seventh grade, it looks like?
0:24:17Well, he's in high school. He's like ninth or tenth. He's actually 14.
0:24:20All right. But still, the fact that there is now a medium that allows a ninth grader to publish their own
0:24:29TV show, effectively, what we used to call a TV show, and have an audience of hundreds of thousands
0:24:35is astonishing. And it is inherently a great thing. It's kind of awesome, right? Like,
0:24:41when I was in ninth grade, it was kind of cool if somebody, you knew somebody who owned a camcorder
0:24:48and you could record yourself on video and put it on TV for you and your friends to see.
0:24:53Hey, we're on TV. Look at that. We're on TV.
0:24:57Exactly. Yeah. And I think you... I remember going to department stores or like a Best Buy or
0:25:05something in that era. I guess it wasn't even Best Buy. But when they'd have a video camera hooked up
0:25:09with a live feed to a TV, people would stop and catch themselves and then just sit there and wave.
0:25:15And I did it as a kid. I'm not laughing how those rube adults when I was a kid.
0:25:20No, everybody did it because it was like you didn't think of yourself as ever possibly being
0:25:26on TV. And if something happened where like the local TV news stopped you because, I don't know,
0:25:33some newsworthy thing happened in your town and that Channel 4 News stopped and talked to you,
0:25:39you'd call everybody you knew. Everybody. You'd run home, open up your phone book or your black book
0:25:45and start calling everybody in your family, every friend you have and say, I might be on
0:25:49Channel 4 News for 10 seconds tonight. That's what you would do because it was so amazing.
0:25:55And now a kid can just put his phone in front of him and review the chicken nuggets at the school
0:26:00cafeteria and make a show. It's awesome. It is awesome.
0:26:04It is awesome. But as you will, you would see on TikTok, not every kid in high school who's
0:26:10reviewing his school lunch will blow up like that. Right. And I do think it's because there's still a
0:26:15baseline thing. The human response to something, someone, how someone's talking or presents
0:26:21themselves. And, and for that kid, like he's not even that he's not being funny. Like when he reviews
0:26:25the school lunch, he's not making jokes. He's not like doing anything outlandish. He's literally just
0:26:31like taking a bite and then he'll say, not six. That's the whole video. But it's this,
0:26:37it touches this weird thing where it's like the most authentic. It also touches nostalgia,
0:26:42people, high school nostalgia, people thinking back to the nineties or whatever. But it's also,
0:26:47this is like the most real it gets. This kid is just in a school lunchroom talking to a phone
0:26:52and that realness, for lack of a better word, I think is what people respond to on TikTok,
0:26:58on Instagram, and I think on YouTube. And that's, that's what wins.
0:27:01Yeah. And it's, I can't think of a better opposite reaction to AI generated content.
0:27:07And then just a kid, totally serious, totally deadpan, no jokes, no sticks, just honest to God,
0:27:14reviewing the meatloaf.
0:27:16That's it. It's, and it's hilarious. I mean, I'll watch a couple of my wife's episodes. I don't know.
0:27:21And then we'll try to predict, oh, was he going to rate this? Is he going to be a five or six?
0:27:24Looks pretty good, but I got to tell you, it's cold in the middle for, you know.
0:27:28He literally said, he'll say exactly that. He was like, the line was kind of long. These
0:27:32tater tots are freezing, but it's just deadpan. It's great. So that's out there. That's stuff's
0:27:37all right. Let me take a break here. This episode
0:27:39is exclusively sponsored by our good friends at Uncommon Goods. Hey, the countdown is on. That's
0:27:46why they've booked an exclusive sponsorship. The holiday shopping season is officially here and
0:27:51uncommon goods takes the stress out of giving gifts, buying gifts with thousands of unique,
0:27:57high quality finds that you won't see anywhere else. Don't wait. The most meaningful gifts get
0:28:02scooped up fast. They might sell out. And now's the perfect time to cross names off your list.
0:28:07Don't be like me, me, John Gruber, notorious gift buying procrastinator who starts buying gifts when
0:28:16it's November or December 20-something. Don't do it. Get it out of the way now. I'm going to start
0:28:22buying some gifts on November 20-something instead of December 20-something this year. I swear to God,
0:28:28an uncommon goods has you handled. They've got products that are high quality, unique all over
0:28:34the place, often handmade in the U.S. And many are crafted by independent artists and small businesses
0:28:40making every gift feel meaningful and truly one of a kind. One of my favorite things, I pointed
0:28:44out the last time they sponsored the show a couple years ago, my wife bought me this. Turns out she
0:28:48got it from uncommon goods a couple years ago, but it sits at my desk. It is just a literal F bomb.
0:28:55It is just a little, I don't know what metal it's made out of, but it's like the old classic Mac
0:29:00error alert bomb, just a spherical bomb with a fuse coming out of it, but a metal letter F on front of
0:29:08it. And nice and heavy, real heavy, but it's a perfect paperweight and just absolutely, I can't
0:29:14think of a better desk trinket for a writer who likes using the actual F word than me. They've got
0:29:21all sorts of fun stuff like that at Uncommon Goods. Something for everyone, from moms and dads, kids and
0:29:27teens, F bomb loving writers like me, book lovers, history buffs, diehard football fans, foodies, they have
0:29:34stuff for you. And when you shop at Uncommon Goods, you're supporting artists and small independent
0:29:39businesses. Many of their handcrafted product products are made in small batches. So shop now
0:29:45before they sell out this holiday season. And with every purchase you make at Uncommon Goods, they give
0:29:51back a dollar to a nonprofit partner of your choice. They've donated more than $3.1 million to date as of
0:30:01this writing. So don't wait. Cross some of the names off your shopping list before the rush and
0:30:07get 15% off your next gift by going to uncommon goods.com slash talk show. That's uncommon goods.com
0:30:17slash talk show for 15% off uncommon goods. We are all out of the ordinary. All right. One of your most
0:30:26recent videos about shortcuts you write and post about shortcuts all the time. Tell me why you love
0:30:31shortcuts. You know, I use the workflow app before with shortcuts and then Apple acquired it. And at
0:30:38first it was just little things. I could do the home ETA where I can estimate my travel time home
0:30:45automatically text it to my wife. I just thought that was so cool that I could just do that automatically.
0:30:50And as they become more and more powerful, it's just amazing to me what they can do. And now with Apple
0:30:55intelligence, it feels like the possibilities are endless. But I think I love I love building things. I love
0:31:01Legos when I was a kid. I love troubleshooting. I like figuring out like, can this work? How can it work? How can I
0:31:07adjust it? And then guys like Federico Vitici and Matthew Castanelli inspired me to be like, okay, this stuff is
0:31:13powerful. And I think more people should use it. And I think that's where I really wanted to start
0:31:19sharing these in videos and in other places. Because anytime I showed someone a shortcut that
0:31:24applied to them personally, it blew their mind and they would use it. And they would be like, oh, yeah,
0:31:29this is going to be amazing. And the difficult part of shortcuts is if you just open the app on your
0:31:33iPhone and you've never used one, nothing's tailored to you. You're not sure how to use it.
0:31:38And that's why my whole business now, most of it is just tailoring shortcuts a little bit
0:31:44differently to every single person. And that's the magic of it is you can make it super personal.
0:31:48It can apply to your workflow. And that's why I love it. It's just it feels like magic.
0:31:52Yeah, until shortcuts and workflow before it, but it did need workflow is brilliant.
0:31:59An idea as it was when it was a third party app. And it's, I remember when I first really explored it,
0:32:07I remember hearing about it and thinking because I thought I was so familiar with all of the
0:32:12limitations of the App Store and iOS apps in terms of inter-application communication.
0:32:18I was like, it can't do much. And I read what people were saying about it. I was like,
0:32:23ah, that's got to be an exaggeration. And then I like started, I actually downloaded it and started
0:32:28trying it. And it was kind of amazing how much it could do on its own before it had any official
0:32:34support from Apple. Just, I think back then, mostly because so many apps had exposed the,
0:32:42the, the one avenue of inter-application communication back then was, do you remember?
0:32:47No, I don't.
0:32:48URL, URL schemes.
0:32:50That's where I was heading, where a bunch of apps had figured, well, apps can't communicate with each
0:32:55other. But the one thing you could do is register. Like if you, I'm going to, I'm going to botch the
0:33:01actual URL for it, but like the drafts app for notes had like a custom, it's like X dash drafts
0:33:08colon. And then there's like a custom URL scheme. So instead of HTTP or mail to, or one of the standard
0:33:16internet protocols, an app can register its own custom protocol. And then other apps could say to
0:33:23the system just open this URL, but it's a drafts URL and the drafts URL could be something like a create
0:33:31new draft command or a get draft command where the parameter is the idea of a draft. And then you could
0:33:38get the text of a draft back into another app and workflow just put like a nice user interface on top of
0:33:48all this. And it was so useful. And then Apple did something that I think surprised just about everybody
0:33:55because it seemed like they had no interest in automation anymore, right? They had no, seeming no interest in
0:34:01bringing automation to iOS at all. And it seemed like their interest in automation on the Mac had completely
0:34:07stagnated. It's since the first decade of the 2000s. The Apple script was there and it wasn't going away because
0:34:15people rely on it, but they were done adding new things. Automator, which was the new way of creating
0:34:22automation on the Mac sort of also stagnated. It didn't go away. It's still there to this day, but
0:34:29doesn't get new things. And then all of a sudden they, Apple bought shortcut or workflow, turned it into
0:34:35shortcuts and then added functionality system wide and brought it to all three of the major platforms,
0:34:43Mac, iPad, and iOS. And a surprising number of workflows work across all three, especially the Mac versus iOS divide.
0:34:52You can even put something in a shortcut to say, if the shortcut's running on a Mac, do this. And if it's on an iPhone,
0:34:57do that.
0:34:58Yep. Do you feel like you're programming? This is my question to everybody who's into shortcuts.
0:35:04I know I vibe coded an iPhone app. I don't know if you saw that video.
0:35:07I did.
0:35:08That revealed to me how much of a developer I am not. And so I'm not programming. I understand the idea of
0:35:16building a shortcut is basically programming. The moment I put a repeat with each action in the
0:35:22shortcut, I think, okay, well that's, yeah, that I understand that that's programming, but I don't know.
0:35:28It doesn't feel like that to me. It feels more like building blocks. It feels like the Duplo to,
0:35:32if Lego was app development, it's the Duplo.
0:35:34Yeah. See, I, my analogy that I often go to though, is I think you're, you're underselling
0:35:39yourself is I think that either whether it's Apple script or automator or now shortcuts,
0:35:45that's the Lego and that the real development is more like custom injection molding. It's,
0:35:52it's making this sort of toy that you get at the toy store in a blister pack that doesn't have
0:35:57bricks that you can take apart. It's pre-made and in a way that like, if you buy a plastic toy or metal
0:36:08could be metal because it's toys can be made out of metal and Legos aren't, you can get a toy that is a
0:36:14perfectly articulated one to 15 scale car that looks exactly like the real size car that it is.
0:36:22And a Lego version of that car is never going to look realistic because it's made even as however
0:36:28many cheaty pieces that the kit comes with to make it look like it, that aren't little rectangles,
0:36:34it still looks like it's a thing out of rectangles. But on the other hand, sometimes the Lego version
0:36:41engenders more affinity. Like you look at you're like, I know that's not realistic, but I actually
0:36:46like this better than a realistic looking car because I know I could take it apart. And it was
0:36:51my fingers that put it together.
0:36:52Yeah. And I think I've messed around with automator for years and could never like,
0:36:58figure it out. I know it can never really build stuff that I wanted to.
0:37:02I pulled Apple scripts from different people and copy and pasted stuff from Stack Exchange and
0:37:07just never like really understood it all. But for some reason, just the shortcuts interface,
0:37:12the easy to see here's the variable, here's one action to another, it allows me to build a lot of
0:37:19stuff. And now with ChatGPT and using APIs and shortcuts, that opens up a whole new world. And that's
0:37:26something I'd never knew JSON before. The only coding I've ever done is like HTML and a little
0:37:31CSS back in the day. That's my total coding extent. I have a music degree is what I joke about. That's
0:37:37zero experience in any of this. But I can ask ChatGPT, I can say, hey, here's an API, look at the
0:37:43documentation. How can I call this API? And what do I put in the shortcut? And a lot of times I'll
0:37:50literally just screenshot the shortcut action, get contents from URL, give it a ChatGPT and say,
0:37:56what do I put in these fields? And if it doesn't work, I'll do it again. I'll say, here's a
0:38:01screenshot. It didn't work. This is what happened. Tell me something else to try. And I don't know if
0:38:06ChatGPT actually knows what to do or not, but eventually we figure it out. And so me and my custom
0:38:11GPT, we get them to work.
0:38:14And I think the other thing, it's sort of generational, but I grew up at a time when
0:38:20the whole point of getting a computer was you get a computer, turn it on in the back and a couple
0:38:26seconds later, because it only took a couple seconds, even though the computers were so slow,
0:38:30but they were so primitive that there was nothing really to boot. And then you'd start typing a
0:38:35computer program or you'd load one that you'd written from disk. And the idea was you'd get a
0:38:41computer to program a computer. And Apple, you know, it's a world move towards graphical user
0:38:47interfaces and a Mac. Apple came out with HyperCard famously, and people of my generation, HyperCard
0:38:53occupies this unique part in our hall of fame of great apps that never really made it, didn't last.
0:38:59But the whole point was, hey, let's make this more approachable. And even Apple was pushing
0:39:05to users the idea of you too can program a computer. That's the whole reason behind the history. And it
0:39:14didn't take long, I think, for most people to agree that the syntax of Apple script, the language was a
0:39:20mistake. The fact that it looks once it's compiled and actually works looks so much like English is cool.
0:39:26But the actual writing of it doesn't follow English at all. And the proof of the pudding is with the GPTs of
0:39:34today, where you can just type English to them. And they understand it, they parse it and give you a
0:39:43response. But the whole idea behind it, though, was to encourage more just regular people who think I can't
0:39:50write programs in C or back then Pascal or in today, Swift or whatever JavaScript, whatever language you
0:39:57want to, to talk, I don't that doesn't work for my brain. But you have things you'd like to build for
0:40:04yourself. Here's a way that you can do them. And I feel like Apple, even though they are the company
0:40:09that's made shortcuts, they're updating it every year. I don't detect any loss of enthusiasm from Apple
0:40:14for it. But I don't think they push it as much. I think it all comes from the community from people
0:40:21like you and Matthew Cassinelli. It comes from the community and me to some degree to encouraging
0:40:30people to try these things to get keyboard maestro for your Mac and make something you can fix these
0:40:36little UI irritations yourself or build the thing you've always wanted. I just think the number of
0:40:43people out there who think they can't write their own programs, but could be writing their own
0:40:47shortcuts is, is this gap to be filled. It's not everyone, right? The idea that everyone could or
0:40:54wants to do this is definitely not true. But there's this gap between the number of people who are doing
0:41:01it, and the number of people who should be doing it. So yeah, there's two things. One, the personalization
0:41:08is where it really matters with shortcuts. And Apple has the gallery tab in the shortcuts app.
0:41:15They do put new shortcuts in there a lot. There's a bunch of Apple intelligence ones in there since
0:41:20iOS 26. And they're cool. You know, it's like make a gif. Here's a daily NASA photo, all this kind of
0:41:26stuff. But it's not going to resonate with most people visiting it, right to say that's a shortcut that I can
0:41:31change a little thing here and there. And now it's immediately applicable to me and I'll use it all
0:41:35the time. So while it's great to have, I think why people watch my videos is because I basically what
0:41:42I'm doing recently is taking all the requests that I get and making shortcuts tailor made for people.
0:41:47But what that does is after seeing so many people begin to think, oh, that's how I can customize this
0:41:54for myself or how I can accomplish this task. But the second part is that what Matthew tells me all
0:41:59the time, if someone can download a shortcut made for them, they'll do that 100% of the time rather
0:42:04than make it themselves. And so and that's something I've been pushing a little more on Instagram recently.
0:42:09And I'll just share a shortcut. I'll just show a shortcut that I think is going to resonate with
0:42:13people. I do the thing where comment and I'll send you a link to download it. And it's been exploding.
0:42:18There's a couple million views just on a couple reels that are showing off a shortcut. And so once people
0:42:23see what is possible, and they can get it easily just by downloading it from a link, people respond to it.
0:42:29I do think it's interesting. And the other thing that I think is interesting is because shortcuts isn't
0:42:35a typed out programming language, you just drag and drop these blocks that function as tokens, like the tokens
0:42:44in a programming language, but it is more visual. It is very well suited to video in a way that actual typed out
0:42:51programming languages like Swift or JavaScript aren't, right? You just don't see many videos where people are like,
0:42:57here's how you here's how to learn something in JavaScript. You do there's I shouldn't say you don't. But it's not.
0:43:04I think when you watch a video about somebody programming in JavaScript, you're like, this should be a blog post so I can
0:43:09copy and paste it. I'd rather read it. There's a moment to every time I run a shortcut. I mean, this happens
0:43:16just when I'm making them by myself, when the shortcut actually works, and you see it either flip over to
0:43:21notes, and it actually puts everything there that you expected, or it correctly identifies an image and tells
0:43:27you what's in a document, whatever it is, there's that moment. I don't know if it's dopamine or serotonin or
0:43:31whatever. But there's like that constant hit of it worked. And it's going to work again, the next time I use it.
0:43:36And I think that's the other thing people get when I do my videos of 15 or 18 shortcuts. I just show it
0:43:41running, you know, I mean, like a 20 minute video, but I'm literally just telling you what it's doing,
0:43:45pressing play, and we're all just going to watch it together. But there's something kind of cool about
0:43:50look, it just flipped over to Apple notes. And it just took this audio file transcribed it summarized it
0:43:55and all you did was press play. And it's it's I don't know, it's fun to watch. Yeah. The other thing too,
0:44:00that is so interesting is that you can do things now with like the, the Apple intelligence blocks, and it's so your
0:44:07options are, yeah, you can run on device, you can run private cloud compute, and you could ask chat GPT, right?
0:44:18Those are the three in escalating order of power. And just like, I watched a video, I wish I knew who it
0:44:27was, because I didn't bookmark it. But it was like on threads or somewhere yesterday. And I watched a
0:44:31video showing how to make a shortcut, where I do all my screenshots to the clipboard, I don't even
0:44:37remember, I think I remapped the keyboard shortcut that puts a screenshot on the desktop as a file,
0:44:43I just always take them as to the pasteboard and then paste them somewhere. It's just for years and
0:44:50years. But I guess most people take screenshots, and they go to the desktop, and it's called like
0:44:54screenshot, Safari date. And she wrote a shortcut that just and it's like the way that you can set up an
0:45:02automation to watch a folder, and it has it watches her desktop. And when a new image appears,
0:45:08if it starts with the word screenshot, send it to chat GPT, create a brief summary up to 40 characters
0:45:16of what's in the screenshot, and then rename the file to that description. And that's it. That's the
0:45:22whole it's like, it's like a three step shortcut. And then she showed it. And it gives these screenshots
0:45:27amazingly apt names, because she's like, I have 12 screenshots on my desktop, I can't remember what
0:45:33the hell they are. And now they have regular names. And it's like, Oh, that's really brilliant. But if
0:45:38you think about how would you have done that five years ago, before these AI systems exist, it would
0:45:45be like, Oh, well, you'd have to hire somebody to write this complex image analysis. I mean, and probably
0:45:51it wouldn't work, right?
0:45:53Yeah, the Apple intelligence action is like the sleeper hit. I mean, it's what I've been making
0:45:58videos about since iOS 26 came out, and even since back to dub dub. But it's so powerful. One, it's way
0:46:04better than the built in chat GPT action that you get in shortcuts, because that will often fail. Chat
0:46:10GPT wants you to open the app and then go back to shortcuts. So just using the chat GPT extension of the
0:46:15Apple intelligence models action is way better. But it can do it can do crazy things. Like in a recent
0:46:20video I showed, I saved a bunch of famous music albums artwork in a folder. And the names were
0:46:27just gibberish. Like they're just numbers and letters. And so I just created a shortcut that
0:46:31allowed me to select multiple files. It sent each image to the use models action using chat GPT. And
0:46:37it says identify this music album, and rename the file the actual album name. And it did it. It does it
0:46:44every time. Crazy stuff. So just like that kind of renaming someone requested the other day in my
0:46:48community. She says, I've taken a bunch of photos of artwork. And I want to put it on my website. But
0:46:54I have 1000s of photos. And I want to identify images that are high resolution, that don't have
0:47:00anything obstructing the artwork, and another criteria. And so I was able to make a shortcut that
0:47:04says, listen, you can select 1000 files, run this shortcut, and it will each one will go through that
0:47:10Apple intelligence action, it can see the resolution, or I can do an action that says if it's greater than 1000
0:47:17pixels wide, then do this, Apple intelligence can see, is there something blocking it? Is this image
0:47:22croppable, and then rename all of that and put it in another folder. And just that kind of again, it's very
0:47:28personal to what that person needed, right? But it's so powerful what it can do in bulk, it blows my mind.
0:47:34Yeah, it brings personal computing back to the roots from the 80s and 90s of, yeah, get a computer and you
0:47:41can build right little things that do false, just scratch your personal itch. And that the Apple
0:47:48intelligent blocks really do like my one of my big complaints about shortcuts for years was that there
0:47:55was no escape hatch to a scripting language automator has automator, you has these blocks that are a lot
0:48:03like shortcuts where it's just like an action block, hey, take a file, you can just like a block that
0:48:07would resize files. So if you take files as input, automator as a block that says resize these images
0:48:14to 50% of their size, and then pass them on to the next step. But the next step in automator could be
0:48:21a script, which could be Apple script could be I think JavaScript, but it could be any of the shell
0:48:27scripting languages, like Perl, Python, Ruby, that come or at times came with Mac OS 10, or just a
0:48:34literally like a bash shell script. And so you had this escape hatch and shortcuts didn't have anything
0:48:41including JavaScript. But now it's got an escape hatch that's even better, which is that you can just have a step
0:48:47in there that's an Apple intelligence action, and instead of a finicky programming language that you can make a
0:48:52bug or something, you just give it a plain text description, like you just did about looking for images that are of a
0:48:58certain size. And if it's not that size, don't worry about it. And then do this. And you think, well, this probably
0:49:04isn't going to work. And then you run it, and it works. And it's like, this is amazing. And so you can put
0:49:10these action steps in that are so just specific to your needs, and just describe them in plain English,
0:49:17it really is the holy grail of non programmer automation.
0:49:22When even before, like if I wanted to do an API call to the movie database, before the Apple
0:49:29intelligence actions, I would do a bunch of get dictionary from this, get this dictionary value,
0:49:34match this text in the result, all this kind of stuff. And now I can literally just do an API call using
0:49:40the get contents of URL action, and then put an Apple intelligence action right after and say,
0:49:44from this data, give me the latest 10 movies that just came out. And also give me the URL for their
0:49:51trailer. Like something that simple that might have been dozens of actions before Apple intelligence,
0:49:56allows me to just do that with an API call. And it's way more accessible for me and many other people.
0:50:01And I want to, if I could, I want to share a Rube Goldberg machine I have set up with shortcuts.
0:50:05Oh, please.
0:50:06I was on the Vergecast, and I didn't share it there because I thought it might be a little technical,
0:50:10but I'll share it with you. So the Mac automations are now a thing where you can automate folder
0:50:14actions, things like that.
0:50:16Yep.
0:50:16And so one of the things I do semi-often, and I can't share this on YouTube because it's against
0:50:21the community guidelines or whatever, is sometimes I want to download a video. Sometimes I want to
0:50:26download a video, and I want to put it on my Plex server. It's something I want to do. I want to be
0:50:30able to do this from my iPhone, which is very difficult. So from my iPhone with two taps, I can
0:50:37be looking at a video. It could be a social media clip. It could be a YouTube video. I share that video
0:50:41to Transloader. It's an app, and it goes from my iPhone to Transloader on a Mac Mini that I have at
0:50:47home. And Transloader on that Mac Mini hands off that URL to an app called Downy. And Downy is, I think,
0:50:56just the best app for downloading anything. So it can download the video file. It could be an Instagram
0:51:00reel. It could be a YouTube video. So it downloads that file to the desktop of that Mac Mini. And now that
0:51:05I have the raw video file on my desktop, I can run a shortcut. And using the Mac automations,
0:51:11now with Apple Intelligence, I can say, transcribe this file, or maybe encode it as an audio first,
0:51:17transcribe it, summarize it, create an Apple note with a title, with a summary, the full transcript.
0:51:24And now in a few seconds, after sharing it from my phone, I have an Apple note with a summary and
0:51:29transcript. But then I can have Apple Intelligence shortcut, or I could just have the shortcuts automation
0:51:34move that file to my Plex server. And now I can watch that video in Plex, all from just a couple
0:51:40taps on my iPhone, all using that Rube Goldberg machine of moving it around.
0:51:44Just by sending the URL for the original version of it, just kickstarting it with just the URL that
0:51:50points to the video on social media or YouTube, throw the URL into this Rube Goldberg contraption,
0:51:56and out comes the Apple note with the summary, the transcript, and a link. There's a link to it in
0:52:03the note. I typically do a link back, like the original link, I'll put that back. And then the
0:52:08video itself is on Plex. And you can watch it from anywhere you can watch Plex. And YouTube doesn't
0:52:13like people talking about the fact that you can get a video out of YouTube with Downey. I just linked to
0:52:20Downey a couple weeks ago or months ago on Dairy Carbill. Absolutely terrific app. And one of my favorite genres of
0:52:28Mac app, especially in the Mac OS X era, it wasn't so much of a thing in the classic Mac era, because it didn't have a
0:52:36command line. But with the whole, the fact that Mac OS X has in terminal a whole Unix system, and so many
0:52:44useful commands built in before you even download anything from Homebrew or anywhere else, where you
0:52:50just have an app that does things you could do at the command line, but it just does them in a much nicer
0:52:56Mac style in the same way that yeah, you could just use Emacs or VI, or you could get like a real text
0:53:03editor like BB edit or use text edit or something and not be confused. Downey is a terrific, terrific
0:53:09app that does what what is YouTube DL or DL YouTube, I forget. There's yeah, there's but there was a forked
0:53:17version before. Anyway, just get Downey instead. It's a terrific, terrific app. It really is. And the
0:53:23developer keeps it up to date. And it's well worth every penny. And it just it also Downey makes it really
0:53:30easy to download a video. If you want a copy of the video as a file from Safari or whatever your
0:53:36browser is as you're watching, you could just say anything at it. Yeah, if you're on like a news
0:53:40website, and there's a video that you want to grab. And he's always updating it because websites and
0:53:45YouTube are trying to like, not allow for that kind of downloading. But but the developer, I believe,
0:53:50Charlie Monroe. Yeah, he is always updating it. And it always works for me. And so that's my Rube Goldberg
0:53:56machine. It's almost like you're paying Charlie for two things. You're paying him a for the work he's
0:54:00already done to make this very well made very Mac ass Mac app. But then you're also paying one time for
0:54:06the app. But for his continuing service of playing the cat and mouse game for you to keep Downey ahead of
0:54:13it. Whereas if you were doing it on your own from the command line, you're the one who's got to keep
0:54:17up to updating the software in your tool chain and staying abreast of the latest tricks and tips and
0:54:23mouse traps to avoid in the cat and mouse game. It's not just paid for Downey and let Charlie do it for
0:54:29everybody. Yeah. Yeah. All right. Before I let you go to speaking of AI and speaking of podcasts and
0:54:36independent media, Apple podcasts is adding a is going to add AI generated chapters to podcasts. And I think
0:54:44this is very important to note for shows that don't include chapters on their own, which is a big thing
0:54:51to because my show has had chapters for many years. Most nerd shows do. And I think most non nerd shows,
0:55:00which is most shows doomed. Marco, Marco Armand always says it's the Germans who complain about the lack of
0:55:08chapters. Well, our audience loves chapters, too. But, you know, creators can still opt out completely
0:55:14from the auto generated chapters. And that's why I'm curious to see when this launches with 26.2,
0:55:21what the big shows like Smart Lists and even some shows like the Verge cast who they don't have
0:55:27chapters. Will they allow the auto generated chapters and will Apple generate a chapter that says sponsors
0:55:32or ad break because I don't imagine the big shows want that to make it easier to skip the ads. So I'm
0:55:40curious which are going to opt out. We I've done it for years. And my thinking as always, and it's never
0:55:48served me honestly, I know it sounds too good to be true, but it's served me well my entire career
0:55:54is the golden rule do for my readers and listeners what I would done unto me as the reader and listener
0:56:01of other forms of media. And part of that is don't treat them like idiots. So we do put chapters in for
0:56:09the ads in the show. Yeah, because we figure your adults and you're going to figure it out. And you
0:56:15know, which part is me talking about a sponsor anyway. And it's my job as the guy reading the sponsor
0:56:21things to try to keep them interesting and moving along and hopefully make you want to listen to
0:56:27them. So yeah, I do that. But you're exactly right that I think others are going to see that if they
0:56:33think, oh, we'll try it. And then they see that it's going to label the breaks and they're going to be
0:56:37like, no, because they're not thinking golden rule. They think the opposite. They think our ads are special.
0:56:45And while they themselves might skip ads in some of the podcasts they listen to, they think, but our ads
0:56:51we don't want anybody to skip. And if we don't have chapters that identify them, people won't skip
0:56:57because they don't know about the 30 second forward button that's in every single podcast app ever made.
0:57:05Right? It's ridiculous. What do you think people are going to do if you don't make chapter marks for
0:57:10the sponsors that they're just going to be like, duh? Maybe if you're washing dishes and you can't get
0:57:16that's when you're forced to listen or if you're driving or whatever. But curious to the
0:57:21the time to link part of the chapters, which is another part of the feature. So this is a thing
0:57:27where, you know, Apple's going to allow you to put links either by plain timestamps in the description
0:57:34of an episode or linking a chapter using the ID3 tags in MP3 and you can link stuff and those links will appear on the now playing screen in Apple Podcasts.
0:57:43Those links will appear in the transcript, but notably only for Apple content.
0:57:48You will not be able to put a link to daringfireball.net and have that link show up in the transcript or the thing.
0:57:56And that, it feels not great to me because that's been an RSS and podcast standard for years where creators could link a chapter.
0:58:04Apps like Pocket Cast and Overcast allow users to tap those links and actually go to those things.
0:58:10And Apple is going to surface those links, but again, only for Apple TV shows, Apple books, Apple news, Apple services, Apple apps, things like that.
0:58:19And that part, I don't know, that doesn't feel great to me, but it feels a lot like Instagram, right?
0:58:24The way that Instagram that everybody has the link in bio, right?
0:58:28And which I think there's a whole generation of people of kids who don't even realize that that that that's frustrating, right?
0:58:37Because the whole idea is that the only place Instagram allows you to place a link to the web is one link in your bio.
0:58:43And so there's this whole cottage industry of link in bio services where you can put it like if you publish an article every day, then you put them on your link in bio page and your link.
0:58:57It sounds like I'm saying like Abe Lincoln, like Lincoln bio, like the Lincoln lawyer show.
0:59:02But no, it's link in bio where you have one link that points to a page that points to all the things you want to rather than just pointing to the things you want to.
0:59:12And it feels like that.
0:59:13And the idea, it's very transparent that Instagram just doesn't want you to leave Instagram.
0:59:17They want you to stay in Instagram forever, forever and ever, and just keep scrolling.
0:59:22Just don't stop.
0:59:23And no, we don't, we're not addictive at all.
0:59:25And we don't think we're addictive.
0:59:26And we don't think anybody has a problem with Instagram.
0:59:28But just keep scrolling.
0:59:29Keep scrolling.
0:59:30There's a whole industry like many, many chat is the thing that I use on Instagram, which is a service that if you,
0:59:38if someone comments a specific word like shortcut, that the service many chat will automatically send a DM with a link to the person.
0:59:47And so my Instagram DMs, there's literally thousands of people in there that I have no idea who they are because they commented shortcut to get a shortcut.
0:59:56And that's the mechanism now that creators have to use.
1:00:00And so chat is an entire service because of that link in bio problem.
1:00:04And for Apple doing this on Apple Podcasts, it's just, it's the first time it feels a little bit like there was an open standard for something.
1:00:11And rather than not just support it, Apple is supporting it, but only when it serves their content as it's linked to their stuff as Apple Podcasts and books and stuff.
1:00:21And so that's, I just wanted to raise a flag to say Apple's been a great arbiter for podcasts for the past two decades.
1:00:29Right.
1:00:29And they've honored all the open standards, maybe not adopted all of them quickly, but they've honored the open standards.
1:00:36And this is the first time with time links, it feels a little not like that.
1:00:39Yeah.
1:00:39And they've always honored the spirit of the open web, which podcasts are, in my opinion, the one form of internet media that stayed the truest for the longest to the ideals of the web.
1:00:53Even the actual use the web in a web browser is, to me, further away from the original ideal than podcasts are, because so much of what you see on the web today is locked behind a paywall.
1:01:06And I'm not, I'm not even, I'm not denouncing it as a trend overall, but it's, there's clearly, it's just, but it is contrary.
1:01:16Because I'm glad the publications large and small that are making a living or making a successful business based on paywalling their content, that it's working.
1:01:27I'm glad, but it's undeniably, it might be good for the media ecosystem, but it's bad for the web itself.
1:01:34And it's against the idea of the web, whereas the idea with podcasts, where all you have to know is this RSS feed, and you just read the RSS feed, and the RSS feed contains a list of episodes, and the episodes have descriptions, and a link to a file that's in an open format, like MP3, that you can just download, and then you can play.
1:01:51And that's it.
1:01:52Yep.
1:01:53And that's why I could build a ton of shortcuts around RSS feeds, because it's so open.
1:01:56Right.
1:01:57It's totally open.
1:01:58Transcribe.
1:01:58And that's, that's the other thing is, when it comes to podcasting, I'm curious, you're, you're feeling about what is Apple's responsibility might be a strong word, but like in the podcast industry, because they have fallen as far as where do people consume podcasts.
1:02:13It's now YouTube one, Spotify is second, and the video part of those platforms obviously is a huge deal.
1:02:20Spotify allows me to upload an entire video episode for free to the podcast, and people can watch my show or listen to it seamlessly in the Spotify app.
1:02:30And so, I wish Apple would adopt a little bit more, and I understand that it's probably not a revenue motivation, because it's not going to be, it's not going to bring a ton of money.
1:02:41If they can add video for creators in Apple Podcasts, I don't know if there's going to be an influx of creators that makes it worthwhile, but it felt like they were the one big player championing the openness of RSS,
1:02:53and I don't want them to stop, because I want RSS to keep going, and for podcasting to still be based on that, rather than the closed algorithmic platforms that we have.
1:03:01It's weird for me, and I know Marco talks about it, and it's even more direct for the ATP guys, because Marco literally is the guy making Overcast, but it's also true for me that I forget that I haven't looked at my numbers in a while,
1:03:15But I think it's 60 to 70% of the listeners of this show are using Overcast, but number two is Apple Podcasts, so it is the second most, and that's very unusual, most certainly Apple-focused podcasts, Apple Podcasts is the biggest, and Apple Podcasts is still the third biggest platform for podcasts, after YouTube and Spotify, overall, for any podcast of any genre, or whatever.
1:03:39But I feel like I'd be more motivated to care if it was number one for my show, but I do care, but literally, I guess, a third of the people listening to me and you talk right now are using Apple Podcasts, and Spotify and YouTube, because I'm not on YouTube, are not factors for me.
1:03:58I think I'm on Spotify, I don't even know, I know dithering is somehow, but I don't even care, honestly, which is weird, and it's just me being me.
1:04:04I think the best thing for Apple, even though they don't make money from it, and they did try, or they are trying, there's ways for people to have a paid members-only podcast through Apple Podcasts, but I don't know anybody doing that.
1:04:19We do it, we do it.
1:04:21Oh, yeah, and we talked about it when I was on Primary Technology.
1:04:24We talked about the same thing, where I think I said the same thing.
1:04:26I was like, I don't know anybody doing it.
1:04:28And you're like, we do it.
1:04:29Yes, I made the same mistake.
1:04:30I adopted it immediately, because at the time when the feature came out, I think it was 2021, I was hosting the Apple Insider Podcast.
1:04:37The vast majority of listeners was in the Apple Podcasts app.
1:04:40This was true for the Apple Insider Show, it was true for Primary Technology.
1:04:43Now, way more people buy the subscriber version of the show directly on Apple Podcasts, then go to our memberful site and sign up there.
1:04:52Right.
1:04:53It's just a way higher conversion rate, because it's easy to do.
1:04:55It's in the app they're already using.
1:04:57Right.
1:04:57It's in the app they're already using, and our listenership is like 56% Apple Podcasts, and then Overcast is like 40-something percent or whatever.
1:05:06But it creates a higher free trial to actual conversion, those higher conversions when we offer that subscription to Apple Podcasts.
1:05:13And those people might not sign up at all if we didn't offer that.
1:05:16So I'm glad it's there.
1:05:18I understand it's not a big moneymaker.
1:05:19I wish Apple would bring podcasts to Android, because they have Apple TV over there.
1:05:24They have Apple Music.
1:05:25Google stopped making their podcast app.
1:05:27All that's there is really YouTube Music.
1:05:29And then there's Pocket Casts and great third-party apps.
1:05:31But I think Apple Podcasts, if it was a good experience on Android, actually might be something that wins over part of that audience.
1:05:37Yeah, and it's really, really hard.
1:05:39Like, if you have an Apple-focused podcast, it's not too ridiculous to say we'll do the paid-only version through Apple Podcasts.
1:05:46Like, I could do it.
1:05:47You guys do do it.
1:05:48But for a general audience podcast, that's like a non-starter.
1:05:52And they're asking, what Apple's asking is do it in addition to Memberful or Substack or however else you might be making.
1:06:00And adding a second leg to the stool of ways that you take subscribers' money, it can be additive, but it's a multiplier complexity-wise.
1:06:16Because now you've got – if you have two ways to subscribe, it's more than twice the work to manage the overall membership and to say, hey, we want to sell T-shirts and we want to give members a discount because they're members.
1:06:32It's more than twice the work now because you've got two entirely different sets of them.
1:06:37And Apple's, of course, always has more privacy restrictions and you probably can't even get a list of their emails or anything.
1:06:43I know you can't get their emails, of course, but it's hard to let them take advantage of the fact that they're subscribed to you in Apple Podcasts and get $5 off a T-shirt on your site.
1:06:53And none of that – I get the privacy motivation from Apple.
1:06:56I totally do.
1:06:57But as a creator, it's sort of like, yeah, well, then why would I sign up for that?
1:07:01Why wouldn't I tell everybody to just go through Memberful where I've only got one database of users and I can just click a button in Shopify and give them a discount?
1:07:12And those are the kind of creator tools that I hope Apple builds in, like to communicate to those subscribers.
1:07:18Like we gave away pins and I offered it to our paid subscribers, but I can only offer it to those through Memberful because I have no way to communicate to those in Apple Podcasts.
1:07:27And in the Apple Insider Show, we did like a private Discord.
1:07:30And so the only way I could think of – because the other thing is in the subscriber, if someone pays to subscribe to an Apple Podcasts show, the show notes are still visible publicly.
1:07:41So if you don't pay to support Primary Tech on Apple Podcasts, you can still go to our bonus episode and you can't listen, but you could see the whole episode description.
1:07:49So I can't put a link there that just our paying members click or see.
1:07:53Everybody could see it.
1:07:54So the only thing we could think to do was, listen, at the end of our bonus episode, I'm going to say some magic words.
1:07:59I think I said something like hamster trumpet.
1:08:01And I said, just DM me with those words and I'll know you pay to listen to the show and I'll give you access to our Discord.
1:08:08And it's like, this is crazy.
1:08:09Like we can get better tools for this.
1:08:11So I do think ultimately bottom line, I think it's the best thing that's happened for Apple was related to Podcasts.
1:08:17A, because no matter how well those subscriber things were going to work, it was never going to matter to Apple's bottom line.
1:08:22So they're never going to drive meaningful revenue to Apple through Podcasts, no matter what they do.
1:08:28But what they can do is get a little spiteful and have somebody who gets their dander up.
1:08:35And Spotify is one of those companies based on the way that Spotify is a constant thorn in their side in the EU with regard to DMA mandate requests and stuff like that.
1:08:46And so I think Spotify's rise in the degree to which right now I don't think anybody dominates, including even YouTube in podcasts.
1:08:58I still think that's one of the things that's so healthy and web-like about podcasts overall.
1:09:02The fact that Spotify counts as number two is the most listened to stream or mechanism for podcasts is a good attention getter for Apple in a way that YouTube isn't.
1:09:13Because YouTube, because Apple and Google are sort of, if anything, getting more and more back together, like with the rumor that Google's Gemini might power the next version of Apple intelligence and stuff.
1:09:23And that they're sort of, after the whole going to war over Android thing, have sort of come back into, oh, these are Google things, these are Apple things, and we get along very well together.
1:09:36Spotify, not so much.
1:09:38And so I think the best thing to happen to think about Apple still being a champion of podcasts as an open medium is the rise of Spotify, who clearly doesn't want them to be an open medium, would love to be to podcast what YouTube is to video.
1:09:55And on a personal level, like, I have a 16-year-old son, 13- and 9-year-old daughter.
1:10:00But my oldest son, he was listening to podcasts in Pocket Cast for a long time.
1:10:06And in the last couple years, he has switched his listening habits to Spotify, which I don't even pay for Spotify Premium.
1:10:12We have the iCloud bundle.
1:10:14We pay for Apple Music.
1:10:15But Spotify, he can watch the podcasts.
1:10:18And it's in the same app that he might listen to something as well.
1:10:21And I'm like, especially younger generation who are developing habits for how to consume this content now, they are developing that habit to go to Spotify.
1:10:28Because that's just where it is.
1:10:30It's where it's easiest to do.
1:10:31And maybe YouTube, those latest stats, I think James Cridland shared this on PodNews, that, like, 80% of people who watch podcasts on YouTube also listen in a podcast apps in addition to watching it on YouTube.
1:10:42So the whole, like, YouTube is number one.
1:10:44Like, I think some of the stats are messy.
1:10:46But the fact that Spotify is just, there's zero barrier.
1:10:49If you want to listen, you want to watch, it's all in this one place.
1:10:52And I think Apple could do that.
1:10:54And for monetization, who knows if Apple will add ads to Apple TV shows one day.
1:11:00There's no ad tier right now.
1:11:02But they could do what Spotify does, which is allow creators to turn on ads, put in a timestamp and say, yeah, just put ads in my podcast, do the revenue share between Apple and the creators.
1:11:13And they can create that monetization mechanism that Spotify has right now, both for video and audio.
1:11:18Yeah.
1:11:18Yeah, that would be great.
1:11:20And going back to the origins of this topic, I just think that it's a perfect scenario for AI to analyze the episodes and do smart things with them.
1:11:34And I think that Apple is thinking about such things is, I think if this gets, if it doesn't get rejected, like you said, that the big creators of the big podcasts, like, there's the one notion of the big popular podcasts that come from these big platform studios or podcast studios.
1:12:02is that they don't have chapters.
1:12:04And I think a lot of us have been assuming that they don't have chapters because they don't care about chapters.
1:12:09And they assume that most of the listeners don't even know what chapters are.
1:12:13And so they don't create them.
1:12:15And so what if, so that they won't care if Apple adds them automatically through AI, but what if they do care and they don't have podcasts because they don't, they don't have chapters because they don't want chapters and they opt out.
1:12:29If a few big players opt out, it's lots and lots of popular podcasts.
1:12:34And then this feature is sort of, it won't be for not because there's dozens of, there are hundreds, thousands, I guess, thousands of little podcasts that don't have chapters who won't opt out.
1:12:45And Apple podcasts will add chapters.
1:12:47And if the chapters that come out of AI are half intelligent, it'll still be a benefit to the user experience, but it won't be the, oh, this is really cool.
1:12:56Now I have chapters in these big podcasts from like the New York times that never had them before.
1:13:01It remains to be seen if it's going to have that effect.
1:13:04But if it does, and they're actually pretty good, I think that's Apple leading the way on a really cool feature because chapters are great.
1:13:12It has really been frustrating to me that some of my favorite podcasts have never had them.
1:13:16And I know you and Ben Thompson, I think, talked about chapters and if you would ever put them in dithering recently.
1:13:22But the thing there is, and people might not realize this and ask why dithering doesn't have it.
1:13:28But if you do paid podcasts, I pay the Verge subscription, and so I get the ad-free versions of their shows.
1:13:33I pay for dithering.
1:13:34I have that show.
1:13:35Like the auto-generated chapters don't exist in those feeds.
1:13:38Apple doesn't have, you might add that feed to the Apple podcast app, but Apple is not doing the AI-generated chapters and the time links and the transcripts for those paid podcasts.
1:13:47So if those creators aren't doing it, they're not going to do it anyway.
1:13:50Right, because as far as Apple knows, they're all unique.
1:13:55If we have 1,000 subscribers that are all paying, it's 1,000 different podcasts.
1:13:59Yeah, I can.
1:14:00Would you allow auto-generated chapters in dithering if it did?
1:14:04I would.
1:14:06I don't know what.
1:14:07I don't want to answer for Ben, though.
1:14:08The CEO's office, I think, handles all the back-end stuff.
1:14:12It's part of the reason I'm so happy to do it is that I just don't worry about the details.
1:14:16I honestly didn't even know we didn't have chapters.
1:14:21I do care.
1:14:23Now, it sounds like I'm completely hands-off.
1:14:26I am so hands-on when it comes to our monthly album art that changes.
1:14:30And Ben is, too.
1:14:33It's not like it's all me.
1:14:34So I do care about that.
1:14:37But in terms of the technical back-end, like the episode titles, I'm not even involved in the chat that makes them.
1:14:44Yeah, and because I'm not doing the editing and I've opted out of it, and by the way, it's our friend Brad Ellis, icon designer and designer extraordinaire, who's done the actual artwork for every episode of Dithering.
1:14:57So hats off to Brad for making one of my favorite little things every month.
1:15:01If it were up to me, yes or no, we'd already have human-generated chapters because, you know, we usually have two or three segments per show.
1:15:09And I would say yes to allowing auto-generated chapters because, sure, why not?
1:15:14I honestly feel like, you know, it's up to the user, to me, whether they're going to do it in the same way that if I could opt out of reader mode in web browsers, I wouldn't.
1:15:26If you want to use reader mode to read Daring Fireball because you don't like the colors and the font size or whatever, that's up to you.
1:15:33That's the nature of the web that you get to do it.
1:15:35And so my thinking is if you want to use auto-generated, as long as they're identified, which Apple's going to do, as long as it says Apple Podcasts generated these chapters and it's very clear in the interface that your client generated them, not us, that would be fine with me.
1:15:51But I don't want to speak for Ben.
1:15:53What about you?
1:15:54I would.
1:15:56I'm kind of obsessive about chapters.
1:15:57I mean—
1:15:58So you make them yourself?
1:15:59I make them myself.
1:16:00I go so far as I have custom chapter artwork for every chapter in every episode.
1:16:05And so, yeah, that's—because I think it's—it makes even the listening a visual experience.
1:16:13If someone has CarPlay and they're listening and we say something because I do video version for our show as well as audio, and those who are listening, if I call something or if I draw attention to it, I can have the chapter artwork change.
1:16:26And you can even do something called silent chapters, which is changing the artwork outside of a chapter marker so just the image could change.
1:16:32Yeah, we use that sometimes.
1:16:34Yeah, and I love chapters.
1:16:36Any show that has chapters, sometimes I'll just look at them to see what are they talking—what are they going to talk about?
1:16:41It's a faster way to do that.
1:16:42I love doing chapters for our own show with the custom chapter artwork and art and all that kind of stuff.
1:16:48And so, yeah, I'm all about it.
1:16:50Chapters all day, every day.
1:16:52Yeah, we don't use it often on this show, but sometimes we'll do it if you're talking about a screenshot or something.
1:16:56And it's a whole segment, like in that whole segment about shortcuts that we had.
1:17:00It might look in your podcast player like there's one 25-minute segment on shortcuts.
1:17:05But in the middle of it, if we're talking about a screenshot of something, you put it a little invisible chapter in where the album art changes to that screenshot, and anybody who looks at their phone or whatever their podcast player is at that time, they'll see the thing that we're talking about.
1:17:20Or if you said, if I was talking about some accident I was in and I have a horrible, horrible scar on my arm, I might put in a chapter art of a photo of the scar on my arm.
1:17:31Whatever.
1:17:31Content warning.
1:17:32Yeah, but you could do it without making an entire actual chapter about it.
1:17:38All right, Stephen, that's a wrap.
1:17:39Thank you for joining me.
1:17:41I definitely will have you on again.
1:17:43Thank you.
1:17:43Everybody just look up Stephen Robles on YouTube, but the actual channel name is at Beard FM.
1:17:51Yeah, that's weird.
1:17:53We didn't talk about this, but I never knew what to brand it, and I eventually just branded it my name.
1:17:56But that means my URL is still at Beard FM or slash Bearded Teacher.
1:18:01But just search my name.
1:18:01It'll come up.
1:18:02Yeah, it's a better way to do it.
1:18:04And let's face it, Google is in charge of YouTube, and that's what they want you to do.
1:18:08Exactly.
1:18:08It's pretty much shortcuts.
1:18:11You'll see my stuff come up in Google.
1:18:12And Primary Technology, your podcast that I was lucky enough to be a guest on in recent months with Jason Aiton.
1:18:20That's right.
1:18:21A.K.A. Brian.
1:18:23Maybe that's his middle name.
1:18:25I don't know.
1:18:26Yeah, maybe.
1:18:26I'll have to ask him.
1:18:27And my thanks to our sponsor, our exclusive sponsor of this very special Black Friday, the Friday before Black Friday episode of the talk show, Uncommon Goods.
1:18:37Thanks to them at UncommonGoods.com slash talk show.