Podcast Search

The Talk Show

437: ‘A Naughty Citizen’, With Quinn Nelson

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00Quinn, you've had a big year, right?

0:00:01Yeah.

0:00:02Is this the year? Am I wrong? I'm at the age now. I've got a senior in college, my son Jonas,

0:00:07and the years now are just flying by like I'm flipping through pages in a book. So I'm thinking

0:00:13this is the year you became a father.

0:00:15That's a good memory. This is the year, yeah, at the end of January. So we're coming up on one year.

0:00:20So I am close.

0:00:22Just in the nick of time.

0:00:23But I'm so worried, and we would have had to start the show over because it would have been so

0:00:29embarrassing if you would have said, no, no, she's in kindergarten.

0:00:32Nope. Great memory. Yeah. It's been a long year. That's how you know. At your age,

0:00:38when you still think it's been only one year, I'm just kidding.

0:00:41Yeah. My son was born in January as well. So we're on the same rough schedule. And I,

0:00:51as long ago as it was for me, the first Christmas was awesome.

0:00:57Yeah. So we're excited. It's fun with a January baby because by the time Christmas rolls around,

0:01:01they're like, they're fun. She's doing stuff. She's crawling around like a monster and right.

0:01:06Yeah. It's a, it's, it's truly, I don't know. The ones, twos and threes are just phenomenal because

0:01:13there's, they're like you said, they're doing stuff and it's like, oh my God, well, look at this.

0:01:18And then for me, at least my wife would be like, shut up. He's not a robot, but I'd be talking about

0:01:23it. Like, look, he is teaching himself to do X, Y, and Z. Yeah. It's been a lot of fun. I'm very

0:01:33lucky. Well, but the other thing I do remember too, though, is like around that age, one and two,

0:01:39it is the most fun. You will have incredible memories. You're going to have fun extemporaneously

0:01:46as it happens. And it is the, it is like running an Ironman. Oh, because instead of a marathon,

0:01:53it is like an Ironman where there's three things at once. Right. Yep. And it's just starting,

0:01:59but I can already foresee the future. I mean, there, I already missed the days where she would just

0:02:05sleep on me all day, or you could sit her on the floor and you would, you were pretty confident

0:02:09that at 30 seconds later, she'd be in the same spot. And now all bets are off. She's climbing up

0:02:13the stairs. She were like, oh man, we've had to get a baby gate within the last like a week.

0:02:19Yep. Yep. We had one for our bottom stairs and we thought she won't try to climb up them. Now she

0:02:24does. So we bought two baby gates within two weeks of each other. Yeah. I remember that part very well

0:02:31to the, why, why was all of this advice about baby proofing? We don't have to do anything.

0:02:36This baby, the baby just stays there. You put the baby down, you can turn around, the baby stays

0:02:42there, and then you come back to where you left the baby. Why do, why do they recommend all this baby

0:02:47proofing? And then they start moving a little and you're like, yeah, like you said, like you get one

0:02:52gate. Yep. Six inches high. Within two weeks, we're like, oh, we, we might need to start thinking

0:02:58about this. And now we're like, red alert, red alert, buy all the door latches and we got

0:03:02to get this done. Yeah. Right. Well, congratulations. There is a lot going on and there are two main

0:03:10topics that I am overdue to talk about on this show. And you happened in the last few weeks to

0:03:18have made excellent videos about both of them. So one is the, I'll just spoil the whole show,

0:03:24the recent executive shufflings at Apple. And two is just a sort of, okay, iPadOS 26 shipped with the

0:03:35windowing. And here's the part where if this weren't a podcast, if it was a video, I would start

0:03:41shuffling through dozens and dozens of headlines that all reference how iPadOS is now like macOS,

0:03:49like macOS, iPad is now like Mac, iPad is now like Mac. No, it's not. No, no, but good and bad.

0:03:57No, it's not. Yeah. Which one would you rather talk about first as a two segment show?

0:04:02Oh, it's up to you. We could probably get the iPad done quickly.

0:04:06Oh, the famous, the famous, actually famous disastrous words on the talk show.

0:04:11Two hours later.

0:04:13Okay. Let's do that then. But let me start. We have two sponsors for today's show. So why don't I just

0:04:25knock the first one out? It is our good friends at Notion. Notion is a great note app. I mean,

0:04:33I guess that's where the note in Notion comes from, but calling it a notes app is sort of

0:04:38underselling. It is a system. It scales. This is where it starts to sound like, hmm, I don't know

0:04:45if this is for me or not. It scales all the way from like an individual use where one person, you,

0:04:51dear listener of the talk show, might want to consider making Notion your primary notes app just

0:04:57for you for your personal use all the way up to Fortune 500 enterprise type situations where you've

0:05:04got all sorts of rules to follow and you have all sorts of teams and collaborations and access and

0:05:08stuff like that. Well, how can one system scale to both uses? Well, through very clever design and a

0:05:15very focused attention to detail throughout the company. And Notion does that. And they are all over

0:05:22the whole AI revolution, for lack of a better term, and what they call Notion agent. And Notion agent is

0:05:32like, instead of using a notes app, and then having an AI thing on the side, and sending stuff back and

0:05:38forth, it is having AI built right into your notes system with complete access to the full database

0:05:45of the back end data of your notes so that when you interact with the AI bot, you don't have to tell it

0:05:53things for your, the task you want to assemble that are based on all the stuff you have stored in Notion.

0:05:59It already knows all of the stuff you have in Notion, including the collaborative stuff. So you can do

0:06:04things like use Notion. People have been using Notion to take like meeting notes with the team ever since

0:06:11Notion came out and started scaling to enterprise use. But now after a meeting where you take notes

0:06:16in Notion, and it knows all the people and knows the other users, the people who are in the meeting,

0:06:21then you can have Notion agent assemble, go through this meeting note and come up with action items for

0:06:27each of the participants, have a summary for people who weren't in the meeting, or people who fell asleep

0:06:32in the meeting, who want to catch up and figure out what they missed while they were sleeping, all of that

0:06:37stuff. It is all built in. It is really, really great. And I just cannot say how much more natural it is just

0:06:44kicking the tires and trying this, having the AI bot know everything in your system. And if you use Notion as your

0:06:51system, where you just put everything you want, your AI system knows everything about it. And if you don't want to

0:06:56use the AI stuff, you don't have to, it is still a great notes app, even without it. Notion brings all of your notes,

0:07:03stocks and projects into one connected space that just works. It is seamless, flexible, powerful,

0:07:07and actually fun to use. With AI built right in, you spend less time switching between tools and more

0:07:13time creating great work. And with Notion agent, your AI doesn't just help with work, it finishes it for

0:07:20you. Try Notion now with Notion agent at notion.com slash talk show. That's all lowercase letters. They want

0:07:28me to emphasize this all lowercase letters, notion.com slash talk show to try your new AI teammate Notion

0:07:37agent today. And when you use that link, you are supporting the talk show notion.com slash talk show.

0:07:45All right. Tell me the premise of your video.

0:07:48Okay. So inside of Notion, I created a framework for what this video would become.

0:07:56No. Yeah. So I have been, and it hasn't been much of a secret, but I haven't gone and shouted it from

0:08:04the rooftops either. I've been primarily an iPad first user for about a year now. I reviewed the M4 iPad Pro,

0:08:13and it was the same kind of review that everybody has given every iPad Pro, where I said, man, this

0:08:20is a great iPad. And the tandem OLED screen is the best screen I've, I literally own in my house,

0:08:25period. It's better than my TV. It's, it's, it's incredible. And the hardware is so thin and Apple

0:08:30pencil is fantastic. And the magic keyboard, the new magic keyboard is really, really good.

0:08:35Who's this for? But after my review, I did something that I don't normally do. And I kept using it because

0:08:44the hardware was so good that I just, I reached for my iPad instead of my MacBook Air. And when I need to do

0:08:52something, I would just go to the iPad first, particularly Spark, which is my email client,

0:08:57is a pile of trash on the Mac. It is like this electron bloat, extraordinary garbage fest. And

0:09:06on iPadOS, it's native. It's fantastic. And so initially, I started using my iPad just as an

0:09:13email machine. And then I used it for more and more things and doing things that people do on the iPad,

0:09:18browsing the web and watching video. But then I did more and more. The Notion app on the iPad is not bad.

0:09:24It could use a little work, to be honest. But we use Notion day in and day out. It's Nazi Labs. It's

0:09:28what we run everything on. I have my ad sales in there. I write my scripts in there. We have team

0:09:32notes in there. And I started-

0:09:35That's unpaid. That's an unpaid testimony.

0:09:37That's right. Yeah. They're not paying me to say anything.

0:09:39In fact, I pay Notion. They pay me negative money.

0:09:43Yeah.

0:09:43It really is something for collaborative use.

0:09:45Right.

0:09:46Oh, it's unbelievable. I'm not like, I don't want to go back and do a Notion tangent. The ad reads

0:09:51over. But I use it. We use it for everything. My whole team's in there. We build out everything

0:09:56in Notion. The Notion agents you mentioned are legitimately amazing where I've gone on site and

0:10:02done interviews that I just record from my phone in Notion as like field notes. And then when I'm done,

0:10:08there's a full kind of summary of whatever happened. And I can just query the AI assistant inside of

0:10:15Notion and say, what was that one thing that he was talking about about this thing without much

0:10:19context? And it finds it line for line. It's good. Anyway, so-

0:10:24It's really amazing when you can query a system without dumping what you want to query into it

0:10:30first.

0:10:31Yeah. It's what LLMs do best.

0:10:33And in the LLM world, if you start from scratch with just a fresh chat GPT window or whatever,

0:10:40and you say, here, take this folder, and you point it at a folder, or you do something like that,

0:10:44or here's a 300-some page PDF thing, and then ask questions about it. That's good. It works.

0:10:52People can use it that way. But when you can just start by asking a question, it is like another-

0:10:57It's pretty awesome.

0:10:58Order of magnitude level of convenience. And you end up asking more questions because you're like,

0:11:03I don't have to spend one minute prepping it. I can just ask the question.

0:11:07You do. And you can build context and you can say, hey, you answered me in this manner,

0:11:12but that's not actually what I'm looking for. Remember this for future reference. And it does.

0:11:16Oh, it's so cool.

0:11:17But to bring it back to this iPad thing, the problem is that with the Notion iPad app,

0:11:25it's sort of a grown-up big screen version of their iPhone app, not just a touchscreen 1311-inch

0:11:33version of the Mac app.

0:11:34Correct. And my biggest problem with the Notion app on the iPad is that it only supports a single

0:11:41window. On the Mac, you can deal with multiple tabs. You can't on the Notion app. So I-

0:11:46actually use a combination. I'll use the Notion app for my primary purposes. And then I'm also

0:11:50running Notion inside of Mobile Safari so that I can have the effective tab feature. So Notion,

0:11:56fix that, guys. But other than that, I just started gravitating towards the iPad more naturally. And I

0:12:02still needed the Mac. But for the first time ever, I think, and this was even before iPadOS 26,

0:12:08by the way, I just found more reasons to use the iPad. And I didn't try to do everything on the

0:12:16iPad. And that was the key. Because we all know that the iPad doesn't do stuff exactly like a Mac.

0:12:22And sometimes you just need a Mac. And every time I would try to move to the iPad, I'd be like, okay,

0:12:26this is going to replace my computer. And ultimately, I would get frustrated and say,

0:12:31this sucks, and I'd leave. But after the M4 iPad Pro review that I did, I loved the hardware so much

0:12:36that I just used it when the iPad made sense to use. And when it didn't, I'd use my MacBook Air.

0:12:41And so that was kind of the situation I had for the better part of a year. And then beta season with

0:12:47iPadOS 26 came around. And everybody was like, oh, this is a paradigm shift. This is... And in many

0:12:53ways, it is. It totally changes how I use the iPad. But it's still not a Mac. There are things that you

0:13:03have to use a Mac for. And what my video kind of detailed is that these are not like top level

0:13:09things that are easy to change. Like windowing is one thing, right? But we're talking about like

0:13:13fundamental OS, not even limitations, but design decisions that make an iPad, an iPad, and a Mac,

0:13:20a Mac. They're not interchangeable, really. And the more you try, the more you just decide that it sucks.

0:13:25Yeah. We are in a weird... Well, the big comparison that I like, my mind always goes to is the car

0:13:34industry, where the car industry is well over, at this point, a century old. And there are still

0:13:42many different car companies. And there is... Everybody loves to lament the sort of... What do

0:13:48they call those? The little SUVs? The one that all the cars look like these days?

0:13:55Oh, just a crossover?

0:13:56Yeah, yeah.

0:13:57Yeah, the crossover. That's the word I was looking for. Right? And there is... It's kind of... For as

0:14:02many different brands as there still are making cars, it is kind of sad. And part of it is just... I

0:14:09think you know better than I do more about cars. But it's really kind of driven by the way that

0:14:14that what's aerodynamic and what is therefore fuel efficient leads to a sameness in design.

0:14:21But there's also just a lack of adventure. And again, I am not going to start. We have too

0:14:26much to talk about. I'm not going to start a whole digression about the Tesla and the big pickup truck.

0:14:32But whatever you want to say about it, it does look unique. Right?

0:14:38Oh, yeah. That's for sure. Yeah.

0:14:40It doesn't look like anything else. And that is in and of itself exciting. And I do wish more

0:14:47companies did that. And computers have worked in a very different way where we're kind of just down

0:14:52to on the desktop, you can have Mac or Windows. And it has been Mac or Windows for a very long time.

0:14:58And yes, and then there's Linux, right? And Linux, arguably, I know my friend David Hennemeyer

0:15:04Hansen is all in on Linux now and has moved away from the Mac. And maybe more people are doing that as

0:15:11they get frustrated with detail. So it's always the year of Linux is coming soon. But it is coming sooner

0:15:18than ever before. It is better. I can tell just by watching a couple YouTube videos that it does seem

0:15:24nicer. But it also seems nicer because the Windows are the Linux window managers no longer are ripping

0:15:32off Windows, they're ripping off the Mac more. But that's it, right? There aren't and there aren't

0:15:40new companies coming out of the woodwork to make computers, right? There's the framework company

0:15:44that makes the modular laptops and stuff. And they are interesting and I wish them well. I don't think

0:15:50they make great hardware. It's just sort of settled. The mobile industry settled even quicker than it

0:15:57than the desktop industry on iOS and Android. And the open source alternatives are even more of a niche

0:16:04than desktop computing. And so it's hard to say that, you know, only Apple would wind up in a position

0:16:12where the Mac and the iPad overlap in so many ways. And they just don't unify them or just add

0:16:21everything from one to the other and from the other to the other. Because who else is there other than

0:16:27Apple who would be in that position today? But it is for all the companies that could have wound up in

0:16:32this position. We've wound up in what I think is a very Apple uniquely Apple position between these two,

0:16:39where inside Apple, the decision makers, I think, can look at any one of these. If we had, if Jaws popped

0:16:45into the show with me and you and we could pepper Jaws with questions about all the frustrations your video

0:16:51pinpointed and the ones I've had for a long time, he could defend all of them very quickly. And there's a

0:16:57sense within Apple of why things are the way they are. But when you examine the same issue from a different

0:17:02perspective, it just seems kind of wild, right? Like fundamentally, like as you point out, iPad hardware,

0:17:08iPad Pro hardware is arguably the nicest hardware Apple makes period, right? Second, maybe in competition

0:17:16only with the iPhone 17 Pro. But I think that they're honestly, I don't either, honestly, for various

0:17:23reasons. And because they still don't make like a $2,500 phone, right? That the best phones they make

0:17:32are actually relative to the iPad Pro very low. The iPad Pros are like, oh, what if we just make like

0:17:38the Rolls Royce of handheld computers? And it shows and they are nicer than MacBook Pros. They really are.

0:17:46They have better displays. Way better displays. Right. Way, just way better displays. They've

0:17:52way, I think, better sound. It's certainly better sound per cubic millimeter, like per space. Like

0:18:01if you're going to just consider the volume, the physical volume of the device, it's just amazing,

0:18:06amazing hardware. It's comparable to a MacBook Air, which is amazing for how thin they are.

0:18:09No, they're exceptional pieces of hardware. And then you get to, you get to the fact that it runs an OS

0:18:15that doesn't have swap. And that's the problem, right? Because as these areas kind of merge,

0:18:22I understand where Apple's coming from, because the argument you'll find from people that don't use the

0:18:27iPad is, well, they should just put Mac OS on the iPad. And now that the hardware is effectively the

0:18:33same, I mean, you're running the same silicon, you've got similar form factors, you've got a keyboard and

0:18:39a trackpad. Could you run Mac OS on an iPad? 100% you could. But that doesn't make an iPad

0:18:45an iPad. I mean, one of the reasons that the iPad is so compelling is because it is this dynamic and

0:18:51unique platform. And for years, it felt limited by iOS, because that is in effect what it was. I mean,

0:19:00the original, I mean, even when they forked kind of into separate iPad OS and iOS branches,

0:19:05that first year, you're like, yeah, but they're the same though. And they still are very,

0:19:09very similar. But with all of the windowing features that have made it over in iPad OS 26,

0:19:15I think the iPad feels as much of its own computer, its own thing as it's ever felt. And yet,

0:19:23I do understand and recognize frustration from both sides, because in so doing, they have inherently made

0:19:31it a little more complicated. There were a lot of people that loved slide over from iPad OS 18. It was

0:19:37requested all summer long, and they shipped 26.0 without slide over. There was so much hoopla, I think,

0:19:43from both inside and outside the company, that in 26.1, they said, fine, have slide over back and it's

0:19:50back. But it now only works from with inside the stage manager UI, which is inherently more complicated

0:19:57than back in the single windowed iPad era. And so in doing this, they've made regular iPads a little more

0:20:05complicated for regular people that just want to browse Twitter and watch YouTube. But then the people that

0:20:11want a Mac are still frustrated because it's not a Mac. It's an iPad. And it's really, really good. And what an iPad

0:20:19is, is better than it's ever been. But there are still, like you mentioned, core fundamental limitations

0:20:25that I think until those are addressed, it's never going to be resolved. And short of doing

0:20:31my like leading hypothesis now for what Apple would need to do to make this kind of work

0:20:36is to, again, fully redesign the files app to turn it into more Finder-esque desktop power. And then I

0:20:45think they would need to quite literally do a reverse catalyst wherein rather than run iOS apps on the Mac,

0:20:51there would need to be a way to virtualize a Mac app on the iPad. You run it in the windowed iPad

0:20:56environment. It looks like an iPad app. Now that the iPad supports menu bars like macOS does, there's

0:21:01no reason they couldn't. And then instead of running macOS, you just run Mac apps when the iPad app doesn't

0:21:09do what you need it to do. But then again, we get to the point of, well, then what's the point of having

0:21:14these two separate platforms if they're so much the same? You know what I mean?

0:21:17Right. And I feel like that's, and then that's where Apple's like, yes, see, that's what we do know what

0:21:23we're doing. And that's why they're very different and will remain different, right? Effectively, what

0:21:27you're talking about is bringing AppKit to iPadOS. And I think that's probably never going to happen

0:21:35because I think, but it's, but I get why you want it. And I kind of do too. And then I start, I'm not

0:21:44even an AppKit developer, but I know enough and I've been following it closely enough for so long

0:21:50that you start thinking of, I start thinking even as a non-developer, oh, but AppKit apps can assume

0:21:59X, Y, Z and it's, oh, and they're never going to allow X, Y, Z. Like an AppKit app can just assume

0:22:05that there's a Unix subsystem available. And if the app wants to and knows that there's a user slash bin

0:22:13Python 3 installed at the system level. And it can, if it wants to process a bit of data with

0:22:19Python, it can just do that in the background, not even tell the user, well, that's not available on

0:22:24iPadOS. And kernel level extensions and all of that stuff. And so that's one of the things my video

0:22:29talked about was, I was like, look, you've got DaVinci Resolve, you've got Final Cut Pro 10,

0:22:34the DaVinci Resolve binary for iPad quite literally is the macOS binary. They've done a couple of things to

0:22:40make it look like it's for the iPad. They're hidden by default. But if you use the keyboard commands that

0:22:45are available on the Mac, it just turns them back on and it doesn't run because they never really meant

0:22:50for it to run on the iPad, but it is the Mac app compiled for iPad. And yet the iPad doesn't support

0:22:56a bunch of media formats that are supported on a Mac. And so if you deal with those formats, which most

0:23:04professionals do, the iPad's not going to work, even though the hardware is capable and the app is

0:23:10literally the same.

0:23:12people who know more than I do listening to this show, write to me, correct me if I'm wrong here,

0:23:17but I don't think I am. I have friends. I just mentioned one the other day on Daring Fireball

0:23:25about the Photoshop 1.0 source code and somebody comment, which was released by the Computer History

0:23:31Museum. And they had somebody take a look at it, like a professor of computer science at,

0:23:37I forget, IBM or something like that. And he was like, well, there aren't very many comments in

0:23:42this code. It was all most of the, it was either assembler, like 15% assembler and 85% Pascal.

0:23:47But it's so clearly written that they're not necessary. And my friend at Adobe still works on

0:23:53Photoshop and adjacent apps. It was like, well, that tradition has continued for 30 years.

0:23:58But I have friends at Adobe and I do think it's true. They're like for a long time.

0:24:05Well, forever, really, it sort of comes from the next era where the right way to write an app for

0:24:11next step. And then the right way from Apple's perspective to write an app for Mac OS 10 was to

0:24:18use AppKit and rely upon the system AppKit framework for as much functionality as possible, including the

0:24:26actual, not just capital F framework of AppKit, but the conceptual framework of how the app manages

0:24:34events and deals with the system. And I think they still make text edit available, but for a long time,

0:24:42at least the source code to text edit was available as a developer thing. So you could look at it and

0:24:48effectively the Mac text edit app, which does a lot. It really is. And I know a lot of people who use it

0:24:54as like they're, they just, it's their go-to app for like, I have a quick idea or meeting notes or

0:24:59something like that. They just go to text edit, command N, start typing. It's a really interesting

0:25:04app, but it's almost nothing to it. The app itself, it's really just a showcase of AppKit, like the RTF

0:25:11rich text view. That is the primary thing you see and interact with in text edit all comes from AppKit,

0:25:18the way that it supports all the fonts you have on your system and can open the system font panel

0:25:23and the way that it has find and all these things come from AppKit, the way that it prints it print

0:25:28printing used to be a nightmare in the days of the nineties when developers had to write their own

0:25:33print stop printing stuff to interact with printers. And there, I'm not saying there's no source code to

0:25:39it. I think like the, it has a pretty by Apple state. I think it's a historical legacy. It has. If you

0:25:45ever look at text edit, you may never need to look in the preferences or that's now we call them

0:25:50settings. It has a pretty, it has a lot more application settings than new Apple apps offer.

0:25:57And that's not free from using AppKit, but text edit shows you just like what AppKit does. And that's,

0:26:04that was the whole idea in the late nineties when it took Apple a little, a couple of years longer to

0:26:09get Mac OS 10 out the door than they originally had hoped for when they bought next. And the next team

0:26:15came in and took over Apple because their original plan was, Hey, we've got this great application

0:26:21framework built into the system. We're bringing it to the new Mac platform. Rewrite all your apps in

0:26:25this app. New, the code was called Coco and the big developers like Microsoft and Adobe to name the two

0:26:34biggest and most important to the platform. We're like, no, we don't think we're going to do that.

0:26:39Rewrite all of our Mac applications from scratch using a new framework and a different programming

0:26:45language. We're not going to do that. And so it took out long story short of why it took Apple

0:26:50longer to ship Mac OS 10 was they had to work out a hybrid system where they could bring more legacy

0:26:55Mac frameworks, which were called carbon and have them work side by side. But the message from Apple

0:27:01was always, well, okay, we'll do that. But the only reason you should probably be using carbon

0:27:05is for legacy purposes with existing apps. And if you're starting a new project, you should use Coco,

0:27:10you should use Coco. But where I'm going with this is that the apps that still haven't, and a lot of

0:27:17the media apps like Adobe's, all of Adobe's apps, they all kind of have effectively their own framework.

0:27:23And in a large part, a lot of it is actually dates back to that era still. And the Adobe Photoshop for

0:27:29iPhone is actually running the Mac app framework from way before the next era at Apple, or at least the

0:27:36parts of it. It's like Darth Vader. It's like more man than machine or machine than man now. It's probably

0:27:43more of a customized Adobe flavor of Mac app than it was the version that Adobe licensed from Apple back in

0:27:50the early 90s. And I think DaVinci is probably the almost exactly the same story where the reason

0:27:56DaVinci is able to run their Mac app on the iPad is that they have the whole app framework themselves

0:28:01and can recompile it. Whereas if they did the thing Apple had been telling them to do for 25 years,

0:28:06rely on AppKit, well, then you'd have to start all over from scratch to make a version for iOS or iPad OS.

0:28:14That's totally true. It's a naughty citizen to until recently, you'd open up DaVinci Resolve,

0:28:20and it had the menu bar inside the window. Yes. Because it was originally a Linux app,

0:28:26and then it was ported to macOS next, and then Windows very hastily after that. Yeah.

0:28:31I've been in so many Apple briefings where one of the demos is DaVinci Resolve, often for iPad or Mac or

0:28:39something where they want to show off something that because DaVinci is such a, I don't know shit about

0:28:44it. I don't, I'm not in that field, but it always is impressive to me. And Apple gins up these

0:28:50impressive demos that show how fast it is or how it's, how efficient it can be on this new Apple

0:28:54hardware. But Apple also, when they pick things to show to the media in a briefing, in addition to

0:29:01showing off the hardware, whatever the message that they're trying to convey is, they also tend to pick

0:29:07apps that are very attractive or follow the design guidelines and look very, and when they'd show

0:29:13DaVinci and it has the menu bar in the windows, it's like, oh, this must be very impressive software

0:29:19because it is not here for the way the UI is designed. No. And to give them credit, I think

0:29:25they have, as they've cozied up to Apple over the last few years, it has gotten substantially better.

0:29:29Right. I think that Apple was like, look, you got to make this look better.

0:29:33Right? Because it really matters to Apple. It's way better than it used to be.

0:29:36It really matters to Apple. And I'm sure the DaVinci people are like, well, who cares? All of our users,

0:29:41their pros, they get used to anything. Professional pilots get used to the cockpit of a Boeing 737,

0:29:47which is incomprehensible to a layperson. They're like, oh, I know everything. I know where every

0:29:52switch is. I know where everything to change. And they're like, all of our users know it. And Apple

0:29:58is like, no, you got to fix this. We're showing this to people. We want to show it off more.

0:30:03You're killing us. Yep. But that's kind of the crux of the issue is that the iPad has gotten

0:30:10and continues to get year on year, ever more powerful, ever more capable. But I think that

0:30:17as much as I appreciate the ideology that there can be room for all of these computers,

0:30:23I still need a Mac. I use my iPad 90% of the time, but I still need a Mac 10% of the time. And the

0:30:32reverse is not true. There's nothing that I do on my iPad that I couldn't do on a Mac. Now,

0:30:36that's not true for everybody. Some people, especially digital artists, using a Wacom tablet

0:30:41that doesn't have a display on your Mac sucks relative to what you can achieve on the iPad.

0:30:47But that's kind of the issue is as the iPad gets even more powerful, it just becomes all the more

0:30:55frustrating when it can't do the stuff that the Mac just does and has done effortlessly for 30 years.

0:31:01And the stuff, the way that because the Mac is designed the way it is, it turns out and has for

0:31:1040 years, the entire history of the Mac wound up being good for things that weren't what it was

0:31:19designed to be good for because they hadn't been anticipated yet. Right. And for example, your video

0:31:25emphasized, hey, so there's a bunch of different ways to run cutting edge LLM models on your own

0:31:32hardware locally. And you the same one on two different machines running the same like M4 class

0:31:40architecture with 16 gigabytes with of RAM on both a Mac and an iPad Pro. And one could do it and

0:31:48once you got it, maybe not easily, but it could do it. And then it was like, hey, this is actually

0:31:54pretty impressive. And one, it was like, no go. Can't do it. Just possibly.

0:31:57Yeah. Well, the iPad would just initiate a jet sound event because it's like, you can't use that

0:32:01much memory. Right. That's what the whole system needs to stay stable. And the Mac will just start

0:32:08pushing its own system processes into swap. And the Mac becomes a horrible experience. It's super slow.

0:32:14It's beach balling everywhere, but it works. And the iPad just goes, yeah, no, I'm not even going

0:32:18to try. I can't do that. Right. And it probably could because I have to imagine that iPad OS is more

0:32:24efficient from a memory standpoint than the Mac is. Or that it could somehow conceivably, if they added

0:32:31the ability to do swap so that, you know, you could have. And technically it has it, but not in the

0:32:38same way that the Mac does. Right. Yeah. And in the Mac and any desktop operating system, Windows,

0:32:47Linux, any version of Unix ever, the classic Mac OS aspired to this and it would only fall short when

0:32:55an actual crash happened. But if something is open, a document, an app, a process, and you leave it open,

0:33:03it stays open and you never come back and find that it has been flushed. It just doesn't happen. And so

0:33:13for example, one of the most comical new things, like the fact that we had to wait for it. And even now

0:33:20it's like a special API that apps have to qualify for with a special entitlement is like the entitlement to

0:33:29export. If you're using Final Cut or Logic, right on the iPad, Apple's own software, and you have this

0:33:36big, huge project that you've been working on. And then the export is going to take a long time because

0:33:41that's exporting is still for high quality video or even huge multi-track audio projects. Exporting is

0:33:50computationally expensive and you have to wait. And you couldn't put the app in the background,

0:33:57which is cuckoo bananas when you think about it historically. And it used to be, I'm so old

0:34:04that I remember when copying things to a floppy disk on the Mac was modal and, or formatting,

0:34:12you put a new, you'd buy a bunch of floppy disks, but they were all DOS formatted. So you'd have to

0:34:18format them on your Mac. And when you'd format the floppy disk, it was system modal while the Mac

0:34:23was formatting the floppy disk, which took a long time because they were floppy drives were

0:34:29very slow. You just had to sit there and wait and wait and wait, right? And there were all sorts of

0:34:37things that were system modal. And there was even a different style of dialogue box when we started to

0:34:42get things that weren't system modal. And you could tell just by looking at the dialogue box style,

0:34:48whether this was going to block all input until this was done and it was going to take up the,

0:34:53that's it. You just wait till this is done before you can, might as well just take your hands off the

0:34:57keyboard and mouse, go stretch your legs, get up, walk away. And when all of computing sort of moved

0:35:06and really with the Mac, it got better. It, it, by the end of the classic era, even though it was all

0:35:12kind of faked, right? It wasn't a real, the term of art at the time was a preemptive multitasking

0:35:17operating system. And it wasn't really, but it faked its way to being one. And the fake part was why

0:35:25sometimes if your internet explorer crashed, it would actually bring down the whole system and you'd have

0:35:31to restart the whole computer. And I hope you saved the documents that were open and the other apps that

0:35:36you had open at the time to a system where every app could just be command tabbed away and it would

0:35:42keep doing what it was doing. And it felt like this is the future and that future, it felt so exhilarating

0:35:48and wow, this is amazing. It's Photoshop is going to be, or whatever app I'm using is going to be doing

0:35:54this for a very long time. And I can go do something else while that's happening in the background.

0:35:59That was 25 years ago with baby computers compared to M four or M five, let alone iPad pro today,

0:36:11like the compute sheer computing power. And we think today like, Oh, an iPad pro, even the most you can

0:36:18spend on one, you still only get 16 gigabytes of Ram. Back then you did, you would have to like 25 years

0:36:26ago, somebody would say 16 gigabytes of Ram. And you'd be like, yes. And they'd be like, I can't

0:36:31wait for this glorious future when there's that much Ram. And it's, and they'd be like, and it's only

0:36:37$2,000. And you'd be like, well, that's actually considered very expensive at the time. And they're

0:36:41like, what? Yeah. You're like for $2,000, I can get a little thing that's this light and this thin,

0:36:48and it has 16 gigabytes of Ram. And you'd be like, yes. And they'd be like, that's like infinite Ram.

0:36:54And then you'd say, nope, actually that's going to feel very constrained if you want to do something

0:36:58advanced. Yeah. And so something that illustrates that point, perhaps perfectly is like you mentioned,

0:37:05the iPad needs to get specific entitlements developers do in order to have their apps continue to process

0:37:11and run in the background. But this even extends as an issue to multitasking. So now that we've got

0:37:17windowing on the iPad, I can plug my iPad into my studio display. And for all intents and purposes,

0:37:23it looks like a Mac. I've got my dock on the bottom. I've got my menu bar that's static up top.

0:37:28I've got multiple windows open. Here's something you'll never see on a Mac. So the iPad can move

0:37:34certain apps to swap. If the memory requested by the foreground app exceeds what the system is normally

0:37:41able to allocate, it puts the apps in the background into a hibernate state, not all that dissimilar from

0:37:46app nap or some of the kind of features on the Mac. This you will never see on the Mac. However, I was exporting a video

0:37:53individual resolve. It's in the foreground. And I tab away command tab to Photoshop, which is also running on the iPad.

0:38:01And

0:38:02DaVinci Resolve, I suspect, had the entitlements to request the largest amount of memory. It was in the middle of the export. And rather than figure out the kind of memory allocations between the foreground app and background apps, it just quit Photoshop, which was the foreground most app.

0:38:21Because it's like, well, DaVinci Resolve needs the memory. And so it just closed the app. It just killed it. It didn't put it into a hibernate state. It didn't reallocate some of the RAM that was in DaVinci Resolve in the background away from it to the foreground app. No, it just killed the foreground primary running app because, well, something else needs it. And you'd never see that on a Mac.

0:38:40Right. So it's like instead of falling apart the way that classic Mac OS did it, because it just wasn't built to do all that much at once in limited resources and a limited computing architecture, the Mac was built to keep everything open running forever, even if you kept opening more stuff, but even at the expense of slowing down the experience.

0:39:02And that's where the dreaded beach ball comes from. Right. And some people think because sometimes you do see the beach ball when an app has spiraled into a death cycle and needs to be forced quit.

0:39:11But sometimes you see the beach ball just because the system is so overwhelmed. Nothing is gone. Nothing is lost. Nothing is forced quit. It's just you got to give us a second here because we've written out the RAM from this app that you're trying to switch to to swap and we got to get it back from swap.

0:39:29But to do that, we've got to get this other apps memory written to swap and hold on, hold on. It's like it's like you don't have enough servers for how many customers are in the restaurant and it's like you're all going to get your food, but it's going to be it's going to be it might be cold by the time you get it, but you're all going to get it.

0:39:48Every single thing that everybody's ordered on every table is going to get to them. We promise. And it does eventually happen and catch up. Whereas like iPad OS from the iPhone is sort of like at any given time, they might just ask the customers to leave at the table.

0:40:05They're like, yeah, you were going to where your your table is no longer even though you've already sat down and ordered your your outside in the lobby again. And then when it's when you want to come back in, we'll just start you all over and we'll put you at a new table and you can order again.

0:40:22It sounds ridiculous. Well, why would anybody make a computer like that? Why? Why shouldn't it all be the Mac way? But there is it's it's the fact that that's why the iPad never gets a beach ball. There is no beach ball in iOS or iPad OS and things never slow down.

0:40:38It is a reasonable trade off, but they are sort of mutually incompatible goals. I kind of feel like the other thing, though, the reason and we keep coming back to it. I think the iPad is in a better shape than it ever has.

0:40:50For sure. Right. I look back at at my the iPad turns awkwardly turns 10 essay from 2020, I guess, when the iPad turned 10. And I think it's been a really good five years for the iPad.

0:41:03But I still feel like the original sin is that Apple primarily has two real computers that they make from that are designed soup to nuts, hardware and software, both to be exactly the way they want them to be the Mac and the iPhone and the iPad is just sort of still fundamentally a big iPhone.

0:41:30It is. It's there's there's no other way. And they can say, no, it's not. That's why we named it iPad OS. And before it's. Yeah. But if if for some reason the only two computers Apple made were iPads and Macs and they didn't make iPhones anymore, like some kind of hypothetical regulatory nightmare gone wrong for Apple.

0:41:51And they have to spin off the iPhone and they have to spin off the iPhone into an independent company. And it truly is independent. It's gone. And Apple computer. Maybe that's the new company's name. They go back to Apple computer and Apple computer, which no longer makes the iPhone only has the iPad and Mac.

0:42:06I think the iPad gets a lot more computery, not necessarily more Mac, but it just gets more computery because they don't have to worry about the limitations of a phone.

0:42:15Right. I agree.

0:42:18Where else was I going to go? Oh, the other thing I want to go back to the how how are you feeling about the UI changes, the the windowing mode in iPad now that I iPad OS 26 has sort of been here for a while?

0:42:31There is a and this is, I think, the prevailing complaint that I've seen online. There is an incredible learning curve.

0:42:36Yeah. Part of it, I think I I tried to put myself in the shoes of someone who hadn't used a computer before. Right.

0:42:44And I was like, if I was sat down in front of an iPad and in front of a Mac, would one feel more intuitive than the other?

0:42:50And my instinct was to say, well, the iPad, because you it's a phone, you you press the icon and then you always swipe up and that always gets you back home and you never get lost.

0:43:01However, as soon as you start to work with the windowing environment, that all falls apart.

0:43:06I think it's substantially more complex because they've had to design a system that works with both touch and with the trackpad.

0:43:15And in so doing, they've made a system that I think is as good as it probably can be, but is also kind of not really good at either.

0:43:24You have to use your finger very precisely to touch the corner of a window to get it to resize.

0:43:30When you're on a trackpad, you can go and drag it like a Mac window.

0:43:33However, it doesn't snap like it does on the Mac.

0:43:36And when you go to use the radio buttons, the traffic light buttons at the top of a window, well, there's not the real estate to have the three buttons there.

0:43:43So you've got to click or hover once to get them to reveal themselves and then you perform the action.

0:43:48And by the way, they're not the same actions that they perform on the Mac.

0:43:52Those three buttons do three different things.

0:43:54I mean, the red button still closes.

0:43:57The yellow one still kind of minimizes, but not really because that's just what the iPad does anyway.

0:44:04You swipe up and then it goes down to the dock.

0:44:07It doesn't hide in the dock like it normally would on the Mac.

0:44:10You can't see an instance of the app running down in the dock.

0:44:13It just goes back into the app icon and you're like, is it still open?

0:44:17Is it being multitasked?

0:44:19You've got to.

0:44:20And if you have a home screen with a bunch of icons in it or if it's inside of a folder on your home screen on your iPad, well, you've got to navigate back into that folder and then open that app back up.

0:44:31And or use the app switcher, which is not really present on the Mac because all apps are open and persistent if they're open.

0:44:38And so it gets it gets kind of weird.

0:44:40And then the green full size button kind of performs the same function, but it also kind of doesn't because it either snaps full screen and or absorbs the full size of the iPad.

0:44:51But without the kind of nuance that it would on the Mac where you can reach up to grab the menu bar, it's it's just weird.

0:45:00I think they did it because they're like, well, we want it to look and feel like a Mac, but it doesn't do the things that the Mac does.

0:45:06And so if you use both of them, it's even more complicated because you have to learn, relearn two interfaces that are visually identical, but are absolutely not operationally identical.

0:45:15Right.

0:45:17And they're not even well, they just to make the simplest possible example.

0:45:24Right.

0:45:25There's two there's Windows and Mac.

0:45:27And how do you close a window?

0:45:29And on the Mac from 1984 onward, you go up to the top left corner and click that button in the top left corner of the window.

0:45:37And that's how you close it.

0:45:38And on Windows, you go to the top right corner.

0:45:41Right.

0:45:41And you click that button.

0:45:43Yeah.

0:45:43And it closes it.

0:45:45And my bias as a Mac user is so strong that I'm not even sure I would like to make the argument that the Mac style makes more close, makes more sense idiomatically.

0:45:59But I think in the grand scheme of things, it probably could have gone either way.

0:46:03And maybe somewhere in 1983, when the original Mac team was deciding that.

0:46:08I don't even know if they if they had an argument, should it be top right or top left?

0:46:13But that's the Mac way and top rights, the Windows way.

0:46:17And then in those years of the Web, when Windows was so much more popular still than the Mac amongst the sort of people who made like even Web apps or video, like the fake computer interface in a video game or something like that.

0:46:32The close buttons were always top right because Windows was more popular than the Mac and it was sort of the bigger thing.

0:46:37Of course, the iPad does it the Mac way, which is if it's got to be top left or top right, it should be top left.

0:46:44Right.

0:46:44That's the Mac way.

0:46:45Kind of.

0:46:46I could go on a whole rant about it.

0:46:47Kind of drives me nuts that three years ago they switched Safari tabs in iOS to put the close button top right.

0:46:55And I honestly blame Alan Dye's spoiler for the rest of the second half of the show.

0:47:01I really do think it's some numb nut who's yeah, but, you know, somebody in the Apple design team who's actually is grew up on the Windows world, not the Mac world.

0:47:11And it was like, yeah, I always thought that top left thing was stupid.

0:47:14Let's put the close button top right.

0:47:16And it's like, that's not the way Apple does things.

0:47:18So there are some similarities.

0:47:20Right.

0:47:20And of course, they're red, yellow and green because that's famously the Mac colors since Mac OS 10.

0:47:25But they do different things.

0:47:27And why is there even a yellow one?

0:47:29Right.

0:47:30It's well, the Mac has one.

0:47:31But it does a different thing.

0:47:32And so that kind of does violate a certain principle of UI design, which is if two things are similar, they should do similar things.

0:47:41They shouldn't look similar if they're not similar.

0:47:44And so the red, yellow, green window buttons on Mac and iPad, they're mostly the same, but I don't know if they're the same enough to look the same.

0:47:53And a lot of what people are calling, hey, now the iPad in iPad OS 26 is a lot more like the Mac.

0:48:01It is a lot more Mac.

0:48:02They're using Mac-like to mean desktop computer, which is that it has these wider general principles that even do admittedly predate the Mac.

0:48:13And that the Mac borrowed from Xerox marks, which is the metaphor for multiple things on screen at once, whether they be multiple documents within one app or multiple windows from different apps that are visual at the same time, visualized and visible at the same time.

0:48:37And it's a powerful metaphor, and it's so obvious.

0:48:40It's one of those things that seems so obvious that it's hard to remember that it had to be invented and seemed novel at one time.

0:48:46But the whole concept of having an application menu with commands like file, edit, view, and then you click on the menu and you can pull down and you get these menu commands.

0:48:57That's just a graphical user interface desktop idiom.

0:49:01And the fact that the iPad didn't even have it at all was the thing that was more frustrating, angering even at times than the fact that it wasn't exactly like the Mac or that whole argument that people will make till the end of time that they should just make macOS run on iPads or vice versa or merge them into one and magically make everybody happy, which is the magic part.

0:49:31But there is like a frustration like, hey, like when iPadOS came up with that heads-up display, when you'd hold that, if you had a hardware keyboard connected in some way, Bluetooth or like a keyboard case, and you held down the command key, you'd get this heads-up display that showed all the commands that were available and the shortcuts, but in a heads-up display instead of in a menu bar.

0:49:54But then if you didn't have a keyboard connected, there was no way to bring that up.

0:49:59And so, yes, of course, you don't need keyboard shortcuts because you don't have a keyboard installed.

0:50:03But what about just showing me the commands that are available?

0:50:06Like, we have this.

0:50:08And so, like, when you sit down in a restaurant and you've never been there before or maybe you haven't been there in a while or maybe you just don't know what to have, what do you look at to decide what to have?

0:50:19The menu.

0:50:20That's what a menu is.

0:50:22It is, here's the things that are available, right?

0:50:25It is a fantastic metaphor for computing.

0:50:30And it really was a novelty when the Mac made it, like, to the mainstream.

0:50:34Like, instead of having to have a book next to your computer to look up how to do things, everything that was available as a command in the current context was available at the top of the screen in a menu bar, organized by categories, and then you could read them.

0:50:50You could read the menu and see what's available.

0:50:54And the iPad had the complexity in its applications to need a menu and didn't have one.

0:51:01It would make you pull your hair out.

0:51:04And now they do, but I still don't know that it's great.

0:51:07And then it goes away if you're not in the advanced mode, right?

0:51:11It's like you just don't have problems like that on the Mac.

0:51:16You could be a typical user who never looks at the menu bar, who just sort of uses the Mail app and Safari or Chrome and the Messages app to send messages.

0:51:26And you don't really use many apps, and you don't really – a lot of users never go to the menu bar.

0:51:31But if they ever do need something up there, they can, like, watch a video or read the search results for how do I do this.

0:51:38And it says go up here to file, go down to this, click that, and then in the next thing that opens up, click this.

0:51:44You can't do that on iPad if you don't have the advanced mode on.

0:51:48Correct.

0:51:48And there is the expectation once you've done that once or twice on the Mac that you're likely to have to interface with the menu bar in the future.

0:51:56And so if you go, oh, I don't really know how to do this, you poke around the menu bar.

0:51:59And or you go to the help menu and you try to make a search term.

0:52:02People are not used to doing that on the iPad, and so some apps – this is where it gets even more complicated.

0:52:08Some of the more sophisticated apps that did have a bunch of those keyboard shortcuts and have had keyboard shortcuts for years, they're getting updated now.

0:52:16But for a while, and still some that I can think of today, there are apps that are not updated.

0:52:20And so it puts every single keyboard shortcut that's been supported on the iPad for three, four years in that iPadOS app all in the file menu.

0:52:27So you go up to file, and it's just a bunch of random crap that should not all be in the file menu.

0:52:33There should be different menu apps, but they're not in there.

0:52:35It's not supported.

0:52:36And then conversely, there are some things that can only be done inside of the window because they expect most users to never interface with the menu bar or the menu bar has never been there.

0:52:48So the iPad apps are built around this idea that, well, everything is accessible through the interface.

0:52:53But now some things aren't, but I can't think of, honestly, a single app, not even Final Cut Pro, which is made by Apple, where there is a function on iPadOS that must be performed through the menu bar.

0:53:05It can all be done in the app.

0:53:07And so the menu bar is almost like this little extra if you know about it.

0:53:10But that by nature makes it so that most of the commands are not placed in there logically or in an area where you'll have to interface with them because, well, you'll just do it with your finger on the iPad because sometimes you don't have the menu bar there.

0:53:23So that's one major issue.

0:53:26And then the other issue that I think is the most breaking about this new windowing environment, there are exceptions, and some I will admit from Apple.

0:53:35Like I just realized that iMessage on the Mac, you can't press Shift-Command-N to open a new window.

0:53:40There's only one windowed instance of iMessage allowed.

0:53:44But that's pretty atypical.

0:53:46On the Mac in general, you can press Shift-Command-N and a new window will open in that same app that you're in.

0:53:52One example that I can think of that I use with Frequency on the Mac, and it makes me so annoyed every time I have to use it.

0:53:57I have a Bamboo Lab 3D printer, and their desktop app is clearly ported from a multi-platform kind of app building environment.

0:54:05And so anytime you open, there is a new window function inside the app.

0:54:09But anytime you do Shift-Command-N, it opens a whole secondary instance of the app.

0:54:14So it just runs another version of the app in macOS.

0:54:18The iPad has supported windowing for a number of years, once again, but the number of apps that used it was so, so few that it's not habitual or second nature to just go, oh, I'll just open up a new window.

0:54:34And many apps, most apps still do not support it.

0:54:38And so when you're inside of the new windowing environment, or particularly when you're using the windowing environment inside of Stage Manager, which is how I prefer to use it, because while I hate Stage Manager on the Mac, I think that your real estate is so limited on the iPad that it's really great.

0:54:51It just rips apps out of your stages if you can't have multiple instances of that app.

0:54:57So you can have a Safari window in every single stage, but if I'm in another app and I'm in another stage where an app is open in another stage, as soon as I request the app, it just rips it out of that stage and pulls it into the stage that I'm in presently.

0:55:10And so you get this weird kind of amalgamation of some things that are windowed apps that cannot have multiple instances, some that can have multiple windows, but not multiple instances, some apps that can be open across multiple stages performing different functions.

0:55:27And so it's this, and again, I think it'll get better, but this is part of you kind of get what you deserve.

0:55:35Apple's had so many different windowing modalities in iPadOS over the last four or five years that until there's been this expectation over a few years of, oh, well, this is how an iPad app works, it's kind of just a mess because you've got every app doing something different over every version of iPadOS, which it has supported.

0:55:53And the reality is, I think there's so few people that want to do this anyway, because the iPad has so few pro users that I wouldn't be surprised if then in a few years stuff is still broken and certain apps still don't work well and certain apps go, well, we're never adopting the menu bar because our usage, our analytics detect that almost nobody uses it anyway.

0:56:15Whereas with the Mac, it might not be the best way to do stuff, but that's just the way that it is because the iPad, because the Mac has been the same way forever.

0:56:23So, yeah, there's an interesting contrast is with the notes app, Apple notes, and Apple notes can do more things than notes on iOS, right?

0:56:37And iPad, but yet it's not in a way, though, that makes you don't wind up with, oh, well, that's this note in Apple notes can only be visible on the Mac.

0:56:49It's it's just like a sort of convenience features, but to create notes that are cross platform, same way that the iPad can make pencil drawings in an Apple note that you can't create because the pencil only works on iPad.

0:57:06iPad, but you can still view the note in the other app.

0:57:08But when you just look at the main window of Apple notes, you don't see that complexity.

0:57:15It actually looks like it exposes about or maybe the exact by default same set of features that are on the iPad.

0:57:22You have to go to the menu bar to see the extra features that you can get because of AppKit and stuff like that.

0:57:29But there are ways, though, that even Apple has grown.

0:57:31I don't want to say lazy, but I think it's more like incoherent.

0:57:35So another app that is in a certain fundamental level, like a lot like notes and I've just oh, yeah, yeah, there's like three columns.

0:57:44One is the folders.

0:57:45One's the list of items in the folder.

0:57:47And then you go to the right and it's the detail view of the one you have selected.

0:57:52And Apple mail is a lot like Apple notes, right?

0:57:56There's the mailboxes, then the messages in a mailbox and then the message that you've selected.

0:58:01And then Apple notes, you've got folders and then the notes in the folder that you've selected and a note.

0:58:07But Apple mail has long had the ability to open up more than one viewer window, like the main window.

0:58:14And I tell this to people, there's probably going to be a bunch of people listening to the podcast who are like, you can do what?

0:58:19And you go up to in mail, go to file and the second item down new viewer window.

0:58:25And it opens an entirely new main window for mail.

0:58:29So you could have two main windows and it's not like having two instances of the app.

0:58:34It's just two of the main window.

0:58:36And so if you've got like a work account and a personal account, you could keep both windows open on two different accounts and have the full thing or open three of them or four of them or five or six.

0:58:50Now, you know, at that point, I think you should start closing your mail windows, but there's no limit on it.

0:58:56And it is tricky and it makes a hard, you know, I know from working on apps myself and having developer friend app who make apps like Net Newswire, my friend Brent makes.

0:59:06It only has one main window.

0:59:07It's a choice, though.

0:59:10And I don't think it makes sense for notes to be limited this way.

0:59:13I think it does for Net Newswire to not have a second main window.

0:59:17But why doesn't notes have that?

0:59:19But the fact that mail does shows something that's possible.

0:59:22And it is the sort of thinking that just never occurs to the makers of iPad apps.

0:59:26Right.

0:59:26And one of the nice things about the Mac, too, is because the Mac is the Mac and because it has this established expectation of being open

0:59:35and having the ability to make modifications.

0:59:37I mean, in the quite literal example of Apple Notes, there's like Pro Notes and Notes Commander.

0:59:43There are third-party apps that add a ton of really useful functionality to notes, markdown and templates and inline calculations and slash commands like you'd get in Notion.

0:59:53And then you move over to the iPad and that paradigm is gone because, of course, there are no apps that can run in the background or on top of other existing applications.

1:00:02And so it's just yet another area.

1:00:04The hardware is the same, but the software experience is just isn't.

1:00:08Or better.

1:00:09Yeah, or better.

1:00:10Right.

1:00:10And that's kind of the line that I said at the end of my videos.

1:00:15I said, I've made peace with the fact a $2,000 computer can't do some of the things that I need my $700 MacBook Air for.

1:00:22And I still need to go use my $700 MacBook Air sometimes.

1:00:25And I'm okay with that.

1:00:26But I also understand why most most people aren't.

1:00:29Yeah.

1:00:30And my hope for the iPad is that this is just the breakthrough year where they erased a bunch of their own previous self-imposed rules.

1:00:41Like they clearly imposed on themselves at Apple a rule that we're not going to have not Mac-style windows, but desktop computing-style windows.

1:00:53We're just not going to have these overlapping rectangles on screen at the same time.

1:00:58And we're not going to call it.

1:00:59They even went out of their way, bent over backwards as it, before iPadOS 26, as it got more window-like in the interface, they still didn't call them windows a lot of the time.

1:01:11Right?

1:01:11I have a friend who pointed out that Apple's own documentation for Stage Manager goes out of its way.

1:01:19It does talk about windows sometimes, but it goes out of its way to avoid using it if it can.

1:01:26When if they just called them windows, it would be so much easier to understand and might make the design of the system more easily understandable.

1:01:33But I feel like they were like, okay, fine.

1:01:36We give in.

1:01:36We tried this.

1:01:37And it was a noble thing to try to just move away from the paradigm of overlapping rectangular windows.

1:01:43But okay, we tried.

1:01:44We didn't come up with something better.

1:01:46Let's go with windows.

1:01:49And this is just the first year.

1:01:52And that they can continue moving forward.

1:01:54And now that there's a different team in charge of user interface design at Apple, you know, that they can rectify and unify some of this.

1:02:02Because I also feel like some of the remaining incoherency in iPadOS 26 is the fact that Stage Manager predates this.

1:02:09Right.

1:02:09It was like their last ditch attempt to not have desktop style windows.

1:02:15Right.

1:02:16And they gave in.

1:02:17They added desktop style windows.

1:02:18And you can use them without Stage Manager and iPadOS 26.

1:02:22But Stage Manager is also still there.

1:02:24Yep.

1:02:24And I feel like there's some conceptual unification to be had there that they haven't even tried yet.

1:02:32Yeah.

1:02:33So we shall see.

1:02:34All right.

1:02:35Let me take a break here and thank our second sponsor of the show.

1:02:40And it is our good friends at Squarespace.

1:02:43Squarespace is the all-in-one platform where you can build your website, your web presence, from soup to nuts, everything from registering domain name to picking a design template to modifying the template through WYSIWYG, drag and drop the old-fashioned way,

1:03:04or through AI prompts with Squarespace's new AI design tools, what they call design intelligence, mix and match the methods you want to use to customize.

1:03:15It's all there, all built into their award-winning platform with absolutely excellent, top-notch technical support when you need it.

1:03:27It is designed to be intuitive, to be understandable by non-technical users, people who think to themselves, I can't build a website.

1:03:35I don't know anything about building a website.

1:03:38This is like in the same way that anybody can make a spreadsheet and that anybody can make a word processing document.

1:03:46Anybody can make a website, an entire website with Squarespace.

1:03:50It is meant to be that easy to use.

1:03:51It has hooks and features for technically adept users who want to get in and modify actual source code and actually do their own CSS or actually modify their own JavaScript if you want.

1:04:02But if you don't, just ignore all of that.

1:04:06Use it WYSIWYG style, AI style, whichever way you want.

1:04:09They've got all of the features.

1:04:11Squarespace payments is their easy-to-use way to manage payments in one place with Squarespace.

1:04:16They have invoices and invoicing, so if you're a consultant or otherwise offer services and you need to offer invoices to clients or customers, you can do that through Squarespace.

1:04:26They get the invoice in a link that opens on your website, and then it can pay right there through Squarespace payments.

1:04:33So everything from every aspect of invoicing, creating, sending, having the customer or client see it and pay it, which is, of course, the key step.

1:04:43As anybody who ever sends invoices know, all built in to Squarespace.

1:04:48Blueprint AI, you can start a fully custom on-brand website with Squarespace's latest AI-enhanced website builder, Blueprint AI.

1:04:57It prompts you with a few questions, and their interactive design system transforms basic information about your brand and business into an elevated online presence.

1:05:06All built in.

1:05:08Analytics built in.

1:05:09It just keeps going.

1:05:10Where do you go to find out more?

1:05:12Go to squarespace.com slash talk show.

1:05:15Squarespace.com slash talk show.

1:05:17You get a free trial for up to 30 days.

1:05:20No limits.

1:05:20No watermarks.

1:05:21Build your whole website.

1:05:23And at the end of the 30 days, go back to squarespace.com slash talk show.

1:05:28Use that code talk show.

1:05:29You save 10% off your first payment just by using that code.

1:05:34You could prepay for a whole year.

1:05:36Whole year save 10% squarespace.com slash talk show.

1:05:41All right.

1:05:42So I loved, I loved your iPad video too, as why we just spend an hour talking about it.

1:05:49But your, all right, let me get the title right.

1:05:51Apple is falling apart.

1:05:53Parentheses on purpose.

1:05:57Thank you.

1:05:58Thank you, Quinn.

1:05:59And I saw some of your screenshots when you did the thing I mentioned of, oh, here come all the headlines and all the hot takes on social media.

1:06:07And I saw you on threads arguing with a few people from the, hey, what's going on at Apple?

1:06:15Has Tim Cook lost his mind?

1:06:16The company seems to be falling apart.

1:06:18They've lost their whole executive suite.

1:06:20No.

1:06:21Not quite.

1:06:22So let's put them into buckets.

1:06:26We already mentioned Alan Dye.

1:06:27Alan Dye is a major exit.

1:06:29It's a surprise to Apple.

1:06:32As you pointed out in the video, the proof, all the proof we need is the starring role he had at WWDC in the keynote to introduce liquid glass.

1:06:41And by, through Mark Gurman's reporting on his departure for Meta, I think the euphemistic description is that Apple executives had been bracing for it for days.

1:06:52I believe that news came out on a Wednesday morning.

1:06:56And I believe, I am to understand that the days was one day when Apple found out about it.

1:07:03Maybe there was an inkling.

1:07:05Maybe there was, hey, what's going on with Alan?

1:07:07Maybe a few days in advance.

1:07:09But I think that Apple's executives found out Tuesday for sure that he was leaving for Meta.

1:07:14That's one.

1:07:15We can talk about that.

1:07:16And I think it's the most interesting to talk about.

1:07:19Then there is the departure that wasn't.

1:07:23Yeah.

1:07:24Johnny Saruji.

1:07:25Johnny Saruji.

1:07:25Right.

1:07:26Where at the end of this week, it was, and it's all happened in one week, which was, does create, from a casual person's perspective, the illusion of a mass exodus.

1:07:36At the end of the week, which would have been the, if true, would have been the biggest and most problematic exit for Apple.

1:07:43Yep.

1:07:44That Gurman reported on a Saturday that Saruji had told Tim Cook he was unhappy at Apple with nothing in the story describing what he was unhappy about.

1:07:54Didn't even allude to whether he was unhappy with the direction of Apple Silicon, what he was being told to work on.

1:08:00Was he bored?

1:08:01Was he unhappy with his pay?

1:08:04Was he unhappy with his stature within the company?

1:08:07Was he unhappy that with the reports that with Cook apparently at the age of 65 preparing to step down as CEO, unsurprisingly, maybe in the next year, that Saruji wasn't named?

1:08:20Did he want to be the next CEO?

1:08:21And now he's mad because it's apparently, by multiple reporting, going to be John Ternus.

1:08:26None of that was in there.

1:08:28He just said he's unhappy at Apple and that if he, and thinking about leaving, and if he does leave, he would not retire.

1:08:34He would go to work at a competitor.

1:08:35And then on Monday morning, Saruji put out a memo that was obviously meant to leak, and they knew it would leak to his team saying, in effect, I mean, I could quote it, but I'm happy.

1:08:48I'm proud of our work.

1:08:49I'm delighted in my job at Apple, and I'm not going anywhere.

1:08:52Yeah, the end of the quote, particularly, I believe, was, I have no plans to leave anytime soon.

1:08:58All right.

1:08:59Yes, which is a very good way to put it publicly.

1:09:03Who else?

1:09:04Oh, well, Jeff Williams, whose retirement was announced in the summer with a six-month sort of ramp down, and then that came to pass in November, and now he's gone.

1:09:16Long-time COO, sort of Tim Cook, mini Tim, except he's actually taller than Tim.

1:09:23He's actually, he doesn't look at, he's like, Jeff Williams is one of those guys who, on video, doesn't, you don't think he's strikingly tall, but I think he's 6'5".

1:09:34He's quite tall.

1:09:35He's gone.

1:09:36Lisa Jackson, long-time environmental chief at Apple, retiring in her, I think, early 60s.

1:09:4463.

1:09:46Yep.

1:09:46The chief lawyer, chief legal counsel, Kate Adams.

1:09:51Kate Adams.

1:09:51Yep.

1:09:51And as you pointed out, she'd been there nine years, which is-

1:09:55Nine years.

1:09:55Longer than average.

1:09:56Industry average is seven years.

1:09:58She was there nine years, which is the same, is actually slightly longer than any other chief legal officer since Jobs has returned to Apple.

1:10:06So in 25 years.

1:10:08And then same with Lisa Jackson was there for 12 years.

1:10:11They've both been there forever.

1:10:12They're at retirement age.

1:10:14None of that's surprising.

1:10:15That's just normal.

1:10:16I think the only reason it was perceivably freaky was that it was amongst this Alan Dye stuff, and then it was also the same week that John Gianandrea kind of officially had his step away, too.

1:10:28So I guess I spoiled it.

1:10:29He's the last one.

1:10:30Right.

1:10:30Right.

1:10:31And it's different than the others, right?

1:10:34It's almost like he's like putting all the others aside.

1:10:38He's sort of the opposite of the Suruji story, right, where Suruji is incredibly, by all accounts, incredibly competent.

1:10:46Has Apple on top of the industry in what he supervises, right?

1:10:51Their phone chips, their desktop computing chips, the whole transition from Intel to Apple Silicon on the Mac was more.

1:11:02Every one of Apple's transitions for the Mac over the last 40 years have been surprisingly seamless for something that is technically very difficult.

1:11:10But this one took the cake in terms of if you didn't know anything, all you know is your computer is thinner, cooler, and the battery lasts seemingly impossibly long.

1:11:22But it wasn't true, didn't leave, and he does a great job, and it seems like that would be a problem if he surprised Apple by up and leaving.

1:11:32And G. Andrea was in charge of an area where Apple is famously, infamously behind all of its peers, AI, I think, and from a general customer level.

1:11:46Just somebody who's never heard of John G. Andrea doesn't know me as J.G., doesn't know him as J.G., doesn't know anybody whose initials are J.G.

1:11:55All they know is that when they talk to Siri, it is frustrating and stupid and incompetent.

1:12:01Well, that was his domain, and it went from bad to worse, I would say, in the Apple intelligence era, as my big baby of 2025 was the Something is Rotten in the State of Cupertino piece I wrote in February, March, whenever that was.

1:12:20Which I think has, was considered very well, and I think was taken very well by my readership outside of Cupertino, and I think taken very well within a certain level of employees within Cupertino, and then as you went up the pyramid of-

1:12:38Yeah, maybe not at the tippy top.

1:12:39Yeah, maybe, maybe not at the tippy top.

1:12:42But I think has aged extremely well as the year went on, and I really do think, I think it's a leadership difference between Tim Cook and Steve Jobs that under Cook, he, I don't know if it was a gentleman's thing for John G. Andrea himself,

1:13:04Or if it's from Tim Cook's perspective, protecting Apple institutionally from looking bad.

1:13:12But I think, I have no sources on this, this is just my read as a Cupertino-ologist, is, I think G. Andrea was out the moment that Gurman first reported, hey, that advanced Siri shit that they talked about at WWDC, that's going to be delayed.

1:13:32And he started reporting that in January or February, before Apple announced the delay.

1:13:38It was more or less the come-to-Jesus moment where they're like, hey, we said in June we're going to ship this.

1:13:45If we're going to ship it this year, it's kind of got to be now, because the next WWDC is coming.

1:13:50And they were like, where are we?

1:13:52Where are we at with this?

1:13:54And I think they looked at it, and I don't know who, again, stuff like this doesn't leak out of Apple, even Gurman doesn't get it.

1:14:00Which people within Apple were like, I don't know, I think maybe we could ship what we have.

1:14:04And which people were like, are you kidding?

1:14:06This is complete garbage.

1:14:07Like, we can't even, this model isn't even usable.

1:14:10It's not just that the feature isn't quite ready.

1:14:12We have to throw out the entire model that we were thinking we were going to use.

1:14:16Which they, by all accounts, have done since then, right?

1:14:19There's the whole thing that they're talking about, which still isn't announced here at the end of December.

1:14:24But the whole idea that they're going to license from Google Gemini to use on a white label basis to use as the model for these features.

1:14:34Well, that wasn't the plan in March when they announced the delay.

1:14:39And it certainly wasn't the plan at WWDC 2024 when they said this will be coming within the next year.

1:14:45Right.

1:14:46That they were going to use Google Gemini.

1:14:47They were going to use their own model.

1:14:49When a push came to shove, they're like, we have to throw this out.

1:14:52I think at that point, John G.

1:14:55And Cook was like, okay, that's it.

1:14:56He's gone.

1:14:57But rather than announce it or fire him, it was like, we'll let him hang on until the end of the year.

1:15:02And kind of when this all dies down, save as much face as possible and announce his retirement.

1:15:09Yeah.

1:15:10And who knows what the, I mean, it could be that he had an operating or contractual agreement with Apple that they would say,

1:15:19nice things about him if it weren't to work out.

1:15:20I mean, he was a, people might forget, he was a massive aqua hire from Google.

1:15:25Yes.

1:15:26So he was a phenom at Google.

1:15:28And by all respects, from a research standpoint, is one of the most important people in the entire field.

1:15:34It just would seem that either he wasn't a good organizational fit for Apple or he lacked the organizational oversight that would be required to make this thing happen.

1:15:45I mean, who's to really say and know.

1:15:47But I think that all of that stuff happened early this year.

1:15:51And then there was the massive kind of report from the information, which Apple has spent not an inconsiderable amount of time attempting to dispute, which is atypical for them.

1:16:02They usually just say nothing when stuff like this happens.

1:16:05But they did, they did come out and say, not all of that is accurate.

1:16:07There's some miss.

1:16:08But the kind of story told through that was that JG was brought on.

1:16:15Craig Federighi in particular was not bullish on AI and kind of thought it was a waste of time.

1:16:22JG was relegated to kind of research stuff.

1:16:24They were trying to change and improve Siri based on the existing model, the transformer model that Siri had been built on.

1:16:32And then when OpenAI came out with ChatGPT, that's apparently what changed everything for JG's team.

1:16:38But then Craig Federighi still was allegedly bullish on it for a few months until he tried it and then thought, holy crap, we need to get on this.

1:16:47And then that's where the disputes internally were alleged to have happened, where there were multiple development tracks because Federighi's team thought that Gian Andres' team was ineffectual.

1:16:58And so they started developing their own AI team, parallel tracks.

1:17:03And yeah, well, and then allegedly, and the last thing, and again, this is all circumstantial.

1:17:08Who knows if this is all accurate?

1:17:10But the last kind of nail in the coffin report was that JG wasn't able to get the hardware that he had requested and needed, the GPUs particularly, in order to build out that model set because everything was said to happen on device.

1:17:26And then, and it does seem a bit funny.

1:17:29If you go back and watch WWDC, and particularly the talk show episode, when you had them on from a couple of years ago, you look at what they, yeah, you look at what they said would be coming relative to where LLMs and AI is now.

1:17:45And you're like, I don't even know how that, how the local, that wouldn't even have happened.

1:17:52It's just the way that everything has changed, even in just the last 18 months, makes it such that the statements that they were making two years ago, then would have been aspirational, if not completely effectual.

1:18:05And now it just seems that's not even doable.

1:18:09And that's, that's where I think we're coming to this, this axis where they're, they're in discussions with Google, because what do you even do?

1:18:15They're so far behind in the, the, what they had promised would come is so not going to happen in the way that they said it would, that they've got to do something.

1:18:24But if they're not, if they're not, if the deal's not even done yet, how long is it going to be until we as consumers see something that's shippable next year?

1:18:32Maybe, I don't know, but boy.

1:18:34Yeah.

1:18:35But that all falls down on JG.

1:18:36So his departure is completely unsurprising.

1:18:39And I think the only thing that surprised maybe some people is that Apple's press release spoke quite highly of him and said that he's capable and he's going to stay at Apple and some kind of non-administrative capacity until he retires next year.

1:18:54And, and I think this is probably mostly comes down to optics and then to maybe some kind of operating agreement where, yeah, but, but, but, well, it seems, it seemed hard for them to want to say.

1:19:06Yeah.

1:19:08And the Lisa Jackson, Kate Adams press release a couple of days later, and it seemed a lot more, man, they'd done great work and we're glad there, you know, we wish them the best.

1:19:17And yeah, absolute legends in Apple history.

1:19:20I know that's exaggeration, but do you remember Mark Papermaster?

1:19:24The name Mark Papermaster.

1:19:27I'll put these links in the show notes.

1:19:28I swear.

1:19:29This was August, 2010.

1:19:32Now, Steve Jobs was still the CEO.

1:19:34Mark Papermaster was an Apple executive in charge of hardware for the company's iPhone.

1:19:39And after the iPhone 4 and Antenagate, which broke as the, the, the, the iPhone 4 came at the end of June or middle of June.

1:19:49And then it was July where the Antenagate scandal, whatever you want to call it, which I think was overblown.

1:19:56I, I firm, I did not just think, I know it was overblown.

1:19:59It was a real issue where there was a, a, a, a defect, not a defect, but a, a unwanted, one of the trade-offs with the design was that the one, if your skin get, bridge the gap between two parts of the external antenna, that it would attenuate the signal of the antenna.

1:20:23And famously, Jobs told people before they just broke down and had a special press conference, you're holding it wrong, right?

1:20:29People still remember that.

1:20:30That's where you're holding it wrong comes from.

1:20:32Just don't, don't have, and some people's skin, because of the nature of their oils, didn't make it happen.

1:20:37You could put a case on the phone or the bumper, whatever.

1:20:41But the reason I say that it's almost provable that it was a non-issue was that the iPhone 4 was the leading iPhone for the longest amount of time of any iPhone, because it was the last one that was released in June.

1:20:53The iPhone 4S was the first one to come out on the modern schedule of September or October.

1:20:59I think it was October, because that also was the first one that came out after, or right before Steve Jobs had died, but right around the time of his death.

1:21:09But it was, so it was the leading iPhone for over a year, not under a year.

1:21:14And it was the first one that the Verizon iPhone came out.

1:21:17And the Verizon iPhone, because it was actually a totally different antenna technology, CDMA versus, what was the other one called, Quinn?

1:21:24GSM, which was AT&T's.

1:21:26They'd already fixed it.

1:21:27So the Verizon iPhone 4 didn't even have the problem.

1:21:30But anyway, the AntennaGate scandal broke July 23rd.

1:21:35They had the special press conference on August 7th.

1:21:39So two weeks later, Apple fired Mark Papermaster.

1:21:42And I'm quoting from my own reporting.

1:21:46Thank God I reported it, because I've forgotten this.

1:21:48But I have a source inside Apple, who back on July 23rd at the AntennaGate conference, described to me that this is, and two weeks before they fired him, said, Papermaster is, quote, the guy responsible for the antenna.

1:22:02Well, two weeks later, he was out of the company.

1:22:05Right.

1:22:06And I don't know what kind of agreement he signed.

1:22:08I don't know what he walked away with.

1:22:09I'm sure once you get to that level, everybody gets some kind of nice truckload of money as they leave the company.

1:22:16Yeah.

1:22:16So I don't think that the JG got to stay on until December because of a contract.

1:22:22I think it's just Tim Cook style.

1:22:25Like, why make a scene about this?

1:22:27Yeah, that's fair.

1:22:28He's definitely not jobs in that regard.

1:22:30Let's save.

1:22:31And he'll take it on the chin.

1:22:33And if people come away thinking Tim Cook is indecisive personally because they couldn't even fire John Giandrea after they had to delay the single biggest announcement they'd made in years for over a year and clearly go back to ground zero and maybe even license from another company the core technology behind it.

1:22:56Right.

1:22:56There's the whole part that Federighi's team was supposed to work on, which is the interface to the more personal Apple intelligence.

1:23:03But the underlying technology was clearly JG's.

1:23:06I mean, that's not insinuation.

1:23:08I mean, that was his job.

1:23:10Totally.

1:23:11It obviously didn't work.

1:23:14Right.

1:23:14And I don't think that the whole story, it sounds to me like an excuse.

1:23:19The Luca Maestri, the CFO, was like, hey, we're not going to give you as much money as you want for server hardware or whatever.

1:23:25Does it seem to anybody, does it seem to you, Quinn, that the problem with Apple's internal AI technology was that they didn't throw enough money at it, at the hardware?

1:23:35I don't think so.

1:23:36I think if there's anything that could be said, it's that if there's any problems outside of JG's realm directly, I could perceivably identify maybe that Apple, because this kind of early AI stuff.

1:23:53Well, first of all, opening, I kind of came out of nowhere, but then even after that, whether there was a little bit of delay to determine how important or how much market demand there was for it, or whether or not that was something Apple would be interested in, and whether it was counter to the way that culturally they've operated, I could see that maybe being the case.

1:24:11And then the other thing that I can maybe see being one of the reasons for which I think it's still ultimately JG's fault, but over years, there has been quite a bit of extensive reporting.

1:24:22And again, maybe this is not true, but it's been said for quite some time, so I have the tendency to believe that it is, that Tim's administrative style amongst his C-suite is, don't come to me with problems.

1:24:34Just figure it out on your own.

1:24:36That's why you're here.

1:24:37I shouldn't have to deal with your crap.

1:24:39And so JG and Craig, I could maybe see a situation where they're trying to work through who's going to do what and for what, and it just takes too much time, and I don't know.

1:24:50But yeah, those are the only things that I can think of that don't pretty much squarely fall on JG as being the problem, you know?

1:24:59There's also the report, and I think this is central to it, too.

1:25:04I think it's from the information.

1:25:05It might have also come from other places, too, but that there's not just one branch of, quote, AI, right?

1:25:12And the whole LLM, large language model thing, wasn't John G.

1:25:17Andrea's core competency.

1:25:19And apparently, he was dismissive of it overall, as a lot of AI researchers in other fields were.

1:25:26And there's this whole – I think the term is hill climbing that is the lingo within the field that JG was more an endorsement of.

1:25:36And it's sort of like maybe like classic – it's not quite disruptor theory, but it's sort of like the way disruptive technologies come, where the entrenched whatever thinks, oh, this is cute, right?

1:25:50Isn't that cute, that little toy?

1:25:51And then it grows and eats the whole industry, right?

1:25:54That's what PCs – that's what x86 hardware did to server-specific hardware like Sun Microsystems, right?

1:26:00People used to buy $30,000 web servers from Sun.

1:26:05And then Google built out its entire infrastructure with consumer-grade x86 hardware that costs like 10 times less per server or more less and just built a system.

1:26:18And they're like, well, that type of hardware isn't as dependable.

1:26:22And they're like, well, we just built an architecture where individual servers can fail and it doesn't matter.

1:26:26And they're like, huh, well, that's pretty interesting.

1:26:28And now that's the way the whole world works.

1:26:31I think that the JGs of the AI field were like – who were outside the LLM thing were like, well, that's cute.

1:26:38And, yes, it's a neat trick, but that's not actual AI and that's not going to be the future and whatever.

1:26:44And famously, multiple sources have reported that he was not a fan of chatbots and thought chatbots were not a good interface to AI.

1:26:53And I'm not even saying that –

1:26:56I was going to say, by contrast, it's reported that Federici tried them and was like, no, this is – we've got to do this.

1:27:01Yeah, because look what you can do.

1:27:02Look what you can do with a chatbot, right?

1:27:05And I'm not saying – I still don't think Apple will or should ever come out with a chatbot of its own, right?

1:27:12They might.

1:27:14They could.

1:27:15But I don't think they need to.

1:27:17In the same way that Apple – I love – I'll stick with the analogy that Apple still to this day dominates the graphic design industry and desktop publishing without making any of the primary software that people use for desktop publishing.

1:27:33They don't make the page layout program.

1:27:34They don't make Photoshop.

1:27:35Yes, there's the whole question one year after the acquisition, what are they going to do with Photomator or, as I like to call it, Photomator.

1:27:42But for the most part, they never made the software.

1:27:45It kept the company alive in the lean years of the 90s and they didn't make it.

1:27:48In the same way, what are the devices that most people use chat GPT on?

1:27:53They use them on iPhones.

1:27:54They use them on Macs.

1:27:56That's a good place to be.

1:27:58It's the most popular app of the year on iOS last year was chat GPT.

1:28:04People use their iPhones for it.

1:28:06And it's chat GPT who's building out like a trillion dollars of server architecture to serve it.

1:28:14There is the possibility that Apple is going to get the latest Google Gemini model white labeled for Apple intelligence for the paltry sum of a billion dollars a year when Google's already paying them like 25 billion a year for the ads.

1:28:31So it's like, how about instead of 25 billion next year, you pay us 24 billion and we get Gemini for free and Google's short.

1:28:36And so there's a there's a path forward where Apple doesn't need to provide it on its own.

1:28:42But the attitude that chat bots are a bad interface for AI, that's a problem.

1:28:46It doesn't mean Apple had to do it, but it's very clear.

1:28:49And that apparently was the come to Jesus moment for Federighi was that he like over the winter break two or three, three or four years ago or whatever was like, I'm going to try this chat GPT thing.

1:28:59Everybody's talking about and really dug into it and was like, whoa, this is amazing because it is.

1:29:04It's amazing.

1:29:04Anybody who's really dug into any of these chat bots, whether Claude or chat GPT or even Grok is amazing in certain ways.

1:29:12They do amazing things and there's problems with how they were trained.

1:29:16There's problems with the hallucinations in their output.

1:29:18There's probably certainly massive problems with blindly trusting their output.

1:29:22Write me write a term paper on this book.

1:29:25Copy, select all copy, put my name at the top, paste.

1:29:29You're probably in trouble, kid.

1:29:31Right.

1:29:32Oh, yeah.

1:29:32But helping you with it and supervising it and correcting it, you're going to get incredible results.

1:29:40But I kind of the other thing, too, and I want to go back to it before I forget, was the whole story about, well, A, we know.

1:29:48It's been announced that Mike Rockwell, who's moved from the Vision Pro team to take over under Craig Federighi, the AI consumer facing stuff.

1:30:00Again, that to me is the proof that JG was actually – Cook made his decision and he was out at that point.

1:30:06It made no sense.

1:30:07I kind of thought at the time, I bet they announced JG's exit before WWDC and that didn't come to pass.

1:30:13I think I just underestimated Tim Cook's patience and let's really let the embers on this fire burn out and cool before he – we officially part ways with him.

1:30:27But it makes no sense that he was still at Apple after the – Mike Rockwell is leaving the Vision Pro team to take over this plate of stuff.

1:30:37Well, then what was JG's in charge of?

1:30:38And Rockwell specifically, too.

1:30:40Right?

1:30:40Yeah.

1:30:41That's just like a euphemism.

1:30:44But there was also the report that while they were creating the Vision Pro that Rockwell wanted to have verbal commands for a lot of stuff because they were inventing this interface.

1:30:55And you've used Vision Pro.

1:30:56There's a lot of stuff where it is visual and you poke at it and you look at it and you make gestures to look at it.

1:31:03But there's a lot of stuff where maybe having visual verbal commands would really help because of the limited input or the different input and that they were so disgusted by the state of Syria at the time that they looked into building their own voice command AI system within Vision Pro, which is the way a lot of big companies work.

1:31:27There's that famous cartoon with the org charts at different tech companies, right?

1:31:32And like the Oracle one is like a whole legal arm and then a little bit of engineering off to the side.

1:31:38And the Apple one famously – this is what – the cartoon was made when Steve Jobs was still in charge.

1:31:43It's a circle, two levels of hierarchy deep around one person in the middle.

1:31:48And then there's Microsoft, which is a real neat pyramid, but all the points of the pyramid have guns pointed at the other parts of the company.

1:31:57So that's where, with the AI stuff, Apple was starting to look like, right?

1:32:02Where Rockwell's team was making its own AI, Federighi's team was making its own AI team.

1:32:09All of a sudden, there's three different AI teams, the one that's supposed to be the one for the whole company, one within Rockwell's team at Vision, one that Federighi was running to actually build stuff that might actually be worth shipping to customers.

1:32:21That's not Apple, right?

1:32:23That's a problem.

1:32:23I'd also think that it is very, very key – and I think it will parlay into the Alan Dye discussion, so put a thumbtack in that.

1:32:32But I do think – hey, I think Apple is getting its shit together on this whole AI front thing.

1:32:38And now this is pure 100% classic Anic data, where it's just my personal impression.

1:32:47I've had Rockwell on my live show twice, once back in, I think, 2018.

1:32:52Maybe it was 2019, 2018 or so.

1:32:54But when Apple first started building out the whole AR thing, and AR kit was a big deal at WWDC, they suggested Rockwell as a guest for my show.

1:33:06I was like, sure.

1:33:07And the song and dance of Apple's executives appearing on my show and who's going to be the special guest outside the regulars of, say, Jaws and Federighi is that Apple won't tell me, like, hey, this is – WWDC this year is all going to be about Apple intelligence.

1:33:25They didn't tell me that, right?

1:33:27But when they said, hey, we were thinking maybe Mike Rockwell would be a good guest this year, and this is obviously before the show, and then I don't ask extra questions.

1:33:38I just say, well, that sounds good to me, too, and I'll bet it'll make sense after I see the keynote.

1:33:42And then they say, yes, actually, it might make some sense after you see the keynote.

1:33:46And that's all that's said.

1:33:48And then that – it's – we both say it without saying it is the way it usually works.

1:33:55But I've met Rockwell twice then and then the year after Vision Pro was announced.

1:33:59And JG was on my show in 2024 after Apple Intelligence was announced.

1:34:05And my impression of them both from the onstage part that everybody can watch and just watch the videos and see, but also the backstage part, which isn't extensive.

1:34:16It's not like they get there super early.

1:34:18It's not like they stay super long after the show is just that he – Mike Rockwell seems like a very Apple-like executive in the way that Eddie Q is extremely Apple-like.

1:34:30The way that Phil Schiller is perhaps the purest, 100% unadulterated example of an Apple-like person and that Jaws is very Schiller-like in a lot of ways.

1:34:46JG did not seem like an Apple-like person at all.

1:34:50And, in fact, by the time I got offstage and I'm, like, thanking the audience and he had left, I went to thank him for being on the show and he was already gone.

1:35:01I mean, and you could watch the video and see how much longer I was onstage than JG and Jaws and Federighi, who were both still there and having a glass of water or a bottle of water or something or some other beverage backstage.

1:35:15And I could say thank you once again for doing this.

1:35:18Thanks.

1:35:18It was good to talk to you.

1:35:19That was a good show.

1:35:20Thank you.

1:35:20Thank you.

1:35:20JG was already gone.

1:35:21I don't think because he was unhappy with how the interview went.

1:35:24I just – it was just an awkward fellow.

1:35:27And Apple people tend not to be awkward people.

1:35:31And Mike Rockwell, on the other hand, very, very nice to meet and very – my off-the-record interactions with him.

1:35:36Not extensive, but very – ah, this guy gets it.

1:35:40This guy is very interesting.

1:35:41I do think there's also a sense – I get this all the time.

1:35:45I should talk about it.

1:35:46I'd love to hear your thoughts that, hey, wait, if Vision Pro is considered a bust, why is it good news that the Vision Pro guy is taking over Siri?

1:35:53What do you think?

1:35:55My take would maybe be that Vision Pro being a quote-unquote bust doesn't necessarily fall on Mike Rockwell.

1:36:02I think the reason it's a quote-unquote bust is because it's $3,500.

1:36:06If you use the Vision Pro and the operating system – Vision OS is unbelievably good.

1:36:13It's – for as much as I just complained about the iPad, the Vision Pro has none of that.

1:36:18Even though it still derives its own iOS, it does feel, while intuitive, entirely different than iOS and iPadOS.

1:36:29And so much of the interaction elements and so much of the UX is really polished and really well done.

1:36:35That doesn't mean that the app marketplace is doing well because it's totally not.

1:36:40That doesn't mean that the hardware is practical or accessible because it absolutely isn't.

1:36:44But Vision OS, which is much of what Rockwell was in charge of, is the best part about the Vision Pro.

1:36:50It's really well done.

1:36:52Yeah, I agree.

1:36:53And I keep making the analogy, and I'll stick with this one too, that it's a lot like the original Macintosh in 1984, which was – inflation adjusted $7,200.

1:37:04Or maybe more at this point because inflation keeps going up.

1:37:07But at least at the time that the Vision Pro shipped, from that point to 1984, it was like $7,200.

1:37:14So twice as much money, sold so poorly that it was the precipitating factor to the board chasing Steve Jobs out of the company.

1:37:21So like when kids today are like, hey, how did that ever happen where Apple ran Steve Jobs out of the company?

1:37:27Well, it was called the Macintosh.

1:37:28And it served – the basic concepts were so right that it served as the basis for what we still use today as the Mac.

1:37:38And it was too big, too heavy, too expensive because you think, well, it was just this tiny little computer.

1:37:44But the form factor that really made computers, desktop computers, popular is the laptop, right?

1:37:51And the Macintosh had a handle, and it had a bag you could buy for it and put it in a bag so you could take it with you.

1:37:57It's just that there was so – it's like, well, that's not really portable, right?

1:38:01But they had the right idea that it should be portable.

1:38:04It just was a long time ahead, and in the same way that the Vision Pro put the cost aside, it's too freaking big and heavy, right?

1:38:10It is.

1:38:11It's just too big and heavy.

1:38:12And it won't be too long where computers like that, whether they're Apple's future vision computers or if some other company does take the lead and define the form factor, they are not going to be big or heavy at all, right?

1:38:24Because nobody – in the same way that nobody wants a bigger, heavy, big, heavy, portable, quote-unquote, portable computer, nobody wants something that needs – you need to worry about what style of headband you have so that your neck doesn't hurt when you use it.

1:38:36But the –

1:38:37What your hair looks like when you take it off.

1:38:39Right.

1:38:40But, man, from building it from scratch, it is an amazing foundation for it going forward.

1:38:45And I think that's where Rockwell's would – it sounds – and it sounds to me like he wanted this job.

1:38:52It wasn't like, hey, Mike, here's a big pile of dog shit.

1:38:54You're taking the Siri job.

1:38:56I think he wanted this.

1:38:58I think he's been interested in it from when he was developing the Vision Pro seven years ago, that, hey, this is core technology that Apple should make good going forward.

1:39:08And I think he's very results-driven.

1:39:11I'll segue into talking about Alan Dye, which is the other common feedback I've gotten now that Alan Dye's left, and I'm dancing on his – not his grave because he's – thankfully, he's apparently in good health.

1:39:25And I certainly wish him a long and happy, healthy life.

1:39:28But dancing on his empty spot on Apple's executive page?

1:39:34Yeah, there you go.

1:39:35How can he be such a bum if Vision Pro has such a great and innovative interface?

1:39:41Didn't Alan Dye's team create that?

1:39:43And I don't know, and I've spent the last month trying to dig around and get more information about it, and if anybody listening has more information.

1:39:52But I get the impression that in the same way that Mike Rockwell wanted to build his own Siri, that they kind of built their own interface.

1:39:59And I'm sure people in Alan Dye's team had a role, but it was more in the what it looks like than what it works like aspect.

1:40:10What it works like and what the interactive concepts are.

1:40:14I don't think Alan Dye had anything to do with him, and I don't even think he knew – this is part of why I don't think he was ever suited for the job in the first place – is I don't even think Alan Dye knew that they had gone behind his back to create the whole Vision OS concept of a user experience.

1:40:33Because I think all he ever thought about is what it looks like, and then he got to say, oh, well, my team will make some icons and decide what the anti-aliasing will look like around the window edges or something like that.

1:40:45Purely aesthetic type stuff.

1:40:48Well, and the great irony in all of it, too, is I think that people who draw the conclusion that liquid glass has directly derived Vision OS haven't really spent much time in Vision OS.

1:40:59Vision OS does look similar.

1:41:02It has the kind of glassy style look, but it does not look like liquid glass.

1:41:06Even still, I think of all of Apple's platforms, Vision OS looks the most distinct, and I think it's because it changed at least, and it's because liquid glass doesn't really look like vision OS.

1:41:17It had its own brand new thing, whereas liquid glass was trying to bring a new design paradigm to a layout and app ecosystem that is already clearly defined, right?

1:41:28There's only so much you can do.

1:41:30So that's part of the problem, too.

1:41:31Yeah, I'm not a liquid glass hater, I keep saying, and I really am not, but I do think that overall liquid glass, as we see it on iOS, iPad, and Mac, is sort of like the Samsung take on something like Vision OS.

1:41:47It's just that Apple sort of Samsung-ed itself.

1:41:50Vision OS still looks way cooler to me than liquid glass does on iOS, right?

1:41:58And I'll just hold iOS's where the new liquid glass in the 26 OS's clearly looks best, right?

1:42:05It's iPhone first.

1:42:06iPhone looks the most, has the least weird things.

1:42:09The Mac has the most weird, ugly things.

1:42:13Maybe tvOS, which is kind of the nature of tvOS, is that it doesn't really have windows and depth.

1:42:20I think the new look of tvOS is excellent.

1:42:23Looks nice.

1:42:24Yeah, it looks nice.

1:42:25But it's, I don't know, it's, it's, it's, it's, but looking at iOS, to me, it looks like iOS as a knockoff of Vision OS.

1:42:33Vision OS looks, still looks way cooler.

1:42:37And I think that was, yeah, I think that was outside, I don't think that, I think that was above and beyond Alan Dye.

1:42:45I really do.

1:42:45And if I'm wrong, well, somebody should correct me.

1:42:48I would love to hear from you as an anonymous source and tell me, no, no, Alan Dye personally deserves tons of credit for Vision OS and the way the whole thing looks and works.

1:42:58I would love to hear that, but I haven't heard that.

1:43:01And I don't think it's true.

1:43:03And one of the other things that I think is true of Vision OS is because it's so focused on mixed reality and those pass-through cameras, the classical nature of the UI elements are more natural because you have the backdrop.

1:43:19It's a window inside your real space.

1:43:21And so you can take on window chrome in the color of what's behind it much easier than you can on an iPhone, which is still ultimately a slider holding you in your hand that is not using the rear-facing camera.

1:43:32And thank goodness to emulate every single thing that is behind the phone, right?

1:43:37But by consequence, to make it look impressive, especially when you're looking at it on like a background, well, you got to make it really, really clear.

1:43:46Otherwise, it kind of just looks like slightly frosted glass on an element.

1:43:50But that's also why it has looked like it has.

1:43:53And throughout the entire beta cycle, it was more transparency, less transparency, a little somewhere in the middle, more again.

1:44:00And I think, you know, in 26.1, giving people the option directly in the UI to dial back the liquid glass, that's proof that Apple themselves is not hyper-confident in it.

1:44:13Because when was the last time Apple ever gave you options like that that weren't directly in accessibility?

1:44:18Right.

1:44:18No, definitely.

1:44:19I literally can't think of any.

1:44:20No, I can't think of any.

1:44:21And it also, it brings back, what were we talking about earlier with, oh, the slide over coming back in 26.1.

1:44:27It also makes me wonder, like, what is going on over the summer when Apple has these betas from WWDC?

1:44:38Because there were, I would say, the two most common things that I heard that had no pushback from the other side.

1:44:48It wasn't a debate.

1:44:49It was only from one perspective, which was, hey, a lot of this shit is way too transparent and you can't read it.

1:44:57And I really miss slide over.

1:45:00Like, they threw out a good baby with the bathwater.

1:45:03This was a feature that I really used.

1:45:06And I don't see why it couldn't still be there and work alongside the desktop-style windowing features that they had.

1:45:12I heard that over and over again all summer from iPad users.

1:45:16And I heard the stuff about the transparency being way too see-through and not working.

1:45:22I can't read my – I can't read some of this stuff.

1:45:25And then only after it actually shipped and then 26.1 came out, did they actually go, oh, okay, you think slide over should come back?

1:45:33Okay, we'll bring it back.

1:45:34And maybe that's just how long it took.

1:45:35I mean, that would be the optimistic take, that the work on this started in the summer, that they heard the feedback in the summer, but they're like, we've got to ship in September.

1:45:45So, you know, these 26.0 releases aren't going to have this, but we'll get the work started for 26.1 to bring slide over back, to bring it, add an option that's not hidden away in accessibility to have tinted instead of transparent, which I don't use.

1:46:02I don't know.

1:46:02Do you use the tinted?

1:46:03I don't.

1:46:04I'm using liquid glass as is.

1:46:06But again, it's mostly because on the phone, I think it looks pretty nice.

1:46:10Yes.

1:46:10On the Mac, oh, the Mac is bad.

1:46:13It is really bad.

1:46:14I've just gotten so brainwashed that I'm used to it, but I went back.

1:46:19I actually had a laptop that I was restoring that was still running Sequoia, and I opened up Sequoia, and I thought, holy crap, this looks so good.

1:46:28People all summer were saying like, oh, as soon as you go back to – and it's true.

1:46:35If you go back and look at iOS 18, you're like, oh, this looks kind of old.

1:46:38But if you go back and look at old Mac OS, you go, oh, man, that looks awesome.

1:46:42Bring that back.

1:46:43Yes, I'm in the exact same boat, and I'm podcasting.

1:46:47My podcast station that I'm talking to you on is running 26 Tahoe, and my main work Mac upstairs in my office is still running Sequoia.

1:46:57And so I see them all the time.

1:46:58I mostly see Sequoia, but every time I come down here and I'm using this and I'm like looking at notes and I'm looking at Safari and I'm looking at this, I'm like, oh, my God, this is worse.

1:47:09And the finder, the finder is so bad.

1:47:10It really is.

1:47:12It is so bad.

1:47:13It's – oh.

1:47:14Everything, to me, looks like it's just held together with Scotch tape.

1:47:18You know how like when you're a little kid and you have a big piece of cardboard and then you're going to paste or attach little pieces of cardboard on top and you make a little roll of Scotch tape, a little roll of it.

1:47:32And then you put it on and then you set the thing on the roll and that's how you stick it on.

1:47:36But then it sticks –

1:47:37Wherever there's a button, just put a little circle above it.

1:47:39Right.

1:47:40It's like everything is stuck on with a bit of a roll of Scotch tape.

1:47:44Not so it's flat, but so that it creates depth, but that the depth wasn't supposed to be there.

1:47:49It's just the nature of how you stuck it on.

1:47:53And when you look at a child's art project that is made that way as an adult, you think, well, be very careful with that because all of those things could just fall off very easily.

1:48:04Don't take it outside if it's windy.

1:48:06Let's be very careful with this.

1:48:09Don't fold it because if you fold it, it's all going to get stuck to each other.

1:48:13You have to be very careful with it.

1:48:15The whole interface looks fragile in a way that something held together with little rolled up pieces of Scotch tape is inherently fragile.

1:48:23And when I go back, I'll go upstairs when we're done recording this show and it's going to be the proverbial glass of ice water in hell for my eyes after two hours of looking at this.

1:48:35And I'm exactly with you where I still have my year old iPhone 16 Pro running the old iOS so that I have a modern phone for points of comparison.

1:48:47Hey, is this new?

1:48:48I like to do that.

1:48:49It's one of the things I like having a new iPhone every year and keep the old one on the old OS so I can look at them side by side.

1:48:55I look at it.

1:48:56A, I don't think liquid glass is that big of a change.

1:48:59I don't look at it and think, wow, this is really old.

1:49:02I just look at it and think, eh, this is a little dull and a little flat.

1:49:05And some of the buttons, we were right for 13 years since iOS 7 that Apple should have been making buttons that look like buttons.

1:49:14And it is nice in liquid glass that most of the buttons now look like buttons and stuff like that.

1:49:21But it's not even that big a change.

1:49:23But in the ways that it has changed, I think it actually looks better.

1:49:26But it doesn't look nearly as cool as Vision OS.

1:49:31No, not at all.

1:49:33That's the other tell without having a source that Alan Dye's team wasn't really behind it.

1:49:38And one of the great things about Vision OS and even, frankly, iOS is that the displays on which they're running, by and large, are HDR.

1:49:45And that's one of the biggest problems, I think, with the Mac.

1:49:47I sent you a screenshot that just makes me laugh so much.

1:49:51So Safari changes as the window chrome to match the web page.

1:49:55But then when you use other UI elements like the search or the find bar, if you do Command F, it pulls up either in light mode or dark mode based on your system.

1:50:04Mine's in light mode.

1:50:05Well, the buttons are white on top of a nearly white background.

1:50:10If you didn't know they were there, you would not see them on a MacBook Air or on a studio display or the only platforms you'd maybe see it on is a MacBook Pro with a really nice, super bright mini LED that has enough kind of brightness to be able to distinguish between the two.

1:50:26But there's just crap that's completely illegible.

1:50:30And I'm running 26.2 on here.

1:50:33So we're months in to public release.

1:50:35And this is what we've got.

1:50:37And it'll get better.

1:50:38But it's just, holy smokes, just hold it.

1:50:42Why did we even release this?

1:50:44It's so bad.

1:50:45As I wrote about, you quoted from my reporting, very nice of you to do so in your video, the Alan Dye news within the rank and file of Apple's designers within the company was too good to be true.

1:51:00I mean, it's just unbelievable.

1:51:04The joy.

1:51:05People couldn't believe it because they really thought they'd never get rid of him.

1:51:08And you think, well, how could that be?

1:51:09How could they be so unhappy with the leader of this organization and not have the people above Alan Dye recognize this?

1:51:19And it's a bit of dysfunction within Apple.

1:51:23And I do think ultimately and what I've heard, I've heard this before he exited.

1:51:28And it's possible.

1:51:30It might be in hindsight that I wasn't critical enough of Alan Dye before he left.

1:51:35But there is a certain diplomacy that I need.

1:51:38It's not about maintaining access to Apple.

1:51:42I mean, I have the whole something rotten in the state of Cupertino proves that I don't care about that.

1:51:47It's I really don't.

1:51:49That's that's not my goal.

1:51:50But there is at some level, a level of diplomacy that needs to be had and a there's a whole list of things I wish I'd gotten around to complaining about under Alan Dye's leadership that I just never got to specific little things.

1:52:05But I think over I saw like on Hacker News, they're like, oh, how come Gruber never criticized this guy before he left Apple?

1:52:11And then all thankfully, not me, but other people were like, well, what about this?

1:52:14What about this?

1:52:15What about the time Louie Mancha was on his show in July?

1:52:17And they like set Louie set Alan Dye on fire verbally.

1:52:21But I think what I also had heard before, but then I also heard very, very strongly afterwards from the rank and file who were like popping open champagne or whatever their favorite beverage of choice.

1:52:36I can't believe he's gone.

1:52:37I can't believe Stephen LeMay, who is beloved within that that level of the company, beloved, like so many people saying of all the people they could have picked to replace Alan Dye, especially on a dime.

1:52:48Stephen LeMay is the guy.

1:52:50That's the guy.

1:52:50Not perfect.

1:52:52Not like I never had a disagreement with him, but also these are people who would be the first to tell you, is there anybody you've ever worked with who you've never had a disagreement with?

1:52:59They'd say, oh, no, of course not, because we're all strongly opinionated designers at Apple who think we're the smartest designers in the world.

1:53:05So, no, I've had an argument with everybody.

1:53:07We love to argue, right?

1:53:09That's the gist of the downside of Stephen LeMay is people have said, well, I disagreed with him about one decision that he made.

1:53:14But the thing that they all said about Alan Dye was that he was so political in a way that felt and you think, oh, some people might think all big corporations are inherently political.

1:53:23And, of course, they are to some degree.

1:53:25I mean, it's just the nature of a larger organization, right?

1:53:28In some levels, a marriage is political, right?

1:53:32It's me and you, our friendship, me and John Gruber and Quinn Nelson is political in some ways.

1:53:37It's politics is just a way of describing human nature, right?

1:53:43But what we think of as politics gets more obvious in a bigger organization with a defined hierarchy.

1:53:50And Alan Dye, I think, excelled at that.

1:53:53He was just very, very adept at the politics of it.

1:53:58I think his right-hand man, Billy Sorrentino, I hope I'm getting his name right, who I had never heard of before.

1:54:04He was at Wired for a while.

1:54:06Literally came from a magazine design background.

1:54:09I'd heard people at Apple describe Alan Dye and his team as magazine designers before.

1:54:14And I thought it was like an analogy or a metaphor.

1:54:20It's because Billy Sorrentino, yeah, it literally came from a perspective.

1:54:24And again, from that, hey, graphic designers can't do user interface design.

1:54:29I wouldn't say that.

1:54:30I believe in being a polymath.

1:54:32I believe in being multidisciplinary.

1:54:35I do think, though, you've got to prove it, right, that if your background is in print graphic design for magazines and you want to head up user interface design for the leading user interface design company the computing industry has ever seen, you should know what the hell you're talking about and know the art and be like, oh, but look at my library.

1:54:55Half my library isn't graphic design.

1:54:57It's actually all this interaction stuff.

1:54:59I've always wanted to do this, that these are people who, you know, what I've heard from Billy Sorrentino when he was at Wired, again, total political operator and was despised by the actual working designers because he just had no interest or talent at it.

1:55:15But they were very good at the politics of it.

1:55:18And so I think basically that they were very good at making the people above them, the Federighis, the Jawses, Tim Cook, obviously need to be happy that they were happy with the work coming out of Apple's user interface design team.

1:55:34And whatever things a lot of us saw as the deficiencies in user interface design aren't things that those people in Apple's C-suite saw.

1:55:42Or if they did, didn't see them and be irritated enough to realize there is a problem.

1:55:48And that whatever it is they wanted out of the UI design team, Alan Dye was very good at delivering.

1:55:55And it's also very, very much true.

1:55:57This is part of what you have to have a big mind here, a big boy mind, and be able to hold two thoughts in your head, which is that overall Apple's user interface design work still is the best in the industry.

1:56:11That it can be true that Apple's platforms still have the best user interfaces of any of the companies they compete with and that they are worse than they ever have been and fail in certain fundamental, the equivalent of grammatical errors in prose or punctuation errors in copy editing.

1:56:33That they fail in certain fundamental levels from the perspective of a practitioner of user experience in ways that Apple's software used to be perfect, in the way that Apple's advertisements always are grammatically perfect and the punctuation is right, that both things could be true.

1:56:52And I think that's how he skated along for so long, that from the perspective of Tim Cook or the people right below him, they're like, well, our user interfaces are still clearly the best in the industry here.

1:57:03Let me spend a day with Android and get angry about the user interface and be like, well, ours is way better than this, which I think is correct.

1:57:10So therefore, we don't have a problem.

1:57:13But I think and that he was just good at the politics of it and telling them what not just telling them what they wanted to hear, but delivering what they wanted to be delivered, which wasn't enough.

1:57:23It just he wasn't good enough at it.

1:57:26And that's where I think it's even more tricky, too, because ultimately it falls on Dai's head because he's the one that was heading the entire kind of effort.

1:57:38But human interface kind of element designers are not inherently graphical interface designers.

1:57:45There's a bunch of different kind of modalities that all have to work together and you have to have someone at the top to head the whole team.

1:57:51And I think just as I've struggled with iOS 7, the same is true here.

1:57:58And I think we'll get to the point for the people that think, oh, great, Allendeye's gone, liquid glass is like, no, liquid glass is sticking around for years.

1:58:05Like it's not going anywhere.

1:58:07But I think that it'll find refinement in the way that iOS 7 found refinement.

1:58:12You look at iOS 7 and iOS 11 is kind of, I think, where post iOS 11, we didn't see much visual change until, well, now.

1:58:21But you look at iOS 7 and iOS 11 and they look so different, even though the concepts, the principles are the same.

1:58:29And iOS 7, from a magazine display keynote standpoint, actually kind of looks better.

1:58:34But then when you have to use it, you're like, I can't read anything.

1:58:38Is this a button?

1:58:39This is just a really thin blue word on top of a white window at the top of the corner.

1:58:43And I only know it's a button because it was a button before when it looked like a skeuomorphic button.

1:58:48And I think liquid glass will get to the point where it does look and function good.

1:58:54But you do ultimately need someone that can kind of work together on that effort.

1:59:00And it sounds like, again, everybody's pretty glad that LeMay's in charge.

1:59:07The only thing of concern, I think, is just that Dai was able to play the system for so long that even the top ranks seem to be kind of, I don't want to say blindsided, but they were convinced enough to let them kind of continue.

1:59:22The fact that it surprised Apple is, I think, a little concerning.

1:59:27Now, on the flip side, who knows if there was a counteroffer by Cook and the board?

1:59:32Who knows what that counteroffer would have been?

1:59:34I don't think so.

1:59:36Maybe they're just like, okay, see you later.

1:59:38And maybe Dai didn't even give them the opportunity, said I'm leaving and this is what it is.

1:59:41Who knows if they would have tried to counter?

1:59:43I don't know.

1:59:44I, and again, I have to speak here without sourcing because the people who would know are very limited because, as you pointed out in your video about their, famously, more than any other company by far, Apple's executive ranks are very stable and that people tend to be career people.

2:00:02Shiller wasn't a lifelong Apple employee.

2:00:05He had been at Apple and then left and went to Macromedia for a couple of years in the 90s.

2:00:10That's right.

2:00:11But then came back before Jobs in the next acquisition.

2:00:14He was one of the people who was there, like the way that Jobs discovered that this young kid named Johnny Ive was in the design team and had made the thought he, Jobs went in there and thought, this company making all these boring, ugly beige computers and these laptops that catch fire in airplanes.

2:00:31I'm going to have to fire all the industrial designers, went into the industrial design lab and saw all these amazing products that they weren't shipping.

2:00:39I was like, who, what is going on here?

2:00:41This is amazing.

2:00:42Whoever made these things is the type of person we need.

2:00:45And it was Johnny Ive.

2:00:46Phil Schiller was there in marketing and Jobs described him as the best demo man in the computer industry history.

2:00:52And he was, he was absolutely fantastic at delivering onstage demos.

2:00:57Very few people at Apple at the executive level were like that when Jobs came back, but Schiller was one.

2:01:02Jaws went to work at Apple right out of college.

2:01:07He's been there.

2:01:08I think you said in your video, John Ternus was nine years old when Jaws started working at Apple.

2:01:13Eddie Q has been at Apple.

2:01:16I don't know where, I don't know if he had worked anywhere before Apple.

2:01:19He's been there forever.

2:01:20That's how Apple is.

2:01:22And there's an implicit loyalty there.

2:01:27And I don't think executives at Apple, I just, I'm not saying that they're not competitive about their salaries and stock compensation.

2:01:36But for the most part, they're not there to make the most money.

2:01:39That they're all compensated to the point where they don't need more money.

2:01:43But none of these people who work till they're 60 or in their 60s, none of them need to financially, right?

2:01:49Phil Schiller is still there running the App Store and running point on the international relations stuff with the EU and the compliance efforts in that regard.

2:01:59As an Apple fellow, he doesn't need a single dollar.

2:02:02He's probably giving away more money now than he's earning from Apple.

2:02:07He's doing it because he loves it, right?

2:02:09Tim Cook is not still the CEO because he needs more money.

2:02:14I think that they see that with all of them.

2:02:16None of them need more money.

2:02:18And so I think the idea that, I think Alan Dye knew this as a political operator.

2:02:22This was not a negotiation.

2:02:24And it wasn't, if he wanted more money at Apple, the way to do it isn't to say, well, I've been talking to Meta and here's their offer for me.

2:02:34I think he knows that that's a non-starter, really.

2:02:37I think it actually would be more shocking and what the hell are you doing, why are you even coming to me with this, than just saying, hey, I'm leaving.

2:02:49I got an offer from Meta and I'm leaving tomorrow.

2:02:51I think that was actually less shocking.

2:02:53I think it would be more like, did you get a brick dropped on your head if he came to Tim Cook and said, are you going to match this offer from Meta?

2:03:03Executives at Apple, they don't do that.

2:03:05I really do.

2:03:06And could I be wrong?

2:03:08And Johnny Surugi every year has feelers put out to Qualcomm and Intel and whoever else, or Google, who makes their own chips.

2:03:18And every year he's seeing what he's worth and then he goes to Tim Cook and gets a raise.

2:03:22I guess it's possible, but I'm pretty sure that's not the way it works.

2:03:27I just don't think so.

2:03:29And I think that it's, I don't know.

2:03:32I don't know what Alan Dye was thinking.

2:03:34I don't know if he was bored.

2:03:35I don't know how much money, I suspect, a genuine mountain of money came to him from Zuckerberg and that he saw that as appealing.

2:03:42He got a C-level title, even though he still reports to Boz at Meta, which is a very strange structure for someone with a chief in their title.

2:03:53But I think it is maybe the luckiest thing that's happened to Apple in a very long time.

2:03:58Yeah, I like your kind of your reference that both companies are probably better for it.

2:04:04So yes.

2:04:04Yeah, I do.

2:04:05I actually do.

2:04:07Yeah.

2:04:08Yep.

2:04:09Let's think anything else.

2:04:12Lisa Jackson, she was on my show quite a few years ago at this point.

2:04:17Delightful.

2:04:17Absolutely delightful in person.

2:04:20I think very, very successful.

2:04:21I think Apple's environmental efforts are very sincere.

2:04:27I mean, is there a PR greenwashing aspect to them?

2:04:30Of course, in the way there are with it is with everything.

2:04:32But I think they're mostly real.

2:04:34And I really do think their goal of having everything they do be carbon neutral by 2030 is genuinely sincere.

2:04:41I think it's a little weird that she's not being replaced and that her job is being sublimated to several other positions.

2:04:51Yep.

2:04:52I think the optimistic take on that is that they don't need a singular person in that role anymore because she came in out of the Obama administration where she was the Environmental Protection Agency chief and sort of made it.

2:05:05And now it could be.

2:05:06I think the pessimistic take is that the political climate has changed and now Apple doesn't need to worry.

2:05:12And maybe her whole position was a little more greenwashing than we'd like to think.

2:05:16But I think it's the former, not the latter.

2:05:18But I don't know.

2:05:19Yeah, I tend to agree.

2:05:20And if it really is Apple 2030, like they had been saying, that's only four years away.

2:05:25So one would expect that most of the framework has already been set up by her and her teams.

2:05:31And now it can be left to the COO to kind of see that it's executed upon.

2:05:35So, yeah.

2:05:36Yeah.

2:05:37Yeah.

2:05:37Yeah.

2:05:38Who knows?

2:05:39Yeah.

2:05:39Who knows?

2:05:40Well, we really will need time to see how that plays out.

2:05:43But I do think it's sort of infused in Apple's hardware culture at this point and software.

2:05:48And I know AI throws a monkey wrench in this for other companies and might for Apple, too.

2:05:54And I think that we'd have to look at their accounting for what counts as Apple carbon expenditure versus, oh, well, that's not us.

2:06:02That's open AI.

2:06:03Sure.

2:06:03It's Apple's.

2:06:07At the behest of Apple's users.

2:06:09Yes.

2:06:09Right.

2:06:10Through their systems.

2:06:11And yeah.

2:06:12Anything else you wanted to get to?

2:06:14I know I've used up an enormous amount of your time.

2:06:17No, not that I can think about.

2:06:19I think that's most of what's been on my mind the last few months.

2:06:23In general, I think Apple's in a good spot.

2:06:25I think that this eventually, I suppose we could say this is what will likely lead into Tim Cook's ultimate replacement, which has been suggested by many to happen probably sooner rather than later.

2:06:39I know Tim Cook has been alluding to the idea that, well, I'm not going to be at Apple for – he's been saying for almost a decade that he's not going to be at Apple for that much longer.

2:06:49So I think that we're probably approaching the end of his tenure.

2:06:53I made the prediction in my video that I think that 2026 is going to be the time that that happens because Arthur Levinson, who's chairman of the board, he can't stand for re-election this February.

2:07:04He's 75 years old.

2:07:05So per Apple's proxy statement, he's out.

2:07:07And I think it's almost certain that Cook becomes the chairman of the board.

2:07:12I think he does that initially while remaining CEO.

2:07:14That's not against Apple's –

2:07:17Bylaws or whatever you want to call it.

2:07:18And it's not that – it's not that atypical for the industry.

2:07:20I mean, Satya Nadella and Microsoft does that.

2:07:22The Zuck, obviously, has been both forever.

2:07:25And it's not even as a step towards retirement for Nadella, who's sort of like –

2:07:29No.

2:07:30In the prime years of his CEO-ship, right.

2:07:33Right.

2:07:33And you look at Nadella and how successful Microsoft has been under his tenure, and why would you not let him be bold?

2:07:40But, yeah, I wouldn't be surprised if next year Cook announces his intentions to retire, if either not next year or the year to follow.

2:07:47And then I don't think that – I suspect that his successor will not be immediately named, but who knows?

2:07:53This is kind of unprecedented territory.

2:07:57This isn't something that happens at Apple.

2:08:00One of the things we didn't talk about, because there's no point, just go watch Quinn's video, which is so good and covers it, but covers the way that at other companies like General Electric with Jack Welch and Disney, the whole sort of back and forth with Bob Iger.

2:08:12Here's my successor.

2:08:13You know what?

2:08:14I don't like that guy anymore, even though I haven't left yet.

2:08:16And then the guy leaves, and here's the guy who is my successor, Bob Chapek, and then he's the CEO for a year and really did fuck up a bunch of things.

2:08:24He was really –

2:08:24Yeah, no, he sucked.

2:08:25He was bad.

2:08:25But then it makes you wonder, but then Bob Iger, so I'm back in, but it's, well, now it really – I got to question Bob Iger because you're the guy who picked this guy, and he was an idiot.

2:08:35This stuff is hard, and it does seem like Apple and Tim Cook are handling it very well and making it look easy and obvious.

2:08:44Your other example was Amazon, where Amazon, there were like maybe two people who Jeff Bezos were in position to succeed him.

2:08:52And the first guy whose name, Jeff, was – it was Jeff something else.

2:08:56Jeff Wilk.

2:08:57Yeah.

2:08:57Yeah, he was the CEO of Amazon Consumer.

2:08:59Yeah, and they let –

2:09:00And everybody was pretty certain he was going to be the CEO.

2:09:02Yeah, and he, quote-unquote, retired at age 53 while Jeff Bezos was still CEO.

2:09:07And it seemed like that was a quiet, dignified look.

2:09:11Probably Bezos went to him and said, I've made my pick.

2:09:13It's going to be Andy.

2:09:14It's probably going to happen next year.

2:09:16And he got to say, OK, and walk away with his dignity intact, low-key, no drama, didn't affect the stock price.

2:09:22Still on the board.

2:09:24He's still involved in the day-to-day.

2:09:25Yeah.

2:09:26And then you cited a McKinsey report.

2:09:28I think it was McKinsey.

2:09:29I have my notes.

2:09:30But it's a more common practice for a CEO who steps aside on his own terms to hand the existing executive suite to his successor and then a bunch of those executives leave because they are like, hey, I was with him.

2:09:44Now there's a new guy.

2:09:46I don't know if they're pissed that they got passed over.

2:09:48I don't know if they just don't like it.

2:09:49I don't know.

2:09:49It just might – in the way that COVID made a lot of people reevaluate their careers.

2:09:53They're like, why am I going to work every day or every week for 60 hours?

2:09:57I like being home with my kids.

2:09:58I'm going to retire.

2:10:00I mean, you look at – and you look at guys like Eddie Q.

2:10:02You look at guys like Greg Jaws.

2:10:04I mean, they've been working with Cook every day for the last 20 years.

2:10:08And so when Tim Cook's like, all right, I'm done, it's natural to go, yeah, do I need to really stay around?

2:10:14Is it time for me to – I don't want to work for a new guy who was 15 years my – I'm 15 years his senior.

2:10:20And not that they think that he'll be bad or that they're too old.

2:10:24I mean, it's totally just a natural kind of turnover cycle.

2:10:28It happens frequently.

2:10:29I mean, the average C-suite tenure in Fortune 500 companies is only seven years anyway, and Apple's average is over 10.

2:10:37And so it's just natural that – and you look at the C-suite as it currently exists, most of them are pretty much retirement age.

2:10:46Because they came in with Cook 15 years ago.

2:10:48And so it's just time to be done.

2:10:50And that's okay.

2:10:52And it doesn't mean that anything is the matter.

2:10:55And anything with helping – and this is why I kind of – I think that Cook is a better manager than people give him credit for.

2:11:05I think Cook is on his own going to his seat and saying, look, this is my time frame.

2:11:10This is when I'm stepping down.

2:11:11You've been here for a long time.

2:11:13I think you should as well.

2:11:14And or here's the new guy.

2:11:16How can – I don't think everybody's going to leave.

2:11:18I would be surprised if Federighi left because he still, I think, got a few years like him.

2:11:22And I don't think that he –

2:11:23I think he's 56.

2:11:24Yeah.

2:11:25Yeah.

2:11:26And despite what a lot of reports and people suggest, everything that I've read and heard about Federighi is that he doesn't have illusions of grandeur either.

2:11:36I think he's quite happy and complacent and feels fulfilled where he's at.

2:11:39I think he has a good working relationship with Ternus and he doesn't feel the need – he's not going to feel jaded if he doesn't get picked as the next CEO.

2:11:46That's not really what's been gunning for to begin with.

2:11:49And so – but I do think that by, quote, unquote, clearing the board, which is very atypical for outgoing CEOs, it gives Cook, especially if he already has his replacement in mind, which I suspect he does, to go to Ternus or whomever is his successor and say, look, who within the company do you think would be best suited to this kind of position?

2:12:11So Ternus can quietly build out his C-suite before he's even named and then everybody's ready to go on day one and they're all on board with the new guy.

2:12:20I think it's a great way to set things up.

2:12:23In as much as –

2:12:24Cook doesn't abandon ship entirely, which again, I don't think he will because I think come February he'll say, hey, I'm the chairman and he's going to stick around and he'll be there to help.

2:12:31But he's not going to be a Bob Iger that tries to micromanage the day-to-day within it.

2:12:37Yeah, I think Cook is really good at – I mean we'll find out.

2:12:42But I would be shocked if he's not an absolutely fantastic chairman just as he's been CEO.

2:12:48Yeah, and I think the closeness of Apple and Disney – Jeff Williams literally just joined the Disney board.

2:12:54I mean they own Pixar and there's an affinity for that.

2:12:58And I keep thinking about the fact that if the timing had been a few decades different and Apple had been where they are now with Apple TV and Apple Originals and the shows and stuff like that, that it would have been Apple that bought Pixar, not Disney, right?

2:13:14Yeah.

2:13:14That the fact that Steve Jobs had two companies, a computer company and a film studio and sold the film studio to Disney.

2:13:22But now his computer company is a film studio.

2:13:25Right.

2:13:26But they get along well and Disney embraced Vision Pro to an extent maybe more than any other big company out there, right?

2:13:35With the custom scenarios and theaters that you can watch movies in, they get along.

2:13:39I think it's good for Tim Cook to look at that succession and if he'd maybe clarify his thinking and dotting his I's, crossing his T's.

2:13:48And if it's Ternus really, really thinking and talking to John Ternus extensively to make sure that he's not a Bob Chapek, which I don't think he would be, but just sort of, hey, I better make triple sure on this one because I don't want to do an Iger and step up to the chairman position and a year later come back and here I am again.

2:14:09Good morning.

2:14:11And that's why I think that's why we've seen all of these CEO potential successors fairly front and center for the last several years.

2:14:21I think that's why Jeff Williams, despite being very Cook-esque and having, honestly, sorry, Jeff, pretty terrible on-screen presence.

2:14:28Yes.

2:14:29As much as in the keynotes, he was rumored for years to be Tim Cook's replacement and or back up in case something happened to Cook.

2:14:35I do think that's true.

2:14:37I think that if Tim Cook had been hit by a bus or whatever the proverbial sudden exit would be, I think the emergency, we need a replacement in an emergency or just a medical condition where they needed a temporary CEO like Cook did with Jobs several times while he was battling his health issues.

2:14:55It would have been Jeff Williams.

2:14:57I do think that's why he was front and center on keynotes with a, not a bad presence, but I think a presence that made Tim Cook seem dynamic.

2:15:08He's not quite Ricky, but he's not far off.

2:15:12And his on-screen and in-person development has been pretty substantial over the last few years.

2:15:18Yeah, and I think that that's one reason why so many people, and I don't think it would be, if surprise, surprise, it turns out that it's not John Ternus, that it is Craig Federighi, none of us are going to be shocked.

2:15:30It wouldn't be like, well, that came out of left field.

2:15:32You know what I mean?

2:15:33The goofy rumor, the information ran that, what's his name?

2:15:36Tony Fidel.

2:15:37That Tony Fidel might be, if they want to go to an outsider.

2:15:40It's like, it's coming back.

2:15:42That would be cuckoo bananas, you know what I mean?

2:15:44That would be like, what is going on in Cupertino?

2:15:46Like, this is back to the early 90s of Michael Spindler hiding under his desk and stories like that.

2:15:52And especially a guy who's ex-Apple and bailed.

2:15:56Right.

2:15:57It's not going to happen.

2:15:59Tony Fidel is not going to come back to Apple, or it's not going to be Scott Forstall.

2:16:03It just isn't.

2:16:04That's just not how things work.

2:16:06If it were Craig Federighi, sure.

2:16:08And I think one reason so many people think that might seem likely is that he is the most dynamic presence on stage.

2:16:14He is.

2:16:15He really is.

2:16:16He's almost shockingly handsome.

2:16:19He's very, very personable and charismatic on camera.

2:16:23So, yeah, you see that.

2:16:26But I also think, what's it called?

2:16:27The Peter Principle, where in a large organization, people tend to rise to their level of incompetence, right?

2:16:33That you're good at this, or you're going to get a promotion.

2:16:35And you keep getting promotions until you get promoted to a position that you're not good at.

2:16:40And you think, oh, that actually makes a lot of sense, right?

2:16:44That if somebody in a large organization with a lot of levels of hierarchy, that somebody who's really good at their current level, you move them up.

2:16:51And then when do they stop moving up?

2:16:52When you move them up to a spot where they're not good.

2:16:55I kind of feel, again, I don't know the guy personally.

2:16:58It's not like Federighi and I talk at all, really, of late.

2:17:03But I do get the opinion from what I've heard about him and the times I have interacted with him backstage at events and stuff like that.

2:17:11I think that he sort of intuitively recognizes the Peter Principle and that rising to lead all of Apple's software is like where he belongs.

2:17:21And he's more influential and visible than almost any CEO in technology.

2:17:27There's no reason for him to feel like he's overlooked or not famous or not renowned or doesn't isn't built a resume.

2:17:34And I think and he is he is a real, real software nerd.

2:17:39He loves Apple.

2:17:40He really knows Apple's history, but he really is a software nerd.

2:17:45I know he said it on my show a few times that like he like one of his hobbies is writing like iPhone and Mac apps in his spare time.

2:17:51It is.

2:17:52That's actually true.

2:17:53Like he.

2:17:54And so like when they're in meetings talking about like the Swift programming language or Swift UI, like he's thinking like a developer, like, yeah, yeah, that makes sense to me.

2:18:03Or I'd like to use that or that seems like a pain in the ass.

2:18:05We should make that easier.

2:18:06He's talking from that perspective that may not apply to any of the other areas of Apple.

2:18:11And maybe Ternus, on the other hand, we haven't seen it because we've only seen him in the context of hardware announcements.

2:18:16But maybe he does have interests and enthusiasm above and beyond just leading the hardware.

2:18:22I guess I would hope so if that's who the pick is.

2:18:26Yeah, and like I mentioned, I think there's this perception that in organizations, particularly when you get to the C-suite, that every single person that is in any kind of VPP capacity aspire to the CEO.

2:18:39And I think that there's a certain type of person that you have to be to get to any of those positions.

2:18:44However, especially if you're happy and you're in a position where you're validated and have the ability to do stuff.

2:18:51And like you mentioned, particularly with Apple, more so than a lot of other companies, people are not – they're not there for the cash.

2:18:59They're not – they're there because they want to change the world and they want to get on the subway one time a year where they're not taking their limo.

2:19:05And they see everybody using the thing that their team helped design and it's bigger than that.

2:19:10And that's why I think it's not – I wouldn't be surprised if Federico even presented the opportunity and he just was like, no.

2:19:19I'm really happy with where I am.

2:19:21And in as much as the new CEO is someone I have rapport with that will let me keep doing kind of what I think is best in the kind of vertical.

2:19:29I wouldn't be at all shocked if there's just – there's no interest in – it's not a I feel betrayed because I've been skipped over or whatever.

2:19:36It's just a – it turns out these guys that are really professional, bold, that don't lead, are pretty professional and they know how to lead, you know?

2:19:44And I think they do have a very personal relationship with each other.

2:19:48There was a famous story or famous in talk show lore where I had Eddie Q and Craig Federighi on remote.

2:19:56It was – I don't forget if it was during COVID or why it was remote.

2:19:59Eddie's never been on my live show.

2:20:01I would love to have him, Eddie, if you're listening.

2:20:03But there was a story where Eddie was having a problem with his iMac and Craig came over to his house to fix it.

2:20:09I'll have to look it up in the show notes.

2:20:13I love that.

2:20:13But that's the type of relationship a lot of Apple executives have with each other.

2:20:18And so I think if Tim Cook went aside and said to Lisa Jackson, hey, what are you thinking, you know, about your career?

2:20:24And she said, I'm winding it down.

2:20:26I've been here for a while.

2:20:27I am thinking about stepping – retiring soon.

2:20:30He might have said, well, I think it would be better if you did it at the end of 2025 because I'm thinking about leaving – I'm going to transition to chairman in 2026.

2:20:39And I think it would be better if the people on the fence at the end of their careers stepped aside before the transition than after to avoid the – again, with Cook here, the whole reason we're talking about this is that all of these departures happening in a week created this perception that there's turmoil.

2:21:01Well, imagine if something like that happened with a new CEO in place, how much more they'd be like, wow, the Apple named a new CEO and all the executives are leaving.

2:21:10It would be even more perceived as turmoil, right?

2:21:14Yeah, well, and that's what a Yale researcher discovered is that average turnover when there's a new CEO is 30%, which is substantial.

2:21:24So you don't want that.

2:21:27Yeah, exactly.

2:21:28And if you have – and this is where Apple is in a unique position.

2:21:31There are not a lot of companies that are operating so well where things are going so great that they don't have to worry about – like most companies that are getting massive turnover are because they're imploding, right?

2:21:45It's not typical to have a company that has been so successful and so stable and so secured for as long as Apple and particularly so being that Apple is in the public eye more than any other publicly traded company on the planet.

2:21:57So it is atypical to see any change whatsoever.

2:22:02And that's why I think it's all the more important that it comes from Cook, who by every measure is one of the best CEOs of all time.

2:22:11Love him or hate him, scoreboard.

2:22:13I mean, so, yeah.

2:22:15Yeah, and so I also conversely think that the other executives like Eddie – just to name two, Eddie Q and Jaws, who are both I think around 60, 61 and have both been at Apple for 35, 40 years.

2:22:27If they don't leave before the transition, I think it's because they don't plan to leave in the next two, three, four years, you know, that they plan to stay until they're 65, 66.

2:22:35That if they're planning to leave soon, they'll leave before.

2:22:38And if they don't leave before this transition happens, which I firmly believe is going to happen, it's probably throughout 2026.

2:22:46I think you nailed it.

2:22:47I think it will start with Cook taking Levinson's spot as the chairman of the board and a dual role, which people will –

2:22:56And some kind of further hints like to the Financial Times that succession planning is proceeding and everybody's in agreement and just make – so don't be surprised, but maybe it's not early in the year.

2:23:08Maybe it's later in the year and that he's going to see the iPhone – he wants to see the iPhone foldable come out as the feather in his cap or – I don't know.

2:23:17They'll say something like that.

2:23:18And then it'll happen at the end of the year, I think.

2:23:21And I think it is – it's like part of human nature.

2:23:25The end of the year is the time for best of lists.

2:23:28It's the time for looking back.

2:23:29It is the time for planned retirements like Lisa Jackson and Kate Adams, right?

2:23:35And so I kind of feel bad for them that they probably had this planned months or maybe even like a year in advance.

2:23:41I'm going to – second week of December, I'm going to announce my retirement.

2:23:45And then it happened in the midst of Alan Dye leaving in a surprise.

2:23:50For sure.

2:23:51Yep.

2:23:52So I wouldn't be surprised if it's like a year from now when Cook – not Christmas week, but early December or late November or something like that.

2:24:00No, I agree.

2:24:01After starting it earlier in the year with taking the dual role of chairman.

2:24:06Yep.

2:24:07And you give the successor time to be able to be integrated, to be kind of shown to the public.

2:24:11It's almost a training period.

2:24:13But then you're not around so damn long that by the time you finally get out of the way, the new CEO can't do anything, a la Bob Chapik and Disney.

2:24:22And there might be like the way that Apple can drop hints without telling us.

2:24:26And Ternus has been in WWDC before because a couple years ago when they announced the new M2 MacBook Airs, they happened at WWDC.

2:24:33So Ternus announced it because it was hardware.

2:24:35But if Ternus has a speaking spot in the WWDC keynote too, even though it's usually a software thing where Federighi is the star because it's about software, it's like, hey, we're putting John Ternus in everything this year.

2:24:47Whether it's hardware or software related or not, we're all going to be talking in the second week of June like, hey, why'd they put Ternus in the keynote?

2:24:54Oh, I know why.

2:24:55And so they don't have to say why.

2:24:57They're just putting them there.

2:24:58It'll be known.

2:24:59Oh, one last person to add to that roster.

2:25:02I think with Q and Joswiak, I think those guys might, Phil Schiller-esque, stay around forever anyway.

2:25:08But I think Deidre O'Brien is also one very soon to probably announce intentions to retire and or to be on board for another three, five years.

2:25:19Yep.

2:25:19And again, she's been at Apple for decades.

2:25:22Forever.

2:25:23Forever.

2:25:24Has overseen what is widely considered a very, very successful HR department.

2:25:30They don't even call it HR.

2:25:31Just like it's very typical for Apple to have a different name.

2:25:33It's like people.

2:25:34Yeah, people.

2:25:35took over the retail after Angela Arntz left.

2:25:39And I think by all accounts has the reason there were lots of complaints about the Angela Arntz retail operation,

2:25:46that it was a little too boutique-y, a little too luxury-focused, a little too aligned with the Johnny Ive Apple Watch.

2:25:54Hey, one of the Apple Watches is $300 and it's made of aluminum.

2:25:58And one of the other ones is made of solid gold and it's $20,000.

2:26:02And I think Angela Arntz was there for the $20,000 Apple Watches and some of the flashier Apple stores.

2:26:09And I think under-

2:26:11Well, and she came from Burberry, too.

2:26:12I mean, she was in the fashion world, right?

2:26:14Right.

2:26:14Very much so, purposefully.

2:26:17And she wasn't unpopular, but I feel like Deirdre O'Brien running stores were like,

2:26:21Hey, I haven't heard anything about the stores in a long time.

2:26:23And I think Deirdre O'Brien would say that's exactly what I want to hear, that nobody's complaining about the stores.

2:26:29And if you don't talk about who's leading or running the stores, that's the way it should be.

2:26:34It's Apple, right?

2:26:35Apple runs the stores.

2:26:37Yeah.

2:26:39And I think she was probably on the short list of successors.

2:26:42I do.

2:26:42I don't think it would have ever been planned.

2:26:44I think she would have been on that emergency list.

2:26:46If Tim Cook and Jeff Williams were in a car accident together and both were incapacitated,

2:26:51let's put it optimistically, just both injured and out of commission for months,

2:26:58I think Deirdre O'Brien could have been the one who is the temporary CEO for a stint waiting for Tim Cook to recuperate or something like that.

2:27:05Very, very accomplished career.

2:27:07But I bet you're right.

2:27:09I wouldn't be surprised.

2:27:10But again, if it doesn't happen, then I bet she's planning to be here for quite a while.

2:27:13Yeah.

2:27:13She's only 59, so she could stay for a long number of years.

2:27:17Yep.

2:27:17Yeah, maybe.

2:27:18I didn't know that.

2:27:19So yeah, maybe not.

2:27:20Maybe not leaving.

2:27:21I wouldn't be surprised.

2:27:22I think she's right where she wants to be then.

2:27:23Anyway.

2:27:24Yep.

2:27:25Good stuff.

2:27:25Good speculation.

2:27:26And it's always good to talk to you.

2:27:28Have a good rest of the holiday season.

2:27:29Everybody can check out your fine work.

2:27:31I will definitely link to the videos we've talked about extensively here in the show notes.

2:27:35And the channel at large is just Google, search the web for snazzy, right?

2:27:40I mean, and it's going to take you right there.

2:27:43I should show up.

2:27:43I think you own the word.

2:27:45I think you own snazzy.

2:27:46We're finally to the point that if I'm not the top recommendation, I'm at least second or third.

2:27:51Let's see.

2:27:52If I search for snazzy, snazzy labs, definitely.

2:27:57There's a dictionary.

2:27:58Oh, yeah.

2:27:58See?

2:27:59Not at the top.

2:28:00Yeah.

2:28:01I am on YouTube.

2:28:02On Google, I think I'm a ways down.

2:28:04But on Google, I'm looking at Google results.

2:28:07The first definition is an in-place definition of the word.

2:28:10Second is a Merriam-Webster definition.

2:28:13Third is a wiktionary definition of the word.

2:28:16And next is snazzy labs at YouTube.

2:28:19Hey, there you go.

2:28:21I don't beat the encyclopedias, but right after.

2:28:23Thanks for having me on, John.

2:28:27I'll bet you rank higher for snazzy than I do for daring.

2:28:29I'll bet.

2:28:30That's probably true.

2:28:32But I don't know that that has anything to do with any of our outreaches versus the words

2:28:36we've selected.

2:28:37No.

2:28:37No.

2:28:38You don't really need the labs.

2:28:40You've got snazzy and it's sort of key.

2:28:42I need daring and fireball.

2:28:44It's the combination of the two.

2:28:46Anyway, happy holidays.

2:28:47I hope to chat soon.

2:28:48Yeah, to you as well.

2:28:49And thanks to you, the listener, for making it this far.