0:00:00Rene, it's been a while.
0:00:01Yes, I've been busy. You've been busy.
0:00:03Yeah, I understand you're working at some kind of plucky startup in the video space.
0:00:10Yeah, it turns out if you want to take yourself and put you on a tube, we got the platform for you.
0:00:15You have been on the show since you've started at YouTube, right?
0:00:19Yeah.
0:00:20And I think it was when you first started.
0:00:22Yeah, absolutely.
0:00:23And how's it going?
0:00:24It's going great.
0:00:26I love helping people, and I get the opportunity to help people at YouTube scale, which is once in a lifetime.
0:00:32That's why I did it.
0:00:33To me, because there's other scaling.
0:00:37Computers can do so much now that there are scaling things that just make no sense.
0:00:42But it's like the stats on how much the amount of video that gets uploaded to YouTube every hour of every day.
0:00:52Do you know the numbers off the top of your head?
0:00:54They're mind-boggling.
0:00:56Don't.
0:00:56But yeah, it's just all the video all day from everybody.
0:00:59And scale's tough.
0:01:00I mean, I think that's going to be one of the themes for our discussion today, is just how hard it is to scale.
0:01:05Right.
0:01:06Because it is the case, like a good, a real public library.
0:01:12Like in a nice city, a big public library.
0:01:15Certainly, there's no librarian who has read every book, right?
0:01:20No.
0:01:21But it's possible, though, for the librarians to have a sense of how much content is in the library.
0:01:30They certainly haven't read it all.
0:01:31They couldn't read it all.
0:01:33If they tried and they had nothing else to do, just sleep, eat, and try to read the whole library, you're not going to catch up.
0:01:42But YouTube is at such a different scale that I don't really think that somebody like you could even fathom how much video is being uploaded per hour.
0:01:49You don't even have an idea.
0:01:50It's just kind of nuts.
0:01:52It's incomprehensible.
0:01:53We do have someone named Kevin Alaka, who's head of culture and trends at YouTube.
0:01:57And every year at VidCon, he does a presentation on the culture, everything from me at the zoo to double rainbow to skippity toilet.
0:02:03And just one is the immensity of YouTube, but also now, and I don't know if Jonas is too old for this already, but like the current generation, they don't have the singular points of focus that we did.
0:02:15There's not one song that everybody knows, one TV show that everybody watches.
0:02:19There are all these micro fandoms and there is no shared culture anymore, which in and of itself is just fascinating.
0:02:25Yeah, I, yeah, it's hard for me to understand it because of the shared culture.
0:02:32Again, I'm not trying to be old man yells at cloud and I'm not mad about it.
0:02:37I'm not saying, hey, it should be the way it was.
0:02:39It's obviously falls perfectly under the category of, hey, culture changes.
0:02:45And in some ways at the intersection of the way that computers have changed culture.
0:02:52And so, of course, it's very different and not just disparate, but because I guess the difference is when I was Jonas's age, he's a senior in college.
0:03:04The big deal was the proliferation of cable TV channels and that by the mid to late 90s, when I was his age, nobody was watching only the big three networks in the U.S., right?
0:03:22It was no longer about the shared experience of, hey, everybody's watching ABC, NBC or CBS.
0:03:28And when something like the big finale of Seinfeld comes on, everybody's watching it.
0:03:36And I guess that's a counterexample because that happened in the late 90s.
0:03:40But it was sort of like that, that those were the Seinfeld was one of the last shows that that happened with where the whole country kind of anybody who you'd think might be watching the Seinfeld finale watched it that Thursday night.
0:03:52And I think it was in the context of that, we're like, hey, we used to have shared things like this all the time.
0:03:57Like every couple months, there'd be like a big event that everybody knew about and watched.
0:04:01But now everybody's watching 80 different cable channels, right?
0:04:04And we thought that was proliferation.
0:04:06Right.
0:04:07The idea that that was proliferation, that looks like a shared experience.
0:04:14And it seems a lot closer that the 80-some or whatever number of cable channels we had to flip through in the late 90s is a lot closer to only having three major broadcast networks than today's video streaming world is to that.
0:04:32Because it is, I was about to say, tens of thousands, hundreds of thousands, probably millions.
0:04:38It's still a niche of the number of people who put themselves out there and create content, but if it's like a 90-10-1 rule, but if the 1% of the smartphone-owning world is filming themselves and putting themselves on TikTok or YouTube or whatever, that's like tens of millions of people.
0:04:57It's funny.
0:04:58Earlier this week, my partner Luria celebrated her 20th year as a creator.
0:05:02She uploaded her first video 20 years ago, and it was basically her and I think Alex Lindsay, maybe Leo, uploading back then.
0:05:11You could count people doing tech videos on the palm of your hand.
0:05:14And she had like Chad Vader on and Kevin Rose and the big people on and like Jeff Smith.
0:05:19And it was all like the people that we started on Twitter with back in the day.
0:05:23And they were all like they were a handful of people.
0:05:25And now there's just millions and I think there's 3 million YouTube partners and probably 30-40 million YouTube creators and bloggers.
0:05:35The other thing, you know, it is a singular entity.
0:05:39We're not here to talk about YouTube, but one of the things I really do...
0:05:41Book cut all this.
0:05:44Well, one of the things I really do admire about YouTube, and it comes up on this show with more and more frequency because I've been doing this show for so long and I've been writing Daring Fireball for so long.
0:05:57But it became a problem while Daring Fireball was still 4, 5, 6 years old, right?
0:06:04By the mid-2000s, I already had link rot from stuff that I had posted in 2002, 2003.
0:06:12And as time goes on, it's almost more and more certain.
0:06:15And when there is some reason for me to call back to an old post, it just happened recently.
0:06:21We'll get to it, I guess, in a year in review.
0:06:23But I was looking back at the Mark Papermaster.
0:06:26Oh, yeah.
0:06:27A hardware executive who kind of took the fall for the antenna gate with the iPhone 4 in 2010.
0:06:34And so many of the links about it were no good.
0:06:38And I fixed them and fixed it.
0:06:40You know, and when I go back and reference old posts and there are still links, I sometimes will go through and find Internet Archive links and update my old links to point to ones that still function.
0:06:52And I guess it's a longstanding to-do and maybe, I don't know, at some point maybe try to automate or pay somebody to go through and fix as many of them as possible in the archive.
0:07:02But YouTube is one of those.
0:07:04Now that they're shuttering sites like iMore and Antec, I think some of those links have expired already.
0:07:09Oh, definitely.
0:07:10But YouTube is one of those things where like an old YouTube link, if it's not still there, it was because it got taken down by a copyright violation for a reason.
0:07:19It's not because it went stale.
0:07:20Or the creator took it down.
0:07:21Yes, or the creator took it down.
0:07:24And there used to be, and I'm kind of glad they gave up, that Apple used to sort of pursue people who put up like an old Macworld Expo keynote from before Apple was doing it.
0:07:36And somebody would be like, well, here's Steve Jobs at Macworld Tokyo in 1999.
0:07:41And it's like, wow, that's really neat.
0:07:43He's not even wearing his black turtleneck.
0:07:45He's got like a suit on because it's Japan.
0:07:47And then it would be like Apple would send them a nasty gram and they'd take it down.
0:07:50It seems like stuff like that doesn't happen anymore.
0:07:52But YouTube links are about as bulletproof as anything could possibly be.
0:07:56It's the creator, not the service.
0:07:58And so in addition to that phenomenal scale of what gets uploaded every day and how much of the daily viewership is, of course, driven by new content, right?
0:08:09New, new, new.
0:08:11The archive of what YouTube has is just probably in terms of actual size digitally is probably the biggest library there is in the internet.
0:08:21Yeah.
0:08:22I have to imagine that.
0:08:23And for everything, fixing your washing machine, learning how to cook consomme, just, yeah.
0:08:29And sometimes finding how to fix an old product that doesn't exist anymore, right?
0:08:33But it's like a tech product.
0:08:34It's here's how to get this old flatbed scanner from 2007 working again.
0:08:39I don't know.
0:08:40Yeah.
0:08:41For years, when you were at iMore and on your own, I had you on at the end of the year for an Apple year in review show.
0:08:48I think 22 was the last time you did it with me.
0:08:51I don't know why.
0:08:53I don't know why it's been that many years.
0:08:56But why not have you back?
0:08:57Yes.
0:08:57Are you ready for this?
0:09:00Absolutely.
0:09:00It's been a fantastic year.
0:09:022025 year in review.
0:09:03All right.
0:09:04Let me just begin, though.
0:09:06Let's just get it out of the way.
0:09:07Let's have the first sponsor break.
0:09:09And I am going to tell you about our good friends at Factor.
0:09:16Now, Factor.
0:09:17All right.
0:09:18Let me tell you about our first sponsor.
0:09:20And I do love this company.
0:09:22I use them all the time.
0:09:24Factor's chef-prepared, dietician-approved meals make it easy to stay on track and enjoy something comforting and delicious.
0:09:31No matter how hectic your holiday season or winter or whatever is going on in your life right now, it is super convenient.
0:09:40Now, there are.
0:09:41This is not to be confused with meal kits where you get shipped to you the ingredients for full meals that are all prepared.
0:09:49And you open them up and follow the recipe and cook a meal in 30 minutes.
0:09:53These, from Factor, are ready-to-heat, ready-to-eat meals.
0:09:58They are refrigerated.
0:10:00They come very similar to a meal kit with, like, dry ice in the box to keep everything fresh.
0:10:05Everything is freshly prepared.
0:10:07It is not frozen.
0:10:08You get it.
0:10:10You put it in the fridge.
0:10:11When you're ready to eat, you just heat it up easily, super easily, often in the microwave.
0:10:15And they have so much variety, so many things.
0:10:19They have a wide variety of selection.
0:10:21And every week, the menu changes.
0:10:22You just go to the website and pick what you want.
0:10:25They've got premium seafood options now, like salmon and shrimp, at no extra cost.
0:10:31They've got all sorts of little subcategories.
0:10:34So if, for example, if you're on, like, the GLP-1 type drugs, they've got friendly meals for that type of the diet that people who are on that type of medication want to eat.
0:10:46They've got a new Mediterranean diet option in the weekly categories and all sorts of global flavors.
0:10:53They've got Asian-inspired meals with bold flavors influenced by China, Thailand, and more.
0:10:5897% of customers say that Factor has helped them live a healthier life.
0:11:03I use Factor.
0:11:06I really like it.
0:11:07I love their breakfast options because that is the part of the day where I am at my absolute laziest and I'm more likely to just not eat at all
0:11:15than if I have to do any kind of work.
0:11:17And having their tasty breakfast, just microwave it, hot breakfast right there without leaving my kitchen.
0:11:24I absolutely love it.
0:11:26Really, really good stuff.
0:11:28But it's so many good options, so many good meals I've gotten from Factor.
0:11:31I don't even know where to start.
0:11:32But I do use it and really, really like it.
0:11:35Both the convenience and it's just good.
0:11:39It's just like, wow, this is really good.
0:11:41Really, really enjoy it.
0:11:42Where do you find out more?
0:11:44Eat smart.
0:11:45At FactorMeals.com slash TalkShow50 off.
0:11:52And the 50 is 5-0.
0:11:53So that's FactorMeals.com slash TalkShow50 off.
0:12:01O-F-F.
0:12:01TalkShow50 off.
0:12:03And guess what?
0:12:04That code gets you 50% off your first box of food plus free breakfast for one year.
0:12:12That's code TalkShow50 off at FactorMeals.com for 50% off your first box plus free breakfast for one year.
0:12:18Get delicious ready-to-eat meals delivered with Factor.
0:12:21Offer only valid for new Factor customers with code and qualifying auto-renewing subscription purchase.
0:12:28All right, January.
0:12:29Let's get started.
0:12:31I actually did a good job.
0:12:33And rather than trying to assemble my notes this morning, I've been, thanks to a weekly or monthly reminder, keeping notes.
0:12:43At the end of every month, I've been doing this, both for this episode of the talk show.
0:12:48And then I'm going to use the same set of notes when I do my Apple report card for Jason Snell's Six Colors.
0:12:53Here are my notes for January 2025.
0:12:56I have down it.
0:12:57It was a quiet month.
0:12:58iOS 18.3 and Mac OS 15.3 shipped.
0:13:01Siri and this was a note of things to come, I guess, in January.
0:13:06Siri and Apple Intelligence, even with ChatGPT enabled, continued to suck.
0:13:11Because that was when I wrote the piece titled, Siri is super dumb and getting dumber, about asking Siri with Apple Intelligence and ChatGPT integration to tell me who won a bunch of Super Bowls.
0:13:30I still think there's like a couple Siri servers in Eddie's back closet that have never been updated.
0:13:34Because like I'll say call my mom and it'll do it nine times.
0:13:37On the 10th time, it'll say calling mom's florist in Poughkeepsie.
0:13:41And there's just no rhyme or reason for it misfiring one out of every like 50 times.
0:13:46But it does.
0:13:47It's funny looking back at January when I guess, I really do, I mean, spoiler for coming months on this review.
0:13:57I guess I was still thinking, hey, this is supposed to get soon midway through this OS cycle.
0:14:05That's when the new smarter Siri with Apple Intelligence was scheduled to ship.
0:14:11But I have to say, just thinking back to where my headspace was a year ago, and I remember when I wrote that series, Super Dumb and Getting Dumber, not that I didn't believe it.
0:14:22And I'm not going to try to say I predicted in January that this whole thing is going to be canceled.
0:14:27It isn't going to happen.
0:14:28But I just remember I was dubious, to say the least.
0:14:32I guess I was surprised that they just outright canceled it and said, we'll come back next year with something new.
0:14:38But it just smelled fishy, even at the time, and just sort of seemed, I hope they're right, but we'll see.
0:14:45And then we wound up seeing.
0:14:47Part that struck me is that they didn't remove it from the marketing.
0:14:50Like, it was interesting that they based the entire marketing for that year's iPhones on Apple Intelligence because it was not a hardware differentiator.
0:14:58And maybe they figured they lacked enough hardware differentiation, then they had to go with some software model.
0:15:04But then they never removed it for the entire year.
0:15:07It was still built for Apple Intelligence, which they'd said wasn't shipping, but they never got rid of it.
0:15:13And so I was like, you know, like, is it coming?
0:15:14That part, because their marketing team is so smart.
0:15:18They are literal geniuses.
0:15:20And yet Apple Intelligence persisted everywhere all year.
0:15:24Yeah, it's almost like it fell.
0:15:26It's like they didn't know how to deal with something that sucked so bad, right?
0:15:33And I think I often say this about Apple marketing is that, and there's no, it's always been the case.
0:15:40I think all the way back to Shiller's title before Next was acquired in 96 and Steve Jobs came back and it was like, hey, this Phil Shiller guy is good.
0:15:53We'll keep him.
0:15:54It's always been called product marketing, not just marketing.
0:15:56And I don't know.
0:15:57I don't want to read too much into it.
0:15:58They could call it whatever.
0:15:59But I think there's a general perception in the world, and maybe this is how, quote unquote, marketing works at many companies where the product or service, whatever it is, is made.
0:16:12It's designed, it's designed, and then at the end, it's handed off to the, quote, marketing team, and they're like, okay, now you make packaging and ads for it and tell the world about it.
0:16:21Whereas at Apple, product marketing is very, they're involved from the concept onward.
0:16:29There are product marketing people.
0:16:30They're like product managers.
0:16:31Right.
0:16:32And it's not that they're the ones who are single-handedly driving the design and engineering of the products.
0:16:38It's all sort of collaborative, but they are involved in the creation and decisions from concept forward.
0:16:47And then when they do the part of marketing that is advertising and packaging and stuff, it's not like they've just been handed it.
0:16:55It's sort of like the culmination of a process that they've been involved with in the beginning, and they kind of know what to make the ads about because they've been there.
0:17:06And it's, well, here's the main thing that we've been thinking about for the iPhone 17 Pro from the beginning five years ago or whenever that project started.
0:17:14And it just, and again, it doesn't matter how your marketing team works.
0:17:20It obviously is easier to market an actually good product than to market a not good product, right?
0:17:28Because no matter what, the job of the marketing team is to make it seem like it's a good product.
0:17:33But if it's actually good, you explain how it is actually good.
0:17:38And if it's not actually good, that's where marketing gets a bad name, right?
0:17:43Yeah.
0:17:43Well, they do have a Marcoms team that is, they just have a much smaller Marcoms team than a lot of companies would have because the product marketing drives so much.
0:17:51But I keep going back to that old guy English when he was still doing Kicking Bear, and he did that article on, do you even talk to each other?
0:17:58Because you and I run into this sometimes.
0:18:00And I remember this happened to us at WWDC once where someone came up and said, I do X, Y, Z.
0:18:04And someone else came up and said, I do X, Y, Z.
0:18:06And they were the same thing, and they had never met each other and never had a conversation with each other.
0:18:11And it's stupefying that with the level of coordination Apple has, but with the level of secrecy they have, there can be things that are very important that aren't cross-pollinated.
0:18:21And I think that's sometimes where you get that situation where the engineers are going, what are they saying?
0:18:25We never built this.
0:18:30I don't have much more for January, though.
0:18:32We can move forward to February, and that brings us to the iPhone 16e, which is one of those things where I'm like, oh, yeah, remember the iPhone 16e?
0:18:44I haven't thought about the iPhone 16e in months.
0:18:48I haven't thought about it at all, but I love the goddamn thing.
0:18:51I had a great time reviewing it, gave it, I think, an exemplary review.
0:18:56I think it is a fantastic product.
0:18:58I love the strategic shift from SE models every irregular, what, three, four years, I think the schedule was.
0:19:07It doesn't really matter.
0:19:08It's not worth looking up.
0:19:09But every three, four years, they would come out with a new iPhone SE based on some two- or three-year-old or four-year-old flagship iPhone, sort of that's the shape, that's the screen.
0:19:22It's years behind, a few years behind, but always quite a bit ahead of whatever the previous SE model was.
0:19:30New insides with the old outsides.
0:19:33Right, and until the 16e, the iPhone SE was still on the old, believe it or not, like a year ago today, they were still selling a phone with a home button.
0:19:45Yeah.
0:19:45Which now, one year later, feels like, wait, do I need to double-check that?
0:19:50That seems ridiculous.
0:19:51That the iPhone 12 months ago in December 2024 was still, still had a brand new device support for a home button with Touch ID.
0:20:01But yes, it did.
0:20:02The 16e brought it to the iPhone 10 future from 10 years ago.
0:20:10I don't blame them.
0:20:11And I think because this is how I see it, looking back at it a year from now.
0:20:17And I guess we're on the cusp of looking at a 17e, which is widely rumored, you know, and that's why they put the number in it instead of calling it the new SE, that they're kind of shifted to a, hey, we'll update this one every year too.
0:20:30But the thing we've, for a long time, I mean, like me, like really decades back to the 90s or even the 80s, Apple Watcher is what would Apple do if they had a 50% plus market share hit product?
0:20:50And so many of the excuses that were given for why PCs sucked in certain ways was, well, you try managing 90% market share and keeping everybody happy.
0:21:03You've got to make some concessions to backwards compatibility.
0:21:06That's how you get massive market share.
0:21:09And of course, therefore, it's slow.
0:21:11The more users you have with a product like that, it's inherently slower to change or to introduce major, oh, it used to work like this with a home button, but now there's no button in it.
0:21:23The whole display goes edge to edge and you swipe up from the bottom instead of a button and instead of touch ID, there's face ID.
0:21:29You can't introduce a big change like that for everybody all at once.
0:21:35And so one way of doing it is to be paralyzed and just never change, which is a pretty good way for a company with a dominant product to eventually die or at least lose their dominant position.
0:21:45Or you can kind of shift to, hey, we'll keep putting leading edge stuff out there for people who want it, but we'll also keep the sort of comforting legacy thing around way longer than we used to like when Steve Jobs was around.
0:22:02And I think the iPhone 16e sort of exemplifies that.
0:22:05Yeah, I think when the iPhone 10 came out and that was the first iPhone without the home button, they very wisely put out the iPhone 8 as an escape hatch.
0:22:13Because a bunch of their market share was not people like us, like not nerds who wanted the latest and greatest technology, but it really was people for whom smartphones were previously unapproachable, like they were trios or Windows PCs or even like BlackBerrys.
0:22:26And the home button was their escape hatch.
0:22:28It would always take them back home.
0:22:29And they gave them many years of that and people would naturally go get new iPhones and get to the full screen.
0:22:36And then after a few years, it was just time.
0:22:38Those people naturally evolved to being able to use those devices.
0:22:42And there were very few left on the market who didn't need them.
0:22:46When it first came out, I thought that they just wanted to deprecate faster and still have devices that could run Apple intelligence.
0:22:53Assuming a perfect world where Apple intelligence shipped on time, you needed enough RAM to run it.
0:22:58You wanted the right neural engines to run it, all those things.
0:23:02And it was unclear if the previous – because usually they – the next year, the old ones drop $100.
0:23:06And the lowest end one, it wasn't clear it would be a great Apple intelligence experience.
0:23:10And I think this also let them have a low-end model that come this year if they want to keep it around and drop it even lower.
0:23:17It gives them the only to do that and keep that unified software lineup.
0:23:21Yeah, and that's a good point.
0:23:24And I think Apple intelligence in particular with its RAM requirements, which to their credit, they've actually admitted, yes, it needs a lot of – it needs – I forget what the minimum is for a phone.
0:23:37It's eight gigs of RAM.
0:23:39But they've just come out and set it.
0:23:42It's like the one feature ever in the now close to, what, 18, 19-year-old history of the iPhone where Apple has ever just come right out and talked about RAM.
0:23:53Well, they didn't need to before because Android was run on an interpreter for many years, and it needed – like the more RAM you gave it, the better.
0:24:01But Apple wrote native software for a native platform that they controlled, and they could be incredibly RAM efficient.
0:24:07I laugh, and it is funny when you understand that these things are just computers, and computers need RAM, and, of course, more RAM is better computationally.
0:24:16And I think – I recall this.
0:24:18You and I talking about it years ago that it's not just, though, oh, they're penny-pinching and they don't want to put more RAM in.
0:24:25The more RAM that's in a device, the more energy it consumes at all times.
0:24:29Like all – you know, so putting – if RAM were free, and we all – anybody who's paying attention lately knows RAM is definitely still not free.
0:24:39Definitely not free.
0:24:41But even if it were, there still is a limit to how much RAM Apple would want to put in an iPhone because the more they put in, the more energy it would consume.
0:24:51So even the cost of goods to put the RAM in aside, there'd still be a balancing act of how much RAM would suit the most people and hit the sweet spot of managing energy efficiency to power all the RAM that's running versus the benefits of having more RAM available for software features.
0:25:12So that's one.
0:25:12Especially if most people aren't using any of that RAM most of the time.
0:25:16Yeah.
0:25:16Yeah, definitely.
0:25:17Right.
0:25:18And that's the other thing, too, is even if it were free, it would be ridiculous – or not ridiculous, but it would be sort of a waste to ship all iPhones with 32 gigs of RAM when iOS is managing it and just fine and people aren't using more than 8 gigs or something like that.
0:25:33Yeah.
0:25:34And it is sort of the downside of the – even the best iPhone you can buy, you don't get to spec things like that.
0:25:42There's no build-to-order option for an iPhone Pro.
0:25:45There is a MacBook Pro where, of course, the default $1,500, $1,600 MacBook Pro comes with – what is it?
0:25:5524 gigs of RAM now?
0:25:57Whatever the minimum is.
0:25:58Nobody is going to make the default go up to the maximum of 128 gigabytes or whatever it's up to at this point, right?
0:26:05But if you want 128 gigabytes of RAM in your MacBook, it's frigging awesome that you can do that now.
0:26:12iPhone isn't like that.
0:26:13iPads are not like that.
0:26:15Kind of wish they were, but I kind of understand why they're not and would open up the whole Pandora's box of take up an hour of podcast time to talk about the philosophical differences between a personal computer that the user ultimately has ultimate control over and the sort of console computing approach of iOS and iPad.
0:26:40But also just like unified memory versus putting it on a daughter, like a sibling board.
0:26:44There's all these different gives and takes.
0:26:46Like everything is – every part of design is a trade-off.
0:26:49But I think – and I do think the 16e was probably in the pipeline before Apple intelligence was like a sure thing for that year.
0:26:59I think they knew things were going that direction.
0:27:02It's probably coincident with, hey, we better get ready for this.
0:27:05But I think it would have happened even if Apple intelligence had been announced the year later for multiple reasons.
0:27:13And I think the, hey, we should get our entry model, the thing that used to be the SE models.
0:27:21It would be better to get these on an annual schedule too, not for Apple intelligence in particular, but for anything like Apple intelligence that they don't know is going to be a big deal in the year 2029 right now.
0:27:39But will become a big deal in the year 2029, unforeseen in the year 2025 when you're planning the phone lineup three, four years out.
0:27:49That if you keep the platform moving and you have plans to put the latest generation silicon in the low-end consumer phone every year, all sorts of good things happen about, oh, well, we can actually bring this feature to the low-end phone because it has this, that, or the other thing, whatever it is.
0:28:12Whether it's the camera sensor or some other capability of the system on a chip, it's just insurance against future software needs.
0:28:21Yeah, I think that's really savvy.
0:28:23Like maybe it wouldn't have had as much RAM, but it's like in another parallel world, again, where Apple intelligence did ship, a lot of the choices that Apple made, because Tim Cook has been bullish on AI for years.
0:28:33He's always said it's one of the biggest things coming in the future, and they've put a lot of work into their neural engines, into their matrix multipliers, their neural accelerators, like just across their entire silicon stack.
0:28:43They could take advantage of all this technology, but I think LLMs was a bit of a surprise to a lot of people, like just the rise of chatbots, and those need a lot of RAM.
0:28:52I'm laughing, John, because these have the interface of Zork.
0:28:54Like we've gone all the way back to having the interface of Zork, but they need a lot of RAM, and that might just be the differentiator for Apple Intelligence was adding more RAM to it.
0:29:04Yeah, I just think it's a good thing, and I just love the damn 16e.
0:29:10I really do.
0:29:11It's just fun to hold and feels less premium, but not in a way that feels cheap.
0:29:17It's not unabashedly plastic.
0:29:20Yeah, it's not plastic.
0:29:21It's the corners aren't as rounded, and certainly they've even gone a little more.
0:29:27They're still flat sides, but with rounded corners on the 17 Pro.
0:29:32The iPhone Air has totally rounded sides.
0:29:36This has sort of sharper corners, but sharper in a way that feels sort of premium, or not cheap, but just different.
0:29:45I love the single camera lens it has on the back.
0:29:49It is not an iPhone Pro caliber camera for the year 2025, but it is very, very credible as a camera.
0:29:58You know, and the iPhone Air, which we'll get to, I guess, when we talk about September, has a much better single camera than the 16e, as you would hope for the price.
0:30:08But as you might think, I don't know if that's possible, given the space constraints of the iPhone Air.
0:30:15But I like the idea of a single camera lens.
0:30:17I did buy a 17 Pro this year, because I do use the other two lenses.
0:30:22We'll get to it.
0:30:23But that's not the main reason I bought a 17 Pro instead of an iPhone Air.
0:30:27I kind of like the idea of, I don't have to decide which camera, because there is only one camera, but it's pretty damn good.
0:30:36It sounds like if you only look at spec checklists, well, one camera lens is obviously worse slash less than three.
0:30:48But there's this other trade-off of, I don't know, it's kind of nice when you go to the ketchup aisle that the main ketchup is Heinz, right?
0:30:56There's the famous difference between ketchup and mustard, where everybody knows Heinz ketchup is the best ketchup and the most popular ketchup.
0:31:02And while there might be other ketchups available there, just get the Heinz and you're done.
0:31:06And the mustard, there's like 40 different mustards.
0:31:08And it's kind of nice not to have to choose, to just have one lens.
0:31:12The tyranny of choice.
0:31:13Right.
0:31:14And it does look better on the back, right?
0:31:17It's like kind of old school iPhone to just have one camera lens up in the corner.
0:31:23I love it.
0:31:23I really do.
0:31:25And I think it's a great, it's just a great phone.
0:31:28I haven't heard much about it.
0:31:29I don't know how well it's selling, but I hope Apple's happy with the results, because I think it's a much better solution than the iPhone SE strategy was for years.
0:31:38It's an interesting discussion.
0:31:39I think we'll get into it more, but just the iPhone alt.
0:31:42Like, Apple sells so many iPhone Pros, because their market really is premium.
0:31:46And the original iPhone SE sold really well, but it seemed like they could never figure out if it was because it was small or cheap or both.
0:31:54And they tried cheaper with the C.
0:31:56Right.
0:31:56Yeah, familiar.
0:31:57They tried the C, which was cheaper.
0:31:59They tried the Mini, which was smaller.
0:32:01They tried the Plus, which was bigger, but not Pro.
0:32:04They've got the E now and the Air.
0:32:06But it still seems like they haven't sold it.
0:32:08Like, people love the iPhone Pro, buy a ton of iPhone Pros, also buy a ton of just iPhones.
0:32:14But that extra iPhone every year seems much more hit and miss still.
0:32:19Yeah, and the thing I noticed, and I was paying attention to it just because in my extended, not my immediate family, but my extended family, over Christmas, there were a couple people who got new iPhones.
0:32:30And they all got the 17 Pro, and because they're not immediate, nobody asked me, this wasn't like an Ask John, close family member.
0:32:40Although, if these people would have, I would have given my opinion.
0:32:42But I might have suggested otherwise.
0:32:44But the thing I noticed, and it's sort of like the, I don't know, maybe they didn't go away, but I think they seem back more than ever, which is the carrier subsidy programs.
0:32:58And I see the commercials all the time because it's NFL season, and this is the four months of the year where I see TV commercials because I'm watching live football games.
0:33:08And there are all sorts of live commercials for AT&T and T-Mobile and Verizon, and they're often talking about, come on in and get an iPhone 17 Pro, I don't know, discount or free or whatever.
0:33:23And I don't, I just know that's too good to be true, right?
0:33:26I mean, I've known that even at the origin of the iPhone back in 2007, 2008, when it was AT&T only, and only available with an AT&T contract.
0:33:38I don't, there wasn't even an option to buy it off carrier because there was no other carrier it supported, right?
0:33:46Steve Ballmer famously, no one's going to buy this.
0:33:48Right.
0:33:49There's no point buying an unlocked iPhone when to unlock it, it would have to be on AT&T otherwise.
0:33:55So we didn't really know what the actual, and I guess the subsidy, it was sort of unsubsidized in 2007, and then they figured out, hey, we can claim it.
0:34:08You can get one for $299 or $199 or something if you agree to this contract, and that made sales go up.
0:34:17And it's like, I guess this is how phones work, and it's not how Apple computers or iPods, whichever one you think is a better example, is it MacBooks because iPhones were so expensive or iPods because they fit in your pocket and started with an eye?
0:34:35But whichever one, Apple wasn't in, never before in the business of selling products where the product wasn't, here's what it costs with our profit margin, you give us the money, then you own the device.
0:34:47And those contracts seem to be roaring back, at least in the U.S., based on my extended family.
0:34:55And I've passed no judgment on it, but it's not really free.
0:34:58But, for example, I was talking to somebody on Christmas, and they traded in an iPhone 11 Pro with a cracked screen.
0:35:07I mean, it was usable, but just cosmetically cracked.
0:35:10But a six-year-old phone, cracked screen, and got $1,100 from the carrier to put towards the price of a 17 Pro.
0:35:19Yeah, the trade-ins are big now, too.
0:35:21Yeah, and that phone is clearly not worth any for close to $1,100.
0:35:25I mean, it's probably worth like $50 with the cracked screen.
0:35:29I don't know, it's just not worth that much.
0:35:34It's a marketing trick to get people to come in.
0:35:38The phone does have to actually work and be usable and have a battery, and they'll give you more than it's worth to get you to buy.
0:35:46But when you do that, you get it.
0:35:48People seem to get the 17 Pro.
0:35:50If they're going to get it at a ridiculous discount, they want the big one.
0:35:54So I don't know.
0:35:55That's sort of the most opposite phone of the 16E, right?
0:36:01The 17 Pro, I think, because they're just the most expensive, and the whole selling point of the 16E is it's the least expensive.
0:36:08And it seems like the carriers don't want to push the least expensive one in any way.
0:36:14I think they want to get you to, oh, I'll get the most expensive phone, but I don't have to pay this eye-dropping $1,000-plus price.
0:36:24I'll get it for seemingly at the moment of making the transaction a lot less, and I'm just agreeing to stay on a carrier who I had no plans to leave in the next few years anyway, right?
0:36:36Yeah.
0:36:36So maybe it's just another form of buy now, pay later, really.
0:36:41And it's also great business for Apple because for years they take those trade-in phones and use them in emerging markets where they don't have competitive new phones.
0:36:48So it works really well for them as well.
0:36:51So I don't know.
0:36:52I feel like only Apple really knows what the 16E is selling.
0:36:56I don't know anybody personally who has one, but I don't know that many people.
0:37:01It seems like you find out every two years if they continue it or not.
0:37:05Like you get two years to sort of make your case for whether you should exist.
0:37:08Yeah, and they often run these experiments like the Mini where there's two and the plus for the new phone, the 15 plus, 16 plus, because they have to plan them out so far in advance where they can't just wait and see how the first one sells and then adjust the next year.
0:37:27It's already kind of set in motion, set in stone.
0:37:31So maybe the fact that all the rumors are pointing towards the 17E next month or February or March or whatever month it'll be this year, this coming year.
0:37:40Maybe there's not an 18E coming the next year.
0:37:43I don't know.
0:37:44Well, those rumors are that the regular phone gets postponed until the spring.
0:37:48So maybe that fills that gap.
0:37:51Right.
0:37:52Who knows?
0:37:53But I don't know.
0:37:54For now, I'm glad that this phone exists.
0:37:56I think it's a great product.
0:37:57And for somebody who just for anybody who is like a recommendation from a family member who's I don't love my phone.
0:38:04I'd like to get a phone that'll last five years.
0:38:06I don't want to spend a lot.
0:38:07What should I buy?
0:38:09And they don't want to take a carrier deal.
0:38:12They're just like, no, I don't want that.
0:38:14I just want to pay the money.
0:38:15I would say, get the E phone.
0:38:17At this point, I'd tell them to wait for the 17E, I guess, right now at the turn of the year.
0:38:23But if they really are like, I don't care, I'd say, well, I would honestly say, well, then go buy the 16E.
0:38:27But it's a great phone that I would recommend wholeheartedly in a way that I wouldn't have recommended the SE a year earlier.
0:38:35Because the silicon in that was obviously dated.
0:38:38It was obviously not going to be able to support Apple intelligence.
0:38:41And I think it was past time for everybody to get over the home button, square corner screen era and get on board with the new stuff.
0:38:52I think they're actually getting to a point where the silicon was so powerful, it wouldn't fit in those smaller frames anymore.
0:38:57It would just hit thermal limits so fast.
0:38:59Yep.
0:39:00All right.
0:39:00Moving on.
0:39:01March.
0:39:02March was a big month.
0:39:03M4 MacBook Airs shipped, new Mac Studios with the M4 Max, and surprise, the M3 Ultra.
0:39:13Boy, that seems like a long time ago.
0:39:16And then in March, the big personalized Siri delay announcement.
0:39:22And somebody wrote a post.
0:39:25Me, actually.
0:39:25Something is rotten in the state of Cupertino.
0:39:29Boy, that was a big month.
0:39:30Yeah.
0:39:31Big post.
0:39:33Yeah, I guess we should talk about that first.
0:39:36I mean, we already kind of opened the door on Apple intelligence.
0:39:39I think I said this with Quinn Nelson on the previous episode of the show.
0:39:43I do think that that piece, for all the consternation it generated and the sort of cold reception from Apple, executives towards it, culminating in their not participating in my live show last year.
0:40:03Well, it's not exactly tit for tat, but it's, and I don't think it's, hey, you wrote this, we're not going to do it.
0:40:11But I think it was, hey, you wrote this and sort of, and while they never said to me, you've got us dead to rights, it also was the case that they didn't have the next thing out.
0:40:22Right.
0:40:23If they had been ready to get the next thing out between March and June, then I wouldn't have written the piece.
0:40:29Right.
0:40:32But it would have made for, I guess, from their perception, an uncomfortable interview.
0:40:38I don't know.
0:40:39But I do think the piece has held up very well.
0:40:42I don't see anything about it.
0:40:44If anything, even better than I would have thought.
0:40:47I think, hey, what the hell, the basic premise is, what the hell were they doing announcing this as coming within the next year, last June?
0:40:57That would be WWDC 24.
0:41:00If they're clearly at the time when they announced it, it was on such shaky footing that they couldn't even film and show actual demonstrations of the alpha level software.
0:41:14If it was that shaky, how could they say?
0:41:17And obviously, the idea that some people read my article and thought that I was insinuating that Apple just fabricated the whole thing and that it was a pure fantasy that they were only then starting to engineer.
0:41:30Well, of course not.
0:41:31That would be ridiculous.
0:41:32I mean, and of course, or the notion that everybody at Apple knew that it wasn't going to ship or was unlikely to ship.
0:41:40Again, that would be ridiculous.
0:41:42And we'll get to this when we talk about December.
0:41:45But Apple executives are not like dip in and out of Apple like they're there for 18 months.
0:41:51They want to build up their resume for two years and then bounce to another company.
0:41:56They tend to build their entire careers there.
0:41:59They are lifers for the most part.
0:42:02And the higher you go in the company, especially in the product areas, these are people who've that this is their life's work is what they're doing at Apple.
0:42:11So they're not going to advocate releasing something they don't think is actually going to ship.
0:42:17Obviously, enough people at Apple were willing to say, yes, we can do this.
0:42:22We're on pace to ship in early 2025.
0:42:25We should announce this.
0:42:27Those people, there were obviously people advocating for that.
0:42:31And I'm we don't know who because they're a team company and nothing leaked about it.
0:42:37But I'm sure that there were people who were skeptical and dubious at the time who thought, I don't know that we should announce this.
0:42:44And like I wrote in my piece, why not wait till September and announce it along with the iPhones and see how much progress it made June, July, August into September.
0:42:57And with three months of progress, it should be even more impressive.
0:43:02They should be able to show demos that wouldn't have to be edited for the demonstration purposes.
0:43:08They could show an actual demo of it in action.
0:43:11And if they couldn't do that by September, it would be even not necessarily proof that they wouldn't be able to ship come March or April, but certainly indicative that they're a lot less likely to than whoever it was who thought they could in June.
0:43:25So why not wait for that bigger thing?
0:43:28I think all of that panned out.
0:43:30And if if anything, even more so with the news now, again, this hinges on the singular reporting of Mark Gurman.
0:43:37I don't think this has been reported by anyone else.
0:43:40And we haven't heard anything new about it in, I think, about two months that Apple has at least two months ago on the cusp of a deal to get a white label version of Gemini to power the upcoming new series slash Apple intelligence features.
0:43:58If true, that wasn't the case when they announced Apple intelligence in June of twenty twenty four.
0:44:04And it wasn't the thing that they canceled in March of twenty twenty five based on Gemini models.
0:44:11It was based on Apple models.
0:44:12So effectively, if Gurman is correct, they're they're just there.
0:44:17They just threw out what plan A was and are going with a plan B that didn't exist at the time and therefore makes it seem like an enormous own goal to have pre announced it at WWDC twenty twenty four.
0:44:35It's just as bad in our own goal.
0:44:37I don't know which one you think is worse, but to make at least that one particular commercial with Bella Ramsey showing features that were predicated on on those things that were announced that they had to pull and is now the subject of several, I guess, false advertising class action lawsuits.
0:44:57I think the whole thing is fascinating, like Apple often I don't say often, but like Apple has their products that get delayed and their features that get delayed.
0:45:05Sometimes we hear about them.
0:45:07Sometimes we don't.
0:45:08Sometimes a piece of hardware ships and it's got old ports and you're like, why?
0:45:11And it's because it was supposed to ship a lot earlier or like the Apple TV famously went through a ton of permutations before 2016.
0:45:19When like the current version of the Apple TV came out, but like all of that stuff is internally don't go and announce it and then it doesn't come.
0:45:26Steve Jobs famously mocked all of those CES announcements where they would show the future of technology that didn't come.
0:45:33So the decision tree to actually, what you said, like to actually announce it and double down on it and make it like the primary feature for the most important product at the company.
0:45:44That to me is fascinating.
0:45:46Like, I think there'll be an Apple University case study on that at some point, if not already.
0:45:51Yeah.
0:45:51If Apple University, if Apple, that's a whole other argument as to whether Apple University remains what it was meant to be at this state and time.
0:46:00But if it does, it will be right.
0:46:03And it's not a little thing.
0:46:05Right.
0:46:06I think I would like to think that I'm very forgiving as a professional critic, analyst, observer of the company in the industry or in my personal life of things that are like easily overlooked.
0:46:20Well, who could have seen that coming?
0:46:22Who could have known that that was going to cause the sink to back up and then overflow or whatever?
0:46:30It was an honest mistake or like an unforeseen event or catastrophe or something that happened.
0:46:37Right.
0:46:38But the decision to promote Apple intelligence is the flagship by far.
0:46:44I would say one of the biggest tentpole announcements out of WWDC in recent memory was not an oversight like that.
0:46:53And it's clear that the software wasn't at the time it was announced was not close in their usual state of close to ready.
0:47:01It was a gamble.
0:47:03And they've gambled before on things that weren't.
0:47:07I mean, mobile me.
0:47:08I think you made that analogy.
0:47:09Yeah.
0:47:10Yeah.
0:47:10Mobile me.
0:47:11Some camera features often.
0:47:14Right.
0:47:14The first generation portrait, I forget which phone it was, maybe iPhone 7, whichever one, though, or 7 Plus.
0:47:25Yeah.
0:47:26The mobile me one, I think, is really apt, though, because like mobile me, I think when the forensics was done, it was the case of they brought in this person and they kept managing up saying, yeah, we'll get it done.
0:47:36Don't worry.
0:47:37Yeah, we'll get it done.
0:47:38Don't worry.
0:47:38And it did not get done.
0:47:40And Apple, like Craig Federici and Bertrand Serlet famously managed five levels down.
0:47:46I think like the rumor was Bertrand could like remember the source code.
0:47:49And I'm sure Apple is way too big now for Craig to remember the source code.
0:47:52But famously, like he manages multiple levels down his chain.
0:47:56But that's not true across Apple.
0:47:58And it seems like where they get into trouble is when they have people who are very good at managing up.
0:48:03Like the App Store famously, Siri over and over again famously.
0:48:08And it's just like, yeah, everything's great.
0:48:10It reminds me of like the South Park and everything's fine.
0:48:12Sit down, take a little break, take a little rest.
0:48:15It's all good.
0:48:16And for some reason, those people don't get managed down.
0:48:19They don't penetrate through the layers and find out what the ground truth is, even when they make like a big mobile me announcement or now like a big Apple intelligence announcement.
0:48:28And it's like it's one of those things that can affect any company.
0:48:30But it's strange to me that it keeps affecting Apple to this degree.
0:48:34Yeah, I guess the comparison to mobile me was – and again, for people who don't remember, there was – man, how many generations did it go through?
0:48:42It was iTools originally.
0:48:44Yeah.
0:48:45And with iTools, you got a Mac.com address.
0:48:49And then I think they called the whole thing Mac.com.
0:48:53And it was just sort of – it wasn't really a technical reset.
0:48:57It was just sort of renaming iTools to Mac.com.
0:49:00I don't know.
0:49:01But there was that era.
0:49:03Then there was mobile me, which was the –
0:49:06Exchange for the rest of us.
0:49:08Yeah.
0:49:08We need to get more serious about having a cloud more than just giving people email and shitty sync, right?
0:49:16And people can say their sync still sucks, but it was like really bad.
0:49:20Whereas it would be hard to find anybody whose contacts were syncing correctly.
0:49:26And you told the story like Steve Jobs famously went through there with a flamethrower saying, what is LightCloud supposed to do?
0:49:33Well, why the fuck does it not do that?
0:49:35Right.
0:49:35It was – somebody gave the answer what it's supposed to do.
0:49:38And he goes, why the fuck doesn't it do that?
0:49:39That was Steve Jobs, you know?
0:49:41And maybe that style of management has actually – it's not just that he was a singular personality.
0:49:46I think that sort of tough love style of management is slightly –
0:49:52Genius to bozo in half a second.
0:49:55Slightly – or pass in in some ways for the better, you know?
0:49:59That it's no longer seen as admirable to yell at your employees.
0:50:06But I think the standard that was held to – you know, and you can say, you know, we're laughing a little because I wasn't the one who was yelled at and neither were you.
0:50:16Serious.
0:50:16I did – and I got – writing about that shook out some emails that I couldn't share that were shared with me under the – hey, I don't know how many people were there.
0:50:25But, you know, some of the more details about that meeting – some of them were funny.
0:50:30But the underlying thing came down to the meaning of why the fuck doesn't it do what you just said it's supposed to do, right?
0:50:37If we decided it was going to do this, that, and the other thing, it needed to do this, that, and the other thing.
0:50:43And it didn't.
0:50:44And that's the bottom line.
0:50:46And anything other than that is sophistry or – and it's the way companies get led astray because it's what they're doing.
0:50:54Trust erosion is brand erosion.
0:50:55Right.
0:50:56And it gets to that diversion that I mentioned before between the actual products and the product marketing, where the marketing is hewing to the story that it does this, that, and the other thing, and the product doesn't.
0:51:10And everybody looks around and they're like, well, nothing really happened.
0:51:16The company is still in business.
0:51:17People are still paying for this thing that we sold.
0:51:20And so I guess it's fine.
0:51:22And then once you've agreed that that's fine, that diversion, I think, inevitably widens.
0:51:31And it keeps widening until the point – and everybody's like, well, but it's okay.
0:51:35It's okay that this sucks because look around.
0:51:38Nothing's happened.
0:51:39And then you go over the cliff.
0:51:41And it's like, oh, yeah.
0:51:43There's that famous Steve Jobs video.
0:51:44I'm sure you've seen it.
0:51:45But when he talks about how companies evolve and you have a product company and after a while, like, you stop making products.
0:51:51So all you can depend on is marketing.
0:51:53And then you lose your marketing mojo.
0:51:56And then all you can depend on is sales.
0:51:57And this is how every company becomes, in his words, like IBM.
0:52:00And I think every Apple enthusiast is afraid that there's that juncture where that's going to be true of Apple.
0:52:06Yeah.
0:52:07I think that was an interview with Robert X.
0:52:09Cringely, I think.
0:52:10Yeah.
0:52:10SJ.
0:52:11But it's very, very – I think it might even be the same interview where he – it was before the next reunification.
0:52:20And he was asked, well, what would you – if you were in charge of Apple, what would you do with the Mac?
0:52:23And he was like, I'd milk it for all it's worth and then move on to the next thing.
0:52:27And I know some people have looked at that and said, well, that's not what he did.
0:52:31The Mac is still around.
0:52:32But I think what Jobs meant – and I'm not trying to make excuses or act as though he was never wrong.
0:52:38And I think one of the things that's so admirable about him is that he would admit he was wrong after he had the solution.
0:52:44Right?
0:52:45He wouldn't say, we're wrong and we'll figure it out.
0:52:47And I think it was tough to convince that he was wrong, but he could be convinced that he was wrong.
0:52:52And the way that he sort of Steve Jobs did would be – and these stories are all over the internet.
0:52:58I know there's several in Andy Hertzfeld.
0:53:00Like the round wrecked.
0:53:00Yeah.
0:53:02Where on Tuesday, he'd still – somebody tried to convince him he was wrong.
0:53:06He'd say, no, you're an idiot.
0:53:07I'm right.
0:53:08You're wrong.
0:53:09And then on Wednesday, he'd come in and say, I had a great idea last night.
0:53:12Yes.
0:53:12And it's what the person told him Tuesday he was wrong about.
0:53:15And they'd be like, okay, I'll just go with it.
0:53:18And they're like, Steve, that's a fantastic idea.
0:53:20But if that's the way he needed to do it to keep his own ego satisfied, it worked.
0:53:26Right?
0:53:26It was better than the more common way of an ego – perhaps egomaniacal leader never willing to admit they're wrong.
0:53:39Right?
0:53:39Like, compare and contrast with, I don't know, let's just say the current president of the United States.
0:53:43Right?
0:53:45There is a difference between never, ever backtracking on anything and euphemizing it by claiming it was your idea all along when you backtrack and go another way.
0:53:57And it overshadowed the fact that Apple had to come out publicly and this probably wouldn't happen again because of what I wrote about later in the month, I guess.
0:54:07I don't know.
0:54:08Maybe it would.
0:54:08I thought – I still think it's interesting.
0:54:10And I don't like to toot my own horn.
0:54:13I really don't.
0:54:14But it was unusual and unclear to me at the time just how few people and outlets they shared the announcement that Apple intelligence was being delayed with.
0:54:26I think it was literally just CNBC – I think Kit Lewing is his name, the reporter there.
0:54:35Maybe Reuters and Daring Fireball were the three outlets that they gave the statement that on the cusp of what was scheduled to be Apple intelligence, what they had.
0:54:46I guess I could look it up.
0:54:47Here's the statement I got on Friday, March 7th from Apple spokeswoman Jacqueline Roy, which was unusual that I got a spokesperson's name to put on it without being the verge and saying,
0:54:59I'm not going to run it if I don't let you have your name on it.
0:55:02Siri helps our users find what they need and get things done quickly.
0:55:05And in just the past six months, we've made Siri more conversational, introduce new features like Type to Siri, which is a weird product to brag about, right?
0:55:13You can just type in a box and product knowledge and added an integration with ChatGPT.
0:55:20We've also been working on a more personalized Siri, giving it more awareness of your personal context, as well as the ability to take action for you within and across your apps.
0:55:29It's going to take us longer than we thought to deliver on those features, and we anticipate rolling them out in the coming year.
0:55:37That statement only went to those three outlets, and I ran it verbatim.
0:55:41Maybe that wasn't an agreement.
0:55:43They were like, we'll give it to you, but you have to run the whole thing.
0:55:46They just gave me the statement, and it's up to me what to do with it.
0:55:50I don't know that I'd be on that short list at this point for a future one, but I hope so.
0:55:55And I think what I wrote about it at first is probably why they thought to give it to me, to sort of put it in context.
0:56:03And in front of the same audience.
0:56:04Right.
0:56:05To sort of explain what it means.
0:56:08And again, my initial take, it took me a while to think deeply about it and come up with the arguments that I made in the Something is Rotten in the State of Cupertino piece, looking deeper at it.
0:56:19And it's one of those things where both things can be true, where this is not a catastrophe, the fact that they delayed it for a year.
0:56:25I really do think not just because it wasn't baked, but because I think they sort of panicked slightly.
0:56:31They didn't need to pre-announce it in 2024, right?
0:56:35That was sort of at the peak wave of AI hype.
0:56:39I know AI hype is continuing to go onward, but in June of 2024, it was almost more, what's the word, unhinged, like pandemonium of, hey, maybe by a year from now, we won't even have operating systems.
0:56:57Like people were saying crazy stuff like that because that's how hype cycles work.
0:57:01And they needed to have a story, blah, blah, blah.
0:57:04Internet, superhighways, fiber space to the cloud.
0:57:07Yeah, exactly.
0:57:08Right.
0:57:09I mean, and the equivalent would be that like in the late 90s, like when the iMac came out, should it just be a net computer, right?
0:57:16Why does it have a hard drive?
0:57:17Why does it boot up locally?
0:57:18Shouldn't all this stuff just all, you turn it on and it'll boot over the internet or something like that?
0:57:24And it's like, I don't know, you put it in a one sentence summary and it sounds like an interesting idea.
0:57:29And it turns out here we are 30 years later.
0:57:33That's actually not the way anybody's computers work.
0:57:35In the future, your net computer will boot you to your personal airplanes flying you through the skies.
0:57:39But when new things come out, people don't know where they're going to go.
0:57:43I don't know.
0:57:44I don't know.
0:57:44But it made for a bad month and it overshadowed the rest of the announcements.
0:57:48Here we are still only at March, but it was a good month otherwise, right?
0:57:52The M4 MacBook Air was a great update.
0:57:55The Mac Studio, the Mac Studio, the M4 Max Studio is a great computer.
0:58:03The, hey, we do have an Ultra version, but it's only in the Mac Studio and we're still not updating.
0:58:10The Mac Pros is an interesting, hmm, what does this mean for the high end of Mac desktops, right?
0:58:20Is this Apple's way of saying, hey, the Mac Studio is actually it and the Mac Pro is never going to be updated?
0:58:26Or is there a shoe to drop in the M5 generation, which is where we'd be at at this point for a new Mac Pro?
0:58:37I think it's just like Apple's scaling issues manifest differently in software and hardware, mostly because hardware is unforgiving.
0:58:44Like you can't have, you just can't have bugs with hardware.
0:58:47They're very hard to fix.
0:58:48So they have to adjust timing.
0:58:51There's no other way to do it.
0:58:52Like that team, famously, Apple started making their own silicon and it was in-house and it's not like vendor silicon or anything.
0:58:58But Apple's teams have never been huge and they're still not huge and they're responsible for a dizzying array of alphabet named chipsets now.
0:59:06Like they're still introducing the C1, the N1.
0:59:09Like there's new chips and new Macs.
0:59:12And there's just a limited capacity of those teams to push those things out, which is why I think you get the more popular ones more often and they have to very carefully stagger the other ones.
0:59:23And they just didn't have time for an M4 Max Ultra and they didn't have time for a Mac Pro.
0:59:28And whether they do in the future, they'll decide based on their market.
0:59:31Yeah.
0:59:32And I still wouldn't bet against it.
0:59:37And I know I don't want to, we don't have time.
0:59:39I don't have the expertise.
0:59:41I looked into it and then my eyes started glazing over.
0:59:43Because I'm not, selfishly, I'm not personally in the market for a Mac Pro if they do have one.
0:59:50I just am pleased.
0:59:52Like they're hitting my sweet spot perfectly, which is let me throw $5,000 or $6,000 at a 14-inch MacBook Pro and let me put, for my needs, an absurd amount of RAM in it.
1:00:07I'm still using, my personal work Mac is still my M1 Max MacBook Pro from 2021 with, at the time, the maximum 64 gigabytes of RAM.
1:00:19Mine's an M2 only because I wanted the, I wanted all the chips in parallel.
1:00:22And I think that was the first generation where everything worked in parallel.
1:00:25I really, I've told this story before, but a year ago when I spent a month, I don't think I actually wrote a review, but I've talked about it.
1:00:32But I spent a month living on an M4 MacBook Pro with the, what do they call the matte display?
1:00:40Oh yeah, nano texture.
1:00:42Nano texture display.
1:00:43And love it.
1:00:45And I love my Mac Studio display with nano texture in my time.
1:00:52Not this time of the year, but other times of the year, sun-filled office.
1:00:57And I loved it.
1:00:59And I love that the dark option, the dark aluminum anodization is now actually very dark, not just ever so slightly.
1:01:07Depends on the lighting darker than unanodized aluminum.
1:01:11That's the real reason to upgrade.
1:01:13So I like the way the hardware looks better.
1:01:15I love the matte display.
1:01:16And when I switched back after a month on it to my personal, then at the time, three-year-old or whatever, M1 Max, but MacBook Pro, I couldn't feel any difference in performance at all.
1:01:34None.
1:01:35And that, going from the new thing to my old thing, is the way for me to tell how fast the new thing is.
1:01:44Because if I start reviewing the new thing, I'll be like, hey, this feels faster.
1:01:47This is good.
1:01:48But then I very, this is the way, especially as a nerd, you very quickly acclimate to the new speed.
1:01:54Yes.
1:01:54And then it's going back.
1:01:55You get philosophized.
1:01:56Yeah.
1:01:57It's like, you know, if you're used to driving a race car that can only go 180 miles an hour, and then you get one that goes 190, you get, and you're a good race car driver, I'll bet, you quickly get acclimated to it.
1:02:13And then it's like, at first, you're excited for a day.
1:02:16You're like, wow, this is 10 miles an hour faster.
1:02:18This is great.
1:02:19This is great.
1:02:19And then a day later, two days later, this is the new normal.
1:02:22And then they put you back in your car that only goes out, the max is out at 180, and you're like, this thing is so fucking slow.
1:02:28God, this is slow.
1:02:30This is horrible.
1:02:31I can't stand it.
1:02:32That's when you notice.
1:02:33And when I went back to my M1 MacBook Pro, I didn't notice anything that was even slightly slower.
1:02:39And I was like, I cannot bring myself to spend.
1:02:42Yes, I could sell the other one.
1:02:44I could get something for it.
1:02:46It's a totally credible, usable machine.
1:02:49I can't bring myself, though, to trade this in for a new one just to get the matte display and the darker aluminum when 90-some percent of my days I'm at my desk and I'm not even using the built-in display.
1:03:03And then, of course, this would be the year where I had, like, a personal thing in September where I was out of the home for a month or more trying to get back to work at a place where I really needed the matte display.
1:03:17Yeah.
1:03:19And I remember thinking the whole time, I was like, boy, I really blew that one.
1:03:23I should have bought an M4 MacBook Pro a year ago.
1:03:27I do a ton of high-end.
1:03:28I would have used it.
1:03:29I would have used it so much more than I expected to.
1:03:32But that's the only reason to upgrade for me.
1:03:34I do a ton of high-end video.
1:03:35And going to the M1 was, like, five times faster.
1:03:39Like, instead of spending 25 minutes to render a video, it was five minutes.
1:03:42Going to the M2, it's maybe three minutes.
1:03:44So, like, there's diminishing returns.
1:03:45But I'm not going to upgrade until there's tandem OLED on the MacBook Pros.
1:03:49And that could be next year or the year after.
1:03:51But that's going to be my next inflection point.
1:03:53Because those screens are so beautiful.
1:03:55I don't know what to do.
1:03:58I might upgrade this year.
1:03:59I'm expecting that it's not OLED.
1:04:01I'm expecting it's just the M5 and it's whatever the M5 brings.
1:04:04But just get it.
1:04:05But I'm so skeptical about the rumors about a touchscreen coming to the Mac that I think I want to buy the M5 that doesn't have a touchscreen as the last ever one.
1:04:14And then if the touchscreen turns out to be a great idea that I actually like, I'll get to try it in a review unit and I'll sell my M5 one early.
1:04:23I just want the touchscreen because then they can put macOS on the iPad and everyone will be quiet about that.
1:04:28I don't think that's what they're going to do.
1:04:31I don't think that's what they're going to do.
1:04:32But we don't have time to talk about that.
1:04:34No.
1:04:34Yes.
1:04:35The past, not the future.
1:04:36Moving onward.
1:04:38April.
1:04:38Not much from Apple.
1:04:39No products.
1:04:40The EU fined Apple $500 million and Meta $200 million for DMA violations.
1:04:48But the fines were expected weeks earlier amid Trump's months-long tariff chaos.
1:04:57I don't, it's, I'd say a quiet month that we don't have much to talk about unless you think otherwise.
1:05:02No, I think the only thing worth calling out there is something you've said often in the past is that Apple keeps having these legal battles over App Store and not over iPhone.
1:05:09And yet they still choose to have these legal battles over App Store.
1:05:13And I always wonder if that goes back to, there was this point where Tim Cook said they're going to double services revenue in two years.
1:05:19And the only way to do that is App Store.
1:05:22And then after that, we started seeing like series after series of like really like penny pinching App Store policies where they really wanted to get every cent out of everybody.
1:05:30And then they accomplished that, they doubled the services revenue and I thought, okay, this is all over.
1:05:34But it never seemed like they let go of the idea like we really need to be a services business now and so much of the services revenue is App Store.
1:05:42And I still don't know if it's worth the amount of like combat they've had to go into over App Store rather than their core businesses.
1:05:51Yeah, I don't think so either.
1:05:53But I also think that the counter argument is, well, where's the downside for us pursuing it for Apple pursuing the route that they've taken?
1:06:06It's in, we're talking about, and it's, it's not direct financial problems, right?
1:06:16The 500 million or whatever, Euro, I think I estimated it to $500 million, but it's roughly one-to-one.
1:06:24And it's all subject to appeal.
1:06:27If they end up paying it, it'll be years from now.
1:06:30And for Apple, $500 million for all of the EU is just not that much money.
1:06:35And I see why they fight it, right?
1:06:38It's not nothing.
1:06:39I just remember that Phil Schiller email where he's like, do we need to keep doing this?
1:06:43Right.
1:06:43And then I forget who it was, but was it Luca who said, yes, we do or something?
1:06:48No, I don't know that anybody wrote that.
1:06:50The one where he was like, where Schiller proposed like, hey, once we get to a billion dollar run rate, why don't we just keep cutting the commission to keep it at a billion?
1:07:00I don't think there was as entered as evidence, anyone telling him to fuck off like Luca, but obviously it happened.
1:07:07You know, I don't think they told Phil to fuck off, but I think they obviously chose a different route where they decided to keep the, rather than slowly decrease the commissions over the years to keep the run rate around the same.
1:07:21Which is sort of how they've managed like share buybacks and stuff, right?
1:07:25And Wall Street loves the services story.
1:07:29Right.
1:07:30When Steve Jobs was CEO and the scale was so different.
1:07:33If in some alternate universe where Steve Jobs had never gotten cancer or had beaten the cancer or stayed ahead of it for many more years, I still think Apple would have had to shift from the, what we know is the Jobs era strategy of taking their profit and putting it in the bank.
1:07:53And just sitting on an ever-growing mountain of cash that's managed by the mysterious Braeburn capital, Braeburn being an Apple variety.
1:08:02But when Jobs was CEO, they more or less, they were making large amounts of profits consistently for several years, especially in those last few years after the iPhone launched.
1:08:12And they were just sitting on the cash and it was sort of, I think, very much when you hear about like my and your grandparents' generation who grew up in the depression and that they were familiar with the era of the, it's a wonderful life when there were runs on banks.
1:08:31And if your money was in the first savings of Sioux City Bank and there was a run on your bank, you might lose your savings because it wasn't insured.
1:08:43And I had old relatives when I was a kid who would talk about the fact that they kept their money in coffee cans hidden in their house somewhere where they wouldn't even want to tell their relatives.
1:08:54And Apple almost went bankrupt and you've heard the stories like they couldn't, like people who, like Apple executives who remembered that wouldn't give you money to buy a server.
1:09:02Right.
1:09:03It was just like a server.
1:09:04Right.
1:09:05And there was a penny-pinching attitude or a, hey, we should protect ourselves with lots of cash.
1:09:11And I think it was a difference, I think, because Tim Cook hadn't been through that.
1:09:15He didn't have that personal bias.
1:09:16And I think also that the scale just grew to the point where it was no longer feasible.
1:09:20Like we've got, we can do both.
1:09:22We can still have plenty of cash and we can do share buybacks and pay dividends and do things with the cash like that.
1:09:31And so they've, I think, I'll bet they have more cash than they've ever had while doing record numbers of share buybacks and paying enormous dividends over the last 15 years to their shareholders.
1:09:44I think the same thing could have been true with the commission rate for the app store where they could have gradually lowered the commission rate from a 30% to 25% to 20% and still grown the amount of money that they were generating from their commissions from the app store.
1:10:02Maybe, you know, and there's some kind of argument in there, like with tax rates, where if the government wants to maximize the amount of income that the government generates, the tax, the ideal tax rate is not 100%.
1:10:19If the only tax in a country was an income tax, just for the sake of simplicity, no sales tax, no VAT, just an income tax, taxing your citizens 100% would not maximize the amount of revenue the government would make because no one would work if they had to pay 100% in taxes or a few people would work, right?
1:10:38Only people who love what they do enough to pay 100% would continue to work.
1:10:43And the ideal tax rate is not 0% because if you tax people 0%, they might think, hey, that's great.
1:10:50I don't have to pay any taxes.
1:10:52But then the government has no money, right?
1:10:54Yeah.
1:10:54The ideal tax rate is somewhere in between where it keeps people the most motivated to work and provides the – it's like a calculus problem where it maximizes –
1:11:07it's the place where the government revenue and citizens' motivation to work harder is both maximized at a certain point.
1:11:17And there's an ideal commission rate for something like the App Store where it may not make developers totally happy because there's going to be developers who want that to be zero.
1:11:28But it's going to make money for Apple and minimize developers – what's the word?
1:11:33Keep everyone equally unhappy.
1:11:35Yeah.
1:11:36That's one way of putting it, right?
1:11:38I suspect that rate is lower than 30%.
1:11:41I really do.
1:11:42And I think that Apple would actually in some ways make more money with a lower rate because it would get more developers to say, okay, for that rate, we'll keep our subscription in the App Store or we'll steer more people to the App Store, right?
1:11:59And it's probably true they were going to lose Netscape – or not Netscape, Netflix, no matter what.
1:12:06Because I think Netflix got so big where they really wanted to have just – they only wanted direct – it's not even about the commission, right?
1:12:13I think Apple could have dropped the commission to zero for Netflix and they still would have stopped in-app transactions for subscriptions because they want a direct relationship with their customers.
1:12:24But for a lot of developers who've left the App Store or gone to some kind of split thing where you can subscribe or buy outside the store or buy inside the store, I think at a lower rate, you'd get more developers either only staying in the store or steering – saying this – the App Store, the in-app purchase is the best way to buy our software or service.
1:12:48And that would actually increase the amount of money Apple made because more developers would be there even if the rate they were taking from each single dollar through the store were lower.
1:12:58I really do believe that's true.
1:13:00And I think there's a certain level of just very, very obstinate stubbornness with their, hey, nobody can make us change this.
1:13:11And the more governments around the world try to make them change it, the more they're digging in.
1:13:18Yeah, 30% was revolutionary when it came out, like compared to what a lot of the other stores were charging at the time.
1:13:23But there is an argument that you could have been Thompson-ed your way to a managed ecosystem over the last 20 years.
1:13:29Yep, yep.
1:13:30What else happened in – did we move to April?
1:13:34No.
1:13:35Yes.
1:13:36Oh, yeah, that was where the EU fines came in.
1:13:39All right, let's move on to May.
1:13:41In May, I've got a lot of links, more EU stuff.
1:13:45We covered that.
1:13:48There was some anti-anti-steering injunction.
1:13:52I think with the – that was with the Epic case.
1:13:57I think that's where – yeah, with Fortnite returning to the App Store.
1:14:01Judge Gonzalez Rogers, that's the month where she kind of had enough of Apple's bullshit.
1:14:07But again, I think Apple – I guess the point I wanted to make a couple minutes ago is I think there are people within Apple, and I do think this comes from Tim Cook because I do think it is – it's how his mind works.
1:14:20And nobody but a fool is going to disagree with that, and therefore, if one choice gets you four and the other gets you three, four is the way to go.
1:14:40The problem is that there are other things that you cannot assign a numeric value to.
1:14:46I think the goodwill that Apple is continuing to squander with its obstinacy in these cases in the U.S., in the EU, and in other places everywhere, almost everywhere around the world.
1:15:03I'm sure anybody at Apple would concede that it's not a good look for them and that they know that some developers, developer relations are frayed because of it.
1:15:14But I do think that they – I think the proof of the way they're acting is evidence that they underestimate the value of those things that are being damaged, the goodwill, their reputation, how they are perceived.
1:15:33You can't put a financial vet number on it, but I do think that they're underestimating how much they've squandered in that regard.
1:15:42Even just the user experience, not even for the developers, because I think like the classic ranking is what's good for Apple, then what's good for customers, then what's good for developers.
1:15:50But even for customers, like the preponderance of MacGyvering that they've done to just buy something on the App Store in all these different countries now, it's just – it's not been a good UX for a long time, and it doesn't seem like it's getting better.
1:16:01And I think the UX argument alone is powerful.
1:16:03Also in May, Patrick McGee's Apple in China.
1:16:08I think without question, the Apple book of the year dropped.
1:16:12I should put a link to the show notes.
1:16:14I had Patrick on the show.
1:16:16It was a great interview.
1:16:17I don't think we have to rehash it, but it's a great book and sort of opened my eyes to a lot of aspects of Apple's relationship with China that just never – it's not that I never pulled the strings.
1:16:31I think there's so much original reporting in Patrick's book.
1:16:34It's – he both collected all of the reporting that was extant on the issue and took that and then did so much original reporting.
1:16:45It's really – it's just a fantastic book, book of the year.
1:16:48And Johnny Ive and Sam Altman jointly announced I.O. with lowercase I, lowercase O, much to my consternation.
1:16:56But I'm learning to live with it.
1:16:58But that's – in fact, here we are in the end of December, and it's still just an announcement, right?
1:17:03I mean, it's coming, but not much to say about it.
1:17:07I don't know if it's going to be a brooch or a Rubik's Cube.
1:17:10Yeah.
1:17:10CarPlay Ultra shipped and got named.
1:17:13Previously, it was called Next Generation CarPlay.
1:17:15Now we know it's called CarPlay Ultra.
1:17:18Yeah.
1:17:20Still don't know how much Apple cares about CarPlay.
1:17:22That's hard to say, right?
1:17:25I think they do care a lot, but it is a unique animal, right, where I don't know that anybody at Apple wants to be driving a car.
1:17:37It doesn't have a good CarPlay system, right?
1:17:39Because – and whatever their own car project was and however many people at Apple were filled in enough to think, yeah, maybe in a couple years that's what I'll be driving.
1:17:50But, you know, that's gone, right?
1:17:53That's over.
1:17:54So I think they care enough, but is that enough?
1:18:01I don't know.
1:18:02There's this dangerous ground where if you don't care at all, you cancel things.
1:18:05If you care a lot, you invest a ton in things.
1:18:08But Apple just has so many pieces on the board now that it's hard to tell what's, like, at maintenance mode.
1:18:13Remember that the remote app famously had one part, like, one engineer half-time.
1:18:18Yeah, yeah.
1:18:18She's been going for a while.
1:18:19Like, it's hard to tell what level of investment.
1:18:21And I'm sure Ultra has much more because it's much higher profile and it's much newer.
1:18:26But compared to, like, the next version of iOS or – it's just hard to tell.
1:18:29And I do think that the next generation thing, there is – right from when they announced it many WWDCs ago.
1:18:36I think 23 was when they announced it.
1:18:38Maybe it was 22.
1:18:41The whole premise of it, of giving Apple more control or putting in Apple's hands more of the interface to the car, that that – hey, is that really going to fly with these proud car makers who want to put their brand forward?
1:18:57Or just want the data.
1:18:58Right.
1:18:59Yeah, which is something nobody wants to talk about.
1:19:02It certainly seems like it's going a little slower than anybody had hoped.
1:19:08But it's not dead, right?
1:19:10What was Aston Martin who shipped the first one?
1:19:13But it's also clearly given that it's Aston Martin primarily or only at this point.
1:19:18I still don't know that anybody else has shipped what's called CarPlay Ultra.
1:19:22It's clearly not a mass market product yet.
1:19:26I know –
1:19:27And Eli has car executives on every week saying they're going to get rid of it.
1:19:30They're not going to get rid of it.
1:19:31They might get rid of it.
1:19:32Right.
1:19:32Right.
1:19:33And you've still got – the Rivian CEO was on with Ben Thompson on Stratech in his last interview of the year saying that they're as firmly entrenched in doing their own thing for the entertainment and not doing CarPlay or Android Auto than as they've ever –
1:19:50Which Tesla famously hasn't done.
1:19:53But Tesla skipping ahead in a year.
1:19:55But I guess we won't come back to it.
1:19:57Again, I think it's German was rumored to be trying or testing CarPlay integration but only CarPlay, which is kind of interesting.
1:20:06But I also think explicable because I think iPhone users really – a lot of iPhone users really want CarPlay in particular.
1:20:14And I think for most Android users, not all because there's definitely the subset of Android users who buy flagship phones and are really, really care about Android in a way that iOS nerds care about iOS.
1:20:27But I think for the most part, that doesn't spread to mainstream people, people who don't listen to the talk show or don't know – or a better example, people who don't know who MKBHD is, right?
1:20:39Yeah.
1:20:40Those people who have Android – people who have an Android phone and have never heard of Marques Brownlee are the sort of people who do not give a shit what's going on with their computer in their car, right?
1:20:53They just don't.
1:20:54And I think they're probably happy and impressed by Tesla's or Rivian's built-in system because they're not juiced into the Android ecosystem the way that casual – a lot of casual iPhone users are where they've got a podcast app on their phone, whatever it is, and they want it in their car.
1:21:13And the only way to have that is through CarPlay.
1:21:15Or, I mean, Apple could just – when you turn the phone sideways, the same way they have bedtime mode, they could give us CarPlay mode in a car without needing the integration, and then you could have it everywhere.
1:21:23I don't know.
1:21:24I don't know, but it seems a little slow.
1:21:28Let's see.
1:21:29All right.
1:21:29That brings us to June and then the halfway mark of the year afterwards, but that's WWDC 2025.
1:21:39I don't really have a lot of thoughts about it.
1:21:40I guess in hindsight, the big thing was liquid glass and the visual changes to the user interface.
1:21:46And the rename of the rebranding.
1:21:48And the rebranding, which I just wrote about.
1:21:50I think – I liked it at the start.
1:21:53I thought, oh, this is great.
1:21:55I think this is going to work out.
1:21:58And selfishly, because of what I do professionally, combined with my rocketing through – not towards, but through middle age and my memory, therefore, not being what it used to be, keeping track of what is the current version number of this OS.
1:22:16All the difference, yeah.
1:22:18Which ones are numbered?
1:22:19There were several –
1:22:20The iPhone is higher than the Mac.
1:22:21Right.
1:22:22The iPhone is higher than the Mac, which never made sense.
1:22:27But the Mac being behind because up until 10.13 or 10.14, they just kept adding a decimal.
1:22:37And because it was Mac OS X originally, they started every version number with 10 dot.
1:22:42And the dot –
1:22:43And originally there was more than one year between the versions.
1:22:46It was actually – the 10 was nothing.
1:22:49And it was the thing after the dot that was the actual version number.
1:22:53And then they eventually ripped that Band-Aid off and said, this is dumb.
1:22:57Let's just give it a real number.
1:22:58But then by the time they did that, iOS was versions ahead, which made no sense.
1:23:03This is great.
1:23:06And when did that come out?
1:23:07Somebody would be talking about this is supported on iOS 12 and up.
1:23:15Well, how far back does iOS 12 go?
1:23:17I don't remember.
1:23:19This new system where all of the OSs get the same primary integer and that integer is based on the main year that those OSs will be the current OS.
1:23:33They didn't make that mistake because a lot of companies named it the same year and then would ship it to next year and then it seemed old and they were smart enough to avoid that.
1:23:40Well, I was about to ask you, do you agree?
1:23:44I agree.
1:23:45I don't even know that inside Apple they even – once they decided we should name them by the year, I don't even know that there was much internal discussion over whether it should be like these – the ones we use today should be 25.0 or 25.2 or 26.
1:24:01Instantly old, yeah.
1:24:03There are – and trust me because when I wrote about it, I heard from a handful of them.
1:24:07And I do understand the counter argument that they came out in 25.
1:24:11They were announced in June of 2025.
1:24:14The betas came out in the summer of 2025 and they all shipped in September of 2025.
1:24:19Therefore, they should all be 25.
1:24:22I completely – and there are – the people who feel this way are – feel very, very strongly about it.
1:24:28And there is – there's a rational, logical argument to be had there.
1:24:34And I have to completely concede that, yes, they came out in September 2025.
1:24:39So you are correct.
1:24:41And so they could be named 25.
1:24:42But I don't think it makes any sense from a marketing perspective because, for example, the version that started auto-installing on people's phones that have the –
1:24:54hey, I'll just take the upgrade whenever you push it to my phone was 26.2, which only came out 10 days ago.
1:25:01So most people who are going to be running iOS 26 only got it or are starting to get it now.
1:25:09So it's – they're all – the fact that it shipped for the early – us early adopters or people who bought the brand new iPhone 17 generation in September,
1:25:19it's a minority of the users.
1:25:21And even for the people who jumped on it on day one, most of the time they're going to spend with it will be in 2026.
1:25:28I don't think it makes any sense.
1:25:30Yeah.
1:25:30And most of the releases will happen in 20 – like there'll be releases for it from January to September 2026.
1:25:36Like the majority of its life will be 2026.
1:25:38I do guess the downsides, I guess it sort of commits Apple to keeping all of these OSs on an annual schedule.
1:25:48But I don't – forever is a long time, but for the near future, everything has been getting – everything Apple does, hardware and software, has getting more annualized.
1:26:02The iPhone has always been the one product that never budges from it, but everything has been getting more annual, cycleized.
1:26:12And I think that's a good – I think Apple is a more annual company than any other big company.
1:26:19And I think they see that as a key to their recent success.
1:26:24It's an artificial constraint and out of constraints, necessity is the mother of invention, right?
1:26:31It's good to have to ship on a regular basis and not pull a Windows Vista and sort of let seven years spiral out of control because you want to make this thing so big and impressive.
1:26:45And the risk is that maybe it keeps you from doing the big impressive thing that would take five years to build.
1:26:54And can you do that in parallel with keeping the old thing updated every year?
1:26:59You probably could by just sort of making the annual – nobody has to – if tvOS 27 is really not an impressive update, if it could have been 26.9, 26.10, 26.11, but they just call it 27.0 to keep it in parallel, nobody cares.
1:27:22You just stagger the size of the project to fit what your resources are.
1:27:26But also, they went to 64-bit in an incredibly managed way over a bunch of years that was almost completely transparent to end users, which was not the case with a lot of people.
1:27:37And they just replaced things sequentially, like one thing this year, one thing the next year, get your binaries updated, do these things.
1:27:44And I think like on the iPhone and the watch, nobody even noticed by that point.
1:27:49Totally transparent.
1:27:50F1, the movie came out in June, I think by far.
1:27:56Apple –
1:27:56Oh, sorry, Don.
1:27:57There was one thing I wanted to mention is the reason I like this so much is it's the fresh bread thing.
1:28:01It's like you go to the bakery, you want to buy fresh bread.
1:28:04Nobody goes to the bakery every day.
1:28:06Well, a few people go to the bakery every day.
1:28:08So they wouldn't need to make fresh bread every day.
1:28:10But any day you go, you want fresh bread.
1:28:12And I think when they don't update things and you buy it like in the second or third year, you're paying the same money because Apple never lowers prices.
1:28:19But you're getting like – like they didn't update the iMac for a couple of years.
1:28:23So you're getting an M1 iMac three years later.
1:28:25Or you're getting like the old OS.
1:28:27So I think it behooves – it's a good feature for consumers to always have like a fresh operating system, a fresh chipset, a fresh thing in the products on an annual cadence.
1:28:35Yeah, I agree with that.
1:28:37I like that analogy.
1:28:38And it is the difference between – it's another one of the – the difference – one of the many differences between hardware and software.
1:28:45And I think in today's world for security reasons and for sort of feature parity and syncing, it's more important than ever for Apple to be pushing most people to stay up to date.
1:29:02I'm – I'm at least for now debating.
1:29:06I'm still probably – if you ask me to make my commitment right now, I'd say I'm going to pass on the whole year of macOS 26 Tahoe on my main work Mac.
1:29:15Yeah, same.
1:29:16It might be the – and going back half an hour there, it might be the main reason I don't buy an M5 MacBook Pro next year in the early part of the year when we expect it to come out because it will only run macOS 26.
1:29:32But for the people who aren't making a decision on very – for very specific nerdy reasons that I'm thinking I might stay with macOS 15, it's more important.
1:29:43And it tells you, hey, yes, your OS is up to date.
1:29:46It's the current year, 26.
1:29:48Yeah.
1:29:48I like that.
1:29:49I mentioned F1.
1:29:51The movie came out in June.
1:29:53I think by far and away Apple's original content movie is the biggest hit they've made.
1:29:59I actually still have not watched it even though I very much want to and really wanted – I wanted to see it in a theater but just never got around to it.
1:30:07And now it's out and it's gotten all the way to being available free to stream on Apple TV and just haven't had a movie night where it felt like the right call.
1:30:17But they keep pushing ahead and sort of ties in.
1:30:20We can just talk that it's – I don't think it's a coincidence that they pushed a big budget Brad Pitt action movie about F1 in the same calendar year when they signed a big deal to make Apple TV the home of F1, actual F1 racing on streaming.
1:30:37Push is a good word because I remember you wrote about the push notifications or how it showed up across the entire operating system.
1:30:45Yeah, yeah, that they maybe overdid it a little.
1:30:49What was the headline I wrote?
1:30:51Let's see.
1:30:52I have it here.
1:30:52There's this old story, and I don't know how true it is still, that marketing would never let –
1:30:57Apple's trusty-roading F1, the movie Wallet Ad.
1:31:00They put an ad in the wallet app.
1:31:03Yeah, there was this old story that marketing would never let services push, like, those kinds of messages.
1:31:09So they would just wait until Phil was on vacation and then push them all.
1:31:13And I don't know if that's still true, but I always remember those stories whenever I get a push notification ad.
1:31:19Someday I will have to have Phil on the show and will have to ask how true that is.
1:31:29He's on vacation and his phone blows up and he's like, what?
1:31:31I bet there's like any – wherever there's smoke, there's fire and there's something to it.
1:31:38But I don't think it's quite as true as, hey, when Phil Schiller is on vacation, you can do anything you want no matter how angry he's going to be when he comes back.
1:31:47Because if it's a vacation, he is coming back, right?
1:31:51Well, it's the thing like some people really – my understanding is the argument was some people value the experience.
1:31:55It was the same thing like Steve not wanting too many Apple logos is that the overall brand value was important.
1:32:01And other people said, no, we have this platform.
1:32:03We have a billion phones in pockets.
1:32:04That's an incredible business opportunity.
1:32:07And you have those two sides of the argument who sometimes win and sometimes lose.
1:32:11All right.
1:32:12Let's take a break here.
1:32:13We're halfway through the year.
1:32:14So let's take a break and thank our second sponsor.
1:32:17And who better to close out the last episode of the talk show in 2025 than our longest running, most loyal sponsor, Squarespace, the all-in-one platform to build your brand online.
1:32:31Hey, New Year's is the perfect time to sort of tackle everybody has their resolutions.
1:32:39If one of your resolutions is the sort of, hey, maybe I should like make my website look better or build a website that I don't have or replace an old website or whatever, go take a look at Squarespace before you try anything else.
1:32:54They've got everything you need from domain name registration to templates to choose from to a zillion features for things like adding a blog or hosting a podcast or having a store or selling time if you're a consultant or a trainer or something like that.
1:33:12All of that stuff.
1:33:14Payments.
1:33:15Everything you might want a modern website to do, Squarespace has on their platform.
1:33:20And what better time of the year than New Year's to sort of, hey, take some time, try it out.
1:33:26You get a 30-day free trial with all new accounts with no limits, no watermarks, nothing like that.
1:33:3230 days to build the website that you want to make, see how it works.
1:33:37And at the end of the 30 days, that's the first time you'll be asked to pay.
1:33:42And when you do, just use the code TALKSHOW, and they'll know you came from here.
1:33:46You can go to squarespace.com slash TALKSHOW to start.
1:33:50But when you pay, just remember to use that code TALKSHOW.
1:33:53Know the, just TALKSHOW to save 10% off your first order up to, you can prepay for up to an entire year of service.
1:34:02Get that code applied that's like getting 10% of the year for free.
1:34:07Squarespace.com slash TALKSHOW.
1:34:09Literally anything you might want to do with a website in today's world, you could do on Squarespace.
1:34:17My thanks to them for their continuing support of the show.
1:34:20Go try them out, or tell your friends who need a new website to try them out for me.
1:34:24Thanks.
1:34:25All right.
1:34:27Second half of the year.
1:34:28July.
1:34:29July.
1:34:32Not much.
1:34:33Jeff Williams announced his retirement, or I guess his, it did retire as COO in July.
1:34:39That's about it.
1:34:40That was huge, though, because he was chief operating officer, succeeded Tim Cook, but he also became head of design at Apple.
1:34:48And I know people like to say that ops didn't get in the way of design, but it absolutely did.
1:34:55And I think that's a huge turning point for Apple.
1:34:57And you and I have talked about this privately, but the entire design team almost, the original design team is at love from with Johnny Ive now.
1:35:06They've got new designers.
1:35:07For a company that has become Apple on Johnny Ive design is now, for the first time, I think, totally going in a new way, new blood, new generation.
1:35:27It remains to be seen how much operations is still in the way of design or contributing to design or I don't know.
1:35:33It just feels like a new era.
1:35:35And I don't get the impression that there's bad blood.
1:35:40I don't know how I would know.
1:35:41Jeff Williams is not a public figure, per se.
1:35:45I did see later, just I guess it's recent news, that he joined the board at Disney.
1:35:50There was speculation.
1:35:52And I do think, I said this last week with Quinn on the show, Tim Cook was COO before he became CEO.
1:36:00And that's an example of one.
1:36:03But there aren't many examples of CEO transitions for modern Apple, where I would define modern Apple as from the reunification with Next in beginning of 1997.
1:36:15Right, because the pre-1997 Apple CEO story was so bananas and so unlike anything.
1:36:29There are no lessons for Apple to learn from that, really.
1:36:33It's not even, well, we want to avoid the mistake we made in 19-whatever, 1990-whatever, when we hired Michael Spindler.
1:36:40I mean, that just isn't going to happen.
1:36:42Nothing is similar.
1:36:44No Gil Emilio story.
1:36:46Right.
1:36:47But there was the, well, if the old COO, who was a tall, southern man, who's sort of soft-spoken and began appearing in Apple keynotes, became the next CEO, wouldn't Jeff Williams be the obvious choice for the next CEO after Cook?
1:37:06And I think it was probably true that he was the, if something emergency happened, if Tim Cook suffered a medical crisis or something and-
1:37:15If he won the lottery.
1:37:16Right?
1:37:18Yeah, yeah.
1:37:19I mean, suddenly became wealthy and didn't need his paycheck anymore.
1:37:24If he stopped living paycheck to paycheck.
1:37:26Yeah.
1:37:27I think it's almost certainly the case that Jeff Williams would have been named his emergency successor or, in the case of a health crisis or something, the temporary CEO.
1:37:35It's the hit-by-a-bus scenario that every company has to, as a part of being a public company, account for.
1:37:40Right.
1:37:43But I don't think he was ever the planned successor because he's too close in age.
1:37:47He's only, like, two years younger than Cook.
1:37:48So, presuming that Cook, the fact that he's still in the job right now at age 64, 65, whatever he is, was always his plan, and I think it probably was, I don't think there was ever any plausible scenario where Jeff Williams would be his successor upon his planned retirement.
1:38:05Whether his planned retirement is, let's just say, leaving early in 2026, like we're months away from Tim Cook saying, hey, I've had a good run and I'm resigning or retiring.
1:38:16I don't think there was ever a plan that it would be Jeff Williams because Jeff Williams is 62.
1:38:21And I think Jeff Williams, if he ever had any aspirations of being the CEO, they were long ago.
1:38:29You know, I don't know that he ever did because I think he knew he could do the math on Tim Cook's age as well as he could.
1:38:36I do think it's why Jeff Williams appeared in all the Apple Watch segments publicly for so long for the last 10 years to familiarize the public with him in case he ever needed to step up into a bigger role.
1:38:50Which is what Steve did with Tim.
1:38:52Like, he made him do marketing.
1:38:53He made him do – just because he said one day you might have to do this.
1:38:57Right. And I do think it's why I don't think Sabi Khan is in any way being positioned for that.
1:39:05The current COO who had worked under Jeff Williams for a long time and has been at Apple for a very long time was, in fact, the legendary figure who – of that story of – from, I don't know, 2008, 2009, when there was some kind of internal meeting at Apple about an emergency in China.
1:39:23And somebody in the meeting, he was like, well, you're going to have to go there and fix this.
1:39:27And 15 minutes later, Cook looked at him again and was like, why are you still here?
1:39:31And that's when the guy realized, oh, you want me to go like now and just said, okay, and stood up from the meeting, left, and went right to SFO with what he had in his pockets.
1:39:42And booked a ticket to China and just bought clothes when he got there.
1:39:48That was Sabi Khan.
1:39:49Yeah.
1:39:51He was still there.
1:39:52But the fact that he – I have no idea what his voice sounds like.
1:39:56I barely know what he looks like because every once in a while I look at the bios page.
1:40:02I would guess that the fact that he has no public presence in keynotes or any other press event means that he's not in any way being prepped to step up to a larger role.
1:40:15I believe he's now at the largest role he's going to have at Apple and that's it and it's sort of off the beaten path.
1:40:21Compare and contrast with the people who are speculated as possible successors to Cook, John Ternus and Craig Federighi, Jaws even, who are obviously very, very public and featured annually in their public keynotes.
1:40:36But also, and I think Quinn mentioned this in his video, like it does clear the deck, like in a way that Steve Jobs never did because Scott Forstall was very contentious with Tim Cook when Tim Cook took over.
1:40:47And this does leave a very clear roadmap for whoever comes next.
1:40:52There's no doubt in your mind that Jeff Williams is over your shoulder.
1:40:55Yeah.
1:40:56Not wanting to play nice.
1:40:58Yeah, and I think, again, boy, I wish somebody would write a book and really detail that.
1:41:04Maybe enough time has passed that people would talk.
1:41:06But there was a, what do they call it about Abraham Lincoln, that he had a cabinet of rivals that he named because of the, maybe not cabinet of rivals, but that it supposedly, or the way it's told historically,
1:41:20is that because of the civil war and the need to unify the country that he'd stocked his cabinet with some of his biggest political rivals, but who were on the side of the union and that they had this forever, whatever other disagreements they had about this, that, the other thing.
1:41:35Here's this one unifying thing.
1:41:37And we disagree with each other vehemently in these other regards, but we need to save the country.
1:41:42And I think Steve Jobs sort of ran his executive cabinet in a similar way where he could have people who hated each other, but because everything went through Steve, he could manage that, right?
1:41:57And I don't think it's any secret.
1:42:00I think it's maybe the opposite of a secret that Johnny Ive in particular did not get along with Scott Forstall.
1:42:07I've heard from multiple sources over the years that at some point, this is after Steve had passed and Cook took over, because I think avoiding this sort of declaration is exactly the sort of thing that Steve Jobs was good at, right?
1:42:24And as much as it's like, he wasn't just like running around telling people their work is shit, or why the fuck doesn't it do what it was supposed to do?
1:42:31He could have two people who hate each other work together because they both loved working for Steve Jobs.
1:42:37And he could, that was part of his genius, was managing.
1:42:42They were doing the work of their lives, working with him.
1:42:45Right. But at some point before Tim Cook pulled the band-aid off and said, okay, we got to fix this, Forstall's out, and we'll move on without him, that Johnny Ive had declared that he would no longer attend any meetings if Forstall was going to be present.
1:43:02I don't know if that's true, but I've heard that multiple times, certainly jibes with everything we do know about the personality conflicts.
1:43:11Forstall was extremely popular as a leader for the people in his division.
1:43:18The iPhone software division ultimately is what he was in charge of.
1:43:22And the people who worked under him, I never heard, I never heard from somebody who worked under him who didn't like him.
1:43:29And they thought he both did good work, had good taste, led the team to produce good work.
1:43:37And I think the early, how we view in hindsight, the early versions of iOS and iPadOS and the apps for them speak to that.
1:43:45And that he had their back across the company when they needed something from outside the division.
1:43:53If they needed, I don't know what it would be, but if it's some kind of feature, resources or servers or some kind of API access from somebody else outside Forstall's purview, he had the team's back.
1:44:08I've heard that multiple times.
1:44:09He also seemed to be able to uniquely distill, what I've heard is when he wasn't there, it was chaos because nobody could get Steve the yellow icon he wanted.
1:44:19But when Scott was there, he could say, Steve will absolutely like one of these three.
1:44:22And Steve chose one of those three.
1:44:25So he was very good at translating what Steve wanted into things that his team could produce.
1:44:30And that no longer was necessary after Steve Jobs was dead.
1:44:34In some ways, I do think Apple forever still misses Scott Forstall.
1:44:45But I also think it was probably true that it was untenable to keep him and Johnny Ive.
1:44:53And if that decision had to be made and it was one of the other.
1:44:57If it really, I think that's too simplistic because I suspect that more of the other people at that level were like, if somebody's got to go, it should be Forstall because I don't think he was popular with them either.
1:45:09The style changed radically, even if the Apple didn't change radically.
1:45:13Right, right.
1:45:14The CEO style changed so radically.
1:45:17And I think it was also part of Cook listening to the one thing he claims to listen to Steve Jobs about, which is his advice to don't ask what I would do.
1:45:28Do it.
1:45:28Make the decision for yourself and basically do it your way.
1:45:32And Apple is very much as much as it's like a tree where the central rings of the tree are all infused with Steve Jobs' DNA.
1:45:43But the last 10 years, 15 years of rings of the tree are very Tim Cook-y.
1:45:49The company is much more in Tim Cook's mold than it was before, which is a sign of good leadership that he was able to steer the company without breaking it, right?
1:46:01Without making it at any point unrecognizable.
1:46:04Jeff is going out on his own terms.
1:46:06Like, it's someone who's done profound work for Apple and is going out without any, like, controversy or...
1:46:12Yeah.
1:46:13I think it's that simple.
1:46:14I think the guy retired.
1:46:15I think the guy had a very long run, and I think he did a very good job, and I think he retired.
1:46:19What does it say to the company?
1:46:21Like, it's time for his family to enjoy spending time with his money.
1:46:24And I think, unlike Phil Schiller, who could retire as Senior Vice President of Product Marketing and let Jaws take over that entire role, but had other significant product positions that he could still run, the App Store and Events are the two, in that role as Apple Fellow.
1:46:48There's nothing like that for Jeff Williams, right?
1:46:51It's once he's retired.
1:46:52Or he doesn't have to come back like Bob Mansfield.
1:46:54Right.
1:46:55There's nothing ancillary like that for him.
1:46:58And maybe he doesn't have an interest or doesn't want to.
1:47:00Maybe there could have been, but he was like, no, I actually want to retire.
1:47:03Like, it's usually a euphemism when somebody, politics, corporate, whatever it is, retires or resigns to spend more time with their family.
1:47:12That is usually an incredible euphemism for whatever actually went wrong.
1:47:17But it really might be the case.
1:47:19It would be nice if he was like, no, I've made a lot of money.
1:47:23Well, Luca stayed on.
1:47:23They have a lot of times where people, or Dan Riccio stayed on for special projects.
1:47:27Like, they've had a lot of that as well.
1:47:28Yeah.
1:47:29And he did stay for six months.
1:47:31And I don't think it was, as we'll get to for other executive exodices coming soon.
1:47:36I don't think it was for show.
1:47:38I think it was to actually do things.
1:47:40But I think it's sort of like, this is the good outcome, right?
1:47:42What do we wait, what's the alternative for Jeff Williams to work there as COO until he's 80 and die in the job?
1:47:49He worked to retirement age and retired.
1:47:52And I think that's it.
1:47:53But I do think it does raise those questions about who is making industrial design choices at Apple and what is that going to look like for the next 10 years?
1:48:00Yeah.
1:48:01I do, too.
1:48:03And I've heard, given, and again, a lot of it got, you know, we're skipping ahead to December and the Allen Dye stuff.
1:48:09But it always did seem curious that the design teams reported to Jeff Williams.
1:48:16I sort of took that as not that Jeff Williams was running design and was going to suddenly impose his taste on design.
1:48:27And there's no evidence, zero evidence that anybody can point to from that point onward after Johnny Ive left and this was reorganized that there was any kind of shift like that.
1:48:39I think it was more Jeff Williams as emergency CEO in glass, right?
1:48:47And I've heard, I did hear, it wasn't like, oh, it was in name only and they didn't really report to him.
1:48:55Jeff Williams was there in design meetings as the person who they were reporting to all the time and frequently.
1:49:03What I heard from other people who were in those meetings was he just, he was there to okay stuff.
1:49:10He wasn't really in the mix.
1:49:13It's what you think, basically, from the outside.
1:49:16It wasn't nothing, but it wasn't, it certainly wasn't essential to the design process in any way.
1:49:22Although I did hear that, like, in the Steve Jobs era, there was like a literal wall of fire where operations people could not get in to design.
1:49:30And afterwards, that was no longer the case.
1:49:32And I don't know how many, like, $5 billion chamfer edges you could push through anymore at that point.
1:49:38I, yeah.
1:49:40For good or for ill.
1:49:42Yeah.
1:49:43And I do think that maybe that's the, it was little things like that.
1:49:49And we don't know what we've missed, right?
1:49:51If it really, from when Steve Jobs was still there to when Jeff would, and then skip the whole Johnny Ives as chief design officer transition, and then Johnny's gone.
1:50:02And now Jeff Williams is there.
1:50:04That transition period of Johnny Ives still being in charge of design is over.
1:50:11And there's, hey, there's two options for next year's iPhone.
1:50:16And the one is the 39% profit margins.
1:50:20Yes.
1:50:21And the other one is really nicer.
1:50:23Take a look at this.
1:50:24Look at this chamfered edge, right?
1:50:25Look at this.
1:50:27But that really is expensive to do that.
1:50:30That would be a 37% profit margin.
1:50:32That might be the sort of thing where a different answer comes out of the medium than before or during the Johnny Ives transition years.
1:50:42And I don't think it's like totally, hey, we could make this thing out of cheap plastic or we could make it out of premium polished titanium.
1:50:51It's not cheap versus luxury.
1:50:55It's little things at the edges of, hey, you know, it's only half a point of margin.
1:51:00It's impossible not to think that Jeff Williams was more interested in that lost half point of margin than other people who were in charge of design before.
1:51:10Or people who could totally get into the vault.
1:51:12Or just Johnny Ives from when Johnny Ives was still there and the chief design officer, right?
1:51:17I don't think – I think I could say as a fact without trying to get in contact with both of them and get them on the record.
1:51:25That Johnny Ives gave a little – cared a little less about each tenth of a percent of profit margin than Jeff Williams did.
1:51:32But he was also – he was making Apple Park by then.
1:51:36I don't know how much he was paying attention to iPhones.
1:51:38Right.
1:51:39Exactly.
1:51:39But it ultimately ran up to him.
1:51:42And I think in the same way that Jeff Williams was still the chief operating officer and had all of those responsibilities, it's not that he was doing design on the side.
1:51:50But it was sort of like at some point things that are ready need to be – get the final okay and that's who they went to.
1:51:56And I think even when Johnny, in his second half of his stint as chief design officer, was spending most of his time on and finishing Apple Park, still those decisions eventually came to him for, okay, these are the colors we're going to go with this year, right?
1:52:11These are the – this is the final lineup of new watch straps for this season.
1:52:16Okay, Johnny, take a look at him.
1:52:18Tell us what you think, right?
1:52:20Ultimately, he's the one who signed off on that stuff.
1:52:22August 2025.
1:52:24I got nothing.
1:52:25That's the sign of a good August, right?
1:52:29Yes.
1:52:30September.
1:52:32The awe-dropping event when the iPhone 17, 17 Pro Max, the – oh, not 17 Air, just the iPhone Air, AirPods Pro 3,
1:52:46and the Apple Watch Series 11 and Ultra 3.
1:52:48You finally get everything on the same number and then the air drops the number.
1:52:52And then the air drops the number, which –
1:52:55Just so Apple.
1:52:56I've – we're running long and I think as we usually do, as I recall, is we spend more time looking back at the earlier part of the year where it's more reminiscing and the more recent parts of the year that everybody's still got in their RAM we can spend less time on.
1:53:13You know, I know the rumors even just last week, some new rumor came out that the iPhone – the next iPhone Air might be on pace for September again, not for an 18-month refresh.
1:53:25Who knows?
1:53:26Who knows why they didn't call it a 17?
1:53:28Especially when they called the 16E, the 16E, and we expect a 17E.
1:53:35If they added a number to the one that didn't have a number, the SE, and then they took away the number from a new one.
1:53:43They only had that one extra number, John.
1:53:45They had to – good.
1:53:46It does seem interesting.
1:53:48Air 2 next year or is it iPhone?
1:53:50Yeah, exactly.
1:53:51All right.
1:53:52Exactly.
1:53:53Exactly.
1:53:54What do they do?
1:53:54Now they're going to renumber them with other numbers?
1:53:57Why would they do that if they were going to use numbers?
1:53:59Or –
1:54:00The new iPhone Air.
1:54:02Yeah, is it a little bit more like iPad Air and MacBook Air where they don't give them names and, yes, you just look up which chip is in it, right?
1:54:12It's the –
1:54:14A20 iPhone Air.
1:54:15Yeah.
1:54:16iPhone Air with the A20.
1:54:18Who knows?
1:54:19I think the new – I don't have much to say about these things that I haven't said repeatedly over the last few months.
1:54:25No, they're great.
1:54:26I think about them, I do really wish I did buy an iPhone and now carry my own iPhone 17 Pro, not Macs, specifically and mainly because it is narrower in my hand.
1:54:40It is the thing that kept me from buying, and I was so close, really, and no pun intended from my other podcast, dithered for months over which one to buy for myself because I had the luxury of both as review units that I could switch back and forth with.
1:54:56Kudos, by the way, to Apple for the eSIM support, which has gotten so good.
1:55:02It is really – it takes two minutes to switch with no tools, no worries about water sealing or anything.
1:55:09Really, really – and kudos to my carrier Verizon for never once giving me any grief over the fact that I changed my SIM probably 20 times.
1:55:19It does make it a little harder to review because, like, it's so easy to review when you can just move a SIM card back and forth.
1:55:24It's certain with a SIM.
1:55:27It is easier, but the eSIM switching is so much easier now.
1:55:32And I read somewhere that Apple and Google are working to really make it pretty easy going from Android to iPhone 2, which is the part that still really sucks compared to a SIM card.
1:55:43But it's – if the Air had two sizes, a bigger size like Macs and a narrower size, the width of the iPhone 17 or 17 Pro, I would have bought the Air in that smaller size.
1:56:00It is the width of the screen that kept me from buying it.
1:56:04I just need the cameras.
1:56:05I'm always going to buy it with the most cameras possible.
1:56:08I've really been paying attention now that I bought and committed myself for the next year to a 17 Pro, how many times I'm using one of the other cameras for something other than macro.
1:56:19Although the macro is nice, I can't say it when I actually macro macro.
1:56:23And I've mentioned this multiple times, and it's so easy to overlook.
1:56:27But every time I do go back to using the Air for a day or just pick it up because I still have my review unit, I do appreciate the extra five centimeters of minimum focal distance.
1:56:39Where for years now, the main camera on the iPhone Pros has a 20 centimeter minimum focal distance.
1:56:46In other words, if your camera is closer than 20 centimeters away, the main camera cannot focus on the subject.
1:56:53And you might say, well, I get closer than 20 centimeters with the 1X camera all the time, and it's focused.
1:56:59That's because your phone and software has switched to the 0.5X ultra-wide, and it's simulating the field of view of the 1X.
1:57:08And you will notice that little yellow flower icon that indicates macro mode is on.
1:57:14And if you turn off macro mode, you will notice that as soon as you get 19 centimeters away from the subject, it'll start getting blurry.
1:57:21And the iPhone Air, which only has one camera, and it has a smaller sensor because it's the Air and it's sort of a thinner, by definition, device, has a totally different camera system.
1:57:32And it has a 15 centimeter minimum focal distance.
1:57:36And that 5 centimeters, 5 centimeters isn't a lot.
1:57:40But when you're doing something like photographing something in your hand or a piece of paper on the table in front of you, that distance is actually right where I want my camera, my phone to be.
1:57:52It's really nice.
1:57:55I would rather have three cameras than the one camera, but that one camera, I could live with it.
1:58:02I know I could.
1:58:03I really could.
1:58:04For me, it's the compression.
1:58:06Maybe it's because I have a face like Gollum, and there's not a lot of compression.
1:58:10Like, my ears are so far back.
1:58:12My nose is so far forward.
1:58:13Especially if you're taking photos of people.
1:58:15I like when you get closer to the 15 millimeters and 80 millimeter functional lenses.
1:58:19Yep.
1:58:20But then you need more light.
1:58:22I mean, because that's the other thing I've really noticed.
1:58:24Even with the 17 Pro, which really has improved the telephoto camera to, it's the best by far they've ever had.
1:58:32It's the first time where they've got the trick where the 4X uses the whole sensor and does the quad pixels.
1:58:40And the 8X uses the center crop of the sensor, but it's one-to-one with the pixels.
1:58:46Yeah.
1:58:47So it's not doing any kind of digital zoom.
1:58:50It is using the – it's just using the center area of the sensor, and it's the first time the telephoto has done that.
1:58:57And it's really noticeably more usable at 8X, but you need a lot of light compared to that 1X.
1:59:04It's not pixel binning, so it's not pulling all – yeah.
1:59:07The watch is nice.
1:59:09I actually bought myself an Ultra 3.
1:59:12I've never owned an Ultra before, and I've only – I think I've only ever bought four Apple Watches.
1:59:18I had the original.
1:59:19Maybe I bought a – no, I bought a Series 0, a 3, a 5, a 7, and now the Ultra 3.
1:59:27I'm on the Ultra 1 still, but I like the Ultra a lot.
1:59:31Yeah.
1:59:32I was curious what you're using, because I know you really love Apple Watch, and I know you were the one who made me – you're the friend I had who owned the ceramic.
1:59:39That made me – yeah.
1:59:41But that's –
1:59:42I'm going to have to upgrade at some point, though, because I have a Canadian Apple Watch, and there's something – like, they don't roam as well as the phones do.
1:59:49Like, I can bring a Canadian phone to America, no problem.
1:59:52The watches don't play nice, so I'm going to have to get an American one.
1:59:56And I – just anecdotally, boy, I see a lot of Ultras out there on people's wrists.
2:00:01I don't know what the explanation is.
2:00:03I – there's sometimes you can – man or woman, you can sort of – if you're a stranger, you see them at the airport or just on the sidewalk, it's – yeah, they kind of look – maybe they're like a hobbyist rock climber or active person who would want to rug in.
2:00:16They're so functional, and they're not that expensive compared to what watches used to cost or what, like, other watches still cost.
2:00:22I wondered, and there is a tremendous battery life difference, right?
2:00:29The battery life on the Ultra – I honestly think Apple undersells it to avoid making the Series 11, Series 10 look bad in comparison.
2:00:38I honestly think maybe the most dishonest Apple's ever been about battery life is with the Ultra watches, and it's on the underselling how long the battery lasts, simply because I think if they really – I think if they added enough more hours of expected battery life as they could legitimately, it would just make the other ones look worse.
2:01:03I really do mean that.
2:01:04I don't think it's a vast underestimation, but it's – it really is different.
2:01:08You just – you could just wear it for days without charging it, and it's fine.
2:01:13It's really –
2:01:14I mean, if you are doing, like, all the hardcore workout stuff, like, you'll run it down faster, but if you're using it as a watchy watch.
2:01:19Yeah.
2:01:20Let's see.
2:01:22Moving on after September, October, I've got a low-key, no-event M5 product intros.
2:01:29Kind of makes sense.
2:01:31Yes, and I know you and I have talked about this on the show and privately many times over the years, and I think it's – I think the most interesting thing about the fact that they didn't have an event for that isn't the products themselves.
2:01:42It's what it says about Apple marketing and PR, that they still do value the attention they get when they hold an event, even if the event is mostly virtual or streaming and the only people who come are invited press to New York or something.
2:02:01There is a – I've always appreciated this, and I don't think other companies do it as well, even though they get less attention for their events.
2:02:11And that's one of the reasons they get less attention for their events.
2:02:14And if they inherited the – hey, all Apple has to do is say they're holding a special event, and you know how much – you know how they're going to dominate tech news for days up to, on, and after.
2:02:28There's people who are most concerned about not the long run of the company or the company's marketing credibility, but the short-term marketing credibility.
2:02:40They'd find it irresistible catnip to just do it.
2:02:43Let's just have a big event for the M5s.
2:02:45And I think they still – I think Apple internally still respects that, and they still preciously guard the attention that their events have.
2:02:56And if they're on the fence about whether an announcement is, quote-unquote, worth holding an event, they err on the side of not doing it.
2:03:04And I think with these M5 ones, it's a perfect example of that.
2:03:07They are very nice updates, so you look at all of the numbers, if you like looking at numbers, like Tim Cook, from benchmarks and et cetera.
2:03:14The M5 versus M4 year-over-year or generation-over-generation if it's not quite 12 months.
2:03:20Very impressive.
2:03:22It seems like Apple Silicon is continuing to improve at the pace that it has been.
2:03:26But does that make it worth an event?
2:03:30Probably not, right?
2:03:31Well, there's nothing they needed to really explain.
2:03:33There's nothing novel that would benefit from stage time where they could take you through and tell you a story about it.
2:03:38Right.
2:03:38That October is also when they announced the F1 Apple TV deal, which we kind of talked about.
2:03:44And I guess the thing we didn't talk about is that it's like the MLS soccer, but I think F1 is going to have more attention because I think more people care about F1, even in the U.S., than they do about MLS soccer.
2:03:56But maybe my anti-soccer bias is showing.
2:03:58But in both cases, they get to do – and again, this is one of those things where you can just listen to what Apple says and believe them.
2:04:05Eddie Q has come out and said that we would like to control, own the whole sport so we can do it our way.
2:04:11And yes, they were in the bidding for the NFL, but if they had gotten NFL games, it would have been something like the Thursday night football package where they get one game a week.
2:04:21Or like Netflix has, which everybody listening right now, as the episode is new, will remember that Netflix hasn't had any NFL games all year, but they had a Christmas Day package of two games.
2:04:32Two games all year, only on Christmas Day.
2:04:35Maybe Apple could have gotten that.
2:04:37Certainly they could have, but I think – and they bid, and when they have Friday night baseball where they do one or two games every Friday night, and that's it out of the thousands and thousands of baseball games MLB plays every year.
2:04:50Each team plays 162 games.
2:04:54So it's not that they stay away from sports if they can't own the whole sport, but they're much more interested – they'd be much – I think they're much more interested in owning something like F1 or MLS soccer than they would be in doing two games a year on Christmas Day for the NFL.
2:05:11Yes, and that's Apple being Apple.
2:05:13I would love to know, and they haven't announced anything, but I feel like the one thing that's unique about F1 for Apple and their whole product, put all their products on a table, is F1 in particular could have an incredible Vision Pro experience with some kind of live cameras in the car that could somehow do immersive.
2:05:37You're in the cockpit of an F1 car in a live race view.
2:05:40They haven't announced anything like that, and all the sports stuff they do for immersive video isn't live, but eventually it will be.
2:05:48I don't know how soon that will be, but it's inevitable that it will be eventually.
2:05:52And I think an ongoing relationship with F1 could make that super-duper exciting.
2:05:58Anything else for October from you?
2:06:01We're getting close to the end of the year here.
2:06:03November?
2:06:04No, I think the only other story is that with the Apple Silicon, because a lot of people have left Apple and got bought by Qualcomm, got bought by other people, it's a much more competitive ARM space now.
2:06:16So I think it's nice to see Apple still pushing forward and not sort of resting, saying we can take two years between updates.
2:06:23We can calm down on this.
2:06:25They're still being very aggressive on the Silicon.
2:06:27Yeah, I think they are, but I also think it was inevitable that everybody else is sort of catching up to some degree, that the gap is narrowing, because I don't think there's any scenario where the gap that Apple Silicon had in 2020 could be maintained going forward.
2:06:45Because I think they really sort of, with phones, I mean, phones were never on x86, but I think when Apple came out with the existence proof that desktop PCs are actually better on ARM than they are on x86, and therefore they could be, it just punctured the idea that it would never make sense.
2:07:05And now I think the whole industry is sort of moving that direction, which is going to have trickle-down benefits, even for phones, right?
2:07:13Well, Qualcomm bought Nuvia, which was a startup from a bunch of people who left Apple, who were working on previous Apple Silicon chips.
2:07:22So all that technology, and also that approach of building up rather than stripping down, I think was fairly transformative.
2:07:30Yep. All right, November. We talked about Apple and Google and Gurman's reporting that they might be collaborating for Apple Intelligence. We don't need to cover that again.
2:07:39There was my post where I had the title, exploring in detail Apple's compliance with the EU's DMA mandate regarding Apple Watch, third-party accessories, and the syncing of saved Wi-Fi networks from phones to which they're paired.
2:07:53Which is just to revisit the EU stuff, and combine that with a recent thing, which is December, but I'll put it here, where Apple has issued their compliance for the Japanese MSCA, Mobile Software Something Act.
2:08:10Which I think addresses many of the same top-level issues as the DMA, where now Japan gets alternate app marketplaces, they get alternate payments within apps if developers want them.
2:08:25And none of the downsides, like features being pulled, like this Wi-Fi syncing of a new device, or the big one to me, because I use it all the time.
2:08:36And for people who haven't used it, either because they don't have a compatible device or because they live in the EU and can't use it, the iPhone mirroring app on Mac, which still isn't available.
2:08:47And at this point, unless the EU changes, I don't think ever will be available in the EU.
2:08:52And off the record, people, and I don't have any specific examples, but people at Apple, without telling me what they are, are saying that there are future features that they don't see a path to release in the EU under the DMA as it is now.
2:09:08Because they are like iPhone mirroring, where they are in conflict with the DMA because they involve the iPhone and other Apple products communicating via private APIs.
2:09:22The Japanese MSCA doesn't have any of those requirements.
2:09:26It just sort of, to me, is a much better...
2:09:28You can argue about whether the government should be regulating any of these things at all.
2:09:33But if you think that government should be saying, yes, these cell phones are so important to the society that government should have a role, which is an argument I'm very amenable to, the Japanese law is very specific and says things like you have to offer alternate marketplaces for apps.
2:09:49But it doesn't step into the sort of, hey, we should design your product from head to toe, and we'll define what other products your phone should talk to, sort of monolithic approach to regulation that the DMA has.
2:10:08I could obviously go on for much longer about that, but I think it's an interesting example.
2:10:13And I think that this little tiny thing about, hey, now in the EU, if you buy a new Apple Watch, when you first pair it, it will no longer know all of your iPhone's known Wi-Fi networks that you've already saved.
2:10:27It'll only know the ones your iPhone connects to from that point going forward, because if they were going to continue doing that in the EU, they'd have to offer the same feature to other competing devices.
2:10:38And Apple is unwilling to do it for privacy reasons.
2:10:41And there's no other reason for it.
2:10:44I know the other counter argument I've seen people make is that it's just pure spite to make people in the EU hate the DMA.
2:10:50But nobody, this issue is so specific and so particular to just one thing, whether a brand new, newly paired Apple Watch already knows all of the Wi-Fi network passwords that your iPhone does.
2:11:03Nobody is going to go complain to the representative in the EU that they should do something about this, right?
2:11:09This is not going to happen.
2:11:11There is going to be no grassroots effort inspired by the removal of this feature.
2:11:17It is simply because Apple can't bring itself to allow any third-party device, like from Meta or any other no-name company, to you pair it with your iPhone and you assume, well, if it can pair with my iPhone, whatever it gets, Apple must think is okay.
2:11:35And all of a sudden, it knows the details of every Wi-Fi network your iPhone knows, which is incredibly privacy invasive.
2:11:43It's a perfect example of it.
2:11:45And some people disagree with me.
2:11:49People have opinions on the Internet, John.
2:11:50People do, especially people in the EU definitely have opinions.
2:11:55But I don't think it's working out well for them.
2:11:57And I think now we're seeing, I think the Japanese law is a good counterexample of a law that addresses the things people think the DMA is specific about.
2:12:06People think at a very basic level it's about alternate marketplaces and alternate forms of payment in app, right?
2:12:13Those are the two big things.
2:12:14And the Japanese have gotten them without any of the downsides that the DMA brings to everyone in the EU.
2:12:20And so I think it's just an interesting counterexample that's not a hypothetical anymore.
2:12:25It's actually out there in a major market for Apple.
2:12:28And Apple's comments about it are far less confrontational, right?
2:12:34So the argument that Apple just objects to the idea of government regulation, period.
2:12:39Also, we now have a counterexample where they're kind of gracious in their public statements.
2:12:44And, yes, we disagree about this or that.
2:12:46But on the whole, we appreciate the relationship we have with the government in Japan.
2:12:52Apple TV got a new fanfare, the new opening.
2:12:56Now, this is right up your alley.
2:12:58I'm a big fan.
2:12:59And because I put myself out there as a big fan of it.
2:13:02I didn't write about it until December, but it happened in November.
2:13:05So I'll put it here.
2:13:06What do you think of it?
2:13:08They shot it practically, too, which is especially in this era of CGI.
2:13:12Like, never mind AI, but CGI, shooting that practically is just – I mean, that's catnip to anybody who loves, like, visual effects and production.
2:13:22It's very, very Apple.
2:13:24Yeah.
2:13:25I like it more – I mean, I don't think the old one was bad.
2:13:29I just think the old one was too basic.
2:13:31That's my argument about it.
2:13:33It just – and it therefore wasn't iconic in a weird way.
2:13:39The two-plane – I like the new one a lot.
2:13:42And I think most people seem to agree with me.
2:13:45And I do think it's beautiful.
2:13:45If you're going to take several seconds of my life, it should be worth it.
2:13:48Yes, I agree.
2:13:49All right.
2:13:50That gets us to the last month of the year, December, where I feel like the only news is the personnel news.
2:13:56And Quinn and I talked about it in a previous episode, so I don't think we need to spend a lot of time here.
2:14:02But I will say, because I brought up Mark Papermaster on the show with Quinn, and it was just extemporaneous.
2:14:08But then I reread it after the show.
2:14:11So Papermaster was brought over to head up – I forget which – what his exact title was.
2:14:18I don't know.
2:14:18I don't think it was all hardware.
2:14:19It was silicon.
2:14:21Yeah, but also like iPod hardware, sort of.
2:14:24And there was a – when he was brought over in 2007 or 2008, there was a mini-controversy about his non-compete at IBM, where Apple had poached him from, and what it meant.
2:14:36But they worked that out.
2:14:37But then come 2010 with the iPhone 4 and the antenna saga, ultimately he took the fall for it.
2:14:45And the interesting thing is that – I looked it up.
2:14:48It's like he got canned by Apple.
2:14:50So the iPhone 4 came out at the end of June.
2:14:54July was when – a month later was when the antenna gate saga erupted.
2:14:58And I think Papermaster was fired or canned in September.
2:15:04So very quickly.
2:15:06I mean, it was like a few weeks period.
2:15:08And my own reporting had said that there was sort of arrogance from Papermaster's team over the antenna that they did.
2:15:18It wasn't just we need a fall guy.
2:15:20It was ultimately his team that said, no, this won't be an issue.
2:15:25And it really wasn't a killer issue.
2:15:26It just was – it was a fine antenna with a specific flaw is the way I wrote about it.
2:15:31Both detune and detune – I forget which one is which.
2:15:34It would detune and attenuate if you put your finger on that specific spot.
2:15:38For some people, based on the moisture of their skin, right?
2:15:41Some other people could put their finger there and it wouldn't happen.
2:15:44So it had to be held in a certain way by certain people or in certain temperatures.
2:15:49And then it would lose –
2:15:50It was like a network pause play button.
2:15:52If you needed your iPhone to absolutely stop loading a web page, you could touch that spot and it would freeze.
2:15:57And then you take your finger off and it would keep going.
2:15:59Right, but it's interesting to compare his ouster in 2010, which happened very quickly after the antenna things happened.
2:16:08And Apple didn't say it.
2:16:09They didn't say we fired him over the antenna thing because they didn't want to slam the antenna thing because they just had kind of fixed the PR fiasco of saying this antenna is fine.
2:16:18And the iPhone 4 went on to remain on the market for 18 months, not 12 months because it was the last phone with a June release, not an October or September release.
2:16:28But he effectively got canned quickly by Steve Jobs over the antenna thing.
2:16:33And then John Giandrea announced a very graceful, quiet – and it was very quickly superseded by other personnel moves in the same week.
2:16:44I would say even more quiet than we thought on the day that his retirement from Apple was announced.
2:16:51It was quickly superseded by the surprise Alan Dye news going to Meta.
2:16:55So I think Tim Cook got it exactly the way he wanted.
2:16:59I believe that John Giandrea was – his goose was cooked at Apple before March of last year, in February or so, which I think was when Gurman first started reporting,
2:17:13Hey, Apple is thinking about delaying the Siri stuff because it's not ready, right?
2:17:19And it makes sense that that conversation was happening within Apple, and Gurman heard it.
2:17:25His report obviously proved to be correct.
2:17:27And if anything, underestimated the significance of the delay, that it was more or less hitting the reset button on the underlying model and would be a full year delay, not like months.
2:17:38I think at that point that John Giandrea's goose was cooked, but it's Tim – I think it's a purely stylistic difference between Steve Jobs and Tim Cook, where I think – I think – and I have no inside information on this.
2:17:51It's just reading the company from afar.
2:17:53I think Tim Cook's thinking is, well, it's not so much the gentleman's agreement of once you're at the senior vice president level, everybody's got a golden parachute and gets lots of money and gets to save as much face as possible.
2:18:07I mean, whatever his severance was, I'm sure was in a contract and would happen no matter what – how quickly he was ousted from the company.
2:18:15But I think Tim Cook's style is to make as little fuss about it as possible and have it be as quiet as possible and make it look as much as possible like, this is all fine, this is all good, and it's just a delay.
2:18:29And I just happened to retire at the end of the year, 10 months later.
2:18:35I mean, I think it was John – I'm forgetting his name, John Browlett, head of Apple Retail before Angela Aarons, is the only other Tim Cook exit that I remember, and that was also not very noisy.
2:18:47No, but it was – but that one was quick.
2:18:50Yeah, and it was interesting because he had – I forget the name of it.
2:18:54I'll put – I made a note here on my sheet here, so I'll try to work it in the show notes.
2:18:59But he had been in charge of some retail outfit in the UK, and when he was hired, I got a bunch – a bunch of people piped up on the internet.
2:19:06A bunch of people wrote to me and said, that's crazy because that whole chain sucks.
2:19:10It's low rate.
2:19:11It's like a discounter, and you go in there, and all anybody cares about is the price, and you get a terrible customer experience.
2:19:18I can't believe that's the guy who's going to be running Apple Retail.
2:19:21It seems like a terrible fit, and it turned out he was a terrible fit.
2:19:25Yes.
2:19:26And then they got Angela Ahrens from Burberry.
2:19:28Right, and went in a complete – and again, I often say over and over again, one of my main theories of all of life is that it's – the way to make the fewest mistakes possible isn't to shoot for making zero mistakes because nobody's perfect, and everybody makes mistakes.
2:19:45And if you're focused on making zero mistakes, you're going to find yourself defending the mistakes you made to create – to argue for the perception of never making a mistake rather than actually fixing them.
2:19:59The best strategy is, of course, to make as few mistakes as possible, but to have an open mind that you are making – you might be making mistakes.
2:20:07Be open-minded to be convinced when you have made a mistake, and then fix the mistake as quickly and as honestly as possible, and then move on.
2:20:18And the John Brownlee, we're going to bring in a discount retailer, maybe Tim Cook-liked from a numeric perspective of margins and pricing.
2:20:28Four is bigger than three.
2:20:29Yeah, and maybe got along with him personally on that regard, and then very quickly listened to the fact that it was nails on the chalkboard to the Apple retail culture.
2:20:41And things Tim Cook does believe, like that it should be a very nice customer experience to walk into an Apple store and buy a product or get one serviced, and acted quickly, and then hired somebody from a completely different background.
2:20:53Angela Arntz from Burberry.
2:20:55Which is when the watch was coming up, and they were getting more into fashion.
2:20:58Right.
2:20:58I don't know.
2:21:00I kind of personally – I feel like if it were me – and again, I don't have any employees.
2:21:05I would probably, because I'm not abrasive and I do tend to avoid confrontation, I probably personally would go the Tim Cook way of letting John Gianandrea leave gracefully 10 months later, even though all of his responsibilities had been taken away in February.
2:21:22But as an observer, not someone who would have to do it and have the uncomfortable conversation myself, I think the Steve Jobs, Mark Papermester way of, you know what, I think you're a bozo, and now that I think you're a bozo, you've got to be – I want you out of here in an hour, is a little bit better.
2:21:38Or going back to Scott Forrestal and then the MAPS apology and –
2:21:42Yeah.
2:21:42Yeah.
2:21:43Yeah.
2:21:43You know, and I think the Forrestal thing shows – I don't think by any account Tim Cook is shrinking violet.
2:21:49I told – I just retold the story of him saying this to be con an hour in.
2:21:54Why are you still here?
2:21:55And the guy just got up and went to SFO and bought a ticket to China with nothing but his backpack.
2:22:01Before Tim finished his power bar.
2:22:03Right.
2:22:04So I don't think he's a shrinking violet, but I also think he's far more in control of his emotions than Steve Jobs.
2:22:12He's cold instead of hot.
2:22:15Right.
2:22:16And that he can – however angry and however – or whatever the emotion would be to describe his disappointment over the Apple intelligence fiasco, for lack of a better word.
2:22:28And I think that's fair.
2:22:30I think it's the biggest public failure Apple's had under Tim Cook.
2:22:34And if that's the worst failure under Tim Cook, I think that's great because it's easily fixable soon, perhaps.
2:22:40I think it could be something –
2:22:43It's super interesting because Scott forced all ran Siri and then Scott left and it's unclear – like it just bounced around.
2:22:48Like it was in services.
2:22:49It was in software.
2:22:51It eventually got to John G.
2:22:54Andrea.
2:22:54But even then, Craig Federighi was running his own on-device intelligence under Sebastian, which was doing – which is doing really well.
2:23:01So you had split attention, competing attention, lack of focus.
2:23:05Like they – AI is incredibly expensive.
2:23:08It sounds like they weren't letting him spend the amount of money he wanted to spend.
2:23:11Yeah.
2:23:12It just seems like it was – that was fraught as an Apple product for a decade.
2:23:16Yeah.
2:23:17And I think that the whole thing where the – oh, John G. Andrea asked for however many zillion dollars of servers for AI training and Luca was like, nah, you're going to – we're going to cheap out on you.
2:23:30I'm sure there's some truth to that, that you ask for a lot and you get a little bit less.
2:23:35But I certainly – it's like I said to Quinn last week.
2:23:38Does anybody really think that the problem with Siri and Apple intelligence overall is that Apple didn't spend quite enough on servers for training?
2:23:46That is not the problem, right?
2:23:48That might be one smaller problem.
2:23:51It's not the original sin.
2:23:52Right.
2:23:54I just think it's an – I think comparing John Gianandreia to Mark Papermaster's Ousters is just a little thing we can pinpoint as, oh, that is a very different approach that Steve Jobs had.
2:24:09But of course Steve Jobs would do it that way.
2:24:12Once he was done with you and thought you were a bozo, you were out.
2:24:14He wanted you out yesterday.
2:24:16And of course Tim Cook wants to save face for the company.
2:24:21I think not for Gianandreia personally but for the company itself to make everything look smooth and there are as few surprises or disappointments as possible.
2:24:32And that everybody at Apple is the best and that you could quietly leave in December and that's it.
2:24:39But I do think though the other thing you mentioned was the way that Siri sort of bounced around and hasn't really had a DRI in Apple's terms of directly responsible individual.
2:24:49And there was also the story that – I don't even know if it's speculation that Mike Rockwell's division running Vision had – he had thought about doing his own thing for voice commands because he thought, well, voice would be a great thing for this new system.
2:25:07And it obviously would be a great system.
2:25:10That's how Jarvis works.
2:25:11If you want to make Jarvis, you need the voice.
2:25:13Right, and that whatever Siri had to offer them as voice control sucked so bad that he literally thought about building his own but they had so much – I guess had so much else to do that it's like, no, he didn't.
2:25:23But I don't think it's a coincidence that the guy who was so unhappy with the state of Siri a couple years ago while building out the Vision platform is now the guy who is now in charge of Siri and Apple intelligence.
2:25:35And there is a DRI and it's Mike Rockwell who reports to Craig Federighi and I think the other thing that is clarifying about that hierarchy is to stop pretending that anything in – with the name AI or LLM or machine learning or whatever isn't part of software engineering.
2:25:57It is.
2:25:58It's – and therefore deserves to be under Craig Federighi's direct purview.
2:26:05I think the idea that there was this other software division and it just happened to be in these fields that are called AI or LLM or machine learning and it wasn't under Craig Federighi was a problem hierarchically.
2:26:18Well, I mean they were building a lot of that stuff for the special projects like for Titan and for everything else like computer vision, like being able to pull data in and make these models.
2:26:27So it was disparate, but again, it was one of the big pillars that Tim Cook always talked about, like automation and AI were his big bets on the future.
2:26:36And it just – it always seemed odd to me that it – it made sense that JG would be – like they would have someone like him, someone looking at this as a big pillar of the future of all Apple, robotics and automation and everything.
2:26:48Autonomy, right?
2:26:50Yeah, autonomy, sorry.
2:26:51Yeah, not automation, autonomy.
2:26:52Autonomy, like it's just so key to all those technologies, but then it never seemed to actually flourish.
2:26:57Yeah, and I think it's almost an example of why Apple is set up in the functional way that it is set up, right?
2:27:04And that letting – thinking that AI and autonomy were functional and deserve to be their own division, I think was a mistake in – I think that was the mistake more than hiring John Gianandrea personally, although I think in hindsight that was a mistake too.
2:27:21And it does tie back to something you said earlier, Rene, about LLMs and John Gianandrea, by all accounts, was never a fan of LLMs as a technology and was sort of from a totally different branch of AI, the hill climbing, more traditional branch, that sort of viewed LLMs as, oh, that's cute.
2:27:42But that's cute, but that's just predicting patterns.
2:27:45That's all it is.
2:27:46And it is.
2:27:47You can say that, right?
2:27:48It's probabilistic.
2:27:50Yeah, it's like that's four words to describe how LLMs work.
2:27:54It's just predicting patterns.
2:27:56It just turns out that with enough computational power, like literally tens of billions of dollars of computation put into the training, and then by having sufficient computing resources available for inference,
2:28:14just predicting patterns can get you really, really far, it turns out.
2:28:18And it was a huge miss for Apple.
2:28:21It really is.
2:28:22From practical terms, what is practically available today in December 2025, LLM technology is orders of magnitude more useful and practical than any other branch of AI in terms of what it can do.
2:28:38It was one of the cornerstones of Siri originally when Apple bought it was semantic inference.
2:28:42That was one of the major novel technologies, that and the natural language interface.
2:28:47And it would have seemed like that was a hint and a half that it would be important a decade, decade later.
2:28:51Yeah.
2:28:51They hired a guy who was making the wrong bet, and they parted ways.
2:28:56So I think the right thing happened.
2:28:58And again, I can say I like Steve Jobs' style.
2:29:00Not that I want to see Gianandrea embarrassed, and it's not like Mark Papermaster.
2:29:06Quinn Nelson had never even remembered hearing his name.
2:29:08It's not like, oh, everybody laughs at that jackass Mark Papermaster.
2:29:11Apple made a huge shit out of him when he had to take the fall for Antennagate.
2:29:15No, they didn't humiliate him, but they just fired him quickly.
2:29:20It's almost a play on this.
2:29:21Anything you're not personally responsible for designing, implementing, shipping, and supporting is trivial by nature.
2:29:28It's the same with business.
2:29:30Any decisions you don't have to own are easy decisions.
2:29:33Yes, exactly.
2:29:36That brings us to the end of the year.
2:29:38Anything else that you can think of?
2:29:40I think the Alan Dye thing is curious to me because it's the other side of the coin.
2:29:43Like, who's in charge of industrial design at Apple now?
2:29:46And I know there's a name.
2:29:47I'm blanking on her name.
2:29:48I know there is a name.
2:29:49But they're going to have a future of industrial design.
2:29:52The part I thought was interesting when you wrote about Alan Dye was that originally iOS 7,
2:29:58and one of the tenets of iOS 7 was we're going to make it computationally expensive
2:30:02because we're tired of other companies copying our interfaces.
2:30:05And if we inject straight into the GL pipeline, no other company can do it.
2:30:09And then when Liquid Glass came out, it's like, we're going to make it computationally expensive.
2:30:13We're going to do these effects that are so hard that if you don't have our class of silicon
2:30:17and our tight integration, it's not going to work.
2:30:19But it was Alan Dye, like, the same thing all these years later.
2:30:24And then he gets poached.
2:30:25And people at Apple are like, yay, but why did he have to get poached?
2:30:30I think was the fascinating not there.
2:30:33Yeah.
2:30:34I mean, and I'm not skipping it because I don't think it's interesting.
2:30:38I'm skipping it because we're two hours before.
2:30:40Yeah, eight hours into this podcast.
2:30:42And I've talked about it so recently.
2:30:44But that was the main, I think the post I had was that Alan Dye was in Tim Cook's blind spot, right?
2:30:52And the problem, it's good news for Apple overall.
2:30:55I really do think the guy was poisoned to Apple's human interface design.
2:30:59I think the weak spot was that both things can be true, that Alan Dye was a terrible leader for Apple's human interface and had surrounded himself with worse people like Billy Sorrentino, who went with him to Meta, who I've heard a number of stories.
2:31:14I hope to report, but let's just say that nobody at Apple who was cheering Alan Dye's departure was sad about Billy Sorrentino going with him.
2:31:23But how could they languish for so long and be in a position where Apple would put him in the biggest spot in the keynote this year at WWDC to take credit for and introduce liquid glass?
2:31:37Like I said, he was in a blind spot, which I think because both things can be true, that Apple's human interface design has been going in the wrong direction overall, honestly, for over 10 years.
2:31:50And it started under Johnny Ive, but it got a lot worse after Johnny Ive left.
2:31:57And it still is true, though, that Apple's human software human interface design is the best in the industry overall and that both things can be true, that their interface, that they were so far ahead that they could have a poor leader and still be putting out the best human interfaces in the industry.
2:32:23And a big part of that isn't that they were entirely spending earned capital in that regard.
2:32:30It's that there's so much talent in the ranks of the company, the rank-and-file designers who've been there for a long time or are new but are talented, the people like Stephen LeMay, who's now replacing Alan Dye as the leader, who's been there since 1999.
2:32:45He's from the great Christine Baz-Ording group of people.
2:32:49Right, that you can have a leader who doesn't get it like Alan Dye but still be producing, making lots of decisions that are good human interface and still doing it, but that it's untenable in the long run and that you need somebody in charge whose taste is at such a high level that it's above the product, right?
2:33:12That you've got, this gets back to my old talk on the auteur theory of design, but what you want is somebody in charge of Apple's human interface design who's ever unsatisfied with where they are because their taste is higher than what they've shipped.
2:33:29And no matter how good it gets and how many years they've been doing it, and I think that defines Steve Jobs, that he was never, ever satisfied.
2:33:35Always, no matter what they've shipped, that it was all of a sudden, no, you can only see what's wrong with it and wants it to be better because his taste was so high that you couldn't really achieve it.
2:33:46Whereas I think Alan Dye had taste that was underneath the level that Apple was shipping.
2:33:52And I, unfortunately, either, I don't, I'm not going to say all, but obviously a majority of Apple's senior leadership couldn't see the problems that the rest of us see.
2:34:03The little, the thousand paper cuts that have developed over the last 10 years and lessons that Apple has forgotten, things that were better before, solved problems that have gone away, like the proxy icons for document windows that you could.
2:34:20Just simple affordance.
2:34:22Simple affordances that were so clever and that Apple innovated and Apple created and Apple brought to market and then Apple walked away from because they added a little bit of visual distraction, not even clutter.
2:34:35It's, it's, it's, it's just an unprecedented own goal.
2:34:39It's hard to compare.
2:34:40It's heartbreaking in a way, but that Apple senior leadership, they were things that they didn't notice.
2:34:45And so they thought it was okay because they still had the best human interface in the world.
2:34:49And I think Alan Dye is very, from everything I've read, and it would explain how he lasted and was still there and in the position he was to get a prime keynote spot, was a very, very good political worker within the company.
2:35:03Very good at managing up.
2:35:04Right.
2:35:05And that, that sort of politics, internal politics first attitude is so contrary to the personality types of everybody I've ever known who works at Apple and in the rank and file engineering or design.
2:35:19Yeah.
2:35:19Areas.
2:35:20It's just off-putting.
2:35:22It's like, oh, and you could say, oh, I work at a company and it's the executives who are good at politics who always succeed.
2:35:28That's just the way business works.
2:35:29It might be the way business works at most companies, but it's definitely not how it typically worked at Apple.
2:35:34And it's sort of poison within Apple's culture to have, I mean, obviously everybody who, who achieves the senior vice president title is good at politics and inside the company in some way, obviously.
2:35:47But to have it be their primary skill is, is a problem.
2:35:51And I think that's what Alan Dye was.
2:35:53So I'm very optimistic about it.
2:35:55So in some, in a weird way, the surprise departure of Apple's senior vice president of design, I think is, I think the best news to happen to Apple all year.
2:36:04And it was the last thing to happen to all year, but it wasn't their choice or doing, but, you know.
2:36:10Yeah, but I think LeMay is like super solid.
2:36:12He's been there since the Steve Jobs days, like famous for his interesting conversations with Steve.
2:36:18And it's just, it's nice.
2:36:21I think you did this too.
2:36:22You contrasted the liquid glass unveiling to when Steve Jobs unveiled Aqua and just the way he spoke about it, like with the lickable icons and the delight he took in presenting it.
2:36:33And I think LeMay has that delight about interface, which makes me very happy.
2:36:38And the other thing too, though, and I'll emphasize this, where there is, I, most people focused on liquid glass are focused on the, the lickability difference.
2:36:48And I don't think it's as nice visually as Aqua was.
2:36:52And it's not about dating or trendiness or it's certainly more of today's style of 2025.
2:36:59The exact Aqua look would look a little bit or a lot dated.
2:37:04But the bigger problems, and I think Steve, so I think Steve and LeMay will do a better job with that.
2:37:09But I don't think that's the main problem with Alan Dye's leadership are the things that would apply even if, remember when macOS, it never actually shipped because Steve Jobs put the kibosh on it.
2:37:24So around that time, Apple was, worked on this thing.
2:37:27They called it the appearance manager.
2:37:29And the appearance manager abstracted the theme of classic macOS out of the system.
2:37:36And there was, the main default theme was called platinum, but you could switch to other themes.
2:37:41And there were third-party utilities that did the same thing, like the ARIN system extension, which would make all your windows look like BOS.
2:37:48But Apple built that into the system in classic macOS.
2:37:51And they're built like three or four themes.
2:37:54I guess I'll, here, I'll make a note and put it in the show notes.
2:37:57But there was the default one that everybody knew.
2:37:59And when Steve Jobs came back, he was like, these other ones are ridiculous and ugly and stupid, and we should be making the decision for what our OS looks like, not the user.
2:38:07So get rid of them.
2:38:08But the appearance manager was still there.
2:38:10So they shipped an OS with an appearance manager where you could choose your appearance, and there was only one choice, which is ridiculous.
2:38:19But you could pick these other themes.
2:38:21There was one, I think it was called techno, where that looked like architectural drawings.
2:38:27It made all the windows look like they were made out of paper, and the system font changed to like a handwriting font, like an architect's handwriting font, not like Comic Sans.
2:38:36There was one called Gizmo that looked like sort of Toy Story, futuristic, primary colored things.
2:38:44I forget what the dark sort of heavy metal one was called.
2:38:48I'll put a link in the show notes.
2:38:49But you could change the theme of the system and get an entirely new, not just like color theme, like dark mode, light mode, but totally different shape to buttons, different system font, different borders.
2:39:03But the fundamental aspects of the Mac interface, human interface from a usability, a user experience standpoint, stayed the same, right?
2:39:13That whether buttons in background windows were still clickable, or you had to bring the window forward to click them.
2:39:20All these little principles of usability that are different from the theme.
2:39:25And the fact that Apple had a theming system could prove it, right?
2:39:30So if you could today put in a theme file, just go to Settings, User Interface, Theme, and pick.
2:39:38Yeah, Theme Kit, or whatever they want to call it.
2:39:40Yeah.
2:39:40And you could pick like an iOS 18 theme to make your phone today running iOS 26 look like it did a year ago.
2:39:49Or pick a theme called iOS 6 that would make everything look like it did.
2:39:55Right, and bring back the rich Corinthian leather to the Contacts app.
2:40:00Yes, from Steve's chat.
2:40:01And whatever other three-dimensional textured formattings there were.
2:40:07Before the digital authenticity era.
2:40:09The main problems of today's Apple user interface, human interface design, are aside from those aesthetic details of the theme.
2:40:19There are the usability things that would be just as true if you got rid of the liquid glass theme and went back to last year's theme.
2:40:27Or went back to iOS 6 for the look and feel.
2:40:30Yeah.
2:40:31But they'd all still be there.
2:40:32The thousand little paper cuts of things you can't do, things you ought to be able to do but can't.
2:40:39Like when you make, just to name one example, like when you make multiple lock screens on your phone, which is a cool feature.
2:40:46And they obviously want you to make them and be able to switch them.
2:40:49But you can't reorder them.
2:40:51Whatever, the most recent one you've made is on the right and the first, oldest one you made is on the left.
2:40:58And if you'd like to, because you have seven of them, but the two you use the most frequently are the first one and the seventh one.
2:41:05There's no way to move them next to each other without deleting the ones in between.
2:41:08That is terrible usability.
2:41:11And that's the sort of thing that the Mac interface has always done right.
2:41:16If you've got a list of seven things and there's a good reason you might want to reorder them, then there's a way to reorder them that is intuitive to the user to do.
2:41:24And Apple has all sorts of shortcomings like that across its user interface.
2:41:29That has nothing to do with the look of liquid glass.
2:41:32It's the actual way that it works in the usability.
2:41:34And that's why it's so galling to see Alan Dye bringing up the Steve Jobs quote that design isn't what it looks like.
2:41:41It's how it works.
2:41:42Because the whole fucking problem with Alan Dye's leadership is that everything was about how it looked.
2:41:47And a lot of us don't like the way it looks, too.
2:41:49Yes.
2:41:50How's that?
2:41:52I think that's the way you cap a show, John.
2:41:54Renee, it's so good to see you.
2:41:57Happy New Year.
2:41:58Thank you for doing this.
2:41:59Happy New Year.