0:00:00Daniel, it's good to see you.
0:00:01You too.
0:00:01We're both snowed in right now, right?
0:00:04Well, the whole eastern half of the United States, I guess.
0:00:07I don't know.
0:00:08It's one of those times where everybody I know on the East Coast has the exact same weather.
0:00:13Yes, it's true.
0:00:15Sub-freezing and about a foot of snow.
0:00:17Exactly.
0:00:18Yeah.
0:00:18I was just out before we started recording.
0:00:21I went out to fill up a portable gas tank thing for my snowblower, and it's kind of surreal out there.
0:00:27I don't know if you've been out at all, but it's just almost...
0:00:30No, Amy and I went out for a bit.
0:00:31Okay, yeah.
0:00:31Just walked like four blocks.
0:00:32Yeah.
0:00:33Took some pictures.
0:00:34It's kind of insane out there.
0:00:36But yeah, it's fun.
0:00:37I like it when everything kind of slows down.
0:00:39Everything is forced to be slow, so...
0:00:42Yeah.
0:00:42We get very little...
0:00:44Well, relatively speaking, we get little snow in Philadelphia, and we haven't had more than six inches of snow, and I forget how many years they said, but it doesn't happen very often.
0:00:56But I love it when it does, because the city...
0:00:59I mean, because we live right in the city, and it gets so quiet from when it snows, because there's no traffic, or almost no traffic, and the traffic that is there is just creeping by on a bed of snow.
0:01:11And then I thought to myself, well, if I like it so much, why the hell do I live in a noisy city?
0:01:15Oh, yeah.
0:01:16Well, you probably like all the things that you can get to amidst the noise.
0:01:21It's like when you like something once a year.
0:01:24Yeah, right, right.
0:01:26What else is going on?
0:01:28Are you ready to hear all of my gripes?
0:01:29I don't know.
0:01:30I'm worried that everybody who reads Staring Fireball is going to get sick of me complaining about macOS 26 Tahoe.
0:01:36I think it's kind of weird.
0:01:38It's kind of surprising and weird.
0:01:40Maybe not too surprising, but the way that everybody's complaining about Tahoe right now, not just Accidental Tech Podcast is going off on it, that is partly inspired by these recent blog posts, like criticizing the icons and blah, blah, blah.
0:01:55You would think that Tahoe came out like last week.
0:01:57Yeah, and I was thinking about it.
0:02:00And I forget when Apple first started consistently doing, I guess it's been a long time, where the betas come out at WWDC in June for all of the operating systems.
0:02:12And I feel like in the early years of that, there was a lot more, hey, I know it's a beta, so let's forgive glitches, but let's review it now.
0:02:24If they've changed X, Y, and Z, let's review it.
0:02:28And if you don't like it, call out what you like, like, hey, here's a really great thing to look forward to when this hits release later in the year, and here's some stuff that Apple should reconsider.
0:02:37I've gotten away from that, and I feel like I got enough pushback from people at Apple that it's like, hey, it's unfair to review the beta that's in beta.
0:02:46And I think, maybe it's just me, but I think that the betas have become more in flux in recent years.
0:02:53Whereas what ships in the middle of June when WWDC hits isn't supposed to be what it's going to look like in September.
0:03:01And it's all sort of, at least for me, I'm blaming myself, not Apple, not anybody else, but I'm blaming myself where it's like, well, then I don't want to give them a hard time over the summer because they're still working on it.
0:03:11And then by the time the fall comes out, a lot of the complaints don't feel fresh anymore.
0:03:16And so I don't make them when it hits the release either.
0:03:20And then it's like, well, when am I supposed to complain?
0:03:23Well, and if you think about it, if nobody complains from June, there's no feedback.
0:03:29I mean, what's the point of having the beta if you don't take the complaints?
0:03:33Maybe what they're saying is, hey, file the bugs privately.
0:03:37Don't write about it publicly.
0:03:38But it's the kind of thing we need a collective reckoning of these major releases.
0:03:43And sometimes I think the feedback really does reach them.
0:03:48And remember a few years ago, like they completely overhauled Safari's tabs.
0:03:53And it was kind of like the tabs were like up at the top of the window edge.
0:03:57It was really unusual.
0:03:59And everybody I know pushed back.
0:04:01And so that didn't happen.
0:04:04Yeah.
0:04:05And I contributed to that.
0:04:09I don't want to, I'm not trying to take credit, but obviously if I make a good point and make it hard, it has carried some weight outside Apple.
0:04:18And I think that's one of the ones where I got some pushback, like, hey, okay, we'll fix this.
0:04:23But, you know, maybe take it easier on it while it's in beta.
0:04:26And I kind of feel like with Tahoe in particular, there was a sense with Liquid Glass in general, hey, what they're showing us at June and what we could see right away, like on the iPhone, where it was the most polished and clearly was the device that Liquid Glass started on conceptually.
0:04:48And then it's like, all right, now how can we apply this to the other devices?
0:04:51It was so clearly, oh, this isn't finished, right?
0:04:55It really wasn't in June.
0:04:56And a whole bunch of the animations they showed in the keynote weren't present in the initial betas.
0:05:02They were, whether they were simulated for the keynote or just in private builds that weren't merged with the main build, whatever.
0:05:10It's, this still doesn't look like what they're saying it's going to look like.
0:05:14And to their credit, especially on iPhone, by 26.1 and 26.2, it really does look like what they promised us in June.
0:05:23But I feel like with a lot of it, on all the OSs, it was like, well, this is clearly not finished, so let's give them a break.
0:05:29And I think with Tahoe in particular, it was like, well, a lot of this, they can't possibly intend to ship like this.
0:05:35And that's how they shipped it.
0:05:37You're right.
0:05:37Right, right, right.
0:05:38Everyone was saying that release after release.
0:05:40Wait, where's the fix for this?
0:05:41There's, people are using the expression paper cuts a lot.
0:05:45And I think that is accurate.
0:05:47I'm sitting here.
0:05:48I'm one of those people.
0:05:50I think I usually start using the new OS, like, in June, and then just never look back.
0:05:55Sometimes it bites me, but for the most part, I just, I'm used to kind of like living through uncomfortable stretches of the OS.
0:06:05And I'm kind of perplexed.
0:06:07I was just thinking about it, before you had even asked me to come on the show, I was thinking, how is Apple living with themselves over some of these things?
0:06:17Because they're the kinds of things, like little misalignments all over the place.
0:06:22They're the kinds of things that Apple is supposed to care about that nobody else cares about.
0:06:27Right.
0:06:28And to see so many of them.
0:06:30I'm just, I'm sitting here now, the app switcher, command tab.
0:06:33You've probably seen this too.
0:06:34You notice how, like, at the edges, the one at the first and the one at the last, often the name is not under the thing you've selected.
0:06:41It's been driving me crazy.
0:06:43That's one of the ones where I was like, come on, fix that.
0:06:45Yeah, yeah, yeah.
0:06:47But somebody should be ashamed.
0:06:49I mean, that's the kind of thing where, I don't know, I'm a shame-driven developer.
0:06:53You will not see a release come out fast enough if somebody points out something that just looks like it was reckless or, you know, inconsiderate of the quality of the product.
0:07:03Yeah, another one, you may not have it handy in front of you right now.
0:07:07I can see it because I'm podcasting.
0:07:09I am, as I keep reiterating on Daring Fireball, I'm using Tahoe on my podcast Mac down here in my basement.
0:07:16I'm not using it.
0:07:17And my current plan is to ride out the whole year without upgrading on my work machine up in my office.
0:07:24But I can see it right now.
0:07:26And I think it's a problem here on Tahoe 26 that when you command tab, in addition to the thing where the name does, yeah, the first one, like now that it's back to Google Chrome for me, because it doesn't fit centered under the icon.
0:07:40It just, it's squished in, but off to the right and like halfway under, it's halfway under the next icon.
0:07:49Yep.
0:07:50Right?
0:07:50So yeah, you haven't been seeing that because you're not on it full time, but that has been there, I believe, since day one.
0:07:56Right.
0:07:57And it needs to be a long name.
0:07:59So Google Chrome is a nice long name for an app.
0:08:02And so when Google Chrome is my leftmost icon, when it goes back to Mars edit, then it's nice because it fits.
0:08:08But Google Chrome, no, not so much.
0:08:10Yeah.
0:08:11The other problem is, do you agree?
0:08:13I don't think that the highlighting, when you're R command tabbing and you're like command tab, tab, tab, because you want to go back like three apps that you most recently used.
0:08:22The highlight around the one that you're selecting is way too subtle, in my opinion.
0:08:27It is.
0:08:27But on iPadOS 26, it's almost invisible.
0:08:31It is, it's almost like an eye test.
0:08:35Can you see a highlight around the third icon?
0:08:38And again, that's the whole point of the command tab switcher, is to switch to another specific app.
0:08:46The whole point of it is to pick an app.
0:08:49And so the highlight should be extremely vivid, not subtle.
0:08:54And whatever urge there is within Apple to have subtle UI elements and that this, clearly, I mean, this has been a decade plus, maybe longer in the making.
0:09:08Of all sorts of complaints across the Apple's OS is, hey, why is that so subtle?
0:09:15I remember when Safari tabs didn't have fav icons, fav icons.
0:09:21And it was like, somebody in Apple didn't want color icons in the tabs.
0:09:25And they were like, okay, if you pin a tab, we'll let you put an SVG icon.
0:09:31But you have to use a custom format, because we're Apple, that is black and white.
0:09:37So it's a monochrome SVG icon.
0:09:39When every single other browser in the known universe just puts the fav icon in the tab.
0:09:45And then I complained about that, and I kind of do take credit for getting that one fixed.
0:09:50There was no good argument against putting the color icon of the website in the tab for that website.
0:09:58Other than, oh, it looks a little cluttered, and we don't get to pick the colors, and CNN's icon may clash with Yahoo's icon or something.
0:10:06But it's your icons.
0:10:08These are the websites you've gone to.
0:10:10They should be there.
0:10:12And with the command tab switcher, any argument that like, hey, selection states should be a little subtle as opposed to being very vibrant.
0:10:20Well, why would you want that in the command tab switcher, which is only up temporarily while you're holding down the keys for command tab, right?
0:10:29It's not like it's in your face all the time.
0:10:31It is the definition of a user interface element that is only up while you're using it, and then immediately goes away.
0:10:38So it should be as vibrant as possible.
0:10:41And yet it's more like a puzzle.
0:10:43Did you get the right app?
0:10:44Who knows?
0:10:45Let go and see.
0:10:47Well, anyway, I don't want to try to fit in the whole rant about this without taking a break.
0:10:53So let me take a first break here and thank Returning Sponsor.
0:10:58This is a sponsor who was here a couple months ago, and they had such a good response that they are back.
0:11:03It is our good friends at Sentry.
0:11:06Sentry is an all-in-one application code monitoring and fixing toolkit.
0:11:12Sentry, S-E-N-T-R-Y, not century.
0:11:16Sentry, like somebody looking over your app, doesn't just catch errors.
0:11:21It catches all the stuff that makes your app feel broken.
0:11:24The random slowdowns, the freezes you can't reproduce, the bugs that only show up once a real user hits them.
0:11:30When something goes wrong, Sentry gives you the whole chain of events in one place.
0:11:35Errors, traces, replays, logs, actually connected so you can see what led to the issue without digging through five different dashboards.
0:11:44And that's what SEER, S-E-E-R, Sentry's AI debugging agent, builds on.
0:11:50It takes that full context, explains why the issue happened, and points to the code responsible, drafts a fix, and even flags if your PR is about to introduce a new problem.
0:12:02So the workflow stays simple.
0:12:05Something breaks, Sentry shows you the full context, and then SEER helps you fix it and catch new issues before they ship.
0:12:13Sentry is used by millions of developers behind some of the biggest apps like Claude, Disney Plus, Duolingo, big apps with lots of users.
0:12:24They support over 100 languages and frameworks across front-end, back-end, and mobile.
0:12:29S-E-N-T-R-Y.
0:12:32Try it free at Sentry, S-E-N-T-R-Y dot I-O slash talk show.
0:12:40That's Sentry dot I-O slash talk show.
0:12:43And when you use that code, talk show, you get 80 bucks in Sentry credits.
0:12:4980 bucks for free just for listening to the show.
0:12:52What else?
0:12:54What else about Tahoe?
0:12:56Do you agree?
0:12:57Am I nuts?
0:12:57Here's the thing.
0:12:58And I don't think – I feel like I've been hammering this point long enough that if there was widespread pushback –
0:13:04because sometimes when I feel like I'm veering towards an extreme opinion on macOS 26 Tahoe,
0:13:09which is that it's an unmitigated disaster and an embarrassment to Apple and that I'm really best avoiding it.
0:13:16And I think, well, that's a harsh take for me.
0:13:18But I'm not really getting much pushback from readers.
0:13:21I mean, I'm getting a little from some who are like, hey, I upgraded back in September.
0:13:26And there's a couple of the things you talk about that are annoying.
0:13:28But overall, it's fine.
0:13:30And of course it is, right?
0:13:32It's not, oh, you install it and everybody's MacBooks are kernel panicking, right?
0:13:37It's not losing data.
0:13:39It's not corrupting your – it's not like they have file system bugs or something truly horrendous.
0:13:45It's just annoying.
0:13:47And I kind of feel like even – it's like the confirmation to me is that even the people who are – the readers who are politely, almost all, telling me,
0:13:56hey, I don't really see why you're so hung up on it, seems fine to me.
0:14:00The sentiment is exactly what you were saying earlier, Daniel, which is, yeah, fine is not the Apple way, right?
0:14:07Right.
0:14:08Right.
0:14:10Like, how about the one that a couple of people wrote about the problem with – what was his name?
0:14:16Norbert – he's the guy – he's one of the developers of LaunchBar.
0:14:18Oh, yeah.
0:14:19It looks like he started a new blog just to post this because it's the only post on his blog.
0:14:25Norbert Heger – I hope I'm pronouncing that right because I believe he's German or something.
0:14:30Why it's difficult to resize Windows on Mac OS.
0:14:33Oh, yeah.
0:14:34Yeah, yeah, yeah.
0:14:35That one was interesting for me because I didn't notice it until I read the post, which is saying something.
0:14:42In other words, it didn't affect me or it didn't affect me enough that I became aware of the problem.
0:14:49But now that I've read the post, I'm missing the target all the time.
0:14:52It's kind of weird, like the knowledge of it.
0:14:54Or maybe I'm just noticing that I'm missing it.
0:14:56But, yeah, that is – that's another little problem here.
0:14:59I just – I guess I should stake out my position on Tahoe because you said it's an unmitigated disaster or you're leaning towards feeling that way.
0:15:07Yeah.
0:15:08That's how I feel.
0:15:10You never hear people talk about it, but maybe it's a mitigated disaster.
0:15:14Yes, yes.
0:15:15Nobody says it's a mitigated disaster because everyone's getting by.
0:15:21It's fine.
0:15:22It's like the Titanic sinking is an unmitigated disaster, but the Titanic showers being cold is just like a mitigated disaster.
0:15:32So I don't know.
0:15:34The fact is I was actually thinking about this a little bit.
0:15:36When you asked me to come on the show, you warned me we're going to talk about Tahoe.
0:15:40And I was doing some errands and I was thinking, why am I not bothered more by the little things?
0:15:46And I started thinking about it.
0:15:47Basically, I think since I've – since my whole career working at Apple, working on my own stuff, I think I'm more dedicated to the pursuit of giving users a clean, flawless experience than I am insistent upon having that experience myself.
0:16:09So maybe it's like a dress designer who goes around wearing blue jeans.
0:16:13It's like they don't need to be wearing the fancy ballroom dress to appreciate the craft and the work that goes into it.
0:16:22Yeah.
0:16:22And I feel for the people inside Apple.
0:16:26And I am not hearing from people currently at Apple because they know better.
0:16:30But I'm hearing – and I think it's a sign of my age that I know a fair number of people now who are retired from Apple because a lot of people, as it's kind of common sense, that people not much older than me are able to retire early if they spent their career at Apple because they were there for a long number of years.
0:16:51And from people who are out of Apple, I'm getting, go, keep it up.
0:17:03This needs to be heard inside the company.
0:17:05And I think Tahoe, because it's very specific, it is this OS for the Mac, this version that has taken such a sharp turn.
0:17:16And again, I mean this with no hyperbole.
0:17:19I wrote the other day on Daring Fireball that I can't think of anything that makes me want to upgrade to Tahoe.
0:17:25And there have been years past – I've been doing this a very long time – where there have been years where I almost never upgrade.
0:17:32I don't upgrade to my work machines in June like you do.
0:17:35And I know that developers often have to.
0:17:37I usually wait until like the .1 update in October or November, shake out some bugs and upgrade then.
0:17:47And sometimes the .2, depending on when it comes out.
0:17:50You know, some years it's a little buggier than others, but this one feels like this sharp turn.
0:17:55But just concentrating on this, it really helps to clarify that an awful lot of things at Apple in recent years I think have been – like how can this ship?
0:18:09How can they excuse it as this bubbles up the hierarchy to the executive level in the company?
0:18:13And I think it really boils down to a bit of maybe almost unavoidable arrogance that comes from, well, this is still the best there is, right?
0:18:24Like this – for whatever you want to say about some of the iPhone interface problems in liquid glass, it is still the best mobile operating system user interface, right?
0:18:36And the problem for me with Tahoe is it's not the best desktop computer interface.
0:18:43Last year's version to me is.
0:18:46And I could even see – and I'm sure there's listeners out there who are itching to jump in and interrupt us and say, no, no, no.
0:18:53You've got to go back like 10 years to like 2014, 2015.
0:18:57And I kind of agree and it was a post where I went back and I was looking at Stephen Hackett's collection of screenshots from every version of Mac OS X from the Mac OS X public beta in 2000 up through Tahoe.
0:19:10And it's, man, the versions from around 10 years ago, like when Alan Dye first came in, they look so good and they don't look old.
0:19:20They don't look like, oh, it's a little bit of a retro Obama-era feel.
0:19:26They look like they could ship that interface today and it would look right at home as the Mac version of Apple's current design language right next to iOS 26 running on an iPhone.
0:19:43Now, it's not liquid glass 10 years ago, but, you know, it's the San Francisco font.
0:19:48It's a similar color palette, a similar overall aesthetic, but applied to a real serious work desktop graphical user interface.
0:19:58It's gotten worse.
0:20:00It really has.
0:20:01And it's not just different.
0:20:03It's not like, oh, I don't like more transparent things.
0:20:07Transparent things are not to my liking.
0:20:09It's real things like, hey, once Norbert Heger posted this, everybody's like, oh, that's why I can't resize windows.
0:20:18Right?
0:20:18Yeah.
0:20:19Yeah.
0:20:21Like I said, Apple should be embarrassed about all the little problems.
0:20:24I'm sure some people at Apple are embarrassed.
0:20:26I had that metaphor with the ballroom gown.
0:20:30It needs to be perfect, right?
0:20:31So imagine like a beautiful like Oscars red carpet ballroom gown and then there's like a big long thread hanging off of the bottom or like a ripped piece of fabric that was like pasted on the bottom.
0:20:45It's like you're looking for an elevated product.
0:20:50It needs to be an elevated product.
0:20:51And as soon as it starts, I guess what I'm just to reiterate, I guess what bothers me is some of these problems should be driving people at Apple crazy that they're not fixed yet.
0:21:04And maybe they are, but I don't understand.
0:21:06There's this other little issue I noticed where, oh, probably like about half of all of Apple's.
0:21:12So you know how like sometimes there's an explanatory text under a radio button or a checkbox and it's usually aligned with the text of the radio button or the checkbox.
0:21:22There's no automated way to do that.
0:21:24You have to just kind of indent it the right amount.
0:21:26And if you start looking around on Tahoe, you'll see in like Apple's preference panes everywhere that the text is a little bit to the left because they made the checkbox or the radio button a little wider.
0:21:40So this is one of these things where I was like, yeah, that's annoying, but actually you could probably fix that.
0:21:47I mean, so the problem is they have to fix it in every app, but they could have somebody just be like, I'm the fixer.
0:21:54Give me access to all the source code and give me two days and this will not be a problem.
0:21:59I feel like there must be systemic issues that are preventing widespread perfectionism these days.
0:22:07And as a developer, somebody who's trying to target the latest OS in as many ways as are sensible, I'm often looking to Apple for direction as to how to embrace the design.
0:22:21And there are very few, even Apple apps.
0:22:24I'm hoping with this new iWork suite coming out that we're going to get some direction because right now, looking on my Mac, Safari has adopted Liquid Glass.
0:22:36Lots of other apps either haven't adopted it or have adopted it in a very light way.
0:22:42I was looking at TextEdit just now.
0:22:44TextEdit.
0:22:45That's what I was looking at.
0:22:46I was looking at because I know TextEdit still has an old-fashioned settings dialog, not the new iOS style one.
0:22:52And I was looking at it to look at the checkboxes.
0:22:54And I see what you mean about the labels being closer to the buttons.
0:22:57Yeah.
0:22:58Actually, now I'm looking at Xcode.
0:23:00Xcode might be the single most complex app I've seen that embraces Liquid Glass.
0:23:09So that's kind of funny, actually.
0:23:11But, you know, if they shipped this in, what, September?
0:23:14And I guess it's not that long.
0:23:17But I was expecting to see Apple, like, just coming down with – because making such a major UI change, the way to beta test that internally is to change your own apps to adopt it.
0:23:30That's how you figure out what design changes work and don't work, is to actually try to apply them to apps.
0:23:38I'm sure they did it to Xcode.
0:23:39They did it to Safari.
0:23:40But there's a lot of, like, complex UI stuff that apps like Pages or Keynote have that Safari doesn't have.
0:23:51So it's sort of adding to the overall incoherence of the OS that, for instance, even among Apple's own apps, TextEdit is an app that everybody uses.
0:24:03I mean, it must be 95% of all Mac users use both Safari and TextEdit to some extent.
0:24:11And they're using this top-of-the-line OS that ships with two apps that everybody uses that don't adopt the same design language.
0:24:19So I think that that inconsistency – here I am ranting after saying I'm fine.
0:24:24I get by fine on the OS.
0:24:25But I'm ranting on behalf of the other users.
0:24:29You know what I mean?
0:24:30I don't care as much.
0:24:31I would like to see it coherent and pristine, but it bothers me.
0:24:37I still have a tiny bit of mental Apple ownership.
0:24:41Like, I identify as an Apple employee 20 years after I quit.
0:24:44And after only working there relatively briefly.
0:24:48Yeah, six or seven – six, seven years.
0:24:52But I still feel proud of Apple.
0:24:54And so when they do something that I think is shameful, it sort of makes me feel ashamed.
0:25:00It kind of makes me feel like a sucker for still defending them.
0:25:04But it's not so bad.
0:25:06It is a mitigated disaster.
0:25:11I guess – I just don't think some people get for how long.
0:25:17It wasn't like, oh, there was a brief heyday for just a handful of years where inside Apple there was a real focus on user interface perfectionism.
0:25:30And that doesn't mean every choice was perfect, which can't be, and that's totally subjective.
0:25:37And probably inside there were always, should we do it this way or that way?
0:25:41And you may not agree with the fact that they chose that way instead of this way.
0:25:45But when they did that way, it was pixel perfect.
0:25:48And if it was supposed to look like this, then it would look exactly like this to the pixel.
0:25:57And I've heard, and you've heard, and some of the stories are public, that was really the way prototyping would work within Apple.
0:26:07That if the design team was making mock-ups using Photoshop or some other just graphic tool and got approval maybe all the way up to Steve and was like, okay, this is what it should look like.
0:26:21Then that's what it was supposed to look like to the pixel, and it was going to look like that to the pixel.
0:26:26Or somebody, including Steve, is going to notice that this is one pixel – this whole sidebar is one pixel too low.
0:26:32Fix it.
0:26:33Yeah.
0:26:33And that would rise to the level – I think that a fair criticism of Apple over the years is that sometimes fixing 50 little misaligned text boxes or divider bars, using your time to do that is time better spent than adding another user feature.
0:26:52And that's a philosophy that many people in this world do not agree with because it leads to less features in the product.
0:27:02But for those who do, Apple has been the place.
0:27:05And so when that starts to deteriorate a little bit, it's like, come on.
0:27:10You've got to do this.
0:27:11Yeah.
0:27:12That's a good point.
0:27:13That if your philosophy is fewer but better features, one way to achieve that is by striving for perfectionism in their presentation and implementation.
0:27:26That anything that could be fast, anything that could be fast, anything that is slow, the bottlenecks are identified, and it is made fast.
0:27:34Anything that is supposed to look a certain way looks that way.
0:27:39Anytime there's a weird edge case that is like, hey, if you turn off the toolbar, it lets you make the window a lot smaller than it does when the toolbar is visible.
0:27:50And when you make the window really small, this, that, the other thing breaks layout-wise.
0:27:55Like, oh, yeah, I didn't really – nobody really tested whatever the app is with the toolbar off.
0:28:01Okay, but let's fix it, right?
0:28:03Or let's set the minimum – one way or the other, let's fix it.
0:28:07Let's either fix those layout bugs when you make the window too small when the toolbar is not visible, or let's make it so that the minimum window side is big enough that the – one way or the other, let's make it so that can't happen.
0:28:17Exactly.
0:28:18And reminding me – I've said this over the years to other developers who maybe they're asking for feedback about their UI.
0:28:25And I often say, don't let users make your app look bad.
0:28:30You know, and that's an example of that is don't let them – because if you don't do anything about it, you can – in a Mac app, you could resize the window to be the size of a postage stamp.
0:28:40And it would just, like, squish all the stuff off the screen, and it looks bad.
0:28:45So I always go by that idea that, similarly, don't let them set ugly colors on the UI, et cetera, et cetera.
0:28:52Where was I going?
0:28:54Don't let them make your app look bad.
0:28:57Don't let them make your app look bad.
0:29:00I think that's it.
0:29:01Yeah.
0:29:02At a certain point, that's the job of design.
0:29:06It is making decisions for the user.
0:29:10That is one simple argument of what design is.
0:29:14It is making decisions and hopefully not making them arbitrarily but making them for good reason and with lots of debate and being able to defend them.
0:29:26And there's just so many things in Tahoe that it just – it's like the – I think it was getting – the Mac interface was getting stretched thin over the – roughly the Apple Silicon era, which is sort of helped disguise the user interface decline because the hardware story suddenly got so much better where it was like, holy crap.
0:29:48These machines, these machines, these laptops run forever, and they don't get hot, and the screens are better than ever.
0:29:54And I have a four-year-old M1, whatever, and it still feels like brand new.
0:30:01I don't feel – this hardware is amazing.
0:30:02And everything – it was another, at an engineering level, extremely, almost bizarrely seamless experience for users in terms of all the Intel not yet updated for Apple Silicon apps that you still had to use just took a little bit longer to launch at first and because of Rosetta.
0:30:25But then actually, because Apple Silicon was so fast and Rosetta was such an efficient translation layer that unless you had a really high-end Intel Mac, your Apple Silicon Mac ran your Intel compiled apps faster than the Intel Mac you switched from, which is amazing.
0:30:42And all of that just sort of helped keep our attention away from the slight decline in user interface attention to detail.
0:30:51And then I feel like as thin as it was stretched, Tahoe bursted open, and now there's garbage all over the interface.
0:31:00You know what's funny?
0:31:01I think the last time I was on this show was very shortly after we both got our M1 MacBook Pros because I remember I was just elated.
0:31:11It was like the most positive version of me.
0:31:13No, you were on in 2023, so I'd had mine for a while.
0:31:15But we still might have been excited.
0:31:18Okay, well, I was excited because I was like, everything is just fast and works.
0:31:23And to your point about things like Rosetta working so well that it's possibly even better.
0:31:30It's an example of its evidence that the people behind the product were asking themselves questions all along the way.
0:31:37Well, what happens if X?
0:31:39And then, well, this is annoying, but we're going to have to write a complete emulation layer for Intel apps.
0:31:47Another company might say, no, we're just going to make them buy new versions of the apps.
0:31:53Apple covered so many bases with this Apple Silicon transition.
0:31:58And the fact that we were just elated by them represents the number of things they must have thought about, acknowledged the problem, and then fixed before it was even shipped.
0:32:11And I'm going to switch to a little bit of hopefulness here because we're talking about how great of a hardware company Apple has shown itself to be, particularly in the last few years.
0:32:21And I don't have to remind anybody listening to this show that we had the keyboard fiasco.
0:32:28There was a time there where you could reasonably suspect Apple of having lost all of its Apple-ness with respect to hardware quality.
0:32:37And so maybe we're in a software valley like the keyboard valley.
0:32:44And especially, I'm optimistic, especially because of the change in leadership for design.
0:32:51I can't imagine anybody at Apple being more embarrassed about the appearance of stuff in the OS than the leader of design.
0:33:02I mean, the buck stops with them.
0:33:04So their reputation is on the line.
0:33:06Yeah.
0:33:08And we don't still, you know, here we are six weeks or eight weeks after the big announcement that Alan Dye has been poached by Meta and took his inner circle with him.
0:33:19And long-time user interface designer Steve LeMay is taking over the software design chief role at Apple.
0:33:28And so many people still, even now that the news isn't so fresh, are still sending me notes that they're cautiously very optimistic because Steve LeMay is just exactly the right type of person.
0:33:40The concern isn't about him personally.
0:33:43The concern is whether anybody can write this ship and turn, maybe not turn it around 180 degrees, but it needs a significant course correction on, especially on macOS.
0:33:56I would argue everywhere, but especially macOS.
0:34:00And there is an institutional aversion at every institution to admit mistakes, right?
0:34:10Nobody likes to.
0:34:11And proud companies and teams are less likely to want to do it.
0:34:16And the longer you go on a good, successful run, we're Apple.
0:34:21We don't make bad mistakes.
0:34:23And part of Apple's identity is that Apple ships terrific user interfaces, right?
0:34:30It's foundational to the identity of the company, and it's why almost everybody I know who works there went to work there, at least obviously on the software side.
0:34:39And on the hardware side, it's because they make great hardware that looks good and runs well and that you go there to make good stuff.
0:34:46And it's good design, great design, the best design in the industry.
0:34:51And so how do they get out of this without admitting mistake?
0:34:55Is their pride going – this is the fear.
0:34:57Is their pride going to get in the way of changing some of these things back or come up with – not necessarily exactly the way they were, but oh, now when you select a menu item or a menu in the menu bar,
0:35:11the actual highlight of the view menu when you click view is visible as opposed to almost invisible.
0:35:18And the shape looks like a rectangle, not an oval because why in the world is – why in the world would you break that, right?
0:35:27Where the idea, the graphical appearance of a selected menu in the Mac menu bar is a rectangle, which is the pulled down menu, with a rectangular selected tab at the top left, which is the name of the menu that you've opened, right?
0:35:46And now it is an iconic appearance, and there are – I can think of other apps that if you need an icon that represents a menu, that's what it looks like.
0:35:56It looks like a little rectangle with a tab that's highlighted at the top left corner, and you could make that icon very small, and everybody would know, oh, that's a menu.
0:36:06So you could make a little 32-point icon that any user would recognize, oh, that little icon, that's a menu.
0:36:15But now the actual menus don't look like menus.
0:36:18Yeah, right.
0:36:20Well, part of my optimism about the next few years for Apple is, to your point about being willing to own the mistakes, actually, Alan Dye leaving is a perfect opportunity to sort of elide the shame.
0:36:36It's like, well, we got a new design head in, and he just had some slight changes in mind for perfecting something that was already almost there.
0:36:47You could say it in a way that was, like, complementary of the current team that implemented it, but also leaves room.
0:36:54In other words, emphasizing more, like, a different take than a correction.
0:36:59Yeah.
0:37:00And that's my hope, too, is that they're obviously never going to mention him, right?
0:37:04They're not going to come out.
0:37:05Let's say come June, and all of our dreams come true, and when they introduce macOS 27 in the keynote in June, that it has – I don't know what they're going to call it.
0:37:20They're not going to call it all new because last year was all new, but improved user interface.
0:37:25And as they start showing right away screenshots and movies of macOS 27 in action, everybody watching the keynote live is excited as they watch.
0:37:36Oh, they fixed the menu bar.
0:37:37Oh, they fixed the window shapes.
0:37:38Yes, yeah.
0:37:39Oh, and you see these things flashing by.
0:37:41And again, Apple did this recently.
0:37:43They did it just last year when they talked about the Photos app, right?
0:37:46Which a lot of people were very upset about the year before in iOS 18 when they changed the sort of – the tabs at the bottom of the Photos app to sort of steer you away from just looking at your library all the time and to show you these smart groups of things like friends and pets and places and stuff like that.
0:38:08And people really didn't like it, and they addressed it.
0:38:12I think it was Federighi himself or somebody who said, hey, we listened to you, we heard you, and in iOS 26, Photos has an improved layout that answers the question or solves the complaint that people had.
0:38:25And I think it does, right?
0:38:26I think people – for whatever other complaints they have about liquid glass, I do think the Photos app responded to the widespread criticism.
0:38:35So there's a hundred of those things in macOS 26.
0:38:39I don't think they're going to get them all next year, but if they start getting some of them, it would be a sign – we'll quickly be disappointed at all the ones that they don't get to.
0:38:49But if it's clear that they're responding to some of them, we'll be like, ah, thank God.
0:38:55They're listening.
0:38:56Yes.
0:38:56Sanity has prevailed.
0:38:58And I think they can do it in a way that does, without ever mentioning him, does sort of put the blame for all of it on the guy who left.
0:39:08Yep.
0:39:09I mean, it's a great opportunity, actually.
0:39:11And I think my complaint about the lack of cohesiveness, that might be a place for them to focus.
0:39:17Because when you make things more cohesive, it inherently means leaving one of the choices aside.
0:39:25So there's going to be some – if you talk about the release, like we have this great new UI, there's some things about the old UI that might have even been better still, and we just want to unify it all.
0:39:38When you're unifying something, you have to choose, do you want the oval selection on the menu or do you want the rectangle?
0:39:44And that's a time to sort of blame the fact that a choice has to be made, right?
0:39:50A choice has to be made if you're going to unify things.
0:39:53Maybe not with the menu bar, because obviously the menu bar is unified, but the way buttons behave from one app to another or the size of checkboxes, et cetera, et cetera.
0:40:02Yeah.
0:40:03All right.
0:40:04Let me take a break here and thank our next sponsor, and it's our good friends at Notion.
0:40:09Notion brings all your notes, docs, and projects into one connected space that just works.
0:40:16It's seamless, flexible, powerful, and actually fun to use.
0:40:20With AI built right in, you spend less time switching between tools and more time creating great work.
0:40:28And now with Notion Agent, your AI doesn't just help with work.
0:40:32It finishes it.
0:40:33Notion Agent can do anything you can do in Notion.
0:40:38So, like, this whole idea that we're moving towards a world where our system-level AI and Apple Intelligence or whatever they call it on Android, but you can just sort of talk to AI, and the AI can kind of take over and run your computer.
0:40:49I know a lot of people are using Cloud Code for that across the system.
0:40:52Notion Agent does that within Notion now.
0:40:56And Notion is sort of – it's more than just notes.
0:40:59It really is databases and documents and a lot more.
0:41:03And you can do anything you can do.
0:41:05You can direct Notion's internal agent to do for you in Notion.
0:41:10It can tap into your Notion workspace.
0:41:12It can go to the web.
0:41:13It can use connected tools that you've connected to your Notion account like Slack and Google Drive to complete assigned actions that have been assigned to you.
0:41:21You can focus on what you want to spend your time and delegate to almost another version of you that knows your style, your workflow, and your preferences.
0:41:32It is really powerful.
0:41:33Notion is used by over 50% of Fortune 500 companies and some of the fastest-growing companies in the world like OpenAI, Ramp, and Versil.
0:41:42But it's also used by really small teams and individuals, too.
0:41:45It is the type of app that scales everything from one-person companies all the way to the Fortune 500.
0:41:51Try Notion, now with Notion Agent, at Notion, N-O-T-I-O-N, Notion.com slash talkshow.
0:42:00That's all lowercase letters.
0:42:02Don't put any capital letters in the URL or it's not going to work.
0:42:05Notion.com slash talkshow to try your new AI teammate, Notion Agent, today.
0:42:11And when you use that link, you're supporting the talkshow, Notion.com slash talkshow.
0:42:17One of the things I wrote about recently, and I really felt like it was, if I do say so, a good point,
0:42:23is combined with these growing rumors that John Ternus is internally to Apple, the intended successor to Tim Cook, is the CEO.
0:42:36And it makes sense in a lot of ways, makes sense age-wise, that Ternus is only 51 or 52.
0:42:41I forget when, I don't know when his birthday is.
0:42:43But relatively young, and it's, you probably feel the same way, but as somebody in his early 50s.
0:42:51I really like hearing somebody in their early 50s described as young.
0:42:55Yeah, right?
0:42:56Yeah.
0:42:57This is our time.
0:42:57Come on.
0:42:58I'm not in my early 50s, by the way.
0:43:00I'm in my early 50.
0:43:02Yeah.
0:43:03Early 50.
0:43:03Okay.
0:43:04I got you.
0:43:04It's a singular still.
0:43:06Yeah.
0:43:06So you'd be a really young CEO for Apple.
0:43:08That's right.
0:43:09Give me a call.
0:43:10But there is the, and again, and who even knows, right, like just to name somebody, just Federighi, right?
0:43:17And I think in some scenario, Federighi's got to be on a short list of people who could be, right?
0:43:24If there was some kind of accident and a couple of other executives were, let's just say, let's be nice about it or optimistic and say they were hospitalized for a while and incapacitated, including Tim Cook.
0:43:38You could certainly imagine a scenario where Craig Federighi would be the interim CEO, without question.
0:43:43He's got charisma.
0:43:44He's got experience.
0:43:45Maybe, though, Craig Federighi really does not want to go any higher than the head of software, that he's had conversations with Tim Cook, and Tim Cook has said, hey, what do you think?
0:43:56And he's all, I don't want your job.
0:43:58I want to stay right where I am.
0:44:00I could really believe that about Craig Federighi.
0:44:02I don't get the sense, but they're all poker players to some extent.
0:44:07If there is some kind of elbow-throwing rivalry within their senior executive ranks for who would take over when Tim Cook does retire, we wouldn't know it.
0:44:19But at a basic level, it makes sense that it would be Ternus, in addition to his age, in addition to the fact that he is good and charismatic on stage or in keynotes that aren't on stages anymore in public, but also just the basic truth that what part of Apple is running the best for the last five to ten years?
0:44:39I think without question, it's their hardware, right?
0:44:42So why not name the hardware guy as the CEO of all the areas of the company?
0:44:47Hardware, software, services, marketing, right?
0:44:51And marketing, JAWS' job at marketing is not just doing ads.
0:44:56That's just a tiny part of it.
0:44:58Product marketing at Apple is really more about the product than the marketing.
0:45:01But the buck stops somewhere.
0:45:03And, you know, the most talked about commercials from Apple in recent years have been ones that were problematic, right?
0:45:11Yeah, the crushed musical instruments where they had to have an apology.
0:45:16The Apple intelligence commercial that they had to pull from YouTube because it wasn't actually going, the feature that it advertised wasn't going to ship in the year that it came out.
0:45:27And software quality, again, like we're talking about Rosetta and other things, engineering quality of software might well be better than ever, right?
0:45:38Fewer bugs, fewer crashes, fewer data losses, more reliable syncing.
0:45:43My uptime, I just looked at it because I'm writing, I'm working on my Apple report card for six colors.
0:45:49My M1 Max MacBook Pro upstairs has an uptime right now of 73 days.
0:45:56Like it's been 73 days since I've restarted that computer.
0:46:00And you probably didn't restart it because of a problem.
0:46:02You probably restarted it before.
0:46:04When I upgraded from 15.7.1 to 15.7.2.
0:46:07And I haven't upgraded to 15.7.3 yet because I've got a bunch of stuff open that I don't want to close to restart the computer.
0:46:1473 days of uptime.
0:46:15And there's nothing that's flaky or wrong.
0:46:18I better restart over the weekend because X, Y, or Z is starting to flake out.
0:46:24Incredible engineering, right?
0:46:26But the one thing at the company that it's hard to even think of something to complain about is hardware across the board.
0:46:33Yep.
0:46:34No, it's absolutely.
0:46:36You know, I'm thinking back to way, way, way back on the System 7, System 8 days of Mac OS, which is when I started working at Apple.
0:46:45There was a lot of inner conflict at Apple at that time.
0:46:49You reminded me of this by talking about Rosetta and maybe its relationship with hardware.
0:46:54At that time, there were two competing engineering groups for what was the standard interface to the Mac.
0:47:03In the sense that the PowerBook team, as opposed to the desktop iMac-type team, made its own software.
0:47:14They made – I'm sure you remember, John.
0:47:16Many of our listeners remember Control Strip.
0:47:19I knew you were going to say that.
0:47:20So Control Strip was like a rogue move by the PowerBook team.
0:47:25And they were like – for a while back then, Control Strip was only available on PowerBooks.
0:47:30Yeah, I know.
0:47:30And it was maddening because it was so cool.
0:47:32It was so cool, and I think there were hacks to get it to work on desktop Macs.
0:47:37It probably didn't take much to make that happen.
0:47:39But I remember being at Apple at the time, people were furious that the PowerBook team was exerting its own taste on the OS, essentially.
0:47:50And adding a system-level feature.
0:47:53I mean, how would you describe Control Strip for those who aren't as old as we are?
0:47:57Or if they are as old, weren't using Macs at the time?
0:48:00I mean, it's really – it's pretty easy to compare now to the status items at the upper right corner of the Mac screen.
0:48:08But essentially like that, but positioned at the bottom left of the screen in a kind of – almost like a zipper-like expanding bar.
0:48:17Yeah, like a little pull tab on it.
0:48:20Yeah.
0:48:20Yeah, and you could just click on the pull tab, and it would go away.
0:48:23But just leave the tab in the corner of the screen, and you could click on it again, and it would snap out.
0:48:28I think you could click and drag if you wanted to make it so instead of being full width, you could make it partial width, and then there would be arrows at the sides to kind of go through the icons.
0:48:36Yeah, that sounds familiar.
0:48:37Yeah, but the quickest way to describe it would be those – yeah, exactly.
0:48:41Those menu items in the top right of your Mac menu bar were not – A, because displays were so much smaller back then.
0:48:51There wasn't room for them to the right of the applications menus, right?
0:48:56Because even back then, serious apps like QuarkXPress and Photoshop and FileMaker and BBEdit had a lot of menus.
0:49:03So there wasn't a lot of space up there, and there was no good API.
0:49:07There were always hacks, right?
0:49:09There was the – what was it?
0:49:10The precursor to FastScripts, OSA script from Leonard Rosenthal.
0:49:15There were ways to put a system-wide script menu up there.
0:49:19But the control strip was an official sanctioned way to get those type of status icons in a strip.
0:49:28And I think it was a more elegant solution than what we've been living with in Mac OS X for 20 years where we stick those icons in the menu bar because they're not really menus, right?
0:49:39They're something else.
0:49:40Like the menu should be for the commands of the system and the commands of the application.
0:49:46It shouldn't be a place for many apps, and the control strip was a better place for that.
0:49:51And I don't know.
0:49:53It just looked cool, but it was incredibly frustrating that it was only for PowerBooks.
0:49:58And that's the sort of thing Apple does once in a while that's like, oh, come on.
0:50:04Why don't you – why doesn't everybody get that?
0:50:07Put it in perspective, I think it's possible that the reason it was only for PowerBooks was because the desktop team refused.
0:50:15And so eventually they won.
0:50:18The PowerBook team won.
0:50:20Like it became a standard element of Mac OS.
0:50:23But there's some funny examples like that of things that just weaseled their way in because of a hardware decision, not a software decision.
0:50:32I hope – I don't even know.
0:50:34I doubt he listens to every episode.
0:50:36I hope the statute of limitations on off-the-record comments have expired on it.
0:50:43But Phil Schiller told me a story once that he prototyped the first version of Control Strip using – what was the macro media tool that you could use to sort of prototype software?
0:50:54Oh, it's not coming to me.
0:50:57It was like a precursor to Flash because it was only on the desktop.
0:51:00But he was on an airplane on a PowerBook and was like mad and frustrated about not being able to get – I don't know what it would have been because Wi-Fi didn't exist yet.
0:51:12But there was something like the volume or something.
0:51:15And so on the plane, he prototyped the first version of the Control Strip.
0:51:20And then he got off the plane and it came from there.
0:51:22I don't know what it looked like.
0:51:23But I thought that was a cool story.
0:51:25But it was specifically because he was on a PowerBook and couldn't get access to some of these system controls.
0:51:32That's a good example of what you said earlier about marketing not just being ads.
0:51:37Absolutely.
0:51:37That was him marketing based on his own experience.
0:51:39Right.
0:51:39But it really was – there was – and you were there.
0:51:43I was outside.
0:51:44But, I mean, it was infamous just reading about the company that the politics inside the company were bad.
0:51:51Yeah.
0:51:52There were fiefdoms.
0:51:54Totally, yeah.
0:51:54And there wasn't – there's that famous cartoon of the org charts of Silicon Valley's biggest companies.
0:52:00And it was drawn when Steve Jobs was still alive.
0:52:02But Apple's org chart was just – it's just a circle around one person in the middle.
0:52:07And everything goes to that one person.
0:52:10You can't really recommend that structure, the Steve Jobs executive leadership style in business school because it sort of hinges upon having a Steve Jobs intellect and level of taste and assertiveness and confidence and charisma and you name it.
0:52:30You name all the things that were great about Steve Jobs and the person who does that to organize a major company like that kind of has to be all of them.
0:52:38But it worked and it did solve – it solved that little fiefdom thing where desktop Macs had a different interface to those things and were missing a cool feature that was PowerBook only.
0:52:50And it's just so spiteful because everybody – and I remember being at the college newspaper where, of course, we had all desktops.
0:52:57I think we did have one PowerBook that was like so – because they were so expensive at the time.
0:53:02They were so much more expensive than even powerful desktop Macs.
0:53:05So we had one PowerBook that like if a reporter was going to the student council meeting and wanted to take notes on the computer, they could sign it out and take it.
0:53:15But all the other computers were desktops and we all wanted that feature.
0:53:18And I think you're right.
0:53:19I kind of remember there was some kind of hack to enable it or something.
0:53:22And, of course, we did it.
0:53:24Yeah, of course.
0:53:26Yeah.
0:53:27Well, I was thinking when you said that about the kind of like circle with one person around it, that kind of harkens back a little bit to me to the concern about attention to detail and perfectionism within Apple.
0:53:41Because it strikes me that a company like Apple can thrive even with a relative lack of sort of top-down control management because everybody who works at the company has.
0:53:56Inherited the taste of the company, you know what I mean?
0:54:01If you go into Apple with Apple taste, you don't need a manager's manager's manager telling you like how to make a control strip or whatever.
0:54:10You have it built in.
0:54:11And I think a lot of times since I left Apple, people ask me, what are Apple interviews like?
0:54:17And, well, there's no answer to that because every single group in every part of the company does it a little differently.
0:54:24And by contrast, Google's interviews are like famously the same.
0:54:28At least they used to be.
0:54:29But it was like at Google, they have a top-down – like every interview will go like this.
0:54:35And at Apple, I don't think they're – the only thing – granted, this was 20 years ago, 25 years ago.
0:54:42But the only thing I had to do in preparation for interviewing a candidate for my first time was either watch or go to some kind of like seminar where they teach you how to not be discriminatory.
0:54:55And I think it was worthwhile.
0:54:56I probably would have made mistakes if it wasn't for that.
0:54:59But apart from that, the only guidance about interviewing came from my manager.
0:55:04And that's how it worked as far as I know all throughout Apple.
0:55:07It was all – how do we hire the way that the specific manager wants to hire?
0:55:12The other thing too – and this is where you really have to wonder – I have to wonder what the hell – how did this break down?
0:55:23Is it just used to be that you might disagree with the choice.
0:55:31Like I said earlier, hey, should the grip strip on the control – or should the control strip buttons look three-dimensional or should they look flat?
0:55:39And they looked three-dimensional.
0:55:41They were – it was in the three-dimensional buttons looked like things – actual buttons you could press and go in.
0:55:46But if somebody said, well, maybe these should look flat because the menu bar is still flat.
0:55:51The menu bar doesn't look three-dimensional in any way.
0:55:53And the control strip should be more like a portable version of the menu bar.
0:55:57It should be flat.
0:55:58And somebody said flat.
0:55:59And somebody said they should look 3D.
0:56:00And 3D won.
0:56:01But once 3D was the choice, which you might disagree with, there was an agreement of what looks properly 3D.
0:56:09What looks pixel perfect as 3D?
0:56:12And if there was like a gap between some of the buttons but not some of the other buttons in the control strip, everybody would see it.
0:56:19And it would be like if you're the one working on it and you're showing it to me, you're like, I know there's a gap there.
0:56:24I'm going to fix that.
0:56:25Right?
0:56:26It wouldn't be like, ah, who cares?
0:56:29So what?
0:56:29There's a gap between some of them.
0:56:31Right?
0:56:32So what?
0:56:33Who cares if sometimes you're scrolling a sidebar in Tahoe and the search field content goes underneath it, rendering both the search field and the content underneath completely inscrutable?
0:56:45Who cares?
0:56:46Right?
0:56:47Somehow something broke where you can point to this and say, well, here's a box where I can still click on it and I can type what I'm searching for, but I cannot read the letters I'm typing as I'm typing the search query because of this transparency and layering.
0:57:05And somehow they're like, well, we'll still ship it.
0:57:09And that is so far beyond the sort of, hey, this is misaligned by two pixels.
0:57:17That used to be like a priority.
0:57:20Well, we absolutely cannot ship this off by two pixels.
0:57:24It just used to be, and that thinking permeated the whole indie Mac culture too, right?
0:57:33All the indie Mac developers I know were, if anything, more persnickety.
0:57:37I remember one time when I was at Bare Bones, probably towards the end, like in 2002, and we were working on Yojimbo, which is still around.
0:57:48It's sort of a notes slash bookmarks, passwords, junk drawer app.
0:57:55And in office, and I went down the hallway to our mutual friend, Jim Correa, who was at Bare Bones at the time, and I could tell that the sidebar was one pixel too low, one pixel.
0:58:06And he looked at it, he's like, oh, yeah.
0:58:09And he knew why.
0:58:10He's like, oh, yeah.
0:58:11You wouldn't understand the explanation completely, but it was Bare Bones' first Coco app, and Jim and its colleague Steve Kalkorf had thrown themselves and learned Coco, and they'd made this sort of use every aspect of Coco app.
0:58:24And it was like, it's a subclass of something, and when you subclass it, it's going to go down.
0:58:29And at the moment, and it was like, let's say it was a Wednesday afternoon, he was like, I don't think there's anything we can do about that.
0:58:35And I was like, all right.
0:58:36And it was one pixel, the whole sidebar was one pixel too low.
0:58:39And then the next morning, Jim called me in, and he was like, I couldn't stop thinking about it, and here, look.
0:58:45And he fixed it, right?
0:58:46Of course he did, yes.
0:58:48He lost sleep that night because it bothered him.
0:58:53And while he couldn't think of it, and it was only literally just one pixel, and it didn't look wrong.
0:58:59I just knew that it didn't used to look like that, and it shouldn't look like that.
0:59:02But then once I, and Jim hadn't even noticed, but then once I pointed it out, he couldn't sleep until he fixed it.
0:59:07That's amazing.
0:59:08Everything was like that everywhere across macOS, right?
0:59:12And then you'd get to an app like, oh, Microsoft came out with a new version of Word, and it's not like that at all.
0:59:19And that's why Mac users kind of held their nose to use Microsoft Office at the time, because it's like, this was the difference between Mac-like and un-Mac-like software.
0:59:29It's not just that some of the idioms aren't right.
0:59:33It's like there's just no attention to detail.
0:59:36And the attention to detail is the one thing that, no matter if you disagree, should this button be a rectangle or an oval?
0:59:45You might think one way.
0:59:46You might think the other way.
0:59:47But whichever way it's decided, that rectangle or that oval should be pixel perfect.
0:59:52Yeah.
0:59:52You're reminding me that I've had this experience.
0:59:56So I started at Apple as a QA engineer.
0:59:59So I was – my job was to look for problems.
1:00:01It was great.
1:00:03I was already a fussy person.
1:00:04I just look for problems and report them.
1:00:06And the key was you were considered to be doing a good job the more things you noticed and reported.
1:00:12And so –
1:00:15Right.
1:00:16It wasn't like, hey, why are you reporting all these things?
1:00:19Right, right, right.
1:00:20You should shut up.
1:00:20It was the opposite, right?
1:00:22It was the opposite.
1:00:23You sent bug reports in like this word is one pixel off.
1:00:28And what I've learned over the years since then is I'm pretty good about reporting bugs both to Apple and to other engineers, other developers of apps.
1:00:37There are some people, some developers I don't report bugs to because they have demonstrated their lack of attention to detail by responding to my bug reports with like dismissive, well, who cares?
1:00:52Or why does that matter?
1:00:54Who cares if the sidebar is one pixel too low?
1:00:56And other developers though, it's kind of like when you – like I know when I read Daring Fireball, I can feel good about reporting any typo or grammatical issue because I know you strive for perfection in that department.
1:01:12And there are other people I have come to realize the last thing you want to do is report a typo to them.
1:01:19I take it as a personal attack and it's like, okay, well, I was just trying to make you better.
1:01:24But it's the same thing with software.
1:01:26And I think there's some people at Apple who are saying who cares if the pixels one stays off.
1:01:31Or that they're mad, right, that they're offended.
1:01:32They're like, why are you picking on me?
1:01:34They feel attacked.
1:01:36They're taking it personally.
1:01:37And I've brought this up multiple times.
1:01:40But one of the most interesting classes – and there's like this one thing I learned from it.
1:01:45But I took a screenwriting class in college at Drexel.
1:01:49And the guy who taught it, his name was Martin Donoff.
1:01:52And he was a great professor.
1:01:54And he had worked on a whole bunch of shows, TV shows, over the decades.
1:01:58He had been a – maybe not the showrunner, but he was one of the writing people for ALF, which was a big hit.
1:02:07And then he was the showrunner on the ALF Saturday morning cartoon.
1:02:12And he'd worked on other things like PBS, like Masterpiece Theater, like real serious adult drama.
1:02:16He had no embarrassment about having worked on ALF.
1:02:19It was a big hit.
1:02:20I think he made a lot of money on it.
1:02:22I hope he did.
1:02:22But the lesson that he learned – we would write – every week, it was a once-a-week class.
1:02:26And every week, you have to write like a scene for something.
1:02:29It might be a comedy.
1:02:30It might be a drama.
1:02:31Whatever.
1:02:31You had to write a one-page screenplay for a scene.
1:02:34And then everybody before the class, there'd be copies that you could get of everybody else's.
1:02:40And I guess we got them electronically, like by email or something.
1:02:43And you were expected to read everybody else in the class's scene.
1:02:47And then there'd be a group discussion where we would critique each other's scenes because you were supposed to have read them before the class started.
1:02:53And the golden rule was you criticized the work, not the person.
1:02:58So you say, hey, this line of dialogue doesn't sound right for the character.
1:03:05The dialogue, the character, not you, Daniel, the person who wrote this scene.
1:03:11You shouldn't have had the character say that.
1:03:13You're making the same point, but the way you phrase it is – and he would interrupt.
1:03:19And people weren't taking it personally and nobody in the class was mean.
1:03:22But if anybody phrased it like you shouldn't have – you should have this character say more here.
1:03:28He would interrupt and he'd say, not the you, the character.
1:03:32The character should say more here.
1:03:33And we all got it.
1:03:34But it was a brilliant breakthrough because it takes that personal aspect of it.
1:03:38But there are still people who, if you phrase your criticisms this way, right, that you focus on the work, they still take it personally, right?
1:03:47And that's what you're talking about.
1:03:48And I hate it.
1:03:49I love typo reports from readers for my writing.
1:03:53Certainly if it's like a spelling mistake or, God forbid, I get somebody's – spell somebody's name wrong, which is like the worst.
1:04:00But even for things that aren't errors but like, hey, I don't know.
1:04:04This sentence confused me, right?
1:04:06I love feedback like that because nine times out of ten, if I reread the sentence, I'm like, oh, I do see that that's not – it's sort of confusing.
1:04:15I know what I meant because I wrote it, but I can see how that sentence is ambiguous.
1:04:20And I love feedback like that because I don't have an editor.
1:04:24Right.
1:04:25But – and the people like you who will frequently report typos, you don't preface it with, hey, sorry, but I think you spelled this word wrong.
1:04:34But when I get like first-time reports from random readers, they're always very apologetic.
1:04:39Hey, sorry, I think you spelled this word wrong or something like that or I think you're missing a punctuation mark here.
1:04:45And it's very obvious that I'm missing a punctuation mark because the paragraph ends without a period, right?
1:04:50Yeah.
1:04:51It's like – but they're so cautious because they know other people are offended.
1:04:54And I try to always write back to those emails and say, thank you.
1:04:57No need to apologize.
1:04:58I love getting typo reports.
1:05:00I fixed it.
1:05:00Thanks to you.
1:05:01And – but people feel like that.
1:05:04And I do think that at Apple, it was – and the indies – the best indie software was all from people.
1:05:11They might be annoyed that there's a bug to fix, but they're not annoyed at you for reporting it, right?
1:05:17Right, right, right.
1:05:18It's – there's a difference.
1:05:20Yeah, I still have to often – I mean it's funny actually.
1:05:24Our mutual friend, Paul Kafasis, he's an active user.
1:05:27Yeah, it's this guy from Boston.
1:05:29He's an active user of my crossword app for iOS.
1:05:33And he sends me lots of bug reports.
1:05:35And it's great.
1:05:36And even him, it just so happens today, he sent me like a litany of reports.
1:05:42And he's like, sorry for the – whatever – for the glut of reports.
1:05:45I'm like, no, no, no.
1:05:46I'd rather have you report it to me than everybody in the public report it to me.
1:05:51I – he reports a lot of typos to me as well.
1:05:56I bet, yeah.
1:05:57You could tell when he's –
1:05:58He's got a good critical eye.
1:06:00He's actually – and it's funny you mentioned Paul, but he's actually very good at pointing out ambiguous sentences to me.
1:06:06Not just typos, which he will, but he's one of my top reporters of, hey, maybe you should rephrase this sentence just because it's not clear or could be read two different ways.
1:06:17It's such a benefit, but you really have to have the right mindset.
1:06:20And I feel like something has been lost within Apple.
1:06:23And then the other – the problem is it cascades because once it kind of gets out of control, like the way you achieve near pixel perfection in software is to get near pixel perfection in software and then try to stay there.
1:06:39Like little – something changed, you upgrade to a new version of OS, and now this button is way too close to the bottom of the dialogue.
1:06:49Or, you know, it's like here's what happened.
1:06:51I upgraded the OS, and now this dialogue box looks wrong.
1:06:55It sticks out because there aren't that many mistakes.
1:07:00But now it's like where do you start, right?
1:07:03It's like, you know, like a wild dog ran through your house and tore up all the furniture and ripped open a trash bag.
1:07:12That scene in Christmas Vacation where the dog goes nuts in the kitchen and tears everything apart.
1:07:18Where do you start cleaning it up?
1:07:20It's got to start somewhere, right?
1:07:22Right.
1:07:23The Journey of a Thousand Miles.
1:07:25Well, let me take another break here and thank our next sponsor of the show.
1:07:28And it is, once again, Shocker, our good friends at Squarespace.
1:07:32This podcast is sponsored, once again, by Squarespace.
1:07:35And Squarespace is the all-in-one website platform designed to help you stand out and succeed online.
1:07:43Whether you're just starting out or scaling your business, Squarespace gives you everything you need.
1:07:48Or someone you know who comes to you for help as, like, the resident nerd in their social circle.
1:07:54Send them to Squarespace and send them with my code.
1:07:57They give you everything you need to claim.
1:07:59Everything from your domain to setting up the way your website looks.
1:08:03To tweaking the way it looks.
1:08:05To updating the content on the website on a regular basis.
1:08:09Like, if it's got, like, a blog or you just have little news items or whatever.
1:08:14You update the website through Squarespace, too.
1:08:17Not just create it and then use something else.
1:08:20All of it you could do in one place.
1:08:23They have so much new stuff.
1:08:26One of the new things they have is analytics, which they've improved greatly in recent years.
1:08:31The built-in analytics at Squarespace websites is one of the best analytics dashboards I've ever seen.
1:08:37Where it's not minimal.
1:08:39It has a lot of information.
1:08:41But it is unlike so many other analytics packages.
1:08:45Google Analytics, I am looking in your direction.
1:08:47It is cohesively designed in a way that you don't have to, like, read a manual to understand the analytics.
1:08:55You just look at it and it's as clear as, hopefully, the dashboard of your car or something like that.
1:09:00So, selling content, selling time, selling products, whatever it is you're hoping to sell, whether it's something virtual like software or whether it's something physical like physical goods or whether it is your time because you're a consultant or a trainer or something like that.
1:09:16You can set up your Squarespace website to handle that sort of stuff.
1:09:20And one of the other new features they've got is Squarespace invoices where it ties together where if whatever it is that you're selling needs an invoice, the invoice you can do through Squarespace, too.
1:09:31Your customers get the invoice, pay the invoice, and it comes to you, including the payment processing, all through the Squarespace platform.
1:09:37Where do you go to find out more?
1:09:40Go to squarespace.com slash talk show.
1:09:45Head there, squarespace.com slash talk show, and save 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain.
1:09:52I want to circle back before I guess we can move on to something other than bitching about Tahoe.
1:09:58But the other thing when I was talking about Ternus, and yeah, of course, he's the guy who they're talking about as the next CEO of the company because he runs hardware, and hardware's the best thing going on.
1:10:07The other point I made on Daring Fireball, and I think it's really key, is that Apple's hardware designers are absolutely unafraid to keep things the same year after year if they don't have a better idea.
1:10:21That they've gotten MacBooks to a point where this is the way a MacBook should look.
1:10:28It should have round corners.
1:10:29It should have a trackpad that is a very large part of the palm rest, but not the whole palm rest.
1:10:34It should have a keyboard that looks like this.
1:10:38And every couple of years, there's a major redesign, and even the major redesigns, like from the Intel, the last era Intel MacBooks to the first redesigned Apple Silicon era ones, they don't look altogether new, right?
1:10:54They're just sort of thinner, flatter.
1:10:56The MacBook Air is no longer wedge-shaped.
1:10:58It's just flat, but thin.
1:11:01And then the M3 MacBook Air looks like the M2, and the M4 MacBook Air looks like the M3, which looks just like the M2, and maybe they tweak the colors.
1:11:09But they have this confidence to keep things the same if they know that they're still the best.
1:11:15And that's where I feel like things under Alan Dye, really.
1:11:20That's the bottom line of how did this happen.
1:11:22I think, and I know it sounds like a harsh word, but I really do think Alan Dye is a fraud.
1:11:27I do not think he is a good user interface designer at all.
1:11:31I actually don't know that he's a very good graphic designer at all, which is what he came from.
1:11:36But he's definitely not a good user interface or interaction designer.
1:11:41And his skills lie elsewhere.
1:11:45The politics of navigating a company like Apple and pleasing the people above him on the org chart.
1:11:51And managing, to some degree, the enormous design talent in the ranks of the rank-and-file designers at Apple, who are still incredibly talented.
1:12:00And that's why, overall, the design of Apple's software is still good overall, looking at the rest of the industry.
1:12:07But there's a lack of confidence that comes from being a fraud, where you feel like you've got to keep new, even if new isn't better.
1:12:16And I think if, like, over the last 10 years, the Mac OS interface had changed as little as the Mac hardware has changed over the same 10 years,
1:12:27this whole conversation would not be happening.
1:12:30And you probably wouldn't even be on the show right now.
1:12:34Yeah.
1:12:35Well, that's a really good point.
1:12:36When you talk about that, it reminds me, people often compare Apple to Porsche for the way that, like, the, like, Roadster or whatever would look the same.
1:12:459-11, famously.
1:12:47Oh, the 9-11.
1:12:48Okay.
1:12:49So, that's if it's not broken, don't fix it type of thinking.
1:12:52And you're right.
1:12:53The MacBook, I'm looking down at my MacBook right now.
1:12:56My first Intel Mac practically looked just like this, just thicker.
1:13:01It was like, things have not changed in decades in a significant way, except for they, of course, get thinner.
1:13:07And I actually was just remembering the touch bar is actually a really good metaphor or comparison for the control strip.
1:13:13It was the one we were trying to kind of explain.
1:13:15So, but that's the example of where Apple took a bold step, but then recognized that it was a mistake, and they pulled back.
1:13:23So, yeah, I don't know.
1:13:26I feel kind of like you're right.
1:13:29Like, we should know by now whether a button should be rounded or square, what size it should be, whether it should look 3D or not, whether it should turn to glass when you click it.
1:13:41Some of these things we should just know as facts, and they shouldn't be kind of like taste-based, I think.
1:13:49And they shouldn't be going for novelty every few years, right?
1:13:53The menu bar should still look like the menu bar did 10 years ago, where it doesn't have to be white, but it should be in light mode.
1:14:00It should be a close to white menu bar with black text, and when you click it, a rectangle around the menu name is highlighted in a very vibrant way, and the rectangular menu drops down beneath it.
1:14:14That's the way it should look.
1:14:16Like, and if it looked, it was a solved problem, leave it solved, and put your attention and your urge to mark your territory like a fucking dog on new stuff, right?
1:14:27It's this, I think, a deep insecurity in Alan Dine and her team led them to want to put their mark on things that had come before them, and they've just, I really don't mean this in any hyperbolic way.
1:14:43It's if they've vandalized it, they really have, and I really do think it's fundamentally a lack of confidence.
1:14:50It's an unconfident designers who insist on new, because new, at least, you can say, well, you just, your complaint is just that you don't like new stuff, right?
1:15:00You're a fuddy-duddy, and you want things to stay the same, and you don't get it.
1:15:04The software needs to keep changing.
1:15:06It is sort of a defense mechanism, and it's kind of hard to argue with that.
1:15:10It's a sophistry, I don't know if that's an adjective or not, but it's a way of debating that sort of avoids debating the actual point of, put aside whether it's new or old, is this a good design for this?
1:15:23And is there a reason to break people's expectations, right?
1:15:27The shape of the windows, the way windows look, whether it is obvious at a glance, instantly, if you see four windows on screen at once, which one is the active window?
1:15:38That should be obvious.
1:15:40That is just part of using a computer, whether it's light mode or dark mode or Windows or Mac or a version of Linux or iPad with multiple windows open.
1:15:50If there are multiple windows, and it is important because keyboard focus can only go to one place at a time, which one is my typing going to go to?
1:15:58That should be very obvious.
1:16:00And instead of making it more obvious, and changes to it should be in the favor of making it more obvious in a way that looks cool, which one is front most, not less.
1:16:10And they just keep making – it's like they're bleaching the whole OS and making it ever more inscrutable, which one is active.
1:16:20I think – getting back to my optimism a little bit, I think what you're describing is a situation where there's probably like a collective sigh of relief among many people who worked for Alan Dye, whose ideas or priorities may have been suppressed over the past several years.
1:16:40There's got to – under any leader, there are people who are suffering with disagreements with the leadership.
1:16:47And I kind of envision now Apple's design department as having like – if it's a garden, like somebody has come in and raked all of the leaves out, and everything can grow now.
1:17:01And that's my really kind of like rosy, rose glasses view of hopefully the next few years.
1:17:07Not only is a leader who has been criticized gone, it's almost poetic that he went to one of Apple's biggest competitors slash enemies.
1:17:18I would say the biggest, right?
1:17:20In a way.
1:17:20Not that they compete directly, but they kind of are starting to with the glasses, right?
1:17:25Where Meta is perhaps more – if you name just the big five or six companies, Microsoft, Google, Amazon – who else should we put in the list?
1:17:35NVIDIA, I guess, deserves to be there.
1:17:37But NVIDIA doesn't make their own devices, right?
1:17:40The one company amongst all of those that is making the sort of devices that Apple makes is Meta with the glasses and with the headsets and stuff like that.
1:17:50But I think culturally it's more than that, right?
1:17:52Meta is the company where Tim Cook, in an interview when they asked him, hey, what would you have done if you were Mark Zuckerberg and you got into the – I think it was the Cambridge Analytica thing.
1:18:02I don't know, whatever.
1:18:02It was some kind of privacy-related scandal.
1:18:05And he's – I wouldn't have been in that situation in the first place.
1:18:09Stone cold.
1:18:10Yeah.
1:18:12And there is a culture within Apple, certainly once you reach senior levels, that these are people, largely men but not all men.
1:18:19Someone like Deirdre O'Brien has been at Apple her whole career, largest part of her career, that you get to that level and Apple is your career.
1:18:28And you retire from Apple and you bleed six colors, right?
1:18:33That's something people in Apple talk about.
1:18:35And it's – you could say, oh, that sounds like a cult and maybe it could, but it's really just more like a camaraderie, right?
1:18:43And a like-mindedness that grows the longer you're there.
1:18:46It is extremely unusual for somebody at the senior vice president level at Apple to leave for another company.
1:18:53I mean I'm trying to think of somebody before Alan Dye who did.
1:18:56It's very, very rare.
1:18:58Right, and just to name one, I'll bet Craig Federighi gets a lot of emails from recruiters looking for CEOs, right?
1:19:06Sure, yeah.
1:19:07I'll bet if like you looked at like the last 20 years of Craig Federighi's email, how many times he's been offered serious job offers as the CEO of another tech company.
1:19:18It's probably ridiculously large and I don't know that he ever even reads them, right?
1:19:23That they just go right to trash because he's not looking for that.
1:19:27But of all the companies for someone to actually leave for to be meta, to me it just proves the point that Alan Dye never belonged at Apple in the first place.
1:19:35What I was thinking as you were describing it is they are not business competitors as much as philosophical competitors.
1:19:43Like if you look at the Venn diagram of overlapping philosophical beliefs with Apple, you can find some that are shared with Google and are shared with Microsoft.
1:19:55And Amazon in certain ways, right?
1:19:57Sure, yep.
1:19:58But there are very few that are shared with Facebook or Meta.
1:20:01Yeah, yeah, right.
1:20:03There was a guy, I don't know if I linked it at Daring Fireball or not.
1:20:07I couldn't, I don't remember, but it doesn't matter.
1:20:10But at the last AWS conference, a couple months ago, sometime like late 2025, Amazon had their big AWS conference.
1:20:18And somebody from Apple came and spoke for like a 10 or 15 minute stint in the keynote.
1:20:25The way that Apple, when they had onstage keynotes at WWDC, would bring in somebody from Intel or from Microsoft to talk about Office and the new APIs or whatever.
1:20:36Here's Jerry Yang from Yahoo to talk about doing the weather app for the original iPhone or something like that.
1:20:42And it was somebody from Apple who came to talk about how much the App Store uses AWS behind the scenes and how running Swift code on the server at AWS made something faster.
1:20:57Like way faster and fixed a whole bunch of bugs because Swift is memory safe and all this and it just runs great on AWS.
1:21:04So they were there to talk about some Apple technology like running Swift on the server, but it was at an AWS conference.
1:21:10And you think, hey, when's the last time you saw someone from Apple speaking at somebody else's conference?
1:21:15Well, there's some overlap with Amazon where they go, guess whose developer conference I don't think we're ever going to see an Apple person speak at.
1:21:23Yeah, exactly.
1:21:23No, you're right.
1:21:25I might soil my pants if I found somebody said, holy shit, somebody from Apple spoke at Meta Connect or whatever the hell the name of their developer conference is.
1:21:34Right.
1:21:34Yeah.
1:21:35It would be shocking.
1:21:37Whereas with the Amazon, it was like, oh, yeah, of course, it kind of makes sense that Apple is leaning on AWS for a lot of the server infrastructure for the App Store rather than building it out on her own.
1:21:48Before we move on, the other one I really do want to talk about is the fucking icons in the menus.
1:21:55Oh, yeah.
1:21:56Okay.
1:21:57Yeah.
1:21:57I this is one of those things.
1:22:00The more I look at it, because the more I'm using Tahoe here while I'm complaining about it, the more angry.
1:22:07Oh, it makes me so angry.
1:22:09This and the fact that like old versions of the Hig specifically said, hey, don't just add icons to every menu item that just looks disorganized and confusing and makes it hard to read the menu.
1:22:20And then they have like examples.
1:22:22And there's one from like 1992.
1:22:24And then there's an updated one from, I don't know, 2004 with a totally different art style to match the look of the Mac at the time.
1:22:31But the don't do this.
1:22:33It looks exactly like screenshots from Tahoe.
1:22:36Yeah.
1:22:38I heard a good amount of conversation about this.
1:22:40Maybe you did, too, on the ATP.
1:22:42And something I think John Syracuse pointed out that even now, apparently, the guidance says not everything needs an icon.
1:22:53Right.
1:22:53But I'm looking right now at Safari and damn near every menu item has an icon, even to the point where they use a generic globe for all the like sites you visited that don't have a favicon.
1:23:07Yeah.
1:23:08Right.
1:23:08And then it's funny, though.
1:23:10I think that's always been the case for the history menu, though, because they do show the five fav icons for ones that do.
1:23:15So now you're looking at the one that always.
1:23:17That makes sense.
1:23:19Yep.
1:23:20One of the best examples, and the Hig always said this, too, that if adding an icon can clarify the meaning, then, yes, add it.
1:23:31And it really is that it's the lesson from the Incredibles movies from Pixar, where they outlaw being a superhero.
1:23:39And it's like if everybody's equally special, then nothing is special.
1:23:43If every single menu item has an icon, then none of the icons are special.
1:23:49And they're just you can't come up with icons for some of these things.
1:23:53Right.
1:23:53What is the icon for show reader?
1:23:55It's a rectangle with a little, you know, it looks like a tiny little text document because I guess you're reading text.
1:24:02And there were two really good blog posts about it.
1:24:05There was the Tonsky one that I linked to both of them.
1:24:09Yeah.
1:24:09It's hard to justify Tahoe icons by Nikita Prokopov.
1:24:15Hard to justify.
1:24:15Oh, just.
1:24:16Okay.
1:24:17Nikita Prokopov.
1:24:19And I'll put links to these back in the show notes.
1:24:21But he pointed out how if you go to two apps that have the same menu command from Apple, both from Apple, they use different icons.
1:24:28Like it was maybe partially a rush job, but partially like, well, some of these commands, they're so abstract where it's like, how do you come up with that?
1:24:40What would like, or I'm looking at Mars at it right now because I was looking up those blog posts.
1:24:45So you've got in the view menu for which things you can view in a window, like title field, slug field, link field, keywords field.
1:24:55Well, what's the difference between a title field and a link field, right?
1:24:58Right.
1:24:59And it's like, well, a link, you could use like the chain link link thing.
1:25:04And the title, you can make like a capital T or something.
1:25:08But then all of a sudden, they're both just text fields.
1:25:11So the icons don't really look as similar as the, you know, why?
1:25:15This was a solved problem.
1:25:17You know what people do with menus?
1:25:19They read them.
1:25:20They read menus.
1:25:21When you go to a restaurant, you read.
1:25:24And a menu at a restaurant is a perfect example.
1:25:27And I bet you know this firsthand is a lot of times you go to a restaurant, they will have an icon to represent vegetarian dishes.
1:25:38And that is a very useful icon.
1:25:41And you put it next to certain items on the menu, which have no animal products in the making of the meal.
1:25:49And if you are a vegetarian, that is a very useful, very useful icon to have.
1:25:55But if every menu item on the menu has its own icon to represent that dish, then having one special icon to mark some of them for a very specific reason that is very important to some people, all of a sudden you can't see it.
1:26:13Right.
1:26:14And you've got to, like, run your finger down the page and kind of look for the icon that you're looking for.
1:26:18In the window menu, move and resize, and this has been true for a couple versions, you can go and you can, like, it's a system-wide feature.
1:26:26Go to window, move and resize, and you can move a window to the left.
1:26:31Or you can move it to the right, and it'll take up half the screen on the right.
1:26:35Well, those commands have had icons on macOS for a couple of years now because the icons show you exactly what the window will look like after you use it.
1:26:45And it's actually better to use the icons for what you want to achieve than to read, right?
1:26:52Another one that didn't have icons, but I think in hindsight should have, is to rotate a photo like in Preview or the Photos app.
1:27:02It'll say in the menu, rotate counterclockwise or rotate clockwise.
1:27:09So I am pretty good with clockwise and counterclockwise, but I still have to think for a second.
1:27:15But there's a lot of people out there, and I live with two of them, who always get it wrong.
1:27:20They just, if you say clockwise, you know, it's like a piece of buttered toast that always falls on the wrong side.
1:27:25They're always guessing the wrong way.
1:27:26But the icon, which shows which way the rotate command works, is actually more clarifying than using the words clockwise or counterclockwise.
1:27:36Draw the arrow showing which way the photo is going to rotate.
1:27:40That would have been a good icon to put in macOS 20 years ago or two years ago or 10 years ago or whenever.
1:27:48Now it's there in macOS Tahoe, but those icons are lost because all the other menu items have icons too, and they don't stand out.
1:27:58Whereas if only rotate clockwise and rotate counterclockwise had icons, they would draw your attention, and you'd be like, oh, yeah, those are the two rotate commands.
1:28:08One rotates this way, one rotates that way.
1:28:10Because everything is special, nothing is special.
1:28:12Because everything has an icon, no icons stand out.
1:28:16I think that's a really good point, especially with the comparison to restaurant menus.
1:28:21We don't often think of menus on computers as directly comparable to restaurant menus, but of course that's where it came from.
1:28:28I mean, at least the idea, a menu of options.
1:28:31And they're organized into sections, right?
1:28:34Like here's the entrees, here's the appetizers, here's the beverages.
1:28:38Right, and so if Apple was in charge of the restaurant menu, there would just be like a generic food icon for anything that nobody could come up with an icon for.
1:28:48I'm looking in preview right now.
1:28:50This is another example that sort of drives home the uselessness of it.
1:28:53If you look in preview under the view menu, you got hide sidebar and thumbnails, which are about as similar an icon as you can get without being identical.
1:29:05It shows a rounded rect with a visual sidebar with three dots representing the content.
1:29:13And it's like, oh, I know.
1:29:15Which one do I want?
1:29:16Oh, I know.
1:29:16I want the one with the three dots that are more centered.
1:29:19I have to take my glasses off and get closer to the screen to see the difference.
1:29:23I can see that the icons aren't exactly the same, but I would have to get closer to the screen to see what the difference is.
1:29:28And it's two totally different commands, right?
1:29:31It's madness.
1:29:33All of the zoom icons, they're so small, I can't even tell which ones have a plus.
1:29:39There's actual size is like a magnifying glass with a one in it.
1:29:43Zoom to fit is a magnifying glass with, I guess, arrows in it.
1:29:48Zoom in is a magnifying glass with a plus.
1:29:51Zoom out is a magnifying glass with a minus sign.
1:29:54The magnifying glasses are so small that those little plus minus or a number one, whatever the hell is in zoom to fit is they're all you can't see them.
1:30:03They all just look like magnifying glasses.
1:30:07So how do you, they don't help.
1:30:09One of the things that was so great in Prokopov's, I think it was his, the other guy who wrote the really good post on this was icons and menus everywhere send help by Jim Nielsen.
1:30:18So I forget if it was Jim Nielsen or Nikita Prokopov who wrote this, who just said, okay, take all the words out of the menus and just show the icons.
1:30:28Can you tell what they do?
1:30:30And he like showed an example.
1:30:31You can't tell what they do.
1:30:33There would be no possible way to possibly navigate the menu bar in Tahoe by the icons alone if you took the words out.
1:30:41But other scenarios where words go with icons like toolbars, right?
1:30:47Like the toolbar, the Cocoa toolbar in Apple Mail or in MarsEdit.
1:30:53And you can set the toolbar to icon only, icon and text or text only, right?
1:30:59That's been this way since Mac OS X shipped 25 years ago.
1:31:03Because a toolbar only has enough, you know, what's the most toolbar items an app usually has?
1:31:09A dozen is probably pretty busy, right?
1:31:11So it's fewer than a dozen toolbar buttons.
1:31:14Probably more like six, seven, eight of the most used commands.
1:31:19And because they're the most used commands, you can come up with icons that represent them.
1:31:23So you could use it icon only.
1:31:25You could use it icon and text.
1:31:27Or you could use it text only because either way you can kind of remember or learn what they represent.
1:31:32But when it's 50 different menu commands, you can't possibly memorize them by icon alone.
1:31:38And so the icons just add noise.
1:31:40It is so frustrating that Apple of all companies shipped an OS with this as the design change.
1:31:49All right, let me take a break here for one more sponsor read.
1:31:53Our fourth and final sponsor of this episode, our good friends at Factor.
1:31:57Factor's chef-prepped, dietician-approved meals make it easy to stay on track and enjoy something comforting and delicious and easy to prepare no matter how hectic your life is.
1:32:13Factor, it's not a meal kit where you get a bunch of ingredients and then you spend 15, 20, 30 minutes putting them all together and then cooking it.
1:32:21These are pre-made meals that come sealed up, refrigerated.
1:32:25They come in a box with dry ice to keep everything cold and refrigerated.
1:32:30You put them in the refrigerator.
1:32:31But these are fresh meals that then when you're ready to eat them, you can just heat them up in the microwave.
1:32:39It takes just a couple minutes to heat them up and you've got a full meal ready to go.
1:32:43And it is really good food.
1:32:45I am just a huge fan of so many of the items there, including their breakfast items in particular.
1:32:51But they've got everything and they've got all sorts of categories, lots of meat options, lots of steak and pork chops and stuff like that, lots of vegetarian options.
1:33:00They have a whole category of new Mediterranean diet options that are packed with protein and good for you fats from Mediterranean diet type meals.
1:33:11And they've got Asian-inspired meals with bold flavors influenced by China, Thailand and more from better choices, from more choices to better nutrition.
1:33:21That's why 97% of customers of Factor say that Factor helped them live a healthier life.
1:33:28These are really good meals.
1:33:29They really do feel healthy, but they are delicious too.
1:33:32So you get variety.
1:33:34You get tons of choices every time you order a new package of Factor meals.
1:33:41So many choices to choose from, something to please everybody, a whole bunch of great breakfast items too.
1:33:46I am a big fan of it.
1:33:48I really do.
1:33:48I eat them all the time.
1:33:50And when I run out, I'm a little bit sad when I'm looking for what I'm going to have for lunch.
1:33:54Eat smart at Factor meals, F-A-C-T-O-R-M-E-A-L-S, factor meals.com slash talk show 50 off.
1:34:05And use that code talk show 50 off.
1:34:08The 50 is five zero.
1:34:10Talk show five zero O-F-F, talk show 50 off, factor meals.com slash talk show 50 off.
1:34:18And you get 50% off your first box plus free breakfast for one year.
1:34:22That's talk show 50 off at factor meals.com for 50% off your first box plus free breakfast for one year.
1:34:29Get delicious ready to eat meals delivered with Factor.
1:34:32Offer only valid for new Factor customers with code and qualifying auto renewing subscription purchase.
1:34:39My thanks to Factor.
1:34:41You had mentioned in a group chat that you and I are both in that you just like last week or Friday maybe added a feature to Mars edit that you said you never would have even tried if not for AI.
1:34:56And I think cloud code in particular.
1:34:57Can you describe it quickly?
1:34:59Because that's a bold statement.
1:35:03I wouldn't have even tried this without AI, but I did it with AI and it was kind of easy.
1:35:06I will explain it because I'm delighted by it.
1:35:10And I think I can explain it in a way that everybody, programmer or not, will be able to appreciate.
1:35:14So the situation is Mars edit connects to WordPress through the WordPress XML RPC API.
1:35:24One day I'll switch to their newer RPC API, but for the time being, it uses this.
1:35:28And one of the persnickety things about the API is that it can be hard to determine when a user types their password wrong, whether the error you get, or I should rephrase that.
1:35:45There are errors you get from WordPress that mean either the user typed their password wrong, they're not authenticated, or they're trying to do something on the blog that their user's permissions don't allow.
1:35:59And so it kind of gives the same status code for each.
1:36:03In some cases, it's a real mess.
1:36:06It's like different between different API calls, et cetera.
1:36:09So for years, I have had this little hack in there that says, if the error mess, because it gives you error message text.
1:36:16And so if I get what looks like you need to.
1:36:20So the code, the code doesn't change, but the error message does change based on the context.
1:36:26And, and so long and short of it is that I have, I call it implicit password sniffing.
1:36:33Of course, no, no, implicit authentication sniffing, because I have to determine in the app, is the error I'm getting actually something I should put up a password prompt for?
1:36:44Or is it something I should just convey the message directly?
1:36:47Because you don't want to show a user a message that just says your password is wrong without giving them a field to put the right password in.
1:36:57And you don't want to give a user repeatedly a password prompt when all, when they're already logged in, they've already been able to download posts.
1:37:05And it turns out the only thing they can't do is like edit other people's posts or something like that.
1:37:09So I ran into a customer.
1:37:13This is one of these situations.
1:37:14This happens to me all the time.
1:37:15A customer's, so getting back to the perfectionism thing, getting back to the no bug report is too trivial.
1:37:23This person running in German, MarsEdit, got, reported a bug to me that every time they tried to edit a post, it asked for the password again.
1:37:35And I was like, what the heck is going on?
1:37:37And I finally realized it's this situation where I never see it myself because I have a workaround in English.
1:37:47So then the question becomes, okay, so what I'm doing is I'm searching the strings for phrases that I think imply permission problem.
1:37:54Like if the string says not allowed, I will, instead of putting up a password prompt, I'll just pass the string along to the user.
1:38:02Like you're not allowed to edit posts.
1:38:04Obviously I can't, so I see this situation.
1:38:07There's no like programmary API level way to tell that it's a authentication thing.
1:38:13I have to use the string.
1:38:15And so I'm thinking, well, I can't just say like, what does not allowed in German mean?
1:38:20And then if I do, that will only fix it for German.
1:38:23So what I used Claude, as it turns out, and ChatGPT in tandem, what I used it to do was to derive a list of error strings that WordPress returns in every language that WordPress supports.
1:38:43And then to map them from the other language back to the English version.
1:38:49So that you, if you know the English ones, you can map it to whatever other language there is.
1:38:54That's exactly right.
1:38:54But more importantly, as it turns out.
1:38:56For the same error.
1:38:57Back from every other language.
1:39:00Because you can envision how if you're on the German Mac, and MarsEdit gets an error back, and it says, you know, whatever in German, you can't edit posts.
1:39:07Right.
1:39:08I now, instead of looking for not allowed, I first translate it to English, and then look for not allowed.
1:39:18And this would have been terrifyingly difficult to put together.
1:39:23How many languages are there?
1:39:25Oh, I think it's like 70 or something.
1:39:27It's a lot.
1:39:27And if I was doing it by hand, there's no way I would have supported all of them.
1:39:32I probably would have just picked, you know, the 10 most popular languages.
1:39:35But.
1:39:37Back to French.
1:39:39So just at a high level, just to kind of, if people might be interested to hear, like, how did I approach this with AI?
1:39:45So at first I realized, luckily, the XML RPC API in WordPress is pretty much dead, like it's not being developed anymore.
1:39:54So with high confidence, I can predict that the error strings in that section of the product are not going to change.
1:40:04So I point Claude at the source file for the XML RPC server on WordPress, and I just say, give me a list of all the unique error strings that are passed to the WordPress localization function.
1:40:18So it gives me this list, whatever it is, it's like, you know, I don't know, 50 something, it's all these different error messages, like you are not allowed to upload, you are not allowed to da da da.
1:40:28So then I ask it to, like, filter out ones that obviously don't have any permission-related context.
1:40:34So I get this list of all the English strings.
1:40:37And then WordPress is localized online with an automatic, not automatic, WordPress.org-based custom, it's called GlotPress, I think.
1:40:48And it's a custom, like, anybody can contribute the translations, blah, blah, blah.
1:40:52But I now need to get a copy of these strings in all whatever 78 languages.
1:40:58And there's no way I would just, like, type every string into every language.
1:41:04So I figured out, with ChatGPT's help, how I could access the site programmatically, supplying an English string and getting back the localized string.
1:41:16Oh, and somewhere in here, I also had to have it figure out for me what all of the international, like, language codes were for all of the pertinent languages.
1:41:25And some of them, it had to, like, infer it because it wasn't, like, the language code listed wasn't the same way it was managed on the site.
1:41:33Just to say, I got this list of language codes, 70 or 80 language codes, a bunch of English strings, and then I had it write a script that would go to the WordPress localization site with each of those strings, with each of those languages.
1:41:49And it created a one megabyte text file that contained all the mappings of all of the strings.
1:41:57And so then I had it write me some code in Swift that would just, like, let me say, okay, here's the English, give me the translation.
1:42:04And then, kind of like a Jim Correa moment, I wasn't going to sleep at night if I knew that I was dedicating one megabyte of my app to supporting the rare case that somebody has a weird error in another language.
1:42:18So, with more AI help, I managed to deduplicate their situations where, like, a lot of the phrases are translated the same in, like, Mexico and Spain and whatever.
1:42:31Anyway, I ended up with this now, I think it's 16K or something small, something small enough that I'm, like, sold.
1:42:39I'm in.
1:42:39Wow.
1:42:40And that's when I committed the feature, I tested it, testing against a local WordPress install, I can change the language at will, it's working everywhere.
1:42:49Why wouldn't it work?
1:42:50It's great, fantastic.
1:42:52And there's no way in hell I would have even bitten off the first part of that challenge.
1:42:57And, like you said, I mean, I did this in, like, a matter of, like, an hour or two.
1:43:03It was something that would have taken days, at least, I think.
1:43:09I mean, I would have, as a programmer, I would have automated what I could.
1:43:15Yeah, of nonstop work.
1:43:16I would have probably figured out how to access the translations with a URL and a script and automate it.
1:43:22I would have written a Python script, probably.
1:43:25But just having it do all of it for me is incredible.
1:43:28I, that is incredible.
1:43:32I have a much, much smaller example.
1:43:34But it, and I don't, I feel like for programming type stuff, I don't use AI enough.
1:43:39And I don't do a lot of programming.
1:43:40And so, and when I do, it is sort of, like, go back to black ink and solving puzzles.
1:43:47I kind of like doing it by hand because it feels like a puzzle to make it work.
1:43:51But the other day, I linked to a post that my friend Om Malik wrote.
1:43:55And there, I've just, back to reporting typos or grammatical things.
1:43:59He repeated the same sentence in two paragraphs.
1:44:02And it was a very good sentence.
1:44:04But I knew that that was a mistake, that he didn't find in editing.
1:44:07And one of them was, like, paragraph 17 and one was paragraph 23.
1:44:11And I just, I wanted to be able to tell him which two paragraphs it was in when I told him about the typo.
1:44:17And I thought, wouldn't it be great if I could just click a button and have numbers for all the paragraphs in Safari?
1:44:23And then I thought, huh, you could probably do that with a bookmarklet.
1:44:26And I was like, I could probably figure out how to do it.
1:44:28And I was like, I'll bet ChatGPT could just make me a bookmarklet.
1:44:31And I just asked for that.
1:44:33Like, it was just a very simple prompt, like one sentence, like, write me a bookmarklet that would add a number to each paragraph.
1:44:42And it did, and that's all I asked for, and it gave it to me, and it worked on the first time when I dragged the bookmarklet to Safari.
1:44:50And that's how I know that they were paragraphs 17 and 23.
1:44:53And the other weird thing is it just counts every P tag in HTML, and sometimes outside the article, like on Daring Fireball, the by John Gruber is a P tag.
1:45:04I don't know why.
1:45:05You know, what else is it going to be?
1:45:07But then, you know, it throws the count off.
1:45:09And so I just asked it, you know, and now do a version of it with a click handler.
1:45:14So if I click on any paragraph, that paragraph becomes the new first paragraph.
1:45:18And the ones that are before that become zero, negative one, negative two.
1:45:24Yeah, it's a –
1:45:26Just type that, gave it to me, and it just worked.
1:45:29And I was like, oh.
1:45:30You didn't ask it.
1:45:33And then I spent two hours tweaking the CSS to get it to look the way I want.
1:45:39Manually.
1:45:40No, but that was fun.
1:45:42But, you know, just – I never in a million years would have sat down to write that bookmarklet because I need paragraph numbers in Safari.
1:45:49Like, it occurs to me like once a year.
1:45:52Like, there's a situation where I want it.
1:45:54So I never would have done it myself.
1:45:56But it literally was as fast as –
1:45:59I had a working bookmarklet that I was using in Safari quicker than I just described it to you here on the podcast.
1:46:07That's how quick it was.
1:46:10And that's the sort of thing that there are people like you, developers, who are actually using AI.
1:46:15And you're like, yeah, duh.
1:46:16It does a lot more than that.
1:46:18It does really –
1:46:19But I think my message here is for the people who are still somewhat skeptical that they could get anything out of it or that there's really something to it.
1:46:28And I'm not even a programmer.
1:46:29Why would I do it?
1:46:30But you might want a bookmarklet in Safari or whatever, Chrome, whatever, that does a weird thing that you kind of want.
1:46:37And that's the sort of place.
1:46:40Like, you're not building a whole app.
1:46:41You're just making a bookmark that you can select that will add blank to every paragraph on a web page.
1:46:48Right.
1:46:49And you did it – what you did was you gave it the chance to be easy.
1:46:54Like, a lot of people just say, I'm sure this isn't going to be easy, so I'm not going to try it.
1:46:58You say, well, what the heck?
1:46:59I'll just ask, can you make this for me?
1:47:01And then, of course, in 10 seconds it was done.
1:47:03And that's the magic of these LLMs.
1:47:08And I agree with you.
1:47:11I mean, I know that there's – we're going to get feedback on this show.
1:47:15Somebody is going to say, you know, we're ruining the planet, whatever, blah, blah, blah.
1:47:18There's still a huge amount of animosity from some people towards anything AI.
1:47:24It's a very charged situation.
1:47:27But there's just no denying –
1:47:29But like on the energy thing, it's like a chat GPT prompt on average takes the same amount of energy.
1:47:36And I've seen this source – I mean, I can't verify the math, but it makes sense to me – that it takes about the same amount of energy as it does to watch eight seconds of video from Netflix.
1:47:46I mean – and I've seen things like a lot of the energy was already spent to build the models, blah, blah, blah.
1:47:51Right.
1:47:52Are these people going to get in their car and drive to Walmart after they're done criticizing my use of electric power?
1:47:59The fact is humanity uses a lot of energy.
1:48:01We use a lot of energy to do a lot of things.
1:48:05And technically speaking, we don't need to use any but maybe a little fire.
1:48:09We're basking in the glories of excessive energy use.
1:48:14And I'm here for it because it is, you know, the whole like bicycle of the mind comparison of like a Mac.
1:48:23The way that like a tool like a bicycle can make you more powerful than you ever could have been without the tool, that is what AI is doing for many of us.
1:48:35Like that was one little example.
1:48:37I often have examples where I'm like I feel like I'm compelled to go share.
1:48:41And in this case, I just shared it with you on the chat we're in.
1:48:44Now I'm sharing it with everybody.
1:48:46But it is remarkable.
1:48:49And as somebody who is a generally like a humanist person, a lot of what I do, you know, the reason I report typos to you, the reason I make software that I think people will like is because I want other people to be more successful.
1:49:02If I only cared about my own success, I wouldn't be bothering.
1:49:06I wouldn't care about fixing your typos.
1:49:08I wouldn't make software for other people unless I guess unless I made a lot of money.
1:49:12But what I feel about AI is it's too good not to share.
1:49:16In other words, like people out there are missing serious improvement.
1:49:22And it is overhyped, right?
1:49:26It is absolutely 100% overhyped.
1:49:28But that doesn't mean that it shouldn't be significantly hyped.
1:49:31Everything that deserves a significant amount of hype and really is transformative is going to get overhyped, right?
1:49:38The existence of the internet was overhyped.
1:49:40Personal computers back in the 80s were overhyped, right?
1:49:44But it really was groundbreaking like that, you know, an accountant who is still doing all of the work and paper in a green book and say to his colleague who is using Lotus, you know, the first spreadsheet.
1:49:57I think Lotus 1-2-3 was the first spreadsheet, right?
1:50:00I think so.
1:50:01Not for – my memory is not that bad.
1:50:02Wait, yeah.
1:50:04You know, but they're using a spreadsheet.
1:50:06Oh, no, no, no, no, no.
1:50:06No, it wasn't Lotus 1-2-3.
1:50:08No, what was it?
1:50:09It was Dan Bricklin.
1:50:11Why am I – it's the classic.
1:50:16I got to look it up right this minute because –
1:50:18I know.
1:50:20VisiCalc.
1:50:20That's it.
1:50:21VisiCalc.
1:50:22VisiCalc.
1:50:22And I think Lotus 1-2-3 was –
1:50:24I was right to question myself.
1:50:25Yeah, yeah.
1:50:25I think Lotus 1-2-3 was like an early kind of clone copycat.
1:50:29Well, but somebody in the early PC era is using a spreadsheet and they're like, I don't see the difference.
1:50:34It doesn't take me that long.
1:50:35I have to type in the number.
1:50:36You have to type in all the numbers anyway.
1:50:38I write them on paper and then type them in a calculator and I get a sum and it's like, okay, but, you know, you've got 500 transactions from a bunch of different states and I've got 500 transactions in my spreadsheet in a bunch of different states.
1:50:51But I just realized that I had the sales tax for Maryland wrong.
1:50:56And I update that in one square, one time, and the whole thing recalculates instantly.
1:51:03And then the guy who's doing it on paper is like, oh, I need that, right?
1:51:08And AI can do things like that too, like where we've all become totally used over the last 40 years to the things like that scenario of, oh, yes, you update the Maryland sales tax once and the sum of 500 transactions, only 10 of which were from Maryland, updates, you know, you get a new sum of the total instantly.
1:51:32We're all used to that.
1:51:33But we're at this moment where there are things like your scenario with 70 different languages and WordPress to try to just add an ease of use, a nice, wouldn't it be nice if every single language that a MarsEdit user connected to WordPress is using got a sensible description of what the problem is for any language?
1:51:57Two hours.
1:51:57Two hours.
1:51:58Right?
1:51:58That is like the, you know, it's maybe not quite instantaneous, but for that task, it feels that might as well be instantaneous.
1:52:06And it's not just like fun and it's not just amazing.
1:52:12It's like it's amplifying my ability to create things.
1:52:17And that's for me, I'm a lucky person.
1:52:20Most of my needs are already met.
1:52:22So for me, it mostly is about fun and continuing to improve the things I like.
1:52:26But for other people out there, this could be like a career changing, you know, like your accountant, the one who didn't get the spreadsheet, made a lot less money the next year.
1:52:38You know what I mean?
1:52:40Like, so I, yeah, yeah, yeah, or it was, it could handle a lot fewer clients.
1:52:46At your own peril, ignore the technological advances.
1:52:49I've got a couple of wrap up points here at the end.
1:52:52I looked it up.
1:52:54It was Macromedia Director.
1:52:56Oh, yeah.
1:52:56Okay.
1:52:57Yep, yep, yep.
1:52:57Director.
1:52:58That was the prototype.
1:52:59Yeah.
1:53:00I want to mention on the menu items in Tahoe that our mutual friends, both of them, including, we keep mentioning him, Paul Kafasis at Rogue Amoeba and Brent Simmons with the latest updates, the Tahoe update to Net Newswire.
1:53:16Brent figured out a way to not have those ugly fucking icons on every menu item and not only shipped a version of Net Newswire for Tahoe that does that and takes them out, but explained, of course, because he's Brent, exactly how.
1:53:32And now Rogue Amoeba's apps for Tahoe do the same thing.
1:53:35And I will put links in the show notes to their posts about that.
1:53:38I still need to write about both of them on Daring Fireball, but there was no way that after mentioning Paul for reporting typos and complaining about the menu icons in Tahoe that I couldn't mention that Paul spearheaded Rogue Amoeba shipping software updated for the Tahoe interface without icons on every goddamn menu item.
1:53:57And last but not least, I want to say that you, Daniel Joukett, are a liar.
1:54:04That's true.
1:54:05Or is it false?
1:54:08Well, in this particular case, it's because your long-running podcast with Manton Reese, Core Intuition, ended last year.
1:54:17And then there were 12 episodes after it ended.
1:54:20I'm a dirty liar.
1:54:23Yeah.
1:54:24Well, we adopted – I know you know this, John, but we adopted the Apple versioning system.
1:54:30So last year we had episode 26.0 and 26.1.
1:54:36So I guess this year we'll move on to 27.
1:54:39Wait, is that right?
1:54:42Yeah.
1:54:42It's actually – yeah.
1:54:46If – you know, and that is actually kind of – I actually – I'm making fun of you.
1:54:51But I actually think that's kind of an interesting way to semi-retire a podcast, right?
1:54:59Where, okay, we're going to stop doing it.
1:55:02What was the old schedule?
1:55:03You guys once a month?
1:55:03Once a week, yeah.
1:55:04Once a week.
1:55:06We were weekly.
1:55:06Holy shit.
1:55:07Yeah, I bet.
1:55:08Well, I missed them.
1:55:08I mean, we were up to 400-something, I think.
1:55:10About where you are.
1:55:12But you know what?
1:55:14I don't miss them now.
1:55:15Oh, yeah.
1:55:15Now that you're doing them like twice a year, I don't miss episodes of Core Intuition.
1:55:19And it's a very interesting way to say, okay, we're not going to do once a week anymore, but we still – every once in a while, we want to talk to each other and do the Core Intuition thing about what's new in the Apple developer community.
1:55:32And I'm so glad you did it.
1:55:33And it is kind of a neat way as a fan of the show to be like, hey, it's not over-over, right?
1:55:39It's like, okay, Letterman doesn't do his nightly talk show anymore, but he's got that thing on Netflix and once a year there's like five special episodes.
1:55:46I think when we said it was over, I think we said something like, who knows what's going to happen, so don't delete us from your podcast feeds.
1:55:55And then I put out an episode and all these people were like, what?
1:55:59I thought you were over.
1:56:00I deleted it already.
1:56:01That's your problem.
1:56:02Don't delete my dinosaur feed.
1:56:04All right.
1:56:08Well, all right.
1:56:10That's it for me.
1:56:11I don't have any other follow-up points.
1:56:13Where else can we direct?
1:56:14So there's Core Intuition, which they can listen to in wherever they're listening to the talk show right now, whatever podcast app you're using to, just search for Core Intuition.
1:56:22You'll see the new episode for sharing numbers that Daniel is talking about.
1:56:28Your software is at RedSweater.com, including MarsEdit, Black Ink, which you mentioned, your crossword app.
1:56:35That's pretty much it.
1:56:37What else?
1:56:37That's just kind of like my old nostalgia stuff.
1:56:40People can enjoy your musings on social media.
1:56:44What's your favorite?
1:56:45What do you have?
1:56:46Mastodon, probably?
1:56:46Well, I start with Micro.blog because of our good friend Manton Reese.
1:56:50Oh, yeah.
1:56:50So what I do is I have pretty much taken a copy everywhere approach.
1:56:55So I write at Micro.blog, which clones it over to Blue Sky for me.
1:57:01And then I could probably automate more of this.
1:57:03But right now, I just end up putting it on Mastodon and Threads as well.
1:57:07I took some time off from Threads because I'm not philosophically aligned with Meta.
1:57:12But I'm back there because, honestly, every one of these services has become the exclusive social networking choice for somebody – some of my favorite people online.
1:57:30Right, right.
1:57:32I keep saying it.
1:57:35In some ways, it was better – it was ideal when Twitter was good overall and it was the one Twitter-like thing.
1:57:43And then when Twitter got bad and it was the one Twitter-like thing, it was terrible.
1:57:48And once Twitter went bad, there was no going back.
1:57:53And now we've got multiple things that are Twitter-like.
1:57:57And in some ways, that's good because it's a healthier – well, if one of them goes bad, if Threads goes bad because Meta owns it, we're not all sunk because we haven't all just thrown all of our stuff into one place.
1:58:11But the downside is it's like people are all over the place.
1:58:16And you can't just go to Twitter to get everybody's Twitter-like musings that you're interested in.
1:58:22You've kind of got to bounce around.
1:58:24But probably better overall.
1:58:27So people can find you there on all of these networks and you've got a wonderfully searchable surname.
1:58:33They'll probably find Jalkit first.
1:58:38All right.
1:58:39Let me just wrap it up by thanking our sponsors.
1:58:43We have four amazing sponsors for this episode.
1:58:45Notion, the AI workspace where teams and AI agents get more done together.
1:58:49Squarespace, where you can build your new website and register domains online.
1:58:55Sentry, a real-time error monitoring and tracing platform.
1:58:58And Factor, healthy eating made easy.