0:00:00Adam Angst, welcome back. I think it's been about five years since I've had you on the show, which I keep saying repeatedly to the guests on the show has been too long. When last we spoke, I believe it was the Tidbits' 30th anniversary of Tidbits.
0:00:13That probably is just about right, because we're closing in on 36 in April, I think, which is utterly incomprehensible.
0:00:22And so, to put it in context, and I think right now, as we record in mid to late February, there is no middle of February. It just goes right from early February to the end of February.
0:00:33But as we record, I think we're going to see a march that is dominated by Apple is turning 50 coverage. And, you know, it's a big anniversary, 50 years. I think Apple itself is going to be very uncomfortable with it.
0:00:47Oh, yeah, I didn't get a copy of that yet.
0:00:50Yeah, you can get Pogues' book, yeah. It's pretty.
0:00:52But I was supposed to, and I don't know why I didn't. And in fact, just before we recorded, I just emailed whoever his rep is about the fact that it's going on.
0:01:03Yeah, Simon & Schuster or someone, yeah, yeah.
0:01:05Yeah, I can't wait to read it. That's Adam. You listeners won't hold it, won't be able to see it. But Adam held up his copy of David Pogues, an early edition of David Pogues' upcoming Apple at 50 book, which I am greatly looking forward to.
0:01:18And so glad that David Pogues wrote that book, because I'm not quite sure. I don't know if anybody would do a better job at an Apple at 50 book.
0:01:27But just to put it in context, Tidbits at 36, Apple's turning 50. That means 72% of Apple's corporate lifespan, Tidbits has been around from. I can't wrap my head around that.
0:01:42And I guess for me, Daring Fireball started in 2020, 2002. So it'll turn 24 in August.
0:01:53So your big one's in next, next year then.
0:01:56Yeah, but pretty close to half. And that to me is nutty. But 72% must feel really weird for you.
0:02:04I will admit there are times when, you know, something happens and you're like, I've seen this so many times before.
0:02:12You know, it's sort of like, it's a speed bump update. Can we just say that?
0:02:17You know, like...
0:02:18Yeah, I do like saying that.
0:02:19It's like, no.
0:02:20I like that speed bump updates are back.
0:02:23Yeah, yeah.
0:02:24But we've seen them before.
0:02:25Do you have... I feel like the fact that I can't really wrap my head around the fact that Daring Fireball has been around...
0:02:33I've been doing this for almost half of Apple's lifespan.
0:02:36I just can't... It doesn't feel right to me.
0:02:38And I think that's sort of why I'm still doing what I do, is that it still feels new and fresh to me in my head.
0:02:45I've come and gone a couple of times throughout, you know, in terms of how I felt about it.
0:02:50It's tricky because I do remember very early on when I started Tidbits, I comment that I had a relatively short attention span.
0:02:58And so this was good because there was always something different happening.
0:03:03And even now, I hate it because I am much better at something has happened right about it right away.
0:03:10If I have to sit on something for, you know, two weeks or whatnot, I lose track of it.
0:03:15The world's moved on.
0:03:16There's times when something will happen and it'll kind of bring it back to front.
0:03:19And I'm like, oh, I'm a little embarrassed I didn't hit this three weeks ago.
0:03:22But now I can touch it again because it's, like, caught my attention.
0:03:26You know, shiny thing.
0:03:29We're very similar in that regard because one of the reasons I have invited you onto the show is to talk about some specific issues.
0:03:38We'll get to it in a bit.
0:03:39Some specific issues in messages and, I guess, the phone app, really, but messages, too.
0:03:48But that you had written about quite a bit ago.
0:03:51I mean, months ago, and that when you wrote about them, I read right away and I noted them and I was like, oh, I would like to link to that.
0:04:00And I have some comments to add.
0:04:02I guess your first post that I linked to was in November.
0:04:05I'm looking at the dates, November 10th.
0:04:07And then the next one was December 7th.
0:04:09And both of those feel a bit of a while ago.
0:04:12But I feel like I had a log jam of what's wrong with macOS Tahoe.
0:04:20And rather than write one 4,000-word mega essay about it, I've started breaking it.
0:04:27There's two ways I break a log jam when it's like this is a big thing I want to write about.
0:04:31Either I formulate like a 4,000-word piece that gets a lot of it off my chest, the Something's Rotten and Cupertino piece about, I don't know how many thousand words that was.
0:04:42But that was a good way of getting the, hey, what went wrong with Apple Intelligence piece about a year ago.
0:04:47I think it was March.
0:04:48But with this UI stuff and with Tahoe, macOS 26 Tahoe in particular, I think doing it piecemeal is much more effective.
0:04:58Well, and there's so many little bits, too, that are somewhat unrelated.
0:05:03Or you're not quite clear how they're related.
0:05:06Plus, they keep appearing.
0:05:07Like the whole thing with Norbert Hager and the window corners.
0:05:11Like, everyone was like, there's something wrong.
0:05:14There's something wrong.
0:05:15And it wasn't until he said, this is what's going on with your missing the edge.
0:05:20Yeah.
0:05:21So it's like when you see a sleight of hand magician who will reveal a trick.
0:05:26Here's how you do the trick.
0:05:27And it's so frigging simple.
0:05:29And you're like, I can't believe I didn't think of that.
0:05:31And with Tahoe's window resizing, where it really came down to, long story short, pretend it really is still a perfectly square, pointy cornered rectangle.
0:05:41The area where the mouse pointer tip needs to be to resize the window hasn't changed at all.
0:05:48Except there used to be like that box in the corner.
0:05:53But if you're drawing it with some of the windows, especially the ones that have been the most updated for the liquid glass effect, with such large corner radiuses.
0:06:06I'm anti-Latin.
0:06:08So I always go radiuses instead of radii.
0:06:10But you have a bit of a more of a classics education.
0:06:13So whichever one, both are accepted.
0:06:15But with such comically large radiuses, which subjectively, people have opinions on how it looks.
0:06:21And subjectively, I don't like the look either.
0:06:24But objectively, it has left it.
0:06:27What Norbert Hager?
0:06:29Hager, I assume.
0:06:31Hager, I believe.
0:06:32I think he's awesome.
0:06:32Well, I'm going to call.
0:06:33Let's pretend we're very close to him.
0:06:35And I'll call him Norbert.
0:06:35What Norbert put his finger on exactly is that a vast majority of the real estate on screen where the hot point is for resizing a window from the corner is actually off the edge of the radius of the window.
0:06:54In the dead space.
0:06:55So it looks like you're clicking behind it.
0:06:57And really, only 28% of the area of the clickable region is literally on the window.
0:07:05And most people, users, the common sense of a user is that you have to click on the thing that you can see.
0:07:13And it is a nice affordance.
0:07:15And I know somebody corrected me on the Don Norman language of affordances versus I forget the other bit of lingo.
0:07:22But I'm just going to call it an affordance, that it's just a nicety that you can click a little bit off.
0:07:28You can make a small mistake and it's okay.
0:07:32And that you can sort of – it's almost a heuristic that the click tracking can use to say if they're clicking this close to the corner and we are rounding them off a bit, they probably mean to resize the window rather than click behind it at that close of a distance.
0:07:49But, you know, when it's 72% or something like that, 72% of the area for resizing a window is actually visibly off the window.
0:08:00That is not right.
0:08:03Anyway.
0:08:06Yeah.
0:08:06Yeah.
0:08:06And there's so many of them.
0:08:09And it's the collection of them that really paints the picture rather than any one in particular.
0:08:15But anyway, back to the tidbits at 36 and Apple at 50 and your feelings on that.
0:08:20Yeah.
0:08:21Does it feel like you've been writing about Apple for 72% of its lifespan?
0:08:26Honestly, it does.
0:08:27So part of the reason why it does is we're renovating the master bathroom right now.
0:08:34And so we have to use the bathroom, the second bathroom on this floor of the house.
0:08:37We went through something like that a couple years ago.
0:08:40And it's right on the other side of that wall in my office.
0:08:42And so when we're brushing our teeth at night, we're the sorts who kind of wander around while we're brushing our teeth and look at things.
0:08:50And so I've been coming in and looking at my bookcase.
0:08:53It's a bookcase, as you can see, full of books, which don't really exist anymore.
0:08:58They're these things that have like covers and lots of pages inside.
0:09:02And there are some old ones there, such as the Macintosh Bible, multiple editions of, and et cetera, et cetera.
0:09:10So it's been really reminding me, oh, my goodness, like there's Michael Frazee's Guide to the Macintosh Underground.
0:09:16Yeah.
0:09:17You know, these wonderful, wonderful books from 20, 30 years ago.
0:09:23So that's when I think, wow, I've been doing this for a while.
0:09:26And for the people who've been listening to and reading us for a while, surely one of the books on their shelves is your Internet Starter Kit, which was a big deal for quite a few years in the mid to late 90s.
0:09:43I have a stack of those.
0:09:45Every edition, every version, so much fun.
0:09:48Back when the Internet was a fun place, a nice place.
0:09:52It really was.
0:09:54It was just so fun because it's like all of a sudden, all of this fun we were having on our Macintoshes, we were connected to each other.
0:10:00And Tidbits, obviously, at almost 36 years, 35 and counting, got off the ground as I know we covered this five years ago.
0:10:10But as HyperCardStack and then originally, and I think it was for a long run, and then sort of slowly but surely turned into an email newsletter.
0:10:22Yeah, two years at the HyperCardStack and then my sister, bless her heart, actually converted all the text to structure enhanced text, which was something I believe you looked at when you were building Markdown.
0:10:33Absolutely.
0:10:34Huge influence on Markdown.
0:10:35Yeah.
0:10:36Structure enhanced text was the full name.
0:10:39C-text, yeah.
0:10:40But C-text is one of...
0:10:41And we still have no idea what happened to Ian Feldman, the guy who actually came up with it, you know, with me way back when.
0:10:48He was a very opinionated Swedish guy, and he disappeared completely.
0:10:55Which sounds like a new Netflix series.
0:10:58Yes.
0:10:58Well, there's actually another great character there, someone who did not disappear.
0:11:04The guy who wrote the first C-text reader was a Turkish guy named Akif Eiler.
0:11:10And Akif, he's still around, I actually hear from him every couple of years.
0:11:15He's retired now, but he was a professor, maybe Ankara University, I forget, a computer science professor.
0:11:22But yeah, he wrote this little browser, you could basically open C-text files, which, you know, and then, you know, they pulled the headings on one side and, you know, show the text in another pane and things like that.
0:11:32And yeah, again, definitely.
0:11:35I do like the idea, though, of the Netflix series, the limited series, with brooding music as the darkness of the Swedish winter.
0:11:42Yes.
0:11:43Well, I seem to remember that app.
0:11:46I don't...
0:11:49Easy text.
0:11:49Easy text.
0:11:50That's it.
0:11:50Easy text.
0:11:51I do remember easy text.
0:11:52Now that you mentioned the name, I guess I did use it, but I often really just read it.
0:11:58My earliest memory is mostly of tidbits, and I remember the hypercard stacks, and I remember downloading them, and I remember thinking how clever it was.
0:12:06And I remember, though, that just the easiest way to get it was to get it in email and just space read, right?
0:12:15And command-click on any interesting links, and that part of it, more than any specific use of asterisks or brackets or whatever punctuation marks to mark things, was sort of the biggest influence on Markdown, was, hey, I just remember it was just plain text, and it was marked up in a sort of structured way that you could tell what was meant.
0:12:40And you couldn't get real italics, but you could tell when something was emphasized.
0:12:45Yeah.
0:12:45Right.
0:12:46That was the trick.
0:12:46That was the trick.
0:12:47Human readable.
0:12:47So Markdown, ctext was fussier officially.
0:12:51It wouldn't fit the need.
0:12:53You know, and I remember, I was so lazy, and there's so much stuff, and we can't get sidetracked on this, and I guess I should do an episode of the show about it.
0:13:01And people keep writing to me about it, about the way that Markdown is having, like, another, without ever having declined from its original purpose of something that humans can use to write text to turn into HTML for the web, is without question the lingua franca of LLMs.
0:13:19That use of it is just growing so explosively.
0:13:24There's all these new features and a lot of these coding agents where it's like, you kind of, a lot of them, I mean, long story short, it's like, it's turned into a programming language.
0:13:34Because you describe the app you want to make in a Markdown file, throw it at the LLM.
0:13:41Yeah, because the LLM actually sort of prefers it in some ways if it's a human readable prompt as opposed to a JSON file or something.
0:13:51We sort of moved all the way into all these XML-y things, and pulling back from that, because the LLMs are like, yeah, just give me text.
0:13:59It's really a very happy accident from the human legibility of Markdown that I intended from the start, that because the LLMs were designed to parse human input, a format with a little bit of extra structure that was meant to be human readable.
0:14:16They didn't have to be, like, instructed specifically how to read Markdown.
0:14:20They just sort of picked it up because what is readable to humans, you know, the idea is you could give a normal person who's never even heard the word Markdown.
0:14:29used outside the context of a sale at a retail store.
0:14:33You could give them a Markdown formatted document in a monospace font, and they could read it and totally understand the stuff like, oh, I get it.
0:14:42That's a link.
0:14:42I see the URL and parentheses.
0:14:44They may not know the rules of which parentheses you use, but they can pick it up.
0:14:48And that the asterisks or underscores around a word are, like, effectively italicizing it.
0:14:54They could pick up the section headers.
0:14:56A normal human being would be able to pick up the gist of it.
0:14:59Or you could travel back in time with it and make it look like a typewriter written manuscript and hand it to somebody in 1955, and they would totally get it.
0:15:08Yeah, right.
0:15:09And that makes it suitable for LLMs to parse.
0:15:12But it's kind of mind-blowing to me that it's, like, the input to the coding agents.
0:15:16But anyway, that's the difference.
0:15:18The difference between Markdown and Ctext, I think, basically, is that Ctext is so much – it is actually nicer to look at or was when people were using it.
0:15:26But it would be way fussier to actually write.
0:15:29Yeah.
0:15:30For instance, one of the things that Ctext did, if I'm remembering correctly, was instead of headings being, you know, hash marks in front of them, you underlined them.
0:15:40Yeah, and that Markdown supports that.
0:15:42Or a single underline.
0:15:44Right.
0:15:44And that was – yeah, and that was, like, all Ctext did.
0:15:46And it made – it looked great, but it turned out it was actually relatively hard to do and, you know, fussy to make and everything.
0:15:53So Markdown was much more about, like, you know, providing that bridge between different systems, whereas Ctext was mostly about displaying to the reader while providing some structure for an app like EasyText to read.
0:16:07What did you use to produce the Ctext?
0:16:10What was the –
0:16:11Yeah, so you guys wrote in Nisys and then had, like, scripts or in Nisys' lingo –
0:16:17Macros.
0:16:18Macros.
0:16:18Macros to emit Ctext.
0:16:21And I know that when the original run of the Macintosh Daily Journal was a thing, which was distributed in Ctext, Matt Detheridge, I know he used Microsoft Word and had scripts that output to – I think he used Word.
0:16:36I forget.
0:16:37But I know it was a real gooey, WYSIWYG word processor that output Ctext.
0:16:43So that's the difference, was that Ctext was so fussy that you wouldn't want to actually write in it, whereas Markdown is, like, both a writing and reading format, and that's the big difference.
0:16:53But huge influence, and it was that reading experience that really informed it more than any specific nature.
0:16:59But anyway.
0:17:00Yeah.
0:17:01All right, let me take a break here and thank our first sponsor of the episode, our good friends at Factor.
0:17:07Hey, cold days.
0:17:09We got big snow time here, I'll tell you.
0:17:11Cold days, big goals, no time to cook.
0:17:14Factor makes healthy eating easy with fully prepared meals designed by dieticians and crafted by chefs.
0:17:22So eat well without the planning or cooking.
0:17:25These are pre-made meals.
0:17:27Easy.
0:17:28You just reheat them.
0:17:29This isn't like an ingredient kit for a whole meal.
0:17:31It's just a pre-packaged meal.
0:17:33Quality, functional ingredients, including lean proteins, colorful veggies, whole food ingredients, and healthy fats.
0:17:39No refined sugars, no artificial sweeteners, no refined seed oils.
0:17:44Meals that fit your goals and schedule.
0:17:46Healthier eating, calorie management, more protein.
0:17:50Variety is terrific with Factor.
0:17:52They have 100 rotating weekly meals to keep things fresh and delicious through winter.
0:17:57So there's variety of 100 meals to pick from every week, and they keep rotating them so it's not the same ones.
0:18:02And part of what makes up the 100 is they have a whole bunch of different categories, like high protein, calorie smart, Mediterranean diet, GLP-1 support, and ready-to-eat salads.
0:18:13Plus, the new Muscle Pro collection supports strength and recovery.
0:18:17Always fresh, never frozen.
0:18:20Like the meal kit type things, it comes with, like, dry ice in a package to your house, so it's fresh, refrigerated style, never frozen.
0:18:29When you're ready to eat one, it's ready in about two minutes, and no prep, no stress.
0:18:35It's just pre-packaged.
0:18:36Put it in a microwave.
0:18:37Two minutes later, you're ready to eat it.
0:18:38I love a couple of them.
0:18:40I love the steak ones.
0:18:41I love steak every time, but they always have good little steak meals, really well-portioned for lunch, so it's not like you're going to, like, a steakhouse and getting, like, something where you've got more food to come home with than you could eat in the next few days.
0:18:53It's a really good portion for lunch, and I really love Factor's breakfast options.
0:18:58I've sort of become more of a breakfast and dinner person than a lunch and dinner person, and they have so many good breakfast options.
0:19:05I really love Factor Meals myself, and if you're looking for something that I've done, check them out, see what you want, see what you like, and if you head to factormeals.com slash talkshow50off and use that code, talkshow50off, it's talkshow, then 5-0 for 50, and then off, O-F-F, talkshow50off.
0:19:29And guess what you get with that, 50% off and free breakfast for a year.
0:19:33Eat a pro this month with Factor.
0:19:35New subscribers only, varies by plan, one free breakfast item per box for one year while subscription is active.
0:19:43Go to factormeals.com slash talkshow50off.
0:19:48All right, let's get into it, the phone app.
0:19:51Do you want to, since it was you who kicked it off with the sort of in-depth analysis of this, the new difference, the new interface for the phone app,
0:19:59Describe it.
0:20:00Yeah, so with iOS 26, Apple dove into the phone app and redesigned it, and completely, utterly and completely.
0:20:17But in a move which we really haven't seen Apple do maybe ever, certainly hardly ever, they left the old interface in place as well and allows you to switch between them.
0:20:32So we now have the classic view and the unified view.
0:20:35And, you know, it was funny.
0:20:40I was on vacation visiting my son in Vancouver, and we were flying home, and I sort of decided I wanted to write this article.
0:20:46And so I'm on an airplane where, of course, I cannot get or receive phone calls.
0:20:52I'm like, the phone app is kind of dead in front of me.
0:20:55But, you know, you're cramped in an airplane, can't do much else.
0:20:57So I'm just monkeying through all this stuff.
0:21:01And I discovered that this is a, you know, I sort of went into it with the kind of get off my lawn, why did you redesign the phone app?
0:21:08You know, those of us who actually use the phone because we still know what a telephone is, and remember, in fact, dialing them with rotary phones.
0:21:17You know, we don't want our phone app messed with.
0:21:19And so I'd gone into it with that kind of attitude.
0:21:23But, you know, I was going to give Apple due credit.
0:21:26And I went through, you know, switched to unified view and switched back to classic view, and then just decided that I had to go through everything you do in the phone app and compare them.
0:21:35And when I did that, I had to rewrite my introduction.
0:21:40Normally, I just sort of write linearly, and it's all good.
0:21:45And this time I had to go like, well, actually, the 20-something engineer that came up with unified view actually did a better job than the 20-something engineer who came up with the classic interface way back when.
0:21:56Yeah.
0:21:57I'm going to disagree with you, and I think you'll just say, yeah, yeah, all right.
0:22:00I think you'll agree with me.
0:22:02I think it's sort of the fact that they offer both the classic and unified view and make it easy to switch in place right there in the main tab of the phone app.
0:22:14It's actually a return to the era of customability by the user that is actually the flip side of the coin of pointing out what's wrong with the OS26 and liquid glass designs.
0:22:29And it harks back to the heyday of both classic Mac OS and the early era of Mac OS X.
0:22:36Like, the fact that even up to today that you can customize the toolbar, AppKit, Mac apps.
0:22:44Yeah.
0:22:45And the fact that it's not as customizable as it used to be, but there are some significant view options in Apple Mail for the way that you want to fundamentally look at your messages.
0:22:59And that you can still get the old classic instead of left to right mailboxes in a column on the left, messages in a column in the middle, and message detail in a column on the right.
0:23:13You can still get the classic three-panel view where it's messages or mailboxes on the left and then an up and down view on the right, which is a list and then the message underneath.
0:23:27You can still get that if you want.
0:23:30And remind me, I don't use Mail regularly, but they don't call it a classic view, though.
0:23:35No.
0:23:36See, that's what I thought was interesting about this was like, I'm actually, to be fair, to be clear, I'm totally in favor of having this choice.
0:23:43I think this choice is great.
0:23:45And because I, you know, particularly, you know, as I've gotten older and people like my parents have gotten older and whatnot, I see the level of confusion that these, we're going to redesign the interface and it's better causes for people.
0:24:00It may even be better, but change is not always a good thing.
0:24:06Yeah, I'm looking at Mail now and on the fly as we record this, I can't even find it because I use the three column left to right view.
0:24:13I don't know, there's, for a while, though, they supported both.
0:24:16I don't know, it's use, use column layout.
0:24:19There you go.
0:24:20So in view menu, there's a view, use column layout, and then it's checked, when it's checked, right, it's so crazy.
0:24:29When you use column layout, you get the classic two panel view, and when it's unchecked, you get what I would think of.
0:24:36You get a couple more columns.
0:24:36Yeah, and I'm looking at it, my podcast machine famously is the one that I'm using Tahoe on.
0:24:43So that's how you do it.
0:24:44In Mail, go to view, use column layout.
0:24:47But I think the checkmark is backwards.
0:24:49Like, when it's unchecked, what I would call this column layout, I don't know, but that's the command to use.
0:24:58You get two entirely different views of your email.
0:25:02Yeah, and again, that was actually a really important thing to provide when they did that switch, because people get very, very accustomed.
0:25:11There's a lot of muscle memory that is built up in using these apps.
0:25:15And to change the interface, even if you have arguments for why the change is better, and even if you're right about those arguments, that doesn't mean that you're helping a person who has built up significant muscle memory.
0:25:28Yeah, and the other big factor, and I think this phone app redesign is one of the first times we're really seeing post-iPhone as a cultural institution, Apple, grapple with it.
0:25:43I guess the iOS 7 redesign was huge, right?
0:25:46Yeah, going to flat from Scumorphic.
0:25:50Right, where everything, and I would say far more, take the subjectivity of which one you liked better out of it.
0:25:56Objectively, was far more obvious than the iOS 26 update.
0:26:04And for all of the ongoing discussion that I think is all valid, iOS 26, I think there are people out there who don't really notice much new about it.
0:26:13Many people.
0:26:14Whereas with iOS 7, there was no frigging way that anybody...
0:26:19Like, where did my buttons go?
0:26:21Right.
0:26:22I mean, the look was so different, so totally different.
0:26:26I don't know that they could get away with something that significant again.
0:26:29And I think that they have sort of steered their design language toward not ever needing to again.
0:26:36But with this classic versus unified layout view, I think we're sort of seeing it.
0:26:42And it's sort of the curse of having a massive general population audience.
0:26:50And one of the things, it was in the early days or in the 90s when Apple was famously tinkering on the edge of bankruptcy and had obviously, just obviously terrible management that didn't know where, how to go forward and failed, majorly, totally failed next generation operating system efforts.
0:27:13Multiples, multiple that failed.
0:27:16BOS, let's buy BOS.
0:27:18Wait, no.
0:27:18The advantage of their small market share, at least, especially once Jobs and the next leadership team came in and kind of righted the ship.
0:27:29And so let's say more the early 2000s.
0:27:32The advantage of the relatively small audience was that they could do something like release the Aqua interface for Mac OS X, which was just as drastic a visual change going from the classic Mac OS look.
0:27:47Which, up until that point, the betas of, or developer betas, whatever they were called, of Mac OS X looked like.
0:27:55They had a sort of, they looked a lot like Mac OS 8 and 9, the platinum look.
0:28:01In fact, it was probably the best platinum look they ever had because they actually, the betas of Mac OS X had some nice improvements, like sort of darker windows for the forefront and some better window management controls.
0:28:14It was really a great look.
0:28:15And it would have been a very subtle difference if that's what they had stuck with.
0:28:19And of course, Steve Jobs didn't want to stick with the old thing.
0:28:22And, but Mac, the Mac OS X Aqua look was just as, oh my God, look at this.
0:28:27This is so, everything is different from corner to corner.
0:28:29Every pixel is different from iOS 7.
0:28:32And one of the advantages of that is that with 5% market share, and that 5% was almost entirely comprised of enthusiasts, is that you could do that.
0:28:42Whereas if you had...
0:28:44It was good, right?
0:28:46Yes.
0:28:46I mean, I remember the whole thing.
0:28:47I mean, I remember Jobs, you know, talking about how it was lickable.
0:28:52Yeah.
0:28:52But I don't remember anyone...
0:28:55And we were serious user interface aficionados and opinionators back then, too.
0:29:01But simultaneously, I don't remember people whining about Aqua.
0:29:04I mean, we used to...
0:29:05I do.
0:29:06It wouldn't go off on Microsoft if they had, like, the find, you know, the okay and the cancel buttons in the wrong order.
0:29:11Oh, yeah.
0:29:12Definitely.
0:29:12Or inconsistently on their side, right?
0:29:15Because they, their guidelines put them in the other order, and we were snobby about the fact that there's a reason that Apple's put the okay button, the default button in the lower right, and the cancel button to the left, and whatever their...
0:29:27I think that their reasoning was, well, if Apple did it this way, we'll flip them so that we have a different way.
0:29:32Whereas Apple's wasn't just an arbitrary decision, so many of us have been looking back at, like, old, late 80s and early 90s editions of the Human Interface Guidelines from Apple and citing all the ways that Mac OS 26 Tahoe literally epitomizes the don't do it this way examples in the old Hig.
0:29:52Like the putting icons next to every single menu item.
0:29:56Right.
0:29:57It was literally an example.
0:30:00It was like, don't do this.
0:30:01It looks like a cluttered mess and will confuse users and make it hard to read.
0:30:04And it's like...
0:30:05I wonder, where is Kai Krause now with Kai's power tools?
0:30:09You know, it's like, he's like, they finally saw the light.
0:30:13People complained about the fact that Aqua looked, I remember people complaining that it looked too, I don't know, childish or non-pro, right?
0:30:25That it looked like the visual, the on-screen incarnation of the iMac hardware.
0:30:32Right.
0:30:32It looked like the iMac.
0:30:33Thus, it didn't look serious and pro like, say, the next hardware did with the black magnesium that it was constructed out of.
0:30:44Or the way Apple's pro hardware has pretty much looked ever since I think the titanium PowerBook G4 kind of started the modern look.
0:30:54It was before they got to aluminum because they couldn't quite, they hadn't mastered constructing with aluminum yet.
0:31:00But that titanium G4 and everything since has been that sort of metallic aluminum, whether it's a MacBook Pro or a Mac Pro or a Mac Mini.
0:31:10Mac G4s, which had that swooshy clear plastic.
0:31:14Yeah, and they used like a, right, right, more, less colorful, a little less translucent, more of a slate color.
0:31:22It was sort of like in aqua.
0:31:23Mirror drive doors.
0:31:24Yeah.
0:31:25Yeah, yeah.
0:31:25And then there was the preference and system preferences at the time before they renamed it system settings, where you could change the red, yellow, green buttons to use graphite, they called it.
0:31:36And it changed those buttons to gray and a sort of gray with a blue tint, which is near and dear to my heart.
0:31:42And the idea was, A, some people just don't like the super colorful, friendly look.
0:31:47And B, that using neutral colors was important for people doing color work in the actual content of their work in the window.
0:31:55But, you know, those were subjective complaints.
0:31:58I don't like how colorful it looks.
0:32:00I don't like just how lickable it looks, that they really do look like candy.
0:32:05But that's truly subjective.
0:32:07From an objective computer-human interaction perspective, it was exquisitely thoughtful.
0:32:13And Jobs, as I cited this back in June, as a contrast with Alan Dye's introduction of liquid glass, and then I quoted a bunch of it, which was just word salad.
0:32:25It really was just word salad.
0:32:27But I went back and transcribed a bit of Steve Jobs' introduction of aqua.
0:32:32And yes, he said that they wanted it to be lickable.
0:32:35But he also said, pointed out things like, hey, look how clear and obvious it is, which is the active window and which windows are inactive in the background.
0:32:46And he referred to it as the key window, I believe specifically, using the parlance of human factors experts, the way that human factors people talk about it.
0:32:58And I think you pointed out that we Mac users at the time, like the audience that Apple hung on to through the lean years, whether we were actually designing interfaces as part of our work or just using it.
0:33:13We were fans of UI design in the way that people are readers of like fiction are fans of good writing and know the rules and can just talk, aren't just interested in the plot of a novel, but are actually interested in the, oh, that's such a beautiful paragraph or what a sentence that is.
0:33:36You actually can see the artisanal aspect to it.
0:33:40And with UI, some of that artisanal aspect is also mechanical in that it has to be functional, it has to be consistent, it has to be clear.
0:33:53But that's what we're doing, right?
0:33:56That's really what we're trying to create with an interface is something that you can use.
0:34:05And that was what Apple under jobs really got and what the Alan Dye era seems to have entirely lost track of.
0:34:13Yeah, I think purposefully, right?
0:34:16I think that they really thought like enough with that nerd talk.
0:34:19And I had a post at some point that somebody who had worked at Apple for quite a while as a UI designer and had left within the last two years and works somewhere else now, but has been a long time.
0:34:31I'll say a friend, but a long time chirper and never like someone who told me leaked information or anything like that.
0:34:39But just a reader who I knew worked at Apple and therefore their emails I took very confidentially.
0:34:44But just when I wrote that had mentioned that in this person's interaction with Alan Dye and their team, like what struck this person about the jobs introduction and they were there for that.
0:34:56I think it just being refreshed that jobs knew the lingo like key window and this person said like I learned when dealing with Alan Dye and his team that if I use words like that their eyes rolled back in their head like look at this guy talking computer nerd stuff.
0:35:10It's not that they didn't know they weren't stupid per se, but that they really had lost the idea of human factors design as a science and it really just went totally to just art of how it looks.
0:35:26And that's what made it so galling so totally galling when Dye announced that he was leaving Apple from meta and then the next day post my work here is done and posted the jobs quote of the famous jobs quote about people have this idea that design is how it looks.
0:35:43It's not it's design is how it works of all people to post that Alan Dye who really it sounds good and they might have thought that's what they were doing, but everything about the work that they did and everything, especially about Matt goes 26 Tahoes to me proves that they totally didn't get it and that it is a science and that you need some in the way that you need.
0:36:06If you're really going to talk about grammar, you need obscure inside lingo words like gerund, you don't need to know it to be a writer, but if you really want to analyze it, you need words like that.
0:36:18You need to know what a preposition is you need to know like the usability testing.
0:36:24I mean, maybe you hear more than I do, but Apple used to have usability testing that you heard about like it bubbled up.
0:36:32There were kitchens there were people got called in there were universities that that, you know, someone would be organizing something at a university that never ever pops up in my feeds anymore or just my awareness.
0:36:47I think and I can't prove it I could be wrong, but what I've heard and it's mostly from people who've left over the last especially the last five years and therefore have gotten freer to share their experience inside Apple over the last 10 to 15 years, but most of which I still treat confidentially because and they don't even have to say it.
0:37:08But it's like people leave Apple for a while and then they often come back like the Jason sells six colors name is such a good name for an Apple site because there are so many people who truly bleed six colors.
0:37:20And so blabbing about their experience would cut that off or would at least make it more difficult in the future.
0:37:28But I think to make a very long complicated story short, I think that while Steve Jobs knew that lingo and knew it and clearly could get enthralled in discussions about details like that.
0:37:43Like if there's a window in the background, which controls should be active right away before you click to activate the window and talking about it with actual human factors people using the lingo in the same way that I think for everything he cared about.
0:38:00He was a what's the other word for a renaissance man, somebody who, you know, like a jack of all trades.
0:38:05Yeah, but generalist.
0:38:07But he could really he could speak that lingo, but I think ultimately trusted his gut so much knowing that his gut was so informed by all of that human factors design that started at Xerox Park with the early GUIs and that so enthralled Apple's team that came and toured and was allowed to use the ideas.
0:38:30Right.
0:38:30They didn't steal anything.
0:38:31It was sort of like, yeah, come on in and learn.
0:38:34We'll tell you everything we know.
0:38:35And that gets back to the whole thing with Jobs having taste.
0:38:38And remember when he was dismissing Microsoft as just having taste and that was in UI and that was important, you know, that you can't do.
0:38:48Yeah, I think that under Steve Jobs, he trusted himself so much that a sort of, hey, we really ought to stick to these written rules sort of went by the wayside.
0:38:59And it was sort of if it passes Steve's muster, then it's good.
0:39:02And it was for the most part.
0:39:04The problem is then it's allowed them to work faster.
0:39:08And I'll make the analogy to grammar again.
0:39:11It's by knowing the rules of grammar that allows a more talented writer to break the rules of grammar in a way that if you handed it in to a sixth grade English teacher would technically require the teacher to put red marks like, hey, that's a no-no right there.
0:39:29But that if you know the rules, you can do this for effect.
0:39:34And it both works and it is effective for communicating to the reader to break the rules.
0:39:39And that's true for the human interface guidelines, too.
0:39:42I mean, we used to complain when Apple mostly stuck to the written HIG.
0:39:46We used to complain about sometimes when they didn't and there didn't seem to be a good reason.
0:39:53But a lot of times they would create innovative new interfaces and, yes, technically, it would violate the written guidelines of the HIG.
0:40:01But you could see why they were doing it.
0:40:03It was because they were so into it.
0:40:05But I think that once Jobs was gone, it left an Apple that was less, hey, by default, we should stick to the written human interface guidelines and only break them for reasons that we can explain.
0:40:19And it left more of a, hey, you can shoot from the hip.
0:40:23That was Steve's way.
0:40:24And he wasn't there anymore.
0:40:26And that's why it was such a long, slow decline.
0:40:30And I wonder to what extent there was also, you know, during that, during those later years of Jobs' tenure, he had Johnny Ive as a balance.
0:40:41You know, he and Johnny Ive balanced each other usefully.
0:40:45Whereas once we lost the Jobs' side of that balance, things got out of whack.
0:40:51Yeah, I think so.
0:40:53All right.
0:40:53Back to the phone app.
0:40:56Back to the phone app and Unified versus Classic.
0:40:59But I think it was a very useful digression.
0:41:01And I do think it's a return to form here to offer both.
0:41:04And I remember exactly where I want to hand this back to you.
0:41:07It's the fact that the switch between Classic and Unified is right there in the app.
0:41:13It is visually illustrated in the, what do you call that menu?
0:41:17The little three-line menu.
0:41:20Sort of hamburger.
0:41:21I mean, not really hamburger.
0:41:23But yeah.
0:41:23But they're against hamburgers.
0:41:24Yeah.
0:41:25It kind of looks like a filtering menu.
0:41:27But it just means menu.
0:41:28And you open it up.
0:41:29And it's illustrated with a large icon representation of an iPhone showing you in icon view the difference between Classic and Unified.
0:41:39So that you can kind of know.
0:41:40It's not just you don't have to guess what the words mean.
0:41:42You kind of get a visual hint what the difference is.
0:41:45And you can switch right there rather than doing what Apple does with almost everything else in iOS.
0:41:50Where if it is an option, you have to go to the Settings app and then go down to Apps and then go into the Apps and then scroll to the app, even if it's one of Apple's apps.
0:41:59And go there and then go into that app and then somehow figure out how to do it, right?
0:42:05Which no one's going to do.
0:42:06This setting is right there.
0:42:08Just like in Mail that you can go up to the menu bar and go to View, Use Column Layout.
0:42:13And interestingly, even though there are plenty of settings that are still buried the heck away in Settings, Apps, Phone, Apple at the bottom of this little menu where you switch between Classic and Unified, there's a Manage Filtering option, which takes you straight there.
0:42:30That's actually, I mean, like it takes you to the kind of down into the filtering sections, but it takes you to that, you know, Settings, Apps, Phone screen, which is really kind of helpful.
0:42:41I'm actually quite happy about that.
0:42:43But yeah, this is good.
0:42:45I mean, there we go.
0:42:45And they put it right up front.
0:42:47There are a couple of little oddities here so that, for instance, this menu only appears in the Classic view, which is the default, when you're in the Recents screen.
0:42:59So, you know, so if you're in Favorites or Contacts or Keypad or Voicemail, it's not there, which is a little weird.
0:43:05But again, they're saying, hey, you're the classic phone user.
0:43:09You don't want things changing too much.
0:43:11We're only going to change it in this one place.
0:43:12Yeah.
0:43:14I think part of the problem with that, too, is that it's only in Recents.
0:43:17But the big thing that Unified does, what does Unified unify?
0:43:21It unifies your Recents with your voicemail.
0:43:23And the fact that it's not in a voicemail tab either is to me a little.
0:43:28Yeah.
0:43:28Yeah.
0:43:29Yeah.
0:43:29Because those buttons at the bottom, I mean, that's the thing that the two big changes are you get those Favorites built into the Unified screen, and then there's fewer buttons at the bottom.
0:43:39Yeah.
0:43:40And this is, again, we could get, I could get sidetracked for a whole hour on it.
0:43:45But this is where the lack of something that is the equivalent of the Mac menu bar in iOS.
0:43:54And now we are approaching almost 20 years of iOS, and it still doesn't have anything like the Mac menu bar.
0:44:01And I'm not saying it has to be a menu bar, but the menu bar on the Mac is there in every app, and it's the place you go.
0:44:08So if there is a view option, you would have a view menu, and no matter what you change from or to, if you want to change back, the view change doesn't remove the thing that you used to switch the view.
0:44:24It's up there in the menu bar, which never goes away.
0:44:26And so you've got this thing that is a menu, right?
0:44:30I think everybody would agree that this hamburger menu, filtering menu, whatever it's called officially in Apple's parlance, but it has no name, no label.
0:44:39It is a menu, but because there's no menu bar in iOS, it goes away unless you're in the Recents tab, one out of the five tabs.
0:44:49Yeah.
0:44:50Yeah.
0:44:50Which is kind of maddening.
0:44:53The only thing I will say is that probably you're going to choose Classic or Unified and stay there, that probably you are not going to.
0:45:04So in some ways, you don't want this to be too visible or too in your face because it'll just get in the way every time you do go to want to filter something, which is the actual utility of that menu is filtering.
0:45:15So one of the things I found that fascinating while I was exploring all this stuff was I could actually hear the discussions.
0:45:23Yes.
0:45:24They were like, well, we could do this, but then this.
0:45:28And you could see there aren't really right and wrong answers to any of these.
0:45:33They're just whose opinion mattered the most in the end because they had a better argument.
0:45:40And the two big ones are why did the phone app need a new layout, a new view option anyway?
0:45:47And I think there's good reasons.
0:45:49And you really put your finger on it, which I mean that both literally and figuratively.
0:45:54Quite literally.
0:45:56Right.
0:45:57Stop calling.
0:45:58Stop calling.
0:45:59We can get into that in a second.
0:46:00And that there were ideas from 2007 about the importance of a phone and people's habits with their old phone, whether it was a smartphone or for most people, including me, I just had like a $20 Nokia candy bar phone.
0:46:16But the main point was using a phone.
0:46:18I remember once you programmed like on my Nokia, I guess I went through a couple of them in the cell phone era before the iPhone, but just no folding, no flipping, just a Nokia candy bar.
0:46:29But then you'd program in your favorites and you could just long press.
0:46:33So like my wife was number one.
0:46:35And if I just long pressed one on the key on the keypad, it would call her.
0:46:41And if one of my friends was number two, you just long press two.
0:46:45It was it.
0:46:46The whole point was, how do you make a phone call to your favorite people very quickly?
0:46:49Yeah.
0:46:50And so it kind of makes sense why the list of recent calls, if you just tapped on any of them in most of the row.
0:46:59It would just call that person.
0:47:00So if Adam Angst had called me today and I had missed the call or I had taken the call and still was there in the recents list, I'd go to recents and anywhere in the row I could tap and it would one tap.
0:47:12It would call you back.
0:47:14And it totally makes sense from the context of what people were familiar with the purpose of a cell phone was in 2007.
0:47:21That's the way it worked.
0:47:22And then there was a little I button on the right side that was the touch target for getting info about Adam.
0:47:29What if I just want to send Adam an iMessage or a text message or send him an email?
0:47:35Just look at his whole contact card and maybe do something else.
0:47:38Just see some details about Adam.
0:47:40There's an I button on the side.
0:47:41And in the new unified one, that's flipped.
0:47:44Most of the row you tap and it just opens a detailed view of that contact.
0:47:49And there is an equivalently small phone icon on the right side, which is a specific touch target for call this person right now.
0:47:58It's like inverted.
0:47:59Yeah.
0:48:00And that was – honestly, I'm writing this article.
0:48:04It took me a while to figure this out.
0:48:07Yeah.
0:48:08Like we are so, so used to that huge touch target for calling back.
0:48:14And I hate it.
0:48:16I cannot tell you the burning passion with which I hate this interface because I don't –
0:48:21The old one, you mean.
0:48:22The old one.
0:48:23The old one.
0:48:23Right.
0:48:24The old one.
0:48:24The classic.
0:48:24Because I was constantly accidentally calling people back when I didn't mean to.
0:48:30It was just – it wasn't even necessarily I wanted to get information on them.
0:48:35I was just in the phone app and my finger touched down.
0:48:38And then you're immediately doing that, you know, cancel, cancel, cancel, cancel as quickly as you can.
0:48:43And it's never fast enough, right?
0:48:45Never.
0:48:45You cannot do it.
0:48:46You cannot get that thing to stop.
0:48:48You think you catch it right away.
0:48:50You canceled the call right away.
0:48:51And you're like, I think I got that before the phone went through.
0:48:54And guess who calls you 15 seconds later?
0:48:56The person you just – it's not a butt dial.
0:49:00I don't know what to call it.
0:49:01There should be a word, a clever word like a butt dial.
0:49:04It's like a –
0:49:05And I think it included butt dial.
0:49:07It helped with butt dialing too.
0:49:08Yeah.
0:49:08I mean, you know, basically someone would finish a call.
0:49:11They'd put their phone in their pocket without locking the screen.
0:49:14Yeah.
0:49:14And it would just get something.
0:49:17And it's really when I first read your article that it really occurred to me just how often that happens to me.
0:49:23It's something I had just sort of gotten used to.
0:49:26And I think one of the reasons it happened – it still kept happening, like I said, 18, 17, 18 years into me owning an iPhone and using it every day was that nothing else in iOS works that way.
0:49:41It's like when you're in the mail app, whatever your mail app is on your iPhone, when you're looking at messages and you tap a message, it doesn't immediately open a reply to that person.
0:49:52It opens the message.
0:49:54Right?
0:49:56Or worse, open a TCPI connection to their machine, you know.
0:49:59I mean, like this is a destructive action in some ways, right?
0:50:04Right.
0:50:04It is certainly destructive to your pride.
0:50:07That's right.
0:50:08Sorry, I didn't mean to call you.
0:50:10It's destructive to your time, and it's destructive to the other person's time and attention.
0:50:15Yeah.
0:50:16You have interrupted someone for no reason when you didn't mean to do it in any way, shape, or form.
0:50:22Right.
0:50:22But no other list of messages works that way.
0:50:27And that's the problem.
0:50:28That's what was making it worse and worse.
0:50:30And that's where that famous word, consistency, comes in.
0:50:34It's not about dogmatic consistency.
0:50:37It is about the way that if things that could be consistent, if they are consistent, then the user can stop thinking about them.
0:50:45And the recent list in the classic mail was a thing you had to think about.
0:50:51But the more I used my iPhone over 15, 16, 17 years, the less likely I was to think about it and just tap on it.
0:50:59And boom, there's the call starting.
0:51:00Yeah.
0:51:01And what is interesting is that phone button was sort of a completely new concept, you know, in the phone app, you know, where each call had its own little button.
0:51:10And you're like, now I know what it does.
0:51:13Like, I literally had to tap those buttons a couple of times.
0:51:16Remember, I was on a plane in airplane mode.
0:51:19So I could do this with impunity.
0:51:20It was great.
0:51:24So I was like, oh, now I understand it.
0:51:27They're actually allowing me to return a call very easily.
0:51:31But you can now work with the call as an object in a list in multiple ways.
0:51:37And there's actually some cool ways you can do that, too.
0:51:40Yeah.
0:51:41In terms of sliding to the left to make a reminder or pressing and holding to get, you know, more information to be able to message the person or mail them directly from that contact.
0:51:52I mean, so they actually made it really kind of useful.
0:51:55Yes, very much so.
0:51:57And I kind of feel to go back, I feel like they had painted them.
0:52:01So it makes total sense why this was the interface for the iPhone call app, the phone app in 2007.
0:52:07I really do see how they were thinking.
0:52:10And they were just sort of forging ahead very quickly to ship this thing at a rapid pace and using good principles.
0:52:18But it's like people expect to make calls quickly on a phone.
0:52:21OK, tap anywhere on a recent call and you call the person made total sense.
0:52:25I don't remember anybody complaining about this.
0:52:27I don't know.
0:52:27I certainly didn't.
0:52:28It never occurred to me to complain about the fact that nothing else worked this way in 2007 because the whole thing seemed so novel.
0:52:36And I was coming from another phone.
0:52:38But the longer they went, the more it stood out as this exception that works in a way that made sense in 2007 and really doesn't seem to make any sense in 2025.
0:52:48Yeah.
0:52:49Yeah.
0:52:50Very much so.
0:52:51And the other aspect of it is that in 2025, and frankly, probably for a fair amount of these past years, is that a lot of people don't make calls ever.
0:53:05Right?
0:53:06Right.
0:53:07We're dating ourselves pretty heavily here.
0:53:10A little.
0:53:10But, you know, people who are five, ten years into their iPhones, you know, now, they probably, you know, make calls purely under duress.
0:53:20It depends, I guess.
0:53:22I'd love to hear and see somebody do a study on how many phone calls per day people get and then correlate it by their age.
0:53:29And surely there's a pretty strong correlation.
0:53:32I don't know if they never make phone calls.
0:53:33But they have to occasionally.
0:53:36But my son is 27.
0:53:38And only really in the last three or four years have we been able to stop saying, you could call them.
0:53:48Like, he'd be complaining about something.
0:53:50I was like, just call them and you'll be able to solve your problem.
0:53:53Doctor's appointments, you know, landlords, whatever.
0:53:56Right.
0:53:58Why don't they do texting?
0:53:59Like, I don't know.
0:54:02But it was.
0:54:04I don't know.
0:54:05I think they've come up with an overall very good solution.
0:54:07I will say this, too.
0:54:09And I think you and I, when I linked to your piece, we had a bit of an email chain going about it.
0:54:14In the summer, when I first put iOS 26 on like a year-old iPhone, and that's what I often, that's my typical pattern,
0:54:24is I don't put the summer betas on my, and I do buy, I get a new iPhone every year.
0:54:30And I put the beta on my year-old phone, and then I just use the eSIM switching in settings, which is really nice,
0:54:38especially for switching between two phones.
0:54:40Like, the disadvantage versus the old-fashioned SIM cards and sticking a paperclip in there to pop it out
0:54:47and having this little tiny thing the size of your pinky finger fingernail to not lose is it was harder to, like, test an Android phone using your real phone number.
0:54:59But now even Android, the whole world is kind of getting on board with eSIMs, and it's really nice.
0:55:04But in the summer, when I first tried Unified, it didn't click for me right away because I only thought of it as a layout change.
0:55:13And I was like, ah, I don't like all my favorites on the top as these big thumbnails.
0:55:17So, nah, I'll go back to the classic.
0:55:19And I went back to classic and then didn't think about it again for a few months.
0:55:23The functional difference of the whole rose tapability and what happens when you tap,
0:55:29I just completely missed it when I looked at it over the summer.
0:55:33Yeah, it was very hidden.
0:55:35And actually, speaking of hidden, we do need to point out that Apple has done something truly strange with phone apps settings
0:55:47with this tap to call, tap recents to call option, which we are praising as for being able to reduce inadvertent calls.
0:55:57If you really like making inadvertent calls, this is...
0:56:02Or if you're really in a hurry to call people back.
0:56:05If you're really in a hurry, you can't tap that little button, that little phone button.
0:56:10They put in a hidden setting that only appears in the settings app when you're in Unified View in the phone app.
0:56:20So, you wrote about that.
0:56:22That's your follow-up from December.
0:56:23I still haven't linked to it, and I showed you a draft.
0:56:26The clock is ticking when we stop recording this show for me to finish that before this show gets published, hopefully tomorrow.
0:56:34And props to Paul Kofasas of Rogaviba, who actually found this and told me about it.
0:56:38Our internet friend and somewhat frequent guest on the show who discovered this.
0:56:43So, it is...
0:56:45And this is another one of those things.
0:56:47I'm with you and Paul.
0:56:48We're all on team.
0:56:50Hey, this is a bad idea for a setting to have it appear and disappear based on something else that is not right there.
0:56:58This is fundamentally a bad idea.
0:57:00But I can totally hear the conversation that led to it.
0:57:03Yes, yes.
0:57:04Can't you, though?
0:57:05I mean, just like these two product managers going at it.
0:57:08So, if you're in the phone app, if you switch to the new one, Unified, and then you go to Settings, Apps, Phone, then there is a preference.
0:57:21Let's see what it's called.
0:57:22Tap Recents to Call.
0:57:25Tap Recents to Call.
0:57:27There we go.
0:57:28And it shows up between haptics and hold assist detection.
0:57:33But if you go back to the phone app, which is where you need to go back to toggle and switch from Unified to Classic, that whole checkbox, I'll call it a checkbox, whatever we call these switches in the toggles in iOS, it just disappears.
0:57:50So, I think it should say in the small text underneath that this option is only available in the Unified when you're using the Unified View.
0:58:07Because I think inside Apple, they're like, the whole point of Classic is that no matter what else you do, it continues working the way the iPhone had from iOS 1 through iOS 18.
0:58:21And Classic is Classic is classic, and that's it.
0:58:24The whole tap anywhere in a row except that I button, and you make a call.
0:58:27That's it.
0:58:28I think that switch, though, should still hold its place.
0:58:32It should just be grayed out with descriptive text underneath explaining why it is grayed out.
0:58:40It's grayed out because it's only available when you're using Unified View in the phone app.
0:58:46And then I think that solves the problem.
0:58:47And that whoever it is at Apple, I actually think, now, if I had my druthers, this option would be available for users in both Classic and Unified Views.
0:58:57And I was going to just say that Classic View is not perfectly like Classic View, right?
0:59:04Because you have these new filtering options where you can hide unknown senders and spam calls.
0:59:09Right.
0:59:10And so I would argue that, okay, if you're going to add these unknown callers and spam things to the Classic Views interface, then allow people to toggle this tap recents to call option as well.
0:59:26And then you don't have to do this super weird thing where it disappears.
0:59:29And when I wrote about this, I commented.
0:59:33I literally just reproduced it here.
0:59:35If you start going back and forth trying to see how this works, you will crash the settings app.
0:59:41Yes.
0:59:41I don't know if that's still true in iOS 24.
0:59:4826.3 it is.
0:59:51I just did it.
0:59:52Right.
0:59:5226.4 beta 1 is out.
0:59:55Beta 1.
0:59:56I don't know.
0:59:58But yes, if you keep playing around with this, it definitely crashes.
1:00:01Wait, does it crash the phone app or it crashes the settings app?
1:00:04Settings app.
1:00:05Yeah.
1:00:05And so it's right.
1:00:08So like here, you've got a big win here, Apple.
1:00:10Make the Classic View more functional.
1:00:13Make the settings app more consistent and have it all stop crashing.
1:00:18Like this is an easy choice.
1:00:21I do think that it should be available in both.
1:00:23And obviously, I guess I'm thinking, again, imagining the conversations is, I think it has something to do with the fact that when you, okay, you're most iPhone users, but overwhelming majority who are now using iOS 26 had been using the iPhone for some number of years before.
1:00:46The number of users whose first iPhone is running iOS 26 is probably vanishingly small.
1:00:55And so everybody's experience with the phone app is coming from the classic behavior.
1:01:00But what they want id is when you switch to unified for the first time to get this new behavior.
1:01:09And so that setting tap reasons to call needs to be on.
1:01:14But if the setting is on, I guess the other solution to this would be separate settings in that list for tap reasons to call a separate setting underneath.
1:01:24I mean, it's a long list and it's kind of buried in settings, but a separate setting for the unified view and for the classic view.
1:01:33That might actually, as I'm talking through this, might be the answer that we're reaching, where what Apple wanted was when you're in classic, you get the old behavior where you tap reasons to call and you're in unified, you don't tap reasons to call.
1:01:47I guess what they need is two settings there, right?
1:01:51That would be another way to do it.
1:01:53There are solutions to this.
1:01:54And this is why user interface design is such an interesting field, right?
1:01:59I think just making it go away and vanish like it's not there is it is a solution.
1:02:06I think it was it was the wrong solution.
1:02:10But yes, or what they mean is tap recents to call in unified view.
1:02:16There are so many ways to describe what they're trying to achieve.
1:02:19And it's so maddening.
1:02:22Like you said, it's actually even described wrong because it says start the call as soon as you tap a name or number in the recents list.
1:02:34But in unified view, that's the calls.
1:02:37I guess it's still the recents list of the calls view.
1:02:41Okay.
1:02:42So maybe not quite.
1:02:43But still, in classic view, that is literally the screen is recents.
1:02:47Right.
1:02:48But in unified, it's the calls screen.
1:02:50But you're down below the favorites.
1:02:52So it's still the recents list, I guess.
1:02:54Okay.
1:02:55It's not as big a mistake as I thought.
1:02:56But yes, they could have said in the unified views recents list and it would have solved the problem.
1:03:00And as we're talking about this, I'm sitting here looking at you as we record the show, talking about this in as explicit detail as we can muster in an audio podcast.
1:03:11I just confused the hell out of myself because I had left the phone.
1:03:14I'm toggling both things and I just left the phone app in classic view and I went back and I'm like, God damn it, Adam just told me it was, where the hell is it?
1:03:24And I was like, what did Adam say?
1:03:26Oh, underneath haptics.
1:03:27Oh, it's not even there.
1:03:28Oh, I just did it to myself.
1:03:29It's gone.
1:03:30As we're talking about it because I had forgotten that I had gone back to classic to look at the filtered list of like unknown and spam callers.
1:03:39It was very much when I was writing, I had the same thing, you know, when I was writing it up, I was like, okay, where did it go?
1:03:44Why did it happen?
1:03:45And then, of course, the fact that the settings app was crashing, you know, every third or fourth time I went in there, it wasn't helping because then I'd get confused about where I was.
1:03:52But one of the things that makes this such an interesting thing to talk about is that overall, this is one of the best things about iOS 26 is user interface changes.
1:04:02Then you unified list overall and you in detail, you're the man who's written the most about it and put your finger on what is good about making this list consistent with the way list views work in all of your other messaging apps and why it's useful and why this is a law.
1:04:19I would say at this point, overdue modernization of the recent call list.
1:04:24But even with this thing that we're praising overall, the way that they dealt with the edge cases is so frustrating and it just sort of shows it's not just that we disagree with it.
1:04:35It's just wrong.
1:04:36It's fundamentally wrong to make the setting just disappear like it wasn't there.
1:04:40Well, it's actually even slightly worse than that because if you use the swipe back and forth on the bottom of the screen to move quickly between settings and phone, you can literally see it go away.
1:04:53Like it animates going away.
1:04:56Right.
1:04:56Which is actually.
1:04:58Put that back.
1:04:58Put that back.
1:04:59Where did it go?
1:05:00Right.
1:05:00Which is actually pretty clever that it's programmed that way and that even in an operating system where you don't think of the apps as having windows, they effectively are windows.
1:05:13And that's when in the switcher view, effectively you see each app as a window that the window is updating as you're switching.
1:05:21And it animates rather than just flashes from one, you know, from one frame to the next.
1:05:28It goes away.
1:05:29It comes back.
1:05:30It animates in and out, which is really nice and clever.
1:05:35It's just sort of rubbing our noses in it.
1:05:37The few of us who notice, but it's just a sign of even when Apple does something right, that they've lost a certain old Apple would not have done this.
1:05:46That at some point, this argument rather than just say, ah, let's end the R.
1:05:49Because that's the other thing.
1:05:50You imagine a conversation and it's like they were just like, ah, all right, fine.
1:05:55We'll just make it go away.
1:05:56We'll only have the option visible when you're in unified view.
1:05:59And then unified view, you can have it both ways.
1:06:02And if you ever switch back to classic view because you're like, I don't know what happened, but I want my phone to work the way it used to.
1:06:09And as soon as you switch to classic, then you get all of the classic behavior, including tap reasons to call.
1:06:16Yeah.
1:06:17Fine.
1:06:18But I don't know.
1:06:19I think with all those settings, I'm just scrolling that list.
1:06:22I was scrolling it again while looking for it when I lost it.
1:06:25With all these settings, they could have had two under tap reasons to call.
1:06:29Unified view where it's off by default and classic view where it would be on by default.
1:06:36And then you could set either one the way you want.
1:06:39And when you switch between the two views, get exactly the behavior you want.
1:06:42Because I really do think you made the case that there is a case to be made for preferring the classic view for layout, but wanting the don't accidentally call people once a week behavior.
1:06:55So the question is, is do we think this classic unified split is going to stick around past, say, iOS 27?
1:07:05I mean, next year, I'm pretty certain it will.
1:07:07But 28?
1:07:08Right.
1:07:09Right.
1:07:10I mean, at some point.
1:07:11The name classic sort of feels like it has an implicit sell-by date on it.
1:07:17Right.
1:07:18You know, as opposed to, again, to go back to mail on the Mac, it's not view, use column layout, or use classic view.
1:07:26Right.
1:07:27It's just a binary toggle.
1:07:28It's just a binary toggle.
1:07:28Because I think that for some people, that old school list of messages in a row, a top, a message view underneath is so ingrained in their mail habits that there's no way they could ever really take it away.
1:07:43I don't know.
1:07:44I don't know.
1:07:44I don't know.
1:07:46I kind of feel like maybe it's here to stay.
1:07:49My bet is it's here to stay and won't go away in the next five years.
1:07:54I think.
1:07:55I mean, it's going to be a hard one to pull because, again, the people who are going to use it, and Apple will have telemetry on this.
1:08:04So they will know how heavily people have switched between classic and unified.
1:08:08They will never tell us, but they will know that.
1:08:10And I forget exactly what happens when you first upgrade to iOS 26, but I'm pretty sure this is a case where what they do is use the new tip kit, which is a very useful new framework across their operating systems, where developers can put a user, you know, like to date us severely.
1:08:32Oh, Christ, the balloon help from system seven.
1:08:35Yeah.
1:08:36Right.
1:08:37Yeah.
1:08:37Google it, kids.
1:08:39Right.
1:08:40Lovely concept.
1:08:41Really.
1:08:42Right.
1:08:42But balloon help was a system wide setting that you could toggle on system wide.
1:08:46And then when balloon help was on, you could hover your mouse over any element and any element that the developer had added a balloon help for.
1:08:54You'd get a hover over balloon with a tool tip describing what the button or icon did.
1:09:03And they called it balloon help because they looked like the balloon dialogues from a comic book or a comic strip.
1:09:10And therefore, and in a way that in a comic strip, that little pointy part of the balloon points towards the mouth of the character who's speaking, it points to the element that you're hovering over so that it would be very specific.
1:09:23And tip kit is a way for developers to add something like that to user interface elements.
1:09:31And I think what happens when you first upgrade to iOS 26 is you get a tip kit thing pointing to the filter menu saying, hey, here's a new thing.
1:09:39It's the filter menu and you can switch to the unified view and we kind of wish you would.
1:09:45Right.
1:09:47But if you don't want to, and then you can always go back here.
1:09:51And it's a very nice feature.
1:09:53And as I recall, it's a very nicely written tip balloon saying, and if you switch, you could switch to unified.
1:10:00And we promise you won't get lost in settings, apps, phone, view, whatever, to ever go back.
1:10:11You can just come back here and tip this, tap this same filter button and to get the menu and you can instantly switch back.
1:10:20We promise you could try unified.
1:10:22And it is literally two taps right here in the view itself to go back.
1:10:27It's a really nice feature.
1:10:28I think that's what they do.
1:10:29They don't switch you by default.
1:10:31They show you a tip that encourages you to try it by default, which is probably the right way to do it.
1:10:37But I think the reason I don't think they're going to, even though they've named it classic, I think they've named it classic more as an encouragement to try the new thing.
1:10:46Like, hey, if you want to be an old fuddy-duddy and stick with the outdated thing, keep using classic.
1:10:52That's fine.
1:10:53Like, which one sounds cooler?
1:10:56It's unified.
1:10:57Certainly sounds cooler than classic.
1:10:59Classic never sounds cool.
1:11:00Right?
1:11:01It always sounds like...
1:11:03It depends on your age, perhaps.
1:11:03There may be the people that are like, I don't know, I'm sticking with classic.
1:11:07It's classic rock, you know, classic coke.
1:11:11I realized the other day I was exercising in a hotel gym and they had, I don't know if it's serious or whatever, but one of those commercial-free satellite radios playing.
1:11:22And they were playing something that they called classic rock and they were playing something that they called classic rock or I think that's what they call it.
1:11:28And I realized that what's now deemed classic rock, while it's all very familiar to me, is actually much older than what they called oldies when I was a teenager.
1:11:39And I don't know who picked the name oldies, but that name was not meant to last because it's so disparaging.
1:11:47So I guess that would be the difference.
1:11:49That would be the sign that maybe this is going to go away next year is if they rename instead of unified and classic, if it's unified and oldie.
1:12:00Which layout do you want, oldie or youth?
1:12:04To crap it?
1:12:05Yeah.
1:12:06Limping along, yeah.
1:12:09Yeah.
1:12:10All right, let me take a break here and thank our next sponsor of the show.
1:12:14And it is our good friends at Sentry, S-E-N-T-R-Y.
1:12:21And there's a couple of sponsors that I had to spell it out or they asked me to spell it out.
1:12:27And I think Sentry in particular is a good one because I think verbally it sounds a lot like century, like a hundred years.
1:12:35But this is Sentry, S-E-N-T-R-Y, like a guard.
1:12:38And Sentry is a great developer toolkit you use when you're an iOS developer.
1:12:45Look, and I want to tell you this on this show, they have a couple of different things that they've been sponsoring the show for me to tell you about.
1:12:52But this time I want to tell you about SEER, S-E-E-R, their AI debugging agent.
1:12:58Look, debugging sucks.
1:13:00They know it, you know it, every developer knows it.
1:13:02You dig through diffs, logs, traces, and code that you didn't even write just to understand what went wrong.
1:13:09SEER is Sentry's AI debugging agent that uses the context Sentry already collects errors, logs, traces, distributed traces, and your code to tell you what went wrong and how to fix it fast.
1:13:24SEER uses your Sentry telemetry data alongside your application code to catch real issues before you ship, not just style nitpicks.
1:13:34When something breaks, SEER examines the error, its trace, surrounding logs, profiling data, and the relevant code to explain what happened.
1:13:41Then SEER can take action, drafting a fix and opening PRs itself for handing the work off to your coding agent to fix automatically.
1:13:49SEER customers can also debug with SEER in their AI-enabled IDE by connecting to Sentry's MCP.
1:13:58They have a video, I'll put a link in the show notes, in the sponsors section on how SEER can integrate with Cursor agents.
1:14:07My thanks to Sentry for sponsoring the show.
1:14:09They support over 100 languages and frameworks.
1:14:11You can try it free at Sentry, S-E-N-T-R-Y dot I-O slash talk show.
1:14:18Sentry dot I-O slash talk show.
1:14:21And that'll let them know that this show sent you, and they have a free developer plan, and listeners of the show can just use that code talk show, T-A-L-K-S-H-O-W, for 80 bucks in Sentry credits.
1:14:33My thanks to Sentry for continuing to sponsor the talk show.
1:14:37Do you want to talk about the way that messages in iOS 26 is sort of similar to the phone app?
1:14:44Yeah, because this was interesting, because, again, this was some consistency.
1:14:50Yeah.
1:14:51We've decided to change things, and, oh, look, phone and messages are very similar kinds of apps.
1:14:58We should do things similarly.
1:15:01And particularly when Apple added the new ability to identify unknown senders slash callers, that was needed a way to be expressed in the interface.
1:15:13And so, you know, we have the, you know, in the phone app, we have that filter menu in the top, and it shows you calls, missed calls, voicemail.
1:15:23And then if you've turned on the feature, unknown callers and spam.
1:15:27I'm curious.
1:15:28Have you turned on spam?
1:15:30Do you see anything in that ever?
1:15:32No.
1:15:33And never.
1:15:34Well, no, I just looked, and there's two.
1:15:35Nope.
1:15:36I've got two.
1:15:37But including one that is not spam.
1:15:41No.
1:15:42So I was wondering where this thread went.
1:15:46Almost never do I ever see anything in there.
1:15:52Yeah.
1:15:52So with the phone app, it's all from the carrier, and I've never seen anything there at all.
1:15:57And with messages, it's the same thing for me, that basically nothing in spam.
1:16:02So I'm curious about that.
1:16:04The promotions filter is the one that has what I would consider to be spam, which is primarily, for me, political spam, which is, it got better for me, and then it got worse.
1:16:18It ebbs and flows, and I'm not quite sure why, but it is starting a few months ago.
1:16:24It started getting worse again, and it continues to be.
1:16:29It's out of control in terms of how many times, I guess, a day.
1:16:33Honestly, at this point, I get unsolicited text messages because my wife and I have donated to, in our case, Democratic candidates.
1:16:43At some point in the past, we literally gave less money to the Harris campaign.
1:16:49I mean, again, I kind of feel bad about it, how things have turned out.
1:16:52But we gave less money in the 2024 cycle than we did in 2020 because we were both so incredibly frustrated by the barrage of text messages from candidates.
1:17:04And I do think it's, you know, I've looked into it some more.
1:17:08I've written about it a little.
1:17:10I think it's the fault of an organization called Act Blue, which is sort of a, I don't know what exact kind of organization Act Blue is, but it's like a political action committee or some kind of nonprofit or some kind of organizing function to help Democratic candidates get elected.
1:17:26But it's them who has this master mailing list that they sell or give to Democratic candidates so that, you know, like in a national election, getting a message from Kamala Harris.
1:17:37I get it.
1:17:37I gave to Joe Biden.
1:17:38We did give money and we tried to figure out a way.
1:17:41Is there a way to donate money?
1:17:43Anonymously.
1:17:44Yeah.
1:17:45Anonymously or at least without your phone number.
1:17:48And I forget how what we did.
1:17:50But it's like, we just keep getting, I just keep getting messages from random candidates in random states and they are all Democrats, but it's like, I'm not going to give money to somebody who's running for the House of Representatives in Texas.
1:18:05Well, I mean, in some ways, I sort of like reading their messages because they're all very earnest.
1:18:12Yeah.
1:18:12You know, like sometimes I'm going to do this, but who are you?
1:18:18Where are you?
1:18:19And sometimes I will look at it for a little because I see the preview and it comes from an unknown number.
1:18:25And so I just see a phone number.
1:18:26And I got one yesterday that was like, I was thinking about my grandfather yesterday.
1:18:30And I was like, now, who is this?
1:18:32And I thought, oh, I bet it's political.
1:18:34And I opened it up and looked.
1:18:35And yes, it was a candidate whose little earnest spiel is that they were thinking about their grandfather and somehow it inspired them to run this year for the Senate or the House or whatever the hell they're running for.
1:18:47But promotions is where, but the filter works.
1:18:51It keeps them out of my main message list.
1:18:55And there are sometimes messages I want in promotions, codes, those two-factor codes come in and get filtered into promotions instead of the main list.
1:19:05It's hard to predict.
1:19:08And sometimes they don't, like we have certain accounts, like I think for our Amex account or something where it always comes to me instead of Amy and I just need to read it.
1:19:17There's that wonderful integration where you can get an SMS code.
1:19:21And when you're using your Mac, it'll autofill via the continuity feature.
1:19:27And one of the great breakthrough features Apple's come up with in the last 10 or 15 years, the team behind that.
1:19:35Honestly, the best thing about Tahoe is that it works in other browsers.
1:19:40Ah, well, I don't use other browsers.
1:19:43It's not just Safari and Tahoe.
1:19:46It's probably the main thing that I miss on my main Mac, which, like you, I have not yet taken to Tahoe.
1:19:53I was like, oh, it always works so well on my MacBook Air.
1:19:57I love to hear that even the good features about Tahoe are things that I don't really want or need because my primary browser is Safari.
1:20:05What's your primary browser?
1:20:06Arc?
1:20:07Are you an Arc guy?
1:20:08Yeah.
1:20:09I am an Arc guy, which means I am bitter and twisted.
1:20:12Yes.
1:20:13All of my friends, I have so many friends who, I guess I have a few who I think use Chrome, and they're not the user interface nitpickiest friends.
1:20:24But I have some user interface nitpicky friends, and I'll count you, I'll add you to the list, Adam, who are big Arc aficionados.
1:20:31And they are becoming ever more increasingly bitter because they got a taste of this thing that they fell in love with.
1:20:39And then the browser company was like, well, that's enough of that.
1:20:43We're going to move on.
1:20:44Let's do something new and much worse.
1:20:47Like, that'll be fun.
1:20:48We'll take all the features you liked and get rid of them.
1:20:52And maybe we'll give them back to you in these, like, teaspoonfuls.
1:20:56I find I don't want to digress too much about it.
1:21:01I totally see the appeal of Arc.
1:21:03I totally see the appeal.
1:21:04I guess the problem for me is I just like Safari so much.
1:21:08It's like what I get.
1:21:09And I totally see why some people don't like Safari or don't prefer it.
1:21:14It's hard to hate it, I think.
1:21:15I totally see the appeal.
1:21:17But Safari is sort of – it just fits me like an old baseball glove that I've worn in.
1:21:24It's just right for me.
1:21:26But I could see how if it doesn't, Arc is way more interesting to me than Chrome or Brave or certainly Microsoft Edge.
1:21:33And I used to be a big fan.
1:21:35People put far into it.
1:21:36Yeah, I used to be a big fan of the sidebar of tabs in OmniWeb was Omnigroup's browser from the early days of Mac OS X.
1:21:46And I remember when OmniWeb sort of faded away.
1:21:50I don't remember it ever quite being explicitly canceled, but just sort of, eh, we can't keep up with this.
1:21:56It was like they had, like, their own custom fork of WebKit.
1:21:58And it's hard to sell a web browser.
1:22:00But I remember being – when I switched back to Safari full-time from OmniWeb.
1:22:06And I think that's how long I've been using Safari as my primary browser continuously is I switched from OmniWeb.
1:22:12At some point, I think in Obama's first term, maybe even before that, maybe George W. Bush was still president.
1:22:19It was very early.
1:22:20It was definitely the 2000s decade.
1:22:23I totally see the appeal of Arc.
1:22:25Yeah, so the autofilling those codes would be great.
1:22:28Yeah, yeah.
1:22:29That was – that's the main thing.
1:22:31But yes, Messages, you know, they did a nice job with some of this stuff.
1:22:36And, you know, the only thing that I have a little argument with, in actually both phone and Messages, is that filter menu is a little hard to move through quickly.
1:22:47Yeah.
1:22:48Like, I mean, it's always two taps.
1:22:51You always have to kind of read everything in the menu.
1:22:53It doesn't have a lot of – it feels like it would be nice to have some way of, like, swiping between these lists quickly so you don't have to kind of look at all of them and go, oh, that's the one I – or to know, you see, because the filter menu will be – indicate it'll have a blue background if there's something in there.
1:23:14So, like, you're trying to figure out, like, why you didn't find the message you're looking for.
1:23:18Like, you saw the notification come in from something, and that's actually the one I just found live on the show, sitting there in the spam filtering.
1:23:26It was a message I remember seeing the notification for from somebody.
1:23:29I was like, whatever happened to that message?
1:23:31And I was like, ah, I'll get to it someday when I zero out my inbox.
1:23:34But, yeah, I think the consistency is pretty good.
1:23:37And it's actually, if anything, more consistent in Messages because Messages only has one main view.
1:23:43It doesn't have a tab bar at the bottom.
1:23:45So that filter menu is always visible as opposed to what we talked about a bit ago about on the phone app that you have to be in the calls list in the tab bar at the bottom.
1:23:55The phone app needs a keypad view.
1:23:57I mean, you kind of do.
1:23:59I mean, it still is a phone.
1:24:01So I get it.
1:24:03But I kind of feel like in Messages, they get away with the fact that there's no system-wide, always-present thing at the top for menus to be in.
1:24:11A menu bar?
1:24:14The other change between Messages and phone, which is sort of a strike against consistency, but I think actually makes sense in each in context, is your favorites in Messages use the contact avatars, little circles.
1:24:30Whereas in Unified View, they have the little thumbnails for the contact posters.
1:24:35Right.
1:24:36Which, it took me a while to figure out the contact posters, too, because I had none, or I had one, or something like that.
1:24:42No one does contact posters.
1:24:44You have to kind of do them yourself.
1:24:46And it's a horrible, horrible interface.
1:24:48They look great when you've done them.
1:24:49Yes, exactly.
1:24:51And I kind of feel like that's, like, don't the people at Apple notice that in their list, none of the people who don't work at Apple, none of the people in their families who aren't their colleagues have posters?
1:25:03This should be something that stands out to them of, we should go back to the drawing board on posters because nobody is setting these up.
1:25:09Well, and I think-
1:25:11I've got one for my wife and son, but nobody else.
1:25:13I didn't even have them for them until I went to write an article about it because I had one person who'd come in with one.
1:25:19I'm like, hey, how did he do that?
1:25:21You know, like, how come I don't have them for anyone else?
1:25:23And it turns out it's only an iMessage.
1:25:25You know, if you don't get an iMessage from someone who's made one, you never get it.
1:25:28And so why are these icons the size of a phone instead of a circle like they are like when you pin chats to the top of messages?
1:25:37Instead of being an icon or just an avatar, why does it look like that?
1:25:43Oh, I see.
1:25:44It's for a feature that nobody else has set up.
1:25:46But that if you do does look really cool.
1:25:49I think this is a serious opportunity for Apple intelligence.
1:25:54Oh, yeah, I agree.
1:25:56It's just like featured photos on your lock screen, right?
1:25:59Exactly.
1:26:00Find me a good photo of this person.
1:26:01We know who they are.
1:26:03And that's an area of AI in general.
1:26:06It's not LLM based.
1:26:07It's-
1:26:08What's the other term?
1:26:09It's-
1:26:09It's machine learning.
1:26:10Machine learning.
1:26:11But Apple's machine learning on photos is so good in getting better.
1:26:15It's like literally, it's at least, I think at this point, 10 years old.
1:26:19But it still continues to get better.
1:26:20One of my all-time features of iOS is the photo widget, which just picks photos through machine learning.
1:26:28And every year it gets better and better.
1:26:31It's the batting average of that widget.
1:26:34It's just extraordinary.
1:26:35For me, the lock screen photo shuffle on both the iPhone and the Apple Watch is possibly my favorite feature ever.
1:26:43Because I'm not one of those people who goes through and looks at my photos.
1:26:47You know, I take photos and I don't really go back to them hardly ever.
1:26:50I don't like the idea of them, but they need to be presented to me at the right time.
1:26:54And the lock screens are the right time.
1:26:56It is like having a personal assistant with who you trust with access to your entire personal library who like, hey, John, it's the start of the day.
1:27:07How about a lovely photo from a vacation you took with your family 10 years ago?
1:27:11And it's like, oh.
1:27:12And then if you're really interested, you could tap it and see more.
1:27:15And it's like, huh, that is a lovely way to start my day.
1:27:18Thank you.
1:27:19Yeah.
1:27:20And that's something that, again, Apple Intelligence, when you connect the faces with the contacts and just pull one up, make a nice one.
1:27:28Do it for both the posters and the photos.
1:27:31Yeah.
1:27:31And make it really easy.
1:27:32And maybe it would be like, pick one automatically.
1:27:35Pick one that you think is best automatically.
1:27:37But make it easy to tap and hold to get a command to pick another one and maybe have one that works like you can do with your lock screen and have it pick a bunch and rotate throughout the day.
1:27:50Right.
1:27:51Don't just use the same picture of my wife.
1:27:53Go through a bunch of my favorite pictures of my wife or ones that your machine learning suggests I might think are favorite photos of my wife.
1:28:02And I will say that the – because the only place you see contact posters otherwise is when one of these people calls you.
1:28:08Yes.
1:28:08The incoming call screen.
1:28:09And it's actually really nice.
1:28:12Yes.
1:28:12I didn't know about it for the longest time because no one used it until I finally set these.
1:28:17I'm like, hey, when my sister calls, I really like that photo.
1:28:20I know who's calling me at an instant late.
1:28:22Yeah.
1:28:23The only thing that has confused me about it is that at least in the iOS 26 era, I have – and I didn't let Apple Intelligence pick them all.
1:28:31I tried it the first time and it got so good.
1:28:33But then I got really picky and went and handpicked a bunch of photos of mostly my wife and son.
1:28:38And for years, I had used other images on my lock screen.
1:28:43And I'm not saying I got into marital trouble over it, but it was noted that I was a person who didn't have family members on my lock screen and had other sorts of wallpapers.
1:28:55And I was like, oh, well, I'll try this feature.
1:28:58And then I was like, oh, I really actually like this.
1:29:00But sometimes it's like one of my favorite pictures of my wife will be my current lock screen photo.
1:29:06But then also, for obvious reasons, one of the people I speak to most frequently on the phone is my wife.
1:29:12And then her poster is the same image.
1:29:15And I'm confused whether I'm on the poster image because I'm on a call or I'm on the lock screen.
1:29:19It's a – I don't know how to solve that issue.
1:29:23The easiest way would be for me to switch my lock screen back to just a wallpaper that isn't my family and not have it change.
1:29:31The side eye.
1:29:33It is a good –
1:29:35Lock screen this time.
1:29:35Yeah.
1:29:35But it is a good problem to have.
1:29:37It's that we have these nice photos and we don't have to go through 30 or 40 or 50,000 photos or however many we have to find the ones we like the best.
1:29:46Yeah, the poster image is great.
1:29:47What else about messages?
1:29:49Anything?
1:29:52You know what bugs me?
1:29:53It's such a little thing.
1:29:54And it's in both messages and phone.
1:29:56It really bothers me that in both of them, when you go to the bottom and there's the manage filtering, which is a great thing to have right there that jumps you into the right place.
1:30:06I hate that it doesn't have an ellipsis at the end because I feel like the ellipsis –
1:30:13Spoken like a Mac user, right?
1:30:15Because yes.
1:30:16And I know that it used to mean, I think, according to Hoyle or according to our Bible, the HIG, it might have at one time meant that you were going to get a dialogue in the app you were in that you would have to deal with before you continued on to the feature.
1:30:33When you have a new untitled document and you hit save, the save command has three dots at the end of it because the save dialogue box is going to come up because it needs to come up because you need to be able to name the file and choose where you want to save it.
1:30:49So it has a dot, dot, dot.
1:30:51The dot, dot, dot means something else is going to happen.
1:30:53But then after you have already named the document, the save command doesn't have dot, dot, dot because it'll just save in place and you don't see a dialogue box.
1:31:04It's really kind of nice.
1:31:06I say when it jumps you to another app, it should have the dot, dot, dot.
1:31:10Yes.
1:31:11I agree.
1:31:12Because I feel like it's a little unexpected maybe for some people that, oh, what does that do?
1:31:19Manage filtering.
1:31:19It does a very nice thing.
1:31:21Jumps you exactly to where you want to be two or three levels deep in the settings app.
1:31:27Two or three levels deep and scrolled way down.
1:31:30Yes.
1:31:31Yes.
1:31:31Because some of these settings apps are getting pretty long.
1:31:34Yeah.
1:31:34And the search feature in settings still isn't that great.
1:31:38That's putting it nicely.
1:31:40Right.
1:31:41So, yes, I didn't even notice that, actually, that it does actually scroll you down to the right spot.
1:31:47That's the first I've noticed.
1:31:48That's a nice touch.
1:31:49Yes.
1:31:50It's really nice.
1:31:52What a great feature.
1:31:53A+, whoever is behind this at Apple, you should go out and have a nice dinner with the people who hooked up the continuity feature to get those SMS codes pre-filled in your browser.
1:32:05Because these are the sort of things that made us Apple users long ago and have kept us Apple users since they're the nice touches that define and always used to define the Apple user experience.
1:32:18So, I have another one that I'm not wild about.
1:32:21I didn't mention this anywhere.
1:32:22But in both phone and messages, in the top left corner is an edit button.
1:32:29And, of course, it's liquid glass, so, you know, good luck figuring out if it's actually a button and everything.
1:32:33And it's what you use to, you know, mess with your favorites or to work with multiple items in the list.
1:32:44And, I mean, you need those features, but it feels somehow overemphasized.
1:32:50Like, it's got a big space for something I never, ever do or I do very, very infrequently.
1:33:00The other thing about it that bugs me, too, I agree that it occupies – and, again, if they had something equivalent to a menu bar where both of these things could go, they wouldn't – it does bug me a little.
1:33:15The other thing is – and I almost want to praise them for one thing about it, which is that they at least spell it out, E-D-I-T.
1:33:24Yeah, right, at least edit as opposed to a cryptic icon, which is what they've done with so much else.
1:33:31And once you go to – if anybody – if you're listening along, I just imagine that this is almost like a video episode of the show where people listening are – they've got their podcast player in the background, and they're using the messages app and phone app as you and I have been talking about them.
1:33:47Go to messages, go to the top left, hit edit, and then go to select messages.
1:33:54And now you can select individual message threads, but the edit button turns into a blue checkmark, right?
1:34:03And in the old days, up until iOS 26, it would say done, which is so much better.
1:34:10Like, these goddamn checkmarks that have replaced the done buttons drive me crazy because there's no consistency between them.
1:34:19Like, when you take a screenshot, it's like, if I hit the X, does the screenshot disappear or does it get saved to my photo roll automatically?
1:34:27I don't know.
1:34:29Well, and also, the checkmark is blue.
1:34:32Right.
1:34:33Why is it selected?
1:34:33I don't know.
1:34:34It looks like a selection.
1:34:36Right.
1:34:36And it replaced – it replaced – you know, like the edit button, which is not blue.
1:34:40Right.
1:34:41So, how are the selected messages indicated?
1:34:43By a blue checkmark.
1:34:45A blue checkmark.
1:34:47It's like you've selected nothing up there.
1:34:49Like, there's – in addition to the ones you are trying to select to delete or to mark unread, you can, like, select multiple threads and mark them red or unread at the same time.
1:35:02And at the bottom, you get a nice little red awl and then a trash icon.
1:35:05It's like we're bouncing back and forth everywhere.
1:35:08And somewhere, Larry Tesler is rolling over in his grave because this is a mode and, I mean, this is a deep discussion.
1:35:17But should we, in the year 2026, still need a separate mode for selecting items in a list than just tapping items in a list?
1:35:26Maybe I get it that we've – instead of a precise mouse cursor, we've got the fat-fingered interface on a touchscreen because they can change the screens and change the size of the phones and advance the software as much as they want.
1:35:39But one thing that's not going to change is the size of our fingers.
1:35:42So, maybe.
1:35:43But I kind of feel like if you're going to have a mode for this, it should be as explicit as possible.
1:35:49And explicit means words.
1:35:51I'm sorry.
1:35:52A checkmark does not – what was wrong with the word done?
1:35:56I kind of feel like one of the lesser complained about, and certainly by me, aspects of liquid glass that I think deserves scorn is the elimination of words in favor of icons only.
1:36:10Which is where people will always say, but you don't have to localize them, and to which I say, get over it.
1:36:17Well, there's two things about that, though.
1:36:21I get it, and that Apple has to localize for literally – by definition, Apple has to localize for every language that they sell the product in.
1:36:28And for the iPhone, that's practically almost every country in the world.
1:36:33Almost every language that has a sizable enough country to have a localized version for it.
1:36:40I get it.
1:36:41But also, localizing is one of those things.
1:36:44A, for Apple itself, cry me a river about the cost of localizing the entire – I mean, it's like, look at their financial reports every quarter.
1:36:53They just had the highest revenue and highest profits of any quarter in the company's history.
1:36:58They can afford to keep paying for people to translate the word done into whatever esoteric languages iOS supports out there.
1:37:08Cry me a river.
1:37:09B, this is actually one of those things that AI is incredibly good for, and I have some developer friends who have localized their apps into more languages than they've ever supported before by using LLM tools to do it.
1:37:23And they've gotten feedback from readers or users of their apps who speak those languages to say, hey, I notice you have a localization for whatever language, and it's really good.
1:37:33And it's like, oh, that's good to know because I used an LLM, so I wasn't really sure.
1:37:38Literally no idea what these words are.
1:37:40Right.
1:37:41But that damn blue checkmark.
1:37:43So I want to complain about the blue checkmark, but I want to thank them that the edit still says edit.
1:37:49I'm with you that it kind of takes up a lot of space for a thing I don't use a lot.
1:37:53Yes.
1:37:54But at least if it's going to be there, spell it out, which they did do.
1:37:57Yeah.
1:37:58And I think it's because what is the icon for edit?
1:38:00I don't know.
1:38:01But I don't know why checkmark means done.
1:38:03It doesn't make any sense to me.
1:38:05Right.
1:38:06You don't ever check.
1:38:08Well, you check something off a to-do list, but that is a single item, not like a set of actions.
1:38:13But if you take a screenshot, take a screenshot right now on your iPhone, and then there's an X button that makes it go away, but then there's also a checkmark.
1:38:22But that opens a menu where you get save the photos, save the file, save the quick note, copy and delete, delete screenshot.
1:38:30So there's, again, consistency.
1:38:33If it just said done, you'd know you're done.
1:38:36And if it's a bunch of options, then, you know, guess what?
1:38:38It should look like it's going to open a menu, right?
1:38:41Remember when menu, buttons that open a menu would have a little down-facing chevron.
1:38:45And they have, in SF, what are the icons called?
1:38:50SF?
1:38:50SF symbols.
1:38:51SF symbols, right.
1:38:53There's icons specifically that mean, like, down-facing arrow chevrons to open a menu.
1:38:59Like, it should look like it.
1:39:00So if in one app, the checkmark means the same thing that a done button does.
1:39:05Done, get out of this view, get out of this mode.
1:39:07But in the screenshot mode, the checkmark opens a menu.
1:39:11It should be a checkmark.
1:39:12At least it should be a checkmark with a chevron to say it's going to open a menu because it's not going to do the thing.
1:39:17That sort of – when I think back to the things that we would have arguments about in our community about consistency.
1:39:28We would have been laughed out of town on these things, right?
1:39:32Right.
1:39:32How fine-grained they were, but how seriously we took them because we're such UI nerds.
1:39:38And again, it's one of those ways where being a stickler for detail is helping everybody else who doesn't – who says they don't care.
1:39:48But if people who really are, like us, bothered by getting little things like this wrong, think all these things through and apply in the software that's being made these principles, all the people out there in the world, the 99% of the world who does not care, has never heard of the human interface guidelines, they benefit from them, right?
1:40:09They learn that a little down-facing chevron on a button means it's going to open a menu, and they learn that if it doesn't, it means it's going to go away.
1:40:17And the word done – and again, maybe it is a problem in some languages that the equivalent of done is a longer string.
1:40:26I don't know.
1:40:28I don't know what the solution is, but it didn't seem to be a problem all the way up through iOS 18 to just say done if they meant done.
1:40:34Yeah.
1:40:35Drives me crazy.
1:40:36I do feel as though with some of these icons – because obviously Apple, they don't have an edit icon, although if you look in the lower right corner, they have a pencil on a square icon, which is the compose icon.
1:40:51But in other apps, like in Pages, like we touched on, the menus in Tahoe having icons, they tend to reuse these things because, in fact, they're very, very hard to describe all these functions with icons.
1:41:05I almost want the cheat sheet.
1:41:07Like, I want a dictionary.
1:41:08What is this?
1:41:10Because we're sitting here going back and forth.
1:41:11We finally kind of settled on this, the filter icon.
1:41:14But it took us a while, right?
1:41:17Because it's not obvious.
1:41:18No, definitely not.
1:41:20And it – because it sort of also looks like it could be a sort icon, like maybe tapping it would sort them in the opposite order of what you're seeing because it's a pyramid that's going down.
1:41:31And, in fact, I believe in years past that's actually very similar to the sort icon from list views across macOS where it was a pyramid of ever-decreasing sizes or ever-increasing whether you were sorting, ascending, or descending.
1:41:45It could be sort.
1:41:46It's just aversion to language.
1:41:47It's just aversion to language.
1:41:48And, again, it sort of fits in with the whole terrible, dumb, no-bad, make-me-furious decision to add icons by default or recommend icons by default for most menu items across macOS Tahoe in the menu bar.
1:42:08It's crazy-making, you know, and I'm not going to relitigate it here.
1:42:11Brent Simmons and I talked about it on the last episode.
1:42:14It's been written about at length exquisitely by other people.
1:42:17But it's such a bad idea.
1:42:19But the best argument against it is if you got rid of the menu names, the words, would you be able to use the menu bar with these icons alone?
1:42:29And the answer, of course, is no.
1:42:30No way.
1:42:31Even close.
1:42:32Right.
1:42:33You might have a chance briefly while you remembered what the positions of the menus were.
1:42:39Right.
1:42:39Oh, I think new is at the top.
1:42:41I'll guess for that one.
1:42:42Right.
1:42:44Some of them you could, you know, you go to view and view as icons, view as list in the finder.
1:42:49View as icons, list as columns, as gallery.
1:42:52The icons do kind of visually represent the layout.
1:42:55But most of the commands, no way.
1:42:58No frigging way.
1:43:00And so many of them are duplicated.
1:43:01The new finder window is just a plus.
1:43:04It could be new anything.
1:43:05Again, it doesn't, I'm not making fun of it.
1:43:08It's just impossible to come up with icons for some of these things.
1:43:12And a menu is meant to be read and commands are meant to be read.
1:43:15And most push buttons, if there's space for them, it would, it's better to have just words.
1:43:22And it makes me feel, it's like an infantilizing aspect of it.
1:43:29It fits in with a big safe, safety, like kindergarten scissors corner radius of the windows.
1:43:36You can't, I don't know, note to Alan Dye, two months out the door.
1:43:40You can't cut yourself with the radius of a window on screen.
1:43:44Just because Steve Jobs liked rounded racks doesn't mean you should keep going that way.
1:43:48But it really does feel like they're moving towards, I really hate to say it and to go to this extreme,
1:43:55but like an idiocracy future where the, even on the Mac, the whole interface is designed for people who can't read.
1:44:02If you assume that people can read, a lot of these decisions make no sense.
1:44:10And one of the things that's going to be interesting is, is that we are interestingly moving back towards a much more textual future with LLMs.
1:44:21You know, there's no interface to an LLM other than words.
1:44:24So the idea that words are old, you know, shut up, old man.
1:44:28Nobody reads anymore.
1:44:29It's like, that's how everybody, the hottest thing in years in tech is entirely text-based almost.
1:44:34Right.
1:44:35And even when you're doing visual things like generating images or now generating videos, you do it with a text prompt.
1:44:42You type what you want it to make and it makes it.
1:44:45And then it asks, hey, how's that?
1:44:47It's crazy making.
1:44:48All right.
1:44:49Let me take one last break here and thank our third and final sponsor of the show.
1:44:54And it's our good friends at Squarespace.
1:44:57Oh, what a surprise.
1:44:59Our longest running, most continuous sponsor on the talk show.
1:45:02And they keep sponsoring because people who listen to the show keep signing up.
1:45:06Or, which I really think is key to the success of this sponsorship deal, is that you, the people listening to me and Adam talk for two hours about these niggling user interface details and are still enthralled and waiting for us to get back to it, are the sort of people your friends and family come to when they have a need.
1:45:26Like, hey, you know, maybe I should have a website for this business I run or thing that I do.
1:45:30Or maybe my business needs a new website or I should replace the one that's already there.
1:45:35Send them to Squarespace.
1:45:36It is so easy.
1:45:38And instead of you building a website for them or you hand-holding them, Squarespace really is the sort of WYSIWYG meant to be approachable from users of all levels of skills.
1:45:52If you really do want to add your own JavaScript to your website, yeah, you can do that with a Squarespace site.
1:45:59And if you don't know the difference between JavaScript and CSS and have no idea what CSS even is and you're already rolling your eyes and running away, you don't need to know any of that to use Squarespace to set up a website.
1:46:13It's that amazing.
1:46:15It really is really scales from don't know anything about making websites technically at all to I can actually code a website by hand if I wanted to, but I don't want to.
1:46:26And but I but because I can do that, I kind of want to be able to get to the code.
1:46:31If there's one little thing I want to tweak, Squarespace scales all the way from one to the other.
1:46:37They've got cutting edge design tools, some of the new stuff that they've done.
1:46:41They have a thing called Blueprint AI, and that's their AI enhanced design partner.
1:46:46You can use AI to describe what you want to build.
1:46:49And again, just like we were talking about on the show, using words, describe the sort of things you want or do the do it the old fashioned way that Squarespace has supported forever and choose from their library of professionally designed and award winning templates.
1:47:03And then once you choose from a template, you can go back to using the Blueprint AI to tweak it.
1:47:09Also, Squarespace domains.
1:47:11Simplest first part of having a website is registering a domain name and keeping it registered and being able to support it.
1:47:19They handle that, too.
1:47:20You could do it all through Squarespace.
1:47:22So where do you go to find out more?
1:47:26Go to Squarespace dot com slash talk show.
1:47:30And when you go there, Squarespace dot com slash talk show, you save 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain using that code talk show.
1:47:39All right.
1:47:41Anything else you wanted to talk about?
1:47:42Anything else?
1:47:43Any other complaints?
1:47:44Anything that have been on your I mean, we could go forever, but I was going to say we could go forever.
1:47:49We won't get into Siri, but yeah.
1:47:51Yeah.
1:47:51That's that's that's that would require an episode.
1:47:54It would require like a new show.
1:47:56Yeah.
1:47:57Yeah.
1:47:57But I was I was almost there when you started talking about balloon help.
1:48:00It's like, oh, balloon help.
1:48:02You know, such a nice idea that they really never did.
1:48:06But we've got choice.
1:48:07We've got options again.
1:48:08If only they could get Siri and Apple intelligence actually working.
1:48:12So many possibilities, but another time.
1:48:15So what did you say earlier?
1:48:17What's your Tahoe story that you're you like me are not using it on your main Mac?
1:48:21I yeah, I installed it right away on my MacBook Air and which I use a fair amount, but not not as my main machine.
1:48:27My main machine's a 14 inch MacBook Pro with two 27s.
1:48:30Right.
1:48:31And I usually upgrade around Christmas, you know, got a little time, you know, it's a it's sort of a good time to do it.
1:48:38And I just didn't.
1:48:40And that was about when a lot of these things started coming out, you know, because I hadn't honestly noticed like the window resizing thing myself until Norbert wrote about it.
1:48:51And and I'm kind of blind to icons.
1:48:54I'm such a word person.
1:48:55I don't see them.
1:48:57So it's not actually a usability thing for me so much as as just like it would make no difference.
1:49:03And and yeah, so just thing after thing after thing.
1:49:09And I wasn't getting it.
1:49:10And I just haven't upgraded.
1:49:12So, you know, it's not a huge stance, but it's definitely a little bit of a stance.
1:49:17Yeah, I'm taking a stance.
1:49:20I even went through the thing at.
1:49:23Oh, it's not coming up in my history because I'm on Chrome.
1:49:27I haven't linked to it at Daring Fireboy.
1:49:31I guess I should.
1:49:32Rob Griffiths or our old mutual friend formerly at Macworld.
1:49:37But as Rob's observatory site, he has had an entry from, I think, early January.
1:49:42I should link to it soon.
1:49:43But basically telling you how to create a I even forget what it's called.
1:49:49But it's like you effectively put your Mac under management like it's like you have an IT department.
1:49:55But you set up.
1:49:57Yeah.
1:49:57You set a policy and you just say and then every 90 days you can renew it with a new certificate that says, don't let this machine upgrade to Tahoe.
1:50:06Oh, yes.
1:50:08And then you will get rid of the red badge on the settings icon, which doesn't bother me.
1:50:14But I totally I'm close enough to being obsessive compulsive about unwanted badges that I told like it doesn't really bother me.
1:50:24And I kind of actually kind of embrace the red badge that I've had for a while of bugging me about Tahoe.
1:50:29But I don't want to make the mistake.
1:50:31And I've had I even wrote about it, how it's kind of there's an aspect of the software update interface that kind of makes it easy to make a mistake.
1:50:40And when you want to just update to the latest version of Sequoia 15 Sequoia, it's if you go to the I click the I for the details, it changes it.
1:50:52If you click the I next to Sequoia automatically selects Tahoe, no matter which I you click, whether you click the I next to the upgrade to Tahoe or the update to the latest point release of Sequoia.
1:51:09When you click any of the I buttons, you get the exact same dialog box, which has Tahoe checked by default, which is atrocious in its own way.
1:51:18And I've had readers write to me and say, even though you wrote about it, it happened to me.
1:51:24And now I'm on Tahoe and I'm and using words often far saltier.
1:51:30They are not happy.
1:51:31No, but yeah, I will link to it.
1:51:33And it's just a bit tricky.
1:51:35And it's one of those things where in the earlier years of Daring Fireball, I'd have been less hesitant to link to it because I felt like I could my audience was more technical.
1:51:44Whereas this requires a bit of technical expertise where I don't want to put my you're kind of on your own if you want to do this.
1:51:53Yeah.
1:51:54And Apple does this things like this every year.
1:51:57So, you know, because I had the same thought, like, do I want to write about this?
1:52:03And I thought, you know, I feel like I feel like a broken record.
1:52:06And, you know, it's the same thing, you know, when they stop signing the iOS updates and, you know, we've just gotten we complain about it every year or people write about every year.
1:52:17And I I don't I don't know what the answer is, because Apple's not going to change.
1:52:23Yeah.
1:52:24That's what it comes down to.
1:52:26I mean, but here's actually here's a question to just finish it off is.
1:52:31Yeah.
1:52:31Do we how much do we think liquid glass is going to change?
1:52:33I mean, it feels to me like they've they've made their bed.
1:52:38I think there's good news and bad news on this front.
1:52:43And with Alan Dye being out, I think with sentiment being very hard not to read.
1:52:49They did a little tell like one thing.
1:52:52I worry because I feel like Apple.
1:52:55I don't I feel like they listen as much as they ever have.
1:53:00And they read the Apple intermedia coverage as much as they ever have.
1:53:06But the amount of feedback they offer is less than ever.
1:53:10So so the illusion has always been that they just don't listen and they have no idea what we on the outside are talking about.
1:53:18But they do.
1:53:19They just don't communicate it, but they communicate it less than ever.
1:53:22But I do think they read it.
1:53:24And then you find out only at the WWDC keynote.
1:53:28So last year at the WWDC keynote for just last June for announcing iOS 26 and all the other 26 OS's, I think it was, though, I think when some of these features, because they're the same across OS's, they have to decide which OS's segment they'll announce it in.
1:53:46But I think because your phone is your main camera, they did this when they were talking about iOS 26, they said about the phone app and the way that that so many users did not like the layout changes in the tab bar and the way that when you scroll down, it gave you a bunch of instead of just showing you your photos, it showed you sections and smart groupings of your photos, like friends and family and stuff like that.
1:54:11It's just show me all my goddamn photos.
1:54:13That's what people thought.
1:54:14I didn't hate that change so much, but it's one of those things where change annoys people, right?
1:54:19Just change, period.
1:54:20And they said, I think it was Federighi speaking, and he even said, or maybe they made somebody else say, I don't know.
1:54:26But whoever said it said, hey, we heard you guys, and we've changed the photos app again in response to very deftly worded to avoid saying to change the things you hated.
1:54:38But they didn't say that.
1:54:39They chose their words very carefully and they came up with a very cleverly, deftly worded way of saying, we've changed photos again because we listened to what you didn't like about it.
1:54:50And they didn't just knee jerk, go back.
1:54:52They didn't add a classic view in this case, but they definitely listened to the specific criticisms that people had, which was basically that people wanted an easy, obvious way to just show thumbnails of their photos in the order that they've been most recently taken, which is the way the library tab at the bottom of the photos app now works.
1:55:16And then they added a second tab collections, which shows all the things that they wanted people to draw people's attention to in iOS 18.
1:55:25So there's two tabs at the bottom, and they even explicitly said, we heard you.
1:55:30So I can't help but think it's not just my own personal bias where I wasn't annoyed so much by the iOS 18 photos app, but I'm highly annoyed by a lot of aspects of liquid glass in across all the 26 OSs.
1:55:44I can't help but think that it's just the plain objective truth that there's just it's not just me.
1:55:51It's out there.
1:55:52It is.
1:55:53So I think little bits of things.
1:55:56So hopefully, and I don't, yeah, little bits of things in the change, but it's it is the at least they are annual like clockwork this year.
1:56:07Like we don't have to wonder, are they going to announce iOS 27 in June?
1:56:11And is it going to come out in September or early October across all their devices?
1:56:14That's pretty much a sure thing.
1:56:16So I think that what they'll do is and are doing clearly at this point in February of 2026 and probably have been doing for months now.
1:56:27And I hope with a more liberated detachment from some of the specific things post Alan Dye and his inner circle going leaving Apple from meta in a surprise announcement, clearly a surprise to Apple's leadership, that it can kind of free them to make more changes than they would have even if Alan Dye had stayed.
1:56:53I think even if he'd stayed, they'd have to address some of these things, but now they can make more changes and without mentioning them by name, just be like, well, good riddance to bad rubbish, right?
1:57:04It was that guy.
1:57:05It was that guy and his mutinous crew who left for meta's fault.
1:57:10And now we're going to make – and I don't think it'll be radical.
1:57:13And there are things like just the fundamental – like the system font being San Francisco.
1:57:18It's a wonderful typeface, really wonderful typeface that I think was designed in a timeless fashion in the way that Helvetica is kind of timeless.
1:57:28And other well-known – it's a typeface that is meant to last for decades.
1:57:33And I really don't think – it doesn't look new and trendy and it doesn't look old.
1:57:39It's just sort of fresh.
1:57:40They don't have to change that.
1:57:42I think there are – I think they can just sort of tweak it.
1:57:45And they certainly need to do some work on the transparency stuff still because – and they added that one option.
1:57:51I think that's what you're referring to in the fall with 26.1 or 26.2.
1:57:55I forget which one where they added a system setting for liquid glass that wasn't – yes, tinted.
1:58:03And the big tell about the fact that they're taking it seriously is that they didn't hide it away in accessibility.
1:58:11There have always – for so many – I mean, I would say probably decades at this point, 20 years, there have been really good features tucked away in accessibility that I think a lot of users miss because they think, well, my vision and hearing and motor skills are fine.
1:58:27So I don't need accessibility features.
1:58:29And no, but there are features in there that you might really like just to make things look better.
1:58:35I mean, you have to reduce transparency as soon as I set up a machine.
1:58:39No, you go to settings, display and brightness.
1:58:41Yeah, reduced transparency is definitely one that I know a lot of people use.
1:58:45And you display and brightness, liquid glass, and it's clear or tinted.
1:58:51The worst part is I like tinted in some places, but I don't for, like, notifications.
1:58:59Like, I feel like on the lock screen with tinted, they don't look –
1:59:04There's a few places where I think Apple has – I don't know if it's intentional, but I almost feel as though they're using liquid glass to punish us.
1:59:12Such as with the scroll bars in Tahoe, that when you –
1:59:16Yes.
1:59:16You know, like, you try to turn off – you know, have reduced transparency on and everything like that.
1:59:21But if you have scroll bars on, they're big black scroll bars.
1:59:25Yeah.
1:59:26They're way more worse than they were in any previous version of Max.
1:59:30They're, like, kind of ugly.
1:59:31They're, like, if, like, I kind of – again, and here I'm – I am connoting pejorative personality defects upon the person who – persons who foisted this upon us.
1:59:43And if I'm wrong, I apologize.
1:59:45But I can't help but feel that there was some contingent within Apple pushing towards this Tahoe interface who were, like, can't we finally just get rid of the always-on scroll bars, right?
1:59:58That's so old-fashioned.
2:00:00And all these people are, like, no, that's the people who I think have disagreed all along with making it the default to turn off always-on scroll bars on the Mac.
2:00:10I think it's one of the worst decisions Apple's ever made.
2:00:13I think scroll bars are such useful contextual information.
2:00:17Why in the world would you want to hide them by default on a display where there's plenty of room for them?
2:00:22Being able to see what views are scrollable when there is more scrollable content, where are you, what range is currently visible by the size of the scroll thumb, and where are you from the beginning to the end in the current context?
2:00:38Why in the world do you have to hover your mouse over the view and start scrolling to get that –
2:00:45To see any of that information.
2:00:46Right.
2:00:46It is unbelievable.
2:00:48Right.
2:00:49And I'm looking now at a finder window in Tahoe.
2:00:52They're just horrible, aren't they?
2:00:53Right.
2:00:54And then you turn on – so I've always recommended this.
2:00:57Again, our mutual friend who we mentioned earlier, Paul Kafasas, has mentioned it, I don't know, on the Rogue Amoeba blog, but certainly on, I think, on his personal blog, One Foot Tsunami.
2:01:05And I know – because I know Paul personally.
2:01:06I know he's had them turned on.
2:01:08But they have turned them – they've made them thicker, which you think is good because they're bigger.
2:01:13But they're always in what used to be the tap-down state.
2:01:18I'm speaking in light mode because I use light mode.
2:01:21But if you're in dark mode, I'm sure it's the opposite.
2:01:23But where you don't – when you click on them, they don't get darker because they're already dark all the time.
2:01:29So it's sort of – I'm imagining a conversation where somebody wanted to get rid of the option so they didn't have to support it.
2:01:35And, in fact, they screwed it up in the Finder column view, which I've written about multiple times and Jeff Johnson, who did most of the legwork on writing it up, that you could turn on column view in the Finder.
2:01:49And with always-on scroll bars, you couldn't resize columns anymore because the widget to resize the columns was underneath the scroll bar.
2:01:57It's crazy.
2:01:58So I think somebody wanted to get rid of them.
2:02:00Another team was like, no, we can't get rid of them.
2:02:04This is actually like an important feature that we use.
2:02:07It's a good idea.
2:02:07And then somebody – the people who wanted to get rid of them are like, well, then we're going to make them black and ugly.
2:02:14It's like – it feels like being punished, right?
2:02:16Right.
2:02:16That's – we don't approve that setting.
2:02:18Suffer.
2:02:19Yeah.
2:02:20So it's like they effectively took the way the scroll bars look, which haven't looked good for a while, I think, ever since they made them look like iOS scroll bars.
2:02:27And, again, on the phone, especially the early iPhones, when they were only three-and-a-half-inch screens, you can understand why they got – I totally understand why they got rid of always-visible scroll bars.
2:02:37I kind of wish it was an option, though.
2:02:39I would keep them on because it's so subtle on iOS.
2:02:43And I would still like to see my current scrolling context all the time, whether I have my thumb on the screen and I'm moving it or not.
2:02:51But I totally understand that space was so limited that only having the scroll bar visible while you're scrolling was a useful and clever decision.
2:03:01But why in the world they brought that to the Mac, I don't know.
2:03:04And getting rid of the arrows to go up and down, which was – we're actually not just a useful tip for newbies, but we're like – you could just put your mouse there.
2:03:13A mouse there and click, down, down, down, down, just keep scrolling a view.
2:03:16Just terrible.
2:03:18And it just feels like somebody spitefully took a big Sharpie marker and just colored the scroll bars in on Tahoe.
2:03:25Like I said, it's like they defaced it.
2:03:28They've defaced the Mac interface, vandalized it.
2:03:31Scroll bars.
2:03:32Yeah, bad mustaches on all the windows.
2:03:35Yeah, so I think they could do things like, hey, what if we made scroll bars on the Mac look cool and useful and, God, it would be so awesome.
2:03:44What if they even turned them back the hell on again by default?
2:03:48Yeah.
2:03:48They could do that without having to backtrack from liquid glass.
2:03:53It's a very long way of answering your question, Adam, but I don't think they're going to backtrack per se.
2:03:58I certainly – I mean, that would be a shock if they were like, remember that thing we announced last year and made you live with for a year?
2:04:03We're throwing it out.
2:04:05I think there's plenty of room in the basic framework of it.
2:04:08And, again, iOS 7 kind of shows the way – iOS 7 was way as radical – more radical as it was than liquid glass is on iOS.
2:04:17It had a lot of problems with just how flat they had made things and how much depth as a visual cue they had eliminated.
2:04:25And then they added depth back in subsequent releases.
2:04:29And I think there are things they can do to, hey, let's find a middle ground between clear and tinted so that we don't even need that option, right?
2:04:38Let's try to eliminate some of these accessibility sessions like reduced transparency and stuff or make it so that fewer people will want to turn it on.
2:04:48Make it an actual accessibility setting as opposed to something that 50% of the population.
2:04:54Make it something for people who have a visual – whatever the visual problem is that it really is for people who like any sort of transparency is a distraction or really reduces the clarity of how well they can see what's on screen.
2:05:07People keep sending me – like one of the most common ones is when you go to the Wi-Fi menu in Tahoe and you list like the network names that if you do it against a white background, it's like you can't frigging read them.
2:05:21It's unbelievable.
2:05:22Let's take a look at some of these things.
2:05:24And I know there's rumors that it's going to be like a snow leopard upgrade this year where they really are just going to tackle things.
2:05:30But that would be great.
2:05:32But people say they want that every year, but I think it's kind of due for one.
2:05:36So that's what I expect is not a backtracking per se, but a, hey, let's fix these things that people are talking about because they obviously are real.
2:05:46And I think that there's a visual framework within LiquidGlass that there's plenty of good territory to work with.
2:05:53I do wonder if they could be using some more of this machine learning technology also because we have the power for it these days to literally be looking on the fly at all times and saying, wow, that's unreadable.
2:06:05Yeah.
2:06:05Fix this little bit here because it's unreadable.
2:06:09I mean, contrast is something you can just calculate.
2:06:12Yeah, or at least to automate the testing of it and to run through all of the possible states so you can get into and make sure that text remains legible at all times.
2:06:22It seems to me like something that maybe should be visible while they're writing the software.
2:06:27Like, hey, this looks cool like this, but if it's a white background on the web page, then you can't read anything.
2:06:33I don't know.
2:06:33Is that a problem?
2:06:34Yeah, it's a frigging problem.
2:06:35So I don't know.
2:06:37I would love to see, too, a backtracking of the everything should look the same across all OSs.
2:06:43I mean, like the biggest rant I would like to get off my chest for Daring Fireball soon would be something along the lines of one of the best things Apple did when they created the iPhone in 2007, the iOS interface in 2007, which I know wasn't called iOS at the time.
2:06:59Was they really didn't make it look like the Mac or, you know, only in ways that made sense.
2:07:05And they didn't import Mac-isms that didn't make sense on a touch screen.
2:07:11But now they're shoving these iOS-isms on the Mac that are just inappropriate for a desktop workstation interface.
2:07:20And they're doing to the Mac what most companies would have done to the phone.
2:07:27And Microsoft proved it, right?
2:07:29The Windows phone interface from the pre, it had a start menu, right?
2:07:34It really looked like Windows 2000 or whatever the version was.
2:07:39Windows phone, yeah, right.
2:07:40Yeah.
2:07:40Windows phone looked like desktop Windows shrunk to a phone and shrunk to a much smaller than iPhone-sized screen because it had, like, a keypad.
2:07:48Funny, it shrunk the interface.
2:07:50That's the obvious thing a company would do.
2:07:53Well, we've got the Mac.
2:07:53The Mac is on a roll, and people love the Aqua interface, so let's put the Aqua interface on a phone.
2:07:58And they didn't do that.
2:07:59But now they've done the reverse and taken the phone interface and put it on the Mac, and it's disrespectful, in my opinion.
2:08:06That's what I'm hoping for.
2:08:08Anything else?
2:08:09Nope.
2:08:10Fingers crossed.
2:08:11WWDC.
2:08:12We'll see what happens.
2:08:13I think it's probably going to be – and I don't think I overhype things like this.
2:08:20I think anything, I tend to underhype them.
2:08:22But I'm looking forward to this WWDC more than any in recent years because I think it's going to be a huge tell what they do user interface-wise.
2:08:31And I think the Apple intelligence aspect is –
2:08:35We've got to see what happens there.
2:08:36Right.
2:08:37At this point, it's like, hey, two years ago, I don't think – that's the whole point of my argument last year.
2:08:42I don't think they needed to pre-announce the stuff that was all half-baked ideas.
2:08:46I think they panicked and rushed and announced stuff that they didn't know if they could build, and it turns out they couldn't build it.
2:08:53But 2026, they need to know that they can build it.
2:08:56Like at this point, it is – now is the time where they really need to announce something that they are definitely going to ship.
2:09:02So I would say the combination of how do they adjust to the reaction to this, the exit of Alan Dye, the internal –
2:09:10And again, I've reported on this probably better or at least more than anybody else that inside Apple, there was much rejoicing when Alan Dye left.
2:09:20So I don't think management was aware of that until he left and that they could kind of get the pulse on how people inside the company.
2:09:29Maybe they were worried like, oh, my God, what are all the other UI designers going to think now that he's left?
2:09:33And it's like it turns out they're throwing parties.
2:09:35And it's like, oh, hey, maybe we had a problem.
2:09:40So if that's all they do, and I think if that could be the gist of the 27 updates is, hey, we're going to fix the most serious, glaring human interface crimes across all the OSs, including and especially the Mac in the 27 updates.
2:09:59And we have a coherent Apple intelligence story that we're really going to be able to ship.
2:10:06That's enough.
2:10:07And that everything else can just be polishing and whatever.
2:10:10That adding features beyond that, forget it.
2:10:13That's two things that would have me throwing a party at WWDC.
2:10:17So that's what I hope.
2:10:19All right, Adam, good to have you on the show again.
2:10:23Let me thank our three sponsors.
2:10:25I'll go in reverse order.
2:10:26It was Squarespace, Sentry, S-E-N-T-R-Y, and Factor.
2:10:31So my thanks to them and my thanks to Adam.
2:10:33And everybody should be following the RSS feed and reading at tidbits.com as much as I do because it's such a great site.
2:10:41Thanks for having me on.
2:10:42So great that it's as good as ever.
2:10:44Thanks, Adam.