0:00:00I wanted you on the show, Jason, for a couple of weeks now. We've been trying to work it out, and now you are, and in the interim, I got very angry at you.
0:00:08Yeah, that's true.
0:00:09Now I'm angry.
0:00:09It's true. I'm sorry you're angry. We're seeing each other next week, so you can pick me down then.
0:00:13Well, that's why I want to work this out before we're in person.
0:00:16Okay, good. I've got to work it through.
0:00:17I'm listening to the upgrade. One of my favorite upgrade episodes of the year is you and Mike Hurley doing the recap of the Apple Report Card.
0:00:27It's part of the whole Apple Report Card annual extravaganza. I love it.
0:00:32And then you get to be talking about the Mac, and you make the very interesting observation that the way you've set up the report card all along is partly to fight against category proliferation.
0:00:47For sure.
0:00:48Because it's already in a lot of categories.
0:00:49Yeah.
0:00:50And partly just to make it—let's make it difficult on the scorers, the graders, the voters.
0:00:56What do we call the invitees?
0:00:58The panelists.
0:00:58The panelists, I would say.
0:01:00I'm not giving you two Mac categories. You've got to set up like the gestalt of the Mac as a whole.
0:01:05And I agree. I both find it difficult, and it makes me angry, but I agree that it's like getting some exercise in.
0:01:13It's supposed to be difficult. It's supposed to work your muscles.
0:01:17And then you get to yapping with Mike about how you would have graded it, which we'll get to in a moment.
0:01:24And you said you would have given it an A because you don't get the kerfuffle over Tahoe.
0:01:29That's not quite what I said. By the way, I'm going to throw you a bone here.
0:01:34This is my piece offering right up front, which is I think you're right about the Siri AI category.
0:01:37I think I need to add it.
0:01:38And I think you were right last year, and I just forgot to add it.
0:01:41I made a to-do to put that in my spreadsheet so that it happens for next year, because I think you're right.
0:01:47I think this year especially, it will be very interesting to see what happens.
0:01:50And so I want to kind of commit to that now that I think that's a good idea.
0:01:54But look, what I said about the Mac, it's funny because I don't think we disagree as much.
0:02:01I don't think you're going to need to throttle me too much.
0:02:04Maybe just to unconsciousness instead of death.
0:02:09Honestly, it's one of these things too where it's obviously the trend over the last few months is people talking about how terrible they think liquid glass is and how bad they think it is on Tahoe.
0:02:18And I don't entirely disagree with that.
0:02:21But I do think that Tahoe has a lot of positives because, I mean, they added productivity features to Tahoe.
0:02:27I think it's the best new set of productivity features added to the Mac in years.
0:02:31And I've been using it since developer beta 2, and I find it perfectly usable.
0:02:37I don't disagree with any of the criticism of the icons, of the little icons in the menus, of the bad effect of liquid glass and how it was implemented in Tahoe.
0:02:50Although my argument is that because it was such a low priority for Apple, clearly.
0:02:56I feel like if they had given the Mac more love, and I use that term loosely with liquid glass, I think it would have been worse, not better.
0:03:04And so I'm kind of okay that it's a half-assed version of liquid glass because I think it could have been way worse.
0:03:10But in the end, a lot of that stuff, I don't like it.
0:03:12It's just like when they did the settings app redesign.
0:03:14It was terrible.
0:03:16And you can criticize it, and they deserve to be criticized because I think that all of this angst about this stuff is actually a symptom of a larger disease that Apple has had for a while in terms of their focus or lack of same on whatever you can call it.
0:03:33Human computer interface, like you and Marco did in the survey.
0:03:35No, no, John, Syracuse.
0:03:37Oh, right, right, John.
0:03:38You can call that user experience, whatever you want to say, focusing on usability.
0:03:43And that's been kind of a problem and a sore spot for them for a while.
0:03:47I think the liquid glass stuff just was an eruption.
0:03:49It was like the, maybe it's the straw that broke the camel's back, if you want to say that.
0:03:53But I feel like it's not the only problem.
0:03:55It's like a really good exemplar that gets everybody talking about those issues.
0:03:59But that all said, Tahoe added triggers for automation at a system level and access to the Apple's cloud models in automation, which I find super useful.
0:04:08And a new Spotlight that is sort of the biggest update to Spotlight in maybe ever.
0:04:14And they added a clipboard history for the very first time to any Apple operating system.
0:04:19There's a lot of stuff that's there, and I can kind of look past how ugly it is because I do find it useful.
0:04:26And at the same time, Mac hardware, everybody basically agrees, is basically like a perfect score.
0:04:33Like they are on all cylinders on the hardware side.
0:04:35So between the functionality of Tahoe and how great the Mac hardware is doing, look, when I said I was being a little rascally or the term that Stuart Wellington uses on the flophouses, I'm a little stinker.
0:04:47It was because I gave a 5 instead of 4.
0:04:49A reasonable argument would be, look, I know that there are problems with the UI, but all the other things give it to a 4.
0:04:56I said a 5 because I was just going to make trouble.
0:04:58And because I've seen so many people who are like, I'm not even going to install it, like you and Marco and other people.
0:05:04And I just don't get it because it's like I get that it's ugly.
0:05:08I get it that it's a regression in a bunch of areas, but there are also a bunch of good things in it.
0:05:13So I, you know, that's so, yes, I was a little stinker and said it was a 5.
0:05:19Probably wasn't.
0:05:20I don't even make up those numbers until Mike asks me about it.
0:05:23I literally don't think, what would I say?
0:05:25What would I give an A or a B to?
0:05:28I literally don't think about it until it was that moment.
0:05:30And you heard me say it.
0:05:31It was like, should I be reasonable or should I be a stinker?
0:05:34And the answer was be a stinker, be a rascal.
0:05:36So I said 5 out of 5.
0:05:37But I do think, I mean, I am here to defend Tahoe at least a little bit because I think there's good stuff in it.
0:05:42I just, and again, I can, look, when I click down a menu in the menu bar, do I roll my eyes a little at all those icons?
0:05:48Yes, I do.
0:05:49They're bad.
0:05:50You should be able to turn them off.
0:05:52There was a great essay about how they're totally inconsistent.
0:05:56It reminded me a lot of what I wrote about the settings app, which is like, why are the icons colored the way they are?
0:06:01Why are they in the order they are?
0:06:03Why are they in groups?
0:06:04What do the groups mean?
0:06:05Nobody knows.
0:06:06Just use the search box.
0:06:07It's a huge, just a give up on this massive scale.
0:06:10The icons are kind of like that too.
0:06:12But at the same time, I use my Mac every day.
0:06:15I get work done.
0:06:16And I actually stopped using LaunchBar and I just use Spotlight now.
0:06:20And it does basically everything I use LaunchBar for.
0:06:22So yeah, Tahoe.
0:06:24You've already, I didn't even share the outline of my show.
0:06:30I actually made an outline because we have so much to cover.
0:06:32I know what you're doing.
0:06:33Where I can't wing it.
0:06:33But I actually was going to ask you what launcher you use.
0:06:37And you've already answered.
0:06:38We'll come back to that.
0:06:39We will come back to that.
0:06:40I mean, I felt like I was simultaneously pushing against the trend a little bit.
0:06:46I want to be honest, right?
0:06:47Like I don't really agree.
0:06:48And you wanted to make me upset.
0:06:49But I also, the little extra part, I was thinking of you.
0:06:53A little extra part.
0:06:53I really was.
0:06:54The fact that you're willing to admit that publicly makes me feel much better.
0:07:00Oh, yeah.
0:07:01Somebody said, I'd really like John and Jason to talk this through on the talk show, which you're welcome.
0:07:05I saw that.
0:07:06And my reply was, I admit, I was thinking of John when I said it all.
0:07:10I mean, I did.
0:07:11Do other people not have a little, like, imagine John Gruber audience on their shoulder?
0:07:16I mean, maybe.
0:07:17And there's people out there listening.
0:07:19And I'm sure there's some of them are still listening.
0:07:21Maybe.
0:07:23No baseball yet.
0:07:24So that's good.
0:07:25No, no baseball yet.
0:07:27I've gotten a little bit of, a little bit, not a lot, much more in my email friend and like Mastodon reader feedback of, keep Adam, this sucks.
0:07:39But a little bit of, hey, come on, what's the big deal?
0:07:42I upgraded.
0:07:43Yeah, some of this stuff is ugly.
0:07:44The corner radiuses.
0:07:46I'm a radiuses man, not a radii, but use your preferred plural.
0:07:50Not everything needs to be Latin.
0:07:50Exactly.
0:07:51I'm anti-Latin.
0:07:53So octopuses, not octopi.
0:07:56I mean, it's a mess.
0:07:56I can simultaneously defend the usability or the functionality in Tahoe and say that there's, I think there's no denying that it's a mess design-wise.
0:08:05Like, when that blog post about the corner radius resizing a window at the corner came out, I thought, I mean, I felt like I had been gaslit up to then.
0:08:13Yes.
0:08:13Because I was like, why is my mouse not working?
0:08:15And then they're like, oh, it's because they broke the resize tool.
0:08:18Oh, okay.
0:08:19And because it works sometimes, because you just throw your mouse towards the corner and you click and you resize, and then sometimes you don't, and you think, what is going on?
0:08:28And then you slow down a little, and you're like, what?
0:08:31Yeah.
0:08:32The funny part about that, too, and Adam Engst and I talked about it on the previous episode of the show, that Norbert Heger, who sort of wrote the definitive two blog posts about the corner resizing, wrote, took the time.
0:08:46Now, speaking of LaunchBar, he's actually one of the developers of LaunchBar, or I don't know what his title is, but it might be the lead developer over at Objective Development.
0:08:55But because he's a developer, of course, wrote a utility to move the mouse cursor automatically, presumably using accessibility APIs, one pixel at a time, to map out the hotspot of where you can resize this.
0:09:13And Apple, obviously in response to the public catching on to this, hey, the corner resizing in Tahoe is clearly off in 26.2, addressed it in the 26.3 betas, all the way up to the release candidate, the RC, which is supposedly, hey, if we don't find anything deal-breaking, this is going to be the official release.
0:09:40And they remapped it and made, instead of making it a stupid little square that's mostly off the window edge, they kind of made a round rect-shaped region around the corner, which is what is kind of necessary.
0:09:56If you're going to make these comically large kindergartner-sized corner radiuses, you kind of need something like this.
0:10:06It was in the release candidate, and then when the final version came out, Norbert ran his utility again, and they went back to the dumb little square that's mostly off the side.
0:10:16I guess that was a deal-breaker.
0:10:17I think it's obviously the case that there must be one or more major third-party apps that have stuff, UI elements, in the corners.
0:10:28Maybe even Apple's own apps.
0:10:30Who knows what they are?
0:10:31They're not going to – Apple's not going to say.
0:10:32But they clearly, in the release candidate, discovered that there are some Mac apps out there that put things in the corner that now the little things in the apps in the corner were overlapping with the resize zones.
0:10:44And they're like, oh, maybe we – and again, maybe, just maybe, rectangular – overall rectangular windows should have – if the corners aren't actually sharp, crisp, cornered rectangles, if they are round recs, and as Steve Jobs said 40 years ago, round recs are everywhere, they should be gently rounded.
0:11:09Yeah, there's no doubt.
0:11:10Yeah, there's no doubt.
0:11:10I mean, they made some mistakes there, right?
0:11:14And then they tried to rectify them and realized that there were more mistakes.
0:11:17I like that they tried to rectify them.
0:11:19I mean, that's good.
0:11:20At least somebody's looking –
0:11:22I'll pace my wins when I get them.
0:11:23So even though it didn't ship in 26.3 final, it was really – it is – and again, you speak as fluent Cupertino-ese as I do.
0:11:32That's Cupertino-ese for, okay, okay, we're listening, we're aware of this.
0:11:37I'll go all the way back.
0:11:40I will go all the way back here to the name Liquid Glass and the most obvious aspect of it across all the platforms and the emphasis Apple put on it at its introduction back at WDC, which is that it looks like liquid glass, right?
0:12:00It does, and there's an increased emphasis on transparency and translucency and the liquid, liquidity.
0:12:10Moves like a liquid, reflects like a liquid, all those things.
0:12:13And there are things that stretch that I can – and in some places on iOS where you can move them, I actually – it's like I'm finding more places where you can stretch things where it looks stupid that you can stretch them.
0:12:25It's a cool effect, but it looks dumb.
0:12:27But that's the thing that still gets the most complaints.
0:12:31It's the translucency and transparency in the places where things you can't read because of the translucency and transparency.
0:12:39Right.
0:12:40Yes, that's an issue, but that is the least of the things that are my complaints on Tahoe because you can fix that with the accessibility settings.
0:12:49And you've always been able to, as Apple has ying and yanged over what's translucent by how much for now, what, 24 years since Mac OS – the first version of Mac OS X?
0:13:04And, you know, they've – the idea that certain aspects of the interface will be translucent or transparent just to look cool has – now it's like about a quarter of a century old.
0:13:17In yings and yangs and ebbs and flows as years change and releases change, that's the least of the problems.
0:13:24It is – and I'll go back all the way to classic Mac OS when there was the abandoned – what was it called?
0:13:33Not the theme manager, the appearance manager in Mac OS 9.
0:13:37Maybe it shipped in Mac OS 8.5?
0:13:40Mm-hmm.
0:13:41Yeah, I guess it probably was around 8.5.
0:13:42Yeah, where you had all the different themes that you could theoretically apply.
0:13:45And the appearance manager's appearance, no pun intended, more or less coincided with Steve Jobs' return to Apple and the next reunification and Avi Tevanian taking over software development.
0:14:01And doing – for all – some of my disagreements over things like file name extensions and Mac OS X, but doing a very good job kind of – Mac OS 9 in the classic era was an outstanding release, Hall of Fame release of Macintosh system software.
0:14:16And obviously, they were kind of save the company heads down – literally, save the company heads down, we've got to make this new operating system that combines the best of Mac OS with the best of the next step operating system and get this out.
0:14:30And it didn't ship for five years or four years, depending on how you count.
0:14:34That was the main thing, but they did a good job keeping classic and kind of sharpening classic, if you will.
0:14:40But there was this thing called the appearance manager built into the operating system, which is – for somebody who wasn't around then, seems crazy for Apple to ship with the idea that you could have completely arbitrary skins like Winamp or all the various MP3 players from the heyday of third party.
0:15:00There was one that was like – you could make it look like a whimsical child's toy.
0:15:04Gizmo.
0:15:05With little spirals and stuff, yeah.
0:15:07Gizmo, yeah.
0:15:08And there was the one that looked like an architect paper that apparently only shipped as a developer beta in Japan.
0:15:13But, of course, we found all of these, and we were able to run them.
0:15:16And then Steve Jobs comes back and is, what are you guys doing?
0:15:20This is our job to decide what our operating system looks like.
0:15:24Get rid of them all.
0:15:25And the only things that shipped – there still was the control panel for appearance manager with themes.
0:15:32And the only themes were platinum with different accent colors based on the colors of the iMac, I guess, eventually.
0:15:40But if you consider that with totally different themes, and if you could still do that today, which you can't, the problems that I'm most concerned about in Tahoe, the ones that have me not upgrading, would still be there even if there was a way to apply a Sequoia theme.
0:15:59Or even, ideally, go back like 10 years to LCAP or one of those operating systems and apply the LCAP theme system-wide and just choose it.
0:16:11The other changes in Tahoe, the things like putting – which really gets me.
0:16:16The icons in the menu bar items really single-handedly is the single biggest reason I'm not upgrading.
0:16:22It just makes me so furious, and I find it – every time I sit here at my podcast station, which runs Tahoe, and I'm looking at them, like, right now, it makes my blood boil because it makes them so goddamn hard to read.
0:16:33There is a reason.
0:16:35I think I've mentioned this on previous shows.
0:16:37Like, when you go into a restaurant and you look at – what do you look at to order from?
0:16:42A menu.
0:16:43They don't put little icons representing the food next to the items.
0:16:48I bet some bad restaurant does.
0:16:50Yeah, there's probably some.
0:16:52Does the Cheesecake Factory do that, maybe?
0:16:53I don't know.
0:16:54They don't have enough icons.
0:16:55No, they would be the last one to do it.
0:16:57I mean, imagine how many icons.
0:16:58It would bankrupt the company to generate that many icons.
0:17:00But I like the idea, too, because you'd have very similar foods that would have very different icons just because they didn't want to reuse the icon, and they're inconsistent with, why is the pizza icon this over here and this over there?
0:17:10And I don't – yeah, I don't disagree.
0:17:12It's a mess, and it's a – this is why I keep saying it's a symptom.
0:17:16I mean, I – so back – oh, God, so long ago now.
0:17:20Back a very long time ago, I taught a class for a few years about web design at the Graduate School of Journalism.
0:17:28It wasn't really about web design, but it was like basically make a blog, make a website because it was one way – that was an era where students who want to be journalists, you could go into a newsroom and say, I understand the web.
0:17:39That was kind of the premise of it.
0:17:41But one of the things we hammered on was usability in web design.
0:17:44And I still think in terms of that to this day because – and I don't know.
0:17:49Do you remember Don't Make Me Think, the book by Steve Krug?
0:17:52Great book.
0:17:53I do.
0:17:53Yeah.
0:17:54And about interface design.
0:17:55And that's what I keep thinking of when you talk about like those icons.
0:17:58The icons are noise.
0:18:00I think there are people for whom the icons could theoretically be useful, but the way it's implemented is so poor and inconsistent, which I keep coming back to this concept of information architecture.
0:18:15It's why I spent so much time railing about the settings app is it's not organized in any logical way.
0:18:23It's – and you can organize – like those icons are color.
0:18:25The icons in the menu bar are just monochrome, but like the icons in settings are color, but the colors don't mean anything.
0:18:31And they're grouped together, but the groups don't mean anything.
0:18:34It's like – imagine if those icons in the menu bar in Tahoe had colors of various shades and there was only one menu.
0:18:45Yes, exactly.
0:18:46That's what the settings app is.
0:18:47Right.
0:18:48And it's just – and this is why I keep coming back to that this is a symptom.
0:18:52I'm sure you know this, talking to people at Apple, anytime people say, why doesn't Apple know that this is bad?
0:19:00Believe me, there are lots of people at Apple who know that it's bad.
0:19:04The problem is they're not being listened to.
0:19:08And to me, it all comes back to the fact that whoever is making decisions has decided that – and in this case, maybe it's Alan Dye and the people who loved Alan Dye who didn't want him to leave.
0:19:23But whoever it is in that system, there are people who are like, but what about the usability?
0:19:27And it feels very clear if you look at the last 10 years of Apple software that those people aren't being listened to.
0:19:34And look, it's a terrible task to be defending usability over something that's new because you're kind of like saying, I want to build this amazing building.
0:19:43And you're like, but it'll fall down.
0:19:44And they're like, we don't care.
0:19:45It's so amazing.
0:19:46Make it work.
0:19:47And I do get the sense that a lot of the people at Apple are just being told, make this thing work, even though it doesn't work.
0:19:52But that, to me, it just – I don't have any inside knowledge of this, but it sure feels like a fundamental cultural problem.
0:20:00And the culture isn't necessarily that there aren't people who care about usability.
0:20:03It's that those people's arguments haven't been allowed to carry the day.
0:20:08And you end up with these things that, like, there's no – somebody – information architecture.
0:20:15You look at the icons and you're like, somebody could do a project where they say, okay, we're going to put icons in the menu bar.
0:20:20What are the rules?
0:20:21When do they go in?
0:20:22When do they not go in?
0:20:23Are they all monochrome?
0:20:24Okay, great.
0:20:25What kinds of icons are used for what kinds of tasks?
0:20:28Let's build a book of what you use in certain ways and how you figure out which SF symbol to use if you're just using SF symbols.
0:20:36And we can also communicate that to developers.
0:20:39And I just don't get the sense that anything like that happened.
0:20:43Yeah, I think based on some discussions with people inside and outside Apple and thinking about it, I think one of the ways that this went off drifted away very slowly and where people like me and you are in a perfect position to sort of take a step back and say, yeah, because we were both using the platform and commenting on it in detail throughout this entire period.
0:21:12You really do have to go back to Steve Jobs and you really do have to go back to his irreplaceable role.
0:21:20I find myself recently referring to it over and over again.
0:21:24I got to put this in the show notes, but the joke cartoon from 20 years ago about Silicon Valley org charts and the one for Apple is just a circle with one dot in the middle, which is Steve Jobs.
0:21:36Do you remember this Silicon Valley org?
0:21:39Yeah, the joke org chart.
0:21:41Yeah.
0:21:41What is it like?
0:21:42Everybody's got a dotted line to Steve Jobs or?
0:21:44Yeah.
0:21:45And Amazon is just like this perfect bureaucracy.
0:21:48Google is like a university style mess.
0:21:52Facebook is bizarre.
0:21:55Microsoft is a bunch of sub organizations pointing guns at each other.
0:22:00Oracle has a giant legal arm and sort of a small engineering arm.
0:22:06But then Apple is just this sort of sphere around one dot in the middle.
0:22:10And it was kind of true.
0:22:12And Steve Jobs trusted his gut.
0:22:14Right.
0:22:15And Steve Jobs had wonderful taste in UI design.
0:22:18And it's like I said this with Adam angst in the previous episode that the principles of user interface design are a lot like the principles of grammar in writing.
0:22:34And I will say, I will admit as a writer, I have forgotten everything.
0:22:39I always, I've always written by ear.
0:22:42I just have.
0:22:43And because of that, I was absolutely terrible trying to learn Spanish as a second language.
0:22:48And I've forgotten.
0:22:49I took four years of it in high school.
0:22:50And pretty much can ask, donde esta el baño?
0:22:55Or something.
0:22:55I think that's.
0:22:57Where's the bathroom?
0:22:57Sure.
0:22:58Where's the bathroom?
0:22:59And dos hamburguesas y papas fritas, por favor.
0:23:03I would like two hamburgers and french fries, please.
0:23:06I can order some food.
0:23:08Amazing.
0:23:09And I can ask where the bathroom is.
0:23:11And that's about it.
0:23:12Because I don't.
0:23:14My brain, I just write and craft English by ear.
0:23:18But I know, I do, it's like I intuitively know the rules.
0:23:21And I think Steve Jobs was like that with user interface design.
0:23:25And as I pointed out when I was comparing and contrasting Alan Dye's introduction of Liquid Glass at WWDC with Steve Jobs' introduction of Aqua back in like 2001 at a Mac World, one of the Mac Worlds that was at the time held all around the world.
0:23:40And Steve Jobs was using words like key window and pointing out things like the key window, you could see that it has this prominence apart from the background windows.
0:23:50And Alan Dye's word salad introducing Liquid Glass didn't use any of those human-computer interaction terms.
0:23:57And the main thing people remember from that introduction was Steve Jobs saying, look at this, we wanted to make the buttons look lickable.
0:24:04And it was true.
0:24:05And he did.
0:24:06And they did.
0:24:07But also he knew these human-computer interaction principles like making the front window, the one that has input focus, visually prominent so that you can tell at a glance without having to think or look or just hunt for the red, yellow, green buttons.
0:24:22Or God, like the way that in previous versions of iPadOS before this year when you had split screen, you know, you really – it was really like where's Waldo trying to figure out which of the panels had input focus.
0:24:35Yep.
0:24:36Yep.
0:24:36Which is just wrong.
0:24:37It is as wrong as saying he don't go there no more.
0:24:41It's grammatically – as wrong as that grammar is was as wrong as that human interface design.
0:24:48Yet I think it was sort of like that the Alan Dye graphic designer school of interface design is, well, this looks better because fading things out if they don't have focus doesn't look cool.
0:25:02And it's like you've completely lost the purpose of what you're doing.
0:25:06Yeah.
0:25:06I do wonder because – and I will say Aqua, I mean, Aqua did have some legibility issues.
0:25:12It wasn't perfect.
0:25:13But I totally get what you're saying because, look, one of the consequences of Tim taking over from Steve is that Tim didn't have that sense, right?
0:25:23So, he has to rely on trusted lieutenants.
0:25:25And it's not a big leap to suggest the danger there is if you trust somebody, you shouldn't.
0:25:32And I think, like, that story that they were disappointed that Alan Dye got poached by Meta, which a lot of us are like, what?
0:25:43Why?
0:25:44I think they're used to him.
0:25:46They invested their trust in him.
0:25:48And this is one of those things where Tim Cook's not going to look at the designs that come out of Alan Dye's group and say, I'm worried about your lack of focus on usability.
0:25:57He's just not because he's been – he's the guy.
0:26:01And the CEO does not have that bone in his body.
0:26:04And so, it's going to be – so, that's the danger of investing all of your hope on somebody.
0:26:10They have to have all the taste because you don't have it.
0:26:13And he's the boss.
0:26:14So, if his lieutenants say, Alan, I don't like this.
0:26:16I don't like where we're going, Mayor.
0:26:17That never reaches Tim Cook, right?
0:26:19Because he's in charge and he's going to make those decisions.
0:26:22And, again, I'm reluctant to entirely personify it on Alan Dye.
0:26:26But, certainly, culturally, it feels like the stuff that came out – like, it's hard not to look at liquid glass and sometimes think, was this designed by designers who assumed that the technical proficiency of the coders at Apple would be so great that any legibility problems could be solved programmatically?
0:26:44You guys will fix that, right?
0:26:46You'll obscure things when they need to be and whatever.
0:26:48I do wonder about that sometimes.
0:26:49If it was like, did they solve the whole math problem or did they solve the best case and then say, well, our geniuses will figure out the rest of it?
0:26:57I don't know.
0:26:58But there's – something is missing in the flow there.
0:27:01It doesn't seem quite like they got the whole picture.
0:27:05Or maybe they didn't care.
0:27:06I mean, that's the alternative.
0:27:07Maybe they thought, look, all that matters is that it looks cool and usability is for suckers.
0:27:11It's possible.
0:27:12I think what happened is that during the jobs era, it could all flow through jobs and actually it was clearly more efficient that way.
0:27:20And I don't think there was – jobs was going to have it any other way.
0:27:22But what happened was the user interface designer stopped reporting up through software engineering, which is where they used to.
0:27:32That group used to report up through software engineering and it was treated as effectively another engineering discipline.
0:27:40So was that an effect of Johnny getting promoted?
0:27:43Is that what that –
0:27:44I think it was before that.
0:27:45I think it happened like when Aqua was designed.
0:27:49I think it happened like in 2000.
0:27:51They started reporting to Steve and not reporting up through software engineering.
0:27:57Which is okay when Steve's there.
0:27:58Right.
0:27:59And then even when Steve died, it was fine for a while because they could drift on the work that was already there.
0:28:09And I think a lot of those – going back through Stephen Hackett's excellent collection of Mac OS X screenshots at 512 pixels, you can see it up through right about the time Alan Dye got hired.
0:28:21And it's not dependent on him personally, but I think that part of Alan Dye getting hired also coincided with Johnny Ive.
0:28:28Who hired Alan Dye?
0:28:30Symptom.
0:28:30It's a symptom.
0:28:32But that's where Johnny Ive's attention was on shipping the watch, the Apple watch, and the architecture of Apple Park, which yada, yada, yada, five years later, he's out of Apple.
0:28:45I would also say – I mean, my CliffsNotes version of this is with Steve gone, Apple needed to invest visibility in people that would allow the markets and everybody else to trust that Apple still had talented people there, even with Steve gone.
0:29:01And so they gave Johnny a lot of responsibility and titles and things to reassure everybody that Apple was going to be okay.
0:29:08And I think in some ways it was the right decision at the time, but it inscribed a bunch of power into Johnny that maybe he didn't deserve in that moment, but he needed to have it because they needed to elevate him.
0:29:20And that meant more of his software thing.
0:29:22And to your point about, like, the watch and Apple Park and all of that, personal opinion, I think Johnny Ive was burned out on making gadgets and just wasn't that interested in it.
0:29:31And so it falls to his people to do that work while he's off looking at handrails for the Steve Jobs Theater, which is a beautiful – I mean, it's a beautiful piece of work.
0:29:39Don't get me wrong, but, like, it's not an iMac.
0:29:41And I think what should have been done when Steve left was instead of putting it under Johnny Ive as the whole discipline, just the graphic design and the style of the icons and the themes, like gizmo and platinum and whatever.
0:29:59The theme of the UI could have remained under Johnny's team, but that the overall structure, the blueprint, the wireframe of the UI and the principles of things like, hey, should every menu item have a little icon next to it or not, or is that a bad idea?
0:30:16Regardless of what the menus look like and how transparent they are or what the system font is or anything like that, just as a general principle, should have gone back to where it was before 2000 or the return of Steve Jobs and become a discipline – an engineering discipline under software engineering.
0:30:33With – and this is an important point – with the ability for them to have an equal weight in the arguments about what was right and wrong.
0:30:42Because you can have a whole group that is in that software group who cares about that stuff, but if they lose every argument to the designers, it doesn't matter.
0:30:49And I think that just stopped happening and that they lost that.
0:30:54And, you know, well, then how did Alan Dye get away with it?
0:30:57How did he succeed for so long?
0:30:59How was this a surprise to the senior leadership?
0:31:01And how was senior leadership thinking this was a terrible loss to the company?
0:31:06And I think it – you know, I heard this.
0:31:09I reported this out and heard this firsthand was that it's not that Alan Dye is or was unlikable.
0:31:15I've met him a few times.
0:31:16He's a fine fellow to have a chat with.
0:31:18You know, and the other thing, too, is people have written to me like, well, then how did cool things like the Dynamic Island ship under Alan Dye?
0:31:25Which they did.
0:31:26Entirely came out under Alan Dye.
0:31:28And it's a very cool feature that I've sung the praises of right from the first time I saw it.
0:31:32And I was lucky enough to run into Alan Dye and the team that designed it literally in the hands-on area after that iPhone event.
0:31:38So, like, ten minutes after we got out of the Steve Jobs Theater, I'm talking to Alan Dye about the Dynamic Island and congratulating him and his team because I was already in love with it.
0:31:48And how could some cool stuff ship under Alan Dye?
0:31:52Nobody, including me, perhaps his most public critic, nobody is saying that Apple's user interface design was a zero on a scale of zero to 100 under him.
0:32:03And there are super talented people still in the ranks of Apple's human interface designers.
0:32:10And hopefully, Stephen LeMay, the new head of user interface design, will exemplify that and sort of bring them back to the forefront.
0:32:18But they were there.
0:32:19And the people like that were clearly the ones driving the Dynamic Island.
0:32:24And the Dynamic Island has a very nice whiz-bang, looks-cool, we-could-feature-this-in-ads-and-keynotes aspect to it that pleases Alan Dye.
0:32:35And the other thing I heard from so many people within Apple was that as likable and as personable as Alan Dye could be, he was clearly, first and foremost, a political operator.
0:32:45And it kind of doesn't fly within Apple's rank-and-file culture.
0:32:49And, of course, there's politics in any company.
0:32:52And there's always been politics at Apple from when you and me were kids all the way through now.
0:32:58I mean, the politics were what got Steve Jobs exiled from the company in 1985.
0:33:02Every company has politics, and once you get to the size of a publicly-held corporation, of course there's politics.
0:33:09But I'm just saying that for a publicly-held corporation, Apple and the rank-and-file levels of designers and engineers, it's kind of frowned upon to be a political player.
0:33:20And by political player, what I mean is I think that Alan Dye is very adept at figuring out how to keep the people above him happy, how to keep Tim Cook happy, how to keep Craig Federighi happy, how to keep Jaws happy, how to keep Eddie Q happy.
0:33:36And you see that in the reports that they were taken aback by his departure.
0:33:40Although I do have a theory there, which is that one of the reasons you look around for another job is that there was some promotion that he thought he was going to get that he didn't get.
0:33:47Or who you're going to – with all the rumors about him retiring and all of that or becoming the chairman and all that, like I just – my spider sense went off.
0:33:55Just one of the things that happens when you're at a fairly high level is you start to have an expectation of who you're going to report to, who's going to report to you.
0:34:03And it's a huge part if you're a political operator especially, but it's a huge part of like what it represents.
0:34:09It's not just the money you get paid.
0:34:11If you've been reporting to Steve Jobs for a while and then Steve Jobs leaves and Tim Cook becomes the CEO, is it time to leave?
0:34:17Because you're going to have to build up a new rapport.
0:34:20And that was my spider sense kind of feeling about Alan Dye was that maybe he was looking for another opportunity, but I do wonder if not that they wanted him out, but that he felt he deserved more than maybe they were willing to give him.
0:34:33And so he started looking around.
0:34:34And there are reports, I think, oftentimes, and a lot of these guys, they truly do – it's why your site's named what it is.
0:34:42They bleed six colors.
0:34:43This is why Apple senior leadership is so steady and that people get in there and spend the rest of their careers there.
0:34:50And a guy like Phil Schiller, even after he retires as senior – or steps aside from the position of senior vice president of worldwide product marketing, whatever his full title was, is still running the App Store and running Apple's events.
0:35:05Right.
0:35:05It's not for the money.
0:35:08Phil Schiller does not need another year's salary in 2026.
0:35:12None of these guys need any more money.
0:35:14They are doing it because they like to.
0:35:16And there have been reports, especially it comes up with AI and AI researchers and the seemingly absurd sums of money that other companies are throwing at top researchers.
0:35:27There are reports, I think, again, oftentimes this all goes back to our friend Mark Gurman, that Meta had poached people from Apple and offered them $100 million or other companies $100 million bonuses to come and join the company.
0:35:42And that at Apple, that is like, no, we're not going to do that.
0:35:47Craig Federighi is like, I don't make that much money.
0:35:49Why in the world would we – you either want to work at Apple or you don't.
0:35:52And if you don't want to work here, you don't belong here.
0:35:55And I kind of feel like maybe part of it is that Alan Dye got an offer like that to go join Meta because Mark Zuckerberg thinks that.
0:36:03And then I'm hopeful – I don't even want to believe that you're right because I think to extrapolate on your theory that he kind of smelled which way the winds were blowing within Apple would mean, if the rumors are right and Ternus is the next CEO of the company, that maybe he knows that Ternus is not a fan of his work in UI design.
0:36:23It could be. It could also be as simple as that guy. I'm going to report to that guy.
0:36:27Or it could be something like, I want to be chief design officer like Johnny, and I want to control all of that stuff.
0:36:32And they're like, that's not going to happen, Alan.
0:36:34And I've seen that time and again where there are people who are valued a lot by the people they report to.
0:36:40But there's a mismatch.
0:36:41But you're right. It could also just be as simple as he's tired of playing those games at Apple and there's a big paycheck dangling somewhere else for more glory.
0:36:48I mean, everybody's motivated by different stuff.
0:36:50It's just sometimes it's surprising, I think, what motivates the people flip side of that is I have heard that, you know, Apple senior management initially was surprised that he left surprised that anybody in that position would leave to go to of all companies meta.
0:37:04Yeah, and sort of had a wow, we had that guy pegged wrong.
0:37:09And then after in the initial days or that first week where it was all a big surprise, they were also surprised to find out that other than the inner circle around him, who either all left with him for meta or also just left Apple, like Alan Dye's whole inner circle, like I would say up to about 10 people probably left with him or left Apple.
0:37:32But the rest of the designers at Apple, they were like partying that he was gone.
0:37:38And that took Apple senior leadership by surprise, too.
0:37:42And you can take it as a sign of dysfunction that they didn't know or that those people who are happy to see Alan Dye go couldn't get themselves heard and that the senior leadership had that wrong of a sense of the rest of the software designers at Apple.
0:37:57And I do think it is, to some degree, a sign of dysfunction, but that took them by surprise, too.
0:38:02But I think it hit home and they're like, oh, and to their credit over the years, all the way back to Steve Jobs, they they it's not that they never make mistakes.
0:38:13It's that Apple at its best recognizes when they've made a mistake and they correct it.
0:38:18And I think that we hopefully, knock on wood, are going to see that with software interface design.
0:38:24I really hope so.
0:38:25Again, it's not neither or.
0:38:27I just, you know, yeah, you want a healthy environment where all of that stuff gets considered properly and it doesn't feel like that that's been the environment there for a while.
0:38:36So, yeah, also maybe something about what a great political operator he is, but he's keeping everybody happy above them.
0:38:41They are never going to know that.
0:38:43And they don't know.
0:38:44And that it's therefore politically not.
0:38:46Yeah, exactly.
0:38:48That he was so successful as a political operator that he kept them happy and kept them from recognizing how unhappy the people under him were.
0:38:54And that explains why he was successful.
0:38:57Anyway, I'm going to take a break here and thank our first sponsor of the show.
0:39:01And it is our friends at Notion.
0:39:03Notion brings all your notes, docs, and projects into one connected space that just works.
0:39:08It's a seamless, flexible, powerful, and easy and actually fun to use system.
0:39:14With AI built right in, you spend less time switching between tools and more time creating great work.
0:39:19And now with Notion Custom Agents, you can do so much more.
0:39:24Let's just say Notion Custom Agents are effectively designed to attack busy work.
0:39:30So if your busy work just disappeared, what could you and your team accomplish?
0:39:35Find out with their new custom agents.
0:39:37Custom agents live directly inside Notion.
0:39:40That's where you make them.
0:39:41That's where they work.
0:39:42And that's where your team already has the knowledge that it needs.
0:39:45So things that used to take hours of busy work, you can set up custom agents that just handle themselves.
0:39:52Think of them like teammates with very specific jobs.
0:39:55One of them is examples are like a Q&A agent that acts like a help desk answering common questions instantly so that you're not repeating yourself all day or that the same questions don't keep popping up on your team's Slack.
0:40:09People can just ask within Notion.
0:40:11And if the answer to the question is in your team's Notion shared database, it'll just find the answer and ask it.
0:40:19Generating like status updates, like a weekly status update that different teams might need to compile.
0:40:25You can just have the agent do it automatically and it'll compile the update and send the status report automatically on the schedule you set so that the whole team stays up to date without endless follow-ups.
0:40:36And that you don't need to manually generate like a weekly status report.
0:40:41And you can, of course, build your own to suit your specific needs.
0:40:45I just read right before we started recording a fantastic post in the Mac Stories weekly newsletter where our friend Federico Vettici used Notion custom agents to build what he calls, I think I might be putting words into his mouth, but effectively the bookmark manager, the bookmark app of his dreams.
0:41:03It's a really good post and it really does get right to the heart of it where he just sends bookmarks into Notion and then the custom agent does all the work of categorizing them and like, oh, this is something about this.
0:41:15And does all the busy work of kind of organizing bookmarks in a slush pile automatically.
0:41:22So what you do, you just get identify patterns of busy work that your team does every week and then you create a custom agent.
0:41:29And it's different from other AI agents because it's all built into Notion.
0:41:34You don't need a whole pile of apps and then give your AI app access to Notion.
0:41:39It's all built in and they just work in the background automatically.
0:41:43Notion is used by over 50% of Fortune 500 companies and some of the fastest growing companies in the world like OpenAI, Ramp, and Vercel.
0:41:51They all use Notion and Notion AI to make their internal processes faster and help their teams stay ahead.
0:41:58Go to Notion.com slash talk show.
0:42:03Notion.com slash talk show.
0:42:06And they'll know you came from the show.
0:42:08You can try custom agents today.
0:42:11Notion.com slash talk show.
0:42:14So going back to the report card, we don't have to rehash everything because you and Mike do it on that Upgrade annual show.
0:42:21I forget this.
0:42:22Every single year I forget it.
0:42:23So now I just want to mention it.
0:42:25Maybe by me mentioning it on the show, it'll finally get into my head.
0:42:29You don't vote in the report card.
0:42:30I do not participate.
0:42:32I just compile it.
0:42:33My numbers are not in there and I don't even think of numbers until Mike makes me talk about it on Upgrade.
0:42:38Well, I couldn't hear you talking that much about the Mac one because my ear.
0:42:42Yeah, I know the red haze.
0:42:43Yes, yes.
0:42:44Was the bees in your head were buzzing so much that.
0:42:47And my eardrums were popping out.
0:42:49But for the rest of the categories, I could hear you thinking it through on the fly, which is amazing.
0:42:55Even if you did vote, there are, I think there were 56 voters this year, panelists this year.
0:43:01So your vote wouldn't sway the numbers that much, but it's an interesting philosophy.
0:43:05And I guess at this point, I'd like to be able to point at it and say, it's not me.
0:43:09I like the clarity of that because in the early days, especially people would see things that they didn't agree with.
0:43:15And they would write me angry emails.
0:43:16They're like, how dare you say this?
0:43:17I'm like, not me.
0:43:18Other people, not me.
0:43:20I get to deny.
0:43:22It's deniability, John.
0:43:23That's what I'm going for.
0:43:24Deniability.
0:43:24Yeah, but you do collect the quotes.
0:43:27It's true.
0:43:28I do.
0:43:29I do select the quotes.
0:43:31And that's an interesting task.
0:43:33I now have an editorial assistant who tees up a bunch of good quotes for me.
0:43:38That's Claude.
0:43:39Because the worst thing in the world is looking, trying to do like the first couple of years,
0:43:45I did like a Scott guide style thing where it was little quotes here and there.
0:43:47And it's just, it's so much work.
0:43:49It makes it untenable.
0:43:50So now I have an AI analysis where it pulls out like a load of possible quotes.
0:43:56And then I end up throwing half of them away, moving a bunch of them around, pulling ones
0:44:03out that are in the original that I felt weren't being reflected.
0:44:06It saves me some time though.
0:44:07And then, you know, yes, because it's AI, I also make sure that everything is verbatim,
0:44:12which it was.
0:44:13To the credit of the AI, when I said, do not invent anything, only direct quotes, following
0:44:18journalistic practice, it actually did it this time.
0:44:20But still, I had moments where everybody's praising Apple's hardware and three separate
0:44:25people made the same joke.
0:44:26And I made sure to get all those in there and line them all up about how whoever's in charge
0:44:30of hardware might need to be the next CEO.
0:44:34So yeah, yeah, there's a lot.
0:44:36There's 32,000 words.
0:44:37Christina Warren always writes the most of anybody because she used to be a tech blogger
0:44:41and now she's not.
0:44:42And so I think she feels like this is her time to shine.
0:44:44Although she did just have surgery and she left me a note at the end of her thing that
0:44:48said, I did this all high on painkillers.
0:44:51It's okay.
0:44:52Fair enough.
0:44:53But it's still good stuff.
0:44:54So I read it.
0:44:56I forgot the thing about painkillers, but I left the rest of it.
0:44:59I should get her on the show soon while she's still on them.
0:45:03It might be fun.
0:45:05Yeah, she had a spinal surgery or something.
0:45:07So it was definitely pretty serious, but she didn't stop her from writing like several
0:45:10thousand words just on her own.
0:45:12It's a very fun disclaimer.
0:45:14I thought I read it from top to bottom.
0:45:17So I got to the end after seeing like Christina's writing thousands of words again and I get to
0:45:21the end and she says, hi, Jason.
0:45:22I did this on painkillers.
0:45:24Okay.
0:45:24Well, explanation accepted.
0:45:27I thought one of the interesting meta commentaries from the upgrade episode
0:45:33was on the renamed.
0:45:36I actually, I just realized I need to rename my own subcategory on my own published report
0:45:41card.
0:45:41It used to be called social and societal impact.
0:45:44Right.
0:45:44Now it's just called Apple's impact on the world.
0:45:47I guess impact on the world.
0:45:49Yeah.
0:45:49Whatever you want to.
0:45:50Yeah.
0:45:50Yeah.
0:45:51It's the grab bag that is based on Apple always says they want to leave the world a better
0:45:55place than they found it.
0:45:56And they've got these various initiatives.
0:45:57And when I started doing this in 2014 or whatever, the idea was how they doing based on everybody's
0:46:05own interpretation of that, how are they living up to the stuff that they say?
0:46:08Because we all know it's a giant corporation owned by, it's a public corporation.
0:46:12Shareholders care about the stock price.
0:46:14It's there to make money.
0:46:15But they also do talk about these other aspects of what they believe in and how they want to
0:46:20leave the world a better place, et cetera, et cetera.
0:46:22And I thought it was only fair to have a category where people could say, how do they live up to
0:46:27that?
0:46:27Now, I admit I didn't really expect it going quite where it's gone the last few years, but
0:46:31that was always the intent with that category.
0:46:33And Brent got me going to force me to.
0:46:39And I'm not afraid to write.
0:46:40As anybody who reads the site knows, I'm not afraid to wade into the Trump 2.0 administration
0:46:46politics and Tim Cook's role in it and the way he's dragging Apple into it with things
0:46:52like the goddamn 24 karat gold trophy with an Apple logo on it.
0:46:57Yep.
0:46:57So, you know, which is compare and contrast with Tim Cook personally paying a million dollars
0:47:02to get a good seat at the inauguration or whatever the hell that racket was, as opposed to Apple
0:47:09paying a million dollars, donating, I'm sorry, donating a million dollars to the inauguration
0:47:16committee.
0:47:16But once you're giving trophies out with the Apple logo on, you are clearly bringing the company
0:47:21the company into it.
0:47:22And the panel did not like Apple's impact on the world this year.
0:47:27It did not.
0:47:27That's a straight up F.
0:47:29It was a straight up F.
0:47:31And but I thought it was really interesting.
0:47:33And I think it's probably true that what you say on the show with Mike, that the vibe in
0:47:38the room, the sort of just read the room.
0:47:41And yeah, yeah, because that's the goal of the whole thing is I don't think anybody who's
0:47:45following what people are writing and saying about Apple should be surprised by anything
0:47:48in the report card.
0:47:49Because what it's reflecting is those feelings that you all felt during the year.
0:47:52It is like to put a number to whatever that vibe was that we were feeling.
0:47:57And definitely the vibes were bad about that.
0:47:59And I do wonder how they were reflected in other scores.
0:48:04I don't know that for certain.
0:48:06Although I know a friend of the show, Kieran Healy, the sociology professor, is doing, he
0:48:12does for every year.
0:48:13He just takes my numbers and does some analysis and make some fun charts.
0:48:16And I know he was interested in looking into that actually directly about does the sentiment
0:48:21about the world impact, is that something that sort of drives other scores down too?
0:48:25Because people are just grumpy.
0:48:27They're just grumpy about Apple right now.
0:48:28And I think there's some truth to that.
0:48:30But I haven't looked at Kieran's numbers to find out what he says.
0:48:32Yeah, Kieran is both a talented data scientist and a very talented author.
0:48:36I've read, I don't have the titles off the top of my head, but I've read at least two of
0:48:41his books and they're excellent, excellent.
0:48:43Just a great writer.
0:48:43Data visualization and the Ordinal Society, yeah, too.
0:48:46Excellent.
0:48:46Data visualization is truly excellent.
0:48:48He's a professor at Duke.
0:48:49I know.
0:48:50I try not to hold that against him.
0:48:51I know.
0:48:52Same.
0:48:52It's the Stanford of the Carolinas.
0:48:54Yeah.
0:48:55I mean that pejoratively.
0:48:58You don't have to be a world-leading data visualization scientist like Kieran.
0:49:05And I mean that sincerely.
0:49:06He really is.
0:49:07To just sort of think, oh, yeah, it would be interesting to take the people who gave Apple
0:49:13particularly low scores on Impact on the World and the people who didn't amongst the panelists
0:49:19and see, oh, amongst the people who gave them a grade of this or above, I don't know where
0:49:24the line would be.
0:49:25Let's say three, three and above.
0:49:27Did they grade everything else a bit higher than the people who gave them a two or a one?
0:49:32And one, not zero, is the lowest score you can give on the report card.
0:49:36Yeah, that would be really interesting.
0:49:38And I would bet money that, yes, that the people who gave Apple a low score, that this one category
0:49:44informs more than any other category how they graded all the other categories.
0:49:49And I ran into this, and I think, yeah, no surprise, Groob's, there were some teachers
0:49:55growing up who really liked me, and there were other teachers who did not.
0:50:00So as a child, you were a polarizing figure is what you're saying.
0:50:04I was a very polarizing figure.
0:50:06And I know what it's like to have a teacher who does not like me, and you don't get any
0:50:13slack on the grading, none.
0:50:15I know, and it is exactly that sentiment.
0:50:18And they don't, not that they took points off unfairly, or unjustifiably, it's a better
0:50:26word than unfairly, unjustifiably.
0:50:29They could find justifications for why this was wrong, or I got a full point off as opposed
0:50:36to a half point off, or whatever.
0:50:38But I wasn't going to get any slack, because I was being a jackass to this teacher.
0:50:44Yeah, when there's an art to it, you're like, why would I give the benefit of the doubt?
0:50:48And yes, I think that there is, it's a small sample, who knows?
0:50:51But I think Kieran would probably agree, having looked at his report a little bit, that yes,
0:50:56people who gave really bad world impact scores tended to give other lower scores.
0:51:01That doesn't necessarily mean maybe they're just grumpy people.
0:51:03That's also true.
0:51:04I don't give any guidance for how to score.
0:51:06Like, somebody could do all fives and fours.
0:51:08Somebody could do all ones and twos.
0:51:09Like, I don't tell them, this is what a three means.
0:51:12It's literally rated from one worst to five best, and that's it.
0:51:15And then we go from there.
0:51:17But certainly, the vibes were bad.
0:51:20And even, I would say, I think some of the panel's comments were interesting in that there
0:51:27is nuance here, right?
0:51:29There's nuance about the motivation, like, to try and prevent tariffs from killing your sales
0:51:36figures and your profits and all of that.
0:51:37Some people were like, I get why you would do this.
0:51:40I had several people, like John Syracuse, I think, just went to the fundamental, what's
0:51:44the point of having FU money if you never say FU?
0:51:46That's really good.
0:51:47And then what I keep thinking is, I keep coming back to the reason that category exists, which
0:51:53is that Apple has always tried to, like, use.
0:51:56I don't mean this, that it was empty PR.
0:51:58It's PR that serves the company's image.
0:52:01I do believe there's also corporate culture that supports it.
0:52:04This idea that we want to make the world a better place, and we want to leave things better,
0:52:09and that the environmental stuff matters, and that all of this stuff is like, we do believe
0:52:13stuff, plus we want to make a lot of money.
0:52:15And that's, I think, a nuance of what happened in this last year, which is, and this is how
0:52:22I feel, certainly, is we, leaving aside the mechanics of the rest of it, really hard for
0:52:28Tim Cook to post a thing about Martin Luther King, or a tragedy that happened somewhere in
0:52:33the world, where you could be like, ah, see, Apple, it's not just about selling computers,
0:52:37it's also about this other stuff.
0:52:38And I think, for a lot of people, that aspect of Apple just got stripped away in 2025.
0:52:44It's like, don't even try that stuff anymore.
0:52:46Your impact on the world is obviously to make as much money as possible, sell as many phones
0:52:51as possible.
0:52:51Why are we pretending that it's otherwise?
0:52:53We've got a lot of that this year.
0:52:55Yeah.
0:52:55And as a side note, I noticed, because Apple did, as they, I think, have done for at least
0:53:01over a decade, probably much longer than a decade, on Martin Luther King Jr. Day this year, dedicate
0:53:07the homepage of apple.com, the front page of apple.com to Dr. King.
0:53:13They did it again.
0:53:14And I think that if Tim Cook and Apple had played year one of the second Trump administration,
0:53:21administration differently, that there would have been more people saying, hey, and look,
0:53:27Apple is still doing this, too.
0:53:29I didn't see anybody give Apple any credit for the fact that they're still doing that, even
0:53:33though there are other companies.
0:53:34And I'll just throw meta under the bus who have explicitly changed their political stance
0:53:41explicitly once Trump was reelected to say, oh, yeah, I think Zuckerberg said something like,
0:53:46we need more masculine energy and all sorts of coded terms like that.
0:53:50Like, what the hell are you talking about?
0:53:51You know, but right there in line with Trump cracking a joke on the phone to the U.S.
0:53:57men's hockey team for winning a gold medal that you guys know.
0:54:00He said something like, you guys know now I got to invite the women's team, too, because I'd get impeached if I didn't.
0:54:05Which it's like, hey, I'm really happy and I got really into the Winter Olympics this year and I watched the men beat Canada in the gold medal game and I was very excited.
0:54:14But that's the first time the men have won the gold medal since 1980 and the women win the gold medal every frigging year and are one of the biggest juggernauts in international sports.
0:54:26Like the U.S. women's ice hockey team is so much better than the U.S. men's ice hockey team as an institution.
0:54:34It's not even funny, let alone even if they'd only won on the same pace as the men, like once every 46 years.
0:54:41How insulting a comment that is.
0:54:44And that's exactly where Zuckerberg explicitly went at meta with this company needs more masculine energy.
0:54:50And Apple and Tim Cook aren't saying any nonsense like that.
0:54:53And they're still doing things like dedicating the homepage to Martin Luther King on Martin Luther King Day.
0:54:58And they haven't changed any of their H.R. policies surrounding lowercase diversity, equity and inclusion within the company.
0:55:08And they've always had weird terms.
0:55:10They call it like I think Deirdre O'Brien's title is director of people or something like that instead of H.R.
0:55:17And they've always had weird terms that aren't like D.E.I. explicitly in capital letters, but that they still had they didn't change anything.
0:55:24They also recast a bunch.
0:55:26So some a couple of people mentioned this, that there is.
0:55:28I mean, look, I think it's very clear that they've decided that if they keep quiet about it,
0:55:33maybe it won't become a thing where Trump will freak out and they'll have to change it in some way because he's demanded that they do it.
0:55:40They like they just or they change the terms.
0:55:42I think the Detroit engineering and manufacturing thing that they've got, like in a different era,
0:55:49they would talk about the diversity of the people of Detroit.
0:55:53Right.
0:55:53But instead, they cast it in this era as American manufacturing and the power of the automotive and legacy in Detroit and all of that.
0:56:01But it's that's nice and all.
0:56:03But like in the end, it's all coded and they've made the decision to go along and not stand up.
0:56:10And we could argue maybe that that was a good business decision or not.
0:56:14I think it's arguable because you give and they just ask for more.
0:56:19But I think it's I think it does eliminate the possibility that you can say, oh, we're different.
0:56:25We're better.
0:56:26We care about bigger ideals.
0:56:27That seems to be like, come on.
0:56:30I don't think I am not one of those people who believes that they like it.
0:56:33I think they've just decided that in terms of being executives at a public corporation, they this is what they have to do.
0:56:40And my personal theory is that after Trump spent all that time complaining that Tim Apple wasn't on the plane with him to Saudi Arabia.
0:56:46Right.
0:56:47Which I think Cook specifically was like, I'm not going to go to Saudi Arabia.
0:56:50That's too far.
0:56:52And Trump complained and complained that Tim didn't show up.
0:56:55And obviously, somebody at Apple, including Tim Cook, were like, OK, we're just going to say yes to anything he asks now.
0:57:00And that's on them.
0:57:01You mean too far, too far by miles or too far figuratively?
0:57:05No, I think Cook didn't want to go because of MBS and the murder of Jamal Khashoggi and all of that.
0:57:12I thought that was like a bridge too far and that you don't really need the CEO of Apple to take a tour around Saudi Arabia.
0:57:19So we'll just beg off of that.
0:57:20And I think they got hammered and they decided we're never doing that again.
0:57:24And that's why Tim Cook shows up at every single thing he's invited to now.
0:57:28And again, I'm not saying I agree, but I'm saying I suspect that's what happened is that they took a little step out of line and were beaten on it until they got back in line.
0:57:38And that's where we are as a country right now, unfortunately.
0:57:41Yeah.
0:57:41And next thing you know, he's showing up at the premiere of Melania's propaganda documentary, even though it's not on Apple TV.
0:57:48It's on Amazon.
0:57:49On the day that federal troops murdered a guy on the streets of Minneapolis.
0:57:53Boy, if ever there was a time for you to say, ooh, the clams, they didn't agree with me.
0:57:57I got to go.
0:57:58I feel ill.
0:57:58That was the day for it.
0:58:00And he didn't do that.
0:58:01Yeah, something came up and I'm not feeling well.
0:58:03And I'm already on my private...
0:58:05Yeah, some bad dates.
0:58:05Already on...
0:58:06Yes, bad dates.
0:58:07I'm already on my plane.
0:58:11I'm in the can on my private jet flying back to Cupertino.
0:58:14I didn't want to get the carpets filthy at the White House, so I...
0:58:19I had to fly back.
0:58:21Appeal to Trump's germophobia.
0:58:24That's right.
0:58:25You don't want what I got.
0:58:27Yeah, you don't want what I got.
0:58:28Bad dates.
0:58:30All right, let me take a break here and thank our next sponsor.
0:58:34And it is our good friends at Sentry.
0:58:38S-E-N-T-R-Y.
0:58:42Not Sentry like 100 years, but Sentry...
0:58:44Like a guard.
0:58:46Sentry is a developer tool.
0:58:48You integrate it with your app, iOS in particular.
0:58:51And it doesn't just catch errors.
0:58:53It catches all of the stuff that makes your app feel broken.
0:58:56The random slowdowns, freezes that you can't reproduce, but that your users are reporting.
0:59:01The sort of bugs that only show up once they hit real users.
0:59:06When something goes wrong, Sentry gives you the whole chain of events in one place.
0:59:12Errors, traces, replays, logs actually connected so that you can see what led to the issue without digging through five different dashboards to get there.
0:59:21And that's what SEER, S-E-E-R, Sentry's AI debugging agent, builds on.
0:59:26It takes that full context, explains why the issue happened, points to the code responsible, even drafts a fix, and flags if your PR is about to introduce a new problem.
0:59:36So the workflow stays simple.
0:59:38Something breaks, then Sentry shows you the full context, and then SEER helps you fix it and catch new issues before they ship.
0:59:45Sentry is used by millions of developers behind some of the biggest apps in the world like Claude, Disney+, and Duolingo.
0:59:52Sentry supports over 100 plus languages and frameworks across front-end, back-end, and mobile.
0:59:59For example, try it free at S-E-N-T-R-Y, Sentry.io slash talk show.
1:00:07Sentry.io slash talk show.
1:00:11And that, by just going to that link, it'll tell them you came from the show.
1:00:15And by going to that link, they have a free developer plan, and listeners of the show going to Sentry.io slash talk show can use that code talk show to get 80 bucks in Sentry credits.
1:00:2880 bucks in Sentry credits, just for following that link.
1:00:30My thanks to Sentry for sponsoring the show.
1:00:34All right, you mentioned earlier some of the functional reasons to like Tahoe, and part of it, though, and part of what I keep saying, why I'm happy staying on Sequoia for the year and just waiting it out, is that while I like all of those, and maybe the triggers for automation, maybe that's where I'm missing out.
1:00:55But like the improved Spotlight and the clipboard history, part of the reason that it's like, yeah, if I only relied on the system for that, ooh, that would give me like the itch.
1:01:05Maybe I can put up with those goddamn icons in the menu bar.
1:01:07But I've had a clipboard history for like 20 years.
1:01:11Of course.
1:01:11And I've had a better Spotlight launcher for 20 years.
1:01:16I used to use Quicksilver back in the day when it first came out.
1:01:20Remember Quicksilver?
1:01:20I do.
1:01:21And there's a guy, I guess I'll put it in the show notes.
1:01:23I forget his name.
1:01:24Oh, yeah, they're doing like a rethink of inspired by Quicksilver.
1:01:27I always preferred LaunchBar.
1:01:28The Quicksilver people always were really mad because I always liked LaunchBar better than Quicksilver.
1:01:32It's called Tuna.
1:01:34I'll put a link.
1:01:35I swear to God, put a link in the show notes to Tuna.
1:01:37But when I, like when Quicksilver sort of withered on the vine and I looked around for a replacement and I switched to LaunchBar, my thought was, ah, this is good enough replacement.
1:01:47My thought was, ah, crap.
1:01:49I should have been using this one all along.
1:01:51This one's better.
1:01:52So I've been using LaunchBar ever since.
1:01:54I was going to ask you, what are you using?
1:01:56But you've switched to the system.
1:01:58So, yeah, I mean, LaunchBar, I do wonder about the trajectory of LaunchBar.
1:02:02It feels like its development has really slowed.
1:02:06I see other launchers doing things that I'm not sure LaunchBar really is built to do or wants to do.
1:02:12But my purpose in dropping it originally was just to live with, when I was preparing my review of Tahoe over the summer, just to see if I could live with Spotlight.
1:02:25And the funny story about a lot of Mac OS X features is we had a lot of great third-party utilities in the early days of Mac OS X to extend the system because it was a brand new operating system.
1:02:35They were lucky to get Spotlight or Search to work at all, let alone work in the way that you wanted.
1:02:41It wasn't really a launcher.
1:02:42What happened is when all of us started using third-party apps is all that stuff in the background got better and we just never saw it because we never used it because we had switched.
1:02:53And, like, Spotlight got to be a much better app launcher than it ever was.
1:02:57And it has progressed over time.
1:02:59And I figured, okay, if I'm going to review this operating system, what I don't want is a blind spot, which is these apps I use to cover up the holes in the operating system.
1:03:07So when they did a new Spotlight, I was like, all right, I'm going to quit LaunchBar.
1:03:10I'm just going to use Spotlight.
1:03:12And I use LaunchBar as my clipboard manager.
1:03:14So I was like, okay.
1:03:16And they've got a clipboard manager, which when I went through the process of thinking what's left that Apple has not put into the core OS that really should be there,
1:03:26clipboard manager is the one that I came to.
1:03:28That is a feature that is fundamental, useful for productivity, will change your life.
1:03:34It's like when they put layers in Photoshop.
1:03:36It's like, wait, I can have multiple things and they don't disappear when the marching ants go away.
1:03:41I can still get back to them having undo as a thing that you could do for the clipboard.
1:03:46It's huge.
1:03:47So they did that.
1:03:48And I thought, I'll live with it.
1:03:49And what I found is, other than the fact that I had to do a macro in Keyboard Maestro to bind to a single keystroke,
1:03:56keystroke for clipboard history, because they want you to hit command space and then command four, which, why can't I just hit, assign a keystroke to that?
1:04:06So I assigned command backslash, which is the LaunchBar keystroke.
1:04:09When I hit that, Keyboard Maestro does command space, command four for me.
1:04:12And I used it.
1:04:13And I kept waiting to go back.
1:04:15And I never did.
1:04:17I mean, that's the one feature that I miss.
1:04:20The thing I miss the most from LaunchBar is you used to be able to call up an app and then drag a file onto it.
1:04:26And you can't do that in Spotlight.
1:04:27And I hate that because that was really good sometimes when you had a file that wouldn't double click open in that app.
1:04:32But you could bring up the app in LaunchBar and then just drag it in and it opened.
1:04:35I miss that feature.
1:04:37But otherwise, it's good.
1:04:39And again, I know I could go back, but I've been having some issues with LaunchBar where it was bogging down.
1:04:45Sometimes it wouldn't be responsive or it would get caught in a loop indexing my hard drive.
1:04:50And I would report those to objective development, but there never seemed to be a solution.
1:04:56And I thought, well, if this is working, why don't I just stay with it?
1:05:00And third-party apps that extend the system are great.
1:05:03Hazel is another great example.
1:05:05Hazel is a great app that does a lot of automations that act on when things change on your Mac.
1:05:10But isn't it nice that the system now, it's sort of like folder actions back in the day, but they've done a modern version of it.
1:05:16You can say if this file changes, if an item gets added to a folder, an item gets edited in a folder, all of these different things,
1:05:24plus the sort of ones that are on iOS in terms of launching a shortcut,
1:05:28you can kick into an automation automatically and have it be just built into the system.
1:05:32That's great.
1:05:34So on one level, I'm just trying to think, is a third-party app really required here?
1:05:40Third-party apps are great, but I am a firm believer that there's some functionality that should probably be in the system
1:05:46and that Apple should not just say, we never need to build a clipboard manager because those in the know will buy one.
1:05:52It's like a clipboard manager is so useful.
1:05:54If you have a friend who just has a stock Mac running Tahoe and they're like, oh no, I copied something over this super important text that I had in the clipboard and I can never get it back,
1:06:03you can say, command space, command four, and it's there.
1:06:07That is so good.
1:06:08It needs to be in there.
1:06:10So I did have some issues with LaunchBar.
1:06:12I would go back to it if I felt like I really needed it, but I am living that part of it, which is Spotlight has gotten a lot better since the last time I took it seriously,
1:06:22which was admittedly like 10 years ago.
1:06:25I think they have been incrementally improving it, but this is a big update and I don't agree with everything.
1:06:30They took some shots with like actions and stuff that I think were all there for app intents that didn't ship.
1:06:36Yes, I think so too.
1:06:38Right.
1:06:38I think they got out over their skis on that one.
1:06:41Yeah, a little bit.
1:06:41You can see the signs of the things they thought would be there that aren't there, but like, it's pretty good.
1:06:45And again, is that enough?
1:06:47I have an uploader.
1:06:48This is on Mac and iPad for images that I'm putting in six colors.
1:06:53And on the Mac, I literally just drag the image into BBEdit and it runs, it's a classic Apple script thing.
1:06:58It's an attachment script.
1:07:00So you can basically attach a script to an action in an app if it's a super Mac app like BBEdit.
1:07:07And it's a shortcut that I can run on the iPad as well.
1:07:10And it uploads, I've had it for ages.
1:07:12It resizes my image to the right specs for six colors, uploads it, gets the, using an API in WordPress, gets the URL back.
1:07:21And in BBEdit, it inserts the HTML that includes that image.
1:07:26Well, in Tahoe, it goes to private cloud compute.
1:07:30It resizes a small version of that image.
1:07:32It's not even the full size version, a smaller image.
1:07:35Puts it in private cloud compute and says, write alt text for this.
1:07:38Puts the alt text in the HTML.
1:07:40And it's, you know, I edit it sometimes, but it's so good that I've got a computer to basically like, write your descriptive text here.
1:07:47Because I want to have descriptive text, but I don't, I really don't want to write it myself all the time.
1:07:52Because it's just more work when I'm ready to post the story.
1:07:55If I'm posting, if I'm putting the image in the story, I'm done.
1:07:58I am trying to get that story up.
1:07:59And on the iPad, it doesn't just do that.
1:08:02On the iPad, because file names there, if I've taken a screenshot, it's just a weird series of numbers from photos.
1:08:09It actually asks private cloud compute, give this a name, give this a file name that's human readable, that explains something about what it is.
1:08:16And those file names are really good too.
1:08:19So like, that's a feature of Tahoe and the 26 OSs.
1:08:22And I know we make jokes about Apple's AI models for lots of good reasons.
1:08:26But like, the fact that they took their cloud model, which is not available to third party developers.
1:08:30And if you write a shortcut, you just get it.
1:08:34And you can use it basically.
1:08:35I mean, Steve Tratton-Smith, I think, found that after a while, they will say you can't use it anymore today.
1:08:41And of course he did.
1:08:42In reasonable use, which I think I'm doing, it works really well.
1:08:47I wish their on-device model took images, but it doesn't.
1:08:51So I have to use the cloud model.
1:08:52But like, that's a really cool feature that right now it feels like only people using shortcuts get it.
1:08:57And like, shortcuts, look, again, that's really great.
1:09:01Then Dan Morin and I were talking today about how he, occasionally he gets, and I get too,
1:09:05private cloud compute errors, where it's just, I can't do it right now.
1:09:08And I said to Dan, well, the good news is you can just put in an error handler and shortcuts.
1:09:13Shortcuts doesn't know about how to do errors.
1:09:17It just stops.
1:09:17And that's the end of it.
1:09:18So like, it gives with one hand and takes away with the other.
1:09:21But like, it's pretty cool stuff in there.
1:09:22And often just fails silently.
1:09:23Yeah, absolutely.
1:09:25But that's cool stuff.
1:09:27And that's why I got so excited about functionality in Tahoe.
1:09:30Because as a Mac user, I mean, we went through that period where the only new features that got added to the Mac were features that were brought over from iOS, usually a year late.
1:09:39Right.
1:09:40And that's gotten more in sync now that they've got the code bases in sync and they can do Catalyst-ish stuff or Swift UI stuff.
1:09:48They can get that stuff to be more aligned.
1:09:50But it feels like it's been a long time.
1:09:53Then somebody at Apple was like, could we do some things for Mac users to make things better?
1:09:58And they did.
1:09:58So like, that's my positivity about Tahoe.
1:10:01They didn't have to do that.
1:10:03They've spent the last decade kind of not caring about a lot of this stuff.
1:10:06And I love that they added some of those features, including some Mac features.
1:10:10Like, Clipboard History, I really want that on the iPad and the iPhone.
1:10:14So badly.
1:10:15Like, maybe this means that'll come, but it's on the Mac now.
1:10:18That's great.
1:10:19And again, yeah, there are third-party apps that do it and that can hit the edge cases and do a better job.
1:10:22But like, that is, I mean, they should have done Clipboard History like 20 years ago.
1:10:27Who are we kidding?
1:10:28But they did it.
1:10:28They chose in 2025 to do it.
1:10:30So I'm glad that they did.
1:10:32The right time to do it was 20 years ago, and the next best time is this year's OS.
1:10:35It's this year.
1:10:36One of my favorite features in LaunchBar, and maybe there's a way.
1:10:39I would say the big three in third-party launchers.
1:10:41The longest standing and my favorite, the one I use is LaunchBar.
1:10:44And then there's Alfred, which I know a lot of people use.
1:10:47And then the newcomer, but it's not that new.
1:10:50And it's kind of maybe got the most momentum, and it's Raycast.
1:10:52Raycast, right.
1:10:53But the one thing that LaunchBar does, and maybe there's a way to do it.
1:10:57And Alfred and Raycast, and I've tried every once in a while.
1:11:00I just, that's a category of apps where every once in a while I'm like, well, let's see what this other command space launcher has going on right now.
1:11:07But one thing LaunchBar does is for apps that have files like BBEdit, and any app where you go to File, and there's an Open Recent menu, and it lists the recently opened files.
1:11:19In LaunchBar, if you type BBEdit to get BBEdit, there will be a right arrow thing in the list, and you can right arrow into BBEdit, and it shows you the recent files.
1:11:30So if you go to, or type OO, for me, that brings me to Omni Outliner.
1:11:35And I can go right arrow, and it lists all of my recent Omni Outliner files, just like the file Open Recent.
1:11:41So right there from my launcher, I can do it.
1:11:43The new Spotlight in Tahoe has that to it.
1:11:45Now, it's not right arrow, it's tab.
1:11:47It's tab.
1:11:48So you type BBE, and then you type tab.
1:11:50And that's a choice, that's a totally valid choice.
1:11:52I mean, and I could, in theory, get used to the, you know, I'm not that, my habit for right arrow isn't that hard.
1:11:59But it's really a great feature, and it's, I don't think, I never found quite a way to do that in Alfred or Raycast quite the same way.
1:12:08And I know that people within Apple are longtime users of LaunchBar and Alfred and probably Raycast at this point.
1:12:15They know what those things do because they use them.
1:12:17The thing about clipboard history, I really do agree that it should have been a feature 20 years ago.
1:12:24And it really, because it is destructive.
1:12:25It's a loss, right, that you can, and it's, at this point in time, it is ridiculous,
1:12:32given the memory of computers, that you only store one thing at a time, like it's 1984.
1:12:39Like, it's very obvious why the 1984 Mac only kept one thing on the clipboard at a time and didn't have a history.
1:12:47I mean, we were lucky with 128 kilobytes of RAM that it could copy anything.
1:12:52But if you cut something instead of copy, which is like a copy and then a delete,
1:12:59and then you accidentally forget, and then you copy something else,
1:13:03you just lost the thing that you cut that was there.
1:13:07It's gone.
1:13:07I mean, and in theory, you could go back to the app, you cut it from,
1:13:11and hopefully undo would bring it back.
1:13:14But like, for example, in Apple Notes, one of my most used, a favorite app,
1:13:19if you switch notes in Apple Notes, you lose the undo stack for that note when you switch notes.
1:13:26So if you only have two notes in Apple Notes, just a very simple example,
1:13:31and you're in note A, and you cut something, and you go elsewhere, you copy something else,
1:13:37you can go back to notes, and if you're still there, you could hit undo, and what you cut will come back.
1:13:42But if you switch to the other note, note B, then whatever you did in note A,
1:13:46if you go back to it, you can't undo to go back.
1:13:48It's just gone.
1:13:51That should not be – you should not be able to lose what you copied.
1:13:54And the fact that's how iPadOS and iOS still work is, in my opinion, ridiculous.
1:14:00And it would get me – I use – what's it called?
1:14:04PasteBot from our friends at TapBots.
1:14:07There are so many clipboard managers.
1:14:09It's such a crowded category of dedicated ones.
1:14:12And then there are so many utilities that offer a clipboard history as a secondary feature,
1:14:19including, I think, all of the major launchers, like LaunchBar, I know, has a clipboard history.
1:14:24Alfred and Raycast probably have them, too.
1:14:26There are so many – Keyboard Maestro has one.
1:14:30It's unbelievable if I counted how many apps that I use that have a clipboard history.
1:14:35But I like PasteBot so much that I actually run a dedicated clipboard history.
1:14:41One of the great things about it, though – and other ones might do this, too –
1:14:46but PasteBot will sync my clipboard history.
1:14:49So I can copy something on my Mac in my office and then come down here to this podcast station
1:14:54and type a keyboard shortcut, and it shows me all – my entire history of clipboard items
1:15:01from the Mac that I use most of the time in my office upstairs.
1:15:04All of them.
1:15:05I have it set to – my preferences for PasteBot are to keep 1,000 items.
1:15:10And that's the maximum it was allowed.
1:15:12If it would allow me to keep more, I would keep more.
1:15:14I actually – I think I've registered a complaint to the developers at PasteBot
1:15:19that I don't think 1,000 is enough.
1:15:21And I know that was one of the things Apple tweaked with Tahoe over the summer.
1:15:24It was like, hey, how much of your history does it keep?
1:15:27And at first, they were very conservative.
1:15:29It was like, I don't know, an hour.
1:15:30Yeah, three hours.
1:15:31And now it's – there's settings for more?
1:15:34I forget what they are.
1:15:35Yeah, I think you can do 12 hours and 24.
1:15:39I mean, yeah, you can go – it's all time-based, not a number-based.
1:15:43It's eight hours, seven days, or 30 minutes.
1:15:45So you can depend on that.
1:15:48Well, the thing you mentioned, this is – even to this day, people talk about Sherlocking, right?
1:15:52And the stuff that I was just praising, you could say that a lot of that is Sherlocking.
1:15:55You're Sherlocking Hazel and LaunchBar by doing this.
1:15:58But I never believed that because I do believe that the OS vendor has a duty of care to provide
1:16:04base features without requiring – the last thing you want to do is be told that when you
1:16:09buy a Mac, the first thing you need to do is buy $150 worth of shareware in order to get
1:16:13it to work right.
1:16:14That's bad for Apple.
1:16:15Apple needs to make it, like, good out of the box.
1:16:17And I think Clipboard Manager in the box – there's not a box anymore, but, you know, is great.
1:16:21But what you described there about Clipboard Managers and Pacebot and all the rest of them,
1:16:28that's why Sherlocking isn't a thing.
1:16:32Because Apple's never going to do the edge cases, right?
1:16:36Right.
1:16:36Apple wants to get that sweet spot where, again, it's like your cousin, oh no, I copied
1:16:42a thing, and now my thing that I copied that's got grandma's will on it is gone.
1:16:47And it's okay, it's there now because you've got a clipboard history.
1:16:50We can get it back.
1:16:51Like, basic use.
1:16:53If you've got more use, that's what the third-party apps are going to be able to give you.
1:16:57Hazel can do way more than the stuff that Shortcuts can do with Actions now.
1:17:02And LaunchBar can do way more than Spotlight can do.
1:17:06And all of the Clipboard Managers can do way more than the base one.
1:17:10And that's good because nobody – we know lots of third-party independent developers in
1:17:16the Apple ecosystem, and they all know, like, Apple could squash their main idea if they're
1:17:20fitting – if it's an obvious main idea that Apple just hasn't gotten to, they could squash
1:17:25it.
1:17:25And in the early days of OS X, this happened all the time.
1:17:27But, like, if you design your app for people who really care about it, and what they really
1:17:30care about is the stuff in the edge case, it doesn't matter if Apple takes the center.
1:17:33Because you've got the whole edge where Apple is never going to be so nerdy that they're
1:17:38going to offer a thousand things and have them sync and have them do, like, Pastebot will
1:17:42do, like, rewrites where it'll do a modification or a conversion or, like, a markdown conversion.
1:17:48All of this stuff.
1:17:49Like, Apple's never going to do that stuff.
1:17:51Right.
1:17:51They're never going to allow custom filters.
1:17:53That's what Pastebot will allow.
1:17:54No, that's so nerdy.
1:17:56That is your classic third-party opportunity.
1:17:58Right.
1:17:59You would understand, listeners of the show would be like, what?
1:18:03But there's four reasons on the server side, my CMS with, you know, movable type, which you
1:18:11don't use anymore, or you do for something.
1:18:13I do.
1:18:13The incomparable, right?
1:18:15The incomparable is a movable type, yeah.
1:18:17So it's, in modern parlance, you could think of it as 20 years ahead of its time in its
1:18:22static site generator.
1:18:23But it generates files with .php extensions.
1:18:27But you'll think, well, the articles on Daring Fireball don't have .php extensions.
1:18:33And there are times, like, when I copy from MarsEdit, it gets the URL that movable type
1:18:39thinks it's generating.
1:18:40But I've used Apache rewrite trickery to make sure that what gets published to the world,
1:18:46you don't need those file extensions.
1:18:47And if you try to use one, it'll automatically redirect you to the same article without the
1:18:53.php.
1:18:54But I have a keyboard maestro macro that every time I copy anything, the macro runs and looks
1:19:00to see if it's a Daring Fireball URL that ends in .php and just clips the .php from it.
1:19:06You can do that on the Mac.
1:19:08You cannot do that sort of thing anywhere else.
1:19:10And Apple's built-in stuff is never going to support that sort of thing, right?
1:19:15So if you can say, and this is my stance, I think you and I share this, my stance on Sherlocking
1:19:19is even if you've invented a new idea or something that hasn't, it's like, wow, I can't think
1:19:26of anything that's done that before.
1:19:28If the answer to the question, hey, should Apple build that into the system for everybody or
1:19:32a version of that, a simpler version of that into the system?
1:19:35If the answer is yes, they probably will eventually, even if it takes until 2026 to build clipboard
1:19:42history into Mac OS.
1:19:43But if they should build it in, they will.
1:19:46And if your idea is so simple that even a simple implementation that Apple adds to the
1:19:52system for everybody kind of obviates, your utility is kind of eventually going to be obviated.
1:19:58And you need to find, you know, like BBEdit is not going to get obviated and hasn't been
1:20:03obviated by TextEdit, even though TextEdit is a very credible text editor for opening text
1:20:08files.
1:20:09Yeah, it's not.
1:20:10It does slightly more.
1:20:11It's the nerdiness and the edge cases and the fact that, yes, it's a little bit like people
1:20:15saying, I've got an idea for a book.
1:20:17I've got an idea for a novel.
1:20:18I just need to find a writer to write the novel.
1:20:20It's like ideas.
1:20:21I know it feels good that you've got a good idea.
1:20:23Ideas have no value.
1:20:24Execution has value.
1:20:26Every writer, they don't need your ideas.
1:20:28They got their own ideas, lots of them, but they have to execute.
1:20:31That's part of the story.
1:20:32And I feel like this is very similar where if all you have is a basic bit of functionality
1:20:37that should be in the system and then Apple puts it in the system and it completely, just
1:20:43completely blots out your app because that's all it did.
1:20:46Your app was just an idea.
1:20:48It was not executed right.
1:20:50Because the execution, you should be listening to your customers because they care enough to
1:20:55get a third party app to do this thing.
1:20:57They probably have desires that are going to be way beyond what Apple wants to offer them.
1:21:01And that's your market ultimately because Apple will blot out the center, but you've
1:21:06got the edge cases.
1:21:07I don't remember every single post I've ever posted to Daring Fireball, but I don't see
1:21:12how I could, but some I do.
1:21:13And one I remember, I just looked it up.
1:21:15I posted it in August of 2008, but it's linking to a post from Derek Sivers that he wrote in
1:21:222005.
1:21:23And it's just one of my favorite little sentences or two sentences ever.
1:21:26Derek Sivers wrote in 2005, to me, ideas are worth nothing.
1:21:31Unless executed, they are just a multiplier.
1:21:34Execution is worth millions.
1:21:36Yeah.
1:21:37And that's it.
1:21:38Execution times the idea.
1:21:40But if the execution is just a one, you're not getting any multiplication out of it.
1:21:44I'm trying to think what else with the Tahoe features.
1:21:47I don't think there's anything else.
1:21:48But the triggers on automation, I do.
1:21:51I guess that's the one thing I'm maybe missing out on, but I probably, I can't think of any
1:21:55places where I need them to kick in.
1:21:56But, and I'm so happy Apple's going in that direction, right?
1:22:00Otherwise, if I weren't so upset about the things I'm upset about in Tahoe, I'd be so
1:22:03happy because there was a long stretch.
1:22:05And I know you and I have talked about it on this show.
1:22:08Oh, yes, we have.
1:22:08About, hey, does Apple care about automation anymore?
1:22:12And when, you know, Sal Soyahan left the company and it looked like, and it's true.
1:22:17I mean, again, the automation things never really go away because they know people rely on them.
1:22:22And if you built a thing in Automator, they're not going to break it.
1:22:26And, you know, AppleScript still is there.
1:22:28It's amazing.
1:22:29And they still are adding it to, like, one of the things I was like, because I have some
1:22:34AppleScripts that, not many, but some that work with messages.
1:22:38And when they were like, hey, we're going to rewrite messages as a, not continuity, a
1:22:43Catalyst app based on the iOS code base.
1:22:46I was like, well, there go my AppleScripts because no matter how good of a Catalyst app
1:22:50they make it, they're not going to bring back the whole AppleScript dictionary.
1:22:52Well, guess what?
1:22:53They brought back the whole AppleScript dictionary.
1:22:55And at least everything I use scripting wise in messages still works, which is awesome.
1:23:01Yeah.
1:23:01I have an Automator services plugin for the Finder that I use for every podcast I do.
1:23:09And it still works.
1:23:11I've, could I rewrite it in something else?
1:23:14Of course I could, but this is the one that's integrated with the Finder.
1:23:17So it's the best one.
1:23:18So I use it and eventually it'll be a shortcut maybe, but yeah, some of those automations,
1:23:23I mean, I've got like, the thing about it is some of the simple ones are really cool.
1:23:28And I wish that they were more discoverable for people because like I realized I was dragging
1:23:33images out of my web browser and they were saving as that cockamamie Google format.
1:23:38What?
1:23:38I don't even remember what it is now.
1:23:40I forget what it is too.
1:23:41Web P or something.
1:23:42Web P.
1:23:42That's it.
1:23:43And I literally have an automation that is when a file is added to the desktop, filter
1:23:50the files where the file extension is web P, convert them to a JPEG, save the converted
1:23:57image to the desktop and delete the web P.
1:24:01It's four lines and shortcuts automated.
1:24:04And when I drag a web P to the desktop, it goes away and a JPEG appears that people can
1:24:09actually see.
1:24:10And I've got a bunch of stuff like that.
1:24:12That's just like super basic.
1:24:13And I, yeah, I had some of it in Hazel before, but like, I really liked the idea that the Mac
1:24:18will let you do not just things like time, which it'll also let you do right every at
1:24:22two 30 on Tuesday, sweep up a bunch of old files and put them in an archive folder.
1:24:27You can do that too, which is really great.
1:24:28But the fact that you can use shortcuts and through shortcuts, you can use anything, right?
1:24:32Cause you can use a shortcut to run a shell script or do whatever based on a file changing
1:24:38or a folder, having something added to it.
1:24:40My automation for solving the same problem where you drag, it's funny, we ran into the
1:24:47same problem and we solved it with different automations for the same thing where you,
1:24:50on some websites, you, you drag an image out and you get a web P and I never want
1:24:57a web P my automation was, I asked Jeff Johnson, the author of a bunch of awesome utilities,
1:25:06like stop the madness.
1:25:07It's an extension for Safari that does so many cool things.
1:25:10I asked him and then he showed me how to, uh, he did it for me and showed me how to, I think
1:25:17he might've even added a feature to stop the madness that does it.
1:25:20What he figured out was that it's the way Safari sends the request to the website for, Hey,
1:25:26images I'll accept and it lists web P in front of ping and JPEG.
1:25:32And so if the server is capable of serving the same image in multiple formats, it'll serve
1:25:39the first one in the list.
1:25:40And because Safari says that, and I think Safari says it because web P's tend to be smaller or
1:25:46that's the whole point.
1:25:46And so Jeff Johnson either added a feature and showed me how to use it, or he just showed
1:25:55me how to use an existing feature and stop the madness.
1:25:57I will put a link to stop the madness.
1:25:59And maybe I've explained this on daring fireball somewhere, but it's a, it's sort of a old school
1:26:06AI.
1:26:06I asked a smart developer friend, Hey, how do I stop doing, how do I stop getting these
1:26:11web P's?
1:26:11And he showed me.
1:26:13And now I, I never, I haven't seen one of those in forever because I don't want them.
1:26:16Yeah.
1:26:17Yeah.
1:26:17Well, that's the point I have a, I think I have an automated thing that literally looks
1:26:20at my downloads folder and says, if there's like a DMG in there older than 30 days, put
1:26:26it in the trash.
1:26:27Right.
1:26:27Like just little stuff.
1:26:29Yeah.
1:26:30I was losing my mind because it was like, I viewed source on these web pages and the image
1:26:36tags in the HTML were specifying like JPEGs.
1:26:39Yeah.
1:26:39But when I dragged them out, I'd get the web P.
1:26:42I know.
1:26:43It's the worst.
1:26:43It's, and it's like I said, if the browser says it'll accept it and the web server is like,
1:26:50Oh, that's an alternative for the same image.
1:26:52I'll send that one instead and save some bandwidth.
1:26:55It works for most people, does not work if you're a blogger who wants to download an image
1:27:00and maybe reuse it without rejiggering or resaving the file.
1:27:04Let me take a break and I will thank our third and final sponsor of the show.
1:27:11Our good friends at Squarespace.
1:27:13Squarespace is the all in one platform for building your website for you, your friends, your company,
1:27:23or friends of friends or family members or anybody who comes to you as their like biggest
1:27:29nerd friend.
1:27:29And it's like, how do I update my website or how do I get a website of my own?
1:27:33Squarespace is where to send them.
1:27:35You can send them to squarespace.com slash talk show.
1:27:39That's the URL to remember.
1:27:40They'll get 30 days free trial, all the features, no watermarks.
1:27:44And then they can just use that code talk show and save money at the end.
1:27:48Some of the features, they've got so many features.
1:27:50It just keeps getting better.
1:27:52I will emphasize today online stores.
1:27:55If you offer services and they store that sells anything products, like if you sell t-shirts
1:28:01or something like that, you can build a store, physical goods.
1:28:04You could build a store in Squarespace, drag and drop.
1:28:06And it manages, it's not just, oh, you can build a layout.
1:28:09It actually has the store, like where you can actually check out and take money and stuff
1:28:16like that.
1:28:16It's not just building the layout of a store.
1:28:18It's actually a store, but it's not just physical goods.
1:28:21You can also sell like virtual goods, like downloadable items or eBooks or whatever it is you're
1:28:26selling or your own services.
1:28:29If you're like a consultant or a trainer or something like that, you can build a website
1:28:33and it's a built-in feature, how to sell that sort of thing and take money for it right there
1:28:40built into Squarespace.
1:28:41They've got invoices that integrate with the store.
1:28:44If it's something like a service or something where an invoice makes sense instead of just
1:28:48a simple receipt, you can do that.
1:28:50And then you send your clients an invoice and when they click the invoice, it goes to your
1:28:54website built on Squarespace and they can pay right there through the Squarespace payments.
1:28:59It is just a great system for all sorts of stuff.
1:29:03Where do you go to find out more?
1:29:06Like I said earlier at the top of the read, go to squarespace.com slash talk show.
1:29:11And when you do, and you use that code talk show at the end of your 30-day free trial, you
1:29:16save 10% off your first order.
1:29:18And your first order, you can prepay for a whole year, which is what I recommend you do.
1:29:22Save 10% on a whole year at squarespace.com slash talk show.
1:29:27Creator Studio.
1:29:29Now, here's one of the traps.
1:29:31And a couple of people have mentioned this to me with the report card.
1:29:35They're like, I can't believe you didn't complain about this, that, or the other thing with Creator
1:29:38Studio.
1:29:39And I wrote to them.
1:29:40I was like, ah, you fell into the trap of writing your report card in January or early
1:29:48February for the last calendar year.
1:29:51Well, guess what?
1:29:51Creator Studio was announced in January.
1:29:54That's right.
1:29:54That's a 2026 thing.
1:29:56Everybody put that on their to-do list for next year's report card, which I'm going to,
1:29:59I have slid it enough.
1:30:00I mean, I had a bunch of stuff come up that I had to, I ended up unexpectedly pushing it
1:30:04back.
1:30:04But I think nothing happens in December.
1:30:06So I think I'm going to try to get people in early to mid-December this year.
1:30:10At least that's my goal right now.
1:30:12Put the AI Siri category and get it a little earlier in the calendar.
1:30:15Well, it's funny that you didn't have the AI Siri thing.
1:30:18And I mentioned it last year.
1:30:19You said you forgot to take a note of it.
1:30:21But if you had, they didn't do anything this year.
1:30:23Oh, it would have been brutal.
1:30:24It would have been brutal.
1:30:25Quite rightly so.
1:30:27I mean, everybody knew that that would have been.
1:30:29It's the argument.
1:30:31People are going to be like, I can't believe you had it this year when they finally shipped
1:30:34something.
1:30:34That's not fair.
1:30:35It's like with Tahoe is like the bad student who came in and turned in trash assignments
1:30:40and failed the test.
1:30:41Siri and Apple Intelligence is like the kid who never showed up to class.
1:30:45They just never showed up.
1:30:47Nope.
1:30:47Still enrolled.
1:30:48We don't know why they're still enrolled.
1:30:49They enrolled in 2024.
1:30:51They're still not here.
1:30:52Yeah.
1:30:52Yeah.
1:30:54So Creator Studio.
1:30:56Yeah.
1:30:56That was in January.
1:30:57I'm glad that you mentioned it because the more I think about it, the angrier I get
1:31:03about it.
1:31:04And it's not, again, it's complicated, right?
1:31:07Actually, it's so complicated.
1:31:09It is.
1:31:11Well, let me, let's start there, right?
1:31:12Why is it the way it is?
1:31:15And I think the answer is the app store is so limited as a place to sell software that even
1:31:22Apple itself can't get it to be better for the launch of their suite.
1:31:27And so they have this ridiculous, like they renamed, like I have Apple scripts that do things
1:31:33for my financial charts in numbers.
1:31:35And I ran the Apple script and realized it was running on a different app now because
1:31:39they had to create new apps.
1:31:41They're the same apps with new names.
1:31:43It's not numbers anymore.
1:31:44It's numbers creator studio dot app.
1:31:47But that's what it is because I think what they did is they fused the iOS and Mac apps in the
1:31:55app store that used to be separate.
1:31:57They fused them together, but not even Apple can find a way to merge them.
1:32:02Even Apple had to just make another app that's the same app in order to do a bundle in order
1:32:08to get this stuff to work the way they did.
1:32:10And then they kept the old Mac apps around because they're going to just grant you use
1:32:14of those, even if you're not a subscriber to this new suite that they've done, this new
1:32:18subscription.
1:32:19But so you end up in the app store also with these stupid looking app names where like
1:32:24pages, the old non creator studio version of pages is now called in the app store pages
1:32:3014.5, which is again, a throwback to the classic era.
1:32:36You'd get Photoshop three and yeah.
1:32:38And the idiom that we all used at the time is we would name Photoshop Photoshop three and
1:32:44it would, you could either keep it a long shot alongside Photoshop 2.5 or wait and see if
1:32:49you liked Photoshop three and then trash Photoshop 2.5.
1:32:53But we put the versions in the app names for a long time as just sort of an idiom of being
1:33:00a Mac user.
1:33:01And now it's back because it's like pages 14.5 numbers.
1:33:05If you, if you launch the old versions, which they were also auto updated, they say you
1:33:11should get the new one from the app store, but you can still use it, but they're like
1:33:14the on launch every time you launch it every time you should get the new one from the app
1:33:18store, which is, it's so terrible.
1:33:20And I think it's really funny in a way because this is developers have had to deal with all
1:33:26the terrible things about the app store and the backend and the limitations of the app
1:33:30store for years now.
1:33:31But here's an example where Apple wants to do this, right?
1:33:34And I'm sure they had ambitious plans and that I'm sure they didn't want it to go like
1:33:38this, but this is what they're, even Apple is reduced to, which it does make me despair.
1:33:43I was talking to some developer friends of mine about this.
1:33:46It does make you despair a little bit when even a major initiative like this couldn't get the
1:33:52app store to fix some of the things that are wrong with it in the app store backend.
1:33:56Apple couldn't even get Apple to do it.
1:33:58So what does that mean for the rest of us if Apple can't even get itself to do it?
1:34:03So that, that part is ridiculous.
1:34:04The suite itself, like I think they needed to do it and I think it's good.
1:34:10I think having final cut, I think for what they're charging, which is about what I pay for Photoshop
1:34:14and Lightroom in a year, you get final cut and logic and pixel mater on iPad and on Mac.
1:34:21I think that's pretty good.
1:34:23I think it's not for everybody.
1:34:24I understand.
1:34:25And you may not need all of those like motion and there's some of the compressor compressor.
1:34:31You get all the ancillary stuff too.
1:34:32And main stage, if you're a live performer, like it's all good.
1:34:36I understand if you only use one of the apps, you're being asked to pay $130 a year or whatever
1:34:41for it.
1:34:41But that's, that is literally, I don't use Lightroom.
1:34:44I literally, I'm just paying for Photoshop and it's fine.
1:34:46And there are free alternatives to all of this if you want to do that instead.
1:34:50But I think that these are good apps like final cut pro.
1:34:52It's a good app.
1:34:53I use it not a lot, but some, I use logic a lot.
1:34:57It's great.
1:34:58And even though I'm misusing it, cause I'm not using it for music.
1:35:00It's still, it's great.
1:35:01The iPad apps are very impressive.
1:35:03I think there's a lot of positive things to be said about the creative aspect of the creator
1:35:09studio.
1:35:09I have problems with everything else that happened, but the main part of like, they
1:35:15should make it because the idea you used to have to spend hundreds and hundreds of dollars
1:35:18to get logic or a final cut.
1:35:20And now you could buy a month and do a final cut project and then turn it back off.
1:35:25Yeah.
1:35:25I think final cut was like $399 when it first came out and it was cheap compared to nonlinear
1:35:31video editors of the time, but we're both getting it wrong.
1:35:34If you go by the app store, the new name of final cut is final cut pro colon create video.
1:35:39Again, Apple is reduced to the same stupid things that app developers have been reduced
1:35:44to because the app store is so bad.
1:35:46Numbers, make spreadsheets.
1:35:49Yeah.
1:35:50Keynote, design presentations.
1:35:52And then my favorite, pages, create documents.
1:35:56All right.
1:35:56Create documents.
1:35:58Yeah.
1:35:58I'm going to know.
1:35:59Now let's open the app pages, create documents, or as we like to know it, pages, creator studio
1:36:04dot app.
1:36:06Yeah.
1:36:07So this is, you're teeing me up here.
1:36:09They added iWork apps to this suite.
1:36:12Yep.
1:36:13And I think part of it, if we're talking about the app store being limited, I think part of
1:36:17it is that kind of like there's only one way to do this kind of a thing.
1:36:20And so they made their one suite and they put all their apps into it.
1:36:23And that's what we have now.
1:36:24But it's been a long time since Apple has made a decision that has incensed me more than
1:36:35this because those aren't creative apps, John.
1:36:40I mean, I know their argument is, oh, but creators might need to do it.
1:36:44Creators might need to make a keynote presentation.
1:36:47A creator might need to do an invoice in pages.
1:36:51I get it.
1:36:52But you've put apps that are general purpose apps that exist so that when you buy a Mac or
1:36:58an iPhone or an iPad, it's not an empty bag.
1:37:02Like I was saying earlier that you then have to purchase apps in order to use it.
1:37:06You just get a document editor and a presentation app and a spreadsheet and you just get them.
1:37:12And like that was the purpose of them.
1:37:13It's for everybody.
1:37:14And now you've shoved them for everybody.
1:37:18You've shoved them inside here.
1:37:19And yes, it's free to use.
1:37:21But now that it's inside this thing, there are like upsells everywhere.
1:37:26There are like you there's UI in the toolbar by default that is content that's only available
1:37:33via the subscription.
1:37:34And I'm sorry if I just use numbers, that one 2090 year does not make any sense, nor is there
1:37:42any way for me to say, I mean, you can edit the toolbar and remove those things.
1:37:46But like the template picker at the beginning when you do command in has a bunch of premium
1:37:51upsell stuff in it just to remind you the there's a the browser of objects that lets you drag
1:37:56like a circle or whatever into your keynote presentation has a whole row of like clip art
1:38:03that if you drag it in, it's watermarked because you don't get it until you pay.
1:38:06It's just so it's so cheapens the idea of why those apps exist and for what end because
1:38:16it's to what end it's in a creative suite that it doesn't belong in on.
1:38:20I might feel differently a little bit if there was also like a $29 a year iWork suite that
1:38:27got you that stuff.
1:38:28And I appreciate that the features are based on AI.
1:38:30There's a bunch of open AI stuff that they're doing that has a real cost.
1:38:33License and clip media has a real cost.
1:38:35I get it.
1:38:36But this is the wrong bundle for it to be in.
1:38:38And you took a free thing and made it an upsell.
1:38:45You made it freemium and it's just crappy.
1:38:48And you just reported your highest revenue and most profitable quarter in the company's
1:38:53history.
1:38:53One of the most profitable quarters any company in the history of the world has ever reported.
1:38:59Maybe that's number one.
1:39:00I don't know.
1:39:01So it's not like...
1:39:02It's them and some oil companies pretty much.
1:39:03Yeah.
1:39:04And they made the decision to stop selling the major updates to the iWork apps and just
1:39:10say, you know what?
1:39:10You buy a Mac, you get these apps for free.
1:39:13That's table stakes for the platform.
1:39:15Yeah.
1:39:15They're the ones who decided to do that.
1:39:17And maybe there's a line to be drawn.
1:39:21Oh, I mean, I so badly want to be rascally and just say that I love the pay wall.
1:39:28I love the pay wall they've added to the iWork apps.
1:39:32But I can't do it, Jason.
1:39:33I'm going to be a bigger...
1:39:34That's the wrong kind of rascal.
1:39:35Don't be that kind of rascal.
1:39:36I'm going to be a bigger man.
1:39:37And I hate it too.
1:39:38I hate the confusion over the SKUs.
1:39:41I hate the way that their own unwillingness, like, hey, we're not using these features.
1:39:48And again, they're all kind of tied together.
1:39:50Where one of the things developers have wanted from the app store from the beginning are ways
1:39:56to sell version updates.
1:39:57Hey, if I sell my app and then I come out with a major new version, the way that my company
1:40:03has always made money is by selling an upgrade version, right?
1:40:08So that if you're a new user, it's $50.
1:40:10And if you're upgrading from the last major version, it's half price.
1:40:15It's $25.
1:40:16And if you bought the last major upgrade in the last X months, and X varies by developer,
1:40:24maybe it's a year, maybe it's six months.
1:40:26But if you bought it in the last year, it's free so that you don't have to feel.
1:40:31And then it sends a message in the future, like, hey, this app hasn't been updated in
1:40:35two or three years.
1:40:36But it looks like the developer updates it every two or three years.
1:40:39I don't want to buy it right now.
1:40:41Because what if a major update comes out and I have to pay for it?
1:40:44Oh, the developer has a history of if you bought it in the last year before a major update,
1:40:49you get the major update for free.
1:40:51This sort of logic is not that hard.
1:40:54And the app store can't handle it.
1:40:56And Apple was like, well, we sold Final Cut Pro.
1:41:00And if you bought it once in the year 2007, we've just given away all of the updates for
1:41:0720 years for free to you for having purchased it once.
1:41:11And that's fine for us.
1:41:13I think they did a Final Cut 10 and they did a Logic 10 X, whatever.
1:41:18Right.
1:41:18And I think they charged for those.
1:41:21Maybe.
1:41:22But, you know.
1:41:22And I think that's the one time in all of the years that I've used those apps that I paid
1:41:27for them.
1:41:27If you bought them a very long time ago, you've gotten a large number of years and a significant
1:41:34number of both compatibility, just updating for Retina and updating all the various things
1:41:40that have happened over.
1:41:41Yeah.
1:41:41Features.
1:41:42A huge number of features.
1:41:43Absolutely.
1:41:44That Apple can afford to effectively give away to existing users for a one-time purchase long
1:41:51ago.
1:41:51But a company that is, or a small independent developer, large or small, cannot afford to
1:41:57do because it's their frigging business.
1:41:59Exactly.
1:41:59It's their only business.
1:42:01And that developers want the flexibility to create bundles and stuff like that.
1:42:05And to bundle apps together in a flexible way.
1:42:09And all of these things that Apple was like, well, we don't do that, so you don't need to
1:42:13do it either.
1:42:14And now Apple, oh, now Apple wants to do it.
1:42:18And it is kind of, it sucks for us as users because it's all, it's not good, but it is kind
1:42:23of, what's the German word?
1:42:25Schadenfreude.
1:42:26Schadenfreude.
1:42:26Schadenfreude.
1:42:27Yeah.
1:42:27Yeah.
1:42:28They've been hoisted by their own petard here.
1:42:30Right.
1:42:30Which is, you're now, oh, now you're the app developer in the app store, aren't you?
1:42:35Right.
1:42:35Ha ha.
1:42:35And now your spreadsheet is named Numbers Make Spreadsheets.
1:42:39Numbers Make Spreadsheets.
1:42:41I mean, what else would numbers do but make spreadsheets?
1:42:43That's what they do.
1:42:44That's what numbers are for.
1:42:45So this is funny because it's connected.
1:42:47I feel like these, this has been a really nice thematic episode of the talk show here.
1:42:51I do.
1:42:51Because I wanted to say, we were talking about Sherlocking, right?
1:42:54The idea that I feel like, I know there are a million clipboard utilities out there, but
1:42:59I do think it matters that Apple puts it in the system.
1:43:01That's a good thing.
1:43:02There are features that should be in the system and you shouldn't need an add-on for.
1:43:06And I feel like the iWork apps have always been that.
1:43:11The origin of that is Steve Jobs basically being like, why do we sell this thing?
1:43:15And then everybody has to get Microsoft Office.
1:43:18Yeah.
1:43:18And they don't do a good job making Mac apps.
1:43:20Is bad on the Mac, then that reflects badly on us.
1:43:23So let's just do it.
1:43:24Just like making their own web browser.
1:43:25They're like, let's make our own apps.
1:43:27And so they made these apps and the net result is the Mac and the iPhone and the iPad are
1:43:32all nicer because it's not just an empty computer that you can add, you can buy apps for, but
1:43:39some stuff is just, it comes with, it's those base OS features.
1:43:43You don't have to buy an extra to get a clipboard.
1:43:46The clipboard comes with the system because you have copy and paste.
1:43:49You don't have to buy a document editor.
1:43:51Pages comes with, you might not want to use pages.
1:43:54You might want to use Word.
1:43:55That's fine.
1:43:55You can go buy Word.
1:43:56The pages will work and it will open Word docs that your friends send to you without
1:44:00making, there's so many reasons to do it.
1:44:02The analogy, I made this analogy, I forget where, on some podcasts, but I'll make it here
1:44:07really quickly, which is I went to Hawaii last month and we stayed in a nice resort-ish, resort-ish
1:44:13kind of place.
1:44:14And it's nice.
1:44:16I mean, we often will just rent a condo when we go on a vacation like that.
1:44:19And then you do your own shopping and all that.
1:44:20But this time it was like, we want it to be a little nicer, a little closer to the beach.
1:44:23It was a little more expensive.
1:44:25And I had a moment while I was in the room where I was thinking like, this is a corporation.
1:44:30It's Marriott.
1:44:31It was Sheraton, but it's owned by Marriott.
1:44:33They have whole conversations about the towels they buy, the furniture they buy, the soap that
1:44:38they stock for your, the facial soap bar in the sink.
1:44:42All of these things are decisions they make.
1:44:44And because they're charging a premium, this is a nice place to stay.
1:44:48They have to make decisions that balance their profit motive and their brand promise, right?
1:44:54You can't have a Motel 6 experience for Sheraton Resort Club prices.
1:44:59You can't do it.
1:45:02Otherwise, nobody would stay there, right?
1:45:04So you've got to make those decisions.
1:45:05And yes, I am the sicko who was thinking about iWork apps while I was on vacation in Hawaii.
1:45:11But there I was.
1:45:13It's the same thing, which is, I know you can make the argument that there's always more revenue
1:45:19to increment and another place to get more out of your users.
1:45:24But if you do that, you always have to balance it.
1:45:28This takes us back to talking about who gets, whose argument wins about design and usability
1:45:34and things like that.
1:45:35In the end, if you are making a little more money, but eroding your brand, which is, I would
1:45:42argue, the most powerful and valuable thing Apple has is what Apple means and what Apple
1:45:50products mean.
1:45:50If you make decisions that hurt the brand, but make a little bit more revenue, you did
1:45:56it wrong.
1:45:56Like, you did it wrong.
1:45:58You are turning your resort into a Motel 6.
1:46:01And the downside of that is people won't buy your products anymore because you aren't living
1:46:07up to your promises.
1:46:08And putting, I think they backed off of some of this, but like launching the new pages and
1:46:13having in the sidebar where you do formatting, a big ad that says you should buy this subscription
1:46:21for apps you don't use so that you can get clip art.
1:46:25It just makes everything crappy.
1:46:27And that is, that's why I think the whole idea that you would turn these things into freemium
1:46:31is a mistake.
1:46:32Let them be their own thing.
1:46:34And then if you want to sell an add-on or put it in a bundle somewhere else, that's
1:46:39fine.
1:46:39But to take the base thing and use it as a, an upsell opportunity, like you're really making
1:46:46the niceness.
1:46:47Like you always say this, right?
1:46:49Like at the end, what is Apple's product promise?
1:46:52It is.
1:46:53It's nice.
1:46:54These, they make good things.
1:46:55They make nice things.
1:46:56The more junk there is that gets in your way.
1:46:59The less reason I have to pay for a nice thing.
1:47:02Cause it's not nice anymore.
1:47:03And that's what I feel like that's, I work inside this suite with the upsell and all of
1:47:08that.
1:47:08I feel like that is part of this same fundamental disconnect that Apple is having where like
1:47:13we all want in our businesses to make more money.
1:47:16I get it.
1:47:17But you've got to have somebody to say, no, I mean, this is what I used to do back in
1:47:21my publishing days is they'd be like, well, let's put more crap on the website.
1:47:24And I'd be like, no, you're hurting the product.
1:47:26And they're like, but there's revenue that's, yeah, but we don't have a product to sell.
1:47:30If we drive everybody away, we have to have, we have to meet the promise of what people expect
1:47:34from us.
1:47:35And with this, Apple just is falling short.
1:47:37This is a, it's just a huge mistake because they're taking a thing that, that the goal of
1:47:42I work is not to make money on I work.
1:47:46The goal of I work is to make buying an Apple device that much easier and nicer.
1:47:52I'm always surprised now I stay at like, I don't know what you, four star hotels, not
1:47:57five, but four.
1:47:58And I'm always disappointed.
1:47:59It happens sometimes where I'll get in a hotel room and they don't have like free bottles
1:48:03of water.
1:48:03Just, just a couple of bottles of water.
1:48:05Or worse, they've got a bottle of water with a tag on it that says, this is $8.
1:48:09Exactly.
1:48:10What am I even doing here?
1:48:11And it's like, that's what Apple has done.
1:48:13And it's like, you stay at a nice hotel.
1:48:16You expect, you get a decent kind of shampoo and soap in the shower and imagine.
1:48:20Exactly.
1:48:20Which is not to say they can't do upsell.
1:48:23Like a mini bar is fine, right?
1:48:25Right.
1:48:25I can choose to use it or not.
1:48:27The Sheraton, I'm just another plug here for the Sheraton, Kauai, Poipu Beach.
1:48:31And it's very nice.
1:48:32It's on the beach.
1:48:33It's great.
1:48:33They had two water bottles for us every day.
1:48:35Little plastic water bottles, free.
1:48:37And then there was like a giant water bottle that sat there and said, this is $9.
1:48:42Right.
1:48:42And so it's like, take it or leave it.
1:48:44But they didn't say, if you touch the refrigerator, we're charging you for the mini bar.
1:48:48Like, not part of the deal.
1:48:50And mini bars are a great example.
1:48:53They've always been paid.
1:48:54Like, you know, and there's a reason for that because, you know.
1:48:56They have cost and it's a profit center and it doesn't make it feel.
1:48:59I always felt like a mini bar doesn't make it feel crappy.
1:49:02Right.
1:49:03But the shampoo in the shower and the conditioner and the body soap.
1:49:07And it's like, if you pay a little more for a nicer hotel, you expect nicer shampoo.
1:49:11And then there it is.
1:49:12And well, now it's like, if you lift the shampoo off the thing, it's like, you can go out to
1:49:17the store and buy your own shampoo or you can use ours, but we're going to charge you.
1:49:21And it's like, what?
1:49:22I'm already paying for a premium hotel.
1:49:24Tap to pay for your shampoo.
1:49:25That's exactly it.
1:49:27Yeah.
1:49:28Well, at.
1:49:28And this used to be free.
1:49:30You used to, I used to stay here for years and get really nice shampoo.
1:49:34I didn't think to pack it.
1:49:36I get a cheaper condo rental and they don't have the stuff that they provide because it's
1:49:42a Vrbo or whatever, an Airbnb.
1:49:44And you know it, you know what you get coming in.
1:49:46Because you get what you pay for.
1:49:47I got to bring shampoo from home.
1:49:49That's just part of the deal.
1:49:50But you got to know what you are as a product, as a company, as a brand.
1:49:54And I cannot believe we even are having a discussion about how Apple doesn't understand
1:49:59its own brand.
1:50:00But this is a move where I'm like, do you not understand why these products exist?
1:50:05They're not just there to be thrown into an inappropriate, on top of it, bundle.
1:50:09Like, they're part of your brand promise to make it so that maybe they don't remember this.
1:50:14But it's really important that when you buy a Mac and somebody sends you a Word file or
1:50:19an Excel file, you can open it.
1:50:21Like, it's really important that you can do that right out of the box.
1:50:26And I'm quite certain it was when I was preparing for the show, it was one of the articles you
1:50:30wrote about it where you pointed out that part of what you get with the Creator Studio bundle
1:50:34is better templates for pages and Keynote.
1:50:38Right, which implies that they're never going to make any effort to do any better templates
1:50:42for it unless you pay them, ever.
1:50:44that you've gotten, and that was part of the brand message of Keynote, and Keynote in
1:50:50particular, which I would argue is the best.
1:50:52And we can have really good arguments, and maybe Excel versus Numbers is a terrific argument
1:50:57where Numbers is clearly a better Mac app, and spreadsheet nerds, which I am not, can make
1:51:05the argument that Excel, because of its specific spreadsheet-y features, is a better spreadsheet.
1:51:11Oh, well, here's a good argument on two different axes of Mac likeness and adherence to platform
1:51:18standards and spreadsheet super nerd programming features.
1:51:24Oh, and you can have a very interesting argument.
1:51:26But one of the things that made Numbers, and especially Keynote, is it came with these exquisite
1:51:35Apple design templates that you could use?
1:51:37And it's like, oh, you could use our templates and make, without any design skills, just use
1:51:42our templates and have a better-looking slide deck than the people who are using PowerPoint
1:51:48or Google Docs.
1:51:49So why are these templates?
1:51:50This is my question is, why are these templates premium?
1:51:52Are they using stock photography that they've licensed?
1:51:56It's like they've decided to stop.
1:52:00A tangential reference here.
1:52:01Somebody looked at this, and they're like, hey, we're not making money on these apps anymore,
1:52:05and they're awesome, so we want to make money on them again.
1:52:06Why not make nice templates to make the product better?
1:52:08Why say all...
1:52:09I mean, because there is a...
1:52:10They say they're going to keep updating and all that, but there is a vibe here that is,
1:52:15we've ceased free improvements to iWork.
1:52:18From this point on, you need to pay us for the Creator Studio if you would like new templates
1:52:25or anything else we do that's...
1:52:28Or what is it?
1:52:29In Numbers, there's some smart autofill stuff.
1:52:31Right.
1:52:32And it's like, would you like that?
1:52:33You need to subscribe to get this feature.
1:52:34Yeah.
1:52:34And it's just like, it gets closer and closer to like, why is that not just a feature?
1:52:37I understand if it's AI or if it's licensed content, but otherwise, why?
1:52:42Even if that one is AI, that feels like table stakes AI.
1:52:46Like, that is so low on the totem pole of stuff that AI can do today.
1:52:51And if, oh, yeah, it's not really like a sequential, like you start a column, one, two, three,
1:52:59and then you drag down.
1:53:00Of course, it goes four, five, six, seven, eight.
1:53:03It knows how to fill it in.
1:53:04But I'm sure that with AI, you could have like an irregular pattern and it could pick it up.
1:53:09You could say to ChatGPT, hey, if I start...
1:53:12With the Fibonacci sequence, it would say, oh, yes, the Fibonacci sequence.
1:53:17I'll figure that out and fill in the rest of the numbers.
1:53:19That's table stakes at this point.
1:53:21It really feels nickel and dimey to say, hey, we've improved a fundamental feature of spreadsheets
1:53:27and now you have to pay for it.
1:53:29It really feels like they've sort of just drawn a line effectively, like whatever was in there
1:53:34before Creator Studio, that's what you get.
1:53:36And everything we do afterwards, you have to pay for.
1:53:38And it's kind of expensive if the only thing you want is one of these iWorks apps.
1:53:45Anyway, bonus round would be talking about next week's event.
1:53:50We're recording this.
1:53:51People might listen to it after it starts on Monday.
1:53:55Well, the event is on Wednesday, or Experience, pardon me.
1:53:58Experience.
1:53:58Experience is on Wednesday in New York.
1:54:01You and I will both be there.
1:54:02John, will you hold my hand if I freak out during the Experience?
1:54:05Yes.
1:54:07Yes, I will.
1:54:08It just sounds a little bit like we're having...
1:54:11It's like a happening and it's freaking me out.
1:54:12It's that kind of very 60s vibe there.
1:54:15My prediction when they first announced it, based primarily on the Experience being on
1:54:20a Wednesday, was that they would do the sort of thing, which they've done before, right?
1:54:23And specifically with New York ones, with iPads and stuff.
1:54:28And I know you talked about this on Upgrade too, but I think we're thinking the exact same
1:54:32thing, where they'll do probably, I guess, Monday will be the iPhone 17e, iPhone first,
1:54:39because the iPhone's iPhone.
1:54:41Then Tuesday will be whatever new iPads are coming, and it's probably iPad Air going to
1:54:47the M5 and the iPad No Adjective going to, I don't know, A18.
1:54:52Some improved AA processor.
1:54:54Yeah.
1:54:55But update the base, just No Adjective iPad, update the iPad Air to the M5 on Tuesday, and
1:55:03then on Wednesday, even though the Experience starts at 9 a.m. in New York, I'm guessing earlier
1:55:09in the morning they'll have press releases for all of the new MacBooks.
1:55:13And I probably guess, based on the combination of just their annual calendar and the rumor
1:55:18mill, that they're going to upgrade all the MacBooks that are left to be upgraded.
1:55:21MacBook Pros to get the M5 Pro and M5 Max chips.
1:55:27MacBook Air to get the M5 chip, which was already out in other products.
1:55:34And this new low-cost MacBook that will supposedly run an A-series chip, presumably the A18.
1:55:43Just three press releases for those three products early in the morning New York time, and then
1:55:50we show up in New York, and there's a dog and pony show where they've got stations, and we get
1:55:56to experience all these things together.
1:55:57I think their press releases tend to go out at 9 a.m. Eastern, actually.
1:56:01Yeah, but I think they might do it earlier.
1:56:03The one thing, did you notice this, or did I learn this by listening to you and Mike?
1:56:07I might have actually learned this from you.
1:56:08I forget which podcast it was.
1:56:09That because they're doing simultaneous experiences in London and Shanghai, the people in Shanghai
1:56:15are getting it at 10 p.m.
1:56:1710 p.m.
1:56:19I have to admit, even though I am a night owl, I have to admit that I would find it extremely
1:56:25unusual to attend an Apple event that begins at 10 p.m.
1:56:29Yeah.
1:56:29Dinner, drinks, and then an Apple event will happen.
1:56:31I would be very out of sorts.
1:56:34But I guess it explains, because they usually don't start at 9 a.m. local time anywhere.
1:56:39Of course, as any proper American, I feel like this is the real event in London and Shanghai
1:56:47are satellite events.
1:56:48Apple events tend to start at 10 a.m., and they're doing this at 9 a.m.
1:56:52because if they started at 10 a.m.
1:56:54New York, it would be 11 o'clock in Shanghai.
1:56:56But again, I think that's their standard drop time is 6 a.m.
1:56:59Pacific, so it's possible that they will be...
1:57:02I'm going to guess they do it at 8 a.m.
1:57:04We did one New York event where they had a video, and they literally just sat us down and
1:57:07watched the video where they announced the products, and then we went and looked at the
1:57:11products.
1:57:11It was literally simultaneous.
1:57:13It was sort of like, I don't know if they had a projector or they bought the biggest
1:57:17TV I've ever seen, but it was sort of like a little movie theater that they set
1:57:21up, but just in a room, in a row of chairs, or a couple rows of chairs.
1:57:25I think it was an iPad event.
1:57:27Yeah, I think so.
1:57:27Anything else that you're expecting next week?
1:57:31That's what I expect, and I think we're of the same mind that they're going to do it
1:57:34day by day, product line by product line, not like pro day, where here's the pro products.
1:57:40Right, because I think that's confusing.
1:57:42I think Apple announces a bunch of new iPads, Apple announces a new iPhone, Apple announces
1:57:46a bunch of new Macs is the way to do that and not kind of mix and match, and then the
1:57:50experience would have all of them, presumably, and then that's probably it for the
1:57:54announcements.
1:57:55The one thing I'd throw in, I think German has said that this is probably not happening,
1:57:59but they could do, if there are new displays, attaching them to an announcement of Mac laptops
1:58:07is not a bad time to do it.
1:58:09Now, there are probably some other Mac announcements forthcoming, because there's a Mac studio
1:58:14announcement, presumably, that will follow once they get these chips out there.
1:58:18They could announce displays alongside the Mac studio instead, but laptops are a great time
1:58:22to talk about displays, because most Macs are laptops, and laptops work great when they're
1:58:26hooked up to displays.
1:58:26So that's the other thing I guess I would watch for, but German's skeptical about it.
1:58:30It doesn't mean they won't do it.
1:58:32I've heard that the studio display is fading away in terms of availability, which suggests
1:58:36that they're going to replace it, but it might not be next week.
1:58:39Yeah, and I could see them wanting to do the studio display separately from, presumably,
1:58:45I mean, whatever the future of the Mac Pro is, I presume they're going to do a new XDR
1:58:50eventually.
1:58:51And it's been like five years, I think, since 2019, because it was a live audience.
1:58:57It was San Jose.
1:58:58We were in San Jose.
1:58:59There was a demo area across the street where you could see it.
1:59:02We all blame COVID for changing to virtual, but it might have been the reaction to John
1:59:07Ternus announcing the price of the stand for the Pro Display XDR.
1:59:12Yeah, it was like, and you could buy a stand for it, and the stand costs $10,000.
1:59:19I don't know what it cost.
1:59:20It was like pin drop in the audience, and Ternus was like, oh, you guys think that's expensive,
1:59:26huh?
1:59:26Yeah.
1:59:27But yeah.
1:59:27Very well engineered.
1:59:28Yeah, so that's six or seven years.
1:59:30So I presume, and I feel like they would want to announce those separately, because
1:59:35I feel like in the way that they aren't afraid to announce new MacBook Airs alongside new MacBook
1:59:40Pros and say the MacBook Pros have brighter screens, et cetera, et cetera, I don't think
1:59:44they'd want to do the studio display alongside the XDR, but they could say, here's what you
1:59:48get for a reasonable price, and here's what you get for an unreasonable price.
1:59:52They might.
1:59:53If they're coming, I mean, I think it's one of those things where they could do it as part
1:59:56of this, or they could not.
1:59:58Generally, it's not bad to put it with another product launch, but the Mac Studio would also
2:00:03work for that, because the Mac Studio really requires an external display, and there's going
2:00:08to be an M5 Mac Studio, presumably, and that's not going to come next week, probably, according
2:00:13to Gurman.
2:00:14So you could see a March announcement that's just a press release that is new Mac Studios and
2:00:19new studio displays.
2:00:21And then, I mean, there's a lot already.
2:00:22Like, if you have three different classes of laptop, you're refreshing almost your entire
2:00:27laptop line, other than the one that you did last fall, then I'm not sure you want more,
2:00:33because that's kind of a lot.
2:00:35I don't think they're a company to hold back if it's ready to go, but I think in this case,
2:00:38even if the studio is ready to go, they might hold back for a month and be like, ah, wait.
2:00:44Just not to overshadow the MacBooks.
2:00:47Exactly.
2:00:47So that low-cost, rumored MacBook, I'm excited about it for a lot of reasons, one of which
2:00:55is that I feel like it's Apple trying to address a market that they couldn't really address.
2:01:00Talking about their brand promise, I'm going to thread all these things through.
2:01:02Like, Apple always has a bar that they won't go below in terms of the quality of the product,
2:01:07and that's why they don't make cut rate stuff, and why there hasn't been a Mac that has been
2:01:13down at that, a Mac laptop down at that price point.
2:01:15I would argue that Apple Silicon has totally changed the game when they started doing the
2:01:19M1 Air at Walmart for a deep discount, because even all this time later, M1 performance is
2:01:26still so good that it's still a viable product, and I think that was the test for whatever this
2:01:31thing is going to be, using an A-series processor.
2:01:33What I think is really funny is, this is a story that goes back, I just looked it up,
2:01:39it goes back to September, it's actually the late summer of 2023, which was the first inkling
2:01:46we got from DigiTimes that Apple was developing a low-cost MacBook, which they framed as being
2:01:53like, to compete with Chromebooks.
2:01:54And I remember, I mean, I wrote a story about it where I'm like, let's forget about the framing,
2:02:00forget about that, but like, a cheaper MacBook, given that at that time, the M1 had remained
2:02:06on sale next to the M2, and then amusingly, the M1 is only now starting to dry up suspiciously
2:02:12at Walmart, but like, they did that deal at Walmart.
2:02:15So, because of this DigiTimes report, we've kind of seen this product coming for almost two
2:02:21and a half years now, and it's taken shape, and then there was the more recent rumor that
2:02:26said very specifically it was going to be an A18 Pro processor, an iPhone class chip, and
2:02:32I did some math, I did some Geekbench score comparing, and like, it's totally viable.
2:02:38An A18 Pro is faster than an M1.
2:02:42Yep, and they've been selling the M1 until now, and people are using the M1.
2:02:46Yeah, it's faster than the M1 in single core, it's the same in multi-core, and it's the same
2:02:51in GPU, and single core for basic use is what you notice.
2:02:56It's the basic performance of a thing you're doing.
2:02:59Yep.
2:03:00Certainly acceptable performance, so if they can, I'm just fascinated by this, what do they
2:03:04do to make it cheaper?
2:03:04What does the performance look like of an iPhone chip and a Mac?
2:03:08And just like, and then we won't get the answer next week, but what does that mean?
2:03:11Does that mean there are people that are buying Mac laptops that would never have bought a Mac
2:03:16before?
2:03:17What does it mean for the MacBook Air?
2:03:18How do they differentiate it?
2:03:19There are a lot of questions there, but I think it's, leaving everything else aside, I think
2:03:24there's absolutely a market that is in this $500 or $600 laptop market that Apple has just
2:03:31never addressed, or at least never addressed directly with a brand new product.
2:03:35Right, only in the weird way that they have with Walmart, with years old MacBook Airs.
2:03:40Exactly.
2:03:41And I think they've found it to be a success.
2:03:43I think that was the test case.
2:03:45I think this idea that some people have that because the chip doesn't start with the letter
2:03:49M, that it's inferior, it's like, you have no idea how good these A-series chips are.
2:03:53They've been overpowered, or powerful enough to run Mac laptops for 10 years.
2:03:58Maybe there are certain features they couldn't handle, but I remember charting the Geekbench
2:04:03numbers in my reviews 10 years ago, and they were faster at single core.
2:04:07And if they were faster at single core, they could be faster at everything.
2:04:11The A18 Pro that's in the iPhone 16 Pro Max, single core Geekbench score, 40% faster, 45%
2:04:23faster.
2:04:24It's faster than the M1.
2:04:26And the other ones are kind of in line with the M1.
2:04:28And again, I know the M1 is an old chip.
2:04:30It's five years old.
2:04:31But it's still perfectly fine for an entry-level computer today.
2:04:37And single core really is more important, especially for consumers.
2:04:42What do they do?
2:04:42They're using web browsers.
2:04:44And the web, famously, is single core, because JavaScript is by the nature of JavaScript, which
2:04:49is a long, separate story.
2:04:51But if most of what you do is surf the web and just use one app at a time, single core is
2:04:56fine.
2:04:56It's absolutely...
2:04:57And it's not like it doesn't have multi-core and GPU power.
2:05:00They are more in line with the M1.
2:05:02But I still believe the M1 is a solid computer today, even.
2:05:09My daughter uses my old M1 MacBook Air, and she edits the upgrade video every week.
2:05:14It's pretty good.
2:05:15And that's the thing that's amazing, is the Air is amazing at $999, and then there are a
2:05:20bunch of discounts out there.
2:05:21But imagine where they said, you know, we can make another computer even below that,
2:05:25that is still really good.
2:05:28And if it's $699 or $599, and then occasionally it gets discounted to like $5 or $499, like
2:05:34$499 is the cheapest any Mac has ever been sold for.
2:05:38Well, I mean, they usually leave room to discounts.
2:05:40I guess the question is, will that initial price be surprisingly low or surprisingly high?
2:05:45If it's surprisingly high, it's because they're going to discount it.
2:05:47I think if it's low, it means they're not going to discount it.
2:05:49So I'm setting my expectations high so that I can't be disappointed.
2:05:53I think it's going to start at $799, which is $200 less than $999.
2:05:58That would give them room.
2:06:00That would give them $699 education, and then occasional specials in the $699 down to $600 range.
2:06:06My prediction is they say the starting price is $799.
2:06:09Maybe there isn't even any RAM configuration, and they only charge for storage upgrades.
2:06:14I don't know what they do.
2:06:15But I'm going to say $799 to start, the initial coverage will be dominated by, wow, $799 is way too expensive.
2:06:21We were hoping for $599 or $499.
2:06:24But then when it gets out in the real world, and maybe not immediately, but very quickly, you'll be able to get it at Walmart or Amazon or places other than the Apple store where it costs $699 or something like that.
2:06:38That's the game.
2:06:38You either set the price higher, and it gives you more room to discount, or you don't.
2:06:42But it would be great if—and I'm going to think $699 would be the lowest.
2:06:46That would be—that's what I think.
2:06:48I can't imagine them going—Apple going lower than $699.
2:06:51Yeah, I can't think it's $699, but $799 with discounts is not a bad guess.
2:06:55Yeah, and $699 would make me happier because, to me, that's more of a magic number that would get people—anybody who's been just put off by the Mac in general by price.
2:07:06What do you think they're going to call it?
2:07:07I think they're going to just call it MacBook.
2:07:09That's what I think, too.
2:07:11They've already used that name.
2:07:12It already was smaller and thinner.
2:07:14It was smaller and thinner.
2:07:16I think that this will be remarkably thin, and it'll put the MacBook Air back in the spot of being called Air but being thicker and heavier.
2:07:25I think it'll be surprisingly thin and an impressive little thing.
2:07:30Oh, my God.
2:07:31Even, like, people who are thinking, oh, I don't want Apple's lowest-cost MacBook are going to be like, oh, maybe I do, because look at it.
2:07:39Plus colors.
2:07:39Yeah.
2:07:40That's the other thing.
2:07:42Gurman says it's going to have colors, and that is very interesting in two ways.
2:07:47A, we've all been complaining for years that Apple doesn't do fun colors with their products enough, and then they make the Cosmic Orange 17 Pro iPhone, and it's, like, a best-selling product.
2:07:56And it's, like, Apple is, like, geez, why didn't anybody ever say we should make the Pro iPhones in fun colors?
2:08:03And all of us are, like, do you ever listen to our podcasts?
2:08:06Do you know how many cumulative hours of Apple-oriented podcasts have been devoted to how come the new iPhones pros don't come in fun colors?
2:08:14Yeah.
2:08:15But I think the really interesting contrast and the thing to think about is, well, how come the iPhone 16e, we don't know about the 17e yet, but 16e came in white and black, no colors at all.
2:08:26Right.
2:08:26And that was sort of, like, part of the, well, if you're going to get the base e-model, you don't get colors.
2:08:32You get white or black.
2:08:33Orthopedics shoes don't come in fun colors.
2:08:35What's the difference between a low-end MacBook and the low-end iPhone?
2:08:39So, I have started to think of that low-end MacBook as being the same as the low-end iPad.
2:08:45Because the low-end iPad has got a bunch of colors, and it's real compromised in a lot of ways.
2:08:51But fact is, for a lot of people, they just want an iPad, and, like, they don't need the higher-end stuff.
2:08:57It's fine.
2:08:58And they put the fun colors on it, partially maybe because they're trying to appeal to, I don't know, kids and schools and stuff like that.
2:09:05I don't know the reasons, but they have stuck with that idea of having a bunch of fun, pastel-y kind of colors on those iPads.
2:09:11And if I think about that product, I feel like the MacBook starts to make sense that it's the Mac equivalent of the low-end iPad.
2:09:22Mm-hmm.
2:09:23Yeah.
2:09:24And I just think there's something a little bit more upsell-y about iPhones.
2:09:30And not in a pejorative way, like with Creator Studio, which I think we both agree that the upsell-y nature of Creator Studio for things that used to be free like iWork is gross.
2:09:41But I feel like with iPhone, it is like, hey, this is a product that everybody in the world needs one of.
2:09:47And we know some of you don't really care about it, but you need a phone anyway.
2:09:51And so here, it's just white or black if all you want is the base model, and you don't want to buy a refurbished years-old one.
2:09:58Whereas a MacBook, even a low-end one, if you get this new MacBook, which I think is really going to be the name, and it only costs $699, that's still like a major purchase, and you care about your laptop.
2:10:13And so it's just like a totally different mindset, I think.
2:10:16That's what I think Apple is thinking, because I kind of agree.
2:10:19It might be like for families and the kids, like you've got like a kid in middle school who's been begging.
2:10:26I would like a MacBook.
2:10:27I don't want to use Dad's old hand-me-down PC or whatever.
2:10:32For the terrible Chromebook that we have at school.
2:10:33Yeah, the terrible Chromebook that we have at school.
2:10:35I want a MacBook.
2:10:36And it's like, okay, if it's $699, we'll get you one.
2:10:40But then it's like the kid wants a fun one, because it's like a really big deal for them.
2:10:45I don't know.
2:10:46I think it's sort of, I'd like to see some colors in the 17e iPhone 2, or at least one color other than black and white.
2:10:53So I'm not saying that that won't be true.
2:10:55I don't know.
2:10:56I mean, and rumors aren't saying it.
2:10:57But I do think there's something different about the MacBook, and I think it's really kind of interesting that's what the rumors say.
2:11:02Now, who knows?
2:11:03Maybe we'll go to the event next week, and there's one color, silver.
2:11:06And I hope you'll like it.
2:11:08Yeah, I think it's going to be funny, though, if everybody who's got like a MacBook Air looks at those things and is like, where are my colors?
2:11:16I just got no colors over here.
2:11:17The role of color in Apple's product line is just endlessly fascinating.
2:11:22The better your MacBook gets, the fewer colors you have to choose from.
2:11:26It would be the first Mac laptop that's had appreciable color since the original iBooks.
2:11:31And when I was back in 2020, when I did the 20 Mac series, I thought about this a lot.
2:11:36And I think Apple philosophically has said, a laptop is a thing you take with you, especially for business, people who are doing work out in the world with their laptop.
2:11:48They maybe don't want to draw attention to themselves.
2:11:51And that a colorful laptop, while a fun idea, is maybe when those original iBooks were out there, they got feedback that they were just too garish.
2:12:05Yeah.
2:12:05Whatever reason, they literally stopped making colorful laptops after that.
2:12:10Other than that, whatever, the blue and the orange, they had a great one.
2:12:14The difference is that with those iBooks, they didn't have a plain version, right?
2:12:19You can sell plain colors alongside bright colors, like the iPhone 17 Pro, right?
2:12:25You could get the titanium-colored one.
2:12:27Very plain.
2:12:28You don't need to buy the orange.
2:12:29You don't need to buy orange.
2:12:31And that's my feeling, and that was my feeling about when they did the colorful iMacs recently, is they sell it in silver.
2:12:38I'm sure the silver one is the most popular one, because it's boring and it's generic.
2:12:42But if you want to put an orange one in your hotel lobby or whatever, you have the option of doing that, and that's pretty awesome.
2:12:48And they made the color-match keyboards and all of that.
2:12:51So I hope this is the start of a better trend.
2:12:53But I would love to see a Mac laptop with color.
2:12:55It's been so long.
2:12:57And we'll see.
2:12:59I mean, Apple will know exactly how many of those things they sell, and maybe we'll never see it again.
2:13:04But the idea that in a week there's going to be a green laptop out there somewhere, that's pretty cool.
2:13:10I'm looking forward to that.
2:13:10Yeah, and I really, you know, I wrote my report card, like one of my favorite things of 2025 for Apple was the shift from iPhone SEs to the 16e and putting the number in there, which implied right at the start, and here we are all expecting a 17e next week,
2:13:28that they're going to update this phone every year as opposed to every two to five years or whatever the totally erratic schedule of the SE updates was.
2:13:36And I think that's great.
2:13:38Like you emphasized just a few minutes ago that the M1 is still a totally credible system on a chip for processing speed, but there's all sorts of other things that are outdated five years later, right?
2:13:49And it would be nice to keep up to date for matter integration with the home and stuff like that, where if they can use the A series chips and put them in a lower cost MacBook and you get performance that actually beats the M1, but then also get relatively up to date Wi-Fi and Bluetooth and everything else.
2:14:15That's just like, hey, you can't just expect a five-year-old SKU to have a Wi-Fi standard that came out three years ago.
2:14:24It doesn't make any sense.
2:14:25It kind of solves that problem.
2:14:26Yeah.
2:14:27I, one of the things I'm curious about is to see how that MacBook's specs look and what they do kind of short of standard and what they do that seems surprisingly like standard.
2:14:38My guess is that they will lean toward having a little less margin or a little higher price in the beginning so that they can use that same design for a long time.
2:14:46Yeah.
2:14:47You put in the chip that's a little more expensive, but it means that you don't have to switch the chip for four years instead of having to switch it next year.
2:14:54And speaking of next year, like they make a new A series chip every year.
2:14:58So I'm not saying they would update this laptop every year, but they might.
2:15:02I think they would.
2:15:03They are updating most Macs every year now.
2:15:06Yeah.
2:15:06Because the Apple Silicon series just roll along.
2:15:09And that is the beauty of taking this M1 and putting it out to pasture, but having like an A18 MacBook is that you could just do an A19 MacBook and it won't be a big deal.
2:15:20It'll just be a speed bump and nobody will really care, but it allows them to kind of keep it kind of just keeping pace at the back of the performance line, but still relevant every year or year and a half.
2:15:31Yeah.
2:15:31Keep it the exact same form factor keyboard screen for four or five years.
2:15:36The only way they're going to be able to keep their margins up on this product is to keep it around for a long time.
2:15:41Yeah.
2:15:42But they can update the A series chip in it and still keep the rest of it exactly the same.
2:15:47And that's, I mean, that's how every Apple product works is they do a big redesign and then they stretch it out over four or five years.
2:15:52Yeah.
2:15:53Because every month that passes, the profit margin goes up.
2:15:57Yeah.
2:15:57And new anodized colors every year.
2:16:00Oh, let's do it.
2:16:01I'm there.
2:16:02So good.
2:16:03All right, Jason.
2:16:03Thank you for coming back.
2:16:05I'm no longer mad at you.
2:16:06Thank you, John.
2:16:07We buried the hatchet.
2:16:08We did.
2:16:09We buried the hatchet and I'm definitely not going to punch you when I see you next week.
2:16:13Well, this podcast did its job then.
2:16:17My thanks to our sponsors, I think, going in reverse order, Squarespace, where you can build a website, Sentry, a developer toolkit that you can integrate in your app for error monitoring and tracing, and Notion, the AI workspace where teams and AI agents, including new custom agents, get more done together.
2:16:37Yeah.
2:16:37And Jason is at SixColors.com, a whole bunch of podcasts at RelayFM and The Incomparable, including my favorite of his podcasts, Upgrade, but listen to those podcasts.
2:16:48And of course, you can follow along at SixColors, where new episodes of all the shows, just follow at SixColors.
2:16:54Yeah.
2:16:55You got it.
2:16:56Yeah.