0:00:00Hey there, it's your internet pal, John Gruber. I've got David Pogue on the show for this episode. The author, well, author of many, many books, but author of the new book, Apple, The First 50 Years. David is in the midst of a very, very tightly packed media tour to promote the book, and his time is really limited. It was really kind of serendipitous that I got him at all. I got him right out off an airplane after he arrived in Seattle,
0:00:29after being in Portland. Didn't have the length of time I would love to have had him, so it's a little bit
0:00:36shorter of an episode than usual, even though we could have gone longer than usual. And because his time was
0:00:43limited, literally he had gotten off an airplane and he had to go to an event. I didn't want to interrupt
0:00:48the show to do my sponsor reads live, so I'm going to unusually, for the talk show, record them in post
0:00:57and we'll insert them in editing. And the first one, I'll just knock it out right here is our good
0:01:03friends at Factor. Hey, Factor makes healthy eating easy with fully prepared meals designed by dieticians
0:01:10and crafted by chefs. You can eat well without the planning or cooking. There's all sorts of companies
0:01:17that make meal kits that get delivered to you and then they come with all the ingredients and they are
0:01:23great. You take the ingredients and you follow the recipe and you prepare a meal. Factor, the meals are
0:01:30already cooked. These are cooked meals that come, but they're fresh. They come like meal kits in a box that
0:01:37has dry ice because it's refrigerated. Everything is fresh, really high quality functional ingredients,
0:01:43including stuff like lean proteins, colorful veggies, whole food ingredients, healthy fats,
0:01:49no refined sugars, no artificial sweeteners, no refined seed oils. They have over a hundred rotating
0:01:55weekly meals to keep things fresh and delicious through the winter and into the spring months.
0:02:02They have options for different types of diets like high protein, calorie smart, Mediterranean diet,
0:02:07meals that are specific for people on GLP-1 medications, all sorts of stuff, ready to eat
0:02:12salads, breakfast food, which is one of my favorites, if not the favorite thing to get from Factor.
0:02:18I order Factor meals. I love them. They are super convenient, super tasty, very good portion size,
0:02:24you know, enough to be filling, but not enough to feel like, oh, this is too much. I really love
0:02:28everything about them. So where do you go to find out more? Head to factor meals.com slash talk show
0:02:36five zero off. That's factor meals.com slash talk show 50 off where the 50 is five zero and use that
0:02:46code talk show 50 off to get, you'll never guess 50% off and free breakfast for a year. Eat like a pro
0:02:54this month. This deal is for new subscribers only. It varies by plan. One free breakfast item per box
0:03:01for one year while subscription is active. Go to factor meals.com slash talk show 50 off. And now on
0:03:08to the show with special guest, David Pogue. David Pogue, welcome to the talk show. You probably should
0:03:15have been on long ago, but if there's ever a good time to have you on for the first time, it is to mark
0:03:20the release of your book, Apple the first 50 years, which came out, I believe a week ago.
0:03:26Well, give or take Tuesday. Yeah. Five days. And you are on a whirlwind book media tour. So
0:03:33traveling all over North America, I believe. Yeah, it's about 10 or 11 cities.
0:03:41And when was the CHM event? Ah, that was the first stop of the tour. That was the day after the book
0:03:47came out Wednesday, March 11. That was, that was one for the books. I'd watched yesterday. I'd put it
0:03:54off. I did not watch live because I wanted to watch on a big TV and I wanted to, you know, take my time
0:04:00and man, it was so good. I think, all right, let me start with this. Number one, I think the book,
0:04:07I have not finished it. I have to say, cause it is 600 dense pages, right? It is a big book. And I kind
0:04:14of feel bad about that because I think every time I've had the author of a book on the show, I have
0:04:18finished the book before the author came on. In this case, I feel like I don't need that. Because I can
0:04:27recommend the book wholeheartedly from like the introduction alone and the parts that I've cherry
0:04:32picked. It is so good. But it is also in addition to being 600 pages, it is 600 dense pages, right? It's
0:04:40beautiful, too. It is full color throughout. It's not like, oh, we're going to put 16 pages of color in the
0:04:47middle of the book. And I'm glad you mentioned that because literally that was a stern conversation
0:04:53with the publisher. They wanted to put 16 pages, you know, in the back and, you know, and you'd be
0:04:59reading along and it would say, please turn to page 582. Like, no, sorry. No, we're not. We're not
0:05:07doing a book that includes the iMac and the iPhone and printing most of it in black and white. We're just
0:05:13not. So I'm very grateful. It is heavy. It is thick. It is dense. It is packed with color photographs
0:05:20that are just terrific. It feels like what I think you meant for it to be, which is almost an
0:05:28encyclopedia of the first 50 years of Apple. Yeah, no, no, you're right. It did. It did come out exactly
0:05:34like what I envisioned. I'd say most of the Apple books that have come along so far are written by
0:05:40business authors, not technologists. And that's great. You know, there's there's great stories in
0:05:46the boardroom and, you know, the stock price and blah, blah, blah. But I've always been interested in
0:05:51the products and the technologies and the backstories, especially. So as you've probably seen, there's a lot of
0:05:57pictures of prototypes in there and and products that never made it to market. I actually got my
0:06:03hands on the one and only Apple fax machine. Already the ship canceled it the last. So I really do mean
0:06:14this with the utmost sincerity. I'm not sure there's any person on the planet better suited to have written
0:06:20this book than you. It is amongst the ways your background. You were a columnist at Macworld for 13
0:06:28years. You were the technology columnist at the New York Times, I think for the same number of years.
0:06:33Yeah, isn't that weird? Yeah, you're still, you know, writing and talking about technology, but more on TV
0:06:41than in in writing these days. You were literally a columnist for Macworld during a huge chunk of the
0:06:48middle of Apple's 50 years. Your time at the Times included being one of the four reviewers who got
0:06:57the iPhone in 2007. So you were right there, which gives you a first person perspective. But also, I
0:07:03think, a credibility with Apple to get the last 15 to 20 years, the Tim Cook era, for sure, covered in
0:07:13any way. Right? Which is, you know, and you've emphasized this in the book and at the event that
0:07:20Apple had no editorial control over this book, but they did help you in some ways. Can you talk about
0:07:25the participation of current Apple with the production of the book?
0:07:29Yeah, I mean, if you wanted to write a book about the beginning years of Apple,
0:07:34you're pretty golden because there's a lot of books, there's a lot of magazine articles,
0:07:38there are interviews with former Apple people that you can do. They've left Apple. They're no longer
0:07:43under NDA. The problem, as you so succinctly put it, was the last 15 years because everybody who was at
0:07:52Apple is still at Apple. And Apple's rule is our people do not speak to journalists as a rule, unless,
0:07:59as you know, from your onstage talk show with executives, when they're trying to make a point about AI or
0:08:07introduce a product or something. Then they handpick the people they want to speak to. So I was
0:08:11literally losing sleep. I mean, how am I going to do this? Who am I going to talk to? And it took six
0:08:18months of making my arguments to Apple. And I wrote a sample chapter so they could see what the tone was
0:08:25going to be like. And, you know, I stress that it's about the products and it's about the people who
0:08:30created them who don't usually get credit. And finally, they said, okay, we're going to line up
0:08:36a bunch of interviews. I mean, a lot of interviews, the entire Tim Cook executive team, engineers,
0:08:43designers, sensor people, the camera technicians. I mean, it was, it was incredible series. Four times
0:08:50I flew out to Apple Park over 2025 and interviewed back to back to back people. And, and they gave me
0:08:57access to the archives. So the two archives who I did, I, two archivists whom I did not meet until
0:09:05a couple of nights ago at a book signing, but I would submit lists of what I was hoping to find.
0:09:12And they came up with like 700 incredible images that have never been seen before.
0:09:18I've sort of suspected that they had archivists, but until you mentioned it at the CHM show,
0:09:24I wasn't sure they did. It's always there because part of, in addition to the culture of secrecy,
0:09:30which is about the current day and sort of does date back a surprising amount of time because
0:09:35the people at Apple have been there for so long, it's been steady leadership for a long time,
0:09:42but even more so under Tim Cook than it was under Steve Jobs, you know, ever since the
0:09:47ouster of Scott Forstall in 2012 and Tony Fidel leaving, the only real high level departure was
0:09:59Johnny Ive, which again, it wasn't like he was forced out. It was sort of, I mean,
0:10:05it's complicated, but everybody else who's there has been there since then and they're not going
0:10:11to talk. And even the people who did leave still tend not to talk. It's true. And there are always
0:10:20these reports of things, you know, that, that Apple has the, in addition to the culture of secrecy,
0:10:24they do have a culture and it comes from Steve Jobs. There's like the, the quote from him that,
0:10:29Hey, if you, I'm going to paraphrase, but if you've accomplished something good, take a moment,
0:10:35to enjoy it and then think about what's next and move on and make something else that's great. And
0:10:39Apple does as an institution sort of have that mindset of let's not look to the past. Let's look
0:10:45to the future. And there were stories that used to be the icon garden at the infinite loop park where
0:10:51they had these classic Mac OS bitmap icons, but yeah, like six feet tall. And then supposedly they
0:10:58were just like, yeah, let's get rid of them. And they just threw them out or something. I don't know.
0:11:02And there was a museum. There was a museum and they got rid of it.
0:11:05Yeah. But I guess they didn't throw this stuff out. They gave it to the donated it to the computer
0:11:10history museum or, or somebody. Yeah. But it's always been a question in my head of how does a
0:11:16company that is this, not repulsed, but this sort of afraid to dwell on the past, right? That I think
0:11:24that it's like, Hey, if we, if we dwell on the past, we're going to lose sight of the future. And that
0:11:29they've seen other technology companies that kind of latch on to their big success and, and ride it
0:11:37into the ground and never obviate their own successes, right? Like the prime example, the iPhone
0:11:45obviating the iPod, you know, teach that one in business school, you know, that they had, it was
0:11:52like the most successful thing Apple had made. It was only six years old at the time. People still
0:11:57remember it, you know, like it was a much longer era, the era of iPods. And they're like, yeah,
0:12:02once we make this thing, nobody's going to buy an iPod again. And they're like, sure, let's do it.
0:12:06They know that other companies over the years in technology would be like, well, we can't do a
0:12:11phone that's going to, you know, we should make it so that you have to connect your iPod to your iPhone
0:12:15to play music. So they still have to buy an iPod. And, but with that attitude, it's like,
0:12:22do they have an archive of all these photos? It's amazing that they do. It really, yeah,
0:12:27they do. And I understand that these archivists are having quite, quite a moment right now because,
0:12:32because Apple, you know, I interviewed Tim Cook a couple of weeks ago for a TV segment,
0:12:38and he admitted that, yes, the motto is we don't look back, we look forward, but obviously we have
0:12:45to commemorate the people who brought us here. He put that very, you know, very lovely way. And so he
0:12:50said, we are doing some stuff to celebrate the 50th, but it's quote, a new muscle for us. It's, it's,
0:12:58it's a little awkward. It's a little new that they have no mechanism in place for it. And, and one
0:13:03reason for that, by the way, is, you know, I had a couple of takeaways, even after having covered Apple
0:13:09for 40 years, you know, doing this book, I came away with a couple of things I hadn't really known.
0:13:15And one is how unbelievably intense it is to work there. I mean, people either quit immediately or they
0:13:25really love the mission and they stay for decades. But I mean, it is intense. And I, I interviewed John
0:13:32Rubenstein, Ruby, who was, you know, the head of hardware for the iMac, iPod, iPhone at the
0:13:38beginning. And I asked him, so it was his idea, by the way, it was Rubenstein who decided we're going
0:13:45to do a new one every year. Yeah. So that's why we get a new iPod and now a new operating system and
0:13:50now a new iPhone every single year. That was him originally because they were convinced that Sony
0:13:56was on their heels when they made this music player. Yes. Apple came across the world's first
0:14:02Oreo sized hard drive. They found it in a Toshiba meeting that Toshiba had come up with this and
0:14:08didn't have any takers for it. Didn't know what to do with it. And Rubenstein's like, uh, we know what
0:14:14to do with that. Uh, we'll buy right now. We'll write you a check for $10 million. We'll buy all you can
0:14:19manufacture. But after that point, he was convinced that Sony was going to come out that Christmas with a
0:14:25competitive project. As it turns out, Sony did not come out with a pocket hard drive based player the
0:14:31first year or the second year or the third year or the fourth year. The fifth year, they came out with
0:14:37a Sony MP3 player that, as you may remember, could not play MP3 files. Oh, that's right.
0:14:46It could only play Sony's proprietary format. So arguably a bad feature in an MP3 player.
0:14:51But, but what, what, what if you, if you described that to somebody, company A did it this way. Company
0:14:57B did it that way. That would sound like Apple to some people's ears, right? That Apple made the player
0:15:02that only played the proprietary format. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. That's right. But, but how this ties into your,
0:15:08to your comment is that Rubenstein said like, when they had the mini, which is the first product to sell
0:15:14hundreds of millions in Apple's history, I'm like, well, there must've been a big beer bash. There
0:15:19must've been, he's like, no, we never had time. We never had time. He said every time they launched
0:15:25something the next morning, there were all guns blazing on the next one. And that's the real reason
0:15:31they don't look back. They just don't have time. Yeah. And I know somebody at the computer history
0:15:37museum event even cited Andy Grove, who is from Intel, but his famous maxim that only the paranoid
0:15:43survive and that that's how Intel stayed on top for so long. And I think you could also say it's sort
0:15:50of how Intel has sort of fallen out of mention as one of the big tech companies in the last 15 years
0:15:57or so that they sort of lost that paranoid mindset of, you know, I think if they had it, they would
0:16:03have seen the initial iPhone. And when the iPhone took off and thought, Hey, we're not a part of this.
0:16:10Nobody's making these, whether it's Apple or whether it's the Android competitors, nobody's
0:16:14using Intel chips for these. We need to be in this game. We need to do whatever it takes to be in this
0:16:18game. And if that means all new chips, all new chips, it is, we need to be there. And instead they were
0:16:23like, ah, well, whatever, that's cute. But I do think that that mindset, it's sort of like
0:16:31when you're onto something, it's hard not to think, well, this is a great idea. And when you realize
0:16:39it's a great idea, it seems starts to seem obvious and you think, well, everybody else must be onto it
0:16:45too. And so when Apple realized this iPod idea is so great, we put it on the market. Each successive
0:16:51model is selling more than the next. There's obviously this huge demand to make it something
0:16:56other than a Mac peripheral to put a version of iTunes on windows so that it'll sync to anybody's
0:17:02PC. Surely every single competing company in the world, including the one whose design chops,
0:17:08we respect the most. Sony is going to come after this with guns a blazing because they're going to
0:17:14see what we've got our hands on right now. And no, they didn't. But they convinced themselves they
0:17:21did. And it motivated them just as much as if Sony were competing with them.
0:17:25That's right. And I'm doing these book talks. And one of the points I'm trying to make in the talk and
0:17:31the book is everybody knows that Steve Jobs could see the future, blah, blah, blah. But even in instances
0:17:38when everybody who knew anything about business or marketing knew that he was wrong. Like in the
0:17:44classic case is the iPod mini. Again, it was the best selling electronics project in history. Hundreds
0:17:52of millions a year. And Jobs said, right as it was ascending, it was ramping up. He said, okay,
0:17:59we're going to shut it down. And like, what are you doing? Like Rubenstein is like, no, Steve, no,
0:18:05no, this is wrong. This is crazy. And he's like, yeah, we're going to replace it with a new model
0:18:10that holds less music. Right. The nano, right? It's smaller and cuter, but it doesn't hold as much
0:18:16music. And the entire team is like, that's insane. People want the mini and Jobs shut down all the
0:18:24factories. He stopped ordering parts for the mini. He transferred all the marketing money to the
0:18:29nano and he was right. How, how did he know? I don't get it. Right. And it's that inflection point
0:18:38between spinning hard disks, which held more data, but which are fragile, slower, less reliable to SSD
0:18:47type storage that has no moving parts is, you know, much, much more reliable and smaller, but dollar for
0:18:55dollar holds fewer bites and therefore fewer songs. And yeah, there was something, your book and the
0:19:04event covered where early, if we go back in time, let's just zip all over the timeline here, but go back
0:19:12to the 1985 or so when Jobs was on the cusp of being ousted from Apple under John Scully. And Jobs came to
0:19:21Scully and said, Hey, we're getting, you know, the Macintosh is not selling as well as it should.
0:19:26It's because you made me price it at $2,500. We should, I, we need to get the price down.
0:19:31And Scully's answer was, well, you wanted a huge marketing campaign. It's the marketing dollars
0:19:36that are driving the price, keeping the price this high. And Jobs wanted Apple to stop marketing the
0:19:42Apple to take all the marketing money from the Apple to, so that they could lower the sales price of the
0:19:49Macintosh. And you know, people who weren't around in the eighties don't remember this, but it was the
0:19:56Apple to pretty much for most of the whole decade years after the came out. Then Apple's revenue was
0:20:02from the Apple to line and the future was the Macintosh, but the Macintosh wasn't selling enough to keep the
0:20:10lights on in Cupertino. It was the Apple to, and really that's what led to jobs as ouster. It was that
0:20:16simple. He wanted to kill the Apple too. And he probably was wrong. We don't know. We can't prove
0:20:21what would have happened if they said, okay, Steve, you know, whatever you want, we'll do it.
0:20:25But it probably wasn't going to happen. Like the people who were buying Apple twos and I, you know,
0:20:31I've told this story, like I was around, I was a kid at the time. I was like 10 years old, 10, 11, 12.
0:20:35I thought the Macintosh was interesting, but it wasn't to me, it wasn't really a computer in the way that it
0:20:41was computer was a computer. Like a computer was a thing that I turned on and I wrote software for
0:20:4710 print, you know, John is awesome. 20 go to 10, you know, and more, I, you know, I was writing more
0:20:54complicated program, but that's what a computer was. And the Macintosh wasn't that it was like, wow,
0:20:59this is really cool. And I was intrigued by it, but it really was a place where you ran software that
0:21:04was pre complex software written by other people that, that, that you ran apps basically in today's
0:21:10mindset. Whereas the Apple two, you wrote programs and you could run apps. There were word processors
0:21:17from Apple and other companies and spreadsheets and stuff like that. You could run apps, but you also
0:21:22wrote apps and it just was a different mindset. And that's what the market wanted. The market wanted,
0:21:27including the big education market, wanted computers where the kids could turn them on and start writing
0:21:33programs for their programming assignments. Right. And the Macintosh wasn't that. So I think jobs was
0:21:38wrong then. And that, you know, what did you call it in the book? The interregnum, you know, the period
0:21:43when he was gone, his exile, I often call it his exile. He was a different man when he came back.
0:21:49And it maybe it's probably all of the above, you know, the age wisdom with age, the humility of,
0:21:57of sort of being forced out of the company that was more successful. The fact that next never really
0:22:03took off, you know, it was sort of a footnote in the computer industry, Pixar hadn't really taken off
0:22:11yet. It was obviously a very interesting company that had a very bright future ahead of it, but
0:22:15wasn't the Pixar we knew, right? Toy Story didn't come out till 1997. I, you know, humility, age,
0:22:22I don't know, but he came back a very different person with, I think, a better sense of things like
0:22:28that, right? Well, yeah, because, because if you think about it, the entire Steve 1.0 era,
0:22:34he never had a successful product, right? So, I mean, Apple two, which is wise, but, you know,
0:22:40Apple three, nope, Lisa, no Macintosh. Nope, not for the first few years. Uh, next, nope. And then when he
0:22:47came back, he had almost nothing but tremendously successful products. I mean, right. iMac, iPod,
0:22:54iPad, iPhone, iMovie, iPhone, I'm just incredible run. And yeah, the, the two jobs could not be more
0:23:01different. Yeah. You can see the run through, right? The impulse is the same. That's why I thought back
0:23:07when you mentioned that he was like, nope, we're going to kill the hard drive based mini in favor of
0:23:13the smaller, cooler looking nano, even though dollar for dollar, it's going to store fewer songs
0:23:19because his, his like, it's most like, like in Star Wars terms, the force, like he could use the force
0:23:26and could tell, you know what, that's enough songs. And I think he was probably right where with the
0:23:32initial iPod, the 5,000 songs in your pocket, most people don't have 5,000 songs.
0:23:37And I mean, speaking of music, he was also dead wrong about people want to own their music.
0:23:44Yeah. He hated the Spotify model where you pay a monthly fee and he would say, and I remember
0:23:49being convinced by this. He said, the day you stopped writing a check to Spotify, you lose all
0:23:55your music. You've got nothing for having paid all that money, but it turns out that's the model people
0:24:00want. Yeah. It's, and it is the ownership. That's another thing too, where it is almost, it's, it's longer
0:24:07than like the iPod, but I was just talking about this, I guess with my wife, but that, you know, and we have a
0:24:13college age son and he just doesn't know the idea of owning music just doesn't really register for him.
0:24:20And we were trying, we were, as my wife and I went to college in the nineties and both of us, and I
0:24:28remember very vividly doing the math because it, that enormous part of my, the majority of my liquid
0:24:37net worth as a college student was tied up in compact discs, right? Because my bank, my, my actual ATM card,
0:24:46the other story I love to tell is that I went to Drexel here in Philly. I knew where the, I had a
0:24:51core state, one of those banks that got eaten by a bigger bank, eaten by a bigger bank, eaten by, you
0:24:56know, now it's part of probably bank America, who knows which bank, but core state's bank had an ATM
0:25:02on Drexel's campus that had no fees for me because I had a core state's bank account and gave $10 bills,
0:25:09which was important as a college student, because sometimes I had less than $20 in my checking account.
0:25:16But what I could do for money is take some of the CDs I had, go to the used CD store and sell them
0:25:24for a reasonable price to get cash. Right. And then if I wanted to buy CDs, I'd buy them used instead of
0:25:31buying brand new, but you know, I had hundreds and hundreds, I guess probably over, you know,
0:25:37thousands of dollars in CDs, you know, cause I, I owned all my music. I had a big collection of compact
0:25:43discs. And if I needed money, I would find some that was like, ah, I don't listen to that anymore.
0:25:48Take it to the used CD store. And all of a sudden I'd have 30 or 40 bucks in my pocket.
0:25:52It makes no sense. Try explaining that to the kids today. It makes. Yeah. Right. Yeah. Although I
0:25:59noticed, interestingly, iPods are suddenly hot again because of the cell phone, the smartphone
0:26:04bands in schools. So kids need a way to listen to music. That's allowed. And it's iPods.
0:26:09Yeah. And I will say my son, I noticed it cause we, we have an old car and it has a CD player.
0:26:15He's started filling it with CDs. Like it is sort of a retro, like the way that my generation
0:26:20got back into vinyl kids today are getting back into CDs, but it, the whole idea of owning music
0:26:28is sort of an interregnum, right? Because previously people just listened to the radio, right? You'd
0:26:33turn on the radio to listen to music. You didn't pay and you listened to ads in between songs. And
0:26:39then there was a period where people bought albums and for a while tapes and CDs. And now it's just
0:26:45pretty much back to the radio, except it's Spotify and Apple music.
0:26:48Right. Right. You're making it sound really old, John.
0:26:51I, well, we are. And it's, but it, but it is, I understand that Steve Jobs mentality of,
0:27:02Hey, I don't want to pay anybody any more money. I already own all of Led Zeppelin's albums,
0:27:06right? It's, I've paid once for the box set. I don't need to pay anymore. Um, I'm trying to think
0:27:14what, again, we could talk forever, but there is the, in the jobs 1.0 era of Apple. And I think
0:27:21your book makes this point clear. There really wasn't a strong CEO figure. Jobs was not the CEO
0:27:27at the time, right? It was Mike Scott for a while and nobody, that's like a name you just never hear
0:27:34anymore. Nobody's ever like, yeah, remember Mike Scott. Those were good times at Apple. No,
0:27:39you know, he just, he just died and there wasn't a whisper of press release, memorial acknowledgement,
0:27:47nothing. In fact, I will say that that's one really meaningful thing about the 150 interviews I did for
0:27:53this book. Four of those guys have now died or become unable to speak since I did the interviews,
0:28:00including Bill Atkinson. Uh, it was his last interview. And so, uh, really, I'm glad I did this
0:28:08when I did. I think that's just to go back. I think that's why the 50th anniversary is so
0:28:14special. Like it is a big round number, right? Obviously a hundred in our numeric system is a
0:28:21bigger number, but we're not going to be around. None of the people who are around are going to be,
0:28:27none of these people are going to be around for Apple's hundredth anniversary, unless Apple health
0:28:32is a better success than, than we anticipated being right. 50 is the big number where it's the
0:28:41biggest number where the people involved are still going to be around to be interviewed and tell their
0:28:46stories for it. And it's also a further blessing that when Apple was founded and through the eighties,
0:28:54so many of the principal players were so young, right? So that 50 years later, there's still,
0:29:03you know, as, as the fact that some of them like Bill Atkinson, and of course, Steve jobs,
0:29:08you know, have already passed and that some of them are starting to fall to other things like dementia
0:29:14and things like, or just faulty, you know, just the memories. Now, maybe they're not suffering from
0:29:19dementia, but they don't remember what happened 48 years ago, which, you know, right happens to
0:29:25everybody eventually. This is the one where it's, it's the sweet spot of an anniversary that hits the
0:29:31most number of people who are still there can recall the stories. Yeah. Bingo. And fortunately there's
0:29:37one and only one person who's been at Apple for all 50 years. He joined when he was 14. It's Chris
0:29:45Espinosa. He's still there. And thank God, he not only has been there, but he has a steel trap memory
0:29:53for detail. He's a great storyteller and he's an incredible technologist. Like, like his explanation
0:30:00of what went wrong with the Apple three, I've never seen written anywhere. And it was, it was golden.
0:30:06He is one of a kind. He was 14 when he started working there. I think you cracked a joke at the,
0:30:12on the stage event. Like, I don't know what the California child labor laws were at the time.
0:30:16His mom would drive him to the homebrew computer club meetings and wait outside in the parking lot.
0:30:24He couldn't drive. But still there. And he's not there in any kind of ceremonial sense. To my
0:30:32knowledge, I think he still runs the developer tools group, right? Or do you know? He's working in
0:30:37a TVOS now, but he's been worked on all kinds of places. Right. Yeah. Yeah. And what a guy he told
0:30:43me that his, sorry, he told me that he's, his phone is blowing up this week and his cubicle is constantly
0:30:51darkened by people stopping in both, both because of the computer history museum event. And that's now,
0:30:58you know, on YouTube and getting a lot of attention, but also just because he's the guy who's been there
0:31:03for 50 years. Continuously in positions of relevance and remembers the details like that.
0:31:10I don't want to spoil it because I've told, I've linked to it on Daring Fireball. I want people to
0:31:14watch the event. I don't want to spoil too much of it, but the story of the heat problems with the Apple
0:31:20Apple III. It's the absolute best. And like you said, there are so many apocryphal stories in Apple
0:31:29history and that you ruthlessly tried to weed those out. Like, well, that didn't really happen. And then
0:31:34you heard the story of the Apple III overheating and you're like, well, that didn't happen. And then you
0:31:38found multiple sources. You're like, no, that was exactly what happened. Basically. Yeah. It doesn't
0:31:42spoil the whole thing, but this will, we'll give him a hint. So just the thing about it. So jobs turns
0:31:49out, didn't like fans. So he wouldn't allow a fan to be in the Apple III. So it got 220 degrees inside
0:31:57there. Like people would pull the floppy drives out of the slot and they'd be melting. It was really hot in
0:32:04there. And basically pins would expand and, and daughter boards would come loose and the thing
0:32:10would shut off. And so Apple, according to legend, sent out a service bulletin to all the dealers
0:32:17saying, if your customers come in complaining that their Apple III's are shutting off, tell them to lift
0:32:22it two or three inches off the desk and drop it. And that will receipt the posts onto the daughter
0:32:29board and it works. But I thought, no way is that story true, but nope. Found the original designer of
0:32:37the Apple III. And he goes, yeah, it works. Why would we not tell people that is a sort of difference
0:32:43between then Apple and today's Apple? Yeah. Imagine if like there was a cellular reception issue with the
0:32:53iPhone and the solution was to drop it six inches off the table onto the table. And that, that'll
0:32:59reseat the cellular modem. Oh, I thought you were going for a joke. I thought you were going to say,
0:33:03imagine if there were a cellular reception issue and they told you that you were holding it wrong.
0:33:07Almost the same thing. That's probably the closest we've come to a similar, similar issue. You're,
0:33:16you're seating your pins wrong. It was one you're holding it wrong is another. All right. I'm going to
0:33:24take this break here and thank our friends at notion notion brings all your notes, docs, and projects into
0:33:32one connected space that just works. It is seamless, flexible, powerful, and actually fun to use with AI
0:33:39built right in. You spend less time switching between tools and more time creating great work. And now
0:33:47with notion agent, your AI doesn't just help with work. It finishes it. Notion agent can do anything
0:33:53you can do in notion. It can tap into your notion workspace, the web and connected tools like Slack and
0:34:00Google drive to complete assigned actions end to end. So you can focus on the hard decisions, do the stuff
0:34:07you want to do and let notion agent complete the sort of tedious, busy work involved in assembling
0:34:15documents and notes and meeting notes and stuff like that. It can complete multi-step tasks like
0:34:21creating new pages or entire databases from scratch or simply editing them or summarizing entire projects
0:34:28in minutes. You assign the tasks and your agent does the work. Notion agent has enhanced database
0:34:35querying capabilities. This is the advantage of using a system, a shared system. It could be personal. You
0:34:42can use notion all by yourself or you can use it with a team. And with AI built right in notion can do so
0:34:50much more than you can using a separate notes or database that you connect to a separate AI tool notion is
0:34:57used by over 50% of fortune 500 companies. And some of the fastest growing companies like open AI ramp and
0:35:05verse L use notion agent to help their teams send fewer emails, cancel more meetings and stay ahead.
0:35:12Try notion now with notion agent at notion.com slash talk show. That's all lowercase letters notion.com slash
0:35:22talk show to try your new AI teammate notion agent today. And when you use that link, you're supporting the
0:35:29notion.com slash notion.com slash talk show. Before we continue into the minutia of some of these stories,
0:35:36I talking about your writing the book itself. Like when did you decide to write the book? And was there a
0:35:43point where you got worried that there would be too many of these Apple at 50 books coming out? Because as it
0:35:49turns out, it seems like yours is the only one. It's the only one. I'm boggled. I mean, not even Apple,
0:35:56not nobody. I'm absolutely. It's like John Rubenstein with Sony. It is. That's exactly what
0:36:04made me think of the question, right? Was there a point where you're like halfway through this book
0:36:08and you know, you've got gold, right? You're like, I've got sources. I've got these great stories. This
0:36:14is coming together. There are going to be a zillion of these books. I mean, I was worried for the entire
0:36:21two years. So I hosted another thing at the computer history museum in 2024 to celebrate the max 40th
0:36:27anniversary. And they brought back Bill Atkinson and Andy Hertzfeld and Susan Kerr and Steve Capps and
0:36:33Bruce Horn and Guy Kawasaki and all these legends from the Macintosh days. And that's on YouTube too. That
0:36:40was unbelievable. It was just, you know, the audience is like Woodstock and these guys were laughing and
0:36:47crying and PTSD. It was, it was really an unforgettable night. And so it was actually
0:36:53my wife's idea, this Apple at 50. She woke me up a few weeks later. I was supposed to be working on a
0:36:57different book for Simon & Schuster. And she woke me up and she's like, you should dump that other book
0:37:02and do a book about Apple's 50th. And I told this on stage, I literally shut her down. I'm like,
0:37:09Nikki, you missed that. That's gone. That date is come and gone. And then in the morning, I looked
0:37:13it up and she was right. It's, it's, it was two years away, just enough time to write a 600 page book
0:37:19if you're crazy. But the part that worried me most was I felt really intense pressure about the different
0:37:29contingents, the different groups of people who were going to pin expectations on this book,
0:37:35right? So there's Apple fans and they want to know the internal stories, the fun stuff,
0:37:40the making of the origin stories. There are Apple haters who are going to be looking over my shoulder
0:37:46to make sure I'm not kissing their ass and not giving them a pass on, you know, Foxconn suicides or
0:37:52whatever it is. There are the people I'm interviewing and man, this was crazy. A lot of these guys are older
0:37:59and I could see in their eyes, this was their shot at immortality. They wanted the story, right? They
0:38:09wanted the credit due to them. They wanted the old mistakes that have been passed on from author to
0:38:14author corrected. And it was so important to them that the story be told correctly, you know, and then
0:38:22there's, who is the book for? Is it, are there going to be business schools who want to know about the
0:38:27financial shenanigans that Fred Anderson did to save the company in 1996? Are there going to be casual
0:38:32readers who aren't Apple diehards, but they just like a really good yarn? I mean, this is the greatest
0:38:39corporate turnaround in history. They went from six weeks from bankruptcy to making a $45 million profit
0:38:46in one year. I mean, that's unbelievable. So that was the biggest stress is I felt all these different
0:38:53audiences, you know, you missed it. You didn't say this, you were to this. Uh, so I felt like it was
0:38:59threading 10 needles so far. I think I pulled it off. I think so too. I, it reads great. I have a very
0:39:06specific question. There's a part where you're talking about the original iPhone and you talk about what the
0:39:13New York times technology columnist said about it at the time. Now that's you, right?
0:39:20Yes. Yes. That was me. I mean, what am I going to do? I wrote this in the New York times. So the
0:39:29solution, and there's a few of those, there's a few times where I'm quoting reviews, but they were my
0:39:34own. Uh, you're the only person, John, you're the only person to catch that. And it's, it's funny
0:39:41because like in certain tertiary ways, I was a character in the Apple story. And this one did not
0:39:50make it in the book. And I've never told this story in public, but the way you take a screenshot
0:39:56on the iPhone press to up internally, they call that the pogue feature. Huh? And I'll tell you why
0:40:03in 2007, I was writing the first iPhone missing manual, how to book about the iPhone. And there was
0:40:10no way to create screenshots with the original iPhone. And so I contacted Apple PR and said,
0:40:16you have screenshots in your ads and your documentation. You must have a way to take
0:40:22screenshots. And they're like, well, yes, we have a very, you know, not polished looking
0:40:26internal tool that we use. And I'm like, can I have it for this book? So it looks good. And they
0:40:33went all the way up to Steve. And the answer was no. They said, you can fly to Cupertino and you can sit
0:40:40in a conference room here under supervision and use our tool to take your screenshots. I'm like, okay,
0:40:46great. I'll book my flight. And then two days later, they said, Steve's changed his mind.
0:40:51You can't use the tool at all, but we will set aside an engineer. If you describe exactly every
0:41:00screenshot you want, you know, this is a spreadsheet in the first column, it's revenue. You describe
0:41:04exactly what you want. We'll have this engineer make the screenshots for you. So this poor slob whom
0:41:12I've never identified spent the entire summer taking 400 screenshots for this book.
0:41:20So then cut to, and they were beautiful and they worked out great, but then cut to a year later,
0:41:26the second annual iPhone comes out and I called Apple PR. They're like, no, no effing way. We are
0:41:34not doing that. We're not giving you an engineer for the whole summer. We will put in a feature
0:41:40built into the iPhone. You press these two buttons and you take a screenshot. So that is with us today on
0:41:46every iPhone and every Android phone. And that was for David Vogt.
0:41:51That's well, job well done. But you, you have been a player in this, like, you know, being the back page or
0:41:58at one of the back page columnist in Macworld magazine was a thing. It really was. And you've been writing
0:42:09about this stuff for a long time. You know, the missing manual series was super influential and that was your imprint. I remember you wrote the user manual for Conflict Catcher.
0:42:24Yeah. Right. And now, and what's his name? Jeff.
0:42:28Jeff Robin.
0:42:29Jeff Robin, who is still at Apple and has been, at least my knowledge, he's still at Apple, was in charge of iTunes, might still be our Apple Music for a long time, the software.
0:42:41But before he went to Apple, before he wrote the music player sound jam that Apple purchased that became iTunes, he had this utility for the classic Mac OS called Conflict Catcher, which, and again, a description of Conflict Catcher is going to sound crazy to people who weren't around for the tail end of the classic era.
0:43:03But to really trick out a Macintosh in the 90s, you would install third-party system extensions and control panels that would add features to the operating system, depending on what business you were in or what fun stuff you wanted to do.
0:43:19But if you were in graphic design, almost everybody ran Adobe Type Manager, just to name one that was very serious.
0:43:26And Adobe Type Manager was a way to get PostScript fonts to render on screen beautifully.
0:43:32And it had anti-aliasing before the system did anti-aliasing.
0:43:36But because all this stuff came from third parties, they often conflicted with each other because they would patch the same traps in the operating system.
0:43:45And if two extensions were trying to write to the same magic spot, you'd have a conflict.
0:43:51And your computer might not boot up successfully.
0:43:55And you'd have to boot up with the shift key down and take half your extensions out and see if that did the trick.
0:44:02And if it did, put those half back in, take the other half out.
0:44:06And, you know, it was this whole thing to try to figure out which to extend.
0:44:09Jeff wrote Conflict Catcher, and it could identify the conflicts before they happened.
0:44:15And you could make sets of extensions so that if you were doing graphic design work, you'd have these extensions enabled.
0:44:22And if you were going to switch to doing music, something I'll bet you did, right?
0:44:26And you'd have different extensions so that, like, a MIDI keyboard could connect to your Mac.
0:44:30Switch to a different set of extensions.
0:44:32Restart the computer.
0:44:33You wrote the manual, and the manual, it didn't read like a manual.
0:44:36It read like a David Pogue book.
0:44:38It was – so, like, when you bought Conflict Catcher, you got two things.
0:44:44You got incredibly useful software as a power user on the Macintosh.
0:44:48But you got a David Pogue book in David Pogue's voice.
0:44:52And me, you know, and you – this is like 1997 or something, I guess.
0:44:58I already knew what I wanted to do with my career, which was sort of do what you did.
0:45:06And I'm like, this is amazing because it's – A, it's great software.
0:45:10But B, there is a place for somebody who wants to write with a voice and with style and inform people, right?
0:45:18Like, your book, the manual for it taught people how they wouldn't even need Conflict Catcher, right?
0:45:25It was like, here's the reason why you need it.
0:45:27If you want to, you could just take this information and do it on your own.
0:45:30But since you already have the book in your hands, you probably paid for the software.
0:45:33And here's why owning the software will make your life easier.
0:45:35Yeah, well, I can't believe you remember the Conflict Catcher manual.
0:45:39I'm so glad you liked it.
0:45:41But the Jeff Robbins story goes back even farther.
0:45:45I don't think I've really ever talked about this either.
0:45:47Jeff Robbins rose to prominence at Apple because he wrote iTunes, the app, right?
0:45:53Right.
0:45:53But that was not Jeff Robbins' first music app for the Mac in the late 80s when I was still a Broadway conductor.
0:46:02I was a musician.
0:46:03I had a job on the side working for a company called Music Theater International.
0:46:09This is the company that rents out Fiddler on the Roof or Les Miserables if your school wants to do it, right?
0:46:15And our CEO thought, it's too hard for some junior high school choir teacher to play these difficult pieces of music,
0:46:25to teach the kids the songs and the choral parts.
0:46:29What if we had a little app and it could play MIDI files?
0:46:32It could play just the Sopranos, now just the Tenors, and now here's the dance break but at half speed.
0:46:38It was basically a MIDI sequencer early on.
0:46:41And I was put in charge of that project and I found this kid, this genius young programmer to write our MIDI playback app,
0:46:51the Rehearse Score, intercapped S in the middle, Rehearse Score.
0:46:55And so Jeff Robbins and I worked together to write a music playback app long before he would then go on to write iTunes.
0:47:04But I like to say I'm the one who got Jeff Robbins his toe in music software.
0:47:09Well, that's an unbelievable story.
0:47:12But again, with the talented teenagers or young people, you know, precocious programmers doing amazing things with these computers that seem so technically primitive in their capabilities to today's eyes.
0:47:27But doing amazing things.
0:47:29Yeah.
0:47:29No, I definitely remember the conflict capture manual because I remember thinking there might be a future for me writing about this stuff, you know.
0:47:36And turns out.
0:47:37Yes.
0:47:38Maybe.
0:47:40We were talking before that in the early years of Apple, the Steve Jobs 1.0 era, they didn't really have a charismatic or influential CEO, really.
0:47:49The products of those early years from 76 through Jobs' ouster, or I guess when Scully came in, which was like 1983.
0:47:57That's right.
0:47:59The products were just driven by the two Steves, right?
0:48:02The Apple II was clearly more the Waz computer and then, you know, the Lisa and the Macintosh, you know, the Steve Jobs computers.
0:48:10There really have only been – there haven't been a lot of CEOs in Apple's history.
0:48:15But the three main ones, and I think they define three eras of the company, John Scully, 1983 to 93, Jobs from the return with Next in 1997 through his death in 2011, and then Tim Cook after that.
0:48:34Right.
0:48:35And those three CEOs, those three eras are very different, right?
0:48:41Like your book even opens with somebody, a woman who's been there since like 19 – somewhere in the 90s, and she's like, I've worked for five different companies, but they're all named Apple.
0:48:51That's right.
0:48:53You had Scully on stage for the CHM thing, and I thought that was a pretty cool thing because as much as you can see the mistakes,
0:49:05that he made and the way that he wasn't the right person for the long run, overall, he was a successful CEO, right?
0:49:14Like I think that the idea that, hey, he's the guy who ran Steve Jobs out of the company, and then he got run out himself, and he was the guy behind the Newton, and the Newton was a joke.
0:49:24So therefore, he was sort of a bum, you know?
0:49:27And that really isn't fair to the Scully decade at all.
0:49:31No, it's amazing.
0:49:34I mean, he also was the guy who got the Macintosh onto Rift processors, which are still with us today.
0:49:41He developed QuickTime.
0:49:42He developed the PowerBook.
0:49:44He put Apple on the laptop map with the PowerBooks.
0:49:48Huge, huge success.
0:49:50They sold a billion dollars worth of PowerBooks the first year.
0:49:54He did a lot of things that kept the company growing and thriving.
0:49:57The first speech recognition that happened under Scully, I do think he's gotten a little bit of a bum rap.
0:50:03I mean, he wasn't Steve Jobs.
0:50:04Nobody is Steve Jobs.
0:50:05But he did keep the innovation going, and I would say he was even more of a product idea guy than Tim Cook is.
0:50:14I mean, remember the 1987 concept video that Scully would show off at educational conferences, the Knowledge Navigator.
0:50:21I mean, it was a mock-up of a six-minute short film about a professor in the future who comes in with an Apple-branded folding tablet.
0:50:32It is very obviously an iPad, except that it folds in half and expands with a front-facing camera, and he's on the Internet, which was still six years away, and there's an AI bot in the corner talking to him, which was decades away.
0:50:49In natural language, right?
0:50:51In natural language, yeah.
0:50:52Right.
0:50:53And he's doing a video conference.
0:50:56You know, it's FaceTime.
0:50:57Decades before there was FaceTime.
0:50:59I mean, the number of technologies on display in that little video that didn't exist then but now do exist in almost exactly that form is stunning.
0:51:09And, of course, the answer is not necessarily, oh, they were so visionary, they knew where technology was going.
0:51:15It might be the other way around, but that video was so influential that people thought, oh, maybe there should be multi-touch.
0:51:22Maybe there should be wireless Internet.
0:51:24Yeah.
0:51:25So we don't know which is the cause.
0:51:26And the Newton gets a bad rap in and of itself, not just the Scully era.
0:51:32I had one, and it was unsat.
0:51:35There was something unsatisfying about it.
0:51:37And the big obvious thing that was missing from all of those devices, and then I wound up with the Handspring visor on the Palm, but not a Palm-branded one.
0:51:47It was like the Palm founders went and founded a sort of an Apple-like story where they left, started their own company, Handspring, and licensed the OS, and then made better products than the company.
0:51:59Right.
0:52:00But all of those devices, the Newton or the Palm, the big missing thing was always on wireless Internet, right?
0:52:07And they didn't have wireless Internet at all.
0:52:09They all predated Wi-Fi, let alone cellular data networking.
0:52:13And it turns out that all of those things, not that they were useless, but they were almost useless.
0:52:19And if you think about what people do with their phones and have ever since 2007 when the iPhone came out, it's about being connected to a network at all times.
0:52:29Yeah, that's great.
0:52:30That's the secret.
0:52:31And you could talk about multi-touch and the color and the size of the phone and the simplicity of just having that one home button on the front.
0:52:39All of those were great.
0:52:40You know, the software, keyboard.
0:52:42But what did you need the keyboard for?
0:52:44It was for texting emails and text messages to people, right?
0:52:47Yeah.
0:52:48Yeah, that's great.
0:52:49I mean, there are exceptions, and there are people who've written books by thumb-typing them on their phones, but not a lot, you know.
0:52:56I'm guessing that out of the 600 pages of your book here, you didn't type many of them with your thumbs.
0:53:03I would say zero.
0:53:04But the interesting thing that you mentioned, that these things were worthless without wireless, reminds me of the iPhone story.
0:53:11When it came out, it sold only okay.
0:53:14It did not sell because it came with 16 apps and jobs, you know, Mr. Closed Systems.
0:53:20He would not allow an app store.
0:53:23For the first year, there was no app store, and people started, as I'm sure you remember, jailbreaking these phones using illegal tactics to install their own apps.
0:53:33And Scott Forstall, who was the head of software for the iPhone and Mac OS X and other projects, who is now a Broadway producer.
0:53:42Affinity with you, right?
0:53:44He's not done an interview with a journalist since he left Apple.
0:53:49One thing for the Computer History Museum, and that was it.
0:53:51But I made him a QuickTime video of me playing the opening of Hadestown, for which he was an investor, and sang to him, begging him for an interview.
0:54:03Anyway, so he told me this incredible story that people started jailbreaking the phone, and Forstall would show jobs.
0:54:10Like, honestly, these are cool apps.
0:54:13And Dad would be like, all right, all right, I'm convinced.
0:54:16Here's what we're going to do.
0:54:18You and I are going to sit down, and we're going to make a list of every app anyone could ever think of.
0:54:25And then you are going to assemble the world's largest army of Apple engineers to write every program.
0:54:32So he wanted to have his cake and eat it, too.
0:54:35He wanted both to have a closed system, right, because all the apps would be written by Apple,
0:54:40and an open system in that he wanted to write every app there could ever be.
0:54:45I mean, total insanity.
0:54:47So Forstall said...
0:54:49I just read that, and Jobs told him, I'll give you a blank check.
0:54:52Yeah, that's right.
0:54:54That's right.
0:54:55And Forstall was like, okay, this is pure insanity.
0:54:59And behind Jobs' back, went to his team and said, here's what we're really going to do.
0:55:04We're going to start building the foundations of an app store.
0:55:06And so by the time Jobs finally came around after a year, okay, okay, we'll open an app store up to anyone.
0:55:14Forstall was ready to say, guess what?
0:55:17I've done most of the work for you.
0:55:19And Jobs was like, oh, you son of a bitch.
0:55:22And that was when the iPhone really took off, because not just apps, but entire businesses, you know, DoorDash and Airbnb and Tinder and Uber and Lyft and all of those things from that app.
0:55:34It just couldn't exist otherwise, really couldn't.
0:55:35I'd heard pieces of that story before from other reports, other books, things that I've been told, but I've never heard it, that part of it, that Forstall told you for the book.
0:55:48That Jobs, at one point, became convinced, well, obviously we need more apps for the phone, but we'll just write them all?
0:55:57I have never heard before.
0:56:00And that is a total Steve Jobs idea.
0:56:03And I've met Scott a few times, not recently, but since, you know, it was when he was still at Apple.
0:56:08But I can see why he got along so well with Steve Jobs, but also there's a practical side to him.
0:56:16That he recognized the folly of that in a way that Steve Jobs, even at his peak as CEO, maybe couldn't recognize the folly of thinking that Apple could, you know.
0:56:30If there was only going to be one word processing app for the iPhone, where's the competition going to come from, right?
0:56:36If there's no competition, you know, and then Jobs' mind is, well, we're going to hire all the best engineers, so there doesn't need to be competition because we'll have the best designers and the best engineers.
0:56:45So, of course, it'll be the best possible theoretical word processor for the iPhone, so we don't need competition.
0:56:50And anybody else would be like, no, that's not how the world works, right?
0:56:56And that's a through line of Apple, though.
0:56:58Like, people being so convinced secretly that Jobs was wrong that they contradicted him privately.
0:57:05I mean, this goes back to the first Mac.
0:57:07The first Mac was going to come with 128K of memory.
0:57:12And everybody could see Moore's law at work.
0:57:14They knew that by the time this thing shipped, it would be obsolete, that memory would be cheaper.
0:57:20And so, Burl Smith, this genius hardware engineer they had, he secretly put traces in there, like copper circuits on the circuit board,
0:57:29that would permit hobbyists to expand the memory without having to buy a whole new Mac.
0:57:33And thousands of people, without telling Jobs.
0:57:37On the bill of lading, like on the list of parts that they had to pay for, they called it something hilarious,
0:57:44like commensurate free module or something like that.
0:57:47It wouldn't let Jobs know that it was a memory expansion slot.
0:57:52And there are a bunch of stories like that.
0:57:54In fact, the story of how Jobs got back to Apple.
0:57:57In 1986, Apple was about to buy B.
0:58:00Remember?
0:58:01The Jean-Louis guy say?
0:58:02Yes, yeah.
0:58:03Yeah, 96.
0:58:04Yeah.
0:58:05Because Apple desperately needed an operating system.
0:58:08The Mac OS still was not a modern, had no memory protection or multitasking, really.
0:58:14And so, this guy at Next, where Jobs had failed to create the next hardware computer, but had a kick-ass OS, Next Step,
0:58:25this guy who is a developer relations guy, not even on Jobs' team, at the risk of his job,
0:58:32he called Apple's CTO without anyone's permission and said, I think you should look at our OS.
0:58:40Why are you messing with this BOS thing?
0:58:43Ours is so much more complete and so much better.
0:58:46And so, Ellen Hancock, the CTO, called Jobs and said, okay, I hadn't thought about this,
0:58:52but let's set up a meeting and show me.
0:58:54And so, this guy, who all writes Garrett Rice's name, by all means, he should have been fired.
0:59:00Instead, Jobs hailed him in an all-hands meeting and wrote him a check for 20 grand for going rogue and then calling up Apple.
0:59:11There's a picture on, as we talk about this transition from Scully, who got forced out in 93, and then Jobs coming back in 97.
0:59:18There's a picture on page 251.
0:59:21I'll show it to you.
0:59:21I'll try to put it in the album art here for the chapter.
0:59:25But it's Scully's executive team.
0:59:29And it's Scully's executive team from left.
0:59:33Kevin Sullivan, Joe Graziano, I think he was the CFO.
0:59:36Michael Spindler, who took over for Scully in the intervening years.
0:59:40And as you report, and multiple people have reported, he had anxiety attacks.
0:59:45He would hide under his desk, curled up in a fetal position.
0:59:49It's true.
0:59:50David Nagel and Al Eisenstadt.
0:59:51It's six white guys, all wearing identical navy blue suits, all with white shirts and ties.
1:00:00And that is clearly not what the executive leadership team at Apple should look like.
1:00:07I had a conversation with Phil Schiller, like off the record, just a couple years ago.
1:00:13And I don't know how we got talking about it, but it was one of the court cases, maybe the epic one.
1:00:19I don't know, but something where he had been testifying in court.
1:00:22And he said, you know, I only wear a suit for three things, weddings, funerals, and when I have to go to court for Apple.
1:00:31And two out of the three of those are not good.
1:00:34They're not happy occasions.
1:00:36Phil is a great storyteller.
1:00:40You know, during this interregnum period when Apple just sank and sank and sank and sank and they had 50 different Mac models and 12 different ad agencies and everything was going to hell, just fiefdoms and redundancies.
1:00:53Phil told me that at one point, two Apple trademark lawyers showed up in trademark court to sue each other.
1:01:01That definitely sounds like Apple of the time, right?
1:01:06Yeah, exactly.
1:01:07It was almost like a federation of individual fiefdoms.
1:01:10But the gist of it was that, like Phil said to me, that if it's a wedding or a funeral, you have one good suit and you could work for both.
1:01:18But when you're going to court every day, you need a bunch.
1:01:20And so like every time you'd have to like go out and buy suits because he didn't own them.
1:01:24You know, he's a longtime senior vice president of Apple.
1:01:27By the time he stepped aside and became an Apple fellow, you know, they were the biggest company in the world and he didn't own suits because he didn't need to because he worked at Apple.
1:01:37And I never worked at Apple, but I've always been fascinated by the company.
1:01:41And I remember as a kid in the 80s, I read a story about the company and it said all of the engineers showed up at work in T-shirts and jeans and sneakers.
1:01:50And they were like, yeah, we just want to be comfortable.
1:01:52Why in the world should we dress up?
1:01:54You know, why would we put a suit, shirt and tie?
1:01:57And I remember telling my dad this and my dad said, John, there is no computer company out there where you show up to work in a T-shirt and jeans.
1:02:03And I'm like, I'm telling you, dad, then they make the best computers.
1:02:07They make the best.
1:02:08And he's like, John, that's not true.
1:02:09But there's something to that, though, where fundamentally Scully wasn't meant to be there for long.
1:02:17He got Apple up and running, but it wasn't meant to last, right?
1:02:22Yeah.
1:02:23And that was the funniest part in that Computer History Museum event that you watched.
1:02:26I asked him, so you were there 10 years.
1:02:29What's the story of your leaving?
1:02:31And he goes, I was fired.
1:02:33Pure and simple.
1:02:36I mean, there's just so much like nobody's Steve Jobs, like not even in Apple, outside Apple.
1:02:43Tim Cook gets this knock.
1:02:45He's not a product person.
1:02:46They've had no big hits, like Steve Jobs-level hits since he took over.
1:02:50AirPods and Apple Watch are both accessories for the iPhone.
1:02:54They're not new platforms.
1:02:55The Vision Pro failed.
1:02:57The car, they spent $10 billion developing a car.
1:03:00That failed.
1:03:01But on the other hand, nobody in the world has come up with a Jobs-level new platform either since he died.
1:03:08So it may just be that that was a perfect era of miniaturization and Chinese manufacturing and the public getting used to technology and that Jobs was there at the right time and that the world has now moved on to software and services, which is, of course, exactly where Tim Cook took the company.
1:03:26Yeah.
1:03:27And I thought your book covers it well and I thought the event covered it well, that it is sort of an unfair knock.
1:03:34And the iPhone really is the culmination of what Apple was set out to make.
1:03:40And at this point, the iPhone is almost, you know, next year will be 20 years.
1:03:45So it's about 40% of the company's history, you know, time-wise.
1:03:50But the first 30 years, in hindsight, clearly were just leading up to the iPhone.
1:03:58That that truly is.
1:03:59It was the slogan for the Macintosh, the computer for the rest of us.
1:04:03But the iPhone truly is the computer for the rest of us.
1:04:06And I think even the people at Apple, even Steve Jobs himself, I think they had had so many false starts of, oh, this is the one that's going to set the whole world on fire and get 2 billion users or 2.5 billion, whatever Apple's at now, which is mostly iPhone users.
1:04:25You know, you might use a Mac, you might have an iPad, you might have AirPods, but you probably have an iPhone too.
1:04:30Like the number of Apple users who don't have an iPhone is probably a pretty small sliver of the 2.5 billion people.
1:04:37That's the one.
1:04:39I almost think that, you know, they thought the Macintosh was it.
1:04:42This is the computer for the rest of us.
1:04:43And it was the computer for more people, but there wasn't anything to it that really engaged the billions as opposed to the millions of people.
1:04:52And it was the iPhone that really hit all the sweet spots, the miniaturization.
1:04:57It's just in your pocket.
1:04:59The wireless internet, including cellular internet.
1:05:02So you didn't have to be at home or the office or a known Wi-Fi location.
1:05:05You just, wherever you go, you just have internet.
1:05:07The fact that it's a communication device that you text people and FaceTime them and call them.
1:05:13That's what human beings want to do with each other is communicate.
1:05:16They want to communicate to their friends and family or to the world, you know, for people who want to put their stuff out on social media.
1:05:24And that's what the iPhone is.
1:05:25But I almost feel like with the iPhone and they even said it like, did you guys think it was going to be as big as hit as it was?
1:05:33Avi Tevanian and Chris Espinosa, they're like, no, not really.
1:05:37No, they're kind of surprised.
1:05:40And John just asked that while he was alive.
1:05:42And he also said no.
1:05:43No one ever seen this.
1:05:44Yeah.
1:05:45And I think it is sort of is right there with his initial reluctance to open it up.
1:05:50You know, that I think if he had been thinking about 2 billion users, he would have known it had had to be open.
1:05:55And as opposed to making just sort of another iPod size hit, which, you know, if that's how big the iPhone had gotten, as big as the iPod had gotten from 2001 to 2006 or 2007, that still would have been a success at that time for Apple and for the cell phone industry.
1:06:12But it wouldn't have changed the world.
1:06:14It wouldn't have redefined the way that the entire world works.
1:06:19Nobody was writing books in 2006 about iPod addiction, right?
1:06:24Right.
1:06:24That's right.
1:06:26And a lot of people that I spoke to regret the dark stuff that the iPhone has unleashed.
1:06:33You know, I mean, you could argue that's why Apple and the rest of the industry are now working on how can we use the benefits, the virtues of that online always computer without occupying your eyes.
1:06:46So that's why they're trying to see what else they can do with AirPods.
1:06:49They put the heart rate monitor.
1:06:50They're playing with putting a camera in there or Johnny Ives new company is talking about a pendant or a badge or a necklace or or a thing you wear in your head.
1:06:59That's why smart glasses are a big initiative for everybody, including Apple.
1:07:03And I think that's exciting.
1:07:05I mean, maybe an Eddie Q, Apple's VP of services, recently testified in one of those copyright patent lawsuits that 10 years from now, it won't be about the iPhone.
1:07:16We won't be pulling this thing out of our pocket all the time.
1:07:20Or it might not.
1:07:21I think it was what he said, because I don't know.
1:07:22You know, it's who knows.
1:07:24But I think if Apple is still Apple, if somebody is going to obviate it, they want to be the ones.
1:07:29But I do think that that's the bum knock against Tim Cook, where I'm with you, where I don't really see the missed opportunities after the iPhone for something that would be as exciting as the iPhone.
1:07:42No, I really don't.
1:07:43And the fact that nobody else made it, it's not like you can say, hey, Apple missed out on blank, which is a computerized consumer electronic device that you can't.
1:07:54It's really hard to say that they did.
1:07:56I really think that a iPhone sized device that's in your pocket all the time and can run any software imaginable.
1:08:05It's like an inflection point in computing.
1:08:08And I don't think it's the end point.
1:08:09Right.
1:08:10I think that we will start to see things like, who knows, if it'll be glasses or earpods or pendants or all of the above or something like that.
1:08:18And it'll involve computers getting ever smaller so that the iPhone seems big and hulking compared to these computers.
1:08:26But it's one of those things where it's a decades long gap between where the modern phone came out and this came out.
1:08:34And I think that if you took somebody back to 2012 when Tim Cook first took over as CEO and had them live in the world of that time and the phones of that time and the camera quality of that time and what you could do.
1:08:49Like, well, this is all seems kind of slow and limiting, but let me get an Uber.
1:08:53And it's like, no, Uber hasn't been invented yet.
1:08:55You know, did you I'm sure you've seen the movie her the independent movie or most people have it.
1:09:04It was like an indie film.
1:09:05But of all Spike Jones, right.
1:09:08Directed.
1:09:08So of all the movies that depict future technologies, I actually think that one's the most plausible.
1:09:15So, you know, in this near future, everybody's wearing what amounts to an AirPod and you do all your computing and information seeking by talking to this glorified Siri played by Scarlett Johansson's voice.
1:09:27Right.
1:09:28But they then you have to answer the question, what if someone wants to send you a picture or if you need a map or you need some visual, they also have in their pocket this little index card size screen that they can whip out and look and then put it back in their pocket.
1:09:42But most of it is offloaded to this thing in your ear.
1:09:45And I think that's actually a fairly plausible future.
1:09:49I do, too.
1:09:49I think that is very prescient and it feels I haven't I forget when I rewatched it.
1:09:55I watched it when it was new and then I rewatched it at some point after AI came became a big thing.
1:10:02So let's say like two years ago, I don't know, a year or two years ago, I rewatched it and it's like, yeah, this really holds up.
1:10:08It really does.
1:10:09It really does.
1:10:10You know, I'm a big Kubrick fan, but I also feel like 2001 A Space Odyssey really holds up in terms of there's one computer.
1:10:19Howl, but you talk to it on multiple devices throughout the spaceship, right?
1:10:24It's one computer, but he's got, you know, multiple outlets.
1:10:27And that's sort of the vision of AI in the future where you don't it's not like your AI lives in your phone.
1:10:33You keep your phone.
1:10:35You could keep it in your pocket and talk to it through your headphones or you're at the gym and the phone is in your locker and all you've got is your AirPods in and you could still bring up the context.
1:10:46You're not talking to your phone.
1:10:48You're talking to something up there.
1:10:50Yeah, that's the vision.
1:10:52All right.
1:10:53This episode is also brought to you by our good friends at Squarespace.
1:10:58You guys know Squarespace.
1:11:00Squarespace is the all in one website platform designed to help you stand out and succeed online.
1:11:07But it might not just be you.
1:11:09It could be somebody, you know, who turns to you as their nerdy friend who knows how to make websites.
1:11:14Send them to Squarespace using the code squarespace.com slash talk show.
1:11:19And your friends don't even have to listen to the show, but they can come here.
1:11:22You'll get credit as the person who listens to the show who sent them to Squarespace from the talk show.
1:11:28And whether you or your friend or whoever it is who wants you to build a website is just starting out or scaling your business, Squarespace gives you everything you need to claim your domain, showcase your offerings, grow your brand, and get paid all in one place.
1:11:45Squarespace has everything from cutting edge design with their collection of excellent design tools, excellent templates.
1:11:53Oh, so many templates to start with.
1:11:55And they've got Blueprint AI, their AI enhanced design partner for making something from scratch or taking one of the existing templates and tweaking it to customize it for the brand you're looking to build on your website.
1:12:10They have every single way you want to work from working with the code, rolling up your sleeves and working with the actual markup and CSS and JavaScript yourself, or just using AI to sort of give art direction.
1:12:22They've got Squarespace domains.
1:12:24So just every website starts with a domain name.
1:12:27You can register it right with Squarespace and it's one place to pay.
1:12:31Instead of two bills to pay, you've just got one.
1:12:34They have all the tools you need to find a good domain name, everything you need for that.
1:12:40Online stores, whether you're offering services, products, physical products that you sell, or selling your time because you're a consultant or a trainer or something like that, Squarespace handles all of those use cases all in one place with easy online payments and built-in tools for things like inventory, shipping, and fulfillment, and invoices all in one place.
1:13:03So whichever of those things you need, Squarespace can do it.
1:13:05They really do run the whole gamut.
1:13:07Where do you go to find out more?
1:13:09I told you up front, squarespace.com slash talk show.
1:13:13And by going there yourself or sending somebody else you know there, you save 10% off on the price of your first purchase.
1:13:22So if you prepay for a year, 10% off for the whole year, squarespace.com slash talk show.
1:13:27The other thing that I concluded from doing this research is that Apple has quietly crept up on us as it turns into a medical company.
1:13:36It's just unbelievable how advanced their medical sensing technology is.
1:13:42I mean, it's more or less diagnosing atrial fibrillation, this devastating heart thing that can give you a stroke, and hypertension, high blood pressure, sleep apnea, senses differences in your gait if you're getting Parkinson's.
1:13:55And with FDA approval, which is so hard to get, to get FDA approval for the heart atrial fibrillation detection, they had to do a study with Stanford involving 400,000 patients.
1:14:16I mean, it is really hard to get approval, and that they're doing it, and that they have more to come.
1:14:23Like, this thing is this watch, and now the AirPods have heart detection in them.
1:14:27I mean, they're saving thousands of lives a year.
1:14:30They just are.
1:14:31And it's sort of a side of Apple that's crept up on us that isn't really recognized, I feel.
1:14:36Yeah, because that's not how they sell the devices, right?
1:14:39No, they're not selling the watch as a health device.
1:14:42The fitness tracking is sort of health-related, but it's not what you're talking about here, right?
1:14:48It's not about – because nobody wants to think that they're going to be diagnosed with atrial fibrillation, right?
1:14:54If you already know you have it, Apple Watch isn't what you need, and that's what your Apple Watch will tell you if it detects the signs of it.
1:15:02It will say, hey, you should go see your doctor and show them this, and if you really have it, they're going to give you the real treatment that you need.
1:15:10The fall detection is a big one that is saving people.
1:15:13It's like you buy it for the fun stuff that you want to have with your Apple Watch and your AirPods and your iPhone.
1:15:21And then there's the story about the guy whose car went off a cliff.
1:15:25Yes.
1:15:26And his phone was like, it seems like you were in a terrible car accident.
1:15:30I'm going to call 911.
1:15:31And it told them exactly where his car was, and he couldn't get to the phone.
1:15:37He couldn't have made the call himself, and they saved his life.
1:15:39And otherwise, he would have just sat there, like, bleeding to death off the side of a cliff.
1:15:43It keeps happening.
1:15:45Like, last night, I was at a bookstore in Portland, and I was making this argument about Apple's turning into a medical company.
1:15:51And during the Q&A, this guy raised his hand, and he said, I just thought I'd tell you that one day, six weeks ago, my Apple Watch said,
1:15:59looks like you've got atrial fibrillation, might want to get checked out.
1:16:02Yesterday, the day before he's talking to me, he had the surgery.
1:16:07A guy in the audience that saved his life is mind-blowing.
1:16:13Yeah, and they're only just getting started.
1:16:15All of this stuff accretes over time, where, as the Apple Watch gains new sensors and new capabilities, the atrial fibrillation detection is still going to be there.
1:16:24It's going to get more fine-grained.
1:16:26And we're going to have more and more of these devices on us, right?
1:16:30Now we've got them on our wrist.
1:16:32We've got them in our ears.
1:16:33We're probably going to have them on our faces soon, those of us who wear glasses.
1:16:37Who knows what things that will detect, right?
1:16:40But they keep asking themselves those questions, like, if we have a thing in their ear, what could we detect about them?
1:16:46Yeah.
1:16:47Not to be, you know, nosy or, you know, just to help this person out.
1:16:52What would we want to be detected for ourselves?
1:16:54You could be so cynical and say, well, you know, what's the money?
1:16:58There's a lot of money in healthcare.
1:17:00So even if you want to be cynical, it is an area of growth for the company without selling, without introducing all new products.
1:17:09You know, the iPhone killer where they can make more money.
1:17:12An interesting little tidbit.
1:17:13I was talking to somebody.
1:17:14It was like a footnote in the introduction of the new studio displays that came out with the MacBook Neo earlier this month.
1:17:21And they said, oh, and they're certified for, like, MRI technicians.
1:17:24And it's something.
1:17:25And I asked about that at the event in New York.
1:17:28And the guy, the product marketing guy, was like, yeah, you're the first one to ask about that.
1:17:32He said it needed FDA approval, but they got it.
1:17:36And I said, who do you compete against in that space?
1:17:39And he looked at me and he said, that's the interesting question.
1:17:42In that, so the studio display XDR, which costs like $3,500, that's the one that's FDA certified for the color and the calibration that needs to happen.
1:17:53Their competitors all cost $7,000 to $20,000 a piece.
1:17:57And the MRI technicians who use these displays always have four displays in front of them for it.
1:18:06So a four-display setup with the Apple Studio Display XDR is like $13,000 to $14,000 for four of them.
1:18:13But it's like $80,000 from their competitors.
1:18:16So they're just.
1:18:18It's like, oh.
1:18:20And I looked at him.
1:18:22I was like, that sounds like a really good business.
1:18:23And he goes, it might be.
1:18:27I think there's more and more stuff like that.
1:18:29Yeah.
1:18:30All right.
1:18:30Let's wrap it up.
1:18:31Are there any.
1:18:32The other thing that's super, super fun in your book, super fun, is you have documentation, including photos of so many abandoned and aborted products that never saw the light of day.
1:18:46Which ones haunt you?
1:18:48I mean, the car.
1:18:52The car.
1:18:53Oh, Project Titan.
1:18:55They spent 10 years, $10 billion.
1:18:57They had 1,200 engineers.
1:18:59They poached from Tesla and BMW and Ford.
1:19:02And, you know, Johnny Ives' idea was completely self-driving.
1:19:08No steering wheel, no pedals, a luxurious living room on wheels.
1:19:12So the four seats were like reclining leather seats facing each other inside.
1:19:18The windows would be all augmented reality.
1:19:22So you could look out the window and see the reviews of the restaurant you're passing or whatever.
1:19:26The world's most incredible sound system.
1:19:29And it was the really sad thing, according to the people who worked on it, is that the original plan was to do a 1.0 version that wasn't level five self-driving.
1:19:42It was Tesla level, but not completely go to sleep behind the wheel and I'll wake you when we get there level.
1:19:49And his argument was, the guy I talked to, that the iPhone 1.0 didn't have video capture.
1:19:57It didn't have copy and paste.
1:19:59It didn't have, you know, face ID.
1:20:01All that stuff came in successive years.
1:20:04That should have been the plan.
1:20:06We put out the first car and then every year we make it better.
1:20:09And we would get to complete self-driving.
1:20:11And then about halfway through the project, they had this big reset.
1:20:15And they're like, no, let's go for the gold.
1:20:18Let's make it a fully self-driving electric luxury car.
1:20:23And unfortunately, here we are in 2026.
1:20:26We still haven't reached that.
1:20:28No company has.
1:20:29So the horizon kept receding.
1:20:32So finally, in 2024, Tim Cook shut the whole thing down.
1:20:36That would have been my favorite.
1:20:37It seems like there's the people who want to play the what would happen if Steve Jobs was still around game and the people who are resistant to it.
1:20:46And I tend to resist it.
1:20:48But you can't help but think, if Steve were around, wouldn't they have shipped something, right?
1:20:52Like, because isn't that where they went wrong?
1:20:56Where somehow, under Johnny Ive, they set the bar so high for what they wanted to ship that they never took a moment.
1:21:04Like, there's a story you tell in the book.
1:21:07And I've heard this one before, too.
1:21:09Where early, like 2004, in the iPhone development project, Scott Forsall's team is showing the software to Jobs.
1:21:15And he's like, this just isn't doing it for me.
1:21:17And he's like, oh, we could tweak this by tomorrow.
1:21:18And he's like, no, no, you don't understand.
1:21:20This is all, this is not good enough.
1:21:23You have two weeks.
1:21:24I'm coming back in two weeks.
1:21:25And you better show me something that wows me or I'm going to shut the whole thing down, right?
1:21:29There seemed to me to be a need for something like that with the car project.
1:21:33Maybe more than two weeks for a car.
1:21:36But some kind of, hey, there's still, people still need cars.
1:21:42This is still a good business.
1:21:44Cars are going to become computers.
1:21:46Or they already are out there in the world.
1:21:49That's what we do.
1:21:50We make computers and we step into things like music players that are going to become computers when they weren't computers at all before.
1:21:59And we make the best one.
1:22:00We could still do that with a car, but we need a reset button here.
1:22:04I can't help but feel that's sort of where Tim Cook's difference is.
1:22:08I'm going to cut our losses and just get out of this.
1:22:11And that's a very Tim Cookian way of looking at it.
1:22:14Like, I think that was very hard.
1:22:15I don't think he took it lightly at all.
1:22:17I think he could tell us exactly to the dollar how much money the company spent on the whole endeavor.
1:22:22And I don't think that sits comfortably with him at all.
1:22:26But I also think that with Steve Jobs, he had more of a, I don't care how much we've spent.
1:22:31I don't care how much it would cost.
1:22:32I need to ship something.
1:22:35And that I don't think Tim Cook feels that I need to ship.
1:22:39I need to put this out in the world.
1:22:41Yeah.
1:22:42I mean, the parallel universe game is really, really tantalizing.
1:22:46I mean, there's an equal likelihood that we would have watched just Steve burn himself out, lose his ideas.
1:22:54I mean, it could have been.
1:22:55I mean, he did exit at the peak of his creative powers.
1:22:59Yeah.
1:23:00And that might have been what happened if he had stayed ahead of the cancer or even better,
1:23:04if he had never come down with it, that we would have lived to see Steve Jobs deliver some busts for Apple again.
1:23:10Right.
1:23:11That he got out in front of his skis.
1:23:14But we didn't.
1:23:15And I can't help but feel that that's one of the differences between him and Tim Cook, where Cook doesn't pretend that he's a product person.
1:23:23But that makes him, I think, overly cautious about a failure.
1:23:28All right.
1:23:29I know you're in a busy book tour.
1:23:32We could talk for hours and hours.
1:23:35Like I said, we could go through this book page by page.
1:23:37It is a fantastic, fantastic book.
1:23:40One final question for you, David.
1:23:42Yeah.
1:23:43How did you pick the cover image, which is the...
1:23:45Oh, I'm so glad you asked that.
1:23:47Why don't more people ask that question?
1:23:48The Apple logo is completely off limits.
1:23:51Right.
1:23:52So, it couldn't be the Apple logo.
1:23:53I was obsessed with something that was simple and pure and streamlined like an Apple product.
1:24:00But I wanted it to be a symbol.
1:24:02I wanted it to have a secondary meaning that if you really thought about it, you'd get.
1:24:07So, that's obviously the click wheel for the iPod, right?
1:24:10So, it's an iconic design element on an iconic product, the product that turned Apple around.
1:24:18But, if you look at those double arrows on the right and left side of that wheel, they represent a timeline.
1:24:26They represent looking back and looking forward.
1:24:29And that's exactly what the book is supposed to do.
1:24:33Not one person in a thousand catches that.
1:24:36But that's how I overthought it.
1:24:38I don't think it's overthinking at all.
1:24:40Somehow, it works.
1:24:41And that's why I wanted to compliment you on it.
1:24:44And I just knew, as many times as I've talked to people who've written books, and they're like,
1:24:47Oh, I hate the cover.
1:24:48They didn't even ask me about the cover.
1:24:50I knew that you had something to do with this cover.
1:24:52Oh, I designed it.
1:24:53Yeah.
1:24:54Yeah.
1:24:54There's no doubt.
1:24:55Oh, my God.
1:24:56There's no question in my mind.
1:24:58I didn't even hesitate to ask you about it.
1:25:00I knew you weren't going to say,
1:25:01Oh, yeah, Simon & Schuster came up with that.
1:25:03I had no idea.
1:25:04I just saw it last week.
1:25:05No, I knew.
1:25:06David Vogel.
1:25:08Good luck with the rest of the book tour.
1:25:10Thank you for writing this book.
1:25:13Thank you.
1:25:14And I am going to do the best I can to encourage as many people who listen to me or read me to buy
1:25:19their own copies, because it's the only one that's out there.
1:25:22And somebody had to write it.
1:25:23And I can't think of anybody better than you.
1:25:25Well, thank you.
1:25:26I'm in your debt.
1:25:28And I, too, am now writing regularly for the first time in 12 years.
1:25:32I've started a subset column that's free, but I'll never be John Gruber.
1:25:36So I love your empire.