Podcast Search

The Talk Show

445: ‘Apple at 50’, With John Siracusa

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00I love having you on, but it always, I don't know, feels like having you on.

0:00:04It's a heavy show, right?

0:00:05I got to bring my, I got to bring my, no, I don't know.

0:00:09I feel like you're a difficult gift.

0:00:11Yeah.

0:00:13Well, I try.

0:00:14Last time I was on with December, December, 2023.

0:00:17It's always, it's a bit of a, you got to bring your A game because you're going to call me

0:00:23out on anything I'm wrong about.

0:00:24I sure am.

0:00:25And I wouldn't have it any other way.

0:00:27And I thought, I'm not one for anniversaries.

0:00:30I'm sort of the anti-Casey, right?

0:00:32I don't really mark anniversaries of my own stuff.

0:00:34And I feel like that is something that I have as a person, an affinity with Apple, the corporation,

0:00:43where they're not into marking anniversaries that much either.

0:00:46And they're kind of doing it.

0:00:47And I kind of even feel like all the 50th stuff they're doing is sort of begrudging.

0:00:53Well, they haven't been into it, but they seem pretty into the 50th stuff.

0:00:58Right.

0:00:58They're more into the 50th.

0:01:00Yeah.

0:01:00Their story is like, and they're public facing words.

0:01:03It's like, we're not a company that looks backwards, but we're totally going to do it this time.

0:01:07But even so, they're not really celebrating history.

0:01:11They're just like having concerts.

0:01:13Yeah.

0:01:13I don't know.

0:01:14They have the Alicia Keys thing in New York.

0:01:16And I guess they're having, so says German, Paul McCartney tomorrow in Cupertino, which is a huge get.

0:01:24I mean, if that's true.

0:01:25I mean, you know, if German hears it's Paul McCartney, it's probably, I don't know.

0:01:29It's such a boomer thing to do.

0:01:31Like, we've got to get a Beatle.

0:01:32That's the way we're going to celebrate the modern Apple, because the only time that is relevant is the time of the boomer's youth.

0:01:40How funny would it be if he gets up there?

0:01:42I mean, it's not going to happen, but it would be absolutely hilarious if he takes the microphone, and rather than play any music, he just gets up there and rants and raves about the Apple records, Apple computer thing.

0:01:56Like, he even remembers that at this point.

0:01:58I don't think Paul McCartney was ever instrumental in that.

0:02:04I think that was more of a Yoko thing.

0:02:06But who knows?

0:02:08It is part of Apple history, though.

0:02:10No, but I guess the one thing I thought is, well, 50 is only going to come around once.

0:02:15I joked on dithering in an episode that will be out before this episode, and was also recorded before, that we're not going to get a chance to, probably not going to get a chance to talk about their 100th anniversary.

0:02:27Speak for yourself.

0:02:28Well, I said probably, and then Ben threw me under the bus as a couple of years younger.

0:02:33He goes, well, you less likely than me.

0:02:35I don't know.

0:02:36I mean, I feel like, I don't know.

0:02:38I feel like I got a chance at it.

0:02:39I got some longevity genes in my family.

0:02:42My dad's 88, doing well.

0:02:44I don't know.

0:02:44I mean, I only have to get to 103, so it's possible.

0:02:48Easy.

0:02:48If we're both still around, I say we definitely do it in 50 years.

0:02:52Yeah, we'll have a holo podcast.

0:02:54I mean, can we make it a date?

0:02:58I mean, then it'll, if I, and the other thing, too, is if I have it on the calendar, it'll give me something to live for.

0:03:05I've got dementia in my family, so my brain will be pudding by then.

0:03:08So it's going to be a tough show for you.

0:03:09You're really going to have to carry me.

0:03:10It might be good fun.

0:03:13I don't know.

0:03:15We'll see.

0:03:16I mean, I guess that's a little, putting the horse a little ahead of the carriage.

0:03:21But I do feel, though, that if I'm going to do anything special for the 50th, a podcast would do better than writing.

0:03:27I don't feel like writing about it.

0:03:29Podcast is more, I don't know, this is why I like podcasting.

0:03:34I have more mixed feelings about podcasting than you do, clearly.

0:03:38I feel like that's one of the ways where you and I are like, we're oddly similar, and then we're very different.

0:03:43And your position in the Mac media has evolved to primarily a podcaster who occasionally writes, and I'm a writer who occasionally podcasts.

0:03:53You podcast all the time, first of all.

0:03:55And second of all, the horse is always in front of the carriage.

0:03:58The expression is putting the cart before the horse.

0:04:00So you wanted me to call you on everything, and I just wanted to make sure I don't disappoint you.

0:04:03I knew I was getting that one wrong.

0:04:06I knew it was just...

0:04:07But yeah, no, I do.

0:04:07You're right that most of the time I spend doing podcasting, and you spend a tremendous amount of time podcasting.

0:04:11I think you podcast more than I do because you do multiple episodes of Dithering Week plus the talk show.

0:04:15Yeah, but the talk show is consistently now down to three episodes a month, and you guys are very consistently, I mean, remarkably consistently,

0:04:23consistently 52, or once a week, so I guess occasionally...

0:04:26But you do like two Ditherings a week, right?

0:04:27Yeah, two Ditherings a week, so...

0:04:30But that only adds up to 15 minutes.

0:04:32You're podcasting up a storm, but I know you want to hold on to your identity as a writer.

0:04:35I've never thought of myself as...

0:04:37If I think of myself as anything, as a programmer, honestly, but I also think of myself as a writer and a podcaster.

0:04:43I'm all the things at the same time, and if I had to hang my hat on one of them, it would probably be programmer just because I've spent more cumulative hours doing that than anything else that I've done.

0:04:50Second place is probably writing, and then third place is probably writing.

0:04:52And then third place is podcasting, but it's catching up now, because I did a lot of writing back in the day.

0:04:56I spent a lot of time doing those really long articles, and not so much time typing things into the final article, but all the research that led up to it, and that really adds up.

0:05:05But yeah, podcasting is catching up rapidly.

0:05:06Yeah, even with the podcast, and your role on ATP is...

0:05:11It's not just, okay, hit record, and then stop, and that's your time on ATP.

0:05:18What was the one recently?

0:05:19Past keys was one of the recent topics.

0:05:22And in case he was like, I'll let Marco go first, but then I want to talk to John to find out what's actually going on with the topic.

0:05:30So all of the time that you have spent looking into and considering the state of past keys in today's world arguably counts towards your time podcasting.

0:05:39And I implemented them, well, with the help of some of my LM friends, implemented them on ATP.fm as well, so that also is some real-world experience with actually dealing with past keys.

0:05:49Like, I was just working on them just before we connected here.

0:05:52I was applying patches to our past key library for the website, like moments before.

0:05:56Really? Why?

0:05:56Yes.

0:05:56How come?

0:05:57Security things.

0:05:58Like, I'm using a library for it.

0:06:00It's a PHP website, and I'm using a PHP library, and that library has issues filed against it in GitHub, and the author hasn't been incorporating them, so I'm manually applying patches to make sure we're up to date with security stuff, yada, yada.

0:06:10Not that it's that important.

0:06:11Like, our website is a podcast website where there's not really any super secure stuff, but I want to make sure that it's as good as it can be.

0:06:18So, yeah.

0:06:18Right.

0:06:19You know, I mean, what's the worst that could happen?

0:06:22You guys don't store credit cards, so what could leak?

0:06:25Emails, email addresses, and that would be bad, right?

0:06:27You wouldn't want to have an episode where you tell all of the subscribers to ATP, we leaked all your email addresses.

0:06:34But that is amongst the things that could leak in a security breach, how many people have an email address that isn't out there to some degree?

0:06:43A lot of people think they do.

0:06:44I try to make the point on ATP that people who think their email address is super secret and no one can know it, and it's like, man, everybody knows everyone's email address.

0:06:52I do, and I wonder about that with mine.

0:06:55I've had comments at Daring Fireball for public email.

0:07:01Honestly, I think I started using it when the site started in 2002, so probably the whole run, so 24 years.

0:07:08And my real address is gruber at daringfireball.net.

0:07:13And both are real, and it is a separate inbox, but I've really thought of late, like, why in the world do I even have two inboxes for these?

0:07:21I might as well just have one.

0:07:23I've told you my mother's thing with email, or at least you've heard it on ATP, my mother's thing with email.

0:07:28She has two email addresses.

0:07:30She's got, like, an Apple one from her Apple ID, and then she's also got a Gmail one.

0:07:35And she's very fastidious about, I forget which is which, but she's very fastidious about using one of them when she does shopping on Amazon.com or whatever.

0:07:45And the other one she doesn't ever use for those things.

0:07:48So she really does not need two email addresses, but she basically says the one that she doesn't use for public stuff is to avoid getting spam.

0:07:54They both get spam.

0:07:56Of course they both get spam.

0:07:57But in her mind, if I never give this one to, like, Amazon or some other website that I use, no one will know about it, and they totally will.

0:08:05It's like they're already spamming you there.

0:08:07It's really not worth it.

0:08:08I mean, what else could happen with the security of ATP?

0:08:10You guys could accidentally leak members-only podcasts out to the world.

0:08:15It's not the worst thing that would happen.

0:08:17So I get it.

0:08:18It's sort of lower stakes.

0:08:19But I also get that you're fastidious and you want to, you're John Syracuse.

0:08:23You're going to keep your passkey support up to date.

0:08:25Yeah, or at least try to.

0:08:27I mean, like, that's the whole thing.

0:08:28Like, why don't you just write the library yourself?

0:08:30Well, I'm not really ready to take that on.

0:08:32Like, I do want to use libraries.

0:08:33I don't want to roll everything my own from scratch.

0:08:36But if you're using a library, it's okay.

0:08:37Well, how much do you trust this library?

0:08:38How good is this library?

0:08:39How many bugs are in this library?

0:08:40Is the library up to date?

0:08:41And it's that cycle.

0:08:43Yeah.

0:08:43It is off topic of Apple's 50th.

0:08:46I should just have you ATP guys on this show more often because I often have commentary on your episodes.

0:08:52There was one where Marco was talking about his whole amazing 48 Mac Mini transcription service for Overcast,

0:09:01which is really amazing.

0:09:02It's like a Hall of Fame segment on ATP.

0:09:04But then he mentioned, I even forget what it is, but I remember years ago when he did it,

0:09:10there was some component of the back end of Overcast where Marco was like, you know, I need to write like a whole new thing.

0:09:15And I've always been intrigued by the Go programming language.

0:09:18I'm going to teach myself Go to write this.

0:09:20And then he wrote it in Go.

0:09:22And then three or four years later, he needed to add a feature and he hadn't touched Go since.

0:09:27And now he's forgotten the entire programming.

0:09:29Yeah.

0:09:29It's the crawler.

0:09:30I think it's the thing that crawls the feeds of the podcast.

0:09:33I remember we talked about when he wrote that in Go, I think we talked about that on ATP all those years ago.

0:09:40And he's like, I'm looking for a language to do this in.

0:09:41I don't want to do it in PHP.

0:09:42Let me try this, that.

0:09:43And he ended up writing in Go.

0:09:44The good thing is he wrote it in Go and it seems to be working.

0:09:46You don't have to touch it for a long time.

0:09:48But if he ever does need to touch it, he's now forgotten about it entirely.

0:09:51And by the way, if you have comments on the show, you should write into the show.

0:09:54You'll totally get put to the front of the queue as a friend of the show, as we have some follow-up here from, you know, we don't even have to use your last name.

0:10:00We can just say we have some follow-up here from John and we'll just say what you have to say.

0:10:03And then the comment starts, when I created Markdown.

0:10:08Now, I did the same thing to myself with a much incredibly less complicated thing than Marco's crawler.

0:10:16But I wrote the Daring Fireball link shortener, which is at like df4, the digit4.us, which was the best short domain I could get.

0:10:27You wanted to spell doofus, I know.

0:10:29Yeah, I couldn't remember why I put that.

0:10:31Just like 4 is my favorite number and I couldn't get df.us, so I took it.

0:10:37I actually, if you recall, for a year or two, I actually was using a Unicode glyph.

0:10:43It was like df and then like a Unicode star dot something.

0:10:49And I forget what country those were.

0:10:51And that kind of worked, but it was like where they really broke down as I could tweet with those URLs and they worked.

0:11:00But what happened was it was at a time when there was a vast proliferation of Twitter clients.

0:11:07It was the heyday of the open Twitter API and Twitter clients were springing up left and right.

0:11:15And various Twitter clients used various different ways to parse or detect URLs.

0:11:22And guess what?

0:11:23Many techniques to parse URLs did not anticipate the puny code encoding of URLs.

0:11:31And so rather than fight it and stomp my feet, I was like, well, this was a clever idea to put an actual star in the URL.

0:11:38And I thought with tiny URLs, I didn't need it because the canonical URL is daringfireball.net slash something something.

0:11:45So the fact that people couldn't verbalize or type by hand the tiny URLs, it's like if you've already got the tiny URL, you just copy and paste it.

0:11:54But it was the fact that the clients wouldn't parse it and wouldn't make it an active clickable link.

0:11:59So I gave up on it.

0:12:00But anyway, I wrote my own link shortening or expansion service that runs at df4.us.

0:12:08And I did the same thing Marco did where I thought, you know, I've always wanted to learn Ruby.

0:12:12Everything I've ever programmed myself is almost that I can still understand is in Perl or PHP a little bit.

0:12:20But for the most part, Perl is the only programming language that's ever stuck with me.

0:12:24And I thought, well, Ruby looks like Perl and looks kind of fun and people are saying good things.

0:12:29But I certainly don't need Rails.

0:12:30Rails seems way too complicated.

0:12:31So I wrote it in Sinatra.

0:12:33Do you ever remember Sinatra?

0:12:34I do.

0:12:35It's super tiny and it's very clear and it appealed to me greatly.

0:12:39And it had a little, I think you could even use regular expressions.

0:12:42So that appealed to me for the routing.

0:12:44And you could just, if the URL looks like this and it matches this pattern, do this and it would go.

0:12:52And it was very simple.

0:12:52And then I wrote it and then I completely forgot all of Ruby.

0:12:56And the next time I needed to touch it, I was, and I also forgot entirely how Sinatra works.

0:13:01I don't remember how the goddamn thing starts.

0:13:03I don't remember how it stops.

0:13:05And all I remember, though, is that it was much like PHP in that once you have it set up and running on a server, you never need to do anything.

0:13:14And that's how I forgot how to stop the Sinatra server, how to start the Sinatra server, because it just runs and runs.

0:13:21And if the server ever restarts automatically because the hosting provider does something, it just starts back up and runs.

0:13:28And I've completely forgot it.

0:13:30And I was like, well, that was pretty stupid.

0:13:31Well, hopefully you'll never have to touch it.

0:13:34I mean, if it's working, don't touch it.

0:13:36No.

0:13:36And then I did touch it at some point just to stop doing all the smarter stuff I was doing.

0:13:42Like I had a little bit of analytics and to see where stuff was coming from.

0:13:45And I updated it just to take everything out and just redirect to daringfireball.net something.

0:13:52All I did was make it stupider.

0:13:54And I guess now I've waited long enough where I don't really have to worry about it, where I could just throw the project at an LLM and just say, tell me how to change this to do whatever I need changed.

0:14:05No problem.

0:14:06You could even have it ported to a different platform or language.

0:14:08Really?

0:14:08Yeah.

0:14:09Yeah.

0:14:09Anyway, even though we haven't really gotten sidetracked yet talking about Apple history, every time you're on the show,

0:14:15I feel like we get sidetracked talking about Apple history.

0:14:18So who better to have to actually talk about Apple history than me and you?

0:14:22Yeah.

0:14:22I just saw you on the Verge podcast.

0:14:24What is it?

0:14:24The Version?

0:14:25Version History with David Pierce and Nilay Patel talking about you.

0:14:30So you watched it?

0:14:31I'm not all the way through it.

0:14:33I watched most of it.

0:14:34It was making me feel old because I feel like David Pierce.

0:14:37Was he alive when the first Mac came out?

0:14:39I don't know how old David is, but I don't think he was.

0:14:45And if he was alive, he was much like when the Apple One came out.

0:14:50You and I were alive, but we certainly don't remember it because we were, I don't know, four years old, three or four years old.

0:14:59So I feel like, yeah, I don't know.

0:15:01I've had the same thought recording that episode.

0:15:04And I know Nilay's a little younger than me too, but I felt like with David, it was like, hey, he's talking about this a little too prehistoric-y as opposed to just old-y, right?

0:15:15Yeah, and I think it's also difficult if you weren't there at the time to get an idea of what the Mac actually meant.

0:15:20Because in hindsight, you map all these things onto it, and I'm not entirely sure.

0:15:25I mean, that's great because you had such an age range on the show.

0:15:27It made for a good episode with your different perspectives.

0:15:29But every time I heard him talk about it, I was like, I turned into a crusty old man.

0:15:33I was like, that's not the important thing about this.

0:15:36And I was like, what are you doing?

0:15:37Also, I think, doesn't David Pierce do the installer at The Verge too?

0:15:41I think so, yes.

0:15:42That segment.

0:15:42I sent him one of my apps for the installer.

0:15:44I thought it would be perfect for the installer.

0:15:45Because I make obscure little apps that no one has ever heard of do some neat technical thing.

0:15:49That's perfect for the installer.

0:15:50He never featured me.

0:15:51I'm still kind of bitter about it.

0:15:52We'll have to fix that.

0:15:55Hopefully, he'll listen to this, and then he'll feel bad.

0:15:57Come on.

0:15:58It's just I sent him one email about it.

0:16:00No reply.

0:16:01It's never going to get featured.

0:16:02It's fine.

0:16:02I understand.

0:16:03I sent him hyperspace.

0:16:05I feel like it's a good thing for...

0:16:06I don't send him switch glass or front and center.

0:16:08Those are too obscure.

0:16:09But hyperspace is perfect for The Verge.

0:16:11It's like, ah, people need to save disk space.

0:16:12Anyway, whatever.

0:16:13I don't think you've been on this show since hyperspace came out.

0:16:17Or were you last on right when hyperspace 1.0 came out?

0:16:192023.

0:16:20Let me see.

0:16:21I'm so old, I've got to look up everything on my own websites now.

0:16:24Luckily, I keep good records.

0:16:25I do, too.

0:16:26Keep good records of things.

0:16:28So that's good.

0:16:28Yeah, hyperspace was 2025.

0:16:30Oh, okay.

0:16:32So, not even close.

0:16:34So, what's hyperspace?

0:16:35You could talk about it.

0:16:36I mean, I'm not here to pitch hyperspace.

0:16:38It's an app that will save you disk space without removing any files by using a feature of the APFS file system.

0:16:44And thank you.

0:16:46And I honestly made it for myself because I'm, as I can frequently complain about in ATP and complained about again in the most recent episode, I have a 4TB SSD in my Mac.

0:16:55And I am right up against the edge of filling it.

0:16:58Like, I'm constantly trying to move things off of it and just save space any way I can.

0:17:03And so, essentially, I wrote hyperspace for myself because if you can find files that are identical, like they have the identical contents, APFS lets you have those bits only on disk one time.

0:17:13And so, it'll find all the files that are identical and say, if these are not already, like, space-saving clones of each other, turn them into that.

0:17:19And the files stay completely separate and independent.

0:17:22It looks exactly the same.

0:17:23There's no weird stuff.

0:17:24It's not a sim link.

0:17:25It's not a hard link.

0:17:25Editing one file doesn't affect the other files.

0:17:27It just saves you space.

0:17:29If you find five files that are the same, you can get rid of the data stored for four of them and just keep the data there once.

0:17:36And, yeah, that's what I've been doing to my own disk with this program because I need a bigger disk and I've been waiting to buy a new Mac.

0:17:42So, yeah, that's what it does.

0:17:43And it doesn't make you pick, like, there's other things that find duplicate files.

0:17:45Oh, you found duplicate files.

0:17:47Do you want to delete all but one of them?

0:17:48No, I never ask you to remove any files.

0:17:50All the files stay there.

0:17:51You don't have to pick.

0:17:52You don't have to pick amongst your children.

0:17:53Ooh, I kind of want this in both folders.

0:17:55No, you never have to remove any.

0:17:57It just gives you the disk space without changing what is on your disk.

0:18:00It's nice.

0:18:01And if you're old enough to really even remember when file systems were less complicated, it sounds too good to be true, right?

0:18:10It doesn't.

0:18:10It's like, oh, so what's it doing?

0:18:12It's like making soft links or something.

0:18:14Or aliases or something like that.

0:18:16Yeah, absolutely.

0:18:16Or aliases or something.

0:18:18And nope, it's not.

0:18:19They are separate files.

0:18:21And if you, so you're like, well, then what happens if you open one of the five copies of the same, five instances of the same file where the bytes are only on disk once, and then you make a change, and then you save it?

0:18:33Well, then that instance gets, that initial save will take some time because it will write out the, now it's suddenly taking up its own bytes on the disk.

0:18:42Yeah, and actually, it really depends on what the program does in terms of saving.

0:18:46If you modify the file, I believe it diverges at the block level, so it doesn't even overwrite the whole file, but most applications will write an entirely new file when you hit save, like even if you just appended a word at the end.

0:18:57So that's really up to the program.

0:18:57But either way, the whole point is it's entirely transparent.

0:18:59And the reason you know it's entirely transparent is for years now, every time you hit command D to duplicate a file in the finder, it does this.

0:19:06It makes a space-saving clone.

0:19:07You don't need to know that.

0:19:08You just need to know, huh, I just duplicated a 20-gig file, and it happened instantly.

0:19:12This SSD must be fast.

0:19:13No, it didn't copy 20 gigs.

0:19:14It just said, oh, yeah, here's another file pointing at the same data, and it's the same deal.

0:19:18If you modify that file, don't worry about it.

0:19:20They're independent.

0:19:21They will diverge as needed.

0:19:22It's one of the great features of APFS.

0:19:24I am.

0:19:25And one thing I've been meaning to, I've been keeping this one in my pocket for when you come back on this show, I just want to say I think Hyperspace is the perfect name.

0:19:36Sometimes you hear a name for an app or a product, and you just know it's the best possible name out there.

0:19:42There's no – in the infinite number of names you could have come up with for this app, you're never going to come up with a better one than Hyperspace.

0:19:50Yeah, I mean, it really does – it relies on knowing my deal and the whole hypercritical branding, and my website is hypercritical.co.

0:19:57So you need to have that and my Star Wars fandom.

0:20:00There's a lot of context – as with everything I do, there's a lot of surrounding context that is required to get it.

0:20:05But honestly, the only people who are going to be interested in the things that I'm doing probably already have that context.

0:20:09So I think it's fine.

0:20:10It's extra charming if you listen to ATP and you know anything that you are a Star Wars fan.

0:20:16But if you're not and you just come across this app in the App Store or however else you come across it because you actually have the same need,

0:20:23because maybe you have a 4-terabyte SSD that is at 3.95 terabytes full, it still sounds like a good name for that app's purpose.

0:20:33And even if you're, like, young and you don't really have a particular affinity for Star Wars or know that they don't call it warp speed or whatever, it's hyperspace.

0:20:42The only thing I waffled on a little bit, and you can relate to this, is Star Wars spells hyperspace all one word with no capitalization.

0:20:48But, of course, I am an old-school Mac user, and I love intercaps like MacPaint, MacWrite, and MacPro.

0:20:53So I was like, oh, capital H, hyper, capital S, space, or like the Star Wars way.

0:20:58In the end, I went with the Star Wars way because I felt like I wanted to lean more in that direction,

0:21:01as evidenced by the amazing icon by IconFactory that shows a spinning hard drive going into hyperspace.

0:21:07That is one of the ways that the whole Apple world and the industry, right?

0:21:11It wasn't really an Apple thing for CamelCase titles.

0:21:14It was sort of the whole industry.

0:21:15There was a time of peak CamelCase naming when you could almost just not even memorize them

0:21:22and just, if it could be CamelCase, just do it, and you were probably right.

0:21:26And now, it's probably, if you never do it, you're probably right more often than wrong.

0:21:32I mean, CamelCasing has sort of fallen out of favor.

0:21:35It fell out of favor, I think, pretty quick.

0:21:37It just seems like a big error because it was like all the original programs, MacWrite, MacPaint,

0:21:42the third-party ones, MacDraw.

0:21:43Photoshop bucked the trend by having a lowercase S.

0:21:47But how many times have you seen Photoshop spelled with a capital S?

0:21:50And Macworld, Macworld famously, for a long time, had the capital W spelled more often than

0:21:57the correct spelling.

0:21:58And it was further complicated by the fact that we, by convention in the community, would abbreviate

0:22:05or not abbreviate, I don't know.

0:22:07Yeah, abbreviate.

0:22:08MWSF, Macworld San Francisco.

0:22:10I think that might be initialized.

0:22:13We initialized the name MWSF for Macworld San Francisco and MWNY for Macworld New York.

0:22:20And no one ever wrote MWBOS, but it did happen every once in a while.

0:22:24No, it did.

0:22:25Which complicates it because then you think, well, that's what the W is.

0:22:30It's for a capital W in the magazine's name.

0:22:32But it was definitely not a capital, never was a capital W in the magazine's name.

0:22:37Also, further complicated from the debut of Macworld in 1984, because in the initial, I don't know

0:22:44how many years, they put it on the magazine cover in all caps that were all the same height.

0:22:50Yeah.

0:22:50And so it was up to you to sort of guess how it might be spelled in upper and lowercase.

0:22:55You can relate to that, although to your credit, you use CSS Text Transform to deal with it.

0:22:59But every time I see one of your article titles, I want to copy it into the ATP show notes.

0:23:03I'm like, oh, it's all caps, but then you copy and paste, and it's like, oh, don't worry.

0:23:06I'll get the capitalization from the pasted text.

0:23:08Exactly.

0:23:09Because I'm courteous, but you can't really copy and paste from a printed magazine.

0:23:14Although I would probably try at this point.

0:23:16Have you ever done that?

0:23:18Have you ever pinched a Zoom on a paper magazine page?

0:23:20I've done it so many times.

0:23:21No, never.

0:23:21Never.

0:23:22I've never done that.

0:23:23The closest I've come is, especially in years past, when I've really spent like a whole week full time on an iPad Pro to write a review of a new iPad Pro plus Magic Keyboard.

0:23:39Then I'll go back to my Mac.

0:23:42Oh, no.

0:23:42I've never actually touched the screen, but I've gotten like horror movie close to actually touching the screen.

0:23:51You don't want to touch that now in texture.

0:23:52Yeah.

0:23:53No, definitely not.

0:23:55All right.

0:23:56Random thought.

0:23:57I was going to take a sponsor break, but before we do, how do you square?

0:24:00This seems like nobody has talked about this.

0:24:02German says they're coming out with touchscreen Macs, possibly at the end of this year.

0:24:06This might be one of those times where the M5 MacBook Pro higher end models with the M5 Max and M5 Ultra, or no, the Ultra.

0:24:16It's the Max and the Pro, the Pro chip for the Pro laptops, only came out earlier in March.

0:24:23And maybe they were originally supposed to ideally come out in November.

0:24:27And he said, because there have been, it was like the M3 or something was only out for 10 months before the M4 ones came out.

0:24:33One of those years.

0:24:34Yeah, the M5 Pro and Max, the rumor is that they were delayed because of that, like, chiplet architecture, that, like, the SMC wasn't ready with that.

0:24:40So they got delayed and they got pushed into this year.

0:24:42Right.

0:24:43That they should have all debuted at the same time as the baby MacBook Pro with just the regular M5 chip in November.

0:24:50And that come this November, there's going to be at least one MacBook, and possibly not called MacBook Pro, who knows, that has a touchscreen.

0:25:01So my question is, as a lover of the nanotexture on my studio display, and I don't have a MacBook Pro with a nanotexture,

0:25:11but it's the only reason I'm even tempted to upgrade the one that I already own, is to get nanotexture.

0:25:16I have no other reason, but I want the nanotexture.

0:25:20And occasionally, while using my MacBook Pro as a laptop, carrying it around, traveling, I'm in a scenario where I see any glare at all now, I'm offended.

0:25:30Because I know that if it was nanotexture, I'd never see glare.

0:25:32How to square that with the idea of a touchscreen Mac, other than that the touchscreen one won't come with nanotexture?

0:25:40I don't see how they can possibly make a nanotexture one that has a touchscreen.

0:25:43Well, yeah, so that's the one option is, hey, no nanotexture on the touchscreen Macs.

0:25:48The other option is that if you've been a student of nanotexture from Apple, I think every single one of their nanotexture finishes has been different.

0:25:58The Pro Display XDR is different than the iPads is different than the MacBooks.

0:26:02I don't see any reason why they couldn't make a fourth nanotexture that is suited for being a touchscreen.

0:26:08And all of these have different compromises in terms of how do they deal with reflectivity, how do they deal with finger grease, how do they feel in the case of the iPad with a stylus underneath it.

0:26:15So I leave that open as a possibility as well that they have come up with a compromised nanotexture that is viable as a touchscreen, that is not impossible to get fingerprints off of, and that works on a touchscreen laptop.

0:26:27But it is definitely simpler to say that they just won't do nanotexture on the touch ones.

0:26:30All right.

0:26:31And I guess the counterexample is the iPad Pro with nanotexture that is obviously a touch device.

0:26:36You touch it all the time, yeah.

0:26:37But it's glass, not whatever the hell they may.

0:26:40And I guess somebody's corrected me at some point that the MacBooks do use glass, but it's not glass like an iPad.

0:26:45Well, I think it actually is probably the same.

0:26:48They could do the same service treatment.

0:26:49I don't know, but I look at my wife has one of those, and I don't like to look at it because she touches it all day long.

0:27:00Yeah, that's how you use it.

0:27:01You know, every once in a while, I'll just suddenly pick it up and clean it, and boy, does it need to be cleaned.

0:27:07So I don't know.

0:27:08I guess the answer to my question is they just forge ahead and do it.

0:27:11And if you like nanotexture and you want to touch your MacBook, you just do it and you have fingerprints all over your screen.

0:27:17Yep.

0:27:19But I can't see how that's possible that somebody would care about nanotexture because they care about the screen and want to touch the screen and put fingerprints all over it.

0:27:29But I'm married to one of them, so I guess there's all kinds of people in the world.

0:27:33All right.

0:27:34Let me take a break and thank our first sponsor.

0:27:36It's our good friends at Sentry, S-E-N-T-R-Y, Sentry, not century.

0:27:41They always want me to emphasize that, and I can see why.

0:27:44It's hard to figure out what actually happened in your app when your logs, errors, and performance data all live in different tools.

0:27:51With Sentry's application logs, everything is connected.

0:27:55Your logs link directly to the errors, traces, and replays that they relate to so you can follow the full story in one place.

0:28:02You can filter and aggregate on any attribute, like user ID, feature flags, or releases, so that you can troubleshoot issues even when nothing through an error.

0:28:12It's a simple setup.

0:28:13You can start sending logs to Sentry without changing your application code.

0:28:18Full stack coverage.

0:28:19It works across back-end, front-end, and mobile.

0:28:22They've got videos and a quick-start guide on their website, so you can figure it out and get up and running very quickly.

0:28:28So if you're a developer, Sentry is used by millions of developers behind some of the biggest apps out there, like Claude, Disney+, and Duolingo.

0:28:38Big names.

0:28:39Sentry supports over 100 languages and frameworks across front-end, back-end, and mobile.

0:28:44Try it for free at Sentry, S-E-N-T-R-Y, Sentry.io, slash talkshow.

0:28:52And use that URL, slash talkshow, and they'll know you came from the show.

0:28:58They have a free dev plan that you can try out.

0:29:00And listeners of the show, using that code talkshow, can get $80, $80 in Sentry credits.

0:29:07Go to sentry.io, slash talkshow.

0:29:09What's your earliest memory of an Apple computer?

0:29:12Probably Apple IIs that were in, like, a basement room of the father of a friend of mine's house.

0:29:21I think it might have been, like, my babysitter's father had Apple IIs, had a bunch of Apple IIs set up, like, in his basement to, like, teach a course on computers that my parents had me attend.

0:29:31You know, it was like when you had, like, rows of desks, and each one had an Apple II on it, maybe three rows.

0:29:35The desks were all touching, like, long tables.

0:29:38Not even desks, but, like, long tables.

0:29:39And then at the front, like, a chalkboard or whatever.

0:29:41That, using the Apple IIs in that room.

0:29:44I don't remember what we did with them.

0:29:46I can picture the room in my head, and I know I was there.

0:29:49And I took whatever class it was.

0:29:50Not sure what I came away with.

0:29:52So that's probably my first Apple hardware memory, Apple anything memory.

0:29:55I think for me, I'm not entirely sure.

0:29:58I'm pretty sure, though, it was at my elementary school.

0:30:02They had a, they called it the gifted program.

0:30:04I think you had, it was like, it took, like, an IQ test.

0:30:07And if you scored above a certain number, they'd invite you.

0:30:11And then once a week, I think it was once a week.

0:30:13I don't know.

0:30:13You'd think if I was gifted, I'd remember.

0:30:15But I think once a week, and they changed the days.

0:30:18It was like, the other teachers all hated it because they didn't want you to miss the same classes.

0:30:23So they would change the day of the week.

0:30:26And whether it was morning or afternoon, but for a half day, once a week, the kids in the gifted program went to the gifted room and the teacher, we had a different curriculum for half a day.

0:30:37But one week, it would be like Wednesday morning.

0:30:40And then the next week, it would be like Thursday afternoon.

0:30:42And I always hate, oh, man, did I hate when we had to skip gym.

0:30:46Usually, I was like, oh, this is so fun.

0:30:49Yeah, but I really hated when we had to miss gym.

0:30:53And I was like, this sucks, especially if it was like a fun day, like we were playing a good sport like kickball or something.

0:30:58I was like, oh, man, this sucks.

0:31:00But ordinarily, it was a lot of fun.

0:31:02But the gifted classroom had an Apple IIe.

0:31:06And most of the other classrooms in my elementary school that had computers, in fact, none of them had apples.

0:31:13They had TI-99 4As.

0:31:15And I was happy to get time on any computer, right?

0:31:19Like they could have imported one of those weird Russian computers that the guy made Tetris on.

0:31:23And I couldn't even read the prompts because it was written in Russian.

0:31:28But I'd still want to touch it and play with it and try to figure out how to make it do things.

0:31:32But that Apple II in the gifted classroom was like, it was different.

0:31:38And it was like, this is clearly, I could see why there's only one of them in the whole school.

0:31:43This is 10 times better than the other computers.

0:31:45I didn't have that impression of the Apple IIes because my next computer memory, sort of my contemporary computer memory, is the first computer that I had in my house, which was a Commodore VIC-20 that my parents rented.

0:31:55And we connected to our television set.

0:31:59That's how you used it.

0:32:00And to me, the VIC-20 and the Apple II were like of a piece because they were both like real chunky, dark background, light text.

0:32:08You know, if anything, the VIC-20 seemed more advanced than the Apple II just because it was on my bigger TV.

0:32:13So my TV was bigger than the Apple II monitors that they had.

0:32:16But they just both seemed like computers.

0:32:19This is my impression of computers.

0:32:20It's a keyboard.

0:32:21It's a black screen.

0:32:22There's text on it.

0:32:23You type stuff.

0:32:23There's a prompt.

0:32:25And whatever we were doing, the Apple IIes was, I don't know if we weren't playing games or we were probably doing basic programming, but it just seemed that's what computers were before I saw the Mac, which was a command prompt and you type basic programs.

0:32:36And granted, the VIC-20 and the Apple II were different and the Apple II was a much more vibrant ecosystem, but I didn't know that.

0:32:41I was a little kid.

0:32:42I just, I was, by my parents, I was being, not forced, but encouraged to quote unquote, learn computers because that was going to be the future.

0:32:51And what learning computers entailed, which they didn't know, they just chucked me, oh, this guy's running computer classes.

0:32:56And honestly, I was so young then, I didn't retain anything from that.

0:33:00But I do remember making, I was excited because the VIC-20 had color and you could do like, you could make basically colored squares.

0:33:06Like you could type a character, but instead of a character coming out, it would just be a square the size of the character that could be in a color by hitting like F2 or some crap.

0:33:13I remember doing that.

0:33:14And of course, writing 10 print John, 20 go to 10.

0:33:16All right.

0:33:17Or Kmart sucks, as I used to like to do.

0:33:21No, this all came up when we rehashed the Commodore 64, which was the successor to the VIC-20.

0:33:26The Commodore 64 versus Apple II debate, I guess like a year ago, Jason Snell and I and others were tweeting about it or blogging about it.

0:33:34It was weird though, the way, I don't know, maybe some people did.

0:33:38And I know that there were things that came out that I wasn't even aware of a year ago was that the Commodore 64 was a bigger deal in Europe than it was here for various reasons.

0:33:50And the whole computing world was so fractured, right?

0:33:56There were little fiefdoms all over the place.

0:33:59And it really wasn't until the IBM PC and DOS that there was ever a monoculture.

0:34:05And I think to the rest of the industry, everybody just had it in their heads that, well, every three or four years, a new computer comes out with no compatibility with what came before it.

0:34:15And that's just the way it is.

0:34:18And nobody had ever really foreseen a world where, no, remember the DOS computers from 1983?

0:34:24Yeah, those are going to work exactly the same way for 30 years.

0:34:27Or more with emulation.

0:34:29But that was appropriate for the time because things were changing so fast.

0:34:32There's no way you could say, well, we've just decided this is it.

0:34:35What we've done on the Altair.

0:34:36That's what we're going to do forever.

0:34:38It's like, no, just you need to scrap it all and start over because things are advancing so rapidly.

0:34:42There's no way you could.

0:34:44And that's kind of what screwed Apple in the end is that they were successful early with the Mac and cemented a bunch of decisions that turned out to they expired.

0:34:53Those decisions expired around the late 90s.

0:34:55And it was a cruel crisis for the company.

0:34:57It almost killed the entire company.

0:34:58And Microsoft went through the same thing, but they navigated it a little bit better with the transition from DOS and Windows to the NT base of Windows 2000.

0:35:05Right.

0:35:06Somehow it's a complicated argument.

0:35:09But they clearly did, right?

0:35:11Because their success was unabated up through then.

0:35:14Whereas Apple's.

0:35:15I mean, yeah, it helps when they had such a massively dominant position at that point that they had a lot of runway to finesse the transition.

0:35:21And they did a pretty good job of it.

0:35:22And their most important thing was that they started NT well before it was time to transition.

0:35:26So NT was a separate project that they put money behind that they did.

0:35:29And you had Windows 95 and 98 and they were parallel until they finally said, you know, we can cross this over in 2000 and give our consumer Windows the base from NT, which has tried and tested some shims to make stuff run.

0:35:39So they did a good job with the transition.

0:35:41Apple did not.

0:35:42Yeah.

0:35:43And I think that's why Windows 7 was such a shock, because it seemed up through XP, which I think came out in 2001.

0:35:52That it just seemed like Microsoft every two to three years came out with a major new version of Windows that was a varying compatibility, you know, right?

0:36:03Like NT was the real OS, but they did it.

0:36:06And in a way that you could install NT and all of your old shit was still there and worked through compatibility.

0:36:12So it was a real OS, but like an old DOS program from 1983 still ran exactly the same way, just in a window or something.

0:36:20Yeah.

0:36:21And Apple didn't have that.

0:36:24I mean, eventually they did, but it was a struggle.

0:36:27But I will admit, though, that like in my elementary school years, while I liked the Apple IIe in that gifted classroom the best, they were I know what you mean.

0:36:38And I largely agree that all computers were basically the same and they just had different keyboards and whatever.

0:36:44And for the most part, most like I know there were advanced ways of writing basic programs where you could have, oh, this is only going to work on integer basic on an Apple IIe.

0:36:56But for the most part, if you bought like a magazine or something with a program that you could type in, it would work on any computer with basic.

0:37:03And all the computers had a basic programming prompt when you turned them on.

0:37:07So you could just.

0:37:07And yeah, there were weird things like the Commodores had the weird box drawing characters on the keys, which is cool.

0:37:14And maybe that wasn't compatible across.

0:37:17But for the most part, every computer was a computer that you turned on and wrote basic programs.

0:37:21Yeah.

0:37:21And well, the interesting part about that is that's what they're kind of selling the computer as.

0:37:24Here's a computer.

0:37:25You can write your own programs.

0:37:26You can get Byte magazine and transcribe them and curse when you've made a typo in some line.

0:37:31But then once there became software for them, those software programs are not necessarily written in basic.

0:37:36A lot of the software programs, especially the good ones, are written in like assembly or other things to make them perform well.

0:37:41And so it was kind of like you weren't doing the real thing.

0:37:47You were doing a thing that was a toy thing that you could do as a user of computers.

0:37:50But you're learning basic.

0:37:51It's not going to serve you well when it comes time to write your VisiCalc competitor.

0:37:54Exactly right.

0:37:56No.

0:37:56And I remember being bothered by that as a kid because I could tell that the way that Jordan Metzner had written Karataka was not with basic.

0:38:05And I was like, well, how did he do this?

0:38:07How did how in the world?

0:38:08How is this game made?

0:38:10It's obviously where and I never thought.

0:38:12And then it made me start thinking about things like, well, how in the world do they make Atari cartridges?

0:38:17How does that work?

0:38:19What is inside?

0:38:20And then I remember like finding and I don't think I ever broke one, but I remember like going through the box of Atari 2600 cartridges we had and taking out like my least favorite one.

0:38:31It was like some kind of off brand, not even Atari or Activision, but one of those third party that you never heard of.

0:38:37And it actually had just like Phillips head screws and you could take it apart and look inside the cartridge and it wasn't very edifying to look inside, you know, just a bunch of chips.

0:38:48Yeah.

0:38:49And then I remember I'm pretty sure I remember trying it where you could still plug the part with the contacts into the 2600.

0:38:56The cartridge itself was I was like, oh, it's sort of just a packaging and all the tricks people had about blowing on them and ever the cartridge was just a chip inside the actual plastic.

0:39:07Obviously, that's very obvious to me now at the age of like eight or nine.

0:39:11It wasn't obvious at all.

0:39:12But I never thought of until then, until I started playing games on an Apple to like Karatica, like games that obviously were not written in basic.

0:39:21It occurred to me like, well, wait, this is a computer where you can type stuff in basic, but that's not how this was made.

0:39:27But how they made this somehow they put it on a floppy disk and it's this is more akin to what they've done on a cartridge, even though a cartridge isn't a disc.

0:39:38And I was like, oh, and I know that's where I started learning the basics of how an actual computer worked.

0:39:44But it was hard because there was no frigging Internet.

0:39:46And it was this type of question where even the teachers who were more computer enthusiasts and had things to do, like my fifth grade math teacher, Mr. Leimbach, to his credit, was a significant computer enthusiast.

0:40:01And so he, for math, had like programs on the TI-99 in his room.

0:40:07And if you finished your classwork, you could raise your hand and ask to play.

0:40:11It was like a baseball game where you'd have to answer.

0:40:13The pitches would come in with a math problem and you'd have to type the answer and hit return before the pitch reached the plate.

0:40:20And then your guy would run around the bases.

0:40:22Way more fun than regular fifth grade math.

0:40:25I'm on a computer, but it was, quote unquote, educational, I guess.

0:40:29Yeah, I had to read the same five computer books in the school library a hundred times that would label the parts of the computer, which is very important in learning the difference between ROM and RAM and what the keyboard was.

0:40:37And it's like, this is it.

0:40:39This is the extent of the material available to me about computers at this point.

0:40:43But even Mr. Leimbach wasn't going to be able to explain to me how a disk drive worked.

0:40:47But I guess where I really remember noticing that I liked Apple computers better was when I got to middle school because they had a whole lab of Apples.

0:40:55They weren't all the same.

0:40:57It was Apple.

0:40:58I think mostly Apple IIEs, maybe some Apple II Pluses and Apple IICs, which was the first time I can remember the part of my brain that noticed industrial design.

0:41:10Like, I always thought Apple's computers had better cases than the others, and I liked their keyboards better.

0:41:17But the Apple IIc was when they sort of took a, oh, that's totally different and feels more futuristic.

0:41:23Like the Apple, and for those out there listening who don't have all these computers memorized, the Apple IIc was the one, what was it called?

0:41:30The Snow White design language?

0:41:32Yeah, I think that Frog design is responsible for it, but yeah.

0:41:35The Apple II was like, what, Jerry Manic or something did the case for that?

0:41:38Yeah.

0:41:38So eventually Apple outsourced the Frog design, which was at the time a very famous design bureau, and they came up with the Snow White design language for the Apple IIc and eventually Mini Macs.

0:41:48Yeah, eventually Mini Macs.

0:41:50And there was a time, like the Apple IIc, the hardware looked a lot more like the Macs.

0:41:57It came with an ADB keyboard that you could just plug into a Mac because it was the same plug.

0:42:04There was even a Mac-like desktop environment for the IIc.

0:42:09I forget what it was called, but it was always sort of gross.

0:42:13It was like Apple had ripped off their own computer in a very poor way.

0:42:18I loved the 2GS, but I didn't love using the Mac compatibility, whatever that was called.

0:42:24I think this would have come up when you guys were talking about on the version history.

0:42:29Is that what it's called?

0:42:29I keep forgetting.

0:42:30The podcast you were just on talking about the Lisa, and I always forget if this is true, and I don't have it off the top of my head now, so I'll just pretend one of us is looking it up and confirming this.

0:42:38But one of the things I recall about the Lisa was, did it have rectangular pixels?

0:42:41I think it did.

0:42:44I do.

0:42:44If it didn't, it looked like it did.

0:42:47And I know a lot of computers back in that day did have rectangular pixels.

0:42:50And basically, any time I saw a rectangular pixel display in those days, I dismissed it.

0:42:58I said, well, it's a neat computer, and maybe it'll play fun games, but man, you can't have rectangular.

0:43:02It's a grid.

0:43:03Have they never seen, like, graph paper?

0:43:06They're squares.

0:43:08Like, you can't have them rectangular.

0:43:09It's so incredibly limiting.

0:43:11And so that's just such an incredible nonstop.

0:43:13I think the Lisa did it because their idea was that, like, vertical space is more important than horizontal or something.

0:43:18They had some rationale about doing it, but it's like, that's not the way to do a bitmap display.

0:43:24And so anytime they tried to do anything bitmap that wasn't a game, like the desktop environment on the 2GS or whatever, if it was in a display mode that had rectangular pixels, it was just like, blah.

0:43:34And if it didn't, if it had square pixels, but those pixels were gigantic, like CGA 320 by 200 on a 14-inch monitor, I was like, well, no, that's not it.

0:43:42320 by 200 on a 14-inch monitor is not enough.

0:43:45It's not enough for a GUI.

0:43:46So you're, like, you're playing pretend to be a GUI, but, like, this was – you talked about, like, noticing things that were different.

0:43:51This was the distinguishing characteristic to me, which is the original Mac on a 9-inch screen with whatever the resolution was, 512 by 384 – 384 or 342, I forget.

0:44:02Anyway –

0:44:03I think it's 342 on the original, and I always get it wrong because 384 would make it a perfect 4-to-3, and it's not.

0:44:09Right.

0:44:09It was actually squatter.

0:44:10But anyway, on a 9-inch screen, those pixels, those 172nd of an inch or whatever pixels, that was, like, the minimum threshold.

0:44:19And any time I saw anyone else doing a desktop environment, I said, see, we're like the Mac, and we even have color.

0:44:24I'm like, no, you are playing pretend with either rectangular pixels or pixels the size of boulders or both.

0:44:31You have insufficient data density to do this.

0:44:34All you can do is do, like, a Monet impressionist painting.

0:44:37Yeah.

0:44:37And that's even before we consider, like, how it actually worked, which was never the way the Mac worked, and how, as you noted on the podcast, like, how there is no command line lurking under this, how there is no DOS prompt under there, how you will never see text filling your screen.

0:44:50So that was the division point for me.

0:44:52When I first saw the Mac, it was the first computer that I instinctively felt was clearly a totally different thing and a better idea.

0:45:01And as a young person, any time I would see any other piece of technology after that, it would always amaze me that people couldn't see.

0:45:08I felt the same way about Japanese animation.

0:45:10Can you not see the difference between Hanna-Barbera and Robotech or whatever?

0:45:15Like, are you not seeing the same things I'm seeing?

0:45:17Like, I know they're both cartoons.

0:45:18Like, I know these are both computers.

0:45:20And I know you're like, well, they both got Windows.

0:45:21But you don't see it?

0:45:22You don't see the difference?

0:45:23It's so clear to me that there's – and it was just incredibly fresh.

0:45:27In the beginning, it was easy because it was, like, gooey versus non-gooey.

0:45:29But then when Windows got a gooey, it's like, Windows 3.1 versus the current state of the Mac?

0:45:33Like, how are you both – how is any rational person looking at these two things and saying, well, they're basically the same?

0:45:38No, they're not the same at all.

0:45:40I don't know what you're thinking.

0:45:40I remember – I'm not the biggest – I didn't go on to become a big anime fan.

0:45:46But I remember as a kid being absolutely blown away by Star Blazers.

0:45:51Remember that?

0:45:52Oh, man.

0:45:53I mean, and that's the perfect example where it was a totally different style.

0:45:58It's like the other cartoons, like the Flintstones and the Jetsons and whatever, the Pink Panther, even Bugs Bunny.

0:46:06If that was on and I had control of the TV, yes, that's the channel I would put it to.

0:46:11But Star Blazers was, like, one of the first shows I can ever remember that I made time for.

0:46:17Oh, Star Blazers comes on Channel 17 at 4 o'clock.

0:46:19I need to be in front of the TV at 4 o'clock because this incredible show is coming on.

0:46:24And it is not like the other shows.

0:46:26It is totally –

0:46:27Yeah, and in that case, like, there's nothing wrong with Hanna-Barbera animation.

0:46:30But to not be able to note that the style is clearly different, to not be able to instantly say, is this Japanese animation or is it not?

0:46:37If you can't look at two frames of animation in different shows and immediately say yes or no, whether it's Japanese animation back in, like, the 80s, I just feel like you're not – you're blind.

0:46:46Like, you can't – you're like, how is this?

0:46:48And it was my particular sensitivity to these details of aesthetics and design that were like a screaming siren in my head that were invisible to hold huge swaths of the public, which would lead to a long, dark time of me feeling like this better thing exists and nobody cares about it but me, which has happened to a lot of Apple fans back then.

0:47:07Why am I the only person in the world who can see this?

0:47:10Why is Apple a niche player in the computer market?

0:47:13Why is the whole world using Windows on PC clones and they all think it's fine?

0:47:18Like, it was kind of a sane person in an insane world feeling for a long time there.

0:47:22Yeah, absolutely.

0:47:23And I would say that the square versus rectangular pixels thing epitomized it.

0:47:28Have you ever seen – this is something that came up – I don't know if you got to this part, but on the Virgin History podcast.

0:47:34I have to admit, I've seen – just like two years ago at some point, or whenever the 40th anniversary of the Macintosh was, I went back to Drexel University, which is actually not even that far from my house.

0:47:47I mean, an easy walk.

0:47:49I went back because there was some kind of 40th anniversary of Drexel.

0:47:53It was like the first university that had a campus-wide collaboration with Apple to have every student have a Macintosh in 1984.

0:48:03And there was all sorts of retro Mac hardware that was set up.

0:48:07I've seen original Macs over the years many times.

0:48:10I wish – I've never seen a Lisa, though, in my life.

0:48:13I've never seen one.

0:48:15Have you?

0:48:16I've seen one but not turned on.

0:48:17I've seen them at the MIT swap years ago, but it wasn't plugged in or turned on.

0:48:21I don't even – I've never even seen one that was, like, broken like one of the droids in Star Wars sitting in the junk pile.

0:48:27I've never seen a Lisa.

0:48:28The MIT swap is basically for Jawas.

0:48:30Yeah.

0:48:31And I'm not that interested in it.

0:48:33I honestly am not even that.

0:48:34I mean, if somebody told me they had one, like when I went up to Drexel for the 40th anniversary thing and they said, you know, there's a Lisa in the corner, I would have gone over to see it.

0:48:43I'd be like, oh, I guess I've always wanted to see one.

0:48:45But there were so many things about it that seemed gross to me.

0:48:49The fact that it was, like, asymmetric, it honestly felt like the Lisa was a weird ripoff of the Mac, even though the Mac came second.

0:48:56I just looked up on the Wikipedia page to confirm the rectangular pixel things, and it did have rectangular pixels.

0:49:01But do you remember the Macintosh XL?

0:49:03Yes.

0:49:05But I don't remember seeing one of those either.

0:49:07That was a Lisa that ran Macintosh system software.

0:49:11Yeah, so the Wikipedia page says there was an upgrade kit for Lisa computers that included hardware and software kit, enabling it to reboot into Macintosh mode and display square pixels.

0:49:21Which is, I don't know how they did that, but.

0:49:24Yeah, but anyway, like it was the last dying breath of that computer was like, well, the Lisa is dead.

0:49:29We'll sell it as the Macintosh XL because it's like a really big Mac.

0:49:32And the cool thing about the Lisa is it had a bigger than nine inch screen on it.

0:49:35So that's nice.

0:49:35But that was totally destroyed by the rectangular pixels.

0:49:38But yeah, I mean, the Lisa got run over by Steve Jobs getting booted off that project and going over to the Mac project.

0:49:44But a lot of ideas obviously were pulled from Lisa, but you look at Lisa's screenshots and it's like, it's not quite it.

0:49:50You can see that it kind of looks sort of like the Mac, but all the ideas aren't there.

0:49:54In the same way that when you look at like a Xerox PARC, like the Alto computer, you're like, well, I recognize this is a graphical user interface, but you haven't solved all the problems.

0:50:02You haven't figured out a reasonable way to do everything.

0:50:05A lot of the things they were doing were not going to work like the three button mouse and the way the cursor worked and text selection.

0:50:11Like they hadn't figured it out yet.

0:50:13Only the Mac figured all that stuff out for good.

0:50:16Well enough that essentially everybody just worked like the Mac from that point on.

0:50:20Even Windows said, well, we're going to do what the Mac does to the degree we can get away with it, given the look and feel lawsuits.

0:50:25And the places they deviated were like, for deviation's sake, so they could try to avoid lawsuits, which didn't really work, but they would win them anyway.

0:50:32So it doesn't matter.

0:50:33Yeah.

0:50:33All right.

0:50:34Let me take a break here and thank our second sponsor while I'm thinking about it.

0:50:38It's our good friends at Factor.

0:50:40Factor is a get food at home type service, but not meal kits.

0:50:46It's not like get a bunch of ingredients in a box and then you spend 20 minutes cooking something.

0:50:51These are pre-made meals that just come in ready to heat up.

0:50:55And it is a great way to eat healthy, whether you are busy, whether you're often tired, whether you're just you just want to take something out of the fridge and heat it up and eat something good.

0:51:08That is what Factor does.

0:51:10I love so many of the meals that I have gotten from Factor.

0:51:14I love the breakfast stuff, especially, but it's all really good.

0:51:18They have so many over 100 rotating weekly meals.

0:51:22So you sign up for a Factor schedule and then every week where you have Factor stuff coming, you go to the website and there are over 100 weekly rotating meals to choose from, from a whole bunch of variety of flavors, Mediterranean, Asian, lots of protein heavy stuff, lots of vegetarian stuff.

0:51:39If you're not eating meat, they've just recently launched ready to eat salads with all sorts of vibrant ingredients like miso, edamame and all sorts of other stuff.

0:51:51And they have 70 plus add-ons to round out your nutrition from green juices to peanut butter energy bites.

0:51:57All of their stuff is ready to eat in two minutes.

0:52:00They shop, prep, cook and deliver straight to your door, fresh with dry ice in the package to keep everything cold.

0:52:08So you have more time for everything you love to do this spring.

0:52:12I use Factor.

0:52:13I really like it.

0:52:14I really love the taste and I really love the variety.

0:52:17Head to factor meals dot com slash talk show 50 off and use that code talk show 50 off to get 50% off and free daily greens per box with new subscription only while supplies last until September 27th, 2026 factor meals dot com slash talk show 50 off.

0:52:42See their website for more details.

0:52:45So here's where I have to give you, as I call them, being right points.

0:52:49And this is one of the differences in our personal computing stories is you latched on to the Mac early and I did not.

0:52:58Well, that's not a being right point.

0:53:00That is being lucky enough to because I was nine years old, eight years old.

0:53:04I was lucky enough to have parents, grandparents and uncles who knew that the Mac exists and collectively convinced each other all to buy them.

0:53:12So my grandfather got one and convinced and my uncle convinced my parents to get one for me.

0:53:17So that's kudos to them for doing that.

0:53:19But I was my being right point is realizing this computer was something special.

0:53:22I didn't.

0:53:24But I don't.

0:53:25We didn't.

0:53:26We never had one in elementary school.

0:53:27And then in the middle school, we still didn't have one.

0:53:30And then in my high school, the computer teacher, Mrs. Spatz, one of the best teachers I ever had, procured one.

0:53:37And I don't even know what model it was.

0:53:39Probably an SE, but I don't know.

0:53:41And there was one and only one Mac in the computer lab in the high school.

0:53:45And the rest were Apple IIs and including a bunch of 2GSs.

0:53:49And I've told this story before, but my senior year of high school, she put together like a, I don't even know what we called it.

0:53:56But I went to a public high school, but it was very small.

0:53:59We have a graduating class of like 70 students.

0:54:02But it was a really good public high school for considering its size.

0:54:05And she was a great computer teacher.

0:54:07And she put together a class for me and another kid named Zach.

0:54:11Just the two of us, like an independent study.

0:54:13I don't think it was AP, but it was just computer programming.

0:54:16And that's where I learned Pascal instead of basic.

0:54:19And we had like a computer programming team throughout high school.

0:54:23I mean, I played sports and I played computer programming.

0:54:25And I remember we won something.

0:54:28We got to take a trip to Houston, Texas from the suburbs of Philadelphia.

0:54:32Pennsylvania for a computer programming guys.

0:54:34Like we won like a local team, like four or five of us who got to program together.

0:54:39You'd get like a little sealed book, like taking the SAT.

0:54:43And it was like, go.

0:54:44And then you'd open it up and it would be like five programs that you'd have to write from scratch in two hours or 90 minutes or something like that.

0:54:52She was a great teacher and really encouraged that stuff.

0:54:55And we, for that senior year, it was like the first day of class.

0:55:00And it was just me and Zach.

0:55:02And she was like, well, there's only one Mac.

0:55:04Which one of you wants it?

0:55:05And the thing she wanted to show us was HyperCard.

0:55:08And I did remember thinking, wow, that's really cool.

0:55:11And I think she was anticipating that we would be arguing over which one of us would use the Mac.

0:55:17And sort of maybe she was prepared.

0:55:19I just recall that she was sort of prepared for maybe you could split times on it.

0:55:23And I was like, I want to be on a 2GS because I wanted color.

0:55:26I was an idiot.

0:55:27And that was the first time I ever really saw the Mac.

0:55:29And I really thought it was cool.

0:55:31But it did not seem like I couldn't break out of the mindset that a computer was really something that you turned on and just gave you a black screen.

0:55:39And what you ran defined what you saw.

0:55:41It seemed weird to me that with the Mac, there was not that I wanted a command line prompt.

0:55:48But I wanted like a, it just seemed like, well, this is an interesting mode for a computer to be in with this graphical user interface.

0:55:56But what if you want to do something else?

0:55:57You know, what if you want to do something that's full screen?

0:56:00And I didn't see the appeal of it.

0:56:02So I was like, Zach, you can have it.

0:56:04And he was like, sure.

0:56:04And I spent the whole senior year on a 2GS.

0:56:07And I guess I made some HyperCard stacks during my senior year at some point.

0:56:12But even then, I remember thinking, boy, HyperCard's weird because it's like an environment in an environment.

0:56:17Because you weren't making Mac apps.

0:56:20You were making these HyperCard stacks that ran in HyperCard.

0:56:24And they were nothing like the other apps.

0:56:26And it was like the first.

0:56:27Yeah, they're never going to be able to use a technology like HyperCard to make a full screen experience on the Mac that would become wildly popular.

0:56:32Right.

0:56:33It just, it seemed cool.

0:56:34That was sarcasm.

0:56:35There's sarcasm tags around that.

0:56:37I gotcha.

0:56:38Mist was written in HyperCard.

0:56:40So little did you know that a full color, full screen, complete immersive experience, one of the most popular ever made at that point in the software industry,

0:56:48would in fact be made in HyperCard.

0:56:50Yeah, but you know what's weird is that my mindset had shifted at that point.

0:56:54I guess I got enough of a taste that senior year of the Mac where I, even then, even though I wasn't using it as my computer in that class,

0:57:03I got enough of a taste of it where what I would want to write were apps, not games.

0:57:07I had already started shifting away from thinking I would ever make games on my own.

0:57:12And it makes sense to me that Mist was an amazing smash hit game that was written in HyperCard, but nobody ever wrote a Mac app that was a smash hit in HyperCard.

0:57:20Yeah.

0:57:21And that seemed weird to me.

0:57:23It was like I kind of got a flavor of what it meant for a Mac app to be a Mac app.

0:57:29And I kind of got the sense of, oh, HyperCard is really cool because it's super approachable.

0:57:34And I kind of liked the HyperTalk programming language.

0:57:37And I liked the way that you could show graphics by just dragging a picked file into the stack.

0:57:42And you didn't have to do any.

0:57:44There was no complex thing.

0:57:45You just dragged it in.

0:57:46And then you had a picture.

0:57:47And I was like, this is cool, but it's like an environment in an environment.

0:57:51It was a reasonable analogy is the Newton is to the iPhone as HyperCard is to the web.

0:57:58It was a lot of the right ideas, a little bit too early and a little bit too constrained.

0:58:03And you can see HyperCard is clearly something like the web made by somebody who's starting from the mindset of writing Mac apps with the Mac toolbox and Pascal.

0:58:12It's like, well, if I could come up with an easier way to do that, that would be great.

0:58:15And they got the hyperlinking part, right?

0:58:17Jumping from card to card and the constrained environment is even right.

0:58:21It could all be in a browser window type of thing.

0:58:23But like the details were a little bit off and it wasn't quite the right time.

0:58:27And same thing if you squint to the Newton, you're like, I could see you got most of the pieces there, but like you're years too early.

0:58:32You don't have the tech for it yet.

0:58:34And you've gone down a couple of blind alleys with like the handwriting recognition and the stylus and stuff.

0:58:38But I remember being super into HyperCard as well.

0:58:41Although your story about which one of you wants to use the Mac and you went to the 2GS because it was color.

0:58:45It's not the first time your foolish love of color would screw you over.

0:58:48I know.

0:58:48I made it.

0:58:49I still did.

0:58:50This is you want me to tell the story.

0:58:53So when I went to Drexel the next year, every freshman had you didn't have to buy a Macintosh, but it was like strongly suggested because you'd have coursework that required to have.

0:59:03And they had phenomenal education discounts.

0:59:05I mean, they were like, I think they were like half price, honestly.

0:59:09And the three options my freshman year, they had three packages and it was like the cheap one was the Mac Classic, which was a real dud of a computer.

0:59:20I think it was.

0:59:21Yeah, it was definitely still black and white.

0:59:22I think.

0:59:23Yeah.

0:59:23The color classic was the color one.

0:59:25The regular color classic.

0:59:26So it was a Mac Classic and that was obviously not what I wanted.

0:59:29The Mac LC, which was the low cost.

0:59:32That's what the LC supposedly stood for, a color computer with a 12 inch, not 13 inch display, which is what I chose.

0:59:40And the SE30, which is, in my opinion, the best Macintosh ever made.

0:59:45And it was more expensive.

0:59:47So I'm not entirely sure my parents would have sprung for the difference.

0:59:52But just so much more powerful than that LC.

0:59:54Just so much more.

0:59:55It's like massively.

0:59:56The SE30 was the top of the line compact Mac.

1:00:01The best one you could buy for any amount.

1:00:03It was a Mac 2X in a box.

1:00:04And you're like, oh, I see is that monochrome screen.

1:00:06Little did you know that you could connect a color monitor to it with the card.

1:00:09But yeah, but I would be it would be years before I could afford any kind of upgrade to the system.

1:00:15It was it was hard enough to buy a I think that SE30 was way more expensive than the LC.

1:00:22Although the EDU discounts were amazing.

1:00:23You're right.

1:00:24They were amazing.

1:00:24But it's not like now where you get like, oh, 15% off if you're a college customer.

1:00:28Then it was ridiculous college discounts.

1:00:30And speaking of colleges and Macs, I remember when I was looking at schools where I was going to go.

1:00:34I didn't know what I was looking for in a college.

1:00:36But the one thing I knew is that I was judging not so secretly, like just right out in the open, judging every school based on what is the Mac situation here.

1:00:44Did they use Macs?

1:00:45Did the students use Macs?

1:00:46Did the classes use like with Drexel?

1:00:48Like they would have got high.

1:00:49If I had looked at them, they would have got high marks for saying, oh,

1:00:51they encourage students to use Macs.

1:00:53They have classes that require you to have the Macs.

1:00:55They have amazing Mac labs.

1:00:57That's the only criteria I was judging schools by.

1:00:59I ended up going to a school that failed.

1:01:01I got an F on all those categories.

1:01:02And it's just as well because what I learned at Boston University was Unix, which is like my second love in computing.

1:01:08But they had no Mac situation at all.

1:01:11It took me a while to even find where the Macs were hiding.

1:01:13I eventually did find them and ended up like getting a job and maintaining the Macs in a lab.

1:01:17And they also had NextCubes and stuff in the lab.

1:01:19So it was pretty amazing.

1:01:19They were there.

1:01:20But everything you saw when you go on the tour or the giant computing centers was all X terms and VT220s and stuff like that.

1:01:27Yeah.

1:01:27No, Drexel was great.

1:01:29And I knew I liked computers.

1:01:31And I was so happy that they kind of made it so you had to get a computer.

1:01:34And so my parents had to buy me a computer.

1:01:36But I remember getting the pamphlet.

1:01:39They sent like a very – Drexel sent me a very nice – it might have even been Apple produced.

1:01:44I don't know.

1:01:44It was a very nice glossy magazine-style catalog that outlaid the three Macs to choose from.

1:01:51And it was easy to rule out the classic because it was A, black and white, and obviously inferior to the SE30.

1:01:57So it was just a question of the LC versus the SE30.

1:02:00And I thought, well, I want color because I want to play games.

1:02:02And I didn't really look – it was like, oh, 68020 versus 68030.

1:02:07What the hell is the difference?

1:02:08Big difference.

1:02:09Yeah.

1:02:10Yeah.

1:02:11And it didn't even come with the right keyboard.

1:02:13It came with a particularly shitty keyboard, actually.

1:02:15Actually, one of the worst keyboards that Apple ever made.

1:02:17You got the linear arrow keys where it was a line of keys.

1:02:21Yep.

1:02:21And they were squishy mechanisms.

1:02:23Yeah.

1:02:24And then I won my – and the SE30s at Drexel in 1991 came with the Apple Extended Keyboard 2.

1:02:32And I believe that I've since learned – again, we could look this up.

1:02:37But I think when the SE30 first debuted in 1989, it didn't come with an Extended Keyboard 2.

1:02:43It was an option.

1:02:44We discussed this over Messages a while ago.

1:02:45We're going to look at the original price for it.

1:02:47You had to pay – I don't know if it came with any keyboard.

1:02:49I think you might have to pay no matter what.

1:02:51But then the Extended 2 was like – I don't know what it was.

1:02:53That's what we're trying to look up.

1:02:54Was it $200?

1:02:55It was like $160 in 1990.

1:02:58And that's the – somehow I also got that keyboard with my SE30 as well because I got my SE30 on the EDU discount.

1:03:05That's my origin story for the SE30 is I – my sister went off to college.

1:03:08She's four years older than me.

1:03:10She went off to college when I was entering high school, and she gets a college discount.

1:03:14That's like I was craving this.

1:03:15I'm like, I know about Apple college discounts.

1:03:17You're going to college.

1:03:18We're going to go to your college bookstore, which is where your computer is.

1:03:21You go to the college bookstore, and I'm going to see what their – at that point, I had encyclopedic knowledge of like how much is one megabyte RAM DIM going for this week based on the ads in the back of Macworld Magazine.

1:03:31I knew everything about it.

1:03:32She went to University of Connecticut and went to their college bookstore.

1:03:35And I was like, look, Mom, we can get an SE30 with a 40 megabyte hard drive or whatever and an Apple extended two keyboard for X amount of money.

1:03:43And here's the deal.

1:03:44We'll get that with this amazing discount, and then we'll give my sister the computer we have at home.

1:03:51And then the computer we bought at her bookstore, that will be my computer that I'll use at home.

1:03:56And so she went to college, and we bought an SE30 from her college bookstore, but she didn't get to use it at college.

1:04:03That was brought back home, and she got to use our original Mac 128 that had been logic board upgraded to a plus, which is a thing that Apple used to offer back in the day.

1:04:11So she was using a Mac Plus for four years, starting in like, what, 1989?

1:04:15She's using a Mac Plus at college, and I'm using the SE30 at home.

1:04:18And you feel no guilt about this whatsoever?

1:04:21It was one of the most amazing managing up parental moves I've ever done in my entire life.

1:04:27Like, I cannot believe I pulled that off.

1:04:29At the age of like 16 or something like that?

1:04:32Yeah, freshman high school.

1:04:33Going out of eighth grade, this is parental manipulation at its finest.

1:04:36I had already been honing the particular parental manipulation deal, which was my birthday is in December.

1:04:41So I would always essentially combine Christmas and birthday to get a present that was more expensive than all of my siblings.

1:04:48I'm like, well, it's not just my Christmas present.

1:04:49It's also my birthday.

1:04:50That worked to varying degrees, but I did.

1:04:53My story with that is I wanted to get an externally Android K floppy drive back before the SE30 was out.

1:04:58So I would have two floppy drives, so I didn't have to swap as much with my motherboard.

1:05:01I created Mac Plus, and I had to pay for half of that.

1:05:05I believe it was $450, and I had to pay for like 200 of it or something like that, and combine Christmas and birthday, and that was my one present.

1:05:11But I saved it up for the SE30.

1:05:13My look up here says the Apple Extended Keyboard 2 Model M3501 originally retailed for $163 when it was introduced in October 15, 1990, and adjusted for inflation.

1:05:26That's approximately $400 today.

1:05:28So Apple still sells equivalent keyboards.

1:05:30The Magic Keyboards for iPads are roughly $400.

1:05:34They don't have as many keys, though.

1:05:35It is funny to think of a $400 equivalent keyboard that was an add-on for an SE30 in today's world where you can, at education pricing, get an entire MacBook Neo for $500.

1:05:47Yeah.

1:05:48Well, the SE30 was like, what, $8,000 in today's money starting?

1:05:51Something like that.

1:05:51And that's before you even upgraded anything?

1:05:52So it was in line with the prices that they had.

1:05:55Yeah.

1:05:56Well, I, but I, you know, it was a mistake.

1:05:58I mean, it wasn't the worst mistake.

1:05:59I regret it, but I did use the hell out of that LC for years and years and loved it and turned it into a career effectively.

1:06:09I was like, oh, this is by far and away the most interesting thing at this entire university is the computer they just gave me.

1:06:16But it, I guess to go back in the 80s, it's fascinating to, I guess, I think that there's different ways of defining eras at Apple.

1:06:27But to me, the cleanest way is just by Steve Jobs.

1:06:34So I would say era one is 1976 to 1985 when he got booted out of the company.

1:06:41Then there's the era when he was exiled from the company, 1985 to 1996.

1:06:46To me, it seems like a continuous era.

1:06:49And that's sort of, even though the original Macintosh is famous as a Steve Jobs product, when he left, it was what?

1:06:57I don't even know if the Fat Mac had come out yet.

1:06:59I mean, the Fat Mac was coming, but I'm not even sure if it was out yet.

1:07:02I guess maybe it was, but it hadn't even turned into a line of computers yet.

1:07:06Then there's the Steve Jobs comeback era, 97 through his death in 2011, which feels like a continuous era.

1:07:16And then I would say the fourth era is the Tim Cook post-Steve Jobs era.

1:07:21That's how I would look at Apple.

1:07:23And because of how old we both are, the time dilation effect makes the, between Steve Jobs leaving and him coming back, seem like 8,000 years.

1:07:32And Tim Cook seems like five years.

1:07:34And it's not, just because of the age we happen to be, like those early eras seem so long.

1:07:39We did some of the math recently on ATP of like how long the Mac has been on each processor architecture.

1:07:43And like, it doesn't fit with my memory of things because, you know, it's, it's so weird how that is.

1:07:49But yeah, things have stretched out.

1:07:50And especially if you look at like the graph of Apple's net worth and it's like, well, Steve Jobs saved the company.

1:07:54And then Tim Cook like quadrupled it.

1:07:56So like he did this amazing growth from the iPod and like the Steve Jobs, the Jobs 2 era on the graph of like Apple's net worth is like, what are you making the big deal about?

1:08:06It's clear that this guy did all the work and it's like, no, you don't understand.

1:08:08It was like, look at, you have to chop off the Tim Cook era.

1:08:11Now look at the graph.

1:08:12Doesn't it look more impressive now?

1:08:13Yes.

1:08:14The Steve Jobs 97 to 2011 run, if you Bezos chart it and take off the numbers, it had a similar trajectory.

1:08:25But then when you think about how much harder or how much more unusual it is to keep that going through other orders of magnitude, it suddenly pales.

1:08:35You know, it's one of those like the animations that zoom out from the molecular level to planets, to solar systems, to galaxies.

1:08:44It's like at a certain level, you realize that when Steve Jobs died in 2011, Apple was like their entire financials were just, I don't know, a week of sales now.

1:08:54Yeah.

1:08:55I mean, the thing is that he had lit the fuse, like he lit the fuse for the iPhone in 2007 and unfortunately died in 2011.

1:09:01But that fuse was lit and that rocket was burning.

1:09:03And so not to say that all Tim Cook had to do was not screw it up, but like that, the rocket ship that produced the Tim Cook era was already, it was ignited when Steve Jobs died, which is, you know, a nice place to be for Tim Cook.

1:09:16We all said that Steve Jobs died or whatever, and it was difficult to take over and fill his shoes and stuff like that.

1:09:20But he wisely essentially didn't screw up that part of the process.

1:09:23And the Tim Cook era has changed, I think, towards the tail end, maybe not like Game of Thrones, but in some similar ways, there's some disappointment on my part or whatever.

1:09:31Yeah, the Jobs 2 era, like, because that era didn't end in a natural way.

1:09:35It didn't end with him getting kicked out of the company.

1:09:37It didn't end with him retiring or it ended with his death.

1:09:39And that was not anything that anyone planned on, and it was a tragedy.

1:09:42Yeah, and, you know, it's hard because, and you and I were both mid-career commentating on Apple while it happened.

1:09:51We were very close in observing it.

1:09:53Not that it leaves a bad taste in your mouth, but it was uncomfortable the last few years because you could see that he wasn't well, right?

1:09:59I mean, we knew that he had the cancer.

1:10:02We knew that he'd been on the medical leaves.

1:10:04We knew when it took towards the end when he needed the transplant, and we could see how gaunt he was.

1:10:10It was made it uncomfortable, but also, I think, clearly focused his mind.

1:10:18And I don't know that the iPad would have happened when it did otherwise.

1:10:22It was, in some ways, again, it's like, it's just a big iPhone.

1:10:27I don't know why not make it.

1:10:29But it was like, all I know is everybody I know who was there at the time was that when he came back from his first long medical leave, that all he wanted to do was make the iPad.

1:10:39And that was pretty much his singular focus until the iPad came out the next year.

1:10:43Yeah, I've always felt like the iPad was kind of—I don't get a lot of people agreeing with me on this, but I feel like the iPad is what he wished the Mac had been.

1:10:53The technology to make something as friendly and as simple and useful as the iPad didn't exist when the Mac was made, what that was he was going for.

1:11:00Like, all—the idea of the Mac, not Raskin's idea of the $500 thing, but, like, Steve Jobs' idea of we're going to make this and this is going to be—or even just the Apple II, like, the computer for the rest of us.

1:11:10The idea is computers are too hard to use.

1:11:12We're going to make them friendly and approachable to people.

1:11:14And their take on that was kind of like Bill Atkinson's HyperCard take on what would eventually become the web.

1:11:19It's like, I know what you're going for, but you don't quite have it.

1:11:22Like, you're missing some stuff and it's not your fault because you literally can't do it yet.

1:11:26But the iPad—I just remember that keynote of him, like, sitting down on the couch.

1:11:29It's like, finally, this is a computer that anybody can use that is incredibly powerful, that does all sorts of things, and you cannot break it, and it is so friendly.

1:11:39And it is like—it really fulfilled so many of the ideals of the Mac because the Mac had gone on to not be that.

1:11:44He left the company.

1:11:45The reason the Mac exists at all, the reason we're on this podcast is like desktop publishing, Photoshop, stuff that Steve Jobs was not responsible for, for the most part, but that made the Mac a thing.

1:11:54And that was complicated and powerful, and we had power users.

1:11:57They called them Power Books and Power Macs, not just because of the Power PC.

1:12:01That was not the original vision from anybody for the Mac, Raskin's $500 Mac, Steve Jobs is one, but that's what the Mac became.

1:12:09And I felt good about seeing the iPad, even though the world had passed by, and even though I was more interested in the Mac than the iPad, that it basically had done it.

1:12:17That Apple had produced the computer for the rest of us, which is the thing that we give to toddlers now, so they can safely play in a computing environment with their applications that they touch.

1:12:26Right.

1:12:26There was famously the story that the original Macintosh did not have any capacity for expansion cards, and then it kind of secretly did, like what Burrell Smith put in it.

1:12:37Yeah, they did the typical thing, which is just secretly ignore your boss and do what you think is right.

1:12:42So that's why an original Macintosh could be upgraded to a fat Mac.

1:12:47But the fact that they had to sneak it in was so Steve Jobs that he didn't want any expansion cards, and at the time, so antithetical to the entire rest of the personal computing industry.

1:13:02Including Apple II.

1:13:03Apple II had expansion cards out the wazoo.

1:13:06It was almost what defined the platform, was its expandability and the way that Waz had designed it.

1:13:13Waz was always designing for himself, and it's like, hey, what would I have wanted to make an awesome computer?

1:13:18Well, if somebody could already give me a computer that worked and was pretty cool, and then I could just put cards in on top of it to make it even better, that's what I would want.

1:13:27Oh, that's the computer I'll make.

1:13:28I'll make a computer that is just sitting here with these slots where you can make your own things that I've never thought of, and you can add them to the computer.

1:13:36And no better way of seeing the difference between the two Steves, where Steve Jobs was already looking at, no, we're going to seal this up.

1:13:46And we're going to use, again, already with the special screws so that people couldn't even try to look inside.

1:13:53And it was too soon, right?

1:13:57It was too soon to have a computer that didn't have expandability.

1:14:00Yeah, the computer industry was moving too fast at that point.

1:14:03You couldn't lock something in stone like that.

1:14:05Right.

1:14:06I just think of how much I used to know about SCSI.

1:14:10And some of it, I actually did understand, no, no, this is why you have to terminate the SCSI here, otherwise it's not going to work.

1:14:17And then there were other things that did just seem like voodoo.

1:14:20Like what order you have to turn the devices on for your thing successfully.

1:14:23Yes, exactly.

1:14:24You've got to turn on ID3 first, then ID1 and ID7, or ID2 and ID7, rather.

1:14:29And you'd sit down at somebody, some other Macintosh, like at a print shop or some place where it wasn't yours, but you had to go there to print something in color or whatever.

1:14:39And there'd be like a sticky note on the computer telling you to turn on the devices in this order.

1:14:44And you had to know how to turn them on.

1:14:47You couldn't just leave them running because nobody left their computers running.

1:14:51Yeah, there was no disk sleep.

1:14:52No.

1:14:53They're on and spinning and loud.

1:14:56Shut down was something you did every day.

1:14:59You'd shut down.

1:14:59Some people, Snell still does that.

1:15:01I haven't shut down my Mac.

1:15:04I know.

1:15:04I shut it down when I go on vacation for more than a few days.

1:15:07I'm not sure I've ever, I've owned this MacBook Pro since early 2021.

1:15:15No, no, no.

1:15:15I guess, I don't know when the hell it came out.

1:15:18But whatever, in 2021 when I bought it, I'm not sure I've ever shut it down.

1:15:21To be honest, I think it's been effectively running continuously for five years.

1:15:28Sleeping often, but no, you used to shut down and you'd have to turn not just your computer on, but all of your various SCSI devices.

1:15:37I would do that multiple times a day with my computer setup because every time I was done using the computer, I would shut everything down.

1:15:42And then an hour later, I would go back in and use the computer again, turn everything on, wait for the interminal boot process just over and over.

1:15:47That's how you use computers.

1:15:48It seemed totally normal.

1:15:50That's what kept the Mac alive in those periods was that it blossomed into a platform that was in many ways contrary to that Steve Jobs original vision from 1984.

1:16:00Yeah, I mean, it's still tied into the vision of his creative professionals who will be able to do things that they couldn't.

1:16:05This would empower creative professionals to do a thing.

1:16:08That was in there as well.

1:16:09But the simplicity in the computer, part of the computer for the rest of us thing, if you watch the old Steve Jobs talks when he was very young and everything,

1:16:16they were still stuck on the idea that people would write programs.

1:16:21Yeah.

1:16:21Like you mentioned it with the basic stuff.

1:16:23And that, no matter how easy you made programming back then, that was just never going to happen, right?

1:16:28You wanted to empower them to do things that, you know, well, this computer can do anything, don't you see?

1:16:32You can write, and it's a general purpose computer.

1:16:34You can write a program to do anything.

1:16:35If you have a problem with your business, you can write a program to solve the problem for your business.

1:16:39And the answer is no, you can't because not everyone's a programmer.

1:16:41And that vision was encompassed in the Mac in a different way.

1:16:46HyperCard mostly encompasses it of like, look, you're not going to write a Mac toolbox app.

1:16:50We understand that.

1:16:51But HyperCard can give you a way to make a HyperCard stack that can run your business.

1:16:54They were leaning in that direction.

1:16:56But like, that turned out to not be, that was never going to happen.

1:17:00And if you were heavily into computers in California in the 70s, and you're at the Homebrew Computer Club, you're like, yeah, everyone's going to write programs, man.

1:17:06And just, it was never going to be the reality.

1:17:09Well, you don't understand, everyone else is an old fogey now.

1:17:11They're all squares.

1:17:12But when the new kids are born, everyone will be a programmer.

1:17:14And I guess, thankfully, that is not the case.

1:17:17I mean, maybe we're starting that phase again with the LLM things.

1:17:20But back then, the answer was that everyone is not going to be a programmer.

1:17:23No, it definitely wasn't.

1:17:25And you never know, right?

1:17:28It's like, I don't know.

1:17:29Like when HBO first took off, it was like, man, this is how everybody's going to watch TV.

1:17:34You pay a couple bucks for a specific channel, and there's no commercial interruptions.

1:17:38And HBO is still around.

1:17:40It's probably changed hands more times than any TV channel in history.

1:17:44But it's never been the case that more than like ever, like 5% of the U.S. population, 5% or 10% had HBO, right?

1:17:53Like, it's just not something that most people are like, oh, yes, that would be nice not to have commercials interrupt the movie that wasn't meant to have commercials.

1:18:02But no, I'm not paying extra for it.

1:18:05And that was the story of the rest of us, right?

1:18:07It's like people could look at the Macintosh and say, boy, that is a neat looking computer.

1:18:11And you're like, look at the fact that the screen is white and the characters are black.

1:18:15And that's how it will look if you print it out.

1:18:19That's amazing.

1:18:19All these other computers have a black screen with white text.

1:18:22Like part of the WYSIWYG was the fact that it was black pixels on a white background.

1:18:27And they're like, yes, I get that.

1:18:28And then they'd go buy a PC, right?

1:18:31Because it was less money.

1:18:32And it was what they had at their desk at work.

1:18:36And if they brought a floppy disk home from work, they could put it in the PC at home and it would work.

1:18:40And that was it.

1:18:41But there was an us who it was the computer for, right?

1:18:46The people who notice things like the pixels obviously should be square, not rectangular.

1:18:52And also noticing like that there was no Scooby-Doo reveal where you take off the mask.

1:18:57There was nothing underneath it.

1:18:58Like from your perspective, the base level was what you were seeing.

1:19:01This computer was the GUI.

1:19:03It wasn't like a program that you ran on top of DOS.

1:19:06There was nothing underneath there.

1:19:08And because there was nothing underneath there, there was no user serviceable parts.

1:19:12And I don't mean that from a hardware perspective.

1:19:13I mean, if you needed to do something to quote unquote fix your computer, you did it by dragging crap around in the finder.

1:19:19There's no point where you were firing up a command line or editing registry keys or anything like that.

1:19:24There was ResEdit, but that was a GUI app.

1:19:27Right.

1:19:27This was the base reality was the GUI on the Mac.

1:19:30And it was relentless and 100% consistent and totally convincing.

1:19:34And no one seemed interested in even doing that because they thought, we just need to have Windows in a menu.

1:19:41And it's like, no, there's more to it than that.

1:19:43It's the fact that this is the base reality.

1:19:44And this computer on your computer, the base reality is DOS.

1:19:47And you have to know that's the base reality.

1:19:50Hell, if you don't have it auto-booting into Windows, you have to type when to even get to Windows.

1:19:54And then you're going to be down there playing your DOS games or messing with all sorts of config files and stuff like that.

1:19:59The fact that the Macintosh was thought through all the way to the bottom so that like any kind of diagnostic mode you would boot into.

1:20:08I forget some of the things like if you had to boot up with.

1:20:11The debugger, the programmer switch that you had, the interrupt switch, that brought up a dialogue, a graphical dialogue.

1:20:16Where granted you typed commands that set memory addresses and stuff, but like it was still a GUI.

1:20:23It wasn't like, oh, and all of a sudden some black text goes over.

1:20:26That was one of the startling things about Mac OS X was like when it would kernel panic and you would see like text going across the screen before they had the nice kernel panic screen.

1:20:34It was like, we're not in Kansas anymore.

1:20:36Like the world did move on.

1:20:37But for what seemed like a very long time there, the Mac proved that you could have a computer where the base reality was the GUI and you never needed to deal with the command line.

1:20:43And that was important back then because every other computer required you to deal with that crap to make your computer work.

1:20:49And now our phones are running Unix, but you never on the phone have to deal with command line crap.

1:20:54It's there, but you never see it.

1:20:56And so that the phone and the iPad are the current versions of the base reality is what you see here.

1:21:01You will never be asked to do command line stuff.

1:21:04And on the phone, we won't even let you.

1:21:05I just remember for years then at the height of like when the whole industry had settled down to Mac versus Windows or Mac versus DOS.

1:21:15I guess it spans the era where it started as an argument about command line interfaces versus graphical interfaces.

1:21:23Yeah, only toy computers have mice.

1:21:24And then it turned into like the side that had previously been arguing that command line interfaces were a man's computer and graphical user interfaces were baby computers.

1:21:36Even when it became Mac versus Windows, they conveniently forgot that they were on that side before.

1:21:41But even then, you'd boot up a Windows PC and you'd see streams of DOS diagnostic messages.

1:21:49You'd see the bio screen before anything.

1:21:51And I check or whatever.

1:21:52Yeah, all sorts of stuff like that.

1:21:54And most people I knew, including me when I had jobs in college that involved PCs, would set it so that it wouldn't launch Windows automatically.

1:22:01It would start at a DOS prompt in case you wanted to do something in DOS first.

1:22:06And then you would type win, which I always thought was, I don't feel like I'm winning using this computer at work.

1:22:12Yeah, I've always thought that was in the Mac PC wars.

1:22:15All those PC users typing win over and over again.

1:22:18The psychic energy that was putting out into the world was crushing my beloved Apple.

1:22:22Yes.

1:22:23They were going to win.

1:22:24And I remember thinking, too, the people who made this, they were just lazy.

1:22:28They weren't even thinking about the fact that it was a win.

1:22:31They just didn't want to make you type Windows.

1:22:32Yeah, there's a mindset.

1:22:35But as much as Steve Jobs was wrong about some of the stuff like the expansion cards and who knows what would have happened with the Mac if things had gone differently personality wise with the other executives and John Scully and if Steve Jobs had somehow never gone into exile outside Apple.

1:22:52But parts of what made the Mac in that era were clearly led by him and they were different from the Lisa, the square pixels instead of rectangular pixels.

1:23:06It's kind of like when Tim Cook took over because so he gets booted out in 85, but he's let the fuse on the Mac and his ideas about the Mac and lack of expandability were wrong.

1:23:16But his taste about the base reality of the Mac should be that consistent gooey and his taste about how it should be artistic and clean or whatever.

1:23:24He's gone, but he has instilled the entire Mac team with that ethos to such a degree that I feel like the run from after he's booted out until a couple of years before he comes back is the best run of the Mac.

1:23:36Everyone hates on that.

1:23:37Like, oh, in the 90s, they made too many Mac miles and John Scully was bad and blah, blah, blah.

1:23:40No, that's the era of the Mac 2 FX, the SE30.

1:23:45That is the heyday of the Mac, and it's powered by essentially his decisions and taste.

1:23:50He's gone, but his decisions and taste leave on, and that Mac team, there's no way in hell that Mac team is going to allow the Mac to be sullied with all the stuff that we think is bad.

1:23:58And then combined with Jean-Louis Gasset saying, you've got to add slots, man.

1:24:02We've got to make a big, powerful computer.

1:24:04We're going to have separate monitors, a single-page display, a dual-page 21.

1:24:08That's all stuff that didn't seem like Steve Jobs was interested in but was required to make the Mac become what it would eventually become.

1:24:14And he needed to not be there for that because I think his ideas were bad and would not have been successful.

1:24:19But the fact that he set this foundation so well allowed the Mac to go on to success without losing its spirit for such a long time before he even came back.

1:24:31He's gone for years, and the Mac is so thoroughly still like, but no matter what, there's going to be no command line.

1:24:36It's going to be clean.

1:24:37Everything's going to be neat.

1:24:39The pixels are going to be beautiful.

1:24:40When we add color, we're going to add it in a beautiful, tasteful way.

1:24:43It's not going to be garish like Windows 3.1 or whatever.

1:24:45It's just kind of a miracle.

1:24:48Even the diagnostic messages were graphical, so you'd boot it up, and it showed the Happy Mac so early in the boot process because it was in the ROM.

1:24:58It wasn't even gotten to the point where it could read from a disk, but it would show you the Happy Mac in a graphic, and not in a mode that looked different from what you were going to see.

1:25:08The pixels weren't fatter.

1:25:09It was the full resolution.

1:25:11It showed a perfect little Happy Mac icon.

1:25:14And if something went wrong, and unfortunately due to the rather shaky dependability of floppy disks and even hard disks of the time, oftentimes something would go wrong while you were starting up.

1:25:26It wouldn't just dump a bunch of text on screen.

1:25:28It would show you a sad Mac with X's for eyes.

1:25:31And some nice sound.

1:25:33Yes.

1:25:33Whatever the sad noise is.

1:25:35Eventually the Macs had like breaking glass sounds, the later one.

1:25:38Right.

1:25:38Remember that?

1:25:39Yeah, I do remember that.

1:25:41I've used them so much during that era that I'm familiar with all of the sickening feelings that come from seeing such things.

1:25:48But, I mean, can you even imagine Apple today having a Mac that is in a bad – maybe there – is there still a Mac with X's for eyes that comes up if something – like a kernel panic or something like that?

1:25:58I don't think so.

1:25:58I think they've gotten rid of all that stuff long ago.

1:26:00Although they still – it's one of the things that has carried over.

1:26:03Obviously the Mac is – and all of Apple's platforms are now Unix-based and as opposed to the old Mac days where the base reality was the GUI, the base reality is now obviously Unix.

1:26:12But Apple works really hard even today to make sure that is hidden from you.

1:26:18Again, phones are running Unix.

1:26:19Do you think anyone who has an iPhone knows anything about Unix?

1:26:21No, you never see it.

1:26:23Even in a totally dead state starting from zero, the first thing you see on that screen is a white Apple logo.

1:26:29You do not see text.

1:26:30You don't see a memory check.

1:26:31You don't see BIOS.

1:26:32You don't see Unix stuff.

1:26:33You don't see firmware.

1:26:34You don't see any of that.

1:26:35Same thing with the Macs.

1:26:36When they boot, they try to keep screen flickering to a minimum.

1:26:40They try to be smart about resolution.

1:26:41Everything you see is graphical before it even finds the boot disk, the diagnostic modes.

1:26:46They've done all sorts of trickery to do that.

1:26:47It's not ROM chips anymore, but they've done everything they can to maintain that, which like why?

1:26:52Does that make a Mac any better to use?

1:26:55Would it kill you to have on this really fancy Unix workstation some Unix stuff?

1:26:58But the Mac ethos is no.

1:27:01You will never see that crap when you turn this thing on.

1:27:03It's graphics from moment one.

1:27:05And if you want to dive down into the terminal, it's there, but you never have to see it.

1:27:11Maybe slightly less so on the Mac these days, because if you end up doing a default right command, you feel like, well, I had to do this.

1:27:16But I think that's more of like, on the classic Mac, you wouldn't have been able to do this at all.

1:27:20So just be glad you have any way to do it.

1:27:22But in general, you don't ever have to see that if you don't want to.

1:27:24Which does make it, it's just kind of odd that, not odd, because somebody was eventually programming on the Mac and on the Lisa.

1:27:33But it was weird that having 80 characters of monospace type on the screen defined the pixel dimensions of the screen.

1:27:40And that's why Monaco 9, I think Monaco 10 fit 80 columns too.

1:27:46But Monaco 9 is the classic, that era, monospaced Mac font.

1:27:52And you just almost never saw it.

1:27:54Whereas if another company had made the first graphical user interface, most of the programs you ran would have been things that just were in Monaco 9, just command line interfaces running in a window.

1:28:07And you almost never saw Monaco.

1:28:10Most users, it was one of the least seen fonts that they encountered, because you didn't need monospace type.

1:28:17And the fact that all the other fonts on the system were proportional was, for a time, a unique thing on the Macintosh.

1:28:25There were no proportional fonts on other computers.

1:28:27Yeah, I think I recall even seeing some programming stuff done in proportional fonts back then, because, of course, you could.

1:28:33There's nothing stopping you other than it's not traditionally done.

1:28:35Although, speaking of programming for the Mac, that reminds me of something from the...

1:28:39I just watched half of this podcast before I came on, so I also want to talk about another podcast.

1:28:43But the one you did, the version history one,

1:28:46you were talking about how the original Mac had no arrow keys.

1:28:48On the keyboard.

1:28:49As all...

1:28:51Yeah, had no arrow keys on the keyboard.

1:28:52As all podcast listeners do, I feel like I need to participate in the podcast that I'm listening to and interject.

1:28:57But you can't, because it's recorded, and you're hearing it.

1:28:59It's already happened.

1:29:00But here I am.

1:29:01The privilege I have is I can now interject in real time and say,

1:29:04the point I would have brought up in that section, you hit all the major points,

1:29:07but the one point that was missed by all three hosts was...

1:29:09So there's no...

1:29:10The original Mac didn't have arrow keys on the keyboard.

1:29:11Steve Jobs wanted everyone to use the mouse, and they didn't...

1:29:14They were afraid if you didn't force people to use the mouse, they would just use the arrow keys.

1:29:17Well, now you don't have any arrow keys, so you've got to use the mouse to move the insertion point,

1:29:20and you're going to learn how to use this computer.

1:29:22The most important feature of the lack of arrow keys on the original Mac

1:29:26was it prevented software developers from writing programs that required the arrow key.

1:29:31Because you just can't write.

1:29:32You can't write.

1:29:33You could.

1:29:33There's nothing stopping you on the Mac to write a program that looks like a DOS program.

1:29:36But guess what?

1:29:37There's no arrow keys on the keyboard.

1:29:38What the heck are you going to do?

1:29:39Make people use VI keys?

1:29:41No one's going to do that.

1:29:42It was to prevent software developers from their old habits of saying,

1:29:46no, you cannot write a program like Lotus 1-2-3 for DOS.

1:29:50You can't port Lotus 1-2-3 from DOS here.

1:29:53We're not.

1:29:53Our users don't have arrow keys on their keyboards.

1:29:56Do you understand?

1:29:56It's a no-go.

1:29:57So, like, the users, that's one thing, but it was developers.

1:30:01Prevent developers from potentially bringing shovelware to the Mac.

1:30:04I think it was called Apple Works.

1:30:06It was the suite of, like, a word processor spreadsheet database for the Apple II platform that Apple itself made.

1:30:13And I think it was like you'd launch the program and you'd use the arrow keys to be like,

1:30:17do you want a new document, a database, or a spreadsheet?

1:30:20And it was like up, down, return.

1:30:22Because how else were you going to pick?

1:30:26I don't know.

1:30:26And as a kid, like, I had not ingrained arrow key text editing things or whatever.

1:30:31So, when I got Mac right, placing the insertion point with the mouse seemed like second nature to me.

1:30:38And I remember when I got my first Mac keyboard with the arrow keys, I'm like, oh, I guess this is easier.

1:30:45Because for years, because I got the Mac 128, the original Macintosh.

1:30:48And then that was motherboard, logic board upgraded to a plus, which was a thing that Apple offered.

1:30:53Officially, you could take in your 128 and say, I'll give you, like, $1,100 and rip out the guts.

1:30:58And they would replace the logic board, the analog circuit board, and the floppy drive.

1:31:03But they would leave the CRT in the front case in there.

1:31:05And then you'd effectively have a plus for less money than a plus.

1:31:07But I still had the 128 keyboard that didn't have any arrow keys on it.

1:31:11So now I'm using the plus.

1:31:12Still no arrow keys.

1:31:13I think the first arrow keys I got on my computer was the SE30 with the extended keyboard, too.

1:31:18And it's like, wow.

1:31:19This makes text editing so much easier.

1:31:23I think I brought this up on version history, but I'll say it again.

1:31:27Like, in recent Apple history, there was, and I participated, and I fired my opinion very strongly when Apple shifted their own MacBook keyboards to have full-height left and right arrow keys,

1:31:42as opposed to the upside-down T arrangement of arrow keys, where the left and right are half-height, even though there's nothing above them.

1:31:51And it's a perfectly cromulent design, and there's a lot for all the ways that many laptops are just MacBook Air ripoffs from PC makers.

1:32:00There's a lot of laptops out there that have the full-height left and right keys.

1:32:05But of all the ways that you can arrange arrow keys on a keyboard, the difference between the exact same arrangement,

1:32:15but whether left and right are full-height or half-height with a gap above them,

1:32:20is one of the most minor agreements.

1:32:21But we went nuts when Apple went to full-height left and right arrow keys, like, eight or nine years ago.

1:32:27And then they were like, it's one of those ways where Apple still shows us that sometimes they'll listen, and they, like, were, never mind.

1:32:34And we went back to the half-height ones.

1:32:36But when you look back at the early Mac keyboards, A, the first one didn't have any arrow keys at all.

1:32:42But then, B, there were the goofy ones like my LC, whatever, shit-ass keyboard, that had left, right, up, down.

1:32:50Yeah, I don't even remember what order it went in, but whatever order it was not the order you thought,

1:32:54because you had to look at the keycaps and go, where is the left and where is the right?

1:32:57I think it went left, right, up, down.

1:33:01Are they going to have to pull up a screenshot?

1:33:03The thing about the full-height arrow keys, like, that whole cycle of change is so emblematic of the Apple of that day.

1:33:14Because, all right, so Johnny Ive is there.

1:33:17You can see why they do the full-height left and right.

1:33:19You can see why they do it, because it looks nicer.

1:33:21It's uniform, it looks nicer, what are you using that space for anyway?

1:33:24Absolutely looks nicer.

1:33:25Right?

1:33:25So it's a form over function there.

1:33:27And there's like, well, the function, like, I'm sure people argue, you know, you can feel for the keys when it's half-height, blah, blah, blah.

1:33:31And they're like, well, we're just going to do this.

1:33:33And people complained, and so they switched it back.

1:33:35So you could look at that and say, okay, they did a little form over function thing.

1:33:38You understand why they did it.

1:33:39It did actually look nicer.

1:33:40Arguably, the left and right keys felt better, but it turns out feeling for the gaps is more important.

1:33:44But the bigger picture of this is, hey, you could have full-size inverted T without jamming them up like that if you give up the perfect rectangle of the keyboard.

1:33:57Tons of PC laptop keyboards did it.

1:34:00You just move that inverted T down a little bit, and guess what?

1:34:02You get the best of both worlds.

1:34:03You got gaps that you can feel for.

1:34:05You got full-size left, right, up, and down.

1:34:07Our keys, just like on a desktop keyboard.

1:34:09Isn't that great?

1:34:10Well, come now.

1:34:11We're not going to break the rectangle of the keyboard.

1:34:13We'll go back and forth on this half-height arrow key thing.

1:34:16Why is this even an issue?

1:34:17Like, half-height keys suck.

1:34:18Why are you doing this?

1:34:19It's like, we cannot break the rectangle.

1:34:21Like, we can only go so far here in the Johnny Ive design ethos.

1:34:25Like, it becomes unharmonious as an object if we ever break that rectangle.

1:34:29And PC makers are like, screw it.

1:34:30We'll move those keys down half a row.

1:34:32We'll move them down three-quarters of a row.

1:34:33We'll move them down a full.

1:34:34We don't care.

1:34:34We don't care if it's symmetrical.

1:34:36We don't care about beauty.

1:34:37If you buy a big enough PC laptop, you can still get a numeric keyboard over there.

1:34:41Yeah, no, we'll put keys anywhere.

1:34:42Whatever, we don't care.

1:34:44We'll do the butterfly keyboard, like the original IBM butterfly keyboard that folded out.

1:34:48Do you remember that one?

1:34:48Laptop, and it would go whoop.

1:34:50I do.

1:34:50Yeah.

1:34:52But with the laptops that have a numeric keypad, your hands are so far off-center, and they're

1:34:58like, well, so what?

1:34:59Yeah.

1:35:00The PC market would try everything, but it's just part of the Apple ethos.

1:35:06There is some wiggle room between form and function, but there's also a line that we won't

1:35:11cross, and that's the keyboard is a rectangle.

1:35:13I'm sorry.

1:35:14When Apple came out with the full-height left and right arrow keys, I was instantly disappointed

1:35:19because I knew that I like reaching for the gap, and I thought, I don't think I'm going

1:35:23to like that.

1:35:24But I at least thought maybe, and I had the thought you did, which I think is almost certainly

1:35:30true, that at the height of Johnny Ives' personal influence within the company, the way that

1:35:36the keyboard just looks when you're looking down at it was given more value than elsewhere.

1:35:42And so I wasn't surprised by the change.

1:35:45If they made a keyboard where the whole arrow key arrangement was full-height keys, and I'm

1:35:51looking at a MacBook Air, as I talk to you right now, there is room for those keys there.

1:35:56Oh, there's plenty of room.

1:35:56Yeah.

1:35:57Because the arrow keys, even with the very large trackpad they have today, there's plenty

1:36:02of room underneath the arrow keys for a row of height, a row of...

1:36:06I mean, even remember one of my first PowerBook reviews for Ars Technica, I was reviewing like

1:36:10the seven, taking a picture of the 17-inch PowerBook, and it used the same keyboard as the 12-inch?

1:36:15Yes.

1:36:16You remember that?

1:36:16Yes, yes.

1:36:17I mean, part of that is part saving, but it's like you have like a dinner plate, you have a

1:36:20lunch tray here, and it's the same keyboard as the 12-inch.

1:36:23You could fit a numeric keypad.

1:36:25You could fit full-size arrow keys that are offset into an...

1:36:28You could fit a...

1:36:28You could fit so much more on there like, nope, same keyboard as the 12-inch.

1:36:32And think about what it would look like.

1:36:33It would look terrible.

1:36:34And there's...

1:36:35Yeah, that's just...

1:36:36It was not going to...

1:36:36It was not going to fly.

1:36:37They'll see you on your form versus function stuff, but only up to a point.

1:36:40All right.

1:36:41I'm going to take a break here.

1:36:42Thank our third sponsor today, and it's our good friends at Notion AI.

1:36:47Notion AI is the all-in-one AI powered by your work and all in one place.

1:36:53It automatically captures meeting notes, instantly finds the exact content you need, drafts detailed

1:37:00docs for you, and lets you chat with the best AI models.

1:37:03Notion AI just became twice as powerful for teams, making it the best AI tool for work.

1:37:10I can't emphasize this enough, and Notion is a great notes app, a personal information

1:37:15manager, if you want to call it that, to go back to like a term from the 80s.

1:37:18And you can and do, a lot of people do, use it by themselves, but I think where Notion really

1:37:24sings is in use in companies and team-type settings.

1:37:29And instead of having your notes and your documents over here, and then using AI chatbots in a separate

1:37:37app over there and dragging things over and saying, here, these are my notes for this or that.

1:37:41With Notion AI, it already knows all of the context of everything that's in your Notion database and

1:37:50data store, all right there.

1:37:52So for meeting notes, man, every idea, every decision, and every next step just gets captured

1:37:59automatically in Notion.

1:38:01Somebody takes the notes in Notion from a meeting, and they can be put to work right

1:38:05away.

1:38:06You can capture anything and turn it into organized searchable notes, everything from group meetings

1:38:12to one-on-one conversations, lectures, even podcast episodes.

1:38:16If there's a podcast that's applicable to your team's work, give it to Notion.

1:38:20Put it into Notion, and Notion can summarize it, and then the whole team can query the AI

1:38:26for stuff about what happened in the episode of the podcast that's there.

1:38:29There's no need for meeting bots, and it works on any meeting platform, Zoom, Google Meet, whatever

1:38:36you use, or just with your computer's system audio.

1:38:39Transcription and summaries are automatically saved in Notion, so your notes are searchable.

1:38:44So all you have to do is open Notion during a meeting and record, and everything just gets

1:38:49transcribed automatically.

1:38:50You can find any past idea, insight, or decision alongside all of your other information.

1:38:55And they've got all the slash commands that everybody loves in Notion.

1:38:59Type slash meet on any Notion page, for example, on desktop or mobile, and you just get started

1:39:05automatically.

1:39:06Just type slash meet, and if a meeting breaks out, there you are, ready to record.

1:39:11Where do you go to find out more?

1:39:13Check out Notion, the best AI tool for work, right now at Notion.com slash talk show.

1:39:20That's all lowercase letters.

1:39:22They want me to emphasize that.

1:39:23Apparently, their system doesn't work if you mix in uppercase.

1:39:26Notion.com, N-O-T-I-O-N.com slash talk show.

1:39:31All lowercase letters to try the powerful all-in-one Notion AI today.

1:39:35And when you use that link, you're supporting the show.

1:39:38Notion.com slash talk show.

1:39:41You mentioned ResEdit earlier.

1:39:42I don't know.

1:39:43I don't know if I can pick one best Mac app of all time or Apple app of all time, but I

1:39:48would put ResEdit in the Hall of Fame for sure.

1:39:51And perhaps it's something that was in the spirit infused from Steve Jobs' original vision,

1:39:57but maybe he wouldn't have liked the way that ResEdit was used by everyone.

1:40:02I certainly had a lot of fun with ResEdit.

1:40:05It was as close as you could get to seeing some of the machinery behind things.

1:40:08But of course, it was another GUI app.

1:40:10And the closest you got, I think there was like, when you opened an application, the list

1:40:15of resources with their like one, the four letter codes or whatever, the 32-bit codes, that was

1:40:21a Mac window with the scroll bar.

1:40:23But it just had, and it was a list window, but it just had text.

1:40:26I think it was like Geneva 12 or something or whatever the heck it was, or Geneva 10.

1:40:30It was just text.

1:40:32And it was one of the few places on the Mac that you could see a list of text with no icon

1:40:39stuff next to it.

1:40:40And it was like, whoa, now we're really getting down to it.

1:40:42And when you opened up the resources, they had little icons for your ICL8 resources for your

1:40:48icons or whatever, and WND for your windows and stuff.

1:40:51Like there was icons for other parts of it, but it was like as nerdy as you could get.

1:40:55And of course, it was just the resource fork.

1:40:56There was a code resource where like the compiled binary was of it.

1:41:00You know, I didn't, I didn't have a disassembler, but if you just wanted to change what every

1:41:04single sprite looked like in Crystal Quest, ResEdit, you could do it.

1:41:06You just make it copy of Crystal Quest, modify it.

1:41:09I made my own custom versions of all sorts of games using the magic of ResEdit or try to

1:41:13do like local cheats on games by changing values in ResEdit.

1:41:16But yeah, I still felt like I was at a remove because at that point I didn't understand programming.

1:41:20Like I knew a little bit of basic, but I didn't really get it.

1:41:23And unlike your school, my high school did not have any programming classes.

1:41:26The closest I got to a computer class in high school was I took an elective.

1:41:30Where we basically played a flight simulator on Apple IIs, which was terrible.

1:41:34And this is like in the early 90s.

1:41:35I'm on an Apple II in the early 90s.

1:41:37Like it was incredibly terrible.

1:41:39So I didn't understand programming, but ResEdit let me at least tinker with my computer in a

1:41:44way that made me feel tech nerdy.

1:41:46And that would impress us to my friends.

1:41:47You could say, you know, like the SNL ad.

1:41:49Do you remember this one?

1:41:50The power to crush the other kids?

1:41:52Yes, yes.

1:41:53It shows a picture of like the pubic library.

1:41:55It says it used to say public.

1:41:56I changed it.

1:41:57Changing the public library to the pubic library is impressive.

1:42:00to your school friends at that time.

1:42:02And basically using ResEdit to mangle games was impressive to people at the time of like,

1:42:07oh, you're really hacking your computer there or whatever language we would have used at the

1:42:10time.

1:42:10So I did spend a lot of quality time with ResEdit.

1:42:12But if I had to pick my favorite Mac program, it's two-way tie.

1:42:16First is MacPaint, which I just spent a tremendous amount.

1:42:19Like when we first got the Mac, it might as well have just been a MacPaint machine.

1:42:22That's all I did was MacPaint.

1:42:23Like just forever and ever and ever.

1:42:25Just every ounce of that program, every feature, everything you could possibly do with it.

1:42:29I just use MacPaint forever.

1:42:30And then the second is Finder, the classic Mac Finder.

1:42:33If I had to pick one, I would probably pick the Finder just because like many programs have

1:42:37come after MacPaint that have bettered it in terms of graphic excellence, in terms of making

1:42:41bitmapped art.

1:42:42Nothing has come after the Finder that has done a better job of providing the interface to the

1:42:47stuff on your computer than the original classic Finder.

1:42:50That's one of the things that was lost in the transition.

1:42:52A couple of things we lost.

1:42:53We lost being able to name files, whatever we wanted, and we lost the classic Mac Finder

1:42:56that has attributes that seem not to be valued or understood by anybody in the modern era and

1:43:01yet are embodied by tons of stuff on the phone.

1:43:04I mean, the freaking springboard is 100% a spatial Finder, albeit a very bad one.

1:43:08But like those attributes are valued by people, but they don't know what it is about them that

1:43:15they like.

1:43:15And anyway, it's a complicated topic, but for my favorite Mac programs, it would be a two-way

1:43:19tie MacPaint and Finder with Finder probably edging out a little bit.

1:43:22That's a good list.

1:43:23I mean, I guess I would probably say the classic Finder, because I think that it embodied

1:43:28all of the ideals.

1:43:30But I put ResEdit up there, and part of it is that the difference in the modern era, and

1:43:36it's fine that everything now is a bundle, and so there's no separate data fork and resource.

1:43:43I've always liked that.

1:43:44I've always thought that was a very clever idea.

1:43:46Like when I learned about that on Next, I said, oh, that's smart.

1:43:49That's a really smart way to do it, because at that point, I understand.

1:43:52Like resource forks were a brilliant solution at the time of the early 80s, but now we're

1:43:59at the point where we don't have to do that.

1:44:00We can use the file system.

1:44:01So I've always thought that was a good idea.

1:44:04Yeah, but it could have been that the Mac had done something similar, but still had an app

1:44:11like ResEdit, where instead of browsing the bundle as a file hierarchy, it would still open

1:44:17the bundle within one unified view.

1:44:20And I get it, because some of the things it's like, oh, if you have a bunch of images in your

1:44:25app and they're just image files in the bundle.

1:44:29They're making a bunch of picked resources.

1:44:30Yeah, you can just open them in an actual image editor like Acorn or Pixelmator.

1:44:34This is the days before code signing, where you could actually mess with the contents of

1:44:37bundles without invalidating the entire application.

1:44:39It was a simpler time.

1:44:41You could mess with it while it was running.

1:44:43But the way that ResEdit had its own self-contained mini MacPaint for the icon editor, and it

1:44:56wasn't any kind of fancy embedding of the actual MacPaint code.

1:45:01They just re-implemented it, but used the same principles and conventions.

1:45:05And I think even the way that the tool palette was arranged was obviously informed.

1:45:11They obviously, whoever, I think ResEdit came second because MacPaint was so close to

1:45:15an original app, but they looked at the MacPaint palette and they're like, well, we'll put

1:45:19the pencil up in the top left, you know, and it worked the same way.

1:45:22If you knew MacPaint and then you opened ResEdit, you already knew how to edit the icons.

1:45:26And that was like such an amazing instantiation of the principle of what system-wide consistency

1:45:36was meant for it.

1:45:37Oh, you spent tons of time playing with MacPaint and now, and you never even heard of the resource

1:45:42fork, but now you've leveled up in your nerdery of the Mac system and you've got ResEdit running

1:45:48and you've opened up an application and you're perusing the resources and you found some of

1:45:54the icons that are used like the app's finder icon or the icons the app uses for various things

1:46:01inside the application UI.

1:46:02Well, guess what?

1:46:04Now you already know how to edit and hand edit the pixels of the icon because it works just

1:46:09like MacPaint.

1:46:10That's amazing.

1:46:11It was one of the things that it helped to be young for because intellectually, especially

1:46:16as I got older, we'd read all sorts of articles about like, here's how the Mac GUI works.

1:46:19As you noted, like having standard controls, you learn how to do something in one program.

1:46:23The other program is familiar to you.

1:46:24That was a revolution compared to like, if you learn Lotus 1, 2, 3, it does not help you

1:46:27with the next DOS program because they, those people did not talk to each other and there

1:46:31was no standard set of interfaces.

1:46:32And like intellectually I understood that.

1:46:34But then as I got older, I realized that when I was young, like I was the person in my house

1:46:39who knew how to use the computer, like from day zero, like my parents bought the thing and

1:46:42they put it in the house, but I was the one who figured out how to use it.

1:46:45And I dealt with it entirely was, that's why it was quote unquote my computer, even though

1:46:48it was the family's computer.

1:46:49And that, that thing of, oh, so you use MacPaint and when you go to ResEdit, oh, it's just like

1:46:54MacPaint, like the familiarity, oh, scroll bars, you're going to see scroll bars everywhere.

1:46:57Windows, how do Windows work?

1:46:59Like that consistency when you're young, I feel it's kind of like picking up a second

1:47:02language or something.

1:47:03When you're young, your brain is like, oh yeah, no, I see.

1:47:05I see.

1:47:06It's, I see the consistency.

1:47:07You don't think of it in that way.

1:47:08But when you're a little tiny kid, but like your little spongy brain, you're just like,

1:47:12you pick it up so quickly and everything is so consistent.

1:47:15And I remember being frustrated with the adults in my life.

1:47:17I'm like, I would show them how to use something in one program.

1:47:20And then a second program, they'd be baffled.

1:47:22Like it's the same thing.

1:47:23It's like everything it's, the menus always work the same.

1:47:27The scroll bars always work the same.

1:47:29Windows always resize this way.

1:47:30This is how folders work.

1:47:31This is how file.

1:47:32It's the same everywhere.

1:47:33Like, how do you not see this?

1:47:34How do you not transferring these skills?

1:47:36And it's just, I think part of being young and having a malleable mind, like you see it

1:47:39with kids today who grew up with phones.

1:47:41If there is that consistency, a young mind will pattern match it and pick it up and latch onto

1:47:46it.

1:47:46And it will become second nature.

1:47:47And even if that consistency does exist, when you're an adult, it's harder to say, like,

1:47:53I've learned one app and now I'm going to transfer those skills to another.

1:47:56Like, it's just something that, you know, it's part of getting older, but I do remember feeling

1:48:00that frustration.

1:48:01Like, I appreciated the consistency, but it's not working on old people as well because

1:48:05they just get set in their way.

1:48:06Like, they had never even seen a computer before.

1:48:08So it just, it was, what was intuitive to me was not intuitive to them.

1:48:12While you're ranting right there, I booted up Infinite Mac, the emulator, because I wanted

1:48:17to double check my memory of the original Finder menus.

1:48:21And I have to laugh at how much faster Infinite Mac is to boot System 1 than a real Macintosh.

1:48:30Yeah, I just started Mini vMac and it booted in about 1.5 seconds, which is not the authentic

1:48:33experience of having an original Mac.

1:48:36Right.

1:48:37One of my favorite little things about the Finder was the menus, file, edit, view, and

1:48:44what's the last one?

1:48:45Special.

1:48:46The special menu.

1:48:48I frigging love the special menu.

1:48:50And again, it's like a little thing that Apple wouldn't do today because it's...

1:48:55Well, hopefully because they're better at it because you see what they do.

1:48:58It's like, we've got commands that don't fit in file, edit, view.

1:49:00What the hell do we call them?

1:49:01It's like a junk drawer and they're like, oh, we'll just call it special and put crap in

1:49:04there.

1:49:05And it's like today, I would hope they would think harder about that.

1:49:07But back then, it's like, look, we got a ship.

1:49:09We got to go up on the menu for this stuff.

1:49:10Yeah.

1:49:11It was the three commands in the special menu in System 1.0.

1:49:16Cleanup, which would move your icons around if you made a mess of the current icon arrangement

1:49:21in the current window or the desktop.

1:49:23Snap them to the grid, I guess.

1:49:26Empty trash and erase disk.

1:49:29That's the only command.

1:49:30No shutdown.

1:49:30Back then, when you were done with using your computer, you turned it off while it was sitting

1:49:34in the Finder.

1:49:35That's how you turned it.

1:49:35The shutdown was added.

1:49:36I remember when shutdown was added.

1:49:37I'm like, oh, they're adding some ceremony.

1:49:39You're turning off your computer.

1:49:40I just reach around with my left hand and go, click.

1:49:41Yep.

1:49:42And I remember reading.

1:49:44I don't know when they started and how long it was, but it was something I had to read

1:49:47in a magazine.

1:49:48But that beta versions of Mac OS, they would put a funny word and replace special.

1:49:54Yeah.

1:49:54Yeah.

1:49:55I remember that.

1:49:56But I read it.

1:49:57And so, like, every beta of whatever version, the programmers on the system software team

1:50:03would put a funny word.

1:50:04I think they all started with S.

1:50:05I think that might have been part of the gimmick.

1:50:07Maybe not.

1:50:08I don't know.

1:50:09But they would just replace, because they knew that the word special was a weird junk

1:50:14drawer.

1:50:15But calling it special somehow worked.

1:50:17You know, if it would have been called the junk drawer menu.

1:50:20Or if it were called, like, ETC or something.

1:50:22Yes.

1:50:23That would be wrong.

1:50:24And we would look back and say that was a mistake.

1:50:27That was a rare mistake in the original Macintosh.

1:50:30The fact that it was called special, you can say that it's wrong, that there wasn't a more

1:50:34elegant way to come up with a set of menus where those commands would fit.

1:50:38But somehow, instead, it just feels right.

1:50:42It feels like, no, they weren't really file commands.

1:50:45They weren't edit.

1:50:45They weren't view commands.

1:50:47They were special commands.

1:50:48It just felt like, of all the words in the English language, I can't think of a better

1:50:53one.

1:50:53And yes, part of it is the bias of, I fell in love with the Macintosh with a special menu.

1:50:59And so, of course, it's like a quirk that I just happen to love.

1:51:03But it's the right kind of quirk.

1:51:05Yeah, it was part of the whimsy that really infused the Mac back in the day.

1:51:10Right down to the ResEdit icon with the jack-in-the-box thing.

1:51:13Like the ResEdit, which should be the least whimsical application on the entire application,

1:51:17was totally like the whole theme of it with the little head poking out and going to the

1:51:21side.

1:51:21It was like, hacking is fun.

1:51:22Yeah.

1:51:24But I can't help but feel like you said, and I totally agree with you, that I almost

1:51:30feel like what happened after Scully got forced out of the company is when things really started

1:51:37going sideways.

1:51:38Yeah, it got real dark.

1:51:39It got dark because they weren't able to actually do anything.

1:51:43They had these bold plans for next generation operating systems, and none of them could come

1:51:49to fruition.

1:51:50And meanwhile, they're not exactly fiddling while Rome burns, but they were making operating

1:51:57systems that next generation operating systems that would never ship while the Macintosh kept

1:52:02the company alive and stagnated.

1:52:04And while their competition, Microsoft was moving ahead rapidly.

1:52:09Yeah.

1:52:10And then so Jobs lit the fuse on the iPhone, and then he died.

1:52:13Scully left the Newton before he left.

1:52:15And that wasn't quite, that wasn't a lit fuse, unfortunately.

1:52:18If it was, it was a lit fuse on a bomb.

1:52:20Right.

1:52:22Again, ahead of its time, amazing technology, great ideas, but it was not a rocket ship

1:52:26that would carry Apple up into the next era.

1:52:28It just wasn't.

1:52:29It was too early.

1:52:30Did you have a Newton?

1:52:31I think we've talked about this.

1:52:33I never owned one until I eventually got one at the MIT swap, and I have a bunch of them,

1:52:37but I did play with them when they originally came out.

1:52:39In fact, in some of the college bookstores and stuff that I would play with, the first time

1:52:43I ever picked one up, I picked the thing up, and I wrote my full name, John Syracuse,

1:52:47in cursive on the Newton, and it correctly translated it to print.

1:52:52I'm like, this is amazing technology.

1:52:54This is the most amazing thing.

1:52:55Yes.

1:52:55Because my handwriting is not good, and I wrote cursive.

1:52:58Back then, we learned cursive in school, and I had to use cursive for school, so I knew

1:53:01how to write cursive.

1:53:02Then I wrote my name in cursive, and it figured it out, and it was like the most amazing computing

1:53:05feat I'd ever seen in my entire life.

1:53:07It was pretty much downhill from there, but that first moment, I was like, holy cow, they

1:53:11did it.

1:53:11I've read about this in a thousand magazines, and it actually works.

1:53:14You write in cursive, and it figures out what you wrote.

1:53:16How can it do that?

1:53:17I think Drexel had them at the student bookstore, too.

1:53:21They were crazy expensive for something that absolutely could not replace your Mac in any

1:53:28way.

1:53:29There's no way.

1:53:30It was like a businessman.

1:53:31It was like an 80s businessman briefcase, like sharper image, like a fantasy thing that

1:53:35just was ahead of its time, but the tech wasn't ready for it yet.

1:53:38There were some fascinating Apple-like choices, like the fonts were very good.

1:53:44The SB font, the pit map font that was like the main system font of the Newton OS was good.

1:53:50The fact that the Newton hardware used Gil Sands as like the word Newton, like in the way that

1:53:57the Macs of the era were using Apple Garamond as the hardware, the branding, and the Newton

1:54:04stuff used Gil Sands, looked really good and felt right.

1:54:08I think they made the right choice with that weird, is it green?

1:54:12Yes, it's green.

1:54:13If you see it in a perfect light.

1:54:14Super dark green.

1:54:15Yeah.

1:54:15Super dark green.

1:54:17But at a basic level, you didn't have to be Steve Jobs.

1:54:21You didn't have to be the most insightful, oh, this is what's wrong with the product visionary

1:54:27to see it.

1:54:28It was like, what do I do with it?

1:54:31It's what in the world do you do with it?

1:54:33Like it was a product that was all computers, including the Macintosh, including Windows, all

1:54:40computers were basically waiting for the internet to actually become the computers, quote, for the

1:54:47rest of us, because that's the thing that made everybody else on the planet finally have a

1:54:53reason to have a computer, because all people like to communicate with other people.

1:54:57And that's what the internet enabled.

1:54:59They turned computers into communication devices, as opposed to the way that me and you could

1:55:04use a computer as a, I'm going to go spend 36 hours nonstop playing with ResEdit.

1:55:09Yeah.

1:55:10Just a computer that is not connected to the internet with a fixed set of software, and you

1:55:13just spend forever in front of it.

1:55:15God knows what we were doing, but we were there forever.

1:55:17Even before the internet connection stuff, like the category of what, I forget if Scully

1:55:23coined this or not, but he certainly used a lot of personal digital assistant, PDA, before

1:55:27it was public displays of affection, personal, or maybe after, personal digital assistant.

1:55:31You're an important executive.

1:55:33You have meetings.

1:55:34You wear a suit.

1:55:34You need something that goes with you that's digital that can be your assistant.

1:55:38You can take notes in it.

1:55:40You can transfer your business card to other people using the IR port.

1:55:43Do you remember that?

1:55:44Yes, absolutely.

1:55:45Like our TV remote has an IR port.

1:55:46That's how we can wirelessly communicate.

1:55:48You can stick in a PCMCIA card to do some kind of networking stuff.

1:55:52But it's like, you don't want to have your Mac with you.

1:55:55It's not a laptop.

1:55:56It's just like a combination of an executive's notepad and something from Star Trek.

1:56:01It's got handwriting recognition, and you can draw pictures, and if you draw a triangle,

1:56:04we'll see that you're trying to draw a triangle.

1:56:06It'll turn into a perfect triangle, and it's got a stylus.

1:56:08Isn't this amazing?

1:56:09And it's like, you're almost there.

1:56:11A digital thing that is your assistant that you carry with you is, in fact, going to be

1:56:16the most important consumer product of humanity.

1:56:18But it's not this one.

1:56:19It's not.

1:56:20You're close, but it's not this one.

1:56:22And even without the internet, the Palm digital assistant said, hey, Newton, the Palm 7 will

1:56:28eventually have cell radio in it.

1:56:29But even before that, if you just make it smaller and cheaper and make it play games,

1:56:32people will buy it, and it'll be more popular than your gigantic multi-thousand-dollar huge

1:56:37thing, because it's just a better product design.

1:56:39We made it cheaper.

1:56:40We made it smaller.

1:56:41The battery lasts longer.

1:56:42You can play cute little games on it.

1:56:44You can read e-books on it.

1:56:45We learned from what you did wrong, and we did it a little bit better.

1:56:48And then, obviously, the iPhone's going to come and say, no, actually, this is it.

1:56:50The tech is here to do this now.

1:56:52So thanks for the warm-up, but we got it this time.

1:56:55The other thing that, and the Palm exemplified it.

1:56:58And I had, my wife had one, too.

1:57:00And I think she used hers more than me.

1:57:02We both had the Handspring Visor, which was the hardware created by Jeff, whatever his name

1:57:07was.

1:57:07He founded Palm originally and then sold it to, who was the big company?

1:57:13They sold it to some big company, but then secured a license to the OS so they could make

1:57:20their own hardware.

1:57:21And in that early black-and-white era of Palm pilots, the Handspring Visor was, I think, clearly

1:57:27the best.

1:57:28But it obviously, you know that it came after the iMac because they had translucent plastic.

1:57:35I had a bunch of handsprings with translucent plastic.

1:57:40And even the styluses, or styli, if you prefer, if you're more of a Latin fan, but the styluses

1:57:45were translucent plastic, too.

1:57:47But even though they were made by a completely unaffiliated with Apple company, they integrated

1:57:54with the Mac better than the Newton did.

1:57:57One of the craziest parts about the Newton, everybody remembers the handwriting and Doonesbury

1:58:02making fun of it.

1:58:03And yes, and they were very expensive.

1:58:05But the absolute craziest part of it was that it didn't integrate with the Mac at all.

1:58:10Even though it came out in the 90s, it was that mindset from the early 80s of, hey, every

1:58:16couple years, we're going to come out with a new platform and we're just going to pretend

1:58:20like the old one didn't exist.

1:58:21And the Mac had no compatibility with the Apple II at all.

1:58:26None.

1:58:27Yeah.

1:58:27It was a slightly different, I feel like it was a slightly different notion that in the

1:58:30early days, it was like, well, of course we've got to start all over because

1:58:32have you seen how much the world has changed since we made the last computer?

1:58:34But with the Newton, it was more like we had been in the PC era long enough that now there

1:58:39was cruft and technical debt.

1:58:41And it's like a lot of the stuff about dealing with a Mac and a PC, we now recognize some

1:58:46of that is just a little bit annoying to deal with.

1:58:48So wouldn't it be great if we could make a clean break from that and do the Newton with

1:58:52its soup of data instead of access to the file system?

1:58:55Again, a lot of the ideas that would eventually become embodied more successfully in the phone

1:58:59of like, we're not going to make you deal with that computer stuff.

1:59:03We want you to be able to do the same things, but there's no finder.

1:59:07Like you're not, there's not files.

1:59:08There's certainly not a command line.

1:59:09And the only way we can do that with the Newton is to have a clean break.

1:59:13And it wasn't so much like we needed something totally new because tech has advanced.

1:59:17It was like when you worked at a job long enough and you made kind of big mess and you're like,

1:59:20you feel like, oh, if I could change jobs, I just wouldn't have to deal with this big mess

1:59:23I made.

1:59:24They were like, this is going to be a new platform and all of our new best ideas are

1:59:27going to be here.

1:59:28And we're going to leave behind the technical debt.

1:59:29And again, that is a thing that Apple would eventually successfully do with the phone, which

1:59:34left behind tons of the tech debt and old style stuff of the Mac.

1:59:37But the phone didn't say, and by the way, we don't work with your Mac at all.

1:59:40Like you have to plug it into the Mac to even use it.

1:59:43So yeah, another slight miss.

1:59:45But I understand the motivation to move on from the decisions of the past now that we

1:59:50see a better way.

1:59:50Right.

1:59:51But it just seemed foolish.

1:59:53And in hindsight, it's more of a mistake than not waiting and keeping it in the labs until

1:59:59some kind of wire.

2:00:00I mean, it came out before Wi-Fi even, let alone cellular.

2:00:03Yeah.

2:00:04So there was no wasn't just that it didn't have wireless networking.

2:00:08There was no wireless networking in the world to have.

2:00:11And the idea of a Palm-sized computer, even if you can argue that the Newton's bigger

2:00:19than a pretty big.

2:00:20It's a Hockenberry Palm.

2:00:21Yeah.

2:00:21Yeah, exactly.

2:00:22A Hockenberry-sized Palm device.

2:00:26It screamed for networking.

2:00:28But the one thing it definitely should have had is some kind of fundamental back and forth

2:00:33compatibility with the Mac for moving text and images.

2:00:38Syncing contacts.

2:00:39That was the thing you did with your Palm.

2:00:40You synced your contacts.

2:00:41And it worked with the Palm.

2:00:43And then you could go out and put somebody's new contact information on your Palm pilot and

2:00:50then come back to your Mac and connect it and sync.

2:00:53And then it would be in your whatever your contacts app was on your Mac.

2:00:56And no, it didn't sync automatically because they didn't.

2:00:59Neither device had always on cloud syncing.

2:01:02But you put on a terrible little cradle with that 98-pin connector.

2:01:05It would go crunch.

2:01:06And then, yeah, you connect it with the cable and it would sync.

2:01:09I just looked at Wikipedia, by the way.

2:01:10U.S. Robotics bought Palm.

2:01:11And then eventually...

2:01:12U.S. Robotics.

2:01:13Robotics got bought by 3Com.

2:01:14And so you might have been thinking of either 3Com or U.S. Robotics.

2:01:17No, U.S. Robotics is what I was thinking of.

2:01:19The modem company.

2:01:23But they had the right idea and it was a better product.

2:01:26But I don't think anything better exemplifies the dysfunction of what Scully's Apple became

2:01:32than not that the Newton had shortcomings, but that it was such a spiteful silo from the Mac.

2:01:40Like, spitefully unrelated to the Macintosh in any way and in any kind of syncing or anything.

2:01:46I don't think it was spite.

2:01:47I think it was aspiration.

2:01:48It was aspirationally disconnected.

2:01:49They were trying to make the clean break that eventually would come with the phone, but

2:01:52they did it in the wrong way.

2:01:53Well, and there was a story, a bit of the spite, though, the fiefdoms that had developed within

2:01:59Apple was like Pogue's book had a...

2:02:02I forget what it was called.

2:02:03I don't have the book in front of me.

2:02:04But there was a Macintosh tablet project that had a couple hundred prototypes made.

2:02:11And I actually heard from a Daring Fireball reader who, before he even had gotten to that

2:02:15point in Pogue's book, had listened to me talking to Pogue on the podcast.

2:02:19And wrote and said, oh, my dad worked at Apple at the time and had one of those Mac

2:02:24tablets and brought it home.

2:02:25And I showed him the page from the book that was a couple hundred pages ahead of where he

2:02:29was.

2:02:29He goes, that was it.

2:02:30We had one of those.

2:02:31And I was like, that's amazing.

2:02:32You know, and he was like, I don't know what happened to it.

2:02:34I was like, oh, if you still had it, that would be worth something.

2:02:38But it got shot down because I don't know if it was Larry Tesler or somebody who has spent

2:02:43time on the Newton project was like, no, we're the tablet from Apple.

2:02:47And it just the sort of as isolated as the different departments within Apple can be in the modern

2:02:54era.

2:02:55It wasn't with guns pointed at each other, right?

2:02:58Somewhere up the chain, even if you're working on a team somewhere and somebody else is working

2:03:06on a team somewhere else, somebody up the chain of management knows what both sides are doing

2:03:11and isn't going to have two headsets coming out.

2:03:15There's a little bit of that, even in the iPhone era of the competition between will

2:03:19it run a something based on Mac OS X versus running something based on Linux or whatever.

2:03:23So, but that's still led from the top.

2:03:24I mean, the whole, like the end of the Scully era and after he leaves in the dark times with

2:03:29Spindler and Emilio, that's also the proliferation of all the performers and stuff like that.

2:03:35That was difficult everywhere.

2:03:36But like the problem with the difficulty across the organization was that it was all filled with

2:03:40talented people and there was lots of people with aspirational ideas, but without leadership,

2:03:44they were going in a million directions.

2:03:45And that was, I think that was also the time of the ATG, the advanced technology group,

2:03:49which was like one of the parts of Apple that I love, which is we're going to look into the

2:03:53really like far-fetched stuff, like just deep research that's going to eventually form,

2:03:56inform our future products.

2:03:58I'm not sure.

2:03:58I think Steve Jobs just totally disbanded ATG when he came back and I don't know if it was

2:04:02even around to contribute anything to even what would become the iMac.

2:04:05But I always liked the idea of that happening.

2:04:07But the problem with that in a company with bad leadership is you get something like the

2:04:10knowledge navigator video.

2:04:11Do you remember that?

2:04:12Yep.

2:04:13Yep.

2:04:14Yeah.

2:04:14Poga and I talked about it.

2:04:15Which was a tablet-y kind of computer and that was glossy and it was made by Apple and they

2:04:19released it to the world to say, this is where our head's at.

2:04:22We're thinking like the future is going to be like this and won't it be amazing?

2:04:25But the company had no, was not, we were like, okay, now who's going to make the knowledge

2:04:30navigator?

2:04:30It was like, that's just a video we made.

2:04:32But everyone in the company was inspired by it.

2:04:34So you got some people were like, I think we should make a tablet-y thing and I think we

2:04:36should make the moon.

2:04:37And then Scully latched onto the Newton so hard it became his thing.

2:04:42I'm going to show that I'm like Steve Jobs.

2:04:43I'm going to come up with this amazing Newton, which did not work out for him, both career-wise

2:04:48and product-wise.

2:04:49But the rest of the company was like, well, we're going to do this and we're going to do

2:04:52that.

2:04:53And no one was stopping them.

2:04:53And it was just like, everyone was doing everything and there was no direction.

2:04:57And they had lots of great ideas and talented people that were just not being, it was a

2:05:02failure of leadership, many times over a failure of leadership.

2:05:05And to be fair, it was also an extremely difficult time for Apple because they were not succeeding.

2:05:10Their market share was shrinking, not growing.

2:05:12Windows 95 was stomping all over their face.

2:05:14Things were not looking up.

2:05:16And so they were looking for the next big thing and the Newton wasn't it.

2:05:19And the other thing about the market share, I think they were not unrelated.

2:05:25It was cause and effect.

2:05:27But the fact that the Macintosh system software as it stood wasn't quote unquote modern, that

2:05:33it didn't have preemptive multitasking.

2:05:35It didn't really have a kernel.

2:05:37It all made sense in 1984 because the computer that they wanted to sell for less than $2,500,

2:05:44not the $2,500 that actually sold for couldn't possibly have had those features and yada, yada,

2:05:51yada.

2:05:52You get seven or eight years down the line and all of a sudden computers were capable of,

2:05:56you know, had enough RAM to do those things.

2:05:58And everybody knew that Apple would need such an operating system.

2:06:04I mean, you've spent half your career talking about it, about those type of transitions that

2:06:09need to happen and you know, it's coming.

2:06:11And meanwhile, while Apple is wasting time on things like the message pad, which obviously

2:06:20wasn't ever going to replace the Mac, even if it had been successful, it wasn't going to

2:06:24replace it.

2:06:25It wasn't intended to.

2:06:26It was like a new type of computing in the way that the iPhone wasn't meant to replace the

2:06:31Mac and any pipe dream that the iPad would 10 years ago, obviously, you know, didn't pan

2:06:38out.

2:06:39But in the meantime, while Apple is wasting time on things like, what was it?

2:06:43Pink and Taligent and other operating systems that never wound up shipping.

2:06:51The Mac just kept going with what it had and was keep paying all of the bills, right?

2:06:57Like financially speaking, the Apple of the late Scully era and up until Jobs's return, really

2:07:04in 97.

2:07:05And honestly, up until the iPod through the first four years.

2:07:10Because the iMac was the first thing Jobs did.

2:07:11He just did another Mac.

2:07:13It was Apple was the Mac company.

2:07:15And it's the brilliance of Jobs's strategy upon coming back to the company and taking

2:07:21the temporary CEO job in 98 or whatever year it was, was basically, well, we've got one

2:07:28thing that's paying the bills and it's taking on water and sinking.

2:07:31So let's cut everything else out.

2:07:33Let's stop doing everything else and fix the one thing that's paying the bills.

2:07:37Then once we've done that, we'll go from there.

2:07:39And it worked.

2:07:41But before he did that, there's one thing paying the bills and it's taking on water and it needs

2:07:47drastic help.

2:07:48And they were like, well, maybe we'll just make something that's not compatible with it

2:07:52at all.

2:07:52And yeah, we got to find the next big thing.

2:07:54Like even, even after Jobs came back and did the iMac, it's not as if he says, okay, we're

2:07:58going to do the iMac to hold up the Mac thing, but then we're going to find the next big

2:08:01thing, which is going to be the next big computing platform.

2:08:03No, they did the iPod, which is absolutely not.

2:08:07Like it was never envisioned as this is going to replace the Mac.

2:08:10This is the next era of computing.

2:08:11This is just, this is a cool idea we have for a product that we think is good.

2:08:14And thanks to the talent at Apple and Steve Jobs taste in giving the go ahead to that particular

2:08:21project and shaping how it looked, it turned out to be wildly successful.

2:08:24It wasn't the next big thing.

2:08:26And in fact, at the time it seemed like it was going to be super popular.

2:08:29But like, if you look at the, remember, see, we used to see those graphs of the iPod and

2:08:32it just was like a dome.

2:08:33It's like iPod, it's going to be things forever.

2:08:36And then it's like, ah, nevermind phone.

2:08:37And it just goes, ah, and the iPod fades away.

2:08:40And like the iPod was not like, you know, Scully was like, I can't figure out how to do the

2:08:44Mac.

2:08:44We're going to find the next big thing.

2:08:46And Jobs was like, I'm going to make it a new great Mac.

2:08:48And if you have, meantime, if you have another good idea, yeah, let's do that music player

2:08:52thing.

2:08:52It might work out.

2:08:53It turns out it did, but it was just a bridge to get to the iPhone.

2:08:56Right?

2:08:56Like they were, it was, he didn't come back and say, I'm betting the company on my grand

2:09:00vision for a device that's going to replace the Mac.

2:09:02That's not how he operated at all.

2:09:04The Apple would have gotten a business.

2:09:05Yeah.

2:09:06And you know what the iPod did in addition to everybody knows it's synced music and podcast

2:09:11files with your Mac, but you know what else it's synced with your Mac contacts.

2:09:17It was actually a better contact manager than the Newton, even though people don't think

2:09:22of the iPod as an app that you have your personal contacts on, but it was actually a better one

2:09:27than the Newton because it's synced with your frigging Mac where you actually had your contacts.

2:09:31Yeah.

2:09:33And I think for most people listening that era, that Steve Jobs, 97 through 2010 era is like

2:09:42the Apple that they remember as the golden era of Apple.

2:09:45That's the Apple that people, most people who know about Apple came to know about Apple

2:09:49because who knew about Apple before that?

2:09:51Just tech nerds after that, because the iPod was not a tech nerd thing.

2:09:56It was an everybody thing.

2:09:57And so remember when people used to say they were going to go to the iPod store, Apple opened

2:10:00to retail stores and they said, I was literally about to say that.

2:10:03And at first it drove me nuts because I'd be in the mall and I'd hear people say, let's go

2:10:08to the iPod store.

2:10:09And I would want, I've already, it's what, 25 years ago.

2:10:14And I wasn't an old man, but the old man that was waiting to come out of me wanted to yell

2:10:19at the kids who were roughly my age for calling it the iPod store.

2:10:23But then it's the Mac company.

2:10:25This iPod is just a new flash in the pan.

2:10:27What are you talking about?

2:10:28But like the iPod was mass market.

2:10:29And so, yeah, that's the Apple that most people know.

2:10:31But then like the serenity would come over me, serenity now.

2:10:35And I would think, well, this is good for Apple that there's something besides.

2:10:38The halo effect, the iPod halo effect.

2:10:39Yes.

2:10:39Yes.

2:10:40We're all hoping this is going to save the Mac.

2:10:42We're always like the iPod is just a vehicle to get our beloved platform to be successful.

2:10:46They're going to use an iPod and then they're going to consider using a Mac.

2:10:49And you know what?

2:10:49That kind of worked pretty well.

2:10:50And to go back to my earlier point, that to me, the eras of Apple are defined by Steve

2:10:56Jobs' presence, his absence, his presence, and then his absence again.

2:11:00And the thing that I think people see so fondly about that era that they see is missing, despite

2:11:09the unbelievable financial success and stability, both technical stability and financial stability

2:11:16of Apple under Tim Cook since Steve Jobs' death.

2:11:20But it was the sort of you-don't-know-what's-coming-next excitement of crazy stuff is going to come out.

2:11:28I was doing The Verges.

2:11:29Did you do the thing where you-

2:11:31Top 50.

2:11:32I can tell you, speaking of feeling like an old person, doing that thing.

2:11:36And I briefly glanced at what the ratings are.

2:11:38And I'm like, I can't be voting with these people.

2:11:40They have no idea what they're talking about.

2:11:41I should have looked at the ratings.

2:11:43I never look at the results before taking a poll.

2:11:47And I just opened it up and I started clicking.

2:11:49And I thought if I clicked 25 times, I'd be done.

2:11:51I didn't realize-

2:11:52Yeah, but no, it just goes on forever.

2:11:53It's like infinite scrolling.

2:11:54I never got to the end of it.

2:11:55But here's the thing.

2:11:56I started to get a sense when I saw which products they were picking.

2:11:59I'm like, really?

2:11:59It's not like you have every Apple product anymore.

2:12:03These are the ones you picked?

2:12:04So I'm like, we need a separate poll just for old people, for old school Mac users.

2:12:08Because this is going to be for the mass market.

2:12:10The Verge, it is a tech website, but it is not an Apple nerd website.

2:12:14And so I just totally dismissed their entire ratings to say, okay, this is what people who

2:12:19think it's the iPod store would rank these products.

2:12:20Yeah.

2:12:21They had two printers in the list.

2:12:22They had the LaserWriter 2 and the ImageWriter, maybe the ImageWriter 2.

2:12:26And they were like at 48 and 49 or something.

2:12:29And you could see it that it's young people who are like, printers?

2:12:31What the hell?

2:12:32I'm not doing it.

2:12:33And I think you would think the LaserWriter 1 would be in there, but no.

2:12:36Yeah, it was kind of.

2:12:37Well, anyway, I'm taking it.

2:12:39And before I realized that, A, I shouldn't have voted at all because it was too wrong.

2:12:43It's not for us.

2:12:43Yeah.

2:12:44It's like I'm trying to raise the ocean level by pissing in the ocean.

2:12:48I'm not going to have any effect here.

2:12:50But while I was clicking through it, they kept showing me the fat, fat nano iPod.

2:12:56Yeah.

2:12:57The first one.

2:12:58Yeah.

2:12:58And I'm like, I hated that iPod.

2:13:01I guess I kind of see that it was the first one sort of where they were like, maybe people

2:13:05do want to watch video on their pocket device.

2:13:08And that's why it had the weird dimensions it had.

2:13:11But it was such an ugly little thing.

2:13:14And it kept coming up in my comparison.

2:13:16And I was like, I'm going to pick the opposite, the other device every time.

2:13:19I don't care what it is.

2:13:21I'm going to pick the other device.

2:13:22Is that why?

2:13:23And then I was like, is that why they keep showing it to me?

2:13:26But it's the fat nano iPod.

2:13:29While I didn't like it, and it obviously is not the iPod form factor that just about anybody

2:13:34I know of thinks of when they think of a classic iPod.

2:13:37It at least exemplified the, hey, we'll try crazy new ideas every year.

2:13:42That is totally absent in the Tim Cook era.

2:13:45Yeah.

2:13:45I mean, the closest he gets is the Vision Pro.

2:13:47But I feel like the Vision Pro is more like his Newton, where it's a product line that

2:13:50he was obsessed with that cost a lot of money and was the next big thing it turned out so

2:13:54far not to be.

2:13:54Whereas Jobs would do stuff like the Cube, where it's like, I just think this is cool.

2:13:58And sometimes it's not going to work.

2:13:59And sometimes it is.

2:14:00But you know, we're going to check it out there.

2:14:01Yeah.

2:14:02And then they got rid of it.

2:14:03They didn't let the Cube hang around for too long.

2:14:06Yeah, because Jobs only likes winners.

2:14:08So he's going to be like, this one didn't work.

2:14:09We'll move on.

2:14:10We'll come back to that idea.

2:14:11We'll try it again with the trash can.

2:14:12It won't work.

2:14:13Maybe we'll get it with the studio.

2:14:14Right.

2:14:15And right, the problem with the trash can power Mac or Mac Pro wasn't that it was a

2:14:20bad idea.

2:14:21It was that it was the Mac Pro for six years.

2:14:24It's try it.

2:14:25And they couldn't upgrade it.

2:14:26That was like, if they wanted this to be the Mac Pro, like they've been able to upgrade

2:14:29the studio because the studio is basically the trash can Mac Pro in a different shape.

2:14:33But guess what?

2:14:33They've upgraded the studio.

2:14:34You can put different stuff in it and it gets more powerful.

2:14:36And they couldn't do that with the trash can.

2:14:38So it's oops.

2:14:39I don't know about you.

2:14:41And I was I was already not in the market for I never I haven't.

2:14:45bought a Pro Mac desktop since I think I've only ever bought one in my life.

2:14:52My Power Mac 9600 350, which is a long time ago.

2:14:57That was an amazing computer.

2:14:59But yeah, that was the last time you were in that market.

2:15:02Yeah, I've been MacBook as my desktop, I think, ever since.

2:15:09And you were obviously different.

2:15:11But I remember it.

2:15:13But I'm excited by Power Macs and Mac Pro hardware just knew that they weren't really for me.

2:15:21And I remember being excited about the trash can Mac Pro.

2:15:24I was like, wow, that's a cool idea.

2:15:26Yeah, it was.

2:15:26I was excited about it, too.

2:15:28They tried something new.

2:15:29Yeah.

2:15:30And I guess the argument is if you don't occasionally have a dud of an idea, hopefully not like a severe dud, but like, let's backtrack.

2:15:39And, you know, there was only one fat nano.

2:15:41Right.

2:15:41It's like, well, all right.

2:15:43Let's backtrack and go back to the other one buttonless shuffle.

2:15:45Let's all right.

2:15:47Forget about the one.

2:15:48Yeah.

2:15:49But didn't they try to say it had no buttons?

2:15:51I forget.

2:15:52Yeah, no.

2:15:52I said they did the one buttonless shuffle.

2:15:55Oh, OK.

2:15:55OK.

2:15:56Well, I thought you meant one button shuffle.

2:15:58But yes, the one comma buttonless shuffle.

2:16:01I think it might have had a hold switch on it.

2:16:04I forget.

2:16:04Yeah, I don't know.

2:16:06But you know what?

2:16:07That's too few buttons.

2:16:08But glad they tried it.

2:16:10Just glad also that they recognize that, no, that's not the way to make a shuffle.

2:16:15I wish Apple still did that.

2:16:17And that's the sort of thing I sort of hope to see a return to after.

2:16:21Well, I mean, you might.

2:16:23If they can ever get their Syriac together, all these rumored home products, a lot of them

2:16:26sound like potential duds in waiting.

2:16:28So you might get your wish to see a bunch of, like, how about this little thing?

2:16:31It sits on your table.

2:16:32It's got a screen and a robotic arm.

2:16:33What do you think?

2:16:34Yeah.

2:16:34And the screen uses the robotic arm and a camera to follow you around like a face.

2:16:39And it's like, I don't know.

2:16:40It seems like it could be weird, but it is different.

2:16:42And it's not like anything else.

2:16:44So I'd like to at least see you try it.

2:16:46It's not trying to be a new platform like the Vision Pro, where it's like, this is all

2:16:49a new platform.

2:16:50The future of computing, spatial computing, this, that, and the other thing.

2:16:52No, this is just a product that we made that we hope you'll like.

2:16:55It is not a platform.

2:16:56We're not going to sell apps on it.

2:16:57It's not going to change the way we use computers.

2:16:59It's going to hopefully sit somewhere in your house and be a useful thing for you.

2:17:02Maybe, maybe not.

2:17:03Kind of like the HomePods.

2:17:04It's like, we'll give it a go.

2:17:05But there's nothing about it that is like the folly of the Newton and the Vision Pro potentially

2:17:11is just like the idea that I've got, I'm going to come up with the next big thing.

2:17:15And maybe you're too early and maybe you're right about it, but it's not going to happen

2:17:18in your lifetime.

2:17:19But that's such a harder bet to make than, hey, let's just try a bunch of products.

2:17:23Let's make a cool Mac.

2:17:24Let's make a cool thing that's not a Mac that might be useful to people and see which

2:17:27one of those stick.

2:17:28That's much lower stakes.

2:17:30Yeah, and I kind of feel like there's a, I don't think they're giving up on the Vision

2:17:35Pro.

2:17:35I don't think anything, they came out with the, what was it, an M4 chip or is it an M5?

2:17:40M5.

2:17:41M5, yeah.

2:17:41So they updated the hardware, but I don't think they're giving up on it.

2:17:45I've heard nothing about layoffs from the team that's there.

2:17:48I think they're still full steam ahead, but there's like a lack of urgency that is obvious.

2:17:54And I feel like that urgency is what Steve Jobs infused the company with.

2:17:59Or sure, maybe he would have shipped the exact same 1.0 Vision Pro, but there would already

2:18:04be a second one out that addressed some of the problems, the price, the weight, something.

2:18:09There would have been something new out just to get something out.

2:18:13Like, hey, this obviously didn't resonate with the market, but if we believe in this as a

2:18:20concept, we need to get our act together and ship something different by next year.

2:18:25Let's go.

2:18:26Scrap it.

2:18:27That's the other choice, which is like, I've lost faith in this.

2:18:29I don't think we're going to be able to do it.

2:18:30We're too early.

2:18:31The tech's not ready.

2:18:31It's too heavy.

2:18:32It's too clunky.

2:18:33But the Apple, Tim Cook Apple did the car project for 10 years and luckily didn't ship anything, but

2:18:39it shows their dedication to like, we are behind this idea.

2:18:41We think there's something there.

2:18:42We're going to see it through versus the Cube where it's like, it didn't fulfill my dreams.

2:18:47So can it?

2:18:48Well, we can always make another Mac.

2:18:49Yeah.

2:18:50I don't know.

2:18:51It just seems less.

2:18:52It's just less exciting.

2:18:53It's more, the company is more successful.

2:18:55Clearly, it's arguably the most successful company in the world, but it's less exciting.

2:19:01Like Jobs, sometimes he just wanted to do something nutty just to do something nutty because he was

2:19:05bored and it was kind of made it more fun to watch and you kind of get this.

2:19:10Like I just wrote the other day, it's such a little thing.

2:19:12It's so silly.

2:19:14It's not the reason, it has nothing to do with the reason the iPhone became the hit that it did.

2:19:18But when Jobs made the first public phone call with an iPhone on stage at Macworld Expo,

2:19:23he called the Starbucks next to the Moscone and ordered a thousand latte, four thousand

2:19:29lattes and then said, sorry, sorry, wrong number and hung up.

2:19:32I can't see Tim Cook doing that.

2:19:34And there's something about that spirit that I feel like it's still there in the company.

2:19:41But like under Tim Cook, it doesn't come out.

2:19:44It never comes out.

2:19:45Yeah.

2:19:45This is the irreverent spirit of the original Mac team with their pirate flag and everything

2:19:49was some of the things that appealed to me as a kid.

2:19:50It's why I literally had pictures of them on my bedroom wall because they were like,

2:19:54as Naila Patel pointed out, it's like the pirate flag, better to be a pirate than to join

2:19:58the Navy.

2:19:58Steve Jobs started the Navy.

2:20:00He founded Apple.

2:20:00And now he's like, I'm rebelling against the company that I made because suits are stifling

2:20:05me.

2:20:05It's like you founded the company, dude.

2:20:07But that rebelliousness appealed to me as a kid because like we have to go off into our

2:20:12own corner and we have to do a thing that's different than the Apple II.

2:20:15Even though Apple II is making all the money and paying all of our salaries, we're going

2:20:18to do this different thing and we're pirates.

2:20:20And then in the Jobs II era, he had matured, but his force of will was so dominant in the

2:20:25company, perhaps learning from his mistakes of like never give up an ounce of power because

2:20:29I'd never want to be driven out of my own company again.

2:20:32It was so forceful that like everyone was in line behind Jobs, but here's the thing.

2:20:36It was kind of like the whole, my complaint about the Tim Cook and what good is having

2:20:39FU money if you never say FU.

2:20:41In the Steve Jobs II era, he was such a dominant force in the company that nobody would step out

2:20:47of line.

2:20:48None of his like lieutenants, not even any of his employees, that they were all aligned

2:20:53behind him.

2:20:53But when you talk to Steve Jobs, he could step out of line all he wanted.

2:20:57He could say whatever the hell he wanted because he was Steve Jobs.

2:21:02And so, yeah, if you interviewed anybody at Apple, they're not going to say anything.

2:21:06You interview Steve Jobs, you have no idea what he's going to say.

2:21:08He could say literally anything.

2:21:10He like, because he both had an exercise to freedom to be like, who's going to yell at

2:21:16me?

2:21:16I'm Steve Jobs.

2:21:17I can say whatever you want.

2:21:18Tim Cook is not like that.

2:21:20Nobody under Tim Cook will step out of line and say something Tim Cook doesn't want them

2:21:24to say.

2:21:24But Tim Cook will also never say anything that is not in line with the Apple philosophy.

2:21:29So any interview with Tim Cook is like, is he going to say anything exciting?

2:21:33The answer is no.

2:21:34He is not going to.

2:21:35I mean, unless he's literally making an announcement, which he is prepared ahead of time about something.

2:21:38You're never going to get an off the cuff remark from Tim Cook that reveals something

2:21:42about his character, about his position on technology.

2:21:45It's all going to be talking points.

2:21:47And it's like, you're Tim Cook.

2:21:48Who's going to yell at you?

2:21:49The board of directors?

2:21:50You could do anything you want, but that's not his personality.

2:21:53And so the excitement of the Steve Jobs era was that the one person who had the freedom

2:21:57to do whatever you want often did.

2:21:59He often did.

2:22:00He would do and say what he was to still that guy with his middle finger up to the IBM sign

2:22:04with the leather jacket from that picture.

2:22:05Like he was like that to the day he died.

2:22:07Yep.

2:22:08He didn't really need the FU money, but he had the FU influence and he used it.

2:22:14He had that attitude even before he had the FU money.

2:22:16Yes.

2:22:17The money came later.

2:22:20There's a story.

2:22:21Well, I forget where, but it was like before the iPhone, obviously.

2:22:24And Steve Jobs was on the Disney board and he went down to Florida, maybe.

2:22:30I think it was Florida where they had a board meeting and somebody showed him an ESPN phone

2:22:34because ESPN was already a Disney property.

2:22:37And it was like some kind of collaboration with Verizon.

2:22:40And you'd get sports scores on your dumb phone.

2:22:43And it had an ESPN logo.

2:22:44And somebody showed it to Steve Jobs thinking, hey, I'm going to impress.

2:22:48We've got this tech guy on the board and I'm going to show him our cool new ESPN phone.

2:22:52He's like, that's the stupidest thing I've ever seen.

2:22:53There's a reaction to almost everything, including things that later he would say are brilliant

2:22:59and the best thing ever.

2:22:59But yep.

2:23:00But like Tim Cook is on boards.

2:23:02I don't think he's on the Disney board.

2:23:04I know he's still on the Nike board.

2:23:05And if Nike came up with an idea as stupid as an ESPN phone back then, Tim Cook is not going to say that's the stupidest thing I ever saw.

2:23:13He's under the thing.

2:23:14If you don't have something nice to say, don't say anything at all.

2:23:16Yeah.

2:23:16He might.

2:23:17In private meetings, there's, you know, we just have that one.

2:23:20The one Tim Cook story we all have is of him being kind of a jerk in typical like internal big company boss way where the guy's going to get.

2:23:28Why are you still here?

2:23:28Why are you still here?

2:23:29And that reads as Tim Cook that I could totally see him doing that, that, yeah, he's not always the affable person in the interviews, that he can be a stern taskmaster internally.

2:23:36But that's internal only.

2:23:38And it's telling.

2:23:39That's the story we have.

2:23:40We don't have 900 of those.

2:23:41Do we have so many Steve Jobs stories inside and outside Apple in public interviews?

2:23:45Not like the stuff he did inside Apple was thousand times worse than the stuff he did in public.

2:23:49And even that was pretty bad.

2:23:51So definitely different leadership styles.

2:23:53Yeah.

2:23:54And I will lastly say, just to bring it up to the present day, that the sort of conservative, always on brand Tim Cook mindset, it has infused the company without ever egotistically trying to redefine the company in his image.

2:24:16Or like Scully, who I don't think tried to remake Apple, but really did, I think, getting to that point of why didn't the Newton integrate with the Mac at all?

2:24:26It was this is my new platform, and it's going to put the company in new territory and set it up for this knowledge navigator future.

2:24:36So why integrate with the old thing that everybody still associates with Steve Jobs, who I ran out of the company eight years ago or whatever?

2:24:42Tim Cook has, without ever trying to break the Apple he inherited from Steve Jobs, infused it with his own personality.

2:24:51And that happens under good, strong leadership, right?

2:24:54It's the natural course of, what, 14 years of CEO ship, 15, going on 15 later this year.

2:25:01Of course, the company has taken on more of Tim Cook's personality.

2:25:06But I think at this point, it's too much, right?

2:25:10It's too much Tim Cook personality infusing the company.

2:25:14And to the current moment of LLMs, I think it has made them so gun-shy and conservative about the weird things that can come out of LLMs, and even within the last few years, that them trying to make sure that anything that comes out of Siri and or Apple intelligence remains ever on brand for Apple is a mindset that kind of explains why they're so far behind.

2:25:40I mean, that may be part of the explanation, and honestly, I kind of agree with them there.

2:25:44There is some brand stuff that they need to protect, and currently the technology doesn't allow them to protect it that way.

2:25:48But I think the best example of the way the Tim Cook mindset is kind of hurting Apple here is that in the Jobs 2 era, with the whole company being so aligned behind him, the rest of the company also got to see him be Steve Jobs.

2:26:03So it was like, okay, we're not Steve Jobs, so we need to be on message and on point and do what the leader wants.

2:26:10But we look up there, and we see our boss, and he says whatever the hell he wants.

2:26:14And that's aspirational for them.

2:26:16And you would see that embodied in things like, maybe even before Steve Jobs dies, but certainly after, his alkalites that saw Steve Jobs, like Schiller, Schiller would occasionally say something irreverent.

2:26:28He's not Steve Jobs.

2:26:29He's not even Tim Cook.

2:26:30But it's like he grew up looking at Steve Jobs as his leader.

2:26:34And so the aspiration is, yeah, you've got to stay in line and be on message.

2:26:36But once you get to the top of this thing, you can say whatever you want.

2:26:39Whereas the Tim Cook era is, you've got to stay in line and be on message, even if you're at the top.

2:26:43So there's no one below Tim Cook that's saying, I aspire to eventually lead Apple, and when I lead Apple, I'll do whatever the hell you want.

2:26:50It's like, I aspire to lead Apple, and I guess I'll be just like Tim Cook and continue to be on message.

2:26:54And so I do worry about Ternus or whoever is going to succeed him, because what you need with a new leader is like, look, it's great to speak with one voice and be aligned, but the top of that pyramid can't be in that mindset because it's paralyzing.

2:27:07And so I do hope whoever succeeds him is able to say, I am now in the power seat.

2:27:13Like, I'm not suggesting Phil Schiller become CEO, he's an Apple fellow, and he's off doing whatever he's doing, but like, he so clearly aspired to be able to be as irreverent as Steve Jobs, and occasionally would sneak out little bits of irreverence, even when Steve Jobs was still around and when he was still at Apple.

2:27:30And that's just not something you see from anybody you see in a keynote these days.

2:27:34Like, you cannot get them on the record being a little stinker.

2:27:37Schiller came on our podcast and was a little bit of a little stinker, and he was still working at Apple then.

2:27:43You've had him on the talk show and everything, but think of all your talk show appearances with those Apple execs.

2:27:47Like, Jaws is a little bit of a stinker in service of Tim Cook's message, and Phil was a little bit of a stinker on his own, and irreverent to everything that came before him.

2:27:57And like, I just don't know how this is going to go, because I really do feel like change in leadership is your opportunity to do something different and to be different.

2:28:03And I think we've run the course of what Tim Cook's style of leadership can provide, which is some amazing stuff, but also some downsides.

2:28:09But I hope the next leader is different, hopefully in a better way.

2:28:12But different, even different in a worse way would be a refreshing change.

2:28:16I forget how I know this, and it might be that I know it directly from Phil, and it was off the record, but he'll forgive me, I think.

2:28:26But I happen to know for a fact that the can't innovate anymore, my ass line, which I think comes from the introduction of the trash can Mac Pro, was ad-libbed and did not occur in any of the rehearsals.

2:28:41Because it was truly felt by Phil in that moment, you could all tell.

2:28:44Yes, and Phil, from the live keynotes, one of the rules, they did not have scripts, and there were talking points.

2:28:52The slides were obviously made in advance, and they rehearsed, rehearsed, rehearsed.

2:28:56But there was no script, and that was a Jobs rule from on high that he doesn't want anybody up there reading from a script because it plays flat.

2:29:05So you've got to speak extemporaneously on stage, but you do need to rehearse.

2:29:11And Phil has told me, and Phil was always great on stage.

2:29:15I would say second best only to Jobs, and there's no question that we know that when Jobs was on missed keynotes because of his medical problems, it was always Phil who stood in for him, which is the toughest thing.

2:29:27Because here, the guy, everybody really wants to see Steve Jobs, he's sick, and everybody's worried about him, and Phil would step in.

2:29:32Phil has told me that the hardest part from his perspective was he did rehearse, and he was there for every rehearsal watching everybody else rehearse and giving notes.

2:29:40But then he never wanted to give his best performance in a rehearsal.

2:29:44He wanted to have it down and feel like, okay, this is good, this is tight, we're hitting all the messages, but I want to stop right now because the next time I give it, I feel like it's going to be the best one, and I want that to be the real one.

2:29:55And that's where it came out.

2:29:57It was his best delivery of the introduction of the Mac Pro, and he added the line, can't innovate anymore of my ass.

2:30:04It's hard to see anybody at Apple today doing that.

2:30:09Again, even Tim Cook, because Tim Cook could do it.

2:30:11You're at the CEO, you can do it, you can check the tone.

2:30:14And it's like, nope, I'm never going to do that.

2:30:16And people would go nuts, that would be the thing, as restrained as Cook has been in public for all this time, if he did it now, people would go nuts for it.

2:30:25If he did it now, I'm not sure if the sentiment has turned so much, but we'll see.

2:30:30I mean, I guess in our little bubble of the world, the sentiment has turned, but I bet when he goes on stage at WRC, there'll still be the same amount of cheers as there has always been.

2:30:38Yeah.

2:30:38And I don't expect any curse words, even as mild as ass.

2:30:43All right.

2:30:45Well, see you in 50 years, John.

2:30:47I guess I'll have you on the show in between.

2:30:50Yeah, I hope so, because again, remember about the brain mush thing.

2:30:53Oh my God, imagine how many fucking ATPs you're going to have between them.

2:30:56Jesus Christ.

2:30:59I don't get it with the 52 shows.

2:31:0152 shows a year for 13 years or so.

2:31:04And now you've got the extra ones, too.

2:31:06So you're probably up to like 52.

2:31:08Yeah, monthly member specials for the past several years.

2:31:11Yeah, and I feel like someday we're going to have a challenging summer schedule this year, but we really don't want to break the streak if possible.

2:31:2052 episodes a year, every year, ATP.

2:31:23It's too much, but it is good.

2:31:25All right.

2:31:26I thank our sponsors, Factor, where you can go get some food.

2:31:30And Sentry, where it's like a dev kit you can put in your app and do all sorts of great stuff with the analytics you collect from your app.

2:31:40And the third one, Notion, the all-in-one AI slash notes database for your teams.

2:31:45Thanks to them.

2:31:46And thank you, John, for everything, really.

2:31:49I mean it.

2:31:4950 years.

2:31:50I'll see you there.

2:31:51We'll be back any time.