0:00:00There are good times to come on the talk show, and there are really good times to come on the talk show.
0:00:05This is the latter.
0:00:07I was thinking about how to open here, and it popped into my head.
0:00:10I return to you at the turnus of the time.
0:00:14How about that?
0:00:15You know what?
0:00:15You're always good for a pun or two, or a movie reference, or both.
0:00:19Yep, or both.
0:00:21Often both.
0:00:21But yes, very good time.
0:00:23We are recording one week after the big announcements, which I think is perfect.
0:00:29I did a couple quick takes on Dithering with Ben Thompson.
0:00:32At the end of the week, I had a very good time with David Pearson and Eli Patel on the Vergecast talking about, guess what?
0:00:40I'm kind of glad to let my big podcast take sit for a week before I talk about it.
0:00:46Where are you at a week later?
0:00:48So as you and I talked about sort of off camera last night and a few days ago, when I write, it sounds like you're the same way.
0:00:56I like to write with fresh, fresh in my head, right?
0:01:00So, like, I try not to read anything about whatever the topic is at hand.
0:01:03Obviously, I'll read, like, the major Wall Street Journal high overview reports to know what the details are.
0:01:09But, you know, in terms of other people's takes and opinions and op-eds and whatnot, I try to keep those out of my feeds or just out of my reader until after I've written something.
0:01:19And while I wrote something, I guess, shortly after, you know, the Cook announcement, I wrote about Cook, but I hadn't written anything about Ternus until I finally did.
0:01:28I published, like, an hour ago, two hours ago or something, because I'm in the UK.
0:01:31So it's still the middle of the day here.
0:01:34And so I feel good about, I think, where my head is at now, too, a week in.
0:01:38So it's not too hot-takey, but it's also nothing too surprising, right?
0:01:43I mean, I think that we've both been following the company long enough to know that this was handled exceptionally well.
0:01:49And so there's no craziness.
0:01:51There's some interesting, I think, things on the periphery to talk about with how it happens and sort of the go-forward strategy of what they may or may not do.
0:01:58But the overall news item itself is pretty established.
0:02:01I think the more I think about it, the more, like, my original take was I kind of smelled this coming.
0:02:07I, for one, really, really, when the FT Financial Times report came out in mid-November, I was like, oh, this is a little surprising that the timeline is so soon.
0:02:20But the FT is, I mean, this is like a lock.
0:02:23I remember, and it was like a really, it was a, for the blockbuster nature of the story that they reported in November, it was actually relatively short.
0:02:31And I went back and reread the whole thing just this week.
0:02:34And it's like, there's not that much more here, but it's got four bylines.
0:02:39Yeah, exactly.
0:02:39Yep.
0:02:40Led by Tim Bradshaw, right, who's well-known, like a very good reporter in this regard.
0:02:47And yeah, and so I, you know, I thought the same thing when I saw it.
0:02:51It's like, not too shocking.
0:02:53The timing, though, makes it seem like if the FT is coming out with this, there's something to the timing element of it.
0:03:00Like either, you don't want to say it's like necessarily hand-fed to them by Apple, but there's some sort of probably something going on behind the scenes.
0:03:08Maybe they were digging into it, maybe Apple decided that they wanted something out there, or maybe not even Apple itself, maybe someone just close to Cook decided that they were okay with sort of letting something sort of slip out there.
0:03:21That has not, that part of it has not come out sort of the behind the scenes element.
0:03:24I don't think it ever will.
0:03:25I don't think it ever will.
0:03:26I don't think it ever will either, of course.
0:03:28But the Mark Gurman element adds an interesting wrinkle to the way that this was reported.
0:03:32And obviously you've talked about that sort of extensively now and wrote about that.
0:03:36Should we save that?
0:03:37I don't know if we should get that out of the way.
0:03:38We could save it.
0:03:39Yeah, it comes into play.
0:03:41It's not the important thing.
0:03:41I'll just say, yeah, let's get to it.
0:03:43But I'll say, how's that for a teaser?
0:03:45I'll say, so like a week ago when it dropped, I was like, huh, okay, now.
0:03:52And it's like, yeah, I guess that's just, you know, we've been sort of bracing for this.
0:03:57It was exciting, but not at all surprising.
0:03:59And now a week later where the excitement is sort of worn off a little, and I don't mean that in a disparaging way.
0:04:05I just mean, okay, this is what they're going to do.
0:04:07It all seems so obvious.
0:04:09And whether it turns out that Ternus is the right guy and Ternus does a good job in the role of CEO, obviously that is to be determined.
0:04:20That is the, you know, it's the nature of a transition like this.
0:04:24Whether it's a political thing like electing a new president or governor or a sports thing, like when you name a new head coach and the old head coach goes out on top and retires rather than being fired, which is probably even more rare in sports than CEOs.
0:04:39I mean, even Joe Belichick got run out of town.
0:04:42I mean, Jesus Christ.
0:04:43Very few retire.
0:04:44So that's to be determined.
0:04:47But in terms of like, how did Tim Cook want to leave the position of CEO of Apple?
0:04:55How did he want to become CEO?
0:04:57I think it's the honest to God truth that he never wanted to be CEO.
0:05:01I really do.
0:05:02I mean, certainly not.
0:05:04It's definitely not in the way.
0:05:05No, I don't think so.
0:05:07With tragedy surrounding it.
0:05:08But I think you're probably right.
0:05:10I mean, I think, look, Apple back then, back 15 plus years ago, as all big companies do, they need a succession plan, right?
0:05:19Like it's famous, like it gets talked about a lot in the press because it's a known thing.
0:05:23If the CEO gets hit by the proverbial bus, who takes over?
0:05:27And so you need a plan, especially as a public company, that needs to be in place.
0:05:31And Steve Jobs' pancreas effectively got hit by the worst type of bus.
0:05:35It really did.
0:05:37So the plan really did have to be enacted a couple of times because it was an extended, protracted medical crisis with multiple, two significant medical leaves, et cetera, where Tim Cook stood in as the temporary CEO or I don't even know if they called him that.
0:05:54And remind me this, I was thinking about this in the context of obviously this transition, but so I recall vividly when I think it was Wall Street Journal that broke the news about Jobs' liver transplant, but it had happened well after the fact, right?
0:06:09It was like he was well into recovery.
0:06:12And so presumably Cook had taken over the reins sort of as like when the president is ill or under anesthesia or whatnot, then the vice president sort of gets the ability.
0:06:23And so I didn't remember, did Apple actually announce that Cook had taken over before they later announced that Jobs has actually had the liver transplant and they just said, oh, he's, he's, there's something going on and we need Cook or did they?
0:06:39I forget.
0:06:39And I don't think, I don't feel like looking it up because I don't think it matters because I think in broad strokes, you're exactly right, which is that more or less his desire for privacy combined with his,
0:06:53being Steve Jobs and maybe being mad about it.
0:06:57They kept the whole thing more or less under wraps.
0:07:00I forget if he actually, I don't know that he had the surgery without people knowing, but I think that he went on a medical leave before they announced that he went on a medical leave.
0:07:11And it wasn't, it wasn't that he had the surgery and there was some initial denial and a really kind of, it really seemed to go just between Steve Jobs and Katie Cotton and the world.
0:07:24And it didn't seem to go to the board and it didn't seem to be a healthy dynamic.
0:07:29And that was, and it was, remember when, and then Jobs, and he was still, there was that incident where he called Joe Nassera at the New York Times, just picked up the phone and called him.
0:07:41Yeah.
0:07:42It's called him a scumbag.
0:07:44You're jogging my mom when you remember.
0:07:45Called him a scumbag.
0:07:45Yeah, that's right.
0:07:46You know, you're a real scumbag.
0:07:49But here's the deal.
0:07:50But he was like, but, you know, you're at the New York Times, so I'll tell you the deal.
0:07:54It just was messy.
0:07:56And it was, and I think the messiness is at a personal level, everybody can 100% understand the desire for privacy.
0:08:05And as the leader of a publicly held company, you can also totally understand that you cannot keep this private.
0:08:13It's, there's an obligation that it really is like being a public servant, being the better than me.
0:08:21But that there are certain positions in a publicly held company that are effectively like public servants, and you have to be listed in the forms, and there's also.
0:08:32Yeah, and any material changes, like, has to be notified, you have to make a filing.
0:08:38You have obligations.
0:08:38There's all sorts.
0:08:39Yeah, if anything, the laws might be more clear for the leaders of a publicly held corporation in terms of making that clear than for things like the president.
0:08:49I mean, there was all sorts of, there was a lot of shenanigans when Trump got COVID, and apparently almost fucking died back in 2020, or whatever the hell that was.
0:08:58Yeah, I think it was late 2020.
0:09:00Yes, but where you're headed with this is that, I think, is Cook, so Cook back then obviously took the reins sort of because someone had to, and that's not to say he wasn't a great choice.
0:09:12He was the perfect choice.
0:09:13He was really probably the only choice, right?
0:09:14He was the person who could keep the trains, all the operations literally running on time.
0:09:19And so he, of course, would sort of swap in there without anyone missing a beat in terms of Apple's overall operations.
0:09:27But I think there is a broader question, like, that you sort of hit on of if Cook would have actually been the successor had he not been teed up by Jobs' unfortunate health situation previously.
0:09:40So Cook basically moved into the de facto role because he was already in the role previously, and then, of course, leading into Jobs' next sort of leave of absence and then ultimate stepping down.
0:09:52There was no question that it would be Cook because he had done it before.
0:09:55And there is a question, though, I think, maybe with hindsight, would the board, I guess, and Jobs have chosen Cook to be the one to succeed him if he had been in total health throughout that entire role?
0:10:08You know, and I do think it's interesting, and this was something, I'll bet you didn't look at my piece until after you wrote your piece, but we both, you and me, both opened by going back to 2011 when Steve Jobs resigned.
0:10:23And that's why I'm going back to this.
0:10:25I do think it's really interesting that Cook, I don't think, ever wanted to be CEO.
0:10:29I think he had, what's that principle where you level up, the Peter principle where you rise to the level of your incompetence in an organization?
0:10:38I think it's the Peter principle.
0:10:40I might be getting it wrong whose principle it is.
0:10:43But the idea is, let's just say you're a really good programmer, and then you become a really good senior program, and then you become a programming manager, and maybe you're good at it.
0:10:53And then you get promoted to be like a senior vice president of other programming managers, and maybe you're terrible at that job.
0:11:00But you got the promotion because you were good at that level, and now you stop getting promoted because now you're at a job where you're no good.
0:11:07And you kind of, if you, it's kind of a crappy place in your career because maybe like for your own personal happiness and you're thriving, you kind of want to take a demotion and go back to where you were good.
0:11:18And I think Cook knew that.
0:11:21I think Cook knew that being the COO and right-hand man to Steve Jobs was exactly where he wanted to be.
0:11:28There were reports.
0:11:29I don't remember the specific ones, but of course there were because he was such an operational wizard, and everybody knew it.
0:11:35Before Jobs even got sick, everybody knew, holy shit, Apple used to be known for having terrible operations.
0:11:43I mean, it was a huge part of the bankruptcy crisis when Steve Jobs and Next were reunified with Apple in 1996 and going into 1997 and 98, and the whole, hey, we're like 90 days away from bankruptcy at one point.
0:12:00A huge part of that, it wasn't because sales tanked particularly, it wasn't, and people misremember this, and no, it wasn't good two years after Windows 95.
0:12:08Windows 95 did adversely affect the market share dynamics in the PC market in terms of, hey, this looks good enough.
0:12:16This doesn't look so janky anymore.
0:12:18But Mac sales were troubled, and the Mac future operating system was severely troubled, but the sales weren't so bad.
0:12:26The biggest problem with the bankruptcy crisis is that they would have these quarters where they ended with massive amounts of inventory.
0:12:34Yeah, inventory, misremembering.
0:12:36Right, and they had this totally dysfunctional internal culture where people were like, I don't know if this company is going to be around anymore.
0:12:43I want to try to make my mark this quarter.
0:12:46And they had managers ordering all of this inventory and building it up because then for this quarter, well, look how many Macs we made.
0:12:56And then here's your bonus.
0:12:58And then they're like, they're sitting in warehouses not being sold, getting old, and you can't sell old computers.
0:13:05That was the big problem.
0:13:06And they had a huge inventory problem just manufacturing-wise and parts that were being shipped around the world.
0:13:13And, hey, we're out of this one component, and we're manufacturing these devices in Mexico.
0:13:18Where do we get the component?
0:13:20Oh, that one comes from Taiwan.
0:13:21So you've got to wait a couple weeks.
0:13:23And it's Cook fixed all of that.
0:13:25I mean, it's like they went.
0:13:26Yeah.
0:13:27They went, if anything, he did the exact, he took it to the other extreme, right, with basically creating sort of just-in-time, yeah, creation.
0:13:36They went from having, like, weeks of inventory to having, like, hours of inventory for a lot of things by moving to China.
0:13:43And everybody knew it.
0:13:45And so there were feelers out there.
0:13:46I think Tim Cook, it was one of those things where his admin staff probably dealt with people asking, hey, do you want to be CEO?
0:13:54You want to interview to be CEO of this company, that company, this company, every day?
0:13:57Yes.
0:13:57And I don't think he had any interest in it.
0:13:59I think that he's somebody who thought, hey, being the right-hand man and COO of this company is actually better than being the CEO of any other company.
0:14:08And being the COO of Apple while Steve Jobs was still there running product and-
0:14:15Yeah, is the best possible combination.
0:14:17Yeah.
0:14:17Right.
0:14:17And I wrote several times before Steve Jobs passed that if you just described what these two men did at Apple, just here's what this guy does.
0:14:27Here's what this other guy does and what they're responsible for.
0:14:30And gave those descriptions to somebody who knows how corporations work.
0:14:34They'd point to Cook and say, well, he's probably the CEO of the company.
0:14:39And this other guy is, I don't know what his title is, but he's probably like the director of-
0:14:43Yeah, head of product, head of strategy.
0:14:45Yeah, something like that.
0:14:46Yeah, yeah, yeah.
0:14:46And it was the other way around.
0:14:48So I think Cook knew that and he's humble.
0:14:51I don't think he needed the title.
0:14:52I think he was fine with it.
0:14:53And I think he obviously knew in terms of being like the face of the company.
0:14:57Well, duh.
0:14:59I mean, we're still talking about it now that Steve Jobs was so goddamn good.
0:15:03You can't replace him.
0:15:05Yeah.
0:15:05So I think that's A, a key.
0:15:07He did not take the job the way he wanted.
0:15:09I don't think he ever wanted it.
0:15:11If Steve Jobs were still alive, I just looked it up.
0:15:13He'd be 71.
0:15:13I think if he had never gotten cancer, he might still be CEO.
0:15:17Yeah.
0:15:18I mean, look at Larry Ellison, who's his buddy, right?
0:15:21Yeah.
0:15:21I think they, who's older than he is, quite, I think 10 years older maybe than he is.
0:15:25And he's still, he's not, he's not effectively CEO of Oracle, but he obviously runs Oracle.
0:15:30Like everyone knows that.
0:15:31And I think Jobs would probably be, it might be, I've referenced this recently, but you'll remember
0:15:36the movie Casino with Robert De Niro, where he's running the casino, but he keeps
0:15:40switching job titles because the gaming commission won't give him, let him take that title.
0:15:45He's the head of food and beverage.
0:15:48Food and beverage.
0:15:49Yeah.
0:15:49So I can see Jobs, Jobs is the head of, yeah, the culinary staff at Apple, but calling the
0:15:56shots as he gives other people some time in the spotlight to build them up or whatnot.
0:16:00But yeah, there's a, well, it's, I can't help.
0:16:06I got to digress.
0:16:07My wife and I always refer back to that scene in Casino where De Niro is having breakfast
0:16:11with somebody in the hotel restaurant and there's two blueberry muffins and one has way too
0:16:18few blueberries and the other one has too many.
0:16:21And he's, hold on a second.
0:16:22And he goes back to the kitchen to talk to the chef, the head chef of the whole casino.
0:16:26And he's like, I want the same amount of blueberries in every muffin.
0:16:30And the guy says, are you kidding me?
0:16:31He goes, look at this one.
0:16:32Doesn't have enough.
0:16:33Look at this one.
0:16:33It has too many.
0:16:34It falls apart.
0:16:34I want the same amount in every muffin.
0:16:36And the guy's like, do you know how long that's going to take?
0:16:38And De Niro's like, I don't care.
0:16:40Do it.
0:16:41My wife and I talk about that all the time and talk about Steve Jobs.
0:16:46Yeah, that's a Steve Jobs moment right there.
0:16:47Blueberry management.
0:16:50To go back to your earlier point real quick, though, about the timing of this part with Cook himself.
0:16:55So when the news first hit, yeah, my mind immediately went to, even ahead of sort of subsequent reporting,
0:17:01which I think confirmed a bunch of this, is that it's all obvious stuff, right?
0:17:05So, of course, there had been already the FT report.
0:17:07There had been the Gurman reporting about succession planning.
0:17:10But then why now?
0:17:11And the timing, I think, just was lining up.
0:17:14The thing I had written months before sort of this, when it actually happened, had been around, like,
0:17:20why might now be a time riffing off of the FT piece of why it seems like, yeah,
0:17:25they were sort of reading the room correctly and why it was the right timing.
0:17:29And it just felt like we knew we were heading into a, what Apple had already said in the previous earnings report,
0:17:35would likely be a block, quote-unquote, blockbuster quarter, as Apple's holiday quarter often is,
0:17:40because that's their main sales period.
0:17:42But it seemed like it was teed up particularly well for it to be an all-time great quarter.
0:17:46And again, they sort of guided to that.
0:17:49So we knew that that was going to be the case.
0:17:50So that was coming in early 2026.
0:17:53And then we also knew that Apple's 50th anniversary was coming up, right?
0:17:58And that was on April 1st in 2026.
0:18:01And we also knew where the stock was, but we knew that there were potentially some storm clouds on the horizon,
0:18:07the least of which was war actually breaking out, but also everything going on.
0:18:12Literal war.
0:18:12Everything.
0:18:13Literal war happening.
0:18:15And so all of these things are swirling around and it just felt, look, Cook, while he cares first and foremost about Apple and leaving Apple in a great spot,
0:18:23he also has to care somewhat about legacy.
0:18:25And he knows that this is like a unique moment in time for him to sort of step back and be sort of at the top, right?
0:18:32With the best earnings of Apple's history, the stock potentially at or near all-time highs, around $4 trillion, Apple's 50th.
0:18:41In hindsight, it's obvious he cared quite a bit about that, right?
0:18:44Famously repeating over and over again, we normally don't do things and Apple normally doesn't look back, but here we're going to do that.
0:18:50So obviously he wanted to be there for that.
0:18:52And so I don't think it's a coincidence that obviously it happened shortly thereafter, a few weeks after,
0:18:56and just ahead of the newest earnings reports, which are later this week.
0:19:00And then, of course, going into the fall, we know about that with the iPhone and whatnot.
0:19:04But I think you noted it too, WWDC gives him one more time on stage, one more keynote.
0:19:10And so all of those things led to this perfect storm where, of course, this is the perfect timing for this to happen announcement-wise right now.
0:19:18And think back to the FT thing that kick-started this.
0:19:23I think it's step one of this plan.
0:19:25In mid-November, so in mid-November, they are exactly halfway through.
0:19:30The holiday quarter.
0:19:31The announcements, the iPhone 17 generation, including the iPhone Air, which probably didn't contribute too much because everybody says it's not selling that well.
0:19:42But the iPhone 17 generation was announced in September on time.
0:19:46There were no shipping delays.
0:19:48They knew how well it was selling, which it turns out is extremely well.
0:19:52The 17 Pro is probably the single most successful iPhone they've ever made.
0:19:57It is a smash hit.
0:19:59The orange is a big hit.
0:20:01A massive, massive hit.
0:20:02I talked to someone at Apple about, like, how come there are no ads for the iPhone Air?
0:20:09And it's like, I love this goddamn thing.
0:20:12Yeah.
0:20:12Why?
0:20:12And the explanation is basically like a sports analogy.
0:20:16Hey, when somebody on the team has a hot hand, you keep giving them the ball.
0:20:20And that's the iPhone 17 Pro.
0:20:22And it's like there's only so many ads to go around, so many billboards, so many commercials.
0:20:28And people just keep – there still are supply problems.
0:20:32Like, they're making them as fast as they can and selling them as fast as they can.
0:20:35Don't mess with it.
0:20:37And that's it.
0:20:37And it is – you know, it makes sense to me.
0:20:40But – and if you remember back to the iPhone 5C, the colorful one, they did plaster that all over.
0:20:46And it still didn't sell well.
0:20:47So they have a history of knowing that it doesn't necessarily work that way.
0:20:50There is a weird chicken and egg scenario to marketing where you can't – you don't just magically sell things by pushing it.
0:20:58The iPhone 5C is a perfect example.
0:21:00And you do sell more of a thing that's already selling by pushing it.
0:21:05Like, it is.
0:21:07And – but by mid-November, they knew it, right?
0:21:09They knew they were going to have a blockbuster probably already.
0:21:12I think they could be confident they were going to have the record-breaking best quarter in the history of the company that they were going to have.
0:21:20So that's when they – that's when they tipped the FT.
0:21:23That's when they set this in motion.
0:21:25Like, this got set in motion in mid-November at a point where it's, okay, we're going to have the best quarter ever.
0:21:30The most important product in the company, the iPhone, is in the best shape it's ever been.
0:21:35Let's get this started.
0:21:3650th is coming up.
0:21:38Everything seemed – and again, this is the whole point of this whole segment of the show is a week later.
0:21:44I can't – from Tim Cook's perspective, I cannot think of a way that this could have – this succession could have been announced and put into motion and timed better.
0:21:54There's no possible way.
0:21:56There is no – everybody's in good health.
0:21:58Everybody is – the company is in fantastic health.
0:22:01Another bit of timing that I don't think you mentioned is Ternus is 50 or 51.
0:22:06It doesn't seem – his birthday is not public knowledge, but he's either 50 or 51, and he might be – he'll probably be going to turn 51 before September 1st.
0:22:14Which is exactly the age Cook was.
0:22:16And if he's successful and has a 15-year run, he'll be around the age Cook is now when it's time for the next succession.
0:22:24Perfectly aligned.
0:22:26One more thing off of that, Cook is 65, which isn't technically the retirement age anymore.
0:22:33I think it's 67.
0:22:33But still, 65 is a nice round age.
0:22:36And Apple famously has their 75 cutoff date for the board, so this would give him exactly 10 years to be on the board as chair and sort of lead from that thing.
0:22:48Which leads to the one other bit of why I pushed back a little bit on Gurman after he pushed back on the FT report because just reading the tea leaves of what happened with Arthur Levinson, who is the board chair of Apple and longstanding since right after –
0:23:03Sorry, right after Jobs passed away.
0:23:05Back in 2011, he was elevated to that role and had been on the board since –
0:23:082000.
0:23:09It has been on the board since 2000, yeah, for a long, long time.
0:23:12So the fact that Apple put out there that they were waiving the 75-year age limit for him and Ronald Sugar, who's another longstanding board member.
0:23:23Now, at the time, they sort of couched it like, look, there's a lot of turnover at Apple.
0:23:27There was a bunch of senior executives retiring.
0:23:29And so you could say that, yeah, that's all normal.
0:23:32But doesn't it just make sense?
0:23:33And this is obvious in hindsight, but I said it in real time at the time.
0:23:37I think that this – that signal, basically, that they knew that Cook would be stepping into that chairman role sooner rather than later.
0:23:46And so there's no way that they let Levinson either off the board or taking out of a chairman role and putting someone in for six months.
0:23:54That doesn't make any sense to do that.
0:23:55And so either you leave it vacant or you just wait for Cook to come in on his timing.
0:24:01And I think he may have taken the holiday time to make sure that he was feeling good about it and making sure that everything was aligned, making sure there was no, say, COVID on the horizon.
0:24:10Like when Bob Iger retired the first time around and famously left sort of a mess, which ended up a giant mess back in his lap after it didn't work out with Bob J. Beck in the first go around.
0:24:20And so I think all of those things come perfectly into play for the time.
0:24:24Yeah, and I think if something else had happened, some black swan event, to put it in that parlance, where let's say instead of a war with Iran that closes the Strait of Hormuz, let's say it's some kind of situation with Taiwan.
0:24:39And all of a sudden products can't get out of Taiwan with China or something like that, a real which would be a huge crisis for Apple.
0:24:46Well, then Tim Cook says, OK, I got at least another year.
0:24:50I'm not handing off the job in this position in that case.
0:24:53Then I think they make a special announcement about Arthur Levinson where they're going to make an exception.
0:24:59And he'll stay as chairman of the board for another year, even because there's a all this is going on.
0:25:04We don't want any disruption on the board.
0:25:06And we're going to make we know that the rule says 75, but Arthur Levinson is in great health and has been a key part of the company since 2000.
0:25:13So he's going to stay another year on as chairman of the board.
0:25:16And there still would have to have been an announcement of some sort.
0:25:20And then that announcement would have been like, oh, Cook's not going anywhere for a year or two.
0:25:24Yes, yes, exactly.
0:25:27But I think that the way they did announce that was a huge tea leaf.
0:25:32Hey, get ready.
0:25:34Like my analogy, I forget if I forget if I put it in writing or not or said it on a podcast.
0:25:39But my analogy is at least I do.
0:25:41I am not a just jump in the pool, get cold person.
0:25:45I put my feet in the water first.
0:25:47Give me a minute.
0:25:49Give me a minute to put my feet in, maybe go up to my ankles, and then I'm going to jump in.
0:25:53And that's what the FT story was.
0:25:56The FT story in November was we're going to put everybody's feet in the water that this is going to happen.
0:26:02And it wasn't – I don't think it was a trial balloon.
0:26:05It wasn't like Apple was waiting to see what everybody said about this plan.
0:26:09That plan, they were like, we know this is going to happen.
0:26:11We just don't want you to be shocked when this happens.
0:26:18Yes, exactly.
0:26:19Yeah, and I had called it a trial balloon, and I got pushback for that.
0:26:22And I think rightfully so, as you're saying right now.
0:26:24You're right.
0:26:25What I mean by that is exactly what you're saying.
0:26:27It wasn't that there was a go, no go for like public perception of it or something like that.
0:26:32It was just to guide the market to know that this was likely coming down the pike and it would happen at some point to be determined.
0:26:41And again, I do think that there was some wiggle room there probably in Cook's court, right?
0:26:45If he decided for whatever reason that he didn't want to step back just right now, it wasn't good timing.
0:26:51For any number of reasons, macro or personal wise, we probably could have pulled it back and said like, hey, let's revisit this in the fall or whatnot.
0:26:58But obviously, yeah, it didn't play out that way.
0:27:02And one other thing that I'm just reminded of talking through this is, remember, we talked about Iger.
0:27:06Iger was on Apple's board for a long, long time.
0:27:09And so that they had to, he must have consulted with him.
0:27:12And Bob Iger went through his own transition, his second transition out of CEO role around the same time.
0:27:19And so obviously, he's conferring with people like that and figuring out exactly what that looks like.
0:27:23Remember, too, he's on the Nike board and they've gone through their own CEO transition.
0:27:27Which wasn't good.
0:27:28Yeah, that's good.
0:27:29Which wasn't a good one.
0:27:30And so all of these things are in his head of knowing why this timing needs to be right.
0:27:37All right, let's come back to that.
0:27:38I'm going to take a break here and thank our first sponsor.
0:27:40It's our good friends at Squarespace.
0:27:42Hey, Squarespace is the most consistent, longest running sponsor of the talk show.
0:27:50And I thank them for that.
0:27:51It's great.
0:27:52But the reason why, it's not like they're just squirting money into the air on this.
0:27:57It is because listeners of this show keep coming back to Squarespace through the code talk show and signing up for websites.
0:28:07And or, as I often reiterate here, as the sort of nerd who listens to a podcast like this, you are the go to person in your family and your friend circle.
0:28:20Like somebody needs a website, they come to you, send them to Squarespace, give them the code talk show and let them do it on their own.
0:28:29And they really can.
0:28:31That is, there are so many little features and I often call them out, the things like the great analytics, the AI design features, all the different ways that you can take payments and stuff on Squarespace.
0:28:42The way that if somebody runs or you run like a consulting business or something like that, where what you're selling is your time, you can do that through Squarespace too.
0:28:52They have an invoice feature that is built into the platform that is also, of course, integrated with their payment system.
0:28:59So the invoices you generate through a Squarespace site, when the client gets the invoice and pays the invoice, it goes through, it's all just built into the system.
0:29:08But the thing that I'll keep coming back to is that it is a WYSIWYG, even better than WYSIWYG, but just sort of approachable to a normal non-web developer person to create their own website the way that they want it to look.
0:29:26And not starting from a blank canvas because they're not a designer, but starting from a wide assortment of really good templates and with really good tools to customize those templates just the way you want.
0:29:39Or if you have a brand for your business or service, you can use that brand to create a website in the flavor of that brand.
0:29:48So if you need a new website or somebody you know needs a new website, go to squarespace.com slash talk show.
0:29:57And using that URL and using that code, you get after your 30-day free trial, which has no limits and no watermarks or anything, 30 days to just make the website, get it the way you want.
0:30:09It all just works with no limits.
0:30:11When that's up and it's time to pay, use that code, talk show, or go to squarespace.com slash talk show again, and you save 10% off your first purchase.
0:30:20So you can prepay for up to a year, save 10% with that code to squarespace.com slash talk show.
0:30:28So let's go back to Disney and Nike, which I think are two examples of comparable companies to Apple in a lot of ways.
0:30:36Disney in particular, right, because they've got like the Walt Disney equals Steve Jobs charismatic founder who constantly, every time he had a major success, would just have this constant drive to create something new, right?
0:30:52That Walt Disney wanted to make just animated feature shorts, and then he wanted to make feature films.
0:30:59And everybody was like, that's crazy.
0:31:01Nobody wants to watch a cartoon that's more than five minutes long.
0:31:03And they bet the whole company.
0:31:06Snow White, if it hadn't been a box office success, nobody here would hear of Disney.
0:31:12It would have been a historical artifact that went out of business in 1937 or whatever year it was.
0:31:18But it turned out Snow White was like the, at the time, like either the or one of the biggest box office hits of all time.
0:31:25When you adjust for inflation, it's still one of the highest of all time, box office wise.
0:31:30And then it's like the rest of the movie industry.
0:31:33Then they become a huge, huge feature film company.
0:31:35And then TV becomes a thing in the 50s.
0:31:38And every other studio is panicked about TV, hates TV.
0:31:42Why in the world?
0:31:44This is our enemy.
0:31:45We want people to come into the theater and see these big, full color cinemascope things on 100 foot screens.
0:31:53And stay away from the little 18 inch black and white static filled picture tube in your house.
0:32:01And Walt Disney was like, oh, no, I want to be on TV every day.
0:32:05We're going to have a Mickey Mouse show after school.
0:32:09So kids come home from school and see it.
0:32:11You know, and Walt Disney himself hosted the show every Sunday night.
0:32:15The Wonderful World at Disney or whatever the hell it was called.
0:32:18Right.
0:32:19Becomes a huge TV thing.
0:32:20Then he's like, you know what?
0:32:21I want to make theme parks.
0:32:22It's one thing after another.
0:32:24Sounds exactly like Steve Jobs.
0:32:26Right.
0:32:26It's such a great analogy.
0:32:27Disney and Apple.
0:32:29Very, very similar.
0:32:30And unfortunately, there is a similarity in how Steve Jobs and Walt Disney left the companies.
0:32:36Right.
0:32:37Yeah.
0:32:38Yeah.
0:32:39And fast forward, of course, a bit.
0:32:42And I think it was Bob Iger in his autobiography talked about how he believed that Apple and Disney would combine at some point if Jobs had remained alive.
0:32:52Which is wild to think about.
0:32:54And it's wild to think about, but it's actually like viable right now in our current world because while Disney is still sort of the foremost movie production company and studio, obviously that whole industry is under just immense amount of change right now.
0:33:11And everything sort of got kicked up.
0:33:13The dust got kicked up when Netflix, of course, zoomed in to try to buy Warner Brothers and which just showcases like the future of Hollywood.
0:33:22As much as everyone in Hollywood will hate to admit it, probably looks a lot more like Netflix and now YouTube and all of these other streaming services coming in and sort of the movie studios are just a part of that, which has been the sort of trend over the past 50 years.
0:33:38Right.
0:33:38Where these giant conglomerate companies for everyone but Disney have swooped in to buy the studios.
0:33:44And so when everyone's like freaking out about Netflix buying Warner Brothers, it's like, where have you guys been for the past 50 years?
0:33:50Like all these various random companies come in conglomerates and buy movie studios.
0:33:56And so this is sort of the norm.
0:33:57And they're freaked out because, of course, streaming is the new boogeyman or has been the new boogeyman until AI becomes the ultimate boogeyman, which is happening now.
0:34:06But again, just to go back, that's Disney and Apple like maybe is becoming more of an actual viable thing.
0:34:12Remember, Disney, I believe, is what a $200 billion or $300 billion company, relatively small compared to the tech giants.
0:34:21Apple could afford it pretty easily.
0:34:23I mean, it would be.
0:34:25And again, their biggest acquisition was Beats and that was $5 billion, I think.
0:34:30I think even less.
0:34:31I think it was like $3 billion.
0:34:32And it was over a decade ago.
0:34:35Yeah, and the world has changed so much since that time where Apple could make a $3 billion acquisition now and it would be like a big deal.
0:34:44Wouldn't be the.
0:34:45Yes, there are AI seed rounds that are that big.
0:34:47Like literally.
0:34:48I know it sounds crazy.
0:34:48Bezos is raising tens of billions of dollars for a seed round for his AI company.
0:34:52Right.
0:34:52It sounds a little crazy to say a hundred times bigger acquisition, like a $300 billion acquisition of Disney would be roughly.
0:35:00It would be a bigger deal than buying Beats.
0:35:02It would.
0:35:03Yeah.
0:35:03But it's.
0:35:04But it's not.
0:35:05But it wouldn't break Apple's bank by any by any stretch.
0:35:08I mean.
0:35:09Right.
0:35:09They could get that deal done in a heartbeat except for regulatory concerns.
0:35:13Right.
0:35:14And I think the way that they've kept the Beats brand and they still sell Beats headphones and I actually really like the Beats cases.
0:35:23I haven't written about it yet, but the Beats iPhone cases are actually better than the Apple branded cases because they don't have the bottom lip or at least you can.
0:35:31They have models without the bottom lip.
0:35:33I've tried them.
0:35:33Interesting.
0:35:34They're actually really good.
0:35:35They're my favorite.
0:35:36You know, I don't use a case.
0:35:37Most.
0:35:38I'm like the most interesting man in the world with the Modelo beer.
0:35:42He doesn't either.
0:35:43But I use one of these like moth things that protects it.
0:35:46So when it's laid down.
0:35:47But.
0:35:48But yeah, I don't use a case anymore these days.
0:35:50Let's just say when I drink, I don't always drink beer.
0:35:53But when I do drink beer, I drink Modelo.
0:35:55And it's like I don't usually wear a case.
0:35:58Oh, it's Dosa Keys.
0:35:59It's not Modelo.
0:36:00Right.
0:36:02But when I do wear a case, I like the Beats case right now.
0:36:05I really do.
0:36:06But they've kept the brand.
0:36:08And obviously, if they bought Disney, they would keep the Disney brand.
0:36:11I mean, that's a huge part.
0:36:13Sort of the value and sort of let it run as an independent company.
0:36:17But with the backing, that's how I would imagine it going.
0:36:20That I think most people wouldn't really.
0:36:23And yes, Apple isn't in the running a conglomerate business like Berkshire Hathaway.
0:36:29But they could make it.
0:36:30Buying Disney would be making an exception to that rule.
0:36:34And that's how they would do it.
0:36:35The problem would come in.
0:36:37And you have to imagine that at least at the corporate corp dev level, they've sort of thought about all these scenarios.
0:36:46Right.
0:36:46Like they have to kick tires on various things and run scenarios of what this looks like.
0:36:50The problem with Disney is I'm sure that they would love to have the movie studio.
0:36:55But much like when all the talk of, and I've written about this a number of times, like they should have bought HBO, right?
0:37:00But they didn't want, and they would have loved to have, I think, Warner Brothers and all the IP there.
0:37:04But they didn't want all the other stuff.
0:37:05They didn't want the TV networks.
0:37:07Right.
0:37:07And famously, Netflix didn't either, right, when they were doing the deal.
0:37:10And with Disney, Apple probably doesn't want the cruise ships.
0:37:14But then you argue, is that a part of the brand?
0:37:16Yeah, I think it's part of the brand.
0:37:18I think it's a logistics nightmare, but it's part of the brand.
0:37:21And they've already, they already run it, right?
0:37:24It wouldn't be like people in Cupertino would suddenly need to figure out how to run cruise ships and theme parks.
0:37:28They've already got the people.
0:37:30Need to bring in Tom Wobz again from Succession.
0:37:33Yeah, but I think that part of the similarity is that Apple knows how important the retail stores have proven to Apple since they created them, how absolutely essential they are to Apple's brand, how there's now an entire generation, entire generation of young adults who don't remember a world without the Apple store.
0:37:54That part of the Apple experience is going to your local Apple store and that if you have a problem or you want to get a new thing or you just want to see the new Neos, you want to see the people know you can just go and check them out.
0:38:05And that they're at, they pay the premium to put the Apple stores in the best parts of the city or the best malls.
0:38:14And they have incredible foot traffic, right?
0:38:17Every time I go to buy an Apple store, they are packed.
0:38:20And so that's very similar to the real world experience of, hey, you don't just pay 20 bucks a month to get Disney Plus.
0:38:31You can bring your kids to a theme park and meet Mickey Mouse.
0:38:35You can come here and get your picture taken and give them a hug.
0:38:38Like that is a thing that other companies do not have in that space.
0:38:43And they're also apparently hugely profitable, right?
0:38:47Both the parks is the major profit center right now of Disney.
0:38:51And so Apple would be sort of silly to get rid of it just from the bottom line perspective.
0:38:56And it just might break the flywheel of the whole thing.
0:39:00Yeah.
0:39:00Yeah.
0:39:00And so there is a Warren Buffett, Berkshire Hathaway, hey, separate all the other stuff.
0:39:07And it's like, is this a good business that has a bright future?
0:39:09And do they have a moat that other companies can't encroach on?
0:39:13Yeah.
0:39:14Right?
0:39:15It's just like a good investment.
0:39:16So I don't know.
0:39:17And we haven't even mentioned the fact that Disney is the company that owns Pixar, which look it up.
0:39:23Let me check my notes.
0:39:24The CEO of Pixar was a guy named Steve Jobs, right?
0:39:28Yes.
0:39:29And their new CEO is apparently more interested on the technology side.
0:39:35You know, he's the one who apparently has done a bunch of the epic stuff, which would be awkward maybe with Apple.
0:39:41But still, I think they could get over that bit.
0:39:43And then, of course, there's ESPN, which is now Apple is clearly ramping on the sports side.
0:39:49Not yet to the extent that maybe Amazon and even Netflix are going all in.
0:39:55But that's just because, per Apple's way, like they want to own the entire experience.
0:39:59They don't just want to pick off these one-off games.
0:40:01And I'm not trying to – I've not heard this.
0:40:04You and me are not trying to ignite a flame under a rumor that Disney and Apple are about to get married.
0:40:10I'm just saying it makes a lot of sense.
0:40:12And in terms of, hey, Apple definitely was sniffing around getting some NFL rights.
0:40:16Another way to do it would be to buy ESPN.
0:40:19Yeah.
0:40:20Yeah.
0:40:21All of a sudden, you are thrown head first.
0:40:23You're thrown into – you're the biggest player all of a sudden in sports.
0:40:27And yeah, there's a lot of reasons why it makes sense.
0:40:32I do think there's got to be the push on complexity of the entire thing.
0:40:38And do they really want to take that on, especially when they're undergoing a CEO change at the moment and how you would handle that?
0:40:44But if they did – you're talking about the Berkshire model.
0:40:47What if they just let Disney run as is and they're just sort of the overall holding company of it?
0:40:54Yeah.
0:40:54And that they have – but also could filter back some – you can get a bundle deal and save money on an Apple TV+.
0:41:02Apple TV+.
0:41:03What if they backed into – so obviously Google, where I worked for a long time, when I was there, they moved up to the sort of alphabet level, right?
0:41:12And sort of they made a holding company on top of Google.
0:41:15And so Apple could do the same thing in reverse where they buy a Disney and then have either Apple or something else as the holding company.
0:41:24And then Apple is one of the pillars.
0:41:25Disney is one of the pillars.
0:41:26Beats probably stays as part of Apple because it's been that way for so long.
0:41:30But you could see a world in which in a different avenue.
0:41:33They would be sort of their own thing and maybe they buy up a couple other things, maybe in gaming, maybe some else tangential, where it can be its own pillar as well.
0:41:42I don't know.
0:41:43But it is – just to circle back to Cook, there's two reasons to look at Disney for succession.
0:41:49There's what happened after Walt died and that was – the company didn't tank, but the 70s and until Eisner came back, came into the company and took the reign in the 80s, there was a sort of 15-year blah period for Disney without Walt.
0:42:05They weren't ready.
0:42:06That's not so instructive.
0:42:09That's more comparable to Tim Cook's era, the 15 years after the death of the charismatic, irreplaceable founder.
0:42:17And Apple clearly had a better 15 years after Steve Jobs died than Disney did after Walt died.
0:42:25There's no doubt.
0:42:26The better example is the Bob-to-Bob transition in 2020.
0:42:31And he picked the wrong guy.
0:42:34Bob Chapek was a goddamn idiot.
0:42:37And it does – the whole question of Iger coming back when Iger came back, it's like, well, somebody needs to come back because somebody's got to get this Chapek guy out of here.
0:42:45But the question with Iger coming back was, but you're the guy who picked Chapek.
0:42:50So, you know, that whole situation, we're obviously going to get more of it with Iger now retired and, like, what actually happened there.
0:42:59But it was very weird.
0:43:00If you remember – I remember reading his biography before he retired the first time around.
0:43:04And he sort of – it did seem like he was telegraphing the fact that he would choose Chapek because there's, like, a scene, a part of the book that I remember where there was an incident.
0:43:13I think a shooting maybe at one of the Disney parks.
0:43:16And Chapek was in charge of the parks.
0:43:19And so the way that he handled it, he, like, just touted him as great.
0:43:22And there was this whole swirl around – there was always a swirl around who would be succeeding Iger at Disney, in part because he had been having such a successful run with all the M&A he had done.
0:43:34And, obviously, after Eisner, he reinvigorated Disney to the point where it was by far the most successful studio.
0:43:40And, again, he executed those M&A transactions better maybe than anyone ever has in history.
0:43:46And then he had his number two person, like, the COO role was a rotating cast of characters who kept leaving.
0:43:53And so it was, like, are they doing that because they don't think he's leaving anytime soon?
0:43:59You know, and they're going to – to your point, earlier point about Cook, like, they must be getting poached left and right to go take a top job somewhere.
0:44:05So did he sort of, like, back into Chapek as the sort of last man standing just at the time that he wanted to go?
0:44:12And he's, well, I'm out, and here's the most obvious person to do it, and so I'm going to give it to him, and he'll be great.
0:44:19But no one thought I could do it either, which is true, right?
0:44:21No one thought that Bob Iger could sort of step into that role and take it on, and obviously he proved them otherwise.
0:44:27And so I think that, in hindsight, it's easy to say what a failure Chapek was because it was a disaster.
0:44:33But it was during COVID, and it was, like, there were a bunch of – yeah, a perfect storm in sort of – we talked about it was a perfect situation for Cook to step back right now.
0:44:42It was basically the opposite when Iger left that first go-around.
0:44:45For people – I mean, we're a Disney family.
0:44:49I mean, now our son's 22.
0:44:50He's senior in college.
0:44:52We don't go – it's been a while, a couple years now.
0:44:55But we used to go to Disney World every year and really enjoyed it.
0:44:59And the idea of the Parks guy taking over, it sounded like a great idea without knowing anything about him.
0:45:06But then the Parks guy took over the company and immediately started wrecking the Parks experience.
0:45:13That's right.
0:45:13They jacked up the prices.
0:45:15Yeah.
0:45:15And they – but it's not – everybody – that's one of those similarities between Apple and Disney.
0:45:20Everybody has always complained about the prices, and the prices are very high.
0:45:25It is very expensive to take a vacation to Disney World or Disneyland or any Disneyland anywhere in the world.
0:45:31And it's like everybody knows Apple's stuff is expensive and that they have high profit margins.
0:45:36And then you're like, so what do people complain about with Apple?
0:45:40Well, everything's expensive.
0:45:41And what do people complain about with Disney?
0:45:42Well, everything's expensive.
0:45:43But then you say, but did you have a good time?
0:45:45And they're like, I can't wait to come back.
0:45:47And it's like, do you like your iPhone?
0:45:49I can't wait to buy my next one.
0:45:50That's the thing that keeps going.
0:45:52But like with Chapek, it was like just little things.
0:45:55Like they had this system for years now called Fast Passes because I know you've been there.
0:46:00But it's like the Fast Pass system.
0:46:02It's like a way that you can get like tickets to go to a ride instead of waiting in line.
0:46:06You can pick the ones you want.
0:46:07Yeah.
0:46:07And then you just show up, you get a Fast Pass that says, come back at 11 a.m.
0:46:13And you come back at 11 a.m. and you go to the Fast Pass line.
0:46:16And then you just go, you don't go right to the front, but you only have like 20 minutes.
0:46:21And then you're on a ride.
0:46:22And you can only get so many of them.
0:46:24And it's like, oh, how do you optimize your use of Fast Passes?
0:46:27And there were all sorts of blogs and books of how to do it.
0:46:30But you could do it and you could get, the bottom line is you could get on more rides in a day than you would otherwise.
0:46:36And you're not spending your time just sitting in a queue.
0:46:39And then when JPEG took over, it was like, oh, we're going to have a new system.
0:46:43And every day while you're at the park at 7 a.m., you need to go online and sign up for your Fast Passes.
0:46:50And you can't do it the day before.
0:46:52And if you wait till like 7.
0:46:53I didn't even realize that.
0:46:54If you wait till 7.15, they're all gone.
0:46:57And it's who wants to wake up at 7 a.m. or 8 a.m., whatever.
0:47:01It was really early.
0:47:02What was the rationale behind it, though?
0:47:06I don't know.
0:47:07Who knows?
0:47:08But it was just one example of many of ruining the experience and giving people something to complain about.
0:47:14But you were the parks guy.
0:47:16It's not like somebody came in from the movie or streaming business and then started making bad decisions for the parks.
0:47:25It would be like if come next year, all of a sudden Apple's hardware gets worse.
0:47:32And it's like, well, wait, they put the hardware guy in charge and now the hardware is worse?
0:47:36What is going on here?
0:47:38Like with inexplicably bad decisions.
0:47:40Like who thought that making people while they're on vacation go on the computer?
0:47:46The whole point, like my argument when we were there doing this wasn't just that it was early in the morning and that it was stressful because hotel Wi-Fi is always an if and it's like you're in a race.
0:47:57It was like any kind of online auction for tickets or something where it's like you don't want to mess it up because they're going.
0:48:04Right.
0:48:05Don't reload.
0:48:06Don't refresh.
0:48:07You got to stay on it.
0:48:08Yeah.
0:48:09But even more than that being a bad experience, shouldn't the whole point of going on vacation anywhere be that the better the vacation, the less time you want to spend on your computer or phone, right?
0:48:20I mean, that should in today's world, that is like a good just rule of thumb for a good vacation or not.
0:48:27Yeah, I was I was so occupied, so interested.
0:48:30We had so much to do that.
0:48:32I spent way, you know, my screen time went way down.
0:48:34And if your screen time doesn't go down on vacation, it's probably not a good vacation.
0:48:38But it's like you're they're begging.
0:48:40It's just baffling.
0:48:41Right.
0:48:42It was like, who is it?
0:48:44They had to get rid of the guy.
0:48:45They really did.
0:48:46Tomorrow, the new CEO was the guy who stepped in and replaced him and apparently fixed.
0:48:50Yeah.
0:48:51Not all a lot of those issues and as well.
0:48:52Yeah.
0:48:53So I'm sure I'm sure Cook knows more about that than just about anybody and really looked at it.
0:48:59And then the other one is Nike.
0:49:01I don't know as much about that one, but I basically, though, the new after I forget the guy's name, but the new CEO of
0:49:07Nike really got them away from retail.
0:49:12It was it was John Donahoe, who was formerly the eBay CEO who came in.
0:49:18And interesting about this, I believe this is correct.
0:49:21I think Cook led the CEO search for the Nike board or at least was the main steward to bring him in and sort of mess that up, I guess.
0:49:32Again, in hindsight, you know, who knows?
0:49:34I'm sure there were many things that sort of contributed to that going sideways.
0:49:37But but yeah, it just seemed like they made the bad the wrong call, like the wrong the wrong type of guy to lead that business.
0:49:44And now they're trying to work backwards and and sort of reverse all those changes again and selling selling direct and doing all that stuff that they used to do.
0:49:52Yeah. And just sort of maybe took for granted the primacy of the position that Nike held in the sneaker world and that underestimated just how much competition was ready to rise up and how quickly Nike could go from being the coolest brand of sneaker to, hey, not so cool.
0:50:12And it was similar in that, again, I don't know that much about Nike relative to Apple like yourself, but Mark Parker was the guy before who was also sort of out of left field, but became like one of these great CEOs.
0:50:25And that's who who had this run that then Donahoe had to step in for and just, yeah, it just totally went sideways after that.
0:50:32But obviously, that's always the risk after you're succeeding someone who's had great success.
0:50:36And that is now the point that Ternus finds himself in, which is odd because, of course, everyone thought that Cook would be in that position.
0:50:45And the one other analogy or back going back to think about a CEO succession thing that's not directly related, but is obviously these companies are forever interlinked is the way that that Balmer took over for Gates.
0:50:58And in a way, like right Gates and Jobs famously were frenemies and had both massive control and mindshare over the companies that they had started and had hugely successful runs by the end of their tenures and left the keys for different reasons, obviously, in good hands.
0:51:19And Balmer, while I think, again, these things are easy to say in hindsight, I think that he did a job of sort of keeping the trains running.
0:51:39But what he really did, when you look back on it, is just sort of milked the cash cow, right?
0:51:45Like he basically just took what was there, what was built from the Gates era, and what he helped build, to his credit, right?
0:51:52Balmer was there as one of the high-up executives most of the time, famously from Harvard.
0:51:58They knew each other.
0:52:00But still, when he came in as a CEO, it seemed like he would just keep everything running as Gates had done it.
0:52:05But what he ended up doing was just like doing, again, milking the profits out of these companies.
0:52:11And so they became more profitable and kept growing the top and bottom lines.
0:52:15But the stock, interestingly, was almost like stagnant for the entire 10-year period, which was obviously just not the case with Cook, who had done it.
0:52:24You could say he did a similar thing in terms of growing the revenues off of the iPhone and growing the profits off of the iPhone.
0:52:30But the market reaction was very, very different.
0:52:33And I think there's reasons for that.
0:52:36Yeah, I do.
0:52:37I think strategically, Cook, and I do, it can be a high priority without being his top priority.
0:52:44The way I put it is Cook's top priority was always the well-being of the company itself.
0:52:51And that's not the shareholders.
0:52:53And that's not a near-term hyper-focus on stock price.
0:52:58Because you can't really control that.
0:53:00And I think any CEO, especially of a bigger company, that gets hyper-focused on that.
0:53:05And to me, that's to Balmer's credit, that he never panicked over the fact that the stock was flat.
0:53:10He used to say repeatedly, I look at two numbers, revenue and profit.
0:53:15And those are both going up, and I can't control the stock price, and the stock price will eventually reflect the success we're having with revenue and profit.
0:53:22And in some ways, I think that's admirable.
0:53:25I just think what the stock price was reflecting was, hey, this company doesn't seem to be heading towards a bright future.
0:53:32No, and I think it was –
0:53:34And Balmer was hyper-focused on milking Windows as the real Windows, which is a PC operating system that runs on personal computers.
0:53:43And then he got hyper-focused on the brand, too.
0:53:47So it was like, hey, everything that this company does is going to be running on Windows PCs.
0:53:51And anything else we do, we're going to just slap the name Windows on it.
0:53:55We got Windows Mobile.
0:53:57And we got – yeah, yeah.
0:53:58And it became like, yeah, this sort of like piecemeal, weird products.
0:54:05And then they had all these like offshoots.
0:54:06And then strategically, remember, of course, he had two deals, one of which didn't happen, which was trying to buy Yahoo, which he almost bought for $40 billion.
0:54:16But Jerry Yang came back and blocked it from happening, which is incredible like in hindsight because if that deal gets done, what does Microsoft look like?
0:54:25That may have sunk Microsoft.
0:54:27I know.
0:54:27It took a lot of money for a product.
0:54:30And back then, that was a lot of money.
0:54:32That would have been one of the biggest deals of all time.
0:54:34I mean, it still would have been, but it would have been maybe an AOL-sized deal.
0:54:39Yeah.
0:54:39And type situation.
0:54:41And again, Yahoo blocked it and is now a fraction of themselves, of course.
0:54:46And then, of course, as he's sort of nearing the end of his run, he buys Nokia for a massive amount of money.
0:54:53And it's just a total wrong decision.
0:54:56I think ultimately, that's what did him.
0:54:58Yeah.
0:54:58Right.
0:54:59And then, again, I don't want to get sidetracked talking about Microsoft, but Satya Nadella, much more Tim Cookian, but really did clean that up and really did come in and just rip the Band-Aid off right away when he took over and said this whole, all we're going to do is Windows.
0:55:13We're going to put Windows everywhere.
0:55:15Forget about that.
0:55:16Windows is an important part of Microsoft's future, but we want our software everywhere, including platforms that are not Windows.
0:55:24And it has turned into a very successful strategy in terms of Balmer's revenue and profit, but also in terms of investors looking at the company and saying, oh, that's pretty smart.
0:55:37And I see how that strategy has a future ahead of it.
0:55:40That feels growthy for the future.
0:55:44Right.
0:55:44And therefore, it was very good for the stock, too.
0:55:48And famously, when one of Nadella's first moves, and this is sort of an interesting one to look back upon, but it was basically that he announced as one of his very first things, I think it was in the audience when he did this, was announcing the iPad version of Office.
0:56:03And, of course, now people say, again, after the fact that, well, Balmer obviously had that in the works under his leadership.
0:56:09But still, it was a watershed moment, and just the announcement of it was the big deal, right?
0:56:15Even more so than the work on it.
0:56:16I would compare it to when Steve Jobs had the Macworld Expo in New York, I think, in summer of 97 with Gates on the screen saying, we've worked out a long-term deal to make Internet Explorer the main browser on a Mac.
0:56:30And people started booing, and we've got a deal with them that they're going to continue developing Office for years to come or five years or something, which was the linchpin of the deal.
0:56:40And they're making a symbolic investment in the company.
0:56:45But you're right.
0:56:46These are watershed moments that matter more for the symbolic nature of them.
0:56:51They're showcasing to the world, to the employee base, to the world that, like, to use the jobs, like, for Apple to win, Microsoft doesn't have to lose.
0:56:59And it's basically showing that we're changing the mentality around what has sort of gotten us into these bad places that we're in.
0:57:07All right, let me take a break here and thank another sponsor, and this one I am so excited to tell you about.
0:57:13It hits home for me in a very personal way, which I will tell you about in just a moment.
0:57:18It's Drafts, D-R-A-F-T-S.
0:57:22Go to getdrafts.com slash the talk show.
0:57:25Drafts is the Swiss Army knife for text on all your Apple devices.
0:57:30Really, the name Draft, that's where it starts.
0:57:33The idea is it is always ready for quick input of new text, especially on your phone.
0:57:38So never lose a thought.
0:57:40It's optimized for low friction capture on all of your Apple devices.
0:57:44Again, iPhone, Apple Watch, Mac, iPad.
0:57:46Just launch drafts and start typing or dictating if that's, you know, you're on your watch or something like that.
0:57:52And boom, you've got a new draft with whatever you just dictated.
0:57:56Close it, go away, and you know it's safe and secure.
0:57:58And it has fast, reliable sync, all using iCloud.
0:58:02Super private because it's iCloud.
0:58:04Super reliable because developer Greg Pierce at Drafts has really, really worked on the sync engine for this over the years.
0:58:11So you dictate something into your watch and then you sit down at your Mac, your draft is going to be there.
0:58:17It is really one of the best sync systems I've ever used.
0:58:20I rely on it all the time.
0:58:22It is a great scratch pad for editing text.
0:58:25It's got a highly customized editor, great markdown syntax support.
0:58:29That is one of the reasons I use it and one of the reasons it's very personally appealing to me.
0:58:33It's got a huge library.
0:58:35Drafts has a huge library of actions.
0:58:37These are custom features for ways to manipulate text or to integrate with third-party APIs or other systems like Dropbox and Google Drive or Notion, Todoist.
0:58:48You name it, there is probably an action for it.
0:58:51I cannot list them all.
0:58:52I'd be here for 10 minutes, but you can also, if you're a nerd and you want to use JavaScript and stuff like that, you can make your own actions to customize.
0:59:00And of course, I've done that for certain things to just a format, my markdown, just the way I like it, stuff like that.
0:59:06Custom actions, built-in actions that are in the app, actions that other developers have made and shared on the web in the great community of draft users that you can download and use yourself.
0:59:18One of the newest features, it's got great integration with ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, and other popular AI platforms.
0:59:25And they even now offer an MCP server for integration with Claude to query your draft library.
0:59:33And if you install that, you get a command line draft tool on macOS.
0:59:37So you can create, edit, add, delete items from your drafts library right from the command line in Terminal.
0:59:43It is always free to use.
0:59:45Drafts is a free download.
0:59:46You can use it for free and in perpetuity.
0:59:49Try it out, and you will fall in love with drafts like I did and rely on it.
0:59:54And when you do, you're probably going to want Drafts Pro.
0:59:57Drafts Pro unlocks great features like themes, workspaces, custom actions, and more.
1:00:03Right now, listeners of the talk show can get their first year of Drafts Pro for just $9.99.
1:00:09$10.
1:00:1050% off the usual price.
1:00:13And the usual price is such a bargain.
1:00:14Such a bargain for Drafts Pro.
1:00:16A longstanding, terrific, first-class app for all Apple platforms.
1:00:21I love Drafts.
1:00:23You will probably love it, too.
1:00:24Go check it out at getdrafts.com slash thetalkshow.
1:00:30Go check them out, 50% off for a whole year.
1:00:32Getdrafts.com slash thetalkshow.
1:00:35I cannot believe I'm getting paid to talk about Drafts.
1:00:38It's so fun.
1:00:39Let's go back to Cook and the timing.
1:00:42So anyway, I said before we digressed there and talked about those other companies.
1:00:46But I do think Cook was looking at them.
1:00:48And the bottom line is, if he's going to transition, I don't see how he could do this better.
1:00:52He's going out on top.
1:00:53He's 65.
1:00:54He's got a 50-year-old, 51-year-old replacement.
1:00:56The hardware business is great.
1:00:58The services business is great and growing.
1:01:01And that's one of Cook's, certainly Cook's financial legacy.
1:01:05What else is Cook's legacy from the last 15 years?
1:01:08The two hardware products, obviously, are the Apple Watch and AirPods.
1:01:14And the Vision Pro, though, in a negative sense, right?
1:01:19And the car in a $10 billion.
1:01:25I would say the car, and I don't think Apple ever really disclosed exactly $10 billion.
1:01:36But it sounds about right.
1:01:38Truthy.
1:01:39It must have been.
1:01:40Yeah.
1:01:40They made acquisitions.
1:01:42They did things here.
1:01:43And they spent a lot of time.
1:01:44It was just a lot of time, a lot of resources.
1:01:47And, you know, I think that they got some things out of it, I'm sure, that learnings and technologies out of it that they've been able to leverage.
1:01:56But still, for the most part, it was a side quest to use OpenAI's new parlance for these things.
1:02:03But you see why they did it, right?
1:02:04Like, what's a business that can actually move the needle, potentially, for a company the size of Apple, which already has potentially one of the biggest, if not the best, businesses of all time in the iPhone?
1:02:14Cars.
1:02:15You can do cars.
1:02:16You can do banking.
1:02:17You can do oil.
1:02:18There's only a few things you can do that would actually potentially move the needle for Apple.
1:02:22And so they tried the car route.
1:02:24And I think that that was the most obvious and probably least painful banking would be a regulatory nightmare as Apple's seen, to some extent, with their partnerships and whatnot.
1:02:33And so it's hard to fault them for doing it.
1:02:36I just didn't work out.
1:02:37If the car didn't exist, if they never even dabbled in it, you could make the argument that – and I'm not trying to carry water for Tim Cook here – but you could make the argument that if they didn't have any, hey, we tried this and it didn't work out, then you could make the argument that they weren't trying hard enough.
1:02:57If you're trying – if you're trying – the optimal amount of trying isn't every single thing you try is a success.
1:03:03It's that most of what you try is a success and then you get a little bit out over your skis once in a while and it's, okay, there's where we tried too hard.
1:03:13But that means we're trying as hard as we can.
1:03:16And Bezos is famous for sort of framing it right with Amazon when he was running Amazon.
1:03:22And Fire Phone is the preeminent example of that.
1:03:24Yeah.
1:03:24But yes, and I think Cook – I think there's – you could say a lot of criticisms of Cook in different degrees, but I do think one thing that he could have sort of done better from a communications perspective is just sort of, yeah, like owning things like that.
1:03:38And he's starting to do that a little bit.
1:03:39I didn't actually – I haven't gone back and revisited it since I've written these pieces now and I'm looking back at these pieces.
1:03:45But I know that one thing he apparently said in the town hall he talked about, the Apple Maps fiasco, right?
1:03:50And so he's at least somewhat going back now and looking at things in the rear view.
1:03:55Yeah, that was – I guess Gurman reported that after the big announcement they held a thing in Steve Jobs Theater, which I always wonder.
1:04:04I've talked to some people at Apple and I guess they simulcast it for the whole company.
1:04:09But you've been there.
1:04:10The Steve Jobs Theater only holds, I think, like 500 people?
1:04:15Yeah, but that's like at Google too.
1:04:19They have like the – they basically, yeah, stream it into then all of the other sort of –
1:04:23So everybody gets to watch it, but I always wonder how they adjudicate the tickets to actually be in the room because it's sort of like –
1:04:32I don't know, maybe it's 1,000 people in a fitness Steve Jobs Theater.
1:04:35I forget.
1:04:35It's not that many.
1:04:36It's a beautiful theater.
1:04:38I think it's like – it might be first come, first serve.
1:04:41Like people like line up just like they would for an event.
1:04:45Well, but some number of people get guaranteed seats.
1:04:47Of course.
1:04:48Right.
1:04:49Eddie Q does not just show up late and it's, no, back to the – go back to your office, Eddie.
1:04:55Your seats are full.
1:04:57Yeah, go watch it on your computer.
1:04:59Sorry.
1:04:59Yeah.
1:05:01The maps thing.
1:05:02It's interesting that he brought it up.
1:05:04It is – he's reflective.
1:05:05It's more complicated though.
1:05:08Like the maps – and it's fine.
1:05:10It all worked out.
1:05:11And again, that's one of those things he doesn't get credit for.
1:05:15People don't give credit for things that just work as expected.
1:05:20And first impressions do matter and there's a lot of people who haven't really looked at Apple Maps in a while and have no idea how good it is.
1:05:31A, how good it looks and B, that the directions are often better than Google's.
1:05:35They're certainly on par.
1:05:37It does depend where you live.
1:05:39It's a U.S.-focused product and there are people in other countries around the world where Google Maps directions are good and Apple Maps are crap.
1:05:48I know that every time I bring it up.
1:05:49But maps turned into a very good product.
1:05:51It is very good now.
1:05:53And there's no moment in time where anybody was like, hey, you know, in 2017 there was this big celebration and all these articles about how Apple Maps is now good.
1:06:04Nope.
1:06:04But everybody just remembers that when it launched, it was horrible.
1:06:07But they kind of had to.
1:06:10Yeah, there's strategic reasons, right?
1:06:12Yeah.
1:06:12Google had them over a barrel where Google, the Google Maps that they had the rights to in iOS was, people don't even talk about this anymore, but they were bitmapped map tiles.
1:06:27So they're like bitmapped images that when you zoom in were pixelated until new map tiles were downloaded.
1:06:34It's like a bitmapped image versus a vector image.
1:06:37And vector map tiles where they just scale like a PDF file when you zoom in, they didn't have those.
1:06:44But the bigger one is they didn't have turn-by-turn directions.
1:06:47Like I know people are like, what?
1:06:49Well, then what did you use maps for?
1:06:51And it's like, I don't know.
1:06:52People would just look it up to like look at directions.
1:06:55But there weren't turn-by-turn directions.
1:06:58And I think maybe you could get like a list of directions, but they weren't updated live.
1:07:01But that was like a thing.
1:07:03But Google had turn-by-turn directions and Android had it because Google had it.
1:07:07And they were offering it to Apple, but they were offering it to Apple with a deal that meant that they would get the location data of the people using it.
1:07:15And that day would be a sign in.
1:07:16It would be optional.
1:07:18You could use Apple Maps with the advanced Google features without signing in, but Google would still get the data, and they could fingerprint to figure out who you are.
1:07:27And guess what?
1:07:28We now know that these companies are really good.
1:07:30They kind of don't need you to sign in.
1:07:32They know who you are.
1:07:33And there would be a sign in so they could know for sure that it's me, John Gruber, who's getting directions to wherever I may not want them to know that I'm going to.
1:07:44That was it.
1:07:45It was like you can keep – they had the choice between keeping the old busted bitmap maps from Google without turn-by-turn directions, or they could switch to the new stuff from Google but accede to Google's demands for what Apple determined was privacy-invasive information, which made that a no-go.
1:08:10I talk to people at Apple who are very high up in that decision-making.
1:08:15That was something they never really considered because it was – and they could not negotiate Google off of those privacy – you know, it was like on a privacy basis, it was like we can't really go this way.
1:08:27Or flip the switch and go with Apple Maps, our in-house product, which we know isn't really ready to go.
1:08:33Which one do we do?
1:08:34And they're like, I guess the best of all these shitty choices is to just flip the switch and go with Apple Maps.
1:08:39And maybe they should have waited another year, but it wouldn't have been a year where they had turn-by-turn directions from Google.
1:08:45It would have been another year with the old Apple Maps from Google.
1:08:48And it would have been a year that they weren't getting data in to make the Maps product better.
1:08:51Right.
1:08:51Yeah, how much better – right.
1:08:53How much better was Maps going to get in a year without – that was the thing.
1:08:56I just wrote about this when I reflected briefly on going full-time at Daring Fireball 20 years ago where my decision matrix was – there were a couple of years where I started having ads and started selling T-shirts.
1:09:07And I was making some money, but it was nowhere near enough to support my family.
1:09:10But I kind of had this notion that I'm never going to make enough money doing this until I'm spending full-time doing it.
1:09:17And I kind of have to go full-time doing it before the ads and the memberships and the T-shirts are going to make enough to support it.
1:09:25And I don't know if I had to do it, but that turned out to be the truth where once I started doing it full-time, even though the revenue wasn't enough to support my family and we were chewing through our savings, that's when the revenue started picking up.
1:09:38And I think they kind of had to go to Apple Maps before it was ready to make Apple Maps better.
1:09:42So it's more complex than that, but it makes for a neater, nicer, hey, what do you regret in your time?
1:09:47Oh, Apple Maps.
1:09:48It was a bad launch.
1:09:49Right.
1:09:50It was a fiasco.
1:09:51But it also is interesting in the context of today in that they're cutting the deals with Google again for AI.
1:09:58And what does that look like five years down the road?
1:10:00Right now, they obviously have a deal that they're happy with.
1:10:03But what if Google says we need X, Y, Z, more information?
1:10:08And presumably because of the Maps situation, they've really locked in these contracts to know what's good and what's not.
1:10:16But at the end of the day, there's always going to be something that they're going to be beholden to the other company on.
1:10:21So that's a really interesting point.
1:10:23I'm glad you brought that up.
1:10:24I think that they're thinking, and I keep going back to that white paper that I think it leaked from Google.
1:10:31I don't think they released it, but I don't know that they, you know, once a white paper is written, it's kind of hard to keep it from leaking.
1:10:37But it was the argument from within Google, from their AI team, that OpenAI has no moat and we don't either.
1:10:45That there is no moat with these LLMs.
1:10:48So that there's enough competition and always will be that if Google were to turn the screws on Apple and say, okay, you like Gemini and you like building Apple intelligence on a Gemini base layer, we want stuff, privacy invasive stuff that you don't want to give.
1:11:07Or we want financial terms that are no longer a deal you want to make, right?
1:11:12Pull the Darth Vader.
1:11:13Pray I don't alter the terms anymore.
1:11:16I don't think, I think Apple's looking at this situation and saying, I don't think they can ever do that because there's enough competition and we can just go somewhere else.
1:11:25And we're seeing that at least right now.
1:11:28We see it right now.
1:11:29It's a bet though, right?
1:11:30I mean, it could go the other way.
1:11:32I don't think, I don't think it necessarily goes fully the other way where it gets like, yeah, it's just one provider rules them all.
1:11:42But I think that there is a world in which it's problematic not to own the underlying models that you're using for these things.
1:11:51It probably is.
1:11:52But I think that, I don't think that going with Gemini now slows Apple down to get their own models.
1:11:59And I think, I think it's pretty clear with, and they can't spell this out, but I kind of think the whole reason Google is going along with this, like why is Google going along with this?
1:12:12And letting Apple use Gemini and to, to sort of save the day, right?
1:12:18Because Apple's models clearly aren't ready.
1:12:20If they were ready, Apple would use their own models, right?
1:12:23It's, oh, it's, it's almost a statement of fact that Apple's in-house models are not up to snuff by today's frontier standards.
1:12:32So why is Google doing this?
1:12:34Why doesn't Google screw them over?
1:12:36Doesn't Google have an interest in Android and aren't they letting their number one competitor catch up in a way?
1:12:41And it's, Google doesn't look at Android the way Microsoft looked at Windows back in the day.
1:12:46Android's just sort of there for them.
1:12:48They care about it.
1:12:49And they, the, the, the pixel team gets to run ads to, to try to get people to switch from iPhone and stuff.
1:12:55And they, if more people want to use Android, Google, cool for Google, but it's not central to them.
1:13:01It just isn't.
1:13:02And I think what Google sees in this clearly is, is kneecapping open AI, right?
1:13:09And to some extent, Anthropic, like if, if Apple is going to go to somebody to fill in the underlying base model for Apple intelligence, let it be Gemini rather than these other guys.
1:13:22Yeah.
1:13:23The risk is sort of the inverse of that.
1:13:25If they don't do the deal and they already did a deal, obviously with open AI last go around and, or they wanted to do a deal.
1:13:33So it sounds like with Anthropic per the reporting, but they couldn't come to terms on it, right?
1:13:37If they do one of those all of a sudden, and they're the underlying model that's powering Siri or the next generation of Siri, all of a sudden, whatever that model is goes overnight, overnight from say hundreds of millions of users to billions of users potentially.
1:13:53And those are billions of users that are not now using Gemini.
1:13:57And so regardless of, of what the, the business terms are around it, I do think that there's, that there's truth in that Google looks at it as look, we have, we all of a sudden will get our models in the hands, the literal hands of, of billions of, of users and the most passionate and the most powerful sort of users of smartphones on the planet.
1:14:19And so why would you not do that deal unless sort of the inverse of what we were talking about?
1:14:25Like then you become too beholden on, on the iPhone for sort of either your usage.
1:14:31And if that goes away and, and all of a sudden you have to disclose that the, the Apple deal is ending one quarter and the stock tanks, because all of a sudden you don't have the iPhone user base anymore propping up sort of Gemini.
1:14:45So I kind of feel like they don't really, you know, that it's more of a, even though Apple doesn't have a good model and Google does, and that makes it seem like Google's in the position of negotiating strength and Apple's not.
1:14:55I think they're much more equals.
1:14:58Certainly it's not like maps and go back to that competition factor.
1:15:02There was nobody else Apple could go to at that time that there was big maps, right?
1:15:07I think Bing had, had, had a maps product, but I don't know if it, and there was Yahoo maps, of course.
1:15:12Yeah. But I don't think that they've, they didn't solve the problems that Apple needed solve with the vector tiles and the turn by turn and stuff.
1:15:19And it probably would have been a harder sell narratively than doing their own thing by just saying, look, we know this isn't the best.
1:15:24Obviously they wouldn't frame it that way, but Apple famously, of course, like wants to give their user base the best product, which is why they've long touted that they go with Google search,
1:15:33even though Bing or someone else might give them better terms because it's the overall best product.
1:15:38And so if they were to sort of swap out Google maps for Bing maps, would they really, with a straight face, say to their user base, hey, sorry, but you know, you got to use this thing now.
1:15:48It's not as good, but you know, we got better terms or whatever.
1:15:50Yeah. And that competition factor, I think that does play into the stability of Apple senior leadership is unlike Disney, where there are other entertainment companies.
1:16:05And especially if you're, and they're kind of are other theme park companies, you can go to universal.
1:16:10There's not too much, there's not as much competition, certainly in theme parks, Disney theme park business is just way ahead.
1:16:17There's competition in cruise ships, but not for like families, not the same thing.
1:16:23Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
1:16:24Disney has a niche in the cruise ship industry that it's hard to imagine anybody else even coming close to.
1:16:33One of the things that makes Apple different is there is no company really like Apple.
1:16:38Let's just pick an executive.
1:16:39Where else is Craig Federighi going to go?
1:16:41Right?
1:16:42Yeah.
1:16:43Is he going to go to Google?
1:16:45Really?
1:16:45Why?
1:16:46Why?
1:16:46Why would he do that?
1:16:47If Google ramped up, if they did the opposite of what you were just talking about and really wanted to ramp up Pixel as the flagship product and they were going to do exclusive Gemini access and all that sort of stuff, maybe you could see it.
1:17:00Or Samsung, same general idea, but it's not going to be as good of a position.
1:17:07There are other phones.
1:17:09Samsung is obviously the competition for the iPhone and the iPhone is the biggest business.
1:17:14The smartphone is the greatest consumer product of all time.
1:17:16I just blogged the other day about a rumor that Samsung is themselves warning investors about that their mobile business might actually register a loss for the first time this year because of the RAM crisis.
1:17:29But it really does seem to still be true from 15 years ago that Apple takes like 80-ish percent of all the profits in the phone business and Samsung takes the other 15 to 20 percent.
1:17:44And everybody else at best has like 1% or 2% profit share of the industry, like the Huawei's and Xiaomi's and that's it.
1:17:52And then everybody else is just sort of breaking even and selling phones for break even.
1:17:57And that's why the phones get loaded up with crapware because the deals that they get for the preloaded crapware software on the phone is the only money they make.
1:18:06That's it.
1:18:07And that they can sell these things at cost basically to the carriers around the world as the freebie phones to give away for discount.
1:18:15Why would anybody even make other phones?
1:18:18It's because there's some kind of demand for people who don't care about their phone, who just want a phone that they get with their $50 a month plan.
1:18:27That's it.
1:18:28But the profits, there just aren't.
1:18:30It's hard to imagine that.
1:18:32Was John Ternus ever going to leave for Samsung?
1:18:35Was John Ternus going to leave to go to HP to fix their hardware business?
1:18:40So this is interesting.
1:18:44I think he would laugh.
1:18:44I honestly think if somebody from like the HP board got Ternus' ear two years ago and said,
1:18:50Hey, what if you came in and we'll make you the CEO of HP?
1:18:53We got to turn this around.
1:18:54I think he would be like...
1:18:55Well, that just reminds me of John Rubenstein going to be CEO of Palm.
1:18:59All right.
1:19:00But so all of this sort of points directly to what happens to everyone that has been at Apple for decades, including Ternus.
1:19:10But now that Ternus is in charge, obviously, when there's CEO transitions, always there's shuffles at the top.
1:19:15There've already been shuffles that have been happening at the top of Apple.
1:19:18But a lot of that is just natural because they're getting up there in retirement age.
1:19:21Yeah.
1:19:22Jeff Williams is 63 or 64 or something.
1:19:24Exactly.
1:19:24And so now that the transition is happening, who sticks around, who doesn't, and what does sort of that look like?
1:19:33It does seem, again, I don't...
1:19:36Reading between the lines of what's sort of out there a week into this now, it feels like there is certainly no animosity amongst the main people at the top of Apple.
1:19:49Like, Eddie Cuse talking up Ternus as the right pick.
1:19:52And I haven't seen anything from Phil Schiller, but presumably, like, he's up there in age enough that he knows, like, this is probably the right pick.
1:19:58I cannot say for sure, but I strongly suspect that Phil Schiller is very supportive of this pick.
1:20:06You would have to imagine that they basically all are, like, they've all been working together so long that if there was major break in that room, like, either someone left already because they didn't like that decision the way it was headed, or they're signed off on it.
1:20:22And they just know that Craig Federighi is an interesting one to me because he's around the same age.
1:20:28I think he's a little bit older than Ternus, and so just from that light, he's the other name that could have been.
1:20:34I mean, Sabi Khan, I think, is in that boat, too.
1:20:37But he's the COO now.
1:20:40He's the COO.
1:20:41And he, I think, I don't know if there's been actual reporting on it, but I think, like, he became sort of the Cook version of if Cook got hit by a bus, like, he could slot in there after Jeff Williams sort of stepped away?
1:20:55I don't think so.
1:20:56Here's what I, because if you look at the timing of all this, I think Williams was definitely that guy for the last, most of the last 15 years.
1:21:05Then I think Cook figured out Ternus is the guy.
1:21:09And I think he sort of had this suspicion.
1:21:12And it's around the times that Williams was announced.
1:21:14Yeah.
1:21:15And I think everybody, I think everybody, I don't think this is all that, I don't know.
1:21:20You'll never know because I think it's a very small group of people and they're very private.
1:21:24I don't think there's any contention about this.
1:21:26We'll have to come back to Johnny Surugi, which is the only asterisk.
1:21:29Ooh, maybe.
1:21:30But I think Cook figured out Ternus is probably the guy.
1:21:34But maybe not definitely.
1:21:35But let's see.
1:21:37Let's give him more FaceTime on the keynotes.
1:21:40Let's put more on his plate.
1:21:42Let me take him under his wing and pick his brain and see how he deals with these other.
1:21:47And I think that's one of the things.
1:21:50I've heard this for a while and a few things have come out in the last week.
1:21:55And it's just that it is – I think it's still on Monday mornings.
1:22:01I don't know.
1:22:02If it's not, nobody's reported it.
1:22:05But Jobs always ran a Monday morning executive meeting at 9 a.m.
1:22:09every Monday.
1:22:10It's several hours, right?
1:22:11Yeah.
1:22:12It probably runs through lunch.
1:22:14But it is every Monday at 9 a.m.
1:22:16The people on the Apple senior leadership team are all in a room together.
1:22:20And they go over everything the company is doing.
1:22:23And what happened the last week?
1:22:26What do we expect this next week?
1:22:27What's on the agenda?
1:22:28Okay.
1:22:29See you next Monday.
1:22:30But it is three or four hours every Monday morning.
1:22:33And I have heard, and I think it's true, that Ternus does very well in that room.
1:22:40And there are strong – there are.
1:22:42They are very strong personalities.
1:22:44Yeah.
1:22:45People have been there for 40 years.
1:22:46Yeah.
1:22:47The two guys –
1:22:47Eddie Cue and – yeah.
1:22:49In order of time I've spent with them, both on stage and public and behind the scenes, off the record, I've spent the most time with the product marketing people because they're the people whose job it is to deal with idiots like me.
1:23:04Phil and Jaws, by far, I've spent the most time with.
1:23:08Craig, second, probably just because – and that's almost all entirely on stage and backstage.
1:23:15But Craig is irascible.
1:23:18His real personality isn't totally different from his onstage personality, but he likes to argue.
1:23:25His default style of debate is to argue very strongly.
1:23:32He is a – and he is extremely smart, extremely fast.
1:23:36It is easy to get cowed over by him.
1:23:40Trust me.
1:23:40Just on any little thing.
1:23:42He is a very strong personality.
1:23:44Jaws and Phil, they are very –
1:23:47very, very personable people, but they are –
1:23:51they can –
1:23:52they are really hard to argue with.
1:23:54They are really, really hard to argue with.
1:23:56And they have very strong opinions.
1:23:58I think Ternus does very well managing all of that.
1:24:01And I think that's the –
1:24:03that's the thing Cook sees.
1:24:05That's interesting.
1:24:06That's interesting.
1:24:06And that – when you talk about it that way, that sort of reminds me of Sundar Pichai, right?
1:24:10Like, he is that – he, I think, was that person within Google, which had a lot of big personalities when it came time to who would sort of come in to be the next CEO of the company, post-Erik Schmidt and then Larry Page sort of coming in.
1:24:26And yeah, that's an interesting – I hadn't thought about it in sort of that –
1:24:30Yeah.
1:24:30And I think Cook knows how important it is to the job.
1:24:34And there's two key moments in his CEO-ship.
1:24:37There's the Forstall situation from very early where he just made the decision.
1:24:43And again, to go back to maps, Forstall's ouster had almost nothing to do with maps.
1:24:49It might have been the straw that broke the camel's back that there was some kind of, hey, Scott, you should put your name on this apology for maps.
1:24:56And he was like, that's not my problem or whatever happened there.
1:24:59That is not why he got fired or oustered, whatever you want to describe it.
1:25:04It was because he did not get along with the other executives, particularly Johnny Ive, but I think others as well.
1:25:12And I can report this from sources familiar with the matter, and other people have reported it from sources familiar with the matter, to put it in that parlance, that it had gotten to the point where Johnny Ive refused to be in a meeting with Scott Forstall or vice versa, that there were no meetings with the two of them together.
1:25:31And that's a problem.
1:25:32I mean, it just was a problem.
1:25:36I don't know that either one of them, especially Johnny, I don't think Johnny Ive went, I don't think, went to Cook and said it's either him or me, but I think Cook looked at the dynamic and realized.
1:25:47Yeah, Cook read the room, literally, and knew.
1:25:49That was the early test for him, that he had to snuff this out quick.
1:25:54Right, and I think that Cook could see, he's so, he doesn't talk about such things, but I think he is very perceptive.
1:26:03And I think he could see that Steve Jobs had an ineffable magic.
1:26:09Part of what made Steve Jobs the singular personality and leader that he was, that that reality distortion field worked all the way up to the senior vice presidents of the company.
1:26:22And that Steve Jobs could keep two people who could not work together otherwise working together because of him, Steve Jobs.
1:26:31And that Cook could see, ah, Steve had something I don't have, and I can see it, and I can understand it, but understanding it doesn't give me the ability to do it too.
1:26:40And so-
1:26:41That's interesting.
1:26:41What I can do, Tim Cook, is I can just make the hard decision and back a truckload of money to Scott Forstall's house and make a decision and move onward.
1:26:52And I forget the exact headline of the press announcement, but it was like, if you go to the Apple newsroom, it was like, in the headline, it was like, in a move to further communication within the company and coordination within the company, Apple announces senior leadership changes.
1:27:08I think there's that one.
1:27:38Again, it wasn't a big deal, ultimately.
1:27:40It is just a curiosity, but it's fine.
1:27:42Make the $20,000 solid gold Apple Watch.
1:27:45Fine.
1:27:45That versus, yeah.
1:27:48Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
1:27:49And it's like, if that makes you happy, we'll do it.
1:27:51Fine.
1:27:51But clearly, that wasn't really the right thing to do.
1:27:54And it kind of put like a weird, it's like putting a 2,000-pound thing in the trunk of a car.
1:28:02The car's not going to drive.
1:28:03Like, the launch of Apple Watch was weighted a little wrong because there was these $20,000 ones at the high end that nobody was going to buy and almost nobody ever even saw in the real world.
1:28:14I think the answer to that riddle was, and we see this now, now that it's played out and it's a successful product, but they didn't know exactly what it would be used for.
1:28:23And Johnny Ives' bet was that it would be a fashion accessory.
1:28:26And he obviously was biased.
1:28:28He's into that.
1:28:29He wanted it to be that.
1:28:30And it is kind of, right?
1:28:32It is kind of, but it's much more health, you know, obviously now.
1:28:36But, yeah, but still, does that make it make sense to do it for $20,000?
1:28:40Probably not.
1:28:42But I do see, like, what he thought that maybe it would be, yeah, this thing.
1:28:48Because look at what he's doing now.
1:28:49He does stuff that's, like, you know, akin to that now.
1:28:51And so I think he was just doing what he thought was the right thing.
1:28:56I want to be clear.
1:28:57Nobody has ever told me this.
1:28:58I do hear things.
1:28:59I've even alluded to some of the things I've heard over the years on the show.
1:29:03I've never heard anything about this.
1:29:05But I would bet money, I would bet money that John Ternus, I forget where he was when the one-port MacBook came out.
1:29:13I'll bet, but he was obviously, he wasn't a senior vice president of hardware, but he might have been, like, second to Dan Ricci at the time.
1:29:20I'll bet John Ternus was opposed to putting out a MacBook with one USB-C port.
1:29:26I do.
1:29:27And I think John Yive.
1:29:28And there has been subsequent reporting about the things that he, and who knows, you know, like, obviously a lot is coming out of the woodwork.
1:29:35That he was opposed to other, I think maybe, was it even the Vision Pro, at least sort of?
1:29:40Supposedly.
1:29:41That's, I think, might be down to Gurman, but that he was sort of skeptical.
1:29:45And Craig Federighi.
1:29:46And maybe the car project.
1:29:47Supposedly was, too.
1:29:48That Federighi and Ternus were like, I don't know if this product's ready to ship.
1:29:52You know, it just doesn't seem ready.
1:29:55I don't know.
1:29:55And who knows?
1:29:56Maybe people are trying to tee him up so that he has good taste or whatever.
1:29:59Yeah, and to keep the stink off him.
1:30:01Yeah.
1:30:02But yes, but the Ive and Cook angle, though, was a little bit unique and weird, too, right?
1:30:08Because Ive famously was so close to Jobs that it felt like any way that he would work with the new CEO, and they made it work for years and years, but it was never going to be the same dynamic, of course.
1:30:19And so it was always sort of set up to probably not be as successful as it was with Jobs in that role.
1:30:27Yeah, I just think that Cook can see that I don't think he has regrets over it, and I don't think he has regrets over parting ways with Forstall.
1:30:35I think it worked out very well for the company.
1:30:37I think there's a fascinating, oh, my God, what if it had worked out some other way?
1:30:42What if Johnny Ive had just said, look, and they backed the proverbial truckload of money to Johnny Ive's house and said, we'll do whatever it takes to keep you here, and we'll give you a title, chief design officer, whatever you want.
1:30:54And Johnny Ive was like, nope, I really wanted design chairs and Ferraris, and I don't want to be here without Steve.
1:31:01I'm going to leave in 2012 or 2013, and I wish you well.
1:31:05I think my disciples, the people I'm leaving behind, I'm leaving the design lab in great hands, but my heart's too broken without Steve.
1:31:13I'm going to leave, and Scott Forstall stayed.
1:31:15I think it's an interesting counterfactual, and I think the world would be very different.
1:31:20Apple would be very different, but I don't think Cook has – because that didn't happen.
1:31:24I don't think Cook has regrets over it, but I think Cook sees how important that job is at Apple to managing extremely talented senior leaders under the CEO who have extremely big egos and strong opinions and to keep them aligned.
1:31:40How do you coach the team full of all-stars?
1:31:44Yes, yeah, yeah, yeah.
1:31:46You've got to be Phil Jackson, basically, who can sort of handle the Zen-like philosophy of coaching Shaq and Kobe and bringing Carl Malone and Dalton.
1:31:55Or Scotty Pippen and Michael Jordan.
1:31:57And how do you get Dennis Rodman to be a team player?
1:32:00That's a huge part of the Bulls story.
1:32:02Everybody remembers the – I mean, the Bulls – that documentary series is fantastic.
1:32:07I should put it in the show notes, but it is fantastic.
1:32:10But you have to remember, Dennis Rodman is like a one and a – the only basketball player who's ever played basketball like Dennis Rodman is Dennis Rodman.
1:32:18Incredible.
1:32:19I mean, he used to get like 25 rebounds a game sometimes.
1:32:22I mean, nobody's ever rebounded like him.
1:32:24And he was a nut.
1:32:25He was a complete nut.
1:32:27Yep, would fly to Vegas for his famous party thing and then come back.
1:32:31Yeah, and they slotted him into a very rigid system at the Bulls.
1:32:36And it worked.
1:32:37That sort of – Cook sees that.
1:32:39Phil Jackson is probably somebody Tim Cook looks at and says, yeah, that guy had a job a lot like mine.
1:32:44And then went elsewhere and went to the Lakers and did it with Kobe and Shaq.
1:32:47But he never had to coach Donald Trump, though, or give him gold tickets.
1:32:51So there's that.
1:32:52So – and I think Ternus is that guy.
1:32:54He's the guy who has – I think has a very good relationship with both Jaws and Federighi and anybody else.
1:33:02Eddie Cue.
1:33:02Eddie Cue, again, like you said and has been alluded to, Eddie Cue's been telling Cook, I think Ternus is the guy, right?
1:33:09Eddie Cue is – has – I think everybody else – everybody I know at Apple really likes Eddie, but Eddie is a very strongly opinioned man.
1:33:16Really?
1:33:17And they're all going to be like that because, again, they've all – Eddie Cue and Jaws have been there for 40-some years, right?
1:33:23Like they – regardless of like their own personalities, the fact that they've been at one company that long, which does not happen in this day and age in tech.
1:33:32It just speaks to like they obviously live and breathe this company and they feel like it's theirs and rightfully so to many degree.
1:33:41And so they're going to have super strong opinions about it.
1:33:43And you're right that it's got to be almost an impossible task to manage that – those sort of personalities when they have that sort of tenure and that level of experience with the company.
1:33:53And just to go back to what kicked this off, but those people are – because of the nature of they've been there so long, they're up there in age to the point where they are not going to be there that much longer, relatively speaking.
1:34:04And so what does that mean for – and so like it – but it even speaks well to what you're sort of laying out there.
1:34:11And like Ternus could be the perfect sort of transitionary person, CEO, to take it from the current leadership stage and then bring in the people who are just the level below that.
1:34:23And I know that every – we can – I want to do one more segment here, but – and we have to talk about AI.
1:34:28But I know everybody seems to be saying, well, AI is the big problem on Ternus' plate.
1:34:33Right.
1:34:34It is a problem on his plate.
1:34:35I think the bigger problem, the most important thing on his plate is bringing up the next generation of senior leaders.
1:34:44I agree because it's been so – Apple is so weird in that what we just talked about, people have been there for so long.
1:34:53But the leadership level in particular has been in place for so long that there never really has been this sort of big transition.
1:35:03There's been small ones here and there where people elevate like Ternus who come up here and there.
1:35:07But we're at the point where they're all around the same age that they're all going to be transitioning out around the same time.
1:35:14And so there's going to be this massive turnover for the company.
1:35:17And that's almost like an impossible task, it feels like, in order to manage that.
1:35:21The software leadership, it was Avi Tavanian, but he actually left kind of early, right?
1:35:27He left in like the early 2000s and then Bertrand Serlet took over.
1:35:32And Bertrand had been there at Next, too, was Tavanian's right-hand man.
1:35:37And Federighi left Apple for a while.
1:35:40I always forget the name of the company he was at, but nobody remembers it.
1:35:43But he had a background, he had been at Next, then he left and sort of built up his leadership chops and then came back to Apple and it's been there ever since.
1:35:52They've only had three software people ever since the reunification with Next in 1997.
1:35:58Yeah, that's wild.
1:35:59Tavanian, Serlet, and Federighi.
1:36:01And Federighi certainly doesn't seem like he's leaving anywhere.
1:36:05And I think he's 56 or 57.
1:36:07I don't think he's going anywhere.
1:36:09They've only had two marketing chiefs.
1:36:12Phil Schiller.
1:36:13That's wild.
1:36:14Yeah, yeah.
1:36:15And now Jaws.
1:36:16Now Jaws is like 60, I think, or 61.
1:36:20Was he an intern?
1:36:21Like, he's the longest serving one, right, of the entire executive team?
1:36:25If it wasn't for Chris Espinosa, employee number eight, who joined when he was 14 years old, Jaws would be seemingly more of a freak.
1:36:35I think Jaws, I think Jaws told me this once.
1:36:38I think he, have you heard of the school, University of Michigan?
1:36:41Yeah, that's right.
1:36:42I know he was a Michigan grad, yep.
1:36:44Jaws, it's a small school somewhere in Michigan.
1:36:46Somewhere in the Midwest, yeah.
1:36:47Has had some sporting success of late.
1:36:51See it over my shoulder here for anyone.
1:36:53No one's watching, but I have a Michigan.
1:36:55No, nobody's watching.
1:36:55I have a Michigan football behind me, yeah.
1:36:57Signed by Tom Brady, actually.
1:36:59There you go.
1:36:59Another fine Michigan grad.
1:37:01But, yeah, Schiller and then Jaws are the only two marketing, product marketing chiefs the company's had since then.
1:37:08Hardware has had more turnover and hasn't had as many.
1:37:12There was Dan Ricci before Ternitz.
1:37:15Yeah, and they...
1:37:17Big Bob Mansfeld.
1:37:18Bob Mansfeld, who retired but then came back to help with the car thing, I think.
1:37:22Right, right, but which was another sign of, hey, where's the next generation?
1:37:27If, you know, the Mansfeld, and I love Bob, and I only met him a couple, a handful of times.
1:37:33They don't really usually put the hardware guys like Bob Mansfeld in the product briefing things that I get in the media, but in person, he seems like exactly what you think he was like, which is awesome.
1:37:45He just seems like an awesome guy, but the, hey, Bob tried to retire, and then we had to bring him back, like, twice.
1:37:51It's not a good sign about the next generation coming up.
1:37:55And remember the other famous, one of the famous sort of cook misses was Browlett, the guy that they hired to do retail, and they, and cook to his credit, I think, recognized the mistake quickly.
1:38:08It was only like six or seven months, and then they brought in Angela Arntz.
1:38:11Did they have something similar with Mark Papermaster?
1:38:13Do you remember that?
1:38:14Yeah, yeah.
1:38:15Yeah, that was a weird thing where they fought, and they did.
1:38:19I'll make a note for the show notes, because I went back to that reporting that I did.
1:38:24Papermaster came from IBM, and IBM tried to hold him to a non-compete.
1:38:29That's right, that's right.
1:38:30And then Apple fought and fought and fought, and got him on board, and then when the antenna gate happened, they were like, hey, this is Papermaster's fault.
1:38:38He's out, and Jobs fired.
1:38:40Yeah, and now I think he's at AMD, and he's been there for a long time.
1:38:42Yeah, he's still there.
1:38:43Super success there.
1:38:44Right.
1:38:44And it came up recently in the context, this is why I looked back at it, in the context of the way Cook dealt with John Gianandrea and AI, where Cook's style was to give, obviously Gianandrea was deemed a failure.
1:39:00And the Apple intelligence, Fiasco might be too strong, because I don't think they're in a bad place.
1:39:07But the fact that they made embarrassing announcements at WWDC two years ago that they could not deliver on fell on Gianandrea.
1:39:15And he was famously, again, in his public remarks, did not think LLMs were the future of AI.
1:39:23It was more of a, if anything, like, I view that as much more of a, just strategic mistakes that he made.
1:39:30Like, he made the wrong calls on things.
1:39:31An AI genius who did not think LLMs were the future of AI five or six years ago.
1:39:38They probably looked very good early on within Apple when they were having the success before it was LLMs, when it was just machine learning.
1:39:45And Apple was touting it, and it seemed like, oh, Apple's in a great spot.
1:39:49Right.
1:39:49And their machine learning features are actually very good.
1:39:52Nobody's impressed.
1:39:52They're just table stakes now.
1:39:53But when you search for dog in your Apple photos, you find all the pictures of dogs now.
1:39:58It's actually really, really good.
1:40:00That's not enough.
1:40:01But, so what did they do?
1:40:03Well, they made some announcements early last year and said Rockwell's going to take over Siri and this and that.
1:40:11But Gianandrea got to stay until December when they announced that he would be retiring.
1:40:17And he just got to leave very, as graciously and gracefully as possible when effectively it was like, yeah, you're out and we're taking everything away from you.
1:40:26Whereas, when there was the antenna gate issue with the iPhone 4, Papermaster was fired like six weeks later.
1:40:34And that was still Jobs, right?
1:40:35Right.
1:40:36That's the difference between Jobs and Cook.
1:40:39And if Jobs were still there, Gianandrea would have been fired like in February when they had to announce the delay.
1:40:46We're not going to ship the thing we said we were going to ship in June?
1:40:49Oh, okay.
1:40:50You're fired.
1:40:51I mean, it would have.
1:40:52I hate to play the what would Steve Jobs do.
1:40:55But this is one where I cannot imagine that Jobs would have said, okay, you can stay on the job for eight months and we'll let you go out gracefully in December.
1:41:03No.
1:41:03But that's the difference between Cook and Jobs' style.
1:41:06And I'm not even saying one's right or one's wrong because I think both of them were very true to themselves.
1:41:11I think it would have killed Jobs.
1:41:13If Jobs had lived, I think it would have killed him if he was still alive to let Gianandrea stay at the company for eight months for the sake of grace.
1:41:23And it's not Tim Cook style to scream at a guy, you're fired, you're out right now.
1:41:31And that's one of the sort of very high-level praise that you would say of Cook but is absolutely true and important is that Jobs famously, of course, told him, don't do what I would do, do what's right.
1:41:44But I think you could knock him a bit for – I think you could knock Apple overall in the intervening years for maybe swaying too much to – even though they're not explicitly doing what Jobs might do.
1:41:56Like they're sort of leaning in the direction of what Jobs might do.
1:41:58But I do think Cook, to his credit, knew that he could not manage and certainly from a stage presence on down but including the company, he couldn't manage in the style of Jobs.
1:42:09Like he just wasn't – it just wouldn't work to do that.
1:42:13It would have been a total fail immediately.
1:42:16And so he knew he was confident enough and lived in his own skin enough to know that he had to do it sort of the way that he does things, which is not the way that Jobs did things.
1:42:25I think that's such a keen observation, MG.
1:42:27I think – and I think that's where that advice from Jobs, parting advice from Jobs to Cook was most applicable.
1:42:33And it wasn't like, hey, don't do what I would do when it comes to product, which it's like, how could they not?
1:42:38Because I think that's actually –
1:42:40Should we cancel the iPhone?
1:42:42And I think that's true for Disney today.
1:42:44I think like Disney can look at a movie and say like, you know who would have loved this?
1:42:47Walt.
1:42:48Walt Disney, you know, who died in 1966 or 767.
1:42:51You don't want to just do the opposite of what has been successful because the founder's not there.
1:42:56The guy who did it wasn't there anymore.
1:42:58And the whole like argument over hand-drawn animation versus Pixar-style Toy Story animation.
1:43:04Walt would have loved it.
1:43:05He would have been like, oh my God, this is amazing.
1:43:07Yeah.
1:43:08But I think, hey, how would he run the company?
1:43:10Don't try to be like me.
1:43:13You're not me.
1:43:14Do it your way.
1:43:15And I think that's where – and the Giannandrea versus Papermaster thing exemplifies it.
1:43:21Well, I'll take a break here and thank our next sponsor.
1:43:25It is Finalist.
1:43:27Finalist is another app that hits home for me because I actually use it.
1:43:31It is a daily planner for iPhone, iPad, and Mac built on a kind of focused, intentional design that stems from the idea of like a paper bullet list or paper bullet journal or a day timer or something like that from the paper era.
1:43:49But brought into a native Apple app.
1:43:52It feels right at home on iPhone, iPad, and Mac.
1:43:57It is not just like a lame catalyst app that looks like the iPhone running on the Mac.
1:44:03It looks great on the Mac.
1:44:04Very modern.
1:44:06Very new.
1:44:07But definitely very native.
1:44:08It fills itself in with – it integrates with at a system level.
1:44:12Your system level calendar, your reminders, your habits, and weather if you want.
1:44:17All of those things are optional.
1:44:18If you don't want to give it weather access or your location access to get your weather, you don't have to.
1:44:23All of those things are optional.
1:44:25But I use them.
1:44:26They're really great.
1:44:27It also has, in addition to reminders, which integrate with the system reminder database and the Apple reminders app, finalist has its own tasks.
1:44:38And tasks are like to-do items that only live in finalist.
1:44:42So you can create and edit reminders in finalist that are both in finalist and in a reminders app or tasks which are only in finalist.
1:44:52And that makes a lot of sense to me.
1:44:54There are certain things that I want to be in reminders and there are certain things that I want only in finalist.
1:44:59And it really makes sense.
1:45:00Visually very distinctive.
1:45:02It's built by one person, Slavin Tradić.
1:45:06And there's a Discord community that shapes its direction.
1:45:09It's a super enthusiastic community of users.
1:45:12Slavin is a great developer.
1:45:15And since I started using it in December, I've actually been using the TestFlight builds just to watch it go.
1:45:20It is amazing how much better it is since December.
1:45:23And in December, it was already good enough for me to start using on a day-to-day basis.
1:45:28And it is improving at an unbelievably fast clip.
1:45:31It is made and a native for iOS, iPadOS, macOS, and visionOS.
1:45:36And it's just the kind of app that you really just need to check it out to see it.
1:45:41One of the things that really makes it different from most to-do tasks apps that I've ever tried is that instead of setting due dates for tasks,
1:45:49and you have a list of tasks and the tasks have dates, instead, you add tasks to days.
1:45:57The tasks live in the days as opposed to days being assigned to tasks.
1:46:01I know that sounds like a nerdy distinction, but for me, that really resonates.
1:46:04And it really makes a lot more sense.
1:46:06With the top-level items being days and days having tasks and events, it just makes it easier to go through time.
1:46:14And maybe there's some things from like last week or the week before that just stay on those days, and you never finish them, and you never go back, and you kind of don't need to.
1:46:22And there's always a list of all unfinished tasks that you can go to to see them, see items from last week that you never finished if you want.
1:46:31But it's a great way to sort of keep your list of things that are at the top of your mind at a minimum as opposed to having a giant pile of tasks that grows faster than you can finish them off.
1:46:44They're all there.
1:46:45You can leave them behind and move on.
1:46:47It's up to you.
1:46:48But I really like that.
1:46:50Where do you go to find out more?
1:46:52Go to finalist.works, great URL, finalist.works slash talkshow.
1:47:02And by going to that URL, you get six months free.
1:47:10It's just an unbelievable deal.
1:47:12Way better deal than I would have expected.
1:47:14I think subscriptions are normally $5 a month or $30 a year.
1:47:18A lifetime license costs just $60.
1:47:21But if you go to finalist.works slash talkshow, you can just try it for free for six months just for listening to the talkshow.
1:47:30And I'm telling you, it is worth checking out.
1:47:33Go check out finalist at finalist.works slash the talkshow.
1:47:38What else do you want to talk about with Cook or do you want to shift to Ternus?
1:47:42Maybe Ternus, I think.
1:47:45So let me read – I haven't linked to it yet, but this is Stephen Levy's take at Wired.
1:47:51Oh, good.
1:47:52I read this one today.
1:47:53And it's – he talked to Ternus and Jaws a month ago.
1:47:58And again, that's sort of the – hey, this was all – you look back, it's like the usual suspects or the Sixth Sense or any of those movies where you get to the end and the big reveal.
1:48:09As you like to quote, The Prestige, right?
1:48:12Yeah.
1:48:13There is a similar moment in The Prestige, which is true.
1:48:17It might be –
1:48:18The aha.
1:48:18Yeah.
1:48:18And then you were like, I have to watch this movie all over again right now.
1:48:22I have to start it.
1:48:23And if it's midnight, you're like, tomorrow night at 8 p.m. we're watching this movie again because I have to – and then you watch it over again.
1:48:30You're like, oh, yeah.
1:48:33All those movies have that.
1:48:34And I think you can look at everything that's happened since the Financial Times leak and planned leak in November and see, oh, yeah, this is why Jaws and Ternus talked to Stephen Levy a month ago.
1:48:46This is why the MacBook Neo was announced in person.
1:48:50Exactly, exactly, exactly.
1:48:51The guy who came out on stage was John Ternus.
1:48:54Oh, this is why.
1:48:56Yeah, they were setting this up.
1:48:58Here's what Stephen Levy wrote.
1:49:00He talked to – this is quoting Ternus.
1:49:02Ternus told him, we never think about AI.
1:49:05We never think about shipping a technology.
1:49:08We want to ship amazing products, features, and experiences, and we don't want our customers to think about what technology makes it possible.
1:49:15That's the way we think about AI, end quote from Ternus.
1:49:19Now, Stephen Levy wrote, that's fine, but I look back to the mid-2000s when everybody was waiting for Apple to come out with a phone.
1:49:28When Jobs finally delivered in January 2007, the product defined the mobile era.
1:49:33It's a big ask for Ternus to do something similar for the AI age, but it's an opportunity that must be seized.
1:49:39AI threatens to disrupt the entire iPhone ecosystem by the end of the decade.
1:49:44It's unlikely that people will swipe on their phones to tap on Uber or Lyft.
1:49:49They will just tell their always-on AI agent to get them home, or that agent will have already figured out where they need to go,
1:49:55and the car will be waiting without the friction of a request.
1:49:58There's an app for that, maybe replaced by let the agent do that.
1:50:02I'm a big Stephen Levy fan, but I think that's all wrong.
1:50:07As am I.
1:50:09Fun fact, he married my wife and I, which is fun.
1:50:11Oh!
1:50:12Well, then you're a bigger fan of Stephen than I am.
1:50:14I am.
1:50:15I'm good friends with him.
1:50:15I did not know that.
1:50:18And the reason why my icon is this Susan Kerr one is that that was a wedding present from him.
1:50:23Oh.
1:50:23He had her.
1:50:24But anyway, neither here nor there, I am also a Stephen fan, but I also know where you're going with this.
1:50:30And I also disagree that I think that, I think at a high level that's right.
1:50:35I think the timing is off probably, right?
1:50:38I don't think that in that time frame we're likely to see the iPhone displaced.
1:50:44I don't think that the app model necessarily even will be displaced.
1:50:49I think there will be differences.
1:50:50I think there will be transitions and differences in the way that we do certain things.
1:50:54And there could vary.
1:50:55And I think there will very well be new devices that we use.
1:50:59But I do think, like, I'm of the mindset very much that the iPhone is going to be the hub for the foreseeable future.
1:51:05I think it's a question of what the timetable is.
1:51:07I don't think it's forever.
1:51:09But I do think that there's a world in which, and I wrote about this when I was writing, thinking through the future of Ternus.
1:51:15There's a world in which Ternus' entire tenure is still dominated by the iPhone.
1:51:20Yeah.
1:51:21Oh, I think so.
1:51:22Think about the Mac.
1:51:23The Mac came out in 1984.
1:51:25Personal computers around 1980.
1:51:27That's 42 years.
1:51:30The Mac is a bigger and more people use a Mac.
1:51:33Apple sells more Macs today than ever before.
1:51:36And in fact, the more people use them and they sell more of them, the curve might actually have just taken a sharp uptick last month when the MacBook Neo came out.
1:51:45I mean, literally.
1:51:46I mean, that MacBook Neo might go down in history as a product that actually, an inflection moment that shifted the demand curve and the number of users of the Macintosh.
1:51:59I think it will.
1:52:00Like, does it double the base?
1:52:02I mean, it's crazy what's going to happen.
1:52:04Yeah.
1:52:04The only problems that have come out about it are the fact that they've run out, apparently, they've run out of the binned 5GPU chips and might have to restart production.
1:52:16Launch the new version early or something.
1:52:17Yeah.
1:52:18And decide what to do with all of the A18 Pro chips that have six working GPUs and just say, okay, now, you know, some of the MacBook Neos have six GPUs and some have five.
1:52:29Or do they disable one?
1:52:30But what a good problem to have.
1:52:32MacBook Neo Plus.
1:52:34So is it crazy to think that the iPhone right now at 20-ish years in, next year it will be the 20, next year's 20, that it'll have 40 or 50 years?
1:52:46I don't think it's crazy at all.
1:52:48And I think if you stop thinking about it as the iPhone and everything you do on the iPhone today, because you do different things on your iPhone today than you used to.
1:52:58And you just think, is the main product a roughly card, pack of cards, wallet-sized computer?
1:53:09The Her device, but it's the iPhone.
1:53:12Yes.
1:53:13Right.
1:53:13It is roughly the size of what we now call phones.
1:53:17And it is a full Unix computer with all-day battery life that most people, from not just adults, but down to some level of teen or even preteen, have with them all day, every day.
1:53:33It's a computer, and it has always connected internet access.
1:53:38Is that the product that everybody carries around with them?
1:53:42And I don't see anything that's changing that, that there is going to be a computer that you carry around with you.
1:53:47And you go back to what Stephen Levy said here, and it's by the end of the decade, you may not tap on Uber or whatever.
1:53:54You just tell your always-on AI agent to get you home.
1:53:57Well, what are you talking to?
1:53:58You're at the restaurant.
1:54:00You need to get home.
1:54:01And you're going to tell your agent to take you home.
1:54:03Where is the microphone that hears the request?
1:54:08It's not in the air.
1:54:11I guess they would say maybe we get to the point – again, it's timetable stuff, though.
1:54:17Like, maybe we get to the point where an AirPod-like device can be made by someone else that doesn't require tethering to the iPhone.
1:54:26Like, that it has a modem in it, that it has a CPU in it, that it has anything else.
1:54:32And that it could – maybe it can even, like, in the next five years, can run models locally that are good enough to be able to do some stuff.
1:54:41But you still need to connect to Uber in this example, right, to call the car.
1:54:45Right.
1:54:46But what are you going to watch when you're in the Uber?
1:54:48Right?
1:54:50What are you going to look at?
1:54:51Like, the olden days, you're going to stare at the window.
1:54:54No.
1:54:55You're going to want a screen.
1:54:57And you want your shit on the screen.
1:54:58And just to play devil's advocate, I guess the counter argument would be that you'll have the meta Ray-Bans on, right?
1:55:06And they have the little screen in them.
1:55:08And so you can watch something that way.
1:55:10But again, I think –
1:55:13It's possible, right?
1:55:13It is possible.
1:55:15Glasses made by somebody else, and the glasses have a screen, and you can be entertained with that.
1:55:20And again, the other function that the phone serves for people when they're out at dinner and they need an Uber.
1:55:24I like to take a picture every time I go out to dinner with friends or some – multiple pictures just so I can remember.
1:55:30Yeah, but you'll be able to do that through your AirPods or whatever.
1:55:32Yeah, do it with your AirPods or your glasses or something.
1:55:35But you do need a computing device with a camera in it.
1:55:38You need a computing device with a microphone in it.
1:55:41You need a computing device with an always-on internet connection.
1:55:43Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
1:55:44And it's very hard for me to imagine a world where people are doing that without a phone.
1:55:50You're carrying six devices.
1:55:51You would need – it's basically like – it goes back to the old argument in the earlier days of the iPhone, like the best camera is the one you have on you, right?
1:55:58Right.
1:55:58Like always.
1:55:59And are you really going to disintermediate the iPhone into six – it's like bundling and unbundling.
1:56:06Are you going to unbundle the iPhone into six different devices that you always have to carry around and that you have to charge and that need connectivity and all this?
1:56:13Or are you going to – more likely the iPhone remains the main hub that you keep and maybe increasingly it's in your pocket because you have one or two other devices, including, by the way, for everyone like right now, AirPods and or the watch, which are already those devices.
1:56:30And maybe now they augment that with either a pendant that has been some level of talked about or glasses or something else.
1:56:36But the key is the iPhone remains the central computing hub.
1:56:40And you're right.
1:56:41Don't think about it as a phone.
1:56:42It hasn't been a phone almost since the day it launched.
1:56:45That was famously one of Jobs' three pillars of it.
1:56:47But that's the least important part of it.
1:56:49It's the one that doesn't hold up.
1:56:50But it was the most important selling point in 2007.
1:56:53Yes.
1:56:54So it's not like –
1:56:55It was the transition point to get people into it.
1:56:58And now it's not needed anymore.
1:57:00They spent so much time in that – the best keynote of all time talking about voicemail.
1:57:07And it blew our mind.
1:57:10Because it was great.
1:57:11Visual voicemail stuff is awesome.
1:57:13It comes in like emails.
1:57:14Oh, my God.
1:57:15You can just swipe to delete.
1:57:16You don't have to type star 77.
1:57:18I remember how cool that was in the first iPhone.
1:57:19Yeah.
1:57:20But so now this is like the end point.
1:57:24This is the ultimate end point of the device though.
1:57:26From that keynote on forward, we've now narrowed the device down to just a computer in your pocket.
1:57:33Like it doesn't – yes, it still has the screen because that's sort of the interface that you do everything you need to do.
1:57:39It's the least common denominator, the way to interact with it.
1:57:42But there's going to be future ways to interact with it.
1:57:44Again, AirPods and watch and glasses.
1:57:46And it all comes in through that phone though.
1:57:50And that's a – that is like the nightmare scenario for Meta and the nightmare scenario for many other companies, OpenAI too.
1:57:57OpenAI and Johnny Ive and IO and –
1:58:00If they never can disintermediate the use of the phone.
1:58:03And there's also the practical – well, even if it's theoretically possible.
1:58:08And it will be eventually, right?
1:58:10Computers just keep getting smaller and even when it becomes theoretically possible for your AirPod sized devices to be your main computer with all day battery life and the internet connection that wherever you go.
1:58:23Or your watch or whatever, anything small like that or your glasses, right?
1:58:27Any of these tiny devices.
1:58:30When do you reach the point though where somebody says, oh, I'm going to put my phone on the shelf and I'm going to call Verizon or AT&T or T-Mobile and say, I cancel my cell phone plan.
1:58:44Right.
1:58:45And I'm going to switch to a pendant plan or an AirPod plan or a glasses plan.
1:58:50When do they do that?
1:58:52And then they take – they're paying for a cellular networking plan or a satellite plan in the future.
1:59:00Who knows?
1:59:00But they're paying somebody for always on internet, wherever they go, from another device and stop paying for the one on their phone even though the phone has this beautiful screen and has a camera that is always going to be better.
1:59:14The camera in your phone is always going to be better than the one in your glasses optically.
1:59:18Just because of physics.
1:59:19Physics.
1:59:20Yeah.
1:59:20Size.
1:59:21Yeah.
1:59:21Land size and stuff.
1:59:22In the same way and maybe eventually the one in the glasses will get good enough optically in the way –
1:59:29Through AI, you know.
1:59:30Yeah.
1:59:31The way that the phone cameras are clearly good enough that people take better pictures with their phones today, almost everybody, than they would with a $1,000 big camera camera from Sony or from Canon or Nikon.
1:59:46Because most people don't have those cameras with them and what makes them better are things that people don't want to use and they're not going to carry that thing around with them.
1:59:54Right?
1:59:55They take, in practical experience, better photos with their phone today than they would with a bigger camera even though optically it's not superior because it's good enough.
2:00:03And eventually the glasses or something will get there.
2:00:05Right.
2:00:05You would counter and say, but the glasses you're always wearing.
2:00:08So, therefore, it's even better than the phone because the phone is not – it's sometimes in your pocket and not pointed at the moment that you would miss.
2:00:14But maybe not because by that time the phone camera will be so good that the 8X camera will – or 20X camera, whatever up to at the point, will let you take like these incredible photos from the back of the arena when you're shooting the stage.
2:00:28Who knows?
2:00:28I don't know.
2:00:29It's hard to see how we get there.
2:00:31My heavy guess would be that the reality is for, say, another decade that the phone remains the main computing hub in your pocket.
2:00:40And increasingly it does maybe stay in your pocket more as these other devices sort of come in and out of popularity.
2:00:46But it remains the main hub.
2:00:48And to your question about connectivity and whatnot, do you cancel – eventually cancel your phone contract because you're using whatever the internet through your AirPods or something?
2:00:57I think that they – just like sort of the cable companies have all morphed into internet now cable companies, it basically becomes the connectivity companies are all just giving you one bill.
2:01:11And you can already get this and bundle together your watch and iPad and everything onto the same cellular thing.
2:01:17I think you're just paying for a data connection and all of your devices are able to access it.
2:01:21And so you pay AT&T or Verizon and basically all of your devices have a link into your account there.
2:01:29But I still think that the phone remains the main computing hub because it's going to have the best CPU and it's going to have sort of the best battery life and it's going to have the way that brings all of those things together.
2:01:41And it lets the other devices do less.
2:01:44Think about battery life.
2:01:46And Apple Watch shows the way where Apple Watch still – and it could be today.
2:01:50And you can set it up when you set one up for like an older parent, like if I got one from my 88-year-old dad or if you sent one up for your young child, which both are use cases I know a lot of people do with Apple Watch.
2:02:03And then they're not paired with their phone because they may not have a phone.
2:02:07You as like a middle-aged adult can pair an Apple Watch with your phone and give it to your elderly adult parents or your small children.
2:02:19But still, even then, the Apple Watch is not really an independent device.
2:02:23It's tied to your phone.
2:02:24And think about the early years of Apple Watch and the way people – everybody who had one knows that you kind of struggle to get through the day on battery life.
2:02:32In the early – for years, that was sort of like, can you get to the end of the day before you have to charge it overnight?
2:02:37Okay, now you – okay, I did.
2:02:38And it was getting better every year.
2:02:40But that's with the watch as a satellite device to the phone.
2:02:45That's with that.
2:02:46Imagine if the Apple Watch had been totally independent and was the main –
2:02:50Yeah, it would have lasted for an hour.
2:02:52And so think about how much –
2:02:54And it would have been so thick and –
2:02:55Right.
2:02:55Yeah, yeah, yeah.
2:02:56Think about how much lighter AirPods are than an Apple Watch.
2:02:59And think about how much lighter glasses have to be than an Apple Watch.
2:03:03You cannot have an Apple Watch Ultra on your fucking face.
2:03:06I mean, it'll drive you crazy.
2:03:08Obviously, technology progresses and all the stuff gets smaller and sort of battery life becomes sort of an inhibiting factor always.
2:03:15But still, like, technology will progress.
2:03:18But I do think, like, even at a more fundamental level, like, it's just a question of what's more comfortable to use?
2:03:23Is it more comfortable to use a bigger screen when you want to browse, yeah, the internet versus doing it in your glasses or on your watch?
2:03:30Right.
2:03:31And obviously, like, it just depends on the context that you're in.
2:03:33And I just don't see a world in which there's a context anytime soon where you wouldn't want a phone-like screen device for a lot of what you want to do.
2:03:44Now, again, it's all going to be augmented by other things.
2:03:47And you'll be able to do some new things, like, with always-on AI through AirPods or whatnot that you can't do right now with a phone because it's in your pocket.
2:03:55But I do think, like, the context matters for all these things and how you're going to use them.
2:04:00And I think it comes down to, like, form factors more than, like, people really want to displace the iPhone because we're looking for what's next.
2:04:08But I just think it remains, again, that key computing point.
2:04:12And I think there is a gnomes-wearing-underpants step two, dot, dot, dot, between AI is an industry-changing technology, dot, dot, dot, new form factors.
2:04:30And I don't know that that's there.
2:04:31And think about the other things over the 20 years of the iPhone's life that have happened that Apple – the other thing that I feel like Stephen kind of fell into the trap with, with the hype around AI right now, by writing that and saying that Apple needs an AI-first product that's going to supplant the phone,
2:04:52It's – think about the other things that have come up that Apple just isn't a part of.
2:04:58Social media, right?
2:04:59Social media was not a big deal in 2007.
2:05:02It really wasn't, or not compared to today.
2:05:04And now Meta is one of the biggest companies in the world, right?
2:05:08It is entirely based – and Meta's presence in the top 10 or top 5 at times in market cap companies is entirely predicated on the role social media plays in the world.
2:05:19And the whole reason social media plays the role it does in so many people's lives, hours a day, tons of screen time, tons of money and ads and the way people get news.
2:05:30And it's all from the phone.
2:05:33Apple doesn't own that.
2:05:35One of the biggest companies and one of Apple's biggest rivals is entirely based on people having phones, but that's not it.
2:05:42Software as a service, right?
2:05:44The sales force and everybody else like them, all of that.
2:05:48All of those software as a service companies are a part of people's lives because they're on their phones all the time and that you can get into your companies, whatever you're doing the software as a service for.
2:05:58It's all on your phone too.
2:06:00And it's integrated.
2:06:01And yes, computers were a big part of all these companies before everybody had an iPhone or an iPhone-like phone in their pocket all the time.
2:06:09But it's way different now than it used to be.
2:06:11And Apple doesn't have to own that.
2:06:13And AI, it is.
2:06:15I think what Ternus said and what Levy quoted him, that it's a technology.
2:06:20It's not even a feature.
2:06:21It's a technology.
2:06:22There's the whole Dropbox is a feature, not a product that Jobs told the Dropbox founders.
2:06:27It was a great feature.
2:06:28AI isn't even a feature.
2:06:30It really is a technology.
2:06:32It's an important one, but I don't think it's one that necessitates our pants are on fire.
2:06:39We need to come out with a product that is just about this.
2:06:42Here's the only push I would give on that.
2:06:44I think there might, there could be, I don't think it'll be any time in the immediate future, but there could be a world in which basically this is, what dictates this is sort of the interface.
2:06:56And so we had computers and then that went to phone and touch, obviously, famously, the iPhone ushered in.
2:07:04If we do get to a world where voice becomes the, maybe not the overall thing, because there's obviously times you don't want to use your voice, but becomes one of the main interfaces of computing.
2:07:18And that is ushered in by AI.
2:07:21There is an argument to be made that we need some sort of newfangled device that's different from a phone.
2:07:29I still think it will be tethered to the phone for the foreseeable future, but that would be the case for there being some sort of, in my mind, at least, that would be the case for there being some sort of new form factor that comes up.
2:07:41It's not so much because of the technology itself, but it's because of the new interface that sort of dictates it.
2:07:47Right, and there is, I can see it.
2:07:49I'm not trying to be a Luddite here regarding, hey, what if AI keeps getting better at the rate it has over the last five years for another five years?
2:08:01Could it be the case that you really just talk to your device and everything gets managed and you really don't have an email app anymore?
2:08:13You just ask and see and it just presents.
2:08:17It presents a to-do list back to emails that it's exchanged on your behalf.
2:08:21Right, and everything, you do have screens because we are visual creatures.
2:08:25We're always going to have screens, but what's shown on your screen is just presented on the fly at all times, like an ad hoc interface for everybody.
2:08:33I see that as possible, but I don't see Apple as being lost by not saying, oh, that's definitely the future at this point.
2:08:41I think Apple's in a better position than anybody to be the company to get there.
2:08:46I agree for sure right now.
2:08:48I've written about this a little bit, and I think the other angle that I've been sort of noodling around it and written a little bit about because of news, I think it was a couple weeks ago now, which is that I wouldn't be shocked if a lot of the big technology companies jump back into the smartphone game.
2:09:04Because they know that Apple's position is such, and Google to a lesser extent, and Samsung, as we've discussed.
2:09:12So there was a rumor that Amazon might be trying to get back in, and now I don't know how Meta is not going to try to get back in.
2:09:21And if the world we're talking about sort of plays out that way, Mark Zuckerberg famously despises Apple because they have control over his ecosystem, and including the new devices, the Meta Ray-Bans and whatnot that they're trying to do.
2:09:35And he's obviously pushing from all angles to try to, from regulatory and whatnot, to try to displace that and break that advantage that Apple holds.
2:09:43I think that they're all going to dive back into smartphones, and it might not be the exact form factor that we've known, the candy bar sort of type style that we've known over these past many years.
2:09:53But they might try with foldables and stuff to get back into this world now that they see sort of these new types of devices coming in.
2:10:00So I wouldn't be shocked if we see Microsoft, we see Amazon, we see Meta, we see everyone else basically jump back in.
2:10:07I would like to see it.
2:10:08I think competition is good.
2:10:09I really do.
2:10:10And I think one of the biggest problems Apple faces is that they don't have enough competition, and it leads to complacency and arrogance.
2:10:17I really do.
2:10:18They can't help the fact that their competitors aren't that good.
2:10:21And other companies with an edge, not an edge, an advantage, but like a grudge, like the way that Zuckerberg has a grudge, that's good for Apple, that he was motivated to do it.
2:10:34It's good that Bezos has instilled in Amazon a, hey, why don't we take over the whole world mentality.
2:10:40I would love to see them take another crack at a phone.
2:10:42I don't know that it's likely to succeed, but I'd like to see it.
2:10:48There are two more parts that I would call out for that, that potential future.
2:10:51One, I think as these companies go down more, and this is related to Apple directly, as they all go down the path of trying to do their own chips more, right?
2:11:02Because they're all basically spinning up these projects to do it from an AI perspective.
2:11:06They want even, but, and it's sort of, it's sort of all bucketed together.
2:11:10But a lot of them aren't just building like NVIDIA GPUs, right?
2:11:13They're building different types of TPUs, different specialized chips in order to do inference in some cases, but also just to do different things.
2:11:21And still, even when you're running AI, you still need a CPU to coordinate all this stuff.
2:11:26And so a lot of them are also now going back into and thinking about building CPUs again.
2:11:30And so if they're building the CPUs already, what if you put that in a device, like a newfangled device that's a mainstream computing device?
2:11:38I think you're going to see, I think NVIDIA is already rumored to be working on more mainstream computing devices.
2:11:42And as why else would, would everyone else not do that?
2:11:46You would probably see Intel eventually get back into that world and all of them, again, competing along those lines.
2:11:52Right.
2:11:52And so I do think that you're going to see about that.
2:11:54The counter to all of this is what we talked about briefly earlier.
2:11:59Apple has such an advantage, not only in obviously supply chain elements, but also in the retail element, the way to sell these things.
2:12:08The reason why Google isn't selling trillions of pixels is you can argue like they're good or not.
2:12:13I think that they're pretty good devices at this point.
2:12:15They have a Pixel Fold that I use as backup device to try out Android.
2:12:18It's good.
2:12:18The problem is they don't have nearly the retail footprint in order to get the consumer traffic that they would need in order to do that.
2:12:25So they have to start carrier deals and do the old school ways of doing things that Apple doesn't have to do right now.
2:12:29And I think that Meta is at a huge disadvantage.
2:12:32They're trying to open some more stores.
2:12:34They have two or three of them right now, and they're trying to roll out more because they know,
2:12:37even with their partnership with Exeter Exotica to sell the glasses in those stores,
2:12:42like they're going to need their own retail experiences.
2:12:44And Apple just has such a head start.
2:12:47I mean, even if you wanted to, it's not even like spinning up a data center.
2:12:50They have to buy retail space and lease up retail space all around the world.
2:12:54It's going to be a decades-long project to do that.
2:12:57Right, and Apple went very fast at that, but it still was like a 20-year process of expanding.
2:13:03Yeah, there's no way to do that super fast.
2:13:04And they're still opening in new places.
2:13:06You can go pop-up stores, I guess.
2:13:06They're still doing things.
2:13:08Like last year was a big deal where they opened like a huge store in India.
2:13:11Right, right.
2:13:12They're still in expansion overall, which is crazy.
2:13:16So even if the companies recognize this opportunity, maybe try to go back into the smartphone game
2:13:23because they're building chips and because they have more hardware prowess than they did previously,
2:13:27and there's just more competition out there in the world to build these types of products,
2:13:31like how are they going to sell them?
2:13:34Amazon obviously has a way, but still, people are going to want to use some of these devices
2:13:38before they actually go to purchase them.
2:13:40Famously, Fire Phone did not work.
2:13:42Yeah, and the retail stores are another form of hardware because they are real.
2:13:47They are atoms, not ones and zeros, and Apple has a real advantage there.
2:13:52And I wrote about it.
2:13:53I do think it does make more sense just in general, not just by Ternus' personal disposition personality,
2:14:01but which I think fits too, but I also think a hardware person is the right person at the moment
2:14:06of all this AI hype because it's grounded in reality, and that's what retail is too.
2:14:12It is grounded in reality, but this is also a good segue to the last thing I have on my list to talk about,
2:14:17which is Johnny Suruji, and that's the chips, right?
2:14:20Yep.
2:14:21And the German factor, and there's two narratives around Suruji.
2:14:28The one, and it is only from one source.
2:14:32It is only from Mark Gurman, and it was hot on the heels literally at the end of the very week
2:14:37where Alan Dye left Apple for Meta, and Bloomberg, Gurman had the scoop, which I don't know,
2:14:44but I believe, and I know a lot of people at Apple believe, came from Dye because Bloomberg
2:14:52and Gurman had the scoop at the same time Apple found out he was leaving.
2:14:56Apple had his little time to prepare for the Bloomberg story announcing that Dye was going
2:15:03to Meta, which in the headline called it a coup for Meta.
2:15:06It was a very pro-Alan Dye, very pro-Apple, or pro-Meta, anti-this is a big problem for
2:15:12Apple story, which suggests that Dye leaked it to Gurman.
2:15:16And then at the end of the week, Gurman had a, nobody else ever had this, but that a story
2:15:22that said Johnny Suruji had gone to Tim Cook and said, hey, I want more, I want more, and
2:15:29if you don't give me more, I don't know if it was money, I don't know if it was a promotion
2:15:33of some sort.
2:15:33Power.
2:15:33Yeah.
2:15:34Power, I'm going to go to, I'm not going to retire, I'm going to go to a competitor.
2:15:38And that, and then on, that was like on a Saturday, I think Gurman published that, which is unusual
2:15:44for Bloomberg to publish anything not on it.
2:15:47Right, because it can't move the market on a Saturday.
2:15:49Can't move the market because it's closed.
2:15:50And then by Sunday night or Monday morning, Suruji had sent a memo to his entire team, more
2:15:57or less calling bullshit on it and saying, I love my job, I love that I'm here, and I'm
2:16:01not going anywhere.
2:16:01Now, you could say, well, Gurman was right, and when the story came out, Tim Cook called
2:16:07Johnny Suruji and said, okay, this looks bad, I'll give you anything you want, and then Suruji
2:16:12sent the memo and stayed.
2:16:14And the other angle, which is my angle, is that the story was nonsense and there was no truth
2:16:21to it, and that's the reason nobody but Gurman had it, and it didn't come from Suruji or
2:16:26anybody around him, but came from, I would guess, Meta, and that Meta just said, hey,
2:16:32you know, we just took Dai, you know, Johnny Suruji's sniffing around, and we could use a
2:16:36chip guy, and maybe he's not happy in doing this.
2:16:38Because this is what I, now, again, I didn't talk to Johnny Suruji, I didn't talk to anybody
2:16:45who talked to Johnny Suruji, but to believe the Gurman narrative, you would have to believe
2:16:49that the successful way for a senior vice president at Apple to get more at Apple is
2:16:56to threaten Tim Cook with leaving for a competitor.
2:16:59I don't, I don't, that makes no sense to me whatsoever.
2:17:03I think if somebody went, if Johnny Suruji went to Tim Cook and said that, I think Tim Cook
2:17:08would say, go fuck yourself, you're out.
2:17:09Go pack your office and get out of here.
2:17:11Johnny Suruji is important.
2:17:14Go fuck yourself, you're out in eight months.
2:17:15Yes, exactly.
2:17:17For earlier discussion.
2:17:19I don't know, though.
2:17:20I actually think if anything would set him off in a way that, like, John G. Andrea at
2:17:24least tried and gave an honest effort and is just the wrong person for the job.
2:17:28He didn't hold him over a fire.
2:17:29I think if somebody went to Cook and threatened him, it might actually trigger the Steve Jobsian
2:17:35go, I'm calling security and you're being escorted out of the building.
2:17:40That, I honestly think Tim Cook, I cannot fathom the idea that Tim Cook would take a threat.
2:17:47My gut instinct on this, and we'll talk to the broader German thing, because I think you
2:17:53and I aligned on the broader point about the succession itself, but, like, with the Suruji
2:18:00element, my instinct was that there's something to Gurman's report here, only because, no, inside
2:18:09information, just the optics of the fact that they announced Suruji's ascension to his new
2:18:17role at the exact same time they announced the Ternus.
2:18:20That is interesting.
2:18:22Is interesting.
2:18:23Like, it suggests that there was some sort of agreement that they would tout him to the
2:18:31heavens, saying that he has this new important role, and that just please stick around, we're
2:18:38making John Ternus the CEO, and we would like you to take over a bigger role within the company.
2:18:48Now, I don't think, both things can be true, right?
2:18:51They could basically have said to him, look, your counterpart in hardware is getting elevated
2:18:59to the CEO role.
2:19:00That's not in the cards for you.
2:19:02Obviously, they wouldn't frame it like that, but you know what I mean?
2:19:04It's not in the cards.
2:19:05But we would like you to take on his responsibility, some of, at least some of his responsibilities
2:19:09that he's been doing, because we want you to stick around.
2:19:12Like, you're a vital part to this company.
2:19:14The chips are arguably the most important hardware breakthrough that we've had in the
2:19:18past decade, and so will you be up for this new challenge?
2:19:22And so that's why they announced them sort of in conjunction with one another.
2:19:26But I do think that there's a world in which Suruji maybe doesn't go to cook, but is sort
2:19:31of floating out there.
2:19:33He's also not a young chicken, right?
2:19:36He's 60-something years old.
2:19:3761, right.
2:19:3861 years old.
2:19:39And so maybe he's floating out there.
2:19:41Look, we're about to go through this CEO transition.
2:19:43I don't know what my future looks like at the company.
2:19:45Again, this is all just me playing this out in my head.
2:19:47Again, maybe not to Tim Cook, but maybe to others within his orbit at Apple and just being
2:19:53like, I don't know what, am I signing up for another decade, like under this new CEO who
2:19:58I like, who I get along with and everything, but what does my role look like?
2:20:02And I don't want to keep doing the same thing that I've been doing because I've had success
2:20:07at that and I want a new challenge.
2:20:08And so maybe they say like, hey, we're elevating John Ternus.
2:20:11John Ternus does XYZ.
2:20:14We think you can handle XYZ of his XYZ alongside what you've been doing.
2:20:19And what do you think about that?
2:20:22And so there's a world in which it's not necessarily like an ultimatum that he gives, but it's just
2:20:27like I'm thinking about what my future looks like at the company.
2:20:31And I couldn't say it better myself.
2:20:34There could be something like that.
2:20:36And then one or two sources removed, it gets to Gurman and it all of a sudden-
2:20:41Yeah, it's like a game of telephone.
2:20:42Right.
2:20:43And in the game of telephone, now it's an ultimatum and a threat.
2:20:46And that wasn't the case.
2:20:48And you could even argue then that that's why Suruji reacted the way he did, which is maybe
2:20:54a little mildly disingenuous in the scenario that we're playing out.
2:20:58But it's also like, I didn't mean it that way.
2:21:00So I'm not talking about leaving.
2:21:01I just, I was floating out there.
2:21:03I'm 61 years old.
2:21:04I'm trying to figure out what my path forward is.
2:21:07One of the other ways to look at it, he is 61.
2:21:10And the fact that he's 61.
2:21:12And again, it's a lot, I think for Suruji is a lot like Craig Federighi, where, like I said,
2:21:18where else could Craig Federighi go as a software executive whose expertise, he'd be the first
2:21:25very, very, very, very explicitly software.
2:21:28Where could he go that would have anywhere near the domain and the effect and just the prestige of leading Apple software at this stage in his career?
2:21:40In theory, he could go, like we said, we could go to Google, but he's not just, Craig Federighi is not just a manager, right?
2:21:48He's not just a guy who could have been the head of fabrics at Nike or the head of roller coasters at Disney theme parks.
2:21:57He knows Apple's technology.
2:22:00Like, a couple of years ago on my show, he was talking about the fact that one of his hobbies is writing apps.
2:22:07He writes apps in Swift UI.
2:22:10Is he going to bring Swift to Google?
2:22:13It doesn't make sense.
2:22:14He gets into arguments and discussions, I say arguments, but he does get into arguments with people at Apple, and he's talking about, like, the API calls.
2:22:22Like, he knows the frameworks.
2:22:24He knows the code.
2:22:25It's not like all the code is going to him for line-by-line approval, but it could.
2:22:31Like, you could get in a meeting with him, and he could be bringing up source code and talking to you about it, and he knows what the fuck he's talking about.
2:22:38He's not going to have that level of expertise anywhere else because the software he has an expertise with is very specific to Apple.
2:22:44And Johnny Suruji is like that with this chip thing that they've built up.
2:22:47They're not just chips in general.
2:22:49The chip thing is interesting, though, right?
2:22:51Because Apple has such an advantage there at the moment, and there's obviously any number of competitors would love to have be in that position.
2:22:59The question then becomes, like, the IP, like, what could he reasonably do at another company if he's not doing exactly what Apple has been doing?
2:23:10Like, does his level of expertise in the way that he's made the A-level chips and the M-series chips, does that translate to doing a slightly different?
2:23:19And maybe it does because they're ARM sort of variants, right?
2:23:22And so, like, maybe there is a world in which he can do that elsewhere.
2:23:25Where, though?
2:23:26Qualcomm?
2:23:27I don't know.
2:23:28Qualcomm, isn't it Qualcomm who poached, they make Snapdragon, and they poached a lot of Apple talent with big, big money?
2:23:34And no surprise, their chips have gotten better and have kind of closed the performance gap with A-series chips.
2:23:43But what would Johnny Suruji go in there?
2:23:45It's not like he's got all these chips in his head.
2:23:47Like, he leaves and he's got the M5 Max chip in his head and can take it and say, now we've got an M5 Max.
2:23:56I mean, I think the reality is what any of these people, the only real option for them to do is not to go, it's like, why do you go to another big company to make, you're already making a zillion, as much money as you can as, like, an executive at these big companies.
2:24:09I think the only answer is they might be tempted to go down the startup path.
2:24:13It's hard to think about.
2:24:16I know.
2:24:16It's hard to think about.
2:24:17But still, like, there's a world in which you could be a co-founder, say, like the technical co-founder of a startup that on paper, given the talent that you have around the table, would be able to raise X billions of dollars at an X billion valuation.
2:24:32And then all of a sudden, your comp, which is tens of millions to hundreds of millions of dollars, is equity that could, on paper, be valued at billions of dollars.
2:24:40I'm just making an argument.
2:24:41That's like the one scenario you could see.
2:24:44I'm just saying, too, I'll go back to Forstall.
2:24:46Forstall was, I think, only in his 40s when he got run out of Apple in 2011.
2:24:51And he's never come back to tech.
2:24:54There just aren't places to go after.
2:24:56When you reach the pinnacle at Apple, there's nowhere else to go but down.
2:25:01And other than a startup, a true – because then you're not even trying to compete.
2:25:05But I really – I don't see anywhere else that Tsurugi could go.
2:25:09If he goes to Qualcomm, he's going to make – what?
2:25:11He's going to leave Apple to go to a company to make the chips that are getting their ass kicked by Apple's chips every year.
2:25:16I think there is a world in which he would do a chip startup.
2:25:19Look at what those are getting acquired for right now.
2:25:21Right.
2:25:21And his level of expertise, not necessarily around –
2:25:25But that wasn't the rumor, though.
2:25:26The rumor that Gurman reported was that he would leave for a competitor.
2:25:29And the only competitor that you could say actually beats Apple in chips in any way right now is NVIDIA.
2:25:36But it's a totally different – Apple makes chips that NVIDIA doesn't make and NVIDIA makes chips that Apple doesn't make.
2:25:43But there are rumors that NVIDIA wants to do more CPUs.
2:25:48They do some of their own already, but they want to do more general purpose.
2:25:50I don't see them hiring somebody from Apple given the history between the companies.
2:25:54But on the other hand, the chief design guy went to Meta.
2:25:58I think somebody going to Meta is more surprising than somebody from Apple going to NVIDIA, but it's about the same level.
2:26:06I just don't see it.
2:26:08I think at age 61, he's riding this out.
2:26:10So the other way of looking at this promotion and timing it to the announcement of Ternus and Cook –
2:26:20And it is funny, Ben Thompson and I talked about this on Dithering, where the news from Apple hit the wires at 4.30 p.m. on last Monday.
2:26:30And Apple's newsroom post didn't go up until 4.40 or so.
2:26:34But in between – so it was out there, and people suddenly started tweeting about it because it was on the PR Newswire, whatever the service is called.
2:26:41And it's like, is this true?
2:26:43And I was reloading Apple's newsroom page, and the first story to come up was Johnny Saruji named chief hardware officer.
2:26:52And it's, what?
2:26:53That's the news?
2:26:54Oh.
2:26:55And that's the only story.
2:26:57Yeah, and then you look at the story, and the story says – has a quote from Tim Cook, Apple's CEO.
2:27:02And it's, Johnny's been great and whatever.
2:27:04He's awesome.
2:27:04And then the next paragraph has a quote from Ternus.
2:27:07And it says, Ternus, Apple's incoming CEO, says that –
2:27:12And it's like, wait.
2:27:13That would be an amazing way to announce.
2:27:14We're like, this is how they announce it.
2:27:16And then like one minute later, the other story came up.
2:27:18And I think they released the one a minute ahead of the other so that the other one would be at the top of the page.
2:27:23Right, right.
2:27:24But there was this one-minute period where it seemed like the way they were announcing it was with a quote in the second paragraph.
2:27:30It was so weird.
2:27:31It is weird that they announced them at the exact same time.
2:27:34Exact same time.
2:27:35So –
2:27:36Why?
2:27:36Why do you think they did that?
2:27:37If it's not for ego reasons for Johnny Saruji?
2:27:43It could be a little.
2:27:44It could just be a pat on the back.
2:27:46It could be that this is sort of like a Phil Schiller to Apple Fellow moment for Saruji.
2:27:54Phil Schiller is not like on a beach sipping Corona.
2:27:59Despite what that name sort of suggests, it sounds like a Tolkien that's like out in the fields having fun.
2:28:06Since stepping down as senior vice president of product marketing and Jaws, his longtime right-hand man, taking over, Phil still runs the App Store, which has become ever more complicated.
2:28:18And it's ever more complicated now in this moment of vibe-goating.
2:28:21And he runs all of Apple's events, all of the keynote movies and the actual on-press events and stuff like that.
2:28:28Phil Schiller still runs.
2:28:30It is a full-time job.
2:28:32It's not as full-time as it was when he was senior vice president.
2:28:35I think he – because he was doing those things then, too.
2:28:37But this could be – and it's been – I forget what year that was.
2:28:41I think it was like 2020.
2:28:42It was a long time ago.
2:28:432019.
2:28:44Yeah, he's still there.
2:28:46And this could be that type of moment for Tsuruji where you get a new title.
2:28:50Maybe some stuff will be off his direct plate.
2:28:55But it also opens up.
2:28:57It's a moment of a promotion.
2:28:59And it's a way of saying, hey, this guy, too, who was Ternus' peer and has done great things for Apple and I think gets along extremely well with Ternus, I think.
2:29:10Yeah, I think there were some reports that suggest that at least, yeah.
2:29:14And it would also jibe with announcing this at the same time.
2:29:17And Ternus is like, yeah, let's make him chief hardware officer.
2:29:20I love that.
2:29:21Like, I get it.
2:29:22You're still the CEO until September.
2:29:23But, yeah, let's do this.
2:29:25Then, come early September, September 1st, September 2nd, a week before the iPhone event, Ternus is named CEO on the first.
2:29:34And then on the second, what can Ternus do as his first action as CEO?
2:29:39He can name a new senior vice president of hardware and a new senior vice president of silicon.
2:29:46Ternus and Suruji can name him together, you know, that there's got to name two new senior vice presidents, one for chips, one for hardware to replace.
2:29:56Because that's Ternus' title until September 1st is still senior vice president of hardware.
2:30:01And the first action Tim Cook took as CEO was promoting Eddie Q from I forget his old title to a senior vice president of whatever his title was at the time.
2:30:11But now it's services.
2:30:12Eddie Q was a big deal at Apple.
2:30:15And Steve Jobs, by multiple reports of this, would take Eddie with him into negotiating rooms.
2:30:21Steve Jobs liked Eddie Q so much that as good a negotiator is...
2:30:26Especially on the media stuff.
2:30:27Yeah, yeah, yeah.
2:30:27Well, no, not just media stuff.
2:30:29Like Intel, like when they went in and were like, like Eddie Q was in the room when they went in and said, okay, we'll do this.
2:30:36But here's our terms for switching the Mac to Intel chips.
2:30:40Eddie Q was in the room with Steve Jobs.
2:30:42Well, he was his chief of staff at one point or something.
2:30:45I forget.
2:30:46He was very close to Steve and always very close to Tim.
2:30:50But he didn't have a senior vice president title.
2:30:52Didn't have his face.
2:30:54We knew him.
2:30:54Until Cook came in.
2:30:55Until Cook came in.
2:30:56And it's a great thing to leave for a new CEO to do as their first action is to name...
2:31:02It's like a cabinet bringing in...
2:31:05Yeah, yeah, yeah.
2:31:06So promoting Johnny Surugi to see chief hardware officer, you're just putting a new title on a picture that's already on this leadership page.
2:31:16What's left for Ternus on September 2nd or 1st or whatever day is to add one or two new pictures to that page.
2:31:25And, like, how much does it matter for Apple...
2:31:30Because this came in with Johnny Ive, too.
2:31:32Like, there is a difference, obviously, between SVP, which is still the upper echelon and the leadership team, versus C-suite, right?
2:31:38Like, the chief fill-in-the-blank.
2:31:40And so, Surugi is now on C-suite level, technically, with his new title, whereas he was SVP before.
2:31:47So, in your scenario, I assume there's something to that.
2:31:51And it's also interesting that they didn't give him, though, the more obvious CTO role.
2:31:56No.
2:31:56Because that sort of implies something that...
2:31:59It depends.
2:32:00It's different at every company, but it's interesting that they didn't do that.
2:32:03Well, CTO would be all technology, and that would imply that Federighi reports to him, and he doesn't.
2:32:08Okay, that's good, yeah.
2:32:09Right?
2:32:10It's just hardware.
2:32:11And I think in the way that chief design officer was a one-time title for Johnny Ive, I think chief hardware officer is a one-time title for Surugi for as many years as he has left.
2:32:22And it could be two or three years or something, and then we'll be like, oh, he was on his way out.
2:32:26Could be five, six, seven years.
2:32:28He is 61.
2:32:29It could be 10 years.
2:32:30I don't know.
2:32:31Maybe he'll be here until he's 70 years old.
2:32:33I don't know.
2:32:33But I think it's only for him, and when Surugi leaves, there's no new chief hardware officer.
2:32:39It just goes back to a chief hardware, or a senior vice president of hardware.
2:32:43SVP of, yeah, yeah.
2:32:44Yeah.
2:32:45And Surugi does have a lieutenant, I think, right?
2:32:47Yeah.
2:32:48Like, there's someone.
2:32:48Well, he's got a bunch.
2:32:49He is.
2:32:49It's a very large.
2:32:51There are a lot of people in that division, and he is the face of it, so he's the one who gets the keynote time when they talk about new silicon and new M-series chips.
2:32:59And he does have a very fun on-camera persona, that sort of stern, almost military style.
2:33:08Like, he seems a little scary.
2:33:09It adds a different-
2:33:10The ship is going to kick your ass.
2:33:11Did he come from PA Semi?
2:33:13Yes, he did.
2:33:14Yep.
2:33:14Okay.
2:33:15Yeah.
2:33:15And just like with Federighi, that's the thing.
2:33:18Apple's silicon is Surugi's life's work.
2:33:22It really is.
2:33:23And it is wholly integrated to within Apple now.
2:33:27It is inseparable from Apple's, any of, all of Apple's future plans.
2:33:32But it is his life's work.
2:33:34That's what makes it impossible for me to imagine doing anything but doing this until he retires.
2:33:39Whether he's retiring soon or far in the future, this is his life's work, and it is still an ongoing concern.
2:33:46For sure.
2:33:47There is as much work to do as there ever was.
2:33:50And because, remember, it's not just the CPUs.
2:33:53Like, it's all of these other tangential chips that Apple has been doing.
2:33:57The different series chips, and there's the ongoing rumors, whispers, that they are continuing to work on their own infrastructure to potentially do more AI work, like in servers.
2:34:11Just not necessarily going head-to-head, again, with what NVIDIA is doing.
2:34:15But in some ways, you know, perhaps doing that.
2:34:18And that would obviously be his purview as well.
2:34:21Yeah, exactly.
2:34:21So I want to get this clear.
2:34:23I've got the senior leadership page up right now, and Saruji's title, still, it actually hasn't been updated, which is a little surprising.
2:34:31Because I don't know if they said that that was effective September 1st.
2:34:33Are they waiting until September 1st or something?
2:34:35I don't know.
2:34:36But his current title on the page is, and I'm glad they haven't changed it so I can get it right, Senior Vice President Hardware Technologies, and Ternus is Senior Vice President Hardware Engineering.
2:34:46And again, you know, how much is in the title and how much is the person, right?
2:34:50It's more of the people than the title.
2:34:53Like, the next Senior Vice President of Hardware Engineering is not going to have Ternus' future ahead of him, because Ternus only spent a few years with the title before becoming CEO.
2:35:04And presumably, the next person to be named Senior Vice President of Hardware Engineering is not going to be the CEO in three years, hopefully.
2:35:10Something bad has happened.
2:35:12Very bad has happened.
2:35:13Yeah.
2:35:13Right.
2:35:14That's the way I see it.
2:35:15I do not see this as there was any sort of threat.
2:35:18I don't, A, I don't think Suruji, I don't think there's anywhere he could go.
2:35:22And B, I do not, even more so, there is no way Tim Cook would respond to a threat from somebody who is replaceable.
2:35:30Johnny Suruji is very important, but he is definitely not an irreplaceable man.
2:35:34No way.
2:35:35Again, I think that there's a way to sort of have both sides be somewhat correct in this.
2:35:41Yeah, and that he has an ego.
2:35:43There was something to the timing of it.
2:35:43Yeah.
2:35:44And I think doing it now, it's a very big feather in his cap, that it's a way of making the promotion carry a little more weight.
2:35:53Where Apple is saying, this is so important to give him the new chief hardware officer title, that we're doing it on the same day that we're announcing this other thing.
2:36:00That is how important Johnny Suruji's contributions to the company are and will be in the future.
2:36:05And thank you, Johnny.
2:36:07And Ternus can say, and I love him, and we work great together, and we have great things ahead.
2:36:12For some reason, this popped into my head earlier when I was writing.
2:36:14Is he sort of the biggest technical rock star left at Apple now, do you think?
2:36:20Because everyone has their own areas of expertise.
2:36:24But from a pure technical perspective, I would imagine that he's the most impressive technical resume and what he's done with those chips that Apple has.
2:36:33Maybe, you know, and I guess if Vision Pro has a brighter future ahead, Rockwell, maybe.
2:36:41But probably Rockwell's picture isn't even on that page.
2:36:43So, I mean, again, he's very important, but.
2:36:45You saw this.
2:36:46This was more, I guess it was this week.
2:36:48Gurman had a new report that Rockwell is potentially unhappy.
2:36:52Yeah, I saw that.
2:36:53I don't know what to make of that.
2:36:54And I've got nothing, so I don't know what to doubt about it.
2:36:57And it's one of those things where we'll either see it play out, and you could say, oh, there's one that Gurman got right.
2:37:03Or it won't.
2:37:05But I feel like that doesn't happen.
2:37:08If he is still here in five years or a couple of years, then I could say we could say Gurman was wrong, not that something's changed.
2:37:14Because something like that doesn't leak if it's not true.
2:37:19He framed it that, A, anything wouldn't happen anytime soon, that he's going to see through his work with Federighi on AI to get that shipped out the door, but that it could be a next year thing.
2:37:28But also that potentially he was perturbed that he thought that maybe he was on a path to CTO-type role if the Vision Pro had worked out and all of that stuff.
2:37:41But again, this all speaks to just there's going to be an immense amount of sort of natural turnover when Ternus sort of takes the helm because of age-related stuff.
2:37:52And some of it is not necessarily going to happen immediately.
2:37:54But within the next few years, there's just going to be naturally a lot of turnover.
2:37:59And on that, people just always leave when new people come in.
2:38:02It just is what happens.
2:38:03I wonder, though, who's going to leave.
2:38:05I mean, and again, Jaws is a little close to retirement age, but he's not.
2:38:10So I don't know that Apple is such a weird and unique company.
2:38:14Not weird, but unique.
2:38:15But it does make them weird.
2:38:17I wouldn't be surprised if there are no departures, that they've all been announced.
2:38:21Federighi, I definitely don't think is going anywhere.
2:38:23I mean, let's look at the senior leadership page.
2:38:25Phil Schiller eventually, I guess, will step down as Apple fellow and seed those things.
2:38:30I don't know anything about that.
2:38:31But Kavan, the chief financial officer, who cares?
2:38:35He just got elevated.
2:38:36He just got elevated.
2:38:37Deirdre O'Brien, you know.
2:38:40She's been talked about potentially retiring.
2:38:42Yeah, yeah.
2:38:42But is that really central to, I mean, she's done a good job running retail.
2:38:46Is that really going to, does anybody really, can anybody just off the top of their head say when Angela Arntz left and when Deirdre O'Brien took over?
2:38:55I almost totally forgot about that.
2:38:57Right.
2:38:57Yeah.
2:38:58Yeah, I don't see it.
2:38:59Speaking about fashion background and stuff.
2:39:01Right.
2:39:01Kavan, I think, it's very telling that he's, I think he's probably got a long runway ahead of him as COO.
2:39:10And by all accounts, Tim Cook loves him and operations are as good as ever.
2:39:13But there's a reason why he's never been in a keynote, right?
2:39:16He's a true operations guy.
2:39:19Who's going to leave?
2:39:21Jaws?
2:39:21I don't know.
2:39:22I don't see Jaws wanting to leave.
2:39:25And he's not that old.
2:39:25Federighi's not going anywhere.
2:39:27And Eddie Q.
2:39:28That's it.
2:39:28So who's going to leave?
2:39:29They're all going to retire eventually, but I don't know that any of them want to retire.
2:39:35One thing I was going to ask you, we talked about the 75-year thing with board members, but Apple doesn't have a rule, right, in terms of forced retirement.
2:39:43And Microsoft famously now is doing this buyout thing, right, to try to get people to sort of retire.
2:39:49But people, like, how long do people reasonably stay at Apple?
2:39:54I guess there's people like Chris Espinoza and stuff, because he started so young.
2:39:58He's still in his 60s, right?
2:39:59But there's no one in their 70s.
2:40:01Do people stay?
2:40:01We don't know.
2:40:03We've never gotten here before.
2:40:05You know?
2:40:06Yeah, I guess there's no...
2:40:07Of being a 40, 50-year-old company.
2:40:09Right.
2:40:10You don't...
2:40:11Yeah, that's exactly it.
2:40:12And that is the...
2:40:13One of the advantages is being a 50-year-old company that was founded by people who were so young, is that it was...
2:40:20It's remarkable how many of them are still around now to remember it, which is great.
2:40:25But the other aspect of it is we've never...
2:40:28Who else has aged out, right?
2:40:30There aren't that many people.
2:40:32It says Phil Schiller was born in 1960, so he's...
2:40:3666.
2:40:3766, yeah.
2:40:38Yeah.
2:40:39So I don't even know...
2:40:40I don't even think Phil's going anywhere.
2:40:41I doubt it.
2:40:43People work later and later, so...
2:40:46Yeah.
2:40:46So I think this idea that, hey, come September and October, or maybe after the stuff gets, you know, October, maybe new Macs get announced, that by the end of the year, like December this year, when they showed Gian Andrea the door and a couple other people retired, right?
2:40:59What's her name who was in charge of the environmental stuff?
2:41:01Lisa Jackson.
2:41:02A couple other people had planned retirements that just unfortunately retired the same week.
2:41:07that Alan Dye jumped ship.
2:41:09It could happen that some of the...
2:41:12But I would be...
2:41:12I would actually be more surprised than not.
2:41:15I think that it'll be a couple of years into Ternus' run as CEO before we start seeing some of these people retire.
2:41:22I don't think Eddie Q or Jaws or Phil or certainly not Federighi are going anywhere.
2:41:27The fact that Ternus has been there for 25 years, half of his life, which is incredible, just speaks to, like, he doesn't necessarily have, quote-unquote, his guys, because his guys are the people who are there.
2:41:39Yeah.
2:41:40His guys are Tim Cook's guys.
2:41:41They've all been working together for two decades plus.
2:41:44Yeah.
2:41:45So, I guess I think we'll see.
2:41:47So, I don't think it'll happen right away, and I think the telltale sign will be in the keynotes.
2:41:51If and when we start seeing more younger people take more time away from people whose faces we're familiar with.
2:41:58And until then, I don't think it'll happen.
2:42:02What is, I know we're running on, coming up on three hours here, just really quick, who takes over design mantel now?
2:42:09I guess they have the people in place, but they haven't, but they sort of have bifurcated it, right?
2:42:13Yeah.
2:42:14Well, it has been.
2:42:15Dai was only ever in charge of software, and I forget the guy's name is essentially in charge of hardware.
2:42:20The question is, under Ternus, do they kind of make faces out of the people in charge of design again?
2:42:26Yeah.
2:42:27Right?
2:42:27Or do they see it as a mistake that they gave Alan Dai FaceTime in the keynotes?
2:42:32And let him jump?
2:42:33Or do they elevate somebody?
2:42:35I don't know.
2:42:35And the other kid, young guy who left and went to a startup, remember?
2:42:40Yeah, a bunch of people did.
2:42:41An awful lot of talent went with Johnny Ive to look from an IO.
2:42:45But it's no surprise, there's an awful lot of designers who were still there and who worked under Johnny Ive.
2:42:52So, that's a thing to watch, definitely.
2:42:55What the story is with design and how much face time those people get in keynotes.
2:43:01And the one last thing I wanted to ask you, because this is what I sort of focused on in writing today.
2:43:08How do you think Ternus will do as the actual emcee of these events when he picks up the iPhone?
2:43:15Obviously, he's done it a few times.
2:43:17We've done it on MacBook Neo.
2:43:18I think he'll do great, but I do think the format will stay the same, which he'll just take over as Tim Cook as the guy in front of the press who announces the movie that's the real announcement.
2:43:29And I think all the, hey, maybe it's Tim Cook who wanted to make movies and not have live events is way too simplistic.
2:43:36And everybody at Apple is fully aware and they have the nostalgia for the live events and they know exactly what we're all talking about when we say we miss them and they miss them too.
2:43:46But if we're talking to people involved, the list of pros and the list of cons is heavily in favor in Apple's perspective to the way they've started doing it in the COVID era.
2:43:57And I don't think there's anybody in the company who disagrees with it.
2:44:01So I think he'll just take over the good morning.
2:44:03He'll just need his own catchphrase.
2:44:06Let her roll.
2:44:07Yeah.
2:44:08But I don't even think there's any question about it.
2:44:12But who knows?
2:44:13They did a neat thing with the Neo.
2:44:15Yeah, yeah, yeah.
2:44:16He did live there.
2:44:18I have the sneaking suspicion based on nothing that they're going to try to bring back the energy, at least for the iPhone event,
2:44:25to have him sort of come out for a first thing.
2:44:28You don't think so?
2:44:28No.
2:44:29We'll see.
2:44:30I think they'll have him come out, but the people out in the world don't see it.
2:44:34Like, I'll be there, hopefully, knock on wood, in the Steve Jobs Theater, and he will come out on stage.
2:44:39But Tim Cook has always come out on stage and said something.
2:44:42And then he says, now here's the show.
2:44:45Thanks for coming.
2:44:46Yeah, but they have the technology to stream that live now.
2:44:49They can do it.
2:44:49They can do it.
2:44:50Keep your fingers crossed.
2:44:52I hope you're right.
2:44:54I would be very excited to be in the room for that, but I would bet very large that it's not even being discussed.
2:44:59We'll see.
2:45:01We'll see.
2:45:02And I think he would do fine, and I think that it would be a good way to introduce other people.
2:45:07But trust me, I've talked about this, and the list of pros from Apple's perspective in the new format is so overwhelming that it's not even a close call for them.
2:45:18So don't get your hopes up.
2:45:21It's smaller things like the Neo, not the iPhone.
2:45:24The iPhone is going to be a prerecorded keynote.
2:45:27More things like the Neo rollout, though?
2:45:29I could see them doing that.
2:45:31And guess what?
2:45:31It was Ternus who took the stage and spoke for five or ten minutes.
2:45:35Yeah, if they could do smaller events all around the world, which he's been doing for a while, right?
2:45:38He was doing, even a few years ago, he was doing the Halloween events and all that sort of stuff.
2:45:43Yeah.
2:45:43All right, MG.
2:45:45I knew it was good having you here, and the fact that we've almost made it to three hours shows it.
2:45:49Before I let you go, I want to forget.
2:45:51I want to pimp your stuff.
2:45:53You're writing your column in your newsletter at spyglass.org, which is, to me, you have found your voice.
2:46:02I don't know.
2:46:03You've tightened it up.
2:46:04Thank you.
2:46:05You're killing it there.
2:46:06And then once a month, you're on the big technology podcast with Alex Kantrowitz.
2:46:10I was on, I'll put a link in the show notes.
2:46:12I was on in February 2024, but I think I was on before YouTube.
2:46:16Really?
2:46:17I think.
2:46:18Yeah.
2:46:18Because the link I have only goes to Apple Podcasts, but it's wherever you can find your podcast.
2:46:23But the YouTube, I'll put a link to the YouTube version of that, which is very good.
2:46:28And you guys still haven't talked about this, so hopefully I haven't gotten you to see.
2:46:32No, yeah, we do it the first Monday of every month.
2:46:34So we're coming up.
2:46:35It'll be on Monday, though.
2:46:36Yeah.
2:46:36Coming right up.
2:46:37We'll talk about it.
2:46:37Anything else you want to mention?
2:46:39No.
2:46:40It was great to see you, John.
2:46:41Great to chat, as always.
2:46:43And yeah, we'll do it again.
2:46:44All right.
2:46:45Next time, there's a CEO change.