0:00:00Stephen Hackett, you talked me through, I don't even know how to describe it. I just want to dive right into it. You talked me through something crazy, sort of, and I don't know. Do you have the impression that you, it was like, I didn't even do anything.
0:00:14A little bit. Yeah. So you texted me dealing with this Apple account issue that like, you can't set it up a little bit. A lot of people I think are in the boat that you and I found ourselves in. We had an Apple ID from back in the day they were using for, mine was like from iTunes.
0:00:30Purchases, like buying music, emo music in 2004 to put on my iPod. But that's not the Apple account I use for my iCloud stuff for various reasons. And that just opens a whole world of hurt.
0:00:46It's so complicated that it is even hard to state the problem as opposed to describe what I think is the solution. But it's basically for the people with the dual accounts that which you said, well, where your iCloud ID, aka your primary Apple account.
0:01:06And I actually, in this case, it's actually ever so slightly more difficult to talk about with the new lingo of Apple accounts, as opposed to Apple IDs.
0:01:16So if I say Apple ID, you know what I mean, because it's a little bit easier to talk, think of them as IDs. But anyway, I've got a Mac.com Apple ID. This is my iCloud life.
0:01:28This is where I get mail there. All my iCloud storage is there. It is part of a family with my wife and my son.
0:01:35But my media and purchases account is secondary. And that's an at daring fireball address for reasons I don't even remember.
0:01:47But I know that it started when I started buying music on iTunes.
0:01:51We were all so innocent back then, right? And the system was so simple, right? It's like, buy music, wrap it in, was it Fairplay was their DRM?
0:01:59Yeah, yeah.
0:01:59And put it on the iPod.
0:02:00Yeah.
0:02:00That's all it had to do in the beginning.
0:02:02Yeah. And I didn't give much thought to, I have no recollection of why I decided to use my main daringfireball.net address as that address.
0:02:15And I guess, I think, at some point, it doesn't even matter at this point, but I think I already had my Mac.com address, but I didn't really use Mac.com for anything.
0:02:26I just, like, wanted the domain or the username, and it felt like a good thing to have, but I didn't want to use it for much, and so I didn't think to use it for the iTunes purchases.
0:02:40And at the time, it just was like, you just need an email address for iTunes purchases. That's it.
0:02:45It wasn't really about having an account, and there was no idea that...
0:02:50Now, fast forward 25 years to now, and I literally have, I know this sounds ridiculous, but I've got, like, thousands of dollars of movies purchased.
0:03:04What, 50 movies times, let's say, $15 each, 750 bucks. Yeah. And I've bought hundreds of movies, because, as I often say, money runs through my hands like water.
0:03:14But instead of renting a movie, I usually buy it from iTunes, or they don't even call it iTunes anymore.
0:03:21Because if I think, if I possibly maybe want to watch it twice, then it's already roughly the same as two rentals, and the rental thing...
0:03:30How many times have you, like, rented a movie?
0:03:32I know Dan Benjamin and I used to talk about it back in the day when we had little kids, when it was a 24-hour period.
0:03:38And I think that now the rental period is, like, 48 or something.
0:03:42It's not 24.
0:03:43But yeah, when your kids are small, it's like, oh, they want to watch it again.
0:03:47It's like, how many times can we watch this Pixar movie in 24 hours?
0:03:52Right. Or just buy it.
0:03:53Or just buy it.
0:03:53Or your parents, and you fall asleep, and you don't finish it.
0:03:56But then by the time it's the next 24 hours later, and the kids are put to bed, and you can start it again, it's, like, oh, too late.
0:04:03Because maybe you started it at 9 o'clock on Monday, and then on Tuesday, you want to watch the second half of the movie, and it's 9.01 when you hit play, and it's like, sorry, it's expired.
0:04:15Too bad.
0:04:15Right.
0:04:16And I guess the 24 hours thing isn't a problem anymore, but I ended up buying a lot of movies.
0:04:22And I don't regret it, but now I've got thousands of dollars worth of movies tied to that account.
0:04:28There is, we should preface it for people who are like, well, isn't there a thing that Apple announced, like, a year ago where you can merge the two accounts?
0:04:37And I guess I should step back a little further, where for years, for anybody out there who does not have to deal with it, hopefully we can make this interesting to listen to.
0:04:48But if you've just got one Apple ID that you use for everything, for iCloud and for purchases, you are in good shape.
0:04:56Yeah.
0:04:57And if you don't, forever, ever since these multiple systems have evolved over the years, Apple has always more or less supported it.
0:05:10And the support has become better in recent years.
0:05:15Putting aside the merging accounts thing, it's when you're setting up a new device, and it says, what's your Apple account?
0:05:22And you put in your Mac.com and then there's a button now that says, like, do you have a separate, it's small print because most people don't have it.
0:05:30They don't want to draw attention to it.
0:05:31But there is a way to say, I have a separate account for media and purchases.
0:05:36And then you can enter a different account for that, and then your new device is set up right out of the box, and your media and purchases go to your secondary account, which is for media and purchases, and your iCloud and everything else goes to your primary account.
0:05:53And it used to be like 10 to 15 years ago, you would have to set it up with a primary account first and then go into the settings app and poke around until you found the media and purchases thing and sign out.
0:06:07And there were always, for a multiple number of years, some weird things that would make the wrong assumption.
0:06:14I think my game center, my, I'm not even a big game center user, so I don't really care even that much.
0:06:20But I think for a number of years, I want my game center ID to be that secondary account, the one that's at daringfireball.net, because that's where most of the people who I would play games with would know me from.
0:06:35But it would default to just guessing it was my Mac.com address.
0:06:40Yeah, it's like that team, no one on that team had the problem we had of multiple Apple accounts, right?
0:06:46Just use the system one.
0:06:48But yeah, I do wonder at what point this became clear to Apple that they needed a solution.
0:06:53And so, like you said, a few years ago, they rolled out a thing where you can optionally migrate purchases from one account to another.
0:07:01And the fine print in that support document is just unbelievable.
0:07:07I mean, I'm sure I've signed contracts with less text, right?
0:07:10You have to jump through all these hoops and the accounts have to be in exactly the correct state, and then you can hit the migrate purchase button.
0:07:18And I remember when that rolled out, it's like, great, I can solve my problem.
0:07:23And best I could tell, I fit all the criteria and I hit the button and just nothing, right?
0:07:30It kind of just fails, not a lot of feedback.
0:07:33And it's frustrating.
0:07:34You're right.
0:07:35Apple has downplayed the sort of dual account thing.
0:07:38It's still there.
0:07:38It still works.
0:07:39But you do run into edge cases.
0:07:41And I think that's just going to continue to sort of degrade over time, right?
0:07:45I know that I have talked about this on previous episodes of the show.
0:07:49I have no recollection with whom.
0:07:50Could have been you even.
0:07:52I don't know.
0:07:53It's probably like somebody who's similarly long on the platform.
0:07:58Snell or Glenn Fleischman or somebody.
0:08:01I don't know.
0:08:01But I know I've talked about it, and I actually almost can state this as a fact, not just as a guess, that part of the saving grace that this has always worked to some degree of ease.
0:08:14And in recent years, it really has been much easier, where if you know what you're doing when you're setting up a new device, everything just works.
0:08:22And it's been a couple of years.
0:08:24And, of course, the nature of my work with a bunch of review units every year, iPads, multiple phones, MacBooks, I set up more devices than almost anybody except people who also work at Apple.
0:08:37And there aren't those edge cases like, oh, Game Center goes to the wrong one sometimes or something like that.
0:08:42It just works for the most part now.
0:08:44Keeping the dual two different accounts, one for iCloud, one for purchases.
0:08:48And the saving grace behind that has been that it's a downstream effect of the fact that Apple employees, by and large, tend to stay at the company for a very long time.
0:09:04That it is not a company where whatever you do, but including engineers, that they don't really job hop through Apple as much as other companies.
0:09:16And there's an awful lot of people.
0:09:18And a lot of times when people do, even people who leave Apple often come back after five or six years.
0:09:26They'll go to another company and then they come back.
0:09:28Part of that's just how the career game works.
0:09:31You come back and all of a sudden, and Apple has stuff built.
0:09:34You get like your old ID number back.
0:09:36You don't get a new number.
0:09:38I think you get your old email address back.
0:09:40In most cases, it's like you never left or in some ways like you never left.
0:09:43Because of that, there are a lot of Apple people in the same situation as us because they were on the platform when iTunes came out, made similar decisions.
0:09:52And so there are more than you would think.
0:09:55It's certainly a higher percentage than in the general population of just users.
0:10:00There are Apple employees in the same boat.
0:10:03And therefore, there are a number of people probably to a very high level within the company who have to deal with this.
0:10:10So either engineers who are willing to work on it or be like managers up to executives who need it and who are like, hey, why the hell doesn't this work?
0:10:19I'm not, you know.
0:10:20Sure.
0:10:20So that's been the saving grace.
0:10:22What I worry about at this point is more and more is how many of those people are starting to retire out of the company because they're in their 60s, not their 40s or 50s.
0:10:35That could be a problem.
0:10:37But for the most part, it all has worked better over the years, not worse.
0:10:42It has gotten more officially supported, and the stuff from device to device has worked better.
0:10:50And it just kind of works.
0:10:51Once you have it set up, it is a little more complicated, but then it just works.
0:10:55And the way it worked with family sharing with iCloud was seamless, where I'm the one who buys most of the stuff.
0:11:02And like the Apple TV is set up to my media and purchasing account.
0:11:06So when my wife or son buys a movie, it goes through my account.
0:11:11Yeah, that's ours is too.
0:11:13And I can join my Mac.com identity is in the family, but because me, the person, in this way, the family is like the person, not the account.
0:11:25And me, the person has both the Mac.com identity and the at Daring Fireball media and purchases identity.
0:11:33And it all just works.
0:11:35Those things go to the family.
0:11:36Where this broke is with Apple One.
0:11:42Yeah.
0:11:43Yeah.
0:11:45This is where I hit the wall, too.
0:11:46Right.
0:11:47Which, I'm sure, Apple One on the surface is great, right?
0:11:50Sometimes I go into the UI where it's like, oh, I actually want to pay for these separately.
0:11:55And I always make a decision of like, it's cheaper for like the combo that I want.
0:12:00And like, who cares about the random stuff that I'm not using?
0:12:03But it does seem like one of those features that doesn't quite gel with the two identity system, and you get into storage, and it gets strange quick.
0:12:12Yeah.
0:12:12So, I just, and I, I was going to do this anyway, but after I got off the phone with you, and then I did some more work, which we will talk about, and I got it working.
0:12:24Where we haven't even gotten to what it is.
0:12:27And you were like, you screamed at me, write it down.
0:12:31Yeah.
0:12:33And I was like, even better, how about I have you on the show?
0:12:36And you're like, okay, but write it down.
0:12:38I have some notes here, but in my notes, this isn't even the problem, but I just did some math, which I haven't looked at recently.
0:12:45Apple One, with, and I have the Premiere whatever plan for family.
0:12:51It includes Apple Music, Apple TV, Apple Arcade, Apple News Plus, Apple Fitness, and two terabytes of iCloud shared storage.
0:13:01And Apple Music costs 17, and Apple does all of this monthly.
0:13:05I don't think you can get a yearly subscription to any of this stuff.
0:13:07Which is kind of interesting, but that's sort of a side discussion, why they don't want to charge annually.
0:13:13But Apple Music, 17, Apple TV is up to 13.
0:13:17Some of this stuff I hadn't really thought about, but remember when Apple TV was like five bucks?
0:13:22Yeah, Apple TV in particular has had several price increases.
0:13:26Some of the others I don't think I've seen quite the jump.
0:13:29Yeah.
0:13:29That's up to like normal.
0:13:32That's no longer like a discounted streaming service.
0:13:35I mean, Netflix is in a class by itself in all ways, but 13 bucks a month, that's like mid-range for those things.
0:13:43But with the benefit, I should say, it's still because it's ad-free, and there is just one tier, and you get the best quality.
0:13:51So it still is, it is a good value compared to the others, because it's a much higher, visibly higher video signal.
0:13:58It's just the compression artifacts are not as good.
0:14:01The sound is great.
0:14:02You don't have to, there's no nickel and diming over, oh, do you want SD or HD or high-quality streaming?
0:14:08You just pay 13 bucks a month, and there's no ads.
0:14:10Anyway, Apple Arcade, 7 bucks a month.
0:14:13Apple News Plus, 13 bucks a month.
0:14:15Apple Fitness, 10 bucks a month.
0:14:16So those things alone cost 60 bucks a month.
0:14:20Even though they're all weird numbers like 13 and 17 and 7, you add them all up, and it's a nice even 60 bucks a month.
0:14:26And I'm cutting off the .99s.
0:14:28Apple, or the 2 terabytes of iCloud storage on its own is 10 bucks a month, right?
0:14:36So that's, to buy them all individually would be 70 bucks a month with family sharing.
0:14:41Apple One includes all of those things, and it's 38 bucks a month.
0:14:47That is almost half price, right?
0:14:51That is a pretty good deal.
0:14:52And even if you say, well, I don't use Apple Arcade or Fitness.
0:14:56Like, of those items, those would be the first two I would probably drop.
0:15:00Although I think my son would immediately notice the Arcade.
0:15:03But even if you take off 17 bucks a month from Arcade and Fitness, you're still at $53 a month, which is still higher than Apple One at $38 a month.
0:15:15You'd have to drop a couple of them to make it even.
0:15:18And even then, it's even, right?
0:15:20So just Apple Music and TV is $30, and 10 for the 2 terabytes of storage gets you to $40.
0:15:28And that's two bucks more than Apple One at $38.
0:15:31So you could think of Apple One as giving you Arcade, News Plus, and Fitness for free.
0:15:37Pretty good deal.
0:15:39Yeah.
0:15:40That's exactly how I think about it, too.
0:15:42It's some of that stuff I never touch, but it's not hurting anything, and I'm saving some money, so be it.
0:15:48It's a very good deal if you were already going to be in for just, like, for me, and I can verify that the music thing, for me personally, the TV is essential.
0:15:58I'm always watching Apple TV programming.
0:16:00I will relay this story.
0:16:02I've learned that dropping Apple Music is instantly noticeable by my family members.
0:16:08Apple News Plus?
0:16:11I actually do.
0:16:13I easily get $13 a month of value out of that.
0:16:17For the Wall Street Journal alone, which comes with it.
0:16:21Right.
0:16:21Wall Street Journal alone is easily worth $13.
0:16:24But also now, the Washington Post, I unsubscribed.
0:16:28I was a longtime subscriber to the Washington Post and unsubscribed in a fit of peak back during the election.
0:16:35And I was like, you know what?
0:16:37It's not just about the Bezos editorial.
0:16:40We're not going to endorse Kamala Harris.
0:16:42It was like, you know what?
0:16:43This newspaper is going to shit anyway.
0:16:45But every once in a while, but they're paywalled, and every once in a while, there's an article I want to read, and I can just go from Safari to Apple News, and it opens right up without a paywall.
0:16:55There's a couple.
0:16:56There's a bunch that I usually get $13 a month out of there.
0:16:59So it's a good value.
0:17:00The problem is, with the family, is that we ran out of storage in December.
0:17:13On the surface of it, right, it's like, oh, we've got two terabytes, in your case, across three people.
0:17:18In my case, it's five.
0:17:20But it's like, it goes by so fast, especially once you have kids with iPhones, and it's game over.
0:17:25My son recently passed me.
0:17:28In between December and now, he's passed my iCloud footprint.
0:17:33I'm still a hair under one terabyte, personally, and he's just passed one terabyte.
0:17:40And then my wife is, I don't know, like 200 gigabytes or something like that.
0:17:44Let me just hold that right there.
0:17:47That seems like as good a spot as any for a cliffhanger around a sponsor, Reed.
0:17:54And I'm going to thank our good friends at Factor.
0:18:00Look, hunger strikes.
0:18:01You're tired.
0:18:02You're exhausted.
0:18:03There's something healthy.
0:18:04Ah, here we go.
0:18:06In your fridge and pantry that you should be making.
0:18:08But you just don't have it in you, right?
0:18:10Yeah.
0:18:11It's like, ugh.
0:18:12I don't have time.
0:18:13I'm too tired already.
0:18:14Factor solves this problem because Factor is a service.
0:18:18You sign up.
0:18:19You get some meals sent to you.
0:18:20They're fresh food but already prepared, not a meal kit with a bunch of ingredients that you
0:18:26have to put together, which is a great idea that those are great services that have sponsored
0:18:30this show in the past and that I have enjoyed very much for making, like, dinners or something
0:18:35like that.
0:18:36But Factor isn't like that.
0:18:37It is all packaged together, a single serving for one person, fresh.
0:18:43They ship to you like the meal kits with, like, dry ice in the package to keep everything
0:18:47cold and refrigerated.
0:18:48But you get a whole meal sent to you.
0:18:51You just put it in the microwave, heat it up in a couple of minutes, and it is ready to
0:18:56eat.
0:18:56It's almost impossible to think of a way that you could get a really good meal, hot meal,
0:19:00easier than just taking it out of the factory meal out of the fridge, putting it in a microwave
0:19:04and eating it.
0:19:05It is really great, really nutritious.
0:19:08They focus on high-quality ingredients, and they have so many options.
0:19:13Every week, they have a different menu to choose from, and they have a whole bunch of categories
0:19:18of food.
0:19:18It's overall stuff.
0:19:19Like, you can concentrate on stuff if you've got, like, goals in mind, like weight loss or
0:19:24just overall nutrition or increasing your protein.
0:19:27And specifically, you can pick out meals that are optimized for that.
0:19:31They've got even something called a Muscle Pro Collection for strength and workout recovery.
0:19:37All sorts of stuff like that if you have specific ingredients.
0:19:40Or you can just browse for ones that look tasty.
0:19:43And I have found, after selecting a lot of meals from Factor through their sponsorships of the
0:19:49show, that whatever sounds like it is going to be like, it is like that.
0:19:55They're very good at describing the meals, and everything kind of comes out the way you think
0:19:58it's going to be.
0:19:59They have bans on their list of over 175 ingredients, stuff that they will not allow in any of their
0:20:06meals, stuff like artificial colors and sweeteners, high fructose corn syrup.
0:20:10They don't use any refined seed oils, just nutrient-dense food.
0:20:14They really have a good story along that line.
0:20:16It's fresh, never frozen, over 100 rotating weekly meals, all sorts of flavors, all sorts
0:20:23of stuff to please anyone in your family, including kid-friendly, simple stuff.
0:20:27Everything's ready in two minutes.
0:20:29They shop, prep, and cook, and deliver straight to your door.
0:20:32It could not be easier.
0:20:34I use Factor.
0:20:35I really like it.
0:20:36I always am happy to have their stuff in the fridge, and it always goes quick.
0:20:40So where do you go to find out more?
0:20:42Head to factormeals.com slash talkshow50off, and the 50 is 5-0, and guess what that code
0:20:53gets you?
0:20:53It gets you 50% off your first purchase.
0:20:58Talkshow50off.
0:21:01You get 50% off, and free daily greens per box with a new subscription only while supplies
0:21:07last until September 27th, 2026.
0:21:11See website for more details.
0:21:13Head to factormeals.com slash talkshow50off, and use that code talkshow50off to get 50% off
0:21:19and free daily greens per box with new subscription only while supplies last until
0:21:25September 27th, 2026. See website for more details. All right. Where did I leave the cliffhanger?
0:21:32Apple one, right? All right. More storage. So December, we get up to 1.9 something terabytes
0:21:40out of two. And I had looked at this problem before and thought the answer was, well, I'm the
0:21:47family nerd, right? I take care of this. Maybe I don't do much as a family contributor, but I can
0:21:54keep all of our technology working. No surprise about a lot of people who listen to the show are
0:22:01in the same role in their family, right? The Wi-Fi doesn't work. Talk to daddy, right? I mean,
0:22:07it's me. That's my job. And I don't really want anybody else screwing with the Wi-Fi. So I'm happy
0:22:11to do it, right? Jump right on it if somebody sees a problem, right? We're out of collective iCloud
0:22:17storage. That's my problem. But I just figured I would go in and click around in settings or system
0:22:24settings on my Mac and buy some additional iCloud storage. And then that would be piled on top of
0:22:31our two terabytes from Apple one. Because the key thing to know is that there is no tier in Apple one
0:22:39above Apple one premier for $38 with all of the media features and app features and two terabytes
0:22:49of iCloud storage. There is no Apple one ultra with all of the media stuff and six terabytes of storage
0:22:57that Apple one as a thing tops out. There is a page. Let me look it up here. I have it here.
0:23:07There is a page on Apple's website. What happens to your iCloud storage when you sign up for Apple one?
0:23:16And when you sign up for Apple one, if you have less storage than the Apple one account tier you're
0:23:25signing up for, it just, it just gets canceled at the end of the month. So if you're only paying for
0:23:30200 gigabytes, but then you upgrade, you get a two terabyte family plan. They just cancel the 20 gigabyte
0:23:36plan. And there's an explanation for this. And for that, there's no explanation for what do you do if
0:23:41you have a separate media account. Right. But there is a part that says, if you belong to a family
0:23:48sharing group, if a family member subscribes to an Apple one family or premier plan, you can choose to
0:23:55keep your current iCloud plus plan or use the shared iCloud storage in Apple one. Now what that bullet point
0:24:04means is let's say my wife wanted to keep her own iCloud storage and she wanted to pay $10 a month
0:24:14and have her own two terabytes that isn't shared with me and our son. She can do that. And she can
0:24:21just say, I don't want to use the family storage. I want the other family privileges like a shared calendar
0:24:26and the access to my apps and the media that I purchased and stuff like that. But she would have
0:24:32her own iCloud plan for $10 a month. And any other member could do that, but then that's not shared.
0:24:40So she buys a $10 iCloud. It doesn't get pooled with the family thing that I'm in charge of and that my
0:24:48account has purchased the Apple one. It's her $10 a month and her two terabytes. And then me and my son
0:24:56would share the other two, the two terabyte shared account. If there's the second bullet point, if
0:25:02your family needs additional iCloud storage, shared storage is implied there, the family member who
0:25:09purchased Apple one can buy more iCloud storage with both Apple one and an iCloud plan, your family can
0:25:17share up to 14 terabytes of total iCloud storage. That's because Apple one comes with two terabytes
0:25:25and the most, the biggest iCloud standalone plan you can currently buy is a 12 terabyte month plan for
0:25:33$60 a month. So two plus 12 is 14, but the person or at night it, what did they say here?
0:25:41The family member who purchased it can buy more. Well, that works if you have a regular single iCloud
0:25:53ID, but it's not the family member, which to me, it says person who has to do this. It has to be the
0:26:02actual account. The actual ID, the actual separate login, right? The separate login has to purchase both.
0:26:11The problem with that is that all of the other ways that you and I have talked about it leading up to
0:26:17this point on the show, it works because those two worlds of purchases are sort of different. You buy
0:26:25iCloud with your iCloud ID and you buy apps and media and subscriptions to media, things like Apple
0:26:34fitness through your media and purchase account. Apple one crosses the two streams because it is a
0:26:41single bundle with both media stuff and iCloud storage. And what happened in December is when I
0:26:52tried to do this, I just started poking around and thinking, well, this must be easy. I probably read
0:26:59that same thing where it says the family member who purchased Apple one just needs to purchase more
0:27:04iCloud. And I thought, well, this is great. I don't even need to pay for the six terabyte plan that costs
0:27:11$30 a month. I just need to pay an extra $10 a month to get two more terabytes, right? To double us to
0:27:18four. And I did it. I purchased two terabytes of iCloud. And then it said our total is now two
0:27:28terabytes. And I spent an entire day doing nothing but looking into this and trying to figure out, well,
0:27:37why won't it add this? It says it's supposed to add it to the shared family pool. And all it was,
0:27:43was two terabytes. And the explanation is when I purchased two terabytes of iCloud, it's my
0:27:52Jay Gruber at mac.com account purchasing two terabytes of iCloud, not my at Gruber or Gruber
0:28:01at daringfireball.net address, which is my media account. But it's my media account that purchased
0:28:10Apple One. And it magically works that iCloud can be assigned to another address. There is a path
0:28:20that you can go through. Yeah, you can purchase iCloud storage and then apply it to another Apple
0:28:27account. It's linked at the bottom of the what happens if you have two accounts. Yes, you go to
0:28:32settings iCloud subscriptions, Apple One, and scroll down and click manage iCloud Plus. And what I see
0:28:40when I go to manage iCloud Plus is who do you want to give the the Apple One bundled two terabytes of
0:28:47storage to? And it lists my son, my wife, and two of me, one for each email address. And when it was
0:28:55assigned to my mac.com address, then it was it could be shared with the whole family. But that that it
0:29:03only applies to it still is purchased by that. And there's no way for that account to just buy more
0:29:08iCloud storage. When I buy iCloud storage, it's purchased by the other account. And then my account
0:29:14has access effectively, I think, to two different ways of having two terabytes of storage. The one I bought
0:29:21for $10 a month on its own, and the one that comes with Apple One, but there is no way to combine the
0:29:26two into two. So your family is still sort of partitioned off into that other storage bucket.
0:29:31So when your son takes one too many photos, and you tip over, the problem remains, right? And I can
0:29:39still because iCloud family sharing works, even without Apple One, I can share the other two terabytes.
0:29:46So we don't lose storage. And when I was using the iCloud storage I purchased, it didn't kick my wife
0:29:53and son out and send them back to five gigabytes of free storage. They still had two terabytes, but it
0:29:59didn't solve our problem that we were out of space. And I realized, I think, I guess, I don't know if they
0:30:06charged me or not. Again, money runs through my fingers like water. I didn't bother to look to see if
0:30:13this $10 that I'd spent and eventually canceled within 24 hours if I ever got charged for it. But
0:30:20I thought, why even bother doing this with, you know, I'm not going to pay for more. We don't need
0:30:27more. That would be a waste of money. I thought maybe the solution is I would just pay for the
0:30:31$30 a month for the six terabytes and share that. And maybe that would have worked. I don't know,
0:30:38but I didn't want to waste the money on it, right? There's a part of me that doesn't want to spend the
0:30:42money on it. And so I solved the problem in December, the very old fashioned way where I
0:30:48found, I don't know, a couple of hundred gigabytes of my stuff that I could delete. I deleted some old
0:30:55device backups. I didn't delete anything I care about. I didn't start doing the thing where like,
0:31:01I don't want to spend any more money. So I'm going to start throwing out photos. No, I didn't,
0:31:07but I cleaned up enough stuff that it dropped our usage down to like 1.8 terabytes. But there was a
0:31:14point, this is the point I alluded to earlier where I thought, well, maybe I need to purchase this
0:31:21from, Oh, I know what I should do is purchase Apple one from my iCloud account instead of from the media
0:31:30account. So I canceled the Apple one that we already had from my media account. And then using my primary
0:31:37account, I signed up for Apple one. And I thought, well, that'll solve it because either way we get all
0:31:44the media and all the iCloud, and then I can buy the two more terabytes of iCloud and then we'll have
0:31:50four, right? That sounds like a maybe, right? I don't think that seems unreasonable. Do you think,
0:31:54Stephen? No, it sounds like that should work. I think most people would assume that it would.
0:31:59Yes. And the reason it didn't work was because I still needed to have a media and purchases account
0:32:08because my media, that account purchased, as I said, thousands of dollars worth of movies,
0:32:14all of our subscriptions, all the apps, every app I've ever paid for, whether it's a subscription app
0:32:20or a one-time app through the Mac app store has gone through that account. So I still need the media
0:32:25and purchases. And when I purchased Apple one through that iCloud account, it only shares the
0:32:33purchases from your media and purchase account if you have one. So the media and purchases from Apple
0:32:39one no longer were shared with the family and they immediately lost access to Apple music. And of course,
0:32:46both of them were going to the gym, one in Boston in college and one here in Philadelphia,
0:32:51where I won't say who's, which one's which, but the one here in Philadelphia could give me an earful
0:32:58immediately upon returning home from the gym where she didn't have any music at all with no warning.
0:33:05And I was like, oh shit. So I can't do that. Yep. Hmm. So I canceled that Apple one subscription and
0:33:14resubscribed to Apple one from the other one and deleted 200 gigabytes or so of stuff that was easily
0:33:23deletable and thought I will solve this in the new year. That's future John's problem. Well, future John
0:33:31came about this week was when I noticed I'd been looking and it was like 1.9 of 2.0 terabytes,
0:33:381.9 of two. And I'm like still going. And this was the week where it got to 2.0 of 2.0 terabytes.
0:33:44And the little graph underneath wasn't all the way. And I don't know, there might be some panel
0:33:49somewhere where you could see the exact, how much space there is, but it was, I didn't want to get to
0:33:56that point. And so I started looking into it and long story short. And this is where I called you
0:34:03yesterday. The only way I could figure out how to solve this. And this is why I called you is the way
0:34:10you solved it. I think basically, and the way you solved it, I will hand this off to you is.
0:34:16Yeah. Adding the media account as a family member in the iCloud family, which does have some trade-offs.
0:34:25Like what if you don't have another slot? What if you have too many people in your family? You got to
0:34:29tell your youngest kid, sorry, you're on your own. That's rough.
0:34:32Or do you kick the youngest or the oldest out? Like the oldest.
0:34:35Maybe the oldest. Yeah. I guess it depends on how old they are, you know? So that's,
0:34:39that's not fantastic. You have the issue, you and I spoke about this is if they are both semi-public,
0:34:45how do you name them differently? So what I did, my, my media account, no one knew what that was.
0:34:51And so I renamed him Legacy Steven and he's in grayscale. He's just in my family, like a ghost
0:34:58of past purchases. The key here though, is to add it to the iCloud family and then turn on shared
0:35:05purchases. That way. Okay. Legacy Steven bought this app five years ago. I use it. And because
0:35:15it's shared within the family, I can use it signed in just as my regular iCloud account, but not
0:35:21everything works with shared purchases. It's actually up to the discretion of developers. If they want to
0:35:28say my app or my subscription, you can share within your family. And there's business models on both
0:35:34sides. I think it makes sense depending on what you're doing with your app. So I did end up having
0:35:38to repurchase a handful of things, but the thing that killed me about this is I don't, I mean, I didn't
0:35:46mind like a year ago. I don't think I came across that in writing anywhere from Apple. It was kind of a,
0:35:52I did all the things you did, jumped through all those hoops. I was like, you know what? I had a slot in
0:35:57my family, in my iCloud family. I was like, you know what? We're just going to adopt him and he
0:36:03will live forever as a third adult in our iCloud family.
0:36:06I searched the web and, you know, I think I'm pretty good at searching the web. I could not find
0:36:11anybody else who has encountered this. There was like a Reddit post from somebody in a way that Reddit
0:36:17often does show up very, is often like the only place where somebody's ever talked about this.
0:36:24I rented, I remember a couple of years ago, sometime in the last three years, I rented
0:36:30a Kia SUV for a road trip to take the kid to college or something. And honest to God,
0:36:38I could not figure out how to open the hatchback. I couldn't figure it out. And I'm like, I'm a grown
0:36:42man. And I look in the dashboard and of course it's a rental with no manual. I don't know. Usually
0:36:47they have the manual. I was like, I cannot figure this out. There's nothing on the fob. And I
0:36:53went in the house and searched on Reddit. And then there was one Reddit thread from somebody who was
0:36:58like, how the hell do you open the hatch on a Kia Sorento 2022 or whatever? And somebody was like,
0:37:05yeah, it's really weird. It's over here. And it's like, oh, holy shit. I would have never gotten that.
0:37:11And there was like one post on Reddit that alluded to this, but your post on 512 pixels was the only one
0:37:19I saw from somebody else that solved it this way. Yeah. Cause I even thought if I hadn't read your
0:37:27post, I, and I honestly don't know if I would have thought to try this because I kind of, and again,
0:37:34it's the way that I can be sort of too stubborn for my own good where I would have thought, well,
0:37:41that's not going to work. They're not going to let me add myself as a family member because I'm already,
0:37:48it's going to say, oh, you can't add Gruber at daring fireball.net as a family member because
0:37:55you're already using that account as your media and purchases account.
0:37:59Or I was afraid too. Oh, it has the same birthday. Right. Cause I did think for a second,
0:38:03I thought family knows about twins. Right. But it did work for me. And again, sharing those purchases.
0:38:12Imagine the cruel parents who named their twins, both John.
0:38:17Yeah. That's rough. Um, do you put a one and two on birth order? You know, it's very confusing.
0:38:24The share purchases work. And the beauty of it now is that I can add storage to my family and I'm signed
0:38:34in on all my devices with just one account. I now no longer have to jump through the hoop of the separate
0:38:40media account because if I go reach for something that old account bought, right? Like an app or a
0:38:46movie I bought or something because it's shared in the family, it just works. And I'll give Apple credit
0:38:53it here for sure. The family sharing of purchases is completely transparent. I mean, it's really,
0:39:00really good. Yeah. And it is something that is opt in. So if in your family, for whatever reason,
0:39:07whether it's you as one person or one other member of your family or your whole family is just sort of
0:39:12independently minded and you want your own purchases, but you want a shared calendar and shared
0:39:17storage space or something, you can do that, right? You can say, I don't want to share my purchases
0:39:24with the family. Um, but if you do want to share that, it just works. And Apple definitely encourages
0:39:31developers. I mean, it's up to developers whether to go along. I know you and I were talking about it.
0:39:36It seems like weather apps in particular often don't because they have a bunch of, and I think it's
0:39:44reasonable that weather apps have a surprising number of ongoing data processing costs that really does
0:39:52escalate with the number of people using it or number of devices effectively using it. And they can't
0:39:58charge you per device for yourself. So if you've got three iPhones because you review them or something,
0:40:05there's no way to charge you separately for it. But that's not unreasonable. There's other developers
0:40:10with other reasons, good or bad who don't enable family sharing, but it seems like most do. I can't
0:40:16remember the last time I've run into it. Yeah. I think weather apps is really the only category that
0:40:21comes to mind for me. And I like carrot weather. I believe what Brian does is there's a standard
0:40:27subscription and then there's a family subscription above that to help offset those ongoing costs because
0:40:35weather data is expensive. And if you're a Brian and you want 15 different weather services and carrot
0:40:40weather, I can't imagine what that must look like. And you know what? I think that's fair. But yeah,
0:40:46for the most part, it just works. And that means if I've purchased something and I'm going to go
0:40:52download that app on my kid's iPad later on, or they want to put it on their phone and I've already paid
0:40:57for it, or we already have a subscription to it, then that automatically gets applied to them.
0:41:02And it's just seamless. There's not like a button somewhere like, oh, enable family sharing on this
0:41:08one thing. It's just a blanket sort of allow statement across the accounts.
0:41:13Right. And that is very nice. But this is where it hits the... So you turn that on,
0:41:21you add the other account as an additional family member. And for me, at least, I didn't do it like
0:41:27you. It's not really a legacy account for me. I just have two Johns in the family now and explained
0:41:34it to the family. They don't really have to worry about it. Maybe because I only did it yesterday,
0:41:40I haven't thought through all the ways that they might. But when they text me, it's not like it's
0:41:46added a new option for who to send an iMessage to. It's still just me and it comes to me. And so
0:41:53it doesn't really affect them. And we don't, we're not anticipating adding family members at this point.
0:42:01So we only had three. You can have up to six, I think is six or five, six. I don't even know what
0:42:08the limit is. I think it's six. Yeah. So we're well below the limit. It just, it bothers me because
0:42:15it is an ungainly solution to the problem. But the additional part of this that I had to do that is
0:42:24still, to me, not obvious unless you really think about how this works, is the extra two terabytes of
0:42:30iCloud storage had to be purchased by my second account, the media and purchasing account. It has
0:42:39the same one that purchased, because that's that thing where the family member who purchased Apple
0:42:44one has to be the one to buy additional iCloud storage. But that's my media account, which I don't
0:42:51use for iCloud. And I even showed you a screenshot. So how do you buy iCloud storage from an account that
0:42:59you don't sign into iCloud on a device for? I don't even know. I actually looked, it's like when
0:43:04you go to their website, maybe if I should try it in Chrome, because when you go in Safari,
0:43:08and you go to purchase iCloud, it opens a link to settings or system settings, and it switches you
0:43:15out of the web into system settings, where I'm signed into my main iCloud account. And I don't want,
0:43:21I'm not going to sign out of iCloud and lose a terabyte of syncing to sign into a different account.
0:43:29So, well, I'm just... You could do a separate user on the Mac, maybe.
0:43:33Right. I thought of that. And that is probably what I would do if I were not me with 50 spare
0:43:41iPhones sitting around my desk. So what I did is take the iPhone 17e review unit, which I had wiped,
0:43:51but still hadn't sent back to Apple and signed into it. But I signed into it only using my secondary
0:43:57account, which logged me into iCloud for that account, maybe for the first time ever. And if not,
0:44:05the first time on purpose. And purchased two terabytes a month of storage and assigned it
0:44:13to the family somehow, there was something I clicked, and it was like the angels started singing,
0:44:20lo...
0:44:22That's right.
0:44:22And then all of a sudden, on all of my devices, I had four terabytes of shared storage in the family sharing.
0:44:28Yeah.
0:44:29But after adding that account as a fourth family member, two Johns now in the family,
0:44:35my main account still uses that account as the media and purchases account. And then the second
0:44:43instance of the account uses that ID for both iCloud and that. And I signed in on a spare iPhone
0:44:49and bought two terabytes of storage, and now it worked.
0:44:52And that's where we took slightly different paths where I was like, if I'm going through all of this,
0:44:58I would like just to have one login for everything. And so I purchased, I just pulled up my subscription
0:45:04tab. I purchased Apple One and my family's additional two terabytes as my iCloud account. So my media,
0:45:12that's why I named him Legacy Steven, like my media purchasing account is no longer active. That
0:45:18account hasn't purchased anything new since I jumped through all of these hoops. But it is good that
0:45:24both work because there are pros and cons to each. And certainly if family sharing wasn't as good as
0:45:32it is, or maybe you ran into something that you really needed to share and it couldn't for some
0:45:37reason, then yeah, it would be good to be able to use the other setup. But why I said write it down,
0:45:44I unpacked most of this on Connected, and then I wrote some about it. But as soon as you do it,
0:45:49it feels so complicated to explain. And it feels like there's so many edge cases. Like when you and
0:45:57I were talking yesterday, I was kind of Googling in the background too. I came across this form,
0:46:01someone had the same problem. And someone later in the thread was like, well, I live in a country
0:46:05without Apple One. And so that changes a lot of these dynamics.
0:46:09Right.
0:46:10It's like, geez, I mean, it's like another complication on top of this.
0:46:13If you don't have Apple One, or you live somewhere where you can't have Apple One,
0:46:17you'll never run into this specific problem. There might be other problems you run into
0:46:21with the two account in the family member who's in charge of it system, but not this one.
0:46:27It's the fact that Apple One is magically special cased on Apple's side to blend the iTunes stuff with
0:46:38the iCloud stuff. And I'm calling it iTunes stuff for all the media, including the App Store. All of the
0:46:44purchasing stuff is separate from the iCloud stuff. And Apple One magically merges those together into a
0:46:52single purchase. This would be solved. And one way Apple could solve it would be to offer those additional
0:46:58storage tiers of 6 terabytes and 12 terabytes through Apple One and just charge the same Delta for two
0:47:08additional tiers of Apple One. I would have done that in a heartbeat. And I would actually be sending them
0:47:14more money because it would cost... I'm only paying $10 more a month now than I was before to get two
0:47:21additional terabytes. It would have cost me $20 a month to get six terabytes. But we don't need that.
0:47:30Again, given the pace at which we got to two terabytes and the four or five months it took to go
0:47:36from December till now, we're probably good for a while. So I don't need to spend it. But I would
0:47:42have done it because it was easy and obvious and it would have worked.
0:47:44And it would have saved you two days of work that you didn't plan on.
0:47:48Right. And this entire episode of the talk show wouldn't even be happening.
0:47:51You might still be here. You were here exactly a year ago.
0:47:54Yeah.
0:47:54We'd be talking about different things. I don't know.
0:47:58The other thing I guess I should talk about is why I don't try merging my two accounts.
0:48:05That migration path.
0:48:06Yeah. So let's come back to that. Let me take another break here and thank our next sponsor.
0:48:11It is our good friends at Notion. With the recent launch of custom agents, Notion became the
0:48:18collaborative AI workspace where teams and agents work side by side. And now their new developer
0:48:25platform is turning that workspace into infrastructure developers can build on. Notion's developer platform
0:48:32is really this is all sorts of platforms are moving in this direction with the MCP stuff, command line
0:48:39stuff like it is so bananas that people keep writing to me about the way that Markdown is suddenly the
0:48:46lingua franqua of AI. And how do I feel about it? And I have very way more thoughts than I can squeeze
0:48:53into a middle of a sponsor read. But the other thing that is so fascinating about the current moment in AI is the
0:49:00way that command line interfaces are have a new they never went away for developers. But now, because AI
0:49:07agents can use them in a great way as it's effectively a form of automation, all sorts of tools that never
0:49:15had command line interfaces, but maybe could have but just never did now have it as like a hey, we need a
0:49:21command line interface. Notion has done that it is NTN. That's pretty good. That's a pretty good name for the
0:49:29command line tool for notion, right? Just take out the vowels. NTN is their command line interface. And it can
0:49:36do just about anything it can read and take action in notion it can manage the workers you have in notion and
0:49:43deploy them through one interface built for developers and coding agents. The workers are notion hosted sandboxes for
0:49:52custom code. They run database syncs, agent tools, webhook triggers on notions runtime. And you don't have to do that on your own. You can just have an agent do all these things for you. They have an external agent API and private alpha testing that you can bring your in house agents into notion. As native workspace participants, they are working on that. But it's all built on this command line stuff that they're building out. It's really, really easy to use the command line interface.
0:50:20The command line interface authenticates on one line. The workers deploy without provisioning infrastructure.
0:50:27And it's in the same way that notion itself is easy to use as a GUI application for your desktop and for your phone. They make it just that easy to get started using AI at even at a team level and enterprise level in notion. Learn more about notions developer platform today at notion.com slash talk show. Now, those are all lowercase letters notion.com slash talk show. To try notions developer platform today.
0:50:47Notions developer platform today. And when you use our link, you're supporting the talk show. Thank you very much to notion notion.com slash talk show. What did I say I was going to come back to?
0:51:08We were talking about iCloud plus additional storage versus Apple one. Why you want to keep the media?
0:51:14Oh, why I don't merge? Why I don't why I don't merge. Yeah, there we go. Oh, God, I didn't know why that was flush from my memory. So that's another way that would solve the problem. If I went through the account merger and merge the two. But the problem is.
0:51:29And that's you. Why didn't you do that?
0:51:32I attempted the migration. And again, if you look at that support page, the list of conditions is very long you have to be in. And it just failed for me, even though best I could tell the conditions were all correct. Now it was earlier on, you know, this feature has been out now an additional year or whatever it's been. And so maybe it's more robust now, but it just didn't work for me.
0:51:57And that sort of set that plus I had the two terabyte problem. It's like, okay, we have to do something with this now. And that's how I ended up bringing my media purchasing into the family.
0:52:08For me, there were a couple of killers in there. First was right off the bat. There was a if it ain't broke, don't fix it angle where and even though that was announced, I guess, shortly after I went through the whole rigmarole.
0:52:22No, that was last year. So no, that I ran out of storage space months later. But my whole dual account system, while more complex, I'm not confused by it until now with this Apple one storage limitation thing.
0:52:38I didn't find it confusing. I'm totally used to it. And it just works and has just worked for years. So why take any risk at all?
0:52:48And I followed along as other people in this situation tried it. And it seemed like most people had success. It seemed like serious problems were few and far between.
0:53:01It seemed like if it didn't work, there was a way to revert. You could just say, ah, just this doesn't work for me for X, Y, or Z. Go back, go back. And you can go back.
0:53:09And you can only do that like once a year, because I guess it's kind of expensive on Apple side to do the work. They don't want people trying it every day. I don't know.
0:53:19Maybe it's some sort of weird piracy loophole. Like, yeah, yeah, stuff to you. You can watch my movies. I don't know.
0:53:25Yeah. And then you can use my law. Yeah, I don't know. Something like that. I was like, if it ain't broke, don't fix it. Mine's not broke. So I'm not going to fix it. But I'd like to see what other people say. And it seems like it worked. But then this is what led me to you is you had to post on 512 pixels last year, where you listed, like after Apple, maybe Apple didn't even know all of these issues.
0:53:47At first, I don't know. But they listed all of the fine print, like don't try this if and one of them is if the secondary media purchase account is also used for test flight installations. And that's a problem for me, because it's just would not have occurred to me 25 years ago when the iTunes store came out. But if I had made, I didn't even need to make a whole email account, just an alias like iTunes purchases at daring fireball.net.
0:54:16If I had made that email alias, and then use that to sign in for iTunes, and then use that to sign in for the app store and that to sign in to buy movies. And here I am 25 years later, still using an email address that I had only created to buy shit from Apple.
0:54:37So I would be a perfect candidate for this account merger thing. And I would think, ah, good riddance to that email address that I never used for anything else. And now it's all on my Mac.com. That's nice and neat.
0:54:49But I can't because I used Gruber at daringfireball.net, my main email address for like my life. And of course, that's the address that I use from all of my test flight accounts. And as I was on the phone with you, I think yesterday I counted, I think I have 50 test flight apps.
0:55:08Yeah. Yeah, I mean, I've got a lot too. It's a cost, I guess, in our profession. But like going back through this list, like something as simple as does the media account have an Apple music library associated with it? If it does, you can't do it.
0:55:21Or if the non, no, I think it's if the non, if both have a music account, right? Of course, my media and purchase one has a music account because it purchased the music. But if your iTunes one has a music library too, then you can't merge the two.
0:55:38That's right. Yeah.
0:55:40That's the problem. I don't think I have that. But who knows, right? Who knows if I set up a review unit phone years ago and only signed into my iCloud account to avoid the hassle of doing a second account login for a phone I was only going to use for a week. And I played a song. I don't know what counts.
0:55:57You know, what would be in there is that U2 album they gave away like 10 years ago comes back to haunt us all the time.
0:56:04Right, right. I've got one album in there and then I go to delete it and it's son of a bitch comes back.
0:56:10That's right.
0:56:10Right. I don't even know if that would trigger me, but it seems like something that could happen. I don't know. And I've already spent days on this problem. How many more do I want to spend? I don't know. But the test flight one is sort of a deal breaker. Again, it's like I could drop out of every single test flight that I'm currently testing, write them all down.
0:56:34And then if they're public, resign in using a different address or do the account merger, merge it all to my Mac.com address and then free up my main Gruber at daring fireball.net and then use it again to get back into test flight.
0:56:52Yeah, but I would have to email every single developer and ask to be invited back.
0:56:58And it's like, I could do that. It's a small ask, but it's a small ask of 50 developers, which is a lot of work.
0:57:08You know, the thing with the original Macintosh, it was like it every second it boots up faster. You save hundreds of years of human life or whatever. That's how it is asking developers to do stuff in App Store Connect.
0:57:19Like, going in and adding a test flight, it's way more clicks than you think it would be.
0:57:23And you're not going to hear back from everybody, right? Like, it's an unpleasant step. And some of these other things you mentioned, it's like, is there something inherent about test flight that is unaware of this other thing that's going on with my accounts?
0:57:35Or was it built in a way? Because it was, test flight was external and then Apple bought them. Is there something like deep in the foundations that, okay, like we can't reasonably fix this. And so it's just going to be some fine print on this page for the handful of people who want to migrate with test flights.
0:57:51Yeah. So, bottom line, just add the other account as a fourth family member. Buy everything through that account, including the iCloud storage. And I guess, I mean, I can't see why it wouldn't work to create a spare user account on a Mac, sign in with that address, without having a spare device to wipe and sign in on.
0:58:14Yeah, I think that would be totally fine.
0:58:16Yeah, I should even try that and just sign in and see if it works. But I'm sure it does.
0:58:20But it was funny because that account shows how, you know, each account, you can see how much storage they're using towards the family. And like I said, I'm just under a terabyte. My son is just over a terabyte. My wife is at 220 gigabytes. And my media account is at 276 kilobytes.
0:58:44You have one text file in there somewhere.
0:58:46Fits on a floppy disk. It doesn't just fit on a floppy disk. It fits on an old original 400K floppy disk.
0:58:57Yeah. You still got room for a system folder, man. I mean, you got it.
0:59:00Oh, boy.
0:59:02It fits on a floppy disk. So probably, I don't know, maybe it doesn't have a music library. Maybe it is on my other, I don't know. But add it if you have another family member to spare and that's it.
0:59:18Or drop out of Apple One and just pay more money a month to buy the ones you need. I mean, that just seems like, I mean, I know Apple is hurting for money, but I don't feel like I need to suggest users or listeners of the show spend more money monthly on a poor Tim Apple's services division.
0:59:40He wants to go out on a bang. I mean, who can blame him, right?
0:59:42He's got to.
0:59:43Right. But what a fiasco. I honestly, I don't know. I think we covered it all. I don't want to cover the rest. I do. I will. I swear to God, write something about this to help people who are Googling for it and tell them this.
0:59:57And I guess I'll leave, last but not least, I'll just say, if anybody out there, whether you work at Apple or whether you're just a listener and you've solved this on your own and you know of a better solution to the problem, please write to me and tell me what it is, right?
1:00:12If there's something better and more graceful, it's the ungracefulness of adding myself secondarily to the family account that really bothers me. It's like the way that I'm still bothered, lo these many years later, by file name extensions on the book, right?
1:00:30Like we, right. We, we had a better system. We had a better system and then we went to this and now we're stuck with it. And now it's, I'm stuck with a phantom John Gruber in my family forever.
1:00:44Yeah. Again, at least you had room for it, right? So the limit is six.
1:00:47Yes.
1:00:47My wife and I have three children. I had one spot left.
1:00:51Yes. So you use the last spot, right?
1:00:53Right. So like if we'd had a fourth, then what, then what do I do? Right. It's messy. And anytime.
1:01:00You run into these things, especially with Apple accounts or like if you're an app store connect or podcast connect or some of these other sort of internally systems, you really feel the age of them.
1:01:13And I'm sure all this stuff, right? Like the joke is, well, it's web objects, right?
1:01:17Right.
1:01:18Sure. It's not. I hope it's not, but there's definitely, there's definitely cruft in here that they either can't or won't get rid of.
1:01:29And I understand like you have more than a billion Apple accounts. I would be so afraid to be on that team that has to do anything with this. And maybe that's why the Apple one thing is kind of semi outside of the path of iCloud plus and test flights kind of semi on the outside of iCloud family sharing.
1:01:49Like if you, if you, if they were going to build it today, surely it would be better and cleaner and easier to understand.
1:01:56But it feels to me at least like they have these limitations due to their, due to the history of the system that they just basically have to live with at this point.
1:02:07Yeah. And I remember for years and years, whenever this would come up and I had the inkling, like it would occur to me like, God damn it.
1:02:15Why can't Apple just fix this and let you just say, take these two Apple IDs and mush them together.
1:02:21Let me pick which one becomes the canonical one.
1:02:25I'd think that. And then I think, I'll bet this is a really hard problem.
1:02:28And then I'd hear from people at Apple from time to time, never with details, but just like, I can't tell you more than this, but yes, it is a very hard problem.
1:02:37And I believe that because like you said, these things grew organically over time with lots of users and from origins that you just never, they never could have been expected to think would grow this way.
1:02:56And it's probably the least, well, not the least, but it's among the least of the various problems we still live with and always will for the fact that the app store started as the iTunes music store.
1:03:12Yes.
1:03:13And evolved into it. And that at this point, it's never, almost certainly never going to come.
1:03:18If it didn't come with the Apple creator studio, it's never going to come the idea of like upgrade pricing for apps, right?
1:03:28Like BB edit 16 just shipped last week.
1:03:30And if you're already a paid BB edit user, you can upgrade from whatever version you currently own to BB edit 16.0 for I think 40 bucks instead of the retail price of whatever it is, a hundred bucks, 90 bucks, whatever.
1:03:44That's the way software world worked forever.
1:03:47That's the way some software like BB edit and others still work.
1:03:50It's never been in the app store.
1:03:51And part of it is maybe Apple just doesn't care about that.
1:03:54But I think part of it was just that it never made any sense.
1:03:57There's no such thing as an upgrade to an album or a single or a movie.
1:04:00So it just wasn't in the infrastructure for the store.
1:04:06And when they were like, all right, let's build an app store.
1:04:09And it was like, Hey, we can just build on top of this.
1:04:12We already people already have almost everybody who bought an iPhone in the first year already had an iTunes account because they had an iPod and iTunes music collection and stuff.
1:04:24So they already have an ID.
1:04:25They can already start buying apps.
1:04:27They don't even have to enter, not just enter it once and save the credit card.
1:04:30They've already got it.
1:04:31Which is the right call at the time, right?
1:04:34To suggest otherwise at the time would have been bananas.
1:04:38But it does have these knock-on effects all these years later.
1:04:42I mean, I remember on Upgrade, Jason and Mike spoke a lot about the Creator Studio thing.
1:04:46And like you go into the app store and there's numbers and then there's numbers, you know, it's got some version number behind it and they're different.
1:04:52I think just yesterday, MacRumors linked to it, there was a support document showing the icons of like the new one and the old one explaining which is which.
1:05:01Like, no one thinks this is a good idea, but they're handcuffed by decisions made 20 years ago.
1:05:07I forget who I was talking about this on a recent show, but I think I was talking about it on a recent show.
1:05:13That part of the reason that you can have them installed side by side is that they're not, on the Mac at least, they don't use the same.
1:05:21Like bundle ID?
1:05:23Bundle ID, the com.apple.numbers.
1:05:26One of them is com.apple.numbers.iOS or iCloud or I forget.
1:05:32But the iOS ones were never the same as the Mac ones until Apple Creator Studio.
1:05:40And again, Apple Creator Studio is to that bundle of apps what Apple One is to the other thing where it's like two worlds collided.
1:05:50Where the fact that Numbers didn't have the same bundle ID on the Mac that it did on iOS never mattered.
1:05:59They could just say, well, we're apps from the same developer.
1:06:02So the two versions of the apps can see the same iCloud Drive folder full of documents and it all just works.
1:06:11And users don't need to, certainly don't need to worry about bundle IDs.
1:06:15And then when they wanted to sell a bundle with all of these apps that would work on all the platforms, they were like, oh.
1:06:22Yeah.
1:06:23We're the bad guys here.
1:06:25Oh, past us.
1:06:25We were the bad guys.
1:06:27So that's why on the Mac, you can, I think on my main Mac, I still have the old versions because I'm a hoarder and I can keep them.
1:06:34And I'm like, well, let me wait and see if there's anything I like about the old version better.
1:06:38But you can just have old numbers and new numbers side by side.
1:06:41But in your applications folder, they both just say numbers.
1:06:45And so it looks like something impossible has happened because if you make two files in the same folder and try to give them the exact same name, when you try to give the second one that name, it's going to say, pick another name.
1:06:56That name's already in use.
1:06:58And you have to make it different by one character somewhere.
1:07:01With numbers, it's like the display name is not the real file name in the file system.
1:07:07So, yes, then they end up – and I guess it's good that they kept the old icons the same so that you can identify them by icon once you learn it.
1:07:16I don't hate it as much as other people, but they're a little –
1:07:21Well, I don't like the old ones either.
1:07:24Sure.
1:07:25The thing – I think you mentioned it or I'm sure we both linked to it or talked about it.
1:07:29The thing that was going around of like the iWork icons get better going backward in time, like the Benjamin Button kind of thing.
1:07:37Man, that's so true of the iWork icons.
1:07:39It is one of the best tweets of all time.
1:07:42I guess I'll put it in the show notes.
1:07:44But, yes, you look at the icons – I think he used pages as the example.
1:07:49I think so.
1:07:49It's true for all of them.
1:07:51But if you just look at the icons for pages, it really does seem like an icon designer getting – going from I don't know what I'm doing to I'm exquisite and can make one of the best icons anybody's ever seen.
1:08:02But only when you go in reverse.
1:08:05Yeah, only backwards.
1:08:06God, I hope that trend changes.
1:08:10All right.
1:08:10Let me take another break here and thank – guess who?
1:08:13Our good friends at Squarespace.
1:08:17Squarespace is the all-in-one platform for your web presence.
1:08:22And you can go to squarespace.com slash talk show.
1:08:26I'll just spoil the end right now.
1:08:27Squarespace.com slash talk show.
1:08:29You save 10% off any purchase for up to a year.
1:08:32And you can give that code to your friends when their friends come to you and say, hey, I need a website because you're the biggest nerd that I know.
1:08:39Send them to Squarespace and assure them that they can sign up for a free trial and start going.
1:08:47And they get full access to everything Squarespace does.
1:08:48And they get full access to everything Squarespace does.
1:08:50The whole shebang.
1:08:51And it is designed for normal people.
1:08:56Like in the way that a word processor is designed so that someone who doesn't even really know what a font is, that they can change margins and actually print.
1:09:07That used to be like a thing people couldn't do with computers is actually like create a document with multiple fonts and get it to print out.
1:09:13And word processors made that easy.
1:09:16Squarespace is like that for websites, except that you can make like not like basic baby websites, but like full-fledged, totally professional-looking websites with all the features that you might want or expect.
1:09:30All sorts of stuff like e-commerce, like being able to sell things like sell goods or sell your time if you're a consultant or a trainer or something like that.
1:09:41And send out invoices and have invoices for the things you're selling or the time you're selling or the services you're selling.
1:09:49And then have your customers, your clients, your users pay the invoices on your website through Squarespace's own payment system.
1:09:58And then you get paid all through your own website.
1:10:01I swear you, listener, to me right now, you can do this on Squarespace.
1:10:07You'll be able to figure it out.
1:10:08And the people you know can figure it out too.
1:10:11It is that integrated of a system where you can build really complex systems like this just by looking and visually learning.
1:10:19And if you want to, using the AI to ask questions like, how do I add invoices to my website and it'll help you out, go to squarespace.com slash talk show to find out more.
1:10:31Start your free trial.
1:10:33And then when your 30-day free trial's up, just go back to that same URL, squarespace.com slash talk show, or just remember the code talk show, T-A-L-K-S-H-O-W, at checkout, and you'll save 10%.
1:10:45My thanks to Squarespace.
1:10:46Well, after all of this breaking news related to 25-year-old payment systems, we can talk breaking.
1:10:58I actually feel like this is a very quiet end of May.
1:11:02For the lead-up to WWDC.
1:11:05Yeah, it does feel that way.
1:11:07You know, sometimes Apple have some, usually developer-related news or App Store-related news, and maybe that's still yet to come, but May is basically over.
1:11:19And, yeah, it just seems quiet.
1:11:22And even Gurman, right, I don't think he's done his annual, this is everything in, you know, iOS.
1:11:28He talked a lot about the Siri and the Gemini integration and some of those things.
1:11:32But at this point, WWDC, other than that, feels like still a bit of a mystery.
1:11:38Yeah, and he often gets, usually in recent years, I forget, I don't know what his track record is, but a lot of times he obviously gets somebody who sees the keynote at the day before, like over the weekend, before when they're going through the final cut.
1:11:55Obviously, the number of people, obviously, the number of people within the company who get to see the keynote expands in the days before the keynote.
1:12:04And some of those people appear to be sources for Gurman.
1:12:08So I certainly wouldn't want to rule out that he has a big spoiler post the weekend before WWDC.
1:12:16But as of now, two weeks before WWDC, I would say that has not happened.
1:12:22I think his biggest scoop was already played out, which was like last fall when Gurman, to his credit, exclusively started saying, hey, Apple and Google are talking about white label, effectively white label Gemini models in Apple's data centers being the AI models to power the actual next generation of Siri and Apple intelligence.
1:12:48And lo and behold, Apple and Google, rather quietly, especially from Apple's perspective, announced that, I think, at the beginning of the year.
1:12:56It was like two sentences on a Google blog somewhere, right?
1:12:59We're doing this.
1:13:00Don't pay attention if you're a government.
1:13:02Right.
1:13:03And surely that stuff will be the high level, sort of the highlight of WWDC.
1:13:10Apple still feels like they are living in the shadow of 24, where they announced a bunch of stuff that wasn't real and hasn't shipped.
1:13:18Oh, I remember.
1:13:19I know.
1:13:19Yeah, I wrote a little thing about it.
1:13:22And this year, I think there's going to be a lot of, this is what we're doing.
1:13:26It's in the betas early.
1:13:28You can see it.
1:13:29You can touch it.
1:13:30Because really, I don't think they're going to do a lot in iOS 27 with Apple intelligence, Siri, Gemini, whatever combination of those things that we're not seeing on Android now.
1:13:42And which is fine.
1:13:44I think it's a reasonable feature set, some of the things Google's doing.
1:13:48And so, I think it's going to be relatively known.
1:13:50And I suspect it's going to be maybe a little constrained.
1:13:54Like, the whole thing of, hey, when does my mom land at the airport?
1:13:57I don't think that's working anywhere on any platform right now.
1:14:00And so, I think it's going to be a little more subdued than 24, but also a lot more grounded.
1:14:07And this stuff is here.
1:14:08It's working.
1:14:10You can touch it.
1:14:12Yeah, and it does make last year's, from an AI perspective, last year's WWDC, it was just kind of weird, right?
1:14:19The last two have been weird.
1:14:20Because two years ago was the one where they announced a lot of stuff that they wound up not shipping.
1:14:27And then when they announced, hey, that stuff we announced, we're going to have to push that back a year, which ended up being more than a year.
1:14:36Because they announced that in March last year with the phrase, in the coming year.
1:14:41Which I, at first, and they gave that statement to me.
1:14:46I think it was like me and Reuters, or me and CNBC.
1:14:49It was only like two outlets, and I was one.
1:14:51And I did not know that I was one of only two.
1:14:54I kind of had an inkling, because it wasn't just emailed to me.
1:14:57I got a phone call, too.
1:14:59And there's only so many phone calls they can make.
1:15:01But they didn't say, you're one of only two places.
1:15:03But I ran the statement, and then thought about it for a day or two.
1:15:06And while I was thinking about it, out came, there's something rotten in the state of Cupertino.
1:15:11But they said, at first, that these features will be coming out in the coming year.
1:15:17In the coming year.
1:15:18Which I thought meant after WWDC last year.
1:15:22I think a lot of people did.
1:15:24It's a reasonable way to interpret that.
1:15:26Right.
1:15:27In the coming year, I would like to see you, Stephen.
1:15:32Hopefully, I'll see you in person in the coming year.
1:15:35I would mean that, but if I said that to you, and I mean it, I actually do mean it, I would think sometime soon.
1:15:40Maybe, I don't know.
1:15:42Are you going to WWDC?
1:15:43I am.
1:15:43I'll be there.
1:15:44Well, then, I'm going to see you in the coming weeks.
1:15:47Right?
1:15:48Right?
1:15:50But what they meant by the in the coming year is the coming year after 2025, which was in 2026.
1:15:59Right?
1:15:59If only there was a different word for that.
1:16:01Next year.
1:16:04Next year?
1:16:04Yes.
1:16:05So, and I do think, I think it was so hard for them to pull the trigger on and rip the tape off that announcement.
1:16:13Right?
1:16:14Sure.
1:16:14And they kind of obviously postponed it as long as they could.
1:16:18I think there was clearly a growing chorus within the company who were like, we're not going to ship this.
1:16:24Right?
1:16:24This isn't like what we were thinking we're going to ship.
1:16:27We can't ship.
1:16:28And this isn't fixable.
1:16:30Right?
1:16:30And effectively, what they're doing is you're using all new models.
1:16:33And the all new models are coming from Google.
1:16:35Right?
1:16:35Which wasn't something they had even on the radar at the time.
1:16:40So, they said in the coming year, what they meant was next year.
1:16:44And what they really meant effective.
1:16:46And maybe they didn't know at the time.
1:16:48Right?
1:16:48Because they had to backtrack.
1:16:49And so, they didn't know when they made the announcement just how long into 2026 it would be.
1:16:54But effectively, it's going to be the end of 2026.
1:16:57Because they're going to announce it two weeks from now at WWDC.
1:17:02And everything they announced at WWDC in June will be stuff that comes out in the various version 27 releases in the fall.
1:17:12And that's if it's there on day one.
1:17:14Right.
1:17:15Which I would really hope this time it is.
1:17:17At least something.
1:17:18Right.
1:17:19But yeah, you're right.
1:17:20I'd like to give them the benefit.
1:17:22So, it made last year's WWDC really weird.
1:17:24Because last year's WWDC came after they made that announcement, but before they had anything new to announce.
1:17:31Yeah.
1:17:31And so, it was sort of an AI-free.
1:17:33I know they mentioned AI in Siri multiple times.
1:17:35And I think they did it on purpose to make sure that they weren't pretending those words didn't exist.
1:17:39But they didn't announce any major Apple intelligence features.
1:17:42It was the huge elephant in the room last year.
1:17:44Right?
1:17:45It's like, there's this whole thing that's happening and you're not discussing it.
1:17:49And yeah, hopefully they've got it right this time.
1:17:51I'm sure it's a bitter pill to swallow for Apple to have to go to Google and be like, we need to use your models.
1:17:58That ours aren't capable of doing what we need them to do.
1:18:02And who knows if that's a short-term or a long-term solution for them.
1:18:07I guess would be they're still working on something.
1:18:09And maybe they view Gemini as a bridge to when Apple's homemade models are ready.
1:18:17But it is just so fascinating that they are turning to an outside company because, honestly, they failed to do it.
1:18:25Right?
1:18:26And people have come and gone from Apple over such things.
1:18:29Right?
1:18:29Yes.
1:18:30It's absolutely wild.
1:18:31There's something so porn-it in today's age.
1:18:34Apple's relying on effectively a vendor to make it possible.
1:18:37At least under the hood.
1:18:38Right?
1:18:38Apple's building the features, but Gemini is the underlying technology.
1:18:42Yeah.
1:18:43I also can't help but suspect that the two years ago pre-announcement was sort of hastened by a sense of urgency.
1:18:57Like, the whole world's going AI crazy.
1:18:59The stock market's going AI crazy.
1:19:01I'm sure there are a bunch of employees in the company who are saying, this is like the next big thing.
1:19:05We need to be on it.
1:19:06We're in trouble if we're not.
1:19:07And they kind of fell prey to the need to get out over their skis on what – and, again, there's some controversy and hard feelings that my writing on this was alluding to the fact that they lied in their announcement.
1:19:25And I definitely did not say that, and I didn't mean that.
1:19:28I don't mean that they knew that they were announcing things they wouldn't ship, which is insane, right?
1:19:33That is not something that somebody would do at a company where the same people were going to be there nine months later.
1:19:38That's malpractice at that point.
1:19:40Right.
1:19:40But I also think they certainly knew that it was a maybe that they were going to ship, that this was uncertain, that there was some uncertainty that they were going to ship it on time.
1:19:51Or if they weren't uncertain at all when they announced it, if they were like, yeah, I'm 100% certain that we are going to ship this when we promised it, well, then those people were technically incompetent because they couldn't ship it.
1:20:04And maybe the truth is that some of those people are no longer at the company, that there were people who were like, yep, 100%, we are going to do this on time.
1:20:11And those people should be gone because that really is a firing offense.
1:20:16But I can't help but think, too, conversely, the fact that last year's WWDC came and went extremely light on AI, just – again, they mentioned it.
1:20:27They had some serious stuff to talk about, but nothing major.
1:20:30And the world didn't collapse, and if anything, public sentiment over the Apple and AI over the last year is far less controversial than the year prior.
1:20:41Yeah.
1:20:41I think –
1:20:42Yeah.
1:20:42The world has changed around them in this timeframe.
1:20:46One thing that I'm sure you've seen it, this sort of theory going around, like, well, say the bubble bursts, and if any of us have any money left, it'll be Apple, and they can just go buy up AI companies for parts.
1:20:59And Apple actually is genius for not investing in this early the way that other companies have.
1:21:03I don't think that's the case at all.
1:21:06I think they were slow, and they had some bad ideas and weren't equipped to do it properly.
1:21:11I'm putting properly in quotes.
1:21:13But now they're in the situation where they're going to announce – assumedly announce a bunch of AI-powered features.
1:21:20It's going to ship in the fall.
1:21:22And public feelings about AI have – they've changed, but they've also grown more sort of extreme at the ends.
1:21:31Yes, definitely.
1:21:32Polarized.
1:21:32Yeah.
1:21:33I mean, I'm sure you see it when you write about it.
1:21:35I see it when I write about it or when we talk about it.
1:21:37Like, you've got people who are really fired up, and you've got people who really dislike it.
1:21:41And Apple's now entering into that when that conversation is supercharged.
1:21:46How do you manage that as a company and the way you talk about it?
1:21:50Even some of their previous talking points about how they were privacy-focused, and so our models were built that in mind.
1:21:56Well, it's not your models anymore.
1:21:57It's so very complicated.
1:22:01And there is – and again, I can go back to the announcement, but it has something to do with – we've decided the Gemini models are the best ones to power Apple's foundation models.
1:22:08And it's like models that power the models.
1:22:11Yeah.
1:22:12But, yeah, I'm not going to say it was genius.
1:22:15I don't think it was genius in that they – for anybody at Apple in a decision-making context completely foresaw how, hey, this would really work out for us if we don't do any of this crazy CapEx spending.
1:22:27Not crazy meaning it's wrong, but crazy that the numbers that their peer companies are spending on CapEx are just unfathomable to even non-mortals.
1:22:38But that we can just avoid that, just not spend the CapEx, and then we'll just cut a deal with whoever's making the best models later.
1:22:46It's like they're spending – they announced it.
1:22:48It's like they're spending a billion dollars a year.
1:22:51They're giving Google one billion for the rights to use Gemini as a white label thing.
1:22:56A billion dollars is like nothing for Apple.
1:23:00It is not much to Google, and compared to the CapEx that Google has spent to build Gemini, it is really a fraction.
1:23:09And it's almost certainly just a billion-dollar discount on what Google was already spending to keep Google Search the default in Safari through the search acquisition deal,
1:23:23which last we've known is 20 billion a year, but those are numbers from like frozen in time from like 2020 or 2021 or something like that.
1:23:34So there's no sign that they've gone down.
1:23:36So they might be slowing though, right?
1:23:40Because famously everybody is saying people are searching the web less because they're turning to AI tools for things they used to go to search.
1:23:48So it might be slowing like the way that it's – over the decades of the deal has grown from a couple billion a year to 10 billion a year to 15 to 20 billion a year.
1:24:00It's probably slowing and going to cap and maybe will start declining because it is usage-based, right?
1:24:06It's not every year Google says we're going to give you $22 billion and you'll make Google Search the default in Safari.
1:24:13It's we're going to pay you this per search for searches that go through the Safari bar.
1:24:18And surely it's still $20 to $25 billion a year and now Apple is going to send $1 billion back and they get the Gemini models?
1:24:27This does not – however much of this was strategic, I don't know.
1:24:33And I think some of it they just kind of – not lucked into but sort of luck favors the prepared and Apple's way of thinking is to be very tight on CapEx.
1:24:46They – famously this whole operations wizardry they've built up in China and elsewhere expanding around the world, they don't own those factories, right?
1:24:58Like the whole Tim Cook operations genius, the whole Apple in China book from Patrick McGee isn't about how Apple built factories around the world.
1:25:09It's how Foxconn built factories around the world up to Apple's specs, right?
1:25:13That's Apple.
1:25:14So kind of taking that approach to AI might work out.
1:25:20Sticking to their guns and not being – like I feel like they got nervous with what they announced at WWDC two years ago.
1:25:27But I don't think they've shown any kinds of nervousness in the way they've spent money or the way they've actually changed their products, right?
1:25:35Like I would say none of Apple's products have been ruined or defaced by AI.
1:25:40No.
1:25:40No.
1:25:41I mean it's right in the setup flow.
1:25:43I was just setting up a new iPhone recently.
1:25:44You can turn it on or off.
1:25:46As a side note, I would like those controls to be more granular.
1:25:49The more AI features are available on the platform.
1:25:51If anyone wins the strategic conversation in my mind, it's Google.
1:25:55Being the platform or the model provider for really the two OSs that matter in the world, iOS and Android, locking Anthropic and OpenAI and other companies out of that from their perspective is a great move, right?
1:26:16I mean really, once this all ships, basically the infrastructure between a feature on a Pixel phone and a feature on an iPhone, the features may work differently because Google and Apple interpret them differently.
1:26:32But the model under them is the same.
1:26:34And if you're Google, that's a huge victory, I think.
1:26:37Yeah.
1:26:38The way it's going to be, and I don't know that we're going to hear anything about Gemini powering this stuff at WWDC.
1:26:45Gurman was, when he first announced that they were working on a deal, he was like, I don't even think they're going to announce it.
1:26:50I think they're just going to keep it secret.
1:26:52And they did announce it very quietly and I can see why, but I think it will remain quiet and I don't think they're going to talk about it because it's not going to be Gemini, Gemini.
1:27:04You're not going to sign in with your Google account.
1:27:06The way I could see Apple mentioning it is only by reemphasizing that everything you do through Apple's Apple-branded Apple intelligence is inherently private and that even Apple cannot see it.
1:27:22None of what you send to it or type into it or talk to it is used for training.
1:27:27And even when it goes to the cloud, the whole private cloud compute thing means that even Apple cryptographically cannot access that stuff, even when it leaves your device, goes to that.
1:27:39And it doesn't matter what model it is, it doesn't use it.
1:27:43So it's not further training Gemini to get better.
1:27:48And Gemini is apparently going to, it would be shocking if it didn't happen in June, is going to be an available partner for the, hey, and if you want to use a third-party AI tool with Apple intelligence, in the way that for a year and a half now we've been able to use ChatGPT and connect ChatGPT to Siri to answer questions, that it's going to be probably the big three, probably ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini.
1:28:15For sure.
1:28:16I think that's totally so.
1:28:18And so people will be confused because they'll be like, well, why do I have to do this to get Gemini?
1:28:23I was told Gemini was going to be built in.
1:28:26And it's like, yeah, that's a different layer.
1:28:28Yeah.
1:28:28That's where Google's branding could have helped Apple, like call the feature and call the model something else.
1:28:34But like Anthropoc is right.
1:28:36It's just Claude, whether you're using Sonnet 4.0, whatever, or Opus or whatever else they're called.
1:28:41So I do think, though, the win for Google to make this deal, it's not the billion dollars in cash.
1:28:47It is the kneecapping of ChatGPT and Claude of cutting them off from serving in that role because I do think it's a good place to be, even if it's not training and you're not making money.
1:28:59I think that it just cuts them off.
1:29:02And Google's the one that already has an existing business model and is actually a very profitable company, even with all the capex that they've been spending.
1:29:13Whereas OpenAI and Anthropoc are losing more money than any startups in the history of the world.
1:29:20Yeah.
1:29:21As of now.
1:29:22Right.
1:29:22So cutting off the two companies that are losing money from any kind of deal and offering Apple to do this for a billion, right?
1:29:30Like, I don't know that those companies that are trying to stop the hemorrhaging could make an offer like this for a billion dollars, even if Apple's hosting the thing.
1:29:39I don't know, but I do think it's a win for Google.
1:29:43And I think there's also a sort of win for them.
1:29:47I don't think Google cares that much about Android.
1:29:49I've been saying this for years.
1:29:50Google I.O. just came and went, and Android really isn't part of it, right?
1:29:54Certainly nothing like the way iOS is the star, always the star of WWDC.
1:29:59They actually made their Android announcements before Google I.O.
1:30:04Early.
1:30:05In the way that it's like, oh, yeah, here's our keynote.
1:30:07We're going to have to cut some stuff.
1:30:09All right, Android, you can make your announcements before I.O., like with the Google books coming out in the fall and stuff like that.
1:30:14Like, we don't have room for it in our crowded keynote.
1:30:17But if Apple is basing their foundation models on Gemini technology, whether it's an Apple hosted private cloud compute or, as Gurman has also alluded to, maybe letting Google do some of the hosting in their data centers, but also in a private cloud compute style way, which Google independently announced last summer that they were working on the same thing for obvious reasons, that they want to sell into enterprise and stuff.
1:30:40And they don't need to see like, it's sort of a layperson's misunderstanding to think that they want to see and use everything you type into the product to train it for the future.
1:30:52They don't need that.
1:30:53So having a private cloud computing thing, whether it's the official Apple branded capital PCC, private cloud compute, or just lowercase letters, hey, it's cloud computing for AI and it's totally private using cryptography.
1:31:10If Apple's using the same underlying technology as Google, then Apple's platform, even if they don't care that much about Android, it's not going to surpass Android.
1:31:21Like the cap on how good the built-in AI built into Apple's platforms is going to be, the cap is on how good Gemini is.
1:31:30And I think that's why they're probably continuing to develop their own in the background where they may have ideas for features or other things that, yeah, Gemini could do it, but maybe it's not great.
1:31:45And if we took it and tweaked it 10%, then we could really build what we want.
1:31:49I think that's definitely an odd effect of this arrangement that you're right.
1:31:56There's not competition in the model space between Apple and Google.
1:31:59There really wasn't ever, but now there really isn't because, at least for now, Gemini is doing both.
1:32:05Right.
1:32:06I can't help but think, and if you pay attention to the papers that Apple publishes through the Apple AI Research Lab, whatever they call it, where they let those employees publish research papers, a lot of it or a disproportionate amount of it is often related, at least from what I've seen.
1:32:28Maybe I'm seeing what I want to see, but I think a disproportionate amount of Apple's published research on this is about doing things locally on devices, as opposed to everybody's thinking about it.
1:32:40But the other companies are like, yeah, but the easiest way for us to do this is to spend literally hundreds of billions of dollars and build out data centers and just do it all there and send the data back and forth.
1:32:51Whereas Apple is – but it makes sense because Apple is the company amongst all these big companies that has over a billion or two billion devices in use around the world.
1:33:03Right.
1:33:04And they've obviously seen this revolution play out over the last three or four years.
1:33:12So the chip designs for things like the A20 and the A21 and the A22, which are in the works now, and the M7, the M6, M7, M8 chips, are all in the works now at various degrees.
1:33:28And those designs are the ones that are all informed by the LLM revolution.
1:33:34And it's not quite Moore's law, but it's like not the technical definition of Moore's law, but the effective definition of Moore's law that every year the chips get faster and cheaper and use less energy is true.
1:33:48And the amount of AI compute that will be able to be able to be done locally on device, on phones, on your frigging AirPods, on your Mac, five years from now, and especially 10 years from now, is going to blow away what's possible now.
1:34:05And I feel like it just seems so obvious that that would be the future Apple's building for, not the next two, three, four years, where to be a player, you need to build these massive hundreds of billions of dollar data centers right now.
1:34:24And almost certainly buying the chips from NVIDIA, Apple doesn't want to do that, they don't want to do the CapEx.
1:34:32And it's all sort of like right now, like what is a data center that's running right now, chock full of today's existing NVIDIA chips, hundreds of billions of dollars.
1:34:45What, how useful is that going to be six years from now?
1:34:48I don't know.
1:34:49Not very useful, would be my guess.
1:34:52Right.
1:34:53So I feel like the way, like, oh, it's like, let's give up on this race and let's build for the next race, which is when this stuff becomes local.
1:35:01And it makes sense that Apple would do that.
1:35:04Yeah.
1:35:04And at that point, you probably still need data centers for the training runs.
1:35:08But.
1:35:09Yeah.
1:35:09And that's where you can see Apple's not even trying to compete in the near term.
1:35:13Right.
1:35:13Because they would need to have the data centers now.
1:35:15Well, for that, but yeah, the day-to-day stuff, make me a Genmoji of John surfing on a refrigerator.
1:35:21Like that, that being done on device as opposed to being sent off to a data center and back, clearly Apple has the priority there.
1:35:28Like if you're anthropic, you don't have a choice but to run data centers.
1:35:32They were just in the news, they're leasing XI's first site here in Memphis because they have to do that because they don't have any other way for this to work.
1:35:41And I think there's something there when you look at open AI, when you do hardware.
1:35:47I think they want to do hardware for a bunch of reasons.
1:35:49But one of them certainly is we could do some of this stuff locally and lessen our expense long term.
1:35:57But yeah, it's just so fascinating that Apple's set up so well for a lot of this and up until signing the paperwork with Google was set up so poorly for other parts of it.
1:36:07But I suspect that three weeks from now, WBC is done, we'll have a much clearer picture about where they're going.
1:36:14And I think it's going to be really, I think the way they talk about it, I think you're right.
1:36:19It's going to be very feature-based.
1:36:21That's what Apple likes to talk about, right?
1:36:22What can your devices do for you?
1:36:24How do they make your life and work better?
1:36:26Not, oh, we have this many parameters under the hood and it's doing this and doing that.
1:36:31Because one, people don't care.
1:36:32And two, their numbers probably don't stack up to everyone else's.
1:36:36Yeah, and I really hope and expect, I do expect, that it will be much more restrained and focused and intentional where and if they add additional AI to the interface.
1:36:54Whereas everybody who uses Microsoft stuff is complaining that there's a co-pilot button everywhere.
1:37:01Yeah.
1:37:01Just everywhere.
1:37:03And the Google I.O. keynote was like, there's Gemini here, Gemini there, Gemini here, Gemini there.
1:37:08It's everywhere.
1:37:09With the Google book, it's at your cursor, right?
1:37:11It's like anywhere you are, it can be there.
1:37:14And I think Apple will be much more constrained about that stuff.
1:37:18And I think if you decide to turn it off, or my hope that you can turn certain features off and leave other ones on, that the app you're using or the feature you're using doesn't feel broken or like half-baked because you turned the switch off.
1:37:32They're going to have to build for both.
1:37:36And I think they will because they think about apps and features first, where maybe that's a little bit different in other places.
1:37:44So I hopefully, you know, it would certainly be a red flag to say the least if it seems scattershot and everywhere and it's AI, AI, AI.
1:37:52Honestly, I just feel like they already have a pretty good idea of where to put stuff.
1:37:58I just want to see it much better.
1:37:59Like, I don't like the writing tools.
1:38:02I just, I've tried them.
1:38:04They're just, they're too slow, too clunky.
1:38:07The presentation and the speed and the quality of the results.
1:38:13But, I like the idea that you, if you want to turn, you can turn it off if you want.
1:38:18And if you have it on, you select some text in any app and a writing tools button appears and you can invoke it and do stuff with it.
1:38:27Make that a lot better?
1:38:29I don't know.
1:38:30I can't see.
1:38:31Even if Genmoji got good in the image playground, I don't know.
1:38:35That was a red flag two years ago for me, how much time they spent on image playground.
1:38:39Oh, and it's still so bad.
1:38:40I mean, it's comical.
1:38:41I appreciate that Apple to date isn't building tools to make effectively deep fakes.
1:38:47But maybe there's ground between where we are now and deep fakes.
1:38:51Right.
1:38:52And it's like maybe you just want to stay out of that, right?
1:38:55I hope so.
1:38:55Right?
1:38:57And people watch a lot of porn on their iPhones.
1:39:01And Apple's like, you know what?
1:39:02We'll just mostly stay out of that.
1:39:04And you can do it on your go to the web and do it on your own.
1:39:07And it's like you want to generate.
1:39:09I'm not even talking about porno image generation.
1:39:13I'm just saying deep fake.
1:39:14We don't want to get into images, right?
1:39:16Just real lifelike images.
1:39:17We just don't want to be the ones who are making those tools.
1:39:20Just stay out of it, right?
1:39:22There's no money in it anyway.
1:39:23Everybody who is making those tools is bleeding money.
1:39:25Just stay out of it.
1:39:27But don't try to tell people, but we have a great solution for people who want to make
1:39:31AI images.
1:39:32And it's to make ones that look the worst in the industry.
1:39:36Like if you're going to make a tool that is meant for making AI images, it should make the
1:39:41best and highest fidelity ones.
1:39:43It's like a cognitive dissonance.
1:39:45Like we want to have a tool that makes images with AI and we don't want ours to look good
1:39:50because that's creepy.
1:39:51And it is kind of creepy.
1:39:52I get it.
1:39:53But that means you don't want to make it, right?
1:39:55So I don't know.
1:39:56Hopefully they have some additional clarity on that.
1:39:59And I do.
1:39:59I hope that it's not just AI, AI, AI, AI.
1:40:04Like, you know, it's got to be there.
1:40:06If there's not a strong amount of it, that'll be weird too, right?
1:40:10There's a, I'll know it when I see it, whether the WWDC keynote has enough Apple intelligence
1:40:15news, right?
1:40:16It should be a lot.
1:40:17It should be a major tentpole.
1:40:18It should probably be the main thing people are talking about in the mass media afterwards,
1:40:23but it shouldn't be everything.
1:40:24Yeah.
1:40:25Yeah.
1:40:25They still need to push the platforms forward.
1:40:28They still need to have their productivity apps get better.
1:40:30They desperately need to revisit the macOS user interface, which I don't think we have
1:40:36time to get into, but I agree with what you've said.
1:40:38No, we have no time.
1:40:39All right.
1:40:39Let me take a break here and thank our next sponsor and is a new sponsor.
1:40:43And I honestly had not heard of them before they got in touch to sponsor the show and start
1:40:48sending me some kit.
1:40:49It is even realities and they make AI smart glasses, even G2.
1:40:57That's the name of the current generation of their smart glasses.
1:41:00Even G2 are productivity smart glasses designed to keep real time support right in view with
1:41:08teleprompting, conversation support, real time translation, AI assistance, and more.
1:41:14They help you stay on top of work and just daily life.
1:41:17And unlike most smart glasses, they are designed to look and feel like premium eyewear with no
1:41:24camera and a lightweight 36 gram design you can wear all day.
1:41:29The more context you give them, the more context, the more context you give them, the smarter they get adapting to how you work and what you need.
1:41:34They have sent me some.
1:41:35I'm just getting started with them.
1:41:37I wear glasses all the time.
1:41:39The frames, they have two frame styles to pick from.
1:41:42And the one is actually just with a couple of colors.
1:41:46The one, though, is pretty similar to the type of glasses that I actually like and prefer.
1:41:50And so I have them here and I was wearing them around the house and my wife and son didn't even notice.
1:41:56And that's the truth.
1:41:57They did not say, hey, did you get new glasses?
1:41:59Why didn't you say you got new glasses?
1:42:00Let alone say anything like, hey, are those like smart glasses?
1:42:03What are those weird things on your face?
1:42:05They really do just look like glasses.
1:42:08Honest to God, it's really one of the main selling points of the glasses.
1:42:13You do not look like you're wearing anything weird.
1:42:16I can vouch for that.
1:42:17They also have a clip that you can buy, an add-on even clip that turns them into sunglasses.
1:42:23Looks very cool.
1:42:23And there is the Even R1, which is their smart ring.
1:42:28Now, the smart ring is optional, but you can use it to tap, press, and scroll the content you see on screen.
1:42:34So it's a controller that you can use for the Even G2 glasses.
1:42:39And the R1 ring also has built-in health sensors that track sleep activity and other things like that that you would want in a smart ring.
1:42:47So it's like a regular smart ring and also an optional control.
1:42:51It is on your finger for the Even G2 glasses.
1:42:54You know what I mean.
1:42:55To learn more about Even G2, go to Even, E-V-E-N, like odd or even, EvenRealities.com, and see how everyday smart glasses keep helpful information in sight so you can stay productive and hands-free throughout the day.
1:43:12And for listeners of the talk show, use promo code TALKSHOW, not know the, just TALKSHOW, at EvenRealities.com, and you will get 10% off the Even R1 ring and or the Even clip, the sunglasses clip, when you add them to your Even G2 smart glasses order.
1:43:32That's EvenRealities.com, promo code TALKSHOW.
1:43:36There's other things to do, for sure, and we, I mean, before 24, like if you count the last several years of WBDCs leading up to that, they were doing good with that stuff, right?
1:43:47It's like, oh, Reminders gets this feature, it gets it everywhere.
1:43:50Safari has this new privacy thing, it works on your phone and your Mac seamlessly.
1:43:54Like, they still have to do all that stuff, they have to leave time to talk about that stuff.
1:43:59That was the other kind of weird thing in 24, is some stuff that felt like it would make the keynote was either in the developer State of the Union or buried somewhere in a document.
1:44:09It's like, okay, like you maybe misspent your time, but I suspect that they have worked on this one very hard to find that balance.
1:44:19To say what they need to say, not over-promise, and just try to gain some of that authenticity back that they sort of blew two years ago.
1:44:30Yeah.
1:44:30Yeah, and on the user interface front, I mean, I think keeping it very short, I do, the way, and some people, for as vociferous as my criticism has been about macOS Tahoe,
1:44:43I am not a more or less pro-liquid glass elsewhere.
1:44:48I think, I do, I haven't talked about it, but I do think it's, I think it's out of place on Apple Watch.
1:44:53I don't think Apple Watch needed to be updated for it, and I think it's weird that buttons that used to be entirely flat on Apple Watch now have a bit of three-dimensionality.
1:45:03It's the one platform where I think being completely flat was right.
1:45:08But even there, it's not over the top.
1:45:09I don't hear anybody saying, boy, they really ruined my Apple Watch with watchOS 11.
1:45:13It's not that different.
1:45:15And I think it's such an interesting idea overall on the touch platforms, and it gives them this foundation to build on.
1:45:23It's like, hey, they can just say, they don't have to backtrack and say, hey, we really screwed up last year.
1:45:29They can say, hey, last year we laid the foundation for the future, and now we can really make it sing and kind of say it that way and then undo some of the things they did that were wrong.
1:45:43I think that's 100% the language that they'll use.
1:45:46And, yeah, I think, I don't mind it on the Apple Watch so much.
1:45:49I think it's best on the phone.
1:45:51Clearly, that's the first target for it, I think, internally.
1:45:54But, yeah, I think they'll spend some time maybe not talking about it, but maybe showing macOS 27 being a little bit different.
1:46:04Like, there's a demo, and maybe he does something in Finder that in 26 just looks awful.
1:46:09It's like, oh, like, you didn't say it, but I saw it.
1:46:11I think that's fine, too.
1:46:13And I certainly hope that's been on the menu for this year.
1:46:16Yeah, and, like, one of my favorite little touches last year was when they totally acknowledged in the keynote, hey, a lot of people didn't like the changes we made the year before to the first page of Apple Photos, the Photos app.
1:46:29Because we wanted to expose a bunch of these features that we felt like people weren't getting to, the special albums of Friends and Family or Recents and stuff.
1:46:39And everybody was like, I just want to see my own most recent photos when I go to the front page of Photos.
1:46:43And they were like, we heard you, and here's what we've done.
1:46:46And they fixed it, right?
1:46:47I think they actually did fix it.
1:46:49And nobody, you know, when there is, and again, if they do fix, I guess I owe them.
1:46:56If they do, if Mac OS 27 really does look good, I can't just say, oh, good, they fixed it.
1:47:01I, you know, I owe it a bit of attention to say why it's better and sing it.
1:47:07But it's never going to be as long and as lengthy as the complaints about what was bad, right?
1:47:12It's just the, it's the human nature, right?
1:47:14And so them fixing photos for a billion iPhone users last year, and I didn't hate the year before change like some people did.
1:47:25I actually didn't mind it.
1:47:26But when I listened to the criticism from the people who hated it, I, it's like, oh, I see what you don't like about it.
1:47:33I don't mind that, but I, but it's, the proof is that there just haven't been complaints in the last year about the Photos app.
1:47:41And the Photos app is one of those handful of apps that almost all iPhone users use and consider important.
1:47:49You really can't not use it.
1:47:51Even if you use like Google Photos or some other cloud service, if you take a picture with the stock camera, it's going in the stock Photos app.
1:47:58Or if you take a photo with a third-party camera, right?
1:48:00I mean, I think there's more people who use Photos than who use the camera app.
1:48:03Probably.
1:48:04It's because people who use the third-party camera app still use Photos to manage the library, and there just haven't been complaints.
1:48:12So that was a total win.
1:48:13They do listen, you know, and I think they could do that.
1:48:16I would expect to come out of WWDC.
1:48:19I have very high hopes for liking the user interfaces across the board.
1:48:23I really do.
1:48:24And I think that Alan Dye's departure is a good rethink, too.
1:48:27And it's not, oh, let's make Stephen LeMay, Steve LeMay a savior and hope that he's going to do revolutionary things.
1:48:34And if you think that the entire liquid glass direction is trash, he's going to make you happy.
1:48:39Well, that's not going to happen.
1:48:41But I do think it's a time for reflection and hey.
1:48:45And the other thing, too, is that the current Apple, and it's clearly the way they like it, but under Craig Federighi, they ship everything at the same year, right?
1:48:58And in years past, 10 years ago, if they were going to do something like this, it would have shipped for iPhone only last year.
1:49:04Well, that's how it was.
1:49:05There was iOS 7, and then Mavericks was still glossy and shiny, and then whatever California place came after Mavericks.
1:49:14I don't even know if they did iPad the first year, did they?
1:49:17They did.
1:49:17I remember only because the beta was late.
1:49:20And it was still called iOS.
1:49:22Yeah.
1:49:22It wasn't iPadOS.
1:49:23Yeah.
1:49:24Yeah, but it was beta and broken.
1:49:26They ship all this stuff.
1:49:28They did it all in the first year.
1:49:29But that doesn't change the fact that they could only do so much in a year, right?
1:49:35They just shipped it all.
1:49:37It's like you could still see that it was best and designed first for iPhone.
1:49:42Yeah, 100%.
1:49:43Right.
1:49:44Anything else you want to get to before we...
1:49:47No, I think that's it.
1:49:48It's always a fun time of year.
1:49:50So, in some ways, it feels like each WBC has a new layer of complexity to it.
1:49:57I think...
1:49:58I'm hopeful about it.
1:49:59I think they're going to get this one right.
1:50:00Yeah, I do too.
1:50:01And I think the other thing is as exciting as AI still is, and the way that their companies still haven't IPO'd, and there's tons of money,
1:50:09I think that the rules of the game and, oh, the nature of the whole thing is more in focus, right?
1:50:16It's not totally in focus.
1:50:18It's still some uncertainty as to how much better it can get, but I feel like the whole, hey, maybe we don't even need an operating system thinking is gone, right?
1:50:27It's a little more, oh, this is a major new technological step change, and we have to adapt to it, and that's it.
1:50:34But we kind of get it.
1:50:35I think that's right.
1:50:36Yeah.
1:50:37All right, my thanks to our sponsors.
1:50:40We had Squarespace, where you can build a website, Factor, where you can get meals to eat, and Notion, of course, Notion, where you can build on their AI platform for developers.