Podcast Search

The Talk Show

450: ‘Perp Walk for Selfies’, With Jason Snell

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00We should start the show.

0:00:00Actually, maybe this could be the show, Jason.

0:00:05I haven't even looked at the Safari and WebKit 27 changes.

0:00:09Have you?

0:00:10No.

0:00:11Although, don't most of those things show up in the purple Safari?

0:00:14Yeah.

0:00:15Yeah.

0:00:16Purple Safari.

0:00:17Safari ST.

0:00:18I always call it STP because that's how I launch it.

0:00:20Safari Tech Preview.

0:00:22Or actually, Safari Technology Preview.

0:00:25Quite the mouthful.

0:00:26Right.

0:00:27That tends to have the stuff that's going to be shipping later in the final.

0:00:32I don't know.

0:00:32We record so many of these podcasts using browser-based tools, and almost invariably, they demand that

0:00:38you use Chrome, which takes me unpleasantly back to the days where everything was best

0:00:43in Internet Explorer.

0:00:43But I have yet to get a good explanation from Apple about why it has failed to support large

0:00:51swaths of the WebRTC frameworks that are used by Chromium browsers.

0:00:56and all of these web apps.

0:00:58And it's very frustrating because Safari is so compatible in so many ways, and yet they

0:01:03seem to have drawn the line here.

0:01:04And it means that I just have to keep Chrome around to record podcasts.

0:01:08Yeah.

0:01:09What are you using?

0:01:10Are you using Chrome Chrome?

0:01:11I'm using Chrome Chrome because I could not care less.

0:01:14Like, I have no opinions.

0:01:17I am a Safari user.

0:01:19I'm very happy in Safari, and so when they say, use Chrome, like, I stop.

0:01:23I'm like, Chrome, fine.

0:01:24Got it.

0:01:25I am recording this on this little podcast workstation I have in Chrome Chrome.

0:01:32But on my main Mac, I think I've deleted all other Chromium browsers except one, which is a newcomer

0:01:39called Helium.

0:01:40Have you seen Helium?

0:01:41No.

0:01:42And I just wrote it down, so I should put it in the show notes.

0:01:45But it's free.

0:01:46It's, I don't know who's making it.

0:01:48I just saw, I don't have it off the top of my head, but somebody just wrote a review of

0:01:52it.

0:01:53It is like the de-googled Chromium browser that I've sort of been looking for.

0:02:02And I, for a while, I used Brave, and Brave isn't bad, but it still is trying to steer you

0:02:08towards their Brave search engine.

0:02:11And Helium, it is a plain browser with no opinion on where you search, and it doesn't add any

0:02:18AI.

0:02:18It's just a Chrome without any other junk, no Ask Gemini thing in the corner.

0:02:24And it has native support for Kagi as their search engine, so you can log in.

0:02:31You know, you don't have to use any kind of tricks or anything.

0:02:33You can just pick Kagi and sign in.

0:02:35Anyway, I'll put a link in the search.

0:02:37I should use it down here, too.

0:02:39I don't know.

0:02:39And every week or two, there's an update with the new Chromium engine.

0:02:43Anyway, these things never last, though.

0:02:45That's the thing.

0:02:46Because I think it's...

0:02:47No, it's hard.

0:02:48If it's a free effort, it's like eventually your willpower to keep maintaining a free browser

0:02:55runs out after a while, and then you have to go look for another one.

0:02:58Remember Kamino?

0:02:59That was really...

0:03:00I mean, that was a good example of this, where somebody was like, I can do a proper Mac version

0:03:03of whatever that was.

0:03:06Firefox?

0:03:06I don't even remember what that was.

0:03:07It was the Firefox engine wrapped in a truly native Mac app.

0:03:13And what was his name?

0:03:14Dave?

0:03:15I want to remember it, but I'm going to have to look it up.

0:03:18Anybody old enough to remember it can't remember it.

0:03:21Yeah.

0:03:24But it was sort of a weird proof of concept for what became Safari, even though Safari didn't

0:03:32use the Firefox rendering engine, whatever it's called.

0:03:36Dave Hyatt.

0:03:37I did not have to look it up.

0:03:39It came to me.

0:03:39Dave Hyatt.

0:03:41And he was also a great blogger for a while.

0:03:43I think he's still at Apple, but he's just one of these guys who decided to drop off the

0:03:49public internet and can't blame him.

0:03:51You're either full-fledged internet personality, or maybe you just want to get work done.

0:03:57But yeah, so Dave Hyatt worked at Netscape and then ended up going to work for Apple.

0:04:01But in there, that was very much an era where it was sort of like nobody really knew what

0:04:07a proper Mac app is, and a lot of stuff was built in the sort of, it's Unix, let's just

0:04:11get it up and running and it'll look terrible.

0:04:13And then Camino felt like a good app, which is why we used it for a long time.

0:04:17But it was also an open source project with a small group that was using somebody else's

0:04:22browser engine.

0:04:22And I wish all of those people well, but you're right.

0:04:25It just tends to not work in the long run because very few people use it and there's more

0:04:31overhead and then invariably some part of the API gets cut off and you don't have a way

0:04:34forward and then that's the end of it.

0:04:37Yeah, it is kind of crazy to think about it, that there was no system level web kit.

0:04:42So it was like this, it was a very long time ago, but Camino was a truly native Mac app,

0:04:49but wrapped the Firefox engine and the Firefox engine, just the rendering engine so badly wanted

0:04:57to be the same on every platform that it was hard to get native stuff in the engine.

0:05:04And it was sort of like the way that Firefox was engineered back then that the Firefox app

0:05:11itself, the official Firefox app was also written in the engine.

0:05:15So it was, it was more than a web rendering engine.

0:05:19It wanted to be a UI toolkit too.

0:05:21And Camino was like, no, no, you're just going to render web pages in a rectangle and we're

0:05:27going to draw the actual browser using Coco.

0:05:29Yeah, that was, I think the key thing is in that era, they were so focused on building the

0:05:34engine that they were like, let's just build a basic cross-platform browser framework around

0:05:38it and the Camino project was like, how about a good app with that at its core, which is

0:05:44what many other browsers did.

0:05:46It's what Safari did with a different engine.

0:05:49And yeah, it's actually a great example of, I think maybe even in the early days, how there

0:05:54are a lot of people who are really invested in web technologies and we love them, right?

0:05:57We love them.

0:05:58But a lot of the people invested in web technologies have this moment where they think it's all

0:06:03you ever need is web technologies.

0:06:05We can do everything on the web and the browser Chrome doesn't really matter and it matters.

0:06:13So you end up with these scenarios where sometimes like Mozilla is a great example or Firefox where

0:06:18it always felt kind of, to me, it always felt kind of clumsy and not quite right, but good

0:06:23browser.

0:06:24But then the other part wasn't there.

0:06:26So Camino was a great example of people saying, actually, the Chrome matters.

0:06:29Ironically, Chrome, the browser Chrome matters.

0:06:32And I mean, Chrome, that's how, that's part of what Chrome is.

0:06:36Chrome is at least one of the original ideas was we're going to build an app around this

0:06:42browsing framework.

0:06:43And yeah, the browser app should be good.

0:06:45And they should be, I would say, platform native because what are we even doing here?

0:06:48The browser engine shouldn't be, right?

0:06:50The browser engine should be the same everywhere, more or less, because the web should look like

0:06:55the web wherever you go.

0:06:56But the tool you use to browse should feel like your platform, I think.

0:07:00Yeah.

0:07:01Well, here we are.

0:07:04Wasting 10 minutes.

0:07:06Instead of talking about baseball, we're talking about web.

0:07:08Baseball or keyboards.

0:07:08Now it's old web browsers.

0:07:10Old web browsers.

0:07:12CaminoBrowser.org is still up, though.

0:07:15So everybody can just check that out.

0:07:16They're still paying that bill.

0:07:19I saw you last week at WWDC.

0:07:22You saw me.

0:07:23It was good to see you.

0:07:25We sat next to each other at the keynote, which was fun.

0:07:27We were both, I used a notebook.

0:07:28I used a reporter's notebook.

0:07:30I did the grouper method.

0:07:31That's right.

0:07:32You did.

0:07:33I noticed that.

0:07:33I've aspired to that for a very long time, but I was so trained to be covering breaking

0:07:37news when I was at Macworld that it's been hard to kind of let it go.

0:07:41But I decided I was going to fully embrace the sort of slower, deeper set of notes where

0:07:46I can sort of circle things and draw arrows toward things and stuff like that.

0:07:50And so I felt great sitting next to you because I knew you were also going to just take notes

0:07:56in your notebook.

0:07:56We also sat either right next to each other or sort of next to each other at the tech talk

0:08:03that was after the keynote.

0:08:05I think I was, was I sandwiched between you and Mike?

0:08:08I think, I know Mike was on the other side of you.

0:08:11Yeah.

0:08:11I'm not sure.

0:08:12Maybe I had John Voorhees next to me, but yeah, we were all there right behind the big

0:08:16wigs.

0:08:17Yeah.

0:08:18Well, we were in the second row, which was the first row they would let us into because

0:08:23the first row was reserved for Apple senior executives.

0:08:27I had Federico next to me because I have a picture of Tim looking up, Tim and Ternus looking

0:08:33up at Craig Federici on stage, but Federico was to my left and he had that shot that he

0:08:39posted, which is just John and Tim looking up into the Apple logo on the stage.

0:08:46And it's like, oh, I didn't see that.

0:08:48But I was one over from that.

0:08:49So I don't have that shot.

0:08:50I didn't see that.

0:08:51Did he post that on Mastodon or something?

0:08:53He posted, he wrote a blog post about sort of 10 years of covering WWDC and it's one

0:08:57of the pictures in there and it's great.

0:08:59It's just out of context.

0:09:00Whereas I like mine because I felt like that entire tech talk and maybe some of it was knowing

0:09:05the context and some of it was just sitting right behind Tim Cook and watching Tim Cook

0:09:09watch Craig Federici.

0:09:11But like, I was so nervous for the guy.

0:09:13And my picture is sort of like Craig's on stage working really hard as John Ternus and Tim Cook

0:09:18are judging him for how he's doing.

0:09:20Don't say anything dumb, Craig.

0:09:22You better get this right, Craig.

0:09:23Because I mean, I think Craig Federici is under some pressure.

0:09:27He's not the chief software officer, right?

0:09:29He's still got his old title and it's his job right now to deliver some real mission critical

0:09:34stuff over the next year or two.

0:09:36And I felt those vibes a little bit and how much of that is me versus the room.

0:09:41I don't know, but he's on stage sort of sweating and working hard with his team up there

0:09:46as the current and future CEOs sit down there and judge.

0:09:50I mean, there was something, I don't know.

0:09:53I felt it.

0:09:53Yeah, I know what you mean.

0:09:56It was a thing and I was glad to have had a, well, I was going to say front row seat, but

0:10:03that's a second row seat, but a front row seat to the front row to sort of see it.

0:10:10And it's like, oh yeah, this is why you show up early.

0:10:13So you get a good seat for things like this.

0:10:15Federico, to his credit, was the one who basically was the pioneer and was like, I'm sitting in

0:10:18the second row.

0:10:19They won't tell me I can't.

0:10:20I'm just going to go sit right there.

0:10:21And then he just waved us all in and we were like, okay, well, I guess we'll sit in the

0:10:25second.

0:10:25And then Tim Cook comes and sits right in front of me.

0:10:27Well, the funny part was it was supposed to start at noon.

0:10:32A, the actual keynote was very short.

0:10:34Well, one of, I haven't looked it up, but it may or may be the shortest WWDC keynote ever.

0:10:41I mean, if not, it's got to be close.

0:10:44I think it was 74 minutes.

0:10:45It was an hour and 14 minutes or 16 minutes or something like that.

0:10:49And for the last few years, they were all, the last few were like an hour 45, an hour 50 minutes.

0:10:58I don't think any of them went over two hours, but they were all closer to two hours.

0:11:03So the keynote was short and we had plenty of time to get there, but it's a fairly small room.

0:11:10How many seats do you think in that developer center theater?

0:11:13Oh, I'm really bad at that.

0:11:15I don't know.

0:11:15Yeah, I am too.

0:11:16I'm really bad too.

0:11:17It's a small, I mean, it's maybe, yeah, I mean, maybe it's two, 300, but it's, it's wide and not that deep.

0:11:25Yeah.

0:11:25And it might be three or 400, but it's not, it's, it's more like a community theater, right?

0:11:30Yeah, because it's outside, the outside viewing of the keynote, they are pretty liberal with press passes.

0:11:40We're glad, I'm glad they are.

0:11:42I saw lots and lots of, lots of people who I know don't get invited to every event.

0:11:47That's great.

0:11:48But this, because it's a smaller inside thing, it was only a subset of the media who got the, what was it?

0:11:54Like a purple, we got a little purple card on our badges.

0:12:00We got there, it was supposed to start at noon and it's like 1159 and that's when Jaws and Ternus and Trudy Miller from PR come in.

0:12:12And I cracked a joke like, nice to come in at the last minute.

0:12:15And Jaws laughed and Ternus laughed and everybody waved and we're like, oh, we got good seats.

0:12:21And then Cook came in at, I don't know, like 12.00 on the dot.

0:12:26Yeah, yeah, just because the lights went up.

0:12:28And I have to admit, I felt the, oh, I'm not making a joke about him.

0:12:32No, Trudy, so Trudy from Apple PR, she used to do product PR and I know her from way back.

0:12:38She's, I think she's on executive PR now.

0:12:41And so she was in that seat and turned around and just chatting with me for like, there's a long, funny story about how back in the day when Lex Friedman worked for Macworld, he would occasionally leave her messages and she wouldn't call him back.

0:12:56And he would leave like increasingly long messages where he would have like these kind of like chatty.

0:13:02It was, it just, it was very endearing.

0:13:04And so I said, Lex says hi.

0:13:05And she's like, oh, what's Lex up to these days?

0:13:07It was very nice.

0:13:08And then there was a moment where she just got tapped on the shoulder and disappeared.

0:13:12And then Tim sat down.

0:13:13I was like, oh, I see.

0:13:15She was just holding, holding Tim's seat, waiting for Tim to arrive.

0:13:18And then she moved down the row a little bit.

0:13:20But yeah, that was weird.

0:13:22That was, I mean, I've never, afterward, I said hi to Tim Cook.

0:13:25I've literally never interacted with Tim Cook in my life.

0:13:28I interviewed Steve Jobs, right?

0:13:29But like, I literally have never interacted with Tim Cook.

0:13:32John Ternus knows who we are.

0:13:34He said hi to me.

0:13:35He said hi to Mike.

0:13:36He said hi to you.

0:13:37He's either, either he knows who we are, like for realsies, or he's really well coached.

0:13:43But we were at an iPhone event, I think a couple of years ago where the same thing happened.

0:13:47We were standing there and John Ternus just walked up and said, hi, John.

0:13:49Hi, Jason.

0:13:50I am pretty convinced that Tim Cook has no idea who I am, but I did get one kind of like handshake before he goes.

0:13:58I kind of watched you doing it because we filed out to the left, so I was leaving first.

0:14:03And then I heard you talking to Tim, and I was like, oh, I'll eavesdrop on that a little bit.

0:14:08And I heard what you said.

0:14:09It was pretty much what you just said.

0:14:10It was, yeah, it was very much like, I think I said something like, thanks for all your work or whatever.

0:14:15Because it's like, how can you encapsulate?

0:14:18And it's complex.

0:14:19But my feeling was sort of like, I have been writing about you and the work that you do for longer than you've been CEO.

0:14:25And you get to retire now, more or less.

0:14:29So I kind of wanted to say, good job.

0:14:32I'm not an investor.

0:14:34You didn't make me any money, but I did write about all your work, and that's my profession.

0:14:38I don't know.

0:14:39I had that moment where it's like, I don't need an interaction with Tim Cook, but I'm never going to get the chance again.

0:14:44And he's standing right in front of me, shaking other people's hands.

0:14:46And I'm like, okay, I'll do this.

0:14:48That's fine.

0:14:49And I always feel like with famous people, especially, the biggest gift I can give a famous person is not bugging them.

0:14:54So I generally don't do that.

0:14:55I had that moment where I'm like, oh, George Lucas.

0:14:58When we moved to Marin County, George Lucas is literally at the next table at the shopping mall at Christmas time when we went to get lunch.

0:15:05And my gift to George Lucas was, we didn't say anything to George Lucas.

0:15:09That seems like the nice thing to do.

0:15:12But in that moment where Tim's not going anywhere, he's stuck in the middle there waiting for everybody to file out before he can disappear.

0:15:18And so I took that moment.

0:15:20That was mine.

0:15:21It did occur to me.

0:15:23And I'm sure he knows who you are.

0:15:25Now, whether he can put a name to the face, I don't know.

0:15:30I don't know.

0:15:31He shouldn't be wasting time on me.

0:15:32I'm sure he knows Six Colors, right?

0:15:35And especially just because Six Colors has so thoroughly covered the quarterly calls for so long.

0:15:43I mean, I would honestly say that it's sort of the canonical site for the quarterly calls.

0:15:48And it's not like Tim needs to go to the web to get the charts and graphs of Apple's finances, which would be funny if he did.

0:16:00I'm laughing here.

0:16:01What did I say?

0:16:02Bring up the transcript.

0:16:05Right.

0:16:06But I think it's so prominent.

0:16:09I'm sure he does.

0:16:10But it is interesting.

0:16:11And it did strike me in that moment in the Tech Talk Theater in the second row with Ternus and Cook.

0:16:21I took a couple pictures.

0:16:22I got a couple good ones of Ternus and Cook next to each other because I was so close.

0:16:25And it occurred to me, like, when Ternus sat down, I could crack a joke.

0:16:31And I do know Ternus.

0:16:32Ternus was on the talk show live back when people like that used to appear on the show two years ago, three years ago.

0:16:40I don't know if it was the last one that they appeared on or the second to last.

0:16:45But Ternus was there, I think it was two years ago when they announced Vision Pro.

0:16:49And it was, yeah.

0:16:51And Ternus did the first half of the show.

0:16:53And then Rockwell came out and took his spot for the second half of the show.

0:16:57That sounds right.

0:16:58And Federighi and Jaws stayed throughout.

0:17:01And I ran into Ternus here in Philadelphia when he, because he went to Penn.

0:17:09I think you might have told this story on the last time I was on, which is like he's literally walking down the street.

0:17:15In front of your house.

0:17:15In front of my house.

0:17:17And I was like, that's John Ternus.

0:17:18I was like, I guess I should go outside and say hello.

0:17:20Yeah.

0:17:20And I did.

0:17:21So I definitely know him to say hello to.

0:17:24And he was on my show.

0:17:25And I've seen him milling about outside Steve Jobs Theater.

0:17:31I don't know which events.

0:17:32They all blur together.

0:17:33But sometimes they'll have us up there in that outside level of Steve Jobs Theater before letting us downstairs for an event.

0:17:41And I've talked to him for 30 seconds there, here and there.

0:17:44I did.

0:17:46I never had like an on-the-record interview with Steve Jobs.

0:17:49But I spoke to him in person twice.

0:17:52Including one that was like an off-the-record briefing.

0:17:57It was me and M.G.

0:17:58Siegler and a guy from the New York Times.

0:18:03A couple of the Times and the USA Today writers are long gone.

0:18:06They're not even – they're not bylines that appear anymore.

0:18:10Right.

0:18:10Like Ed Bigg and –

0:18:12Yeah.

0:18:12That was the – and then I wrote about it when Jobs died that it was – because it was like the WWDC, the year that he died.

0:18:20So I guess 2011.

0:18:21After the keynote.

0:18:23And I wrote about like I mentioned I just noticed because – and that was one too where I took a good seat.

0:18:28They let us in and the way I've told the story is it's the closest I'll ever feel to when Lando Calrissian is taking Han and Leia and Chewie to dinner.

0:18:39And they open the door and holy shit there's Darth Vader at the end of the table.

0:18:43They didn't tell us who we were meeting with.

0:18:45They were just – it was Steve Dowling at the time in Apple PR.

0:18:49And they had me and MG –

0:18:50He was the exact guy, yeah.

0:18:51Miguel, somebody from the New York Times, and somebody from USA Today.

0:18:56So it was just four of us after the keynote upstairs at Moscone.

0:19:01And it was like – it was running a little late and they took us – it was like – because it's Moscone.

0:19:08So it wasn't a room.

0:19:09It was like a room they made with curtains.

0:19:11And there was like a table – a long table.

0:19:13And Phil Schiller was in there.

0:19:15A couple other people were in there.

0:19:18But at the end of the table was Steve Jobs.

0:19:20And I was like –

0:19:22Darth Vader right there.

0:19:23Yeah.

0:19:24And I – the way that Han Solo took out his blaster and started shooting, I just like, I'm taking the seat next to Steve.

0:19:30And I just marched in.

0:19:32I was like, to hell with these other guys.

0:19:34I'm taking that seat.

0:19:35And sat right next to him.

0:19:37So I've met him.

0:19:38And he emailed me like twice.

0:19:40And then I, of course, emailed him back.

0:19:43The only times I've ever seen Tim Cook were totally random.

0:19:48One time I saw him.

0:19:49He walked past me downstairs in one of the years when WWDC was at the San Jose Convention Center.

0:19:58Oh, yeah.

0:19:59Outside the – remember they had like a media green room in a weird space.

0:20:03And it was like in Vegas vacation when they go to the Mirage and they check in.

0:20:09And she's like, go to the slot machines.

0:20:11Then make a right.

0:20:11Go to the blackjack table.

0:20:13So if you get to the second set of elevators, the ones that have gold buttons, you've gone too far.

0:20:18Go back to the ones with the silver buttons and hit up.

0:20:21You know, and it's like really, really complicated.

0:20:24It was like here's how you get to the green room.

0:20:25And I'm out there waiting.

0:20:27And it was locked.

0:20:28And you had to like wait for like someone from PR to let you in.

0:20:31So I'm just standing there annoyed that the door was locked and mildly annoyed.

0:20:37I'm easy to get along with.

0:20:38And then Tim Cook just walks right past me.

0:20:40And I was like, hey, John Gruber.

0:20:42And he was like, hey, how you doing?

0:20:43But he didn't stop walking, which is like a patented famous person, important person move.

0:20:51And I was just like.

0:20:52It's funny, too, because there's like the buzz of famous people around them.

0:20:57We were at a, I don't know if you went.

0:20:59There was a reception thing on Sunday night before.

0:21:01No, I couldn't make it.

0:21:03And all of a sudden there's a hubbub and it's John Ternus has walked, did a walk through and a bunch of, you know, influencers.

0:21:09Because it's all media and influencers.

0:21:12And so all the influencers and creators go over to do a selfie with him.

0:21:16It was basically his perp walk for selfies.

0:21:18Those in my group were like, nope, not interested at all.

0:21:23But little did we know we would get some more chatting time with them.

0:21:27And then there was, you took pictures of it.

0:21:30I was talking to Ternus and Jaws and Phil Schiller at that New York event.

0:21:35I was literally talking to Phil.

0:21:36I was just talking to Phil.

0:21:38And John Ternus walks up and Greg Joswiak walks up.

0:21:41And I'm like, what is happening here?

0:21:43But Phil is the one that I've gotten emails from in the past.

0:21:46Because he just, we're not just talking about, it's not even being starstruck.

0:21:52It's more like these are the subjects of our careers, but there's a remove there.

0:21:57So when they're actually human beings in front of you, it's a little bit uncanny, I would say, because they know us and we know them.

0:22:05And that is the truth is, I don't know if any granted CEO or whatever like Tim knows in detail who I am.

0:22:13But I will say people below him know exactly every word we write and every word we speak because it's their job too.

0:22:19And that filters around.

0:22:20And that part is true.

0:22:22So it is this weird thing where I kind of don't want to think about that because it's not my job to care what they are reading of mine.

0:22:30But it is a weird thing when you're then in the same room with them because we're not, I write about what I think about what they say and talk about what I think about what they say.

0:22:42And what they say is very carefully crafted not to touch on subjects that then you and I will immediately talk about.

0:22:48And so there's a real disconnect because our job is not their job.

0:22:52In some ways, it's the opposite of their job.

0:22:54But we're also on the same playing field.

0:22:56It's a weird thing.

0:22:57It's weird.

0:22:58Yeah, it is.

0:23:00And I don't know how well I manage it.

0:23:01But you do have to, or at least to do the job that we want to do, you have to kind of disassociate from the fact that, well, I know Greg Joswiak personally.

0:23:14I know Phil Schiller.

0:23:15I know they read my stuff.

0:23:17I'm going to write this and I'm going to see them again.

0:23:19But there's definitely not a like this one goes out to Jaws, right?

0:23:22No, right.

0:23:23It's not what we're doing, but you know that it's happening.

0:23:26And I guess it is somewhere on the spectrum of sociopathy, right?

0:23:32Like most humans can't disconnect from it.

0:23:35But when I'm writing and I'm in the flow of writing a column on Daring Fireball, I can totally just disassociate from what the people, if it's a negative slant on whatever, and I think those people are going to read it.

0:23:49I can just disassociate from it if I think this is fair and true and what I want to communicate to the readers.

0:23:56I really do feel like...

0:23:58That's a classic journalism thing.

0:24:00And you got it exactly right there, which is you're focused on communicating to the people who read your stuff.

0:24:04You're not sending smoke signals to Apple.

0:24:06And what I always say is like they know how the game is played.

0:24:09They know how this works.

0:24:10If my job was just to please them, I don't think they would care a little bit about what I do, right?

0:24:16Like we exist because our job is not there just to please them and to write words that they want to write because they write those words.

0:24:23They do the PR.

0:24:24They don't need more PR.

0:24:25And that's our role in the ecosystem is to write what we want and to think about the people who read or listen to our stuff.

0:24:31And I don't have any close personal relationships with Apple executives, but I know who they are.

0:24:38And I mean, it is hard not to.

0:24:40I got ambushed by everybody else in New York.

0:24:42I was just reminiscing with Phil because Phil's been there so long and I've been doing this for so long now that like I remember when Phil came to the Macworld offices to demo a version of OS X.

0:24:53Let me tell you, Apple doesn't visit somebody's offices anymore.

0:24:56You go see them.

0:24:57But they did a road show.

0:25:00They did a road show about 10-1 or something like that because they really wanted people in the install base to get it.

0:25:07So it was very much like that was just kind of fun because it's like he remembers stuff from the 90s and I remember stuff from the 90s that nobody else does.

0:25:15And Jaws is a very similar guy who, I mean, he was like the product marketing manager for the PowerBook back in the 90s.

0:25:21So that's how I got to know him.

0:25:23So, yeah, it's weird because, I mean, I guess that's the classic journalist and subject thing and you just don't want to get captured.

0:25:29You got to keep your independence even though you're aware that you're right.

0:25:33I wouldn't say it's like being a sociopath, but you do have to disconnect a little bit.

0:25:39It's on the spectrum.

0:25:41As a normal empathetic human being, you would say, oh, there's that guy I know, Jaws.

0:25:47He's going to be sad when I write this thing.

0:25:49And it's like, but it doesn't matter, right?

0:25:51Like you just, it doesn't matter.

0:25:53You can't do that.

0:25:54Right.

0:25:55So how do I phrase it so he's not mad or he's not hurt or whatever?

0:25:59A lesson I learned the hard way at Macworld was it's not personal because we had a writer who got in trouble because they were like, it was a really good lesson to learn.

0:26:13I'm sorry that this writer had to learn it and I just had to observe it as one of their editors.

0:26:16But like, they made it personal where they're like, oh, Phil Schiller is doing this thing and all of that.

0:26:21And it's like, but Apple, you don't actually know.

0:26:23Nobody signs their work.

0:26:25It's just from Apple.

0:26:26And if you start to personalize it and say like, this person should be fired or this person screwed up and you don't know it for a fact, it's just don't make it personal.

0:26:35Apple is Apple and Apple does things and then you can criticize them.

0:26:40But if you make it too personal, because like, even with somebody like Alan, and I know you, like you may have personal with Alan Dye, right?

0:26:46But like, you may know, I don't know for a fact that Alan Dye did X.

0:26:50I just know that under his watch, they did X.

0:26:53And so I try not to make it too personal because that's when I think it becomes problematic.

0:26:57Because if you're like, hey, you person who works at Apple, you suck, right?

0:27:02It's like, let's talk about the work and whether it's good or bad.

0:27:06But I try to avoid getting personal, especially about people I don't know.

0:27:12And I don't know if they're – sometimes I have found behind the scenes that it's exactly who you think it is.

0:27:19Other times I've found that it's not at all who you thought it was and that the person you thought was responsible was actually fighting the good fight and they lost the fight.

0:27:26So don't blame them.

0:27:28So I've become really reluctant to personify a lot of stuff because you don't know.

0:27:33Unless you do actually literally know what went down, and most of the time I certainly don't, and sometimes it happens way after the fact, I just am reluctant to do that.

0:27:42And I just try to follow that.

0:27:43It's like, I don't know who's responsible for this, but I can still say that it's bad.

0:27:47Yeah, and the Alan Dye example is a good one.

0:27:49I just got an email from a reader, and I'm so far behind on email, but I happened to stumble across one where some reader very kindly said something to the effect of, hey, aren't you making this too personal with Alan Dye with the interface stuff?

0:28:02Like, I don't think you have to do that.

0:28:05And my response was, well, I know some things about how it went down and how the culture had developed under his leadership, especially in the last few years.

0:28:16And I stand behind it to the degree that I've made fun of him personally, but to the effect that if I ever ran into him again, and he's a very – you can't miss him because he's six foot five or something like that.

0:28:30And I have heard from somebody through the grapevine, somebody who's at Meta or somebody who still knows him somehow, that he's noticed his mentions on Derek Fireball and has been a little confused by them.

0:28:44If I ran into him again, I think we could have a laugh about it.

0:28:47I genuinely do.

0:28:48And I'm not saying all would be forgiven, but I could – if I saw him, I would go up to him and say, hey, and then he would say, hey, and we would talk it out.

0:28:58Like, I could stand behind everything I wrote about it.

0:29:01But I mentioned to this reader, you will note that I haven't done the same thing with John Gian and Drea.

0:29:07I haven't made jokes about the fact that they forced him out or whatever.

0:29:11I think – like, my problem with Alan Dye is I think his intentions were actually bad.

0:29:16And I think his respect for especially the Mac wasn't there and should have been.

0:29:23And the stories I've heard about his personal style of leadership within the design company, it just seems worth making – fair game to make fun of.

0:29:33Yeah.

0:29:33Whereas John Gian and Drea, I think, meant well and just failed at the job.

0:29:37And that's it.

0:29:39So it turns out I know somebody who worked with John Gian and Drea before at a previous job.

0:29:43And I had no idea about this until like two weeks ago where he was like, oh, yeah, I work with JG.

0:29:48And I said, okay, my theory is that they hired JG because they wanted somebody who could help long-term building machine learning models because they know that machine learning models are important.

0:29:58They've been focusing on that with Apple Silicon for years and all of that.

0:30:01My theory was he brought a very academic viewpoint, a very kind of like we're here to do research.

0:30:06And then that moment where the chatbots took off, everybody at Apple was like, oh, no, you need to now – you need to be a product person now.

0:30:13And he was – and my guess – my read on it is that he was probably the wrong person to do that because that's not what he was hired to do and that's not what his skill set was.

0:30:23And my friend who turns out work with JG said that is absolutely the right read on him as a person, which is he's a very kind of academic, researchy kind of guy.

0:30:34So that's my – at least my read on it is that he was not hired to do the job that suddenly became the job because he was about we're going to build some new models.

0:30:44He was not trying to build a general purpose chatbot.

0:30:46He was trying to build a new image generation model and a new camera editing model and other research.

0:30:52They were very much like we're going to do research because remember, Apple before the chatbot revolution was doing a lot of AI stuff, but it was all bespoke training and models to solve specific problems.

0:31:03And I think that's what he was mostly hired to do.

0:31:07And Apple is not, especially post Steve Jobs' return, is not a company that's about pure research as much as they are about shipping the product, right?

0:31:16And I think that that is what happened is they made the mistake of bringing in a guy who was really, really brilliant at doing the research and building a knowledge base.

0:31:25But then they asked him, because of what happened with the chatbot thing, then they asked him to kind of like start shipping products, and he's the wrong guy.

0:31:32Yeah, and the other thing too, and I, again, I am not an AI expert, but I do have a computer science degree, and I do keep one of my artificial intelligence textbooks from college underneath my mouse pad because it's the perfect height for my wrist.

0:31:48Oh, man.

0:31:49You know, that's better than –

0:31:51You've been using AI forever.

0:31:52Yeah, that's way better than sleeping with a book under your pillow.

0:31:56I mean, I've got it right under my hand all day, every day, and have for years.

0:32:00But I also – I do know enough that John Gianandrea, his background in AI was on like a different fork of the whole field than LLMs.

0:32:11And that whole side had deep skepticism about how far LLMs could go.

0:32:19And Gianandrea was on that side and was fully on board and was like, yeah, this is not that big a deal.

0:32:24And honestly, you have to say at this point they were wrong.

0:32:27Now, that doesn't mean that the biggest proponents of LLMs, that the future pursuing LLMs is artificial – what is it?

0:32:38The AGI.

0:32:39What's that stand for?

0:32:40Artificial general intelligence?

0:32:42Yeah, something like that.

0:32:43The actual –

0:32:44Defense general?

0:32:46Right, or just the super intelligence like creating an intellect that is actually greater than human intelligence.

0:32:52I remain skeptical of that.

0:32:54I kind of feel like what we're seeing is that LLMs are kind of reaching – we can see how the slope of improvement is tailing off.

0:33:02And that it will keep improving, but that the great orders of magnitude leaps are sort of running out.

0:33:08And that other branches of AI might make a comeback.

0:33:13Oh, now all of a sudden there's this huge advance in machine learning or hill climbing or whatever the hell Gianandrea was a bigger proponent of.

0:33:20And that eventually – I think it's pretty obvious that eventually there will be artificial intelligence that is, quote, unquote, super intelligent.

0:33:28I mean, it's – how could they're not on a long enough timeline?

0:33:31Sure.

0:33:32And that it will probably be some kind of combination of technologies in the way that human beings – our brains are combinations of very different parts of our brain that work in very different ways and evolved at very different epochs in history.

0:33:50We've got parts of our brain that are like a billion years old, and then we've got other parts that are like 10,000 years old, and something like that.

0:33:58So there might be a being right, like, hey, I knew there was a limit on this.

0:34:02But moment this decade, he was definitely the wrong guy to be in charge of AI.

0:34:07Yeah.

0:34:08Yeah, I think in the long run what we got here is that this is the place that's the most fruitful, and so everybody's putting their foot to the floor to say we got to do this.

0:34:16But that in the long run, yeah, general purpose, there's going to be room for things that are not general purpose that are targeted.

0:34:21And that Apple – that's the most Apple, right?

0:34:24The most Apple is to say we built a model that does this, and isn't it amazing?

0:34:28And that's what they did.

0:34:29But the LLM thing happened, and they were flat-footed, and I think he was the wrong guy.

0:34:32And, again, that's – and I guess that's my point is you could be mean about John G. and Andrea, but I suspect that it's not that he is bad at his job.

0:34:44It's that he was hired to do something that suddenly became not what they needed him to do.

0:34:50And maybe that was a misread.

0:34:52Maybe that's a miscalculation.

0:34:53Maybe it's just then it's the breaks.

0:34:54Things changed, and suddenly you got to react.

0:34:57I will say, to get us back to this year, that I really got the vibe, and that tech talk was a big part of it, that the message Apple's trying to send is we have a new team and we're on it, basically.

0:35:11And, like, Mike Rockwell, especially – and we – if you know – so if you accept Mark Gurman's backstory about how Mike Rockwell was – just really thought that the best way to do a Vision Pro UI was Siri, and he was going to build around Siri for Vision Pro, and then the Siri team failed to give him anything useful.

0:35:29I just keep thinking, like, this is Rockwell's revenge, right?

0:35:33They put him in charge of Siri.

0:35:34It's like, okay, tough guy.

0:35:35You've been bellyaching about Siri.

0:35:37Fix it.

0:35:38And there's that moment in the tech talk where he said, yeah, about a year ago, we realized Siri was just not going to do it in any way, and we tore it to the ground.

0:35:45And I was like, that is one of the most outrageous statements I have ever heard from an Apple executive in terms of behind-the-scenes activity of we tore Siri to the ground because it was – and the implication there is very clear.

0:35:57It's because it couldn't be saved.

0:35:59And I think anybody who's observed Apple struggle with Siri over the last decade probably had come to the conclusion that it couldn't be saved.

0:36:06But everybody inside is like, well, we can't tear it to the ground.

0:36:08And finally, it got so bad that Rockwell was allowed to come in and say, we're going to tear it to the ground.

0:36:14And so they did.

0:36:15There are times when companies say things like that, like it's a ground-up rewrite, and you have to kind of – let me see who I can talk to off the record and see just how much.

0:36:25But this is a case where I think everybody's saying the same thing, and I think the evidence in our hands is, oh, yeah, they tore this to the – this is a ground-up rewrite.

0:36:34This is all new.

0:36:35Hold that thought, though.

0:36:36Let me take a break here and thank our first sponsor, and it's our good friends at Factor.

0:36:40Hey, maybe you've got lots of stuff in your fridge, but it's like you're busy.

0:36:44You don't have a lot of time.

0:36:45You're not going to cook a whole meal right now.

0:36:47Factor is a great service.

0:36:50You get entire meals.

0:36:52You pick.

0:36:53They have a tremendous menu every week of hundreds of meal options.

0:36:58They come prepackaged.

0:37:00You just put them in the microwave, or you can heat them up in the oven or something, but they're meant to be microwaved, and they taste great.

0:37:06And it's all a single portion for one person, the whole meal.

0:37:09Super easy, but fresh food.

0:37:13It comes to you in a box, refrigerated with, like, dry ice.

0:37:17You put it in the fridge.

0:37:18You don't want to order months and months of food.

0:37:20You order it, like going to the grocery store and getting fresh food, really fresh, really healthy, and it's a big focus.

0:37:27That's the whole focus of the whole Factor menu is fresh, healthy food and variety, and it's just really great.

0:37:34They've got so many different ways, like whatever your goals are.

0:37:38Maybe you just want tasty food that's easy to make.

0:37:41That's really my story, but if you're looking to lose weight, if you are on a high-protein diet,

0:37:48if you are on GLP-1 drugs and there are certain foods that you want to eat because of that, they have a whole, you can just click.

0:37:55That's what you want to look at, and it'll filter your options based on that.

0:37:59Strength and workout recovery, all sorts of ways to look at the menu options.

0:38:04It's really, really easy.

0:38:06Each meal is crafted with functional ingredients, lean proteins, colorful veggies, whole foods, healthy fats.

0:38:13They ban over 175 ingredients that they just do not allow in any of their meals.

0:38:19They have no artificial colors or sweeteners, no high-fructose corn syrup, no refined seed oils, just nutrient-dense ingredients.

0:38:27Fresh, never frozen, over 100 rotating weekly meals.

0:38:32My favorites, I love, A, everybody knows I love steak.

0:38:35They have really good steak.

0:38:36The filet mignon that I've gotten in a couple different ways, like just steak, mashed potatoes.

0:38:41But I really love Factor's breakfast options.

0:38:44It's so good, and it's a time of the day when I am the laziest, and definitely all of my effort goes into making my fussy coffee.

0:38:51I do not want to spend any time on breakfast, and they have so many good breakfast options.

0:38:55Really, really good.

0:38:56They've got other stuff, too.

0:38:58If you don't want entire meals, you can get ready to eat salads, all sorts of stuff like that.

0:39:02I use Factor.

0:39:04I really, really like it.

0:39:05I mean, it's really worth checking out.

0:39:07Where do you go to find out more?

0:39:08Head to factormeals.com slash talkshow50off.

0:39:14Talkshow50off.

0:39:17Factormeals.com slash talkshow50off.

0:39:21And guess what?

0:39:22With that code, talkshow50off, you get 50% off and free daily greens per box with a new subscription only.

0:39:30While supplies last until September 27th, 2026.

0:39:36See their website for more details.

0:39:38Factormeals.com slash talkshow50off.

0:39:41Well, before we move on, just going back to the whole Cook being a bit, he's not aloof, but he's standoffish.

0:39:50And he's never really been personally involved with the media in a way that Steve Jobs certainly was.

0:40:00And like I said, I've already got more of a relationship with Ternus than I had with Cook.

0:40:05And it did.

0:40:05That's it occurred to me as you were saying that to Cook shaking his hand on the way out of the theater.

0:40:12And I thought, oh, maybe I should have done that, too.

0:40:14Because when am I ever going to see him again?

0:40:15I don't even know.

0:40:16And I thought, you know, and this is it.

0:40:18This was the last Tim Cook event, presumably.

0:40:21I mean, they typically never hold events between WWDC and the iPhone event in September.

0:40:27And Ternus' start date as CEO is September 1st, which is conspicuously at the beginning of the month they do the event.

0:40:35So the iPhone event presumably will be the first John Ternus CEO-hosted event.

0:40:40And so this is it.

0:40:42Like people used to say to me, like when the executives came on my live show, like, hey, maybe it's Tim Cook this year.

0:40:49Maybe it's Tim Cook this year.

0:40:50Every year for years.

0:40:51And some number of people who were coming or just looking forward to the YouTube version were hoping.

0:40:58And I was always sort of like, I don't know about that.

0:41:02If Apple had said, hey, Tim would like to do the show, I would have said yes.

0:41:07And if they, you know, if anybody, Trudy, if you're listening, and he would like to do my show on his way out.

0:41:13Excellent interview.

0:41:14You know my phone number.

0:41:16I would love to.

0:41:17But I always, especially for the live show, I would have, as nervous and as agitated as I get to do the live show, if Tim Cook had been my guest, it would have been doubled.

0:41:32Because I just would have been worried about the vibe.

0:41:35Because I think he's an incredibly tough interview.

0:41:39Jaws and Phil before him are naturals on stage.

0:41:44They really are.

0:41:45It seems like Phil, especially.

0:41:47It's just like, was he ever on like Letterman or something?

0:41:50And the answer is no.

0:41:51But he really has an onstage demeanor, like sitting on the couch, where it seems like he was a regular on Letterman for years.

0:41:59And Jaws kind of has that too.

0:42:00And Federighi is a distinct personality, but he's good up there.

0:42:05Right?

0:42:06And he plays to the audience.

0:42:08He knows how to do that.

0:42:09And I don't think Cook does.

0:42:11Like when I've seen Cook be interviewed, he's impossible to get off talking points.

0:42:17He's well-trained.

0:42:20He is the talking points.

0:42:21Yeah.

0:42:22So here's a theory I have, which is related to this, which is think about Tim Cook's background.

0:42:28Tim Cook went to business school.

0:42:30He was in various tech companies.

0:42:32He got recruited by Steve Jobs to come and fix, again, for those who did not live through it, Apple's calamitous supply chain issues.

0:42:42They had so much extra inventory.

0:42:45This idea that they would introduce a new product and they would have thousands of the old product in a warehouse that they would just have to unload.

0:42:53Whereas the goal, which seemed impossible and has turned out to essentially be real, is that for everyone that ships, one is sold.

0:43:02And so basically we make them as fast as you buy them and we never have any inventory.

0:43:06That's sort of the goal.

0:43:07It's not quite always that way.

0:43:09Sometimes they preload.

0:43:10They have stuff in the channel.

0:43:12But he was brought in by Steve Jobs to do that.

0:43:14He's an operations guy.

0:43:15He's an efficiency guy.

0:43:17By all accounts, everybody would say incredibly efficient at that job.

0:43:21And then Steve Jobs felt this is the person I can trust to be a steady hand at the wheel after I'm gone.

0:43:30Because I believe in Tim Cook in that way.

0:43:33And he gets what I get about Apple.

0:43:36And I think that's true.

0:43:38And Steve Jobs was probably thinking, also, there's all those other people who are going to be around there to support him.

0:43:42Like Johnny and Phil.

0:43:44And they all get it, too.

0:43:46And Tim Cook will be a steady hand.

0:43:47And I defy anybody to say that Tim has not been a steady, efficient hand at the wheel all of this time.

0:43:53And he has grown the company.

0:43:54And he's done what he feels he needs to do for Wall Street and all of those things that are kind of the CEO job, while also encouraging the people around him to design products that fit Apple's approach.

0:44:05Because it's not his bag.

0:44:06All that being said, Tim is a lifelong computer industry operations man.

0:44:15Whereas, let's take John Ternus.

0:44:17John Ternus has been building hardware at Apple for 25 years.

0:44:23Right?

0:44:23Right.

0:44:25And so, I don't want to overstate this, but John Ternus is one of us, and Tim Cook isn't.

0:44:31Yeah.

0:44:32And I feel like we need to remember that.

0:44:34That, like, Tim was spotted by Steve and brought in and brings a level of competence and all of those things to the table.

0:44:45But, and he professes being a true believer in Apple's mission and understanding what it is.

0:44:52And I think to the degree that Tim Cook can be a true believer, he is.

0:44:56But somebody like John Ternus, who has been working at Apple since basically the turn of the century, and building products at a low level, is more, I just, I don't think it's outrageous to say he gets what Apple is about and what Apple customers want and what makes Apple products special at a level that Tim Cook has never and can never.

0:45:21Which is not to say that Tim Cook sucks.

0:45:22That's not what I'm saying.

0:45:23I'm saying that Tim Cook was the right guy for that time.

0:45:27But one of the things that excites me about Ternus is that Ternus understands Apple at a level that Steve Jobs did and that Tim Cook didn't.

0:45:39And that's why I think we have a better vibe with somebody like John Ternus.

0:45:44Because John Ternus was in the trenches at Apple, whereas Tim has, like, been optimizing at Apple at a high level from the beginning.

0:45:51And it's just a really different approach and a different perspective.

0:45:55And I think that's one of the reasons that John Ternus, like, knows our names is because he's been marinating in this stuff for 25 years.

0:46:04Yeah, and there's just, like, when you said, I'll just go back to when you said he is the talking points.

0:46:10Like, he is.

0:46:11Tim inhabits the talking points.

0:46:13He creates the talking points.

0:46:15Tim is, I mean, right?

0:46:17He defines them.

0:46:19And is them.

0:46:20I'm not going to complain because I think he's been incredibly competent.

0:46:22And I think that after Steve, not just after Steve died, but in the aftermath where all the people like Johnny Ive who are sort of, like, kind of done, needed to kind of, like, move on with their lives.

0:46:34And they needed to figure out what they were going to do and where the iPad was going to go and how the Mac was going to fit and all of that.

0:46:41And it was awkward.

0:46:41And, like, Tim was like, this is awkward, but also we're going to make a lot of money and it's going to be fine in the iPhone and all of that.

0:46:48I can't complain about it, but it is kind of refreshing to see a CEO coming in who I think sees Apple the way we do in a way that I don't think Tim did because Tim, it was not his perspective.

0:47:01It was not his job to see it the way we do because he was coming at it from a very different level.

0:47:06And he's just a – there's that old adage, measure twice, cut once, and Tim's more of a measure three or four times.

0:47:17And let's make sure that we've got the best – who makes the best rulers in the world?

0:47:23Oh, this company in Japan?

0:47:24Well, let's get those.

0:47:25And let's measure with the best rulers in the world four times, and then let's cut with the best saw, and that's it.

0:47:32And Steve Jobs shot from the hip, right?

0:47:36I'm going to bring up an old article.

0:47:38This is July 2008.

0:47:41Remember Joe Nassara?

0:47:42He was a business columnist at New York Times.

0:47:45And 2008 was sort of in the midst of one of Jobs' downswings.

0:47:52It might have been before he got the liver transplant.

0:47:55Here's Joe Nassara.

0:47:57I'm going to quote from his column.

0:47:59This is in the New York Times.

0:48:00On Thursday afternoon, several hours after I'd gotten my final, quote, Steve's health is a private matter, end quote.

0:48:08And much to my amazement, Mr. Jobs called me.

0:48:11This is Steve Jobs, he began.

0:48:14You think I'm an arrogant asshole who thinks he's above the law, and I think you're a slime bucket who gets most of his facts wrong.

0:48:21After that rather arresting opening, he went on to say that he would give me some details about his recent health problems, but only if I would agree to keep them off the record.

0:48:29And I wrote, as I linked to it, now that's how you start a phone call.

0:48:34Christ, I love Steve Jobs.

0:48:36Tim Cook is not going to call up a columnist from anybody.

0:48:40New York Times, Six Colors, Daring Fireball, The Wall Street Journal.

0:48:45He's not going to call up and say, you think I'm an arrogant asshole who thinks he's above the law, and I think you're a slime bucket who gets most of his facts wrong.

0:48:53That just isn't going to happen.

0:48:55Those words are not going to come out of Tim Cook's mouth.

0:48:57And I'm not saying Ternus is going to call me up and call me a slime bucket or that he's going to call you up and say, you think I'm an arrogant asshole.

0:49:08But I don't know, I think it's not out of the question that we might hear from Ternus more than we ever heard from Cook, which is zero.

0:49:19I think there might be a little bit of a return to a more back and forth with the media than there was under Tim Cook.

0:49:28And I don't think Cook was wrong.

0:49:31I think he was true to himself and that that was his vision for how Apple should be, but that it is a little bit more isolated and just cautious in what I think he thought was a good way.

0:49:44You know, there were like no sloppy mistakes in the whole Tim Cook era.

0:49:48There was that whole stock options backdating thing under Cook or under jobs around the same time, like 2008.

0:49:55And I don't think it was any kind of it was, I guess, technically illegal, but it wasn't like an attempt to to do something devious.

0:50:04It was just like, let's just put the dates on that.

0:50:08We, you know, we forgot to do this.

0:50:10Let's just do it like we did it and it'll all work out.

0:50:12And stuff like that just never happened under Tim Cook.

0:50:15There was no stock options backdating scandal under Tim Cook there.

0:50:19It just didn't happen.

0:50:21And like when executives left, there was no drama.

0:50:24It wasn't like when paper master left after the antenna gate thing weeks after.

0:50:28And it was just an open secret that he took the fall for the antenna thing and he was out of the company.

0:50:34It's like when Gian Andrea left, it was a year long goodbye and he got to retire on his own terms in December and golden parachute.

0:50:42Right.

0:50:42I don't know.

0:50:44I feel like there's a chance here that media relations are going to change a bit under Ternus is basically where I'm going.

0:50:50You've got a CEO who has different, he's totally different in terms of his dynamic and he's going to make some decisions about how he wants to play it.

0:51:00Right.

0:51:00But like, it's hard to think that the John Ternus playbook will be, eventually will be the Tim Cook playbook just used for John Ternus.

0:51:10In the short term, that may be true because as a new CEO, you may, I don't know if John Ternus is like, I don't like how Tim's interviews were handled.

0:51:19I want you to do it a different way.

0:51:21He may be like, look, you know how to handle CEO interviews.

0:51:24You just set me up and I'll do it just like Tim did.

0:51:27But in the long run, I think he may have different opinions and honestly, some of his people may have different opinions.

0:51:33This is a different guy.

0:51:34We can deploy him in a very different way than we deployed Tim because it's a different guy and he's got different skills.

0:51:40Yeah, and he just has a different style about him.

0:51:43He really does.

0:51:44I don't know.

0:51:44I'm looking forward to it.

0:51:45It just felt like it at WWDC and that tech talk, me and you and Federico and Mike being right there in the second row.

0:51:54It really felt like, hey, we've got front row seats to like this physical manifestation of the transition.

0:51:59It was no coincidence that Trudy was saving Tim's seat right next to John Ternus.

0:52:05That was very deliberate.

0:52:07And it's like, this is a moment.

0:52:10This is the transitional WWDC.

0:52:12In hindsight, I guess we'll remember this WWDC for two things.

0:52:17This was when the real Apple intelligence launched and this was the last cook WWDC, right?

0:52:24That's it in a nutshell.

0:52:25Five, six, seven years from now.

0:52:27That's how we'll look back at last week.

0:52:29Yeah, last cook appearance.

0:52:31Other than probably the end of July, he'll be on the results call for his final farewell, but that's not quite the same as a public.

0:52:39And he'll surely be in those front two rows for keynotes to come.

0:52:44Even if he weren't taking the job of executive chairman, he would still be there.

0:52:48John Gianandrea was at the keynote.

0:52:51I saw somebody had a photo of him up there in the front row of the outdoor area.

0:52:57Executives who leave with those golden parachutes tend to keep coming around.

0:53:00I've seen, I didn't see him this time, but within the last handful of years, I've seen Bertrand floating about WWDC.

0:53:07And board members show up there.

0:53:09I remember running into Al Gore at your boyfriend when he was on Apple's board.

0:53:13Yeah, I saw him at a, maybe the same one.

0:53:15And I actually shook his hand and just said, it did the same thing you did.

0:53:19I learned it from.

0:53:20I didn't shake his hand because we were in the men's room at the time.

0:53:22So I, I refrained.

0:53:23I forget what it was.

0:53:26It was like, I, and it's not like I was famously, again, I don't peck away on a keyboard at those events.

0:53:31I write in a notebook and I was like the, one of the last press members to leave one of those Yerba Buena things.

0:53:37And everybody else had filed out and Gore was, I guess, hanging around the front of the room.

0:53:43It was like, we were two of the last people to leave the Yerba Buena theater.

0:53:47And I was like, holy shit, it's Al fucking Gore.

0:53:49And I shook his hand and his hands are enormous.

0:53:52He's a very large man.

0:53:53He's a very much bigger man than, than, than I had filed away.

0:53:57And I just said, Hey, John Gruber, Daring Five, I have no idea if Al Gore reads my site.

0:54:02Maybe, I don't know, or maybe at least heard of it.

0:54:05He acted like he did.

0:54:06And I just said, Hey, I want to thank you for everything.

0:54:08And that's like all I said, hopefully said it all, you know.

0:54:12Right.

0:54:13What can, what more can you say in a moment like that?

0:54:15Yeah, that's, that's good.

0:54:16I, I, I always got the sense that Al Gore was one of those people who was out on Apple's board because he thought Apple was cool and he liked Apple stuff.

0:54:23Yeah.

0:54:24I don't know.

0:54:25I was impressed the one time when they showed, when he was like the making of one of the things that he hasn't done anything recently.

0:54:32Remember when he had the documentary, An Inconvenient Truth.

0:54:34He just is, I think it's like the 20th anniversary of that or something that he's, he, that he went around and was talking about it.

0:54:39But it's been a while since your, Apple doesn't hold, I was thinking about this the other day.

0:54:43Apple doesn't hold events in Yerba Buena anymore.

0:54:46Right.

0:54:46That's, I was actually thinking how that is an amazing example of how much bigger Apple is than it used to be.

0:54:53That they just went up to San Francisco to this little theater and, and said, we're going to release like major new products.

0:55:02And that stuff does not happen anymore.

0:55:05Just forget it.

0:55:07Forget it.

0:55:07They, they're, it, when you grow by whatever, an order of magnitude, that stuff doesn't happen anymore.

0:55:12So, yeah, I mean, one way or the other, Tim Cook will be around at those events, but I think the odds that he's ever going to sit down for like a sit down interview on upgrade is that time has passed.

0:55:24You know, yeah, I think he's done his duty.

0:55:27Yeah.

0:55:28And, and what I keep thinking is the guy seems like such a type A workaholic kind of guy.

0:55:33I hope he finds some time to enjoy.

0:55:36Yeah.

0:55:37Not being more or less retired.

0:55:39Supposedly he bought a mansion in Palm Springs.

0:55:42I was like, I hope he has a pool party.

0:55:43I hope he has, I just hope he has a, I hope because it's.

0:55:47Have you, have you seen the rumors though, that he might buy the Seahawks?

0:55:50That's not, I think that was batted down immediately as not true.

0:55:54Oh yeah.

0:55:54I could see him as a sports owner, but it's also seems like a hard thing to get into at age 65, but I don't know.

0:56:00He does love sport.

0:56:01He'll give some money to Duke and Auburn and show up at their events.

0:56:06And, and, and, and I think that'll probably be enough for him is my guess, but I don't know.

0:56:10Who knows?

0:56:11He's got a lot of money, but I just hope it's just on a personal scale as a human being, not even that it's Tim Cook specifically, somebody who's worked that hard and seems that obsessed with his job to step back.

0:56:24I hope he uses that time to do something he loves because he, he should, that's a thing that all human beings should do, especially when they're at retirement age is enjoy their retirement a little bit.

0:56:36And he's got the money to do it.

0:56:37So I hope he does it.

0:56:38Well, I hope so too.

0:56:40And I hope he doesn't just sit around forever wishing I was, he was still CEO of Apple.

0:56:45Yeah.

0:56:45Being on the, studying the board minutes.

0:56:47I got notes about the board minutes.

0:56:48Like Tim, no, don't.

0:56:49Because you say that, but then there's guys like Warren Buffett who just retired this year at, I think the age of 93 at Berkshire Hathaway.

0:56:57I heard people speculated he might go on some other corporate boards and that wouldn't surprise me.

0:57:01It wouldn't surprise me if he, he ended up on like the, whatever, the board of, of Auburn or Duke or something like that too.

0:57:08Just how Phil Schiller is on.

0:57:11I think he's on the board of trustees at BC, I think.

0:57:15I forget which school, but yes, definitely.

0:57:17And I know that Phil and his wife are, are very big financial donators to a bunch of environmental causes that they're actively involved with.

0:57:26That it's, it's not just here's some money.

0:57:28It's they're doing things like that.

0:57:30And I could see Tim Cook once he's no longer CEO.

0:57:35Also, in addition to like corporate boards and Duke or Auburn, I could see him getting involved with some environmental organizations.

0:57:44Yeah.

0:57:44So you just sent me a link, Boston College.

0:57:46Yeah.

0:57:47There's the Schiller Institute at Boston College.

0:57:49That's the, Dan Morin ran into him at, at Logan airport and he was flying back to Apple having been to a BC board of trustees meeting.

0:57:59And, and so that's when I realized, oh, I didn't even realize he was on the board of trustees there.

0:58:02So yeah, I just, I just, I don't know.

0:58:05I mean, he seems to have given the stuff we read about anyway.

0:58:09It's like his entire life has just been focused on Apple for so long now that it just as a human being, I hope, I look forward to seeing what he might choose to do, but also I just hope he has a good, like, I'm not kidding.

0:58:19When I say, I hope he has a nice pool party at his Palm Springs mansion because like, yeah, have, have a good time.

0:58:26You've worked hard for a long time.

0:58:28Maybe I have a good time.

0:58:31Yeah.

0:58:31And I get the impression when I run into Schiller these days, I talked to him.

0:58:36I didn't talk to him at W.

0:58:37I waved hello to him at WWDC, but at, I ran into him for a few minutes also at the Neo event in New York separately from when I photographed you talking to him.

0:58:47Because I didn't want to barge in.

0:58:48I was like, let me just take some pictures.

0:58:49Jason will enjoy that.

0:58:50So my backpack weighed like 30 pounds.

0:58:52It was killing me.

0:58:53That's the part about that.

0:58:54So why did I put my backpack down?

0:58:55Was I afraid that Phil Schiller was going to steal my backpack?

0:58:57I don't know.

0:58:58I wasn't thinking clearly.

0:58:59I have no idea.

0:59:00Maybe he's still working 80 hours a week on Apple stuff, but I get the impression that he's busy, but he's rebalanced how much stuff because before he took the new position, he had so much on his plate.

0:59:15And now it's like he runs events, he runs the App Store.

0:59:18I know he's involved with the compliance stuff because, or at least as it pertains to the App Store, which is a lot of the compliance stuff, but that it leaves more time for non-Apple and stuff too.

0:59:29He seemed more relaxed to me.

0:59:32Yeah, totally.

0:59:33And I think that's the way it should be, even if you're still involved with Apple to a significant degree, as the executive chairman of the board surely will be.

0:59:42No matter how it plays out, he's going to be involved to some degree.

0:59:45But I think for the last, probably the entirety, not just the 15 years that he had the title CEO, but I think the entirety of Tim Cook's time at Apple, he's been pretty busy.

0:59:56He's had a lot on his plate.

0:59:58I could argue that after those very first years with Steve, like Steve cared about products and that was what he cared about.

1:00:09Steve Jobs, he cared about operating a corporation only in the sense that he needed to keep it running with the money that would fuel the engine, which was making products.

1:00:22And so his recruitment of Tim Cook, you know, I haven't read a lot about this.

1:00:28I should read more about what's been written about that part of the story.

1:00:33But like, I get the feeling that very quickly, Tim Cook and I guess I think Fred Anderson was the CFO at that time.

1:00:42We say that Tim Cook's been CEO since right before Steve Jobs died.

1:00:47On another level, I think very quickly Steve Jobs left that part of running the company to Tim and probably Fred Anderson.

1:00:57Because once he knew that Apple was up and running and was going to have a money pipeline that meant they weren't going to go out of business and they weren't going to be in trouble and they could develop new products.

1:01:06It's not like he's sweating the details of the supply chain, right?

1:01:10He's just not.

1:01:11So Tim Cook's been doing parts of that job for way before Steve Jobs handed the role to him.

1:01:18I wrote a column once, I forget if it was when Steve Jobs took a medical leave or maybe when it was official and it was permanent.

1:01:26But at some point, one of those times I wrote that if you just wrote what Steve Jobs does, like on a day to day, week to week, yearly base, annual basis at Apple, what his responsibilities are and where he spends his time.

1:01:39And then you did the same thing for Tim Cook, but you didn't put their names on it.

1:01:42And then you just handed this is what these two senior executives at a computer company do.

1:01:48What do you think their titles are?

1:01:50They would point to Tim Cook and say, oh, he's probably the CEO of the company.

1:01:53And then this guy, I don't know, maybe he's like chief product officer or senior product officer or something like that.

1:01:59I think his job description in plain language sounded like the CEO of the company all along.

1:02:07And it wasn't that there was any sense that I don't think when Tim speaks of Steve Jobs, you can tell he knew who was in charge, right?

1:02:17It is fascinating because there's nobody else Tim Cook speaks of like that, right?

1:02:22But like when he speaks about Steve Jobs, you could tell that he knew he was the number two guy, right?

1:02:28There was no question.

1:02:29You know, like Commander Riker never asserted, you know, maybe there's like one or two episodes where he disagreed with Picard, but it was like a private disagreement.

1:02:38He knew he was number one.

1:02:40There was no doubt who was in charge, but I think with Steve, and this is going to be a question for John Ternus, I firmly believe that the CEO has to be the CEO of the entire company and the buck does stop with them and they need to make the big picture decisions.

1:02:53But also, what they choose to focus on is going to be informed by what they know.

1:02:58And so Tim Cook was always the head of operations.

1:03:03He was the COO.

1:03:04And then when he was the CEO, he also knew and cared about operations and all that.

1:03:08So what will John Ternus care about?

1:03:10John Ternus is going to be more like Steve Jobs, just in the sense that he's more closely attached to the product process.

1:03:17And I think it may be that Sabi Khan and Kevin Parik, who are the COO and CFO, will be more involved, more sort of like, not even necessarily responsible, like more directly involved with that part of the business where Tim might have had a little more informing him.

1:03:40And I think that's natural.

1:03:42I think every CEO is going to take it a little differently because Steve Jobs was clearly number one.

1:03:46But the products is the part that he cared about.

1:03:50And the rest of it, he really did want to delegate to other people.

1:03:52And that's fine.

1:03:53I think every CEO needs to be smart about knowing that they are number one.

1:03:57They do need to make the tough decisions.

1:03:59But also, where is your brainpower best used?

1:04:02And John Ternus' brainpower is not going to be best used in the same place as Tim Cook or Steve Jobs.

1:04:08Yeah.

1:04:08And I get the sense that everybody knows it.

1:04:10So we'll see.

1:04:11All right, let me take a break here and thank our next sponsor.

1:04:13It's our good friends at Squarespace.

1:04:15Hey, Squarespace is, you know it, they are the all-in-one website platform designed to help you stand out and succeed online.

1:04:24Whether you're just starting out or scaling an existing business, Squarespace gives you everything you need to claim your domain, showcase your offerings with a professional website, grow your brand, and get paid all in one place.

1:04:39And it doesn't even have to be a business.

1:04:41It could be an organization, could be a group, could be your local softball team or something, or softball league, and you need to have a website where you have the schedule and stuff like that.

1:04:51And if you're the nerd who's going to volunteer to do it, do it at Squarespace.

1:04:56It is so much easier.

1:04:57And you're like, well, don't you do things like this just by doing AI now?

1:05:02And if it's like doing a volunteer effort for something like that?

1:05:06Well, yeah, you can do that in Squarespace, right?

1:05:09Built in.

1:05:10You can just click and drag.

1:05:12And if that's what you want to do, of course, that's like sort of Squarespace's claim to fame is the WYSIWYG drag and drop.

1:05:19What you're looking at as you design the website is what visitors will see because you're doing it in the web browser.

1:05:26And then when people come to visit your website, they see what you see.

1:05:29But they also have AI tools if you want to just describe what you want to change or add or what you want the website to be if you're just getting started.

1:05:38All of that is right there.

1:05:39They have so many built-in components that you can use.

1:05:44Like I said, cutting-edge design tools with Blueprint AI.

1:05:47That's what their name for their AI-enhanced design partner.

1:05:51They have the same ever-growing library of professionally designed and award-winning website templates so that you can start with a look like, yes, this is where I want to start.

1:06:01This is how I want to tweak it.

1:06:02Online stores, whether you are selling products or selling your time or both, Squarespace will let you do it.

1:06:12And you can send invoices.

1:06:14You can collect the actual payments all through Squarespace itself.

1:06:19Built-in analytics.

1:06:21You can see which parts of your website people are going to, where they are coming from, which parts are popular, which parts are not, which sources of traffic are working, and which ones aren't sending people to your website.

1:06:33All of that is built in.

1:06:35They even have some of the new stuff they've added, expanded global shipping options.

1:06:41It's just amazing.

1:06:42If you're shipping, you can get the rates right there in Squarespace for shipping.

1:06:48And trust me, as somebody who has sent T-shirts recently, global shipping is much more complicated than it used to be.

1:06:54Where do you go to find out more?

1:06:56Same as usual.

1:06:57Go to squarespace.com slash talkshow.

1:07:00And remember that code, talkshow, because that's the code that saves you 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain.

1:07:08And if you get the website and pay for a whole year, you can save 10% on the whole year.

1:07:13So, squarespace.com slash talkshow.

1:07:17Well, that brings us to the news of WWDC.

1:07:20I had my live show.

1:07:22You were there.

1:07:22Joanna and Neila and I talked about a lot of the stuff.

1:07:26There was some stuff I didn't get to.

1:07:28Thank you.

1:07:28Thank you.

1:07:29I thought it went pretty well.

1:07:30I thought it was really interesting how, and again, I do feel maybe it is sort of.

1:07:37The tech talk was sort of a beginning of a new era.

1:07:41Like, I get it.

1:07:42There's one CEO at a time, and it was definitely Tim Cook.

1:07:44John Ternus was not in the keynote, right, which was kind of notable.

1:07:48I would have lost a bet on that.

1:07:50I don't know.

1:07:50Did you and Mike have that on your bingo?

1:07:52Yeah.

1:07:53How did you?

1:07:53I think he thought he took that he would be there.

1:07:57He was betting on there being some hardware announcement, and it didn't happen.

1:08:00Yeah.

1:08:00Yeah, that's what I thought, too, that they would, because there's some Macs that are overdue for updates.

1:08:06And I do think that so many years now since 2020 of no live events that they see, you know,

1:08:14and there was a live aspect to the Neo event in New York a couple months ago where they had, like, a little movie that they played before it.

1:08:22And then Ternus came out and spoke to us live on stage for a bit.

1:08:27I think that they're sort of course correcting a bit.

1:08:30I do not think they're going to return to live on stage major keynotes, right?

1:08:35WWDC is not going to be a live on stage keynote event.

1:08:39I don't think the iPhone events are ever going to be live the way they were before 2020.

1:08:44But I think smaller things might be.

1:08:47And I think even Apple sort of misses it in some ways, including live demos, right?

1:08:54Rockwell did live demos of Siri AI at the Tech Talk.

1:08:58I thought that was one of the most interesting things to happen in the whole week at WWDC.

1:09:02How do you add value when you've decided that, look, having a controlled video release, and it's always been true of the WWDC or any Apple event,

1:09:11but even just even a developer event that was theoretically open to the public, you had to be a developer and you had to sign up and you had to get a ticket and all of that.

1:09:19It still went to 99.9% of the people who cared were not there.

1:09:25That's just how it was in the last 15 years of it.

1:09:29So I think having that completely controlled thing up front is the smart thing to do, and having all the prerecorded sessions is the smart thing to do.

1:09:39I think that's all great.

1:09:40I think what they have learned, or what they're trying, is we're doing a live in-person event in conjunction with the video release.

1:09:49Rather than we get all these people to show up, what can we do when they're there?

1:09:54And one of the things you could do is have a not-streamed, not-video, live, on-the-record event with members of the media.

1:10:04Or they also had, I heard some people online grumbling about this, they had some developer sessions in person for the in-person developers.

1:10:12And people are like, how dare they not, we're not there.

1:10:15It's supposed to be a virtual event.

1:10:16And I think they're experimenting with it not being quite a virtual event.

1:10:21The keynote is the keynote, and we all saw it on video.

1:10:24We saw the same keynote.

1:10:26But if you were there, and you had the purple card on your badge, you got to go to see an actual live event.

1:10:35And I don't know, I think maybe uncoupling your got-so-big-and-gets-so-much-attention-that-maybe-you-need-to-have-complete-control-of-it keynote thing.

1:10:45Uncoupling that from the live give-and-take is a good idea.

1:10:52Like, why not?

1:10:52You got us all there.

1:10:54Why not do it?

1:10:55Why make everything recorded?

1:10:57They experimented with that two years ago, right, where they did the thing with iJustine.

1:11:00I think having it be a presentation with a small amount of questions sent in from the audience, it was a tiny amount.

1:11:09They overstated how they were going to do that.

1:11:10They didn't want to have too many questions from the audience.

1:11:12It was very much like the earnings calls where it was like a long pre-planned thing followed by an FAQ where the frequently asked questions were posed by Craig to Craig.

1:11:24And then, like, two questions from the audience.

1:11:26But still, it's a good use.

1:11:27You've got us there.

1:11:28Why not interact with us if you've got us there?

1:11:32This is your opportunity to do more for the people that you cared about enough to bring to Cupertino.

1:11:39And I think there's something about being there that it's – I think being in a lecture hall to hear a lecture live is a better way to learn than watching the same lecture on YouTube.

1:11:57And there was much to explain about the architecture of the new Apple intelligence and the new private cloud compute and the way it's going.

1:12:05And Federighi did a great job.

1:12:08It was a really good explanation with the right amount of slides and a thing that would have been off for the WWDC keynote itself.

1:12:20Bad fit for the keynote – I think I talked to you about this.

1:12:23I know I talked to a bunch of people about when we were there.

1:12:25You've got to think about what the WWDC keynote is.

1:12:28It's not like an iPhone event or any other product event.

1:12:32Because, first off, it is for developers.

1:12:34Secondly, especially if they have no new hardware announcements, it's not for people who care about new Apple products.

1:12:39It's not for people who care about the OSs because I can tell you, and you know this probably, but I definitely know this through Macworld sales figures and traffic numbers over many, many years.

1:12:49It is absolutely 100% true that you can tell the regular people who care about Apple stuff about an OS in June.

1:12:58And when you tell them about it in September, they'll be like, what, there's a new OS?

1:13:03Because until it's on their phone, they don't care.

1:13:07So it's not for them really either.

1:13:09It's sort of for the industry as well.

1:13:12But, like, what is the keynote even for?

1:13:14It's complicated, especially if you aren't doing a product launch.

1:13:18It's complicated.

1:13:19It's for the press and the industry and the developers and kind of a customer base, but not really.

1:13:25But whatever it is, and it is weird, it's not what's in the State of the Union.

1:13:31And it's not Craig Federighi putting up a chart with, like, a flow chart of how AI sequences happen, right?

1:13:40It's that, no, don't do it.

1:13:42And so, yeah, it was like a, they call it a tech talk.

1:13:45I was thinking it's like a chalk talk.

1:13:46It's like a coach putting up, like, John Madden at a chalkboard being like, boom, it goes over here and it does this thing.

1:13:52And that's basically what Federighi did.

1:13:54And I think that's, I agree with you.

1:13:56I think that's a great venue for it because a keynote, keynote is not the place to do that.

1:14:00Whatever the keynote is, and it is weird, and it has many audiences and also no audience in kind of, in some ways, it's not the place for that.

1:14:08So I'm really glad they did it.

1:14:09I wish they would do, I mean, the last couple of years, it used to be like you'd go and then you'd leave.

1:14:16Or you'd go and you'd have one thing.

1:14:17The last couple of years, for a lot of us press who go there, it's like a two-day extravaganza where you are being taken from one place to another for a briefing or an experience or a demo or a Q&A session.

1:14:31And it's a full-on, it feels very much like WWDC used to.

1:14:39It is packed, in a way, as an in-person event, for press anyway.

1:14:44Yeah, absolutely.

1:14:46And my schedule was packed, including my Tuesday.

1:14:49And I was like, this better be good because I've got the show at the end of the day.

1:14:54Like, I don't want to be wasting my time.

1:14:57But it was, it was all, the sessions were worthwhile.

1:15:00They were good demos.

1:15:01Yeah.

1:15:01It was, it's very busy.

1:15:04But I do, and I remember passing at one point Tuesday morning, the crowd of invited lucky lottery winner developers, not press,

1:15:14coming down from Steve Jobs' theater after the Apple intelligence session they had in person there.

1:15:20And that was awesome.

1:15:22I think, I wish I could have gone.

1:15:24I was busy with press briefings and I wasn't a attendee.

1:15:27But A, it's, I love that more people got to see Steve Jobs' theater, right?

1:15:33People, it is a thing to see.

1:15:35It is, it's sort of an architectural marvel.

1:15:39It is like, ooh, this is, this is something.

1:15:41It is striking.

1:15:44And it's cool that people who, you know, but it's also cool they had something to do the next day.

1:15:49And it was in person.

1:15:50And it was, again, with live demos of Apple intelligence and technical explanations of how, what's available to third-party developers

1:15:58and why they should be excited about it.

1:16:00And the sort of thing Apple has not done in years, really, since pre-COVID.

1:16:06And I think it's great.

1:16:07I would love to see them do more of it.

1:16:09And I really do think it is just sort of both ways.

1:16:13I think those of us on the outside, either whether we're press or developers who are attending,

1:16:17and we were like, yeah, this is great.

1:16:19I think inside Apple, the people I've talked to, they were like, yeah, this is great.

1:16:22We really have been wanting to do this.

1:16:24And we were thinking, hey, why don't we do more of this?

1:16:27I was talking to somebody after my show, somebody who works at Apple,

1:16:30who had something to do with the Tuesday morning thing that the developers went to at Steve Jobs Theater.

1:16:37And he was like, yeah, it went really well.

1:16:39And then afterwards, we were like, why don't we do this more often?

1:16:42Like, I'm not saying that they've already decided to, but they were like, yeah, that felt great.

1:16:48There's like a connection to the developers there.

1:16:50It's ineffable what it's like when there's 500, 600 people in front of you, and you're getting these, you're in the same room.

1:16:59But they were like, yeah, this is great.

1:17:00We haven't had this in a while.

1:17:02And we miss it.

1:17:03And it's good for everybody.

1:17:05Yeah.

1:17:06It's win-win.

1:17:07Doing the videos as videos instead of as live events, I get why they do it.

1:17:12I know you and Ben Thompson talk about this a lot on Dethering.

1:17:14I get why they do it because it gives them complete control.

1:17:16You do miss something.

1:17:18But there may be other ways to get that thing.

1:17:21And, like, COVID made them slam the door, and now they're rediscovering what could we do to get back some of the stuff that was lost, even if they're very happy with the idea of the pre-recorded keynote, which I think they are.

1:17:35Yeah.

1:17:35It doesn't just have to be that.

1:17:37And that's what they're kind of messing around with at WWDC as a thing.

1:17:42And, like, iPhone day, if you get to go to the iPhone event, like, there's a lot of stuff going on on the iPhone event day, too.

1:17:49But, like, WWDC is a good fit for developer stuff and also for press to kind of, like, check in about where they're doing it.

1:17:57So, yeah, I hope they keep exploring it because we did lose a lot.

1:18:00And although some of it I can understand tactically why they might not want to do it anymore, I like the idea that they're realizing they did lose some stuff that they could get back.

1:18:08And that Tech Talk was a good example, and those briefings were a good example.

1:18:11And, you know, we could all do WebEx briefings and stuff.

1:18:14We did during COVID.

1:18:16But, like, if you're going to get us out there, talk to us.

1:18:20That's your opportunity to explain yourself to the people who are communicating about what you're doing.

1:18:26Yeah.

1:18:27It's – I don't know.

1:18:29It's one of my big takeaways is that this was – and also, I know Neela and Joanna and I talked about it on stage, but I'll just say it again.

1:18:37The keynote itself was lower key, and I'm not saying it will always be that way.

1:18:42But there was no high production bit, no – nothing like the Phil Schiller's flying an airplane and all the senior executives are parachuting out into – there was no – somebody's driving a race car or anything like that.

1:18:58And maybe it's the simple explanation, and again, nobody at Apple who knows is going to explain it, at least not now while it's fresh.

1:19:05Maybe it's just that all of this was so – we don't know what we can announce in sort of much more last minute than most years.

1:19:15I don't know.

1:19:16Like, maybe there was a – hmm, are we going to pull all this together to announce in June?

1:19:21And I don't know.

1:19:22But there was something about it that was much more low key.

1:19:25And the other thing I do know, there's no secret.

1:19:28If you really want to ask somebody at Apple, hey, how come you guys stopped making the mini after the iPhone 13 mini?

1:19:35And it's like they'll give you a look.

1:19:38They're not going to say it, but it's, is it because it didn't sell that well?

1:19:41And they're going to give you a look that's duh, right?

1:19:43They're not going to say it, even off the record.

1:19:45But it's like, what do you think the – if it was selling like hotcakes, why would we stop making it?

1:19:51And if we stop making it, what do you think that means?

1:19:53And it's like, why do you think – they don't talk about the – they do put them on YouTube, and YouTube, they don't have an exemption from YouTube's download or views or whatever they call the number.

1:20:04And I just looked at keynotes at 8.1 million.

1:20:07But they also host their own version of it.

1:20:10If you just go to Apple TV and look in it, they have the keynote.

1:20:15Or if you go to apple.com in a web browser when the keynote's on, they're not playing the YouTube version.

1:20:20They're playing their own version.

1:20:21And who knows which is more popular?

1:20:23But there's certainly millions more views that are their own.

1:20:27They know the numbers.

1:20:29And it's like, are these prerecorded keynotes more popular than the ones that were on stage and put to tape?

1:20:35And they'll just give you a look like, duh.

1:20:37Like they don't talk about the numbers, but they are way more popular.

1:20:41And that's basically it.

1:20:43As a marketing exercise, the prerecorded keynotes that are at a cinematic pace of editing are just more conducive to watching.

1:20:55And it's the same way that, like, people liked it when they put Hamilton on Disney+, like a video of the live production of Hamilton.

1:21:04But that is not as popular as a feature film, right?

1:21:08Like film movies are put together at a different pace than a stage production.

1:21:13And a stage production works for the people who are in the audience.

1:21:17And a movie works for people who are watching a video.

1:21:20And you can enjoy a live production that is put to tape, but it doesn't hit the same way.

1:21:28And there's millions of people who watch these prerecorded infomercial style videos, to borrow Neela's term.

1:21:36And there are thousands of people who can watch them live.

1:21:40And which one do you think they're going to optimize for?

1:21:42Duh.

1:21:43I think what you end up with and where Apple may be evolving to is the idea that, like, look, doing an infomercial, doing a commercial video thing is the right thing to do because of all those reasons.

1:21:55Right.

1:21:56And it doesn't have to be either or live event or a commercial because we had the live event.

1:22:06Right.

1:22:07And part of it was the infomercial, but also there was a lot for members of the press.

1:22:12There was a lot more and there was value in that.

1:22:14And there's value for Apple in it and there's value for us in that.

1:22:17So, yeah, I feel like they're just kind of letting the video be what it is and what it needs to be and how it evolves.

1:22:23And then also saying that doesn't have to be our whole strategy when we're talking to the media or when we're talking to developers.

1:22:29We can do some other stuff, too.

1:22:30And I think that that is great.

1:22:32My favorite word that Neelai and Joanna said on your stage is Joanna said that it was boring.

1:22:41Yeah.

1:22:42And there was a moment where you're like, oh, here it comes.

1:22:46And she basically said in a good way.

1:22:50And I was struck by that word because what it said to me is it says everything about how companies always have an incentive to do big tentpole features every year because that's the stuff that's exciting.

1:23:07And that initial 15-minute block where they talked about making everything on all the devices you use faster, more efficient, less buggy, fixing all these annoyances that you've had for a decade.

1:23:21Somebody was like, I'm surprised that that didn't go on longer.

1:23:25It was actually kind of dull as it was because I keep saying to people, it's like sand running through your fingers.

1:23:30It's like a lot of little things are hard to get your hands around.

1:23:34And this is the dichotomy is we need as users updates that fix the broken stuff and make everything faster.

1:23:43But the reason we don't get that as often as we should is it's boring.

1:23:48I mean, it is boring.

1:23:50It's good for you and you should do it.

1:23:52But there is no denying that it's boring.

1:23:54And that's why we have to have tentpole features.

1:23:56The good news is fixing Siri and Apple intelligence is such a big A-plus tentpole feature that it allowed them to say, beyond this, just make everything work better.

1:24:09And, like, great.

1:24:10But calling it boring, she's not wrong.

1:24:13But I think it's really interesting because it goes to human nature, right?

1:24:17It's like we want to be entertained by these events.

1:24:19But sometimes not being entertained and having them fix the stuff that's broken is better for us, but is not as entertaining.

1:24:27Yeah.

1:24:28And I feel like it's one of those be careful what you measure type things.

1:24:32Like, if you're measuring excitement, you're like, hey, we need more exciting features.

1:24:37And excitement in general is good from a marketing perspective.

1:24:41But I think that it leads to a cycle where Apple lost track of, okay, there are some unexciting things that will resonate and create affection.

1:24:55And, yeah, this is why I love owning an iPhone.

1:24:58Feelings from regular users that aren't exciting at all.

1:25:03And it's like, oh, yeah, people do love bug fixes and low latency and stuff like that.

1:25:08And it's why people so fondly remember.

1:25:12It's like a legendary term in Apple's world, Snow Leopard, right?

1:25:16And it wasn't, as John Syracuse has gone on at length on ATP, it was not a no-new-features release.

1:25:23There was all sorts of major new features.

1:25:25I think that's when the 64-bit stuff went in.

1:25:28I know Grand Central Dispatch was introduced, like, an entirely new features.

1:25:33And the bug fix update.

1:25:34Including, you know, with Grand Central Dispatch, an entirely new way of doing multitasking and multi-threading in EOS.

1:25:41Like, really low-level stuff.

1:25:43Yeah.

1:25:43I had forgotten.

1:25:44I got Macworld to repost my review of it, which also has buying advice because it's back when you...

1:25:50Yes.

1:25:50Snow Leopard, you had to buy it.

1:25:52Like, what?

1:25:53But, yeah, that's their trick.

1:25:55That's always their trick is they say, oh, no new features.

1:25:58And it's totally new features.

1:25:59There's hundreds.

1:25:59I remember they put up a slide at some point that was like, it's actually hundreds of new features.

1:26:03But they're all little and a lot of them are...

1:26:06And that was what the 15-minute block at the beginning of the keynote was, right?

1:26:09It's like, all you can do is give examples.

1:26:11So they're like, for example, you walk out your front door and your iPhone just doesn't connect to anything for a while because it can't bear to let go of your Wi-Fi, even though your Wi-Fi is not talking to it anymore.

1:26:20And until you leave your house and drive halfway down the block and the cellular connection finally cuts in, that you can...

1:26:27I can't tell you how many times I've stopped the stop sign at the end of my street in order to get my maps directions to work because I can't do it.

1:26:34Everybody, when you talk about this feature, everybody knows this feature because almost everybody leaves the house.

1:26:41So it is a cloud pleaser.

1:26:41It's just little.

1:26:42You know that dumb thing?

1:26:44And I applaud them for doing it because it does require Apple to have a little bit of humility because they do have to say, this is a thing that didn't work as well as it should have.

1:26:51And then say, but we fixed it.

1:26:53And I could be mad that it's gone on this long, but I think I'm just going to be grateful that maybe it's fixed.

1:26:59You know, again, what took you so long?

1:27:01One of the answers is, well, we were busy working on all those tentpole features that were super dramatic in the keynote instead of fixing this thing you deal with every time you leave your house.

1:27:10Yes.

1:27:11So good.

1:27:11Let's do it.

1:27:12I had a briefing.

1:27:14I don't know.

1:27:15Maybe you might have been in it.

1:27:17It was like a sort of briefing specifically about the performance updates and little tweaks.

1:27:23Yeah, which mine was awkward because it's like, what do you want to talk about?

1:27:27And it's like, there's so many things, but they're all little.

1:27:30It's like, what?

1:27:30We talked about the Wi-Fi release one.

1:27:33I talked about that too.

1:27:34Yeah, we talked about that.

1:27:35I asked them specifically, what are you doing there?

1:27:38And the answer was, I mean, it's very funny because the answer was, well, quite frankly, we were just looking at signal attenuation.

1:27:43Right.

1:27:43And now we look at latency, bandwidth across the link, signal attenuation.

1:27:49We look at a bunch of stuff and we do it way faster.

1:27:51Yeah.

1:27:52And I know you can do multi-homing.

1:27:55It's like, yeah, you should be looking at the Wi-Fi and saying, I can't get any data on the Wi-Fi and immediately just pulling that data off of cellular.

1:28:02And I did make them laugh because I said, it's like my iPhone is mourning for its Wi-Fi for a little while.

1:28:07And I wanted to get over it faster.

1:28:09And they thought that was kind of a funny way to put it.

1:28:12But it's like, it's tell me, show me the lie.

1:28:14Right.

1:28:14It's like every time you leave your house, your iPhone is like, I remember that Wi-Fi.

1:28:17It was really good.

1:28:18And it's like, stop.

1:28:19Yeah.

1:28:20You are a phone.

1:28:20You have a cellular modem.

1:28:22Use it.

1:28:23Yeah.

1:28:23I get that just that when they were like, OK, let's actually tackle this problem.

1:28:27And they're like, this is not like rocket science.

1:28:29It's like we can just do a couple of simple things that are not even that intensive.

1:28:32But if we like, yeah, send like a ping and test the latency, that's trivial.

1:28:37That can happen in one ten thousandth of a second and use almost no battery life or energy.

1:28:43And it's just like, oh, yeah, we'll just send a signal and see if we get anything.

1:28:46Oh, we're not getting anything back.

1:28:47Then let's try switching antennas.

1:28:49And maybe I don't even know.

1:28:50They didn't mention this one specifically, but maybe they can tie the accelerometer in, too, and be like, yeah, the iPhone's been in motion.

1:28:58The user is clearly moving, whether they're in a car or walking out the door.

1:29:02So let's just check if they're connected.

1:29:05OK, they are connected.

1:29:06We have a great connection to the Wi-Fi, stay in the Wi-Fi.

1:29:08Or no, look at the ping time.

1:29:10This is terrible.

1:29:11Let's switch.

1:29:12They mentioned in that briefing, they mentioned the word Snow Leopard to me, to my group.

1:29:18I forget who was in my group.

1:29:19And then they also said iOS 12.

1:29:22And I don't recall iOS 12 being that type of relief.

1:29:27And maybe it's one of those things where because iOS releases don't get names, I don't have them.

1:29:34I don't like, oh, yeah, that was the one where blank.

1:29:37But at least inside Apple, that's how they saw iOS 12 as a sort of, hey, let's stop with the exciting new features or slow down on exciting new features.

1:29:49And let's just turn around and improve some existing ones.

1:29:52And the way that they presented it was like, oh, yeah, I guess it does kind of make sense, though, that these things just ebb and flow through multi-year cycles.

1:30:01The whole organization gets on board with something.

1:30:04And obviously, last year's was liquid glass, right?

1:30:07Hey, we're going to do a new UI paint job in front of all the platforms.

1:30:12We're going to do it all in one year.

1:30:14We're not going to do iPhone first and other platforms the next year or two years later for some of them.

1:30:20We're going to do it all at once.

1:30:22Everybody get on board.

1:30:23We're going to touch every piece of software and how it looks.

1:30:25And that's the big thing.

1:30:27And this year is obviously AI, but it's obviously with a bunch of – and I think it is related to Siri AI, right?

1:30:35Like, obviously, like the, hey, let's tear Spotlight down and do an entirely new version of Spotlight is both beneficial just for searching through your email messages.

1:30:46And it's clearly a key aspect.

1:30:50It doesn't matter how good the actual Gemini-derived LLM is.

1:30:54If the search index is bad, it's not going to be able to find the personal context, right?

1:30:59It's just not going to happen.

1:31:00And so it's like win-win.

1:31:01And you can say, well, why didn't they do this years ago?

1:31:04But it's like, I don't know.

1:31:05It's like all of a sudden the whole company is on board with this is the year we're going to fix things.

1:31:09And next year will be something else.

1:31:12The AI stuff gives them cover to do this, and I think that's great.

1:31:17Make no mistake, I think they should do this stuff every year, right?

1:31:21I think speed and bug fixes should always be higher on their agenda than it is.

1:31:28I think they've gotten that out of balance most years that they could do more.

1:31:32But all I'm saying is I understand why all tech companies are predisposed to do big things and not worry so much about fixing the old things because the big things are what people notice.

1:31:47And when I just had a briefing for BB Edit, the new version of BB Edit came out, and I talked to Rich Siegel about it.

1:31:54And I know you beta test it like I do and all of that.

1:31:57And the new version versus 16, it doesn't really have any tentpole features.

1:32:04It's got like a thousand things that are a little bit better.

1:32:06And the challenge is then I need to write a story about it.

1:32:09And what do I say?

1:32:10Hey, BB Edit got a little bit better.

1:32:11And so I get it.

1:32:13I get why they do it.

1:32:14One of the ways you get publicity is that people have a feature to glom onto.

1:32:19I don't think that – I think that's human nature.

1:32:21I think it's our mistake.

1:32:23We don't want to take our medicine.

1:32:24I do wish Apple had a little more cultural focus on keeping the bug fixes and improvements party rolling every year a little more than they tend to do.

1:32:36If we have to stop every five years and do this, okay.

1:32:40But I'd really rather do a fifth of it every year.

1:32:43I just don't know culturally if – you know, you've heard stories.

1:32:46I've heard stories where people are like, I'm aware that bug exists and I cannot get permission to fix it.

1:32:50And I know – and this debate always goes on, right?

1:32:55Is Apple software quality in decline, right?

1:32:58And there are some people who have – who would – every single year for the last 20 years would have said this year over last year Apple software quality is in decline and they would have voted the same way for 20 straight years.

1:33:12But if that were true, Apple software quality in 2026, 20 years later would be unusable, right?

1:33:20It's not.

1:33:21It's so complex.

1:33:23Their software portfolio is so broad that there are – and you can look at specific things.

1:33:29And all of us have our pet peeves and gripes.

1:33:34But I do think in broad strokes – and I think this goes back to one of the last years that I did my live show in San Francisco.

1:33:44And I think Federighi was on stage.

1:33:49I think he might have only been on stage in San Francisco once.

1:33:52And we were – I brought it up with – I think it was Phil and Federighi.

1:33:56I could be wrong, but I'm pretty sure it was Phil and Federighi.

1:33:59And they were adamant that their software quality is up, not down because they measure it.

1:34:05And what I took away from that – and that's good, right?

1:34:09But it is like how many crash reports were they getting in their database?

1:34:15And I do think Apple's apps crash way less often than they did 10 to 15 years ago.

1:34:23You just – it's very seldom that I see crashes anymore.

1:34:27I really don't.

1:34:28And they measured it and they fixed those things.

1:34:31And I think switching from Objective-C to Swift has fixed other classes of bugs, memory management bugs.

1:34:38And those are good, but if you think that's the only measure of software quality, like, hey, our app doesn't crash – Apple Notes doesn't crash.

1:34:46It only crashes a hundredth of – one percent as much as it used to.

1:34:49It's like that's a 99 percent reduction in the number of crashes.

1:34:53I don't know.

1:34:53I'm making that number up.

1:34:54You could say that's fantastic, but that doesn't mean there aren't bugs in Apple Notes that don't cause crashes.

1:35:00And how do you measure those?

1:35:02Or just irritations, right?

1:35:05Also, I feel like – and people at Apple agree or disagree, but from the outside, it feels like there is a culture at Apple that – and sometimes I think this is also about their hiring process because famously, like, Apple's bad at hiring people.

1:35:21It takes forever.

1:35:22And some of that is a legacy of, like, oh, we only want eight players here.

1:35:26But I think also they have a – I think personal opinion, just as I think Apple's hiring processes, at least as I have come to know them over the last few years talking to people, seem really old and hidebound and slow.

1:35:38And I think that it may lead to one of the things that I'm about to describe, which is I get the feeling like they decide to do a big feature.

1:35:47The circus comes to town.

1:35:49They build the feature.

1:35:51They launch it.

1:35:52They leave town.

1:35:54And that feature sits there.

1:35:55And the problem is there's bugs.

1:35:57Things are broken.

1:35:59And in year two, you're like, you're going to fix all the things that were broken in the thing you shipped last year, right?

1:36:05And in the last decade, I would say a lot of times what happens is they just don't.

1:36:11And if you're lucky, they'll fix it year three or year four.

1:36:14Some people will come back and kind of, like, give it a polish.

1:36:17But that's the thing that troubles me most about sort of Apple software quality in general is the feeling like they don't have the people to own the thing that they launch.

1:36:27They build the thing that they launch, and then those people go off and do something else.

1:36:30And nobody is maintaining and improving the thing that's there.

1:36:33And, like, whether it's time machine, things that are often really system critical that are, like, super quirky, and then they will do a brush up, and you'll be like, yay, but there's still this bug, and then it's good luck.

1:36:47Wait three more years.

1:36:48Or I think the one that we're all thinking of this year is screen time, which they have a big revamp, and they're doing all these things.

1:36:56And, again, I heard you and Ben talking about it on Dithering.

1:36:59Like, on one level, it's great.

1:37:03But on another level, if you've talked to anybody who's tried to use screen time, it's broken.

1:37:09And so what they're really doing here is trying to fix it, and we'll see how they do.

1:37:14Which ties into the parental controls, which there's an overlap where some of the parental controls are about screen time.

1:37:19It's basically, yeah, that screen time was launched in the digital well-being era, and now people are more concerned about kids using technology.

1:37:26But it's all kind of a piece.

1:37:28And I think screen time's a great example because screen time launched with a lot of fanfare, and it had problems.

1:37:36And, you know, new features with problems is not a crime.

1:37:40It happens.

1:37:41The crime is they never fix the problems.

1:37:45And that's the part that I would like to see Apple get better at is just if you're going to launch something, you've got to maintain it.

1:37:54And sometimes I feel like Apple is willing to spend the money and time and effort to launch something, but then they're not really willing to do anything other than walk away.

1:38:05And I think that's irresponsible.

1:38:06If you can't stand by that feature, you shouldn't launch it.

1:38:08Yeah.

1:38:09And if you're not willing to put a team together to, instead of making it a circus, to use your analogy, that has tents, and then the tents, it's a big fanfare, and you go, but it's not built to last.

1:38:22You should be building permanent amusement parks and theaters that are meant to be...

1:38:27Great new feature.

1:38:28Who owns this now forever, right?

1:38:30Forever.

1:38:30What team owns this and cares about it the most, if anything?

1:38:34Because we've all had that issue where sometimes you even hear from somebody at Apple and you get the distinct senses like, oh, that's the guy who does this.

1:38:41There's a person who is on this, and it's not their whole job.

1:38:45I don't know.

1:38:47Feels like there should be people on this thing that's super important and is a core of all of Apple's operating systems.

1:38:53And sometimes you get the sense that that code is just there and nobody really knows about it.

1:38:59And it's very disturbing when you get that sense that things are kind of abandoned inside of Apple's operating systems.

1:39:07All right, let me take one more break here and thank our third and final sponsor, and it's our good friend at Finalist.

1:39:14Finalist, they sponsored my live show, and I say they, but it's really just one developer, Slavin Radic.

1:39:20And he's back sponsoring this week's show, the week after WWDC.

1:39:24Finalist is, I love this app.

1:39:27I really do.

1:39:28I said it on stage that I still use it after he first sponsored Daring Fireball in December.

1:39:33It is sort of a paper day planner in a digital form.

1:39:38And it's iPhone, iPad, Mac.

1:39:41The Mac app has been making – I liked it from the start.

1:39:44I wouldn't have really been able to use it the way I've been using it if it didn't have a good Mac app months ago.

1:39:51But it's really improved lately.

1:39:54And it's – I keep saying over and over again, the reason it works for me is that you have days and days have tasks, not a list of tasks and the tasks have dates assigned to them.

1:40:06This works for my brain in a fundamental way that a lot of other to-do lists and management type apps don't.

1:40:14And if you've ever thought, hey, none of these apps really fit with the way I work, and if you kind of have the mentality that fits with a paper planner, you should really check out Finalist.

1:40:26It's just a great app.

1:40:27And it's – the pace of development is just amazing, especially for a one – well, I say especially for a one-person team, but maybe it's because it's a one-person team and in a way that a really, really productive developer can move faster than a team ever could.

1:40:43It's just a great app.

1:40:44So you can go to finalist.works.

1:40:48That's the URL, finalist.works slash talkshow.

1:40:53And by going there, you get six months free off the subscription.

1:40:59That's an unbelievable deal.

1:41:01So just – it's a special deal just for talkshow listeners.

1:41:04Go to finalist.works slash talkshow.

1:41:07You get six months free.

1:41:09Try it.

1:41:10It is the type of app you're either going to be like, yes, this is for me.

1:41:14And again, you're not locked into like the finalist system.

1:41:17It's such a great ecosystem app where the calendar events come from the system-level calendar.

1:41:22I don't even use Apple Calendar.

1:41:24I use Fantastical.

1:41:25That's still my calendar app.

1:41:27But then those events from Fantastical, because they're in the system database, they show up in finalist.

1:41:32Reminders.

1:41:33You tell Siri to set a reminder in the reminders app.

1:41:36Guess what?

1:41:37If it has a date, it shows up on that date in finalist.

1:41:40It's such a great app.

1:41:41Go check it out.

1:41:42Finalist.works slash talkshow.

1:41:47Hey, let's take a break before we go back to WWDC.

1:41:49Before I forget, I don't want to run out of time on this.

1:41:52There's one thing I wanted to say to you and Mike in WWDC, and I forgot to.

1:41:59I ran out of time.

1:42:00And it's, are you two out of your frigging minds?

1:42:03Oh, well, what do you mean, John?

1:42:07What do you mean?

1:42:08We might be.

1:42:09Well, I heard, when I first heard the idea, you and Mike Hurley, your co-host of Upgrade, are launching a new podcast.

1:42:17It's currently, and this is coincident with your appearance here, because we still, I think you still have two weeks left on the Kickstarter.

1:42:23Yeah, we're going to the end of June.

1:42:24All right.

1:42:25So we've got plenty of time.

1:42:26Designed in California, an Apple history podcast.

1:42:30And I thought, oh, that's great.

1:42:32It's the Apple's, you know, and blah, blah, blah.

1:42:35The two of us, Mike Hurley and Jason Snow, have been discussing Apple in depth.

1:42:38This is from the description on Kickstarter.

1:42:40And I'm like, yeah, an Apple history podcast with Mike and Jason, and that would be great.

1:42:47And then I read that it is going to consist of 50 episodes dropping over 12 months.

1:42:53I mean, it's just weekly.

1:42:55But it's not like you're stopping what you're already doing.

1:43:02Well, I mean, I stopped a podcast that I was doing that, that was not doing too well.

1:43:06And I, I, so I knocked that off and there may be some other stuff that I, I stopped, but I did.

1:43:11Look, we did Kickstarter because we knew this would be a lot of work and we didn't want to do it.

1:43:17We couldn't do it the way that you usually do, which is you launch a podcast and see if anybody shows up because it's so much work.

1:43:24That if we're going to commit to that level of work, we need to know there's an audience for it.

1:43:27And the Kickstarter has been really successful.

1:43:30It's still up.

1:43:31Love support.

1:43:32If you want to get the ad free feed with a whole bunch of bonus features, you can do it.

1:43:35It's designed.fm.

1:43:37There will be a regular free feed with ads and stuff as well, but there's some good deals and there's some merch.

1:43:44There's some art and, and other stuff there too, that you can get.

1:43:48It's a Kickstarter, right?

1:43:49But it literally is what Kickstarter was meant to do, which is validate this idea and allow it to happen in the world.

1:43:54It's not like some of these like pre-cooked products where they put it on Kickstarter as a marketing ploy.

1:43:58Like literally we didn't know whether we were going to, it was going to make sense for us to make the effort.

1:44:03And the, the initial goal was only for 30.

1:44:06And then there was a stretch goal, which was for 50 episodes or weekly.

1:44:10They're like half an hour ish to 45 minutes ish.

1:44:13We record them in a block.

1:44:16So, you know, it's more manageable than you might think.

1:44:19We're not doing it every week.

1:44:20We're kind of like producing a month's worth at once in a cycle and we get time because it's not timely.

1:44:26Like all these shows that we do, it's got, it's scripted and it's about the past and we can take our time on it and do that.

1:44:32But it's still going to be a lot of work, which is why we calculated it out of like the minimum amount possible to do it.

1:44:39I've already stopped working on some stuff because I'm going to do this instead, which is great.

1:44:43I'm very excited about the project.

1:44:44That was part of the deal.

1:44:46We did an episode about the 50th anniversary of Apple.

1:44:48That was very much like, how did those guys meet and what did they do?

1:44:52And that was kind of our proof of concept.

1:44:54And we really enjoyed it.

1:44:55It was inspired by the rest is history, which is a great podcast about all of history, not 50 years of Apple history.

1:45:02But it's Mike and I, both of us love that podcast.

1:45:05And we thought, is there a way to do, there are so many sources about Apple.

1:45:09There's so many books about Apple and so many stories that you could tell if you zero in on a particular topic.

1:45:15And also doing this for as long as you and I have, you've come to realize there are a lot of people out there who are in our audience who actually don't know those stories.

1:45:23Yeah.

1:45:23Because they predate their interest in Apple.

1:45:26And so we thought that there was something there.

1:45:29The truth is, I was working on a version of this last year.

1:45:33It was going to be a follow up to that 20 Max for 2020 series I did, my pandemic project, but I hadn't quite figured it out.

1:45:40And then I got sidetracked by two things, which is I got sidetracked by having a month's warning to be on Jeopardy.

1:45:49So I had to do a lot of studying and sidetracked by the Wall Street Journal asking me to review David Polk's 650 page book about Apple history.

1:45:56And when I finished doing those two things, it was almost the 50th anniversary of Apple.

1:46:01And I was like, okay, Mike, why don't I write a script like the script I was writing last year?

1:46:05But instead of it being about whatever that script was about, let's make it about the founding of Apple.

1:46:10And then Mike was like, I think this is great.

1:46:12We should do it.

1:46:13I think we should do it as a Kickstarter, you and me.

1:46:15I'm going to be writing the episodes, but Mike's going to be doing a lot of the production and the marketing and all sorts of other stuff, too.

1:46:21It's a good division of labor between us.

1:46:22And we'll figure out where it goes.

1:46:24I mean, the thing about it is the rest is history.

1:46:27Guys can't bring on somebody who knew Napoleon, right?

1:46:30But we could bring on people who were there or around there to talk about it.

1:46:35And so that's part of the things we have to figure out is, like, I got an email about one of the, we're doing previews in the upgrade feed this month.

1:46:43And I got an email from somebody who said there's a detail in one of our stories that may not be right.

1:46:48It's in the book this way.

1:46:50But our friend Harry McCracken interviewed one of the people who was involved, and he said that book got it wrong.

1:46:58I wasn't there.

1:46:59Other people were there, but not me.

1:47:01And it's, like, fascinating because it's, like, it's not, it is in the book, but the book isn't maybe right.

1:47:10So, yeah, I'm digging through all the old books and oral histories, and I imagine that at some point we're going to do an episode or a series about the transition from classic macOS to macOS 10.

1:47:20And I guess this will serve as an announcement that we're doing this.

1:47:24It's like, we're going to have John Syracuse on those.

1:47:26Like, who lived through it?

1:47:28I did, but John certainly did and cared about it a lot.

1:47:32So some of them will have guests and some of them won't.

1:47:34We'll, like, figure out the dynamic as we go.

1:47:36I mean, really, it's, part of this is going to figure out what is this show ultimately going to be like.

1:47:40But I, what gave me confidence that we could do this is we came up with a list.

1:47:45We came up, John, it's at least, like, two or three years of material.

1:47:49And that was just our first wish list, right?

1:47:52There are so many stories to tell from the prehistory to the present day.

1:47:57And like Pogue's book, I'll grant you the last 10 or 15 years are a much tougher nut to crack because not only is everybody who's listening probably lived through those, right?

1:48:06But those people work at Apple and they're not talking yet.

1:48:08But even, like, at this point, like, even to the start of the iPhone, and there are so many great stories to tell.

1:48:16I want to do a series about Microsoft and Apple being frenemies, right?

1:48:21And how that has changed over time.

1:48:24And sometimes they're enemies and sometimes they're not.

1:48:26And I want to kind of, like, dig into it.

1:48:28And I think there's, but this will afford us the ability to really dig into it.

1:48:32So as an example, I was thinking the other day, this was a shower thought.

1:48:35Or maybe it was a driving thought because I just drove back from my son's graduation in Oregon.

1:48:40And so that's like an eight-hour drive.

1:48:41I had a lot of time to think about stuff.

1:48:43And one of the thoughts I had is, if we're going to do the Microsoft and Apple frenemies story, I probably need to do an entire episode about Microsoft.

1:48:50Like, about Bill Gates and Paul Allen and how they came to even exist.

1:48:57That's the latitude a show like this gets us.

1:49:00Is the ability to take the time to say, like, have you ever really heard the story about Microsoft?

1:49:06Because all of these stories, we know, like, the sketch version of it.

1:49:10But, like, I had no idea that Steve Jobs and Steve Wozniak took an Apple II prototype with them on a red eye to Philadelphia in the summer of 1976 to go to a trade show in Atlantic City.

1:49:25And that their arch rivals were sitting right behind them looking over their shoulders and laughing at this bare computer board that was in a cigar box.

1:49:35Which, as it turns out, was the Apple II, and it would destroy that company.

1:49:38Those people all were destroyed.

1:49:40We've never heard of – nobody's ever heard of that company.

1:49:42But we've all heard of Apple.

1:49:43And it was Atlantic City in 1976, which is before the casinos went in.

1:49:46So it was a dump.

1:49:48Like, I'd never heard that story.

1:49:50And that's when I have fun doing the research on this.

1:49:52It's like, we all know kind of, like, the sketch version of all this history.

1:49:56But the details are so interesting, and they're not what you expect.

1:50:01So it's been fun, and we're doing it now.

1:50:04But if more people want to support us, what I'm excited about, too, is that there are so many podcasts like this one where we talk about current events.

1:50:13Yeah.

1:50:14And you can't listen to them all.

1:50:16Right.

1:50:17But this one will be different.

1:50:18So I'm hoping that people who listen to the talk show and ATP and other places like that, and people who don't even listen to news shows about Apple, might be into it.

1:50:27Because they're fun stories.

1:50:28And if you care anything about, like, the tech industry or Silicon Valley or Apple, hopefully you will get fun stories out of it.

1:50:35Like, I get out of The Rest is History, where they're telling stories about parts of history I know nothing about.

1:50:40Maybe would never have even cared about.

1:50:42But to listen to a couple of people who've done the research or, you know, have read the primary sources and then put it together in an entertaining story.

1:50:52Like, I love that stuff.

1:50:54So I'm hoping we can do the same thing.

1:50:56Yeah.

1:50:56And The Rest is History is one of those shows.

1:50:59I think you're one of them.

1:51:00that when I was going on and on about having – admitting that I'm very late to have stumbled upon the Acquired podcast, which has been going on for years and is a huge success and is one of the most popular podcasts there is, let alone in tech.

1:51:16And I've just fell in love with it, with these – and the Acquired show is, like, each episode is, like, a three to four hour deep dive on one specific company's entire history.

1:51:29In addition to just loving the episodes I've listened to, I'm absolutely in love with the use of the podcast, the audio podcast – I wish I didn't have to say that – audio podcast form to tell the story.

1:51:44And that – I found the nature of the Acquired format to be so revelatory.

1:51:52And apparently The Rest is History is similar.

1:51:55It's the same type of format.

1:51:57There's another show people mentioned that's similar.

1:51:59But it's perfect for this.

1:52:02And I'm not – I have never, ever been an audio book listener.

1:52:06I know they're super popular and I know people who have long – if they're driving back and forth from California to Oregon frequently, you need something to listen to.

1:52:14Absolutely.

1:52:15Because I read faster than I can listen and that's how I – it just doesn't work for my brain.

1:52:21But I do listen to lots of current event or at least I think I listen to Apple News and political current event, like stuff happening this week podcasts.

1:52:30The idea – but there is a middle ground of using the podcast in the conversational form for something that is historical.

1:52:42But the transcript wouldn't make necessarily a good book, right?

1:52:47I love Acquired, but I don't think a transcript of Acquired is something that I would enjoy reading.

1:52:53It is the conversation I enjoy listening to.

1:52:56It is very of the format.

1:52:58Like the – it is – it is – and that's what I'm hearing that this podcast is.

1:53:04And your 20 for 20 max thing was like that too.

1:53:07Yeah, this is – so it's a little bit different because that was more like edited collage of interviews and stuff.

1:53:12And this is more just sort of me selling stories and Mike asking me questions about it and us going back and forth about it.

1:53:16But that's the beauty of the format.

1:53:18It's why we love The Rest is History.

1:53:20You're not just telling the story, although you are telling the story, but you've also got somebody else who knows the subject matter who is asking you – like Michael asked me questions in the sample episodes we did that I'm like, I hadn't really thought of it that way, right?

1:53:34And it's like, well, let's talk about that.

1:53:36So you end up doing some analysis.

1:53:38One of the things that I came to in doing this – the thing that we're doing in Upgrade as bonus episodes and will be the first four episodes of the show when it airs in probably September-ish – is the Apple II.

1:53:54There's so many details that I didn't realize about it, including my favorite anecdote is that Steve Wozniak's dad decided to make Steve Jobs cry so that he'd give the company back to Steve Wozniak.

1:54:04It didn't work, by the way.

1:54:06But, I mean, it worked.

1:54:07He cried.

1:54:07He cried.

1:54:09Steve Jobs was a crier.

1:54:10But when Steve Jobs was like, look, if you want the whole thing, you can take it, but I'm adding value here.

1:54:16Like Jerry Wozniak.

1:54:18I did not know that, that he ambushed Steve Jobs and made him cry.

1:54:22But the moment – and Mike – having a give and take with Mike is really good because we talked about Steve Jobs' obsession with the finished product.

1:54:31And the Apple I was just a circuit board.

1:54:34But the Apple II was a finished product with a plastic shell, painted beige, and he cared about the details of it.

1:54:39It had a bunch of parts that were not the result of Steve Wozniak's genius.

1:54:44They were other people's genius, like the power supply, which was by a totally different – this random socialist biker dude named Rod Holt designed that, and that was a revolutionary power supply.

1:54:55And Mike and I are talking about this, and I realized, based on what we were talking about, that this is the moment where Steve Jobs shows Steve Wozniak's dad why it's a 50-50 partnership.

1:55:08It's because it's the first moment that Steve Jobs is Steve Jobs, recognizably Steve Jobs.

1:55:14You can see his traits before, but that product is the result of Steve Jobs thinking about the end product for a consumer market and saying,

1:55:22we need not just the technical brilliance of Steve Wozniak, but we also need the power supply, which he got from Rod Holt.

1:55:30They needed the case design, and every other case looked like it belonged in a lab and it was made out of metal.

1:55:35And he's like, no, we're going to make it out of plastic.

1:55:37I want it to look like a Cuisinart, which is such a leap to think of it as a consumer product.

1:55:42But that was Jobs.

1:55:44And I came to the realization at the end, this is like, oh, this is the appearance of a familiar Steve Jobs for the first time.

1:55:50And he spent the rest of his career trying to do the same thing again and again in a way,

1:55:57which was take this very technical thing and try to apply as much consumer sensibility to it as possible so that it could be used by regular people.

1:56:07The Apple II couldn't really be used by regular people, but like more than the Apple I.

1:56:11At least they could get it to turn on.

1:56:13Yeah, it had a keyboard attached to it.

1:56:16It was in a case.

1:56:17You didn't have to supply your own wood box for it.

1:56:20Anyway, it's stuff like that where it's good having the rapport with Mike, too, because he gets the Apple stuff.

1:56:25I've come with my research notes and all of that.

1:56:28And then we have a back and forth about it.

1:56:30It's a lot of fun.

1:56:31I mean, you just heard me.

1:56:33It's really fun to rediscover this stuff or discover stuff I didn't even knew before.

1:56:37And let me tell you, there are a lot of great books about Apple out there.

1:56:42They all cover different aspects.

1:56:44Most of them are out of print.

1:56:46I've got them all.

1:56:47I went on a used book buying Binge, and that's been fun because a lot of this stuff is not widely available.

1:56:55And David Polk's book is great, and I recommend it.

1:56:58It's huge, and it's authoritative, and it's great.

1:57:00The Steve Jobs biography is not great by Walter Isaacson, but it has a lot of details in it that are interesting.

1:57:06And you could read the audiobook version, and that's very entertaining.

1:57:10And David does a bunch of stuff in his audiobook version that is very David.

1:57:14He's an entertainer at heart.

1:57:15But this is a different format.

1:57:19And what I think we have going for us is we're going to focus in on some specific stories and do it in this way.

1:57:25And I'm trying to pull from all of the relevant backgrounds.

1:57:30So it's the books and where I can find them, the magazines, some of which I wrote, but they're in there.

1:57:36And oral histories at the Computer History Museum and all sorts of other stuff to try and tell a fun story about the history of this company that I would argue is,

1:57:46and you might agree with me, is one of, if not the most influential company in the last 50 years.

1:57:53Yeah, I agree.

1:57:54I think it has to be, especially, and I don't think that was, I thought so all along, but I think it's almost undeniable.

1:58:03Even people who don't like their products have to agree at this point.

1:58:07And the other gift, I talked about this when Pogue was on my show for his book a couple weeks ago.

1:58:12What a remarkable, I mean, 50 is a real close, about as close to an even number within a human lifespan that you can get to, right?

1:58:20Nobody who was there for the origin is going to be around for the 100th anniversary.

1:58:24Right.

1:58:25Unless some kind of Futurama brains in jars technology comes about.

1:58:31So who knows?

1:58:32But combined, though, with the fact that so much of the origin was from 20-year-olds, like in Espinosa's case, 14-year-olds,

1:58:42that 50 years on, so many of them are still around, that they're only in their 70s and are there to tell the story.

1:58:51And yeah, the last 10 to 15, and Pogue talked about it too, that the last 10 or 15 years is not as comprehensive.

1:58:59It just can't be.

1:59:00There's just no possible way.

1:59:02But it's also, even if Apple were a more open company and was more willing to talk about five-year-old stuff, like, yeah, we're still going to be secretive about what's coming and what's current.

1:59:16But yeah, five years ago, sure, we'll tell you the real origin story of the – or 10 years ago, right?

1:59:23Like, how did the iPhone 10 come about?

1:59:27What's the inside story on getting rid of the home button and going to round corners and the new swipe up?

1:59:33We'll tell that story now.

1:59:35And even if they were like that, I don't think that's – history needs time to settle before you know it, right?

1:59:42I agree.

1:59:43And I do think – I remember as I listened to the entirety of the 20 for 20 podcast, of course some recent Macs made the list.

1:59:51You know, I put them – I forget how you did it.

1:59:54I think I got the vote.

1:59:55I don't know.

1:59:55There was a –

1:59:56No, I just chose.

1:59:57You chose?

1:59:58All right.

1:59:58I'm mixing it up with my report card.

2:00:01But of course there were recent ones.

2:00:03But I think the episodes for the older ones were better because they were more – we know that that's – the SE30 is an all-time great Mac.

2:00:13We could think the M1 MacBook Air was an all-time great Mac, and it probably is, but it's like – it's so soon you don't know, right?

2:00:22And is it the M1 or is it the M2 or is it the – right?

2:00:27Like, yeah, it's too soon.

2:00:28It's too soon to know.

2:00:29Yeah.

2:00:30And it's like – I don't know.

2:00:31It needs time.

2:00:32I agree.

2:00:33And then you can see – if you can project back from 10 or 20 years in the future, looking back at that event, now you can see that – I mean, not to use a cliche, but that arc of history.

2:00:43You can see, oh, I see.

2:00:45I see.

2:00:46Now we know where they're going, right?

2:00:47Like, a thing that Mike brought up repeatedly when we were talking about these early days of Apple is Apple is not special in 1976, 1975.

2:00:58They are not – I mean, 76, 77 especially.

2:01:02They are not special.

2:01:04And Mike made the point.

2:01:05He's like, there are dozens of these companies, aren't there, that are literally just two kids selling tech stuff in the garage and companies that got some funding and had some salespeople in suits.

2:01:18And the only reason we're talking about Apple is that it made it.

2:01:22But it was not unique.

2:01:24There were – the people at Processor Technologies thought that the Sol was going to be a huge hit and that Processor Technologies was on its way.

2:01:35And I never heard of that company or its computer ever.

2:01:40At least you've heard of, like, Commodore.

2:01:42But Processor Technologies, they just died.

2:01:44And I think that is really interesting, right?

2:01:48It's like, this is a story that matters because of what happened over 50 years, not because of what – in that moment, it's important.

2:01:57But it's only important because we can look back at it now and trace the line and say that was important.

2:02:02And that – only time can give you that.

2:02:04Yeah.

2:02:05And the sweet spot for it is when time has given you that, but the people creating the work, documenting it, lived through it and can kind of put that first-person angle.

2:02:18And the people on it and the people who made it are still around to talk to, right?

2:02:22And I'm not saying that people who write about 17th century geopolitics are wasting their time, you know, or that new history isn't being – useful history isn't being forged of the founding of America 250 years ago.

2:02:39That's true.

2:02:39That's true.

2:02:40But it's past the sweet spot, right?

2:02:43It would be better.

2:02:44And anybody who's doing that work today for something that far in the past has to rely on the history work that was done 20, 30 years after the fact, right?

2:02:56So there might be – again, on the 100th year anniversary of Apple, there might be some really good history work being done, whether Apple is still around then or not.

2:03:07But it's going to be relying on things that were written today or recorded today, as the case may be.

2:03:15Right.

2:03:15Well, talking to Jeffrey Cain, who did the Steve Jobs in Exile book, which is really good, he spent a lot of time in the Apple Archive at Stanford.

2:03:23And he spent looking at papers and a lot of time at the Computer History Museum, I think, working with their historians.

2:03:31So, like, that is one of the benefits of this is that they're – right now is a good time in some ways because a lot of the people who are involved in this, they may not be around or they may not be around much longer.

2:03:46But a lot of people have had that realization that we need to talk to them.

2:03:51So the oral history stuff is very impressive.

2:03:54But also, yes, the fact is, at David Pogue's book event at the Computer History Museum, John Scully was just there.

2:04:02John Scully was just there.

2:04:04The guy who designed the original Apple logo and was the third partner in the partnership for about two weeks, Ron Wayne, who's in his 90s, was there.

2:04:13Bit of a kook.

2:04:15It is, yeah.

2:04:17I'm not planning on writing a book and doing a lot of original research for this, but I anticipate what's going to happen is I am going to hear from people who know what happened.

2:04:29And that's great.

2:04:31Bring it on.

2:04:31That sounds like a lot of fun.

2:04:32There's a place for books and then there's a place for stories.

2:04:35Yeah, yeah.

2:04:36I think that's right.

2:04:39And that's, at a certain level, that's fundamentally what human beings evolved to pick up.

2:04:45Right.

2:04:45And that's why we want to hop around, right?

2:04:47There are so many stories to tell and, like, different kinds of stories.

2:04:51Like, the Microsoft thing is totally different.

2:04:53Like, that's not about a particular event in history.

2:04:55It's about tracking a relationship between these two interesting companies over time.

2:04:59I haven't written that one yet, but it's up here.

2:05:02I know what I want to do with that to a certain degree.

2:05:04And the way we're planning on architecting this is, like, we'll do that and that'll be four episodes.

2:05:08And then we'll leave it.

2:05:09And then we'll do something else in a different era.

2:05:11And so, hopefully, we can keep good stories flowing as a part of this.

2:05:16I still say 50 episodes in 12 months is you're out of your freaking minds.

2:05:20But I'm really looking forward to it.

2:05:22We can do it.

2:05:23Well, okay.

2:05:24Yeah.

2:05:24Yeah.

2:05:25But we record four at once.

2:05:27I know.

2:05:28I know.

2:05:29We come back a month later.

2:05:30We just, well, we'll see.

2:05:31We'll see.

2:05:32We, fortunately, we have reached the point in the Kickstarter where every dollar that we

2:05:37get, it is just going to allow us to do, like, I realized that because we blew past our number,

2:05:42but we would still love everybody's support because it does help the show be better.

2:05:46I'm going to get people to read my scripts in advance and compare them to the sources and

2:05:50make sure I didn't make dumb mistakes.

2:05:52That's probably not something I could have done at $40,000 because we would be at the bare

2:05:58bones of what we could do.

2:05:59So, like, all of this stuff just gets better because people have shown, almost 2,000 people

2:06:05have said, yes, I want this to exist in the world, which is awesome.

2:06:08But it does allow us to make the show actually better in ways that if it was super bare bones,

2:06:16we couldn't have done.

2:06:17Every Kickstarter I link to, I do it because I think it is going to hit for a significant,

2:06:25a notable chunk of the Daring Fireball audience.

2:06:29And then there are Kickstarters where I'm like, well, who isn't going to contribute to this one?

2:06:35And that's what Designed in California is for me.

2:06:38I guess there are people listening to you pitch it here and me talk about how much I'm

2:06:43looking forward to it who are like, yeah, maybe I'll listen to the free version.

2:06:46But I don't know who you are.

2:06:48Like, if you're listening to this and you haven't already contributed, go to design.fm and do what

2:06:55I suspect you're probably doing with your thumbs right now on your phone and contributing because

2:07:00if this isn't right up the alley of the audience that I think that I have, then I don't understand

2:07:08my audience at all.

2:07:09And the plug I'll get for the people who are backing who are going to be members, essentially,

2:07:12I'll also say is when I say we're going to record four episodes at one time, the free feed

2:07:16will get those one a week.

2:07:17The members will just get them all at once.

2:07:20And this is what the rest is history does.

2:07:22And it's the best because, like, the first week of the World Cup, all of a sudden, six

2:07:27episodes, six hour-long episodes appeared in my feed that are about national anthems, which

2:07:34is such a great idea.

2:07:35National anthems and the history behind them of six countries that are in the World Cup.

2:07:38Right.

2:07:39Great episodes.

2:07:40Amazing.

2:07:41That's what we listen to on the drive to and from Oregon, I'll tell you, is we listen to

2:07:45all six of them.

2:07:46But that's a great benefit, right?

2:07:48Because the last thing you want to do is hit the cliffhanger and be like, well, what

2:07:52happens next.

2:07:53And so the members are just going to get the whole story at once.

2:07:55And the free feed will get part one and then wait a week for part two and then wait a week

2:08:00for part three.

2:08:01So it's plus bonus episodes and a bunch of other stuff, too.

2:08:04We're really hoping to do it right.

2:08:06But you know what?

2:08:07The fact is, if you don't want to back it, you will get that.

2:08:10It's still a podcast.

2:08:11It'll still be a free feed.

2:08:13It will be out there.

2:08:14But anybody, yeah, if you want to make it happen, if you're excited about it, I think

2:08:17it's going to be a fun ride.

2:08:18Yeah.

2:08:19All right.

2:08:20Well, anything else you wanted to talk about from WWDC?

2:08:22I have one more thing on my list.

2:08:24Yeah, let's do it.

2:08:25All right.

2:08:26Well, the one more thing for me is, did you see that they've, I think for iPhones, it's

2:08:31the same list for iOS 27 as 26.

2:08:35But for iPads, they cut some devices off.

2:08:40And notably mine, my 2018 11-inch iPad Pro.

2:08:45And I know why, because iOS 26 has absolutely sucked on it.

2:08:50And it's one of those things where it's like, I don't want to complain because, well, it is

2:08:56a 2018 iPad.

2:08:57How I probably, I can't complain that I'm due for a new one.

2:09:02But if I, if it were easy to go back to iPadOS 18, if it was just like, go through system

2:09:09settings and hit reset, and then you could pick it, I would.

2:09:12I don't even know if you can.

2:09:13I don't know if there's some kind of complicated DFU reset.

2:09:17I don't know.

2:09:17I don't think there is, because I don't think they sign iPadOS 18 anymore.

2:09:21So I don't think even in a wiped state, you can reinstall it.

2:09:24But it's, the whole time, it's been bad.

2:09:27And because I don't really care too much about my iPad, I installed the beta last summer and

2:09:33thought, well, this is probably unbelievably slow and freezes up.

2:09:37Like, at times, it breaks the number one rule of iOS, which is that even scrolling doesn't

2:09:42work.

2:09:42Like, the whole screen just looks like a screenshot.

2:09:45And it's like, I have to wait, and wait, and wait, and then I can maybe scroll again.

2:09:49I don't know.

2:09:50It should have been cut off a year earlier.

2:09:53This iPad never should have gotten iOS 26.

2:09:56And even with, and I thought, as I left the keynote, well, maybe with the optimizations and

2:10:01the new CPU scheduler and stuff, maybe it'll actually bring my old iPad back to usable life.

2:10:07And no, they just were like, no, you don't get it.

2:10:10No.

2:10:11Cut it right off.

2:10:12Eight years is a pretty good run.

2:10:15Oh, yeah.

2:10:16I can't complain.

2:10:16It was more like wishful thinking.

2:10:19Anything else that stuck out to you?

2:10:21It's not surprising, but like one of the things Joanna said to you on your live show is it

2:10:27feels, in the nerdiest comment I've ever heard Joanna Stern make, honestly, she said it feels

2:10:33like a DP3.

2:10:33It feels like a DP3.

2:10:34Yeah.

2:10:35Developer Preview 1 feels like Developer Preview 3.

2:10:37Yeah.

2:10:38which if it's, I guess if you spent your entire development cycle trying to be, find efficiency

2:10:45and stamp out bugs, that you wouldn't have that many bugs in your beta, right?

2:10:53Like on one level, isn't that the whole point?

2:10:55Is that this is the debug, more efficient release, and therefore why would it be riddled with bugs

2:11:03right now?

2:11:04So, like, I think that's interesting.

2:11:06And yeah, all signs point to that it's in pretty good shape.

2:11:11I'm reluctant to put it everywhere right now, but I did put it on my iPad.

2:11:15I had to restart it this morning.

2:11:17It got super jittery and janky and stuff, and it's still indexing on that device, so that's

2:11:23going to take forever.

2:11:23I will give everybody the advice that was given to me, and you probably got it too, which is

2:11:28if you're planning on later on this summer or even in the fall going to 27, get on the 26.6

2:11:38betas.

2:11:38Right.

2:11:39Because my understanding is that if you're on 26.6, all that spotlight indexing happens

2:11:45in the background, secretly, on 26.6.

2:11:49While it's charging.

2:11:51So when you upgrade to 27.

2:11:51Yeah, while it's charging, you can't access it.

2:11:54It's just building a new spotlight index.

2:11:56But it means that the moment you update to 27, it just picks up the index, and it doesn't

2:12:00have to sit there for three days indexing your phone.

2:12:02All right.

2:12:03Mine indexed for six days.

2:12:04I installed the beta after the keynote on Monday on a spare iPhone, and it's finished

2:12:10Sunday, so six days.

2:12:12And during those six days, you're like, oh, I see why they're pre-indexing in 26.6.

2:12:16But I have to say, it was very usable while it was still indexing.

2:12:19Sure, sure.

2:12:20So I could see why they're pre-indexing.

2:12:21I mean, I guess that's the thing I'll talk about last here on this show, is I've been...

2:12:26It's so good and so stable for a...

2:12:31It's maybe the most stable WWDC beta of iOS I've ever seen.

2:12:36Yeah.

2:12:36I mean, it's not necessarily the highest bar, but it is not...

2:12:40DP1 is usually pretty scary.

2:12:43Yeah.

2:12:44I mean, they've shipped a build that they figure will not destroy everybody, but is not always

2:12:50their best.

2:12:51And I think it's often the case that that first developer build for WWDC, there's some,

2:12:56at least two or three major tenfold features that really were just like, yes, we're going

2:13:02to get this together by September, but ooh, boy, we're going to give this to millions of

2:13:07people in June?

2:13:08Ooh, okay.

2:13:10Maybe we'll comment, comment, comment all this out and turn off this, turn off that.

2:13:15And the series stuff, I mean...

2:13:16And I think there's often stuff that has never been together, right?

2:13:20There's like a build of iOS that has this new thing, and other people are testing a version

2:13:24that has that new thing, but nope.

2:13:26And you put it together and it goes kablooey.

2:13:27Yeah, it goes kablooey.

2:13:28None of that this year.

2:13:29I feel like we've been so focused on AI and Apple's failing from two years ago that I feel

2:13:36like we haven't given enough attention to the fact that they seem to have actually fixed

2:13:40Siri.

2:13:40I know it's there.

2:13:42Yes.

2:13:42Right.

2:13:43I know it's there, but perspective, it's been like a decade where we've been saying Siri isn't

2:13:48good enough, and then Mike Rockwell came in and was like, I'm going to burn it to the

2:13:53ground.

2:13:53I filled in for somebody who is absent, I don't know why, on MacBreak Weekly this week.

2:13:59I don't know why.

2:14:00They had some bullshit excuse.

2:14:02Somebody was in the car.

2:14:02Yeah.

2:14:03Somewhere in southern Oregon.

2:14:04Sons graduating from college or something.

2:14:06Yeah.

2:14:06But I said, Leo asked me about you spending a week with Siri AI and iOS 27 on an iPhone.

2:14:12And I said, honest to God, Leo, the hardest thing is to remember to use it.

2:14:16The whole reason I switched my SIM to this phone at WWDC to start using it as my daily main phone

2:14:24was to try to test Siri AI.

2:14:26And that's the whole reason I'm using beta one.

2:14:30And I keep forgetting because I've so ingrained, oh, don't try Siri for that.

2:14:35Don't try Siri.

2:14:36Right.

2:14:37Like, why would you use Siri for that?

2:14:39I know.

2:14:39And every once in a while, I'll catch myself doing something, searching the web or going to

2:14:45chat GPT.

2:14:46And I'm like, oh, I should try that in Siri first.

2:14:48And I'm like, oh, that probably won't work.

2:14:50And every single time so far, it's worked.

2:14:52It's amazing.

2:14:53In a personal context, it's kind of hit and miss still, which I totally expect.

2:14:58But I've had those things, just like Joanna said last week, I've had those moments where

2:15:03I've asked.

2:15:04So like I do a, it was originally a pandemic project and we just do it now in the summer

2:15:09for fun podcast with Phil Michaels and David Lohr, where we watch old episodes of Magnum

2:15:13P.I.

2:15:13Randomly.

2:15:14It's fun.

2:15:14It's great.

2:15:15I loved that show when I was a kid.

2:15:16And we plan it.

2:15:18We record those two at a time and we plan it in an iMessage thread where we will at the

2:15:23end of the recording, we'll say, okay, here are the next two episodes we're doing.

2:15:26And every time I sit down where I'm like, oh yeah, we're recording that tomorrow.

2:15:31I need to watch.

2:15:31I got to take my medicine.

2:15:32I got to watch Magnum P.I.

2:15:34solve some crimes in Hawaii in 1985.

2:15:36I have to scroll through my message history to find what we said.

2:15:41And I did that thing where I said, what are the next two episodes of Magnum P.I.

2:15:46that we're doing on the podcast?

2:15:47And within 30 seconds or whatever, Siri AI came back and said,

2:15:53it's this episode and this episode.

2:15:55Because it was able to formulate a spotlight search on that, that, that turned up the message

2:16:04that was most recent because there are plenty of messages that list episodes, but it was

2:16:08the most recent ones.

2:16:09And I was like, okay, that is useful because what's better than me searching messages is

2:16:17me not searching messages and you just telling me the answer.

2:16:21And I feel like that's the platonic ideal of Siri AI on device search in a way is just

2:16:26like, I know it's there.

2:16:28I might not know whether it's an email or in message thread or something else, but like

2:16:35just, I know it's there.

2:16:37Can you search for it?

2:16:38And telling it to do whatever search it needs to formulate to get where it needs to go.

2:16:43And so I'm really optimistic about it.

2:16:45We'll see.

2:16:45It's early days yet.

2:16:46Right.

2:16:47But like, so far, so good.

2:16:49Yeah.

2:16:49And one of the examples I cited it, if you listened on MacBreak Weekly, I talked about

2:16:53it, but my, my barber works in a building.

2:16:57He moved from one place and he opened his own place in a building where it's like a shared,

2:17:03it's like a whole floor where stylists and nail salons and stuff can rent like a very small

2:17:09place, but you need a door code to get in the building.

2:17:13And I was on my way.

2:17:16And I just said to Siri, what did Tola tell me his door code is?

2:17:20That's his name, Tola.

2:17:21And it took 15 seconds, maybe, I don't know.

2:17:25It's a little longer than I wish, but not too long.

2:17:28And then it said the door code is one, two, three, four, and showed me the text message where

2:17:34he had sent it to me weeks ago.

2:17:35It's a week's old text message.

2:17:37It was exactly just ask the phone.

2:17:41What did he tell me?

2:17:42Cause I don't want to remember it.

2:17:43And what I used to do is just, I know he, I knew he texted, but I didn't say, what did

2:17:48he text me?

2:17:48What did he tell me the door code is?

2:17:50And my only complaint about the answer is that verbally, cause I'm, and I'm, I did this as

2:17:57I was walking down the city street to go is I had my AirPods in and the verbal answer from

2:18:04Siri pronounced the door code 1,234.

2:18:11Which is sort of, it's correct.

2:18:14But I was like, Oh, but that's not right.

2:18:16Cause that's not how people talk about door codes.

2:18:18You don't say voices are, are kind of broken.

2:18:21Mine felt like somebody from like not Canada or, but something like that, where it's like

2:18:27a country that speaks North American English.

2:18:29Do you have it on, on a phone, a last year phone that has the new voices?

2:18:33I've got the, yeah.

2:18:35Yeah.

2:18:35And, and, and it, it referred it, I think it mispronounced podcast.

2:18:39It said like podcast.

2:18:41And I'm like, what are you doing voice?

2:18:44That's just a normal word.

2:18:45But it was like, well, this person obviously comes from some weird part of North America

2:18:51that has, no, it's just like, it's kind of busted right now.

2:18:54There's a, there's a bunch of stuff.

2:18:55I've saw somebody else say that, that is like the code is 108,324.

2:18:59And it's like, nope, that's not it.

2:19:01You gotta, gotta, gotta work on that one.

2:19:03Yeah.

2:19:03But boy, that seems like a fixable problem.

2:19:06You know, this is what, look, I don't know if you got the shortcuts experience that I did,

2:19:11but yes, yes.

2:19:13I've had a few moments and I think this is a sign that this is a good release and that

2:19:18Apple is moving in the right direction.

2:19:19I've had a few moments in the last week where I've thought this is actually fulfilling stuff

2:19:27that we wanted our devices to do, but it's never been able to be quite as good.

2:19:32And it's things like, what if I ask you for information and you figure out where it might

2:19:37be in search for it and what the search terms might be and look at what the results are and

2:19:42then come back with what you think the answer is.

2:19:44And with shortcuts, it's like all those dreams, all the way back to hyper talk in hyper card

2:19:50and Apple script and everything else that's been shortcuts is literally every weekday morning

2:19:58at 5am, send me a list of all of my to do's and events for the day.

2:20:06You type that and hit return and it builds a shortcut that does it.

2:20:11That is it.

2:20:13And that is the dream, right?

2:20:14Even if you talk to Sal Segoian, he will tell you, Mr. Apple script, he will tell you that

2:20:19ultimately the dream is that a user could just tell their device what it wants from it.

2:20:26Mr. Automation is a better way to put it, right?

2:20:28Yeah, you're right.

2:20:28Mr. Automation.

2:20:29He did Automator 2.

2:20:31His goal was always better and broader than any specific tool, you know?

2:20:36Absolutely.

2:20:37And he would be the first to tell you.

2:20:39And he's around.

2:20:40I'm sure he would.

2:20:42If I talked to him today, he would tell me this, which is, this is the dream, right?

2:20:45Is why don't you just tell your computer what to do?

2:20:48And it says, got it.

2:20:50And then you can say, do that every day at 5am.

2:20:53And it says, got it.

2:20:55And that's it.

2:20:55And that shortcuts thing.

2:20:57I mean, it's limited.

2:20:58You can't make it too complicated.

2:20:59It doesn't use third-party apps yet.

2:21:01Like, I get it.

2:21:02It's got a lot of limitations.

2:21:03I was about to ask you.

2:21:05You just read my mind.

2:21:06I often leave WWDC with a long list of, oh, shit, I should have asked this question, that question.

2:21:11I only had like three questions this year on the plane ride home where I'm like, oh, I should have asked that.

2:21:15And one was, can it use third-party app actions?

2:21:19Any answers?

2:21:20Not yet.

2:21:20Okay.

2:21:21Not yet.

2:21:22Not yet.

2:21:22And they haven't said, and that's one of my questions for them is, is this one of those things where we might see that in a future beta?

2:21:28Or is that one of those things where it's like, we're not talking about it, which means it's not going to ship with that?

2:21:31Clearly, it's a direction that they would go is it should know what apps you've got installed and be able to use them too.

2:21:38For that, it's kind of like a core part of Siri AI, this idea to have app knowledge, but it's not there yet.

2:21:43It's trained.

2:21:44Federico, of course, took the model apart and knows that there's a database and it's of all the actions of all the Apple built apps in the system.

2:21:51And that's it.

2:21:52But like still, it does fulfill that.

2:21:55I have a very simple automation that I was comfortable building in shortcuts, which is when my phone connects to my shower speaker because I listen to podcasts in the shower.

2:22:03It puts me in do not disturb.

2:22:04So does my wife.

2:22:06It puts me in do not disturb because I have been in the shower and had people text me.

2:22:10And it's so because I want to see the text now.

2:22:13Right.

2:22:14And I'm in the shower.

2:22:15I don't.

2:22:15So it's like, I don't even want to know.

2:22:17I don't even want to know that somebody is trying to reach me when I'm in the shower.

2:22:20I'm listening to my podcast.

2:22:21I'll get out.

2:22:22But I could build that.

2:22:23Well, you know what?

2:22:24In in 27, you can just say when I connect to my shower speaker, put me in do not disturb and you hit return and it says which one of these Bluetooth devices is your shower speaker and you pick it and it says done.

2:22:37And that's it.

2:22:38It's automation is turned on because they added that feature.

2:22:41All the automation is attached to the shortcut now instead of being in a separate place.

2:22:45And like, I don't know, I think it's really exciting because that's the kind of stuff that people have been talking about for like 40 years.

2:22:51Could you use natural language to control your device where it's intelligent enough to do the programming for you?

2:22:57And like that shortcuts is on that path.

2:23:00Every semi savvy user knows how it's a human being.

2:23:04It's even it's it's a remarkable aspect of being a human being just looking at us as as machines that even human beings who are on the wrong side of the 50 yard line IQ wise, everybody learns how to talk.

2:23:21And they learn how to understand language.

2:23:23Right.

2:23:23And you could just take a person with low IQ as a baby and just put them in the world and they just listen and they learn they learn how to talk and to understand language.

2:23:35We know that's that is maybe the fundamental thing.

2:23:39That's why I said to that stories are the reason the the way of learning things that we either best learn and most enjoy learning.

2:23:48It's like what we evolved to be.

2:23:51And so we can communicate what we want these devices to do in language.

2:23:57We really can we can say I would like to be able to just play a podcast and go into do not disturb and here and it'll do it.

2:24:06Yeah.

2:24:06I don't need to know that there's a trigger block.

2:24:08Yeah.

2:24:09I don't need to know that there's, you know, an if then statement.

2:24:11I don't need to know any of that.

2:24:12I just like do this thing.

2:24:13And because the shortcuts thing is iterative, you can do the vibe coding thing where you say do this thing and then you can add actually do this thing every day.

2:24:23Yeah.

2:24:23And it'll be like great and it rebuilds it and now it does it every day.

2:24:27And like I mean seriously, that is a dream.

2:24:31This is the closest I've seen to the fulfillment of that dream in 40 years.

2:24:36Yeah.

2:24:36And it might be maybe it would have come out this way either way, but it's great that shortcuts has already existed for as long as it has.

2:24:45And as frustrating as I and many others who are used to typing a programming language find the block-based nature of shortcuts to be just like just the nested if thens and stuff like that.

2:24:58It's just so finicky and so hard.

2:25:00And this, what's great about it is the new default view of a shortcut in iOS 27 and macOS 27 is you just open the shortcut and it's a shortcut that with a play button and you just play it.

2:25:13And because I think the assumption is most of them are going to be made by just talking to Siri AI and having it made, but then there's a tab at the top where you can just see the traditional view.

2:25:24So you don't have to ever look at it, but if you have never really done it or you've just kind of clicked around and you're like, I know that there are so many people building things that they know they would never have made otherwise.

2:25:37Right, like our friend Adam Lissagore, friend of the show and the guy at Sandwich Video, he's made, I've linked to it, the Hovercraft.

2:25:45He was on the show, this show recently talking about it.

2:25:48He'd be the first to admit that he isn't a Mac developer and now he's made this Mac app that does a kind of complex thing.

2:25:55But before you get to using AI to vibe code, a thing that you know you couldn't have made without AI is the first step of, oh, I could make that on my own.

2:26:08I know I could make that on my own, but I probably I'm not going to carve out the time to do it.

2:26:14But if I just tell the thing and because, you know, you could build it, you know, it's possible, right?

2:26:21You know that you could build a shortcut that turns on do not disturb when you go in the shower or when you're playing a podcast.

2:26:26It's it comes to your mind to build that habit in the same way that I have to build a habit now of remembering, oh, use Siri for that.

2:26:35Use Siri.

2:26:36Try Siri.

2:26:37Try it.

2:26:37Just try it because I don't have an expectation that Siri can do it.

2:26:41But the whole list of things I know shortcut can do, but that I've never taken the time to build a shortcut to do because it seems like it would be a pain in the ass and I wouldn't want to do it.

2:26:51Now I'm going to make them.

2:26:53And if I want to make a small tweak, maybe I won't do it iteratively through the vibe coding.

2:26:59I will open it up and look at the steps and say, oh, right here.

2:27:03It's not the code, but it's close.

2:27:05It's what passes for code.

2:27:06Yeah.

2:27:06Also, there's levels, right?

2:27:08Like, I don't mean I'm sure somebody out there heard me just rave about typing a thing into shortcuts using Apple's technologies only and was like, come on, Jason.

2:27:15Like, you can build whole apps.

2:27:16Like, I built a Mac app the other week.

2:27:18Yeah.

2:27:18Yeah, you did too.

2:27:20It's staggering.

2:27:20But most people don't.

2:27:22Most people don't want to.

2:27:23Most people.

2:27:23This is why I believe that developers have a future.

2:27:25It's like being a developer requires like a vision and detail and all these things that most people do not want to do.

2:27:34Right?

2:27:35Simple tasks and shortcuts, I totally think, even then, it's only going to be like 10% of the people are going to want to do even that.

2:27:42Almost nobody is going to want to do all the work required to get an app when there's a person who's used their brain for weeks or months or years to come up with an app that solves problems, that's listened to the customer needs and has built a good app.

2:27:57And just because you can vibe code something and you can make something good, most people don't want to do that level of work.

2:28:04So there is a future for people who care, but I also do think it's amazing that we are seeing, I wrote a piece about this, like how many longtime Mac users are building Mac apps now because they can and they're the ones who care.

2:28:18They really care about making their Mac experience better.

2:28:21And like, that's great that the code is no longer the limitation for them, but be clear, that is a, it's a fraction of a fraction of the user base.

2:28:31And the shortcuts thing alone, like what I like about it is it's so simple that maybe in the long run, you're just telling Siri, hey, could you do this thing?

2:28:39And it says, sure.

2:28:40And then you say, could you do that every day?

2:28:42And it goes, yeah, I just made a shortcut and turned it on and it's done now.

2:28:44And like, that's the, that's how low the bar should go.

2:28:47Yeah.

2:28:48And I also think I know that one of the things, you know, and I thought, who knows, I don't know what Apple's going to do at WWDC, especially with developer tools where they can keep it secret is, are they going to have the whole Xcode vibe coding thing for making whole apps?

2:29:02And the answer is no, they didn't really.

2:29:04I mean, there's, there's, there's features, AI features and people, but people are already, developers are already doing it, right?

2:29:12You did it.

2:29:13Adam did it.

2:29:14You can use Cursor, you can use Codex, you can use other people's things to drive Xcode to make Mac apps.

2:29:21I use Cloud Code in an empty Xcode project.

2:29:23And the problem is I had to ask Cloud, like, where to click.

2:29:26And as a longtime Mac user, Xcode is so not a good normal Mac app that Cloud would say like, hey, you need to click on this thing in Xcode and do this thing for me.

2:29:35And I'd be like, I don't know what you're talking about.

2:29:37You need to tell me exactly what to do.

2:29:39And I felt like such a dummy, but it's like, I am really good at reading Mac user interfaces.

2:29:43I have no idea what you're talking about.

2:29:45And it's because like, it's in a pane in a tab that has opens another window that has another set of tabs under it.

2:29:52And you're like, what am, what are we even doing here?

2:29:54And that's why I think Apple should make an effort to make it easier to create Mac apps or iOS apps using Vibe coding tools.

2:30:01And that means making some of the junk that's around that.

2:30:05It's hard to get that far in Xcode.

2:30:07I do think they should make that easier for people like me who who have the interest.

2:30:13But like, I just, I hit a wall with Xcode and I asked Claude to handhold me through it and it did.

2:30:18But like, I think a quick win to make Apple's development platform that much better for people who have ideas.

2:30:26Because in the end, it's a small group.

2:30:28Some people have really good ideas for a thing that they want to exist in the world and nobody else makes it.

2:30:35And like, you can do it.

2:30:37You could just make it be in the world now.

2:30:39That's exciting.

2:30:39I still think that's probably coming.

2:30:42I wouldn't be surprised if there's something.

2:30:44I keep saying if Xcode is Logic Pro, it needs a garage band.

2:30:49What's a garage band for apps?

2:30:50Even if it's just a front end on Xcode.

2:30:52Right.

2:30:52What's the iMovie to Final Cut Pro for apps?

2:30:56Or Swift Playground, but Swift Playground isn't there.

2:31:00Not that Swift Playground doesn't have a reason, but it's not the answer.

2:31:05It's not what GarageBand is, right?

2:31:08And I just linked to some young artist who made a super hit song in GarageBand on an iPad when she was in high school, like when she was supposed to be in class.

2:31:17And it's like, you can use GarageBand to make a real song.

2:31:20You can't really use Swift Playground to make a real app.

2:31:23There's no really amazing like, oh, it's like Hovercraft, right, from Adam.

2:31:28And then you find out he made it in Swift Playground.

2:31:30No, that didn't happen.

2:31:32There should be.

2:31:33But that could still be coming.

2:31:35But I still feel like the shortcuts thing that they did announce and is here to use today in the betas is actually a better first step because it's more people are going to use it because more people have a shortcut scope thing.

2:31:52I wish I would like a 5 a.m. daily email sent to me with this, this, this, and this from these four sources.

2:32:06And there's no one app that connects to those four sources.

2:32:08You could use shortcuts to build that and have it run at 5 a.m. every day.

2:32:13And then you're like, the first day you get one on Saturday, you're like, oh, I forgot.

2:32:17I don't want it every day.

2:32:18And then you just say to it, I meant only a weekday.

2:32:22And then it'll just be like, OK, only every weekday.

2:32:24And then it'll change it.

2:32:25That is that is a better first step.

2:32:29Do step one first.

2:32:31And then maybe next year we get garage apps or whatever.

2:32:34But this is a better first step.

2:32:36And to me is the first time shortcuts is like, oh, this is now a good system.

2:32:44I've sort of been very mixed feelings about shortcuts all the way up until last week.

2:32:49And now I'm like, oh, this is the way shortcuts should be.

2:32:53And this justifies the finickiness of the block based nature of the actual shortcut.

2:32:59It's like, I don't mind it now if I can just talk to the damn thing and have it do these things.

2:33:04That's fair.

2:33:05Also, I have to say one of my favorite things that happens at WWDC is when there are longstanding

2:33:09grievances with Apple features and then a new Apple feature requires them to be better,

2:33:14which in this case, like, yes, if else has not been in existence in shortcuts, which is

2:33:21like a fun.

2:33:22It's so frustrating.

2:33:23And I I have to imagine plus the attaching of of of automations to specific shortcuts.

2:33:29Yeah.

2:33:30And I mean, we all know what happened, right, is that the people who are doing the vibe coding

2:33:33interface for shortcuts are like, what do you mean there's no if else?

2:33:35Yeah.

2:33:36Like, all right, we're on it.

2:33:37We'll do it.

2:33:37We'll build it for you.

2:33:38What do you mean you have to go to a separate tab to attach?

2:33:41No, no.

2:33:42OK, we'll fix it.

2:33:42We'll fix it.

2:33:43Apple is Apple's best customer sometimes.

2:33:45And then people who care about shortcuts, they get those features, too.

2:33:48Right.

2:33:48Yeah.

2:33:48And I think the one that nobody was surprised by, including the team building Siri AI, is

2:33:54they weren't surprised by the fact that Apple Mail can't really search Apple Mail.

2:33:59And they're like, well, this time we really need it to be able to search.

2:34:03Yeah.

2:34:04Spotlight in general.

2:34:05Right.

2:34:06Clearly, Spotlight wasn't good enough for Siri AI.

2:34:10And so after years where we've all been like, guys, the Spotlight Index isn't very good.

2:34:14And it doesn't surface mail properly in mail because it's using Spotlight.

2:34:18Like, finally, Apple rolls in with Siri AI and they're like, this is all predicated on Spotlight

2:34:23working.

2:34:24Yeah.

2:34:24And I'll give you another example, too.

2:34:27Because this is one of those ways that computer interfaces in general, it's a very slow transition.

2:34:35But it was effectively, if you really think about it, very radical, which is in the classic

2:34:43era, go back to classic Mac and go back even to the early days of Mac OS X.

2:34:50Search interfaces were feature rich.

2:34:53And it's I'm not just talking about BB edit where you had regular expression searching all

2:34:58the way back in 1992.

2:35:00But any app that had search would have a pretty complex list, you know, word processors, everything

2:35:09that had search almost every time if the app gained any success had a pretty powerful set

2:35:16of search tools.

2:35:18And over time, that got reduced to no, there's just an oval in the corner of the window and

2:35:24you type and you don't even.

2:35:25And yeah, there are like in Apple Mail, you can type from colon Jason and then you hit return.

2:35:33But there's no pop up for that.

2:35:34And that's frustrating.

2:35:36I only want to search the from.

2:35:37I don't want anything that mentioned somebody named Jason just emails from because I don't

2:35:42remember the guy's last name.

2:35:43I just know he was named Jason and he emailed me.

2:35:46You can do that, but now you have to know something that's even nerdier than if they had a little

2:35:51pop up menu there for that.

2:35:52And for me, Apple Notes is I have let me count.

2:35:572,680 Apple Notes.

2:36:01It has been since Vesper went to the great beyond of apps that demise.

2:36:07This is where I put my notes.

2:36:08And yes, I'll bet most of my 2,680 notes are no longer relevant.

2:36:14But I don't feel like going I'm not going to go through and delete them.

2:36:17But all Apple Notes has for search is an oval up in the corner where you start typing and

2:36:23it doesn't really limit it to like the title of the note or whatever.

2:36:28I know I made an Apple Note telling me how to change the propane tank on the grill or whatever

2:36:36thing you do once a year is.

2:36:38I know I have an Apple Note, but God damn it.

2:36:41If you use the new Siri AI and you just say, how did I do this?

2:36:47It'll search through your notes.

2:36:48And it's such a better interface for search because you can just say it in a sentence what

2:36:54note you're looking for.

2:36:55And you don't have to magically know a string of multiple words you put in the note.

2:37:00It surfaces the right note in a big pile of notes in a way that the Notes app itself really

2:37:07can't.

2:37:08This is the best thing maybe about LLMs is this idea that if I tell you what I am trying

2:37:18to look for, if I type that in a traditional search box, it doesn't find anything, right?

2:37:24Because it's, oh, oh, you were searching for this word, but conceptually that's right, but

2:37:30it was a different word.

2:37:31But if you talk to an LLM and you say, can you find this thing in context?

2:37:35It's better at that.

2:37:37It's just better at that because it's not doing a harsh, hard text string search.

2:37:42It's doing a holistic kind of like semantic search.

2:37:45And that sounds kind of highfalutin, but it's more like, don't make me search for the

2:37:52word, I'm looking for the red wagon.

2:37:55And they're like, well, you didn't use the word wagon.

2:37:57You use trailer.

2:37:59It's okay.

2:38:00You know what I mean, right?

2:38:01But a string search, classic old computer string search, will not find that.

2:38:07But a semantic search using an LLM will.

2:38:09So yeah, I guess that's the answer.

2:38:10At what point do our search boxes and apps just become places where you type what you

2:38:17were looking for and it is reformatted into a property query by a search engine?

2:38:21I don't know.

2:38:22Yeah, that's kind of where I'm going is the next step here after they get the, like maybe

2:38:27a next year thing is to sort of turn those search boxes in all these apps into a net.

2:38:32You know, if that's the way you want to go and you don't want to give me an interface

2:38:36with a couple of pop-ups for things like the from or the subject or the title or whatever

2:38:42so that I can do a more complex search than just typing words in an oval, make it a Siri

2:38:49AI interface.

2:38:50And if I'm typing in the search field in Apple Notes, it can already prompt Siri to be like,

2:38:59well, just search Apple Notes, right?

2:39:01I don't have to type search this notes database for blank, blank, blank about my grill on the

2:39:07deck.

2:39:08It's it can already, you know, if you're typing in notes, it kind of knows that.

2:39:11I don't know.

2:39:12It's way better already.

2:39:14I can't remember feeling one week after WWDC, like I kind of have to, I guess I'm going

2:39:20to wait for beta two just to have a couple more bugs shake out, but I've got to put this

2:39:24on my main phone.

2:39:25More to the point.

2:39:26This is your opportunity to leap right over Tahoe.

2:39:29It's I'm going to.

2:39:30Yeah.

2:39:30And I guess that's the last thing.

2:39:32I mean, I know we're going long here, so I won't go into, but basically my take on the

2:39:36interface in Mac OS 27 Golden Gate.

2:39:40I remember the name.

2:39:40I love it.

2:39:42I don't love everything about it, but the thing I love is that every single change is

2:39:46for the better.

2:39:47And in fact, I would say that about iOS 27 too.

2:39:49And I was talking to friend of the show, Cable Sasser from Panic.

2:39:53I can't find a single interface change they have made since last year on any of these platforms

2:39:58that I think is for the worse.

2:40:00There are some that I think like, I don't really care, but for the most part, every single

2:40:04interface change that's different is for the better.

2:40:07And Mac OS nowhere is that more true.

2:40:10I saw Jaws after the keynote and he laughed and he said his favorite moment from the keynote

2:40:16was when they mentioned the corner radiuses being the same and that everybody laughed and

2:40:23cheered.

2:40:23And he said, that's how I knew that this was still a real WWDC audience.

2:40:28Nowhere else would people laugh and cheer for corner radiuses being fixed.

2:40:34And I was like, yeah, that was a great moment.

2:40:36They got rid of the stupid icons in the menu bar.

2:40:39I mean, they just got rid of them.

2:40:40And the ones that are left are actually sensible.

2:40:42It's like the only ones that are left by default are ones where it actually does improve the

2:40:48legibility and scannability of the menus.

2:40:50They just said, you know what, effectively by getting rid of it, they're like, yeah, that

2:40:54was a mistake.

2:40:54So, yeah, I look forward to upgrading to Mac OS.

2:40:57In addition to the fact that I've entire, I'm going to no doubt entirely skip Tahoe, except

2:41:04now I'm wondering, is it better to upgrade to Tahoe and then upgrade to 27 because the upgrade

2:41:10from 26 to 27, it might be better tested.

2:41:12But I'd like to be able to say I just skipped right to it.

2:41:16Yeah.

2:41:16But I honestly, I think I'm going to go from skipping an entire year's Mac OS on my main

2:41:23work Mac.

2:41:24To a developer beta?

2:41:24To a developer beta.

2:41:26I honest to God, because I don't see how I'm going to wait.

2:41:29I really don't.

2:41:30No.

2:41:31It's so many good things.

2:41:32I'm very excited.

2:41:33Yeah.

2:41:33Even the icons look better, the app icons.

2:41:36And I feel like it's not a huge difference, but it's like the decline in the artistic value

2:41:43of application icons coming from Apple and their direction for the platform bottomed out

2:41:49last year.

2:41:50And now the curve, it's gone back up.

2:41:53It's not to get personal, but I'll say it's as if there was a real change in philosophy in

2:41:58the design group.

2:41:59Yes.

2:41:59Yes.

2:42:00As if.

2:42:01Right.

2:42:01Not to make it personal.

2:42:02Who knows what that might be.

2:42:04Right.

2:42:05And so, and I just off the record, somebody from the design team I ran into after my

2:42:11show, and I was like, what's the mood?

2:42:13And they're like, the mood is great inside the software design team at Apple.

2:42:17They're just, everybody there feels good.

2:42:20Feels good about what they showed last week and feels good about the direction they're going.

2:42:23And I have to say, it feels that way on the outside too.

2:42:27So, yeah.

2:42:28Tahoe, screw you.

2:42:30It's gone.

2:42:31Jason, thank you for doing the show.

2:42:35Good to see you last week.

2:42:36Good to have you on right here.

2:42:37First and foremost, I will remind people, designed.fm.

2:42:42That'll take you to the Kickstarter.

2:42:43If you're listening to this episode in June, go there.

2:42:46Sign up if you haven't already.

2:42:48Six colors, com, and as I always like to note, you can spell colors whichever way you feel

2:42:53is natural.

2:42:55It's true.

2:42:55I pay for both of those domains and redirect.

2:42:57It's true.

2:42:58Yeah.

2:42:58I had to laugh.

2:42:59Andy and Adko on MacBreak Weekly yesterday.

2:43:02I forget what the context was, but I was like, oh, that's going to be episode title.

2:43:06He said the phrase, intimately, intimate functionalities.

2:43:11And we all started laughing.

2:43:13And then Leo had a bit about it.

2:43:16And then two minutes later, Andy was like, well, I registered the domain.

2:43:21Yeah.

2:43:21Yeah.

2:43:23Registering domains is a hazard of the job, honestly.

2:43:27So no intimate functionalities there, but you can go to sixcolors.com.

2:43:32You can even go to sixcolo.rs if you want to, because I give money, I tithe to the Republic

2:43:38of Serbia annually for that domain.

2:43:41That's a new one.

2:43:42Sixcolo.

2:43:43Colo.rs.

2:43:44I don't know what I was even thinking.

2:43:46Look.

2:43:46Yeah.

2:43:48It does look good.

2:43:48But you don't want to say it.

2:43:50Right.

2:43:51Yeah.

2:43:51No, it's not.

2:43:52It was during the brief time when link shorteners looked like they were going to be a thing.

2:43:56And so I got that as a good link shortening domain, and then it suddenly didn't matter

2:44:00anymore.

2:44:00So it just redirects to, but it's fine.

2:44:02It's all good.

2:44:02Upgrade, of course, is your regular podcast with Mike Hurley and anything else you want

2:44:07to mention?

2:44:08No, I'm very grateful that I got to talk about the new podcast here, and hopefully people

2:44:13will enjoy it.

2:44:14The thing is, we announced it, and then there's WWDC, and then I'm going for my son's graduation

2:44:20and all of that.

2:44:21And it's like, only now am I at the point where I'm like, I could actually start working

2:44:26on this new project.

2:44:27Right.

2:44:28Because we announced it.

2:44:29I mean, you got to announce it when people are paying attention, which is WWDC is a good

2:44:33time to do it.

2:44:34Yeah.

2:44:34But I look forward to actually proceeding with the work of doing the podcast now.

2:44:39I do too.

2:44:40I look forward to listening to it.

2:44:42All right.

2:44:43Thank you, Jason.