Podcast Search

The Talk Show

452: ‘A Scam Held Together With Patriotism and Golden Paint’, With Quinn Nelson

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00Quinn, I don't know what I'm going to do in September because usually I go out to Cupertino and go to see the new iPhones that are coming out, but there's no point this year because it's been obviated. The Trump T1 phone came out.

0:00:11That's right. I mean, what else do you need, right?

0:00:15Oh, boy. What a disaster that thing is.

0:00:20I don't know. I want to talk about it with you, but without discouraging listeners from going to your channel to watch your video about it. Somehow you got 30 minutes out of it, and I wanted so much more.

0:00:34Well, good. That's high praise. I was worried that we wouldn't be able to make anything super entertaining about it because ultimately it's just a rebranded HTC phone.

0:00:45But the process of trying to get it, and then the way that it was packaged, and even as it came, everything was so absurd that, yeah, it just ended up being a content goldmine.

0:00:57I should have written it down, and it's so great. It's early in the video, and you say that it is a phone that is held together with patriotism, and I forget the other thing.

0:01:09I don't remember.

0:01:10It's not held together.

0:01:11It's in hopes and dreams or something.

0:01:12Yeah, hopes and dreams. And if you have an opinion of the Trump family's actual patriotism that even vaguely matches mine, you'll realize that the phone isn't held together at all.

0:01:24No, not well. Not well, that's for sure.

0:01:28Yeah.

0:01:29So it is not a good phone?

0:01:33That's the thing, is no, but it's not as bad as it was rumored to be.

0:01:39And who the hell knew what it was going to be anyway? Because they released like nine different renderings. Some of them were clearly done by AI. It wasn't even a device that existed.

0:01:49Once they took an iPhone and made it gold, and they're like, yep, this is the Trump phone. Okay, yeah, good luck with that one.

0:01:55And so by the time it finally shipped, there had been so much, I think, I don't want to say misreporting.

0:02:02I think it was, there had been so little information that people were just surmising what the phone would be.

0:02:08And I saw an overwhelming number of outlets report that it was some kind of rebranded $120 Chinese OEM device.

0:02:17And I was looking at this phone compared to the Trump phone, or at least the renders that they had released.

0:02:22And I was thinking to myself, those are not the same phones.

0:02:24It is quite literally, it looks exactly the same as the HTC U24 Pro.

0:02:29And so that's probably what the phone is. And sure enough, I got it. And it was, that's what it is.

0:02:33And that phone is also a bad value, but it's around the same-ish price.

0:02:39And so if you really wanted an HTC U24 Pro, and you wanted it in yellow, because the phone's not gold,

0:02:46then the Trump T1, maybe not such a bad buy.

0:02:50So I think the U24, if I recall, it's like $400. And the Trump T1 phone is $500.

0:02:57And again, it's a couple years, yeah. And it's a couple years old.

0:03:00So like I said, it's not that it's an outright scam. It's probably a $50 premium over the HTC phone.

0:03:07But don't, you don't want the HTC phone anyways.

0:03:09It wasn't a good deal two years ago when it came out, and now it's two years old.

0:03:12So, yeah.

0:03:13I think it might even be the 24 in U24 is that it came out in 2024.

0:03:20So it's older, but not like ridiculously old.

0:03:25It's not ancient, and it's not using totally terrible internal components.

0:03:31Like it's built, it's a respectable device built by a real company.

0:03:35It's just, yeah.

0:03:37But what do you think really happened?

0:03:39Nobody that cared about specs was going to buy this anyway.

0:03:42What do you think really happened?

0:03:44I have no idea.

0:03:47Part of the lashback that I got, of course, from the kind of MAGA side of things was this

0:03:52is not Donald Trump.

0:03:54It was Eric and Don Jr.

0:03:55And I'm like, yeah, that's the same family.

0:04:00They share the same ventures.

0:04:01One enriches himself off the other.

0:04:04And I even got people that were saying, yeah, well, you know, Eric and Don Jr., they were

0:04:08at the unveil event a year ago, but they're clearly not involved in the day-to-day.

0:04:12Otherwise, stuff would have been more well fleshed out.

0:04:15And I was like, really?

0:04:16You actually think that?

0:04:17But anyway.

0:04:17That is something.

0:04:18So I did a little bit of investigation.

0:04:21I didn't end up fully reporting on it because I couldn't really with full confidence say

0:04:25that this is what was going on behind the scenes.

0:04:27But my very heavy suspicions, and The Verge has kind of corroborated the same, is that Trump

0:04:33Mobile is a licensed kind of sub-provider of another small carrier called Liberty Mobile.

0:04:40And Liberty Mobile is an NBNO that mostly licensed T-Mobile's spectrum, I think.

0:04:46And so you're running on T-Mobile's network, but I think Trump Mobile is almost a de facto

0:04:51kind of adjacent subsidiary of Liberty Mobile.

0:04:54And if you go to Liberty Mobile's website, you should.

0:04:56It is hilarious.

0:04:58I mean, if you think the Trump Mobile website looks bad, go look at Liberty Mobile.

0:05:02Everything about this looks like an outright scam.

0:05:04But the customer support representative that I talked to and the director of sales who called

0:05:12me to see if I was going to buy the phone, I looked up his name and he appears to be the

0:05:16son of the CEO of Liberty Mobile.

0:05:19And so I think it's probably something like Liberty Mobile and their whole value proposition

0:05:25is patriotism, network, freedom first kind of thing.

0:05:27Exactly what the MAGA side of things wants to believe.

0:05:30So I'm betting they're just savvy businessmen that went to the Trump org and was like, hey,

0:05:34you guys don't have a mobile network and we could get you one really, really easily.

0:05:39And we could even have a phone for you.

0:05:40And then it all just spiraled out of control and it became the built in America bullcrap

0:05:46that was spouted for months and months and months, even though everybody surely knew that

0:05:51that was not going to be possible.

0:05:52And here we are a year later with a thing that kind of exists in an execution that was

0:05:58done pretty poorly.

0:05:59And is anybody surprised?

0:06:01No.

0:06:02But on the flip side, how many of these damn things do you think they had to make?

0:06:06I mean, how many pre-orders did they sell?

0:06:08There was some speculation about it.

0:06:10Well, yeah.

0:06:10Well, there had been original reporting that it was a quarter of a million, but then there

0:06:15was actually, unsurprisingly, a huge data leak.

0:06:19The entire customer order database got hacked.

0:06:22I forgot about that.

0:06:23And it turned out that there had been about 30,000 people that had put down $100 to buy the

0:06:28phone.

0:06:28But what percentage of those actually converted?

0:06:32I would presume they are very, very few.

0:06:34And my question is, I mean, it is a real phone.

0:06:38It's got a custom back cover.

0:06:40They moved the flash around.

0:06:41I mean, they anodized the aluminum differently.

0:06:43So it's not like they just stuck a sticker on a phone that already exists.

0:06:46It's not like they went up and built a phone from the ground up either.

0:06:49But you would have to imagine that the minimum order quantities to do this amount of work to

0:06:53a phone has got to be pretty high.

0:06:54And I see no scenario in which they break even on this.

0:06:59Because they have to order, I would presume, low tens of thousands of units.

0:07:03And by all reporting I've seen, they've sold maybe a few hundred.

0:07:08Yeah.

0:07:09Not great.

0:07:10I wonder what the long tail of Android really is.

0:07:14Like the, hey, I just want whatever free phone you get.

0:07:18All right, fine.

0:07:19I'll sign a contract with my carrier and I'll just get it.

0:07:24I don't really know people who have such phones, though.

0:07:26The people, I'll admit, most of my...

0:07:28They're alleged to exist.

0:07:29All of my friends are, I think of one exception, who's an Android user.

0:07:35But in my extended family, and again, I often say this, I have, throughout this course of

0:07:41my career, very successfully stayed out of becoming the Apple IT guy for my extended family.

0:07:49I've taken care of my...

0:07:50That is pretty good.

0:07:51I took care of my parents.

0:07:52I take care of my wife's mom.

0:07:54And in fact, I just talked to her today about something with her Apple Watch.

0:07:58And she's so...

0:08:00I have a great relationship with my mother-in-law.

0:08:02Fantastic relationship.

0:08:03It really is.

0:08:04It's incomprehensible.

0:08:05And she's also...

0:08:06But she's very, very sensitive about my time.

0:08:08And I'm like, you can take all the time you want.

0:08:10I have nothing to do.

0:08:10It's just lunch.

0:08:11Ask me your questions.

0:08:12But very few other people.

0:08:14I have not steered my extended family towards Apple stuff because I'm John Gruber and this

0:08:19is what I write about.

0:08:19It's just happened that most of my extended family is all on iPhones now.

0:08:26I don't know.

0:08:27So I don't know, like, how many new $300 Android phones, how many SKUs are there?

0:08:35If there's no celebrity endorsement like Trump, and I can't...

0:08:40It doesn't seem like this is really a thing.

0:08:42That's the thing where I think they ran into trouble.

0:08:45Celebrities having their own phones is not really a thing.

0:08:50You can't go out and buy a Taylor Swift phone.

0:08:52She could sell them if she wanted to.

0:08:54I mean, if she did the same thing Trump did, she'd sell a lot more of these goddamn phones.

0:08:58She'd do way more numbers.

0:08:58Yeah, absolutely.

0:08:59Could even be the T1 phone, right?

0:09:02It could still be the T.

0:09:03Hey, there you go.

0:09:04Yep.

0:09:04Right.

0:09:05But she's not a scammer.

0:09:07So she doesn't try to do it.

0:09:10Well, there's one distinguishing...

0:09:12I don't know.

0:09:12What do they need to do to, you know, just to do the...

0:09:16Like you said, they didn't just put a sticker on it.

0:09:18They actually did anodize a yellow aluminum case and move the cameras around.

0:09:24I'll just add this, too, before I forget, is while they were in that period at the beginning

0:09:30of this calendar year, right?

0:09:31They started selling this thing last year.

0:09:33They said it was going to come out by the end of the year, and it didn't.

0:09:36And that's when everybody started getting suspicious.

0:09:38The Verge was running a lovely one week, once a week, did the Trump phone come out column?

0:09:44Yep.

0:09:45And guess what?

0:09:46You didn't need AI.

0:09:47The answer was no.

0:09:48Mm-hmm.

0:09:52But when they started getting real and they started saying, well, here's a render of it.

0:09:57And, like, there was one that was clearly AI.

0:09:59There was one that was...

0:10:01I don't know.

0:10:01And the one that was just clearly an iPhone that they colored.

0:10:05When the one that is the actual T1 came out, I thought it might have been AI, too, because

0:10:11the lenses, the camera lenses were, like, asymmetrically arranged on the back.

0:10:15The unveil video was 100% done with AI, because the camera buttons move, the sheen on the back

0:10:22the device is different.

0:10:23On one shot, there's 11 stripes on the flag.

0:10:26And on another, there's 14.

0:10:27It's just totally done by AI.

0:10:29I think they fed it.

0:10:30The probably HTC-provided, like, CAD files.

0:10:34And then they're like, okay, make it a thing.

0:10:36So that's what was even crazier, is they come out, you know, a year after they've been taking

0:10:41pre-orders.

0:10:41And they go, okay, here, it finally is.

0:10:43We know we've shown five different versions before.

0:10:46One of them, this is my favorite.

0:10:47They even released a render of it being a Galaxy S25 Ultra last year, but with a gold

0:10:53Spigen case on the phone.

0:10:55So they actually took the phone with the case, and there's a Spigen logo at the very bottom,

0:11:00which is how it became gold.

0:11:02And they didn't remove that, of course, from their crappy Photoshop job and just put Tron

0:11:05Mobile right over the top.

0:11:06And Spigen, I think, at replied them on Twitter and was like, bro?

0:11:10And so the whole thing was a disaster from top to bottom.

0:11:15Again, where I'm kind of confused, they're clearly targeting a very specific demographic

0:11:20because I think anybody that's buying a kind of budget bargain Android phones, they're just

0:11:26going to standard carriers anyway.

0:11:27That's the irony about this is you've got to find it.

0:11:30You've got to seek out Trump Mobile.

0:11:32And by the way, their pricing is not compelling at all.

0:11:35MVNOs are usually fairly popular.

0:11:37I'm on one, U.S. Mobile, because I'm able to be multi-network, and they have a plan that's

0:11:42unlimited everything for like $40, and you have pretty high network priority.

0:11:46And so it's a good compromise from the big three.

0:11:49But Liberty Mobile does not have compelling plans, and Trump Mobile's is even worse.

0:11:53So the Trump plan, there's one plan.

0:11:55They call it the 47 plan.

0:11:57And rather than the price being $45.47, they need more money.

0:12:01So it's $47.45 is the plan price.

0:12:06It's $47.45 per month.

0:12:07Why leave?

0:12:08And I think you get like 10 gigs of priority data with the bunch being like limited to edge

0:12:13speeds.

0:12:14So the plan is not a good plan at all.

0:12:17It's worse than a Mint Mobile or a U.S. Mobile plan for $35, $40.

0:12:22And you have to bring your own device or buy a refurbished iPhone, which they also offer

0:12:28customers, or the Trump phone.

0:12:29I think what happened is—and it doesn't disagree with yours at all.

0:12:35Mine's just bigger picture, which is that Trump world is—and again, putting the left-right

0:12:42politics of it aside, which I know is very difficult for some people.

0:12:46But just put it—put the actual traditional political divisions aside.

0:12:53I linked to a piece that Kotke found—I think it was on Reddit last year—where Trump is

0:12:58to stupid Americans what JFK was to Catholic Americans and what Obama was to African Americans.

0:13:05It's like, we've never been represented at the highest levels, and now we are.

0:13:10And he's our guy.

0:13:11And it's—I'll put a link in the show notes to the original rant.

0:13:15But I think the Dunning-Kruger effect comes into this at some point.

0:13:19But a lot of people just assume that people who are stupid know that they're stupid and lack

0:13:26self-confidence because of their self-awareness of their stupidity.

0:13:29And that's just not true.

0:13:33Self-confidence is, I suspect, largely unrelated to intelligence and capabilities.

0:13:40You know, and if you think about—well, I don't know if that's true in general, but

0:13:44I sure know a lot of really smart, confident—or really smart, competent people who are—I'm

0:13:49always telling them, you're too insecure.

0:13:51Why are you always doubting yourself?

0:13:52You shouldn't be doubting yourself.

0:13:53Everybody knows people like that.

0:13:54And everybody knows the opposite, like their idiot uncle who thinks he knows everything.

0:13:59And if you really realize, it's not your personal life and your circle of friends and family.

0:14:05It's the whole world.

0:14:06They're just disconnected.

0:14:07But that these really stupid people with no competence, competence, have all sort of found

0:14:16themselves.

0:14:17And they just—part of their competence is thinking that everything in the world is easy.

0:14:23Everything is a scam.

0:14:24Everybody else is pulling one over on other people.

0:14:27How hard can it be, right?

0:14:29Like, all of them, if they were capable of actually writing a book, could title their

0:14:33book about their time in Trump world as, how hard could it be?

0:14:36And somebody said, you know what?

0:14:39You know where a lot of these companies are making a lot of money is cell phones.

0:14:43Everybody's got a cell phone.

0:14:44We should get some money on cell phones, too.

0:14:47And that's it.

0:14:49A lot of people were making money on crypto.

0:14:52A lot of people are making money.

0:14:54How about we make money on crypto, too?

0:14:55A lot of people—

0:14:56Including the Trumps, by the way.

0:14:58And unlike this, where I don't think that their Trumps are making much money at all.

0:15:03The New York Times had an investigation where the crypto coin, they made like $1.8 billion

0:15:09or something.

0:15:10Or he, Trump, the president of the United States, made.

0:15:13And the Times did the work and figured out that American citizens who bought his crypto, which

0:15:20is now, and that what they bought it at is now underwater, have lost like a collective $2.8 billion.

0:15:26So he got like $1.8 billion of it.

0:15:29Another billion went to whoever else organized the crypto.

0:15:33And some unbelievable number of gullible, well-intentioned, believed in their president, Americans, lost $2.8 billion.

0:15:53I don't think they're going to make billions from the phones.

0:15:56But how hard can it be, right?

0:15:58And it works out sometimes.

0:16:00And I think that's the same gambit.

0:16:02They found these Liberty Mobile guys are probably Trump donors.

0:16:06And they said, hey, we've got an opportunity for you guys.

0:16:09Eric and Don Jr. said, oh, there's a chance to make money.

0:16:12Yeah, sure, let's do it.

0:16:13You can parade us around, put us on the stage.

0:16:15We'll say it's going to be the most American phone.

0:16:16We'll pull a bunch of headlines, which they did.

0:16:18And they got news coverage for months for free, effectively.

0:16:21And they knew they were peddling a scam.

0:16:23But that's what they do.

0:16:24And then they ship a piece of crap that's kind of technically, I guess, what's partially what they promised it would be.

0:16:31And they have enough of a product.

0:16:33And it's real enough that they maybe shield themselves from most of the liability.

0:16:37And who's going to sue them anyway?

0:16:40And it might not work, but it might.

0:16:41And so let's try it.

0:16:42And if we throw 50 darts at the dartboard, one of them ought to stick.

0:16:45And I don't think this is the multi-billion dollar crypto scam.

0:16:48But it's just one of the many things the Trump org has always kind of done and put their name in front of to see if it sticks.

0:16:53And the stuff that doesn't, like this, will probably just disappear in a couple of years.

0:16:58It'll remain probably some weirdo kind of subsidiary of Liberty Mobile that is managed and operated by them.

0:17:05And the couple dozen or hundred customers that continue to pay for the Trump plan.

0:17:09We'll just have their old legacy dashboard available to them.

0:17:12There's basically no overhead.

0:17:14So what's the risk?

0:17:15Right.

0:17:15And how hard can it be is a reasonable question to ask in life.

0:17:21And there are a lot of things in life in broad areas where maybe it's not as hard as everybody thinks it is or times change and technology changes and things that weren't hard.

0:17:33I mean, effectively, what you and I do for a living is an answer to how hard can it be from the perspective of being a full-time media professional from, like, a generation ago.

0:17:44Sure.

0:17:45You couldn't do it on your own a generation ago.

0:17:47You certainly couldn't do the video aspect that you do.

0:17:50You'd have to get on television, and getting on television meant somehow, depending on how far back in time, getting on a very limited number of networks, right?

0:18:00Even at the biggest that cable ever got, compared to YouTube, the opportunities for people to make a living on television were infinitesimal.

0:18:12Yeah, compared to now.

0:18:14And if you go back a little bit further to my childhood, they were incredibly rare because there were really only three real networks and maybe four if you count PBS.

0:18:22How hard can it be?

0:18:23It is still hard, but it's, like, a good question to ask.

0:18:26But there's a big difference between crypto and cell phones because crypto, without going on a whole side rant about it, I mean, and it is kind of unique.

0:18:36Like, maybe in the history, there's really very hard to say, oh, crypto is like, cryptocurrency is like X.

0:18:44No, there really isn't anything in the past that was like it.

0:18:48And there are cryptocurrencies, Bitcoin in particular, that has lasting value, apparently.

0:18:54You know, it does not seem like it's going to crash.

0:18:56It is real.

0:18:58Whether it's a net win for the world, I don't know.

0:19:02I don't want to debate it, but there is some cryptocurrency that has real value.

0:19:07There are people who have, if you got in early enough on Bitcoin, probably there are people listening to this show who have made an awful lot of money by putting a relatively small amount into Bitcoin 10, 15 years ago or whatever.

0:19:20There is real value, but also, because there is real value, it is the perfect, and you can make scam ones and rug pull type ones.

0:19:33It is the, there's never been a way to make computers work better for running a scam than cryptocurrency.

0:19:40Because there is a real there there, for some of them, and you can just make a new one, and like Trump currency, whatever the hell, Trump coin, whatever his was called, take people's money, take your end and convert it to actual dollars right away, and then see what happens.

0:19:58And nobody would have been happier than if Trump coin had held its value or gone up in value.

0:20:04Trump might have actually been angry if it did, because he'd be like, well, why don't, why aren't I making more money from this now that it's held its value?

0:20:10Sure.

0:20:11Right?

0:20:12But it's all just, it, what did somebody long ago, somebody's great description was like explaining crypto to their mom, and it was like, imagine if you could burn fossil fuels to solve Sudokos.

0:20:26And it's like, yeah, yeah, yeah, that's, that's basically it.

0:20:30You're converting energy, and in the middle, there's a lot of GPUs, and at the end comes out, it's solved Sudokus.

0:20:38And that brings us to AI.

0:20:41No, I'm just kidding.

0:20:42Well, but cell phones are real.

0:20:45The difference is a cell phone is real.

0:20:47A cell phone network is a real thing.

0:20:49People get a phone, and they expect it to work, right?

0:20:53And it either does or it doesn't.

0:20:54And I think at the outset of this whole endeavor, there were people who were like, ah, how hard can it be?

0:20:59We'll make a phone.

0:20:59And somebody bought into the whole, why can't we just make one in the United States?

0:21:04How hard could it be?

0:21:05And they, turns out they were wrong.

0:21:07And then I think what happened is shit got real around the new year, because the publicity around, hey, they took all this, these $100 deposits.

0:21:15If you read the fine print, if you read the fine print, it actually says that they don't have to give these deposits back, right?

0:21:23And so people really, and I thought, ah, I think they're going to ship some kind of phone eventually.

0:21:28But I was like, would I be shocked if they just kept the $100 deposits in forever and said, whatever?

0:21:35I wouldn't, with these people, I wouldn't be surprised.

0:21:38But I think somebody realized, and somewhere down the legal chain, there are people whose last names aren't Trump who were on the hook for this.

0:21:47And that's what it reads to me.

0:21:50If you look at the box, the packaging, this was clearly something put together quickly.

0:21:54This is not the phone that they were making a year ago.

0:21:57This happened within the last few months, right?

0:22:00But it is a real, tangible thing.

0:22:03Somebody who knows their shit about the phone industry got called in as a fixer.

0:22:09And they're like, here's the situation.

0:22:10We took these number of pre-orders.

0:22:11We told them they'd get this.

0:22:13And this person said, well, we can find, like, an HTC phone.

0:22:17We'll white label it.

0:22:18I know somebody.

0:22:19We can make a custom gold-toned or yellow-toned case.

0:22:24We can do this for $500.

0:22:26I'll bet they're not.

0:22:27I'll bet they're, like, breaking even at $500 overall, especially in the quantities they're talking about.

0:22:32But presumably, everybody who is buying one is going to stay on this $47, $45 plan.

0:22:37And they'll make money.

0:22:40That's where the money is, theoretically.

0:22:40Yeah, that's where the money is anyway, right?

0:22:42And so, you know, sell what's costing them probably $20 or $15 a month in service and make $30 a month from them on this.

0:22:52And that's actually pretty good money.

0:22:53And that's also why I think they are probably going with the HTC phone as opposed to one of these sketchier Chinese kind of reskins that they were rumored to is I honestly think it comes down to competence.

0:23:06If they could have done it, they probably would have, but they needed something that was going to be pretty well put together and has a decent track record and they could get in the order quantities they needed.

0:23:17And so they went to a real company that was accessible and has people that's worked with the West and they don't have to start from scratch.

0:23:26They can be pretty highly confident that the phones that they are going to ship aren't going to have spyware on them.

0:23:31You know what I mean?

0:23:31Like, I kind of made that joke in the video.

0:23:33There were all these people suggesting, oh, this thing's going to be totally loaded with spyware.

0:23:38And after I unboxed it, I said, no, this is just an HTC phone.

0:23:41But because I wanted to see the bootloader came unlocked on this device and I ended up installing some software on it to do some packet sniffing and to see what network activity it was doing.

0:23:50Everything was totally fine.

0:23:51All kosher.

0:23:52No big deal at all.

0:23:53Which I suspected, but I also kind of suggested, had they gone with a cheaper Chinese device, that actually might have been a problem.

0:24:01Not because the Trump organization or Trump Mobile wanted to spy on their customers, but as a consequence of incompetence.

0:24:07Like, I think that a bad foreign actor might have actually tried to do it, but the Trump Mobile people, they wouldn't have even known.

0:24:16And so they probably just said, yeah, let's go with someone who's reputable, who has a track record.

0:24:20We can get this thing out the door and, yeah, we're not going to make money off of it, but we will on the backside on the plan.

0:24:24And then if you believe their website, this is a temporary promotional pricing and that the phone price of the T1 won't go up over time.

0:24:32I don't think so, but yeah.

0:24:34I think they would really just like for people to forget about it.

0:24:38And probably if it remains a going concern that the MVNO on an MVNO, they're just going to get away from their custom phones and just give people whatever phones, used iPhones or whatever.

0:24:51I mean, they're already doing that where you can just buy an iPhone.

0:24:53It's actually one of the things that they have found out, and that I'm sure the person or persons who came in to fix this and make the real phone from HTC were like, you dumbasses, there's no money in phones.

0:25:05Only Apple and maybe Samsung make money in phones.

0:25:08That's it.

0:25:08And nobody else makes money.

0:25:10There is money in people owning cell phones, but it all comes on the carrier side.

0:25:15And I think they might have known this.

0:25:16I think that the phone was the prop to prop up the network.

0:25:20I mean, that was the thing that was going to grab the headlines, the gold phone, made in America.

0:25:24I mean, if they had come out and said, hey, the Trump family, we've got an MVNO, nobody would have cared.

0:25:29The phone was what catapulted them into the front of the world, and I think they knew that, and that's why they did that.

0:25:36And now that Trump Mobile is a thing, well, the phone exists as a byproduct of that kind of promotion, but it's not the focus, and it never has been.

0:25:45It never will be, and frankly, it's probably, based on the people that I've talked to at Trump Mobile, in order to get the darn thing, I would suspect they have fewer than five people working there anyway.

0:25:55And I think they all already work for Liberty Mobile, and so their overhead is effectively zero.

0:26:00And so I think the Liberty Mobile guys, this would be my suspicion.

0:26:04This is all speculation.

0:26:05I have no evidence to back this up.

0:26:07I would suggest that it's most likely the Liberty Mobile guys that are getting the sweetest end of the deal, and I think they might even be a little disappointed that it's not panicking.

0:26:15They're not panning out quite like they had hoped or expected either.

0:26:17Right, that they had maybe put competent people in charge of the T1 phone earlier to make it more of a thing.

0:26:23You know, and it is maybe to his credit that his scams are sort of a shotgun approach, see what sticks.

0:26:30I don't think they made a lot of money selling those mechanical watches.

0:26:36Nor do I.

0:26:37I don't know.

0:26:38Maybe they made more money on the Trump coins that they've sold, but by trying everything and seeing what sticks, they found the cryptocurrency one, which actually made them billions of dollars.

0:26:49Right.

0:26:50And if you get a couple successes through dozens of failures, well, that's fine.

0:26:54Just add it to the Trump stakes list.

0:26:56You know what I mean?

0:26:57Yeah.

0:26:57There was, I forget, there was somebody who bought the Trump mechanical watch that, you know, which is sort of like, of course, also gold toned and looks very Rolex.

0:27:08It really looks just, you can just smell it, that it smells like the type of Rolex you buy from a guy with a card table in lower Manhattan.

0:27:17Yep.

0:27:18It's got like a bargain bin Miota movement in it.

0:27:21It's like very, they probably built the thing for less than a hundred bucks.

0:27:25It was some local, I'll make a note and see if I can find it for the show notes, but there was some local news somewhere who, and I love, sometimes local TV news can make the, get the best stories.

0:27:37It's like, but some guy bought his wife a Trump phone or Trump watch for her birthday, and it was late, of course.

0:27:47And then when it did arrive, the Trump logo was with applied, applied to the dial.

0:27:54You know what that means, but they're like little, a T and an R and a U that are like glued onto the dial.

0:28:00But I forget, I swear to God, it might've been the T, I swear to God, fell off.

0:28:06And it was rattling around in there, leaving the word rump, but it, maybe it was the P, I don't know.

0:28:11But one of the letters fell off and was rattling around in there and it didn't, guess what?

0:28:16It didn't keep good time.

0:28:17Canal street quality.

0:28:19You get what you pay for or not, I guess.

0:28:21Yeah.

0:28:22But anyway, the video is just magnificent.

0:28:27And it's, it's, I think it's much higher viewers than your typical videos.

0:28:32All of your videos are good.

0:28:33Oh yeah.

0:28:33But this one struck gold, no pun intended.

0:28:37We thought it would do well, but I, even I was surprised by how well it did.

0:28:41It was a, it was a lot of fun to make.

0:28:43And you know, we were late to the, that's kind of why I was a little worried is we were late

0:28:46to it.

0:28:47I had had the phone for almost three weeks before we finally published the video, but I wanted

0:28:51to make sure it was all really well, nicely done.

0:28:53I fix it had already had a tear down by the time we put our video up.

0:28:56It was already all shot.

0:28:57But so when we put it up, I was like, oh man, this is not going to do as well as I hoped.

0:29:01And then it got a couple of million views in two days, I think.

0:29:05I mean this with no hyperbole.

0:29:08I really do.

0:29:09But I really do think that you put more work and time and a combined effort into your video

0:29:14than all of what went into making the Trump T1 phone in the first place.

0:29:19Even, even when they hit the reset button at the beginning of the year and were like, let's

0:29:24just go to HTC.

0:29:25I still don't think it was as much effort or attention to detail as, as went into your

0:29:30video, which is just, certainly supported more American jobs and salaries.

0:29:34That's for sure.

0:29:35All right.

0:29:37Let me take a break here and thank our first sponsor.

0:29:38It's our friends at Notion AI.

0:29:40Notion AI is the all in one AI powered by your work and it's all in one place.

0:29:46It automatically captures meeting notes, instantly finds the exact content you need, drafts, detailed

0:29:52docs for you and lets you chat with the best AI models.

0:29:56Notion AI just became twice as powerful for teams, making it the best AI tool for work.

0:30:02AI meeting notes.

0:30:04Now, I'm lucky.

0:30:05I live a life where I don't really have a lot of meetings.

0:30:08But I know that everybody out in the real world with real jobs, that meetings are a real thing

0:30:14and meeting notes are a real thing.

0:30:16AI meeting, and there are a zillion AI meeting note solutions out there.

0:30:21But Notion's AI meeting notes is just perfect for collaboration and for ease of use.

0:30:29It captures every idea, every decision, every next step that is proposed in the meeting.

0:30:34It's all captured in Notion, which is what your team is already using to collaborate and

0:30:40share shared information.

0:30:43So the shared meeting notes are right there in Notion, ready for your whole team to share,

0:30:47where they can be put to work right away.

0:30:49And even the AI will even follow up at the end of the meeting with suggested action items

0:30:54immediately after the meeting, which you can take or leave or adjust as you want.

0:30:57You don't have to just take AI's word for it.

0:30:59But here's, hey, that's actually a good list of action items.

0:31:03They got it.

0:31:03And then you don't have to think about it.

0:31:05You can capture anything and turn it into organized, searchable notes, including regular

0:31:10group meetings, one-to-one conversations, lectures, even podcast episodes.

0:31:15You can capture this episode of the talk show and get it summarized right there in Notion

0:31:20AI.

0:31:20It works on any meeting platform, Zoom, Google Meet, et cetera, or just with your computer

0:31:26system audio.

0:31:27Like if you're in a room together, the old-fashioned way, having an actual meeting face-to-face,

0:31:31just capture it right on your device.

0:31:33But if you're doing it remotely, it integrates with any tools that you might have.

0:31:37Just type slash meet on any Notion page or on desktop or mobile and get started instantly.

0:31:43Check out Notion, the best AI tool for work right now at Notion.com slash talk show.

0:31:50And they want me to emphasize that all of those letters have to be lowercase.

0:31:55Notion.com slash talk show.

0:31:58All lowercase letters to try the powerful all-in-one Notion AI today.

0:32:01And when you use that link, you are supporting the show.

0:32:06Well, that's enough talk about Trump, I guess.

0:32:09Yeah.

0:32:10One more thing.

0:32:11And about Notion, I suppose.

0:32:14Notion's not paying me, but I do use Notion every day.

0:32:17And I just asked Notion AI, what did I say the Trump phone was held together with?

0:32:21Because you mentioned that earlier.

0:32:22And it found it in my script.

0:32:23You said it was, quote, a scam held together with patriotism and golden paint.

0:32:27There you go.

0:32:28Thank you, Notion AI.

0:32:30It did it.

0:32:31It did it.

0:32:31It's real.

0:32:32Isn't that amazing?

0:32:35It's pretty cool.

0:32:37I forget his exact quote, and I can't be bothered to look it up.

0:32:41But my friend Daniel Joukett of Red Sweater Software, the makers of Mars, had a good long-term

0:32:45personal friend, but he had a tweet a couple of weeks ago, or maybe right before WWDC, that

0:32:51was basically like, the AI enthusiasts are way too into AI, and the AI skeptics are way too

0:32:58skeptical of AI, and that the truth is somewhere in the middle.

0:33:01And it's just turned into such a polarizing thing.

0:33:04But there is a there there that is amazing at times, right?

0:33:10And that's a perfect example.

0:33:11Oh, yeah.

0:33:11Right?

0:33:12Yeah.

0:33:14Yeah, no, I started out as a heavy skeptic, and I still am not a believer that it will

0:33:21change every aspect and facet of our lives.

0:33:23But to think that it's completely worthless is naive.

0:33:27It's a thing.

0:33:29Yeah, I'm exactly on board with that.

0:33:31Me, you, and Daniel Joukett, apparently the only three people.

0:33:34Well, speaking of AI, I guess we can roll into on the more recently news topics is,

0:33:44I've taken a great interest in the native Mac apps, I don't know if you've noticed, on Daring

0:33:52Fireball for ChatGPT and Anthropics, Claude.

0:33:55And while I'm in the, and I knew this was coming, right?

0:34:00There was the whole pre-announcement of the quote unquote super app, which is such a dumb

0:34:05name and such a red flag.

0:34:07And I felt like, my God, is this predicting in advance that this is going to be a disastrous

0:34:13user experience is the easiest pickings of my prognosticating professional life.

0:34:20So I kind of, and of course it was going to, you know, with a native app kit, Mac app for

0:34:27ChatGPT and an Electron Codex app and the whole Atlas web browser that was a Chromium thing that

0:34:36they had wasted so much time and money on, of course those things were going to serve as

0:34:42the foundation of the super app, not the native app kit, ChatGPT app.

0:34:47But as I'm writing about it is when they unveiled it.

0:34:50And boy, oh boy, did they, I expected it to make me unhappy personally, but I did not expect

0:34:58it to be maybe the least competent launch of a mass market app in the entire history of

0:35:08the PC industry.

0:35:09I'm trying to think of an example.

0:35:12I'm trying to think of an example that was worse.

0:35:15And they have, I know the Mac app didn't have a billion users, but ChatGPT has a billion

0:35:20users and they, they really botched it.

0:35:23I don't know what you think, but.

0:35:25It was bad top to bottom.

0:35:27I mean, their whole entire product is ChatGPT, but you wouldn't know that based on the fact

0:35:33that the new app basically shoved chat in a corner and you're like, that's what people

0:35:38do.

0:35:38And the whole thing about these AI models anyways, is that you often don't have to provide their

0:35:45context switching capable.

0:35:46And so the fact that I have to go into a specific mode to do co-work or codex or any

0:35:53other is so weird because with the previous app, you could just go into a chat session and

0:35:58say, hey, I want to do this thing.

0:35:59And I would say, hey, we really should, if we're working on files on our, on our Mac, we

0:36:03should move to this mode.

0:36:03And you go, okay, it just does it.

0:36:05And now it's just flabbergasting.

0:36:07Even just the, what was it called?

0:36:10The blocking and tackling, just the basics of, okay, we would like to rename an app.

0:36:19And that's, that's a tough thing.

0:36:21I know it's a rose by any other name would smell just as sweet, but it is hard to rename

0:36:27an app.

0:36:27There's just a lot of little things.

0:36:30And the list of things that you have to address are at a technical level are, it's long and

0:36:37you want to make sure software updates go right.

0:36:40And then there's the whole marketing angle of communicating with your users.

0:36:44We've changed the name of this app, but I can't recall anybody ever wanting to change

0:36:51the name of an app that does X into the existing name of an app that does something almost entirely

0:36:59different.

0:36:59Yes.

0:37:00Yes.

0:37:01And to make matters worse, to, to let you choose, hey, do you want the old icon or do

0:37:06you want to keep this icon or what do you want to do?

0:37:08Yeah.

0:37:08It's chat GPT now, but it's actually kind of codex under the covers, but you use the new

0:37:12chat GPT logo, but you can also use the old codex logo and you're like, what are we doing

0:37:16here?

0:37:16Yeah.

0:37:18And with your bit, the bit you wrote about that caught me is that when you download the

0:37:22new version of the app and mount it as an image on, you open the thing up and rather than

0:37:27be prompted to drag it to the applications folder, it just says double click this app here.

0:37:31But all that does is open another, another instance of this separate app.

0:37:36And at least as they shipped the 1.0 of this, I don't know what the version numbers are, but

0:37:43the 1.0 of the new chat GPT that's the renamed codex.

0:37:46And it has the had chat GPT itself, the actual chat tucked into a corner and they shipped

0:37:53this Mac app that said double click this.

0:37:55As best I can understand it.

0:37:58If you already were a user of chat GPT and codex apps on your Mac and you just double clicked

0:38:06it, then it would update your codex to be chat GPT the name and it would replace your old

0:38:15chat GPT app with chat GPT classic.

0:38:19But that's if and only if you already had both of those installed.

0:38:23And of course they didn't say anything like that.

0:38:26All they said is double click this.

0:38:27Now I personally had never installed codex.

0:38:30I just, I've never gotten into that whole area of AI yet, even though I'm dithering.

0:38:36Ben Thompson's always telling me I should.

0:38:38And I do want to, I really do.

0:38:41Cause I mean, I even have a computer science degree.

0:38:43I, you know, I can use this to, to make software and I've been meaning to try it.

0:38:49And I have been a chat GPT man, not a Claude man for chat driven stuff.

0:38:55So I probably was going to try codex first.

0:38:57I still might even after all of this, but I'd never installed codex.

0:39:01So all I did was double click it.

0:39:03And all it, all it did was launch a second version.

0:39:05This is my experience as a user.

0:39:07It launched a second version of chat GPT in my doc.

0:39:12And I could see, and I still had the old one running and then the new one just bounced

0:39:17for a bit and then it disappeared and I went and looked in my applications folder and there's

0:39:22one app and it wasn't called, it was just called chat GPT, but it was the old app and

0:39:27there was no new app and no app named classic.

0:39:29And I launched it and it wasn't even updated.

0:39:32It was the one from like a week before.

0:39:34So then I quit that app.

0:39:36I, the reason I saw them both in my doc is I'd left chat GPT running when I launched the

0:39:40new one, which I didn't know what to do.

0:39:42I, if I had had to drag it to the applications folder, I would have known I need.

0:39:45So I quit it, then launched it again.

0:39:47And I, it updated my chat GPT app, but didn't rename it to classic.

0:39:53And so at least if I went to software updates, but it didn't rename it to classic.

0:39:58And I'm like, well, how do I get this?

0:40:00How do it?

0:40:00And the answer, I even wrote a post, like, I think I even put the question mark in the

0:40:04title.

0:40:04How do you get the chat GPT classic app if you didn't get it automatically?

0:40:07And there's no document.

0:40:09I even quoted it.

0:40:09There was a help document on their website that was like, after you upgrade, you may

0:40:14have both chat GPT classic and chat GPT.

0:40:17And they didn't say why you may or may not, because I'm not sure they knew.

0:40:21I've never seen any.

0:40:23And again, this is a company with, it's privately held at the moment, but it's, their self-proclaimed

0:40:31valuation is around a trillion dollars with a billion users.

0:40:36And this is how they launched an update to their flagship product.

0:40:40It is bananas.

0:40:41It's honestly flabbergasting.

0:40:42Yep.

0:40:43And on your point, the fact that it was designed for people that had both chat GPT and Codex

0:40:50installed, they probably didn't even QA it with, I bet there's not a single person that works

0:40:54at OpenAI that doesn't have Codex.

0:40:56So they probably never even ran it on a machine without Codex installed.

0:40:59So they had no idea it was going to happen anyway.

0:41:00And they've.

0:41:02And chat GPT and Codex didn't catch it.

0:41:04Yeah, a week later, they kind of fixed this.

0:41:07And it seems like now you can get both.

0:41:10They've kind of cleaned it up and they've done some work, some obvious work in the sidebar

0:41:15so that there's actually a top level chat.

0:41:17Chats are in the sidebar now in the bottom.

0:41:19They push it below all of your Codex projects, which is honestly pretty annoying, but they're

0:41:24there.

0:41:24And yeah, that's the thing that's the most frustrating to me is that Codex and what do they call it?

0:41:31Do they call it work or is that clock?

0:41:32Yeah, work.

0:41:33No, it is work.

0:41:33Yeah, yeah.

0:41:34They still appear in line.

0:41:36But again, like you mentioned, they're not the same function.

0:41:39I mean, I have a chat GPT worker setup that goes through my email inbox using the Spark CLI

0:41:46every morning and cleans up my email inbox and preps it for me with automatic tagging.

0:41:50It's great.

0:41:51Love it.

0:41:51But it is now kind of an equal priority to other apps that have been developed using Codex

0:41:58on my machine.

0:41:59And you're like, this is not even they're not even the same ballpark because one is coding

0:42:03brain and one is using kind of agentic pre-existing MCPs.

0:42:08It's just bizarro that they're all thrown into this.

0:42:11And then they're like, oh, yeah.

0:42:12And then if you want to chat, it's just at the bottom.

0:42:14So I have been doing, and it's probably what they want.

0:42:16I've been going to chat.com to freaking use ChatGPT as a chat bot.

0:42:22And I'm just devastated because you go back six months ago, and they had an amazing, native,

0:42:27excellent Mac app.

0:42:29And now it's gone.

0:42:29Why not just do what I do and just stick with ChatGPT Classic?

0:42:32I could.

0:42:35I just hate having two apps that are the same but different.

0:42:39And I use Spotlight to launch everything.

0:42:41And it's, yeah, you want ChatGPT.

0:42:43I'm like, no, no, no.

0:42:43I want a classic.

0:42:44So I have to retrain my brain.

0:42:46Type classic when you want that.

0:42:47And the one that's now called ChatGPT Classic.

0:42:52It's much lighter on system resources and memory.

0:42:55But if you are going to be using the other one anyway because you were using Codex already,

0:42:59it does feel like, well, the last thing I need to do is give more of my precious RAM to running processes.

0:43:07And I already have a browser open.

0:43:09It is funny.

0:43:11That is sort of the – it's not my biggest complaint about Electron, honestly, the RAM consumption.

0:43:17It's really the lack of native UI idioms and support for them.

0:43:22Yeah.

0:43:22But it's a list.

0:43:24It's a long list.

0:43:26And on there is the memory consumption.

0:43:28And it does seem – again, I can't think of any comparison in the history of the computer world where they're responsible on both ends.

0:43:39On the one end, it is the AI mania building out data centers that has consumed – they're outbidding everybody else for the limited supply of actual RAM,

0:43:52which has created this unprecedented RAM shortage that has driven up prices.

0:43:57And even with the driven up prices has created product shortages, right?

0:44:02There are still configurations of, like, Mac Minis that you cannot get.

0:44:06I don't think you can get a Mac Mini with more than 96 gigabytes of RAM or something.

0:44:11That's right, yep.

0:44:11And it used to be a lot more, and now you go to eBay, and people are trying to sell loaded-out Mac Studios with more RAM than you can get today for, like, the price of a BMW.

0:44:23It's crazy.

0:44:25I don't know if people are buying them, but if you really need 512 gigabytes of RAM, you cannot get it from Apple.

0:44:32It's crazy.

0:44:32It's all from AI mania.

0:44:35Certainly, you can't blame them entirely for the mania.

0:44:39It's the people who've become maniacs bear some responsibility.

0:44:43But then on the user side, they are pushing apps that use way more RAM on your personal computer than they should for the functionality they provide locally.

0:44:55So they're driving up demand for RAM on your personal device while they're the ones to blame for the price increase and shortage.

0:45:04Correct.

0:45:04And I understand going with Electron as a framework, it's easy to use, it's more scalable, it's multi-platform agnostic.

0:45:13However, they already went to the effort of building an excellent native Mac app.

0:45:17Like, who's already done?

0:45:19I do think.

0:45:21Well, I keep coming back to it, and it's a bigger, broader question.

0:45:27And it gets to a point that you raised about, or that we talked about, about where on the spectrum of, oh, the whole world is different now because of AI, or AI is entirely a scam.

0:45:38There's nothing to it.

0:45:39It's just a ripoff engine.

0:45:40There's nothing.

0:45:41I'm 100% convinced that both of those polarized views are wrong.

0:45:49The truth is in the middle.

0:45:50But to me, it is really, really interesting with both of these companies at this point, but at the Anthropic in particular, which is the one I wrote about first with their use of Electron, where if they're so good at coding, and one of the, you even mentioned it, one of the main reasons, and it is understandable that why organizations, big or small, for different reasons, would want to go with a write-once, run-everywhere solution.

0:46:18This has been a recurring thing in computing all the way back to when writing programs was first.

0:46:28We didn't even call them apps.

0:46:29They were programs.

0:46:29But the idea of having the ANSI standard for C so that you could write your code to the ANSI standard and then move the same C program to a different version of Unix or a different platform than Unix and still have it compile because you wrote it to the standard, right?

0:46:50There have been efforts like this, and it makes sense.

0:46:52Why in the world would you want to rewrite the program for every computer it runs on?

0:46:55But if AI is so good at writing programs, why in the world can't they make it existence proof of how good they are by using Claude to make a native Claude Mac app, right?

0:47:08And if it's...

0:47:08Yes.

0:47:09The argument is we don't want to spend all this time and all these resources on a platform just for the Mac, but it shouldn't, isn't the answer that your AI can do it?

0:47:17And I think the evidence is no, it can't, right?

0:47:21They are good at generating code, and I know people.

0:47:24I've written scripts, and I've written things with ChatGPT that are functional scripts.

0:47:30I can see it, and I have close friends who are using it to help them make apps.

0:47:34But I don't know anybody who's made an entire app this way.

0:47:38Or if they have, it is really limited in scale.

0:47:43And it might be useful and clever, but it's not, hey, here's an entire replacement for Claude for the Mac, and it was entirely written by Claude.

0:47:52I don't think that can happen at this time.

0:47:55And if they want to prove me wrong, they should.

0:47:58They probably could, but with more oversight than they're willing to allocate.

0:48:00I think that's the main issue is they just don't care.

0:48:03Right.

0:48:04And I think that's a pretty sad condemnation, but I think that's probably the reality is even though it's possible, it's just not a priority,

0:48:12and they know that people are going to use the product anyway, and so there's just whatever's easier for them to scale more quickly and rapidly.

0:48:18And if they have to do less QA, and if you don't have multiple binaries, and you have to test multiple platforms,

0:48:23and you can just do it once everywhere, then that's what they're going to do.

0:48:25But it is a bit ironic that one of the selling points of these tools is how easy it makes at taking code in one language

0:48:35and translating it to another and from one platform to the next, but they don't.

0:48:40And part of it, it really is, I think, A, you need the expertise still, right?

0:48:45The people who are best able to make a great Mac app, whether it's an all-new app or just rewrite an existing app

0:48:52or add new features to an app using AI, are expert Mac developers.

0:48:57To do it on iOS, to already be a talented iOS developer.

0:49:01In their hands, AI can accelerate greatly what they're capable of producing.

0:49:07And there are people who are not developers at all who are doing this, but they care, right?

0:49:12I think Jason Snell, I forget the name of the, I think it's called Double Ender, is the name of the app.

0:49:17It's a podcasting solution app where you and I right now are actually recording a Double Ender,

0:49:23where you're recording audio locally and I'm recording audio locally,

0:49:26and then it's going to go to the hands of my editor.

0:49:30And he would like to align those two tracks, and it's a Mac app that does this in a very Mac-esque way,

0:49:37does this one thing and does it really well.

0:49:39And Jason is not a Mac developer, but he's a, he knows the, he cares about the idioms of being a Mac-esque Mac app,

0:49:49and therefore was able to direct it to do this.

0:49:53And it probably would have been easier for him to make it a web app and just drag the files into a web interface,

0:49:58but he wanted a native Mac app because he cares.

0:50:00And Glenn Fleischman wrote an app called Mr. Plimsoll, which I think that's the name of it,

0:50:05but it's a super clever little app.

0:50:07And you could just set it up to say, hey, pay attention to this drive on my Mac,

0:50:11and when it gets to this percentage full, tell me.

0:50:15Because maybe you have a drive where you store, like you might have a drive where you store video,

0:50:20and it can fill up very quickly.

0:50:23And you would like to know before the wrong time that you've reached 85% capacity.

0:50:29It's a very Mac-esque app.

0:50:31And Glenn is, again, he's a programmer, and he's written programs over time, but not a Mac developer.

0:50:37But he cares, and he cares about the Mac-esque-ness of it, and therefore is able to do it.

0:50:43And obviously, if anybody at Anthropic really cared about great native Mac apps,

0:50:47they wouldn't have had to wait for Claude to be capable of making one.

0:50:51They would have made one in the first place.

0:50:52And somebody at OpenAI cared enough a couple of years ago that they put a team together at OpenAI

0:50:59to make a native pretty good.

0:51:03I mean, and it's like I sing the praises of it because I'm comparing it to Claude and everything else that only runs in a browser.

0:51:09It's actually not a great Mac app.

0:51:11It never has been.

0:51:12Like, one of the things that, to me, just defines a Mac app is being able to open whatever the element of the app is.

0:51:20You should be able to open that into a window on its own.

0:51:24So Apple Notes.

0:51:25You can go into Apple Notes, find a note, and double-click on the note, and it opens into a window on its own.

0:51:31You can go to Apple Mail and find any mail message or a thread of them and double-click on it in the list of messages,

0:51:38and guess what?

0:51:38It opens into a window on its own.

0:51:40And even messages from Apple, which they rewrote using Catalyst a couple of years ago,

0:51:46and when they announced that they were going to do that, I was like, uh, in other words,

0:51:50bring sort of the iPad version of messages to the Mac,

0:51:53I got worried that it was going to lose a lot of its Mac acidness.

0:51:58And in actuality, the version that they shipped was actually a better Mac app than the one that it replaced,

0:52:05including support for AppleScript.

0:52:08I don't use AppleScripts against messages often, but I have a couple of things I do.

0:52:14I have a couple of scripts that run for a long period of time, and I want to know about the progress.

0:52:18And then years ago, I just wrote a thing that just sends a text message to myself in messages while it's running,

0:52:25and then I can walk away, and then my phone, like, every half hour gets a progress message from myself with the thing,

0:52:32because AppleScript says send a message to my iMessage ID with this text and this status update.

0:52:39All of that continued to work, and guess what?

0:52:41When you double-click on a chat in messages, guess what happens?

0:52:44It opens up into a window on its own.

0:52:46Guess what you can never have done in ChatGPT Classic?

0:52:49It cannot open into a window on their own.

0:52:52And it still drives me crazy, but I don't want to complain too much about it,

0:52:56because it's such a better app than anything else that does chat-style interaction with AI.

0:53:03Oh, yeah.

0:53:04It's honestly kind of impressive how bad Cloud is.

0:53:07Cloud Desktop is a disaster on the Mac.

0:53:10And again, I think it just comes down to caring.

0:53:14I'm not a programmer.

0:53:15I have no experience programming.

0:53:17Well, I have incredibly limited experience programming.

0:53:19I took one class about C Sharp in high school, and that didn't go anywhere.

0:53:25I very quickly realized that I was never going to be a programmer.

0:53:28However, I used Codex and Cloud Code to create, you can't say write, to supervise the creation of-

0:53:39I think direct, you direct it.

0:53:41You direct an app.

0:53:41Okay.

0:53:42To direct the creation of an app that writes our old data on our server to LTO tape.

0:53:48And it's a fairly complex process.

0:53:51There's a lot of moving parts.

0:53:53It's working with real hardware that has drivers that need to be accessed.

0:53:56And it took a little bit of troubleshooting and looking over, but it works really well.

0:54:02We've been using it for months.

0:54:03It's effectively, as far as I'm concerned, bug-free.

0:54:06There are bugs somewhere, I'm sure, but not that are user-facing and not that we've had issues with.

0:54:10We've had no issues with data loss.

0:54:12Data recovery has been awesome.

0:54:13It works great.

0:54:14And it's a native Swift UI app.

0:54:16And I'm some bozo that doesn't know what he's doing at all.

0:54:21So, yeah.

0:54:22And that's the really cool thing about these tools is they're capable of it.

0:54:26But, boy, I'll tell you, it took a lot of iteration from the initial output where I would say, are you-

0:54:31That is not what a Mac app should look like.

0:54:34And me having to be pretty explicit in kind of wireframing out the appearance and how the interaction behavior should be and how shortcuts and hotkeys should work and all of this stuff.

0:54:45But I did get it there.

0:54:46It just took time and care, which it seems they're unwilling to give, which is a real bummer.

0:54:51Because it does make the experience much worse on a Mac.

0:54:54And there's like a whole thing.

0:54:56And it's all, to me, evidence that a class of executive, and I think at OpenAI, we've sort of watched it happen almost publicly with the way that their executive shufflings have happened with public announcements.

0:55:14But that the product-minded people have been replaced by people who just don't think product quality matters.

0:55:21They don't really think that's-

0:55:23It's not just that they don't understand it themselves or have a bar, a thermometer of taste themselves where they can taste their own product and say, oh, yeah, that's good enough or that's right or that's wrong or, boy, that sure looks confusing.

0:55:40It's that they don't even think it matters.

0:55:42And you can succeed with a confusing product.

0:55:46There is evidence of it.

0:55:48That doesn't mean it's the best way to succeed.

0:55:51And it doesn't mean it's the—I would argue that it is always the wrong thing to do, right?

0:55:57And it certainly never hurts a product to be well-designed as opposed to poorly designed.

0:56:03But it's just there's so many signs of it where it's just there's no way that this shipped with product-minded people in charge when they've got, like, at this point, Claude has in their settings, like, plugins, extensions, connectors, and something else that is, like, in the thesaurus as synonyms for those words.

0:56:25And they all do different things.

0:56:28And somebody else—I wrote this on Daring Fireball, and somebody wrote to me, hey, you don't even know the half of it because if you're, like, in an IT organization and you're the administrator, you get connectors for something else, and the word means a different thing.

0:56:43And it's like, these are problems—and it's like, yeah, but look at our valuation.

0:56:49Number goes up, so obviously it doesn't matter, right?

0:56:51But it is the sort of thing that when ChatGPT or Claude itself is making these things and nobody who knows better is there to say, no, that's not good enough, they're just like, ship it.

0:57:03That's the other—on the valuation thing, that's one of the excuses that I've seen from people to say, oh, well, they're building quickly, and they're shipping all the time, and these are still new fledgling companies.

0:57:14But if they have alleged effective market caps of a trillion dollars, that's their private valuation, that's bigger than Walmart.

0:57:21That's bigger than AMD.

0:57:22That's as big as Samsung.

0:57:24So, oh, we didn't have time to make a native app doesn't really fly with me anymore at that point.

0:57:31Right, these are not—they are, in some sense, because they're pre-IPO startups, but they're not startups like anything that we've ever seen before.

0:57:39There's not five people working there.

0:57:41Yeah.

0:57:41Right, and they're the ones declaring and accepting these trillion-dollar valuations.

0:57:46This establishes them as in the range, like a trillion dollars, give or take.

0:57:51I think that puts them above Berkshire Hathaway, which is bananas.

0:57:55Yes, I think Berkshire's nine-something.

0:57:56Yes, which is crazy.

0:57:59It's, like, arguably the best company that's ever existed.

0:58:04It is quite literally crazy.

0:58:05Right.

0:58:06I would happily—like, my wife explained to me long ago, and it's like, oh, yeah, I see why it's like that.

0:58:14But in law school, you had to be prepared to argue any side of the issue, whatever.

0:58:20It's contracts law.

0:58:21And you come in, you have to be able to argue on the spot, because you might get called on in class, the client side of the contract, the vendor side of the contract, or some other side of the contract, like somebody who was caught in the middle.

0:58:35And you need to be ready to argue that side of the case.

0:58:38And if you—we had, like, a debate, like, who's the best company that's ever existed in the 20—from the 20th century onward?

0:58:44And I got dealt Berkshire Hathaway, I'd be like, oh, I might win this, because I can argue that this might be the best company that's ever existed.

0:58:51And you've got numbers to back it up, right?

0:58:56They put them at the beginning of their annual report every year, where they compare their returns against the S&P 500.

0:59:03Yeah, you could just have put money into Berkshire Hathaway in, like, 1978, and no matter how much you put in, you're pretty rich right now.

0:59:11Right.

0:59:12And these companies are more valuable than Berkshire Hathaway, and Berkshire Hathaway hasn't, like, suffered or declined.

0:59:17Like, they're thriving.

0:59:19It is kind of bananas.

0:59:21So don't sing me the, oh, they've got to move fast, they're startups.

0:59:26It's like, forget about it.

0:59:27But it is true, that's the other thing that is very evident, is in their list of priorities, moving fast is number one.

0:59:34And I think to the point where it's, at this point for them, irresponsible.

0:59:40And I'm not an AI doomer, but I do think it's irresponsible to move fast.

0:59:45And to me, we can laugh and complain about the sloppiness of this rollout of the Mac ChatGPT codex renaming and rebranding or whatever.

0:59:54But to me, the red flag is, what else are they doing slapdash?

0:59:58And there are people who are putting very important decisions in the hands of their LLMs.

1:00:06And it's, to me, that sort of hair on the back of the neck gets raised.

1:00:11Like, hey, this, you know, and they're the ones who keep saying, this is transformative of all of society and culture.

1:00:18And it's as dangerous as nuclear weapons.

1:00:21And they can't even release a software update in a comprehensible, cohesive faction.

1:00:26Because they're so hell-bent on moving as fast as they can.

1:00:30It's very strange.

1:00:31Yeah.

1:00:31All right, let me take a break here and thank our good friends at Factor.

1:00:36Hey, hunger strikes and you're exhausted.

1:00:39Oh, what are you going to do?

1:00:41But guess what?

1:00:41If you use Factor, you've got something healthy in your fridge or your pantry and you can make it right now.

1:00:49Factor is not a meal kit type thing where you get a whole bunch of ingredients in a box and then you have a recipe card and you put it all together quickly.

1:00:57Those things are great.

1:00:58I've used them and I really like them and I think they're really interesting.

1:01:01But Factor is entire meals that are already prepared, but they are fresh.

1:01:07So just like meal kits, they come in a box that's got dry ice in it to keep the cold stuff or the refrigerated stuff cold.

1:01:12It's fresh.

1:01:14It is fresh food that you need to keep refrigerated.

1:01:17But then when you're ready to eat it, you can just pop it in the microwave and heat it up and it is all made with really fresh ingredients.

1:01:24Really, really just heat it up and eat it.

1:01:27It is fantastic for lunch.

1:01:28Super duper fantastic for breakfast.

1:01:31You can have it for dinner.

1:01:32It is absolutely great, but it's really, really good.

1:01:36And amongst the things that are really, really good about it, fresh, never frozen.

1:01:41They have over 100 rotating weekly meals, including globally inspired flavors like Mediterranean, Asian.

1:01:47So there's always something new to look forward to.

1:01:50Over 100 a week and including other specialties like kid-friendly stuff.

1:01:55If you've got kids who do not want to eat quote-unquote weird food or something like that, there's some really kid-friendly stuff that is obviously kid-friendly.

1:02:02They've got protein-heavy stuff if you're like into maximizing the amount of protein you're intaking.

1:02:08Whatever – if you have specific dietary needs or vegetarian or anything like that, you can definitely find it.

1:02:14They have plus selections every week, but it's not overwhelming because they're broken down into obvious categories that you can pick from.

1:02:21So within that category, there's not too much.

1:02:24You're definitely not overwhelmed by choice.

1:02:26But you're also never – every time I've ordered from them, I've never felt like, ugh, that's not enough to choose from.

1:02:33It's a really, really good mix of choices, always fresh ingredients, and it really does come on time, and it's super easy to eat, and I really do like it.

1:02:42I especially love the breakfast stuff with the eggs because that's when I am at my absolute laziest.

1:02:47And I'll just admit it, I love having a little tiny steak for lunch, like a filet or mignon or something.

1:02:53I feel like I feel like a king because ordinarily I never, ever eat something like a steak for lunch.

1:02:57Really good.

1:02:58Where do you go to find out more?

1:03:00Go to factormeals.com slash talkshow50off.

1:03:07That's factormeals.com slash talkshow50off.

1:03:14And guess what?

1:03:15You can guess it from the code talkshow50off.

1:03:18That gets you 50% off and free daily greens per box with a new subscription only while supplies last until September 27, 2026.

1:03:29See website for more details.

1:03:31Do not miss those extra details.

1:03:33See their website for more details at factormeals.com slash talkshow.

1:03:3750 off.

1:03:38All right, parlaying from ChatGPT and the Mac, how about Siri AI?

1:03:42Have you been running iOS 27 or macOS 27 anywhere?

1:03:46I have been, yeah, everywhere pretty much.

1:03:49I'm running it on my iPad, on my iPhone, on one of the Macs that I'm using, not my main production Mac, but my laptop, it's on there.

1:03:56And yeah, I've been impressed.

1:03:59It's really good.

1:04:01I actually ran into one.

1:04:03And, you know, you asked that question of notion earlier in the show, like, what was it that you described the Trump phone as?

1:04:09And I, those are the sort of things that have just been blowing me away.

1:04:12Oh, this does, this is amazing.

1:04:15I've mentioned, I think on a previous episode, like a door code for a doctor, you've got to punch in a certain door code.

1:04:21I don't memorize it.

1:04:22What's the door code for Dr. What's-his-name?

1:04:25And then it just spins for a bit and it's like, one, two, three, four.

1:04:28And it's like, damn.

1:04:30And I've done it with a couple of places with door codes where some, I've tried it both ways, where I've had it in an Apple note and I've had it in the contact, in the contacts app or Cardhop, which is what I use.

1:04:41But Cardhop shares the system contacts database.

1:04:46You can put it in like something in the notes field for a contact or something that's in a note in Apple notes.

1:04:53You just ask these questions or the actual questions about like recent iMessages or mail messages.

1:04:59It just works.

1:05:01But I ran into one the other day that it didn't work and it was actually like, I've gotten so used to it working that it didn't.

1:05:09My son needed his social security number and I knew that I'd, and I had shared it with the, it's a shared Apple note with my wife and son with all of our social security numbers and our driver's license cards.

1:05:23And I said, oh, what's Jonas's social security number?

1:05:25And it spun and it said, I don't have that information or something like that.

1:05:29I was like, hmm.

1:05:30Oh, I was like, oh, maybe I locked that one or something because it's private.

1:05:33But then I realized you can't lock a shared note and it wasn't locked.

1:05:37I don't, I don't worry about us having a shared note with our Apple, our driver's license numbers and social security numbers.

1:05:43They're not, social security numbers aren't that secret.

1:05:45It really is just a shared note and Siri AI failed to find it.

1:05:50And then I think I could look it up, but it's like, I asked it, like, are you sure it's not an Apple notes?

1:05:55And it's like, I don't see it.

1:05:56And I was like, what about an Apple note that has SSN in the title?

1:05:59And it was, then it found it.

1:06:01It did.

1:06:01It actually was like coaxing a little kid.

1:06:04What's, what's three times seven, 20.

1:06:07No, no.

1:06:08Think about it.

1:06:09It's gotta be an odd number, right?

1:06:11Cause what's seven times two, 14.

1:06:13Well then what's seven times three.

1:06:15Oh, 21, like you can kind of coax it, but I was actually, I'd gotten so used to it finding

1:06:21little things like that, that when it got that one wrong, I was, I was actually surprised.

1:06:26Yeah.

1:06:27Me too.

1:06:27I've had a few small instances like that.

1:06:30We have a calendar that's an iCloud shared calendar called family.

1:06:34And that's where we put all our kind of family stuff.

1:06:37Yeah.

1:06:37And for whatever reason, sometimes it doesn't properly identify the calendar.

1:06:43The main thing that's more concerning though, is that it doesn't say, Hey, I don't know what

1:06:47calendar you're talking about.

1:06:48Or can you say that again?

1:06:49I've, I've had instances where I've got event information.

1:06:53And this is one of my favorite things about Siri, by the way.

1:06:54And it's, it's going to be a huge thing that people will have to reframe if you're not running

1:06:58the beta because it is a revelation once you do it, but it's so counter to how input has

1:07:03always been based on iOS, but because it has on-screen context.

1:07:07And I think Apple in some ways did themselves a disservice by pseudo kind of launching Apple

1:07:12intelligence a couple of years ago.

1:07:14Everybody knows if you take a screenshot, you can have the kind of ask or, you know, kind

1:07:19of like Siri based prompts that have always been able to come up and they're still there.

1:07:23But what you can do is just ask about stuff on screen.

1:07:25So you can have, and I've had this happen before.

1:07:28Where we'll get a text message or I'll be on a website for, I did it last night with

1:07:32a concert.

1:07:32I was on a website, there was a concert, they didn't have an add to calendar button.

1:07:36And so I just held the side button on my phone and Siri popped up and I said, add this to

1:07:41the family calendar.

1:07:41And the first time it said, great, add it.

1:07:44And it showed all the correct information and whatever, but it didn't look like the card

1:07:49that I've normally seen where it kind of appears like a little calendar card.

1:07:52So I go, oh, it was probably there.

1:07:54And then I noticed on the little family calendar we have running in our kitchen, it wasn't there

1:07:59five, 10 minutes later.

1:08:00And it's always pretty quick to appear.

1:08:01So I thought, huh, I go back in there and I try to find the conversation in the Siri app,

1:08:07which it doesn't tend to track.

1:08:09I've also noticed this.

1:08:10It doesn't tend to log stuff that is action-based.

1:08:13And so if you ask, for example, what's the pin code to this door, that doesn't appear

1:08:18in the Siri app.

1:08:18It's mostly stuff that's chat-based, which on one hand makes sense because you don't want

1:08:24your Siri app to be filled with like, hey, dingus, turn off the lights.

1:08:27Right.

1:08:27Right.

1:08:28But on the flip side, it is nice to kind of go back and say, okay, what happened here?

1:08:33Why didn't that work?

1:08:34So I tried again and said, hey, add this to the family calendar.

1:08:37And it gave me, rather than a, hey, that worked out great, it just spun indefinitely.

1:08:43And then it said, can't do it.

1:08:45So I try one more time and it says, yep, I added it.

1:08:48No problem.

1:08:48It doesn't appear.

1:08:49So then I tried to rephrase it.

1:08:51And I said, add this to the calendar family, because that's technically what the calendar

1:08:55is called.

1:08:56It's not a family calendar.

1:08:57It's a calendar called family.

1:08:58And sure enough, worked perfectly.

1:09:01And so there's just some little weird stuff because it's an LLM or at least powered by LLM

1:09:06tech, it very much is desirous to provide some sort of successful or satisfactory output.

1:09:14And so whereas with the old Siri, it would just say, well, I can't do that.

1:09:17Ask again from your iPhone.

1:09:19Search the web, which was frustrating because it never did anything.

1:09:23Now it'll say, oh, yeah, no problem.

1:09:25I did that.

1:09:26And then you look and it didn't actually do that.

1:09:28And so I think that's, and luckily that's stuff that you can kind of guardrail.

1:09:32And I should mention that this is not the norm.

1:09:34It's an anomaly.

1:09:35It doesn't happen very often, but it's happened a few times where it said, yeah, sure.

1:09:40Perfect.

1:09:40Did that.

1:09:41Another example is because it supports app intents and app intents have been around forever.

1:09:45It adds stuff fairly dependably to my to-do list, which is my reminders app of choice.

1:09:50So I can say, add, add these items.

1:09:52And I've been doing this all the time.

1:09:53It's amazing.

1:09:53You have a recipe pulled up on Safari and you say, add all of these ingredients to to-do list.

1:09:58And by the way, I already have sugar, salt, and pepper.

1:10:00So don't include those.

1:10:01And it doesn't.

1:10:01It's great.

1:10:02However, I think my microphone misunderstood me saying, add this to my grocery to-do list to add this to my grocery to-do list.

1:10:11And it went into reminders and goes, oh, he doesn't have a list called groceries, so I better start one.

1:10:16And so it created a new list called groceries and put all this crap in there.

1:10:20And I went to the store and opened up my to-do list app, and I'm like, where the heck is everything?

1:10:24And then I realized, oh, it's in reminders in a new list that it created because I didn't see one there.

1:10:28And so that's one of those things where I understand why I did it.

1:10:32But on the flip side, if I don't ever use reminders and every single time I tell you to do something with a reminder involving to-do list, you probably ought to just assume I mean to-do list.

1:10:40But I think that stuff will massage itself out over time.

1:10:43Yeah, because it's close enough.

1:10:46You can see how that ought to be technically possible already, right?

1:10:49Oh, totally.

1:10:50Sure.

1:10:51That you can kind of, they can just kind of push it there from where they already are, right?

1:10:57And conversely, I see why it messed up.

1:10:59It's a totally reasonable mistake.

1:11:01I probably didn't enunciate well, but it's one of those things where when it does the thing that it's wrong or it's just to kind of crap your experience, and that's the risk I think they have.

1:11:11And the good news is it's way better than old Siri.

1:11:13But I ran a poll amongst my own audience saying, hey, how often do you use Siri?

1:11:17And the vast majority of people said never.

1:11:19I don't ever use it for anything because it doesn't do anything right.

1:11:22I use Siri often, but it's because I know exactly what it can and can't do.

1:11:28And that's been learned behavior over years of trying stuff and going, okay, I can't do that, so I'm not going to try that again.

1:11:34And I think retraining people to actually give it a shot is going to be hard for Apple to do.

1:11:40And then on the flip side, I also think that they have to yield proper results so that people don't go, I tell it to do this, and it never really does it quite right.

1:11:47So I'm just going to stop trying altogether.

1:11:49That's the risk they run, I think.

1:11:50It's such an interesting point, Quinn, because now that they're calling the new version, quote, unquote, Siri AI, it makes sense as the name.

1:11:58And it's kind of a good, there's some cleverness built in where not calling it new Siri is good because eventually it's not going to be new, right?

1:12:10This is, I don't know, at some point three years from now, it's just Siri.

1:12:15And Siri AI, but there is a word to use for, hey, if you're still on iOS 26, you've got old Siri, which is just called Siri.

1:12:25And if you're on iOS 27, you can opt into Siri AI, which is the new thing.

1:12:30But I've been thinking ever since, certainly last year, but even before they announced Apple Intelligence two years ago at WWDC, I had been wondering whether they had burned the Siri brand to the ground.

1:12:45Because so many people that I know in my personal life have just, they just, you say Siri, they hear a stupid thing that doesn't work, you know?

1:12:56And it's to the point where some of the things that Apple had gotten right or much improved, like I think they're, it varies.

1:13:08And some of the people out there listening are going to be like, are you out of your mind, John?

1:13:11It always gets it wrong.

1:13:13But I use, I've been using the dictate my voice to text and using the Siri, they branded under Siri, the little microphone button and messages for years now.

1:13:26And yes, some, there are certain things that it's like, oh God, why did you capitalize that word or something?

1:13:31But it got a lot better than it was when they first announced the feature.

1:13:36When the feature first came out, it was really unusable.

1:13:39I mean, and I, I speak well enough and dictate well enough that I have a semi-popular podcast, right?

1:13:46My voice is pretty standard white American male, right?

1:13:53I mean, it is, I'm not, I don't have an accent or at least much of one.

1:13:57I should not have had any problems with it.

1:14:00It was unusable for a while.

1:14:01And I know a lot of people who like tried using it and they're like, well, screw it.

1:14:04I'm never going to try this again.

1:14:05And it got better that they should have tried it, but I can't blame them.

1:14:09There is a sort of first impression.

1:14:11That's why first there's so many adages about you never get a second chance to make a, well, I guess it's one adage, but it's so often cited that you only get one chance to make a first impression.

1:14:21It goes back to Steve Jobs' obsession with product packaging in an industry where product packaging is notoriously bad because the people's first impression with a product is when they open the package, right?

1:14:34And you never get a second chance at that, right?

1:14:36And if you already, if the packaging is bad, if it's one of those hard to open bubble boxes that you kind of have to almost cut yourself to open, you've put a bad seed in the person's head and they haven't even used your thing yet.

1:14:51Now you're starting from a hole in the ground to try to make a good impression.

1:14:55And if you shipped a bad product for years, well, Siri overall has been out since 2010.

1:15:01And most of that time, certainly the last 10 years, it has been something that people think is terrible.

1:15:07So I think, I honestly think with no hyperbole that getting people to actually try the new Siri AI is the single biggest product marketing challenge Apple has had in a very long time, maybe ever.

1:15:22And I'm someone who understands the changes that have come to Siri.

1:15:27I'm excited about them and even I will forget to ask Siri to do things because my brain, after years of training, just goes, I can't do that.

1:15:34So I start doing something manually only to realize, wait a minute, I do it all the time.

1:15:39Or I'll use, I'll go to ChatGPT because it's what I've been using for the last two years because of course, why would I ask?

1:15:44Siri can't do that, but Siri can and it actually yields pretty excellent results.

1:15:48And I think that's not just a hurdle because of all of the tech debt and the negative experience that people have had.

1:15:56But I think the other problem, in my opinion, is it's kind of 3D touch coded.

1:16:003D touch was an amazing technology.

1:16:03And all of the ways that 3D touch enabled you to use the iPhone more quickly and at a greater level of depth were, in my opinion, super impressive.

1:16:14But it was one of those things where unless you knew something could be 3D touched, you wouldn't try to do it.

1:16:20Because, and there was no visual context.

1:16:22There were no clues that told you, hey, this button, you can push this a little physically harder and something will happen.

1:16:27Now, haptic touch with being long hold, it's a learned enough behavior that I think now a lot of times you can prove.

1:16:33But still, there are times where I'll hold something accidentally and go, oh, I didn't know this had a submenu there because I've never thought to try it.

1:16:40And I think Siri is the same way where many of these new features are things that there's no visual prompt on screen that tells you, hey, did you know that these are ingredients and you can ask me to add these to your grocery list?

1:16:50So people won't even try it because they don't even think it's possible.

1:16:53And that's where I think so much of what this new Siri could do isn't well documented.

1:16:59And maybe by the time they ship iOS 27, they'll have you go through some sort of walkthrough that tells you kind of what it can do.

1:17:06But they can only give two or three examples as part of this walkthrough.

1:17:09And the capability set in the new Siri is so broad and so wide and so far reaching.

1:17:15But if there's no way to know or to be taught that that's how a thing works, I can imagine a lot of people just straight up won't use it because they won't even think to ask.

1:17:25Yeah.

1:17:26And that's a bummer.

1:17:28Yeah.

1:17:29And so I really do think they need – I don't think they can solve it with a first run experience.

1:17:34Yeah.

1:17:35They should put something in there.

1:17:36But I don't think it's enough.

1:17:37I think they really do need some kind of ad campaign.

1:17:41And it's sort of – I didn't mention it, but it is sort of why I had a couple of linked items in the last few weeks where I was linking to brands that have had sort of, hey, we used to suck and now we don't suck anymore ad campaigns.

1:17:56Like Domino's Pizza had one like 10 years ago.

1:17:59And after I wrote about it, a bunch of people were like, you know, every once in a while, every time I go to my mother-in-law, she always gets Domino's.

1:18:04And I always kind of dread it because it was so freaking terrible.

1:18:07And you know what?

1:18:08They actually – she still gets it, and it actually is better now.

1:18:11It actually is pretty decent.

1:18:12And I think it was Carlsberg Beer or something where their slogan for like 100 years was like the world's best beer.

1:18:18And they came out with a slogan that said, not the world's best beer.

1:18:21And they came out and said, you know what?

1:18:23We kind of let our ingredients slip.

1:18:25And I don't know.

1:18:26And it's certainly not recent Apple style to run self-deprecating ads, so it would be a challenge for JAWS and team.

1:18:35But there's a way – there's certainly got to be a way to do it, right?

1:18:39And probably the best – one of the best ad campaigns any company has ever run, and it speaks to how much Apple liked it and how successful it was, was the – it's actually called Get a Mac, but everybody remembers it as I'm a Mac, you're a PC.

1:18:56But it was the Get a Mac campaign with John Hodgman and Justin Long.

1:19:00And it was – it was self – it was deprecating PCs and Windows, so that's a different challenge than a sort of, hey, we know Siri used to suck, but Siri is actually really awesome now.

1:19:12But it's the fact that those ads were legit funny that really made it stick.

1:19:20And they could have – there's an opportunity for fun here to say, yes, Siri used to be stupid, and now it's really useful and smart, and you should try it again.

1:19:30And it's hard – you know, the other challenge is they tend to – for obvious reasons, they tend to make ads for the phones, not for iOS in general, right?

1:19:40They're not selling Siri.

1:19:42If you have a recent iPhone, you get the new Siri when you get iOS 27.

1:19:48But I don't know.

1:19:50I think that they should just run some Siri ads that are really like, hey, you should upgrade to the new iOS, or just say get a new iPhone.

1:19:57Say that that's how – the easiest way to get it is to get a new iPhone and then leave it to everybody else to figure out that you just have it on your phone if you have iOS 27.

1:20:05But just run ad campaigns in major sporting events and popular TV shows to tell people, seriously, try it.

1:20:13It is actually good now.

1:20:14We mean it.

1:20:14And, yes, we can laugh at the old Siri now because we finally fixed it.

1:20:19They're never going to crack a joke at old Siri before they fixed it, but now they fixed it.

1:20:24And however good you end up thinking out there that the new Siri AI is, it is not a joke.

1:20:30Yeah.

1:20:31No, I think – and I think that's part of the reason why the new Siri app exists, why it is an app, why it will be on the home screen is to signal, hey, this isn't just your average kind of thing.

1:20:42But what I do think is a little lackluster is the app itself, respectively, a card tile and or list view of your past conversations.

1:20:50But I think it should be better at helping you prompt what you want or giving you ideas of what to search for.

1:20:57The photos app has done a fairly decent job at this in the last couple of years where it kind of says, hey, you can ask questions or say, hey, generate a video of my pictures from our San Francisco trip or whatever.

1:21:09But that is still siloed inside of the photos app, which I've always found a bit confusing, still inside of messages where I think Siri AI is the most powerful because it has, again, contextual knowledge of your entire conversation history in iMessage, years worth of iCloud synced messages.

1:21:26You go to the search field and it's still just doing a dumb bog standard keyword search and there's nothing that suggests to you, hey, you can ask Siri how to do this or this is a text field.

1:21:37Why don't you enter a complete sentence and we can run a search query using an LLM rather than a basic keyword index lookup?

1:21:45Because that's what I think people are doing anyway, what they've historically done.

1:21:50As you well know, very few people actually know how to search the web.

1:21:54Everybody goes, dear Google, I'm looking for a blah, blah, blah.

1:21:58And Google search has actually been made worse by trying to accommodate sentence or conversation input rather than kind of keyword search for people that actually know how to search the web.

1:22:09And it's gotten even worse, in my opinion, given the advent of LLMs where people just go to ChatGPT and say, my tummy feels funny.

1:22:16This is what it was.

1:22:17And so let the system inhabit that same kind of thing.

1:22:21When you pull down to Search Spotlight, when you click the search field in Messages, just run a rich LLM-based search and make that part of Siri AI and Apple Intelligence because that will help encourage people to kind of try to use it, even if it's not by holding the side button and saying, hey, Siri, do this thing.

1:22:39I think it still seems kind of siloed inside of the Siri AI or UI, UX rather, where it need not be and can apply system-wide.

1:22:48Yeah.

1:22:49And it's funny because I can't speak to it.

1:22:52Maybe you can.

1:22:53But I am testing it on – actually, I could probably test it on my phone.

1:22:58I'm running iOS 27 on my main phone, have been since beta 2, and no looking back.

1:23:03I mean, there's a couple of issues I've run into.

1:23:05Beta 3 seemed pretty hard on the battery, but beta 4 seems to have returned that.

1:23:10And, you know, that's what you –

1:23:12It's beta.

1:23:12It would be shocking if I went through the whole summer without one of the betas being, oh, yeah, we kind of botched the battery consumption.

1:23:19Something spiraled out of control on that one.

1:23:22But it's really been fine.

1:23:24So anybody out there who's at least on the public beta, it's probably – it's got to be better.

1:23:29And I – at this point, unless something horrible happens in August, I would say jump on – you could jump on iOS 27.0 when it comes out in September, and you're probably going to have a very good experience.

1:23:42Mail got – and they mentioned it in WWDC – Mail got, hey, search actually works now.

1:23:48And they kind of said that in so many words in the keynote.

1:23:51We kind of know searching for email and mail, Apple Mail, has sucked forever, like, bizarrely.

1:23:58And now it doesn't.

1:23:59And I've played around with it.

1:24:01But the whole preface was that on my Mac where I've got Mac OS 27 installed, I don't even have all of my email.

1:24:06I only have my iCloud email, which isn't my main one.

1:24:09But on the phone, it does seem better.

1:24:12But I asked Apple at WWDC, hey, you guys said – you've got Siri connected to the index of everything, the semantic index.

1:24:21And you said you've fixed search and mail.

1:24:24But what about messages?

1:24:25And it was just one of those awkward pause.

1:24:28And like, yeah, we might – you know, that'll be a thing to look at in the future.

1:24:32Which is their way of saying, no, search in the messages app isn't different at all.

1:24:38And again, it is – I don't know which one's worse, search and mail or search and messages.

1:24:43If you're searching for a message from the last week, it's fine.

1:24:47If you – if I'm searching for the last time, Quinn, you and I, you had you on the talk show, which might be like a year ago, forget about it.

1:24:56It might come up.

1:24:56It might not.

1:24:57I don't know.

1:24:57But if you ask Siri now, it'll find it.

1:25:00It's there.

1:25:00There is code on the device.

1:25:03That's what I think your rant was about.

1:25:06You can do this now, right now, on the device, running the beta – summer betas of these 27 OSs.

1:25:13But if you just search in messages, which is what people do, you don't even get a hint that, hey – like a button, hey, do you want to run this same search and ask Siri to find them?

1:25:22Yeah.

1:25:23Which is kind of stupid.

1:25:24Or just run it automatically and just –

1:25:25Right.

1:25:25Yeah.

1:25:26Why do that at all?

1:25:27And that's the other thing that – I mean, you can do – and there are multimodal searches where you can still do a string search.

1:25:33If I search the word door code, that's going to be instant.

1:25:35It's going to be fast.

1:25:36It's going to be used.

1:25:37No battery.

1:25:38But recognize context.

1:25:39If there's no results or if the user starts to enter code to door or trying to kind of play around with the word salad to get stuff through, then just run it as an extended search or prompt the user.

1:25:52Or if the user goes in and types a question, which, again, so many people do.

1:25:56I watched – I love my wife, and she's amazing and a genius and way smarter than me.

1:26:02But I saw her type – this was years ago, and I teased her about it, and now she's – we've learned.

1:26:08I've improved much more as a person ever since having met her than vice versa.

1:26:12But the first time I saw her ever do a Google search, I was like, what are you doing?

1:26:17Because she said, what will be the weather tomorrow in San Francisco, and should I bring a coat?

1:26:21I'm like, what are you expecting the output to be?

1:26:25Just search weather SF.

1:26:27There you go.

1:26:27And like, that's all you need to do.

1:26:30It's going to yield you the same thing, and it's not a person.

1:26:33It's not conversational.

1:26:34But now, LLMs are.

1:26:36And so every search field that isn't conversational in return feels weird and feels dated and feels bad.

1:26:42And I am excited to see the changes in photos and in mail.

1:26:49I'm excited to see how much further that goes because I still feel like typing provides you lesser, worse results than asking.

1:26:57And I don't feel that those two should be materially different.

1:27:01When I go into Spark, which is my email client that I use, and I'm not singing Spark's praises.

1:27:06It is an electron pile of garbo that uses so much memory, it's unbelievable.

1:27:10But they do have a function called Spark AI.

1:27:13And when it shipped, it was pretty basic kind of garbage LLM shenanigans.

1:27:21But now they've done really, really great indexing.

1:27:23And I am shocked where I'm actually going into my email client and saying, hey, what was the promo code from that sponsor?

1:27:29And it finds the answer almost immediately because it's not searching through my entire thing.

1:27:34It's already pre-indexed, very a la Spotlight.

1:27:37And it links me directly with evidence to the email thread so that I can double check to make sure it didn't hallucinate some garbage, which it's become increasingly less prone to do.

1:27:48And it's made it to the point where that's my default entry and input.

1:27:52And I think that in this era of LLM and AI technology, just make anywhere where you can interact at all, just run that.

1:28:02How are you going to do it?

1:28:02And I understand they have to accommodate battery limitations and certain devices will not be able to do it as extensively and or as capably as other devices.

1:28:10And you don't want to have to go out to private cloud computer if you don't have to and do it on device.

1:28:14And that stuff, as memory increases and gets better, that will become better.

1:28:18But that's one of those areas where I'm like, I will say, have you noticed, I guess, are you using an iPhone 17 Pro?

1:28:25Yep.

1:28:26Yeah, I'm on the air.

1:28:28I'm one of the few, I think, that has stuck with it since launch day.

1:28:31It's my daily driver.

1:28:32I love the iPhone Air.

1:28:33When you run Siri for more than two or three messages back and forth, I think you could almost melt the surface of the sun with the back of the iPhone Air.

1:28:43It is so unbelievably hot.

1:28:45It is unreal to the point where the screen dims, the phone starts to lag, and it's only in Siri.

1:28:51And it's only, and I do have all the new fancy pants stuff enabled.

1:28:55I've got the enhanced voice and all the crap that's limited to the Pro-Skew variants of the phone.

1:29:01But, yeah, wow.

1:29:02It's rough.

1:29:03It's an odd phone.

1:29:05I still have my review unit.

1:29:08And I still actually mean to write about it.

1:29:10And I did, at first, put, like, for Beta 1, I used it on the Air.

1:29:15And I didn't notice it getting that hot, but I chalked it more up to it being the first developer beta because I hadn't used it side-by-side with it on the iPhone 17 Pro.

1:29:29But on the 17, and I don't know how, I think that the Air is in an unusual spot where it's got most of the top-tier specs, right?

1:29:40The photography doesn't, right?

1:29:42Like, you can't shoot Apple log video on the Air.

1:29:47And there's other things, too.

1:29:49You can't do the pro, quote-unquote, well, actual pro video stuff on the Air.

1:29:53But for the most part, though, you can.

1:29:56And so it has the new voices for Siri.

1:29:59So in more ways than not.

1:30:02It's got the 19 Pro and all the memory.

1:30:04Yeah.

1:30:04In more ways than not, and I think all of the knots are related to photography in particular, it is a 17 Pro-class phone.

1:30:13But it doesn't have 17 Pro-class thermals.

1:30:16I mean, I think that's basically it.

1:30:19It is, A, it's so much thinner that it's the entire premise of the device, and B, doesn't have the-

1:30:26Vapor chamber.

1:30:27The vapor chamber.

1:30:28Yeah.

1:30:29Thank you.

1:30:29So it's almost like two entirely different things, right?

1:30:34The space, the physical space itself, and the vapor chamber.

1:30:38So it's sort of taking it on the chin.

1:30:41Yeah.

1:30:42And to be clear, it's only when running the AI stuff within Siri.

1:30:46Everywhere else, totally fine.

1:30:48So I don't even know that it's a beta issue in as much as it is it's really making that SoC work when it's really trying to find stuff.

1:30:56And I know the NPU is going wild.

1:30:58And so maybe that's why they're not doing it in as many areas of the OS yet is because it would just completely nerf the experience on a bunch of devices.

1:31:07But if that's not a problem on the 17 Pro, then maybe as we see vapor chambers make their way down the line and they end up in the base iPhone, because they will eventually, then maybe it ends up not being such a big deal in a year or two for them to flip the switch on.

1:31:22Right.

1:31:22Within a couple of years, it'll be the base phone that runs whatever the base system is for most people will be much more capable.

1:31:29But they're pushing the limits on this right now.

1:31:32And it's also easy to overlook based on the fact, and especially people in your audience and my audience, who know that nothing that Siri AI is doing is anywhere near the cutting edge of just chatbots and putting aside all the Igentic stuff.

1:31:52But this is any kind of actual structured test that they run to benchmark new models or just an ad hoc tech test that we could run on the show or you could put in a video where, hey, let's just come up with 10 interesting questions to ask various chatbots.

1:32:12Siri AI is not going to win that contest.

1:32:16There's just no question about it.

1:32:18But it's going to do credibly.

1:32:20It is a, you know, and I admire the attitude that it takes.

1:32:24It is just very plain spoken.

1:32:27It's not too dry, but it's not overly cheerful.

1:32:30It doesn't sprinkle emojis everywhere.

1:32:32I was a little worried at first when it didn't have a setting for personality at all.

1:32:37I was like, oh, God, don't let this be too saccharine sweet.

1:32:40But it's not.

1:32:41But it's not going to win.

1:32:43And so it's easy for technically minded people who know that this is not cutting edge LLM frontier technology to just sort of say, well, it's not impressive.

1:32:52But it really is impressive in terms of how many people out there have never used anything like this and that it's just right there, a side button press away from you asking a question or it evaluating what's on the screen right now at any moment.

1:33:08And that it will be the baseline, right?

1:33:10This is the worst version of Siri AI there's ever going to be.

1:33:13And it's going to run on the least number of devices and have the most adverse effect on the iPhone air in particular or whatever other devices like smaller iPads or whatever that this might be pressing the limits of what it can do.

1:33:29All of that's going to go away in the near future, right?

1:33:32And that they have been they've known now they're they're now shipping products where the SOCs are meant to be running local models.

1:33:42And maybe no, nobody ever has enough RAM and nobody's none of us are going to have enough RAM for years to come at this point.

1:33:50For real.

1:33:51But all of this stuff has been happening with SOCs that weren't really meant for local execution for a while now.

1:33:57And now we're getting to the point where we're getting devices that are.

1:34:01So it's very exciting.

1:34:02It is.

1:34:04It really is.

1:34:04One of the other reasons that I'm kind of glad they did ultimately relent and decide to make in a way a chat bot.

1:34:11I mean Siri's not a chat bot, but it is.

1:34:14You can chat with it and you can ask it questions that it sources information from either its trained index and or even from the web.

1:34:21And I think it was wise of them to do that, even though I know they resisted for quite a long time, because ultimately that is what people do.

1:34:27And if you can provide a field for people to type or speak text, it's only a matter of time before they start to ask the device and by consequence Siri to do things that it can do that they would never think to prompt on their own unless they had this conversational kind of established relationship.

1:34:48And so if they hadn't changed anything else and they just said, yeah, you can search everything's indexed now and you can ask it to provide your photos and do all this stuff, people wouldn't really try it because it's still Siri.

1:34:59But if it can be LLM powered and act and walk and talk like a chat bot, which it does, then I think a lot of people that have been using the free version of ChatGPT will be compelled to use the version of Siri.

1:35:13And even me, I understand, like you mentioned, the limitations of the fact that it's not cutting edge LLM tech.

1:35:19But for stuff that I know basic LLMs can do, I'm going to ask Siri because it's free.

1:35:25It's in my pocket.

1:35:26It's ready to go.

1:35:27I can prompt it via voice and it'll give me the right output.

1:35:31I don't need the latest version of Claude Fable to know when JFK died.

1:35:37You know what I mean?

1:35:38Right, right.

1:35:39It's just that same kind of thing.

1:35:41And hopefully that extends beyond kind of basic interaction for most users.

1:35:46And I think it will.

1:35:48The more that I use it, the more that I see it, I think people will use it once they discover that it exists and it can do what it can do.

1:35:55The problem is training users to understand what it's capable of with the preconceived notion that it can't do anything.

1:36:03So I had a funny one over the last week.

1:36:08I was at a restaurant with a French menu and I was pretty sure I was going to get it.

1:36:14And I only asked, I'm not trying to, I'm going to butcher some French very shortly.

1:36:19So me saying I don't speak French and don't know much about French, I'm going to prove it very shortly.

1:36:23I was almost certain that a croquet monsieur is a ham and cheese sandwich where it's heated up and melted.

1:36:30But I was like, well, that seems like a question, people, this put me into reviewer mindset.

1:36:35So I asked Siri AI, what is croquet monsieur?

1:36:38And the answer, a croquet monsieur is a classic French hot sandwich made with ham and cheese, typically gruyere or a menthol between slices of bread is often topped with a creamy becamel.

1:36:51I don't know what that is, but it was good.

1:36:53Or mornay sauce and baked or fried until golden brown.

1:36:57Good answer.

1:36:58Very good answer.

1:37:00But then here's, I've got two issues here.

1:37:02First is then it added a second paragraph, which is, oh, and just a quick note, always verify important details.

1:37:08As an AI, I may make mistakes.

1:37:10I get it.

1:37:13And I know why I'm sure it's in the system prompt, but it doesn't do this on every one.

1:37:18And it's got, it's like a, it's like maybe in Dungeons and Dragons terms, it rolls a D6.

1:37:25And it's one out of every six times.

1:37:27It'll just tack that on at the end of your chat.

1:37:30But this is not a dangerous question, right?

1:37:33What is a croquet monsieur, right?

1:37:35It didn't need, I wasn't asking for life advice.

1:37:38You know what I mean?

1:37:39My doctor told me to take a statin.

1:37:41Is that important?

1:37:42I wasn't, I didn't need the O in just a quick note.

1:37:46But anyway, on the menu at the restaurant, what they had said, it was made with Comte, C-O-M-T-E cheese, which is not Gruyere or Amantel.

1:37:56So that, oh, so I just wrote Comte, question mark.

1:38:02And it turns out in real life, Comte is just, it's a Gruyere de Comte.

1:38:07So it is a type of Gruyere cheese.

1:38:10So Siri was right.

1:38:11It is Gruyere.

1:38:11They just, the restaurant, because they use this specific kind of Gruyere cheese, that's what they put on the menu.

1:38:17But all my question was, was just C-O-M-T-E, question mark.

1:38:23And it tricked Siri AI into completely responding in French.

1:38:28It just switched from English to French.

1:38:31Here, I'll put a, I will, I will put a screenshot in and I'll text it to you.

1:38:38And I thought that was pretty funny.

1:38:40I thought that was really, really funny.

1:38:43So it's obviously wrong, but I thought wrong in a charming and fun way.

1:38:47Pretty charming.

1:38:48You could, you could probably follow up and say, no, I need that in English.

1:38:52Yeah, I'm for sure I could, but I didn't want to, I just wanted to leave it as is.

1:38:56I was like, oh, this is a good one.

1:38:57And so I still don't know what its answer is because I did not translate it.

1:39:02I guess I should ask it.

1:39:03If only you use the translation feature powered by the new Apple Intelligent.

1:39:08No, I'm just kidding.

1:39:09What do you think, the last one, what do you think of the new voices for Siri so far?

1:39:13I think they're good.

1:39:15They do need some tuning.

1:39:18There's been, it did get better with Beta 4, I feel.

1:39:22But sometimes the enunciation is totally wacky where it's said or finished some things where it will say like, you need to go to this door.

1:39:31And you're like, the what?

1:39:33This door.

1:39:33And like, it'll, it'll cut stuff off.

1:39:36It's very strange.

1:39:37And it's almost always the last word.

1:39:38Like it doesn't know how to finish, roll off a sentence or ask a question or whatever.

1:39:42But in general, they've sounded way more natural.

1:39:46And every time I use with disdain my HomePod to trigger HomeKit automations, I am reminded how terrible the old Siri voice was that I had just kind of accepted as being Siri.

1:39:59Not it wasn't even I didn't even think it was that bad.

1:40:01It was like, no, yeah, computer voice that's been around forever.

1:40:03But the new ones are so good that, boy, they make that old one sound very robotic and terrible.

1:40:09Yeah, it's like when retina screens came out.

1:40:12And at first, you're like, oh, my God, this is amazing.

1:40:13I can't really see the pixels unless I get them real close.

1:40:15I can't believe it.

1:40:16This is really what a leap forward.

1:40:18This is great.

1:40:19And it's like, yeah, it's got a great screen.

1:40:21And then you go after a week or two, you go pick up an iPhone 3G without the retina screen.

1:40:25And you're like, what is this hot garbage?

1:40:28These pixels are the size of marbles.

1:40:31This is absurd.

1:40:32The language is like that.

1:40:34But the old Siri had weird mispronunciations, too, for whatever reason, at least for us.

1:40:38It does.

1:40:38It drives my wife crazy where the old Siri always pronounces the word turnpike, tornpike.

1:40:45There's an O in there, tornpike.

1:40:48And we've got a Pennsylvania turnpike and a New Jersey turnpike in our area.

1:40:53So we've got turnpikes.

1:40:54And often those are the ones where we're using directions because it's not just a crosstown errand where we don't even need directions.

1:41:03But it just drives my wife crazy when Siri says tornpike.

1:41:07It's like the number one reason I could get her to upgrade is if I could tell her Siri no longer pronounces turnpike, she'll be like, okay, I'll take it.

1:41:15And you could probably even tell it to change the pronunciation.

1:41:19That's one of the other things I noticed that was pretty cool is we named – I've got a – my first little girl, I've got a daughter who's 17 months old.

1:41:29And we named her a very – the name sounds exactly the same as one of my very good friends who's in my phone as a contact.

1:41:36But the spelling is different.

1:41:37And so every single time I would talk about my daughter, the name was misspelled because she doesn't have a contact card in my phone because she's a baby.

1:41:45And what I –

1:41:47You can solve that problem.

1:41:49Well, not yet.

1:41:50Not yet.

1:41:51What I ended up telling Siri was, hey, when I'm messaging these people, I'm always talking about my daughter.

1:42:00I'm not talking about my friend unless I'm probably talking with my friend.

1:42:04And to my surprise, it said, okay, I get it.

1:42:08And I at first thought, oh, this is just an LLM thing where it's like, yeah, sure, okay.

1:42:12And then it would never actually do anything with it.

1:42:14No, it actionably changed the output where almost every single time I did dictation or sent messages or wherever else, it started using the daughter's spelling correctly.

1:42:23And it somehow, surprisingly, even maintained the correct spelling of my friend when I was talking in a group chat with him and other people.

1:42:33And so that was one of the things that I did not expect, and it has been literally flawless ever since beta 2 where I told it, hey, stop misspelling this name.

1:42:43It's pissing me off because I'd have to go through and correct it every single time.

1:42:45The other thing you can do that I've tried is when you know that the device is likely to spell something wrong, you can just spell it out.

1:42:54So you can say, oh, Comte, C-O-M-T-E, and it'll spell it out exactly as you dictate it rather than writing out the letters

1:43:02as you would suspect it to do in both dictation and in Siri.

1:43:05So that's an area where it's gotten way, way, way better.

1:43:08One thing I just remembered that it did end up screwing me a little bit, we had planned to go to lunch with family,

1:43:16and there's a restaurant nearby that opens at a certain time on weekdays.

1:43:23It opens earlier on weekdays than it does on the weekend.

1:43:25And so I ended up asking Siri, hey, is this restaurant open right now?

1:43:31Or it might have been the night before.

1:43:32What time does it open tomorrow morning?

1:43:33And it said, oh, this time.

1:43:35And I just was like, okay.

1:43:36Well, we all got there.

1:43:37The restaurant was closed.

1:43:40And they didn't open for another 45 minutes.

1:43:43And so I was like, oh, crap.

1:43:44And it's sort of on you because you're the one who gets it.

1:43:47Yes, of course it is.

1:43:48Yeah, and it's by our house.

1:43:50And what I realized was it wasn't that Siri had just hallucinated or made something up.

1:43:55It's that it had depended on Yelp to determine when this – and Yelp is never right relative to the Google Maps information.

1:44:03And so I do think that it is still going to struggle in as much as where is the data being sourced.

1:44:11I think that it's pretty good, better than most LLMs at not hallucinating or not making stuff up if it doesn't know.

1:44:18But it is still limited to whatever it determines its data source is going to be.

1:44:23And I think that Siri's data sources have historically not been very great, and that's still going to be a problem.

1:44:29It's still going to use Yelp data over Google Maps data, which – yeah, which is a bummer.

1:44:35You know, I ran into a problem, and it all worked out well.

1:44:38A couple nights ago, it was really late, and we hadn't eaten, and I said, I'll make mac and cheese.

1:44:45And my wife was like, that's fine.

1:44:47And I boiled the – just boxed mac and cheese, just basic bitch shit.

1:44:54And it turned out, though – and my dad had – we often don't have milk in the house.

1:44:59My son has a dairy allergy, and I don't drink milk, and my wife doesn't even drink coffee.

1:45:04I don't take – so we often don't have milk.

1:45:06And my dad was here for a couple days last week, and he takes milk in his coffee sometimes, but not always.

1:45:14And I thought I bought milk, but it turned out I didn't because he was like, I'll just drink black coffee.

1:45:18And I was like, oh, but I thought I had it.

1:45:20I'd already boiled the pasta, and I needed to go out to get milk, and it was 9.30 at night.

1:45:25And there's a place that's like right around the – I live right in the city.

1:45:29I don't have to get in a car.

1:45:30It's walkable.

1:45:31But spot A is only a block away.

1:45:35But I know for a while they were closing at 9 o'clock.

1:45:39And spot B is more like six blocks away, six quick blocks, but – and in opposite directions.

1:45:46So I couldn't pass the one on the way to the other.

1:45:49And I looked – I asked Siri, and it said it was open until midnight.

1:45:54And I was like, that doesn't sound right.

1:45:56And I looked in Apple Maps, and it said it's open to midnight every night.

1:46:00And I thought, oh, it's one block out of the way out gamble.

1:46:03And I went, and guess what?

1:46:05They were still open, but they closed at 10.

1:46:08So I was lucky because it was only 9.30, but they were definitely not open as late as Siri thought.

1:46:16And it's just because it got the map – they got it from Apple Maps.

1:46:18And I don't know if Apple Maps gets it from Siri or from Yelp or what.

1:46:22But, you know, and it wasn't a catastrophe.

1:46:24But I had that same thought.

1:46:25You know what?

1:46:26This isn't really Siri's fault.

1:46:28It is the data's fault.

1:46:29You know what I mean?

1:46:30If I made an Apple note with my son's wrong social security number, and I ask what's my son's social security number, and it gives me the wrong answer that I put in the notes, well, it's not Siri's fault, right?

1:46:42I mean, how is Siri supposed to know that?

1:46:46But I do think – I think with Maps in particular, that is going to – it's been – every time I sing the praises of Apple Maps, I get two responses.

1:46:56One from people who live somewhere, often outside the U.S. or somewhere non-metro in the U.S., where they get shit directions from Apple Maps.

1:47:06That seems to be happening less and less in the U.S., and it is more of an outside-the-U.S. thing.

1:47:11I get great turn-by-turn directions here in the greater Philadelphia area from Apple Maps.

1:47:17But the data about businesses problem, to me, is as bad as Apple Maps has ever been.

1:47:26It is, to me, one of the least trustworthy sources of data that I ever, ever even look at.

1:47:34It makes me – I never trust it.

1:47:37I left the house thinking I'm almost certainly going to have to walk an entire two blocks out of my way, one block to see that it's closed, and then another block back where I'm going to be cursing it.

1:47:47But I was – and it was wrong.

1:47:49It just was wrong in a way that I was within half an hour of it closing.

1:47:53Yeah.

1:47:54But it's going to – as bad as it's already been that Apple Maps has bad data about businesses.

1:48:00I forget there was one, two, where it just did not know that a restaurant had closed.

1:48:05And I knew that it had closed because I had seen the sign on the restaurant.

1:48:08Yeah.

1:48:08And it's like, why are you telling me I can go there?

1:48:10I know that they closed like two months ago.

1:48:11It's been out of business for three months ago.

1:48:12Yeah.

1:48:13Yeah.

1:48:13Yeah.

1:48:14And it's like you don't get that from Google Maps.

1:48:16And I feel like they've fixed their actual map data.

1:48:20They have excellent, beautiful maps now in most places.

1:48:23I think their directions have gotten good enough.

1:48:25But the data about businesses, it's already a problem for the way people were using Apple Maps.

1:48:32But they're going to use this information so much more with Siri AI.

1:48:35And it's where Siri AI is going to go.

1:48:38And I don't think they're going to support – hey, by the way, Siri, the way you told it how to pronounce your daughter's name, you're not going to be able to say, get your business information from Google.

1:48:49So actually – I mean, it didn't do that.

1:48:52But what I figured – let me just try this again.

1:48:54So I searched the same restaurant and said, what time does the restaurant open on Saturday?

1:48:58And it says, it opens at 10 o'clock.

1:48:59That's wrong.

1:49:00It opens at 11.

1:49:01So then I responded and said, that is incorrect.

1:49:04Please identify the correct time.

1:49:06I didn't tell it what to do.

1:49:07And then it said, searching the web, which it didn't do before.

1:49:10And then it came back with the right time.

1:49:12So it probably went out to the restaurant's website and found the right time or whatever.

1:49:16But it was only after I said, no, that's wrong.

1:49:19You've got to try again.

1:49:20And so, again, I think probably for speed because they've got access.

1:49:24It's built into Apple Maps.

1:49:25That's what they pulled by default.

1:49:26But that's not helpful if that's wrong.

1:49:28And so that's the kind of stuff that's going to – it's not that big of a deal.

1:49:32But it happens more than once or twice.

1:49:35And people go, you know, screw Siri.

1:49:36I'm not using this anymore.

1:49:37So that's the best thing.

1:49:38You know, yeah.

1:49:40And that scenario you painted where it's a real-life scenario.

1:49:43You've got other people.

1:49:44You're physically – my face got flushed hearing you tell the story because I've been there where it's my fault.

1:49:49And now you've got 45 minutes to sit around with your hands in your pockets.

1:49:53And everybody's like, oh, we'll just wait and whatever.

1:49:55But it's – that is the sort of real-life repercussion.

1:50:01Nobody got hurt, but that's the sort of thing that will turn people away from using it again.

1:50:06It really is.

1:50:07So they kind of got to be careful.

1:50:09All right.

1:50:09Let me take a break here and thank our third sponsor.

1:50:11It is our good friends at Squarespace.

1:50:13Squarespace is the all-in-one platform for building a website to help you stand out and succeed online.

1:50:22Whether you are just starting out or scaling your business, Squarespace gives you everything you need to claim your domain,

1:50:28showcase your offerings with a professional-looking website, grow your brand, and get paid all in one place.

1:50:37I just heard – and I know this sounds like I'm making it up, but I can't reveal the person.

1:50:42But a reader of the website mentioned that I often say friends come to you to ask for help with a website because you're the nerd in their friend circle.

1:50:54And rather than building it for them or something complicated, just send them to Squarespace.

1:50:59Somebody who listens to the show said, I actually did that.

1:51:03It actually worked out great.

1:51:04The person, the friend of theirs who does it, has no idea who I am, doesn't know what the talk show is, but built a brand-new website on the Squarespace platform.

1:51:14Loves it.

1:51:15Couldn't be happier.

1:51:17Can't believe that something like Squarespace existed.

1:51:20They didn't even know it was possible.

1:51:22So you out there listening to me tell you about Squarespace – I talk about Squarespace all the time because they sponsor the show all the time.

1:51:30But there are so many people out there who do not know that Squarespace existed.

1:51:35And you could be the one who tells them that they do and that it solves the exact problem they have, which is that they need a website or a new website.

1:51:46New features or existing features that have gotten better.

1:51:49Squarespace domains, everything, register domain, find an available domain if your first choice isn't available.

1:51:56They've got that built in.

1:51:58Online stores for selling goods, they've got that built in.

1:52:02Analytics, so you can see who's coming to your website, where they're coming from, it's built in.

1:52:06And it has a really good, comprehensible interface.

1:52:09Just one of the best analytics interfaces I've ever seen.

1:52:13And even stuff that's not really exactly a website but is tangential because it's online, like an email campaign, like sending out newsletters, Squarespace has that too.

1:52:23It's all there.

1:52:24I tell everybody on the show, try Squarespace if you need a website.

1:52:29But it's you guys who listen to the show who can tell other people the reach is so much vaster through the audience.

1:52:36Like when people come to you as their nerdy friend, send them to Squarespace.

1:52:41And if you want to help out this show, give them the URL, the code TALKSHOW.

1:52:46Send them to squarespace.com slash TALKSHOW and tell them to remember that code TALKSHOW.

1:52:52And when they do sign up after a 30-day, no features held back, free trial, that code TALKSHOW gets them 10% off whatever they purchase the first time, including up to a year of service.

1:53:04So my thanks to Squarespace for sponsoring this show.

1:53:07All right, Quinn, last subject.

1:53:10You had a post recently about Mac Gaming and the Game Porting Toolkit and stuff like that.

1:53:17Did you hear ATP where John Syracuse said?

1:53:21I did, yeah.

1:53:22It's pretty much – I've never heard John Syracuse – honest to God, I've been friends with the guy for 20-some years.

1:53:29I have never once – and I've listened to collectively – I was going to say hundreds, but it really might be thousands, a thousand hours of podcasts with him.

1:53:40500 ATP episodes, two hours each, maybe.

1:53:45I have never heard him say, this person's argument is right and I agree with it.

1:53:50And I don't have any corrections or notes to add.

1:53:53I'm so pleased to have heard it myself, too.

1:53:56When he started talking about it, I thought, oh, no.

1:53:58And then he said, Quinn is like my spirit animal on this.

1:54:01He goes, I really care about Mac Gaming and I know nobody else does, but Quinn does, too.

1:54:05And I'm like, yes, us, too.

1:54:07Yeah.

1:54:09But I think you're both wrong, in a way.

1:54:12Oh, man.

1:54:15I need John to back me up.

1:54:16All right.

1:54:17Well, I'm afraid of him.

1:54:18What's your beef?

1:54:19What's your beef?

1:54:20Well, it's not the whole thing.

1:54:23I think that your points and calling out how Apple is doing really – I mean, you can jump in and take it from here.

1:54:32That the Mac Gaming Toolkit is a way to port PC games to run on the Mac.

1:54:39And it's always been sort of technically impressive, but often practically ineffective because it results in three- or four-year-old games coming to the Mac in semi-playable shape.

1:54:53And it's gotten better.

1:54:55Each generation, when Apple bumps the major version number, it is major improvements in frame rate and quality.

1:55:02And it's gotten really kind of sleeper hit good.

1:55:07Is that a fair summary?

1:55:09No, this year in particular, it's massively improved over version 3, which was improved from 2 and 1.

1:55:16Yeah.

1:55:17No, it's remarkable how much the performance uplift has come around this year.

1:55:21Games that were unplayable last year where you were getting maybe 5 to 10 frames per second will now run at the same resolution, 40 to 60 FPS, no problem.

1:55:30It's not every game, but it's a lot of games.

1:55:34And I've known for years that there's at least some reasonable team of passionate, talented people at Apple who really do want to see this happen.

1:55:45And that you're singing the praises of it is existence proof.

1:55:50They're doing something.

1:55:50But I don't even know if the person who initially reached out is even still there.

1:55:54But I got like a private email from somebody at Apple and, you know, nothing, just the sort of conversation they can't officially have with me if Apple knew.

1:56:03But just basically saying, hey, it was a couple of years ago, but I was talking about the fact that my son had gotten a gaming PC is now on like gaming PC three, I think, or at least two.

1:56:14But somebody said that, like, in a way that things I post on Daring Fireball sometimes catch the attention of people higher up within Apple, it was caught that, hey, even Gruber's son has a gaming PC.

1:56:28And I didn't even think, and again, I'm often surprised at what catches the attention.

1:56:32I didn't say it.

1:56:33I never even posted it.

1:56:34It wasn't like, oh, I have to hold my nose and buy my son a gaming PC.

1:56:38I don't want a crappy PC in my house.

1:56:40I didn't know what I was doing.

1:56:41I wasn't as much help helping him buy what to get as I usually am when he buys Apple products.

1:56:48But I totally understood it, and I was of the perspective of, oh, when I was his age, I would have wanted a gaming PC, too.

1:56:55There's no question.

1:56:56I loved video games at the time.

1:56:58So I didn't.

1:56:59I was like, what kind of an idiot would think it's odd that a teenage boy in 2018 or 2017, whatever year it was, would want a gaming PC?

1:57:08I mean, I think you have a hard time finding a high schooler in 2017 or today who doesn't want a gaming PC of some sort.

1:57:16So I know that that's a real thing, but I do think they're making progress, right?

1:57:20I mean, it's...

1:57:21Yeah.

1:57:22But I don't think people...

1:57:24I don't think it's registering amongst the...

1:57:27It's like the Siri problem, right?

1:57:29Yeah.

1:57:29Well, then I think it's because if you talk to Apple officially on the record, it's not for end consumers.

1:57:35The idea is that it's designed for video game developers to take their existing titles and port them over to the Mac and or to take titles that are in development

1:57:43and to do all the translations such that they can run on the Mac and it's low amount of work.

1:57:49But developers are not doing this en masse because, as you've stated, there is no demand for gaming on the Mac because you don't game on the Mac.

1:57:57And so developers are very wary.

1:58:00I've talked to developers that have fairly popular games that have told me it's just not worth porting to the Mac because you inherit a support burden

1:58:09and tax liabilities and all of this infrastructure that you're willing to accept if there's some level of expected sales volume, but nobody buys games on the Mac.

1:58:21So it's not even worth doing if it takes five hours to do because that's just not worth it.

1:58:26There's not that many people that will play games on the Mac because the idea that you're buying, that gamers are buying games through the Mac app store, it's just not a thing.

1:58:35And you'll even see, and I mentioned this in the video, that Apple themselves are so desperate, in my opinion, to have games appear on the Mac

1:58:43that they've walked out every major dev that has even considered putting games on the Mac in the last few years at WWDC and other keynotes.

1:58:53And they haven't even required or asked them.

1:58:55I mean, maybe they've asked, but some of these games haven't even shipped on the Mac app store.

1:59:00So they end up shipping on Steam.

1:59:01Apple doesn't get the 30% cut anyway.

1:59:03Valve does.

1:59:04And Apple still says, wow, look, there's games happening on the Mac.

1:59:07So I really think they want games to be happening on the Mac and will take them in any flavor that they can.

1:59:13But they're not really happening because nobody plays games on the Mac because there is no infrastructure to support Mac gaming.

1:59:20And so, so far, so good.

1:59:24I completely agree.

1:59:25But where I feel like you and Syracuse go off the rails is suggesting that Apple make a product with this in mind.

1:59:32I guess, again, I don't want to put words in your mouth, but to make something like a Switch or a Steam.

1:59:40What's the, what's the Steam one called?

1:59:42Steam Deck.

1:59:42Yeah.

1:59:43Put an M5 chip in there and then use the game porting toolkit.

1:59:49Don't, don't wait for them.

1:59:50Just download PC games and do the transliteration on the fly.

1:59:54I don't know.

1:59:56Pretty much.

1:59:57And run PC games on an Apple branded handheld player that you could connect like a Switch or if you want, you play it in a handheld thing.

2:00:06It would have actual buttons and then you could connect it by HDMI to your TV and.

2:00:11Yeah.

2:00:12Or just create a separate, you could do a box to throw an Apple TV, basically.

2:00:16Same form factor, throw an M series chip in there, sell it for 500 bucks.

2:00:19There's a little Apple game console and hell, make it an Apple TV too.

2:00:23You can call it an Apple TV pro.

2:00:25I don't know.

2:00:26What do you, would you be satisfied if they only, if that was only the next generation Apple TV and it was, so it had to be plugged into a TV.

2:00:33It wasn't a handheld thing.

2:00:34I mean, I would love a handheld, but yeah, I'd be fine with that.

2:00:38And I think that the opportunity is ripe because if you look at the console market, they're, they do incredible volume, but they're just getting absolutely blasted as is everybody, but absolutely blasted by all the stuff that's going on right now with memory shortages.

2:00:53And Sony and Microsoft have both historically sold their consoles in the first couple of years at a loss in anticipation that, hey, the people buying on day one or year one are the most, you know, devout gamers that are going to buy dozens of games over the course of the life of the console.

2:01:11And we'll make up that amount of money on the back end, and the people who will only ever buy one or two games ever, they're going to wait until year three or year four, by which point we'll be making money on the hardware anyway.

2:01:22So it doesn't matter, but we're in this weirdo situation where it costs more money to buy a six-year-old PlayStation five today than it did back in 2020 when it came out and not by a small margin either by a lot.

2:01:35It's hundreds of more dollars.

2:01:37And Apple is in this really unique opportunity where I think they could sell a pretty comparable game console.

2:01:44I mean, if you look at the really well-optimized ports that exist, their performance is slightly worse than a PlayStation five while consuming a fraction of the wattage.

2:01:55And do I think that Apple could make an Apple TV style box with an M5 inside of it for less than $700?

2:02:02Yeah, absolutely I do.

2:02:04Because they, yeah.

2:02:06So that's where I think the opportunity is ripe is there is this weird fraction in the market that won't exist forever.

2:02:12And I'm not saying they would have to do it today or if the memory crisis suddenly disappeared that Apple would no longer have a leg to stand on.

2:02:20But I think there is a unique opportunity to support gaming on a platform that is truly cross-platform because you buy a game on a PlayStation, you're stuck on the PlayStation.

2:02:31You buy a game on Xbox, you're only playing it on an Xbox on a TV, kind of sometimes with Windows here and there.

2:02:37But that's the compelling aspect of the Steam Deck is it is just a little PC.

2:02:42And so you can play a game on the handheld and then when you want to go play it on your big boy PC and you're attached to a monitor, you can.

2:02:50And Apple has that same ecosystem where they could run games.

2:02:55You can run a game on a Mac and play it on an M5 Max and get really excellent performance.

2:03:00But then run it on a dinky little $400 handheld that does a pretty decent job.

2:03:04As good as an iPhone, maybe better.

2:03:06And it's not an iPhone that's bugging you while you're playing games about messages and running down your battery and all that stuff.

2:03:13So I don't disagree with you as much as I thought.

2:03:16And I'm glad I had you on the show instead of Syracuse.

2:03:19Because I think Syracuse on ATP was caught up on the Steam Deck idea, which is when you're saying, sure, they could do that or they could do it as a thing you hook up to your TV.

2:03:28And that I think they could do.

2:03:30I think they could turn Apple TV as a no-screen device that you have to connect to a TV that they might try to do this.

2:03:37I think that's feasible.

2:03:38They're never going to do it.

2:03:41The idea that they would do a Steam Deck-like thing that plays anything other than iPhone games is just incomprehensible in the Apple mindset.

2:03:51And you and you in your video where you talk about how Apple has really maybe technically fixed Mac gaming without actually fixing it because they can't actually get the games there.

2:04:04Because they, you know, it all makes technical sense, right, that they could do it.

2:04:09But it doesn't make Apple sense in terms of the way Apple views what they do in their platforms.

2:04:14Whereas if it has a screen and it's roughly in between the size of a screen of an iPhone and an iPad, then it's an iPhone or an iPad and they already make those devices.

2:04:25Yeah.

2:04:25And that just ends the discussion right there.

2:04:28And you can go, but, but, but, but, but, but there's these awesome games.

2:04:31There's this, have you ever heard of PC gaming?

2:04:33Do you realize, as Syracuse pointed out, that PC games are a big, and console games in particular, but, you know, AAA games, whatever you want to call them, are a much bigger market than all of Hollywood movies combined.

2:04:46In terms of the dollars people spend and the time, the time they spend playing them, which makes sense that, that it makes more money, people spend more money and the time they spend on them is commensurate.

2:04:57And all of those games, we're talking about playing those games on an Apple device and that you could have a services story by having a game store just for these type of games from Apple.

2:05:08And you could take your precious 30% cut of them or whatever, all of that, but, but, but, but, but, but it's, it's just, forget it.

2:05:15It just is incomprehensible.

2:05:16If it has a small screen, then it is an iPhone or an iPad and that's it.

2:05:21So, so I do actually agree with you.

2:05:23That's unfortunately what I think their issue has been for so many years, however, because for as much as I think we, I, I don't want to include you in this.

2:05:33A lot of people think, well, Apple's not going to do that because there's just not the volume.

2:05:38There's not the, if, if it's somewhat similar to something that they already sell, they're not going to do it.

2:05:44If they can't sell a hundred million of these, they're not even going to consider it.

2:05:47But I think from a volume aspect, that's not necessarily true because look at the Vision Pro, look at the HomePod, look at the other home devices.

2:05:55They're alleged to be working on, they're alleged to be working on a frigging doorbell, which to me is just insane.

2:06:01Because sure, Apple could make a really nice doorbell that's better and more well-designed and runs better than a ring camera, but there's so many doorbells.

2:06:08And what is Apple going to do?

2:06:09That's going to be like, oh, well, revelation.

2:06:10Nobody's thought of this before.

2:06:12No, it's a doorbell.

2:06:12Yeah, sure.

2:06:13They could have two cameras on us.

2:06:14You could have a package view that already exists.

2:06:16Sure.

2:06:17It could support.

2:06:18And maybe we'll see this new fancy doorbell that apparently they're working on.

2:06:23I don't know.

2:06:23And go, oh, wow, who would have expected us to see that?

2:06:28But I do think that they're always working on a bunch of stuff and not all of them see the light of day.

2:06:33And I think that's Apple's strength.

2:06:34They're not just releasing every single thing that they start working on.

2:06:37Look at Project Titan.

2:06:38Look at any number of other things that never saw the light of day.

2:06:42But I do think that this is not a doorbell.

2:06:45It's not Vision Pro either.

2:06:47It is a device that could have mass market success.

2:06:50The Nintendo Switch sold 20 million units in less than a year.

2:06:54The Nintendo Switch 2.

2:06:56And the original Nintendo Switch has sold over 150 million units.

2:06:59Now, that's not the iPhone.

2:07:01That's not even the iPad.

2:07:02But it's pretty close to the Mac.

2:07:04Right.

2:07:05And it's a big, enormous market that continues to grow more and more and more every single year.

2:07:12And the opportunity for Apple here, and this is where I was trying to appeal to Apple, the entity, is there, forget about the hardware.

2:07:22There are enormous upsides to potential services revenue.

2:07:26Because I think Apple's historic problem with gaming is, I think they're very complacent with where they are in the gaming market.

2:07:34They think, oh, well, we make 30% off of every App Store transaction that involves gaming, which is almost 50%.

2:07:4250% of the entire industry's gaming revenue anyway.

2:07:45And so we're a massive player just by consequence of having the iPhone.

2:07:50But I'm not confident that that money is going to exist forever or in the same volume that it has historically.

2:07:57We're already seeing regions in which that's no longer the case.

2:08:00And I think they have an opportunity to protect themselves from a services, I don't want to say rent-seeking revenue, but kind of in this historic app store services industry, if they were to release a gaming platform that by default supported translation.

2:08:18You could log in with your Steam account, and you can download the games that you've already bought and purchased on PC.

2:08:24And that sounds so anti-Apple.

2:08:25And I understand it does.

2:08:26But I think they would need to do that to get people to join.

2:08:30Because it's not like they've invented this new thing where people are going to go, oh, I'm going to buy my first game console.

2:08:34No, people have spent thousands of dollars on their gaming libraries elsewhere.

2:08:38And so you need to support the people where they are.

2:08:40But if they allowed you to ingest your Steam library and you could bring your existing purchases, but then Apple had additional features that were provided to gamers and users by virtue of a new store that they supported.

2:08:54And it wasn't the Mac App Store built on the old bones of iTunes, but was actually designed with community and DLC functionality and marketplace stuff like Steam does so well.

2:09:06And if it supported cross-play and cross-saving and you could auto-resume, like one of the best features of the Steam Deck is even though it's a PC, you turn it on and it's in the exact same place it was when you turned it off a week ago.

2:09:18That's not a thing with PC games, but it is on the Steam Deck.

2:09:21And now the Steam Machine, which is the TV version that Valve sells of the Steam Deck.

2:09:26If Apple did that, where you could play a game on your TV and then press pause, turn your TV off, and you open it up on your iPhone or on your Mac or on your newfangled game console, and it's in the exact same spot as where you left off, oh my goodness.

2:09:41Gamers would absolutely thrive to that.

2:09:45And one of the things that Marco said on the podcast was, I think gamers are just incompatible with Apple.

2:09:51They hate Apple, and there's so much bad blood over so many decades that gamers wouldn't gravitate towards that.

2:09:58And while I understand that sentiment, gamers hate everyone.

2:10:01They hate NVIDIA.

2:10:02They hate Intel.

2:10:04They hate AMD.

2:10:05They hate everybody responsible for the memory crisis.

2:10:07And at the end of the day, I think most people who play video games want the best hardware for the least amount of money possible and with the lowest resistance.

2:10:15And I think that Apple, from a technical hardware positioning standpoint, is at a better position than almost anybody to enter this market.

2:10:23And the revenue upsides are enormous.

2:10:26I just think there's a culture mismatch that will make it never happen.

2:10:30And that's a bummer because I think it could, and I think it could be amazing.

2:10:35Yeah, that's a great way to put it.

2:10:37I'll say this because I'm glad you brought up that comment from Marco, which is right.

2:10:41But I think where Marco overlooks is how a lot can change in five years if you ship something and stick with it.

2:10:50And the best example, I just thought of it immediately.

2:10:55And it was like circa 2007 or 2008 maybe.

2:11:02I don't know.

2:11:03But it's not that long after Marco became a Mac user.

2:11:06And maybe that's why he doesn't remember it.

2:11:08But it was like a Ruby on Rails conference.

2:11:10And there was a picture of the audience in a theater setting.

2:11:14So you could, it wasn't flat.

2:11:16It was raised.

2:11:17And they were all MacBooks.

2:11:19And you could see because the Apple logos used to light up.

2:11:23And it's an audience of a certain personality type that is largely overlaps with gamers as sort of, and that was historically, quote unquote, hated Apple.

2:11:35That these are the sort of exact, I mean, literally maybe, and the same sort of people who maybe bought a MacBook or still use a MacBook now 20 years later for their work and don't use it to bring it full circle.

2:11:51Don't really use their Macs in a Mac-like way from my perspective.

2:11:56I'd like to be a Mac Catholic.

2:12:01You know, you can laugh, but you know what I mean, you know, and spend their time.

2:12:08And the rise of TextMate as a text editor on the Mac, super, still popular.

2:12:13It was sort of fallen by the wayside development-wise.

2:12:17But it was so weird to me as a BB edit user because so many aspects of TextMate weren't Mac-like at all.

2:12:23It was so weird.

2:12:24It was like there was a menu command in the first version that was like option P.

2:12:28That's how you, I don't know if it was print or what the hell the command was.

2:12:32But I was like, you can't use option P as a menu command.

2:12:37How in the world would you type a pi character?

2:12:39And I said that to somebody, like, what do you mean?

2:12:41I was like, if you type option P, that's how you type pi.

2:12:44And they're like, you can just type the pi character, you know, like the Greek letter?

2:12:48I'm like, yeah.

2:12:49And if you option shift pi is an uppercase pi.

2:12:51And they're like, what?

2:12:53And it's like, the reason that it didn't occur to the guy who made TextMate is I'm sure he didn't know you could, that's what the option key is for.

2:13:01It's not Mac-like.

2:13:01But anyway, but it was, but it served the needs of Unix-minded developers.

2:13:06And they, it wasn't right away, but within a few years after Mac OS X shipped, it was like, give it half a decade.

2:13:15And then a conference full of Ruby on Rails developers who weren't traditional Mac users and had very strong opinions about Apple and would have sworn up and down five years prior that they would never buy a Mac, let alone a Mac lap or Apple anything, let alone a Mac laptop for work.

2:13:30We're all using Mac laptops for work.

2:13:33It can change.

2:13:33Yep.

2:13:34You know, but you have to ship it first.

2:13:37You look at where development is.

2:13:39And even in the last five to seven years, I don't know any professional developer who develops on a PC.

2:13:47I mean, there are people that use, they run VS Code on a Mac.

2:13:50Right.

2:13:51I mean, it's, it's, it's where stuff happens.

2:13:53And I think that could happen if Apple determined that they were serious about it.

2:13:58And the problem with where they're at now is it's a mature market where I think they could innovate.

2:14:05I think they could offer something really hyper compelling, but there is already loyalty out of convenience to specific platforms.

2:14:15And so Apple either has to work with bringing compatibility there or offer something so hyper compelling that you would forfeit your gaming PC with hundreds of games that you've purchased over the last 15 years.

2:14:26And I just don't think they can do that.

2:14:28The good news is I don't think they would have to.

2:14:31There's a famous quote from Gabe Newell, who's the CEO of Valve and gamers in general adore Valve.

2:14:37I think falsely, not to suggest that I think Valve is bad, but they are a business that is designed to make money and they are effectively a monopoly on PC gaming.

2:14:51I mean, they're not really, but I think they own 80% market share.

2:14:54So they may as well be there's the Epic game store and others.

2:14:57But one of the reasons Valve has had such incredible staying power is that their software is really good and that because they make 30% on every game transaction, they can do a bunch of kind of there's a meme good guy Valve that does all this stuff.

2:15:12And they open source their crap and they give it away for free.

2:15:15And Proton is multi-platform and they've made Linux.

2:15:18They're one of the biggest contributors to Linux.

2:15:20And they've made so many things so much better by virtue of it being altruistic, but it's not really altruistic.

2:15:26It benefits them just on the back end.

2:15:28And I think there is some, I don't want to say that it's all self-serving because I think there are reasons that they do it, but they can do it because they, just like Apple, are rent seekers.

2:15:39They charge 30% of every game cell on the PC, which is a lot of money.

2:15:42But that's where the gamers are.

2:15:44They have no interest in leaving and they have famously worked with Apple a bunch over the last many, many years.

2:15:51One of the, you might recall in 2017, when VR came to the Mac, if only through Final Cut Pro for 360 degree video editing, that was done with Valve.

2:16:02They supported SteamVR.

2:16:03SteamVR was ported to the Mac.

2:16:05You could play VR video games on a Mac.

2:16:09And I did on an iMac Pro in an era where that was, I mean, at the peak of the Intel era where literally nobody was gaming on a Mac unless you were booting into Windows, which if you had any interest in gaming, you were because there was seriously zero games for a Mac OS, much less the five or 10 that we get now that are big games every year.

2:16:29But Newell has a quote about Apple where he says, we have this pattern with Apple where we meet with them.

2:16:34We want to work with them, but then we never see them again.

2:16:37And a year later, a new group of people show up who apparently have no idea that the last group of people were even there.

2:16:42I just don't think that they've ever taken gaming seriously and they probably never will.

2:16:46And that's a long time ago.

2:16:48That was 20 years ago.

2:16:49A lot can happen in 20 years.

2:16:51Certainly the turnover that's happened.

2:16:53But I think that's generally been the case where Apple is interested in gaming, but not enough to make an organizational commitment to it.

2:17:01And that's what they would need to do to succeed.

2:17:04And so for as much as I think, and they are in gaming.

2:17:09I mean, the App Store is enormous, but they could further cement their position as a major player in gaming.

2:17:15If they did more, I just, I don't think, I think it's an organizational and a cultural mismatch that they'll probably never get over.

2:17:23But it's a bummer because they have the best silicon in the industry and they now have a really amazing, technically incredible translation platform that allows you to run DirectX Windows games on Mac OS remarkably well.

2:17:39Better than Valve's own Steam hardware can do because Apple has Apple Silicon and Valve is a low volume kind of producer of PC hardware that has to work with AMD on getting the best they can get for a low price.

2:17:52And they just, they can't get the performance that Apple could.

2:17:54So Apple could dominate if only they wanted to.

2:17:57But I just don't think there's the commitment there.

2:17:59And I think there never will be.

2:18:00So that's why I made the video.

2:18:02I was like, oh, I wish they would do it.

2:18:04But I think hoping, hoping that that's where they take Apple TV.

2:18:09I think is a reasonable hope.

2:18:11Hoping they make a handheld device with a screen that does it, they're never going to do.

2:18:15The problem is I think that they need to do both in order to bring people over in any big numbers.

2:18:22I mean, I think if they did it on the Mac and if they did it on the Apple TV, it'd be like, oh, yeah, cool.

2:18:26You can do that.

2:18:28But they would need to do two things to make sure that they dominated their position.

2:18:32Number one is support non-Apple gaming stores, which I think is already a non-starter.

2:18:39I don't think Apple would ever do that.

2:18:40But they would have to in order to bring people over.

2:18:43And then the second thing is make the hardware truly kind of multimodal.

2:18:48And I think slapping a jawbone controller to the back of your iPhone is not going to cut it.

2:18:54It's not the same experience as a dedicated game handheld with an M-Series chip and a fan and everything else that PC gaming handhelds just have.

2:19:02Hell, the Switch has a fan.

2:19:03But they're never going to put a fan in the iPad.

2:19:05They're never going to put a fan in the iPhone.

2:19:08But you need one.

2:19:08I am so glad you mentioned that.

2:19:10Oh, my God.

2:19:11That was about to be the I'm going to kick myself for not bringing it up when Quinn was on the show.

2:19:16That aspect of it.

2:19:18Because Syracuse was like, you know, they invented these things called fans a long time ago.

2:19:22And they really help with cooling.

2:19:24Apple's approach to fans.

2:19:26I'm not even defending it.

2:19:27I'm just translating from Cupertinoese.

2:19:30It is religious.

2:19:31They hate fans.

2:19:32It is in their DNA.

2:19:36Jobs hated fans.

2:19:37And they just let's I almost want to shut up about it.

2:19:43And they're definitely if they were to make such a device, it would not have a fan.

2:19:48There's no way if it was handheld and had a screen.

2:19:50Which I think would be a mistake.

2:19:52Because you look at it.

2:19:53I agree.

2:19:53But they're not going to.

2:19:55Luckily, they're not going to make the handheld device with the screen anyway.

2:19:58That's true.

2:19:58But they wouldn't.

2:19:59But I almost want to shut up about this whole thing because I don't want to jinx the fact that they make any devices with fans at all.

2:20:06That the MacBook Pro still has.

2:20:07They don't even call it a fan.

2:20:09What do they call it?

2:20:10Active cooling.

2:20:11Oh, there you go.

2:20:12I know it's not technically a fan.

2:20:14But they even their antipathy towards fans is so much that they even invented a new terminology.

2:20:20Active cooling system.

2:20:22And thank God they I'm glad they do.

2:20:25I only buy Mac.

2:20:26The MacBook Pro is my machine.

2:20:27And every once in a while, the active cooling system does activate.

2:20:32And I can hear it.

2:20:33And it does sound remarkably like a fan.

2:20:36It's also one of the areas where you can get more performance for less.

2:20:41If you could overclock an A-series chip and slap a fan on there, you could probably get an extra 10, 15, 20% out of that than if you didn't.

2:20:50And that's why everybody does it.

2:20:51That's why Nintendo does it.

2:20:53And Nintendo is not someone famous for having loud.

2:20:56But you play Switch 2, you never freaking hear the fan.

2:21:00It's on there.

2:21:01But I would never know unless you hover your nose over the top of the vent and go, yeah, I think I feel something.

2:21:06I would bet that if you could talk to Nintendo's hardware engineering teams that they have a very practical.

2:21:12And they probably do lean towards not having a fan and that their devices, their consoles always, or at least, I don't know, you'd have to go back to like N64 to say that they had one that was a breakthrough, leading edge.

2:21:28Certainly since in the PlayStation era, they have never been the one with the technical advantages on frame rate or resolution.

2:21:35The GameCube was the last one that was competitive, yeah.

2:21:37Yeah, so that came after N64.

2:21:39But, I mean, the Wii was, the original Wii, which really was the one that came that sort of, shoo, I was really worried Nintendo would still be around.

2:21:48And it was only 480, right?

2:21:50It wasn't even 720 resolution.

2:21:51480 in the world where all the competition had HD.

2:21:56But the Wii also had a fan.

2:21:58Right, had a fan, but only supported 480 resolution and was a blast, was probably the most fun I've ever had playing video games in my life at home.

2:22:09But here's, I just want to mention this, but it does, and I'm like, ooh, and I remember thinking, when the price increases came out last, earlier this month, I guess, it's been a long month, or was it at the end of June, whatever.

2:22:22But when the Apple's, all right, here they are, price increases across the board, except for the iPhone, which I think we're going to hear about in September.

2:22:30The one product that took it on the chin the hardest was the Apple TV.

2:22:36Almost doubled in price.

2:22:38I mean, I think, I don't know if you were on Twitter, or where, or I just, somewhere, you were just like, like, just cackling with laughter.

2:22:49It's, the 64 gig one went from 130 to 200, and the 28 gigabyte one went from 150 to 250, a 67% increase.

2:22:59And it's not just the storage, it's the fact that the bigger one is the one with thread networking.

2:23:04Yep, has Ethernet.

2:23:06There's Ethernet, and there's, I mean, the Ethernet, come on, just did not, nobody's talking about an Ethernet port shortage in today's world.

2:23:14It's RAM, and it's not the Ethernet port that made the price go up.

2:23:18It is overdue for an update.

2:23:20I think this one came out in 2022, and the A-series chip in it is two years older than that, or at least one year older than that, so it's like a 2020 or 2021 era A chip.

2:23:31And I thought, well, this makes sense in some ways, because they're pricing, they're not pricing this Apple TV, which will be preposterously priced for June, July, August, and maybe September.

2:23:44I mean, I'm hoping, given that they already raised the price, that they're not saving the new Apple TV for late October or November, that this will be at the September event, because if it's not, then that means September and October are also months where if you do need to buy an Apple TV, you're getting ripped off.

2:24:00And I thought, well, maybe this is all about the next one, and maybe the next one's actually worth more money, because here's where I'm the sucker, and somebody should take me aside and say, calm down.

2:24:11That maybe this is the one that actually is going to be much more of an actual useful computer that could play games, too, right?

2:24:20This could be.

2:24:21But at this point, maybe $250, that's not really in the price range of what you're talking about, feasibly, right?

2:24:27No.

2:24:28And I also made the argument in my video, too.

2:24:30I mean, the cost differences between an M-series chip and an A-series chip definitely exist, but they're not as great as you think.

2:24:38An M-series chip is estimated to be anywhere from about 50% to 70% more expensive to produce, which is non-zero.

2:24:47I mean, that's a lot.

2:24:48It's 50% to 70%.

2:24:49But it's not enormous.

2:24:51It doesn't double the cost of a piece of hardware that you're selling.

2:24:54And so if you're going to be selling the next Apple TV with a year-old A-series chip for $250, hell, just sell it with an M-series chip for $400.

2:25:02What's the difference?

2:25:02I mean, it's $150, but the market for $250 streaming boxes is so tiny anyways that you might as well just go whole hog, and maybe you'll find greater adoption.

2:25:13I don't know.

2:25:13Especially with these price increases, it really does seem that Apple has put Apple TV into a no-man's land, that they were already sort of in with the pre-price range prices, where they are so much more expensive than the competing products that are just sticks from Amazon or Roku or the Roku box, which are all under $100 and maybe a lot under $100 if it's just a stick.

2:25:38And they're not expensive enough to actually be interesting.

2:25:41They're in this no-man's land.

2:25:43And $200 to $250 is more squarely in that land, where it's an even harder sell for anybody who's not already convinced that Apple TV is the best streaming device to watch on their TV, which I am.

2:25:57But I also, again, I don't proselytize it to my family members because I don't want to be the same way that I don't want to be on the hook for their tech support.

2:26:05It's not my job to sell somebody $150, but now $200 box to hook up to their TV, when their TV might have only cost $200.

2:26:14And it's really big, and they're very impressed and blown away by what they got for $200.

2:26:19And then to tell them that the thing that I'm telling them they should buy to connect to their TV to watch Netflix, which their TV says it already does, is $200?

2:26:28And for as much as the TV software sucks, by virtue of the Apple TV existing, it has gotten better.

2:26:35I mean, if you run Google TV built onto a bunch of TVs, it's not bad.

2:26:40It's not great.

2:26:41It's not the Apple TV.

2:26:43But is it bad enough that I'm like, oh, my gosh, I have to spend $250 to get an Apple TV?

2:26:48No, I might not even do that.

2:26:49And I'm the Apple guy.

2:26:50Yeah.

2:26:52I think that, too, we bought an outdoor Samsung TV for our deck, and I'm going to connect an Apple TV to it, but I'm waiting for a weatherproof box.

2:27:02It's a long story.

2:27:03But in the meantime, it's just running the Samsung software, and I don't love it, but it's like, I don't really watch a lot of TV up there, so I don't really care.

2:27:12And it's not bad.

2:27:13And it's actually a lot better, in my personal opinion, to a Roku.

2:27:18Yeah, Roku is by far the worst, in my opinion, and I think Samsung's right above it.

2:27:22I think they're both pretty bad.

2:27:24But that's a good illustration that even the stuff that sucks is like, it's fine.

2:27:29What are you doing?

2:27:29You're just opening the streaming app of your choice.

2:27:31Once you're in Netflix, once you're in, heck, the Apple TV app that's everywhere, it's kind of pretty much the same.

2:27:38It's not technically, if you have a home theater set up, and there's slight codec differences, but for most people that are just using the internal speakers on their $500 TV they got on Black Friday, eh, who cares?

2:27:50It's like going to a restaurant where the foyer has a bad smell, and the person who checks you in is rude and competent, and it's always a hassle, even though you made a reservation.

2:28:03And it's like, ugh, you can hold your breath through the foyer, and it's like they do eventually give you a table, and then that was really only 90 seconds of a bad smell and a bad check-in experience.

2:28:15And then the rest of the time you're eating the meal, that's streaming, right?

2:28:18It kind of sucks to futz around with the Roku.

2:28:21But then once you get the show on that you wanted to watch, you watch the show, and it's the same.

2:28:26Who cares?

2:28:27And it's fine.

2:28:27And so I get it.

2:28:29I do think Roku stinks in particular.

2:28:32I mean, I just had to use one a couple months ago for the first time in a while.

2:28:35I was like, I can't believe this.

2:28:37I can't believe how they made this worse than just the dumbass just list of channels in a grid.

2:28:43They've added this weird interface that is trying to be suggested.

2:28:49It's like, no, just show me a grid of icons, you idiots.

2:28:51But fine, it just works.

2:28:53But it's like the built-in thing just works.

2:28:55So I don't know.

2:28:56I don't know what Apple is doing.

2:28:58But the opportunity for them to do it is Apple TV.

2:29:00And I do think that's the other thing that's going to kill the idea that you have and that Syracuse endorses is how in the world can they sell a $700 thing that competes with the $200 thing from Apple TV?

2:29:15I mean, maybe.

2:29:15If it's a PlayStation, that's how I think they have to do it is if they sell it as a console that also does all the TV stuff better than, I mean, because the consoles kind of technically do it, but not well.

2:29:26If you could say, hey, this is the one box that does everything.

2:29:28It's the best streaming box, and it's the best game console, and everything's, oh, it could be so good.

2:29:34They just won't do it.

2:29:35Right, and yeah, and then maybe instead of having two Apple TVs where the difference is sort of you have to be a real nerd to, oh, it's got thread networking and Ethernet port.

2:29:45And, like, try, I mean, how many people out there really know what an Ethernet port is?

2:29:48It's like, what?

2:29:49You get Internet through a cable?

2:29:50And you're like, yeah, you used to always get it through a cable.

2:29:52And they're like, no, you didn't.

2:29:54It's always been in the air, and it's like, oh, but what if they had two Apple TVs, and it was regular Apple TV, and it's 200 bucks, and it's good, and there's only one size, and it has the thread networking and the Ethernet port, and there it is.

2:30:07It's the new Apple TV, and it's 200 bucks, and then there's Apple TV Ultra, and it's a slightly bigger box, and it has an active cooling system, and it's 500 bucks or something, or 700, and it does, and then you could have games.

2:30:23There's games that run on all Apple TV, and then there's games that are only for Apple TV Ultra.

2:30:28Yeah, it could be cool.

2:30:30I think the problem is it comes back to this idea of even if they did that, it's dead in the water if they don't have the store support ready to go from the beginning.

2:30:39And they won't, because they're just going to have the app store, and they're going to say, we have this amazing hardware.

2:30:44Developers, come bring your game.

2:30:46And nobody will.

2:30:46And so they're going to have to do it on their own.

2:30:49And that's what Valve did with Linux, is they're like, look, no matter how hard we try, nobody's going to freaking port their game to Linux.

2:30:54So we've just got to support translation of these games such that they can run on Linux.

2:30:59And now that there's millions of people playing video games on Linux, guess what?

2:31:04Game developers actually do target for Linux now.

2:31:06Yeah.

2:31:07Because they know it's going to happen.

2:31:09A reasonable person, and who knows?

2:31:11I mean, again, I do not think this is going to happen.

2:31:14But there is a new CEO coming in, and we know that the old CEO, Tim Cook, had a religious devotion to the services revenue and the sort of, like, the Phil Schiller memo from 2011 that was like, when the app store first started, this came out, I think, in the Epic trial.

2:31:32But it was discovered in one of the trials, probably the Epic one, but it was like, hey, the run rate on the app store is so exceeding what we, even our wildest dreams.

2:31:41We're going to adjust that percentage.

2:31:43What if we cap it at a billion dollars, and once we start making a billion dollars, we just keep lowering the commission rate to keep our side at a billion, which is good money, and then we can just lower the commission.

2:31:57And we don't, there was no email entered with Tim Cook's answer, but we know the answer, because we know what they did.

2:32:03And his answer was, no, I like 30.

2:32:05How about 30?

2:32:06There's a great New Yorker cartoon where there's, like, a business guy on the phone, and he's making an appointment, and he's like, the caption is, how about never?

2:32:16Does never work for you?

2:32:17And I think, how should we adjust the rate?

2:32:20I think Tim Cook's answer is 30.

2:32:22How about 30?

2:32:23Does 30 work for you guys?

2:32:25Let's go around the table.

2:32:27What do you guys say we keep it at 30?

2:32:28And what if we say we keep it at the exclusive way to load software, games, otherwise, whatever, right?

2:32:34Because the obvious answer of, hey, you could just put the App Store on this new device and work out a deal with Valve and just do Valve.

2:32:42And maybe Valve would throw 5% Apple's way, right?

2:32:45We'll build you into the thing, and anybody who buys the thing here, you get 25.

2:32:50Keep it at 30, and you get 25, and Apple gets 5.

2:32:54I don't know.

2:32:55I bet Valve would do that.

2:32:57No, they for sure would.

2:32:58And it would be there alongside the App Store, and all of the App Store games for Apple TV that you know and love would be there.

2:33:06I laugh because I don't think there's many Apple TV games that people know and love.

2:33:12Crossy Road, yeah.

2:33:13But they'd be there.

2:33:14And if that's the type of gaming, I don't know, maybe more people play those games on Apple TV than I think.

2:33:18They'd all be there.

2:33:19And all of the streaming stuff would all come from the App Store, right?

2:33:23Your Netflix and your Hulu and your Disney Plus would all come from the App Store, not the Steam Store.

2:33:28But then you could have a second source of games, and no one would be confused.

2:33:31It would just be Steam.

2:33:33And if you believe that your App Store monopoly is in jeopardy, which I think in a lot of ways they do, hey, this is a new way to re-up the service's revenue volume while still being able to say, no, we're competing honestly and fairly.

2:33:50This device supports multiple game place marketplaces, and we're selling games via the App Store on Merit, and we think that buying games on the App Store is the best place to do it.

2:34:02But if you have an existing library, if you want to buy it somewhere else, we're not going to put a buy the game on Steam button on the Apple TV.

2:34:09But if you go do it on your computer, yeah, it'll show up on the Apple TV, too.

2:34:13And I think they would kill it.

2:34:14I think it'd be amazing.

2:34:15But they won't.

2:34:16No.

2:34:18Yeah.

2:34:19And it's not because I think Tim Cook only picked John Ternus because he agrees with everything Tim Cook does.

2:34:25I think we're going to – I don't know what they are because I don't think we know Ternus.

2:34:28No, we don't.

2:34:28I think we're going to see noticeable changes, and we'll be like, oh, John Ternus has different opinions on X, Y, and Z than Tim Cook did.

2:34:35I think we will start seeing them fairly quickly.

2:34:38I do, too.

2:34:38And I think that's part of – I think that is why Tim Cook picked him, that he is looking for an independent-minded CEO with different ideas.

2:34:46I don't think that's going to be one of them.

2:34:48No.

2:34:48I don't think Ternus is a gamer, unfortunately.

2:34:50No.

2:34:51So that's not going to change.

2:34:53He's been at Apple for 30 years.

2:34:54Right, and I think that's ultimately what you need.

2:34:56And if secretly he is a gamer, that could be the change.

2:35:01That would be the change.

2:35:02Yeah.

2:35:03But let's see.

2:35:03All right.

2:35:04Good discussion.

2:35:06Thank you, Quinn.

2:35:06Thank you.

2:35:09Your channel on YouTube, YouTube.com slash snazzy.

2:35:13When did they put the ad symbols in?

2:35:14I don't even know.

2:35:16I've had an account for so long that you don't need to use the ad symbol on my channel.

2:35:20I don't know why.

2:35:21But I've got the real YouTube slug.

2:35:23So YouTube.com slash snazzy is where you can find me.

2:35:28Right, and I will have links to the videos we just talked about, the Trump T1 phone, the Mac Gaming one.

2:35:34But it's a great channel, and you're continuing to do great work there.

2:35:38And I thank our various sponsors.

2:35:41I really mean it.

2:35:42It's great.

2:35:43I laughed so many times at the goddamn T1 video.

2:35:45It is.

2:35:48And again, of course I did, because it made me laugh.

2:35:52Technically, it made me laugh.

2:35:53Politically, it made me laugh in terms of the gold.

2:35:57Anyway, I want to thank our sponsors for this episode.

2:36:00Let's go backwards in time.

2:36:02Squarespace, where you can build a website.

2:36:04Factor, where you can get Meals to Eat.

2:36:08And Notion, the all-in-one AI platform for teams.

2:36:11Thanks.